AP Psychology built lesson by lesson from the College Board course framework. Each of the 57 lessons follows one or two framework topics, quotes the learning objectives and essential knowledge it covers, defines the vocabulary, walks through a real study (method, participants, findings, limits), and ends with worked examples, an exam-focus box, and six practice items with answers. Each unit finishes with a ten-question review in the exam's three item styles, and the two free-response sections let you practice the Article Analysis Question and the Evidence-Based Question against the College Board rubrics.
What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.
AP Psychology has five units, and the College Board weights each at 15–25% of the exam, so none is safe to skip. The exam is 2 hours 40 minutes and digital: Section I is 75 multiple-choice questions in 90 minutes (66.7% of the score), and Section II is two free-response questions in 70 minutes (33.3%): the Article Analysis Question (25 minutes, including 10 minutes of reading) and the Evidence-Based Question (45 minutes, including 15 minutes of reading), each worth 7 points. Both free-response questions hand you research to read, so the course opens with four lessons on science practices and research methods (asking questions, designing studies, reading data, and interpreting statistics), and every later lesson names the research behind its concepts. Every unit ends with a ten-question review that mixes the exam's three multiple-choice styles: concept application, data analysis, and scientific investigation. The two writing sections at the bottom of the outline hold five AAQ prompts and five EBQ prompts, each with the research summaries, a timed writing space that scores against the official rubric, and a 7/7 model response.
U1Biological Bases of Behavior15–25%
U2Cognition15–25%
U3Development and Learning15–25%
U4Social Psychology and Personality15–25%
U5Mental and Physical Health15–25%
All five units are open, 57 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a ten-problem mixed review.
Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set,
is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open
for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no
card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of
written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.
Lesson 1.1 · Unit 1 · Science practice skills 2.A to 2.C
Psychology is the scientific study of behavior and mental processes, and what makes it a science is not the topic but the method. Every claim in this course, from how neurons fire to why people obey, rests on a study somebody designed, and the AP Exam keeps asking you to look at a described study and say what kind it was, what was measured, and what the results can and cannot show. Both free-response questions hand you summarized research to read, and about a quarter of the multiple-choice questions test research methods directly. So this course starts with the toolkit. The next three lessons cover sampling, ethics, and statistics; after that every lesson introduces a topic through the studies behind it, and you will use these ideas on every page.
Required skills · 2.A, 2.B, 2.C
Science practice skills.
2.A. Determine the type of research design(s) used in a given study.
2.B. Evaluate the appropriate use of research design elements in experimental methodology.
2.C. Evaluate the appropriate use of research design elements in non-experimental methodologies.
What the exam asks you to do.
2.A: Determine whether a study is using experimental or non-experimental methodologies.
2.A: Experimental methodology involves the use of independent variable(s) and random assignment to groups.
2.A: Non-experimental methodologies include case study, correlation, meta-analysis, and naturalistic observation.
2.B: State the hypothesis of a research scenario, including whether the hypothesis is falsifiable.
2.B: Identify operational definitions of variables in research scenarios to determine how well the definitions allow for the study to be replicated.
2.B: Identify the independent variable(s), dependent variable(s), and/or confounding variable(s) in a research scenario.
2.B: Identify the experimental and control groups, including the process and purpose for assigning people to groups, whether a placebo was used with the control group, and the effect of the placebo on the results.
2.B: Determine whether the study used single-blind or double-blind procedures to control for confounding variables like experimenter bias or the social desirability bias.
2.C: Identify the variables of interest in a research scenario.
2.C: Evaluate whether the results of a correlational study have a directionality problem or third variable problem that demonstrates that correlation does not equal causation.
2.C: Determine whether the research used a survey technique and whether the wording of the survey could lead respondents to demonstrate self-report bias or social desirability bias.
From a question to a testable hypothesis
A research project begins with a question, such as whether sleep affects memory. A theory is an organized set of principles that explains observations and predicts new ones. From a theory a researcher derives a hypothesis, a specific, testable prediction: "Students who sleep eight hours after studying will recall more words the next day than students who stay awake." Notice what a good hypothesis does. It names the variables and says how they should be related, and it can be shown wrong.
That last property is called falsifiability. A hypothesis is falsifiable if some possible result would count against it. "Sleeping students will recall more than awake students" is falsifiable because the awake students might do as well or better. "Some people are destined to be lucky" is not, because any outcome can be explained after the fact. The exam asks you to state a hypothesis from a scenario and to say whether it is falsifiable, so practice turning vague claims into predictions that could fail.
A variable is anything that can take different values or levels across people or situations: hours of sleep, number of words recalled, anxiety score. To test a hypothesis researchers must give each variable an operational definition, a precise statement of how the variable is measured or manipulated in this particular study. "Memory" is a construct; "the number of words from a 20-word list recalled correctly after 24 hours" is an operational definition. A good operational definition is specific enough that another researcher could repeat the procedure exactly. That is replication, repeating a study (often with different participants) to see whether the finding holds, and it is the reason clear operational definitions matter.
Experiments: the one design that tests cause and effect
An experiment is the research method that can test whether one variable causes a change in another. The exam describes experimental methodology as the use of an independent variable and random assignment to groups. The pieces are:
The independent variable (IV) is the variable the researcher manipulates on purpose. It is the proposed cause.
The dependent variable (DV) is the variable that is measured to see whether it changed. It is the proposed effect, and it depends on the IV.
The experimental group receives the treatment (a level of the IV). The control group does not, or receives a standard or neutral condition, and provides a baseline for comparison.
Random assignment means every participant has an equal chance of landing in any condition, decided by chance (a coin flip, a random number list). Its purpose is to spread pre-existing differences such as mood, intelligence, or motivation evenly across groups, so that the groups are equivalent before the treatment.
A confounding variable is any factor other than the IV that differs between the groups and could explain a difference in the DV. Random assignment and keeping everything else the same (testing everyone in the same room at the same time of day, with the same instructions) are the defenses against confounds.
Random assignment is easy to confuse with random sampling. Random assignment decides which condition a participant is placed in, and it is what allows a cause-and-effect conclusion. Random sampling decides who is chosen from the population to be in the study at all, and it affects how far the results can be generalized. The next lesson returns to sampling.
Controlling expectations: placebos and blinding
People's beliefs change their behavior. In a drug trial, some participants feel better simply because they expect to, a result called the placebo effect. To separate the effect of the drug from the effect of expectation, researchers give the control group a placebo, an inactive substance or sham treatment that looks the same as the real one. If the drug group improves more than the placebo group, the extra improvement can be attributed to the drug.
Researchers have expectations too, and these can leak into the results through the way they treat participants or score the data, which is called experimenter bias. Participants may also try to look good or give the answers they think are wanted, called social desirability bias. Two procedures guard against these problems:
In a single-blind procedure the participants do not know which condition they are in.
In a double-blind procedure neither the participants nor the researchers who interact with them or score the results know who is in which group.
If a scenario says "the nurse giving the pills did not know which were real," that is a clue to double-blind. If only the patients were kept uninformed, it is single-blind.
Study spotlight · Dunn, Aknin, and Norton (2008)
A team of researchers wanted to know whether spending money on other people makes us happier than spending it on ourselves. In one experiment, university students were given an envelope in the morning containing either $5 or $20 and were randomly assigned to spend the money by 5 p.m. either on themselves or on someone else. That evening the participants rated their happiness. The students told to spend on others reported greater happiness than those told to spend on themselves, and the amount of money ($5 or $20) did not matter.
Reading the research: the IV had two parts (who the money was spent on, and how much money). The DV was a self-reported happiness rating, which is the operational definition of happiness here. Random assignment made the groups equivalent at the start, so the researchers could conclude that spending on others caused the higher happiness. The sample was small and made up of university students, which limits generalizing, and a self-report measure can be affected by social desirability.
Non-experimental methods
When an experiment is impractical or unethical (you cannot randomly assign children to be abused or to lose a brain region), researchers use non-experimental designs. These methods can describe and predict behavior, and some of them are the source of famous hypotheses, but because they lack a manipulated IV and random assignment they cannot show that one variable causes another.
A naturalistic observation records behavior as it happens in its natural setting without interfering. Jane Goodall's long study of wild chimpanzees in Tanzania, in which she observed tool use, is the standard example. The strength is realistic behavior; the weaknesses are that observers can be biased and that the situation cannot be controlled.
A case study is an in-depth investigation of one person or a small group, often someone with an unusual condition. Case studies generate hypotheses and document rare events, but one person may not be typical, so the results may not generalize.
A survey collects self-reported answers from many people. Surveys are fast and reach large samples, but they are affected by self-report bias (people may not remember accurately or may not be honest), by social desirability bias, and by wording effects: leading or loaded questions steer answers. Compare "Do you support helping the poor?" with "Do you support giving tax money to people who don't work?"
A correlational study measures two or more variables as they naturally occur and determines whether and how strongly they are related. Correlations are reported with a coefficient that the statistics lesson explains.
A meta-analysis is a statistical combination of the results of many separate studies on the same question. It gives a more stable estimate than any single study and helps show whether a finding replicates.
Correlation does not equal causation
Because a correlational study does not manipulate anything, a relationship found in it can be explained in more than one way. Suppose a correlational study finds that students who eat breakfast have higher grades. There are three possible explanations:
Directionality problem: the causal arrow could run the other way. Perhaps students who are organized and doing well in school are the ones who eat breakfast.
Third variable problem: a hidden variable could cause both. Perhaps family income or a stable home routine produces both regular breakfasts and better grades.
Causation in the direction suggested: breakfast helps learning. This is possible but cannot be concluded from the correlation alone.
Only an experiment (randomly assigning students to eat or skip breakfast) can sort these out. When you read "linked to," "associated with," or "related to," think correlation; when you read "caused" or "led to" after random assignment, think experiment.
Choosing and recognizing a design
Method
Manipulates an IV?
Random assignment?
Can show cause and effect?
Typical weakness
Experiment
Yes
Yes
Yes
Artificial settings; some questions are unethical to test
Correlational study
No
No
No
Directionality and third-variable problems
Naturalistic observation
No
No
No
Observer bias; no control of conditions
Case study
No
No
No
One case may not generalize
Survey
No
No
No
Self-report bias, wording, social desirability
Meta-analysis
No (combines studies)
No
Only as strong as the studies included
Depends on the quality of the studies pooled
Worked example · Classifying a scenario
A researcher recruits 60 volunteers and flips a coin for each to decide whether they will spend 10 minutes writing about something they are grateful for or 10 minutes writing about their day. Afterward, everyone completes a 10-item mood questionnaire scored from 10 to 50. The researcher predicts that the gratitude group will score higher. Identify the design, IV, DV, and the role of the coin flip.
Step 1, look for random assignment and a manipulated variable. The researcher decides what each person writes about, and the coin flip assigns people to conditions. So this is an experiment.
Step 2, the IV is the type of writing (gratitude versus daily events). The gratitude group is the experimental group and the writing-about-the-day group is the control group.
Step 3, the DV is the mood score, and the operational definition of mood is the score on the 10-item questionnaire.
Step 4, the coin flip is random assignment, which makes the groups roughly equal in mood, personality, and other characteristics before the writing, so a difference in the scores can be attributed to the writing task.
Step 5, the hypothesis is falsifiable: the gratitude group might not score higher.
Worked example · Evaluating a correlational claim
A survey of 500 high school students finds that those who spend more hours on social media each day report lower self-esteem. A news headline says, "Social media is lowering teens' self-esteem." Evaluate the headline.
Step 1, name the design: a survey that measured two variables as they occur, so it is correlational. The researchers did not assign anyone to use more or less social media.
Step 2, directionality: students who already feel poorly about themselves might turn to social media more often, so low self-esteem could cause heavier use.
Step 3, third variable: loneliness or a stressful home life could both lower self-esteem and increase online time.
Step 4, add the survey limitation: both variables are self-reported, so they can be affected by inaccurate memory of hours and by social desirability.
Step 5, conclusion: the data support "heavier use is associated with lower self-esteem," not "social media lowers self-esteem." To test cause, a researcher would randomly assign students to reduce their use and measure self-esteem afterward.
Worked example · Spotting a confound
In a study of whether a new teaching method improves test scores, one class (taught by the researcher's favorite teacher) uses the new method and a second class uses the usual method. The new-method class scores 8 points higher. What went wrong?
Step 1, the IV is the teaching method, but the classes were not randomly assigned, and the teacher is a second difference between the groups.
Step 2, the teacher differs between conditions. It is a confounding variable, so the 8-point difference could come from the teacher, from differences between the students in the two classes, or from the method.
Step 3, a better design randomly assigns students to classes, or has the same teacher teach both methods, and uses the same test and conditions for both.
Exam focus
Experiments (manipulated IV + random assignment) are the only method that can show cause and effect; the DV is what is measured.
Name the design from the scenario: coin flip or random assignment means experiment; "measured two variables" means correlational; one person means case study; recording behavior in natural settings means naturalistic observation; self-reports from many people mean a survey; combining many studies means meta-analysis.
A placebo tests expectation; single-blind hides the condition from participants, double-blind hides it from participants and researchers.
For any correlation, give the directionality problem and the third-variable problem.
An operational definition is a measurement or procedure specific enough to replicate. A hypothesis must be falsifiable.
Practice
A researcher says, "People who are meant to be creative will always find a way to show it." Is this hypothesis falsifiable? Rewrite it as a falsifiable hypothesis.
Show answer
No, because any behavior (including no creative behavior) could be explained away as not "meant to be." A falsifiable version: "Students who receive 30 minutes of brainstorming training will list more unusual uses for a brick in 3 minutes than students who receive no training." This names the variables, operational definitions, and a result that could fail.
In a drug trial for headaches, patients receive either the drug or a sugar pill. The nurses who hand out the pills also do not know which is which. Name the placebo, the control group, and the blinding procedure.
Show answer
The sugar pill is the placebo and the patients who take it are the control group. Both the patients and the nurses are unaware of the assignment, so it is a double-blind procedure.
A study measures the number of hours teens sleep and their GPA in 300 students and finds r = +0.30. Give one directionality explanation and one third-variable explanation.
Show answer
Directionality: students who do well in school feel less stressed, so they sleep more (GPA affects sleep). Third variable: a stable, supportive home might both give teens time and a quiet place to sleep and help them study (home environment affects both).
A researcher watches how often children share toys on a playground without interfering and records each sharing act. What method is this and what is one weakness?
Show answer
Naturalistic observation. A weakness: the observer cannot control conditions or may be biased about what counts as sharing; the observed children may also behave differently if they know they are watched.
Why does random assignment, but not random sampling, allow the conclusion that the IV caused a change in the DV?
Show answer
Random assignment makes the groups equivalent at the start (spreading pre-existing differences by chance), so a later difference in the DV is likely due to the IV. Random sampling affects who is in the study and so how far the results generalize to the population, but it does not make the groups equal or control confounds.
A survey question reads, "Do you agree that wasteful government spending should be cut?" Identify the problem and its effect.
Show answer
The wording is loaded: it labels spending as "wasteful," so it steers respondents toward agreeing. This is a wording effect that biases the results (and it can combine with social desirability bias).
Lesson 1.2 · Unit 1 · Science practice skills 2.B to 2.D
A study's design tells you what kind of conclusion it can support. Three other questions decide whether you should believe the conclusion: who took part, how the variables were measured, and whether the participants were treated properly. This lesson covers all three, and then shows how a single study becomes part of scientific knowledge. These are the questions behind the research-methods items on the multiple-choice section and behind several of the points on the Article Analysis Question, which asks about the sample, the measures, the ethical guidelines, and whether the results can be generalized.
Required skills · 2.B and 2.C, 2.D
Science practice skills.
2.B and 2.C. Evaluate the appropriate use of research design elements in experimental and non-experimental methodologies (sampling, measurement and scientific process).
2.D. Evaluate whether a psychological research scenario followed appropriate ethical procedures.
What the exam asks you to do.
2.B and 2.C: In a research scenario, identify the participants of a study who make up the sample that is drawn from a population.
2.B and 2.C: Determine whether the sample used is representative of the population and is selected by either random sampling or convenience sampling.
2.B and 2.C: Evaluate whether the sampling procedure involves sampling bias.
2.B and 2.C: Determine to what extent the sampling method allows for results of the study to be generalized.
2.B and 2.C: Determine whether the measurement instrument for research used qualitative (such as structured interviews) or quantitative measures (such as Likert scales).
2.B and 2.C: Describe the impact of appropriate representation of participants in conducting research and on the outcomes of research.
2.B and 2.C: Explain how conclusions from research evolve via scientific processes such as peer review and replication.
2.D: Explain the importance of institutional review for research involving human and non-human animals.
2.D: Determine whether proper informed consent and/or informed assent was used in a research scenario.
2.D: Determine whether researchers took steps to protect participants from harm.
2.D: Determine whether researchers kept participant information confidential and/or anonymous.
2.D: Determine whether deception was used in the research (possibly with the help of research confederates).
2.D: Determine whether researchers used proper debriefing techniques with participants at the conclusion of the research.
Population and sample
The population is the entire group a researcher wants to draw conclusions about, such as all U.S. high school juniors. Studying everyone is almost never possible, so researchers study a sample, a smaller group drawn from the population. The sample is the people who actually took part, and a good one lets researchers say something true about the population.
A representative sample has the same mix of characteristics as the population (age, gender, region, income, and so on). The best way to get one is random sampling: every member of the population has an equal chance of being chosen, so chance, not the researcher's convenience, decides who is in. A convenience sample is made of people who are easy to reach, such as the students in a psychology class, shoppers at one mall, or volunteers who answer an online ad. Convenience samples are cheap but risky, because the people who are easy to reach may differ from the population.
When the way a sample is chosen leaves out or over-includes some kinds of people, the result is sampling bias. A phone survey that only calls landlines will miss people with only cell phones. An online survey about internet habits will only reach people online. Volunteers differ from non-volunteers as well, since the people who choose to answer a questionnaire about stress may be those who feel stress most.
Generalizability
Generalizability is the extent to which findings apply beyond the sample to the wider population and to other settings. To judge it, read the description of the participants and ask: how many were there, who were they (age, gender, culture, country), how were they recruited, and where was the study done? A large, randomly chosen, diverse sample supports broad generalization; a small group of volunteer undergraduates at one university supports only cautious generalization.
The exam also expects you to understand why appropriate representation of participants matters. Much of the early research in psychology was done on college students in Western countries, and many studies left out women, people of color, older adults, and people from other cultures. Findings from a narrow group can be wrong or misleading for everyone else, and using them to make decisions about education, health care, or policy can lead to unfair or ineffective results. Including diverse participants improves the accuracy of the conclusions and the fairness of how they are used.
A reminder from the last lesson: random sampling is about who gets into the study and affects generalizability; random assignment is about which condition each participant gets and affects whether the study can show cause and effect. A study can have either, both, or neither.
Measuring variables
Researchers need a way to turn a construct into data. The exam separates two kinds of measurement:
Quantitative measures produce numbers: test scores, reaction times in milliseconds, counts of behaviors, heart rate, or ratings on a Likert scale (for example, from 1 = strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree).
Qualitative measures produce descriptions in words, such as answers to open-ended questions, a structured interview with set questions, or narrative notes from observations. They capture detail and context that a number can miss, but are harder to compare across people.
Whatever the measure, two properties matter. A measure is reliable if it gives consistent results when repeated, and valid if it measures what it is supposed to measure. A bathroom scale that reads 5 pounds heavier every time is reliable but not valid. (Lesson 2.9 develops these ideas for tests.) Self-reports are a common quantitative measure, and they are open to the self-report and social desirability biases from the last lesson, which is why researchers often add direct observation or physiological measures.
How a finding becomes knowledge: peer review and replication
One study is never the last word. Before a study is published in a scientific journal it goes through peer review: independent experts in the field read it and judge whether the methods and conclusions are sound, and they can ask for changes or reject it. Peer review is a filter, not a guarantee, and it does not replace the next step. Replication means that other researchers repeat the study, ideally with different participants and settings, and see whether they get the same result. If a finding replicates across samples, confidence in it grows; if it does not, researchers revise or abandon the claim. Meta-analyses combine many such studies. This ongoing process of review and repeating is how conclusions from both experimental and non-experimental research evolve, and it is why a single exciting result should be described as "suggests," not "proves."
Research ethics
Psychologists work with people and animals who can be harmed, so research follows ethical guidelines established by the American Psychological Association (APA) and by federal rules. You should be able to recognize each one in a scenario.
Institutional review board (IRB): a committee that reviews any proposed study with human participants before it begins, to make sure the risks are justified and participants are protected. For studies using non-human animals, an institutional animal care and use committee reviews the plan and requires humane treatment of the animals (housing, care, minimizing pain, and using as few animals as needed).
Informed consent: participants are told what the study involves, including any risks and the right to quit, and agree to take part voluntarily. For children and others who cannot legally consent, a parent or guardian gives permission and the participant gives informed assent, their own agreement to take part.
Protection from harm: researchers must minimize physical and psychological risk (stress, embarrassment, distress) and weigh it against the expected benefit of the knowledge.
Confidentiality and anonymity: confidentiality means the researchers know who the participants are but keep their data private and report results without identifying anyone. Anonymity means the researchers cannot connect the data to any person at all.
Deception: misleading participants about the true purpose is allowed only when the question cannot be studied any other way, the risk is minimal, and the participants are told the truth afterward. A confederate is someone who appears to be a participant but is really working with the researcher, a common way to carry out deception.
Debriefing: after the study, participants are told the real purpose, any deception is explained, their questions are answered, and they are checked for lingering distress.
Voluntary participation and the right to withdraw: participants can quit at any time without penalty.
Study spotlight · Milgram (1963)
Stanley Milgram recruited 40 men from New Haven, Connecticut, by newspaper ad and told them the study was about learning and memory. An experimenter in a lab coat told each man (the "teacher") to give a series of increasing shocks, on a generator labeled from 15 to 450 volts, to another man (a confederate, the "learner") every time the learner made a mistake. No shocks were actually delivered. As the learner protested, the experimenter used standard prods such as "The experiment requires that you continue." In the original study 26 of the 40 participants (65%) went all the way to 450 volts.
Reading the research: a laboratory study of obedience with an actual measure (the highest voltage given). It also became a landmark case in research ethics. Participants were deceived about the purpose and about the shocks, many showed obvious distress, and the right to quit was effectively undermined by the prods. The study helped drive the requirements for review boards, informed consent, minimizing distress, and debriefing that are in place today. (Unit 4 returns to what the study shows about obedience.)
Worked example · Evaluating sampling and generalizability
A team surveyed 1,200 teenagers about vaping. They posted the survey link on a popular social media site for two weeks. Participants were mostly girls (72%) and 88% were from large cities; 60% were 17 or 18 years old. The researchers concluded, "Most U.S. teens have never vaped." Evaluate the sample and the conclusion.
Step 1, identify the population: U.S. teenagers. The sample is the 1,200 respondents.
Step 2, how was it chosen? A link on a social media site, so people chose themselves: a convenience (volunteer) sample, not random.
Step 3, sampling bias: the sample over-represents girls, urban teens, and older teens, and it only includes teens who use that site, so it does not match the population.
Step 4, generalizability: the 1,200 respondents are a decent number, but they are not representative, so the conclusion about "most U.S. teens" is not well supported. It is better to describe only the results for the people surveyed. A stronger design randomly selects teens from school lists across regions and uses a measure that protects privacy to reduce social desirability.
Worked example · Applying the ethical guidelines
A researcher tells students they are in a study of "group problem solving." In fact, the study measures how participants react when a confederate on the team insults them. The researcher records the students' stress with a questionnaire and publishes the data with each student's name. The students were never told they could leave. Identify at least four ethical problems and a fix for each.
Step 1, deception: students were told the wrong purpose. Deception is allowed only if no other way exists and the participants are debriefed. Fix: justify the deception to the IRB and debrief afterward.
Step 2, informed consent and right to withdraw: students were not told about the insults or that they could leave. Fix: give a consent form that describes the risks in general terms and states they can stop at any time without penalty.
Step 3, protection from harm: insults cause stress. Fix: keep the stress mild, monitor participants, and offer support or counseling contacts.
Step 4, confidentiality: publishing names breaks confidentiality. Fix: report only group data or use code numbers.
Step 5, debriefing: none was described. Fix: explain the real purpose and the confederate's role, and check how each student feels.
Step 6, review: the plan needs IRB approval before it begins.
Exam focus
Random sampling helps a sample represent the population (generalizability); convenience samples risk sampling bias. Random assignment is a separate idea about creating equal groups.
To judge generalizability, cite specific evidence about participants: number, age, gender, culture, recruitment, setting.
Quantitative measures are numbers (Likert scales, scores); qualitative measures are words (structured interviews, open-ended answers).
Peer review and replication are how findings are checked and conclusions revised.
Ethics checklist: IRB (and animal care committee), informed consent or assent, protection from harm, confidentiality or anonymity, deception only when justified, debriefing, right to withdraw.
Practice
A researcher wants to know how stressed students at a large public high school are. She puts the name of every student in a hat and draws 200 names. Is this a random sample or a convenience sample? Which group is the population?
Show answer
It is a random sample, because every student had an equal chance of being picked. The population is all the students at that high school (and the 200 chosen students are the sample).
A psychologist studies memory using only 20 first-year students from her own university who took part for course credit. Give two reasons the results might not generalize.
Show answer
The sample is small (20), and it is a convenience sample of young, college-educated students from one school, so it may not represent older adults, people who did not attend college, or other cultures.
Classify each as quantitative or qualitative: (a) a 1 to 5 satisfaction rating, (b) a participant's spoken description of a recent stressful day, (c) reaction time in milliseconds.
Show answer
(a) quantitative (a Likert scale); (b) qualitative (a description in words); (c) quantitative (a number).
A study of a new reading program for 8-year-olds requires a signed form from each child's parent, and each child also says "yes" when asked if they want to play the reading game. Name the two kinds of agreement.
Show answer
The parent's signed form is informed consent (permission), and the child's own agreement is informed assent.
Researchers collected survey answers using code numbers, and the key linking codes to names is stored in a locked cabinet that only two researchers can open. Is this anonymity or confidentiality? Explain.
Show answer
Confidentiality. The researchers can identify who gave which answers, but they keep that information private. In true anonymity no one could link answers to a person.
Explain why replication matters even when a study was published after peer review.
Show answer
Peer review checks the methods and logic, but it cannot show whether the result will hold with new participants or settings. Replication tests that: if other researchers get the same result, confidence grows, and if they do not, the claim must be revised. One study can be affected by chance, a biased sample, or a hidden confound.
Lesson 1.3 · Unit 1 · Science practice skills 3.A and 3.B
Describing data: averages, spread, and the normal curve
Psychologists collect numbers, and a pile of numbers means nothing until it is summarized. Descriptive statistics do that job: they describe the data you have, using a measure of where the scores are centered, a measure of how spread out they are, and a picture of their overall shape. The exam asks you to calculate the simple ones from a small data set and to interpret all of them, including the standard deviation and percentile rank, which you will not have to compute from raw data but must be able to read. This lesson gives you everything you need for that, with careful practice, because these items are among the most reliable points on the test.
Required skills · 3.A, 3.B
Science practice skills.
3.A. Identify psychology-related concepts in descriptions or representations of data.
3.B. Calculate and interpret measures of central tendency, variation, and percentile rank in a given data set.
What the exam asks you to do.
3.A: Identify variables in descriptions or representations of data.
3.A: Identify statistical and psychological concept(s) depicted in a table, graph, chart, or figure.
3.B: Calculate mean, median, mode, and range from a set of data.
3.B: Explain the elements of the normal curve including percentages of distributions of scores across the curve, how to interpret skewness in a graph, and how to interpret a bimodal distribution.
3.B: Interpret mean, median, mode, range, standard deviation, and percentile rank from a set of data.
3.B: Explain how regression toward the mean occurs as more data are collected.
Measures of central tendency
A measure of central tendency gives one number that represents the center of a distribution.
The mean is the arithmetic average: add all the scores and divide by the number of scores.
The median is the middle score when the scores are put in order. If there is an even number of scores, it is the mean of the two middle scores. Half the scores are above it and half are below.
The mode is the most frequent score. A distribution can have no mode, one mode, or more than one.
The three can differ, and which is best depends on the data. The mean uses every score, so it is pulled strongly by extreme scores called outliers. The median is not affected much by outliers, so it is the better summary when a few extreme values would distort the mean, which is why reports of household income use the median.
Measures of variation
Two groups can have the same mean and look nothing alike, so a measure of variation says how spread out the scores are.
The range is the highest score minus the lowest. It is easy to compute but depends only on the two most extreme scores.
The standard deviation (SD) describes the typical distance of scores from the mean. A small SD means the scores cluster tightly around the mean; a large SD means they are widely scattered. You will be asked to interpret an SD, not to compute one: if two classes both average 75 on a test but class A has an SD of 4 and class B has an SD of 15, class A's scores are all close to 75, while class B has many scores far above and far below.
Shapes of distributions
A graph of a distribution (most often a histogram, which shows how many scores fall in each interval) has a shape, and the shape tells you how the mean, median, and mode relate.
Figure 1.1. Three shapes. In a positively skewed distribution the long tail points toward high scores, and the mean is pulled toward the tail, above the median. A normal curve is symmetric. A bimodal distribution has two peaks, which often means two different groups are mixed together.
In a normal distribution the scores are symmetric around the center and form a bell-shaped curve; the mean, median, and mode are all the same. In a skewed distribution one tail is long. The skew is named for the direction of the tail: a positively skewed distribution has its long tail toward high scores (a few high outliers), and a negatively skewed distribution has its tail toward low scores. In either case the mean is pulled toward the tail, so in a positive skew the mean is greater than the median, and in a negative skew the mean is less than the median. A bimodal distribution has two peaks. It suggests that two different groups are mixed in the data, such as scores from two very different kinds of students, and the mean in that case may describe almost nobody.
The normal curve
Many psychological measures (heights, many test scores, IQ) form a distribution close to the normal curve. The curve has a fixed relationship between the mean, the SD, and the percentage of scores, shown in Figure 1.2.
Figure 1.2. The normal curve. About 34% of scores fall between the mean and 1 SD on each side, 68% within 1 SD, 95% within 2 SD, and nearly all within 3 SD. The percentile rank under each mark is the approximate percent of scores at or below that value.
Memorize the 68-95-99.7 rule: about 68% of scores are within 1 SD of the mean, about 95% are within 2 SD, and about 99.7% are within 3 SD. Because the curve is symmetric, half of those percentages are on each side: about 34% of scores lie between the mean and 1 SD above, 34% between the mean and 1 SD below, and about 13.5% in each band from 1 to 2 SD away.
Percentile rank
A percentile rank tells where a score stands compared with the others: the percent of scores in the distribution at or below that score. A score at the 84th percentile is higher than or equal to 84% of the scores. On a normal curve, the mean is at the 50th percentile, a score 1 SD above the mean is at about the 84th percentile (50% below the mean plus 34% between the mean and 1 SD), and a score 2 SD above is at about the 98th (50% + 47.5%). A score 1 SD below the mean is at about the 16th percentile.
Regression toward the mean
Suppose a coach picks the 10 students who scored lowest on a first quiz and gives them a tutoring session, and on the second quiz their scores rise. Did the tutoring work? Maybe, but there is another explanation. Any score is partly skill and partly luck (a good or bad day, a lucky guess, a missed question). People who score at an extreme the first time are likely to have had unusual luck, and on the next try their luck is likely to be more ordinary. So extreme scores tend to move closer to the average when measured again. This is regression toward the mean, and it shows up as more data are collected. It explains why a very tall couple's children are, on average, a bit shorter than the parents, why a rookie with a spectacular first season often has a weaker second, and why a "worst-ever" week at work is usually followed by a better one. When you evaluate a claim of improvement that follows an extreme score, ask whether a comparison group with no treatment improved as well. In an experiment with a control group, regression toward the mean affects both groups equally.
Worked example · Mean, median, mode, and range
Nine students scored 62, 70, 70, 74, 78, 81, 85, 90, and 98 on a unit test. Find the four statistics.
Step 1, the scores are already in order and there are 9 of them.
Step 2, the mean: add the scores. \(62+70+70+74+78+81+85+90+98=708\). Divide by 9: \(708\div 9\approx 78.7\).
Step 3, the median: with 9 scores the middle score is the 5th, which is 78.
Step 4, the mode: 70 appears twice and no other score repeats, so the mode is 70.
Step 5, the range: \(98-62=36\).
Step 6, interpret: the mean (78.7) is slightly above the median (78), so the distribution is almost symmetric with a very slight pull toward the high scores.
Worked example · How an outlier changes the measures
Eight students reported the minutes they spent on homework one night: 24, 25, 27, 27, 28, 29, 30, and 95. Find the mean and median with and without the 95. Which better represents a typical student?
Step 1, with all eight scores: the sum is 285, so the mean is \(285\div 8\approx 35.6\) minutes. The median is the mean of the 4th and 5th scores, \((27+28)\div 2=27.5\) minutes. The mode is 27.
Step 2, without the 95 (seven scores): the sum is 190, so the mean is \(190\div 7\approx 27.1\), and the median is the 4th score, 27.
Step 3, compare: one outlier moved the mean by about 8.5 minutes, but moved the median by only half a minute.
Step 4, conclusion: the median (27.5) describes a typical student far better than the mean (35.6), because seven of the eight students spent between 24 and 30 minutes. The distribution is positively skewed, and the mean (35.6) is greater than the median (27.5), as expected.
Worked example · Percentile rank on a normal curve
A test is scored so that the mean is 100 and the SD is 15, and the scores are normally distributed. Estimate the percentile rank of scores of 115, 130, and 85, and the percent of people who score between 85 and 115.
Step 1, 115 is 1 SD above the mean. Everything below the mean is 50% of scores, and the band from the mean to +1 SD adds about 34%, so the percentile rank is about 84.
Step 2, 130 is 2 SD above the mean: \(50+34+13.5=97.5\), so about the 98th percentile.
Step 3, 85 is 1 SD below the mean: \(50-34=16\), so about the 16th percentile.
Step 4, between 85 and 115 is within 1 SD of the mean, so about 68% of people.
Step 5, check by symmetry: the 84th percentile (115) and the 16th percentile (85) are the same distance from 50 in opposite directions, and \(84-16=68\).
Exam focus
Calculate mean, median, mode, and range from a short list; put the scores in order first.
Outliers pull the mean, so with skew the median is the better center. Mean greater than median means positive skew; less than means negative skew.
A larger standard deviation means more spread. Interpret it; do not compute it.
Use the 68-95-99.7 rule and symmetry to find percentages on a normal curve; a score 1 SD above the mean is at about the 84th percentile.
Percentile rank is the percent of scores at or below a score. Regression toward the mean: extreme scores tend to be less extreme on retest.
Practice
Find the mean, median, mode, and range of 4, 6, 6, 7, 9, 12, and 14.
Show answer
The sum is 58 and there are 7 scores, so the mean is \(58\div 7\approx 8.3\). The median is the 4th score, 7. The mode is 6. The range is \(14-4=10\).
A distribution of salaries at a small company has a mean of $82,000 and a median of $58,000. Describe its shape and say which measure better represents a typical salary.
Show answer
The mean is much higher than the median, so the distribution is positively skewed (a few very high salaries pull the mean up). The median, $58,000, better represents a typical salary.
Two sections of AP Psychology both have a mean of 80. Section A has an SD of 3 and section B has an SD of 12. Which section's scores are more spread out, and what does that mean for the students?
Show answer
Section B has the larger SD, so its scores are more spread out: many students scored far above and far below 80. Section A's students scored very close to 80.
On a normal curve with a mean of 50 and an SD of 10, about what percent of scores are between 40 and 60? Between 50 and 70?
Show answer
40 to 60 is within 1 SD of the mean, so about 68%. 50 to 70 is the mean to +2 SD, which is about \(34+13.5=47.5\%\).
A score is at the 84th percentile. What does that mean?
Show answer
About 84% of the scores in the distribution are at or below it (it is higher than or equal to most of the group).
A new reading program is given to the 15 lowest-scoring students in a class, and their average score rises by 6 points on the next test. Give one reason the gain might not come from the program.
Show answer
Regression toward the mean: extreme low scores on the first test partly reflect bad luck, so on a retest these students would be expected to score closer to the average even with no program. A control group of equally low scorers who did not get the program would show how much of the gain is due to this effect.
Correlation, effect size, and statistical significance
The last lesson summarized one variable at a time. Most psychological questions ask how two variables relate: do people who sleep more remember more, and does a treatment make a difference? This lesson covers the three tools the exam uses to describe those relationships and results: the correlation coefficient, effect size, and statistical significance. Together with the descriptive statistics, they are what you need to read the data tables and graphs in the multiple-choice questions and the statistics in the Article Analysis Question, where you must say what a number means in the context of the study.
Required skills · 3.C
Science practice skills.
3.C. Interpret quantitative or qualitative inferential data from a given table, graph, chart, figure, or diagram.
What the exam asks you to do.
3.C: Describe trends in and relationships between the variables as depicted in the data presented, such as interpreting correlational data from a scatterplot, including the correlation coefficient.
3.C: Interpret results from research that could be expressed as effect sizes or statistical significance.
3.C: Effect size indicates the strength of the relationship between or among variables in a non-experimental study or the size of the difference between or among conditions in an experimental study. The effect size statistic is often interpreted as follows: a small effect size statistic is usually 0.2 and below; a medium effect size statistic is usually between 0.3 and 0.7; a large effect size statistic is usually 0.8 or greater.
3.C: Statistical significance indicates that the results of the study are not likely due to chance and instead likely due to the variables being studied. This statistic can be calculated for all types of research methods.
Correlation and the scatterplot
A correlation is a measure of how strongly two variables are related. Each person is measured on both variables, and the data can be shown in a scatterplot, where each point is one person: one variable is on the horizontal axis and the other on the vertical axis.
Figure 1.3. Each point is one person measured on two variables. The pattern shows the direction of the relationship (up to the right is positive, down to the right is negative) and its strength (how tightly the points follow a line). The correlation coefficient r summarizes both.
In a positive correlation, the two variables increase together (more hours of studying, higher scores): the points trend up to the right. In a negative correlation, as one variable increases the other decreases (more hours of screen time before bed, less sleep): the points trend down to the right. When there is no pattern, the correlation is near zero.
The correlation coefficient, written \(r\), is a number from \(-1.00\) to \(+1.00\). The sign gives the direction. The distance from zero gives the strength: \(r=+1.00\) or \(r=-1.00\) is a perfect straight-line relationship, and \(r=0\) means no linear relationship. Rough guidelines are that values around \(\pm0.2\) are weak, around \(\pm0.5\) moderate, and \(\pm0.8\) or more strong, but use the pattern: how tightly the points cluster around a line. Remember that a correlation of \(-0.80\) is stronger than one of \(+0.30\); the minus sign says nothing about strength.
Three cautions apply to every correlation. First, correlation does not equal causation: it may reflect a directionality problem or a third variable (see Lesson 1.1). Second, a correlation tells you about a group, not about what will happen to any one person. Third, an outlier can change the value of \(r\) a great deal.
Inferential statistics and statistical significance
Descriptive statistics summarize the data in hand. Inferential statistics are used to decide whether a result from a sample is likely to be true of the population, or whether it might just be a coincidence of who happened to be in the sample. Suppose a researcher randomly assigns 30 students to a sleep condition and 30 to stay awake, and the sleep group recalls an average of 2 more words. Even if sleep did nothing, random variation in who was in each group would produce some difference. The question is how likely a difference that big would be by chance alone.
A result is statistically significant if it is unlikely to have happened by chance. The exam describes it this way: statistical significance indicates that the results of the study are not likely due to chance and instead likely due to the variables being studied. It is reported as a \(p\) value, the probability of getting results at least this extreme if only chance were operating. By convention, researchers call a result significant when \(p\lt .05\) (less than a 5% probability). A report of "\(p=.01\)" means that if there were really no effect, a difference this large would show up only about 1 time in 100. Statistical significance can be calculated for any kind of research method, not only experiments.
Two things significance does not say. It does not say the effect is large or important, and it does not prove the hypothesis, because there is always a small chance that the result is a fluke. A larger sample makes it easier to get a significant result, which is why effect size is also reported.
Effect size
Effect size says how big the effect or relationship is. In a non-experimental study, it indicates the strength of the relationship between variables (the correlation coefficient is itself an effect size). In an experimental study, it indicates the size of the difference between conditions. A common effect size for a difference between two groups is the difference in means divided by the typical SD, so it tells you how many SDs apart the groups are. The AP Exam interprets effect-size statistics this way: a small effect size is usually 0.2 and below; a medium one is usually between 0.3 and 0.7; and a large one is usually 0.8 or greater.
The two ideas answer different questions. Significance asks, "Is there probably a real effect?" Effect size asks, "How big is it?" A tiny effect can be significant if the sample is huge, and a large effect can fail to be significant if the sample is tiny.
Reading tables and graphs
When a question shows a table or graph, work through the same steps each time. First identify the variables and what is on each axis or in each column, including units. Second, describe the trend or comparison: which group is higher, what direction a relationship goes, and how strong. Third, look for the statistic (means, \(r\), \(p\), effect size) and say what it means in context. Fourth, ask what the design allows: an experiment can support a causal claim; a correlation cannot. Be careful with graphs whose vertical axis does not start at zero, which can make a small difference look dramatic.
Worked example · Interpreting a correlation
A researcher measures hours of sleep and score on a memory test for 8 students and finds \(r=+0.97\). A second study of 400 adults finds a correlation of \(r=-0.62\) between hours of daily social media use and hours of sleep. Interpret each.
Step 1, study 1: the sign is positive, so more sleep goes with higher memory scores. The size, 0.97, is very close to 1, so the relationship is very strong. With only 8 students, one or two unusual people could affect \(r\) a lot, so the researcher should be cautious about generalizing.
Step 2, study 2: the sign is negative, so more social media use goes with less sleep. The size, 0.62, is moderate to strong.
Step 3, causation: neither study can say that one variable caused the other. In study 2, heavier use could cut into sleep, or people who cannot sleep might turn to their phones (directionality), or stress could cause both (third variable).
Step 4, compare strength: study 1's relationship (0.97) is stronger than study 2's (0.62), even though study 2 is negative.
Worked example · Significance and effect size together
In an experiment, students who slept after studying (mean recall 14.2 words, SD 2.1) are compared with students who stayed awake (mean 11.8 words, SD 2.4). The result is reported as \(p=.01\), and the effect size is 1.06. Interpret the results.
Step 1, the difference between the group means is \(14.2-11.8=2.4\) words in favor of the sleep group.
Step 2, significance: \(p=.01\) is below .05. If sleep had no effect, a difference this large would occur by chance only about 1% of the time, so the result is statistically significant and is probably due to the sleep condition.
Step 3, effect size: 1.06 is above 0.8, so it is a large effect. The group averages are about one SD apart. (The effect size here is the mean difference, 2.4, divided by the typical SD, about 2.25.)
Step 4, cause: because participants were randomly assigned to conditions in an experiment, the researchers can conclude that sleep, rather than a confound, probably caused the better recall, within the limits of the sample.
Worked example · A significant result that is not large
Two groups of 10,000 people each take a reading test. The group that used a new app averages 100.6 and the group that did not averages 100.0, with an SD of 15 in both groups. The difference is statistically significant (\(p\approx.005\)). Should the app be considered a major improvement?
Step 1, the difference is 0.6 points, and the SD is 15, so the groups are \(0.6\div15=0.04\) SD apart. That is an effect size of 0.04, far below the 0.2 that counts as small.
Step 2, the difference is significant only because the samples are enormous: with 10,000 people per group, even a tiny difference is unlikely to be chance.
Step 3, conclusion: the effect is real in a statistical sense but trivial in size, so the app is not a major improvement. Always read the effect size as well as the \(p\) value.
Exam focus
\(r\) runs from \(-1\) to \(+1\); the sign is direction and the size is strength (\(-0.80\) is stronger than \(+0.30\)). Correlation does not equal causation.
Statistical significance (\(p\lt .05\)) means a result is unlikely due to chance alone. It does not mean the result is large or important.
Effect size shows the strength or size of an effect: small about 0.2 or less, medium 0.3 to 0.7, large 0.8 or more.
For any table or graph: identify the variables, describe the trend, interpret the statistic in context, and state what the design allows.
Practice
Which shows the stronger relationship: \(r=-0.75\) or \(r=+0.40\)? Explain.
Show answer
\(r=-0.75\) is stronger. Strength depends on how far the value is from zero (0.75 versus 0.40); the sign shows only direction.
A study reports a correlation of \(r=+0.55\) between hours of exercise per week and a happiness score. Describe the relationship, and say why the study cannot conclude that exercise makes people happier.
Show answer
It is a moderate to fairly strong positive correlation: more exercise goes with higher happiness. A correlation cannot show cause. Happier people might be more motivated to exercise (directionality), or a third variable such as good health or a supportive social life could increase both.
A study reports \(p=.03\). Explain what that means in plain words.
Show answer
If only chance were operating, a result this extreme would happen about 3% of the time. Because that is below the .05 convention, the result is considered statistically significant, so it is likely due to the variables studied rather than chance.
A result is statistically significant but has an effect size of 0.05. What can you conclude?
Show answer
The effect is probably real (not due to chance) but it is very small, much less than even a small effect (0.2), so it likely has little practical importance. A very large sample can make a tiny effect significant.
An experiment reports a mean of 80 for a treatment group and 70 for a control group, with an SD of 10 for each, and a significant \(p\) value. About how large is the effect, and how would you describe it?
Show answer
The means differ by 10, which is 1 SD (\(10\div10=1.0\)), so the effect size is about 1.0. That is greater than 0.8, so it is a large effect.
A bar graph's vertical axis runs from 70 to 74, and one group's bar looks twice as tall as the other's. What should you check before concluding the difference is large?
Show answer
Check the axis scale and the actual numbers. Because the axis does not start at zero, a difference of a point or two looks huge; look at the effect size or the means and SDs to judge the real size.
Heredity, environment, and the evolutionary perspective
Why are you the way you are? A person's behavior and mental processes come from an inherited biological blueprint and from everything that happens to that person after birth. The old argument over whether "nature" or "nurture" is more important has been replaced by a better question: how do the two work together? This lesson sets out the terms, shows how researchers try to pull the two influences apart, and introduces the evolutionary perspective, one of the major frameworks you will use to explain behavior throughout the course.
Required content · 1.1.A
Learning objective.
1.1.A. Explain the relationship between heredity and environment in shaping behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.1.A.1. Heredity and environmental factors interact to shape behavior and mental processes.
1.1.A.1.i. Heredity, or “nature,” refers to genetic or predisposed characteristics that influence physical, behavioral, and mental traits and processes.
1.1.A.1.ii. Environmental factors, or “nurture,” refers to the external factors that one experiences, such as family interactions or education. Exclusion Statement: Specific information about genetics (genotype, phenotype, DNA, chromosomes, and recessive and dominant gene expression) is beyond the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
1.1.A.2. The evolutionary perspective explores how natural selection affects the expression of behavior and mental processes to increase survival and reproductive success. Some theorists have sought to apply principles of the evolutionary perspective in ways that discriminate against others (eugenics).
1.1.A.3. Research on the effects of genes on individual behavior and mental processes is often conducted using twin studies, family studies, and adoption studies. 1.A 2.A
Nature, nurture, and their interaction
Heredity, or "nature," refers to the genetic or predisposed characteristics a person inherits from biological parents, which influence physical, behavioral, and mental traits and processes. Eye color is almost entirely hereditary, but so are tendencies toward certain temperaments and some risk for conditions such as depression. Environmental factors, or "nurture," refers to the external influences a person experiences: family interactions, education, nutrition, culture, friends, and chance events. The exam treats the two as interacting. Genes give a predisposition, and the environment shapes how, and whether, that predisposition shows up.
A simple example is height. Genes strongly influence how tall a child can become, but a child who is poorly fed during growth will not reach the potential that good nutrition would allow. Another is a child with a genetic tendency toward anxiety: in a calm, supportive home the tendency may never become a problem, and in a chaotic home it may. The genes and the environment are not adding up separately; they are interacting. You will see this idea again in the diathesis-stress model in Unit 5.
You do not need detailed genetics for the AP Exam. Terms such as genotype, phenotype, DNA, chromosomes, and dominant and recessive genes are beyond the scope of the exam, so concentrate on the broad idea of nature interacting with nurture and on how researchers study it.
The evolutionary perspective
The evolutionary perspective explains behavior and mental processes by asking how they helped our ancestors survive and reproduce. It rests on natural selection, the principle (from Charles Darwin) that traits that increase an organism's chances of surviving and reproducing are more likely to be passed on, so that over many generations such traits become more common in a population. Behaviors can be inherited tendencies too, so evolutionary psychologists ask what problem a behavior solved for early humans. Examples include fear of snakes and heights (which would help someone avoid danger), the bond between infant and caregiver (which keeps a helpless infant alive), and the preference for sugary and fatty foods (which were scarce and valuable sources of energy).
The perspective also has limits. Explanations can be built after the fact ("it must have helped our ancestors"), which makes them hard to test, so a hypothesis from this perspective should still be falsifiable. Natural selection acts on populations over many generations, so it does not explain why one individual acts a certain way on a given day.
The exam also asks you to know that evolutionary ideas have been misused. Some theorists have used the logic of inheritance and "fitness" to argue that some groups of people are superior to others, and have promoted discrimination against groups they judged inferior. The best-known example is eugenics, a movement that sought to improve the human population by encouraging reproduction among people thought to have desirable traits and preventing it among others. In the United States in the early twentieth century, eugenics laws led to the forced sterilization of tens of thousands of people, many of them poor, disabled, or from minority groups. The movement rested on bad science and on prejudice, and it was used to justify horrific policies in Nazi Germany. Psychology rejects it. The lesson to remember is that a scientific theory can be applied in unethical and discriminatory ways, and that you can be asked to recognize and evaluate such an application.
Studying heredity: twin, family, and adoption studies
Researchers cannot randomly assign people to have certain parents or genes, so research on the effects of genes on behavior relies on non-experimental designs that use natural relationships. Three are required.
Twin studies compare identical (monozygotic) twins, who share essentially 100% of their genes, with fraternal (dizygotic) twins, who share on average about 50%, as ordinary siblings do. If a trait is influenced by heredity, identical twins should be more alike on it than fraternal twins, because their genes are more alike while their shared environment (same family, same age) is similar. Studies of identical twins who were separated early in life and raised in different homes are especially informative, because any similarity cannot be due to a shared upbringing.
Family studies look at how common a trait is among biological relatives. If a trait has a genetic basis, closer relatives (parents, siblings) should be more likely to share it than distant relatives. A weakness is that relatives usually share an environment as well as genes.
Adoption studies compare adopted children with their biological parents (who gave genes but not a home) and with their adoptive parents (who gave a home but not genes). If adopted children resemble their biological parents on a trait, heredity is implicated; if they resemble their adoptive parents, environment is implicated.
All three are correlational: each compares naturally occurring groups and measures similarity, and none can show cause and effect the way an experiment can. Researchers often summarize their results with a heritability estimate, which is a statistic about how much of the differences among people in a group can be linked to genetic differences. It is not a measure of how much of one person's trait is "genetic," and it can change when the environment changes.
Study spotlight · The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart (Bouchard and colleagues, 1990)
Researchers at the University of Minnesota located many sets of twins who had been separated early in life and raised in different families. They brought the twins to the laboratory for several days of testing on intelligence, personality, interests, and other measures. The results showed that identical twins raised apart were strikingly similar, with correlations on IQ scores in the neighborhood of +0.70, roughly as similar as identical twins raised together and much more similar than fraternal twins. Similarities also appeared in personality and attitudes.
Reading the research: this is a correlational study of naturally occurring groups with a small, volunteer sample. Strengths include testing twins who had grown up in different homes. Limitations are that many of the twins were reunited before testing and were not randomly placed in homes (adoption agencies often placed twins in similar homes), so the "different environments" were not always very different. The data show that heredity matters; they do not show that environment does not.
Study spotlight · Enriched environments (Rosenzweig, Bennett, and Diamond, 1972)
These researchers raised rats from the same litters in two conditions. Some rats lived alone in bare cages; others lived in groups in cages with toys, ladders, and objects that were changed regularly. After a period of weeks the brains of the enriched rats showed a thicker cerebral cortex and other differences. Because littermates were randomly assigned to conditions, this is an experiment, with the environment (enriched or bare) as the IV and the physical features of the brain as the DV.
Reading the research: it shows that the environment can change the brain, an example of nurture acting on biology. A limitation is that it used rats, so human experience may differ.
Worked example · What the twin data suggest
A researcher gathers the following hypothetical data on a trait called "novelty seeking," measured on a scale from 0 to 100, for 50 pairs of each type of twin. The correlation within pairs is: identical twins raised together, \(r=+0.55\); fraternal twins raised together, \(r=+0.28\); identical twins raised apart, \(r=+0.50\). What can the researcher conclude?
Step 1, identical twins share 100% of their genes and fraternal twins share about 50%. The identical pairs are much more alike (0.55) than the fraternal pairs (0.28), though both pairs share a family environment. This points to a hereditary influence.
Step 2, identical twins raised apart (0.50) are almost as similar as those raised together (0.55). Since they did not share a home, the similarity is probably not from the same upbringing, which supports heredity again.
Step 3, the correlations are not 1.00, even for twins with identical genes. So environment, or measurement error, also plays a role.
Step 4, what is not justified: the study cannot say that heredity causes novelty seeking, because twin studies are correlational. It also cannot say what percent of any individual's novelty seeking is genetic.
Worked example · Choosing the method
For each question, name the best method among a twin study, a family study, and an adoption study. (a) Researchers want to separate the effect of the home environment from the effect of the genes inherited from birth parents. (b) Researchers compare identical and fraternal pairs on the risk of a disorder. (c) Researchers survey a large group of families to see whether a trait is more common among closer relatives.
Step 1, (a) an adoption study. Adopted children have genes from birth parents and a home from adoptive parents, so the researcher can compare resemblance to each.
Step 2, (b) a twin study, because the identical versus fraternal comparison is the defining feature.
Step 3, (c) a family study, because it looks at the pattern of a trait across relatives of different closeness.
Step 4, note that all three are non-experimental, since no one is randomly assigned to be related to someone.
Exam focus
Heredity (nature) and environment (nurture) interact. Do not study genotype, phenotype, DNA, or dominant and recessive genes for this exam.
The evolutionary perspective uses natural selection to explain behaviors that aid survival and reproduction. It can be misused to discriminate (eugenics), and you should be able to evaluate that.
Twin studies (identical about 100% shared genes, fraternal about 50%), family studies, and adoption studies are the research designs for the effects of genes. All are correlational.
Heritability describes group differences, not how "genetic" an individual is.
Practice
Define heredity and environmental factors, and give one example of each.
Show answer
Heredity ("nature") is the genetic or predisposed characteristics that influence traits and processes, such as a tendency toward a certain temperament. Environmental factors ("nurture") are external influences a person experiences, such as family interactions or education.
A researcher finds that identical twins are much more alike than fraternal twins in their risk of a mental disorder. What does that suggest, and why can't the researcher say heredity is the only cause?
Show answer
It suggests a hereditary influence, since identical twins share more genes. But the correlation between identical twins is not perfect, so the environment also matters, and the study is correlational so it cannot show cause.
Adopted children's reading scores are more similar to those of their adoptive parents than to their biological parents. Which influence does this suggest?
Show answer
Environment (the home provided by the adoptive parents) rather than inherited characteristics.
Explain, using natural selection, why an infant's strong attachment to a caregiver might be an inherited tendency.
Show answer
Infants who stayed close to a caregiver and signaled their needs were more likely to be fed, protected, and to survive and reproduce, so a tendency toward attachment would be passed on over generations.
What is eugenics, and why does it illustrate misuse of the evolutionary perspective?
Show answer
Eugenics was a movement that applied ideas about inheritance to try to "improve" the population by controlling who could reproduce, which led to discrimination and forced sterilization. It used a distorted version of heredity and fitness to justify prejudice, so it is an example of applying theory in a discriminatory way.
Why is a study of identical twins who were separated at birth especially useful for researchers on nature and nurture?
Show answer
The twins have the same genes but grew up in different environments, so similarities between them are more likely to come from heredity than from a shared upbringing.
Every thought, movement, and feeling depends on a communication network that reaches from your brain to your fingertips and organs. The nervous system is that network. It collects information from the body and the world, decides what to do with it, and sends instructions back out. This lesson maps the system's divisions and what each does. It is a short topic, but the map is used constantly in later lessons: the autonomic nervous system returns in the study of stress and emotion, and the brain structures come in Lesson 1.9.
Required content · 1.2.A
Learning objective.
1.2.A. Differentiate among the subsystems of the human nervous system and their functions.
Essential knowledge.
1.2.A.1. The central nervous system includes the brain and the spinal cord and interacts with all processes in the body.
1.2.A.2. The peripheral nervous system relays messages from the central nervous system to the rest of the body and includes the autonomic and somatic nervous systems.
1.2.A.2.i. The autonomic nervous system governs processes that are involuntary and includes the parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous systems.
1.2.A.2.ii. The somatic nervous system governs processes that are voluntary. 1.A 3.A
Two main parts: central and peripheral
The central nervous system (CNS) is the brain and the spinal cord. The brain is the control center that interprets information and directs responses, and the spinal cord is a bundle of neurons running down the back that carries messages between the brain and the rest of the body and also handles some simple reflexes by itself. The CNS interacts with all the processes in the body.
The peripheral nervous system (PNS) is made up of all the nerves outside the brain and spinal cord. Its job is to relay messages between the CNS and the rest of the body. Information flows both ways: sensory (afferent) neurons carry information from the senses and organs toward the CNS, and motor (efferent) neurons carry commands away from the CNS to muscles and glands. A simple memory aid is that afferent neurons arrive at the CNS and efferent neurons exit it.
The two divisions of the peripheral nervous system
The PNS has two parts, which differ in whether you control them.
The somatic nervous system governs processes that are voluntary. It carries sensory information from the skin, eyes, and other sense organs and sends the motor commands that move your skeletal muscles, as when you lift your hand to answer a question, walk to class, or write a sentence.
The autonomic nervous system (ANS) governs processes that are involuntary: the activity of organs and glands that run without your deciding, such as heart rate, breathing rate, digestion, and pupil size. ("Autonomic" is related to "automatic.")
The autonomic nervous system: sympathetic and parasympathetic
The autonomic nervous system has two subdivisions that usually work in opposite directions and balance each other.
The sympathetic nervous system prepares the body for action and responds to stress or danger. When it is active the heart beats faster, breathing quickens, pupils widen, digestion slows, and stress hormones, notably adrenaline, are released. This is the fight, flight, or freeze response: the body mobilizes its resources to confront a threat, escape it, or hold still. The parasympathetic nervous system calms the body and conserves energy after the threat has passed. It slows the heart, lowers breathing, and restarts digestion, sometimes described as "rest and digest."
Division
Voluntary?
What it does
Example
Central nervous system
Both
Brain and spinal cord process information and direct responses
Deciding what to say
Somatic nervous system
Voluntary
Senses and skeletal muscle movement
Raising your hand
Sympathetic nervous system
Involuntary
Arouses the body for action
Pounding heart before a speech
Parasympathetic nervous system
Involuntary
Calms the body and conserves energy
Heart rate settling after the speech
The two sides do not work like an on/off switch. Most of the time both are active, and their balance shifts with circumstances. Before a presentation the sympathetic side dominates; afterward the parasympathetic side restores calm. A person who stays chronically aroused, with the sympathetic system active for long periods, is at higher risk for stress-related health problems, which Unit 5 returns to.
Study spotlight · Cannon and the fight-or-flight response (1915)
The American physiologist Walter Cannon studied how animals' bodies change when they are frightened or enraged. In experiments with cats and other animals he observed that threat produced a coordinated set of changes, including faster heartbeat, release of adrenaline, widened pupils, and slowed digestion, which prepared the animal either to fight or to flee. He named this the "fight-or-flight" response, and later researchers added "freeze." Cannon argued that the response is adaptive because it mobilizes energy when action is needed.
Reading the research: a set of controlled laboratory observations in animals, linking a stimulus (threat) to measured bodily responses. A limitation is that the work was done on animals, so researchers had to confirm that humans respond similarly.
Worked example · Which system is acting?
Name the division most directly involved in each: (a) lifting a pencil to write, (b) your pupils widening when you walk into a dark room, (c) your heart racing when you hear a loud noise behind you, (d) your digestion resuming and your heart slowing down once you realize the noise was a dropped book, (e) a message from your skin to your brain telling you the pan is hot.
Step 1, (a) is voluntary muscle movement, so the somatic nervous system (motor neurons).
Step 2, (b) is involuntary control of an organ (the iris), so the autonomic nervous system.
Step 3, (c) is an involuntary arousal response to a sudden threat, so the sympathetic division.
Step 4, (d) is the return to calm, so the parasympathetic division.
Step 5, (e) is sensory information traveling toward the CNS, carried by sensory (afferent) neurons of the peripheral nervous system, which are part of the somatic system when they carry information from the skin.
Worked example · Reading data from the nervous system
A researcher measures the heart rate (beats per minute) of 6 students at three times: resting at baseline, during a surprise oral presentation, and 10 minutes after it. The averages are 72, 98, and 76. Interpret the data.
Step 1, identify the variable: heart rate in beats per minute, a measure of autonomic activity, in a repeated-measures sample of 6 students.
Step 2, during the presentation the mean rose by \(98-72=26\) beats per minute, which is consistent with sympathetic activation.
Step 3, after 10 minutes the mean fell to 76, only \(76-72=4\) above baseline, consistent with the parasympathetic system restoring calm.
Step 4, limitations: only 6 participants, so this cannot be generalized widely. Without a control group (students who did not present) the researchers cannot be sure that the presentation, not something else such as caffeine or exercise, caused the change, although the stress of presenting is a plausible explanation.
Exam focus
CNS = brain + spinal cord. PNS = everything else; it relays messages and has somatic (voluntary) and autonomic (involuntary) parts.
The autonomic system has the sympathetic (arousal, fight-flight-freeze) and parasympathetic (calming, rest and digest) divisions.
Sensory (afferent) neurons carry information toward the CNS; motor (efferent) neurons carry commands away from it.
Match behaviors to systems: voluntary movement is somatic; heartbeat, digestion, and pupil size are autonomic.
Practice
Which nervous system divisions make up the peripheral nervous system, and how do they differ?
Show answer
The somatic nervous system (voluntary: skeletal muscles and senses) and the autonomic nervous system (involuntary: organs and glands, including the sympathetic and parasympathetic divisions).
After a near-miss in traffic, a driver's heart pounds and her palms sweat. Which division is responsible, and what does it do?
Show answer
The sympathetic division of the autonomic nervous system. It arouses the body for a threat (fight, flight, or freeze) by speeding the heart, quickening breathing, and releasing adrenaline.
Why is the parasympathetic nervous system important after a stressful event?
Show answer
It calms the body: it slows the heart rate and breathing and restores digestion, conserving energy and returning the body to its resting state.
A person touches a hot stove. Describe the direction of messages carried by sensory and motor neurons.
Show answer
Sensory (afferent) neurons carry the pain message from the skin to the central nervous system. Motor (efferent) neurons carry the command away from the CNS to the muscles that pull the hand back.
A person with a spinal cord injury cannot move their legs but still digests food normally. Which divisions might explain the difference?
Show answer
Movement of the legs depends on motor commands in the somatic system that travel through the spinal cord, which was damaged. Digestion is controlled by the autonomic system, which can operate without voluntary commands.
State one limitation of drawing a conclusion about humans from Cannon's animal work.
Show answer
Animal bodies and brains differ from humans', so the same pattern of responses must be confirmed in people before it can be generalized.
Your brain contains roughly 86 billion neurons, and everything you think or do depends on how they pass messages among themselves. The AP Exam asks about this process of neural communication rather than about memorizing parts, so this lesson concentrates on what a neuron does and how a message moves: how a signal is triggered, how it travels, and what happens when the process is disrupted. The next lesson covers the chemical messengers that carry the signal across the gap between neurons, and the drugs that interfere with them.
Required content · 1.3.A, 1.3.B
Learning objectives.
1.3.A. Explain how the structures and functions of typical neurons in the central nervous system affect behavior and mental processes.
1.3.B. Explain how the basic process of neural transmission is related to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.3.A.1. Two common types of neural cells in the brain are neurons (neural cells that transmit information) and glial cells (cells that provide structure, insulation, communication, and waste transport). These types of cells form the basis of the nervous system and are the building blocks of all behavior and mental processes.
1.3.A.2. In the spinal cord, the reflex arc demonstrates how neurons within the central and peripheral nervous systems work together to respond to stimuli. Three types of neurons work together in the spinal cord to create a reflex arc: sensory neurons, motor neurons, and interneurons.
1.3.B.1. The process of neural transmission most commonly occurs in an orderly, systematic way and involves the all-or-none principle, depolarization, refractory period, resting potential, reuptake, and threshold. Disruptions to this process could lead to disorders such as multiple sclerosis or myasthenia gravis. Exclusion Statement: The sodium-potassium pump is outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam. 1.A 2.A 3.A
Two kinds of cells
The nervous system is built from two types of cells. Neurons are the cells that transmit information. Glial cells do not carry messages themselves but support the neurons: they provide structure, insulate neurons, help with communication, and carry away waste. Together, these cells form the basis of the nervous system and of all behavior and mental processes.
A typical neuron has a cell body (soma) containing the nucleus, branching dendrites that receive messages from other neurons, a long axon that carries the message away from the cell body, and terminal buttons at the end of the axon that send the message on. Many axons are wrapped in a fatty myelin sheath, which insulates the axon and makes the signal travel much faster, like the plastic coating on a wire.
Figure 1.4. A neuron. Dendrites receive messages, the cell body integrates them, and if the neuron fires an action potential travels down the axon (faster along the myelin sheath) to the terminal buttons, which release neurotransmitter into the synapse.
The reflex arc
The spinal cord shows how neurons work together. When you touch a hot pan, you pull your hand back before you consciously feel the pain. This is a reflex arc, an automatic response that goes through the spinal cord without waiting for the brain. Three types of neurons are involved:
A sensory neuron detects the stimulus (heat) and carries the message to the spinal cord.
An interneuron in the spinal cord connects the incoming sensory message to the outgoing response. Interneurons are the most numerous neurons in the body, and in the brain they connect neurons to each other.
A motor neuron carries the command to the muscle, which pulls the hand away.
A message travels to the brain at the same time, which is why you then feel the pain and decide what to do about the burn. The reflex arc is useful because the shortcut saves time when speed matters.
How a neuron fires
Neural communication follows an orderly sequence. A neuron is not simply "on" or "off"; it is an electrical device that can be pushed over a limit.
Resting potential. When a neuron is not being stimulated, the inside of the cell is slightly negative compared with the outside, with a voltage of about −70 millivolts. The neuron is polarized, "at rest," ready to respond.
Threshold. Signals from other neurons arrive at the dendrites. Some are excitatory (they make an action potential more likely) and some are inhibitory (they make it less likely). The neuron adds them up. If the total reaches a minimum level of stimulation, called the threshold (about −55 millivolts), the neuron fires. If the total falls short, nothing happens.
Depolarization and the action potential. At threshold, channels in the axon open and positively charged particles (sodium ions) rush in, making the inside of the cell briefly positive. This sudden change in voltage is the action potential (the neural impulse). The change, called depolarization, triggers the same change in the next section of the axon, so the impulse travels down the axon like a wave. In a myelinated axon the impulse jumps along the gaps in the myelin, which is why myelin makes it faster.
Release. When the impulse reaches the terminal buttons, the neuron releases chemical messengers (neurotransmitters) into the synapse, the tiny gap between neurons.
Refractory period. After firing, the neuron needs a short time to reset. During this refractory period it cannot fire again, however strong the stimulus. The membrane returns to its resting potential.
Reuptake. Neurotransmitter molecules left in the synapse are reabsorbed by the sending neuron, which clears the gap and ends the message. This is reuptake. The next lesson covers what this means for drugs.
Figure 1.5. Voltage across the membrane over time. At rest the neuron sits near −70 mV. A stimulus that raises it to threshold (about −55 mV) triggers the all-or-none action potential, and the shaded refractory period follows, during which the neuron cannot fire again.
The all-or-none principle
The all-or-none principle says that a neuron either fires completely or does not fire at all, and every action potential in a given neuron has the same strength. A stronger stimulus does not make a bigger impulse. Instead, a stronger stimulus makes the neuron fire more often (a higher rate of action potentials) and recruits more neurons to fire, and that is how the nervous system distinguishes a light touch from a hard push. An analogy is a toilet or a gun: pushing the handle or trigger harder does not change what happens once it has been triggered, but you may fire again sooner.
When the process is disrupted
Because neural communication depends on an orderly process, disruptions cause disorders. Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a disease in which the body's immune system attacks the myelin sheath of neurons in the central nervous system. Without healthy myelin, signals slow down or fail, and people experience problems with vision, balance, muscle control, and sensation. The next lesson describes a second example, myasthenia gravis, which involves the chemical step of the process. You are not required to know how the sodium-potassium pump works; just remember the sequence above and what happens when it breaks down.
Study spotlight · Measuring the speed of the nerve impulse (Helmholtz, 1850)
In the nineteenth century people believed that nerve messages traveled almost instantly, like thought. The German scientist Hermann von Helmholtz tested that idea by stimulating a frog's nerve at two different distances from the muscle and measuring the time it took the muscle to twitch. The difference in time divided into the difference in distance gave the speed of the impulse. It was far slower than electricity in a wire, on the order of tens of meters per second in that preparation. Later work found that myelinated axons in humans conduct impulses at more than 100 meters per second.
Reading the research: a controlled laboratory experiment in which the independent variable was the distance from the muscle and the dependent variable was the time to twitch. It established that neural transmission is a physical process that takes time. A limitation is that the early measurements used a frog nerve and were later refined for humans.
Worked example · Does the neuron fire?
A neuron has a resting potential of −70 mV and a threshold of −55 mV. Four stimuli shift its voltage to −62 mV, −56 mV, −54 mV, and −20 mV. Which stimuli cause an action potential, and how do the resulting impulses compare?
Step 1, compare each level with the threshold of −55 mV. A voltage of −62 mV is below (more negative than) the threshold, so no firing. −56 mV is also below, so no firing.
Step 2, −54 mV has crossed the threshold, so the neuron fires. So does −20 mV.
Step 3, compare the impulses: by the all-or-none principle, the action potentials at −54 mV and −20 mV have the same size. The stronger stimulus (−20 mV) does not make a larger impulse.
Step 4, what changes with stimulus strength: the stronger stimulus would make the neuron fire more frequently, and would likely activate more neurons.
Worked example · Tracing a reflex
You step on a sharp piece of glass. Describe the path of the message and name the neurons.
Step 1, a sensory neuron in the foot detects the stimulus and fires, sending the impulse along its axon to the spinal cord.
Step 2, in the spinal cord an interneuron receives the signal and passes it to a motor neuron without waiting for a decision from the brain.
Step 3, the motor neuron's impulse travels to the leg muscles, and they contract to lift the foot.
Step 4, at the same time the message goes up the spinal cord to the brain, which interprets it as pain. This is why you pull away first and feel the pain a moment later.
Worked example · Interpreting a graph
A graph of a neuron's voltage over time shows a flat line at −70 mV, a rise to about −55 mV, a sharp spike to about +40 mV, a drop below −70 mV, and a return to −70 mV. Identify each phase.
Step 1, the flat line at −70 mV is the resting potential.
Step 2, the rise to −55 mV is the stimulus bringing the neuron to threshold. The point where the sudden spike begins is the threshold.
Step 3, the spike to +40 mV is depolarization and the action potential.
Step 4, the drop below −70 mV and slow return is the refractory period, when the neuron cannot fire again until it resets.
Step 5, if a second stimulus arrived during the refractory period, the neuron would not fire, however strong the stimulus.
Exam focus
Neurons transmit information; glial cells support, insulate, and clean up. A reflex arc uses a sensory neuron, an interneuron, and a motor neuron in the spinal cord.
The sequence: resting potential, then enough excitation to reach threshold, then depolarization (action potential), then refractory period, then reuptake of the neurotransmitter.
All-or-none principle: every action potential has the same size; stimulus strength changes the rate of firing and the number of neurons.
Multiple sclerosis (damaged myelin) is an example of disrupted neural transmission. The sodium-potassium pump is outside the scope of the exam.
Practice
Name the three neuron types in a reflex arc and give the job of each.
Show answer
Sensory neurons carry the message from the stimulus to the spinal cord; interneurons connect the sensory message to the response within the spinal cord; motor neurons carry the command to the muscle.
Explain the all-or-none principle. How can a neuron signal that a stimulus is stronger?
Show answer
A neuron either fires with full strength or does not fire. A stronger stimulus makes it fire more frequently, and more neurons are activated, rather than making a stronger single impulse.
What is the refractory period, and why is it important?
Show answer
It is the brief time after an action potential when the neuron cannot fire again while it resets. It keeps impulses moving in one direction and limits how fast the neuron can fire.
How does damage to the myelin sheath, as in multiple sclerosis, affect behavior?
Show answer
Without myelin the impulses travel more slowly or fail, so signals do not reach their targets properly. This produces problems with movement, balance, vision, and sensation.
A neuron's threshold is −55 mV. Will a stimulus that moves its voltage from −70 mV to −58 mV make it fire? Explain.
Show answer
No. The voltage did not reach the threshold of −55 mV, so there is no action potential, and by the all-or-none principle there is no partial impulse.
What is the function of the glial cells?
Show answer
They support neurons: providing structure, insulation (including myelin), communication, and waste removal.
Neurotransmitters, hormones, and psychoactive drugs
An action potential cannot jump across the synapse. To pass a message to the next neuron, the sending neuron releases chemicals, and these chemical messengers are what the exam asks you to connect to behavior and mental processes: which messenger does what, how hormones act like neurotransmitters but elsewhere in the body, and how drugs change behavior by changing the way these chemicals work. The exam limits its questions to the neurotransmitters and hormones listed in this lesson, so you can study them with confidence.
Required content · 1.3.B, 1.3.C
Learning objectives.
1.3.B. Explain how the basic process of neural transmission is related to behavior and mental processes.
1.3.C. Explain how psychoactive drugs affect behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.3.B.2. Each neurotransmitter has specific function(s) related to behavior and mental processes, which may depend on the neurotransmitter’s location in the nervous system. Neurotransmitters generally communicate either excitatory (making an action potential more likely) or inhibitory (making an action potential less likely) messages. Neurotransmitters related to behavior and mental processes for study in AP Psychology are limited to dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine, glutamate, GABA, endorphins, substance p, and acetylcholine. Exclusion Statement: The AP Psychology Exam will only address the listed neurotransmitters in EK 1.3.B.2.
1.3.B.3. Outside of the nervous system, hormones perform actions similar to neurotransmitters. Hormones related to behavior and mental processes for study in AP Psychology are limited to adrenaline, leptin, ghrelin, melatonin, and oxytocin. Exclusion Statement: The AP Psychology Exam will only address the listed hormones in EK 1.3.B.3. Exclusion Statement: Specific information about the glands of the endocrine system (with the exception of the pituitary gland as referenced in EK 1.4.A.4) is outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
1.3.C.1. Psychoactive drugs can influence neurotransmitter function in various ways throughout the neural communication process. Some act as agonists which encourage neural firing. Some act as antagonists which discourage neural firing. Some act as reuptake inhibitors which block the reabsorption of neurotransmitters back into the cell.
1.3.C.2. Psychoactive drugs have psychological and physiological effects.
1.3.C.2.i. Stimulants, such as caffeine and cocaine, typically cause increased neural activity.
1.3.C.2.ii. Depressants, such as alcohol, typically cause decreased neural activity.
1.3.C.2.iii. Hallucinogens, such as marijuana, typically cause distortions in perception and/or cognition.
1.3.C.2.iv. Opioids, such as heroin, typically act as pain relievers.
1.3.C.3. Psychoactive drug use can lead to tolerance and/or addiction. Addiction can create significant withdrawal symptoms if the psychoactive drugs are no longer consumed.
Crossing the synapse
When an action potential reaches the terminal buttons, the neuron releases neurotransmitters into the synapse. These molecules drift across the gap and fit into receptor sites on the next neuron's dendrites, somewhat like a key fitting a lock. A neurotransmitter generally sends one of two kinds of message. An excitatory message makes the receiving neuron more likely to fire an action potential, and an inhibitory message makes it less likely to fire. The receiving neuron adds up all the excitatory and inhibitory messages it receives and fires only if it reaches threshold. Afterward the neurotransmitter is cleared from the synapse, most often by reuptake, when the sending neuron reabsorbs it.
Each neurotransmitter has specific functions related to behavior and mental processes, and these may depend on where in the nervous system it is released. The ones to know are the following.
Neurotransmitter
Main roles
Links to disorders and drugs
Dopamine
Reward and motivation, pleasure, voluntary movement, attention
Too little is linked to the tremors and movement problems of Parkinson's disease; excess activity is hypothesized to be linked to schizophrenia; many addictive drugs raise dopamine
Serotonin
Mood, sleep, appetite, and arousal
Low levels are linked to depression; common antidepressants raise serotonin activity
Norepinephrine
Alertness, arousal, attention, and the stress response
Involved in the body's response to stress; stimulants increase it
Glutamate
The main excitatory transmitter of the brain; learning and memory
Too much can overexcite and damage neurons
GABA
The main inhibitory transmitter of the brain; calms neural activity
Low GABA is linked to anxiety, and alcohol and antianxiety drugs boost GABA
Endorphins
The body's natural pain relievers; pleasure, such as the "runner's high"
Opioid drugs mimic them
Substance P
Carries pain messages to the brain
Part of how pain is felt
Acetylcholine
Muscle contraction, learning, and memory
Lower levels are linked to Alzheimer's disease; myasthenia gravis (see below)
Myasthenia gravis is the second example the course gives of a disrupted neural process. In this disease the immune system attacks the receptors for acetylcholine on muscles, so the signal from motor neurons cannot be received properly and muscles become weak and tire easily. It shows that a problem at the synapse, not in the neuron itself, can disrupt behavior.
Hormones
The endocrine system is a set of glands that release hormones, chemical messengers that travel through the bloodstream to affect distant organs and behavior. Outside the nervous system, hormones perform actions similar to neurotransmitters. They act more slowly than neurotransmitters, which work across a synapse in milliseconds, but their effects last longer. The exam limits hormones to the following, and does not require specific glands except the pituitary, which you will meet in the brain lessons (the hypothalamus controls the pituitary, which in turn signals other glands).
Adrenaline (epinephrine) is released during stress and arousal, speeding the heart and mobilizing energy for the fight-or-flight response.
Leptin is released by fat cells and signals that you are full (satiety), reducing hunger.
Ghrelin is released by the stomach and signals that you are hungry.
Melatonin is released in response to darkness and helps regulate the sleep and wake cycle by making you sleepy.
Oxytocin is involved in bonding and trust, in childbirth, and in the bond between mother and infant.
Study spotlight · Loewi and the chemical messenger (1921)
The physiologist Otto Loewi wanted to know whether nerves influence organs by electricity or by chemicals. He prepared two frog hearts in separate baths of fluid. Stimulating the vagus nerve of the first heart slowed its beat. Loewi then collected the fluid bathing the first heart and transferred it to the second heart, which also slowed down, even though no nerve to it had been stimulated. He concluded that stimulation had released a chemical (later identified as acetylcholine) and that the chemical, not electricity, carried the message.
Reading the research: a controlled laboratory experiment. The independent variable was the fluid (from a stimulated heart or not), and the dependent variable was the heart rate of the second heart. The study provided the first evidence of chemical neurotransmission. A limitation is that frog hearts are far simpler than the human brain, and the finding had to be extended to the central nervous system by later studies.
Psychoactive drugs and the synapse
A psychoactive drug is a chemical that changes perception, mood, thinking, or behavior by altering the activity of neurotransmitters. Drugs can interfere with neural communication at several points in the process.
An agonist mimics a neurotransmitter or increases its effect, so it encourages neural firing. For example, opioid drugs mimic endorphins, binding to endorphin receptors and relieving pain.
An antagonist blocks a neurotransmitter's receptors or reduces its effect, so it discourages firing. An example is curare, a poison that blocks acetylcholine receptors on muscles and causes paralysis.
A reuptake inhibitor blocks the reabsorption of the neurotransmitter by the sending neuron, so the neurotransmitter stays in the synapse longer and keeps stimulating the receiving neuron. Common antidepressants (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, SSRIs) block the reuptake of serotonin. Cocaine blocks the reuptake of dopamine, producing a rush of pleasure.
Types of psychoactive drugs
The exam classifies psychoactive drugs by their typical effects:
Stimulants, such as caffeine and cocaine, typically increase neural activity, raising alertness, energy, and heart rate.
Depressants, such as alcohol, typically decrease neural activity, slowing reaction time and judgment, and lower inhibitions at first.
Hallucinogens, such as marijuana, typically distort perception and cognition. (The course places marijuana in this category.)
Opioids, such as heroin, typically act as pain relievers and also produce euphoria and drowsiness.
Tolerance, addiction, and withdrawal
With repeated use, the body adapts to many drugs. Tolerance means a person needs larger doses to get the same effect, because the nervous system adjusts. Addiction is a compulsive need to use a drug despite harmful consequences. When a person who has become dependent stops using the drug, withdrawal symptoms, such as anxiety, sweating, tremors, or intense cravings, can result, and these can be severe. The brain's reward circuits, which depend on dopamine, are involved in addiction, which is why quitting is so hard and why treatment is a medical and psychological matter, not a matter of willpower alone.
