AP World History: Modern · History & Social Science

AP World History: Modern

c. 1200 to the present across the whole globe, argued from the documents themselves, not a survey of one continent with the others added on. Every unit is taught through the sources historians actually use, every unit ends with a stimulus-based review, and the essay sections let you write DBQs and LEQs against the real College Board rubrics with a top-score response to compare against.

3H 15M EXAM 55 MCQ 3 SAQ 1 DBQ 1 LEQ 84 LESSONS 108 REVIEW QUESTIONS 10 ESSAY PROMPTS NO PREREQ

Read the free lessons and the full lesson list for AP World History: Modern

Free exam guides for AP World History: Modern (8)

Course overview

What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.

AP World History: Modern follows the nine units of the College Board course framework, running from about 1200 to the present, in 84 lessons. Each lesson follows one or two CED topics, quotes the learning objectives and key concepts in a Required content box, reads a primary source (or a labeled description of one) with attention to point of view, purpose, situation, and audience, and ends with an Exam focus box and six practice items. The middle units carry the most weight (Units 3 through 6 are each worth 12–15% of the exam, against 8–10% for Units 1, 2, and 7 through 9), so the period from 1450 to 1900 deserves the most attention. The exam is 3 hours 15 minutes: 55 multiple-choice questions, 3 short-answer questions, a document-based question drawn from 1200–2001, and a long essay question. Every unit ends with a stimulus-based review, and the essay sections at the bottom of the outline hold DBQ and LEQ prompts with a writing space that scores against the official rubric.

  • U1Unit 1: The Global Tapestry, c. 1200–c. 14508–10%
  • U2Unit 2: Networks of Exchange, c. 1200–c. 14508–10%
  • U3Unit 3: Land-Based Empires, c. 1450–c. 175012–15%
  • U4Unit 4: Transoceanic Interconnections, c. 1450–c. 175012–15%
  • U5Unit 5: Revolutions, c. 1750–c. 190012–15%
  • U6Unit 6: Consequences of Industrialization, c. 1750–c. 190012–15%
  • U7Unit 7: Global Conflict, c. 1900–present8–10%
  • U8Unit 8: Cold War and Decolonization, c. 1900–present8–10%
  • U9Unit 9: Globalization, c. 1900–present8–10%

All nine units are open, 84 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a twelve-problem mixed review.

Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set, is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.

Lesson 1.1 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.1

Song China and the East Asian world

In 1200 the Song dynasty ruled the most populous and commercial society on earth. This lesson covers how the Song governed through an educated bureaucracy and Confucian ideas, how its economy grew through new crops, tools, and money, and how Chinese traditions shaped Korea, Japan, and Vietnam. The Song fell to the Mongols in 1279, so the lesson ends where Unit 2 begins.

Required content · 1A, 1B, 1C

Learning objectives.

  • 1A. Explain the systems of government employed by Chinese dynasties and how they developed over time.
  • 1B. Explain the effects of Chinese cultural traditions on East Asia over time.
  • 1C. Explain the effects of innovation on the Chinese economy over time.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.A. Empires and states in Afro-Eurasia and the Americas demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity in the 13th century. This included the Song Dynasty of China, which utilized traditional methods of Confucianism and an imperial bureaucracy to maintain and justify its rule.
  • 3.1.III.D.i. Chinese cultural traditions continued, and they influenced neighboring regions.
  • 3.1.III.D.ii. Buddhism and its core beliefs continued to shape societies in Asia and included a variety of branches, schools, and practices.
  • 3.3.III.A.i. The economy of Song China became increasingly commercialized while continuing to depend on free peasant and artisanal labor.
  • 3.1.I.D. The economy of Song China flourished as a result of increased productive capacity, expanding trade networks, and innovations in agriculture and manufacturing.

Government: Confucianism and the bureaucracy

The Song (960 to 1279) ruled much of China with a bureaucracy of officials chosen mostly by the civil service examination. Candidates studied the Confucian classics for years, and the exams tested their knowledge of them. Passing could raise a family from landowning wealth into the governing class, although in practice the cost of education meant that most successful candidates came from families with land and money. The CED describes this as using traditional methods of Confucianism and an imperial bureaucracy to maintain and justify its rule.

Confucianism taught that society was a set of relationships, such as ruler and subject, parent and child, and husband and wife, each held together by duties. The ruler's duty was to govern virtuously, and the subject's duty was loyalty. Filial piety, the respect and obedience owed to parents and ancestors, was the model for all other relationships. Under the Song, thinkers such as Zhu Xi (1130 to 1200) combined Confucian ethics with ideas about the nature of the universe borrowed partly from Buddhism and Daoism. This blend is called Neo-Confucianism, and it became the dominant school of thought in China and, later, across East Asia.

Confucian thought also shaped gender. It expected women to defer to fathers, husbands, and sons, and it valued their roles inside the household. During the Song, the practice of foot binding among elite families spread. It was painful, it limited women's movement, and it became a mark of status. Women's work did not disappear, though, since they spun silk and cotton and ran household workshops that fed the commercial economy.

Religion: Buddhism alongside Confucianism

Buddhism had come to China from India more than a thousand years earlier, and in 1200 it was a major part of religious life. It developed into several branches. Theravada Buddhism stressed monastic discipline and the early teachings and was strong in Southeast Asia and Sri Lanka. Mahayana Buddhism, which stressed compassion and the ideal of the bodhisattva who delays nirvana to help others, was strong in China, Korea, and Japan. Tibetan Buddhism blended Mahayana teaching with local traditions and rituals. Buddhism and Confucianism were not rivals in the way two religions sometimes are in other places, since many people used Confucian ethics in public life and Buddhist practice for spiritual needs.

The economy: commercialization and innovation

The Song economy was one of the most productive in the world. Several developments explain why.

  • Agriculture. Champa rice, an early-ripening and drought-resistant variety imported from Southeast Asia, allowed two harvests a year in many places and fed a population that grew past 100 million.
  • Transportation. The Grand Canal, first built under the Sui and expanded over time, linked the Yangzi valley to the north and moved grain and goods cheaply.
  • Industry. Iron and steel production expanded so much that some estimates put output near 100,000 tons a year in the eleventh century, using coal and coke as fuel. Silk, porcelain, and later textiles were made for export.
  • Money. A shortage of copper coin led merchants in Sichuan to issue paper notes, and the government took over the practice. The Song were among the first to use paper money widely.
  • Technology. Printing spread learning, and gunpowder weapons and the magnetic compass appeared and began to travel to other regions.

The CED calls the result an economy that was increasingly commercialized while continuing to depend on free peasant and artisanal labor. Cities grew, merchants gained wealth, and markets stretched across the country, but most people were still farmers.

East Asia and the spread of Chinese culture

China's neighbors borrowed heavily from it, but not in the same way. Korea under the Goryeo dynasty (918 to 1392) adopted Confucian institutions and a civil service examination, and Buddhism flourished. Japan during the Heian period (794 to 1185) borrowed Chinese writing, Buddhism, and art, but adapted them. Japanese writers created their own scripts to write their own language, and the Tale of Genji, a novel by the court lady Murasaki Shikibu, is a Heian work. By the late twelfth century, warrior families gained power, and in 1185 the Kamakura shogunate began a period of rule by military leaders (shoguns) under a nominal emperor. Vietnam (Dai Viet) borrowed Chinese administration and Confucian learning but resisted Chinese rule and defended its independence several times.

1206 Chinggis Khan proclaimed 1206 Delhi Sultanate begins c. 1235 Mali empire founded 1258 Mongols sack Baghdad 1271 Yuan dynasty founded c. 1325 Mexica found Tenochtitlan 1368 Ming dynasty founded c. 1438 Inca expansion begins
Figure 1.1. Some state formations of the period. New states arose on every inhabited continent, in different ways and at different times.
Description of: a Song painting of a city

Description of "Along the River During the Qingming Festival," a handscroll attributed to Zhang Zeduan (twelfth century). This is a description, not a quotation.

The scroll shows a long stretch of the countryside and the capital's busy waterfront. Boats unload goods at a bridge, shops line the streets, and people of many kinds, including porters, merchants, officials, and travelers, move through crowds.

Sourcing (HIPP). The artist worked in the Song period and is associated with the court, so the historical situation is a wealthy, urban society, and the point of view is that of an educated observer showing a prosperous scene. The purpose was probably to display the capital's peace and prosperity as well as to please viewers who valued fine painting. The audience was elite viewers. Because the scroll is a flattering picture, it cannot tell us how the poor lived, but it is good evidence that markets and waterways mattered in daily life.

Source analysis · Commercial life

Claim. Song China had a commercialized, urban economy.

Evidence. The scroll shows boats unloading at a bridge, streets lined with shops, and crowds of people of many occupations.

Reasoning. A society in which many people work as merchants, porters, and shopkeepers, and in which goods arrive by boat to be sold in markets, is one in which trade matters, not only farming. A limit is that the painting is an artistic and flattering view meant for an elite audience, so the text should be combined with other evidence, such as the spread of paper money or the growth of iron production.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way Song China continued earlier traditions and one way it changed.

Model. One continuity was the use of Confucianism and a bureaucracy chosen by examination to justify and manage imperial rule, a system older than the Song. One change was the commercialization of the economy, as Champa rice, new iron production, and paper money allowed more trade and larger cities than earlier dynasties had seen.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 1A to 1C ask for government, culture, and economy. Pair each with an example: bureaucracy and Neo-Confucianism, filial piety and the Buddhist branches, and Champa rice, the Grand Canal, iron, and paper money. For regional influence, name what each neighbor borrowed (Korea: exams, Japan: writing and Buddhism, Vietnam: administration) and note that each adapted rather than copied.

Practice
  1. What was the purpose of the civil service examination?
    Show answer

    To select government officials by their knowledge of Confucian texts, which linked education to government service and supported the dynasty's claim to rule by virtue.

  2. Define filial piety.
    Show answer

    The Confucian value of respect and obedience owed to parents and ancestors, the model for other relationships.

  3. Name two Song innovations that raised economic output.
    Show answer

    Champa rice (two harvests a year), expanded iron and steel production, the Grand Canal, and paper money are all correct.

  4. Name three branches of Buddhism.
    Show answer

    Theravada, Mahayana, and Tibetan Buddhism.

  5. How did Japan adapt Chinese culture rather than simply copying it?
    Show answer

    Japan borrowed Chinese writing, Buddhism, and art but created its own scripts to write Japanese, and Heian writers produced works such as the Tale of Genji.

  6. Why was Confucianism significant for women's roles?
    Show answer

    It expected women to defer to fathers, husbands, and sons and valued their household roles, and the Song practice of foot binding became a mark of elite status.

Lesson 1.2 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.2

Dar al-Islam after the Abbasids

Dar al-Islam, the "house of Islam," names the lands where Islam was the main religion and Muslim law and culture shaped public life. By 1200 this world stretched from Spain and West Africa to India and Central Asia. This lesson covers how new Muslim states replaced the Abbasid caliphate's direct rule, how Islam spread, and why Muslim scholars made so many intellectual advances.

Required content · 1D, 1E, 1F

Learning objectives.

  • 1D. Explain how systems of belief and their practices affected society in the period from c. 1200 to c. 1450.
  • 1E. Explain the causes and effects of the rise of Islamic states over time.
  • 1F. Explain the effects of intellectual innovation in Dar al-Islam.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.III.D.iii. Islam, Judaism, Christianity, and the core beliefs and practices of these religions continued to shape societies in Africa and Asia.
  • 3.2.I. As the Abbasid Caliphate fragmented, new Islamic political entities emerged, most of which were dominated by Turkic peoples. These states demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity.
  • 3.1.III.A. Muslim rule continued to expand to many parts of Afro-Eurasia due to military expansion, and Islam subsequently expanded through the activities of merchants, missionaries, and Sufis.
  • 3.2.II.A.i. Muslim states and empires encouraged significant intellectual innovations and transfers.

From one caliphate to many states

The Abbasid caliphate (750 to 1258) was the great Muslim empire centered in Baghdad. But it had lost real control over distant provinces long before the Mongols took the city in 1258. Regional dynasties ruled in its place while often keeping the caliph as a symbol of unity. The CED asks about new Islamic political entities, and three matter most.

  • The Seljuk Empire was established by Turkic peoples from Central Asia. Seljuk sultans took Baghdad in 1055 and ruled much of Southwest Asia, while the caliph remained a religious figurehead. They defeated the Byzantines at Manzikert in 1071, which opened Anatolia to Turkic settlement.
  • The Mamluk sultanate of Egypt (1250 to 1517) was ruled by former slave soldiers (mamluks) who seized power. They defeated a Mongol army at Ain Jalut in 1260 and ruled Egypt and Syria.
  • The Delhi sultanates (from 1206) were Muslim states in northern India founded by Turkic military leaders. Their rulers governed a population that was mostly Hindu, which shaped their policies.

Islam spread as well, which the CED traces to military expansion and, after that, to the activities of merchants, missionaries, and Sufis. Conquest brought Muslim rule, but conversion was usually gradual. Merchants carried Islam along trade routes to East Africa, Southeast Asia, and West Africa. Sufis, Muslim mystics who stressed personal devotion and often traveled, attracted converts through teaching and example. Sufi orders such as the Chishti in India set up lodges that served as centers of charity, learning, and prayer.

Religious communities in Muslim lands

Muslim rulers governed large populations of Jews, Christians, and others. Under Islamic law, these groups were considered "people of the book," who paid a special tax in exchange for protection and the right to practice their religion. Judaism, Christianity, and Islam each shaped social life. The practices were not always the same everywhere, and treatment of minorities varied by place and ruler, but this arrangement meant that Muslim states ruled diverse societies rather than forcing quick conversion.

A center of learning

The CED says Muslim states encouraged significant intellectual innovations and transfers. Scholars in places such as Baghdad, Cairo, Cordoba, and Samarkand preserved and extended Greek, Persian, and Indian learning. They translated works into Arabic, and Arabic served as a common language of scholarship across a huge area. Notable achievements included:

  • Mathematics. Al-Khwarizmi's work gave algebra its name, and the Indian numbering system, adopted and passed on by Muslim scholars, reached Europe as "Arabic numerals."
  • Medicine. Ibn Sina (Avicenna) wrote the Canon of Medicine, which was used in Europe for centuries, and hospitals in cities such as Cairo trained physicians.
  • Astronomy and navigation. Muslim astronomers refined the astrolabe and improved tables of the stars, which helped travelers find the direction of Mecca and sailors find their way.
  • Philosophy. Ibn Rushd (Averroes) wrote commentaries on Aristotle that influenced Latin Christian thinkers.

These ideas moved to other regions through trade, travel, and contact, which is why Muslim lands were an important link between the ancient Mediterranean world and the later growth of learning in Europe.

Description of: a traveler in the Muslim world

Description of the account of Ibn Battuta (1304 to c. 1369), a Moroccan jurist who traveled for about thirty years across Africa, Asia, and Europe. This is a description of the book, not a quotation.

Ibn Battuta wrote of being received as a scholar of Islamic law in cities from Cairo to Delhi. Local rulers gave him hospitality and appointments, and he praised the cities' markets, colleges, and mosques while sometimes criticizing local customs he found un-Islamic.

Sourcing (HIPP). Ibn Battuta's point of view was that of an educated Sunni Muslim jurist. His purpose was to describe his travels, and he dictated the account in the 1350s after returning to Morocco at the request of a ruler, so some details were written from memory and may be exaggerated. The audience was educated Muslims at a royal court. Even so, his journey shows that scholars, law, and the Arabic language connected distant parts of Dar al-Islam.

Source analysis · A connected Muslim world

Claim. Shared religion and learning connected distant parts of Dar al-Islam, even though it had no single ruler.

Evidence. A Moroccan jurist could travel across Africa and Asia and be received as a scholar of law by rulers in cities as far apart as Cairo and Delhi.

Reasoning. His ability to find work and hospitality in many places shows that Islamic law, the Arabic language, and a common educated culture linked societies that were politically divided into Seljuk, Mamluk, and Delhi states. A limit is that the account was written long after the journey by a man who wanted to impress a court, so details may be exaggerated.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one way Islam spread after 1200.

Model. Islam spread through the activities of Sufis, who traveled and attracted followers through personal devotion, charity, and teaching in lodges such as those of the Chishti order in India. Unlike conquest, this method led to gradual conversion because Sufis often adapted their message to local customs.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 1D to 1F ask about belief systems, state formation, and intellectual innovation. Name the three new states (Seljuk, Mamluk, Delhi), the three agents of expansion (military, merchants, Sufis), and at least two innovations (algebra, medicine, astronomy, translation). Stress that cultural unity continued even though political unity did not.

Practice
  1. What was the Abbasid caliphate and what happened to it in 1258?
    Show answer

    It was the Muslim empire centered in Baghdad (750 to 1258); the Mongols sacked Baghdad in 1258, ending it, though it had long ceased to rule directly.

  2. Who were the Mamluks?
    Show answer

    Former slave soldiers who seized power in Egypt and Syria and ruled from 1250 to 1517, defeating a Mongol army at Ain Jalut in 1260.

  3. What role did Sufis play in the spread of Islam?
    Show answer

    Sufis, Muslim mystics, traveled and attracted converts through personal devotion, teaching, and charity, so Islam spread by example as well as by conquest.

  4. Name two intellectual advances of Muslim scholars.
    Show answer

    Algebra and the transmission of Indian numerals, Ibn Sina's Canon of Medicine, improved astronomical tools, and translations of Greek works are examples.

  5. How did Muslim states rule non-Muslim subjects?
    Show answer

    They usually allowed Jews and Christians to practice their religion under Islamic law in exchange for paying a special tax and accepting Muslim rule.

  6. Why was Arabic important?
    Show answer

    It served as a common language of scholarship, law, and religion across a huge area, which helped ideas travel among distant societies.

Lesson 1.3 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.3

South and Southeast Asia, c. 1200 to c. 1450

South and Southeast Asia in 1200 combined several religions and many states. Hinduism, Buddhism, and Islam all shaped societies, and rulers used religion to support their power. This lesson covers the belief systems of the region, the Hindu and Buddhist states that developed there, and the Muslim states that arrived from outside.

Required content · 1G, 1H

Learning objectives.

  • 1G. Explain how the various belief systems and practices of South and Southeast Asia affected society over time.
  • 1H. Explain how and why various states of South and Southeast Asia developed and maintained power over time.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.III.D.iv. Hinduism, Islam, and Buddhism, and their core beliefs and practices, continued to shape societies in South and Southeast Asia.
  • 3.2.I.B.i. State formation and development demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, including the new Hindu and Buddhist states that emerged in South and Southeast Asia.

Belief systems and practices

Hinduism was the main religion of much of the Indian subcontinent. It included a wide range of beliefs and practices, a caste system that ranked social groups, and temples that were centers of wealth and learning. The bhakti movement emphasized personal devotion to a god, such as Vishnu or Shiva, expressed in poetry and song in local languages. Many bhakti poets criticized caste and rigid ritual and welcomed followers from many social groups, including women and lower castes.

Buddhism had begun in India but had lost much of its support there by 1200. It remained strong in Sri Lanka, Burma, and mainland Southeast Asia, where Buddhist monasticism was central to society. Monasteries educated boys and received gifts from rulers who wanted merit and legitimacy.

Islam arrived in India through two routes: military conquest from the northwest and trade by sea. Sufism was especially important, since Sufi teachers drew converts with a message of devotion and equality that overlapped in tone with bhakti. In Southeast Asia, Islam spread mainly through merchants, and rulers of trading ports such as Malacca adopted it in the fifteenth century.

The CED notes that these systems continued to shape societies, and that in this region they often coexisted and influenced one another rather than replacing one another.

Hindu and Buddhist states

The CED lists several states that were Hindu and Buddhist.

  • Vijayanagara Empire (founded 1336 in southern India). It ruled the south after the decline of earlier kingdoms, defended its territory against northern Muslim states, and drew wealth from agriculture and the trade in spices and cloth. Its rulers used Hindu temples and ceremonies to support their rule.
  • Rajput kingdoms. These were regional kingdoms in northwestern India led by warrior clans who defended their territory against the Delhi sultans and others.
  • Sinhala dynasties in Sri Lanka, which supported Buddhist monasteries.
  • Srivijaya Empire (about 650 to 1200s). A maritime empire based on the island of Sumatra that controlled the Strait of Malacca and gained wealth from taxing trade between China and India. It supported Buddhism.
  • Khmer Empire (about 800 to 1400s). A land-based empire in Cambodia that built the huge temple complex of Angkor Wat and relied on rice farming and a large system of canals and reservoirs.
  • Majapahit (1293 to c. 1500). A Hindu-Buddhist empire on Java that grew powerful through sea trade.
  • Sukhothai kingdom (founded c. 1238). An early Thai kingdom that supported Theravada Buddhism.

Notice that some of these states relied on sea trade (Srivijaya, Majapahit) and others on land and agriculture (Khmer). That difference matters in the comparison lesson at the end of the unit.

The Delhi Sultanate

In 1206, a Turkic general established the Delhi Sultanate, which ruled northern India until the 1500s. Its rulers were Muslim, but most of their subjects were Hindu. Sultans ruled through military force and a system of land grants and tax collection, and they usually allowed Hindus to practice their religion in exchange for a tax. The sultanate also built mosques, patronized Persian culture, and brought new technologies, such as new kinds of irrigation and papermaking, to India. It repelled Mongol attacks in the thirteenth century.

Description of: a Hindu temple relief

Description of the carved reliefs at Angkor Wat, built in the early twelfth century under the Khmer king Suryavarman II. This is a description, not a quotation.

The temple, dedicated to the Hindu god Vishnu, is decorated with long carved walls that show scenes from Hindu epics and the king's own armies and court. The temple was the king's burial monument as well.

Sourcing (HIPP). The temple was built by a king for religious and political reasons, so its point of view is royal. Its purpose was to honor Vishnu, to associate the king with the god, and to display his power to subjects and rivals. The audience was the people of the kingdom, the priests, and later visitors. Because it was a royal monument, it shows how rulers wanted to be seen, not what ordinary farmers who built and fed the kingdom believed.

Source analysis · Religion and rule

Claim. Khmer kings used religion to support their rule.

Evidence. The huge temple was dedicated to Vishnu, decorated with scenes of epics and of the king's own army, and was a burial monument for the king.

Reasoning. Placing the king's image beside a Hindu god and showing his armies in sacred space tied his power to divine authority. The size of the temple also displayed the king's ability to command labor and resources. A limit is that the monument reflects the ruler's view, so it does not show how ordinary people experienced Khmer rule.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain how one South or Southeast Asian state developed and maintained power.

Model. The Srivijaya Empire grew powerful by controlling the Strait of Malacca, the narrow sea route between India and China. Its rulers taxed the merchants who passed through and used the wealth to support a navy and to patronize Buddhism, which gave them prestige and links to other Buddhist states.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 1G and 1H ask about belief systems and state building. For beliefs, know Hinduism and bhakti, Buddhism and monasticism, and Islam and Sufism. For states, give one Hindu or Buddhist example and one Muslim example (Delhi), and say how each developed and maintained power (trade, land, religion, or military force).

Practice
  1. What was the bhakti movement?
    Show answer

    A Hindu devotional movement that stressed personal devotion to a god, expressed in poetry and song in local languages, and often criticized caste and rigid ritual.

  2. How did Islam spread in Southeast Asia?
    Show answer

    Mainly through merchants and trade, and rulers of trading ports such as Malacca adopted it.

  3. Name two Hindu or Buddhist states of the region.
    Show answer

    Vijayanagara, Srivijaya, the Khmer Empire, Majapahit, Sukhothai, or the Rajput kingdoms.

  4. How did Srivijaya gain wealth?
    Show answer

    By controlling the Strait of Malacca and taxing trade between China and India.

  5. Why was the Delhi Sultanate unusual?
    Show answer

    Its rulers were Muslim but most of their subjects were Hindu, so they had to govern a mostly non-Muslim population, usually by allowing Hindus to practice their religion in exchange for a tax.

  6. What was the Khmer Empire known for?
    Show answer

    Building the temple complex of Angkor Wat and relying on rice agriculture and a large system of canals and reservoirs.

Lesson 1.4 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.4

State building in the Americas

The Americas in 1200 held complex societies that developed independently of Afro-Eurasia. The CED says that state systems in the Americas, as in Afro-Eurasia, demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, and expanded in scope and reach. This lesson covers the Maya, the Mexica, the Inca, and the societies of the North American Southwest and Mississippi valley.

Required content · 1I

Learning objective.

  • 1I. Explain how and why states in the Americas developed and changed over time.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.D.i. In the Americas, as in Afro-Eurasia, state systems demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, and expanded in scope and reach.

Maya city-states

The Maya lived in southern Mexico and Central America. Their civilization reached a peak between about 250 and 900 CE, when dozens of city-states, such as Tikal and Calakmul, ruled by kings with divine status, competed through trade and war. Maya cities built stepped pyramids, kept a calendar, and used a system of hieroglyphic writing. Many southern cities declined in the ninth and tenth centuries, probably because of drought, warfare, and environmental strain. By 1200 the center of Maya power had moved to the northern Yucatan, where cities such as Chichen Itza and later Mayapan flourished. Maya states were never united into one empire.

The Mexica

The Mexica, often called the Aztecs, were a people who migrated into the Valley of Mexico and, according to tradition, founded their capital, Tenochtitlan, on an island in Lake Texcoco around 1325. In 1428 they joined with two other cities in the Triple Alliance, and over the next century the alliance grew into a tribute empire. Conquered peoples kept their own rulers and customs but had to send tribute, such as cloth, food, and goods, to the Mexica capital, and tribute lists record these demands. The Mexica also relied on chinampas, artificial garden plots built in the lake, to grow food for a city of perhaps 200,000 people. Their religion included human sacrifice, which rulers used to justify wars and to display power, and priests played an important role in the state.

The Inca

The Inca built the largest empire in the Americas. From a base in the highlands around Cuzco, they expanded rapidly after about 1438 under the ruler Pachacuti, until the empire reached from modern Ecuador to Chile. The Inca ruled through several tools.

  • Roads. A network of roads, bridges, and storehouses connected the empire. Runners relayed messages along it.
  • Mit'a labor. Subjects owed labor service, called the mit'a, to the state, which used it to build roads and terraces and to work in mines and on state lands. The state provided food and support in return.
  • Khipu. The Inca had no writing system but kept records on khipu, knotted cords that recorded numbers and probably other information.
  • Religion and rulers. The Sapa Inca ruler was believed to descend from the sun god. Conquered peoples were required to honor Inca gods.

North American societies

Large societies existed north of Mexico as well, and the CED lists three. At Chaco Canyon in New Mexico, the Ancestral Puebloan people built great houses and roads and traded across a wide area until about 1150. At Mesa Verde in Colorado, Ancestral Puebloans built cliff dwellings in the 1200s and abandoned them before 1300, probably because of drought. At Cahokia, near modern St. Louis, the Mississippian culture built an urban center with large earthen mounds and a population that may have reached 10,000 to 20,000 at its peak around 1100, before it declined by about 1350. These societies were not empires, but they had long-distance trade, planning, and religious centers.

Description of: Inca record keeping

Description of a khipu, a knotted-cord record used by the Inca. This is a description of an object, not a quotation.

A khipu has a main cord with many hanging cords. Knots tied in different positions and styles stand for numbers in a decimal system. Specialists called khipu keepers recorded the state's goods, labor service, and population.

Sourcing (HIPP). The khipu is an artifact made by Inca officials, so its point of view is that of the state. Its purpose was to record information needed for administration, such as how many workers owed service. The audience was other state officials who could read it. Because we can read the numbers but not all of the other information, the khipu shows how the state counted resources more clearly than what rulers or subjects believed.

Source analysis · A state without writing

Claim. The Inca ruled a large empire without a system of writing.

Evidence. Officials used khipu, knotted cords that recorded numbers, to count goods, labor service, and people.

Reasoning. Records of this kind let the state collect resources and assign labor across thousands of miles, which are the tasks writing served in other empires. A limit is that scholars can read the numerical information but not all of the other information that may have been recorded, so the source is incomplete.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the Mexica and Inca states.

Model. Both built large empires that drew on the labor and resources of conquered peoples: the Mexica through tribute and the Inca through the mit'a labor system. A difference is that the Mexica left conquered rulers in place and demanded tribute, whereas the Inca moved populations, built roads, and took labor directly from subjects and organized it through the state.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 1I asks how and why states in the Americas developed and changed. For each state, give the method of rule (Maya: city-states and kings; Mexica: tribute; Inca: mit'a, roads, and khipu) and a cause of change (drought, warfare, or conquest). Stress diversity: there was no single American model.

Practice
  1. What was the Maya political structure?
    Show answer

    A set of independent city-states ruled by kings with divine status, never united into one empire.

  2. What was tribute under the Mexica?
    Show answer

    Goods such as cloth and food that conquered peoples had to send to the Mexica capital, which allowed the empire to rule through local leaders.

  3. What was the mit'a?
    Show answer

    The Inca system of labor service owed by subjects to the state, used for roads, terraces, mines, and state lands.

  4. What is a khipu?
    Show answer

    A set of knotted cords used by the Inca to record numbers and other information, since they had no writing system.

  5. What were chinampas?
    Show answer

    Artificial garden plots built in lakes that the Mexica used to grow food for their large capital.

  6. Name two North American societies of this period.
    Show answer

    Chaco Canyon, Mesa Verde, or Cahokia, all of which had large centers and long-distance trade.

Lesson 1.5 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.5

State building in Africa

Africa in this period had many kinds of states. The CED says that in Africa, as in Eurasia and the Americas, state systems demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity and expanded in scope and reach. This lesson covers Great Zimbabwe, Ethiopia, and the Hausa kingdoms, and then adds two of the best-known African states, Mali and the Swahili city-states, which the rest of Unit 2 returns to.

Required content · 1J

Learning objective.

  • 1J. Explain how and why states in Africa developed and changed over time.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.D.ii. In Africa, as in Eurasia and the Americas, state systems demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, and expanded in scope and reach.

Great Zimbabwe

In southeastern Africa, between the Zambezi and Limpopo rivers, the Shona-speaking people built a state centered on a stone city called Great Zimbabwe (c. 1100 to 1450). Its massive stone walls, built without mortar, enclosed a royal compound. The state grew rich from cattle herding and from trade in gold and ivory with Swahili merchants on the coast, who in turn traded with the Indian Ocean world. Archaeologists have found Chinese porcelain and glass beads at the site, which shows how far its trade reached. Its decline in the fifteenth century may have come from overuse of the land and shifts in trade routes.

Ethiopia

Ethiopia, in the highlands of East Africa, was a Christian kingdom that had existed since the fourth century. In the 1200s, the Zagwe dynasty, and then from 1270 the Solomonic dynasty, ruled from the highlands. Kings claimed descent from the biblical King Solomon and the Queen of Sheba, which supported their legitimacy. Ethiopia is known for its churches carved from solid rock at Lalibela, built under a Zagwe ruler about 1200. The kingdom was surrounded by Muslim states and traded with them while also fighting them for control of land and routes. It also kept contact with Christians in Egypt and Europe.

The Hausa kingdoms

In what is now northern Nigeria, a group of Hausa city-states, such as Kano and Katsina, developed from about 1000. Each was a walled city ruled by its own king and surrounded by farmland. The cities made cloth and leather goods and were important points on the trans-Saharan trade routes (Lesson 2.4). Hausa rulers adopted Islam over time, and Kano and Katsina became centers of Muslim learning. The Hausa kingdoms did not form one empire, which makes them an example of the diversity the CED mentions.

Two more African examples

The CED names three examples, but any account of African states in this period must include two others.

  • Mali. Founded about 1235 by Sundiata Keita, Mali grew into a large empire in West Africa that controlled much of the gold trade. Its most famous ruler, Mansa Musa (r. c. 1312 to 1337), made a pilgrimage to Mecca in 1324 and gave away so much gold in Cairo that it affected prices there. We return to Mali in Lesson 2.4.
  • The Swahili city-states. Along the East African coast, trading cities such as Kilwa, Mombasa, and Mogadishu grew rich in Indian Ocean trade. They were ruled by Muslim merchants and rulers, and their culture combined African, Arab, and Persian elements. We return to them in Lesson 2.3.

Why diversity matters

Some African societies had kings and large armies, and others were organized around lineages and councils of elders without central rulers. Trade, religion, and military force each shaped state growth, and no one pattern applied everywhere. Most African states relied on agriculture and herding and on trade in gold, salt, ivory, and enslaved people, and they built institutions that fit local needs, such as the stone buildings of Great Zimbabwe or the rock churches of Ethiopia.

Description of: Lalibela

Description of the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela, Ethiopia (c. 1200). This is a description of a monument, not a quotation.

Eleven churches were carved down into solid volcanic rock to form buildings, with courtyards and passages between them. Local tradition ties them to King Lalibela, who wanted to make a "new Jerusalem" in the highlands.

Sourcing (HIPP). The churches were commissioned by a king, so their point of view is royal and Christian. The purpose was religious devotion and the building of a holy site, and it also strengthened the ruler's legitimacy. The audience was worshipers and pilgrims. Because the sources for the king's motives come largely from later tradition, the monument is better evidence for the kingdom's wealth and its Christian identity than for the details of Lalibela's reign.

Source analysis · Religion and legitimacy

Claim. Ethiopian rulers used Christianity to strengthen their authority.

Evidence. A king had eleven churches carved from solid rock and linked to the idea of a "new Jerusalem," and later kings claimed descent from King Solomon.

Reasoning. Building a holy city and claiming a biblical ancestor tied the dynasty to sacred tradition, which made rule seem divinely supported. The limit is that the stories about Lalibela's motives come from later traditions, so the monument is stronger evidence for the kingdom's wealth and Christian identity than for exact events.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way African states developed through trade.

Model. Great Zimbabwe grew rich by trading gold and ivory with Swahili merchants on the coast, who linked it to the Indian Ocean world. The wealth supported the building of a large stone capital and the power of its rulers, and its decline in the fifteenth century coincided with shifts in trade routes and pressure on the land.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 1J asks how and why states in Africa developed and changed. Use specific examples: Great Zimbabwe (cattle and gold trade), Ethiopia (Christian kingship), the Hausa city-states (trans-Saharan trade and Islam), Mali (gold), and the Swahili coast (Indian Ocean trade). Say that African states differed from one another and were not isolated.

Practice
  1. What was Great Zimbabwe and how did it get wealthy?
    Show answer

    A stone-walled capital of a Shona-speaking state in southeastern Africa that grew rich through cattle herding and trade in gold and ivory with Swahili merchants.

  2. Why is Lalibela important?
    Show answer

    It is a site of eleven rock-cut churches built about 1200 under an Ethiopian king, showing the wealth of the Christian kingdom and the ruler's religious claims.

  3. What were the Hausa kingdoms?
    Show answer

    City-states in northern Nigeria such as Kano and Katsina, ruled by their own kings and involved in trans-Saharan trade; they were not united into one empire.

  4. Who was Mansa Musa?
    Show answer

    The ruler of Mali (r. c. 1312 to 1337) whose pilgrimage to Mecca in 1324, with large amounts of gold, made West African wealth famous.

  5. Which trade networks did the Swahili city-states belong to?
    Show answer

    The Indian Ocean trade network, linking East Africa to Arabia, India, and China.

  6. Give one example of diversity in African state building.
    Show answer

    Some societies had kings and large states, such as Mali and Great Zimbabwe, while others, such as the Hausa city-states, remained separate cities, and others were organized around lineages without central rulers.

Lesson 1.6 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.6

Europe, c. 1200 to c. 1450

Europe in 1200 was less wealthy and less unified than China or the Muslim world, and it was mostly rural. This lesson covers the three ideas the CED asks about: how Christianity and other religions shaped society, how political decentralization worked and why it developed, and how agriculture and coerced labor organized daily life.

Required content · 1K, 1L, 1M

Learning objectives.

  • 1K. Explain how the beliefs and practices of the predominant religions in Europe affected European society.
  • 1L. Explain the causes and consequences of political decentralization in Europe from c. 1200 to c. 1450.
  • 1M. Explain the effects of agriculture on social organization in Europe from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.III.D.v. Christianity, Judaism, Islam, and the core beliefs and practices of these religions continued to shape societies in Europe.
  • 3.2.I.B.ii. Europe was politically fragmented and characterized by decentralized monarchies, feudalism, and the manorial system.
  • 3.3.III.C. Europe was largely an agricultural society dependent on free and coerced labor, including serfdom.

Religion: Christianity, Judaism, and Islam

The CED says Christianity, Judaism, Islam, and the core beliefs and practices of these religions continued to shape societies in Europe. Roman Catholic Christianity was the dominant faith in western and central Europe, and the Church, led by the pope in Rome, was the only institution that crossed political borders. Monasteries preserved learning, parish priests served villages, and the Church owned much land and collected a tax called the tithe. Eastern Christianity under the Byzantine Empire, with its capital in Constantinople, followed the Orthodox Church and spread to Russia and southeastern Europe. Jewish communities lived in many European cities, often under restrictions, and sometimes faced violence. Muslim rule in parts of Spain and Sicily left a lasting mark, and Muslim scholarship helped bring Greek and Arabic learning into European universities, which began to appear in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.

The Church also launched the Crusades from 1095, a series of religious wars to take Jerusalem and the Holy Land from Muslim rule. They brought some European contact with the Muslim world and its goods and ideas, though the crusaders ultimately lost the territory they took.

Political decentralization

The CED says that Europe was politically fragmented and characterized by decentralized monarchies, feudalism, and the manorial system. After the Roman Empire collapsed in the west, no state controlled the whole region. Instead, power was spread out.

  • Feudalism. A lord granted land, called a fief, to a vassal who in return promised military service and loyalty. Vassals often had vassals of their own, so authority formed a chain from kings to knights. Because the system relied on personal agreements, kings often had less real power than the nobles who held the land.
  • Decentralized monarchies. Kings in France, England, and elsewhere existed, but their direct control was limited. In England, nobles forced King John to accept Magna Carta in 1215, which limited royal power by saying that the king had to follow the law.
  • The Holy Roman Empire. This was a loose collection of German and Italian states under an elected emperor with limited authority.

Why did Europe stay decentralized? Poor roads, regional languages, and weak money economies made central rule hard, and the Church and nobles competed with kings. Consequences included frequent local wars, protection of local rights, and, over time, the growth of assemblies where nobles and townspeople could advise rulers, such as the English Parliament. By the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, some kings in England, France, and Spain began to increase their power, which prepared the way for the stronger states of later centuries.

Agriculture and the manorial system

The CED says that Europe was largely an agricultural society dependent on free and coerced labor, including serfdom. Most people were peasants who farmed. Under the manorial system, a manor was an estate owned by a lord and worked by peasants. Some peasants were free and paid rent. Many others were serfs, who were bound to the land, could not leave without permission, and owed labor and a share of their crop to the lord. In return, the lord offered protection and the use of land. Serfs were not slaves, since they could not be sold apart from the land, but they had few rights.

Farming improved between 1000 and 1300. The heavy plow, the three-field system of crop rotation, and better harnesses for horses raised food output and helped the population and towns grow. This growth ended in the fourteenth century with famines and the Black Death (1347 to 1351), which killed perhaps a third or more of Europe's people. Because workers were scarce afterward, survivors often gained higher wages and more freedom, and serfdom weakened in much of western Europe (Lesson 2.6).

Description of: a manorial record

Description of a typical English manorial court roll or survey of the thirteenth century. This is a description, not a quotation.

Such records list the peasants on a manor, the plots they hold, the rent they pay, and the labor they owe on the lord's land. They also record fines for offenses, such as a serf leaving the manor without permission or a woman marrying without the lord's consent.

Sourcing (HIPP). Manorial records were kept by the lord's officials, so the point of view is that of the landholder. Their purpose was to record what the lord was owed and to enforce his rights. The audience was the lord and his stewards. Because the records focus on dues and fines, they tell us a great deal about how the system worked, but little about what peasants thought of it.

Source analysis · Serfdom

Claim. Serfs had limited freedom under the manorial system.

Evidence. The records list labor owed to the lord and fines for leaving the manor without permission or marrying without consent.

Reasoning. A person who needs the lord's permission to leave or marry, and who owes labor on the lord's land, is bound to the estate. A limit is that the records were kept by the lord's officials for the lord's purposes, so they emphasize dues and enforcement and say little about how peasants viewed or resisted the system.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one cause and one effect of political decentralization in Europe.

Model. One cause was the lack of a strong central authority after the Roman Empire, along with poor roads and weak money, which made it hard for kings to control distant regions, so lords held land in exchange for military service. One effect was that nobles could limit kings, as in Magna Carta in 1215, and assemblies such as Parliament developed.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 1K to 1M ask about religion, decentralization, and agriculture. Define feudalism, the manor, and serfdom, and link each to a cause and an effect. For Europe, remember that the Church was the single unifying institution and that the Black Death began to change labor relations.

Practice
  1. What was feudalism?
    Show answer

    A system in which lords granted land (fiefs) to vassals in exchange for military service and loyalty, creating chains of personal obligation.

  2. Why was the Church important in medieval Europe?
    Show answer

    It was the one institution that crossed political borders, preserved learning, owned much land, collected the tithe, and shaped daily life.

  3. What did Magna Carta do?
    Show answer

    In 1215 it forced King John of England to accept limits on royal power, establishing that the king had to follow the law.

  4. What was a serf?
    Show answer

    A peasant bound to the land who owed labor and a share of crops to the lord and could not leave without permission.

  5. Name one agricultural improvement of the period.
    Show answer

    The heavy plow, the three-field crop rotation, or better horse harnesses.

  6. How did the Black Death affect labor?
    Show answer

    It killed a large share of the population, so workers were scarce and survivors often gained higher wages and more freedom, which weakened serfdom in much of western Europe.

Lesson 1.7 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.7

Comparison: state formation, c. 1200 to c. 1450

This lesson practices comparison, the reasoning process the CED attaches to this topic. Comparison does not mean listing facts about two societies, because it means saying what they share, how they differ, and why. The topic: how states formed and developed between about 1200 and 1450 in East Asia, the Islamic world, South and Southeast Asia, the Americas, Africa, and Europe.

Required content · 1N

Learning objective.

  • 1N. Explain the similarities and differences in the processes of state formation from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.A. Empires and states in Afro-Eurasia and the Americas demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity in the 13th century. This included the Song Dynasty of China, which utilized traditional methods of Confucianism and an imperial bureaucracy to maintain and justify its rule.
  • 3.2.I.B.i. State formation and development demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, including the new Hindu and Buddhist states that emerged in South and Southeast Asia.
  • 3.2.I.D.i. In the Americas, as in Afro-Eurasia, state systems demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, and expanded in scope and reach.
  • 3.2.I.D.ii. In Africa, as in Eurasia and the Americas, state systems demonstrated continuity, innovation, and diversity, and expanded in scope and reach.

How to compare

A strong comparison has three parts.

  1. A category. Compare along one dimension, such as how rulers justified power, how states raised resources, or what role religion played.
  2. A similarity and a difference. Both are needed. "Both used religion to support rule" is a similarity. "One relied on a bureaucracy and the other on personal ties" is a difference.
  3. A reason. Explain why. Geography, trade, and earlier traditions are common reasons.

Comparing states

RegionHow rulers held powerMain resourcesRole of religion
Song ChinaBureaucracy chosen by examRice farming, iron, trade, paper moneyConfucianism and Buddhism
Dar al-IslamSultans, military leadersTrade and agricultureIslam and Islamic law
South and Southeast AsiaKings, sultans, regional kingdomsRice, sea trade, tributeHinduism, Buddhism, Islam
The AmericasDivine kings, tribute, labor serviceMaize, chinampas, labor serviceState religions
AfricaKings and city-states, trade-based statesGold, cattle, tradeIslam, Christianity, local religions
EuropeFeudal lords and decentralized monarchsAgriculture on manorsRoman Catholic Church

Some patterns stand out.

  • Similarities. Almost every state used religion or ideas to justify rule, such as Confucianism in China, Islam in Delhi and Mali, Hinduism and Buddhism in Khmer and Vijayanagara, divine kingship in the Inca state, and Christianity in Ethiopia and Europe. Many states relied on agriculture and on trade, and many taxed trade or used tribute and labor service.
  • Differences in method. China relied on a bureaucracy selected by examination, which is more impersonal than the personal ties of European feudalism. The Mexica and Inca extracted tribute and labor from conquered peoples, while Delhi's sultans taxed a mostly Hindu population. Some states, like Srivijaya and the Swahili cities, were built on sea trade, while others, like the Khmer and the Inca, relied on land and agriculture.
  • Differences in centralization. China, the Inca, and Mamluk Egypt had strong central governments, while Europe and the Hausa kingdoms were decentralized.

Why the differences?

Geography and resources played a role. Trade routes by sea or land made some regions rich through taxation. Earlier traditions mattered too, since China had centuries of bureaucratic experience, while Europe inherited the broken Roman state and the strength of the Church. Contact with other societies also mattered, since Muslim and Chinese technologies moved across Eurasia, while the Americas developed in isolation from Afro-Eurasia.

Figure 1.1 in Lesson 1.1 shows that these state formations occurred at different times, so comparing them requires careful dating.

Practice source · A modern comparison table (constructed for this lesson)

A kind of source the exam uses: a modern historian's table comparing the sizes and capitals of major states around 1300. This is a description of a type of source, not a quotation from a real table.

Imagine a table that lists each state's capital, ruler, and estimated population, from the Yuan dynasty of China, which was by far the largest, to the small kingdoms of Europe.

Sourcing (HIPP). A modern historian would compile such a table from many sources, so the point of view is that of scholarship. Its purpose is to summarize and allow comparison, and its audience is students and scholars. Because population numbers for this period are estimates based on incomplete records, such a table is useful for rough comparison of scale but should not be treated as exact.

Source analysis · Using estimates

Claim. Chinese states were much larger than European states around 1300.

Evidence. A scholar's table lists the Yuan dynasty's population as far greater than those of the small kingdoms of Europe.

Reasoning. The scale of the Chinese state gave it more resources for administration and defense than European kingdoms had. A limit is that population numbers for this period are estimates from incomplete records, so they support a general claim about relative size better than any exact figure.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare how two states justified their rule between 1200 and 1450.

Model. Both Song China and the Inca Empire tied their rule to a belief system. Song rulers used Confucian ideas of virtuous government and a bureaucracy chosen by exam, while the Inca ruler was believed to be descended from the sun god, which gave him divine authority. The difference is that Chinese legitimacy rested on moral conduct and learning, whereas the Inca emperor's rested on divine descent, which reflects the different religious traditions of each region.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 1N is a comparison objective. On the exam, pick a category (justifying power, raising resources, role of religion), give one similarity and one difference, and explain why. Use specific examples named in the CED: Song bureaucracy, Delhi Sultanate, Vijayanagara, Maya, Mexica, Inca, Great Zimbabwe, Ethiopia, and decentralized Europe.

Practice
  1. What are the three parts of a strong comparison?
    Show answer

    A category of comparison, at least one similarity and one difference, and a reason that explains them.

  2. Give one similarity among states of this period.
    Show answer

    Many states used religion or ideas to justify rule, such as Confucianism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, or divine kingship.

  3. Contrast China's government with Europe's.
    Show answer

    China had a centralized bureaucracy chosen by exam, while Europe was decentralized and held together by personal feudal ties.

  4. Contrast sea-based and land-based states.
    Show answer

    Sea-based states such as Srivijaya and the Swahili cities relied on trade revenue, while land-based states such as the Khmer and the Inca relied on agriculture and labor.

  5. Why did Chinese bureaucratic traditions matter?
    Show answer

    China had centuries of experience with bureaucratic government, which gave Song rulers tools for central control that Europe, with its broken Roman inheritance, lacked.

  6. Which two American states relied on obtaining resources from conquered peoples?
    Show answer

    The Mexica, through tribute, and the Inca, through the mit'a labor system.

Unit 1 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 1 review: The Global Tapestry, c. 1200–c. 1450

Ten stimulus- and knowledge-based multiple-choice questions and two short-answer questions covering Song China and East Asia, Dar al-Islam, South and Southeast Asia, the Americas and Africa, and Europe: click an option to see why each answer is right or wrong, then write the SAQs on paper before opening the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Description of: a Song-dynasty handscroll of a city on the eve of a spring festival, painted for the imperial court, early twelfth century.

    Porters unload sacks from flat-bottomed river boats; a crowd watches a large vessel lower its mast to pass beneath an arched bridge. Shopfronts line the streets under cloth awnings: a wine shop, a physician, a scribe writing for a customer. Camels carrying bundles enter through a city gate. Several hundred figures fill the roadway; no soldiers appear.

    The image is most useful as evidence for which of the following?

    Correct. Specialized shops, hired porters, river and camel transport, and a dense street population all document an economy in which many people lived by commerce rather than by farming.

    The description explicitly notes that no soldiers appear. A court scroll showing civil prosperity is poor evidence about military arrangements.

    Camels entering the city gate and boats unloading cargo indicate active long-distance trade, not its decline.

    The scene is entirely urban and commercial. Subsistence agriculture would be shown in the countryside, and the scroll's subject is the city.

  2. The Song civil service examination system differed most significantly from contemporary European arrangements in that it

    Correct. Europe's political authority rested on inherited land and armed retainers, while Song officials owed their positions to performance on examinations set by the state.

    Formally open but practically restricted: years of study required family money, so the candidates were overwhelmingly from landholding or merchant households.

    The examinations tested the Confucian classics. Song China deliberately subordinated the military to the civil bureaucracy.

    This describes aspects of medieval Europe, where the Church held a near-monopoly on literacy, rather than Song China.

  3. Source: Ibn Battuta, Rihla, describing Cairo, mid-fourteenth century; early English translation.

    "Cairo, mother of cities … she surges as the sea with her throngs of folk and can scarce contain them for all the capacity of her situation and sustaining power."

    Ibn Battuta's career is most useful to historians as evidence for which of the following?

    The period is defined by the opposite: the Abbasid caliphate had fragmented into Seljuk, Mamluk, and Delhi sultanates with no single ruler.

    Correct. A Moroccan legal scholar could find employment as a judge in Delhi and the Maldives on the strength of a shared training: his mobility is itself the evidence for integration without political unity.

    His own career as a scholar finding posts across three continents demonstrates that scholarship was flourishing and portable.

    Ibn Battuta traveled for roughly thirty years across Africa, Asia, and Europe, which disproves rather than supports this.

  4. Islam spread into West Africa, South Asia, and Southeast Asia in this period primarily through

    Arab conquests had ended centuries earlier and never reached these regions. Expansion after 1200 followed commerce, not armies.

    Correct. Sufism's emphasis on personal devotion and tolerance of local practice made Islam adaptable, and it traveled with merchants along Saharan and Indian Ocean routes.

    The Delhi Sultanate governed a Hindu majority largely by accommodation, collecting the jizya rather than compelling conversion.

    The Abbasid caliph retained religious prestige but little power in this period and organized no such missionary program.

  5. Description of: the temple complex at Angkor, built by Khmer rulers in the twelfth century.

    The central temple rises in stepped terraces to five lotus-bud towers, ringed by a moat more than three miles around. Bas-relief galleries run for hundreds of meters. Beyond the temple, survey reveals a grid of reservoirs and canals covering hundreds of square kilometers, capable of storing monsoon water for dry-season rice cultivation.

    The hydraulic system described provides the strongest evidence for which conclusion about the Khmer state?

    Correct. Digging and maintaining reservoirs across hundreds of square kilometers required mobilizing and feeding labor year after year, which only a state controlling substantial agricultural surplus could do.

    That describes sea-based states such as Srivijaya. The Khmer built inland on the Mekong floodplain and lived on rice agriculture.

    The complex was later converted to Buddhist use, but the reliefs depict Hindu epics and the reservoirs say nothing about religion either way.

    Nothing in the evidence indicates foreign expertise, and the scale points to locally organized capacity rather than imported skill.

  6. Which best describes a difference between the Mexica and Inca empires?

    Correct. The Mexica left conquered city-states intact and demanded tribute, while the Inca built roads, resettled populations, and bound communities through the mit'a labor obligation.

    Neither empire had iron tools or draft animals, which is what makes their construction and administration so notable.

    Both practiced intensive agriculture: the Mexica using chinampas, the Inca terracing. Neither was primarily pastoral.

    The Inca kept detailed records on khipu, knotted cords used for census and tribute accounting, even without a writing system.

  7. Source: al-Umari, an Egyptian official, recording in the 1330s what was remembered in Cairo of Mansa Musa's visit; early English translation.

    "This man flooded Cairo with his benefactions. He left no court emir nor holder of a royal office without the gift of a load of gold. … They spoiled the value of money."

    This passage is most reliable as evidence for which of the following?

    Al-Umari wrote a decade later from what Cairo officials recalled, so his impression of quantity is unreliable. Contemporary figures for treasure rarely are.

    Correct. A measurable effect on Cairo's currency shows that Mali's gold mattered to the economy of the largest city in the Islamic world.

    Mali did not control most of the goldfields, whose locations the mining peoples kept secret, and the passage says nothing about extraction.

    The source records spending in Cairo, not motive. Inferring personal piety from public generosity would go well beyond the evidence.

  8. The Swahili city-states of the East African coast are best characterized as

    Kilwa, Mombasa, and Mogadishu were separate and often rival city-states, never unified under one inland authority.

    Correct. Their wealth came from Indian Ocean commerce, and the encounter produced a Bantu language heavily marked by Arabic and an elite that converted to Islam.

    They flourished for centuries before the Portuguese arrived; Ibn Battuta praised Kilwa in the 1330s, well over a century earlier.

    They controlled ports rather than farmland, exporting gold and ivory that came from the interior through intermediaries.

  9. Description of: a manorial survey of an English estate, thirteenth century.

    A villein holding thirty acres owes three days' work a week on the lord's demesne, extra days at harvest, rent in hens and eggs at Christmas, a payment when a daughter marries outside the manor, and the best beast on his death. Free tenants on the same estate owe cash rent and no labor.

    The contrast between villein and free tenants on the same estate best demonstrates that

    Correct. Two tenants could work comparable land on the same manor and owe entirely different obligations, because the difference lay in legal condition rather than in wealth.

    The survey records labor services in detail, which is the opposite of conversion to wages. Cash rents appear only for the free tenants.

    Three days a week plus harvest boon-work is a substantial extraction, and the survey exists to record the lord's claims.

    The document gives the villein thirty acres and does not state that free tenants held more. Acreage is not the variable distinguishing them.

  10. Compared with Song China and the Delhi Sultanate around 1200, western Europe was distinctive in that

    The largest and richest cities of the period were in China and the Islamic world. European towns were small by comparison.

    Correct. Feudal Europe distributed authority through oaths between lords and vassals, while Song China governed through a salaried examination bureaucracy and the Delhi Sultanate through appointed officials.

    Hereditary nobility was the foundation of European political order in 1200. Recruitment by examination describes China, not Europe.

    Europe sat at the far end of the Eurasian trade network, buying luxuries through Italian and Islamic intermediaries.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way a state in Afro-Eurasia organized political authority in the period 1200–1450.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the method you described in (a) differed from the practice of another state in the same period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way religion contributed to political or cultural integration in this period.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the Song examination bureaucracy; the Delhi Sultanate ruling a Hindu majority through accommodation and the jizya; Inca integration by road, storehouse, and mit'a; Mexica tribute through local rulers; European feudal oaths and manorialism; Mali taxing trade routes. Must name a state and a mechanism.
    • (b) Accept any accurate contrast that names a second state and its different basis of authority: recruitment by examination against inherited land, tribute extraction against direct integration, control of trade routes against control of territory. Do not accept a second description with no comparison made.
    • (c) Accept: Dar al-Islam's shared law and Arabic scholarship binding a politically divided zone; Sufism carrying Islam along trade routes; the Roman Catholic Church as Europe's one trans-regional institution; Neo-Confucianism shaping Chinese administration and spreading to Korea, Japan, and Vietnam; the bhakti movement crossing caste lines.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Song China recruited its administrators through civil service examinations on the Confucian classics, producing a bureaucracy of scholar-officials who owed their positions to the emperor and to a curriculum the state controlled rather than to inherited land.

    (b) In western Europe over the same period, political authority rested on inherited landholding and personal oaths between lords and vassals. A European lord's power came from land his family held and the armed retainers he could summon, which made it far harder for a monarch to remove him than for a Chinese emperor to remove an official.

    (c) Across Dar al-Islam, shared religious law and the use of Arabic as a language of scholarship allowed merchants, scholars, and pilgrims to move through a zone no single ruler governed. Ibn Battuta, a Moroccan legal scholar, found employment as a judge in both Delhi and the Maldives on the strength of that common training.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way the natural environment shaped a society in the Americas or Africa in the period 1200–1450.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way a state in this period used labor or tribute to maintain power.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of the sources available for studying societies that left few written records.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: chinampa agriculture on Lake Texcoco supporting Tenochtitlan; Andean terracing and vertical ecology; Saharan oases and camel routes structuring West African trade; the monsoon shaping Swahili coastal commerce; Great Zimbabwe's position on interior gold routes. Must link environment to a social or political outcome.
    • (b) Accept: the Inca mit'a rotational labor; Mexica tribute through conquered city-states; Mali taxing trans-Saharan caravans; European labor services owed by villeins. Must explain how it sustained the state.
    • (c) Accept: material evidence can show scale and organization but not intention or point of view; surviving written accounts of these societies were frequently produced by outsiders or later conquerors; khipu records cannot be fully read; elite perspectives dominate what survives. Must identify a specific limitation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The Mexica built Tenochtitlan on an island in Lake Texcoco and fed a population of around 200,000 using chinampas, raised garden beds constructed from lake mud. The lake environment that limited ordinary farmland was turned into the basis of an unusually productive agriculture.

    (b) The Inca required conquered communities to provide rotating labor service through the mit'a, working on roads, terraces, mines, and state lands for fixed periods. This supplied the empire with a workforce for infrastructure without a cash economy and bound communities to the state through a continuing obligation.

    (c) Societies such as the Inca left material evidence (roads, terraces, khipu) that documents organizational capacity but not motive or debate. Archaeology can show that a state mobilized enormous labor, but it cannot recover what the people performing that labor thought about it, and the written accounts that do survive were largely produced later by Spanish conquerors.

Lesson 2.1 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.1

The Silk Roads and the growth of trade

The Silk Roads were a web of overland and sea routes that linked China, Central Asia, India, the Middle East, and the Mediterranean. They carried silk and other goods, but also ideas, religions, and diseases. Their trade had existed for more than a thousand years, but the CED says that after 1200 improved commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes. This lesson covers what made trade grow, what was traded, and which cities rose because of it.

Required content · 2A

Learning objective.

  • 2A. Explain the causes and effects of growth of networks of exchange after 1200.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.I.A.i. Improved commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes, including the Silk Roads, promoting the growth of powerful new trading cities.
  • 3.1.I.C.i. The growth of interregional trade in luxury goods was encouraged by innovations in previously existing transportation and commercial technologies, including the caravanserai, forms of credit, and the development of money economies.
  • 3.3.I.B. Demand for luxury goods increased in Afro-Eurasia. Chinese, Persian, and Indian artisans and merchants expanded their production of textiles and porcelains for export; manufacture of iron and steel expanded in China.

What the Silk Roads were

No single road existed. Merchants traveled in stages, passing goods from one trader to the next, so few people made the whole trip from China to the Mediterranean. Caravans of camels and horses crossed deserts and mountains, stopping at oasis towns that offered water, food, and markets. Routes shifted as wars, climate, and politics changed which were safe. Between about 1200 and 1450, the rise of the Mongol Empire (Lesson 2.2) made travel across Eurasia easier and safer than it had been for a long time.

Why trade grew: commercial and transportation innovations

The CED points to innovations in previously existing transportation and commercial technologies, including the following.

  • Caravanserai. A caravanserai was a roadside inn with a walled courtyard, stables, storage, and rooms where merchants and animals could rest. Rulers and wealthy donors built networks of them along main routes, which lowered the cost and risk of long journeys.
  • Forms of credit. Merchants carried bills of exchange and letters of credit rather than heavy coins. A merchant could deposit money in one city and collect an equal amount elsewhere, which reduced the risk of robbery. Some banking houses, such as those in the Italian cities, grew rich by lending to merchants.
  • Money economies. Governments and merchants relied more on coin and paper money than on barter. The Chinese had used paper notes since the Song dynasty (Lesson 1.1), and the Mongol rulers of Yuan China made paper money the main currency, which drew curiosity from travelers.
  • Larger demand and supply. Wealthy buyers across Eurasia wanted luxury goods, and producers expanded output to meet them.

What was traded

The CED stresses that demand for luxury goods increased in Afro-Eurasia. Chinese, Persian, and Indian artisans and merchants expanded their production of textiles and porcelains for export, and the manufacture of iron and steel expanded in China. Silk and cotton cloth, porcelain, spices from South and Southeast Asia, precious stones, and horses from Central Asia all moved along the routes. In the other direction, gold, silver, and woolen goods from the west paid for eastern products. Notice that these goods were mostly luxuries, since carrying bulk goods over mountains and deserts was too expensive. Bulk trade, such as grain, moved by sea (Lesson 2.3).

The rise of trading cities

Trade promoted the growth of powerful new trading cities. The CED names two. Kashgar, in the far west of China, was an oasis city where roads from China, India, and Persia met. Samarkand, in Central Asia, was a major market and a center of crafts and learning. Cities like these grew by taxing, housing, and supplying merchants, and many became centers of different faiths and languages. Other trading cities, such as Venice, Genoa, Baghdad, Cairo, and Hangzhou, also grew rich from the same commerce, and their merchants built connections among separate regions.

Effects

The Silk Roads did more than move goods. Religions such as Buddhism and Islam traveled along them, and so did technologies such as papermaking and gunpowder, which we return to in Lesson 2.5. The routes also carried disease, which Lesson 2.6 covers. For ordinary people, effects varied. Artisans and merchants in cities could prosper, but farmers and herders along the routes sometimes faced taxes and the burdens of supplying travelers, and few ordinary people ever used the luxury goods.

Description of: Marco Polo on paper money

Description of a passage in The Travels of Marco Polo, the account of a Venetian merchant who spent years in Asia and said he served the Mongol ruler Khubilai Khan. This is a description, not a quotation.

Polo described how the Great Khan issued paper notes made from the bark of mulberry trees, stamped with his seal, which his subjects had to accept as payment for goods. He marveled that the ruler had thus found a way to make money from paper and to buy valuable goods with it.

Sourcing (HIPP). Polo's book was dictated around 1298 to a writer named Rustichello while Polo was in a Genoese prison. His point of view was that of a Venetian merchant impressed by wealth he had not seen at home. The purpose was probably to entertain and inform readers and perhaps to advertise a world of commercial opportunity. The audience was European readers. Scholars debate how much of Asia Polo actually saw, and some details are exaggerated, so the passage is good evidence of how a European merchant viewed Mongol China's money, but less reliable on how paper money worked in practice.

Source analysis · Credit and money

Claim. Paper money was one of the commercial practices that supported the growth of trade in this period.

Evidence. Polo described the Great Khan's notes of mulberry bark, stamped with his seal, that his subjects had to accept as payment.

Reasoning. Paper money is lighter and safer to carry than coin, so it eased trade across a large empire. The Mongol ruler's requirement that subjects accept it shows that states helped create the money economy. A limit is that Polo was a foreign merchant writing years later for European readers, so his description may exaggerate how smoothly the system worked.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one cause of the growth of trade on the Silk Roads after 1200.

Model. One cause was the creation of caravanserai and new forms of credit. Caravanserai gave merchants safe places to rest and store goods, which made long journeys less risky, and bills of exchange let them move money without carrying heavy coin. Both reduced the cost and danger of long-distance trade, so more merchants made the journey.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 2A asks for causes and effects of growth in networks of exchange. List causes (caravanserai, credit, money economies, demand for luxuries) and effects (trading cities such as Kashgar and Samarkand, spread of goods, religions, and technologies). Be ready to say why luxuries dominated overland trade.

Practice
  1. What was a caravanserai?
    Show answer

    A roadside inn with a walled courtyard, stables, and storage where merchants and animals could rest, which made long-distance travel safer and cheaper.

  2. Name two forms of credit or money used in Eurasian trade.
    Show answer

    Bills of exchange, banking houses, and paper money.

  3. Why did overland trade focus on luxury goods?
    Show answer

    Goods had to be carried by animals over long, expensive distances, so only high-value items such as silk, porcelain, and spices were worth the cost.

  4. Name two trading cities that grew because of the Silk Roads.
    Show answer

    Kashgar and Samarkand (others include Baghdad, Cairo, and Hangzhou).

  5. What did Chinese, Persian, and Indian artisans produce for export?
    Show answer

    Textiles and porcelains, and Chinese iron and steel production also expanded.

  6. Why must a historian be careful with Marco Polo as a source?
    Show answer

    His book was dictated years later to a writer, written for European readers, and contains exaggerations, so his account of Mongol China has to be checked against other evidence.

Lesson 2.2 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.2

The Mongol Empire and the making of the modern world

In 1200 the Mongols were herders on the steppe of Central Asia. By 1300 they had built the largest connected land empire in history, stretching from Korea to Hungary. This lesson covers how the Mongol Empire was built, how it ruled, how it changed trade and communication, and why historians argue about its legacy.

Required content · 2B, 2C, 2D

Learning objectives.

  • 2B. Explain the process of state building and decline in Eurasia over time.
  • 2C. Explain how the expansion of empires influenced trade and communication over time.
  • 2D. Explain the significance of the Mongol Empire in larger patterns of continuity and change.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.B.iii. Empires collapsed in different regions of the world and in some areas were replaced by new imperial states, including the Mongol khanates.
  • 3.1.I.E.i. The expansion of empires, including the Mongols, facilitated Afro-Eurasian trade and communication as new people were drawn into their conquerors’ economies and trade networks.
  • 3.2.II.A.ii. Interregional contacts and conflicts between states and empires, including the Mongols, encouraged significant technological and cultural transfers.

The rise of the Mongols

The Mongols were organized into clans of mounted archers. In 1206 a leader named Temujin was recognized as Chinggis Khan ("universal ruler") by a great assembly of Mongol chiefs. He reorganized the army on a decimal system of units of ten, hundred, thousand, and ten thousand, and he promoted men on merit rather than clan loyalty. Mongol armies were fast, disciplined, and skilled at siege warfare, and they used technology from the people they conquered, including Chinese engineers and gunpowder.

Over the next decades the Mongols conquered northern China, Central Asia, Persia, and Russia, and they raided Hungary and Poland in 1241. In 1258 they sacked Baghdad and ended the Abbasid caliphate. After Chinggis's death in 1227, the empire was divided among his descendants into regional khanates, such as the Yuan dynasty in China, founded in 1271 by Khubilai Khan, the Ilkhanate in Persia, the Golden Horde in Russia, and the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia. The CED says that empires collapsed in different regions of the world and in some areas were replaced by new imperial states, including the Mongol khanates.

1206 Chinggis Khan unites the Mongols 1219 Invasion of Khwarazm 1241 Raids reach Hungary and Poland 1258 Baghdad falls 1260 Mamluks halt Mongols at Ain Jalut 1271 Khubilai founds Yuan dynasty 1347 Plague reaches Mediterranean 1368 Yuan overthrown by the Ming
Figure 2.1. Rise and fall of Mongol power. Conquest was fast, the connections it made lasted longer, and the same routes later carried plague.

How the Mongols ruled

  • Rule through existing elites. The Mongols usually left local officials and customs in place in conquered lands and used educated foreigners, including Chinese, Persians, and Uyghurs, to manage administration and taxes.
  • Religious tolerance. Mongol rulers tolerated Buddhists, Muslims, Christians, and others, partly because it kept conquered peoples calm. In the Ilkhanate and Golden Horde, the rulers eventually converted to Islam, which shows how rulers adapted to their subjects.
  • Communications. A relay system called the yam gave official couriers fresh horses and lodging at stations, which allowed messages to travel enormous distances quickly. Travelers with a passport tablet could use it.
  • Law and commerce. The Mongols protected merchants, because trade brought them revenue. Their rule reduced the number of states along the Silk Roads that taxed and fought over the routes.

The Pax Mongolica

Historians call the period of relative peace and safe travel under Mongol rule the Pax Mongolica ("Mongol peace"). The CED says that the expansion of empires, including the Mongols, facilitated Afro-Eurasian trade and communication as new people were drawn into their conquerors' economies and trade networks. Merchants such as the Polo family, missionaries, and diplomats crossed Eurasia. The same safety helped spread both goods and ideas, and, as Lesson 2.6 shows, disease.

Transfers of technology and culture

Contact between the Mongol realms encouraged significant technological and cultural transfers.

  • Medicine. Greco-Islamic medical knowledge passed to western Europe and China.
  • Numbers. Numbering systems from the Muslim world reached Europe, where they gradually replaced Roman numerals.
  • Writing. The Mongols adopted the Uyghur script to write the Mongol language.
  • Technology. Gunpowder, printing, and papermaking from China spread westward, and Persian and Chinese experts shared astronomy and mathematics.

Destruction and decline

The Mongols were not only builders. Their conquests destroyed cities such as Baghdad, killed large numbers of people, and damaged irrigation systems in parts of Persia and Central Asia. Historians debate whether their rule was mostly destructive or whether it made the connections that later states built on. The empire broke into separate khanates because of disputes over succession, the difficulty of ruling vast distances, and the pull of local cultures, since khans adopted the religions and customs of the lands they ruled. Plague in the fourteenth century added to the strain, and the Yuan dynasty was overthrown by a rebellion that founded the Ming dynasty in 1368. Russian princes and others later challenged the Golden Horde.

Description of: a Persian account of conquest

Description of the History of the World Conqueror by Ata-Malik Juvaini (c. 1260). This is a description, not a quotation.

Juvaini, a Persian official who served the Mongols, wrote about their invasions of Iran. He described the destruction of cities such as Bukhara, in which the population was killed or enslaved and buildings burned. He also wrote about the Mongols' organization and their leaders' sense of divine mission.

Sourcing (HIPP). Juvaini was a Muslim administrator who worked for the Mongol governors of Persia, so his point of view is that of a conquered man who served the conquerors. His purpose was to record the Mongol conquests and probably to praise his patrons, and his audience included Mongol rulers and the educated Persian elite. Because he served the Mongols, his account may soften criticism, yet his description of the destruction is still strong evidence of the violence of the conquests.

Source analysis · A servant of the conquerors

Claim. The Mongol conquests caused great destruction in Persia.

Evidence. Juvaini, a Persian official, wrote that cities such as Bukhara were burned and their people killed or enslaved.

Reasoning. A writer who served the Mongols would have reason to soften criticism, so his report of destruction is credible evidence that the violence was real. A limit is that he also wrote to praise his patrons, so his account may also emphasize Mongol organization and legitimacy.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way the Mongol Empire changed Eurasia and one way it continued earlier patterns.

Model. One change was that the Mongols linked a huge area under a single political system for a time, which made travel safer and spread technologies such as gunpowder and papermaking westward. One continuity was that trade continued along older Silk Road routes, and the Mongols ruled through existing local elites and religions rather than replacing them.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 2B to 2D ask about state building and decline, trade and communication, and the empire's significance. Give specifics: Chinggis Khan and the decimal army, the four khanates, rule through local elites, the yam, the Pax Mongolica, and transfers (medicine, numbers, writing, gunpowder). Present both sides, since the empire was destructive and connecting.

Practice
  1. Who was Chinggis Khan?
    Show answer

    The leader recognized by a great assembly in 1206 as ruler of all Mongols, who built the army and began the conquests that created the empire.

  2. Name two Mongol khanates.
    Show answer

    The Yuan dynasty in China, the Ilkhanate in Persia, the Golden Horde in Russia, or the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia.

  3. What was the yam?
    Show answer

    A relay system of stations that supplied official couriers with fresh horses and lodging, enabling fast communication across the empire.

  4. What was the Pax Mongolica?
    Show answer

    The period of relative peace and safe travel under Mongol rule that encouraged trade and communication across Eurasia.

  5. Give one technological or cultural transfer encouraged by the Mongols.
    Show answer

    Greco-Islamic medical knowledge to Europe, numbering systems to Europe, adoption of the Uyghur script, or the westward spread of gunpowder and papermaking.

  6. Why did the Mongol Empire break into khanates?
    Show answer

    Disputes over succession, the difficulty of ruling vast distances, and the pull of local cultures and religions divided it, and later plague and rebellion weakened it further.

Lesson 2.3 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.3

Exchange in the Indian Ocean

The Indian Ocean was the busiest trading sea in the world. It linked East Africa, Arabia, Persia, India, Southeast Asia, and China. This lesson covers why trade there grew, which technologies and environmental knowledge made it possible, how it created states and merchant communities, and what the voyages of Zheng He show about the limits of state-led trade.

Required content · 2E, 2F, 2G

Learning objectives.

  • 2E. Explain the causes of the growth of networks of exchange after 1200.
  • 2F. Explain the effects of the growth of networks of exchange after 1200.
  • 2G. Explain the role of environmental factors in the development of networks of exchange in the period from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.I.A.ii. Improved transportation technologies and commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes, including the Indian Ocean, promoting the growth of powerful new trading cities.
  • 3.1.I.C.ii. The growth of interregional trade in luxury goods was encouraged by significant innovations in previously existing transportation and commercial technologies, including the use of the compass, the astrolabe, and larger ship designs.
  • 3.1.I.A.iii. The Indian Ocean trading network fostered the growth of states.
  • 3.1.III.B. In key places along important trade routes, merchants set up diasporic communities where they introduced their own cultural traditions into the indigenous cultures and, in turn, indigenous cultures influenced merchant cultures.
  • 3.2.II.A.iii. Interregional contacts and conflicts between states and empires encouraged significant technological and cultural transfers, including during Chinese maritime activity led by Ming Admiral Zheng He.
  • 3.1.II.A.i. The expansion and intensification of long-distance trade routes often depended on environmental knowledge, including advanced knowledge of the monsoon winds.

The monsoons: environment shapes trade

The CED says that the expansion and intensification of long-distance trade routes often depended on environmental knowledge, including advanced knowledge of the monsoon winds. The monsoons are seasonal winds. In the summer they blow from the southwest, from Africa and Arabia toward India. In the winter they reverse and blow from the northeast. Sailors learned to leave on one wind, trade for months in a distant port, and return on the opposite wind. This pattern made long journeys predictable and shaped the trading year.

Technologies that made trade possible

The CED lists significant innovations in previously existing transportation and commercial technologies, including the use of the compass, the astrolabe, and larger ship designs.

  • Ships. The dhow, with its triangular lateen sail, was a flexible Arab and Indian vessel that could sail across and against the wind. Chinese shipbuilders developed large junks with watertight compartments and rudders, which carried more cargo.
  • The compass. Chinese sailors used the magnetic compass, which later reached the Indian Ocean and Mediterranean.
  • The astrolabe. Developed and refined by Muslim astronomers, the astrolabe let sailors measure the height of stars above the horizon to find their position.

What was traded

Unlike overland routes, the sea allowed bulk goods. Ships carried spices such as pepper and cloves, cotton cloth from India, porcelain and silk from China, ivory, gold, and enslaved people from East Africa, horses from Arabia, and timber, grain, and other bulky goods. Because ships could carry far more than camels, the Indian Ocean network was larger and cheaper than the overland Silk Roads.

States and trading cities

The CED says that the Indian Ocean trading network fostered the growth of states. It gives three examples.

  • City-states of the Swahili Coast. Cities such as Kilwa, Mombasa, and Mogadishu on the East African coast grew rich from the trade in gold, ivory, and goods from the interior. They were ruled by Muslim merchants and rulers, and Swahili culture and language combined African and Arab elements.
  • Gujarat. This region in western India was a center of textile manufacturing and a home to merchants who traveled throughout the ocean.
  • Sultanate of Malacca. Founded about 1400 on the Strait of Malacca in Southeast Asia, Malacca grew rich by controlling ship traffic and by providing a market, and its rulers adopted Islam, which helped attract Muslim merchants.

Diasporic merchant communities

In important ports, merchants formed diasporic communities, groups living far from their homeland who kept their own customs. The CED says that merchants introduced their own cultural traditions into the indigenous cultures and, in turn, indigenous cultures influenced merchant cultures. Arab and Persian merchants settled on the East African coast, Gujarati merchants in Southeast Asia, and Chinese merchants in Southeast Asian ports. Their intermarriage with local people and exchange of customs helped spread Islam and produced mixed cultures such as that of the Swahili.

Zheng He's voyages

Between 1405 and 1433, the Ming dynasty sent seven great naval expeditions under the admiral Zheng He, a Muslim eunuch from southwestern China. His fleets, some with more than 200 ships and tens of thousands of men, visited Southeast Asia, India, Arabia, and East Africa. The CED says that interregional contacts encouraged significant technological and cultural transfers, including during Chinese maritime activity led by Ming Admiral Zheng He. The voyages displayed Ming power, collected tribute from foreign rulers, and spread Chinese goods. They were state projects, not private trade, and they were expensive. After 1433 the Ming court, under pressure from officials who preferred to spend money on defense against the north, ended the voyages. Private Chinese merchants continued to trade, but the government did not claim the seas as European states later did.

Description of: a Ming stele

Description of an inscription Zheng He ordered carved in 1431 at a temple in Fujian, recording his voyages. This is a description, not a quotation.

The inscription says that the fleet visited more than thirty countries, that it carried gifts and received foreign envoys, and that the voyages brought distant peoples to respect the emperor. It also thanks the goddess Tianfei for protecting the ships.

Sourcing (HIPP). The inscription was made by the admiral himself, so the point of view is that of a Ming official. The purpose was to record achievements and to give thanks, and it also celebrated the emperor's authority. The audience was the court, officers, and later visitors. Because it was written to praise the voyages, it shows what the Ming government wanted remembered and does not tell us what foreign ports gained or lost.

Source analysis · The purpose of the voyages

Claim. The Ming treated Zheng He's voyages as a display of imperial authority.

Evidence. The inscription says foreign envoys were received, gifts exchanged, and distant peoples brought to respect the emperor.

Reasoning. Receiving envoys and giving gifts was a way of showing Chinese leadership, so the voyages were as much political as commercial. A limit is that the stone was meant to praise the expeditions, so it does not show how local rulers or merchants in other ports saw them.

Worked example · Environmental causes

Question. Explain how one environmental factor shaped Indian Ocean trade.

Model. The monsoon winds shaped trade because they blew from the southwest in summer and from the northeast in winter. Sailors who understood the pattern could leave on one wind, trade in a distant port, and return on the other wind, which made long voyages predictable and allowed trade networks to expand.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 2E to 2G ask for causes, effects, and the role of environment. Name the monsoons, the compass, astrolabe, and large ships (causes), and states such as the Swahili cities and Malacca, diasporic communities, and cultural exchange (effects). Use Zheng He as an example of state sponsorship that ended, in contrast to continuing private trade.

Practice
  1. What are monsoon winds and why did they matter?
    Show answer

    Seasonal winds that blow in opposite directions in summer and winter, letting sailors travel to distant ports and return on predictable winds.

  2. Name two technologies that improved Indian Ocean travel.
    Show answer

    The compass, the astrolabe, the lateen sail on dhows, and larger ship designs such as Chinese junks.

  3. Why was bulk trade possible by sea?
    Show answer

    Ships carried far more than camels, so heavy and bulky goods were affordable to ship long distances.

  4. Name two states or cities that grew through Indian Ocean trade.
    Show answer

    Swahili city-states such as Kilwa, Gujarat, or the Sultanate of Malacca.

  5. What is a diasporic merchant community?
    Show answer

    A group of merchants living in a foreign port who kept their own customs while exchanging ideas and practices with local people.

  6. Why did the Ming end Zheng He's voyages?
    Show answer

    They were very expensive, and officials argued the money was needed for defense against the north, so after 1433 the state stopped sponsoring them while private trade continued.

Lesson 2.4 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.4

Trans-Saharan trade routes

The Sahara, the world's largest hot desert, separates North Africa from West Africa. For centuries merchants crossed it in caravans, and between 1200 and 1450 the trade grew. This lesson covers the technology that made the crossing possible, the goods and states that resulted, and how Islam spread along the routes.

Required content · 2H, 2I

Learning objectives.

  • 2H. Explain the causes and effects of the growth of trans-Saharan trade. HISTORICAL DIFFERENCES
  • 2I. Explain how the expansion of empires influenced trade and communication over time.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.II.A.ii. The growth of interregional trade was encouraged by innovations in existing transportation technologies.
  • 3.1.I.A.iv. Improved transportation technologies and commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes, including the trans-Saharan trade network.
  • 3.1.I.E.ii. The expansion of empires, including Mali in West Africa–facilitated Afro-Eurasian trade and communication as new people were drawn into the economies and trade networks.

The camel and the caravan

The CED says that the growth of interregional trade was encouraged by innovations in existing transportation technologies. Its examples are the camel saddle and caravans. The camel can go several days without water and carry heavy loads over sand. Improved saddles, which let riders and loads sit securely, made camels more useful. Merchants organized into caravans of hundreds or thousands of camels, led by guides who knew the routes and wells, and they traveled together for safety. Along the way they relied on oasis towns, such as Taghaza and Walata, for rest and supplies.

Goods and the economy

The trans-Saharan network connected West African societies, which produced gold and had a plentiful supply of forest and savanna goods, with North African merchants, who supplied salt, cloth, copper, and other goods.

  • Gold from the forests near the upper Niger and Senegal rivers went north and was a major source of gold for Mediterranean and Islamic coinage.
  • Salt from desert mines such as Taghaza went south, since people in the humid savanna needed it for food and health.
  • Other goods included ivory, kola nuts, cloth, copper, and enslaved people. Slavery existed in many forms in Africa and the Mediterranean, and the trans-Saharan trade moved enslaved people north, a trade that continued for centuries.

The CED says that improved transportation technologies and commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes, including the trans-Saharan trade network.

The rise of Mali and its neighbors

The empire of Mali grew from a small state on the upper Niger River. Its founder, Sundiata Keita, defeated a rival kingdom in about 1235 and began to build a large state. Mali taxed the gold and salt trade and controlled the key cities, so it grew rich. The CED notes that the expansion of empires, including Mali in West Africa, facilitated Afro-Eurasian trade and communication as new people were drawn into the economies and trade networks. Its most famous ruler, Mansa Musa, made a pilgrimage (hajj) to Mecca in 1324 with a huge caravan and gave away so much gold in Cairo that its value fell for years. On his return, he brought back scholars and architects, and the city of Timbuktu grew into a center of trade and Islamic learning, with mosques and libraries. Later, in the fifteenth century, the Songhai Empire, based at Gao, replaced Mali as the main power.

The spread of Islam

Muslim traders and scholars crossed the Sahara and settled in West African towns. Rulers such as Mansa Musa adopted Islam, and it gave them literate officials, connections to the wider Muslim world, and a shared legal system with traders from the north. Yet Islam spread unevenly. Rulers and merchants in the cities were often Muslim, while many rural people kept local religions, and Muslim rulers often blended Islamic and local practices. Islamic scholarship in cities such as Timbuktu would become important to the region's history.

Effects on society

Trade raised wealth and built states, but it also brought change. The demand for gold and salt created specialized trades, and cities such as Timbuktu and Gao grew, while the trade in enslaved people harmed those taken. As in other networks, ideas and goods traveled together.

Description of: an Egyptian writer on Mansa Musa

Description of the account by the Arab geographer al-Umari (died 1349), who collected stories in Cairo about Mansa Musa's visit in 1324. This is a description, not a quotation.

Al-Umari reported that Mansa Musa's party arrived in Cairo with large numbers of people and enormous amounts of gold, that he gave gold freely, and that the price of gold in the city fell and stayed low for years afterward.

Sourcing (HIPP). Al-Umari wrote about thirteen years after the visit and relied on Cairo officials and merchants who had seen it, so his account is secondhand. His point of view is that of an Egyptian scholar writing a geographical and administrative encyclopedia. The purpose was to inform readers about distant lands, and the audience was educated people in the Mamluk state. Because the story passed through informants and grew in the telling, specifics such as the amount of gold may be exaggerated, but the story is good evidence that Mali's wealth impressed the Muslim world.

Source analysis · Mali's wealth

Claim. Mali's gold made it known across the Muslim world.

Evidence. Al-Umari reported that the ruler's gifts in Cairo made the price of gold fall for years.

Reasoning. A story about gold's price in Cairo shows that Muslim writers outside Mali knew of and were impressed by its wealth. A limit is that the writer relied on informants years later, so the amounts may be exaggerated, but the persistence of the story supports the claim about Mali's reputation.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one reason the trans-Saharan trade grew after 1200.

Model. One reason was technological: improved camel saddles and the organization of caravans made it possible to carry more goods across the desert more safely. Another was the growth of strong states such as Mali, which protected the trade routes and taxed the gold and salt that passed along them, which gave rulers a reason to encourage commerce.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 2H and 2I ask for causes and effects of trans-Saharan trade and how empires influenced trade. Name the camel saddle and caravans, gold and salt, Mali and Mansa Musa, Timbuktu, and the spread of Islam. Say that Mali's rulers helped the trade by providing order.

Practice
  1. Which technology made crossing the Sahara easier?
    Show answer

    The camel, with improved saddles, organized into caravans.

  2. What goods moved across the Sahara?
    Show answer

    Gold, ivory, kola nuts, and enslaved people moved north, while salt, cloth, and copper moved south.

  3. Who was Mansa Musa?
    Show answer

    The ruler of Mali whose pilgrimage to Mecca in 1324 brought attention to West African wealth and who helped make Timbuktu a center of learning.

  4. How did Mali benefit from the trans-Saharan trade?
    Show answer

    It controlled and taxed the gold and salt trade, which made it wealthy and powerful.

  5. How did Islam spread in West Africa?
    Show answer

    Through merchants, scholars, and rulers who adopted it, especially in trading cities, though it spread unevenly and often blended with local practices.

  6. Why should a historian be careful with al-Umari's account?
    Show answer

    He wrote years after the event and relied on informants, so details such as the amount of gold may have been exaggerated.

Lesson 2.5 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.5

Cultural consequences of connectivity

When people and goods travel, ideas travel with them. This lesson covers the CED's statement that increased cross-cultural interactions resulted in the diffusion of literary, artistic, and cultural traditions, as well as scientific and technological innovations. It also covers how cities grew or declined and how travelers wrote about what they saw.

Required content · 2J

Learning objective.

