The second algebra-based physics course (thermodynamics, electric fields and circuits, magnetism and induction, optics, waves, and modern physics) taught unit by unit to the current College Board framework. Like Physics 1, the exam grades the reasoning as much as the arithmetic. Exam format from 2027: this is a hybrid digital exam: multiple choice in Bluebook, free response handwritten in a paper booklet. Work the practice problems on paper and check your steps against the worked answer, the way you will sit the free-response section in May.
3H EXAM42 MCQ4 FRQ63 LESSONS70 PRACTICE PROBLEMSPREREQ: PHYSICS 1
What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.
AP Physics 2 follows the seven units of the College Board course framework (2026 edition). The College Board numbers them 9 through 15, continuing from the eight units of Physics 1, and this course keeps that numbering so it matches the official materials. Thermodynamics, electric force and field, and circuits are the three largest units, 15 to 18% of the exam each, together about half of it. Every lesson follows one College Board topic, quotes the required content, draws the pictures, and works examples in the exam's style.
U9Thermodynamics15–18%
U10Electric Force, Field, and Potential15–18%
U11Electric Circuits15–18%
U12Magnetism and Electromagnetism12–15%
U13Geometric Optics12–15%
U14Waves, Sound, and Physical Optics12–15%
U15Modern Physics12–15%
All seven units are open, 63 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a ten-problem mixed review.
Free preview: all of Unit 9, its lessons and its review set,
is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open
for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no
card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of
written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.
Open a bottle of perfume at one end of a room and, within minutes, someone at the other end smells it. Nothing pushed the scent across the room; the molecules did it themselves, moving at several hundred meters per second and colliding constantly. Physics 1 treated a few objects at a time. A gas has about \(10^{22}\) atoms in a thimble, so we cannot follow them one by one. Instead we ask what the crowd does on average, and two measurable quantities appear: pressure and temperature. This lesson explains both in terms of atomic motion, which is the heart of thermodynamics.
Learning objective · 9.1.A
Describe the pressure a gas exerts on its container in terms of atomic motion within that gas.
Required content · EK 9.1.A.1
Atoms in a gas collide with and exert forces on other atoms in the gas and with the container in which the gas is contained. Collisions can be analyzed using conservation of momentum.
The pressure exerted by a gas on a surface is the ratio of the sum of the magnitudes of the perpendicular components of the forces exerted by the gas’s atoms on the surface to the area of the surface: \(P = F_\perp/A\).
Pressure exists throughout the gas itself, not just at the boundary between the gas and the container.
Learning objective · 9.1.B
Describe the temperature of a system in terms of the atomic motion within that system.
Required content · EK 9.1.B.1
The temperature of a system is characterized by the average kinetic energy of the atoms within that system.
The Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution is a graphical representation of the energies and speeds of atoms at a given temperature.
The root-mean-square speed corresponding to the average kinetic energy of an ideal gas is related to the temperature by \(K_{avg} = \tfrac{1}{2}m v_{rms}^2 = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\).
Pressure from collisions
Pressure is force per unit area, \(P = F_\perp/A\), measured in pascals (1 Pa = 1 N/m\(^2\)). The key word is perpendicular: only the part of the force pressing straight into the surface counts. Where does that force come from in a gas? From atoms bouncing off the walls.
Consider one atom of mass \(m\) hitting a wall head-on at speed \(v\) and rebounding at the same speed (an elastic collision). Take the direction toward the wall as positive. Its momentum changes from \(+mv\) to \(-mv\), so \(\Delta p = -2mv\). By conservation of momentum the wall receives \(+2mv\), the same size and opposite in sign. One bounce is a tiny impulse; an average force appears because there are astronomically many bounces. At room temperature, a wall of area 1 cm\(^2\) is struck by roughly \(10^{23}\) atoms every second. The impacts blur into a steady push: \(F_{avg} = N_{hits}\cdot 2mv/\Delta t\).
Figure 9.1a Gas pressure from collisions. Left: atoms move at random in a container and strike the walls. Right: in one elastic head-on collision the atom’s momentum reverses, Δp = −2mv, so by conservation of momentum the wall receives +2mv. The pressure is the average of an enormous number of such impulses per unit area and time.
Three more ideas follow from this picture, and each is a common exam question.
More atoms means more pressure. Doubling the number of atoms in the same container doubles the number of hits per second, so \(P\) doubles (at fixed temperature).
Smaller volume means more pressure. Squeeze the same atoms into half the volume and they reach any wall twice as often, so \(P\) doubles.
Faster atoms mean more pressure. A faster atom hits harder (larger \(\Delta p\)) and hits more often. Both effects raise the pressure, so raising the temperature raises \(P\) at fixed volume.
The pressure is not special to the walls. Imagine a thin imaginary sheet in the middle of the gas. Atoms cross it from both sides, and the momentum exchanged with the neighbors is the same kind of exchange that happens at a wall. That is why a pressure gauge or a sealed balloon registers the same pressure at any depth inside a gas (ignoring the small difference due to gravity). Pressure exists throughout the gas.
Temperature as average kinetic energy
Temperature is not the same as heat or energy. For a gas of atoms, temperature measures the average translational kinetic energy per atom. For an ideal monatomic gas,
\[ K_{avg} = \tfrac{1}{2}m v_{rms}^2 = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT, \]
where \(k_B = 1.38\times10^{-23}\) J/K is Boltzmann’s constant and \(T\) is the absolute (kelvin) temperature. The \(rms\) speed is the square root of the mean of the squares of the speeds, a kind of typical speed that weights fast atoms a little more than slow ones. Solving for it gives
\[ v_{rms} = \sqrt{\frac{3k_BT}{m}}. \]
Notice what this does and does not say. Two gases at the same temperature have the same average kinetic energy per atom, but the lighter atoms are faster because the same energy is shared by less mass. Doubling the kelvin temperature doubles the average kinetic energy but multiplies the speed by only \(\sqrt{2}\), because the speed depends on \(\sqrt{T}\).
The kelvin scale starts at absolute zero, where the average kinetic energy would be zero. A temperature in kelvin is the Celsius temperature plus 273 (more precisely 273.15). Using Celsius in \(\tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\) is a mistake: 0\(^\circ\)C does not mean zero energy. Doubling the Celsius temperature from 20\(^\circ\)C to 40\(^\circ\)C raises the kelvin temperature only from 293 K to 313 K, a 7% increase.
The Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution
The atoms in a gas do not all move at the same speed. Collisions constantly pass energy around, so at any instant some atoms are slow, most are near the middle, and a few are very fast. The Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution is the graph of how many atoms have each speed (or each energy) at a given temperature. You do not need its equation. You do need to read it.
Figure 9.1b The Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution for the same gas at two temperatures. Raising the temperature moves the peak to higher speed, lowers and broadens it, and leaves the area (the number of atoms) unchanged. The rms speed, marked with a dashed line, lies to the right of the peak because of the long tail of fast atoms.
Shape. It rises from zero (very few atoms are nearly at rest), reaches a peak, and has a long tail toward high speed.
Higher temperature. The whole curve shifts to the right, the peak lowers, and the curve broadens. The area under the curve is the same because it counts the same number of atoms.
Rms speed and peak. The rms speed lies to the right of the peak, because of the tail.
Heavier atoms. At the same temperature, heavier atoms have a curve shifted to the left (slower) and narrower.
The tail matters: at any temperature a few atoms are much faster than average, which is why a puddle can evaporate well below its boiling point and why chemical reactions speed up when warmed.
Figure 9.1c Root-mean-square speeds of common gases at 300 K, from vrms = √(3kBT/m). All of these molecules have the same average kinetic energy at the same temperature, so the lightest are the fastest: the speed scales as 1/√m. Hydrogen is about 3.2 times faster than neon, whose mass is 10 times larger.
Worked example · force from one collision
A helium atom (\(m = 6.64\times10^{-27}\) kg) strikes a wall head-on at 1300 m/s and rebounds with the same speed. Find the impulse it delivers to the wall, and the average force if \(2.0\times10^{23}\) such collisions happen on 1.0 cm\(^2\) each second.
One atom. \(\Delta p = 2mv = 2(6.64\times10^{-27})(1300) = 1.73\times10^{-23}\) kg·m/s.
Many atoms. The momentum delivered each second is \(2.0\times10^{23}\times1.73\times10^{-23} = 3.5\) kg·m/s per second, so \(F_{avg} = 3.5\) N.
Pressure. \(P = F/A = 3.5\ \text{N}/(1.0\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2) = 3.5\times10^{4}\) Pa. Real atoms strike at many angles and speeds, so this is a model, but the order of magnitude shows how a steady pressure arises from impulses.
Worked example · rms speed
Find the rms speed of helium (\(m = 6.64\times10^{-27}\) kg) and of nitrogen molecules (\(m = 4.65\times10^{-26}\) kg) at 300 K. Treat nitrogen as a single particle.
Check. The mass ratio is 7.0, so the speed ratio should be \(\sqrt{7.0} = 2.65\): \(1370/517 = 2.65\). ✓ Both gases have the same average kinetic energy, \(\tfrac{3}{2}k_BT = 6.21\times10^{-21}\) J per particle.
Worked example · explain in words
A sealed rigid container of gas is heated. Explain why the pressure on the walls rises.
Argument. Heating raises the temperature, and temperature measures the average kinetic energy of the atoms, so the atoms move faster on average. The volume and the number of atoms are unchanged. Each atom therefore hits a wall more often (it crosses the container faster) and with a larger momentum change per hit (\(\Delta p = 2mv\) is larger). Both effects increase the total perpendicular force per unit area, so the pressure increases.
Exam focus
Pressure. \(P = F_\perp/A\); it comes from collisions, analyzed with momentum and impulse, and it exists throughout the gas.
Temperature. Proportional to the average kinetic energy of the atoms: \(K_{avg} = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\), with \(T\) in kelvin.
Speed versus temperature. \(v_{rms} \propto \sqrt{T/m}\). Same \(T\), same average kinetic energy; lighter atoms are faster.
Distribution sketches. Higher \(T\): peak moves right and lower, curve wider, area unchanged. Heavier atoms: curve moves left.
Common error. Doubling the Celsius temperature does not double the energy or the pressure.
Practice
An atom of mass \(5.0\times10^{-26}\) kg hits a wall head-on at 400 m/s and rebounds elastically. What impulse does the wall receive?
Show answer
\(\Delta p = 2mv = 2(5.0\times10^{-26})(400) = 4.0\times10^{-23}\) kg·m/s, directed into the wall.
The temperature of a gas rises from 300 K to 1200 K. By what factor does the rms speed of its atoms change?
Show answer
\(v_{rms} \propto \sqrt{T}\), and \(T\) increases by a factor of 4, so the speed increases by a factor of 2.
Neon (20 u) and argon (40 u) are at the same temperature. Which has the greater average kinetic energy per atom, and which is faster on average?
Show answer
Their average kinetic energies are equal, since \(K_{avg} = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\). Neon is lighter, so it is faster; the ratio of rms speeds is \(\sqrt{40/20} = 1.41\).
Calculate the average kinetic energy of an atom in a gas at 27\(^\circ\)C.
Show answer
\(T = 300\) K. \(K_{avg} = \tfrac{3}{2}(1.38\times10^{-23})(300) = 6.21\times10^{-21}\) J.
A student says the pressure in a closed jar is highest at the walls and zero in the middle. Correct this.
Show answer
Pressure exists throughout the gas. Atoms in the middle exchange momentum with their neighbors just as atoms at the wall do, so the pressure is (nearly) the same everywhere in the gas. The walls are just where we usually measure it.
Sketch how the Maxwell–Boltzmann curve for a gas changes when it is cooled. State what happens to the peak position, the peak height, and the area.
Show answer
The peak moves to lower speed, the peak becomes taller and the curve narrower, and the area under the curve stays the same because the number of atoms has not changed.
A bicycle tire, a helium balloon and the air in a classroom all obey nearly the same equation, even though they hold different gases at different pressures. That is a remarkable fact, and it is possible because, at ordinary conditions, the atoms of a gas are so far apart that each one hardly notices the others. Physicists capture this with a simple model, the ideal gas, and one equation that links pressure, volume, amount and temperature. This lesson states the model, introduces the mole, and practices using the law to find a missing variable or a factor of change.
Learning objective · 9.2.A
Describe the properties of an ideal gas.
Required content · EK 9.2.A.1 and 9.2.A.2
The classical model of an ideal gas assumes that the instantaneous velocities of atoms are random, the volumes of the atoms are negligible compared to the total volume occupied by the gas, the atoms collide elastically, and the only appreciable forces on the atoms are those that occur during collisions.
An ideal gas is one in which the relationships between pressure, volume, the number of moles or number of atoms, and temperature of a gas can be modeled using the equation \(PV = nRT = Nk_BT\).
The ideal gas model
A model is a simplification chosen so that we can calculate. The ideal gas model makes four assumptions, which together say that the atoms behave like tiny, perfectly elastic billiard balls that interact only when they touch.
Random motion. At any instant the velocities of the atoms point in random directions with no preferred direction.
Negligible size. The atoms take up almost none of the container’s volume; nearly all of the volume is empty space between them.
Elastic collisions. No kinetic energy is lost when atoms collide with each other or with the walls.
No forces between collisions. The atoms do not attract or repel one another except at the instants of impact. (Gravity on a single atom is negligible.)
Real gases fit the model best when they are hot (atoms are fast and the weak attractions do not matter) and dilute (low pressure, so the atoms are far apart). Helium and other monatomic gases at room temperature and atmospheric pressure fit very well. On the AP exam, unless a problem says otherwise, ideal gases are monatomic.
The law
The pressure, volume, temperature and amount of an ideal gas are related by
\[ PV = nRT = Nk_BT. \]
Each symbol needs care.
\(P\) is the absolute pressure, in pascals. A tire gauge reads gauge pressure, the amount above atmospheric pressure (1 atm = \(1.01\times10^5\) Pa), so add atmospheric pressure before using the law.
\(V\) is the volume of the container, in cubic meters (1 L = \(10^{-3}\) m\(^3\)).
\(n\) is the amount in moles. One mole contains Avogadro’s number of particles, \(N_A = 6.02\times10^{23}\), so \(N = nN_A\).
\(T\) is the absolute temperature in kelvin.
\(R = 8.31\) J/(mol·K) is the universal gas constant and \(k_B = 1.38\times10^{-23}\) J/K is Boltzmann’s constant. They are related by \(R = N_Ak_B\), which is why the two forms of the law are the same equation: \(nRT = nN_Ak_BT = Nk_BT\).
Figure 9.2a The four variables of the ideal gas law: pressure \(P\) (force per area on the walls and piston), volume \(V\), temperature \(T\) (kelvin) and the amount of gas (\(n\) moles or \(N\) atoms). The constants on the right link the two forms of the law.
Use the \(n\) form when the problem gives moles and the \(N\) form when it counts atoms or molecules. Using the form \(PV = Nk_BT\) you can see the physical content: pressure is proportional to the number of atoms per unit volume and to the temperature. The law also holds for mixtures, and the same law applies to each gas in the mixture independently.
Factors of change
Many exam questions ask what happens to one variable when another changes. The approach is always the same: write the law, decide which quantities are held fixed, and let the others vary.
Fixed \(n\) and \(V\): \(P \propto T\). Doubling the kelvin temperature doubles \(P\).
Fixed \(n\) and \(P\): \(V \propto T\). Doubling the kelvin temperature doubles \(V\).
Fixed \(P\) and \(T\): \(V \propto n\). Adding gas expands a balloon in proportion.
For a fixed amount of gas that changes from one state to another, divide the law for the final state by the law for the initial state. This gives the combined gas law,
\[ \frac{P_1V_1}{T_1} = \frac{P_2V_2}{T_2}, \]
in which any unit may be used for \(P\) and \(V\) (it cancels) but \(T\) must be in kelvin.
Figure 9.2b Three ways to double the pressure of an ideal gas: double the kelvin temperature at fixed volume, halve the volume at fixed temperature, or double the number of atoms at fixed volume and temperature. All follow from \(P = nRT/V\).
Worked example · find the pressure
A rigid tank of volume 0.050 m\(^3\) contains 2.0 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K. Find the pressure.
Equation. \(P = nRT/V\).
Substitute. \(P = (2.0)(8.31)(300)/0.050 = 9.97\times10^{4}\) Pa, about 1.0 atm.
Worked example · how many atoms?
How many atoms of an ideal gas are in a 1.0 L container at \(1.01\times10^5\) Pa and 300 K? How many moles is that?
Equation. \(N = PV/(k_BT)\) with \(V = 1.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\).
A sealed container of fixed volume holds an ideal gas at 200 K and 1.0 atm. The temperature is raised to 600 K. Then half of the gas is released while the temperature stays at 600 K. Find the final pressure.
Step 1. At fixed \(V\) and \(n\), \(P \propto T\): \(P = 1.0\times(600/200) = 3.0\) atm.
Step 2. At fixed \(V\) and \(T\), \(P \propto n\): releasing half the gas halves the pressure, \(P = 1.5\) atm.
The temperature of a fixed amount of gas in a rigid container rises from 20\(^\circ\)C to 80\(^\circ\)C. By what factor does the pressure change?
Show answer
Convert to kelvin: 293 K to 353 K. \(P_2/P_1 = 353/293 = 1.20\), a 20% increase (not a factor of 4).
A gas at constant temperature is compressed to one third of its volume. What happens to its pressure?
Show answer
\(PV\) is constant, so the pressure triples.
A tire gauge reads 2.0\(\times10^5\) Pa (gauge) on a day when the atmospheric pressure is \(1.0\times10^5\) Pa. What absolute pressure should be used in the gas law?
Show answer
\(P = P_{gauge} + P_{atm} = 3.0\times10^5\) Pa.
Two containers have the same volume and temperature. One holds helium and the other holds argon, and both are at the same pressure. Which container holds more atoms? Explain.
Show answer
They hold the same number of atoms. \(N = PV/(k_BT)\) depends only on \(P\), \(V\) and \(T\), not on the kind of atom. (The argon container has more mass.)
Show that \(PV = nRT\) and \(PV = Nk_BT\) say the same thing.
Show answer
\(N = nN_A\) and \(R = N_Ak_B\), so \(nRT = nN_Ak_BT = Nk_BT\).
In the 1600s Robert Boyle trapped air in a bent glass tube, added mercury to squeeze it, and measured how the volume shrank as the pressure grew. Two centuries later experimenters heated gases and noticed something odd: when they extended their graphs of pressure against temperature backward, every gas pointed to the same temperature, about \(-273\,^\circ\)C. That unexpected agreement was the first hint of an absolute zero. This lesson turns the ideal gas law into graphs you can sketch and read, shows how to extract physical constants from them, and describes how you would test the law in a laboratory.
Learning objective · 9.2.A (continued)
Describe the properties of an ideal gas, including how graphs of its pressure, volume and temperature are used.
Required content · EK 9.2.A.3 and 9.2.A.4
Graphs modeling the pressure, temperature, and volume of gases can be used to describe or determine properties of that gas.
A temperature at which an ideal gas has zero pressure can be extrapolated from a graph of pressure as a function of temperature.
Four graphs, one law
Start from \(PV = nRT\) and hold two quantities fixed. Each choice gives a graph with a different shape, and the skill is to recognize each shape and to know what its slope means.
Fixed
Graph
Shape
Slope or constant
\(n\), \(T\)
\(P\) against \(V\)
Hyperbola (an isotherm)
\(PV = nRT\) at every point
\(n\), \(T\)
\(P\) against \(1/V\)
Straight line through the origin
Slope \(= nRT\)
\(n\), \(V\)
\(P\) against \(T\) (kelvin)
Straight line through the origin
Slope \(= nR/V\)
\(n\), \(P\)
\(V\) against \(T\) (kelvin)
Straight line through the origin
Slope \(= nR/P\)
Figure 9.3a The gas law as four graphs. The ‘P–V’ curve (an isotherm) is a hyperbola; plotting P against 1/V straightens it, and the slope is nRT. At constant volume P is proportional to T, and at constant pressure V is proportional to T, both with the line passing through the origin when T is in kelvin.
The first row is the one to learn well. The graph of \(P\) against \(V\) curves, so you cannot read a constant from it directly. Plot \(P\) against \(1/V\) instead and the data fall on a straight line. This is linearization: choose the variables so that the relationship becomes a straight line and the slope carries the physics. In a real experiment you do this because a line is easy to fit and easy to judge by eye, while a curve is not.
Changing the temperature changes the graph in predictable ways. On a \(P\)–\(V\) graph a higher temperature gives an isotherm farther from the origin (a larger \(PV\) product). On a \(P\)–\(1/V\) graph a higher temperature gives a steeper line. If you are asked to sketch two isotherms, draw the one for the higher temperature above and to the right of the other, and never let them cross.
Absolute zero from a graph
Fix the amount of gas and the volume, and measure the pressure at several Celsius temperatures. The points fall on a straight line, but the line does not pass through the origin of the Celsius axis, because 0\(^\circ\)C is not a special temperature for a gas. Extend the line backward until it reaches \(P = 0\). The temperature where this happens is the extrapolated absolute zero, near \(-273\,^\circ\)C. In kelvin the line passes through the origin, consistent with \(P = (nR/V)T\).
Figure 9.3b Finding absolute zero by extrapolation. Two different samples of gas, held at fixed volume, give straight lines of pressure against temperature with different slopes. Extended backward (dashed), both reach zero pressure at the same temperature, about −273 °C. The agreement is why the kelvin scale can be defined with one fixed zero.
Notice that this is an extrapolation. Real gases condense to liquids before they get anywhere near this temperature, so no real gas actually reaches zero pressure. What the graph shows is that the ideal gas model, extended, points to a lowest possible temperature. Every gas gives nearly the same intercept, which is evidence that the temperature scale from the gas law is universal.
Designing a gas-law experiment
The free-response section often asks you to design an experiment. For gases the classic design is a sealed syringe. Trap a fixed amount of air in a syringe, attach a pressure sensor, and change the volume slowly (so the temperature stays constant). A second version loads books of known weight on the plunger: the absolute pressure is \(P = P_{atm} + mg/A\), where \(A\) is the cross-sectional area of the plunger.
Figure 9.3c Testing Boyle’s law. A fixed amount of air is trapped in a syringe; the volume is read from the scale and the pressure from a sensor (or computed from the books’ weight, \(P = P_{atm} + mg/A\)). Plotting \(P\) against \(1/V\) straightens the data; the slope is \(nRT\), and the line should pass through the origin.
Measure. Record the volume \(V\) from the syringe scale and the pressure \(P\) from the sensor for at least five settings.
Control. Move the plunger slowly so the air stays at room temperature, and check for leaks, since \(n\) must stay fixed.
Plot. Graph \(P\) against \(1/V\). The data should fall on a line through the origin with slope \(nRT\).
Analyze. Find the slope of the best-fit line. Then \(n = \text{slope}/(RT)\), or compare the slope with the prediction.
Error sources. Air trapped in the tip of the syringe adds a small volume that does not change. Friction between the plunger and the barrel changes the pressure for the books-on-plunger method. Slow changes only keep the temperature constant approximately.
Worked example · extrapolating to absolute zero
A student measures the pressure of a fixed volume of gas: 100 kPa at 0\(^\circ\)C and 137 kPa at 100\(^\circ\)C. Assume the pressure is a linear function of temperature and extrapolate to the temperature at which the pressure would be zero.
Extrapolate. From 100 kPa at 0\(^\circ\)C, the pressure falls to zero after \(100/0.37 = 270\) degrees below zero, so the intercept is \(-270\,^\circ\)C.
Compare. The accepted value is \(-273.15\,^\circ\)C; the difference of about 1% is within the precision of two data points.
Worked example · isothermal compression
A gas in a syringe is at 100 kPa and 2.0 mL. The plunger is pushed slowly until the volume is 0.50 mL, and the temperature stays constant. Find the final pressure, and state what a \(P\)–\(1/V\) graph would show.
Graph. The factor of 4 in \(1/V\) gives the factor of 4 in \(P\). The points lie on a straight line through the origin with slope \(P_1V_1 = 200\) kPa·mL.
Worked example · combined gas law
A sealed 2.0 L container of air at 300 K and \(1.0\times10^5\) Pa is heated to 450 K while a piston lets the volume grow to 3.0 L. Find the final pressure.
Equation. \(P_2 = P_1(V_1/V_2)(T_2/T_1)\).
Substitute. \(P_2 = (1.0\times10^5)(2.0/3.0)(450/300) = 1.0\times10^5\) Pa. The pressure is unchanged: the volume grew by a factor of 1.5 and so did the temperature.
Exam focus
Shapes. \(P\)–\(V\) hyperbola; \(P\)–\(1/V\), \(P\)–\(T\) and \(V\)–\(T\) straight lines through the origin (kelvin).
Slopes. \(P\) against \(1/V\): \(nRT\). \(P\) against \(T\): \(nR/V\). \(V\) against \(T\): \(nR/P\).
Absolute zero. Extrapolate the \(P\)–\(T\) line back to \(P = 0\); it is about \(-273\,^\circ\)C for any gas.
Experiment design. Measure \(P\) and \(V\); keep \(T\) and \(n\) constant; linearize with \(1/V\); get the constant from the slope.
Sketching. Higher temperature: isotherm farther from the origin, steeper \(P\)–\(1/V\) line. Isotherms never cross.
Practice
A gas at fixed temperature has a pressure of 60 kPa at 5.0 L. What is its pressure at 3.0 L?
Show answer
\(P_2 = (60)(5.0)/3.0 = 100\) kPa.
On a graph of \(P\) against \(1/V\) for a fixed amount of gas at 300 K, the slope is 24.9 J (in SI units). How many moles are there?
Show answer
Slope \(= nRT\), so \(n = 24.9/(8.31\times300) = 0.010\) mol.
A student plots the pressure of a fixed gas sample against its Celsius temperature and gets a straight line that reaches zero pressure at \(-272\,^\circ\)C. What does the intercept represent, and why is it an extrapolation?
Show answer
It estimates absolute zero, the temperature at which the ideal gas pressure would vanish. It is an extrapolation because real gases condense before reaching it, so no measurement can be made there.
A student puts books on a syringe plunger and notices that the air volume is smaller than the ideal gas law predicts at the first setting. Name one experimental error that could explain this.
Show answer
Friction in the plunger changes the net force that the books apply, a small leak lets gas escape (smaller \(n\)), or air was heated by the pushing; any of these changes \(P\) or \(n\) from what was assumed.
Sketch two isotherms on a \(P\)–\(V\) graph, one at 300 K and one at 600 K. Which one is farther from the origin?
Show answer
The 600 K isotherm is farther from the origin because \(PV = nRT\) is twice as large. The curves are hyperbolas that do not cross.
A fixed amount of gas in a rigid container is heated. A student plots \(P\) against \(T\) in kelvin. What does the graph look like, and what physical quantities does the slope contain?
Show answer
A straight line through the origin. The slope is \(nR/V\) (or \(Nk_B/V\)), which depends on the amount of gas and the container volume.
Pick up a spoon that has been sitting in a hot cup of tea and your fingers get warm, while the tea cools slightly. Nobody pushed anything with a force that did work; energy simply moved from the hot object to the colder one because of their difference in temperature. This is the most familiar thermal process, and it is the starting point for the first and second laws of thermodynamics. In this lesson we name the ways energy is transferred, explain why it flows from hot to cold in terms of atomic collisions, and define thermal equilibrium.
Learning objective · 9.3.A
Describe the transfer of energy between two systems in thermal contact due to temperature differences of those two systems.
Required content · EK 9.3.A
Two systems are in thermal contact if the systems may transfer energy by thermal processes. Heating is the transfer of energy into a system by thermal processes; cooling is the transfer of energy out of a system by thermal processes.
The thermal processes by which energy may be transferred between systems at different temperatures are conduction, convection, and radiation.
Energy is transferred through thermal processes spontaneously from a higher-temperature system to a lower-temperature system. In collisions between atoms from different systems, energy is most likely to be transferred from higher-energy atoms to lower-energy atoms. After many collisions, the most probable state is one in which both systems have the same temperature.
Thermal equilibrium results when no net energy is transferred by thermal processes between two systems in thermal contact with each other.
Heating, cooling and the word “heat”
We use heating for the transfer of energy into a system by thermal processes, and cooling for the transfer out of a system. The amount of energy transferred this way is written \(Q\) and measured in joules. In everyday speech people say an object “has heat,” and that causes confusion. An object has internal energy and a temperature; it does not contain a quantity called heat. Heating is a process, a way energy gets into or out of the system, just as doing work is a process. Two systems are in thermal contact if they can exchange energy this way, even if they never touch (the Sun and the Earth are in thermal contact by radiation).
Three thermal processes
Process
How energy moves
Needs a medium?
Example
Conduction
Collisions between neighboring atoms and free electrons pass kinetic energy along, with no bulk motion of the material.
Yes, matter in contact
A metal spoon in hot soup
Convection
Moving fluid carries energy from one place to another. Warm fluid is less dense and rises; cooler fluid sinks.
Yes, a fluid
Warm air rising from a radiator; ocean currents
Radiation
Electromagnetic waves carry energy. Every object with a temperature emits it.
No; it crosses a vacuum
Sunlight; the glow of a heating coil
Figure 9.4a The three thermal processes. Conduction: energy is passed along by collisions between neighboring atoms. Convection: a moving fluid carries energy with it. Radiation: electromagnetic waves carry energy and need no medium.
Several of these usually act together. Standing in front of a fire you feel radiation directly, the air near the fire warms by conduction and convection, and a metal poker handle warms by conduction. Part of the skill on the exam is to identify which process is the main one in a given situation. Metals conduct well because their free electrons carry energy quickly; air and foam conduct poorly (they are good insulators), which is why a fluffy jacket or double-pane window slows the loss of energy.
Why energy flows from hot to cold
The atoms of a hot object have, on average, more kinetic energy than the atoms of a cold object. Place them in contact and atoms collide across the boundary. In a collision between a high-energy atom and a low-energy atom the energy is shared, and on average the low-energy atom gains and the high-energy atom loses. It is possible for a single collision to go the other way, but with trillions of collisions the net result is overwhelmingly one-sided: the cold object’s atoms speed up and the hot object’s slow down. The direction is not forced by a law of motion for each collision; it is the most probable outcome for the whole crowd. Lesson 9.8 returns to this idea under the name entropy.
The transfer continues until the two sides have the same average kinetic energy per atom, the same temperature. Then collisions still occur, but on average as much energy passes one way as the other, so there is no net transfer. That state is thermal equilibrium. Two systems in equilibrium with a third are in equilibrium with each other, which is why a thermometer works: it reaches equilibrium with the object, and its own temperature is then the object’s.
Figure 9.4b Two objects in thermal contact. Atoms of the hot object (fast, left) collide with atoms of the cold object (slow, right) and on average give up energy, so the hot object cools and the cold one warms. The two temperatures meet at a common value, where the net transfer is zero: thermal equilibrium.
The graph of temperature against time for two objects in contact shows the pattern. The hot object cools, the cold object warms, both curves flatten as they approach a common final temperature, and the rate of transfer is greatest at the start, when the temperature difference is largest. The final temperature lies between the two starting values; it is closer to the one belonging to the system that can store more energy per degree (larger mass or larger specific heat, a topic for lesson 9.7).
Worked example · identifying the process
Name the main thermal process in each case: (a) sunlight warming a parked car; (b) a pot of water on a stove, once the bottom has heated; (c) the handle of a pot on a stove; (d) the Earth’s interior heat reaching the surface through rock.
(a) Radiation: the Sun’s energy crosses a vacuum and passes through the glass. (b) Convection: the heated water at the bottom becomes less dense and rises while cooler water sinks. (c) Conduction: energy passes along the metal. (d) Conduction through the solid rock (with some convection deep in the mantle).
Worked example · equal samples in contact
Two identical, rigid, insulated-from-the-outside containers each hold 1.0 mol of the same ideal monatomic gas, one at 300 K and the other at 500 K. They are placed in thermal contact. Find the final temperature and the average kinetic energy of an atom afterward.
Reasoning. The samples are identical, so they hold equal amounts of energy per kelvin. The energy given up by the hot gas equals the energy gained by the cold gas, so the final temperature is the average: \(T_f = (300+500)/2 = 400\) K.
Energy per atom. \(K_{avg} = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT_f = \tfrac{3}{2}(1.38\times10^{-23})(400) = 8.28\times10^{-21}\) J, the same for atoms of both samples.
Worked example · explain in words
A student places a metal block at 80\(^\circ\)C against a wooden block at 20\(^\circ\)C. After a long time a thermometer reads the same temperature for both. Explain, in terms of atoms, why the energy transfer stopped.
Argument. At first, atoms in the metal block had higher average kinetic energy than atoms in the wood. In collisions across the contact surface, energy was transferred on average from the faster metal atoms to the slower wood atoms, lowering the metal’s temperature and raising the wood’s. This continued until the average kinetic energies of atoms in the two blocks were equal. Then collisions in either direction transfer equal amounts of energy on average, so there is no net transfer: the blocks are in thermal equilibrium.
Exam focus
Vocabulary. Heating and cooling are processes; use \(Q\) for the energy transferred, never “an amount of heat.”
Three processes. Conduction (contact, atoms colliding), convection (moving fluid), radiation (electromagnetic waves, no medium).
Direction. Spontaneously from higher to lower temperature, because high-energy atoms most probably give energy to low-energy atoms.
Equilibrium. No net transfer; both systems have the same temperature. Collisions continue.
Writing. Argue from average kinetic energy of atoms in collisions, not from the idea that “cold flows in.”
Practice
Which thermal process allows the Sun’s energy to reach the Earth?
Show answer
Radiation, since there is no medium in space.
Why does a metal tray feel colder than a wooden tray in the same room, even though both are at the room temperature?
Show answer
Metal conducts energy away from your hand much faster than wood does, so your skin loses energy at a greater rate and feels colder, although the two trays are at the same temperature.
Two objects are in thermal equilibrium. What can you say about their temperatures, and about the energy transferred between them?
Show answer
Their temperatures are equal, and the net energy transferred between them is zero (equal amounts pass in each direction).
An ideal gas sample at 200 K is placed in contact with an identical sample at 400 K. What is the final temperature if no energy is lost to the surroundings?
Show answer
The two samples are identical, so the final temperature is the average, 300 K.
A student says, “When ice touches your hand, cold flows from the ice into your hand.” Rewrite the statement correctly.
Show answer
Energy flows from the hand (higher temperature) into the ice (lower temperature), by conduction. The hand is being cooled and the ice is being heated.
Why is a thermal-energy transfer from cold to hot not impossible in a single collision, yet it never occurs for macroscopic objects?
Show answer
A single collision may transfer energy either way, but for enormous numbers of atoms the most probable outcome by far is that energy moves from the higher-energy atoms to the lower-energy atoms on average; the probability of a net reverse transfer for a macroscopic system is vanishingly small.
Internal energy and the first law of thermodynamics
Pump a bicycle tire quickly and the pump barrel gets warm. Nobody lit a fire in it; you did work on the air by compressing it, and the energy went into the motion of its atoms. Rub your hands together and the same thing happens. Energy can enter a system as work or as heating, and what the system does with it is raise its internal energy. The first law of thermodynamics is the statement that none of this energy is lost: it is conservation of energy written for systems of many particles. This lesson defines internal energy, gives the first law with its sign convention, and shows how to use it for a gas.
Learning objective · 9.4.A
Describe the internal energy of a system.
Required content · EK 9.4.A
The internal energy of a system is the sum of the kinetic energy of the objects that make up the system and the potential energy of the configuration of those objects.
The atoms in an ideal gas do not interact with each other via conservative forces and the internal structure is not considered, so an ideal gas has no internal potential energy. The internal energy of an ideal monatomic gas is the sum of the kinetic energies of its atoms: \(U = \tfrac{3}{2}nRT = \tfrac{3}{2}Nk_BT\).
Changes to a system’s internal energy can result in changes to the internal structure and internal behavior of that system without changing the motion of the system’s center of mass.
Learning objective · 9.4.B (part 1)
Describe the behavior of a system using thermodynamic processes.
Required content · EK 9.4.B.1
The first law of thermodynamics is a restatement of conservation of energy that accounts for energy transferred into or out of a system by work, heating, or cooling. For an isolated system, the total energy is constant.
For a closed system, the change in internal energy is the sum of the energy transferred to or from the system by heating, and the work done on the system: \(\Delta U = Q + W\).
The work done on a system by a constant or average external pressure that changes the volume of that system (for example, a piston compressing a gas) is \(W = -P\Delta V\).
Internal energy of an ideal gas
In Physics 1 you kept track of the kinetic energy of a whole object moving through space and its potential energy in a field. A gas in a closed box sitting on a table has none of that: its center of mass is at rest. But its atoms are all moving, and the energy of that hidden motion is the gas’s internal energy \(U\). Internal energy is the sum of the kinetic energies of the particles and the potential energy of their interactions.
An ideal gas has no interactions except during collisions, so it has no potential energy at all, and its internal energy is just the total kinetic energy of its atoms. From lesson 9.1 each monatomic atom has average kinetic energy \(\tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\). With \(N\) atoms,
\[ U = N\cdot\tfrac{3}{2}k_BT = \tfrac{3}{2}nRT. \]
Two consequences are used constantly. First, \(U\) depends only on the temperature (and the amount of gas): if the temperature does not change, \(\Delta U = 0\). Second, \(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}nR\,\Delta T\), so the sign of \(\Delta T\) tells you the sign of \(\Delta U\). Because \(PV = nRT\), we can also write \(U = \tfrac{3}{2}PV\), which is helpful when you are given a PV diagram instead of a temperature.
Internal energy is a state function: it depends only on the current state of the gas (its \(P\), \(V\), \(T\)), not on how the gas got there. Work and heating are not state functions; they depend on the path.
The first law
There are two ways to change the internal energy of a closed system: transfer energy by heating (or cooling), \(Q\), or transfer energy by work, \(W\). The first law says
\[ \Delta U = Q + W. \]
Sign convention. This course defines both \(Q\) and \(W\) as energy transferred into the system. So \(Q\) is positive when the system is heated and negative when it is cooled, and \(W\) is positive when work is done on the system and negative when the system does work on its surroundings. Whenever you see a sign problem on an exam, check it against this table.
Figure 9.5a The sign convention for the first law, \(\Delta U = Q + W\). Q and W are both energy transferred into the system: heating and compression are positive; cooling and expansion are negative.
For a gas in a cylinder with a movable piston, work is done by changing the volume. If the pressure is constant (or if we use an average pressure), pushing the piston inward so the volume decreases does positive work on the gas, and letting the gas expand does negative work on it:
\[ W = -P\Delta V. \]
With \(\Delta V \lt 0\) (compression) \(W \gt 0\); with \(\Delta V \gt 0\) (expansion) \(W \lt 0\). A force that does not change the volume (a rigid container) does no work, so \(W = 0\) if \(\Delta V = 0\).
Figure 9.5b Work on a gas by a piston at constant pressure, \(W = -P\Delta V\). Pushing the piston in (\(\Delta V \lt 0\)) does positive work on the gas and raises its energy. When the gas pushes the piston out (\(\Delta V \gt 0\)) the work done on it is negative.
Applying the first law in three steps avoids most errors: (1) decide whether the temperature increases, decreases or stays the same, which gives the sign of \(\Delta U\); (2) find \(W\) from the volume change; (3) solve for \(Q\) or whatever is unknown. For an isolated system, \(Q = 0\) and \(W = 0\), so \(\Delta U = 0\) and the energy is constant.
Worked example · heating at constant volume
An ideal monatomic gas of 2.0 mol in a rigid container is heated from 300 K to 350 K. Find \(\Delta U\), \(W\) and \(Q\).
Internal energy. \(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}nR\Delta T = \tfrac{3}{2}(2.0)(8.31)(50) = 1250\) J.
Work. The volume does not change, so \(W = 0\).
Heating. \(Q = \Delta U - W = +1250\) J. All the energy transferred by heating becomes internal energy.
Worked example · fast compression
A bicycle pump compresses 1.0 mol of air quickly, doing 200 J of work on it. Assume that no energy leaves the air by heating during the short stroke and treat the air as monatomic. Find the temperature rise.
First law. \(Q = 0\) (fast, so adiabatic), \(W = +200\) J, so \(\Delta U = +200\) J.
Temperature. \(\Delta T = \Delta U/(\tfrac{3}{2}nR) = 200/(1.5\times1.0\times8.31) = 16\) K. The air in the pump warms by about 16 K.
Worked example · isobaric expansion
A gas at constant pressure \(2.0\times10^5\) Pa expands from 0.010 m\(^3\) to 0.020 m\(^3\) while 5000 J enter by heating. Find \(W\), \(\Delta U\) and whether the temperature rises.
Work. \(W = -P\Delta V = -(2.0\times10^5)(0.010) = -2000\) J (the gas does work on its surroundings).
First law. \(\Delta U = Q + W = 5000 - 2000 = +3000\) J.
Conclusion. \(\Delta U \gt 0\), so \(T\) rises. Check with \(PV = nRT\): the volume doubled at constant \(P\), so the kelvin temperature doubled.
Exam focus
Ideal gas energy. \(U = \tfrac{3}{2}nRT\); \(\Delta U = 0\) when \(T\) is constant.
First law. \(\Delta U = Q + W\); \(Q \gt 0\) heating, \(W \gt 0\) work done on the system.
Procedure. Sign of \(\Delta U\) from \(\Delta T\); \(W\) from \(\Delta V\); solve for \(Q\).
Common error. Using the sign convention “work done by the gas” from other courses; this course counts work done on the gas as positive.
Practice
A gas absorbs 400 J by heating and does 150 J of work on its surroundings. Find \(\Delta U\).
Show answer
\(Q = +400\) J; the gas does work, so \(W = -150\) J. \(\Delta U = 400 - 150 = +250\) J.
An ideal monatomic gas of 0.50 mol cools from 500 K to 400 K at constant volume. Find \(\Delta U\) and \(Q\).
Show answer
\(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}(0.50)(8.31)(-100) = -623\) J. \(W = 0\), so \(Q = -623\) J: the gas is cooled and gives up 623 J.
A gas is compressed at a constant pressure of \(1.0\times10^5\) Pa from 0.040 m\(^3\) to 0.010 m\(^3\). Find the work done on the gas.
Show answer
\(\Delta V = -0.030\) m\(^3\), so \(W = -P\Delta V = +3000\) J.
An isolated ideal gas has no energy transfer in or out. What can be said about its temperature?
Show answer
\(Q = W = 0\), so \(\Delta U = 0\) and the temperature is constant (for an ideal gas).
An ideal gas in a cylinder is kept at constant temperature while it is compressed by 600 J of work. How much energy is transferred by heating?
Show answer
\(T\) constant gives \(\Delta U = 0\), so \(Q = -W = -600\) J: the gas gives 600 J to its surroundings.
Two students push a piston inward. Student A does it very quickly, student B very slowly in a metal cylinder that conducts well. Compare the temperature changes and explain.
Show answer
Quickly, there is no time for energy to leave by heating (\(Q \approx 0\)), so \(\Delta U = W \gt 0\) and the gas warms. Slowly, the energy leaves as heating, so \(\Delta U\) can stay near zero and the temperature is nearly constant.
An automobile engine runs through the same four steps thousands of times a minute: gas is drawn in, compressed, ignited so that it expands and pushes the piston, and exhausted. Engineers track each step on a graph of pressure against volume. That graph, the PV diagram, lets you read the work done on a gas directly as an area, see at a glance how the temperature changes, and recognize the special cases that appear on every AP Physics 2 exam: isovolumetric, isobaric, isothermal and adiabatic processes. This lesson develops those tools and then follows a gas around a complete cycle.
Learning objective · 9.4.B (part 2)
Describe the behavior of a system using thermodynamic processes.
Required content · EK 9.4.B.2 and 9.4.B.3
Pressure–volume graphs (PV diagrams) are representations used to represent thermodynamic processes. Lines of constant temperature on a PV diagram are called isotherms.
The absolute value of the work done on a gas when the gas expands or compresses is equal to the area underneath the curve of a plot of pressure versus volume for the gas.
Special cases of thermal processes depend on the relationship between the configuration of the system, the nature of the work done on the system, and the system’s surroundings. These include constant volume (isovolumetric), constant temperature (isothermal), and constant pressure (isobaric), as well as processes where no energy is transferred to or from the system through thermal processes (adiabatic).
Reading a PV diagram
Each point on a PV diagram is one state of a fixed amount of gas: its pressure, volume, and (through \(PV = nRT\)) its temperature. A curve or line joining two points is the process that carries the gas from the first state to the second. An arrow shows the direction.
Work is an area. For a process at constant pressure, \(|W| = P|\Delta V|\), which is a rectangle on the diagram. For any process, \(|W|\) is the area between the curve and the volume axis.
The sign comes from the direction. Moving to the right (expansion) means the gas does work, so \(W \lt 0\) for the gas. Moving to the left (compression) means work is done on the gas, so \(W \gt 0\).
Temperature from \(PV\). Because \(T \propto PV\), points farther from the origin are hotter. All points on one hyperbola \(PV = \) constant have the same temperature (an isotherm), and \(U\) is the same for all of them.
Internal energy. \(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}\Delta(PV)\) for a monatomic gas, so you can find \(\Delta U\) directly from the coordinates of the two end points.
Figure 9.6a Work as the area under the process curve. The size of the work is the shaded area, \(P|\Delta V|\) for constant pressure. The sign depends on direction: expansion (to the right) means the gas does work, \(W \lt 0\); compression (to the left) means work is done on the gas, \(W \gt 0\).
Four special processes
The first law \(\Delta U = Q + W\) takes a simple form in each special process, and the shapes of the paths are worth memorizing.
Process
What is constant or zero
On the PV diagram
First law consequence
Isovolumetric (isochoric)
\(\Delta V = 0\)
Vertical line
\(W = 0\), so \(\Delta U = Q\)
Isobaric
\(P\) constant
Horizontal line
\(W = -P\Delta V\); \(Q\) and \(W\) both matter
Isothermal
\(T\) constant
Hyperbola \(PV = \) constant
\(\Delta U = 0\), so \(Q = -W\)
Adiabatic
\(Q = 0\)
Curve steeper than an isotherm
\(\Delta U = W\)
Figure 9.6b Four special processes from one starting state. Isobaric: horizontal. Isovolumetric: vertical. Isothermal: along the hyperbola \(PV = \) constant. Adiabatic: steeper than the isotherm, so an adiabatic expansion ends at a lower pressure and a lower temperature.
The adiabatic curve deserves a closer look. It is steeper than the isotherm through the same point. In an adiabatic expansion the gas does work, so \(\Delta U = W \lt 0\) and the gas cools, ending at a lower temperature than where an isothermal expansion would end, hence lower pressure. In an adiabatic compression the gas warms. Adiabatic processes are fast (little time for energy to leave) or occur in an insulated container. A fire syringe, in which a plunger is driven down suddenly and the air gets hot enough to ignite a bit of tissue, is an adiabatic compression.
Cycles
A cycle returns the gas to its starting state, so over a complete cycle \(\Delta U = 0\) and therefore \(Q_{net} = -W_{net}\). On the PV diagram a cycle is a closed loop, and the net work is the enclosed area: the work is negative (done by the gas) if the loop is clockwise, and positive (done on the gas) if it is counterclockwise. Clockwise cycles are engines; counterclockwise cycles are refrigerators and heat pumps.
Figure 9.6c A clockwise cycle for a monatomic gas. The enclosed area, (2.0 × 105 Pa)(0.020 m3) = 4000 J, is the magnitude of the net work. Over the cycle ΔU = 0 and the net work done on the gas is −4000 J, so 4000 J more enters by heating than leaves.
Worked example · work from a diagram
A gas expands at a constant pressure of \(3.0\times10^5\) Pa from 0.010 m\(^3\) to 0.030 m\(^3\). Then it is cooled at constant volume until its pressure drops to \(1.0\times10^5\) Pa. Find the work done on the gas in each step, and \(\Delta U\) for the whole process if the initial temperature is \(T_0\) and \(n R T_0= 3000\) J.
Step 1 (isobaric). \(W_1 = -(3.0\times10^5)(0.020) = -6000\) J.
Step 2 (isovolumetric). \(W_2 = 0\).
Temperatures. Initial state \(PV = (3.0\times10^5)(0.010) = 3000\) J \(= nRT_0\). Final state \(PV = (1.0\times10^5)(0.030) = 3000\) J. The initial and final points have the same product \(PV\), so they are on the same isotherm and \(\Delta U = 0\) overall.
Net heating. \(Q = \Delta U - W = 0 - (-6000) = +6000\) J: the net energy entering the gas by heating equals the work it did.
Worked example · a complete cycle
An ideal monatomic gas goes clockwise through the rectangle A \(\to\) B \(\to\) C \(\to\) D \(\to\) A: A (\(1.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.010 m\(^3\)), B (\(3.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.010 m\(^3\)), C (\(3.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.030 m\(^3\)), D (\(1.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.030 m\(^3\)). Find the work, \(\Delta U\) and \(Q\) for each step and the net work.
Use \(W = -P\Delta V\) and \(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}\Delta(PV)\), then \(Q = \Delta U - W\).
Step
Process
\(W\) (J)
\(\Delta U\) (J)
\(Q\) (J)
A \(\to\) B
isovolumetric
0
+3000
+3000
B \(\to\) C
isobaric expansion
\(-6000\)
+9000
+15000
C \(\to\) D
isovolumetric
0
\(-9000\)
\(-9000\)
D \(\to\) A
isobaric compression
+2000
\(-3000\)
\(-5000\)
Cycle
\(-4000\)
0
+4000
Check. The enclosed area is \((2.0\times10^5\ \text{Pa})(0.020\ \text{m}^3) = 4000\) J, equal to the net work done by the gas, and \(\Delta U\) sums to zero. ✓ Energy enters by heating in steps A\(\to\)B and B\(\to\)C (total 18000 J) and leaves in C\(\to\)D and D\(\to\)A (total 14000 J).
Worked example · explain in words
A gas is expanded from the same initial state along an isotherm and along an adiabat, to the same final volume. Compare the final pressures, the work done by the gas, and the heating.
Argument. In the adiabatic expansion \(Q = 0\) and the gas does work, so its internal energy and temperature fall; since \(P \propto T\) at a given volume, the final pressure is lower than in the isothermal case, where the temperature is unchanged. The adiabat lies below the isotherm, so the area under it, and the work done by the gas, is smaller. In the isothermal case \(\Delta U = 0\), so the gas must absorb energy by heating equal to the work it does. In the adiabatic case no energy is absorbed by heating.
Exam focus
Work. Area under the curve; sign from the direction (right means \(W \lt 0\)).
Special cases. Isovolumetric \(W = 0\); isothermal \(\Delta U = 0\); adiabatic \(Q = 0\); isobaric \(W = -P\Delta V\).
Temperature. \(T \propto PV\); compare products, or compare positions relative to isotherms.
Cycles. \(\Delta U = 0\), net \(Q = -\) net \(W\), net work equals the enclosed area (clockwise: done by the gas).
Common errors. Reading the area as the work without checking direction; drawing an adiabat shallower than an isotherm.
Practice
A gas expands at \(2.0\times10^5\) Pa from 0.020 m\(^3\) to 0.050 m\(^3\). Find the work done on the gas.
Show answer
\(W = -P\Delta V = -(2.0\times10^5)(0.030) = -6000\) J.
An ideal gas undergoes an isothermal expansion and does 800 J of work. How much energy is transferred by heating?
Show answer
\(\Delta U = 0\), so \(Q = -W = +800\) J (800 J enters by heating).
A monatomic gas is compressed adiabatically with 500 J of work. Find \(\Delta U\), \(Q\), and say whether the temperature rises.
Show answer
\(Q = 0\), \(\Delta U = W = +500\) J, so the temperature rises.
On a PV diagram a gas moves from state 1 (\(2.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.010 m\(^3\)) to state 2 (\(1.0\times10^5\) Pa, 0.040 m\(^3\)). Is the final temperature higher or lower than the initial?
Show answer
\(PV\) goes from 2000 J to 4000 J. Since \(T \propto PV\), the final temperature is twice as high.
Describe a clockwise cycle on a PV diagram in terms of the signs of the net work done on the gas and the net heating.
Show answer
Net work done on the gas is negative (the gas does net work). Since \(\Delta U = 0\) for the cycle, the net energy transferred by heating is positive, equal in size to the net work done by the gas.
In the cycle of the worked example, the gas absorbed 18000 J in total and did 4000 J of net work. What fraction of the energy absorbed became net work?
Show answer
On a summer afternoon the sand at the beach is too hot to walk on, while the water beside it is pleasantly cool, even though both have been in the same sunshine for hours. Later, at night, the sand is cold and the water is still warm. The sand changes temperature easily and the water resists change. A thick wool blanket keeps you warm, while a thin sheet of metal does not, though both are the same temperature as the room. Two properties of a material explain these everyday facts: its specific heat, which says how much energy it takes to change its temperature, and its thermal conductivity, which says how fast energy moves through it. This lesson develops both, and shows how to measure them.
Learning objective · 9.5.A
Describe the energy required to change the temperature of an object by a certain amount.
Required content · EK 9.5.A
The amount of energy required to change the temperature of a material is related to the material’s specific heat: \(Q = mc\Delta T\).
The specific heat of a material is an intrinsic property of that material that depends on the arrangement and interactions of the atoms that make up the material.
Learning objective · 9.5.B
Describe the rate at which energy is transferred by conduction through a given material.
Required content · EK 9.5.B
The rate at which energy is transferred by conduction through a given material is related to the thermal conductivity, the physical dimensions of the material, and the temperature difference across the material: \(\dfrac{Q}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{kA\Delta T}{L}\).
The thermal conductivity of a material is an intrinsic property of that material that depends on the arrangement and interactions of the atoms that make up the material.
Boundary: AP Physics 2 models specific heat as independent of temperature.
Specific heat
The energy needed to raise the temperature of a sample by \(\Delta T\) is proportional to its mass and to the temperature change:
\[ Q = mc\,\Delta T, \]
where \(c\) is the specific heat of the material, in J/(kg·K). Water has \(c = 4186\) J/(kg·K), which is large; copper has 385 and aluminum 900. A kelvin and a Celsius degree are the same size, so \(\Delta T\) can be taken in either. A larger \(c\) means more energy for the same temperature change, so a substance with a large specific heat warms and cools slowly. That is why water moderates coastal climates and why a car radiator uses water.
The specific heat is a property of the material’s atoms, not of the object’s size, and it depends on how the atoms are arranged and how they are bound. Water is unusual because its molecules can store energy in rotation and in hydrogen-bond stretching as well as in translation, so it takes a lot of energy to raise its temperature. A monatomic gas, by contrast, can store energy only as translational kinetic energy, so its internal energy increases by exactly \(\tfrac{3}{2}nR\) per kelvin.
When two objects exchange energy only with each other, the energy lost by one equals the energy gained by the other, \(Q_{hot} + Q_{cold} = 0\). The result is the calorimetry method: write \(mc\Delta T\) for each object (with \(\Delta T = T_f - T_i\), so a loss comes out negative), set the sum equal to zero, and solve for the common final temperature. With two objects, \(T_f\) is a weighted average of the starting temperatures, weighted by \(mc\), the energy each object stores per kelvin.
Figure 9.7a Calorimetry. In an insulated container the copper loses exactly the energy the water gains (33.1 kJ). The water has 4186 J/K of heat capacity against 192.5 J/K for the copper, so the final temperature, 27.9 °C, is much nearer the water’s starting value.
An experiment that measures \(c\): heat a sample with an electric heater of known power \(P\) for a time \(t\), so \(Q = Pt\), while recording the temperature. A graph of \(\Delta T\) against \(Q\) is a straight line with slope \(1/(mc)\); a graph of \(Q\) against \(\Delta T\) has slope \(mc\). Good practice includes insulating the sample (to reduce losses by conduction, convection and radiation), stirring liquids so the temperature is uniform, and subtracting the energy absorbed by the container.
Figure 9.7b The experiment that measures specific heat. For a fixed mass, a plot of the energy supplied against the temperature change is a straight line through the origin with slope \(mc\). The steeper the line, the more energy it takes to warm the sample; water’s large specific heat gives the steepest line.
Thermal conductivity
How quickly does energy move through a slab of material between a hot side and a cold side? Experiments show that the rate of energy transfer by conduction is proportional to the area \(A\) through which it passes, proportional to the temperature difference \(\Delta T\) across the slab, and inversely proportional to the thickness \(L\):
\[ \frac{Q}{\Delta t} = \frac{kA\Delta T}{L}. \]
The proportionality constant \(k\) is the thermal conductivity, in W/(m·K). A large \(k\) means a good conductor (copper, 400; aluminum, 240; window glass, 0.8; wood, 0.12; still air, 0.025). Think of it as a flow through a pipe: a wider pipe (larger area) and a bigger push (larger \(\Delta T\)) increase the flow; a longer pipe (larger \(L\)) decreases it.
Figure 9.7c Conduction through a slab. The rate of energy transfer grows with the area \(A\) and the temperature difference \(\Delta T = T_H - T_C\), and shrinks with the thickness \(L\); the conductivity \(k\) sets the scale. In steady state the temperature falls linearly across a uniform slab.
Doubling the thickness halves the rate.
Doubling the area doubles the rate.
Doubling the temperature difference doubles the rate.
Replacing glass with foam (smaller \(k\)) cuts the rate by the ratio of the conductivities.
The conductivity depends on the atomic structure, which is why metals (with free electrons that carry energy) are good conductors and gases (with widely spaced atoms) are poor ones. A good insulator, such as a double-pane window with an air gap, uses a layer of low-\(k\) material to reduce the rate. Experiments on conductivity usually measure the temperatures on both sides of a slab of known size and the energy that passes in a known time, or the rate at which an ice-water bath melts. They often linearize by plotting the rate against \(A\Delta T/L\); the slope is \(k\).
Worked example · energy to heat water
How much energy is required to heat 0.50 kg of water from 20\(^\circ\)C to 50\(^\circ\)C? How long does a 1000 W heater (no losses) take?
Equation. \(Q = mc\Delta T = (0.50)(4186)(30) = 6.28\times10^4\) J.
Time. \(t = Q/P = 6.28\times10^4/1000 = 63\) s.
Worked example · calorimetry
A 0.50 kg block of copper at 200\(^\circ\)C is dropped into 1.0 kg of water at 20\(^\circ\)C in an insulated container. Find the final temperature. (\(c_{Cu} = 385\), \(c_w = 4186\) J/(kg·K).)
Solve. \((192.5)(T_f - 200) + (4186)(T_f - 20) = 0\), so \(4378.5\,T_f = 38500 + 83720\) and \(T_f = 27.9\,^\circ\)C.
Check. The water has much more energy capacity per kelvin than the copper (4186 against 192.5 J/K), so the final temperature is near the water’s start. ✓
Worked example · conduction through a wall
A brick wall (\(k = 0.80\) W/(m·K)) is 0.20 m thick and 10 m\(^2\) in area. The inside is at 20\(^\circ\)C and the outside at 0\(^\circ\)C. Find the rate of energy transfer, and the energy lost in one hour.
Rate. \(Q/\Delta t = kA\Delta T/L = (0.80)(10)(20)/0.20 = 800\) W.
One hour. \(Q = (800)(3600) = 2.9\times10^6\) J.
Effect of insulation. Adding a 0.10 m layer of foam (\(k = 0.04\)) in series would reduce the rate a great deal, because most of the temperature drop would then occur across the foam.
Exam focus
Specific heat. \(Q = mc\Delta T\); \(Q\) negative when the object cools. A larger \(c\) means the temperature changes less for the same energy.
Calorimetry. Energy lost equals energy gained; final temperature is a weighted average.
Conduction rate. \(kA\Delta T/L\): proportional to area and temperature difference; inversely proportional to thickness.
Material properties. \(c\) and \(k\) are intrinsic; they depend on the atomic structure, not on the size of the sample.
Experiments. Heater of known power: \(Q = Pt\). Linearize: \(Q\) against \(\Delta T\) (slope \(mc\)).
Practice
How much energy is needed to raise 2.0 kg of aluminum (\(c = 900\) J/(kg·K)) by 40 K?
Show answer
\(Q = (2.0)(900)(40) = 7.2\times10^4\) J.
The same energy is given to equal masses of water and copper, both starting at the same temperature. Which ends up hotter, and why?
Show answer
The copper, because it has the smaller specific heat (385 against 4186 J/(kg·K)), so the same \(Q\) gives a much larger \(\Delta T\).
0.20 kg of water at 80\(^\circ\)C is mixed with 0.20 kg of water at 20\(^\circ\)C in an insulated cup. Find the final temperature.
Show answer
Same material and equal masses: \(T_f = (80+20)/2 = 50\,^\circ\)C.
The rate of energy transfer through a window is 120 W. If the glass is replaced by glass twice as thick of the same area and the same temperature difference, what is the new rate?
Show answer
The rate is inversely proportional to the thickness, so it becomes 60 W.
A student plots \(Q\) against \(\Delta T\) for a 0.25 kg sample and finds a slope of 225 J/K. What is the specific heat?
Show answer
Slope \(= mc\), so \(c = 225/0.25 = 900\) J/(kg·K), consistent with aluminum.
Explain why a coastal city has smaller day-to-night temperature swings than a desert city at the same latitude.
Show answer
Water has a large specific heat, so large amounts of energy must enter or leave it to change its temperature; the ocean warms little by day and cools little by night, and the air above it follows. The dry ground and air of the desert change temperature easily.
Film a glass falling off a table and shattering, then run the film backward. You know at once which is real, though the backward film does not break the first law of thermodynamics: every joule of energy is accounted for either way. Something else tells the two directions apart. Hot coffee cools to room temperature but never warms itself up by cooling the room; a drop of ink spreads through water but never gathers itself back into a drop. The first law says energy is conserved. The second law says which processes actually occur. This lesson introduces entropy, the quantity that tracks that one-way tendency, and uses it to explain why heat engines cannot be perfectly efficient. The treatment is qualitative.
Learning objective · 9.6.A
Describe the change in entropy for a given system over time.
Required content · EK 9.6.A
The second law of thermodynamics states that the total entropy of an isolated system can never decrease and is constant only when all processes the system undergoes are reversible.