Worked example · Naming the drug action
For each, say whether the drug is acting as an agonist, antagonist, or reuptake inhibitor. (a) A pain medication binds to endorphin receptors and relieves pain. (b) A drug binds to acetylcholine receptors on muscle cells without activating them, so acetylcholine cannot get in. (c) A medication prevents the sending neuron from reabsorbing serotonin, so more remains in the synapse.
Step 1, (a) the drug fits the receptors and produces the effect the neurotransmitter would, so it is an agonist.
Step 2, (b) the drug occupies the receptors and blocks the natural messenger, so it is an antagonist.
Step 3, (c) the serotonin stays in the synapse longer because reuptake is blocked, so it is a reuptake inhibitor.
Step 4, effect on firing: an agonist and a reuptake inhibitor encourage firing at the affected synapse; an antagonist discourages it.
Worked example · Tolerance and withdrawal
Maya has been drinking several cups of strong coffee each morning for years. Now it takes four cups to feel as alert as one cup once did, and when she skipped coffee on a trip she had a headache, fatigue, and irritability. Identify the concepts.
Step 1, caffeine is a stimulant: it increases neural activity, which explains the alertness.
Step 2, needing four cups for an effect that once took one is tolerance: her nervous system has adapted to the drug.
Step 3, the headache, fatigue, and irritability after stopping are withdrawal symptoms, which show physical dependence.
Step 4, whether to call this addiction depends on whether she uses it compulsively in spite of harm; the key idea is that tolerance and withdrawal are separate, observable outcomes of repeated use.
Worked example · Neurotransmitter or hormone?
After skipping lunch, a student feels hungry. The stomach releases ghrelin into the bloodstream, which signals the brain. Later, after a big meal, fat cells release leptin and the student feels full. Meanwhile, at the synapse between two neurons in the brain's reward circuit, dopamine is released and received in milliseconds. Compare the two kinds of chemical messengers.
Step 1, ghrelin and leptin are hormones. They are released by glands or cells outside the nervous system and travel in the bloodstream to distant targets.
Step 2, dopamine is a neurotransmitter: it is released by a neuron into a synapse and acts on the neighboring neuron.
Step 3, speed and duration: neurotransmitter messages are very fast and brief, hormone messages are slower but last longer.
Step 4, similarity: both are chemical messengers that bind to receptors and change the activity of the target cells.
Exam focus
Know only the listed messengers: dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine, glutamate, GABA, endorphins, substance P, acetylcholine; hormones: adrenaline, leptin, ghrelin, melatonin, oxytocin.
Neurotransmitters are excitatory or inhibitory (glutamate and GABA are the main examples).
Agonist = mimics or boosts; antagonist = blocks; reuptake inhibitor = keeps the transmitter in the synapse.
Match each to its role: (a) ghrelin, (b) melatonin, (c) endorphins, (d) GABA.
Show answer
(a) signals hunger; (b) helps regulate sleep and wake cycles by promoting sleepiness; (c) the body's natural pain relievers; (d) the main inhibitory neurotransmitter, which calms neural activity.
What is the difference between a neurotransmitter and a hormone?
Show answer
A neurotransmitter is released by a neuron into a synapse and acts quickly on the neighboring neuron. A hormone is released by a gland or cell into the bloodstream, acts more slowly on distant targets, and its effect lasts longer.
A drug increases the amount of serotonin in the synapse by blocking its reabsorption. Name the action and one likely benefit.
Show answer
It is a reuptake inhibitor. Because serotonin is linked to mood, it is used to treat depression.
Why do heroin and other opioids relieve pain?
Show answer
They act as agonists for endorphin receptors: they mimic the body's natural pain relievers and bind to the same receptors.
A person who has used a depressant for years now needs a larger amount to feel the same effect, and gets shaky and anxious when stopping. Name the two concepts.
Show answer
Tolerance (needing more for the same effect) and withdrawal (symptoms when stopping).
What does Loewi's experiment show about how a nerve signal affects an organ?
Show answer
It showed that the signal is carried by a chemical: fluid from a stimulated heart slowed a second heart, so the chemical released by the nerve (acetylcholine) carried the message, not electricity alone.
The brain is about three pounds of tissue that produce every thought, memory, and emotion you will ever have. No single structure does everything, and the exam does not ask you to name parts for their own sake. It asks you to predict what happens to behavior and mental processes when a region is damaged or active: if a person can no longer recognize faces, what region would you suspect? This lesson organizes the brain from the bottom up, from the structures that keep you alive to the cortex that lets you plan, and the next lesson covers specialization of the two hemispheres, plasticity, and how scientists study the living brain.
Required content · 1.4.A
Learning objective.
1.4.A. Explain how the structures and functions of the brain apply to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.4.A.1. The brain stem (including the medulla) generally controls basic functioning such as breathing and heart rate.
1.4.A.2. The reticular activating system and the brain’s reward center generally control alertness, some voluntary movement, eye movement, and some types of learning, cognition, and emotion.
1.4.A.3. The cerebellum generally controls coordination of muscle movement, balance, and some forms of procedural learning.
1.4.A.4. The cerebral cortex is divided into two hemispheres and includes the limbic system (thalamus, hypothalamus, pituitary gland, hippocampus, amygdala), corpus callosum, and the lobes of the cortex.
1.4.A.4.i. The occipital lobes generally control visual information processing and are located in the rear of the brain.
1.4.A.4.ii. The temporal lobes generally control auditory and linguistic processing and are located on the sides of the brain. 1.A 2.C 2.D 3.A
1.4.A.4.iii. The parietal lobes generally control association areas, which process and organize information, and the somatosensory cortex, which processes touch sensitivity. These lobes are located near the back crown of the brain.
1.4.A.4.iv. The frontal lobes, located just behind the forehead, generally control linguistic processing, higher-order thinking, and executive functioning, especially in the prefrontal cortex. The motor cortex is located at the rear of the frontal lobes and controls most types of skeletal movement.
The brain stem, the cerebellum, and the reticular formation
The brain stem is the oldest part of the brain, where the spinal cord enters the skull. It controls basic life functions that you do not think about, such as breathing and heart rate. Its lowest part, the medulla, regulates these. Damage to the brain stem is often fatal.
The reticular activating system (RAS) is a network of neurons that runs through the brain stem and up toward the cortex. It controls alertness and arousal, so it helps you stay awake and attentive and filters incoming stimuli, and it plays a role in some voluntary movement, eye movement, and some types of learning, cognition, and emotion. The brain's reward center, a set of pathways that release dopamine when something pleasurable happens, is also part of this deeper circuitry. It motivates you to repeat behaviors such as eating, social contact, and, unfortunately, drug use.
The cerebellum ("little brain") sits at the back of the brain below the cortex. It coordinates the timing and smoothness of muscle movement, balance, and some forms of procedural learning, the learning of skills such as riding a bike or typing. A person with cerebellar damage may appear clumsy or unsteady, as if intoxicated, even though the person can still decide to move.
The limbic system
Between the brain stem and the cortex lies the limbic system, a set of structures involved in emotion, motivation, and memory. The exam includes five:
The thalamus is the brain's sensory relay station. It receives information from the senses (all except smell) and sends it on to the appropriate part of the cortex.
The hypothalamus is a small structure that regulates hunger, thirst, body temperature, sleep cycles, and sexual behavior. It also controls the pituitary gland.
The pituitary gland is the "master gland" of the endocrine system. Under the hypothalamus's direction, it releases hormones that influence growth and other glands. It connects the nervous system to the hormone system.
The hippocampus is important for forming new explicit memories, those you can consciously recall, such as facts and events. Damage makes it hard to form new memories.
The amygdala processes emotion, especially fear and aggression. It helps attach emotional significance to events, which is why frightening experiences are remembered so well.
The cerebral cortex
The cerebral cortex is the thin, wrinkled outer layer of the brain, where complex thought, perception, and planning take place. The folds increase its surface area. It is divided into two hemispheres, left and right, connected by a thick band of nerve fibers called the corpus callosum, which lets the hemispheres communicate. Each hemisphere is divided into four lobes.
Figure 1.6. The left side of the brain. The central groove divides the frontal lobe (with the motor cortex just in front of it) from the parietal lobe (with the somatosensory cortex just behind it). The temporal lobe lies below the lateral groove and the occipital lobe is at the back.
The occipital lobes, at the back of the brain, process visual information. Damage can cause blindness even when the eyes are healthy.
The temporal lobes, on the sides of the brain (above the ears), process auditory information and take part in linguistic processing, including understanding speech.
The parietal lobes, near the back crown of the brain, contain association areas that process and organize information and the somatosensory cortex, which processes touch sensation (pressure, temperature, pain) from the body.
The frontal lobes, just behind the forehead, are involved in speaking, higher-order thinking, and executive functioning (planning, judgment, decision making, and self-control), especially in the prefrontal cortex. The motor cortex, at the back of the frontal lobes, controls most voluntary skeletal movement.
The sensory and motor cortex strips lie next to each other, separated by the central groove that divides the frontal and parietal lobes. Parts of the body with more sensitivity (the fingertips, the lips) or finer control (the fingers, the tongue) have more cortex devoted to them than parts such as the back.
Region
Main functions
Example of damage effect
Brain stem (medulla)
Breathing, heart rate
Loss of vital functions
Reticular activating system
Alertness, arousal
Coma or inability to stay alert
Cerebellum
Coordination, balance, procedural learning
Clumsy, unsteady movement
Thalamus
Relays sensory information
Disrupted sensation
Hypothalamus
Hunger, thirst, temperature, controls pituitary
Disrupted eating or body temperature
Hippocampus
Forming new explicit memories
Trouble forming new memories
Amygdala
Fear, aggression, emotional memory
Reduced fear response
Occipital lobe
Vision
Vision loss, trouble recognizing objects
Temporal lobe
Hearing and language
Trouble understanding sounds or speech
Parietal lobe
Touch, association
Trouble with touch and spatial tasks
Frontal lobe
Executive functions, speech, movement
Poor planning, impulse control, weak movement
Study spotlight · Phineas Gage (1848)
Phineas Gage was a 25-year-old railroad construction foreman in Vermont. In 1848 an explosion drove an iron tamping rod, about 3 feet 7 inches long and an inch and a quarter across, up through his left cheek and out the top of his skull, destroying much of his left frontal lobe. Gage survived and could walk, talk, and work, but accounts by his doctor, John Harlow, described a change in personality: he had been responsible and well liked, and afterward was said to be impulsive and rude. The case suggested that the frontal lobes are involved in planning and regulating behavior.
Reading the research: a case study, a non-experimental method. It is valuable because it is a rare "natural experiment" in which a specific region was damaged. But the evidence is limited: it is a single case, observations were reported by one doctor and were not measured with tests, and later accounts exaggerated the story, so the conclusions must be drawn with care. Case studies suggest hypotheses that other methods can test; they cannot establish cause and effect, and one person may not represent others.
Study spotlight · The brain's reward center (Olds and Milner, 1954)
James Olds and Peter Milner implanted tiny electrodes in the brains of rats, in a region that is part of the reward circuitry, and let the rats press a lever to deliver a brief electrical stimulus to themselves. Some rats pressed the lever hundreds or even thousands of times an hour and chose it over food. The researchers concluded that the stimulation was intensely rewarding and that the brain has a reward center.
Reading the research: an experiment with animals; the independent variable was the placement of the electrode and the dependent variable was the rate of lever pressing. It identified a reward circuit that involves dopamine, which is also implicated in addiction. Because the subjects were animals, the research would be reviewed by an institutional animal care committee, and it is not certain that the same experience occurs in humans.
Worked example · Predicting effects of damage
For each patient, name the likeliest damaged region. (a) She can see normally but cannot recognize objects by their appearance, and a scan shows damage at the back of the head. (b) He cannot form new memories of events, although he remembers his childhood. (c) After a stroke, she walks with a jerky, unsteady gait and cannot touch her nose smoothly, but her thinking is intact. (d) After an accident, he is easily angered, plans poorly, and ignores consequences, though he can move and see normally.
Step 1, (a) the back of the head holds the occipital lobe, which processes vision. Damage there disrupts the processing of visual information.
Step 2, (b) trouble forming new explicit memories with old memories intact points to the hippocampus.
Step 3, (c) poor coordination and balance with intact thinking points to the cerebellum.
Step 4, (d) impulsivity and poor planning are executive functions, so the prefrontal cortex of the frontal lobe.
Worked example · Evaluating a case study
A neurologist reports on a patient whose left temporal lobe was damaged in a stroke. After the stroke, the patient could speak but did not understand words spoken to her. The neurologist concludes that the temporal lobe is "the" center for understanding language. Evaluate the conclusion.
Step 1, the design is a case study of one person. It does not use an IV or random assignment, so it cannot prove that the damage caused the problem.
Step 2, what the case supports: it fits what is known about the temporal lobes' role in auditory and linguistic processing, so it is consistent with that function.
Step 3, limits: with one patient, the finding may not generalize, and the stroke could have damaged other regions that were not examined. Language involves a network of areas, including the frontal lobe.
Step 4, a better conclusion: the temporal lobe is important for understanding speech. Studies using brain scans of many people would give stronger evidence.
A person's vision is lost though her eyes are healthy. Which lobe is most likely damaged, and where is it located?
Show answer
The occipital lobe, at the back of the brain.
What is the function of the hypothalamus, and what is its relationship to the pituitary gland?
Show answer
The hypothalamus regulates hunger, thirst, body temperature, and related drives, and it controls the pituitary gland, which in turn releases hormones that influence other glands.
In what way is the case of Phineas Gage evidence about the frontal lobes, and what are two limitations?
Show answer
After damage to his frontal lobe his behavior reportedly became impulsive, so the frontal lobe is involved in regulating behavior. Limitations: it is a single case, and the reports of his change were subjective and later exaggerated, so it cannot show cause and effect.
Where is the motor cortex, and what is the somatosensory cortex?
Show answer
The motor cortex is at the rear of the frontal lobes and controls voluntary movement. The somatosensory cortex is in the parietal lobe and processes touch sensation.
Explain why Olds and Milner's rats pressed the lever so many times. What brain system does this implicate?
Show answer
The stimulation activated the brain's reward center (a dopamine-related circuit), which made the behavior intensely rewarding, so the rats repeated it.
The two halves of the cerebral cortex look like mirror images, but they do not do identical jobs, and the brain is not fixed once it is built. This lesson covers three ideas the exam tests: the specialization of the hemispheres (shown most dramatically by patients whose hemispheres were separated), the brain's ability to rewire itself after damage or experience, and the tools researchers use to learn how all of this works. It is also a good place to practice evaluating non-experimental research, since much brain research is based on case studies and scans.
Required content · 1.4.A
Learning objective.
1.4.A. Explain how the structures and functions of the brain apply to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.4.A.5. Split brain research, achieved by severing the corpus callosum (often a treatment for severe epilepsy), reveals that the right and left hemispheres of the brain may specialize in different activities and functions.
1.4.A.5.i. Areas of the brain that affect language are typically located in the left hemisphere and include Broca’s area (responsible for speech production) and Wernicke’s area (responsible for speech comprehension). Damage to these parts of the brain can lead to aphasia.
1.4.A.5.ii. Researchers test for cortex specialization with split-brain patients by showing information in each visual field, taking advantage of the brain’s contralateral hemispheric organization.
1.4.A.6. Brain plasticity is the ability of the brain to rewire itself or modify or create new connections throughout development and generally allows for the function of a damaged part of the brain to be assumed by a different part of the brain.
1.4.A.7. Research on the brain is done using scans (including EEG and fMRI), case studies, and surgical procedures (such as lesioning) to promote understanding of how the different structures of the brain work and how the brain functions together as a whole.
Hemispheric specialization and the split brain
For most people the left hemisphere is specialized for language, and the right hemisphere takes a larger role in spatial and some perceptual tasks and in the emotional tone of speech. This is called lateralization. The popular idea that people are "left-brained" or "right-brained" is a myth: the hemispheres cooperate on nearly everything, and the corpus callosum constantly passes information between them.
Two areas in the left hemisphere of most people are important for language. Broca's area, in the frontal lobe, is responsible for speech production. Damage causes labored, halting, telegraphic speech, though the person understands much of what is said. Wernicke's area, in the temporal lobe, is responsible for speech comprehension. Damage causes fluent speech that is full of words but often makes little sense, and the person has trouble understanding language. Damage to either area can lead to aphasia, a loss or impairment of language.
The strongest evidence for specialization comes from split-brain research. To control severe epilepsy, surgeons sometimes cut the corpus callosum, which stops seizures from spreading between the hemispheres. These patients usually function normally in daily life, but carefully designed tests show that their hemispheres cannot share information. The tests rely on the brain's contralateral organization: each hemisphere receives information from, and controls, the opposite side of the body. Because of how the optic nerves cross, anything in the left visual field (what you see to the left of a point of focus) goes to the right hemisphere, and anything in the right visual field goes to the left hemisphere. Researchers present information to just one visual field and ask the patient to respond.
Study spotlight · Sperry and Gazzaniga's split-brain studies (1960s)
Roger Sperry and Michael Gazzaniga tested patients whose corpus callosum had been cut. The patient stared at a dot while an image or word was flashed briefly to one side. When the word was flashed to the right visual field (left hemisphere), the patient could say what it was. When it was flashed to the left visual field (right hemisphere), the patient said they saw nothing, because speech is controlled by the left hemisphere, but the patient's left hand (controlled by the right hemisphere) could pick out the matching object from a group hidden behind a screen. Sperry received a Nobel Prize for this work in 1981.
Reading the research: a set of experiments in which the independent variable was the visual field where the stimulus was shown and the dependent variable was how the patient responded. The participants were a very small number of patients with an unusual medical history, so the findings may not generalize, but the experimental control was strong.
Brain plasticity
Brain plasticity is the brain's ability to rewire itself, modifying existing connections and creating new ones, throughout development. Plasticity is greatest in childhood but continues in adults. It explains why, after damage to one part of the brain such as a stroke, other parts can sometimes take over the function. A young child who has a hemisphere removed to stop severe seizures can often recover remarkable language and movement because the remaining hemisphere takes on both sets of jobs. It also explains why practice changes the brain: learning strengthens certain connections and so physically reorganizes them. A person who loses a sense, such as vision, may find that the cortex area that would have processed it is taken over by another sense, such as touch.
Study spotlight · London taxi drivers (Maguire and colleagues, 2000)
To become a licensed taxi driver in London, a person must memorize the layout of thousands of streets, a process that takes years. The researchers used brain scans (MRI) to compare the brains of 16 licensed taxi drivers with those of 50 other adults who were not taxi drivers. The back part of the hippocampus, which is important for spatial memory, was larger in the taxi drivers, and the amount of time a person had worked as a taxi driver correlated with how large this region was.
Reading the research: a correlational, non-experimental design, so it cannot prove that driving caused the growth, because people with a larger hippocampus might be more likely to become taxi drivers. But the finding that more experience goes with a larger region fits the idea of plasticity.
Ways to study the brain
The brain is difficult to study because it is protected inside the skull and because you cannot ethically cut into a healthy person's brain. The exam names three families of methods.
Brain scans. An EEG (electroencephalogram) records the electrical activity of the brain through electrodes placed on the scalp. It follows changes in activity on a millisecond scale and is the tool used to study sleep stages, but it shows only the surface and does not show where activity comes from precisely. An fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging) measures changes in blood flow (and so activity) in specific regions while a person performs a task, producing detailed images of which areas are active. It has good spatial detail but is slower, taking a few seconds, and is expensive. Other scans, such as the CT and PET scans, show brain structure or metabolic activity.
Case studies of people with brain damage, like Phineas Gage, show what is lost when a region no longer works.
Surgical procedures such as lesioning, which means destroying a small area of brain tissue, were used with animals to learn what a region does (for example, lesioning part of the hypothalamus changes eating). Because it destroys tissue, lesioning is done in animals under review by animal care committees, or used therapeutically in humans for a medical purpose, not in healthy people.
Notice the connection to the research methods lessons. A scan study of healthy people comparing activity across tasks is often correlational; studies that compare scans between conditions with random assignment are experimental; and case studies and lesions in animals are non-experimental or experimental, depending on the design. Always ask what was measured and whether the groups were assigned by the researcher.
Worked example · Predicting a split-brain result
A split-brain patient stares at a dot. The word "SPOON" is flashed briefly on the left side of the screen. What will the patient say when asked what they saw, and what will they do if asked to pick the object with their left hand from a hidden collection?
Step 1, because of contralateral organization, the left visual field goes to the right hemisphere.
Step 2, speech depends on the left hemisphere in most people. The right hemisphere can see the word but cannot tell the speech centers about it, because the corpus callosum is cut. So the patient will probably say "nothing" or "I didn't see anything."
Step 3, the left hand is controlled by the right hemisphere, which knows what it saw, so the patient will probably choose the spoon.
Step 4, the lesson: the two hemispheres each have their own knowledge when disconnected, and language is typically (not always) a left-hemisphere function.
Worked example · Distinguishing Broca's and Wernicke's aphasia
Patient A says, "Want... water... go... kitchen" slowly and with effort but understands questions. Patient B speaks fluently and quickly, but her sentences are a jumble of real words that do not make sense, and she does not respond appropriately when spoken to. Which patient likely has damage to which area?
Step 1, patient A understands but cannot produce smooth speech, so the problem is speech production, which points to Broca's area in the frontal lobe.
Step 2, patient B produces fluent but meaningless speech and cannot comprehend, so the problem is comprehension, which points to Wernicke's area in the temporal lobe.
Step 3, both are types of aphasia, and both areas are typically in the left hemisphere.
Worked example · Choosing a research method
Choose the best method for each question. (a) How does brain activity change second by second when a person falls asleep? (b) Which areas become active when people solve a math problem? (c) What happens to eating when a small region of a rat's hypothalamus is destroyed?
Step 1, (a) requires fast time resolution, so EEG, which records electrical activity continuously.
Step 2, (b) requires locating active regions during a task, so fMRI, which shows detailed images of blood flow.
Step 3, (c) is a question about the effect of removing tissue, so a lesion study in animals, with approval from an animal care committee.
Step 4, in each case, think about what the method allows: scans describe activity (correlation); a lesion in an experiment with a control group can support a cause-and-effect conclusion.
Exam focus
Lateralization: language is usually in the left hemisphere; Broca's area (speech production) and Wernicke's area (comprehension) damage can cause aphasia.
Split-brain research cuts the corpus callosum; contralateral organization means left visual field goes to the right hemisphere. "Left-brain" and "right-brain" types are a myth.
Plasticity: the brain rewires itself, so other regions can take over for damaged ones.
Why can a split-brain patient name an object shown to the right visual field but not the left?
Show answer
The right visual field goes to the left hemisphere, which controls speech, so the patient can name it. The left visual field goes to the right hemisphere, which cannot pass the information to the speech centers because the corpus callosum was cut.
A stroke patient understands what others say but speaks in slow, broken phrases. What area is likely damaged?
Show answer
Broca's area (speech production), in the left frontal lobe.
Explain how brain plasticity could help a child recover after injury to one part of the brain.
Show answer
The brain can form new connections and reorganize so that another region takes over the function of the damaged one, which is most effective in young children.
Which method would you use to see which brain regions are active while a person reads: EEG or fMRI? Why?
Show answer
fMRI, because it provides detailed images of where activity (blood flow) occurs, whereas EEG shows only electrical activity at the scalp with little detail about location.
The taxi driver study found a larger hippocampus in taxi drivers. Why can't the researchers conclude that driving caused the growth?
Show answer
The study is correlational: people with larger hippocampal regions might have been more likely to become taxi drivers (directionality), or some third factor could explain the difference. Only an experiment with random assignment could show cause.
Why is the claim "I am right-brained, so I am more creative" a myth?
Show answer
Both hemispheres work together on nearly all tasks and communicate through the corpus callosum. Hemispheres specialize in some functions, but people are not dominated by one side.
Consciousness, circadian rhythms, and the stages of sleep
You will spend about a third of your life asleep, and while you are asleep your brain is far from idle. Sleep research began with a surprise: in the 1950s, researchers watching sleeping people found that the brain cycles through distinct stages through the night, including a stage in which it is as active as when awake. This lesson covers what consciousness is, how the body clock sets the sleep and wake cycle, and the stages you pass through every night. The next lesson covers dreams, theories of why we sleep, and sleep disorders.
Required content · 1.5.A
Learning objective.
1.5.A. Explain how the sleep/wake cycle affects behavior and mental processes throughout the day and night.
Essential knowledge.
1.5.A.1. Consciousness has varying levels of awareness of thoughts, feelings, behavior, and events in individuals’ internal and external worlds. Sleep and wakefulness are two types of consciousness.
1.5.A.2. The sleep/wake cycle is a circadian rhythm, which in humans is about a 24-hour cycle. Jet lag and shift work are disruptions of the circadian rhythm.
1.5.A.3. The stages of sleep are identified by their specific EEG patterns.
Consciousness
Consciousness is your awareness of your thoughts, feelings, behavior, and the events in the world inside you and around you. It comes in varying levels. When you are alert and focused on a task you are highly aware; when your mind wanders or you daydream, awareness is lower; and in sleep you are mostly unaware of the outside world, though not completely (a parent wakes at a baby's cry). Sleep and wakefulness are two types of consciousness. They are not simple opposites, because the sleeping brain is active in organized ways.
The sleep-wake cycle is a circadian rhythm
A circadian rhythm is a biological cycle that repeats about every 24 hours ("circa" means about and "dian" means day). In humans, the sleep and wake cycle is a circadian rhythm, and body temperature, hormone release, and alertness follow similar daily cycles. The internal clock is set by light. Light that enters the eyes tells the brain it is daytime, and darkness triggers the release of the hormone melatonin, which makes you sleepy. This is one reason bright screens late at night can delay sleep.
When the internal clock is out of step with the outside world, the result is a disruption of the circadian rhythm. Jet lag occurs after traveling quickly across time zones: your body clock is still on home time, so you are sleepy at the wrong hour and awake in the night. Shift work, such as working a night shift, requires staying awake when the body is programmed to sleep, and sleeping when it is programmed to be awake. Both reduce alertness and can harm health and performance.
Study spotlight · Siffre's cave studies (1962)
In 1962 the French geologist Michel Siffre lived alone for two months in a cave deep in a glacier, with no clocks, no sunlight, and no way of knowing the time. He slept and woke when he felt like it and phoned his support team when he woke and when he went to sleep. When he came out, he believed less time had passed than really had (by several weeks), because his days had become longer. His sleep and wake cycle had settled into one a little longer than 24 hours, around 25 hours.
Reading the research: this is a case study of one person (and Siffre later repeated it with others). It suggested that the human body has an internal clock that runs even without cues from the sun, and that it is close to, but not exactly, 24 hours. Because it involved a single participant, the finding was later confirmed in studies with larger samples of volunteers living without time cues.
Measuring sleep: the EEG
Sleep stages are identified by their patterns of brain waves, recorded by an EEG (electroencephalogram), which records the electrical activity of the brain from electrodes on the scalp. Brain waves differ in speed and size. An awake and alert person shows fast, small waves (beta waves). A relaxed, drowsy person shows slower, larger waves (alpha waves). As sleep deepens, the waves become slower and larger still.
The stages of sleep
During a night, a sleeper goes through cycles of about 90 minutes, five or so cycles in an eight-hour night. Each cycle includes four stages of two types.
NREM sleep (non-rapid-eye-movement sleep) has three stages.
Stage 1 is the lightest. The sleeper drifts off, breathing slows, and the waves are slow and irregular. People may experience hypnagogic sensations: vivid sensory experiences like a feeling of falling, a sudden jerk of the body, or seeing images as one is falling asleep. Someone woken from stage 1 often says they were not asleep.
Stage 2 is a deeper light sleep, which takes up about half of the night. The EEG shows bursts of rapid waves called sleep spindles. The sleeper is harder to wake.
Stage 3 is deep, slow-wave sleep, with large, very slow waves (delta waves). It is hardest to wake someone from this stage, and it is when the body does much of its physical restoration. Sleepwalking and night terrors are most common here.
NREM sleep is deepest early in the night, and it decreases in duration with each successive cycle.
REM sleep (rapid-eye-movement sleep) is a very different state. The eyes dart back and forth behind the closed lids, and the brain's EEG looks much like that of someone awake, with fast, irregular waves. Yet the body's large muscles are temporarily paralyzed, and heart rate and breathing are irregular. For these reasons REM sleep is called paradoxical sleep: the brain is highly active while the body is at its most relaxed. Dreaming typically occurs in REM sleep. REM sleep becomes longer with each cycle, so the longest periods of REM come in the final hours before waking. When a person is deprived of REM sleep (for example, by being awakened whenever they enter REM), the brain makes up for it later with extra REM, called REM rebound.
Figure 1.7. A typical night. The sleeper cycles through the stages about every 90 minutes. Stage 3 (deep) sleep is longest in the first cycles and fades, while REM periods (shaded) get longer toward morning.
Study spotlight · The discovery of REM sleep (Aserinsky and Kleitman, 1953; Dement and Kleitman, 1957)
Eugene Aserinsky, a graduate student working with Nathaniel Kleitman at the University of Chicago, noticed that sleepers' eyes moved rapidly at certain times during the night. When he woke people during these periods, they usually reported vivid dreams. William Dement and Kleitman followed up by waking volunteers during REM and non-REM sleep and asking whether they had been dreaming. People woken from REM sleep reported dreaming in most cases (roughly 80 percent), and people woken from non-REM sleep did so rarely. Dement then woke people each time they entered REM, which led to REM rebound on the following nights.
Reading the research: the experiments compared reports collected under different conditions, using physiological measures (EEG and eye movements) rather than relying only on self-report, which strengthened the evidence. A limitation is that participants slept in a laboratory, which is not their usual setting, and dream reports are self-reports that depend on memory.
Worked example · Reading a sleep graph
A graph of a night's sleep shows the sleeper in stage 3 for 40 minutes in the first cycle, 20 minutes in the second, and almost none in the last two. REM periods last about 10 minutes at the start of the night and about 40 minutes just before waking. What patterns do you see?
Step 1, deep (stage 3) sleep is longest early in the night and decreases across the night.
Step 2, REM sleep is shortest early and longest near morning, so it increases across the night.
Step 3, this matches what the exam expects: NREM duration decreases through the cycles and REM frequency and length increase as the night goes on.
Step 4, a practical implication: cutting a night short by a few hours takes away mostly the late REM sleep, which is why people who sleep too little may be missing much of their REM.
Worked example · Identify the stage
Identify the stage of sleep described by each. (a) The EEG shows large, slow delta waves and the sleeper is difficult to wake. (b) The sleeper is vividly dreaming and the EEG resembles wakefulness, but the muscles are paralyzed. (c) The person feels a sudden sensation of falling and a muscle jerk as they drift off. (d) The EEG shows bursts of activity called sleep spindles.
Step 1, (a) is stage 3 (slow-wave) NREM sleep.
Step 2, (b) is REM sleep, called paradoxical because the brain is active while the body is relaxed.
Step 3, (c) is hypnagogic sensation during stage 1.
Step 4, (d) is stage 2 sleep.
Worked example · Jet lag
A student from California flies to London, eight time zones ahead, and has trouble sleeping at night and feels sleepy during the day for several days. Explain.
Step 1, the student's circadian rhythm is still set to California time. When it is bedtime in London (11 p.m.), it is 3 p.m. in California for the body clock, so the student is alert.
Step 2, in the morning in London the body clock is signaling that it is the middle of the night, so the student feels sleepy and groggy.
Step 3, over several days, exposure to the new light and dark pattern resets the clock, and melatonin release shifts, so the symptoms fade. This is a disruption of the circadian rhythm, like the effects of shift work.
Exam focus
Consciousness has varying levels; sleep and wakefulness are two types.
The sleep-wake cycle is a circadian rhythm (about 24 hours); jet lag and shift work disrupt it; melatonin helps regulate it.
NREM stages 1 to 3 (stage 1 includes hypnagogic sensations; stage 3 has slow delta waves) and REM (paradoxical: active brain, relaxed body, dreaming). NREM decreases and REM increases across the night. REM rebound follows REM deprivation.
Sleep stages are identified by EEG patterns.
Practice
What is a circadian rhythm? Give an example in humans.
Show answer
A biological cycle that repeats about every 24 hours; the sleep and wake cycle is an example (as are daily changes in body temperature and hormone release).
Why is REM sleep called paradoxical?
Show answer
The brain's EEG pattern looks similar to wakefulness and the brain is very active, but the body is almost completely relaxed (the large muscles are paralyzed).
How do the proportions of NREM and REM sleep change over the course of a night?
Show answer
Deep NREM sleep is longest in the early cycles and decreases, while REM periods become longer and more frequent toward morning.
A person is awakened every time they begin REM sleep for three nights, and on the fourth night is allowed to sleep. What would you predict about the fourth night, and what is it called?
Show answer
The person will spend more time in REM sleep than usual (REM rebound), as the brain makes up for the lost REM.
A night-shift nurse struggles to stay alert at 4 a.m. Use the idea of circadian rhythm to explain.
Show answer
Her body clock is programmed for sleep at that hour (low body temperature and high melatonin), so working then conflicts with the circadian rhythm, reducing alertness.
Why did Siffre's cave study suggest that the body has an internal clock?
Show answer
Without clocks or sunlight, his sleep and wake cycle continued on a regular schedule of about 25 hours, so the rhythm came from inside him rather than from outside cues.
Why do people spend a third of their lives unconscious, and why does the sleeping brain produce vivid, strange stories? Scientists do not have complete answers, but they have well-supported theories, and the exam expects you to know the main ones. This lesson covers the two current theories of dreaming, the two main explanations of why we sleep, the sleep disorders the course names, and what happens to behavior and health when sleep is disrupted. It is also a topic where you will practice making a defensible claim from evidence, which is skill 4.A.
Required content · 1.5.A
Learning objective.
1.5.A. Explain how the sleep/wake cycle affects behavior and mental processes throughout the day and night.
Essential knowledge.
1.5.A.4. Theories regarding the structure and function of dreams include activation-synthesis and consolidation theory. Exclusion Statement: The psychoanalytic theory of dreams is outside of the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
1.5.A.5. Memory consolidation and restoration are current theories about why sleep occurs. These theories suggest that sleep is useful for organizing and consolidating memories or restoring depleted resources used throughout a given day.
1.5.A.6. Many disorders interrupt healthy sleep, and their effects on waking behavior and health vary. Sleep disruptions can affect physical and cognitive performance during wakefulness. Treating sleep disorders and following regular schedules for sleeping can improve waking performance and overall well-being. Disorders commonly studied in introductory psychology include insomnia, narcolepsy, REM sleep behavior disorder, sleep apnea, and somnambulism. Exclusion Statement: The AP Psychology Exam will only address the listed disorders in EK 1.5.A.6.
Theories of dreaming
Dreams are experiences of images, thoughts, and emotions during sleep, and they occur most often in REM sleep (though they can occur in other stages). Two theories are tested on the exam. (The older psychoanalytic theory that dreams hide wishes is outside the scope of the AP Exam.)
Activation-synthesis theory, proposed by J. Allan Hobson and Robert McCarley in 1977, says that dreams have a biological origin. During REM sleep, the brain stem fires bursts of random neural signals. This is the activation. The cortex then tries to make sense of the signals by weaving them into a story, using memories and emotions. This is the synthesis. A dream's strange plot is the brain's best attempt to interpret chaotic input, which is why dreams combine odd events and why they often reflect recent experiences and worries.
Consolidation theory says that dreaming is linked to the memory consolidation that goes on during sleep. The brain replays and sorts the day's experiences, strengthening important memories and discarding others. Dreams may be a conscious by-product of this processing, which is why they often draw on recent events.
The two theories are not necessarily in conflict. Activation-synthesis explains where the content of a dream comes from, and consolidation theory explains what the sleeping brain may be doing with it.
Why do we sleep?
Everyone sleeps, including animals, and long deprivation is deadly in animal studies, so sleep must serve important functions. The exam names two current theories.
Restoration. Sleep allows the body and brain to repair and restore resources that were used up during the day. Tissue growth and repair, immune function, and the clearing of waste from the brain are all active in sleep, particularly in deep NREM sleep, when growth hormone is released.
Memory consolidation. Sleep helps organize and consolidate memories: strengthening new learning, moving it into long-term storage, and linking it to existing knowledge. People who sleep after learning tend to remember more than people who stay awake for the same period.
Study spotlight · Replay of memories during sleep (Wilson and McNaughton, 1994)
Matthew Wilson and Bruce McNaughton recorded the activity of many individual hippocampal neurons in rats as the rats ran along a track. Different neurons fired as the rat passed different places, producing a pattern for each location. When the researchers later recorded from the same neurons while the rats slept, they found that the neurons fired in the same sequence as when the rats were running the track, as if the rats were replaying the experience.
Reading the research: an animal experiment using recordings (and therefore under animal care review). It supports consolidation, since the hippocampus seemed to replay the day's experience during sleep, but it does not show that this replay is necessary for memory, and the findings in rats must be tested in humans.
Sleep disorders
Many disorders interrupt healthy sleep, and their effects on waking behavior and health vary. The exam names five.
Insomnia is persistent difficulty falling asleep, staying asleep, or waking too early, with daytime effects such as fatigue, poor concentration, and irritability. Stress, irregular schedules, caffeine, and screens at night all contribute.
Narcolepsy is a disorder in which a person has sudden attacks of overwhelming sleepiness during the day and may fall asleep in the middle of an activity. People with narcolepsy may drop directly into REM sleep, and some experience sudden loss of muscle tone when excited or laughing.
REM sleep behavior disorder occurs when the muscle paralysis that normally accompanies REM sleep fails, so the person physically acts out their dreams, by shouting, punching, or kicking, sometimes injuring themselves or a bed partner.
Sleep apnea is a condition in which breathing repeatedly stops for short periods during sleep, often because the airway is blocked. The sleeper briefly wakes to gasp, usually without remembering it. It causes loud snoring, poor-quality sleep, and daytime sleepiness, and it is linked to heart problems. It is common in people who are overweight, and treated with devices that keep the airway open.
Somnambulism (sleepwalking) is walking or doing other complex activities while asleep. It happens mostly in children, in deep NREM sleep (stage 3), not during dreaming, and the person usually does not remember it. Compare it with REM sleep behavior disorder, in which the person acts out a dream during REM sleep and may remember the dream.
Effects of sleep disruption, and the benefit of regular sleep
Missing sleep affects both waking performance and health. Sleep-deprived people have slower reaction times, poorer attention, weaker memory, more mistakes in judgment, and more irritability and low mood. They are more likely to be injured in car accidents and are more susceptible to illness. These effects are cumulative. Treating sleep disorders and following regular schedules for sleeping can improve waking performance and well-being. Healthy practices include going to bed and getting up at about the same times, avoiding caffeine late in the day, keeping screens away at night, and keeping the bedroom dark and cool.
Sleep needs vary by age: infants sleep most of the day, children need more than adults, and teenagers need about eight to ten hours. Around puberty the body clock shifts later, so teenagers naturally get sleepy later at night and want to wake later. Because of this, researchers such as Mary Carskadon have argued that very early school start times conflict with teenagers' biology, and some school districts have moved start times later. This is a good example of how cultural norms and circumstances (school schedules, work schedules, and social expectations) interact with biology to affect behavior.
Worked example · Identify the disorder
Name the sleep disorder most likely in each case. (a) A man falls asleep without warning at his desk, in the middle of a conversation, several times a day. (b) A woman snores loudly, wakes gasping, and is exhausted all day despite 8 hours in bed. (c) A man is observed kicking and shouting during the night, and later describes a dream in which he was fighting off an attacker. (d) A 9-year-old gets out of bed and walks to the kitchen during deep sleep and remembers nothing in the morning. (e) A woman lies awake for hours most nights, worrying, and is tired and irritable at work.
Step 3, (c) acting out a dream, as the REM paralysis fails: REM sleep behavior disorder.
Step 4, (d) walking during deep NREM sleep with no memory: somnambulism.
Step 5, (e) trouble falling asleep and daytime effects: insomnia.
Worked example · Theories applied to a dream
After a week studying for finals, a student dreams that she is taking a test in a building that turns into her grandmother's kitchen. How would each theory explain it?
Step 1, activation-synthesis: during REM, random signals from the brain stem activate the cortex, and the cortex synthesizes a story from them. It drew on her recent experience (test) and old memories (grandmother's kitchen), which explains why the story is odd, combining unrelated settings.
Step 2, consolidation theory: the brain is replaying and organizing what she studied and her recent experiences during sleep. Dreaming about tests is a side effect of the brain's sorting and storing of that material.
Step 3, the psychoanalytic idea that the dream hides a secret wish is outside the scope of the AP Exam, so it is not required.
Worked example · Making a defensible claim
A school board is debating whether to move the start time of a high school from 7:30 a.m. to 8:30 a.m. A summary of a study of students at two schools says that, in the school that moved its start time later, students slept on average 45 more minutes on school nights and reported fewer days of daytime sleepiness, while a similar school that did not change start times showed no change. Write a defensible claim and support it.
Step 1, a claim takes a position that can be supported with evidence: "Moving the start time to 8:30 a.m. will improve students' sleep and alertness."
Step 2, evidence: students in the school with the later start gained an average of 45 minutes of sleep and reported less sleepiness, and the comparison school stayed the same.
Step 3, reasoning: teenagers' body clocks run later at puberty (a biological reason), so an earlier start forces them to wake during their body's night, and later starts allow more sleep, which improves alertness and performance. The comparison school helps rule out other explanations such as the time of year.
Step 4, limitations: the sample is two schools, and students reported sleepiness themselves, so the claim should be stated cautiously ("is likely to improve").
Exam focus
Dream theories: activation-synthesis (random brain stem signals are interpreted by the cortex) and consolidation (dreaming linked to memory processing). The psychoanalytic theory is not tested.
Why we sleep: restoration and memory consolidation.
Disorders: insomnia, narcolepsy, REM sleep behavior disorder, sleep apnea, somnambulism (sleepwalking in NREM stage 3). Only these five are tested.
Sleep loss harms attention, memory, mood, and health; regular schedules help. Teen body clocks shift later.
Practice
Compare activation-synthesis theory and consolidation theory of dreaming in one sentence each.
Show answer
Activation-synthesis: dreams result from the cortex interpreting random neural activity generated by the brain stem during REM sleep. Consolidation: dreams are linked to the brain's processing and storing of memories during sleep.
Why do researchers think sleep helps memory? Give evidence.
Show answer
Sleep seems to consolidate memories: people who sleep after learning remember more, and rat hippocampal neurons replay the pattern of a previous experience during sleep.
How is REM sleep behavior disorder different from sleepwalking?
Show answer
In REM sleep behavior disorder the normal paralysis of REM fails and the person acts out a dream (and may remember it). In sleepwalking (somnambulism) the person walks in deep NREM sleep and typically does not remember it.
A truck driver has loud snoring and many brief awakenings at night and falls asleep at red lights. Name the disorder and explain how it affects waking behavior.
Show answer
Sleep apnea: breathing stops repeatedly, which fragments sleep, producing daytime sleepiness, slowed reactions, and reduced attention.
Why might teenagers have trouble falling asleep before 11 p.m. and getting up at 6:30 a.m.?
Show answer
Around puberty, the circadian rhythm shifts later (melatonin is released later), so teens are not sleepy until later and need to sleep later in the morning.
A student claims that "sleep deprivation cannot hurt me because I get by on 4 hours." What evidence would you cite to evaluate this claim?
Show answer
Studies show that reduced sleep slows reaction time, impairs attention and memory, and worsens mood, and people often underestimate their own impairment. Sleep deprivation is also associated with illness and accidents.
Sensation: thresholds, adaptation, and sensory interaction
Right now your eyes, ears, skin, nose, and tongue are collecting more information than your brain could ever use. Sensation is how that information gets in: sensory receptors detect energy or chemicals from the environment and convert them into signals the nervous system can use. The exam questions on sensation lean on a handful of measurable ideas: how strong a stimulus must be to be noticed, how big a change must be to be detected, why you stop noticing constant stimuli, and how the senses work together. This lesson covers those general principles; the three lessons after it take the senses one at a time.
Required content · 1.6.A
Learning objective.
1.6.A. Explain how the process of sensation is related to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.6.A.1. Sensation is the process of detecting information from the environment that meets a certain threshold and transducing stimuli into neurochemical messages for processing (perception) in the brain. The absolute threshold occurs when a stimulus can be detected at least 50% of the time.
1.6.A.2. Detection of change in stimuli or diminished sensitivity to stimuli can be explained by the just-noticeable difference and sensory adaptation. Weber’s law describes the degree to which stimuli need to be different for the difference to be detected.
1.6.A.3. The sensory systems constantly work together in a process called sensory interaction. Synesthesia is an experience of sensation in which one system of sensation is experienced through another.
Sensation versus perception
Sensation is the process of detecting information from the environment and transducing (converting) stimuli into neurochemical messages that the brain can process. Light, sound waves, pressure, and chemicals are all physical energy that the nervous system cannot use directly, so each sense has specialized receptor cells that transduce the stimulus into neural impulses. The brain then interprets the messages. That interpretation is perception, covered in Unit 2. A helpful way to keep them apart: sensation is the raw detection of stimuli, and perception is organizing and making sense of them.
Thresholds
A stimulus must be strong enough to have any effect. The absolute threshold is the minimum stimulus energy needed to detect a stimulus. Because detecting a faint stimulus varies from moment to moment, it is defined by a probability: the absolute threshold is the intensity at which a stimulus can be detected at least 50% of the time. Under ideal conditions, humans are very sensitive. Commonly cited estimates are that you could see a candle flame from about 30 miles away on a dark, clear night and hear a ticking watch from 20 feet away in a quiet room.
The difference threshold, or just-noticeable difference (JND), is the minimum difference between two stimuli that a person can detect 50% of the time. If you are holding a 100-gram weight and a second weight is added, the JND is the smallest added amount you can notice.
Weber's law describes how the JND works: the size of the JND is proportional to the size of the original stimulus. In other words, for two stimuli to be perceived as different, they must differ by a constant proportion, not a constant amount. Adding 5 candles to a room lit by 10 candles is noticeable; adding 5 candles to a room lit by 1,000 is not. If the JND for the weight of lifted objects is 2% (a hypothetical value for practice), then a 100-gram weight needs 2 more grams for you to notice, but a 1,000-gram weight needs 20 more grams.
Sensory adaptation
Sensory adaptation is a diminished sensitivity to a stimulus that does not change. When you first put on a sweater, you feel it on your skin; a few minutes later you stop noticing it. When you enter a room with a strong smell, it fades. Adaptation helps the nervous system, which is designed to detect change, to pay attention to new events rather than to constant background stimulation. (Note the difference between adaptation, which is a decrease in sensitivity to an unchanging stimulus, and habituation, a decline in response to a repeated stimulus, covered in Unit 3.) If a stimulus changes, sensitivity returns, so that you notice if the sweater's tag scratches you.
Sensory interaction and synesthesia
The senses do not work in isolation. In sensory interaction, the senses influence one another: taste depends heavily on smell (a stuffy nose makes food bland), and what you see can change what you hear. The sensory systems constantly work together to produce a single experience of the world.
Study spotlight · The McGurk effect (McGurk and MacDonald, 1976)
Harry McGurk and John MacDonald showed participants a video of a person's mouth forming the syllable "ga" while the audio played the sound "ba." Participants typically reported hearing a third syllable, "da," a blend of what they saw and heard. When they closed their eyes, they correctly heard "ba."
Reading the research: an experiment with the type of stimulus as the independent variable and the syllable reported as the dependent variable. It demonstrates sensory interaction, since vision changed what people heard. A limitation is that the reports were self-reported, and the participants varied in how strongly they experienced the effect.
Synesthesia is a rare condition in which stimulation of one sense is experienced through another. A person with synesthesia may see colors when hearing music, see letters or numbers as having specific colors, or taste a flavor when hearing a word. The experiences are automatic and consistent over time. It shows how closely sensory systems can be linked in the brain.
Worked example · Finding an absolute threshold from data
A researcher presents tones of increasing intensity (arbitrary units) 100 times each and records the percentage of times a participant says "I hear it." The results are: intensity 1, 4%; intensity 2, 18%; intensity 3, 44%; intensity 4, 62%; intensity 5, 86%; intensity 6, 97%. Estimate the absolute threshold.
Step 1, the absolute threshold is the intensity detected 50% of the time.
Step 2, the detection rate is 44% at intensity 3 and 62% at intensity 4, so 50% falls between them.
Step 3, estimate: the rate rises 18 percentage points (from 44 to 62) across one unit. To go from 44 to 50 takes 6 of those 18 points, so the intensity is about \(3+6/18\approx3.3\).
Step 4, interpretation: the threshold is about 3.3 units. Notice that detection does not jump from 0% to 100% at one exact value; it rises gradually, which is why a 50% criterion is used.
Worked example · Applying Weber's law
Suppose a person's JND for the loudness of a sound is 10% of its starting level. A sound is at 50 units. How much louder does it have to get for the person to notice? What if it starts at 200 units? Would an increase of 15 units be noticed in each case?
Step 1, JND = 10% of the starting level. At 50 units: \(0.10\times50=5\) units.
Step 2, at 200 units: \(0.10\times200=20\) units.
Step 3, an increase of 15 units: at 50 units, 15 is greater than 5, so the person would notice. At 200 units, 15 is less than 20, so it would likely go unnoticed.
Step 4, the lesson of Weber's law: the same absolute increase (15 units) is clear against a quiet background and invisible against a loud one, because what matters is the proportion.
Worked example · Adaptation or something else?
A student walks into the school cafeteria and notices a strong smell of pizza, but 10 minutes later no longer notices it. Her friend arrives and says it smells strongly. Explain using the concepts of the lesson. Then explain why a stuffy nose makes the pizza taste bland.
Step 1, the student's receptors responded strongly at first, and then the nervous system reduced its response to the unchanging smell. This is sensory adaptation.
Step 2, her friend, newly arrived, has not yet adapted, so the smell seems strong to her.
Step 3, the stuffy nose blocks smell, and flavor comes from the combination of taste and smell, which is sensory interaction.
Exam focus
Sensation = detecting and transducing stimuli; perception = interpreting them (Unit 2).
Absolute threshold: minimum stimulus detected at least 50% of the time. JND: smallest detectable difference. Weber's law: the JND is a constant proportion of the starting stimulus.
Sensory adaptation: reduced sensitivity to an unchanging stimulus. Sensory interaction: senses influence one another (taste and smell; the McGurk effect). Synesthesia: one sense experienced through another.
Practice
Define absolute threshold. Why is it defined by a percentage?
Show answer
It is the minimum stimulus intensity that can be detected, specifically at least 50% of the time. Detection varies from trial to trial, so there is no single point where detection goes from never to always.
According to Weber's law, the JND for a 50-gram weight is 1 gram. Predict the JND for a 500-gram weight.
Show answer
The JND is proportional to the starting weight. 1 gram out of 50 is 2%, so for 500 grams the JND is \(0.02\times500=10\) grams.
Why do you stop noticing the hum of a refrigerator?
Show answer
Sensory adaptation: the nervous system reduces its sensitivity to a constant, unchanging stimulus so you can notice changes.
What is synesthesia? Give an example.
Show answer
A condition where stimulation of one sense is experienced through another, such as seeing colors when hearing music or tasting flavors when hearing words.
Which is an example of sensation and which of perception: (a) the retina converting light into neural signals, (b) recognizing a friend's face in a crowd?
Show answer
(a) is sensation (transduction of light); (b) is perception (interpreting and recognizing).
In the McGurk effect, why do viewers hear "da" when they see "ga" and hear "ba"?
Show answer
Vision and hearing interact. The brain combines the visual information (the mouth shape) with the auditory information to produce a blended perception, which shows sensory interaction.
Vision is the sense we rely on most, and it shows nearly every principle of sensation in action: a stimulus (light), transduction (the retina), a pathway to the brain, and an interpretation that is partly built by the brain rather than simply recorded. The exam asks about the functions of the eye's parts rather than their anatomy, so concentrate on what each part does for vision and what goes wrong when it fails. This lesson also covers the two theories of color vision and two disorders that result when the brain's visual areas are damaged.
Required content · 1.6.B
Learning objective.
1.6.B. Explain how the structures and functions of the visual sensory system relate to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.6.B.1. The retina is the photosensitive surface at the back of the eye. Cells in the retina capture visual information that is transduced to the brain for processing. Evidence of incomplete images captured by the retina is demonstrated by the presence of the blind spot, where the visual nerve exits the eye. The brain fills in the gaps in the incomplete retinal images to perceive a relatively complete picture of the world. 1.A 2.B 3.B 3.C
1.6.B.2. Visual stimuli are focused onto the retina by the lens via a process called accommodation. When this process is altered, nearsightedness or farsightedness can result.
1.6.B.3. Cells that lie in the periphery of the eye and detect shapes and movement, but not color, are called rods. These cells are mainly activated in low-light environments. These cells play a role in light and dark adaptation.
1.6.B.4. Color vision is explained by both the trichromatic theory and the opponent-process theory.
1.6.B.4.i. Photoreceptor cells located in the fovea of the eye that process color and detail are called cones. Researchers have identified blue (detecting short wavelengths), green (detecting medium wavelengths) and red (detecting long wavelengths) cones in the retina.
1.6.B.4.ii. Afterimages result when certain ganglion cells in the retina are activated while others are not. The ganglion cells involved in this opponent process are red/green, blue/yellow/and black/white.
1.6.B.4.iii. Color vision deficiency involves damage or irregularities to one or more cones or ganglion cells (red/green, blue/yellow). Color vision deficiency includes dichromatism or monochromatism.
1.6.B.5. Damage to parts of the brain responsible for vision (mainly the occipital lobes) can result in disorders such as prosopagnosia (face blindness) and blindsight.
Light and the path to the retina
The stimulus for vision is light, a form of electromagnetic energy that travels in waves. The wavelength of the light determines its hue (color: short wavelengths look blue, long wavelengths look red) and the amplitude (height) of the wave determines its brightness. Light enters the eye through the transparent cornea, which begins to bend (focus) the light. It passes through the pupil, the opening whose size is controlled by the colored iris: the pupil gets smaller in bright light and larger in dim light. Behind the pupil is the lens, which changes shape to focus the light on the back of the eye.
Figure 1.8. The eye. Light is bent by the cornea, passes through the pupil, and is focused by the lens onto the retina, where rods and cones transduce it. The fovea is the center of sharpest, most colorful vision, and the optic nerve leaves at the blind spot.
The lens focuses by changing its curvature, a process called accommodation: it flattens to focus on distant objects and thickens to focus on near ones. When the focus does not land exactly on the retina, vision is blurred. In nearsightedness (myopia) the image focuses in front of the retina, so nearby objects are clear but distant ones are blurry. In farsightedness (hyperopia) the image focuses behind the retina, so distant objects are clear and close ones are blurry. Glasses, contact lenses, or surgery correct the focus.
The retina
The retina is the light-sensitive surface at the back of the eye. It contains the photoreceptor cells, rods and cones, that transduce light into neural signals. These signals pass through other neurons (bipolar cells, then ganglion cells) whose axons bundle together to form the optic nerve, which carries the information to the brain.
Rods are located mostly in the periphery of the retina and detect shapes and movement, but not color. They are very sensitive to dim light, so they work mainly in low-light environments, and they play the major role in dark adaptation (the increasing sensitivity as you stay in the dark, the way your eyes adjust after the lights go out) and light adaptation.
Cones are concentrated in the fovea, the small central region of the retina, and they detect color and fine detail. They work best in bright light. This is why you look straight at something to see its detail.
The place where the optic nerve leaves the eye contains no receptors, so there is a blind spot in each eye. You do not normally notice it because the brain fills in the gap, using information from the surrounding area and from the other eye, to produce a relatively complete picture of the world. This shows that what we see is partly constructed by the brain.
From the eye to the brain
The optic nerves carry information to the thalamus, which relays it to the visual cortex in the occipital lobes at the back of the brain, where it is processed and interpreted. As a result of the crossing of the optic nerves, information from the left half of each eye's visual field is processed by the right hemisphere and vice versa (this is the contralateral organization seen in split-brain studies).
Study spotlight · Hubel and Wiesel and feature detection (1959 to 1968)
David Hubel and Torsten Wiesel recorded the activity of single neurons in the visual cortex of anesthetized cats while showing them lines and shapes on a screen. They found that individual cells responded best to specific features, such as a line at a particular angle, an edge, or a particular direction of movement, and different cells responded to different features. The researchers won a Nobel Prize in 1981 for the work.
Reading the research: an animal experiment in which the independent variable was the feature shown (angle of the line, for example) and the dependent variable was the neuron's firing rate. It showed that the visual cortex analyzes the scene in pieces that are later combined, which is the basis for the idea of feature detection. Generalizing from cats to humans requires some caution, but human brain imaging has supported the same ideas.
How we see color
Two theories, which turn out to describe different stages, are needed to explain color vision.
Trichromatic theory (the Young-Helmholtz theory) says that the retina has three kinds of cones, each most sensitive to a different range of wavelengths: blue (short wavelengths), green (medium), and red (long). The brain perceives any color by comparing how strongly each type responds. If all three respond equally strongly, you see white. This theory explains how cones detect color.
Opponent-process theory says that color is also processed in opposing pairs by ganglion cells in the retina: red/green, blue/yellow, and black/white. When one member of a pair is stimulated the other is inhibited, so you cannot see reddish-green or bluish-yellow. This theory explains afterimages: if you stare at a green square and then look at a white surface, you see a red afterimage. Staring at green tires the cells that respond to green, so when you look at white the opposing red response is stronger. The two theories work together: three cone types in the retina, and opponent-process cells that process the signals after them.
Color vision deficiency (color blindness) results from damage or irregularities in one or more types of cones or ganglion cells. Most commonly the red/green or blue/yellow system is affected. A person who is missing one type of cone has dichromatism and can distinguish only two dimensions of color (for example, red/green deficiency, which is more common in males); a person with monochromatism has only one cone type or none and sees no color at all, which is rare.
When the visual brain is damaged
Damage to the parts of the brain responsible for vision, mainly the occipital lobes, can produce disorders even when the eyes work well. Prosopagnosia (face blindness) is the inability to recognize familiar faces, even one's own, although the person can see that it is a face and recognize people by other cues such as voice or clothing. In blindsight, a person with damage to the visual cortex insists they cannot see anything in part of the visual field but can still point to or guess the location of objects there, with accuracy better than chance, because other pathways still process some visual information without conscious awareness.
Worked example · Rods or cones?
For each situation, say whether rods or cones are mainly responsible. (a) Reading small print in bright light. (b) Noticing a movement at the edge of your vision at dusk. (c) Telling red from green. (d) Finding your way around a dark bedroom after your eyes have adjusted.
Step 1, (a) fine detail in bright light needs cones, which are concentrated in the fovea.
Step 2, (b) movement in the periphery in dim light is mostly rods.
Step 3, (c) color is detected by cones.
Step 4, (d) dark adaptation is a function of rods.
Worked example · Explaining an afterimage
You stare at a bright yellow flag for 30 seconds, then look at a white wall and see a blue flag. Which theory explains this, and how?
Step 1, the opponent-process theory, because yellow and blue are an opposing pair.
Step 2, staring at yellow fatigues the cells that respond to yellow in the blue/yellow system.
Step 3, when you look at white (which contains all wavelengths), the fatigued yellow response is weak, so the opponent blue response dominates, and you see blue.
Step 4, trichromatic theory explains the first step (the cones that respond to red and green wavelengths together signal yellow) and opponent-process theory explains the afterimage.
Worked example · Diagnosing a visual problem
A student sees close objects clearly but the whiteboard is blurry. What is the condition, what is happening inside the eye, and what would help?
Step 1, near objects clear and far objects blurry is nearsightedness (myopia).
Step 2, the lens focuses distant images in front of the retina rather than on it.
Step 3, glasses or contact lenses with a lens that shifts the focus back onto the retina would help.
Step 4, this is a problem of focusing (accommodation), not of the retina or brain, so rods and cones are normal.
Rods: periphery, dim light, shape and movement, dark adaptation, no color. Cones: fovea, color and detail, bright light. The blind spot is where the optic nerve exits; the brain fills it in.
Trichromatic theory: blue, green, and red cones. Opponent-process theory: red/green, blue/yellow, black/white (explains afterimages). Dichromatism and monochromatism are forms of color vision deficiency.
Prosopagnosia and blindsight result from damage to the visual brain (occipital lobes).
Practice
What is accommodation, and what happens in nearsightedness?
Show answer
Accommodation is the lens changing shape to focus light on the retina. In nearsightedness the image focuses in front of the retina, so distant objects are blurry.
Why can't you see color well in dim light?
Show answer
Cones, which detect color, need bright light; in dim light mainly rods are active, and they do not detect color.
Explain the blind spot and why you don't normally notice it.
Show answer
The optic nerve exits the eye at a point with no receptors, so that spot cannot detect light. The brain fills in the gap using surrounding information and the other eye's input.
Name the theory that explains each: (a) three types of cones, (b) afterimages.
Show answer
A man cannot recognize his wife's face, but knows her by her voice. Name the disorder and the brain region involved.
Show answer
Prosopagnosia (face blindness), associated with damage to visual areas in the occipital (and temporal) lobes of the brain.
What did Hubel and Wiesel's cat experiments show about the visual cortex?
Show answer
Individual neurons respond best to specific features such as lines at certain angles, edges, or movement, so the visual system analyzes the scene in parts.
Hearing may seem effortless, but it turns a series of air-pressure waves into the voice of a friend or a favorite song through a chain of mechanical and neural steps. The exam asks about what the ear does with a sound, the competing and complementary explanations for how we tell high from low, how we know where a sound came from, and the two main kinds of hearing loss. This lesson follows a sound from the air to the brain and ends with problems that interrupt it.
Required content · 1.6.C
Learning objective.
1.6.C. Explain how the structures and functions of the auditory sensory system relate to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.6.C.1. Sound occurs through the movement of air molecules at different wavelengths (called pitch) and amplitudes (called loudness).
1.6.C.2. Theories that help explain pitch perception include place theory, volley theory, and frequency theory.
1.6.C.3. Sound localization describes how we identify where sounds in our environment are coming from.
1.6.C.4. Hearing difficulties can result from aging and various kinds of damage to auditory structures. Types of hearing loss include conduction deafness and sensorineural deafness.
What sound is
Sound occurs through the movement of air molecules, which produces waves of alternating pressure. Two physical features of the wave matter. The frequency of the wave, how many cycles occur per second (measured in hertz, Hz), is perceived as pitch: high frequencies sound high and low frequencies sound low. (The course description calls this feature "wavelength," because longer waves are lower in frequency.) The amplitude, or height of the wave, is perceived as loudness, measured in decibels (dB): the larger the amplitude, the louder the sound. Humans can hear frequencies from roughly 20 to 20,000 Hz, and are most sensitive in the range used for speech.
From the air to the brain
The ear has three sections, each of which does one job in the chain.
The outer ear. The visible pinna collects sound waves and funnels them down the ear canal to the eardrum (tympanic membrane), which vibrates when sound strikes it.
The middle ear. The eardrum's vibrations move three tiny bones, the hammer, anvil, and stirrup (together the ossicles). They amplify the vibrations and pass them to the oval window, a membrane at the entrance to the inner ear.
The inner ear. The oval window vibrates the fluid inside the snail-shaped cochlea. The movement of the fluid causes a flexible strip called the basilar membrane to ripple. Resting on it are hair cells, the receptor cells for hearing, which bend as the membrane moves. The bending of the hair cells is the transduction: it triggers neural signals, which travel along the auditory nerve to the thalamus and then to the auditory cortex in the temporal lobes.
A key idea is that damage to hair cells is permanent in humans. They do not regrow, so exposure to loud sounds can cause lasting loss.
Theories of pitch perception
How does the ear tell a high note from a low one? Three theories explain different parts of the answer.
Place theory says that different pitches stimulate different locations (places) along the basilar membrane. High-frequency sounds make the hair cells near the base (the start) of the cochlea respond, and low-frequency sounds stimulate cells farther along toward the tip. The brain reads pitch from which hair cells are active. Place theory explains the perception of high-pitched sounds well.
Frequency theory says that the rate at which neurons fire matches the frequency of the sound wave: a 100-Hz tone makes the auditory nerve fire about 100 times per second. This explains low pitches, but a single neuron cannot fire fast enough for high frequencies (neurons are limited by the refractory period).
Volley theory is an extension of frequency theory. Groups of neurons fire in alternation, in volleys, so that together they reach higher rates than any single neuron could. Volley theory helps explain medium-to-high pitches.
The current understanding is that the three combine: place theory for high pitches, frequency and volley for lower pitches, with overlap in the middle.
Study spotlight · Georg von Békésy and the traveling wave (1940s)
Georg von Békésy, a Hungarian-born scientist, studied the cochleas of human cadavers and other animals under a microscope, using tiny flecks of silver on the basilar membrane to see how it moved when sounds of different frequencies were played. He found that each frequency made a wave that traveled along the membrane and peaked at a different place: high frequencies near the base, low frequencies farther toward the tip. He received a Nobel Prize in 1961 for this work.
Reading the research: a controlled laboratory study in which the independent variable was the frequency of the sound and the dependent variable was the location of the peak movement. It provided strong support for place theory. A limitation is that the cochleas were not alive, so the live ear's responses can differ in some details.
Sound localization
You can tell where a sound is coming from because you have two ears. A sound from your right reaches the right ear slightly earlier than the left ear, and it is slightly louder in the right ear because your head blocks and weakens it on the way to the left. The brain compares the time and intensity differences between the ears to work out the location. This process is called sound localization. A sound directly in front or behind you reaches both ears at the same time and is harder to locate, so people often tilt their heads to get a better comparison.
Hearing loss
Hearing difficulties can result from aging and from various kinds of damage to the structures of the auditory system. The two types that you need to know are:
Conduction deafness (conductive hearing loss) is caused by damage to the mechanical system that conducts sound waves to the cochlea, such as a punctured eardrum, fluid in the middle ear, or damaged ossicles. The hair cells and nerves are fine. It is often treatable with hearing aids that amplify the sound, or surgery.
Sensorineural deafness is caused by damage to the cochlea's hair cells or to the auditory nerve. It is the more common type, caused by aging and by loud noise, and it is usually permanent. Hearing aids help less because the damage is to the receptors, but a cochlear implant, which converts sounds into electrical signals and stimulates the auditory nerve directly, can restore some hearing.
Worked example · Tracing a sound
A friend calls your name. List, in order, the structures that carry the sound and the type of energy at each step.
Step 1, sound waves (air pressure changes) are collected by the pinna and funneled down the ear canal.
Step 2, the waves vibrate the eardrum, converting air pressure waves to mechanical vibration.
Step 3, the vibrations pass through the hammer, anvil, and stirrup, which amplify them, to the oval window.
Step 4, the oval window vibrates the fluid in the cochlea, which moves the basilar membrane and bends the hair cells.
Step 5, the hair cells transduce the movement into neural impulses, which go to the thalamus and the auditory cortex in the temporal lobes.
Worked example · Which theory of pitch?
For each, name the best theory. (a) A very high-pitched whistle activates hair cells near the base of the cochlea. (b) A 150-Hz tone makes auditory neurons fire about 150 times per second. (c) A 2,000-Hz tone is above the firing rate of any single neuron, yet the auditory nerve represents it.
Step 1, (a) pitch is represented by location on the basilar membrane, so place theory.
Step 2, (b) firing rate matches frequency, so frequency theory.
Step 3, (c) groups of neurons taking turns firing to reach a combined rate that is higher than any one can fire alone is volley theory.
Worked example · Distinguishing the types of hearing loss
Case 1: A boy has an ear infection, and fluid builds up behind his eardrum. He hears muffled sounds, but a hearing aid helps. Case 2: A worker exposed to loud machinery for 30 years has lost most hearing for high pitches. A hearing aid helps only a little. Classify each.
Step 1, case 1: the problem is in the middle ear (fluid prevents the eardrum and ossicles from vibrating normally), so it is conduction deafness. The hearing aid helps because it amplifies the sound to overcome the blockage.
Step 2, case 2: years of loud noise destroy hair cells in the cochlea, so it is sensorineural deafness. The damage is to the receptors, so amplification helps less.
Step 3, high-pitched sounds are often the first lost because of the hair cells at the base of the cochlea, which are most vulnerable to damage (consistent with place theory).
Exam focus
Frequency (wavelength) = pitch; amplitude = loudness.
Place theory (location on the membrane), frequency theory (firing rate), volley theory (groups of neurons firing in turn).
Sound localization uses time and loudness differences between the ears.
Conduction deafness (outer or middle ear) versus sensorineural deafness (hair cells or nerve).
Practice
What physical feature of a sound wave determines pitch, and which determines loudness?
Show answer
Frequency (wavelength) determines pitch; amplitude determines loudness.
What do the hair cells in the cochlea do, and why is damage to them serious?
Show answer
They transduce the movement of the basilar membrane into neural signals. In humans, hair cells do not regrow, so damage causes permanent hearing loss.
Why is it harder to locate a sound directly in front of you than one to your side?
Show answer
A sound at the side reaches one ear earlier and louder than the other, giving the brain differences to compare. A sound straight ahead arrives at both ears at the same time and loudness.
Which pitch theory explains how we hear a very low sound, and what is its limit?
Show answer
Frequency theory: neurons fire at the same rate as the sound waves. Its limit is that neurons cannot fire fast enough to match high frequencies.
Which type of hearing loss would a cochlear implant most likely treat?
Show answer
Sensorineural deafness, because the implant bypasses damaged hair cells by stimulating the auditory nerve directly.
Explain how von Békésy's research supported place theory.
Show answer
He saw that different frequencies produce traveling waves that peak at different locations on the basilar membrane, so pitch is related to where on the membrane the hair cells are stimulated.
Smell, taste, touch, pain, balance, and body position
Vision and hearing get most of the attention, but the other senses keep you fed, safe, and upright. This lesson covers the chemical senses (smell and taste), the skin senses of touch and pain, and the two body senses that tell you where you are and how you are moving: balance and the sense of body position. The exam asks the same kind of question about each: what stimulus is detected, what structure transduces it, where it goes in the brain, and what happens when the system is disrupted or two systems interact.
Required content · 1.6.D, 1.6.E, 1.6.F, 1.6.G
Learning objectives.
1.6.D. Explain how the structures and functions of the chemical sensory systems relate to behavior and mental processes.
1.6.E. Explain how the structures and functions of the touch sensory system relate to behavior and mental processes.
1.6.F. Explain how the structures and functions of the pain sensory system relate to behavior and mental processes.
1.6.G. Explain how the structures and functions that maintain balance (vestibular) and body movement (kinesthetic) relate to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
1.6.D.1. Structures in the nose and brain process and/or transduce olfactory stimuli. Smell is the only sense not processed first in the thalamus of the brain. Pheromones produce chemical messages for the olfactory system.
1.6.D.2. Gustation is the sense of taste, and types of tastes include sweet, sour, salty, bitter, umami, and oleogustus.
1.6.D.3. Structures in the tongue, mouth, and brain process and/or transduce basic tastes. The number of taste receptors on the tongue is related to how sensitive people are to tastes, classifying them as supertasters, medium tasters, or nontasters.
1.6.D.4. The chemical senses interact to create the sensation of taste. Without the sense of smell, taste sensations are either muted or not experienced.
1.6.E.1. Structures within the skin and brain process and/or transduce touch stimuli. The sensation of “hot” is produced by the activation of warm and cold receptors in the skin. 45
1.6.F.1. Pain is processed both in the body and in the brain. Gate control theory is one attempt to describe the complexities of pain. Phantom limb sensation occurs when people who have lost limbs report sensation or pain where the limb used to be.
1.6.G.1. The vestibular sense controls balance and is primarily detected by the semicircular canals and structures in the brain.
1.6.G.2. Kinesthesis the sense of one’s body movement. Kinesthesis allows the body to move in coordinated ways without having to look at the various parts of the body as it moves. 46
Smell (olfaction)
Smell is detected by receptor cells in the upper part of the nasal cavity that respond to chemical molecules in the air. When the molecules bind to receptors, the receptors transduce them into neural signals. The signals go to the olfactory bulb at the base of the brain and from there directly to parts of the limbic system and the temporal lobes. Smell is the only sense that is not processed first in the thalamus, which helps explain why smells are tied so closely to emotion and memory: a scent can bring back a memory from childhood in a flash, because the pathway connects directly to the amygdala and hippocampus.
Animals also communicate by pheromones, chemicals released by one individual that influence the behavior of another of the same species. They are well established in insects and many mammals (for example, signaling readiness to mate), and they are a chemical message for the olfactory system. Whether pheromones affect human behavior is still debated.
Taste (gustation)
Gustation, the sense of taste, responds to chemicals dissolved in saliva. The basic tastes are sweet, sour, salty, bitter, umami (savory, as in meat and broth), and oleogustus (the taste of fatty acids). Receptor cells in taste buds, located in bumps on the tongue and in the mouth, transduce the chemicals, and signals travel to the thalamus and on to the brain's taste areas.
People differ in how sensitive they are, and the difference is related to the number of taste receptors on the tongue. Researchers classify people as supertasters (with the most taste buds, who find bitter foods and strong tastes intense), medium tasters, or nontasters (with the fewest, who find the same foods mild). Supertasters are more likely to dislike coffee and bitter vegetables.
Taste and smell interact. Much of what we call the "flavor" of food comes from smell, which is why food tastes bland when you have a cold. Without the sense of smell, taste sensations are either muted or not experienced.
Touch
The skin contains many kinds of receptors that respond to pressure, vibration, temperature, and tissue damage. Receptors in the skin transduce the stimulus, the signals travel through the spinal cord and the thalamus to the somatosensory cortex in the parietal lobe. More cortex is devoted to the most sensitive parts of the body, such as the fingertips and lips, than to less sensitive areas like the back. There are separate receptors for warmth and for cold. Interestingly, the sensation of "hot" is produced when both warm and cold receptors are activated at the same time, which explains why touching something very hot can briefly feel cold or painful at once.
Pain
Pain is a protective sense that warns of tissue damage. It is processed both in the body and in the brain. Nociceptors, receptors in the skin and organs that respond to damaging stimuli, send signals along nerve fibers to the spinal cord and brain. The brain's interpretation depends on more than the signal itself: mood, attention, expectations, and culture all affect how much pain a person feels.
Gate control theory, proposed by Ronald Melzack and Patrick Wall in 1965, is an attempt to describe this complexity. It says that the spinal cord contains a neurological "gate." Signals from small pain fibers open the gate and let pain messages travel to the brain, while signals from larger fibers carrying touch information, or messages from the brain itself, can close the gate and block pain messages. This explains why rubbing a bumped elbow reduces the pain, and why distraction, relaxation, and the release of endorphins (the body's natural pain relievers) can lessen it.
Phantom limb sensation occurs when people who have lost a limb still feel sensations, or even pain, where the limb used to be. It shows that sensation is constructed in the brain: the brain areas that once received input from the limb continue to be active.
Study spotlight · The mirror box and phantom limb pain (Ramachandran, 1996)
V. S. Ramachandran treated patients who felt that their missing arm was clenched in a painful cramp. He placed a mirror in a box so that, when the patient looked into it, the reflection of the intact hand appeared where the missing hand would be. When the patient moved the intact hand and watched the reflection, the "phantom" hand seemed to move too, and some patients reported that the cramped feeling released and pain was reduced.
Reading the research: a small set of case studies. It suggests that the brain's expectations and vision can alter the pain signal, consistent with gate control ideas. Limitations are the small number of patients and the lack of a control group, so later controlled studies were needed to test how well the approach works.
Balance and body position
The vestibular sense controls balance and your sense of head position and movement. It is detected primarily by the semicircular canals in the inner ear (three fluid-filled loops oriented at right angles to one another, so that they sense rotation in any direction) and structures in the brain. When you spin and stop, the fluid keeps moving and makes you feel dizzy.
Kinesthesis is the sense of your body's movement and position. Receptors in the muscles, tendons, and joints send information about where your limbs are. Because of kinesthesis, you can touch your nose with your eyes closed and move in coordinated ways without having to look at your body parts. Together, the vestibular and kinesthetic senses allow you to walk and keep balance without conscious thought.
Worked example · Smell and memory
A woman smells fresh bread in a bakery and suddenly recalls her grandmother's kitchen in great detail. Explain with a fact about the brain.
Step 1, smell is detected by receptors in the nose and sent to the olfactory bulb.
Step 2, unlike the other senses, smell is not processed first in the thalamus. The olfactory information goes directly to the limbic system, including the amygdala and hippocampus, which are involved in emotion and memory.
Step 3, this direct connection explains why smells can trigger vivid emotional memories.
Worked example · Applying gate control theory
A student bangs her shin on a desk and immediately rubs it. The pain lessens. Later, she is absorbed in a computer game and does not notice a headache until the game ends. Explain both with gate control theory.
Step 1, rubbing stimulates large fibers that carry touch information. According to the theory, this activity closes the spinal "gate" and reduces the pain signals from the small pain fibers reaching the brain.
Step 2, being absorbed in the game involves the brain sending signals (attention and the release of endorphins) that can close the gate from above, so she notices the pain less.
Step 3, when the game ends and her attention shifts, the gate opens more and the pain is felt.
Step 4, this shows that pain is not only a matter of the body's signal but also of how the brain handles it.
Worked example · Taste classification
Two friends try black coffee. One makes a face and calls it unbearably bitter. The other thinks it is mild. A researcher counts taste buds on each tongue and finds the first has far more. Classify each and explain.
Step 1, the first friend has many taste receptors, so is a supertaster who experiences strong tastes intensely.
Step 2, the second friend, with fewer, is probably a nontaster (or medium taster).
Step 3, the number of taste receptors is related to sensitivity, so the same stimulus produces different sensation. This also shows that individuals differ in sensation, not just in preferences.
Exam focus
Smell: nasal receptors, olfactory bulb, limbic system; the only sense not first processed by the thalamus; pheromones are chemical messages.
Taste: sweet, sour, salty, bitter, umami, oleogustus; supertasters, medium tasters, nontasters; taste and smell interact.
Pain: gate control theory; phantom limb sensation.
Vestibular sense (semicircular canals) = balance; kinesthesis = body movement and position.
Practice
Why do smells trigger memories so powerfully?
Show answer
Smell is the only sense not first processed in the thalamus; olfactory signals go directly to the limbic system, including the amygdala and hippocampus, which handle emotion and memory.
List the six basic tastes in the course.
Show answer
Sweet, sour, salty, bitter, umami, and oleogustus.
Why does a person with a stuffy nose think food has little taste?
Show answer
Taste and smell interact: much of flavor comes from smell. Without it, taste sensations are muted.
Explain how gate control theory accounts for rubbing a sore spot to relieve pain.
Show answer
Touch signals carried by larger fibers close the spinal "gate" to pain signals from the smaller pain fibers, so less pain reaches the brain.
A person spins in a circle and then stops, feeling dizzy. Which sense is responsible and where are its receptors?
Show answer
The vestibular sense; the fluid in the semicircular canals of the inner ear continues to move after you stop, sending signals that the body is still rotating.
Distinguish the vestibular sense from kinesthesis.
Show answer
The vestibular sense detects balance and head position and movement (mainly via the semicircular canals); kinesthesis detects the position and movement of body parts via receptors in muscles, tendons, and joints.
Unit 1 review · 10 multiple-choice
Unit 1 review: Biological Bases of Behavior
Ten questions in the three styles the exam uses (concept application, data analysis, and scientific investigation) one drawn from each lesson in the unit; click an option to see why that choice is right or wrong.
Multiple choice
Described study
A researcher wants to know whether background music helps students learn vocabulary. She posts a sign-up sheet offering two sessions. Students who sign up for the 4 p.m. session study a 30-word list for 20 minutes in a room with instrumental music playing; students who sign up for the 6 p.m. session study the same list for 20 minutes in silence. Both groups take the same recall test immediately afterward. The music group recalls a mean of 19.4 words and the silence group a mean of 22.1 words. The researcher concludes that background music impairs learning.
Which of the following is the most serious threat to the researcher's causal conclusion?
An immediate test narrows what the study can say about durable learning, which is a fair limitation. But the delay was identical in both conditions, and a weakness that applies equally to both groups cannot explain why they differed.
This is self-selection, and it is the confound that matters here. Students who pick a 4 p.m. slot may differ from students who pick 6 p.m. in sleep, course load, or study habits, and every one of those differences travels with the condition. Random assignment is the design feature that would rule them out.
A lyrics condition would tell you more about which kind of music matters, but it would leave the existing comparison just as uninterpretable. Adding conditions does not repair groups that differed before the manipulation began.
You cannot judge whether a 2.7-word gap is real by looking at it; that needs the spread of the scores and a significance test. And even a large, clearly real difference would still have self-selection as a rival explanation.
Data: four measures of sleep quality given to the same 150 adults. Test-retest reliability is the correlation between scores taken two weeks apart. The validity column is the correlation between each measure and total sleep time recorded by a wrist actigraph on the same nights.