  • 2J. Explain the intellectual and cultural effects of the various networks of exchange in Afro-Eurasia from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.III.D. Increased cross-cultural interactions resulted in the diffusion of literary, artistic, and cultural traditions, as well as scientific and technological innovations.
  • 3.3.II. The fate of cities varied greatly, with periods of significant decline and periods of increased urbanization, buoyed by rising productivity and expanding trade networks.
  • 3.1.III.C. As exchange networks intensified, an increasing number of travelers within Afro-Eurasia wrote about their travels.

The diffusion of religions

Trade routes carried belief systems, and conversion often followed contact rather than conquest.

  • Buddhism in East Asia. Buddhism had spread from India along the Silk Roads to China, Korea, and Japan. By 1200 it had mixed with local traditions and with Confucianism and Daoism, and monasteries became centers of land, learning, and charity.
  • Hinduism and Buddhism in Southeast Asia. Indian merchants and priests brought these religions and ideas of kingship to places such as Cambodia and Java, where rulers built temples such as Angkor Wat to support their rule (Lesson 1.3).
  • Islam in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia. Merchants and Sufis carried Islam to West and East Africa, South and Southeast Asia, and Central Asia (Lessons 1.2 and 2.4).

The diffusion of science and technology

Innovations also moved along trade routes.

  • Gunpowder came from China, where it was invented in the ninth or tenth century and used in weapons by the Song. Through contact with the Mongols and Muslim lands, it reached the Middle East and Europe.
  • Paper came from China and spread through Muslim lands, where paper mills operated in cities such as Samarkand and Baghdad, and then to Europe. Paper was cheaper than parchment, so it made books and records more common.
  • Other transfers included Indian mathematics, Chinese printing, Greek and Islamic medicine, and the compass.

The effect was cumulative. A technology invented in one place could be improved in another, such as when European and Muslim armies later developed cannons based on Chinese gunpowder.

Travelers and their writings

The CED notes that as exchange networks intensified, an increasing number of travelers within Afro-Eurasia wrote about their travels. It names three.

  • Marco Polo (1254 to 1324), a Venetian merchant, whose Travels told Europeans about China.
  • Ibn Battuta (1304 to c. 1369), a Moroccan scholar who traveled through North Africa, the Middle East, India, Southeast Asia, China, and West Africa, and wrote about the Muslim world.
  • Margery Kempe (c. 1373 to after 1438), an English woman who went on pilgrimages to the Holy Land and elsewhere and whose Book recounts her religious visions and travels.

These writers show that travelers had different purposes. Polo and Ibn Battuta wrote about wealthy courts and cities, and Kempe's travels were religious. They also show that travel was not limited to men of power, since Kempe was a middle-class woman who went on pilgrimage with other ordinary people.

The fate of cities

The CED says the fate of cities varied greatly, with periods of significant decline and periods of increased urbanization, buoyed by rising productivity and expanding trade networks. Trade built cities such as Samarkand, Kilwa, Malacca, and Timbuktu. But war and disease destroyed or shrank others. The Mongols devastated cities such as Baghdad, and the Black Death killed many urban residents in the fourteenth century (Lesson 2.6). Cities tended to prosper where they sat on trade routes and where rulers were stable, and to decline when routes shifted or states collapsed.

Description of: a pilgrim's book

Description of The Book of Margery Kempe, written about 1436 by a scribe from Kempe's dictation. This is a description, not a quotation.

Kempe, a married woman of King's Lynn, England, tells of her visions, her weeping in public, and her pilgrimages to Jerusalem, Rome, and Santiago de Compostela. She reports being accused of heresy and traveling with fellow pilgrims, some of whom disliked her.

Sourcing (HIPP). Kempe was a layperson with no formal education, so she dictated her story, and her point of view is that of a devout Christian woman describing her experiences. The purpose was to record her spiritual life and defend her reputation, and the audience was probably other devout Christians. Because she wrote about her own religious experience, the book shows how ordinary Europeans participated in long-distance travel for faith, but not how merchants or rulers traveled.

Source analysis · Who traveled

Claim. Long-distance travel in this period included ordinary people, not only merchants and rulers.

Evidence. Kempe, an English woman of the middle class, went on pilgrimages to Jerusalem, Rome, and Santiago, traveling with others.

Reasoning. Pilgrimage was a form of travel open to people of modest means, which shows that exchange networks moved religious practice as well as goods. A limit is that Kempe's unusual religious fervor and the fact that she dictated the book make her an individual case, so it cannot stand for all women or all pilgrims.

Worked example · Cultural diffusion

Question. Explain one example of the spread of a technology and one of a belief system along trade routes.

Model. Paper spread from China through Muslim lands, where mills operated in cities such as Samarkand and Baghdad, and then to Europe, making books cheaper and records easier to keep. Buddhism spread from India along the Silk Roads to China, Korea, and Japan, where it blended with local traditions and Confucianism.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 2J asks for intellectual and cultural effects. Give examples of religions (Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam), technologies (gunpowder, paper), and travelers (Polo, Ibn Battuta, Kempe). Say what each traveler's account is good evidence of, and what it is not.

Practice
  1. Name three travelers who wrote about their journeys in this period.
    Show answer

    Marco Polo, Ibn Battuta, and Margery Kempe.

  2. What was the importance of paper?
    Show answer

    It was cheaper than parchment, so it made books and records more common, and it spread from China through Muslim lands to Europe.

  3. How did gunpowder spread?
    Show answer

    It was invented in China and spread through contact with the Mongols and Muslim lands to the Middle East and Europe.

  4. Give two examples of religions spreading along trade routes.
    Show answer

    Buddhism in East Asia, Hinduism and Buddhism in Southeast Asia, and Islam in Africa and Asia.

  5. What caused cities to grow or decline?
    Show answer

    Cities grew on trade routes and where rulers were stable, and declined where wars, disease, or shifting routes hurt them, such as Baghdad after the Mongols.

  6. What makes Margery Kempe different from Marco Polo as a source?
    Show answer

    Kempe was a middle-class religious pilgrim who dictated her book, while Polo was a merchant who visited courts; they show different kinds of travel.

Lesson 2.6 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.6

Environmental consequences of connectivity

Trade networks did not only move merchants and goods. They also moved plants, animals, and microbes. The CED states that there was continued diffusion of crops and pathogens, with epidemic diseases, including the bubonic plague, along trade routes. This lesson covers the spread of crops, the Black Death, and the ways environmental change affected people.

Required content · 2K

Learning objective.

  • 2K. Explain the environmental effects of the various networks of exchange in Afro-Eurasia from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.IV. There was continued diffusion of crops and pathogens, with epidemic diseases, including the bubonic plague, along trade routes.

Diffusion of crops

Merchants and travelers carried seeds and plants from one region to another. The CED lists three examples.

  • Bananas in Africa. Bananas, native to Southeast Asia, were brought across the Indian Ocean and became a staple in parts of East and Central Africa, where they supported larger populations.
  • New rice varieties in East Asia. Early-ripening varieties such as Champa rice (Lesson 1.1) allowed multiple harvests a year.
  • Citrus in the Mediterranean. Muslim farmers introduced oranges, lemons, and other citrus fruits to Spain, Sicily, and North Africa, along with irrigation techniques.

Other crops also moved, including sugarcane, cotton, and new kinds of grain. These crops changed what people ate, what they wore, and what land was farmed. They often supported larger populations, and they depended on environmental conditions such as water supply.

The Black Death

The most important biological effect was the Black Death, an epidemic of bubonic plague. The plague is caused by a bacterium carried by fleas on rodents, and it spreads through bites and, in some forms, through the air. It appears to have spread from Central Asia along trade routes, carried in part by ships and caravans. It struck the Crimean port of Caffa in 1346, entered the Mediterranean by ship in 1347, and spread through Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East in just a few years. Earlier outbreaks and later ones also affected China.

Estimates of deaths in Europe run from about a third to a half of the population, and the Middle East also lost great numbers. Records for other regions are incomplete, so numbers are uncertain.

Effects of the Black Death

  • Labor and wages. In Europe, so many workers died that survivors could demand higher wages and more freedom. Landowners tried to hold wages down with laws, and peasants rebelled in some places, such as England in 1381. Over time, serfdom declined in much of western Europe (Lesson 1.6).
  • Society and belief. People tried to explain the plague by sin, astrology, or foul air. Some groups were blamed, and Jewish communities were attacked in parts of Europe. The Church lost some of its authority as clergy died or fled.
  • Trade and cities. Cities lost much of their population, and trade routes were disrupted. In Asia, plague and political turmoil contributed to the fall of the Yuan dynasty and the Mongol khanates.

Other environmental effects

Trade also changed environments in other ways. Increased demand for timber, for charcoal to smelt iron, and for farmland led to deforestation in parts of China and Europe. Large cities produced waste and pollution. Cold or dry climate shifts in the fourteenth century, sometimes called the start of a "little ice age," added to famine and hardship before the plague.

Description of: a plague chronicle

Description of the introduction to Giovanni Boccaccio's Decameron (written about 1350), which describes the plague in Florence in 1348. This is a description, not a quotation.

Boccaccio, a Florentine writer, described how the sickness began with swellings in the groin or armpit and led to death within days. He said families abandoned the sick, neighbors avoided one another, and burials became hurried and unceremonial.

Sourcing (HIPP). Boccaccio lived through the epidemic and wrote it up as the background to a collection of stories. His point of view is that of an educated, urban Italian. The purpose was literary, to explain why a group of young people fled the city and told stories, and the audience was educated readers. Because he wrote as a storyteller, details may be shaped for effect, but his description is useful evidence of how it felt to live through the plague and how social bonds were strained.

Source analysis · The effect on society

Claim. The Black Death strained social bonds in European cities.

Evidence. Boccaccio wrote that families abandoned the sick, neighbors avoided one another, and burials were hurried.

Reasoning. An eyewitness account of people avoiding the sick suggests that fear of contagion weakened the family and community ties that normally supported people. A limit is that Boccaccio wrote the passage as a framing for fiction and described only Florence, so it cannot stand for all of Europe.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one economic effect of the Black Death in Europe.

Model. The plague killed so many workers that labor became scarce, so survivors could demand higher wages and leave estates for better terms. Landowners tried to limit wages by law, which caused conflict such as the English Peasants' Revolt of 1381, and over time serfdom weakened in much of western Europe.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 2K asks about environmental effects. Name the diffusion of crops (bananas, rice, citrus) and the Black Death. For the plague, give the route (trade networks), the scale (a third or more of Europe), and effects (labor, belief, trade). Stress that connectivity had costs as well as benefits.

Practice
  1. Name two crops that spread in this period.
    Show answer

    Bananas to Africa, new rice varieties in East Asia, and citrus in the Mediterranean are all correct.

  2. What caused the Black Death?
    Show answer

    Bubonic plague, caused by bacteria carried by fleas on rodents, which spread along trade routes.

  3. How did the plague reach Europe?
    Show answer

    It spread from Central Asia along trade routes, reached the Crimean port of Caffa in 1346, and entered the Mediterranean by ship in 1347.

  4. How did the plague affect European labor?
    Show answer

    Workers became scarce, so survivors gained higher wages and more freedom, and serfdom weakened in much of western Europe.

  5. Name one social effect of the plague.
    Show answer

    People blamed sinful behavior or minority groups, the Church lost some authority, and social ties were strained.

  6. Why must a historian be careful with Boccaccio as a source?
    Show answer

    He wrote about Florence as the setting for a literary work, so his account is vivid but local and shaped for storytelling.

Lesson 2.7 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.7

Comparison of economic exchange

This lesson practices argumentation, the skill the CED attaches to this topic, using the comparison among the three great networks of exchange you studied: the Silk Roads, the Indian Ocean, and the trans-Saharan routes. An argument is a claim backed by specific evidence and reasoning. On the exam, you are rarely asked to list facts. You are asked to state a claim and defend it.

Required content · 2L

Learning objective.

  • 2L. Explain the similarities and differences among the various networks of exchange in the period from c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.I.A.i. Improved commercial practices led to an increased volume of trade and expanded the geographical range of existing trade routes, including the Silk Roads, promoting the growth of powerful new trading cities.
  • 3.1.I.C.i. The growth of interregional trade in luxury goods was encouraged by innovations in previously existing transportation and commercial technologies, including the caravanserai, forms of credit, and the development of money economies.
  • 3.3.I.B. Demand for luxury goods increased in Afro-Eurasia. Chinese, Persian, and Indian artisans and merchants expanded their production of textiles and porcelains for export; manufacture of iron and steel expanded in China.

The three networks compared

Silk RoadsIndian OceanTrans-Saharan
Route typeOverland, with some sea linksSeaOverland across desert
TechnologyCamel and horse caravans, caravanseraiDhows, lateen sail, compass, astrolabe, junksCamels, saddles, caravans
Main goodsSilk, porcelain, spices, luxury goodsSpices, cloth, porcelain, ivory, bulk goodsGold, salt, ivory, cloth
Role of statesMongol rule protected the routesPort city-states, sultanates, Chinese fleetsMali and Songhai taxed and protected trade
Cultural effectsBuddhism, Islam, paper, gunpowderIslam, Swahili culture, merchant diasporasIslam, Timbuktu's learning

Similarities

  • Each network depended on a transportation technology adapted to its environment (camel, monsoon sailing).
  • Each linked producing regions with markets and encouraged the growth of trading cities.
  • Each carried religion and ideas as well as goods, and merchants helped spread Islam in particular.
  • In each case states benefited by taxing or protecting trade.

Differences

  • Scale and goods. Ships could carry bulk goods, so the Indian Ocean network handled more volume than the overland routes, which emphasized luxuries.
  • Who organized it. The Mongol state played a large role in the Silk Roads, but the Indian Ocean was mostly the work of merchants and city-states, apart from Zheng He's state fleets. In the Sahara, the rulers of Mali taxed trade but did not control all of it.
  • Environment. The monsoons shaped Indian Ocean trade, and the desert shaped trans-Saharan trade. Neither network could be run the same way.

Building an argument

Suppose the prompt asks you to argue which network had the greatest effect on the growth of states. A strong argument has these parts.

  1. Claim. "The Indian Ocean network did the most to create new states."
  2. Evidence. Name specific, relevant facts: the Swahili city-states of Kilwa and Mombasa, Gujarat, and the Sultanate of Malacca all grew through ocean trade.
  3. Reasoning. Explain how the evidence supports the claim: because ships could carry bulk goods, ports that controlled trade became rich enough to support rulers and armies.
  4. Counterevidence and qualification. Acknowledge a limit or counterexample: the trans-Saharan trade also helped Mali and Songhai rise, so the Indian Ocean was not unique.

A good argument takes a position and defends it. Facts that are accurate but do not support the claim do not help.

Description of: Ibn Battuta on Kilwa

Description of Ibn Battuta's visit to the East African city of Kilwa in about 1331. This is a description, not a quotation.

Ibn Battuta described Kilwa as one of the most beautiful and well-built towns in the world. He wrote that its people were Muslims who followed a particular school of Islamic law, that its ruler was generous and devout, and that its wealth came from raids on the mainland and from trade.

Sourcing (HIPP). Ibn Battuta was a traveling Muslim jurist, so his point of view is that of an educated Muslim visitor who admired a fellow Muslim city. His purpose was to describe his travels, and the audience was educated readers at a Moroccan court. His admiration for the ruler's faith may overstate how Islamic the town was, but his description is useful evidence that a Muslim city-state on the East African coast was wealthy and connected to the Indian Ocean world.

Source analysis · Evidence for an argument

Claim. Indian Ocean trade helped create wealthy, Muslim city-states on the East African coast.

Evidence. Ibn Battuta called Kilwa one of the most beautiful towns, noted that its people followed Islamic law, and said its wealth came from raids and trade.

Reasoning. A visitor describing a well-built Muslim city whose wealth came partly from trade shows that ocean commerce supported urban wealth and spread Islam. A limit is that he was a Muslim visitor who admired the city's faith, so he may overstate how Islamic it was, and he visited only briefly.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the Silk Roads and the Indian Ocean network.

Model. Both networks carried luxury goods such as spices and porcelain and helped spread religions such as Islam. A difference is that sea transport could carry bulk goods cheaply, so the Indian Ocean trade handled larger volumes, while overland caravans could carry only high-value luxuries because camels carried much less than ships.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 2L asks for similarities and differences among networks, and the skill is argumentation. State a claim, support it with specific evidence from named networks, explain the reasoning, and add a qualification. Do not simply list facts.

Practice
  1. What is an argument in historical writing?
    Show answer

    A claim supported by specific evidence and reasoning that explains how the evidence supports the claim.

  2. Give one similarity among the three networks.
    Show answer

    All carried goods and ideas, relied on technology suited to the environment, and encouraged the growth of trading cities and states.

  3. Give one difference between overland and sea trade.
    Show answer

    Ships carried bulk goods cheaply, while overland caravans mostly carried luxuries.

  4. Which network depended on monsoon winds?
    Show answer

    The Indian Ocean network.

  5. What does a qualification do in an argument?
    Show answer

    It admits a limit or counterexample, which makes the argument more careful and complete.

  6. How did states help trade in each network?
    Show answer

    The Mongols protected the Silk Roads, port city-states and sultanates ran the Indian Ocean ports, and Mali and Songhai protected and taxed the trans-Saharan trade.

Unit 2 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 2 review: Networks of Exchange, c. 1200–c. 1450

Ten questions on the Silk Roads, the Mongol Empire, Indian Ocean and trans-Saharan trade, and what those networks carried (goods, technology, religion, and plague) plus two short-answer questions on connectivity and its consequences.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Marco Polo, The Travels, on paper currency in Yuan China; nineteenth-century English translation.

    "All these pieces of paper are issued with as much solemnity and authority as if they were of pure gold or silver … and indeed everybody takes them readily, for wheresoever a person may go throughout the Great Kaan's dominions he shall find these pieces of paper current."

    Polo's astonishment at this practice is best explained by the fact that he

    Correct. Polo was Venetian, from Europe's most commercially sophisticated city, and paper money still struck him as remarkable, which measures the gap between Chinese and European financial practice.

    Polo was a merchant from a banking and trading republic, thoroughly familiar with money and credit.

    Nothing suggests forgery, and the passage describes currency accepted throughout the empire, which a forgery would not be.

    The Mongols actively protected and promoted trade, and Polo's account describes commerce flourishing.

  2. The sharp increase in Silk Road trade volume during the thirteenth century is best explained by

    European demand for luxuries was fairly constant across centuries. What varied was how much actually arrived and at what price.

    Correct. One authority over the whole overland route collapsed transaction costs (fewer tolls, protected caravans), and volume rose accordingly.

    The compass mattered for sea navigation. Overland caravans followed known routes between oases and caravanserai.

    Indian Ocean trade continued and carried far greater tonnage than the overland routes throughout this period.

  3. Description of: a Persian history of the Mongol conquests, written in the thirteenth century by an administrator serving the Ilkhanate.

    The account describes a great Persian city's population summoned outside the walls, artisans separated out and spared for deportation east, the remainder killed, and irrigation works broken. The author then praises the order that followed: roads on which a traveler could carry gold without fear, merchants protected, and taxes collected on a regular schedule.

    Which feature of this source most strengthens its reliability regarding the destruction it describes?

    Correct. An administrator writing for Mongol patrons had every incentive to minimize the massacres and recorded them anyway, which is a classic admission against interest.

    The description does not claim eyewitness status, and a single observer could not have witnessed campaigns across a continent.

    The source is contemporary, written in the thirteenth century, not a later archival reconstruction.

    He was a Persian administrator writing within the Ilkhanate, not a Mongol addressing Europeans.

  4. Which best describes the relationship between Mongol destruction and Mongol facilitation of exchange?

    The Pax Mongolica developed across all four khanates regardless of their differing religious trajectories, and destruction continued well after Chinggis.

    Correct. Cities that resisted were destroyed as a demonstration while artisans were deported and trade routes protected: two halves of one approach to extracting wealth and skill.

    Persian, Chinese, and Arabic sources independently record the destruction, including sources written by administrators serving the Mongols.

    Persia experienced both: cities destroyed and irrigation broken, followed by the protected trade and patronage of the Ilkhanate.

  5. Source: Ibn Battuta, Rihla, on the Swahili coast, c. 1331; early English translation.

    "Kilwa is one of the most beautiful and best constructed towns in the world. The whole of it is elegantly built."

    Ibn Battuta's praise carries particular weight because he

    Correct. A traveler who knew the great cities of the Islamic world was not easily impressed, and he had no local connection requiring flattery.

    Nothing indicates commercial interest; he traveled as a scholar seeking legal appointments rather than as an investor.

    He was Moroccan, and the account is explicitly that of a visitor arriving by sea.

    He had already visited Cairo, Damascus, Mecca, and many other major cities, which is precisely why the comparison is meaningful.

  6. The discontinuation of Zheng He's voyages after 1433 is best explained by

    The technology existed and the ships were built; the fleet was left to rot by decision rather than lost through incapacity.

    Correct. The voyages were enormously expensive, the Confucian bureaucracy distrusted the eunuch faction that sponsored them, and the Mongol threat in the north was a more pressing claim on revenue.

    The Portuguese did not reach the Indian Ocean until 1498, sixty-five years after the voyages ended.

    The voyages reached India, Arabia, and the East African coast, far beyond Southeast Asia.

  7. Which technological development was most essential to regular trans-Saharan trade?

    Correct. Camels could cross the desert, but the saddle is what made them controllable and able to carry commercially viable loads in organized caravans.

    The lateen sail belongs to Indian Ocean and Mediterranean shipping, not to desert crossing.

    Caravans navigated by knowledge of wells and oases passed down among Berber merchants, not by compass.

    The astrolabe was used at sea. Desert routes depended on route knowledge and water sources rather than celestial navigation.

  8. Mali's wealth in the fourteenth century derived primarily from

    The goldfields lay to the south and were worked by peoples who kept their locations secret. Mali controlled the routes, not the mines.

    Correct. Mali produced neither the gold nor the salt but taxed the exchange and guaranteed the security that made it possible, which is why road safety mattered so much to its rulers.

    Mali's exports were raw commodities and its revenue came from transit, not from manufacturing for export.

    The Swahili city-states were on the opposite side of the continent and entirely outside Mali's reach.

  9. Description of: burial and taxation records from a European city around 1348.

    Parish burial entries rise to several times the normal annual figure within months, then fall below the earlier baseline and stay there. Tax registers from the following decade list substantially fewer households. Wage records for building trades show day rates roughly doubling within a generation, and several ordinances attempt to fix wages at pre-plague levels.

    The wage-fixing ordinances are most significant as evidence that

    Correct. A government legislating against wage increases is documenting increases it could not otherwise stop: a law banning something is evidence the thing was happening.

    The wage records show rates roughly doubling, so the ordinances were attempting to suppress a rise, not arrest a fall.

    The ordinances worked against wage earners rather than for them, which indicates pressure from labor scarcity rather than successful bargaining.

    Burial spikes and a lasting fall in household numbers both indicate severe mortality.

  10. Which best states the relationship between the Mongol trade network and the spread of the Black Death?

    Correct. Plague reached the Black Sea in 1347 and Europe the following year along the routes the Mongols had secured, most likely in fleas on rats in grain shipments.

    The disease moved from Central and East Asia westward, reaching Europe last among the major affected regions.

    No such policy existed, and the disease devastated Mongol-ruled territories including Persia and China.

    It traveled by both land and sea, and the overland routes were central to its westward movement.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way trade networks expanded in the period 1200–1450.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the Mongol Empire affected exchange across Eurasia.
    3. Briefly explain ONE unintended consequence of increased connectivity in this period.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: caravanserai and improved commercial infrastructure; bills of exchange and banking reducing the need to carry bullion; the camel saddle enabling Saharan crossing; the dhow and monsoon knowledge structuring Indian Ocean trade; Chinese paper money. Must name a specific development.
    • (b) Accept: unification lowering tolls and risk on the overland route; the yam relay system; deliberate transfer of specialists between khanates; protection of merchants; diffusion of gunpowder, printing, and the compass. Must explain the mechanism.
    • (c) Accept: the Black Death traveling the same routes; the labor shortage and its effects on wages and serfdom; the plague contributing to Mongol fragmentation; environmental strain along intensively used routes. Must identify it as unintended and trace a consequence.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Merchants developed bills of exchange, which allowed money deposited with a banking house in one city to be collected in another. This removed the need to carry gold and silver across routes where robbery was a serious risk, making transactions practical over journeys that took months.

    (b) By bringing the entire overland route under a single authority, the Mongols eliminated the many separate tolls and threats a caravan had faced and actively protected merchants. This lowered the cost and risk of long-distance trade enough that volume rose sharply, and it allowed the deliberate movement of specialists such as Persian astronomers and Chinese engineers between the khanates.

    (c) The plague that reached Europe in 1348 traveled along the same secured routes that carried silk and porcelain, killing roughly a third of the population. The resulting labor shortage raised wages for surviving workers and weakened serfdom in western Europe: an outcome no participant in the trade network intended.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way environmental conditions shaped a trade network in this period.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way a state used control of trade to build its power.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of travel accounts as historical sources.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: monsoon winds structuring the Indian Ocean trading year and producing diasporic communities; the Sahara's oases determining caravan routes; Central Asian aridity requiring caravanserai spacing. Must connect environment to how the network operated.
    • (b) Accept: Mali taxing trans-Saharan gold and salt; Srivijaya taxing shipping through the Strait of Malacca; Swahili city-states on Indian Ocean commerce; Mongol protection of routes for revenue. Must explain the link between control and power.
    • (c) Accept: dictated or written long after the events; the author's own cultural expectations shaping judgments; access limited to elite or co-religionist circles; exaggeration for patrons or audiences; translation issues. Must name a specific limitation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The monsoon winds of the Indian Ocean reverse direction seasonally, blowing northeast for roughly half the year and southwest for the other half. Because voyages had to follow that cycle, merchants were obliged to wait out the opposite season in foreign ports, which is why permanent diasporic trading communities formed across the network.

    (b) Mali taxed the gold moving north and the salt moving south through the cities and routes it controlled, without producing either commodity. That revenue funded an army, a court, and the mosques and schools of Timbuktu, and it gave the state a strong interest in guaranteeing the security of the roads merchants used.

    (c) Ibn Battuta dictated his account years after his travels from memory, which makes specific details such as dates and numbers unreliable. His movement also took him mainly through Muslim elite circles, so his descriptions tell us little about non-Muslim or rural populations in the places he visited.

Lesson 3.1 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.1

Gunpowder empires: the Ottomans and Safavids

Between about 1450 and 1750, a group of large, powerful states rose across Eurasia and the Americas. The CED says that imperial expansion relied on the increased use of gunpowder, cannons, and armed trade to establish large empires in both hemispheres. This lesson covers the first two Muslim empires of the era, the Ottomans and the Safavids, and how their rivalry shaped the Middle East. The next lesson covers the Mughals, Qing, Russians, and Songhai.

Required content · 3A

Learning objective.

  • 3A. Explain how and why various land-based empires developed and expanded from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.II. Imperial expansion relied on the increased use of gunpowder, cannons, and armed trade to establish large empires in both hemispheres.
  • 4.3.III.i. Political and religious disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states.

The Ottoman Empire

The Ottomans began as one of several Turkic principalities in Anatolia around 1300, led by a ruler named Osman. They grew by conquest into a state that took the Balkans and, in 1453, the Byzantine capital of Constantinople. The sultan Mehmed II (r. 1444 to 1446 and 1451 to 1481) used huge cannons to batter the city's walls, which showed how gunpowder had changed siege warfare. He made the city, renamed Istanbul, the new capital. The CED lists the Ottoman Empire among the land empires that held Southern Europe, the Middle East, and North Africa.

Expansion continued. In 1517 Sultan Selim I defeated the Mamluks and took Syria, Egypt, and the holy cities of Mecca and Medina, which made the Ottoman sultan the protector of the Muslim holy places. Suleiman I (r. 1520 to 1566), called "the Magnificent" in Europe and "the Lawgiver" in the Ottoman world, defeated Hungary at the Battle of Mohacs in 1526 and besieged Vienna in 1529. The empire controlled the eastern Mediterranean, the Red Sea trade, and large parts of North Africa. It was a land empire that also had a navy, though its fleet lost a major battle to a Christian coalition at Lepanto in 1571.

The Ottoman army combined cavalry, which was the traditional strength of Turkic states, with janissaries, infantry soldiers equipped with firearms who were recruited through the devshirme (Lesson 3.2b). The janissaries were paid by the state and served the sultan directly, which was a mark of the empire's centralization.

The Safavid Empire

The Safavids grew out of a Sufi religious order in northwestern Iran. In 1501 a young leader, Ismail, took the city of Tabriz and proclaimed himself shah of Iran. He declared Twelver Shi'a Islam the state religion, and since most Iranians were then Sunni, the Safavids spread Shi'ism by persuasion and force, using clergy brought from other places. The shah claimed descent from the imams, the line of the Prophet's family honored by Shi'a Muslims, which gave him religious authority (Lesson 3.2a).

The Safavids relied at first on Turkmen cavalry warriors, but they were defeated by the Ottomans at the Battle of Chaldiran in 1514, where Ottoman firearms and artillery proved decisive. Later, Shah Abbas I (r. 1588 to 1629) reformed the army by creating a force of slave-soldiers loaded with firearms, loyal to him and not to tribal leaders, and he moved the capital to Isfahan, which he adorned with mosques, palaces, and gardens. Under Abbas the empire controlled a rich trade in silk and carpets. After his death, the Safavids weakened, and in 1722 Afghan raiders took Isfahan.

1453 Ottomans take Constantinople 1501 Safavids found a Shi'a state 1526 Babur wins at Panipat; Mughal rule 1556 Akbar becomes emperor 1644 Qing take Beijing 1683 Ottomans fail at Vienna 1689 Russia and Qing: Treaty of Nerchinsk 1722 Safavid collapse begins
Figure 3.1. The great land-based empires rose within about two centuries of one another, and several began to lose strength by the early 1700s.

Rivalry and religious conflict

The CED notes that political and religious disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states. The Ottoman and Safavid empires were neighbors with competing interests. They fought over territory in Iraq, the Caucasus, and Anatolia, and over the control of trade routes. They also had a religious difference, since the Ottomans were Sunni and the Safavids Shi'a. Each ruler used religion to justify war, and each sometimes persecuted the other's followers in its own lands. The conflict continued for more than a century, with wars in the 1500s and 1600s, and it hardened the divide between Sunni and Shi'a in the region (Lesson 3.3).

Gunpowder and the state

Why are these empires called "gunpowder empires"? Cannons and firearms gave rulers an advantage over rivals who lacked them, and they favored states with the wealth and organization to make them and to pay for professional soldiers. But the label can mislead. The Ottomans and Safavids also relied on cavalry, administrators, trade, and religion, and they adopted gunpowder from China and other regions, so it was one of several tools.

Description of: an observer of the Ottoman army

Description of letters by Ogier Ghiselin de Busbecq, an ambassador of the Habsburg emperor to Suleiman's court in the 1550s, published in 1581. This is a description, not a quotation.

Busbecq wrote that the Ottoman army was disciplined, orderly, and well supplied. He contrasted it with Christian armies, which he thought were more disorganized, and warned that the Ottomans were a serious threat to Europe.

Sourcing (HIPP). Busbecq was a diplomat serving Suleiman's rival, so his point of view is that of a European Christian official. His purpose was partly to inform his government and partly to urge his readers to prepare for war with the Ottomans, so he may exaggerate Ottoman strength. The audience was European readers, including rulers who needed to be persuaded to act. His account is good evidence for how the Ottoman army looked to a European, but not necessarily for how it actually performed.

Source analysis · A foreign view

Claim. The Ottoman army was a formidable force in the mid-1500s.

Evidence. The Habsburg ambassador Busbecq described it as disciplined and well supplied and contrasted it with disorganized Christian armies.

Reasoning. A rival's praise is credible because he had no reason to flatter the Ottomans, and his reports match the fact that Ottoman armies reached Vienna in 1529. A limit is that he was trying to persuade Europeans to prepare for war, so he may exaggerate the danger.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one reason the Ottoman Empire expanded between 1450 and 1600.

Model. One reason was its use of gunpowder weapons and a professional army. Mehmed II's cannons broke the walls of Constantinople in 1453, and the janissaries, paid and equipped by the state with firearms, gave the sultan a loyal force that could defeat rivals and take territory such as Egypt in 1517.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3A asks how and why land-based empires developed and expanded. Pair each empire with specific causes: Ottoman (cannons, janissaries, conquest of Constantinople and Mamluk lands) and Safavid (Shi'a identity, the army reforms of Abbas, Isfahan). Name the rivalry and its religious dimension, and note that gunpowder was important but not the only factor.

Practice
  1. What did Mehmed II capture in 1453 and how?
    Show answer

    Constantinople, the Byzantine capital, using large cannons to break its walls.

  2. Who were the janissaries?
    Show answer

    Infantry soldiers equipped with firearms who were recruited through the devshirme and paid by the sultan, serving as a loyal standing army.

  3. What religious change did Ismail make in Iran?
    Show answer

    He proclaimed Twelver Shi'a Islam the state religion, which began the spread of Shi'ism across Iran.

  4. What was the Battle of Chaldiran?
    Show answer

    The 1514 Ottoman victory over the Safavids in which Ottoman firearms and artillery proved decisive.

  5. Why did the Ottomans and Safavids fight?
    Show answer

    They competed for territory and trade routes and also differed in religion, as the Ottomans were Sunni and the Safavids Shi'a.

  6. Why is the term "gunpowder empire" sometimes misleading?
    Show answer

    These empires also relied on cavalry, administration, trade, and religion, and they adopted gunpowder from elsewhere, so it was only one tool of expansion.

Lesson 3.2 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.1

The Mughal, Qing, Russian, and Songhai expansions

The previous lesson covered the Ottomans and Safavids. This lesson covers four more empires that the CED lists or implies: the Mughal in South and Central Asia, the Manchu (Qing) in Central and East Asia, the Russian state, and the West African Songhai Empire. It ends with the conflicts that pitted some of them against each other.

Required content · 3A

Learning objective.

  • 3A. Explain how and why various land-based empires developed and expanded from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.II.B. Land empires included the Manchu in Central and East Asia; the Mughal in South and Central Asia; the Ottoman in Southern Europe, the Middle East, and North Africa; and the Safavids in the Middle East.
  • 4.3.III.i. Political and religious disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states.

The Mughal Empire

The Mughals were Muslims of Turkic and Mongol descent from Central Asia. Babur, a descendant of Timur and Chinggis Khan, took Kabul and then invaded northern India. At the Battle of Panipat in 1526 he defeated the Delhi sultan, partly through the use of cannons and matchlock guns, and founded the empire. His grandson Akbar (r. 1556 to 1605) was the real builder. He expanded the empire across most of northern India and created a strong administration (Lesson 3.2b). The Mughals ruled a population that was mostly Hindu, with a Muslim ruling class, and their policies toward religious diversity changed from ruler to ruler (Lesson 3.4). The empire reached its greatest size under Aurangzeb (r. 1658 to 1707), who conquered much of the south, but costly wars and revolts such as the Maratha resistance weakened it in the early eighteenth century.

The Qing Empire

The Manchu, a people from the northeast of China, built the Qing dynasty. Their leader Nurhaci united Manchu clans, and in 1644, when a peasant rebellion had toppled the Ming, Manchu armies took Beijing. The Qing then conquered the rest of China. A small Manchu elite ruled a huge Han Chinese majority, and rulers took care to keep Manchu identity. They kept the exam system and Confucian government to win Chinese cooperation (Lesson 3.2b). The Qing also expanded into Central Asia. The emperor Kangxi (r. 1661 to 1722) defeated rebels and the Mongol Zunghar state and secured Taiwan, and later emperors such as Qianlong (r. 1735 to 1796) added Xinjiang and Tibet. The CED lists the Manchu among empires in Central and East Asia.

The Russian Empire

Russia began as a principality around Moscow that freed itself from Mongol overlordship, a process completed under Ivan III by about 1480. Ivan IV, "the Terrible" (r. 1547 to 1584), was crowned the first tsar, which means "caesar," and he expanded into the Volga region. Russian explorers, Cossacks, and fur traders moved across Siberia in the late 1500s and 1600s, using firearms against peoples who lacked them, and reached the Pacific by 1639. Under Peter the Great (r. 1682 to 1725) the state modernized its army, built a new capital at St. Petersburg, and gained a Baltic coast after the Great Northern War. Russia's expansion over land, rather than overseas, makes it a good comparison with the Ottoman and Qing cases.

The Songhai Empire

In West Africa, the Songhai Empire replaced Mali (Lesson 2.4). Sunni Ali (r. 1464 to 1492) built a river and cavalry force and took Timbuktu and Jenne, and Askia Muhammad (r. 1493 to 1528) organized an Islamic empire with provincial governors and scholars. Songhai grew rich from the trans-Saharan gold trade. In 1591 an army sent by the sultan of Morocco, with guns and cannons, defeated Songhai's forces, which had fewer firearms, and the empire fragmented. This conflict is one of the CED's examples of state rivalries: Songhai Empire's conflict with Morocco. The other is the Safavid-Mughal conflict, since the two empires fought over the city of Kandahar in the 1600s.

Figure 3.1 in Lesson 3.1 shows how the rise of these empires overlapped in time.

What they shared

All of these empires used gunpowder weapons and large armies, expanded by conquest, and ruled populations of many religions and languages. Several began as outsiders: Mughals and Manchus were conquerors from beyond the heartland who adopted local administration. They also all faced limits, such as the cost of war, resistance from local elites, and the difficulty of governing huge territories.

Description of: a conqueror's memoir

Description of the Baburnama, the memoir of Babur, written in Chagatai Turkic in the early 1500s. This is a description, not a quotation.

Babur described his campaign in India, including the battle of Panipat. He wrote about how his army used cannons and guns, how he arranged his troops with carts and trenches, and how he defeated a larger force. He also wrote candidly about the land, its heat, its cities, and what he disliked about India.

Sourcing (HIPP). Babur wrote his own memoir, so the point of view is that of a conqueror presenting his own achievements. His purpose was to record his life and explain his choices, and his audience was his family and later Mughal readers. Because he wrote about his victories, he may emphasize his skill, but the account is rare, detailed evidence of how firearms and tactics gave him an advantage.

Source analysis · Gunpowder at Panipat

Claim. Gunpowder weapons helped the Mughals take northern India.

Evidence. Babur wrote of arranging his army with carts and trenches and using cannons and guns to defeat a larger force at Panipat.

Reasoning. An eyewitness commander credited firearms and tactics with a victory over a bigger army, which supports the idea that gunpowder gave an advantage. A limit is that Babur wrote about his own achievements, so he may overstate the role of his planning, and other factors such as divisions among his enemies also mattered.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way the Qing and Mughal rulers governed their subjects.

Model. Both were conquerors from outside the heartland who ruled majority populations of a different culture, the Mughals a mostly Hindu population and the Qing a Han Chinese majority. Both kept much of the existing administration to win cooperation, the Mughals through local landholders and officials and the Qing through the Confucian exam system, while keeping their own elite in key positions.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3A again asks how and why empires expanded. Link each empire to a cause: Mughals (guns and cavalry at Panipat), Qing (Manchu military organization and Chinese rebellion), Russia (firearms and a fur trade across Siberia), Songhai (cavalry, trade, and later defeat by Moroccan guns). Know the rivalries the CED names: Safavid-Mughal and Songhai-Morocco.

Practice
  1. Who founded the Mughal Empire and in what battle?
    Show answer

    Babur, who defeated the Delhi sultan at Panipat in 1526 using cannons and guns.

  2. Who were the Manchu?
    Show answer

    A people from northeastern Asia who took Beijing in 1644, founded the Qing dynasty, and ruled a Han Chinese majority.

  3. How did Russia expand?
    Show answer

    By moving across land, especially Siberia, using firearms against peoples who lacked them, as well as gaining a Baltic coast under Peter the Great.

  4. What ended the Songhai Empire as a great power?
    Show answer

    A 1591 Moroccan army armed with guns and cannons defeated its forces, and the empire fragmented.

  5. Name two state rivalries the CED lists.
    Show answer

    The Safavid-Mughal conflict and the conflict between Songhai and Morocco.

  6. What did these empires have in common?
    Show answer

    They used gunpowder weapons and large armies, expanded by conquest, and ruled diverse populations, and several began as outsiders who adopted local administration.

Lesson 3.3 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2

How rulers legitimized power

Force alone cannot hold a large empire for long. Rulers also needed people to accept their right to rule, which historians call legitimacy. The CED says that rulers continued to use religious ideas, art, and monumental architecture to legitimize their rule. This lesson covers the ideas rulers used and the buildings and images they created. The next lesson covers administration and revenue.

Required content · 3B

Learning objective.

  • 3B. Explain how rulers used a variety of methods to legitimize and consolidate their power in land-based empires from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.I.A. Rulers continued to use religious ideas, art, and monumental architecture to legitimize their rule.

Religious ideas of kingship

  • Divine right in Europe. In many European monarchies, rulers claimed that their authority came from God and that they answered only to God. This idea, divine right, was used by kings in France, England, and Spain.
  • The Mandate of Heaven in China. In Chinese thought, Heaven gave a ruler the right to rule as long as he ruled virtuously. Natural disasters and rebellion could be signs that Heaven had withdrawn its approval. The Qing, as foreign conquerors, used this idea to claim they were the rightful rulers.
  • Descent from holy figures. The Safavid shahs claimed descent from the imams, the line of the Prophet's family honored by Shi'a Muslims, as part of their authority. The Mexica rulers claimed a role as servants and allies of their gods, and the Inca emperor claimed descent from the sun.
  • Promotion of religion. Songhai's Askia Muhammad promoted Islam, made a pilgrimage to Mecca, and received the title of caliph of the Sudan. The Mexica practice of human sacrifice, in which captives were killed to feed the sun god and keep the world in order, was both a religious act and a display of the king's power and the fate of his enemies.
  • Protector of the faith. After conquering Mecca and Medina in 1517, the Ottoman sultan claimed to protect the holy cities, which raised his status across the Muslim world.

Art and monumental architecture

Rulers built to impress.

  • Mughal mausolea and mosques. Shah Jahan built the Taj Mahal (begun in the 1630s) in Agra as a tomb for his wife Mumtaz Mahal. It combines Persian, Indian, and Islamic styles, and its size and beauty displayed the wealth and taste of the dynasty. The Mughals also built mosques, such as the Jama Masjid in Delhi, and tombs for emperors, such as Humayun's tomb.
  • Ottoman mosques. The architect Sinan designed the Suleymaniye Mosque in Istanbul (completed in 1557) for Suleiman. Its huge dome and surrounding buildings, which included schools and a hospital, tied the sultan to Islam and to charity.
  • Qing imperial portraits. Qing emperors had portraits painted that showed them in many roles, such as a scholar, a warrior, and a Buddhist or Confucian patron, which helped them appeal to different subjects.
  • The Incan Sun Temple of Cuzco. The Coricancha, covered in gold, honored the sun god and the emperor, whose mummy was kept and honored.
  • European palaces. Louis XIV of France built Versailles, a huge palace outside Paris where nobles lived and competed for royal favor. Its grandeur displayed royal glory, and it tied the nobility to the king.

Why legitimacy mattered

A ruler faced several audiences. Subjects had to accept taxes and orders. Elites, such as nobles and generals, could rebel. Foreign rivals watched for weakness. Religion and monuments spoke to all of them at once. They showed that the ruler was favored by the divine, powerful, and generous. A ruler who lost legitimacy could face rebellion or collapse, as Chinese dynasties had in the past.

Because the empires ruled diverse populations, some rulers used more than one source of legitimacy. The Mughals, for example, used both Islamic symbols and Persian court culture and accommodated Hindu elites, and the Qing used the Mandate of Heaven for the Han and Buddhist patronage for Mongols and Tibetans.

Description of: the Taj Mahal

Description of the Taj Mahal, built at Agra from about 1632 to 1653 by the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan. This is a description of a monument, not a quotation.

The monument, built in white marble, stands on a platform with four minarets. Its central dome is surrounded by gardens laid out in a pattern that Islamic tradition connects with paradise. Verses from the Quran are inscribed around its entrance.

Sourcing (HIPP). The building was commissioned by the emperor, so the point of view is royal. Its purpose was to honor Mumtaz Mahal and to proclaim the dynasty's wealth, taste, and religious piety. The audience included his court, foreign visitors, and later generations. Because it is a monument built by a ruler to be admired, it shows how the dynasty wanted to be seen, not what it cost the workers and farmers who paid for it.

Source analysis · A monument as a claim

Claim. The Mughal emperors used architecture to display wealth and religious authority.

Evidence. The Taj Mahal was built in marble with Quranic verses inscribed at its entrance and gardens that evoked paradise.

Reasoning. A vast and beautiful building paid for by the emperor displayed the resources at his command, and the use of religious verses and symbols linked the dynasty to Islam. A limit is that the building says little about the burden that taxes and labor placed on ordinary people.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way two rulers used religion to legitimize power.

Model. The Mexica kings and the Safavid shahs both tied their rule to the divine. The Mexica ruler used human sacrifice and the role of servant of the sun and war god to display his power, while the Safavid shah claimed descent from the imams and promoted Twelver Shi'a Islam, so each used a different religious claim to strengthen authority.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3B asks how rulers legitimized and consolidated power. In this lesson, the key is religious ideas (divine right, Mandate of Heaven, descent from the imams, Mexica sacrifice, Songhai Islam) and art and architecture (Taj Mahal, Suleymaniye, Qing portraits, Coricancha, Versailles). Always state what the building or idea said about the ruler's power and for whom.

Practice
  1. What is legitimacy?
    Show answer

    The acceptance by subjects and elites that a ruler has the right to rule.

  2. What is the Mandate of Heaven?
    Show answer

    A Chinese idea that Heaven grants a ruler the right to rule as long as he rules virtuously.

  3. Name one monument built to display a ruler's power and the ruler who built it.
    Show answer

    The Taj Mahal (Shah Jahan), the Suleymaniye Mosque (Suleiman), Versailles (Louis XIV), or the Coricancha in Cuzco (the Inca).

  4. How did the Safavid shahs claim religious authority?
    Show answer

    By claiming descent from the imams and promoting Twelver Shi'a Islam as the state religion.

  5. Why did Mexica kings practice human sacrifice?
    Show answer

    It was a religious act meant to feed the sun god and keep the world in order, and it also displayed the king's power and the fate of his enemies.

  6. Why might a ruler use more than one source of legitimacy?
    Show answer

    Because the empire ruled diverse peoples, so the ruler needed to appeal to different groups, as the Qing did with the Mandate of Heaven for the Han and Buddhist patronage for Mongols and Tibetans.

Lesson 3.4 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2

Bureaucrats, soldiers, and taxes

Empires needed people to run them and money to pay for armies, roads, and courts. The CED says that recruitment and use of bureaucratic elites, as well as the development of military professionals, became more common among rulers who wanted to maintain centralized control over their populations and resources, and that rulers used tribute collection, tax farming, and innovative tax-collection systems to generate revenue. This lesson covers both.

Required content · 3B

Learning objective.

  • 3B. Explain how rulers used a variety of methods to legitimize and consolidate their power in land-based empires from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.I.C. Recruitment and use of bureaucratic elites, as well as the development of military professionals, became more common among rulers who wanted to maintain centralized control over their populations and resources.
  • 4.3.I.D. Rulers used tribute collection, tax farming, and innovative tax-collection systems to generate revenue in order to forward state power and expansion.

Bureaucratic elites and military professionals

Rulers wanted officials and soldiers who were loyal to them, not to local nobles or tribal leaders. They found several ways to build them.

  • Ottoman devshirme. Under this system, officials took boys from Christian families in the Balkans, converted them to Islam, and trained them for the sultan's service. Some became janissaries, soldiers armed with firearms who served the sultan directly. The most talented rose to be high officials, even grand viziers. They were technically slaves of the sultan, but they held great power, and because they owed everything to him, they were loyal. Families in the Balkans sometimes resisted the levy, and others sought it as a way for their sons to gain status.
  • Salaried samurai. In Japan, after a century of civil war, the Tokugawa shoguns established peace in 1603. Samurai were the warrior class, but most were now paid a stipend of rice by their lords and became administrators and officials. The shogun also made the regional lords, the daimyo, spend alternate years in the capital, which kept them under watch.
  • Mughal mansabdars. The Mughal emperor Akbar organized officials and military leaders into a ranked system, with each holding a rank (mansab) that set his salary and the number of troops he had to supply. Appointments came from the emperor and not from birth, and officials could be transferred.
  • Chinese examination system. The Ming and the Qing continued to use civil service examinations to select officials, which tied educated men to the state.

Tribute, tax farming, and new tax systems

Revenue was the other pillar. The CED lists several methods.

  • Mexica tribute lists. The Mexica did not directly govern most conquered peoples but demanded regular tribute of cloth, food, feathers, and goods, recorded on lists such as those in the Codex Mendoza.
  • Ottoman tax farming. The Ottoman government sold the right to collect taxes in a region to individuals, who paid the state a fixed sum in advance and kept what they collected beyond that. This system, called tax farming, gave the state steady cash but could lead to abuse, as farmers squeezed peasants for profit.
  • Mughal zamindars. Akbar's government assessed the land and set the tax on crops. Zamindars, local landholders, collected the tax from peasants, kept a share, and passed the rest to the state. They also became powerful local figures.
  • Ming collection in hard currency. In the late 1500s, the Ming moved toward collecting taxes in silver instead of grain or labor, in a reform known as the Single Whip. It simplified taxation but made the economy dependent on silver, much of which came from the Americas (Lesson 4.5a).

Why these choices mattered

Each system shaped the relationship between ruler and ruled. Rulers who built loyal bureaucracies and armies reduced the power of hereditary nobles, but they had to pay for them. Tax farming and tribute raised money but could alienate those taxed. Rulers also had to balance centralization against the need for local cooperation, which is why many empires relied on local elites such as zamindars. Where a system failed to pay its soldiers or keep local officials honest, as in the later Ottoman and Mughal cases, central authority weakened.

Description of: Mexica tribute records

Description of a page of the Codex Mendoza, an illustrated manuscript made in Mexico about 1541 for the Spanish viceroy, based on earlier Mexica records. This is a description, not a quotation.

A page of the codex lists the towns that paid tribute to the Mexica capital. Pictures show the goods, such as cloaks, warrior costumes, jade, feathers, and food, and the quantities due each year, with a Spanish explanation added beside them.

Sourcing (HIPP). The codex was made by Mexica scribes under Spanish direction after the conquest, so its point of view is mixed, since Mexica tradition was filtered through colonial requirements. Its purpose was to give the Spanish king a record of Mexica society, including what tribute had been collected. The audience was Spanish officials. Because the codex was made after the empire fell and for a conqueror, its details may have been shaped by Spanish interests, but it preserves Mexica records of how the state collected goods.

Source analysis · Tribute

Claim. The Mexica empire relied on regular tribute from conquered peoples.

Evidence. The codex lists towns, pictured goods such as cloaks and feathers, and the quantities due each year.

Reasoning. A record of this type shows that conquered towns owed fixed goods on a schedule, which supports the claim that tribute was systematic. A limit is that the manuscript was made for the Spanish after the conquest, so details may have been altered or selected for Spanish purposes.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way rulers built loyal officials and one way they raised revenue.

Model. Ottoman sultans built loyal officials through the devshirme, which took boys from Christian families, converted them, and trained them as soldiers and administrators who owed everything to the sultan. To raise revenue, the Mughals assessed the land and used zamindars to collect taxes from peasants, which gave the state a steady income.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3B again covers consolidation of power. Match methods to empires: devshirme (Ottoman), salaried samurai (Tokugawa Japan), mansabdars (Mughal), exams (Ming and Qing), tribute (Mexica), tax farming (Ottoman), zamindars (Mughal), and hard currency (Ming). Explain why each helped central control or revenue.

Practice
  1. What was the devshirme?
    Show answer

    The Ottoman practice of taking boys from Christian families, converting them to Islam, and training them as soldiers and officials loyal to the sultan.

  2. What was tax farming?
    Show answer

    A system in which the government sold the right to collect taxes to individuals, who paid the state a fixed sum and kept the rest.

  3. What was a zamindar?
    Show answer

    A local landholder in Mughal India who collected taxes from peasants, kept a share, and passed the rest to the state.

  4. How did samurai change under the Tokugawa?
    Show answer

    After peace in 1603, most became salaried officials and administrators paid in rice rather than landholding warriors.

  5. What was tribute in the Mexica empire?
    Show answer

    Regular payment of goods such as cloth, food, and feathers by conquered peoples to the Mexica capital.

  6. Why did the Ming collect taxes in silver?
    Show answer

    It simplified taxation and reflected the growth of a money economy, but it made China depend on silver, much of which came from the Americas.

Lesson 3.5 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.3

Belief systems in an age of empires

Religion shaped empires, and empires shaped religion. The CED asks about continuity and change within the various belief systems during the period from 1450 to 1750 and lists three developments: the Protestant and Catholic reformations, the Sunni-Shi'a split in Islam, and the rise of Sikhism. The skill for this topic is sourcing, so the lesson ends with a closer look at how to analyze a source's point of view.

Required content · 3C

Learning objective.

  • 3C. Explain continuity and change within the various belief systems during the period from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.VI.i. The Protestant Reformation marked a break with existing Christian traditions and both the Protestant and Catholic reformations contributed to the growth of Christianity.
  • 4.1.VI.ii. Political rivalries between the Ottoman and Safavid empires intensified the split within Islam between Sunni and Shi’a.
  • 4.1.VI.iii. Sikhism developed in South Asia in a context of interactions between Hinduism and Islam.

The Protestant Reformation and the Catholic response

In 1517 a German monk and professor, Martin Luther, published ninety-five theses attacking the sale of indulgences, certificates that the Church said reduced a sinner's punishment. His ideas spread quickly with the help of the printing press. Luther taught that salvation came by faith alone and that the Bible, not the pope, was the final authority. Others, such as the Swiss reformer John Calvin, developed related ideas, and the movement called Protestantism broke from Roman Catholic Christianity. The CED says it marked a break with existing Christian traditions.

Rulers in Germany, Scandinavia, England, and elsewhere sided with the reformers, partly for religious reasons and partly to gain church lands or independence from the pope. The result was a century of religious wars. The Catholic Church responded with the Catholic Reformation, which included the Council of Trent (1545 to 1563), which reaffirmed Catholic teachings and ended some abuses, and new orders such as the Jesuits, who founded schools and missions around the world. The CED notes that both the Protestant and Catholic reformations contributed to the growth of Christianity, because both groups worked hard to educate believers and convert others, including in Asia and the Americas.

The Sunni-Shi'a split hardens

Islam had been divided since the earliest years over who should lead the community after the Prophet's death. Sunni Muslims, the majority, accepted the early caliphs, and Shi'a Muslims believed that leadership belonged to the Prophet's family through Ali and his descendants, the imams. For centuries, this difference coexisted with shared practice. But the CED says political rivalries between the Ottoman and Safavid empires intensified the split. When the Safavids made Twelver Shi'ism the state religion in 1501, and the Sunni Ottomans fought them (Lesson 3.1a), religious identity became tied to state identity. The effect was a long-lasting division between Sunni-majority and Shi'a-majority regions that still marks the Middle East.

The rise of Sikhism

Sikhism began in the Punjab region of South Asia with Guru Nanak (1469 to 1539). The CED says it developed in South Asia in a context of interactions between Hinduism and Islam. Nanak taught that there is one God, that all people are equal before God, and that devotion, honest work, and sharing are more important than ritual or caste. His teachings drew on the bhakti movement within Hinduism and on Sufi ideas in Islam, though Sikhs see it as a distinct revealed faith. Nine later gurus led the community and compiled its scripture, the Guru Granth Sahib. Under Mughal rule, Sikhs sometimes faced persecution, and in 1699 the tenth guru, Gobind Singh, founded the Khalsa, a community of initiated Sikhs with a military discipline, and by the 1700s Sikhs had become a political and military force.

Continuity and change

In each case, new ideas drew on older traditions. Protestants appealed to the Bible and early Christian practice, Safavid Shi'ism built on a tradition more than eight hundred years old, and Sikhism took ideas from earlier religions. And each change had political effects. Beliefs became a basis for state policy, for war, and for identity.

Sourcing: reading point of view

On the exam, a source question may ask you to explain how an author's point of view, purpose, historical situation, or audience affects the source's value. This lesson's source is a sentence from Luther.

Primary source · Luther on indulgences

Martin Luther, Ninety-Five Theses (1517), thesis 36, in the English translation by Wace and Buchheim (1883).

Every truly repentant Christian has a right to full remission of penalty and guilt, even without letters of pardon.

Sourcing (HIPP). Luther was a German monk and professor of theology, so his point of view is that of a reformer within the Church who was troubled by the sale of indulgences. His purpose was to start an academic debate about indulgences, and he wrote in Latin for scholars, which was his first audience. His historical situation was a time of growing criticism of the Church and of rising German resentment of money flowing to Rome. The sentence matters because it shows that Luther claimed a direct relationship between believers and God that did not depend on the Church's certificates.

Source analysis · A challenge to authority

Claim. Luther challenged the Church's role as the necessary go-between between believers and God.

Evidence. He wrote that a repentant Christian has a right to full forgiveness even without letters of pardon.

Reasoning. If forgiveness does not depend on papal certificates, then the Church's power to sell indulgences loses its basis. A limit is that Luther meant to begin a debate among scholars and did not yet intend to break from the Church, so the sentence expresses reform more than revolt.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way the Sunni-Shi'a split in Islam changed after 1500.

Model. After the Safavids made Twelver Shi'ism the state religion of Iran in 1501, the long-standing religious difference became tied to a state rivalry with the Sunni Ottoman Empire. Religious identity then marked political boundaries and justified wars, which deepened the division.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3C asks for continuity and change within belief systems. Cover three: the Protestant and Catholic reformations (break and growth), the Sunni-Shi'a division (state rivalry), and Sikhism (interaction of Hinduism and Islam). For sourcing questions, always identify point of view, purpose, situation, or audience and say how each affects the source.

Practice
  1. What did Martin Luther criticize in 1517?
    Show answer

    The sale of indulgences, certificates the Church said reduced the punishment of sinners.

  2. What was the Catholic Reformation?
    Show answer

    The Catholic response to Protestantism, including the Council of Trent, which reaffirmed doctrine, and new orders such as the Jesuits that educated and sent missionaries.

  3. How did Ottoman-Safavid rivalry affect Islam?
    Show answer

    It tied Sunni and Shi'a identity to rival states, which deepened the divide between them.

  4. What are the main teachings of Sikhism?
    Show answer

    One God, equality of all people before God, and devotion, honest work, and sharing over ritual or caste.

  5. Who founded the Khalsa and when?
    Show answer

    The tenth guru, Gobind Singh, in 1699.

  6. What does it mean to analyze a source's point of view?
    Show answer

    To consider who wrote it, what position the author held, and how that perspective may shape what the source says.

Lesson 3.6 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.4

Comparison in land-based empires

This lesson practices comparison, the skill the CED attaches to this topic. The question it addresses is how various empires increased their influence between 1450 and 1750. Influence means power over other states and peoples, and rulers pursued it through force, religion, administration, and economic means.

Required content · 3D

Learning objective.

  • 3D. Compare the methods by which various empires increased their influence from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.VI. In some cases, the increase and intensification of interactions between newly connected hemispheres expanded the reach and furthered development of existing religions, and contributed to religious conflicts and the development of syncretic belief systems and practices. Transoceanic Interconnections
  • 4.3.II.B. Land empires included the Manchu in Central and East Asia; the Mughal in South and Central Asia; the Ottoman in Southern Europe, the Middle East, and North Africa; and the Safavids in the Middle East.
  • 4.3.III.i. Political and religious disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states.

Methods of increasing influence

MethodExamples
Military power and gunpowderOttoman cannons at Constantinople (1453); Mughal guns at Panipat (1526); Russian firearms in Siberia; Moroccan guns against Songhai (1591)
ReligionSafavid imposition of Shi'ism; Mughal and Ottoman patronage of Islam; Songhai promotion of Islam; Mexica sacrifice and Inca sun worship
AdministrationOttoman devshirme and janissaries; Mughal mansabdars; Qing use of the exam system
RevenueOttoman tax farming; Mughal zamindars; Mexica and Inca tribute and labor service
Tolerance and incorporationOttoman millet system; Akbar's policies; Qing patronage of Buddhism for Mongols and Tibetans
Monuments and ceremonyTaj Mahal; Suleymaniye; Qing portraits; Versailles

Comparing religious policy

Empires took very different approaches to religious diversity, and a comparison can use these differences.

  • The Ottomans used the millet system, in which religious communities such as Orthodox Christians, Armenians, and Jews governed their own affairs under their own leaders and paid a special tax in exchange for protection. After Spain expelled its Jews in 1492, many settled in Ottoman lands.
  • The Mughals under Akbar practiced tolerance toward Hindus and other groups. Akbar abolished the tax on non-Muslims (the jizya), appointed Hindus to high rank, married Hindu princesses, and hosted discussions among religious leaders. His great-grandson Aurangzeb reversed some of these policies, reimposed the jizya in 1679, and destroyed some Hindu temples, which fueled resistance.
  • The Safavids imposed Shi'a Islam on a largely Sunni population and persecuted those who refused.
  • The Qing used different tools for different groups: Confucian ideas for the Han, Buddhism and the title of Mongol khan for Mongols, and patronage of Tibetan Buddhism.

The CED notes that these differences were a part of how states expanded the reach and furthered development of existing religions and contributed to religious conflicts.

Similarities

  • Almost every empire used a mix of force, ideology, and administration.
  • Most used gunpowder and professional soldiers and tried to build loyalty to the ruler rather than to local lords.
  • Most ruled diverse populations, so each had to decide whether to include or impose.
  • Most faced rivalries that were both political and religious, such as Safavid-Mughal and Ottoman-Safavid conflicts.

Differences

  • Land versus sea. Ottoman, Safavid, Mughal, and Qing power rested on land and agriculture, while later European empires depended more on the sea (Unit 4).
  • Incorporation versus imposition. Akbar and the Ottomans were more inclusive, while the Safavids imposed a state religion and Aurangzeb reversed Akbar's tolerance.
  • Who ruled. Some dynasties were conquerors from outside the lands they ruled, such as the Mughals and Manchus, and others, such as the Songhai, rose from within.
Description of: Akbar's policy of tolerance

Description of the Akbarnama, the official history of Akbar's reign written by his court historian Abu'l Fazl in the 1590s. This is a description, not a quotation.

Abu'l Fazl wrote that the emperor ended the tax on non-Muslims, welcomed scholars of different religions to the discussion hall at Fatehpur Sikri, and sought peace among his subjects of different faiths. He presented the emperor as a ruler of universal justice.

Sourcing (HIPP). Abu'l Fazl was Akbar's friend and official historian, so his point of view is strongly favorable to the emperor. The purpose was to glorify Akbar's reign and justify his policies, and the audience was the court. Because it is a flattering history, it shows how the court wanted Akbar remembered, but it should be checked against other evidence, such as the actual ending of the jizya and the appointment of Hindus to high rank.

Source analysis · A court historian

Claim. Akbar followed a policy of accommodation toward non-Muslims.

Evidence. Abu'l Fazl wrote that the emperor ended the tax on non-Muslims and welcomed scholars of many religions to debates.

Reasoning. The ending of a tax and the invitation of other religions to discussion are specific actions that fit a policy of inclusion. A limit is that the author was a friend and official historian who wrote to praise the emperor, so his account may exaggerate Akbar's tolerance and ignore its limits.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference in how the Ottomans and Safavids used religion.

Model. Both used religion to strengthen their rule, the Ottomans as protectors of Sunni Islam and its holy cities and the Safavids as leaders of Twelver Shi'ism descended from the imams. They differed in policy toward other groups, since the Ottomans allowed Christians and Jews to govern their own communities under the millet system, whereas the Safavids imposed Shi'a Islam on a largely Sunni population.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 3D is a comparison objective. Choose a method (military, religion, administration, revenue) and give a similarity and a difference with a reason. Name the empires and the specific policies. A strong answer also mentions change over time, such as the contrast between Akbar and Aurangzeb.

Practice
  1. Name two methods empires used to increase their influence.
    Show answer

    Military power with gunpowder, religion, administration through bureaucracies or standing armies, revenue systems, and monuments are all correct.

  2. What was the millet system?
    Show answer

    The Ottoman arrangement that let religious communities govern their own affairs under their own leaders in exchange for protection and a special tax.

  3. How did Akbar's religious policy differ from Aurangzeb's?
    Show answer

    Akbar practiced tolerance by ending the jizya and including Hindus in government, while Aurangzeb reimposed the jizya and destroyed some temples.

  4. How did the Safavids differ from the Ottomans in religion?
    Show answer

    The Safavids imposed Shi'a Islam as the state religion, while the Ottomans were Sunni and allowed religious communities limited self-government.

  5. What did most land-based empires have in common?
    Show answer

    They used gunpowder and professional soldiers, ruled diverse populations, and faced rivalries that were both political and religious.

  6. Why is a court historian a limited source?
    Show answer

    He writes to praise the ruler and justify his policies, so his account may exaggerate or leave out failures.

Unit 3 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 3 review: Land-Based Empires, c. 1450–c. 1750

Ten questions on the Ottoman, Safavid, Mughal, Qing, and Russian empires (how they were built, how they were legitimized, how they were paid for, and how they governed subjects who did not share the ruler's faith) plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Description of: a sixteenth-century Ottoman miniature painting of a siege, produced for the sultan's court.

    Cannon of different sizes are drawn up before a walled city, with crews shown loading and a section of wall breached. Ranks of infantry in uniform dress carry firearms; behind them, cavalry wait in formation. Tents of the sultan's camp fill the background, with a covered treasury wagon and scribes seated at a table.

    The combination of elements in the painting best supports which conclusion about the Ottoman state?

    Correct. Cannon, uniformed infantry, a treasury wagon, and scribes shown together make the point that artillery armies required tax collection and record-keeping to exist at all.

    Cavalry appear, but the uniformed firearm infantry are placed in the foreground ranks, reflecting the janissaries' central role.

    The cannon are shown crewed and loading with a breach opened in the wall, which is combat use rather than display.

    Scribes seated at a table beside the treasury indicate exactly the delegated administration this option denies.

  2. Source: Ogier Ghiselin de Busbecq, Habsburg ambassador to the Ottoman court, letters written in the 1550s; early English translation.

    "Among the Turks, honours, high posts, and judgeships are the rewards of great ability and good service. … Each man in Turkey carries in his own hand his ancestry and his position in life."

    Busbecq's admiration for Ottoman promotion practice is best understood in light of the fact that he

    Correct. A Habsburg envoy praising advancement by ability was making a pointed comparison with a European nobility whose claims rested on descent: the passage is as much about Vienna as about Istanbul.

    He remained a Habsburg Christian diplomat throughout and wrote as an outside observer.

    He served the Ottomans' principal European rival, and his letters were addressed to a European readership.

    The high offices he describes were largely filled through the devshirme, which conscripted Christian boys and did not offer equal access to the whole population.

  3. The Ottoman millet system is best described as a method of

    That describes the devshirme, a separate institution that drew boys into janissary and administrative service.

    Correct. Each recognized community managed its own religious law and internal affairs while its leadership was held responsible to the state: subordination without assimilation.

    That describes the timar system of land grants supporting cavalry service.

    The millet system did the opposite, institutionalizing the continued existence of non-Muslim communities under their own leaders.

  4. Safavid Persia's adoption of Twelver Shi'ism as the state religion had which significant long-term consequence?

    Correct. A Shi'a Persia between two Sunni empires acquired a lasting identity whose consequences remain visible in the region's politics.

    It sharpened sectarian conflict, producing repeated warfare with the Ottomans along the western frontier.

    The Safavids made Shi'ism the basis of state legitimacy rather than abandoning the faith.

    The Ottomans became the Safavids' principal enemy, not their ally.

  5. Description of: two Mughal court chronicles, one from the late sixteenth century and one from the late seventeenth.

    The earlier records the abolition of a tax on non-Muslims, the appointment of Hindu Rajputs to senior commands, and debates in a hall where scholars of several religions were invited to speak. The later records the reimposition of that tax, the appointment of officials to enforce religious observance, and the expansion of the empire's territory to its greatest extent.

    The comparison between the two chronicles best illustrates which generalization?

    Correct. Akbar's accommodation and Aurangzeb's reversal came from the same dynasty a century apart, and the later policy strained loyalties the earlier one had secured.

    The later chronicle records the reimposition of the jizya and enforcement of religious observance, which contradicts consistency.

    The later chronicle pairs maximum territorial extent with policies that provoked rebellion, which shows the two coming apart.

    The earlier chronicle records Rajputs holding senior commands, so the exclusion claim fails.

  6. Description of: a Qing imperial edict of the mid-seventeenth century addressed to the newly conquered Chinese population.

    The edict requires adult men to shave the front of the head and wear the remaining hair in a single braid in the Manchu manner, on pain of death for refusal. Other edicts from the same decade confirm the continuation of the civil service examinations and the appointment of Chinese scholars to office alongside Manchu bannermen.

    Taken together, these edicts best demonstrate that the Qing

    Correct. The queue was a daily public act of submission, while the examinations and Chinese officeholding preserved the machinery a small conquering minority needed to run an enormous empire.

    The examinations continued, which is the central Chinese administrative tradition and the opposite of abolition.

    The queue requirement, enforced on pain of death, is a strong assertion of Manchu distinctiveness.

    Chinese scholars were appointed to office alongside bannermen, as the description states.

  7. Rulers in this period commonly used monumental architecture and court patronage primarily to

    Employment was a byproduct at most. The buildings were sited and designed for visibility and association with sacred authority.

    Correct. Süleymaniye, Isfahan's royal square, the Taj Mahal, and the Forbidden City each translated a claim about the ruler into stone that subjects encountered directly.

    Treasuries were housed separately; these were mosques, palaces, tombs, and ceremonial spaces.

    Most such projects were religious buildings or closely tied to religious legitimacy rather than secular replacements.

  8. Tax farming, used by several land-based empires in this period, involved

    Correct. It delivered revenue to the treasury immediately without a large salaried bureaucracy, at the cost of giving collectors an incentive to squeeze the population.

    Direct delivery to the capital describes tribute systems rather than tax farming, whose defining feature is the private intermediary.

    Agricultural land was the main tax base in all these empires and was not exempted.

    Salaried assessment is the alternative to tax farming, which these states adopted precisely because they could not afford it.

  9. Which best explains why Russia's expansion under the Romanovs is grouped with the other land-based empires of this period?

    Russian expansion was overland across Siberia and toward the Black Sea and Baltic, not a network of coastal trading posts.

    Correct. Gunpowder-backed overland conquest, a diverse subject population, and a ruler claiming religious sanction place Russia squarely alongside the Ottoman, Safavid, Mughal, and Qing cases.

    Russian serfdom was tightened rather than loosened in this period and was not abolished until 1861.

    The tsars ruled as autocrats claiming divine sanction, and representative institutions were weak or absent.

  10. A historian comparing the Ottoman, Safavid, Mughal, and Qing empires would most accurately conclude that all four

    Correct. Sunni Ottomans over Christians and Jews, Shi'a Safavids over Sunnis, Muslim Mughals over a Hindu majority, and Manchu Qing over Han China all faced versions of the same problem.

    Religious difference between ruler and ruled is the shared condition, not religious unity.

    All four drew their core revenue from taxing agricultural land, whatever trade they also taxed.

    Each developed administrative forms out of its own traditions; European models were not adopted in this period.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE method a land-based empire used to legitimize its rule in the period 1450–1750.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way a land-based empire financed its military or administration.
    3. Briefly explain ONE challenge these empires faced in governing religiously diverse populations.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: monumental architecture such as Süleymaniye, Isfahan, the Taj Mahal, or the Forbidden City; the Ottoman sultan's claim to the caliphate; Safavid Shi'a religious authority; the Mandate of Heaven under the Qing; tsarist claims as defender of Orthodoxy; art and manuscript patronage. Must name empire and method.
    • (b) Accept: tax farming; the Ottoman timar system; Mughal zamindars; Qing land tax and the examination-recruited bureaucracy; Russian serf labor and obligations. Must connect the method to funding.
    • (c) Accept: the tension between accommodation and enforcement of orthodoxy, illustrated by Akbar and Aurangzeb; the millet system's balance of autonomy and subordination; Safavid conversion pressure on Sunni subjects; Manchu rule over a Han majority. Must explain why it was difficult.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Ottoman sultans commissioned enormous mosque complexes such as the Süleymaniye in Istanbul, which combined a mosque with schools, a hospital, and a kitchen. The building made the sultan's claim to be protector of Islam and provider for his subjects into something people encountered daily.

    (b) The Ottomans and Mughals both used tax farming, selling the right to collect taxes in a district to a private party who paid the treasury in advance and kept whatever he could gather beyond that sum. This gave the state immediate revenue without maintaining a salaried collection service across a vast territory.

    (c) Rulers had to choose between accommodating subjects of other faiths and enforcing religious orthodoxy, and each choice carried a cost. Akbar abolished the jizya and appointed Hindu Rajputs to high command, which secured their loyalty; when Aurangzeb reimposed the tax and enforced Islamic observance a century later, he provoked rebellions that drained the empire even as it reached its greatest size.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way gunpowder weapons affected state formation in this period.
    2. Briefly explain ONE similarity between two land-based empires of this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of court chronicles as evidence about imperial rule.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: artillery reducing the defensive value of fortified walls and favoring centralized states; the expense of cannon and trained infantry requiring large tax revenues; the decline of cavalry nobility relative to infantry and artillery. Must link the weapon to a political outcome.
    • (b) Accept: rule over religiously diverse populations; reliance on agricultural taxation; monumental architecture as legitimation; recruitment of administrators outside the hereditary elite; expansion by overland conquest. Must name two empires.
    • (c) Accept: written by or for the ruler and therefore shaped to flatter; silence on failure and dissent; elite and capital-centered perspective; omission of peasant and provincial experience. Must name a specific limitation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Siege artillery could break the walls that had previously made local fortresses defensible, so a ruler who could afford cannon could subdue landholders who had earlier been able to resist. Power concentrated in states large enough to pay for artillery and the infantry to protect it.

    (b) The Ottoman and Qing empires both placed the administration of the state in the hands of men who did not inherit their positions. The Ottomans drew janissaries and high officials through the devshirme, and the Qing retained the Chinese civil service examinations, so in each case the ruler faced a service elite that depended on him rather than an independent hereditary nobility.

    (c) Court chronicles were written for the ruler who paid for them, so they record successes, campaigns, and building projects while passing over defeats, rebellions, and the cost of policies to ordinary subjects. They also describe the empire from the capital, telling us far more about the court's intentions than about what provincial governance actually looked like.

Lesson 4.1 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.1

Technology and the age of exploration

Europe in 1450 was a poor and divided corner of Eurasia, yet within fifty years its ships were crossing the Atlantic and entering the Indian Ocean. How? The CED says that knowledge, scientific learning, and technology from the Classical, Islamic, and Asian worlds spread, facilitating European technological developments and innovation. This lesson covers the tools and knowledge that made ocean travel possible and shows how most of them came from elsewhere.

Required content · 4A

Learning objective.

  • 4A. Explain how cross-cultural interactions resulted in the diffusion of technology and facilitated changes in patterns of trade and travel from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.II. Knowledge, scientific learning, and technology from the Classical, Islamic, and Asian worlds spread, facilitating European technological developments and innovation.
  • 4.1.II.A. The developments included the production of new tools, innovations in ship designs, and an improved understanding of regional wind and currents patterns, all of which made transoceanic travel and trade possible.

Borrowed knowledge

Many European advances built on earlier work in other regions. The CED names European technological developments influenced by cross-cultural interactions with the Classical, Islamic, and Asian worlds, and gives three examples.

  • The lateen sail. The triangular sail was used on Arab and Indian dhows (Lesson 2.3). Because it could be angled to catch wind from the side, it let ships sail against the wind, which square sails could not do well.
  • The compass. This Chinese invention, a magnetized needle that points north, reached Europe through Muslim lands by about 1200. It helped sailors keep their direction when the sun and stars were hidden.
  • Astronomical charts and instruments. The astrolabe, perfected by Muslim astronomers, and tables of the stars, many compiled in the Muslim world, helped sailors work out their latitude. Greek geography, preserved and extended by Muslim and Jewish scholars, also informed European maps.

Other transfers included gunpowder and printing from China. The printing press with movable type developed by Johannes Gutenberg around 1450 in Germany drew on earlier Chinese and Korean printing and on European metalworking. It made books and maps cheap, and it helped spread navigational knowledge.

New ships

The CED also lists innovations in ship designs, including three types.

  • The caravel. A small, fast Portuguese ship with lateen sails, which could sail close to the wind and explore coasts and rivers. Columbus's Nina and Pinta were caravels.
  • The carrack. A larger ship with a deep hull and mixed square and lateen sails, able to carry heavy cargo and cannons over long distances. Portuguese and Spanish carracks sailed to India and the Americas.
  • The fluyt. A Dutch cargo ship of the late 1500s with a flat bottom and a small crew, cheap to build and operate, which helped the Dutch dominate European shipping.

Cannons mounted on ships were also important, since they gave European vessels firepower that many Asian and African ports lacked at sea.

Understanding winds and currents

The CED stresses an improved understanding of regional wind and current patterns. Sailors learned that the trade winds blow from the east near the equator and the westerlies from the west in the middle latitudes. The Portuguese discovered that to return from West Africa they had to sail far out into the Atlantic and then turn back, a route called the volta do mar. Later, ships could cross the Atlantic by the trade winds and return by the westerlies, which made regular travel possible. In the Indian Ocean, Europeans learned the monsoons from local sailors.

These advances together made transoceanic travel and trade possible, in the CED's words. But note what they were not. They were not a European miracle of isolated genius. They built on knowledge from around Afro-Eurasia, and the power to use it came from states that chose to pay for it (Lesson 4.2).

Description of: a Portuguese world map

Description of the Cantino planisphere, a Portuguese world map made in 1502 and smuggled to Italy. This is a description of a map, not a quotation.

The map shows the coast of Africa and India as Portuguese sailors had charted them, the new lands in the Atlantic that Spain and Portugal had reached, and a line dividing the Atlantic between Spain and Portugal under the Treaty of Tordesillas (1494). It also shows compass lines and a scale of latitude.

Sourcing (HIPP). The map was made by Portuguese mapmakers, so its point of view is that of the Portuguese crown. Its purpose was to record discoveries that were state secrets, and it was copied for the Duke of Ferrara by an agent who obtained it illegally. The audience was a rival ruler, which shows how valuable such information was. Because the map records what the Portuguese knew in 1502, it is excellent evidence of their growing knowledge of coasts and winds, but it also reflects their claim to a share of the world.

Source analysis · Knowledge as power

Claim. Maps and navigational knowledge were valuable state resources in this period.

Evidence. The Cantino planisphere recorded Portuguese discoveries and was smuggled to Italy by an agent of the Duke of Ferrara.

Reasoning. If a map was worth smuggling, rival rulers saw geographic knowledge as an advantage in trade and empire. A limit is that the map is a single document, so it shows the Portuguese claim and knowledge in 1502 and not the full range of European or Asian geographic understanding.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way cross-cultural interactions led to new European technology.

Model. The lateen sail came from Arab and Indian ships in the Indian Ocean, and Europeans adopted it for the caravel. Because it let ships sail against the wind, it helped Portuguese sailors explore the coast of Africa and return, which made long voyages practical.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 4A asks how cross-cultural interactions resulted in the diffusion of technology. Name three tools (lateen sail, compass, astronomical charts), three ships (caravel, carrack, fluyt), and the key discovery about winds and currents. Stress that the origins were Chinese, Islamic, and Classical, not only European.

Practice
  1. Name one technology Europeans borrowed from Asia or the Islamic world.
    Show answer

    The compass, the lateen sail, the astrolabe, and astronomical charts all came from or through Asian and Islamic lands.

  2. What was the caravel?
    Show answer

    A small, fast Portuguese ship with lateen sails that could sail close to the wind and explore coasts.

  3. What was the fluyt?
    Show answer

    A Dutch cargo ship with a flat bottom and small crew, cheap to build and operate, which helped the Dutch dominate shipping.

  4. Why was knowledge of winds and currents important?
    Show answer

    It let ships cross oceans and return, for example by using the trade winds out and the westerlies back across the Atlantic.

  5. What was the volta do mar?
    Show answer

    The Portuguese route of sailing far out into the Atlantic to catch the westerlies and return from West Africa.

  6. Why was a map such as the Cantino planisphere valuable to rulers?
    Show answer

    It recorded newly discovered coasts and routes that gave a trade and military advantage, so rivals tried to obtain it.

Lesson 4.2 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.2

Exploration: causes and events

Between 1415 and 1650, ships from Portugal, Spain, England, France, and the Netherlands sailed to Africa, Asia, and the Americas. The CED says that new state-supported transoceanic maritime exploration occurred in this period. This lesson covers why states sponsored voyages, what they found, and how different European powers approached the task.

Required content · 4B, 4C

Learning objectives.

  • 4B. Describe the role of states in the expansion of maritime exploration from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4C. Explain the economic causes and effects of maritime exploration by the various European states.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.III. New state-supported transoceanic maritime exploration occurred in this period.
  • 4.1.III.A. Portuguese development of maritime technology and navigational skills led to increased travel to and trade with Africa and Asia and resulted in the construction of a global trading-post empire.
  • 4.1.III.B. Spanish sponsorship of the voyages of Columbus and subsequent voyages across the Atlantic and Pacific dramatically increased European interest in transoceanic travel and trade.
  • 4.1.III.C. Northern Atlantic crossings were undertaken under English, French, and Dutch sponsorship, often with the goal of finding alternative sailing routes to Asia. Transoceanic Interconnections

Why explore?

The CED asks about the role of states and the economic causes and effects of exploration. Several motives worked together.

  • Wealth. Europeans wanted direct access to Asian spices, silk, and gold without paying the Muslim and Italian merchants who controlled the trade routes. Monarchs wanted new revenues to fund wars.
  • Religion. Rulers wanted to spread Christianity, and the Iberian kingdoms had just finished centuries of war against Muslim rulers in Spain (the Reconquista, ending in 1492).
  • Glory and rivalry. Kings competed for prestige, and a claim to new lands could bring status.
  • Technology. Better ships and navigation tools (Lesson 4.1) made voyages possible.

States provided money, ships, and legal claims. Royal charters granted explorers rights to land and trade in exchange for a share of the profit.

Portugal and Spain

Portugal, a small kingdom on the Atlantic coast, led the way. Prince Henry (1394 to 1460), called "the Navigator," sponsored voyages down the African coast, and the Portuguese took the port of Ceuta in 1415. In 1488 Bartolomeu Dias rounded the southern tip of Africa, and in 1498 Vasco da Gama reached India, which opened a sea route to Asia. The CED says that Portuguese development of maritime technology and navigational skills led to increased travel to and trade with Africa and Asia and resulted in the construction of a global trading-post empire (Lesson 4.4a).

Spain sponsored the voyages of Christopher Columbus, an Italian navigator who in 1492 sailed west across the Atlantic hoping to reach Asia and instead reached islands in the Caribbean. The CED says that Spanish sponsorship of the voyages of Columbus and subsequent voyages across the Atlantic and Pacific dramatically increased European interest in transoceanic travel and trade. In 1494 the Treaty of Tordesillas, arranged with the pope's help, divided the unclaimed world between Spain and Portugal along a line in the Atlantic, which gave Portugal Brazil and Spain most of the rest of the Americas. In 1519 to 1522 an expedition begun by Ferdinand Magellan sailed around the world, though Magellan himself died in the Philippines. Spanish ships began to cross the Pacific from the Philippines to Mexico in the 1560s.

1415 Portugal takes Ceuta 1488 Dias rounds the Cape 1492 Columbus crosses the Atlantic 1498 da Gama reaches India 1519 Cortes enters Mexico 1521 Magellan expedition crosses Pacific 1565 Manila galleon route opens 1602 Dutch East India Company founded
Figure 4.1. Key steps in European overseas expansion. State-backed voyages joined the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific oceans into one system.

England, France, and the Netherlands

The CED says that northern Atlantic crossings were undertaken under English, French, and Dutch sponsorship, often with the goal of finding alternative sailing routes to Asia. John Cabot, sailing for England in 1497, reached North America, and Jacques Cartier, for France, explored the St. Lawrence River in the 1530s. Henry Hudson, sailing for the Dutch in 1609, searched for a passage through North America. They did not find a northwest passage, but they claimed lands and prepared the way for later colonies. The Dutch and English also founded chartered companies, the Dutch East India Company in 1602 and its English counterpart in 1600, to carry on trade and war in Asia (Lesson 4.5a).

Effects

The economic effects were large. Europeans gained access to new goods and, in the Americas, to silver and land. They created new trade networks that joined the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific oceans into one system. For Indigenous peoples of the Americas and for many in Africa, the effects included disease, conquest, and enslavement, which later lessons cover. And exploration encouraged more state investment in navies, mapmaking, and trading companies.

Description of: Columbus's report

Description of the letter Christopher Columbus wrote in 1493 to a Spanish royal official reporting on his first voyage. This is a description, not a quotation.

Columbus described the islands he reached as beautiful and fertile and the people as gentle and willing to trade. He said they would be easy to convert to Christianity and he promised that with Spanish support he could bring back gold, spices, and enslaved people.

Sourcing (HIPP). Columbus wrote to the officials who had funded him, so his point of view is that of an explorer seeking to justify further support. His purpose was to persuade Ferdinand and Isabella that the voyage was a success and to win backing for more. The audience was the Spanish court, and the letter was printed and spread across Europe. Because he wanted to impress his sponsors, he likely exaggerated the riches and ease of conquest, and he described the people he met through the lens of conquest rather than their own view.

Source analysis · A sponsor's purpose

Claim. Columbus's report was shaped by his need to win further royal support.

Evidence. He described the islands as fertile, the people as gentle and easy to convert, and promised gold, spices, and enslaved people.

Reasoning. The emphasis on riches and easy conquest matches what a monarch funding an expensive expedition would want to hear, which suggests the author was making a case rather than simply reporting. A limit is that the letter is still valuable evidence of Spanish motives and expectations, even if its description of the islands is exaggerated.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one economic cause and one role of the state in European exploration.

Model. One economic cause was the desire to reach Asian spices and gold directly, bypassing the Muslim and Italian merchants who controlled the trade routes, which would raise profits for European merchants and revenue for monarchs. One role of the state was financing and chartering voyages, as Spain did when it sponsored Columbus, and claiming land, as the Treaty of Tordesillas did.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 4B and 4C ask for the role of states and economic causes and effects. Give examples: Portugal (Henry, Dias, da Gama), Spain (Columbus, Magellan, Tordesillas), and the northern powers (Cabot, Cartier, Hudson). Always say who sponsored each voyage and what the state gained.