Entropy can be qualitatively described as the tendency of energy to spread or the unavailability of some of the system’s energy to do work. Localized energy will tend to disperse and spread out. Entropy is a state function and therefore depends only on the current state or configuration of a system, not on how the system reached that state. Maximum entropy occurs when a system is in thermodynamic equilibrium.
The change in a system’s entropy is determined by the system’s interactions with its surroundings. Isolated systems spontaneously move toward thermodynamic equilibrium. The entropy of an isolated system never decreases, but the entropy of a closed system can decrease because energy can be transferred into or out of the system.
Boundary: only a qualitative treatment of the second law is within the scope of AP Physics 2.
Why some processes never run backward
Take 10 gas atoms in a box, with a removable divider down the middle. Place all 10 on the left and remove the divider. Each atom now wanders at random, and at any instant it is equally likely to be on either side. How many arrangements put all 10 on the left? Exactly one. How many put 5 on each side? 252. Counting the possible ways to arrange the atoms (called microstates), the near-even splits dominate, and the lopsided ones are rare. The gas does not “want” to spread out; it ends up spread out because the spread-out arrangements are overwhelmingly more numerous.
Figure 9.8a Why gases spread out. With 10 atoms, only 1 arrangement of 1024 puts all of them in the left half, while 252 put exactly five on each side. Spread-out arrangements are overwhelmingly more numerous, so they are overwhelmingly more probable. For a mole of atoms the imbalance is beyond astronomical.
With 10 atoms, the chance of finding all of them back on the left is about 1 in 1000. With a mole of atoms (\(6\times10^{23}\)), it is far smaller than one in \(10^{10^{20}}\), a number with so many digits that it is never seen in the lifetime of the universe. This is why free expansion of a gas is irreversible even though each atom’s motion is reversible in principle.
Entropy: the spreading of energy
Entropy measures how spread out the energy of a system is, equivalently, how many microscopic arrangements are consistent with its macroscopic state. At the level of this course it is enough to say it this way: entropy increases when energy that was localized becomes dispersed. A hot object next to a cold one holds energy concentrated in one place; after contact, the energy is shared evenly, with a higher entropy. A compressed gas spreads out into a larger volume, with higher entropy. A pot of boiling water cooling in a room spreads its energy into the room.
State function. Entropy depends only on the state of the system (its \(P\), \(V\), \(T\), composition), not on the path. If a gas goes from state A to state B, the entropy change is the same by any process.
Maximum at equilibrium. The entropy of an isolated system rises until the system reaches thermodynamic equilibrium, where it is as large as it can be. Nothing further happens spontaneously.
Unavailable energy. Energy that has dispersed evenly cannot be gathered to do work. A lake of warm water holds enormous energy but you cannot run a heat engine from it without a colder place to dump energy.
The second law
The second law of thermodynamics states that the total entropy of an isolated system never decreases; it remains constant only if every process in the system is reversible (idealized, frictionless and infinitely slow). All real processes, including those with friction, heat flow across a temperature difference, mixing, and free expansion, are irreversible, and they increase entropy.
An important distinction: the law applies to an isolated system. A closed system can exchange energy with its surroundings, and then its entropy can decrease. When water freezes in a freezer, the water’s entropy decreases (it becomes more ordered), but the freezer expels energy into the kitchen, and the entropy of the kitchen increases by more than the water’s entropy decreases. The total, water plus kitchen plus freezer, increases. Living things also decrease their own entropy while increasing the entropy of their surroundings.
Figure 9.8b Three spontaneous processes, all of which increase entropy as energy or matter spreads out. The reverse of each, in an isolated system, would decrease entropy and is never observed.
Heat engines and the second law
A heat engine takes energy \(Q_H\) by heating from a hot reservoir, converts part of it to useful work \(W_{out}\), and must dump the rest, \(Q_C\), to a cold reservoir. Over a complete cycle the engine returns to its initial state, so \(\Delta U = 0\), and conservation of energy gives
\[ Q_H = W_{out} + Q_C. \]
The efficiency is \(e = W_{out}/Q_H = 1 - Q_C/Q_H\). The second law says \(Q_C\) cannot be zero. If it were, the engine would convert all of the energy from a single reservoir into work, and entropy would fall in the hot reservoir without any increase elsewhere. The energy you must dump into the cold reservoir spreads out and raises entropy, which pays for the entropy removed from the hot reservoir. So no engine can be 100% efficient. The cycle of lesson 9.6 had \(Q_H = 18000\) J and \(W_{out} = 4000\) J, so \(e = 22\%\) and 14000 J had to be rejected.
Figure 9.8c A heat engine running the cycle of lesson 9.6. Per cycle it takes in \(Q_H = 18\,000\) J, does \(W_{out} = 4000\) J and rejects \(Q_C = 14\,000\) J. Energy is conserved (\(Q_H = W + Q_C\)); the second law forbids \(Q_C = 0\), so the efficiency is always below 100%.
A refrigerator runs the cycle backward (counterclockwise on the PV diagram): work is done on the system and energy is carried from the cold interior to the warm room. That does not violate the second law, because the work supplied produces extra entropy elsewhere: the room receives more energy than was removed from the food. Energy does not flow from cold to hot by itself, only when something else changes.
Worked example · energy bookkeeping for an engine
A heat engine absorbs 600 J from a hot reservoir in each cycle and rejects 450 J to the cold reservoir. Find the work output and the efficiency, and decide if the engine violates the first or second law if it claimed to produce 200 J.
Claim of 200 J. \(Q_H - W_{out} = 400\) J would have to be rejected, not 450 J, so the energy would not balance; the claim as stated violates the first law (conservation of energy) for the given \(Q_C\). A claim of 600 J of work with \(Q_C = 0\) would conserve energy but violate the second law.
Worked example · which process is allowed?
An isolated box has a gas on the left half and a vacuum on the right. A divider is removed. A student claims the gas will later (a) fill the box evenly and (b) after a while, all go back to the left half by itself. Which is consistent with the second law?
(a) The gas spreads out: the entropy increases and the system approaches equilibrium. Allowed and observed. (b) The gas returning to the left half would decrease the entropy of an isolated system. Not allowed in practice (the probability is astronomically small), even though energy would be conserved.
Worked example · explain in words
An ice cube melts in a glass of warm water inside an insulated container. Explain in terms of entropy why the final state has the temperature of both parts equal, and why the reverse (a warm cube and a cooler glass reappearing) does not happen.
Argument. The glass and cube form an isolated system. At first the energy is concentrated in the warmer water. When energy spreads from the water to the ice, the system moves toward a state with the same temperature everywhere, in which the energy is as dispersed as possible; that is thermodynamic equilibrium, the state of maximum entropy. The reverse process would take the system to a state with less dispersed energy and a lower entropy, which the second law forbids for an isolated system.
Exam focus
Second law. Total entropy of an isolated system never decreases; constant only for reversible processes.
Meaning. Entropy measures dispersal of energy; spreading raises entropy; equilibrium is maximum entropy.
State function. Depends only on the current state, not the path.
Closed versus isolated. A closed system can lose entropy if energy flows out, as with freezing water; the surroundings gain more.
Engines. \(Q_H = W + Q_C\); \(e = 1 - Q_C/Q_H \lt 1\). Some energy must be rejected to a cold reservoir.
Practice
A heat engine takes in 800 J per cycle and does 200 J of work. How much energy is rejected, and what is its efficiency?
Show answer
Does the entropy of a hot cup of coffee in a room increase or decrease as it cools? What about the entropy of the coffee plus the room?
Show answer
The coffee’s entropy decreases as it loses energy, but the room’s entropy increases by more. The total (coffee plus room) increases.
True or false: entropy depends on the path that takes a gas from one state to another. Explain.
Show answer
False. Entropy is a state function, so the change depends only on the initial and final states.
A student claims a device removes 500 J from a lake and converts it entirely to work, with no other change. Which law does the claim violate?
Show answer
The second law. A cyclic device cannot convert energy from a single reservoir entirely to work; some energy must go to a colder reservoir. Energy is conserved, so the first law is not violated.
Why can entropy decrease inside a refrigerator while the second law remains valid?
Show answer
The refrigerator is not isolated: work is supplied, and more energy is released into the room than is removed from the food. The entropy of the room increases by more than the entropy of the contents decreases, so the total increases.
Four atoms are in a box with a divider removed. Estimate whether it is more probable to find all four on the left, or two on each side. Explain.
Show answer
Two on each side is far more probable: there are 6 arrangements giving 2 and 2, but only 1 giving all four on the left. Equal spreading corresponds to more microstates, which is why spread-out states have higher entropy.
Unit 9 practice · 10 problems
Unit 9 practice: Thermodynamics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer: the reveal shows the key steps, not just the number.
Constants: \(R = 8.31\ \text{J/(mol·K)}\), \(k_B = 1.38\times10^{-23}\ \text{J/K}\),
g = 9.8 m/s². Treat every gas as monatomic and ideal. Calculator allowed.
A vertical cylinder is sealed by a frictionless piston of area 0.012 m². The gas inside is at 2.5 × 10⁵ Pa; the atmosphere above the piston is at 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa. Find the net force the two gases exert on the piston, and the largest mass the piston could support at rest (ignore the piston's own weight).
A sealed sample of gas is heated so that its absolute temperature doubles. The rms speed of its molecules
Temperature is a measure of the average kinetic energy of the molecules, so it cannot rise without the molecules moving faster. In a sealed container the added energy goes entirely into molecular motion.
\(\tfrac{3}{2}k_BT = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_{\text{rms}}^2\) gives \(v_{\text{rms}} = \sqrt{3k_BT/m} \propto \sqrt{T}\), so doubling \(T\) doubles the average kinetic energy but multiplies the speed by only \(\sqrt{2}\).
Doubling the speed would quadruple the kinetic energy (since \(K \propto v^2\)) and therefore quadruple the temperature. The speed scales as the square root of \(T\), not linearly with it.
Quadrupling comes from applying the \(v^2\) relationship in the wrong direction. \(T\) is proportional to \(v^2\), so \(v\) is proportional to \(\sqrt{T}\), and the speed changes by less than the temperature does, not more.
A single-pane window has area 1.5 m², thickness 4.0 mm, and thermal conductivity 0.80 W/(m·K). The inside surface is 15 K warmer than the outside surface. Find the rate of heat conduction through the glass and the energy lost in one hour. What would doubling the glass thickness do to the rate?
Show answer
\(\dfrac{Q}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{kA\,\Delta T}{L} = \dfrac{(0.80)(1.5)(15)}{4.0\times10^{-3}} = 4.5\times10^{3}\ \text{W}\). In one hour, \(Q = (4500\ \text{W})(3600\ \text{s}) = 1.6\times10^{7}\ \text{J}\). The rate is inversely proportional to \(L\), so doubling the thickness halves it to \(2.3\times10^{3}\ \text{W}\).
A 0.200 kg copper block (\(c = 385\ \text{J/(kg·K)}\)) at 150 °C is dropped into 0.500 kg of water (\(c = 4186\ \text{J/(kg·K)}\)) at 20.0 °C in an insulated cup. Find the final temperature, and explain in one sentence why it is so close to the water's starting temperature.
Show answer
Heat lost by copper = heat gained by water: \(m_c c_c(150 - T_f) = m_w c_w(T_f - 20.0)\), so \(77(150 - T_f) = 2093(T_f - 20.0)\). Then \(11{,}550 + 41{,}860 = 2170\,T_f\), giving \(T_f \approx 24.6\ ^\circ\text{C}\). The water's heat capacity \(mc = 2093\ \text{J/K}\) is 27 times the copper's 77 J/K, so the same heat changes its temperature 27 times less.
On a PV diagram a gas moves along a straight line from state A (V = 2.0 L, P = 4.0 × 10⁵ Pa) to state B (V = 5.0 L, P = 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa). Find the work done on the gas, the change in internal energy, and the heat transferred.
Show answer
The area under the slanted segment is a trapezoid: \(|W| = \tfrac{1}{2}(P_A + P_B)\Delta V = \tfrac{1}{2}(5.0\times10^{5})(3.0\times10^{-3}) = 750\ \text{J}\). The gas expands, so \(W_{\text{on}} = -750\ \text{J}\). Internal energy from the endpoints: \(U_A = \tfrac{3}{2}P_AV_A = \tfrac{3}{2}(4.0\times10^{5})(2.0\times10^{-3}) = 1200\ \text{J}\), \(U_B = \tfrac{3}{2}(1.0\times10^{5})(5.0\times10^{-3}) = 750\ \text{J}\), so \(\Delta U = -450\ \text{J}\). First law: \(Q = \Delta U - W = -450 - (-750) = +300\ \text{J}\) flows into the gas.
1.5 mol of gas expands at a constant pressure of 2.0 × 10⁵ Pa from 3.0 L to 5.0 L. Find the work done on the gas, the temperature change, the change in internal energy, and the heat added.
Show answer
\(W = -P\,\Delta V = -(2.0\times10^{5})(2.0\times10^{-3}) = -400\ \text{J}\). From \(P\,\Delta V = nR\,\Delta T\): \(\Delta T = \dfrac{400}{(1.5)(8.31)} \approx 32\ \text{K}\). \(\Delta U = \tfrac{3}{2}nR\,\Delta T = \tfrac{3}{2}(400) = 600\ \text{J}\). \(Q = \Delta U - W = 600 - (-400) = 1000\ \text{J}\). For an isobaric expansion, only 3/5 of the heat raises the temperature; the rest leaves as work.
A gas runs clockwise around a rectangle on a PV diagram: A (1.0 L, 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa) → B (1.0 L, 4.0 × 10⁵ Pa) → C (3.0 L, 4.0 × 10⁵ Pa) → D (3.0 L, 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa) → A. Find the net work done by the gas per cycle, then rank the four legs by the heat added to the gas, greatest to least.
Show answer
Net work by the gas is the enclosed area: \((3.0\times10^{5}\ \text{Pa})(2.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3) = 600\ \text{J}\). Per leg, using \(U = \tfrac{3}{2}PV\) and \(Q = \Delta U - W\): AB (isochoric, \(W = 0\)): \(Q = \Delta U = +450\ \text{J}\). BC (isobaric expansion, \(W = -800\ \text{J}\)): \(\Delta U = +1200\ \text{J}\), \(Q = +2000\ \text{J}\). CD (isochoric): \(Q = \Delta U = -1350\ \text{J}\). DA (isobaric compression, \(W = +200\ \text{J}\)): \(\Delta U = -300\ \text{J}\), \(Q = -500\ \text{J}\). Ranking: BC > AB > DA > CD. Check: \(450 + 2000 - 1350 - 500 = +600\ \text{J} = -W_{\text{net, on gas}}\). ✓
A gas is compressed rapidly enough that no heat is exchanged with the surroundings. Explain in words, using the first law and a particle-level picture, why its temperature rises.
Show answer
Adiabatic means \(Q = 0\), so \(\Delta U = W\); compression is positive work on the gas, so \(U\), and therefore \(T\), must rise. At the particle level, molecules that bounce off the inward-moving piston rebound faster than they arrived, like a ball hit by a moving bat. Each collision adds kinetic energy, and with no heat leaving, the average kinetic energy, which is temperature, goes up. This is why a bicycle pump gets warm.
Each cycle, a heat engine absorbs 3000 J from a hot reservoir and exhausts 2100 J to a cold reservoir. (a) Find the work per cycle and the efficiency. (b) Describe qualitatively how the entropy of each reservoir changes, and say what the second law requires of the total. (c) Explain why an engine with \(Q_C = 0\) is forbidden.
Show answer
(a) \(W = Q_H - Q_C = 900\ \text{J}\); \(e = \dfrac{W}{Q_H} = \dfrac{900}{3000} = 0.30\), or 30%. (b) The hot reservoir loses energy, so its entropy decreases; the cold reservoir gains energy, so its entropy increases. The second law requires the total entropy of the isolated system (engine plus both reservoirs) not to decrease. (c) With \(Q_C = 0\) the hot reservoir’s entropy would drop and nothing would compensate, so the total entropy would decrease: the second law forbids it even though energy would be conserved. Some energy has to be rejected to the cold reservoir to raise its entropy.
Rub a balloon on your hair and it sticks to a wall. Drag your feet across a carpet and you get a spark from a doorknob. Both are the same ancient observation, known to the Greeks who rubbed amber (elektron) with fur: some property of matter, which we call electric charge, can be transferred, and charged objects push and pull on one another without touching. This unit builds the theory of those forces from a single law, Coulomb’s law, and then extends it to fields, energy and potential. Most of what follows is a close cousin of Physics 1: forces, vectors, energy and Newton’s laws, applied to a new kind of interaction.
Learning objective · 10.1.A
Describe the electric force that results from the interactions between charged objects or systems.
Required content · EK 10.1.A
Charge is a fundamental property of all matter. Charge is described as positive or negative. The magnitude of the charge of a single electron or proton, the elementary charge \(e\), can be considered to be the smallest indivisible amount of charge. The charge of an electron is \(-e\), the charge of a proton is \(+e\), and a neutron has no electric charge. A point charge is a model in which the physical size of a charged object or system is negligible in the context of the situation.
Coulomb’s law describes the electrostatic force between two charged objects as directly proportional to the magnitude of each of the charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the objects: \(F = k\dfrac{|q_1q_2|}{r^2}\).
The direction of the electrostatic force depends on the signs of the charges and is parallel to the line of separation between the objects: charges of the same sign repel; charges of opposite signs attract.
Electric forces are responsible for some of the macroscopic properties of objects in everyday experiences (normal force, friction, tension are contact forces that arise from them).
Learning objective · 10.1.C (part)
Describe the electric permittivity of a material or medium. Free space has a constant value of electric permittivity, \(\varepsilon_0\), that appears in physical relationships.
Charge and its units
Matter is built from three particles. The proton carries charge \(+e\), the electron carries \(-e\), and the neutron carries none, where \(e = 1.60\times10^{-19}\) C is the elementary charge. The SI unit of charge is the coulomb (C). It is a huge unit: a one-coulomb object would hold \(6.25\times10^{18}\) extra electrons. Static charges in everyday situations are measured in microcoulombs (\(\mu\)C, \(10^{-6}\) C) or nanocoulombs (nC, \(10^{-9}\) C).
Charge comes in whole multiples of \(e\), so the charge on any object is \(q = Ne\) with \(N\) an integer (positive or negative). An everyday object is nearly always neutral because it has as many protons as electrons. When we say it is “charged,” it has a small excess or shortage of electrons. Protons are locked in nuclei, so what moves in ordinary charging is electrons. A “charged” \(1.0\) nC sphere has an excess of \(1.0\times10^{-9}/1.60\times10^{-19} = 6.3\times10^{9}\) electrons, a tiny fraction of the \(10^{23}\) electrons in the object.
Coulomb’s law
Charles-Augustin de Coulomb measured the force between small charged spheres with a delicate torsion balance in 1785 and found a law with the same mathematical form as Newton’s law of gravity. For two point charges (charged objects small compared with their separation) a distance \(r\) apart,
\[ F = k\frac{|q_1q_2|}{r^2}, \qquad k = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} = 9.0\times10^{9}\ \text{N·m}^2/\text{C}^2. \]
The constant \(\varepsilon_0 = 8.85\times10^{-12}\ \text{C}^2/(\text{N·m}^2)\) is the permittivity of free space, a measure of how a vacuum responds to electric fields; it appears naturally in the equations that follow in this unit and the next. Use whichever form is convenient.
The formula gives only the magnitude of the force, which is why absolute values appear. The direction follows from the signs: like charges repel, unlike charges attract, along the line joining the charges. By Newton’s third law the two charges exert forces of equal magnitude and opposite direction on each other, whatever their sizes.
Figure 10.1a The direction of the electric force depends on the signs of the charges. In every case the two forces have the same magnitude \(F = k|q_1q_2|/r^2\), are opposite in direction, and lie along the line joining the charges.
The force follows an inverse-square law: double the distance and the force falls to one quarter; triple it and the force falls to one ninth. Doubling either charge doubles the force; doubling both quadruples it. These “factor of change” relationships are tested on every AP exam, and the method is the one from Physics 1: write the formula, say what changes, and multiply the factors.
Figure 10.1b The inverse-square law. If the distance doubles the force drops to one quarter; if it triples the force drops to one ninth. The right-hand panel lists the factors of change to apply when one quantity changes at a time.
Coulomb forces are responsible for everything we call a contact force. When you push on a wall, electrons in the atoms of your hand repel electrons in the atoms of the wall; the normal force, friction and tension are the macroscopic way of bookkeeping an astronomical number of such interactions, which is why in mechanics we treat them as separate “nonfundamental” forces.
Worked example · force between two charges
A \(+3.0\ \mu\)C charge and a \(-2.0\ \mu\)C charge are 0.30 m apart. Find the force on each.
Magnitude. \(F = k|q_1q_2|/r^2 = (9.0\times10^{9})(3.0\times10^{-6})(2.0\times10^{-6})/(0.30)^2 = 0.60\) N.
Direction. Opposite signs attract, so each charge feels a 0.60 N force directed toward the other. The two forces are an action–reaction pair.
Worked example · the hydrogen atom
In a hydrogen atom the electron is about \(5.3\times10^{-11}\) m from the proton. Find the electric force between them.
Equation. \(F = ke^2/r^2 = (9.0\times10^{9})(1.60\times10^{-19})^2/(5.3\times10^{-11})^2 = 8.2\times10^{-8}\) N.
Meaning. The force is tiny in newtons, but it acts on a particle of mass \(9.11\times10^{-31}\) kg, giving an acceleration of \(9\times10^{22}\) m/s\(^2\). It is this force that keeps the electron bound, as lesson 15.3 shows.
Worked example · factors of change
Two point charges exert a force \(F_0\) on each other. The first charge is tripled, the second is halved, and the separation is tripled. What is the new force?
Two charges attract each other with a force of 12 N. If the charges are moved to three times the distance, what is the force?
Show answer
It falls to \(12/9 = 1.3\) N.
An electron and a proton are separated by 1.0 nm. Compare the force on the electron with the force on the proton.
Show answer
The magnitudes are equal, \(ke^2/r^2 = 2.3\times10^{-10}\) N, by Newton’s third law, and they point in opposite directions, each toward the other.
A student says the electric force on a small charge is smaller than the force on a large charge because it is smaller. Is this correct?
Show answer
No. The two charges exert equal and opposite forces on each other regardless of their sizes. The smaller one will accelerate more if it has less mass, but the forces are equal.
Real situations seldom involve just two charges. A charge near the corner of a molecule feels forces from several neighbors at once; an electron in a metal feels a push from every other electron and a pull from every nucleus. The good news is that electric forces add like any other forces: you compute each one separately from Coulomb’s law and then add them as vectors. This lesson practices that procedure for up to four charges, which is all the exam requires, and then compares the electric force with gravity, which explains why electricity dominates the world of atoms and gravity dominates the world of planets.
Learning objective · 10.1.B
Describe the electric and gravitational forces that result from interactions between charged objects with mass.
Required content · EK 10.1.B and boundary statement
Electrostatic forces can be attractive or repulsive, while gravitational forces are always attractive.
For any two objects that have mass and electric charge, the magnitude of the gravitational force is usually much smaller than the magnitude of the electrostatic force.
Gravitational forces dominate at larger scales even though they are weaker than electrostatic forces, because systems at large scales tend to be electrically neutral.
AP Physics 2 only expects students to make calculations of the electric force between four or fewer interacting charged objects. The analysis of the resulting force from more charges is allowed in situations of high symmetry.
Superposition of forces
The electric force on a charge \(q\) due to several other charges is the vector sum of the forces due to each of them separately:
\[ \vec{F}_{net} = \vec{F}_1 + \vec{F}_2 + \vec{F}_3 + \cdots \]
This is the principle of superposition. It says the other charges do not interfere with each other: the force of charge 2 on \(q\) is the same whether or not charge 1 is present. A reliable procedure follows.
Draw the charges, label the signs, and mark the charge on which you want the net force.
Find each magnitude separately with \(F = k|q_1q_2|/r^2\), using only magnitudes of the charges.
Find each direction from the signs: away from a like charge, toward an unlike charge, along the line joining them. Draw each force arrow on the diagram, starting at the charge you are studying.
Choose axes and add components (or add arrows head to tail). In one dimension use signs: \(+\) for one direction, \(-\) for the other.
Figure 10.2a Superposition on a line. The positive charge on the left repels the test charge toward +x and the negative charge on the right attracts it toward +x, so the two forces add: 3.6 N + 3.6 N = 7.2 N toward +x.
When all the charges lie on one line, the vector sum is just addition with signs, and it is easy to see when two forces reinforce or cancel. When they do not, split each force into \(x\) and \(y\) components. Symmetry often helps: for a charge placed symmetrically between two equal charges, the components along the line between them cancel.
Figure 10.2b Adding forces that are not along one line. Each +3.0 μC charge repels the +1.0 μC charge at the origin with a 2.7 N force along the line joining them. The two forces are at right angles, and their resultant has magnitude \(\sqrt{2.7^2 + 2.7^2} = 3.8\) N.
Electric force versus gravity
Newton’s law of gravity has the same form as Coulomb’s law, \(F_g = Gm_1m_2/r^2\), so we can compare them directly. For two protons at any distance, the ratio is independent of \(r\):
\[ \frac{F_E}{F_g} = \frac{ke^2}{Gm_p^2} = \frac{(9.0\times10^{9})(1.60\times10^{-19})^2}{(6.67\times10^{-11})(1.67\times10^{-27})^2} = 1.2\times10^{36}. \]
The electric repulsion between two protons is a million trillion trillion trillion times stronger than their gravitational attraction. For an electron and a proton the ratio is even larger (about \(2\times10^{39}\)). Inside atoms and molecules, gravity is utterly irrelevant.
Figure 10.2c Two protons 1.0 nm apart. The electric repulsion is \(2.3\times10^{-10}\) N and the gravitational attraction only \(1.9\times10^{-46}\) N, a ratio of \(1.2\times10^{36}\), independent of separation because both forces follow an inverse-square law. Note the logarithmic scale: each tick is a factor of \(10^5\).
Why then does gravity run the solar system and shape galaxies? Two differences matter. First, gravity is always attractive, so the masses of all the atoms in a planet add up. Electric forces can attract or repel, and large objects contain nearly equal numbers of positive and negative charges, so they are almost exactly neutral and their net electric force on other objects is close to zero. Second, any small imbalance gets canceled quickly: a net charge on a large object attracts opposite charges from its surroundings. At large scales the residual electric forces vanish and the small but cumulative gravitational force wins.
Worked example · three charges in a line
A \(+4.0\ \mu\)C charge is at \(x = 0\) and a \(-4.0\ \mu\)C charge is at \(x = 0.20\) m. A \(+1.0\ \mu\)C test charge is placed at \(x = 0.10\) m between them. Find the net force on it.
Magnitudes. Each source is 0.10 m away: \(F = (9.0\times10^{9})(4.0\times10^{-6})(1.0\times10^{-6})/(0.10)^2 = 3.6\) N.
Directions. The \(+4.0\ \mu\)C charge repels the test charge toward \(+x\). The \(-4.0\ \mu\)C charge attracts it toward \(+x\). The forces add.
Net. \(F_{net} = 3.6 + 3.6 = 7.2\) N in the \(+x\) direction.
Worked example · charges at right angles
A \(+1.0\ \mu\)C charge sits at the origin. A \(+3.0\ \mu\)C charge is at \((0.10\ \text{m}, 0)\) and another \(+3.0\ \mu\)C charge is at \((0, 0.10\ \text{m})\). Find the net force on the charge at the origin.
Each force. \(F = (9.0\times10^{9})(1.0\times10^{-6})(3.0\times10^{-6})/(0.10)^2 = 2.7\) N, repulsive. The charge at \(+x\) pushes the origin charge toward \(-x\); the charge at \(+y\) pushes it toward \(-y\).
Components. \(F_x = -2.7\) N, \(F_y = -2.7\) N.
Net. \(F_{net} = \sqrt{2.7^2 + 2.7^2} = 3.8\) N, directed at \(45^\circ\) below the \(-x\) axis (toward the lower left).
Worked example · electric against gravity
Two small spheres each of mass 1.0 g carry equal charges and are 10 cm apart. What charge on each sphere would make the electric repulsion equal the gravitational attraction? Use \(G = 6.67\times10^{-11}\) N·m\(^2\)/kg\(^2\).
Set equal. \(kq^2/r^2 = Gm^2/r^2\), so \(q = m\sqrt{G/k}\).
Solve. \(q = (1.0\times10^{-3})\sqrt{(6.67\times10^{-11})/(9.0\times10^{9})} = (1.0\times10^{-3})(8.6\times10^{-11}) = 8.6\times10^{-14}\) C.
Meaning. That is only 540 000 electrons, a negligible static charge. Ordinary objects carry far more charge than this, so for charged small objects electricity easily beats gravity. The separation \(r\) cancels, so the result holds at any distance.
Exam focus
Procedure. Compute each force with magnitudes only; assign directions from signs; add as vectors.
Symmetry. Components along a symmetry line cancel for equal charges placed symmetrically.
Scope. Calculations are limited to four or fewer charges (or high symmetry).
Electric versus gravity. Electric can attract or repel and is much stronger (about \(10^{36}\) times for protons); gravity is always attractive and dominates only because large objects are nearly neutral.
Check. A net force should point in a direction that makes sense on the diagram.
Practice
Charges \(+2.0\ \mu\)C at \(x = 0\) and \(+2.0\ \mu\)C at \(x = 0.40\) m. What is the net force on a \(+1.0\ \mu\)C charge at \(x = 0.10\) m?
Show answer
From the first: \(k(2.0\times10^{-6})(1.0\times10^{-6})/(0.10)^2 = 1.8\) N toward \(+x\). From the second, 0.30 m away: \(0.20\) N toward \(-x\). Net \(= 1.6\) N toward \(+x\).
Where on the line between two equal positive charges is the net force on a third charge zero? Explain without calculation.
Show answer
At the midpoint: the two forces have equal magnitude and opposite direction, so they cancel (the same is true for a negative third charge).
Three equal charges sit at three corners of a square. Describe the direction of the net force on a fourth equal charge at the empty corner.
Show answer
Along the diagonal pointing away from the opposite corner. The two adjacent charges give equal forces at right angles whose sum points along the diagonal, and the third (opposite) charge pushes in the same direction, so all three contribute to a force directed outward along the diagonal.
Compare the electric and gravitational forces between an electron and a proton. Which is larger and by about what factor?
Show answer
The electric force is larger by a factor of about \(2\times10^{39}\), and it does not depend on the separation.
Why do we feel gravity from the Earth but no electric force, although the Earth contains enormous quantities of charge?
Show answer
The Earth (and we) are very nearly neutral: the positive and negative charges nearly cancel, so the net electric force is tiny. Gravity is always attractive and the contributions of all the atoms add.
A \(+5.0\ \mu\)C charge and a \(-5.0\ \mu\)C charge are 1.0 m apart. Is the net force on a \(+1.0\ \mu\)C charge placed on the line between them largest at the midpoint, near the positive charge, or near the negative charge? Explain.
Show answer
The two forces always point the same way (away from the positive, toward the negative), so they add; each grows as the distance to its source shrinks, so the net force is smallest at the midpoint and increases toward either charge.
A balloon rubbed on wool clings to a ceiling, and a plastic comb that you have run through your hair picks up tiny bits of paper. The paper is neutral, yet it is attracted. A metal doorknob delivers a spark but a wooden one does not. These everyday facts show three ideas that this lesson ties together: charge is conserved, materials differ in how freely their charges move, and a charged object can rearrange the charges in a nearby neutral one. Together they explain how objects become charged and why neutral objects are attracted to charged ones.
Learning objective · 10.2.A
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of charge.
Required content · EK 10.2.A
The net charge or charge distribution of a system can change in response to the presence of, or changes in, the net charge or charge distribution of other systems. The net charge of a system can change due to friction or contact between systems.
Induced charge separation occurs when the electrostatic force between two systems alters the distribution of charges within the systems, resulting in the polarization of one or both systems. Induced charge separation can occur in neutral systems.
Any change to a system’s net charge is due to a transfer of charge between the system and its surroundings. The charging of a system typically involves the transfer of electrons to and from the system. The net charge of a system will be constant unless there is a transfer of charge to or from the system.
Grounding involves electrically connecting a charged system to a much larger and approximately neutral system (for example, Earth).
Learning objective · 10.1.C
Describe the electric permittivity of a material or medium.
Required content · EK 10.1.C
Electric permittivity is a measurement of the degree to which a material or medium is polarized in the presence of an electric field. Polarization can be modeled as the induced rearrangement of electrons by an external electric field, resulting in a separation of positive and negative charges within a material or medium.
The permittivity of matter has a value different from that of free space that arises from the matter’s composition and arrangement. It is determined by the ease with which electrons can change configurations within the material.
Conductors are made from electrically conducting materials in which charge carriers move easily; insulators are made from electrically nonconducting materials in which charge carriers cannot move easily.
Conservation of charge
The total charge of an isolated system never changes. Charge is never created or destroyed; it is only moved from one place to another. When a pair of neutral particles interact in a collision and a positive and a negative particle emerge, the two new charges still add to zero. When you rub a balloon on your hair, electrons move from one to the other: the balloon gains \(N\) electrons (charge \(-Ne\)) and your hair loses \(N\) electrons (charge \(+Ne\)), and the sum is unchanged. The net charge of a system changes only if charge is transferred between the system and its surroundings.
Almost always, the carriers that move are electrons, because they are the loosely bound outer particles of atoms. A positively charged object has lost electrons; it does not have extra protons. (Charged ions in liquids and gases can also carry charge, but protons in nuclei do not move in ordinary charging.)
Three ways to charge an object
Friction. Rubbing two different materials together transfers electrons from one to the other, depending on how strongly each holds its outer electrons. The two objects acquire equal and opposite charges.
Contact (conduction). Touching a charged conductor to a second conductor shares the charge between them. If the objects are identical spheres, they end with equal charges, each half of the total. The sign of the second object becomes the same as the sign of the first.
Induction. A charged object brought near (but not touching) a conductor rearranges the conductor’s electrons. If the conductor is then connected to the ground while the charged object is still nearby, charge can flow on or off the conductor through the ground. Removing the ground connection and then the charged object leaves the conductor with a net charge opposite in sign to the charged object.
Figure 10.3a Charging a conductor by induction with a negative rod. (1) Free electrons are repelled to the far side. (2) Grounding lets electrons leave to the Earth. (3) The ground connection is removed while the rod is still near. (4) With the rod gone, the electrons that left are not replaced, and the sphere is positively charged.
Grounding connects an object to a very large reservoir of charge, the Earth, which is so big that it can give or take electrons without a noticeable change in its own charge or potential. In the induction sequence, a negatively charged rod near a metal sphere pushes electrons to the far side of the sphere. Grounding lets those electrons escape to the Earth. After the ground connection is broken and the rod removed, the sphere is left short of electrons: positively charged.
Conductors and insulators
In a conductor (metals, salt water, graphite) some electrons are free to move through the material; in an insulator (glass, rubber, dry wood, plastic) the electrons are bound to their atoms and cannot move far. A charge placed on an insulator stays where it was put. A charge on a conductor spreads out over the whole object and can be carried away by anything that touches it. That is why a charged balloon (insulator) stays charged for a long time, and a charged metal sphere on a metal stand loses its charge immediately.
Polarization and permittivity
A charged rod attracts neutral bits of paper. In a neutral insulator there are no free charges, but the electrons in each atom shift slightly toward a nearby positive rod (or away from a negative one), so each atom becomes a tiny separated pair of positive and negative charges. This is polarization: induced charge separation without net charge transfer. The paper has no net charge, but the side nearer the rod holds the opposite sign and is closer, so the attraction (stronger at shorter distance) outweighs the repulsion from the far side, and there is a net attraction. Neutral objects are always attracted to charged objects in this way, whatever the sign of the charge.
Figure 10.3b Polarization. A charged rod displaces the charges inside a neutral object slightly (the electrons toward a positive rod, away from a negative one). The object stays neutral overall, but the side nearer the rod carries the opposite charge and is closer, so the attractive force is larger than the repulsive force and the net force is toward the rod, whatever the sign of the rod.
A material’s electric permittivity, \(\varepsilon\), measures how strongly the material polarizes in an electric field. A material whose electrons rearrange easily has a large permittivity. In vacuum the value is \(\varepsilon_0\); in matter it is larger, \(\varepsilon = \kappa\varepsilon_0\), where \(\kappa\) is the dielectric constant (air about 1.0006, glass 5 to 10, pure water about 80). When charges are embedded in a medium, the induced polarization partly cancels the field of the charges, so the force between them is reduced:
\[ F = \frac{1}{4\pi\kappa\varepsilon_0}\frac{|q_1q_2|}{r^2}. \]
In water, with \(\kappa \approx 80\), the force between two ions is 80 times weaker than in a vacuum, which is why salt dissolves in water: the ions are pulled apart easily.
Worked example · sharing charge by contact
Identical conducting spheres A and B carry \(+8.0\) nC and \(-2.0\) nC. They are touched together and then separated. Find the final charge on each, and the number of electrons that moved.
Conservation. The total is \(+8.0 + (-2.0) = +6.0\) nC. Identical spheres share it equally: each ends with \(+3.0\) nC.
Electrons. Sphere A went from \(+8.0\) to \(+3.0\) nC, a change of \(-5.0\) nC. A gained \(5.0\) nC of electron charge, so \(N = 5.0\times10^{-9}/1.60\times10^{-19} = 3.1\times10^{10}\) electrons moved from B to A. (Check with B: it went from \(-2.0\) to \(+3.0\) nC, losing the same number.)
Worked example · explain in words
A negatively charged rod is brought near, but does not touch, a neutral metal sphere on an insulating stand. Describe the charge on the sphere, and whether it is attracted or repelled.
Argument. Free electrons in the metal are repelled by the negative rod and move to the far side of the sphere, leaving the near side with a net positive charge. The sphere as a whole is still neutral, but its positive side is closer to the rod than its negative side. The attraction to the nearer positive charge is greater than the repulsion from the farther negative charge (Coulomb’s law gets stronger as the distance shrinks), so the net force is attractive.
Worked example · force in a medium
Two ions are 1.0 nm apart and exert a force of \(2.3\times10^{-10}\) N on each other in a vacuum. What is the force if they are placed in water with \(\kappa = 80\) at the same separation?
Scaling. \(F = F_0/\kappa = 2.3\times10^{-10}/80 = 2.9\times10^{-12}\) N.
Exam focus
Conservation. Net charge is constant unless charge crosses the boundary; the carriers are electrons.
Contact. Identical conductors share total charge equally.
Induction. Charge by induction leaves the opposite sign to the inducing charge; it requires grounding while the charged object is near.
Polarization. Neutral objects are attracted to both signs of charge because the near side is closer.
Materials. Conductors have mobile charges; insulators do not. Permittivity measures how easily a material polarizes.
Practice
A glass rod rubbed with silk becomes \(+6.0\) nC. What is the charge on the silk, and which particles moved?
Show answer
The silk is \(-6.0\) nC, because the total charge stays zero. Electrons moved from the rod to the silk.
A \(-6.0\) nC conducting sphere touches an identical neutral sphere. Find the final charge on each.
Show answer
\(-3.0\) nC each.
A positive rod is brought near a neutral metal sphere, the sphere is touched with a finger and the finger is removed, then the rod is removed. What is the sign of the final charge on the sphere? Explain.
Show answer
Negative. The rod attracts electrons to the near side; the finger lets more electrons flow from the Earth onto the sphere; removing the finger traps them, and the sphere is left with extra electrons.
Why does a neutral piece of paper jump to a charged comb, and why does it often jump away again after touching it?
Show answer
The comb polarizes the paper, and the nearer (opposite) charge is attracted more strongly. After contact, charge is transferred to the paper, so both have the same sign and repel.
Why is it better to hold a charged metal rod with a plastic handle?
Show answer
The plastic is an insulator, so charge cannot flow from the rod through your hand to the ground; the rod stays charged.
The force between two charges is 6.0 N in air (\(\kappa \approx 1\)). They are placed in oil with \(\kappa = 2.0\) at the same distance. What is the force?
Show answer
How does one charge “know” that another charge is a meter away? Coulomb’s law gives the force but does not say how the interaction is carried across empty space. Michael Faraday’s answer in the 1830s was that a charge changes the space around it. Every point in space acquires a property, the electric field, that tells a charge placed there what force to feel. The idea of a field turned out to be one of the most powerful in physics: it organizes electricity, magnetism and light, and it lets us separate the source (the charges that create the field) from the effect (what the field does to some other charge). This lesson defines the electric field, gives the field of a point charge, adds fields by superposition, and shows how to draw them.
Learning objective · 10.3.A
Describe the electric field produced by a charged object or configuration of point charges.
Required content · EK 10.3.A
Electric fields may originate from charged objects. The electric field at a given point is the ratio of the electric force exerted on a test charge at that point to the charge of the test charge: \(\vec{E} = \vec{F}_E/q\).
A test charge is a point charge of small enough magnitude that its presence does not significantly affect the electric field in its vicinity.
An electric field points away from isolated positive charges and toward isolated negative charges. The electric force exerted on a positive test charge by an electric field is in the same direction as the field.
The electric field is a vector quantity and can be represented in space using vector field maps. The net electric field at a given location is the vector sum of the individual electric fields created by nearby charged objects.
Electric field maps use vectors to depict the magnitude and direction of the electric field at many locations. Electric field line diagrams are simplified models of electric field maps and can be used to determine the relative magnitude and direction of the electric field at any position in the diagram.
AP Physics 2 only expects calculations of the electric field resulting from four or fewer charged objects. Analysis of the field from more charges is allowed in situations of high symmetry.
The definition
Suppose a small positive test charge \(q\) is placed at some point and feels a force \(\vec{F}_E\). The electric field at that point is the force per unit charge:
\[ \vec{E} = \frac{\vec{F}_E}{q}. \]
The units are newtons per coulomb (N/C), which are the same as volts per meter. The test charge is chosen small enough that it does not disturb the charges that make the field. Rearranged, the definition gives the force on any charge \(q\) placed in a known field: \(\vec{F}_E = q\vec{E}\). If \(q\) is positive the force is in the direction of \(\vec{E}\); if \(q\) is negative the force is opposite to \(\vec{E}\). This is the single most common source of sign errors, so check it every time.
The field does not depend on the test charge. It is a property of the source charges and the position, which is why we can map it once and use the map for any charge we choose to place there. The field exists at a point whether or not there is a charge to feel it.
The field of a point charge
Place a test charge \(q\) a distance \(r\) from a point charge \(Q\). By Coulomb’s law the force has magnitude \(kQq/r^2\), so dividing by \(q\) gives
\[ E = \frac{k|Q|}{r^2}. \]
The field points away from a positive source charge and toward a negative one. It follows the same inverse-square pattern as the force: double the distance and the field falls to one quarter. At 1 m from a charge of \(1\ \mu\)C the field is \(9.0\times10^{3}\) N/C.
Figure 10.4a Vector field maps. Each arrow shows the direction of the electric field at its location, and its length indicates the magnitude. The field points away from a positive source charge and toward a negative one, and is strongest close to the charge.
Superposition of fields
Because forces add as vectors, so do fields. The net field at a point is the vector sum of the fields due to each source charge:
\[ \vec{E}_{net} = \vec{E}_1 + \vec{E}_2 + \cdots \]
The procedure is the same as for forces: find each magnitude using \(E = k|Q|/r^2\) with its own distance, assign each direction (away from positive, toward negative), and add components. A good habit is to draw the field arrow due to each charge at the point of interest before doing any arithmetic, and to check at the end that the answer points in a sensible direction.
Figure 10.4b Superposition of fields. Each charge creates a field at P directed away from it. By symmetry the horizontal components cancel and the vertical components add: \(E_{net} = 2(1800)\cos45^\circ = 2.5\times10^{3}\) N/C, pointing up.
Field maps and field lines
A vector field map draws a small arrow at many points; its direction is the direction of the field and its length shows the magnitude. A field-line diagram is a simplified version: continuous curves whose tangent at any point gives the direction of the field. The rules are short.
Lines start on positive charges and end on negative charges (or run off to infinity if there is no opposite charge nearby).
The number of lines leaving or entering a charge is proportional to the size of the charge.
The lines are closer together where the field is stronger, and farther apart where it is weaker.
Field lines never cross; the field at a point has just one direction.
The force on a positive charge is along the tangent to the line, in the direction of the arrow; on a negative charge it is opposite.
Figure 10.4c Field-line diagrams. Lines start on positive charges and end on negative charges; they are closest where the field is strongest, never cross, and give the field direction by their tangent. Between two equal positive charges the field is zero at the midpoint.
The simplest patterns are worth knowing by heart: lines radiating outward evenly from an isolated positive charge (inward for a negative); the dipole pattern for equal opposite charges, in which lines curve from the positive to the negative charge; and, for two equal positive charges, lines that curve away from each other, with a point exactly halfway between them where the field is zero.
Worked example · the field of a point charge
Find the electric field 0.20 m from a \(-5.0\) nC point charge, and the force on an electron placed there.
Field. \(E = k|Q|/r^2 = (9.0\times10^{9})(5.0\times10^{-9})/(0.20)^2 = 1.1\times10^{3}\) N/C, directed toward the charge (it is negative).
Force. \(F = |q|E = (1.60\times10^{-19})(1125) = 1.8\times10^{-16}\) N. The electron is negative, so the force is opposite to the field, away from the charge (two negative charges repel).
Worked example · two opposite charges
A \(+2.0\) nC charge is at \(x = -0.10\) m and a \(-2.0\) nC charge is at \(x = +0.10\) m. Find the field at the origin.
Magnitudes. Each is 0.10 m away: \(E = (9.0\times10^{9})(2.0\times10^{-9})/(0.10)^2 = 1.8\times10^{3}\) N/C.
Directions. The positive charge pushes the field away from it, toward \(+x\). The negative charge pulls the field toward it, also toward \(+x\). They add.
Net. \(E_{net} = 3.6\times10^{3}\) N/C in the \(+x\) direction.
Worked example · symmetry
Two \(+4.0\) nC charges are at \(x = \pm0.10\) m. Find the field at the point \((0, 0.10\ \text{m})\).
Each charge. The distance is \(r = \sqrt{0.10^2 + 0.10^2} = 0.141\) m, so \(E = (9.0\times10^{9})(4.0\times10^{-9})/(0.141)^2 = 1800\) N/C, directed away from its charge, at \(45^\circ\) above the horizontal.
Components. The \(x\)-components cancel by symmetry. The \(y\)-components add: \(E_y = 2(1800)\cos45^\circ = 2.5\times10^{3}\) N/C.
Net. \(2.5\times10^{3}\) N/C in the \(+y\) direction.
Exam focus
Definition. \(\vec{E} = \vec{F}/q\); \(\vec{F} = q\vec{E}\), opposite to \(\vec{E}\) for negative \(q\).
Point charge. \(E = k|Q|/r^2\), away from \(+\), toward \(-\).
Superposition. Vector sum; draw each arrow first.
Field lines. Start on \(+\), end on \(-\); denser means stronger; never cross; tangent gives direction.
Units. N/C \(=\) V/m.
Practice
A \(+2.0\ \mu\)C charge feels a force of 0.050 N. What is the field there?
Show answer
\(E = F/q = 0.050/(2.0\times10^{-6}) = 2.5\times10^{4}\) N/C, in the direction of the force.
Find the field 0.50 m from a \(+10\) nC point charge.
Show answer
\(E = (9.0\times10^{9})(10\times10^{-9})/(0.50)^2 = 360\) N/C, pointing away from the charge.
The field at some point is \(4.0\times10^{3}\) N/C to the right. What force does a \(-3.0\ \mu\)C charge feel there?
Show answer
\(F = |q|E = (3.0\times10^{-6})(4.0\times10^{3}) = 0.012\) N, to the left because the charge is negative.
How does the field of a point charge change if the distance is tripled?
Show answer
It falls to one ninth.
On a field-line diagram, point A has lines drawn twice as close together as at point B. What can you say about the fields?
Show answer
The field is stronger at A, because the density of field lines indicates the relative magnitude of the field.
Two equal positive charges are a distance \(d\) apart. What is the field at the midpoint? What force acts on a charge placed there?
Show answer
The two fields are equal in size and opposite in direction, so \(\vec{E} = 0\) at the midpoint, and the force on any charge placed there is zero.
If you are in a car during a lightning storm, you are safe, even though the car is struck by thousands of amperes. The metal body shields its inside from the electric field outside. That is not luck but a consequence of how the free charges in a conductor behave. Conductors and insulators carry charge in very different ways, and the electric fields around and inside them follow simple rules. These rules explain shielding, the shape of the field around a charged sphere, and why charge collects at the points of a lightning rod. This lesson develops them.
Learning objective · 10.3.B
Describe the electric field generated by charged conductors or insulators.
Required content · EK 10.3.B
While in electrostatic equilibrium, the excess charge of a solid conductor is distributed on the surface of the conductor, and the electric field within the conductor is zero.
At the surface of a charged conductor, the electric field is perpendicular to the surface.
The electric field outside an isolated sphere with spherically symmetric charge distribution is the same as the electric field due to a point charge with the same net charge as the sphere located at the center of the sphere.
While in electrostatic equilibrium, the excess charge of an insulator is distributed throughout the interior of the insulator as well as at the surface, and the electric field within the insulator may have a nonzero value.
AP Physics 2 only requires qualitative analysis of electric fields within insulators.
A conductor in electrostatic equilibrium
Electrostatic equilibrium means all the charges have stopped moving. A conductor has free charges, so it can reach this state only if no net force acts on any of them. A free charge in a conductor would feel a force \(q\vec{E}\) from any electric field inside, and would keep moving. Equilibrium is therefore possible only if
the electric field is zero everywhere inside the conducting material, and
any excess charge sits on the surface. Charges of the same sign repel, so extra charge spreads as far apart as it can, which in a conductor means to the outer surface.
The field is also zero in the interior of a solid conductor whether or not the conductor is charged and whether or not it is in an external field. If you place a neutral conductor in an external field, charges rearrange until their own field exactly cancels the external field inside the material. That is the induced charge separation of lesson 10.3, taken to equilibrium.
At the surface of a charged conductor the field is perpendicular to the surface. A component along the surface would push charges along it, and they would keep moving. The same reasoning says that no electric field line can run along the surface of a conductor in equilibrium.
Figure 10.5a A charged conducting sphere in electrostatic equilibrium. All excess charge sits on the outer surface, the field inside the material is zero, and the field outside points perpendicular to the surface, just like the field of a point charge at the center.
The field around a charged sphere
For a solid or hollow conducting sphere of radius \(R\) with net charge \(Q\), the excess charge spreads uniformly over the surface. A mathematical result for spherical symmetry (proved in calculus-based courses with Gauss’s law) is that outside the sphere the field is exactly the field of a point charge \(Q\) at the center:
\[ E = \frac{k|Q|}{r^2} \quad (r \ge R), \qquad E = 0 \quad (r \lt R). \]
So the field is zero inside, jumps to its largest value \(kQ/R^2\) at the surface, and then falls off as \(1/r^2\) outside. The same statement holds for any sphere with a spherically symmetric charge distribution, including an insulating sphere with the charge spread evenly through its volume, as far as the outside is concerned.
Figure 10.5b Field of a charged conducting sphere (\(Q = +5.0\) nC, \(R = 0.10\) m). Zero inside the conductor, \(kQ/R^2 = 4500\) N/C at the surface, and \(kQ/r^2\) outside, so the field at \(2R\) is one quarter of the surface value.
Shielding
The result that the field vanishes inside a conductor extends to a conductor with a hollow cavity that contains no charge. The charges on the conductor rearrange so the field is zero throughout the metal, and the field inside the empty cavity is zero too. A closed metal shell, or even a metal cage or mesh, shields its interior from external electric fields. This is why the inside of a car (or an airplane) is safe from lightning, why sensitive electronics are put in metal boxes, and why a microwave oven’s metal mesh door keeps microwaves in while letting you see the food.
Figure 10.5c Electrostatic shielding. Free charges in the shell rearrange until their field exactly cancels the external field throughout the metal and the empty cavity. Field lines end on the induced charges at the surface, perpendicular to it. This is why the inside of a car is safe from lightning.
Insulators
The charges on an insulator cannot move freely, so excess charge placed on one stays where it is: it can be spread through the interior as well as over the surface. The field inside an insulator does not have to be zero, and the field inside a uniformly charged insulating sphere, for instance, is nonzero. On the AP exam you only need to describe this qualitatively: in an insulator the charges cannot rearrange to cancel the field, so the field inside can be nonzero. This is the opposite of a conductor. A non-conducting object that is polarized (as in lesson 10.3) has a field inside it too, just smaller than the external field, which is what makes the permittivity differ from that of free space.
Worked example · field around a charged sphere
A conducting sphere of radius 0.10 m carries a net charge \(+5.0\) nC. Find the electric field (a) at the center, (b) just outside the surface, and (c) 0.20 m from the center.
(a) Inside a conductor in equilibrium the field is zero: \(E = 0\).
(b) At \(r = R = 0.10\) m: \(E = (9.0\times10^{9})(5.0\times10^{-9})/(0.10)^2 = 4.5\times10^{3}\) N/C, perpendicular to the surface and pointing outward.
(c) At \(r = 0.20\) m: \(E = (9.0\times10^{9})(5.0\times10^{-9})/(0.20)^2 = 1.1\times10^{3}\) N/C, which is one quarter of the surface value, as the inverse-square law predicts.
Worked example · explain in words
A hollow metal sphere with a small neutral metal ball inside it (not touching) is placed in a strong horizontal external electric field. Describe the field inside the cavity and explain why.
Argument. Free electrons in the shell shift toward the end of the shell facing the positive side of the field, leaving a positive charge on the other end. This rearrangement continues until the field due to these induced surface charges exactly cancels the external field throughout the shell’s material and in the cavity. If any field remained, the free charges would still be moving, and the conductor would not be in equilibrium. So the field in the cavity is zero, and the ball inside feels no force.
Worked example · comparing a conductor and an insulator
Two spheres of equal radius carry equal total charge: sphere A is a metal, sphere B is a plastic with its charge spread uniformly through its volume. Compare the fields at (a) a point outside both, at the same distance, and (b) a point halfway between the center and the surface.
(a) Outside, both are spherically symmetric with the same net charge, so the fields are equal, \(kQ/r^2\).
(b) Inside the metal sphere the field is zero. Inside the plastic sphere some of the charge is enclosed within that radius and creates a nonzero field. The two fields are not equal.
Exam focus
Conductors. In equilibrium the field inside is zero, excess charge lies on the surface, and the field at the surface is perpendicular to it.
Spheres. Outside, a symmetric sphere acts like a point charge at its center; inside a conducting sphere, \(E = 0\).
Shielding. A closed conductor shields its cavity from external fields.
Insulators. Charge can be spread through the interior and the field inside may be nonzero (qualitative only).
Reasoning. If a field acted on free charges, they would move; equilibrium means no net field on them.
Practice
A metal sphere of radius 0.050 m has a net charge of \(+2.0\) nC. Find the field at a point 0.25 m from its center.
Show answer
For the same sphere, what is the field at 0.020 m from its center? Explain.
Show answer
Zero, because this point is inside the conductor, where the field must vanish in equilibrium.
Why must the field at the surface of a charged conductor be perpendicular to the surface?
Show answer
A component parallel to the surface would exert a force on the free charges and make them move along the surface; in electrostatic equilibrium no such motion occurs, so that component is zero.
A student places an unknown charge inside a hollow metal sphere and says that the outside field is zero because “the field in a conductor is zero.” What is wrong with this?
Show answer
The field is zero inside the material of the conductor, but the charge inside induces an opposite charge on the inner surface and an equal charge of the same sign on the outer surface, which creates a field outside. Shielding works for fields coming from outside, not for charges inside the cavity.
Why is it safe to sit in a car during a lightning strike?
Show answer
The metal body is a conductor; the charge from the strike spreads over its outer surface, and the field inside the car is approximately zero, so the occupants experience no significant field or current.
An insulating sphere has charge spread uniformly through its volume. Is the field at its center zero?
Show answer
At the exact center, the symmetric distribution gives zero field; but at other points inside, the field is nonzero, unlike in a conductor, where the field is zero everywhere inside the material.
Lift a book and its gravitational potential energy rises, because you did work against gravity. Push two like charges together and the same thing happens: you do work against their repulsion, and the energy you supply is stored in the system of charges. Release them and they fly apart, converting that stored energy into kinetic energy. Chemical bonds, the energy of a lightning bolt, and the energy stored in a battery are all forms of electric potential energy. This lesson defines it for point charges, learns how to add the contributions of several charges, and explains what its sign means.
Learning objective · 10.4.A
Describe the electric potential energy of a system.
Required content · EK 10.4.A
The electric potential energy of a system of two point charges equals the amount of work required for an external force to bring the point charges to their current positions from infinitely far away.
The general form for the electric potential energy of two charged objects is \(U_E = \dfrac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\dfrac{q_1q_2}{r} = k\dfrac{q_1q_2}{r}\).
The total electric potential energy of a system can be determined by finding the sum of the electric potential energies of the individual interactions between each pair of charged objects in the system.
AP Physics 2 only requires the calculation of the electric potential energy of configurations of four or fewer point charges.
The potential energy of two point charges
Choose the zero of electric potential energy for two charges that are infinitely far apart, where the force between them is zero. Then bring one charge in from infinity to a distance \(r\) from the other. The work that an external agent must do, which is the energy stored in the system, is
\[ U_E = k\frac{q_1q_2}{r}. \]
Unlike the force formula, the signs of the charges are kept, because the sign carries information.
Like charges (\(q_1q_2 \gt 0\)): \(U_E \gt 0\). You must do positive work to push them together against their repulsion. As \(r\) decreases \(U_E\) increases. Released, they fly apart and gain kinetic energy.
Unlike charges (\(q_1q_2 \lt 0\)): \(U_E \lt 0\). They attract, so an external force would have to do negative work to hold them back as they come together; the system is lower in energy than when the charges were infinitely far apart. Such a system is bound. As \(r\) decreases \(U_E\) becomes more negative. Separating them to infinity costs energy equal to \(|U_E|\).
Large \(r\): \(U_E \to 0\) in both cases.
Figure 10.6a Potential energy of a pair of point charges. For like charges (orange) \(U\) is positive and grows as they are pushed together; for unlike charges (blue) \(U\) is negative, a bound pair, and becomes more negative as they approach. Both approach zero at large separation.
The graph makes the connection to forces plain. The magnitude of the force is the (negative) slope of the \(U\)–\(r\) curve, so the force is large where the curve is steep (small \(r\)). A positive slope means an attractive force, and a negative slope a repulsive force. Notice that \(U_E\) depends on \(1/r\), while the force depends on \(1/r^2\). Be careful not to mix up the two.
The electric potential energy belongs to the pair, not to either charge alone, exactly as the gravitational potential energy belongs to the Earth–book system. In energy conservation problems it is the sum of kinetic energies plus the potential energy of the system that is constant, \(K + U_E = \) constant, if no other forces do work.
Systems of several charges
The potential energy of a collection of charges is the sum over every pair. Each pair is counted exactly once.
\[ U_{total} = k\frac{q_1q_2}{r_{12}} + k\frac{q_1q_3}{r_{13}} + k\frac{q_2q_3}{r_{23}} + \cdots \]
Three charges have three pairs, four charges have six, and \(N\) charges have \(N(N-1)/2\) pairs. Writing the pairs in a list, with the sign of each product, is the best way to avoid missing one. Another way to say it: the work to assemble the system is the sum of the work to bring each charge in turn from infinity, each in the field of those already placed.
Figure 10.6b Counting pairs. Three charges make three pairs, and each contributes \(kq_1q_2/r\) with its own sign: the like pair is \(+0.27\) J and the two unlike pairs are \(-0.27\) J each. The total, \(-0.27\) J, is negative, so the system is bound.
Worked example · two like charges
How much energy is stored in two \(+3.0\ \mu\)C charges held 0.20 m apart?
Equation. \(U_E = kq_1q_2/r = (9.0\times10^{9})(3.0\times10^{-6})(3.0\times10^{-6})/0.20 = +0.41\) J.
Meaning. An external agent had to do 0.41 J of work to bring them together from infinity. If they are released, the sum of their kinetic energies when far apart will be 0.41 J.
Worked example · three charges
Three charges sit at the corners of an equilateral triangle of side 0.30 m: \(+3.0\ \mu\)C, \(+3.0\ \mu\)C and \(-3.0\ \mu\)C. Find the total electric potential energy.
Pairs. Each pair is 0.30 m apart. The size of each term is \(k(3.0\times10^{-6})^2/0.30 = 0.27\) J.
Signs. The (\(+\),\(+\)) pair is \(+0.27\) J; each (\(+\),\(-\)) pair is \(-0.27\) J, and there are two of them.
Total. \(U = +0.27 - 0.27 - 0.27 = -0.27\) J. The negative total means the system is bound: you would have to supply 0.27 J to pull the charges infinitely far apart.
Worked example · the hydrogen atom
Find the electric potential energy of the electron–proton pair in a hydrogen atom with separation \(5.3\times10^{-11}\) m, in joules and in electron-volts.
Equation. \(U_E = k(-e)(+e)/r = -(9.0\times10^{9})(1.60\times10^{-19})^2/(5.3\times10^{-11}) = -4.3\times10^{-18}\) J.
In eV. Divide by \(1.60\times10^{-19}\) J/eV: \(U_E = -27\) eV. We return to this number in lesson 15.3, where half of its magnitude turns out to be the kinetic energy of the electron.
Exam focus
Formula. \(U_E = kq_1q_2/r\), with signs; zero at infinite separation.
Sign. Positive for like charges (repulsive), negative for unlike charges (bound system).
Multiple charges. Add every pair once; four or fewer charges.
Work. The work an external force does to assemble the system equals the potential energy.
Conservation. \(K + U_E\) is constant when only electric forces do work.
Do not confuse \(1/r\) (energy) with \(1/r^2\) (force).
Practice
Find the potential energy of a \(+2.0\ \mu\)C and a \(-4.0\ \mu\)C charge 0.50 m apart.