Measure
Test-retest r
r with actigraph sleep time
Single item: "I am a good sleeper" (yes/no)
0.88
0.15
Nightly 1–5 rating of how rested you feel
0.61
0.24
Nightly diary of minutes asleep
0.79
0.68
Bed partner's report of how well you slept
0.55
0.34
Which measure best illustrates that a measure can be highly reliable and still have poor validity?
The diary is the measure that works: reasonably consistent across two weeks at 0.79, and by far the closest to the actigraph record at 0.68. It is the example of reliability and validity together, not of the two coming apart.
The partner's report is the weakest entry on both counts, 0.55 across occasions and 0.34 against the actigraph. A measure that is neither consistent nor accurate cannot illustrate a point that requires one high number and one low one.
This item is the most consistent of the four across two weeks, at 0.88, and the least related to how long the person actually slept, at 0.15. People answer it the same way every time because it reports a stable self-image, which is exactly how a measure can be perfectly reliable and still miss the construct.
This measure is mediocre on both counts, 0.61 and 0.24. Because its reliability is the second lowest in the table, it cannot be the example of high reliability paired with weak validity.
Described study
Researchers recruit 48 first-year college students for what the consent form describes as a study of group problem solving. Each participant is seated with three other people who appear to be fellow participants but are working for the researchers and who, on twelve of eighteen trials, give the same obviously wrong answer to a simple perceptual question. The measure is how often the participant gives the group's wrong answer. Participants are told they may stop at any time, and responses are stored without names. Sessions last about twenty minutes.
Because the procedure uses deception, which additional safeguard is required?
Deception is permitted only when a study cannot be run without it and participants are told the truth as soon as the session ends. Debriefing restores what an incomplete consent form could not cover, and it is the step this description leaves out.
Random assignment is a design feature that supports causal claims, not an ethical guideline. Adding a comparison group would strengthen the inference and do nothing at all about the fact that participants were misled.
The description already says responses are stored without names, so anonymity is in place. It is a genuine guideline, but it is not the one that the use of deception specifically triggers.
Telling participants beforehand would eliminate the deception rather than justify it, and the behavior under study would vanish with it. The rule is not that deception must be disclosed in advance but that it must be disclosed afterward.
A news story reports that a large twin study estimated the heritability of height in a Dutch sample at about 0.80. A reader concludes that 80% of his own height was produced by his genes and 20% by his diet. Which of the following best identifies the error?
Heritability is estimated for physical traits as routinely as for psychological ones, and height is one of the standard textbook examples. The trouble with the reader's conclusion is what the statistic refers to, not which kind of trait it describes.
Heritability is not a twin correlation read off directly. It is calculated from how much more similar identical twins are than fraternal twins, and it describes a population rather than a match rate for any pair of people.
Genes and environments do interact, but that does not make heritability meaningless. It stays a well-defined statistic about variation within a specific population at a specific time, which is precisely the part the reader drops.
The statistic is about variance between people: in this Dutch sample most of the differences in height track genetic differences. It does not partition the reader's own height, and in a population where nutrition varied far more, the same trait would show lower heritability.
During an unexpected fire alarm, Amara's heart pounds and her hands go cold within seconds. The alarm is canceled after two minutes, but ten minutes later she is still shaky and her heart is still fast. Which of the following best explains why her arousal outlasts the alarm?
The somatic nervous system carries voluntary commands to skeletal muscle; it is not what raises heart rate or constricts the vessels in her hands. Those organs are under autonomic control, which is the whole reason the division exists.
This is the two-speed design of the stress response. The sympathetic division acts in a fraction of a second through nerves, and it also tells the adrenal glands to release epinephrine into the blood, where it keeps acting on the heart until it is metabolized: minutes after the danger has passed.
The parasympathetic division works through the vagus nerve and does not wait on a pituitary signal. The pituitary belongs to the slower cortisol pathway, not to the switch that turns arousal off.
The two divisions are not locked in a tug-of-war at full strength; the parasympathetic division becomes dominant as arousal subsides. Sustained shakiness is explained by how long a hormone stays in the blood, not by simultaneous maximum firing.
Dmitri brushes a hot pan lightly and feels a mild sting; a moment later he grips it and feels intense pain. Which of the following best describes what differs at the level of the individual sensory neurons?
This is the all-or-none principle. A neuron either reaches threshold and fires at full strength or does not fire at all, so intensity has to be coded some other way, by how often a neuron fires and by how many neurons are recruited.
This is the most common misconception about action potentials. Once threshold is crossed the spike is the same size every time; a stronger stimulus does not produce a bigger spike, any more than pressing a doorbell harder makes it louder.
A resting potential sitting above threshold would mean the neuron fired continuously with no input at all, which would make it useless as a signal. Resting potential stays near −70 mV, and it is depolarization from incoming input that carries the cell to roughly −55 mV.
The refractory period is the brief window after firing during which the neuron cannot fire again, so lengthening it would lower the maximum firing rate rather than raise the signal. Charge does not accumulate across spikes to build a larger one.
Data: described bar graph of mean fluid consumed per day by two groups of laboratory rats.
The horizontal axis has two groups: rats housed alone in standard cages, and rats housed together in a large social colony. Each group has two bars, one for a sweetened morphine solution and one for plain water. The vertical axis is mean milliliters consumed per day and runs from 0 to 20. For the isolated group the morphine bar reaches 8.4 mL and the water bar 12.0 mL. For the colony group the morphine bar reaches 2.1 mL and the water bar 18.3 mL.
Which conclusion is best supported by the graph?
Add the two bars for each group and both totals come to 20.4 mL. Total fluid intake is effectively held constant across the groups, so it cannot explain a four-fold difference in morphine solution.
The graph says nothing about addictiveness in general; it compares two housing conditions in one species. The colony animals' low intake is a fact about those rats in that environment, not a property of the drug.
8.4 plus 12.0 and 2.1 plus 18.3 both equal 20.4 mL, so the groups differ in what they drank rather than in how much. 8.4 of 20.4 is about 41% and 2.1 of 20.4 about 10%: the comparison the display actually licenses.
Two problems at once: the participants were rats, and even inside the study, housing was manipulated in a laboratory rather than across human lives. A causal claim about substance use disorder in people needs evidence this design cannot supply.
After a stroke, a woman speaks in short, effortful bursts, "want... water... cup", and is visibly frustrated by her own speech. She follows spoken instructions accurately and points to the correct object every time she is asked. Damage to which area best accounts for this pattern?
Damage to Wernicke's area produces the opposite pattern: speech that flows easily but carries little meaning, paired with impaired comprehension. This woman understands everything said to her, which rules that area out.
Hippocampal damage blocks the formation of new explicit memories; it does not disrupt the production of speech. She is not failing to remember the word: she knows what she wants to say and cannot get it out.
The cerebellum supports balance, coordinated movement, and procedural learning. Cerebellar damage can slur articulation, but it does not produce the grammar-stripped, telegraphic output described here.
Non-fluent aphasia (halting, effortful speech with comprehension largely intact and the person aware of the problem) is the signature of damage to Broca's area. Its position beside the motor cortex also explains why right-side weakness so often accompanies it.
Data: one adult's overnight sleep recording, divided into four successive cycles of about 90 minutes. The table gives the minutes of N3 (slow-wave) sleep and of REM sleep in each cycle; the remaining minutes in each cycle were N1 and N2.
Cycle
1
2
3
4
N3 sleep (minutes)
45
30
10
0
REM sleep (minutes)
8
18
32
45
A student whose sleep follows this pattern goes to bed, sleeps through cycles 1 and 2, about three hours, and then gets up to study. Which of the following is best supported by the table?
The table shows the reverse. N3 falls from 45 minutes in cycle 1 to none at all in cycle 4, so slow-wave sleep is front-loaded and a shortened night keeps most of it.
Add the columns she skipped. Cycles 3 and 4 hold 32 plus 45, or 77, of the night's 103 REM minutes, close to 75%, while the two cycles she kept contain 75 of the 85 N3 minutes. That asymmetry is why a short night costs REM first, and why REM rebound tends to follow the next night.
The four cycles in the table are plainly not identical: N3 runs 45, 30, 10, 0 while REM runs 8, 18, 32, 45. Treating cycles as interchangeable is the assumption these data contradict.
Consolidation is not confined to one stage; overnight gains on motor sequence tasks are associated with sleep containing both slow-wave and REM periods. Keeping N3 while losing three-quarters of REM is a real cost, not a neutral trade.
In the last hour of a long shift, a baggage screener fails to flag a prohibited item that is clearly visible on the scanner image. Her supervisor then announces that inspectors are running test images through the line, and over the next hour she flags several harmless objects as suspicious. Which of the following best explains the change in her performance?
An absolute threshold is the weakest stimulus a person detects half the time, and it does not drop because a supervisor makes an announcement. Nothing about her eyes changed; what changed is how much evidence she demanded before saying yes.
Sensory adaptation is a receptor-level decline in response to unchanging stimulation, and the images on her screen change every few seconds. It also cannot explain a rise in false alarms, which is a decision made about ambiguous evidence.
Signal detection theory separates sensitivity from the criterion. Fatigue and a long uneventful stretch pushed her criterion toward "nothing there," producing a miss; the warning raised the cost of a miss and dragged the criterion down, and the predictable by-product of catching more real threats is flagging more harmless objects.
Weber's law describes the proportional size of a just-noticeable difference between two stimuli, such as two weights or two tones. It is about discriminating magnitudes, not about the decision rule a person adopts when the incentives change.
Unit 1 ended with sensation, the detection of raw stimuli. Unit 2 begins where sensation stops. The brain does not passively record what the senses deliver; it organizes, interprets, and often fills in missing pieces, using what it already knows. This process is perception, and it produces your experience of a stable, meaningful world. This lesson covers the factors that shape perception (what is expected, what is known, and what culture teaches), the rules the mind uses to organize shapes, and attention, which decides what gets perceived in the first place. The next lesson takes up depth, constancy, and motion in vision.
Required content · 2.1.A
Learning objective.
2.1.A. Explain how internal and external factors influence perception.
Essential knowledge.
2.1.A.1. Perception is influenced by whether one primarily relies on external sensory information (bottom-up processing) or internal prior expectations (top-down processing).
2.1.A.2. Schemas and perceptual sets are internal factors that filter perceptions of the world.
2.1.A.3. Contexts, experiences, and cultural experiences and expectations are external factors that filter perceptions of the world.
2.1.A.4. Perceptual principles proposed by Gestalt psychology (closure, figure and ground, proximity, and similarity) help explain how humans organize their perceptual world.
2.1.A.5. Attention is an interaction of sensation and perception that is affected by internal and external processes.
2.1.A.5.i. Some experiences of attention can be selective, such as with the cocktail party effect, where people attend to mentions of their names or specific topics in loud or distracting environments.
2.1.A.5.ii. Inattention can lead to a type of “blindness” to aspects of the environment. Change blindness occurs when changes to the environment are not perceived due to inattention. 1.B 3.A
Bottom-up and top-down processing
Perception works in two directions at once. In bottom-up processing, you start with the raw sensory information and build up to a perception. The receptors send in details (edges, colors, sounds), and the brain assembles them: the information flows from the senses upward to the brain. In top-down processing, you start with what you already know, expect, or want to see, and your prior knowledge guides how you interpret the sensory input: information flows from the brain down to interpret the senses. The exam describes perception as influenced by whether one relies primarily on external sensory information (bottom-up) or on internal prior expectations (top-down).
Reading a sentence with a blurry word shows both at once. You see the letters (bottom-up), but you use the sentence's meaning (top-down) to fill in the word. Unusual stimuli lean on bottom-up processing, since expectations do not help; familiar stimuli in familiar settings lean on top-down processing, which is faster but can lead you to see what you expect rather than what is there.
Internal factors: schemas and perceptual sets
Two internal factors filter how you see the world. A schema is a mental framework, an organized set of knowledge, built from experience about a concept, person, or situation (Lesson 2.3 covers how schemas form). A schema about restaurants tells you what to expect when you walk in, and it shapes what you notice. A perceptual set is a mental predisposition to perceive one thing and not another. If you are told that the picture is of a rabbit, you see the rabbit, and if told it is a duck, you see the duck. Perceptual sets arise from expectations, motives, emotions, and recent experience, and they explain why two people can look at the same ambiguous scene and see different things.
Study spotlight · Bruner and Postman (1949)
Jerome Bruner and Leo Postman briefly showed participants playing cards, one at a time, for very short exposures that were gradually lengthened until the participants identified each card correctly. Most of the cards were ordinary, but some were trick cards with the wrong color for the suit, such as a red six of spades or a black four of hearts. Participants usually identified the trick cards as normal ones (for example, calling a red six of spades "six of spades" or "six of hearts") without noticing anything odd, and they needed more time to realize something was wrong. Some became confused or distressed when they could not make sense of the cards.
Reading the research: a controlled laboratory experiment in which the dependent variable was the exposure time needed to identify the card. It shows that expectations (a perceptual set from long experience with card suits) shape perception through top-down processing. A limitation is that the sample was small, drawn from college students, and the study measured reports rather than direct neural processing.
External factors: context, experience, and culture
External factors also filter perception. Context can change what a stimulus looks like: the same gray patch looks darker against a white background than against a black one, and an ambiguous letter in the middle of a word is read according to the word. Experience matters too: people who have spent their lives in cities see differently from people who have not. Cultural experiences and expectations shape perception as well. A well-known example is the Müller-Lyer illusion, two lines of equal length that look unequal because of the arrowheads at their ends. In a classic study, Marshall Segall and colleagues found that people from cultures with few straight lines and right angles in their surroundings were less susceptible to the illusion than people from cultures with many of them, suggesting that visual experience trains perception. Notice again that sensation is the same for everyone, but perception is not.
Gestalt principles of organization
How does the brain turn a scatter of edges and colors into whole objects? The Gestalt psychologists of the early twentieth century (the word means "whole" or "form") argued that we perceive organized wholes, not just collections of parts: "the whole is different from the sum of its parts." They proposed principles that the mind uses to organize sensory input. Four are required.
Figure 2.1. Four Gestalt principles of perceptual organization. We see a figure against a ground, group near things (rows of pairs), group similar things (columns of circles and squares), and fill in gaps to see complete shapes.
Figure and ground. You organize a scene into a figure (the object that stands out) and the ground (the background). Ambiguous images, such as the vase and two faces, can switch because the figure and ground can reverse.
Proximity. Objects that are near one another are grouped together. A row of dots arranged in pairs looks like pairs.
Similarity. Objects that are alike in shape, color, or size are grouped together. A grid of alternating columns of circles and squares looks like columns.
Closure. We fill in gaps to see a complete figure. A circle drawn with small gaps is still seen as a circle.
Attention
You cannot process everything, so attention selects what you will process. Attention is an interaction of sensation and perception, and it is affected by internal factors (goals, interests) and external ones (a loud noise, a sudden movement).
Selective attention is focusing on one stimulus while filtering out others. The cocktail party effect is the ability to follow one conversation in a noisy room, and to notice when someone across the room says your name or a topic that interests you, even though you were not attending to that conversation.
Inattentional blindness is a failure to notice a visible stimulus because attention is focused elsewhere. Change blindness is a failure to notice a change in the environment, because attention is not directed to it.
Study spotlight · "Gorillas in our midst" (Simons and Chabris, 1999)
Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris showed participants a video of two teams of players, one in white shirts and one in black, passing basketballs. Participants had to count the passes made by the team in white. Partway through, a person in a gorilla suit walked into the middle of the scene, beat its chest, and walked off, in view for about nine seconds. About half of the participants did not notice the gorilla.
Reading the research: an experiment in which the independent variable was the task (and details such as the color of the team) and the dependent variable was whether participants reported the gorilla. It demonstrates inattentional blindness: when attention is directed to a demanding task, even a large and unusual object can go unseen. The findings suggest that people overestimate how much they notice, which matters for subjects such as eyewitness testimony and distracted driving.
Worked example · Top-down or bottom-up?
A radiologist glances at an X-ray and instantly says "broken wrist," while a first-year student has to examine each part of the image carefully, naming the structures. Explain the difference.
Step 1, the radiologist has years of experience and strong schemas for what X-rays look like. She relies on top-down processing: her knowledge and expectations guide interpretation of the image quickly.
Step 2, the student lacks these schemas and must work bottom-up, building the perception piece by piece from the details.
Step 3, a risk for the radiologist is the flip side: expectations can cause her to miss something unexpected in an image, such as a second problem in a place she was not looking. This is a perceptual set at work.
Worked example · Which Gestalt principle?
Name the principle at work. (a) You see a dotted outline of a dog on a sign and recognize a dog. (b) In a logo, you see white arrows in the space between black letters. (c) In a field of red and blue marbles, you see two groups by color. (d) In a night sky, you group stars that are close together into a constellation.
Step 1, (a) filling in the gaps is closure.
Step 2, (b) seeing the space between letters as a shape is a figure-ground reversal.
Step 3, (c) grouping by shared color is similarity.
Step 4, (d) grouping nearby stars is proximity.
Worked example · Attention in everyday life
A driver is talking on a phone and drives through a stop sign she has driven past a hundred times, later insisting she never saw it. Explain with two concepts.
Step 1, inattentional blindness: her attention was on the conversation, so she failed to notice a visible stimulus.
Step 2, top-down processing and a perceptual set: she expected no stop sign changes along a familiar route, so she did not look for it.
Step 3, this fits the Simons and Chabris finding that a stimulus in plain view can go unnoticed when attention is elsewhere, which is why laws against phone use while driving are supported by research.
Exam focus
Bottom-up = from stimulus to perception; top-down = from prior knowledge and expectations. Schemas and perceptual sets are internal filters; context, experience, and culture are external filters.
Gestalt principles to know: figure and ground, proximity, similarity, closure.
Selective attention and the cocktail party effect; inattentional blindness and change blindness result from lack of attention.
Practice
Distinguish bottom-up from top-down processing, with an example of each.
Show answer
Bottom-up processing builds a perception from the sensory details (such as assembling edges into an unfamiliar shape); top-down processing uses prior knowledge and expectations to interpret the input (such as reading a smudged word by using the sentence).
What did Bruner and Postman's playing-card study show?
Show answer
People often identified trick cards (such as a red spade) as normal ones, because their expectations (perceptual set) shaped perception; unexpected stimuli took longer to notice.
Identify the principle: a row of dots arranged in tight pairs looks like pairs of dots.
Show answer
Proximity: things near one another are perceived as a group.
What is the cocktail party effect, and what kind of attention does it show?
Show answer
The ability to focus on one conversation in a noisy setting while still noticing your own name in another. It shows selective attention.
How is change blindness different from inattentional blindness?
Show answer
Inattentional blindness is failing to see an unexpected object that is in view because attention is elsewhere; change blindness is failing to notice that something in a scene has changed.
How does the Müller-Lyer study across cultures support the claim that culture shapes perception?
Show answer
People from cultures with fewer straight lines and corners in their environment were less fooled by the illusion, suggesting that experience with such environments trains the way the brain interprets lines.
Visual perception: depth, constancy, and apparent motion
The image on each of your retinas is flat, and it is changing all the time as your eyes, head, and body move. Yet you perceive a stable three-dimensional world of objects that stay the same size, shape, and color. This is one of the brain's great achievements, and its methods are the subject of this lesson: the cues the visual system uses to judge distance and depth, the constancies that keep objects looking the same as the images of them change, and the illusion of movement. The lesson ends by showing how the same mechanisms that usually produce accurate perceptions can produce errors, which is the basis of visual illusions.
Required content · 2.1.B
Learning objective.
2.1.B. Explain how visual perceptual processes produce correct or incorrect interpretations of stimuli.
Essential knowledge.
2.1.B.1. Binocular depth cues of retinal disparity (the difference between the images projecting onto the retina) and convergence (the merging of the retinal images by the brain) utilize images from each eye to provide perception of depth.
2.1.B.2. Monocular depth cues (relative clarity, relative size, texture gradient, linear perspective, and interposition) give the illusion of depth on flat or two-dimensional surfaces. Exclusion Statement: The AP Psychology Exam will only address the listed monocular depth cues in EK 2.1.B.2.
2.1.B.3. Visual perceptual constancies maintain the perception of an object even when the images of the object in the visual field change.
2.1.B.4. Apparent movement can be visually perceived even when objects are not actually moving. 55
Binocular depth cues
Because your two eyes are a few centimeters apart, each gets a slightly different view of the world. The brain uses this to judge depth. Two binocular cues (cues that require both eyes) are required:
Retinal disparity is the difference between the images that fall on the two retinas. Nearby objects produce a large disparity (the images are very different), and distant objects produce a small one. The brain uses the size of the disparity to calculate distance. You can see it by holding a finger in front of your face and closing one eye and then the other: the finger seems to jump against the background.
Convergence is the inward turning of the eyes when looking at a nearby object. The brain uses the strain on the eye muscles as a cue: the more the eyes turn inward, the closer the object. Look at a finger moving toward your nose, and you can feel your eyes converging.
Binocular cues work only at moderate distances (a few meters). For farther objects, the retinal images are nearly identical.
Monocular depth cues
Monocular cues need only one eye, and they are the cues artists use to create the illusion of depth on a flat surface such as a painting or photograph. The exam lists five.
Relative clarity: objects that look sharp and clear seem closer, and hazy objects seem farther. Distant mountains look blurry because of haze in the air.
Relative size: if two objects are assumed to be about the same size, the one that casts a smaller image on the retina seems farther away.
Texture gradient: the texture of a surface becomes finer and less distinct with distance. A field of pebbles looks coarse nearby and smooth far away.
Linear perspective: parallel lines, such as railroad tracks, appear to converge as they recede into the distance. The more the lines converge, the greater the perceived distance.
Interposition: if one object partially blocks the view of another, the blocking object is seen as closer.
You do not need to learn other monocular cues (such as shadows or motion parallax) for the exam.
Perceptual constancies
The image of an object on your retina changes enormously as you move toward or away from it, view it from a different angle, or see it under different light. Yet you perceive the object as unchanged. Perceptual constancy is the perception of an object as having stable properties, even as the sensory image changes. The three main kinds are:
Size constancy: perceiving an object as the same size even as its image on the retina grows or shrinks with distance. A friend walking away does not seem to shrink, although the image on your retina does.
Shape constancy: perceiving an object's shape as the same even when its retinal image changes with the viewing angle. A door appears rectangular even as it swings open and its image becomes a trapezoid.
Color and brightness constancy: perceiving a color or lightness as stable even as lighting changes. A white shirt looks white in dim and in bright light.
Constancy depends on depth cues: your brain takes into account how far away something is when deciding how large it is. That is why mistakes in judging depth lead to mistakes in judging size.
Apparent movement
You can perceive motion even when nothing moves. Apparent movement is the perception of motion from stationary stimuli presented in rapid succession. The classic form is the phi phenomenon: when two lights a short distance apart flash on and off alternately in quick succession, you see a single light moving back and forth. Neon signs, movie film, and video screens all rely on it: a sequence of still images shown quickly is perceived as smooth motion.
Study spotlight · Wertheimer's apparent motion (1912)
The German psychologist Max Wertheimer presented observers with two stationary lights that flashed one after the other. When the time between the flashes was very short, the observers saw two lights flashing at once. When the interval was long, they saw two separate flashes. At an intermediate interval of a few tenths of a second, the observers saw a single light moving from one position to the other. Wertheimer's observation helped launch Gestalt psychology, since the perception of motion, a whole, was not present in either stimulus alone.
Reading the research: an experiment in which the independent variable was the time between flashes and the dependent variable was the observers' report. It is early and relies on self-report from a few observers, but the effect has been replicated many times and is the basis of film.
When perception goes wrong: illusions
A visual illusion is a perception that does not match reality, and illusions arise because the same rules that normally produce accurate perception are applied in a misleading situation. In the Müller-Lyer illusion, a line with outward-pointing arrowheads looks shorter than an identical line with inward-pointing arrowheads. In the Ponzo illusion, two identical horizontal bars are drawn between converging lines, and the upper one looks larger. In both, depth cues such as linear perspective trigger the brain to adjust the apparent size, and size constancy then produces a wrong answer, because the image is flat. This is a useful lesson in how perception is an active process of interpretation. The brain's "mistakes" are usually adaptive in the three-dimensional world, where converging lines really do mean distance.
Worked example · Identify the cue
Name the depth cue in each. (a) In a photograph of a street, the parked cars on the near side look large and cars far down the road look tiny. (b) A hiker sees a tree partially hidden behind a boulder and judges it to be farther away. (c) Two ladybugs appear at different distances on a window and a person with one eye covered can still tell which is closer because one is sharper. (d) A brain compares the differences between the two retinal images of a cup.
Step 1, (a) similar objects appear smaller in the distance: relative size (and the converging street edges would add linear perspective).
Step 2, (b) one object blocks another: interposition.
Step 3, (c) the sharper one looks closer: relative clarity. Because the person has one eye covered, this is a monocular cue.
Step 4, (d) comparing the two retinal images is retinal disparity, a binocular cue.
Worked example · Constancy in action
A friend walks away down a long hallway. Her image on your retina shrinks to a tiny fraction of its starting size, yet you do not think she is shrinking. What concept explains this, and what would happen if you could not judge distance?
Step 1, size constancy: the brain perceives her as the same size, even though the retinal image shrinks.
Step 2, the brain does this by taking distance into account (using depth cues such as linear perspective and texture gradient in the hallway). It reasons that a smaller image from a greater distance means the same size.
Step 3, if depth cues were removed (viewing her through a tiny hole so that nothing indicates distance), the brain could misjudge her size, as in an illusion.
Worked example · Explaining the Ponzo illusion
In a drawing of railroad tracks converging toward the top, two identical horizontal bars are placed across the tracks, one higher than the other. The upper bar looks longer. Explain.
Step 1, the converging lines are a linear perspective cue that the upper part of the picture is farther away.
Step 2, the brain assumes that if two objects cast the same size image but one is farther, the farther one must be larger (a consequence of size constancy).
Step 3, the bars are drawn on a flat page, so they are actually the same length. The mistake arises because depth cues that are usually helpful are misapplied to a flat picture.
Exam focus
Binocular cues: retinal disparity (difference between the two images) and convergence (eyes turning inward). Monocular cues (only these five): relative clarity, relative size, texture gradient, linear perspective, interposition.
Perceptual constancies: size, shape, color and brightness constancy keep objects stable as the image changes.
Apparent movement (the phi phenomenon): motion is perceived from stationary stimuli shown in succession.
Illusions show that perception is constructed: depth cues and constancy applied to flat pictures can produce errors.
Practice
What is the difference between retinal disparity and convergence?
Show answer
Retinal disparity is the difference between the images on the two retinas (greater for nearer objects). Convergence is the inward turning of the eyes when looking at a nearby object, with the muscle tension as the cue.
Which monocular depth cue is at work when railroad tracks appear to meet in the distance?
Show answer
Linear perspective.
Why does a car driving away appear to stay the same size even though its image on the retina shrinks?
Show answer
Size constancy: the brain accounts for the increasing distance and perceives the car's size as constant.
How do movies create the perception of motion from still frames?
Show answer
Through apparent movement (the phi phenomenon): still frames shown in quick succession are perceived as continuous motion.
A student says that someone with one eye cannot perceive depth. Evaluate this claim.
Show answer
It is false. A person with one eye cannot use binocular cues (retinal disparity and convergence) but can use monocular cues such as relative size, relative clarity, texture gradient, linear perspective, and interposition.
Explain why the Müller-Lyer illusion fools us even when we know the lines are equal.
Show answer
The brain automatically applies depth and size-constancy rules to the arrowhead cues, which usually produce accurate perception in three-dimensional scenes, so the illusion persists even when we know the truth.
Thinking, problem solving, judgment, and decision making
Thinking is mental activity that processes information: forming concepts, solving problems, making judgments, and deciding what to do. Most of the time people think quickly and reasonably well, but the shortcuts they use also produce predictable errors. This lesson covers the building blocks of thought (concepts and schemas), the strategies people use to solve problems (algorithms and heuristics), the influences and fallacies that distort decisions, and the abilities that let people direct their thinking toward a goal (executive functions and creativity). Because these are the mental mistakes that show up in the real world, from shopping to gambling, expect many scenario questions on this topic.
Required content · 2.2.A
Learning objective.
2.2.A. Explain how psychological concepts and theories account for thinking, problem-solving, judgment, and decision-making.
Essential knowledge.
2.2.A.1. Concepts form the basis of thought. Prototypes are the ideal example for any given concept.
2.2.A.2. People form and modify schemas, or frameworks for thinking, through assimilation (taking in new information but not changing the schema in light of it) and accommodation (taking in new information and changing the schema to incorporate the new information).
2.2.A.3. Algorithms address problems by attempting all possible solutions until the correct one is found.
2.2.A.4. Heuristics address problems by using mental shortcuts to make judgments. Using heuristics can lead to errors in judgment when decisions are made according to prior expectations or stereotypes (representativeness heuristic) or recalling the first or most vivid example that comes to mind (availability heuristic).
2.2.A.5. Decision making can be influenced by prior experiences that were successful (mental set) or circumstances surrounding a decision (priming and framing).
2.2.A.6. Cognitive processes such as gambler’s fallacy and sunk-cost fallacy can hinder people from making good decisions. 1.B 2.A
2.2.A.7. Executive functions are cognitive processes that allow individuals to generate, organize, plan, and carry out goal-directed behaviors and experience critical thinking.
2.2.A.8. Creativity is a way of thinking that includes generating novel ideas and engaging in divergent (versus convergent) thinking. Creative thinking is hindered by functional fixedness.
Concepts, prototypes, and schemas
A concept is a mental grouping of similar objects, events, ideas, or people. Concepts form the basis of thought: you do not have to relearn what a chair is each time you see one. People often organize a concept around a prototype, the best or most typical example. For most people the prototype of "bird" is something like a robin, not a penguin, and so a robin is recognized as a bird faster.
A schema is a mental framework, an organized pattern of knowledge about a concept or situation that helps you interpret new experiences. People form and change their schemas through two processes, introduced by Jean Piaget (Lesson 3.4).
Assimilation is taking in new information and fitting it into an existing schema, without changing the schema. A toddler who knows "dog" calls a cat a dog, assimilating the new animal into an old schema.
Accommodation is taking in new information and changing the schema to include it. When the toddler learns that the cat meows and is not a dog, the child adjusts the "dog" schema and builds a new "cat" schema.
Strategies for solving problems
An algorithm is a step-by-step procedure that will always produce the correct solution, trying all the possible solutions if necessary. A recipe or a math formula is an algorithm. A student who tries every possible combination on a lock until it opens is using an algorithm. Algorithms are reliable but can be very slow.
A heuristic is a mental shortcut or rule of thumb that lets you make a judgment quickly. Heuristics are fast and often right, but not guaranteed, and they can lead to errors in judgment. Two are required.
The representativeness heuristic judges the likelihood of something by how well it matches a prototype or stereotype, ignoring other information such as how common it is. If a quiet, tidy person who loves books is described, people guess "librarian" rather than "salesperson," even though there are far more salespeople than librarians.
The availability heuristic judges how common or likely something is by how easily examples come to mind. Dramatic, recent, or vivid events come to mind easily, so people overestimate their frequency. After news reports of a plane crash, people overestimate the danger of flying, even though driving is far more dangerous.
What sways decisions
Several things push decisions in predictable directions.
Mental set is a tendency to approach a problem in the way that has worked before. It helps when the old solution works, but it blocks seeing a better solution when the situation has changed.
Priming is the activation of certain associations, often unconsciously, that then influence later thoughts or behavior. Seeing the word "yellow" makes you faster to recognize "banana." Quick exposure to a word or scene can shift later judgments.
Framing is the way an issue is presented, which can change the choices people make even when the facts are the same. A treatment described as having a "90% survival rate" sounds better than one with a "10% death rate," though they are identical.
Study spotlight · Tversky and Kahneman's framing of a decision (1981)
Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman gave participants this scenario: a disease is expected to kill 600 people, and two programs are proposed. One group chose between Program A ("200 people will be saved") and Program B ("a one-third chance that 600 will be saved and a two-thirds chance that none will be saved"). A large majority, about 72 percent, chose the certain option, A. A second group was given the same facts framed in terms of losses: Program C ("400 people will die") or Program D ("a one-third chance that nobody will die and a two-thirds chance that 600 will die"). Now a large majority, about 78 percent, chose the risky option, D. The two sets of programs are mathematically identical.
Reading the research: an experiment with the framing (gain or loss) as the independent variable and the choice as the dependent variable. Participants were randomly assigned to the frames. It shows that framing, not the facts, can change decisions. A limitation is that these were hypothetical choices, not real decisions with real consequences.
Fallacies that hinder good decisions
Two common errors in reasoning are named on the exam.
The gambler's fallacy is the belief that after a run of one outcome, the opposite outcome is "due." A person who has seen a fair coin land on heads five times may bet heavily on tails, but the coin has no memory, and the chance of tails is still one half on the next flip.
The sunk-cost fallacy is the tendency to continue investing in something because of what you have already put in (time, money, or effort), even when it would be wiser to stop. Someone who sits through a terrible movie "because I paid for the ticket" is committing it, because the money is gone whichever choice is made, and what matters is what is best from now on.
The exam also lists other mistakes you may be asked about: overconfidence (being more certain than your accuracy justifies), hindsight bias (the belief, after learning an outcome, that you "knew it all along"), and confirmation bias, which Unit 4 explains.
Executive functions
Executive functions are cognitive processes that allow you to generate, organize, plan, and carry out goal-directed behavior, and they include critical thinking. They depend heavily on the prefrontal cortex. Planning a study schedule, resisting the urge to check your phone, switching strategies when one fails, and holding several steps in mind are all executive functions. They develop through childhood and adolescence, which is part of why teenagers sometimes act impulsively.
Creativity
Creativity is a way of thinking that generates novel and useful ideas. It involves divergent thinking, producing many different possible answers to an open-ended question (How many uses can you think of for a brick?), as opposed to convergent thinking, narrowing down to the single best answer to a problem (What is 14 times 6?). Creativity is hindered by functional fixedness, the tendency to see objects only in terms of their usual function.
Study spotlight · Duncker's candle problem (1945)
Karl Duncker gave participants a candle, a box of thumbtacks, and a book of matches and asked them to attach the candle to a wall so that it would burn without dripping wax on the table. Many participants struggled because they saw the box only as a container for the tacks. Those who thought of the box as something that could also be a platform (tack the empty box to the wall and set the candle in it) solved the problem. In versions where the tacks were outside the box, so that the box looked empty and available, more people solved it.
Reading the research: an experiment comparing conditions. It shows functional fixedness: the usual use of an object blocks a new use. A limitation is that it is a single puzzle, so one needs other tasks to show how widely the effect holds.
Worked example · Name the heuristic or fallacy
Identify the concept. (a) After watching news coverage of a shark attack, Maya refuses to swim in the ocean, thinking attacks are common. (b) Ben has lost six games of roulette in a row and bets his remaining money on red because "it's due." (c) Dana keeps pouring money into repairs on an old car because she has already spent $3,000. (d) A man in a business suit with a briefcase is assumed to be a lawyer rather than a teacher, though there are more teachers.
Step 1, (a) examples are vivid and easy to recall: the availability heuristic.
Step 2, (b) believing a streak will reverse: the gambler's fallacy.
Step 3, (c) continuing because of past investment: the sunk-cost fallacy.
Step 4, (d) judging by how well the person matches a stereotype and ignoring the base rate: the representativeness heuristic.
Worked example · Algorithm or heuristic?
A student must find the right 3-digit combination for a lock. She tries 000, 001, 002, and so on until it opens. Her friend instead tries birthdays and other numbers that people often use. Which strategy is which, and what are the tradeoffs?
Step 1, the student who tries every combination in order uses an algorithm. It is guaranteed to work (there are only 1,000 possibilities), but it may take a very long time.
Step 2, the friend uses a heuristic, a shortcut based on how people usually choose numbers. It may find the answer quickly, but it is not guaranteed.
Step 3, the lesson is about the tradeoff: speed against certainty.
Worked example · The effect of framing
A hospital tells patients, "This surgery has a 90 percent survival rate." A different hospital tells patients, "This surgery has a 10 percent mortality rate." Which message will lead more people to choose surgery, and why?
Step 1, the two statements are mathematically identical, since 90% survive means 10% die.
Step 2, the first is framed as a gain (survival), the second as a loss (death), and people tend to respond more favorably to the positive frame, so more people will choose surgery after the first message.
Step 3, this is the framing effect. A good decision maker would check that the facts are the same and look at them in both ways before choosing.
Exam focus
Prototype: best example of a concept. Assimilation (fit new information into a schema) versus accommodation (change the schema).
Algorithm = guaranteed but slow. Heuristics = fast, error-prone: representativeness (matches a stereotype) and availability (easily recalled).
Influences: mental set, priming, framing. Fallacies: gambler's fallacy, sunk-cost fallacy; also overconfidence and hindsight bias.
Give an example of assimilation and one of accommodation.
Show answer
Assimilation: a child calls a zebra a "horse" (fits it to an existing schema). Accommodation: the child learns that zebras are different, and creates a new "zebra" schema.
Why might a person overestimate the chances of dying in a plane crash after hearing about one on the news?
Show answer
The availability heuristic: the vivid recent event comes to mind easily, so it seems more common than it is.
A coin has landed on heads seven times in a row. What is the probability that the next flip lands on tails, and which fallacy would suggest otherwise?
Show answer
50 percent (the flips are independent). The gambler's fallacy is the belief that tails is "due."
You do not want to leave a restaurant meal that is terrible because you paid a lot for it. Name the fallacy and the better reasoning.
Show answer
The sunk-cost fallacy. The money is already spent either way, so the better choice depends only on what you will gain or lose from now on.
What is functional fixedness and how did Duncker's candle problem illustrate it?
Show answer
It is seeing an object only in terms of its usual function. Participants who saw the tack box only as a container failed to see it could be a platform for the candle.
Describe one executive function and the brain area most involved.
Show answer
Examples include planning, organizing, and self-control. They depend largely on the prefrontal cortex in the frontal lobe.
Memory is the persistence of learning over time through the encoding, storage, and retrieval of information. Without it you would not recognize your own face, understand a sentence, or know how to ride a bicycle. This lesson is the first of five on memory. It maps the territory: the different kinds of memories, the biological process that strengthens a memory, and three models psychologists use to explain how memory is organized. The next three lessons follow information through the three stages (encoding, storage, retrieval), and the last asks why memory fails.
Required content · 2.3.A
Learning objective.
2.3.A. Explain how the types, structures, and processes of memory work.
Essential knowledge.
2.3.A.1. Memories for learned knowledge, events, and experiences are differentiated by how they are processed by, stored in, and retrieved by the brain.
2.3.A.1.i. Explicit memory is a type of memory that is more easily described or explained to others. Types of explicit memory include episodic and semantic.
2.3.A.1.ii. Implicit memory is more challenging to describe or explain to others. Procedural memory is a type of implicit memory for procedures and processes.
2.3.A.1.iii. Prospective memory is a type of memory related to future actions.
2.3.A.2. Long-term potentiation, a process by which synaptic connections between neurons become stronger with frequent activation, is a biological process for memory.
2.3.A.3. The working memory model examines how our primary memory system—working memory— engages in a dynamic interaction with several components, namely the central executive, phonological loop, and visuospatial sketchpad, to process information into long-term memory. 1.A 2.A
2.3.A.4. The multi-store model proposes three interacting systems (sensory memory [including iconic and echoic memory], short-term memory, and long-term memory) that information must pass through to be remembered. This model focuses on the impact of automatic and effortful processing on memory encoding, storage, and retrieval.
2.3.A.5. The levels of processing model proposes that memory is encoded on three levels from shallowest to deepest: structural, phonemic, and semantic.
Types of long-term memories
Memories for learned knowledge, events, and experiences differ in how they are processed, stored, and retrieved. The first big division is by whether you are aware of the memory.
Explicit memory (declarative memory) is memory you can consciously recall and describe to others. It has two subtypes.
Episodic memory is memory for personal experiences and events, tied to a time and place: your last birthday, what you ate for breakfast this morning, the first day of high school.
Semantic memory is memory for general facts and knowledge, not tied to when you learned them: that Paris is the capital of France, that a triangle has three sides.
Implicit memory (nondeclarative memory) is memory that influences behavior without conscious recall, and it is harder to describe to others. The key type is procedural memory, memory for skills and procedures: how to ride a bicycle, tie shoes, or type. You can do these without being able to explain exactly how.
Prospective memory is remembering to do something in the future, such as remembering to take medication at 8 p.m. or to return a book tomorrow. It fails often in daily life.
The biology of memory: long-term potentiation
How does an experience physically become a memory? When neurons fire together repeatedly, the connection between them gets stronger, so that the same input triggers a bigger response. This is long-term potentiation (LTP): a long-lasting strengthening of the synaptic connections between neurons after frequent activation. LTP is the main biological process for memory, and it is the reason practice improves recall. It involves increased sensitivity of receiving neurons (for example, to the neurotransmitter glutamate) and can involve the growth of new connections. A common summary is that neurons that fire together wire together.
Three models of how memory works
Psychologists use models to describe how information moves through memory. The exam requires three.
The working memory model
Working memory is the active, short-term system you use to hold and manipulate information in your mind right now, such as keeping a phone number in mind while dialing it or solving a math problem in your head. Alan Baddeley and Graham Hitch proposed that working memory is not a single storage place but a dynamic system with several components that interact to process information into long-term memory.
The central executive directs attention and coordinates the other parts, deciding what to work on and how to use information.
The phonological loop holds and processes spoken and written language, for example by silently repeating a phone number to yourself.
The visuospatial sketchpad holds and processes visual and spatial information, such as picturing the layout of a room or the route to school.
The multi-store model
Richard Atkinson and Richard Shiffrin proposed the multi-store model, which treats memory as three interacting systems that information must pass through to be remembered.
Figure 2.2. The multi-store model. Information must pass through sensory memory (held only if attended to), short-term or working memory (held for about 20 seconds unless rehearsed), and then be encoded into long-term memory, from which it can be retrieved.
Sensory memory is a brief, high-capacity record of sensory input. Iconic memory is visual (a fraction of a second), and echoic memory is auditory (a few seconds). Sensory memory holds a large amount but fades almost immediately unless it is attended to.
Short-term memory holds a small amount of information for a short time (roughly 20 seconds without rehearsal). Information is moved on by attention and rehearsal.
Long-term memory is the nearly unlimited, relatively permanent store.
The model emphasizes the role of automatic and effortful processing in encoding, storage, and retrieval. Automatic processing is the unconscious encoding of information such as the time of day, the place of an event, or frequency of things, without effort. Effortful processing requires attention and conscious effort, as when you study vocabulary or a list of dates. Most of the information that gets into long-term memory about school subjects does so through effortful processing.
The levels of processing model
Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart proposed the levels of processing model, which says that the depth at which you process information matters more than the number of stores it passes through. Memory is encoded on three levels, from the shallowest to the deepest:
Structural (shallow): attending to what the word looks like, such as whether it is written in capital letters.
Phonemic (intermediate): attending to the sound of the word, such as whether it rhymes with another word.
Semantic (deep): attending to the meaning of the word and how it relates to other ideas.
The deeper the level, the stronger the memory. Thinking about what a word means produces much better memory than noticing its shape or sound.
Study spotlight · Craik and Tulving's levels of processing (1975)
Fergus Craik and Endel Tulving showed participants a series of words, each preceded by a question. Some questions required shallow, structural processing ("Is the word in capital letters?"), some required phonemic processing ("Does the word rhyme with weight?"), and some required semantic processing ("Would the word fit the sentence 'He met a ___ in the street'?"). Later the participants were given a surprise recognition test with the original words mixed in with new ones. Words that had been processed semantically were recognized far more often than words processed phonemically, and those were recognized more than the structural words.
Reading the research: an experiment in which the independent variable was the type of question (the level of processing) and the dependent variable was how many words were later recognized. Participants did not know that a memory test was coming, which reduces the effect of deliberate strategies. A limitation is that the tasks used words on a list, which differ from real-world learning.
Study spotlight · Sperling's test of sensory memory (1960)
George Sperling flashed a grid of 12 letters (three rows of four) on a screen for about one-twentieth of a second. When asked to recall as many letters as possible (the whole-report method), participants could name only about four or five. But Sperling suspected that participants saw more than they could report before the image faded. In the partial-report method, a tone sounded just after the display disappeared: a high tone meant "report the top row," a medium tone meant "the middle row," and a low tone meant "the bottom row." Participants could then report almost all of the letters in whichever row was cued, which meant that they briefly held nearly all the letters in a fading visual memory.
Reading the research: an experiment comparing the two methods (the independent variable) with the number of letters reported (the dependent variable). It shows that sensory (iconic) memory has a large capacity but fades in less than a second. A limitation is that the stimuli were simple, briefly shown letters.
Worked example · Classify the memory
Classify each memory as episodic, semantic, procedural, or prospective. (a) Remembering that the Pacific is the largest ocean. (b) Remembering your graduation party. (c) Playing a piano piece from muscle memory without thinking about the notes. (d) Remembering to pick up milk on the way home.
Step 1, (a) general knowledge: semantic (explicit).
Step 2, (b) a personal event in time and place: episodic (explicit).
Step 3, (c) a skill performed automatically: procedural (implicit).
Step 4, (d) a plan for the future: prospective.
Worked example · Applying the working memory model
A student listens to a teacher give directions to a room ("go down the hall, turn right at the water fountain, and it is the third door on the left") and silently repeats them while picturing the hallway. Which components of working memory are involved?
Step 1, silently repeating the words uses the phonological loop.
Step 2, picturing the hallway uses the visuospatial sketchpad.
Step 3, deciding to coordinate the two strategies and keeping attention on the task is the work of the central executive.
Step 4, if the student then walks to the room and later remembers the route, information has been processed into long-term memory.
Worked example · Predict recall from levels of processing
Group A is asked to count the number of vowels in each word on a list. Group B is asked to decide whether each word is pleasant or unpleasant. Neither group knows that a memory test will follow. Which group will recall more, and why?
Step 1, Group A processes words at the structural (shallow) level, attending to letters.
Step 2, Group B processes the meaning of each word, a semantic (deep) level.
Step 3, according to the levels of processing model, deeper processing produces stronger memories, so Group B will recall more words.
Exam focus
Explicit memory (episodic, semantic) is conscious; implicit memory (procedural) is not. Prospective memory is remembering future actions.
Long-term potentiation is the strengthening of synapses with repeated activation: the biological basis of memory.
Working memory model: central executive, phonological loop, visuospatial sketchpad.
Which levels-of-processing task would produce the best memory for the word "brave": deciding whether it has five letters, whether it rhymes with "save," or whether it describes you?
Show answer
Deciding whether it describes you: it is the deepest (semantic) level, since it requires thinking about the meaning.
What did Sperling's partial-report study show about sensory memory?
Show answer
Sensory memory briefly holds much more information than people can report (nearly all the letters in a row), but it fades in less than a second.
Encoding is the first stage of memory: getting information into the memory system in a form that can be stored. How a piece of information is encoded can determine how well it is stored and later retrieved. The good news is that encoding is the one stage you can control. Many of the study habits students rely on, such as rereading and cramming, are among the least effective ways to encode, while several simple strategies (organizing, spacing, and putting information into meaningful form) are among the most effective. This lesson covers the strategies the exam names, with the evidence behind them, and it is a good place to practice evaluating an experiment.
Required content · 2.4.A
Learning objective.
2.4.A. Explain how different encoding processes work to get information into memory.
Essential knowledge.
2.4.A.1. Encoding involves processes and strategies to get information into memory. How information is encoded can determine how effectively information is stored and retrieved.
2.4.A.2. Mnemonic devices, such as method of loci, are processes that aid in encoding information into working and long-term memory.
2.4.A.3. Encoding can be improved by the process of grouping information together into meaningful chunks (“chunking”), categories, or hierarchies.
2.4.A.4. The spacing effect is a process that can cause significant differences in encoding and memory consolidation depending on whether the information is encoded all at once (massed practice) or distributed over time (distributed practice).
2.4.A.5. Encoding processes can be affected by the order of how the information is presented, called the serial position effect. The serial position effect predicts that information presented at the beginning of a list (primacy effect) or the end of a list (recency effect) will be more memorable than information presented in the middle of a list. 1.A 2.B 3.B
Encoding processes and strategies
Encoding involves processes and strategies to get information into memory. Some encoding is automatic, such as noticing where you ate lunch, and some is effortful and requires deliberate attention and strategies. The methods below are all effortful strategies that improve the chance that information gets into working memory and then into long-term memory.
Mnemonic devices
A mnemonic device is a memory aid, often a technique that connects new information to something already familiar, that helps encode information. Examples include:
Acronyms and acrostics: HOMES for the Great Lakes (Huron, Ontario, Michigan, Erie, Superior), or "My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nachos" for planets.
Rhymes and songs: "Thirty days hath September..." or the alphabet song.
The method of loci: imagining walking through a familiar place, such as your house, and "placing" each item to remember in a specific location along the route. To recall, you imagine walking the route again and seeing each item. The method of loci dates back to ancient Greece and Rome, and it is used by memory champions. It works because it uses vivid images and a familiar structure.
Mnemonics work by adding meaning, imagery, and organization to arbitrary information.
Chunking, categories, and hierarchies
Working memory can hold only a limited amount of information at one time. George Miller proposed in 1956 that the capacity was about seven items, plus or minus two ("the magical number seven"). Later research suggests that the true limit is smaller for unrelated items. But the limit is on the number of chunks, not on the raw amount of information. Chunking is grouping information together into meaningful units. A phone number 5-5-5-2-3-4-1-9-6-7 is ten digits to hold, but if you chunk it as 555-234-1967, it becomes three. Expert chess players chunk the positions of pieces into familiar patterns, and so remember far more of a real game position than novices do.
Organizing information into categories and hierarchies (broad categories that contain narrower ones) is another way to encode. A list of 20 random words is hard to recall, but the same words sorted into categories (animals, tools, foods) are much easier, because each category acts as a cue. A textbook chapter outlined in a hierarchy of topics and subtopics is easier to learn than one memorized sentence by sentence.
Study spotlight · Organization and recall (Bower and colleagues, 1969)
Gordon Bower and his colleagues had participants learn lists of words, with some participants seeing the words arranged in a conceptual hierarchy (for example, "minerals" divided into "metals" and "stones," and so on) and others seeing the same words in random positions. When they were later asked to recall the words, the group that saw the hierarchical arrangement remembered two to three times as many words as the group that saw random positions.
Reading the research: an experiment in which the independent variable was how the words were organized when presented and the dependent variable was the number recalled. Random assignment makes the groups comparable. The finding supports the claim that organization helps encoding, though the lists are simpler than the material students study in real courses.
The spacing effect
The spacing effect is the finding that information is encoded better and consolidated into long-term memory when study is spread out over time (distributed practice) than when it is concentrated into one session (massed practice, or cramming). Students who study 30 minutes a day for a week remember more, and remember it longer, than students who study the same total time in one night. The reason may be that each time you return to material after a delay, you retrieve and re-encode it, strengthening the memory, and that sleep between sessions consolidates it. Cramming can produce good short-term performance on tomorrow's test, but the learning fades quickly.
Study spotlight · Spacing and long-term retention (Bahrick and colleagues, 1993)
Harry Bahrick and his family studied foreign-language vocabulary. Participants learned a set of Spanish words and then reviewed them in sessions that were spaced either 14, 28, or 56 days apart, with the same number of sessions. When they were tested up to five years later, the participants who had spaced their sessions the farthest apart (56 days) remembered the most, even though the shorter intervals had looked better during training.
Reading the research: an experiment with the interval between sessions as the independent variable and later recall as the dependent variable. It was long-term, which is a strength, but the sample was very small (a few participants), so replications with more people are important for confidence.
The serial position effect
The order in which information is presented affects how well it is encoded and remembered. The serial position effect is the tendency to remember the items at the beginning and end of a list better than the items in the middle. The advantage for early items is the primacy effect: those items had more time to be rehearsed and move into long-term memory. The advantage for the last items is the recency effect: those items are still in working memory when recall is tested. A middle item has neither advantage. A graph of recall against position forms a U-shape (high, then low, then high again). If a delay or distraction is added after the list, the recency effect shrinks because the last items fade from working memory, but the primacy effect remains.
Position in list
Effect
Why
First few items
Primacy effect (well remembered)
More rehearsal; transferred to long-term memory
Middle items
Poorest recall
Less rehearsal, and interference from items before and after
Last few items
Recency effect (well remembered)
Still active in working memory
Worked example · Which strategy?
Name the strategy that is being used. (a) A student remembers the order of the colors of the rainbow with the name "Roy G. Biv." (b) A waiter groups the table numbers of orders into 5-table sections. (c) A student studies for 40 minutes on each of five days instead of studying 200 minutes the night before the test. (d) A speaker imagines walking from the front door of her house to the kitchen, attaching each of her main points to a piece of furniture along the way.
Step 1, (a) an acronym, a mnemonic device.
Step 2, (b) grouping into a few units is chunking (or organization into categories).
Step 3, (c) spreading study over time is distributed practice, which uses the spacing effect.
Step 4, (d) the method of loci.
Worked example · Predicting the serial position curve
A researcher reads a list of 20 unrelated words aloud, one every 2 seconds, and immediately asks participants to write down as many as they can. Which words will be recalled best, and what would change if participants had to count backward for 30 seconds before writing?
Step 1, without a delay, the first few words show the primacy effect (they were rehearsed and encoded into long-term memory) and the last few show the recency effect (they are still in working memory). The middle words are remembered worst.
Step 2, with 30 seconds of counting backward, rehearsal of the last words is blocked, and they leave working memory. The recency effect shrinks or disappears.
Step 3, the primacy effect remains, because the early items already reached long-term memory.
Worked example · Evaluating a claim about cramming
A student says, "Cramming works. I studied for 6 hours the night before and got an A on the test." Evaluate with the spacing effect, then describe a design that would test whether spacing is better.
Step 1, cramming (massed practice) can work for a test that comes immediately afterward, because the information is in working memory and short-term storage. One A does not show that it is the best method (a single case).
Step 2, the spacing effect says that distributed practice produces more durable learning, so the student may have forgotten much of the material a week later.
Step 3, a design: randomly assign students to study the same material for the same total time, either in one session or spread over several days, then test everyone both the next day and a month later. The independent variable is the schedule (massed or distributed). The dependent variable is the score. Predict that scores will be similar the next day but much higher a month later for the spaced group.
Exam focus
Effortful strategies: mnemonics (acronyms, rhymes, method of loci), chunking, categories and hierarchies.
Spacing effect: distributed practice beats massed practice (cramming) for lasting memory.
Serial position effect: primacy (first items) and recency (last items) are best remembered; the middle is worst. A delay erases recency, not primacy.
Practice
Explain how chunking helps working memory.
Show answer
Working memory has limited capacity for separate items, so grouping information into meaningful units (such as turning ten digits into three chunks) reduces the number of items to hold.
A student studies vocabulary words for one hour each day for five days. Another studies for five hours the day before the test. Which will likely remember more a month later and why?
Show answer
The first student, because of the spacing effect: distributed practice leads to better encoding and long-term retention than massed practice.
Describe the method of loci in your own words.
Show answer
You mentally place each item to be remembered at a specific location along a familiar route (such as through your house), and to recall them you imagine walking through the route and "seeing" each item.
On a list of 15 words, why is recall better for the first and last words than for those in the middle?
Show answer
The first words are rehearsed more and enter long-term memory (primacy); the last words remain in working memory (recency); the middle words get neither advantage.
Why does the Bower study support the use of outlines when studying?
Show answer
Participants who learned words arranged in an organized hierarchy recalled far more than those who saw random arrangements, so organizing information into categories and hierarchies improves encoding.
What would happen to the recency effect if a 30-second distraction followed the list, and why?
Show answer
It would shrink or vanish, because the distraction prevents rehearsal and the last items fade from working memory.
Once information is encoded, it has to be kept. Storage is the retention of encoded information over time. A good analogy is a set of containers that differ in how long they hold their contents and how much they can hold: some memories last a fraction of a second and others a lifetime. This lesson compares the memory stores by duration, capacity, and content, shows how rehearsal keeps information in storage, looks at people with extraordinary storage, and explores what happens when storage processes are damaged by injury, disease, or immaturity. The patient known as H.M. is one of the most important case studies in psychology, and you should know his story and its lessons.
Required content · 2.5.A
Learning objective.
2.5.A. Explain how memory storage processes retain information in memory.
Essential knowledge.
2.5.A.1. Sensory memory, short-term memory, working memory, and long-term memory are processes that differ in storage duration, capacity, and content.
2.5.A.2. Storage may be prolonged by rehearsing information over time (maintenance rehearsal). Rehearsing information over time in ways that promote meaning (elaborative rehearsal) helps with memory retention.
2.5.A.3. Some people demonstrate highly superior autobiographical memory which may indicate that there are biological processes for superior memory storage. Autobiographical memory may also explain why memories connected to our own lives or selves are more memorable.
2.5.A.4. Storage processes may be negatively affected by physical impairment and developmental limitations, such as amnesia (retrograde and anterograde), Alzheimer’s disease, and infantile amnesia. 1.A 2.C
The memory stores compared
The stores differ in storage duration, capacity, and content.
Store
Duration
Capacity
Content
Sensory memory
Iconic: about a fraction of a second; echoic: a few seconds
Large
Raw sensory input
Short-term memory
About 20 seconds without rehearsal
Small (about 7 plus or minus 2 items, or fewer chunks)
What you are currently aware of or have just heard
Working memory
Seconds, while you actively use it
Limited
The same information, but actively manipulated (reasoning, problem solving)
Long-term memory
Potentially a lifetime
Essentially unlimited
Facts, events, skills, and everything you have learned
Short-term memory and working memory are closely related. Short-term memory emphasizes the temporary storage of information, and working memory emphasizes the active processing of the information, as in the working memory model.
Rehearsal
Information can be kept in storage by rehearsing it over time. Maintenance rehearsal is simply repeating the information over and over, as when you repeat a phone number until you can write it down. It keeps information in short-term memory but does not work well for building long-term memory. Elaborative rehearsal links new information to existing knowledge and ideas, thinking about its meaning and connecting it to what you know. It leads to much better retention in long-term memory. If you want to remember that "the amygdala is involved in fear," thinking about a time you felt afraid and the almond shape of the structure is elaborative rehearsal, and repeating the sentence 20 times is maintenance rehearsal. (Notice the connection with the semantic level of the levels of processing model.)
Extraordinary storage
A few people have an extraordinary ability to remember their own lives. People with highly superior autobiographical memory (HSAM) can recall in great detail what they did, what the weather was, and what the news was on almost any date in their lives. The condition was first described in 2006 in a woman called "AJ" by researchers led by James McGaugh at the University of California, Irvine. People with HSAM do not necessarily have better memory for lists or facts, and they may be no better at ordinary school tasks than most people. Their brains differ in some regions that scans show, which suggests that there may be biological processes underlying superior memory storage.
HSAM also illustrates a general principle: autobiographical memory, memory for events connected to your own life or self, is generally more memorable than other information. You remember what relates to you much better than random facts, which is called the self-reference effect and links to elaborative rehearsal.
When storage is impaired
Storage can be damaged by physical impairment and by developmental limitations.
Amnesia is the loss of memory. In retrograde amnesia, a person loses memories of events before the injury or illness (the arrow points back in time). In anterograde amnesia, a person cannot form new memories after the injury (the arrow points forward in time). Amnesia can be caused by head injury, brain surgery, disease, or severe trauma. Often, both occur together.
Alzheimer's disease is a progressive brain disease, the most common cause of dementia, in which abnormal protein deposits damage neurons and the brain shrinks. Early symptoms include trouble with recent memories (a form of anterograde loss), with later symptoms of confusion, loss of language, and loss of remote memories. Levels of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine are reduced in the brain of a person with Alzheimer's.
Infantile amnesia is the inability of adults to remember events from before about age 3 or 4. The brain structures needed for explicit, episodic memory, and the language to organize memories, are still developing in early childhood, so those experiences are not stored in a form that can be retrieved.
Study spotlight · The case of H.M. (Scoville and Milner, 1957)
In 1953, to relieve severe epilepsy, a surgeon removed parts of the temporal lobes of a 27-year-old man, Henry Molaison, including most of his hippocampus on both sides. The seizures improved, but he could no longer form new explicit memories. He could carry on a conversation, but minutes later he would not remember that it had happened, and he did not recognize the doctors who saw him every day. His memories from before the operation were largely intact (although he lost memories for a few years before it), and his intelligence and his ability to hold things in mind briefly were normal. Brenda Milner showed that H.M. could still learn a new skill: in a mirror-drawing task, his accuracy improved over days, though each time he insisted that he had never seen the task before.
Reading the research: a famous case study (H.M. was identified after his death in 2008). It showed that the hippocampus is needed to form new explicit memories (anterograde amnesia), that explicit and implicit (procedural) memory are separate systems, and that long-term memories are not stored only in the hippocampus. Limits are that it is a single person, whose brain damage was larger than the hippocampus alone, and that ethical issues about consent and his long-term testing have been discussed.
Worked example · Retrograde or anterograde?
A man in a car accident can remember his childhood and his wedding but cannot remember the accident or the year before it. After the accident, he cannot recall new people he meets, even those he sees every day. Describe his condition.
Step 1, loss of memories from before the injury (the year before the accident) is retrograde amnesia.
Step 2, inability to form new memories after the injury (new people) is anterograde amnesia.
Step 3, he has both, which is common. His old memories (childhood, wedding) are preserved, so long-term storage as a whole is not destroyed, but the ability to transfer new experiences into long-term memory is damaged.
Worked example · Maintenance or elaborative rehearsal?
Two students must remember that the hippocampus is important for forming new explicit memories. Student A writes the sentence over and over 15 times. Student B thinks of H.M., imagines the seahorse shape of the structure, and connects it to the fact that she can remember what she ate for breakfast but not how to describe how to tie her shoes. Which is likely to remember better in a week, and why?
Step 1, Student A uses maintenance rehearsal: simple repetition that keeps information in short-term memory.
Step 2, Student B uses elaborative rehearsal: connecting the idea to meanings, images, and other knowledge, so it is processed deeply.
Step 3, Student B will probably remember better in a week, because elaboration encodes the information with many connections that serve as retrieval cues.
Worked example · Interpreting the H.M. case
What do the results with H.M. suggest about memory systems? Explain how each finding supports a conclusion.
Step 1, he could not form new explicit memories after the surgery. That suggests the hippocampus is needed for transferring new explicit memories into long-term storage.
Step 2, his old memories were mostly preserved. That suggests that long-term memories are stored elsewhere, in other parts of the brain, once formed.
Step 3, he improved at mirror drawing without remembering practicing. That suggests that procedural (implicit) memory uses different brain systems from explicit memory, since it did not need the hippocampus.
Step 4, a limit of the case study method: results from one person with damage to several structures should be confirmed with other patients and other methods.
Exam focus
Stores differ in duration, capacity, and content: sensory (very brief, large), short-term (about 20 seconds, small), working (active), long-term (very long, unlimited).
HSAM shows biological differences in storage; self-related information is remembered better.
Retrograde amnesia (loss of old memories) versus anterograde (no new memories); Alzheimer's disease; infantile amnesia.
Practice
Compare the capacity and duration of short-term and long-term memory.
Show answer
Short-term memory holds a small amount (about 7 plus or minus 2 items) for about 20 seconds without rehearsal; long-term memory has essentially unlimited capacity and can last a lifetime.
Why does elaborative rehearsal help more than maintenance rehearsal for exam preparation?
Show answer
Elaborative rehearsal connects new information to meaning and existing knowledge, creating a deeper encoding with more retrieval cues, whereas repetition keeps it in short-term memory but does little to build long-term memory.
A person suffers a head injury and cannot form new memories but remembers everything before the injury. Which type of amnesia?
Show answer
Anterograde amnesia.
What did H.M.'s ability to improve at mirror drawing show?
Show answer
That procedural (implicit) memory is separate from explicit memory and does not depend on the hippocampus: he learned the skill without remembering the practice.
Why can't most adults remember events from their first two years?
Show answer
Infantile amnesia: the brain structures and language ability needed to store explicit, episodic memories in an organized way are still developing in early childhood.
Why might a person with highly superior autobiographical memory not be better at memorizing a list of random words?
Show answer
Their ability is specific to their own life experiences, which are linked to the self and have personal meaning, and does not extend to all kinds of memory.
Retrieval is the last stage of memory: getting information out of storage. It is also where most of the effort in an exam goes, since knowing something and being able to get it out when it is needed are different things. This lesson explains the two basic kinds of retrieval, why where you are and how you feel affect what you can remember, and the single most useful discovery for students in memory research: the act of retrieving a memory strengthens it. It also introduces metacognition, thinking about your own thinking, which is how you tell whether you really know something.
Required content · 2.6.A
Learning objective.
2.6.A. Explain how memory retrieval processes get information out of memory.
Essential knowledge.
2.6.A.1. The process of memory retrieval occurs through recall (remembering without cues) or recognition (which relies on retrieval cues).
2.6.A.2. The process of memory retrieval can be enhanced when people are in the same environmental space (context-dependent memory), mood (mood-congruent memory), or physical state (state-dependent memory) as they were when they encoded the information to be retrieved.
2.6.A.3. Successful retrieval is more likely when using retrieval practice processes, including testing effect and metacognition. 1.B 3.A 3.C
Recall and recognition
There are two basic ways to retrieve.
Recall is retrieving information without cues, from your own memory: a fill-in-the-blank or essay question, or naming the capital of Australia. It is the harder kind of retrieval.
Recognition is identifying information from a set of options when you see or hear it, which relies on retrieval cues supplied to you: a multiple-choice question or picking a suspect out of a lineup. Because the answer is in front of you, recognition is generally easier than recall. You can recognize many things you could not recall.
A retrieval cue is any stimulus that helps trigger a memory. The strength of memory often depends on the match between the cues present when information is encoded and those present when it is retrieved.
Context, mood, and state
Memory is better when conditions at retrieval match conditions at encoding. Three kinds of match are required.
Context-dependent memory: retrieval is easier when you are in the same environmental space as when you encoded. Returning to your elementary school may bring back memories you had not thought of in years.
Mood-congruent memory: the tendency to recall experiences that are consistent with your current mood. When you are sad, you recall sad memories more easily, and when you are happy, you recall happy events.
State-dependent memory: retrieval is easier when your physical or internal state (such as being tired, or under the influence of a drug such as caffeine) matches your state when you learned the information.
Study spotlight · Memory underwater (Godden and Baddeley, 1975)
Duncan Godden and Alan Baddeley asked scuba divers to learn a list of words either on land or underwater, and then to recall the list either in the same place or in the other one. The divers recalled more words when they were tested in the same environment where they learned them (land-land or water-water) than when the environments were different. The effect was strong: words learned and recalled in matching settings were remembered noticeably better.
Reading the research: an experiment in which divers were randomly assigned to conditions, with the learning environment and the recall environment as independent variables and the number of words recalled as the dependent variable. It provided evidence for context-dependent memory in a natural setting. Divers are not typical participants, though, and the words were arbitrary lists rather than the material students study.
The practical lessons for students are mixed. Matching conditions can help, so studying in a quiet room similar to the testing room may be better than studying in a noisy café. But the better lesson is to vary the contexts in which you study, so that your memory does not depend on one setting. You cannot control the state or mood you will be in during an exam.
Retrieval practice and the testing effect
The most reliable way to improve memory is to practice retrieving it. Retrieval practice is the act of testing yourself by trying to recall information from memory instead of rereading it. The testing effect is the finding that being tested on material produces better long-term retention than spending the same time studying it again. Each successful retrieval strengthens the memory and makes it easier to retrieve the next time. Retrieval also reveals what you do not know.
Study spotlight · The testing effect (Roediger and Karpicke, 2006)
Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke had students study short prose passages. One condition read the passage four times in a row (repeated study). Another read it once and then took three free-recall tests (repeated testing), where the students wrote down everything they could remember without looking. On a test given five minutes later, the repeated-study group did better. But on a test one week later the results flipped: the students who had been tested recalled about 61 percent of the material, compared with about 40 percent for the students who had only restudied.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment and a delayed test as the dependent measure, which is a strength. It also shows how easily students are misled. The restudying group felt more confident because the material seemed familiar, but it did not remember as well. A limitation is that participants were college students and the material was short passages.
Metacognition
Metacognition is thinking about your own thinking: how well you understand something, how well you will remember it, and which strategy to use. Good learners monitor their learning and adjust. A common error is mistaking familiarity for knowledge: after reading a chapter several times it looks familiar, which feels like learning, but recognizing familiar text is not the same as being able to recall it. Testing yourself gives an honest measure, and it counteracts the overconfidence that many students show about how well they have learned. Metacognition works together with retrieval practice: use self-testing to find your weak spots, then restudy those and test again.
Worked example · Recall or recognition?
Which kind of retrieval is each? (a) Answering "Name the three components of working memory." (b) Choosing the right answer from four options on a multiple-choice question. (c) Picking out the burglar from a lineup of six people. (d) Writing an essay on the stages of sleep.
Step 1, (a) no cues are given: recall.
Step 2, (b) the options provide cues: recognition.
Step 3, (c) identification from the lineup: recognition.
Step 4, (d) generating from memory with no cues: recall.
Step 5, because recognition is easier, students who prepare only by recognizing (rereading and highlighting) often do worse on recall-based tests than they expect.
Worked example · Which kind of match?
Identify the kind of memory effect. (a) Ana can recall a childhood friend's name only when she walks back into her old classroom. (b) After a fight with her best friend, Dee keeps remembering other times people let her down. (c) A student who studied while very tired and drinking coffee does better on the test when she again drinks coffee.
Step 1, (a) a physical place: context-dependent memory.
Step 2, (b) memories matching her emotion: mood-congruent memory.
Step 3, (c) matching internal states, such as the effect of a drug: state-dependent memory.
Worked example · Designing a study plan from the research
A student has one week to prepare for a big exam on Unit 2. Use research from this lesson and the last to design a study plan.
Step 1, spacing: study a little each day, for example one topic per day with a cumulative review, instead of one long session at the end.
Step 2, retrieval practice: after each reading, close the book and write down everything you remember, answer practice questions, or make flashcards, instead of rereading.
Step 3, metacognition: use the self-test results to find which topics you cannot recall, and give them more time.
Step 4, context and state: study in more than one place, and sleep well before the test (which also helps consolidate memory).
Step 5, the plan is supported by evidence from experiments such as Roediger and Karpicke's, which showed that tested students remembered more after a week.
Exam focus
Recall (no cues) is harder than recognition (cues provided).
Retrieval practice and the testing effect: self-testing beats rereading for long-term memory.
Metacognition: monitoring your own learning; familiarity is not knowledge.
Practice
Why is a multiple-choice test generally easier than a short-answer test?
Show answer
A multiple-choice test uses recognition, with the correct answer present as a cue, while short-answer questions require recall without cues.
A student learns a list of facts while listening to jazz and does better on the test if jazz is playing. Which type of effect?
Show answer
Context-dependent memory (or state-dependent, if it is the effect of mood or a physical state); here the environmental cue (music) matches.
What did the Roediger and Karpicke study show about studying by rereading versus self-testing?
Show answer
Students who tested themselves remembered more after one week (about 61% versus 40%) than those who restudied, even though restudying seemed more effective right away.
Explain mood-congruent memory with an example.
Show answer
People recall experiences that match their current mood, such as remembering unhappy events more easily when feeling sad.
Why is "I read the chapter three times, so I know it" a metacognitive error?
Show answer
Rereading makes material feel familiar, which can be mistaken for knowledge, but familiarity (recognition) does not guarantee recall. A self-test would measure what is actually known.
Describe how the Godden and Baddeley study supports context-dependent memory.
Show answer
Divers remembered more words when the place where they recalled matched the place where they learned (land or underwater) than when the two differed.
Forgetting is not simply a failure. A mind that remembered everything would be cluttered with details it never needs again, and memory researchers consider forgetting an essential part of a working memory system. But forgetting also causes real problems, and memory can go wrong in a second way that is more troubling: sometimes people remember things that did not happen, with complete confidence. This lesson covers why information is lost, the explanations offered for failures of memory, and the ways that memories are changed, reconstructed, and sometimes invented. These topics matter in everyday life, especially in eyewitness testimony.
Required content · 2.7.A
Learning objective.
2.7.A. Explain possible reasons why memory failure or errors may occur.
Essential knowledge.
2.7.A.1. The forgetting curve shows that time is a significant factor in forgetting. Forgetting occurs rapidly after initial learning and levels off over time.
2.7.A.2. Many memories are difficult to retrieve due to encoding failure, interference (proactive or retroactive), or inadequate retrieval (i.e., tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon).
2.7.A.3. Psychodynamic theorists believe that information or memories can be forgotten to defend the ego from distress (repression).
2.7.A.4. The accuracy of memories may be affected by the misinformation effect, source amnesia, or constructive memory (via memory consolidation and imagination inflation). 1.A 2.B 4.A
The forgetting curve
The first scientific study of memory was done by the German psychologist Hermann Ebbinghaus in the 1880s. He made lists of nonsense syllables (such as "ZOF" and "KEB") so that prior knowledge could not help, memorized them, and measured how much effort it took to relearn them after different delays. His results gave the forgetting curve, which shows that time is a significant factor in forgetting: forgetting is rapid after initial learning and then levels off over time.
Figure 2.3. The forgetting curve from Ebbinghaus's savings data (approximate values). Most forgetting happens soon after learning, and the loss then slows down.
The numbers show the pattern. Ebbinghaus found that after 20 minutes about 58% of the original learning was retained, after an hour about 44%, after a day about 34%, after six days about 25%, and after a month about 21%. The steepest loss comes in the first hour, and little more is lost after that. The practical message is to review soon after learning, before most of the loss has occurred, and then at spaced intervals.
Study spotlight · Ebbinghaus's memory experiments (1885)
Hermann Ebbinghaus was his own subject. He memorized lists of nonsense syllables until he could recite them perfectly, then, after a delay, relearned each list. He measured the savings: the time or number of repetitions saved in relearning compared with learning from scratch. The more savings, the more had been retained. By testing different delays, he drew the forgetting curve.
Reading the research: a controlled experiment with a single participant, using a very precise measure, which was a strength. The sample of one (Ebbinghaus himself, who knew what he was testing), and the use of meaningless syllables, which are unlike real-life memories, are limitations. The basic curve has been replicated many times with different participants and materials.
Why do we forget?
Many memories are difficult to retrieve for one of several reasons.
Encoding failure. The information never got into long-term memory in the first place, because it was not attended to or encoded. Most people cannot draw the front of a penny correctly, not because they forgot it, but because they never encoded the details.
Interference. Other information gets in the way of retrieval. In proactive interference, old information interferes with the learning or recall of new information (the arrow points forward): your old phone number keeps coming to mind when you try to recall the new one. In retroactive interference, new information interferes with the recall of old information (the arrow points back): after learning Spanish vocabulary, you find it hard to recall the French words you learned last year.
Inadequate retrieval. The information is still in storage, but you cannot find the cue to get to it. The tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon is the feeling that a word is on the verge of coming to mind but cannot quite be retrieved; you may know the first letter or number of syllables. The information is there, but the retrieval failed, and the right cue often makes it come back.
Psychodynamic theorists propose a different reason: repression, the motivated forgetting of painful memories to defend the ego from distress (Unit 4 discusses defense mechanisms). It is a theory from Freud's tradition, and evidence that people routinely repress and then accurately recover traumatic memories is weak. Research suggests that traumatic events are usually remembered, often too well.
The errors of memory
Memory is not a recording. When you recall an event, you reconstruct it from stored fragments, general knowledge, and expectations, and that reconstruction can be altered. This is constructive memory: memories are rebuilt during retrieval, so they can change over time. The exam names three ways that accuracy suffers.
The misinformation effect is the distortion of a memory by misleading information received after the event. Eyewitnesses who are asked leading questions may recall details that were not there.
Source amnesia (source misattribution) is remembering information but forgetting where it came from. You might "remember" a fact and credit it to a teacher when you really read it in a tabloid, or recall a dream as an event. Familiar claims feel true even if they come from an unreliable source.
Imagination inflation is the finding that imagining an event can make people more confident that it really happened. Imagining or repeatedly talking about an event can create a memory of something that never occurred. (Memory consolidation, in which memories are reorganized after the fact, also contributes to errors.)
Study spotlight · Loftus and Palmer's leading questions (1974)
Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer showed students films of traffic accidents and then asked them to estimate how fast the cars were going. The question varied only in the verb: "About how fast were the cars going when they smashed into each other?" or "...when they contacted each other?" The estimates differed with the verb: the average estimate was 40.8 miles per hour for "smashed" and 31.8 for "contacted." In a second experiment, a week later, the students were asked whether they had seen any broken glass (there was none). About 32 percent of those who had heard "smashed" said yes, compared with about 14 percent of those who had heard "hit."
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to the verb condition (the independent variable), which makes the conclusion about the effect of wording strong. It shows how the misinformation effect and constructive memory can distort recall, which is why police and courts should avoid leading questions. A limitation is that the participants watched filmed accidents, which are less emotional than real ones.
Worked example · Which explanation?
Identify the reason for forgetting. (a) After getting a new locker combination, Tia keeps entering the old one. (b) A student studies for French after Spanish and cannot recall the Spanish words she learned a week ago. (c) Marco is sure he knows the name of the actor, can picture the face and remembers it starts with a K, but cannot say it. (d) A person cannot say which way the head faces on a penny despite seeing pennies thousands of times.
Step 1, (a) old information interfering with new: proactive interference.
Step 2, (b) new information (French) interfering with old (Spanish): retroactive interference.
Step 3, (c) the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon: inadequate retrieval of information that is in storage.
Step 4, (d) the detail was never encoded: encoding failure.
Worked example · Reading the forgetting curve
Using Ebbinghaus's values (100% at learning, about 58% after 20 minutes, 44% after 1 hour, 34% after 1 day, 25% after 6 days, 21% after 31 days), how much of the original learning is lost between 20 minutes and 1 hour, and between 6 days and 31 days? What does it show?
Step 1, from 20 minutes to 1 hour: \(58-44=14\) percentage points lost in 40 minutes.
Step 2, from 6 days to 31 days: \(25-21=4\) percentage points lost in 25 days.
Step 3, in the first hour, 56 points were lost (from 100 to 44), but over the next month only 23 more (from 44 to 21).
Step 4, the curve is steep at first and then flattens, which shows that forgetting is rapid soon after learning and levels off, so review soon after learning.
Worked example · Evaluating eyewitness testimony
A witness to a robbery is asked by a police officer, "Was the man with the gun wearing a red hat?" The man had no hat. Weeks later the witness testifies that the robber wore a red hat. Explain and suggest improvements.
Step 1, the officer's question included a false detail (a hat), so the witness absorbed misinformation, and that changed her memory: the misinformation effect.
Step 2, because memory is constructive, the witness rebuilt the memory with the hat included, and may even recall the hat vividly.
Step 3, she might also have source amnesia, forgetting that the idea of the hat came from the officer rather than from the robbery.
Step 4, improvements: use open-ended, non-leading questions ("What was the man wearing?"), interview witnesses early, and do not give feedback or suggest details.
Exam focus
Forgetting curve (Ebbinghaus): steep loss soon after learning, then it levels off. Review early.
Causes: encoding failure, interference (proactive: old blocks new; retroactive: new blocks old), inadequate retrieval (tip-of-the-tongue); repression (psychodynamic; weak evidence).
Describe the shape of the forgetting curve and what it implies for studying.
Show answer
Memory loss is rapid right after learning and then levels off. Therefore review shortly after learning, before most forgetting has happened.
Distinguish proactive from retroactive interference with an example of each.
Show answer
Proactive: old information interferes with new (your old password keeps coming to mind). Retroactive: new information interferes with old (after learning a new password you cannot recall the old one).
What is the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon, and what does it suggest about the cause?
Show answer
The feeling that you know something but cannot retrieve it, often with partial information. It suggests the memory is stored but retrieval failed.
In Loftus and Palmer's study, why did students who heard "smashed" estimate higher speeds?
Show answer
The leading word changed the way they reconstructed the memory of the event: it suggested a more violent crash, an example of the misinformation effect.
A person is confident that he heard a news story from a friend, but it was from a satire website. Name the memory error.
Show answer
Source amnesia (misattributing the source of the information).
Why is the evidence for repression described as weak?
Show answer
Research suggests that traumatic events are generally remembered, often vividly, and there is little scientific evidence that people routinely forget and then accurately recover them. Memories recovered by suggestive methods can also be false.
What is intelligence, and can it be measured with a number? These questions have one of the most contested histories in psychology. People have used intelligence tests to help students who needed support, and also to label people and exclude them. Both parts of the history are on the AP Exam. This lesson covers how psychologists have defined intelligence, how it came to be measured, and what makes any psychological test trustworthy. The next lesson takes up the social issues the tests raise and the related topic of academic achievement.
Required content · 2.8.A, 2.8.B
Learning objectives.
2.8.A. Explain how modern and historical theories describe intelligence.
2.8.B. Explain how intelligence is measured.
Essential knowledge.
2.8.A.1. Throughout history, consensus about how to define and measure intelligence continues to be elusive and can be subject to bias. Researchers debate whether intelligence is a general ability (called g) or is comprised of multiple abilities.
2.8.B.1. Early formal intelligence tests yielded an intelligence quotient (IQ), which divided mental age by chronological age. In modern times, IQ scores are often used to identify students for educational services. Exclusion Statement: Labeling or describing cognitive abilities and disabilities are outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
2.8.B.2. All psychological assessments, including intelligence tests, should adhere to sound psychometric principles to be considered useful.