Practice
  1. Name two motives for European exploration.
    Show answer

    Wealth from direct access to Asian trade, spreading Christianity, rivalry and glory among rulers, and new technology.

  2. What did Vasco da Gama accomplish?
    Show answer

    He reached India by sailing around Africa in 1498, opening a sea route from Europe to Asia.

  3. What was the Treaty of Tordesillas?
    Show answer

    A 1494 agreement that divided the unclaimed world between Spain and Portugal along a line in the Atlantic.

  4. Why did England, France, and the Netherlands sponsor northern voyages?
    Show answer

    They hoped to find alternative sailing routes to Asia, such as a northwest passage, to avoid Spanish and Portuguese routes.

  5. What role did states play in exploration?
    Show answer

    They provided funding and ships, granted charters and legal claims, and sometimes sent navies to protect them.

  6. Why must Columbus's letter be read with care?
    Show answer

    He wrote to win more royal support, so he probably exaggerated riches and the ease of conquest.

Lesson 4.3 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.3

The Columbian Exchange

After 1492, the Eastern and Western Hemispheres, separated for thousands of years, were joined by regular voyages. The CED says that the new connections between the Eastern and Western Hemispheres resulted in the exchange of new plants, animals, and diseases, known as the Columbian Exchange. It was one of the most important environmental and biological changes in history. This lesson covers the causes, the exchange of diseases, crops, and animals, and the effects on each hemisphere.

Required content · 4D

Learning objective.

  • 4D. Explain the causes of the Columbian Exchange and its effects on the Eastern and Western Hemispheres.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.V. The new connections between the Eastern and Western Hemispheres resulted in the exchange of new plants, animals, and diseases, known as the Columbian Exchange.
  • 4.1.V.A. European colonization of the Americas led to the unintentional transfer of disease vectors, including mosquitoes and rats, and the spread of diseases that were endemic in the Eastern Hemisphere, including smallpox, measles, and malaria. Some of these diseases substantially reduced the indigenous populations, with catastrophic effects in many areas.
  • 4.1.V.B. American foods became staple crops in various parts of Europe, Asia, and Africa. Cash crops were grown primarily on plantations with coerced labor and were exported mostly to Europe and the Middle East.
  • 4.1.V.C. Afro-Eurasian fruit trees, grains, sugar, and domesticated animals were brought by Europeans to the Americas, while other foods were brought by African enslaved persons.
  • 4.1.V.D. Populations in Afro-Eurasia benefitted nutritionally from the increased diversity of American food crops.

Disease

The most devastating part of the exchange was disease. The CED says that European colonization of the Americas led to the unintentional transfer of disease vectors, including mosquitoes and rats, and the spread of diseases that were endemic in the Eastern Hemisphere, including smallpox, measles, and malaria.

Indigenous peoples of the Americas had no prior exposure to these diseases, so they had no immunity. Smallpox, measles, influenza, and later malaria and yellow fever swept through populations. Estimates vary widely, but many scholars think that in some regions, such as the Caribbean and the central Mexican highlands, the Indigenous population fell by 50 to 90 percent within a century. The CED says these diseases substantially reduced the indigenous populations, with catastrophic effects in many areas. The scale of death also made conquest easier, since states such as the Mexica and Inca were weakened by epidemics just as Spanish forces arrived.

Crops and animals going west

Europeans, and also enslaved Africans, brought plants and animals to the Americas.

  • Afro-Eurasian crops. The CED lists fruit trees, grains, sugar, and domesticated animals. Wheat, barley, grapes, and sugarcane were planted. Sugar became the main crop of plantations in Brazil and the Caribbean.
  • Animals. Horses, pigs, and cattle transformed American life. Horses changed warfare and hunting on the Great Plains, and cattle and pigs changed land use and diets, though grazing animals also changed landscapes.
  • Foods brought by enslaved Africans. The CED lists okra and rice, which were part of African farming and cooking and became important in the Americas, where African farmers' knowledge of rice growing shaped plantations in places such as South Carolina.

Crops going east

The CED notes that American foods became staple crops in various parts of Europe, Asia, and Africa. Maize (corn), potatoes, sweet potatoes, and cassava spread widely. Potatoes became a staple in northern Europe and Ireland. Maize and sweet potatoes spread to China, where they grew on land too poor for rice and wheat, and cassava and maize spread across Africa. Other American crops, such as tomatoes and chili peppers, changed cooking. The CED adds that populations in Afro-Eurasia benefitted nutritionally from the increased diversity of American food crops, and many historians connect these crops to later population growth. Some crops, such as tobacco, were valued as luxuries.

Cash crops and plantations

The CED also says that cash crops were grown primarily on plantations with coerced labor and were exported mostly to Europe and the Middle East. Sugar, tobacco, and later cotton were cash crops, grown for sale and not for the farmer's own use. Plantations used Indigenous people and, more and more, enslaved Africans, which links the exchange to the Atlantic slave trade (Lesson 4.4b). In this way, the Columbian Exchange helped create new patterns of wealth and labor.

Effects

For the Americas, the effects were demographic collapse, new crops and animals, and the reorganization of land and labor. For Europe, Asia, and Africa, they included richer diets, population growth, and new commercial goods. Winners and losers were unequal. The benefits went mostly to people in the Eastern Hemisphere, while many Indigenous peoples of the Americas suffered the worst of the costs.

Description of: a Nahua account of smallpox

Description of the Florentine Codex, a twelve-book encyclopedia of Nahua (Aztec) life compiled in the 1550s and 1560s by the Franciscan Bernardino de Sahagun with Nahua informants. This is a description, not a quotation.

In the book on the conquest, Nahua informants describe the epidemic of 1520 in Tenochtitlan. They say the sickness spread across the city, that many were too ill to care for one another or to get food, and that large numbers died.

Sourcing (HIPP). The account was given by Nahua elders to a Spanish friar and written down in Nahuatl, so the point of view is Nahua, filtered through a Franciscan project. Its purpose was to preserve knowledge of Nahua history and to help missionaries understand the people they aimed to convert. The audience was the friars and, in Spain, church officials. Because the informants spoke decades after the events, memory may have shaped details, but the account is valuable as a rare Indigenous description of the epidemic's effects.

Source analysis · The human cost

Claim. Smallpox weakened the Mexica capital during the Spanish conquest.

Evidence. Nahua informants said the sickness spread across Tenochtitlan, many were too ill to care for others or find food, and many died.

Reasoning. An epidemic that disables large parts of the population would reduce a city's ability to resist a siege, which supports the claim that disease helped the Spanish. A limit is that the account was recorded decades later by a friar, so it reflects memory and the purposes of the project, and it does not measure how much disease mattered compared with Spanish alliances with other Indigenous groups.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of the Columbian Exchange on the Americas and one on Eurasia or Africa.

Model. In the Americas, Eastern Hemisphere diseases such as smallpox killed a large share of the Indigenous population, which weakened states and eased European conquest. In Afro-Eurasia, American crops such as maize, potatoes, and sweet potatoes added to the food supply, and they could grow on land that older crops could not, which supported larger populations.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 4D asks for causes and effects of the Columbian Exchange. Organize your answer by category: diseases (smallpox, measles, malaria), crops both ways (maize, potatoes, sugar, wheat), animals (horses, pigs, cattle), and cash crops with coerced labor. Explain who gained and who lost.

Practice
  1. What was the Columbian Exchange?
    Show answer

    The transfer of plants, animals, and diseases between the Eastern and Western Hemispheres after 1492.

  2. Why did disease devastate Indigenous peoples?
    Show answer

    They had no prior exposure or immunity to diseases such as smallpox and measles, so mortality was extremely high.

  3. Name two American crops that spread to the Eastern Hemisphere.
    Show answer

    Maize, potatoes, sweet potatoes, cassava, tomatoes, and chili peppers are all correct.

  4. Name two animals brought to the Americas.
    Show answer

    Horses, pigs, and cattle.

  5. How did the exchange link to slavery?
    Show answer

    Cash crops such as sugar and tobacco were grown on plantations with coerced labor, which increased demand for enslaved Africans.

  6. Why is the Florentine Codex valuable and also limited as a source?
    Show answer

    It preserves Nahua descriptions of the conquest and epidemic, but it was recorded decades later by a Spanish friar for missionary purposes, so memory and purpose shaped it.

Lesson 4.4 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.4

Maritime empires established

The CED says that driven largely by political, religious, and economic rivalries, European states established new maritime empires, including the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch, French, and British. This lesson covers how each empire was built, how Asian and African states responded, and which trade networks continued. The next lesson covers the labor systems that these empires created.

Required content · 4E, 4G, 4F

Learning objectives.

  • 4E. Explain the process of state building and expansion among various empires and states in the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4G. Explain changes and continuities in systems of slavery in the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4F. Explain the continuities and changes in economic systems and labor systems from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.II.A.i. Europeans established new trading posts in Africa and Asia, which proved profitable for the rulers and merchants involved in new global trade networks. Some Asian states sought to limit the disruptive economic and cultural effects of European-dominated long-distance trade by adopting restrictive or isolationist trade policies.
  • 4.3.II.C. Driven largely by political, religious, and economic rivalries, European states established new maritime empires, including the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch, French, and British.
  • 4.3.II.A.ii. The expansion of maritime trading networks fostered the growth of states in Africa, including the Asante and the Kingdom of the Kongo, whose participation in trading networks led to an increase in their influence.
  • 4.3.II.A.iii. Despite some disruption and restructuring due to the arrival of Portuguese, Spanish, and Dutch merchants, existing trade networks in the Indian Ocean continued to flourish and included intra-Asian trade and Asian merchants.

The Portuguese trading-post empire

Portugal did not try to conquer large territories in Asia or Africa. Instead it built a chain of fortified trading posts to control sea trade: Elmina on the Gold Coast (1482), Goa in India (1510), Malacca in Southeast Asia (1511), and Macao in China (1557). From these bases its ships tried to force Asian merchants to buy permits and to channel spices to Lisbon. The CED says Europeans established new trading posts that proved profitable for the rulers and merchants involved in new global trade networks. But the Portuguese never controlled all the trade, and Asian, Arab, and Indian merchants kept their own ships.

The Spanish empire in the Americas

Spain created a settler and extraction empire. In 1519, Hernan Cortes, with a few hundred soldiers and thousands of Indigenous allies who resented Mexica rule, attacked the Mexica capital, and with the help of epidemic disease, he took it in 1521. In 1532 to 1533, Francisco Pizarro took advantage of an Inca civil war and smallpox to capture the Inca emperor Atahualpa. Spain then governed the Americas through viceroyalties (New Spain and Peru) and councils in Spain, with large landholdings and forced Indigenous labor. Silver mines at Potosi (from 1545) and Zacatecas made the empire rich (Lesson 4.5a). Spain also took the Philippines in the 1560s, which tied the Americas to Asia across the Pacific.

The Dutch, French, and British

  • The Dutch formed the Dutch East India Company (VOC) in 1602, with the right to wage war and make treaties in Asia. They took Portuguese posts, founded Batavia on Java in 1619, and later set up a colony at the Cape of Good Hope (1652). They also set up colonies in the Americas, such as New Amsterdam.
  • The French set up fur-trading colonies in Canada (Quebec, 1608) and plantations in the Caribbean, such as Saint-Domingue, and had a small presence in India.
  • The British formed the East India Company in 1600 and founded settlements in North America, beginning with Jamestown in 1607, as well as sugar colonies in the Caribbean.

The CED explains that these empires were driven by political, religious, and economic rivalries. Spain and Portugal were Catholic, while the Dutch and English were mostly Protestant, and the powers fought over trade, colonies, and religion.

How Asian states responded

The CED notes that some Asian states sought to limit the disruptive economic and cultural effects of European-dominated long-distance trade by adopting restrictive or isolationist trade policies. Two examples:

  • Ming China restricted trade by confining foreign merchants to certain ports, and later the Qing continued to limit contact, with European trade at Canton.
  • Tokugawa Japan, in the 1630s, forbade Japanese from traveling abroad, banned Christianity, and expelled most Europeans. Only the Dutch were allowed to trade, at a small island called Dejima in Nagasaki harbor, and Chinese traders also came. This policy, later called sakoku ("closed country"), did not end trade but controlled it.

The CED also adds that despite some disruption and restructuring due to the arrival of Portuguese, Spanish, and Dutch merchants, existing trade networks in the Indian Ocean continued to flourish and included intra-Asian trade and Asian merchants. Europeans joined the Indian Ocean system more than they replaced it.

African states

In Africa, the expansion of maritime trading networks fostered the growth of states, including the Asante and the Kingdom of the Kongo, whose participation in trading networks led to an increase in their influence. African rulers sold goods, and also enslaved people, to Europeans, and used the guns and goods they received to extend their power. The Kongo, whose king Afonso I (r. 1509 to 1542) adopted Christianity and corresponded with Portugal, soon saw the slave trade damage his kingdom, which shows that participation could bring both gains and costs.

Description of: Japan's seclusion policy

Description of the edicts of 1635 issued by the Tokugawa shogun Iemitsu, which restricted travel and foreign contact. This is a description, not a quotation.

The edicts forbade Japanese ships from sailing abroad and Japanese people from going overseas, with a penalty of death for those who returned after leaving. They also banned the Christian religion and regulated foreign trade at Nagasaki.

Sourcing (HIPP). The edicts were issued by the shogun's government, so the point of view is that of a ruler trying to control his realm. The purpose was to prevent the spread of Christianity, which the Tokugawa saw as a threat, and to keep foreign merchants and Christian missionaries under control. The audience was Japanese officials, merchants, and sailors. Because it was a legal order and not a description of what really happened, it shows state policy but not how fully it was enforced.

Source analysis · Limiting contact

Claim. Tokugawa Japan restricted contact with Europeans to control foreign influence.

Evidence. The edicts banned overseas travel and Christianity and regulated foreign trade at Nagasaki.

Reasoning. Penalties for leaving and a ban on a religion linked to European missionaries show a policy of controlling cultural and economic influence. A limit is that the edicts say what the government ordered, not how well it enforced them, and trade with the Dutch and Chinese continued under supervision.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way the Portuguese and Spanish built their empires.

Model. Both used state-sponsored voyages to claim lands and wealth. The Portuguese built a chain of fortified trading posts in Africa and Asia to control sea trade, while the Spanish conquered large territories in the Americas, taking over Indigenous empires with the help of disease and local allies and governing them through viceroys and forced labor.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 4E to 4G ask about state building and expansion, economic and labor systems, and slavery. For this lesson, know the empires (Portuguese posts, Spanish conquest and viceroyalties, Dutch VOC, French and British colonies), Asian responses (Ming and Tokugawa restrictions), African state growth (Asante and Kongo), and the continued Indian Ocean trade.

Practice
  1. What was a trading-post empire?
    Show answer

    An empire made of fortified ports used to control and tax sea trade rather than large territories, as the Portuguese built in Africa and Asia.

  2. How did Cortes conquer the Mexica?
    Show answer

    With a small Spanish force, thousands of Indigenous allies who opposed Mexica rule, and epidemic disease that weakened the city.

  3. What was the VOC?
    Show answer

    The Dutch East India Company, founded in 1602, a chartered company that could wage war and make treaties in Asia.

  4. What was Tokugawa Japan's policy toward Europeans?
    Show answer

    It banned Japanese from traveling abroad and banned Christianity, and allowed only the Dutch and Chinese to trade at Nagasaki under supervision.

  5. Name two African states that grew through trade with Europeans.
    Show answer

    The Asante and the Kingdom of the Kongo.

  6. Did European empires replace existing Indian Ocean trade?
    Show answer

    No, existing networks continued to flourish, with Asian merchants and intra-Asian trade, and Europeans joined the system more than they replaced it.

Lesson 4.5 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.4

Labor systems and the Atlantic slave trade

European empires needed labor to mine silver and to grow sugar, and the labor systems they used shaped millions of lives. The CED asks for continuities and changes in economic systems and labor systems and in systems of slavery. This lesson covers slavery in Africa before and after European contact, the Atlantic slave trade and plantation economy, and the other labor systems used in the Americas.

Required content · 4E, 4G, 4F

Learning objectives.

  • 4E. Explain the process of state building and expansion among various empires and states in the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4G. Explain changes and continuities in systems of slavery in the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4F. Explain the continuities and changes in economic systems and labor systems from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.II.B. Enslavement in Africa continued in its traditional forms, including incorporation of enslaved persons into households and the export of enslaved persons to the Mediterranean and the Indian Ocean regions.
  • 4.2.II.C. The growth of the plantation economy increased the demand for enslaved labor in the Americas, leading to significant demographic, social, and cultural changes.
  • 4.2.II.D. Newly developed colonial economies in the Americas largely depended on agriculture, utilized existing labor systems, including the Incan mit’a, and introduced new labor systems including chattel slavery, indentured servitude, and encomienda and hacienda systems.

Slavery in Africa before the Atlantic trade

Slavery already existed in many societies. The CED says that enslavement in Africa continued in its traditional forms, including incorporation of enslaved persons into households and the export of enslaved persons to the Mediterranean and the Indian Ocean regions. In many African societies, captives from war or debt became servants or members of households with some rights, and their children might eventually gain freedom. This was very different from the chattel slavery of the Atlantic plantations. A trade also carried enslaved Africans across the Sahara and the Indian Ocean to Muslim lands.

The rise of the Atlantic slave trade

European traders began buying enslaved Africans along the African coast in the 1400s. The numbers grew with the plantation system. The CED says that the growth of the plantation economy increased the demand for enslaved labor in the Americas, leading to significant demographic, social, and cultural changes. Historians estimate that about 12.5 million Africans were forced onto ships between the 1500s and 1800s, and that about 10.7 million survived the Middle Passage, the voyage across the Atlantic, in which crowding, disease, and cruelty killed large numbers. Most were taken to Brazil and the Caribbean, where sugar plantations were the largest users, and a smaller share to North America.

Chattel slavery, in which a person is treated as property that can be bought, sold, and inherited, and in which slavery passes to children, became the main labor system on Atlantic plantations. Racial ideas increasingly justified it, as slavery came to be tied to African descent.

Europe West Africa The Americas Manufactured goods, textiles, firearms Enslaved Africans (the Middle Passage) Sugar, tobacco, cotton, silver, and other raw goods
Figure 4.2. The Atlantic system. Goods, wealth, and enslaved people moved in a loop that tied three continents together. Not every voyage followed the full triangle.

African rulers and merchants took part. Some states, such as Dahomey and Asante, raided or traded for captives and used the guns and goods they received to build power. The trade also destroyed communities, drove warfare, and caused lasting damage in the regions it touched.

Other labor systems in the Americas

The CED notes that newly developed colonial economies in the Americas largely depended on agriculture, utilized existing labor systems, including the Incan mit'a, and introduced new labor systems including chattel slavery, indentured servitude, and encomienda and hacienda systems.

  • Mit'a. The Spanish adopted the Inca labor draft and used it to supply workers for the silver mines of Potosi, where conditions were deadly.
  • Encomienda. The Spanish crown granted colonists (encomenderos) the right to demand labor and tribute from Indigenous communities, in exchange for protection and instruction in Christianity. In practice it was often brutal, and critics such as the friar Bartolome de las Casas protested. Laws in 1542 tried to limit it.
  • Hacienda. A large landed estate that grew in Spanish America, with workers tied to it through debt and custom.
  • Indentured servitude. Poor Europeans, especially in English colonies, signed contracts to work for several years in exchange for passage. Their conditions were hard, but the term was limited.
  • Chattel slavery. As Indigenous populations declined and European labor was costly, enslaved Africans supplied the sugar, tobacco, and later cotton plantations.

Continuity and change

Forced labor itself was not new, since the Inca mit'a, African household slavery, and European serfdom existed before. What changed was the scale, the connection to global markets, and the racial basis of Atlantic slavery. The CED also notes that the growth of the plantation economy led to demographic, social, and cultural changes, including the creation of new communities in the Americas with African cultures (Lesson 4.5b).

Description of: a survivor's account of the Middle Passage

Description of The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano (1789), the autobiography of a formerly enslaved man who lived in England. This is a description, not a quotation.

Equiano wrote that he was taken as a child from his home in West Africa and put on a slave ship. He described the crowding below decks, the stench and sickness, the sailors' cruelty, and the despair of the captives, some of whom tried to jump overboard.

Sourcing (HIPP). Equiano wrote as a free man in England, so his point of view is that of a survivor who became an abolitionist. His purpose was to expose the cruelty of the trade and to support the movement to end it, and the audience was a British reading public. Scholars debate details of his early life, such as whether he was born in Africa or in the Americas, but his description of the Middle Passage matches other evidence about conditions on slave ships.

Source analysis · The Middle Passage

Claim. The Middle Passage involved extreme suffering.

Evidence. Equiano described crowding, stench, sickness, and despair among captives, some of whom tried to jump overboard.

Reasoning. Details of crowding and illness match records of high death rates on slave ships, which supports the account. A limit is that Equiano wrote to support abolition and decades after the voyage, so his description may be shaped by that purpose, and scholars debate parts of his life story.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in systems of slavery between 1450 and 1750.

Model. One continuity was that slavery persisted in Africa in traditional forms such as household slavery, and enslaved people continued to be exported across the Sahara and Indian Ocean. One change was the growth of chattel slavery on Atlantic plantations on a vast scale, which tied slavery to race and to global markets for sugar and other crops.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 4F and 4G ask for continuities and changes in economic and labor systems and slavery. Define encomienda, hacienda, mit'a, indentured servitude, and chattel slavery, and give the scale (about 12.5 million embarked). Always contrast African household slavery with Atlantic chattel slavery.

Practice
  1. What was the mit'a under Spanish rule?
    Show answer

    The Inca labor draft adopted by the Spanish to supply workers for mines such as Potosi.

  2. What was the encomienda?
    Show answer

    A grant by the Spanish crown to colonists of the right to demand labor and tribute from Indigenous communities.

  3. What is chattel slavery?
    Show answer

    A system in which a person is treated as property who can be bought and sold and whose children are also enslaved.

  4. What was the Middle Passage?
    Show answer

    The voyage of slave ships across the Atlantic, in which crowding, disease, and cruelty killed many captives.

  5. How did slavery in Africa differ from Atlantic plantation slavery?
    Show answer

    In many African societies enslaved people were incorporated into households with some rights, while Atlantic plantation slavery was chattel slavery, hereditary, on a vast scale, and tied to race.

  6. What does a historian need to remember about Equiano as a source?
    Show answer

    He wrote as an abolitionist decades later for a British audience, so purpose shaped his account, though it matches other evidence about conditions.

Lesson 4.6 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.5

Mercantilism, silver, and the first global economy

By the 1600s, goods, money, and people moved among Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Americas as never before. The CED asks how rulers used economic strategies to consolidate and maintain power and how networks of exchange changed. This lesson covers the economic ideas European rulers used, the companies they chartered, the global flow of silver, and the Atlantic trading system. The next lesson covers society, belief, and rivalry.

Required content · 4H, 4J, 4I, 4K

Learning objectives.

  • 4H. Explain how rulers employed economic strategies to consolidate and maintain power throughout the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4J. Explain how political, economic, and cultural factors affected society from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4I. Explain the continuities and changes in networks of exchange from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4K. Explain the similarities and differences in how various belief systems affected societies from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.IV.C. Mercantilist policies and practices were used by European rulers to expand and control their economies and claim overseas territories. Joint-stock companies, influenced by these mercantilist principles, were used by rulers and merchants to finance exploration and were used by rulers to compete against one another in global trade.
  • 4.1.IV.D.i. The Atlantic trading system involved the movement of goods, wealth, and labor, including enslaved persons.
  • 4.1.IV. The new global circulation of goods was facilitated by chartered European monopoly companies and the global flow of silver, especially from Spanish colonies in the Americas, which was used to purchase Asian goods for the Atlantic markets and satisfy Chinese demand for silver. Regional markets continued to flourish in Afro-Eurasia by using established commercial practices and new transoceanic and regional shipping services developed by European merchants.
  • 4.2.II.A. Peasant and artisan labor continued and intensified in many regions as the demand for food and consumer goods increased. Transoceanic Interconnections

Mercantilism

The CED says mercantilist policies and practices were used by European rulers to expand and control their economies and claim overseas territories. Mercantilism was the belief that a state's wealth depended on its stock of gold and silver, and that the way to gain it was to export more than it imported. To achieve this, governments did several things.

  • They placed tariffs on foreign goods and encouraged domestic manufacturing.
  • They set up colonies to supply raw materials and buy finished goods, and required colonists to trade only with the mother country. England's Navigation Acts (from 1651) required that colonial goods travel in English ships.
  • They gave monopolies to favored companies.

Under mercantilism, trade was seen as a competition in which one state's gain was another's loss, so economic rivalry fed political rivalry (Lesson 4.5b).

Joint-stock and chartered companies

The CED says that joint-stock companies, influenced by these mercantilist principles, were used by rulers and merchants to finance exploration and were used by rulers to compete against one another in global trade. In a joint-stock company, many investors bought shares, which pooled money for expensive and risky ventures and limited each investor's loss to what he put in. Governments gave companies charters, or monopolies, over trade in particular regions. The English East India Company (1600) and the Dutch East India Company (VOC, 1602) are the leading examples, and others traded in the Atlantic, such as the Royal African Company, which traded in enslaved people. These companies could raise armies and navies, build forts, and govern territory, so they were also instruments of state power.

The flow of silver

The CED notes the global flow of silver, especially from Spanish colonies in the Americas, which was used to purchase Asian goods for the Atlantic markets and satisfy Chinese demand for silver. Silver mines at Potosi in the Andes and in Mexico produced enormous quantities, mined with forced Indigenous labor such as the mit'a. Silver traveled two ways.

  • To Europe, in Spanish treasure fleets, where it paid for Spain's wars and goods from Asia.
  • Across the Pacific, on Manila galleons that sailed from Acapulco in Mexico to Manila in the Philippines, where it was traded to Chinese merchants for silk and porcelain.

China needed silver because the Ming and Qing collected taxes in it (Lesson 3.2b), and its ample supply of goods meant Chinese merchants wanted payment in silver. As a result, a large share of the world's silver ended up in China. This silver trade is often called the first truly global exchange, because it connected the Americas, Europe, and Asia.

The Atlantic trading system

The CED says that the Atlantic trading system involved the movement of goods, wealth, and labor, including enslaved persons. In outline, European manufactured goods went to Africa, enslaved Africans went to the Americas, and sugar, tobacco, cotton, and silver went to Europe (see Figure 4.2 in Lesson 4.4b), though real routes were more complex. Ports such as Lisbon, Seville, Amsterdam, London, and Bristol grew wealthy from this trade.

Regional markets continued

The CED reminds us that regional markets continued to flourish in Afro-Eurasia by using established commercial practices and new transoceanic and regional shipping services developed by European merchants. Peasants and artisans in many regions also produced more as demand grew. The CED says peasant and artisan labor continued and intensified in many regions as the demand for food and consumer goods increased. Many people lived far from the new global system but felt its effects through prices and demand.

Primary source · A theory of trade

Thomas Mun, England's Treasure by Forraign Trade (written in the 1620s and published in 1664), spelling modernized.

The ordinary means therefore to increase our wealth and treasure is by foreign trade, wherein we must ever observe this rule: to sell more to strangers yearly than we consume of theirs in value.

Sourcing (HIPP). Mun was a director of the English East India Company, so his point of view is that of a merchant with a stake in overseas trade. His purpose was to defend the company against critics who said it drained England of silver by buying goods in Asia. His audience was English officials and the public. Because he was defending his own business, the passage shows the logic of mercantilism as merchants wanted it understood, and it is an interested argument, not a neutral analysis.

Source analysis · The logic of mercantilism

Claim. Mun expressed the central rule of mercantilism: a state grows wealthy by selling abroad more than it buys.

Evidence. He wrote that wealth increases by foreign trade and that the rule is to sell more to strangers yearly than we consume of theirs.

Reasoning. The rule describes a favorable balance of trade, in which exports exceed imports and bring in precious metals. A limit is that Mun worked for the East India Company and was defending it against criticism, so he framed trade in a way that served his employer.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way mercantilism contributed to rivalry among European states.

Model. Mercantilism treated trade as a competition for a limited supply of wealth, so states sought colonies, monopolies, and tariffs that favored themselves and excluded others. Laws such as England's Navigation Acts limited Dutch shipping, which contributed to the Anglo-Dutch wars, so economic goals led to armed conflict.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 4H and 4I ask for economic strategies of rulers and continuities and changes in exchange. Define mercantilism, joint-stock companies, and chartered monopolies, and trace the silver flow (Potosi, Manila galleons, China). Note what continued: regional markets, peasant and artisan labor.

Practice
  1. What is mercantilism?
    Show answer

    The belief that a state's wealth depends on its stock of gold and silver and that it should export more than it imports, using tariffs, colonies, and monopolies.

  2. What is a joint-stock company?
    Show answer

    A company funded by many investors who buy shares, pooling money for risky ventures and limiting each investor's loss.

  3. Name two chartered companies.
    Show answer

    The English East India Company and the Dutch East India Company (VOC).

  4. Where did much American silver end up and why?
    Show answer

    In China, because the Chinese economy demanded silver for taxes and trade and sold goods such as silk and porcelain for it.

  5. What were Manila galleons?
    Show answer

    Spanish ships that carried American silver from Acapulco to Manila and Chinese goods back, linking the Americas and Asia.

  6. Why is Mun's writing an interested source?
    Show answer

    He was an East India Company director defending the company's trade, so his argument served his own business.

Lesson 4.7 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.5

Society, belief, and rivalry in the age of oceans

Global trade changed how people lived, worshipped, and fought. The CED asks how political, economic, and cultural factors affected society and how belief systems affected societies. This lesson covers family and gender, the mixing of cultures in the Atlantic world, religious change and syncretism, and the conflicts over trade that mercantilism produced.

Required content · 4H, 4J, 4I, 4K

Learning objectives.

  • 4H. Explain how rulers employed economic strategies to consolidate and maintain power throughout the period from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4J. Explain how political, economic, and cultural factors affected society from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4I. Explain the continuities and changes in networks of exchange from 1450 to 1750.
  • 4K. Explain the similarities and differences in how various belief systems affected societies from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.III.ii. Economic disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states.
  • 4.2.III.C. Some notable gender and family restructuring occurred, including demographic changes in Africa that resulted from the trade of enslaved persons.
  • 4.1.IV.D.ii. The Atlantic trading system involved the movement of labor, including enslaved persons and the mixing of African, American, and European cultures and peoples, with all parties contributing to this cultural synthesis.
  • 4.1.VI. In some cases, the increase and intensification of interactions between newly connected hemispheres expanded the reach and furthered development of existing religions, and contributed to religious conflicts and the development of syncretic belief systems and practices. Transoceanic Interconnections

Family and gender

The CED says that some notable gender and family restructuring occurred, including demographic changes in Africa that resulted from the trade of enslaved persons. Slave traders, especially for the Americas, tended to buy more men than women, though the Muslim trade across the Sahara and Indian Ocean took more women. In parts of West Africa, this left a surplus of women, which affected marriage and led in some places to more polygyny and to women taking larger roles in farming and trade. In the Americas, enslaved families were constantly at risk of being broken apart by sale. European colonial societies also had unusual gender patterns, since early colonies had few European women, which encouraged unions between European men and Indigenous or African women and led to mixed populations (Lesson 4.7).

A cultural mixing

The CED says that the Atlantic trading system involved the movement of labor, including enslaved persons, and the mixing of African, American, and European cultures and peoples, with all parties contributing to this cultural synthesis. The mixing took many forms.

  • Food and music. Foods, instruments, and rhythms from Africa shaped the cuisine and music of Brazil, the Caribbean, and the American South.
  • Language. Creole languages formed from the mixing of African and European tongues.
  • Craft and farming knowledge. African knowledge of rice cultivation, metalwork, and medicine shaped American economies.
  • Peoples. Mixed populations arose in the Spanish and Portuguese colonies, which led to the casta system (Lesson 4.7).

Religion and syncretism

The CED notes that in some cases, the increase and intensification of interactions between newly connected hemispheres expanded the reach and furthered development of existing religions, and contributed to religious conflicts and the development of syncretic belief systems and practices. Several things happened.

  • Christianity expanded to the Americas, the Philippines, and parts of Africa and Asia through Spanish and Portuguese missionaries. Jesuits such as Matteo Ricci went to China and learned Chinese language and customs, hoping to make Christianity acceptable to scholars and officials.
  • Islam expanded in the Indian Ocean, as in Malacca and the Indonesian islands.
  • Syncretism, the blending of religions, appeared in many places. In the Americas, Indigenous and African practices blended with Catholicism. In Mexico, devotion to the Virgin of Guadalupe, who was reported to have appeared to a Nahua man in 1531, drew on both Catholic and Indigenous traditions. In the Caribbean and Brazil, African religions mixed with Catholic saints in practices such as Vodun in Haiti, Santeria in Cuba, and Candomblé in Brazil.
  • Conflict. Religious differences added to wars, such as those between Protestant and Catholic powers in Europe and between Muslim and Christian states around the Indian Ocean.

Trade rivalry and conflict

The CED says that economic disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states. It gives two examples: Muslim-European rivalry in the Indian Ocean and the Moroccan conflict with the Songhai Empire.

  • In the Indian Ocean, the Portuguese used force to take ports and to demand that merchants buy passes. Ottoman and Muslim rulers, including Gujarat and the Mamluks, fought them in the early 1500s and sent fleets, though the Portuguese held many ports through naval power. Over the next century the Dutch and English challenged the Portuguese in turn.
  • Morocco's sultan wanted control of the gold and salt trade across the Sahara and in 1591 sent an army that broke Songhai's power (Lesson 3.1b).

These conflicts show that the new trade did not just add exchange. It also created fights over who would control it.

Description of: a Jesuit in China

Description of the journals of Matteo Ricci, an Italian Jesuit who lived in China from 1583 until his death in 1610. This is a description, not a quotation.

Ricci wrote that he dressed as a Confucian scholar, learned Chinese, and discussed science and religion with scholars. He brought maps, clocks, and books on mathematics and astronomy, and he argued that Christianity was compatible with Confucian ethics. He also described Chinese customs, government, and society for European readers.

Sourcing (HIPP). Ricci was a Catholic missionary, so his point of view is that of a European Christian who admired parts of Chinese civilization and hoped to convert it. His purpose was to report to his order and to gain support for the mission, and his audience was fellow Jesuits and church authorities in Europe. Because he wanted to show the mission's promise, he may overstate Chinese interest in Christianity, but he is a very valuable source for how a European saw Ming China.

Source analysis · Cultural adaptation

Claim. Jesuit missionaries adapted to Chinese culture in order to spread Christianity.

Evidence. Ricci dressed as a Confucian scholar, learned Chinese, and argued that Christianity fit with Confucian ethics.

Reasoning. Taking on Chinese dress and learning shows an effort to fit in with the educated elite, which supports the idea of adaptation. A limit is that Ricci wrote to win support for the mission, so he may overstate how much scholars accepted his ideas.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of the Atlantic trade on society in Africa or the Americas.

Model. In parts of West Africa, the export of more men than women left a surplus of women, which changed marriage patterns and increased women's roles in farming and trade. In the Americas, the mixing of African, European, and Indigenous peoples and cultures produced new forms of religion, food, and music, such as Vodun and Candomblé.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 4J and 4K ask for political, economic, and cultural effects on society and for similarities and differences in belief systems. Give examples for gender and family, cultural synthesis, syncretism (Guadalupe, Vodun, Santeria, Candomblé), and rivalry (the Indian Ocean and Morocco versus Songhai).

Practice
  1. How did the slave trade change gender balance in parts of West Africa?
    Show answer

    More men than women were exported to the Americas, leaving a surplus of women, which affected marriage patterns and women's roles in farming and trade.

  2. What is syncretism?
    Show answer

    The blending of religious traditions, such as African religions with Catholic saints in Vodun, Santeria, and Candomblé.

  3. How did Matteo Ricci try to spread Christianity in China?
    Show answer

    He adopted the dress and language of Confucian scholars, shared Western science, and argued that Christianity fit with Confucian ethics.

  4. Name one conflict caused by economic rivalry.
    Show answer

    Muslim-European rivalry in the Indian Ocean, or Morocco's conquest of Songhai to control Saharan trade.

  5. How did the Atlantic system mix cultures?
    Show answer

    Africans, Europeans, and Indigenous peoples shared food, music, language, farming knowledge, and religious practices, which created new creole cultures.

  6. Why must Ricci's journals be read with care?
    Show answer

    He was a missionary writing to win support for his order, so he may overstate Chinese interest in Christianity.

Lesson 4.8 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.6

Challenges to state power, 1450 to 1750

Rulers who tried to centralize power and raise revenues met resistance. The CED says that state expansion and centralization led to resistance from an array of social, political, and economic groups on a local level, and that enslaved persons challenged existing authorities in the Americas through organized resistance. This lesson covers local rebellions against the state and the resistance of enslaved people.

Required content · 4L

Learning objective.

  • 4L. Explain the effects of the development of state power from 1450 to 1750.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.III.iii. State expansion and centralization led to resistance from an array of social, political, and economic groups on a local level.
  • 5.3.III.C. Enslaved persons challenged existing authorities in the Americas through organized resistance.

Why resistance?

Centralizing states imposed taxes, laws, armies, and religions on people who had long governed themselves. Local nobles lost power, peasants lost income to taxes, and religious minorities were pressed to conform. The more a state tried to reach into local life, the more it provoked those who stood to lose. Resistance took many forms, from tax evasion and petitions to armed revolt.

Local resistance: examples

The CED lists several.

  • Pueblo Revolt (1680). The Pueblo peoples of New Mexico, under a leader named Pope (Popay), rose against Spanish rule. Spanish colonists and priests had forced labor, taxed crops, and suppressed Pueblo religion. The revolt drove the Spanish out of the region for about twelve years, until they returned in 1692.
  • The Fronde (1648 to 1653). In France, nobles and the courts of Paris rebelled against the growing power of the crown and the taxes imposed to pay for wars. The young king Louis XIV, who later centralized rule at Versailles, was marked by this experience, and the rebellion failed.
  • Cossack revolts. In Russia and Ukraine, Cossacks (free frontier warriors) resisted the tsar's control, as in the revolt led by Stenka Razin in 1670 to 1671, which drew peasants angered by serfdom and taxes. It was defeated.
  • Maratha conflict with the Mughals. In western India, the Marathas under Shivaji built a Hindu kingdom in the late 1600s, using guerrilla warfare to resist Aurangzeb's efforts to conquer the Deccan. Mughal wars against them drained the empire (Lesson 3.1b).
  • Ana Nzinga's resistance. Nzinga, ruler of Ndongo and later Matamba in what is now Angola, fought the Portuguese for decades in the 1600s, using diplomacy, alliances with the Dutch, and war to resist Portuguese slave raiding and control. She died in 1663, after forty years of resistance.
  • Metacom's War (King Philip's War, 1675 to 1676). In New England, Wampanoag leader Metacom led an alliance of Native peoples against colonists who were taking land and imposing laws. The war was extremely costly to both sides and ended with the defeat of the Native alliance.

Resistance of enslaved people

The CED says that enslaved persons challenged existing authorities in the Americas through organized resistance. Forms included work slowdowns, sabotage, escape, and revolt. The CED gives two examples.

  • Maroon societies. Maroons were communities of people who escaped slavery and set up free settlements, often in remote forests or mountains. They existed in the Caribbean and Brazil. The largest in Brazil was Palmares, which lasted for most of the 1600s and held thousands of people before Portuguese forces destroyed it in 1694. In Jamaica and Suriname, Maroons forced colonial governments to sign treaties recognizing their freedom.
  • Resistance in North America. Enslaved people in the British colonies also rebelled, as in the 1739 Stono Rebellion in South Carolina, in which dozens of enslaved people tried to reach Spanish Florida, where they had been promised freedom. The revolt was crushed, and colonial law grew harsher.

Results

Most of these resistance movements were defeated, but they changed state policy. The Pueblo Revolt led the Spanish to treat the Pueblo more carefully after they returned. The Fronde convinced French kings to build a stronger royal bureaucracy. Slave revolts and Maroon communities led to harsher slave codes but also to treaties and, in some places, to freedom. Resistance shows that centralization was never uncontested and that subjects often had their own ideas about how they should be governed.

Description of: a Pueblo leader's testimony

Description of testimony by Pueblo captives taken by Spanish officials after the revolt of 1680, recorded in Spanish documents of 1681. This is a description, not a quotation.

A Pueblo man questioned by the Spanish said that the leaders had urged people to break with the Spanish and their religion, to burn churches and religious images, and to return to the old ways. He said they claimed their ancestral spirits would help them if they did.

Sourcing (HIPP). The testimony was recorded by Spanish officials from a captive under interrogation, so the point of view is Pueblo, but filtered through Spanish questioning, and the witness may have said what the interrogators wanted to hear. The purpose of the record was to understand the revolt, which means it was gathered by those who wanted to prevent another one. The audience was Spanish authorities. The account is useful for how the revolt was explained, but should be read as shaped by the circumstances of interrogation.

Source analysis · Religion and resistance

Claim. The Pueblo Revolt was partly a defense of Pueblo religion.

Evidence. A captive said the leaders urged people to burn churches and religious images and to return to the old ways.

Reasoning. A call to destroy Christian symbols and restore ancestral practice shows that religion was central to the revolt, which agrees with other evidence that the Spanish had suppressed Pueblo ceremonies. A limit is that a prisoner under Spanish interrogation may have told his questioners what they wanted to hear.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one reason state centralization led to resistance.

Model. Centralizing states raised taxes and tried to control local religion and law, which threatened local leaders and ordinary people. For example, French nobles and courts rebelled in the Fronde against royal taxes and growing royal power, and the Pueblo rose against Spanish forced labor and suppression of their religion.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 4L asks for effects of the development of state power. Know at least three examples of local resistance (Pueblo Revolt, Fronde, Cossack revolts, Maratha, Nzinga, Metacom) and the Maroon societies. Explain why state expansion caused resistance and what the result was.

Practice
  1. What was the Pueblo Revolt?
    Show answer

    A 1680 uprising by Pueblo peoples of New Mexico against Spanish rule and religion that drove the Spanish out for about twelve years.

  2. What was the Fronde?
    Show answer

    A rebellion of French nobles and courts from 1648 to 1653 against royal taxes and growing royal power, which failed.

  3. Who was Nzinga?
    Show answer

    The ruler of Ndongo and Matamba who resisted Portuguese slave raiding and control for decades in the 1600s.

  4. What was a Maroon society?
    Show answer

    A community of people who escaped slavery and built free settlements, such as Palmares in Brazil.

  5. Name one result of resistance by enslaved people.
    Show answer

    Harsher slave codes in many places, but also treaties recognizing freedom for some Maroon communities, as in Jamaica and Suriname.

  6. Why must testimony under interrogation be read carefully?
    Show answer

    The witness may have said what the interrogators wanted to hear, so the account is shaped by the circumstances of the questioning.

Lesson 4.9 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.7

Changing social hierarchies, 1450 to 1750

Empires and global trade created new elites and changed how societies ranked people. The CED asks how social categories, roles, and practices have been maintained or have changed over time. This lesson covers how states treated religious and ethnic groups, how new elites formed, and how old elites fared under stronger rulers.

Required content · 4M

Learning objective.

  • 4M. Explain how social categories, roles, and practices have been maintained or have changed over time.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.I.B. Many states, such as the Mughal and Ottoman empires, adopted practices to accommodate the ethnic and religious diversity of their subjects or to utilize the economic, political, and military contributions of different ethnic or religious groups. In other cases, states suppressed diversity or limited certain groups’ roles in society, politics, or the economy.
  • 4.2.III.A. Imperial conquests and widening global economic opportunities contributed to the formation of new political and economic elites, including in China with the transition to the Qing Dynasty and in the Americas with the rise of the Casta system.
  • 4.2.III.B. The power of existing political and economic elites fluctuated as the elites confronted new challenges to their ability to affect the policies of the increasingly powerful monarchs and leaders.

How states treated diverse groups

The CED says that many states, such as the Mughal and Ottoman empires, adopted practices to accommodate the ethnic and religious diversity of their subjects or to utilize the economic, political, and military contributions of different ethnic or religious groups. In other cases, states suppressed diversity or limited certain groups' roles in society, politics, or the economy. It gives examples.

  • Expulsion of Jews from Spain and Portugal. In 1492 Spain's rulers ordered Jews to convert or leave, and Portugal followed in 1497. Many Jews moved to the Ottoman Empire and North Africa, where they were accepted, and some converted and faced suspicion and the Inquisition.
  • Acceptance of Jews in the Ottoman Empire. Ottoman sultans welcomed the exiles and used the skills of Jewish merchants, doctors, and printers.
  • Restrictive policies against Han Chinese in Qing China. After the Manchu conquest, the Qing required Han men to wear the Manchu hairstyle (the queue), reserved top posts for Manchus, and kept Manchu banner garrisons separate. The Qing also banned marriage between Manchus and Han in principle.
  • Varying status of women in the Ottoman Empire. Under Islamic law, Muslim women could own property, inherit, and go to court, which some used to protect their wealth. Elite palace women, such as the sultan's mother, sometimes held great political influence, and village women worked in the fields. Status varied by class and religion.

New elites

The CED says that imperial conquests and widening global economic opportunities contributed to the formation of new political and economic elites, including in China with the transition to the Qing and in the Americas with the rise of the casta system.

  • Casta system. In Spanish America, society was ranked by ancestry. At the top stood peninsulares, people born in Spain, then criollos (Creoles), people of Spanish descent born in the Americas, then groups of mixed ancestry such as mestizos (European and Indigenous) and mulattoes (European and African), then Indigenous people, and then enslaved Africans. Names for dozens of mixtures were recorded, and the ranking affected taxes, jobs, and legal rights. In practice, wealth and local conditions could change a person's standing.
  • Qing China. The Manchu rulers and their allies became a new ruling elite, and a class of merchants grew rich.
  • Merchants. Everywhere, merchants profited from trade, and in places such as the Netherlands and England, they gained political influence.

Existing elites and monarchs

The CED notes that the power of existing political and economic elites fluctuated as the elites confronted new challenges to their ability to affect the policies of the increasingly powerful monarchs and leaders. Examples:

  • Ottoman timars. The sultan granted officers timars, rights to collect taxes from lands, in return for military service. Over time, as armies shifted to paid soldiers with guns, the timar system declined and local notables gained power.
  • Russian boyars. Russia's great nobles, the boyars, lost power to the tsars. Ivan IV attacked them, and Peter the Great later organized nobles into a service ranking.
  • European nobility. Nobles in France lost political power as kings centralized, though they kept social privileges, while in England they shared power with Parliament.

The pattern is that strong rulers wanted elites to serve them and not to rival them. Some elites accepted this in exchange for status and wealth. Others resisted, as in the Fronde (Lesson 4.6).

Continuity

Many hierarchies persisted. Men dominated most public roles, nobles and landholders kept great wealth, and religion and ancestry still shaped status. The new elements were the growing role of race in labor systems and the opportunities for merchants in the new trade.

Description of: a casta painting

Description of a type of painting made in eighteenth-century Mexico, called pinturas de castas. This is a description of a genre, not a quotation.

Casta paintings are sets of pictures, often sixteen, that show a man and woman of different ancestries with their child, such as Spanish and Indigenous parents with a mestizo child. Each scene is labeled with the name of the mixture and shows the family's clothing, home, and occupation.

Sourcing (HIPP). Painters, usually in Mexico City, made the paintings for wealthy colonial and European buyers, so the point of view is that of the colonial elite. The purpose may have been to catalog the colony's peoples, to show that the elite ordered society, and to please collectors interested in New World customs. The audience was elite and European. Because they present a neat system, the paintings may overstate how rigid the classification was in daily life.

Source analysis · A system on canvas

Claim. Colonial elites in Spanish America viewed their society as ranked by ancestry.

Evidence. Casta paintings labeled families by the mixture of the parents and often showed different clothing and homes for different groups.

Reasoning. The labels and visual differences show that people were sorted by ancestry and that the elite wanted to catalog the sorting. A limit is that the paintings were made for elite buyers and present a tidy system, whereas actual social standing could change with wealth, location, and individual choices.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way social hierarchies changed and one way they continued.

Model. One change was the casta system in Spanish America, a new hierarchy based on ancestry that emerged from conquest and the mixing of Europeans, Indigenous peoples, and Africans. One continuity was that landowning nobles, such as the European nobility and Ottoman officers, kept their wealth and status even as monarchs gained power, though many lost political independence.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 4M asks how social categories, roles, and practices were maintained or changed. Use specifics: expulsion of Jews from Spain and Portugal versus acceptance in the Ottoman Empire; Qing restrictions on Han; the casta system; Ottoman women; and what happened to timars, boyars, and nobles.

Practice
  1. What happened to Jews in Spain in 1492?
    Show answer

    They were ordered to convert or leave, and many went to the Ottoman Empire and North Africa.

  2. What was the casta system?
    Show answer

    A social ranking in Spanish America based on ancestry, with peninsulares at the top, then criollos, mixed groups such as mestizos and mulattoes, Indigenous people, and enslaved Africans.

  3. How did the Qing treat Han Chinese men?
    Show answer

    They required them to wear the Manchu queue hairstyle and reserved top positions for Manchus.

  4. What were timars?
    Show answer

    Grants of the right to collect taxes from land that the Ottoman sultan gave to cavalry officers in exchange for military service.

  5. How did strong rulers treat nobles?
    Show answer

    They tried to make nobles serve the state rather than rival it, reducing their independent power, though nobles often kept wealth and status.

  6. Why must historians be careful with casta paintings?
    Show answer

    They were made for elite buyers and show a neat system, so they may overstate how rigid and clear the classification was in daily life.

Lesson 4.10 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.8

Continuity and change from 1450 to 1750

This lesson practices continuity and change over time, the reasoning skill attached to this topic. The CED question is: how did economic developments from 1450 to 1750 affect social structures over time? The exam asks you to say what stayed the same, what changed, and how much. A strong answer does not simply say "everything changed." It identifies specific continuities and specific changes and judges their relative importance.

Required content · 4N

Learning objective.

  • 4N. Explain how economic developments from 1450 to 1750 affected social structures over time.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.II.A. The developments included the production of new tools, innovations in ship designs, and an improved understanding of regional wind and currents patterns, all of which made transoceanic travel and trade possible.
  • 4.2.II. The demand for labor intensified as a result of the growing global demand for raw materials and finished products. Traditional peasant agriculture increased and changed in nature, plantations expanded, and the Atlantic slave trade developed and intensified.
  • 4.3.III.ii. Economic disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states.

How to analyze continuity and change

  1. Choose a baseline. Describe the situation at the start of the period (here, about 1450).
  2. Identify changes. Name specific developments that altered the situation, with dates and examples.
  3. Identify continuities. Name what persisted despite the changes.
  4. Judge the extent. Decide which dominated and why, using words such as "primarily," "to a limited extent," or "although."

The baseline in 1450

In 1450 most people were peasants who farmed. Trade was regional, with long-distance networks (Unit 2) carrying mostly luxuries. Slavery existed but was local or regional in scale. Empires such as the Ming and the Ottomans were growing, but no ocean-crossing empires existed, and the Eastern and Western Hemispheres were unconnected.

Economic changes

  • A global trade network. New ocean routes linked all inhabited continents. Silver, sugar, and spices moved among them. Joint-stock companies and mercantilist policy were new organizing tools (Lesson 4.5a).
  • Demand for labor. The CED says that the demand for labor intensified as a result of the growing global demand for raw materials and finished products. Traditional peasant agriculture increased and changed in nature, plantations expanded, and the Atlantic slave trade developed and intensified.
  • Technological change. Improved ships, navigation, and knowledge of winds supported the growth of trade (Lesson 4.1).
  • State rivalry. The CED notes that economic disputes led to rivalries and conflict between states, as states competed for colonies and markets.

Social changes

  • New elites and hierarchies. Merchants gained wealth in many places, and the casta system and race-based slavery appeared in the Americas (Lesson 4.7).
  • Forced migration. About 12 million Africans were shipped across the Atlantic, which changed African and American societies.
  • Cultural mixing. The Atlantic and Indian Ocean networks produced mixed populations and religions (Lesson 4.5b).
  • Population shifts. Disease devastated the Americas, while American crops supported growth in Afro-Eurasia (Lesson 4.3).

Continuities

  • Agriculture. Most people still lived by farming. The CED notes that peasant and artisan labor continued and intensified.
  • Existing trade networks. The Indian Ocean network continued to flourish with Asian merchants.
  • Patriarchy and hierarchy. Men still dominated, and nobles and landholders kept much of their wealth.
  • Coerced labor. Forced labor was not new, since it extended earlier systems such as the mit'a and African household slavery, though on a larger scale.

Judging extent

An argument might hold that the period brought deep change in the scale and character of exchange and coerced labor, but less change in the daily lives of most farmers. Evidence for change is the Atlantic system and silver trade. Evidence for continuity is that peasants and artisans remained the majority. Notice that this judgment depends on whose experience is described. For an enslaved African or an Indigenous American, change was enormous. For a farmer in China or India, much remained familiar, though silver and cash crops reached them too.

Description of: the Potosi silver mountain

Description of Spanish accounts of the silver mines of Potosi, such as that of Pedro Cieza de Leon in the 1540s. This is a description, not a quotation.

Spanish observers wrote that after the discovery of the Rich Mountain in 1545, a mining town grew rapidly, with thousands of Indigenous workers, many drafted under the mit'a, and that the mines produced vast quantities of silver, which was sent to Spain and traded to Asia.

Sourcing (HIPP). Spanish writers, who were officials, soldiers, and priests, wrote about the mines in reports and chronicles, so their point of view is that of the colonial elite. The purpose was to describe the colony's wealth and to inform the crown. The audience was Spanish officials and readers. Because they wrote as Europeans interested in wealth, they said less about the lives and deaths of the workers, though other sources, including complaints by priests, show how harsh the conditions were.

Source analysis · Change at Potosi

Claim. Silver mining at Potosi was a major economic change that depended on coerced labor.

Evidence. Spanish observers described a rapidly growing mining town, thousands of Indigenous workers drafted under the mit'a, and large silver shipments to Spain and Asia.

Reasoning. A new town built around exports of silver, using an adapted Inca labor draft, shows both economic transformation and continuity of coerced labor. A limit is that Spanish officials focused on wealth and said little about the workers' suffering, so other sources are needed to judge its human cost.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in labor systems from 1450 to 1750.

Model. One continuity was that forced labor drafts continued, since the Spanish kept the Inca mit'a for mining at Potosi. One change was that the Atlantic slave trade made chattel slavery the main labor system on plantations on a huge scale, tied to global markets and to race, which was different from household slavery in Africa.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 4N asks how economic developments affected social structures. In an essay, state a baseline, name specific changes and continuities, and judge the extent. Do not claim that everything changed. Use the contrast between the experience of different groups, such as enslaved Africans, Indigenous Americans, merchants, and peasants.

Practice
  1. What are the steps in analyzing continuity and change?
    Show answer

    Choose a baseline, identify changes, identify continuities, and judge the extent of each.

  2. Name one major economic change from 1450 to 1750.
    Show answer

    The creation of a global trade network, the growth of plantations and the Atlantic slave trade, or the rise of joint-stock companies and mercantilist policy.

  3. Name one continuity from 1450 to 1750.
    Show answer

    Most people were still farmers, the Indian Ocean network continued, men dominated, and forced labor drafts persisted.

  4. How did the experience of change differ among groups?
    Show answer

    For enslaved Africans and Indigenous Americans the change was enormous, while farmers in China or India saw less change in daily life.

  5. Why is "everything changed" a weak thesis?
    Show answer

    It ignores continuities and does not judge extent, so it gives no balanced argument.

  6. Why is Spanish writing about Potosi limited as evidence?
    Show answer

    The writers were officials focused on wealth and said little about the workers' suffering.

Unit 4 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 4 review: Transoceanic Interconnections, c. 1450–c. 1750

Ten questions on maritime technology, the Columbian Exchange, silver and the first global economy, coerced labor systems, and the social consequences of empire, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Which combination of developments most directly enabled European transoceanic voyaging after 1450?

    Correct. The compass came from China and the astrolabe from the Islamic world; combined with the lateen sail, the caravel, and guns mounted on ships, they made long ocean voyages survivable and armed.

    Steam and iron hulls belong to the nineteenth century, hundreds of years after the voyages in question.

    No usable Atlantic charts survived from Norse voyages, and Columbus sailed with a badly mistaken estimate of the earth's size.

    Gunpowder originated in China and was used across Eurasia. What was distinctive was mounting effective artillery on ocean-going ships.

  2. Description of: a table of estimated population figures for central Mexico, compiled by modern demographic historians from tribute records and colonial censuses.

    The table gives a pre-contact figure in the range of several million, a figure roughly a third of that within fifty years of contact, and a figure of about one-tenth the original within a century, before a slow recovery begins. A footnote records wide disagreement among scholars about the pre-contact baseline.

    Which conclusion is best supported by this data?

    Correct. Every estimate shows collapse on an enormous scale, and the footnoted disagreement concerns the baseline rather than whether the collapse happened.

    Demographic data alone cannot establish cause, and epidemic disease is the explanation historians give for mortality on this scale.

    Disagreement over the starting figure does not erase a consistent pattern of decline across all estimates.

    The table shows recovery beginning only after a century of decline, from a point around one-tenth the original.

  3. The most significant long-term global consequence of the Columbian Exchange was

    Wheat mattered to colonists but altered far fewer lives than the crops moving in the other direction.

    Correct. Potatoes and maize grew where existing staples would not and fed more people per acre, contributing to sustained population growth in China, Europe, and Africa.

    Horses transformed Plains societies in North America but did not replace shipping, which carried the trade.

    Christianity spread substantially in the Americas but did not unify world religions, and most of Asia remained unaffected.

  4. Description of: a graph of estimated annual silver production at Potosí and Japanese mines, with a second line for silver arriving at Chinese ports, 1550–1700.

    Both production lines rise steeply after 1570 and remain high for several decades. The import line for China tracks them closely. A note marks the Ming decision requiring tax payments in silver, and a second note marks a sharp fall in all three lines in the 1640s.

    The relationship shown between the lines best supports which conclusion?

    Correct. A fiscal decision in Beijing set a price that made mining profitable on the other side of the world, which is what a genuinely global market means.

    Spain supplied silver but did not direct Chinese policy; the Ming tax decision drove the demand that made the trade work.

    The import line is central to the graph precisely because China's domestic production could not meet its demand.

    The noted tax requirement and the coinciding 1640s collapse both point to a strong connection with state finance.

  5. The encomienda and the colonial mit'a in Spanish America are best understood as

    Neither involved negotiation or wages in any meaningful sense; both compelled labor under colonial authority.

    Correct. The colonial mit'a took an Inca rotational labor obligation and redirected it to silver mining, while the encomienda assigned communities to Spaniards entitled to their labor.

    Both differed from chattel slavery: workers were not owned as property and were nominally free subjects of the crown, though the coercion was severe.

    The encomienda was a grant of labor rights over people, and neither system conveyed secure title to indigenous communities.

  6. The shift toward enslaved African labor on American plantations is best explained by

    Correct. Sugar demanded continuous heavy labor, and with indigenous populations devastated by disease, planters turned to an Atlantic trade in people that existing commercial networks could supply.

    Resistance was constant (sabotage, flight, maroon communities, and revolt), so the premise of the option is false.

    The trade was violent capture and sale, not voluntary migration driven by land shortage.

    Indigenous coerced labor continued in mining and agriculture throughout the colonial period.

  7. The Spanish casta system in colonial Latin America functioned primarily to

    The system was explicitly unequal, sorting people into ranked categories with different rights.

    Correct. Descent determined what taxes a person owed, what offices they could hold, and what legal standing they had, with peninsulares at the top and enslaved people at the bottom.

    It responded to mixing that had already occurred by classifying its products, rather than promoting it.

    Plantation labor was organized through slavery and estate management; the casta system was a legal and social hierarchy.

  8. Portuguese activity in the Indian Ocean during the sixteenth century is best characterized as

    The Portuguese took coastal strongpoints such as Goa and Malacca; they could not conquer the Mughal or Ottoman states.

    Correct. Naval artillery let them hold ports and demand that ships buy passes, inserting themselves into a network they had neither built nor could replace.

    The arrangement was imposed by naval force against resistance, not agreed on local terms.

    Gujarati, Arab, Chinese, and other merchants continued trading throughout; the Portuguese were one armed participant among many.

  9. A defining feature of the joint-stock companies chartered by European states in this period was that they

    Correct. Spreading risk across investors made costly long voyages financeable, and charters delegated sovereign powers that let companies act like states abroad.

    Their distinguishing feature was private shareholding under a royal charter rather than direct royal ownership.

    The Dutch and English companies maintained fleets, forts, and armies as a matter of course.

    Profits went to shareholders in proportion to their holdings, not to the population.

  10. Which statement best captures the global economic position of Asia in 1750?

    Indian textiles and Chinese porcelain and tea dominated demand, while European manufactures found little market in Asia before industrialization.

    Correct. Europeans had strong positions at sea and in the Americas, but in Asia they were customers who settled their accounts with silver.

    The Qing and Mughal empires were still major powers in 1750; large-scale colonization of Asia came later.

    The Atlantic grew enormously in importance, but Asian trade remained central and drew the silver the Atlantic produced.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE effect of the Columbian Exchange on a region outside the Americas.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the silver trade connected distant economies in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way labor systems changed in the Americas between 1450 and 1750.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: potatoes supporting population growth in Europe; maize and sweet potatoes in China allowing cultivation of marginal land; cassava and maize in Africa; tobacco and cacao entering global consumption. Must name crop and effect.
    • (b) Accept: Ming and Qing tax requirements in silver creating demand that drew American and Japanese output; the Manila galleons linking Acapulco to Asia; silver funding European purchases of Asian goods. Must show the connection across regions.
    • (c) Accept: encomienda and colonial mit'a giving way to enslaved African labor as indigenous populations collapsed; the growth of plantation slavery with sugar; indentured servitude in North America. Must describe change over time.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Maize and sweet potatoes from the Americas could be grown on hill slopes and sandy soils where rice and wheat would not thrive, and their adoption in China allowed cultivation of land that had previously fed no one. This supported a large and sustained rise in Chinese population from the seventeenth century onward.

    (b) When the Ming required taxes to be paid in silver, Chinese demand raised the metal's value in China well above its value elsewhere. That price difference made it profitable to mine silver at Potosí in the Andes and ship it across the Pacific from Acapulco to Manila, so a tax decision in Beijing set the pace of mining on another continent.

    (c) Early Spanish colonization relied on indigenous labor through the encomienda and a colonial version of the Inca mit'a. As epidemic disease destroyed indigenous populations and sugar plantations spread through the Caribbean and Brazil, planters turned to enslaved Africans, and by 1750 plantation slavery was the dominant labor system of the American tropics.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE technological development that made transoceanic voyaging possible.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way European involvement in the Indian Ocean differed from European activity in the Americas.
    3. Briefly explain ONE form of resistance to coerced labor in this period.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the magnetic compass; the astrolabe; the lateen sail; the caravel and later ocean-going designs; shipboard cannon; accumulated knowledge of Atlantic wind systems. Must identify the development.
    • (b) Accept: in the Indian Ocean Europeans seized ports and taxed existing trade without conquering territory, while in the Americas they conquered and settled; disease gave them an advantage in the Americas that did not exist in Asia; Asian states remained strong enough to set terms. Must draw the contrast.
    • (c) Accept: maroon communities such as Palmares; shipboard revolt; sabotage, work slowdowns, and flight; preservation of religious and cultural practice; indigenous uprisings such as the Pueblo Revolt. Must identify the form and connect it to resistance.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The lateen sail, a triangular sail adopted from Indian Ocean and Mediterranean shipping, allowed a vessel to sail at an angle into the wind rather than only before it. Combined with the square sails that gave speed downwind, it made it possible to plan a return voyage across an ocean rather than depend entirely on favorable winds.

    (b) In the Americas the Spanish and Portuguese conquered territory and built colonies over populations devastated by disease. In the Indian Ocean the Portuguese could seize fortified ports such as Goa and Malacca and use naval artillery to demand payments from shipping, but they faced healthy populations and powerful states, so they inserted themselves into an existing trade network rather than replacing it.

    (c) Enslaved people who escaped plantations formed maroon communities in remote terrain, the largest of which, Palmares in Brazil, survived for most of a century and defended itself against repeated Portuguese expeditions. Its existence forced colonial authorities to devote military resources to a problem they could not eliminate.

Lesson 5.1 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.1

The Enlightenment and its reach

In the 1600s and 1700s, European thinkers began to apply reason and observation to society, government, and religion. This movement, the Enlightenment, helped inspire revolutions and reform movements around the world. The CED asks for the intellectual and ideological context in which revolutions swept the Atlantic world and for how the Enlightenment affected societies.

Required content · 5A, 5B

Learning objectives.

  • 5A. Explain the intellectual and ideological context in which revolutions swept the Atlantic world from 1750 to 1900.
  • 5B. Explain how the Enlightenment affected societies over time.

Historical developments.

  • 5.3.I.A. Enlightenment philosophies applied new ways of understanding and empiricist approaches to both the natural world and human relationships; they also reexamined the role that religion played in public life and emphasized the importance of reason. Philosophers developed new political ideas about the individual, natural rights, and the social contract.
  • 5.3.I. The rise and diffusion of Enlightenment thought that questioned established traditions in all areas of life often preceded revolutions and rebellions against existing governments.
  • 5.3.II.i. Nationalism also became a major force shaping the historical development of states and empires.
  • 5.3.I.C. Enlightenment ideas and religious ideals influenced various reform movements. These reform movements contributed to the expansion of rights, as seen in expanded suffrage, the abolition of slavery, and the end of serfdom.
  • 5.3.IV.B. Demands for women’s suffrage and an emergent feminism challenged political and gender hierarchies.

Core ideas

The CED says that Enlightenment philosophies applied new ways of understanding and empiricist approaches to both the natural world and human relationships; they also reexamined the role that religion played in public life and emphasized the importance of reason. Philosophers developed new political ideas about the individual, natural rights, and the social contract. The ideas built on the Scientific Revolution, in which Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton had shown that nature followed discoverable laws. If reason could explain the heavens, thinkers asked, could it also improve government and society?

  • John Locke (1632 to 1704), an Englishman, argued that people have natural rights to life, liberty, and property, that governments exist to protect them, and that when a government violates them, the people may replace it.
  • Montesquieu (1689 to 1755), a Frenchman, argued that power should be divided among branches of government, such as a legislature, an executive, and courts, so that none could become tyrannical.
  • Voltaire (1694 to 1778) defended religious toleration and free speech and criticized the Church and absolute monarchy.
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712 to 1778) argued in The Social Contract that legitimate government rests on the general will of the people, an agreement among free people, and that "man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains."
  • Immanuel Kant (1724 to 1804) urged people to "dare to know" and to think for themselves rather than rely on authority.
  • Adam Smith (1723 to 1790) argued for free markets (Lesson 5.7).

The key concepts are natural rights (rights people have by nature, not by the grant of a ruler), the social contract (the idea that government comes from an agreement among the governed), and popular sovereignty (the idea that the people are the source of political authority).

How the ideas spread

Ideas moved through books, newspapers, coffeehouses, salons, and secret societies. They spread outward from Europe along trade and empire routes to the Americas, and later to Asia and Africa. The CED notes that the rise and diffusion of Enlightenment thought that questioned established traditions in all areas of life often preceded revolutions and rebellions against existing governments. Leaders of revolutions in the Americas and France knew these writers and drew on them (Lesson 5.2a).

Effects: reform movements and rights

The CED says that Enlightenment ideas and religious ideals influenced various reform movements. These reform movements contributed to the expansion of rights, as seen in expanded suffrage, the abolition of slavery, and the end of serfdom.

  • Abolition. If all men have natural rights, slavery seemed indefensible. Abolitionists in Britain and the United States, many of them motivated by religion as well as reason, campaigned against the slave trade and slavery. Britain ended its slave trade in 1807 and slavery in its empire in 1833, and slave revolts, notably in Haiti, played a part.
  • Serfdom. Rulers such as Joseph II of Austria ended serfdom in parts of the Habsburg lands, and Russia ended it in 1861.
  • Suffrage. Political rights slowly expanded to more men in the 1800s.
  • Women's rights. The CED says that demands for women's suffrage and an emergent feminism challenged political and gender hierarchies. Mary Wollstonecraft published A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), arguing that women's apparent inferiority came from poor education. Olympe de Gouges wrote the Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen (1791) in France, and she was executed during the Terror. In 1848, a convention at Seneca Falls, New York, organized by Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Lucretia Mott, issued a declaration demanding women's equality, including the vote.

Limits

Many Enlightenment thinkers did not extend rights equally. Some held racial prejudices, and most did not support equality for women or the poor. The ideas could also be used to justify empire, as Europeans claimed to bring reason and progress to others (Lesson 6.1). Yet the principle that people have rights as human beings gave later movements a powerful argument.

Primary source · Wollstonecraft on women's power

Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792).

I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves.

Sourcing (HIPP). Wollstonecraft was an English writer who had followed the debates of the French Revolution, so her point of view is that of a radical thinker. Her purpose was to argue that women should be educated and treated as rational beings, and the audience was educated English readers, including men in power. She wrote in a society that denied women the vote and most legal rights, so her sentence shows how some Enlightenment thinkers applied the principle of natural rights to women.

Source analysis · Enlightenment ideas applied to gender

Claim. Wollstonecraft used Enlightenment ideas to argue for women's rights.

Evidence. She wrote that women should not have power over men but over themselves.

Reasoning. The sentence asks for self-government, which applies the Enlightenment idea of individual autonomy to women, and it does so without claiming dominance, which answered critics who feared women's equality. A limit is that she wrote for an educated English audience and focused on education and not the vote, so she represents one strand of early feminism.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of Enlightenment ideas on political life.

Model. Enlightenment ideas of natural rights and the social contract gave colonists and subjects a justification for challenging existing governments. Leaders of the American and French revolutions cited Locke and Rousseau when they argued that governments that violate rights can be replaced, which helped spark revolutions across the Atlantic world.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 5A and 5B ask for the context of revolutions and how the Enlightenment affected societies. Name thinkers and what each argued, define natural rights, social contract, and popular sovereignty, and link the ideas to reform movements (abolition, serfdom, suffrage, women's rights).

Practice
  1. Name two Enlightenment thinkers and one idea of each.
    Show answer

    Locke argued for natural rights and government by consent, Montesquieu for separation of powers, Voltaire for toleration, and Rousseau for the general will.

  2. What is the social contract?
    Show answer

    The idea that government comes from an agreement among the governed to protect their rights.

  3. How did the Scientific Revolution influence the Enlightenment?
    Show answer

    It showed that nature follows discoverable laws, which led thinkers to apply reason to society and government.

  4. Name two reform movements influenced by Enlightenment ideas.
    Show answer

    Abolition of slavery, the end of serfdom, expanded suffrage, and the women's rights movement.

  5. What did Olympe de Gouges demand?
    Show answer

    Equal rights for women in her Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen (1791).

  6. What was a limit of Enlightenment thinking?
    Show answer

    Many thinkers did not extend rights equally to women, the poor, or people of other races, and some used the ideas to justify empire.

Lesson 5.2 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.2

The American and French revolutions

The CED asks for causes and effects of the various revolutions in the period from 1750 to 1900. This lesson covers the first two, the American and French revolutions. The next two lessons cover the Haitian and Latin American revolutions and nationalism.

Required content · 5C

Learning objective.

  • 5C. Explain causes and effects of the various revolutions in the period from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.3.IV.A.i. Discontent with monarchist and imperial rule encouraged the development of systems of government and various ideologies, including democracy and 19th-century liberalism.
  • 5.3.III.B. Colonial subjects in the Americas led a series of rebellions inspired by democratic ideals. The American Revolution, and its successful establishment of a republic, the United States of America, was a model and inspiration for a number of the revolutions that followed. The American Revolution, the Haitian Revolution, and the Latin American independence movements facilitated the emergence of independent states in the Americas.
  • 5.3.I.B. The ideas of Enlightenment philosophers, as reflected in revolutionary documents, including the American Declaration of Independence during the American Revolution, the French “Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen” during the French Revolution, and Bolívar’s “Letter from Jamaica” on the eve of the Latin American revolutions, influenced resistance to existing political authority, often in pursuit of independence and democratic ideals.

The American Revolution

The CED says that colonial subjects in the Americas led a series of rebellions inspired by democratic ideals. Britain's thirteen colonies in North America had governed themselves in practice for a long time. After Britain won the Seven Years' War (1756 to 1763), it faced heavy debt and tried to tax the colonists and control them more tightly with measures such as the Stamp Act (1765) and tea duties. Colonists protested that they could not be taxed by a Parliament in which they had no representatives. Armed conflict began in 1775, and in 1776 the Continental Congress issued the Declaration of Independence, which drew on Locke's ideas of natural rights. With help from France, the colonies won, and in 1783 Britain recognized the United States. The CED says that the American Revolution's successful establishment of a republic, the United States of America, was a model and inspiration for a number of the revolutions that followed. Its limits were also clear. Slavery continued, women could not vote, and Native Americans were pushed off their lands.

The French Revolution

France in 1789 was an absolute monarchy with three social estates: the clergy, the nobility, and everyone else. The privileged first two estates paid few taxes, and the third paid most, with feudal dues on top. The state was nearly bankrupt from wars, including its costly support for the American Revolution, and bad harvests had pushed up the price of bread. The king, Louis XVI, called a meeting of the Estates General in 1789, and the Third Estate declared itself a National Assembly. On July 14, a Paris crowd stormed the Bastille. In August, the Assembly abolished feudal privileges and issued the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.

The revolution became more radical. The monarchy was abolished in 1792, and King Louis was executed in 1793. Under Maximilien Robespierre and the Committee of Public Safety, the Reign of Terror (1793 to 1794) executed tens of thousands of suspected enemies. Then a more moderate government, the Directory, took power, and in 1799 a general, Napoleon Bonaparte, seized control. He made himself emperor in 1804, spread revolutionary reforms, such as the Napoleonic Code that established legal equality for men, across Europe by conquest, and was defeated in 1815.

1776 American Declaration of Independence 1789 French Revolution begins 1791 Haitian Revolution begins 1804 Haiti independent 1810 Latin American independence wars begin 1821 Mexico independent 1824 Battle of Ayacucho 1848 Revolutions across Europe
Figure 5.1. A connected wave of revolutions around the Atlantic. Each drew on the language of rights, and each looked different in practice.

Ideas and documents

The CED says that the ideas of Enlightenment philosophers, as reflected in revolutionary documents, including the American Declaration of Independence during the American Revolution, the French "Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen" during the French Revolution, and Bolivar's "Letter from Jamaica" on the eve of the Latin American revolutions, influenced resistance to existing political authority, often in pursuit of independence and democratic ideals. Both documents state that people have natural rights, and both claim that government rests on the people's consent. The CED also says that discontent with monarchist and imperial rule encouraged the development of systems of government and various ideologies, including democracy and nineteenth-century liberalism, and the term liberalism names the belief in individual rights, representative government, and free markets.

Compare the two

Both revolutions cited natural rights and popular sovereignty and began as responses to royal taxation and debt. They differed in scale and result. The American Revolution was a colonial war for independence that kept much of the existing social order, while the French Revolution transformed French society, abolishing privileges and challenging the Church, and then moved through violence and a military dictatorship.

Primary source · The rights of men

United States Declaration of Independence (1776).

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Declaration was drafted mainly by Thomas Jefferson, a Virginia planter who owned enslaved people, and adopted by the Continental Congress. The point of view is that of colonial leaders in revolt against Britain. The purpose was to justify independence to the world and to rally support, especially from foreign powers such as France. The audience was the American public, the British, and other nations. The words say "all men," yet slavery continued, so the document states ideals more than it describes the new nation's practice.

Source analysis · Ideals and limits

Claim. The Declaration of Independence expressed the Enlightenment idea of natural rights.

Evidence. It says that all men are created equal and have unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

Reasoning. The language echoes Locke's idea that rights come from nature, not from kings, which supported the colonists' case for independence. A limit is that the author owned enslaved people, and the new nation kept slavery and denied women the vote, so the text states an ideal that was not applied to all.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the American and French revolutions.

Model. Both were inspired by Enlightenment ideas of natural rights and popular sovereignty, and both began with disputes over taxes and royal authority. A difference is that the American Revolution was mainly a war for independence from Britain that preserved most social structures, whereas the French Revolution overturned the old social order by abolishing noble privileges and the monarchy.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5C asks for causes and effects of revolutions. For each revolution, give causes (taxes and representation in America, debt and inequality in France), events, and effects. Use the CED's three documents as evidence of ideas, and be ready to compare outcomes.

Practice
  1. What was a cause of the American Revolution?
    Show answer

    Disputes over British taxes and control, as colonists objected to being taxed by a Parliament in which they had no representatives.

  2. What were the three estates in France?
    Show answer

    The clergy, the nobility, and everyone else, with the first two privileged and the third paying most taxes.

  3. What was the Reign of Terror?
    Show answer

    A period from 1793 to 1794 under Robespierre's Committee of Public Safety in which tens of thousands of suspected enemies were executed.

  4. What did Napoleon do?
    Show answer

    He seized power in 1799, became emperor in 1804, spread revolutionary reforms such as the Napoleonic Code by conquest, and was defeated in 1815.

  5. What is liberalism?
    Show answer

    The belief in individual rights, representative government, and free markets.

  6. Why is the Declaration of Independence limited as evidence of practice?
    Show answer

    It states ideals of equality, but the author owned enslaved people and the new nation kept slavery and excluded women, so it shows aims more than reality.

Lesson 5.3 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.2

The Haitian and Latin American revolutions

The wave of revolution that began in North America and France reached the Caribbean and Latin America. The CED says that the American Revolution, the Haitian Revolution, and the Latin American independence movements facilitated the emergence of independent states in the Americas. This lesson covers the second and third of these.

Required content · 5C

Learning objective.

  • 5C. Explain causes and effects of the various revolutions in the period from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.3.III.B. Colonial subjects in the Americas led a series of rebellions inspired by democratic ideals. The American Revolution, and its successful establishment of a republic, the United States of America, was a model and inspiration for a number of the revolutions that followed. The American Revolution, the Haitian Revolution, and the Latin American independence movements facilitated the emergence of independent states in the Americas.
  • 5.3.I.B. The ideas of Enlightenment philosophers, as reflected in revolutionary documents, including the American Declaration of Independence during the American Revolution, the French “Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen” during the French Revolution, and Bolívar’s “Letter from Jamaica” on the eve of the Latin American revolutions, influenced resistance to existing political authority, often in pursuit of independence and democratic ideals.

The Haitian Revolution

Saint-Domingue, the French colony on the western part of the island of Hispaniola, was the richest colony in the world in the 1780s. It produced a large share of the world's sugar and coffee, using the labor of about half a million enslaved Africans, who made up the great majority of the population. Free people of color, many of them wealthy, and white planters formed other groups, and the three clashed over rights.

When the French Revolution proclaimed that men were free and equal, the contradiction with slavery became impossible to ignore. In 1791 enslaved people rose in a massive revolt in the north. A former slave, Toussaint Louverture, emerged as a leader who built a disciplined army, defeated Spanish and British forces that had invaded, and in 1794 saw France's revolutionary government abolish slavery. Toussaint governed the colony until, in 1802, Napoleon sent a large army to restore French control and slavery. Toussaint was captured and died in a French prison in 1803. But the army was defeated, with yellow fever helping to destroy it, and in 1804 his successor Jean-Jacques Dessalines declared the independence of Haiti.

Haiti was the first state founded by a successful revolt of enslaved people, and the second independent republic in the Americas. Its meaning was enormous. It showed that the principle of natural rights applied to Black people, and it terrified slaveholders in the United States and the Caribbean. The new state paid a heavy price, since France demanded a huge indemnity in 1825 in return for recognition, and other powers refused to recognize Haiti for decades.

The Latin American independence movements

Spain and Portugal ruled Latin America in 1800 through a social order in which peninsulares (born in Spain) held the top offices and criollos (people of European descent born in the Americas) were excluded from the highest positions despite their wealth, while mestizos, Indigenous peoples, and enslaved Africans were lower in the hierarchy (Lesson 4.7). Criollos had grown resentful of Spanish control and trade restrictions, and Enlightenment ideas and the examples of the United States and France encouraged them.

The crisis came in 1808, when Napoleon invaded Spain and removed its king. Without a legitimate monarch, colonial leaders formed local governments and, over time, demanded independence. The wars took different forms.

  • Mexico. In 1810, a priest, Miguel Hidalgo, called on poor Indigenous and mestizo people to rise against Spanish rule. He was executed, but the revolt continued, and in 1821 Mexico became independent under conservative creole leaders.
  • South America. In the north, Simon Bolivar led armies that freed Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru, and in the south Jose de San Martin freed Argentina and Chile and helped liberate Peru. The decisive battle at Ayacucho in 1824 ended Spanish power on the mainland.
  • Brazil. The Portuguese royal family had fled to Brazil in 1807 to escape Napoleon, and when the king returned to Portugal, his son declared Brazilian independence in 1822, with far less fighting than in Spanish America.

Results

Independence did not bring equality. In most countries, creole elites replaced Spanish officials, while the poor, Indigenous peoples, and people of African descent gained little. Slavery was ended in some places soon after independence and in others, including Brazil, not until 1888. Bolivar's dream of a unified Spanish America failed as the region split into separate states, and economic dependence on Britain and later the United States grew. Even so, independent states replaced colonies across the hemisphere.

Description of: Bolivar's letter from Jamaica

Description of the "Letter from Jamaica" written by Simon Bolivar in 1815, one of the documents named in the CED. This is a description, not a quotation.

Writing from exile in Jamaica, Bolivar argued that Spain's rule over the Americas had been tyrannical and that Spanish Americans were a new people who were neither European nor Indigenous. He reviewed the prospects for the new republics and predicted which regions might form which kinds of government.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bolivar was a wealthy creole who had led a failed revolt and was in exile, so his point of view is that of a revolutionary seeking support. His purpose was to explain the cause of independence and to appeal for British help, and the audience was a British gentleman who had asked about the revolution, and through him foreign governments. Because he was making a case, the letter is better evidence of the ideals and arguments of the creole leaders than of the views of the poor and enslaved, whose conditions he said little about.

Source analysis · A creole perspective

Claim. Creole leaders such as Bolivar used Enlightenment ideas and grievances against Spain to justify independence.

Evidence. Bolivar described Spanish rule as tyrannical, called Spanish Americans a new people, and reviewed which governments the new republics might adopt.

Reasoning. Calling Spanish rule tyranny matches Enlightenment language about illegitimate government, and discussing new republics shows he drew on liberal ideas. A limit is that the letter represents a wealthy creole's view and speaks little about Indigenous and enslaved people, whose goals often differed.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause of the Haitian Revolution.

Model. One cause was the contradiction between the French Revolution's claims of liberty and equality and the brutal system of slavery in Saint-Domingue, where enslaved people made up most of the population. When the revolution declared rights for men, enslaved people and free people of color demanded them too, and the revolt that began in 1791 grew into a war for freedom.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5C again asks for causes and effects. For the Haitian Revolution, give the cause (slavery plus revolutionary ideals), key figures (Toussaint Louverture, Dessalines), and effects (first state founded by an enslaved people's revolt, fear among slaveholders, the indemnity). For Latin America, give the cause (creole grievances plus the invasion of Spain in 1808), leaders (Hidalgo, Bolivar, San Martin), and limits (creole elites replaced Spanish rulers).

Practice
  1. Why was Saint-Domingue important to France?
    Show answer

    It was the richest colony in the world, producing much of the world's sugar and coffee with enslaved labor.

  2. Who was Toussaint Louverture?
    Show answer

    A former slave who led the Haitian Revolution, built an army, and governed the colony until Napoleon's forces captured him in 1802.

  3. When did Haiti become independent and why was that significant?
    Show answer

    In 1804, as the first state founded by a successful revolt of enslaved people, which showed that natural rights applied to Black people and frightened slaveholders.

  4. What event in 1808 started Latin American independence movements?
    Show answer

    Napoleon's invasion of Spain, which removed the king and left colonial leaders without a legitimate monarch.

  5. Name two leaders of South American independence.
    Show answer

    Simon Bolivar and Jose de San Martin.

  6. How did independence change society in Latin America?
    Show answer

    Creole elites replaced Spanish officials, but the poor, Indigenous peoples, and people of African descent gained little, and slavery lasted in some places until later.

Lesson 5.4 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.2

Nationalism and new nations

Nationalism, the belief that people who share a language, culture, or history should form their own state and give it their primary loyalty, became one of the strongest forces of the nineteenth century. The CED says that nationalism became a major force shaping the historical development of states and empires. This lesson covers what nationalism is, how states encouraged it, and how it built and broke states.

Required content · 5C

Learning objective.

  • 5C. Explain causes and effects of the various revolutions in the period from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.3.II.ii. People around the world developed a new sense of commonality based on language, religion, social customs, and territory. This was sometimes harnessed by governments to foster a sense of unity.
  • 5.3.II.iii. Newly imagined national communities often linked this new national identity with borders of the state, and in some cases, nationalists challenged boundaries or sought unification of fragmented regions.

What nationalism is

Before the 1700s, most people's loyalty went to a local lord, a religion, or a dynasty. The CED says that people around the world developed a new sense of commonality based on language, religion, social customs, and territory. This was sometimes harnessed by governments to foster a sense of unity. Nationalism spread through schools, newspapers, flags, songs, and military service, which taught people to see themselves as members of a nation. The French Revolution and Napoleon's wars helped spread it, since French armies of citizens fought for the nation, and conquered peoples began to resist in the name of their own nations.

The CED adds that newly imagined national communities often linked this new national identity with borders of the state, and in some cases, nationalists challenged boundaries or sought unification of fragmented regions. Nationalism could therefore unite (bringing together people in fragmented regions) or divide (breaking up multiethnic empires).

Nationalism that unified: Italy and Germany

  • Italy. In 1815, Italy was divided into many states, some ruled by Austria. Nationalists, including Giuseppe Mazzini, Giuseppe Garibaldi, and the Piedmontese prime minister Count Cavour, worked to unify it. Cavour used diplomacy and war, Garibaldi's volunteers conquered southern Italy in 1860, and the Kingdom of Italy was proclaimed in 1861, with Rome added in 1870.
  • Germany. The German-speaking lands were divided into dozens of states. Prussia, under its minister Otto von Bismarck, defeated Denmark, Austria (1866), and France (1870 to 1871) in wars that drew the other German states into a union. The German Empire was proclaimed in January 1871 at Versailles, outside Paris.