Show answer
\(U = (9.0\times10^{9})(2.0\times10^{-6})(-4.0\times10^{-6})/0.50 = -0.14\) J.
Two like charges are moved to half their original separation. By what factor does the electric potential energy change?
Show answer
\(U \propto 1/r\), so it doubles.
How many pairs must be included in the potential energy of a system of four charges?
Show answer
Six pairs: \(4\times3/2 = 6\).
An external agent moves two opposite charges from a separation of 1.0 m to 2.0 m. Does the agent do positive or negative work, and does the potential energy increase or decrease?
Show answer
The agent does positive work (pulling against the attraction); the potential energy increases (becomes less negative).
Two equal charges \(+q\) are released from rest at a separation \(r\). What is the kinetic energy of each after they are very far apart?
Show answer
All of the initial potential energy \(kq^2/r\) becomes kinetic energy. By symmetry each particle has half, \(kq^2/(2r)\).
A student says the potential energy of two opposite charges is negative, so it is “less than nothing” and does not exist. Explain what a negative \(U\) means.
Show answer
The zero of potential energy is chosen at infinite separation. A negative value means the system has less energy than when the charges were infinitely far apart, so energy must be supplied to separate them; it is the energy of a bound system.
A 9-volt battery and a 120-volt outlet both supply electric energy, but you would not want to confuse them. A bird sitting on a high-voltage line is unharmed, while a person touching the same line while standing on the ground is in danger. What matters in each case is voltage, a quantity that belongs to a point in space (or a point on a circuit) rather than to a particular charge. Voltage is electric potential. Just as the electric field is the force per unit charge, the electric potential is the potential energy per unit charge: it describes the situation at a point, independent of which charge you later put there. This lesson defines potential and potential difference, shows how to compute them for point charges, and links them to batteries.
Learning objective · 10.5.A
Describe the electric potential due to a configuration of charged objects.
Required content · EK 10.5.A
Electric potential describes the electric potential energy per unit charge at a point in space.
The electric potential due to multiple point charges can be determined by the principle of scalar superposition of the electric potential due to each of the point charges: \(V = \sum k\dfrac{q_i}{r_i}\).
The electric potential difference between two points is the change in electric potential energy per unit charge when a test charge is moved between the two points: \(\Delta V = \Delta U_E/q\). Electric potential difference may also result from chemical processes that cause positive and negative charges to separate, such as in a battery.
When conductors are in electrical contact, electrons will be redistributed such that the surfaces of the conductors are at the same electric potential.
AP Physics 2 only expects calculation of the electric potential of configurations of four or fewer point charges (or more with high symmetry). The electric potential is zero at an infinite distance from an isolated point charge.
Potential and potential difference
The electric potential \(V\) at a point is the electric potential energy per unit charge that a small test charge \(q\) would have there, \(V = U_E/q\). The SI unit is the volt (V), where 1 V \(=\) 1 J/C. Like the field, the potential is a property of the source charges and the location, not of the test charge.
Only differences in potential have physical meaning, since we may choose where \(V = 0\). The potential difference between two points is
\[ \Delta V = V_B - V_A = \frac{\Delta U_E}{q}, \]
the change in potential energy per unit charge when a test charge moves from A to B. Rearranged: \(\Delta U_E = q\,\Delta V\). A charge of \(+q\) moving to a point of higher potential gains potential energy \(q\Delta V\); a charge of \(-q\) moving to a point of higher potential loses energy, because \(q\) is negative. Volts therefore tell you energy per charge: a 9 V battery gives each coulomb of charge that passes through it 9 J of energy.
A convenient energy unit follows from this: the electron-volt (eV) is the energy gained by an electron (or any charge of magnitude \(e\)) moving through a potential difference of 1 V, so \(1\ \text{eV} = 1.60\times10^{-19}\) J. It is the natural unit for atomic and particle physics, and it will appear again in Unit 15.
The potential of point charges
Dividing the potential energy of two charges by one of them, with the zero of potential at infinity, gives the potential of a point charge \(Q\) at a distance \(r\):
\[ V = \frac{kQ}{r}. \]
Here the sign of \(Q\) is kept: the potential of a positive charge is positive and decreases toward zero with distance; the potential of a negative charge is negative and rises toward zero. Potential is a scalar, so the potential of several charges is found by simple (algebraic) addition, with no components and no directions:
\[ V = k\left(\frac{q_1}{r_1} + \frac{q_2}{r_2} + \cdots\right). \]
This is far easier than adding the field vectors, and it is an important reason for using potential. Remember that the field and the potential are different quantities: the field of a point charge falls as \(1/r^2\), the potential as \(1/r\), and the potential can be zero at a point where the field is not (and vice versa).
Figure 10.7a Potential of a point charge, \(V = kQ/r\). It is positive near a positive charge and negative near a negative charge, and it falls off as \(1/r\) (more slowly than the field, which falls as \(1/r^2\)). It is a scalar, so potentials of several charges are added algebraically.Figure 10.7b Potentials add as ordinary numbers. Each charge contributes \(kq/r\) at P with its own sign, so \(V = +225\ \text{V} - 90\ \text{V} = +135\ \text{V}\). The directions and the angle between the lines to P do not matter.
Batteries and conductors
A battery is a device that uses a chemical reaction to separate positive and negative charges, keeping its terminals at a fixed potential difference called its emf (electromotive force, \(\mathcal{E}\)). A 1.5 V battery keeps one terminal 1.5 V above the other. When it is connected to a circuit, charges are driven around, and each coulomb gains 1.5 J of energy as it passes through the battery (Unit 11).
When two conductors touch (or are joined by a wire), electrons flow until the entire connected conductor is at the same potential. A conductor in equilibrium is an equipotential: the field inside is zero, so no work is done in moving a charge between any two points of it, and the potential is the same at every point. This explains why a bird on a power line is safe (both feet are at the same potential, so no current flows through the bird) and why the potential difference across the gap between your hand and the doorknob is what produces the spark.
Figure 10.7c A battery keeps a fixed potential difference between its terminals by chemically separating charge; each coulomb passing through gains \(q\Delta V = 12\) J. When conductors are joined, charge flows until they are at the same potential.
Worked example · potential of a point charge
Find the electric potential 0.50 m from a point charge of \(+8.0\) nC.
Equation. \(V = kQ/r = (9.0\times10^{9})(8.0\times10^{-9})/0.50 = +1.4\times10^{2}\) V.
Check. For a negative charge of the same size and distance the potential would be \(-1.4\times10^{2}\) V.
Worked example · two charges
A \(+5.0\) nC charge and a \(-3.0\) nC charge are placed so that a point P is 0.20 m from the first and 0.30 m from the second. Find the potential at P.
Sum the scalars. \(V = k(q_1/r_1 + q_2/r_2) = (9.0\times10^{9})[(5.0\times10^{-9})/0.20 + (-3.0\times10^{-9})/0.30] = (9.0\times10^{9})(2.5\times10^{-8} - 1.0\times10^{-8}) = +1.35\times10^{2}\) V.
No directions needed. The angle between the two lines to P does not matter for the potential.
Worked example · potential difference and work
A \(+2.0\) nC source charge is fixed. Find the potential difference between a point 0.40 m from it and a point 0.10 m from it, and the work needed to move a \(+1.0\ \mu\)C charge from the far point to the near point.
Difference. \(\Delta V = V_{near} - V_{far} = 135\) V.
Work. \(W_{ext} = \Delta U_E = q\Delta V = (1.0\times10^{-6})(135) = 1.4\times10^{-4}\) J. The external agent does positive work because the like charge is pushed toward the source.
Exam focus
Definition. \(V = U_E/q\) (J/C = V); \(\Delta U_E = q\Delta V\), with the sign of \(q\).
Point charges. \(V = kQ/r\) with sign; add as scalars; \(V = 0\) at infinity.
Field versus potential. \(1/r^2\) vector versus \(1/r\) scalar; one can vanish without the other.
Batteries. Maintain a potential difference (emf) by chemical separation of charge.
Conductors. Connected conductors come to the same potential.
Unit. \(1\ \text{eV} = 1.60\times10^{-19}\) J.
Practice
What is the potential at 2.0 m from a \(-6.0\) nC point charge?
Show answer
\(V = (9.0\times10^{9})(-6.0\times10^{-9})/2.0 = -27\) V.
An electron moves through a potential difference of 250 V from low to high potential. What is the change in its potential energy, in joules and electron-volts?
Show answer
\(\Delta U = q\Delta V = (-1.60\times10^{-19})(+250) = -4.0\times10^{-17}\) J, or \(-250\) eV. It loses potential energy (and gains kinetic energy).
Two \(+4.0\) nC charges are each 0.30 m from point P. Find the potential at P.
Show answer
\(V = 2(9.0\times10^{9})(4.0\times10^{-9})/0.30 = 240\) V.
The potential at P due to two point charges is zero. Does the electric field at P have to be zero?
Show answer
No. The potential is a scalar sum in which positive and negative contributions can cancel, while the field is a vector sum. For example, midway between equal and opposite charges \(V = 0\) but \(E \neq 0\).
How much energy does a 12 V car battery give to each coulomb of charge that passes through it?
Show answer
12 J per coulomb.
Two charged conducting spheres of different sizes are connected by a long wire. What can you say about their potentials, and do they necessarily have equal charges?
Show answer
Their potentials are equal once equilibrium is reached. Their charges are not equal in general; the larger sphere holds more charge for the same potential.
A hiker reads a topographic map to see how steep the land is. The contour lines join points of equal height; where they bunch together the slope is steep, and the direction of steepest descent is at right angles to the lines. Electric potential works the same way. Lines of equal potential (equipotentials) are the contours of an electric landscape, and the electric field is its slope: it points “downhill,” perpendicular to the contours, and it is strong where the contours are close together. This analogy gives you a quick way to turn a map of potential into a map of the field, and vice versa, and a tool for predicting the motion of charges. This lesson makes the relationship precise.
Learning objective · 10.5.B
Describe the relationship between electric potential and electric field.
Required content · EK 10.5.B
The average electric field between two points in space is equal to the electric potential difference between the two points divided by the distance between the two points: \(E_{avg} = -\dfrac{\Delta V}{\Delta r}\) (in magnitude, \(E = |\Delta V|/d\)).
Electric field vector maps and equipotential lines are tools to describe the field produced by a charge or configuration of charges and can be used to predict the motion of charged objects in the field.
Equipotential lines represent lines of equal electric potential in space. These lines are also referred to as isolines of electric potential. Isolines are perpendicular to electric field vectors. An isoline map can be constructed from an electric field vector map, and an electric field map may be constructed from an isoline map.
An electric field vector points in the direction of decreasing potential. There is no component of an electric field along an isoline.
The relation \(E = \Delta V / d\)
Consider a region where the field is uniform, with magnitude \(E\), and move a positive test charge a distance \(d\) against the field, in the direction opposite to \(\vec{E}\). The field pushes with force \(qE\), so an external agent must do work \(W = qEd\). That work equals the increase in potential energy, \(q\Delta V\). Equating them gives
\[ E = \frac{|\Delta V|}{d}, \]
and shows that the units V/m and N/C are the same. More generally, the field is the rate at which the potential changes with distance along a line, \(E = -\Delta V/\Delta r\) for the component along that line. The minus sign says the field points toward decreasing potential. For a nonuniform field, \(\Delta V/d\) gives the average field between the two points.
Think of a 12 V battery connected to two parallel plates 0.030 m apart. The potential changes uniformly by 12 V over 0.030 m, so \(E = 12/0.030 = 400\) V/m between the plates, pointing from the high-potential plate to the low-potential plate.
Equipotential lines
An equipotential line (or surface in three dimensions) joins points that are all at the same potential. Moving a charge along an equipotential changes neither its potential nor its potential energy, so the electric force does no work along it. Work is force times the displacement component along the force; that can be zero for every displacement along the line only if the force, and therefore the field, is perpendicular to the line. This gives the key rules.
Equipotentials are perpendicular to the field at every point. There is no component of the field along an equipotential.
The field points from high potential to low potential, perpendicular to the lines.
Close lines mean a strong field (the potential changes rapidly over a short distance); widely spaced lines mean a weak field. This is true for lines drawn at equal increments of potential.
Equipotential lines never cross (a point cannot have two potentials).
The surface of a conductor in equilibrium is an equipotential, and the field lines meet it at right angles.
Figure 10.8a Equipotentials of a point charge are concentric circles. The field lines (blue) cross them at right angles and point toward lower potential. The circles drawn at equal steps in potential get farther apart as the distance grows, because the field is weaker there.
For a single point charge the equipotentials are concentric circles (spheres in three dimensions), spaced farther apart as the distance grows, because the potential \(kQ/r\) falls ever more slowly. For a uniform field they are equally spaced parallel lines perpendicular to the field, like contour lines on a uniform slope.
Figure 10.8b Equipotentials in a uniform field are equally spaced parallel lines perpendicular to the field. The field points from the higher potential to the lower, and its size is the potential change per unit distance: \(E = 10\ \text{V}/0.020\ \text{m} = 5.0\times10^{2}\) V/m.
Converting between maps
Given a map of equipotentials with their values, you can find the field direction (perpendicular to the lines, toward lower values) and an estimate of its size (\(E \approx \Delta V/d\), where \(d\) is the distance between neighboring lines measured perpendicular to them). Given a field map, draw lines perpendicular to the arrows. These conversions are a favorite free-response task, where you are asked to sketch the missing map. Equipotentials also let you predict motion: a positive charge accelerates toward lower potential, a negative charge toward higher potential, and in both cases the speed gained follows from \(\Delta K = -q\Delta V\).
Figure 10.8c Converting an isoline map to a field map. Draw arrows perpendicular to the lines, pointing toward lower potential; where the lines at equal potential steps are closer together, the field is stronger (\(E \approx \Delta V/d\)), so draw longer arrows.
Worked example · field between plates
Two parallel plates are held at 12.0 V and 0 V and are 0.030 m apart. Find the field between them and the force on a \(+2.0\ \mu\)C charge placed there.
Field. \(E = \Delta V/d = 12.0/0.030 = 400\) V/m (N/C), directed from the 12 V plate to the 0 V plate.
Force. \(F = qE = (2.0\times10^{-6})(400) = 8.0\times10^{-4}\) N, in the direction of the field.
Worked example · reading an equipotential map
In a region of uniform field, equipotentials at 10 V, 20 V and 30 V are straight lines 2.0 cm apart. Find the magnitude and direction of the field, and the work done by the field when an electron moves from the 30 V line to the 10 V line.
Direction. Perpendicular to the lines, pointing toward lower potential (from the 30 V line toward the 10 V line).
Work by the field. \(\Delta U = q\Delta V = (-1.60\times10^{-19})(10 - 30) = +3.2\times10^{-18}\) J. The electron’s potential energy increases, so the field does negative work, \(W = -3.2\times10^{-18}\) J = \(-20\) eV. The electron was moving against the force (the force on an electron is opposite to the field).
Worked example · explain in words
A student claims that a charge moved along an equipotential line from A to B needs no force at all. Evaluate this.
Argument. The electric force does no work along an equipotential, since the potential energy does not change. But the field is not zero there; the electric force on the charge is still \(qE\), perpendicular to the line. Something else (an external force) must supply the sideways force that keeps the charge on the line, if it is not going to follow the electric force. The net work done is zero because the force and displacement are perpendicular.
Parallel plates 5.0 mm apart have a potential difference of 150 V. Find the field.
Show answer
\(E = 150/0.0050 = 3.0\times10^{4}\) V/m.
The field in a uniform region is 800 V/m. How far apart are two equipotentials that differ by 24 V?
Show answer
\(d = \Delta V/E = 24/800 = 0.030\) m.
An equipotential map has lines spaced 1.0 cm apart in one area and 3.0 cm in another, at the same potential steps. Where is the field stronger, and by what factor?
Show answer
In the first area, by a factor of 3 (the field is inversely proportional to the spacing).
A proton is released from rest in a region of field. Does it move toward higher or lower potential? How does its potential energy change?
Show answer
Toward lower potential; its potential energy decreases and its kinetic energy increases.
On a sketch, field lines run from left to right. Draw (in words) the equipotentials, and say which side is at higher potential.
Show answer
Vertical lines (perpendicular to the field). The left side is at higher potential, since the field points toward decreasing potential.
Why can two equipotential lines never cross?
Show answer
The crossing point would have to have two different potential values at once, which is impossible; it would also have two perpendicular field directions.
The flash of a camera is far brighter than a small battery could deliver directly. A defibrillator sends a large pulse of energy through the chest within a few milliseconds. In both, the energy was stored slowly in a capacitor and released quickly. A capacitor is a device that stores energy in the electric field between two conductors, and it is in every phone, computer, radio and power supply. The simplest form, two parallel plates, also gives the standard example of a uniform electric field, and shows how a charged particle moves like a projectile. This lesson develops the capacitor from the field and potential of the earlier lessons.
Learning objective · 10.6.A
Describe the physical properties of a parallel-plate capacitor.
Required content · EK 10.6.A
A parallel-plate capacitor consists of two separated parallel conducting surfaces that can hold equal amounts of charge with opposite signs.
Capacitance relates the magnitude of the charge stored on each plate to the electric potential difference created by the separation of those charges: \(C = Q/\Delta V\). The capacitance depends only on the physical properties of the capacitor, such as its shape and the material used to separate the plates.
The capacitance of a parallel-plate capacitor is proportional to the area of one of its plates and inversely proportional to the distance between its plates, with the constant of proportionality the product of the dielectric constant \(\kappa\) of the material between the plates and the permittivity of free space: \(C = \kappa\varepsilon_0 A/d\).
The electric field between two charged parallel plates with uniformly distributed charge is constant in both magnitude and direction, except near the edges: \(E = Q/(\varepsilon_0 A)\) for plates in vacuum, equivalently \(E = \Delta V/d\). A charged particle between the plates undergoes constant acceleration, like projectile motion in a gravitational field.
The electric potential energy stored in a capacitor is equal to the work done by an external force to separate that amount of charge: \(U_C = \tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = Q^2/(2C)\).
Adding a dielectric between two plates changes the capacitance and induces an electric field in the dielectric in the opposite direction to the field between the plates.
Only parallel-plate capacitors are required; edge effects are ignored unless stated. Capacitors are air-filled unless stated.
Capacitance
A parallel-plate capacitor is two flat conducting plates of area \(A\), separated by a small gap \(d\) (air or vacuum, or an insulating material called a dielectric). When connected to a battery, charge flows: the plate attached to the positive terminal accumulates \(+Q\), the other \(-Q\). The charges are equal in magnitude, and the potential difference \(\Delta V\) between the plates is the battery voltage. Experiments show that the charge is proportional to the voltage; the ratio is the capacitance:
\[ C = \frac{Q}{\Delta V}. \]
The unit is the farad (F), 1 F \(=\) 1 C/V. Practical capacitors range from picofarads (pF, \(10^{-12}\) F) to millifarads. \(Q\) here is the charge magnitude on one plate, not the total charge (which is zero).
The capacitance depends only on the geometry and the material, not on \(Q\) or \(\Delta V\). For parallel plates in a vacuum or air,
\[ C = \varepsilon_0\frac{A}{d}. \]
Larger plates hold more charge for a given voltage; plates closer together hold more charge as well, because the opposite charges on facing plates attract each other and bind the charges. Doubling \(A\) doubles \(C\); doubling \(d\) halves \(C\).
Figure 10.9a A parallel-plate capacitor. Equal and opposite charges \(\pm Q\) sit on the plates; the field between them is uniform (except near the edges) and points from the positive plate to the negative plate. The panel lists the capacitor relationships.
The field between the plates
Between the plates, away from the edges, the field is uniform: it has the same magnitude and direction everywhere, and points from the positive plate to the negative one. Its magnitude is related to the potential difference by \(E = \Delta V/d\) (lesson 10.8), and, combining with \(C = Q/\Delta V\) and \(C = \varepsilon_0A/d\), also to the charge: \(E = Q/(\varepsilon_0A)\). The second form says the field depends on the charge per unit area on the plates, and not on the separation. This uniform field is the electric analogue of the uniform gravitational field near the Earth’s surface; a charged particle in it feels a constant force \(qE\), has constant acceleration \(a = qE/m\), and moves like a projectile (lesson 10.10).
Energy stored in a capacitor
Charging a capacitor means moving charge from one plate to the other against the growing field. As the charge on the plates increases, the voltage increases in proportion, \(\Delta V = Q/C\), so the work for each additional bit of charge increases. The total work is the area of the triangle under the graph of \(\Delta V\) against \(Q\):
\[ U_C = \tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = \frac{Q^2}{2C}. \]
The energy is stored in the electric field between the plates. Which of the three forms to use depends on what is held constant: if the capacitor stays connected to a battery, \(\Delta V\) is fixed; if it is disconnected, \(Q\) is fixed.
Figure 10.9b Charging a capacitor. The potential difference rises in proportion to the charge, \(\Delta V = Q/C\), so the slope is \(1/C\) and the work to charge it is the area of the triangle, \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V\). The values are those of the example in this lesson.
Dielectrics
Inserting an insulating material (a dielectric) between the plates increases the capacitance. The molecules of the dielectric polarize in the field of the plates (lesson 10.3): positive charges shift slightly toward the negative plate and negative charges toward the positive plate. The result is a layer of bound charge on each face of the dielectric, which sets up a field of its own pointing opposite to the field of the plates, so the net field in the dielectric is smaller than before. For the same charge on the plates the potential difference is therefore smaller, and the capacitance \(C = Q/\Delta V\) is larger. The capacitance is multiplied by the dielectric constant:
\[ C = \kappa C_0 = \kappa\varepsilon_0\frac{A}{d}. \]
Figure 10.9c A dielectric polarizes: its molecules shift charge toward the plates of opposite sign, leaving bound charge on its faces whose field opposes the field of the plates. For the same charge the net field, and so the potential difference, is smaller, so \(C = Q/\Delta V\) is larger by the factor \(\kappa\).
Battery connected (\(\Delta V\) fixed): \(C\) rises by \(\kappa\), so \(Q = C\Delta V\) rises by \(\kappa\) and \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2\) rises by \(\kappa\). The battery supplies the extra charge and energy.
Battery disconnected (\(Q\) fixed): \(C\) rises by \(\kappa\), so \(\Delta V = Q/C\) falls by \(\kappa\), and \(U = Q^2/2C\) falls by \(\kappa\). The field pulls the dielectric in, and the energy lost is the work done on the dielectric.
Worked example · an air capacitor
A parallel-plate capacitor has plates of area \(0.040\ \text{m}^2\) separated by 1.0 mm of air and is connected to a 12 V battery. Find \(C\), \(Q\), \(E\) and the stored energy.
Energy. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.54\times10^{-10})(144) = 2.5\times10^{-8}\) J.
Worked example · adding a dielectric, battery connected
A dielectric with \(\kappa = 4.0\) is slid between the plates of the capacitor above while the battery stays connected. Find the new \(C\), \(Q\) and \(U\).
Capacitance. \(C = 4.0(3.54\times10^{-10}) = 1.4\times10^{-9}\) F.
Charge. The voltage is still 12 V, so \(Q = (1.42\times10^{-9})(12) = 1.7\times10^{-8}\) C, four times the original.
Energy. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.42\times10^{-9})(144) = 1.0\times10^{-7}\) J, four times the original. The battery did the extra work.
Worked example · adding a dielectric, battery disconnected
The same capacitor (\(Q = 4.2\times10^{-9}\) C at 12 V) is disconnected from the battery, and then the \(\kappa = 4.0\) dielectric is inserted. Find the new voltage and energy, and explain what happened to the energy.
Voltage. \(Q\) is fixed and \(C\) is four times larger, so \(\Delta V = Q/C = 12/4 = 3.0\) V.
Energy. \(U = Q^2/(2C)\) is one quarter of the original, \(6.4\times10^{-9}\) J.
Explanation. The polarized dielectric is attracted into the gap, and the field does positive work on it, so the energy stored in the field falls.
Field. Uniform between plates: \(E = \Delta V/d = Q/(\varepsilon_0A)\), from \(+\) to \(-\).
Energy. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = Q^2/2C\); the area under a \(\Delta V\)–\(Q\) graph.
Dielectric. Raises \(C\) by \(\kappa\) by polarizing and reducing the field.
Key question. Is the battery connected (\(\Delta V\) fixed) or not (\(Q\) fixed)?
Practice
A \(2.0\ \mu\)F capacitor is connected to a 9.0 V battery. Find its charge and stored energy.
Show answer
\(Q = C\Delta V = 18\ \mu\)C. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0\times10^{-6})(81) = 8.1\times10^{-5}\) J.
The plate separation of an isolated, charged air capacitor is doubled. What happens to \(C\), \(\Delta V\), \(E\) and \(U\)?
Show answer
\(C\) halves. \(Q\) is fixed, so \(\Delta V = Q/C\) doubles. \(E = Q/(\varepsilon_0A)\) is unchanged. \(U = Q^2/2C\) doubles (the work done in pulling the plates apart).
A capacitor has \(C = 5.0\) nF and a plate separation of 0.20 mm. What is the area of one plate?
Show answer
An air capacitor connected to a battery has a dielectric inserted. State what happens to \(\Delta V\), \(C\), \(Q\) and the net field between the plates.
Show answer
\(\Delta V\) is fixed by the battery; \(C\) increases by \(\kappa\); \(Q = C\Delta V\) increases by \(\kappa\). The net field \(\Delta V/d\) is unchanged: the extra charge on the plates raises their own field by \(\kappa\), and the opposing field of the polarized dielectric cancels that increase.
On a graph of \(\Delta V\) against \(Q\) for a capacitor, what do the slope and the area under the graph represent?
Show answer
The slope is \(1/C\); the area under the graph is the stored energy, \(\tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V\).
Why does a dielectric reduce the field inside it?
Show answer
Its molecules polarize, leaving bound charge on its faces whose field points opposite to the field of the plates, partially canceling it.
The picture on an old television tube was painted by a beam of electrons accelerated through thousands of volts and steered by electric fields. Today the same physics runs particle accelerators, ink-jet printers (which steer charged droplets), and electron microscopes. All of them rely on one idea: when a charged particle moves between points at different potentials, its potential energy changes, and by conservation of energy its kinetic energy changes by the opposite amount. In a uniform field the motion is also the simplest imaginable: constant acceleration. This lesson combines the energy and force views of the earlier lessons and applies them to moving charges, which closes the unit.
Learning objective · 10.7.A
Describe changes in energy in a system due to a difference in electric potential between two locations.
Required content · EK 10.7.A
When a charged object moves between two locations with different electric potentials, the resulting change in the electric potential energy of the object–field system is given by \(\Delta U_E = q\Delta V\).
The movement of a charged object between two points with different electric potentials results in a change in kinetic energy of the object consistent with the conservation of energy: \(\Delta K + \Delta U_E = 0\).
Energy conservation for a moving charge
If the electric force is the only force doing work on a particle of charge \(q\) moving from point A to point B, the sum of its kinetic and potential energies is constant:
\[ \Delta K + \Delta U_E = 0, \quad\text{so}\quad \tfrac{1}{2}mv_B^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_A^2 = -q\Delta V = -q(V_B - V_A). \]
The signs deserve care. A positive charge speeds up when it moves toward lower potential (\(\Delta V \lt 0\), so \(\Delta K \gt 0\)); a negative charge speeds up when it moves toward higher potential. Both cases are the same statement: a charge speeds up when it moves in the direction that the electric force pushes it, and it slows down when it moves against the force. A charge released from rest always starts out moving the way the force points.
Figure 10.10a Energy bars for a charge moving in an electric field. The total \(K + U_E\) stays the same. A charge gains kinetic energy when it moves in the direction of the force on it: positive charges toward lower potential, negative charges toward higher potential.
A charge accelerated from rest through a potential difference of magnitude \(|\Delta V|\) gains kinetic energy \(K = |q|\,|\Delta V|\). For a particle of charge \(e\) through 1 V that is 1 eV, so a proton accelerated through 2000 V gains 2000 eV. Solving for the speed, \(v = \sqrt{2|q\Delta V|/m}\). Because of its tiny mass, an electron reaches high speeds with only modest voltages: through 100 V it reaches \(5.9\times10^{6}\) m/s, 2% of the speed of light.
Figure 10.10b Acceleration through a potential difference. Any particle of charge \(\pm e\) gains 500 eV of kinetic energy in 500 V, so the lighter particle ends up faster: \(v = \sqrt{2e\Delta V/m}\).
Motion in a uniform field
Between the plates of a parallel-plate capacitor the field is uniform, so a charged particle of mass \(m\) feels a constant force \(F = qE\) and has a constant acceleration
\[ a = \frac{qE}{m}, \]
in the direction of \(\vec{E}\) for a positive charge and opposite to it for a negative charge. This is exactly the situation of a projectile in a gravitational field, where gravity is replaced by the electric force. All the equations from Physics 1 apply: \(v = v_0 + at\), \(\Delta y = v_{0y}t + \tfrac{1}{2}at^2\), and so on. A particle entering the field perpendicular to it, with horizontal speed \(v_0\), keeps its horizontal velocity (no horizontal force) and accelerates vertically, tracing a parabola, which is a perfect match to a horizontally launched projectile.
Figure 10.10c A charged particle in the uniform field of parallel plates follows a parabola, like a horizontally launched projectile with the electric force in place of gravity. The horizontal velocity is constant, so \(t = L/v_0\), and the vertical deflection is \(y = \tfrac{1}{2}at^2\) with \(a = qE/m\).
For electrons and ions the electric force is overwhelmingly larger than the weight, so gravity is neglected. (For an electron in a field of 100 N/C, \(qE = 1.6\times10^{-17}\) N compared with \(mg = 9\times10^{-30}\) N.) The usual procedure for a particle crossing a region of field is to find the time of flight from the horizontal motion, \(t = L/v_0\), and then the vertical deflection from \(y = \tfrac{1}{2}at^2\). Remember also that the energy method gives the speed on exit from the potential difference passed through, without the need to find the time.
Worked example · acceleration through a potential difference
A proton is accelerated from rest through a potential difference of 2000 V. Find its final kinetic energy and speed.
An electron enters the region between two horizontal plates with a horizontal speed of \(2.0\times10^{7}\) m/s. The plates are 0.050 m long, and the field between them is 3000 N/C, directed upward. Find the vertical deflection on exit, and the direction.
Time. \(t = L/v_0 = 0.050/(2.0\times10^{7}) = 2.5\times10^{-9}\) s.
Acceleration. \(a = eE/m = (1.60\times10^{-19})(3000)/(9.11\times10^{-31}) = 5.3\times10^{14}\) m/s\(^2\), directed downward (opposite to the field, because the electron is negative).
Deflection. \(y = \tfrac{1}{2}at^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(5.27\times10^{14})(2.5\times10^{-9})^2 = 1.6\times10^{-3}\) m, about 1.6 mm downward.
Check. The weight of the electron, \(mg \approx 9\times10^{-30}\) N, is about \(10^{-14}\) of \(eE = 4.8\times10^{-16}\) N, so ignoring gravity is justified.
Worked example · closest approach
A proton is fired from far away directly toward a fixed \(+20\) nC charge with an initial speed of \(2.0\times10^{5}\) m/s. How close does it get before it stops?
Energy. At the closest point all the kinetic energy has become potential energy: \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = kQe/r\).
Solve. \(K_0 = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.67\times10^{-27})(2.0\times10^{5})^2 = 3.3\times10^{-17}\) J. \(r = kQe/K_0 = (9.0\times10^{9})(20\times10^{-9})(1.60\times10^{-19})/(3.3\times10^{-17}) = 0.86\) m.
Exam focus
Energy. \(\Delta U_E = q\Delta V\); \(\Delta K = -\Delta U_E\). A charge speeds up when it moves with the electric force.
From rest. \(K = |q\Delta V|\); \(v = \sqrt{2|q\Delta V|/m}\).
Uniform field. \(a = qE/m\), constant; parabolic path for perpendicular entry; use projectile equations.
Direction. For negative charges, force and acceleration are opposite to the field.
Gravity. Negligible for electrons and ions.
Choose the method. Energy for speeds between two potentials; kinematics for paths and times in a uniform field.
Practice
An electron is accelerated from rest through 500 V. Find its final speed.
Show answer
A \(+3.0\ \mu\)C charge moves from a point at 80 V to a point at 20 V. What is the change in its kinetic energy?
Show answer
\(\Delta U = q\Delta V = (3.0\times10^{-6})(-60) = -1.8\times10^{-4}\) J, so \(\Delta K = +1.8\times10^{-4}\) J.
A proton and an electron are each released from rest in the same uniform field. Compare their accelerations and the directions of motion.
Show answer
Same force magnitude \(eE\), so the electron’s acceleration is about 1840 times larger (mass ratio); they move in opposite directions: the proton with the field, the electron against it.
A particle of charge \(+2.0\ \mu\)C and mass 1.0 g is released from rest in a field of 500 N/C. Find its acceleration (ignore gravity).
Show answer
\(a = qE/m = (2.0\times10^{-6})(500)/(1.0\times10^{-3}) = 1.0\) m/s\(^2\) in the direction of the field.
A charged particle crosses the same region of uniform field twice, once at speed \(v_0\) and once at \(2v_0\), entering perpendicular to the field. By what factor does its deflection change?
Show answer
The time in the field is halved, and the deflection \(\tfrac{1}{2}at^2\) falls to one quarter.
Why can a student use \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = q\Delta V\) to find the speed of a charge accelerated through a nonuniform field but not \(v^2 = 2ad\) with \(a = qE/m\)?
Show answer
The kinematic equation assumes constant acceleration, which is true only in a uniform field. The energy relation depends only on the potential difference between the end points, so it holds for any field.
Unit 10 practice · 10 problems
Unit 10 practice: Electric Force, Field, and Potential
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Constants: \(k = 8.99\times10^{9}\ \text{N·m}^2/\text{C}^2\),
\(e = 1.60\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}\), \(\varepsilon_0 = 8.85\times10^{-12}\ \text{C}^2/(\text{N·m}^2)\),
\(m_e = 9.11\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}\). Calculator allowed.
Identical conducting sphere A carries +6.0 nC and sphere B carries −4.0 nC. They touch and are separated. Find each final charge, and the number of electrons that moved from one sphere to the other. Which direction did they move?
Show answer
Charge is conserved: \(+6.0 + (-4.0) = +2.0\ \text{nC}\), shared equally by identical spheres, so each ends with +1.0 nC. Sphere B went from −4.0 nC to +1.0 nC, so it lost 5.0 nC of electrons to A: \(n = \dfrac{5.0\times10^{-9}}{1.60\times10^{-19}} \approx 3.1\times10^{10}\) electrons moved from B to A.
A +3.0 μC charge and a −5.0 μC charge are 0.20 m apart. Find the magnitude of the force on each, and state whether it is attractive or repulsive.
Show answer
\(F = \dfrac{k|q_1q_2|}{r^2} = \dfrac{(8.99\times10^{9})(3.0\times10^{-6})(5.0\times10^{-6})}{(0.20)^2} = 3.4\ \text{N}\). Opposite signs: attractive. Each charge feels 3.4 N toward the other (Newton's third law), regardless of which is larger.
Both charges in a pair are doubled and their separation is halved. The electric force between them becomes
A factor of 2 would come from doubling only one charge and leaving the distance alone. Here both charges double (a factor of 4 in the numerator) and the distance halves (another factor of 4 from the inverse square).
4 accounts for the two doubled charges (\(2 \times 2\)) but ignores the halved separation, or accounts for the separation but forgets the charges. Each change contributes its own factor of 4.
8 is what you get by treating the distance as inverse-linear, as if halving \(r\) merely doubled \(F\). Coulomb's law has \(r^2\) in the denominator, so halving \(r\) multiplies \(F\) by 4, not 2.
\(F \propto \dfrac{q_1q_2}{r^2}\): the numerator grows by \(2\times2 = 4\) and the denominator shrinks by \((\tfrac{1}{2})^2 = \tfrac{1}{4}\), so \(F\) grows by \(4 \times 4 = 16\).
On the x-axis: \(q_1 = +2.0\ \mu\text{C}\) at \(x = 0\), \(q_3 = -1.0\ \mu\text{C}\) at \(x = 0.10\ \text{m}\), and \(q_2 = +2.0\ \mu\text{C}\) at \(x = 0.40\ \text{m}\). Find the net force on \(q_3\).
Show answer
Directions first: \(q_3\) is attracted toward \(q_1\) (−x) and toward \(q_2\) (+x). Magnitudes: from \(q_1\), 0.10 m away, \(F_1 = \dfrac{(8.99\times10^{9})(2.0\times10^{-6})(1.0\times10^{-6})}{(0.10)^2} = 1.80\ \text{N}\); from \(q_2\), 0.30 m away, \(F_2 = \dfrac{(8.99\times10^{9})(2.0\times10^{-6})(1.0\times10^{-6})}{(0.30)^2} = 0.20\ \text{N}\). Net: \(1.80 - 0.20 = 1.6\ \text{N}\) in the −x direction (toward \(q_1\), the closer charge).
Find the electric field 0.30 m from a +6.0 nC point charge. An electron is released there; find the force on it and its initial acceleration, with directions.
Show answer
\(E = \dfrac{k|Q|}{r^2} = \dfrac{(8.99\times10^{9})(6.0\times10^{-9})}{(0.30)^2} = 6.0\times10^{2}\ \text{N/C}\), pointing away from the positive charge. The electron is negative, so \(\vec{F}\) is opposite \(\vec{E}\): \(F = eE = (1.60\times10^{-19})(600) = 9.6\times10^{-17}\ \text{N}\) toward the charge. \(a = \dfrac{F}{m_e} = \dfrac{9.6\times10^{-17}}{9.11\times10^{-31}} \approx 1.1\times10^{14}\ \text{m/s}^2\), toward the charge.
A +4.0 nC charge is at \(x = 0\) and a +9.0 nC charge at \(x = 0.50\ \text{m}\). Find the point between them where the net electric field is zero, and the electric potential at that point.
Show answer
Set the magnitudes equal: \(\dfrac{k(4.0)}{x^2} = \dfrac{k(9.0)}{(0.50 - x)^2}\), so \(\dfrac{2}{x} = \dfrac{3}{0.50 - x}\), giving \(1.0 - 2x = 3x\) and \(x = 0.20\ \text{m}\) (closer to the smaller charge). Potential is a scalar sum: \(V = k\left(\dfrac{4.0\times10^{-9}}{0.20} + \dfrac{9.0\times10^{-9}}{0.30}\right) = (8.99\times10^{9})(5.0\times10^{-8}) \approx 4.5\times10^{2}\ \text{V}\). Zero field, but not zero potential.
Rank the electric potential energy of these pairs of point charges, greatest to least: (i) \(+2q\) and \(+2q\) separated by \(r\); (ii) \(+q\) and \(-4q\) separated by \(r\); (iii) \(+q\) and \(+q\) separated by \(r/2\); (iv) \(-2q\) and \(-2q\) separated by \(2r\).
Show answer
\(U = \dfrac{kq_1q_2}{r}\), signs included. In units of \(kq^2/r\): (i) \(\dfrac{4}{1} = 4\); (ii) \(-4\); (iii) \(\dfrac{1}{1/2} = 2\); (iv) \(\dfrac{4}{2} = 2\). Ranking: (i) > (iii) = (iv) > (ii). Like charges store positive energy; the only negative entry is the unlike pair, which sits at the bottom no matter its size.
Two parallel plates 2.0 cm apart are held at a potential difference of 400 V. (a) Find the field between them. (b) An electron released from rest at the negative plate reaches the positive plate; find its speed there. (c) How much work is needed to push a +3.0 μC charge from the negative plate to the positive plate?
Show answer
(a) \(E = \dfrac{\Delta V}{d} = \dfrac{400}{0.020} = 2.0\times10^{4}\ \text{V/m}\), from the positive plate toward the negative one. (b) The electron moves from low to high potential, so it speeds up: \(\Delta K = -q\,\Delta V = -(-e)(+400\ \text{V}) = e\,\Delta V = (1.60\times10^{-19})(400) = 6.4\times10^{-17}\ \text{J}\), and \(v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2K}{m_e}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(6.4\times10^{-17})}{9.11\times10^{-31}}} \approx 1.2\times10^{7}\ \text{m/s}\). (c) Pushing a positive charge toward the positive plate raises its energy: \(W = q\,\Delta V = (3.0\times10^{-6})(400) = 1.2\times10^{-3}\ \text{J}\).
A field-line sketch shows two charges, A and B. Twelve lines leave A; six of them end on B and six run off the page. Explain in words (a) the sign of each charge, (b) the ratio \(|q_A|/|q_B|\), (c) why field lines never cross, and (d) how you would compare the field strength at two points using only the sketch.
Show answer
(a) Lines leave positive charges and end on negative ones, so A is positive and B is negative. (b) Line count is proportional to charge: 12 lines on A versus 6 ending on B, so \(|q_A| = 2|q_B|\). (c) The field at any point has one direction; a crossing would give two. (d) The field is stronger where the lines are closer together, so compare the spacing of the lines around each point.
A parallel-plate capacitor has plate area 0.040 m² and separation 0.20 mm (air). It is charged to 50 V and then disconnected from the battery. Find \(C\), \(Q\), and the stored energy. A dielectric with \(\kappa = 3.0\) is then slid between the plates; find the new voltage and energy, and explain where the energy went.
Show answer
\(C = \dfrac{\varepsilon_0 A}{d} = \dfrac{(8.85\times10^{-12})(0.040)}{2.0\times10^{-4}} = 1.8\times10^{-9}\ \text{F}\); \(Q = C\,\Delta V = 8.9\times10^{-8}\ \text{C}\); \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^2 = 2.2\times10^{-6}\ \text{J}\). Disconnected, \(Q\) is fixed while \(C\) triples to \(5.3\times10^{-9}\ \text{F}\), so \(\Delta V = Q/C = 50/3 \approx 17\ \text{V}\) and \(U = \dfrac{Q^2}{2C}\) falls to one third, \(7.4\times10^{-7}\ \text{J}\). The field pulls the dielectric in; the lost energy became work done on the slab.
In Unit 10 the charges sat still. Flip a light switch and they do not: within a fraction of a second charge is flowing through the filament of a bulb, carrying energy from the power plant to the room. A flow of charge is called a current, and it is the starting point for everything in this unit. Two ideas need care from the beginning. First, current is a rate, the charge that passes a point each second, and the same current can be carried by few fast charges or many slow ones. Second, the direction we assign to a current is a convention that was fixed before anyone knew that the charge carriers in a wire are negative.
Learning objective · 11.1.A
Describe the movement of electric charges through a medium.
Required content · EK 11.1.A
Current is the rate at which charge passes through a cross-sectional area of a wire: \(I = \Delta q/\Delta t\).
Electric charge moves in a circuit in response to an electric potential difference, sometimes called an electromotive force, or emf (\(\mathcal{E}\)).
If the current is zero in a section of wire, the net motion of charge carriers is also zero, although individual charge carriers will not have zero speed.
Current is not a vector, but it does have a direction: the direction of conventional current is the direction in which positive charge would move. In common circuits, current is actually due to the movement of electrons.
Current as a rate
Imagine a plane perpendicular to a wire, like a finish line across a track. If a net charge \(\Delta q\) crosses that plane in a time \(\Delta t\), the current is
\[ I = \frac{\Delta q}{\Delta t}. \]
The unit is the ampere (A), defined as one coulomb per second: 1 A \(=\) 1 C/s. A small LED draws a few milliamperes, a phone charger about an ampere, a household circuit breaker trips at 15 or 20 A. Because the unit of charge is so large, a current of just 1 A means about \(6\times10^{18}\) elementary charges pass every second.
The word net matters. In a metal the free electrons are always moving, at speeds of order \(10^{6}\) m/s, colliding with the lattice and changing direction. Yet a wire with no battery connected carries no current, because just as many electrons cross the plane in one direction as in the other. The speed of an individual electron is not zero in this case; it is the net flow of charge that is zero. When a potential difference is applied, a small steady drift is superimposed on the random motion, and that drift is the current. For ordinary wires the drift speed is only about a millimeter per second, which is why a lamp lights at once when you flip the switch: the electric field that pushes the charges travels down the wire at nearly the speed of light and starts every electron drifting at the same moment, rather than one electron racing from the switch to the bulb.
Figure 11.1a Inside a wire the free electrons move rapidly and randomly (small arrows). Only the small net drift across the cross section counts as current, \(I = \Delta q/\Delta t\). With no net flow the current is zero, although the individual speeds are not.
What drives the current
Charges do not flow unless something pushes them. The push is an electric field in the conductor, which exists when there is a potential difference between the ends. A battery (or other source) maintains this potential difference, called its emf \(\mathcal{E}\), by doing work on the charges (Lesson 10.7). Emf is not really a force, in spite of the name; it is the energy per unit charge the source supplies, measured in volts. We will usually treat the battery's terminal voltage and its emf as the same, and relax that in Lesson 11.6.
The direction of current
Current is a scalar in the sense that you do not add components, but it has a direction along the wire: toward one end or the other. By convention, conventional current points in the direction positive charge would move, from the positive terminal of a battery through the external circuit toward the negative terminal. In metals the carriers are actually electrons, which drift the opposite way, from the negative terminal toward the positive. Both descriptions predict the same effects: moving positive charge to the right is equivalent, for current, to moving negative charge to the left. Unless stated otherwise, every circuit diagram in this course (and on the exam) uses conventional current. In some solutions, such as salt water or a plasma, both positive ions and negative ions carry charge, each contributing to the same conventional current.
Figure 11.1b Conventional current leaves the positive terminal of the battery and goes around the circuit to the negative terminal; the electrons that actually carry the charge in a metal move the other way. Diagrams use conventional current.
Worked example · charge from current
A phone charger delivers a steady current of 0.50 A for 1.0 hour. (a) How much charge passes through it? (b) How many electrons is that?
(a) Rearrange the definition. \(\Delta q = I\Delta t = (0.50\ \text{A})(3600\ \text{s}) = 1.8\times10^{3}\) C.
(b) Divide by the elementary charge. \(N = \Delta q/e = (1.8\times10^{3})/(1.60\times10^{-19}) = 1.1\times10^{22}\) electrons.
Worked example · current from charge
In a laboratory a net charge of 4.8 C passes a cross section of wire in 2.0 minutes. What is the current?
Convert the time. 2.0 min \(=\) 120 s.
Divide. \(I = \Delta q/\Delta t = 4.8\ \text{C}/120\ \text{s} = 0.040\) A \(= 40\) mA.
Zero current. Net charge flow is zero, not the speed of each charge.
Direction. Conventional current is the direction positive charge would move; electrons move the opposite way.
Cause. A potential difference (emf) from a source such as a battery drives the charge.
Reading a graph. On a graph of charge against time, current is the slope; on a graph of current against time, the charge transferred is the area.
Practice
How much charge passes a point in a wire carrying 2.0 A for 30 s?
Show answer
\(\Delta q = I\Delta t = (2.0)(30) = 60\) C.
A wire carries 0.25 A. How long does it take for 5.0 C to pass a cross section?
Show answer
\(\Delta t = \Delta q/I = 5.0/0.25 = 20\) s.
Electrons move through a wire from left to right. What is the direction of the conventional current?
Show answer
Right to left. Conventional current points the way positive charge would move, opposite to the motion of the electrons.
A student says, "The current in this wire is zero, so nothing in it is moving." Is that correct?
Show answer
No. Zero current means the net charge flow across a cross section is zero. The free electrons still move randomly at high speed; just as many cross in each direction.
On a graph of charge passing a point against time, a straight line rises from 0 C to 12 C in 4.0 s. What is the current?
Show answer
The slope is the current: \(12/4.0 = 3.0\) A.
A lamp lights almost the instant a switch is closed, although electrons drift only about a millimeter per second. Explain.
Show answer
Closing the switch sets up the electric field along the whole wire almost instantly, so charge carriers everywhere in the circuit, including those already in the filament, begin to drift at once. No single electron has to travel from the switch to the lamp.
A flashlight works when a battery, a switch and a bulb are connected in an unbroken ring, and it fails if any link is missing. That ring is the central idea of this topic: charge can flow continuously only around a closed path, and the behavior of the whole depends on how the parts are connected, not just on what the parts are. Engineers describe circuits with schematic diagrams, a shorthand that shows the connections and ignores the shape of the wires. This lesson sets out the vocabulary (closed, open and short circuits, loops, elements) and the symbols you must be able to read and draw.
Learning objective · 11.2.A
Describe the behavior of a circuit.
Required content · EK 11.2.A
A circuit is composed of electrical loops, which may include circuit elements such as wires, batteries, resistors, lightbulbs, capacitors, switches, ammeters and voltmeters.
A closed electrical loop is a closed path through which charges may flow. A closed circuit is one in which charges would be able to flow; an open circuit is one in which charges would not be able to flow; a short circuit is one in which charges would be able to flow with no change in potential difference.
A single circuit element may be part of multiple electrical loops.
Circuit schematics are representations used to describe and analyze electric circuits. The properties of a circuit depend on the physical arrangement of its elements. Elements have common symbols; variable elements are shown with a diagonal strikethrough arrow.
Unless otherwise specified, all circuit schematic diagrams are drawn using conventional current.
Elements and symbols
Each device in a circuit has a standard symbol. A battery is shown as a long line (the positive terminal) next to a short line (the negative terminal). A resistor is a zigzag, and a lightbulb, which is a resistor that glows, is a circle with a cross. A capacitor is two equal parallel lines. A switch is a gap that can be closed by a movable bar. An ammeter and a voltmeter are circles containing A and V. Ideal wires are plain lines; unless told otherwise they have no resistance. A diagonal arrow through a symbol means the element is variable, for example a variable resistor (a dimmer) or a variable capacitor (a radio tuner).
Figure 11.2a Standard circuit symbols. The long line of the battery symbol is the positive terminal. A diagonal arrow through a symbol marks a variable element.
Loops and the three states of a circuit
A closed electrical loop is a closed path through the circuit along which charge can flow. A circuit is closed when at least one such path through a source exists, so that a steady current can flow. It is open when a gap, such as an open switch or a broken wire, interrupts every path, so no current flows anywhere in the loop. A short circuit is a path of negligible resistance connected directly across a source (or part of a circuit). Charge can flow with essentially no change in potential, so the current becomes very large; with a real battery or wall outlet this heats the wires dangerously, which is why fuses and circuit breakers are installed.
Figure 11.2b Closed, open and short circuits. A closed circuit has a complete path; an open circuit has a gap that stops the flow everywhere in the loop; a short circuit has a path of almost no resistance across a source or a component, so the current in that path is very large.
Elements shared by several loops
Many circuits contain more than one path. A single element may belong to more than one loop. In the circuit in the figure, the battery belongs to two loops (one through each bulb) and the two bulbs together form a third loop that does not include the battery. Recognizing which elements are in which loops is the first step in analyzing a circuit, and it prepares you for the loop rule (Lesson 11.7).
Figure 11.2c A circuit with two parallel branches contains three closed loops. Each bulb and the battery appears in more than one loop. Identifying the loops is the first step in applying the loop rule.
Schematics and physical layout
A schematic diagram shows how components are connected, not where they are. A wire may be bent, lengthened or redrawn without changing the circuit, so long as the connections do not change: two circuits are the same if the elements are joined at the same points. What does matter is the arrangement. Connecting two bulbs in a single path gives a different circuit from connecting them in separate branches, and the properties of the circuit (brightness, current, power) depend on which one you build. That is the subject of Lesson 11.5. A dot at a crossing of two lines means the wires are joined; with no dot, the wires merely pass over each other.
Worked example · is it closed?
A battery, a switch and a bulb are connected in a single loop. A student measures zero current with the switch open and then closes it. What changes?
Open. The gap at the switch breaks the only path, so no charge can flow and the current is zero everywhere in the loop (including in the battery).
Closed. The loop is complete, so the battery's potential difference drives a current through the bulb and it lights. Closing the switch did not create the potential difference (the battery had it all along); it created a path.
Worked example · short circuit
A wire is accidentally connected across the terminals of a battery with a bulb in a parallel branch. What happens to the bulb?
Path with no change in potential. The wire provides a path of near-zero resistance directly across the battery. Almost all the current takes it.
Consequence. The potential difference across the wire is essentially zero, so the bulb, which is in parallel with it, has almost no potential difference across it and goes out, while the battery and wire carry a very large current and heat up.
Exam focus
Closed, open, short. Closed: charge can flow around a loop. Open: a gap stops all flow. Short: path with no change in potential.
Symbols. Know all seven, and the diagonal arrow for a variable element.
Loops. One element can be in more than one loop.
Schematics. Connections matter, wire shapes do not; a dot means a joined crossing.
Direction. Draw conventional current leaving the positive terminal.
Practice
A bulb in a flashlight does not light. Name two circuit faults that could cause this.
Show answer
Any break in the single loop: an open switch, a loose or broken wire, a missing or dead battery, or a burned-out filament. Each opens the circuit so no current can flow.
On a schematic, how do you show that two wires that cross are connected?
Show answer
Draw a dot (junction) at the crossing. With no dot the wires are not connected.
In a circuit a battery drives current through two bulbs in separate branches. How many closed loops contain the battery, and how many contain both bulbs?
Show answer
Two loops contain the battery (one through each bulb). One loop contains both bulbs and not the battery.
Why is a short circuit dangerous?
Show answer
The path has almost no resistance, so a very large current flows from the source; the wires and battery heat up and can overheat or start a fire.
An open switch is placed in a loop that contains a battery. What is the potential difference across the open switch compared with the battery's?
Show answer
With no current, there is no potential drop across the bulb or wires, so the whole battery potential difference appears across the open gap in the switch.
What does a diagonal arrow drawn through a resistor symbol indicate?
Show answer
That it is a variable resistor, one whose resistance can be adjusted (such as a dimmer or a rheostat).
Connect the same battery across a copper wire and across a thin strand of nichrome and the currents are very different. Connect it across a long thin wire and across a short thick one of the same metal and again they differ. Something about the object opposes the flow of charge, and it depends both on what the object is made of and on its shape. We call it resistance, and the law that connects it to current and potential difference (Ohm's law) is probably the most-used equation in electronics. This lesson separates the two ingredients, a property of the material (resistivity) and a property of the shape (length and area), and shows how to read resistance from a graph.
Learning objectives · 11.3.A and 11.3.B
Describe the resistance of an object using physical properties of that object. Describe the electrical characteristics of elements of a circuit.
Required content · EK 11.3.A and 11.3.B
Resistance is a measure of the degree to which an object opposes the movement of electric charge.
The resistance of a resistor with uniform geometry is proportional to its resistivity and length and inversely proportional to its cross-sectional area: \(R = \rho\ell/A\). Resistivity is a fundamental property of a material, depending on its atomic and molecular structure, that quantifies how strongly the material opposes the motion of charge. The resistivity of a conductor typically increases with temperature.
Ohm's law relates current, resistance and potential difference across a conductive element: \(I = \Delta V/R\). Materials that obey Ohm's law have constant resistance for all currents and are called ohmic. The resistivity of an ohmic material is constant regardless of temperature.
Resistors can convert electrical energy to thermal energy, which may change the temperature of the resistor and its environment.
The resistance of an ohmic element can be determined from the slope of a graph of the current in the element as a function of the potential difference across it.
Resistance and resistivity
Charges drifting through a material collide with its atoms, and the resulting loss of directed motion is what we call resistance, \(R\), measured in ohms (\(\Omega\), 1 \(\Omega\) = 1 V/A). For a piece of material of uniform cross section, the resistance follows from three facts you can reason out. A longer wire gives the charges more collisions, so \(R\) is proportional to the length \(\ell\). A wider wire gives the charges more room, like adding lanes to a highway, so \(R\) is inversely proportional to the cross-sectional area \(A\). And the material matters: the resistivity \(\rho\) (units \(\Omega\cdot\)m) measures how strongly a given material opposes the flow. Combining,
\[ R = \frac{\rho\,\ell}{A}. \]
Copper has a very low resistivity (about \(1.7\times10^{-8}\ \Omega\cdot\)m), which is why it is used for wires; nichrome has about 60 times more, which makes it useful for heating elements; glass and rubber are so high (\(10^{10}\ \Omega\cdot\)m or more) that they are insulators. The resistivity of a metal generally rises with temperature, because the lattice atoms vibrate more and scatter the charges more often.
Figure 11.3a How resistance depends on shape. \(R = \rho\ell/A\): doubling the length doubles \(R\); doubling the cross-sectional area halves it; doubling the diameter multiplies the area by four, so \(R\) falls to a quarter.
For a wire of circular cross section, \(A = \pi r^2 = \pi d^2/4\), so resistance changes with the square of the diameter: halving the diameter increases the resistance by a factor of four. For ratio problems, write \(R \propto \ell/A\) and substitute the changes directly.
Ohm's law
The relationship among the potential difference \(\Delta V\) across an element, the current \(I\) in it, and its resistance is
\[ \Delta V = IR \qquad\text{or}\qquad I = \frac{\Delta V}{R}. \]
For a given element, doubling the potential difference doubles the current. Such an element is ohmic: its resistance \(R\) is a constant (and so its resistivity is constant, at constant temperature). Not everything is ohmic. For a diode or a light bulb filament, the resistance changes with current (the filament gets hotter and its resistivity rises), so \(\Delta V = IR\) still defines \(R\) at each moment but \(R\) is not a constant.
If you plot the current in an ohmic element against the potential difference across it, you get a straight line through the origin whose slope is \(1/R\). A steep line means low resistance. If the axes are reversed (potential difference on the vertical axis), the slope is \(R\) itself. Take care: the slope gives resistance only for a line through the origin; for a curve such as that of a bulb you must use \(R = \Delta V/I\) at the point in question, not the slope there.
Figure 11.3b Current against potential difference. For an ohmic element the graph is a straight line through the origin whose slope is \(1/R\); a steeper line means a smaller resistance. A bulb filament is not ohmic: its resistance rises as it heats up, so the line bends over.
Resistors convert electrical energy to thermal energy: the charges lose kinetic energy in collisions, which warms the material. That is useful in a toaster and a nuisance in a laptop, and it is why high-current wires must be thick (to lower \(R\)) and why the next lesson is about power.
Figure 11.3c Ohm's law in a circuit. The ammeter is in series with the resistor and reads the current; the voltmeter is connected across the resistor and reads the potential difference. \(R = \Delta V/I = 12\ \text{V}/0.25\ \text{A} = 48\ \Omega\).
Worked example · resistance of a wire
Find the resistance of a 10 m length of copper wire of diameter 1.0 mm (\(\rho = 1.7\times10^{-8}\ \Omega\cdot\)m).
Reasonableness. A fraction of an ohm is typical for a short copper wire, which is why wires may be neglected in most circuit problems.
Worked example · Ohm's law and a graph
A resistor is connected across a 12 V source. (a) The current is 0.25 A. What is its resistance? (b) What current would flow at 18 V, and what does the \(I\)-\(\Delta V\) graph look like?
(a) \(R = \Delta V/I = 12/0.25 = 48\ \Omega\).
(b) \(I = 18/48 = 0.375\) A (about 0.38 A), 1.5 times as large for 1.5 times the potential difference. The graph is a straight line through the origin with slope \(1/R = 1/48 = 0.021\) A/V.
Worked example · changing geometry
A wire has resistance \(R_0\). A second wire of the same material has twice the length and twice the diameter. What is its resistance?
Length. Doubling \(\ell\) doubles \(R\).
Area. Doubling the diameter multiplies the area by 4, which divides \(R\) by 4.
Together. \(R = R_0 \times 2/4 = R_0/2\).
Exam focus
Resistance of a shape. \(R = \rho\ell/A\); \(R\) up with length and resistivity, down with area; circular wire \(A \propto d^2\).
Resistivity. A material property, \(\Omega\cdot\)m; rises with temperature in conductors.
Ohm's law. \(\Delta V = IR\); ohmic means \(R\) is constant.
Graph. \(I\) against \(\Delta V\): slope \(= 1/R\) for an ohmic element; a curve means non-ohmic.
Energy. Resistors turn electrical energy into thermal energy.
Practice
What current flows through a 60 \(\Omega\) resistor connected to a 9.0 V battery?
Show answer
\(I = \Delta V/R = 9.0/60 = 0.15\) A.
A wire is stretched to twice its length at constant volume, so its area is halved. What happens to its resistance?
Show answer
Twice the length doubles \(R\); half the area doubles it again. The resistance is four times as large.
An ohmic resistor has the graph of current against potential difference passing through (2.0 V, 0.10 A). What is the resistance and what is the slope?
Show answer
\(R = 2.0/0.10 = 20\ \Omega\). The slope is \(1/R = 0.050\) A/V.
A nichrome wire has \(\rho = 1.0\times10^{-6}\ \Omega\cdot\)m, length 2.0 m and cross-sectional area \(5.0\times10^{-7}\) m². Find its resistance.
Show answer
The resistivity of a copper wire is measured at 20 °C and again after it is heated by the current. How does it change, and what happens to the resistance?
Show answer
The resistivity of a conductor typically increases with temperature, so the resistance increases as well.
The current in a bulb is 0.20 A at 4.0 V and 0.50 A at 12 V. Is the bulb ohmic? Support your answer with numbers.
Show answer
No. At 4.0 V, \(R = 4.0/0.20 = 20\ \Omega\); at 12 V, \(R = 12/0.50 = 24\ \Omega\). The resistance is not constant (the filament is hotter at the higher current), so the bulb is not ohmic.
A 100 W bulb is brighter than a 40 W bulb, a 1500 W hair dryer needs a heavier cord than a 15 W phone charger, and your electric bill is for energy, not for current. All three statements are about power, the rate at which energy is transferred, converted or dissipated. In a circuit the energy comes from the source and goes into thermal energy and light in resistors, into the electric field of capacitors, and into motion in motors. This lesson derives the three forms of the power equation, uses them to predict how bright bulbs will be, and connects power to the energy a device uses over time.
Learning objective · 11.4.A
Describe the transfer of energy into, out of, or within an electric circuit, in terms of power.
Required content · EK 11.4.A
The rate at which energy is transferred, converted or dissipated by a circuit element depends on the current in the element and the electric potential difference across it: \(P = I\,\Delta V\). Derived equations (using Ohm's law): \(P = I^{2}R\) and \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\).