2.8.B.2.i. A test is said to be standardized when it is administered using consistent procedures and environments.
2.8.B.2.ii. A test is considered valid if it measures what it is designed to measure. Types of validity include construct and predictive.
2.8.B.2.iii. A test is considered reliable if it yields similar results each time it is administered. Types of reliability include test-retest and split-half. 1.B 2.D 4.B
2.8.B.3. Researchers strive to develop assessments of intelligence that are socio-culturally responsive to reduce stereotype threat and potential inequity that may occur due to stereotype lift.
Defining intelligence
Throughout history, there has been no consensus on how to define and measure intelligence, and definitions can be shaped by the values and biases of the people who write them. In general, intelligence is the ability to learn from experience, solve problems, and use knowledge to adapt to new situations. The central debate is whether intelligence is a single general ability or several separate abilities.
General intelligence (g). Charles Spearman noticed in 1904 that students who did well in one school subject tended to do well in others, so scores on different mental tests are positively correlated. Using a statistical technique called factor analysis, he proposed that a single underlying general ability, which he called g, contributes to performance on every mental task, along with specific abilities for particular tasks.
Multiple abilities. Other theorists argue that intelligence is made up of several distinct abilities. Howard Gardner proposed multiple intelligences: linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalist. He argued that standard tests capture only some of these, and that someone can be extraordinary in one and ordinary in another. Robert Sternberg proposed the triarchic theory, which includes analytical intelligence (problem solving of the kind on tests), creative intelligence (generating new ideas), and practical intelligence ("street smarts," adapting to everyday demands). Critics of multiple-ability theories point out that the abilities are often correlated with one another and that some of Gardner's categories look more like talents than intelligences.
The research debate is still open: g has strong statistical support, but it does not capture everything people mean when they call someone smart.
Study spotlight · Spearman and the positive manifold (1904)
Charles Spearman gave students tests in different school subjects (such as classics, French, English, and mathematics) and a test of sensory discrimination, and computed the correlations between every pair. Nearly all correlations were positive: students who scored high on one tended to score high on the others. He explained the pattern by proposing a single general factor, g, plus factors specific to each test.
Reading the research: a correlational study, so it could not prove that g is a single cause. The sample was a group of schoolchildren in England in the early twentieth century, and the statistical methods were primitive by today's standards. Later researchers have used larger samples and better methods to confirm the positive correlations, but they continue to disagree about whether to interpret them as one general ability.
The history of measurement: from mental age to IQ
In 1905 the French psychologist Alfred Binet and his colleague Théodore Simon developed the first practical intelligence test to identify children who needed extra help in school. Binet insisted that the test should be used to help children, not to label them. The test gave each child a mental age, the age level of the questions the child could answer correctly. A child who answered as well as the typical 8-year-old had a mental age of 8.
The German psychologist William Stern suggested comparing mental age with actual age. Lewis Terman at Stanford revised Binet's test as the Stanford-Binet and used the formula called the intelligence quotient (IQ):
A child with a mental age of 10 and a chronological age of 8 has an IQ of \(10\div8\times100=125\), and a child with a mental age of 6 and a chronological age of 8 has an IQ of \(6\div8\times100=75\). A child whose mental age equals chronological age has an IQ of exactly 100. The formula breaks down for adults (a 40-year-old's mental age does not keep increasing). Modern tests such as the Wechsler scales (the WAIS for adults and the WISC for children) therefore report scores by comparing a person to others of the same age, so that the average is set at 100 and the standard deviation at 15, in a distribution close to the normal curve (Lesson 1.3). In modern times IQ scores are often used to identify students for educational services, such as gifted programs and special education.
You do not need to learn the labels used to describe or classify cognitive abilities and disabilities; those are outside the scope of the exam.
What makes a test good: psychometric principles
All psychological assessments, including intelligence tests, should follow sound psychometric principles to be considered useful. There are three.
A test is standardized if it is administered using consistent procedures and environments, and if scores are interpreted by comparison with a large, representative group of test takers who took it under the same conditions, called the norm group. Standardization lets you say what a given score means.
A test is valid if it measures what it is designed to measure. There are two types you need to know. Construct validity is the extent to which a test measures the concept (the construct) it is supposed to, such as whether a test of "intelligence" really reflects reasoning and not just vocabulary or test-taking skill. Predictive validity is the extent to which the test predicts a future outcome that it should predict, such as how well a college admissions test predicts college grades.
A test is reliable if it yields similar results each time it is administered. Test-retest reliability compares scores from the same people who take the test twice. Split-half reliability compares scores on two halves of the same test (for example, odd and even items) taken by the same people. High correlations show high reliability.
Reliability and validity are different. A test can be reliable without being valid: a ruler that is 2 inches short measures consistently but wrongly. But a test cannot be valid unless it is reliable.
Worked example · Calculating a ratio IQ
Marcus is 9 years and 0 months old and takes a test with a result of a mental age of 12. His sister Lena is 10 and has a mental age of 8. Calculate each IQ.
Step 1, Marcus: \(12\div9\times100=133.3\), about 133.
Step 2, Lena: \(8\div10\times100=80\).
Step 3, interpret: Marcus is performing above his age level and Lena below. Notice that the ratio method works only for children, which is why modern tests compare scores to the norm for people of the same age.
Step 4, on a modern scale with a mean of 100 and an SD of 15, a score of 133 is about 2.2 SD above the mean, which is roughly the 98th to 99th percentile. A score of 80 is about 1.3 SD below the mean, roughly the 9th percentile.
Worked example · Reliability or validity?
A new "creativity" test gives nearly the same score to the same students when they take it two weeks apart (correlation \(r=+0.92\)), but scores on the test do not correlate with creative achievements such as winning art contests or inventing things (\(r=+0.05\)). Evaluate the test.
Step 1, the high correlation across two administrations shows high test-retest reliability: the test gives consistent results.
Step 2, the near-zero correlation with creative achievement means it has poor predictive validity, and it may not measure the construct of creativity at all (poor construct validity).
Step 3, conclusion: the test is reliable but not valid, so it is not useful as a measure of creativity. This shows that reliability alone is not enough.
Worked example · Matching theories
Match each description to a theory. (a) A student has a high score on tests of vocabulary, math, and spatial reasoning, and attributes this to one underlying general ability. (b) A person with average test scores is a gifted musician and a leader. (c) A researcher distinguishes between a person's test-taking skills, creativity, and everyday "street smarts."
Step 1, (a) is Spearman's general intelligence (g).
Step 2, (b) fits Gardner's multiple intelligences (musical and interpersonal).
Step 3, (c) is Sternberg's triarchic theory (analytical, creative, practical).
Exam focus
Debate: general intelligence (g) (Spearman) versus multiple abilities (Gardner's multiple intelligences; Sternberg's triarchic theory: analytical, creative, practical).
Mental age, ratio IQ = mental age / chronological age \(\times\) 100; modern tests use mean 100, SD 15. Binet's purpose was to help children.
Good tests are standardized, valid (construct, predictive) and reliable (test-retest, split-half). Reliable does not mean valid.
Practice
What is the IQ of a 5-year-old with a mental age of 7?
Show answer
\(7\div5\times100=140\).
How did Binet intend his test to be used, and why is that important in the history of intelligence testing?
Show answer
He designed it to identify children who needed extra help in school, not to label children or rank them. Later uses of IQ tests to label and exclude groups went against that purpose.
What is the difference between predictive validity and construct validity?
Show answer
Construct validity: the test measures the concept it claims to (such as intelligence). Predictive validity: the test accurately predicts a future outcome (such as grades).
A test gives a person a score of 110 on Monday and 85 on Friday, with no change in the person. What is the problem?
Show answer
Low reliability: the test does not give consistent results.
Which theorist argued for several intelligences, such as musical and bodily-kinesthetic?
Show answer
Howard Gardner (multiple intelligences).
Why was the ratio IQ formula replaced by comparing a person to others of the same age?
Show answer
The formula does not work for adults because mental age does not continue to rise with chronological age; the norm-referenced approach (mean 100, SD 15) works at every age.
Intelligence tests are not just scientific tools; they are used to make decisions that change people's lives, such as who is placed in advanced classes, who is admitted to a school, and in the past who was allowed to enter the country. For that reason psychologists spend a great deal of effort on the question of whether tests are fair and how their results are interpreted. This lesson looks at the evidence on how intelligence scores change over time, how they differ within and between groups, how tests have been misused, and how to design assessments that are fair. It ends with the difference between intelligence and achievement and the role that a person's beliefs about intelligence play in school success. The exam asks you to reason about evidence and policy on these topics, so be ready to support claims with research.
Required content · 2.8.B, 2.8.C, 2.8.D
Learning objectives.
2.8.B. Explain how intelligence is measured.
2.8.C. Explain how systemic issues relate to the quantitative and qualitative uses of intelligence assessments.
2.8.D. Explain how academic achievement is measured and experienced as compared to intelligence.
Essential knowledge.
2.8.B.3. Researchers strive to develop assessments of intelligence that are socio-culturally responsive to reduce stereotype threat and potential inequity that may occur due to stereotype lift.
2.8.C.1. IQ scores across much of the world have generally increased over time (Flynn Effect) due to societal factors, such as higher socioeconomic status and access to better health care and better nutrition.
2.8.C.2. IQ scores tend to vary more within a group than between groups. Personal and sociocultural biases can impact the interpretation of individual IQ scores and the score’s relationship with other outcomes. Poverty, discrimination, and educational inequities can negatively influence intelligence scores of individuals and societal groups around the world.
2.8.C.3. Scores from intelligence tests have been used to limit access to jobs, military ranks, educational institutions, and immigration to the US.
2.8.D.1. Some academic tests attempt to measure what someone knows (achievement tests) or predict how someone will perform in the future (aptitude tests).
2.8.D.2. People’s beliefs about whether intelligence is fixed from birth (fixed mindset) or malleable due to experience (growth mindset) can affect academic achievement. 65
The Flynn effect
Average IQ scores have risen over time in many parts of the world, by about three points per decade over much of the twentieth century. This is the Flynn effect, named for the researcher James Flynn, who documented it. The rise is too fast to be due to genes changing, so it must be due to environmental and societal factors: better nutrition and health care, more schooling, higher socioeconomic status, smaller families, and a world that increasingly demands abstract thinking. As a result, tests must be re-normed periodically, because a score of 100 refers to the average of the group that took the test when it was standardized.
Variation within and between groups
Intelligence scores vary widely among individuals. One of the main findings is that IQ scores vary much more within any group than between groups. When two groups are compared, the difference in their averages is small compared with the differences among the individuals in each group, so the distributions overlap greatly. Knowing someone's group tells you very little about that person's score.
Differences in group averages do not tell you the cause. Personal and sociocultural biases can affect the interpretation of an individual's IQ score and its relationship to other outcomes. Poverty, discrimination, and educational inequities can lower the measured intelligence scores of individuals and societal groups around the world, through influences like poor nutrition, exposure to toxins, stress, disrupted schooling, and fewer opportunities to learn the content tested. Test content and format can also favor people from the culture that wrote the test (a test item about regattas will be harder for someone who has never encountered the word).
Stereotype threat and stereotype lift
Stereotype threat is the anxiety that a person may confirm a negative stereotype about their group, which can lower their performance. Stereotype lift is the performance boost that can occur when a person is a member of a group that is not negatively stereotyped on a task and is reminded of this, such as when a negative stereotype is applied to another group.
Study spotlight · Steele and Aronson's stereotype threat (1995)
Claude Steele and Joshua Aronson gave Black and white Stanford undergraduates a difficult verbal test made up of items from the Graduate Record Examination. In one condition, the students were told that the test was a diagnostic measure of intellectual ability, which brought to mind the negative stereotype about Black students' academic performance. In another condition, they were told that it was a laboratory problem-solving exercise that was not diagnostic of ability. When the test was described as diagnostic, Black participants scored lower than white participants who had been matched on prior test scores. In the nondiagnostic condition, the gap closed.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to the description of the test (the independent variable) and the test score as the dependent variable. It suggests that the way a test is framed and the setting can affect scores, independent of ability. The sample was small and was made up of students at an elite university, so the extent to which the effect generalizes has been debated, and later studies have found that its size varies across settings.
Researchers therefore try to develop assessments of intelligence that are socio-culturally responsive, meaning that they are designed and administered with attention to the cultural backgrounds of the test takers: using content that does not depend on knowledge specific to one culture, giving clear instructions, and avoiding conditions that trigger stereotype threat. The goal is to reduce stereotype threat and inequity (which can also result from stereotype lift) and to measure ability more accurately.
The misuse of intelligence tests
The history shows that scores have sometimes been used to limit access to jobs, military ranks, educational institutions, and immigration to the United States. During World War I the U.S. Army gave the Army Alpha and Army Beta tests to more than a million recruits, and the scores were used to assign people to ranks and roles. Henry Goddard administered tests to arriving immigrants at Ellis Island, and he judged large numbers of them "feebleminded," although many of the questions required knowledge of English and of American customs. Results from such tests were cited in support of the Immigration Act of 1924, which sharply limited immigration from southern and eastern Europe. These uses relied on tests that did not account for language, education, and culture, so they were invalid for the purposes that were claimed, and they illustrate how scientific tools can be applied in discriminatory ways.
Intelligence versus achievement
Not every test measures intelligence. Achievement tests measure what a person has learned (such as a final exam or an AP Exam), and aptitude tests try to predict how a person will perform in the future (such as a test for admission to college or a training program). The two overlap, since what you have learned affects how well you are predicted to do. The distinction is in the purpose: measuring what has been learned, or predicting what will be learned.
Mindset and achievement
A person's beliefs about intelligence affect achievement. Carol Dweck and colleagues distinguished two mindsets. People with a fixed mindset believe that intelligence is fixed from birth and cannot be changed much, so struggling means they are "not smart" and effort is a sign of low ability. People with a growth mindset believe that intelligence is malleable and grows through experience, effort, and good strategies, so challenges and mistakes are chances to learn. A growth mindset is associated with greater persistence and higher achievement.
Study spotlight · Teaching a growth mindset (Blackwell, Trzesniewski, and Dweck, 2007)
Researchers followed several hundred seventh-graders in a New York City school as they made the transition into a harder program. Students who held a growth mindset showed better grades in mathematics over two years than students with a fixed mindset, even when they began with the same level of achievement. In a follow-up experiment, students were randomly assigned to eight sessions of either a study skills workshop alone or a workshop that also taught them that the brain grows with effort and learning. The mindset students then showed improved motivation and reversed the decline in math grades that the control group continued to show.
Reading the research: the first part is correlational and the second part is an experiment with random assignment, which supports a causal conclusion about the intervention. The samples were limited to one school district and one age group, and later large-scale studies have found that the effects of mindset interventions are smaller and vary across settings.
Worked example · Evaluating a claim about group differences
A pamphlet says, "Group A scores 6 points higher on average on an IQ test than Group B, so any person in Group A is smarter than any person in Group B." Evaluate the claim.
Step 1, the claim is about individuals, but the data are about group averages. IQ scores vary much more within groups than between them, so the distributions overlap greatly and many people in Group B score higher than many in Group A.
Step 2, a difference in averages does not show why the difference exists. Differences in nutrition, school quality, poverty, discrimination, and test content can affect scores, so they cannot be assumed to reflect inborn differences.
Step 3, conclusion: the claim is not supported. The evidence supports only a statement that the averages differed on that test.
Worked example · Predict the result of a stereotype threat study
In a study, two groups of equally skilled female students take a challenging math test. Group 1 is told, "Women often perform worse on this test than men." Group 2 is told, "This test shows no gender differences." Predict the results, and explain.
Step 1, the first instruction activates a negative stereotype, which may create stereotype threat, anxiety about confirming it, which uses up working memory and attention. Predict a lower mean score for Group 1.
Step 2, in Group 2 there is no stereotype to fear, so predict a higher mean score.
Step 3, because the students are randomly assigned to the two instructions, any difference can be attributed to the instruction, and not to ability.
Step 4, implication: a socio-culturally responsive way of giving tests avoids cues that trigger the threat.
Worked example · Achievement or aptitude?
Classify each test. (a) A final exam in chemistry. (b) A test designed to predict how well a person will do in flight training. (c) The AP Psychology Exam. (d) A college entrance test that is used to predict first-year college grades.
Step 1, (a) measures what has been learned: an achievement test.
Step 2, (b) predicts future performance: an aptitude test.
Step 3, (c) an achievement test.
Step 4, (d) predicting a future outcome: an aptitude test, whose predictive validity is the correlation with later grades.
Exam focus
Flynn effect: average IQ scores have risen about three points per decade, so environmental factors matter. Tests must be re-normed.
IQ varies more within groups than between groups. Poverty, discrimination, and educational inequity can lower scores; tests can be culturally biased.
Stereotype threat lowers performance; stereotype lift raises it. Socio-culturally responsive assessments reduce these effects. Tests have been misused to limit jobs, military roles, education, and immigration.
Achievement tests measure what was learned; aptitude tests predict future performance. Fixed versus growth mindset.
Practice
What is the Flynn effect and what does it show about the causes of intelligence scores?
Show answer
Average IQ scores have risen over time (about 3 points per decade). The rise is too fast to be genetic, so it shows that environmental factors such as nutrition, health care, and education affect scores.
A researcher finds that two groups differ by 5 points on average, but individual scores in each group range from 70 to 130. What can be concluded about the usefulness of group membership in predicting an individual's score?
Show answer
Very little: scores vary far more within each group than between them, so the distributions overlap and group membership is a poor predictor of an individual's score.
Describe stereotype threat and how Steele and Aronson tested it.
Show answer
Stereotype threat is anxiety about confirming a negative stereotype, which can reduce performance. They gave the same test to students described either as diagnostic of ability or not; Black students scored lower when it was called diagnostic, but not when it was nondiagnostic.
Give one historical example of how intelligence test scores were used to limit access.
Show answer
Examples include tests given to immigrants at Ellis Island and test results cited in support of the 1924 Immigration Act, and Army tests used to assign roles in World War I.
How is an achievement test different from an aptitude test?
Show answer
An achievement test measures what has been learned; an aptitude test predicts how someone will perform in the future.
Rewrite this fixed-mindset thought as a growth-mindset thought: "I'm just not a math person."
Show answer
"I haven't learned this yet. If I use different strategies and keep practicing, I can improve."
Unit 2 review · 10 multiple-choice
Unit 2 review: Cognition
Ten questions in the three styles the exam uses (concept application, data analysis, and scientific investigation) one drawn from each lesson in the unit; click an option to see why that choice is right or wrong.
Multiple choice
During a chemistry demonstration Priya is counting how many times the instructor stirs a beaker. She does not notice a classmate walk slowly across the front of the room holding a large yellow sign. Which of the following best explains what happened?
Change blindness needs two views with something altered between them: a photograph that differs after a flicker, a person swapped during an interruption. Nothing here changed; an object was present the whole time and simply never registered.
Sensory adaptation happens at the receptor level and requires constant, unchanging stimulation, like the smell of a room you have been sitting in for an hour. A classmate walking past is novel and moving, and Priya's retina responded to him normally.
This is the finding behind the gorilla-in-the-video study: a demanding counting task consumes attention, and an unexpected object in plain view goes unreported. Her eyes worked; the bottleneck was attention, which is why "she wasn't paying attention" names the outcome rather than the mechanism.
A perceptual set biases how an ambiguous stimulus is interpreted, as when you read a smudged letter as the one you expected. Priya did not misread the sign: she never saw it at all.
Theo cancels a beach vacation after a week of news coverage of a shark attack, then drives eight hours to the mountains instead without a second thought, even though the drive carries the far higher risk of injury. Which of the following best explains his judgment?
Shark attacks are rare and highway crashes are common, but coverage reverses how easily each comes to mind. The availability heuristic substitutes "how quickly can I recall an example" for "how often does this actually happen," and a week of coverage is what loaded his memory.
Representativeness judges probability by resemblance to a stereotype: deciding someone is a librarian because he is quiet and tidy. Theo is not matching the beach to a category; he is over-weighting one event he can picture vividly.
Confirmation bias would mean he already feared sharks and then went looking for stories that supported it. In the stem the coverage arrives first and the fear follows, which is availability rather than a biased search.
Anchoring requires a specific number to anchor on: a listed price, a first offer, an initial estimate that later judgments drift toward. No figure appears anywhere in the stem.
A pharmacist hears a 12-character prescription code read aloud once and, without writing it down, types it correctly ten seconds later. On the way to the keyboard she has recoded it as a four-digit year, a three-letter drug abbreviation she uses daily, and a five-digit lot number. Which of the following best explains her success?
Iconic memory is a visual store that fades in well under a second, and she heard the code rather than seeing it. Even echoic memory, its auditory equivalent, lasts only a few seconds and could not carry her to the keyboard.
Deep semantic processing builds durable long-term memories, which is not what happened here: ask her an hour later and the code will be gone. Recoding something for immediate use is not the same as encoding it for storage.
Capacity limits are remarkably stable across people; experts do not get extra slots, they pack more into each slot. Assuming she has unusual capacity skips the mechanism the stem hands you.
Chunking changes what counts as an item. Three familiar units sit well inside the roughly seven-item limit, and the phonological loop rehearses them for the few seconds she needs. This is why experienced people look like they remember more within their own field.
Data: described bar graph. Participants answered one question about each of 60 words (about the word's appearance, its sound, or its meaning), and then took an unexpected recognition test.
The vertical axis is the percentage of words later recognized, running from 0 to 80%, and there are three bars. The bar for appearance questions ("Is the word printed in capital letters?") reaches 18%. The bar for sound questions ("Does the word rhyme with train?") reaches 39%. The bar for meaning questions ("Does the word fit in this sentence?") reaches 63%. A note beneath the graph gives the mean time taken to answer each type of question: 0.6 seconds for appearance, 0.8 seconds for sound, and 1.1 seconds for meaning.
Which statement is best supported by the data as presented?
The answer times point the other way. Meaning questions took nearly twice as long as appearance questions, so processing time varies right alongside depth instead of being held constant, which is what a confound looks like.
Both halves of this statement come straight off the display: 63 divided by 18 is about 3.5, and the note shows the deepest condition also consumed the most time. Naming the finding and then the alternative explanation it cannot exclude is exactly what a data-analysis item rewards.
Repetition is held constant here: every word was presented once and only the question about it differed. A variable that does not vary cannot explain a difference in the results.
Using the same words for every participant controls for word difficulty, which is a real strength, but it does nothing about the timing difference the note reports. Controlling one variable is not controlling all of them.
A man who developed anterograde amnesia after damage to both hippocampi is taught to use an unfamiliar espresso machine. Across five daily sessions his time to produce a cup falls steadily from four minutes to under one. Asked each day whether he has used the machine before, he says he has never seen it. Which of the following best accounts for this pattern?
Retrograde amnesia erases memories formed before an injury, and these sessions happen after it. His difficulty is with the new, which is precisely what anterograde amnesia means.
Working memory holds information for seconds, not across a night's sleep. Nothing held in working memory could survive from one daily session to the next, so it cannot explain a five-day improvement.
This dissociation is the classic finding from the patient known as H.M.: medial temporal damage blocks new explicit memories while procedural learning, supported by the cerebellum and basal ganglia, proceeds normally. He knows how without knowing that.
Sensory adaptation is a decline in receptor response to constant stimulation; it does not make anyone faster at a sequence of actions. A steady gain across five sessions is learning, not a change in sensitivity.
Described study
Researchers tested 32 members of a university diving club. Each diver learned one list of 36 unrelated words while standing on a beach, and a second, equivalent list while submerged about fifteen feet underwater in scuba gear. Each diver was then tested for free recall twice: once in the setting where that list had been learned and once in the other setting. The order of lists and settings was counterbalanced across divers. Recall was substantially higher when the learning and testing settings matched than when they did not.
Every diver completed all four learning-and-testing combinations. What does this feature of the design accomplish?
This is a repeated-measures, or within-subjects, design. The comparison happens inside each person, so stable differences in memory ability, diving experience, and motivation are held constant instead of being left to chance.
The match between learning and testing setting was manipulated by the researchers, and every diver met every combination, which makes this an experiment. Repeated measures is a way of assigning conditions, not a retreat from manipulating them.
Generalization depends on who the participants are and how large the manipulation is, not on how conditions were assigned. A beach and open water differ far more than a dorm room and a classroom, so the everyday version of this effect is much smaller.
Recall still has to be operationalized: here as the number of words from a 36-word list produced without cues. Measuring the same people repeatedly changes what the comparison controls, not whether the measure needs defining.
Described study
Researchers showed 90 adults at a driving school the same 30-second video of a collision between a car and a bicycle. Participants who attended the morning sessions were asked how fast the car was going when it smashed into the bicycle; those who attended the afternoon sessions were asked how fast it was going when it hit the bicycle. Everything else about the questionnaire was identical. Mean speed estimates were 41 mph in the morning group and 34 mph in the afternoon group. The researchers concluded that the verb changed the estimates.
Which of the following is the most serious threat to that conclusion?
A speed estimate is a serviceable operational definition: a number, produced under stated conditions, that another researcher could collect the same way. The weakness here is not the measure but what produced the difference between the groups.
Random assignment is what makes two groups equivalent before a manipulation. Assigning by session time lets a whole bundle of differences (alertness, driving experience, who is free in the morning) ride along with the verb, so the 7 mph gap has more than one candidate explanation.
This is a genuine limitation on generalizing to real witnesses, and it would affect the absolute level of both groups' estimates. But it applies equally to everyone, so it cannot account for the difference between the groups.
A neutral-verb condition would make the finding richer by showing which direction the shift runs from. It would not repair a comparison in which the groups were formed by when people happened to show up.
Naomi is a strong mathematics student. Just before a difficult placement test, the proctor remarks that the test is designed to measure whether students like her can handle advanced coursework. Naomi spends much of the period worrying about how her score will be read and finishes fewer items than usual. Which concept best explains her performance?
Test bias is a property of a test's predictive accuracy across groups, established with data on how scores forecast later outcomes. Nothing in the stem concerns prediction; what changed was Naomi's state in the room.
The Flynn effect is the long-run rise in raw test scores across generations, a fact about norms over decades. It has no bearing on one student's performance on one afternoon.
A self-fulfilling prophecy runs through someone else's expectations changing their behavior toward the person: different teaching, different grading, fewer opportunities. The proctor scored nothing differently here; the effect ran through Naomi's own attention.
Stereotype threat is the term the exam wants for this pattern: making a negative stereotype relevant adds a monitoring load, and working memory spent on worry is unavailable for the problems. The prediction is specific: the effect shows up on difficult items and disappears when the framing is removed.
Data: summary statistics for the same 100-point final project in two sections of one course, each with 28 students.
Statistic
Section A
Section B
Mean
78
78
Median
78
85
Standard deviation
4
14
Lowest score
70
31
Highest score
86
96
Which statement is best supported by the table?
When the mean sits below the median, the tail runs to the left: the extreme scores are low ones, and they drag the mean down while barely moving the middle value. A low score of 31 and a standard deviation of 14 are what produce that gap, and the median is the defensible summary.
Positive skew means a long right tail, with the mean above the median. Section B shows the opposite ordering, mean 78 and median 85, and a wide range by itself tells you nothing about which direction the tail runs.
Spread measures how alike the scores are, not how much anyone learned. Section B's median is seven points higher than Section A's, so the section with the tighter distribution is not the higher-scoring one.
Equal means do not imply equally useful means. In Section A one standard deviation puts roughly two-thirds of students between 74 and 82; in Section B the same band runs from 64 to 92, which describes almost nobody.
Data: correlations between four self-reported study habits and final exam score, from a survey of 180 students in one course. No variable was manipulated.
Variable
Correlation with final exam score
Hours per week spent self-testing
+0.41
Hours per week spent rereading notes
+0.06
Hours of sleep the night before the exam
+0.22
Hours per week at a part-time job
−0.35
Which statement is best supported by these data?
An r of +0.06 is essentially no linear relationship, and its sign is positive in any case. Reading a near-zero coefficient as a negative relationship confuses a weak association with a reversed one.
Strength is distance from zero, so +0.41 is the largest of the four, just ahead of −0.35. The second clause is the part the exam is really testing: in a survey with no manipulation, students who self-test more may also be the students who attend more, sleep more, or care more.
Direction and strength are separate readings. The sign says which way the relationship runs; the distance from zero says how strong it is, and 0.35 is larger than 0.22, so the job variable is the stronger of the two.
This is a causal claim drawn from correlational data, with a prescription stacked on top of it. Work hours may stand in for financial pressure, commuting time, or lost sleep, and cutting the hours would not remove those.
Developmental psychology studies how people change, and how they stay the same, from conception through old age. It asks old questions in a scientific way: are we shaped mostly by our genes or by our experiences? Do we change smoothly or in jumps? Is the child the parent of the adult, or does a person become new at each stage? This lesson introduces the three enduring themes that organize the field, then covers the two research designs that psychologists use to study change over time, which are among the most frequently tested research methods in the course. The rest of the unit (physical, cognitive, language, and social-emotional development, and then learning) draws on these ideas.
Required content · 3.1.A, 3.1.B
Learning objectives.
3.1.A. Explain how enduring themes inform developmental psychology.
3.1.B. Describe ways cross-sectional and longitudinal research design methods used in developmental psychology inform understanding about behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.1.A.1. Developmental psychology is concerned with both chronological order of development and/or thematic issues in development across the lifespan. Thematic issues of interest to developmental psychologists include stability and change, nature and nurture, and continuous and discontinuous stages of development.
Two ways to organize the study of development
Developmental psychology is concerned with both the chronological order of development, the typical sequence of changes by age (infancy, childhood, adolescence, adulthood), and thematic issues, questions that cut across all ages. Textbooks and the exam use both approaches. In this unit we move through ages for physical, cognitive, and social development, while the three themes below come up in every section.
Three enduring themes
Stability and change. Which of our characteristics stay the same throughout life, and which change? A shy child may become a shy adult (stability), or may become outgoing (change). Psychologists find some of each: temperament shows moderate stability, while skills, knowledge, and interests change a lot.
Nature and nurture. How do heredity and the environment contribute to development? As Unit 1 explained, they interact. A child's genes influence how the environment affects her, and the environment influences how her genes show up.
Continuous and discontinuous development. Is development a gradual, smooth process of adding more of the same (continuous, like a tree growing taller), or does it proceed through distinct stages with qualitative shifts (discontinuous, like a caterpillar becoming a butterfly)? Stage theories, such as Piaget's and Erikson's in the next lessons, assume discontinuity: each stage is different in kind, and everyone goes through the stages in the same order. Critics argue that many changes are more gradual than stage theories claim.
Studying change: cross-sectional and longitudinal designs
How can you study how people change with age? Two research designs, both non-experimental (you cannot randomly assign people to ages), are the standard tools.
A cross-sectional study compares people of different ages at one time. A researcher who wants to know how memory changes with age might test groups of 20-year-olds, 40-year-olds, and 60-year-olds on the same day. It is fast, relatively inexpensive, and gives answers quickly. Its main weakness is the cohort effect: people of different ages differ in more than age. They were born in different years, grew up in different historical periods, and had different educational and cultural experiences. If the 60-year-olds do worse on a computer memory test, it may be because they had less experience with computers, not because of aging.
A longitudinal study follows the same people over a long period, retesting them at intervals. A researcher might test a group of 20-year-olds now, again at 40, and again at 60. Because each person is compared with himself or herself, longitudinal designs avoid the cohort problem and can show actual change within individuals. But the weaknesses are practical and serious: it takes years or decades, it is expensive, and participants drop out (attrition), which may leave a sample of the healthier, more motivated people who stay, biasing the results. Repeated testing can also give participants practice.
Feature
Cross-sectional
Longitudinal
Who is studied
Different people of different ages, at one time
The same people, repeatedly over time
Time needed
Short
Long (years or decades)
Cost
Lower
Higher
Main weakness
Cohort effects (groups differ in more than age)
Attrition, cost, practice effects
Shows change within individuals?
No
Yes
Study spotlight · The marshmallow test and its follow-ups (Mischel, 1972; Shoda, Mischel, and Peake, 1990; Watts, Duncan, and Quan, 2018)
In the original experiments, Walter Mischel and colleagues placed preschool children at a university nursery school in a room with one marshmallow (or a similar treat) and told them that if they waited until the researcher came back, they could have two. The time that each child waited before eating the treat was recorded. Years later, in a longitudinal follow-up, children who had waited longer were rated by their parents as more competent and had higher scores on college-entrance tests as adolescents. The finding became famous as evidence that self-control early in life predicts later success.
A later replication by Tyler Watts and colleagues used a much larger and more diverse sample of children and found that the association was about half as large, and after the researchers controlled for family background, early cognitive ability, and the home environment, it shrank to near zero in many analyses.
Reading the research: the original is a longitudinal, correlational study of a small sample, mostly children of Stanford faculty, so it has limited generalizability and cannot show cause, since a third variable such as family background could explain both waiting and later outcomes. The replication shows how a larger, more representative sample and statistical controls can change the conclusion, and why replication matters.
Worked example · Choosing a design
A researcher wants to know whether vocabulary grows steadily or in bursts between ages 2 and 6. (a) Describe a cross-sectional design. (b) Describe a longitudinal design. (c) Which would better answer the question, and what is a drawback of each?
Step 1, (a) a cross-sectional design: test different groups of 2-, 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-year-olds on the same vocabulary measure this month, and compare group averages.
Step 2, (b) a longitudinal design: test one group of 2-year-olds, then test the same children again at 3, 4, 5, and 6.
Step 3, (c) the longitudinal design better shows how each child changes, including individual bursts. Its drawbacks: it takes four years, and some families will drop out (attrition). The cross-sectional design is fast but cannot show individual change, and the groups differ in more than age (for example, different families or preschool programs: the cohort effect).
Worked example · Evaluate a conclusion
A cross-sectional study compares the average scores on a spatial reasoning test of people aged 25, 45, and 65 and finds that scores are lower in older groups. The researchers conclude, "Spatial reasoning declines with age." Evaluate.
Step 1, the design is cross-sectional, so it compares different people.
Step 2, the cohort effect: the groups differ in education, early experience with video games and technology, nutrition, and health. These differences, not aging, might explain the gap.
Step 3, a longitudinal study that tests the same people over 40 years would give stronger evidence of change with age, though attrition could leave out the people whose abilities declined most.
Step 4, a defensible conclusion: "Older groups scored lower on this test; this suggests, but does not prove, that spatial reasoning declines with age."
Worked example · Applying the themes
Identify the theme in each statement. (a) "Some kids are shy from birth and stay shy as adults." (b) "A baby cannot think symbolically, but a 3-year-old can; thinking changes in kind." (c) "Her musical talent comes from her genes, but she developed it because her parents paid for lessons." (d) "A child's vocabulary grows a few words at a time."
Step 1, (a) stability (of temperament).
Step 2, (b) discontinuous development (qualitative change, as in stage theories).
Step 3, (c) nature and nurture interacting.
Step 4, (d) continuous development (gradual addition).
Exam focus
Three themes: stability and change, nature and nurture, continuous and discontinuous (stage) development.
Cross-sectional: different ages at one time (fast; cohort effects). Longitudinal: same people over time (shows individual change; slow, costly, attrition).
Both are non-experimental designs, so neither can show cause and effect.
Practice
Explain the cohort effect and which research design it threatens.
Show answer
Cohort effect: people of different ages also differ in when they were born and so in historical and cultural experiences. It threatens cross-sectional studies, where age groups are compared at one time.
What is attrition and why is it a problem in longitudinal research?
Show answer
Attrition is participants dropping out over time. It can leave a biased sample (such as the healthiest or most committed participants), which may distort the results.
Is a stage theory of development continuous or discontinuous? Explain.
Show answer
Discontinuous: it claims that development occurs in distinct stages that differ qualitatively from each other.
A study follows 200 children from age 5 to age 25 and measures their reading each year. What kind of design is it, and what is a major strength?
Show answer
A longitudinal design. A strength is that it shows how each person changes, without cohort differences.
Why can't cross-sectional or longitudinal designs prove that age causes a change?
Show answer
Neither design randomly assigns participants to ages or manipulates any variable, so other factors (cohort, history, experience) might explain differences.
Why was the replication of the marshmallow test important?
Show answer
It used a larger, more diverse sample and controlled for family background, finding a much smaller effect. It shows that the original finding may have been partly due to a third variable and a narrow sample.
The body changes more across a lifetime than any other part of a person: from a single cell to a newborn who cannot hold up her own head, to a toddler who runs, to an adolescent whose body is transformed by puberty, to an older adult whose body slows. These changes matter to psychology because physical development makes possible what people can do and learn, and in turn the experiences people have affect the development of the brain and body. This lesson follows physical development in order: before birth, infancy and childhood, adolescence, and adulthood. Look for the research method behind each fact, because the exam often asks you to analyze a study of infants or children.
Required content · 3.2.A, 3.2.B, 3.2.C, 3.2.D
Learning objectives.
3.2.A. Explain how physical development before birth applies to behavior and mental processes.
3.2.B. Explain how physical development in infancy and childhood apply to behavior and mental processes.
3.2.C. Explain how physical development in adolescence applies to behavior and mental processes.
3.2.D. Explain how physical development in adulthood applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.2.A.1. Teratogens, maternal illness, genetic mutations, hormonal, and environmental factors can influence the major physical and psychological milestones that occur during prenatal development. Exclusion Statement: The stages of prenatal development (zygote, embryo, and fetus) are outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
3.2.B.1. Physical development in infancy and childhood happens in generally the same order, but the timing of the development can vary. The development of fine and gross motor coordination is among the major physical and psychological milestones that define infancy and childhood. These physical skills develop as children mature, allowing children to develop critical skills needed to become more independent.
3.2.B.2. Infants possess reflexes, like the rooting reflex, that indicate on-track physical and psychological milestone development.
3.2.B.3. Research using the visual cliff apparatus demonstrates an early ability in infants to perceive depth and an innovative way to assess infant responses. 1.A 3.C 4.A
3.2.B.4. Research suggests that critical or sensitive periods in infancy and childhood have strong developmental effects, especially for skills such as language. Some non-human animals will imprint on the first object they encounter as a means of survival.
3.2.C.1. The main physical and psychological milestones that occur in adolescence are the adolescent growth spurt and puberty, in which reproductive ability develops. Adolescents develop primary and secondary sex characteristics during this time, such as menarche and spermarche.
3.2.D.1. Adulthood spans most of the lifespan and is characterized by a general leveling off and then a varying decline in reproductive ability (i.e., menopause), mobility, flexibility, reaction time, and visual and auditory sensory acuity. 76
Before birth
The environment inside the mother's body is a child's first environment, and it can help or harm development. Teratogens are agents such as chemicals and viruses that can cross the placenta and harm the developing embryo or fetus. The best-known teratogen is alcohol: heavy drinking during pregnancy can cause fetal alcohol syndrome, which involves physical abnormalities and lasting problems with learning, attention, and behavior. Other teratogens include tobacco, certain drugs, and certain medications. Maternal illness, such as rubella (German measles) early in pregnancy, can also cause serious harm. In addition, genetic mutations, hormonal influences, and other environmental factors (such as malnutrition and extreme stress) can affect the major physical and psychological milestones of prenatal development. You do not need to know the stages of prenatal development (zygote, embryo, fetus) for the AP Exam.
Infancy and childhood
Newborns are born with reflexes, automatic responses that are important for survival and that are signs of healthy neurological development. The rooting reflex (turning the head toward a touch on the cheek and opening the mouth) helps the baby find the breast or bottle. Others include sucking, grasping a finger placed in the palm, and the startle (Moro) reflex. These reflexes are present at birth and gradually disappear as the cerebral cortex takes control of movement. Absence of an expected reflex, or its persistence beyond the usual age, can indicate a problem.
Motor development, the growth of control over movement, follows a general sequence that is similar for all children, though the timing varies from child to child and across cultures. Gross motor skills use large muscles (holding the head up, sitting, crawling, standing, walking, running), and fine motor skills use small muscles (grasping, picking up small objects, drawing, buttoning). A typical sequence is rolling over, sitting without support, crawling, pulling up to stand, and walking, but "typical" covers a wide range: most babies walk on their own somewhere between about 9 and 17 months. These skills develop through maturation, the biological growth processes that follow a genetic timetable, together with experience and practice. As children gain physical skills they gain independence, and this affects their psychological and social development.
Study spotlight · The visual cliff (Gibson and Walk, 1960)
Eleanor Gibson and Richard Walk placed infants (aged 6 to 14 months) on a thick glass-topped table with a checkerboard pattern. On one side the pattern was directly under the glass (the "shallow" side); on the other, the pattern was several feet below the glass, so it looked like a drop-off (the "cliff"). The mother called the infant to cross from the other side of the apparatus. Nine of the 36 infants would not leave the center board at all. Of the 27 who did, 24 crawled to the shallow side and only 3 crawled over the deep side. Most infants refused to crawl over the apparent drop even though the glass was solid and their mothers were encouraging them.
Reading the research: a controlled experiment in which the independent variable was the side (shallow or deep) and the dependent variable was whether the infant crossed. It showed that infants who can crawl can perceive depth, and it created a clever way to learn what infants perceive, since babies cannot tell us. A limitation is that infants who have been crawling for some time may have learned about heights from experience, so it does not prove the ability is innate. Later research found that infants' heart rates changed over the deep side even before they could crawl.
Critical and sensitive periods
Some kinds of development depend on experience during a particular window of time. A critical (or sensitive) period is a time in development when an organism is especially responsive to certain experiences, and the absence of those experiences can cause lasting problems. Language is the standard example for humans. Children who are not exposed to language in the first years of life have great difficulty learning it fully later (Lesson 3.5). In some animals, the critical period is shorter and strict. Imprinting is the rapid learning, during a critical period, of an attachment to the first moving object seen. Konrad Lorenz showed that goslings hatched in an incubator followed him, the first moving thing they saw, as though he were their mother. Imprinting has survival value, because it keeps the young animal close to its mother.
Adolescence
Adolescence begins with puberty, the period of sexual maturation, when the person becomes capable of reproduction. Two main physical changes are the adolescent growth spurt, a rapid increase in height and weight, and the development of sexual characteristics. Primary sex characteristics are the body structures that make sexual reproduction possible (the ovaries and uterus, the testes and penis). Secondary sex characteristics are nonreproductive sexual traits, such as breast development, a deeper voice, and facial and body hair. Menarche is a girl's first menstrual period, and spermarche is a boy's first ejaculation. Puberty begins at different ages for different young people, and starting earlier or later than peers can affect how adolescents feel about themselves.
Adulthood
Adulthood covers most of the lifespan. Physical abilities generally peak in early adulthood and then show a leveling off followed by a decline that varies from person to person. Changes include the decline of reproductive ability (for women, menopause, the end of menstrual cycles, typically around the early 50s; for men, a gradual decline in fertility), reduced mobility and flexibility, slower reaction time, and reduced visual and auditory acuity (sharpness). Lifestyle matters a great deal: regular physical activity, a healthy diet, and mental and social engagement can slow many of these changes. Despite these changes, many older adults remain healthy, active, and satisfied with life.
Worked example · Interpret the visual cliff data
In a replication of the visual cliff, 30 infants are placed at the center, and 25 crawl to the shallow side, 2 to the deep side, and 3 do not move. Calculate the percent who crossed each side among those who moved, and interpret.
Step 1, those who moved: \(25+2=27\) infants.
Step 2, shallow side: \(25\div27\approx0.926\), about 93%.
Step 3, deep side: \(2\div27\approx0.074\), about 7%.
Step 4, interpretation: the infants strongly preferred the shallow side, which suggests that they could perceive the depth and avoided the drop. The experiment has no way to say how much of the avoidance was learned, since the infants had been crawling for some time.
Worked example · Which developmental concept?
Identify the concept. (a) A newborn turns her head and opens her mouth when touched on the cheek. (b) A gosling follows the first moving object it sees after hatching. (c) A 13-year-old grows 3 inches in a year. (d) A mother drinks heavily during pregnancy and her child has learning problems.
Step 1, (a) the rooting reflex, a newborn reflex that helps with feeding.
Step 2, (b) imprinting during a critical period.
Step 3, (c) the adolescent growth spurt, associated with puberty.
Step 4, (d) a teratogen (alcohol) causing fetal alcohol syndrome.
Worked example · Make a defensible claim
A summary of research reports that infants of mothers who smoked during pregnancy had lower birth weights on average (3,100 g) than infants of mothers who did not smoke (3,400 g). A friend says, "I smoked and my baby was fine, so the study is wrong." Write a claim and evaluate the friend's argument.
Step 1, claim: "Smoking during pregnancy is associated with lower birth weight, which is a risk for development." (Because this is a comparison of groups of mothers, probably non-experimental, the claim must be careful about cause.)
Step 2, evidence: the groups' averages differ by \(3{,}400-3{,}100=300\) grams.
Step 3, the friend's argument uses one case, but the finding is about group averages and risk, so one healthy baby does not refute it.
Step 4, because mothers cannot be randomly assigned to smoke, a third variable (such as stress or poverty) could contribute; but the biology of teratogens makes the causal explanation plausible.
Exam focus
Teratogens (alcohol, viruses, drugs) and maternal illness affect prenatal development. The stages of prenatal development are not tested.
Newborn reflexes (rooting) show healthy development. Gross and fine motor skills develop in a similar order with varied timing. The visual cliff shows infants perceive depth.
Critical or sensitive periods (language) and imprinting (Lorenz).
Puberty: growth spurt, primary and secondary sex characteristics, menarche, spermarche. Adulthood: menopause, slower reaction time, reduced mobility, flexibility, vision, hearing.
Practice
Give two examples of teratogens and an effect of one.
Show answer
Alcohol (can cause fetal alcohol syndrome) and tobacco or certain viruses such as rubella, which can cause birth defects and developmental problems.
What is the rooting reflex, and why is it useful?
Show answer
The newborn turns toward a touch on the cheek and opens the mouth, which helps the baby find food.
Why can the visual cliff be used with infants who cannot speak?
Show answer
It uses a behavior (crawling or not crawling across the deep side) as the measure, so researchers can infer what infants perceive without words.
Distinguish primary from secondary sex characteristics.
Show answer
Primary: the body structures directly involved in reproduction (such as ovaries and testes). Secondary: nonreproductive sexual traits that appear at puberty (such as breast development, voice change, body hair).
What is a critical or sensitive period, and what is the human example given in this unit?
Show answer
A time in development when experiences have especially strong effects. Language learning is the example: children not exposed to language early struggle to learn it fully later.
List three physical changes common in later adulthood.
Show answer
Menopause or reduced fertility, slower reaction time, reduced mobility and flexibility, and declines in vision and hearing.
Sex, gender, and sexual orientation in development
Some of the most personal parts of a person's identity, whether they think of themselves as a girl, a boy, or neither, how they express that, and whom they are attracted to, are also topics of psychological research. This is a topic where evidence matters a great deal, and where popular beliefs, stereotypes, and politics are often loud. The exam asks one thing: that you can describe how sex and gender influence socialization and other aspects of development. This lesson gives you the vocabulary, the research on how children learn gender, what the evidence says about sexual orientation, and a famous case that taught researchers lessons about both science and ethics. As in the rest of the course, the goal is to describe what research shows, with care about how far each finding can be generalized.
Required content · 3.3.A
Learning objective.
3.3.A. Describe how sex and gender influence socialization and other aspects of development.
Key terms
Sex refers to biological characteristics that are used to classify people as male or female at birth: chromosomes, hormones, and reproductive anatomy. Some people are born with variations in these characteristics.
Gender refers to the social and cultural meanings attached to being male or female: the roles, behaviors, and expectations that a society associates with each.
Gender identity is a person's internal sense of being a girl or woman, a boy or man, both, or neither. It may or may not match the sex assigned at birth. Most people's gender identity matches their sex assigned at birth, and some people's does not (for example, transgender people).
Gender roles are the behaviors and expectations that a culture assigns to each gender. Gender typing is the process by which a child acquires the traits and behaviors considered appropriate for one's gender.
Sexual orientation is a person's enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, and sexual attraction (for example, to the other gender, the same gender, or more than one). It is distinct from gender identity.
How children learn gender: socialization
Socialization is the process by which individuals learn the norms, values, and behaviors of their culture. Children begin learning gender early, from many sources.
Parents and family may treat boys and girls differently from birth, through clothing, toys, the rooms they decorate, the chores they assign, and the way they talk about emotions.
Peers reinforce gender-typical play and often sort themselves by gender.
Schools, media, and culture supply images of what boys and girls "should" do. Books, television, and advertising often show stereotyped roles.
Several theories explain how this works. Social learning theory (Lesson 3.11) says children learn gender-appropriate behavior by observing and imitating models, and by being reinforced for matching their gender roles. Gender schema theory says that children actively build mental frameworks (schemas) about gender and then use them to organize and interpret their experience, so they pay attention to what matches the schema.
The extent of gender differences is smaller than stereotypes suggest. For most psychological traits, such as intelligence, the differences between averages for men and women are small compared with the variation among individuals within each gender, and the distributions overlap a great deal. Many differences that do appear in behavior have been found to vary across cultures and over time, which shows the influence of socialization. Gender roles also differ among cultures: tasks and traits that are considered feminine in one society may be considered masculine in another.
Study spotlight · Parents' perceptions of newborns (Rubin, Provenzano, and Luria, 1974)
The researchers asked parents of newborns, within 24 hours of the birth, to describe their babies. The infants (the sons and daughters) were similar in length, weight, and Apgar scores (a health rating at birth). Yet the parents described daughters as smaller, softer, more finely featured, and less attentive, and described sons as firmer, larger-featured, better coordinated, and more alert.
Reading the research: a non-experimental study, since the infants' sex cannot be assigned. It shows that adults' stereotypes may shape what they see even when the infants objectively do not differ, and so may shape the way parents later treat boys and girls. A limitation is that the sample consisted of the parents at a single hospital in the 1970s, and gender expectations have changed since then.
Sexual orientation
Research on sexual orientation has been summarized by major scientific and professional organizations, including the American Psychological Association. Key points are:
Sexual orientation exists along a continuum, and most people report that it is a stable part of who they are.
It is not considered a mental disorder. The APA removed homosexuality from its list of mental disorders in 1973.
Evidence suggests that sexual orientation arises from a complex interaction of biological factors (genetic and hormonal influences, including during prenatal development) and environmental factors. It is not caused by parenting style or a "choice." Twin and family studies show a moderate genetic influence, but it is not entirely genetic, since identical twins are not always alike in orientation.
Efforts to change a person's sexual orientation through therapy (sometimes called conversion therapy) have not been shown to work, and they can cause harm, including depression and anxiety. Major professional organizations oppose them.
Notice that gender identity and sexual orientation are different. A person's gender identity says nothing about whom they are attracted to.
Study spotlight · The case of David Reimer (Money, 1970s; Diamond and Sigmundson, 1997)
In 1965, a baby boy named Bruce Reimer lost his penis in a botched circumcision. His parents consulted the psychologist John Money, who argued that gender identity is mostly learned and that a child could be raised successfully as either a boy or a girl if raised that way from an early age. The baby had surgery, was renamed Brenda, and was raised as a girl. Money reported the case as a success. In reality, Brenda was unhappy and rejected the girl's role throughout childhood. At age 14, learning the truth, the child switched to living as a male and took the name David. Later reports by Milton Diamond and Keith Sigmundson, in 1997, brought the case to the public. David Reimer died by suicide in 2004.
Reading the research: a case study, and a cautionary one. It seemed to be a natural experiment on nature and nurture, but there was only one case, with a reporter who had a stake in the conclusion, and the evidence did not support his theory; it suggested that biological factors also shape gender identity. It is also an ethics lesson: the child and parents were not adequately informed, the child was harmed, and the outcome was misreported. Review boards, informed consent, and honest reporting are now required for this reason.
Worked example · Sex, gender, or orientation?
Identify the term. (a) A person's chromosomes and reproductive anatomy. (b) A society's expectation that women will be the main caregivers of children. (c) A person feels deeply that they are a man, although they were identified as female at birth. (d) A woman is romantically attracted to other women.
Step 1, (a) sex (biological characteristics).
Step 2, (b) a gender role.
Step 3, (c) gender identity.
Step 4, (d) sexual orientation.
Step 5, notice that (c) and (d) are different dimensions: the first is about who one is, and the second is about whom one is attracted to.
Worked example · Evaluate a claim about gender differences
A headline reads, "Boys are better at math than girls." The article reports a study in which the mean math score for boys was 51 and for girls was 50 on a test with an SD of 10 within each gender. Evaluate.
Step 1, the difference between the group means is only 1 point, and the SD is 10, so the effect size is about \(1\div10=0.1\), which is below the 0.2 that counts as small.
Step 2, scores vary much more within each gender than between them (SD of 10 versus a gap of 1), so the two distributions overlap almost completely. A particular girl is about as likely as a particular boy to be better at math.
Step 3, the gap is also tied to socialization: expectations and encouragement differ across cultures and over time, and the gap changes with them.
Step 4, a defensible conclusion: the study shows a very small difference in average scores, and does not support the headline.
Worked example · Applying the theories to a scenario
A 4-year-old boy sees his mother and father cooking, and when his friend says "boys don't cook," he insists he can. Another day he sees a commercial in which a boy and a girl play with toy trucks and a doll. Use social learning and gender schema ideas.
Step 1, social learning: he is observing models (his parents) and the commercial's characters, and what he sees reinforced or punished (his friend's comment) shapes what he imitates.
Step 2, gender schema: he is building a framework about what boys and girls do, and his friend's statement shows the framework in use. His own family's model conflicts with it, so he may adjust the schema (accommodation).
Step 3, both show the role of socialization and culture, so gender roles are shaped by environment as well as biology.
Exam focus
Sex (biological), gender (social and cultural), gender identity (internal sense), gender role, sexual orientation (attraction) are different ideas.
Socialization (family, peers, school, media) shapes gender; social learning and gender schema theories explain it. Differences between the genders are small and overlap a lot.
Sexual orientation arises from a mix of biological and environmental factors, is not a choice or a disorder, and does not change with therapy.
The case of David Reimer shows the limits of case studies and the importance of ethics.
Practice
Distinguish sex from gender.
Show answer
Sex refers to biological characteristics such as chromosomes and reproductive anatomy; gender refers to the social and cultural roles, behaviors, and identities associated with being male or female.
Explain how parents' behavior could contribute to gender typing.
Show answer
Parents may treat boys and girls differently from birth (clothing, toys, chores, and how they talk to them), and children learn from this reinforcement and from observing models.
Why are the findings about parents' descriptions of newborns important?
Show answer
Newborn boys and girls were objectively similar, yet parents described them differently, showing that stereotypes can shape perception and might lead to different treatment.
What do major scientific organizations conclude about sexual orientation?
Show answer
It results from a combination of biological and environmental factors, not from parenting or choice; it is not a mental disorder; and efforts to change it through therapy have not been effective and can be harmful.
What are two lessons from the Reimer case?
Show answer
A scientific lesson: a single case study with biased reporting cannot establish a theory, and the outcome showed that gender identity is not simply determined by upbringing. An ethical lesson: researchers must protect participants, obtain informed consent, and report results honestly.
Why might a small difference between average scores of two genders be misleading?
Show answer
The difference may be tiny compared with the variation within each gender, so the distributions overlap, and the average says little about an individual.
How does a child's way of thinking differ from an adult's? A 3-year-old who insists that the moon follows the car is not being silly; she is thinking in a way that fits her stage of development. Cognitive development is the study of how thinking, knowing, and problem solving change with age. This lesson covers the two most influential theories of childhood thinking, Jean Piaget's stages and Lev Vygotsky's sociocultural theory, then follows cognition into adulthood, where some abilities hold steady, some decline, and in some people dementia appears. The exam asks you to apply these theories to examples and to evaluate the research behind them, so look for the evidence for each idea and for its limits.
Required content · 3.4.A
Learning objective.
3.4.A. Explain how theories of cognitive development apply to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.4.A.1. According to Piaget, children develop schemas via continuous and discontinuous processes such as assimilation and accommodation.
3.4.A.1.i. The sensorimotor stage occurs from infancy through toddlerhood. Object permanence develops during this stage.
3.4.A.1.ii. The preoperational stage occurs from toddlerhood through early childhood. Children become proficient in using mental symbols and engage in pretend play. The preoperational stage is identified more by cognitive tasks children cannot perform such as conservation and reversibility, or by those they exhibit, such as animism and egocentrism. Children begin to develop a theory of mind during this stage.
3.4.A.1.iii. The concrete operational stage occurs from early through late childhood. Children in this stage can generally correct the cognitive errors made in the preoperational stage and understand the world in logical, realistic, and straightforward ways, but struggle to think systematically.
3.4.A.1.iv. The formal operational stage occurs from late childhood through adulthood. People in this stage gain the ability to think abstractly and hypothetically. Piaget proposed that not all people achieve formal operational thinking. 1.B 2.C 4.B
3.4.A.2. According to Vygotsky, children are social learners who learn through interacting with and scaffolding by other people within sociocultural contexts. Ideally, learning occurs while the person is in their zone of proximal development.
3.4.A.3. Adults experience changes in cognitive capabilities as they progress through the lifespan. Crystallized intelligence remains relatively stable through adulthood while fluid intelligence tends to wane as people age. Cognitive disorders that affect adults include dementia.
Piaget's theory
Jean Piaget, a Swiss psychologist, watched children closely, including his own, and concluded that children are not small adults who know less. They actively build their understanding of the world. He proposed that thinking develops through four stages, each qualitatively different from the one before (a discontinuous theory), always in the same order.
Two processes drive the building. A schema is a mental framework, or concept, that organizes knowledge (a young child's schema for "dog" may include "furry, four legs, barks"). Assimilation is interpreting a new experience in terms of an existing schema (calling a cat a "dog" because it has fur and four legs). Accommodation is changing the schema to fit new information (learning that cats are a different kind of animal, and forming a new schema). Children move toward equilibrium, a balance between what they know and what they experience.
Stage
Typical ages
Key features
Sensorimotor
Birth to about 2
Learns through senses and actions; object permanence develops; stranger anxiety appears
Preoperational
About 2 to 7
Uses symbols and language; egocentrism; centration; lacks conservation; pretend play
Concrete operational
About 7 to 11
Logical thinking about concrete objects; conservation; reversibility
Formal operational
About 12 and up
Abstract, hypothetical, and systematic thinking; scientific reasoning
Sensorimotor stage. Infants know the world through their senses and motor actions. A major achievement is object permanence, the understanding that objects continue to exist when they cannot be seen. Before about 8 months, a baby who sees a toy covered by a blanket acts as though it has vanished ("out of sight, out of mind"). Later the baby searches for it. Related to this, stranger anxiety (distress at unfamiliar people) appears around the same time, partly because the infant can now compare faces with the familiar ones in memory.
Preoperational stage. Children now use words and images to represent things (the symbolic function), shown in pretend play, and in drawing. But thinking is not yet logical in the adult sense. Egocentrism is the difficulty of taking another person's point of view. In the three mountains task, a child viewing a model of mountains from one side says that a doll seated at another side sees the same view as the child does. Centration is focusing on one feature of a situation and ignoring others, and it leads to failure at conservation, the understanding that quantity stays the same despite changes in shape or appearance. In the classic test, water is poured from a short wide glass into a tall thin glass, and the preoperational child says the tall glass has more because it is taller. Children at this stage also show animism, believing that inanimate objects have feelings or life, and may show artificialism.
Concrete operational stage. Children can reason logically about real, concrete things. They master conservation, understand reversibility (the water can be poured back), and can sort objects into categories and arrange them in order. They still struggle with purely abstract or hypothetical problems.
Formal operational stage. Adolescents can reason about abstract ideas such as justice, think about hypothetical possibilities ("what if...?"), and test ideas systematically, as scientists do. Not everyone reaches this stage in all areas, and the ages are approximate.
Evaluation. Piaget's work changed how people see children, and its sequence of stages is a useful description. But later research found that children can do more, earlier, than he thought. In studies with infants, who look longer at an "impossible" event (such as a solid object that appears to pass through another), researchers argue that object permanence begins well before 8 months. Children also vary: they do not move through a stage all at once, and culture and education matter. Critics also argue that development is more continuous than stages suggest, and that Piaget underestimated the role of social interaction. That is the focus of the next theory.
Vygotsky's sociocultural theory
Lev Vygotsky, a Russian psychologist, emphasized that thinking develops through social interaction within a culture. Children learn from more knowledgeable people (parents, teachers, older peers) who share their culture's tools, especially language. Key ideas:
The zone of proximal development (ZPD) is the range of tasks that a child cannot yet do alone but can do with help from someone more skilled. Learning happens most efficiently in this zone, not on tasks that are too easy or impossible.
Scaffolding is the support given by a more skilled partner that is adjusted to the learner's level and gradually withdrawn as the learner becomes more competent. A parent who first holds a bike steady, then lets go for a moment, then lets the child ride alone is scaffolding.
Language is central: children use private speech (talking aloud to themselves while solving a problem), which gradually becomes silent inner thought.
Piaget saw the child as a lone scientist exploring the world, and Vygotsky saw the child as an apprentice learning within a community. Piaget emphasized stages of development coming first, then learning; Vygotsky emphasized that social learning leads development.
Theory of mind
Theory of mind is the understanding that other people have thoughts, beliefs, and desires that differ from one's own, and that these can be used to explain and predict behavior. It develops in the preschool years and connects to Piaget's egocentrism.
Study spotlight · The Sally-Anne test (Baron-Cohen, Leslie, and Frith, 1985)
Children watched a doll named Sally put a marble in her basket and leave. While Sally was away, another doll, Anne, moved the marble to her own box. The children were asked where Sally would look for the marble when she returned. To answer correctly ("in her basket"), a child must understand that Sally has a false belief that is different from what the child knows to be true. Most typically developing 4-year-olds answered correctly, while most 3-year-olds pointed to the box where the marble really was. Of children with autism (average age about 12), most failed the task, though they had higher mental ages than the other groups.
Reading the research: an experiment comparing groups, with a clear test of one specific ability. It suggests that theory of mind develops around age 4 and may be delayed in autism spectrum disorder. The sample sizes were small, and later studies that adjusted the task (for example, tracking where very young children look) suggest that some implicit understanding of false belief may appear earlier. Not all people with autism fail the task.
Cognition in adulthood
Cognitive abilities change throughout adulthood, but not all in the same direction.
Fluid intelligence is the ability to reason quickly and solve novel problems, independent of what you have learned. It tends to peak in early adulthood and decline slowly with age.
Crystallized intelligence is the accumulation of knowledge and verbal skills from experience (vocabulary, general information). It stays stable or even increases into late adulthood.
Processing speed and some kinds of memory, especially remembering new information, decline gradually, while knowledge, expertise, and practical judgment can remain strong. Many older adults compensate with experience and strategies.
Dementia is a serious decline in cognitive abilities, such as memory, language, and reasoning, that interferes with daily life. It is not a normal part of aging. Alzheimer's disease (Lesson 2.5) is the most common cause. Other causes include strokes and other damage to blood vessels in the brain. Early signs include trouble remembering recent events, and as the disease progresses, a person may have difficulty with language, recognizing familiar people, and self-care. Unlike normal forgetting (such as a misplaced key, with a later recollection), dementia involves forgetting experiences and losing the ability to use the information.
Worked example · Piaget's stages
Identify the stage and the concept. (a) A 6-month-old drops a rattle and does not look for it. (b) A 5-year-old says the tall glass has more juice after juice is poured from a short wide glass. (c) A 9-year-old correctly says the amounts are the same, because "you can pour it back." (d) A 15-year-old considers what would happen if there were no gravity.
Step 1, (a) sensorimotor: no object permanence yet.
Step 2, (b) preoperational: lacks conservation (centration on height).
Step 3, (c) concrete operational: conservation and reversibility.
A toddler knows "dog" as a furry animal with four legs. (a) She sees a horse and says "big dog." (b) After being told it is a horse, she creates a new category called "horse." Name the process in each.
Step 1, (a) assimilation: the horse is fit into the existing "dog" schema.
Step 2, (b) accommodation: the schemas change to include a new category.
Step 3, cognitive growth results from these processes together, as the child's schemas become more accurate.
Worked example · Piaget versus Vygotsky
A child struggles with a jigsaw puzzle. Her father suggests, "Find all the edge pieces first," and then lets her place most of the pieces on her own. Interpret using Vygotsky and contrast with Piaget.
Step 1, the puzzle is in the child's zone of proximal development: too hard alone, but possible with help.
Step 2, the father's tip, which he gradually reduces, is scaffolding.
Step 3, Vygotsky: learning is social, guided by a more skilled partner. Piaget would instead stress that she is building understanding by exploring the puzzle herself, and that she must be at a stage that is ready for the task.
Step 4, the theories are not completely opposed; many teachers use both ideas.
Exam focus
Piaget: sensorimotor (object permanence), preoperational (egocentrism, centration, no conservation), concrete operational (conservation), formal operational (abstract thinking). Schema, assimilation, accommodation. Later research suggests children can do more, earlier.
Vygotsky: social interaction, zone of proximal development, scaffolding, language and private speech.
Theory of mind and the Sally-Anne test of false belief.
Adulthood: fluid intelligence declines; crystallized intelligence stays. Dementia is not normal aging; Alzheimer's is the most common cause.
Practice
Distinguish assimilation from accommodation with an example.
Show answer
Assimilation fits new experiences into existing schemas (calling a cow a "dog"); accommodation changes schemas to fit new information (creating a new category for "cow").
What is object permanence and in which stage does it develop?
Show answer
Understanding that objects continue to exist when out of sight; it develops in the sensorimotor stage.
A child watches clay rolled from a ball into a long snake and says there is more clay now. Which concept does the child lack, and which stage is it?
Show answer
Conservation, in the preoperational stage (the child centers on length).
Explain the zone of proximal development and scaffolding.
Show answer
The zone of proximal development is the range of tasks a learner can do only with help; scaffolding is the adjustable support from a more skilled person, gradually removed as the learner improves.
What did the Sally-Anne test show, and what is one limitation?
Show answer
Most 4-year-olds, but fewer 3-year-olds, understand that Sally has a false belief, which shows theory of mind develops around age 4. A limitation is that modified tasks suggest earlier implicit understanding, and the samples were small.
Which type of intelligence tends to decline with age and which tends to remain stable?
Show answer
Fluid intelligence tends to decline; crystallized intelligence tends to remain stable or increase.
A newborn cannot say a word, and by age 5 the same child speaks in long sentences, tells stories, and makes jokes. No other skill is learned so quickly and with so little formal teaching. How children do this has been one of the most debated questions in psychology, because it touches the nature and nurture theme directly: is language learned from the environment, or is the brain built to acquire it? This lesson describes what language is made of, the usual sequence of its development, the theories that explain it, and the evidence about critical periods. Be ready to match a child's utterance to a stage and to apply the theories to a scenario.
Required content · 3.5.A, 3.5.B
Learning objectives.
3.5.A. Explain how key components of language and communication apply to behavior and mental processes.
3.5.B. Explain how language develops in humans.
Essential knowledge.
3.5.A.1. Language is a shared (mutually agreed upon) system of arbitrary symbols (often expressed as and combined into phonemes, morphemes, and semantics) that are rule-governed (via grammar and syntax) and generative to produce an infinity of ideas. Exclusion Statement: Pragmatics of language are outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
3.5.B.1. In language development across all cultures, people use nonverbal manual gestures (e.g., pointing) to communicate and develop formal language through specific stages (cooing, babbling, one-word stage, and telegraphic speech). People learning a language often make errors such as overgeneralization of language rules as they learn. 1.B 2.D
The components of language
Language is a system of symbols and rules that lets people communicate. Its parts are:
Phonemes: the smallest units of sound in a language (English has about 40; "cat" has three: /k/, /a/, /t/).
Morphemes: the smallest units of meaning. "Cats" has two morphemes: "cat" and the plural "s."
Semantics: the meanings of words and sentences.
Syntax: the rules for combining words into grammatical sentences. "The dog chased the cat" and "The cat chased the dog" have the same words but different meanings, because of syntax.
Pragmatics: the social rules for using language, such as taking turns in a conversation, and speaking differently to a friend than to a teacher.
The usual sequence
Children across cultures follow a similar sequence, though the ages vary.
Approximate age
Stage
Example
Birth to 4 months
Cooing
Vowel sounds such as "oooh"
About 4 to 10 months
Babbling
Consonant-vowel sounds such as "ba-ba-ba," in all languages at first, then narrowing to the sounds of the home language
About 10 to 12 months
One-word stage
"Milk" (which may mean "I want milk")
About 18 to 24 months
Two-word stage (telegraphic speech)
"Want cookie," "Daddy go" (like a telegram: key words, no small connecting words)
After 24 months
Rapid growth in sentence length
"I want a cookie, please"
Before they can speak, infants show receptive language, the understanding of words, which is ahead of productive language, the ability to produce words. A baby may respond to "no" months before saying it. By around age 6, children understand and use about 10,000 words, and they pick up words at a rate of several per day, a process called fast mapping, when a child links a new word to its meaning after a single exposure.
Overgeneralization
A common sign of rule learning is overgeneralization (also called overregularization): applying a grammar rule to cases where it does not fit. A child who correctly said "went" and "mice" at first later says "goed" and "mouses." This is evidence that the child has learned the rule ("add -ed for past tense," "add -s for plural") and is applying it, not just imitating what adults say, because no adult says "goed." Later the child learns the exceptions.
Theories of language acquisition
Learning (behaviorist) theory, B. F. Skinner: children learn language through imitation and reinforcement. Parents smile and respond when a baby says something close to a word, and so shape speech gradually. It explains learning of vocabulary and accent, but it cannot easily explain overgeneralization or how children create sentences they never heard.
Nativist theory, Noam Chomsky: humans have an inborn capacity for language, often called a language acquisition device, a built-in understanding of the structure of grammar (a "universal grammar"), which the environment triggers. Evidence includes the speed of acquisition, the similar sequence across languages, and overgeneralization. The theory has been criticized for not stressing the role of the environment and social interaction.
Interactionist theory combines the two: children are biologically prepared for language, and social interaction with caregivers provides the experience that shapes it. Many psychologists favor this view.
Critical periods and the effects of deprivation
The ability to learn language is strongest in early childhood. A critical (sensitive) period for language appears to end around puberty: children who learn a second language before about age 7 usually speak it with native fluency, but later learners usually keep an accent and have more trouble with grammar.
Some of the sad evidence comes from cases of extreme isolation. The case of "Genie" (discovered in 1970 in California at age 13, after having been kept isolated in a room) showed that she could learn many words, but she never fully mastered grammar, which supports a critical period. (Because her situation included severe abuse and malnutrition, other factors than missing language may have contributed, and it is a single case.) Studies of deaf children who are exposed to sign language late show similar results.
Study spotlight · Perceiving speech sounds (Werker and Tees, 1984)
Janet Werker and Richard Tees tested whether infants and adults could hear the difference between pairs of speech sounds that are used in languages other than English (from Hindi and from a Native American language, Salish). English-speaking adults could not tell the sounds apart. English-learning infants aged 6 to 8 months could. By 10 to 12 months, the infants' ability to distinguish the foreign sounds had greatly declined, while infants growing up in Hindi-speaking homes could still hear the Hindi sounds.
Reading the research: an experiment comparing age groups, using head turns as the response. It shows that infants begin life able to discriminate sounds of all languages and that experience narrows this ability to the sounds of the home language, evidence of a sensitive period and of the effect of experience. Because it is a comparison across ages, not tracking the same infants, it cannot rule out cohort differences, although the pattern is consistent across later studies.
Language and thought
Does the language you speak affect how you think? Linguistic relativity (the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis) proposes that language influences thought. The strong version, that language determines thought, is not supported. Research supports a weaker version: for example, speakers of languages with many words for colors can distinguish some shades of color slightly faster, so language can influence perception and memory. Bilingualism can give some advantages in attention and switching between tasks, though findings vary.
Worked example · Match the utterance to the stage
Identify the stage. (a) A 5-month-old says "ba-ba-ba." (b) A 12-month-old says "ball" and points to a ball. (c) A 20-month-old says "More juice." (d) A 4-year-old says "I runned fast."
Step 1, (a) babbling.
Step 2, (b) the one-word stage.
Step 3, (c) the two-word (telegraphic) stage.
Step 4, (d) overgeneralization of the past tense rule: evidence that the child has learned the rule.
Worked example · Components of language
Name the component. (a) The word "unhappy" has the parts "un" and "happy." (b) Changing "Is he here?" to "He is here" changes the meaning. (c) The sound /b/ versus /p/ distinguishes "bat" and "pat." (d) A child learns to say "please" and to wait for a turn to speak.
Step 1, (a) morphemes (smallest meaning units).
Step 2, (b) syntax (word order).
Step 3, (c) phonemes (sound units).
Step 4, (d) pragmatics (social use of language).
Worked example · Which theory?
A child says, "The sheeps runned away." Her mother responds, "Yes, the sheep ran away!" Explain using the three theories.
Step 1, the child never heard adults say "sheeps" or "runned," so imitation alone (learning theory) cannot explain it. It shows she applies rules (nativist view: the innate grammar capacity).
Step 2, the mother's correct repetition provides a model and feedback (learning/social influence), and over time the child will learn the exceptions.
Step 3, the interactionist theory combines these: an inborn readiness, and experience with caregivers.
Exam focus
Parts of language: phonemes, morphemes, semantics, syntax, pragmatics.
Sequence: cooing, babbling, one word, two words (telegraphic), sentences. Understanding comes before speaking.
Critical period for language (Genie; deaf children; Werker and Tees). Linguistic relativity: language can influence, not determine, thought.
Practice
Define phoneme and morpheme and give an example of each.
Show answer
A phoneme is the smallest unit of sound (the /k/ in "cat"); a morpheme is the smallest unit of meaning (the word "cat," or the plural "s").
Why does a child saying "goed" support the idea that children learn rules, not just imitate?
Show answer
Adults do not say "goed," so the child must have formed the rule "add -ed for the past tense" and applied it to a verb that is an exception.
Describe telegraphic speech.
Show answer
A stage at about 18 to 24 months in which children combine two words, using key words and leaving out small connecting words, such as "want cookie."
Contrast Skinner's and Chomsky's explanations of language acquisition.
Show answer
Skinner: language is learned by imitation and reinforcement. Chomsky: humans have an inborn capacity for grammar that experience triggers.
What does the evidence about Genie and late-exposed deaf children suggest?
Show answer
It suggests a critical period for language: people who are not exposed to language until after early childhood rarely master grammar fully.
What did Werker and Tees find about infants' perception of speech sounds?
Show answer
Young infants could distinguish the sounds of other languages, but by about 10 to 12 months this ability declined if the sounds were not part of the language they heard, showing the effect of experience.
Social-emotional development: family and attachment
Children grow up in a web of relationships, beginning with the people who care for them. The bond with a caregiver, the style of parenting, a baby's own temperament, and the wider world around the family all shape how a child feels, relates to others, and sees themselves. This lesson covers the first half of social-emotional development: the settings that influence a child, the major parenting styles, temperament, and attachment, including the two classic experiments on it. The second half (peers, adulthood, identity, and Erikson's stages) is in the next lesson. Throughout, remember that most of this research is correlational, so be careful about claims of cause.
Required content · 3.6.A
Learning objective.
3.6.A. Explain how social development relates to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.6.A.1. The ecological systems theory explores how the social environment influences development. The five systems in this theory are as follows: Microsystem (groups that have direct contact with the individual); Mesosystem (the relationships between groups in the microsystem); Exosystem (indirect factors in an individual’s life); Macrosystem (cultural events that affect the individuals and others around them); Chronosystem (the individual’s current stage of life).
3.6.A.2. Research has identified different parenting styles of caregivers, including authoritarian, authoritative, and permissive. Cultural differences exist in the ways these parenting styles affect outcomes in caregivers and children.
3.6.A.3. Research has identified different attachment styles demonstrated by infants and children, which vary by culture. The types of attachment infants and children display include secure and insecure (avoidant, anxious, and disorganized). Temperament is related to how children attach to caregivers. 1.A 2.A 2.B
3.6.A.3.i. Separation anxiety occurs when children express heightened anxiety or fear when away from a caregiver or in the presence of a stranger.
3.6.A.3.ii. Studies with monkeys demonstrate the importance of comfort over food in attachment.
The contexts of development
Urie Bronfenbrenner's ecological systems theory describes development as occurring within nested layers of environment.
Figure 3.1. Bronfenbrenner's ecological systems theory. The child sits inside the microsystem (direct contacts), which sits inside the mesosystem (links between settings), the exosystem (settings that affect the child indirectly), and the macrosystem (the broad culture). The chronosystem is change over time.
The microsystem is the child's immediate settings and the people in them: family, school, peers, neighborhood.
The mesosystem is the connections between those settings (for example, how a parent's involvement with the school relates to the child's school performance).
The exosystem is settings that affect the child indirectly, where the child is not a participant (a parent's workplace and its schedule).
The macrosystem is the broad culture: its values, laws, and customs.
The chronosystem is time: changes over the person's life and across historical periods (a parent's divorce, or growing up during a recession).
The theory is a reminder that no child is shaped by a single factor, and that the relationship between a child and the environment goes both ways: a child's temperament affects how parents respond.
Parenting styles
Diana Baumrind described three styles (authoritarian, authoritative, and permissive; the AP course tests these three), later extended by others with a fourth, neglectful, according to two dimensions: warmth (responsiveness) and control (demands and expectations). Cultures differ in how these styles affect outcomes.
Style
Warmth
Control
Typical approach
Typical outcomes in the research
Authoritative
High
High
Sets clear rules and explains them; listens; flexible
Higher self-esteem, better school performance and social skills
Authoritarian
Low
High
"Because I said so"; strict, punishment-oriented
More anxiety and withdrawal; lower self-esteem; may rebel
Permissive
High
Low
Few rules; indulgent; acts as a friend
Poorer self-control; more risk-taking
Neglectful (uninvolved)
Low
Low
Little attention or support
Greatest risk of problems; often poor attachment
These are correlations. Children with easy temperaments may be easier to parent in an authoritative way, so the direction of cause is not certain, and the outcomes can differ by culture, since research suggests that the benefits of authoritative parenting are clearest in the United States and some other cultures, and that in some communities strictness has different meanings.
Temperament
Temperament is an infant's characteristic emotional reactivity and intensity, which is present early and seems to have a biological basis. Alexander Thomas and Stella Chess, in a longitudinal study of babies, identified three common patterns: easy babies (about 40 percent), who are cheerful, regular in their habits, and adaptable; difficult babies (about 10 percent), who are irritable, irregular, and resistant to change; and slow-to-warm-up babies (about 15 percent), who are cautious and withdrawn at first and adapt gradually. The rest do not fit one pattern. Temperament shows moderate stability, so a very inhibited infant is more likely to be a shy child, but experience can change it. The idea of goodness of fit, how well the parents' approach matches the child's temperament, helps to explain why the same style works differently for different children.
Attachment
Attachment is the strong emotional bond between an infant and a caregiver. Evidence about how it forms comes from two lines of research.
Study spotlight · Harlow's monkeys (1958)
Psychologist Harry Harlow separated infant rhesus monkeys from their mothers shortly after birth and raised them with two artificial "mothers": a wire frame that held a bottle of milk and a similar frame covered in soft terry cloth that gave no milk. Monkeys spent most of their time clinging to the cloth mother and went to the wire mother only to feed. When frightened, they ran to the cloth mother. Monkeys raised with no mothers were later fearful, socially disturbed, and, as mothers, neglected their own babies.
Reading the research: an experiment with animals. It challenged the behaviorist idea that attachment arises mainly because the caregiver provides food, and showed the importance of contact comfort. Limits: monkeys are not humans, so generalizing to human infants requires caution, and the study caused severe suffering to the animals, which raises ethical concerns that led to stricter rules on animal research.
Study spotlight · The Strange Situation (Ainsworth, 1970)
Mary Ainsworth developed a laboratory procedure in which a one-year-old child is observed through a sequence of short episodes: playing with the mother present, a stranger arriving, the mother leaving, the mother returning, and so on. Observers record how the child responds when the mother leaves and returns. Ainsworth found that children differ in their attachment style.
Secure attachment (about 60 to 65 percent of American infants): the child explores with the mother present, is upset when she leaves, and is comforted quickly and returns to play when she comes back. The caregiver tends to be sensitive and responsive.
Insecure-avoidant (about 20 percent): the child shows little distress at separation and avoids or ignores the mother on return.
Insecure-ambivalent (resistant) (about 10 to 15 percent): the child is very distressed when the mother leaves, and on return both seeks contact and angrily resists it, and is not easily comforted.
Later researchers added disorganized attachment, with confused and contradictory behavior, which is often found in children who have been abused.
Reading the research: an observational laboratory procedure with a small initial sample of mostly middle-class American families. Securely attached infants tend to have caregivers who respond sensitively, but temperament also plays a role, and it is not clear how far the procedure applies in other cultures, where the expected behavior of infants differs. Attachment style in infancy is moderately related to later relationships, but it is not destiny.
Separation anxiety is the heightened fear or distress that children show when away from a caregiver or in the presence of a stranger; it typically appears in the second half of the first year and is a normal sign of attachment.
Deprivation and its effects. Children who experience severe neglect (such as those raised in understaffed institutions) show more attachment problems, delays in language and thinking, and emotional difficulties, though when removed to caring homes early, many recover substantially, which suggests that development is resilient and that earlier rescue means better recovery.