Nationalism that divided: empires under strain

Multiethnic empires such as the Ottoman Empire and the Austrian (Habsburg) Empire faced nationalist demands from groups such as Greeks, Serbs, Bulgarians, Czechs, and Hungarians. Greece became independent of the Ottomans in the 1830s, and over the century other Balkan nationalisms produced new states such as Serbia and Bulgaria, which is why the region became unstable. Some Ottoman leaders responded with Ottomanism, the idea that all Ottoman subjects, whatever their religion, should share a common Ottoman identity. It did not succeed in holding the empire together.

Nationalism in colonized lands

Nationalist ideas also spread among colonized peoples, and the CED lists examples.

  • Propaganda Movement in the Philippines. Educated Filipinos, including Jose Rizal, whose novel Noli Me Tangere (1887) criticized Spanish friars and colonial abuses, demanded reforms in the 1880s and 1890s. Rizal was executed in 1896, and the revolution that followed made him a hero.
  • Maori nationalism and the New Zealand wars. Maori leaders resisted British settlement and land seizure in a series of wars in the 1860s and created a Maori king movement to unite tribes.
  • Puerto Rico. The poet Lola Rodriguez de Tio wrote works that demanded independence from Spain and wrote the revolutionary lyrics for a song that became known as the Puerto Rican national song.

Limits and costs

Nationalism could also be exclusionary. Defining "the nation" meant deciding who did not belong, and minorities sometimes faced pressure or violence. In mixed regions, such as the Balkans, borders could not match every nationality. These tensions produced conflicts that Unit 7 returns to.

Description of: a nationalist novel

Description of Noli Me Tangere ("Touch Me Not"), a novel by Jose Rizal published in Berlin in 1887. This is a description, not a quotation.

The novel follows a young Filipino returning from Europe who finds corruption, abuse of power by Spanish friars, and injustice in his homeland. It portrays the Spanish colonial order as cruel and stifling and shows a society of Filipinos, Spaniards, and mixed families.

Sourcing (HIPP). Rizal was a Filipino doctor and writer educated in Spain and Europe, so his point of view is that of an educated reformer. His purpose was to expose colonial abuses and arouse Filipino and Spanish readers, and his audience was educated Filipinos and Spaniards. Because he was writing fiction with a message, the details are shaped for effect, but the novel is strong evidence of how educated Filipinos came to see themselves as a nation with rights.

Source analysis · Nationalism in a colony

Claim. Educated Filipinos developed a national consciousness in the late nineteenth century.

Evidence. Rizal's novel criticized the Spanish friars and colonial order and described a Filipino society mistreated by its rulers.

Reasoning. Writing a novel to expose abuses and to portray the Philippines as one society suggests an effort to build a shared identity and a case for reform. A limit is that it is a work of fiction written by an educated man for a particular audience, so it does not show how most Filipinos, who were poor farmers, thought.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way nationalism unified states and one way it divided them.

Model. Nationalism helped unify Germany, as Prussia under Bismarck won wars that drew the German-speaking states into a single empire in 1871. It divided multiethnic empires such as the Ottoman Empire, where Greeks, Serbs, and Bulgarians sought independent nations, which produced new Balkan states and weakened the empire.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5C asks for causes and effects of revolutions including nationalist movements. Define nationalism, and give examples of unification (Italy, Germany), division (Balkans, Ottoman and Habsburg lands), and colonial nationalism (Philippines, New Zealand, Puerto Rico). Note how governments used nationalism to build unity.

Practice
  1. What is nationalism?
    Show answer

    The belief that people who share a language, culture, or history should form their own state and give it their loyalty.

  2. How did Italy become unified?
    Show answer

    Through the efforts of Mazzini, Garibaldi, and Cavour, using diplomacy and war, and the Kingdom of Italy was proclaimed in 1861.

  3. Who unified Germany and how?
    Show answer

    Otto von Bismarck of Prussia, through wars against Denmark, Austria, and France that led to the German Empire in 1871.

  4. How did nationalism threaten multiethnic empires?
    Show answer

    Groups such as Greeks, Serbs, Bulgarians, and Czechs demanded their own states, which weakened the Ottoman and Habsburg empires.

  5. What was Ottomanism?
    Show answer

    The idea that all Ottoman subjects, whatever their religion, should share a common Ottoman identity.

  6. Why is Rizal's Noli Me Tangere limited as evidence?
    Show answer

    It is a work of fiction by an educated man for a particular audience, so it shows educated Filipino views more than those of ordinary farmers.

Lesson 5.5 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.3

How the Industrial Revolution began

The Industrial Revolution was the shift from farm and hand production to factories and machines powered by coal and steam. It began in Britain in the late 1700s. The CED asks how environmental factors contributed to industrialization and lists the conditions that favored it. This lesson covers why industry began where it did and what the factory system changed.

Required content · 5D

Learning objective.

  • 5D. Explain how environmental factors contributed to industrialization from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.I.A. A variety of factors contributed to the growth of industrial production and eventually resulted in the Industrial Revolution, including:; Proximity to waterways; access to rivers and canals; Geographical distribution of coal, iron, and timber; Urbanization; Improved agricultural productivity; Legal protection of private property; Access to foreign resources; Accumulation of capital
  • 5.1.I.C. The development of the factory system concentrated production in a single location and led to an increasing degree of specialization of labor.

The conditions: why Britain?

The CED says that a variety of factors contributed to the growth of industrial production and eventually resulted in the Industrial Revolution, including:

  • Proximity to waterways, and access to rivers and canals. Britain's rivers and coasts and the canals built in the 1700s let heavy goods move cheaply.
  • Geographical distribution of coal, iron, and timber. Britain had large deposits of coal and iron near each other and near ports. Coal replaced scarce wood as fuel and later powered steam engines.
  • Urbanization. Growing towns supplied workers and markets.
  • Improved agricultural productivity. New farming methods, such as crop rotation, selective breeding, and the enclosure of common lands, raised output with fewer workers, which freed labor for factories and fed city populations. This is sometimes called the Agricultural Revolution.
  • Legal protection of private property. Courts protected property and contracts, which encouraged investment, and patents rewarded inventors.
  • Access to foreign resources. Britain's empire supplied raw materials, such as cotton from India, Egypt, and the American South, and markets for its goods. Much of that cotton was grown by enslaved people, so the factories of Britain depended on slave labor overseas.
  • Accumulation of capital. Wealth from trade, banking, and empire provided money to invest in machines and factories.

No single factor explains the Revolution. Historians debate which mattered most, but they agree that these conditions together made Britain an early industrial leader. Environmental conditions, such as the location of coal near manufacturing areas and ports, were very important.

Early industries and inventions

Cotton textiles led the way. Inventions such as the spinning jenny (1760s) and the water frame (1769) multiplied the output of spinners, and the power loom did the same for weaving. James Watt's improved steam engine (1769) was more efficient than earlier models and could power machines anywhere, not just near rivers. Iron-making improved when coal-derived coke replaced charcoal. These developments reinforced each other, since steam engines needed iron and coal, and mines needed engines to pump out water.

The factory system

The CED says that the development of the factory system concentrated production in a single location and led to an increasing degree of specialization of labor. Before, most cloth was made in homes by spinners and weavers working for a merchant (the "putting-out" system). In factories, workers came to a single building to use machines powered by water or steam, and they worked set hours under a supervisor. Tasks were divided so that each worker did one repeated step, which raised output but could make the work dull and tiring.

The new system changed the pace and discipline of life. Work followed the clock and the machine, not the sun and the season, and workers, including women and children, were paid wages and often worked six days a week for twelve or more hours (Lesson 5.9).

Effects

The Industrial Revolution greatly increased production and lowered the price of goods, and it began the shift of the economy from farming to manufacturing. It also had costs. Factories and cities polluted air and water, workers faced danger and low pay, and Britain's industry depended on the raw materials and markets of its empire, including goods from slave plantations.

Primary source · Specialization of labor

Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), book 1, chapter 1.

One man draws out the wire, another straights it, a third cuts it, a fourth points it, a fifth grinds it at the top for receiving the head.

Sourcing (HIPP). Smith was a Scottish professor and economist, so his point of view is that of an Enlightenment thinker interested in how wealth is created. His purpose was to explain how dividing work among many people makes it far more productive, and his audience was educated British readers and policymakers. He was describing a small workshop making pins, not a steam-powered factory, so the passage shows the idea of specialization, which factories later applied on a larger scale.

Source analysis · The idea of specialization

Claim. Dividing work into specialized steps was recognized as a source of productivity before factories became common.

Evidence. Smith described pin-making as divided among workers, with one drawing the wire, another straightening it, another cutting it, and others pointing and grinding it.

Reasoning. Assigning each step to a different worker is the principle of specialization that factories later used, so the passage shows the idea in advance of the factory system. A limit is that Smith described a small workshop, so it does not show the machines, steam power, or large scale of factory work.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one environmental factor that helped Britain industrialize.

Model. One factor was the location of coal and iron deposits near each other and near ports and rivers. Cheap coal powered steam engines and iron-making, and waterways and canals moved the heavy fuel and goods to factories and markets at low cost, which helped industry grow.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5D asks how environmental factors contributed. List the CED's conditions (waterways, coal, iron, timber, urbanization, farming improvements, property law, foreign resources, capital) and explain how each helped. Also define the factory system and specialization of labor. Include the role of empire and slavery in supplying cotton.

Practice
  1. What was the factory system?
    Show answer

    A system in which production was concentrated in one location, using machines and workers who performed specialized tasks under supervision.

  2. Why was coal important to British industrialization?
    Show answer

    It replaced scarce wood as fuel, powered steam engines, and was available near iron deposits and ports.

  3. How did agricultural change help industrialization?
    Show answer

    New methods raised output with fewer workers, which fed cities and freed labor for factories.

  4. How did empire help British industry?
    Show answer

    It supplied raw materials such as cotton, often grown by enslaved people, and provided markets and capital.

  5. What is specialization of labor?
    Show answer

    Dividing a job into separate tasks so each worker repeats one step, which raises output.

  6. Why is Smith's pin factory a limited example of the factory system?
    Show answer

    It describes a small workshop of hand work, not a large factory with machines and steam power.

Lesson 5.6 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4

Industrialization spreads

Industry did not stay in Britain. The CED asks how different modes and locations of production have developed and changed over time, and its two main points are the spread of industry to other regions and the decline of manufacturing in others. This lesson covers who industrialized, who did not, and why the shares of world production shifted.

Required content · 5E

Learning objective.

  • 5E. Explain how different modes and locations of production have developed and changed over time.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.II.B. The rapid development of steam-powered industrial production in European countries and the U.S. contributed to the increase in these regions’ share of global manufacturing during the first Industrial Revolution. While Middle Eastern and Asian countries continued to produce manufactured goods, these regions’ share in global manufacturing declined.
  • 5.1.I.D. As new methods of industrial production became more common in parts of northwestern Europe, they spread to other parts of Europe and the United States, Russia, and Japan.

The spread of industrialization

The CED says that as new methods of industrial production became more common in parts of northwestern Europe, they spread to other parts of Europe and the United States, Russia, and Japan. The pattern was that of waves.

  • Belgium and France followed Britain in the early 1800s. Belgium had coal and iron near each other.
  • The United States industrialized rapidly in the 1800s, helped by large natural resources, a growing population, and railroads. Its first factories in New England made textiles.
  • Germany industrialized later, after unification in 1871, and quickly became a leader in steel, chemicals, and electrical goods.
  • Russia began industrializing in the late 1800s with government support (Lesson 5.6).
  • Japan industrialized after 1868 (Lesson 5.6).

Later industrializers had advantages. They could copy British technology and skip stages of development, and some used the state to raise capital, which earlier industrializers had not needed. But they faced competition from the earlier leaders.

1712 Newcomen steam engine 1769 Watt's improved engine 1825 First public steam railway in Britain 1830s Industry spreads to Belgium and France 1868 Meiji restoration 1870s Second industrial revolution 1891 Trans-Siberian Railway begun 1900 US, Germany pass Britain in steel output
Figure 5.2. Industry began in Britain and spread outward in waves. Later industrializers often borrowed technology and relied more on the state.

Steam and the rise of Europe and the United States

The CED says that the rapid development of steam-powered industrial production in European countries and the U.S. contributed to the increase in these regions' share of global manufacturing during the first Industrial Revolution. In 1750, China and India together produced a large share of the world's manufactured goods, in textiles, porcelain, and iron. By the late 1800s, Europe and the United States produced most of them. Estimates by the economic historian Paul Bairoch suggest that Britain's share of world manufacturing grew from a few percent in 1750 to about a quarter by 1880, while China's share fell from about a third to about an eighth and India's from about a quarter to just a few percent. Such figures are rough, but the direction is clear.

Decline elsewhere

The CED continues: while Middle Eastern and Asian countries continued to produce manufactured goods, these regions' share in global manufacturing declined. It gives examples:

  • Shipbuilding in India and Southeast Asia. Wooden ships built in India's yards were famous, but steamships made of iron displaced them.
  • Iron works in India. Traditional smelting in India could not compete with imported British iron and steel.
  • Textile production in India and Egypt. Indian cloth had been sold across the world for centuries. Cheap machine-made British cloth, entering colonial markets with few tariffs, undercut Indian weavers, and many lost their livelihoods. In Egypt, Muhammad Ali's state-run cotton mills were weakened after 1838, when an Anglo-Ottoman treaty forced open Egyptian markets to British goods.

Some historians use the term deindustrialization for this decline. It came not from any lack of skill but from industrial machines that made goods more cheaply, together with colonial policies and unequal trade agreements that favored British exports (Lesson 6.5). It also shows that industrialization was not simply "progress" for all, since for many artisans in Asia it meant loss.

Why did some places industrialize and others not?

Several factors mattered: the availability of coal, iron, and capital, the existence of stable states willing to promote industry, the size of markets, and political independence. Colonial territories were often kept as suppliers of raw materials and buyers of finished goods, which held back local industry. States that kept their independence, such as Japan and the United States, were better able to protect and promote industry.

Description of: shares of world manufacturing

Description of a table in the work of the economic historian Paul Bairoch (1982) estimating each country's share of world manufacturing output, 1750 to 1900. This is a description, not a quotation.

The table shows Britain's share of world manufacturing rising from about 2 percent in 1750 to about 23 percent in 1880, while China's falls from about a third to about an eighth, and India's from about a quarter to under 3 percent. The shares of the United States and Germany grow sharply in the later 1800s.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bairoch was an economic historian who compiled estimates from many incomplete records, so the point of view is that of modern scholarship. The purpose was to measure long-term changes in industrial power, and the audience was scholars. Because data for 1750 are rough, the exact numbers are debated, but the broad pattern is widely accepted and illustrates the shift in industrial power.

Source analysis · Reading data

Claim. Industrialization shifted the world's manufacturing power from Asia to Europe and the United States.

Evidence. Bairoch's estimates show Britain's share rising from about 2 percent to about 23 percent between 1750 and 1880, while India's fell from about a quarter to under 3 percent and China's from a third to an eighth.

Reasoning. Large changes in shares in opposite directions support a claim about a major shift. A limit is that the 1750 numbers are estimates based on incomplete records, so they are best used for general direction and not for exact amounts.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare the experience of Britain and India with industrialization in the 1800s.

Model. Britain's share of world manufacturing grew as steam-powered factories mass-produced textiles, while India's weavers, who had once supplied world markets, lost out to cheap British cloth. Both were affected by the same technology, but Britain gained and India declined partly because India was a colony whose markets were open to British goods.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5E asks how modes and locations of production changed. Name who industrialized (Belgium, France, the United States, Germany, Russia, Japan) and who declined (India, the Middle East), with specific examples from the CED (shipbuilding, iron, textiles). Explain why, including colonial policy and independence.

Practice
  1. Which regions industrialized after Britain?
    Show answer

    Belgium, France, the United States, Germany, Russia, and Japan.

  2. Why did India's textile industry decline?
    Show answer

    Cheap British machine-made cloth entered Indian markets with few tariffs and undercut handloom weavers.

  3. What is deindustrialization?
    Show answer

    The decline of manufacturing in a region, as happened in parts of Asia and the Middle East when they could not compete with industrial imports.

  4. Name one advantage of later industrializers.
    Show answer

    They could copy British technology and skip stages, and some used the state to raise capital.

  5. Why did independence matter for industrialization?
    Show answer

    Independent states such as Japan and the United States could protect and promote industry, while colonies were kept as suppliers of raw materials and buyers of finished goods.

  6. Why are 1750 estimates of manufacturing share uncertain?
    Show answer

    They are based on incomplete records, so the exact numbers are debated, though the broad pattern is accepted.

Lesson 5.7 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.5

The technology of the industrial age

New machines and new energy sources changed how people made things and how they traveled. The CED asks how technology shaped economic production over time, and points to the fossil fuels revolution, the "second industrial revolution," and the new transport and communication systems. This lesson covers each.

Required content · 5F

Learning objective.

  • 5F. Explain how technology shaped economic production over time.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.I.B. The development of machines, including steam engines and the internal combustion engine, made it possible to take advantage of both existing and vast newly discovered resources of energy stored in fossil fuels, specifically coal and oil. The fossil fuels revolution greatly increased the energy available to human societies.
  • 5.1.I.E. The “second industrial revolution” led to new methods in the production of steel, chemicals, electricity, and precision machinery during the second half of the 19th century.
  • 5.1.IV. Railroads, steamships, and the telegraph made exploration, development, and communication possible in interior regions globally, which led to increased trade and migration.

From steam engines to the internal combustion engine

The CED says that the development of machines, including steam engines and the internal combustion engine, made it possible to take advantage of both existing and vast newly discovered resources of energy stored in fossil fuels, specifically coal and oil. The fossil fuels revolution greatly increased the energy available to human societies. Before industrialization, people relied on human and animal muscle, wind, and water. Coal and steam engines released far more energy. In the later 1800s, engineers developed the internal combustion engine, which burned gasoline or diesel fuel from petroleum. The first practical cars appeared in the 1880s and 1890s, and Rudolf Diesel patented his engine in 1892. Oil became a vital resource, which later shaped global politics.

The second industrial revolution

The CED says that the "second industrial revolution" led to new methods in the production of steel, chemicals, electricity, and precision machinery during the second half of the nineteenth century.

  • Steel. The Bessemer process (1856) and later methods made cheap steel from iron, which was stronger than iron and was used for rails, bridges, buildings, ships, and machines.
  • Chemicals. Chemists developed synthetic dyes, fertilizers, explosives, and medicines, and Germany became a leader in the chemical industry.
  • Electricity. Inventors such as Thomas Edison and Nikola Tesla developed generators, electric lighting, and motors, and by the 1880s power stations supplied cities. Electricity let factories use power flexibly and changed urban life.
  • Precision machinery. Machine tools that could shape metal to exact measurements allowed interchangeable parts and mass production.

The second revolution favored countries with strong science and education, large markets, and capital, which helped Germany and the United States overtake Britain in several industries by 1900.

Transport and communication

The CED says that railroads, steamships, and the telegraph made exploration, development, and communication possible in interior regions globally, which led to increased trade and migration.

  • Railroads. After the first public steam railway in Britain in 1825, railroads spread across Europe, North America, and India. They carried goods and people faster and cheaper than horses and canals, opened inland regions such as the American plains and Russia's Siberia, and linked farms and mines to ports.
  • Steamships. Steam-powered iron ships crossed oceans on schedules, unaffected by winds. The Suez Canal (opened 1869) cut the sea route between Europe and Asia by thousands of miles, and the Panama Canal (opened 1914) joined the Atlantic and Pacific.
  • The telegraph. Samuel Morse's electric telegraph (first public line in 1844) sent messages across long distances in moments. Undersea cables, such as the transatlantic cable laid successfully in 1866, connected continents and allowed news, orders, and prices to travel instantly. Merchants, governments, and newspapers used the telegraph to coordinate their actions.

These networks reduced the cost of moving goods, which raised trade and also supported migration (Lesson 6.6). They also helped governments control distant lands and made empires easier to run, which connects to imperial expansion (Unit 6).

Effects on production

Technology changed how and where things were made. Factories grew larger, and cities grew around them. Standardization and mass production lowered prices. Workers faced new dangers and pressures, since machines set the pace. And access to energy and communication became a basis of national power.

Primary source · The first telegraph message

The first message sent by Samuel Morse over the Baltimore-to-Washington telegraph line, May 24, 1844 (public domain).

What hath God wrought.

Sourcing (HIPP). The phrase comes from the Bible (Numbers 23:23), and it was suggested to Morse by Annie Ellsworth, the daughter of a government official. Morse was an American inventor, so the point of view is that of the person demonstrating a new technology. The purpose was to mark a successful public demonstration of the line, and the audience was officials and the public. The choice of a religious phrase shows how people at the time viewed the technology with a sense of awe, but the short message says nothing about its later economic effects.

Source analysis · Reactions to a new technology

Claim. Contemporaries regarded the telegraph as a remarkable change.

Evidence. The first message, "What hath God wrought," used a biblical phrase of wonder.

Reasoning. Choosing language of awe for a first test suggests that those present saw the telegraph as extraordinary, which fits its rapid spread. A limit is that a single phrase tells us about a ceremonial moment and not about how ordinary people or businesses used the telegraph.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way railroads or steamships changed trade or migration.

Model. Railroads linked inland farms and mines to ports and moved goods and people faster and more cheaply than horses and canals, which opened regions such as the American plains and Siberia to settlement and exports. This raised trade and also made it easier for migrants to travel to new places.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5F asks how technology shaped production. Name the fossil fuels revolution, the second industrial revolution (steel, chemicals, electricity, precision machinery), and the transport and communication technologies (railroads, steamships, the telegraph, and canals). Say how each increased trade and migration or changed production.

Practice
  1. What energy sources did industrialization draw on?
    Show answer

    Fossil fuels, especially coal and later oil, burned in steam engines and internal combustion engines.

  2. What was the second industrial revolution?
    Show answer

    A wave of innovation in the later 1800s in steel, chemicals, electricity, and precision machinery.

  3. How did the telegraph change communication?
    Show answer

    It sent messages across great distances almost instantly, and undersea cables connected continents.

  4. Name one canal built in this period and its effect.
    Show answer

    The Suez Canal (1869) shortened the sea route between Europe and Asia, and the Panama Canal (1914) joined the Atlantic and Pacific.

  5. How did railroads affect trade?
    Show answer

    They moved goods and people faster and more cheaply than earlier transport and linked inland regions to ports.

  6. Why is a single telegraph message limited evidence?
    Show answer

    It shows a ceremonial moment and reactions of awe, not how businesses or ordinary people used the telegraph.

Lesson 5.8 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.6

The state and industrialization

Not every state left industry to private businessmen. The CED says that as the influence of the Industrial Revolution grew, a small number of states and governments promoted their own state-sponsored visions of industrialization, and that the expansion of U.S. and European influence in Asia led to internal reform in Japan that supported industrialization and led to the growing regional power of Japan in the Meiji Era. This lesson covers three state-led efforts: Japan, Russia, and Egypt.

Required content · 5G

Learning objective.

  • 5G. Explain the causes and effects of economic strategies of different states and empires.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.V.C. As the influence of the Industrial Revolution grew, a small number of states and governments promoted their own state-sponsored visions of industrialization.
  • 5.2.II.A. The expansion of U.S. and European influence in Asia led to internal reform in Japan that supported industrialization and led to the growing regional power of Japan in the Meiji Era.

Japan and the Meiji Restoration

Under the Tokugawa shoguns, Japan had limited contact with the outside world (Lesson 4.4a). In 1853, American Commodore Matthew Perry arrived with warships and demanded that Japan open to trade, and in 1854 Japan signed a treaty that opened ports. Other powers won similar treaties, and Japanese leaders saw how China had suffered from Western pressure in the Opium Wars (Lesson 6.5). Some samurai and officials decided that Japan needed to modernize to avoid being colonized.

In 1868 they overthrew the shogun in the Meiji Restoration, which restored the emperor (Meiji) as the nominal head of a new government. The government worked deliberately to catch up to the West.

  • Political reform. It abolished the old domain system and samurai privileges, created a centralized state, and issued a constitution in 1889 that set up an elected Diet with limited powers.
  • Economic policy. The state built railroads, telegraph lines, shipyards, and model factories, sent officials abroad to study Western methods (the Iwakura Mission, 1871 to 1873), and hired foreign experts. It later sold many enterprises to private companies, some of which grew into large conglomerates called zaibatsu.
  • Education and military. It created a national school system and a conscript army and navy built on Western models.

The result was rapid industrialization. By the 1890s, Japan was a power. It defeated China in a war in 1894 to 1895, and it defeated Russia in 1904 to 1905, and it began to build its own empire in Asia, which fits the CED's description of growing regional power.

Russia

Russia's rulers were also aware that their country lagged behind Western Europe. Defeat in the Crimean War (1853 to 1856) showed the weakness of its army and economy. In 1861 Tsar Alexander II ended serfdom, which freed peasants but left them with heavy debts. In the 1890s, finance minister Sergei Witte pushed state-led industrialization, with government investment, protective tariffs, foreign loans, and railroads. The Trans-Siberian Railway, begun in 1891, linked European Russia to the Pacific. Industry grew in cities such as Moscow and St. Petersburg, but most Russians remained poor peasants, and tension between the autocratic state and its workers fed unrest that led to revolution in 1905 and 1917.

Egypt

In Egypt, Muhammad Ali, an Ottoman officer who became governor in 1805, built a strong state. He created a modern army, built factories for textiles, arms, and other goods, and promoted cotton as a cash crop, with the state controlling much of the economy. He drew on French advisers and sent students to Europe. His son and grandson continued some efforts. Egypt's industry was undermined by the 1838 treaty that opened Ottoman markets to British goods (Lesson 5.4), and the state's heavy borrowing for projects such as the Suez Canal left it in debt to European lenders, and Britain occupied Egypt in 1882. Egypt's case shows that state sponsorship did not always succeed without full independence and a strong financial base.

Compare

All three governments believed that a strong state needed modern industry and a strong military, and all borrowed Western technology. Japan's reforms went deepest and fit with political centralization, and it avoided colonial control. Russia's effort was incomplete and Egypt's was undermined by foreign pressure and debt.

Primary source · The Charter Oath

The Charter Oath of the Meiji government (1868), in a standard English translation.

Knowledge shall be sought throughout the world so as to strengthen the foundations of imperial rule.

Sourcing (HIPP). The oath was issued in the name of the young Meiji emperor by his advisers, so the point of view is that of the new government. Its purpose was to announce the reform program and to win support for it from the old elite and the people. The audience was the Japanese public and the court. Because the oath is a statement of intentions, it shows the government's goals and justification, not how the reforms actually worked out.

Source analysis · Reform to strengthen the state

Claim. The Meiji leaders sought foreign knowledge in order to strengthen the Japanese state.

Evidence. The Charter Oath says that knowledge shall be sought throughout the world to strengthen the foundations of imperial rule.

Reasoning. Linking foreign learning to imperial rule shows that borrowing was a means to preserve Japan's independence and the emperor's power, not an end in itself. A limit is that it is a statement of intentions written to win support, so it does not prove how far the reforms succeeded.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between Meiji Japan's and Muhammad Ali's industrialization efforts.

Model. Both used the state to build factories, a modern army, and education, and both sent people abroad to learn Western methods. Japan's effort succeeded because it kept its independence and carried out deep political and economic change, while Egypt's was weakened by the 1838 treaty opening its markets and later by heavy foreign debt and British occupation.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5G asks for causes and effects of economic strategies of states. Know Meiji Japan (Perry, the Restoration, state-built industry, Iwakura Mission, wars with China and Russia), Russia (Witte, the Trans-Siberian Railway), and Egypt (Muhammad Ali). Explain why Japan succeeded where others struggled.

Practice
  1. What event pushed Japan to open its ports?
    Show answer

    Commodore Perry's arrival with warships in 1853 and the treaty of 1854.

  2. What was the Meiji Restoration?
    Show answer

    The 1868 overthrow of the Tokugawa shogun that restored the emperor as nominal head of a new government that modernized Japan.

  3. How did the Meiji state promote industry?
    Show answer

    It built railroads, telegraphs, shipyards, and model factories, sent officials abroad to study, and later sold enterprises to private firms.

  4. Who was Sergei Witte?
    Show answer

    The Russian finance minister of the 1890s who promoted state-led industrialization with loans, tariffs, and railroads such as the Trans-Siberian.

  5. Why did Egypt's industrialization fail to last?
    Show answer

    The 1838 treaty opened markets to British goods, heavy foreign debt followed, and Britain occupied Egypt in 1882.

  6. Why does the Charter Oath show intentions rather than results?
    Show answer

    It is a government statement written to win support, so it shows goals and justification, not how reforms actually worked out.

Lesson 5.9 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.7

Capitalism, free trade, and global business

The industrial age changed not only machines but also ideas about how economies should work and the institutions that carried them out. The CED asks how economic systems, ideologies, and institutions developed and contributed to change from 1750 to 1900. Two developments stand out: the shift from mercantilism to free trade, and the rise of large transnational businesses.

Required content · 5H

Learning objective.

  • 5H. Explain the development of economic systems, ideologies, and institutions and how they contributed to change in the period from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.III.A. Western European countries began abandoning mercantilism and adopting free trade policies, partly in response to the growing acceptance of Adam Smith’s theories of laissez-faire capitalism and free markets.
  • 5.1.III.B. The global nature of trade and production contributed to the proliferation of large-scale transnational businesses that relied on new practices in banking and finance.

From mercantilism to free trade

Lesson 4.5a described mercantilism, in which states used tariffs and monopolies to build national wealth. In the 1700s, some thinkers argued that this was a mistake. Adam Smith, in The Wealth of Nations (1776), argued that economies work best when individuals pursue their own interest in free markets, with little government interference. He called this system laissez-faire (French for "let it do"), and held that competition, supply, and demand, guided as if by an "invisible hand," would produce wealth for society. He also argued that international trade benefits all participants when each specializes in what it makes best.

The CED says that Western European countries began abandoning mercantilism and adopting free trade policies, partly in response to the growing acceptance of Adam Smith's theories of laissez-faire capitalism and free markets. The most important British steps were:

  • The repeal of the Corn Laws in 1846, which had taxed imported grain to protect landowners, and which manufacturers and workers wanted ended because they raised the price of bread.
  • The repeal of the Navigation Acts in 1849, which had limited foreign shipping.
  • Trade treaties in the 1860s, such as the Anglo-French treaty of 1860, that lowered tariffs.

Britain, as the leading industrial power, benefited from free trade because its goods could outcompete others. Other states, such as the United States, Germany, and Russia, kept protective tariffs to shield their young industries, so free trade was never universal. Critics noted that free trade policies could also be forced on weaker states, as in treaties that kept tariffs low in China, the Ottoman Empire, and Latin America (Lesson 6.5).

New business organization and finance

The CED says that the global nature of trade and production contributed to the proliferation of large-scale transnational businesses that relied on new practices in banking and finance. Industrial and imperial enterprises needed large amounts of money, and older ways of raising it were not enough. Two financial instruments mattered.

  • Stock markets. In a stock exchange, people buy and sell shares of companies. Exchanges in London, New York, Paris, and elsewhere let companies raise capital from many investors, and let investors sell their shares.
  • Limited-liability corporations. Laws in Britain (1855 and 1862) and elsewhere allowed investors in a company to lose only the amount they had put in, not their entire wealth if the company failed. This made it safer to invest and let companies grow large.

Banks also expanded across borders. The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC), founded in 1865, financed trade across Asia. The CED also lists Unilever, which was based in England and the Netherlands and operated in British West Africa and the Belgian Congo, as an example of a transnational business, though that company was created in 1929 from earlier firms. These businesses moved goods and money across borders and linked colonies to the world economy.

Effects

Capitalism expanded production and trade, created great fortunes, and gave a role to investors and managers. It also created large inequalities, periodic crises called panics or depressions, such as the long depression of the 1870s, and, as Lesson 5.8a shows, strong reactions from workers and critics.

Primary source · Self-interest and the market

Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), book 1, chapter 2.

It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.

Sourcing (HIPP). Smith was a Scottish moral philosopher writing in the Enlightenment, so the point of view is that of a thinker who believed that markets could harness self-interest for society's benefit. The purpose was to explain how exchange works and to argue against the mercantilist controls that restricted trade, and the audience was educated British readers and officials. The sentence describes a small town market, so it does not address large corporations or colonial trade that developed later.

Source analysis · Self-interest as a principle

Claim. Smith argued that markets work through self-interest rather than through rulers' commands.

Evidence. He wrote that we expect our dinner not from the benevolence of the butcher, brewer, or baker but from their regard to their own interest.

Reasoning. The sentence explains how people supply one another's needs through exchange without any central direction, which supports laissez-faire policy. A limit is that Smith described a local market of small traders, so it does not explain the effects of large corporations or monopolies, which later critics emphasized.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change in economic policy and one new institution of the industrial age.

Model. One change was the shift in Britain from mercantilist protection to free trade, as seen in the repeal of the Corn Laws in 1846 and the Navigation Acts in 1849, influenced by Adam Smith's arguments. One new institution was the limited-liability corporation, which let investors risk only what they put in and so made it easier to raise capital for large enterprises.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5H asks about economic systems, ideologies, and institutions. Know laissez-faire, the repeal of mercantilist laws (Corn Laws, Navigation Acts), stock markets, limited-liability corporations, and transnational businesses such as HSBC. Note that free trade favored the strongest economies and that many states kept tariffs.

Practice
  1. What is laissez-faire?
    Show answer

    An economic idea that government should interfere little in the economy and let markets and competition work.

  2. Who was Adam Smith?
    Show answer

    A Scottish thinker whose book The Wealth of Nations (1776) argued for free markets and against mercantilist controls.

  3. What were the Corn Laws and why were they repealed?
    Show answer

    Laws that taxed imported grain to protect landowners; they were repealed in 1846 because manufacturers and workers wanted cheaper bread and free trade.

  4. What did limited liability do?
    Show answer

    It limited investors' possible losses to what they had invested, which made large investments safer and easier.

  5. Name one transnational business or bank of the period.
    Show answer

    The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC), founded in 1865.

  6. Why was free trade never universal?
    Show answer

    Countries such as the United States, Germany, and Russia kept tariffs to protect new industries, and free trade favored the strongest economies.

Lesson 5.10 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.8

Workers, unions, and the rise of socialism

Industrial capitalism created great wealth and hard conditions for the workers who produced it. The CED asks about the causes and effects of calls for changes in industrial societies. This lesson covers the responses within industrialized states: reform, labor organization, and new ideologies, including socialism and communism. The next lesson covers reform efforts in Asia and Africa.

Required content · 5I

Learning objective.

  • 5I. Explain the causes and effects of calls for changes in industrial societies from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.V.D. In response to the social and economic changes brought about by industrial capitalism, some governments, organizations, and individuals promoted various types of political, social, educational, and urban reforms.
  • 5.1.V.A. In industrialized states, many workers organized themselves, often in labor unions, to improve working conditions, limit hours, and gain higher wages. Workers’ movements and political parties emerged in different areas, promoting alternative visions of society.
  • 5.3.IV.A.ii. Discontent with established power structures encouraged the development of various ideologies, including those espoused by Karl Marx, and the ideas of socialism and communism.

The problems

Factory workers, including women and children, often worked twelve to sixteen hours a day for low pay. Factories could be dangerous and unhealthy, and cities were crowded, dirty, and unsafe (Lesson 5.9). Workers had few legal protections, and employers could dismiss them at will. Bad harvests or business slumps could bring unemployment and hunger.

Reform

The CED says that, in response to the social and economic changes brought about by industrial capitalism, some governments, organizations, and individuals promoted various types of political, social, educational, and urban reforms. In Britain, for example:

  • Factory Acts. Laws from 1833 on limited child labor and working hours. A law of 1847 reduced hours for women and children.
  • Public health and urban reform. After cholera epidemics, governments built sewers, supplied clean water, and set standards for housing (Lesson 5.9).
  • Education. Governments and charities created schools, so that by the late 1800s many states required elementary education.
  • Political reform. The Reform Acts of 1832 and 1867 widened the vote, and the Chartists of the 1830s and 1840s demanded universal male suffrage and other changes in a mass petition movement.

Workers organize

The CED says that in industrialized states, many workers organized themselves, often in labor unions, to improve working conditions, limit hours, and gain higher wages. Workers' movements and political parties emerged in different areas, promoting alternative visions of society. At first, governments often banned unions as illegal combinations, but they gained legal recognition in Britain in 1871 and spread elsewhere. Unions used strikes and collective bargaining. In the later 1800s, workers also formed political parties, such as the German Social Democratic Party (founded 1875), and these sometimes won seats in parliaments.

Socialism and Marx

Some thinkers argued that reform was not enough and that the system itself should change. The CED says that discontent with established power structures encouraged the development of various ideologies, including those espoused by Karl Marx, and the ideas of socialism and communism.

Socialism is the belief that the means of production, such as factories and land, should be owned collectively or by the state, so that wealth benefits everyone and not just the owners. Early socialists, such as Robert Owen in Britain, tried to build cooperative communities. Karl Marx (1818 to 1883), a German thinker, and Friedrich Engels (1820 to 1895) wrote The Communist Manifesto (1848) and Marx wrote Capital (1867). They argued that history is driven by class struggle and that under capitalism, the bourgeoisie (owners of capital) exploit the proletariat (industrial workers). They predicted that workers would overthrow capitalism in a revolution and build a classless society, which they called communism. Their ideas inspired labor parties and, in the next century, revolutions (Lesson 7.1).

Other ideologies also appeared. Anarchists wanted to abolish the state altogether, while liberals wanted reform within a capitalist, constitutional system. Some governments, including Bismarck's Germany in the 1880s, introduced insurance for illness, accidents, and old age, partly to blunt socialism's appeal.

Why they mattered

These movements changed politics. Workers' voices entered public debate, laws began to regulate working conditions, and the idea that the state has a role in citizens' welfare began to grow. They also created lasting conflicts about the role of government in economic life that continue today.

Primary source · The Communist Manifesto

Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The Communist Manifesto (1848), opening of section 1, in the English translation by Samuel Moore (1888).

The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.

Sourcing (HIPP). Marx and Engels were German thinkers living in exile, so their point of view is that of revolutionary critics of capitalism. The purpose of the pamphlet was to state the program of a communist organization, the Communist League, and to inspire workers, and the audience was workers and radicals across Europe. It appeared in the year of revolutions, when many hoped for sweeping change. Because it is a manifesto written to persuade, it presents history in a way that supports its argument, so historians treat it as evidence of an ideology and not as a neutral account.

Source analysis · A theory of history

Claim. Marx and Engels interpreted history as a struggle between social classes.

Evidence. The first line says the history of all existing society is the history of class struggles.

Reasoning. The sentence presents conflict between classes as the central cause of change, which frames capitalism as one stage in a long struggle. A limit is that it is a political pamphlet written to persuade workers, so it is best used as evidence of what its authors believed and wanted, not as an objective analysis.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one reform and one ideology that arose in response to industrial capitalism.

Model. One reform was the Factory Acts in Britain, which limited child labor and working hours, so the state began to regulate conditions in factories. One ideology was Marxism, which argued that workers should overthrow capitalism and build a classless society and which inspired labor parties and later revolutions.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5I asks for causes and effects of calls for change. Name reforms (Factory Acts, public health, education), labor unions and parties, and ideologies (socialism, Marxism and communism, anarchism). Stress that responses ranged from reform to revolution.

Practice
  1. What did the Factory Acts do?
    Show answer

    They limited child labor and the working hours of women and children in Britain.

  2. What did Chartists demand?
    Show answer

    Universal male suffrage and other political reforms, through mass petitions in the 1830s and 1840s.

  3. What is socialism?
    Show answer

    The belief that the means of production should be owned collectively or by the state so wealth benefits everyone.

  4. Who were Marx and Engels, and what did they argue?
    Show answer

    German thinkers who argued that history is a class struggle and that workers would overthrow capitalism and build a classless communist society.

  5. Why did Bismarck introduce social insurance?
    Show answer

    Partly to blunt the appeal of socialism by giving workers protection against illness, accident, and old age.

  6. Why is The Communist Manifesto limited as a neutral account?
    Show answer

    It is a political pamphlet written to persuade workers, so it presents history in a way that supports its argument.

Lesson 5.11 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.8

Reform and modernization in the Ottoman and Qing empires

The CED says that, in response to the expansion of industrializing states, some governments in Asia and Africa, including the Ottoman Empire and Qing China, sought to reform and modernize their economies and militaries. Reform efforts were often resisted by some members of government or established elite groups. This lesson covers two of the largest efforts, the Ottoman Tanzimat and the Chinese Self-Strengthening Movement, and compares them with Japan.

Required content · 5I

Learning objective.

  • 5I. Explain the causes and effects of calls for changes in industrial societies from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.V.B. In response to the expansion of industrializing states, some governments in Asia and Africa, including the Ottoman Empire and Qing China, sought to reform and modernize their economies and militaries. Reform efforts were often resisted by some members of government or established elite groups.

The Ottoman Tanzimat

By 1800 the Ottoman Empire had lost territory to Russia and Austria, faced rebellions in the Balkans and Egypt, and lagged behind Europe in military and economic strength. Sultan Mahmud II (r. 1808 to 1839) destroyed the janissaries, whose resistance had blocked change, and created a modern army. His successors began a series of reforms called the Tanzimat ("reorganization," 1839 to 1876).

  • Legal equality. The Gülhane decree of 1839 promised all Ottoman subjects, whatever their religion, security of life, honor, and property, and fair taxation. A decree of 1856 repeated the promise of equality between Muslims and non-Muslims.
  • Modernizing institutions. The state set up secular courts and schools, reformed the army on a European model, built telegraph lines and railroads, and reorganized taxes and provincial government.
  • A constitution. In 1876 the empire adopted a constitution and an elected parliament, though the sultan, Abdulhamid II, suspended it in 1878.

The reforms had limits. Conservative religious scholars and officials resisted changes that seemed to threaten Islamic law and tradition, and the empire's growing debt to European lenders, which led to foreign control of its finances in 1881, made it difficult to carry out reforms independently. Nationalist movements among Greeks, Serbs, and others also continued (Lesson 5.2c).

Qing China and Self-Strengthening

The Qing faced even greater crises. China's defeat by Britain in the Opium War (1839 to 1842) forced it to open ports and cede Hong Kong, and the Taiping Rebellion (1850 to 1864), a huge uprising led by a man who claimed to be Jesus's younger brother, killed millions. A second Opium War (1856 to 1860) brought further losses.

In response, some officials launched the Self-Strengthening Movement (about 1860 to 1895). Led by regional officials such as Zeng Guofan and Li Hongzhang, it aimed to adopt Western technology while preserving Chinese values. The slogan was to use Chinese learning as the base and Western learning for practical use. Projects included arsenals and shipyards, a modern navy, telegraph lines, railroads, coal mines, and schools to teach foreign languages and science. But the movement was limited. The conservative court, under the Empress Dowager Cixi, resisted deeper change, funds were short and sometimes diverted, and the program lacked a coordinated national plan. China's defeat by Japan in 1894 to 1895 showed that Self-Strengthening had not made China as strong as its neighbor. A short, more radical reform effort, the Hundred Days' Reform of 1898, was ended by a conservative coup.

Comparing the three

Ottoman EmpireQing ChinaJapan
Reform programTanzimat (1839 to 1876)Self-Strengthening (1860s to 1890s)Meiji (from 1868)
FocusLaw, army, schools, taxesMilitary and industryGovernment, industry, education, army
ObstaclesConservative elites, debt, nationalismCourt conservatism, lack of fundsFewer; leaders were committed
ResultPartial change, growing foreign controlLimited, defeated by Japan in 1895Rapid industrialization, regional power

The CED's emphasis is on the resistance to reform. Established elites in each empire stood to lose from change. Japan's leaders, who had overthrown the old order, faced less resistance, which helps explain why its reforms went deeper.

Description of: the Gülhane decree

Description of the imperial decree read at the Gülhane (Rose Garden) palace in Istanbul on November 3, 1839, which began the Tanzimat. This is a description, not a quotation.

The decree declared that the empire had grown weaker because the laws of Islam and of justice had not been observed. It promised security of life, honor, and property for all subjects, fair and regular taxation, and orderly conscription for the army, and it promised that the new laws would apply to people of every religion.

Sourcing (HIPP). The decree was issued in the sultan's name by the reforming minister Mustafa Resid Pasha, so the point of view is that of reformers within the government. The purpose was to explain and justify reform in terms of Islamic and Ottoman tradition and to win both Ottoman and European support. The audience was Ottoman subjects, officials, and the European powers, whose goodwill the empire needed. As a statement of goals, it shows what reformers promised, not how the promises were carried out.

Source analysis · Reform justified by tradition

Claim. Ottoman reformers presented modernization as a return to proper Islamic and Ottoman principles.

Evidence. The decree said the empire had weakened because the laws of Islam and justice had not been observed, and it promised security and fair taxation for all.

Reasoning. Framing reform as restoring justice and law gave it religious legitimacy and was meant to reduce conservative opposition, which fits the CED's point that elites resisted change. A limit is that the decree states aims written to win support, so it does not show how far the promises were kept.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between Ottoman and Qing reform efforts.

Model. Both governments tried to modernize their armies and economies in response to Western pressure, and both faced resistance from conservative officials and elites. A difference is that the Ottomans reformed law, citizenship, and government as well as the army, through the Tanzimat decrees, while the Qing Self-Strengthening Movement focused mainly on military technology and industry and avoided political change.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5I covers responses to the industrial economy, including reform in Asia and Africa. Know the Tanzimat and Self-Strengthening, their goals, and why they were limited (elite resistance, debt, lack of funds). Compare with Meiji Japan in a sentence or two.

Practice
  1. What was the Tanzimat?
    Show answer

    A series of Ottoman reforms from 1839 to 1876 that modernized law, the army, schools, and administration and promised equality among subjects.

  2. What was the Self-Strengthening Movement?
    Show answer

    A Qing effort from about 1860 to 1895 to adopt Western military and industrial technology while preserving Chinese values.

  3. Why did these reforms often fail?
    Show answer

    Conservative elites resisted change, funds were short, and foreign debt and pressure limited the governments' independence.

  4. What event showed the limits of Self-Strengthening?
    Show answer

    China's defeat by Japan in 1894 to 1895.

  5. How did Ottoman reformers justify change?
    Show answer

    They said it would restore the proper observance of Islamic and Ottoman law and justice.

  6. Why does the Gülhane decree show intentions, not results?
    Show answer

    It is a statement of goals meant to win support, so it does not show how far the promises were carried out.

Lesson 5.12 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.9

Society in the industrial age

Industrialization changed not only how things were made but also how people lived. The CED asks how industrialization caused change in existing social hierarchies and standards of living, and lists three changes: new social classes, new roles for women and children, and rapid urbanization with its problems.

Required content · 5J

Learning objective.

  • 5J. Explain how industrialization caused change in existing social hierarchies and standards of living.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.VI.A. New social classes, including the middle class and the industrial working class, developed.
  • 5.1.VI.B. While women and often children in working class families typically held wage-earning jobs to supplement their families’ income, middle-class women who did not have the same economic demands to satisfy were increasingly limited to roles in the household or roles focused on child development.
  • 5.1.VI.C. The rapid urbanization that accompanied global capitalism at times led to a variety of challenges, including pollution, poverty, increased crime, public health crises, housing shortages, and insufficient infrastructure to accommodate urban growth.

New social classes

The CED says that new social classes, including the middle class and the industrial working class, developed.

  • The middle class (bourgeoisie). Factory owners, bankers, merchants, managers, lawyers, doctors, and shopkeepers gained wealth and influence. They valued education, thrift, and respectability, and their rising status challenged the older landowning aristocracy. Many supported liberal politics that protected property and widened the vote.
  • The industrial working class. Factory workers, miners, and railway laborers lived on wages and had little control over their work. Many had come from farms, where the family and the seasons set the pace, to factories where a clock and a foreman did. Their income was often low and unstable, and many lived in poverty, though over time wages in industrial economies rose.

The older classes did not disappear. Landowning nobles kept wealth and political power in many countries, and most people in the world were still farmers. But industrial economies had a new balance of classes.

Women and children

The CED says that while women and often children in working-class families typically held wage-earning jobs to supplement their families' income, middle-class women who did not have the same economic demands to satisfy were increasingly limited to roles in the household or roles focused on child development.

In working-class families, everyone's wages mattered. Women and children worked in textile mills, mines, and workshops, as domestic servants, or in piecework at home, often for lower pay than men. Reformers and the Factory Acts later limited children's work and pushed for schooling.

Among the middle class, an ideal emerged that the husband earned the income and the wife managed the household and raised the children, a view often called the doctrine of "separate spheres." It reflected rising wealth, since a family could live on one income, and it limited women's access to professions and public life. Many women challenged these limits, and the women's movement of the later 1800s demanded access to education, property rights, and the vote (Lesson 5.1).

Urbanization and its problems

Industrial cities grew at astonishing speed. Manchester, for example, grew from a town of about 25,000 in the 1770s to a city of several hundred thousand by the 1850s, and by 1900 more than half of Britain's people lived in cities. The CED says that the rapid urbanization that accompanied global capitalism at times led to a variety of challenges, including pollution, poverty, increased crime, public health crises, housing shortages, and insufficient infrastructure to accommodate urban growth.

  • Housing. Workers crowded into cheap rows of houses or tenements, often with several families to a room and no running water.
  • Public health. Without sewers or clean water, diseases such as cholera and typhoid spread. A cholera epidemic in London in 1854 led the physician John Snow to trace it to a contaminated water pump, which helped show how disease spread by water.
  • Pollution. Coal smoke blackened the air, and factories dumped waste into rivers.
  • Crime and poverty. Poverty and crowding produced crime and social tension, and cities created police forces.

Governments gradually responded with reforms, such as sewers, water supply, building codes, parks, and public transport, and by the late 1800s cities in the industrial world had become cleaner and healthier. In many other regions, industrial and colonial cities, such as Calcutta, Shanghai, and Cairo, grew quickly and faced similar problems.

Standards of living

Historians debate how industrialization changed living standards. In the early decades, many workers saw little improvement, and some, such as handloom weavers, lost income. Over the long run, as productivity grew and wages and public health improved, living standards in industrial countries rose substantially. The cost was borne unevenly, by class, by gender, and by region.

Description of: Engels on Manchester

Description of Friedrich Engels's The Condition of the Working Class in England (1845), based on his observations in Manchester in the early 1840s. This is a description, not a quotation.

Engels, the son of a mill owner, described the crowded and filthy districts where workers lived, the lack of sewers and clean water, the sickness and short lives of the poor, and the long hours of factory labor, including that of women and children. He blamed the system of factory ownership for these conditions.

Sourcing (HIPP). Engels was a German radical who managed his father's business in Manchester, so his point of view is that of a critic of capitalism with close access to the city. The purpose was to expose the workers' conditions and to argue that capitalism produced misery, and the audience was German and English readers, including reformers. Because he was a committed socialist, he emphasized the worst conditions, yet his description is supported by other official inquiries of the time.

Source analysis · Conditions in the industrial city

Claim. Industrial cities such as Manchester had harsh living conditions for workers.

Evidence. Engels described crowded, filthy districts without sewers or clean water, sickness among the poor, and long factory hours.

Reasoning. An observer with direct access describing crowding, disease, and long hours provides evidence for the conditions the CED lists, and other government inquiries support him. A limit is that he was a socialist writing to condemn capitalism, so he may have emphasized the worst conditions and overlooked improvements.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change and one continuity in the lives of women in industrializing societies.

Model. One change was that middle-class women were increasingly limited to the household and child-rearing, as the husband's income was expected to support the family. One continuity was that working-class women continued to work for wages to support their families, as women had long contributed to household income, though now in factories and for low pay.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5J asks how industrialization changed social hierarchies and standards of living. Be ready with classes (middle class, working class), gender and family (working-class wage earning, middle-class domesticity), and urban problems (pollution, poverty, crime, disease, housing, infrastructure). Add that reforms followed and that effects were uneven.

Practice
  1. What new social classes appeared with industrialization?
    Show answer

    The middle class (bourgeoisie) and the industrial working class.

  2. How did roles differ for working-class and middle-class women?
    Show answer

    Working-class women and children usually earned wages to supplement family income, while middle-class women were increasingly limited to the household and child-rearing.

  3. Name two problems of rapid urbanization.
    Show answer

    Pollution, poverty, crime, disease, housing shortages, and lack of sewers and clean water.

  4. What did John Snow show in 1854?
    Show answer

    That a cholera epidemic in London was linked to a contaminated water pump, which helped show how disease spread through water.

  5. How did governments respond to urban problems?
    Show answer

    They gradually built sewers and clean water supplies, set building codes, created parks and public transport, and set up police forces.

  6. Why might Engels's account be biased?
    Show answer

    He was a socialist who wanted to condemn capitalism, so he may have emphasized the worst conditions, though other inquiries support much of his account.

Lesson 5.13 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.10

Continuity and change in the industrial age

This lesson practices continuity and change over time for Unit 5. The CED question is: to what extent did industrialization bring change from 1750 to 1900? A strong response states what changed, what stayed the same, and how much each matters, with specific evidence.

Required content · 5K

Learning objective.

  • 5K. Explain the extent to which industrialization brought change from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.IV. Railroads, steamships, and the telegraph made exploration, development, and communication possible in interior regions globally, which led to increased trade and migration.
  • 5.3.I.A. Enlightenment philosophies applied new ways of understanding and empiricist approaches to both the natural world and human relationships; they also reexamined the role that religion played in public life and emphasized the importance of reason. Philosophers developed new political ideas about the individual, natural rights, and the social contract.
  • 5.3.I. The rise and diffusion of Enlightenment thought that questioned established traditions in all areas of life often preceded revolutions and rebellions against existing governments.
  • 5.3.II.i. Nationalism also became a major force shaping the historical development of states and empires.

Baseline and framework

In 1750, the world's economies were based mainly on farming, with human and animal power, and regional crafts. Governments were mostly monarchies and empires. Britain was not yet industrial, and Asia produced a large share of the world's goods. The unit's developments include industry, revolutions, nationalism, and ideologies.

Evidence of change

  • Energy and technology. Fossil fuels, steam engines, railroads, steamships, and the telegraph transformed production, transport, and communication (Lesson 5.5).
  • Economic organization. Factories, wage labor, joint-stock companies, and free-trade policies reorganized work and business (Lessons 5.3 and 5.7).
  • Global economic balance. Europe and the United States, and later Japan, gained a large share of world manufacturing, while India and the Middle East lost ground (Lesson 5.4).
  • Social structure. New classes appeared, women's roles shifted, and cities grew (Lesson 5.9).
  • Political ideas and states. The CED notes that the rise and diffusion of Enlightenment thought that questioned established traditions in all areas of life often preceded revolutions and rebellions, and that nationalism became a major force shaping the historical development of states and empires. Revolutions created republics in the Americas, and nationalism created new states and strained empires (Lessons 5.2a to 5.2c). Reform movements also expanded rights (Lesson 5.1).
  • Transport and migration. Railroads, steamships, and the telegraph led to increased trade and migration (Lesson 5.5).

Evidence of continuity

  • Farming remained the main occupation. Even in 1900, most of the world's people lived on the land, in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and much of Europe, including Russia.
  • Hierarchy and patriarchy. Landed elites kept power in many places, and men dominated politics and most paid work. Women's suffrage was still unachieved nearly everywhere.
  • Coerced labor. Slavery continued in some places for decades. The Atlantic trade ended and slavery ended in the British empire in 1833, in the United States in 1865, and in Brazil in 1888, but new forms of coerced and semi-coerced labor, such as indentured labor, grew (Lesson 6.6).
  • Empire and unequal power. Rather than disappearing, empires grew stronger by using industrial technology, which Unit 6 covers.
  • Religion. Religious belief and practice remained important almost everywhere.

Judging extent

A good thesis might read: Industrialization brought profound change in production, transport, and the balance of global power between 1750 and 1900, but continuity in farming as the main work, in political and gender hierarchies, and in coerced labor meant that for most of the world's people the change was gradual and uneven. Notice that the thesis takes a position, names categories, and qualifies its claim with "most" and "uneven."

Different groups experienced change differently. For a British factory owner or a Japanese official, the change was dramatic. For an Indian weaver, it meant decline. For a farmer in West Africa, it might first mean new demand for cash crops. For a woman in a middle-class household in Britain, it meant new expectations and limits. A good analysis acknowledges these differences.

Description of: the Great Exhibition

Description of the Great Exhibition of 1851, held in the Crystal Palace in London. This is a description, not a quotation.

The exhibition displayed more than 100,000 objects from Britain, its empire, and other countries, including machines, tools, textiles, and raw materials. The huge glass-and-iron building was itself an example of industrial technology. Millions of visitors came, many by railroad.

Sourcing (HIPP). The exhibition was organized by Prince Albert and a committee of British officials and businessmen, so its point of view is that of the British establishment. The purpose was to display British industrial leadership and promote free trade and progress. The audience was the British public and the world. Because it was designed to celebrate Britain, it shows how its leaders wanted industrialization to be understood, and it is silent about the costs borne by workers and colonial peoples.

Source analysis · A showcase of progress

Claim. British leaders in 1851 viewed industrialization as a source of national pride and progress.

Evidence. The Great Exhibition displayed machines and goods from Britain and its empire in a building of glass and iron, and drew millions of visitors, many by railroad.

Reasoning. An event that put industrial products and technology on public display shows the confidence of the organizers, and the large attendance suggests wide interest. A limit is that it was designed to celebrate Britain, so it leaves out the hardships of workers and the costs of empire.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in the global economy from 1750 to 1900.

Model. One change was the shift in industrial power, as Europe and the United States came to produce most of the world's manufactured goods while India's and China's shares fell. One continuity was that agriculture remained the main occupation for most of the world's people, and many economies still depended on peasant farming.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 5K asks the extent to which industrialization brought change. Give a thesis that judges extent, with at least two changes and two continuities from the unit. Note that different groups experienced change differently, and use words such as "gradual," "uneven," and "primarily."

Practice
  1. What makes a strong continuity-and-change thesis?
    Show answer

    It names specific changes and continuities and judges their extent with a qualified claim.

  2. Name two changes industrialization brought.
    Show answer

    New energy and technology (steam, railroads, telegraph), factory production, new classes, urban growth, and a shift of manufacturing power to Europe and the United States.

  3. Name two continuities.
    Show answer

    Farming as the main occupation, male dominance, landed elites' power in many places, coerced labor, and the importance of religion.

  4. How did experiences of change differ?
    Show answer

    A British factory owner saw dramatic gains, an Indian weaver saw decline, a farmer might see new demand for cash crops, and middle-class women faced new expectations and limits.

  5. How did industrialization affect empire?
    Show answer

    Industrial technology strengthened empires and helped them expand, rather than ending them.

  6. Why is the Great Exhibition limited as a source on industrialization?
    Show answer

    It was designed to celebrate Britain, so it leaves out the hardships of workers and the costs of empire.

Unit 5 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 5 review: Revolutions, c. 1750–c. 1900

Ten questions on Enlightenment thought, the Atlantic and Latin American revolutions, nationalism and unification, industrialization and its causes, and the social consequences of industrial work, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Jean-Jacques Rousseau, The Social Contract, 1762; early English translation.

    "Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains. One thinks himself the master of others, and still remains a greater slave than they."

    This passage is most directly a challenge to which prevailing idea?

    Correct. Beginning from natural freedom makes existing authority something requiring justification, which undercuts claims resting on inheritance or divine sanction.

    Rousseau shared the Enlightenment confidence in reason; the passage is about political legitimacy rather than natural philosophy.

    Economic regulation is not the subject here, and the argument concerns the basis of political obligation.

    Toleration was an Enlightenment theme, but this passage concerns freedom and authority rather than religion.

  2. Which best explains why the Haitian Revolution posed a distinctive challenge to the Atlantic order?

    Haiti became a republic, and the constitutional monarchy description fits neither the revolution nor its significance.

    Correct. Other revolutions had claimed universal rights while preserving slavery; Haiti took the claim literally, which is why the United States and European powers isolated it for decades.

    It involved more than a decade of warfare against French, Spanish, and British forces.

    It ended French rule and abolished slavery, the opposite of restoring colonial authority.

  3. Source: Simón Bolívar, "Letter from Jamaica," 1815; early English translation.

    "We are … neither Indian nor European, but a species midway between the legitimate proprietors of this country and the Spanish usurpers."

    Bolívar's characterization of creole identity was most consequential because

    Correct. Leadership by creoles who saw themselves as neither indigenous nor European produced republics that replaced Spanish officials while leaving social hierarchies largely in place.

    Bolívar personally opposed slavery, but the new republics retained racial hierarchies and the passage makes no equality commitment.

    Independence was won through long and destructive wars, not negotiation.

    He places creoles between indigenous people and Spaniards, and indigenous communities did not lead the new states.

  4. Nationalism contributed to both unification and fragmentation in the nineteenth century because it

    Correct. The same principle pulled the German and Italian states together and pulled at the seams of the Austrian and Ottoman empires, because everything depends on where national boundaries are drawn.

    Nationalism emerged largely from intellectuals and middle-class movements; rulers such as Bismarck later harnessed it.

    It also operated within states, as in Germany and Italy, where the units being joined were not foreign empires.

    Unification movements typically built on existing institutions, as Prussia's did in Germany.

  5. Which factor is most important in explaining why industrialization began in Britain?

    Industrialization rested on many incremental improvements and their adoption, and the technologies spread quickly once conditions elsewhere allowed.

    Correct. No single factor is sufficient; it was fuel, food, capital, labor freed from the land, and secure property rights arriving together that mattered.

    Britain faced intense commercial competition from the Netherlands and France throughout the period.

    British industry was overwhelmingly privately owned and financed, not state-directed.

  6. Source: testimony gathered by a British parliamentary committee on child labor in textile factories, 1832.

    Asked what time the girls began work, a witness answers that in the brisk season they worked from five in the morning until nine at night, with forty minutes allowed at noon for the only break. Asked whether the children were tired, he answers that they were and that overseers strapped them to keep them awake.

    Which consideration is most important in evaluating this testimony?

    Correct. The evidence is valuable and was corroborated, but it was collected to support a legislative campaign, which shaped which witnesses were called and how they were questioned.

    Such testimony is central evidence for industrial conditions; it simply requires attention to how it was produced.

    The witness describes working hours and treatment from direct observation.

    Factory records, inspectors' reports, and other inquiries document hours as well, which is how corroboration is possible.

  7. The factory system changed the experience of work most fundamentally by

    Correct. Under the putting-out system households controlled their own rhythm; the factory moved work to a separate place and set its pace by the machine and the clock.

    Women and children were central to early factory workforces, often preferred because they could be paid less.

    Hours in early factories were long, frequently exceeding those of the work they replaced.

    Pace was set by machinery and overseers, which is the defining loss of control workers protested.

  8. Source: Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The Communist Manifesto, 1848; authorized English translation.

    "The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionising the instruments of production … Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch."

    The passage is best read as an argument that

    The passage insists on the opposite, describing constant disturbance as the epoch's defining feature.

    Correct. The authors argue that the system must keep transforming production to survive, and that social disruption follows necessarily from that.

    The Manifesto credits the bourgeoisie with enormous productive achievement and does not call for halting technology.

    Elsewhere in the same text the authors describe bourgeois productive achievement in strikingly admiring terms.

  9. Government responses to industrial conditions in nineteenth-century Europe most commonly took the form of

    Nationalization under worker control was a program of the revolutionary left, not the policy states adopted.

    Correct. Factory acts limiting children's hours came first as the most politically achievable measure, and union rights were conceded slowly over decades.

    The direction of legislation was toward restriction, however gradual and imperfectly enforced.

    No such redistribution occurred; the argument over ownership remained largely theoretical in this period.

  10. Which best describes the global economic effect of British industrialization on India by the mid-nineteenth century?

    Correct. Machine-spun British cloth undersold handloom production while tariff arrangements favored British goods, converting India from a leading textile exporter into a market for British cloth and a supplier of raw cotton.

    Substantial Indian industrialization came much later and was constrained by colonial policy.

    Indian textile exports collapsed over this period rather than expanding, because the mills of Lancashire could produce cloth far more cheaply than handloom weavers could.

    Britain expanded its presence in India across this period rather than withdrawing.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE Enlightenment idea that influenced a revolution between 1750 and 1900.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the outcome of a revolution differed from the ideas that inspired it.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way nationalism reshaped political boundaries in the nineteenth century.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: natural rights; popular sovereignty and the social contract; separation of powers; equality before the law; the argument that legitimacy rests on consent. Must connect the idea to a revolution.
    • (b) Accept: French declarations of universal rights alongside continued colonial slavery until 1794 and its attempted restoration under Napoleon; American independence with slavery intact; Latin American republics preserving racial hierarchy; the Terror and Napoleonic rule following from a republic. Must name the gap between principle and outcome.
    • (c) Accept: German unification under Prussia; Italian unification; Greek and Balkan independence from Ottoman rule; strains on the Austrian and Ottoman multi-ethnic empires. Must connect nationalism to a boundary change.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Enlightenment writers argued that legitimate government rests on the consent of the governed rather than on inheritance or divine right. Rousseau's claim that people are born free made existing authority something that had to justify itself, and revolutionaries in North America, France, and Latin America drew on that claim directly.

    (b) The French revolutionaries declared rights they described as universal while slavery continued in France's most profitable colony. The National Convention abolished it in 1794 only after the enslaved population of Saint-Domingue had already risen and made the old order unworkable, and Napoleon attempted to restore it in 1802, so the universal claim was applied only when force compelled it.

    (c) Nationalism held that political borders should follow national communities, and Prussia used that principle to draw the German states into a single empire proclaimed in 1871. The same principle worked in the opposite direction on the Austrian and Ottoman empires, whose many national groups had every reason to seek states of their own.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE cause of industrialization in Britain.
    2. Briefly explain ONE social consequence of industrialization.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way industrialization altered the relationship between industrialized states and other parts of the world.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: accessible coal and iron; agricultural improvement freeing labor; capital accumulated from Atlantic trade; property rights and patent law; access to colonial raw materials and markets; a dense internal transport network. Must identify a cause.
    • (b) Accept: rapid urbanization and its sanitary consequences; new class structures and class consciousness; time discipline replacing household work rhythms; child and female factory labor; the emergence of unions and reform movements. Must explain the consequence.
    • (c) Accept: the decline of Indian handloom textile production; demand for raw materials driving imperial expansion; unequal treaties opening markets in China and Japan; the widening technological and military gap. Must explain the altered relationship.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Britain had large coal deposits close to the surface and near navigable water, which made fuel cheap where it was needed. Steam engines were first developed to pump water out of those very mines, so the resource and the technology for using it developed together.

    (b) Industrial cities grew far faster than housing, water supply, or sewerage could be built, and the result was overcrowding and repeated epidemics of cholera and typhus. The crisis was severe enough that it eventually forced governments into public health measures they had previously regarded as outside their responsibility.

    (c) Machine-made British cloth undersold Indian handloom textiles in their own market while tariff arrangements favored British goods, so a region that had been the world's leading textile exporter became a supplier of raw cotton and a market for British cloth. Industrialization thus converted a trading relationship into a colonial one.

Lesson 6.1 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.1

Rationales for imperialism

Industrial Europe, the United States, and Japan took control of huge areas of the world between about 1750 and 1900. The CED asks how ideologies contributed to the development of imperialism. It says that a range of cultural, religious, and racial ideologies were used to justify imperialism, including Social Darwinism, nationalism, the concept of the civilizing mission, and the desire to religiously convert indigenous populations. This lesson explains each ideology, and shows how economic and strategic motives worked beside them.

Required content · 6A

Learning objective.

  • 6A. Explain how ideologies contributed to the development of imperialism from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.2.III. A range of cultural, religious, and racial ideologies were used to justify imperialism, including Social Darwinism, nationalism, the concept of the civilizing mission, and the desire to religiously convert indigenous populations.

Imperialism and its meaning

Imperialism is the policy of extending a state's power over other territories and peoples, by conquest, settlement, or economic and political control. Empires were not new, as earlier lessons showed. What was new after about 1850 was the speed and scale of expansion by industrial states, which had the steamships, railroads, telegraphs, rifles, and machine guns to carry it out. Historians call this period the new imperialism.

The ideologies

  • Social Darwinism. The English naturalist Charles Darwin published On the Origin of Species in 1859, explaining how species change over time by natural selection. Thinkers such as Herbert Spencer applied the idea of "survival of the fittest" to human societies, claiming that some races and nations were naturally superior and that the strong were destined to rule the weak. This was a distortion of Darwin's biological theory, but it gave imperial expansion a pseudo-scientific justification and supported racist ideas.
  • Nationalism. National pride and rivalry drove states to compete for colonies as a measure of greatness. A state with an empire could claim to be a great power. Politicians and newspapers urged the public to support expansion, so that nationalism and imperialism fed each other (Lesson 5.2c).
  • The civilizing mission. Many Europeans argued that they had a duty to bring "civilization," meaning their own education, laws, technology, and religion, to peoples they regarded as backward. In France this was called the mission civilisatrice. Critics noted that the claim hid exploitation, and that colonial rule often provided little education or health care.
  • Religious conversion. Christian missionaries, Protestant and Catholic, worked across Africa, Asia, and the Pacific. Many sincerely sought to convert and to help, by building schools and hospitals, and some opposed abuses. Others supported colonial rule. The CED includes the desire to religiously convert indigenous populations among the justifications.

Other motives

Ideology was not the only cause. Historians point also to:

  • Economic motives: access to raw materials such as rubber, cotton, and minerals, new markets for factory goods, and places to invest surplus capital (Lessons 6.4 and 6.5).
  • Strategic motives: naval bases, coaling stations, and control of routes such as the Suez Canal to guard routes to India and compete with rival powers.
  • Political motives: the wish of leaders to win domestic support by foreign successes.

Ideologies helped people explain and defend what economic and strategic interests had already prompted. They also shaped how colonial rule worked, with racial hierarchies built into law and daily life in many colonies.

Contextualization

The skill for this topic is contextualization, which means placing a source or development in its broader historical setting. On the exam, a document written in 1899 would have to be read in the light of industrial power, racial science, nationalism, and recent imperial wars. The more completely you can describe the setting, the better you can judge what the author wanted and why readers might have agreed or objected.

Primary source · The "White Man's Burden"

Rudyard Kipling, "The White Man's Burden" (1899), opening lines. Kipling was an English writer born in India. The poem was published in the United States as it debated annexing the Philippines.

Take up the White Man's burden, Send forth the best ye breed, Go bind your sons to exile To serve your captives' need.

Sourcing (HIPP). Kipling, a British writer and defender of empire, wrote the poem in 1899 as the United States, after the Spanish-American War, decided whether to keep the Philippines. His point of view is that of an imperialist who saw colonial rule as a heavy duty. The purpose was to urge Americans to take on the task of ruling, and the audience was the American public and politicians. The poem calls colonized people "captives," which reveals the unequal view it promotes, and it frames conquest as sacrifice for the benefit of others, which many colonized people and critics rejected.

Source analysis · The civilizing mission

Claim. Supporters of empire presented it as a duty to help others.

Evidence. Kipling urged readers to send forth their best sons into exile "to serve your captives' need."

Reasoning. Presenting rule as sacrificial service to those who need it is the civilizing-mission argument, which turned conquest into duty. A limit is that the poem was written to persuade Americans to take the Philippines, so it reflects an advocate's view, and it assumes that colonized people were inferior and needed rule.

Worked example · Contextualization

Question. Explain one broader historical context for the rise of the new imperialism.

Model. One context was industrialization, since the steamships, railroads, telegraphs, and rifles that industrial economies produced gave Europe, the United States, and Japan the means to conquer and control distant lands, while the need for raw materials and markets gave them reasons to do so.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6A asks how ideologies contributed to imperialism. Define Social Darwinism, nationalism, the civilizing mission, and religious conversion, and note economic and strategic motives alongside them. For contextualization, link a source to industrial power, racial ideas, and great-power rivalry.

Practice
  1. What is imperialism?
    Show answer

    The policy of extending a state's power over other territories and peoples by conquest, settlement, or economic and political control.

  2. What was Social Darwinism?
    Show answer

    The application of Darwin's idea of survival of the fittest to human societies, used to claim that some races and nations were superior.

  3. What was the civilizing mission?
    Show answer

    The belief that Europeans had a duty to bring their own education, laws, technology, and religion to peoples they considered backward.

  4. Name one non-ideological motive for imperialism.
    Show answer

    Access to raw materials, markets for factory goods, places to invest capital, naval bases, or political advantage at home.

  5. Why did industrialization make the new imperialism possible?
    Show answer

    It supplied steamships, railroads, telegraphs, and modern weapons that allowed industrial states to conquer and control distant lands.

  6. What does contextualization mean?
    Show answer

    Placing a source or development within its broader historical setting.

Lesson 6.2 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.2

European empires in Africa and Asia

The CED asks students to compare processes by which state power shifted in various parts of the world from 1750 to 1900. This lesson covers the expansion of European states in Africa and Asia. The next covers settler colonies and the expansion of the United States, Russia, and Japan.

Required content · 6B

Learning objective.

  • 6B. Compare processes by which state power shifted in various parts of the world from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.2.I.A. Some states with existing colonies strengthened their control over those colonies and in some cases assumed direct control over colonies previously held by non-state entities.
  • 5.2.I.B. European states as well as the United States and Japan acquired territories throughout Asia and the Pacific, while Spanish and Portuguese influence declined.
  • 5.2.I.C. Many European states used both warfare and diplomacy to expand their empires in Africa.

Strengthening control over existing colonies

The CED says that some states with existing colonies strengthened their control over those colonies and in some cases assumed direct control over colonies previously held by non-state entities. Earlier empires had often relied on chartered companies. In the nineteenth century, governments took over.

  • India. The British East India Company had become the ruler of much of India. After the Indian Rebellion of 1857 (Lesson 6.3), Parliament abolished the Company in 1858, and the British crown took direct control of India, ruling through a viceroy. In 1877 Queen Victoria was proclaimed empress of India.
  • Indonesia. The Dutch East India Company, which had ruled parts of Southeast Asia, went bankrupt, and the Dutch government took control of its holdings in 1800 and expanded them through the 1800s.
  • The Congo. King Leopold II of Belgium claimed the Congo basin as a private possession after the Berlin Conference of 1884 to 1885, and his agents forced Africans to collect rubber, mutilating and killing many. International protest forced Belgium's government to take the colony over in 1908.

The scramble for Africa

In 1800, Europeans controlled little of the African interior, apart from coastal posts and settlements such as the Cape. Steamships, the quinine used against malaria, and repeating rifles and machine guns changed this. After about 1880, European states raced to claim African territory, a process called the scramble for Africa. At the Berlin Conference (1884 to 1885), delegates from European states, with no African representatives, set rules for claiming African land, including the principle of "effective occupation." By 1914, only Ethiopia and Liberia remained independent.

The CED says that many European states used both warfare and diplomacy to expand their empires in Africa. Examples are Britain in West Africa and Egypt and southern Africa, France in West Africa, and Belgium in the Congo. They made treaties with some local rulers, often unequal or misunderstood, and used force against those who resisted. Borders were drawn to fit European agreements, which cut across many African peoples and kingdoms and left a lasting mark.

1830 France invades Algeria 1857 Indian Rebellion 1858 Britain takes direct rule of India 1869 Suez Canal opens 1884 Berlin Conference begins 1898 Spanish-American War; US gains colonies 1899 Boer War begins 1914 Only Ethiopia and Liberia remain independent
Figure 6.1. Selected steps in imperial expansion. By 1914 nearly all of Africa and much of Asia and the Pacific were under outside control.

Asia and the Pacific

The CED says that European states as well as the United States and Japan acquired territories throughout Asia and the Pacific, while Spanish and Portuguese influence declined.

  • South and Southeast Asia. Britain added Burma (1824 to 1886) and Malaya, and France conquered Indochina (Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos) between the 1860s and 1890s. Only Siam (Thailand) stayed independent, by balancing British and French interests and modernizing.
  • China. European powers and Japan did not divide China as a colony, but they took ports and carved out "spheres of influence" (Lesson 6.5).
  • The Pacific. Britain, France, Germany, and the United States claimed island groups.
  • Decline of Spain and Portugal. Spain lost almost all of its American empire by the 1820s and the rest of its colonies, including the Philippines, to the United States in 1898. Portugal held on to Angola, Mozambique, and a few Asian ports but was a minor power.

Methods

States used several tools to expand: military force supported by industrial weapons, treaties with local rulers, economic pressure, the use of local troops, such as the sepoys of India, and divide-and-rule policies that played groups against each other. Colonial governments set up different systems, sometimes direct rule with European officials, and sometimes indirect rule that worked through local leaders.

Primary source · A novelist on conquest

Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness (1899).

The conquest of the earth, which mostly means the taking it away from those who have a different complexion or slightly flatter noses than ourselves, is not a pretty thing when you look into it too much.

Sourcing (HIPP). Conrad was a Polish-born British novelist who had worked on a steamer in the Congo in 1890, and the line is spoken by the narrator, Marlow, in a work of fiction. The point of view is that of a critical observer, though the novel has also been criticized for its portrayal of Africans. The purpose was literary and critical, to explore the moral costs of imperialism, and the audience was British readers of a magazine. Since it is fiction, it cannot be used as proof of events, but it shows that some contemporaries saw the racial basis of conquest and judged it harshly.

Source analysis · A critical voice

Claim. Some Europeans in 1899 criticized the racial basis of imperial conquest.

Evidence. Conrad's narrator says conquest means taking land from people who look different, and that it is "not a pretty thing."

Reasoning. The line names the racial logic of conquest and judges it harshly, which shows that not all contemporaries accepted the civilizing mission (Lesson 6.1). A limit is that it is a line from fiction and that the novel has been criticized for its own portrayal of Africans, so it shows one writer's ambivalent view and not general opinion.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between British rule in India after 1858 and Belgian rule in the Congo.

Model. In both cases a government took direct control from a private body, the British crown from the East India Company and the Belgian state from King Leopold II. A difference is that the Congo had been run as a personal possession of the king under a brutal system of forced rubber collection, while British India was a larger and older colony governed through a bureaucracy that included Indian officials and sepoy troops.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6B asks you to compare processes by which state power shifted. Use CED examples: shift from non-state to state control (India 1858, Congo 1908, Dutch Indonesia), the scramble for Africa (Berlin Conference, warfare and diplomacy), and Asia and the Pacific. Note that Spanish and Portuguese influence declined.

Practice
  1. What happened to the East India Company's rule in India?
    Show answer

    After the Rebellion of 1857, Parliament abolished the Company in 1858 and the British crown took direct control.

  2. What was the Berlin Conference?
    Show answer

    A meeting of European states in 1884 to 1885 that set rules for claiming African land, without African representatives.

  3. Which two African states remained independent in 1914?
    Show answer

    Ethiopia and Liberia.

  4. How did Europeans expand in Africa?
    Show answer

    With both warfare and diplomacy, using treaties with some rulers and force against others, aided by steamships, quinine, and modern rifles.

  5. Which Southeast Asian state stayed independent?
    Show answer

    Siam (Thailand), by balancing British and French interests and modernizing.

  6. Why is Heart of Darkness limited as historical evidence?
    Show answer

    It is fiction and the novel has been criticized for its portrayal of Africans, so it shows one writer's view and not facts about events.

Lesson 6.3 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.2

Settler colonies and expanding land empires

Not all imperial expansion looked like the European partition of Africa. The CED says that Europeans established settler colonies in some parts of their empires, and that the United States, Russia, and Japan expanded their land holdings by conquering and settling neighboring territories. This lesson covers these two patterns.

Required content · 6B

Learning objective.

  • 6B. Compare processes by which state power shifted in various parts of the world from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.2.I.B. European states as well as the United States and Japan acquired territories throughout Asia and the Pacific, while Spanish and Portuguese influence declined.
  • 5.2.I.D. Europeans established settler colonies in some parts of their empires.
  • 5.2.II.B. The United States, Russia, and Japan expanded their land holdings by conquering and settling neighboring territories.

Settler colonies

A settler colony is one in which large numbers of colonists from the home country move permanently to the colony, take land, and often outnumber or displace the Indigenous population. This differs from an extractive colony, where a small group of officials and merchants rules a large local population and takes its resources.

  • New Zealand. British settlers began arriving in large numbers in the 1830s. In 1840, Maori chiefs and Britain signed the Treaty of Waitangi, but the English and Maori versions differed on whether the Maori had given up sovereignty. Settlers pressed for land, and wars in the 1860s (Lesson 5.2c) ended with large confiscations of Maori land.
  • Australia. Britain claimed the continent in 1788 and used it first as a place to send convicts, and the Aboriginal population fell sharply from violence and disease as settlers took land.
  • South Africa. Dutch settlers (Boers) and British settlers competed for land with each other and with African peoples, and the discovery of gold and diamonds drew more. The Boer War (1899 to 1902) ended with British victory.
  • Algeria. France conquered Algeria from 1830 and settled many Europeans there, and Algeria was legally part of France, though most Algerians lacked equal rights.
  • Canada and others. Settlers also expanded in Canada and Argentina.

In settler colonies, Indigenous peoples often lost land, population, and independence. Settlers set up their own governments and economies, and some, such as Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, later gained self-government within the British Empire.

The United States

After independence, the United States expanded across North America. The Louisiana Purchase (1803) doubled its size, and later acquisitions included Florida, Texas, and, after war with Mexico (1846 to 1848), California and the Southwest. The government pushed Native peoples, such as the Cherokee in the 1838 "Trail of Tears," off their land by treaty, force, and removal. In 1898, after the Spanish-American War, the United States gained Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines, and annexed Hawaii, which marked its entry into overseas empire.

Russia

Russia continued to expand over land. It took more of Central Asia in the 1800s, conquering the khanates of Kokand, Bukhara, and Khiva, and in the Far East it gained territory from China by treaty in 1858 and 1860, founding Vladivostok in 1860. This expansion brought Russians into contact and conflict with many Muslim and Asian peoples. The CED's category covers land empires such as Russia that expanded by conquering and settling neighboring territories.

Japan

After the Meiji reforms (Lesson 5.6), Japan began to expand. It took the Ryukyu Islands in the 1870s, Taiwan and an influence over Korea after its victory over China in 1894 to 1895, and southern Sakhalin and more influence in Korea and Manchuria after defeating Russia in 1904 to 1905. In 1910 it formally annexed Korea. Japan thus became the first non-Western imperial power and a model for others who wished to resist colonization.

Comparing patterns

PatternExampleFeatures
Partition of a region by outside powersAfricaTreaties, force, borders set by Europeans
Settler colonyNew Zealand, Australia, AlgeriaLarge-scale settlement, loss of Indigenous land
Continental expansionUnited States, RussiaExpansion into neighboring land, settlement
Expansion by a newly industrial stateJapanUsed modern army and navy against neighbors

The CED also stresses that Spanish and Portuguese influence declined as these newer powers rose.

Description of: the Treaty of Waitangi

Description of the Treaty of Waitangi, signed on February 6, 1840, by representatives of the British crown and many Maori chiefs. This is a description, not a quotation.

The treaty has an English text and a Maori text. In English, the chiefs "cede" sovereignty to the Queen. The Maori text uses a word that many Maori understood as governance rather than ultimate authority, and it guarantees chiefs their "chieftainship" over their lands and treasures.

Sourcing (HIPP). The treaty was drafted by British officials and translated by a missionary, so the point of view is that of the crown and its representatives, though chiefs also took part. The purpose was to establish British authority and to regulate the settlers' land purchases. The audience was the Maori chiefs, who signed, and the British public. The difference between the texts shows why the treaty has been disputed ever since, and it is evidence that the two sides may have understood the agreement differently.

Source analysis · Two texts, two meanings

Claim. The Maori and the British may have understood the Treaty of Waitangi differently.

Evidence. The English text speaks of ceding sovereignty, while the Maori text uses a word many Maori read as governance and guarantees the chiefs' authority over their lands and treasures.

Reasoning. If the two texts do not match on the central point of sovereignty, the signers could have believed they were agreeing to different things, which helps explain later disputes about land. A limit is that the question of what individual chiefs understood is debated, so the texts alone do not settle it.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the expansion of the United States and the expansion of Russia in the 1800s.

Model. Both expanded over land into neighboring territories and settled them, pushing aside or ruling the peoples who lived there, such as Native Americans and the Muslim peoples of Central Asia. A difference is that the United States, after 1898, also acquired overseas colonies such as Puerto Rico and the Philippines, while Russia remained a land empire.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6B again asks you to compare processes. Contrast settler colonies (New Zealand, Australia, South Africa, Algeria) with extractive and partitioned colonies, and add continental expansion by the United States, Russia, and Japan. Explain how each expanded and what happened to the people already there.

Practice
  1. What is a settler colony?
    Show answer

    A colony in which many colonists from the home country settle permanently, take land, and often displace or outnumber the Indigenous population.

  2. What was the Treaty of Waitangi?
    Show answer

    A 1840 treaty between the British crown and many Maori chiefs, whose English and Maori texts differed on whether sovereignty was ceded.

  3. How did the United States expand in the 1800s?
    Show answer

    Across North America by purchase, war, and the removal of Native peoples, and after 1898 overseas into Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines, and Hawaii.

  4. Where did Russia expand?
    Show answer

    Across Central Asia and in the Far East, where it gained territory from China and founded Vladivostok in 1860.

  5. How did Japan become an imperial power?
    Show answer

    After the Meiji reforms it used a modern army and navy to take Taiwan, gain influence in Korea, defeat Russia in 1904 to 1905, and annex Korea in 1910.

  6. Why do the two texts of the Waitangi treaty matter to historians?
    Show answer

    They differ on sovereignty, so the two sides may have understood the agreement differently, which helps explain later disputes.

Lesson 6.4 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.3

Responses to imperial expansion

Colonized peoples did not accept foreign rule quietly. The CED asks how internal and external factors influenced the process of state building, and says that increasing questions about political authority and growing nationalism contributed to anticolonial movements, that anti-imperial resistance took various forms, including direct resistance within empires and the creation of new states on the peripheries, and that increasing discontent with imperial rule led to rebellions, some of which were influenced by religious ideas. This lesson covers each type.

Required content · 6C

Learning objective.

  • 6C. Explain how and why internal and external factors have influenced the process of state building from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.3.III.D. Increasing questions about political authority and growing nationalism contributed to anticolonial movements.
  • 5.2.II.C. Anti-imperial resistance took various forms, including direct resistance within empires and the creation of new states on the peripheries.
  • 5.3.III.E. Increasing discontent with imperial rule led to rebellions, some of which were influenced by religious ideas.