The brightness of a bulb increases with power, so power can be used to qualitatively predict the brightness of bulbs in a circuit.
Power from current and potential difference
Power is energy per unit time. A charge \(\Delta q\) that moves through a potential difference \(\Delta V\) changes its electric potential energy by \(\Delta q\,\Delta V\) (Lesson 10.7). If the charge passes through an element in a time \(\Delta t\), the rate of energy transfer is
\[ P = \frac{\Delta q\,\Delta V}{\Delta t} = I\,\Delta V. \]
The unit is the watt (1 W = 1 J/s = 1 A \(\cdot\) V). This holds for any element: for a resistor the energy becomes thermal; for a battery doing work on charge it is the power the source delivers; for a motor it becomes mechanical energy. For an ohmic resistor we can substitute Ohm's law, \(\Delta V = IR\), to get two more forms:
\[ P = I^{2}R = \frac{(\Delta V)^{2}}{R}. \]
Which form to use depends on which quantity you know, and, more importantly, on which one the problem holds fixed. If the same current flows through two resistors (as in series), \(P = I^{2}R\) says the larger resistance dissipates more power. If the same potential difference is across them (as in parallel), \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\) says the smaller resistance dissipates more. Using the wrong form is the most common error on this topic.
Figure 11.4a The three forms of the power equation. Choose the form that uses the quantity shared by the elements you are comparing: current in series, potential difference in parallel.
Brightness
A bulb's brightness increases with the power it dissipates, so you can rank bulbs by computing (or reasoning about) \(P\). For identical bulbs in different circuits, the one with the larger current and larger potential difference is brighter. Two identical bulbs in series with a battery carry the same current and share the potential difference equally, so they are equally bright, and each dissipates one quarter the power it would if connected alone across the battery (half the potential difference means \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\) falls by 4). In parallel across the same battery each has the full potential difference and each shines at full brightness. If one bulb in a series string burns out, the loop is open and all go out; in parallel, the others stay on. That is why house wiring is parallel.
Figure 11.4b The same two resistors on the same battery. In series the larger resistance gets more power (\(I^2R\)); in parallel the smaller resistance gets more power (\((\Delta V)^2/R\)). A bulb's brightness follows its power.
Energy used over time
Since \(P = \Delta E/\Delta t\), the energy transferred in a time \(t\) is \(E = Pt\). Electric utilities sell energy in kilowatt-hours: 1 kW\(\cdot\)h \(= (1000\ \text{W})(3600\ \text{s}) = 3.6\times10^{6}\) J. A 1500 W space heater run for 2.0 hours uses 3.0 kW\(\cdot\)h, or \(1.1\times10^{7}\) J. Energy is conserved: the electrical energy delivered to the heater all appears as thermal energy in the room.
Worked example · three forms of the power equation
A resistor of 24 \(\Omega\) is connected to a 12 V battery. Find the current and the power, using each form.
Current. \(I = \Delta V/R = 12/24 = 0.50\) A.
Power, three ways. \(P = I\Delta V = (0.50)(12) = 6.0\) W. \(P = I^{2}R = (0.50)^{2}(24) = 6.0\) W. \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R = 144/24 = 6.0\) W.
Worked example · bulbs in series and in parallel
Two bulbs, \(R_1 = 10\ \Omega\) and \(R_2 = 20\ \Omega\), are connected first in series and then in parallel to an ideal 12 V battery. Which is brighter in each case?
Series. The total resistance is 30 \(\Omega\), so \(I = 12/30 = 0.40\) A in both. \(P_1 = I^{2}R_1 = (0.40)^{2}(10) = 1.6\) W and \(P_2 = (0.40)^{2}(20) = 3.2\) W. The 20 \(\Omega\) bulb is brighter.
Parallel. Each has 12 V across it. \(P_1 = 144/10 = 14.4\) W and \(P_2 = 144/20 = 7.2\) W. The 10 \(\Omega\) bulb is brighter.
Lesson. The brighter bulb switches when the arrangement changes, because in series the current is shared and in parallel the potential difference is shared.
Worked example · energy from power
A 1500 W heater runs for 2.0 h. How much energy does it use, in kilowatt-hours and joules?
A 5.0 \(\Omega\) resistor carries 3.0 A. How much power does it dissipate?
Show answer
\(P = I^{2}R = (3.0)^{2}(5.0) = 45\) W.
Two identical bulbs are connected in series to a battery. How does the power in each compare with the power if one bulb were connected alone to the same battery?
Show answer
In series each has half the battery potential difference, so \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\) is one quarter of the single-bulb value.
The resistance of a heater element is doubled while it stays connected to a fixed potential difference. What happens to its power?
Show answer
\(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\), so the power is cut to one half.
How much energy, in joules, does a 100 W bulb use in 1.0 hour? How much is that in kW\(\cdot\)h?
Show answer
\(E = Pt = (100)(3600) = 3.6\times10^{5}\) J, which is 0.10 kW\(\cdot\)h.
A 40 \(\Omega\) bulb and a 10 \(\Omega\) bulb are connected in parallel to the same battery. Which is brighter? Explain.
Show answer
The 10 \(\Omega\) bulb. In parallel both have the same potential difference, so \(P = (\Delta V)^{2}/R\) is larger for the smaller resistance (four times as large here).
Real circuits have many elements, and the first skill in analyzing them is to recognize how they are connected. There are only two basic ways to join resistors: end to end, so the charge has one path (series), or side by side, so the charge has a choice of paths (parallel). Any complicated network of resistors built from these two can be replaced by one equivalent resistor that draws the same current from the battery, and the replacement reduces a hard circuit to a one-loop problem. This lesson gives the rules for each connection, the reasoning behind them, and a procedure for reducing combinations.
Learning objective · 11.5.A
Describe the equivalent resistance of multiple resistors connected in a circuit.
Required content · EK 11.5.A
Circuit elements may be connected in series and/or in parallel. A series connection is one in which any charge passing through one element must proceed through all the elements in that connection and has no other path available; the current in each element in series must be the same.
A parallel connection is one in which charges may flow through one of two or more paths; across each path, the potential difference is the same.
A collection of resistors may be analyzed as though it were a single resistor with an equivalent resistance \(R_{eq}\). In series, the equivalent resistance is the sum of the individual resistances: \(R_{eq} = \sum R_i\).
In parallel, the inverse of the equivalent resistance is the sum of the inverses of the individual resistances: \(1/R_{eq} = \sum 1/R_i\). When resistors are connected in parallel, the number of paths available to charges increases, and the equivalent resistance of the group decreases.
Series connection
Resistors are in series when they are joined end to end so that all the charge that goes through one goes through the next, with no branching in between. The charge cannot pile up or disappear, so the current is the same in every resistor. The potential differences across the resistors add up to the total supplied, \(\Delta V = \Delta V_1 + \Delta V_2 + \cdots\) (energy conservation, formalized in Lesson 11.7). Substituting \(\Delta V_i = IR_i\):
\[ R_{eq} = R_1 + R_2 + R_3 + \cdots \]
Adding a resistor in series always increases the equivalent resistance and decreases the current. The larger resistor has the larger share of the potential difference.
Parallel connection
Resistors are in parallel when they are connected between the same two points, so each is a separate path. Every path has the same potential difference across it, equal to that between the two points. The currents in the paths add to the current entering the junction, \(I = I_1 + I_2 + \cdots\) (Lesson 11.8). With \(I_i = \Delta V/R_i\):
\[ \frac{1}{R_{eq}} = \frac{1}{R_1} + \frac{1}{R_2} + \frac{1}{R_3} + \cdots \]
Each new path gives the charges another way through, like opening another lane, so the equivalent resistance decreases: it is always smaller than the smallest resistor in the group. For two resistors it is convenient to use \(R_{eq} = R_1R_2/(R_1 + R_2)\), and for \(N\) identical resistors \(R_{eq} = R/N\). The smaller resistor carries the larger share of the current.
Figure 11.5a Series and parallel connections. In series there is one path (same current, potential differences add); in parallel there are several paths between the same two points (same potential difference, currents add).
Reducing a combination
To find \(R_{eq}\) for a mixed network, work from the inside out. Find a group that is purely in series or purely in parallel, replace it by its equivalent, redraw, and repeat until one resistor is left. Then find the total current from \(I = \mathcal{E}/R_{eq}\). To find the current and potential difference for each part, work back: the current through a series element equals the current through its equivalent, and the potential difference across a parallel group equals the potential difference across its equivalent.
Figure 11.5b Reduce from the inside out: combine the parallel pair into 3.0 \(\Omega\), add it to the 6.0 \(\Omega\) in series for \(R_{eq} = 9.0\ \Omega\), then work back out to find each current and potential difference.
A useful check on any answer: the current in a parallel branch with smaller resistance is greater; the branch currents add to the total; and the potential differences around a path from one battery terminal to the other add to the battery's emf.
Worked example · three resistors
Resistors of 10 \(\Omega\), 20 \(\Omega\) and 30 \(\Omega\) are connected (a) in series and (b) in parallel. Find \(R_{eq}\) for each.
(b) Parallel. \(1/R_{eq} = 1/10 + 1/20 + 1/30 = (6 + 3 + 2)/60 = 11/60\), so \(R_{eq} = 60/11 = 5.5\ \Omega\). It is smaller than the smallest resistor (10 \(\Omega\)), as it must be.
Worked example · a mixed network
A 6.0 \(\Omega\) resistor is in series with a parallel pair of 12 \(\Omega\) and 4.0 \(\Omega\), connected to an 18 V battery. Find the current in each resistor.
Four identical 8.0 \(\Omega\) resistors are in parallel. What is \(R_{eq}\)?
Show answer
\(R/N = 8.0/4 = 2.0\ \Omega\).
A 15 \(\Omega\) and a 25 \(\Omega\) resistor are in series with a 20 V battery. Find the current and the potential difference across the 25 \(\Omega\) resistor.
Show answer
A 20 \(\Omega\) resistor is connected in parallel with a second resistor of the same value. Does the total current drawn from a fixed battery increase or decrease, and by what factor?
Show answer
It increases by a factor of 2: the equivalent resistance falls from 20 \(\Omega\) to 10 \(\Omega\), so \(I = \mathcal{E}/R_{eq}\) doubles.
In the mixed network of the worked example, what is the power dissipated in the 6.0 \(\Omega\) resistor?
Show answer
\(P = I^{2}R = (2.0)^{2}(6.0) = 24\) W.
Three identical bulbs: A in series with a parallel pair B and C, connected to a battery. Rank the bulbs by brightness.
Show answer
A carries the total current, while B and C each carry half of it (same potential difference, equal resistances). A is brightest and B and C are equal and dimmer. If C is removed, A dims somewhat (the total resistance rises) and B gets brighter (it now carries the full current).
Lesson 11.6 · Unit 11 · CED topic 11.5 (real batteries and meters)
So far we have treated batteries as perfect sources, wires as perfect conductors and meters as perfect observers. None of these is exactly true. A car battery cranking the starter motor sags to a lower terminal voltage; the headlights dim at the same moment. A cheap voltmeter connected to a high-resistance circuit gives a wrong reading, because the meter itself draws current. This lesson explains these effects with simple models: a battery with internal resistance, wires with small but nonzero resistance, and meters that disturb what they measure. It also tells you how to connect ammeters and voltmeters, and when the ideal assumptions are safe.
Learning objectives · 11.5.B and 11.5.C
Describe a circuit with resistive wires and a battery with internal resistance. Describe the measurement of current and potential difference in a circuit.
Required content · EK 11.5.B and 11.5.C
Ideal batteries have negligible internal resistance; ideal wires have negligible resistance. The resistance of wires that are good conductors may normally be neglected, because it is much smaller than that of other elements, but only if the circuit contains other elements that do have resistance.
The potential difference a battery would supply if it were ideal is the potential difference measured across its terminals when there is no current in the battery, and is sometimes referred to as its emf (\(\mathcal{E}\)).
The internal resistance of a nonideal battery may be treated as the resistance \(r\) of a resistor in series with an ideal battery and the remainder of the circuit. When there is current in a nonideal battery, the potential difference across its terminals is reduced: \(\Delta V_{terminal} = \mathcal{E} - Ir\).
Ammeters measure current at a specific point and must be connected in series with the element; ideal ammeters have zero resistance. Voltmeters measure potential difference between two points and must be connected in parallel with the element; ideal voltmeters have infinite resistance, so no charge flows through them.
Nonideal ammeters and voltmeters will change the properties of the circuit being measured. AP Physics 2 expects only a qualitative discussion of this. Unless otherwise stated, batteries, wires and meters are assumed ideal.
Emf and internal resistance
The emf \(\mathcal{E}\) of a battery is the potential difference between its terminals when no current flows, which is what an ideal battery would always supply. A real battery is made of chemicals and metal plates that charges must also pass through, and this opposition is modeled as a resistor \(r\), the internal resistance, in series with an ideal battery. When a current \(I\) flows through the battery, there is a potential drop \(Ir\) inside it, so the potential difference across its terminals is less than the emf:
\[ \Delta V_{terminal} = \mathcal{E} - Ir. \]
Equivalently, a battery of emf \(\mathcal{E}\) and internal resistance \(r\) connected to an external resistance \(R\) drives a current \(I = \mathcal{E}/(R + r)\). The terminal voltage falls as the current increases; the graph of terminal potential difference against current is a line starting at \(\mathcal{E}\) on the vertical axis (zero current) with a negative slope of magnitude \(r\). This is why a nearly dead battery can still show nearly its full voltage on a voltmeter when nothing is connected, yet fail to run a bulb: the open-circuit voltage is close to \(\mathcal{E}\), but a bigger \(r\) makes the terminal voltage collapse when a current is drawn. Using the same model, a short circuit across a real battery produces the finite current \(\mathcal{E}/r\), which is large because \(r\) is small.
Figure 11.6a A real battery behaves as an ideal source of emf \(\mathcal{E}\) in series with an internal resistance \(r\). The terminal voltage \(\mathcal{E} - Ir\) falls as the current drawn rises; the slope of the graph is \(-r\).
When wire resistance can be ignored
The resistance of copper wire of normal length is a fraction of an ohm, which is negligible next to resistors of tens or hundreds of ohms. So we normally treat wires as having no resistance and no potential difference along them. This is legitimate only when the circuit also contains elements with significant resistance. In a circuit consisting of a battery and wires alone, the current would be limited only by the wire resistance and the battery's internal resistance, so they could not be neglected.
Ammeters and voltmeters
An ammeter measures the current at one point, so it must be placed in series: the charge to be measured passes through the meter. A good ammeter has very low resistance, so adding it to the circuit does not reduce the current it is trying to measure; an ideal ammeter has zero resistance. A voltmeter measures the potential difference between two points, so it is connected in parallel with the element: one lead on each side. A good voltmeter has very high resistance so that it draws almost no current from the circuit; an ideal voltmeter has infinite resistance and carries none.
Real meters are not ideal, and the effect can be predicted qualitatively. A real ammeter adds a small resistance in series, so the circuit current is slightly lower than before and the reading is a little too low. A real voltmeter in parallel with a resistor lowers the equivalent resistance of that part, which reduces the potential difference across it, so the reading is slightly lower than the value without the meter. The effect is small if the meter's resistance is much smaller (ammeter) or much greater (voltmeter) than the resistance in the circuit and large otherwise. A voltmeter connected in series, or an ammeter connected in parallel across a resistor, is a mistake: the ammeter would act as a short circuit.
Figure 11.6b Connecting meters. An ammeter goes in series (low resistance, so it barely changes the current); a voltmeter goes in parallel across the element (high resistance, so it barely draws current).
Worked example · terminal voltage
A battery of emf 12.0 V and internal resistance 0.50 \(\Omega\) is connected to a 5.5 \(\Omega\) resistor. Find the current, the terminal voltage, and the power dissipated inside the battery.
Terminal voltage. \(\Delta V = \mathcal{E} - Ir = 12.0 - (2.0)(0.50) = 11.0\) V, which is also \(IR = (2.0)(5.5) = 11\) V across the resistor.
Internal dissipation. \(P = I^{2}r = (2.0)^{2}(0.50) = 2.0\) W is wasted as heat inside the battery, out of a total \(I\mathcal{E} = 24\) W.
Worked example · short circuit current
What current flows if the terminals of that battery are connected by a heavy wire of negligible resistance?
Only the internal resistance remains. \(I = \mathcal{E}/r = 12.0/0.50 = 24\) A, and all the power, \(I^{2}r = 288\) W, is dissipated inside the battery, which is why shorting a battery makes it hot.
Exam focus
Model. A real battery is an ideal emf \(\mathcal{E}\) in series with \(r\); \(\Delta V_{terminal} = \mathcal{E} - Ir\).
Open circuit. No current: the terminal voltage equals the emf.
Graph. Terminal voltage against current: intercept \(\mathcal{E}\), slope \(-r\).
Wires. Neglect their resistance only when other resistance is present.
Meters. Ammeter in series (ideal: \(R = 0\)); voltmeter in parallel (ideal: \(R = \infty\)); nonideal meters disturb the circuit.
Practice
A 9.0 V battery with internal resistance 1.0 \(\Omega\) drives a 17 \(\Omega\) resistor. What is the terminal voltage?
Show answer
\(I = 9.0/18 = 0.50\) A; \(\Delta V = 9.0 - (0.50)(1.0) = 8.5\) V.
A voltmeter connected across a battery with no load reads 6.0 V. When a bulb is connected it reads 5.4 V. Explain and find the internal potential drop.
Show answer
With no current the reading is the emf, 6.0 V. With current, part of the emf is lost across the internal resistance: \(Ir = 6.0 - 5.4 = 0.6\) V.
Why should an ammeter have low resistance and a voltmeter high resistance?
Show answer
The ammeter is in series, so low resistance keeps it from changing the current it measures. The voltmeter is in parallel, so high resistance keeps it from drawing current and changing the potential difference it measures.
A student connects an ideal ammeter directly across a resistor. What happens?
Show answer
The ammeter, which has zero resistance, short-circuits the resistor: almost all the current goes through the meter, the resistor's potential difference drops to nearly zero, and the meter (and battery) can be damaged.
On a graph of terminal voltage against current for a battery, the line has intercept 3.0 V and slope \(-0.40\ \Omega\). Find \(\mathcal{E}\), \(r\) and the current at which the terminal voltage is 2.2 V.
Show answer
A real voltmeter with a high but finite resistance is connected across a 100 k\(\Omega\) resistor in a circuit. Is the reading higher or lower than the true value without the meter?
Show answer
Lower. The meter in parallel reduces the equivalent resistance of that part of the circuit, which lowers the potential difference across it.
Series and parallel reductions work when a circuit can be broken into those two patterns, but many circuits cannot, such as two batteries in one loop or a network with several sources. Kirchhoff's two rules are more general: they apply to any circuit, however tangled. The first is nothing more than conservation of energy applied to a charge that travels once around a closed loop. If you go around a loop and return to your starting point, the electric potential must be exactly what it was when you started, so the rises in potential must equal the drops. This lesson states the rule, gives a reliable sign convention, and applies it to loops with one and two sources.
Learning objective · 11.6.A
Describe a circuit or elements of a circuit by applying Kirchhoff's loop rule.
Required content · EK 11.6.A
Energy changes in simple electrical circuits may be represented in terms of charges moving through electric potential differences within circuit elements: \(\Delta U_E = q\Delta V\).
Kirchhoff's loop rule is a consequence of the conservation of energy.
Kirchhoff's loop rule states that the sum of potential differences across all circuit elements in a single closed loop must equal zero: \(\sum \Delta V = 0\).
The values of electric potential at points in a circuit can be represented by a graph of electric potential as a function of position within a loop.
The rule
A charge \(q\) that completes a closed loop returns to where it started with the same potential energy, so the net change in potential energy around the loop is zero. Since \(\Delta U_E = q\Delta V\) for each element, the potential differences around any closed loop sum to zero:
\[ \sum \Delta V_{loop} = 0. \]
Energy is also conserved in the sense that the energy a charge gains from the source equals what it gives up in the resistors; the energy supplied by a battery is dissipated in the circuit. When you traverse a loop you must choose a direction (clockwise or counterclockwise) and stay with it, and assign each \(\Delta V\) a sign according to the following conventions.
Battery. Going from the negative terminal to the positive terminal is a rise: \(+\mathcal{E}\). Going from positive to negative is a drop: \(-\mathcal{E}\).
Resistor. If you go with the current direction through a resistor, the potential falls: \(-IR\). Going against the current direction, the potential rises: \(+IR\).
The direction you choose for the current is a guess. If the calculation gives a negative value for a current, the real current is in the opposite direction to the one you assumed, and the magnitude is right. A negative answer is not a mistake.
Figure 11.7a Signs in the loop rule. Travel around the loop in a chosen direction: crossing a battery from − to + is a rise \(+\mathcal{E}\); crossing a resistor in the direction of the current is a drop \(-IR\). The total change is zero.
The potential-versus-position graph
A graph of electric potential against position around a loop shows the rule at a glance. Choose a point (usually the negative terminal of the source) as \(V = 0\). The potential jumps up by \(\mathcal{E}\) across the battery, then falls in steps across each resistor in the direction of current, and returns to zero. Wires are horizontal segments, because ideal wires have no potential difference. The size of each step down is \(IR\) for that resistor, so a bigger resistor has a bigger step, and the steps down add up to exactly the emf.
Figure 11.7b Potential around a loop. Starting at the negative terminal (taken as 0 V), the potential rises \(\mathcal{E}\) across the battery and falls by \(IR\) across each resistor; ideal wires are level. The total rise equals the total fall.
Loops with two sources
The loop rule is most valuable when sources oppose or aid each other. Choose a direction of travel, and include every battery with its sign. For a loop with two batteries of emfs \(\mathcal{E}_1\) and \(\mathcal{E}_2\) that oppose each other in a loop of total resistance \(R\), the current is \((\mathcal{E}_1 - \mathcal{E}_2)/R\) in the direction set by the larger. (The CED does not assess circuits with batteries of different potential differences connected in parallel; series loops like these are fine.)
Figure 11.7c Opposing batteries in one loop. The larger emf sets the direction of the current. The loop rule includes each battery with its sign, and the smaller battery is charged by the current that flows through it.
Worked example · one source, two resistors
A 9.0 V battery drives a current through 10 \(\Omega\) and 20 \(\Omega\) resistors in series. Use the loop rule to find the current and the potential difference across each resistor.
Loop equation (going around with the current, starting at the negative terminal). \(+9.0 - I(10) - I(20) = 0\).
Solve. \(I = 9.0/30 = 0.30\) A.
Drops. \(\Delta V_{10} = (0.30)(10) = 3.0\) V and \(\Delta V_{20} = (0.30)(20) = 6.0\) V, which add to 9.0 V.
Worked example · two opposing batteries
A 12 V battery and a 6.0 V battery are connected in a single loop with their positive terminals toward each other, along with 10 \(\Omega\) and 20 \(\Omega\) resistors. Find the current and its direction.
Assume the current runs in the direction the 12 V battery drives it. Going that way: \(+12 - I(10) - I(20) - 6.0 = 0\). (The 6.0 V battery is traversed against its own emf, a drop.)
Solve. \(I = (12 - 6.0)/30 = 0.20\) A, in the direction the 12 V battery drives. The 6.0 V battery is being charged, since the current goes into its positive terminal.
Exam focus
Rule. \(\sum\Delta V = 0\) around any closed loop; it expresses conservation of energy.
Signs. Battery − to +: \(+\mathcal{E}\). Resistor with the current: \(-IR\); against it: \(+IR\).
Negative current. The real current runs opposite your assumed direction; keep the magnitude.
Graph. Potential rises by \(\mathcal{E}\) across the battery, falls by \(IR\) across each resistor, is level along ideal wires.
Check. Rises equal drops.
Practice
A 6.0 V battery is connected in a loop with 4.0 \(\Omega\) and 8.0 \(\Omega\) resistors in series. Write the loop equation and find the current.
Show answer
\(6.0 - I(4.0) - I(8.0) = 0\), so \(I = 6.0/12 = 0.50\) A.
In the circuit of problem 1, what is the potential difference across the 8.0 \(\Omega\) resistor?
Show answer
\(IR = (0.50)(8.0) = 4.0\) V.
A student applies the loop rule and finds \(I = -0.40\) A. What does the sign mean?
Show answer
The current is 0.40 A in the direction opposite to the direction assumed. The magnitude is correct.
A 15 V battery and a 5.0 V battery are in a series loop with their negative terminals joined (so they oppose), and a total resistance of 20 \(\Omega\). Find the current.
Show answer
\(I = (15 - 5.0)/20 = 0.50\) A, in the direction driven by the 15 V battery.
On a graph of potential around a simple loop, one resistor's step down is twice another's. What does this say about the resistors?
Show answer
They carry the same current in series, and \(\Delta V = IR\), so the resistor with the larger step has twice the resistance.
Explain why the loop rule is a statement of conservation of energy.
Show answer
A charge that makes a complete trip around a loop returns to its starting point with the same potential energy, so the net change \(q\sum\Delta V\) must be zero. The energy the source gives the charge equals the energy dissipated in the resistors.
The loop rule applies conservation of energy. Kirchhoff's second rule applies conservation of charge, and it governs what happens where wires meet. A water pipe that splits into two carries away as much water per second as comes in, because water does not pile up at the fork. Charge in a circuit behaves the same way: whatever flows into a junction per second must flow out. This sounds obvious, but combined with the loop rule it lets us solve circuits of any complexity. This lesson states the junction rule, uses it to find unknown currents, and puts the two rules together on a two-loop circuit.
Learning objective · 11.7.A
Describe a circuit or elements of a circuit by applying Kirchhoff's junction rule.
Required content · EK 11.7.A
Kirchhoff's junction rule is a consequence of the conservation of electric charge.
Kirchhoff's junction rule states that the total amount of charge entering a junction per unit time must equal the total amount of charge exiting that junction per unit time: \(\sum I_{in} = \sum I_{out}\).
The rule
A junction is a point where three or more wires meet. In steady state, charge does not accumulate at a junction: the net charge there is constant, so the charge that arrives each second equals the charge that leaves each second:
\[ \sum I_{in} = \sum I_{out}. \]
The rule does not depend on the type of elements on the wires, only on the conservation of charge. It is the reason the parallel-resistor rule \(I = I_1 + I_2\) holds, and it is why the current in a series circuit is the same everywhere: a point with one wire in and one wire out is a junction with a single current on each side.
To apply the rule, draw an arrow on each wire for the current, guessing a direction if you do not know it. Write one equation for each junction. Remember that a negative result means the current runs the other way. For a circuit with \(N\) junctions you can write \(N - 1\) independent junction equations, because the last one adds no information.
Figure 11.8a The junction rule. Charge entering a junction per second equals charge leaving per second: \(3.0\ \text{A} = 1.2\ \text{A} + I_3\), so \(I_3 = 1.8\) A.
Using both rules together
Many circuits need both rules. The procedure is: (1) label the current in each branch with an assumed direction; (2) write the junction equation or equations; (3) write a loop equation for each independent loop (use as many loops as you need unknowns); (4) solve the simultaneous equations. When the circuit has only one source, you can also use the equivalent-resistance method of Lesson 11.5, and the two methods must agree, which is a good check.
Figure 11.8b Using both rules. Label a current in each branch, write the junction equation and one loop equation per independent loop, and solve. The answers agree with the equivalent-resistance method: \(R_{eq} = 8.0\ \Omega\), \(I = 1.5\) A.
Worked example · unknown branch current
A current of 3.0 A flows into a junction. 1.2 A leaves through one wire. What is the current in the third wire, and which way does it flow?
Junction rule. \(I_{in} = I_{out}\), so \(3.0 = 1.2 + I_3\), giving \(I_3 = 1.8\) A, out of the junction.
Worked example · both rules
An ideal 12 V battery is connected to a 4.0 \(\Omega\) resistor in series with a parallel pair of 12 \(\Omega\) and 6.0 \(\Omega\) resistors. Find every current.
Unknowns. \(I\) (main branch, through the 4.0 \(\Omega\)), \(I_2\) (through 12 \(\Omega\)), \(I_3\) (through 6.0 \(\Omega\)).
Loop 2 (through both parallel resistors, no source). \(+12I_2 - 6.0I_3 = 0\), so \(I_3 = 2I_2\).
Solve. \(I = I_2 + 2I_2 = 3I_2\). Then \(12 - 12I_2 - 12I_2 = 0\) gives \(I_2 = 0.50\) A, \(I_3 = 1.0\) A and \(I = 1.5\) A.
Check by equivalent resistance. \(R_p = (12)(6)/18 = 4.0\ \Omega\), \(R_{eq} = 8.0\ \Omega\), \(I = 12/8.0 = 1.5\) A. The two methods agree.
Exam focus
Rule. \(\sum I_{in} = \sum I_{out}\) at any junction; conservation of charge.
Method. Label currents, write junction and loop equations, solve; negative means reversed.
Count. You need as many independent equations as unknown currents.
Check. Branch currents add up to the main current; compare with the equivalent-resistance method.
Why series current is uniform. One wire in, one wire out.
Practice
Three wires meet at a junction. Currents of 2.0 A and 3.5 A flow in. What flows out in the third wire?
Show answer
5.5 A out of the junction.
A 6.0 V battery is across a 12 \(\Omega\) and a 4.0 \(\Omega\) resistor in parallel. Find the current drawn from the battery.
Show answer
Branch currents: \(6.0/12 = 0.50\) A and \(6.0/4.0 = 1.5\) A. By the junction rule the battery current is \(0.50 + 1.5 = 2.0\) A.
In the worked circuit, what is the potential difference across the parallel pair, and what is the power in the 4.0 \(\Omega\) resistor?
Show answer
\(\Delta V = (12)(0.50) = 6.0\) V (or \((6.0)(1.0)\)). \(P = I^{2}R = (1.5)^{2}(4.0) = 9.0\) W.
A junction has currents 4.0 A in and the solution of your equations gives \(-1.0\) A for one outgoing branch. What does that mean?
Show answer
That branch actually carries 1.0 A into the junction, opposite to the direction assumed. The sign of an unknown current only reflects the guess.
Why is the current the same at every point of a series circuit?
Show answer
Each point is effectively a junction with one wire in and one wire out; by conservation of charge the current in equals the current out.
A parallel branch of 8.0 \(\Omega\) carries 0.75 A. A second branch in parallel carries 1.5 A. What is the second resistor's value and the total current?
Show answer
The potential difference is \((0.75)(8.0) = 6.0\) V, so \(R = 6.0/1.5 = 4.0\ \Omega\). The total current is \(0.75 + 1.5 = 2.25\) A.
In Lesson 10.9 a single capacitor was a pair of plates holding charge in proportion to the potential difference. Real devices contain many capacitors: a camera flash, a touch screen, a radio tuner. They are often connected to each other, and the question is the same as for resistors: can the group be replaced by one equivalent capacitor? It can, but the rules turn out to be the reverse of the resistor rules, and it pays to see why. In parallel, capacitors act like one bigger capacitor with more plate area, so their capacitances add. In series, the charge must be the same on every capacitor and the potential differences add, which gives the reciprocal rule.
Learning objective · 11.8.A
Describe the equivalent capacitance of multiple capacitors.
Required content · EK 11.8.A
A collection of capacitors in a circuit may be analyzed as though it were a single capacitor with an equivalent capacitance \(C_{eq}\).
The inverse of the equivalent capacitance of a set of capacitors connected in series is equal to the sum of the inverses of the individual capacitances: \(1/C_{eq} = \sum 1/C_i\). The equivalent capacitance of capacitors in series is less than the capacitance of the smallest capacitor.
The equivalent capacitance of a set of capacitors in parallel is the sum of the individual capacitances: \(C_{eq} = \sum C_i\).
As a result of conservation of charge, each of the capacitors in series must have the same magnitude of charge on each plate.
Capacitors in parallel
Capacitors connected between the same two points have the same potential difference \(\Delta V\) across each, since each plate pair is joined to the same two terminals. Each stores a charge \(Q_i = C_i\Delta V\), and the total charge the combination holds is the sum \(Q = \sum Q_i = (\sum C_i)\,\Delta V\). Comparing with \(Q = C_{eq}\Delta V\):
\[ C_{eq} = C_1 + C_2 + C_3 + \cdots \]
This makes physical sense: connecting capacitors in parallel is like joining their plates into larger ones, so the total plate area, and with it the capacitance, adds. The equivalent capacitance is larger than any individual one.
Capacitors in series
In a series chain, the capacitors are connected end to end, and the inner plates between neighbors are not connected to anything else. They are electrically isolated, so the charge they hold must stay zero in total: a plate that gains \(+Q\) leaves \(-Q\) on the facing plate of its neighbor. Therefore, by conservation of charge, every capacitor in a series chain has the same magnitude of charge \(Q\) on each plate, and this equals the charge of the equivalent capacitor. The potential differences add, \(\Delta V = \Delta V_1 + \Delta V_2 + \cdots = Q/C_1 + Q/C_2 + \cdots\), so
\[ \frac{1}{C_{eq}} = \frac{1}{C_1} + \frac{1}{C_2} + \frac{1}{C_3} + \cdots \]
The equivalent capacitance of a series chain is smaller than the smallest capacitor. (For instance, adding capacitors in series is like increasing the plate separation, which reduces capacitance.) The capacitor with the smallest capacitance gets the largest share of the potential difference, since \(\Delta V_i = Q/C_i\).
Figure 11.9a Capacitors in series and parallel across a 12 V battery. In series the reciprocals add and the charge is shared; in parallel the capacitances add and the potential difference is shared.
Putting the rules to work
The procedure mirrors that for resistors: reduce a series or parallel group to one capacitor, redraw, repeat, and then work back out. The shared quantities are reversed: for capacitors in parallel the potential difference is shared and the charges add; in series the charge is shared and the potential differences add. The energy stored in any capacitor is \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^{2}\), and the energy of a combination is the sum of the energies in the individual capacitors (equivalently, \(\tfrac{1}{2}C_{eq}(\Delta V)^{2}\) for the whole). Do not confuse the rules with those for resistors: the parallel rule for capacitors looks like the series rule for resistors, and vice versa.
Figure 11.9b Sharing in the two connections. In series the same charge appears on each capacitor and the smallest capacitor has the largest potential difference. In parallel each has the same potential difference and the largest capacitor holds the most charge.
Worked example · three capacitors
Capacitors of 2.0 \(\mu\)F, 3.0 \(\mu\)F and 6.0 \(\mu\)F are connected (a) in parallel and (b) in series across a 12 V battery. Find \(C_{eq}\) and the charge on each capacitor.
(a) Parallel. \(C_{eq} = 2.0 + 3.0 + 6.0 = 11\ \mu\)F. Each has 12 V: \(Q_1 = (2.0)(12) = 24\ \mu\)C, \(Q_2 = (3.0)(12) = 36\ \mu\)C, \(Q_3 = (6.0)(12) = 72\ \mu\)C. The total is 132 \(\mu\)C, which equals \(C_{eq}\Delta V = (11)(12)\).
(b) Series. \(1/C_{eq} = 1/2.0 + 1/3.0 + 1/6.0 = (3 + 2 + 1)/6 = 1.0\ \mu\text{F}^{-1}\), so \(C_{eq} = 1.0\ \mu\)F, smaller than 2.0 \(\mu\)F as it must be. The charge on each is \(Q = C_{eq}\Delta V = 12\ \mu\)C.
Potential differences (series). \(\Delta V_i = Q/C_i = 6.0,\ 4.0\) and \(2.0\) V, which add to 12 V. The smallest capacitor has the largest potential difference.
Worked example · energy stored
What is the energy stored in the 1.0 \(\mu\)F equivalent capacitor of part (b)?
Energy. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}C_{eq}(\Delta V)^{2} = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.0\times10^{-6})(12)^{2} = 7.2\times10^{-5}\) J. The same value is found by adding \(\tfrac{1}{2}Q\Delta V_i\) for the three capacitors: \(\tfrac{1}{2}(12\times10^{-6})(6.0 + 4.0 + 2.0) = 7.2\times10^{-5}\) J.
Exam focus
Parallel. Same \(\Delta V\); charges add; \(C_{eq} = \sum C_i\) (larger than any one).
Series. Same \(Q\); potential differences add; \(1/C_{eq} = \sum 1/C_i\) (smaller than any one).
Reverse of resistors. Capacitors add in parallel; resistors add in series.
Find the equivalent capacitance of the same two capacitors in parallel.
Show answer
\(4.0 + 12 = 16\ \mu\)F.
The series pair in problem 1 is connected to a 16 V battery. What is the charge on each capacitor and the potential difference across the 12 \(\mu\)F capacitor?
Show answer
\(Q = C_{eq}\Delta V = (3.0)(16) = 48\ \mu\)C on each. \(\Delta V_{12} = Q/C = 48/12 = 4.0\) V (and 12 V across the 4.0 \(\mu\)F).
Two identical capacitors are connected in series. How does \(C_{eq}\) compare with \(C\)?
Show answer
\(1/C_{eq} = 2/C\), so \(C_{eq} = C/2\).
Three 6.0 \(\mu\)F capacitors are in parallel across 9.0 V. What is the total charge and the total energy stored?
Show answer
Why do the capacitors in a series chain all hold the same charge?
Show answer
The plates between neighboring capacitors are connected only to each other, so their net charge cannot change. Charge \(+Q\) on one means \(-Q\) on the facing plate; this holds all along the chain, so each capacitor holds \(Q\).
A camera flash takes a couple of seconds to "charge up" and then releases its energy in a thousandth of a second. A turn signal blinks, a pacemaker paces, and a touch screen counts the time a capacitor takes to charge. All use a resistor and a capacitor together. The resistor limits how fast charge can flow, and the capacitor stores it, so the capacitor charges or discharges gradually instead of at once. The time that process takes is set by the product of the resistance and the capacitance. On the AP Physics 2 exam these circuits are described qualitatively: you should give the initial and final states mathematically and describe in words and graphs what happens in between.
Learning objective · 11.8.B
Describe the behavior of a circuit containing combinations of resistors and capacitors.
Required content · EK 11.8.B
The time constant \(\tau = RC\) is a significant feature of an RC circuit and a measure of how quickly the capacitor will charge or discharge. For a charging capacitor, it is the time required for the capacitor's charge to increase from zero to approximately 63 percent of its final value; for a discharging capacitor, it is the time for the charge to fall from fully charged to approximately 37 percent of its initial value.
The potential difference across a capacitor and the current in its branch each change over time but reach a steady state after a long time. Immediately after being placed in a circuit, an uncharged capacitor acts like a wire.
After a long time, a charging capacitor is fully charged, at a maximum potential difference, with zero current in its branch. After a charged capacitor begins discharging, the charge and the stored energy decrease, and the charge, potential difference and current all fall until a steady state is reached.
After times much greater than the time constant, the capacitor and the circuit branch may be modeled using steady-state conditions.
Boundary: descriptions are limited to qualitative descriptions and representations. Students should be able to describe initial and final states mathematically, but are not expected to model the behavior mathematically with respect to time.
Charging a capacitor through a resistor
Connect a battery of emf \(\mathcal{E}\), a resistor \(R\) and an uncharged capacitor \(C\) in series, and close the switch. Apply the loop rule: \(\mathcal{E} = IR + Q/C\). At the instant the switch is closed the capacitor has no charge, so it has no potential difference across it, and \(\mathcal{E} = IR\): the capacitor acts like a wire and the current has its maximum value \(I_0 = \mathcal{E}/R\). As charge accumulates, the capacitor's potential difference \(Q/C\) rises, which leaves less of the emf across the resistor, so the current falls. Eventually the capacitor's potential difference equals the emf, the current is zero, and the capacitor is fully charged with \(Q_{max} = C\mathcal{E}\). In steady state a charged capacitor acts like an open circuit (a break in its branch), and the full emf is across it.
The charge and the capacitor's potential difference rise steeply at first and then level off, approaching their final values asymptotically (they never quite reach them, but get as close as you like). The current does the opposite: it starts at \(\mathcal{E}/R\) and decays toward zero. The stored energy \(\tfrac{1}{2}C(\Delta V)^{2}\) grows as the capacitor charges.
Discharging
Now remove the battery and connect the charged capacitor across the resistor. The capacitor's potential difference drives a current through \(R\), and the charge and stored energy begin to decrease immediately. Applying the loop rule to the capacitor and resistor alone, \(Q/C = IR\), so the initial current is \(I_0 = Q_0/(RC) = \Delta V_0/R\), and as the charge decreases, the potential difference and the current fall together, all approaching zero. The direction of the current is opposite to what it was while the capacitor was charging, because the capacitor is now the source. All the energy originally stored is dissipated as thermal energy in the resistor.
The time constant
How long does this take? The scale is set by the time constant
\[ \tau = RC. \]
A larger resistance restricts the flow so charging is slower; a larger capacitance holds more charge for the same potential difference, so it takes longer to fill. During charging, after one time constant the charge has risen to about 63 percent of its final value; during discharging, after one time constant it has fallen to about 37 percent of its initial value. Because the curves approach their final values asymptotically, after several time constants (five is a good rule of thumb) the capacitor is, for practical purposes, in its steady state, so we may use the steady-state description. Doubling \(R\) or doubling \(C\) doubles the time constant and stretches the graphs horizontally without changing their final levels.
Figure 11.10a An RC circuit. When charging, the battery drives current through \(R\) onto the capacitor; when discharging, the charged capacitor acts as the source and the current decays through the resistor.Figure 11.10b Charging an RC circuit. Both curves approach their final values asymptotically. After one time constant the charge is about 63 percent of its final value; after several time constants the circuit is in its steady state.Figure 11.10c Discharging an RC circuit. The charge, potential difference and current all decay toward zero; after one time constant about 37 percent of the initial charge remains.
Capacitors in circuits with several resistors
The same two limits (a wire at \(t = 0\) if uncharged, an open circuit at long times) let you analyze more complicated circuits without any new equation. At the instant of closing, replace each uncharged capacitor by a wire and analyze the resistors. After a long time, replace each capacitor by a break in the branch, find the potential difference across the break, and that is the capacitor's potential difference. A charged capacitor at \(t = 0\) acts like a battery with emf equal to its potential difference.
Worked example · charging
A 12 V battery is connected through a switch to a 10 k\(\Omega\) resistor in series with an uncharged 100 \(\mu\)F capacitor. Describe the initial and final states and the time scale.
Initial state. The capacitor acts like a wire: \(I_0 = \mathcal{E}/R = 12/(1.0\times10^{4}) = 1.2\) mA, the potential difference across the capacitor is 0, and the resistor has the full 12 V.
Final state. The current is zero, the capacitor has 12 V across it, and \(Q_{max} = C\mathcal{E} = (100\times10^{-6})(12) = 1.2\times10^{-3}\) C. The energy stored is \(\tfrac{1}{2}C\mathcal{E}^{2} = 7.2\times10^{-3}\) J.
Time scale. \(\tau = RC = (1.0\times10^{4})(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 1.0\) s. After 1.0 s the charge is about 63 percent of 1.2 mC, or 0.76 mC; after about 5 s the capacitor is essentially fully charged.
Worked example · discharging
The capacitor above, charged to 1.2 mC, is disconnected from the battery and connected across the same 10 k\(\Omega\) resistor. How long until its charge has fallen to about 37 percent, and what is the charge then?
One time constant. \(\tau = 1.0\) s, and at that time \(Q \approx 0.37(1.2\ \text{mC}) = 0.44\) mC. The initial current is \(\Delta V_0/R = 12/10^{4} = 1.2\) mA, flowing in the direction opposite to that while charging, and it decays together with the charge.
Exam focus
Start. An uncharged capacitor acts like a wire: \(I_0 = \mathcal{E}/R\), \(\Delta V_C = 0\).
Long time. A charged capacitor acts like an open circuit: \(I = 0\), \(\Delta V_C = \mathcal{E}\), \(Q = C\mathcal{E}\).
Time constant. \(\tau = RC\); about 63 percent charged, or 37 percent remaining, after one \(\tau\); steady state after several.
Graphs. Charging: \(Q\) and \(\Delta V_C\) rise toward a limit while \(I\) falls to zero. Discharging: all three fall toward zero.
Method. Use the two limits and the loop rule; no time-dependent equations are needed.
Practice
Find the time constant of a 2.0 k\(\Omega\) resistor and a 50 \(\mu\)F capacitor.
Show answer
\(\tau = RC = (2.0\times10^{3})(50\times10^{-6}) = 0.10\) s.
An uncharged capacitor in series with a 100 \(\Omega\) resistor is connected to a 5.0 V battery. What is the current just after the switch is closed, and what is it after a very long time?
Show answer
Initially the capacitor acts like a wire: \(I = 5.0/100 = 0.050\) A. After a long time the capacitor is fully charged and the current is zero.
The resistance in an RC circuit is doubled. How does the time to charge change, and what happens to the final charge on the capacitor?
Show answer
The time constant doubles, so charging takes twice as long. The final charge \(Q = C\mathcal{E}\) does not depend on \(R\), so it is unchanged.
A capacitor discharges through a resistor. Which of these decrease with time: the charge, the potential difference across the capacitor, the current, the stored energy?
Show answer
All four decrease, approaching zero.
A 100 \(\mu\)F capacitor in an RC circuit is charged by a 6.0 V battery. What is the final charge, and the charge after one time constant of charging?
Show answer
\(Q_{max} = C\mathcal{E} = (100\times10^{-6})(6.0) = 6.0\times10^{-4}\) C. After one time constant, about 63 percent of that, \(3.8\times10^{-4}\) C.
A student connects a charged capacitor to a resistor and says the current is largest at the end because the capacitor is "full." Correct this.
Show answer
When a charged capacitor begins to discharge, its potential difference, and so the current, is greatest at the start. The current decays toward zero as the capacitor empties.
Unit 11 practice · 10 problems
Unit 11 practice: Electric Circuits
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Constant: \(e = 1.60\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}\). Treat batteries
as ideal unless the problem gives an internal resistance. Calculator allowed.
A lamp draws 0.75 A for 2.0 minutes. How much charge passes through it, and how many electrons is that? In which direction do the electrons actually move relative to the conventional current?
Show answer
\(\Delta Q = I\,\Delta t = (0.75\ \text{A})(120\ \text{s}) = 90\ \text{C}\). \(n = \dfrac{90}{1.60\times10^{-19}} \approx 5.6\times10^{20}\) electrons. Electrons drift opposite to conventional current, from the − terminal toward the +.
(a) A nichrome wire (\(\rho = 1.10\times10^{-6}\ \Omega\text{·m}\)) is 1.5 m long with diameter 0.40 mm. Find its resistance. (b) A different wire of resistance 3.0 Ω is stretched to twice its length without changing its volume. Find its new resistance and explain the factor.
Two identical bulbs, 1 and 2, are connected in series to an ideal battery. A third identical bulb is then added in parallel with bulb 2. Bulb 1 becomes
Adding a parallel branch lowers the resistance of the bulb-2 section from \(R\) to \(R/2\), so the total resistance drops from \(2R\) to \(1.5R\) and the battery current rises. All of that current passes through bulb 1, so its power \(I^2R\) rises and it brightens, while bulb 2 dims because it now shares the current and has less voltage across it.
Bulb 1 would dim only if the total current fell, which requires the total resistance to rise. Adding a resistor in parallel always lowers the resistance of that section, so the current goes up, not down.
Bulb 1 would be unchanged only if the battery were a constant-current source. An ideal battery holds the voltage fixed, so any change in total resistance changes the current, and all of it flows through bulb 1.
Bulb 1 sits in the only path from the battery, so it cannot go dark: every bit of current still flows through it. Only a short circuit across bulb 1 itself would darken it.
A 24 V battery is connected to \(R_1 = 6.0\ \Omega\), which then leads to \(R_2 = 12\ \Omega\) and \(R_3 = 4.0\ \Omega\) wired in parallel, returning to the battery. Find the battery current, the current through each resistor, and the power dissipated in \(R_3\).
Resistors of resistance \(R\), \(2R\), and \(3R\) are connected to the same ideal battery, first all in parallel and then all in series. For each arrangement, rank the resistors by power dissipated, greatest to least, and justify in one sentence each.
Show answer
Parallel: same \(\Delta V\) across each, so \(P = (\Delta V)^2/R\) is largest for the smallest resistance: \(R \gt 2R \gt 3R\). Series: same \(I\) through each, so \(P = I^2R\) is largest for the largest resistance: \(3R \gt 2R \gt R\). Pick the power formula whose shared quantity is the one held in common.
Three branches join a top node to a bottom node. Left branch: a 12 V battery (+ up) in series with 3.0 Ω. Middle branch: 6.0 Ω. Right branch: a 6.0 V battery (+ up) in series with 3.0 Ω. Find the three currents, and interpret any negative result.
Show answer
Guess \(I_1\) up the left, \(I_3\) up the right, \(I_2\) down the middle; junction: \(I_1 + I_3 = I_2\). Left loop: \(12 - 3.0I_1 - 6.0I_2 = 0\). Right loop: \(6.0 - 3.0I_3 - 6.0I_2 = 0\). So \(I_1 = 4 - 2I_2\) and \(I_3 = 2 - 2I_2\); the junction rule gives \(6 - 4I_2 = I_2\), \(I_2 = 1.2\ \text{A}\). Then \(I_1 = 1.6\ \text{A}\) and \(I_3 = -0.40\ \text{A}\). The minus sign means 0.40 A actually flows down the right branch: the 12 V battery is pushing current backward through the 6 V battery, charging it. Check left loop: \(12 - 4.8 - 7.2 = 0\). ✓
A 4.0 μF and a 12 μF capacitor are connected in series across 24 V. Find the charge on each and the voltage across each, and the total energy stored. Then find the total charge drawn from the battery if the same two capacitors are placed in parallel across 24 V.
A 9.0 V battery is in series with \(R_1 = 3.0\ \Omega\), which leads to \(R_2 = 6.0\ \Omega\) and an uncharged 10 μF capacitor connected in parallel with each other. The switch closes at \(t = 0\). Find the battery current at \(t = 0\) and at steady state, and the final charge on the capacitor. Explain in words why the capacitor behaves differently at the two moments.
Show answer
At \(t = 0\) the capacitor is uncharged, so there is no voltage across it: it acts like a wire and shorts out \(R_2\). \(I_0 = \dfrac{9.0}{3.0} = 3.0\ \text{A}\). At steady state no more charge flows onto it, so it acts like an open switch and the current runs through \(R_1\) and \(R_2\) in series: \(I_\infty = \dfrac{9.0}{9.0} = 1.0\ \text{A}\). The capacitor sits across \(R_2\): \(V_C = (1.0)(6.0) = 6.0\ \text{V}\), \(Q = CV_C = (10\times10^{-6})(6.0) = 60\ \mu\text{C}\). In between, charge builds up on the plates, its voltage grows, and the current through \(R_1\) falls from 3.0 A to 1.0 A.
A battery's terminal voltage is 5.7 V when it delivers 1.0 A and 5.1 V when it delivers 3.0 A. (a) Find its emf and internal resistance. (b) It is then connected to a 1.2 Ω resistor. Find the current, the terminal voltage, the power delivered to the resistor, and the power wasted inside the battery.
Show answer
(a) \(V = \varepsilon - Ir\). Slope of \(V\) versus \(I\): \(\dfrac{5.1 - 5.7}{3.0 - 1.0} = -0.30\ \text{V/A}\), so \(r = 0.30\ \Omega\); \(\varepsilon = 5.7 + (1.0)(0.30) = 6.0\ \text{V}\). (b) \(I = \dfrac{\varepsilon}{R + r} = \dfrac{6.0}{1.5} = 4.0\ \text{A}\); \(V_{\text{terminal}} = 6.0 - (4.0)(0.30) = 4.8\ \text{V}\); \(P_{\text{load}} = I^2R = (16)(1.2) = 19\ \text{W}\); \(P_{\text{internal}} = I^2r = (16)(0.30) = 4.8\ \text{W}\). The battery supplies 24 W and delivers 80% of it.
Lesson 12.1 · Unit 12 · CED topic 12.1 (fields and dipoles)
A compass needle swings to point roughly north, a refrigerator magnet clings to the door, and an MRI scanner uses a magnet strong enough to pull a wheelchair across the room. All are magnetic effects, and they are described by a field, just as electric effects are. But the magnetic field is different from the electric field in an important way: you can isolate a positive charge, but you can never isolate a north pole. This lesson introduces the magnetic field as a vector field, the dipole that produces it, and the rules for its direction and for how magnets interact.
Learning objectives · 12.1.A and 12.1.B
Describe the properties of a magnetic field. Describe the magnetic behavior of a material as a result of the configuration of magnetic dipoles in the material.
Required content · EK 12.1.A and 12.1.B (part)
A magnetic field is a vector field that can be used to determine the magnetic force exerted on moving electric charges, electric currents or magnetic materials. Magnetic fields can be produced by magnetic dipoles or combinations of dipoles, but never by monopoles. Magnetic dipoles have north and south polarity.
A magnetic field is a vector quantity and can be represented using vector field maps. Magnetic field lines form closed loops. In a bar magnet the external field points away from one end (defined as the north pole) and returns to the other end (the south pole).
Magnetic dipoles result from the circular or rotational motion of electric charges; in magnetic materials, this can be the motion of electrons.
No magnetic north pole is ever found in isolation from a south pole: if a bar magnet is broken in half, both halves are dipoles. Magnetic poles of the same polarity repel; poles of opposite polarity attract. The magnitude of the field from a dipole decreases with distance from the dipole.
A magnetic dipole, such as a compass, placed in a magnetic field will tend to align with the field.
The magnetic field
The magnetic field \(\vec{B}\) is a vector at each point in space that describes the magnetic force that would act on a moving charge, a current, or a magnetic material placed there. Its SI unit is the tesla (T), where \(1\ \text{T} = 1\ \text{N}/(\text{A}\cdot\text{m})\). For scale: the Earth's field at the surface is about \(5\times10^{-5}\) T; a refrigerator magnet is about \(5\times10^{-3}\) T; an MRI magnet is 1.5 to 3 T. Like the electric field, \(\vec{B}\) is drawn with field lines: the direction of the line at each point is the direction of the field, and where the lines are closer together the field is stronger. Unlike electric field lines, magnetic field lines never start or end: they form closed loops.
Dipoles and poles
The simplest source of a magnetic field is a magnetic dipole, which has a north pole and a south pole. A bar magnet is a dipole. Outside the magnet, the field lines leave the end called north, curve around, and enter the end called south; inside the magnet they continue from south to north, closing the loop. A compass needle is a small dipole, and it aligns with the field, with its north end pointing along \(\vec{B}\). That is why a compass points toward the Earth's geographic north: the Earth is like a big dipole whose magnetic south pole is located near the geographic north pole. The interaction between two magnets follows the rule that like poles repel and unlike poles attract. The field of a dipole weakens with distance; far from a small dipole, the magnitude falls off quickly (as the inverse cube of distance, which is not required here).
No magnetic monopole, an isolated north or south pole, has ever been found. Break a bar magnet in half and you do not get a north half and a south half; you get two smaller magnets, each with its own north and south pole, and the same happens however small the pieces are. This is the main difference from electricity, where isolated positive and negative charges exist, and it is the reason magnetic field lines form closed loops instead of starting on a "magnetic charge."
Figure 12.1a Field lines of a bar magnet. Outside the magnet they run from the north pole to the south pole; inside, from south to north, so they form closed loops. The field is strongest where the lines are closest, near the poles.
Where dipoles come from
Every magnetic dipole results from moving charge. A current loop is a magnetic dipole: it produces the same pattern of field as a bar magnet, with the north pole on the side from which the field emerges (found with the right-hand rule in Lesson 12.5). In atoms, the dipole arises from the motion of electrons, which both orbit the nucleus and have an intrinsic property (spin) that makes each electron a tiny dipole. Whether a large piece of material is magnetic depends on how these atomic dipoles are arranged, which is the subject of the next lesson. In every case, a dipole in an external field experiences a torque that tends to align it with the field, which is how a compass works.
Figure 12.1b Forces between magnets. Unlike poles attract and like poles repel, just as with charges, but poles come only in pairs: every magnet is a dipole.
Worked example · reading a field map
The figure shows field lines of a bar magnet. A compass is placed at a point near the north end of the magnet, outside it. In which direction does its north pole point, and where is the field strongest?
Direction. The field outside the magnet leaves the north pole, so the compass north end points along the field line at that point, away from the magnet's north pole (and curving around toward its south pole).
Strength. The lines are closest together near the poles, so the field is strongest there and weakens with distance.
Worked example · breaking a magnet
A student cuts a bar magnet in half and expects to find a "north piece" and a "south piece." What is found, and why?
Result. Each half is a complete magnet with its own north and south poles; cutting again does the same. No isolated pole appears.
Reason. Magnetism comes from circulating charge (dipoles), and a dipole always has two poles. Magnetic monopoles do not exist as far as we know.
Exam focus
Field. A vector field in teslas; lines close on themselves; denser lines mean a stronger field.
Direction. Outside a magnet lines go from north to south; inside, south to north; a compass north end points along \(\vec{B}\).
Poles. Like poles repel, unlike attract; no monopoles, so every magnet is a dipole.
Origin. Dipoles come from circular or rotational motion of charge.
Alignment. A dipole in a field tends to line up with it.
Practice
Two bar magnets are placed with their north poles facing each other. Do they attract or repel?
Show answer
They repel: like poles repel.
How do magnetic field lines differ from electric field lines of point charges?
Show answer
Magnetic field lines form closed loops with no beginning or end, since no magnetic monopoles exist; electric field lines of point charges start on positive charges and end on negative charges.
A magnet is cut into four pieces. How many north poles and south poles are there?
Show answer
Four of each: every piece is a complete dipole with its own north and south pole.
Inside a bar magnet, in which direction does the magnetic field point?
Show answer
From the south pole toward the north pole, so the field lines form closed loops with the outside part.
Why does a compass needle point in a definite direction?
Show answer
The needle is a magnetic dipole that tends to align with the magnetic field of the Earth, so its north end points along the field, roughly toward geographic north.
On a field map, the lines near point A are twice as close together as near point B. What does this say about the field?
Show answer
The field is stronger at A, about twice as strong as at B.
Lesson 12.2 · Unit 12 · CED topic 12.1 (materials and permeability)
A paper clip is not a magnet, but it is attracted to one, and after it has touched a magnet for a while it can pick up another clip. A strip of aluminum foil ignores a magnet entirely, and a tiny frog, in a strong enough field, can be levitated. These differences come from how the atoms of each material respond to an external magnetic field. All materials respond; the response is large in iron and tiny in water or copper, and it can be in either direction. This lesson explains the three kinds of magnetic behavior, the idea of permeability that measures it, and the Earth's own dipole field.
Learning objectives · 12.1.B (part) and 12.1.C
Describe the magnetic behavior of a material as a result of the configuration of magnetic dipoles in the material. Describe the magnetic permeability of a material.
Required content · EK 12.1.B (part) and 12.1.C
Permanent magnetism and induced magnetism are system properties that both result from the alignment of magnetic dipoles within a system.
A material's composition influences its magnetic behavior in an external field. Ferromagnetic materials such as iron, nickel and cobalt can be permanently magnetized by an external field that causes the alignment of magnetic domains or atomic dipoles.
Paramagnetic materials such as aluminum, titanium and magnesium interact weakly with an external field: their dipoles do not remain aligned after the field is removed.
All materials have the property of diamagnetism, in that their electronic structure creates a usually weak alignment of dipole moments opposite the external field.
Earth's magnetic field may be approximated as a magnetic dipole.
Magnetic permeability is a measure of the amount of magnetization in a material in response to an external field. Free space has a constant value, the vacuum permeability \(\mu_0\), which appears in equations for magnetic relationships. The permeability of matter differs from that of free space, arises from the matter's composition and arrangement, and is not a constant for a material: it varies with temperature, orientation and the strength of the external field.
Domains and ferromagnetism
In a ferromagnetic material (iron, nickel, cobalt and some alloys) neighboring atoms interact so strongly that their dipoles line up in small regions called magnetic domains, each containing enormous numbers of atoms. In an unmagnetized piece of iron the domains point in random directions and their fields cancel, so the piece has no net field. When an external field is applied, the domains aligned with it grow at the expense of the others and some rotate toward the field, so the piece becomes strongly magnetized in the direction of the field. This is induced magnetism, and it explains why a magnet attracts an unmagnetized nail: the nail's end nearest the north pole becomes a south pole, and unlike poles attract. In some materials the aligned domains stay aligned after the external field is removed; the piece is then a permanent magnet. Heating or hammering a magnet can scramble the domains and destroy its magnetism, and above a characteristic temperature a ferromagnet loses its ferromagnetism altogether. Both induced and permanent magnetism are properties of the whole system of dipoles: they result from the alignment of many atomic dipoles.
Figure 12.2a Magnetic domains in a ferromagnet. Each box is a domain with its dipoles aligned. Random domains cancel; an external field aligns them and the material becomes strongly magnetized.
Paramagnetism and diamagnetism
In a paramagnetic material (aluminum, titanium, magnesium) the atoms have dipoles but they interact only weakly with each other. An external field tends to align them, so the material is weakly attracted to a magnet, but thermal motion scrambles them again, so when the field is removed the alignment is lost and the material is not a permanent magnet. Diamagnetism is present in every material: the external field slightly alters the motion of the electrons so that the induced dipoles point opposite the field, and the material is weakly repelled. In substances with no other magnetic behavior (copper, water, graphite, most organic matter) diamagnetism is the only effect, and it is thousands of times weaker than ferromagnetism; in paramagnets and ferromagnets it is overwhelmed. Strong magnets can still make the repulsion visible, for example by levitating a small piece of graphite or a frog.
Permeability
The extent to which a material becomes magnetized and enhances (or weakens) the field is measured by its magnetic permeability, \(\mu\). In free space (vacuum, and to a good approximation air) the permeability has a fixed value, the vacuum permeability \(\mu_0 = 4\pi\times10^{-7}\ \text{T}\cdot\text{m}/\text{A}\), which appears in the equations for the field of a current (Lesson 12.5). The permeability of matter, \(\mu\), is different from \(\mu_0\): it is a little greater than \(\mu_0\) for paramagnets, a little less for diamagnets, and hundreds to many thousands of times greater for ferromagnets. Unlike \(\mu_0\), the permeability of a material is not a constant: it depends on temperature, on the orientation of the sample and on the strength of the external field (a ferromagnet saturates when all its domains are aligned). This is why an iron core inside a coil of wire multiplies the field of the coil many times, which is the idea behind electromagnets, transformers and the cores of electric motors.