Worked example · Identify the parenting style
Name the style. (a) "You will do your homework now. No discussion." (b) "Let's talk about why we have a bedtime. I'll listen to your ideas, but the bedtime is 9." (c) A parent who rarely knows where their teenager is and who does not provide any rules or help. (d) A parent who almost never says no and lets the child decide meals, bedtimes, and screen time.
Step 1, (a) high control, low warmth: authoritarian.
Step 2, (b) high warmth and high control, with reasoning: authoritative.
Step 3, (c) low warmth, low control: neglectful.
Step 4, (d) high warmth, low control: permissive.
Worked example · Interpret Strange Situation results
In a study of 80 one-year-olds, 52 are classified secure, 16 avoidant, and 12 ambivalent. Calculate the percentages and interpret.
Step 1, secure: \(52\div80=0.65\), or 65%.
Step 2, avoidant: \(16\div80=0.20\), or 20%.
Step 3, ambivalent: \(12\div80=0.15\), or 15%. Check: \(65+20+15=100\).
Step 4, interpretation: most infants are securely attached, as in Ainsworth's findings. Because attachment style is measured by a procedure designed for U.S. families, comparisons with other cultures must take into account differences in typical infant behavior.
Worked example · Applying ecological systems
A girl's grades decline after her mother loses her job and has to work night shifts. Her teachers have started a new after-school program that she can no longer attend. Name the systems.
Step 1, her mother's workplace and schedule, which affect her indirectly, belong to the exosystem.
Step 2, her family and school are part of the microsystem; the interaction between her home and school (the mother cannot attend the program) is the mesosystem.
Step 3, the economic downturn that caused the job loss and the cultural values about work are the macrosystem, and the timing of these events in her life is the chronosystem.
Exam focus
Bronfenbrenner: micro-, meso-, exo-, macro-, and chronosystems.
Parenting styles: authoritative (warm and firm), authoritarian, permissive, neglectful. Findings are correlational.
Temperament: easy, difficult, slow-to-warm-up; goodness of fit.
Attachment: Harlow (contact comfort) and Ainsworth (secure, avoidant, ambivalent, disorganized). Severe deprivation harms development, but recovery is possible.
Practice
Describe the authoritative parenting style and a limitation of research on it.
Show answer
High warmth and high control: clear rules, explained, with responsiveness. A limitation is that the research is correlational, and the benefits may differ across cultures.
What does the exosystem include? Give an example.
Show answer
Settings that affect the child indirectly although the child is not a participant, such as a parent's workplace.
What did Harlow's cloth and wire mother experiment show?
Show answer
Infant monkeys preferred the soft cloth mother even though the wire mother provided food, showing the importance of contact comfort in attachment.
Describe a securely attached infant's behavior in the Strange Situation.
Show answer
The infant explores with the caregiver present, is upset when she leaves, and is easily comforted and goes back to playing when she returns.
Why can't we conclude from correlational studies that authoritative parenting causes better outcomes?
Show answer
A child's temperament, genes, and other variables may influence both the parenting style and the outcomes, and the direction of cause could go from child to parent.
Explain goodness of fit.
Show answer
How well the parents' expectations and behavior match the child's temperament; a good match supports adjustment.
As children grow, the center of their social world moves from the family toward peers, and in adolescence the question "Who am I?" becomes urgent. Adults continue to change as they take on work, partners, parenthood, and eventually face aging and loss. This lesson picks up the story of social-emotional development: the role of peers, how adverse childhood experiences leave marks, Erik Erikson's well-known eight stages, and the research on identity in adolescence and well-being in adulthood. As with other stage theories, ask what evidence supports the claims, and whether development really proceeds in neat stages.
Required content · 3.6.A
Learning objective.
3.6.A. Explain how social development relates to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.6.A.4. Developmental psychologists study how peer relationships develop over time.
3.6.A.4.i. Children engage with peers via play (parallel and pretend).
3.6.A.4.ii. Adolescents gradually rely more on peer relationships as they age. As adolescents interact with peers, they demonstrate a type of egocentrism that is often demonstrated via the imaginary audience and the personal fable.
3.6.A.5. Developmental psychologists study how adults develop socially over time.
3.6.A.5.i. Culture plays a role in determining when adulthood begins and when major life events occur (social clock). Some cultures allow for a time of emerging adulthood as a transition from adolescence to adulthood.
3.6.A.5.ii. Relationships with other adults result in adults forming families or family-like relationships that should provide mutual support and care. Childhood attachment styles can affect how adults form attachments to other adults.
3.6.A.6. The stage theory of psychosocial development, which was a reconceptualization of the psychosexual theory, proposes that people must resolve psychosocial conflicts at each stage of the lifespan. The stages are as follows: Trust and mistrust; Autonomy and shame and doubt; Initiative and guilt; Industry and inferiority; Identity and role confusion; Intimacy and isolation; Generativity and stagnation; Integrity and despair. Exclusion Statement: The psychosexual stage theory of development is outside of the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
3.6.A.7. The experience of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) has effects on relationships people form throughout the lifespan. Sociocultural differences exist in what is considered an ACE and how ACEs affect outcomes people may experience.
3.6.A.8. Adolescents develop a sense of identity for who they will be as an adult through the processes of achievement, diffusion, foreclosure, and moratorium. Identity development also includes processes for developing identities such as racial/ethnic identity, gender identity, sexual orientation, religious identity, occupational identity, and familial identity, often through considering possible selves.
Peers and friendships
Young children engage with peers through play. In parallel play, children play side by side, each doing their own activity, with little interaction. In pretend play, they act out roles and imaginary situations, often together. Peer relationships become more important in middle childhood and adolescence, and adolescents gradually rely more on peers as they age. Adolescent thinking shows a kind of egocentrism: the imaginary audience is the belief that everyone is watching and judging you ("everyone will notice my pimple"), and the personal fable is the belief that your experiences are unique and that you are invulnerable ("it can't happen to me"), which can contribute to risk taking. Children and adolescents learn cooperation, negotiation, and social skills from peers, and they compare themselves with others, which shapes self-esteem. Peers also influence behavior: adolescents are more likely to take risks when friends are present. Being rejected by peers is associated with loneliness and depression, and being bullied has lasting effects on well-being. At the same time, good friendships are protective. Parents and peers both matter: parents often influence values and long-term goals, and peers influence daily behavior and styles.
Adverse childhood experiences
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are potentially traumatic events in childhood, such as abuse, neglect, and living with a family member who has a serious mental illness or who abuses substances. Studies have found that the more ACEs a person has, the greater the risk of later problems, including depression, substance use, and some physical illnesses. This is a correlational finding based on adults looking back on their childhoods, and so memory may be imperfect, but the pattern is consistent. Protective factors, such as at least one stable, supportive adult, and a sense of safety, help children to recover, and many children who have experienced adversity do well. This ability to adapt successfully despite adversity is called resilience.
Erikson's psychosocial stages
Erik Erikson proposed that each person passes through eight stages across the whole lifespan, and that each stage centers on a psychosocial crisis, a conflict between two outcomes, a positive one and a negative one. How the person resolves the crisis shapes personality and readiness for the next stage. Unlike many theories, Erikson's covers adulthood.
Stage (approximate age)
Crisis
Positive resolution
Infancy (0 to 1)
Trust versus mistrust
The caregiver's reliability leads the infant to trust the world
Toddler (1 to 3)
Autonomy versus shame and doubt
Toddlers practice independence (toilet training, choices)
Preschool (3 to 6)
Initiative versus guilt
The child plans and carries out activities
School age (6 to puberty)
Industry versus inferiority
The child feels competent through mastering skills, such as at school
Adolescence
Identity versus role confusion
The teen forms a sense of self: values, goals, and roles
Young adulthood
Intimacy versus isolation
The person forms close, committed relationships
Middle adulthood
Generativity versus stagnation
The person contributes to the next generation through work, parenting, and community
Late adulthood
Integrity versus despair
The person looks back on life with a sense of meaning and acceptance
Strengths of Erikson's theory include its attention to the whole lifespan and to social relationships. Limitations: the stages are described in general terms that are hard to test; the ages are approximate and culture-specific; and many people revisit issues such as identity at other times. It describes development as discontinuous, which is a point of debate.
Identity in adolescence
James Marcia built on Erikson's ideas, proposing four identity statuses according to whether a person has explored alternatives (a crisis) and whether the person has made a commitment:
Identity diffusion: no exploration and no commitment.
Foreclosure: commitment without exploration (adopting parents' choices without questioning).
Moratorium: exploring, but not yet committed.
Identity achievement: has explored and made a commitment.
Adolescents also develop a sense of ethnic and cultural identity and sexual identity, and a secure sense of identity is associated with better mental health. Adolescence is also marked by emerging adulthood (about ages 18 to 25 in many Western countries), when people are not yet settled in adult roles and explore options, a period proposed by Jeffrey Arnett.
Adulthood and well-being
Culture plays a role in deciding when adulthood begins and when major life events (marriage, a first job, parenthood) are expected. This cultural timetable is the social clock. Adults form families or family-like relationships that should provide mutual support, and childhood attachment styles can affect how adults form attachments to others (a securely attached child tends to form trusting adult relationships). Adults deal with career, partnerships, parenthood, caring for aging parents, and eventually retirement and loss. Researchers find that:
Life satisfaction is often relatively high in later adulthood, and older adults tend to focus on emotionally meaningful goals and report positive emotions more often than the young (the positivity effect in emotion and attention).
Close relationships and social support are among the strongest predictors of well-being at all ages.
Many people experience grief after the death of a loved one, and the process varies; most people are resilient, and there is no required sequence of stages for everyone.
Worked example · Erikson's stage
Name the crisis. (a) A 4-year-old eagerly starts building a fort and feels proud when it is done. (b) A 9-year-old fails at schoolwork and feels worthless compared with classmates. (c) A 70-year-old reviews her life with pride and acceptance. (d) A 35-year-old mentors younger workers and volunteers to coach.
Step 1, (a) initiative versus guilt (preschool).
Step 2, (b) industry versus inferiority (school age), with the negative outcome.
Step 3, (c) integrity versus despair, with the positive outcome.
Step 4, (d) generativity versus stagnation, with the positive outcome.
Worked example · Marcia's identity statuses
Name the status. (a) A high school senior plans to be a doctor "because my parents said so" and has never considered other careers. (b) A college sophomore is trying out different majors and clubs and has not yet decided. (c) A person has tried several fields and has settled on teaching with strong commitment. (d) A teenager has not thought about career or beliefs and seems uninterested.
Step 1, (a) foreclosure.
Step 2, (b) moratorium.
Step 3, (c) identity achievement.
Step 4, (d) identity diffusion.
Worked example · Interpreting an ACEs study
A survey finds that, among adults with 4 or more ACEs, 30% report depression, versus 10% of those with none. Interpret and identify the design problem.
Step 1, the difference is \(30-10=20\) percentage points, and the risk is three times as high (\(30\div10=3\)).
Step 2, this is a correlation: adverse experiences are associated with later depression, but the design cannot show that they cause it, since other factors (genes, poverty) could contribute to both.
Step 3, adults reported their childhood events from memory, so recall may be biased, especially in people who are depressed now.
Step 4, a defensible claim: "More adverse childhood experiences are associated with a higher risk of depression, and protective relationships can reduce the risk."
Exam focus
Peers shape social skills and behavior; ACEs are linked with later problems; resilience and supportive adults protect.
Erikson's eight stages: trust, autonomy, initiative, industry, identity, intimacy, generativity, integrity (each versus its negative).
Adult well-being: social support and relationships matter; the positivity effect.
Practice
List Erikson's eight stages in order.
Show answer
Trust vs mistrust; autonomy vs shame and doubt; initiative vs guilt; industry vs inferiority; identity vs role confusion; intimacy vs isolation; generativity vs stagnation; integrity vs despair.
Distinguish foreclosure from moratorium.
Show answer
In foreclosure a person has made a commitment without exploring alternatives; in moratorium a person is exploring but has not yet committed.
What are adverse childhood experiences, and why is the research on them correlational?
Show answer
Potentially traumatic events in childhood such as abuse or neglect. Participants cannot be randomly assigned to these experiences, so other variables could explain the later outcomes.
What is resilience?
Show answer
The ability to adapt and do well despite adversity; supportive relationships help.
Give one strength and one limitation of Erikson's theory.
Show answer
Strength: it covers the whole lifespan and emphasizes social relationships. Limitation: its concepts are vague and hard to test, and the stages and ages are culture-specific.
What is the positivity effect in older adults?
Show answer
Older adults tend to attend to and remember positive information more than negative information and to report more positive emotions.
Why does your mouth water when you smell a favorite food cooking, why does the sound of a dentist's drill make you tense, and why might you never want to eat a certain food again after it made you sick? These are all examples of learning, a relatively lasting change in behavior or knowledge that results from experience. The behavioral perspective, which grew from early studies of learning, focused on observable behavior and traditionally left out mental processes. This lesson covers the first of its two main forms of learning, classical conditioning, in which organisms learn to associate one stimulus with another. You will learn the vocabulary (it is tested heavily and is easy to confuse), the processes that strengthen or weaken associations, the classic studies, and how the ideas are used in treatment.
Required content · 3.7.A
Learning objective.
3.7.A. Explain how classical conditioning applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.7.A.1. The behavioral perspective evolved from theories about learning via conditioning. Behaviorists have traditionally focused on observable behavior to the exclusion of mental processes.
3.7.A.2. Classical conditioning focuses on the association of one stimulus with another stimulus to elicit a response. Learning the association (also known as acquisition) involves a series of steps that demonstrate principles of associative learning.
3.7.A.2.i. The unconditioned stimulus (UCS) elicits an unconditioned response (UCR). This response becomes the conditioned response (CR) when it is performed in response to the conditioned stimulus (CS).
3.7.A.2.ii. The order of presentation of the CS with the UCS is important to successful acquisition.
3.7.A.2.iii. A CR can become extinct when the CS is no longer paired with the UCS. A formerly extinct CR can be spontaneously recovered when the CS is again presented after extinction.
3.7.A.2.iv. Stimulus discrimination and generalization have been demonstrated in studies of classical conditioning. 1.A 2.D 3.A
3.7.A.2.v. A CS can be used as a UCS in higher-order conditioning. Exclusion Statement: Delayed conditioning, trace conditioning, simultaneous conditioning, and backward conditioning are outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
3.7.A.3. Research has demonstrated that emotional responses can be classically conditioned. These findings form the basis of therapeutic interventions for many mental disorders, such as counterconditioning. Exclusion Statement: The expectancy theory is outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
3.7.A.4. Research on taste aversions, which are acquired through classical conditioning, demonstrates one-trial conditioning and biological preparedness. One-trial learning occurs when the association is acquired through one pairing of the stimulus and response and is not strengthened by further pairings. Biological preparedness refers to how animals are biologically predisposed to learning certain stimulus-response pairings more quickly than others.
3.7.A.5. Habituation occurs when organisms grow accustomed to and exhibit a diminished response to a repeated or enduring stimulus.
Pavlov's discovery
The Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov was studying digestion in dogs when he noticed that they began to salivate before food arrived, at the sight of the lab assistant or the sound of footsteps. He realized that this was not a reflex but a learned association, and he studied it systematically. In classical conditioning, a neutral stimulus comes to trigger a response after being paired with a stimulus that already triggers the response.
Figure 3.2. Classical conditioning in Pavlov's dogs. Food (UCS) triggers salivation (UCR) without learning. After the bell (neutral stimulus) is repeatedly paired with the food, the bell becomes a conditioned stimulus (CS) and triggers salivation as a conditioned response (CR).
The vocabulary
Unconditioned stimulus (UCS): a stimulus that automatically triggers a response without any learning (food).
Unconditioned response (UCR): the automatic, unlearned response to the UCS (salivation to food).
Neutral stimulus (NS): a stimulus that at first does not trigger the response (a bell).
Conditioned stimulus (CS): the formerly neutral stimulus that, after pairing with the UCS, triggers a response (the bell).
Conditioned response (CR): the learned response to the CS (salivation to the bell). It is similar to the UCR but is triggered by the CS.
A reliable way to identify them: find the stimulus that triggers the response without learning; that is the UCS, and the response to it is the UCR. Whatever now triggers a similar response because of learning is the CS, and the response is the CR.
Acquisition is the process of learning the association. The order of presentation matters: conditioning works best when the CS comes just before the UCS (the bell, then food), so that the CS signals that the UCS is coming. (The names of the different timing arrangements, such as delayed, trace, simultaneous, and backward conditioning, are not tested on the AP Exam.)
Strengthening and weakening: processes of association
Extinction: the CR weakens and disappears when the CS is repeatedly presented without the UCS (the bell rings with no food, and the dog stops salivating).
Spontaneous recovery: after a rest period, the extinguished CR sometimes reappears when the CS is presented again, though weaker. It shows that extinction does not erase the learning but suppresses it.
Generalization: responding to stimuli similar to the CS. A dog conditioned to a bell of one pitch also salivates to similar pitches.
Discrimination: learning to respond only to the CS and not to similar stimuli, because only the CS is followed by the UCS.
Higher-order conditioning: a CS is used as if it were a UCS to condition a new neutral stimulus. After the bell predicts food, pairing a flash of light with the bell (with no food) can make the light trigger salivation.
Emotional responses and counterconditioning
Emotions, including fears, can be classically conditioned. This finding helps to explain phobias and why places, songs, or smells that were present during emotional events can bring back strong feelings. It also forms the basis for treatments. Counterconditioning replaces an unwanted response with a different one by pairing the CS with a new, incompatible response, such as relaxation. In therapy, a person with a fear of dogs might learn to relax while being gradually exposed to dogs. (The expectancy theory of conditioning is not tested on the AP Exam.)
Study spotlight · Little Albert (Watson and Rayner, 1920)
John Watson and Rosalie Rayner worked with an 11-month-old infant known as "Albert B." At first he showed no fear of a white laboratory rat and was curious about it. Then, every time he reached for the rat, the researchers made a loud, frightening noise by striking a steel bar behind him. After several pairings, Albert cried and tried to crawl away when he saw the rat alone. The fear also generalized to other furry things: a rabbit, a fur coat, and a Santa Claus mask.
Reading the research: an uncontrolled demonstration, with a single infant, so it cannot show how typical the result is. It suggested that emotional responses such as phobias can be learned through conditioning. It is also widely seen as a serious ethical violation: the infant was deliberately frightened, had no consent from an informed guardian by today's standards, and the fear was never removed. Modern ethical rules would not allow it.
Taste aversion and biological preparedness
Study spotlight · Taste aversion (Garcia and Koelling, 1966)
John Garcia and Robert Koelling gave rats water that was flavored with saccharin and also accompanied by a light and a click when the rats drank it. Afterward, some rats were made sick with radiation (or a drug), and others were shocked on the feet. The rats that were made sick later avoided the flavored water but not the light and click water, and the rats that were shocked avoided the light and click water but not the flavored water.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to the type of consequence. It showed biological preparedness: animals are biologically predisposed to associate certain stimuli more quickly than others (taste with illness, which fits an animal's survival, and sights and sounds with external pain). It also showed one-trial learning, since taste aversion can form after a single pairing (and the delay between taste and sickness can be hours), in contrast to the repeated pairings needed in Pavlov's work. This challenged the idea that any stimuli can be associated equally well. A limit is that it was done with rats in a laboratory, but similar taste aversions occur in people (the food that made you sick once).
Habituation
Habituation is the decrease in response to a repeated or constant stimulus, such as getting used to the sound of a refrigerator, or a city dweller no longer noticing traffic noise. It is a simple form of learning (not classical conditioning, since it does not involve an association), and it is how an organism stops spending attention on harmless, unchanging stimuli. Researchers use it with infants: when a baby has stopped looking at a repeated picture and then looks longer at a new one, the baby must notice the difference.
Worked example · Identify the parts
A child is bitten by a dog and feels fear. After that, whenever the child hears a dog bark, the child feels fear. Identify the UCS, UCR, CS, and CR.
Step 1, the bite triggers fear without learning: UCS = the bite; UCR = fear (and pain).
Step 2, the bark was originally neutral but was paired with the bite: the bark is the CS.
Step 3, fear in response to the bark alone is the CR.
Step 4, if the child hears many barks that are not followed by bites, the fear fades: extinction. If the fear also arises at a growl, that is generalization.
Worked example · Interpret an extinction curve
A conditioned response is measured as drops of saliva in 6 trials in which the bell is presented without food: 12, 8, 5, 2, 0, 0. After a day's rest, the bell produces 3 drops. Describe each phase.
Step 1, the decline from 12 drops to 0 across trials is extinction: the CS without the UCS.
Step 2, the return of 3 drops after the rest is spontaneous recovery.
Step 3, the recovery (3) is smaller than the original (12), and it shows that extinction suppresses the learned response, not erases it.
Step 4, if the bell is repeatedly presented again with no food, the response will likely fade again, and more quickly.
Worked example · Applying classical conditioning
A person is nervous at the dentist because of past pain. Every time she hears a drill, her heart rate rises. (a) Name the CS and CR. (b) Design a counterconditioning approach. (c) A friend says that dogs "can learn to associate anything with anything." Respond using the research.
Step 1, (a) the CS is the drill sound (originally neutral; paired with pain, the UCS), and the CR is the heart-rate increase and fear.
Step 2, (b) pair the drill sound, in small doses, with a relaxed state (breathing exercises), gradually replacing fear with relaxation.
Step 3, (c) Garcia and Koelling showed biological preparedness: associations that match an animal's survival (taste and illness) are learned more easily than others, so not just anything is associated with anything.
Exam focus
UCS → UCR; after pairing, CS → CR. Order matters (CS just before UCS).
Emotions can be conditioned (Little Albert); counterconditioning treats fears.
Taste aversion: one-trial learning and biological preparedness (Garcia and Koelling). Habituation is not classical conditioning.
Practice
A cat comes running to the sound of an electric can opener. Identify the CS, UCS, UCR, and CR.
Show answer
CS: the can opener sound. UCS: the food. UCR: running to the food (and excitement). CR: running when the sound is heard.
What is the difference between extinction and spontaneous recovery?
Show answer
Extinction is the fading of the CR when the CS is presented without the UCS; spontaneous recovery is the reappearance of the CR after a rest when the CS is presented again.
Why was the Little Albert study ethically problematic?
Show answer
The infant was deliberately made fearful, the fear was not removed, and the procedure would not meet current standards for informed consent and protection from harm.
How do taste aversions challenge the idea that any stimuli can be paired equally well?
Show answer
Rats associated taste with illness but not lights and sounds with illness, showing biological preparedness; they also learned after one trial, with a long delay.
What is higher-order conditioning? Give an example.
Show answer
A CS is used as if it were a UCS to condition a new stimulus. After a tone predicts food, pairing a light with the tone can make the light trigger salivation.
How is habituation different from classical conditioning?
Show answer
Habituation is a decreased response to a repeated stimulus and does not require an association between two stimuli.
Operant conditioning: reinforcement and punishment
Classical conditioning explains how we learn what goes with what. But much of everyday learning is about what happens after we act: a child learns to say "please" because it gets a cookie, a student studies because it brings good grades, and a driver slows down after a speeding ticket. Operant conditioning is learning in which behavior is changed by its consequences. This lesson covers the central ideas: the law of effect, the four kinds of consequences (the most tested vocabulary in this unit, and easy to mix up), shaping, and some surprising findings, such as superstition and learned helplessness. The next lesson covers the timing of reinforcement.
Required content · 3.8.A
Learning objective.
3.8.A. Explain how operant conditioning applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.8.A.1. Operant conditioning focuses on associating consequences (reinforcement and punishment) with behaviors. The Law of Effect states that behaviors with reinforcing consequences are more likely to be repeated while behaviors with punishing consequences are not as likely to be repeated.
3.8.A.2. Reinforcement and punishment can be positive or negative. Reinforcers can be primary or secondary. Reinforcement discrimination and generalization have been demonstrated in studies of operant conditioning.
3.8.A.3. Reinforcement can be used to shape behavior (“shaping”) gradually through rewarding successive approximations of the desired behavior. Research with animals shows that only certain behaviors can be shaped through reinforcement (known as instinctive drift).
3.8.A.4. Superstitious behavior occurs when consequences reinforce unrelated behaviors. Learned helplessness occurs when organisms learn that they have no control over their experience of aversive consequences in a given situation. 1.A 3.A 3.B 4.A
The law of effect and Skinner's box
Edward Thorndike put hungry cats in "puzzle boxes" and timed how long they took to escape and reach food. Over many trials, they escaped faster. From this he stated the law of effect: behaviors followed by satisfying consequences are more likely to be repeated, and behaviors followed by unpleasant consequences are less likely to be repeated.
B. F. Skinner extended this work. He built the operant chamber (the "Skinner box"), in which an animal, such as a rat, presses a lever to get food, so that the rate of responding can be recorded precisely. His central claim was that behavior is controlled by its consequences. Classical conditioning involves automatic responses (such as salivating) to a stimulus before the response; operant conditioning involves voluntary behavior, which is shaped by what follows it.
Reinforcement and punishment
A reinforcer is any consequence that makes a behavior more likely. A punisher is any consequence that makes a behavior less likely. Both can involve adding or removing a stimulus, and the words "positive" and "negative" mean adding and taking away, not "good" and "bad."
Add a stimulus (positive)
Remove a stimulus (negative)
Behavior increases (reinforcement)
Positive reinforcement: praise or a treat after a behavior
Negative reinforcement: an unpleasant thing is removed, such as taking a pill to end a headache, or buckling a seat belt to stop the beeping
Behavior decreases (punishment)
Positive punishment: an unpleasant thing is added, such as a speeding ticket
Negative punishment: a pleasant thing is removed, such as losing phone privileges
Common confusions: negative reinforcement is not punishment, since it increases a behavior. The test is: did the behavior go up (reinforcement) or down (punishment), and was something added (positive) or removed (negative)?
Primary reinforcers satisfy a biological need and need no learning (food, water, warmth). Secondary (conditioned) reinforcers gain their power through association with primary ones (money, grades, praise, tokens). Reinforcement can also show generalization and discrimination: an animal reinforced in the presence of a signal (a green light) learns to respond only when the signal is present (discrimination) and may also respond to similar signals (generalization).
Punishment has drawbacks as a way to control behavior: it tells a person what not to do and does not teach what to do instead; its effects can be temporary; it can produce fear, anger, or avoidance of the person who punishes; and physical punishment can model aggression (Lesson 3.11). Research tends to favor reinforcing the behavior you want.
Shaping
How do you train a behavior that the animal never does by itself, like a dog rolling over? Shaping reinforces successive approximations: first reward any movement toward the goal, then only closer and closer versions, until the full behavior appears. Animal trainers and teachers use this method. But animals do not learn everything equally: Keller and Marian Breland found that animals trained with food for unusual tasks (such as raccoons putting coins in a bank) drifted back toward their natural food-related behaviors, such as rubbing the coins together. This is instinctive drift, and it shows that biology limits which behaviors can be shaped.
Superstition and learned helplessness
Superstitious behavior appears when a consequence reinforces an unrelated behavior. Skinner delivered food to pigeons at regular intervals regardless of what they did; many pigeons repeated whatever they had been doing when the food last came, such as turning in circles. People show the same pattern, such as wearing a "lucky" shirt for a game that was won.
Learned helplessness occurs when organisms learn that they have no control over aversive events, and then stop trying to escape even when escape becomes possible.
Study spotlight · Learned helplessness (Seligman and Maier, 1967)
Martin Seligman and Steven Maier gave dogs mild electric shocks in a harness. One group could stop the shock by pressing a panel with their noses, a second group received the same shocks but could not control them (their shocks stopped when the first group's dogs pressed), and a third group received no shocks. Later, all the dogs were put in a box where they could escape the shock by jumping over a low barrier. Dogs who had control, and those who had no shocks, learned to jump. Most of the dogs who had experienced uncontrollable shock just lay down and endured the shocks.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment, and the yoked group provided a control for the amount of shock. It suggests that the lack of control, and not the pain itself, caused the passivity, and the finding has been related to depression in people. A limit is that the dogs were harmed, raising ethical issues about animal research, and generalizing from dogs to people's depression requires caution.
Worked example · Which consequence?
Name the type. (a) A student gets a sticker for finishing homework, and does it more often. (b) A teenager is grounded and stops arguing. (c) A driver wears a seat belt to stop the dinging sound. (d) A child gets time-out and stops hitting.
Step 4, (d) removes access to attention and fun (the child is removed from the activity), behavior decreases: negative punishment.
Worked example · Plan a shaping program
Describe how to teach a rat to press a lever it has never touched.
Step 1, reinforce (with food) any movement toward the lever, such as turning to face it.
Step 2, reinforce only when the rat moves close to the lever, then when it touches it, then when it presses it.
Step 3, each step is a successive approximation that is reinforced and then no longer reinforced as the standard rises.
Step 4, once the rat presses reliably, move to a schedule that reinforces some of the responses (next lesson).
Worked example · Superstition or learned helplessness?
Identify each. (a) A gambler always blows on the dice before a win and has done so ever since. (b) A student who has failed many tests despite effort stops studying even when the teacher offers extra help and the test is easy. (c) A basketball player repeats a pregame ritual because they won the last time.
Step 1, (a) superstitious behavior: a reinforcer followed an unrelated behavior.
Step 2, (b) learned helplessness: the student has learned that effort does not control the outcome, and gives up.
Step 3, (c) superstitious behavior.
Exam focus
Law of effect (Thorndike); operant chamber (Skinner). Voluntary behavior is shaped by consequences.
Positive = add, negative = remove. Reinforcement increases behavior; punishment decreases it. Four combinations.
Primary and secondary reinforcers. Shaping by successive approximations; instinctive drift.
Superstitious behavior; learned helplessness (Seligman and Maier).
Practice
Explain why negative reinforcement is not the same as punishment.
Show answer
Negative reinforcement removes an unpleasant stimulus and increases the behavior; punishment decreases the behavior.
Classify: a child's allowance is taken away after lying, and lying decreases.
Show answer
Negative punishment (something pleasant is removed and the behavior decreases).
What is a secondary reinforcer? Give an example.
Show answer
A stimulus that gains reinforcing power by association with primary reinforcers, such as money or praise.
Describe how shaping works.
Show answer
The trainer reinforces successive approximations of the target behavior, gradually requiring closer matches until the full behavior is performed.
What is instinctive drift and what does it show?
Show answer
Animals trained to perform tasks drift back toward their natural behaviors, showing that biology limits what can be shaped.
What did Seligman and Maier's dogs show about uncontrollable aversive events?
Show answer
Dogs that could not control shocks later failed to escape when it was possible, which shows learned helplessness: the experience of no control made them passive.
A slot machine does not pay off every time you pull the lever, yet people play for hours. A vending machine that fails once to give you a soda gets abandoned by the second try. The difference is the schedule of reinforcement: the rule that determines when a behavior is reinforced. Schedules determine how fast learning occurs, how strong the behavior is, and how long it persists after reinforcement stops. This lesson covers continuous and partial schedules, the four partial schedules and the characteristic graph pattern each produces, and ways to apply them. The exam expects you to identify a schedule from a scenario and to recognize it from a graph.
Required content · 3.8.A
Learning objective.
3.8.A. Explain how operant conditioning applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.8.A.5. The schedule with which reinforcement is delivered can determine the strength of the association between the consequence and the response. The two main types of reinforcement schedules are continuous and partial. Each type of reinforcement behavior can be graphed, resulting in a distinctive pattern on the graph (e.g., fixed-interval schedule produces a scalloped graph).
3.8.A.5.i. Continuous reinforcement schedules deliver reinforcement for each and every correct behavior.
3.8.A.5.ii. The partial reinforcement schedules focus on whether reinforcement is delivered on a time-based schedule (fixed- or variable-interval) or for the number of behaviors performed (fixed- or variable-ratio).
Continuous versus partial reinforcement
Continuous reinforcement reinforces every correct response. Learning is fastest, which makes it best when a new behavior is being acquired (giving a puppy a treat every time it sits). But the behavior also dies out quickly when the reinforcement stops.
Partial (intermittent) reinforcement reinforces only some responses. Learning is slower, but the behavior becomes much more resistant to extinction. This is the partial reinforcement effect. A person who has been reinforced sometimes does not notice that reinforcement has ended as quickly as one who has received it every time.
The four partial schedules
Partial schedules are based on time (interval) or on the number of responses (ratio), and the rule is either fixed (the same each time) or variable (it changes around an average).
Schedule
Rule
Example
Typical pattern
Fixed-ratio (FR)
Reinforcement after a set number of responses
A factory worker is paid for every 10 items assembled
High, steady rate, with a short pause after each reinforcement
Variable-ratio (VR)
Reinforcement after an unpredictable number of responses (an average)
Slot machines, lottery scratch cards
Very high, steady rate, with almost no pauses; most resistant to extinction
Fixed-interval (FI)
Reinforcement for the first response after a set amount of time
A paycheck every two weeks; studying only before scheduled exams
Low rate right after reinforcement and increasing as the time approaches: a scalloped pattern
Variable-interval (VI)
Reinforcement for the first response after an unpredictable amount of time
Checking for text messages; a pop quiz at unpredictable times
Slow, steady rate
Figure 3.3. Idealized cumulative records. Steeper lines mean faster responding. Variable ratio is steepest and steadiest, fixed ratio is steep with a pause after each reinforcement, variable interval is moderate and steady, and fixed interval is scalloped: it speeds up as the next reinforcement approaches.
A useful way to remember: ratio schedules are about how much you do, so responding faster earns more rewards, and rates are higher. Interval schedules are about how much time has passed, so responding faster does not speed up reinforcement, and rates are lower. Variable schedules are unpredictable and so produce steadier behavior than fixed ones, which makes people check constantly.
Applications
Teachers, parents, and trainers use these principles. When teaching a new skill, begin with continuous reinforcement and then shift to a partial schedule so that the behavior persists without constant rewards. Employers use fixed-interval (salary) and fixed-ratio (commissions) schedules. Gambling is built on variable-ratio reinforcement, which helps to explain why it is hard to stop. Behavior modification programs, for example token economies, in which people earn tokens (secondary reinforcers) for desired behavior that can be exchanged for rewards, apply operant principles in classrooms and treatment programs.
Worked example · Identify the schedule
Name the schedule. (a) A salesperson earns a bonus after every 5 sales. (b) A fisher casts a line over and over; a fish bites after an unpredictable number of casts. (c) A student checks mail at 3:00 pm each day, when it is delivered. (d) A teacher gives a pop quiz at random times, so students study a little every night.
Step 1, (a) set number of responses: fixed-ratio.
Step 2, (b) unpredictable number of responses: variable-ratio.
A cumulative record graphs total responses (vertical) over time (horizontal), so a steeper line means a faster rate. Graph A is a steep line with tiny breaks; graph B is a repeating curve that flattens after each reinforcement and then gets steeper; graph C is a moderate, steady line. Match each to a schedule.
Step 1, graph A: a very high, steady rate with almost no pauses: variable-ratio.
Step 2, graph B: the scalloped pattern (a pause, then an accelerating rate toward the next reinforcement): fixed-interval.
Step 4, fixed-ratio would look like a steep line with short flat pauses after each reinforcement.
Worked example · Which schedule resists extinction?
A researcher trains two groups of rats to press a lever. Group 1 gets food for every press (continuous), and Group 2 gets food after an unpredictable number of presses (variable-ratio). After training, food stops. Predict and explain the results.
Step 1, group 1 will stop pressing quickly, because the absence of reinforcement is very noticeable after every press was rewarded.
Step 2, group 2 will keep pressing much longer, because they were used to going unrewarded for many presses and do not detect the change easily.
Step 3, this is the partial reinforcement effect; variable-ratio schedules are the most resistant to extinction.
Step 4, a measurable comparison is the number of responses made before the rat stops, a dependent variable that can be compared across the random groups.
Exam focus
Continuous reinforcement: fastest learning, fastest extinction. Partial: slower learning, more resistant to extinction.
Ratio schedules give higher rates than interval schedules.
Practice
Why does partial reinforcement make behavior more resistant to extinction than continuous reinforcement?
Show answer
With partial reinforcement the organism is used to responses that are not rewarded, so it does not quickly notice that reinforcement has stopped.
A person gets paid $10 for every 20 bracelets made. Which schedule?
Show answer
Fixed-ratio.
Which schedule produces the scalloped pattern and why?
Show answer
Fixed-interval: responding slows right after reinforcement and speeds up as the time for the next reinforcement approaches.
Why are slot machines so compelling in terms of schedules?
Show answer
They use variable-ratio reinforcement: payoffs come after an unpredictable number of plays, producing high, steady responding that is highly resistant to extinction.
A parent wants a child to keep doing chores without constant rewards. Advise a plan.
Show answer
Start with continuous reinforcement while the behavior is learned, then switch to a partial (preferably variable) schedule so the behavior persists.
Compare interval and ratio schedules in terms of how responding affects reinforcement.
Show answer
In ratio schedules reinforcement depends on the number of responses, so faster responding earns more reinforcement; in interval schedules it depends on time, so responding faster does not speed up reinforcement.
Not all learning requires a reward or a pairing with a stimulus. You can learn how to use a vending machine by watching a stranger do it, and a rat in a maze may learn the layout without any food at all. This lesson covers learning that goes beyond the two forms of conditioning: observational (social) learning, where we learn from models, and cognitive learning, where mental processes such as insight and cognitive maps play a role. These ideas helped to move psychology beyond a purely behavioral view and are the basis of influential debates about media and violence.
Required content · 3.9.A, 3.9.B
Learning objectives.
3.9.A. Explain how social learning applies to behavior and mental processes.
3.9.B. Explain how cognitive factors in learning apply to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
3.9.A.1. Social learning theory proposes that learning can occur by observation and does not have to involve personal experience with a consequence (vicarious conditioning). Learning can occur by copying the behavior of models. The more similar a model is, the more likely the behavior is to be learned.
3.9.B.1. Insight learning occurs when the solution to a problem occurs without any association, consequence, or model being present.
3.9.B.2. Latent learning occurs when information is learned without reinforcement but is not immediately evident. Latent learning is often demonstrated by cognitive maps. 1.A 4.B 88
Social learning
Social learning theory, developed by Albert Bandura, proposes that people learn by observation and do not need to experience a consequence themselves. We learn by copying the behavior of models, and we also learn from seeing what happens to the model (vicarious conditioning): a child who sees a sibling praised for sharing is more likely to share, and one who sees a sibling punished for lying is less likely to lie. The more similar the model is to the observer, the more likely the behavior is to be learned. Bandura also identified conditions for observational learning: paying attention to the model, retaining what was seen, being able to reproduce the behavior, and being motivated to do it.
Study spotlight · The Bobo doll experiment (Bandura, Ross, and Ross, 1961)
Preschool children watched an adult play in a room with toys, including an inflatable "Bobo" doll. One group saw the adult attack the doll, hitting it with a mallet and shouting. Another group saw the adult play quietly with other toys and ignore the doll, and a third group saw no adult. Afterward, each child was left alone in a room with the toys, including the doll, and was observed. Children who had seen the aggressive adult imitated the exact actions and words, and were more aggressive than the other groups. Boys imitated more than girls, and children were more likely to copy a same-sex model.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment, so it supports the conclusion that observing aggression can cause imitation in the short term. Limits: the Bobo doll is designed to be hit, so it is not clear that the aggression would transfer to real people; the children were observed immediately; and it is not obvious that the findings generalize to realistic situations outside the laboratory. The study is, however, a basis for research on the effects of violent media.
Prosocial and antisocial models. Models can teach helpful behaviors as well as harmful ones. Observing models who are kind, who cooperate, or who resolve conflicts peacefully encourages similar behavior. In the same way, exposure to media violence is associated with higher aggression, though the size of the effect is debated, and, since most studies are correlational, other variables may contribute. Bandura's work also led to the concept of self-efficacy, the belief in one's own ability to succeed.
Cognitive factors in learning
Some learning cannot be explained by association or consequences alone, and it involves mental processes.
Insight learning occurs when the solution to a problem appears suddenly, without any association, consequence, or model. Wolfgang Köhler placed a chimpanzee named Sultan in a cage with bananas out of reach and sticks inside. After some time spent without success, Sultan seemed to pause and then joined two sticks together to reach the fruit. This "aha" moment suggests that the animal restructured the problem mentally. Humans experience insight when a solution suddenly "clicks."
Latent learning is learning that occurs without reinforcement and is not obvious until there is a reason to use it. It is often demonstrated by a cognitive map, a mental representation of the layout of a place.
Study spotlight · Latent learning in rats (Tolman and Honzik, 1930)
Edward Tolman and C. H. Honzik ran three groups of rats through a maze for several days. Group 1 always found food at the end. Group 2 never found food. Group 3 found no food for the first 10 days and then began to find food on day 11. Group 1's errors fell steadily. Group 2's stayed high. Group 3's errors were high until food was introduced, and then they dropped sharply on the next day, to the level of Group 1, or below.
Reading the research: a controlled experiment comparing groups. Group 3 must have learned the layout of the maze during the earlier trials, even though nothing reinforced it. The learning was hidden (latent) until there was an incentive to show it. This challenged the strict behaviorist view that learning requires reinforcement and supported the idea of a cognitive map. A limit is that the rats' maze may not reflect how humans learn spatial layouts.
Worked example · Social learning or conditioning?
Classify. (a) A child watches an older sibling get a cookie for cleaning a room and then cleans their own room. (b) A dog salivates at the sound of a can opener. (c) A rat presses a lever for food. (d) A teenager begins to smoke after seeing admired older students do so.
Step 1, (a) social learning by vicarious reinforcement: the child did not receive the reward.
Step 2, (b) classical conditioning.
Step 3, (c) operant conditioning.
Step 4, (d) social learning, with imitation of models that the teen admires and sees as similar.
Worked example · Interpret the latent learning data
In the Tolman and Honzik design, the average number of errors on day 12 is Group 1: 4, Group 2: 9, Group 3: 4. Interpret, using the fact that Group 3 was only rewarded from day 11.
Step 1, Group 3 made as few errors as Group 1 after being rewarded for a single day.
Step 2, they could only do so if they had already learned the maze, during the 10 unrewarded days, so the learning was latent.
Step 3, Group 2 (never rewarded) made many errors, which shows that without incentive, the knowledge was not used.
Step 4, cognitive map: the rats must have built a mental representation of the maze.
Worked example · Evaluate a media violence claim
A news story says that a study found a correlation of +0.20 between hours of violent video games and aggressive behavior in teenagers, and concludes that "violent games cause aggression." Evaluate.
Step 1, the correlation of +0.20 is positive and weak: more play is slightly associated with more aggression.
Step 2, correlational design: it cannot show that games cause aggression. Teens who are already aggressive may choose violent games (reverse direction), or a third variable such as family environment may affect both.
Step 3, Bandura's experiments support a causal effect of observing aggression in a lab, in the short term, which makes the claim plausible but not proven for games.
Step 4, a defensible claim: "Violent game play is weakly associated with aggression; experimental evidence suggests observing violence can increase imitation in the short term."
Exam focus
Social learning (Bandura): observation and imitation of models; vicarious conditioning; similar models are copied more. Bobo doll study.
Insight learning (Köhler): sudden solution. Latent learning and cognitive maps (Tolman and Honzik).
Correlational research on media violence cannot prove cause.
Practice
What is vicarious conditioning?
Show answer
Learning by observing the consequences that a model receives, without personally experiencing them.
In the Bobo doll study, what was the independent variable and what was the dependent variable?
Show answer
Independent: the type of model the child saw (aggressive, nonaggressive, or none). Dependent: the child's aggressive behavior toward the doll afterward.
Why is the Bobo doll study criticized?
Show answer
The doll is made to be hit, so the aggression may not be comparable to harming a real person; the children were observed only briefly in a laboratory.
How did Köhler's chimpanzee study show insight?
Show answer
The chimpanzee solved the problem suddenly (joining sticks) after a pause, without trial and error or reinforcement for the steps.
What does Group 3's result in the maze study show about learning?
Show answer
The rats had learned the maze without reinforcement (latent learning), and showed it only when rewarded, so they must have formed a cognitive map.
Why can't a correlation between violent media and aggression prove that media cause aggression?
Show answer
The direction of the relationship could be reversed, or a third variable might explain both, since the design does not manipulate exposure.
Unit 3 review · 10 multiple-choice
Unit 3 review: Development and Learning
Ten questions in the three styles the exam uses (concept application, data analysis, and scientific investigation) one drawn from each lesson in the unit; click an option to see why that choice is right or wrong.
Multiple choice
Described study
To study how memory for names changes with age, researchers recruit 90 volunteers in three groups: 30 people aged 20 to 29, 30 aged 50 to 59, and 30 aged 75 to 84. All are tested on the same afternoon in the same room. Each learns twenty face-and-name pairs and is tested ten minutes later. The mean number of names recalled is 14.2 in the youngest group, 11.6 in the middle group, and 8.3 in the oldest group. The researchers conclude that memory for names declines with age.
Which feature of this design most limits that conclusion?
A ten-minute delay limits what the study can say about long-term retention, but every group faced the same delay. A feature shared by all three conditions cannot explain the differences among them.
Cross-sectional designs compare different people at a single moment, so everything that separates someone born in 1945 from someone born in 2000 travels with the age difference. A longitudinal or sequential design is what pulls age and cohort apart.
Thirty per group is a workable sample for a comparison of this kind, and the reported differences are large. Sample size affects how precise an estimate is; it is not the structural problem in this design.
Participants cannot be randomly assigned to an age: age is a participant variable, not something a researcher can hand out. That is exactly why developmental research so often has to settle for quasi-experimental comparisons.
Jonas, 16, can explain in detail why texting while driving is dangerous and scores well on the written portion of his driving test. With three friends in the car on a Friday night, he texts anyway. Which of the following best explains the gap between what he knows and what he does?
The developmental mismatch is the point. Reasoning about risk is fully available to him, the written test proves it, but the systems that make a reward feel urgent, particularly a social reward, come online years before the frontal machinery that brakes them.
Formal operational reasoning is precisely what he demonstrates when he explains the danger and passes the written test. His difficulty is not thinking about hypotheticals; it is which system wins in the moment.
Synaptic pruning begins in early childhood and continues prominently through adolescence, so it is not a process still waiting to start. The raw number of synapses is not what settles a single decision either.
The personal fable, the sense of being uniquely protected, is a real feature of adolescent egocentrism and may well contribute here. But "literally unable to perceive" overstates it: he perceives the risk and discounts it, which is the distinction this item is testing.
Described study
A gender-role inventory built in the early 1970s was scored from ratings by American undergraduates of how desirable each of hundreds of traits was for a man, or for a woman, in their society. Twenty traits rated far more desirable for men, twenty far more desirable for women, and twenty rated neutral became the scale. A researcher now administers that inventory, with its original scoring key, to 800 undergraduates at the same university and finds that far fewer students score in the masculine range than the original norms recorded.
Which interpretation of the new result is most defensible?
This treats the scale as a fixed yardstick, when the yardstick itself was built out of one era's ratings. A trait that counted as masculine in 1974 may simply no longer be sorted that way, which would move scores without anyone changing at all.
Test-retest reliability concerns whether the same people score similarly across a short interval, not whether two different samples fifty years apart score alike. Genuine change over decades is not evidence that a measure is inconsistent.
Neither sample was drawn randomly from all adults, yet comparing two student samples from the same university is still informative. The caution belongs on what the scale's norms mean, not on whether any comparison can be made.
This is the limitation the exam expects you to name for scale-construction and survey research: the norms are cultural data. The result is genuinely interesting and genuinely ambiguous between a change in people and a change in what the culture codes as masculine, and this design cannot separate the two.
A five-year-old watches as ten pennies in a tight row are spread out into a longer row. He counts ten pennies before the change and ten after it, then insists the longer row now has more. Which of the following best describes his reasoning?
Object permanence, knowing a hidden object still exists, is typically in place before a child's second birthday, and these pennies were never hidden. He can see all ten of them the entire time.
Accommodation means changing a schema when new information will not fit it, which is the thing he is failing to do. He is assimilating the spread-out row to a rule he already holds: longer looks like more.
Conservation is the understanding that quantity is unchanged by a change in appearance. Centering on a single dimension and being unable to mentally undo the transformation are the two limits Piaget identified, and both show in his answer even though his counting is accurate.
Egocentrism is difficulty taking another person's perspective, as when a child hides by covering his own eyes. Nothing in this task turns on what he believes the adult can see.
At two, Lena said "I ran" and "two mice." At three and a half she says "I runned" and "two mouses." Her grandfather worries that her language is going backwards. Which of the following is the best response?
Telegraphic speech is the two-word stage, "want cookie," "Daddy go", in which endings and function words are missing altogether. Lena is adding endings, not dropping them.
Earlier, "ran" and "mice" were whole items copied from adults. Now she has abstracted the rules (add -ed, add -s), and applies them everywhere, including where English is irregular. The error is the evidence for the rule, which is why it appears after the correct forms rather than before them.
Critical and sensitive periods describe windows during which experience has an outsized effect, such as the early years for a first language. The label does not explain why one particular error emerges, and "they disappear on their own" is not a mechanism.
She produces both the -ed and the -s ending accurately, so articulation is not the problem, and she says "runned" rather than mispronouncing "ran." The error is grammatical, not phonological.
Data: 100 one-year-olds observed in a laboratory playroom through a standard sequence of separations from and reunions with a caregiver. Trained coders classified each infant's reunion behavior and recorded two timed measures.
Classification
Secure
Avoidant
Resistant
Number of infants
65
21
14
Mean seconds exploring while caregiver present
142
118
63
Mean seconds of contact-seeking at reunion
38
9
165
A reader concludes from the table that the avoidant infants were the least distressed by the separation. Which response is best supported by the data?
Contact-seeking is a behavior, not a feeling, and the whole point of an operational definition is that the two are not interchangeable. An infant can be highly aroused and still not approach the caregiver.
Exploration while the caregiver is present speaks to whether the infant uses her as a secure base, and it is measured before the separation even happens. It cannot establish what the separation did.
The table shows resistant infants exploring the least, at 63 seconds, with avoidant infants at 118. That column does not contradict the reader's claim: it simply does not address it.
This is a "what the data do not show" item, and the answer sits in the row labels. Neither timed measure records separation distress, so the reader has quietly swapped a coded reunion behavior for an internal state the study never measured.
A patient who is receiving chemotherapy eats a lemon drop in the waiting room before each infusion. The drug reliably causes nausea a few hours later. After four rounds, the smell of lemon alone makes her feel sick. In this example, what is the conditioned stimulus?
Nausea produced directly by the drug is the unconditioned response: an automatic reaction that required no learning. A response is never a stimulus in this scheme, so it cannot be the conditioned stimulus.
The lemon was neutral before the pairings and now triggers the reaction on its own, which is the definition of a conditioned stimulus. Taste aversions like this one form remarkably fast, often after a single pairing, because organisms are biologically prepared to link flavors with illness.
The drug is the unconditioned stimulus: it produces nausea with no learning history at all. Confusing the unconditioned stimulus with the conditioned stimulus is the most common error on these items, and the test is always which one was neutral to begin with.
Her queasiness at the smell of lemon is the conditioned response: the learned reaction to the conditioned stimulus. It looks much like the unconditioned response, but it is triggered by the signal rather than by the drug.
Priya checks her email roughly every four minutes throughout the day. Messages she cares about arrive a few times a day at unpredictable times, and checking more often does not make one arrive any sooner. Which reinforcement schedule best describes her checking?
A fixed-ratio schedule pays off after a set number of responses (every tenth sale, every fifth punch on a coffee card), and produces a burst-and-pause pattern. Nothing in the stem counts her checks.
Variable-ratio is the slot-machine schedule, where responding faster genuinely earns more payoffs. The stem rules it out directly: checking more often does not make a message arrive sooner, so the reward is not tied to her response count.
The question that separates these schedules is whether time or responses control availability. A message becomes available as time passes, and her checks matter only in that one of them eventually finds a waiting message: the signature of a variable-interval schedule, which produces a steady, moderate rate of responding.
Fixed-interval means reinforcement becomes available after a set amount of time, which produces the scalloped pattern of a student who studies harder as a weekly quiz approaches. Her messages arrive unpredictably, so the interval is variable rather than fixed.
Data: described bar graph. Preschoolers who already chose to draw during free play were randomly assigned to three conditions. In the expected-reward condition each child was promised a certificate for drawing; in the unexpected-reward condition each child received the same certificate afterward with no prior promise; in the no-reward condition no certificate was mentioned or given.
The vertical axis is the percentage of free-play time spent drawing, running from 0 to 25%, and the horizontal axis has three pairs of bars, one pair per condition. The lighter bar in each pair is the baseline measured before the conditions began and the darker bar is the measurement taken two weeks afterward, with no certificates available. Expected reward: baseline 17%, follow-up 9%. Unexpected reward: baseline 17%, follow-up 17%. No reward: baseline 16%, follow-up 18%.
Which conclusion is best supported by the graph?
The comparison that matters is expectation, not reward: both rewarded groups received the identical certificate, and only the group promised it beforehand dropped. That isolates the mechanism: a promised reward supplies an external reason for an activity the child was already choosing freely.
The unexpected-reward group received a certificate and stayed at 17%. Since one rewarded group declined and the other did not, "rewards reduce motivation" is contradicted by the graph's own data.
A two-point move from 16% to 18% in a group where nothing was done is the size of change that ordinary variation produces. Reading it as an effect of withholding rewards treats noise as a finding.
If the certificate were simply too small a reward, the unexpected-reward group, which received exactly the same certificate, should have declined as well. It did not, so the value of the reward cannot be what separates the groups.
Data: four studies of the same tutoring program, each measuring the same 100-point reading test. Within-group standard deviations were about 10 points in all four studies.
Study
1
2
3
4
Participants (n)
40
1,200
60
2,400
Mean difference (points)
8.2
1.8
4.5
0.5
Cohen's d
0.82
0.18
0.45
0.05
p
.01
.002
.09
.22
Which statement is best supported by the table?
A p-value answers a different question from an effect size: how surprising this result would be if nothing were going on, given this sample size. With 1,200 participants even a d of 0.18 clears any conventional threshold, while the effect itself is the second smallest in the table.
A p-value above .05 means the result did not reach the conventional threshold, not that the effect is zero. Study 3's d of 0.45 is a moderate difference measured with only 60 participants, so the honest reading is "underpowered," not "no effect."
Study 1 pairs the largest d with the smallest sample, which is exactly the combination that should slow you down. With 40 participants the estimate is imprecise, and publication bias means the literature over-represents large effects that came from small samples.
Dividing the mean difference by the standard deviation is what makes the four studies comparable: 1.8 points on a scale with a standard deviation of 10 is d = 0.18, a gap most students would never notice. This is the practical-versus-statistical significance distinction the exam tests, and the fix is to read d before you read p.
Social psychology asks how the real or imagined presence of other people shapes what we think, feel, and do. It begins with a very basic mental activity: explaining behavior. When a driver cuts you off, when a friend forgets your birthday, or when you fail a test, you ask "why?" The answer you give shapes your emotions and your response: you may be angry at the "jerk," or sympathetic to a stressed-out person, or determined to study harder. This lesson covers attribution theory, the predictable patterns and errors in how people explain behavior, explanatory style, and locus of control, which concerns how much people believe they control their lives.
Required content · 4.1.A
Learning objective.
4.1.A. Explain how attribution theory applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.1.A.1. Attributions are how people explain behavior and mental processes of themselves and others. Dispositional attributions relate to internal qualities of others (such as intelligence or personality) while situational attributions relate to external circumstances that are experienced.
4.1.A.2. People demonstrate a predictable pattern of attributions called explanatory style. Explanatory style is how people explain good and bad events in their lives and in the lives of others. Explanatory style can be optimistic or pessimistic.
4.1.A.3. People are subject to biases in their attributions. Those biases include actor/observer bias, fundamental attribution error, and self-serving bias, all of which can affect behavior and mental processes.
Attributions: dispositional and situational
An attribution is an explanation for the cause of behavior or events, one's own or other people's. Fritz Heider proposed that people sort causes into two kinds:
A dispositional attribution explains behavior by internal qualities of the person: personality, intelligence, attitudes, or effort ("he's lazy," "she's smart").
A situational attribution explains behavior by external circumstances: the task, other people, luck, or the environment ("traffic was heavy," "the test was unfair").
The same event can be explained in either way. A student who is late may be seen as irresponsible (dispositional) or as delayed by a bus breakdown (situational).
Predictable biases in attribution
People do not choose attributions at random; they show systematic errors.
Fundamental attribution error (FAE): the tendency, when explaining other people's behavior, to overestimate dispositional causes and underestimate situational ones. If a classmate stumbles into a room late, you may think "careless," ignoring the situation. The FAE appears more strongly in individualistic cultures than in collectivist ones.
Actor-observer bias: the tendency to explain your own behavior with situational causes, but other people's with dispositional causes. "I was late because of traffic; you were late because you are disorganized." The "actor" sees the situation, while the "observer" sees the person.
Self-serving bias: the tendency to take credit for successes (dispositional: "I worked hard") and blame failures on the situation ("the test was unfair"). It protects self-esteem. A mild form of it is common, though people who are depressed sometimes show the reverse.
Study spotlight · The attitude-essay study (Jones and Harris, 1967)
Edward Jones and Victor Harris had participants read a student's essay about Fidel Castro's Cuba, which was either supportive or critical of Castro. Some participants were told that the writer had freely chosen the position, and others were told that the writer had been assigned the position by a professor. When the writer chose freely, participants inferred that the writer's attitude matched the essay. But even when told that the writer had no choice, participants still rated the writer as having a pro-Castro attitude if the essay was pro-Castro, though less strongly.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to the choice condition. The persistence of dispositional attributions despite a clear situational cause is the fundamental attribution error. The participants were college students in one country, and the topic was political, so the results may not apply to all kinds of behavior or cultures, but the effect has been replicated many times.
Explanatory style
Beyond individual events, people show a habitual way of explaining good and bad events, called explanatory style. Martin Seligman identified three dimensions. An optimistic explanatory style explains bad events as external (not caused by me), unstable (temporary), and specific (limited to this situation), and good events as internal, stable, and global ("I failed this test because it was hard and I was sick; next time will be different"). A pessimistic explanatory style explains bad events as internal, stable, and global ("I failed because I'm stupid and I always fail at everything"). A pessimistic style is associated with depression, lower achievement, and poorer health, and it is related to learned helplessness (Lesson 3.9). Because explanatory style is a habit of thinking, cognitive therapies teach people to change it.
Locus of control
Julian Rotter proposed that people differ in locus of control, their general belief about what controls the outcomes in their lives.
People with an internal locus of control believe that their own actions and efforts determine outcomes ("I got the grade because I studied").
People with an external locus of control believe that outcomes are controlled by outside forces such as luck, fate, or powerful other people ("I got the grade because the teacher likes me," or "it was just luck").
An internal locus of control is associated, on average, with greater persistence, better school achievement, and better health behavior, and with less stress. However, an extreme belief that you control everything can lead to self-blame when bad things happen that are not your fault. Locus of control is related to attributions: a person with an internal locus tends to make internal attributions for outcomes. Cultures also differ: people in some collectivist cultures see more outcomes as shaped by the group or circumstances.
Worked example · Classify the attribution
Classify each. (a) "She failed the test because she didn't study." (b) "He failed because the test was unfairly hard." (c) "The cashier was rude because she is a mean person." (d) "I was rude to the cashier because I had a bad day."
Step 1, (a) dispositional (effort).
Step 2, (b) situational (the test).
Step 3, (c) dispositional, a possible fundamental attribution error if the situation (a stressful day, a long shift) is ignored.
Step 4, (d) situational. Notice that (c) and (d) together are the actor-observer bias: when it is my own rudeness, I blame the situation; when it is someone else's, I blame the person.
Worked example · Which bias?
Name the bias. (a) A student who gets an A says, "I'm a great student." The same student who gets a D says, "The teacher is a bad grader." (b) A coach concludes that a player who missed practice is "irresponsible," not knowing the player's car broke down. (c) A man says that he spilled coffee because the floor was slippery, but says that a coworker who spilled coffee was "clumsy."
Step 1, (a) self-serving bias: success is credited to the self, failure to the situation.
Step 2, (b) fundamental attribution error: a dispositional explanation of someone else's behavior that ignores the situation.
Step 3, (c) actor-observer bias: situational for self, dispositional for others.
Worked example · Explanatory style and locus of control
After failing a driving test, two people respond. Rita says, "I messed up because it was raining hard, and the examiner was hurried. I'll do better next time." Sam says, "I'm a terrible driver. I'll never pass anything." Describe each person's explanatory style, and predict what each may do next.
Step 1, Rita attributes the failure to external (rain), unstable (this time only), and specific (this test) factors: an optimistic explanatory style.
Step 2, Sam attributes it to internal (me), stable (never), and global (anything) causes: a pessimistic explanatory style.
Step 3, prediction: Rita is likely to try again and persist. Sam is more likely to give up and feel depressed. This links to learned helplessness.
Step 4, a cognitive approach could help Sam question the permanent and global parts of his explanation.
Exam focus
Dispositional (internal) versus situational (external) attributions.
Biases: fundamental attribution error, actor-observer bias, self-serving bias.
Locus of control (Rotter): internal versus external.
Practice
Define fundamental attribution error and give an example.
Show answer
The tendency to overestimate dispositional causes and underestimate situational ones when explaining other people's behavior, such as assuming a late person is irresponsible without considering traffic.
How does actor-observer bias differ from self-serving bias?
Show answer
Actor-observer bias is explaining my behavior by the situation and others' by their dispositions; self-serving bias is taking credit for successes and blaming failures on the situation.
Describe a pessimistic explanatory style.
Show answer
Explaining bad events as caused by internal, stable, and global factors ("it's my fault, it will always be this way, and it affects everything").
A student says, "I did well because I studied hard." Is this an internal or external locus of control?
Show answer
Internal.
Why is the Jones and Harris study evidence for the fundamental attribution error?
Show answer
Participants attributed the essay's position to the writer's attitude even when they knew the position was assigned, so they underweighted the situation.
Why might the fundamental attribution error be less strong in some collectivist cultures?
Show answer
These cultures often emphasize context and relationships, so people more readily consider situational causes of behavior.
We form impressions of other people in seconds, and these impressions affect whom we like, whom we hire, and even how we behave. Person perception is the process of forming impressions of and making judgments about other people, and of ourselves. This lesson covers four ideas that the exam tests: the mere exposure effect, the self-fulfilling prophecy, social comparison, and relative deprivation. Each shows that perception is not a mirror: our beliefs and our social context shape what we see and can even change the reality we are observing.
Required content · 4.1.C
Learning objective.
4.1.C. Explain how person perception applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.1.C.1. People’s perception of how much they like something can be influenced by the mere exposure effect. The mere exposure effect occurs when people are exposed to a stimulus repeatedly over time, which causes them to like the stimulus more. 1.B 2.B 2.C 4.A 96
4.1.C.2. People can behave in ways that elicit behaviors from others that confirm their beliefs or perceptions about themselves or others (self-fulfilling prophecy).
4.1.C.3. Social comparison is a type of person perception that occurs when people evaluate themselves based on comparisons to other members of society or social circles. Social comparison can be upward or downward. People often judge their own sense of deprivation relative to others (relative deprivation).
The mere exposure effect
The mere exposure effect is the tendency to like a stimulus more simply because we have been exposed to it repeatedly. It applies to faces, songs, words, brands, and even your own face in a mirror (people tend to prefer the mirror image of their face, the one they have seen most often, while friends prefer the true image). It helps to explain why advertisers repeat messages and why we often grow fonder of a song after hearing it a few times. The effect works best for stimuli that are neutral or mildly positive at first, and with a limited number of repetitions; a stimulus that is disliked does not become liked, and too much repetition can produce boredom.
Study spotlight · Mere exposure to faces (Zajonc, 1968; Moreland and Beach, 1992)
Robert Zajonc showed participants photographs of faces, nonsense words, and Chinese characters, shown 0, 1, 2, 5, 10, or 25 times. Later, participants rated how much they liked each. The more often a stimulus had been shown, the more positively it was rated. In a classroom field study, Moreland and Beach had four women who looked similar attend a large lecture class different numbers of times (0, 5, 10, or 15 class sessions) without interacting with anyone. At the end of the semester, students who saw photos of the four women rated those who had attended more often as more attractive, more likable, and more similar to themselves, although the students were unaware of their different exposure.
Reading the research: an experiment with a manipulated independent variable (number of exposures). The field study shows that the effect occurs outside the laboratory, but it used a small number of confederates and a single class, so its generalizability is limited. The effect works even when people cannot recall the exposures, which suggests it can operate outside conscious awareness.
Self-fulfilling prophecy
A self-fulfilling prophecy occurs when a person's expectation about someone causes that person to behave in ways that make the expectation come true. A teacher who expects a student to struggle may give him less attention and challenge, and the student may do poorly; an employer who expects a trainee to excel may invest more, and the trainee excels. Notice the chain: expectation, behavior of the perceiver, behavior of the target, confirmation. The expectation was not necessarily true in the beginning.
Study spotlight · The Pygmalion study (Rosenthal and Jacobson, 1968)
Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson gave elementary school students a test and told teachers that it identified children who were about to "bloom" intellectually. In fact, the researchers chose about 20 percent of the children at random. At the end of the year, the "bloomers" (especially in the first and second grades) showed larger gains in IQ than the other children, even though they had been selected randomly.
Reading the research: a field experiment with random assignment of the expectation, which supports the claim that teachers' expectations can affect student performance. It also has limits: the effect was found mainly in the youngest grades, some researchers could not replicate it, and the results do not show exactly how the teachers' behavior changed. Later reviews find that the effect exists but is smaller and not universal.
Social comparison and relative deprivation
Social comparison is evaluating oneself by comparing with other people. Leon Festinger proposed that we do this to judge our abilities and opinions when no objective standard exists.
Upward social comparison compares yourself with someone who is better off or more skilled. It can motivate you, but it can also make you feel inadequate.
Downward social comparison compares yourself with someone who is worse off. It can make you feel better about yourself, but may reduce motivation.
Social media offers constant comparison, and research finds that heavy use of it is often associated with lower well-being when people compare themselves with idealized images, though the evidence is mostly correlational.
Relative deprivation is the perception that you are worse off than others to whom you compare yourself. It depends on the comparison group, not on your objective circumstances: a person with a comfortable income may feel deprived if neighbors are richer, and a person with less may feel content among those with similar means. Relative deprivation can lead to resentment and has been used to explain some social unrest.
Worked example · Identify the concept
Name the concept. (a) A student notices she likes a song more after hearing it on the radio many times. (b) A coach expects a new player to be weak, gives him few chances, and he plays poorly. (c) A runner compares her time with an elite athlete's and feels discouraged. (d) A family earning $60,000 feels poor because their neighbors earn $200,000.
Step 1, (a) mere exposure effect.
Step 2, (b) self-fulfilling prophecy.
Step 3, (c) upward social comparison.
Step 4, (d) relative deprivation: feeling worse off compared with a reference group.
Worked example · Analyze the Pygmalion design
In a Pygmalion-style experiment, 100 students are randomly assigned to be labeled "bloomers" (n = 20) or "controls" (n = 80). At the end of the year, bloomers gained 12 IQ points on average and the controls gained 8. Interpret.
Step 1, the independent variable is the label given to the teacher (bloomer or not); the dependent variable is IQ gain.
Step 2, the difference is \(12-8=4\) points in favor of the bloomers.
Step 3, because assignment to the label was random, the groups were equivalent at the start, so the difference can be attributed to the teacher's expectations.
Step 4, to claim that it is statistically significant, the researchers would also need to know the variability of the scores and test the difference; and the effect may not generalize to older students.
Worked example · Apply to a scenario
A manager believes that new employees from a certain university are lazy. He gives them boring tasks and little feedback. Over time they become disengaged, and he says, "See, I was right." Explain, and suggest a way to break the cycle.
Step 1, a self-fulfilling prophecy: the expectation (lazy) changed his behavior (boring tasks, no feedback), which changed the employees' behavior (disengagement), which confirmed the expectation.
Step 2, the manager also shows a dispositional attribution and ignores the situational cause (his own treatment).
Step 3, break the cycle: treat new employees equally, give the same challenging work, and judge them on their performance records.
Exam focus
Mere exposure effect: repeated exposure increases liking (Zajonc).
Self-fulfilling prophecy: expectations change behavior and bring about the expected outcome (Rosenthal and Jacobson).
Social comparison: upward or downward. Relative deprivation: feeling worse off than a reference group.
Practice
Describe the mere exposure effect and a practical application.
Show answer
Repeated exposure to a stimulus makes people like it more; advertisers repeat their messages to build liking.
Explain how a self-fulfilling prophecy works, step by step.
Show answer
A person holds an expectation about someone, behaves in a way that is consistent with it, the other person responds by behaving in line with the expectation, and the expectation appears confirmed.
What was the independent variable in the Rosenthal and Jacobson study?
Show answer
What teachers were told about the students (that some were expected to "bloom").
Give an example of downward social comparison and one possible effect.
Show answer
Comparing your grade with a classmate who did worse; it may make you feel better about yourself, but reduce your motivation to improve.
How can relative deprivation occur even when a person's income is high?
Show answer
It depends on the comparison group; if the person's reference group has much more, they perceive themselves as deprived.
Why can't we conclude from a correlation between social media use and low well-being that social media causes it?
Show answer
The direction could be reversed (unhappy people use more social media) or a third variable may influence both.
An attitude is a learned evaluation of a person, object, idea, or event, which includes feelings, beliefs, and a tendency to act. Attitudes guide behavior, and sometimes behavior changes attitudes. This lesson covers the harmful attitudes that psychology tries to understand (stereotypes, prejudice, and discrimination, including the implicit forms that people may not know they have), then the processes that keep beliefs in place (belief perseverance and confirmation bias) and change them (cognitive dissonance). These topics apply directly to everyday life, and the exam often asks you to apply them to a scenario or to read an experiment.
Required content · 4.2.A, 4.2.B
Learning objectives.
4.2.A. Explain how stereotypes and implicit attitudes contribute to the behaviors and mental processes of prejudice and discrimination.
4.2.B. Explain how belief perseverance and cognitive dissonance apply to attitude formation and change.
Essential knowledge.
4.2.A.1. A stereotype is a generalized concept about a group. Stereotypes can help reduce cognitive load when making decisions or judgments. Stereotypes can be the cause and/or result of biased perceptions and experiences and are frequently the basis of prejudiced attitudes and discriminatory behaviors.
4.2.A.2. Implicit attitudes are those that individuals hold but may be unaware of or may not acknowledge. Research has focused on how implicit attitudes reflect negative evaluations of others, as demonstrated by the just-world phenomenon, out-group homogeneity bias, in-group bias, or ethnocentrism.
4.2.B.1. Belief perseverance occurs when a belief persists even if evidence suggests it is not accurate. People experiencing belief perseverance may engage in confirmation bias, thereby clinging to an attitude or belief regardless of the evidence for or against it.
4.2.B.2. Cognitive dissonance refers to the mental discomfort that occurs when actions or attitudes are in conflict. People are motivated to reduce the discomfort by changing either actions or attitudes to be more in line with each other. 1.B 3.A 3.B 4.B 98
Stereotypes, prejudice, and discrimination
Three terms are often confused. A stereotype is a generalized belief about a group of people (a cognitive component). Prejudice is a negative attitude toward a group and its members (an emotional component). Discrimination is unjustified negative behavior toward a group and its members (a behavioral component). Stereotypes can lead to prejudice, and prejudice can lead to discrimination, though people can hold stereotypes without acting on them.
Why do stereotypes exist? They reduce cognitive load: categorizing people lets the mind make quick judgments with little effort. But they cause errors and harm because they overgeneralize, ignore individual differences, and are often based on biased experiences or media. Stereotypes can be both the cause and the result of biased perceptions: if you expect a group to behave in a certain way, you notice and remember the cases that fit, and you may treat people in ways that bring about the behavior (a self-fulfilling prophecy).
Implicit attitudes and group biases
Implicit attitudes are evaluations that a person holds but may be unaware of or may not acknowledge. They can differ from the attitudes a person reports openly (explicit attitudes). A well-known measurement is the Implicit Association Test (IAT), which measures how quickly people pair concepts (for example, faces of different groups with positive or negative words). Its usefulness for predicting an individual's behavior is debated, and scores can vary from one occasion to the next. Several biases involve negative evaluations of others, and they are worth knowing:
In-group bias: favoring the group you belong to (the "in-group") over groups you do not (the "out-groups"). Even groups formed on trivial grounds, such as a coin toss, show it.
Ethnocentrism: the belief that your own culture or ethnic group is superior and the standard by which others are judged.
Out-group homogeneity bias: the tendency to see members of other groups as more alike than members of your own ("they all look alike," while "we are diverse").
Just-world phenomenon: the belief that the world is fair, so people get what they deserve and deserve what they get. It can lead to blaming victims ("she must have done something to deserve it").
Belief perseverance and confirmation bias
Belief perseverance is the tendency to hold on to a belief even after the evidence for it has been discredited. People who have formed a theory often build explanations for it that persist after the original evidence is removed. Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for and favor information that supports what you already believe and to ignore or discount information that contradicts it. Together they help to explain why stereotypes and false beliefs are so hard to change.
Cognitive dissonance
Leon Festinger proposed that people have a drive for consistency among their thoughts, attitudes, and actions. Cognitive dissonance is the mental discomfort that occurs when your actions and attitudes conflict, or when you hold two conflicting beliefs. Because the discomfort is unpleasant, people are motivated to reduce it, usually by changing an attitude or an action so that they fit together, or by adding a justification. A smoker who knows that smoking causes cancer feels dissonance and may quit (change the action), or decide that "the risk is exaggerated" (change the belief), or add a thought like "it helps me relax" (rationalization).
Study spotlight · Dissonance and a boring task (Festinger and Carlsmith, 1959)
Participants spent an hour doing very dull tasks, such as turning pegs on a board. Afterward, each was asked to tell the next participant, who was waiting, that the tasks had been fun and interesting, which was a lie. One group was paid $1 for the lie, a second group was paid $20, and a control group was not asked to lie. Later, participants rated how enjoyable the tasks had really been. The $1 group rated the tasks as more enjoyable than the $20 group did, and also more than the control group.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to payment. The explanation is that the $20 group had sufficient external justification for lying, so they felt little dissonance. The $1 group had insufficient justification, felt dissonance ("I lied for a dollar"), and reduced it by changing their attitude toward the task. Limits: the sample consisted of college students, and critics have proposed other explanations, but the finding that a small reward produces more attitude change than a large one is robust.
Worked example · Stereotype, prejudice, or discrimination?
Classify. (a) "Teenagers are irresponsible." (b) A person dislikes teenagers and avoids them. (c) A landlord refuses to rent to teenage tenants. (d) A fan believes that all members of the rival school are cheaters.
Step 1, (a) stereotype (belief).
Step 2, (b) prejudice (negative feeling and attitude).
Step 3, (c) discrimination (behavior).
Step 4, (d) stereotype (a belief about a group), and out-group homogeneity bias, since all members are seen as alike.
Worked example · Predict dissonance
Two students are paid to write an essay supporting a tuition increase they oppose. Student A is paid $5 and Student B is paid $100. Predict who will change their attitude more and why.
Step 1, both acted against their attitude, which creates dissonance.
Step 2, Student B has strong external justification ($100), so little dissonance and little reason to change the attitude.
Step 3, Student A has insufficient justification ($5), so more dissonance, and is more likely to reduce it by deciding that the tuition increase is not so bad.
Step 4, this is the same logic as Festinger and Carlsmith: less external reward means more attitude change.
Worked example · Which bias or process?
Identify. (a) After a debate, a voter reads only articles that agree with her views. (b) A student told that his "bloomer" label in an experiment was random still believes he is gifted. (c) A man thinks that a robbery victim "should have been more careful" and must have done something to deserve it. (d) A fan of one team thinks the other team's fans "are all rowdy."
Step 1, (a) confirmation bias.
Step 2, (b) belief perseverance: the belief persists after the evidence is removed.
Cognitive dissonance: discomfort from conflicting actions and attitudes reduces by changing one of them. Less external justification means more change (Festinger and Carlsmith).
Practice
Distinguish prejudice from discrimination.
Show answer
Prejudice is a negative attitude toward a group; discrimination is unjustified negative behavior toward group members.
Why do people use stereotypes, and what is their main problem?
Show answer
They reduce cognitive load by allowing fast judgments, but they overgeneralize and ignore individual differences, leading to biased judgments.
What is the just-world phenomenon and how can it harm victims?
Show answer
The belief that people get what they deserve; it can lead people to blame victims for misfortune.
Why did the $1 participants in Festinger and Carlsmith's study rate the task as more enjoyable than the $20 group?
Show answer
$1 was insufficient justification for lying, so they felt dissonance and reduced it by changing their attitude to believe the task was enjoyable; $20 justified the lie.
How are confirmation bias and belief perseverance related?
Show answer
Confirmation bias is selectively seeking and favoring information that supports one's beliefs, and it helps beliefs persist even after the evidence against them has been presented (belief perseverance).
Give two ways a person might reduce dissonance after buying an expensive item they later regret.
Show answer
Change the attitude (decide it was worth it or has useful features) or change the behavior (return the item).
Social influence: norms, persuasion, conformity, obedience
Why do people wear what others wear, change their answers when everyone disagrees, or agree to requests they would normally refuse? Social situations exert powerful, often unnoticed influence on behavior. This lesson is the first of three on the psychology of social situations. It covers social norms, the two kinds of social influence, persuasion techniques, and the classic experiments on conformity and obedience. These studies are among the most famous in psychology, and they are also important for what they teach about research ethics. The exam expects you to describe each study, identify what increases or decreases the effect, and evaluate its ethics and generalizability.
Required content · 4.3.A
Learning objective.
4.3.A. Explain how the social situation affects behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.3.A.1. Social norms define expectations and roles a society may have for its members in individual and social situations.
4.3.A.2. Social influence theory proposes that social pressure to behave or think in certain ways can be normative or informational.
4.3.A.3. Persuasion refers to the techniques applied to convince the self or others of particular ideas, actions, or beliefs.
4.3.A.3.i. Persuasion can depend on the route to persuasion. The elaboration likelihood model outlines two main routes to persuasion: central and peripheral. The halo effect is an example of a peripheral route to persuasion.
4.3.A.3.ii. Persuasion can depend on how information is presented, as demonstrated by the foot-in-the-door and the door-in-the-face techniques.
4.3.A.4. Research on conformity clarifies the conditions that strengthen the likelihood of people adhering to unspoken rules, norms, or expectations.
4.3.A.5. Research on obedience clarifies the conditions that strengthen the likelihood of people complying with the directives of an authority figure. 1.B 2.D 3.B 4.A 99
Social norms and social influence
Social norms are the expectations about how members of a society or group are supposed to behave, including the roles that people play (student, parent, customer). Norms are often unspoken: no one tells you to face forward in an elevator. Violating them tends to produce discomfort or disapproval.
Social influence is the pressure to behave or think in certain ways. It comes in two kinds:
Normative social influence: going along with the group to be accepted or to avoid rejection ("I want to fit in").
Informational social influence: going along with the group because you believe they have correct information, especially when the situation is uncertain ("they must know").
Persuasion
Persuasion refers to techniques applied to convince oneself or others of an idea, action, or belief. The elaboration likelihood model says that there are two routes:
The central route persuades through careful thinking about the content and quality of the arguments. It works when people are motivated and able to think, and it produces longer-lasting attitude change.
The peripheral route persuades through superficial cues such as the speaker's attractiveness, fame, or the number of arguments, and it works when people are not thinking carefully. The halo effect, the tendency to assume that a person who has one positive trait (such as being attractive) has other positive traits (such as being intelligent and kind), is an example, which is why advertisers use celebrities.
Two techniques that use the way a request is presented:
Foot-in-the-door: first make a small request that people will agree to, then a larger one. People who comply with the small request are more likely to agree to the larger one later, partly because they want to act consistently with their earlier behavior.
Door-in-the-face: first make a very large request that will be refused, then a smaller request. The smaller request now seems reasonable by comparison, and people often agree to it (a concession was made, and they feel obliged to respond with one).
Study spotlight · Foot-in-the-door (Freedman and Fraser, 1966)
Researchers posing as volunteers asked homeowners to put a large, ugly "Drive Carefully" sign in their front yards. Among those who were asked directly, only 17 percent agreed. Other homeowners had been asked two weeks earlier to do a small thing, such as displaying a small sign or signing a petition for safe driving. Of those who agreed to the small request, 76 percent later agreed to the large sign.
Reading the research: a field experiment with different groups of homeowners. It shows that a small initial commitment makes a later, bigger request much more likely to be accepted. A limit is that the effect depends on the kind of small request, and homeowners in one community may not represent everyone.
Conformity
Conformity is adjusting your behavior or thinking to match a group standard.
Study spotlight · Asch's line judgment studies (1951)
Solomon Asch asked college men, in groups, to say which of three comparison lines matched a standard line. The task was easy, and when judging alone, people were almost never wrong. But in the experimental condition, all but one of the group were confederates who, on certain trials, unanimously gave the same wrong answer, with the real participant answering near the end. About 75 percent of the participants conformed to the wrong answer at least once, and across the critical trials about 37 percent of the answers were conforming. About one-quarter never conformed.