Direct resistance

The CED lists four examples.

  • Tupac Amaru II's rebellion in Peru (1780 to 1781). José Gabriel Condorcanqui, a descendant of the Inca who took the name Tupac Amaru, led a massive uprising in the Andes against Spanish taxes and forced labor. He was captured and executed in 1781, but the revolt shook Spanish rule.
  • Samory Toure's military battles in West Africa. Samory Toure built an empire in the upper Niger region in the 1870s and fought French forces for about sixteen years, using modern rifles and clever tactics, until his capture in 1898.
  • The Yaa Asantewaa War (1900). Yaa Asantewaa, the queen mother of an Asante state in what is now Ghana, led the Asante in a rising against British demands, including a demand for the Golden Stool, the sacred symbol of Asante unity. The British put down the revolt and exiled her, but they never captured the Stool.
  • The 1857 rebellion in India. Indian soldiers (sepoys) in the East India Company's army rose in anger over rumors that new rifle cartridges were greased with animal fat, over annexations, and over wider fear that the British threatened religion and custom. Civilians joined them in northern and central India. The British crushed the revolt in 1858, with great brutality, and then took direct control of India (Lesson 6.2a).

New states on the peripheries

The CED says anti-imperial resistance also included the creation of new states on the peripheries, and lists several.

  • Independent states in the Balkans. Serbia, Greece, Romania, and Bulgaria gained independence from the Ottoman Empire in the 1800s (Lesson 5.2c).
  • Sokoto Caliphate. In 1804, the Muslim scholar Usman dan Fodio led a jihad against Hausa rulers he judged to be unjust, and he founded the Sokoto Caliphate in what is now northern Nigeria, which became one of the largest states in West Africa.
  • Cherokee Nation. The Cherokee adopted a written constitution in 1827, a writing system created by Sequoyah, and a government on the American model, but were forced west by the United States government in the 1830s.
  • Zulu Kingdom. Under Shaka (r. c. 1816 to 1828), the Zulu built a powerful military state in southern Africa that fought neighbors and later the British.

Rebellions with religious ideas

The CED notes that some rebellions were influenced by religious ideas. Examples are:

  • The Ghost Dance among Plains peoples in the United States, which spread in 1889 to 1890 from a Paiute prophet, Wovoka, who taught that dance and ritual would bring back the dead and drive out white settlers. Fear of the movement contributed to the US Army's massacre of Lakota people at Wounded Knee in 1890.
  • The Xhosa Cattle-Killing Movement (1856 to 1857) in southern Africa, in which a prophecy told the Xhosa to kill their cattle and destroy their crops so that ancestors would rise and drive out the British. The result was famine and a loss of Xhosa independence.
  • The Mahdist wars in Sudan. In 1881, Muhammad Ahmad proclaimed himself the Mahdi, an expected redeemer in Islam, and led a movement against Egyptian and British rule. His forces killed General Charles Gordon at Khartoum in 1885 and held the Sudan until a British army defeated them in 1898.

Successful resistance

A few states beat back imperial powers. Ethiopia, under Emperor Menelik II, defeated an Italian army at the Battle of Adwa in 1896, preserving its independence. Japan avoided colonization by reform (Lesson 5.6). Such cases were exceptions that inspired anti-colonial thinkers.

Description of: Yaa Asantewaa's call to arms

Description of an address attributed to Yaa Asantewaa, queen mother of Ejisu, to Asante chiefs in 1900. The words are known from oral tradition and later written accounts. This is a description, not a quotation.

The speech, as it is remembered, shames the chiefs for hesitating to resist the British demand for the Golden Stool and says that if the men will not fight, the women will.

Sourcing (HIPP). The account comes from oral tradition and from writers, including some colonial officials, who recorded it later, so the exact words are uncertain. The point of view differs across versions, with Asante tradition praising her leadership and British accounts treating the rising as a rebellion. The purpose of retelling it has often been to honor Asante pride and women's leadership. Because the speech is remembered and not documented, it is better evidence of how the Asante remembered resistance than of exactly what she said in 1900.

Source analysis · Remembered resistance

Claim. Asante tradition remembers Yaa Asantewaa as a leader who defended the nation's honor.

Evidence. The remembered speech shames hesitant chiefs and says the women would fight if the men would not.

Reasoning. The speech as remembered shows how Asante tradition celebrates her courage and the importance of the Golden Stool, and it fits with documented facts that she led the revolt. A limit is that the exact words are uncertain, since they come from oral tradition and later accounts.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause of the Indian Rebellion of 1857.

Model. One cause was the fear among sepoys and civilians that the British threatened Indian religion and custom, as shown by the rumor that new rifle cartridges were greased with animal fat offensive to Hindus and Muslims. Annexations of Indian states and discontent with British rule also fed the revolt.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6C asks how and why internal and external factors influenced state building and resistance. Sort the CED's examples into three groups: direct resistance (Tupac Amaru II, Samory Toure, Yaa Asantewaa, 1857), new states (Balkans, Sokoto, Cherokee, Zulu), and religious rebellions (Ghost Dance, Xhosa Cattle-Killing, Mahdist wars). Add Adwa as a success.

Practice
  1. What triggered the Indian Rebellion of 1857?
    Show answer

    Fear of religious insult, shown by rumors about cartridges greased with animal fat, plus annexations and wider discontent with British rule.

  2. What happened to the East India Company after 1857?
    Show answer

    Parliament abolished it in 1858 and the British crown took direct control of India.

  3. Who was Samory Toure?
    Show answer

    A West African leader who built an empire and fought French forces for about sixteen years until his capture in 1898.

  4. What was the Sokoto Caliphate?
    Show answer

    A large Muslim state in northern Nigeria founded in 1804 by Usman dan Fodio after a jihad against Hausa rulers.

  5. How did the Xhosa Cattle-Killing Movement end?
    Show answer

    The prophecy led the Xhosa to kill their cattle and destroy crops, which caused famine and loss of independence.

  6. Why did Ethiopia remain independent?
    Show answer

    Emperor Menelik II defeated an Italian army at the Battle of Adwa in 1896.

Lesson 6.5 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.4

Export economies and the global market

By the late 1800s, much of the world was tied to the industrial economies as a supplier of raw materials and food. The CED asks how various environmental factors contributed to the development of the global economy and says that the need for raw materials for factories and increased food supplies for the growing population in urban centers led to the growth of export economies around the world that specialized in commercial extraction of natural resources and the production of food and industrial crops. The profits from these raw materials were used to purchase finished goods. This lesson explains these export economies, their examples, and their effects.

Required content · 6D

Learning objective.

  • 6D. Explain how various environmental factors contributed to the development of the global economy from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.1.II.A. The need for raw materials for factories and increased food supplies for the growing population in urban centers led to the growth of export economies around the world that specialized in commercial extraction of natural resources and the production of food and industrial crops. The profits from these raw materials were used to purchase finished goods.

Why export economies grew

Industrial factories needed cotton, rubber, oil, metals, and other inputs. Growing cities in Europe and North America needed food that local farms could not supply. Steamships and railroads, refrigerated ships (from the 1870s), and the telegraph made it cheap and fast to move bulk goods across oceans. Colonial governments and local elites often encouraged cash crops and mining, and some farmers chose them for the money. As a result, regions began to specialize, producing goods for sale abroad and buying manufactured goods from outside.

Examples

The CED lists several.

  • Cotton in Egypt. Egyptian cotton grew on irrigated land along the Nile, especially during the American Civil War (1861 to 1865), when the supply of Southern cotton to Britain's mills was cut off. Egypt's economy came to depend on the crop.
  • Rubber in the Amazon and the Congo basin. Wild rubber was tapped for the tires and equipment of the new industries. In the Congo Free State, workers were forced to meet rubber quotas under brutal punishment, and in the Amazon, tappers were often held in debt. Later, rubber plantations in Southeast Asia displaced wild rubber.
  • The palm oil trade in West Africa. After the slave trade was banned, West African merchants and farmers sold palm oil, used for soap, candles, and machine lubricants, to Europe. This "legitimate trade" brought wealth to some.
  • Guano in Peru and Chile. Peru exported guano, accumulated seabird droppings used as fertilizer, in huge quantities from the 1840s. Peru, Bolivia, and Chile later fought a war over nitrate and mineral resources (1879 to 1884).
  • Meat from Argentina and Uruguay. Refrigerated ships let South American ranchers send beef to Europe from the 1880s.
  • Diamonds from Africa. The discovery of diamonds (1867) and then gold (1886) in South Africa drew migrants and foreign capital, and led to the creation of large mining companies.

Other cases include tea in India and Ceylon, jute in Bengal, sugar in the Caribbean and Hawaii, tin in Malaya, and wheat in the Americas, Australia, and Russia.

Effects

  • Wealth for some. Export economies enriched merchants, landowners, and mining companies, and governments collected taxes on trade. In some places, such as Argentina, exports produced a prosperous economy.
  • Dependence. Economies that relied on one or two exports were exposed to price swings. When the price of cotton, rubber, or sugar fell, whole regions suffered.
  • Unequal exchange. The CED states that profits from raw materials were used to purchase finished goods. Colonies sold cheap raw materials and bought expensive factory goods, which tended to keep industry in the industrial countries, as with Indian textiles (Lesson 5.4).
  • Labor and environment. Plantations and mines relied on low-paid, indentured, or forced labor (Lesson 6.6) and changed landscapes, with deforestation, soil exhaustion, and pollution.
  • Local control. In many places, foreign companies and colonial officials, and not local people, controlled the land and profits.

Environmental factors

The CED's learning objective stresses environmental factors. Resources occurred in particular places, such as guano on dry Pacific islands and coast, rubber in tropical forests, and diamonds in South African rock, so the global economy was built on where natural resources were found. Climate shaped what could grow, while technology allowed these resources to be harvested and shipped.

Description of: a report on Congo rubber

Description of the 1904 report to the British government by Roger Casement, a British consul, on conditions in the Congo Free State. This is a description, not a quotation.

Casement traveled up the Congo River and reported that Africans were forced to collect wild rubber under quotas enforced by armed company agents, that villages were raided and hostages taken to compel delivery, and that people were beaten and killed. His findings helped launch a campaign for reform.

Sourcing (HIPP). Casement was a British government official, so his point of view is that of an outsider sent to investigate for a state that had its own interests, including rivalry with Belgium. The purpose was to report on the treatment of the population, and the audience was the British Foreign Office and, once published, the public. His report was based on direct interviews, which gives it weight, though a government report might stress the abuses of a rival power and say less about those within British colonies.

Source analysis · Cost of an export economy

Claim. Export economies could rely on coercion and cause great suffering.

Evidence. Casement reported that Africans in the Congo were forced to deliver rubber quotas under threat of violence and that villages were raided.

Reasoning. An official's report based on interviews supports the claim that the rubber economy used forced labor and punishment. A limit is that Britain, a rival of Belgium, had reasons to emphasize abuses in the Congo, and similar problems existed in other colonies.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause of the growth of export economies after 1750.

Model. One cause was the demand of industrial factories and growing cities for raw materials and food. Factories in Britain needed cotton and rubber, and urban populations needed grain and meat, and steamships, railroads, and refrigeration made it possible to ship them from far away, so regions such as Egypt and Argentina specialized in export crops.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6D asks about environmental factors in global economic development. Give at least three examples from the CED's list (cotton in Egypt, rubber, palm oil, guano, meat, diamonds) and explain why industrial demand and transport technology made them grow. Describe effects: wealth for some, dependence, unequal exchange, forced labor, and environmental damage.

Practice
  1. What is an export economy?
    Show answer

    An economy that specializes in producing raw materials or crops for sale abroad, using the profits to buy manufactured goods.

  2. Name two export products from the CED's list.
    Show answer

    Egyptian cotton, rubber from the Amazon and Congo, West African palm oil, Peruvian and Chilean guano, meat from Argentina and Uruguay, or African diamonds.

  3. What technology helped meat exports from South America?
    Show answer

    Refrigerated ships.

  4. Why were export economies vulnerable?
    Show answer

    They depended on one or two products, so a price fall could hurt an entire region.

  5. What was the "unequal exchange" in colonial trade?
    Show answer

    Colonies sold cheap raw materials and bought expensive finished goods, which tended to keep industry in the industrial countries.

  6. Why might Casement's report be treated carefully?
    Show answer

    He was a British official reporting on a rival's colony, so Britain had reasons to emphasize abuses there, though his interviews give the report weight.

Lesson 6.6 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.5

Economic imperialism

Control does not always require conquest. The CED says that industrialized states and businesses within those states practiced economic imperialism primarily in Asia and Latin America, and that trade in some commodities was organized in a way that gave merchants and companies based in Europe and the U.S. a distinct economic advantage. This lesson covers what economic imperialism was, how it worked in China and Latin America, and the commodities that made it profitable.

Required content · 6E

Learning objective.

  • 6E. Explain how various economic factors contributed to the development of the global economy from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.2.I.E. Industrialized states and businesses within those states practiced economic imperialism primarily in Asia and Latin America.
  • 5.1.II.C. Trade in some commodities was organized in a way that gave merchants and companies based in Europe and the U.S. a distinct economic advantage.

What is economic imperialism?

Economic imperialism means dominating another country through trade, investment, and finance, usually without formally ruling it. Sometimes called informal empire, it relied on treaties that forced open markets, loans that created dependence, and the pressure of warships. The state remained nominally independent but could not freely control its own tariffs, laws, or resources. Industrial powers gained cheap raw materials and protected markets for their goods.

China and the Opium Wars

China is the main example. The Qing government allowed European trade only at Canton (Lesson 4.4a), and the British, who wanted Chinese tea, silk, and porcelain, had little to sell that the Chinese wanted. To pay for tea, British merchants began selling opium, grown in British India, to Chinese buyers. The drug caused widespread addiction, and silver began to flow out of China. In 1839, an imperial commissioner, Lin Zexu, seized and destroyed thousands of chests of opium at Canton and wrote an open letter to Queen Victoria, appealing to her to stop the trade.

Britain responded with war. In the First Opium War (1839 to 1842), British steamships and guns defeated China. The Treaty of Nanking (1842) gave Britain the island of Hong Kong, opened five treaty ports to British trade, and paid an indemnity. The treaty set a pattern. A Second Opium War (1856 to 1860), fought by Britain and France, forced the opening of more ports, the legalization of opium, and the right of Christian missions to operate. These unequal treaties gave foreigners special rights, such as extraterritoriality (they were tried by their own courts, not Chinese courts) and limits on Chinese tariffs. By the end of the century, foreign powers and Japan had divided China into spheres of influence, where each claimed special economic rights, though China was never formally partitioned.

The CED cites Britain and France expanding their influence in China through the Opium Wars as its example of economic imperialism.

Latin America

Latin American countries won political independence in the early 1800s (Lesson 5.2b) but came under economic influence from Britain and then the United States. British banks lent money, British firms built railroads, ports, and utilities, and British manufactures flooded the market. The CED's example is the construction of the Port of Buenos Aires with the support of British firms. Latin American economies exported raw materials and imported manufactured goods, and foreign owners held key industries. The United States, after the Monroe Doctrine (1823) and especially after 1898, also intervened in the Caribbean and Central America to protect its investments.

Commodities with a European or American advantage

The CED lists several commodities that contributed to European and American economic advantage:

  • Opium produced in the Middle East or South Asia and exported to China.
  • Cotton grown in South Asia and Egypt and exported to Great Britain and other European countries.
  • Palm oil produced in sub-Saharan Africa and exported to European countries.
  • Copper extracted in Chile.

Merchants and companies based in Europe and the U.S. controlled shipping, insurance, and finance, and so captured much of the profit. Producers received low prices for raw goods, and buyers sold finished goods at higher prices.

Other cases

The Ottoman Empire, though independent, also fell under foreign financial control after it went bankrupt in 1875 and creditors set up the Ottoman Public Debt Administration in 1881. Egypt came under British occupation in 1882 after a debt crisis.

Description of: Lin Zexu's letter

Description of the letter Lin Zexu wrote in 1839 to Queen Victoria, in which he asked her to stop the opium trade. This is a description, not a quotation.

Lin wrote that the Chinese emperor had always treated foreign merchants kindly and that Britain profited from trade in Chinese goods such as tea and rhubarb. He asked how it could be right to sell to China a drug that Britain forbade at home and that harmed Chinese people, and he said that Chinese law imposed severe punishments on those who dealt in opium.

Sourcing (HIPP). Lin was a high Qing official, so his point of view is that of an imperial administrator enforcing a ban. His purpose was to appeal to the British ruler's sense of morality and to explain China's actions, and the audience was Queen Victoria, though it seems the letter never reached her and was published in the British press. The letter is evidence of Chinese views of the trade and of the Qing's belief that China was the center of a tribute system, and it also reflects the dispute that led to war.

Source analysis · A moral appeal

Claim. Chinese officials viewed the opium trade as harmful and hypocritical.

Evidence. Lin asked how it could be right to sell China a drug that Britain forbade at home and that harmed Chinese people.

Reasoning. The question points to an apparent double standard and to the damage of addiction, which gave China a moral argument for the ban. A limit is that Lin wrote as a Qing official, so he did not address China's own domestic opium market or the silver drain that also motivated the ban, and it is unclear whether the queen read it.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause and one effect of the Opium Wars.

Model. One cause was Britain's trade deficit with China, since the British wanted tea and silk but China wanted little that they made, so British merchants sold opium to pay for them, which led to addiction and a Chinese ban. One effect was the unequal Treaty of Nanking, which gave Britain Hong Kong, opened treaty ports, and began a pattern of unequal treaties that reduced China's control over its own trade.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6E asks about economic factors in the global economy. Define economic imperialism, and give the Opium Wars and the Port of Buenos Aires from the CED. Know the key terms unequal treaties, treaty ports, spheres of influence, and informal empire, and the commodities in which Europe and the US held the advantage.

Practice
  1. What is economic imperialism?
    Show answer

    Dominating another country through trade, investment, and finance, usually without formally ruling it.

  2. Why did British merchants sell opium in China?
    Show answer

    To pay for tea, silk, and porcelain, since the Chinese wanted few British goods.

  3. What was the Treaty of Nanking?
    Show answer

    The 1842 treaty ending the First Opium War, in which China gave Britain Hong Kong, opened treaty ports, and paid an indemnity.

  4. What is extraterritoriality?
    Show answer

    The right of foreigners in a country to be tried under their own laws and courts and not local ones.

  5. How did Britain influence Latin America's economies?
    Show answer

    Through loans, investment in railroads and ports such as Buenos Aires, and trade in which Latin America exported raw materials and imported manufactured goods.

  6. Why is Lin Zexu's letter useful but limited?
    Show answer

    It shows Chinese views and moral arguments against opium, but it was written by an official, probably never reached the queen, and does not address all of China's motives.

Lesson 6.7 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.6

Causes of migration in an interconnected world

In the nineteenth century, tens of millions of people left their homes for other regions. The CED asks how environmental factors and economic factors contributed to varied patterns of migration from 1750 to 1900. This lesson covers who moved, why, and how: free migrants, coerced and semi-coerced laborers, and people who returned.

Required content · 6F, 6G

Learning objectives.

  • 6F. Explain how various environmental factors contributed to the development of varied patterns of migration from 1750 to 1900.
  • 6G. Explain how various economic factors contributed to the development of varied patterns of migration from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.4.I. Migration in many cases was influenced by changes in demographics in both industrialized and unindustrialized societies that presented challenges to existing patterns of living.
  • 5.4.I.B. Because of the nature of new modes of transportation, both internal and external migrants increasingly relocated to cities. This pattern contributed to the significant global urbanization of the 19th century. The new methods of transportation also allowed for many migrants to return, periodically or permanently, to their home societies.
  • 5.4.II.A. Many individuals chose freely to relocate, often in search of work.
  • 5.4.II.B. The new global capitalist economy continued to rely on coerced and semicoerced labor migration, including enslavement Chinese and Indian indentured servitude, and convict labor.

Demographic pressures

The CED says that migration in many cases was influenced by changes in demographics in both industrialized and unindustrialized societies that presented challenges to existing patterns of living. Populations grew in the 1700s and 1800s in many regions, helped by new crops (Lesson 4.3), better food supply, and later by improvements in public health. In Europe, growing numbers of rural people could not find land or work. In industrial towns, wages were low and cities were crowded. In parts of Asia and Africa, colonial taxes and export agriculture pushed farmers to seek wage work.

Environmental causes

Natural disasters and food crises were powerful pushes. The most famous is the Irish Potato Famine (1845 to 1852). A blight destroyed the potato, the main food of poor Irish families, and about a million people died and another million or more emigrated, many to the United States and Britain. Droughts and floods in China and India also drove migration, and the spread of railroads and steamships meant that people could leave far more easily.

Economic causes

  • Free migration for work. The CED notes that many individuals chose freely to relocate, often in search of work. Millions of Europeans, including Irish, Germans, Italians, and Eastern Europeans, moved to the United States, Canada, Argentina, Brazil, and Australia, where land and jobs were available. Cheap steamship fares made the Atlantic crossing quick and affordable.
  • Urban migration. The CED says that, because of the nature of new transportation, both internal and external migrants increasingly relocated to cities, contributing to significant global urbanization. Railroads brought rural people to cities such as Manchester, Chicago, and Bombay.
  • Return migration. The same transport made it possible for many migrants to return, periodically or permanently, to their home societies. The CED gives examples: Japanese agricultural workers in the Pacific (for example in Hawaii), Lebanese merchants in the Americas, and Italian industrial workers in Argentina, some of whom, nicknamed "swallows," traveled each year between Italy and Argentina for the harvest seasons.

Coerced and semi-coerced migration

The CED says the new global capitalist economy continued to rely on coerced and semi-coerced labor migration, including enslavement, Chinese and Indian indentured servitude, and convict labor.

  • Enslavement. The Atlantic slave trade continued into the nineteenth century, and enslaved people were moved within the Americas, for example from the Upper South to the Deep South of the United States. Britain banned the slave trade in 1807 and slavery in 1833, and other states ended slavery later, in the United States in 1865 and in Brazil in 1888.
  • Indentured servitude. After the end of slavery, planters needed labor. Under indenture, workers signed contracts, often with little understanding, to work for a fixed number of years in exchange for passage and a small wage. Hundreds of thousands of Indians went to the Caribbean, South Africa, Fiji, and Mauritius, and many Chinese went to Southeast Asia, Cuba, Peru, and elsewhere. Conditions were often harsh and mortality high, and critics called it "a new system of slavery."
  • Convict labor. Britain transported tens of thousands of convicts to Australia from 1788 until the 1860s, and France sent prisoners to colonies such as New Caledonia and Guiana.

Patterns

Most migrants were men of working age, though many families also moved. Some stayed permanently and others returned. These moves created new connections across the world and linked sending and receiving societies.

Description of: an indenture contract

Description of the kind of contract signed by Indian laborers recruited for sugar plantations in places such as Fiji, Mauritius, and Trinidad in the 1800s. This is a description of a document type, not a quotation from one contract.

A typical agreement bound the worker to labor for five years for a monthly wage and food, with a promise of a return passage after a number of years. Workers could be fined or jailed for leaving the plantation or refusing work, and the contract was written in English or another language that many could not read.

Sourcing (HIPP). Colonial officials and planters drew up such contracts, so the point of view is that of employers and governments. Their purpose was to secure labor and to appear to regulate it, and the audience was the workers, recruiters, and officials. Because the terms favor the employer, and because many workers signed without understanding them, the contracts show how the system was designed, and they must be read alongside workers' own accounts to see what indenture was like in practice.

Source analysis · A contract and its limits

Claim. Indenture contracts gave employers great control over workers.

Evidence. A typical contract bound workers for five years, allowed fines or jail for leaving or refusing work, and was written in a language many could not read.

Reasoning. Terms that punish leaving and are written in a language workers cannot read favor the employer and support the comparison with slavery. A limit is that the contract shows the planned system, not the lived experience, and some workers did benefit, so workers' accounts are needed.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one environmental cause and one economic cause of migration between 1750 and 1900.

Model. One environmental cause was the Irish Potato Famine, in which the failure of the potato crop caused starvation and led more than a million people to emigrate. One economic cause was the search for work and land, as millions of Europeans moved to the Americas and Australia, aided by cheap steamship fares and the demand for labor.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 6F and 6G ask about environmental and economic factors in migration. Give causes (population growth, famine, search for work, urbanization), types (free, indentured, convict, enslaved), and examples from the CED (Japanese in the Pacific, Lebanese in the Americas, Italians in Argentina). Note return migration.

Practice
  1. Name one environmental cause of migration.
    Show answer

    The Irish Potato Famine, droughts or floods, and crop failures.

  2. What is indentured servitude?
    Show answer

    A labor system in which workers sign contracts to work for a fixed number of years in exchange for passage and a small wage, often under harsh conditions.

  3. Why did demand for indentured labor grow after 1833?
    Show answer

    Britain and other powers ended slavery, so planters sought other cheap labor, drawing on India and China.

  4. What was return migration?
    Show answer

    Migrants going back to their home societies, periodically or permanently, as with Italian workers in Argentina.

  5. Which technologies made migration easier?
    Show answer

    Steamships and railroads, which lowered cost and travel time.

  6. Why must indenture contracts be read with other sources?
    Show answer

    They show the system's design and favor the employer, but they do not show workers' experience, which requires workers' accounts.

Lesson 6.8 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.7

The effects of migration

Migration changed both the places migrants left and the places where they settled. The CED asks how and why new patterns of migration affected society from 1750 to 1900, and lists three effects: new roles for women in home societies, ethnic enclaves in new lands, and prejudice and legal restrictions in receiving societies.

Required content · 6H

Learning objective.

  • 6H. Explain how and why new patterns of migration affected society from 1750 to 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 5.4.III.A. Migrants tended to be male, leaving women to take on new roles in the home society that had been formerly occupied by men.
  • 5.4.III.B. Migrants often created ethnic enclaves in different parts of the world that helped transplant their culture into new environments.
  • 5.4.III.C. Receiving societies did not always embrace immigrants, as seen in the various degrees of ethnic and racial prejudice and the ways states attempted to regulate the increased flow of people across their borders.

Effects on home societies

The CED says that migrants tended to be male, leaving women to take on new roles in the home society that had been formerly occupied by men. In regions that sent many laborers abroad, such as parts of southern China, India, Italy, and Ireland, women often ran farms and households alone, managed money sent home, and made decisions that men had made. Remittances, money sent home by migrants, could support families, pay for land, and fund schools or temples, though they could also make communities dependent. Families were often split for years, and some migrants never came back.

Ethnic enclaves

The CED says migrants often created ethnic enclaves in different parts of the world that helped transplant their culture into new environments. An enclave is a neighborhood or region where people of a shared background live together and keep their language, food, religion, and customs. Examples named in the CED:

  • Chinese in Southeast Asia, the Caribbean, South America, and North America, where they created "Chinatowns" with shops, associations, and temples.
  • Indians in East and Southern Africa, the Caribbean, and Southeast Asia, where they kept their languages and religions and sometimes became merchants and clerks.
  • Irish in North America, where they settled in large numbers in cities such as Boston and New York, and the Catholic Church became a central institution.
  • Italians in North and South America, who formed neighborhoods such as "Little Italies."

Enclaves gave newcomers support in finding jobs and housing, and they helped to spread religions, foods, and music, which changed the culture of host countries. Migrants usually also adapted, and their children often combined elements of both cultures.

Reception and restriction

The CED reminds us that receiving societies did not always embrace immigrants, as seen in the various degrees of ethnic and racial prejudice and the ways states attempted to regulate the increased flow of people across their borders. Migrants competed for jobs, spoke other languages, and practiced other religions, and some groups blamed them for low wages and social problems.

  • Chinese Exclusion Act. In the United States, Chinese laborers faced violence and discrimination in the West, and in 1882 Congress passed the Chinese Exclusion Act, which barred Chinese laborers from entering the country. It was the first major US law to restrict immigration by nationality, and it was extended and then made permanent in 1902. It was not repealed until 1943.
  • White Australia policy. After Australian colonies united in 1901, the new government passed the Immigration Restriction Act, which used a language test to keep out non-European immigrants, especially Asians and Pacific Islanders. The policy lasted for decades.
  • Other restrictions. Canada imposed a head tax on Chinese immigrants in 1885, and South Africa and other colonies placed limits on Indian immigrants and on their rights.

These policies show a link between migration, race, and the new nation-states. States began to define who could enter and to build systems of passports and border controls, which were far less common before the late 1800s.

Long-term effects

Migration spread populations and cultures, built diasporas that kept ties to ancestral homes, and fed the growth of cities in the Americas and elsewhere. It also created new minorities and new conflicts over race and belonging, and these conflicts would shape the politics of the twentieth century.

Primary source · The Chinese Exclusion Act

United States, An Act to Execute Certain Treaty Stipulations Relating to Chinese (the Chinese Exclusion Act), May 6, 1882. A US federal law (public domain).

Whereas, in the opinion of the Government of the United States the coming of Chinese laborers to this country endangers the good order of certain localities within the territory thereof.

Sourcing (HIPP). The law was passed by the United States Congress, so the point of view is that of a government responding to political pressure, much of it from workers and politicians in the West. Its purpose was to stop the immigration of Chinese laborers, and the audience was the American public, immigration officials, and China. It claims that Chinese laborers endanger "good order," a justification that reflects the racial prejudice of the time. The law shows official policy and its stated reasons, but not the actual conduct of Chinese immigrants, who contributed greatly to railroads, farming, and mining in the West.

Source analysis · A stated justification

Claim. The US government justified excluding Chinese laborers by claiming they threatened public order.

Evidence. The act's preamble says the coming of Chinese laborers endangers the good order of certain localities.

Reasoning. The law gives public order as its reason, though contemporary evidence shows that much of the pressure came from economic competition and racial prejudice. A limit is that a law's preamble states what officials chose to say publicly and does not tell us all of the motives behind it.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of migration on a home society and one on a receiving society.

Model. In home societies, the migration of men left women to take on roles formerly held by men, such as running farms and managing remittances sent from abroad. In receiving societies, migrants formed ethnic enclaves such as Chinatowns and Little Italies, which preserved their culture, but they also faced prejudice and laws such as the Chinese Exclusion Act.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6H asks how and why new patterns of migration affected society. Cover three effects in the CED: gender roles in home societies, ethnic enclaves, and prejudice and regulation (Chinese Exclusion Act, White Australia policy). Explain why receiving societies reacted as they did.

Practice
  1. How did male migration affect women in home societies?
    Show answer

    Women often took on roles formerly held by men, such as running farms and households and managing remittances.

  2. What is an ethnic enclave?
    Show answer

    A neighborhood or region where people of a shared background live together and keep their language, food, religion, and customs.

  3. What did the Chinese Exclusion Act do?
    Show answer

    It barred Chinese laborers from entering the United States starting in 1882, the first major US law to restrict immigration by nationality.

  4. What was the White Australia policy?
    Show answer

    Australian immigration rules after 1901, using a language test to keep out non-European immigrants, especially Asians.

  5. Why did some receiving societies resist migrants?
    Show answer

    Migrants competed for jobs and spoke other languages and practiced other religions, so some groups blamed them for low wages and social problems, and racial prejudice played a role.

  6. Why does a law's preamble limit what it tells a historian?
    Show answer

    It states the reasons officials chose to give publicly, which may not include all motives.

Lesson 6.9 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.8

Causation in the imperial age

This lesson practices causation, the reasoning skill for the final topic of Unit 6. The CED asks you to explain the relative significance of the effects of imperialism from 1750 to 1900. Relative significance means judging which effects mattered most and why, and not just listing them.

Required content · 6I

Learning objective.

  • 6I. Explain the relative significance of the effects of imperialism from 1750 to 1900.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

What is causation?

A cause is a factor that helps produce an event. Effects are the results. Historians distinguish:

  • Long-term and short-term causes. Industrialization was a long-term cause of the new imperialism. A specific crisis, such as the Berlin Conference, was a short-term one.
  • Direct and indirect effects. A tax is a direct effect of conquest. A later nationalist movement is an indirect effect.
  • Intended and unintended effects. Colonial officials built railroads to move goods, and one unintended effect was that Indian nationalists used them to organize.

When the exam asks for relative significance, it asks you to argue that one cause or effect mattered more than others, using criteria such as scale (how many people), duration (how long it lasted), depth (how deeply it changed lives), and connection (how much it led to other changes).

Effects of imperialism

Group the effects of imperialism into categories.

  • Economic. Export economies, resource extraction, unequal trade, the decline of local industry (Lessons 5.4, 6.4, and 6.5), and in some places new infrastructure such as railroads and ports built to serve the colonial economy.
  • Political. New borders, direct and indirect rule, loss of independence, and the strengthening of European, American, and Japanese states. Anti-colonial movements and new states also developed in response (Lesson 6.3).
  • Social and demographic. Forced labor, migration, new class systems based on race, ethnic enclaves, and disease and population loss in some places (Lessons 6.6 and 6.7).
  • Cultural and ideological. Racist theories, missionary activity, the spread of European languages and education, and new ideas of nationalism and rights adopted by colonized peoples.
  • Environmental. Deforestation, mining, cash-crop monoculture, and the introduction of new plants and animals.

Weighing significance

Suppose the prompt asks: Evaluate which effect of imperialism was most significant between 1750 and 1900. One argument:

  • Claim. The most significant effect was the creation of dependent export economies.
  • Reasons. It affected hundreds of millions of people across Africa, Asia, and Latin America (scale), lasted well after formal rule ended (duration), shaped what people farmed, mined, and bought (depth), and connected to other effects, including forced labor, migration, and the decline of local industry (connection).
  • Counterargument. Political effects such as new borders and loss of sovereignty were also large, and they produced anti-colonial movements. But economic structures shaped later politics, as newly independent states found themselves dependent on a few exports.

Notice that a strong answer weighs two alternatives and explains why one outweighs the other. A weaker answer lists effects without ranking them.

The same cause, different effects

The effects varied by place. In settler colonies, Indigenous populations lost land. In extractive colonies, local peoples faced forced labor. In states that avoided conquest, such as Japan and Siam, imperial pressure led to reform. Imperialism also changed the colonizers, as profits, raw materials, and nationalism reshaped their economies and politics.

Description of: Hobson's critique

Description of Imperialism: A Study (1902) by the British economist J. A. Hobson. This is a description, not a quotation.

Hobson argued that imperial expansion mainly benefited a small group of investors, financiers, and arms makers rather than the nation as a whole. He said that wealthy people with surplus capital pushed governments to acquire colonies where they could invest it, and that this led to militarism and the oppression of subject peoples.

Sourcing (HIPP). Hobson was a British liberal economist and critic of empire, so his point of view is that of a reformer who thought imperialism was bad for Britain and the world. His purpose was to challenge the idea that empire served the national interest, and he wrote partly in response to the Boer War (1899 to 1902). His audience was British readers and policymakers. Because he emphasized economic motives, his argument may overstate the role of financiers and understate nationalism and strategy, but his work influenced later critics, including Lenin.

Source analysis · A critic's explanation

Claim. Some contemporaries argued that economic interests drove imperialism.

Evidence. Hobson wrote that a small group of investors and financiers with surplus capital pushed governments to acquire colonies for investment.

Reasoning. His argument ties imperial expansion to the search for profitable investment, and it matches the evidence of export economies and economic imperialism. A limit is that he was a critic writing to persuade, and he stressed economic motives while giving less weight to nationalism, strategy, and ideology.

Worked example · Relative significance

Question. Explain which of two effects of imperialism was more significant: the spread of export economies or the drawing of new borders.

Model. The spread of export economies was more significant because it affected the daily work and income of far more people, shaped economies for decades, and was linked to other changes such as forced labor, migration, and the decline of local industry. New borders mattered greatly, because they cut across peoples and states, but their effects often worked through economic structures that were already in place.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 6I asks you to explain relative significance of effects. Group effects (economic, political, social, cultural, environmental), apply criteria (scale, duration, depth, connection), and argue for a ranking with a counterargument. Avoid merely listing.

Practice
  1. What does relative significance mean?
    Show answer

    Judging which cause or effect mattered more and explaining why, using criteria such as scale, duration, depth, and connection.

  2. Name two categories of effects of imperialism.
    Show answer

    Economic, political, social and demographic, cultural, and environmental effects.

  3. What is the difference between intended and unintended effects?
    Show answer

    Intended effects were what rulers planned, such as railroads to move goods, while unintended effects were results nobody planned, such as nationalists using the railroads to organize.

  4. Give one criterion for judging significance.
    Show answer

    Scale (how many people), duration (how long), depth (how much it changed lives), or connection (how many other changes it led to).

  5. Why should an essay include a counterargument?
    Show answer

    Considering another view shows judgment and strengthens a ranking by explaining why one effect outweighs the other.

  6. Why might Hobson overstate economic motives?
    Show answer

    He was a critic writing to persuade who stressed financiers and investment while giving less weight to nationalism, strategy, and ideology.

Unit 6 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 6 review: Consequences of Industrialization, c. 1750–c. 1900

Ten questions on new imperialism and its justifications, the Ottoman and Qing responses to pressure, Japan's divergent path, resistance and rebellion, and the global migrations industry set in motion, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Which best explains the economic motivation behind the new imperialism of the late nineteenth century?

    Correct. Rubber, cotton, palm oil, and tin fed the factories, and colonial tariff arrangements gave the metropole's manufacturers markets that competitors could not enter on equal terms.

    Colonial agriculture was mostly directed toward industrial crops for export rather than food for European populations.

    The flow ran the other way: colonies supplied raw materials and bought manufactures.

    Europe held the technological advantage in weapons, which is part of what made the conquests possible.

  2. Description of: two maps of Africa, one drawn in 1870 and one in 1914.

    The earlier map shows coastal enclaves and trading stations in several European colors, with the vast interior unshaded and labeled with the names of African states and peoples. The later map shows the whole continent divided into large blocks of color, many with long straight boundaries, with only two areas left uncolored.

    The straight boundaries visible on the later map are most useful as evidence for which of the following?

    Correct. Straight lines are the signature of boundaries drawn on maps in European conference rooms, and their persistence after independence is one of colonialism's most durable legacies.

    African states were not represented at the Berlin Conference and did not negotiate these divisions.

    Natural features rarely run straight; these lines cut across rivers, peoples, and existing polities.

    Much of the interior was still poorly known to Europeans when the partition was agreed, which is part of why the lines are arbitrary.

  3. Social Darwinism functioned in the late nineteenth century primarily as

    It misapplied Darwin's account of natural selection to societies and nations, a move biologists did not support and Darwin did not make.

    Correct. Its usefulness lay in presenting European domination as the working out of a natural law rather than as a series of political choices that could be questioned.

    It was used to defend expansion; critics of empire argued on moral, economic, and religious grounds instead.

    It shaped colonial administration, immigration law, and public rhetoric well beyond academic circles.

  4. The Ottoman Tanzimat reforms of the mid-nineteenth century are best understood as an attempt to

    Correct. Reformers hoped a modern army, a codified legal system, and equal citizenship would hold a multi-ethnic empire together against nationalist movements and European pressure.

    The janissaries had been destroyed in 1826 precisely because they blocked military modernization.

    The reforms deepened Ottoman engagement with European models, capital, and diplomacy.

    Islamic law remained in force in important domains; the reforms added new codes alongside it rather than replacing it wholesale.

  5. Source: Lin Zexu, Chinese imperial commissioner, letter addressed to Queen Victoria, 1839; early English translation.

    "Let us ask, where is your conscience? I have heard that the smoking of opium is very strictly forbidden by your country … it is clearly not permitted to do harm to your own country."

    Lin's argument is best characterized as an appeal to

    Correct. He builds the case on Britain's own domestic prohibition, arguing that a government cannot forbid a harm at home while exporting it: an argument from principle rather than from force.

    Lin makes no military claim, and the war that followed demonstrated the opposite.

    No treaty governed the opium trade at this point; the treaties came after China's defeat.

    Free trade was the British justification for the opium trade, not Lin's argument against it.

  6. The unequal treaties imposed on China after 1842 most significantly affected Chinese sovereignty by

    China was never formally colonized; the treaties created zones of foreign privilege within a state that remained nominally sovereign.

    Correct. Fixed low tariffs stripped away the ability to protect domestic industry or raise revenue, and extraterritoriality meant foreigners answered to their own consuls rather than Chinese courts.

    No constitutional requirement was imposed; the Qing political system was left in place.

    The treaties forced ports open to foreign trade rather than closing them.

  7. Japan's experience after 1868 differed from China's in the same period chiefly because Japan

    Correct. A new government that had overthrown the shogunate could abolish the domains, build railways and factories, create a conscript army, and send students abroad: actions the Qing court, facing entrenched interests and rebellion, could not take on the same scale.

    Perry's arrival and the unequal treaties of the 1850s were precisely the pressure that provoked the Meiji reforms.

    Japan was poor in coal, iron, and oil, which later shaped its imperial ambitions.

    No such protection existed; Japan built its own navy and army, defeating China in 1895 and Russia in 1905.

  8. Description of: an official British report on the reorganization of Indian government, 1858.

    The report recommends transferring authority from the East India Company to the Crown, establishing a Secretary of State for India answerable to Parliament, increasing the proportion of British to Indian soldiers in the army, and issuing a proclamation promising non-interference in religious practice.

    The recommendations taken together best indicate that the British government

    Correct. Direct Crown rule and a higher British proportion in the army address control, while the religious proclamation addresses the grievances that had spread the revolt through the sepoy regiments.

    Crown rule lasted nearly ninety years, and nothing in these measures points toward independence.

    The Company was abolished by these very recommendations, which is a verdict on its performance.

    The report increases the British share of the army rather than reducing forces.

  9. Description of: a table of recorded migration flows, 1834–1917, compiled from colonial shipping and labor registers.

    Columns show origin, destination, and numbers. Large flows run from India to Mauritius, the Caribbean, Fiji, and Natal, and from China to Southeast Asia, Peru, Cuba, and California. A column headed "terms of contract" records fixed periods of years with return passage promised in some schemes and not in others.

    The pattern shown is best explained by which development?

    Correct. The dates begin with British emancipation, and the destinations are sugar colonies and mines: indentured contracts filled the labor gap that abolition created.

    Indentured laborers were recruited for unskilled work at very low wages, frequently through deception about the terms.

    The fixed contract periods and return passage in the table point to temporary labor rather than settlement, which colonial authorities often discouraged.

    Recruitment was organized by colonial employers and agents, and the Qing and colonial Indian governments largely tried to regulate or restrict it.

  10. Economic imperialism in nineteenth-century Latin America is best described as a situation in which

    These states kept their formal independence; the influence ran through investment, loans, and trade rather than colonial administration.

    Correct. British and later American capital built the railways and ports that moved guano, nitrates, coffee, and beef outward, leaving economies exposed to swings in the price of one or two exports.

    Industrialization was limited, and these economies mainly supplied raw materials to industrial states.

    Trade expanded dramatically, and the openness of these economies is central to the concept.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE justification Europeans gave for imperial expansion in the nineteenth century.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way a state outside Europe responded to industrial-era pressure.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way industrialization changed patterns of global migration.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: Social Darwinism; the civilizing mission; missionary Christianity; strategic competition between powers; economic arguments about markets and raw materials. Must identify the justification, not merely the motive.
    • (b) Accept: the Ottoman Tanzimat; the Qing Self-Strengthening Movement; the Meiji Restoration; the Indian Rebellion of 1857; Ethiopian resistance and the victory at Adwa; the Boxer Uprising. Must explain the response.
    • (c) Accept: indentured labor replacing enslaved labor on plantations; European emigration to the Americas and settler colonies; internal migration to industrial cities; steamships and railways lowering the cost of moving; restrictive immigration laws targeting Asian migrants. Must connect industry to the change.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Social Darwinists applied the language of natural selection to nations and peoples, arguing that European domination reflected a natural hierarchy rather than superior weapons. This recast conquest as the working out of a law of nature, which made it appear inevitable rather than chosen.

    (b) After 1868 the Meiji government abolished the feudal domains, built railways and state factories, created a conscript army on European models, and sent students abroad to study foreign institutions. Japan aimed to become strong enough that the unequal treaties could be revised, and within thirty years it had defeated China and then Russia in war.

    (c) When Britain abolished slavery in its empire, planters in Mauritius, the Caribbean, Fiji, and Natal turned to indentured labor recruited mainly from India and China on fixed-term contracts. Steamships made moving hundreds of thousands of people across oceans practical, and the result was large permanent South Asian and Chinese communities in places they had not previously reached.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE form of resistance to imperial rule between 1750 and 1900.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way technology contributed to the expansion of European empires in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of colonial official reports as evidence about colonized populations.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the Indian Rebellion of 1857; the Boxer Uprising; Ethiopian resistance culminating at Adwa in 1896; the Zulu defeat of a British force at Isandlwana; the Herero and Nama uprising; the Taiping Rebellion as an internal challenge; early nationalist organizations such as the Indian National Congress. Must identify the form.
    • (b) Accept: quinine reducing malaria mortality in Africa; the steamship and river gunboat; the repeating rifle and machine gun; the telegraph speeding communication; railways moving troops and exports. Must explain the contribution.
    • (c) Accept: written to justify policy to superiors; categories that impose the administration's assumptions on the people described; silence on resistance and on what colonized people thought; reliance on intermediaries who shaped what officials heard. Must name a specific limitation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) In 1896 an Ethiopian army under Menelik II defeated an invading Italian force at Adwa. Menelik had used the rivalry between European powers to acquire modern rifles and artillery beforehand, and the victory preserved Ethiopian independence through the era of partition.

    (b) Quinine, taken prophylactically, dramatically reduced European mortality from malaria, which had previously confined outsiders to the West African coast. Combined with steam-powered river gunboats that could travel inland against the current, it made the interior of Africa reachable in a way it had not been a generation earlier.

    (c) Colonial reports were written by officials to superiors who controlled their careers, so they emphasize order, revenue, and progress and pass lightly over coercion and failure. They also classify colonized people using categories the administration invented, which tells us how officials thought rather than how the people described understood themselves.

Lesson 7.1 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.1

Shifting power and the fall of old empires

At the start of the twentieth century, the West dominated the world. By the century's end, almost all of the great empires had disappeared. The CED asks how internal and external factors contributed to change in various states after 1900 and states that the West dominated the global political order at the beginning of the 20th century, but both land-based and maritime empires gave way to new states by the century's end. This lesson covers the collapse of the older land-based empires and the revolutions that followed, including in Mexico.

Required content · 7A

Learning objective.

  • 7A. Explain how internal and external factors contributed to change in various states after 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.I. The West dominated the global political order at the beginning of the 20th century, but both land-based and maritime empires gave way to new states by the century’s end.
  • 6.2.I.A. The older, land-based Ottoman, Russian, and Qing empires collapsed due to a combination of internal and external factors. These changes in Russia eventually led to communist revolution.
  • 6.2.II.D. States around the world challenged the existing political and social order, including the Mexican Revolution that arose as a result of political crisis.

The Qing collapse in China

By 1900 the Qing dynasty was weak. It had lost the Opium Wars, suffered the Taiping Rebellion, been defeated by Japan in 1895, and faced foreign spheres of influence (Lesson 6.5). A violent anti-foreign uprising, the Boxer Rebellion (1899 to 1901), ended in a new defeat when an international army entered Beijing. Reformers, including the exiled thinker Sun Yat-sen, called for a republic. The Qing tried late reforms, such as new schools and an end to the exam system in 1905, but they came too late. In October 1911, an army uprising at Wuchang began the Xinhai Revolution. In February 1912, the last emperor, a child named Puyi, abdicated, and China became a republic, the end of more than two thousand years of imperial rule. But the new republic was weak. Regional warlords took real power, and China remained divided for decades.

The Ottoman collapse

The Ottoman Empire had lost territories in the Balkans and North Africa. In 1908, a group of reformist officers called the Young Turks forced the sultan to restore the constitution. They promoted a Turkish nationalism that alienated Arabs, Armenians, and others. The empire joined Germany in World War I and was defeated. The victorious Allies planned to divide it. A Turkish nationalist army under Mustafa Kemal (Ataturk) fought off the plans, abolished the sultanate in 1922, and in 1923 proclaimed the Republic of Turkey. Arab lands, such as Iraq, Syria, and Palestine, passed to British and French control as mandates (Lesson 7.5).

The Russian Empire and the revolutions of 1917

The CED states that the older, land-based Ottoman, Russian, and Qing empires collapsed due to a combination of internal and external factors. These changes in Russia eventually led to communist revolution. Russia in 1900 was an autocracy ruled by Tsar Nicholas II, with a vast peasant majority, a small but growing industrial working class (Lesson 5.6), and widespread discontent. Defeat by Japan in 1904 to 1905 led to the Revolution of 1905, after which the tsar allowed an elected parliament (the Duma) with limited power. World War I then strained the empire beyond its limits. Millions of soldiers died, food and fuel ran short, and the tsar was unpopular.

In March 1917 (February by the old Russian calendar), strikes and mutinies in Petrograd forced the tsar to abdicate, and a Provisional Government took over but continued the war. In November 1917 (October in the old calendar), the Bolsheviks, a radical socialist party led by Vladimir Lenin, seized power. Lenin promised "peace, land, and bread," took Russia out of the war in 1918, and, after a bitter civil war, established the Soviet Union in 1922 as the world's first communist state. This revolution inspired communists elsewhere and alarmed many governments.

The Habsburg Empire

The Austro-Hungarian Empire, a multiethnic state of Germans, Hungarians, Czechs, Poles, Serbs, Croats, and others, broke apart at the end of World War I in 1918 as national groups declared independence, creating states such as Czechoslovakia, Austria, Hungary, and Yugoslavia (Lesson 5.2c).

The Mexican Revolution

The CED adds that states around the world challenged the existing political and social order, including the Mexican Revolution that arose as a result of political crisis. Mexico, under President Porfirio Diaz (in power for most of 1876 to 1911), had grown economically with foreign investment, but wealth and land were in few hands, and most peasants were poor. In 1910, Francisco Madero challenged Diaz, who was forced to resign in 1911. A decade of civil war followed, with leaders such as Emiliano Zapata, who demanded land for peasants, and Pancho Villa. The Constitution of 1917 promised land reform, workers' rights, limits on the Church, and state control over resources such as oil. The revolution produced some change but also much violence, and perhaps a million died.

Internal and external factors

Notice the combination. Internal factors included weak or unpopular rulers, economic hardship, nationalist movements, and reform efforts that came too late. External factors included military defeat, foreign pressure, and the effects of world war. The collapse of empires was not caused by one thing, and the CED's phrase combination of internal and external factors is what you should show.

Description of: Sun Yat-sen's program

Description of the "Three Principles of the People," the program of Sun Yat-sen, set out in his writings and speeches from the early 1900s. This is a description, not a quotation.

Sun's program rested on three principles: nationalism, meaning an end to foreign domination and to Manchu rule; democracy, meaning a republican government with the people's rights; and the people's livelihood, meaning measures to secure economic well-being, including land reform.

Sourcing (HIPP). Sun was a Chinese physician and revolutionary who spent years in exile and raised money among overseas Chinese, so his point of view is that of a reformer from outside the Qing system. His purpose was to unite opponents of the dynasty around a program, and his audience included Chinese students and merchants abroad. Because the program was a statement of goals by a leader seeking support, it shows what revolutionaries wanted more than what the new republic achieved.

Source analysis · A revolutionary program

Claim. Chinese revolutionaries linked the fall of the Qing to nationalism and reform.

Evidence. Sun's three principles called for an end to foreign and Manchu domination, a republic, and economic well-being.

Reasoning. Putting nationalism first shows that anti-foreign and anti-Manchu feeling helped drive the revolution, and the other two principles show a demand for new government and social change. A limit is that the program was written to win supporters, and the republic that followed was weak and divided.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one internal and one external cause of the collapse of the Russian Empire.

Model. One internal cause was the weakness of the autocracy and the widespread discontent of peasants and workers, as shown in the Revolution of 1905. One external cause was World War I, which killed millions of soldiers, caused food and fuel shortages, and led to the tsar's abdication in 1917.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7A asks how internal and external factors caused change in states. Give at least three cases: the Qing (1911), the Ottomans (1908 to 1923), Russia (1905 and 1917), and Mexico (1910). For each, name an internal and an external factor and the result.

Practice
  1. What ended imperial rule in China?
    Show answer

    The Xinhai Revolution of 1911, after which the last emperor abdicated in 1912 and China became a republic.

  2. Who were the Young Turks?
    Show answer

    Reformist officers who forced the Ottoman sultan to restore the constitution in 1908 and promoted a Turkish nationalism.

  3. What did Mustafa Kemal (Ataturk) do?
    Show answer

    He led a Turkish nationalist army that resisted Allied plans to divide Turkey, abolished the sultanate in 1922, and founded the Republic of Turkey in 1923.

  4. Who were the Bolsheviks?
    Show answer

    A radical socialist party led by Lenin that seized power in Russia in November 1917 and founded the Soviet Union.

  5. What happened to Austria-Hungary in 1918?
    Show answer

    It broke apart as national groups declared independence, creating states such as Czechoslovakia, Austria, Hungary, and Yugoslavia.

  6. What did Zapata demand in the Mexican Revolution?
    Show answer

    Land for peasants.

Lesson 7.2 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.2

The causes of World War I

World War I (1914 to 1918) killed about nine to ten million soldiers and millions of civilians, and it reshaped the world. The CED asks for the causes and consequences of World War I and states that the causes of World War I included imperialist expansion and competition for resources. In addition, territorial and regional conflicts combined with a flawed alliance system and intense nationalism to escalate the tensions into global conflict. This lesson covers the long-term causes and the crisis of 1914. The next lesson covers how the war was fought.

Required content · 7B

Learning objective.

  • 7B. Explain the causes and consequences of World War I.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.B.i. The causes of World War I included imperialist expansion and competition for resources. In addition, territorial and regional conflicts combined with a flawed alliance system and intense nationalism to escalate the tensions into global conflict.

Long-term causes

Historians often organize the causes under four headings, sometimes remembered as MAIN: militarism, alliances, imperialism, and nationalism. The CED's wording matches these.

  • Imperialist expansion and competition for resources. European powers competed for colonies and markets in Africa and Asia, and crises such as the 1905 and 1911 Moroccan crises between France and Germany increased tension (Lesson 6.2a). Competition for trade and naval power also created rivalry, especially between Britain and Germany.
  • Militarism. The powers built large armies and navies. Germany's naval buildup alarmed Britain, which responded with a larger fleet (the dreadnought race). General staffs drew up detailed plans for rapid mobilization, which made delay seem dangerous.
  • A flawed alliance system. By 1907, Europe was divided into two blocs: the Triple Alliance of Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy, and the Triple Entente of France, Russia, and Britain. The alliances were meant to deter war, but they made a local conflict likely to become a general one, since each state feared losing an ally. Italy later left the Triple Alliance and joined the Allies in 1915.
  • Intense nationalism. Nationalism made peoples proud and resentful. France wanted revenge for losing Alsace and Lorraine to Germany in 1871. Pan-Slavism in Russia and Serbia sought to unite Slavic peoples. And nationalists in the Habsburg and Ottoman empires wanted independence (Lesson 5.2c).
  • Territorial and regional conflicts. The Balkans were especially volatile. After the Ottoman Empire's decline, Serbia, Bulgaria, Greece, and others fought the Balkan Wars of 1912 to 1913, and Austria-Hungary feared that Serbian nationalism would break its empire apart.

The July Crisis

On June 28, 1914, a Bosnian Serb nationalist, Gavrilo Princip, assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, in Sarajevo. Austria-Hungary, with German backing (a "blank check"), sent Serbia an ultimatum on July 23 and declared war on July 28. Russia, which saw itself as Serbia's protector, mobilized. Germany declared war on Russia (August 1) and on France (August 3), and invaded neutral Belgium to carry out the Schlieffen Plan, a plan for a quick defeat of France. Britain, which had guaranteed Belgian neutrality, declared war on Germany on August 4. Within a week, the great powers of Europe were at war, and their empires dragged colonies in.

Why did war happen?

Historians still debate responsibility. Some emphasize German aggression and its support for Austria-Hungary. Others stress the system of alliances and military plans, or the role of Russia and France. The CED does not assign blame. It asks you to explain the combination of imperialism, alliances, militarism, and nationalism, and to see that the assassination was the trigger, not the only cause. A long-term cause makes war likely, while a short-term trigger sets it off.

Consequences

The war ended with the defeat of the Central Powers (Germany, Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman Empire, and Bulgaria), the collapse of four empires (Lesson 7.1), the creation of new states, the Treaty of Versailles (Lesson 7.6), and a political and economic crisis that helped lead to the next war.

Description of: the ultimatum to Serbia

Description of the ultimatum Austria-Hungary sent to Serbia on July 23, 1914. This is a description, not a quotation.

The note accused Serbia of tolerating terrorist organizations and demanded that it suppress anti-Austrian propaganda, dismiss officials named by Austria, and allow Austrian officials to take part in the investigation inside Serbia. It gave Serbia forty-eight hours to reply.

Sourcing (HIPP). The note was written by the Austro-Hungarian foreign ministry, with German encouragement, so the point of view is that of a government seeking a pretext to crush Serbia. Its purpose was to present demands that Serbia could not fully accept, and the audience was the Serbian government and the other powers. Serbia accepted most demands but rejected the one allowing Austrian officials to investigate on its territory. Because the document was drafted to be rejected, it shows how a government deliberately escalated the crisis.

Source analysis · A harsh ultimatum

Claim. Austria-Hungary wanted a war with Serbia, not only justice for the assassination.

Evidence. The note demanded that Austrian officials take part in an investigation inside Serbia and gave only forty-eight hours to respond.

Reasoning. Demands that infringed on Serbian sovereignty, with a very short deadline, would be hard for any government to accept in full, which suggests that the goal was to provoke war. A limit is that historians still debate how far Austrian leaders aimed for war and how far they expected it to stay limited to the Balkans.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one long-term cause and one immediate cause of World War I.

Model. One long-term cause was the alliance system, which divided Europe into two blocs so that a local conflict between Austria-Hungary and Serbia drew in Russia, Germany, France, and Britain. One immediate cause was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914, which led to Austria's ultimatum and the declarations of war.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7B asks for the causes and consequences of World War I. Give the CED causes: imperialist rivalry, militarism, alliances, nationalism, and Balkan conflicts. Separate long-term causes from the immediate trigger, and note consequences (end of empires, new states, Versailles).

Practice
  1. Name the two alliance blocs of 1914.
    Show answer

    The Triple Alliance (Germany, Austria-Hungary, Italy) and the Triple Entente (France, Russia, Britain).

  2. What was the immediate trigger of the war?
    Show answer

    The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914.

  3. What was the Schlieffen Plan?
    Show answer

    A German plan for a quick defeat of France through Belgium, which brought Britain into the war.

  4. How did imperialism contribute to the war?
    Show answer

    Competition for colonies, resources, and markets increased rivalry and tension among the powers, as in the Moroccan crises.

  5. Why were the Balkans important?
    Show answer

    Nationalist conflicts there, including Serbian nationalism that threatened Austria-Hungary, sparked the crisis.

  6. Why might historians disagree about responsibility?
    Show answer

    They weigh German aggression, the alliance system, military plans, and Russian and French actions differently.

Lesson 7.3 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.3

Conducting World War I: the first total war

The CED says that World War I was the first total war. Governments used a variety of strategies, including political propaganda, art, media, and intensified forms of nationalism, to mobilize populations (both in the home countries and the colonies) for the purpose of waging war, and that new military technology led to increased levels of wartime casualties. This lesson covers how governments mobilized, how technology changed fighting, and what the war cost.

Required content · 7C

Learning objective.

  • 7C. Explain how governments used a variety of methods to conduct war.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.A.i. World War I was the first total war. Governments used a variety of strategies, including political propaganda, art, media, and intensified forms of nationalism, to mobilize populations (both in the home countries and the colonies) for the purpose of waging war.
  • 6.1.III.C.i. New military technology led to increased levels of wartime casualties.

What is total war?

In a total war, a government mobilizes all of its society's resources for the war effort. The economy, the labor force, the media, and civilians all become part of the war, not only soldiers. Armies were drawn by conscription, factories switched to weapons production, governments controlled industry and prices, and food was rationed.

Mobilizing populations

  • Propaganda and art. Governments used posters, newspapers, films, and speeches to recruit soldiers, sell war bonds, and demonize the enemy. In Britain, a famous poster showed Lord Kitchener pointing and saying that the country needed you. In the United States, the Committee on Public Information ran a large publicity campaign. Governments also censored news and suppressed dissent.
  • Intensified nationalism. Appeals to national honor and duty drew volunteers and justified sacrifice. In the early days, crowds in many capitals cheered the war.
  • Women and the home front. With millions of men at the front, women took jobs in factories, offices, and farms and served as nurses and in auxiliary units. Their war work strengthened demands for the vote, and several countries, including Britain (1918), Germany (1918), and the United States (1920), gave women the vote around the end of the war.
  • Colonies. The CED stresses mobilization both in the home countries and the colonies. Britain drew over a million Indian soldiers and laborers, along with soldiers from Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and Africa. France recruited hundreds of thousands of soldiers and workers from West Africa, North Africa, and Indochina. Colonies also supplied food, raw materials, and money. Colonial subjects hoped that their service would earn greater rights, and many were disappointed after the war (Lesson 7.5).

New military technology

The war's weapons made killing easier than moving. On the Western Front, from Belgium to Switzerland, opposing armies dug lines of trenches protected by barbed wire and machine guns. Attacks across "no man's land" often gained little at enormous cost.

  • Machine guns and artillery. Rapid-fire machine guns and heavy artillery caused most casualties.
  • Poison gas. First used on a large scale by Germany in 1915, gas caused terrible injuries, though it was less deadly than other weapons.
  • Tanks, aircraft, and submarines. Tanks appeared in 1916, airplanes were used for scouting and bombing, and German submarines (U-boats) attacked merchant ships, which helped bring the United States into the war after unrestricted submarine warfare resumed in 1917.

The CED says that new military technology led to increased levels of wartime casualties. At Verdun (1916) and the Somme (1916), each battle caused hundreds of thousands of casualties. Overall, about nine to ten million soldiers died, with about twenty million wounded, and millions of civilians died from disease, hunger, and occupation. An influenza pandemic in 1918 to 1919 killed many more.

June 1914 Assassination at Sarajevo Aug 1914 War begins; Germany invades Belgium 1915 Gallipoli; poison gas used 1916 Verdun and the Somme 1917 US enters; Russian Revolution Mar 1918 Treaty of Brest-Litovsk Nov 1918 Armistice 1919 Treaty of Versailles
Figure 7.1. The course of the war. A regional crisis became a world war, and the peace left many problems unsettled.

Outcome

The war was fought on many fronts: Western, Eastern, the Middle East, Africa, and at sea. In 1917, the United States joined the Allies, and Russia left the war after its revolution. In 1918, German offensives failed, and the Central Powers collapsed. An armistice took effect on November 11, 1918.

Primary source · A poet on the war

Wilfred Owen, "Dulce et Decorum Est" (written 1917 to 1918, published 1920). Owen was a British soldier-poet killed in action in November 1918. The poem's last lines quote a Latin phrase by the Roman poet Horace.

The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria mori.

Sourcing (HIPP). Owen was an officer who served in the trenches and was wounded, so his point of view is that of a combat soldier disillusioned by what he saw. His purpose was to challenge the idea, shown in propaganda, that dying for one's country is sweet and fitting, which is what the Latin means. The audience was the British public at home. Because he wrote from his own experience, he offers a view very different from the official posters, but he speaks for only one soldier and for a poet's critical reaction, not for all who fought.

Source analysis · Propaganda and its critics

Claim. Some soldiers rejected the patriotic message that governments used to mobilize populations.

Evidence. Owen called the idea that it is sweet and fitting to die for one's country "the old Lie."

Reasoning. The poem directly attacks the message of propaganda, using the author's own experience of the trenches, which shows that official appeals did not persuade everyone. A limit is that it is one poem by one soldier writing for a public audience, so it does not show how most soldiers felt.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way governments mobilized for total war and one effect on society.

Model. Governments used propaganda posters and newspapers to recruit soldiers and sell war bonds and appealed to nationalism, while also drawing on colonial subjects as soldiers and laborers. One effect was that women took factory and office jobs while men were at the front, which strengthened the case for women's suffrage in several countries around 1918 to 1920.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7C asks how governments used a variety of methods to conduct war. Define total war, and give mobilization methods (propaganda, art, media, nationalism, conscription, rationing), the colonial role, and technology (machine guns, gas, tanks, aircraft, submarines) with its effect on casualties.

Practice
  1. What is total war?
    Show answer

    A war in which a government mobilizes all of its society's resources, including the economy, labor, media, and civilians, for the war effort.

  2. How did governments use propaganda?
    Show answer

    They used posters, newspapers, films, and speeches to recruit soldiers, sell war bonds, appeal to nationalism, and demonize the enemy.

  3. How were colonies involved in World War I?
    Show answer

    They supplied millions of soldiers and laborers, as well as food, raw materials, and money.

  4. Name two new weapons of World War I.
    Show answer

    Machine guns, poison gas, tanks, airplanes, and submarines.

  5. How did the war affect women?
    Show answer

    Women took jobs in factories and offices and served as nurses, and the war strengthened demands for suffrage in several countries.

  6. Why is Owen's poem a limited source?
    Show answer

    It expresses one soldier's disillusionment and a poet's reaction, so it does not show how all soldiers or civilians felt.

Lesson 7.4 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.4

The interwar economy and the state

The years between the world wars were an age of economic crisis. The CED asks how different governments responded to economic crisis after 1900 and says that, following World War I and the onset of the Great Depression, governments began to take a more active role in economic life. This lesson covers the Great Depression, and four responses: the Soviet Five-Year Plans, the American New Deal, fascist corporatism, and the policies of leaders in Brazil and Mexico.

Required content · 7D

Learning objective.

  • 7D. Explain how different governments responded to economic crisis after 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.I.B. Following World War I and the onset of the Great Depression, governments began to take a more active role in economic life.
  • 6.3.I.A.i. In the Soviet Union, the government controlled the national economy through the Five Year Plans, often implementing repressive policies, with negative repercussions for the population.

The Great Depression

World War I left Europe in debt and caused inflation, and Germany was burdened with reparations (Lesson 7.6). In the 1920s the United States was prosperous and lent money abroad, which tied the world economy to American finance. In October 1929, stock prices in New York crashed. Banks failed, businesses closed, and unemployment soared, reaching about a quarter of the American workforce by 1933. The crisis spread globally, since the United States stopped lending and raised tariffs, which cut trade. By 1932, world trade had fallen by about two thirds, and unemployment was severe in industrial countries. Countries that exported raw materials, such as Brazil, which depended on coffee, suffered from the collapse of prices.

The traditional view had been that governments should let markets correct themselves (Lesson 5.7), but the scale of the crisis led many states to intervene.

The Soviet Union: the Five-Year Plans

The CED says that in the Soviet Union, the government controlled the national economy through the Five Year Plans, often implementing repressive policies, with negative repercussions for the population. After a civil war, Lenin's government had allowed some private trade in the 1920s. Under Joseph Stalin, who gained control after Lenin's death in 1924, the state moved to a planned economy. The First Five-Year Plan (1928 to 1932) set targets for heavy industry, such as steel, coal, and machinery, and the state owned all factories and set the goals. Peasants were forced into collective farms, and the government took grain to feed cities and for export. Those who resisted, including better-off peasants labeled "kulaks," were deported or killed. The result was a rapid rise in industrial output but also a terrible famine in 1932 to 1933, especially in Ukraine and Kazakhstan, that killed millions. The government also used the secret police and forced labor camps to enforce its plans. The Soviet Union industrialized quickly, which later helped it to resist Germany, but at a huge human cost.

The New Deal in the United States

President Franklin D. Roosevelt, elected in 1932, promised "a new deal for the American people" and expanded the government's role. The New Deal created programs to put people to work (the Works Progress Administration and the Civilian Conservation Corps), regulated banks and the stock market, insured bank deposits, supported farm prices, and established Social Security in 1935 and recognized labor unions. It did not end the Depression by itself, since unemployment remained high until war production began, but it changed ideas about government's responsibility, and it preserved democratic government and capitalism.

Fascist corporatist economies

The CED lists the fascist corporatist economy. In Italy under Benito Mussolini, and in other fascist states, the government claimed to organize the economy through corporations, groups that brought together employers, workers, and the state by industry. In practice, independent unions were banned and the state, working with big business, controlled labor and promoted rearmament and public works. In Nazi Germany, after 1933, the government undertook large public works and rearmament, which reduced unemployment, and it directed trade and production toward preparing for war. Fascist economies stressed national unity over class conflict, and they were closely tied to militarism and repression.

Governments with popular support in Brazil and Mexico

The CED also mentions governments with strong popular support in Brazil and Mexico. In Brazil, Getulio Vargas, who took power in 1930 and ruled as an authoritarian leader (the "Estado Novo," 1937 to 1945), promoted industry, labor laws, and state control of key sectors. In Mexico, President Lazaro Cardenas (1934 to 1940) carried out major land reform, distributing millions of acres to peasants, and in 1938 nationalized the foreign-owned oil industry. Both governments used state power to reduce dependence on foreign capital and gain popular support.

Comparing responses

CountryResponseMain features
Soviet UnionFive-Year PlansState ownership, central planning, collectivization, repression
United StatesNew DealPublic works, regulation, social insurance, democratic institutions
Italy and GermanyFascist corporatismState directing business and labor, rearmament, repression
Brazil and MexicoState-led developmentSupport for industry, land reform, nationalization

In all cases, the state played a larger economic role than before, though the political systems differed from democracy to dictatorship.

Primary source · A new deal

Franklin D. Roosevelt, speech accepting the Democratic nomination for president, Chicago, July 2, 1932 (a US federal public record).

I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.

Sourcing (HIPP). Roosevelt was the governor of New York and a candidate for president, so his point of view is that of a politician seeking support in an economic crisis. His purpose was to offer hope and a break from the policies of the incumbent president, Herbert Hoover, and his audience was the Democratic convention and the American public listening on radio. A campaign pledge states intentions without specifying the programs that followed, so it is evidence of the political mood and promise of the moment, not of what the New Deal achieved.

Source analysis · A political promise

Claim. Roosevelt promised that government would take a more active role in dealing with the Depression.

Evidence. He pledged "a new deal for the American people."

Reasoning. The phrase signaled a break from earlier policy and a commitment to new government action, which fits the CED's point that governments took a more active role in economic life. A limit is that it is a campaign line with no details, so it does not tell us what the New Deal actually did or how well it worked.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference in how the Soviet Union and the United States responded to economic crisis.

Model. In both countries the government took a much larger role in the economy, through the Five-Year Plans in the Soviet Union and the New Deal in the United States. The difference is that the Soviet state owned the means of production and directed the economy by central planning, with repression, while the United States kept private ownership and democratic institutions and added regulation, public works, and social insurance.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7D asks how different governments responded to economic crisis. Know the Depression and four responses: Five-Year Plans, the New Deal, fascist corporatism, and Brazil and Mexico. For each, name specific policies and say how the state's role changed.

Practice
  1. What triggered the global Depression?
    Show answer

    The 1929 American stock market crash, followed by bank failures, falling lending and trade, and rising tariffs.

  2. What were the Five-Year Plans?
    Show answer

    Soviet plans for state-controlled industrialization and collective farming that raised industrial output but caused famine and repression.

  3. Name two New Deal programs.
    Show answer

    The Works Progress Administration, the Civilian Conservation Corps, Social Security, and bank regulation and deposit insurance.

  4. What was fascist corporatism?
    Show answer

    A system in which the state claimed to organize the economy through industry corporations of employers, workers, and the state, while banning independent unions.

  5. What did Cardenas do in Mexico?
    Show answer

    He distributed land to peasants and nationalized the foreign-owned oil industry in 1938.

  6. Why is a campaign slogan limited as evidence of policy?
    Show answer

    It states intentions without details, so it does not show what programs were adopted or how they worked.

Lesson 7.5 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.5

Unresolved tensions after World War I

The peace settlement of 1919 did not end empires. It rearranged them. The CED says that between the two world wars, Western and Japanese imperial states predominantly maintained control over colonial holdings; in some cases, they gained additional territories through conquest or treaty settlement and in other cases faced anti-imperial resistance. The learning objective asks about continuities and changes in territorial holdings. This lesson covers the mandate system, Japanese and Italian expansion, and anti-imperial resistance.

Required content · 7E

Learning objective.

  • 7E. Explain the continuities and changes in territorial holdings from 1900 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.I.B. Between the two world wars, Western and Japanese imperial states predominantly maintained control over colonial holdings; in some cases, they gained additional territories through conquest or treaty settlement and in other cases faced anti-imperial resistance.

The mandate system

After World War I, the victorious powers divided the colonies of the defeated states. The new League of Nations, created in 1920, assigned these lands as mandates to winners, who were supposed to prepare them for eventual independence. The CED's example is the transfer of former German colonies to Great Britain and France under the system of League of Nations mandates. Germany's colonies in Africa and the Pacific were divided among Britain, France, Belgium, Japan, and others. Former Ottoman lands were also handled this way. Britain received Iraq, Palestine, and Transjordan, and France received Syria and Lebanon. Arab leaders who had been promised independence in return for help against the Ottomans felt betrayed. And in the Balfour Declaration (1917), Britain had supported a Jewish national home in Palestine, which set the stage for later conflict between Jews and Arabs. In practice, the mandates were new forms of colonial rule.

President Woodrow Wilson had called in his Fourteen Points for national self-determination, the idea that peoples should choose their own government, but it was applied mainly to the peoples of Europe, and not to colonies.

Japanese expansion

Japan, a victor in 1918, gained German islands in the Pacific as a mandate. It continued to build its empire, and the CED refers to Manchukuo and the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere. In 1931, Japanese army officers staged an incident and seized Manchuria in northeastern China. In 1932 Japan set up a puppet state there called Manchukuo. The League of Nations condemned the action, and Japan withdrew from the League in 1933. In 1937 Japan invaded China more fully, and in 1940 it announced a Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, a plan for an Asian economic bloc led by Japan that claimed to free Asia from Western rule while actually serving Japanese interests.

Italian expansion

Italy under Mussolini sought a new empire. In 1935 it invaded Ethiopia, one of the few independent African states, and conquered it by 1936, using poison gas and modern weapons. The League of Nations imposed only weak sanctions, and the episode showed that it could not stop a determined aggressor.

Anti-imperial resistance

The CED lists two examples of anti-imperial resistance.

  • Indian National Congress. Founded in 1885, the Congress became a mass movement under Mohandas Gandhi, who returned to India in 1915 and led campaigns of nonviolent resistance (satyagraha) against British rule, such as the Salt March of 1930, when he led a march to the sea to make salt in defiance of the British monopoly. Britain granted some reforms in the 1935 Government of India Act but not independence.
  • West African resistance. In French West Africa and in British colonies such as the Gold Coast and Nigeria, strikes, congresses, and newspapers challenged colonial rule and demanded rights. These efforts were limited but laid the ground for later independence movements.

Elsewhere, Egypt gained nominal independence in 1922 but remained under British influence, and in the Middle East, Arab nationalists resisted the mandates, as in Syria's revolt of 1925 to 1927 and the Arab revolt in Palestine of 1936 to 1939.

Continuity and change

On the whole, continuity was strong, since the major colonial empires, British and French especially, were larger in 1919 to 1939 than before the war. Change included the end of German and Ottoman colonial holdings, the creation of the mandate system, and the growth of organized nationalism in the colonies, which many colonial subjects strengthened after serving in the war.

Primary source · A promise and its limits

Woodrow Wilson, address to Congress on the Fourteen Points, January 8, 1918 (a US federal public record), point 5 in part.

The interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight with the equitable claims of the government whose title is to be determined.

Sourcing (HIPP). Wilson was President of the United States, so the point of view is that of the leader of a power that had joined the war late and sought a peace on liberal principles. The purpose of the Fourteen Points was to state war aims and to rally Allied and neutral opinion, and the audience was Congress, the Allies, the Central Powers, and peoples under imperial rule. Point 5, about colonial claims, was vaguely worded and gave equal weight to the colonial powers' claims, so many colonized peoples who read it as a promise of independence were disappointed.

Source analysis · A vague principle

Claim. Wilson's statement raised hopes among colonized peoples that it did not satisfy.

Evidence. Point 5 says the interests of the populations must have equal weight with the claims of the government that holds title.

Reasoning. Giving the colonial government's claim equal weight with the people's interests did not promise independence, but colonial nationalists quoted the language of self-determination, which shows the gap between hopes and results. A limit is that the text alone does not show how colonized peoples reacted, which requires other evidence such as nationalist writings.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in territorial holdings between the world wars.

Model. One continuity was that Britain and France kept their colonial empires and even expanded them, since they gained former German and Ottoman lands as League of Nations mandates. One change was that Germany and the Ottoman Empire lost their colonies, and Japan and Italy expanded their empires by conquest, in Manchuria and Ethiopia.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7E asks for continuities and changes in territorial holdings. Cover the mandate system, Japanese expansion (Manchukuo, the Co-Prosperity Sphere), Italian conquest of Ethiopia, and resistance (Indian National Congress and West Africa). Stress that imperial control largely continued.

Practice
  1. What were League of Nations mandates?
    Show answer

    Former German and Ottoman colonies assigned to victorious powers, such as Britain and France, to administer and supposedly prepare for independence.

  2. Which former Ottoman lands did Britain and France receive?
    Show answer

    Britain received Iraq, Palestine, and Transjordan, and France received Syria and Lebanon.

  3. What was Manchukuo?
    Show answer

    A puppet state Japan set up in Manchuria after seizing it in 1931 to 1932.

  4. What was the Salt March?
    Show answer

    Gandhi's 1930 march to the sea to make salt in defiance of the British monopoly, a campaign of nonviolent resistance.

  5. Why did the League of Nations fail to stop aggression?
    Show answer

    It had no army and its members imposed only weak sanctions, as shown by the invasions of Manchuria and Ethiopia.

  6. Why was Wilson's self-determination limited?
    Show answer

    It was applied mainly to the peoples of Europe, while colonies became mandates under the victorious powers.

Lesson 7.6 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.6

The causes of World War II

World War II (1939 to 1945) was the deadliest conflict in human history, killing an estimated 70 to 85 million people. The CED asks about the causes and consequences of World War II. It states that the causes of World War II included the unsustainable peace settlement after World War I, the global economic crisis engendered by the Great Depression, continued imperialist aspirations, and especially the rise to power of fascist and totalitarian regimes that resulted in the aggressive militarism of Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler. This lesson takes each cause in turn.

Required content · 7F

Learning objective.

  • 7F. Explain the causes and consequences of World War II.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.B.ii. The causes of World War II included the unsustainable peace settlement after World War I, the global economic crisis engendered by the Great Depression, continued imperialist aspirations, and especially the rise to power of fascist and totalitarian regimes that resulted in the aggressive militarism of Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler.

An unsustainable peace

The Treaty of Versailles (1919) was meant to prevent another war. It took territory from Germany, limited its army, and blamed it for the war. Many Germans felt humiliated, and some leaders exploited this resentment. Economists such as John Maynard Keynes warned that heavy reparations would harm Europe's economy. The peace also created many new states in Eastern Europe, with borders that left large minorities and disputes, and the United States, whose president Wilson had helped design the settlement, refused to join the League of Nations, which weakened the new order. The CED calls it an unsustainable settlement, since it was too harsh to be accepted by Germany and not strong enough to be enforced against it.

The Great Depression

The global crisis of the 1930s (Lesson 7.4) destroyed confidence in democracy and capitalism in many countries. In Germany, unemployment passed six million, and voters turned to extremist parties. In Japan, the Depression strengthened the military's claim that expansion was the solution to economic problems. The Depression also weakened the democratic powers, who focused on their own recovery.

Continued imperialist aspirations

Several powers aimed to expand. Japan sought an empire in Asia (Lesson 7.5), Italy sought to rebuild a Mediterranean and African empire, and Germany sought Lebensraum, "living space," in Eastern Europe. These ambitions meant that they were not satisfied with the existing order.

The rise of fascist and totalitarian regimes

The key cause, in the CED's view, was the rise to power of fascist and totalitarian regimes. Fascism is an ideology that glorifies the nation and the leader, rejects democracy and liberalism, and uses violence and propaganda. A totalitarian state seeks to control all aspects of life. The main examples were:

  • Italy, where Benito Mussolini took power in 1922.
  • Germany, where Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party came to power in January 1933, ended democracy, and persecuted Jews and political opponents. Nazism stressed racial theories, extreme nationalism, and the revision of Versailles.
  • Japan, where military leaders gained control in the 1930s, though Japan's regime differed from European fascism.
  • The Soviet Union, a communist totalitarian state under Stalin.

Hitler, in the CED's phrase, led the aggressive militarism of Nazi Germany. He openly broke Versailles by rebuilding the army in 1935 and sending troops into the demilitarized Rhineland in 1936.

Appeasement and the road to war

Britain and France, wanting to avoid another war, followed a policy of appeasement, giving in to some demands in the hope of satisfying Hitler. Germany annexed Austria in March 1938. At the Munich Conference in September 1938, Britain and France agreed to let Germany take the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia, and in March 1939 Hitler took the rest of Czechoslovakia. In August 1939, Germany and the Soviet Union signed the Nazi-Soviet Pact, a nonaggression treaty with a secret agreement to divide Poland. Germany invaded Poland on September 1, 1939, and Britain and France declared war. In Asia, the war had begun earlier, with Japan's full invasion of China in 1937.

Consequences

World War II led to the defeat of Germany, Italy, and Japan, enormous destruction, the Holocaust, the creation of the United Nations in 1945, the rise of the United States and Soviet Union as superpowers, and the Cold War (Unit 8). It also weakened the European empires and speeded decolonization.

Primary source · The war guilt clause

Treaty of Versailles (1919), Article 231, in the official English text.

The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage to which the Allied and Associated Governments and their nationals have been subjected as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies.

Sourcing (HIPP). The treaty was written by the victorious Allies, and Germany was forced to sign it, so the point of view is that of the victors. The purpose of Article 231 was to establish a legal basis for reparations by assigning responsibility for the war's damage, and the audience was Germany, the Allies' own publics, and the world. Many Germans read it as a statement of sole guilt for the war, though the article's wording concerns responsibility for loss and damage, and the resentment it caused became a theme of nationalist politics.

Source analysis · Responsibility and resentment

Claim. The war guilt clause fed German resentment of the peace.

Evidence. Article 231 says Germany accepts responsibility for causing all the loss and damage of the war.

Reasoning. A statement that places responsibility for all damage on Germany, together with the heavy reparations that followed, could easily be read as a charge of guilt, which nationalists used to attack the Weimar government. A limit is that the legal purpose of the article was to justify reparations, and not every German reaction was the same, so the clause alone does not explain Nazi success.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way the Great Depression contributed to the outbreak of World War II.

Model. The Depression caused mass unemployment and distrust of democratic governments in Germany, which helped Hitler and the Nazi Party win support and come to power in 1933. In Japan, it strengthened the military's argument that expansion in Asia would solve economic problems, which led to the invasion of Manchuria.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7F asks for the causes and consequences of World War II. Cover the four CED causes (the unsustainable peace, the Depression, imperial aspirations, and fascist and totalitarian regimes), and the path to war (appeasement, Munich, the Nazi-Soviet Pact). Link each cause to specific events.

Practice
  1. Why was the Treaty of Versailles called unsustainable?
    Show answer

    It was too harsh to be accepted by Germany but not strong enough to be enforced against it.

  2. How did the Depression help extremist movements?
    Show answer

    It caused mass unemployment and distrust of democracy, which led German voters toward the Nazis and strengthened the military in Japan.

  3. What is fascism?
    Show answer

    An ideology that glorifies the nation and leader, rejects democracy and liberalism, and uses violence and propaganda.

  4. What was appeasement?
    Show answer

    The policy of Britain and France of giving in to some of Hitler's demands in the hope of avoiding war, as at Munich in 1938.

  5. What was the Nazi-Soviet Pact?
    Show answer

    A 1939 German-Soviet nonaggression treaty with a secret agreement to divide Poland.

  6. Why is Article 231 limited as evidence of Allied purpose?
    Show answer

    Its legal purpose was to justify reparations, so it does not show all Allied motives, though many Germans read it as a charge of sole guilt.

Lesson 7.7 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.7

World War II: the course of the war

This lesson covers how the war unfolded in Europe, Asia, and the Pacific. The next lesson covers how governments mobilized their societies and how weapons changed the war's scale. The CED says that World War II was a total war and that new military technology and new tactics, including the atomic bomb, fire-bombing, and the waging of "total war," led to increased levels of wartime casualties.

Required content · 7G

Learning objective.

  • 7G. Explain similarities and differences in how governments used a variety of methods to conduct war.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.A.ii. World War II was a total war. Governments used a variety of strategies, including political propaganda, art, media, and intensified forms of nationalism, to mobilize populations (both in the home countries and the colonies or former colonies) for the purpose of waging war. Governments used ideologies, including fascism and communism to mobilize all of their state’s resources for war and, in the case of totalitarian states, to repress basic freedoms and dominate many aspects of daily life during the course of the conflicts and beyond.
  • 6.1.III.C.ii. New military technology and new tactics, including the atomic bomb, fire-bombing, and the waging of “total war” led to increased levels of wartime casualties.

War in Europe, 1939 to 1941

Germany used fast, concentrated attacks by tanks, aircraft, and motorized infantry, called blitzkrieg ("lightning war"), to defeat Poland in September 1939, Denmark and Norway in April 1940, and the Netherlands, Belgium, and France by June 1940. Britain, led from May 1940 by Winston Churchill, held out in the Battle of Britain, where the Royal Air Force defeated German air attacks in the second half of 1940. By 1941 Germany and its allies controlled most of continental Europe, and Italy, Germany's partner, had joined the war in June 1940.

The war widens, 1941

On June 22, 1941, Germany broke the Nazi-Soviet Pact and invaded the Soviet Union in Operation Barbarossa, the largest invasion in history, hoping for a quick victory. German forces advanced deep into the country but failed to take Moscow before winter. On December 7, 1941, Japan attacked the American naval base at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, and at the same time attacked British and Dutch colonies in Southeast Asia. Germany then declared war on the United States, and the separate wars in Europe and Asia became one global war. The Allies, mainly the United States, Britain, and the Soviet Union, faced the Axis powers of Germany, Italy, and Japan.