The Earth's magnetic field
The Earth's field is well approximated as that of a magnetic dipole tilted about \(11^\circ\) from the rotation axis, produced by electric currents in the molten iron of the outer core. Field lines leave the surface in the southern hemisphere and re-enter in the northern; the pole of the Earth in the north is therefore a magnetic south pole of the dipole (it attracts the north poles of compasses). The field is about \(5\times10^{-5}\) T at the surface and is weaker near the equator than near the poles. Animals, including birds and sea turtles, use it for navigation.
Figure 12.2b The Earth's field approximated as a dipole. The field lines enter the Earth near the geographic north, so that region behaves as a magnetic south pole, which is why the north end of a compass points toward it.
Worked example · why a magnet picks up a nail
An unmagnetized iron nail is brought near the north pole of a magnet. Explain the attraction and what happens when the nail is withdrawn.
Induction. The field of the magnet aligns the nail's domains, so the nail is magnetized with its near end a south pole and its far end a north pole.
Force. The near end is a south pole, attracted by the magnet's north pole; the far end is farther away and its repulsion is weaker (the field decreases with distance), so the net force is attractive.
Withdrawn. Iron that is "soft" loses most of its magnetization once the field is gone, because thermal motion and the random-pointing domains restore disorder; a hardened steel nail would retain more.
Worked example · classifying materials
A sample is weakly pushed away from either pole of a strong magnet. A second sample is weakly attracted but is not attracted at all after the magnet is removed. Classify each.
First sample. Weak repulsion means the induced dipoles oppose the field: diamagnetic.
Second sample. Weak attraction, with no lasting alignment: paramagnetic (a ferromagnet would be strongly attracted and might stay magnetized).
Exam focus
Ferromagnetic. Strong attraction; domains align; may be permanently magnetized (iron, nickel, cobalt).
Paramagnetic. Weak attraction; alignment disappears when the field is removed (aluminum, titanium, magnesium).
Diamagnetic. Weak repulsion; present in all materials; usually only visible when nothing else acts.
Permeability. \(\mu_0 = 4\pi\times10^{-7}\) T\(\cdot\)m/A for free space; for matter it is not a constant.
Earth. Approximately a dipole; the geographic north pole is near a magnetic south pole.
Practice
Why is an unmagnetized piece of iron not a magnet even though it is made of atomic dipoles?
Show answer
Its domains point in random directions, so their fields cancel and the net field is nearly zero.
What is the difference between induced and permanent magnetism?
Show answer
Induced magnetism exists only while an external field aligns the dipoles. In permanent magnetism the dipoles stay aligned after the external field is removed.
Aluminum is brought near a strong magnet. Is it attracted or repelled, and how strongly?
Show answer
Aluminum is paramagnetic: it is very weakly attracted, and the effect disappears when the magnet is removed.
A compass needle near the Earth's geographic north points toward that pole. What kind of magnetic pole must be located there?
Show answer
A magnetic south pole of the Earth's dipole, because the north end of the needle is attracted to it.
Why does an iron core greatly strengthen the field of a coil of wire?
Show answer
The iron is ferromagnetic with a permeability thousands of times that of free space. Its domains align with the coil's field and add their own field to it.
A magnet loses its magnetism when it is heated strongly or hammered. Explain.
Show answer
Thermal agitation and mechanical shock rearrange the domains into random directions, so their fields cancel and the net magnetization disappears.
A stationary charge feels no force from a magnetic field. A charge moving through the field does, and the force is unlike any other you have met: it is perpendicular to the velocity and perpendicular to the field. The beam of electrons in an old television tube is bent by magnets, the aurora is the glow of charged particles from the Sun swept along the Earth's field lines, and every electric motor depends on this force. This lesson also tells the other half of the story: a moving charge is itself a source of a magnetic field. Together they show that magnetism is the interaction between moving charges.
Learning objectives · 12.2.A and 12.2.B
Describe the magnetic field produced by moving charged objects. Describe the force exerted on moving charged objects by a magnetic field.
Required content · EK 12.2.A and 12.2.B
A single moving charged object produces a magnetic field. The field at a point depends on the object's velocity and on the distance between the point and the object. Its direction is perpendicular to both the velocity and the position vector from the object to that point, and can be found with the right-hand rule. Its magnitude is a maximum when the velocity and position vectors are perpendicular.
Magnetic forces describe interactions between moving charged objects. A magnetic field may exert a force on a charged object moving in it.
The magnitude of the force is proportional to the magnitude of the charge, the speed, and the magnitude of the field, and depends on the angle between the velocity and field vectors: \(F_B = |q|vB\sin\theta\). The direction is perpendicular to both the field and the velocity, as given by the right-hand rule.
In a region containing both a magnetic field and an electric field, a moving charge experiences independent forces from each field.
The Hall effect describes the potential difference created in a conductor by an external magnetic field that has a component perpendicular to the direction of the charges moving in the conductor.
Boundary: quantitative treatment of the magnitude of the magnetic force on a moving charge is limited to angles of 0°, 90° and 180° between the velocity and the field. Qualitative analysis of other angles is permitted.
The magnitude of the force
The magnetic force on a charge \(q\) moving with velocity \(\vec{v}\) in a field \(\vec{B}\) has magnitude
\[ F_B = |q|\,v\,B\sin\theta, \]
where \(\theta\) is the angle between \(\vec{v}\) and \(\vec{B}\). The force is proportional to the charge, the speed and the field, and vanishes if the charge is at rest. Three cases matter. When the velocity is perpendicular to the field (\(\theta = 90^\circ\)) the force is a maximum, \(F_B = |q|vB\). When the velocity is parallel or antiparallel to the field (\(\theta = 0^\circ\) or \(180^\circ\)) the force is zero, since \(\sin\theta = 0\): a charge moving along a field line feels no magnetic force. At other angles, only the component of the velocity perpendicular to the field produces force, and you may reason about it qualitatively (the force is smaller than the maximum).
The direction: the right-hand rule
The force is perpendicular to both \(\vec{v}\) and \(\vec{B}\), that is, perpendicular to the plane that contains them. To find which of the two perpendicular directions it takes, use the right-hand rule for a positive charge: point the fingers of your right hand along \(\vec{v}\), curl them toward \(\vec{B}\) (through the smaller angle), and your extended thumb points along the force. For a negative charge the force is opposite the direction the rule gives. Field directions into and out of the page are drawn with \(\otimes\) (into the page, like the tail of an arrow) and \(\odot\) (out of the page, like the tip).
Because the force is always perpendicular to the velocity, it changes the direction of the velocity but not the speed. A magnetic force therefore does no work on the charge (\(W = F d\cos 90^\circ = 0\)), and it cannot change the kinetic energy of the particle. Only an electric force, or some other force, can.
Figure 12.3a The right-hand rule for the force on a moving charge. For a positive charge, fingers along \(\vec v\), curled toward \(\vec B\), the thumb points along \(\vec F\). A negative charge feels the opposite force; a charge moving along the field feels none.
Electric and magnetic forces together
If both an electric field and a magnetic field are present, the charge feels each force independently and the net force is their vector sum, \(\vec{F} = q\vec{E} + q\vec{v}\times\vec{B}\). The electric force acts whether or not the charge moves, in the direction of \(\vec{E}\) (for a positive charge); the magnetic force acts only if it moves, and perpendicular to \(\vec{v}\). The two can be arranged to cancel, which is the basis of the velocity selector in the next lesson.
Moving charges make magnetic fields
A moving charge also produces a magnetic field. At a point at position \(\vec{r}\) from the charge, the field is perpendicular to both the velocity \(\vec{v}\) and \(\vec{r}\), with direction given by a right-hand rule (for a positive charge: fingers along \(\vec{v}\), curled toward \(\vec{r}\), thumb along \(\vec{B}\)). It is largest where \(\vec{r}\) is perpendicular to \(\vec{v}\), and it is zero straight ahead of or behind the charge. The field depends on the speed and weakens with distance from the charge. Since a current is a stream of moving charges, this is the origin of the field of a wire (Lesson 12.5), and since the force between currents is a force between moving charges, magnetism can be regarded as the force between moving charges.
The Hall effect
Suppose a current flows along a flat conducting strip in a field perpendicular to the strip's face. The moving charge carriers experience the magnetic force and are pushed toward one edge of the strip. That edge becomes charged (with an excess of one sign) and the other edge is left with the opposite sign, so a potential difference appears across the width of the strip. This Hall effect grows until the electric force from the charge separation balances the magnetic force and the carriers go straight again. The sign of the potential difference shows whether the carriers are positive or negative, and its size can be used to measure the field, which is how many magnetic-field sensors (in phones, for example) work.
Figure 12.3b The Hall effect. The magnetic force pushes the moving carriers toward one edge; the charge that collects there creates a potential difference \(V_H\) across the strip, which grows until the electric force balances the magnetic force. Its sign shows whether the carriers are positive or negative.
Worked example · magnitude and direction
A proton moves at \(2.0\times10^{6}\) m/s to the right in a uniform field of 0.50 T directed into the page. Find the force on it.
Magnitude. The velocity is perpendicular to the field, so \(F = qvB = (1.60\times10^{-19})(2.0\times10^{6})(0.50) = 1.6\times10^{-13}\) N.
Direction. Fingers to the right, curled into the page: the thumb points up the page. The force is up.
Acceleration. \(a = F/m = (1.6\times10^{-13})/(1.67\times10^{-27}) = 9.6\times10^{13}\) m/s², huge, but only a sideways deflection because the force stays perpendicular to the velocity.
Worked example · electron and zero force
An electron is moving in the same direction and speed in the same field. What is the force, and what if the electron moves parallel to the field?
Same speed, same field. The magnitude is the same, \(1.6\times10^{-13}\) N, but the charge is negative, so the force is down.
Parallel to the field. \(\theta = 0^\circ\) and \(\sin\theta = 0\), so the force is zero and the electron keeps moving in a straight line.
Exam focus
Force. \(F_B = |q|vB\sin\theta\): maximum at 90°, zero at 0° and 180°; none on a charge at rest.
Direction. Perpendicular to \(\vec{v}\) and \(\vec{B}\); right-hand rule for positive charge, reverse for negative.
Work. The magnetic force does no work: the speed and kinetic energy do not change.
Both fields. The electric and magnetic forces act independently and add as vectors.
Moving charge as a source. Its field is perpendicular to \(\vec{v}\) and \(\vec{r}\); maximum when they are perpendicular.
Hall effect. Magnetic deflection of carriers builds a potential difference across a conductor.
Practice
An alpha particle (charge \(+3.2\times10^{-19}\) C) moves at \(4.0\times10^{5}\) m/s perpendicular to a 0.20 T field. Find the force.
Show answer
\(F = qvB = (3.2\times10^{-19})(4.0\times10^{5})(0.20) = 2.6\times10^{-14}\) N.
A charged particle moves directly along the direction of a magnetic field. What is the magnetic force?
Show answer
Zero, because the angle is 0° and \(\sin 0 = 0\).
A positive charge moves to the right and the field points out of the page. Which way is the force?
Show answer
Fingers right, curled out of the page: the thumb points down. The force is down the page.
A magnetic force acts on a moving charge. Does it change the particle's kinetic energy? Explain.
Show answer
No. The force is always perpendicular to the velocity, so it does no work. It changes only the direction of the velocity.
An electron moving at \(3.0\times10^{6}\) m/s passes through a region with a 0.10 T field at 90°. What is the magnitude of the force?
Show answer
\(F = (1.60\times10^{-19})(3.0\times10^{6})(0.10) = 4.8\times10^{-14}\) N.
A conventional current flows to the right along a flat strip in a field directed into the page. The top edge of the strip is found to be at a lower potential than the bottom edge. Are the charge carriers positive or negative?
Show answer
Whatever their sign, the carriers are pushed toward the top edge: positive carriers moving right are pushed up, and negative carriers moving left (the same conventional current) are also pushed up. The top edge collects the carriers' charge, so a lower potential on top means the carriers are negative, as in a metal.
Lesson 12.4 · Unit 12 · CED topic 12.2 (motion of charged particles)
A force that is always perpendicular to the velocity does something no other force does: it bends the path without changing the speed. That is exactly what is needed for uniform circular motion. A charged particle that enters a uniform magnetic field perpendicular to it travels in a circle, and the size of the circle tells you the particle's momentum and charge. This is the principle of the mass spectrometer, which weighs atoms; of cyclotrons, which accelerate particles for medicine and research; and of the bubble-chamber photographs in which particles leave spiral tracks. With an electric field added to cancel the magnetic force, the same ideas give a velocity selector. This lesson combines the magnetic force of the last lesson with the circular motion you know from mechanics.
Learning objective · 12.2.B (application)
Describe the force exerted on moving charged objects by a magnetic field, and the motion that results.
Required content · EK 12.2.B (applied)
The direction of the force on a moving charge is perpendicular to both the field and the velocity, so the force changes the direction of the velocity but not its magnitude.
In a region containing both a magnetic field and an electric field, a moving charged object will experience independent forces from each field.
Quantitative treatment of the magnitude of the magnetic force is limited to angles of 0°, 90° and 180° between the velocity and the field; qualitative analysis of other angles is permitted.
Circular motion in a magnetic field
Let a particle of charge \(q\) and mass \(m\) enter a uniform field \(B\) with velocity \(v\) perpendicular to the field. The magnetic force \(|q|vB\) is perpendicular to the velocity, so it acts as a centripetal force and the particle moves in a circle in a plane perpendicular to \(\vec{B}\). Newton's second law, \(\sum F = ma_c\), gives
\[ |q|vB = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad r = \frac{mv}{|q|B}. \]
The radius is proportional to the momentum \(mv\) and inversely proportional to the charge and the field. A faster or heavier particle makes a larger circle, a stronger field or larger charge a smaller one. The period is the circumference divided by the speed, \(T = 2\pi r/v = 2\pi m/(|q|B)\), which does not depend on the speed or the radius; this is why a cyclotron can accelerate particles by timing a push each half turn at a fixed frequency. The direction of circulation depends on the sign of the charge: the two signs go around opposite ways in the same field.
If the velocity is not exactly perpendicular to the field, split it into a component perpendicular to \(\vec{B}\) (which produces the circular motion) and a component parallel to it (which feels no force and is unchanged). The resulting path is a helix, a spiral around the field lines. This is qualitative at angles other than 0°, 90° and 180°; it is how charged particles from the Sun spiral along the Earth's field lines toward the poles and produce the aurora.
Figure 12.4a Circular motion in a magnetic field. The magnetic force is perpendicular to the velocity and acts as the centripetal force, so the speed is constant and \(r = mv/(|q|B)\). A velocity component along the field is unaffected, and the path becomes a helix.
Velocity selector
Suppose a particle moves through a region where an electric field and a magnetic field are perpendicular to each other and to the velocity. The electric force \(qE\) points one way and the magnetic force \(qvB\) the other way. If they balance, the net force is zero and the particle moves in a straight line. Setting \(qE = qvB\) gives
\[ v = \frac{E}{B}, \]
independent of the charge and the mass. Particles with faster or slower speeds are deflected out of the beam. Such a velocity selector is often the first stage of a mass spectrometer: after it, all the particles have the same speed, and the radius of their circular path in a second field region is proportional to \(m/q\), so different isotopes land at different positions.
Figure 12.4b A velocity selector. With \(\vec E\) and \(\vec B\) perpendicular and both perpendicular to \(\vec v\), the electric and magnetic forces oppose each other. Only particles with \(qE = qvB\), that is \(v = E/B\), travel straight.
Motion in an electric field, for comparison
In a uniform electric field the force on a charged particle is \(qE\), constant in magnitude and direction, so it follows a parabola when it enters at an angle to the field (Lesson 10.10). In a magnetic field the force is perpendicular to the velocity and changes direction as the particle turns, so the path is a circle. An electric field changes the particle's speed and kinetic energy; a magnetic field does not. When both are present, treat the forces separately (they act independently), then add them.
Worked example · radius of a proton's path
A proton moving at \(2.0\times10^{6}\) m/s enters a uniform 0.50 T field perpendicular to it. Find the radius of its path and its period.
Radius. \(r = mv/(qB) = (1.67\times10^{-27})(2.0\times10^{6})/[(1.60\times10^{-19})(0.50)] = 4.2\times10^{-2}\) m, about 4.2 cm.
Period. \(T = 2\pi m/(qB) = 2\pi(1.67\times10^{-27})/[(1.60\times10^{-19})(0.50)] = 1.3\times10^{-7}\) s, independent of the speed.
Worked example · accelerating, then bending
An electron is accelerated from rest through 500 V and then enters a 2.0 mT field perpendicular to its velocity. Find its speed and the radius of its path.
A particle moves in a straight line through a region with both an electric and a magnetic field. What can you say about the forces?
Show answer
The net force is zero: the electric and magnetic forces are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction (a velocity selector).
A proton enters a magnetic field at an angle of 45° to the field direction. Describe qualitatively the path that results.
Show answer
A helix: the component of velocity perpendicular to the field gives circular motion, and the component along the field is unchanged, so the proton spirals along the field direction.
In 1820 Hans Christian Oersted noticed that a compass needle twitched when a nearby wire was connected to a battery. A current produces a magnetic field. Within weeks Ampère showed that two wires with currents attract or repel each other, and the next logical step was an electric motor: a current in a magnetic field feels a force. This lesson covers both directions of the connection: the field produced by a current in a straight wire and in a loop, and the force exerted by a field on a current-carrying wire. Both rest on one idea from the last lesson: a current is a stream of moving charges, so a wire creates a field and feels a force, just as an individual moving charge does.
Learning objectives · 12.3.A and 12.3.B
Describe the magnetic field produced by a current-carrying wire. Describe the force exerted on a current-carrying wire by a magnetic field.
Required content · EK 12.3.A and 12.3.B
A current-carrying wire produces a magnetic field. The field vectors around a long, straight wire are tangent to concentric circles centered on the wire; the field has no component toward, away from or parallel to the wire.
At a point in space, the magnitude of the field due to a long, straight, current-carrying wire is proportional to the current and inversely proportional to the perpendicular distance from the wire to the point: \(B = \mu_0 I/(2\pi r)\). Its direction is given by the right-hand rule. The field at the center of a current-carrying loop is directed along the axis of the loop and can be found with the right-hand rule.
The field at a location near two or more current-carrying wires can be determined using vector addition principles.
A magnetic field may exert a force on a current-carrying wire. The magnitude is proportional to the current, the length of wire in the field, and the magnitude of the field, and depends on the angle between the direction of the current and the field: \(F = I\ell B\sin\theta\). The direction is determined by the right-hand rule.
The field of a long straight wire
A long, straight wire carrying a current \(I\) produces a field that circles the wire. At a perpendicular distance \(r\) from the wire the field has magnitude
\[ B = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi r}, \]
with \(\mu_0 = 4\pi\times10^{-7}\ \text{T}\cdot\text{m}/\text{A}\) (Lesson 12.2). The field is proportional to the current and falls off as \(1/r\). Its direction is tangent to a circle centered on the wire: it has no component along the wire, toward it or away from it. To find the sense of the circulation, use the right-hand rule for a wire: point your right thumb along the (conventional) current and your fingers curl around the wire in the direction of the field. A wire carrying current out of the page has counterclockwise field circles around it; current into the page gives clockwise circles.
Figure 12.5a The field of a long straight wire is tangent to circles centered on the wire. Right-hand rule: thumb along the current, fingers curl in the direction of the field. The magnitude falls off as \(1/r\).
Loops and several wires
A wire bent into a loop produces a field that is strongest near the wire and, at the center of the loop, points along the axis of the loop. To find which way, use a second right-hand rule: curl the fingers of the right hand in the direction of the current around the loop, and the thumb points along the field at the center (the loop's north pole is on the side the thumb points toward). Stacking many loops into a coil (a solenoid) adds their fields and gives a strong, nearly uniform field inside, like a bar magnet: that is an electromagnet.
The field near two or more wires is found by vector superposition: calculate the field of each wire at the point, with the right-hand rule for each direction, and add the vectors. Two wires carrying currents in opposite directions, for example, produce fields in the same direction at points between them (so they add) and opposite directions outside (so they partly cancel). Two currents in the same direction have fields that cancel between the wires.
Figure 12.5b Fields of a loop and of two wires. At the center of a loop the field is along its axis (right-hand rule with the fingers following the current). Fields of several wires add as vectors; between wires with opposite currents they point the same way.
The force on a current-carrying wire
A wire carrying current \(I\) in a magnetic field feels the sum of the magnetic forces on its moving charges. For a straight segment of length \(\ell\) in a uniform field, the magnitude of the force is
\[ F = I\,\ell\,B\sin\theta, \]
where \(\theta\) is the angle between the direction of the current and the field. It is largest when the wire is perpendicular to the field (\(F = I\ell B\)) and zero when the wire is parallel to the field. The direction follows the right-hand rule for a positive moving charge, with the current as the velocity: fingers along the current, curled toward \(\vec{B}\), thumb along the force. The force is perpendicular to both the wire and the field. A loop of wire in a field feels forces on opposite sides in opposite directions, which makes a torque: this is the principle of an electric motor.
Combining the two ideas gives the force between two parallel wires. Wire 1 creates a field at wire 2, \(B_1 = \mu_0 I_1/(2\pi d)\), and wire 2 carries a current in that field, so the force per unit length on it is \(F/\ell = I_2B_1 = \mu_0I_1I_2/(2\pi d)\). Wires with currents in the same direction attract each other; wires with currents in opposite directions repel. The two forces are equal and opposite (Newton's third law).
Figure 12.5c Forces on current-carrying wires. A wire in a field feels \(F = I\ell B\sin\theta\). Parallel currents attract and antiparallel currents repel with force per length \(\mu_0I_1I_2/(2\pi d)\).
Worked example · field of a wire
A long straight wire carries 10 A. Find the field at 5.0 cm from the wire.
Equation. \(B = \mu_0I/(2\pi r) = (4\pi\times10^{-7})(10)/[2\pi(0.050)] = 4.0\times10^{-5}\) T, which is comparable to the Earth's field (\(\sim5\times10^{-5}\) T).
Doubling the distance would halve the field, to \(2.0\times10^{-5}\) T.
Worked example · two wires
Two long parallel wires 0.20 m apart carry 10 A each in opposite directions. Find the field at the midpoint between them.
Each wire. \(B = \mu_0I/(2\pi r) = (4\pi\times10^{-7})(10)/[2\pi(0.10)] = 2.0\times10^{-5}\) T.
Direction. Between wires with opposite currents the two fields point the same way, so they add: \(B = 4.0\times10^{-5}\) T. For currents in the same direction the fields would cancel there.
Worked example · force on a wire
A 0.20 m length of wire carrying 5.0 A lies perpendicular to a 0.40 T field. What force acts on it? And in the field of a second wire, what is the force per meter between two 10 A and 20 A currents 0.10 m apart?
First wire. \(F = I\ell B = (5.0)(0.20)(0.40) = 0.40\) N, perpendicular to both the wire and the field.
Two parallel wires. The 10 A wire produces \(B_1 = (4\pi\times10^{-7})(10)/[2\pi(0.10)] = 2.0\times10^{-5}\) T at the second wire. Then \(F/\ell = I_2B_1 = (20)(2.0\times10^{-5}) = 4.0\times10^{-4}\) N/m, attractive for currents in the same direction.
Exam focus
Straight wire. \(B = \mu_0I/(2\pi r)\); circles around the wire; thumb along current, fingers give \(\vec{B}\).
Loop. Curl fingers with the current; the thumb gives the field along the axis.
Several wires. Add the field vectors.
Force on a wire. \(F = I\ell B\sin\theta\); maximum when perpendicular, zero when parallel; direction by the right-hand rule.
Parallel currents. Same direction attract; opposite directions repel.
Practice
Find the magnetic field 2.0 cm from a long wire carrying 5.0 A.
Show answer
\(B = (4\pi\times10^{-7})(5.0)/[2\pi(0.020)] = 5.0\times10^{-5}\) T.
Current in a long straight wire runs out of the page. Which way does the field circulate around it?
Show answer
Counterclockwise: with the thumb out of the page, the fingers curl counterclockwise.
A 0.50 m wire carries 4.0 A perpendicular to a 0.30 T field. What is the force on it?
Show answer
\(F = I\ell B = (4.0)(0.50)(0.30) = 0.60\) N.
The same wire is turned parallel to the field. What is the force?
Show answer
Zero, since \(\sin 0^\circ = 0\).
Two parallel wires carry currents in opposite directions. Do they attract or repel?
Show answer
They repel.
Two wires carry equal currents in the same direction, 0.10 m apart. What is the field at the point midway between them?
Show answer
Zero. The two fields have equal magnitude (each is the same distance away) and opposite directions between the wires, so they cancel.
Lesson 12.6 · Unit 12 · CED topic 12.4 (flux and Faraday's law)
Oersted showed that electricity makes magnetism. In 1831 Michael Faraday asked the opposite question, and found that magnetism can make electricity, but only when something changes. A magnet at rest next to a coil does nothing; move the magnet in or out and a current flows in the coil. Almost all the electric power in the world is generated by this effect: a turbine spins a coil in a magnet, and the changing magnetic effect creates the emf that drives current through our homes. The quantity that matters is the magnetic flux, a measure of how much of a magnetic field passes through a surface. This lesson defines flux, states Faraday's law, and shows the three ways to change flux.
Learning objective · 12.4.A (flux and Faraday's law)
Describe the induced electric potential difference resulting from a change in magnetic flux.
Required content · EK 12.4.A (part)
Magnetic flux is a description of the amount of the component of a magnetic field that is perpendicular to a cross-sectional area.
Magnetic flux through a surface is proportional to the magnitude of the component of the field perpendicular to the surface and to the area of the surface: \(\Phi_B = BA\cos\theta\). The area vector is perpendicular to the plane of the surface (directed outward from a closed surface). The sign of the flux indicates whether the field is parallel or antiparallel to the area vector.
Faraday's law describes the relationship between changing magnetic flux and the resulting induced emf in a system: \(\mathcal{E} = -\Delta\Phi_B/\Delta t\).
Magnetic flux
Picture the field lines passing through a loop of wire like rain through a hoop. The amount that gets through depends on how strong the field is, how large the loop is, and how the loop is tilted. The magnetic flux through a flat surface of area \(A\) in a uniform field is
\[ \Phi_B = BA\cos\theta, \]
where \(\theta\) is the angle between the field \(\vec{B}\) and the area vector \(\vec{A}\), a vector whose magnitude is the area and whose direction is perpendicular to the surface. Only the component of \(\vec{B}\) perpendicular to the surface counts, \(B\cos\theta\). The unit is the weber (Wb): 1 Wb \(=\) 1 T\(\cdot\)m². The flux is a maximum when the field is perpendicular to the surface (\(\theta = 0^\circ\), face-on) and zero when the field is parallel to the surface (\(\theta = 90^\circ\), edge-on). The sign tells whether the field passes through the surface along the area vector (positive) or against it (negative, \(\theta\) between \(90^\circ\) and \(180^\circ\)); flipping a loop over reverses the sign. The direction you choose for \(\vec{A}\) is a convention, but you must keep it throughout the problem.
Figure 12.6a Magnetic flux \(\Phi_B = BA\cos\theta\), where \(\theta\) is the angle between \(\vec B\) and the area vector. It is largest when the loop faces the field and zero when the field lies in the plane of the loop.
Faraday's law
When the flux through a loop changes, an emf is induced in the loop. Faraday's law says the induced emf equals the (negative of the) rate of change of the flux:
\[ \mathcal{E} = -\frac{\Delta\Phi_B}{\Delta t}. \]
The size of the emf is the rate of change of flux, \(|\Delta\Phi_B/\Delta t|\); a coil of \(N\) turns acts like \(N\) loops in series, so its emf is \(N\) times as large. The minus sign records the direction (Lenz's law, next lesson). If the loop is part of a closed circuit of resistance \(R\), the emf drives a current \(I = \mathcal{E}/R\). Notice what matters: the rate of change of flux, not the flux itself. A large steady field through a loop induces nothing; a small field that changes quickly can induce a large emf.
There are three ways to change \(\Phi_B = BA\cos\theta\): change the field strength \(B\) (move a magnet closer, or change the current in an electromagnet), change the area \(A\) of the loop in the field (stretch or squeeze it, or slide a rod along rails), or change the angle \(\theta\) (rotate the loop). Rotating a coil steadily in a magnetic field makes the flux oscillate and produces an alternating emf, which is how a generator works.
Figure 12.6b Faraday's law on a graph. The induced emf is the negative slope of the flux against time. A constant flux gives no emf; a steeper change gives a larger emf; rising and falling flux give emfs of opposite sign.
Worked example · flux
A circular loop of area 0.020 m² is in a uniform 0.50 T field. Find the flux when the field is (a) perpendicular to the loop, (b) at 60° to the area vector, (c) parallel to the plane of the loop.
(c) The area vector is perpendicular to the field, \(\theta = 90^\circ\), so \(\Phi = 0\).
Worked example · induced emf and current
The field through the loop (area 0.020 m², face-on) rises uniformly from 0 to 0.80 T in 0.50 s. The loop's resistance is 0.40 \(\Omega\). Find the induced emf and current.
Change in flux. \(\Delta\Phi = A\Delta B = (0.020)(0.80) = 1.6\times10^{-2}\) Wb.
Emf. \(|\mathcal{E}| = \Delta\Phi/\Delta t = (1.6\times10^{-2})/0.50 = 0.032\) V.
Current. \(I = \mathcal{E}/R = 0.032/0.40 = 0.080\) A, flowing for as long as the field is changing. If the field stops changing, the emf and current drop to zero.
Exam focus
Flux. \(\Phi_B = BA\cos\theta\) (weber); \(\theta\) is between \(\vec{B}\) and the area vector; zero when the field lies in the surface.
Faraday. \(\mathcal{E} = -\Delta\Phi_B/\Delta t\); only a change of flux induces an emf.
Three ways. Change \(B\), change \(A\), or change \(\theta\).
Current. \(I = \mathcal{E}/R\) in a closed loop.
Graphs. The emf is the slope of the flux-versus-time graph (with a minus sign).
Practice
What is the flux through a 0.10 m² loop perpendicular to a 0.30 T field?
Show answer
\(\Phi = BA = (0.30)(0.10) = 3.0\times10^{-2}\) Wb.
A loop rotates from face-on to edge-on in a uniform field. What happens to the flux and is an emf induced?
Show answer
The flux falls from \(BA\) to zero as \(\cos\theta\) goes to zero. Because the flux is changing during the rotation, an emf is induced.
The flux through a loop changes from \(4.0\times10^{-3}\) Wb to \(1.0\times10^{-3}\) Wb in 0.10 s. What is the magnitude of the induced emf?
Show answer
\(|\mathcal{E}| = |\Delta\Phi|/\Delta t = 3.0\times10^{-3}/0.10 = 0.030\) V.
A magnet is held at rest inside a coil. Is there an induced emf? Explain.
Show answer
No. The flux is constant, so \(\Delta\Phi_B/\Delta t = 0\) and no emf is induced, however strong the magnet.
A loop of area 0.050 m² is face-on in a field that changes from 0.20 T to 0.60 T in 0.20 s. The loop's resistance is 2.0 \(\Omega\). Find the current.
Show answer
Faraday's law gives the size of an induced emf. Which way does the induced current flow? The answer, due to Heinrich Lenz, is a statement about energy: the induced current always opposes the change that produced it. Drop a magnet through a copper pipe and it falls slowly, as though in thick honey, because the currents it induces in the pipe create a field that resists its motion. If induced currents helped the change instead of opposing it, a small push would grow into an ever-larger current with no source of energy, which is impossible. This lesson turns the minus sign in Faraday's law into a working rule, and then applies it to the standard example of a rod sliding on rails.
Learning objective · 12.4.A (Lenz's law and the sliding rod)
Describe the induced electric potential difference resulting from a change in magnetic flux.
Required content · EK 12.4.A (part)
Lenz's law is used to determine the direction of an induced emf resulting from a changing magnetic flux. An induced emf generates a current that creates a magnetic field that opposes the change in magnetic flux. The right-hand rule is used to determine the relationships among current, emf and magnetic flux.
A common example of electromagnetic induction is a conducting rod on conducting rails in a region with a uniform magnetic field. The derived equation is \(\mathcal{E} = B\ell v\).
Lenz's law
Lenz's law: the direction of the induced emf (and current) is such that the magnetic field of the induced current opposes the change in flux that caused it. It does not oppose the flux itself, only its change. If the flux through a loop is increasing, the induced current produces a field opposite to the original field, to reduce the increase. If the flux is decreasing, the induced current produces a field in the same direction as the original, to try to keep the flux from falling. If the flux is not changing, there is no induced current to oppose anything. The minus sign in \(\mathcal{E} = -\Delta\Phi_B/\Delta t\) expresses this.
A reliable procedure for a loop or coil:
Decide the direction of the original field through the loop.
Decide whether the flux through the loop is increasing or decreasing (in magnitude).
Decide the direction of the induced field: opposite to the original if the flux is increasing, the same if decreasing.
Use the right-hand rule (fingers curl with the current, thumb along the induced field) to find the direction of the induced current around the loop.
When you push the north pole of a magnet toward a loop, the flux through the loop increases, so the loop's induced field points back toward the magnet: the loop acts like a north pole facing the approaching north pole and repels it. If you pull the magnet away, the flux decreases, and the loop makes a south pole toward the receding magnet, attracting it. In both cases the induced current resists what you are doing, so you must do work, and that work is the energy that appears in the circuit. Lenz's law is conservation of energy at work.
Figure 12.7a Lenz's law. The magnet's field points to the right through the loop. If the flux is increasing, the induced field opposes it (to the left, so the loop repels the magnet); if it is decreasing, the induced field points the same way (to the right, so the loop attracts the magnet).
A rod sliding on rails: motional emf
A conducting rod of length \(\ell\) slides with speed \(v\) along two parallel rails joined at one end, with a uniform field \(B\) perpendicular to the plane of the rails. The loop formed by the rod, the rails and the connecting end encloses an area that grows by \(\ell v\,\Delta t\) in a time \(\Delta t\), so the flux changes by \(\Delta\Phi_B = B\ell v\,\Delta t\). Faraday's law gives the motional emf
\[ \mathcal{E} = B\ell v. \]
The same result follows from the magnetic force on the charges in the moving rod: they move with the rod at speed \(v\) in the field, feel a force \(qvB\) along the rod, and are pushed toward one end until the charge separation sets up a balancing electric field, producing a potential difference \(B\ell v\) between the ends. If the circuit has total resistance \(R\), the induced current is \(I = B\ell v/R\). The current direction follows from Lenz's law: the enclosed area is growing, so the flux is increasing, so the induced current creates a field opposing the original field.
The current in the rod is itself in a magnetic field, so the field exerts a force \(F = I\ell B\) on it, and by Lenz's law this force opposes the rod's motion. To keep the rod moving at constant speed, you must apply an equal force in the direction of the motion. The mechanical power you supply is \(Fv\), and it equals the electrical power dissipated in the resistance, \(I^{2}R\): the energy conservation that Lenz's law guarantees.
Figure 12.7b A rod on rails. The area of the loop grows as the rod moves, so the flux (into the page) increases and the induced current is counterclockwise, producing a field out of the page. The force on the current in the rod opposes the motion; the work done by the applied force becomes thermal energy in \(R\).
Worked example · direction of the induced current
A loop lies in the plane of the page. A uniform field points out of the page and is increasing in strength. Which way does the induced current flow?
Flux. The original field is out of the page and the flux (out) is increasing.
Induced field. It must oppose the increase, so it points into the page.
Current. Thumb into the page, fingers curl clockwise, so the induced current flows clockwise around the loop.
Worked example · a rod on rails
A 0.50 m rod slides at 4.0 m/s on rails in a 0.30 T field perpendicular to the plane of the rails. The circuit's resistance is 2.0 \(\Omega\). Find the emf, the current, the force needed to keep it moving at constant speed, and the power.
Emf. \(\mathcal{E} = B\ell v = (0.30)(0.50)(4.0) = 0.60\) V.
Current. \(I = \mathcal{E}/R = 0.60/2.0 = 0.30\) A.
Force. The magnetic force on the rod is \(F = I\ell B = (0.30)(0.50)(0.30) = 0.045\) N, opposing the motion, so the applied force is 0.045 N in the direction of motion.
Power. Mechanical: \(Fv = (0.045)(4.0) = 0.18\) W. Electrical: \(I^{2}R = (0.30)^{2}(2.0) = 0.18\) W. The two agree.
Exam focus
Lenz's law. The induced current's field opposes the change in flux: opposite the field if flux increases, same direction if it decreases.
Procedure. Original field, increasing or decreasing, induced field, right-hand rule for the current.
Force on the rod. \(F = I\ell B\) opposes the motion; applied power \(Fv = I^{2}R\).
Energy. Lenz's law is conservation of energy: induced currents cannot help the change.
Practice
The south pole of a magnet is pulled away from a loop. What magnetic pole does the loop present toward the magnet?
Show answer
The flux is decreasing, so the loop opposes the decrease by creating a field in the same direction as the original. Pulling the south pole away, the loop's near face is a north pole, which attracts the receding south pole and resists its removal.
A field into the page through a loop is decreasing. Which way does the induced current flow?
Show answer
The induced field must be in the same direction (into the page), so the current is clockwise.
A 0.20 m rod moves at 5.0 m/s perpendicular to a 0.40 T field on rails. Find the emf.
Show answer
\(\mathcal{E} = B\ell v = (0.40)(0.20)(5.0) = 0.40\) V.
In the situation of problem 3 the resistance is 4.0 \(\Omega\). What force must be applied to keep the rod moving at constant speed?
Show answer
\(I = 0.40/4.0 = 0.10\) A; \(F = I\ell B = (0.10)(0.20)(0.40) = 8.0\times10^{-3}\) N.
If the speed of the rod doubles, by what factor do the emf and the applied force change?
Show answer
The emf doubles. The current doubles, so \(F = I\ell B\) doubles as well. (The power increases by a factor of 4.)
A copper plate is pulled out of a magnetic field and is hard to pull. Explain.
Show answer
The decreasing flux induces circulating currents in the plate. By Lenz's law these currents produce forces that oppose the motion, so you must do work; that energy is dissipated as thermal energy in the plate.
Unit 12 practice · 10 problems
Unit 12 practice: Magnetism and Electromagnetism
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Constants: \(e = 1.60\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}\),
\(m_e = 9.11\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}\), \(\mu_0 = 4\pi\times10^{-7}\ \text{T·m/A}\), g = 9.8 m/s².
Calculator allowed.
A proton moves at 2.0 × 10⁶ m/s perpendicular to a uniform 0.80 T magnetic field. Find the magnitude of the magnetic force on it. Does the force change the proton's speed? Explain.
Show answer
\(F = qvB = (1.60\times10^{-19})(2.0\times10^{6})(0.80) = 2.6\times10^{-13}\ \text{N}\) (at \(90^\circ\), \(\sin\theta = 1\)). No: the force is always perpendicular to the velocity, so it does no work and changes only the direction of motion, never the speed.
An electron moves at 3.0 × 10⁶ m/s perpendicular to a 2.0 × 10⁻³ T field. Find the radius of its circular path and the time for one revolution.
A positive charge moves due north through a region where the magnetic field points straight up, away from the ground. The magnetic force on it points
Point your fingers along \(\vec{v}\) (north) and curl them toward \(\vec{B}\) (up): the thumb points east, the direction of \(q\vec{v}\times\vec{B}\) for a positive charge.
West is the answer for a negative charge such as an electron, whose force is opposite to \(\vec{v}\times\vec{B}\). It also results from curling from \(\vec{B}\) toward \(\vec{v}\) instead of from \(\vec{v}\) toward \(\vec{B}\).
The magnetic force is always perpendicular to the velocity, so it can never point along or against the direction of motion. That is why a magnetic field changes a charge's direction but never its speed.
The magnetic force is also perpendicular to \(\vec{B}\), so it cannot point up or down when the field is vertical. A force along the field line is what an electric field produces, not a magnetic one.
A horizontal wire 0.50 m long carries 8.0 A perpendicular to a 0.30 T field. (a) Find the force on it. (b) The wire has mass 0.020 kg; what current would make the magnetic force just balance its weight?
Show answer
(a) \(F = BIL\sin 90^\circ = (0.30)(8.0)(0.50) = 1.2\ \text{N}\). (b) Set \(BIL = mg\): \(I = \dfrac{mg}{BL} = \dfrac{(0.020)(9.8)}{(0.30)(0.50)} = 1.3\ \text{A}\), with the current directed so the right-hand rule gives an upward force.
A long straight wire carries 20 A. (a) Find the magnetic field 4.0 cm from it. (b) A second long wire 4.0 cm away carries 10 A in the opposite direction. Find the force per meter between the wires and state whether they attract or repel.
Show answer
(a) \(B = \dfrac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi r} = \dfrac{(4\pi\times10^{-7})(20)}{2\pi(0.040)} = 1.0\times10^{-4}\ \text{T}\), circling the wire. (b) The second wire sits in that field: \(\dfrac{F}{L} = BI_2 = (1.0\times10^{-4})(10) = 1.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{N/m}\). Antiparallel currents repel.
Rank the magnetic flux through these flat loops, greatest to least. Loop A: area 0.10 m², B = 0.50 T, field perpendicular to the loop. Loop B: area 0.20 m², B = 0.50 T, field parallel to the plane of the loop. Loop C: area 0.20 m², B = 0.30 T, field at 60° to the normal. Loop D: area 0.050 m², B = 1.2 T, field perpendicular to the loop.
Show answer
\(\Phi = BA\cos\theta\) with \(\theta\) measured from the normal. A: \((0.50)(0.10)(1) = 0.050\ \text{Wb}\). B: field skims the plane, \(\theta = 90^\circ\), \(\Phi = 0\). C: \((0.30)(0.20)\cos 60^\circ = 0.030\ \text{Wb}\). D: \((1.2)(0.050)(1) = 0.060\ \text{Wb}\). Ranking: D > A > C > B.
A 50-turn circular coil of radius 0.10 m and resistance 2.5 Ω lies flat on the page in a uniform field directed into the page. The field falls steadily from 0.60 T to zero in 0.20 s. Find the induced emf and current, and give the current's direction with a Lenz's-law justification.
Show answer
\(A = \pi(0.10)^2 = 3.14\times10^{-2}\ \text{m}^2\); \(\Delta\Phi = \Delta B\,A = (0.60)(3.14\times10^{-2}) = 1.88\times10^{-2}\ \text{Wb}\). \(|\varepsilon| = N\dfrac{\Delta\Phi}{\Delta t} = 50\cdot\dfrac{1.88\times10^{-2}}{0.20} = 4.7\ \text{V}\); \(I = \dfrac{4.71}{2.5} = 1.9\ \text{A}\). The into-the-page flux is decreasing, so the induced current makes its own field into the page inside the loop to oppose the loss: thumb into the page, fingers curl clockwise.
A strong magnet dropped down a vertical copper pipe falls far more slowly than in free fall, even though copper is not magnetic. Explain in words what is happening, and account for the energy.
Show answer
As the magnet falls, the flux through each ring of the pipe changes: increasing below the magnet, decreasing above it. By Faraday's law, currents are induced around the pipe, and by Lenz's law they flow so as to oppose the change: the ring below repels the approaching magnet and the ring above attracts the departing one. Both forces point up, so the magnet reaches a slow terminal speed. The gravitational potential energy it loses is not becoming kinetic energy; it is dissipated as heat by the induced currents in the copper. If the currents helped the motion instead, energy would be created from nothing.
A 0.40 m conducting rod slides at 5.0 m/s along frictionless rails, perpendicular to a 0.50 T field. The rails are joined through a 4.0 Ω resistor. Find the emf, the current, the force needed to keep the rod moving at constant speed, and show that the mechanical power in equals the electrical power out.
Show answer
\(\varepsilon = BLv = (0.50)(0.40)(5.0) = 1.0\ \text{V}\); \(I = \dfrac{1.0}{4.0} = 0.25\ \text{A}\). The current-carrying rod feels \(F = BIL = (0.50)(0.25)(0.40) = 0.050\ \text{N}\) opposing its motion (Lenz), so the same 0.050 N must pull it. Mechanical power \(Fv = (0.050)(5.0) = 0.25\ \text{W}\); electrical power \(I^2R = (0.25)^2(4.0) = 0.25\ \text{W}\). Equal, as energy conservation demands.
An ideal transformer steps 120 V down to 9.0 V. The primary has 2400 turns. (a) How many turns does the secondary have? (b) If the secondary delivers 1.5 A, what current does the primary draw? (c) Explain in one or two sentences why the transformer does nothing if the primary is connected to a steady DC source.
Show answer
(a) \(\dfrac{N_s}{N_p} = \dfrac{V_s}{V_p}\), so \(N_s = 2400\cdot\dfrac{9.0}{120} = 180\) turns. (b) Power is conserved: \(I_p = \dfrac{I_sV_s}{V_p} = \dfrac{(1.5)(9.0)}{120} = 0.11\ \text{A}\). (c) A steady current makes a steady flux through the core, and only a changing flux induces an emf in the secondary. With DC, nothing changes after the first instant, so the secondary voltage is zero.
You see this page because light left a source, struck the page, and some of it was scattered into your eyes. You see your face in a mirror because light from your face is reflected back to you. Both facts can be understood without thinking about waves at all, by following straight lines. This is geometric optics: a model in which light travels in straight lines called rays, bending only when it meets a boundary. The model explains mirrors, lenses, cameras, telescopes and eyeglasses, and, together with Unit 14, completes the picture of light. This lesson sets up the ray model and the law of reflection, and explains why a mirror gives a sharp image while a sheet of paper does not.
Learning objectives · 13.1.A and 13.1.B
Describe light as a ray. Describe the reflection of light from a surface.
Required content · EK 13.1.A and 13.1.B
A light ray is a straight line that is perpendicular to the wavefront of a light wave and points in the direction of travel of the wave. Light rays can be used to determine the behavior of light in geometric optics, where the wave nature of light can be neglected.
Rays are not sufficient to understand the spreading of light: in interference and diffraction the wave nature of light is important. A laser is a common source of a single coherent, monochromatic beam of light that can be modeled as a ray.
Ray diagrams depict the path of light before and after an interaction with matter.
Light that is incident on a surface can be reflected. The law of reflection states that the angle between the incident ray and the normal (the line perpendicular to the surface) is equal to the angle between the reflected ray and the normal: \(\theta_i = \theta_r\).
Diffuse reflection is the reflection of light from a rough surface and results in light reflected in many directions, because the normal varies over the area. Specular reflection is the reflection from a smooth surface and results in light reflected uniformly, because the normal has an approximately constant direction.
The ray model
Light is a wave, but when it passes through openings and around objects much larger than its wavelength (about 500 nm), the wave spreading is negligible and it is accurate to say that light moves in straight lines. A light ray is such a line, drawn perpendicular to the wavefronts and pointing in the direction in which the wave travels. A narrow laser beam is the nearest real thing to a ray, though even a laser beam spreads a little. Rays cannot describe what happens when light passes through a narrow slit or around a thin obstacle: then the wave nature matters, and the effects of interference and diffraction in Unit 14 appear. In this unit we work with rays and ignore those effects.
A ray diagram shows the path of light before and after it interacts with matter: where it starts, where it strikes a surface, and where it goes next. We draw rays as straight lines with arrowheads, and use the normal, a line perpendicular to the surface at the point where the ray strikes it, as the reference for all angles. Angles in optics are always measured from the normal, not from the surface.
The law of reflection
When a ray (the incident ray) strikes a surface, part of it can be reflected. The law of reflection says that the angle of incidence \(\theta_i\), between the incident ray and the normal, equals the angle of reflection \(\theta_r\), between the reflected ray and the normal:
\[ \theta_i = \theta_r. \]
The incident ray, the reflected ray and the normal all lie in one plane, and the reflected ray is on the opposite side of the normal from the incident ray. A ray striking perpendicular to the surface (along the normal) is reflected straight back on itself. The law holds for any surface at each point where the ray strikes; it is the foundation of all the mirror work in the next two lessons.
Figure 13.1a The law of reflection: the angle of incidence equals the angle of reflection, both measured from the normal (the line perpendicular to the surface).
Specular and diffuse reflection
Every surface obeys the law of reflection at every point, but what you see depends on how the surface is arranged. On a smooth surface such as a mirror, a calm pond or polished metal, the normal points in the same direction everywhere, so parallel incident rays are reflected as parallel rays: specular reflection preserves the arrangement of rays and forms images. On a rough surface such as paper, cloth, wall paint or the ground, the surface is made of tiny facets with normals pointing every which way, so parallel incident rays are reflected in many directions: diffuse reflection. No image forms, but that is why you can see the page from any angle. Roughness is judged against the wavelength of the light: a surface is smooth for light if its irregularities are much smaller than a wavelength.
Figure 13.1b Specular reflection from a smooth surface keeps the rays parallel and can form an image; diffuse reflection from a rough surface scatters them, so the surface is visible from all angles but forms no image.
Worked example · the reflected ray
A ray strikes a flat mirror at an angle of 35° to the surface. At what angle to the normal does it leave, and what is the angle between the incident and reflected rays?
Convert to the normal. The normal is 90° from the surface, so the angle of incidence is \(90^\circ - 35^\circ = 55^\circ\).
Law of reflection. \(\theta_r = \theta_i = 55^\circ\).
Between the rays. The rays are 55° on either side of the normal, so the angle between them is \(55^\circ + 55^\circ = 110^\circ\).
Worked example · rotating a mirror
A mirror is rotated by 10° while the incident ray stays fixed. By how much does the reflected ray rotate?
Normal rotates 10°. The angle of incidence changes by 10°, and the reflected ray is at the same angle on the other side of the normal.
Result. The reflected ray turns through 20°, twice the rotation of the mirror. This doubling is used in laser pointers and some measuring instruments to amplify small rotations.
Exam focus
Rays. Straight lines perpendicular to wavefronts; valid when wave effects (interference, diffraction) are negligible.
Angles. Measured from the normal, never the surface.
Law. \(\theta_i = \theta_r\); both rays and the normal are in one plane.
Rotating a mirror. The reflected ray turns by twice the angle.
Practice
A ray hits a mirror with an angle of incidence of 28°. What is the angle between the reflected ray and the surface?
Show answer
\(\theta_r = 28^\circ\), so the angle from the surface is \(90^\circ - 28^\circ = 62^\circ\).
A ray hits a mirror along the normal. In which direction does it reflect?
Show answer
Straight back along the incident path, since \(\theta_i = 0^\circ\) and \(\theta_r = 0^\circ\).
Why can a person see a sheet of white paper from any direction but not a clear image in it?
Show answer
Paper reflects diffusely: its rough surface has normals in many directions, so light is scattered widely and is seen from any angle, but the rays lose their arrangement so no image forms.
Name one condition under which the ray model of light is inadequate.
Show answer
When light passes through an opening or around an object comparable in size to its wavelength: diffraction and interference occur and the wave nature must be used (Unit 14).
A mirror is rotated by 15°. By how much does a reflected ray turn?
Show answer
By 30°.
A calm lake gives a clear reflection of the trees, but when a breeze ripples the surface the reflection breaks up. Explain in terms of the normal.
Show answer
On a calm surface the normal points in nearly one direction everywhere, so the reflection is specular and forms a clear image. Ripples make the normal vary from point to point, scattering the reflected rays in different directions and breaking up the image.
Lesson 13.2 · Unit 13 · CED topic 13.2 (mirrors and ray diagrams)
A bathroom mirror, a makeup mirror that magnifies, and the passenger-side mirror that warns "objects in mirror are closer than they appear" are all mirrors, but they form very different images. The reason is shape. A flat mirror gives a faithful but reversed copy; a curved mirror can enlarge, shrink or invert, and can even form an image you can project onto a screen. In this lesson we meet the three mirror types the course covers (plane, concave and convex), define real and virtual images, and learn the ray-diagram method that locates an image without any equation. The next lesson adds the equations.
Learning objective · 13.2.A (qualitative)
Describe the image formed by a mirror.
Required content · EK 13.2.A (part)
Incident rays parallel to the principal axis of a concave (converging) mirror are reflected toward a common location, called the focal point. For a convex (diverging) mirror they are reflected as if they originated from a common point behind the mirror, the focal point. The focal point of a plane mirror is an infinite distance from the mirror.
The focal point of a spherical mirror may be approximated as a point on the principal axis halfway between the surface of the mirror and the center of its radius of curvature: \(f = R/2\).
A real image is formed when light rays from a common point are reflected and then intersect at a common point. A virtual image is formed when reflected rays diverge so that they appear to have originated from a common point.
The distance between the image and a plane mirror equals the distance between the object and the mirror.
Ray diagrams can be used to determine the location, type, size and orientation of images. The three principal rays: (1) the ray parallel to the principal axis, (2) the ray that reflects at the center of the mirror where the principal axis meets the mirror, (3) the ray that passes through the focal point. Images can be upright or inverted, virtual or real, and reduced, enlarged or the same size.
Boundary: mirrors are limited to plane mirrors, convex spherical mirrors and concave spherical mirrors.
Real and virtual images
Each point of an object sends rays in all directions. A mirror redirects them, and the image is where they come together, or appear to. If the reflected rays actually cross at a point, the image is real: light really is there, and a screen placed at that point would show the image. If the reflected rays diverge but their backward extensions meet at a point behind the mirror, the image is virtual: the rays only appear to come from that point, no light is there, and no screen can show it, although your eye sees it just as it sees any other object. A virtual image is where your brain thinks the rays came from, since the eye assumes light travels in straight lines. We draw actual rays as solid lines and backward extensions as dashed lines.
The plane mirror
In a flat mirror the image is always virtual, upright and the same size as the object. It appears at the same distance behind the mirror as the object is in front, so you standing 2.0 m from a mirror see yourself 2.0 m behind it, 4.0 m away. The image is reversed front to back (not truly left to right): a point on your right side is imaged at the same lateral position, so the image only looks left-right reversed when you compare it with yourself by turning around. A plane mirror may be thought of as a spherical mirror with an infinite radius, so its focal point is infinitely far away. To see your whole height in a plane mirror it needs to be only half as tall as you are, at any distance.
Spherical mirrors and the focal point
A spherical mirror is a piece of a sphere of radius \(R\). The center of the sphere is the center of curvature \(C\), and the line from \(C\) through the middle of the mirror is the principal axis. A concave mirror reflects from the inside of the sphere (like the inside of a spoon), and a convex mirror reflects from the outside (the back of the spoon). Rays parallel to the principal axis, as from a very distant object, are reflected through (concave) or as if from (convex) a single focal point \(F\), located at half the radius of curvature:
\[ f = \frac{R}{2}. \]
The concave mirror is a converging mirror, because it brings parallel rays together at a real focal point in front of the mirror; the convex mirror is diverging, because it spreads parallel rays so that they appear to come from a virtual focal point behind it. (These statements are accurate for rays near the axis; rays far from the axis do not meet at a single point, an effect called spherical aberration.)
Figure 13.2a Focal points of spherical mirrors. Parallel rays converge at a real focal point in front of a concave mirror and diverge as if from a virtual focal point behind a convex mirror. For both, \(f = R/2\).
Locating images with three principal rays
To find the image of a point on an object, draw two or three of these principal rays from that point and find where they meet (or appear to meet):
Parallel ray. A ray parallel to the principal axis is reflected through the focal point (concave) or as if from the focal point (convex).
Center ray. A ray that strikes the mirror at the center, where the principal axis meets it, is reflected at an equal angle on the other side of the axis (law of reflection with the axis as the normal).
Focal ray. A ray through the focal point (or directed toward it) is reflected parallel to the axis.
For a concave mirror the type of image depends on where the object is. Beyond the center of curvature (\(s_o \gt R\)): real, inverted, reduced. Between the center of curvature and the focal point (\(f \lt s_o \lt R\)): real, inverted, enlarged. Inside the focal point (\(s_o \lt f\)): virtual, upright, enlarged (the makeup mirror). For a convex mirror the image is always virtual, upright and reduced, wherever the object is, which is why it is used for wide-angle security and car mirrors: it shows a wide field in a small image.
Figure 13.2b Concave mirror, \(f = 20\) cm. Left: object at 60 cm gives a real, inverted image at 30 cm. Right: object at 10 cm gives a virtual, upright image 20 cm behind the mirror (dashed rays are extensions, not actual light).Figure 13.2c A convex mirror always forms a virtual, upright, reduced image of a real object. Dashed lines are the backward extensions of the reflected rays.
Worked example · plane mirror geometry
A student stands 2.0 m in front of a plane mirror and walks 0.50 m toward it. How far is the student from his image before and after, and does the image get larger?
Before. The image is 2.0 m behind the mirror, so the separation is 4.0 m.
After. He is 1.5 m from the mirror, so the image is 1.5 m behind it and the separation is 3.0 m. The image remains the same size as the object: it does not grow as he approaches.
Worked example · focal length from the radius
A concave mirror has a radius of curvature of 40 cm. Where do rays from a very distant star converge, and what image does an object 10 cm from the mirror produce?
Focal length. \(f = R/2 = 20\) cm. Rays from a distant star are parallel to the axis, so they converge at 20 cm in front of the mirror.
Object at 10 cm. It is inside the focal point (10 cm \(\lt\) 20 cm), so the image is virtual, upright and enlarged, behind the mirror. (The numbers follow in the next lesson.)
Real image. Rays actually meet; can be projected; inverted for a single mirror.
Virtual image. Rays only appear to meet (dashed lines); cannot be projected.
Principal rays. Parallel to the axis; center; through the focal point.
Convex mirror. Always virtual, upright, reduced.
Practice
A concave mirror has a radius of curvature of 30 cm. What is its focal length?
Show answer
\(f = R/2 = 15\) cm.
You stand 3.0 m from a plane mirror. How far are you from your image?
Show answer
6.0 m (3.0 m to the mirror and 3.0 m behind it).
For a concave mirror, describe the image of an object placed beyond the center of curvature.
Show answer
Real, inverted and reduced, between the focal point and the center of curvature.
What kind of image does a convex mirror always form of a real object?
Show answer
Virtual, upright and reduced.
What is the difference between a real and a virtual image, and how could you test which you have?
Show answer
A real image is formed where reflected rays actually intersect, so a screen placed there shows the image. A virtual image is where rays appear to originate; no light reaches that location, and a screen placed there shows nothing.
Sketch in words the three principal rays for a concave mirror when the object is beyond \(C\).
Show answer
(1) A ray parallel to the axis reflects through the focal point. (2) A ray to the center of the mirror reflects at the same angle on the other side of the axis. (3) A ray through the focal point reflects parallel to the axis. The three intersect at the image point, between \(F\) and \(C\), inverted.
Lesson 13.3 · Unit 13 · CED topic 13.2 (equation and magnification)
A ray diagram gives the type of image and a rough position. To find exactly where the image forms and how large it is, as a pharmacist designing a shaving mirror or an engineer designing a telescope must, we need an equation. One equation relates the object distance, the image distance and the focal length; another gives the magnification. Both depend on a sign convention that tells you, from the sign of the answer, whether the image is real or virtual and upright or inverted. This lesson states the equations and the convention, and works through all three kinds of image from concave and convex mirrors.
Learning objective · 13.2.A (quantitative)
Describe the image formed by a mirror.
Required content · EK 13.2.A (part)
The location of an image depends on the focal length of the mirror and the distance between the object and the surface of the mirror: \(\dfrac{1}{s_i} + \dfrac{1}{s_o} = \dfrac{1}{f}\). The locations of the focal point, the object and the image follow sign conventions that are used to determine them relative to the mirror itself.
The magnification of an image formed by a mirror is the ratio of the size of the image to the size of the object and depends on the locations of the object and image relative to the mirror: \(M = \dfrac{h_i}{h_o} = -\dfrac{s_i}{s_o}\).
Images formed by a mirror can be upright or inverted, virtual or real, and reduced, enlarged or the same size as the object.
The mirror equation and its sign convention
For a mirror with focal length \(f\), an object at distance \(s_o\) from the mirror produces an image at distance \(s_i\), with
\[ \frac{1}{s_o} + \frac{1}{s_i} = \frac{1}{f}. \]
The distances carry signs. This course uses the following convention, with the mirror's reflecting side as the "front":
\(s_o\) is positive for a real object in front of the mirror (the usual case).
\(s_i\) is positive for a real image (in front of the mirror, on the same side as the object) and negative for a virtual image (behind the mirror).
\(f\) is positive for a concave (converging) mirror and negative for a convex (diverging) mirror. A plane mirror has \(f = \infty\), so \(s_i = -s_o\).
The magnification is the ratio of the image height to the object height,
\[ M = \frac{h_i}{h_o} = -\frac{s_i}{s_o}. \]
The size of \(M\) tells you the size of the image relative to the object (\(|M| \gt 1\) enlarged, \(|M| \lt 1\) reduced, \(|M| = 1\) same size), and its sign tells you the orientation: \(M \gt 0\) means upright, \(M \lt 0\) means inverted. Note that real images (\(s_i \gt 0\)) of real objects are inverted (\(M \lt 0\)), and virtual images (\(s_i \lt 0\)) are upright (\(M \gt 0\)).
Figure 13.3a Sign convention for the mirror equation and magnification (the same convention is used for thin lenses, with the real side of a lens behind it).
Strategy
Choose the sign of \(f\) from the mirror type, put in \(s_o\) as positive, solve for \(s_i\) by taking the reciprocal of \(1/f - 1/s_o\), and then compute \(M\). Decide real or virtual from the sign of \(s_i\), and upright or inverted from the sign of \(M\). Always check the answer against a ray diagram: the equation and the sketch must agree. As an experiment: if you measure pairs \((s_o, s_i)\) and plot \(1/s_i\) against \(1/s_o\), the data fall on a straight line with slope \(-1\) and a vertical intercept of \(1/f\), which lets you find \(f\) from the graph.
Figure 13.3b Linearizing mirror (or lens) data. Plotting \(1/s_i\) against \(1/s_o\) gives a straight line of slope \(-1\); the vertical intercept is \(1/f\).