Conditions that affected conformity: conformity increased as the group grew up to about three or four confederates, and then leveled off; it dropped sharply when even one confederate disagreed with the majority (the participant had an ally); and it was lower when answers were given privately.
Reading the research: an experiment with a controlled procedure. It showed normative influence, since many participants said they knew the group was wrong, but went along. Limits: the participants were all white male college students in the United States in the 1950s, a time often described as conformist, and the task (judging lines) is artificial. Later studies find lower levels of conformity in the United States in later decades, and higher levels in some collectivist cultures. There was also deception, and participants experienced stress.
Factors that increase conformity: a larger unanimous group, group members with high status, a difficult or ambiguous task (more informational influence), a public (not private) response, and a collectivist culture. A single dissenter strongly reduces it.
Obedience
Obedience is complying with the directives of an authority figure.
Study spotlight · Milgram's obedience experiments (1963)
Stanley Milgram told participants that they were taking part in a study of learning and memory. The participant played the "teacher" and was told to give an electric shock to a "learner" (a confederate who was actually not shocked) each time the learner made a mistake, increasing the voltage with each error, up to 450 volts. As the "shocks" increased, the learner protested, screamed, and eventually fell silent. If the participant hesitated, the experimenter in a lab coat said calmly, "The experiment requires that you continue." In the original version, 65 percent of the participants (26 of 40) went all the way to 450 volts, and all 40 went at least to 300 volts. Many showed great distress.
Variations changed the amount of obedience: it dropped when the experimenter gave orders by telephone, when the study was moved to a run-down office building, when the learner was in the same room, when the teacher had to touch the learner's hand to the plate, and when two other "teachers" refused (allies). It was higher when the participant did not deliver the shock personally.
Reading the research: an experiment with variations of conditions. It showed that ordinary people may obey an authority even when it conflicts with their conscience, which helps explain real-world cases of harm. Ethical criticism is strong: deception, severe stress for participants, and difficulty withdrawing ("you must continue"). Participants were debriefed and most said they were glad they took part, but the study would not be permitted under today's ethical guidelines, which require informed consent, the right to withdraw, and protection from harm. Other criticisms: the sample was limited to men, and participants may have suspected that the shocks were not real.
Worked example · Normative or informational influence?
Identify the type of influence. (a) You are in a new country and copy how others use the subway ticket machine, since you do not know how. (b) A teen starts using slang that all of her friends use, so that she is not left out. (c) In an emergency, the crowd runs in one direction, and you follow, assuming that they know the exit.
Step 1, (a) informational: you believe others have the information.
Step 2, (b) normative: you want to be accepted.
Step 3, (c) informational (and the crowd's behavior signals danger).
Worked example · Peripheral or central route? Foot or door?
Identify. (a) An advertisement shows a famous athlete wearing a brand of shoes. (b) A consumer reads reviews, compares features and prices, and decides. (c) A charity first asks you to sign a petition and then asks you to donate. (d) A neighbor first asks to borrow $500, you say no, and then asks for $20, and you agree.
Step 2, (b) central route (careful thought about the arguments and evidence).
Step 3, (c) foot-in-the-door.
Step 4, (d) door-in-the-face.
Worked example · Evaluate Milgram's data
In a Milgram variation, 20 of 40 participants went to 450 volts when the experimenter was in the room, versus 8 of 40 when the experimenter gave orders by telephone. Compute the percentages and interpret.
Step 1, in the room: \(20\div40=0.50\), or 50%.
Step 2, by telephone: \(8\div40=0.20\), or 20%.
Step 3, the difference is 30 percentage points.
Step 4, interpretation: the physical presence of the authority figure increases obedience, which suggests that the situation, not just the personality of the participants, strongly influences behavior. Because participants were not randomly sampled from the general population, generalizing needs caution.
Exam focus
Norms; normative (to fit in) versus informational (believe others know) influence.
Elaboration likelihood model: central and peripheral routes; halo effect. Foot-in-the-door and door-in-the-face.
Asch: about 75 percent conformed at least once; an ally reduces conformity. Milgram: 65 percent went to 450 volts; authority presence matters. Both raise ethical and generalizability questions.
Practice
Distinguish normative from informational social influence.
Show answer
Normative: conforming to be accepted or avoid rejection. Informational: conforming because you think the group has correct information.
Why is the peripheral route to persuasion less long-lasting?
Show answer
It relies on superficial cues such as attractiveness or fame and not on careful thinking about the arguments, so attitude change is weaker and less durable.
What are two factors that reduced conformity in Asch's studies?
Show answer
The presence of even one other person who disagreed with the majority, and giving answers privately.
What are two reasons Milgram's study is considered unethical?
Show answer
Participants were deceived and experienced severe stress, and the experimenter's prods made it hard for them to withdraw.
Describe a situational variable that decreased obedience in Milgram's variations.
Show answer
The experimenter giving orders by telephone, being in a run-down building, or having other "teachers" who refused all reduced obedience.
Explain why door-in-the-face works.
Show answer
After refusing a big request, the second smaller request seems reasonable by comparison, and people feel pressure to reciprocate the concession.
Being part of a group changes how people think and act. A person who is thoughtful alone may behave differently at a concert, a protest, a team meeting, or a jury. This lesson covers the effects of groups on individual behavior, from performing in front of others to losing individual responsibility, plus the ways groups polarize, how superordinate goals reduce conflict between groups, social traps, culture's influence, and what industrial-organizational psychologists study about work. The studies here are among the most cited in the course, and the vocabulary is closely related, so learn to tell the terms apart by the situation they describe.
Required content · 4.3.B
Learning objective.
4.3.B. Explain how being in a group can affect an individual’s behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.3.B.1. Cultural phenomena such as individualism, collectivism, and multiculturalism can influence how one perceives and behaves towards oneself and others.
4.3.B.2. Being a member of a group can influence how one behaves or experiences mental processes via group polarization, groupthink, diffusion of responsibility, social loafing, and deindividuation.
4.3.B.3. Performing a mental or physical behavior in front of a group can lead to social facilitation.
4.3.B.4. People often overestimate the levels to which others agree with them, known as the false consensus effect.
4.3.B.5. Superordinate goals serve to unite disparate groups under a common goal and help reduce negative affect and stereotyping among groups. Social traps occur when individuals do not unite and act in their own self-interest to the detriment of the group.
4.3.B.6. Industrial-organizational (I/O) psychologists study how people perform in the workplace. I/O psychologists study best practices in management of work, relationships among people working together or for a common company or program, and how people feel about work (burnout).
Individualism is a cultural orientation that gives priority to personal goals, independence, and self-expression over group goals (common in the United States and Western Europe). Collectivism gives priority to the goals of the group (family, community, or nation), harmony, and duty (common in many East Asian, Latin American, and African cultures). These are tendencies, not absolute rules, and individuals within a culture vary. Culture influences how people see themselves (independent versus interdependent self), how they explain behavior, and how much they conform. Multiculturalism is the recognition and valuing of different cultural groups within a society.
How being in a group affects behavior
Social facilitation: performing a task better in the presence of others, when the task is simple or well-learned. Norman Triplett noticed in 1898 that cyclists rode faster when racing against others than when racing against a clock. When the task is difficult or new, the presence of others can make performance worse (Robert Zajonc's explanation: an audience increases arousal, which strengthens the dominant response, which is correct for easy tasks and wrong for hard ones).
Social loafing: the tendency to put forth less effort when working in a group than when working alone, because individual contributions are not identifiable. In tug-of-war and in group projects, people exert less. It is reduced when individual contributions are identified or the group is small and the task is meaningful.
Deindividuation: loss of self-awareness and self-restraint in a group situation that provides anonymity and arousal (a mob, an online forum, wearing a mask or uniform), which can lead to impulsive or antisocial behavior. It can also increase positive behavior if the group norm is positive.
Diffusion of responsibility: the sense that responsibility is shared among everyone present, so that each person feels less responsible to act. It helps to explain the bystander effect (next lesson) and social loafing.
Group polarization: discussion with like-minded people strengthens the group's initial leaning, so group opinions become more extreme than the average of the members' initial views. A group of mildly cautious people may become very cautious, and a group of moderately favorable people becomes strongly favorable. Social media "echo chambers" can intensify it.
Groupthink: a group's desire for harmony and agreement overrides realistic appraisal of alternatives. Irving Janis described it in decisions such as the 1961 Bay of Pigs invasion. Symptoms include an illusion of invulnerability, pressure on dissenters, self-censorship, and an illusion of unanimity. It can be reduced by encouraging dissent, appointing a devil's advocate, and seeking outside opinions.
False consensus effect: the tendency to overestimate how much other people share one's opinions, attitudes, and behaviors ("everyone agrees with me").
Reducing conflict, and social traps
Study spotlight · The Robbers Cave experiment (Sherif, 1954)
Muzafer Sherif took 22 well-adjusted 11- and 12-year-old boys to a summer camp at Robbers Cave State Park in Oklahoma and divided them into two groups, the "Eagles" and the "Rattlers," who at first did not know about each other. When the groups met in competitions for prizes, hostility grew quickly: name-calling, flag-burning, and raids on cabins. Simply bringing the groups together for meals and movies did not reduce the conflict. What worked was introducing superordinate goals, shared goals that could not be achieved by one group alone, such as fixing the camp's water supply and pooling money to rent a movie. After working together on these goals, hostility dropped and friendships formed across groups.
Reading the research: a field experiment, not a lab experiment, with many chances to observe real behavior. It shows that competition for limited resources can produce prejudice, and that cooperation toward common goals can reduce it. Limits: the participants were all white, middle-class boys at a single camp, and there was no random assignment of conditions in all stages. The study also involved deception, since the boys did not know that they were being studied.
A superordinate goal unites groups around a common goal and reduces negative feelings and stereotyping between them. A social trap is a situation in which individuals, each acting in their own self-interest, produce a result that harms everyone, including themselves (overfishing a lake, or each driver using a car and creating pollution and traffic). Solving social traps usually requires communication, cooperation, and rules.
Industrial-organizational psychology
Industrial-organizational (I/O) psychologists apply psychology to the workplace. They study the best practices in managing work (selecting and training employees, setting goals, designing jobs and evaluating performance), the relationships among people working together (leadership, teamwork), and how people feel about work, including burnout, a state of physical and emotional exhaustion from prolonged work stress. They also study motivation and job satisfaction.
Worked example · Identify the group effect
Name the concept. (a) A runner posts her best time while spectators watch. (b) In a group project, one member does little because "the others will do it." (c) A group of moderately pro-environment students talk and leave more strongly pro-environment than before. (d) People in masks at a riot do things they would never do alone. (e) A committee suppresses doubts to keep agreement and approves a risky plan.
Step 1, (a) social facilitation (on a well-learned task).
Step 2, (b) social loafing, with diffusion of responsibility.
Step 3, (c) group polarization.
Step 4, (d) deindividuation.
Step 5, (e) groupthink.
Worked example · Predict social facilitation
Beginners and experts practice billiards alone and in front of an audience. Predict the effect on each, and explain using arousal.
Step 1, an audience raises arousal, which strengthens the dominant (most practiced) response.
Step 2, for experts, the dominant response is the correct skill, so their performance improves with an audience.
Step 3, for beginners, the dominant response is likely to be incorrect, so their performance declines with an audience.
Step 4, if this is tested with random assignment of audience or no audience within each skill level, we could draw a causal conclusion.
Worked example · Apply superordinate goals
Two rival departments at a company are in conflict and blame each other for failures. Recommend a plan based on Sherif.
Step 1, do not rely on contact alone, since mere contact (as at the camp meals) did not reduce hostility.
Step 2, create a superordinate goal that needs both departments, such as a joint project with a deadline that neither can complete alone.
Step 3, reward the shared success, not just each department's results, to reduce competition.
Step 4, expected result: less stereotyping and more cooperation, as the boys showed.
Exam focus
Individualism versus collectivism; multiculturalism.
Social facilitation (easy tasks improve with an audience), social loafing, deindividuation, diffusion of responsibility, group polarization, groupthink, false consensus effect.
Why does an audience help experts but hurt beginners?
Show answer
The audience raises arousal, which strengthens the dominant response; for experts, that is the correct one, and for beginners it is likely to be a mistake.
Distinguish social loafing from diffusion of responsibility.
Show answer
Social loafing is reduced individual effort in a group; diffusion of responsibility is the feeling that responsibility is shared so no one feels personally responsible. The second helps to explain the first.
What is group polarization? Give an example.
Show answer
Group discussion strengthens the members' shared leaning, so the group's view becomes more extreme; for example, a group of moderately cautious people becoming very cautious.
How can groupthink be reduced?
Show answer
Encourage dissent, assign a devil's advocate, invite outside opinions, and let members voice doubts privately.
What did the Robbers Cave study show about reducing conflict?
Show answer
Contact alone did not reduce hostility, but superordinate goals that required cooperation did.
What is a social trap? Give an example.
Show answer
A situation in which individuals pursuing their own self-interest cause harm to the group, such as overfishing a shared lake.
Social psychology often studies harmful behavior, but it also asks why people help. Prosocial behavior is any action intended to benefit others, such as donating, comforting a friend, or stopping to help a stranger. Yet one of the most striking discoveries in the field is that people are often less likely to help when others are present. This lesson covers the explanations for helping, including altruism, social reciprocity, and social responsibility, and then the bystander effect, with the classic study that tested it. It is a good example of how a famous real event led to experiments that produced a surprising and useful result.
Required content · 4.3.C
Learning objective.
4.3.C. Explain how prosocial behavior affects behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.3.C.1. Altruism refers to selfless behavior, but some researchers suggest that people act in prosocial ways due to incurring social debt. The social reciprocity norm and the social responsibility norm explain this type of behavior.
4.3.C.2. The bystander effect demonstrates that situational and attentional variables predict whether someone is likely to help another person. 100
Why do people help?
Altruism is helping others without expecting any reward for oneself, even at some cost, and so it is called selfless behavior. Some researchers argue that much helping is motivated by empathy and real concern for others. Others suggest that people help because of social debt, an obligation created by the norms of the society. Two norms explain this:
The social reciprocity norm is the expectation that we should help those who have helped us, and not harm them ("you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours"). It explains why people feel obliged to return favors and why door-in-the-face works.
The social responsibility norm is the expectation that we should help people who need help, even if they cannot repay us, such as a person with a disability or a child. It is a basis for charitable giving.
Whether or not true altruism exists is debated, since a helper may also gain feelings of satisfaction. The exam expects you to describe both explanations and apply them.
The bystander effect
In 1964, a young woman named Kitty Genovese was attacked and killed in New York City. A newspaper story reported that 38 neighbors had watched and not called the police. (Later investigations found that the account was exaggerated, and that some people had responded.) The story led psychologists to ask why bystanders might not help.
The bystander effect is the finding that the presence of other people makes it less likely that any one person will help someone in need. The more bystanders there are, the less likely each is to help. Situational and attentional variables predict whether someone will help. Researchers Bibb Latané and John Darley proposed a sequence of steps that must occur for a person to help: notice the event, interpret it as an emergency, take personal responsibility, decide how to help, and act. A bystander can be stopped at any step:
Not noticing: hurrying people attend less to others. (In one study, seminary students who were told they were late were much less likely to stop to help a slumped man, even though they were about to give a talk on the Good Samaritan.)
Ambiguity and pluralistic ignorance: if others do not react, each person assumes that it is not an emergency, and since everyone is looking to others, no one acts. This is an informational influence.
Diffusion of responsibility: with more people present, each person feels less personally responsible.
Study spotlight · The seizure study (Darley and Latané, 1968)
In the "seizure" study, participants in separate rooms talked over an intercom in a discussion about personal problems. Participants were told there were one, two, or five other people in the discussion. During the discussion, one "participant" (a recording) said he was prone to seizures, then seemed to have one and called for help, and fell silent. The researchers recorded whether the participant left the room to get help. When the participants believed they were the only one who could hear, about 85 percent reported the seizure before the "victim" fell silent. When they believed there was one other person, about 62 percent helped, and when they believed there were four others, only about 31 percent did.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment to the number of others, which supports the claim that the number of bystanders can cause a reduction in helping. The participants were college students, the emergency was staged, and participants could not see the others, so the results may differ in real face-to-face emergencies. Later analyses show that the bystander effect is smaller or may reverse when the emergency is clearly dangerous or when the bystanders know each other.
Increasing helping
Knowing the causes lets people reduce the effect: if you need help in a crowd, point to a specific person and give an instruction ("You in the red jacket, call 911"), which eliminates the diffusion of responsibility. Bystanders can also state clearly that it is an emergency. People who know about the bystander effect are somewhat more likely to help. Helping is also more likely when the person is similar to us, when we are not in a hurry, when we are in a good mood, and when we have seen others help.
Worked example · Which norm?
Name the norm. (a) A neighbor shoveled your driveway last week, so you offer to water his plants. (b) A person donates blood for strangers, expecting nothing in return. (c) You hold the door for an elderly person.
Step 1, (a) social reciprocity norm.
Step 2, (b) social responsibility norm (and possibly altruism).
Step 3, (c) social responsibility norm: helping someone who needs help.
Worked example · Analyze the seizure data
In a Darley and Latané-style study, the percentages of participants who helped before the victim fell silent are: alone 85%, with 1 other 62%, with 4 others 31%. Describe the pattern, and calculate the drop from alone to 4 others.
Step 1, as the number of other people believed to be present increased (0, 1, 4), the percentage of helpers decreased (85, 62, 31).
Step 2, the drop from alone to 4 others is \(85-31=54\) percentage points.
Step 3, explanation: diffusion of responsibility, since each person felt less responsible when others could help.
Step 4, because participants were randomly assigned to conditions, we can conclude that the number of bystanders caused the change in helping.
Worked example · Apply the helping steps
A man collapses on a busy train platform. Twenty people watch, and no one moves. Explain with two concepts and recommend what the man (if he can speak) should do.
Step 1, pluralistic ignorance: each person looks at others, sees no one reacting, and concludes that it may not be an emergency.
Step 2, diffusion of responsibility: with 20 people present, each feels that someone else will act.
Step 3, the man should address one person directly ("You, in the blue coat, call 911"), which removes the ambiguity and puts the responsibility on a specific person.
Exam focus
Altruism; social reciprocity norm (return help); social responsibility norm (help those in need).
Bystander effect: more bystanders, less helping. Causes: diffusion of responsibility, pluralistic ignorance (informational influence), not noticing.
Darley and Latané seizure study: 85 percent alone, 31 percent with four others. Increase helping by asking a specific person.
Practice
Distinguish the social reciprocity norm from the social responsibility norm.
Show answer
Reciprocity: we should help those who have helped us. Responsibility: we should help people who need help even if they cannot repay us.
Define the bystander effect.
Show answer
The presence of other people makes it less likely that any one person will help someone in need.
Why does pluralistic ignorance reduce helping?
Show answer
Each person looks to others for cues; if no one reacts, everyone assumes it is not an emergency, so no one helps.
How did Darley and Latané's design allow a causal conclusion?
Show answer
Participants were randomly assigned to believe different numbers of others were present, and the dependent variable (helping) was measured, so differences could be attributed to the number of bystanders.
What should a person in need do in a crowd to get help?
Show answer
Single out a specific person and give a clear request, which removes diffusion of responsibility and ambiguity.
Why is the Kitty Genovese story a cautionary tale about sources?
Show answer
The newspaper account of 38 passive witnesses was later found to be exaggerated and inaccurate, showing that striking stories should be checked against evidence.
Personality is a person's relatively stable pattern of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors that distinguishes them from others. Psychologists have proposed several families of theories to explain it. This lesson covers two that differ sharply in their view of human nature. The psychodynamic approach, which began with Sigmund Freud, sees personality as shaped by unconscious conflicts and early experiences. The humanistic approach, which began as a reaction against it, sees people as basically good and motivated to grow. The AP course tests the core ideas and the way each approach assesses personality, while specifically excluding Freud's psychosexual stages and Maslow's hierarchy of needs, so you can skip them. The next lesson covers social-cognitive and trait theories.
Required content · 4.4.A, 4.4.B
Learning objectives.
4.4.A. Explain how the psychodynamic theory of personality defines and assesses personality.
4.4.B. Explain how the humanistic theory of personality defines and assesses personality.
Essential knowledge.
4.4.A.1. According to the psychodynamic theory of personality, unconscious processes drive personality. Exclusion Statement: The stage theory of psychosexual development is out of scope for the AP Psychology Exam.
4.4.A.2. Ego defense mechanisms (denial, displacement, projection, rationalization, reaction formation, regression, repression, and sublimation) serve to protect the ego unconsciously from threats.
4.4.A.3. Psychodynamic personality psychologists assess personality using projective tests that are designed to probe the preconscious and unconscious mind.
4.4.B.1. According to humanistic psychology, personality focuses on unconditional regard and the self-actualizing tendency as primary motivating factors. Exclusion Statement: Maslow’s hierarchy of needs is outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam. 1.A 2.C 101
The psychodynamic perspective
According to the psychodynamic theory of personality, unconscious processes drive personality. Freud proposed that the mind has three levels: the conscious (what you are aware of right now), the preconscious (information that can be brought into awareness easily, such as your phone number), and the unconscious (thoughts, wishes, and memories that are outside awareness, which Freud believed influence behavior). Freud thought that the unconscious contains unacceptable urges and painful memories that have been repressed, and that they emerge indirectly in dreams, slips of the tongue ("Freudian slips"), and symptoms.
He also described three parts of personality, which are in constant conflict:
The id operates on the pleasure principle, seeking immediate gratification of basic urges, and is unconscious.
The ego operates on the reality principle, mediating between the id's demands, the superego's rules, and the real world.
The superego is the internalized sense of morality and ideals (conscience), formed from parents and society.
Anxiety arises when the ego is threatened by conflict between these forces. To protect itself, the ego uses defense mechanisms, unconscious strategies that distort reality to reduce anxiety. The AP list is:
Defense mechanism
What it does
Example
Denial
Refusing to accept reality
A person told of a serious diagnosis insists that the tests are wrong
Repression
Pushing anxiety-producing thoughts out of awareness
A person has no memory of a traumatic event
Displacement
Redirecting an impulse from a threatening target to a safer one
A worker yelled at by the boss yells at his family at home
Projection
Attributing one's own unacceptable feelings to others
A person who is angry at a friend says, "You're mad at me"
Rationalization
Creating a logical-sounding reason for an unacceptable action or feeling
"I cheated because everyone does"
Reaction formation
Acting in the opposite way from one's true feelings
Someone who is attracted to a rival is rude to them
Regression
Returning to behavior of an earlier stage
An adult who is stressed sucks a thumb or throws a tantrum
Sublimation
Channeling unacceptable urges into socially acceptable activities
A person with aggressive impulses becomes a boxer or a surgeon
Assessment. Psychodynamic psychologists assess personality with projective tests, which present ambiguous stimuli and ask people to interpret them, on the theory that they will project their unconscious thoughts and feelings. The Rorschach inkblot test asks what the ten inkblots look like, and the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) asks the person to tell a story about ambiguous pictures of people. Projective tests are widely criticized for low reliability (different scorers give different interpretations) and low validity (they do not predict behavior well), though they are still used in some clinical settings. Critics of the whole psychodynamic approach add that its ideas are hard to test scientifically (they are difficult to falsify), that it relies on case studies of a small, unusual group of patients, and that it gives too much weight to sexual and aggressive drives. Its influence is still large: the idea that unconscious processes matter, and that early experiences shape adult life, is widely accepted in modified form.
The humanistic perspective
Humanistic psychology, which developed in the mid-twentieth century (a "third force" beyond psychodynamic and behaviorist views), emphasizes free will, personal growth, and the positive potential of human beings. Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow were its leading figures. (Maslow's hierarchy of needs is not tested on the AP Exam.) Two ideas from Rogers are central:
The self-actualizing tendency is the innate drive to develop one's potential and to become the best person one can be. A person who is on this path is described as fully functioning.
Unconditional positive regard is acceptance and love given without conditions, valuing a person for who they are and not for what they do. Rogers argued that when parents or others give only conditional regard (approval only when behaving in certain ways), a person's actual self and ideal self come apart, and this incongruence causes anxiety and low self-esteem.
Rogers also stressed that empathy, genuineness, and acceptance by a therapist help the client to grow, which is the basis of client-centered therapy (covered in Unit 5).
Assessment. Humanistic psychologists prefer to assess personality through the person's own report of their experience, such as interviews and self-report questionnaires that compare a person's actual self-concept with their ideal self, instead of tests that interpret hidden meanings. Critics of the humanistic approach say its concepts, such as self-actualization, are vague and hard to measure scientifically, that it is too optimistic, and that it ignores biology and the influence of the environment. Its contribution includes a respectful view of people and a lasting influence on counseling.
Worked example · Identify the defense mechanism
Name the mechanism. (a) A student who failed the exam says the teacher is unfair, not admitting that he did not study. (b) A man who is furious with his boss kicks the door of his car. (c) A woman who has strong unacceptable feelings toward her sister is very sweet to her. (d) A child who is stressed by a new sibling starts wetting the bed again. (e) A person with aggressive impulses becomes a successful football player.
Step 1, (a) rationalization (a plausible reason) and also possibly projection of blame.
Step 2, (b) displacement.
Step 3, (c) reaction formation.
Step 4, (d) regression.
Step 5, (e) sublimation.
Worked example · Compare the two approaches
A teenager's parents praise her only when she gets A grades. Interpret using a psychodynamic and a humanistic view.
Step 1, psychodynamic: the superego is shaped strongly by parents' standards; strict demands may produce guilt, and the teen may use defense mechanisms (such as rationalization) to cope with anxiety about failing, and some of her motives may be unconscious.
Step 2, humanistic (Rogers): the parents give conditional positive regard, so the teen may feel worthy only when achieving, and her actual self may differ from her ideal self, which blocks self-actualization.
Step 3, the humanistic therapist would offer unconditional positive regard.
Step 4, difference: the psychodynamic view stresses unconscious conflict, and the humanistic view stresses the conditions of acceptance for growth.
Worked example · Evaluate a projective test
A psychologist concludes that a client is "hostile" because he sees violence in many inkblots. Evaluate this conclusion.
Step 1, the psychodynamic assumption is that responses to ambiguous stimuli reveal hidden thoughts and feelings.
Step 2, reliability problem: different psychologists might interpret the same responses differently, and the same person might respond differently on another day.
Step 3, validity problem: there is little evidence that responses predict actual hostile behavior, and the person may be responding to the vivid shapes of the blots.
Step 4, a defensible conclusion: the test response is only a hypothesis to check against other evidence, such as interviews, observations of behavior, and well-validated questionnaires.
Exam focus
Psychodynamic: unconscious drives; id, ego, superego; defense mechanisms (denial, displacement, projection, rationalization, reaction formation, regression, repression, sublimation); projective tests (Rorschach, TAT) with weak reliability and validity. Psychosexual stages are not tested.
Humanistic (Rogers): self-actualizing tendency, unconditional positive regard; assessed by interviews and self-reports; criticized as vague and untestable. Maslow's hierarchy is not tested.
Practice
Distinguish displacement from projection.
Show answer
Displacement redirects an impulse onto a safer target; projection attributes your own unacceptable feelings to someone else.
Describe the roles of the id, ego, and superego.
Show answer
The id seeks immediate gratification (pleasure principle), the superego imposes moral standards, and the ego mediates between them and reality (reality principle).
Why are projective tests criticized?
Show answer
They have low reliability (inconsistent scoring) and low validity (they do not predict behavior well).
What is unconditional positive regard and why does Rogers consider it important?
Show answer
Acceptance of a person without conditions; it lets the person develop a healthy self-concept and grow toward self-actualization.
Which defense mechanism is shown by a person who denies that he is angry and acts unusually friendly toward the person he is angry with?
Show answer
Reaction formation.
Give one criticism of each perspective.
Show answer
Psychodynamic: its concepts are hard to test scientifically. Humanistic: its concepts, such as self-actualization, are vague and hard to measure.
Social-cognitive and trait theories of personality
Two more families of personality theory take very different routes. The social-cognitive approach says that personality is shaped by the interaction between a person's thoughts, behavior, and situation. The trait approach does not try to explain the causes of personality as much as to describe it, listing the enduring characteristics that make people different and measuring them. This lesson covers both, with the best-known trait model, the Big Five, and how personality is measured, including the idea of factor analysis. It also introduces a few important concepts, such as self-efficacy and self-esteem, that you will see throughout the course.
Required content · 4.5.A, 4.5.B
Learning objectives.
4.5.A. Explain how the social-cognitive theory of personality defines and assesses personality.
4.5.B. Explain how trait theories of personality define and assess personality.
Essential knowledge.
4.5.A.1. According to social-cognitive theory, reciprocal determinism shapes personality. Reciprocal determinism explores self-concept (how one views themselves and in relation to others) and how self-efficacy and self-esteem both contribute to self-concept.
4.5.B.1. Trait theories of personality conclude that personality involves a set of enduring characteristics that lead to typical responses to stimuli.
4.5.B.2. The Big Five theory of personality proposes that traits of agreeableness, openness to experience, extraversion, conscientiousness, and emotional stability make up one’s personality. These traits are measured by specialized personality inventories that use factor analysis to organize item responses. 1.A 2.A 3.C 102
Social-cognitive theory
Albert Bandura, whose work on observational learning you studied in Unit 3, proposed that personality comes from how a person's thinking and behavior interact with the environment. His central idea is reciprocal determinism: three factors influence each other in both directions: personal factors (thoughts, beliefs, expectations, and personality traits), behavior, and the environment (situations and other people). A student who believes she is good at math (personal) takes harder classes (behavior), which put her in a group of motivated peers (environment), which strengthens her belief. People are not simply shaped by situations: they also choose and change them.
Two important concepts are part of the self-concept, how one views oneself and in relation to others:
Self-efficacy is the belief in your own ability to succeed at a specific task or in a particular situation. High self-efficacy leads people to take on challenges, persist after setbacks, and perform better. It is built by mastering experiences, watching similar people succeed, encouragement, and managing stress.
Self-esteem is your overall evaluation of your own worth. High self-esteem is generally associated with better well-being, but it is not clearly a cause of success, and unrealistic or fragile high self-esteem can be a problem.
Both contribute to the self-concept. Social-cognitive theorists assess personality by observing behavior in different situations and using questionnaires about beliefs and expectations, and they believe that behavior depends on the situation as well as on the person. Critics say that the theory pays less attention to biology and unconscious processes and to emotions.
Trait theories
A trait is a stable characteristic that leads a person to respond in a typical way across situations (such as friendliness or shyness). Trait theories say that personality is a set of enduring characteristics and that people differ in how much of each trait they have. Early trait theorist Gordon Allport collected thousands of English words that describe personality, and Raymond Cattell used statistics to reduce them to a smaller set. Hans Eysenck proposed that two dimensions, introversion-extraversion and emotional stability, organize many traits.
### The Big Five
Today the most widely accepted trait model is the Big Five (also called the five-factor model), which proposes that personality can be described by five broad dimensions:
Trait
High scorers tend to be
Low scorers tend to be
Openness to experience
Curious, imaginative, willing to try new things
Conventional, prefer routine
Conscientiousness
Organized, disciplined, dependable
Careless, impulsive, spontaneous
Extraversion
Outgoing, energetic, talkative (seek stimulation from others)
Reserved, quiet (introverted)
Agreeableness
Cooperative, trusting, kind
Competitive, suspicious, critical
Emotional stability (the opposite of neuroticism)
Calm, even-tempered, secure
Anxious, moody, easily upset
A way to remember them is OCEAN (openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, neuroticism). On the AP Exam, the fifth trait is called emotional stability. Each trait is a continuum, and most people fall in the middle. Research shows that the Big Five have moderate stability across adulthood, are partly heritable (twin studies suggest about 40 to 50 percent), and the traits predict outcomes: for instance, conscientiousness predicts job performance and academic success, and neuroticism predicts anxiety and depression. The model has been found in many cultures, though the evidence is less consistent in some.
### Measuring traits
Traits are measured with personality inventories, questionnaires with many statements to which people respond, such as "I am the life of the party" (agree or disagree). The Big Five are measured by instruments such as the NEO Personality Inventory. The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) is a widely used inventory for assessing psychological disorders, with scales that detect lying and faking.
Developers organize the item responses with factor analysis, a statistical method that finds clusters of items that correlate with each other. Items such as "I am talkative," "I like parties," and "I make friends easily" go together and form one factor, which the researcher then names (extraversion). Factor analysis therefore helps to identify the basic dimensions that underlie many specific traits.
Strengths of inventories: they are objective, easy to score, and have good reliability and validity when carefully developed. Weaknesses: people may answer in socially desirable ways or may not know themselves well, and responses may vary with mood. Another criticism of trait theory is that it describes personality, but does not explain it, and that behavior can vary with the situation, a criticism known as the person-situation debate. Research suggests that traits predict average behavior across many situations better than behavior in any one situation.
Worked example · Reciprocal determinism
A boy who is shy (personal) avoids parties (behavior), so he has few friends (environment), which makes him more convinced that he is unlikeable (personal). Explain with the theory and suggest a way to change it.
Step 1, the cycle shows reciprocal determinism: personality, behavior, and environment each influence the others.
Step 2, to change it, work on any one: build self-efficacy with small social successes (behavior), join a supportive group (environment), or challenge the belief (personal).
Step 3, a change in one factor will change the others over time.
Worked example · Match to the Big Five
Name the trait. (a) A person keeps a spotless schedule and always arrives early. (b) A person loves attending art shows and trying unusual foods. (c) A person is calm in crises and rarely worries. (d) A person gladly helps others and trusts people easily. (e) A person gets energy from large social gatherings.
Step 1, (a) high conscientiousness.
Step 2, (b) high openness to experience.
Step 3, (c) high emotional stability (low neuroticism).
Step 4, (d) high agreeableness.
Step 5, (e) high extraversion.
Worked example · Interpret a factor analysis
A researcher gives 10 questionnaire items to 500 people. Items 1, 2, and 3 (about parties, talking, and making friends) correlate +0.7 with each other but only +0.1 with items 4, 5, and 6 (about being organized, punctual, and neat). Interpret.
Step 1, the two clusters of items form separate factors, since items inside each cluster correlate strongly but items across clusters do not.
Step 2, the researcher might name the first factor extraversion and the second conscientiousness.
Step 3, this suggests that these are two distinct, independent dimensions of personality, in line with the Big Five.
Step 4, a limit is that naming factors involves judgment, and the factors depend on which items were included.
Trait theories: enduring characteristics. Big Five (OCEAN): openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, emotional stability (neuroticism).
Measured by personality inventories; factor analysis groups items. The person-situation debate.
Practice
Explain reciprocal determinism with an example.
Show answer
Personal factors, behavior, and the environment influence each other; for example, a student who believes she is good at math takes harder classes, meets motivated peers, and gains more confidence.
Distinguish self-efficacy from self-esteem.
Show answer
Self-efficacy is the belief in your ability to succeed at a specific task; self-esteem is your overall sense of your own worth.
List the Big Five traits.
Show answer
Openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability (neuroticism).
What does factor analysis do in the development of a personality inventory?
Show answer
It finds clusters of items whose responses correlate, grouping them into underlying factors or dimensions.
Give one strength and one limitation of personality inventories.
Show answer
Strength: objective and easily scored with good reliability. Limitation: people may answer in a socially desirable way or lack self-insight.
What is the person-situation debate?
Show answer
The question whether behavior is better explained by stable traits or by the situation; research suggests traits predict average behavior across situations better than behavior in one.
Why do you get up in the morning, study for a test, or choose one option over another? Motivation is the set of needs and desires that energize and direct behavior. Psychologists have offered many theories, each of which explains part of the picture: some focus on biological needs, some on the pleasure of stimulation, some on rewards and the reasons behind our goals, and some on the conflicts among our choices. This lesson covers the main theories, the biology of hunger as a model of a motivated behavior, and the role of belonging. The AP Exam expects you to identify each theory in an example and to compare them, so pay attention to what each theory says that the others do not.
Required content · 4.6.A, 4.6.B
Learning objectives.
4.6.A. Explain how theories about motivation apply to behavior and mental processes.
4.6.B. Explain how eating and belongingness motivate behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
4.6.A.1. Some theories about motivation focus on behavior and mental processes that seek to address physical needs and desires such as drive-reduction theory and arousal theory. Drive-reduction theory addresses how certain behaviors help maintain homeostasis while arousal theory addresses how people seek an optimal level of arousal when they behave (as demonstrated by the Yerkes-Dodson Law).
4.6.A.2. Self-determination theory proposes that people are motivated by intrinsic (internal) or extrinsic (external) motivations. Incentive theory explores the role of rewards (an extrinsic motivation) in motivating behavior.
4.6.A.3. Many non-human animals are motivated by instincts (innate, typically fixed patterns of behavior in animals in response to certain stimuli). Humans do not seem to demonstrate instinctual behavior or mental processes.
4.6.A.4. Lewin’s motivational conflicts theory proposes that choices create conflicts one must resolve as the basis of motivation. The type of conflicts faced include approach-approach, approach-avoidance, and avoidance-avoidance.
4.6.A.5. Sensation-seeking theory proposes that one’s level of need for varied or novel experiences is the basis of motivation. The types of sensation seeking are experience seeking, thrill or adventure seeking, disinhibition, and boredom susceptibility. 1.A 2.B 2.C 103
4.6.B.1. Eating is a complex motivated behavior that demonstrates how physical and mental processes interact.
4.6.B.1.i. Hormones, such as ghrelin and leptin (regulated by the hypothalamus via the pituitary gland), regulate feelings of hunger and satiety.
4.6.B.1.ii. External factors like the presence of food, time of day, or social gatherings around meals also influence the behavior of eating. 104
Instincts
An instinct is an innate, fixed pattern of behavior in response to certain stimuli, which does not need to be learned. Many non-human animals have instincts (a salmon returning to its birthplace, a bird building its nest). Early psychologists suggested that human behavior was also motivated by instincts, but this failed as an explanation: naming a behavior an "instinct" does not explain it, and humans do not seem to show fixed, inborn behavior patterns. Today the term is mostly applied to animals.
Drive-reduction and arousal theories
Drive-reduction theory proposes that a physiological need (such as a lack of food or water) creates a state of tension called a drive, which motivates behavior that reduces the drive, such as eating. The aim is to maintain homeostasis, a stable internal state (such as a steady body temperature or blood sugar). Drive reduction explains hunger and thirst well, but not why people seek stimulation (such as riding a roller coaster or reading a mystery novel), which raises tension.
Arousal theory proposes that people are motivated to maintain an optimal level of arousal, neither too low nor too high. When under-aroused (bored), we seek stimulation; when over-aroused (stressed), we seek calm. The Yerkes-Dodson law says that performance is best at a moderate level of arousal, and that the best level depends on the task: easy or well-learned tasks are performed best at higher arousal, while difficult or new tasks are performed best at lower arousal.
Figure 4.1. The Yerkes-Dodson law. Performance is best at a moderate level of arousal, forming an inverted U. The best level of arousal is higher for easy or well-learned tasks (solid line) and lower for difficult or new tasks (dashed line).
Incentives and intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
Incentive theory proposes that behavior is pulled by external rewards (and avoidance of punishments) as well as being pushed by internal drives. An incentive is a positive or negative stimulus that motivates behavior, such as money, praise, a grade, or a trophy.
Self-determination theory, from Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, proposes that people have basic needs for autonomy (control over your own actions), competence (feeling effective), and relatedness (connection to others), and that motivation is better when these needs are met. It distinguishes two kinds of motivation:
Intrinsic motivation: doing something because it is enjoyable or satisfying in itself (reading for fun).
Extrinsic motivation: doing something for an external reward or to avoid punishment (reading for a prize).
Extrinsic rewards usually work, but sometimes they can undermine intrinsic motivation, an effect known as the overjustification effect.
Study spotlight · Rewards and intrinsic interest (Lepper, Greene, and Nisbett, 1973)
Preschool children who liked to draw with felt-tip markers were assigned to one of three conditions. In one, they were told that they would get a "Good Player" award for drawing (expected reward); in another, they were given the award as a surprise afterward (unexpected reward); in the third, they received no award. Two weeks later, the children were observed during free play. The children in the expected-reward group spent only about half as much time drawing as the others (about 8.6 percent of the time versus about 16 to 18 percent).
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment. It suggests that when people expect a reward for something they already enjoy, they may come to see themselves as doing it for the reward and lose interest when it is gone. The sample was small and young, and the effect depends on the kind of reward (verbal praise often does not undermine interest), so the finding should not be overgeneralized.
Motivational conflicts
Kurt Lewin proposed that choices can create conflicts between motives:
Approach-approach conflict: you must choose between two attractive options (two good job offers). It is the least stressful.
Avoidance-avoidance conflict: you must choose between two unattractive options ("the lesser of two evils," like paying for an expensive repair or going without a car).
Approach-avoidance conflict: a single option has both attractive and unattractive features (a high-paying job that requires moving away from family). It often leads to hesitation, and as you get closer to the goal, avoidance feelings rise.
Sensation seeking
Sensation-seeking theory proposes that people differ in their need for varied, novel, and intense experiences, which motivates them to seek stimulation. Marvin Zuckerman described four types: experience seeking (new sensations through travel, art, or unconventional lifestyle), thrill or adventure seeking (risky physical activities such as skydiving), disinhibition (seeking release through parties, drinking, or gambling), and boredom susceptibility (dislike of routine and repetition). High sensation seeking is partly biological, and it is higher in adolescence and young adulthood.
Eating and belongingness
Eating is a complex motivated behavior that shows how physical and mental processes interact.
Biological factors: the hormone ghrelin, released by the stomach when it is empty, increases the feeling of hunger. The hormone leptin, released by fat cells, signals fullness (satiety) and suppresses hunger. The hypothalamus (acting through the pituitary gland) regulates these signals, as you saw in Unit 1.
External and psychological factors: the sight and smell of food, the time of day, portion size, the culture's customs, and social gatherings around meals all influence whether and how much you eat, even when you are not physiologically hungry.
Humans also have a strong need to belong: to form and keep close relationships. Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary proposed that this need is a fundamental motive. When it is not met, people suffer, and social exclusion can be experienced as pain; belonging is associated with better health and well-being.
Worked example · Identify the theory
Name the theory. (a) After a day without water, a hiker is driven to find a stream. (b) A bored student on a quiet afternoon starts exploring a new website. (c) A child draws because she loves it. (d) An employee works harder because of the promise of a bonus.
Step 1, (a) drive-reduction theory (a need creates a drive, and satisfying it restores homeostasis).
Step 2, (b) arousal theory (seeking an optimal level of stimulation).
Step 4, (d) incentive theory (extrinsic motivation).
Worked example · Identify the conflict
Name the conflict. (a) A student must choose between two equally attractive colleges. (b) A person must decide between a painful surgery and living with chronic pain. (c) A person wants a cake but is trying to lose weight.
Step 1, (a) approach-approach.
Step 2, (b) avoidance-avoidance.
Step 3, (c) approach-avoidance (one option with both attractive and unattractive features).
Worked example · Yerkes-Dodson
A runner (a simple, well-learned task) and a student taking a very hard, new exam both feel the same high level of arousal. Predict who benefits, using the law.
Step 1, the law says that performance rises with arousal up to a point and then falls (an inverted U), and that the best level is higher for easy tasks and lower for hard tasks.
Step 2, at high arousal the runner's performance is near its best, since the task is simple.
Step 3, the student's performance is likely to be impaired, since the hard, new task is best at lower to moderate arousal.
Step 4, a practical conclusion: the student should use relaxation techniques before the exam, and the runner might use a pep talk.
Exam focus
Instincts (animals), drive-reduction (homeostasis), arousal theory and Yerkes-Dodson law (moderate arousal best; easy tasks tolerate more).
Incentive theory; self-determination theory (autonomy, competence, relatedness); intrinsic versus extrinsic; the overjustification effect.
Ghrelin (hunger), leptin (satiety); external eating cues; the need to belong.
Practice
What is the difference between drive-reduction and arousal theory?
Show answer
Drive-reduction says that needs create tension that behavior reduces to restore homeostasis; arousal theory says that people seek an optimal level of arousal, sometimes increasing stimulation.
State the Yerkes-Dodson law.
Show answer
Performance is best at a moderate level of arousal, with a higher optimal level for easy tasks and a lower one for difficult tasks.
Give an example of the overjustification effect.
Show answer
A child who loves to read is given prizes for reading, then reads less when the prizes stop.
Distinguish ghrelin from leptin.
Show answer
Ghrelin, from the stomach, increases hunger; leptin, from fat cells, signals fullness and decreases hunger.
Name the type of conflict: choosing between going to a party and finishing an assignment you want to do well.
Show answer
Approach-approach (two attractive options), assuming both are attractive.
List two of the four types of sensation seeking and an example of each.
Show answer
Thrill or adventure seeking (skydiving); boredom susceptibility (disliking repetitive routines); also experience seeking (travel) and disinhibition (parties).
Emotions color nearly every moment of life: the thrill of a win, the dread before a test, the calm of a quiet morning. Emotion (or affect) is a complex psychological process involving physiological arousal, expressive behavior, and conscious experience. It is distinct from reasoning and knowledge, though the two interact constantly. Psychologists ask three kinds of questions: What is the sequence that produces an emotion (does the body respond first, or the thought)? What are the effects of emotions on thinking and action? And how much of emotional expression is universal, and how much depends on culture? This lesson covers all three, and the exam expects you to apply the ideas and to evaluate evidence of mixed quality.
Required content · 4.7.A, 4.7.B
Learning objectives.
4.7.A. Explain how theories of emotion apply to behavior and mental processes.
4.7.B. Explain how social norms and experiences influence the expression of emotions.
Essential knowledge.
4.7.A.1. Emotion, or affect, is a complex psychological process that is distinguished from reasoning or knowledge. Emotions reflect internal and external factors affecting an individual. Early 20th century psychological theories of emotion parsed the distinction between the physiological and cognitive experiences of emotion. Some theories proposed that the physiological and cognitive experiences occurred in succession while others proposed that they occurred simultaneously. Other theories emphasize that the cognitive label is required to experience an emotion. The facial-feedback hypothesis suggests that the experience of emotion is influenced by facial expressions, which supports theories that propose the physiological experience of emotion precedes the cognitive appraisal, and research testing this hypothesis has produced mixed results. Exclusion Statement: Specific names of theories of emotion are outside the scope of the AP Psychology Exam.
4.7.A.2. The broaden-and-build theory of emotion proposes that positive emotional experiences tend to broaden awareness and encourage new actions and thoughts. Negative emotions tend to reduce awareness and narrow thinking and action. 1.A 2.D 3.A 4.B 105
4.7.B.1. Research has explored whether the expression of emotions is universally common. Some emotions that may be commonly experienced across cultures include anger, disgust, sadness, happiness, surprise, and fear. Research on the universality of emotions shows mixed results.
4.7.B.2. Display rules and elicitors for emotional expression can differ among cultures. Display rules and elicitors may regulate how people from different genders, ages, or socioeconomic classes within a culture can display and interpret emotions. 106
The components of emotion
An emotion usually involves three parts:
A physiological component: arousal of the autonomic nervous system (racing heart, sweating, trembling) and changes in brain activity, such as in the amygdala (Unit 1).
A behavioral component: expressions, gestures, and actions (smiling, crying, fleeing).
A cognitive component: the conscious experience and appraisal of the situation ("this is dangerous").
Theories about the order of emotion
Early twentieth-century psychologists disagreed about which comes first, the body's response or the mental experience. The AP Exam does not require the names of the theories, but it does ask about the ideas.
Some proposed that the physiological response comes first and the experience of emotion results from noticing it ("I feel afraid because my heart is pounding"). This is the idea of the James-Lange theory.
Others proposed that the physiological and cognitive experiences happen simultaneously and independently (Cannon-Bard): seeing a bear triggers both the pounding heart and the feeling of fear at the same time.
Others emphasized that a cognitive label is needed: the arousal is interpreted in light of the situation, and the label determines the emotion (Schachter-Singer two-factor theory). The same arousal might be labeled fear at a haunted house and excitement at a party. Related approaches (Lazarus) say that the appraisal of an event comes first.
The facial-feedback hypothesis proposes that facial expressions influence the experience of emotion, so that smiling can make you feel a little happier. This supports theories in which the physiological experience comes before the cognitive appraisal. Research testing it has produced mixed results: some experiments have found small effects, and large replication attempts have found little or none.
Study spotlight · The pen in the mouth (Strack, Martin, and Stepper, 1988; replication by Wagenmakers and colleagues, 2016)
Fritz Strack and colleagues asked participants to hold a pen in their mouths while rating how funny cartoons were. Participants held the pen between their teeth, which forces a smile-like expression, or with their lips, which prevents smiling. Those who held the pen with their teeth rated the cartoons as funnier. In 2016, a group of 17 laboratories attempted to replicate the study with nearly 1,900 participants, and the combined results did not show a significant effect.
Reading the research: the original is an experiment with random assignment to the pen position, and it seemed to support the facial-feedback hypothesis. The replication used a larger total sample across many sites, and it did not find the effect, which illustrates the importance of replication and why the evidence is described as mixed. A limit for both is that the situation is artificial, and participants may have guessed the purpose of the task.
Emotion and thought: broaden and build
Barbara Fredrickson's broaden-and-build theory proposes that positive emotions (joy, interest, contentment) broaden awareness and encourage new thoughts and actions, such as exploring and playing, which over time build lasting resources, such as skills, friendships, and resilience. Negative emotions tend to narrow thinking and action (fear leads to the urge to flee, anger to attack), which is useful in an emergency but limits creativity. This helps to explain why a good mood can promote problem solving and why chronic negative emotion may be harmful.
Culture and the expression of emotion
Are emotions the same everywhere? Charles Darwin argued that emotional expressions evolved and are shared. Paul Ekman and colleagues found that people in many cultures, including an isolated group in New Guinea, could identify facial expressions of anger, disgust, sadness, happiness, surprise, and fear (some researchers add contempt) at a rate better than chance. This suggests that these emotions may be commonly experienced across cultures. However, research on the universality of emotions shows mixed results: recognition accuracy is lower across cultures than within, and researchers debate whether the labels used in the studies influenced the results, and whether expressions map neatly onto the emotions.
What differs across cultures is how and when emotions are shown:
Display rules are the cultural norms about when, where, and how to express emotions, and they differ among cultures and by gender, age, and social class within a culture. For example, in some cultures people are expected to show restraint in public, while in others a more open display is acceptable; and in many places boys are encouraged to hide sadness.
Elicitors are the situations and events that trigger an emotion; what elicits shame, pride, or anger depends on the culture's values.
Worked example · Which order?
A person sees a snake and (a) feels a pounding heart and then concludes, "I'm afraid." (b) feels the pounding heart and the fear at the same moment. (c) feels the pounding heart, notices a "danger" sign, and labels the feeling as fear. Match each to the idea.
Step 1, (a) physiological response first, then experience (James-Lange idea).
Step 2, (b) simultaneous physiological and cognitive responses (Cannon-Bard idea).
Step 3, (c) arousal plus a cognitive label from the situation (Schachter-Singer two-factor idea).
Step 4, the AP Exam does not require the names; focus on the sequence.
Worked example · Evaluate the facial-feedback evidence
Describe how a researcher could design a better test of whether smiling increases happiness, and what result would support it.
Step 1, randomly assign participants to hold a pen with their teeth (smile-like) or with their lips (no smile), and have them rate the same set of cartoons.
Step 2, the independent variable is the facial position; the dependent variable is the funniness rating (on a scale).
Step 3, to reduce demand characteristics, hide the purpose from participants (single-blind), and have the experimenter who collects ratings not know the condition (double-blind).
Step 4, replicate with a large sample in multiple labs. If the "smile" group consistently rates higher, the hypothesis is supported; if not, as in the 2016 replication, the evidence is weak.
Worked example · Display rules
At a funeral in Culture A, mourners openly wail and weep. In Culture B, mourners are quiet and composed. Does this mean that Culture B members feel less sadness? Explain.
Step 1, not necessarily. The same emotion (sadness) may be felt, but the display rules for expressing it differ.
Step 2, the elicitor (death of a loved one) may be common to both cultures, supporting the idea of universal emotion.
Step 3, the difference in expression reflects the cultural norms, not the absence of the feeling.
Step 4, a cautious claim: some emotions and their elicitors are shared across cultures, while display rules differ.
Exam focus
Emotion has physiological, behavioral, and cognitive parts. Theories differ in the sequence (body first, simultaneous, or cognitive label); names are not tested.
Possibly universal emotions: anger, disgust, sadness, happiness, surprise, fear (mixed evidence). Display rules and elicitors differ by culture, gender, age, and class.
Practice
What are the three components of emotion?
Show answer
Physiological arousal, behavior or expression, and cognitive experience (appraisal).
Describe the facial-feedback hypothesis and how strong the evidence is.
Show answer
Facial expressions influence emotional experience (smiling can make one feel happier). Evidence is mixed: early studies supported it, but large replications found little or no effect.
Explain broaden-and-build theory.
Show answer
Positive emotions broaden awareness and encourage exploration, which builds lasting resources; negative emotions narrow thinking and action.
List the emotions that may be commonly experienced across cultures.
Show answer
Anger, disgust, sadness, happiness, surprise, and fear.
Distinguish display rules from elicitors.
Show answer
Display rules are cultural norms about how to express emotions; elicitors are the events or situations that trigger emotions.
Why is it a mistake to conclude that a person who does not show sadness is not feeling it?
Show answer
Display rules may limit how the emotion is expressed, so expression is not a reliable measure of feeling.
Unit 4 review · 10 multiple-choice
Unit 4 review: Social Psychology and Personality
Ten questions across all ten lessons in the exam's three styles (concept
application, data analysis, and scientific investigation), so answer each one before you click,
then read all four rationales, not just the one for the option you chose.
Multiple choice
Ravi's teammate Nia misses two group meetings, and Ravi concludes she is unreliable
and does not care about the project. When Ravi himself misses the next meeting, he explains
that his shift ran late and the bus never came. Which of the following best describes Ravi's
pattern of explanation?
Correct. Ravi reaches for Nia's character (unreliable, uncaring), and skips the
circumstances, which is the fundamental attribution error; when the target is himself he
reaches for the bus and the shift instead. That reversal by target is exactly what the
actor-observer bias names.
The directions are backwards: Ravi credits Nia's disposition, not her situation.
The just-world hypothesis is also a different idea: the assumption that people get the
outcomes they deserve, which would show up as "she must have done something to deserve it,"
not as an explanation of lateness.
False consensus is overestimating how widely your own view or behavior is shared,
as in assuming most people would also skip the meeting. Nothing in the scenario tells you what
Ravi believes about other classmates, so this is a real bias that does not answer the
question.
A halo effect runs from one positive impression outward, letting a
single good quality inflate unrelated judgments. Ravi is not generalizing from one trait
across many; he is explaining one behavior, and the two explanations differ depending on
whose behavior it is.
A club needs volunteers to hand out flyers for a cause its members feel lukewarm
about. Half the members are offered a $20 gift card to do it; the other half are asked as a favor and receive nothing. Everyone hands out flyers. A week later, which group is likelier to
report warmer attitudes toward the cause, and why?
Reinforcement raises the rate of a behavior while it is delivered; it
does not reliably move the private attitude behind it. In dissonance research the payment
works the other way, because a large reward supplies a ready explanation for the act and
leaves no discomfort to resolve.
Correct. Dissonance is largest under insufficient justification: the unpaid
members advocated for something they barely believed, with no money or requirement to point
at, so the cheapest repair is to shift the attitude toward the behavior. This is the
Festinger and Carlsmith pattern, in which the $1 group reported more enjoyment than the $20
group.
Mere exposure is increased liking from repeated contact with a stimulus itself,
not from a reward attached to it, and a gift card given for handing out flyers is an
incentive rather than a peripheral persuasion cue. The distractor mixes two real concepts and
applies neither correctly.
Attitude change through the central route is one path, but it is not the only
one: the elaboration likelihood model also allows peripheral change, and dissonance changes
attitudes with no persuasive message at all. Here the members' own behavior, not an argument,
is what does the work.
Described data
A research team ran a line-judgment task. On each trial the participant said aloud which of
three comparison lines matched a standard line; the correct answer was obvious. Confederates
seated with the participant answered first. The table reports the percentage of critical
trials on which participants gave the majority's wrong answer, by condition.
Condition
Percent of critical trials conformed
Judging alone, no group present
1%
Unanimous majority of 3
32%
Unanimous majority of 7
36%
Majority of 7, one confederate answers correctly
7%
Which conclusion is best supported by the data in the table?
The table contradicts this. Going from three confederates to seven, more than
doubling the majority, moved conformity only from 32% to 36%, which is the finding that
majority size stops mattering quickly once a few people agree.
The alone condition rules this out: with no group present, participants were
wrong on about 1% of trials, so they could see perfectly well which line matched. That
baseline is what turns the other rows into evidence about social pressure rather than about
perception.
Correct. Compare the rows the data actually let you compare: 36% minus 32% is
about 4 percentage points for four extra people, while 36% minus 7% is about 29 points for
one confederate who breaks the unanimity. The comparison also separates the mechanisms: a
single ally mostly relieves normative pressure, the concern about being the odd one out.
Read the column heading. These are percentages of trials, not of
participants, and the two are very different claims: a third of trials can come from most
people conforming occasionally rather than from a third of people conforming always.
Described study
A researcher posts a 40-item online personality inventory and recruits 60 students to
complete it. A week later every student receives a paragraph described as "your individual
profile," and rates on a 1-to-5 scale how accurately it describes them. In fact all 60
students receive the identical paragraph, made of statements general enough to fit almost
anyone. The mean accuracy rating is 4.2. The researcher concludes that the inventory is a
valid measure of personality.
Which change to the design would most directly test the researcher's conclusion?
A larger sample narrows the confidence interval around 4.2, but it cannot tell
you what the 4.2 means, because there is still nothing to compare it against. Precision is
not the problem here; the missing comparison condition is.
Stable ratings across two weeks would show only that students agree with the
same vague paragraph twice. Reliability is consistency of measurement, and a measure can be
perfectly consistent while measuring nothing the researcher claims: reliability is necessary
for validity but never sufficient.
Inter-rater reliability matters when human judges score open-ended material, as
with a projective test. Here the students score themselves on a fixed scale, so there are no
raters to agree, and agreement would still say nothing about whether the inventory captures
personality.
Correct. With every student receiving the same generic text, a mean of 4.2 is
fully explained by the Barnum effect: near-universal statements feel personal. A control
group given genuinely individualized profiles supplies the comparison: only if the
individualized profiles are rated clearly more accurate is the inventory adding
information.
Marcus is passed over for a solo. He tells his friends the choir director is jealous
of his voice, and that evening he snaps at his younger sister over something trivial. A
psychoanalytic theorist would name these two responses, in order, as
The order is reversed. Telling everyone the director is the jealous one comes
first and moves a feeling onto another person, which is projection; snapping at a sister
comes second and moves a target, which is displacement.
Correct. Projection attributes your own unacceptable feeling (here, envy) to
someone else. Displacement keeps the feeling and swaps the target for a safer one, which is
why the anger aimed at the director lands on a younger sibling instead. Remember the pair as:
projection moves the feeling, displacement moves the target.
Reaction formation would have Marcus acting conspicuously delighted for whoever
got the solo, expressing the opposite of what he feels. Rationalization would have him
producing an acceptable reason for the outcome, such as deciding he never wanted the part:
neither matches what he actually does.
Rationalization supplies a comfortable justification rather than accusing
someone else of the feeling. Regression would mean returning to behavior from an earlier
developmental stage, such as a tantrum, and snapping once at a sibling is ordinary displaced
irritation, not a return to childhood functioning.
Talia is confident she can work through a hard calculus problem set if she keeps at
it, and she persists for an hour when a problem resists her. She also believes she could never
give a decent speech, and she avoids the one presentation in the course. Which construct does
this pattern best illustrate?
Locus of control is a broad belief about what produces outcomes in general, your own effort versus luck and powerful others, so it would not flip between two courses in
the same semester. The scenario gives you a belief about capability in a specific domain, not
about where outcomes come from.
Self-esteem is a global evaluation of your own worth, which is why it changes
slowly and does not vary by subject. Talia's confidence is high in one task and low in
another, and that variation is the clue that the item is testing a task-specific
construct.
Correct. Self-efficacy is Bandura's term for the belief that you can carry out a
particular task, and it is domain-specific by definition: high for calculus, low for public
speaking, in the same person. It also predicts exactly what the scenario reports: persistence
in the high-efficacy task and avoidance in the low-efficacy one.
Reciprocal determinism is the three-way loop among personal factors, behavior,
and environment. It would apply if the scenario showed the avoidance changing her
environment, which then fed back onto the belief; as written, you are given the belief and
its immediate behavioral consequence.
Described data
Students worked on an interesting spatial puzzle in three sessions. In each session the
experimenter left the room for an 8-minute (480-second) break and said the students could do
whatever they liked; magazines lay on the table. In session 2 only, students in one group
earned $1 per puzzle solved. The table gives each group's mean number of seconds spent on the
puzzle during the unmonitored break.
Group
Session 1
Session 2
Session 3
Paid in session 2
205 s
290 s
155 s
Never paid
208 s
215 s
220 s
Which statement is best supported by the table?
Correct. Track the paid row against its own session 1 baseline: 205 to 290 while
the dollar was on offer, then down to 155, fifty seconds below where it started, after payment stopped. The never-paid row barely moves, which rules out simple boredom with
the puzzle and leaves the reward as the difference between the groups.
The session 2 mean is indeed the table's highest, but the claim is about what
happens afterwards, and session 3 answers it: 155 seconds is the table's lowest value. A
reward can raise behavior while it is delivered and still leave the behavior lower than
baseline once it is withdrawn.
Their means rise slightly across the three sessions, from 208 to 215 to 220
seconds. That flat-to-upward trend is what makes this group a useful comparison: whatever the
paid group's session 3 drop reflects, it is not the puzzle becoming dull with repetition.
Negative reinforcement means a behavior increases because it removes something
aversive, and nothing aversive is removed here. Payment is a positive reinforcer during
session 2; the interesting result is the overjustification effect that follows it, which is a
change in the reason for the behavior rather than a schedule of reinforcement.
Ana finishes a hard training run and meets a stranger at the finish line while her
heart is still pounding and her breathing has not settled. She later reports finding the
stranger unusually attractive. Which explanation fits the view that emotion requires arousal
plus a cognitive label drawn from the situation?
This is the body-first view, in which the emotion just is your reading of a specific
bodily pattern and no cognitive label from the situation is needed. Two-factor theory was
built precisely because the same racing heart can become fear, anger, or attraction depending
on what is around you.
This is the simultaneous view: arousal and emotional experience occur simultaneously, with
the thalamus routing the signal both ways and neither one producing the other. It is a real
theory but it cannot explain why the stranger, rather than the run, gets the credit.
The facial feedback hypothesis says expressions feed back into what is felt, and
it is worth treating cautiously since a large multi-laboratory replication failed to reproduce
the classic result. It also does not fit: the scenario gives you exertion and a pounding
heart, not a held smile.
Correct. Two-factor theory requires both ingredients, physical arousal plus a
cognitive label drawn from the situation, and the label is wrong here, which is what
misattribution of arousal means. Notice the condition the explanation depends on: the arousal
has to be unexplained, so if Ana consciously credited the run, the effect should disappear.
Described study
Researchers post a survey link in an online forum devoted to sleep advice. Over two weeks
1,200 forum members complete it, answering questions about their electronics use and their
sleep. Among respondents who report keeping a screen curfew in the hour before bed, 68% rate
their sleep quality as good or very good, compared with 41% of respondents with no curfew. The
researchers conclude that most adults would sleep better if they adopted a screen curfew.
Which of the following is the most serious threat to the researchers' conclusion?
Twelve hundred respondents is a large sample, and a 27-percentage-point gap is
not a subtle effect, so power is not the issue. Sample size and sample representativeness are
different problems: a huge sample drawn from the wrong population is still the wrong
population.
Correct. People who join a forum about sleep advice are already unusual in their
sleep habits and their interest in fixing them, and those who answered are volunteers within
that group, so this is volunteer bias layered on a convenience sample. Part E of an AAQ is
scored on this kind of participant evidence: name who was recruited and where, then say what
it does to the claim.
Self-report has real weaknesses, social desirability and response sets among
them, but it is standard, usable evidence when the construct is a private experience such as
perceived sleep quality. An answer that rejects a whole class of measurement is too strong to
be the best objection here.
This confuses the two randoms. Random assignment licenses causal
claims, and its absence does mean the curfew may not be what produced better sleep; random
selection is what licenses generalizing to a population. The conclusion quoted is a
generalization, so the sampling term is the one that applies.
Described data
Students were randomly assigned to use a vocabulary app or to a control activity for four
weeks, then took a 100-point vocabulary test. Reported with the table: the mean difference is
1.4 points, p = .02, and Cohen's d = 0.12.
Group
n
Mean test score
SD
Used the app
600
71.8
12.0
Control activity
600
70.4
12.0
Which statement is best supported by these results?
Significance and size are separate questions, and this is the confusion data
analysis items are built to catch. A p-value says a difference this large is unlikely if the
app truly did nothing; only the effect size says whether the difference is worth anything, and
d = 0.12 is small by any convention.
A p-value is the probability of a result at least this extreme if the null
hypothesis were true, not the probability that the null hypothesis is true, and not the
probability the finding will replicate. Reversing the conditional is the single most common
error with p-values.
Correct. Both readings are in the numbers: 71.8 minus 70.4 is a 1.4-point gap,
p = .02 clears the conventional .05 cutoff, and 1.4 divided by the standard deviation of 12.0
gives d ≈ 0.12. Power is why both are true at once, with 600 students per group, even a
trivial difference becomes detectable, which is exactly why effect size is reported
alongside.
A Type II error is missing a real effect: failing to reject a null
hypothesis that is false. These researchers detected an effect, so if they erred it would be a
Type I error, a false alarm; and a small effect size is not itself evidence of any error.
Your body evolved to respond quickly to threats, and that response is a lifesaver when a car swerves toward you. The trouble comes when the alarm keeps ringing over weeks and months because of exams, money worries, or conflict at home. Health psychology studies how psychological, behavioral, and social factors affect physical health and wellness, and how to prevent illness and promote healthy behavior. Its central topic is stress, the process by which we appraise and respond to events (stressors) that we perceive as threatening or challenging. This lesson covers the kinds of stressors, the body's response, the way stress affects health, and the two main ways of coping. These are tested in many applied questions, so be ready to match a scenario to a concept and to evaluate a coping plan.
Required content · 5.1.A, 5.1.B, 5.1.C, 5.1.D
Learning objectives.
5.1.A. Explain how health psychology addresses issues of physical health and wellness as they apply to behavior and mental processes.
5.1.B. Explain how stress applies to behavior and mental processes.
5.1.C. Explain how reactions to stress apply to behavior and mental processes.
5.1.D. Explain how the ways that people cope with stress applies to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
5.1.B.1. Stress is a factor in heightened susceptibility to disorders and disease. Stress has been linked to physiological issues such as hypertension, headaches, and immune suppression.
5.1.B.2. Stressors can be viewed as motivating (eustress) or debilitating (distress). Stressors can be experienced as traumatic or as daily hassles that can build up over time. Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are sources of stress that can affect a person throughout the lifespan.
5.1.C.1. The general adaptation syndrome (GAS) describes the process of experiencing stress. Initially, alarm reaction occurs when the stress is encountered (via a fight-flight-freeze response). Then, a resistance phase occurs as the stress is confronted. Finally, an exhaustion phase occurs when the stress subsides, or resources are spent. The greatest susceptibility to illness occurs during the exhaustion phase. 1.B 3.A 3.B 114
5.1.C.2. The tend-and-befriend theory proposes that some people react to stress by tending to their own needs and/or the needs of others and seeking connection with others. This phenomenon seems to occur mostly in women.
5.1.D.1. Problem-focused coping involves seeing stress as a problem to be solved and working solutions until a solution is found.
5.1.D.2. Emotion-focused coping involves managing emotional reactions to stress as a means of coping. Strategies that are emotion-focused may include deep breathing, meditation, or taking medication aimed at reducing stressful emotional responses. 115
Stressors: kinds and sources
A stressor is any event or circumstance that we appraise as threatening or challenging. Stressors vary:
Eustress is a stressor that is viewed as motivating and positive, such as a challenging project, a race, or a wedding; it energizes us and may improve performance.
Distress is a stressor that is viewed as debilitating, such as an overwhelming workload or the loss of a loved one.
Traumatic events (disasters, assault, combat) are extreme, sudden stressors.
Daily hassles are the small, everyday irritations (traffic, a broken printer, arguments). Richard Lazarus found that these can build up over time and may predict health problems better than major life events.
Adverse childhood experiences (Lesson 3.7) are sources of stress that can affect a person throughout life.
Whether an event is stressful depends on how it is appraised, so the same event can be eustress for one person and distress for another. Stress is also affected by feelings of control and predictability, and by social support.
The general adaptation syndrome
Hans Selye studied how the body responds to many different stressors and described the general adaptation syndrome (GAS), a three-phase pattern:
Figure 5.1. Selye's general adaptation syndrome. Resistance to stress first drops in the alarm reaction, then rises above normal during resistance, and finally falls during exhaustion, when susceptibility to illness is greatest.
Alarm reaction: when the stress is first encountered, the sympathetic nervous system activates the fight-flight-freeze response: adrenaline and cortisol are released, heart rate and blood pressure rise, and energy is mobilized. Resistance to stress temporarily drops at first, then rises.
Resistance: if the stressor continues, the body adapts and stays on alert, coping with it. Physiological arousal remains higher than normal even though the person may seem to be coping.
Exhaustion: when the stress continues for a long time or resources are spent, the body's reserves are depleted. The greatest susceptibility to illness occurs during this phase.
The model shows that the stress response is adaptive in the short term but harmful if it is prolonged.
Stress and health
Chronic stress is a factor in heightened susceptibility to disorders and diseases. It has been linked to hypertension (high blood pressure) and heart disease, headaches, digestive problems, sleep problems, depression and anxiety, and immune suppression: the stress hormone cortisol, when elevated for a long time, reduces the activity of the immune system, so people are more likely to get infections and heal more slowly. The field that studies the connections among psychology, the nervous system, and the immune system is called psychoneuroimmunology.
Study spotlight · Stress and wound healing (Marucha, Kiecolt-Glaser, and Favagehi, 1998)
Researchers gave dental students a small standardized wound (a punch biopsy on the roof of the mouth) twice: once during a summer vacation (low stress), and once three days before a major exam (high stress). The wounds healed about 40 percent more slowly during the exam period than during the vacation.
Reading the research: a within-subjects (repeated measures) design in which each student served as his or her own control, which reduces the effect of individual differences. The study shows that stress can slow a physical process connected to the immune system. Limits: the sample was small and consisted of young, healthy dental students, and the order of the conditions was not randomized for all participants, so other differences between summer and exam time (sleep, diet) may play a role.
Reactions to stress
People do not all respond to stress in the same way. The fight-flight-freeze response is usually described as the typical reaction. Tend-and-befriend theory, proposed by Shelley Taylor, suggests that some people react to stress by tending (protecting and caring for themselves and others, particularly children) and befriending (seeking social connection and support). The theory proposes that this pattern occurs mostly in women, and it may be related to the hormone oxytocin. Social support in general is a powerful buffer against the effects of stress.
Coping with stress
Coping is the effort to manage stressors and the emotions they cause. Two main styles were described by Richard Lazarus and Susan Folkman:
Problem-focused coping treats stress as a problem to be solved and works to change or remove the source: making a study schedule, asking a teacher for help, confronting a conflict. It works best when the situation can be changed.
Emotion-focused coping manages the emotional reaction to the stress when the stressor cannot be changed or while it is being addressed. Strategies include deep breathing, meditation, relaxation, talking to a friend, exercise, or taking medication that reduces the emotional response.
Most people use both, and the best choice depends on the situation: problem-focused coping is more useful when the stressor is controllable, and emotion-focused when it is not (such as the death of a loved one). Other helpful factors include social support, exercise, a sense of control, sleep, and a sense of humor.
Worked example · Match the GAS phase
Name the phase. (a) A student's heart pounds and her hands shake when she learns that her exam is tomorrow. (b) Weeks later, she continues to work long hours and stays alert, although she is tired. (c) By finals week, she is worn out, and catches a cold.
Step 1, (a) alarm reaction: sympathetic arousal.
Step 2, (b) resistance: the body copes with continued stress.
Step 3, (c) exhaustion: reserves depleted, and susceptibility to illness is highest.
Worked example · Problem-focused or emotion-focused?
Classify each. (a) A worker overwhelmed by tasks makes a priority list and asks for help. (b) A person whose parent has died practices meditation and talks with friends. (c) A student worried about a failing grade meets with the teacher to ask what to do. (d) A person who is anxious before a speech does deep breathing.
Step 1, (a) problem-focused (attacking the source).
Step 2, (b) emotion-focused (the situation cannot be changed).
Step 3, (c) problem-focused.
Step 4, (d) emotion-focused (managing anxiety), though practicing the speech would be problem-focused.
Worked example · Evaluate the wound-healing data
Wounds took 40 days to heal in the exam period and 24 days in the vacation period for a student. Calculate the percent difference in healing time, and say what can and cannot be concluded.
Step 1, the difference is \(40-24=16\) days.
Step 2, relative to the vacation time, \(16\div24\approx0.667\), so healing took about 67% longer (equivalently, healing was slower by a large amount).
Step 3, what can be concluded: wounds healed more slowly in the exam period, consistent with stress suppressing the immune function.
Step 4, what cannot: that stress was the only cause, since other changes (sleep, diet, smoking) may also differ between the periods, and one student is not enough; the study used a group of students.
Chronic stress links to hypertension, headaches, and immune suppression (psychoneuroimmunology).
Tend-and-befriend. Problem-focused (solve the problem) and emotion-focused (manage feelings) coping.
Practice
Distinguish eustress from distress.
Show answer
Eustress is stress viewed as motivating or positive; distress is stress viewed as debilitating.
Describe the three phases of the general adaptation syndrome.
Show answer
Alarm (fight-flight-freeze arousal), resistance (the body copes with the continuing stressor), and exhaustion (resources are depleted and illness susceptibility is greatest).
Why can daily hassles harm health?
Show answer
They accumulate over time and keep the stress response active, which can lead to chronic stress effects.
What is the tend-and-befriend response?
Show answer
A reaction to stress in which people care for themselves and others and seek social connection; it is thought to occur mostly in women.
When is emotion-focused coping more useful than problem-focused coping?
Show answer
When the stressor cannot be changed, such as a death or a diagnosis, so managing the emotional reaction is more effective.
Name two physical health effects associated with chronic stress.
Show answer
Hypertension, headaches, and immune suppression (also heart disease and slower healing).
For most of its history, psychology focused on what goes wrong: disorders, deficits, and problems. In the late 1990s, Martin Seligman and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi argued that psychology should also study what makes life go well. Positive psychology seeks to identify the factors that lead to well-being, resilience, positive emotions, and psychological health. It does not deny suffering, but it asks about the conditions that help people and communities thrive. This lesson covers the three ideas that the exam emphasizes: gratitude, signature strengths and virtues, and posttraumatic growth. Because positive psychology produces simple, practical interventions, the exam often asks you to read a study of one and decide what it shows.
Required content · 5.2.A, 5.2.B
Learning objectives.
5.2.A. Explain how positive psychology approaches the study of behavior and mental processes.
5.2.B. Explain how positive subjective experiences apply to behavior and mental processes.
Essential knowledge.
5.2.A.1. Positive psychology seeks to identify factors that lead to well-being, resilience, positive emotions, and psychological health.
5.2.B.1. Expressing gratitude, a positive subjective experience, increases subjective well-being.
5.2.B.2. People who exercise their signature strengths or virtues report higher levels of positive objective experiences such as happiness and subjective well-being. A classification of character strengths has been developed around 6 categories of virtues: wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, and transcendence.
5.2.B.3. Posttraumatic growth, a positive subjective experience, may result after the experience of trauma or stress. 1.B 2.C 4.A 116
Well-being
Subjective well-being is a person's self-evaluation of life: a high level of positive emotions, a low level of negative emotions, and a general sense of satisfaction with life. It is usually measured by self-report scales. Research finds that well-being is related to close relationships, health, meaningful work, and a sense of purpose. Income matters most at lower levels, when it helps to meet basic needs, and has smaller effects above that. People also tend to adapt to changes (the hedonic treadmill), so a raise or a new purchase gives a boost that fades.
Another positive state is flow, described by Csikszentmihalyi: complete absorption in a challenging activity that matches your skills, so that you lose track of time. It is common in sports, music, and craftwork, and is associated with satisfaction.
Gratitude
Expressing gratitude, a positive subjective experience, increases subjective well-being. Gratitude is the appreciation of the good in one's life and of what others have done for us.
Study spotlight · Counting blessings (Emmons and McCullough, 2003)
Robert Emmons and Michael McCullough randomly assigned college students to one of three groups. Each week for ten weeks, one group wrote down up to five things they were grateful for ("gratitude" group). A second group wrote down five hassles from the week, and a third group wrote down five events that had affected them, without a focus on emotion (neutral). The gratitude group reported feeling better about their lives as a whole, was more optimistic about the coming week, reported fewer physical complaints, and spent more time exercising than the other groups.
Reading the research: an experiment with random assignment, supporting a causal claim that the gratitude exercise increased well-being. It also used self-report measures, which can be influenced by demand characteristics (participants may guess what researchers want), and the sample was made up of college students. Later studies have found that the effect is real but often modest, and that it varies among people and cultures.
Another intervention is the gratitude visit: writing a letter to someone to whom you are grateful and delivering it in person. In one study by Seligman and colleagues (2005), this produced a large increase in happiness that lasted about a month, a larger and longer effect than some other exercises.
Signature strengths and virtues
Christopher Peterson and Martin Seligman developed a classification of character strengths organized around six categories of virtues that appear across cultures. Signature strengths are the character strengths that a person possesses most strongly and uses most often. The six virtues, each with some of its strengths, are:
Virtue
Examples of strengths
Wisdom
Creativity, curiosity, open-mindedness, love of learning, perspective
Courage
Bravery, perseverance, honesty, zest
Humanity
Love, kindness, social intelligence
Justice
Teamwork, fairness, leadership
Temperance
Forgiveness, humility, prudence, self-regulation
Transcendence
Appreciation of beauty, gratitude, hope, humor, spirituality
People who identify their signature strengths and apply them in new ways (for example, using humor or curiosity at work or school) report higher levels of positive experiences such as happiness, and higher subjective well-being. A well-known test is the VIA Survey of Character Strengths. Critics note that the classification is based on the researchers' judgment about what counts as a virtue, may reflect Western values, and that strengths-based interventions are generally modest in effect.
Posttraumatic growth
Trauma and severe stress are painful and can lead to disorders (Lesson 5.8), but some people report positive changes after them. Posttraumatic growth, a concept from Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun, is positive psychological change that results from struggling with highly challenging circumstances. People describe greater appreciation of life, closer relationships, a sense of personal strength, new possibilities, and spiritual or existential change. Growth is not guaranteed, and it does not mean that the person did not suffer; it often occurs along with distress. It is also different from simple resilience, which is returning to normal functioning after adversity. Researchers are cautious because growth is usually measured by self-report, and people may overstate it.
Worked example · Which concept?
Name the concept. (a) A person writes a thank-you letter to a teacher and reads it aloud. (b) A student who is naturally curious takes a job that involves research. (c) A cancer survivor says that the illness taught her what matters and brought her closer to her family. (d) An athlete loses track of time during a close match.
Step 1, (a) gratitude (the gratitude visit).
Step 2, (b) using a signature strength (curiosity, under the virtue of wisdom).
Step 3, (c) posttraumatic growth.
Step 4, (d) flow.
Worked example · Evaluate the gratitude experiment
In a gratitude study, 60 students are randomly assigned (20 each) to gratitude, hassles, and neutral groups, and the mean well-being ratings (scale 1 to 9) at week 10 are 7.0, 5.8, and 6.1. Interpret.
Step 1, the gratitude group's mean is higher by \(7.0-5.8=1.2\) than the hassles group and by \(7.0-6.1=0.9\) than the neutral group.
Step 2, the independent variable is the type of writing task; the dependent variable is the well-being rating.
Step 3, because of random assignment, the differences are likely caused by the exercise, if the differences are statistically significant.
Step 4, limits: self-report ratings, the possibility of demand characteristics, students only, and no data about long-term effects. A good follow-up would test other groups and measure behavior.
Worked example · Strengths and virtues
Match each strength with its virtue. (a) Forgiveness. (b) Fairness. (c) Bravery. (d) Kindness. (e) Hope.
Step 1, (a) forgiveness belongs to temperance.
Step 2, (b) fairness belongs to justice.
Step 3, (c) bravery belongs to courage.
Step 4, (d) kindness belongs to humanity.
Step 5, (e) hope belongs to transcendence.
Exam focus
Positive psychology studies well-being, resilience, positive emotions, and health; flow; the hedonic treadmill.
Gratitude increases well-being (Emmons and McCullough; gratitude visit).
Signature strengths and six virtues: wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, transcendence.
Posttraumatic growth: positive change after struggle; differs from resilience.
Practice
What is the goal of positive psychology?
Show answer
To identify the factors that lead to well-being, resilience, positive emotions, and psychological health.
How did Emmons and McCullough test the effect of gratitude?
Show answer
They randomly assigned students to write weekly about things they were grateful for, hassles, or neutral events, and compared their well-being; the gratitude group did better.