1931 Japan seizes Manchuria 1933 Hitler becomes chancellor Sept 1939 Germany invades Poland June 1941 Germany invades the USSR Dec 1941 Pearl Harbor; war becomes global 1942-43 Midway and Stalingrad June 1944 D-Day Aug 1945 Atomic bombs; Japan surrenders
Figure 7.2. Key moments of the war. The conflict began in Asia and Europe separately and merged into a single global war in 1941.

The turning points, 1942 to 1943

  • Midway (June 1942). In the Pacific, US naval forces sank four Japanese aircraft carriers near Midway Island, which ended Japan's offensive.
  • Stalingrad (1942 to 1943). The Soviet army encircled and destroyed a German army at Stalingrad, in one of the bloodiest battles of the war, and began to push the Germans back.
  • North Africa and Italy. The Allies defeated German and Italian forces in North Africa in 1943 and invaded Italy, which surrendered in September 1943, though German forces continued to fight there.

Allied victory, 1944 to 1945

On June 6, 1944 (D-Day), Allied forces landed in Normandy, France, and opened a second front in the west. Soviet armies advanced from the east. Germany surrendered on May 8, 1945, after Hitler's death. In the Pacific, American forces advanced island by island toward Japan, and bombed Japanese cities. In August 1945, the United States dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima (August 6) and Nagasaki (August 9), and the Soviet Union declared war on Japan. Japan announced its surrender on August 15, and the formal surrender was signed on September 2, 1945.

The atomic bomb

The atomic bomb was developed by the United States in the secret Manhattan Project, with British and Canadian help. It could destroy a city with a single weapon. The decision to use it is debated. Supporters argued that it ended the war quickly and avoided an invasion that would cost many lives. Critics argue that Japan was near defeat, that alternatives existed, and that the bombs killed tens of thousands of civilians at once, with many more dying later of radiation. The CED points to the bomb as an example of new military technology that increased casualties, and it changed the world by making nuclear weapons central to international politics.

Casualties

About 70 to 85 million people died in the war, more than half of them civilians, from combat, bombing, massacres, famine, and genocide. The Soviet Union lost an estimated 24 to 27 million people, China about 15 to 20 million, and Germany about 7 million. The war's effects are covered further in Lessons 7.7b and 7.8.

Primary source · Announcing the atomic bomb

Harry S. Truman, statement by the President announcing the use of the atomic bomb, August 6, 1945 (a US federal public record).

It is a harnessing of the basic power of the universe.

Sourcing (HIPP). Truman was the President of the United States, so the point of view is that of the head of the government that built and used the bomb. His purpose was to inform the public of the new weapon and to present its use as part of a justified effort to end the war, and the audience was the American public and Japan. The statement emphasizes scientific achievement and does not describe the human cost at Hiroshima, which was not yet known to the public, so it shows how the government framed the event and not what it did to the city.

Source analysis · How the bomb was announced

Claim. The US government presented the atomic bomb as a major scientific and military achievement.

Evidence. Truman described it as a harnessing of the basic power of the universe.

Reasoning. The language stresses scientific accomplishment and power, which suggests that the government wanted to present the weapon as a triumph and as part of the Allied effort to end the war. A limit is that the statement says nothing about the casualties at Hiroshima, so it shows how the event was framed for the public, not its effects.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way the war in Europe and the war in Asia became a single global war.

Model. The wars were joined in December 1941 when Japan attacked Pearl Harbor and European colonies in Southeast Asia, and Germany then declared war on the United States. Before that, Germany and Japan had fought separate wars, but afterward the United States, Britain, and the Soviet Union fought the Axis powers across both regions.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7G asks about how governments conducted war. For this lesson, know the sequence (blitzkrieg, Battle of Britain, Barbarossa, Pearl Harbor, Midway and Stalingrad, D-Day, atomic bombs) and why the war became global in 1941. Note the new technology (the bomb, firebombing) and the casualties.

Practice
  1. What was blitzkrieg?
    Show answer

    German "lightning war" using concentrated tanks, aircraft, and motorized infantry for fast attacks.

  2. Why did the war become global in 1941?
    Show answer

    Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June and Japan attacked Pearl Harbor and Southeast Asia in December, after which Germany declared war on the United States.

  3. What were two turning points of 1942 to 1943?
    Show answer

    The American victory at Midway in the Pacific and the Soviet victory at Stalingrad.

  4. What was D-Day?
    Show answer

    The Allied landing in Normandy, France, on June 6, 1944, which opened a second front in the west.

  5. How did the war with Japan end?
    Show answer

    After atomic bombs were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the Soviet Union declared war, Japan surrendered in August 1945.

  6. Why is Truman's statement limited as evidence about Hiroshima?
    Show answer

    It frames the bomb as a scientific achievement and says nothing about the human cost, which was not yet known to the public.

Lesson 7.8 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.7

World War II: mobilization and technology

The CED asks you to explain similarities and differences in how governments used a variety of methods to conduct war. It says that World War II was a total war. Governments used a variety of strategies, including political propaganda, art, media, and intensified forms of nationalism, to mobilize populations (both in the home countries and the colonies or former colonies) for the purpose of waging war. Governments used ideologies, including fascism and communism, to mobilize all of their state's resources for war and, in the case of totalitarian states, to repress basic freedoms and dominate many aspects of daily life during the course of the conflicts and beyond. This lesson compares democratic and totalitarian mobilization.

Required content · 7G

Learning objective.

  • 7G. Explain similarities and differences in how governments used a variety of methods to conduct war.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.A.ii. World War II was a total war. Governments used a variety of strategies, including political propaganda, art, media, and intensified forms of nationalism, to mobilize populations (both in the home countries and the colonies or former colonies) for the purpose of waging war. Governments used ideologies, including fascism and communism to mobilize all of their state’s resources for war and, in the case of totalitarian states, to repress basic freedoms and dominate many aspects of daily life during the course of the conflicts and beyond.
  • 6.1.III.C.ii. New military technology and new tactics, including the atomic bomb, fire-bombing, and the waging of “total war” led to increased levels of wartime casualties.

Western democracies mobilizing for war

The CED lists Great Britain under Winston Churchill and the United States under Franklin Roosevelt.

  • Britain. The government introduced conscription, rationing of food and fuel, and controls over industry. Churchill's speeches inspired national resolve, and civilians, including women, worked in factories, ran farms, served as air-raid wardens, and joined auxiliary military units. Britain also drew on its empire, with millions of soldiers and laborers from India, Africa, the Caribbean, and the dominions.
  • The United States. Within months of Pearl Harbor, American industry was converted to war production. The country built tens of thousands of aircraft, ships, and tanks, which earned it the title "the arsenal of democracy." Roosevelt used radio addresses to explain the war. Rationing, war bonds, and scrap drives involved civilians. Millions of women took industrial jobs, and posters such as one featuring "Rosie the Riveter" encouraged them. The government also interned about 120,000 Japanese Americans, most of them US citizens, a policy later recognized as unjust. The country remained a democracy and allowed criticism, though it censored some news.

Totalitarian states mobilizing for war

The CED lists Germany under Adolf Hitler and the USSR under Joseph Stalin.

  • Germany. The Nazi state used propaganda, directed by Joseph Goebbels, through film, radio, rallies, and schools, to build loyalty to Hitler. It controlled all aspects of life, used the secret police to repress opponents, and used slave labor from occupied countries and concentration camps for its war economy. As the war turned against it, the regime called on all civilians to fight to the end.
  • The Soviet Union. Stalin's government used a planned economy already geared to heavy industry (Lesson 7.4) and moved factories east, out of the reach of the invaders. It used propaganda that appealed both to communism and to Russian nationalism, calling the struggle the "Great Patriotic War." The state demanded vast sacrifices and punished retreat and suspected disloyalty harshly. Women served in factories and in combat roles, including as pilots and snipers.

Similarities and differences

Democracies (Britain, US)Totalitarian states (Germany, USSR)
PropagandaUsed posters, radio, and film to rally supportUsed propaganda with control of all media
EconomyGovernment direction, rationing, private industryState control of the economy, forced labor
FreedomsLimited by emergency measures, with elections and a free press largely preservedRepressed basic freedoms, with secret police and terror
IdeologyDefense of liberty and nationFascism (Germany) and communism combined with nationalism (USSR)
WomenEntered industry and auxiliary servicesEntered industry, and in the USSR also combat

Both groups mobilized populations, built propaganda, and drew on colonies or occupied lands, but the totalitarian regimes went further in dominating daily life.

The colonies

Colonial peoples were drawn into the war. India contributed over two million soldiers, and many African, Caribbean, and Southeast Asian people served or labored. Japan also claimed to liberate Asians from Western rule, but its occupation was often brutal, with forced labor, and some nationalist leaders, such as Sukarno in Indonesia, cooperated with it for their own aims. The war weakened the European colonial powers and raised hopes for independence (Lesson 8.5a).

Technology and tactics

New weapons and tactics raised casualties. Strategic bombing of cities targeted factories and civilians: German raids on London and Coventry, Allied raids on Hamburg and Dresden, and American fire-bombing of Tokyo in March 1945, which killed an estimated 100,000 people in a night. Radar, aircraft carriers, tanks, submarines, rockets, and the atomic bomb changed warfare. The decision to target civilians blurred the line between military and civilian targets and fits the CED's term total war.

Description of: a wartime poster

Description of the American poster "We Can Do It!" (1943), made for the Westinghouse Electric company by the artist J. Howard Miller. This is a description, not a quotation.

The poster shows a woman in a work shirt and a red-and-white polka dot bandanna, flexing her arm, with the words "We Can Do It!" above her. It was displayed in factories as part of a campaign to encourage worker morale.

Sourcing (HIPP). The poster was made for a company, as part of a program by the War Production Coordinating Committee, so the point of view is that of employers and government wartime planners. Its purpose was to boost morale and cooperation among workers in factories, and its audience was workers inside Westinghouse plants, not the general public, and it became widely known only decades later. The poster shows how wartime messaging encouraged women to take industrial roles, but it was not a record of women workers' own experiences.

Source analysis · Wartime messaging

Claim. Wartime campaigns encouraged women to take industrial jobs.

Evidence. A poster made for factory use showed a determined woman in work clothes and said "We Can Do It!"

Reasoning. An image that portrays women workers as strong and capable shows an attempt to persuade women, and factory managers, that women could do war production work. A limit is that it was made by a company for its workers and became famous much later, so it shows planners' intentions and not what women workers felt.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference in how Britain and the Soviet Union mobilized for World War II.

Model. Both used propaganda and appealed to nationalism to rally their populations, and both brought women into war industry. The difference is that Britain remained a parliamentary democracy with a free press and limited emergency controls, while the Soviet state, a totalitarian regime, controlled all media and economic life, and enforced obedience through the secret police and harsh punishment.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7G asks for similarities and differences in methods governments used. Compare democracies (Britain, the US) with totalitarian states (Germany, the USSR) in propaganda, economy, freedoms, ideology, and the use of colonies. Name the new technologies and tactics (bombing, fire-bombing, radar, the atomic bomb) that raised casualties.

Practice
  1. How did the United States mobilize its economy for war?
    Show answer

    It converted industry to war production, built huge numbers of aircraft, ships, and tanks, and used rationing, war bonds, and posters to involve civilians.

  2. How did Germany mobilize its population?
    Show answer

    Through propaganda, control of all aspects of life, secret police repression, and the use of slave labor in the war economy.

  3. What was the Great Patriotic War?
    Show answer

    The Soviet name for the war against Germany, used in propaganda that appealed to both communism and Russian nationalism.

  4. Name one difference between democratic and totalitarian mobilization.
    Show answer

    Democracies kept elections and a largely free press under emergency limits, while totalitarian states repressed basic freedoms and dominated daily life.

  5. What was fire-bombing?
    Show answer

    Bombing with incendiary weapons to start fires in cities, as in the American raids on Tokyo in 1945.

  6. Why is the Rosie poster limited as evidence of women's experience?
    Show answer

    It was made by a company for workers and became famous later, so it shows planners' intentions and not how women workers felt.

Lesson 7.9 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.8

Mass atrocities and genocide

The twentieth century saw mass killing on a scale rarely seen before. The CED asks about the various causes and consequences of mass atrocities in the period from 1900 to the present and states that the rise of extremist groups in power led to the attempted destruction of specific populations, notably the Nazi killing of the Jews in the Holocaust during World War II, and to other atrocities, acts of genocide, or ethnic violence. This lesson covers the term and the CED's examples. It treats the subject plainly and without graphic detail.

Required content · 7H

Learning objective.

  • 7H. Explain the various causes and consequences of mass atrocities in the period from 1900 to the present. HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENS

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.III.C. The rise of extremist groups in power led to the attempted destruction of specific populations, notably the Nazi killing of the Jews in the Holocaust during World War II, and to other atrocities, acts of genocide, or ethnic violence.

Definitions

Genocide is the deliberate attempt to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group, in whole or in part. The word was coined in 1944 by Raphael Lemkin, a Polish Jewish lawyer, and the United Nations adopted a convention against genocide in 1948. Ethnic violence and mass atrocities are broader terms for killings and persecution of civilians because of their identity.

Common causes

Historians point to several patterns, though no single cause explains every case.

  • Extremist ideologies in power. Regimes built on extreme nationalism, racism, or revolutionary ideology that treat a group as an enemy.
  • War and crisis. Many atrocities occurred during wars or social upheaval, which gave governments a pretext and cover.
  • Propaganda and dehumanization. Governments portrayed victims as dangerous or subhuman.
  • State power and bureaucracy. Modern states had the means to register, remove, and kill people on a huge scale.
  • Failure of outsiders to intervene. Other countries often did not act, or acted too late.

The CED's examples

  • Armenians in the Ottoman Empire during and after World War I. In 1915, the Ottoman government, fearing that Armenians, a Christian minority, would help Russia, ordered mass deportations, and in the process hundreds of thousands of Armenians were killed by massacres, starvation, and exposure. Estimates of deaths run from about 600,000 to over a million. Many countries and historians recognize it as genocide, though the modern Turkish government rejects that term.
  • Ukraine in the Soviet Union in the 1920s and 1930s. The Soviet policy of forced collectivization and grain seizure caused a famine in 1932 to 1933 (the Holodomor) that killed several million Ukrainians. Historians debate whether it was intended to destroy Ukrainians as a nation, though many governments and scholars call it a genocide. Stalin's regime also carried out mass arrests and executions in the "Great Terror" of 1937 to 1938.
  • The Holocaust. Nazi Germany persecuted Jews from 1933, and during the war, from 1941 to 1945, it organized the systematic murder of about six million Jews across Europe, using shootings, ghettos, and death camps such as Auschwitz-Birkenau. The Nazis also killed Roma and Sinti, disabled people, Poles and other Slavs, Soviet prisoners of war, and political and religious opponents, for a total of millions more. The Holocaust was carried out by a modern state with the help of collaborators in occupied countries.
  • Cambodia in the late 1970s. The communist Khmer Rouge, led by Pol Pot, took power in 1975 and tried to build a radical agrarian society. They emptied cities, abolished money and schools, and killed or worked to death an estimated 1.5 to 2 million people, about a quarter of the population, including religious and ethnic minorities, educated people, and suspected enemies, until Vietnam invaded in 1979.
  • Tutsi in Rwanda in the 1990s. In 1994, Hutu extremists in the government, using radio propaganda and organized militias, carried out a campaign to kill the Tutsi minority and moderate Hutu. Within about a hundred days, an estimated 800,000 people were killed. The international community, including the United Nations, did not intervene in time.

Other atrocities occurred in places such as Nanjing, China, in 1937 to 1938, when Japanese forces killed tens of thousands or more civilians, and in the Balkans in the 1990s, including at Srebrenica in 1995.

Consequences

After the Holocaust, the world created new institutions and ideas, including the Nuremberg trials of Nazi leaders (1945 to 1946), the Genocide Convention (1948), and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948). Later, international tribunals tried leaders for atrocities in Yugoslavia and Rwanda, and the International Criminal Court was founded in 2002. The record also shows the limits of these efforts, since atrocities continued.

Description of: a witness to the Armenian massacres

Description of the memoir of Henry Morgenthau Sr., Ambassador Morgenthau's Story (1918). Morgenthau was the US ambassador to the Ottoman Empire from 1913 to 1916. This is a description, not a quotation.

Morgenthau wrote that the Ottoman government's deportations of Armenians in 1915 amounted to a plan to destroy the Armenian people. He described reports he received from American consuls and missionaries and his own unsuccessful appeals to Ottoman officials to stop the killing.

Sourcing (HIPP). Morgenthau was a diplomat from a neutral power at the time, so his point of view is that of an outside official who saw reports from many places. His purpose was to inform the American public, which he thought had not grasped the scale of the crime, and the book was published during the war, so some wartime motives may have affected how he presented the Ottoman government. His account is supported by other witnesses, including missionaries, consuls, and German officials, which makes it strong evidence.

Source analysis · A diplomat's testimony

Claim. The deportations of Armenians in 1915 were a deliberate campaign of destruction.

Evidence. The American ambassador described them as a plan to destroy the Armenian people and cited reports from consuls and missionaries.

Reasoning. An official in a neutral country with access to many reports is a credible witness, and other sources support the account. A limit is that he published during the war to inform an American public and so may have framed events to move readers, though that does not undermine the facts he reported.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause common to several twentieth-century atrocities.

Model. One common cause was the rise to power of extremist ideologies that treated a group as an enemy, as in the Nazi racial ideology that targeted Jews and the Hutu extremist propaganda that targeted Tutsi in Rwanda. In both cases, state or militia leaders used propaganda to dehumanize victims and organized killing during a time of war or crisis.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7H asks for causes and consequences of mass atrocities. Know the CED's examples (Armenians, Ukraine, the Holocaust, Cambodia, Rwanda), common causes (extremist ideology in power, war, propaganda, state power), and consequences (Nuremberg, the Genocide Convention, tribunals). Handle the topic with accuracy and care.

Practice
  1. What is genocide?
    Show answer

    The deliberate attempt to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group in whole or in part.

  2. What was the Holocaust?
    Show answer

    The Nazi regime's systematic murder of about six million Jews and millions of others between 1933 and 1945, carried out mostly from 1941 to 1945.

  3. Which group committed mass killing in Cambodia?
    Show answer

    The communist Khmer Rouge under Pol Pot, who killed an estimated 1.5 to 2 million people between 1975 and 1979.

  4. What happened in Rwanda in 1994?
    Show answer

    Hutu extremists carried out a campaign of killing against the Tutsi minority and moderate Hutu, killing an estimated 800,000 people in about a hundred days.

  5. Name one international response after the Holocaust.
    Show answer

    The Nuremberg trials, the Genocide Convention of 1948, or the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

  6. Why is Morgenthau's account considered strong evidence?
    Show answer

    He was a neutral diplomat with access to many reports, and consuls, missionaries, and others support his account.

Lesson 7.10 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.9

Causation in global conflict

This lesson practices causation for Unit 7. The CED asks you to explain the relative significance of the causes of global conflict in the period 1900 to the present. Relative significance means judging how much each cause contributed compared with the others.

Required content · 7I

Learning objective.

  • 7I. Explain the relative significance of the causes of global conflict in the period 1900 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.I. The West dominated the global political order at the beginning of the 20th century, but both land-based and maritime empires gave way to new states by the century’s end.
  • 6.2.I.A. The older, land-based Ottoman, Russian, and Qing empires collapsed due to a combination of internal and external factors. These changes in Russia eventually led to communist revolution.
  • 6.2.II.D. States around the world challenged the existing political and social order, including the Mexican Revolution that arose as a result of political crisis.

Identifying and sorting causes

A good causal analysis sorts causes into categories and judges them.

  • Long-term and short-term. Imperial rivalry and nationalism were long-term causes of World War I, while the assassination in Sarajevo was a short-term trigger (Lesson 7.2).
  • Necessary and sufficient. A cause is necessary if the event would not have happened without it, and sufficient if it alone would have produced the event. Few historical causes are sufficient. The alliance system was a necessary part of the spread of war in 1914, but not enough by itself.
  • Political, economic, social, and ideological. Group causes by type, such as the Great Depression (economic) and fascism (ideological).
  • Internal and external. The CED reminds us that the collapse of empires came from a combination of internal and external factors (Lesson 7.1).

Comparing World War I and World War II

World War IWorld War II
Imperial rivalryCompetition for colonies and resourcesJapanese, Italian, and German expansion
NationalismBalkan nationalisms, Pan-Slavism, revancheExtreme nationalism and racial ideology
Alliances and diplomacyRigid alliance blocsAppeasement, failed collective security
Economic factorsTrade and naval rivalryGreat Depression, reparations
Immediate triggerAssassination in SarajevoInvasion of Poland
Link between themThe peace settlement of 1919

One causal link is especially important. The consequences of World War I, such as the harsh treaty, economic dislocation, and the collapse of empires, became causes of World War II. Historians sometimes call the two a single "thirty years' crisis."

Judging relative significance

Suppose you are asked: Evaluate the relative significance of the Great Depression and the rise of fascism as causes of World War II. A strong response might argue:

  1. Claim. The rise of fascist regimes was more significant, but it depended on the Depression.
  2. Evidence. Hitler, Mussolini, and Japan's militarists set the aims of expansion and chose war, which the CED calls the especially important cause. The Depression, however, helped bring Hitler to power by wrecking the German economy and support for democracy.
  3. Reasoning. Without fascist ideology and leaders determined to conquer, economic hardship could have led to other outcomes, as it did in the United States and Britain. But without the Depression, fascism might have remained a fringe movement.
  4. Qualification. The two causes were linked, and the unsustainable peace of 1919 and the weakness of the League also mattered.

Notice the structure: a claim, evidence for each cause, reasoning about significance, and a link between causes.

Challenging the existing order

The CED also includes states around the world challenged the existing political and social order, including the Mexican Revolution that arose as a result of political crisis. Such challenges, along with the Russian and Chinese revolutions, show that conflict in the twentieth century was not only between nations but also between social and political systems. This matters for the Cold War, which Unit 8 covers.

Description of: Keynes on the peace

Description of The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919) by the British economist John Maynard Keynes, who attended the Paris Peace Conference as an adviser to the British Treasury. This is a description, not a quotation.

Keynes argued that the Treaty of Versailles, with its large reparations demands on Germany, was unwise and unjust, and that it would damage the economy of Europe as a whole. He said that the peace would breed poverty and resentment in Germany and that the victors were ignoring the interdependence of European economies.

Sourcing (HIPP). Keynes was a British economist who resigned from the delegation in protest, so his point of view is that of an insider who opposed the settlement. His purpose was to persuade the public and policymakers to revise the treaty, and his audience was the British and American public. He was writing in 1919, long before the events of the 1930s, so his warning was a prediction, not a description of what happened, though later events made him seem right. Some historians argue that the reparations were less damaging than he claimed.

Source analysis · An early warning

Claim. Some contemporaries warned that the peace settlement would cause future trouble.

Evidence. Keynes wrote in 1919 that the treaty's reparations would damage Europe's economy and breed poverty and resentment in Germany.

Reasoning. A well-informed insider predicting these effects shows that the settlement's weaknesses were visible at the time, which supports the claim that the peace was an underlying cause of later conflict. A limit is that he wrote to persuade and that some historians believe he overstated the burden of reparations.

Worked example · Relative significance

Question. Explain which was more significant as a cause of World War II: the peace settlement of 1919 or the rise of fascist regimes.

Model. The rise of fascist regimes was more significant, because leaders such as Hitler set expansion and war as aims and took the decisions that began the war. The peace settlement was important, since it left Germany resentful and unstable and helped extremists, but many countries lived with its terms without going to war, so it was a condition that made fascism's rise easier rather than the direct cause.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 7I asks for the relative significance of causes of global conflict. Sort causes by type and time, use necessary and sufficient thinking, and compare causes with evidence. Show links between the causes of the two world wars, and give a counterargument.

Practice
  1. What is the difference between a necessary and a sufficient cause?
    Show answer

    A necessary cause is one without which the event would not have occurred, while a sufficient cause could produce the event by itself.

  2. How did the aftermath of World War I help cause World War II?
    Show answer

    The harsh treaty, economic dislocation, and the collapse of empires created resentment and instability that extremist movements used.

  3. Why does a strong causation answer include a link between causes?
    Show answer

    It shows how causes interacted, such as the Depression helping fascism rise, which gives a more complete explanation.

  4. Name two types of causes.
    Show answer

    Political, economic, social, and ideological, or long-term and short-term.

  5. What other kind of challenge to the existing order did the CED mention?
    Show answer

    Revolutions such as the Mexican Revolution, which challenged the political and social order of a state.

  6. Why might Keynes overstate the effect of reparations?
    Show answer

    He was an advocate writing to persuade, and some historians argue that reparations were less damaging than he claimed.

Unit 7 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 7 review: Global Conflict, c. 1900–present

Ten questions on the causes and conduct of the world wars, total war and mobilization, the Russian Revolution, the Great Depression, the rise of fascism, mass atrocity, and the effect of the wars on empire, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Which combination best accounts for the outbreak of the First World War?

    Correct. Sarajevo triggered a system already primed: treaty obligations converted a Balkan quarrel into a continental war, and rigid mobilization plans left governments little room to pause.

    The assassination was the trigger, but similar Balkan crises had passed without general war; the system is what made this one escalate.

    No such agreement existed, and the powers were competing rather than coordinating.

    The prewar decade saw substantial European economic growth rather than depression.

  2. Description of: a wartime government recruitment and production poster, 1916.

    The upper half shows a woman operating a lathe in a factory; the lower half shows soldiers in a trench. Text urges the viewer to enlist or to take up work in munitions, and a panel at the base lists the quantity of shells required per day at the front.

    The poster is most useful as evidence for which characteristic of the war?

    Correct. Placing the lathe and the trench in one frame is exactly the argument of total war: the factory is part of the front, and the whole population is enlisted.

    The poster's existence and its appeal for factory labor indicate mass civilian mobilization rather than a professional army fighting alone.

    The image shows a woman at industrial work, which the government is actively encouraging.

    The shell quantities listed and the appeal itself indicate shortage, not sufficiency.

  3. Source: Treaty of Versailles, Article 231, 1919.

    "The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage … as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies."

    The immediate legal purpose of this article was to

    Correct. Establishing responsibility for loss and damage is the legal predicate for the financial claim; the article was drafted to make reparations enforceable.

    Colonial transfers were handled in separate articles establishing the mandate system.

    Military restrictions appeared in different parts of the treaty altogether.

    The mandate system for Ottoman territories was a separate provision with its own machinery.

  4. Which best explains why the Bolsheviks were able to take power in Russia in 1917?

    The Bolsheviks lost the Constituent Assembly elections and dissolved the assembly when it met.

    Correct. Keeping Russia in the war destroyed the Provisional Government's support, and a program addressing exactly the grievances of soldiers, peasants, and city workers gave the Bolsheviks their opening.

    Much of the officer corps and the old elite fought against them in the civil war that followed.

    Germany allowed Lenin transit to Russia, but the seizure of power was carried out by the Bolsheviks themselves.

  5. Description of: a chart of industrial production and unemployment indices for several countries, 1928–1938.

    Production lines for the United States, Germany, and Britain fall steeply after 1929, with unemployment rising sharply in each. The German production line begins rising again after 1933 and unemployment falls quickly; the American line recovers more slowly and dips again in 1937. A line for the Soviet Union rises throughout without a break.

    The Soviet line's divergence from the others is best explained by the fact that the Soviet Union

    Correct. Production targets set by the state rather than by demand meant that a collapse in world prices and trade did not transmit into Soviet output figures.

    Soviet living standards were far below those of the industrial democracies; the chart measures output, not welfare.

    No such assistance was provided, and diplomatic relations were limited in this period.

    Collectivization and forced industrialization caused famine and mass death that the production line does not show, which is a caution about reading such charts.

  6. Which set of features most accurately characterizes interwar fascist movements?

    Correct. These movements defined themselves against both liberal democracy and communism, promising national renewal through a leader and organized street violence.

    Fascist movements attacked parliamentary institutions and targeted minorities as enemies of the nation.

    Internationalism was a communist position; fascists treated the nation as the fundamental unit and opposed class solidarity across borders.

    Fascist regimes intervened heavily in the economy, directing production toward rearmament and autarky.

  7. Japanese expansion in Asia during the 1930s was driven primarily by

    Japan installed military administrations in occupied territories and suppressed representative politics at home during this period.

    Correct. A resource-poor industrial economy hit hard by collapsing trade, combined with an army that could act beyond civilian control, produced expansion into Manchuria and then China.

    The League condemned the seizure of Manchuria, and Japan left the organization in response.

    Japan invaded China in 1937; the two were at war, not allied.

  8. Description of: administrative records introduced as evidence at postwar trials, compiled by a European state during the Second World War.

    The documents include railway schedules allocating rolling stock for the transport of specified populations, ledgers recording numbers of arrivals at named camps, requisition orders for construction materials and chemical supplies, and correspondence on the budgetary cost per prisoner.

    These records are most significant as evidence for which conclusion about the Holocaust?

    Correct. Timetables, ledgers, and cost accounting mean transport ministries, construction firms, and finance officials were all participants: the crime was administered, not improvised.

    Bureaucratic scheduling across multiple ministries is the opposite of spontaneous local action.

    Records were destroyed in some cases, but the volume that survived and was introduced in evidence contradicts the claim as stated.

    Officials allocating rolling stock to named destinations and ordering specific supplies had direct knowledge of what they were arranging.

  9. The participation of colonial troops and laborers in both world wars contributed to decolonization mainly because it

    Correct. Men who had fought for self-determination and against tyranny returned to territories governed without their consent, and independence movements built their arguments on exactly that contradiction.

    The colonial powers retained substantial military capacity and used it: fighting long wars in Indochina, Algeria, and Kenya after 1945.

    Wartime experience generally strengthened nationalist conviction rather than deference.

    The 1919 settlement extended colonial control through the mandate system; large-scale independence came after 1945.

  10. Which statement best describes the global balance of power in 1945 compared with 1914?

    Correct. Two wars in thirty years destroyed European primacy, and power shifted decisively to a pair of states whose rivalry would organize the following four decades.

    Both were financially and militarily exhausted and began losing their empires within a few years.

    Both were defeated, occupied, and disarmed in 1945.

    India was still a colony in early 1945, and China was devastated by war and about to enter renewed civil war.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE cause of global conflict in the period 1900–1945.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way total war changed the relationship between governments and their populations.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way the world wars affected colonial empires.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: alliance systems and mobilization plans; imperial and naval rivalry; nationalism in the Balkans; the terms of the Versailles settlement; the Great Depression; Japanese and German expansionism; the failure of collective security. Must identify a cause.
    • (b) Accept: conscription; rationing and direction of production; propaganda and censorship; women entering industrial work; expanded state powers over information and labor; the extension of suffrage in some states after the war. Must explain the change in relationship.
    • (c) Accept: colonial troops' service raising expectations that produced nationalist movements; the exhaustion of European powers after 1945; self-determination rhetoric applied selectively at Versailles; the mandate system; the wartime demonstration that European powers could be defeated in Asia. Must explain the effect.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) By 1914 the great powers were bound in two alliance systems with mobilization plans that ran on fixed railway timetables. Once one power began to mobilize, its rivals believed they had to follow within days or lose the war before it started, so a crisis in the Balkans escalated into a continental conflict with very little room for negotiation.

    (b) Total war required governments to direct the whole economy, which meant conscripting soldiers, rationing food, controlling what factories produced, and managing what newspapers could print. States acquired powers over daily life that peacetime governments had never held, and many of those powers proved difficult to give back afterwards.

    (c) Millions of colonial subjects served in Allied armies and labor corps in both wars, fighting in a cause described as the defense of freedom and self-determination. Returning to territories still governed without their consent gave nationalist movements an argument that was hard to answer, and after 1945 the European powers were too exhausted to hold their empires against it.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way economic conditions contributed to political change between the world wars.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way technology changed the conduct of warfare in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason historians treat wartime propaganda as valuable evidence despite its unreliability as fact.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the Great Depression undermining faith in liberal democracy and aiding extremist movements; German hyperinflation; reparations and war debts destabilizing the international economy; collapsing commodity prices affecting colonial and Latin American economies. Must link economics to political change.
    • (b) Accept: machine guns and artillery producing trench stalemate; poison gas; the tank and the airplane; submarine warfare; strategic bombing of cities; radar and codebreaking; nuclear weapons. Must explain the effect on how war was fought.
    • (c) Accept: it reveals what governments believed would persuade their populations; it documents official aims and anxieties; it shows what identities and enemies states wished to construct. Must explain the evidentiary value despite distortion.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The Depression threw millions out of work and discredited the liberal democratic governments in office when it struck. In Germany, where unemployment reached roughly a third of the workforce, voters moved rapidly toward parties promising radical solutions, and the Nazis rose from a fringe movement to the largest party in the Reichstag within three years.

    (b) Machine guns and quick-firing artillery gave defenders such an advantage that infantry attacking across open ground were destroyed, which produced the trench systems of the Western Front. Armies then spent four years developing tanks, aircraft, and new artillery methods specifically to break a deadlock that the technology itself had created.

    (c) Propaganda is unreliable about events but highly reliable about its makers. A poster tells us what a government thought would move its population to enlist or accept rationing, and which fears and loyalties officials believed they could draw on: information that official policy documents often leave unstated.

Lesson 8.1 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.1

Setting the stage for the Cold War and decolonization

The end of World War II in 1945 left a changed world. The CED asks for the historical context of the Cold War after 1945, and notes that technological and economic gains experienced during World War II by the victorious nations shifted the global balance of power and that in the years following World War II, increasing anti-imperialist sentiment contributed to the dissolution of empires and the restructuring of states. This lesson explains the postwar setting that produced both the Cold War and decolonization.

Required content · 8A

Learning objective.

  • 8A. Explain the historical context of the Cold War after 1945.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.II. Hopes for greater self-government were largely unfulfilled following the World War I; however, in the years following the World War II, increasing anti-imperialist sentiment contributed to the dissolution of empires and the restructuring of states.
  • 6.2.IV.C.i. Technological and economic gains experienced during World War II by the victorious nations shifted the global balance of power.

A ruined Europe and Asia

The war killed tens of millions of people and destroyed cities and industries across Europe, the Soviet Union, China, and Japan. Germany and Japan were occupied. Britain and France, though victorious, were exhausted and deeply in debt. Their economic strength and prestige were much reduced. Meanwhile, the war had boosted the economy of the United States, whose factories were untouched. By 1945, the US produced about half of the world's manufactured goods, held most of the world's gold reserves, and had the only atomic bomb. The Soviet Union, though it suffered enormous losses, had the largest army in Europe and had pushed its forces deep into Eastern Europe. These two states emerged as superpowers.

New institutions

The Allies built new international institutions meant to prevent another war and another depression.

  • The United Nations (1945) replaced the weak League of Nations. It had a General Assembly of all members and a Security Council with five permanent members (the US, USSR, Britain, France, and China) who could veto resolutions, which meant that it could not act against any of them.
  • The Bretton Woods system (1944) created the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank to stabilize currencies and finance rebuilding, with the US dollar at the center of the system.

Wartime conferences and disagreement

At wartime conferences at Yalta (February 1945) and Potsdam (July to August 1945), the US, Britain, and the Soviet Union agreed on plans for dividing Germany into occupation zones and for the future of Europe, but disagreed about Poland and the rest of Eastern Europe. Stalin wanted friendly governments on the Soviet Union's western border as a buffer against another invasion, while the Western powers wanted free elections. By 1946, Soviet-backed communist governments were taking power in Eastern Europe, and Churchill said that an "iron curtain" had descended across Europe.

Why was there tension?

The two superpowers had fundamentally different systems. The United States promoted democracy and capitalism, and the Soviet Union a one-party communist state with a planned economy. Each believed that its system should be the world's model, and each distrusted the other, since they had been allies only because of Hitler. This ideological conflict, together with disputes over Germany and Eastern Europe, produced the Cold War, a prolonged struggle between the two blocs, fought through alliances, economic aid, propaganda, spying, an arms race, and conflicts in other countries, but not through direct war between the superpowers. The next lesson covers its ideological side.

The other change: anti-imperialism

At the same time, colonial peoples pressed for independence. The war had shown that European powers could be defeated, as when Japan overran British, French, and Dutch colonies in Asia. Colonial soldiers who had fought in Allied armies expected more rights. The Atlantic Charter (1941) and the UN Charter spoke of self-determination. And both superpowers, for different reasons, opposed the old empires. The CED notes that hopes for greater self-government were largely unfulfilled following World War I, but that after World War II, increasing anti-imperialist sentiment contributed to the dissolution of empires and the restructuring of states. Decolonization is the subject of Lessons 8.5a to 8.6.

Primary source · Self-government and the Atlantic Charter

Atlantic Charter, joint declaration by Franklin D. Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, August 14, 1941, point 3 (a US federal public record).

They respect the right of all peoples to choose the form of government under which they will live.

Sourcing (HIPP). The declaration was issued by the American president and British prime minister during the war, before the United States had entered it, so the point of view is that of the leaders of two democracies setting war aims. Its purpose was to rally support for the Allied cause and to describe a postwar world. The audience included peoples under Axis rule and colonized peoples. Churchill later said it did not apply to the British Empire, so many colonial leaders took the language of self-determination as a promise that was not kept, which led them to use it in their own demands.

Source analysis · A promise used by others

Claim. The language of self-determination encouraged anti-colonial movements.

Evidence. The Atlantic Charter said all peoples have the right to choose their form of government.

Reasoning. Colonial leaders could cite the leaders of the two largest empires' allies against the empire itself, which explains why the principle appealed to them. A limit is that Churchill said it applied only to Europe, so the document shows a principle that was stated more widely than it was meant.

Worked example · Contextualization

Question. Explain one way World War II created the context for the Cold War.

Model. The war left the United States and the Soviet Union as the two strongest powers, since Europe's economies were ruined while the US economy grew and the Soviet army held Eastern Europe. Their opposed systems, capitalism and democracy against communism, and their disagreements over Germany and Eastern Europe produced a lasting rivalry.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8A asks for the historical context of the Cold War. Name the shift in power (two superpowers, weakened Europe), new institutions (UN, IMF, World Bank), wartime conferences (Yalta, Potsdam), and the ideological divide. Add the anti-imperial context that produced decolonization.

Practice
  1. Why were the United States and Soviet Union superpowers in 1945?
    Show answer

    The US had a huge untouched economy and the atomic bomb, and the Soviet Union had the largest army in Europe, while Europe and Asia were devastated.

  2. What did the UN Security Council do?
    Show answer

    It handled threats to peace, with five permanent members who could veto resolutions.

  3. What were the IMF and World Bank?
    Show answer

    Bretton Woods institutions created to stabilize currencies and finance rebuilding after the war.

  4. Why did the Soviet Union want friendly governments in Eastern Europe?
    Show answer

    Stalin wanted a buffer against another invasion from the west.

  5. What was the Cold War?
    Show answer

    A prolonged struggle between the US-led and Soviet-led blocs fought through alliances, aid, propaganda, an arms race, and conflicts elsewhere, but without direct war between the superpowers.

  6. Why did World War II encourage decolonization?
    Show answer

    It weakened European powers, showed they could be defeated, and raised hopes for self-government among colonial peoples and soldiers.

Lesson 8.2 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.2

The Cold War: an ideological struggle

The CED asks about the causes and effects of the ideological struggle of the Cold War. It states that the global balance of economic and political power shifted during and after World War II and rapidly evolved into the Cold War. The democracy of the United States and the authoritarian communist Soviet Union emerged as superpowers, which led to ideological conflict and a power struggle between capitalism and communism across the globe. This lesson covers the opening of the Cold War and the third path offered by the Non-Aligned Movement.

Required content · 8B

Learning objective.

  • 8B. Explain the causes and effects of the ideological struggle of the Cold War.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.C.ii. The global balance of economic and political power shifted during and after World War II and rapidly evolved into the Cold War. The democracy of the United States and the authoritarian communist Soviet Union emerged as superpowers, which led to ideological conflict and a power struggle between capitalism and communism across the globe.
  • 6.2.V.B. Groups and individuals, including the Non-Aligned Movement, opposed and promoted alternatives to the existing economic, political, and social orders.

Two ideologies

The United States stood for liberal democracy and capitalism: free elections, private property, markets, and individual rights. The Soviet Union stood for communism, in practice a one-party state with state ownership and central planning, and it presented itself as the leader of a world revolution of workers. Each regarded the other as a threat to its own survival and to the world order. Each also offered a model to the new states created by decolonization.

Containment and the Truman Doctrine

In 1946, the American diplomat George Kennan, writing from Moscow, argued that the Soviet Union was expansionist and should be resisted by firm, patient containment. Containment became the basis of US policy. In March 1947, President Harry Truman announced the Truman Doctrine, promising American support for free peoples resisting subjugation, and asked Congress for aid to Greece and Turkey, where communist movements were active. In June 1947, Secretary of State George Marshall proposed the Marshall Plan, which gave about $13 billion in aid to rebuild Western Europe. The Soviet Union rejected it for itself and its allies, and set up its own organization, Comecon, in 1949 to coordinate Eastern European economies.

Division of Europe and Germany

Germany was divided into four occupation zones, and so was Berlin. In 1948, when the Western powers created a new currency for their zones, the Soviets blocked road and rail access to West Berlin. The United States and Britain flew in supplies for almost a year in the Berlin Airlift until the blockade ended in 1949. In that year, Germany split into two states, the Federal Republic (West Germany) and the German Democratic Republic (East Germany). The West formed NATO in 1949, and the Soviets formed the Warsaw Pact in 1955 (Lesson 8.3a). Europe was divided into two blocs, with Churchill's "iron curtain" between them.

Effects of the ideological struggle

  • Economic. The US promoted market economies and trade in the West, while the Soviet bloc used central planning.
  • Political. Governments around the world were pressed to choose sides, and both superpowers supported friendly governments, whether democratic or not.
  • Domestic. In the United States, fear of communism led to loyalty investigations and anti-communist campaigns, often called the "Red Scare" of the early 1950s. In the Soviet bloc, the government suppressed dissent.
  • Cultural. Both sides competed in science, sports, and propaganda, as in the Space Race that began when the Soviet Union launched the satellite Sputnik in 1957.

The Non-Aligned Movement

Many newly independent states did not want to join either bloc. The CED notes that groups and individuals, including the Non-Aligned Movement, opposed and promoted alternatives to the existing economic, political, and social orders. At the Bandung Conference in Indonesia in 1955, leaders of twenty-nine Asian and African states met to oppose colonialism and to assert their independence from the superpowers. In 1961, at Belgrade, leaders including Jawaharlal Nehru of India, Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt, Josip Broz Tito of Yugoslavia, Sukarno of Indonesia, and Kwame Nkrumah of Ghana founded the Non-Aligned Movement. The CED lists Sukarno in Indonesia and Kwame Nkrumah in Ghana. The movement tried to give the developing world a voice and to play both superpowers against each other for aid, though in practice many of its members leaned toward one side or the other.

Primary source · The Truman Doctrine

Harry S. Truman, address to a joint session of Congress, March 12, 1947 (a US federal public record).

I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.

Sourcing (HIPP). Truman was the President of the United States, so the point of view is that of the leader of a democracy seeking to counter Soviet influence. His purpose was to persuade a Congress and a public tired of war to support aid to Greece and Turkey, and he framed the issue in broad terms as a choice between two ways of life. His audience was Congress, the American public, and the Soviet Union. Because it was written to win support, the speech presents a stark picture and the "free peoples" it describes were not always democratic, since the United States later supported dictators who opposed communism.

Source analysis · A global commitment

Claim. The Truman Doctrine committed the United States to opposing the spread of communism beyond Greece and Turkey.

Evidence. Truman said that the US must support free peoples resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or outside pressures.

Reasoning. The language is general, not limited to two countries, so it sets out a policy that could apply anywhere, which the later containment of communism in Korea and Vietnam followed. A limit is that Truman was seeking congressional support and presented the choice in stark terms, and the "free peoples" were not always democracies.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause and one effect of the division of Europe after 1945.

Model. One cause was the disagreement between the Soviet Union and the Western powers over Germany and Eastern Europe, as Stalin wanted friendly governments on his border while the West wanted free elections. One effect was the creation of two German states and two military alliances, NATO and the Warsaw Pact, which divided Europe for more than forty years.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8B asks for causes and effects of the ideological struggle. Know containment, the Truman Doctrine, the Marshall Plan, the Berlin Airlift, NATO, the Warsaw Pact, and Comecon, and add the Non-Aligned Movement (Bandung, Nehru, Nasser, Tito, Sukarno, Nkrumah). Remember that non-alignment was a deliberate third path.

Practice
  1. What was containment?
    Show answer

    The US policy of resisting the spread of Soviet communism through firm and patient opposition.

  2. What was the Marshall Plan?
    Show answer

    American economic aid of about $13 billion to rebuild Western Europe, which the Soviet Union rejected.

  3. What was the Berlin Airlift?
    Show answer

    The 1948 to 1949 operation in which the US and Britain flew supplies into West Berlin after the Soviets blocked land access.

  4. What was the Non-Aligned Movement?
    Show answer

    A group of newly independent states, founded in 1961, that refused to join either superpower bloc.

  5. Name two founders of the Non-Aligned Movement.
    Show answer

    Nehru of India, Nasser of Egypt, Tito of Yugoslavia, Sukarno of Indonesia, or Nkrumah of Ghana.

  6. Why is Truman's speech limited as a description of US policy?
    Show answer

    It was written to win congressional support and framed the issue in stark terms, and the free peoples it described were not always democracies.

Lesson 8.3 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.3

Superpower influence: alliances, aid, and nuclear weapons

The CED asks you to compare the ways in which the United States and the Soviet Union sought to maintain influence over the course of the Cold War. It states that the Cold War produced new military alliances, including NATO and the Warsaw Pact, and led to nuclear proliferation and proxy wars between and within postcolonial states in Latin America, Africa, and Asia. This lesson covers the alliances, the tools of influence, and the nuclear arms race. The next lesson covers the proxy wars.

Required content · 8C

Learning objective.

  • 8C. Compare the ways in which the United States and the Soviet Union sought to maintain influence over the course of the Cold War.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.D. The Cold War produced new military alliances, including NATO and the Warsaw Pact, and led to nuclear proliferation and proxy wars between and within postcolonial states in Latin America, Africa, and Asia.

Military alliances

  • NATO. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was formed in 1949 by the United States, Canada, and ten Western European states. Its members agreed that an attack on one would be an attack on all, which tied the US to the defense of Western Europe. West Germany joined in 1955. The US also formed alliances elsewhere, such as SEATO (1954) in Southeast Asia, and signed treaties with Japan, South Korea, and others.
  • The Warsaw Pact. In 1955, in response to West Germany's entry into NATO, the Soviet Union created a military alliance with its Eastern European satellites. The Pact also served as a means of control. When Hungary tried to leave in 1956, Soviet tanks crushed the revolt, and when Czechoslovakia introduced reforms in 1968 (the "Prague Spring"), Warsaw Pact forces invaded. The Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev claimed the right to intervene when socialism was threatened in a bloc country, a policy called the Brezhnev Doctrine.

Tools of influence

United StatesSoviet Union
AlliancesNATO, SEATO, treaties with Japan, South Korea, and othersWarsaw Pact, treaties with Cuba, Vietnam, and others
Economic aidMarshall Plan, loans, development aidComecon, subsidies and aid to client states
MilitaryBases abroad, arms sales, direct interventionMilitary aid, advisers, direct intervention in the bloc
Covert actionCIA operations, as in Iran (1953) and Guatemala (1954)KGB operations, support for communist movements
Propaganda and cultureRadio Free Europe, jazz and film, consumer goodsState media, the Space Race, sports and cultural exchange

Both sides gave economic and military aid to friendly regimes, used spies and covert operations, and promoted their ideology. The United States tended to support anti-communist governments even when they were dictatorships, and the Soviet Union supported communist and left-leaning movements, and later governments, in the Third World.

Similarities and differences

  • Similarities. Each used alliances and economic aid, built a large military, intervened in other countries, and used propaganda and covert action to extend influence.
  • Differences. The US relied more on market incentives, trade, and voluntary alliances (though it also used force), while the Soviet Union ruled Eastern Europe more directly, with tighter political control, and kept its allies in place by force when needed.

The nuclear arms race

The US exploded the first atomic bomb in 1945, and the Soviet Union tested one in 1949. Each side then built hydrogen bombs and long-range missiles, and the number of warheads reached tens of thousands. Other states acquired nuclear weapons, such as Britain (1952), France (1960), and China (1964), which is called nuclear proliferation. The two superpowers faced a situation of mutually assured destruction, in which a nuclear attack by either would bring catastrophic retaliation, which is thought to have deterred direct war, though the risk was real.

The nearest approach to nuclear war was the Cuban Missile Crisis (October 1962). After the Cuban Revolution (1959), Fidel Castro's government allied with the Soviet Union, which placed missiles in Cuba. President John F. Kennedy announced a naval quarantine and demanded the missiles' removal. After tense days, the Soviets agreed to withdraw them in exchange for a US pledge not to invade Cuba and a quiet promise to remove missiles from Turkey. Afterward, both sides set up a "hotline" and signed a Limited Test Ban Treaty (1963) and later arms control agreements, such as SALT.

Primary source · The Cuban Missile Crisis

John F. Kennedy, radio and television address to the nation, October 22, 1962 (a US federal public record).

It shall be the policy of this Nation to regard any nuclear missile launched from Cuba against any nation in the Western Hemisphere as an attack by the Soviet Union on the United States, requiring a full retaliatory response upon the Soviet Union.

Sourcing (HIPP). Kennedy was the President of the United States, so the point of view is that of the leader of one superpower in the middle of a crisis. His purpose was to inform the American public of the missiles, to warn the Soviet Union, and to rally support for a naval quarantine, and the audience was the American people, the Soviet leadership, and allies. The statement shows how US leaders framed the deterrent threat, but it does not reveal the private negotiations that helped end the crisis.

Source analysis · Deterrence in words

Claim. The superpowers relied on the threat of nuclear retaliation to deter attack.

Evidence. Kennedy said that a missile launched from Cuba would be treated as a Soviet attack requiring a full retaliatory response.

Reasoning. The statement ties any use of the missiles to a massive response, which is the logic of deterrence and of mutually assured destruction. A limit is that it is a public warning meant to rally support and pressure Moscow, and the diplomatic deal that ended the crisis was partly secret.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference in how the United States and the Soviet Union maintained influence.

Model. Both built military alliances, NATO and the Warsaw Pact, and gave economic and military aid to friendly governments. The difference is that the Soviet Union controlled its Eastern European allies more directly and used force to keep them, as in Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968, while the US relied more on voluntary alliances and market incentives, though it also intervened, as in Guatemala and Iran.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8C is a comparison objective. Compare alliances, aid, covert action, and nuclear weapons. Name NATO, the Warsaw Pact, Comecon, the Marshall Plan, Hungary 1956, Czechoslovakia 1968, the Cuban Missile Crisis, and nuclear proliferation. For each, give a similarity and a difference.

Practice
  1. What was NATO?
    Show answer

    A military alliance formed in 1949 by the United States, Canada, and Western European states, in which an attack on one was an attack on all.

  2. What was the Warsaw Pact?
    Show answer

    The 1955 Soviet-led military alliance of Eastern European states that also served as a tool of control.

  3. What did the Soviet Union do in Hungary in 1956?
    Show answer

    It sent tanks to crush a revolt that sought to leave the Warsaw Pact.

  4. What is nuclear proliferation?
    Show answer

    The spread of nuclear weapons to more states, such as Britain, France, and China.

  5. How was the Cuban Missile Crisis resolved?
    Show answer

    The Soviets withdrew the missiles in exchange for a US pledge not to invade Cuba and a quiet promise to remove missiles from Turkey.

  6. What is mutually assured destruction?
    Show answer

    A situation in which a nuclear attack by either superpower would bring catastrophic retaliation, which deterred direct war.

Lesson 8.4 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.3

Proxy wars

The superpowers avoided direct war, yet they fought through others. The CED defines these as proxy wars between and within postcolonial states in Latin America, Africa, and Asia, and lists three examples: the Korean War, the Angolan Civil War, and the Sandinista-Contras conflict in Nicaragua. The skill for this topic is making connections, so this lesson also explains how each war related to larger developments. It adds the Vietnam War and the Soviet-Afghan War, which belong to the same pattern.

Required content · 8C

Learning objective.

  • 8C. Compare the ways in which the United States and the Soviet Union sought to maintain influence over the course of the Cold War.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.D. The Cold War produced new military alliances, including NATO and the Warsaw Pact, and led to nuclear proliferation and proxy wars between and within postcolonial states in Latin America, Africa, and Asia.

What is a proxy war?

A proxy war is a conflict in which two powers support opposing sides in a third country, supplying weapons, money, advisers, and sometimes troops, instead of fighting each other directly. The Cold War's nuclear risk made direct war too dangerous, so rivalry moved to the developing world. Local conflicts often had their own causes, such as nationalism, civil war, or social conflict, which the superpowers then joined.

1947 Truman Doctrine; Marshall Plan 1949 NATO formed; Chinese communist victory 1950-53 Korean War 1955 Warsaw Pact; Bandung Conference 1961 Berlin Wall built 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis 1979 Soviet invasion of Afghanistan 1991 Soviet Union dissolves
Figure 8.1. Major events of the Cold War. The superpowers never fought each other directly, but they backed opposing sides in many other conflicts.

Korea (1950 to 1953)

After World War II, Korea was divided at the 38th parallel, with a communist government in the north under Kim Il Sung and an anti-communist one in the south. In June 1950, North Korea invaded the South. The UN Security Council, which the Soviet Union was boycotting, authorized a response, and US-led forces, with troops from fifteen other nations, drove the North Koreans back. In October, China entered the war on the North's side. The fighting stalled near the original line, and an armistice in 1953 left Korea divided. The war cost millions of lives, and it led the US to build up its military and alliances.

Vietnam (1955 to 1975)

Vietnam had been a French colony. After Ho Chi Minh's communist-led Viet Minh defeated France at Dien Bien Phu in 1954 (Lesson 8.4b), the Geneva Accords divided the country into a communist North and a non-communist South. The US supported South Vietnam, fearing that if it fell, neighboring states would follow (the "domino theory"). Troop numbers grew after 1964 to more than half a million. The communist forces in the South (the Viet Cong) and North Vietnam, supported by China and the Soviet Union, fought a guerrilla war the US could not win. American forces withdrew in 1973, and the North conquered the South in 1975. About two to three million Vietnamese and nearly 58,000 Americans died.

Angola (1975 to 2002)

When Portugal withdrew from Angola in 1975 (Lesson 8.5b), three movements fought for power. The Soviet Union and Cuba supported the leftist MPLA, with thousands of Cuban troops, while the US and apartheid South Africa supported rival groups, FNLA and UNITA. The Angolan Civil War lasted until 2002, with great loss of life, and showed how the conflict spread to Africa.

Afghanistan (1979 to 1989)

The Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan in December 1979 to support a communist government. The US, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and others supplied weapons to the Muslim guerrillas, the mujahideen. The war was costly for the Soviets, who withdrew in 1989, and it contributed to the collapse of the USSR (Lesson 8.8). It also left a country in chaos from which later extremist groups emerged.

Nicaragua (1979 to 1990)

In 1979 the Sandinistas, a leftist movement, overthrew the Nicaraguan dictator Somoza. The US, under President Reagan, supported the Contras, rebels who fought the Sandinistas, partly with secret funds, which led to the Iran-Contra scandal. The war killed thousands, and ended with elections in 1990 in which the Sandinistas lost.

Making connections

The skill asks you to connect developments. Proxy wars connect decolonization (new states were weak and divided and became arenas), Cold War ideology (each superpower feared losing allies), and nuclear deterrence (rivalry was shifted to smaller wars). They also connected to economic factors, as states sought markets, resources, and bases. And they show a pattern in which local conflicts gained global importance and lasted longer because of outside support.

Primary source · Authorizing force in Vietnam

Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, joint resolution of the United States Congress, August 7, 1964 (a US federal public record).

The Congress approves and supports the determination of the President, as Commander in Chief, to take all necessary measures to repel any armed attack against the forces of the United States and to prevent further aggression.

Sourcing (HIPP). The resolution was passed by Congress at the request of President Lyndon Johnson after reports of attacks on US ships, so the point of view is that of the American government, which wanted a free hand. Its purpose was to give the President wide authority to respond in Vietnam, and the audience was the American public and North Vietnam. Later evidence showed that one of the reported attacks probably did not happen, so the document shows how the escalation was justified and not necessarily what had occurred.

Source analysis · Authority for escalation

Claim. The US Congress gave the President broad power to expand the war in Vietnam.

Evidence. The resolution approved "all necessary measures" to repel armed attack and prevent further aggression.

Reasoning. The phrase "all necessary measures" had no specific limit, which allowed the President to send large forces without a declaration of war. A limit is that the resolution was passed on the basis of reports that were later questioned, so it reflects the government's justification and not a full account of events.

Worked example · Making connections

Question. Explain one way the Korean War connected to the Cold War.

Model. The war began when communist North Korea invaded the South, and the US-led UN force and later China intervened, so the conflict became a contest between the two blocs. It led the US to build up its military and alliances, which shows how the ideological struggle turned into military conflict in a divided postcolonial state.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8C continues. Know the CED's three proxy wars (Korea, Angola, Nicaragua) and also Vietnam and Afghanistan. For each, name the sides and their backers and the outcome. Show connections to decolonization, ideology, and nuclear deterrence.

Practice
  1. What is a proxy war?
    Show answer

    A conflict in which two powers support opposing sides in a third country with weapons, money, advisers, or troops, instead of fighting each other directly.

  2. What happened in the Korean War?
    Show answer

    North Korea invaded the South in 1950, a US-led UN force and later China intervened, and an armistice in 1953 left Korea divided.

  3. Who fought in the Angolan Civil War?
    Show answer

    The MPLA, supported by the Soviet Union and Cuba, fought rivals backed by the US and apartheid South Africa.

  4. Why did the US support South Vietnam?
    Show answer

    It feared that if South Vietnam fell to communism, neighboring states would follow, a view called the domino theory.

  5. What was the Sandinista-Contras conflict?
    Show answer

    A war in Nicaragua in the 1980s in which the US supported the Contras against the leftist Sandinista government.

  6. Why is the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution limited as evidence of what happened?
    Show answer

    It was passed on reports of attacks that were later questioned, so it shows how the government justified escalation and not necessarily what occurred.

Lesson 8.5 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.4

China's turn to communism

The CED asks for the causes and consequences of China's adoption of communism. It says that as a result of internal tension and Japanese aggression, Chinese communists seized power, and that in communist China, the government controlled the national economy through the Great Leap Forward, often implementing repressive policies, with negative repercussions for the population. This lesson covers how the Communist Party came to power and what it did.

Required content · 8D, 8E

Learning objectives.

  • 8D. Explain the causes and consequences of China’s adoption of communism.
  • 8E. Explain the causes and effects of movements to redistribute economic resources.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.I.i. As a result of internal tension and Japanese aggression, Chinese communists seized power. These changes in China eventually led to communist revolution.
  • 6.3.I.A.ii. In communist China, the government controlled the national economy through the Great Leap Forward, often implementing repressive policies, with negative repercussions for the population.

The background: a divided China

After the fall of the Qing in 1911 (Lesson 7.1), China was divided among warlords. In the 1920s, the Nationalist Party (Guomindang), led by Sun Yat-sen and, after his death in 1925, by Chiang Kai-shek, reunified much of the country. The Chinese Communist Party (founded in 1921) first cooperated with the Nationalists, then was attacked by them in 1927. Many communists were killed, and the Party's leaders retreated to the countryside.

Internal tension and the rural base

Mao Zedong, a Party leader, argued that China's revolution should rely on peasants, not the urban workers on whom Marxist theory had focused. China was overwhelmingly rural, and many peasants suffered from landlord exploitation, high rents, debt, and famine. The Communists built bases in the countryside, taking land from landlords and distributing it to peasants, which won support. In 1934 to 1935, pursued by Nationalist armies, they made the Long March, a retreat of thousands of miles to the northwest, in which most of the marchers died but the survivors, led now by Mao, reached safety.

Japanese aggression

Japan's invasion of Manchuria (1931) and of China proper (1937) changed the situation (Lesson 7.5). The Nationalists were forced to retreat, lost their richest regions, and were weakened by corruption and inflation. The Communists, who fought as guerrillas behind Japanese lines and showed that they were willing to fight, gained prestige as defenders of the nation. The CED summarizes this: internal tension and Japanese aggression.

Civil war and victory

After Japan's defeat in 1945, the civil war resumed. The Nationalists had more men and weapons, but they were demoralized and widely disliked for corruption and inflation, while the Communists enjoyed peasant support and strong discipline. By 1949, the Communists had won the mainland. On October 1, 1949, Mao proclaimed the People's Republic of China (PRC). Chiang Kai-shek and the Nationalists fled to Taiwan. In 1950, China signed an alliance with the Soviet Union and entered the Korean War (Lesson 8.3b).

The Communist state and the Great Leap Forward

The new government carried out land reform, redistributing land from landlords (many of whom were killed), and took control of industry and banking. It promoted literacy and women's rights, including a new marriage law in 1950.

In 1958, Mao launched the Great Leap Forward, a campaign to transform the economy rapidly. Farms were merged into huge people's communes, and peasants were ordered to make steel in backyard furnaces. The CED says that this was a case where the government controlled the national economy, often implementing repressive policies, with negative repercussions for the population. Unrealistic targets led local officials to report inflated harvests, so the state took too much grain, and the combination of bad policy and poor weather caused a famine from 1959 to 1961. Estimates of deaths range from about 15 million to over 40 million, among the deadliest famines in history. The program was abandoned in 1962.

In 1966, Mao launched the Cultural Revolution, a campaign against supposed "bourgeois" elements and old culture, in which young people called Red Guards attacked teachers, officials, and intellectuals, and the country sank into disorder until Mao's death in 1976. Afterward, leaders under Deng Xiaoping reformed the economy (Lesson 9.4).

Effects

Communist rule gave China a strong central government for the first time in decades, ended foreign control, reduced some inequalities, and improved public health and literacy. But its policies also caused enormous suffering, and its repression limited freedom.

Description of: Mao on the peasant movement

Description of Mao Zedong's "Report on an Investigation of the Peasant Movement in Hunan" (1927). This is a description, not a quotation.

Mao reported after a visit to rural Hunan that peasants were rising against landlords and local officials. He argued that this movement was powerful and should be supported, and that the Party should not hold it back, because it would sweep away old rural authority.

Sourcing (HIPP). Mao was a young Communist organizer writing a report for his Party, so his point of view is that of an advocate of the peasant movement. His purpose was to persuade Party leaders, who were mostly focused on cities, to make the peasants a central force, and his audience was the Party leadership. Because he was arguing for a strategy, he may have emphasized peasant strength and unity, but the report shows the origin of the idea that later shaped Chinese communism.

Source analysis · The peasant strategy

Claim. Mao argued that peasants could be the basis of revolution in China.

Evidence. He reported that peasants in Hunan were rising against landlords and that the Party should support, not restrain, the movement.

Reasoning. Placing peasants at the center departed from orthodox Marxism's focus on urban workers, and later success in rural base areas supports his judgment. A limit is that he was advocating a strategy within his Party, so he may have overstated peasant unity and strength.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one reason the Chinese Communists won the civil war.

Model. One reason was peasant support, won by land reform and by fighting the Japanese, while the Nationalists were weakened by corruption, inflation, and years of war. The Communists' discipline and rural base let them defeat the larger Nationalist army by 1949.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8D asks for causes and consequences of China's adoption of communism. List causes (peasant discontent, the Long March, Japanese invasion, Nationalist weakness) and consequences (the PRC, land reform, the Great Leap Forward famine, the Cultural Revolution). Be able to explain why the Great Leap Forward failed.

Practice
  1. What was the Long March?
    Show answer

    The Communists' 1934 to 1935 retreat of thousands of miles from Nationalist armies to the northwest, after which Mao emerged as leader.

  2. Why did Japan's invasion help the Communists?
    Show answer

    It weakened the Nationalists and let the Communists gain prestige as guerrilla fighters defending the nation.

  3. When was the People's Republic of China founded and by whom?
    Show answer

    On October 1, 1949, by Mao Zedong after the Communists won the civil war.

  4. What was the Great Leap Forward?
    Show answer

    Mao's 1958 campaign to transform the economy through people's communes and backyard steel, which caused a famine killing many millions.

  5. Why did the Great Leap Forward cause famine?
    Show answer

    Unrealistic targets led officials to report false harvests, so the state took too much grain, and bad policy combined with poor weather.

  6. Why is Mao's Hunan report limited as evidence?
    Show answer

    It was written to persuade Party leaders and may overstate peasant strength and unity, though it shows the origin of his strategy.

Lesson 8.6 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.4

Movements to redistribute land and wealth

The CED asks about the causes and effects of movements to redistribute economic resources. It states that movements to redistribute land and resources developed within states in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, sometimes advocating communism or socialism. This lesson covers four examples the CED names: the communist revolution for Vietnamese independence, Mengistu Haile Mariam in Ethiopia, land reform in Kerala and other Indian states, and the White Revolution in Iran.

Required content · 8D, 8E

Learning objectives.

  • 8D. Explain the causes and consequences of China’s adoption of communism.
  • 8E. Explain the causes and effects of movements to redistribute economic resources.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.II.D.i. Movements to redistribute land and resources developed within states in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, sometimes advocating communism or socialism.

Why redistribution?

Many societies in Asia, Africa, and Latin America in the 1900s were deeply unequal. A few landlords held most of the farmland, and many peasants worked as tenants or laborers with little security. Colonial rule had often strengthened landlords and export agriculture. After independence, leaders and movements argued that poverty and weakness could not be overcome unless land and wealth were shared more equally. Some turned to socialism or communism, and others to reform within capitalism. The Cold War made these choices part of a global rivalry.

Vietnam

Under French rule, Vietnam had large landholdings and a heavy tax burden on peasants. Ho Chi Minh, a nationalist who had become a communist while living in France, founded the Viet Minh in 1941 to fight both Japanese occupiers and the French. In September 1945, he declared Vietnam's independence. France tried to reassert control, and the First Indochina War (1946 to 1954) followed. In 1954, the Viet Minh, with Chinese aid, defeated the French at Dien Bien Phu. The peace settlement divided the country, and the North under Ho carried out land reform, taking land from landlords (and executing many) and giving it to peasants. The CED calls this the communist revolution for Vietnamese independence, which combined nationalism with the promise of social change, and it continued into the war with the US (Lesson 8.3b).

Ethiopia

In 1974, Emperor Haile Selassie, who had ruled for decades, was overthrown by military officers who formed a council called the Derg. Mengistu Haile Mariam became its leader by 1977 and ruled as a Marxist dictator allied with the Soviet Union. In 1975 the government nationalized rural land, ending the old landlord system in which most peasants had paid rent to nobles and the church, and later it nationalized urban land and many businesses. Peasants gained use of land, but the state controlled it and forced resettlement and collectivization. The regime's "Red Terror" (1977 to 1978) killed tens of thousands of opponents, and a famine in the 1980s, worsened by war and government policy, killed hundreds of thousands. The Derg fell in 1991.

Kerala and other Indian states

In India, land reform came by democratic means. The state of Kerala elected a communist government in 1957, one of the first in the world to take office by free elections. It passed land reform laws, which were fully carried out only in 1969 to 1970. The laws limited the amount of land a person could own and gave tenants ownership of their plots. Along with investment in schools and health, this helped Kerala achieve high literacy and long life expectancy. Other Indian states also passed land-ceiling laws, though enforcement was uneven, and the national government's approach mixed state planning with private enterprise.

The White Revolution in Iran

In Iran, Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi launched the White Revolution in 1963, a program of top-down reform. It included land reform, which redistributed land from large owners to peasants, the sale of state factories, the right of women to vote, and a literacy campaign. The shah hoped to modernize the country and to gain support among peasants and prevent revolution. But the reforms created problems. Many peasants received plots too small to farm, landlords and religious leaders were angry, and the government was authoritarian, with a secret police. The opposition included religious leader Ayatollah Khomeini, who was exiled in 1964. In 1979 the Iranian Revolution overthrew the shah.

Comparing the cases

CaseMethodOutcome
VietnamCommunist revolution and warLand reform in the North, a long war, unified communist state in 1975
EthiopiaMilitary Marxist coupLand nationalized, terror and famine, regime fell in 1991
KeralaElected government and lawLand reform and social gains within a democracy
IranReform by the monarchyMixed results and a revolution in 1979

The cases show that redistribution could come by revolution, coup, election, or royal decree, with very different human costs.

Description of: the 1975 Ethiopian land proclamation

Description of the Public Ownership of Rural Lands Proclamation issued by the Derg in March 1975. This is a description, not a quotation.

The proclamation declared that all rural land was the collective property of the Ethiopian people. It ended private ownership and tenancy, and gave farmers the right to use plots of limited size, which could not be sold or rented.

Sourcing (HIPP). The decree was issued by a military regime, so the point of view is that of a government that claimed to act for the peasants. Its purpose was to break the power of the old landowning class and to build support among the rural poor, and the audience was Ethiopian farmers and landlords. Because it states the law and not its results, the proclamation shows the regime's aims. Later evidence shows that peasants lost freedom to the state even as they gained use of land.

Source analysis · A law and its effects

Claim. The Derg's land proclamation broke the old landlord system.

Evidence. The decree made all rural land the property of the people, ended tenancy, and gave farmers use rights to plots.

Reasoning. Abolishing tenancy and private ownership removed the landlords' basis of power, which fits the regime's aim of redistribution. A limit is that the decree states the law and not its results, since the state, not the peasants, controlled the land afterward and the regime used force to resettle people.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between land reform in Ethiopia and in Kerala.

Model. Both sought to end the power of landlords and give farmers access to land. The difference is that in Ethiopia a military regime imposed nationalization by decree and used terror, while in Kerala an elected government passed land laws within a democracy, which allowed gradual change with fewer deaths.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8E asks for the causes and effects of redistribution movements. Know the four CED examples (Vietnam, Ethiopia, Kerala and India, Iran) and compare methods (revolution, coup, election, royal reform). Explain why landholding inequality drove them.

Practice
  1. Why did land redistribution movements arise?
    Show answer

    Land and wealth were highly unequal, often strengthened by colonial rule, and leaders argued poverty could not be overcome without sharing them more fairly.

  2. What was the Viet Minh?
    Show answer

    The communist-led nationalist movement founded by Ho Chi Minh in 1941 that fought the Japanese and French.

  3. What did the Derg do in Ethiopia in 1975?
    Show answer

    It nationalized rural land and ended private ownership and tenancy.

  4. How did Kerala carry out land reform?
    Show answer

    An elected communist government passed land ceiling and tenant laws, with full enforcement in 1969 to 1970.

  5. What was the White Revolution?
    Show answer

    The shah of Iran's 1963 reform program, which included land reform and women's suffrage, but led to opposition and the 1979 revolution.

  6. Why is a decree limited as evidence of results?
    Show answer

    It states the law and the regime's aims, not what actually happened when it was carried out.

Lesson 8.7 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.5

Decolonization: nationalist leaders and independence

Between 1945 and the 1970s, most of the world's colonies became independent. The CED asks you to compare the processes by which various peoples pursued independence after 1900. It states that nationalist leaders and parties in Asia and Africa sought varying degrees of autonomy within or independence from imperial rule, and that after the end of World War II, some colonies negotiated their independence, while others achieved independence through armed struggle. This lesson covers the nationalist leaders and the negotiated cases. The next covers armed struggle and the regional movements.

1947 India and Pakistan independent 1948 Israel founded 1949 Indonesia independent 1954 Dien Bien Phu; Algerian war begins 1957 Ghana independent 1960 Year of Africa: 17 states independent 1962 Algeria independent 1975 Angola and Mozambique independent
Figure 8.2. Independence came in waves. Some states negotiated it and others won it through war, and the pace was fastest around 1960.
Required content · 8F

Learning objective.

  • 8F. Compare the processes by which various peoples pursued independence after 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.II.A. Nationalist leaders and parties in Asia and Africa sought varying degrees of autonomy within or independence from imperial rule.
  • 6.2.I.C. After the end of World War II, some colonies negotiated their independence, while others achieved independence through armed struggle.

Why decolonization happened

Several causes combined. Nationalism grew among educated colonial subjects and the masses. The world wars weakened Britain, France, and the Netherlands and showed that colonial powers could be beaten. Colonial soldiers who had fought for the empire expected rights. The United States and the Soviet Union, for different reasons, opposed old-style empires, and the UN supported self-determination. And the costs of holding empires, especially against resistance, rose.

Nationalist leaders and parties

The CED lists several.

  • Indian National Congress. Founded in 1885, the Congress, with leaders such as Mohandas Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru, led the independence movement through nonviolent mass campaigns (Lesson 7.5). Its goals were self-rule for a united India.
  • Ho Chi Minh in French Indochina. A communist nationalist who founded the Viet Minh (Lesson 8.4b).
  • Kwame Nkrumah in the British Gold Coast (Ghana). An American-educated leader who founded the Convention People's Party in 1949 and used strikes and boycotts, and was jailed.
  • Gamal Abdel Nasser in Egypt. An army officer who led a coup in 1952, took power, and in 1956 nationalized the Suez Canal, defying Britain and France.

These leaders differed in methods and ideology. Some were socialist or communist, others liberal or religious, and some sought autonomy within an empire first, while others demanded full independence.

Negotiated independence

The CED lists three examples of negotiated independence.

  • India from the British Empire. After decades of struggle and the exhaustion of Britain after World War II, the British government agreed to leave. India and Pakistan became independent on August 14 to 15, 1947 (Lesson 8.6). On the eve of independence, Nehru spoke of India's "tryst with destiny."
  • The Gold Coast from the British Empire. After Nkrumah's party won elections in 1951 and 1954, Britain gradually handed over power, and in March 1957 the Gold Coast became Ghana, the first sub-Saharan colony to gain independence. It encouraged others.
  • French West Africa. In 1958, France offered its African colonies a choice in a referendum between a new French community and immediate independence. Only Guinea chose independence, under Ahmed Sekou Toure. In 1960, France granted independence to most of its other African colonies, including Senegal, Mali, and Ivory Coast, often with continued French ties in finance, trade, and defense.

In 1960, seventeen African states became independent, which is called the "Year of Africa." Britain also released colonies such as Nigeria (1960), Tanganyika (1961), and Kenya (1963), though Kenya's came after the violent Mau Mau rebellion.

Why negotiation?

Negotiation was more likely where a strong, organized nationalist movement existed, where the colonial power had fewer settlers with interests to protect, and where the cost of repression seemed too high. Negotiated independence was not always smooth. Britain and France often tried to ensure friendly governments and continued economic ties.

Primary source · Independence at midnight

Jawaharlal Nehru, speech to the Constituent Assembly of India, August 14, 1947 (a famous public speech).

At the stroke of the midnight hour, when the world sleeps, India will awake to life and freedom.

Sourcing (HIPP). Nehru was the first prime minister of independent India and a leader of the Congress, so his point of view is that of a nationalist who had been jailed by the British. The purpose of the speech was to mark the moment, express hope, and call on Indians to dedicate themselves to the nation, and the audience was the Constituent Assembly and the Indian people listening by radio. The same day was marked by the partition of the subcontinent and widespread violence, so the speech captures a moment of hope but not the full human cost of independence.

Source analysis · The language of freedom

Claim. Nationalist leaders presented independence as a new beginning for their peoples.

Evidence. Nehru said that at midnight India would "awake to life and freedom."

Reasoning. The imagery of waking from sleep frames independence as a rebirth, which fits the hopes of a nationalist movement after years of struggle. A limit is that the speech was made on the eve of partition, which caused mass killing and displacement, so it expresses hope and not the whole reality.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the independence of India and of Ghana.

Model. Both were British colonies that gained independence by negotiation after nationalist parties built mass movements, the Indian National Congress and Nkrumah's Convention People's Party. The difference is that India's independence came with partition into India and Pakistan and violence, while Ghana's was a peaceful transfer and became the first sub-Saharan African colony to gain independence.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8F is a comparison objective. Know the nationalist leaders and parties (Indian National Congress, Ho Chi Minh, Nkrumah, Nasser) and the negotiated cases (India, the Gold Coast, French West Africa). Say why negotiation happened, and compare with the armed struggles in the next lesson.

Practice
  1. Why did decolonization accelerate after World War II?
    Show answer

    Nationalism grew, the war weakened the European powers, the US and USSR opposed old empires, and the costs of holding colonies rose.

  2. Who was Kwame Nkrumah?
    Show answer

    The nationalist leader who led the Gold Coast to independence as Ghana in 1957, the first sub-Saharan colony to become independent.

  3. What did Nasser do in 1956?
    Show answer

    He nationalized the Suez Canal, defying Britain and France.

  4. How did French West Africa gain independence?
    Show answer

    France offered a referendum in 1958; Guinea chose independence at once, and most other colonies became independent in 1960, often keeping ties to France.

  5. What was the "Year of Africa"?
    Show answer

    1960, when seventeen African states became independent.

  6. Why does Nehru's speech not tell the whole story of 1947?
    Show answer

    It expresses hope, but independence came with partition and widespread violence and displacement.

Lesson 8.8 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.5

Decolonization: armed struggle and separatist movements

Not every colonial power left peacefully. The CED says that some colonies achieved independence through armed struggle, and that regional, religious, and ethnic movements challenged colonial rule and inherited imperial boundaries. Some of these movements advocated for autonomy. This lesson covers the wars of independence, and the movements within colonies and new states that sought separate paths.

Required content · 8F

Learning objective.

  • 8F. Compare the processes by which various peoples pursued independence after 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.I.C. After the end of World War II, some colonies negotiated their independence, while others achieved independence through armed struggle.
  • 6.2.II.B. Regional, religious, and ethnic movements challenged colonial rule and inherited imperial boundaries. Some of these movements advocated for autonomy.

Independence through armed struggle

The CED lists three examples.

  • Algeria from the French empire. Algeria had been conquered in 1830, and about a million European settlers lived there, who controlled the best land and held privileges, while the Muslim majority had few rights. In November 1954, the National Liberation Front (FLN) began an uprising. The Algerian War (1954 to 1962) was marked by guerrilla war and terrorism by the FLN, and by French torture and mass repression. Perhaps several hundred thousand Algerians died, and about two million were forced into camps or resettled. The war toppled France's Fourth Republic in 1958, and under President Charles de Gaulle, France agreed to independence in 1962. Most settlers left for France.
  • Angola from the Portuguese empire. Portugal, under a dictatorship, refused to give up its African colonies. Independence movements began fighting in Angola in 1961, and later in Mozambique and Guinea-Bissau. The long wars helped cause a military coup in Portugal in 1974, and the new government granted independence to its colonies in 1975. Angola then fell into a civil war (Lesson 8.3b).
  • Vietnam from the French empire. The Viet Minh's war defeated France at Dien Bien Phu in 1954 (Lesson 8.4b), and the country was divided, which led to a second war with the United States.

Other violent struggles included the Mau Mau rebellion in Kenya (1952 to 1960), in which British forces held many Kikuyu in detention camps, and the Indonesian war of independence from the Netherlands (1945 to 1949).

Why armed struggle?

Violence was more likely where there were large settler populations (Algeria, Kenya, Southern Rhodesia) who defended their privileges, where colonial powers saw the colony as essential to national prestige or economy (France in Algeria, Portugal in Africa), and where nationalists saw no way to negotiate. In many cases the wars also had Cold War links, since the Soviet Union and others helped guerrilla movements.

Regional, religious, and ethnic movements

The CED also notes that regional, religious, and ethnic movements challenged colonial rule and inherited imperial boundaries. In many colonies, borders had been drawn by Europeans, so they enclosed many peoples. When colonies became independent, groups within them sometimes sought autonomy or separation. The CED's examples:

  • The Muslim League in British India. Led by Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the Muslim League argued that Muslims were a separate nation and demanded a separate state. This movement led to the creation of Pakistan in 1947 (Lesson 8.6).
  • The Quebecois separatist movement in Canada. French-speaking Quebec developed a nationalist movement, especially from the 1960s, that sought greater autonomy or independence for the province, and two referendums on sovereignty, in 1980 and 1995, were narrowly defeated. This shows that such movements occurred in wealthy democracies as well.
  • The Biafra secessionist movement in Nigeria. In 1967, the eastern region of Nigeria, home mainly to the Igbo people, declared independence as Biafra after violence against Igbo in other regions. A war followed, with the Nigerian government blockading the region, and when Biafra surrendered in 1970, as many as one to two million people had died, many from starvation. The war shows how colonial borders and ethnic rivalries could threaten new states.

Comparing the paths

PathExamplesKey features
Negotiated independenceIndia, Gold Coast, French West AfricaStrong nationalist party, fewer settlers, lower cost of ending rule
Armed struggleAlgeria, Angola, VietnamSettlers or imperial prestige, guerrilla war, high casualties
Separatist movementsMuslim League, Quebec, BiafraRegional, religious, or ethnic identity against a larger state
Description of: the FLN's proclamation

Description of the proclamation issued by the National Liberation Front of Algeria on November 1, 1954, at the start of the uprising. This is a description, not a quotation.

The proclamation announced the creation of the FLN and called on Algerians to fight for national independence, the restoration of a sovereign Algerian state within the principles of Islam, and respect for all fundamental freedoms. It addressed French authorities and the Algerian people.

Sourcing (HIPP). The text was written by the leaders of a revolutionary movement, so the point of view is that of Algerian nationalists who had decided on armed struggle. Its purpose was to announce the start of the war, to unite Algerians behind one front, and to win international support, and its audience was the Algerian people, the French government, and foreign opinion. Because it is a political declaration, it shows the movement's stated aims and not the ways in which the war was fought.

Source analysis · A declaration of war

Claim. The FLN presented the war as a struggle for national independence.

Evidence. The proclamation called for independence and a sovereign Algerian state within the principles of Islam, and for respect for fundamental freedoms.

Reasoning. Linking independence to Islamic principles and to freedoms was meant to unite Algerians and to gain foreign sympathy, which shows the movement's nationalist and religious appeal. A limit is that it states aims as the movement wished them to be seen and does not show how the war was fought.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the independence of Algeria and Ghana.

Model. Both ended European colonial rule and were led by nationalist movements. The difference is that Ghana gained independence in 1957 through negotiation after strikes and elections, while Algeria's came only in 1962 after a long, violent war, because France saw Algeria as part of France and had a large settler population.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8F continues with the armed cases (Algeria, Angola, Vietnam) and regional, religious, and ethnic movements (Muslim League, Quebec, Biafra). Compare paths and explain why violence or separatism arose: settlers, imperial prestige, colonial borders, ethnic and religious identity.

Practice
  1. Why was decolonization violent in Algeria?
    Show answer

    France saw Algeria as part of France, and a large settler population defended its privileges, so the FLN fought a long guerrilla war from 1954 to 1962.

  2. What ended Portuguese colonial rule in Africa?
    Show answer

    Long independence wars helped cause a military coup in Portugal in 1974, and the new government granted independence in 1975.

  3. What was the Muslim League's goal?
    Show answer

    A separate state for Muslims in British India, which led to the creation of Pakistan.

  4. What happened in Biafra?
    Show answer

    The Igbo-dominated eastern region of Nigeria declared independence in 1967, and a civil war ended with its defeat in 1970 after as many as one to two million deaths.

  5. Why did colonial borders cause problems?
    Show answer

    Europeans drew them without regard to peoples, so new states often enclosed groups with rival identities, some of whom sought autonomy or separation.

  6. Why is a proclamation limited as evidence of how a war was fought?
    Show answer

    It states the movement's aims for its audience, not the methods or conduct of the war.

Lesson 8.9 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.6

Newly independent states

Independence created dozens of new states, with new borders, populations on the move, and economies to build. The CED asks how political changes led to territorial, demographic, and nationalist developments and about the economic changes and continuities resulting from decolonization. This lesson covers redrawn borders and their consequences, state-led economic policies, and the migration of former colonial subjects to the former imperial centers.

Required content · 8G, 8H

Learning objectives.

  • 8G. Explain how political changes in the period from c. 1900 to the present led to territorial, demographic, and nationalist developments.
  • 8H. Explain the economic changes and continuities resulting from the process of decolonization.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.III.A.i. The redrawing of political boundaries after the withdrawal of former colonial authorities led to the creation of new states.
  • 6.2.III.A.ii. The redrawing of political boundaries in some cases led to conflict as well as population displacement and/or resettlements, including those related to the Partition of India and the creation of the state of Israel.
  • 6.3.I.C. In newly independent states after World War II, governments often took on a strong role in guiding economic life to promote development.
  • 6.2.III.B. The migration of former colonial subjects to imperial metropoles (the former colonizing country), usually in the major cities, maintained cultural and economic ties between the colony and the metropole even after the dissolution of empires.

Redrawn borders and new states

The CED says that the redrawing of political boundaries after the withdrawal of former colonial authorities led to the creation of new states and that in some cases it led to conflict as well as population displacement and/or resettlements, including those related to the Partition of India and the creation of the state of Israel. Its examples of new states are Israel, Cambodia, and Pakistan.

  • The Partition of India. In 1947, Britain divided British India into two states, Hindu-majority India and Muslim-majority Pakistan, which had two parts, West and East, separated by India. Boundary lines drawn in haste by a British lawyer, Cyril Radcliffe, split the provinces of Punjab and Bengal. Fear and violence followed. About fifteen million people moved across the new borders, Hindus and Sikhs to India and Muslims to Pakistan, in one of the largest migrations in history, and perhaps one to two million people were killed. The two states fought wars over the region of Kashmir. In 1971, East Pakistan broke away with Indian help to form Bangladesh.
  • Israel and Palestine. Britain held the mandate for Palestine (Lesson 7.5). After the Holocaust, pressure grew for a Jewish state, and in 1947 the UN proposed dividing Palestine into Jewish and Arab states. Arab leaders rejected the plan, and Israel declared independence in May 1948. Neighboring Arab states invaded, and Israel won the war. About 700,000 Palestinians fled or were expelled from their homes, which Palestinians call the Nakba ("catastrophe"), and many became refugees in neighboring countries. Hundreds of thousands of Jews also left or were expelled from Arab countries in the following years, many moving to Israel. The conflict continued in wars in 1956, 1967, and 1973.
  • Cambodia. Cambodia gained independence from France in 1953, under King Norodom Sihanouk, and it became involved in the conflicts of Vietnam and later experienced the tragedy of the Khmer Rouge (Lesson 7.8).
  • Africa. Colonial borders, drawn by Europeans at the Berlin Conference and later, were mostly kept after independence, since the Organization of African Unity (1963) agreed to respect them to avoid endless disputes. Yet the borders joined peoples who had little in common and divided others, which fed conflict in places such as Nigeria and the Congo.