Worked example · object beyond C (real image)
A concave mirror has \(f = 20\) cm. A 4.0 cm tall object is 60 cm from it. Find the image.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/f - 1/s_o = 1/20 - 1/60 = 2/60\), so \(s_i = +30\) cm (real, in front of the mirror).
Magnification. \(M = -s_i/s_o = -30/60 = -0.50\): inverted and half the size.
Height. \(h_i = Mh_o = -2.0\) cm. A real, inverted, reduced image, as the ray diagram predicts for an object beyond \(C = 40\) cm.
Worked example · object inside F (virtual image)
The same mirror with the object at 10 cm.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/20 - 1/10 = -1/20\), so \(s_i = -20\) cm (virtual, 20 cm behind the mirror).
Magnification. \(M = -(-20)/10 = +2.0\): upright and twice the size. This is how a shaving or makeup mirror works: you hold your face inside the focal length.
Worked example · convex mirror
A convex mirror has \(f = -15\) cm. An object is 30 cm from it. Find the image.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/f - 1/s_o = -1/15 - 1/30 = -3/30\), so \(s_i = -10\) cm: virtual, 10 cm behind the mirror.
Magnification. \(M = -(-10)/30 = +0.33\): upright and one third the size, as a convex mirror always gives.
Signs. \(f\) positive for concave, negative for convex; \(s_i\) positive real, negative virtual.
Sign of M. Negative means inverted (real); positive means upright (virtual).
Size of M. Greater than 1 enlarged, less than 1 reduced.
Check. Compare with a ray diagram; use the graph \(1/s_i\) against \(1/s_o\) (slope \(-1\), intercept \(1/f\)) in experiments.
Practice
A concave mirror of focal length 12 cm has an object 36 cm away. Find the image distance and the magnification.
Show answer
\(1/s_i = 1/12 - 1/36 = 2/36\), so \(s_i = +18\) cm. \(M = -18/36 = -0.50\): real, inverted, reduced.
A concave mirror of focal length 20 cm forms a real image 40 cm away. Where is the object?
Show answer
\(1/s_o = 1/20 - 1/40 = 1/40\), so \(s_o = 40\) cm (the object is at the center of curvature, and the image is the same size and inverted, \(M = -1\)).
A convex mirror has \(f = -20\) cm and an object 20 cm away. Find \(s_i\) and \(M\).
Show answer
An image has a magnification of \(-3.0\). What can you say about it?
Show answer
It is inverted (negative \(M\)), so real (for a single mirror), and three times as tall as the object.
In an experiment, \(1/s_i\) is plotted against \(1/s_o\) for a concave mirror and the line crosses the vertical axis at \(0.040\ \text{cm}^{-1}\). What is the focal length?
Show answer
The intercept is \(1/f\), so \(f = 1/0.040 = 25\) cm.
Lesson 13.4 · Unit 13 · CED topic 13.3 (refraction)
A straw in a glass of water looks broken at the surface. A swimming pool looks shallower than it is. A diamond sparkles and window glass does not. All of these come from one fact: light changes speed when it passes from one transparent material into another, and a ray that meets the boundary at an angle changes direction. This bending is refraction. It is the principle behind eyeglasses, microscopes, cameras and the lens of your own eye, which we take up in the following lessons. Here we study the bending itself: what causes it, how it is measured by the index of refraction, and how Snell's law gives the angle.
Learning objective · 13.3.A (refraction)
Describe the refraction of light between two media.
Required content · EK 13.3.A (part)
Refraction is the change in direction of a light ray as the ray passes from one medium into another. Refraction is a result of the speed of light changing when light enters a new medium.
The index of refraction of a medium is inversely proportional to the speed of light in the medium: \(n = c/v\).
Snell's law relates the angles of incidence and refraction of a ray passing from one medium to another to the indices of refraction of the two media: \(n_1\sin\theta_1 = n_2\sin\theta_2\).
When light travels from a medium with a higher index of refraction into one with a lower index, the ray refracts away from the normal; from lower to higher, toward the normal. When a ray is incident along the normal to a surface, the transmitted ray is not refracted.
Speed of light and the index of refraction
In a vacuum all light travels at \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\) m/s. In a material it travels more slowly, at a speed \(v\) that depends on the material. The index of refraction of the material is the ratio
\[ n = \frac{c}{v}. \]
Since \(v \le c\), the index is never less than 1: \(n = 1.00\) for vacuum (and 1.0003 for air, usually rounded to 1.00), about 1.33 for water, about 1.5 for ordinary glass and 2.42 for diamond. A larger index means slower light. The frequency of the light is set by the source and does not change when the light enters a new medium; the wavelength changes in proportion to the speed (\(\lambda = v/f\), Unit 14).
Why a ray bends
Picture a wavefront arriving at an angle to a boundary. One end of the wavefront reaches the new medium first and slows down while the other end is still moving at the original speed, so the wavefront swings around, as a line of marchers turns when one end steps into mud. The ray, being perpendicular to the wavefront, turns with it. If the light enters a slower medium (higher \(n\)) the ray bends toward the normal; if it enters a faster medium (lower \(n\)) it bends away from the normal. A ray traveling along the normal reaches the whole wavefront at once, so it is not deflected at all.
Figure 13.4a Why light bends. The frequency is fixed; in the slower medium the wavelength shrinks (\(\lambda = v/f\)) and the wavefronts, which stay continuous across the boundary, change direction. The ray, perpendicular to the wavefronts, bends toward the normal.
Snell's law
The quantitative relation between the angles was found by Willebrord Snell:
\[ n_1\sin\theta_1 = n_2\sin\theta_2, \]
where \(\theta_1\) is the angle of incidence in medium 1 and \(\theta_2\) is the angle of refraction in medium 2, both measured from the normal. The refracted ray lies in the same plane as the incident ray and the normal. Notice that if \(n_2 \gt n_1\) then \(\sin\theta_2 \lt \sin\theta_1\), so \(\theta_2 \lt \theta_1\) (toward the normal), and the reverse if \(n_2 \lt n_1\). Light paths are reversible: a ray traveling from medium 2 to medium 1 along the refracted path emerges along the incident path.
When the ray passes through a flat sheet with parallel faces, such as a window, the second refraction undoes the first: the emerging ray is parallel to the incident ray, merely shifted sideways. Part of the light is always reflected at each boundary as well, though ray diagrams usually show only the refracted ray.
Figure 13.4b Snell's law examples, \(n_1\sin\theta_1 = n_2\sin\theta_2\). Entering the higher index bends the ray toward the normal; entering the lower index bends it away.
Worked example · speed in glass
Find the speed of light in glass of index 1.50 and in water of index 1.33.
A ray in water travels toward the surface at 30° from the normal. What angle does it make in the air?
Show answer
\(1.33\sin30^\circ = \sin\theta_2\), so \(\sin\theta_2 = 0.665\) and \(\theta_2 = 42^\circ\), bent away from the normal.
A ray strikes a boundary along the normal. What is the angle of refraction?
Show answer
0°. The ray continues undeflected, since \(\sin 0^\circ = 0\).
Light passes from a medium with \(n = 1.2\) into a medium with \(n = 1.6\). Does its speed increase or decrease, and does the ray bend toward or away from the normal?
Show answer
The speed decreases (\(v = c/n\)), and the ray bends toward the normal.
Why does a pool appear shallower than it is when viewed from above at an angle?
Show answer
Rays from the bottom bend away from the normal as they leave the water, so they appear to come from a point higher than the true bottom. The eye traces the rays back in straight lines and sees the apparent (virtual) image of the bottom at a smaller depth.
Look up from underwater at a swimming pool and, at a steep enough angle, the surface turns into a mirror. Light carrying the internet through the ocean floor is held inside hair-thin glass fibers over thousands of kilometers, and a cut diamond seems to hold light and release it in flashes. All three effects arise when light tries to leave a slower medium for a faster one at a large angle: Snell's law has no solution, and all the light is reflected instead. This is total internal reflection, and it follows from the refraction rule of the last lesson once we ask what happens as the angle of incidence grows.
Describe the refraction of light between two media.
Required content · EK 13.3.A (part)
Total internal reflection may occur when light passes from one medium into another medium with a lower index of refraction.
Total internal reflection occurs beyond a critical angle of incidence: \(\sin\theta_c = n_2/n_1\), where \(n_1 \gt n_2\).
For incident rays at the critical angle, the ray refracts at 90° and travels along the surface of the material.
For incident rays beyond the critical angle, all the light is reflected (no light is transmitted into the other medium).
The critical angle
Let light travel from glass (\(n_1 = 1.50\)) toward air (\(n_2 = 1.00\)). Since \(n_2 \lt n_1\), the transmitted ray bends away from the normal, and its angle is always larger than the angle of incidence. As the angle of incidence grows, the angle of refraction grows faster, until the refracted ray skims along the surface, at \(\theta_2 = 90^\circ\). The angle of incidence that does this is the critical angle \(\theta_c\). Setting \(\theta_2 = 90^\circ\) in Snell's law, \(n_1\sin\theta_c = n_2\sin90^\circ\):
\[ \sin\theta_c = \frac{n_2}{n_1}\qquad(n_1 \gt n_2). \]
For any larger angle of incidence there is no angle \(\theta_2\) that satisfies Snell's law, since it would require \(\sin\theta_2 \gt 1\); the light cannot enter the second medium, and all of it is reflected back into the first, obeying the law of reflection. This is total internal reflection. It is "total" because, apart from tiny absorption losses, none of the light is lost, which is better than the typical 90 to 95 percent reflection of a metal mirror.
Total internal reflection can occur only when light travels from a higher index to a lower index; if \(n_2 \gt n_1\) the argument above fails (there is always a refracted ray). For incident angles below \(\theta_c\) most of the light is refracted and a little is reflected; at \(\theta_c\) the refracted ray grazes the surface; beyond \(\theta_c\) the light is entirely reflected.
Figure 13.5a Total internal reflection. Below the critical angle light is refracted (with a weak reflection, dashed); at \(\theta_c\) the refracted ray grazes the surface; beyond it all the light is reflected.
Applications
An optical fiber is a thin strand of glass (core) surrounded by a cladding of glass with a slightly lower index. Light entering the fiber strikes the core-cladding boundary at angles beyond the critical angle, and is reflected again and again with almost no loss, so it can follow a curved path for kilometers. Fibers carry telephone and internet signals and are used in endoscopes to look inside the body. Prisms in binoculars and periscopes use total internal reflection at a glass-air boundary to turn light through 90° or 180°, with less loss than a silvered mirror. A diamond has a high index (2.42) and a small critical angle (about 24°), so light entering through the top is internally reflected several times before leaving, giving its brilliance. Mirages and the shimmering of a road surface in the heat are related effects of gradual refraction.
Figure 13.5b An optical fiber. The core has a higher index than the cladding, and light entering at a shallow angle to the axis meets the core-cladding boundary beyond the critical angle, so it is totally reflected again and again.
Worked example · critical angle in glass
Find the critical angle for light going from glass (\(n = 1.50\)) to air.
Meaning. A ray inside the glass that meets the surface at more than 41.8° from the normal is totally reflected. A 45° prism (as in binoculars) has rays meeting its faces at 45°, which is beyond \(\theta_c\), so they are totally reflected.
Worked example · water and a diver
The critical angle at a water-air surface is found, then used for a light under the water. Find \(\theta_c\) for \(n = 1.33\), and say what happens to a ray in the water at 50° to the normal.
At 50°. This exceeds the critical angle, so no light escapes into the air: the ray is totally reflected back into the water, and the surface acts as a mirror for this ray.
Worked example · no total internal reflection
Can light going from air into glass be totally reflected?
No. The light would be moving from a lower index (1.00) to a higher index (1.50). Snell's law \(1.00\sin\theta_1 = 1.50\sin\theta_2\) always has a solution (\(\theta_2\) is at most \(\sin^{-1}(1/1.5) = 41.8^\circ\)), so some light is always refracted.
Exam focus
Condition. Light going from higher \(n\) to lower \(n\) at an angle beyond \(\theta_c\).
Critical angle. \(\sin\theta_c = n_2/n_1\); at \(\theta_c\) the refracted ray travels along the surface.
Beyond \(\theta_c\). All the light is reflected; none transmitted.
Applications. Optical fibers, prisms, diamonds.
Never for light going from lower to higher index.
Practice
Find the critical angle for light going from diamond (\(n = 2.42\)) into air.
Show answer
\(\sin\theta_c = 1/2.42 = 0.413\), so \(\theta_c = 24.4^\circ\).
A ray in glass of \(n = 1.50\) strikes a glass-water (\(n = 1.33\)) boundary. What is the critical angle?
Show answer
\(\sin\theta_c = 1.33/1.50 = 0.887\), so \(\theta_c = 62.5^\circ\).
A ray in water meets the surface at 40°. Is it totally reflected? (The critical angle is 48.8°.)
Show answer
No. 40° is less than the critical angle, so most of the light is refracted into the air (and a little is reflected).
Why must the cladding of an optical fiber have a lower index than the core?
Show answer
Total internal reflection requires light going from a higher index to a lower index. The core must have the higher index so that rays striking the boundary at large angles are totally reflected and stay in the core.
A ray inside a material strikes the surface at exactly the critical angle. In what direction does the refracted ray travel?
Show answer
Along the surface, at 90° to the normal.
Can total internal reflection occur for light going from air into water? Explain.
Show answer
No. Air has a lower index than water, so Snell's law always gives a refracted ray; total internal reflection happens only from higher to lower index.
Lesson 13.6 · Unit 13 · CED topic 13.4 (lenses and ray diagrams)
A lens is a piece of transparent material, usually glass or plastic, shaped so that refraction at its two curved surfaces bends light in a controlled way. A magnifying glass is a lens; so are the objective of a camera, the lens of your eye, the lenses in eyeglasses, microscopes and telescopes. Where a mirror reflects light back to the side it came from, a lens passes light through, and the image forms on the far side (real) or the near side (virtual). The method for finding the image is the same ray-diagram method as for mirrors, with refraction in place of reflection. This lesson applies it to the two lens types, converging and diverging, and catalogs the images each can form.
Learning objective · 13.4.A (qualitative)
Describe the image formed by a lens.
Required content · EK 13.4.A (part)
Incident rays parallel to the principal axis of a thin convex (converging) lens are refracted and converge toward a common location on the transmitted side of the lens, called the focal point. Parallel rays incident on a thin concave (diverging) lens are refracted and diverge as if they originated from a focal point on the incident side.
A real image is formed by a lens when light rays originating from a common point are refracted such that they intersect at another common point. A virtual image is formed when refracted rays diverge so that they appear to have originated from a common point.
Lenses have a focal point on both sides of the lens that depends on the shape of the respective side of the lens.
Ray diagrams can be used to determine the location, type, size and orientation of images. The three principal rays: (1) the ray parallel to the principal axis, (2) the ray that passes through the center of the lens where the principal axis intersects it, (3) the ray that passes through the focal point. Images can be upright or inverted, virtual or real, and reduced, enlarged or the same size.
Converging and diverging lenses
A thin convex (converging) lens is thicker at the center than at the edges. Rays parallel to the principal axis are refracted so that they converge on the transmitted side at a point called the focal point, at a distance \(f\) from the lens called the focal length. A thin concave (diverging) lens is thinner at the center; parallel rays emerge spread apart, as if they came from a focal point on the incident side. A lens has two focal points, one on each side at the same distance \(f\) for a thin lens in air, because light can come from either direction. A magnifying glass, a camera lens and the lens of the eye are convex; lenses for correcting nearsightedness are concave. The focal length depends on the lens's shape (how strongly curved its surfaces are) and on its index of refraction relative to the surroundings: more curved surfaces and a higher index shorten the focal length. We treat the lens as thin, so that refraction can be pictured as occurring at the single central plane of the lens.
Figure 13.6a Thin lenses. A converging lens bends parallel rays through a real focal point; a diverging lens bends them away from the axis so they appear to come from a virtual focal point. Each lens has a focal point on both sides.
The three principal rays
To find the image of a point on an object, trace two or three of these rays from the point and see where they meet (or appear to meet):
Parallel ray. A ray parallel to the principal axis emerges through the focal point on the far side (converging lens) or as if from the focal point on the near side (diverging lens).
Center ray. A ray through the center of the lens, where the principal axis crosses it, goes straight through without bending (for a thin lens).
Focal ray. A ray through the near focal point (converging lens), or directed toward the far focal point (diverging lens), emerges parallel to the principal axis.
The image is a real image where the refracted rays actually intersect, always on the far side of the lens; it can be shown on a screen, and it is inverted. It is a virtual image where the refracted rays appear to originate (their backward extensions meet), on the same side as the object; it is upright. The patterns for a converging lens:
Object beyond \(2f\): real, inverted, reduced image between \(f\) and \(2f\) (a camera or the eye photographing a distant scene).
Object at \(2f\): real, inverted image at \(2f\), the same size as the object.
Object between \(f\) and \(2f\): real, inverted, enlarged image beyond \(2f\) (a projector).
Object at \(f\): no image (the rays emerge parallel).
Object inside \(f\): virtual, upright, enlarged image on the object's side (a magnifying glass).
A diverging lens produces for every real object a virtual, upright, reduced image between the lens and the focal point on the object's side. The same pattern appears in convex mirrors, which is not an accident: both are diverging devices.
Figure 13.6b Converging lens, \(f = 10\) cm. The three principal rays (parallel, central, focal) locate the image. Dashed lines are backward extensions of rays, not actual light.Figure 13.6c A diverging lens always forms a virtual, upright, reduced image of a real object.Figure 13.6d Images of a converging lens by object position. The image changes character at \(2f\) (same size) and at \(f\) (no image, then virtual).
Worked example · classify the image
A converging lens has \(f = 10\) cm. An object is 25 cm from the lens. Describe the image without calculation.
Where is the object? \(25\ \text{cm} \gt 2f = 20\) cm: beyond \(2f\).
Image. Real, inverted and reduced, between 10 cm and 20 cm from the lens on the far side, as in a camera photographing a scene.
Worked example · the magnifier
Why must an object be held closer than the focal length for a magnifying glass to work?
Inside \(f\). Rays from the object diverge after the lens but less steeply than before. Extended backward, they meet farther from the lens than the object, giving an upright, enlarged, virtual image that the eye can view.
Outside \(f\). The image would be real and inverted: it could be projected on a screen, but the eye looking through the lens at close range would see a blurred, inverted view.
Exam focus
Converging lens. Convex; rays parallel to the axis converge at \(F\); real focal point on the far side.
Diverging lens. Concave; parallel rays spread as if from \(F\) on the object's side.
Principal rays. Parallel to the axis, through the center (undeviated), through the focal point.
Images. Real images are inverted, on the far side; virtual images are upright, on the object's side.
Converging patterns. Beyond \(2f\): reduced real. At \(2f\): same size. Between \(f\) and \(2f\): enlarged real. Inside \(f\): enlarged virtual.
Diverging lens. Always virtual, upright, reduced.
Practice
An object is placed exactly at the focal point of a converging lens. Where is the image?
Show answer
At infinity: the rays emerge parallel and never meet, so no image forms at a finite distance.
Describe the image of an object 8 cm in front of a converging lens of focal length 12 cm.
Show answer
The object is inside \(f\), so the image is virtual, upright and enlarged, on the same side as the object.
What kind of lens can produce a real image?
Show answer
Only a converging (convex) lens, with the object outside the focal length.
Which of the three principal rays is not bent at all by a thin lens, and why?
Show answer
The ray through the center of the lens. At the center the two surfaces are parallel, so it passes through as through a thin flat slab, with negligible displacement.
A student places an object at \(2f\) from a converging lens. Describe the image.
Show answer
Real, inverted, and the same size as the object, located \(2f\) from the lens on the far side.
Why can a real image be seen on a screen but not a virtual one?
Show answer
At a real image the light rays actually converge and cross, so a screen placed there is lit by them. For a virtual image the rays only seem to come from that point; no light reaches it.
Lesson 13.7 · Unit 13 · CED topic 13.4 (thin-lens equation and experiments)
The ray diagram for a lens tells you what kind of image to expect. To say that a projector lens must be 3.2 cm from the slide to focus the picture 4.0 m away, or that a camera must be moved 1.5 mm when you refocus from a distant mountain to a nearby flower, you need numbers. The thin-lens equation and the magnification equation provide them, and they are the same equations as for mirrors, with the same sign convention. This lesson works through examples with converging and diverging lenses, and shows how a lens experiment is designed and analyzed on a graph, which is a frequent task on the AP Physics 2 exam.
Learning objective · 13.4.A (quantitative)
Describe the image formed by a lens.
Required content · EK 13.4.A (part)
For a thin lens, the location of an image depends on the focal length of the lens and on the distance between the object and the midline of the lens, as given by the thin-lens equation: \(\dfrac{1}{s_i} + \dfrac{1}{s_o} = \dfrac{1}{f}\).
The locations of a lens's focal point, an object and the image of the object follow sign conventions used to determine them relative to the lens itself.
For a thin lens, the magnification of an image is the ratio of the size of the image to the size of the object, and depends on the locations of the object and image relative to the lens: \(M = \dfrac{h_i}{h_o} = -\dfrac{s_i}{s_o}\).
Images formed by a lens can be upright or inverted, virtual or real, and reduced, enlarged or the same size as the object.
The equations and the sign convention
For a thin lens with an object at distance \(s_o\) from the lens, the image is at distance \(s_i\) given by
\[ \frac{1}{s_o} + \frac{1}{s_i} = \frac{1}{f}, \qquad M = \frac{h_i}{h_o} = -\frac{s_i}{s_o}. \]
The convention: \(s_o\) is positive for a real object; \(f\) is positive for a converging (convex) lens and negative for a diverging (concave) lens; \(s_i\) is positive for a real image (on the opposite side of the lens from the object) and negative for a virtual image (on the same side as the object). As for mirrors, \(M \lt 0\) means inverted and \(M \gt 0\) upright, and \(|M|\) compares sizes. These are the same equations as for mirrors, but where the mirror's real side is in front of the mirror (the object side), the lens's real side is behind the lens (the far side); the signs tell you which.
The method: write \(1/s_i = 1/f - 1/s_o\), combine the fractions, and invert at the end. Be careful with the final inversion, a frequent source of errors (the reciprocal of a sum is not the sum of reciprocals). Then check against the ray diagram: for \(s_o \gt f\) with a converging lens you should get a positive \(s_i\); for \(s_o \lt f\), a negative \(s_i\); for a diverging lens always a negative \(s_i\) with a real object.
Figure 13.7a The worked examples of this lesson, drawn to scale (distances in cm). The sign of \(s_i\) tells real from virtual, and the sign of \(M\) tells inverted from upright.
Designing a lens experiment
To find the focal length of a converging lens, place an object (a lit bulb or a bright slide) at various distances \(s_o\) from the lens and for each locate the sharp image on a screen at \(s_i\). Then: (1) measure many pairs of distances; (2) plot \(1/s_i\) on the vertical axis against \(1/s_o\) on the horizontal axis; (3) the points should lie on a straight line \(1/s_i = -1/s_o + 1/f\) with slope \(-1\) and vertical intercept \(1/f\), so \(f\) is the reciprocal of the intercept; (4) the horizontal intercept also equals \(1/f\). Plotting the reciprocals is an example of linearizing the data: it turns a curved relationship between \(s_i\) and \(s_o\) into a straight line from which a physical quantity is read off a feature of the graph. Sources of uncertainty include the difficulty of judging the sharpest focus, the thickness of the lens (the distances should be measured from the lens midline), and the finite size of the object.
Figure 13.7b Finding \(f\) by linearization. A straight line of slope \(-1\) confirms the thin-lens equation, and the intercepts give \(1/f\).
Worked example · real image
An object 2.0 cm tall is 30 cm from a converging lens of focal length 10 cm. Find the image position, size and orientation.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/10 - 1/30 = 2/30\), so \(s_i = +15\) cm (real, on the far side).
Magnification. \(M = -15/30 = -0.50\).
Height. \(h_i = (-0.50)(2.0) = -1.0\) cm: inverted and half the size, 1.0 cm tall.
Worked example · the magnifier (object inside f)
The same lens with the object 6.0 cm away.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/10 - 1/6 = -2/30\), so \(s_i = -15\) cm: virtual, on the same side as the object.
Magnification. \(M = -(-15)/6.0 = +2.5\): upright and 2.5 times as large. The image of a 2.0 cm object is 5.0 cm tall.
Worked example · diverging lens
A diverging lens has \(f = -20\) cm. An object is 40 cm from it. Find the image.
Image distance. \(1/s_i = 1/f - 1/s_o = -1/20 - 1/40 = -3/40\), so \(s_i = -13\) cm (virtual, 13 cm from the lens on the object's side).
Magnification. \(M = -(-13.3)/40 = +0.33\): upright and one third the size, the pattern a diverging lens always gives.
Worked example · from data to focal length
In an experiment with a converging lens, an object at 45 cm gives a sharp image at 22.5 cm. Find the focal length.
Equation. \(1/f = 1/45 + 1/22.5 = 1/45 + 2/45 = 3/45\), so \(f = 15\) cm.
Check. The object is at 3\(f\), beyond \(2f\), so the image should be between \(f\) and \(2f\) (15 to 30 cm). It is: 22.5 cm.
A lens produces a real image the same size as the object, 40 cm from the lens. What is its focal length?
Show answer
\(|M| = 1\) means \(s_i = s_o = 40\) cm, so \(1/f = 1/40 + 1/40 = 1/20\) and \(f = 20\) cm (the object is at \(2f\)).
On a graph of \(1/s_i\) (in cm\(^{-1}\)) against \(1/s_o\), a student's data lie on a line crossing the vertical axis at 0.050 cm\(^{-1}\). What is the focal length, and what is the slope of the line?
Show answer
\(f = 1/0.050 = 20\) cm. The slope is \(-1\) (dimensionless).
Unit 13 practice · 10 problems
Unit 13 practice: Geometric Optics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Sign conventions as in the lessons: \(d_i \gt 0\) is real,
\(d_i \lt 0\) is virtual; \(f \gt 0\) for concave mirrors and converging lenses.
Constant: \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\ \text{m/s}\). Calculator allowed.
A person 1.70 m tall stands 2.0 m in front of a vertical plane mirror. Where is the image, how far is the person from the image, and what is the shortest mirror in which they can see their entire body?
Show answer
The image is virtual, upright, the same size, and 2.0 m behind the mirror (\(d_i = -2.0\ \text{m}\)); person-to-image distance is 4.0 m. The ray from any body point reflects at the midpoint height between that point and the eyes, so the mirror need only span half the height: \(0.85\ \text{m}\), independent of distance.
An object stands 45 cm in front of a concave mirror whose radius of curvature is 30 cm. Locate the image, find the magnification, and describe the image.
Show answer
\(f = R/2 = 15\ \text{cm}\). \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{f} - \dfrac{1}{d_o} = \dfrac{1}{15} - \dfrac{1}{45} = \dfrac{2}{45}\), so \(d_i = 22.5\ \text{cm}\). \(m = -\dfrac{d_i}{d_o} = -\dfrac{22.5}{45} = -0.50\). Real (\(d_i \gt 0\)), inverted, half size, 22.5 cm in front of the mirror, between F and C, as expected for an object beyond C.
The same object is placed 40 cm in front of a convex mirror with \(f = -20\ \text{cm}\). Locate and describe the image.
Show answer
\(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{-20} - \dfrac{1}{40} = -\dfrac{3}{40}\), so \(d_i = -13\ \text{cm}\); \(m = -\dfrac{-13.3}{40} = +0.33\). Virtual, upright, one-third size, 13 cm behind the mirror. A convex mirror gives this kind of image for every real object.
An object is placed between a concave mirror and its focal point. The image is
A real, inverted, enlarged image is what a concave mirror gives when the object sits between \(f\) and \(2f\), not inside \(f\). Inside the focal point the reflected rays diverge and never cross in front of the mirror.
A real, inverted, reduced image requires the object to be beyond \(2f\), farther from the mirror than the center of curvature: the opposite placement from the one described.
With \(d_o \lt f\), \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{f} - \dfrac{1}{d_o} \lt 0\), so the image is virtual and behind the mirror, and \(|d_i| \gt d_o\) makes \(|m| \gt 1\): upright and enlarged. This is the makeup-mirror case.
A virtual, upright, reduced image is what a convex mirror (or a diverging lens) produces for any object position. A concave mirror's virtual image is always magnified.
Light of wavelength 600 nm in air strikes a water surface (\(n = 1.33\)) at 50° from the normal. Find the angle of refraction, the speed of light in the water, and the wavelength in the water. What happens to the frequency?
Show answer
\(\sin\theta_2 = \dfrac{n_1\sin\theta_1}{n_2} = \dfrac{\sin 50^\circ}{1.33} = \dfrac{0.766}{1.33} = 0.576\), so \(\theta_2 = 35^\circ\), bent toward the normal. \(v = \dfrac{c}{n} = \dfrac{3.00\times10^{8}}{1.33} = 2.26\times10^{8}\ \text{m/s}\); \(\lambda_n = \dfrac{\lambda}{n} = \dfrac{600}{1.33} = 451\ \text{nm}\). The frequency is unchanged: it is set by the source, and \(v = f\lambda\) makes \(\lambda\) shrink with \(v\).
(a) Find the critical angle for light inside diamond (\(n = 2.42\)) meeting air, and explain in one sentence why a cut diamond sparkles more than a glass imitation (\(n = 1.50\)). (b) Rank the critical angles for light leaving diamond, glass, and water (\(n = 1.33\)) into air, smallest to largest.
Show answer
(a) \(\sin\theta_c = \dfrac{n_2}{n_1} = \dfrac{1.00}{2.42} = 0.413\), so \(\theta_c = 24^\circ\). Any ray inside striking a facet at more than 24° is totally reflected, so light bounces around inside and exits only through the facets it was cut for; glass, with \(\theta_c = 42^\circ\), lets far more light leak out the back. (b) \(\theta_c\) grows as \(n_1\) shrinks: diamond (24°) < glass (42°) < water (49°).
A 2.0 cm tall object stands 15 cm from a converging lens of focal length 10 cm. Describe in words how you would draw the three principal rays from the tip of the object and where they meet, then confirm with the thin-lens equation and find the image height.
Show answer
Draw the axis, the lens as a vertical line, focal points 10 cm on each side, and the arrow 15 cm to the left. From its tip: (1) a ray parallel to the axis refracts through the far focal point; (2) a ray through the center of the lens continues straight; (3) a ray through the near focal point emerges parallel to the axis. All three cross on the far side, below the axis, at the tip of an inverted, enlarged real image. Equation: \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{10} - \dfrac{1}{15} = \dfrac{1}{30}\), so \(d_i = 30\ \text{cm}\); \(m = -\dfrac{30}{15} = -2.0\); \(h_i = (-2.0)(2.0) = -4.0\ \text{cm}\), 4.0 cm tall and inverted, 30 cm beyond the lens.
A magnifying glass with \(f = 8.0\ \text{cm}\) is held 5.0 cm above a page. Locate the image, find the magnification, and explain why you must look through the lens to see it.
Show answer
\(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{8.0} - \dfrac{1}{5.0} = \dfrac{5 - 8}{40} = -\dfrac{3}{40}\), so \(d_i = -13\ \text{cm}\); \(m = -\dfrac{-13.3}{5.0} = +2.7\). Virtual, upright, 2.7 times larger, 13 cm below the lens on the page's side. The rays leaving the lens are still diverging; they never meet, so no screen can catch the image. Your eye traces them back to where they appear to come from.
An object is 30 cm from a diverging lens with \(f = -15\ \text{cm}\). Locate and describe the image. Could a diverging lens alone ever form a real image of a real object? Explain.
Show answer
\(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{-15} - \dfrac{1}{30} = -\dfrac{3}{30} = -\dfrac{1}{10}\), so \(d_i = -10\ \text{cm}\); \(m = -\dfrac{-10}{30} = +0.33\). Virtual, upright, one-third size, 10 cm from the lens on the object's side. No: with \(f \lt 0\) and \(d_o \gt 0\), \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{f} - \dfrac{1}{d_o}\) is always negative, so the image is always virtual.
A camera lens has \(f = 50\ \text{mm}\). A subject at 1.0 m is in sharp focus. The subject then steps closer, to 0.50 m. Find the lens-to-sensor distance in each case and explain in words which way, and how far, the lens must move to refocus.
Show answer
At 1.0 m: \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = \dfrac{1}{0.050} - \dfrac{1}{1.0} = 19.0\ \text{m}^{-1}\), \(d_i = 52.6\ \text{mm}\). At 0.50 m: \(\dfrac{1}{d_i} = 20 - 2.0 = 18.0\ \text{m}^{-1}\), \(d_i = 55.6\ \text{mm}\). A closer object makes \(1/d_o\) larger, so \(1/d_i\) is smaller and \(d_i\) is larger: the lens must move away from the sensor by about 2.9 mm. That is exactly what a focusing ring does.
Flick one end of a rope and a bump races down it to the other end. Drop a pebble in a pond and rings spread outward. Clap your hands and the sound reaches the far wall. In each case something travels, but no piece of rope, water or air travels with it: the rope, the water and the air each end up where they started, and what has moved is energy. This is the defining feature of a wave. In this unit we use waves to understand sound, musical instruments, the colors of soap bubbles and the evidence that light is a wave. This first lesson sets out the basic vocabulary: pulses and waves, mechanical and electromagnetic, transverse and longitudinal, and what determines how fast a wave moves.
Learning objective · 14.1.A
Describe the physical properties of waves and wave pulses.
Required content · EK 14.1.A
Waves transfer energy between two locations without transferring matter between those locations. A wave pulse is a single disturbance that does this; a wave is modeled as a continuous, periodic disturbance with a well-defined wavelength and frequency.
Mechanical waves require a medium in which to propagate; electromagnetic waves do not. The speed of a wave depends on the type of wave and the properties of the medium; the speed of all electromagnetic waves in vacuum is the constant \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\) m/s.
The speed of a wave pulse or wave along a string depends on the tension \(F_T\) and the mass per unit length \(\mu\): \(v = \sqrt{F_T/\mu}\). In a given medium, the speed of sound increases with the temperature of the medium.
In a transverse wave the disturbance is perpendicular to the direction of propagation; in a longitudinal wave it is parallel. Sound waves are mechanical longitudinal waves, with regions of high and low pressure called compressions and rarefactions.
Amplitude is the maximum displacement from equilibrium. The amplitude of a longitudinal pressure wave is the maximum increase or decrease in pressure from equilibrium. The loudness of a sound, and the energy carried by a wave, increase with increasing amplitude.
Energy without matter
A wave is a disturbance that moves through a medium or through space, transferring energy from one place to another without transferring matter. The particles of the medium (the bits of rope, the water molecules, the air molecules) are displaced and then return: they oscillate about fixed equilibrium positions, and each passes the disturbance on to its neighbor. A wave pulse is a single disturbance, such as a single bump on a rope; a wave (in the ordinary sense) is a continuous periodic disturbance, such as the sinusoidal motion produced by a source that vibrates steadily. A cork floating on the water simply bobs up and down as waves pass; it is not carried along.
Mechanical waves need a medium (a material that can be disturbed), and they travel through it because of the forces between its parts: waves on strings, water waves, sound in air, seismic waves. Remove the medium and they cannot travel; that is why there is no sound in a vacuum. Electromagnetic waves (light, radio waves, X-rays, Lesson 14.4) require no medium; they travel through empty space, as sunlight does, at the universal speed \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\) m/s.
Transverse and longitudinal waves
The two basic kinds are distinguished by the direction of the disturbance relative to the direction in which the wave moves. In a transverse wave the particles move perpendicular to the direction of propagation: waves on a rope or string, and electromagnetic waves (whose oscillating quantities are the electric and magnetic fields). In a longitudinal wave the particles move parallel to the direction of propagation, so the medium is alternately squeezed and stretched. Sound is a longitudinal wave in air: a vibrating source pushes the air molecules together into a region of high pressure, a compression, and pulls them apart in a region of low pressure, a rarefaction, and the pattern of compressions and rarefactions moves outward. A coiled spring such as a Slinky can demonstrate both: shake the end sideways to send a transverse pulse, or push and pull it along its length to send a longitudinal pulse.
Figure 14.1a Transverse and longitudinal waves. In a transverse wave the particles move perpendicular to the direction the wave travels; in a longitudinal wave they move along it, producing compressions (high pressure) and rarefactions (low pressure).
Speed of a wave
The speed of a mechanical wave is set by the medium, not by the source. For a pulse or wave on a stretched string it depends on the string's tension \(F_T\) and its mass per unit length \(\mu\) (linear density):
\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{F_T}{\mu}}. \]
Pulling the string tighter makes the restoring forces stronger and the pulse faster; a heavier string is more sluggish. For sound in a gas the speed depends on the temperature: warmer air is faster (about 343 m/s at 20 °C and 331 m/s at 0 °C), because the molecules move faster and pass the disturbance on sooner. Sound is also faster in liquids and solids than in gases (about 1500 m/s in water, 5000 m/s in steel). In all cases the speed of electromagnetic waves in vacuum is \(c\), and in matter they are slower (Unit 13). Changing how the source vibrates (faster, harder) does not change the speed of the wave in the medium; it changes the frequency and the amplitude.
Amplitude and energy
The amplitude \(A\) of a wave is the maximum displacement of the medium from its equilibrium position. For a longitudinal pressure wave, the amplitude is measured by the maximum increase or decrease in pressure from the equilibrium pressure. The energy carried by a wave increases with its amplitude (in fact, in proportion to the square of the amplitude, which is not required here). A bigger disturbance carries more energy: a larger sound amplitude is a louder sound, and a larger water-wave amplitude is a more destructive wave.
Figure 14.1b A pulse moves along the string without carrying the string with it. Its speed depends on the tension and the mass per unit length of the string, not on the size of the pulse.
Worked example · speed on a string
A string has tension 100 N and mass per unit length 0.010 kg/m. How fast does a pulse travel, and how long does it take to cross a 4.0 m length?
If the tension is quadrupled the speed doubles to 200 m/s, since \(v \propto \sqrt{F_T}\).
Worked example · classify the wave
A student pushes a Slinky back and forth along its length, and the pulse moves away. Is it transverse or longitudinal? What would a cork on a pond do as a wave passes?
Slinky. The coils move parallel to the direction in which the pulse travels: a longitudinal wave, with compressions where coils bunch together and rarefactions where they are spread out.
Cork. It moves up and down about its equilibrium position (and, for water waves, a little back and forth) but does not travel with the wave: energy is transferred, not matter.
Exam focus
Waves transfer energy, not matter. Particles oscillate about equilibrium.
Mechanical vs electromagnetic. Mechanical needs a medium; EM does not and moves at \(c\) in vacuum.
Transverse vs longitudinal. Disturbance perpendicular vs parallel to propagation; sound is longitudinal (compressions and rarefactions).
Speed on a string. \(v = \sqrt{F_T/\mu}\); set by the medium, not the source. Sound is faster in warmer air.
Amplitude. More amplitude means more energy and, for sound, more loudness.
Practice
A string of mass per unit length 0.025 kg/m is under a tension of 40 N. What is the wave speed?
Show answer
\(v = \sqrt{40/0.025} = \sqrt{1600} = 40\) m/s.
What happens to the speed of a wave on a string if the tension is increased by a factor of 9?
Show answer
It increases by a factor of 3, because \(v \propto \sqrt{F_T}\).
Why can sound not travel through a vacuum, while light can?
Show answer
Sound is a mechanical wave and needs a medium whose particles pass the disturbance on. Light is an electromagnetic wave, whose oscillating fields need no medium.
In a sound wave, what is the difference between a compression and a rarefaction?
Show answer
A compression is a region of high pressure where the particles are closer together than normal; a rarefaction is a region of low pressure where they are farther apart.
A student claims that increasing the frequency at which she shakes a rope will make the waves travel faster. Is she correct?
Show answer
No. The speed is set by the tension and linear density of the rope. A higher frequency gives a shorter wavelength at the same speed.
A loudspeaker is turned up so that the sound is louder, with the same pitch. Which property of the wave has changed?
Show answer
The amplitude (the maximum pressure variation) has increased, so more energy is carried. The frequency, which sets the pitch, has not changed.
A tuning fork rings at 440 Hz, the A above middle C. A radio station broadcasts at 100 MHz. The light that your eye calls green oscillates about \(5\times10^{14}\) times each second. All of these are periodic waves, patterns that repeat in time and in space, and they are described with the same four ideas: period, frequency, wavelength and speed. The relation among them, \(v = f\lambda\), is the single most-used equation in the unit. This lesson defines each quantity, shows how they connect, and shows how a sinusoidal wave is written down as a function of time at one place or as a function of position at one moment, because the graphs of those two functions look alike and are easy to confuse.
Learning objective · 14.2.A
Describe the physical properties of a periodic wave.
Required content · EK 14.2.A
Periodic waves have regular repetitions that can be described by the period (the time for one complete oscillation) and the frequency (the rate at which the wave repeats): \(T = 1/f\).
The amplitude of a wave is independent of the period and the frequency. The energy of a wave increases with increasing frequency, and the frequency of a sound wave is related to its pitch.
Wavelength is the distance between successive corresponding positions (such as peaks or troughs) on a wave.
A sinusoidal wave can be described by an equation for the displacement from equilibrium at a specific location as a function of time, and by an equation for the displacement at a specific time as a function of position.
For a periodic wave, the wavelength is proportional to the wave speed and inversely proportional to the frequency: \(v = f\lambda\).
Period, frequency, wavelength
Watch one point of the medium as a periodic wave passes: it goes through its cycle of displacements again and again. The period \(T\) is the time for one complete cycle; the frequency \(f\) is the number of cycles per second, measured in hertz (Hz, 1 Hz = 1 s\(^{-1}\)). They are reciprocals:
\[ f = \frac{1}{T}. \]
Now freeze the wave at one instant and look along it: the pattern repeats in space. The wavelength \(\lambda\) is the distance between successive corresponding points, such as two adjacent crests or two adjacent troughs. The amplitude (Lesson 14.1) is the maximum displacement, and it is independent of the period and frequency: you can make a high-frequency wave with a small amplitude or a low-frequency wave with a large amplitude. For a source that vibrates with frequency \(f\), the wave has the same frequency everywhere. Higher-frequency waves carry more energy per cycle; for sound, frequency is perceived as pitch (high frequency, high pitch), while amplitude is perceived as loudness.
The wave equation \(v = f\lambda\)
In one period \(T\) the wave moves forward exactly one wavelength, since the pattern repeats once. So the speed is \(v = \lambda/T\), that is,
\[ v = f\lambda. \]
The speed is determined by the medium (Lesson 14.1) and the frequency by the source, so the wavelength follows: \(\lambda = v/f\). For a given medium, a higher frequency means a shorter wavelength; for a given frequency, a faster medium means a longer wavelength. When a wave passes from one medium to another, its frequency stays the same (it is set by the source, and the boundary cannot create or destroy cycles), but its speed and wavelength change in proportion.
Figure 14.2a Displacement against position gives the wavelength \(\lambda\); displacement against time gives the period \(T\). Always read the axis label first.
Two graphs, two meanings
A sinusoidal wave has two kinds of graph that look alike. A graph of displacement against time at one fixed location shows how one point of the medium oscillates: the horizontal distance between peaks is the period \(T\). A graph of displacement against position at one fixed instant is a snapshot of the whole wave: the horizontal distance between peaks is the wavelength \(\lambda\). Always check the horizontal axis label. In equation form, for a wave moving in the \(+x\) direction with amplitude \(A\), the displacement at position \(x\) and time \(t\) is
\[ y(x,t) = A\sin\!\left[2\pi\left(\frac{t}{T} - \frac{x}{\lambda}\right)\right]. \]
At a fixed position (say \(x = 0\)) this reduces to \(y = A\sin(2\pi t/T)\), a function of time with period \(T\); at a fixed time (\(t = 0\)) it is \(y = -A\sin(2\pi x/\lambda)\), a function of position with period \(\lambda\). (You will not be asked to derive these, only to interpret them.)
Worked example · sound wave
A tuning fork produces a 440 Hz tone. Find the period and the wavelength in air at 20 °C, where the speed of sound is 343 m/s.
Period. \(T = 1/f = 1/440 = 2.27\times10^{-3}\) s.
Wavelength. \(\lambda = v/f = 343/440 = 0.780\) m.
Pitch up an octave (880 Hz) at the same speed would halve the wavelength to 0.39 m.
Worked example · light
Green light has wavelength 550 nm in vacuum. What is its frequency?
Equation. \(f = c/\lambda = (3.00\times10^{8})/(550\times10^{-9}) = 5.45\times10^{14}\) Hz.
Period. \(T = 1/f = 1.8\times10^{-15}\) s, far too short to see: the eye responds to the average.
Worked example · from graphs
A wave on a string is shaken at 5.0 Hz and the speed of waves on the string is 2.0 m/s. What are the wavelength and the period, and what would the horizontal-axis spacing of peaks be on each kind of graph?
Wavelength. \(\lambda = v/f = 2.0/5.0 = 0.40\) m.
Period. \(T = 1/f = 0.20\) s.
Graphs. On a displacement-versus-position graph the peaks are 0.40 m apart; on a displacement-versus-time graph at one point they are 0.20 s apart.
Exam focus
Relations. \(f = 1/T\); \(v = f\lambda\).
What sets what. The source sets the frequency; the medium sets the speed; then \(\lambda = v/f\).
Amplitude. Independent of frequency; sets energy (and loudness); frequency sets pitch.
Two graphs. Displacement vs time gives \(T\); displacement vs position gives \(\lambda\).
Crossing a boundary. Frequency unchanged; speed and wavelength change together.
Practice
A wave has frequency 120 Hz and wavelength 2.5 m. What is its speed?
Show answer
An FM station broadcasts at 100 MHz. What is the wavelength of the radio waves?
Show answer
\(\lambda = c/f = (3.00\times10^{8})/(1.00\times10^{8}) = 3.0\) m.
The period of a wave on a string is 0.050 s and its wavelength is 0.60 m. What is its speed?
Show answer
\(f = 20\) Hz; \(v = f\lambda = 12\) m/s.
A sound wave goes from air into water, where the speed is greater. What happens to its frequency, speed and wavelength?
Show answer
The frequency is unchanged; the speed increases; the wavelength increases in proportion to the speed (\(\lambda = v/f\)).
A displacement-versus-time graph for one point on a string has peaks 0.020 s apart. What is the frequency?
Show answer
The spacing is the period, \(T = 0.020\) s, so \(f = 1/T = 50\) Hz.
Two sound waves have the same amplitude but one has twice the frequency. Which is louder, and which has the higher pitch?
Show answer
Loudness is set by the amplitude, so the two are equally loud (for waves of the same intensity). The wave with the higher frequency has the higher pitch.
Shout in a canyon and you hear an echo: part of the sound is reflected. Shine a flashlight at a window and you see both the light that goes through and a faint reflection in the glass: part is transmitted and part is reflected. Whenever a wave reaches the boundary between two media it divides, and how it divides, and whether the reflected pulse comes back flipped over, depends on how the speed changes across the boundary. This lesson uses waves on strings to see the rules clearly, and then turns to a property of transverse waves that longitudinal waves cannot have: polarization, which is what a pair of polarized sunglasses exploits.
Learning objective · 14.3.A
Describe the interaction between a wave and a boundary.
Required content · EK 14.3.A
A wave that travels from one medium to another can be transmitted or reflected, depending on the properties of the boundary. For example, a wave traveling between low-mass and high-mass strings results in reflected and transmitted waves.
A reflected wave is inverted if the transmitted wave travels into a medium in which the speed of the wave decreases; it is not inverted if the transmitted wave travels into a medium in which the speed increases. The frequency of a wave does not change when it travels from one medium to another.
Transverse waves that are reflected from a surface, refracted through a medium, or pass through specific openings may be polarized: transverse waves can be polarized and oscillate in a single plane; longitudinal waves cannot be polarized.
Polarization of a wave may result in a reduction of the wave's intensity. Intensity is a measure of the power transferred per unit area, the average power per unit area over one period of the wave.
Reflection and transmission
When a pulse reaches a boundary, part of it is reflected back into the first medium and part is transmitted into the second. Picture a light string joined to a heavy string. A pulse on the light string reaches the knot: it must be able to move the heavy string, which is hard (it is sluggish), so the knot hardly moves, the pulse is reflected strongly and a smaller pulse goes on into the heavy string. The rules, which are the heart of this topic, concern the sign of the reflected pulse:
If the pulse goes into a medium in which the wave speed is smaller (light string to heavy string), the reflected pulse is inverted (turned upside down). The transmitted pulse is never inverted.
If the pulse goes into a medium in which the wave speed is larger (heavy string to light string), the reflected pulse is not inverted.
As limiting cases: a string attached to a rigid wall behaves as a medium in which the wave cannot move (infinite mass): the reflected pulse is inverted. A string whose end is free to move (a ring sliding on a pole) reflects the pulse without inversion. The frequency of the wave does not change when it crosses a boundary, since the particles at the boundary are shaken at the incoming frequency and shake the next medium at that same rate. Because the speed changes, the wavelength changes in proportion: \(\lambda = v/f\), smaller in the medium where the wave is slower. The pattern is the same for light at a boundary between media; it determines the phase shifts that matter for thin films in Lesson 14.11.
Figure 14.3a Reflection at a junction of two strings. When the wave speed decreases in the second medium the reflected pulse is inverted; when it increases the reflected pulse is upright. The transmitted pulse is always upright, and the frequency never changes.
Polarization of transverse waves
A transverse wave oscillates perpendicular to the direction in which it moves, but "perpendicular" leaves a choice of directions around the line of travel. A wave on a rope shaken only up and down oscillates in a single plane: it is polarized (linearly polarized, in a vertical plane). A rope shaken in random directions is unpolarized. A vertical slit in a fence lets a vertical wave through but blocks a horizontal one, like a filter. Light is a transverse electromagnetic wave, and the light from a lamp or the Sun is unpolarized: it is a mixture of oscillation planes. A polarizing filter (as in polarized sunglasses or a camera filter) transmits only the component of the light that oscillates along its transmission axis. Light can also become polarized by reflection (glare from a road or water is partly polarized horizontally), by refraction, or by passing through a filter.
Longitudinal waves cannot be polarized. Sound oscillates along the direction of travel; there is only one direction, so no plane can be selected. The fact that light can be polarized shows that it is a transverse wave: that was the evidence for the transverse nature of light in the 19th century.
Figure 14.3b Polarization. A polarizing filter passes only the component of the light that oscillates along its axis. Unpolarized light loses half its intensity; crossed filters block all the light.
Intensity
The intensity of a wave is the average power it delivers per unit area perpendicular to its direction of travel, averaged over one period:
\[ I = \frac{P}{A}, \]
in watts per square meter. A source radiating uniformly in all directions spreads its power over the surface of a sphere of area \(4\pi r^{2}\), so \(I = P/(4\pi r^{2})\), which falls off as \(1/r^{2}\). A polarizer reduces the intensity because it absorbs the component of the wave that oscillates along the other direction: an ideal polarizing filter transmits half the intensity of unpolarized light, and polarized light passing through a second filter whose axis is perpendicular to the first (crossed filters) is blocked entirely. Between these extremes, the intensity depends on the angle between the polarization and the filter's axis (qualitatively: the less the alignment, the less the transmission).
Worked example · pulse at a junction
A pulse travels along a light string toward a junction with a heavy string. Describe the reflected and transmitted pulses, and compare the wavelengths if the frequency is 50 Hz, the speed on the light string is 40 m/s and on the heavy string 20 m/s.
Reflected. The speed decreases in the second medium, so the reflected pulse is inverted. Transmitted. Upright (never inverted), and smaller than the incident pulse.
Wavelengths. The frequency is 50 Hz on both strings. \(\lambda_1 = v_1/f = 40/50 = 0.80\) m and \(\lambda_2 = 20/50 = 0.40\) m: half as long on the heavy string.
Worked example · intensity
A 100 W source radiates uniformly in all directions. What is the intensity at 2.0 m, and what area at that distance receives 1.0 W?
Boundary. A wave is partly reflected and partly transmitted.
Inversion. Reflected pulse inverted if the speed decreases (to heavier/denser medium); not inverted if the speed increases. Transmitted pulse is not inverted.
Frequency. Unchanged across a boundary; wavelength changes with speed.
Polarization. Only transverse waves; longitudinal waves (sound) cannot be polarized.
Intensity. \(I = P/A\); an ideal polarizer passes half the unpolarized intensity; crossed polarizers block light.
Practice
A pulse on a heavy string reaches a junction with a light string. Is the reflected pulse inverted?
Show answer
No. The speed is greater in the light string, so the reflected pulse is not inverted.
A pulse on a string reaches a fixed end (wall). What happens to the reflected pulse?
Show answer
It is inverted: the wall acts as a medium in which the pulse cannot move.
A wave of frequency 200 Hz crosses a boundary into a medium where its speed is half as large. What are the new frequency and wavelength ratio?
Show answer
The frequency stays at 200 Hz. The wavelength is half as long, since \(\lambda = v/f\).
Why can sound waves not be polarized?
Show answer
Sound is longitudinal: the oscillation is along the direction of propagation, so there is no perpendicular plane in which it could be confined.
A lamp radiates 60 W uniformly. What is the intensity at 1.5 m?
Show answer
\(I = 60/[4\pi(1.5)^{2}] = 2.1\) W/m².
Two polarizing filters are crossed (axes perpendicular). A third filter with its axis at 45° is placed between them. Does any light get through? Explain qualitatively.
Show answer
Yes. The first filter polarizes the light; the middle filter passes the component along its 45° axis, re-polarizing the light at 45°; the last filter, 45° from that, passes a component of it. Without the middle filter nothing gets through, but with it some does.
The radio in a car, the microwave oven in the kitchen, the lamp that lights this page, the sunburn that follows a day at the beach and the X-ray at the dentist are all the same kind of wave, differing only in wavelength. Maxwell showed in the 1860s that a changing electric field makes a magnetic field and a changing magnetic field makes an electric field (Faraday's law, Unit 12), so the two can sustain each other and travel through empty space as a wave. He calculated its speed and found it to be the speed of light. Light is an electromagnetic wave. This lesson describes how such a wave is built and arranges the electromagnetic spectrum in order.
Learning objective · 14.4.A
Describe the properties of an electromagnetic wave.
Required content · EK 14.4.A
Electromagnetic waves consist of oscillating electric and magnetic fields that are mutually perpendicular. They are transverse waves because the oscillations of the fields are perpendicular to the direction of propagation, and they are commonly assumed to be plane waves, characterized by planar wavefronts.
Electromagnetic waves do not need a medium through which to propagate.
Categories of electromagnetic waves are characterized by their wavelengths. In order of decreasing wavelength (from kilometers to picometers): radio waves, microwaves, infrared, visible, ultraviolet, X-rays and gamma rays. Visible light is broken into colors, in order of decreasing wavelength: red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet.
Visible electromagnetic waves are also called light; sometimes electromagnetic waves of all wavelengths are collectively referred to as light or electromagnetic radiation.
Boundary: students are expected to know the ordering of the spectrum but not the exact wavelength ranges.
What an electromagnetic wave is
An electromagnetic (EM) wave is a self-sustaining pattern of oscillating electric and magnetic fields. At every point the electric field \(\vec{E}\) and the magnetic field \(\vec{B}\) are perpendicular to each other, and both are perpendicular to the direction in which the wave travels, so an EM wave is a transverse wave. The two oscillate in phase: where the electric field is at a maximum so is the magnetic field. The wave is produced by accelerating electric charges (the oscillating current in an antenna, the vibrating electrons in a hot filament, electrons dropping between atomic energy levels). Far from the source it is usually modeled as a plane wave, whose wavefronts are flat planes perpendicular to the direction of propagation, with the fields uniform on each plane.
An EM wave needs no medium: the fields themselves carry the disturbance, which is why light reaches us from the Sun across empty space. In a vacuum all EM waves travel at the same speed \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\) m/s, whatever their wavelength, so the wave relation \(c = f\lambda\) ties each wavelength to a definite frequency. In matter, the speed is less, \(v = c/n\) (Lesson 13.4), but the frequency is the same. EM waves carry energy and, like all waves, transfer no matter.
Figure 14.4a An electromagnetic wave is made of oscillating electric and magnetic fields that are perpendicular to each other and to the direction of travel, so it is a transverse wave. It needs no medium and travels at \(c\) in vacuum.
The electromagnetic spectrum
EM waves are classified by wavelength (or equivalently frequency). In order of decreasing wavelength, from kilometers down to picometers, the categories are:
Radio waves (meters to kilometers), from broadcasting, communication and radar.
Microwaves (millimeters to centimeters), used for ovens, satellite links and Wi-Fi.
Infrared, emitted by warm objects and used in remote controls and thermal imaging.
Visible light (roughly 400 to 700 nm), to which the human eye is sensitive: in order of decreasing wavelength, red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet.
Ultraviolet, which causes sunburn and is used for sterilization.
X-rays, produced when fast electrons stop in matter, used in medical imaging.
Gamma rays (the shortest wavelengths), emitted by radioactive nuclei and in astronomical events.
The sequence (radio, microwave, infrared, visible, ultraviolet, X-ray, gamma) is what you must know; exact boundaries are not required. The boundaries blur: the ranges overlap, and the same wave may be called an X-ray or a gamma ray depending on its origin. Frequency and photon energy (Unit 15) increase in the opposite order from wavelength, so gamma rays and X-rays are the most energetic and are ionizing, which is why they are dangerous in large doses, while radio waves are harmless at ordinary intensities. Because \(v = f\lambda\) with a fixed \(c\), a wave with a longer wavelength has a lower frequency.
Figure 14.4b The electromagnetic spectrum in order of decreasing wavelength. Exact wavelength boundaries need not be memorized; the order does.
Worked example · wavelengths and frequencies
Find the wavelength of (a) an FM radio wave of frequency 100 MHz and (b) microwaves of frequency 2.45 GHz in an oven.
(a) \(\lambda = c/f = (3.00\times10^{8})/(1.00\times10^{8}) = 3.0\) m.
(b) \(\lambda = (3.00\times10^{8})/(2.45\times10^{9}) = 0.122\) m, about 12 cm.
Worked example · across the spectrum
Compare the frequencies of red light (700 nm) and violet light (400 nm), and of an X-ray of wavelength 0.10 nm.
Red. \(f = c/\lambda = (3.00\times10^{8})/(700\times10^{-9}) = 4.3\times10^{14}\) Hz.
Violet. \(f = (3.00\times10^{8})/(400\times10^{-9}) = 7.5\times10^{14}\) Hz, higher: violet has the shorter wavelength.
X-ray. \(f = (3.00\times10^{8})/(0.10\times10^{-9}) = 3.0\times10^{18}\) Hz, thousands of times higher than visible light.
Exam focus
Structure. Oscillating \(\vec{E}\) and \(\vec{B}\), perpendicular to each other and to the direction of travel: transverse; plane waves.
No medium. EM waves travel in vacuum at \(c\); \(c = f\lambda\).
An ambulance races toward you with its siren wailing. As it passes, the pitch drops abruptly, from a higher note to a lower one, although the siren itself has not changed. The same effect lets police radar measure the speed of a car, lets doctors measure the flow of blood, and lets astronomers find that distant galaxies are rushing away from us. It is the Doppler effect, a change in the observed frequency of a wave due to relative motion of the source and the observer. On the AP Physics 2 exam it is treated qualitatively: you must be able to say whether the observed frequency is higher, lower or the same, and why.
Learning objective · 14.5.A
Describe the properties of a wave based on the relative motion between the source of the wave and the observer of the wave.
Required content · EK 14.5.A
The Doppler effect describes the relationship between the rest frequency of a wave source, the observed frequency of the source, and the relative velocity of the source and the observer.
A greater relative velocity results in a greater measured difference between the observed and rest frequencies.
For a source moving at the same velocity as the observer, the observed frequency is equal to the rest frequency. For a source moving toward an observer, the observed frequency is greater than the rest frequency. For a source moving away from an observer, the observed frequency is less than the rest frequency.
Boundary: only qualitative treatments of the Doppler effect are required.
A moving source
A source at rest emits wavefronts at a steady rate, each spreading outward as a circle centered on the source. If the source moves, each wavefront is emitted from a different position, but once emitted it spreads from the point where it was emitted, at the speed of the wave in the medium, independent of the motion of the source. Ahead of the moving source the wavefronts are crowded together: successive crests are closer, so the wavelength is shorter, and since the speed through the medium is fixed, more crests per second reach an observer there: the observed frequency is higher. Behind the source the wavefronts are spread out: the wavelength is longer, fewer crests per second arrive, and the observed frequency is lower.
Figure 14.5a The Doppler effect. Each wavefront spreads from where it was emitted. Ahead of a moving source the wavefronts are crowded (shorter wavelength, higher observed frequency); behind it they are spread out (lower observed frequency).
The rule
Let \(f_0\) be the rest frequency (the frequency measured when the source and observer are at rest relative to each other) and \(f\) the observed frequency.
Source and observer approaching (the distance between them decreasing): \(f \gt f_0\).
Source and observer receding (the distance increasing): \(f \lt f_0\).
No relative motion (including a source and observer moving together with the same velocity): \(f = f_0\).
The greater the relative speed, the larger the difference \(|f - f_0|\).
What matters is the relative motion along the line joining the source and the observer. For motion of the observer, the effect is the same in kind: an observer moving toward the source meets crests more often than if at rest, and so measures a higher frequency; moving away, a lower frequency. A car moving with the ambulance hears the rest frequency. A source moving perpendicular to the line of sight at the instant of observation produces (to a first approximation) no change at that instant, which is why the pitch of a passing siren changes abruptly at the closest approach, shifting from higher to lower. The actual frequency emitted does not change; the observed frequency does. The same reasoning applies to any wave: for light, a source receding from us has its light shifted to lower frequency, or longer wavelength (a "redshift"), and an approaching source is "blueshifted"; the red shifts of distant galaxies are evidence that the universe is expanding.
Worked example · the passing siren
An ambulance siren has a rest frequency of 700 Hz. Describe what a stationary observer hears as it approaches, passes, and recedes.
Approaching. The observed frequency is greater than 700 Hz (a higher pitch).