Name the six virtues in the classification of character strengths.
Show answer
Wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, and transcendence.
What is posttraumatic growth and how is it different from resilience?
Show answer
Positive psychological change that results from struggling with a highly challenging experience; resilience is simply returning to normal functioning after adversity.
Why are self-report measures a limitation in positive psychology research?
Show answer
Participants may give socially desirable answers or guess what the researchers want (demand characteristics), and they may overstate growth or happiness.
Which virtue includes the strength of self-regulation?
Show answer
Everyone feels sad, worried, or odd at times. When does ordinary distress become a psychological disorder, a pattern of thoughts, feelings, or behaviors that is deviant, distressing, and dysfunctional? There is no single dividing line, and where it is drawn matters a great deal, because a label can lead to treatment, insurance coverage, and understanding, but it can also bring stigma, and it can be applied unfairly. This lesson covers the criteria for identifying a disorder, the consequences of diagnosis, and the manuals that clinicians use to classify disorders. It prepares you for the next lesson, which covers the perspectives psychologists use to explain disorders, and for the specific disorders that follow.
Required content · 5.3.A
Learning objective.
5.3.A. Describe the approaches used to define behaviors and mental processes as psychological disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.3.A.1. Level of dysfunction, perception of distress, and deviation from the social norm are all factors used to identify psychological disorders.
5.3.A.2. Diagnosing or classifying psychological disorders has positive and negative consequences depending on the nature of the disorder, the individual being diagnosed, and the presence of cultural/societal norms, stigma, racism, sexism, ageism, and discrimination.
5.3.A.3. Diagnosing psychological disorders requires specialized training and the use of evidence-based diagnostic tools. The American Psychiatric Association developed the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) of Mental Disorders to classify mental disorders. The World Health Organization developed the International Classification of Mental Disorders (ICD) to classify mental disorders. These classification systems are updated regularly to be responsive to new research and practice advances.
Criteria for a disorder
Psychologists use several factors, and no one factor decides it alone.
Level of dysfunction: the behavior or thoughts interfere with the person's ability to function in daily life, such as work, school, relationships, or self-care. A student who is so anxious that she cannot leave home shows dysfunction.
Perception of distress: the person experiences significant suffering, or causes suffering for others. (Some conditions, such as a manic episode, may not feel distressing to the person but still harm them.)
Deviation from the social norm: the behavior is unusual or violates the norms of the person's culture. This criterion is the most problematic, since being unusual is not in itself a disorder (a person with exceptional talents is statistically rare), and norms differ among cultures and change over time. Behavior can be seen as normal in one culture, such as hearing the voices of ancestors in a religious ritual, and as pathological in another. In history, behaviors such as homosexuality and, for women, being assertive have been classified as disorders because of social norms.
Some clinicians also use danger to self or others and irrationality as criteria. The combination of the criteria, considering the cultural context, is more reliable than any one on its own.
Consequences of diagnosis
Diagnosing and classifying disorders has positive and negative consequences, depending on the nature of the disorder, the person being diagnosed, and cultural and societal norms.
Possible benefits: it gives clinicians a shared language, guides treatment choices that research shows to be effective, helps researchers to study causes, allows insurance coverage and access to services, and can give a person relief and a sense of understanding ("there is a name for what I have").
Possible harms: the label can bring stigma (negative judgment and discrimination), can lead people to be defined by the diagnosis, can become a self-fulfilling prophecy (Lesson 4.2), and can be applied unfairly because of bias. Evidence shows that racism, sexism, ageism, and discrimination can influence who is diagnosed and with what. For example, studies have found that Black Americans are more likely than white Americans to be diagnosed with schizophrenia, even with similar symptoms, which may reflect clinician bias and a lack of cultural understanding. Overdiagnosis (labeling normal variation as a disorder) and underdiagnosis (missing a disorder) both occur, and cultural differences in how people express distress can lead to misreading.
Study spotlight · Being sane in insane places (Rosenhan, 1973)
David Rosenhan and seven other mentally healthy people (the "pseudopatients") went to different psychiatric hospitals and reported one symptom, hearing a voice saying words such as "thud" and "empty." All were admitted, and all but one were diagnosed with schizophrenia. After admission, they acted normally and said that they felt fine. They stayed an average of 19 days (range 7 to 52) before they were released, with a diagnosis of "schizophrenia in remission." Staff did not detect them, but other patients often did ("You're not crazy. You're a journalist or a professor"). Rosenhan also reported that staff interpreted normal behavior (such as note taking) as a symptom. In a follow-up, a hospital was told that pseudopatients would try to be admitted, and it identified many real patients as pseudopatients, though none had been sent.
Reading the research: a field study with a small sample and no control group, so it cannot show how often misdiagnosis occurs. It suggests that diagnostic labels can strongly bias how behavior is interpreted, and it helped to produce reforms in diagnostic criteria. Critics have questioned the details of the study, including how the data were reported, and have noted that modern criteria and practice are more precise. It also raises ethical issues, since the hospitals did not consent to be tested.
Diagnostic manuals
Diagnosis requires specialized training and evidence-based diagnostic tools, such as structured interviews, standardized questionnaires, and observation, since symptoms of different disorders overlap and may result from medical conditions. Two systems classify disorders:
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), published by the American Psychiatric Association, is the most widely used in the United States. It lists disorders with specific criteria (the symptoms required, the duration, and the effect on functioning). The current edition is the DSM-5 (with text revisions).
The International Classification of Diseases (ICD), published by the World Health Organization (WHO), includes a chapter on mental disorders and is used around the world.
Both systems are revised regularly in response to new research and clinical experience. Over the years, disorders have been added, changed, or removed; for example, homosexuality was removed from the DSM in the 1970s. A strength of the manuals is that they make diagnoses more reliable (different clinicians are more likely to agree), and a weakness is that categories can be arbitrary (symptoms often vary along a continuum) and can be influenced by culture and politics.
Worked example · Apply the criteria
A person hears loud music at night and dances in a trance at a ceremony in her community. A second person, who has never taken part in a ritual, hears voices telling him to harm himself, cannot work, and is terrified. Evaluate whether each shows a disorder.
Step 1, the first person's behavior deviates from the norm of the broader society, but it is accepted in her culture, causes no distress, and does not interfere with functioning, so it is not a disorder.
Step 2, the second shows dysfunction (cannot work), distress (terror), and a danger to self, and is not a cultural practice, so it is likely to be a disorder and needs evaluation.
Step 3, lesson: deviation from the norm alone is not enough. Culture must be considered.
Worked example · Weigh the consequences of a label
A teen is diagnosed with ADHD. List one possible benefit and one possible harm.
Step 1, benefit: access to accommodations at school, effective treatment (such as behavioral strategies or medication), and an explanation for difficulties that reduces self-blame.
Step 2, harm: stigma, lowered expectations from teachers (a self-fulfilling prophecy), and being defined by the label. If the diagnosis was wrong, the child may receive unnecessary treatment.
Step 3, a balanced conclusion: accurate diagnosis by a trained clinician using evidence-based tools tends to help, and the risks can be reduced by respect and cultural sensitivity.
Worked example · Analyze Rosenhan's evidence
Evaluate the claim that "Rosenhan proved that psychiatric diagnosis is useless."
Step 1, the study showed that one reported symptom led to admission and that labels influenced how staff interpreted behavior, which shows the risk of diagnostic bias.
Step 2, the study was small (eight pseudopatients), with no control group of real patients, and it could not show how often errors occur.
Step 3, diagnostic criteria and procedures have changed since 1973, and modern manuals use more specific criteria.
Step 4, a defensible claim: the study showed that diagnosis can be unreliable and biased when it relies on limited information, and it motivated reforms, but it did not show that diagnosis is useless.
Exam focus
Disorder criteria: dysfunction, distress, deviation from social norms (the weakest alone; culture matters).
DSM (American Psychiatric Association) and ICD (World Health Organization) are revised regularly. Diagnosis requires training and evidence-based tools. Rosenhan's study shows the risk of labels.
Practice
List the three main factors used to identify a psychological disorder.
Show answer
Level of dysfunction, perception of distress, and deviation from the social norm.
Why is deviation from social norms an insufficient criterion by itself?
Show answer
Norms differ among cultures and change over time, and being unusual is not always harmful; some behavior that is normal in one culture would be a disorder in another.
Give one positive and one negative consequence of diagnosis.
Show answer
Positive: access to effective treatment and services. Negative: stigma and possible biased labeling.
Which organization publishes the DSM, and which publishes the ICD?
Show answer
The American Psychiatric Association publishes the DSM; the World Health Organization publishes the ICD.
What did Rosenhan's pseudopatient study suggest?
Show answer
That diagnostic labels can strongly bias how behavior is interpreted by staff, and that diagnosis can be unreliable without careful criteria.
Why are the manuals revised regularly?
Show answer
To reflect new research and clinical practice and to correct earlier errors or biases.
Why do psychological disorders happen? Is a person's depression due to a chemical imbalance, a way of thinking, an upbringing, or a stressful life? The answer depends on whom you ask, since each perspective in psychology offers its own explanation. This lesson reviews the perspectives you have met in the course and applies each to the question of disorders, then introduces two interaction models that combine them: the biopsychosocial model and the diathesis-stress model. Understanding these frameworks will help you with the lessons that follow, which describe specific disorders and their possible causes, and with the questions that ask you to apply a perspective to a case.
Required content · 5.3.B, 5.3.C
Learning objectives.
5.3.B. Explain how psychological perspectives define psychological disorders.
5.3.C. Explain how interaction models define psychological disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.3.B.1. Most psychologists employ an eclectic approach (using more than one psychological perspective) when diagnosing and treating clients. 1.B 2.D 4.B 117
5.3.B.2. The behavioral perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on maladaptive learned associations between or among responses to stimuli.
5.3.B.3. The psychodynamic perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on unconscious thoughts and experiences, often developed during childhood.
5.3.B.4. The humanistic perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on a lack of social support and being unable to fulfill one’s potential.
5.3.B.5. The cognitive perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on maladaptive thoughts, beliefs, attitudes, or emotions.
5.3.B.6. The evolutionary perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on behaviors and mental processes that reduce the likelihood of survival.
5.3.B.7. The sociocultural perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on maladaptive social and cultural relationships and dynamics.
5.3.B.8. The biological perspective proposes that the causes of mental disorders focus on physiological or genetic issues.
5.3.C.1. The biopsychosocial model assumes that any psychological problem potentially involves a combination of biological, psychological, and sociocultural factors.
5.3.C.2. The diathesis-stress model assumes that psychological disorders develop due to a genetic vulnerability (diathesis) in combination with stressful life experiences (stress). 118
An eclectic approach
Most psychologists employ an eclectic approach, using more than one perspective when diagnosing and treating clients, because disorders usually have several causes and no single perspective fits every person. Each perspective focuses on different causes.
Perspectives on the causes of disorders
Perspective
Proposes that disorders result from...
Example (a phobia of dogs)
Behavioral
Maladaptive learned associations between stimuli and responses
A dog bite (UCS) conditioned fear of dogs (CS); avoidance is reinforced because it reduces anxiety
Psychodynamic
Unconscious thoughts and conflicts, often developed in childhood
Fear of dogs symbolizes a repressed fear of a parent or a conflict from childhood
Humanistic
A lack of social support and being unable to fulfill one's potential
A lack of acceptance blocks growth and leaves the person anxious and inhibited
Cognitive
Maladaptive thoughts, beliefs, attitudes, or emotions
The person thinks "all dogs are dangerous and will attack me"
Evolutionary
Behaviors and mental processes that reduce the chance of survival, or that were once adaptive but are no longer (a "mismatch")
Fear of animals that can harm helped early humans survive, and may be exaggerated now
Sociocultural
Maladaptive social and cultural relationships and dynamics (family, culture, poverty, discrimination)
A culture or family that models fearful reactions to dogs
Biological
Physiological or genetic problems (brain structure, neurotransmitters, heredity)
An overactive amygdala and an inherited tendency toward anxiety
Each perspective leads to different treatments (Lesson 5.9 and Lesson 5.10): behavioral and cognitive approaches teach new associations and thinking, psychodynamic approaches explore unconscious conflicts, humanistic approaches offer acceptance, and biological approaches use medication or brain stimulation.
Interaction models
Two models combine factors instead of choosing one cause.
The biopsychosocial model assumes that any psychological problem potentially involves a combination of biological factors (genes, brain chemistry, health), psychological factors (thoughts, emotions, learned behavior, coping), and sociocultural factors (family, culture, relationships, economic conditions, discrimination). All three interact. For example, depression may be influenced by a genetic tendency, negative thinking patterns, and the loss of a job and social support. This model is the most widely used in modern psychology and medicine, and it supports treatment plans that combine approaches (such as medication plus therapy).
The diathesis-stress model assumes that disorders develop due to a genetic vulnerability (diathesis) in combination with stressful life experiences (stress). Neither alone is enough: a person with a vulnerability may never develop the disorder without enough stress, and a person with low vulnerability may be able to withstand high stress. The more vulnerable a person is, the less stress is needed to trigger the disorder. The model is often applied to schizophrenia and depression.
Study spotlight · Genes, stress, and depression (Caspi and colleagues, 2003)
Avshalom Caspi and colleagues followed about 1,000 New Zealanders from birth to age 26 in the Dunedin longitudinal study. They examined a variant of a gene that affects serotonin transport (the 5-HTT gene, with a "short" or "long" form) and recorded stressful life events between ages 21 and 26. Among people who had experienced several stressful events, those with one or two copies of the short form of the gene were more likely to become depressed than people with two long forms. Without stressful events, the gene variant was not associated with greater depression.
Reading the research: a longitudinal, correlational study, so it cannot show a cause, but it is a well-known example of the diathesis-stress model, in which vulnerability and stress interact. Later studies and analyses of many studies have had mixed results, and the effect may be smaller than first reported, which shows the need for replication. Genes in general rarely have large single effects.
Worked example · Match the perspective
Name the perspective for each explanation of a person's depression. (a) "He has an imbalance in serotonin and runs in the family." (b) "She believes she is worthless and expects to fail." (c) "He was rewarded for staying home, so he stopped going out." (d) "She is isolated and has faced discrimination." (e) "He has unresolved childhood conflicts."
Step 1, (a) biological.
Step 2, (b) cognitive.
Step 3, (c) behavioral.
Step 4, (d) sociocultural.
Step 5, (e) psychodynamic.
Worked example · Diathesis-stress
Two siblings go through a parent's death. Anna has a family history of anxiety disorders, and she develops an anxiety disorder after the death. Her brother Ben has no family history and does not. Explain with the model, and say what it predicts if Ben had been through many more stressors.
Step 1, Anna has a diathesis (genetic vulnerability); the death provided the stress, and together they triggered the disorder.
Step 2, Ben has low vulnerability, so the same stress was not enough.
Step 3, if Ben faced many more severe stressors, he might eventually develop symptoms as well, since high enough stress can overcome low vulnerability.
Step 4, a limit of the explanation: it is difficult to measure vulnerability directly, and Anna's environment may also differ in other ways.
Worked example · Use the biopsychosocial model
A teen develops an eating disorder. List one biological, one psychological, and one sociocultural factor.
Step 1, biological: genetic risk and hormonal changes in puberty.
Step 2, psychological: perfectionism and a negative body image.
Step 3, sociocultural: media images of thinness and peer pressure about weight.
Step 4, the model predicts that treatment may need to address all three levels (medical care, therapy, and family or community support).
Exam focus
Eclectic approach: using more than one perspective.
Behavioral (learned associations), psychodynamic (unconscious conflict), humanistic (lack of support and unfulfilled potential), cognitive (maladaptive thoughts), evolutionary (survival-reducing behavior), sociocultural (social and cultural dynamics), biological (physiology and genes).
Biopsychosocial model: biological, psychological, and sociocultural factors interact. Diathesis-stress: genetic vulnerability plus stress.
Practice
Why do most psychologists use an eclectic approach?
Show answer
Disorders usually have multiple causes, and no single perspective explains all cases, so combining perspectives gives a fuller picture and better treatment.
Explain how the cognitive perspective would explain depression.
Show answer
By maladaptive thoughts and beliefs, such as seeing oneself, the world, and the future negatively.
Distinguish diathesis from stress in the diathesis-stress model.
Show answer
The diathesis is the genetic (inherited) vulnerability to a disorder; the stress is the life experiences that can trigger it.
How is the biopsychosocial model different from a purely biological explanation?
Show answer
It includes psychological and sociocultural factors as well as biological ones, and says that they interact.
What did Caspi's study suggest about the 5-HTT gene?
Show answer
The short form of the gene increased the risk of depression only among people who had experienced many stressful events, supporting the diathesis-stress model.
Which perspective emphasizes unconscious childhood conflicts as a cause of disorders?
Show answer
Neurodevelopmental and schizophrenic spectrum disorders
The next four lessons describe the specific disorders that the AP course covers. For each category, learn the defining symptoms, which are what you would use to identify the disorder in a case study, and the possible causes, which come from the perspectives of the previous lesson. Remember that only a trained clinician can diagnose a disorder, and that these descriptions are for learning, not for labeling yourself or others. This lesson covers two groups: neurodevelopmental disorders, which begin early in life, and the schizophrenic spectrum disorders, which are among the most serious. In both, biology plays an important role, though experience matters too.
Required content · 5.4.A, 5.4.B
Learning objectives.
5.4.A. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected neurodevelopmental disorders.
5.4.B. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected schizophrenic spectrum disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.4.A.1. Neurodevelopmental disorders are a group of disorders with onset occurring during the developmental period. Symptoms of neurodevelopmental disorders focus on whether the person is exhibiting behaviors appropriate for their age or maturity range. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
5.4.A.2. Possible causes of neurodevelopmental disorders may be environmental, physiological, or genetic in nature. 1.A 2.D 3.A 4.A 119
5.4.B.1. Schizophrenic spectrum disorders are characterized by issues in one or more of these five areas: delusions, hallucinations, disorganized thinking or speech, disorganized motor behavior, and negative symptoms. Schizophrenia can be experienced as an acute or chronic condition.
5.4.B.1.i. Delusions (false beliefs) are positive symptoms and may manifest in ways such as delusions of persecution or grandeur.
5.4.B.1.ii. Hallucinations (false perceptions) are positive symptoms and may involve one or more of the senses.
5.4.B.1.iii. Disorganized thinking or speech is a positive symptom and may manifest as speaking in ways such as speaking in a word salad (stringing together words in nonsensical ways).
5.4.B.1.iv. Disorganized motor behavior may manifest as catatonia. Catatonia, or disordered movement, may be experienced as excitement (a positive symptom manifestation) or stupor (a negative symptom manifestation).
5.4.B.1.v. Negative symptoms present as the lack of a typical behavior, such as the lack of emotional expression (flat affect) or lack of movement (catatonic stupor).
5.4.B.2. Possible causes of schizophrenia suggest a genetic or biological link, such as prenatal virus exposure or imbalances with certain neurotransmitters (dopamine hypothesis).
Neurodevelopmental disorders
Neurodevelopmental disorders are a group of disorders with onset during the developmental period, typically before a child enters school. The symptoms focus on whether the person's behavior is appropriate for their age or maturity. The two in scope for AP Psychology are ADHD and ASD.
ADHD is characterized by a persistent pattern of inattention (difficulty sustaining attention, careless mistakes, losing things, being easily distracted), hyperactivity (excessive movement, fidgeting, talking), and impulsivity (acting without thinking, interrupting, difficulty waiting a turn). The symptoms must begin in childhood, appear in more than one setting (such as home and school), and interfere with functioning. It affects roughly 5 to 7 percent of children, is diagnosed more often in boys, though girls are often underdiagnosed because they more often show inattentive symptoms, and it often continues into adulthood. A child who is a "normal" active child differs in the severity and persistence of the symptoms.
### Autism spectrum disorder (ASD)
ASD is characterized by two core types of symptoms: persistent difficulties in social communication and interaction (such as difficulty with back-and-forth conversation, eye contact, nonverbal communication, and forming relationships), and restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, or activities (such as hand flapping, insistence on sameness and routines, intense focused interests, and unusual sensory reactions). It is called a spectrum because the symptoms and the support needed vary widely, from people who need substantial support to people who live independently. Symptoms appear in early childhood. Many people with ASD show strengths, such as attention to detail, and the condition is increasingly viewed in terms of neurodiversity (natural variation in brain function), while support and accommodations remain important. (Recall the theory of mind research in Lesson 3.4.)
### Possible causes
Possible causes of neurodevelopmental disorders may be environmental, physiological, or genetic. Twin studies show that both ADHD and ASD are highly heritable (many genes, each with a small effect). Differences in brain structure and function (such as in the prefrontal cortex and in dopamine regulation in ADHD) have been found. Prenatal and early environmental factors, such as premature birth, prenatal exposure to alcohol or tobacco, and other risks, may contribute. One well-known claim, that vaccines cause autism, was based on a fraudulent 1998 paper that was retracted, and large studies of millions of children have found no link.
Schizophrenic spectrum disorders
Schizophrenia is a severe disorder involving a break from reality, which affects about 1 percent of people, with onset typically in late adolescence or early adulthood. It can be acute (short-term, with rapid onset) or chronic (long-lasting, with a gradual onset), and it is characterized by issues in one or more of five areas. Some are positive symptoms (the presence of something that is not normally there), and some are negative symptoms (the absence of a typical behavior).
Delusions (false beliefs): positive symptoms, such as delusions of persecution (believing that others are plotting against you) or delusions of grandeur (believing that you are famous or have special powers).
Hallucinations (false perceptions): positive symptoms, in one or more senses, most often auditory (hearing voices), but can be visual or in any sense.
Disorganized thinking or speech: a positive symptom, such as speaking in a word salad, stringing words together in a nonsensical way.
Disorganized motor behavior: may appear as catatonia, a disorder of movement. It can be experienced as excitement (purposeless, excessive movement: a positive symptom) or stupor (remaining motionless and unresponsive: a negative symptom).
Negative symptoms: a lack of typical behavior, such as flat affect (little emotional expression), lack of speech, or loss of motivation, or lack of movement (catatonic stupor). They are often more disabling over time than positive symptoms and respond less well to medication.
Schizophrenia is not "split personality" (dissociative identity disorder is a different disorder, covered in Lesson 5.8).
### Possible causes
Possible causes suggest a genetic or biological link. The risk rises with genetic relatedness: about 1 percent in the general population, about 10 percent for a child with one parent with schizophrenia, and about 48 percent for an identical twin of someone with the disorder (so genes matter, but they do not determine it, since the twin rate is not 100 percent). Biological factors include prenatal virus exposure (such as influenza during pregnancy), complications at birth, and imbalances with certain neurotransmitters. The dopamine hypothesis proposes that overactivity of the neurotransmitter dopamine contributes to positive symptoms; this fits with the fact that antipsychotic medications block dopamine receptors. Brain scans show enlarged fluid-filled ventricles and loss of brain tissue in some people with schizophrenia. Following the diathesis-stress model, stress and cannabis use in adolescence may trigger the disorder in vulnerable people.
Worked example · Match the symptom
Name the symptom. (a) A man believes that the CIA has put a chip in his head and is following him. (b) A woman hears a voice telling her to run away. (c) A person says, "The table running blue cats because ocean tomorrow." (d) A patient sits motionless for hours and does not respond. (e) A person shows no emotion even when told good news.
Step 4, (d) catatonic stupor (a negative symptom of disorganized motor behavior).
Step 5, (e) flat affect (negative symptom).
Worked example · Interpret the heritability data
The risk of schizophrenia is about 1% in the general population, 10% for children of one affected parent, and 48% for the identical twin of an affected person. What do these data suggest, and what do they not show?
Step 1, the risk rises as genetic similarity increases (1%, then 10%, then 48%), which suggests a genetic contribution.
Step 2, the identical twin risk (48%) is much less than 100%, so genes alone do not cause the disorder. Environmental factors, such as prenatal exposure and stress, also matter (diathesis-stress).
Step 3, relatives also share environments, so the family data alone cannot separate genes and environment; twin and adoption studies are used to do that.
Step 4, conclusion: schizophrenia has a substantial genetic component with significant environmental influence.
Worked example · Evaluate a claim
A website claims that "ADHD is just bad parenting and too much sugar." Evaluate.
Step 1, research shows that ADHD is strongly heritable (twin studies) and is associated with differences in brain function.
Step 2, controlled studies have not found that sugar causes ADHD symptoms.
Step 3, parenting can influence how a child's symptoms are managed, but it is not the cause of the disorder.
Step 4, a defensible claim: ADHD results from a combination of genetic and environmental factors, and treatments such as behavioral strategies and medication are supported by evidence.
Exam focus
ADHD: inattention, hyperactivity, impulsivity (before school age; multiple settings). ASD: social communication difficulty and restricted, repetitive behaviors; a spectrum.
Causes: genetic, physiological, environmental. Vaccines do not cause autism.
Schizophrenia: delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech (word salad), disorganized motor behavior (catatonia), negative symptoms (flat affect). Positive versus negative symptoms.
What are two core types of symptoms in autism spectrum disorder?
Show answer
Difficulties in social communication and interaction, and restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior or interests.
Distinguish positive from negative symptoms of schizophrenia, with an example of each.
Show answer
Positive symptoms are the presence of abnormal behaviors, such as hallucinations or delusions; negative symptoms are the absence of typical behavior, such as flat affect.
What is the dopamine hypothesis?
Show answer
The idea that overactivity of the neurotransmitter dopamine contributes to the symptoms of schizophrenia, supported by the effects of antipsychotic drugs that block dopamine.
Why does the 48 percent identical-twin risk suggest that schizophrenia is not purely genetic?
Show answer
If it were purely genetic, identical twins (who share all their genes) would both have it in 100 percent of cases; environmental factors must also contribute.
Is schizophrenia the same as having multiple personalities? Explain.
Show answer
No. Schizophrenia involves a break from reality (delusions, hallucinations, and disorganized thinking), while multiple identities refer to dissociative identity disorder.
Mood disorders involve disturbances of emotion that go far beyond everyday ups and downs. Depressive disorders involve persistent lows, and bipolar disorders involve swings between lows and highs. Depression is one of the most common disorders in the world, and a leading cause of disability. This lesson covers the symptoms of the two depressive disorders and the two bipolar disorders that are in scope for AP Psychology, the way to tell them apart, and the possible causes that psychologists propose. Care with the details matters here, because the exam asks you to distinguish disorders in case studies that sound similar.
Required content · 5.4.C, 5.4.D
Learning objectives.
5.4.C. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected depressive disorders.
5.4.D. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected bipolar disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.4.C.1. Depressive disorders are characterized by the presence of sad, empty, or irritable mood along with physical and cognitive changes that affect a person’s ability to function. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are major depressive disorder and persistent depressive disorder. 120 e
5.4.C.2. Possible causes of depressive disorders focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources.
5.4.D.1. Bipolar disorders are characterized by periods of mania and periods of depression. Bipolar cycling involves experiencing periods of depression and mania in alternating periods that can last various amounts of time. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are Bipolar I disorder and Bipolar II disorder.
5.4.D.2. Possible causes of bipolar disorders focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources.
Depressive disorders
Depressive disorders are characterized by a sad, empty, or irritable mood, along with physical and cognitive changes that affect the person's ability to function. The two in scope are:
Major depressive disorder (MDD): at least two weeks of depressed mood or loss of interest or pleasure in nearly all activities, plus other symptoms such as changes in appetite or weight, sleep problems (insomnia or sleeping too much), fatigue, feelings of worthlessness or guilt, trouble concentrating or making decisions, slowed or restless movement, and thoughts of death or suicide. Episodes may occur once or repeatedly. It affects roughly 7 to 8 percent of U.S. adults each year, and about twice as many women as men are diagnosed (possibly because of hormonal, social, and reporting differences).
Persistent depressive disorder (dysthymia): a less severe but chronic depressed mood lasting most of the day on most days for at least two years (one year in children), with additional symptoms such as poor appetite or overeating, sleep problems, low energy, low self-esteem, and hopelessness. The person may be described as "gloomy" and may not remember feeling differently.
Grief after a loss is not by itself a disorder, though it can overlap with depression. Depression is different from normal sadness in its intensity, its duration, and its effect on functioning.
Bipolar disorders
Bipolar disorders are characterized by periods of mania and periods of depression. Mania is a distinct period of abnormally elevated, expansive, or irritable mood, with increased energy, along with symptoms such as inflated self-esteem or grandiosity, reduced need for sleep, rapid or pressured speech, racing thoughts, distractibility, and risky behavior (spending sprees, reckless driving, gambling). Bipolar cycling involves alternating periods of depression and mania, lasting varying amounts of time, with periods of normal mood between them in many people. The two in scope are:
Bipolar I disorder: at least one full manic episode (at least one week of elevated mood and energy, or any length if hospitalization is needed). Depressive episodes are common but not required for the diagnosis. Mania can be severe, with psychosis, and can lead to hospitalization.
Bipolar II disorder: at least one hypomanic episode (a milder, shorter version of mania, lasting at least four days, which does not cause serious impairment) and at least one major depressive episode. There has never been a full manic episode.
An easy way to remember: the "II" is less intense on the high side (hypomania), while Bipolar I has the full mania. Bipolar disorder affects about 2 to 3 percent of people and is about equally common in men and women.
Possible causes
Possible causes of depressive and bipolar disorders focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources, in line with a biopsychosocial view.
Biological and genetic: depression runs in families (the risk is about two to three times higher for a first-degree relative, and about 40 to 50 percent concordance for identical twins in depression, and higher for bipolar disorder, which is among the most heritable psychological disorders). Low levels or poor regulation of the neurotransmitters serotonin and norepinephrine are linked to depression, and antidepressants act on them (although the details are more complex than "low serotonin"). Brain differences such as reduced activity in the prefrontal cortex and an overactive amygdala have been observed. Hormonal changes and sleep disturbances can contribute.
Cognitive: Aaron Beck proposed that depressed people have a negative cognitive triad (negative views of the self, the world, and the future) and a pessimistic explanatory style (Lesson 4.1). Learned helplessness (Lesson 3.9) is another cognitive-behavioral explanation.
Behavioral: fewer rewarding activities and a lack of positive reinforcement can maintain depression, and withdrawal worsens it.
Social and cultural: stressful life events, loss, isolation, abuse, discrimination, and poverty raise the risk, and cultures differ in how people describe distress (for example, in some cultures, depression is expressed more as physical complaints).
Study spotlight · Depressive realism? (Alloy and Abramson, 1979)
Lauren Alloy and Lyn Abramson asked depressed and non-depressed students to judge how much control their button presses had over whether a light came on. In some conditions the light came on regardless of what the students did (they had no control). The depressed students estimated their control accurately. The non-depressed students overestimated their control when the outcome was desirable, with an "illusion of control."
Reading the research: an experiment comparing groups (depressed versus not, which is a quasi-independent variable), with participants who were college students. It suggests that depression is not always associated with distorted thinking in all circumstances, and that mild positive illusions may be common in healthy people. The findings have been debated and are not consistent across studies, and the task is not like the real-world situations in which depressed people may think negatively. It is a useful reminder that the cognitive explanation of depression is complex.
Worked example · Which disorder?
Identify. (a) A man has felt down and hopeless most days for three years, with low energy and low self-esteem, but has still worked. (b) A woman had two weeks of intense sadness, loss of interest, and insomnia, and thoughts of death. (c) A person who has had several depressive episodes also had one week of euphoria, no sleep, and reckless spending that led to hospitalization. (d) A person with depressive episodes and several periods of four days of energetic, talkative, and mildly irritable mood, without serious impairment.
Step 1, (a) persistent depressive disorder (chronic, at least two years).
Step 2, (b) major depressive disorder.
Step 3, (c) bipolar I disorder (a full manic episode with hospitalization).
Step 4, (d) bipolar II disorder (hypomania and depression).
Worked example · Apply Beck's cognitive triad
A student who fails a quiz thinks, "I'm useless (self), school is unfair (world), and I'll never get into college (future)." Name the idea and propose an intervention.
Step 1, these are the three parts of the negative cognitive triad: negative thoughts about oneself, the world, and the future.
Step 2, a cognitive therapist would help the student to identify the thoughts, test them against evidence (what other grades has she earned?), and replace them with more realistic ones (cognitive restructuring).
Step 3, a behavioral therapist might add scheduled rewarding activities.
Worked example · Interpret twin concordance
The concordance rate for bipolar disorder is about 40% in identical twins and about 5% in fraternal twins. Interpret.
Step 1, identical twins share nearly 100% of their genes, and fraternal twins about 50%. The higher concordance for identical twins suggests a genetic contribution.
Step 2, the rate for identical twins is only 40%, not 100%, so environmental factors also play a role.
Step 3, because twins share environments, a stronger test uses twins reared apart or adoption studies.
Step 4, the pattern supports a diathesis-stress explanation.
Exam focus
Major depressive disorder (two weeks, depressed mood or loss of interest plus other symptoms) and persistent depressive disorder (chronic, two years).
Bipolar I (full mania) and Bipolar II (hypomania plus major depression). Bipolar cycling.
Causes: genetic, neurotransmitters (serotonin, norepinephrine), cognitive triad, behavioral, social and cultural stressors.
Practice
How does persistent depressive disorder differ from major depressive disorder?
Show answer
Persistent depressive disorder is less severe but chronic, lasting at least two years, while major depressive disorder involves more severe episodes of at least two weeks.
List three symptoms of mania.
Show answer
Elevated or irritable mood, reduced need for sleep, rapid speech or racing thoughts, inflated self-esteem, risky behavior.
What is the main difference between Bipolar I and Bipolar II?
Show answer
Bipolar I includes at least one full manic episode; Bipolar II includes hypomania (a milder form) and major depression, with no full manic episode.
Describe Beck's negative cognitive triad.
Show answer
Negative thoughts about oneself, the world, and the future.
Why do twin studies suggest that environment matters in bipolar disorder?
Show answer
Identical twins share all their genes but do not always both have the disorder, so non-genetic factors also contribute.
Give one biological and one social possible cause of depression.
Show answer
Biological: low or poorly regulated serotonin or norepinephrine, or genetic risk. Social: stressful life events, isolation, or discrimination.
Fear is a normal and useful response to danger. Anxiety is the anticipation of a future threat, with tension and worry. In anxiety disorders, fear and anxiety are excessive, out of proportion to the actual threat, and disturb behavior. Closely related are the obsessive-compulsive and related disorders, in which intrusive thoughts lead to repetitive behaviors. This lesson covers the five anxiety disorders and the two obsessive-compulsive-related disorders in scope for AP Psychology, including two culture-bound syndromes that the course names. Anxiety disorders are the most common category of disorder in the United States, which is why the exam asks about them in many forms.
Required content · 5.4.E, 5.4.F
Learning objectives.
5.4.E. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected anxiety disorders.
5.4.F. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected obsessive-compulsive disorders and related disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.4.E.1. Anxiety disorders are characterized by excessive fear and/or anxiety with related disturbances to behavior. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are specific phobia, agoraphobia, panic disorder, social anxiety disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder.
5.4.E.1.i. Specific phobia involves fear or anxiety toward a specific object or situation, such as acrophobia (heights) or arachnophobia (spiders).
5.4.E.1.ii. Agoraphobia is intense fear of specific social situations, including using public transportation, being in open spaces, being in enclosed spaces (e.g., shops, theaters, etc.), standing in line or being in a crowd, or being outside of the home alone.
5.4.E.1.iii. Panic disorder involves the experience of panic attacks (unanticipated and overwhelming biological, cognitive, and emotional experiences of fear/anxiety). Panic disorder can manifest as a culture-bound anxiety disorder such as ataque de nervios (experienced mainly by people of Caribbean or Iberian descent). 121
5.4.E.1.iv. Social anxiety disorder involves the intense fear of being judged or watched by others. Social anxiety disorder is distinct from but may include agoraphobia. Taijin kyofusho is a culture-bound anxiety disorder experienced mainly by Japanese people in which people fear others are judging their bodies as undesirable, offensive, or unpleasing.
5.4.E.1.v. Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) involves prolonged experiences of nonspecific anxiety or fear.
5.4.E.2. Possible causes of anxiety disorders focus on learned associations between and among stimuli, maladaptive thinking or emotional responses, and biological or genetic sources.
5.4.F.1. Obsessive-compulsive and related disorders are characterized by the presence of obsessions (intrusive thoughts) and compulsions (intrusive, often repetitive, behaviors intended to address obsessions). Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are obsessive-compulsive disorder and hoarding disorder.
5.4.F.2. Possible causes of obsessive-compulsive disorders involve learned associations between and among stimuli, maladaptive thinking or emotional responses, and biological or genetic sources.
Anxiety disorders
Anxiety disorders are characterized by excessive fear and/or anxiety with related disturbances to behavior (such as avoidance). The five in scope are:
Specific phobia: intense fear or anxiety about a specific object or situation, out of proportion to the actual danger, that the person avoids or endures with great distress. Examples are acrophobia (heights) and arachnophobia (spiders). The most common anxiety disorder is a specific phobia.
Agoraphobia: intense fear of situations in which escape might be difficult or help unavailable, such as using public transportation, being in open spaces, being in enclosed spaces (shops, theaters), standing in line or being in a crowd, or being outside the home alone. People may refuse to leave home.
Panic disorder: recurrent, unexpected panic attacks, sudden episodes of overwhelming fear with physical symptoms (pounding heart, shortness of breath, dizziness, sweating, trembling, a feeling of unreality or fear of dying) that peak within minutes, plus persistent worry about further attacks or changes in behavior to avoid them. It can appear as a culture-bound anxiety disorder, ataque de nervios, which is experienced mainly by people of Caribbean or Iberian descent (intense emotional distress, shouting, and trembling, often after a stressful event such as a death in the family).
Social anxiety disorder: intense fear of being judged, scrutinized, or embarrassed in social situations (public speaking, eating in front of others), leading to avoidance. It is distinct from, but may include, agoraphobia. A culture-bound form, taijin kyofusho, experienced mainly by Japanese people, is the fear that others are judging one's body as undesirable, offensive, or unpleasing (the concern is for others' discomfort as much as for one's own).
Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD): prolonged experience (at least six months) of nonspecific anxiety or fear: excessive worry about many things, accompanied by restlessness, fatigue, trouble concentrating, irritability, muscle tension, and sleep problems, with the worry difficult to control. The anxiety is "free-floating," not attached to a single object.
### Possible causes of anxiety disorders
Possible causes focus on learned associations, maladaptive thinking or emotional responses, and biological or genetic sources.
Behavioral: classical conditioning (a frightening experience paired with a neutral object, as in Little Albert) and operant conditioning (avoidance is negatively reinforced because it reduces anxiety, which maintains the phobia). Observational learning also plays a role.
Cognitive: catastrophic thinking and misinterpreting normal body sensations (for example, thinking that a racing heart means a heart attack) can lead to panic. People with anxiety disorders pay more attention to threats.
Biological and genetic: anxiety disorders run in families; the amygdala is overactive; the neurotransmitter GABA (which calms neural activity) and serotonin have been implicated. Biological preparedness (Lesson 3.8) helps to explain why people develop phobias of snakes, spiders, and heights more easily than of cars or electrical outlets.
Sociocultural: stress, trauma, and cultural norms influence the expression of anxiety.
Obsessive-compulsive and related disorders
These disorders are characterized by obsessions (intrusive, unwanted, repeated thoughts, images, or urges that cause anxiety) and compulsions (repetitive behaviors or mental acts that a person feels driven to perform to reduce anxiety or to prevent something bad, though they are excessive or not realistically connected to the fear). The two in scope are:
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD): obsessions (such as fear of contamination, or doubts about whether a door was locked) and compulsions (washing hands repeatedly, checking, counting, arranging) that take more than an hour a day or cause distress or impairment. The compulsion gives temporary relief, which reinforces the cycle. The person usually recognizes that the behavior is excessive. OCD is different from the everyday meaning of "being neat" or "being a perfectionist."
Hoarding disorder: persistent difficulty discarding possessions, regardless of their value, because of a perceived need to save them and distress at the idea of discarding, which results in clutter that makes living areas unusable.
### Possible causes
As with anxiety disorders, causes involve learned associations (compulsions are negatively reinforced because they reduce anxiety), maladaptive thinking (inflated sense of responsibility, thought-action fusion, in which a thought is treated as equal to an action), and biological or genetic sources, such as heredity and overactivity in frontal lobe and basal ganglia circuits, with serotonin involved.
Study spotlight · A cognitive view of panic (Clark, 1986)
David Clark proposed that panic attacks arise from a catastrophic misinterpretation of normal bodily sensations. A person who notices a faster heartbeat after climbing stairs thinks "I am having a heart attack," which increases fear, which increases the sensations, and so on in a spiral. In experiments, people with panic disorder were more likely than others to be frightened by a description of a harmless sensation as dangerous, and treatments that taught people to interpret sensations differently reduced panic attacks substantially.
Reading the research: a theory supported by experiments comparing patients and controls and by treatment studies. It shows how a cognitive explanation leads to a treatment (cognitive therapy). Limits: it does not explain the first attack or why some people are more sensitive than others, so biological vulnerability probably contributes.
Worked example · Which anxiety disorder?
Identify. (a) A man avoids all elevators and ladders because of an intense fear of heights. (b) A woman has sudden attacks of pounding heart and fear of dying with no warning and worries about the next one. (c) A student has worried excessively about school, health, and money for over a year, with muscle tension and trouble sleeping. (d) A person fears speaking in class because others will judge him. (e) A person is afraid to leave home alone, ride a bus, or enter a crowded store.
Step 1, (a) specific phobia (acrophobia).
Step 2, (b) panic disorder.
Step 3, (c) generalized anxiety disorder.
Step 4, (d) social anxiety disorder.
Step 5, (e) agoraphobia.
Worked example · Negative reinforcement of a phobia
A girl who is afraid of dogs crosses the street whenever she sees one, and feels relief. Explain why the fear continues, and how treatment could break the cycle.
Step 1, avoiding the dog removes the anxiety (an unpleasant stimulus), which negatively reinforces avoidance, so avoidance becomes more likely.
Step 2, because she never stays long enough for the fear to extinguish, she never learns that the dog was harmless.
Step 3, treatment (exposure therapy, Lesson 5.9) exposes her to the dogs gradually, with no escape, so that extinction occurs.
Worked example · Obsession or compulsion?
Classify. (a) A repeated, unwanted thought that hands are covered in germs. (b) Washing hands 40 times a day. (c) An intrusive image of causing an accident. (d) Checking that the stove is off over and over.
Step 1, (a) obsession.
Step 2, (b) compulsion.
Step 3, (c) obsession.
Step 4, (d) compulsion.
Step 5, the compulsions reduce anxiety briefly, which reinforces the cycle.
Exam focus
Specific phobia, agoraphobia, panic disorder (ataque de nervios), social anxiety disorder (taijin kyofusho), generalized anxiety disorder.
OCD (obsessions and compulsions) and hoarding disorder.
Causes: learned associations (negative reinforcement of avoidance), catastrophic thinking, genes, amygdala, GABA and serotonin, biological preparedness.
Practice
Distinguish agoraphobia from social anxiety disorder.
Show answer
Agoraphobia is fear of situations from which escape may be hard, such as crowds, open spaces, or public transport; social anxiety disorder is fear of being judged or embarrassed by others.
What is a panic attack?
Show answer
A sudden episode of overwhelming fear with physical symptoms such as a pounding heart and shortness of breath that peaks within minutes.
Explain why avoidance maintains a phobia.
Show answer
Avoidance reduces anxiety, which negatively reinforces the avoidance and prevents the person from learning that the feared object is harmless.
Distinguish obsessions from compulsions.
Show answer
Obsessions are intrusive, unwanted thoughts or images; compulsions are repetitive behaviors or mental acts performed to reduce anxiety.
Give a cognitive explanation for panic attacks.
Show answer
Catastrophic misinterpretation of normal body sensations (such as thinking a fast heartbeat means a heart attack) increases fear and the sensations in a spiral.
What does biological preparedness help to explain about phobias?
Show answer
Why people more easily develop fears of evolutionarily relevant dangers such as snakes, spiders, and heights.
Dissociative, trauma, eating, and personality disorders
This last lesson on disorders covers four categories that the AP course includes: dissociative disorders, which involve a breakdown in the normal integration of consciousness, memory, and identity; trauma and stressor-related disorders, which follow terrible events; feeding and eating disorders, which involve disturbed eating that harms health; and personality disorders, which are long-lasting patterns of thinking and behaving that cause problems. Some of these categories attract many myths in popular media, so pay attention to what the research supports, and to the difference between a symptom as a clinician uses the word and as it is used in everyday speech.
Required content · 5.4.G, 5.4.H, 5.4.I, 5.4.J
Learning objectives.
5.4.G. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected dissociative disorders.
5.4.H. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected trauma and stressor-related disorders.
5.4.I. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected feeding and eating disorders.
5.4.J. Describe the symptoms and possible causes of selected personality disorders.
Essential knowledge.
5.4.G.1. Dissociative disorders are characterized by dissociations from consciousness, memory, identity, emotion, perception, body representation, motor control, and behavior. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are dissociative amnesia (with and without fugue) and dissociative identity disorder.
5.4.G.2. Possible causes of dissociative disorders involve the experience of trauma or stress. 122
5.4.H.1. Trauma and stressor-related disorders are characterized by exposure to a traumatic or stressful event with subsequent psychological distress. Symptoms of trauma and stressor-related disorders may involve hypervigilance, severe anxiety, flashbacks to traumatic or stressful experiences, insomnia, emotional detachment, and hostility. The selected disorder in scope for AP Psychology in this category is posttraumatic stress disorder.
5.4.H.2. Possible causes of trauma and stressor-related disorders involve the experience of trauma or stress.
5.4.I.1. Feeding and eating disorders are characterized by altered consumption or absorption of food that impairs health or psychological functioning. Selected disorders in scope for AP Psychology in this category are anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa.
5.4.I.2. Possible causes of feeding and eating disorders focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources.
5.4.J.1. Personality disorders (which fall into three clusters) are characterized by enduring patterns of internal experience and behavior that is deviant from one’s culture; is pervasive and inflexible; begins in adolescence or early adulthood; is stable over time; and leads to personal distress or impairment.
5.4.J.1.i. Cluster A is the odd or eccentric cluster and includes paranoid, schizoid, and schizotypal personality disorders.
5.4.J.1.ii. Cluster B is the dramatic, emotional, or erratic cluster and includes antisocial, histrionic, narcissistic, and borderline personality disorders. 123
5.4.J.1.iii. Cluster C is the anxious or fearful cluster and includes avoidant, dependent, and obsessive-compulsive personality disorders.
5.4.J.2. Possible causes of personality disorders focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources.
Dissociative disorders
Dissociation is a disconnection among a person's consciousness, memory, identity, emotion, perception, body representation, motor control, and behavior. Dissociative disorders involve such disruptions. The two in scope are:
Dissociative amnesia: an inability to recall important personal information, usually about a traumatic or stressful event, that is too extensive to be ordinary forgetting. It is not due to a brain injury or substance use. It may occur with fugue, in which the person suddenly and unexpectedly travels away from home or work and may take on a new identity.
Dissociative identity disorder (DID): the presence of two or more distinct identities or personality states, each with its own pattern of perceiving and relating to the world, along with gaps in memory for everyday events. It was formerly called "multiple personality disorder." It is not the same as schizophrenia. DID is rare, and it is controversial: some researchers argue that it is a real response to severe childhood trauma, and others argue that many cases are produced by suggestion or by media portrayals, in therapy.
Possible causes: dissociative disorders are linked to the experience of trauma or stress, especially severe childhood abuse or neglect, with dissociation understood as a way of coping with overwhelming experience by mentally "escaping."
Trauma and stressor-related disorders
These disorders follow exposure to a traumatic or stressful event with subsequent psychological distress. The one in scope is posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). After events such as combat, assault, a serious accident, a disaster, or abuse, a person may show symptoms for more than a month, such as:
Intrusive memories and flashbacks (reliving the event), and nightmares.
Avoidance of reminders of the event.
Negative changes in thinking and mood, including emotional detachment and numbness.
Hypervigilance (constantly on guard), exaggerated startle, severe anxiety, insomnia, irritability, and hostility.
Possible causes: the experience of trauma or stress is the necessary trigger, but not everyone who experiences trauma develops PTSD. Risk factors include the severity of the trauma, a lack of social support, previous trauma, and a genetic vulnerability (consistent with the diathesis-stress model). The classical conditioning of fear to cues related to the trauma (Lesson 3.8) helps to explain flashbacks. Treatment is discussed in Unit 5's treatment lessons.
Feeding and eating disorders
These disorders involve altered consumption or absorption of food that impairs health or psychological functioning. The two in scope are:
Anorexia nervosa: restriction of food intake leading to a significantly low body weight, an intense fear of gaining weight, and a distorted body image (seeing oneself as overweight when underweight). It has one of the highest death rates among psychological disorders, from medical complications and suicide. It occurs most often in adolescent girls and young women, but it affects people of all genders.
Bulimia nervosa: recurrent episodes of binge eating (eating a large amount of food in a short time with a sense of loss of control) followed by compensatory behaviors such as self-induced vomiting, misuse of laxatives, fasting, or excessive exercise, to prevent weight gain. People with bulimia are often of normal weight, which can hide the disorder, and they experience guilt and shame. Binges and compensation occur on average at least once a week for three months.
Possible causes focus on biological, genetic, social, cultural, behavioral, or cognitive sources: heritability (twin studies show a substantial genetic contribution), differences in serotonin function, perfectionism and low self-esteem, a distorted body image, cultural pressure for thinness through media and peer norms, dieting, and family factors. The fact that these disorders are more common in cultures that idealize thinness supports a sociocultural cause.
Personality disorders
Personality disorders are enduring patterns of internal experience and behavior that:
deviate from one's culture's expectations,
are pervasive and inflexible (across many situations),
begin in adolescence or early adulthood,
are stable over time, and
lead to personal distress or impairment.
The DSM groups the ten personality disorders into three clusters:
Cluster
Description
Disorders (with brief descriptions)
A: odd or eccentric
Social withdrawal, suspiciousness, and unusual thinking
Paranoid (distrust and suspicion of others), schizoid (detachment from relationships, limited emotional range), schizotypal (odd beliefs, eccentric behavior, and discomfort in close relationships)
B: dramatic, emotional, or erratic
Impulsive, emotional, and attention-seeking behavior
Antisocial (disregard for and violation of others' rights, lack of remorse, deceit), histrionic (excessive emotionality and attention seeking), narcissistic (grandiosity, need for admiration, lack of empathy), borderline (unstable relationships, self-image, and emotions; impulsivity; fear of abandonment)
C: anxious or fearful
Anxious, inhibited behavior
Avoidant (social inhibition, feelings of inadequacy, fear of rejection), dependent (excessive need to be taken care of, clinging), obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (preoccupation with order, perfectionism, and control, without the obsessions and compulsions of OCD)
Possible causes include biological and genetic factors (heritability; for antisocial personality disorder, lower arousal and reduced prefrontal activity), social and cultural factors (childhood abuse, neglect, and unstable families), and behavioral and cognitive factors. Note that antisocial personality disorder is often called psychopathy or sociopathy in everyday speech, and that it is not the same as "being antisocial" in the sense of being shy.
Study spotlight · The debate over dissociative identity disorder
In 1957 a book and film popularized the case of "Eve," a woman said to have three distinct personalities. It brought DID into public view, and cases increased sharply in the following decades, especially in the United States. Critics such as Nicholas Spanos argued that therapists using hypnosis and leading questions could create the impression of multiple identities in suggestible clients. In support, a large share of cases are diagnosed by a small number of clinicians. Others point to evidence that people with DID have a history of severe trauma and show measurable differences in memory and physiology.
Reading the research: the debate comes from case studies, clinical reports, and some small experiments, not from a single controlled experiment, and the evidence is mixed. It is an example of why the AP course asks you to evaluate claims, and to recognize that a diagnosis can be influenced by culture and by the clinician. A defensible position is that dissociation in response to trauma is real, while the extent and cause of DID are debated.
Worked example · Identify the disorder
Identify. (a) A woman suddenly finds herself in another city, cannot remember who she is or how she got there. (b) A veteran startles at loud noises, has nightmares, and avoids crowds, six months after combat. (c) A teen restricts food, is very thin, but sees herself as overweight. (d) A man eats very large amounts of food in an hour, then vomits, several times a week. (e) A man shows a long-term pattern of lying, deceiving, and violating others' rights without remorse.
Name the cluster for each. (a) Schizoid. (b) Borderline. (c) Avoidant. (d) Narcissistic. (e) Paranoid.
Step 1, (a) Cluster A (odd or eccentric).
Step 2, (b) Cluster B (dramatic, emotional, or erratic).
Step 3, (c) Cluster C (anxious or fearful).
Step 4, (d) Cluster B.
Step 5, (e) Cluster A.
Worked example · Evaluate a causal claim about eating disorders
A magazine says "Fashion magazines cause eating disorders." Using the biopsychosocial model, evaluate.
Step 1, a correlation between exposure to thin ideals and eating disorders supports a sociocultural contribution, since eating disorders are more common in cultures that idealize thinness.
Step 2, but most people who see such images do not develop eating disorders, and twin studies show a genetic contribution, so media exposure is not sufficient to cause the disorder.
Step 3, the biopsychosocial model explains that biological vulnerability, psychological factors (perfectionism, low self-esteem), and sociocultural pressure interact.
Step 4, a defensible claim: media is one risk factor among several.
Exam focus
Dissociative amnesia (with or without fugue) and DID; linked to trauma; DID is debated.
PTSD: flashbacks, hypervigilance, anxiety, insomnia, detachment, hostility after trauma.
Anorexia nervosa (restriction, low weight) and bulimia nervosa (binge and compensate).
Personality disorders: enduring, pervasive, inflexible. Cluster A odd (paranoid, schizoid, schizotypal); B dramatic (antisocial, histrionic, narcissistic, borderline); C anxious (avoidant, dependent, obsessive-compulsive).
Practice
Distinguish dissociative amnesia from ordinary forgetting.
Show answer
Dissociative amnesia is an extensive inability to recall important personal information, usually about a traumatic event, that is not explained by brain injury or substance use.
List three symptoms of PTSD.
Show answer
Flashbacks or intrusive memories, hypervigilance, insomnia, emotional detachment, or hostility.
How do anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa differ?
Show answer
Anorexia involves restricting food intake to a very low body weight with fear of weight gain; bulimia involves binge eating followed by compensatory behaviors, often at normal weight.
List the features that define a personality disorder.
Show answer
An enduring pattern that deviates from cultural expectations, is pervasive and inflexible, begins in adolescence or early adulthood, is stable over time, and causes distress or impairment.
Which cluster includes borderline, and what is its theme?
Show answer
Cluster B, the dramatic, emotional, or erratic cluster.
Why is DID controversial?
Show answer
Some researchers believe it results from severe trauma, while others argue that suggestion by therapists or media may produce or inflate cases, and the evidence is mixed.
Psychotherapy: approaches, ethics, and effectiveness
When a person has a psychological disorder, what helps? The answer depends partly on how the disorder is understood, since each perspective in psychology has its own therapy. This lesson covers psychotherapy, treatment through psychological techniques, from the main approaches and their techniques to the ethical principles that guide therapists and the evidence for effectiveness. In the exam, you will often be given a short case and asked which therapy fits, or what technique a therapist is using, so match each technique with its approach. The next lesson covers group therapy, hypnosis, and biological treatments.
Required content · 5.5.A, 5.5.C, 5.5.D
Learning objectives.
5.5.A. Describe research and trends in the treatment of psychological disorders.
5.5.C. Describe ethical principles in the treatment of psychological disorders.
5.5.D. Describe techniques used with psychological therapies.
Essential knowledge.
5.5.A.1. Many researchers who have conducted meta-analytic studies of psychotherapy conclude that psychotherapies are generally effective. Many psychologists use evidence-based interventions to develop treatment plans. Therapists should exhibit cultural humility and establish a therapeutic alliance with the client to deliver therapy successfully.
5.5.C.1. Psychologists in clinical or therapeutic situations must follow certain ethical principles as established by the APA, including nonmaleficence, fidelity, integrity, and respect for people’s rights and dignity.
5.5.D.1. Psychodynamic therapies employ free association and dream interpretation to uncover the unconscious mind. 1.A 2.B 2.D 3.C 4.B 125
5.5.D.2. Cognitive therapies may employ cognitive restructuring or fear hierarchies to combat maladaptive thinking. Cognitive therapy proposes that people should focus on the cognitive triad—negative thoughts about oneself, the world, and the future.
5.5.D.3. Applied behavior analysis involves applying principles of conditioning to address mental disorders and developmental disabilities. Exposure therapies (such as systematic desensitization), aversion therapies, and token economies all employ principles of applied behavior analysis. Biofeedback uses principles of conditioning to help clients regulate body systems (such as the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems) that contribute to feelings of anxiety or depression.
5.5.D.4. Cognitive-behavioral therapies, such as dialectical behavior therapy and rational-emotive behavior therapy, combine techniques from the cognitive and behavioral perspectives to treat mental and behavioral disorders.
5.5.D.5. Therapy from the humanistic perspective, commonly referred to as person-centered therapy, employs active listening and unconditional positive regard.
Is psychotherapy effective?
Many researchers who have conducted meta-analytic studies (statistical combinations of many studies) of psychotherapy conclude that psychotherapies are generally effective: on average, people who receive therapy do better than most people who do not. The famous 1977 meta-analysis by Mary Smith and Gene Glass of about 375 studies found that the average treated person was better off than about 75 percent of untreated people. Many psychologists use evidence-based interventions (treatments supported by research) to develop treatment plans, and the best treatment depends on the disorder (for example, exposure-based therapy for phobias). Two further points matter for successful therapy: therapists should exhibit cultural humility, an attitude of openness to learning about the client's culture and a recognition of one's own biases, and they should establish a therapeutic alliance, a trusting, collaborative relationship with the client, which is one of the best predictors of good outcomes in all approaches. Some of the improvement seen in therapy may result from the passage of time (spontaneous remission), the placebo effect, and the hope that therapy brings, which is why researchers compare treatments with control groups.
Ethical principles
Psychologists in clinical or therapeutic situations must follow ethical principles established by the American Psychological Association:
Nonmaleficence: "do no harm," avoiding actions that would harm clients.
Fidelity: keeping promises and being faithful to the client's trust, including maintaining confidentiality (with legal exceptions, such as risk of serious harm to the client or others).
Integrity: being honest and accurate, and not deceiving or exploiting clients.
Respect for people's rights and dignity: honoring privacy, autonomy, and informed consent, and avoiding discrimination.
Psychodynamic therapies
Psychodynamic therapies aim to bring unconscious conflicts into awareness (insight). Their techniques, begun by Freud in psychoanalysis, include:
Free association: the client says whatever comes to mind, without censoring, so that the therapist can notice themes, hesitations, and connections that reveal unconscious material.
Dream interpretation: the therapist helps the client to understand the manifest content (the story of the dream as remembered) and the latent content (the hidden meaning that the dream is thought to symbolize).
Related ideas include resistance (the client's blocking of anxiety-provoking material) and transference (the client's redirecting of feelings about important people, such as parents, onto the therapist).
Modern psychodynamic therapy is briefer and focuses more on current relationships. Critics say that its claims are hard to test, and that it takes a long time; research does support that short-term psychodynamic therapy can be effective.
Humanistic (person-centered) therapy
Therapy from the humanistic perspective, commonly called person-centered therapy (or client-centered therapy), was developed by Carl Rogers. The therapist creates an atmosphere of acceptance in which the client can grow, using active listening (restating and clarifying what the client says, reflecting feelings, without judging or directing) and unconditional positive regard, along with empathy and genuineness. The client leads the session, and the therapist does not interpret or advise. It is effective for many people, especially with the therapeutic alliance as a basis, though it is less structured and less targeted for specific disorders.
Behavioral therapies
Behavior therapy applies the principles of learning. Applied behavior analysis is the application of conditioning principles to address mental disorders and developmental disabilities. Techniques include:
Exposure therapies: expose clients to the feared stimulus so that the anxiety extinguishes. Systematic desensitization, developed by Joseph Wolpe, is a form of counterconditioning: the client learns relaxation, builds a fear hierarchy (a list of feared situations ranked from mild to terrifying), and then progresses step by step through the list while staying relaxed, since relaxation is incompatible with anxiety. Other forms include flooding (immediate, prolonged exposure to the most feared stimulus) and virtual-reality exposure. Exposure with response prevention is the standard for OCD.
Aversion therapy: pairing an unwanted behavior with an unpleasant stimulus, such as medication that causes nausea when alcohol is consumed, so that the behavior becomes less appealing. Its effects are often temporary, and it raises ethical concerns.
Token economies: reinforcing desired behavior with tokens that can be exchanged for rewards, used in schools, hospitals, and programs (operant conditioning).
Biofeedback: using instruments that show a person physiological signals (heart rate, muscle tension, skin temperature) so that the person can learn to regulate body systems, including those of the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems, that contribute to anxiety or depression. It relies on operant conditioning.
Cognitive and cognitive-behavioral therapies
Cognitive therapy proposes that maladaptive thinking causes distress. Aaron Beck focused on the cognitive triad: negative thoughts about oneself, the world, and the future (Lesson 5.6). Techniques include cognitive restructuring, in which the client identifies automatic negative thoughts, tests them against evidence, and replaces them with more realistic ones. A fear hierarchy may also be used.
Cognitive-behavioral therapies (CBT) combine cognitive and behavioral techniques. Two types named in the course are:
Rational-emotive behavior therapy (REBT), by Albert Ellis, which challenges irrational beliefs ("I must be perfect, or I am worthless") that lead to distress. The therapist actively disputes them.
Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), by Marsha Linehan, which combines CBT with skills of mindfulness, emotion regulation, and distress tolerance, with an emphasis on accepting oneself while also working on change. It was developed for borderline personality disorder and is used for other disorders.
CBT has strong research support for depression, anxiety disorders, OCD, and PTSD, and is often brief (for example, 12 to 20 sessions), which makes it one of the most widely used evidence-based treatments.
Study spotlight · Comparing therapies for depression (Elkin and colleagues, 1989)
In the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program, 239 people with major depression were randomly assigned to 16 weeks of one of four treatments: cognitive-behavioral therapy, interpersonal therapy, the antidepressant imipramine with clinical management, or a placebo with clinical management. Among those with less severe depression, all four groups improved to a similar extent, including the placebo group. Among the more severely depressed, imipramine and interpersonal therapy did better than the placebo, and CBT was in between.
Reading the research: a randomized controlled trial with a placebo control, a strong design. It shows that several therapies can be effective, and that a large part of the improvement is shared across treatments, which supports the importance of common factors such as the therapeutic alliance and expectation. Limits: only 16 weeks of treatment, and results varied by severity, so the study is a basis for matching treatment with the person.
Worked example · Match the therapy
Name the therapy or technique. (a) A client says whatever comes to mind while the therapist listens for themes. (b) A therapist reflects the client's feelings without judging, and accepts them fully. (c) A client with a fear of flying builds a list of fear-provoking situations and practices relaxation at each step. (d) A therapist helps a client identify the thought "I always fail" and test it against evidence. (e) A client earns points for completing tasks, which can be traded for privileges.
Step 1, (a) psychodynamic: free association.
Step 2, (b) person-centered (humanistic): active listening and unconditional positive regard.
Step 3, (c) systematic desensitization (a behavioral exposure therapy using a fear hierarchy and counterconditioning).
Step 5, (e) a token economy (applied behavior analysis).
Worked example · Plan treatment for a phobia
A man has an intense fear of dogs. Describe a behavioral treatment and why it works.
Step 1, build a fear hierarchy: for example, looking at a photo of a dog, watching a dog from a distance, being in the same room as a dog, then petting a dog.
Step 3, progress one step at a time, only when he is relaxed at the current step. This is counterconditioning: relaxation replaces fear.
Step 4, it works by extinction: the dog (CS) occurs without harm (UCS), so the conditioned fear weakens, and by preventing avoidance (which reinforces the fear). A cognitive component might challenge catastrophic thoughts ("all dogs bite").
Worked example · Ethical principle
A therapist tells a friend about a client's problems at a party. Which principle was violated, and why?
Step 1, fidelity (and respect for people's rights and dignity): confidentiality is part of the client's trust.
Step 2, it could also harm the client, violating nonmaleficence.
Step 3, an exception to confidentiality exists, such as a client's serious threat to harm someone, but gossip is not an exception.
Exam focus
Therapy is generally effective (meta-analyses); cultural humility and the therapeutic alliance matter. Ethics: nonmaleficence, fidelity, integrity, respect for rights and dignity.
What does the research on psychotherapy conclude about its effectiveness?
Show answer
Meta-analyses conclude that psychotherapies are generally effective, and evidence-based interventions are used to plan treatment.
Explain the principle of nonmaleficence.
Show answer
Therapists must do no harm to their clients.
What is the purpose of free association?
Show answer
To let unconscious thoughts and conflicts emerge as the client says whatever comes to mind, so the therapist can notice patterns.
Describe systematic desensitization.
Show answer
A behavioral therapy in which a client learns relaxation and works up a fear hierarchy step by step, replacing fear with relaxation (counterconditioning).
Distinguish cognitive therapy from person-centered therapy.
Show answer
Cognitive therapy actively identifies and changes negative thinking; person-centered therapy uses active listening and unconditional positive regard and lets the client lead.
Name the two cognitive-behavioral therapies named in the course and the key idea of each.
Show answer
REBT challenges irrational beliefs; DBT combines CBT with mindfulness, emotion regulation, and acceptance.
Biological treatments, hypnosis, and group therapy
Not all treatment is talk. If a disorder has biological causes, as many do, then treating the brain directly can help, and medication has changed the lives of many people with serious disorders. This lesson covers the medications and brain-based interventions of the biological approach, the history of treatment that led from asylums to community care, the evidence about hypnosis, and how group therapy differs from individual therapy. For the exam, you should be able to match a drug class with its disorder, to describe the side effects and risks of each, and to evaluate claims about unusual treatments, such as hypnosis for recovering memories.
Required content · 5.5.B, 5.5.F, 5.5.G
Learning objectives.
5.5.B. Describe research and trends in the treatment of psychological disorders.
5.5.F. Describe effective uses of hypnosis.
5.5.G. Describe interventions derived from the biological perspective.
Essential knowledge.
5.5.B.1. Due to the increased use and effectiveness of psychotropic medication therapy, hospitals and asylums deinstitutionalized massive numbers of people in the late 20th century. Therapists now prefer to treat in decentralized ways, often with a combination of medication and psychological therapies.
5.5.F.1. Hypnosis has shown effectiveness in treating pain and anxiety. Research does not support the use of hypnosis to retrieve accurate memories or regress in age. 126
5.5.G.1. Psychoactive medications, such as antidepressants, antianxiety drugs, lithium, or antipsychotic medications, interact with specific neurotransmitters in the central nervous system to address possible biochemical causes of mental disorders. Psychoactive medications can have side effects such as tardive dyskinesia (a movement disorder related to the regulation of dopamine in the nervous system).
5.5.G.2. Surgical or invasive interventions include psychosurgery (which may involve lesioning), TMS (transcranial magnetic stimulation), or electroconvulsive therapy. The lobotomy is a form of psychosurgery that was popular in the mid-20th century but is rarely, if ever, performed today. 127
From asylums to community care
For most of history, people with severe disorders were confined in asylums, often in poor conditions. The introduction of the first effective psychotropic (psychoactive) medications in the 1950s, such as the antipsychotic chlorpromazine, allowed many patients to live outside hospitals. Due to the increased use and effectiveness of psychotropic medication, hospitals and asylums deinstitutionalized massive numbers of people in the late twentieth century. The shift was meant to support treatment in the community, but the promised community services were often underfunded, and many people ended up homeless, in jails, or without care. Therapists now prefer to treat in decentralized ways (in outpatient clinics, community mental health centers, and the home), often with a combination of medication and psychological therapies.
Psychoactive medications
Psychoactive medications interact with specific neurotransmitters in the central nervous system, to address possible biochemical causes of mental disorders. They treat symptoms and do not cure, and only physicians and certain other licensed professionals can prescribe them (most psychologists cannot, except in a few states). The main classes are:
Class
Used for
How it works (in general)
Examples and notes
Antipsychotics
Schizophrenia (positive symptoms) and other psychoses
Block dopamine receptors (the dopamine hypothesis)
Chlorpromazine, haloperidol. Older ones cause tardive dyskinesia; newer "atypical" ones act on dopamine and serotonin and have fewer movement effects but may cause weight gain
Antidepressants
Depression, and also anxiety disorders and OCD
Increase availability of serotonin and/or norepinephrine, such as by blocking reuptake
SSRIs (such as fluoxetine, or Prozac); take weeks to work; side effects include nausea, sexual dysfunction, and sleep changes. Effects are larger for severe depression
Antianxiety drugs (anxiolytics)
Anxiety and panic
Enhance the calming neurotransmitter GABA
Benzodiazepines (such as diazepam, or Valium) act quickly but can cause drowsiness, dependence, and withdrawal
Mood stabilizers
Bipolar disorder
Reduce the extremes of mania and depression
Lithium, and some anticonvulsant drugs; lithium needs monitoring of blood levels, because the safe range is narrow
Stimulants
ADHD
Increase dopamine and norepinephrine, improving attention
Methylphenidate (Ritalin)
Side effects can be serious. Tardive dyskinesia is a movement disorder, with involuntary movements of the face, mouth, and limbs, related to the regulation of dopamine in the nervous system, that can appear after long use of antipsychotic medication and may be permanent. Medications can also have a placebo effect, so researchers use double-blind designs to separate drug effects from expectations.
Brain stimulation and surgery
Surgical or invasive interventions are used when other treatments fail.
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT): a brief electric current is passed through the brain of an anesthetized patient to produce a seizure. It is used mainly for severe depression that has not responded to other treatments, and can work quickly. Side effects include temporary confusion and memory loss around the treatment, and it is controversial, though it is safe and effective under modern medical conditions.
Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS): a magnetic coil placed on the scalp sends pulses that stimulate nerve cells in a targeted area (often the left prefrontal cortex). It is noninvasive, needs no anesthesia, and has fewer side effects than ECT. It is used for depression that does not respond to medication.
Psychosurgery: surgery on the brain to change behavior, which may involve lesioning (destroying a small area of tissue). The lobotomy (cutting the connections to the frontal lobes) was popular in the mid-twentieth century, and was used on tens of thousands of people, though it often left patients with serious personality and cognitive damage; it is rarely, if ever, performed today. Modern psychosurgery is rare and precise and is a last resort.
Hypnosis
Hypnosis is a social interaction in which a hypnotist suggests that a person will experience changes in perception, thought, or behavior, and the person, in a relaxed and focused state, responds. Hypnosis has shown effectiveness in treating pain and anxiety, as an addition to treatment (for example, during medical procedures). Research does not support the use of hypnosis to retrieve accurate memories or for age regression: hypnotized people can feel more confident about their memories and produce more detail, but they also produce more false memories, because the suggestions of the hypnotist can create them (Lesson 2.8). For this reason, testimony recalled under hypnosis is generally not accepted in court. Theories differ about whether hypnosis is an altered state of consciousness or a case of focused attention and role-playing (the sociocognitive view), and there is evidence for both.
Group therapy
Group therapy is treatment in which several clients meet together with one or more therapists. It differs from individual therapy in several ways:
Clients see that others share their problems (universality), which reduces isolation, and they can give and receive support.
Clients practice social skills and get feedback from several people, not only the therapist.
It is less expensive, because many people are treated at once, and it allows more people to be treated.
The therapist's attention to each person is limited, and some people may feel uncomfortable sharing personal issues in a group, and confidentiality is harder to ensure.
Related formats include family therapy, which treats the family as a system in which a problem may reflect the relationships and patterns among members, and self-help or support groups (such as Alcoholics Anonymous), which are led by peers and not professionals.
Worked example · Match the drug class
Match the class. (a) A medication that blocks dopamine to reduce hallucinations. (b) A drug that blocks serotonin reuptake to relieve depression. (c) A fast-acting drug that calms panic by enhancing GABA. (d) A salt that levels out manic and depressive swings. (e) A drug that increases dopamine to improve focus in a child with ADHD.
Step 1, (a) antipsychotic.
Step 2, (b) antidepressant (SSRI).
Step 3, (c) antianxiety drug (benzodiazepine).
Step 4, (d) mood stabilizer (lithium).
Step 5, (e) stimulant.
Worked example · Evaluate a hypnosis claim
A lawyer says that a witness who was hypnotized "remembered exactly" what the suspect looked like, so the memory must be more accurate. Evaluate.
Step 1, research shows that hypnosis does not increase the accuracy of memory; it often increases the amount of detail and the person's confidence.
Step 2, suggestion by the hypnotist can lead to false memories, so the added details may be wrong.
Step 3, because confidence is not a reliable sign of accuracy, the claim is not supported, and courts often exclude such testimony.
Step 4, hypnosis does have support for treating pain and anxiety.
Worked example · Choose a treatment
Compare ECT and TMS for a patient with severe depression that has not improved with two antidepressants. List one advantage of each.
Step 1, ECT: works quickly and has strong evidence of effectiveness for severe depression, including in people who have not responded to other treatments.
Step 2, TMS: noninvasive, no anesthesia or seizure, and fewer side effects (no memory loss of the kind seen with ECT).
Step 3, a clinician would weigh the severity (ECT for severe or urgent cases), the patient's preferences, and the risks, and might use medication and psychotherapy along with it.
Exam focus
Deinstitutionalization followed psychotropic medication; treatment is now decentralized, often with medication plus therapy.
ECT, TMS, psychosurgery (the lobotomy is obsolete).
Hypnosis helps with pain and anxiety, not memory retrieval or age regression.
Group therapy: lower cost, universality, social feedback; less individual attention.
Practice
What led to deinstitutionalization in the late twentieth century?
Show answer
The increased use and effectiveness of psychotropic medications, which allowed many people to be treated outside hospitals.
What is tardive dyskinesia and which drugs cause it?
Show answer
A movement disorder, linked to dopamine regulation, that can follow long-term use of antipsychotic medication.
Compare ECT and TMS.
Show answer
Both stimulate the brain to treat depression; ECT uses an electric current to cause a seizure under anesthesia and can cause memory loss, while TMS is noninvasive and uses magnetic pulses with fewer side effects.
Why is hypnosis not a reliable method of recovering memories?
Show answer
It can create false memories through suggestion and increases confidence without increasing accuracy.
Give two advantages and one limitation of group therapy.
Show answer
Advantages: lower cost and the sense that others share one's problems (and social feedback). Limitation: less individual attention and less privacy.
Which type of medication is used for bipolar disorder?
Show answer
A mood stabilizer such as lithium.
Unit 5 review · 10 multiple-choice
Unit 5 review: Mental and Physical Health
Ten questions spread across all eleven lessons in the exam's three styles (concept
application, data analysis, and scientific investigation) with DSM-5-TR criteria, treatment
evidence, and the design questions that decide what a clinical result is worth.
Multiple choice
For three weeks Priya works long hours on a demanding project, feels wired but
functional, and sleeps badly. The morning after she submits it she comes down with a heavy cold.
Which stage of the general adaptation syndrome does the cold best illustrate?
Alarm is the opening burst (sympathetic activation, adrenaline, a body mobilized
in seconds), and it belongs at the start of the three weeks, not at the end. By the time the
cold arrives the stressor is over, which is the giveaway that a later stage is being
tested.
Correct. Selye's third stage is where the bill comes due: cortisol held high
through the resistance phase suppresses immune function, so illness tends to surface once the
demand lifts. Note the coping split the lesson uses: a fixed revision schedule is
problem-focused because it changes the stressor, while a run is emotion-focused because it
changes her reaction.
Resistance is the plateau during the three weeks: costly but functional, exactly
the "wired but functional" stretch the scenario describes. The question asks about the cold,
which comes after that plateau ends, so resistance names the wrong part of the sequence.
Eustress is arousal that sharpens performance rather than swamping it, and it may
well describe her first week. It is a label for a quality of stress, not a stage of the general
adaptation syndrome, so it cannot answer a question about which stage the illness shows.
Described study
Researchers recruited 240 adults through a well-being website and randomly assigned each one
to one of two one-week writing exercises: listing three good things each evening along with
what caused them, or writing each evening about early childhood memories. Both groups were
asked to write for the same number of minutes and were told the exercise was expected to help.
Happiness and depressive-symptom questionnaires were completed before the week, immediately
after, and again at one, three, and six months.
What is the main purpose of the early-memories writing condition?
That question could be asked of the data, but it is not why the condition is
there. A control condition is defined by its role in the comparison, it supplies the baseline
the treatment is measured against, not by an interest in the control activity itself.
Power comes from how many participants are in the study, and splitting them
across conditions is how an experiment is built, not a way of manufacturing power. If sample
size were the aim, the researchers would simply put all 240 in one group and have no
comparison at all.
An active comparison condition drawn from a rival theory is a legitimate design,
but nothing here presents early-memory writing as a treatment anyone predicted would work.
It was chosen because it looks and feels like the exercise while lacking the ingredient under
test.
Correct. A control that does nothing leaves expectancy and time-on-task free to
explain any improvement; this one matches both and withholds only the active ingredient,
crediting causes and noticing good things. That is what makes the comparison clean, and it is
the design point a scientific investigation item usually targets.
A ninth grader checks his locker four or five times before every class. He knows it is
locked, the checking makes him late, and he has started leaving home early to make room for it.
He describes feeling ashamed and unable to stop. A counselor is weighing whether this pattern
crosses the threshold for a diagnosis. Which criteria are doing most of the work?
Correct. Of the four criteria clinicians weigh (distress, dysfunction,
deviation, danger) two are clearly present: he suffers, and the behavior costs him time and
punctuality. That functional cost, not the strangeness of the behavior, is what moves a habit
toward a diagnosis such as obsessive-compulsive disorder, and it is why a person can be
unusual without being unwell.
Deviation from a norm is the weakest of the four criteria on its own: plenty of
statistically unusual behavior is harmless, and what counts as deviant varies by culture and
setting. Using it alone is how ordinary difference gets pathologized, which is the error the
criteria are designed to prevent.
Danger means risk of physical harm to the person or to others, and nothing in
the scenario describes any. It is also the rarest of the four criteria in practice: most
people who meet criteria for a psychological disorder pose no danger to anyone, and assuming
otherwise is the stereotype that drives stigma.
Comorbidity describes two or more diagnoses co-occurring, such as a depressive
disorder alongside an anxiety disorder. It is a real and common feature of clinical practice,
but it is not a criterion for deciding whether a single pattern is a disorder in the first
place.
Tomás is afraid of dogs. Each time he sees one he crosses the street, and his anxiety
drops within seconds. He has now rerouted his commute and stopped visiting a friend who has a
dog. Which principle best explains why the avoidance persists and why the fear does not fade?
Relief is the removal of something unpleasant, not the addition of
something pleasant, so this is negative rather than positive reinforcement. The two are the
most confused pair in the unit: both raise behavior, and the sign refers to whether a stimulus
is added or taken away.
Punishment decreases the behavior it follows, and Tomás's avoidance is
increasing, so the term has the wrong direction built in. Notice that the scenario reports a
behavior becoming more frequent and more elaborate, which rules out punishment before any
other reasoning starts.
Correct. The avoidance is maintained because it works in the short run, and that
short-run success is the trap: each crossing removes anxiety immediately, while guaranteeing
he never learns that a leashed dog on the sidewalk passes without incident. Breaking that loop
is exactly what exposure therapy is for, which is why it is the best-supported treatment for
specific phobia.
Classical conditioning plausibly explains how the fear was acquired, but the
roles are assigned wrongly: a frightening event would be the unconditioned stimulus and the
dog the conditioned stimulus. And acquisition is not the question asked: the item asks what
keeps the fear alive now, which is the operant half of the two-factor account.
After a poor audition, Wren says: "I choked because I'm just not a performer. I never
have been and I never will be. And it's the same with everything I try." Which part of her
statement expresses the global dimension of a pessimistic explanatory style?
This is the event being explained, not the explanation of it. Attributional style
is about the causes a person assigns, so the phrase that describes the outcome cannot be the
one that carries a dimension.
This is the internal dimension: the cause is located in her rather than
in the situation, the piece, or the panel. Internal, stable, and global are three separate
dimensions, and items like this one ask you to keep them apart.
This is the stable dimension: the cause is treated as permanent rather
than temporary. It is the one most often mistaken for global, but stability is about time,
while global is about breadth across situations.
Correct. Global means the cause is taken to apply everywhere, so one bad audition
becomes evidence about her whole life. A cognitive therapist would often dispute the global
claim first, because it is the easiest to test against evidence Wren already has: the other
things she does competently.
Described graph
A bar chart shows the lifetime risk of a diagnosis of schizophrenia by genetic relationship to
a person diagnosed with it, pooled across dozens of European twin, family, and adoption
studies (Gottesman, 1991). Risk in percent runs up the vertical axis. Four bars are shown:
general population, just under 1%; sibling, about 9%; fraternal (dizygotic) twin, about 17%;
identical (monozygotic) twin, about 48%.
Which conclusion is best supported by the display?
A single-gene disorder would produce concordance near 100% in identical twins,
who share essentially all their genes. The chart shows about 48%, which is the strongest
single piece of evidence against a one-gene account and for many genes of small
effect plus environmental contributions.