State-led economic development

The CED states that in newly independent states after World War II, governments often took on a strong role in guiding economic life to promote development. Leaders wanted to end poverty and economic dependence, and many believed that private capital alone would not industrialize their countries fast enough. They used:

  • Five-year plans and state industries. India's planned economy, begun under Nehru in 1951, combined state-owned heavy industry and protected markets with some private enterprise. Egypt, under Nasser, nationalized the Suez Canal in 1956 and many industries and built the Aswan High Dam with Soviet help.
  • Land reform and import substitution, making goods at home instead of importing them, and building dams, roads, and schools.
  • Socialist policies, as in Tanzania under Julius Nyerere (the ujamaa village program).

Results varied. Some countries raised literacy and health, and India achieved the Green Revolution's wheat gains (Lesson 9.1b). But many remained dependent on exporting a few raw materials, faced debt, and found that state-run industries were inefficient. Continuities with the colonial economy included reliance on cash-crop and mineral exports and foreign investment.

Migration to the imperial centers

The CED adds that the migration of former colonial subjects to imperial metropoles, usually in the major cities, maintained cultural and economic ties between the colony and the metropole even after the dissolution of empires. After the war, many people from former colonies moved to Britain, France, the Netherlands, and Portugal to find work or to escape conflict. Examples include Caribbeans and South Asians in Britain (the Empire Windrush arrived in 1948 with Caribbean passengers), Algerians in France, and Indonesians in the Netherlands. These communities sent money home, kept ties of language and culture, and changed the societies that received them, and sometimes met discrimination.

Description of: the Radcliffe boundary

Description of the work of the Boundary Commission chaired by Sir Cyril Radcliffe, which drew the borders between India and Pakistan in 1947. This is a description, not a quotation.

Radcliffe, a British lawyer who had never been to India, had about five weeks to draw lines through Punjab and Bengal, using census data on religion and information on railways, canals, and property. The boundary was announced on August 17, 1947, two days after independence, and left many people on the wrong side of the border.

Sourcing (HIPP). Radcliffe was an outsider chosen to appear impartial, so the point of view is that of the departing British government. Its purpose was to settle the border quickly so that Britain could leave on schedule, and the audience was the Indian and Pakistani leaders and populations. Because the work was rushed and the borders were announced after independence, the commission's decision is evidence of the haste of British withdrawal, and of how colonial decisions had lasting human costs.

Source analysis · A rushed boundary

Claim. The haste of British withdrawal contributed to the violence of Partition.

Evidence. Radcliffe, who had never been to India, had about five weeks to draw the lines, and the boundary was announced after independence.

Reasoning. A boundary drawn in a few weeks by an outsider and announced late left people uncertain about which country they were in, which increased fear and flight. A limit is that Partition violence also had deep local causes, including communal tension, so haste was one factor among several.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change and one continuity in economies after decolonization.

Model. One change was that governments took a strong role in guiding the economy, as in India's five-year plans and Egypt's nationalization of the Suez Canal, to promote development and reduce dependence on foreign control. One continuity was that many states still relied on exporting a few raw materials, as under colonial rule, and so remained vulnerable to price changes.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives 8G and 8H ask about territorial, demographic, and nationalist developments and economic changes and continuities. Use Partition, Israel and Palestine, and Africa's inherited borders; state-led development (India, Egypt, Tanzania); and migration to the metropoles. Always name a continuity as well as a change.

Practice
  1. What was the Partition of India?
    Show answer

    The 1947 division of British India into India and Pakistan, which caused about fifteen million people to move and one to two million deaths.

  2. What happened to Palestinians in 1948?
    Show answer

    About 700,000 fled or were expelled during the war that followed Israel's declaration of independence, which Palestinians call the Nakba.

  3. Why did African states keep colonial borders?
    Show answer

    The Organization of African Unity agreed to respect them to avoid endless disputes, though they often joined or split peoples.

  4. Name one state-led development policy.
    Show answer

    India's five-year plans, Egypt's nationalizations, or Tanzania's ujamaa villages.

  5. Why did migrants move from colonies to the former imperial centers?
    Show answer

    To find work or escape conflict, using existing ties of language and culture, which kept cultural and economic links alive.

  6. Why is the Radcliffe boundary useful evidence about British withdrawal?
    Show answer

    It shows the haste with which Britain left and how colonial decisions had lasting human costs.

Lesson 8.10 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.7

Resistance to power structures, violent and nonviolent

Individuals and groups in the twentieth century resisted existing power in many ways. The CED asks about various reactions to existing power structures in the period after 1900 and states that, although conflict dominated much of the twentieth century, many individuals and groups, including states, opposed this trend. Some individuals and groups, however, intensified the conflicts. This lesson covers nonviolent resistance, militarized responses, and violence against civilians.

Required content · 8I

Learning objective.

  • 8I. Explain various reactions to existing power structures in the period after 1900.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.V. Although conflict dominated much of the 20th century, many individuals and groups, including states, opposed this trend. Some individuals and groups, however, intensified the conflicts.
  • 6.2.V.A. Groups and individuals challenged the many wars of the century, and some, such as Mohandas Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., and Nelson Mandela, promoted the practice of nonviolence as a way to bring about political change.
  • 6.2.V.C. Militaries and militarized states often responded to the proliferation of conflicts in ways that further intensified conflict.
  • 6.2.V.D. Some movements used violence against civilians in an effort to achieve political aims.

Nonviolence

The CED says that groups and individuals challenged the many wars of the century, and some, such as Mohandas Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., and Nelson Mandela, promoted the practice of nonviolence as a way to bring about political change.

  • Gandhi. Gandhi developed satyagraha ("holding to truth"), a method of resisting injustice with nonviolent noncooperation, such as boycotts, strikes, and civil disobedience. He first used it in South Africa against discrimination against Indians, and in India he led campaigns such as the Salt March of 1930 (Lesson 7.5) against British rule. He was assassinated in 1948 by a Hindu nationalist.
  • Martin Luther King Jr. Inspired by Gandhi and by Christian teaching, King led the American civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, including the Montgomery bus boycott (1955 to 1956) and the March on Washington (1963). His "Letter from Birmingham Jail" argued that "injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Voting Rights Act of 1965 followed. King was assassinated in 1968.
  • Nelson Mandela. In South Africa, the National Party government from 1948 enforced apartheid, a system of legal racial segregation that denied rights to the Black majority. Mandela, a leader of the African National Congress (ANC), first led nonviolent protests, but after the Sharpeville massacre of 1960, in which police killed dozens of protesters, the ANC turned partly to armed resistance. Mandela was jailed for 27 years, beginning in 1962. International sanctions and internal resistance pressured the government, which freed him in 1990, and he led negotiations to end apartheid. In 1994 he became South Africa's first Black president, and he promoted reconciliation.

Other movements, such as the anti-colonial movements and peace movements against nuclear weapons and the Vietnam War, also used nonviolent protest.

Militarized responses that intensified conflict

The CED also says that militaries and militarized states responded to the proliferation of conflicts in ways that further intensified conflict. Its examples:

  • Chile under Augusto Pinochet. In 1973, the Chilean military, led by Pinochet, overthrew the elected socialist president Salvador Allende, with US encouragement, and ruled for seventeen years. The regime killed or "disappeared" thousands of opponents and tortured many more.
  • Spain under Francisco Franco. Franco won the Spanish Civil War (1936 to 1939) with German and Italian help and ruled as a dictator until 1975, repressing opponents and regional cultures.
  • Uganda under Idi Amin. Amin seized power in 1971, expelled the country's South Asian population in 1972, and ruled by terror, with perhaps 100,000 to 300,000 killed.
  • The buildup of the military-industrial complex and weapons trading. During the Cold War, governments spent heavily on arms, and arms industries and arms sales helped fuel conflicts around the world.

Violence against civilians by movements

The CED adds that some movements used violence against civilians in an effort to achieve political aims. Examples:

  • Shining Path, a Maoist guerrilla movement in Peru, which fought the government from the 1980s and killed many civilians, with the conflict costing about 70,000 lives.
  • Al-Qaeda, an Islamist extremist network led by Osama bin Laden, which attacked US embassies in Africa in 1998 and carried out the attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001, that killed nearly 3,000 people.

Such groups targeted civilians to spread terror, provoke governments, or force change, while states often responded with harsh measures. The result was often a cycle of violence.

Primary source · The military-industrial complex

Dwight D. Eisenhower, farewell address to the nation, January 17, 1961 (a US federal public record).

In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex.

Sourcing (HIPP). Eisenhower was a career army officer and the retiring president, so the point of view is that of a former general who had commanded Allied forces in World War II and who was concerned about the growing size of the arms industry. His purpose was to warn the nation that permanent large armaments industries could distort government and policy, and the audience was the American public. The warning came from an unusually credible source, since it was made by a military hero and a Cold War leader, and not from an opponent of defense spending.

Source analysis · A warning from within

Claim. Some leaders worried that the arms industry could intensify conflict and weaken democratic control.

Evidence. Eisenhower warned of the unwarranted influence of the military-industrial complex in the councils of government.

Reasoning. A president and former general who had presided over a huge arms buildup raised this concern, which makes the warning more credible than one from an opponent of defense. A limit is that a speech states a concern and does not prove how much influence arms industries had on specific decisions.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one similarity and one difference between the methods of Gandhi and Mandela.

Model. Both used mass resistance to challenge a government that denied rights to a majority, Gandhi against British rule in India and Mandela against apartheid in South Africa. The difference is that Gandhi held to nonviolence throughout, while Mandela, after Sharpeville and the banning of the ANC, accepted armed resistance as well, before later negotiating a peaceful end to apartheid.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8I asks about reactions to existing power structures. Know nonviolence (Gandhi, King, Mandela), militarized responses (Pinochet, Franco, Amin, the arms buildup), and violence against civilians (Shining Path, Al-Qaeda). Be ready to compare methods and results.

Practice
  1. What is satyagraha?
    Show answer

    Gandhi's method of nonviolent resistance through noncooperation, boycotts, and civil disobedience.

  2. What was apartheid?
    Show answer

    South Africa's system of legal racial segregation, in place from 1948, that denied rights to the Black majority.

  3. How did Martin Luther King Jr. resist injustice?
    Show answer

    Through nonviolent protest such as boycotts, marches, and civil disobedience, in the American civil rights movement.

  4. Name one military regime that intensified conflict.
    Show answer

    Chile under Pinochet, Spain under Franco, or Uganda under Idi Amin.

  5. Name one movement that used violence against civilians.
    Show answer

    Shining Path in Peru or Al-Qaeda.

  6. Why is Eisenhower's warning notable?
    Show answer

    It came from a former general and president, who was an unusually credible source, since he was not an opponent of defense.

Lesson 8.11 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.8

The end of the Cold War

The Cold War ended with the collapse of communist governments in Eastern Europe in 1989 and the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. The CED asks for the causes of the end of the Cold War and says that advances in U.S. military and technological development, the Soviet Union's costly and ultimately failed invasion of Afghanistan, and public discontent and economic weakness in communist countries led to the end of the Cold War and the collapse of the Soviet Union. This lesson explains each cause and the sequence of events.

Required content · 8J

Learning objective.

  • 8J. Explain the causes of the end of the Cold War.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.IV.E. Advances in U.S. military and technological development, the Soviet Union’s costly and ultimately failed invasion of Afghanistan, and public discontent and economic weakness in communist countries led to the end of the Cold War and the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Causes

  • Advances in US military and technological development. In the 1980s, the Reagan administration greatly increased defense spending and announced the Strategic Defense Initiative (1983), a proposed missile defense system nicknamed "Star Wars." Whether the system could work was doubtful, but Soviet leaders feared they could not match the cost or the technology. The US also supported anti-Soviet forces in Afghanistan, Poland, and elsewhere, and its computer and communications advances widened the gap.
  • The costly invasion of Afghanistan. The Soviet invasion of 1979 (Lesson 8.3b) led to a long war that Soviet forces could not win. It killed about fifteen thousand Soviet soldiers, wasted resources, hurt morale and the USSR's image abroad, and was a symbol of the system's weakness. The Soviet Union withdrew in 1989.
  • Economic weakness. The Soviet economy, planned from above, was inefficient, lagged in technology, and produced shortages of consumer goods, while spending a very large share on the military. Growth had stagnated by the 1980s. Other communist economies in Eastern Europe were also falling behind the West.
  • Public discontent. People in communist states resented political repression, economic hardship, and the lack of freedoms. Dissident movements, such as Solidarity, an independent labor union in Poland founded in 1980 by Lech Walesa, showed that organized opposition was possible. Radio and later television gave people news of Western life. The Catholic Church, especially Pope John Paul II, a Pole, supported Polish opposition.

Gorbachev's reforms

In 1985, Mikhail Gorbachev became leader of the Soviet Union. He wanted to save communism by reforming it. He introduced glasnost ("openness"), which allowed more free speech and criticism, and perestroika ("restructuring"), which tried to introduce some market elements into the economy. He also sought to reduce tensions with the West, meeting with Reagan and signing the INF Treaty (1987), which eliminated a class of nuclear missiles. In 1988 he announced that the Soviet Union would no longer use force to keep Eastern European governments in power, abandoning the Brezhnev Doctrine (Lesson 8.3a).

The revolutions of 1989

With Soviet intervention no longer expected, communist governments in Eastern Europe fell in a few months. In Poland, Solidarity won elections in June 1989. In Hungary, the government opened its border with Austria. In East Germany, mass protests led the government to open the Berlin Wall on November 9, 1989, and Germany reunified in 1990. Czechoslovakia's "Velvet Revolution" brought down its government in weeks, and Romania's communist dictator was overthrown and executed in December. Most of these revolutions were peaceful.

The Soviet collapse

Reforms unleashed nationalist movements in the Soviet republics. The Baltic states, Ukraine, and others demanded independence. In August 1991, hardline communists attempted a coup against Gorbachev, but it failed, and Boris Yeltsin, the president of Russia, rallied resistance. In December 1991, Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus agreed to dissolve the Soviet Union, which formally ended on December 25. Fifteen new states emerged.

Interpreting the end

Historians debate which cause was most important. Some stress Reagan's pressure, others the internal weakness of the Soviet system and Gorbachev's decisions, and others the role of people's movements. The CED lists the main factors together without ranking them, so a good answer names several and connects them, and then judges.

Primary source · A call at the Berlin Wall

Ronald Reagan, speech at the Brandenburg Gate, West Berlin, June 12, 1987 (a US federal public record).

Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!

Sourcing (HIPP). Reagan was the President of the United States, so the point of view is that of a firm critic of the Soviet system speaking to a Western audience at the dividing line of the Cold War. His purpose was to press Gorbachev to prove his reforms were real by taking concrete steps, and to assure West Berliners of American support, and his audience was West Berliners, the American public, and the Soviet leadership. The wall fell two years later, but because it happened as the result of popular protests in East Germany and policy changes by Gorbachev, the speech shows American aims more than it explains the outcome.

Source analysis · A demand, not a cause

Claim. Reagan used public statements to pressure the Soviet leadership.

Evidence. At the Berlin Wall, he called on Gorbachev to tear it down.

Reasoning. The speech was a demand placed before the Soviet leader and the world, which fits the policy of pressure the US pursued in the 1980s. A limit is that the wall fell in 1989 because of East German protests and Gorbachev's decision not to use force, so the speech does not show that US words caused the outcome.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one external and one internal cause of the end of the Cold War.

Model. One external cause was the US military buildup and technological development, including the Strategic Defense Initiative, which put pressure on the Soviet Union to compete at great cost. One internal cause was the weakness of the Soviet economy, which suffered shortages and stagnation while spending heavily on the military, and public discontent in Eastern Europe, as shown by Solidarity.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8J asks for the causes of the end of the Cold War. Name the CED's causes (US military and technological advances, the Afghan war, economic weakness, public discontent), Gorbachev's reforms (glasnost, perestroika), the revolutions of 1989, and the Soviet collapse in 1991. Judge the relative importance of the causes.

Practice
  1. What was the Strategic Defense Initiative?
    Show answer

    A 1983 US proposal for a missile defense system, nicknamed "Star Wars," which Soviet leaders feared they could not match.

  2. How did the war in Afghanistan affect the Soviet Union?
    Show answer

    It was costly, could not be won, hurt morale and the USSR's image, and the Soviets withdrew in 1989.

  3. What were glasnost and perestroika?
    Show answer

    Gorbachev's policies of openness, with more free speech, and restructuring, with some market elements in the economy.

  4. What was Solidarity?
    Show answer

    An independent labor union in Poland, founded in 1980 under Lech Walesa, which became a mass movement against communist rule.

  5. What happened on November 9, 1989?
    Show answer

    East Germany opened the Berlin Wall after mass protests.

  6. When did the Soviet Union end?
    Show answer

    In December 1991, when Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus agreed to dissolve it and it formally ended on December 25, leaving fifteen new states.

Lesson 8.12 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.9

Causation in the age of the Cold War and decolonization

This lesson practices causation for Unit 8. The CED asks you to explain the extent to which the effects of the Cold War were similar in the Eastern and Western Hemispheres. That is a question of comparing effects across regions, so it combines causation with comparison. The CED says that the Cold War conflict extended beyond its basic ideological origins to have profound effects on economic, political, social, and cultural aspects of global events, and that states responded in a variety of ways to the economic challenges of the 20th century.

Required content · 8K

Learning objective.

  • 8K. Explain the extent to which the effects of the Cold War were similar in the Eastern and Western Hemispheres.

Historical developments.

  • 6.2.II. Hopes for greater self-government were largely unfulfilled following the World War I; however, in the years following the World War II, increasing anti-imperialist sentiment contributed to the dissolution of empires and the restructuring of states.
  • 6.2.IV.C. The Cold War conflict extended beyond its basic ideological origins to have profound effects on economic, political, social, and cultural aspects of global events.
  • 6.3.I. States responded in a variety of ways to the economic challenges of the 20th century.

Setting up the comparison

The Cold War affected nearly every part of the world, but in different ways.

Effects in the Eastern Hemisphere (Europe, Asia, Africa):

  • Europe was divided by the Iron Curtain into two blocs, with East Germany and Berlin at the center.
  • Proxy wars were fought in Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Angola, often with enormous casualties (Lesson 8.3b).
  • Decolonization in Asia and Africa became an arena of rivalry, as the superpowers courted new states (Lesson 8.5a).
  • Communist revolutions and movements arose, as in China and Vietnam, and states sought a path between the blocs through the Non-Aligned Movement.

Effects in the Western Hemisphere (the Americas):

  • US influence in Latin America was supported by covert action and military aid. The CIA helped overthrow the elected government of Guatemala in 1954, and the US supported coups such as the one in Chile (1973).
  • The Cuban Revolution (1959) brought a communist government 90 miles from Florida and led to the Missile Crisis (Lesson 8.3a).
  • Proxy conflicts occurred in Central America, such as the Sandinista-Contras war in Nicaragua and civil wars in El Salvador and Guatemala.
  • The United States itself was affected by anti-communist politics, huge military spending, and the civil rights movement, which was shaped by the Cold War competition for global opinion.

Similarities

  • In both hemispheres, the superpowers gave military and economic aid to allies and fought for influence through covert action.
  • Both saw violence and instability in places where local conflicts joined Cold War rivalry.
  • In both, governments responded to economic challenges by using state-led plans or by seeking aid and investment from one side or the other, as the CED says in its last key concept.
  • In both, ideas and culture spread, such as Marxism, liberalism, and mass media.

Differences

  • Direct superpower involvement. In the Eastern Hemisphere, the Soviet Union controlled a bloc of states in Eastern Europe, and the US led an alliance in Western Europe and East Asia. In the Western Hemisphere, US dominance went largely unchallenged except in Cuba, so the effects were mostly the consequences of US policy.
  • Scale of war. Large conventional wars (Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan) took place in the East. In the West, conflicts were smaller and mostly civil wars and coups, apart from the nuclear confrontation over Cuba.
  • Decolonization. Colonial independence movements were mostly in Asia and Africa, while Latin America had been independent since the 1800s, so its concerns centered more on economic dependence and US influence.

Judging the extent

A strong argument might claim: The effects were similar in that both hemispheres saw superpower intervention, proxy conflict, and the pressure to choose sides, but different in that the Eastern Hemisphere experienced larger wars and decolonization while the Western Hemisphere experienced mostly US-backed coups and civil wars. Note that the claim qualifies itself ("similar in that... different in that...") and judges the extent.

Description of: Nkrumah on neocolonialism

Description of Kwame Nkrumah's book Neo-Colonialism: The Last Stage of Imperialism (1965). This is a description, not a quotation.

Nkrumah, who had been overthrown as president of Ghana in 1966, argued that newly independent states were still controlled by outside powers through economic means, such as investment, aid, and trade, even if they had flags and governments of their own. He saw the Cold War as part of this process.

Sourcing (HIPP). Nkrumah was a leader of African independence and a socialist, so his point of view is that of an anti-imperialist critic. His purpose was to warn African states that political independence was not enough and to argue for African unity, and his audience was Africans and others in the developing world. Because he wrote as a politician who blamed outside forces for Africa's difficulties, he may have given less weight to the failures of African governments, but his argument was widely shared and reflected real patterns of dependence.

Source analysis · Independence and dependence

Claim. Some leaders of new states argued that political independence did not end outside control.

Evidence. Nkrumah argued that new states were still controlled through investment, aid, and trade.

Reasoning. His claim links the Cold War to economic influence, which matches the CED's point that the Cold War affected economic aspects of global events and fits patterns such as reliance on a few exports. A limit is that he was a politician with a stake in blaming outsiders, so he may have understated domestic causes of difficulties.

Worked example · Extent of similarity

Question. Explain one similarity and one difference in the effects of the Cold War in the Eastern and Western Hemispheres.

Model. One similarity is that in both hemispheres the superpowers intervened in local conflicts, as in Vietnam and Nicaragua, to support friendly governments or movements. One difference is that large conventional wars such as Korea and Vietnam took place in Asia, whereas in the Americas the main effects were coups and civil wars supported by the United States, along with the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 8K asks for the extent to which the effects of the Cold War were similar in the two hemispheres. Compare specific cases from each, name similarities and differences, and make a qualified judgment. Use the CED's idea that the Cold War had economic, political, social, and cultural effects.

Practice
  1. Name two effects of the Cold War in the Eastern Hemisphere.
    Show answer

    The division of Europe, proxy wars in Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Angola, and the pull on decolonizing states in Asia and Africa.

  2. Name two effects in the Western Hemisphere.
    Show answer

    US-backed interventions and coups, such as in Guatemala and Chile, the Cuban Revolution and Missile Crisis, and conflicts in Central America.

  3. Give one similarity across hemispheres.
    Show answer

    The superpowers gave aid and intervened to support friendly governments, and local conflicts became part of the rivalry.

  4. Give one difference.
    Show answer

    Large conventional wars were mostly in Asia, while decolonization was mainly in Asia and Africa, since Latin America had been independent since the 1800s.

  5. Why should a strong answer be qualified?
    Show answer

    The effects were similar in some ways and different in others, so a qualified claim judges the extent honestly.

  6. Why was Nkrumah an interested source?
    Show answer

    He was a politician who blamed outside powers for Africa's difficulties, so he may have understated domestic causes.

Unit 8 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 8 review: Cold War and Decolonization, c. 1900–present

Ten questions on the origins and mechanics of the Cold War, the varied paths to independence, non-alignment, revolution in China and Cuba, and the collapse of the Soviet system, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Harry S. Truman, address to a joint session of Congress, 12 March 1947.

    "I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures."

    The doctrine stated here is most significant because it

    Correct. The language names no country and sets no limit, which is why the principle could later be invoked from Korea to Vietnam to Latin America.

    The doctrine was directed against Soviet influence and marked the hardening of the rivalry rather than an alliance.

    It committed the United States to deeper and sustained involvement in Europe.

    The immediate occasion was aid to Greece and Turkey, but the statement is framed as a general policy and was applied as one for decades.

  2. The Marshall Plan served American strategic aims primarily by

    Aid funded reconstruction by European governments and firms; no ownership transfer was involved.

    Correct. The plan treated poverty as the condition in which communism grew, and prosperous trading partners served American economic interests at the same time.

    It was economic aid; the military alliance came separately with NATO in 1949.

    Several major recipients retained colonies for years afterwards, and no such condition was imposed.

  3. The concept of proxy war is most useful for understanding the Cold War because it explains why

    Correct. Nuclear weapons made direct war unthinkably costly, so the rivalry was fought out through client states in Korea, Vietnam, Angola, Afghanistan, and Central America.

    The period contained many deadly wars; the point is where they were fought and by whom.

    Superpower vetoes frequently paralyzed the Security Council on exactly these conflicts.

    The superpowers never fought each other directly, which is the fact the concept exists to explain.

  4. Description of: a set of maps and population figures for the subcontinent, 1947.

    A map shows a single colonial territory replaced by two states, with the new boundary cutting through two provinces. Accompanying figures record several million people moving in each direction across the new border within months, and estimates of deaths in the accompanying violence ranging from several hundred thousand upward.

    The data shown best supports which conclusion about decolonization in South Asia?

    Correct. Two states were created and millions displaced within months, which makes independence and catastrophe inseparable parts of the same event.

    Migration of millions and deaths in the hundreds of thousands are the definition of significant disruption.

    The boundary was drawn hurriedly by a commission and published after independence, cutting through provinces and communities.

    Independence and partition occurred together in August 1947, not after a decade of negotiation.

  5. Ghana's path to independence in 1957 differed from Algeria's chiefly in that

    Correct. Nkrumah's party built mass support and used strikes and elections, whereas France treated Algeria as part of France itself and fought an eight-year war before conceding in 1962.

    Ghana was the British colony of the Gold Coast and had an organized independence movement.

    Algeria's independence came in 1962, after Ghana's, and only after a war that killed hundreds of thousands.

    Ghana became independent in 1957, the first sub-Saharan African colony to do so.

  6. The Non-Aligned Movement that emerged from the Bandung Conference sought primarily to

    The movement was political and diplomatic, not a military alliance, and had no such capability or intention.

    Correct. States that had just escaped colonial rule had no wish to become dependencies of Washington or Moscow, and acting together gave them leverage neither could have alone.

    Its members were the products of decolonization and opposed any return of colonial rule.

    No monetary union was proposed; the agenda concerned sovereignty, anti-colonialism, and development.

  7. Description of: Chinese government production and population statistics for 1957–1962, alongside demographic estimates produced by later researchers.

    Official grain output figures reported at the time rise sharply in 1958 and 1959. Provincial procurement records show unusually high state grain collections in the same years. Later demographic estimates, based on census data, indicate tens of millions of excess deaths across the period.

    The discrepancy between the reported output figures and the demographic estimates is best explained by which of the following?

    Correct. Cadres under pressure to show success reported harvests that did not exist, and procurement quotas calculated from those reports took the real grain from villages that had none to spare.

    The mortality is concentrated in rural grain-producing regions and tracks procurement, which points to famine rather than unrelated disease.

    The estimates rest on census data collected separately, which is precisely why they can contradict the reported harvests.

    No blockade caused this; the crisis was generated by domestic policy and reporting.

  8. The Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 is most significant in Cold War history because it

    Correct. Thirteen days at the edge of nuclear exchange produced a direct communications link between the capitals and the 1963 test ban treaty, as both sides recognized how close they had come.

    Nuclear weapons were used in combat only in 1945; the crisis ended without their use.

    The rivalry continued for nearly three more decades after 1962.

    Castro's government remained in power, and the settlement included an American commitment not to invade.

  9. Which combination best explains the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991?

    Correct. A command economy that had stopped delivering growth, an arms race it could not afford, and reforms that permitted criticism before producing improvement combined with republics that wanted out.

    No such war occurred; the collapse came from internal pressures.

    The Soviet Union was not invaded, and the dissolution was negotiated among the republics' leaders.

    The August 1991 coup attempt was by hardliners trying to preserve the union, and no monarchy was restored.

  10. A historian comparing decolonization across Asia and Africa would most accurately conclude that

    Processes ranged from negotiated transfer in Ghana to prolonged war in Algeria, Kenya, Indochina, and Angola.

    Correct. Where Europeans had settled in numbers or where the colony was economically or strategically valuable, the metropole fought; where neither applied and nationalist organization was strong, it negotiated.

    France fought in Indochina and Algeria, Britain in Kenya and Malaya, and Portugal into the 1970s.

    Many new states inherited economies built around a single export and faced serious difficulties after independence.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE cause of the Cold War.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the Cold War shaped events outside Europe and North America.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason decolonization took different forms in different territories.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: ideological opposition between communism and liberal capitalism; disagreement over the postwar settlement in eastern Europe; mutual mistrust deepened by the atomic bomb; the security vacuum left by German and Japanese defeat. Must identify a cause.
    • (b) Accept: proxy wars in Korea, Vietnam, Angola, or Afghanistan; superpower support for friendly governments regardless of their conduct; development aid used as an instrument of competition; the Cuban Revolution and its consequences; the Non-Aligned Movement as a response. Must explain the effect.
    • (c) Accept: settler populations making negotiated withdrawal politically impossible; the colony's economic or strategic value; the organizational strength of nationalist movements; the metropole's own capacity after 1945; Cold War calculations. Must explain the variation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The defeat of Germany left the Soviet Union in occupation of eastern Europe, where it installed governments answerable to Moscow. The United States and Britain had gone to war over the independence of exactly those countries, so the postwar arrangement in eastern Europe became the first and most durable point of conflict between the wartime allies.

    (b) Because nuclear weapons made direct war between the superpowers unthinkable, the rivalry was fought through client states elsewhere. In Vietnam, Angola, and Afghanistan, local conflicts over independence or governance were supplied with weapons and money from outside, which made them longer and far more destructive than they would otherwise have been.

    (c) Where large European settler populations had established themselves, the colonial power faced constituents who refused to leave, and independence had to be fought for. Algeria, which France treated as part of France itself, required an eight-year war, while the Gold Coast, with no comparable settler community, achieved independence as Ghana in 1957 largely through mass political organization and negotiation.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way a communist state attempted to transform its economy in the twentieth century.
    2. Briefly explain ONE consequence of that kind of transformation.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of official government statistics as historical evidence.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: Soviet collectivization of agriculture; the Five-Year Plans; the Chinese Great Leap Forward and communes; land redistribution in China after 1949; Cuban nationalization. Must describe the policy.
    • (b) Accept: famine and mass death in the Soviet Union and China; rapid heavy industrial growth; the destruction of the landholding classes; long-term agricultural weakness; the political consequences of failure, such as China's later turn to reform. Must explain the consequence.
    • (c) Accept: officials rewarded for reporting success inflate figures; categories chosen to flatter policy; suppression of inconvenient data; absence of independent verification. Must name a specific limitation.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Under the Great Leap Forward beginning in 1958, China organized the rural population into large communes, abolished private plots, and directed peasants to produce steel in backyard furnaces alongside farming. The aim was to overtake industrial economies within a few years by mobilizing labor rather than capital.

    (b) The policy produced a famine that killed tens of millions. Officials under pressure to demonstrate success reported harvests far larger than what had actually been grown, and the state then collected grain in proportion to those reported figures, taking from villages the food they needed to survive.

    (c) Official statistics record what a government wanted recorded, and where officials are rewarded for good numbers, the numbers improve without the underlying reality changing. Chinese grain figures for 1958 and 1959 showed record harvests during the worst famine of the century, which is why historians test such data against census records and other independent evidence.

Lesson 9.1 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.1

Communication, transportation, and energy technologies

The twentieth century brought technologies that changed distance and energy. The CED asks how the development of new technologies changed the world from 1900 to the present and states that new modes of communication, including radio communication, cellular communication, and the internet, as well as transportation, including air travel and shipping containers, reduced the problem of geographic distance, and that energy technologies, including the use of petroleum and nuclear power, raised productivity and increased the production of material goods. This lesson covers these. The next lesson covers agriculture, medicine, and birth control.

1903 Wright brothers fly 1928 Penicillin discovered 1956 First shipping container voyage 1960s Green Revolution; birth control pill 1969 ARPANET begins 1980 Smallpox declared eradicated 1995 WTO founded 2007 Smartphones spread
Figure 9.1. Some technologies that shrank distance, extended life, or changed how goods and information move.
Required content · 9A

Learning objective.

  • 9A. Explain how the development of new technologies changed the world from 1900 to present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.1.I.A. New modes of communication, including radio communication, cellular communication, and the internet, as well as transportation, including air travel and shipping containers, reduced the problem of geographic distance.
  • 6.1.I.D. Energy technologies, including the use of petroleum and nuclear power, raised productivity and increased the production of material goods.

Communication

  • Radio. Guglielmo Marconi sent wireless signals across the Atlantic in 1901, and by the 1920s radio broadcasting reached millions of homes. Governments and leaders used it for news and propaganda, as in the speeches of Roosevelt and Hitler (Lessons 7.4 and 7.7b).
  • Television. From the 1950s, television brought images from around the world into homes, shaping public opinion about events such as the Vietnam War.
  • Cellular communication. Mobile telephones, introduced commercially in the 1980s, spread rapidly in the 1990s and 2000s. In many developing countries, mobile phones skipped older landline networks, and by the 2010s there were more mobile subscriptions than people in the world.
  • The internet. It began with the US government's ARPANET (1969), a network linking computers. The World Wide Web, invented by Tim Berners-Lee in 1989 to 1991, made it easier to use, and by the late 1990s the internet was global. Email, search engines, social media, and smartphones (from about 2007) allowed instant communication and sharing of information across borders.

Transportation

  • Air travel. The Wright brothers flew in 1903, airplanes were used in World War I, and by the 1950s jet airliners carried passengers across oceans in hours. Air freight allowed fast delivery of goods, and mass tourism and business travel grew.
  • Shipping containers. In 1956, American businessman Malcom McLean sent the first container shipment by sea. Standard metal containers could be moved from truck to train to ship without unloading, which sharply lowered the cost and time of moving goods. Container ports became a basis of global trade, and large container ships crossed the oceans.
  • Automobiles and highways. The mass-produced car, pioneered by Henry Ford in the 1910s, changed cities and economies around the world.

The CED states that these technologies reduced the problem of geographic distance. People, goods, money, and information moved faster and more cheaply, which supported globalization (Lesson 9.4).

Energy

  • Petroleum. Oil became the leading fuel of the century, for cars, trucks, ships, airplanes, and as a raw material for plastics and chemicals. It gave states such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, Venezuela, and Nigeria great wealth, and oil-importing states grew dependent on a few producers. The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), formed in 1960, raised prices in the 1970s, producing an "oil shock" that harmed the economies of importers.
  • Nuclear power. After the atomic bomb (Lesson 7.7a), scientists developed controlled nuclear reactors to produce electricity. The first nuclear power plants began operating in the 1950s. By the end of the century, nuclear plants supplied a significant share of electricity in countries such as France, Japan, and the United States. Accidents at Three Mile Island in the US (1979), Chernobyl in the Soviet Union (1986), and Fukushima in Japan (2011) raised concerns about safety and radioactive waste.

The CED says that these energy technologies raised productivity and increased the production of material goods. Cheap energy supported mass production, mechanized farming, and consumer goods, though it also had environmental costs (Lesson 9.3).

Effects

New technologies connected the world but did not reach everyone equally. Wealthier countries and regions gained first, and a "digital divide" separated those with internet access from those without. The technologies also changed war, since airplanes, rockets, and nuclear weapons made destruction faster and more complete.

Description of: a commentator on a connected world

Description of Thomas Friedman's book The World Is Flat (2005). This is a description, not a quotation.

Friedman, an American journalist, argued that new communication technologies, such as the internet and fiber-optic cables, had leveled the economic playing field so that people in places such as India and China could compete with those in the United States and Europe. He described companies placing work in many countries.

Sourcing (HIPP). Friedman was a columnist for a major American newspaper, so his point of view is that of an optimistic observer of the global economy from a wealthy country. His purpose was to explain and promote the benefits of globalization to a general readership, and his audience was mostly American readers. Critics said that he overstated how equal the playing field had become and underestimated the harm to some workers, so his book is good evidence of how some commentators saw technology, and less reliable as a measure of its actual effects.

Source analysis · An optimistic view

Claim. Some observers of the early 2000s saw communication technology as making global competition more equal.

Evidence. Friedman argued that the internet and fiber-optic cables let people in India and China compete with those in wealthy countries.

Reasoning. His examples of companies placing work across many countries show how falling communication costs changed business. A limit is that he was promoting globalization to an American audience, and critics said he overstated equality and ignored workers who lost jobs.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way shipping containers or air travel changed the world economy.

Model. Shipping containers let goods move from truck to train to ship without being unloaded, which sharply lowered shipping costs and time. As a result, it became cheaper to make products in one region and sell them in another, which supported the growth of global trade and the movement of manufacturing to places such as East Asia.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9A asks how new technologies changed the world. Name communication (radio, cellular, internet), transportation (air travel, shipping containers), and energy (petroleum, nuclear power), with an effect for each: shrinking distance, raising productivity, and supporting globalization. Note uneven access.

Practice
  1. Name two modes of communication that spread in the twentieth century.
    Show answer

    Radio, television, cellular phones, and the internet.

  2. What was ARPANET?
    Show answer

    A US government computer network begun in 1969 that was the forerunner of the internet.

  3. How did shipping containers change trade?
    Show answer

    Standard containers could move from truck to train to ship without unloading, which lowered cost and time and supported global trade.

  4. Why was petroleum important?
    Show answer

    It became the leading fuel for cars, ships, and aircraft and a raw material for plastics and chemicals, giving oil-producing states wealth and importers dependence.

  5. What was OPEC?
    Show answer

    The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, formed in 1960, which raised oil prices in the 1970s.

  6. Why is Friedman a limited source on globalization?
    Show answer

    He promoted its benefits to an American audience, and critics said he overstated equality and ignored workers who lost jobs.

Lesson 9.2 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.1

Food, medicine, and birth control

Science also changed how people eat, how long they live, and how many children they have. The CED says that the Green Revolution and commercial agriculture increased productivity and sustained the earth's growing population as it spread chemically and genetically modified forms of agriculture, that medical innovations, including vaccines and antibiotics, increased the ability of humans to survive and live longer lives, and that more effective forms of birth control gave women greater control over fertility, transformed reproductive practices, and contributed to declining rates of fertility in much of the world. This lesson covers each in turn.

Required content · 9A

Learning objective.

  • 9A. Explain how the development of new technologies changed the world from 1900 to present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.1.III.B. More effective forms of birth control gave women greater control over fertility, transformed reproductive practices, and contributed to declining rates of fertility in much of the world.
  • 6.1.I.B. The Green Revolution and commercial agriculture increased productivity and sustained the earth’s growing population as it spread chemically and genetically modified forms of agriculture.
  • 6.1.I.C. Medical innovations, including vaccines and antibiotics, increased the ability of humans to survive and live longer lives.

Population growth

The world's population was about 1.6 billion in 1900. It passed 2.5 billion by 1950 and reached 7 billion by about 2011. This rapid growth occurred because death rates fell much faster than birth rates, thanks to better food and medicine, and it was greatest in the developing world after about 1950.

The Green Revolution

By the 1940s and 1950s, there were fears that population growth would outrun food supplies. Agricultural scientists responded with new methods. The American agronomist Norman Borlaug, working in Mexico, developed high-yield, disease-resistant dwarf wheat. At the International Rice Research Institute in the Philippines, scientists developed a high-yield rice (IR8, released in 1966). These high-yield varieties, combined with chemical fertilizers, pesticides, irrigation, and machinery, raised crop yields sharply, especially in Mexico, India, Pakistan, and the Philippines. India, which had feared famine in the 1960s, became nearly self-sufficient in grain in the 1970s. Borlaug won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1970.

The CED says the Green Revolution and commercial agriculture sustained the earth's growing population as they spread chemically and genetically modified forms of agriculture. Commercial farming also grew, with large farms producing for global markets. In the 1990s, genetically modified (GM) crops, such as insect-resistant cotton and herbicide-resistant soybeans and maize, began to be grown widely, in countries such as the United States, Argentina, Brazil, India, and China.

There were costs. High-yield crops needed fertilizer, water, and machinery that poorer farmers could not always afford, so benefits were uneven. Chemical runoff polluted water, irrigation depleted aquifers, and a focus on a few crop varieties reduced diversity. Debates over GM crops concern their safety, their environmental effects, and corporate control of seeds.

Medicine

The CED says that medical innovations, including vaccines and antibiotics, increased the ability of humans to survive and live longer lives.

  • Antibiotics. Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in 1928, and it was developed into a drug and mass-produced in the 1940s. Antibiotics turned many deadly bacterial infections into treatable ones. Overuse later led to resistant bacteria.
  • Vaccines. Vaccines against diphtheria, tetanus, polio (the Salk vaccine, 1955), measles, and many other diseases saved millions of lives. A global campaign eradicated smallpox by 1980 (Lesson 9.2).
  • Other advances. Better sanitation and clean water, X-rays and surgery, blood transfusion, and public health programs also contributed.

As a result, global life expectancy rose from about 30 to 35 years in 1900 to over 70 years by the early twenty-first century, although progress was uneven, and gaps remained between rich and poor countries.

Birth control

The CED says that more effective forms of birth control gave women greater control over fertility, transformed reproductive practices, and contributed to declining rates of fertility in much of the world. In 1960, the US approved the first oral contraceptive pill, and other methods, such as intrauterine devices, became widely used. Governments in some countries, such as India and China, promoted family planning, and China's one-child policy (from 1979 to 2015) used strong state pressure. Access to birth control, along with education, urbanization, and women's work outside the home, helped to lower birth rates in much of the world. Many countries in Europe and East Asia now have fertility rates below the level needed to maintain their populations, and the world's population growth has slowed. Birth control also changed social and gender relations, since it gave many women more choice about education, work, and family, though it also faced religious and political objections in some places.

Description of: Borlaug's Nobel lecture

Description of the lecture Norman Borlaug gave on accepting the Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo in 1970. This is a description, not a quotation.

Borlaug argued that the new high-yield wheat and rice had given the world a "breathing space" in the race between food and population growth, but he warned that the gain was temporary unless population growth slowed. He linked hunger to the risk of political unrest.

Sourcing (HIPP). Borlaug was an agricultural scientist honored for his work, so his point of view is that of a researcher who believed passionately in raising yields. His purpose was to explain the achievement and warn that continued effort and population control were necessary, and his audience was the Nobel committee and the world. Because he spoke at the high point of the Green Revolution's reputation, he said less about its environmental and social costs, which later critics emphasized.

Source analysis · A scientist's warning

Claim. The Green Revolution bought time but did not solve the problem of hunger by itself.

Evidence. Borlaug called the gain a breathing space and warned that it would be temporary unless population growth slowed.

Reasoning. A leading scientist's warning that technology alone was not enough shows that contemporaries saw food and population as linked. A limit is that he spoke at the Green Revolution's peak and said little about its costs, such as pollution and uneven benefits.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of the Green Revolution and one limitation.

Model. One effect was that high-yield wheat and rice, with fertilizer and irrigation, raised crop yields sharply and helped countries such as India avoid famine and feed growing populations. One limitation was that the new methods required costly inputs that poorer farmers could not always afford and caused pollution and water depletion.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9A continues with agriculture, medicine, and birth control. Name the Green Revolution (Borlaug, high-yield crops, fertilizer), GM crops, antibiotics and vaccines, and birth control, with effects (population growth, longer lives, lower fertility) and limits (uneven benefits, environmental costs).

Practice
  1. What was the Green Revolution?
    Show answer

    The spread of high-yield crop varieties with fertilizers, pesticides, and irrigation after the 1940s, which raised yields in countries such as Mexico, India, and the Philippines.

  2. Who was Norman Borlaug?
    Show answer

    The American agronomist who developed high-yield dwarf wheat in Mexico and won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1970.

  3. Name two medical innovations that lengthened life.
    Show answer

    Antibiotics such as penicillin and vaccines such as the polio and measles vaccines.

  4. How did birth control affect women?
    Show answer

    It gave women greater control over fertility, which transformed reproductive practices and helped lower birth rates.

  5. Why did world population grow so fast after 1950?
    Show answer

    Death rates fell faster than birth rates because of better food, sanitation, and medicine.

  6. Why does Borlaug's lecture say less about the Green Revolution's costs?
    Show answer

    He spoke at its high point as a scientist promoting it, so critics later emphasized pollution, water depletion, and uneven benefits.

Lesson 9.3 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.2

Disease and the limits of technology

Modern medicine reduced many diseases, but others persisted or appeared. The CED asks how environmental factors affected human populations over time, and it states that diseases, as well as medical and scientific developments, had significant effects on populations around the world. It adds that diseases associated with poverty persisted while other diseases emerged as new epidemics and threats to human populations, in some cases leading to social disruption. These outbreaks spurred technological and medical advances. Some diseases occurred at higher incidence merely because of increased longevity. This lesson covers three groups of diseases from the CED and the response.

Required content · 9B

Learning objective.

  • 9B. Explain how environmental factors affected human populations over time.

Historical developments.

  • 6.1.III. Diseases, as well as medical and scientific developments, had significant effects on populations around the world.
  • 6.1.III.A. Diseases associated with poverty persisted while other diseases emerged as new epidemics and threats to human populations, in some cases leading to social disruption. These outbreaks spurred technological and medical advances. Some diseases occurred at higher incidence merely because of increased longevity.

Diseases associated with poverty

The CED's examples are malaria, tuberculosis, and cholera. These are caused by bacteria, parasites, or viruses and spread easily where there is poor housing, dirty water, and weak health systems.

  • Malaria, spread by mosquitoes, killed more than half a million people a year in the early twenty-first century, mostly young children in sub-Saharan Africa. Insecticide-treated bed nets and new drugs reduced deaths in the 2000s.
  • Tuberculosis (TB) is a lung infection that spreads through the air in crowded conditions. It was a major killer in industrial cities in the 1800s, declined with better living conditions and antibiotics, and returned in poor communities and alongside HIV, with drug-resistant strains.
  • Cholera spreads through contaminated water and caused repeated global epidemics from the 1800s. It remains a danger in places without clean water, as in Haiti after the earthquake of 2010.

Technology alone could not eliminate these diseases, because their causes included poverty and weak public services.

Emergent epidemic diseases

The CED lists the 1918 influenza pandemic, Ebola, and HIV/AIDS.

  • The 1918 influenza pandemic. Spreading with troop movements at the end of World War I (Lesson 7.3), it infected perhaps a third of the world's people and killed an estimated 50 million, more than the war itself, which shows the effect of global transport on disease.
  • HIV/AIDS. Identified in 1981, HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, spread through the world, and by the early 2020s had caused about 40 million deaths. It was especially devastating in sub-Saharan Africa, where it reduced life expectancy and left millions of orphans. The introduction of antiretroviral drugs in the mid-1990s made it a manageable condition for those with access to treatment, but these drugs were costly and unavailable to many in poorer countries, which led to campaigns to make them affordable.
  • Ebola. A severe viral hemorrhagic fever that emerged in Central Africa in 1976. The outbreak in West Africa in 2014 to 2016 killed over 11,000 people and led to a large international response and the development of vaccines.

Other recent epidemics include SARS (2003) and the COVID-19 pandemic that began in late 2019 and caused millions of deaths worldwide, disrupted economies and travel, and led to the rapid development of vaccines. These show how fast air travel and global trade can spread disease, and how science can respond. The CED says such outbreaks spurred technological and medical advances.

Diseases of longevity

The CED adds that some diseases occurred at higher incidence merely because of increased longevity, listing heart disease and Alzheimer's disease. As infectious diseases declined and people lived longer, chronic and degenerative illnesses became leading causes of death in many countries, including cancer, heart disease, and dementia. This is a sign of success in one respect and a new challenge in another.

Smallpox: a success

The great success was smallpox. A global campaign by the World Health Organization, using vaccination and surveillance, found and contained outbreaks, and the last natural case occurred in 1977. In 1980 the World Health Assembly declared the disease eradicated, the first human disease to be eliminated. It showed that international cooperation and science could remove a disease that had killed millions, including in the Americas after 1492 (Lesson 4.3).

Social effects

Diseases caused social disruption: fear and stigma, as with HIV, loss of workers and parents, strain on health systems, and in the case of pandemics, closure of schools and businesses. The response depended on states' resources and on international cooperation.

Primary source · Smallpox eradicated

World Health Assembly, resolution on the global eradication of smallpox, May 1980 (a World Health Organization public document).

The world and all its peoples have won freedom from smallpox.

Sourcing (HIPP). The statement was issued by the World Health Assembly, the governing body of the World Health Organization, so the point of view is that of an international organization celebrating its own program. The purpose was to announce and mark the success of the eradication campaign, and the audience was governments and the public worldwide. The announcement was based on years of surveillance, which makes it reliable on the main fact, but as a celebratory declaration, it says little about the cost or the difficulties of the campaign.

Source analysis · A celebration of cooperation

Claim. International cooperation could defeat a major disease.

Evidence. The World Health Assembly declared in 1980 that the world and all its peoples had won freedom from smallpox.

Reasoning. The declaration, backed by years of surveillance, shows that a global campaign eliminated a disease that had killed millions. A limit is that a celebratory statement by the organization that ran the campaign emphasizes success and says little about difficulties and costs.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change and one continuity in how disease affected human populations after 1900.

Model. One change was that vaccines and antibiotics reduced or eliminated many infectious diseases, as with the eradication of smallpox, so people lived longer. One continuity was that diseases tied to poverty, such as malaria, tuberculosis, and cholera, persisted, and new epidemics such as HIV/AIDS and the 1918 influenza showed that disease continued to threaten populations.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9B asks how environmental factors affected human populations. Know the CED's three groups: poverty (malaria, tuberculosis, cholera), emergent epidemics (1918 influenza, Ebola, HIV/AIDS), and longevity (heart disease, Alzheimer's). Include smallpox eradication as a success and note social effects.

Practice
  1. Name two diseases associated with poverty.
    Show answer

    Malaria, tuberculosis, and cholera.

  2. Why was the 1918 influenza pandemic so deadly?
    Show answer

    It spread rapidly with troop movements and global travel and infected perhaps a third of the world's people, killing an estimated 50 million.

  3. What is HIV/AIDS and where was its effect greatest?
    Show answer

    A disease caused by the HIV virus, identified in 1981, that spread worldwide and was especially devastating in sub-Saharan Africa.

  4. Why do diseases like heart disease and Alzheimer's occur more often?
    Show answer

    People live longer as infectious diseases decline, so chronic and degenerative illnesses become more common.

  5. How was smallpox eradicated?
    Show answer

    Through a World Health Organization campaign of vaccination and surveillance, and it was declared eradicated in 1980.

  6. Why is a celebratory declaration a limited source?
    Show answer

    It emphasizes success and says little about difficulties and costs.

Lesson 9.4 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.3

Debates about the environment

Industrial and agricultural growth changed the earth. The CED asks about the causes and effects of environmental changes in the period from 1900 to the present, and states that as human activity contributed to deforestation, desertification, a decline in air quality, and increased consumption of the world's supply of fresh water, humans competed over these and other resources more intensely than ever before, and that the release of greenhouse gases and pollutants into the atmosphere contributed to debates about the nature and causes of climate change. This lesson covers the changes, their causes, and the debates.

Required content · 9C

Learning objective.

  • 9C. Explain the causes and effects of environmental changes in the period from 1900 to present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.1.II.A. As human activity contributed to deforestation, desertification, a decline in air quality, and increased consumption of the world’s supply of fresh water, humans competed over these and other resources more intensely than ever before.
  • 6.1.II.B. The release of greenhouse gases and pollutants into the atmosphere contributed to debates about the nature and causes of climate change.

Causes: more people, more energy, more consumption

Population growth, industrial production, rising incomes, and the use of fossil fuels all increased the human footprint. The same technologies that raised food production and living standards (Lessons 9.1a and 9.1b) put heavier demands on land, air, and water. In many countries, rapid industrialization, as in China and India, produced pollution on a large scale.

Environmental changes

  • Deforestation. Forests were cleared for farmland, ranches, timber, and roads. Large areas of the Amazon, Southeast Asia, and Africa lost forest, which reduced biodiversity and affected climate and soils.
  • Desertification. The loss of vegetation, overgrazing, and drought turned dry lands into desert, as in the Sahel region of Africa, where a drought in the 1970s and 1980s caused famine.
  • Decline in air quality. Burning coal, oil, and wood polluted the air in cities such as London in the 1950s, and in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries in Beijing, Delhi, and Mexico City. Smog caused respiratory disease and early death. Chemicals called CFCs damaged the ozone layer, until a 1987 international agreement, the Montreal Protocol, phased them out, which is a success story.
  • Fresh water. Irrigation, industry, and growing cities used more water, and rivers and underground aquifers declined. The Aral Sea in Central Asia, drained by Soviet irrigation projects, shrank to a fraction of its size. Competition for water caused tensions among states along shared rivers such as the Nile.
  • Disasters. Nuclear accidents at Chernobyl (1986) and Fukushima (2011), oil spills, and industrial disasters such as the gas leak in Bhopal, India (1984) showed the dangers of technology.

The CED notes that humans competed over these and other resources more intensely than ever before, including oil, water, minerals, and land. Disputes over resources contributed to wars and diplomatic tensions, for example in the Middle East.

Climate change and the debates

The CED states that the release of greenhouse gases and pollutants into the atmosphere contributed to debates about the nature and causes of climate change. Burning fossil fuels and clearing forests release carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, which trap heat in the atmosphere. By the late twentieth century, scientists reported that the global average temperature was rising, and by the 2010s the great majority of climate scientists concluded that human activity was the main cause. Effects include rising sea levels, melting ice, more extreme weather, and disruptions to farming and ecosystems.

The debates concerned several questions:

  • Nature and causes. A small number of people, including some politicians and businesses, doubted or denied that humans were causing warming, while scientific bodies became more confident.
  • Responsibility. Wealthy countries had emitted the most greenhouse gases historically, while developing countries argued that they should not have to limit growth to solve a problem they had not caused. Developing countries, including China and India, later became large emitters.
  • Solutions. Options include cutting fossil fuel use, shifting to renewable energy, nuclear power, and adapting to change, and they involve costs and trade-offs.

International responses

  • 1972: The UN Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm.
  • 1987: The Montreal Protocol on the ozone layer.
  • 1992: The Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, which produced a climate change convention.
  • 1997: The Kyoto Protocol, which set emission targets for wealthy countries. The United States did not ratify it.
  • 2015: The Paris Agreement, in which nearly all countries pledged to limit warming and to set their own national targets.

Progress has been uneven, since emissions have kept rising overall.

Primary source · The Paris Agreement

Paris Agreement under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (2015), Article 2.

Holding the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels and pursuing efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels.

Sourcing (HIPP). The agreement was negotiated by representatives of nearly two hundred governments, so the point of view is that of a compromise among states with very different interests. Its purpose was to set a common goal for limiting climate change, and its audience was governments, businesses, and the public. Because each country was left to set its own targets, and because the goal is stated as an aim and not a requirement, the document shows international agreement on a goal but not the actual cuts countries made.

Source analysis · A shared goal

Claim. Most governments agreed to a common temperature goal in 2015.

Evidence. The Paris Agreement set the goal of holding warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius and pursuing efforts to limit it to 1.5.

Reasoning. The text shows broad agreement about the objective, which reflects the CED's point that climate change became a central international debate. A limit is that national targets were voluntary, so the agreement states aims but does not show what countries actually did.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause and one effect of environmental change after 1900.

Model. One cause was the burning of fossil fuels for industry, power, and transport, which released greenhouse gases and pollutants into the atmosphere. One effect was a rise in average global temperatures, which contributed to melting ice, rising sea levels, and more extreme weather, and led to international debates about how to respond.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9C asks for causes and effects of environmental changes. Name changes (deforestation, desertification, air quality, fresh water, climate change), causes (population, industry, energy, consumption), and responses (Montreal, Kyoto, Paris). Describe debates about causes, responsibility, and solutions, and note the competition over resources.

Practice
  1. What is desertification?
    Show answer

    The spread of desert conditions into dry lands because of overgrazing, loss of vegetation, and drought, as in the Sahel.

  2. Why was the Montreal Protocol significant?
    Show answer

    It was a 1987 agreement that phased out CFCs, which damaged the ozone layer, and is regarded as a success.

  3. What are greenhouse gases?
    Show answer

    Gases such as carbon dioxide that trap heat in the atmosphere, released by burning fossil fuels and clearing forests.

  4. Why did developing countries argue about climate responsibility?
    Show answer

    Wealthy countries had emitted most historically, and developing countries argued that they should not have to limit growth to solve a problem they had not caused.

  5. What did the Paris Agreement do?
    Show answer

    In 2015, nearly all countries pledged to limit warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius, with each setting its own national targets.

  6. Why is the Paris text limited as evidence of what countries did?
    Show answer

    National targets were voluntary, so it shows agreement on goals and not the actual emission cuts.

Lesson 9.5 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.4

Economics in the global age

After 1980, the world economy became more connected through trade, investment, and finance. The CED asks about the continuities and changes in the global economy from 1900 to the present and states three developments: free-market policies, knowledge economies and the shift of manufacturing, and new economic institutions and multinational corporations. The skill for this topic is sourcing, so the lesson ends with an analysis of a source's limits.

Required content · 9D

Learning objective.

  • 9D. Explain the continuities and changes in the global economy from 1900 to present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.I.D. In a trend accelerated by the end of the Cold War, many governments encouraged free-market economic policies and promoted economic liberalization in the late 20th century.
  • 6.3.I.E. In the late 20th century, revolutions in information and communications technology led to the growth of knowledge economies in some regions, while industrial production and manufacturing were increasingly situated in Asia and Latin America.
  • 6.3.II.B. Changing economic institutions, multinational corporations, and regional trade agreements reflected the spread of principles and practices associated with free-market economics throughout the world.

The turn toward free markets

The CED states that, in a trend accelerated by the end of the Cold War, many governments encouraged free-market economic policies and promoted economic liberalization in the late twentieth century. After the 1970s, rising inflation and slow growth led many to doubt the state-led economic management that had spread after the Great Depression (Lesson 7.4). Leaders turned toward privatization (selling state companies), deregulation, lower taxes and tariffs, and open markets. The CED gives four examples:

  • The United States under Ronald Reagan (1981 to 1989), who cut taxes and regulations.
  • Britain under Margaret Thatcher (1979 to 1990), who sold state industries and curbed union power.
  • China under Deng Xiaoping, who from 1978 introduced market reforms, such as allowing farmers to sell crops on the market and creating special economic zones open to foreign investment, while keeping Communist Party rule. China's economy grew by about ten percent a year for decades and lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty.
  • Chile under Augusto Pinochet, whose advisers, trained in free-market economics, privatized industries and opened trade, even as the regime used repression (Lesson 8.7).

The collapse of communism, and the shift of former communist states in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union toward markets, accelerated this trend.

Knowledge economies and the shift of manufacturing

The CED states that in the late twentieth century, revolutions in information and communications technology led to the growth of knowledge economies in some regions, while industrial production and manufacturing were increasingly situated in Asia and Latin America.

  • Knowledge economies, based on research, education, software, and services, grew in Finland, Japan, and the United States. Finland, for instance, built a strong technology sector, including the mobile phone company Nokia.
  • Manufacturing moved. Because of cheap transport and communication (Lesson 9.1a), companies in wealthy countries moved factories to places with lower labor costs. In Asia, the CED lists Vietnam and Bangladesh, which developed clothing and electronics manufacturing, and the already industrial economies of South Korea, Taiwan, and China. In Latin America, it lists Mexico and Honduras, where "maquiladora" assembly plants made goods for export, especially to the United States.

This shift created jobs and growth in some developing countries but also brought factory accidents and low wages, such as the collapse of the Rana Plaza garment factory in Bangladesh in 2013, which killed over 1,100 workers. In wealthy countries, it caused the loss of some manufacturing jobs.

Institutions and corporations

The CED states that changing economic institutions, multinational corporations, and regional trade agreements reflected the spread of principles and practices associated with free-market economics throughout the world.

  • World Trade Organization (WTO). Created in 1995 to replace the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, it sets rules for trade and settles disputes among its members. China joined in 2001.
  • North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). Took effect in 1994, removing most tariffs among the United States, Canada, and Mexico. (It was replaced in 2020 by a new agreement.)
  • Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). Founded in 1967, it increasingly promoted regional trade among its Southeast Asian members.
  • Multinational corporations. The CED lists Nestle (Switzerland), Nissan (Japan), and Mahindra and Mahindra (India). These companies operate in many countries, with production, sales, and finance spread across borders. Their growth shows that large firms came from many regions, not only the United States and Europe.

Continuity

Not everything changed. Global inequality remained large, many countries still depended on exporting raw materials, and states kept some control over their economies. In 2008, a global financial crisis showed how connected and fragile the system was.

Description of: Deng Xiaoping's pragmatism

Description of a saying often attributed to Deng Xiaoping in the early 1960s and repeated during the reform era. This is a description, not a verified quotation.

The saying holds that it does not matter whether a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice. It was used to express the idea that economic results matter more than ideology.

Sourcing (HIPP). The saying is attributed to Deng, a veteran Communist leader, and its exact wording and origin are uncertain, since it was passed down in speeches and reports. The point of view is that of a leader who wanted to justify market-oriented policies to a Party that valued socialist ideology. Its purpose was to defend practical reform, and its audience was Party members and the public. Because the quotation's source and wording are not certain, a historian would use it as evidence of how Deng's reforms were popularly understood and not as a documented statement.

Source analysis · Limits of an attributed saying

Claim. Chinese reformers justified market policies by focusing on results over ideology.

Evidence. A saying attributed to Deng says it does not matter if a cat is black or white as long as it catches mice.

Reasoning. The saying fits the reforms that allowed private markets and foreign investment under Communist rule, which supports the claim about how the policy was explained. A limit is that its wording and origin are uncertain, so it is better evidence of popular understanding than of Deng's own words.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change and one continuity in the global economy after 1980.

Model. One change was the spread of free-market policies, such as privatization and trade agreements, and the shift of manufacturing to Asia and Latin America. One continuity was that large inequalities between rich and poor countries remained, and many countries still depended on exporting raw materials.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9D asks for continuities and changes in the global economy. Know the CED's free-market examples (Reagan, Thatcher, Deng, Pinochet), knowledge economies and shifting manufacturing (Finland, Japan, the US; Vietnam, Bangladesh, Mexico, Honduras), and institutions (WTO, NAFTA, ASEAN) and corporations (Nestle, Nissan, Mahindra and Mahindra). For sourcing, state limits of the source.

Practice
  1. What is privatization?
    Show answer

    The sale of state-owned companies to private owners.

  2. What reforms did Deng Xiaoping introduce?
    Show answer

    Market reforms from 1978, such as allowing farmers to sell crops and creating special economic zones for foreign investment, while keeping Communist Party rule.

  3. What is a knowledge economy?
    Show answer

    An economy based on research, education, software, and services, as developed in places such as Finland, Japan, and the United States.

  4. Why did manufacturing move to Asia and Latin America?
    Show answer

    Cheaper transport and communication let companies move factories to places with lower labor costs.

  5. What did NAFTA do?
    Show answer

    It removed most tariffs among the United States, Canada, and Mexico starting in 1994.

  6. Why is the "black or white cat" saying a limited source?
    Show answer

    Its wording and origin are uncertain, so it shows popular understanding of the reforms rather than a documented statement by Deng.

Lesson 9.6 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.5

Calls for reform and the response

The twentieth century saw movements demanding equal rights and a fairer sharing of the benefits and costs of change. The CED asks how social categories, roles, and practices have been maintained and challenged over time. It states that rights-based discourses challenged old assumptions about race, class, gender, and religion, that in much of the world, access to education as well as participation in new political and professional roles became more inclusive in terms of race, class, gender, and religion, and that movements throughout the world protested the inequality of the environmental and economic consequences of global integration. This lesson covers each.

Required content · 9E

Learning objective.

  • 9E. Explain how social categories, roles, and practices have been maintained and challenged over time.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.III.i. Rights-based discourses challenged old assumptions about race, class, gender, and religion.
  • 6.3.III.ii. In much of the world, access to education as well as participation in new political and professional roles became more inclusive in terms of race, class, gender, and religion.
  • 6.3.II.C. Movements throughout the world protested the inequality of the environmental and economic consequences of global integration.

Human rights

The idea that all people have rights as human beings, which came from the Enlightenment (Lesson 5.1), became an international principle after the Holocaust. In 1948, the United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, drafted under the chairmanship of Eleanor Roosevelt. It declared that all people have rights, including the rights to life, liberty, equality before the law, education, and freedom of thought. The CED stresses the Declaration as it sought to protect the rights of children, women, and refugees. It is not legally binding, but it inspired later treaties, laws, and movements, and it gave activists a global standard.

Challenging assumptions about race, class, gender, and religion

The CED lists several movements.

  • Global feminism. Women's movements demanded political, economic, and legal equality. Women gained the right to vote in many countries in the twentieth century: the United States (1920), Brazil (1932), Turkey (1934), Japan (1945), India (1947), and Morocco (1963), among others. The UN held a series of world conferences on women, from Mexico City in 1975 to Beijing in 1995, where the First Lady Hillary Clinton declared that "women's rights are human rights." Women's literacy and education also rose in most parts of the world, as did the number of women in universities and professions.
  • Negritude. In the 1930s, Black writers from French colonies and the Caribbean, including Aime Cesaire of Martinique and Leopold Senghor of Senegal, created the Negritude movement, which celebrated Black identity and culture and rejected colonial claims of European superiority.
  • Liberation theology. In Latin America, Catholic priests and thinkers such as Gustavo Gutierrez argued that the Church should stand with the poor against injustice. The movement grew after the Latin American bishops' conference at Medellin in 1968, and it challenged ideas about class, though the Vatican later criticized parts of it.
  • Civil rights and anti-racism. Beyond the American civil rights laws of 1964 and 1965 that outlawed racial segregation and protected voting rights, movements such as the one against apartheid ended the system in South Africa in the early 1990s (Lesson 8.7). India's caste reservation system, which sets aside places in schools, jobs, and legislatures for historically disadvantaged castes, is another example.

The CED also notes that access to education and to new political and professional roles became more inclusive across race, class, gender, and religion in much of the world, though inequality and discrimination persisted.

Environmental and economic movements

The CED adds that movements throughout the world protested the inequality of the environmental and economic consequences of global integration.

  • Environmental movements. Greenpeace, founded in 1971, used direct action to oppose nuclear testing and whaling. The Green Belt Movement in Kenya, founded in 1977 by Professor Wangari Maathai, mobilized women to plant millions of trees to fight deforestation and soil loss and linked environmental care to democracy and women's rights. Maathai won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2004.
  • Economic movements. The World Fair Trade Organization (founded 1989) and other fair trade groups sought better prices and working conditions for farmers and workers in developing countries, arguing that global trade had been unfair to them.

Responses

States and elites responded in different ways. Some governments adopted reforms, such as laws against discrimination, school expansion, and quotas, while others resisted or repressed movements. Resistance came from traditional groups who feared the loss of status and from governments that saw the movements as threats. The result was a series of ongoing struggles and partial gains.

Primary source · The Universal Declaration

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (United Nations, 1948), Article 1, first sentence.

All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Declaration was drafted by a UN committee that included representatives from many countries, and adopted by the General Assembly in December 1948, shortly after the Holocaust and World War II. The point of view is that of a body of states, mostly the victorious powers and new members, seeking a common standard. Its purpose was to set out rights that all governments should respect, and its audience was governments and peoples. It was not binding, and many member states, including colonial powers and the Soviet bloc, did not follow it in practice, so it states ideals and does not describe the actual treatment of people.

Source analysis · A standard and its limits

Claim. The Universal Declaration gave rights movements a global standard.

Evidence. Its first article says all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.

Reasoning. Activists could point to a document adopted by the world's governments to challenge discrimination, which helps explain its influence on later movements. A limit is that the Declaration was not legally binding and many states that approved it violated its principles, so it states ideals and does not show practice.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way social roles changed and one way they were maintained after 1900.

Model. One change was that women gained the vote in many countries, such as the United States in 1920 and India in 1947, and their access to education and professions grew. One continuity was that discrimination and inequality persisted, as seen in the need for caste reservation in India and continuing struggles over racial equality and women's rights.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9E asks how social categories, roles, and practices were maintained and challenged. Know the Universal Declaration, global feminism and suffrage dates, Negritude, liberation theology, civil rights and the end of apartheid, caste reservation, environmental movements (Greenpeace, the Green Belt Movement), and fair trade.

Practice
  1. What was the Universal Declaration of Human Rights?
    Show answer

    A 1948 UN statement that all people have rights such as equality, liberty, and education, which became a global standard though it was not legally binding.

  2. Name two countries and dates in which women gained the vote.
    Show answer

    The United States (1920), Brazil (1932), Turkey (1934), Japan (1945), India (1947), or Morocco (1963).

  3. What was Negritude?
    Show answer

    A movement of Black writers in the 1930s, including Cesaire and Senghor, that celebrated Black identity and culture against colonial claims of superiority.

  4. What was liberation theology?
    Show answer

    A Latin American Catholic movement that argued the Church should stand with the poor against injustice.

  5. What was the Green Belt Movement?
    Show answer

    A Kenyan movement founded by Wangari Maathai in 1977 that mobilized women to plant trees against deforestation and linked environmental care to democracy and women's rights.

  6. Why is the Universal Declaration limited as evidence of actual practice?
    Show answer

    It was not binding and many states that approved it did not follow it, so it shows ideals and not how people were treated.

Lesson 9.7 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.6

Globalized culture

Music, films, sports, brands, and ideas now travel across the world. The CED asks how and why globalization changed culture over time. It states that political and social changes of the twentieth century led to changes in the arts and, in the second half of the century, popular and consumer culture became more global, that arts, entertainment, and popular culture increasingly reflected the influence of a globalized society, and that consumer culture became globalized and transcended national borders. The skill for this topic is contextualization.

Required content · 9F

Learning objective.

  • 9F. Explain how and why globalization changed culture over time.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.IV.i. Political and social changes of the 20th century led to changes in the arts and in the second half of the century, popular and consumer culture became more global.
  • 6.3.IV.ii. Arts, entertainment, and popular culture increasingly reflected the influence of a globalized society.
  • 6.3.IV.iii. Consumer culture became globalized and transcended national borders.

Why culture went global

Several developments made a global culture possible.

  • Technology. Radio, film, television, and satellites (and later the internet and social media) spread images and sounds instantly (Lesson 9.1a).
  • Transportation and migration. Air travel, tourism, and the movement of people spread customs and created diaspora audiences (Lesson 6.7).
  • Economic integration. Trade and multinational companies carried brands and products around the world (Lesson 9.4).
  • Politics. The end of the Cold War opened many countries to outside influence, and the United States, as the strongest power with a large entertainment industry, promoted its culture.

Examples of global culture

The CED lists examples.

  • Music: reggae. Reggae began in Jamaica in the 1960s, and the singer Bob Marley made it a worldwide music with messages about poverty, justice, and Black pride. Other forms, such as rock and roll, jazz, hip-hop, and K-pop, also spread internationally.
  • Movies: Bollywood. India's Hindi-language film industry, based in Mumbai, is one of the world's largest, and its films have wide audiences in South Asia, the Middle East, Africa, and among diaspora communities.
  • Social media: Facebook and Twitter. Platforms started in the 2000s link billions of people and spread news, ideas, and movements, such as the protests of the Arab Spring in 2011.
  • Television: the BBC. The British Broadcasting Corporation's programs and news reached audiences worldwide, and global television networks and streaming services followed.
  • Sports: the World Cup and the Olympics. The football (soccer) World Cup, first held in 1930, and the modern Olympic Games, begun in 1896, draw billions of viewers and create shared experiences.

Global consumerism

The CED lists online commerce, such as Alibaba and eBay, which allow buyers and sellers around the world to trade, and global brands, such as Toyota and Coca-Cola, whose products are sold nearly everywhere. Chains of fast-food restaurants, clothing brands, and electronics similarly appear in cities across continents. The CED says that consumer culture became globalized and transcended national borders.

Effects and debates

  • Cultural mixing. Cultures borrow and adapt. Hip-hop is performed in many languages, and Bollywood films borrow from Hollywood, so global culture is not just one-way.
  • Homogenization. Critics worry that dominant cultures, especially American, may crowd out local traditions, languages, and industries, producing a sameness. Some speak of "cultural imperialism."
  • Shared experiences. Global events and media create common references among people who live far apart.
  • Change at home. Local customs and arts responded in different ways, from adoption to resistance (Lesson 9.7).

Contextualization

To contextualize a cultural development, place it in the broader setting. For example, the global spread of television in the 1950s and 1960s must be understood in the context of postwar prosperity, Cold War competition over images, and new broadcast technology. A strong answer links the example to at least one broader process, such as technology, migration, or the end of the Cold War.

Description of: a global advertisement

Description of the 1971 television advertisement for Coca-Cola known by the line "I'd like to buy the world a Coke." This is a description, not a quotation of the whole advertisement.

The advertisement shows a crowd of young people of many nationalities singing on a hillside in Italy and holding bottles of Coca-Cola, with a song about unity and peace. It was broadcast in many countries and became one of the most famous commercials of the century.

Sourcing (HIPP). The advertisement was made by an American company and its advertising agency, so the point of view is that of a corporation selling a product. Its purpose was to link the brand to harmony and youth culture, and the audience was consumers in the United States and many other countries. It was made in the context of the Vietnam War and youth movements of the early 1970s and the company's global expansion. Because it was meant to sell, it shows how a global brand presented itself, not how people around the world experienced either the brand or the ideals it claimed.

Source analysis · Selling a global brand

Claim. Global companies marketed their products as symbols of shared human values.

Evidence. The advertisement showed young people of many nationalities singing about unity while holding bottles of Coca-Cola.

Reasoning. Linking a product with peace and international harmony shows how a corporation used a global image to sell, which fits the spread of consumer culture across borders. A limit is that the advertisement was made to sell a product, so it shows the company's presentation and not how viewers around the world responded.

Worked example · Contextualization

Question. Explain one broader historical context for the spread of global popular culture.

Model. One context was the development of communication technologies such as television, satellites, and later the internet, which made it possible to send films, music, and sports to audiences around the world instantly. Another was the end of the Cold War, which opened more countries to foreign media and products.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9F asks how and why globalization changed culture. Give examples from the CED (reggae, Bollywood, social media, the BBC, the World Cup and Olympics, Alibaba, eBay, Toyota, Coca-Cola), causes (technology, trade, migration), and debates (mixing versus homogenization). For contextualization, link a cultural example to a broader process.

Practice
  1. Name two examples of global popular culture.
    Show answer

    Reggae, Bollywood films, Facebook, the BBC, the World Cup, the Olympics, and others.

  2. Why did popular culture become global in the second half of the century?
    Show answer

    Communication and transportation technologies spread media, trade and companies carried brands, migration created audiences, and the end of the Cold War opened more countries.

  3. What is global consumerism?
    Show answer

    The worldwide spread of brands and products and of online buying and selling, as with Coca-Cola, Toyota, Alibaba, and eBay.

  4. Give one effect of global culture.
    Show answer

    Cultural mixing and shared experiences, or concern about homogenization and loss of local traditions.

  5. What does contextualization require?
    Show answer

    Placing a development in its broader historical setting and linking it to larger processes such as technology, migration, or politics.

  6. Why is a company advertisement limited as evidence?
    Show answer

    It was made to sell a product, so it shows the company's presentation and not how people actually experienced the brand.

Lesson 9.8 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.7

Resistance to globalization

Globalization brought benefits, but it also provoked opposition. The CED asks about the various responses to increasing globalization from 1900 to the present and states that responses to rising cultural and economic globalization took a variety of forms. This lesson covers the reasons for opposition and the forms it took. The skill is sourcing, so the lesson ends with a source analysis.

Required content · 9G

Learning objective.

  • 9G. Explain the various responses to increasing globalization from 1900 to present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.IV.iv. Responses to rising cultural and economic globalization took a variety of forms.

Why resist?

People objected to globalization for several reasons.

  • Economic. Workers in wealthy countries feared the loss of factory jobs to places with lower wages, and farmers and small businesses in poorer countries feared competition from large foreign firms. Critics argued that trade rules and institutions favored rich countries and corporations, increased inequality, and reduced the power of governments to protect workers and the environment.
  • Cultural. Some feared the loss of local languages, traditions, and values to foreign media and products, which they saw as dominated by the United States.
  • Political. Some saw global institutions as overriding national sovereignty and democratic control.
  • Religious. Some religious groups objected to global popular culture as immoral or as a threat to tradition.
  • Environmental. Critics argued that global trade and industry harmed the environment (Lesson 9.3).

Forms of resistance

The CED lists examples of responses to economic globalization: anti-IMF and anti-World Bank activism and the advent of locally developed social media, such as Weibo in China. The following give a fuller picture.

  • Protest movements. In 1999, tens of thousands of people, including labor unions, environmentalists, and student groups, protested the World Trade Organization meeting in Seattle, Washington, and shut down parts of the meeting. Similar protests targeted meetings of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank, whose loans in the 1980s and 1990s often required "structural adjustment" policies, such as cuts in public spending and privatization, which critics said increased poverty. Movements such as the World Social Forum, begun in Brazil in 2001, formed an international network to promote "another world."
  • The Zapatistas. On January 1, 1994, the day NAFTA took effect, an armed Indigenous movement, the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN), rose in the Mexican state of Chiapas, saying that the agreement threatened Indigenous land and livelihoods.
  • Local media and technology. Some governments and companies created local alternatives to global platforms. Weibo, launched in China in 2009, became a Chinese microblogging platform at a time when Twitter and Facebook were blocked there. It served local users, and it also allowed the government to monitor and censor content. Other countries have set up their own search engines, social media, and payment systems.
  • Cultural protection. Some states set rules to protect local culture, such as quotas for national films and music on radio and television, as in France, or language laws, as in Quebec.
  • Protectionism and nationalism. Some governments raised tariffs or favored domestic industries. In the 2010s, political movements in several countries, including the United Kingdom's vote to leave the European Union (2016), combined opposition to global institutions with nationalism and concern about immigration.
  • Religious and fundamentalist movements. Some religious groups promoted traditional values against secular global culture, from conservative movements in many religions to extremist groups that used violence (Lesson 8.7).

Mixed responses

Not all resistance rejected globalization. Many movements used global tools, such as the internet, to organize, and some, such as fair trade and environmental movements (Lesson 9.5), called for fairer globalization instead of its end. Governments also adopted policies that combined openness with protection, as China did.

Sourcing

To judge a source on this topic, ask who wrote it, why, and for whom. A protest statement, a corporate report, and a government policy would each describe globalization differently.

Description of: the Zapatistas' declaration

Description of the "Declaration of the Lacandon Jungle," issued by the Zapatista Army of National Liberation on January 1, 1994. This is a description, not a quotation.

The declaration announced war on the Mexican government and army, said that Mexico's Indigenous people had been denied land, food, education, and a voice for centuries, and called on Mexicans to support the movement's demands for work, land, health, and justice. It was released on the day NAFTA began.

Sourcing (HIPP). The declaration was issued by a rebel group of Indigenous peasants led by a spokesman known as Subcomandante Marcos, so the point of view is that of a movement presenting itself as the voice of the excluded. Its purpose was to announce the uprising, state its demands, and win support in Mexico and abroad, and its audience included Mexicans and the international public. The timing, on the day NAFTA took effect, made the movement a symbol of resistance to economic globalization, but the text itself concentrates on Mexican Indigenous grievances and demands, so it shows how the movement defined itself and not all of its connections to NAFTA.

Source analysis · Timing as a message

Claim. The Zapatistas linked local grievances to opposition to the global economy.

Evidence. They launched their uprising on the day NAFTA took effect and called for land, work, and justice for Indigenous people.

Reasoning. Choosing that date linked their grievances to the trade agreement and drew attention to the issue, which supports the claim that they saw globalization as a threat. A limit is that the declaration's text focuses on Mexican Indigenous grievances, so the connection to NAFTA comes more from the timing and later statements than from the text itself.

Worked example · Responses

Question. Explain one way people resisted economic globalization and one way they resisted cultural globalization.

Model. One form of economic resistance was protest against the IMF, World Bank, and WTO, as in Seattle in 1999, where critics argued that trade rules and structural adjustment policies increased inequality and harmed workers. A form of cultural resistance was the creation of local alternatives such as Weibo in China, or laws such as quotas for national films and music in France, to protect local culture and control.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9G asks for the various responses to globalization. Give reasons (economic, cultural, political, religious, environmental) and forms (protest against the IMF and World Bank, the Zapatistas, local media such as Weibo, cultural quotas, protectionism, religious movements). Note that resistance often used global tools.

Practice
  1. Name two reasons people opposed globalization.
    Show answer

    Fear of job losses and inequality, loss of local culture, loss of national sovereignty, religious objections, and environmental harm.

  2. What happened at the 1999 WTO meeting in Seattle?
    Show answer

    Tens of thousands of protesters, including unions and environmentalists, disrupted the meeting.

  3. What was Weibo?
    Show answer

    A Chinese microblogging platform launched in 2009 that served local users when Twitter and Facebook were blocked, and which the government could monitor.

  4. Why did the Zapatistas rise on January 1, 1994?
    Show answer

    It was the day NAFTA took effect, and they said the agreement threatened Indigenous land and livelihoods, along with long-standing grievances.

  5. How can a state resist cultural globalization?
    Show answer

    Through measures such as quotas for national films and music or language laws that protect local culture.

  6. Why is the timing of the Zapatista uprising important to a historian?
    Show answer

    It linked the movement to opposition to NAFTA and gave it a global symbolic meaning, although the declaration's text focuses on Mexican Indigenous grievances.

Lesson 9.9 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.8

International institutions in a globalized world

Globalization created a need for institutions that cross national borders. The CED asks how and why globalization changed international interactions among states and states that new international organizations, including the United Nations, formed with the stated goal of maintaining world peace and facilitating international cooperation. This lesson covers the main kinds of institutions, what they did, and their limits.

Required content · 9H

Learning objective.

  • 9H. Explain how and why globalization changed international interactions among states.

Historical developments.

  • 6.3.II.A. New international organizations, including the United Nations, formed with the stated goal of maintaining world peace and facilitating international cooperation.

The idea

After two world wars, many leaders believed that international cooperation could prevent future conflict and manage shared problems. The League of Nations (Lesson 7.5) had failed, and in 1945 states created the United Nations (UN), with the stated goals of maintaining peace, protecting human rights, and promoting economic and social development. Over the next decades, many other organizations appeared, covering trade, health, finance, the environment, and regional cooperation.

The United Nations

The UN has several main bodies.

  • The General Assembly, where all member states have one vote and which debates global issues.
  • The Security Council, with five permanent members (the United States, Russia as the successor to the USSR, China, France, and the United Kingdom) who can veto resolutions, and rotating members. It can impose sanctions and authorize peacekeeping forces.
  • Specialized agencies, such as the World Health Organization (WHO), which led the campaign against smallpox (Lesson 9.2), the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), the UN Children's Fund (UNICEF), and the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

The UN grew from 51 members in 1945 to 193 by 2011, as decolonization created new states (Lesson 8.5a). Its peacekeepers have served in many conflicts. But its record is mixed. The veto often blocked action during the Cold War and later, and the UN did not stop atrocities such as the Rwandan genocide in 1994 (Lesson 7.8).

Economic institutions

  • The IMF and World Bank (1944) lend money to governments and help set economic policy, with a strong influence from wealthy countries. Their conditions have been criticized (Lesson 9.7).
  • The WTO (1995) sets trade rules (Lesson 9.4).
  • OPEC (1960) coordinates oil production among major producers (Lesson 9.1a).

Regional organizations

  • The European Union (EU). It began with the European Coal and Steel Community (1951) and the European Economic Community (1957), among France, West Germany, Italy, and others, to prevent another war through economic integration. The Maastricht Treaty (1993) created the EU, and in 2002 twelve member states adopted a common currency, the euro. The EU grew to include much of Eastern Europe after the Cold War, with 27 members by 2020 after the United Kingdom left.
  • ASEAN (1967), linking Southeast Asian states.
  • The African Union (2002), the successor to the Organization of African Unity (1963), promoting unity and cooperation.
  • Others, including the Arab League (1945), the Organization of American States (1948), and Mercosur (1991) in South America.

Courts and civil society

The International Criminal Court (2002) tries individuals for genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, though major powers such as the United States, Russia, and China have not joined. Meanwhile, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), such as the Red Cross, Amnesty International, Doctors Without Borders, and Greenpeace, form a global civil society that monitors rights, delivers aid, and pressures governments.

Changes in how states interact

Globalization changed international relations in several ways. States now work through institutions, sign treaties on trade, rights, and the environment, and accept some limits on their freedom of action. Yet states remain the main actors, and they often ignore institutions when their interests conflict. Powerful states also have more influence in many organizations, so critics say that institutions mostly serve the powerful. Supporters point to successes such as the eradication of smallpox, the reduction of trade barriers, and long peace within Western Europe.

Primary source · The UN Charter's aims

Charter of the United Nations (1945), Article 1, part of paragraph 1.

To maintain international peace and security, and to that end: to take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Charter was drafted by representatives of the Allied states at San Francisco in 1945, so the point of view is that of the victors of World War II who wanted to avoid a third world war. Its purpose was to establish a new organization and state its aims, and its audience was governments and peoples. It states what the organization was meant to do. Whether it succeeded is a separate question, since the veto and the Cold War limited what the Security Council could do.

Source analysis · Aims versus results

Claim. The UN was created to prevent war through collective action.

Evidence. Article 1 states the aim to maintain international peace and to take effective collective measures to prevent and remove threats to the peace.

Reasoning. The language places collective action at the center, which responds to the failure of the League of Nations. A limit is that the Charter states aims, and the Security Council veto often prevented collective action, so it shows intention and not results.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one reason for the growth of international institutions and one effect on how states interact.

Model. One reason was that two world wars convinced leaders that cooperation was needed to prevent conflict, and that growing trade and shared problems such as disease required common rules. One effect was that states began to act through institutions, such as the UN, WTO, and EU, and accept some limits on their freedom of action, though powerful states still often followed their own interests.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9H asks how and why globalization changed interactions among states. Know the UN (General Assembly, Security Council, agencies), economic institutions (IMF, World Bank, WTO, OPEC), regional bodies (EU, ASEAN, African Union), the ICC, and NGOs. Give both successes and limits.

Practice
  1. What was the stated goal of the United Nations?
    Show answer

    To maintain world peace and facilitate international cooperation.

  2. What is the Security Council veto?
    Show answer

    The power of the five permanent members to block any resolution, which often limited the UN's action.

  3. What is the European Union?
    Show answer

    A regional organization that grew out of postwar economic integration, created in 1993, with a single currency, the euro, for many members.