Passing. At the instant of closest approach the relative motion along the line of sight is momentarily zero, and the pitch drops through 700 Hz.
Receding. The observed frequency is less than 700 Hz (a lower pitch).
Faster ambulance. The higher and lower pitches differ more from 700 Hz.
Worked example · same velocity
A passenger in a car follows the ambulance, moving at the same velocity. What frequency does the passenger observe?
Relative velocity is zero. The distance between source and observer does not change, so the observed frequency equals the rest frequency, 700 Hz, even though both are moving relative to the road.
Exam focus
Approaching. Observed frequency greater than rest frequency (shorter wavelength).
Receding. Observed frequency less than rest frequency (longer wavelength).
No relative motion. Observed equals rest frequency.
Speed. Greater relative speed gives a greater difference.
Source frequency is unchanged; only what the observer measures changes. For light: blueshift (approaching) and redshift (receding).
Practice
A train horn has a rest frequency of 400 Hz. Is the frequency heard by a person on the platform higher or lower as the train approaches?
Show answer
Higher than 400 Hz: the source is approaching.
A train passing at higher speed produces a larger or smaller shift than a slower one?
Show answer
Larger; a greater relative speed gives a greater difference between the observed and rest frequencies.
An observer runs toward a stationary loudspeaker. Is the observed frequency greater than, equal to or less than the speaker's rest frequency?
Show answer
Greater: the observer meets more wave crests per second.
Light from a distant galaxy has its spectral lines at longer wavelengths than in the laboratory. What does this suggest about the galaxy's motion?
Show answer
The galaxy is moving away from us (receding): the observed frequency is lower and the wavelength longer, a redshift.
A student says that the siren changes its pitch as it passes. Explain what is really happening.
Show answer
The siren emits the same frequency all the time. The observer's relative motion with respect to the source changes from approaching to receding, so the observed frequency changes from above to below the rest frequency.
A source and an observer move together at the same constant velocity. Is there a Doppler shift?
Show answer
No: the relative velocity is zero, so the observed frequency equals the rest frequency.
Lesson 14.6 · Unit 14 · CED topic 14.6 (superposition)
Two ripples on a pond cross and pass through each other without either being changed. Two people talking in a room do not bounce each other's voices away. When waves meet, they do not collide the way balls do; they pass through each other, and while they overlap, the medium simply responds to both at once. That simple fact, superposition, explains why noise-canceling headphones work, why soap films show colors, why a tuning-fork pair makes a pulsing sound, and why concert halls have dead spots. This lesson states the superposition principle, distinguishes constructive from destructive interference, and shows how two waves of slightly different frequency produce beats.
Learning objective · 14.6.A
Describe the net disturbance that occurs when two or more wave pulses or waves overlap.
Required content · EK 14.6.A
Wave interference is the interaction of two or more wave pulses or waves. When they interact they travel through each other and overlap rather than bouncing off each other.
When two or more wave pulses or waves overlap, the resulting displacement can be determined by adding the individual displacements. This is called superposition.
Interference may be constructive (displacements in the same direction) or destructive (displacements in opposite directions). Two or more traveling waves can interact so as to produce amplitude variations in the resultant wave.
Visual representations of wave pulses or waves are useful in determining the result of two interacting pulses or waves.
Beats arise from the addition of two waves of slightly different frequency. The waves are sometimes in phase and sometimes out of phase, causing periodic amplitude changes. The beat frequency is the difference in the frequencies: \(f_{beat} = |f_1 - f_2|\). Tuning forks are devices commonly used to demonstrate beat frequencies.
Superposition
When two or more waves overlap in the same region, the displacement at each point is the algebraic sum of the displacements the individual waves would produce there:
\[ y_{net} = y_1 + y_2 + \cdots \]
This is the principle of superposition. The waves do not alter each other: after they have passed through the region of overlap they continue exactly as before. To find the combined disturbance, draw each pulse (or wave) and add the heights point by point, counting displacements up as positive and down as negative. If the two displacements have the same sign the result is bigger than either (constructive interference); if they have opposite signs the result is smaller (destructive interference), and equal and opposite pulses cancel exactly for an instant, as when two equal pulses of opposite sign pass through each other on a string. The energy is not destroyed in destructive interference: it is redistributed, appearing elsewhere (at places of constructive interference) or being temporarily stored in the motion of the medium.
Figure 14.6a Superposition. Where the pulses overlap their displacements add, giving constructive interference (same side) or destructive interference (opposite sides). The pulses then pass through each other and continue unchanged.
Interference of two waves
For continuous waves the outcome depends on the phase relationship between them at each point. Two identical waves in phase (crests on crests) give a wave of double the amplitude; two identical waves exactly out of phase (crests on troughs) cancel completely. In between, the amplitude is intermediate. For two sources that emit identical waves in phase, the phase difference at a point depends on the difference in the distances traveled, the path difference \(\Delta\):
Constructive interference where \(\Delta = m\lambda\) (a whole number of wavelengths, \(m = 0, 1, 2, \ldots\)).
Destructive interference where \(\Delta = (m + \tfrac{1}{2})\lambda\) (a half-integer number of wavelengths).
This is the basis of the double-slit pattern (Lesson 14.10), and it is the same logic as for thin films (Lesson 14.11). Noise-canceling headphones apply it: a microphone picks up the ambient noise and the electronics produce a wave of equal amplitude and opposite phase, which destructively interferes with the noise at the ear.
Figure 14.6b Interference of two waves. In phase (path difference a whole number of wavelengths) they reinforce; half a wavelength out of phase they cancel.
Beats
If two waves of slightly different frequencies \(f_1\) and \(f_2\) arrive at the same place, they are sometimes in phase and sometimes out of phase, and the sum alternates between loud (constructive) and soft (destructive) in a regular pulsation. These pulses are beats. In each second, the faster wave gains a number of cycles equal to the frequency difference, so the loudness rises and falls at the beat frequency
\[ f_{beat} = |f_1 - f_2|. \]
The pitch heard is close to the average of the two frequencies. Piano tuners and guitarists use beats to tune: when a string is compared with a tuning fork (or another string) the beats get slower as the frequencies get closer, and stop when they match. If the beat frequency is 4 Hz, the unknown string is either 4 Hz above or 4 Hz below the reference; adjusting the tension and seeing whether the beat rate rises or falls tells which.
Figure 14.6c Beats. Waves of slightly different frequency are alternately in and out of phase, so the amplitude of the sum rises and falls at \(|f_1 - f_2|\), here 4 Hz.
Worked example · beats
A 440 Hz tuning fork and a guitar string are sounded together and four beats are heard each second. What are the possible frequencies of the string? After the string is tightened slightly, the beats speed up to 6 per second. Which was it?
Possible frequencies. \(|f - 440| = 4\), so \(f = 444\) Hz or \(436\) Hz.
Tighten the string. This raises its frequency. If it started at 444 Hz the difference would rise to 6 (for example, 446 Hz). If it started at 436 Hz the difference would fall. So the string was at 444 Hz.
Worked example · two speakers
Two small speakers in phase emit a 686 Hz tone (\(\lambda = 343/686 = 0.50\) m in air). A listener is 3.00 m from one and 4.25 m from the other. Is the sound loud or quiet?
Result. A half-integer number of wavelengths, so the waves arrive out of phase: destructive interference, a quiet spot. Moving 0.25 m farther from one speaker would make \(\Delta\) a whole number of wavelengths (3.0 \(\lambda\)) and give constructive interference.
Exam focus
Superposition. Add displacements algebraically; waves pass through each other unchanged.
Constructive vs destructive. Same-direction displacements add; opposite-direction ones subtract.
Two sources. Constructive at path difference \(m\lambda\); destructive at \((m+\tfrac12)\lambda\).
Beats. Slightly different frequencies; beat frequency \(|f_1 - f_2|\); amplitude varies periodically.
Energy. Conserved: redistributed in interference.
Practice
Two pulses of equal height, one upward and one downward, meet on a string. What is the displacement at the instant they exactly overlap?
Show answer
Zero everywhere in the overlap: they cancel (complete destructive interference). They then continue unchanged.
Two tuning forks of 256 Hz and 260 Hz are sounded together. What is the beat frequency and the period of the beats?
Show answer
\(f_{beat} = 4\) Hz; the period is 0.25 s.
Two identical in-phase sources emit waves of wavelength 0.40 m. A point P is 3.20 m from one source and 4.00 m from the other. What is the interference at P?
Show answer
\(\Delta = 0.80\) m \(= 2.0\lambda\): a whole number of wavelengths, so constructive interference.
Why do the beats stop when two strings are exactly in tune?
Show answer
The beat frequency is the difference of the frequencies, which is zero when the strings have the same frequency; the waves stay in phase and there is no periodic variation in loudness.
In destructive interference, where does the energy go?
Show answer
It is not destroyed. It is redistributed: energy that is missing at the places of destructive interference appears at places of constructive interference (and in the overall motion of the medium).
Two waves of amplitude 3 cm and 2 cm overlap. What are the largest and smallest possible amplitudes of the combination?
Show answer
Largest 5 cm (fully constructive) and smallest 1 cm (fully destructive).
Pluck a guitar string and it vibrates in a smooth arc, loops that seem to stand still while the string shakes up and down. Hold one finger lightly at the string's middle and pluck again and the pitch jumps up an octave, with a node at the middle where your finger rests. These are standing waves. They form when two waves of equal amplitude travel in opposite directions in a confined region and interfere. On a string fixed at both ends, the reflected wave coming back from one end meets the wave going out, and only certain wavelengths fit. That restriction is the reason a string has a definite set of notes and is the foundation of every stringed instrument.
Learning objective · 14.6.B (strings)
Describe the properties of a standing wave.
Required content · EK 14.6.B (part)
Standing waves can result from interference between two waves that are confined to a region and traveling in opposite directions. Standing waves have nodes (points where the amplitude is always zero) and antinodes (points where the amplitude is always at a maximum).
The possible wavelengths of a standing wave are determined by the size and boundary conditions of the region to which it is confined; common regions include pipes with open or closed ends and strings with fixed or loose ends.
A standing wave with the longest possible wavelength is the fundamental or first harmonic; the second-longest wavelength is the second harmonic, and so on.
Visual representations of standing waves are useful in determining the relationships among the length of the region, wavelength, frequency, wave speed and harmonic.
How a standing wave forms
A wave traveling along a string is reflected at the end and returns. The incident and reflected waves have the same frequency and amplitude and travel in opposite directions, and by superposition their sum has a fixed pattern: at certain points the two always cancel (nodes, where the amplitude is always zero), and halfway between them they always add (antinodes, where the amplitude is a maximum). The pattern does not travel; each point of the string oscillates up and down with its own fixed amplitude, zero at the nodes. Adjacent nodes are half a wavelength apart, as are adjacent antinodes, and a node and the next antinode are a quarter-wavelength apart.
A string with both ends fixed must have a node at each end, because the ends cannot move. This restricts the possible wavelengths to those that fit an integer number of half-wavelengths into the length \(L\):
\[ L = n\,\frac{\lambda_n}{2} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \lambda_n = \frac{2L}{n},\qquad n = 1, 2, 3, \ldots \]
The longest wavelength, \(n = 1\), is the fundamental or first harmonic, with \(\lambda_1 = 2L\) and a single antinode in the middle. The second harmonic (\(n = 2\)) has \(\lambda_2 = L\), a node at the center and two antinodes; the third has three antinodes, and so on. Every integer harmonic is allowed on a string fixed at both ends. The corresponding frequencies, from \(f = v/\lambda\), are
\[ f_n = \frac{v}{\lambda_n} = n\,\frac{v}{2L} = n f_1, \]
whole-number multiples of the fundamental \(f_1 = v/2L\), where \(v = \sqrt{F_T/\mu}\) is the speed of waves on the string (Lesson 14.1). So the notes of a string depend on its length (shorter means higher), tension (tighter means higher) and mass per length (lighter means higher): the three things a guitarist changes by fingering, tuning and choosing the string. A string with one end fixed and the other free (loose) would have a node at the fixed end and an antinode at the free end, so only odd harmonics, as in the closed pipe of the next lesson.
Figure 14.7a Standing waves on a string with both ends fixed. The fundamental has \(\lambda = 2L\); each higher harmonic fits one more half-wavelength, \(f_n = nv/2L\).
Reading a standing wave diagram
A diagram of a standing wave shows the extreme positions of the string (the envelope) with nodes at the points that never move. To use it: count the number of antinodes (loops) \(n\) between the fixed ends: that is the harmonic number; the wavelength is \(2L/n\); then \(f = nv/2L\). If a problem gives you the frequency and the length, you can find the speed of the waves, \(v = f\lambda\), and then the tension. When you change the tension, the speed changes but the length does not, so the harmonics move to new frequencies in proportion to \(\sqrt{F_T}\).
Worked example · fundamental and harmonics
A string of length 0.60 m fixed at both ends supports waves of speed 120 m/s. Find the wavelength and frequency of the fundamental and of the next two harmonics.
Fundamental. \(\lambda_1 = 2L = 1.20\) m, \(f_1 = v/\lambda_1 = 120/1.20 = 100\) Hz.
Second. \(\lambda_2 = L = 0.60\) m, \(f_2 = 200\) Hz.
Third. \(\lambda_3 = 2L/3 = 0.40\) m, \(f_3 = 300\) Hz.
Worked example · tuning a string
The tension in the string is quadrupled. What happens to the fundamental frequency?
Speed. \(v = \sqrt{F_T/\mu}\) doubles.
Frequency. The wavelength of the fundamental, \(2L\), is unchanged, so \(f_1 = v/2L\) doubles, to 200 Hz: the pitch rises by an octave.
Worked example · from a diagram
A standing wave on a 1.5 m string fixed at both ends shows four antinodes, and the string vibrates at 80 Hz. Find the wavelength, the speed, and the fundamental frequency.
Harmonic. Four antinodes means \(n = 4\), so \(\lambda = 2L/4 = 0.75\) m.
Speed. \(v = f\lambda = (80)(0.75) = 60\) m/s.
Fundamental. \(f_1 = f/4 = 20\) Hz.
Exam focus
Standing wave. Two equal waves traveling in opposite directions; nodes (zero amplitude) and antinodes (maximum).
Fixed-fixed string. Nodes at both ends; \(\lambda_n = 2L/n\); \(f_n = nv/2L\); every harmonic allowed.
Spacing. Adjacent nodes: \(\lambda/2\); node to antinode: \(\lambda/4\).
What are the frequencies of the second and third harmonics of a string whose fundamental is 150 Hz?
Show answer
300 Hz and 450 Hz.
How many nodes (including the ends) does the third harmonic of a string fixed at both ends have?
Show answer
Four: the two ends plus two interior nodes (three antinodes).
A violinist presses a finger to shorten the vibrating length of a string from 0.32 m to 0.24 m. By what factor does the fundamental frequency change?
Show answer
\(f \propto 1/L\), so \(f\) increases by a factor of \(0.32/0.24 = 1.33\).
A string's fundamental frequency is 100 Hz. If a student wants 150 Hz without changing the string's length, by what factor should the tension be changed?
Show answer
\(f \propto \sqrt{F_T}\), so \(F_T\) must be multiplied by \((150/100)^{2} = 2.25\).
Blow across the top of a bottle and it hums; blow a flute, a trumpet or an organ pipe and the air inside sings at a pitch set by the length of the tube. Sound is a longitudinal wave, but the standing-wave idea is the same: waves reflect from the ends of the tube and interfere. The ends now fall into two kinds. An open end lets the air move freely in and out, so it is where the motion of the air is greatest (a displacement antinode), while a closed end does not let the air move at all (a displacement node). Those two boundary conditions determine the possible wavelengths. This lesson derives the harmonics of open and closed pipes and shows why a closed pipe produces only odd harmonics.
Learning objective · 14.6.B (air columns)
Describe the properties of a standing wave.
Required content · EK 14.6.B (part)
The possible wavelengths of a standing wave are determined by the size and boundary conditions of the region to which it is confined. Common regions include pipes with open or closed ends, as well as strings with fixed or loose ends.
A standing wave with the longest possible wavelength is the fundamental or first harmonic; the second-longest is typically called the second harmonic, and so on. However, for a standing wave with a node at one end and an antinode at the other end, only odd harmonics can be established.
Visual representations of standing waves are useful in determining the relationships between the length of the region, wavelength, frequency, wave speed and harmonic.
Boundary conditions in a pipe
A sound wave in a pipe can be described by the displacement of the air molecules. At a closed end the air cannot move along the pipe, so there is a displacement node. At an open end the air is free to move, so there is a displacement antinode (just beyond the end, in practice, by a small amount that we ignore). The pressure variation behaves in the opposite way: where the displacement has a node, the pressure variation has an antinode, but the standard exam diagrams, and this lesson, use displacement. Standing waves in the pipe have a node or antinode at each end consistent with these conditions. A node and the next antinode are \(\lambda/4\) apart, which fixes which wavelengths fit.
Pipe open at both ends
With an antinode at each end, an integer number of half-wavelengths must fit in the length \(L\), just like the string:
\[ \lambda_n = \frac{2L}{n},\qquad f_n = n\,\frac{v}{2L},\qquad n = 1, 2, 3, \ldots \]
Every harmonic is present. The fundamental has \(\lambda_1 = 2L\) with a node in the middle and an antinode at each end. Flutes and open organ pipes are of this type.
Pipe closed at one end
With a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, the shortest fit is a quarter wavelength: \(L = \lambda/4\). The next possible pattern adds a half-wavelength, so \(L = 3\lambda/4\), then \(5\lambda/4\), and so on, giving only odd multiples of a quarter-wavelength:
\[ \lambda_n = \frac{4L}{n},\qquad f_n = n\,\frac{v}{4L},\qquad n = 1, 3, 5, \ldots \]
The fundamental is \(f_1 = v/4L\), which is half that of an open pipe of the same length: a closed pipe sounds an octave lower. Only the odd harmonics (\(f_1, 3f_1, 5f_1, \ldots\)) can be established, which gives the closed pipe (a clarinet, a bottle, a stopped organ pipe) its characteristic hollow tone. Any standing wave with a node at one end and an antinode at the other end has this odd-harmonic property, including the string with one fixed and one free end.
Figure 14.8a Air-column standing waves. An open end is a displacement antinode and a closed end a displacement node, so open-open pipes support every harmonic and closed-open pipes only the odd ones.
Using the diagrams
Draw the standing wave in the tube with the correct pattern at each end, count the quarter or half wavelengths that fit in \(L\), and read off \(\lambda\); then \(f = v/\lambda\) with \(v\) the speed of sound in air (343 m/s at 20 °C). A tube resonates (sounds loudly) when a source of that frequency is placed at the open end. In a resonance-tube experiment a vibrating tuning fork is held above a tube whose air column length is adjusted (by changing the water level): the loudest sound occurs when \(L = \lambda/4\), \(3\lambda/4, \ldots\), and the spacing between successive resonances is \(\lambda/2\), which allows the speed of sound to be found from the known frequency.
Worked example · open pipe
An organ pipe 0.50 m long is open at both ends. Find its first three harmonics (take \(v = 343\) m/s).
Fundamental. \(f_1 = v/2L = 343/(2\times0.50) = 343\) Hz.
Next two. \(f_2 = 686\) Hz and \(f_3 = 1029\) Hz (all integer multiples).
Worked example · closed pipe
The same pipe is closed at one end. Find the first three resonant frequencies.
Fundamental. \(f_1 = v/4L = 343/(4\times0.50) = 171.5\) Hz (about 170 Hz), an octave below the open pipe.
Next two. Only odd harmonics: \(f_3 = 3f_1 = 514.5\) Hz and \(f_5 = 5f_1 = 857.5\) Hz. There is no 343 Hz resonance.
Worked example · resonance tube
A 512 Hz tuning fork resonates in a tube closed at one end at air-column lengths of 16.7 cm and 50.1 cm. Find the speed of sound.
Spacing. Successive resonances are half a wavelength apart: \(\lambda/2 = 50.1 - 16.7 = 33.4\) cm, so \(\lambda = 66.8\) cm.
Speed. \(v = f\lambda = (512)(0.668) = 342\) m/s.
Exam focus
Ends. Closed end: displacement node. Open end: displacement antinode.
Node-to-antinode. A quarter wavelength; node-to-node is \(\lambda/2\).
Sound speed. About 343 m/s at 20 °C, higher in warmer air.
Practice
What is the fundamental frequency of a 0.40 m pipe open at both ends? (\(v = 343\) m/s)
Show answer
\(f_1 = v/2L = 343/0.80 = 429\) Hz.
What is the fundamental frequency of a 0.40 m pipe closed at one end?
Show answer
\(f_1 = v/4L = 343/1.6 = 214\) Hz.
What is the wavelength of the third harmonic in a closed pipe of length 0.60 m?
Show answer
\(\lambda_3 = 4L/3 = 0.80\) m.
Why does a closed pipe not produce the second harmonic?
Show answer
With a node at one end and an antinode at the other, the length must be an odd number of quarter-wavelengths; a pattern with two quarter-wavelengths would put a node at both ends (or an antinode at both), which does not fit the boundary conditions.
On a hot day the speed of sound is greater. What happens to the resonant frequencies of an organ pipe of fixed length?
Show answer
\(f = nv/2L\) (or \(nv/4L\)) increases with \(v\), so the pitch rises.
In a closed-tube experiment, resonances occur at 20.0 cm and 60.0 cm with a 420 Hz fork. Find the speed of sound.
Show answer
\(\lambda/2 = 40.0\) cm, so \(\lambda = 0.800\) m and \(v = (420)(0.800) = 336\) m/s.
You can hear a person talking around the corner of a building, but you cannot see them. Sound waves, with wavelengths of about a meter, bend easily around the corner; light waves, with wavelengths of half a micrometer, hardly seem to bend at all. Yet they do bend, a little, and the bending shows that light is a wave. Shine a laser through a very narrow slit onto a screen and instead of a single bright line you see a wide central band with dimmer bands on either side, separated by dark gaps. This is diffraction, and its explanation is interference among the many wavelets that emerge from different parts of the slit. This lesson explains the pattern and gives the equations for the dark fringes.
Learning objective · 14.7.A
Describe the behavior of a wave and the diffraction pattern resulting from a wave passing through a single opening.
Required content · EK 14.7.A
Diffraction is the spreading of a wave around the edges of an obstacle or through an opening. It is most pronounced when the size of the opening is comparable to the wavelength of the wave.
Diffraction of multiple wavefronts through a single opening leads to observable interference patterns. It is commonly demonstrated by monochromatic light of wavelength \(\lambda\) incident on a narrow opening of width \(a\), a distance \(L\) from a screen: constructive and destructive interference of wavefronts originating from the opening produce bright and dark bands on the screen.
The amount of interference between two wavefronts depends on the path length difference \(\Delta\), which can be described in terms of the opening width \(a\) and the angle \(\theta\) between the direction of propagation and the normal to the opening: \(\Delta = a\sin\theta\). The dark fringes (minima) are at \(a\sin\theta = m\lambda\), \(m = \pm1, \pm2, \ldots\)
For small angles (less than about \(10^{\circ}\)) the small-angle approximation relates \(\lambda\), \(a\) and \(L\) to \(y_{min}\), the distance from the middle of the central bright fringe to the \(m\)th minimum: \(y_{min} = m\lambda L/a\).
Visual representations of single-slit diffraction patterns are useful in determining the physical properties of the slit and the interacting waves. The pattern produced by a wave passing through an opening depends on the shape of the opening.
Diffraction
Diffraction is the spreading of a wave as it passes through an opening or around the edge of an obstacle. Think of an opening as a row of point sources, each emitting a circular wavelet (Huygens' idea); the observed wave is the combination of all of them. The effect is greatest when the width of the opening is comparable to the wavelength: a doorway (about 1 m) spreads sound (\(\lambda \sim 1\) m) widely but hardly spreads light (\(\lambda \sim 5\times10^{-7}\) m), and radio waves of 3 m bend around buildings while visible light casts sharp shadows. For ray optics to work, the openings must be much larger than the wavelength. When the opening is narrowed to a few wavelengths, even light spreads visibly.
The single-slit pattern
Monochromatic light of wavelength \(\lambda\) passes through a slit of width \(a\) and falls on a screen a distance \(L\) away (with \(L \gg a\)). The light is bright at the center and there is a series of dark and weaker bright bands to either side. The central bright band is about twice as wide as each of the others and much brighter. The pattern is an interference effect: the wavelets from different points across the slit travel different distances to a point on the screen, and are in or out of phase there.
Locate the first dark fringe. Pair up the wavelet from the top edge of the slit with the one from the middle: these two travel path lengths differing by \(\Delta = (a/2)\sin\theta\). If this equals half a wavelength, they cancel; every wavelet from the top half pairs up with one from the bottom half a distance \(a/2\) away and cancels it, so the intensity is zero. The condition is \((a/2)\sin\theta = \lambda/2\), or \(a\sin\theta = \lambda\). The same argument with the slit divided into four, six, \(\ldots\) parts gives all the dark fringes:
\[ a\sin\theta = m\lambda,\qquad m = \pm1, \pm2, \pm3, \ldots \]
(Notice that \(m = 0\) is not a minimum: it is the center of the bright central band.) For small angles (below about \(10^\circ\)) we may write \(\sin\theta \approx \tan\theta \approx y/L\), where \(y\) is the distance on the screen from the center, so the minima are at
\[ y_{min} = \frac{m\lambda L}{a}. \]
The width of the central bright band, from the first minimum on one side to the first on the other, is \(2\lambda L/a\). Two consequences are worth remembering: narrowing the slit widens the pattern (smaller \(a\), larger \(y\)), which is the opposite of what the ray model predicts; and longer wavelengths spread more (red more than blue). The pattern also depends on the shape of the opening: a circular hole gives circular rings, and a slit gives a pattern that spreads in the direction perpendicular to the slit.
Figure 14.9a Single-slit diffraction. The central maximum is twice as wide as the others, and the dark fringes are at \(a\sin\theta = m\lambda\), \(m = \pm1, \pm2, \ldots\)
Worked example · width of the central maximum
Light of wavelength 600 nm passes through a slit of width 0.10 mm and falls on a screen 2.0 m away. Find the distance from the center to the first dark fringe and the width of the central bright band.
Small angle. \(\theta \approx \lambda/a = (600\times10^{-9})/(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 6.0\times10^{-3}\) rad (about 0.34°), small enough for the approximation.
First minimum. \(y_1 = \lambda L/a = (600\times10^{-9})(2.0)/(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 1.2\times10^{-2}\) m \(= 1.2\) cm.
Central band. \(2y_1 = 2.4\) cm wide.
Worked example · narrower slit
The slit is narrowed to half its width (0.050 mm). What happens to the pattern?
Doubling. \(y_1 \propto 1/a\), so \(y_1\) doubles to 2.4 cm, and the central band becomes 4.8 cm wide. The light spreads more because the opening is closer to the wavelength. The pattern would also be dimmer, since less light gets through.
Worked example · finding the slit width
A red laser (\(\lambda = 650\) nm) on a screen 1.5 m away gives a central maximum 3.0 cm wide. What is the slit width?
First minimum. Half the central width: \(y_1 = 1.5\) cm \(= 0.015\) m.
Width. \(a = \lambda L/y_1 = (650\times10^{-9})(1.5)/0.015 = 6.5\times10^{-5}\) m \(= 0.065\) mm.
Exam focus
Diffraction. Spreading through an opening or around an obstacle; strongest when the opening is comparable to \(\lambda\).
For the slit in problem 1 and a screen 3.0 m away, how far from the center is the first dark fringe?
Show answer
\(y_1 = \lambda L/a = (500\times10^{-9})(3.0)/(5.0\times10^{-5}) = 0.030\) m \(= 3.0\) cm.
What happens to the diffraction pattern if red light is replaced by blue light with the same slit?
Show answer
The pattern narrows: the shorter wavelength of blue light gives smaller \(y_{min}\) (\(y \propto \lambda\)).
The slit width is doubled. By what factor does the width of the central maximum change?
Show answer
It is halved (\(y \propto 1/a\)).
Why can you hear around a corner but not see around it?
Show answer
Diffraction is most pronounced when the opening or obstacle is comparable to the wavelength. Sound wavelengths (about 1 m) are comparable to the sizes of doorways and corners; light wavelengths (about 500 nm) are far smaller, so light diffracts negligibly and travels in nearly straight lines.
On a single-slit pattern the second dark fringe on one side is 8.0 mm from the center. Where is the first?
Show answer
In 1801 Thomas Young let sunlight pass through two narrow slits cut close together in a card and saw, on a wall behind, not two bright lines but a whole series of evenly spaced bright and dark fringes. No particle model of light could explain dark places where light from two openings should add. Young's experiment was the decisive evidence that light is a wave, and it also gave the first accurate measurement of the wavelength of light. Replace the two slits by thousands and the bright fringes sharpen and spread out into spectra: this is the diffraction grating, the basic tool for analyzing light in chemistry, astronomy and the colors of a compact disc. This lesson derives the pattern and the equations for both.
Learning objective · 14.8.A
Describe the behavior of a wave and the diffraction pattern resulting from the wave passing through multiple openings.
Required content · EK 14.8.A
The pattern from monochromatic light of wavelength \(\lambda\) incident on two slits a distance \(d\) apart is caused by a combination of wave diffraction and wave interference. Considering only interference, a double slit creates a pattern of uniformly spaced maxima; constructive and destructive interference of the wavefronts from each slit produce bright and dark bands on the screen.
The amount of interference depends on the path length difference \(\Delta = d\sin\theta\). Maxima occur at \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\), \(m = 0, \pm1, \pm2, \ldots\) For small angles (less than about \(10^{\circ}\)): \(y_{max} = m\lambda L/d\).
Considering both interference and diffraction, a double slit creates an interference pattern of maxima and minima superimposed within the envelope created by single-slit diffraction.
Interference patterns produced by light interacting with a double slit indicate that light has wave properties; the source of this discovery was Young's double-slit experiment.
A diffraction grating is a collection of evenly spaced parallel slits that produces an interference pattern that is the combination of numerous diffraction patterns superimposed on each other. When white light is incident on a grating, the center maximum is white and the higher-order maxima disperse the light into a rainbow of colors, with the longest-wavelength light (red) farthest from the central maximum.
Two slits
Light of wavelength \(\lambda\) falls on two narrow slits separated by a distance \(d\) (center to center). Each slit acts as a source of waves that spread by diffraction, and the waves overlap on a screen at distance \(L\). At a point on the screen at angle \(\theta\) from the central axis, the path from one slit is longer than the path from the other by
\[ \Delta = d\sin\theta. \]
This is the same path-difference reasoning as for two speakers (Lesson 14.6). Where \(\Delta\) is a whole number of wavelengths the waves arrive in phase and interfere constructively: a bright fringe (maximum). Where \(\Delta\) is a half-integer number of wavelengths they arrive out of phase: a dark fringe (minimum). So the bright fringes are at
\[ d\sin\theta = m\lambda,\qquad m = 0, \pm1, \pm2, \ldots \]
where \(m\) is the order (\(m = 0\) is the central maximum, directly ahead). For small angles (under about \(10^\circ\)), \(\sin\theta \approx y/L\), so the positions of the maxima are
\[ y_{max} = \frac{m\lambda L}{d}, \]
and neighboring fringes are equally spaced by \(\Delta y = \lambda L/d\). Two features follow. A smaller slit separation \(d\) gives a wider fringe spacing, and a longer wavelength gives wider spacing (red fringes are farther apart than blue). With white light the central maximum is white and the other fringes are colored.
In an actual double slit each slit is not infinitely narrow, and the finite width \(a\) of each produces its own single-slit diffraction pattern (Lesson 14.9). The observed pattern is the closely spaced double-slit fringes inside the broad envelope of the single-slit pattern: the fringes are bright near the center and fade toward the dark minima of the envelope, and a fringe whose position coincides with a single-slit minimum may be missing. Both effects are present: diffraction sets the envelope, interference sets the fine fringes.
Figure 14.10a Double-slit interference. Bright fringes at \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\) are equally spaced; the single-slit pattern of each slit forms an envelope over them.
Diffraction gratings
A diffraction grating is a large number of evenly spaced parallel slits, typically hundreds or thousands per millimeter. The condition for a bright maximum is the same as for two slits, \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\), where \(d\) is the spacing between adjacent slits, but because the waves from many slits must all be in phase, the maxima are much sharper and brighter, with nearly dark gaps between, so their positions can be measured accurately. When a grating is illuminated with white light, the central maximum (\(m = 0\)) is white, and each higher order spreads the colors into a spectrum: since \(\sin\theta = m\lambda/d\), the longer-wavelength light is bent through the larger angle, so red is farthest from the center and violet is nearest. Gratings are used in spectrometers to analyze the light from stars, lamps and chemical samples, and the colors seen on a compact disc are produced by its closely spaced tracks. The number of orders is limited, because \(\sin\theta\) cannot exceed 1: \(m \le d/\lambda\).
Figure 14.10b A diffraction grating. The maxima are at \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\), as for two slits, but they are much sharper and brighter; white light gives a white center and spectra with red farthest from the center.
Worked example · fringe spacing
Light of wavelength 500 nm illuminates two slits 0.20 mm apart. The screen is 1.5 m away. Find the spacing of the bright fringes and the position of the second maximum.
Small angle. \(\theta \approx y/L\) is small (the fringes are millimeters from the center on a meter-scale screen).
Spacing. \(\Delta y = \lambda L/d = (500\times10^{-9})(1.5)/(2.0\times10^{-4}) = 3.75\times10^{-3}\) m \(= 3.75\) mm.
Second maximum. \(y_2 = 2\Delta y = 7.5\) mm from the center.
Worked example · a grating
A grating has 600 lines per millimeter. Find the angles of the first- and second-order maxima for light of wavelength 600 nm. Is a third order possible?
Spacing. \(d = 1\ \text{mm}/600 = 1.67\times10^{-6}\) m.
First order. \(\sin\theta_1 = \lambda/d = (600\times10^{-9})/(1.67\times10^{-6}) = 0.36\), so \(\theta_1 = 21^\circ\).
Second order. \(\sin\theta_2 = 0.72\), so \(\theta_2 = 46^\circ\).
Third order. \(\sin\theta_3 = 1.08\) is greater than 1: no third-order maximum exists.
Worked example · white light on the grating
The same grating is used with white light. Where do red (700 nm) and violet (400 nm) appear in the first order?
Red. \(\sin\theta = (700\times10^{-9})/(1.67\times10^{-6}) = 0.42\), so \(\theta = 25^\circ\).
Violet. \(\sin\theta = 0.24\), so \(\theta = 14^\circ\). The red is farther from the center, as expected.
Exam focus
Maxima (two slits or grating). \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\), \(m = 0, \pm1, \ldots\); small angles: \(y = m\lambda L/d\).
Fringe spacing. \(\Delta y = \lambda L/d\), uniform; smaller \(d\) or longer \(\lambda\) widens it.
Envelope. Double-slit fringes lie within a single-slit diffraction envelope.
Grating. Sharp bright maxima; white light gives white center and spectra with red farthest out.
Evidence. Young's experiment shows that light is a wave.
Compare. Single slit: minima \(a\sin\theta = m\lambda\). Double slit: maxima \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\).
Practice
Two slits 0.10 mm apart are illuminated by 600 nm light. Find the angle to the first bright fringe.
Show answer
For the slits of problem 1 and a screen 2.0 m away, what is the spacing between adjacent bright fringes?
Show answer
\(\Delta y = \lambda L/d = (600\times10^{-9})(2.0)/(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 1.2\times10^{-2}\) m \(= 12\) mm.
What happens to the fringe spacing if the slit separation is doubled?
Show answer
It is halved (\(\Delta y \propto 1/d\)).
A grating has 400 lines per mm. At what angle does the first-order maximum of 500 nm light appear?
Show answer
\(d = 2.5\times10^{-6}\) m; \(\sin\theta = 500/2500 = 0.20\), so \(\theta = 11.5^\circ\).
What is the highest order that can be seen with a grating of 500 lines/mm and light of wavelength 600 nm?
Show answer
\(d = 2.0\times10^{-6}\) m, so \(m \le d/\lambda = 3.3\). The highest order is the third (\(\sin\theta_3 = 0.90\), \(\theta_3 = 64^\circ\)); a fourth order would need \(\sin\theta_4 = 1.2\).
Why does a diffraction grating give brighter and sharper fringes than a double slit?
Show answer
Many slits contribute, and the waves from all of them are in phase only at the maxima; at nearly all other angles they cancel. The maxima are therefore narrow and bright.
A soap bubble shimmers with swirling colors, a puddle with a drop of oil shows rainbow bands, and the glass of a camera lens has a faint purple tint. None of these has any dye in it. The colors come from interference between light reflected at the front and back surfaces of a layer so thin that its thickness is comparable to the wavelength of light. The two reflected waves have traveled slightly different distances, and, as we shall see, one of them may have been flipped over in the reflection. Whether they add or cancel depends on the thickness, the wavelength and those flips. This lesson gives the rules for phase changes on reflection and applies them to soap films and to anti-reflection coatings.
Learning objective · 14.9.A
Describe the behavior of light that interacts with a thin film.
Required content · EK 14.9.A
When light travels from one medium to another, some of the light is transmitted, some is reflected and some is absorbed.
The phase change of a reflected ray depends on the relative indices of refraction of the materials: a phase change of 180° occurs when a ray is reflected from a medium with a greater index of refraction than the medium through which the ray is traveling; no phase change occurs when it is reflected from a medium with a lower index. The phase of a wave does not change when it is refracted as it passes from one medium into another.
Thin-film interference occurs when light interacts with a medium whose thickness is comparable to the light's wavelength. The light reflected from the first interface and the light reflected from the second interface after passing through the film interfere, resulting in a single wave that is the sum of the two.
The amount of constructive or destructive interference depends on the film thickness, the wavelength, any phase shifts and the angle of incidence.
Examples include the colors of soap bubbles and oil films (from differences in film thickness) and anti-reflection coatings, which create destructive interference between light reflected from the two surfaces. The simplest coating has a thickness of one quarter of the wavelength of the light in the coating, and an index of refraction greater than that of air and less than that of the surface it covers (for light at normal incidence).
Boundary: quantitative analysis is limited to light incident normal to the surface.
Phase changes on reflection
The reflected light is the key. When a light wave meets a boundary, the reflected wave may be shifted in phase, in exact analogy with the pulse on a string in Lesson 14.3:
Reflection from a medium of higher index of refraction (light slows down, like the pulse going into the heavier string): the reflected wave is inverted, a phase change of 180° (a half-wavelength shift).
Reflection from a medium of lower index (light speeds up, like the light string): no phase change.
The transmitted (refracted) wave undergoes no phase change.
Also remember that the wavelength of light in a film of index \(n\) is shorter than in vacuum: \(\lambda_{film} = \lambda/n\). The interference depends on the path length in the film measured in wavelengths in the film.
Interference of the two reflected waves
Consider light striking a thin film at normal incidence. Some of it reflects from the front surface (ray 1). Some enters the film, reflects from the back surface, and comes back out (ray 2), having traveled an extra distance \(2t\) (down and back through the film of thickness \(t\)). The two reflected rays combine, and the result depends on (a) the extra path \(2t\), expressed in wavelengths in the film, and (b) whether one of the two reflections, but not the other, includes a 180° phase change. Two cases:
Exactly one of the two reflections has a phase change (the typical soap film or oil film in air, where the front reflection is from higher index and the back from lower index): the rays are already half a wavelength out of phase. They interfere constructively when \(2t = (m + \tfrac12)\lambda_{film}\) and destructively when \(2t = m\lambda_{film}\), \(m = 0, 1, 2, \ldots\) A very thin film (\(t \ll \lambda\)) therefore looks dark, which is why a soap bubble turns black just before it pops.
Both reflections have a phase change, or neither (the anti-reflection coating on glass): the reflections start in phase, and the roles are reversed: constructive when \(2t = m\lambda_{film}\) and destructive when \(2t = (m + \tfrac12)\lambda_{film}\).
For white light each wavelength interferes differently at a given thickness, so some colors are strengthened and others weakened in reflection. In a soap bubble or an oil slick the thickness varies from place to place, so the reflected color changes from place to place: the colors are determined by the film thickness. Viewing from a different angle changes the path and so changes the color.
Figure 14.11a Thin-film interference. The two reflected rays differ by the extra path \(2t\) in the film and by any 180° shifts on reflection; together these decide whether the film looks bright or dark.
Anti-reflection coatings
A lens or solar cell loses several percent of the light at each surface by reflection. An anti-reflection coating is a thin transparent layer designed so that the two reflected waves cancel. For the cancellation to be near-perfect the coating's index must lie between that of air and that of the glass, \(n_{air} \lt n_{coat} \lt n_{glass}\); then both reflections (air to coating, coating to glass) are from a higher index, both have a 180° phase change, and the reflected waves would be in phase if the film were very thin. To make them cancel the extra path \(2t\) must be half a wavelength in the coating, so the simplest coating has
\[ t = \frac{\lambda_{coat}}{4} = \frac{\lambda}{4n_{coat}}, \]
one quarter of the wavelength in the coating. The cancellation is exact only for one wavelength (usually chosen in the middle of the visible, green-yellow); the remaining reflected light at the ends of the spectrum, red and violet, gives a coated lens its purple tint. The energy is not lost: where there is no reflection, all the light is transmitted into the glass.
Worked example · anti-reflection coating
A glass lens (\(n = 1.50\)) is coated with magnesium fluoride (\(n = 1.38\)) to reduce reflection of 550 nm light at normal incidence. Find the minimum coating thickness.
Phase changes. Air (1.00) to coating (1.38): reflection from higher index, 180°. Coating (1.38) to glass (1.50): reflection from higher index, 180°. Both reflections are shifted, so the shifts cancel in the comparison.
A soap film (\(n = 1.33\)) in air is illuminated at normal incidence with 550 nm light. Find the smallest nonzero thickness that gives strong reflection (a bright film).
Phase changes. Front surface (air to film): reflection from higher index, 180°. Back surface (film to air): reflection from lower index, no change. Exactly one shift, so the rays begin half a wavelength out of phase.
Dark for the thinnest film. As \(t \to 0\), \(2t \to 0\) and the half-wavelength shift makes the two rays cancel: the film appears black just before bursting. The next dark film occurs at \(2t = \lambda_{film}\), \(t = 207\) nm.
Exam focus
Phase change on reflection. 180° from a higher-index medium; none from a lower-index medium; none on refraction.
Wavelength in the film. \(\lambda_{film} = \lambda/n\); the extra path is \(2t\) at normal incidence.
One shift (soap film in air). Constructive: \(2t = (m+\tfrac12)\lambda_{film}\); destructive: \(2t = m\lambda_{film}\).
Zero or two shifts (anti-reflection coating). Destructive: \(2t = (m+\tfrac12)\lambda_{film}\); simplest \(t = \lambda_{film}/4\) with \(n_{air} \lt n_{coat} \lt n_{glass}\).
Colors. Come from differences in film thickness and the angle of viewing.
Practice
Light in air is reflected from the surface of glass (\(n = 1.5\)). Is there a phase change on reflection?
Show answer
Yes: the reflection is from a medium of higher index, so there is a 180° phase change.
Light traveling inside glass is reflected at the glass-air surface. Is there a phase change?
Show answer
No: the reflection is from a medium of lower index (air).
What is the wavelength in oil of index 1.45 of light of wavelength 580 nm in vacuum?
Show answer
\(\lambda_{film} = 580/1.45 = 400\) nm.
An anti-reflection coating of index 1.25 is designed for 500 nm light. Find its minimum thickness.
Show answer
\(\lambda_{coat} = 500/1.25 = 400\) nm, so \(t = \lambda_{coat}/4 = 100\) nm. (This requires that the glass index exceed 1.25.)
Why does a soap bubble look black just before it breaks?
Show answer
The film becomes much thinner than a wavelength. The two reflected rays have almost no path difference but one has a 180° phase shift and the other none, so they cancel: almost no light is reflected.
A thin oil film on water shows different colors in different places. Explain.
Show answer
The film's thickness varies from place to place. For each thickness different wavelengths satisfy the conditions for constructive interference, so the reflected color depends on the local thickness.
Unit 14 practice · 10 problems
Unit 14 practice: Waves, Sound, and Physical Optics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Take the speed of sound in air as 340 m/s and
\(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\ \text{m/s}\). Calculator allowed.
Twelve crests of a wave on a rope pass a fixed point in 3.0 s, and adjacent crests are 0.50 m apart. Find the frequency, period, and wave speed. If the amplitude is doubled, what happens to the energy the wave carries and to its speed?
Show answer
\(f = \dfrac{12}{3.0} = 4.0\ \text{Hz}\); \(T = \dfrac{1}{f} = 0.25\ \text{s}\); \(v = f\lambda = (4.0)(0.50) = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\). Energy \(\propto A^2\), so it quadruples; the speed is set by the rope, not the amplitude, and stays 2.0 m/s.
A 1700 Hz sound travels through air (340 m/s) into a steel rail where sound travels at 5100 m/s. Find the wavelength in each medium and explain why the frequency does not change.
Show answer
\(\lambda_{\text{air}} = \dfrac{340}{1700} = 0.20\ \text{m}\); \(\lambda_{\text{steel}} = \dfrac{5100}{1700} = 3.0\ \text{m}\). The steel surface is driven by the air at 1700 oscillations per second, so it vibrates at 1700 Hz too; only the wavelength adjusts, by the same factor of 15 as the speed.
Waves travel at 270 m/s on a 0.90 m string fixed at both ends. Find the fundamental frequency and the frequency and wavelength of the third harmonic, and give the positions of the nodes in the third-harmonic pattern.
Show answer
\(f_1 = \dfrac{v}{2L} = \dfrac{270}{2(0.90)} = 150\ \text{Hz}\); \(f_3 = 3f_1 = 450\ \text{Hz}\); \(\lambda_3 = \dfrac{2L}{3} = 0.60\ \text{m}\). Nodes every half wavelength (0.30 m): at 0, 0.30 m, 0.60 m, and 0.90 m: four nodes and three loops.
A guitar string's tension is increased so that the wave speed on it doubles, with its length unchanged. Its fundamental frequency
Halving would happen if the wavelength doubled at fixed speed, or if \(f\) were inversely related to \(v\). But \(f = v/\lambda\) with \(\lambda\) fixed, so a faster wave means a higher frequency.
The frequency would be unchanged only if the wavelength changed in step with the speed, but the fundamental wavelength \(\lambda_1 = 2L\) is set by the clamped ends and does not depend on tension. Only the speed changes, so the frequency must change too.
The fundamental wavelength \(\lambda_1 = 2L\) is fixed by the clamped ends, so \(f_1 = v/(2L)\) scales directly with \(v\). Doubling the speed doubles the pitch, one octave up.
Quadrupling would require a factor-of-4 change in speed. Doubling the wave speed does require quadrupling the tension (since \(v = \sqrt{F_T/\mu}\)), but the frequency tracks the speed, not the tension, so it only doubles.
(a) A pipe 0.85 m long is closed at one end. Find its three lowest resonant frequencies. (b) Rank the fundamental frequencies of these pipes, greatest to least: (i) open–open, length \(L\); (ii) open–closed, length \(L\); (iii) open–open, length \(2L\); (iv) open–closed, length \(L/2\).
Show answer
(a) Closed pipes hold odd harmonics only: \(f_1 = \dfrac{v}{4L} = \dfrac{340}{4(0.85)} = 100\ \text{Hz}\), \(f_3 = 300\ \text{Hz}\), \(f_5 = 500\ \text{Hz}\). (b) (i) \(\dfrac{v}{2L}\); (ii) \(\dfrac{v}{4L}\); (iii) \(\dfrac{v}{4L}\); (iv) \(\dfrac{v}{4(L/2)} = \dfrac{v}{2L}\). Ranking: (i) = (iv) > (ii) = (iii). Closing one end or doubling the length each halve the fundamental.
A string sounded together with a 512 Hz tuning fork produces 4 beats per second. When the string is loosened slightly, the beat rate decreases. What was the string's original frequency? Justify.
Show answer
\(f_{\text{beat}} = |f_1 - f_2| = 4\ \text{Hz}\), so the string was at 508 Hz or 516 Hz. Loosening lowers its frequency; since the beats slowed, it moved toward 512 Hz, so it started above: 516 Hz.
A train horn emits a steady tone while the train approaches a stationary listener, passes, and moves away. Describe how the frequency the listener hears compares with the frequency emitted before, during and after the pass, and explain in words, using wavefronts, why the pitch is higher on approach. What does not change?
Show answer
On approach the listener hears a frequency higher than the emitted one; after the train passes, a lower one. Each wavefront is emitted from a point closer to the listener than the one before, so the fronts ahead of the train are crowded together: shorter wavelength, more fronts per second arriving, higher frequency. Behind the train the fronts are spread out, giving a longer wavelength and a lower frequency. The wave speed in the air, which is set by the air, does not change, and neither does the frequency the horn emits.
(a) A microwave oven operates at 2.45 GHz. Find the wavelength. (b) Unpolarized light of intensity \(I_0\) passes through a polarizer. What is the transmitted intensity and what is special about the light? (c) Why can no light pass through two polarizers whose axes are perpendicular, and why can sound waves never be polarized?
Show answer
(a) \(\lambda = \dfrac{c}{f} = \dfrac{3.00\times10^{8}}{2.45\times10^{9}} = 0.122\ \text{m}\), about 12 cm. (b) The polarizer passes only the component of the oscillation along its axis, so the transmitted intensity is \(\tfrac{1}{2}I_0\) and the light is polarized along that axis. (c) The light leaving the first polarizer oscillates along its axis, so it has no component along the perpendicular axis of the second and none passes. Only a transverse wave, whose oscillation is perpendicular to the direction of travel, has a direction to select; sound is longitudinal, so it cannot be polarized.
Light of wavelength 500 nm passes through two slits 0.20 mm apart onto a screen 3.0 m away. Find the spacing of the bright fringes, the distance from the center to the second dark fringe, and the angle of the second-order bright fringe.
Show answer
\(\Delta y = \dfrac{\lambda L}{d} = \dfrac{(5.00\times10^{-7})(3.0)}{2.0\times10^{-4}} = 7.5\times10^{-3}\ \text{m} = 7.5\ \text{mm}\). Dark fringes sit at \((m + \tfrac{1}{2})\Delta y\): the second (\(m = 1\)) is at \(1.5(7.5) = 11\ \text{mm}\). Second-order bright: \(d\sin\theta = 2\lambda\), \(\sin\theta = \dfrac{2(5.00\times10^{-7})}{2.0\times10^{-4}} = 5.0\times10^{-3}\), \(\theta = 0.29^\circ\): small-angle approximation fully justified.
A thin film of oil (\(n = 1.45\)) floats on water (\(n = 1.33\)) and is viewed in air under 580 nm light. Track the phase change at each reflecting surface, then find the minimum oil thickness for which the reflected light is strongly constructive.
Show answer
Top surface, air → oil (low to high \(n\)): the reflection flips by half a wavelength. Bottom surface, oil → water (high to low \(n\)): no flip. The two reflections start half a wavelength apart, so the round trip inside the film must add another half wavelength (in the oil) for constructive interference: \(2t = \left(m + \tfrac{1}{2}\right)\dfrac{\lambda}{n}\). Minimum (\(m = 0\)): \(t = \dfrac{\lambda}{4n} = \dfrac{580}{4(1.45)} = 100\ \text{nm}\).
Lesson 15.1 · Unit 15 · CED topic 15.1 (quantum theory and photons)
By 1900 physics looked nearly finished. Newton's laws explained the motion of matter, Maxwell's equations explained light as a wave, and thermodynamics explained heat. Then a handful of stubborn experiments refused to fit: the glow of hot objects, the colors emitted by gases, and the way light knocks electrons out of metal. Each one demanded the same strange idea, that energy comes in indivisible packets. Light, which Young's slits had shown beyond doubt to be a wave, also behaves as a stream of particles called photons. This lesson introduces the photon and its energy and momentum, and Unit 15 then follows the idea through atoms, nuclei and the radioactive decay of matter.
Learning objective · 15.1.A
Describe the properties and behavior of an object that exhibits both particle-like and wave-like behavior.
Required content · EK 15.1.A (part)
Quantum theory was developed to explain observations of matter and energy that could not be explained using classical mechanics. These phenomena include atomic spectra, blackbody radiation and the photoelectric effect.
Quantum theory is necessary to describe the properties of matter at atomic and subatomic scales. In quantum theory, fundamental particles can exhibit both particle-like and wave-like behavior.
Light can be modeled both as a wave and as discrete particles, called photons. A photon is a massless, electrically neutral particle with energy proportional to the photon's frequency, \(E = hf\). Photons travel in straight lines unless they interact with matter.
The speed of all photons in free space is the speed of light, \(c = 3.00\times10^{8}\) m/s. In general, the speed of photons through a given medium is inversely proportional to the index of refraction of that medium.
Values of energy and momentum have discrete, or quantized, values for bound systems described by quantum theory.
Why classical physics was not enough
Classical physics treats energy as continuous: a wave can have any amplitude, an oscillator any energy. Three families of observations contradicted that picture. A hot object glows with a smooth spectrum whose shape classical theory could not reproduce (Lesson 15.5). A thin gas emits light only at certain sharp wavelengths, a different set for every element (Lesson 15.4). Light shining on a metal can eject electrons, but only if its frequency is high enough, no matter how bright it is (Lesson 15.6). In each case the data fit a model in which energy is exchanged in discrete amounts. Quantum theory is the theory that grew out of that insight, and it is required whenever we describe matter at the scale of atoms and smaller.
The photon
A photon is one quantum of electromagnetic radiation. It is massless and electrically neutral, it carries energy, and it moves in a straight line at the speed of light unless it interacts with matter. Max Planck proposed, and Einstein extended, that its energy is proportional to the frequency of the light:
\[ E = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}, \]
where \(h = 6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J·s}\) is Planck's constant. Atomic problems are easier in electron volts, with \(1\ \text{eV} = 1.60\times10^{-19}\) J, because then \(h = 4.14\times10^{-15}\ \text{eV·s}\) and
\[ hc = 1240\ \text{eV·nm}, \qquad E(\text{eV}) = \frac{1240}{\lambda\ (\text{nm})}. \]
The tiny size of \(h\) explains why we never notice photons in daily life: a green photon carries only \(3.6\times10^{-19}\) J, so a 100 W bulb emits some \(10^{20}\) of them each second, and the stream looks smooth.
Figure 15.1a Photon energy is proportional to frequency, \(E = hf\); the slope of the line is Planck's constant. Violet photons carry nearly twice the energy of red photons.
A photon also carries momentum, even though it has no mass:
\[ p = \frac{E}{c} = \frac{h}{\lambda}. \]
The momentum is what a photon transfers when it is absorbed or scattered (Lesson 15.7 uses it). A beam of photons that reflects from a surface pushes on it; this is radiation pressure.
In a medium of index \(n\) the speed of the photons is \(v = c/n\), so photons are slower in glass or water, but their frequency, and so their energy \(hf\), does not change when they cross a boundary. The wavelength shortens instead, \(\lambda_{medium} = \lambda/n\), exactly as for any wave (Lesson 13.4).
Both wave and particle
The photon does not replace the wave; it is a second, equally necessary description. Interference and diffraction (Unit 14) need the wave model. Absorption by a single atom, and the counting of photons by a detector, need the particle model. A quantum object is not a tiny ball or a spreading ripple but something that shows one face or the other depending on what an experiment asks of it. When many photons arrive, the intensity of the light, the energy per unit area per unit time, equals the number of photons per second per unit area times the energy of each. Dim light is not weaker light of the same photons; it is fewer photons.
The word quantized in the last objective of this topic means that bound systems, atoms for example, can have only certain allowed energies, not any value. A free particle can have any energy. An electron bound in an atom cannot, and that is the subject of Lessons 15.3 and 15.4.
Worked example · energy of a visible photon
Find the energy, in joules and electron volts, and the momentum of a photon of green light of wavelength 550 nm.
Energy in eV. \(E = 1240/550 = 2.25\) eV.
Energy in joules. \(E = (2.25)(1.60\times10^{-19}) = 3.61\times10^{-19}\) J, the same as \(hc/\lambda\).
Ratio. \(3.6\times10^{-19}/6.6\times10^{-26} \approx 5\times10^{6}\). A visible photon has millions of times the energy of a radio photon, which is why radio waves look wave-like and smooth while visible and higher-frequency light shows its photon nature.
Exam focus
Photon energy. \(E = hf = hc/\lambda\); in convenient units \(E\ (\text{eV}) = 1240/\lambda\ (\text{nm})\). The equation sheet gives \(h\) and \(hc\).
Photon momentum. \(p = E/c = h/\lambda\); a photon has no mass.
Speed. \(c\) in vacuum, \(c/n\) in a medium; the frequency (and energy) is unchanged on refraction.
Intensity. More photons per second means greater intensity; each photon's energy depends only on frequency.
Model. Wave behavior (interference, diffraction) and particle behavior (absorption of single photons) are both needed.
Practice
Find the energy in eV of a photon of wavelength 400 nm.
Show answer
\(E = 1240/400 = 3.10\) eV.
A photon has energy 2.0 eV. What are its wavelength and its frequency?
Show answer
Light, which seemed to be a wave, turned out to have particle properties. In 1924 a French graduate student, Louis de Broglie, asked the reverse question: if light waves can behave like particles, might particles such as electrons behave like waves? Within a few years electrons fired at a crystal produced exactly the diffraction patterns that waves would. The wave nature of matter is not a curiosity. It is why atoms have discrete energy levels, why electron microscopes can see viruses, and why quantum theory is needed whenever an object is small. This lesson gives the de Broglie wavelength, shows how to use it, and explains when it matters.
Learning objective · 15.1.A
Describe the properties and behavior of an object that exhibits both particle-like and wave-like behavior.
Required content · EK 15.1.A.4
Particles can demonstrate wave properties, as shown by variations of Young's double-slit experiment.
A wave model of matter is quantified by the de Broglie wavelength, \(\lambda = h/p\), which increases as the momentum of a particle decreases.
Quantum theory is necessary to describe systems where the de Broglie wavelength is comparable to the size of the system.
The de Broglie wavelength
For a photon the wavelength and momentum are related by \(p = h/\lambda\). De Broglie proposed that the same relation holds for any particle:
\[ \lambda = \frac{h}{p} = \frac{h}{mv}. \]
The more momentum a particle has, the shorter its wavelength. Because \(h\) is so small, the wavelength of an everyday object is far too small to detect. A 0.145 kg baseball at 40 m/s has \(p = 5.8\) kg·m/s and \(\lambda = 1.1\times10^{-34}\) m, about \(10^{19}\) times smaller than an atomic nucleus: no slit could ever diffract it. An electron is another matter. Its mass is \(9.11\times10^{-31}\) kg, so even at modest speeds its wavelength is a fraction of a nanometer, comparable to the spacing of atoms in a crystal.
For a charged particle accelerated from rest through a potential difference \(\Delta V\), the kinetic energy is \(K = q\Delta V\) and the momentum is \(p = \sqrt{2mK}\). The wavelength can therefore be tuned by changing the voltage, and a larger voltage means a shorter wavelength.
Evidence: the double slit for particles
The test of a wave is interference. When a beam of electrons passes through two narrow slits, or scatters from the regularly spaced atoms of a crystal, the detector records bright and dark fringes at the angles predicted by \(d\sin\theta = m\lambda\) with the de Broglie wavelength. The striking part is that the pattern builds up one electron at a time. Each electron strikes the screen at a single point, as a particle would, but the places where electrons land are distributed according to the interference pattern; an electron sent through the slits alone, with no other electrons present, still avoids the dark fringes. The electron passes through the apparatus as a wave and is detected as a particle. The same behavior has been seen with neutrons, atoms and even large molecules.
Figure 15.2a Electrons passing through a double slit one at a time. Each is detected at a single point, like a particle, but the places they land build up the interference pattern of a wave.
When is quantum theory necessary?
Wave effects matter when the wavelength is comparable to the size of the object or opening it interacts with. For a baseball against a doorway the wavelength is absurdly small compared with the size and no wave effect appears, so classical mechanics works. For an electron in an atom the wavelength (about 0.3 nm, as Lesson 15.3 shows) is comparable to the size of the atom itself, and a classical particle picture fails: the electron must be treated as a standing wave, which is exactly what produces discrete energy levels. As the momentum of a particle decreases its wavelength grows, so slow, light particles confined in small regions are the ones for which quantum theory is essential.
Figure 15.2b The de Broglie wavelength falls as the momentum rises. Wave effects matter only when \(\lambda\) is comparable to the size of the system, as for electrons in atoms.
A practical consequence is the electron microscope. The smallest detail that any wave can resolve is about its wavelength. Visible light (400 to 700 nm) cannot show anything smaller than about 200 nm, but electrons accelerated through a few thousand volts have wavelengths of a few picometers and can image atoms.
Worked example · an electron
An electron has kinetic energy 100 eV. Find its de Broglie wavelength.
Wavelength. \(\lambda = h/p = (6.63\times10^{-34})/(5.4\times10^{-24}) = 1.2\times10^{-10}\) m \(= 0.12\) nm, about the spacing of atoms in a crystal, so the electron will diffract from one.
Worked example · a baseball
Find the de Broglie wavelength of a 0.145 kg baseball moving at 40 m/s and say whether it would show wave behavior.
Wavelength. \(\lambda = h/mv = (6.63\times10^{-34})/((0.145)(40)) = 1.1\times10^{-34}\) m.
Conclusion. This is far smaller than any structure it could encounter, so no diffraction or interference is possible and the baseball is described by classical mechanics.
Worked example · comparing two particles
A proton and an electron have the same speed. Which has the longer wavelength, and by what factor?
Ratio. \(\lambda = h/mv\), so at equal speed \(\lambda\) is inversely proportional to mass. The electron is lighter by a factor of about 1840, so its wavelength is about 1840 times longer.
Exam focus
de Broglie. \(\lambda = h/p\) applies to every particle; larger momentum means shorter wavelength.
Accelerated charge. \(K = q\Delta V\) and \(p = \sqrt{2mK}\).
Evidence. Electron diffraction and double-slit patterns, built up one electron at a time, show wave behavior of matter.