  4. What does the International Criminal Court do?
    Show answer

    It tries individuals for genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.

  5. Give one limit of international institutions.
    Show answer

    Powerful states can ignore or block them, as with the Security Council veto, and critics say they mostly serve the interests of the powerful.

  6. Why does the UN Charter show aims and not results?
    Show answer

    It states what the organization was meant to do, and the veto and Cold War limited what it could achieve.

Lesson 9.10 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.9

Continuity and change in a globalized world

This final lesson practices continuity and change over time for Unit 9 and for the course. The CED asks you to explain the extent to which science and technology brought change in the period from 1900 to the present. You must judge how much changed, how much stayed the same, and for whom.

Required content · 9I

Learning objective.

  • 9I. Explain the extent to which science and technology brought change in the period from 1900 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 6.1.I.A. New modes of communication, including radio communication, cellular communication, and the internet, as well as transportation, including air travel and shipping containers, reduced the problem of geographic distance.
  • 6.1.I.D. Energy technologies, including the use of petroleum and nuclear power, raised productivity and increased the production of material goods.
  • 6.1.III.B. More effective forms of birth control gave women greater control over fertility, transformed reproductive practices, and contributed to declining rates of fertility in much of the world.
  • 6.1.I.B. The Green Revolution and commercial agriculture increased productivity and sustained the earth’s growing population as it spread chemically and genetically modified forms of agriculture.
  • 6.1.I.C. Medical innovations, including vaccines and antibiotics, increased the ability of humans to survive and live longer lives.

Evidence of change

  • Communication and transportation. The CED notes new modes of communication, including radio communication, cellular communication, and the internet, as well as transportation, including air travel and shipping containers, reduced the problem of geographic distance. People can talk across continents instantly, and goods move around the world cheaply (Lesson 9.1a).
  • Energy. Petroleum and nuclear power raised productivity and increased the production of material goods (Lesson 9.1a).
  • Food and population. The Green Revolution and commercial agriculture increased productivity and sustained the earth's growing population (Lesson 9.1b). The world's population grew from about 1.6 billion in 1900 to over 8 billion by the 2020s.
  • Health. Medical innovations, including vaccines and antibiotics, increased the ability of humans to survive and live longer lives (Lessons 9.1b and 9.2). Life expectancy more than doubled in many places.
  • Women and family. More effective forms of birth control gave women greater control over fertility, transformed reproductive practices, and contributed to declining rates of fertility in much of the world (Lesson 9.1b).
  • Warfare. Technology made war more destructive, with airplanes, tanks, and nuclear weapons (Lessons 7.7a and 7.7b).
  • The environment. Technology also increased pressure on land, water, and the climate (Lesson 9.3).

Evidence of continuity

  • Inequality. The benefits of technology were uneven. Wealthy regions gained first, and poverty, hunger, and disease persisted in many places, including diseases linked to poverty (Lesson 9.2).
  • Older ideas and conflicts. Religious belief, nationalism, and political rivalries remained powerful, and wars continued, with technology often serving old goals.
  • Gender and social hierarchies. Even with change, discrimination and inequality persisted (Lesson 9.5).
  • Dependence on resources. Societies still depended on the energy and raw materials of the natural world, and often competed over them.
  • Human responses. People continued to use new tools in familiar ways, such as adapting culture to local settings (Lesson 9.6) or resisting change (Lesson 9.7).

A comparison across the course

The course began in 1200 with regional societies and long-distance trade carried by caravans and sailing ships. By the present, a single global network connects nearly all people. A powerful theme across the whole course is that connections increased over time (Silk Roads, the Indian Ocean, the Atlantic system, industrial transport, and the internet), yet at every stage they brought gains for some and harm for others, including disease, conquest, coerced labor, and inequality. Another theme is that states and empires shifted from land-based and maritime empires to nation-states and international institutions, but power remained unevenly distributed.

Judging the extent

A strong thesis might read: Science and technology brought profound change in communication, health, food production, and the speed of exchange, but they did not end inequality, conflict, or the human need to adapt to environmental limits, so the extent of change was great in material life and more limited in social structures and political conflict.

Notice that it names categories, avoids claiming that everything changed, and qualifies the claim. You should also consider whose experience you are describing, since a farmer in a village in South Asia, a worker in a Chinese factory, and a software engineer in the United States each experienced technological change differently.

Description of: the Human Development Report

Description of the annual Human Development Report of the United Nations Development Program, first published in 1990. This is a description, not a quotation.

The reports compare countries using measures of life expectancy, education, and income. They show that life expectancy and literacy rose in nearly all regions between 1970 and later decades, while large gaps remained between the richest and poorest countries.

Sourcing (HIPP). The reports are produced by an international agency that works to promote development, so the point of view is that of experts and officials who favor development and use standard measures. Their purpose is to track progress and encourage policies, and their audience is governments, researchers, and the public. Because they rely on national statistics of varying quality and combine measures into one index, they are good evidence for broad trends, and less reliable for exact comparisons.

Source analysis · Change and continuing gaps

Claim. Technology and development raised living standards in most regions, but large inequalities persisted.

Evidence. The reports show rising life expectancy and literacy across regions, with large gaps remaining between rich and poor countries.

Reasoning. Evidence of broad gains together with persistent gaps supports a thesis that combines change and continuity. A limit is that the reports depend on national statistics of uneven quality and combine measures into an index, so they are best used for trends, not exact figures.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change and one continuity brought by science and technology since 1900.

Model. One change was that vaccines and antibiotics greatly extended life expectancy and reduced deaths from infectious disease. One continuity was that inequality persisted, since poorer regions had less access to these advances, and diseases linked to poverty such as malaria and tuberculosis continued to kill many people.

Exam focus

Learning Objective 9I asks the extent to which science and technology brought change. Name changes (communication, energy, agriculture, medicine, birth control), continuities (inequality, conflict, social hierarchies), and judge the extent with a qualified thesis. Consider different groups and connect to themes from the whole course.

Practice
  1. Name two changes brought by technology since 1900.
    Show answer

    Faster communication and transport, new energy sources, higher food production, longer lives through medicine, or greater control over fertility.

  2. Name two continuities despite technological change.
    Show answer

    Persistent inequality, continued conflict, discrimination, and dependence on natural resources.

  3. Why is "technology changed everything" a weak argument?
    Show answer

    It ignores continuities and does not judge extent, so it gives no balanced answer.

  4. How did the benefits of technology differ among regions?
    Show answer

    Wealthy regions gained first, while poorer regions had less access, so poverty and diseases of poverty persisted.

  5. What theme connects the whole course?
    Show answer

    Connections among societies increased over time, bringing gains for some and harm for others, and power shifted from empires to nation-states and international institutions.

  6. Why is a Human Development Report best for trends?
    Show answer

    It relies on national statistics of uneven quality and combines measures into one index, so it is better for broad trends than exact comparisons.

Unit 9 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 9 review: Globalization, c. 1900–present

Ten questions on scientific and medical change, population and environment, the integrated global economy, migration, and the movements for rights that reshaped politics worldwide, plus two short-answer questions.

Multiple choice

  1. Description of: a chart of world population and world cereal production per person, 1900–2000.

    The population line rises from roughly 1.6 billion to about 6 billion, with the steepest climb after 1950. The cereal-per-person line falls slightly in the 1930s and 1940s, then rises from the 1960s onward despite the accelerating population growth. A note marks the introduction of high-yield wheat and rice varieties.

    The behavior of the cereal-per-person line after 1960 is best explained by

    Correct. Yields per hectare rose sharply in Mexico, India, and elsewhere, which is what allows output per person to climb while the population line is at its steepest.

    The population line rises fastest in exactly this period, so demand grew rather than fell.

    Mechanization increased, and the noted seed varieties depended on fertilizer and irrigation infrastructure.

    The chart measures production per person rather than consumption preferences, and cereals remained the staple of most diets.

  2. The principal cause of the acceleration in world population growth after 1945 was

    Birth rates were already falling in many regions; the change was that far more of the children born survived.

    Correct. Population grows when deaths fall faster than births, and twentieth-century public health drove infant and child mortality down dramatically across most of the world.

    Migration redistributes population between places but does not change the global total.

    Several of the most populous states adopted policies to restrain family size during this period.

  3. Which best describes the environmental consequence most closely tied to twentieth-century industrial and population growth?

    Correct. Coal, oil, and gas powered industry, transport, and agriculture, and the carbon released has changed the composition of the atmosphere measurably within a single century.

    Global energy consumption rose steeply after 1950 rather than declining.

    Forest cover declined substantially over the century as land was cleared for agriculture and timber.

    Industrial water pollution remains a serious global problem despite regulation in some regions.

  4. Multinational corporations became more prominent in the late twentieth century largely because

    Correct. Once a container could move cheaply and a factory could be managed from another continent, a firm could place each stage of production wherever it was cheapest.

    States remained sovereign and continued to set the rules such firms operate within.

    Tariffs generally fell through successive trade agreements, which is part of what enabled global supply chains.

    Transport costs fell dramatically with containerization, which is the opposite of the claim.

  5. Description of: a chart of international migrant numbers and remittance flows, 1970–2015, compiled from national statistics and central bank data.

    The migrant line rises steadily across the period. The remittance line rises far more steeply after 1990 and, by the end of the period, exceeds total official development assistance to lower-income countries. A note observes that informal transfers are not captured.

    The relationship between the two lines best supports which conclusion?

    Correct. Money sent home now exceeds official aid, which makes migration a significant part of how households and national economies in origin countries are financed.

    Remittances are evidence of continuing ties, not of separation.

    The chart shows remittances overtaking development assistance by the end of the period.

    The note about uncaptured informal transfers is an explicit qualification.

  6. The spread of the internet and mobile communications has most significantly affected global politics by

    Correct. The same networks that let movements coordinate and publish also give states unprecedented tools for surveillance and for shaping what circulates.

    Several governments filter, block, and shut down networks effectively, so control has been contested rather than eliminated.

    Mass movements have continued to depend on physical assembly, which the networks help coordinate rather than replace.

    Access is unequal and the same channels carry misinformation widely, so equality of accurate information does not follow.

  7. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights adopted in 1948 is most significant because it

    The International Criminal Court was established half a century later by a separate treaty.

    Correct. Its power has been rhetorical and political: anti-colonial, anti-apartheid, and civil rights movements all used it to hold governments to a standard those governments had formally endorsed.

    It was a declaration of the General Assembly rather than a treaty, and binding covenants followed only in 1966.

    It was framed in universal terms and addressed to all states.

  8. Which best characterizes changes in women's political and economic position globally over the twentieth century?

    Correct. The franchise spread from a handful of countries in 1900 to nearly all by century's end and paid work expanded greatly, but formal rights did not close the gaps in earnings, property, and office-holding.

    Many states retained unequal laws on property, marriage, and inheritance well past mid-century, and some still do.

    Participation in paid employment rose substantially in most regions after 1945.

    Organized movements developed in Latin America, Africa, and Asia, often tied to anti-colonial and independence struggles.

  9. The growing importance of non-state actors in global affairs since 1945 is best illustrated by

    Correct. Organizations such as Amnesty International and Médecins Sans Frontières, global corporations, and transnational armed movements all act across borders in ways no single government governs.

    States remain the principal actors; non-state actors operate alongside them rather than replacing them.

    Border and immigration controls have generally tightened over recent decades.

    International organizations expanded substantially in number and scope during this period.

  10. A historian assessing globalization since 1900 would most accurately conclude that it has

    Correct. The silver trade and the nineteenth-century commodity economy were already global; what changed was speed, volume, and depth, along with who gained and who was exposed.

    Global economic connection long predates 1900, as the Indian Ocean network and the silver trade demonstrate.

    Gains have been highly uneven between and within countries, which is among the most documented features of the period.

    Cultural forms have mixed and adapted rather than converging on a single model, and local identities have often strengthened in response.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE scientific or technological development that changed human life in the period 1900–present.
    2. Briefly explain ONE environmental consequence of economic and population growth in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way global economic integration affected a region outside Europe and North America.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: antibiotics and vaccines; the Green Revolution; the contraceptive pill; containerized shipping; computing and the internet; nuclear technology. Must connect the development to a change in how people live.
    • (b) Accept: rising atmospheric carbon dioxide and warming; deforestation; air and water pollution; depletion of aquifers and fisheries; loss of biodiversity. Must explain the connection to growth.
    • (c) Accept: export-led industrialization in East Asia; dependence on a single commodity and exposure to price swings; the effects of structural adjustment programs; the growth of manufacturing supply chains; remittances from migrant workers. Must explain the effect on the region.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Antibiotics, introduced widely after 1945, made infections that had routinely killed people treatable within days. Together with vaccines and clean water supplies, they cut infant and child mortality sharply, which is the main reason world population roughly quadrupled over the century.

    (b) Industry, transport, and mechanized agriculture have all run on coal, oil, and gas, and burning them has raised the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere measurably within a single century. The resulting warming has changed sea levels and weather patterns in ways that fall hardest on countries that consumed the least of that energy.

    (c) Several East Asian economies, beginning with Japan and followed by South Korea and Taiwan, built growth on manufacturing for export to industrial markets. Integration into global supply chains raised incomes rapidly, but it also left those economies exposed to demand and financial conditions decided elsewhere, as the Asian financial crisis of 1997 demonstrated.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE movement for rights or political inclusion in the period 1900–present.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way such movements drew on ideas or examples from outside their own country.
    3. Briefly explain ONE continuity between the period 1200–1450 and the present that this course has traced.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: women's suffrage movements; the anti-apartheid movement; the American civil rights movement; anti-colonial nationalism; labor movements; indigenous rights movements. Must identify the movement and its aim.
    • (b) Accept: Gandhi's influence on later non-violent campaigns; anti-colonial leaders invoking the Universal Declaration or Allied war aims; international solidarity and boycott campaigns against apartheid; transnational networks among suffrage movements. Must show the transfer of ideas or methods.
    • (c) Accept: long-distance exchange networks reshaping the societies at their ends; disease traveling the routes of trade; religion and ideology crossing political borders; migration in response to economic opportunity and coercion; states justifying authority through visible claims. Must identify a genuine continuity and give evidence from both ends of the period.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The movement against apartheid in South Africa sought to end a legal system that assigned rights, residence, and political participation by racial classification. It combined internal resistance (strikes, boycotts, and civil disobedience, met with severe repression) with an international campaign for sanctions and disinvestment.

    (b) Movements repeatedly borrowed methods across borders. Gandhi developed mass non-violent non-cooperation in South Africa and then in India, and American civil rights organizers studied those campaigns directly and adapted their tactics of boycott and disciplined public protest.

    (c) Long-distance exchange has continuously reshaped the societies at both ends of a network, and it has continuously carried more than goods. Plague traveled the Silk Roads and Indian Ocean routes in the fourteenth century and reached Europe within a few years; the influenza pandemic of 1918 and COVID-19 followed the shipping lanes and air routes of their own periods. The speed changed enormously; the pattern did not.

DBQ 1 · Units 1–2 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which long-distance exchange networks transformed the societies they connected in the period c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis that says how much these networks transformed the societies they linked and in what respects, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the networks that already existed before 1200, or the consequences that followed after 1450. Use the content of at least four documents to support your argument, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how the author's point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant to your argument. Finally, show complexity: qualify your claim, weigh one region against another, or explain how the same network produced opposite effects in different places.

Document 1

Source: Marco Polo, The Travels, on the currency of Yuan China, written c. 1300; nineteenth-century English translation.

All these pieces of paper are issued with as much solemnity and authority as if they were of pure gold or silver … and indeed everybody takes them readily, for wheresoever a person may go throughout the Great Kaan's dominions he shall find these pieces of paper current.

Document 2

Source: Ibn Battuta, Rihla, on the East African coast, c. 1331; early English translation.

Kilwa is one of the most beautiful and best constructed towns in the world. The whole of it is elegantly built.

Document 3

Description of: the excavated remains of a caravanserai on the route between Persia and Central Asia, built in the thirteenth century.

Material evidence: described

A square walled enclosure roughly sixty meters on a side, with a single fortified gate wide enough for a loaded camel. Inside, an open court surrounded by vaulted bays: stalls for animals along the lower level, small chambers for travelers above. A cistern fed by an underground channel occupies one corner; a small prayer room adjoins the gate. Comparable structures stand roughly a day's march apart along the same route. An inscription over the gate records that the building was endowed as a charitable foundation by a provincial governor.

Document 4

Description of: a summary table of archaeological finds from excavated sites on the Swahili coast, compiled by modern researchers.

Quantitative: described

Columns record site, period, and counts of imported objects. Chinese celadon and blue and white porcelain sherds appear at every coastal site from the thirteenth century onward, in numbers that rise sharply across the fourteenth. Glass beads of Indian and Middle Eastern manufacture appear in the thousands. Coins minted at Kilwa are found along hundreds of kilometers of coastline and on offshore islands. Locally made pottery outnumbers imports at every site by a wide margin, and inland sites fifty kilometers from the coast show almost no imported material at all.

Document 5

Source: the Catalan Atlas, produced on Majorca for a European royal patron, 1375.

Image: described

The West African section of the map shows a crowned Black ruler seated on a throne, holding a large gold nugget in one hand and a scepter in the other. A veiled rider on a camel approaches him across a band of desert dotted with named towns. The caption identifies the ruler as the lord of the region and states that the gold found in his country makes him the richest and noblest king of these lands. The interior beyond his throne is left largely blank.

Document 6

Source: al-Umari, an Egyptian official in the Mamluk administration, recording in the 1330s what was remembered in Cairo of Mansa Musa's visit; early English translation.

This man flooded Cairo with his benefactions. He left no court emir nor holder of a royal office without the gift of a load of gold. … They spoiled the value of gold in Egypt.

Document 7

Description of: an Italian chronicle account of the arrival of plague, written in the years after 1348 by a townsman who survived it.

The chronicler records that the sickness came from the east with ships putting in at Mediterranean ports, and spread inland along the roads merchants used. He describes burials in mass pits, the flight of those who could afford to leave, and the collapse of ordinary obligations: notaries refused to attend the dying, and laborers demanded wages he calls extortionate. He blames the calamity on divine anger, on a conjunction of the planets, and in some passages on foreigners, and he notes that in several cities Jewish communities were attacked and killed.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the networks that already existed before 1200 (the Silk Roads under earlier dynasties, Indian Ocean monsoon trading, trans-Saharan routes opened by the camel saddle), so that the question becomes what changed in intensity rather than what was invented. Several sentences, not a phrase.
  • Grouping the documents by function rather than walking through them in order. One workable arrangement: Docs 1, 3, and 4 on the institutions and infrastructure that made volume possible; Docs 2, 5, and 6 on wealth, reputation, and the reach of information; Doc 7 on what the same routes carried besides goods.
  • Evidence beyond the documents, described rather than named: the Mongol yam relay system and the deliberate transfer of Persian astronomers and Chinese engineers between khanates; bills of exchange and the commenda; Zheng He's voyages; Timbuktu's scholarly establishment; the diffusion of gunpowder, printing, and the compass; the labor shortage and wage pressure that followed the plague in western Europe.
  • Sourcing that explains why the feature matters. Doc 5's purpose is a European royal patron's map: Mali appears because its gold mattered to Mediterranean economies, and the blank interior shows how far reliable knowledge actually reached. Doc 6's situation is a Cairo official writing from what others recalled a decade later, which makes his impression of scale unreliable but his account of currency disruption revealing. Doc 2's author had already seen Cairo and Damascus, so his praise of Kilwa is a comparison rather than flattery.
  • A complexity path: argue that transformation was real but concentrated; Doc 4's inland sites with almost no imported material show that the network reshaped coastal and urban societies far more than the rural populations a few days' travel away. Or argue that the most transformative thing the network carried was not a commodity at all but disease, and that the plague's demographic and social consequences outweighed everything traded along the same roads.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context None of the major routes of this period were new. Silk had moved west across Central Asia for well over a thousand years, merchants had sailed the Indian Ocean on the monsoon since antiquity, and the camel saddle had made regular Saharan crossings possible centuries before 1200. What changed after 1200 was scale and security: Mongol unification of the overland route, the growth of Indian Ocean shipping, and the expansion of West African states that could tax and protect caravans. Thesis These networks transformed the societies they connected profoundly, but the transformation was highly uneven: it reshaped coastal and commercial cities, the elites who lived by exchange, and the states that taxed it, while leaving rural populations a few days inland largely untouched; and its single most far-reaching effect, the plague, was one no participant sought or controlled.

Doc evidence The first transformation was institutional. Doc 3 shows what sustained volume required: a fortified enclosure with stalls, sleeping chambers, water, and a prayer room, built to a standard plan and spaced a day's march apart, endowed by a provincial governor as a charitable foundation. That is a state and an elite investing in commerce as public infrastructure. Doc 1 shows the same principle in a different register: a currency backed by nothing but the Khan's authority yet accepted across an empire, which eliminated the need to carry metal over vast distances. Outside evidence Merchants elsewhere solved the same problem with bills of exchange, allowing money deposited with a banking house in one city to be collected in another, and the Mongols added the yam, a relay system of post stations that moved messages and officials at speeds no previous overland power had managed.

Doc evidence The second transformation was in wealth and reputation. Doc 2 records a Moroccan traveler calling Kilwa one of the best-built towns in the world. Sourcing Ibn Battuta had already seen Cairo, Damascus, and Mecca, so his praise is a comparison against the standard of the Islamic world's greatest cities rather than the courtesy of a guest. Docs 5 and 6 show the same process at the other end of Africa. Al-Umari reports that Mansa Musa's spending disrupted Cairo's currency; the Catalan Atlas places a crowned West African ruler holding a nugget of gold at the center of its African section. Sourcing The atlas was made on Majorca for a European royal patron, and its purpose explains what it contains: Mali appears in detail because its gold reached Mediterranean markets and mattered to the people paying for the map, while the interior beyond the throne is left blank because no commercial interest carried information out of it. Reputation traveled along the same routes as the metal.

Doc evidence But Doc 4 is the document that limits the argument. Chinese porcelain and Indian glass beads appear at every excavated Swahili coastal site and rise sharply across the fourteenth century, and Kilwa's coins turn up hundreds of kilometers away: clear evidence of integration. Yet locally made pottery outnumbers imports everywhere, and sites only fifty kilometers inland show almost no imported material at all. The network transformed the ports and the merchant elite who lived by them; fifty kilometers away, daily life went on substantially as before. Outside evidence The same pattern holds in West Africa, where Timbuktu acquired mosques, a scholarly establishment, and a book trade that made it a center of Islamic learning, while the gold-producing peoples to the south, who were not Muslim and did not join the network on its terms, kept the locations of their fields secret and remained outside the transformation the gold financed.

Complexity The deepest change these networks produced was therefore not a change anyone intended. Doc 7's chronicler records plague arriving on ships from the east and moving inland along the roads merchants used: the precise infrastructure described in Doc 3, working exactly as designed. Its consequences ran far beyond the commercial world: the labor shortage that followed pushed wages up sharply in western Europe and weakened serfdom there, while the same mortality helped fracture the Mongol khanates that had made the overland route safe in the first place. The chronicler's own reaction is evidence of a further consequence, since blaming foreigners and attacking Jewish communities shows connection producing violent rejection rather than tolerance. So the strongest claim about this period is double-edged: exchange networks transformed the societies they touched more thoroughly than any state policy did, and the mechanism that carried prosperity to the coasts carried catastrophe along the identical roads, reaching populations the porcelain never did.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The last sentence of the introduction claims profound but uneven transformation, specifies who was transformed and who was not, and adds that the largest effect was unintended. That is a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the body follows.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening sentences establish that the routes predate 1200 and name what changed after it, which frames the whole question as one of degree. Several sentences of relevant context rather than a passing phrase.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): All seven documents are used for their content and grouped by function (1 and 3 on infrastructure, 2, 5, and 6 on wealth and reputation, 4 on the limits of penetration, 7 on disease) each described accurately and deployed to support the argument rather than summarized in turn.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Several pieces appear and are described, not merely named: bills of exchange, the Mongol yam, Timbuktu's scholarly establishment, and the post-plague wage rise in western Europe.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Doc 2's author judging against Cairo and Damascus, Doc 5's purpose as a commercial map for a European patron explaining both its content and its blank spaces, and Doc 6's situation as a Cairo official's second-hand recollection. Each explains why the feature matters to the argument.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph turns the essay's own evidence against the simple answer, showing that the infrastructure celebrated in Doc 3 is what delivered the plague of Doc 7, that the consequences reached populations the trade goods never did, and that connection produced violent rejection as well as exchange. The qualification is sustained across the paragraph rather than asserted in a phrase.

DBQ 2 · Units 3–4 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which the expansion of maritime empires transformed systems of labor in the period c. 1450 to c. 1750.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how much labor systems were transformed and in what respects, with a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: coerced labor as it existed before 1450, in the Americas, in Afro-Eurasia, or both. Use the content of at least four documents, bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents, and for at least two documents explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant to your argument. Demonstrate complexity by qualifying your claim, weighing continuity against change, or accounting for evidence that cuts against your position.

Document 1

Source: Bartolomé de las Casas, Dominican friar and former encomendero, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies, addressed to the Spanish crown, 1542; early English translation.

They took infants from their mothers' breasts … and threw them into the rivers. … The reason the Christians have murdered on such a vast scale and killed anyone and everyone in their way is purely and simply greed.

Document 2

Description of: a Spanish viceregal decree organizing labor drafts for the silver mines at Potosí, 1570s.

The decree requires designated highland communities to send a fixed proportion of their adult men each year to work at the mines for a set term, traveling at their own expense and returning when the term ends. It sets a daily wage, specifies that the draft rotates so that no community sends the same men in consecutive years, and instructs officials to record names and numbers. It invokes the obligation to labor for the common good that the decree says existed under the previous rulers of the region, and orders local headmen to deliver the required workers on penalty of punishment.

Document 3

Description of: a summary table of estimated transatlantic slave-trade embarkations and disembarkations, compiled by modern historians from shipping records.

Quantitative: described

Rows give fifty-year periods from 1500 to 1750; columns give African region of embarkation, American region of disembarkation, and estimated numbers. Totals are modest before 1600, rise steeply across the seventeenth century, and rise again after 1700. The largest destination column throughout is Brazil, followed by the Caribbean islands; mainland North America receives a small fraction of the total. A final column records estimated mortality during the crossing, expressed as a percentage, running between roughly one in eight and one in five across the periods.

Document 4

Source: an eighteenth-century casta painting produced in New Spain for a wealthy patron.

Image: described

The canvas is divided into sixteen framed panels arranged in a grid. Each panel shows a man, a woman, and a child, with a painted label naming the parents' categories and the term assigned to the child. The upper panels show subjects in fine imported cloth in furnished interiors, several holding books or writing implements. Panels lower in the grid show plainer dress, bare rooms, market stalls, and tools, and the labels grow longer and more elaborate as the grid descends.

Document 5

Description of: archaeological survey of the refining works below the silver mountain at Potosí.

Material evidence: described

Terraced stone platforms carry the remains of dozens of water-powered stamp mills, fed by a system of reservoirs and channels running down from lakes constructed in the mountains above. Wide shallow patios show heavy mercury contamination in the soil, consistent with the amalgamation process used to separate silver from crushed ore. Sediment cores from lakes downwind record a sharp rise in atmospheric lead and mercury deposition beginning in the late sixteenth century. Housing remains cluster densely around the works.

Document 6

Source: Olaudah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, published in London, 1789, describing the author's account of the middle passage.

The closeness of the place, and the heat of the climate, added to the number in the ship, which was so crowded that each had scarcely room to turn himself, almost suffocated us.

Document 7

Description of: a Portuguese colonial governor's report on operations against a community of escaped slaves in the interior of Brazil, seventeenth century.

The report describes a settlement of several thousand people in defensible hill country, with cultivated fields, a stockade, and an organized leadership. It records that previous expeditions had failed, lists the cost of the current force in men and supplies, and argues that the settlement must be destroyed because its existence encourages flight from the plantations and because neighboring planters will not invest while it stands. It notes in passing that the community had at times traded with nearby settlers.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: coerced labor was not invented after 1450. The Inca mit'a, serfdom in Europe and Russia, slavery within Africa and across the Indian Ocean and Sahara, and corvée obligations in many states all predate the maritime empires, so the question is what changed in scale, organization, and character.
  • Grouping rather than document-by-document narration. One arrangement: Docs 2 and 5 on the adaptation of existing obligations to a new commodity economy; Docs 3 and 6 on the scale and character of Atlantic slavery; Docs 1, 4, and 7 on how these systems were justified, classified, and resisted.
  • Evidence beyond the documents, described rather than named: the encomienda and the New Laws of 1542; the sugar plantation as a coordinated agricultural and industrial operation; the Manila galleon and Chinese demand for silver; indentured servitude in English North America; the Haitian Revolution as the endpoint of the system described here.
  • Sourcing that explains why the feature matters. Doc 1's purpose is to persuade the crown to legislate, which makes its rhetoric deliberately extreme and its author an interested party who had himself held an encomienda. Doc 4's patron and function, a decorative commission for a wealthy household, explain why hierarchy is presented as orderly and natural. Doc 7's author is arguing for resources, so his emphasis on the threat is self-interested, but that is precisely why his admission of repeated failure is credible.
  • A complexity path: argue that the transformation lay in scale and purpose rather than in the invention of coercion; Doc 2's decree explicitly borrows an existing obligation, but redirects it toward a world market. Or weigh the systems against each other: the Potosí draft left workers legally free subjects with a wage and a term, while Atlantic slavery made people property and heritable, and treating the two as one thing obscures more than it explains.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Coerced labor long predates the maritime empires. The Inca required rotating service through the mit'a, European and Russian peasants owed labor to landholders, and slavery existed within Africa and moved people across the Sahara and the Indian Ocean for centuries before 1450. Thesis What the maritime empires transformed was therefore not the existence of coercion but its scale, its organization, and above all its purpose: labor was reorganized around producing commodities for distant markets, and in the Atlantic this produced a system that made people permanently and heritably property in a way earlier arrangements had not. The change was enormous, but it worked by capturing and redirecting existing obligations rather than by inventing unfreedom.

Doc evidence Doc 2 shows the capture happening on the page. The viceregal decree drafting highland communities for Potosí sets wages, terms, and rotation, and justifies itself by invoking an obligation to labor for the common good that it says existed under the previous rulers. That is a colonial administration deliberately taking the Inca mit'a and pointing it at a silver mountain. Outside evidence The purpose of the redirection was global: silver from Potosí crossed the Pacific on the Manila galleons to a Chinese economy that required tax payments in the metal, so Andean villagers were being conscripted to serve a fiscal decision made in Beijing.

Doc evidence Doc 5 shows what that conscription actually built. Dozens of water-powered stamp mills fed by reservoirs constructed in the mountains above, mercury-saturated refining patios, and dense housing around the works describe an industrial complex, not a mine in the ordinary sense. Sediment cores recording a sharp rise in atmospheric lead and mercury from the late sixteenth century measure both the intensity of production and the cost to the people breathing that air. The scale of organization is the transformation: earlier tribute systems had moved goods, and this one moved and consumed people to run machinery.

Doc evidence The Atlantic system differed in kind as well as degree. Doc 3 records embarkations rising steeply across the seventeenth century and again after 1700, concentrated in Brazil and the Caribbean, with mortality on the crossing running from about one in eight to one in five: a rate treated as an ordinary cost of business. Doc 6 supplies what the table cannot. Sourcing Equiano published in London in 1789 into an active abolition campaign, and he was writing to persuade; that purpose shapes his emphasis, but it also means he was addressing readers who could check a great deal of what he described about the trade, and the physical conditions he reports match what the shipping records independently imply. Outside evidence What made this system distinct was the sugar plantation, which combined field agriculture with a mill and boiling house that had to run continuously through harvest, and so demanded a large workforce that could be driven at a pace no free labor market would supply.

Doc evidence Docs 1, 4, and 7 show the systems being justified, classified, and resisted. Sourcing Las Casas wrote to move the crown to legislate, and his rhetoric is calibrated for that purpose by a man who had himself held an encomienda; the extremity of the language is advocacy, but the fact that he had to make the argument at all documents what the encomienda had become. Doc 4 shows the settled answer a century later: a grid of sixteen panels sorting descent into named categories, with imported cloth and books at the top and tools and market stalls below. Sourcing It was painted for a wealthy patron's household, and that purpose explains its serenity: the hierarchy is presented as orderly and natural precisely because in practice it was neither. Doc 7 is the rebuttal: several thousand people in a fortified hill settlement with fields and organized leadership, against whom previous expeditions had failed.

Complexity The most useful qualification is that these were not one system but several, and flattening them obscures the argument. The Potosí draftee in Doc 2 was a legally free subject of the crown with a wage, a fixed term, and a village to return to; the people counted in Doc 3 were property, and their children were property. Both were coerced, and the coercion killed enormous numbers in each case, but only one of the two produced a status that descended by birth and required an ideology like Doc 4's grid to sustain it. Doc 7 supplies the sharpest evidence for that distinction: the governor argues that the settlement must be destroyed because neighboring planters will not invest while it stands, and admits the maroons had at times traded with settlers. Property that can escape, farm, fortify, and trade is not a stable category, and holding it in place required the permanent application of force, which is why the system that looked most total was also the one that had to be defended most continuously, and why it ended in Saint-Domingue in revolution rather than in reform.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims that scale, organization, and purpose were transformed while coercion itself was inherited, and distinguishes the Atlantic case as different in kind. That is a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the body follows.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening names the mit'a, European and Russian serfdom, and pre-existing African and Indian Ocean slavery, establishing that the question is about change in degree and character. Several sentences of relevant context.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): All seven documents are used for their content and grouped by function, 2 and 5 on adaptation and industrial scale, 3 and 6 on the Atlantic system, 1, 4, and 7 on justification, classification, and resistance.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Several pieces appear and are described: the Manila galleon and Chinese silver demand, and the sugar plantation's combination of field and mill that dictated its labor requirements.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Equiano's purpose and audience in an abolition campaign, Las Casas's purpose and his own past as an encomendero, and the casta painting's patron and decorative function explaining its serenity. Each explains why the feature matters.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph distinguishes two systems the prompt invites a reader to merge, uses Doc 7's own admissions to show why the distinction holds, and closes by connecting the instability of the category to the revolution that ended it. The qualification is sustained rather than asserted.

DBQ 3 · Units 5–6 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which industrialization changed economic relationships between industrialized states and the rest of the world in the period c. 1750 to c. 1900.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how much these relationships changed and in what respects, with a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the pattern of world trade before industrialization, when Europeans bought Asian goods with American silver. Use the content of at least four documents, bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents, and for at least two documents explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience matters to your argument. Demonstrate complexity by qualifying your claim, weighing regions against one another, or explaining evidence that cuts against your position.

Document 1

Source: Lin Zexu, Chinese imperial commissioner, letter addressed to Queen Victoria, 1839; early English translation.

Let us ask, where is your conscience? I have heard that the smoking of opium is very strictly forbidden by your country … Since it is not permitted to do harm to your own country, then even less should you let it be passed on to the harm of other countries.

Document 2

Description of: a table of cotton textile production and trade, compiled by modern economic historians from customs and mill records, 1750–1900.

Quantitative: described

One column gives Indian handloom cloth exported to Britain and Europe, high in the mid-eighteenth century and falling to a negligible figure by the 1850s. A second gives British machine-made cloth exported to India, negligible before 1800 and rising to dominate the Indian market by mid-century. A third gives raw cotton shipped from India to Britain, rising steadily across the nineteenth century. A fourth column records the tariff rates applied to Indian cloth entering Britain and to British cloth entering India, the former consistently higher than the latter.

Document 3

Description of: the terms of the treaty concluded between Britain and China at Nanjing, 1842, and of the supplementary agreements that followed.

China cedes Hong Kong, opens five ports to British trade and residence, and pays an indemnity covering the cost of the war and the value of the destroyed opium. A fixed schedule of import duties is established, which China may not alter without British consent. British subjects in the treaty ports are made answerable to British consular courts rather than to Chinese law. A later clause provides that any privilege China grants to another foreign power extends automatically to Britain. Opium is not mentioned in the treaty text.

Document 4

Source: a photograph taken at the opening of a railway line in western India, 1860s, commissioned by the railway company.

Image: described

A locomotive stands under a decorated arch at a new station. British officials and company directors in formal dress occupy the platform in front of the engine; behind them and to the side stand several dozen Indian workmen and a group of local dignitaries in separate positions. Goods wagons on the adjoining siding are stenciled with the names of a cotton-exporting firm. The station building carries the company's name in English only.

Document 5

Source: the Charter Oath issued in the name of the Meiji Emperor, Japan, 1868; early English translation.

Knowledge shall be sought throughout the world so as to strengthen the foundations of imperial rule.

Document 6

Description of: the surviving records and buildings of a Lancashire cotton mill, 1830s–1890s.

Material evidence: described

The mill is a multi-story structure with a boiler house and chimney, built beside a canal and later served by a rail siding. Bale marks preserved in the warehouse records trace raw cotton first to the American South, then, from the 1860s, in rising proportion to western India and Egypt. Shipping ledgers list finished cloth consigned to Calcutta, Bombay, Lagos, and Shanghai. Wage books record a workforce in which women and children outnumber adult men, and machinery inventories show power looms replacing handloom contracts over two decades.

Document 7

Source: Dadabhai Naoroji, Indian economist and member of the British Parliament, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, 1901.

The bleeding of India is going on. … Materially, the British rule has caused the greatest destruction of property and of industry in the world.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: before industrialization the flow ran the other way. Europeans wanted Indian textiles, Chinese porcelain, tea, and spices, and had little Asia wanted in return, so they paid in American silver. Establishing that pattern is what makes the reversal measurable.
  • Grouping rather than narrating. One arrangement: Docs 2 and 6 on the mechanism of reversal in production and trade; Docs 1 and 3 on the use of force where commerce alone did not suffice; Docs 4, 5, and 7 on the varied responses; infrastructure built for extraction, deliberate adoption, and analytical critique.
  • Evidence beyond the documents, described rather than named: the Manila galleon and the earlier silver flow; the opium triangle and the balance-of-payments problem it solved for Britain; Japan's state-funded arsenals, railways, and student missions abroad; Egypt under Muhammad Ali and its cotton monoculture; the rise of Bombay's own mill industry late in the century.
  • Sourcing that explains why the feature matters. Doc 4's photograph was commissioned by the railway company, which explains who stands in front of the engine and who stands to the side; its purpose is to present the line as an achievement, and the stenciled cotton-firm wagons reveal what the line was for. Doc 7's author sat in the British Parliament and wrote for a British readership, framing his argument as a claim that British rule was un-British: a choice of audience that shapes the whole book. Doc 1's author was addressing a sovereign he could not compel, so he argued from her own law.
  • A complexity path: argue that the change was a reversal of direction rather than the creation of connection, the same regions were trading, but the terms and the direction of manufacture inverted. Or weigh Japan against India and China: the same pressure produced subordination in one case and a competing industrial power in another, which means industrialization did not determine outcomes by itself.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context For three centuries before industrialization, the trade between Europe and Asia ran on a simple asymmetry: Europeans wanted Indian cloth, Chinese porcelain, and tea, and Asia wanted almost nothing Europe made, so Europeans paid in silver mined in the Americas. Thesis Industrialization did not create the connection between these regions; it inverted it. By 1900 the industrial states manufactured and the rest of the world supplied raw materials and bought finished goods, and where this inversion could not be achieved by price it was achieved by force. But the inversion was not automatic, and Japan's trajectory shows that it followed from political capacity rather than from the technology itself.

Doc evidence Docs 2 and 6 show the mechanism. Doc 2 records Indian handloom cloth exported to Europe falling to nothing by the 1850s while British machine-made cloth came to dominate the Indian market and raw cotton flowed the other way, and it records the tariff schedule that helped it happen, with Indian cloth entering Britain taxed more heavily than British cloth entering India. Doc 6 shows the same reversal from the other end: bale marks shifting from the American South to western India and Egypt, finished cloth consigned to Calcutta, Bombay, Lagos, and Shanghai. One mill's warehouse records describe a world economy reorganized so that raw material moves in and manufactures move out. Outside evidence The same pressure remade Egypt, where Muhammad Ali's successors turned the Nile valley over to cotton for European mills, leaving the country dependent on a single crop whose price was set elsewhere.

Doc evidence Where the market did not deliver the reversal, force did. Doc 1 shows Lin Zexu arguing that Britain could not forbid opium at home and profit from selling it abroad. Sourcing He was addressing a sovereign he had no power to compel, which is why the letter argues from British law and conscience rather than from threat; the choice of argument measures the imbalance he was facing. Doc 3 records the answer: an indemnity, five open ports, a tariff schedule China could not alter without British consent, and extraterritoriality for British subjects. The provision that any privilege granted to another power extends automatically to Britain turned every future concession into a general one. Outside evidence The underlying problem was British: tea purchases drained silver until opium grown in Bengal reversed the flow, so the war was fought to protect a solution to a balance-of-payments problem.

Doc evidence Doc 4 shows what the new relationship built. Sourcing The photograph was commissioned by the railway company to mark an achievement, and its composition is therefore evidence about how the company saw the enterprise: British officials and directors occupy the platform in front of the locomotive, Indian workmen and local dignitaries stand to the side, and the station name appears in English only. The goods wagons stenciled with a cotton-exporting firm's name say plainly what the line was for. Railways were real infrastructure that Indians used, but this one was laid to move raw cotton to a port.

Doc evidence Docs 5 and 7 show two responses. Doc 5's Charter Oath proposes seeking knowledge throughout the world in order to strengthen imperial rule: a program of borrowing for the sake of independence rather than of imitation. Outside evidence Japan followed it with state-funded arsenals, shipyards, and railways, students sent abroad, and foreign experts hired on term contracts and then dismissed, and within thirty years it had defeated China in war, and within forty, Russia. Doc 7 takes the opposite case. Sourcing Naoroji wrote as a member of the British Parliament addressing a British readership, and framing his charge as a claim that British rule was un-British is a deliberate rhetorical choice aimed at that audience; the argument works by holding the empire to a standard it claimed for itself.

Complexity The comparison between Japan and India is what prevents the simple version of this argument. Both faced industrialized powers with superior weapons; Japan was forced into unequal treaties in 1854 and 1858, and India had already been brought under company and then Crown rule. But Japan had a government that had just overthrown the old order and could abolish the domains, conscript an army, and direct capital into industry, while India was governed by the power whose mills stood to benefit from its deindustrialization, and Doc 2's tariff column shows that government choosing accordingly. Industrialization therefore did not by itself determine who ended up manufacturing and who ended up supplying; it made an enormous difference in capability, and political control over economic policy decided how that capability was used. The evidence for this is that India did eventually industrialize, with Bombay mills competing in Asian markets by the century's end, once Indian capital found a way around the constraints, and that the reversal Doc 2 records was never as complete as the deindustrialization thesis suggests.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims industrialization inverted an existing relationship rather than creating one, adds that force substituted for price where necessary, and flags Japan as the qualification. Defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening establishes the pre-industrial pattern of European silver paying for Asian goods, which is what makes the reversal measurable. Several sentences, not a phrase.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): All seven documents are used for their content and grouped by function, 2 and 6 on mechanism, 1 and 3 on force, 4 on infrastructure, 5 and 7 on divergent responses.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Several pieces appear and are described: Egyptian cotton monoculture, the opium triangle as a solution to Britain's silver drain, and Japan's arsenals, student missions, and contract foreign experts.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Doc 4's commissioning company explaining its composition, Doc 7's author and British audience explaining his framing, and Doc 1's situation as an argument to a sovereign who could not be compelled.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph holds two comparable cases against each other, identifies political control over economic policy as the variable the documents reveal, and qualifies the deindustrialization thesis with the late-century growth of Bombay's mills. Sustained rather than asserted.

DBQ 4 · Units 6–7 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which movements in Asia and Africa between 1850 and 1945 sought to adopt rather than reject the institutions and technologies of the imperial powers.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how far these movements pursued adoption as against rejection, with a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the industrial and military gap that opened in the nineteenth century, or the earlier relationships these states had with Europe. Use the content of at least four documents, bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents, and for at least two documents explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience matters. Demonstrate complexity by qualifying your claim, weighing cases against one another, or explaining evidence that complicates a simple adoption-versus-rejection division.

Document 1

Description of: the Ottoman reform edict of 1856, issued during the Tanzimat period.

The edict confirms equality before the law for all subjects regardless of religion, abolishes distinctions in eligibility for state employment and military service, provides for mixed civil and criminal courts, promises a regular system of taxation to replace tax farming, and announces the establishment of banks and public works on European models. It frames these measures as the fulfillment of the sultan's traditional duty to his subjects and was issued at the close of the Crimean War, in which the empire had fought alongside Britain and France.

Document 2

Description of: a summary table of railway mileage, telegraph lines, and state arsenals, 1870–1914, compiled from official returns for Japan, the Ottoman Empire, Egypt, China, and British India.

Quantitative: described

Japan's figures begin near zero in 1870 and rise steeply in all three categories, with arsenals and shipyards listed as state-owned. India shows the largest absolute railway mileage but only two listed arsenals, and a footnote records that the network was financed by guaranteed returns to British investors. Ottoman and Egyptian mileage rises substantially, with a column recording the foreign ownership of most lines and a note on the debt administrations established in both states. China's figures remain low throughout the period.

Document 3

Source: a photograph of a Japanese government mission to Europe and the United States, taken in the early 1870s.

Image: described

Five officials pose in a studio. Four wear European frock coats, trousers, and leather shoes, with watch chains and short cut hair; the fifth, seated at the center, wears traditional Japanese dress with a sword and his hair in the older style. The furniture and painted backdrop are those of a Western commercial photographer's studio. The mission's published itinerary lists visits to factories, naval yards, parliaments, schools, and prisons.

Document 4

Description of: proclamations circulated by the Boxer movement in northern China, 1899–1900.

The texts call for the expulsion of foreigners and of foreign religion, blame drought and hardship on the offense given to local gods by churches, railways, and telegraph lines, and promise their followers protection from bullets through spirit possession and training. They call for the restoration of proper relations between heaven and earth and urge support for the ruling dynasty against the outsiders. Several texts name railway embankments and telegraph poles specifically as objects to be destroyed.

Document 5

Source: M. K. Gandhi, Hind Swaraj, written 1909, English version published 1910.

It is machinery that has impoverished India. … Machinery is the chief symbol of modern civilization; it represents a great sin.

Document 6

Description of: the material remains and production records of a state arsenal established in East Asia in the 1880s.

Material evidence: described

Brick workshops arranged around a central power house, with imported machine tools bearing European and American maker's plates still bolted to their beds. Production ledgers record rifles assembled from imported components in the earliest years, then from locally forged barrels, and finally to a locally designed pattern within two decades. A separate building housed a technical school; its registers list foreign instructors employed on fixed-term contracts, with the contracts ending as local graduates take over the same posts.

Document 7

Description of: the founding proceedings and early resolutions of a nationalist political association in a British colony, 1880s–1900s.

The association meets annually, conducts its business in English, and is composed largely of lawyers, journalists, and graduates of colleges founded under colonial rule. Its early resolutions request expanded representation on legislative councils, the holding of civil service examinations in the colony as well as in Britain, reductions in military expenditure, and inquiry into the causes of rural poverty. The resolutions repeatedly invoke the rights of British subjects and the principles of British constitutional government.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the industrial and military gap that opened after 1800 (steamships, quinine, repeating rifles, the telegraph), and the unequal treaties and debt administrations that followed. This is what made the question of adoption urgent rather than abstract.
  • Grouping rather than narrating. One arrangement: Docs 1, 3, and 6 on deliberate and systematic adoption; Docs 4 and 5 on rejection, from very different premises; Docs 2 and 7 on why adoption produced such different results depending on who controlled it.
  • Evidence beyond the documents, described rather than named: the Qing Self-Strengthening Movement and its defeat in 1895; Muhammad Ali's industrialization in Egypt and the debt administration that followed; the Ottoman constitution of 1876 and its suspension; the Meiji abolition of the domains and conscription; Ethiopian acquisition of modern rifles before Adwa.
  • Sourcing that explains why the feature matters. Doc 3 is a studio photograph made for circulation, so the mixture of dress is a composed statement about continuity within change rather than a candid record. Doc 5's author wrote in 1909 for Indian readers he wished to dissuade from armed struggle and from simple imitation, which explains the extremity of the formulation. Doc 7's proceedings are the record of an association that needed to remain legal under colonial rule, which shapes what its resolutions could ask for.
  • A complexity path: argue that adoption versus rejection is the wrong axis; Doc 4 and Doc 5 reject on entirely different grounds, and Doc 6's arsenal adopted technology precisely in order to resist. Or argue that the decisive variable was not attitude but control: Doc 2 shows that railways built by a sovereign state and railways built by foreign investors produced opposite consequences for the states that hosted them.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context By the middle of the nineteenth century the gap in military and industrial capability between the industrialized states and everyone else had become impossible to ignore. Quinine, steam gunboats, repeating rifles, and the telegraph made conquest cheap, and unequal treaties, indemnities, and foreign debt administrations followed defeat. Thesis Movements across Asia and Africa overwhelmingly sought to adopt industrial technology and administrative institutions, but almost always in order to resist rather than to imitate, and the outcomes varied less with the enthusiasm for adoption than with whether the adopting society controlled the terms. Outright rejection was rarer than it appears and rested on premises so different from one another that treating rejection as a single position obscures what was actually at stake.

Doc evidence Docs 1, 3, and 6 show adoption pursued deliberately and at the level of the state. The Ottoman edict of 1856 promises equality before the law, mixed courts, regular taxation in place of tax farming, and banks and public works on European models: a wholesale institutional program. Doc 6 shows the same logic in material form: a state arsenal with imported machine tools, ledgers recording rifles first assembled from imported parts, then from locally forged barrels, then to a locally designed pattern within twenty years, and a technical school whose foreign instructors' contracts end as local graduates replace them. That progression is the whole strategy in miniature: borrow, learn, dispense with the lender. Outside evidence Japan's Meiji government did the same across the state, abolishing the domains, conscripting an army, and hiring foreign experts on term contracts, and within thirty years it had defeated China, and within forty, Russia.

Doc evidence Doc 3 shows how that program was presented. Sourcing This is a studio photograph made for circulation, not a candid image: four officials in frock coats and cut hair, one seated at the center in traditional dress with a sword, against a Western photographer's backdrop. The composition is an argument, that adopting foreign methods is compatible with remaining what one is, and the published itinerary of factories, naval yards, parliaments, schools, and prisons shows that the mission understood institutions and technology as a single package to be studied together.

Doc evidence Docs 4 and 5 are usually grouped as rejection, but they reject on incompatible grounds. The Boxer proclamations blame drought on the offense given to local gods by churches, railways, and telegraph lines, and name embankments and telegraph poles as objects for destruction; the framework is religious and restorationist, and the aim is to expel foreigners and restore proper relations between heaven and earth. Sourcing Doc 5's rejection comes from a very different place. Gandhi wrote in 1909 for Indian readers he wanted to turn away from both armed struggle and simple imitation of Britain, and the sweeping claim that machinery represents a great sin is calibrated for that persuasive purpose: it is a moral argument about what independence should be for, made by a man who used railways, printing presses, and English-language journalism throughout his career. Grouping these two as one position would miss that one is defending an existing cosmology and the other is proposing a new political ethic.

Doc evidence Docs 2 and 7 show why adoption produced such different results. Doc 2 records India with the largest railway mileage in the table but only two arsenals, financed by guaranteed returns to British investors; Ottoman and Egyptian lines largely foreign-owned, with debt administrations attached; Japan's arsenals and shipyards state-owned and its figures rising in every category. Railways were built in all these places, and they meant entirely different things. Doc 7 shows the same pattern in the institutional register. Sourcing The association conducts business in English, consists of lawyers and graduates of colonial colleges, and frames its demands as the rights of British subjects, but it had to remain legal under colonial rule, so the moderation of the early resolutions is evidence about the constraints on political action as much as about what its members believed. Outside evidence The Qing Self-Strengthening Movement makes the contrast sharpest: it built arsenals and shipyards and bought modern warships, yet without the central control over revenue and policy that Japan had acquired, and in 1895 the fleet it built was destroyed by the one Japan had.

Complexity The adoption-versus-rejection axis therefore distorts the period. Nearly everyone in these documents wanted the capability; the real disagreement was over what it was for and who would own it. Doc 6's arsenal adopted foreign machine tools in order to stop needing them, which is rejection carried out by means of adoption. Doc 2 shows two countries with extensive railways in opposite positions, because one owned its lines and the other hosted lines owned by its creditors. Even Doc 5, the sharpest rejection in the set, is an argument about ends rather than means, and its author went on to build a mass movement using precisely the communications and legal training the colonial order had made available. The variable that predicts outcomes is not attitude toward foreign methods but sovereignty over the decision, which is why the Ottoman reforms of Doc 1, comprehensive on paper, coincided with a slide into foreign debt administration, while an arsenal in a state that could set its own tariffs produced a rifle of its own design in twenty years.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims that adoption predominated but was undertaken in order to resist, that outcomes turned on control rather than enthusiasm, and that rejection was not a single position. Defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the capability gap and the treaties and debt administrations that followed defeat, establishing why adoption became urgent. Several sentences of relevant context.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): All seven documents are used for their content and grouped by function, 1, 3, and 6 on systematic adoption, 4 and 5 on incompatible forms of rejection, 2 and 7 on why control determined outcomes.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Several pieces appear and are described: the Meiji abolition of the domains and conscription, and the Qing Self-Strengthening Movement's fleet and its destruction in 1895.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Doc 3's nature as a composed studio photograph for circulation, Doc 5's purpose and intended readership explaining the extremity of its formulation, and Doc 7's need to remain legal explaining the moderation of its resolutions.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph rejects the prompt's own axis with evidence, shows adoption and rejection collapsing into each other in Doc 6, and identifies sovereignty over the decision as the variable that actually predicts outcomes. Sustained across the paragraph.

DBQ 5 · Units 8–9 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which the Cold War shaped the process and outcomes of decolonization after 1945.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how much the Cold War shaped decolonization and in what respects, with a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the nationalist movements that predate 1945, or the effect of the world wars on the colonial powers. Use the content of at least four documents, bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents, and for at least two documents explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience matters. Demonstrate complexity by qualifying your claim, weighing causes against one another, or explaining evidence that cuts against your position.

Document 1

Source: Harry S. Truman, address to a joint session of the United States Congress, 12 March 1947.

I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.

Document 2

Description of: the final communiqué of the Asian–African Conference held at Bandung, Indonesia, 1955.

The communiqué declares colonialism in all its manifestations an evil to be brought to an end, affirms respect for the sovereignty and territorial integrity of all nations, and rejects arrangements of collective defense that serve the particular interests of great powers. It calls for economic and cultural cooperation among the participating states, for technical assistance without political conditions, and for the admission of newly independent states to the United Nations. Twenty-nine states attended, representing a majority of the world's population.

Document 3

Description of: a series of maps showing states achieving independence by decade, 1945–1975, with an accompanying table.

Quantitative: described

The 1940s map shades a small number of Asian states; the 1950s adds North Africa and the first sub-Saharan cases; the 1960s shades most of the African continent, with seventeen states in a single year; the 1970s adds the Portuguese territories. The table lists, for each state, the colonial power, the year, and a column headed "manner of transfer" with entries reading negotiated, armed conflict, or both. A final column records United Nations membership totals, rising from 51 to more than 140 across the period.

Document 4

Source: a photograph of the opening session of a conference of Asian and African states, mid-1950s.

Image: described

Delegates are seated at long tables in a hall hung with the flags of the participating states. Several wear Western suits, others national dress; the platform party stands beneath a banner in English and the host language. Photographers and newsreel cameras crowd the aisles at the front. No flags of the major Cold War powers appear anywhere in the hall.

Document 5

Description of: a table of foreign economic and military assistance to newly independent African and Asian states, 1955–1975, compiled from donor government records.

Quantitative: described

Columns give recipient, donor, year, amount, and category. Several states appear with substantial assistance from both superpowers in overlapping years. Military assistance rises sharply in states experiencing internal armed conflict, and in three cases the donor changes after a change of government. A note records that comparable figures for covert assistance are not available. Economic aid is concentrated in large infrastructure projects, several of which appear in the records of both donors as competing offers for the same scheme.

Document 6

Description of: a French government white paper on the conflict in Algeria, late 1950s.

The paper describes the territory as an integral part of France rather than a colony, cites the size of the European settler population and the length of French administration, and characterizes the insurgency as the work of an armed minority supported from outside. It argues that withdrawal would open North Africa and the Mediterranean to hostile influence and would break faith with those who had served France, and it details programs of rural development and schooling to be undertaken alongside military operations.

Document 7

Description of: the public statements and early policy record of the first government of a newly independent West African state, 1957–1960.

The leadership declares that independence is meaningless unless linked to the liberation of the whole continent, announces a policy of non-alignment between the power blocs, and seeks development assistance from western governments, the Soviet Union, and the Commonwealth simultaneously. Early projects include a large hydroelectric and aluminum scheme financed through a combination of western public and private capital. The government also invests heavily in education and in support for independence movements in neighboring territories.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: nationalist movements predate the Cold War by decades (the Indian National Congress from 1885, Vietnamese and Indonesian organizations from the interwar years), and the world wars exhausted the colonial powers and exposed the gap between Allied war aims and colonial rule. The Cold War arrived into a process already under way.
  • Grouping rather than narrating. One arrangement: Docs 1, 5, and 6 on how superpower rivalry entered and reshaped particular conflicts; Docs 2, 4, and 7 on the attempt by new states to refuse that framing and use it; Doc 3 on the timing and scale of the whole process.
  • Evidence beyond the documents, described rather than named: Indian independence and partition in 1947, before the Cold War had hardened; the Vietnamese wars against France and then the United States; the Congo crisis; Suez in 1956 as a demonstration that the old imperial powers could no longer act independently; Portuguese wars into the 1970s.
  • Sourcing that explains why the feature matters. Doc 1's audience is the American Congress being asked for money, which explains its universal framing; the language names no country and set no limit, and that is what made it portable. Doc 6 is a government white paper produced to justify a war to domestic and allied opinion, so its description of the insurgency as an armed minority supported from outside is a claim in Cold War terms made for a Cold War audience. Doc 4's photograph records a hall in which no superpower flag appears: a deliberate absence staged for the cameras crowding the aisles.
  • A complexity path: argue that the Cold War changed how decolonization happened without determining whether it happened; Doc 3's chronology tracks the exhaustion of the colonial powers more closely than it tracks superpower rivalry. Or argue that new states were not passive: Docs 2 and 7 show leaders using the rivalry as leverage, which means the Cold War was a resource as well as a constraint.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Decolonization was under way before the Cold War began. The Indian National Congress had organized since 1885, Vietnamese and Indonesian nationalist movements dated from the interwar decades, and the two world wars had both exhausted the colonial powers and exposed the contradiction between fighting for self-determination in Europe and denying it in Asia and Africa. Thesis The Cold War therefore did not cause decolonization; it shaped its conduct, its cost, and its aftermath decisively, turning some independence struggles into proxy wars and giving new states a bargaining position they would not otherwise have had. New leaders were not merely acted upon by the rivalry, several of them worked it deliberately, but the price of that leverage was that internal political disputes became superpower business.

Doc evidence Doc 1 shows the framework being built. Truman's commitment to support free peoples resisting subjugation by armed minorities or outside pressures names no country and sets no geographical limit. Sourcing He was addressing a Congress he needed to vote money, which explains the universal framing: a specific request for Greece and Turkey would have been harder to sell than a principle. But a principle with no limits is portable, and within a decade it was being applied to conflicts that had begun as anti-colonial wars. Outside evidence Vietnam is the clearest case: a movement that had fought the Japanese and then the French for independence was reclassified as a front in the global contest, and the United States took over financing a colonial war it had earlier criticized.

Doc evidence Doc 6 shows a colonial power adopting that vocabulary for its own purposes. Sourcing The white paper was produced to justify the Algerian war to French and allied opinion, and its characterization of the insurgency as an armed minority supported from outside is precisely Truman's formula, borrowed by a government whose actual problem was a settler population and a century of administration it could not abandon. Describing Algeria as an integral part of France rather than a colony was the same move in constitutional form. Doc 5 shows what the framework produced in practice: states receiving substantial assistance from both superpowers in overlapping years, military aid rising sharply where there was internal armed conflict, donors changing after changes of government, and competing offers for the same infrastructure schemes. Independence movements' internal disagreements acquired external sponsors.

Doc evidence Docs 2, 4, and 7 show the attempt to refuse that framing. The Bandung communiqué condemns colonialism in all its manifestations and rejects collective defense arrangements serving great-power interests: a rejection of both blocs in one sentence. Sourcing Doc 4's photograph records how deliberately this was staged: delegates beneath the flags of the participating states, newsreel cameras crowding the aisles, and no superpower flag anywhere in the hall. The absence is the message, and it was arranged for the cameras. Doc 7 shows non-alignment as practice rather than declaration: a government seeking assistance from western states, the Soviet Union, and the Commonwealth simultaneously, financing a hydroelectric and aluminum scheme through western public and private capital while supporting independence movements elsewhere. That is not neutrality; it is the systematic use of competition to obtain terms neither side would have offered alone.

Doc evidence Doc 3 supplies the check on all of this. The chronology shows a trickle in the 1940s, North Africa and the first sub-Saharan cases in the 1950s, most of the African continent in the 1960s with seventeen states in a single year, and the Portuguese territories in the 1970s. Outside evidence That sequence tracks the capacity of the colonial powers more closely than it tracks the intensity of superpower rivalry: India became independent in 1947 before the Cold War had hardened, Suez in 1956 demonstrated that Britain and France could no longer act without American consent, and Portugal held on longest because a dictatorship insulated from electoral pressure could absorb costs that democracies could not.

Complexity The most defensible position is therefore that the Cold War determined the form and the cost of decolonization rather than its occurrence, and that its effects ran in both directions. It made some wars far longer and deadlier than they needed to be, because a local conflict with external sponsors on both sides need never run out of weapons; Doc 5's military assistance column and Doc 6's use of Truman's vocabulary both document that. But Doc 7 shows the same rivalry functioning as leverage for states with almost no other source of it, and Doc 3's final column, United Nations membership rising from 51 to more than 140, records a shift in the composition of international institutions that gave the new states a collective voice in forums the superpowers had built for their own purposes. The cost of that leverage was high and fell unevenly: where a country's internal divisions mapped onto the global contest, as in the Congo, external sponsorship turned a political dispute into a war. Whether the Cold War helped or harmed a given new state depended less on which side it chose than on whether its own politics could be forced into the shape the contest required.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction distinguishes cause from conduct, claims the Cold War shaped the process decisively without producing it, and identifies new states as active users of the rivalry. Defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening establishes nationalist organization from the 1880s and the effect of the world wars, which is what makes the Cold War's role a question of degree. Several sentences of relevant context.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): All seven documents are used for their content and grouped by function, 1, 5, and 6 on the framework and its effects, 2, 4, and 7 on the attempt to refuse and exploit it, 3 on chronology as a check.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Several pieces appear and are described: American financing of the French war in Vietnam, Indian independence in 1947, Suez in 1956, and Portugal's insulation from electoral pressure.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Doc 1's audience explaining its unlimited framing, Doc 6's purpose as a justification borrowing that framing, and Doc 4's staged absence of superpower flags before assembled newsreel cameras.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph holds the two directions of effect against each other, uses Doc 3's membership figures as evidence for the second, and closes with a conditional claim about which states were harmed and why. Sustained rather than asserted.

LEQ 1 · Units 1–2 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which the Mongol Empire changed patterns of exchange across Eurasia in the period c. 1200 to c. 1450.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how much changed. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning (causation, comparison, or continuity and change) to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple variables, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the Silk Roads existed for well over a millennium before the Mongols, and the Indian Ocean network carried far greater tonnage throughout. Establishing that exchange was already ancient turns the question into one about intensity and terms rather than invention.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: the yam relay system of post stations; the protection of merchants and the reduction of tolls along a single-authority route; deliberate deportation of artisans and transfer of specialists; Persian astronomers to China, Chinese engineers to Persia; the westward diffusion of gunpowder, printing, and the compass; paper money in Yuan China; Marco Polo and Ibn Battuta as evidence that long journeys had become practical; the plague reaching the Black Sea in 1347.
  • Reasoning: causation is the natural structure, with the Mongol conquests as the cause and increased volume, technological transfer, and disease as effects. Continuity and change also works: the routes were old, the conditions on them were new, and after the khanates fragmented the overland route declined again.
  • Complexity: qualify by noting that the same policy produced both the destruction of cities and the security of routes, and that these were not separate phases but two sides of one approach. Or note that the Indian Ocean carried more goods than the Silk Roads throughout, so an account centered on the overland route overstates the Mongol contribution to Eurasian exchange as a whole.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context Goods had moved across Eurasia for well over a thousand years before Chinggis Khan. Silk reached Rome, Buddhism traveled from India into Central Asia and China, and the Indian Ocean carried far greater tonnage on the monsoon than any overland caravan could manage. Thesis The Mongols therefore did not open Eurasian exchange; they altered its conditions so sharply that volume, speed, and the kinds of things that traveled all changed within a generation. That transformation was real but temporary and double-edged: it rested on a political unity that lasted less than a century, and the same policy that secured the roads destroyed the cities along them.

Evidence The mechanism was the reduction of transaction costs. A caravan crossing Central Asia before 1200 passed through many jurisdictions, each charging tolls and none responsible for its safety. Under a single authority the tolls collapsed and the Mongols actively protected merchants, whom they valued and taxed. The yam relay system of post stations, with fresh horses and supplies at fixed intervals, moved officials and messages at speeds no previous overland power had achieved. Paper currency in Yuan China, accepted across the empire on the Khan's authority alone, removed the need to carry metal over thousands of kilometers.

Evidence The consequence was not only more goods but different cargo. The Mongols deliberately moved people: artisans were spared from destroyed cities and deported east, Persian astronomers worked at the Chinese court, and Chinese siege engineers served in the campaigns in Persia. Gunpowder, printing, and the compass moved west in this period, and within two centuries gunpowder weapons would reshape state formation from the Atlantic to the Bay of Bengal. That a Venetian merchant could spend years in China and a Moroccan legal scholar could hold judicial office in Delhi is itself evidence of the change: such journeys had been possible before, but they had not been ordinary.

Reasoning The causal argument holds in reverse as well, which is the strongest test of it. When the khanates fragmented in the fourteenth century and the unified authority disappeared, overland volume fell and the route never recovered its earlier importance. The conditions, not the geography, had been doing the work. That is also why the maritime route to Asia became so attractive to Europeans in the following century: the overland alternative had become expensive and uncertain again.

Complexity The qualification that matters most is that the destruction and the facilitation were the same policy rather than sequential phases. Cities that resisted were destroyed as a demonstration, artisans were extracted from them, and the routes between them were then protected because protected routes produced revenue. Persian irrigation systems broken during the conquests took generations to rebuild, and the populations that maintained them were gone. Beyond that, an account of Eurasian exchange centered on the Mongols overstates their share of it. The Indian Ocean carried more goods than the Silk Roads throughout this period, and the Mongols never controlled it; Swahili, Gujarati, and Chinese merchants sustained that network entirely independently. The clearest measure of the Mongol contribution is also the least intended one: the plague that reached the Black Sea in 1347 traveled the routes they had secured, and it killed a larger share of the populations at both ends of Eurasia than any policy of theirs achieved deliberately.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims the Mongols altered conditions rather than opening exchange, and specifies that the change was real, temporary, and double-edged. Defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening establishes exchange long predating 1200 by land and sea, which frames the question as one of degree.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence is supplied and explained (tolls and protection, the yam, paper money, deported artisans, Persian astronomers and Chinese engineers, the westward movement of gunpowder and printing) with each tied to the claim rather than listed.
  • Reasoning (1): The argument is causal and is tested against the reverse case: when the unifying authority disappeared, volume fell, which shows the conditions rather than the geography were responsible.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph shows destruction and facilitation as one policy, limits the claim by pointing to an Indian Ocean network the Mongols never touched, and closes with the plague as the largest and least intended consequence.

LEQ 2 · Units 3–4 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which land-based and maritime empires used similar methods to govern conquered peoples in the period c. 1450 to c. 1750.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how similar these methods were. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning, comparison is the natural choice here, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple variables, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the problem all these states faced; ruling populations larger and more diverse than any premodern administration could supervise directly, with communications limited to the speed of a horse or a ship. Or the gunpowder revolution that made the conquests possible in the first place.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: the Ottoman millet system and devshirme; Mughal accommodation under Akbar and its reversal under Aurangzeb; Qing retention of the civil service examinations alongside the queue edict; Russian incorporation of Siberian peoples through tribute in furs; the Spanish encomienda, the colonial mit'a, and the casta system; Portuguese fortified ports and the cartaz pass system in the Indian Ocean; Dutch and English company charters delegating sovereign powers.
  • Reasoning: comparison, organized by method rather than by empire (legitimation, use of existing elites, religious policy, revenue extraction), so that similarities and differences emerge from the categories rather than from a list of empires in sequence.
  • Complexity: qualify by noting that the crucial variable was not land versus sea but whether the conquering power had to live with the conquered population. Where disease destroyed the existing society, as in the Americas, methods diverged sharply from anywhere that did not happen. Or note that maritime empires in Asia behaved much more like tributary states than like their own American possessions.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context Every empire in this period faced the same structural problem: it had conquered more people than it could possibly supervise, across distances measured in weeks or months of travel, using administrations of a few thousand men. Gunpowder weapons had made the conquests possible; nothing had made the governing easier. Thesis Land-based and maritime empires converged on strikingly similar solutions (rule through existing local elites, revenue farmed out to intermediaries, and legitimacy asserted through visible religious and architectural claims), because those solutions followed from the shared constraint. They diverged most sharply where the conquered population itself did not survive, which makes the decisive variable demographic rather than geographic.

Evidence The most common method was to govern through people already in place. The Ottomans recognized religious communities and held their own leaders responsible for taxes and order under the millet arrangement. The Mughals under Akbar appointed Hindu Rajputs to senior military commands and left zamindars to collect revenue in the countryside. The Qing, a Manchu minority ruling an enormous Han population, retained the civil service examinations and appointed Chinese scholars alongside Manchu bannermen. The Spanish did the same where they could, ruling through surviving indigenous nobility and keeping the Inca rotational labor obligation in operation for the mines at Potosí under its own name. In every case the conquerors used a structure they had not built because they could not have built one fast enough.

Evidence Revenue arrangements converged for the same reason. Tax farming, selling the right to collect in a district to a private party who paid in advance, appears in Ottoman and Mughal practice because neither state could afford a salaried collection service across its territory. The joint-stock companies chartered by the Dutch and English are the maritime version of the same logic: a state that lacked the capital and administration to run an Asian trading empire delegated sovereign powers, including war and treaty-making, to shareholders who would finance it themselves.

Reasoning Legitimation converged as well, and the comparison is sharpest here. Ottoman sultans built the Süleymaniye complex, Safavid shahs rebuilt Isfahan's royal square, Mughal emperors raised the Taj Mahal, and Qing emperors occupied the Forbidden City: each translating a claim about the ruler into stone that subjects encountered daily. The Spanish did the identical thing in the Americas, building cathedrals on the foundations of demolished temples in Mexico City and Cuzco, which states the succession of authority as plainly as any edict.

Complexity The divergence, where it appears, does not track the land and sea distinction the prompt suggests. Portuguese and Dutch conduct in the Indian Ocean resembled a tributary arrangement more than a colonial one: they seized ports, sold passes to shipping, and taxed a trade network they could not replace, because Mughal and Ottoman power and healthy local populations set limits they could not cross. What made Spanish America different was not that Spain arrived by sea but that epidemic disease destroyed the societies through which Spain would otherwise have ruled. Once indigenous populations fell by something approaching ninety percent, there were no intermediary elites left to work through, and the Spanish built something without parallel in the land-based empires: a legally ranked racial hierarchy sorting people by descent, and a plantation and mining economy supplied by people transported across an ocean as property. That system had to be created precisely because the ordinary method, rule through the people already there, had ceased to be available.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims convergence driven by a shared constraint and identifies demography rather than geography as the source of divergence. Defensible claim with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the common administrative problem and the gunpowder conquests that produced it.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence across both categories of empire (millet, Rajput commands, zamindars, Qing examinations, the colonial mit'a, tax farming, company charters, and four building programs) each tied to the argument.
  • Reasoning (1): The essay is organized by method rather than by empire, so the comparison is sustained throughout rather than assembled at the end.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph shows the prompt's own category failing, uses the Indian Ocean case to demonstrate maritime empires behaving like tributary states, and explains Spanish America as the consequence of demographic collapse rather than of maritime conquest.

LEQ 3 · Unit 5 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which the Atlantic revolutions transformed social hierarchies in the period c. 1750 to c. 1900.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how much changed. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning (causation, comparison, or continuity and change) to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple variables, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the hierarchies these revolutions inherited; legal orders of nobility, clergy, and commoners in France; the casta system in Spanish America; chattel slavery throughout the Atlantic world; the exclusion of women from political life everywhere.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: the abolition of noble privilege and the Declaration of the Rights of Man in France; the Haitian Revolution and the abolition of slavery there; the French abolition of 1794, Napoleon's attempted restoration in 1802, and final abolition in 1848; creole leadership and the survival of racial hierarchy in the new Latin American republics; slavery preserved in the United States for nearly ninety years after independence; Olympe de Gouges and Mary Wollstonecraft; property qualifications on voting throughout the nineteenth century.
  • Reasoning: continuity and change is the natural structure; legal categories abolished rapidly while economic and racial hierarchies persisted. Comparison across Haiti, France, the United States, and Spanish America also works well.
  • Complexity: qualify by distinguishing between legal status and actual social position, since the revolutions transformed the first far more than the second. Or note that Haiti is the exception that reveals the rule: it was the one revolution where the people at the bottom of the hierarchy made the revolution themselves, and it was the one the others refused to recognize.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context The Atlantic world of 1750 was organized by legal categories of birth. France divided its population into three estates with different rights and tax obligations. Spanish America sorted people by descent into ranked castas that determined taxation, office, and standing at law. Slavery was legal throughout the Americas, and women were excluded from formal political life everywhere. Thesis The revolutions of this period dismantled the legal architecture of that order with remarkable speed and left most of the underlying hierarchy standing. They replaced inherited legal rank with formal equality among a restricted category of men, and the gap between the universal language they used and the narrow application they permitted became the most productive contradiction of the following century.

Evidence The legal transformation was genuine and fast. The French National Assembly abolished noble privilege in a single night in August 1789 and issued a declaration asserting that men are born free and equal in rights. Spanish American independence removed the peninsular officials who had sat at the top of the casta hierarchy, and the new republics wrote constitutions declaring citizens equal before the law. These were not empty gestures: the legal order that had assigned rights by birth did not return, and no nineteenth-century state successfully restored a formal estate system.

Evidence But the application was narrow and deliberately so. The French declaration's universal language coexisted with slavery in Saint-Domingue, the most profitable colony in the Atlantic, and the National Convention abolished it in 1794 only after the enslaved population had already risen and made the old order unworkable; Napoleon attempted to restore it in 1802, and final abolition came only in 1848. The United States declared that all men are created equal and preserved slavery for eighty-nine years after. The Latin American republics were led by creoles who replaced Spanish officials and kept the social hierarchy beneath them substantially intact, and indigenous communities in particular gained little. Women were excluded throughout; Olympe de Gouges published a declaration of the rights of woman in 1791 and was executed two years later.

Reasoning The pattern is therefore one of rapid change in legal categories alongside strong continuity in economic and racial hierarchy, which is also why the revolutions kept generating further movements. Abolitionists, suffragists, and labor organizers throughout the nineteenth century did not have to invent new principles; they argued that the principles already proclaimed had not been applied. The declarations turned out to be more dangerous to the order that produced them than their authors intended.

Complexity Haiti is the case that clarifies all of this. It was the one Atlantic revolution made by the people at the very bottom of the hierarchy rather than by an elite claiming to speak for the nation, and it is the one that actually destroyed the social order it overthrew: slavery abolished, the plantation elite eliminated, and an independent Black republic established. The response measures how much the others had really changed. France demanded an indemnity for lost property that Haiti paid for over a century, the United States withheld recognition for nearly six decades, and the slaveholding powers treated the example as a threat to be contained. The same governments that had proclaimed universal rights refused to accept the one revolution that took the proclamation literally, which suggests that what the Atlantic revolutions transformed most thoroughly was the language in which hierarchy had to be defended, and that this, over the following century, proved to matter more than it looked.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims rapid legal transformation alongside persistent underlying hierarchy and identifies the gap between language and application as the productive result. Defensible claim about extent.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the estate system, the casta hierarchy, slavery, and women's exclusion: the specific order the revolutions inherited.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence on both sides of the claim (the August 1789 abolition of privilege, the 1794 and 1848 abolitions with Napoleon's restoration between them, creole leadership in Latin America, eighty-nine years of American slavery, Olympe de Gouges) each explained rather than listed.
  • Reasoning (1): Continuity and change structures the essay, and the closing move identifies why the contradiction kept generating further movements.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph uses Haiti as a test case, measures the other revolutions by their response to it, and ends with a qualified claim about what actually changed.

LEQ 4 · Units 5–6 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which industrialization caused the expansion of European empires in the period c. 1750 to c. 1914.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how far industrialization explains imperial expansion. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning, causation is the natural choice, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple causes, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: European empires already existed in 1750 (the Americas, coastal trading posts in Asia and Africa), so the question concerns the change in character and pace after roughly 1870 rather than the origin of empire itself.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: quinine prophylaxis opening the African interior; steamships and river gunboats; the telegraph; breech-loading and repeating rifles and the machine gun; demand for rubber, palm oil, cotton, and tin; the Suez Canal and the strategic logic of routes to India; the Berlin Conference; Social Darwinism and the civilizing mission; Ethiopian victory at Adwa in 1896 as a limit case.
  • Reasoning: causation, distinguishing the causes that made expansion possible from those that made it attractive and those that made it urgent. This distinction is what produces a sophisticated argument rather than a list of factors.
  • Complexity: qualify by noting that industrialization explains capability far better than it explains motive, since several colonies never repaid their costs and expansion continued anyway. Or weigh economic against strategic and domestic political causes (Egypt was occupied for the canal, not for its exports), and note that Adwa shows the technological advantage was contingent rather than absolute.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context European empires were not new in 1750. Spain and Portugal had governed American territories for two centuries, and trading companies held fortified ports around the Indian Ocean. What changed after roughly 1870 was pace and depth: within four decades almost the whole African continent was partitioned, and European control in Asia moved from coastal enclaves to the administration of entire territories. Thesis Industrialization is the best single explanation for that change, but it operates unevenly across the different kinds of cause. It explains capability almost completely, motive only partly, and urgency hardly at all, and separating these is what the evidence requires.

Evidence Capability is where the industrial explanation is strongest. Before the 1850s the African interior was effectively closed to Europeans by malaria, which killed a large proportion of any expedition that attempted it. Regular quinine prophylaxis cut that mortality dramatically. Steam-powered river gunboats could travel inland against the current, carrying artillery to places no sailing vessel could reach. The telegraph let a government in London or Paris direct operations weeks closer to real time than before. And the gap in weapons widened enormously: breech-loading rifles, then repeating rifles, then the machine gun, against forces often armed with muskets or spears. Every one of these was a product of industrial manufacture, and together they made conquests possible that had not been possible a generation earlier.

Evidence Motive is a more mixed case. Industrial economies genuinely needed rubber for tires and insulation, palm oil for lubricants and soap, cotton for mills, and tin for canning, and colonial tariff arrangements gave metropolitan manufacturers markets competitors could not enter on equal terms. Britain's Indian market for machine-made cloth is the clearest example of the pattern working as intended. But many colonies never repaid what they cost to conquer and administer, and governments knew this at the time; expansion continued regardless, which means economic return cannot be the whole account.

Reasoning Urgency came from elsewhere. Much of the partition of Africa was driven by the fear that a rival would take a territory first, so that the value of a claim lay in denying it to someone else rather than in what it produced. Britain occupied Egypt in 1882 to secure the Suez Canal and the route to India, not for Egyptian exports. At home, newly enfranchised electorates and a cheap mass press made imperial success politically useful, and Social Darwinism supplied a language in which conquest could be described as the working out of a natural law rather than as a series of contested decisions. None of these causes is industrial in any direct sense, though industrial wealth is what paid for acting on them.

Complexity The strongest test of the industrial explanation is where it failed. In 1896 an Ethiopian army defeated an invading Italian force at Adwa, having acquired modern rifles and artillery beforehand by playing European rivals against one another. That single outcome shows the technological advantage was contingent rather than absolute: it depended on the asymmetry being maintained, and where a state could obtain the same weapons and mobilize an army to use them, the advantage evaporated. Japan makes the same point from the other direction, industrializing and then acquiring an empire of its own. The most defensible conclusion is therefore that industrialization was a necessary condition for the new imperialism and nowhere near a sufficient one. It determined who could expand, and how cheaply; strategic rivalry, domestic politics, and ideology determined whether they chose to.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction distinguishes capability, motive, and urgency and claims industrialization explains them to very different degrees. Defensible claim with a line of reasoning the body follows exactly.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening establishes that empires predate 1750 and specifies what changed after 1870, framing the question as one about pace and depth.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence throughout (quinine, river gunboats, the telegraph, the rifle and machine gun, rubber and palm oil, the Indian cloth market, Suez, the mass press) each explained rather than named.
  • Reasoning (1): The causal analysis is structured by type of cause, which is what allows the essay to say industrialization explains some things well and others poorly.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph tests the thesis against Adwa and against Japan, establishing the technological advantage as contingent, and closes with a necessary-but-not-sufficient formulation supported by the evidence.

LEQ 5 · Units 8–9 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which patterns of global exchange since 1945 have continued patterns established before 1900.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how much is continuity and how much is change. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning, continuity and change over time is the natural choice, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple variables, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the pre-1900 patterns the question refers to, the Indian Ocean and Silk Road networks, the silver trade linking Potosí to Manila and China, the nineteenth-century commodity economy in which industrial states manufactured and others supplied raw materials.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: containerized shipping and the collapse of freight costs; multinational supply chains separating design, production, and assembly; continued commodity dependence in many states and exposure to price swings; migration and remittances now exceeding official development assistance; the Green Revolution; the spread of disease along modern transport routes; export-led industrialization in East Asia as a break in the pattern; international institutions such as the IMF, World Bank, and WTO.
  • Reasoning: continuity and change, organized so that each claimed continuity is paired with the specific respect in which the modern case differs. Avoid a list of "same" followed by a list of "different".
  • Complexity: qualify by distinguishing structure from scale and speed, the shape of the relationship between commodity suppliers and manufacturers persisted while its velocity and volume changed by orders of magnitude. Or identify genuine breaks: the emergence of former suppliers as manufacturing powers, and the fact that environmental effects are now global rather than local.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context Global exchange is not a recent invention. Merchants moved goods across the Indian Ocean on the monsoon for centuries before 1500, silver mined at Potosí crossed the Pacific to pay Chinese taxes in the sixteenth century, and by 1900 a nineteenth-century commodity economy had settled into a clear shape: industrial states manufactured, other regions supplied raw materials, and the terms were set where the factories were. Thesis Exchange since 1945 has continued the structure of that relationship far more than most accounts of globalization acknowledge, while transforming its speed, volume, and the identity of the participants so thoroughly that the continuity is easily missed. The genuine breaks are two: some former suppliers became manufacturers, and the consequences of the system became planetary rather than regional.

Evidence The clearest continuity is commodity dependence. States whose export earnings rest on one or two primary products (oil, copper, cocoa, coffee) face exactly the problem nineteenth-century Egypt faced with cotton: their national budgets are hostage to prices set in markets they do not control. The mechanism is unchanged even though the commodities and the buyers have shifted. Migration shows a similar continuity in altered form: people have always moved toward economic opportunity and under coercion, and remittances from migrant workers now exceed total official development assistance to lower-income countries, which makes labor migration a major channel of finance much as indentured migration was a major channel of labor in the nineteenth century.

Evidence Disease supplies the most striking continuity of all, because it follows the routes of trade as reliably now as it did in 1347. Plague reached Europe along the Silk Roads and Mediterranean shipping within a few years of reaching the Black Sea; influenza in 1918 followed troopships and railways; COVID-19 followed air routes and reached six continents in weeks. The pattern is identical and the timescale has collapsed from years to days, which is exactly the relationship between continuity and change that this period displays generally.

Reasoning Set against these continuities, the changes are mostly of degree rather than of kind. Containerization cut the cost of moving goods so far that it became economic to manufacture a product from components made on three continents, and telecommunications made managing such an operation possible from a fourth. But separating production stages across distances is an intensification of the division of labor the nineteenth century had already established, not a new principle. What changed was that the relationship could now be sliced much more finely.

Complexity Two developments do break the pattern rather than extend it. The first is that several economies moved from the supplier side of the relationship to the manufacturing side. Japan, then South Korea and Taiwan, then China built growth on manufacturing for export and are now sources of capital and technology rather than of raw materials: a reversal with no nineteenth-century precedent, though it left them exposed to demand decided elsewhere, as the 1997 Asian financial crisis demonstrated. The second is environmental. Nineteenth-century industry poisoned the rivers and air of the districts where it stood; the carbon released by twentieth-century industry, transport, and agriculture has changed the composition of the atmosphere itself, and the consequences fall hardest on countries that burned the least of it. That is a genuinely new kind of connection: for the first time, the exchange network has produced an effect that no participant can opt out of and that no single state can address alone.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims structural continuity beneath transformed speed and scale, and names the two genuine breaks in advance. Defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the body follows.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening establishes Indian Ocean trade, the silver network, and the nineteenth-century commodity economy as the baseline being compared against.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence throughout (single-commodity export dependence against Egyptian cotton, remittances exceeding development assistance, plague and influenza and COVID-19 along successive transport networks, containerization and multinational supply chains) each explained rather than named.
  • Reasoning (1): Each continuity is paired with the specific respect in which the modern case differs, so the essay argues about change over time rather than listing similarities and differences separately.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph identifies two developments that genuinely break the pattern, distinguishes them from the changes of degree discussed earlier, and explains why the environmental case is different in kind.

Unit recap

Unit recap

0:00 / 0:00

Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play counts as your one free video.

Free preview complete

That's the end of the free preview.

You've opened five lessons, which is as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go back to it.

Book a tutor instead