When it matters. When \(\lambda\) is comparable to the size of the system or opening; otherwise the classical model works.
Claim style. "The wavelength is far smaller than the slit, so no pattern is observed" is the standard argument for large objects.
Practice
An electron moves at \(2.0\times10^{6}\) m/s. Find its de Broglie wavelength.
Show answer
If the momentum of a particle is doubled, what happens to its de Broglie wavelength?
Show answer
It is halved, since \(\lambda = h/p\).
An electron is accelerated from rest through 150 V. Find its wavelength.
Show answer
\(K = 150\) eV \(= 2.40\times10^{-17}\) J; \(p = \sqrt{2(9.11\times10^{-31})(2.40\times10^{-17})} = 6.6\times10^{-24}\); \(\lambda = (6.63\times10^{-34})/(6.6\times10^{-24}) = 1.0\times10^{-10}\) m.
Why can a beam of electrons be diffracted by a crystal but a beam of baseballs cannot be diffracted by a doorway?
Show answer
Diffraction needs a wavelength comparable to the opening or spacing. The electron's wavelength is about the spacing of atoms; the baseball's wavelength is about \(10^{-34}\) m, vastly smaller than a doorway.
Electrons passing through a double slit are detected one at a time and the fringes still appear. What does this show?
Show answer
Each electron is detected at one point like a particle, but the probability of landing at a given place follows the wave interference pattern, so each electron behaves as a wave in passing through the slits. Matter has both wave and particle behavior.
Why do electron microscopes resolve smaller detail than light microscopes?
Show answer
The resolvable detail is about one wavelength, and the de Broglie wavelength of accelerated electrons is thousands of times shorter than the wavelength of visible light.
Everything we touch is made of atoms, and every atom is mostly empty space. In 1911 Ernest Rutherford fired alpha particles at gold foil and found that a few bounced straight back, which could only happen if the positive charge and most of the mass were packed into a tiny nucleus at the center. That left a puzzle: electrons that orbit a nucleus are accelerating, and a classical accelerating charge radiates energy and should spiral into the nucleus in a fraction of a second. Yet atoms are stable, and each element emits only its own particular colors. In 1913 Niels Bohr proposed a model that combined classical orbits with a quantum rule, and it explained the hydrogen atom. This lesson reviews the structure of atoms, then develops the Bohr model and shows how the wave nature of the electron produces discrete energy levels.
Learning objective · 15.2.A
Describe the properties of an atom.
Required content · EK 15.2.A
Atoms consist of a small, positively charged nucleus surrounded by one or more negatively charged electrons. The nucleus is made up of protons and neutrons. The numbers of neutrons and protons can be represented using nuclear notation. An ion is an atom with a nonzero net electric charge.
Each atomic element has a unique number of protons. The number and arrangement of electrons affects how atoms interact. The total number of neutrons and protons identifies the isotope of an element. The mass of an atom is dominated by the total mass of the protons and neutrons in its nucleus.
The Bohr model is based on classical physics and was the historical representation of the atom that led to the description of the hydrogen atom in terms of discrete energy states. Electrons are modeled as moving around the nucleus in circular orbits determined by the electron's charge and mass and the electric force between the electron and the nucleus, \(F_e = kq_1q_2/r^2\) and \(F_{net} = mv^2/r\).
The standing wave model of electrons accounts for the existence of specific allowed energy states, because the electron orbit's circumference must be an integer multiple of the electron's de Broglie wavelength.
Boundary: the analysis and description of electron structure is limited to energy levels and does not include orbitals, orbital shapes or probability functions.
Parts of an atom and nuclear notation
An atom has a nucleus of protons (charge \(+e\), mass about 1 u) and neutrons (no charge, mass about 1 u), surrounded by electrons (charge \(-e\), mass about 1/1840 u). The nucleus has a radius of about \(10^{-15}\) m and the atom about \(10^{-10}\) m, so the nucleus is about 100,000 times smaller than the atom, yet it holds essentially all the mass: the mass of an atom is the mass of its protons and neutrons. A neutral atom has equal numbers of protons and electrons. An ion has gained or lost electrons and so has a net charge.
The atomic number \(Z\) is the number of protons and fixes the element. The mass number \(A\) is the total number of protons and neutrons (nucleons). Nuclear notation writes the nuclide as \({}^{A}_{Z}\text{X}\), for example \({}^{12}_{6}\text{C}\) is carbon with 6 protons and \(12 - 6 = 6\) neutrons. Isotopes of an element have the same \(Z\) but different numbers of neutrons: \({}^{12}_{6}\text{C}\) and \({}^{14}_{6}\text{C}\) are both carbon (same electrons, same chemistry) but with different mass. The arrangement of the electrons determines how the atom interacts with other atoms.
The Bohr model of hydrogen
Hydrogen has one electron. Bohr pictured it moving in a circle of radius \(r\) about the proton. The electric force supplies the centripetal force:
\[ \frac{ke^2}{r^2} = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
If the radius could take any value, so could the energy, and the atom would radiate away its energy. Bohr's quantum rule was that only certain orbits are allowed, and in these the electron does not radiate. The standing wave idea of Lesson 15.2 explains the rule. An electron in a stable orbit is a wave that must join smoothly onto itself after one trip around the circle; otherwise it would cancel itself out. So the circumference holds a whole number of de Broglie wavelengths:
\[ 2\pi r = n\lambda, \qquad n = 1, 2, 3, \ldots \]
This is the same boundary-condition reasoning that gave the standing waves on a string in Lesson 14.7, applied to a circle. Combined with the force equation it gives the allowed radii and energies of hydrogen:
\[ r_n = n^2(0.0529\ \text{nm}), \qquad E_n = -\frac{13.6\ \text{eV}}{n^2}. \]
The integer \(n\) is the energy level. The energy is negative because it is measured so that a free electron at rest far from the nucleus has \(E = 0\); the electron is bound, so its total energy is lower. The lowest level \(n = 1\) is the ground state, with \(E_1 = -13.6\) eV, and the higher levels are excited states that get closer together and closer to zero as \(n\) grows.
Figure 15.3a Bohr's orbits. The allowed radii grow as \(n^2\); the energy \(-13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2\) rises toward zero. The drawing is to scale in radius.Figure 15.3b The standing-wave model of the atom. Only orbits whose circumference holds a whole number of de Broglie wavelengths are allowed, which makes the energies discrete.
Both of these results are quantized: the electron cannot be at any radius or have any energy, only those given by whole numbers \(n\). The model is a historical one. It works for hydrogen and for one-electron ions but fails for atoms with several electrons, and modern quantum mechanics replaces circular orbits with orbitals; the course asks only for the energy levels.
Worked example · nuclear notation
Describe uranium-238, \({}^{238}_{92}\text{U}\), and the ion \({}^{23}_{11}\text{Na}^{+}\).
Sodium ion. 11 protons, \(23 - 11 = 12\) neutrons and, because the charge is \(+1\), 10 electrons.
Worked example · radius and wavelength of the ground state
The ground-state radius of hydrogen is \(r_1 = 0.0529\) nm. Use the force equation to find the electron's speed, then check the standing-wave condition.
Why quantized. The electron is a standing wave around the nucleus.
Limit. Energy levels only; no orbitals or probability functions.
Practice
How many protons, neutrons and electrons are in a neutral \({}^{40}_{20}\text{Ca}\) atom?
Show answer
20 protons, 20 neutrons, 20 electrons.
Carbon-12 and carbon-14 are isotopes. What is the same and what is different?
Show answer
Both have 6 protons (and 6 electrons when neutral), so the same chemistry. Carbon-14 has two more neutrons (8 against 6), so greater mass.
Find the energy of the \(n = 2\) level of hydrogen.
Show answer
\(E_2 = -13.6/4 = -3.4\) eV.
How much energy must be supplied to a ground-state hydrogen atom to remove the electron completely?
Show answer
13.6 eV, to raise the energy from \(-13.6\) eV to 0.
In the Bohr model, how many de Broglie wavelengths fit around the \(n = 4\) orbit?
Show answer
Four: \(2\pi r = n\lambda\) with \(n = 4\).
Why was a classical orbiting electron a problem for the stability of the atom, and how does the standing-wave model avoid it?
Show answer
A classical accelerating charge radiates energy and would spiral into the nucleus. In the wave model only orbits with a whole number of wavelengths exist, and the lowest such orbit (\(n = 1\)) has no lower state to fall to, so the atom is stable.
Put a thin gas in a glass tube, pass electricity through it, and look at the glow through a diffraction grating. A white bulb gives a continuous rainbow, but the gas gives a handful of bright, sharp lines: hydrogen shows red, cyan and violet, neon shows a crowd of orange-reds, sodium a pure yellow. Each element has its own pattern, a fingerprint. Astronomers read the compositions of stars light-years away from such lines, and chemists identify unknown samples with them. The explanation is the quantization of atomic energy: an atom can absorb or emit light only by moving between its allowed energy levels, so only certain photon energies take part. This lesson turns that statement into numbers.
Learning objective · 15.3.A
Describe the emission or absorption of photons by atoms.
Required content · EK 15.3.A
Energy transfer occurs when photons are absorbed or emitted by an atom, modeled as a system consisting of a nucleus and an electron.
Energy can only be absorbed or emitted by an atom if the amount corresponds to the energy difference between two atomic energy states. An atom in a given state may absorb a photon of the appropriate energy and move to a higher state; an atom in an excited state may emit a photon of the appropriate energy and spontaneously move to a lower state. A change in the energy state corresponds to a change in the interaction energy between the electron and the nucleus.
Transitions between two energy states correspond to the absorption or emission of a photon of a single frequency and therefore a single wavelength.
Atoms of each element have a unique set of allowed energy levels and so a unique set of absorption and emission frequencies, which determines the element's spectrum. An emission spectrum can identify the elements in a source of light; an absorption spectrum can identify the elements in a substance from the light it absorbs. Energy level diagrams represent the energy states of an atom.
Binding energy is the energy required to remove an electron from an atom, ionizing it. An atom in the ground state requires the greatest energy to remove the electron.
Boundary: only energy-level diagrams of single-electron atoms are considered.
Energy level diagrams
An energy level diagram shows each allowed energy of the atom as a horizontal line, with the ground state at the bottom and the levels getting closer together toward the top. For hydrogen \(E_n = -13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2\). The line at \(E = 0\) is the ionization limit: an electron with more than that energy is free of the atom. The binding energy of an electron in a given state is the energy needed to remove it, so for the ground state of hydrogen it is 13.6 eV, the largest of all, and for the \(n = 2\) level it is only 3.4 eV.
Figure 15.4a Hydrogen energy levels. A photon is emitted when the atom drops between levels, with energy equal to the difference; the spacing gets smaller toward the top.
Emission and absorption
An atom in an excited state can drop to a lower one, emitting a photon whose energy is the difference between the two levels:
\[ E_{photon} = E_i - E_f = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}. \]
This is emission; it happens spontaneously. The reverse, absorption, can happen only if a photon arrives whose energy exactly matches the difference between the atom's present level and a higher one; a photon with a different energy (even slightly) passes by. Energy is conserved: the change in the atom's energy equals the photon's energy. In this model the energy of the atom is the interaction energy of the electron and nucleus, so a transition changes how tightly the electron is bound.
Since every transition has one definite energy, it gives one frequency and one wavelength. Hydrogen's visible lines (the Balmer series) all end on \(n = 2\): \(3\to2\) is red (656 nm), \(4\to2\) cyan (486 nm), \(5\to2\) violet (434 nm). Transitions ending on \(n = 1\) release more energy (10.2 eV for \(2\to1\)) and fall in the ultraviolet; those ending on \(n = 3\) are infrared. Each element has different levels, so each has its own set of lines.
Figure 15.4b Line spectra of hydrogen. The emission lines and the absorption lines occur at the same wavelengths, because the same energy-level differences are involved.
Emission and absorption spectra
A hot, thin gas shows an emission spectrum: bright lines on a dark background, at the frequencies for transitions between its levels. If white light with a continuous spectrum passes through a cooler gas, the atoms absorb photons at exactly those frequencies and the transmitted light shows an absorption spectrum: dark lines on a bright continuous background, at the same positions as the emission lines of that element. The dark lines in sunlight identify the elements in the Sun's atmosphere, and the element helium was found in the Sun's spectrum before it was found on Earth.
An atom that absorbs a photon with more energy than its binding energy is ionized: the electron escapes with the leftover as kinetic energy. For example, a 14.0 eV photon absorbed by ground-state hydrogen frees the electron with \(14.0 - 13.6 = 0.4\) eV of kinetic energy. The ionization energy and the energies of excited states are measured directly from the spectrum.
Worked example · the red hydrogen line
Find the wavelength of the photon emitted when a hydrogen atom drops from \(n = 3\) to \(n = 2\).
Energies. \(E_3 = -1.51\) eV and \(E_2 = -3.40\) eV.
Photon. \(E = E_3 - E_2 = 1.89\) eV, and \(\lambda = 1240/1.89 = 656\) nm: the red line.
Worked example · absorption
A hydrogen atom is in its ground state. Which of these photon energies can it absorb: 10.2 eV, 11.0 eV, 12.09 eV, 14.0 eV? Describe what happens in each case.
Allowed jumps. From \(n = 1\): to \(n = 2\) needs \(10.2\) eV; to \(n = 3\) needs \(13.6(1 - 1/9) = 12.09\) eV.
10.2 eV and 12.09 eV. Absorbed, raising the electron to \(n = 2\) and \(n = 3\) respectively.
11.0 eV. Not absorbed: it matches no transition, so the photon passes through.
14.0 eV. Absorbed above the 13.6 eV ionization energy, ionizing the atom and leaving the electron with 0.4 eV of kinetic energy.
Worked example · the possible emission lines
A group of hydrogen atoms is excited to the \(n = 3\) level. How many different photon energies can they emit, and what is the largest?
Transitions. \(3\to2\), \(2\to1\) and \(3\to1\): three lines.
Largest energy. \(3\to1\): \(13.6(1 - 1/9) = 12.1\) eV, an ultraviolet photon of \(1240/12.1 = 103\) nm.
Exam focus
Photon emitted or absorbed. \(E_{photon} = |E_i - E_f|\); only differences between allowed levels occur.
Spectrum. Each element has unique levels, so a unique spectrum; emission gives bright lines, absorption gives dark lines at the same positions.
Binding energy. The energy to remove the electron; largest in the ground state (13.6 eV for hydrogen).
Above the limit. A photon above the binding energy ionizes the atom; the extra is the electron's kinetic energy.
Ladder rule. Larger energy gap, shorter wavelength.
Practice
Find the energy of the photon emitted when hydrogen drops from \(n = 4\) to \(n = 2\), and its wavelength.
Show answer
A stove element glows dull red, then orange, then yellow-white as it gets hotter. The filament of a bulb, a star, a lump of molten steel and even your own body all radiate electromagnetic waves because of their temperature; your body radiates in the infrared, which is why night-vision cameras can see people in the dark. The remarkable fact is that the spectrum of this thermal radiation depends almost entirely on the temperature, not on what the object is made of. The attempt to explain the shape of that spectrum in 1900 forced Max Planck to propose that light is emitted in quanta, and so started quantum theory. This lesson describes the blackbody spectrum, Wien's law for its peak and the Stefan-Boltzmann law for the power radiated.
Learning objective · 15.4.A
Describe the electromagnetic radiation emitted by an object due to its temperature.
Required content · EK 15.4.A
Matter will spontaneously convert some of its internal thermal energy into electromagnetic energy.
A blackbody is an idealized model of matter that absorbs all radiation that falls on it. If the body is in equilibrium at a constant temperature, then it must in turn emit energy.
A blackbody emits a continuous spectrum that depends only on its temperature, often modeled by plotting intensity per unit wavelength against wavelength. The distribution cannot be modeled using only classical physics; it is described by Planck's law, which assumes that the energy of light is quantized.
The peak wavelength emitted decreases with increasing temperature, as described by Wien's law, \(\lambda_{max}T = 2.898\times10^{-3}\ \text{m·K}\).
The rate at which energy is emitted (power) is proportional to the surface area and to the temperature to the fourth power, as described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law, \(P = \sigma A T^{4}\).
The blackbody
A blackbody is an idealized object that absorbs all the radiation falling on it. Because an object at constant temperature must emit as much energy as it absorbs, a perfect absorber is also a perfect emitter, and the radiation it gives off, blackbody radiation, is a continuous spectrum: light of every wavelength, with a smooth hump. A good approximation is a small hole in a closed oven; light that enters is trapped and absorbed, and the radiation that leaks out is the thermal spectrum of the walls. Real objects, from the Sun's surface to a lightbulb filament, follow the blackbody curve closely. Thermal energy, the random motion of the charged particles in the matter, is converted spontaneously into electromagnetic energy at all temperatures above absolute zero.
Figure 15.5a Blackbody spectra. A hotter object emits more at every wavelength and its peak (Wien's law) moves to shorter wavelengths.
What the spectrum looks like
Graph the intensity per unit wavelength against wavelength for a given temperature and you get a curve that rises from zero at short wavelengths, peaks, and trails off at long wavelengths. Three things happen as the temperature rises: the curve gets taller everywhere (more total energy is emitted), the total area grows very fast, and the peak moves to shorter wavelengths. A 3000 K filament peaks in the infrared and has only a little visible light, which is why incandescent bulbs are inefficient and look yellowish; the 5800 K surface of the Sun peaks in the middle of the visible range; hotter stars peak in the ultraviolet and look blue-white. Classical physics predicted that the intensity should keep rising toward short wavelengths without limit (the "ultraviolet catastrophe"), which is clearly wrong. Planck found that the data are matched exactly if radiation is emitted and absorbed in quanta of energy \(hf\): high-frequency quanta are too costly to be made in large numbers at a given temperature, so the curve falls at short wavelengths. That is Planck's law, which is the first quantum law of physics. The course asks you to know its idea, not its formula.
Wien's law
The wavelength at which a blackbody emits the most energy per unit wavelength is inversely proportional to its absolute temperature:
\[ \lambda_{max} = \frac{2.898\times10^{-3}\ \text{m·K}}{T}. \]
Temperatures must be in kelvin. The law lets us take the temperature of a star or a furnace from its color alone. Doubling the Kelvin temperature halves the peak wavelength.
The Stefan-Boltzmann law
The total power radiated by a blackbody of surface area \(A\) at temperature \(T\) is
\[ P = \sigma A T^{4}, \qquad \sigma = 5.67\times10^{-8}\ \text{W/(m}^2\text{·K}^4). \]
The fourth power makes the dependence very steep: doubling the Kelvin temperature increases the power by \(2^4 = 16\). The power is also proportional to the surface area, so a larger object at the same temperature emits more. (A real object emits a fraction of this, the emissivity \(e\) times it, but the idealized blackbody has \(e = 1\).)
Worked example · temperature of the Sun
The peak wavelength of sunlight is about 500 nm. Estimate the temperature of the Sun's surface.
Wien. \(T = (2.898\times10^{-3})/(500\times10^{-9}) = 5800\) K.
Worked example · the human body
The skin is at about 310 K. At what wavelength does it radiate most strongly, and in what part of the spectrum is that?
Wien. \(\lambda_{max} = (2.898\times10^{-3})/310 = 9.3\times10^{-6}\) m \(= 9.3\ \mu\)m: infrared, well beyond the visible, so we do not see people glow but infrared cameras do.
Worked example · power of the Sun
The Sun has radius \(6.96\times10^{8}\) m and surface temperature 5800 K. Treat it as a blackbody and find its power output.
Area. \(A = 4\pi R^2 = 4\pi(6.96\times10^{8})^2 = 6.09\times10^{18}\) m².
Power. \(P = \sigma A T^4 = (5.67\times10^{-8})(6.09\times10^{18})(5800)^4 = 3.9\times10^{26}\) W, the measured solar luminosity.
Scaling. A star with the same size and a temperature of 11,600 K would radiate \(2^4 = 16\) times as much.
Exam focus
Blackbody. Idealized absorber and emitter; continuous spectrum that depends only on temperature.
Peak. \(\lambda_{max}T = 2.898\times10^{-3}\) m·K; hotter means shorter peak wavelength. Use kelvin.
Power. \(P = \sigma A T^4\); doubling \(T\) multiplies the power by 16, doubling the area multiplies it by 2.
Graphs. Intensity-against-wavelength curves for higher temperature lie above, with the peak shifted left.
Quantum link. Planck's law explains the curve only if light energy is quantized.
Practice
A star has a peak wavelength of 290 nm. What is its surface temperature?
Show answer
\(T = (2.898\times10^{-3})/(290\times10^{-9}) = 1.0\times10^{4}\) K.
An incandescent filament is at 2000 K. Find its peak wavelength and say whether most of its radiation is visible.
Show answer
\(\lambda_{max} = (2.898\times10^{-3})/2000 = 1.45\times10^{-6}\) m \(= 1450\) nm: infrared. Most of its radiation is not visible.
By what factor does the power radiated by a blackbody change if its temperature goes from 300 K to 600 K?
Show answer
\(2^4 = 16\) times as much.
Two stars have the same temperature. Star B has twice the radius of star A. Compare their powers.
Show answer
Area is proportional to \(R^2\), so B has area 4 times larger and radiates 4 times the power.
A blackbody is heated from 3000 K to 6000 K. What happens to its peak wavelength?
Show answer
It is halved, from \(2.898\times10^{-3}/3000 = 966\) nm to 483 nm.
Why did the classical wave model fail to explain the blackbody spectrum, and what did Planck assume?
Show answer
Classical theory predicted ever-increasing intensity at short wavelengths, which is not observed. Planck assumed that energy is emitted and absorbed in quanta \(E = hf\), which makes short-wavelength (high-energy) quanta rare at a given temperature and fits the observed curve.
When light falls on a clean metal surface, electrons can be knocked out of the metal. This is the photoelectric effect, and it is how a solar cell, a digital camera sensor and the door-opening eye of an elevator turn light into electric current. In 1902 Philipp Lenard measured how it works, and the results flatly contradicted the wave model of light. A wave model says a brighter beam should give the electrons more energy; a dim beam should eventually deliver enough energy if one waits long enough. Neither is true. In 1905 Albert Einstein explained everything by taking Planck's quanta seriously: light is made of photons, and one photon gives all its energy to one electron. He received the Nobel Prize for it. This lesson sets out the experiment, its surprising results, and the equation that explains them.
Learning objective · 15.5.A
Describe an interaction between photons and matter using the photoelectric effect.
Required content · EK 15.5.A
The photoelectric effect is the emission of electrons when electromagnetic radiation is incident upon a photoactive material.
The emission of electrons requires a minimum frequency of incident light, called the threshold frequency. Light at or above the threshold frequency will induce electron emission regardless of the number of photons that strike the material. The energy of the emitted electrons does not depend on the number of photons incident on the material, which is evidence that light is a collection of discrete, quantized energy packets called photons.
The maximum kinetic energy of an emitted electron is related to the frequency of the incident light and the work function \(\phi\) of the material. The work function is the minimum energy required to emit an electron from atoms in the material: \(K_{max} = hf - \phi\).
In a typical setup, two metal plates in a vacuum chamber are connected to a variable source of potential difference. One plate is illuminated by monochromatic light that ejects electrons, and the potential difference between the plates is adjusted until no current is measured in the circuit.
Boundary: work functions will be provided on the exam; students need not know values.
The experiment
In a vacuum tube, monochromatic light of frequency \(f\) shines on a metal plate (the emitter). Ejected electrons cross to a second plate (the collector), and an ammeter in the circuit measures the current. A variable voltage can be put across the tube, either helping the electrons across or opposing them. The results are summarized below.
Figure 15.6a A photoelectric-effect experiment. Reversing the potential difference until the current stops gives the stopping potential, and so the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons.
Threshold frequency. Below a certain frequency \(f_0\), no electrons are emitted at all, however intense the light and however long it shines. Above it, emission begins immediately, even for very faint light.
Number of electrons. For a fixed frequency above threshold, the current is proportional to the intensity of the light: more photons per second eject more electrons per second.
Energy of the electrons. The maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons depends only on the frequency, not on the intensity. Brighter light gives more electrons, not faster ones; a higher frequency gives faster ones.
The wave model predicts the opposite of the first and third results. The photon model explains all three.
Einstein's explanation
A photon of energy \(hf\) is absorbed completely by a single electron. Some energy is needed to get the electron out of the metal, the work function \(\phi\), which depends on the material (a few eV for most metals). The rest becomes the electron's kinetic energy. The most energetic electrons, those that lose nothing else on the way out, have
\[ K_{max} = hf - \phi. \]
If \(hf \lt \phi\), no electron can escape, whatever the number of photons, because the photons act one at a time and each one is too weak. That gives the threshold frequency and wavelength:
\[ f_0 = \frac{\phi}{h}, \qquad \lambda_0 = \frac{hc}{\phi}. \]
Increasing the intensity increases the number of photons and so the number of electrons (the current), but not the energy each photon delivers, so \(K_{max}\) is unchanged. Increasing the frequency increases \(K_{max}\) in proportion, with slope \(h\) on a graph of \(K_{max}\) against \(f\).
Figure 15.6b Maximum kinetic energy against frequency. The line has slope \(h\), crosses the axis at the threshold frequency and extends to \(-\phi\) at \(f = 0\).
The stopping potential
To measure \(K_{max}\) apply a reversed voltage that pushes the electrons back toward the emitter. When it is just big enough that even the fastest electrons cannot reach the collector, the current falls to zero. That voltage is the stopping potential \(V_s\), and the work done against the field equals the maximum kinetic energy:
\[ eV_s = K_{max} = hf - \phi. \]
A graph of \(V_s\) against \(f\) is a straight line with slope \(h/e\) and \(x\)-intercept \(f_0\); this is how the work function of a metal and Planck's constant are measured. The magnitude of the stopping potential in volts is numerically the maximum kinetic energy in electron volts.
Figure 15.6c Photocurrent against voltage. The stopping potential depends on the frequency, not the intensity; doubling the intensity doubles the current at positive voltage.
Worked example · will it eject electrons?
A metal has work function 2.3 eV. Light of wavelength 400 nm falls on it. Find the maximum kinetic energy of the electrons and the stopping potential. What if the light is 600 nm?
600 nm. \(hf = 1240/600 = 2.07\) eV, which is less than 2.3 eV: no electrons are emitted, however intense the beam.
Worked example · threshold
Find the threshold frequency and wavelength for the same metal (\(\phi = 2.3\) eV).
Frequency. \(f_0 = \phi/h = (2.3)(1.60\times10^{-19})/(6.63\times10^{-34}) = 5.6\times10^{14}\) Hz.
Wavelength. \(\lambda_0 = 1240/2.3 = 539\) nm. Any light with a wavelength shorter than this ejects electrons; longer wavelengths do not.
Worked example · changing the beam
With the 400 nm light on the metal above, the light is made twice as intense, then replaced by 250 nm light. What happens to \(K_{max}\) and the current?
Twice the intensity. Twice as many photons per second, so the current doubles, but each photon still gives 3.10 eV, so \(K_{max}\) stays at 0.80 eV.
250 nm. \(hf = 1240/250 = 4.96\) eV and \(K_{max} = 4.96 - 2.3 = 2.66\) eV, more than three times larger; the stopping potential is 2.66 V.
The intensity of light above the threshold is tripled. What happens to the photocurrent and the maximum kinetic energy?
Show answer
The current triples (three times as many photons per second); the maximum kinetic energy is unchanged.
Red light of any intensity fails to eject electrons from a metal, but a faint violet beam does. Explain.
Show answer
Each photon gives its energy to a single electron. Red photons have energy below the work function, so no electron is freed no matter how many photons arrive; violet photons have energy above the work function.
A graph of \(K_{max}\) against frequency has an \(x\)-intercept of \(5.0\times10^{14}\) Hz. What is the work function?
Show answer
Stopping potentials of 0.80 V and 1.42 V are measured for frequencies \(7.5\times10^{14}\) Hz and \(9.0\times10^{14}\) Hz. Estimate Planck's constant.
Show answer
The photoelectric effect showed that a photon can hand over all of its energy to an electron. In 1923 Arthur Compton found a second, different kind of photon-electron encounter that gave even more direct proof that photons carry momentum. He sent X-rays at a block of graphite and found that the scattered X-rays came out with a longer wavelength than they went in with, and that the change depended on the angle at which they left. A wave model predicts no such change: a scattered wave should keep its frequency. But if the X-ray is a particle of energy and momentum colliding with an electron, the longer wavelength (lower energy) is just the energy the electron took away, exactly as a billiard ball loses energy when it strikes another. This lesson develops Compton scattering as a two-dimensional collision.
Learning objective · 15.6.A
Describe the interaction between photons and matter using Compton scattering.
Required content · EK 15.6.A
In Compton scattering a photon interacts with a free electron. The photon that emerges has a lower energy and longer wavelength than the incoming photon. The magnitude of the change is related to the direction of the photon after the collision.
Compton scattering provides evidence that light is a collection of discrete, quantized energy packets called photons. It can be explained by treating a photon as a particle and applying conservation of energy and conservation of momentum to the collision.
The transfer of a photon's energy to an electron changes the energy, momentum, frequency and wavelength of the photon. The change in wavelength is related to how much the photon's direction changes: \(\Delta\lambda = \dfrac{h}{m_ec}(1 - \cos\theta)\).
Boundary: AP Physics 2 includes full quantitative and qualitative treatments of conservation of momentum in two dimensions.
The collision
An incoming photon of wavelength \(\lambda\) strikes an electron that is (nearly) at rest. The photon scatters at angle \(\theta\) from its original direction with a new wavelength \(\lambda'\), and the electron recoils at some angle \(\phi\) on the other side. Treat it as a collision of two particles:
Energy is conserved. The photon loses the energy that the electron gains as kinetic energy: \(\dfrac{hc}{\lambda} = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda'} + K_e\). Since the electron has gained energy, \(\lambda' \gt \lambda\).
Momentum is conserved in both directions. The photon's momentum is \(p = h/\lambda\). Along the original direction, \(\dfrac{h}{\lambda} = \dfrac{h}{\lambda'}\cos\theta + p_e\cos\phi\); perpendicular to it, \(0 = \dfrac{h}{\lambda'}\sin\theta - p_e\sin\phi\).
Figure 15.7a Compton scattering. The photon gives some of its energy and momentum to the electron, so its wavelength increases by an amount that depends on the scattering angle.
Solving these equations (the algebra is long, and the result is given on the equation sheet) gives the Compton shift
\[ \Delta\lambda = \lambda' - \lambda = \frac{h}{m_ec}\,(1 - \cos\theta), \qquad \frac{h}{m_ec} = 2.43\times10^{-12}\ \text{m}. \]
The constant \(h/m_ec\) is the Compton wavelength of the electron. The shift depends only on the scattering angle, not on the incoming wavelength. There is no shift for \(\theta = 0\) (the photon goes straight on, no collision), \(\Delta\lambda = 2.43\) pm at \(90^\circ\), and the maximum \(\Delta\lambda = 4.85\) pm at \(180^\circ\) (the photon bounces straight back). The more the photon's direction changes, the more energy is given to the electron.
The size of the shift is tiny, a few picometers. For visible light (wavelength about 500 nm) it is a change of one part in 100,000 and cannot be detected, which is why the effect is only seen with X-rays and gamma rays, whose wavelengths (about 0.01 to 0.1 nm) are comparable to the Compton wavelength.
Why this is evidence for photons
A classical wave striking an electron would make it oscillate at the frequency of the wave and so re-radiate light of the same frequency in all directions. Compton's measurement found a shifted wavelength that depended on angle, in agreement with the particle collision. The photon carries momentum \(h/\lambda\), exchanges it with the electron and loses energy, so its frequency decreases and its wavelength increases. The photoelectric effect demonstrates the energy of the photon; Compton scattering demonstrates its momentum.
Worked example · scattering through 90°
X-rays of wavelength 0.0710 nm scatter from electrons in graphite and are detected at \(90^\circ\). Find the wavelength of the scattered X-rays.
Electron. By conservation of energy, \(K_e = 17.5 - 16.9 = 0.58\) keV, which is about 3% of the photon's energy.
Worked example · direction and shift
Find the maximum possible wavelength shift and the angle at which it occurs.
Maximum. \(1 - \cos\theta\) is largest when \(\cos\theta = -1\), that is \(\theta = 180^\circ\) (backscatter), where \(\Delta\lambda = 2(2.43\times10^{-12}) = 4.85\times10^{-12}\) m.
Electron. In that case the electron receives the most energy and moves straight ahead along the original direction.
Exam focus
Setup. Photon plus free electron; conserve energy and momentum (in two dimensions, so both components).
Result. The scattered photon has a longer wavelength, lower frequency and lower energy.
Shift. \(\Delta\lambda = (h/m_ec)(1 - \cos\theta)\); zero at \(0^\circ\), maximum at \(180^\circ\), independent of the incident wavelength.
Evidence. Shows that photons carry momentum \(p = h/\lambda\) and behave as particles.
Compare. In the photoelectric effect the photon is absorbed entirely; in Compton scattering it survives with less energy.
Practice
Compare the wavelengths of an X-ray photon before and after Compton scattering.
Show answer
The scattered photon has a longer wavelength, since it has given some of its energy to the electron.
Find the Compton shift for scattering at \(60^\circ\).
Show answer
\(\Delta\lambda = (2.43\times10^{-12})(1 - \cos60^\circ) = (2.43\times10^{-12})(0.5) = 1.21\times10^{-12}\) m.
For which scattering angle is the energy transferred to the electron greatest?
Show answer
\(180^\circ\), where the photon is scattered straight back and the wavelength shift is largest.
Why is Compton scattering seen with X-rays but not with visible light?
Show answer
The shift is at most \(4.9\times10^{-12}\) m regardless of wavelength. For X-rays of about \(10^{-10}\) m this is a few percent and measurable; for visible light of about \(5\times10^{-7}\) m it is about one part in \(10^5\).
In a collision, a photon of momentum \(p\) strikes an electron at rest and scatters at \(90^\circ\). Which direction does the electron move, in terms of conservation of momentum?
Show answer
The component perpendicular to the original direction must cancel: the scattered photon has momentum perpendicular to the original direction, so the electron recoils at an angle on the opposite side, with a component along the original direction equal to the photon's loss of forward momentum.
What does Compton scattering show that the photoelectric effect does not?
Show answer
It shows that photons carry momentum \(h/\lambda\) and that momentum as well as energy is conserved in the collision. The photoelectric effect shows only the quantization of energy.
The Sun releases about \(4\times10^{26}\) joules every second, enough to have shone for over four billion years. No chemical burning could do that; the energy comes from the nuclei of atoms. A kilogram of uranium fuel can supply as much electrical energy as millions of kilograms of coal. In the nucleus the forces are enormously stronger than those between atoms, and the energies involved are millions of times larger. Einstein's equation \(E = mc^2\) tells us where it comes from: a small amount of mass disappears and appears as energy. This lesson looks at what holds a nucleus together, how mass and energy are exchanged, and what happens in fission and fusion.
Learning objective · 15.7.A
Describe the physical properties that constrain the behavior of interacting nuclei, subatomic particles and nucleons.
Required content · EK 15.7.A
The strong force is exerted at nuclear scales and dominates the interactions of nucleons (protons or neutrons).
Possible nuclear reactions are constrained by conservation of nucleon number. The behavior of the constituents is constrained by conservation of energy, energy-mass equivalence and conservation of momentum.
For all nuclear reactions, mass and energy may be exchanged due to mass-energy equivalence, \(E = mc^2\). Energy may be released in the form of kinetic energy of the products or as photons.
Nuclear fusion is the process by which two or more smaller nuclei combine to form a larger nucleus, as well as subatomic particles. Nuclear fission is the process by which the nucleus of an atom splits into two or more smaller nuclei, as well as subatomic particles. Fission may occur spontaneously or may require an energy input, depending on the binding energy of the nucleus.
The strong force and the nucleus
A nucleus packs protons (which repel each other electrically) and neutrons into a space about \(10^{-15}\) m across. The electric repulsion between two protons that close would blow the nucleus apart, but a stronger attraction, the strong force, acts between all nucleons (protons and neutrons) and holds them together. It is a very short-range force, acting only over a few femtometers, but over that range it far exceeds the electric force. Because it acts only on neighbors, adding more and more nucleons to a nucleus makes the electric repulsion, which is long-range, increasingly important: large nuclei are only marginally stable, and the heaviest are radioactive.
Mass-energy equivalence and binding energy
Mass is a form of energy, and the relation is
\[ E = mc^2. \]
One kilogram of mass is equivalent to \(9\times10^{16}\) J. In nuclear physics masses are given in atomic mass units (u), with \(1\ \text{u} = 1.66\times10^{-27}\) kg, and the equivalent energy is
\[ 1\ \text{u} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}/c^2, \qquad\text{so mass defect}\ \Delta m\ (\text{u}) \to E = (931.5\ \text{MeV/u})\,\Delta m. \]
The mass of a stable nucleus is less than the total mass of its separate protons and neutrons. The difference, the mass defect, corresponds to the binding energy, the energy that must be supplied to pull the nucleus apart into its nucleons. For helium-4, the mass defect of 0.030376 u gives a binding energy of 28.3 MeV, or 7.07 MeV per nucleon. The binding energy per nucleon is a measure of how tightly each nucleon is held: the greater it is, the more stable the nucleus.
Figure 15.8a Binding energy per nucleon. Fusing light nuclei or splitting heavy ones moves toward the peak near iron and releases energy.
Plotted against mass number, the binding energy per nucleon rises steeply for light nuclei, reaches a maximum of about 8.8 MeV near iron-56 and nickel-62, and then declines slowly for heavier nuclei. Any reaction that moves nuclei toward the peak releases energy, because the products are more tightly bound than the starting nuclei and the extra binding energy comes out of the mass.
Fusion and fission
In fusion, small nuclei join to form a larger one. Joining two light nuclei moves up the left side of the curve and releases energy. The two positive nuclei repel each other, so fusion happens only at enormous temperatures, millions of degrees, where they collide fast enough to get within range of the strong force. This is what powers the Sun and stars, where hydrogen nuclei fuse into helium: the net result of four hydrogens becoming one helium is a mass loss of 0.0287 u, or 26.7 MeV.
In fission, a heavy nucleus splits into two medium-sized ones. This moves down the right side of the curve toward the peak and releases energy. A uranium-235 nucleus that absorbs a neutron becomes unstable and splits into two smaller nuclei (for example barium and krypton) plus two or three neutrons, releasing about 200 MeV in all. The released neutrons can strike other uranium nuclei and cause further fissions, a chain reaction, which is controlled in a reactor and uncontrolled in a bomb. Some very heavy nuclei fission spontaneously; others need an energy input, such as a neutron, to start, depending on how tightly they are bound.
Figure 15.8b Fusion and fission. In both, the products are more tightly bound per nucleon than the starting nuclei, and the mass difference is released as energy.
Every nuclear reaction obeys conservation laws. The total number of nucleons (mass number \(A\)) is the same before and after, and so is the total charge (sum of \(Z\)). Energy and momentum are conserved; the released energy appears as the kinetic energy of the products and as photons (gamma rays).
Worked example · energy from a deuterium-tritium reaction
The fusion reaction \({}^{2}_{1}\text{H} + {}^{3}_{1}\text{H} \to {}^{4}_{2}\text{He} + {}^{1}_{0}\text{n}\) uses masses 2.014102 u, 3.016049 u, 4.002603 u and 1.008665 u. Check conservation of nucleons and charge, and find the energy released.
Mass lost. Before: \(5.030151\) u. After: \(5.011268\) u. \(\Delta m = 0.018883\) u.
Energy. \(E = (0.018883)(931.5) = 17.6\) MeV, carried off mostly as the kinetic energy of the neutron and the helium nucleus.
Worked example · a gram of matter
Find the energy equivalent of 1.0 g of mass.
Energy. \(E = mc^2 = (1.0\times10^{-3})(3.00\times10^{8})^2 = 9.0\times10^{13}\) J, about the energy released by the explosion of 20,000 tons of TNT.
Worked example · which way releases energy?
Iron-56 has the highest binding energy per nucleon. Does fusing two helium-4 nuclei release energy? Does fissioning iron-56?
Helium. Helium-4 (7.07 MeV per nucleon) is on the rising side of the curve, so fusing light nuclei into heavier ones (up to iron) releases energy.
Iron. Iron is at the peak. Splitting it would produce nuclei with lower binding energy per nucleon, so fission of iron would need an energy input instead of releasing energy.
Exam focus
Equivalence. \(E = mc^2\); \(1\ \text{u} = 931.5\) MeV; energy released equals the mass lost times \(c^2\).
Binding energy. The energy to separate a nucleus into nucleons; the mass defect gives it. Higher binding energy per nucleon means more stable.
Conserved. Nucleon number, charge, energy and momentum.
Fusion. Light nuclei combine and release energy; needs very high temperature to overcome repulsion.
Fission. A heavy nucleus splits and releases energy; may be spontaneous or induced, as by absorbing a neutron.
Practice
How much energy is equivalent to a mass of 0.0010 u?
Show answer
\((0.0010)(931.5) = 0.93\) MeV.
In a nuclear reaction the products have 0.0050 u less mass than the reactants. How much energy is released?
Show answer
\((0.0050)(931.5) = 4.7\) MeV.
Why must the number of nucleons be the same before and after a nuclear reaction?
Show answer
Conservation of nucleon number: protons and neutrons are neither created nor destroyed in these reactions (they can change type, but the total is constant).
Why does fusion require very high temperatures?
Show answer
The nuclei are positively charged and repel each other. They must collide at very high speeds to come within the short range of the strong force, which then binds them.
What holds the nucleus together despite the repulsion between protons?
Show answer
The strong force, an attraction between nucleons that is stronger than the electric force at distances of a few femtometers.
For nuclei heavier than iron, does fusion or fission release energy? Explain with the binding energy curve.
Show answer
Fission releases energy. Heavy nuclei lie on the falling side of the curve, so splitting them gives products nearer the peak with greater binding energy per nucleon; fusing them would move away from the peak and need energy input.
Some nuclei are not stable. Left alone, a nucleus of carbon-14, uranium-238 or iodine-131 will sooner or later change into a different nucleus, giving off radiation as it does. This radioactive decay is spontaneous, nothing can speed it up or slow it down, and no one can say when a given nucleus will go. Yet when there are billions of nuclei the behavior of the whole sample is perfectly predictable, and that regularity lets us date a bone, time a medical treatment, or decide how long nuclear waste must be stored. This lesson develops the mathematics of decay and the idea of half-life.
Learning objective · 15.7.B
Describe the radioactive decay of a given sample of material consisting of a finite number of nuclei.
Required content · EK 15.7.B
Radioactive decay is the spontaneous transformation of a nucleus into one or more different nuclei, or into a lower energy level of the same nucleus.
The time at which an individual nucleus decays is indeterminable, but decay rates can be described using probability. The half-life \(t_{1/2}\) of a radioactive material is the time it takes for half of the initial number of radioactive nuclei to decay spontaneously. The decay constant \(\lambda\) is related to the half-life by \(\lambda = \dfrac{\ln 2}{t_{1/2}}\).
A material's decay constant may be used to predict the number of nuclei remaining in a sample after a period of time, \(N = N_0e^{-\lambda t}\), or the age of a material if the initial amount is known.
Different unstable elements and isotopes have vastly different half-lives, from fractions of a second to billions of years.
Random events, predictable samples
Every unstable nucleus has the same probability per second of decaying, whatever its history: a nucleus that has survived a million years is no more likely to decay in the next second than a brand-new one. It is like rolling a die for every nucleus each second. You cannot say which nucleus will go next, but you can say how many of a large sample will go. If the probability per unit time is \(\lambda\), the decay constant, then in a short time \(\Delta t\) the number that decay is \(\Delta N = -\lambda N\Delta t\): the decay rate is proportional to the number of nuclei still present. A rate proportional to the quantity itself gives an exponential, so the number remaining after time \(t\) is
\[ N = N_0\,e^{-\lambda t}. \]
Here \(N_0\) is the number at \(t = 0\). The decay rate, or activity \(A = \lambda N\), is the number of decays per second and falls off by the same exponential. (The unit is the becquerel, one decay per second.)
Half-life
The half-life \(t_{1/2}\) is the time for half the nuclei in a sample to decay. Setting \(N = N_0/2\) in the exponential gives
\[ t_{1/2} = \frac{\ln 2}{\lambda} = \frac{0.693}{\lambda}, \qquad\text{so}\qquad N = N_0\left(\tfrac12\right)^{t/t_{1/2}}. \]
After one half-life half the nuclei remain, after two a quarter, after three an eighth, and so on, regardless of how many were there to begin with. The half-life is a property of the particular isotope, and it varies enormously: polonium-214 has a half-life of 0.00016 s, iodine-131 about 8 days, carbon-14 5730 years, uranium-238 4.5 billion years. A short half-life means a high decay constant and an intensely active but short-lived source; a long half-life gives a feebly radioactive material that lasts essentially forever.
Figure 15.9a Radioactive decay curve. After each half-life the number of undecayed nuclei is halved, whatever the starting number.
Whole half-lives are easy: \(N = N_0/2^n\) after \(n\) half-lives. For other times use \(N = N_0(1/2)^{t/t_{1/2}}\) or the exponential form with \(\lambda = 0.693/t_{1/2}\); the two are the same function.
Dating and tracing
Living things take in carbon-14, which is made continually in the atmosphere by cosmic rays, so the fraction of their carbon that is carbon-14 matches that of the atmosphere. When an organism dies the intake stops and the carbon-14 decays with a half-life of 5730 years. Measuring the fraction that remains gives the time since death: if one quarter remains, two half-lives (11,460 years) have passed. Radioactive isotopes with much longer half-lives, such as uranium-238, date rocks and the Earth itself. Isotopes with short half-lives are used as medical tracers because they decay away within days and give little dose.
Worked example · whole half-lives
A sample contains 20 mg of iodine-131, half-life 8.02 days. How much remains after 24 days?
Half-lives. \(24/8.02 = 3.0\), so about 3 half-lives.
Remaining. \(20\,(1/2)^{3} = 2.5\) mg (more precisely 2.51 mg). Of the 20 mg, 17.5 mg has decayed into other nuclei.
Worked example · using the decay constant
Carbon-14 has half-life 5730 years. Find the decay constant and the fraction remaining after 10,000 years.
Decay constant. \(\lambda = 0.693/5730 = 1.21\times10^{-4}\) per year.
Half-life. Time for half the nuclei to decay; independent of the sample size; after \(n\) half-lives the fraction left is \(1/2^n\).
Dating. Compare the remaining fraction with the initial one to find the elapsed time.
Graphs. \(N\) against \(t\) falls exponentially; each equal interval of one half-life halves the value.
Practice
A radioactive sample has a half-life of 6.0 hours. What fraction remains after 18 hours?
Show answer
Three half-lives: \((1/2)^3 = 1/8 = 12.5\%\).
Find the decay constant of an isotope with half-life 20 minutes.
Show answer
\(\lambda = 0.693/20 = 0.035\) per minute (or \(5.8\times10^{-4}\) per second).
After 3.0 days, 12.5% of a sample remains. What is its half-life?
Show answer
12.5% is three half-lives, so \(t_{1/2} = 3.0/3 = 1.0\) day.
A sample has \(8.0\times10^{6}\) radioactive nuclei with a half-life of 10 s. How many remain after 40 s?
Show answer
Four half-lives: \(8.0\times10^{6}/16 = 5.0\times10^{5}\).
A sample of a certain isotope has activity 2000 decays per second. After one half-life what is its activity?
Show answer
1000 decays per second: the activity is proportional to \(N\) and \(N\) has halved.
Why is it impossible to predict when one particular nucleus will decay, yet possible to predict what a large sample will do?
Show answer
Each nucleus decays with a fixed probability per unit time, so the moment is random for one nucleus. In a large sample the law of large numbers makes the fraction that decays in a given time very nearly equal to the probability, giving the smooth exponential.
Early researchers sent the radiation from radioactive samples through a magnetic field and found that it split into three kinds. One bent one way, one bent the other way, and one went straight on. They named them alpha, beta and gamma after the first three letters of the Greek alphabet. Modern physics identifies what each one is: alpha particles are helium nuclei, beta particles are electrons or positrons, and gamma rays are high-energy photons. Which decay a nucleus undergoes depends on how its protons and neutrons are balanced, and every decay obeys the same conservation laws: of charge, of nucleon number, of energy and of momentum. This lesson describes each type and shows how to write the nuclear equations.
Learning objective · 15.8.A
Describe the processes by which individual nuclei decay.
Required content · EK 15.8.A
Some processes by which nuclei decay emit subatomic particles with unique properties. An alpha particle, or helium nucleus, consists of two neutrons and two protons and is symbolized by \({}^{4}_{2}\text{He}\) or \(\alpha\) (in Physics 2 only He-4 nuclei are considered).
Neutrinos and antineutrinos are subatomic particles with no electric charge and negligible mass, symbolized by \(\nu\) and \(\bar\nu\). They interact with matter only via the weak force and gravity, so they interact very little with ordinary matter.
Positrons, or antielectrons, are subatomic particles with an electric charge opposite that of an electron and the same mass, symbolized by \({}^{0}_{+1}e\) or \(\beta^{+}\).
Nuclei can undergo radioactive decay via alpha decay, beta-minus decay, beta-plus decay and gamma decay.
Conservation laws for nuclear equations
In a nuclear equation write each particle with its mass number \(A\) (top) and atomic or charge number \(Z\) (bottom). The sum of the \(A\)'s must be the same on both sides, and so must the sum of the \(Z\)'s. An electron has \(A = 0\) and \(Z = -1\); a positron has \(A = 0\) and \(Z = +1\); a neutrino has \(A = 0\) and \(Z = 0\). Energy and momentum are also conserved, so the energy released (from the mass lost, Lesson 15.8) goes into the kinetic energy of the products and any photons.
Alpha decay
In alpha decay a heavy nucleus emits an alpha particle, a helium-4 nucleus of two protons and two neutrons, and becomes a nucleus with \(Z\) lower by 2 and \(A\) lower by 4:
\[ {}^{238}_{92}\text{U} \;\to\; {}^{234}_{90}\text{Th} + {}^{4}_{2}\text{He}. \]
Alpha decay occurs mostly for heavy nuclei, where the electric repulsion between many protons overcomes the strong force's hold on the nucleus. The alpha particle is heavy and doubly charged, so it ionizes strongly but has little penetrating power: a sheet of paper or a few centimeters of air stops it.
Beta decay
In beta-minus decay a neutron in the nucleus changes into a proton, and the nucleus emits an electron and an antineutrino. The nucleus gains one proton, so \(Z\) increases by 1, while \(A\) is unchanged:
\[ {}^{14}_{6}\text{C} \;\to\; {}^{14}_{7}\text{N} + {}^{0}_{-1}e + \bar\nu. \]
This happens in nuclei that have too many neutrons. In beta-plus decay a proton changes into a neutron, with the emission of a positron (the antiparticle of the electron, with the same mass and the opposite charge) and a neutrino; \(Z\) decreases by 1 and \(A\) is unchanged:
\[ {}^{22}_{11}\text{Na} \;\to\; {}^{22}_{10}\text{Ne} + {}^{0}_{+1}e + \nu. \]
This happens in nuclei that have too many protons. The electron or positron is created in the decay; it was not in the nucleus beforehand. The neutrino or antineutrino carries off part of the energy, which is why beta particles come out with a whole range of energies, and it has no charge and almost no mass, so it passes through matter almost without interacting. Beta particles are more penetrating than alphas: a few millimeters of aluminum stops them.
Figure 15.10a The four decay types. Alpha and beta change the element; gamma only changes the energy of the nucleus. Mass number and charge are conserved in every case.
Gamma decay
After an alpha or beta decay the daughter nucleus is often left in an excited state, just as an atom can be, but with energies a million times greater. It drops to a lower energy level by emitting a photon, a gamma ray, in gamma decay. \(Z\) and \(A\) do not change; only the energy of the nucleus does:
\[ {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X}^{*} \;\to\; {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X} + \gamma. \]
Gamma rays are photons of energy typically 0.1 to several MeV and are the most penetrating of the three radiations, requiring thick lead or concrete to absorb them.
Worked example · alpha decay
Radium-226 (\(Z = 88\)) decays by alpha emission. Identify the daughter nucleus (radon has \(Z = 86\)).
A nucleus \({}^{60}_{27}\text{Co}\) decays to \({}^{60}_{28}\text{Ni}\) with the emission of other particles. What particles are emitted?
Balance. \(A\) is unchanged at 60, and \(Z\) increases by 1, so a neutron has become a proton: beta-minus decay, emitting an electron \({}^{0}_{-1}e\) and an antineutrino \(\bar\nu\) to balance the charge and the lepton count. (The nickel is left in an excited state and then emits gamma rays.)
Exam focus
Alpha. \({}^{4}_{2}\text{He}\) emitted; \(A\) down 4, \(Z\) down 2; least penetrating.
Beta minus. Electron plus antineutrino emitted; \(Z\) up 1, \(A\) unchanged (neutron becomes proton).
Beta plus. Positron plus neutrino emitted; \(Z\) down 1, \(A\) unchanged (proton becomes neutron).
Gamma. A photon from an excited nucleus; \(A\) and \(Z\) unchanged.
Always check. Sum of \(A\)'s and sum of \(Z\)'s equal on both sides; neutrinos have no charge and almost no mass.
Practice
Complete: \({}^{238}_{92}\text{U} \to {}^{A}_{Z}\text{X} + {}^{4}_{2}\text{He}\).
Show answer
\(A = 234\), \(Z = 90\): thorium-234.
Complete: \({}^{14}_{6}\text{C} \to {}^{14}_{7}\text{N} + \;? + \bar\nu\).
Show answer
An electron, \({}^{0}_{-1}e\) (beta-minus particle), balancing the charge.
A nucleus \({}^{22}_{11}\text{Na}\) emits a positron. What are the \(A\) and \(Z\) of the daughter nucleus?
Show answer
\(A = 22\), \(Z = 10\): neon-22.
A nucleus emits a gamma ray. How do \(A\) and \(Z\) change?
Show answer
They do not change; the nucleus moves to a lower energy level.
Rank alpha, beta and gamma radiation by penetrating power, least to most.
Show answer
Alpha (stopped by paper), beta (stopped by a few millimeters of aluminum), gamma (needs thick lead or concrete).
Why do neutrinos have to be emitted in beta decay, according to conservation of charge and energy?
Show answer
They do not carry charge, so they do not affect the charge balance, but they take part of the released energy and momentum, which explains why beta particles have a continuous range of energies rather than one fixed energy.
Unit 15 practice · 10 problems
Unit 15 practice: Modern Physics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Constants: \(h = 6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J·s}\),
\(hc = 1240\ \text{eV·nm}\), \(1\ \text{eV} = 1.60\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}\),
\(1\ \text{u} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}/c^2\), \(m_p = 1.007276\ \text{u}\), \(m_n = 1.008665\ \text{u}\),
\(m_e = 9.11\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}\). Calculator allowed.
Complete and balance each nuclear equation, identifying the unknown nucleus by its \(A\) and \(Z\). (a) Polonium-210 (\(Z = 84\)) undergoes alpha decay. (b) Cobalt-60 (\(Z = 27\)) undergoes beta-minus decay. (c) \({}^{235}_{92}\mathrm{U} + {}^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n} \to {}^{141}_{56}\mathrm{Ba} + \mathrm{X} + 3\,{}^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n}\). (Lead is \(Z = 82\), nickel \(Z = 28\), krypton \(Z = 36\).)
Show answer
Conserve nucleon number and charge. (a) \({}^{210}_{84}\mathrm{Po} \to {}^{206}_{82}\mathrm{Pb} + {}^{4}_{2}\mathrm{He}\): \(210 = 206 + 4\), \(84 = 82 + 2\). (b) \({}^{60}_{27}\mathrm{Co} \to {}^{60}_{28}\mathrm{Ni} + {}^{\ 0}_{-1}\mathrm{e} + \bar{\nu}\): \(A\) unchanged, \(27 = 28 - 1\). (c) \(A\): \(235 + 1 = 141 + A + 3\), so \(A = 92\); \(Z\): \(92 = 56 + Z\), so \(Z = 36\). X is \({}^{92}_{36}\mathrm{Kr}\).
A radioactive sample of 160 mg has a half-life of 6.0 h. How much remains after 24 h? After 15 h? When will 5.0 mg remain?
Show answer
24 h is 4 half-lives: \(160 \to 80 \to 40 \to 20 \to 10\ \text{mg}\). 15 h is 2.5 half-lives: \(m = 160\left(\tfrac{1}{2}\right)^{15/6} = 160(0.177) = 28\ \text{mg}\). \(5.0 = 160/32\) and \(32 = 2^5\): five half-lives, \(t = 30\ \text{h}\).
In beta-minus decay, which of the following is unchanged?
In beta-minus decay a neutron becomes a proton, so the proton count rises by one. That is what moves the daughter nucleus one place to the right in the periodic table.
A neutron turns into a proton plus an electron and an antineutrino: neutrons drop by one, protons rise by one, and the total nucleon count \(A = Z + N\) stays the same. Only alpha decay changes \(A\).
The neutron count falls by one, since one neutron is converted into a proton. Beta-minus decay happens in nuclei with too many neutrons and is how they shed one.
\(Z\) is the number of protons, so it increases by one: the daughter is a different element. Picking this usually means confusing \(Z\) with the mass number \(A\).
The carbon-12 nucleus has mass 11.996706 u. Find its mass defect, total binding energy in MeV, and binding energy per nucleon.
Show answer
\(\Delta m = 6m_p + 6m_n - m_{\text{nuc}} = 6(1.007276) + 6(1.008665) - 11.996706 = 12.095646 - 11.996706 = 0.098940\ \text{u}\). \(E_B = (0.098940)(931.5) = 92.2\ \text{MeV}\); per nucleon \(\dfrac{92.2}{12} = 7.68\ \text{MeV}\). Carbon-12 is bound more tightly per nucleon than helium-4 (7.07 MeV).
In the fusion reaction \({}^{2}_{1}\mathrm{H} + {}^{2}_{1}\mathrm{H} \to {}^{3}_{2}\mathrm{He} + {}^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n}\) the nuclear masses are 2.013553 u (each deuteron), 3.014932 u, and 1.008665 u. Find the energy released in MeV and in joules, and explain in one sentence where it comes from.
Show answer
\(\Delta m = 2(2.013553) - (3.014932 + 1.008665) = 4.027106 - 4.023597 = 0.003509\ \text{u}\). \(E = (0.003509)(931.5) = 3.27\ \text{MeV} = (3.27\times10^{6})(1.60\times10^{-19}) = 5.2\times10^{-13}\ \text{J}\). The products are lighter than the reactants; the missing mass appears as kinetic energy of the helium nucleus and neutron, by \(E = \Delta m\,c^2\).
Potassium has a work function of 2.30 eV. It is lit with 350 nm light. Find the photon energy, the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons, the stopping potential, and the longest wavelength that ejects any electrons.
A graph of \(K_{\max}\) versus light frequency for a metal is a straight line crossing the frequency axis at 5.5 × 10¹⁴ Hz. (a) What does the slope represent? (b) Find the work function in joules and eV. (c) Find \(K_{\max}\) for 8.0 × 10¹⁴ Hz light. (d) Explain in words why doubling the light's intensity leaves the graph unchanged.
Show answer
(a) \(K_{\max} = hf - \phi\), so the slope is Planck's constant \(h\), the same for every metal. (b) At the intercept \(K_{\max} = 0\): \(\phi = hf_0 = (6.63\times10^{-34})(5.5\times10^{14}) = 3.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{J} = 2.3\ \text{eV}\). (c) \(K_{\max} = h(f - f_0) = (6.63\times10^{-34})(2.5\times10^{14}) = 1.7\times10^{-19}\ \text{J} \approx 1.0\ \text{eV}\). (d) Intensity is photons per second; each electron absorbs one photon, whose energy depends only on frequency. More photons means more electrons per second, not faster ones.
(a) Find the de Broglie wavelength of an electron with kinetic energy 50 eV. (b) An electron, a proton, and an alpha particle move at the same speed; rank their de Broglie wavelengths, longest to shortest.
Show answer
(a) \(K = 50(1.60\times10^{-19}) = 8.0\times10^{-18}\ \text{J}\); \(p = \sqrt{2mK} = \sqrt{2(9.11\times10^{-31})(8.0\times10^{-18})} = 3.8\times10^{-24}\ \text{kg·m/s}\); \(\lambda = \dfrac{h}{p} = \dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{3.8\times10^{-24}} = 1.7\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}\), about 0.17 nm: atomic spacing, so a crystal diffracts it. (b) \(\lambda = h/(mv)\) at equal \(v\) goes as \(1/m\): electron > proton > alpha, the electron's about 1800 times the proton's.
A hydrogen electron drops from \(n = 5\) to \(n = 2\). Find the photon's energy, wavelength, and frequency. Then find the wavelength of the photon a ground-state atom must absorb to reach \(n = 3\).
(a) Rank the wavelengths of the hydrogen photons emitted in the transitions \(2 \to 1\), \(3 \to 2\), and \(4 \to 3\), longest to shortest. (b) Explain in words why a hot gas emits a line spectrum rather than a continuous rainbow, and why the dark lines in a star's spectrum sit at exactly the same wavelengths.
Show answer
(a) Energies: \(2 \to 1\): \(10.2\ \text{eV}\); \(3 \to 2\): \(1.89\ \text{eV}\); \(4 \to 3\): \(0.66\ \text{eV}\). Longer wavelength means smaller energy: \(4 \to 3\) (1880 nm) > \(3 \to 2\) (656 nm) > \(2 \to 1\) (122 nm). The levels crowd together as \(n\) grows, so high transitions are gentle. (b) A bound electron can hold only certain energies, so a photon can carry away only the difference between two allowed levels: a discrete set of energies, hence discrete wavelengths. Cool gas in a star's atmosphere absorbs photons of exactly those same energies, lifting electrons across the same gaps in the other direction, and removes them from the continuous light behind it.
Unit recap
Unit recap
0:00 / 0:00
Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to
have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play
counts as your one free video.
Free preview complete
That's the end of the free preview.
You've opened five lessons, which is
as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've
already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go
back to it.