Correct. Read the display in both directions, which is what a data analysis item
rewards: 48% against 17% for pairs who share a womb and a household is the genetic evidence,
because identical twins differ from fraternal twins mainly in genes; 48% against 100% is the
environmental evidence. Together they are the diathesis-stress model in one chart.
The bars are not close, 17% is nearly double 9%, and even if they were, a
chart of relatedness categories cannot isolate shared environment. That comparison needs
designs the display does not contain, such as identical twins reared apart or adoption
studies.
The number is read correctly and then explained backwards. Identical and
fraternal twin pairs are both typically raised in the same household, so a shared household
cannot explain why one group's risk is nearly three times the other's; what differs between
them is genetic similarity.
Described data
Adolescent girls in a rural Fijian province completed a standard questionnaire on eating
attitudes in 1995, shortly after television became available in the region, and a separate
sample of about the same size completed it in 1998 (Becker and colleagues, 2002). The table
gives the percentage of each sample scoring in the range that indicates disordered eating
attitudes.
Survey year
Percent scoring in the at-risk range
1995, television newly available
about 13%
1998
about 29%
Which statement is best supported by these data?
Correct. Both halves are supported: 29% against 13% is more than double, and no
one was randomly assigned to watch television, so the design is correlational. The honest
reading names a plausible alternative: the late 1990s also brought tourism, cash work, and
schooling changes to the province, any of which could carry the effect.
Two errors in one sentence. The causal verb is not licensed by a study with no
random assignment, and the arithmetic is misreported: 13% to 29% is a rise of 16 percentage
points, which is a relative increase of more than 120%, not "a 16% increase."
A screening questionnaire measures attitudes, not diagnoses. Scoring in an
at-risk range means a clinician might want to look further; a diagnosis of anorexia nervosa
requires restriction leading to significantly low body weight, intense fear of weight gain,
and disturbed body image, assessed by a clinician.
The stimulus says a separate sample of about the same size completed the 1998
survey, so these are two cross-sectional samples three years apart, not the same girls
followed over time. That distinction matters: a repeated cross-section describes a population
shift and cannot tell you that any individual's attitudes changed.
Described data
Adults who met criteria for a specific phobia of dogs were randomly assigned to eight sessions
of systematic desensitization, eight sessions of cognitive restructuring alone, or a waitlist.
Avoidance was measured with a behavioral approach test scored from 0 (will not enter the room)
to 40 (will hold the leash), administered before treatment and again after eight weeks by an
assessor who did not know the assignment. Higher scores mean less avoidance.
Group
n
Mean before
Mean after 8 weeks
Systematic desensitization
32
11.4
30.6
Cognitive restructuring only
31
11.8
22.1
Waitlist
30
11.6
13.2
Which statement is best supported by the table?
Compare each group with the control, not with the best group. Cognitive
restructuring gained 10.3 points against the waitlist's 1.6, which is a substantial benefit;
it is simply a smaller one than desensitization produced.
A 1.6-point move on a 40-point scale over eight weeks is close to flat, and it is
the reason the waitlist is there, to show what happens without treatment. Reading it as
spontaneous recovery inverts the evidence, and it would also have to explain why the treated
groups moved six to twelve times as far.
Correct. Subtract before from after in each row: 30.6 − 11.4 = 19.2,
22.1 − 11.8 = 10.3, and 13.2 − 11.6 = 1.6. The comparison is fair because random assignment
left the groups nearly equal at baseline and the assessor was blind to condition, which is why
the gap between the two active treatments can be read as the contribution of exposure
itself.
Similar baselines show that random assignment worked, not that the measure is
valid. Validity would require the approach-test score to line up with something independent (clinician ratings, or real avoidance outside the clinic), and a table of group means cannot
supply that.
Described study
A company gave a new herbal supplement to 300 adults who reported persistent low mood.
Everyone received the supplement, everyone knew what they were taking, and each person
completed a standardized depression rating scale at enrollment and again after eight weeks.
The group's mean score fell from 18.6 to 13.9. The company's press release states that the
supplement "relieves depression in eight weeks."
Which change to the design would most directly address the strongest objection to that
conclusion?
More participants would pin down the 4.7-point drop more tightly, but the problem
is not how precisely the drop is measured: it is that a one-group design offers no way to
tell what produced it. Thirty times the sample with no comparison condition buys a precise
estimate of an uninterpretable number.
Correct. With a single group, at least three explanations compete with the
supplement: expectancy, ordinary remission over eight weeks, and regression toward the mean,
since people enroll when they feel worst. A placebo arm supplies the baseline and
double-blinding keeps expectancy from moving either the participants' answers or the raters'
scores, and such a trial must also disclose the chance of receiving placebo in the consent
form and move anyone who worsens into active treatment.
Weekly measurement produces a nicer curve and might reveal when change happens,
but every point on that curve still belongs to one group with nothing to compare it against.
More frequent measurement of the wrong design does not fix the design.
A clinician interview is generally a stronger outcome measure than self-report,
and in an unblinded study it can be worse, since a clinician who knows everyone took the
supplement brings expectations too. Either way, improving the dependent variable leaves the
missing control group untouched.
A research summary contains this sentence: "Symptom severity was recorded as each
participant's total score on a 17-item clinician-administered interview, completed before
treatment and again after twelve weeks." Which part of an Article Analysis Question does this
sentence most directly answer?
Correct. An operational definition says how a construct was actually measured, here a total score on a named 17-item interview at two fixed time points, which is what part
B is scored on. Writing "symptom severity means how bad the symptoms were" is a dictionary
definition and earns nothing; the instrument and the score are the point.
Part A wants the design named: experiment, quasi-experiment, correlational study,
case study, naturalistic observation, survey, longitudinal design, or meta-analysis. A measures
sentence describes an instrument, not a design, and you would look instead for the sentence
about assignment to conditions.
Part C asks you to say what a reported number indicates about the findings: what
a mean difference, a percentage, a correlation, or an effect size tells us here. The sentence
quoted reports no number at all; it describes how numbers were generated.
Part E is answered from the participants paragraph: how many people, their ages,
sex, culture, how they were recruited, and the setting. The sentence quoted names who
administered the interview, which is procedure, not a participant characteristic.
AAQ 1 · 25 minutes · 7 points
Using the source, respond to parts A through F: do the reported results support or refute the claim that memory is reconstructive?
Directions
Read the source, then respond to all six parts in complete sentences, in order, labeling
each part with its letter. You may write the parts as separate short paragraphs. Do not bring
in a different study; every claim you make about the research must come from this source.
Parts A through E are worth one point each and part F is worth two, for seven points in
twenty-five minutes.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. State the operational definition of the dependent variable in the
first experiment, the speed estimate.
C. Describe what the difference between the mean speed estimate of 40.8
miles per hour and the mean speed estimate of 34.0 miles per hour indicates about the
study's findings.
D. Identify at least one ethical guideline the researchers applied.
E. Explain the extent to which the findings can be generalized beyond
the people who took part, using specific evidence about the participants.
F. Explain how the study's specific results support or refute the claim
that memory is reconstructive. (2 points)
Source
Source: research summary written for this course, based on Loftus and
Palmer (1974).
The researchers asked whether the wording of a question put to a witness after an event
changes what that witness later reports about the event. Two experiments were run with
undergraduate students at an American university, tested in groups in a campus laboratory
room.
In the first experiment, 45 students watched seven short films of staged traffic
accidents, each running between about five and thirty seconds, drawn from driver-education
safety materials. After each film the students wrote an account of the accident in their
own words and then answered a set of specific questions about it. One question was
critical. Students were asked how fast the cars were going when the collision occurred,
and the verb used in that question differed by group: nine students were asked with the
verb smashed, nine with collided, nine with bumped, nine with
hit, and nine with contacted. Each student answered by writing a speed
in miles per hour. The mean estimate was 40.8 miles per hour among students asked with
smashed and 34.0 miles per hour among students asked with hit, with the
other three verbs producing means that fell between those two figures.
A second experiment asked whether the wording changes the remembered event itself rather
than only the answer given at the moment. A further 150 students watched a one-minute film
that contained a brief multiple-car accident. Fifty were asked the speed question with the
verb smashed, fifty with the verb hit, and fifty were asked no question
about speed at all. One week later all 150 returned and answered a new set of questions
without seeing the film again. Among these was a question about whether they had seen any
broken glass. There was no broken glass anywhere in the film. About 32 percent of the
students questioned with smashed reported that they had seen broken glass,
compared with about 14 percent of those questioned with hit and about 12 percent
of those who had been asked nothing about speed.
Students volunteered for the sessions after being told they would watch films of traffic
accidents and answer questions about what they had seen, and they could stop at any point.
The films were standard driver-education footage rather than graphic material. Responses
were recorded by group rather than by name, and the purpose of varying the verb was
explained to the students once their questionnaires had been collected.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The method, named: the word experiment (or laboratory
experiment) has to appear. The source gives you the two features that make it one: groups
received different verbs while the films were held constant. Describing that procedure
without naming the method earns nothing, and "survey" or "correlational study", tempting
because the data came from a questionnaire, contradicts the source.
B. How the variable was measured here: the speed estimate in miles per
hour that each student wrote on the questionnaire after viewing the film. Saying "how fast
the students thought the cars were going" is a definition of the construct, not an
operational definition; the point comes from naming the written number and its unit.
C. Interpret the gap, do not restate it: 40.8 and 34.0 are means for
groups who saw identical films, so the 6.8 mile-per-hour difference cannot have come from
what was on screen. Say what it indicates: the verb in the question shifted reported speed
by almost seven miles per hour. Writing "a mean is an average" defines a statistic instead
of interpreting this one.
D. A guideline they followed: informed consent (students were told what
they would watch and could stop), debriefing (the verb manipulation was explained after the
questionnaires were collected), the right to withdraw, or confidentiality of responses. A
criticism of the study, that the wording misled people, is an ethical problem, not a
guideline applied, and earns nothing.
E. Participant evidence first, then the judgment: 45 undergraduates at
one American university in the first experiment and 150 in the second, all students, all
watching short films in a laboratory rather than witnessing a crash. Cite at least one of
those details and then say how far the findings travel. A bare "this cannot be generalized"
earns nothing.
F. Results plus the concept, both (2 points): cite figures from the
source (40.8 against 34.0; 32 percent against 14 and 12 percent) and explain that a stored
recording could not be altered by a question asked afterward, so retrieval must rebuild the
event from the trace plus later information. One point if you cite the numbers without
linking them to reconstruction, or explain reconstruction without the numbers.
Show a 7/7 response
A The researchers used an experiment. Students were assigned to
groups that received different verbs in the critical question while the films were held
constant, so a variable was manipulated across conditions: a laboratory experiment, not a
survey or a correlational study.
B In the first experiment the dependent variable was the speed
estimate, operationally defined as the number of miles per hour each student wrote on the
questionnaire in answer to the question about how fast the cars were going when the
collision occurred. In the second experiment it was a yes-or-no answer to the question about
broken glass one week later.
C Both numbers are group means for students who watched exactly the
same films, so the 6.8 mile-per-hour difference between 40.8 and 34.0 cannot come from
anything they saw. It indicates that a single word in the question changed the reported
speed: students asked with the stronger verb reported a crash almost seven miles per hour
faster than students asked with the milder one. The mean difference measures the size of
that wording effect.
D The researchers applied informed consent. The source reports that
students volunteered after being told they would watch films of traffic accidents and answer
questions about them, and could stop at any point. They also debriefed
participants, explaining the purpose of varying the verb once the questionnaires had been
collected.
E Generalization is limited, and the participant details show why.
The first experiment used 45 undergraduates at a single American university and the second
150 more from the same population, so the sample was narrow in age, education and country.
They also watched short driver-education films in a laboratory, where nothing was at stake,
rather than witnessing a real crash. The wording effect has been found with other groups, so
the direction probably extends beyond students, but the size of these means and percentages
should not be carried over to witnesses of real events.
F The results support the claim that memory is reconstructive. If
remembering worked like replaying a recording, the question asked afterward could not touch
the stored copy, and every group watching the same film would report the same speed. Instead
the mean estimate was 40.8 miles per hour with one verb and 34.0 with another, and a week
later about 32 percent of the students asked with the stronger verb reported broken glass
that was never in the film, against about 14 percent asked with the milder verb and about 12
percent asked nothing about speed. The broken-glass result is the stronger evidence, because
a detail that did not exist was reported as something seen, seven days later, by people whose
only difference was one word in an earlier question. That is what reconstruction means:
retrieval rebuilds the event from the original trace together with information that arrived
afterward, and the post-event wording became part of what these students reported
remembering. The misinformation effect names this pattern, and the percentages rise with how
much misleading information each group received.
Where the points are earned
A: Research method (1): names the method, "an experiment", and
justifies the label with the manipulation of the verb against constant films. Naming it
is what earns the point; the justification protects against a reader who suspects a
lucky guess.
B: Operational definition (1): gives the measure as the researchers
took it, a number of miles per hour written on a questionnaire in answer to a named
question, rather than defining "speed estimate" in the abstract. The second sentence
covers the follow-up measure in case a reader treats the broken-glass report as the
identified variable.
C: Interpreting the statistic (1): interprets the mean difference
in context instead of defining a mean: identical films, a 6.8 mile-per-hour gap,
therefore an effect of the question's wording on what was reported.
D: Ethical guideline (1): identifies informed consent and grounds it
in what the source actually reports, students were told what they would watch and could
stop, then adds debriefing as a second guideline. Either alone would earn the point.
E: Generalizability (1): states a limit and supports it with
participant evidence from the source: 45 undergraduates, then 150 more, one American
university, laboratory films rather than a witnessed crash. It also separates the
direction of the effect from its magnitude, which is the honest version of the
judgment.
F: Argumentation, evidence (1 of 2): cites specific results rather
than gesturing at them: 40.8 against 34.0 miles per hour, and 32 percent against 14 and
12 percent reporting broken glass a week later.
F: Argumentation, explanation (2 of 2): links those results to
reconstructive memory and uses the concept correctly: a recording could not be altered
by a later question, so retrieval must combine the original trace with post-event
information, which is the misinformation effect. The response says which result is the
stronger evidence and why, which is what separates a full-credit argument from a
summary.
AAQ 2 · 25 minutes · 7 points
Using the source, respond to parts A through F: do the reported results support or refute observational learning as an explanation of aggression?
Directions
Read the source, then respond to all six parts in complete sentences, in order, labeling
each part with its letter. You may write the parts as separate short paragraphs. Do not bring
in a different study; every claim you make about the research must come from this source.
Parts A through E are worth one point each and part F is worth two, for seven points in
twenty-five minutes.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. State the operational definition of the dependent variable, imitative
physical aggression.
C. Describe what the difference between a mean of about 25.8 imitative
physically aggressive acts among boys who watched an aggressive male model and a mean of
about two among children who watched no model indicates about the study's findings.
D. Identify at least one ethical guideline the researchers applied.
E. Explain the extent to which the findings can be generalized beyond
the children who took part, using specific evidence about the participants.
F. Explain how the study's specific results support or refute
observational learning as an explanation of aggression. (2 points)
Source
Source: research summary written for this course, based on Bandura, Ross
and Ross (1961).
The researchers tested whether young children will reproduce specific aggressive acts
performed by an adult they have watched, in the adult's absence and without reward.
The participants were 72 children at a university nursery school in the United States, 36
boys and 36 girls, aged about three to six years (mean age near four years and four
months). Each child was first rated for everyday aggressiveness by an experimenter and a
teacher who knew the child. Children with similar ratings were matched in groups of three,
and one child from each group was placed in each of three conditions: an aggressive model,
a non-aggressive model, or no model. Within the model conditions half the children saw an
adult man and half an adult woman.
Children in the model conditions were brought one at a time to a room with craft materials
at one table and, in a corner, a mallet, toys, and a five-foot inflatable doll weighted
to right itself when struck. For about ten minutes the non-aggressive model assembled toys
quietly and ignored the doll. Over the same period the
aggressive model performed a fixed sequence of distinctive acts against it: laying it on its
side and punching its nose, striking its head with the mallet, tossing it in the air,
and kicking it about the room, while repeating a short set of aggressive phrases. Every
child was then taken to a room of attractive toys and, after a brief play period, told
they were being saved for other children: a mild frustration procedure used in all three
conditions. Each child was then observed for twenty minutes in a test
room containing the mallet, the doll and other toys, with an adult present. Observers behind
a one-way mirror recorded behavior in five-second intervals, giving 240 scored intervals
per child, and counted those containing an act reproducing what the model had done.
Children who had watched the aggressive model reproduced those acts far more often than
the other two conditions, whose imitative counts were close to zero. Boys who
had watched an aggressive male model averaged about 25.8 imitative physically aggressive
acts; girls who had watched an aggressive female model averaged about 5.5; children who saw
no model averaged about two or fewer. Counting all aggressive behavior rather than
imitation alone, the aggressive-model group produced roughly twice as much as the other
groups, and boys imitated physical aggression more than girls did.
The children took part with the permission of their parents. The frustration procedure was
kept brief and mild, an adult stayed in the room throughout the test, and the records were coded
interval counts rather than identifying accounts.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The method, named:experiment (a laboratory experiment with
matched participants). The source hands you the evidence: children were matched on prior
aggressiveness and then assigned to three conditions that differed only in what the adult
did. "Naturalistic observation" is the trap here: observation through a one-way mirror is
how the data were collected, not the design, because the researchers arranged what each
child saw.
B. How the variable was counted here: the number of five-second
intervals, out of the 240 in the twenty-minute session, in which observers recorded the
child performing one of the acts the model had performed. Calling it "how aggressive the
child was" restates the construct; the point comes from the interval count and the fact that
only reproductions of the model's specific acts were scored.
C. Interpret the gap, do not restate it: about 25.8 against about two is
a difference of roughly an order of magnitude between groups that had been matched on
aggressiveness beforehand, so the gap indicates that what the children watched, not who they
already were, produced the behavior. Saying "25.8 is bigger than 2" is not an
interpretation.
D. A guideline they followed: parental consent, protection from harm
(the frustration was deliberately brief and mild, an adult stayed in the room), or
confidentiality (coded interval counts rather than identifying records). Writing that
frustrating children was unethical names a problem rather than a guideline applied, and
earns nothing.
E. Participant evidence first, then the judgment: 72 children, aged
about three to six, all enrolled at one university nursery school in the United States in
the early 1960s. Cite at least one of those facts, then say how far the findings travel and
note that the target was an inflatable toy built to be struck.
F. Results plus the concept, both (2 points): use the numbers (about
25.8 against about two, imitative counts near zero without an aggressive model) and explain
that the children performed distinctive acts they had never been taught and were never
reinforced for, in the model's absence: acquisition by observation. A full-credit answer
also marks the limit: imitation directed at a doll. One point for numbers without the
concept, or the concept without numbers.
Show a 7/7 response
A The researchers used an experiment. Children were matched on
prior aggressiveness ratings and then assigned to one of three conditions (aggressive
model, non-aggressive model, or no model), so the adult's behavior was manipulated while
everything else was held constant.
B Imitative physical aggression was operationally defined as the
number of five-second intervals, of the 240 in the twenty-minute test, in which
observers behind a one-way mirror recorded the child performing one of the specific acts the
model had performed, such as punching the doll's nose, striking it with the mallet, or tossing it
in the air.
C Boys who watched an aggressive male model averaged about 25.8
of these acts while children who saw no model averaged about two, so the modeled group
produced them more than ten times as often. Because the children had been matched on how aggressive
they already were, that difference indicates the effect
of what the child watched rather than a difference in the children themselves.
D The researchers applied consent in the form appropriate to
children: the source reports that they took part with the permission of their parents. They
also protected them from harm, since the frustration procedure was kept brief and mild
and an adult stayed in the room throughout.
E Generalization is limited. All 72 participants were three- to
six-year-olds at a single university nursery school in the United States, a narrow slice by
age, culture and background, and the behavior was measured minutes later in a
laboratory room. The target was an inflatable doll built to be struck, not a person, so the
results speak to whether young children copy what they see, not to whether watching aggression
harms others. That children imitate adult models has held up widely,
but these counts are not a measure of real-world aggression.
F The results support observational learning as an explanation of
how aggressive behavior is acquired. The children who saw the aggressive model reproduced a
fixed sequence of unusual acts (punching the doll's nose, hitting it with a mallet, throwing
it in the air) that no one had taught them and for which they received no reward, and they
did it with the model gone. That is the core claim of observational learning:
behavior can be acquired by watching a model, with no reinforcement of the learner.
The comparison groups strengthen the case: children who saw no model and children who watched an
adult play quietly averaged about two such acts or fewer. These were not simply
what nursery school children do with a mallet and a doll; they reached 25.8 only where they had been
demonstrated. Boys imitated physical aggression most after watching a male
model, which fits the idea that a model's characteristics affect how much is imitated. The
evidence has a boundary: what was copied was aggression toward an inflatable
toy, so the study supports observational learning as a route by which aggressive acts are
acquired rather than proving it explains violence against people.
Where the points are earned
A: Research method (1): names the method, "an experiment", and
supports the label with the manipulation of the model's behavior across three
conditions. It does not stop at describing the one-way mirror, which would be procedure
rather than design.
B: Operational definition (1): gives the measure as it was actually
taken: coded five-second intervals, 240 of them, scored only when the child reproduced
one of the model's specific acts. A general description of "aggressive behavior" would
not earn this.
C: Interpreting the statistic (1): interprets the mean difference in
this study: about 25.8 against about two, a more than tenfold gap between groups matched
on prior aggressiveness, and says what that licenses: the behavior came from what was
watched, not from who the children were.
D: Ethical guideline (1): identifies parental consent, grounded in
the sentence of the source that reports it, and adds protection from harm as a second
guideline. Either would earn the point on its own.
E: Generalizability (1): makes a judgment and supports it with
participant evidence from the source: 72 children, ages three to six, one university
nursery school in the United States. It then separates the general principle from these
particular numbers.
F: Argumentation, evidence (1 of 2): cites specific results: the
distinctive modeled acts reproduced, about 25.8 imitative acts against about two
without a model, imitation highest for boys watching a male model.
F: Argumentation, explanation (2 of 2): uses observational learning
correctly, explaining that behavior was acquired by watching, without reinforcement and
in the model's absence, and uses the control comparison to rule out the obvious rival
explanation. Naming the boundary (a doll, not a person) shows control of the concept
rather than weakening the argument.
AAQ 3 · 25 minutes · 7 points
Using the source, respond to parts A through F: do the reported results support or refute normative social influence as the explanation of conformity?
Directions
Read the source, then respond to all six parts in complete sentences, in order, labeling
each part with its letter. You may write the parts as separate short paragraphs. Do not bring
in a different study; every claim you make about the research must come from this source.
Parts A through E are worth one point each and part F is worth two, for seven points in
twenty-five minutes.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. State the operational definition of the dependent variable,
conformity.
C. Describe what the figure of about 37 percent of critical trials
indicates about the study's findings.
D. Identify at least one ethical guideline the researchers applied.
E. Explain the extent to which the findings can be generalized beyond
the people who took part, using specific evidence about the participants.
F. Explain how the study's specific results support or refute normative
social influence as the explanation of conformity. (2 points)
Source
Source: research summary written for this course, based on Asch (1951,
1956).
The researchers examined how often a person will give an answer he can see is wrong when
everyone else in the room has already given that answer aloud.
Across this series of studies 123 male college students in the United States took part, one
at a time, in what each was told was an experiment on visual perception. Each participant
joined a group of seven to nine other people, all of them confederates working with the
experimenter: a fact the participant did not know. The group sat in a row, and the
participant was seated second from the end so that he heard almost all of the other answers
before giving his own.
On each of 18 trials the experimenter displayed two cards. One carried a single standard
line; the other carried three comparison lines, one matching the standard in length and two
differing from it clearly. Group members said aloud, in seating order, which comparison line
matched the standard. On six of the trials the confederates gave the correct answer. On the
remaining 12, the critical trials, every confederate named the same wrong line before the
participant spoke.
Conformity was recorded as the proportion of critical trials on which the participant named
aloud the same wrong line as the unanimous majority. Across participants that figure came to
about 37 percent of critical responses. About 75 percent of participants went along with the
majority on at least one critical trial and about a quarter never did. A control group judged
the same cards alone and wrote their answers privately; those participants were wrong on
under 1 percent of trials. In a further variation one confederate broke the unanimity by
naming the correct line, and conformity fell to a fraction of its level in the unanimous
condition.
Participants were interviewed after the session. Those who had gone along most often said
that they had seen the difference between the lines but did not want to appear different
from the group or to draw its attention; a smaller number said the group's agreement had
made them doubt their own eyes.
Participation was voluntary and the line judgments carried no risk of harm. Participants
were deceived about the purpose of the sessions and about the other people in the room,
because telling them in advance would have destroyed the situation being studied. The
interview afterward was used to explain the deception, the role of the confederates and the
real purpose of the research before the participant left.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The method, named:experiment (a laboratory experiment). The
researchers arranged what the confederates said and compared it with a control condition in
which people judged alone, so nothing here was left to occur naturally. "Naturalistic
observation" and "case study" both contradict the source.
B. How the variable was counted here: the proportion of the 12 critical
trials on which the participant said aloud the same wrong comparison line the majority had
named. "How much the participant agreed with the group" restates the construct; the point
comes from naming the critical trials and the spoken wrong answer.
C. Interpret the figure, and read it correctly: 37 percent is the share
of critical responses that followed the majority, not the share of people who
conformed: that is the 75 percent figure, and confusing the two is the commonest error on
this item. Interpret it against the baseline: people judging alone erred on under 1 percent
of trials, so more than a third of public answers went wrong under group pressure while
nearly two thirds stayed independent.
D. A guideline they followed: debriefing (the interview afterward
explained the deception, the confederates and the real purpose), voluntary participation, or
protection from harm (a line-judging task carries no risk). Writing that the deception was
unethical names a problem rather than a guideline applied, and earns nothing.
E. Participant evidence first, then the judgment: 123 male college
students in the United States, tested in the 1950s, judging lines whose correct answer was
obvious. The all-male, single-country, single-era sample is the evidence part E wants; cite
it, then say how far the findings travel.
F. Results plus the concept, both (2 points): the strongest evidence for
normative influence is the combination of the under 1 percent error rate alone, the
interview reports of seeing the difference but not wanting to stand out, and the collapse of
conformity when one confederate dissented. A full-credit answer also uses the minority who
said they doubted their own eyes to limit the claim. One point for results without the
concept, or the concept without results.
Show a 7/7 response
A The researchers used an experiment. They controlled what the
confederates said on each trial and compared the result against a control condition in which
people judged the same cards alone, so this is a laboratory experiment rather than observation
of groups in natural settings.
B Conformity was operationally defined as the proportion of the 12
critical trials on which the participant said aloud the same wrong comparison line that the
unanimous majority of confederates had named before him.
C About 37 percent means that just over a third of the answers
given on critical trials followed the majority into an error. It is a
rate of responses, not a count of people, so it does not mean 37 percent of participants
conformed. Set against the control group, who were wrong on under 1 percent of trials when
they judged alone, the figure indicates that hearing a unanimous wrong answer made public
errors far more likely on a task whose answer was obvious, while leaving nearly two thirds of
responses independent.
D The researchers debriefed their participants. The source reports
that the interview after the session explained the deception, the role of the confederates and the
real purpose of the research before the participant left. Participation
was also voluntary, and the line-judging task itself carried no risk of harm.
E Generalization is limited by who was studied. All 123 participants
were male college students in the United States, tested in the 1950s, so the results describe
young American men of one decade and say nothing directly about women, older adults, or
cultures where disagreeing carries a different cost. The task was
also unusual: an unambiguous perceptual judgment made aloud among strangers. Conformity
to a unanimous majority has been found in many places since, so the direction travels, but the
37 percent rate is not a fixed value.
F The results support normative social influence as the main
explanation, though not the only one. Normative influence means going along with a
group to gain acceptance or avoid standing out, not because you believe it is right. Three results point that way. First, control participants judging alone were wrong on
under 1 percent of trials, so conformers could see which line matched; their errors were not
failures of perception. Second, in the interviews those who had gone along
most often said they had seen the difference but did not want to appear different from the
group: a concern about being accepted, not about being correct, which is exactly what
normative influence describes. Third, conformity fell sharply when a single
confederate named the correct line: what changed was not the information about the lines but
the cost of being the only person to disagree. The claim is qualified by the smaller
group who reported that the majority's agreement made them doubt their own eyes. Those participants describe informational social influence, so the study
supports normative influence as the dominant process here while refuting the stronger claim that
it is all of conformity.
Where the points are earned
A: Research method (1): names the method, "an experiment", and
backs the label with the manipulation of the confederates' answers and the alone
condition used for comparison, instead of describing the line task and stopping.
B: Operational definition (1): gives the measure as it was taken:
the proportion of the 12 critical trials on which the participant spoke the majority's
wrong line aloud. It specifies the trials that counted and the behavior that was
scored.
C: Interpreting the statistic (1): interprets 37 percent in context
and corrects the usual misreading by stating that it is a rate of responses rather than
a percentage of people, then anchors it to the under 1 percent baseline from the alone
condition.
D: Ethical guideline (1): identifies debriefing and grounds it in
what the source reports about the post-session interview, adding voluntary participation
and a harmless task. Any one of the three would earn the point.
E: Generalizability (1): supports its judgment with participant
evidence (123 male college students, United States, 1950s), and names the unusual
feature of the task, then separates the general phenomenon from the particular
rate.
F: Argumentation, evidence (1 of 2): cites three specific results:
the under 1 percent error rate in the alone condition, the interview reports, and the
drop in conformity when one confederate dissented.
F: Argumentation, explanation (2 of 2): defines normative social
influence correctly and links each result to it: accurate private perception, a stated
motive of acceptance rather than accuracy, and unanimity rather than information doing
the work. Using the minority who doubted their own eyes to mark where informational
influence takes over shows the concept is under control rather than merely named.
AAQ 4 · 25 minutes · 7 points
Using the source, respond to parts A through F. Explain whether the findings support or refute neuroplasticity: the claim that experience changes the physical structure of the brain.
Directions
You have 25 minutes. Respond to all parts of the question in complete sentences, in order,
labeling each part A through F. Use the source to answer; do not summarize it.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. State the operational definition of the dependent variable, cortical
development.
C. Describe what the difference in mean cortical weight between the
enriched and isolated groups indicates about the study's findings.
D. Identify at least one ethical guideline the researchers applied.
E. Explain the extent to which the findings can be generalized, using
specific evidence about the participants.
F. Explain how the study's specific results support or refute
neuroplasticity. (2 points)
Source
Source: research summary written for this course, based on Rosenzweig,
Bennett, and Diamond (1972).
Researchers at a university laboratory asked whether the complexity of an animal's daily
surroundings changes the physical structure of its brain. The animals were male rats of a
standard laboratory strain, taken from the same litters and weaned at about twenty-five days
old. Within each litter, siblings were assigned by chance to one of three housing conditions,
so that each litter contributed one animal to each condition and inherited differences were
spread evenly across the groups.
In the enriched condition, about a dozen rats shared one large cage furnished with a changing
set of objects (ladders, platforms, wheels, boxes, tunnels) drawn from a larger pool, with
several objects swapped for different ones each day. In the standard colony condition, two or
three rats lived together in an ordinary laboratory cage containing no objects. In the
isolated condition, a rat lived alone in a cage of the same kind, in a separate quiet room.
Food and water were freely available in every condition, and lighting, temperature, diet and
handling were held the same across the three. Animals remained in the assigned condition for
about thirty days in the standard version of the experiment.
At the end of that period the brains were removed and dissected into standard sections.
Cortical development was recorded as the weight in milligrams of the dissected cortical
tissue, the thickness of the cortex measured in prepared sections, and the ratio of cortical
weight to subcortical weight, which the researchers treated as their most consistent measure
because it adjusts for differences in overall body and brain size. They also measured the
activity of acetylcholinesterase, an enzyme involved in synaptic transmission.
Rats from the enriched condition finished with a heavier and thicker cortex than their
isolated littermates. Averaged across the cortex as a whole, the difference in mean weight
was about four percent; in the occipital region, the visual area at the back of the cortex,
it was larger, on the order of six percent. The cortical-to-subcortical ratio separated the
groups more consistently than raw weight did, and total acetylcholinesterase activity was
greater in the cortex of the enriched animals. The differences were small in absolute terms,
but they appeared again in repeated runs of the experiment over several years, and standard
colony animals fell between the other two groups.
The work was carried out under the institution's animal-care oversight. Housing met the
standards then in force for cage size, ventilation, temperature, diet and veterinary
attention, trained staff handled the animals daily, and the procedures at the end of the
study followed approved humane methods.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A: Research method: the word experiment. Littermates were assigned
to housing conditions by chance and the researchers controlled the condition each animal lived
in, so housing is a manipulated independent variable. Saying "the researchers put rats in
different cages and weighed their brains" describes the procedure without naming the method and
earns nothing; so does calling it a correlational study or a naturalistic observation.
B: Operational definition: cortical development as this study measured it:
the weight in milligrams of dissected cortical tissue, cortical thickness in prepared sections,
and the ratio of cortical to subcortical weight. "Brain development" or "how developed the brain
was" restates the construct rather than defining it by the measurement, and earns nothing.
C: Interpreting the statistic: say what the roughly four percent difference
in mean cortical weight tells us here: on average the enriched rats ended with a
measurably heavier cortex than their isolated littermates, a small difference that ran in the
same direction across replications and was larger, about six percent, in the occipital cortex.
Defining what a mean or a percentage is does not earn the point.
D: Ethical guideline: institutional animal-care review, or humane treatment
and housing of animal subjects: cage standards, ventilation, temperature, diet, veterinary
attention, trained handling, approved humane procedures at the end of the study. Point to what
the source reports. Criticizing the isolation condition names a problem, not a guideline the
researchers applied, and earns nothing.
E: Generalizability: limited, and the participant evidence has to be
specific: male rats of one laboratory strain, littermates weaned at about twenty-five days,
housed for roughly thirty days in a laboratory, with no human participants and no females. The
contrast between about a dozen cage-mates with daily new objects and solitary housing in a quiet
room is also far wider than the gap between two children's homes. A bare "this can't be
generalized to humans" with no participant detail earns nothing.
F: Argumentation (2 points): commit to support, then quote the
study's own numbers and connect them to the concept. Neuroplasticity claims that experience
changes brain structure; the enriched animals' cortex was about four percent heavier, about six
percent heavier in the occipital region, thicker, higher in cortical-to-subcortical ratio and
higher in total acetylcholinesterase activity, and random assignment of littermates rules out
inherited differences as the cause. Results with no link to the concept, or the concept with no
results, caps the part at 1.
Show a 7/7 response
A The researchers used an experiment. Littermate rats were assigned by
chance to one of three housing conditions, and the researchers controlled which condition each
animal lived in, so housing was a manipulated independent variable rather than something the
animals arrived with.
B The dependent variable was cortical development, and in this study it
was operationally defined as the weight in milligrams of the dissected cortical tissue, the
thickness of the cortex measured in prepared sections, and the ratio of cortical weight to
subcortical weight, the measure they relied on most because it adjusts for differences in
overall brain and body size.
C The statistic is the roughly four percent difference in mean cortical
weight between the enriched and the isolated groups. It indicates that the average rat raised
with cage-mates and rotating objects finished with a measurably heavier cortex than the average
littermate raised alone. Four percent is a small difference in absolute terms, but it is a
difference between group averages that came out in the same direction each time the experiment
was repeated, and it was larger, about six percent, in the occipital cortex.
D One ethical guideline the researchers applied was institutional
animal-care review with humane treatment of animal subjects. The source reports that the work
was carried out under institutional animal-care oversight, that housing met the standards
then in force for cage size, ventilation, temperature, diet and veterinary attention, and that
the procedures at the end of the study followed approved humane methods.
E The findings generalize only so far. The participants were male rats
of a single standard laboratory strain, littermates weaned at about twenty-five days old and
kept in their assigned cages for roughly thirty days in a laboratory. No humans took part, no
females were included, and only one strain was used, so the size of the effect cannot be
carried over to people. The conditions were also more extreme than ordinary human variation:
about a dozen cage-mates with new objects daily at one end, a rat living alone in a quiet room
at the other. What does travel is the claim the study was built to test: that structure
responds to experience at all.
F The results support neuroplasticity, the claim that experience
changes the physical structure of the brain. The enriched rats' cortex was about four percent
heavier on average than their isolated littermates', about six percent heavier in the occipital
region, thicker in prepared sections, higher in the ratio of cortical to subcortical weight, and
higher in total acetylcholinesterase activity. F Those are structural
and biochemical differences that line up with the one thing that differed between the groups:
what the animals did all day. Because littermates were assigned to conditions by chance,
inherited differences cannot explain the gap, so experience is the credible cause of the
structural change, which is what neuroplasticity claims. Standard colony animals landing
between the other two groups strengthens the reading, since the amount of structural change
tracked the amount of experience.
Where the points are earned
A: Research method (1): the first sentence names the method, and the
rest of A justifies the name by pointing to random assignment of littermates and to a
manipulated independent variable. Naming the method is what the rubric requires; describing
the procedure alone would earn nothing.
B: Operational definition (1): B gives the measurements this study
actually took (milligrams of dissected cortical tissue, thickness in prepared sections, and
the cortical-to-subcortical weight ratio) instead of defining cortical development in the
abstract.
C: Interpreting the statistic (1): C says what the four percent mean
difference indicates in this study: the average enriched rat finished with a heavier cortex
than the average isolated littermate, a small but repeated difference that was larger in the
occipital cortex. It interprets the number rather than defining what a percentage is.
D: Ethical guideline (1): D names institutional animal-care review and
humane housing, both grounded in what the source reports, and is a guideline the researchers
followed rather than a criticism of the isolation condition.
E: Generalizability (1): E gives a judgment, limited, and supports it
with specific participant evidence: male rats, one laboratory strain, littermates weaned at
about twenty-five days, thirty days of housing, a laboratory setting, and conditions far
more extreme than ordinary human variation.
F: Argumentation (2): the first point comes from citing the study's
specific results: the four percent whole-cortex difference, the six percent occipital
difference, greater thickness, a higher cortical-to-subcortical ratio, greater
acetylcholinesterase activity. The second point comes from the explanation that follows:
these are structural differences produced by the one factor that varied, random assignment
of littermates rules out heredity, and the standard colony group falling in between shows
the change scaling with experience, which is precisely the claim neuroplasticity makes.
AAQ 5 · 25 minutes · 7 points
Using the source, respond to parts A through F. Explain whether the findings support or refute the cognitive explanation of depression: the claim that changing distorted thinking changes mood.
Directions
You have 25 minutes. Respond to all parts of the question in complete sentences, in order,
labeling each part A through F. Use the source to answer; do not summarize it.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. State the operational definition of the dependent variable, depression
severity.
C. Describe what the difference between the two groups' mean end-of-treatment
scores on the self-report depression inventory indicates about the study's findings.
D. Identify at least one ethical guideline the researchers applied.
E. Explain the extent to which the findings can be generalized, using
specific evidence about the participants.
F. Explain how the study's specific results support or refute the cognitive
explanation of depression. (2 points)
Source
Source: research summary written for this course, based on Rush, Beck,
Kovacs, and Hollon (1977).
Researchers at the outpatient clinic of a university medical center in the United States
compared a talking therapy with an antidepressant medication as treatments for depression.
Forty-one adults who had come to the clinic for help with moderate to severe depression took
part. Women and men were included; all were seeking treatment for themselves, and each was
interviewed and rated by a clinician before entering. People whose difficulties were better
accounted for by another condition, and people already receiving another treatment, were not
enrolled.
Each patient was assigned at random to one of two twelve-week treatments. Nineteen were
assigned to cognitive therapy: up to twenty sessions in which the therapist and the patient
identified automatic negative thoughts about the self, the world and the future, tested those
thoughts against evidence from the patient's own week, and worked out more accurate
alternatives, with assignments to carry out between sessions. Twenty-two were assigned to
imipramine, a tricyclic antidepressant, prescribed and adjusted by a physician across the same
twelve weeks and tapered before the end of the trial.
Depression severity was measured with two standardized instruments given before treatment, at
intervals during it, and at the end: an inventory the patient completed alone and a rating
scale completed by a clinician who interviewed the patient. Each instrument yields a total
score, with higher totals indicating more severe symptoms.
Both groups improved over the twelve weeks. Mean self-report scores at intake were close to 30
in both groups, in the moderate to severe range. By the end of treatment the cognitive therapy
group's mean had fallen into the single digits and the medication group's mean to the
mid-teens, leaving a difference between the two group means of roughly seven points in favor
of cognitive therapy. The clinician ratings moved in the same direction. About 79 percent of
the patients assigned to cognitive therapy were rated markedly improved or free of symptoms at
the end of treatment, compared with about 23 percent of those assigned to medication. One of
the nineteen patients in cognitive therapy left treatment early, compared with eight of the
twenty-two taking medication. The trial ran at one clinic, with no placebo condition and no
group receiving both treatments.
Before entering, each patient was told what the two treatments involved, what would be
measured and how often, and that participation could be ended at any point without affecting
the care available at the clinic; each then gave informed consent. A clinician monitored
symptoms at scheduled points throughout the twelve weeks. Patients whose symptoms did not
improve, and patients who left the trial early, were offered continued care and referral to
other treatment. Records were kept confidential.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A: Research method: the word experiment, or the more precise
randomized clinical trial, which is an experiment. Patients were assigned at random to
one of two treatments, so treatment type is a manipulated independent variable. Calling it a
case study, a correlational study or a longitudinal study earns nothing, and so does describing
the twelve weeks of treatment without naming the method.
B: Operational definition: depression severity as this study measured it:
the total score on a standardized self-report inventory the patient completed and on a rating
scale completed by an interviewing clinician, given before, during and after the twelve weeks,
with higher totals meaning more severe symptoms. Defining depression by its symptoms is a
definition of the construct, not an operational definition, and earns nothing.
C: Interpreting the statistic: say what the roughly seven-point gap between
the two group means indicates here: both groups started near 30 and both improved, but
the average patient finishing cognitive therapy ended with a lower symptom score than the
average patient finishing on medication. Note that it compares group averages, so it does not
mean every person in cognitive therapy did better. Defining what a mean difference is earns
nothing.
D: Ethical guideline: informed consent is the cleanest answer: patients
were told what each treatment involved and what would be measured before agreeing. The right to
withdraw without penalty, protection from harm through scheduled clinical monitoring and the
offer of continued care and referral, and confidentiality of records are all equally creditable.
Naming the missing placebo condition is a design criticism, not a guideline applied, and earns
nothing.
E: Generalizability: limited, with the participant evidence named: 41
adults, women and men, at a single university outpatient clinic in one country, all of them
help-seekers who came to the clinic themselves with moderate to severe depression, and people
with other conditions or already in treatment excluded. Forty-one people at one site is a small
base for a treatment claim, and the findings say nothing about children or adolescents, about
people with mild depression, or about people who never seek treatment. A bare "the sample was
too small" with no participant detail earns nothing.
F: Argumentation (2 points): commit to support, then use the
numbers. The cognitive explanation holds that depressed mood is maintained by distorted negative
thinking about the self, the world and the future; a treatment that targets those thoughts
directly should therefore reduce symptoms. It did (roughly seven points lower on the mean
self-report score, about 79 percent versus about 23 percent rated markedly improved or free of
symptoms, and 1 dropout out of 19 versus 8 out of 22), and random assignment makes the treatment
the credible cause. A strong response also names the limit: symptoms were measured, thoughts
were not, so the result is consistent with the explanation rather than proof of the mechanism.
Results with no link to the concept, or the concept with no results, caps the part at 1.
Show a 7/7 response
A The researchers used an experiment: a randomized clinical trial.
Patients were assigned at random to either cognitive therapy or imipramine, so treatment type
was a manipulated independent variable rather than something patients chose.
B The dependent variable was depression severity, operationally defined
as the total score on two standardized instruments given before, during and after the twelve
weeks: an inventory the patient completed alone and a rating scale completed by a clinician who
interviewed the patient, with higher totals meaning more severe symptoms.
C The statistic is the roughly seven-point difference between the two
groups' mean self-report scores at the end of treatment. Both groups began near 30, in the
moderate to severe range, and both improved, so the seven points indicate how much further the
cognitive therapy group moved: the average patient finishing cognitive therapy ended in the
single digits while the average patient finishing on medication ended in the mid-teens. It is a
comparison of group averages, so it does not mean every patient in cognitive therapy did better
than every patient on medication.
D One ethical guideline the researchers applied was informed consent.
The source reports that before entering, each patient was told what the two treatments involved
and what would be measured, and was told that participation could end at any point without
affecting the care available at the clinic. Protection from harm was also handled: a clinician
monitored symptoms at scheduled points, and patients who did not improve or who left early were
offered continued care and referral.
E The findings generalize to patients much like these and not far
beyond. There were 41 adults, women and men, all of them people who came on their own to one
university outpatient clinic in one country with moderate to severe depression, and people with
other conditions or already in treatment were excluded. That is a small sample at a single site,
so the exact size of the advantage is imprecise. The results also say nothing about children or
adolescents, about people with mild depression, or about people who never seek treatment.
F The results support the cognitive explanation of depression. Patients
given a treatment aimed directly at distorted thinking ended about seven points lower on the
mean self-report inventory than patients given medication, about 79 percent of them were rated
markedly improved or free of symptoms against about 23 percent on medication, and only one of
nineteen left treatment early against eight of twenty-two. F The
cognitive explanation says depressed mood is maintained by negative, distorted beliefs about the
self, the world and the future, so a therapy that catches those thoughts and tests them against
evidence should lift mood, and here it did, at least as much as a drug acting on
neurotransmitters, with random assignment making the treatment the credible cause. The support
is real but partial: the study measured symptoms, not the thoughts themselves, so it shows the
prediction holding rather than proving that changed thinking is the mechanism.
Where the points are earned
A: Research method (1): the first sentence names the method, experiment,
and identifies the more precise form, a randomized clinical trial, then justifies the label
with random assignment and a manipulated independent variable.
B: Operational definition (1): B gives the measurement this study used (total scores on a patient-completed inventory and a clinician-completed rating scale, taken
before, during and after treatment, higher meaning more severe) instead of defining
depression as a construct.
C: Interpreting the statistic (1): C says what the seven-point gap
indicates in this study: both groups started near 30 and improved, and the cognitive therapy
group finished further down, in the single digits against the mid-teens. The closing
sentence shows the response understands that a difference in means describes groups, not
individuals.
D: Ethical guideline (1): D names informed consent and grounds it in
what the source reports, then adds protection from harm through monitoring and the offer of
continued care. Both are guidelines the researchers followed, not criticisms of the design.
E: Generalizability (1): E gives a judgment and backs it with specific
participant evidence: 41 adults, women and men, one university outpatient clinic in one
country, self-referred help-seekers with moderate to severe depression, other conditions
excluded, then says which populations are therefore out of reach.
F: Argumentation (2): the first point comes from citing the study's
specific results: the seven-point difference in mean self-report scores, about 79 percent
against about 23 percent rated markedly improved or free of symptoms, one dropout of
nineteen against eight of twenty-two. The second point comes from the explanation that
follows: the cognitive explanation is stated correctly, the prediction it makes is spelled
out, the results are shown to meet that prediction with random assignment supporting the
causal reading, and the honest limit (symptoms measured, thoughts not) keeps the claim
the size the evidence allows.
EBQ 1 · 45 minutes · 7 points
Using the sources provided, develop and justify an argument about whether high schools should start the school day later in the morning.
Directions
You have 45 minutes. Use the three sources below. Your evidence must come from at least two of
them. Cite the sources you use as "Source A," "Source B," or "Source C," or by the authors' names.
Write in complete sentences and label each part.
A. Propose a specific and defensible claim, based in psychological science,
that responds to the question.
B(i). Support your claim using one specific and relevant piece of evidence
from one of the sources, and cite that source.
B(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part B(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding you learned in this course.
C(i). Provide additional support for your claim using a second specific and
relevant piece of evidence, drawn from a different source than the one used in Part
B(i), and cite that source.
C(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part C(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding that is different from
the one used in Part B(ii).
Source A
Source A: research summary written for this course, based on Carskadon and colleagues (1980, 1998).
A sleep laboratory studied adolescents in a residential summer sleep camp, recording brain
activity overnight and testing daytime alertness the next day. Participants were boys and girls
ranging from late childhood into the late teens, some of them followed across several summers
as they moved through puberty. Given a fixed ten-hour opportunity to sleep each night, the
older adolescents slept about as long as the youngest, roughly nine hours, even though the
older ones reported feeling less sleepy in the evening. Compared across stages of pubertal
maturation, the onset of melatonin release shifted later, so the more physically mature
adolescents did not become sleepy until later at night. A second study by the same group
followed several dozen students in a Rhode Island district whose high school day began at
7:20 a.m. On school nights those students slept roughly seven hours, well short of the nine
hours the laboratory work indicated they needed. On morning laboratory tests many fell asleep
within a few minutes, a degree of sleepiness clinicians treat as pathological, and some entered
REM sleep directly, a pattern otherwise seen in sleep disorders. Limitation: the camp work used
small volunteer samples living under artificial conditions, and the school study compared
students before and after a schedule change rather than assigning them to start times, so
maturation and course load changed alongside the clock.
Source B
Source B: research summary written for this course, based on Walker and colleagues (2002).
Healthy young adults with no reported sleep disorders learned a motor sequence task in a
laboratory: typing a fixed five-key sequence with the non-dominant hand, as quickly and
accurately as possible, across a series of timed trials. Learning was operationalized as the
number of correct sequences typed per trial. Participants were assigned to be retested either
after about twelve hours awake across an ordinary day or after about twelve hours that included
a night of sleep. No one practiced between training and retest. The group that stayed awake
finished close to where training had left them. The group that slept typed the sequence
roughly 20 percent faster and made fewer errors, with no additional practice. When the
researchers examined the overnight sleep recordings, the size of a participant's improvement
was related to the amount of stage 2 NREM sleep in the last quarter of the night, the part of
the night a person loses by setting an early alarm. A companion experiment found that a daytime
nap containing both slow-wave and REM sleep produced gains comparable to a full night, while
shorter naps without REM did not. Limitation: the samples were small groups of healthy young
adults and the task was narrow, so a keyboard sequence is not the same as classroom material.
Source C
Source C: research summary written for this course, based on Dunster and colleagues (2018).
Two public high schools in Seattle moved their start time from 7:50 a.m. to 8:45 a.m., a delay
of 55 minutes, and researchers measured what changed. Participants were roughly 170 sophomore
biology students, studied as two cohorts: one in the spring before the change and one in the
spring after it. Each student wore a wrist activity monitor for about two weeks, which recorded
movement and rest and produced an objective estimate of sleep duration rather than a
self-report. Students also completed sleepiness questionnaires, and the researchers obtained
course grades and attendance records. After the change, median sleep duration on school nights
was about 34 minutes longer. Self-reported daytime sleepiness was lower. Median grades in the
same course, taught with the same curriculum both years, were about 4.5 percent higher in the
later-start cohort, and at the school serving more economically disadvantaged students,
tardiness and first-period absence dropped. Limitation: this is a before-and-after comparison
of two different groups of students, not a randomized experiment, so anything else that
differed between the two years (the teachers, the particular students, the season) could
contribute to the grade difference, and the comparison covers one course rather than a whole
transcript.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The claim (1 point). Take a side and make it specific enough to be wrong.
"Schools should start later because adolescent sleep timing is biologically delayed and the lost
sleep is the sleep that consolidates learning" earns the point. "Sleep is important for students"
does not: nothing in the sources could contradict it. "Later starts are not worth the cost
because the grade gain in Source C comes from an uncontrolled before-and-after comparison" is
also defensible here, and the sources support it; you are not required to argue for delay.
B(i) and C(i): the evidence (1 point each). Quote a particular result, not a
topic. Usable pieces: the roughly nine hours of sleep obtained under a ten-hour opportunity and
the later melatonin onset with pubertal maturation (Source A); the seven hours slept under a
7:20 a.m. start and falling asleep within minutes on morning tests (Source A); the roughly 20
percent overnight gain with no extra practice, and its link to stage 2 NREM sleep late in the
night (Source B); the 55-minute delay, the 34 additional minutes of measured sleep, the 4.5
percent higher median grades, or the drop in first-period tardiness (Source C). "Source C is
about Seattle schools" earns nothing. The two pieces must come from two different sources:
two findings out of Source A cannot earn both points.
B(ii). The first explanation (2 points). Name the concept and apply it.
Circadian rhythms and the suprachiasmatic nucleus is the cleanest fit for Source A: the SCN sets
a roughly 24-hour rhythm from light and drives melatonin, the adolescent phase delay pushes sleep
onset later, and therefore an early bell cannot move bedtime; it only cuts the morning off.
One point instead of two if you write "teenagers' body clocks are different" without naming the
rhythm, the nucleus, or the phase delay, or if you only restate that the students slept seven
hours.
C(ii). The second explanation (2 points), with a different concept.
Sleep-dependent memory consolidation is the natural second family: the hippocampus-to-cortex
stabilization that happens during NREM and REM explains why 34 more minutes of sleep shows up as
higher grades, and Source B supplies the research finding that the relevant sleep sits in the
last quarter of the night. Other usable concepts: operant conditioning and environmental
contingencies for the attendance and tardiness result, or selective attention and working memory
capacity for daytime performance.
Which pairs count as "different." Circadian rhythm and the SCN (a biological
explanation of timing) paired with memory consolidation (a cognitive explanation of
learning) satisfies the rule, as does circadian rhythm paired with operant
reinforcement of attendance, or consolidation paired with the person-environment fit between a
delayed clock and a fixed bell. What fails: "circadian rhythms" and "the body clock," or "sleep
deprivation" and "not enough sleep." Those are one concept named twice, and the second
explanation scores 1 at most.
Show a 7/7 response
A High schools should start the day later, because the obstacle to
adolescent sleep is biological timing rather than teenage choice, and the sleep an early bell
removes is precisely the sleep that stabilizes what students learned the day before.
B(i) Source A reports that adolescents given a ten-hour sleep
opportunity slept about nine hours regardless of age, that the onset of melatonin release shifted
later as students matured through puberty, and that students in a district starting at 7:20 a.m.
slept only about seven hours on school nights and fell asleep within a few minutes on morning
laboratory tests.
B(ii) This supports the claim through circadian rhythms and the
suprachiasmatic nucleus. The SCN uses light to hold the body on a roughly 24-hour cycle and
triggers melatonin release when that cycle says night has arrived, and Source A shows that the
release point moves later with pubertal maturation. That matters because a start time can only
change when sleep ends, not when it begins: a student whose melatonin does not rise until late
cannot fall asleep on command at nine o'clock, so moving the bell from 8:45 to 7:20 subtracts
time from the front of the morning rather than adding it to the night. The seven-hour average
and the pathological-level sleep latencies in Source A are what that subtraction looks like. The
shortfall is a mismatch between a fixed schedule and a delayed biological clock, which is a
problem schools can fix and adolescents cannot.
C(i) Source C provides a second kind of support: when two Seattle high
schools delayed their start by 55 minutes, wrist monitors showed students sleeping about 34
minutes longer on school nights, and median grades in the same biology course were about 4.5
percent higher in the later-start cohort.
C(ii) Sleep-dependent memory consolidation explains why extra sleep
turns into higher grades. Consolidation is the process by which a newly encoded memory is
stabilized and reorganized during sleep rather than during practice, and Source B demonstrates
it directly: participants who slept typed a learned sequence about 20 percent faster with no
further practice, while those who stayed awake did not improve, and the size of each person's
gain tracked the stage 2 NREM sleep in the final quarter of the night. The 34 minutes Seattle
students recovered came from exactly that final quarter, so the later start returned the sleep
in which the previous day's learning gets consolidated. The grade increase is the classroom
version of the laboratory result. I would hold this conclusion loosely, since Source C compared
two different cohorts rather than randomly assigning start times, but the mechanism in Source B
is experimental and predicts the direction Source C found.
Where the points are earned
A: Defensible claim (1): The claim answers the question asked with a
position, not a summary, and names the reasoning the response then defends: the constraint
is biological timing, and the sleep lost is the sleep that consolidates learning. Sources
could contradict it, if Source A had shown melatonin onset unchanged by puberty, the claim
would fail.
B(i): Evidence from a source (1): Three specific results from Source A,
cited by source: nine hours slept under a ten-hour opportunity, later melatonin onset with
pubertal maturation, and seven hours of school-night sleep with sleep latencies of a few
minutes under a 7:20 a.m. start. Each is a particular finding rather than a description of
what the source is about.
B(ii): Explanation with a concept (2): Names circadian rhythms and the
suprachiasmatic nucleus and applies them correctly: the SCN entrains to light and gates
melatonin, the adolescent phase delay moves sleep onset later, and therefore an earlier
start clips the end of sleep instead of moving the beginning. The explanation connects the
mechanism to the exact numbers cited rather than restating them.
C(i): Evidence from a different source (1): The second piece comes from
Source C, not Source A, and is equally specific: a 55-minute delay, about 34 additional
minutes of actigraphy-measured sleep, and median grades about 4.5 percent higher in the same
course.
C(ii): Explanation with a different concept (2): Sleep-dependent memory
consolidation is a genuinely different family of explanation from circadian timing (one is
about when sleep happens, the other about what sleep does to a memory), and
it is named, defined, and applied. It also imports Source B's research finding, the 20
percent overnight gain tied to late-night stage 2 NREM sleep, to link the recovered 34
minutes to the grade increase. The closing sentence acknowledges Source C's cohort design
without abandoning the claim, which costs nothing and shows the reader the argument is
controlled.
EBQ 2 · 45 minutes · 7 points
Using the sources provided, develop and justify an argument about the extent to which the situation, rather than personality, explains harmful obedience.
Directions
You have 45 minutes. Use the three sources below. Your evidence must come from at least two of
them. Cite the sources you use as "Source A," "Source B," or "Source C," or by the authors' names.
Write in complete sentences and label each part.
A. Propose a specific and defensible claim, based in psychological science,
that responds to the question.
B(i). Support your claim using one specific and relevant piece of evidence
from one of the sources, and cite that source.
B(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part B(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding you learned in this course.
C(i). Provide additional support for your claim using a second specific and
relevant piece of evidence, drawn from a different source than the one used in Part
B(i), and cite that source.
C(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part C(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding that is different from
the one used in Part B(ii).
Source A
Source A: research summary written for this course, based on Milgram (1963, 1974).
Forty men from the New Haven area, aged roughly 20 to 50 and recruited by newspaper
advertisement, were told the study concerned learning and memory. Each was assigned the role of
teacher at a shock generator whose switches were labeled from 15 to 450 volts. When the
learner, who was a confederate, answered incorrectly, an experimenter in a lab coat instructed
the teacher to move one switch higher and delivered a fixed series of verbal prods whenever the
teacher objected. No shocks were actually delivered. The dependent variable was the highest
switch a participant pressed. Twenty-six of the forty men, 65 percent, continued to the maximum
level, and many showed visible distress while continuing. The same researcher later ran
variations that changed only the setting. When the experimenter left the room and gave the
orders by telephone, the proportion reaching the maximum fell to about one participant in five.
When the study moved from the university to a run-down office building, it fell to roughly half.
When two confederates playing fellow teachers refused and walked out first, about one in ten
continued to the end. Limitation: all participants were men from one American city, the
deception and distress would not pass review today, and no participant was randomly assigned to
a no-authority control.
Source B
Source B: research summary written for this course, based on Burger (2009).
A partial replication was designed to run under modern ethical rules. Seventy adults, 29 men
and 41 women aged 20 to 81, were recruited from a California community. A two-stage screening
excluded anyone with a history of anxiety or depressive disorders and anyone who recognized the
original procedure, a clinical psychologist observed every session with authority to halt it,
participants were told at least three times that they could stop and keep the payment, and the
sample shock was reduced. The procedure was stopped at 150 volts, the point in the original
study where the learner first demands to be released and where most participants who defied the
experimenter did so. About 70 percent of participants in the base condition were still going at
that point and had to be stopped by the experimenter, a rate close to the comparable figure in
the original study; the difference was not statistically significant. Men and women did not
differ. Participants had completed questionnaire measures of empathic concern and desire for
control weeks earlier, and those scores showed no reliable difference between the people who
continued and the people who refused. Limitation: the procedure stopped at 150 volts, so the
study cannot show what any participant would have done at higher levels, and the screening
produced an unusually resilient sample.
Source C
Source C: research summary written for this course, based on Haslam and Reicher (2006).
Fifteen men, selected from a large applicant pool after screening for mental health and
antisocial tendencies, were randomly assigned to be five guards or ten prisoners in a purpose-built
institution and observed for eight days. Clinical psychologists monitored participants daily,
an independent ethics panel held the power to stop the study at any moment, and participants
could withdraw. Psychological measures, including social identification with one's own group,
were collected repeatedly. The guards never became a cohesive group: they disagreed about how
to use their authority, and their identification with the guard role declined across the days.
The prisoners moved the other way. Once it became clear that no prisoner could be promoted into
the guard group, their identification with each other rose sharply, and on day six they
breached the barrier and the guard system collapsed. The participants then set up a
self-governing commune, which broke down within a day, after which a subgroup began planning a
far harsher regime and the researchers ended the study. The authors argued that people do not
automatically conform to an assigned role; harm follows from identifying with a group and its
leaders and working actively toward what feels like a worthwhile cause. Limitation: fifteen male
volunteers, filmed for broadcast, is a small and observed sample.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The claim (1 point). The question asks about extent, so a claim that
weighs the two causes earns the point: "situational features explain most of the variation in
obedience, because identical people obey at very different rates when the setting changes, while
measured personality differences do not separate those who obey from those who refuse." A
qualified claim scores equally well, "the situation explains most of it, but Source C shows the
situational cause is identification with a group and its leaders, not role-following", and is
often easier to defend. "Both personality and the situation matter" does not earn the point;
nothing in the sources could contradict it.
B(i) and C(i): the evidence (1 point each). Name a result. Usable pieces:
26 of 40 men, 65 percent, reaching the maximum level, or the drops to about one in five with
telephoned orders and about one in ten after two confederates walked out (Source A); the roughly
70 percent still going at 150 volts under modern safeguards, or the empathic-concern and
desire-for-control scores failing to separate those who continued from those who stopped
(Source B); guards' identification with their role falling while prisoners' identification with
each other rose, the collapse of the guard system on day six, or the later push toward a harsher
regime (Source C). The two pieces must come from two different sources.
B(ii). The first explanation (2 points). The agentic state and diffusion of
responsibility fit Source A precisely: a legitimate authority who is physically present and who
accepts responsibility lets a person stop seeing themselves as the author of their own act, so
weakening any of those cues (moving the authority to a telephone, removing the university's
prestige, or breaking the unanimity of compliance) lowers obedience without changing who the
participants are. Normative and informational social influence work equally well for the
rebellious-peers variation. One point rather than two if the response says "the situation made
them do it" without naming a mechanism, or names the agentic state but never ties it to a
particular variation.
C(ii). The second explanation (2 points), with a different concept. Trait
theory and the person-situation controversy fit Source B: traits predict behavior averaged over
many occasions, while the situation usually decides any single occasion, which is exactly the
pattern when empathy and control scores fail to predict a one-time decision. Social identity
theory fits Source C: guards who never formed a shared identity could not act as a group, while
prisoners who did, acted decisively.
Which pairs count as "different." Agentic state and diffusion of
responsibility (a situational account of how responsibility is displaced) paired with trait
theory and the person-situation debate (a dispositional account of prediction) satisfies the
rule, as does agentic state paired with social identity theory, or normative social influence
paired with social identity theory. What fails: "obedience" and "social influence," or
"conformity" and "going along with the group." Those are one idea named twice and cap the second
explanation at 1 point.
Show a 7/7 response
A The situation carries most of the explanatory weight: obedience rates
swing enormously when only the setting is changed, while measured personality differences do not
separate the people who obey from the people who refuse. The qualification Source C adds is that
the situational cause is identification with a group and its leaders rather than automatic
role-following.
B(i) Source A reports that 26 of 40 men, 65 percent, continued to the
maximum switch in the original procedure, but that the proportion fell to about one participant
in five when the experimenter gave orders by telephone instead of standing in the room, and to
about one in ten when two confederates playing fellow teachers refused and walked out first.
B(ii) The agentic state, together with diffusion of responsibility,
explains this. Milgram's account is that a person facing a legitimate authority shifts out of an
autonomous state, in which they see themselves as the author of their own actions, into an
agentic state, in which they see themselves as carrying out someone else's intention and hand
the responsibility for the outcome to that person. Each variation removes one of the cues that
supports the shift. A voice on a telephone is a weaker claim to authority than a man in a lab
coat two feet away, so the participant is left holding the responsibility himself. Two peers who
walk out destroy the unanimity that made compliance look like the only available reading of the
situation. The participants in those variations were drawn from the same population as the
original sample, so nothing about their personalities changed between conditions. What changed
was the strength of the situational cues, and behavior followed.
C(i) Source B adds evidence of the other kind. In a replication run
under modern safeguards, questionnaire measures of empathic concern and desire for control,
completed weeks before the session, showed no reliable difference between the participants who
continued past 150 volts and those who refused, even though about 70 percent continued.
C(ii) That null result is what trait theory and the person-situation
controversy predict. Traits are stable dispositions that show their predictive power when
behavior is averaged across many occasions; a single decision in a strong, unfamiliar situation
is precisely the case where the situation dominates and trait scores explain almost nothing.
Empathic concern probably does predict how often a person is kind over a year, but it does not
predict what one person does once at a shock generator with an experimenter insisting. Because
Source B measured personality directly and prospectively rather than inferring it after the
fact, the absence of a relationship is informative: if harmful obedience were a property of
unusual people, those questionnaires were the place it should have appeared.
Where the points are earned
A: Defensible claim (1): The claim answers the "extent" question with a
weighting rather than a summary, gives the reason the response then defends, and is
falsifiable: had Source B found empathic concern predicting refusal, the claim would be in
trouble. The qualification drawn from Source C sharpens it instead of hedging it away.
B(i): Evidence from a source (1): Specific and accurate figures from
Source A, cited by source, 26 of 40 at the maximum level, roughly one in five with
telephoned orders, roughly one in ten after two confederates refused. The comparison across
variations is what makes the evidence relevant to a claim about situations.
B(ii): Explanation with a concept (2): Names the agentic state and
diffusion of responsibility, defines the autonomous-to-agentic shift correctly, and maps
each variation onto a cue that the shift depends on. It also states the logical point that
holds the argument together: the participants did not change across conditions, only the
setting did.
C(i): Evidence from a different source (1): The second piece comes from
Source B rather than Source A, and is a particular result: prospectively measured empathic
concern and desire for control failing to distinguish those who continued from those who
refused, alongside the roughly 70 percent continuation rate.
C(ii): Explanation with a different concept (2): Trait theory and the
person-situation controversy are a different family of explanation from the agentic state:
one is a dispositional theory about when traits predict behavior, the other a situational
mechanism for displaced responsibility. The concept is named and applied correctly (traits
predict aggregated behavior, situations decide single occasions), and the response explains
why a null result here counts as evidence rather than as missing data.
EBQ 3 · 45 minutes · 7 points
Using the sources provided, develop and justify an argument about whether beliefs about ability and control can be changed in ways that improve outcomes.
Directions
You have 45 minutes. Use the three sources below. Your evidence must come from at least two of
them. Cite the sources you use as "Source A," "Source B," or "Source C," or by the authors' names.
Write in complete sentences and label each part.
A. Propose a specific and defensible claim, based in psychological science,
that responds to the question.
B(i). Support your claim using one specific and relevant piece of evidence
from one of the sources, and cite that source.
B(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part B(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding you learned in this course.
C(i). Provide additional support for your claim using a second specific and
relevant piece of evidence, drawn from a different source than the one used in Part
B(i), and cite that source.
C(ii). Explain how the evidence in Part C(i) supports your claim, using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding that is different from
the one used in Part B(ii).
Source A
Source A: research summary written for this course, based on Mueller and Dweck (1998).
Across six experiments, fifth graders recruited from several schools worked a set of nonverbal
reasoning problems and were then told they had done well. The only thing that differed between
groups was the sentence that followed. Children randomly assigned to the ability condition were
told they must be smart at these problems; children in the effort condition were told they must
have worked hard; a comparison group was praised for the score alone. Offered a choice of what
to do next, most effort-praised children took a challenging set described as one they would
learn from, while most ability-praised children took an easier set described as one they would
do well on. Every child then worked a much harder set that almost everyone failed. Afterward
the ability-praised children reported enjoying the work less and wanting to stop, were more
likely to attribute the failure to not being smart enough, and scored lower on a final set of
easy problems than they had on the first set. The effort-praised children attributed the
failure to not having worked hard enough and improved on the final set. Several hundred
children took part across the six experiments, which repeated the pattern with different tasks
and wording. Limitation: the sessions were short, ran outside normal instruction, and measured
performance minutes rather than months later.
Source B
Source B: research summary written for this course, based on Seligman and Maier (1967) and Maier and Seligman (2016).
Dogs were assigned to three conditions: shocks they could switch off themselves, the same
shocks delivered on the same schedule with no way to stop them, and no shocks at all. The
second group received exactly the pattern of shock that the first group's own behavior
produced, so the single difference between those two groups was control. All the animals were
later placed in an apparatus where escaping required only stepping over a low barrier. Animals
from the controllable condition escaped promptly. Most animals from the uncontrollable
condition did not try, remaining still and absorbing the shock. The researchers named the
effect learned helplessness and, in 1978 with Abramson and Teasdale, recast it for humans as
explanatory style: the person who attributes bad events to internal, stable, and global causes
is the one who stops trying. In 2016 the original researchers revised the account on
neuroscience evidence. Passivity, they argued, is the default response of brain circuits to
prolonged aversive events and is not learned at all; what an animal learns when it can act is
that it has control, and that learning inhibits the default. Limitation: small groups of
animals, a procedure that would face far stricter animal-care review today, and a step from
escape latency to human belief that is an inference rather than a finding.
Source C
Source C: research summary written for this course, based on Yeager and colleagues (2019).
A preregistered randomized experiment tested a brief online program in a nationally
representative sample of United States public high schools. Sixty-five schools took part, and
more than 12,000 ninth graders were randomly assigned, within their own schools, to the program
or to a control activity of the same length. The program was two online sessions totaling
about 25 minutes, delivered during the school day, which presented the idea that intellectual
ability can grow with effort and better strategies and asked students to write about it in
their own words. The outcome was grade point average in core ninth-grade courses, taken from
school records rather than from self-report, and recorded by people who did not know which
condition a student had been in. Among lower-achieving students, those who received the
program earned about 0.10 grade points more than the control students, a small average
difference that held across the sample, and more of them enrolled in advanced mathematics the
following year. The effect appeared in schools where peer norms supported taking on
challenging work and was near zero where those norms did not. Limitation: the average effect is
small, it did not appear among higher-achieving students, and its dependence on the school
environment means the program should not be expected to work everywhere.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A. The claim (1 point). The sources support a "yes, with conditions" claim,
and the conditions are what make it defensible: "beliefs about ability and control can be
changed by brief interventions, and the change improves real outcomes, but the gains are small
and appear only for students who held the unhelpful belief and only where the environment lets
the new belief pay off." A skeptical claim also works, "the belief changes reliably in the
laboratory but the payoff outside it is too small and too conditional to justify treating
mindset programs as a fix for achievement gaps", because Source C supplies the effect size and
the moderation. "Mindset matters" earns nothing.
B(i) and C(i): the evidence (1 point each). Cite a result, not a topic.
Usable pieces: one sentence of praise changing which task children chose, and ability-praised
children scoring lower on the final easy set than on the first while effort-praised children
improved (Source A); animals with prior control escaping promptly while most animals without it
did not try, or the 2016 revision that control rather than helplessness is what gets learned
(Source B); the 0.10 grade-point gain for lower-achieving students across 65 schools and more
than 12,000 students, the increased enrollment in advanced mathematics, or the near-zero effect
where peer norms did not support challenge (Source C). Both pieces cannot come from one
source.
B(ii). The first explanation (2 points). Attribution theory and explanatory
style fit Source A exactly: praise for ability supplies an internal, stable, global cause for
success, which the child then applies to failure as "I'm not smart enough," while praise for
effort supplies an internal but unstable and controllable cause. Achievement goal orientation, performance goals versus mastery goals, is an equally good fit for the task choice. One point
rather than two if the response says the children "got a fixed mindset" without naming the
attributional mechanism or connecting it to the specific result.
C(ii). The second explanation (2 points), with a different concept.
Self-efficacy inside Bandura's reciprocal determinism fits Source C: a changed belief about
one's own capability changes behavior, such as enrolling in harder mathematics, which changes
the environment the student then learns in, which feeds back on the belief. Reciprocal
determinism also explains the moderation directly: the person factor alone cannot carry the
outcome, so the effect disappears where peer norms do not cooperate. Effect size versus
statistical significance is the other strong move here: 0.10 grade points is a real but small
difference, and saying so is what makes the claim defensible rather than promotional.
Which pairs count as "different." Attributional style, which is about the
causes a person assigns to an outcome, paired with self-efficacy and reciprocal determinism,
which is about the loop between belief, behavior, and environment, satisfies the rule. So does
attributional style paired with intrinsic motivation and the overjustification effect, or
achievement goal orientation paired with reciprocal determinism. What fails: "growth mindset"
and "fixed mindset," which are two ends of one construct; "learned helplessness" and
"pessimistic explanatory style," which are the same theory in its 1967 and 1978 wordings; and
"self-efficacy" and "self-confidence." Any of those caps the second explanation at 1 point.
Show a 7/7 response
A Beliefs about ability and control can be changed, and changing them
improves real outcomes: but the gains are small, they show up in the students who held the
unhelpful belief to begin with, and they depend on an environment that lets the new belief pay
off.
B(i) Source A reports that a single sentence of praise was enough to
move fifth graders' behavior: most children told they must be smart chose an easier follow-up
task, and after a hard set that nearly everyone failed they blamed their ability, said they
enjoyed the work less, and scored lower on a final easy set than they had scored on the first
one, while the children told they must have worked hard chose the challenging task and improved
on that final set.
B(ii) Attribution theory explains why one sentence did that much work.
An explanatory style is the habit of assigning causes along three dimensions (internal or
external, stable or unstable, global or specific), and the praise handed each group a different
cause for the same success. "You must be smart" is internal, stable, and global, so when the
hard set arrived those children had only one place to file the failure: a fixed quality of
themselves that the evidence now said was low. Nothing can be done about a stable cause, so they
disengaged, and their scores fell. "You must have worked hard" is internal but unstable and
controllable, so failure meant the effort was insufficient, which is a repairable cause, and
those children pushed on. The manipulated variable was the sentence, not the children, so the
belief is what changed and the behavior followed it.
C(i) Source C shows the same kind of change outside a laboratory and
also shows its limits: in a preregistered randomized trial across 65 nationally representative
high schools and more than 12,000 ninth graders, two online sessions of about 25 minutes raised
the core-course grade point average of lower-achieving students by about 0.10 points and raised
the number who later enrolled in advanced mathematics, but the effect was near zero in schools
where peer norms did not support taking on hard work.
C(ii) Reciprocal determinism, with self-efficacy as the personal
factor, accounts for both halves of that result. Bandura's claim is that personal factors,
behavior, and environment each act on the other two, so a belief only produces an outcome by
changing behavior that the environment then rewards. Raising a student's belief that she can
handle harder mathematics changes a choice, she enrolls, and the harder course supplies the
instruction that raises the grade, which in turn confirms the belief. Where classmates treat
challenge-seeking as foolish, the same belief change produces no new behavior, the loop never
closes, and the effect is near zero, which is exactly the pattern Source C found. The 0.10-point
gain should be read as a small effect that reached significance in a very large sample, not as a
transformation.
Where the points are earned
A: Defensible claim (1): The claim takes a position and states three
conditions the response then defends: small gains, concentrated in students who held the
unhelpful belief, dependent on the environment. It is falsifiable: if Source C had found
uniform effects across all schools and all achievement levels, the claim would be wrong.
B(i): Evidence from a source (1): Specific results from Source A, cited
by source: the task chosen after ability versus effort praise, the attribution each group
made after the hard set, and the fall below baseline on the final set for ability-praised
children against improvement for effort-praised children.
B(ii): Explanation with a concept (2): Names attribution theory and
explanatory style, states the internal-stable-global dimensions correctly, and applies them
to the exact wording of each praise condition and the exact result that followed. It also
makes the experimental point that the sentence, not the child, was manipulated, which is
what licenses the causal reading.
C(i): Evidence from a different source (1): The second piece comes from
Source C rather than Source A, and is specific on every count: 65 schools, more than 12,000
ninth graders, about 25 minutes of intervention, 0.10 grade points among lower-achieving
students, higher advanced-mathematics enrollment, and a near-zero effect where peer norms
did not support challenge.
C(ii): Explanation with a different concept (2): Reciprocal determinism
and self-efficacy are a different family of explanation from attributional style: one is a
three-way causal loop among person, behavior, and environment, the other a scheme for the
causes a person assigns to an outcome. The concept is named, defined, and applied to both
the positive result and the null result, and the closing sentence reads 0.10 grade points as
a small effect in a large sample, which keeps the claim's first condition honest.
EBQ 4 · 45 minutes · 7 points
Using the three sources, develop and justify an argument about how much confidence a court should place in a confident eyewitness's memory.
Directions
You have 45 minutes. Read the three sources, then respond to every part in complete sentences,
in order, labeling each part. Your evidence must come from at least two of the three sources.
Cite a source as Source A, Source B, or Source C, or by the researcher's name. You do not need
outside research, but everything you say a source reports must be accurate.
A. Propose a specific and defensible claim based in psychological science
that responds to the question.
B(i). Support your claim using at least one piece of specific and relevant
evidence from one of the sources.
B(ii). Explain how the evidence from Part B(i) supports your claim using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding learned in AP Psychology.
C(i). Provide additional support for your claim using at least one
additional piece of specific and relevant evidence from a different source than the
one used in Part B(i).
C(ii). Explain how the evidence from Part C(i) supports your claim using a
different psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding than the
one used in Part B(ii).
Source A
Source A: research summary written for this course, based on Sperling (1960).
Adult observers viewed a grid of twelve letters, arranged in three rows of four, flashed on a
screen for a fraction of a second. In the whole-report condition they wrote down as many
letters as they could recall from the whole grid. They typically produced about four or five,
and several reported that more letters had been visible but had faded before they could be
written down. In the partial-report condition, a high, medium, or low tone sounded immediately
after the display disappeared, and the pitch indicated which single row to report. Observers
could not know in advance which row would be called. Cued this way, they reported roughly
three of the four letters from whichever row the tone named. Because performance on a randomly
chosen row was that high, the researcher inferred that nearly the whole array had been
available for a brief moment after the display ended. Delaying the tone weakened the
advantage; at a delay of about one second, partial report was no better than whole report.
The design was an experiment in which each observer served in both conditions; the instruction
was the manipulated variable and the number of letters correctly reported was the measure.
Only a small number of practiced observers took part, each completing many trials. The results
are treated as evidence for a very brief visual store, now usually called iconic memory, that
holds more than can be reported before it decays.
Source B
Source B: research summary written for this course, based on Simons & Chabris (1999).
Observers watched a short video of two teams passing basketballs, one team in white shirts and
one in black, and were asked to keep a silent count of the passes made by one of the teams. In
some conditions the task was made harder by requiring separate counts of bounce passes and
aerial passes. Partway through the video, a person in a gorilla suit walked into the middle of
the scene, turned toward the camera, and walked out the other side, on screen for several
seconds. Afterward each observer reported the count and was then asked whether anything
unusual had appeared. Across conditions, roughly half of the observers failed to report the
unexpected event; in the most-cited version of the report about 46% missed it. Misses were
more common when the counting task was harder, and more common when observers were attending
to the white-shirted team than the black-shirted one. Observers who watched the same video
with no counting task noticed the figure nearly every time. Many of those who missed it were
surprised on a second viewing and some questioned whether the same video had been shown.
The design was an experiment: video version and counting difficulty were manipulated across
groups, and the measure was simply whether the observer reported the unexpected event.
Participants were college students tested individually in a laboratory.
Source C
Source C: research summary written for this course, based on Loftus & Palmer (1974).
Forty-five college students watched short films of traffic accidents and then completed a
questionnaire about what they had seen. Buried in the questionnaire was one critical item
asking how fast the cars had been going when they met; the verb in that sentence differed
across groups and included "smashed into," "collided," "bumped," "hit," and "contacted."
Every group had watched the same films. Average speed estimates tracked the verb: the group
questioned with "smashed into" gave a mean of about 40.8 miles per hour, while the group
questioned with "hit" gave a mean of about 34.0. A second experiment with new participants
showed a brief film of a crash and then asked the speed question with "smashed into," with
"hit," or not at all. A week later everyone returned and answered a further questionnaire that
included a question about whether they had seen broken glass. There was no broken glass in the
film. About 32% of those originally questioned with "smashed into" reported seeing it,
compared with about 14% of those questioned with "hit." Both studies were experiments in which
the wording of the question was the manipulated variable; the measures were a numerical speed
estimate and, a week later, a yes-or-no report. The participants were undergraduates watching
films, not witnesses to real crashes.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A: A claim that takes a position on how much weight confident
eyewitness testimony deserves: for example, that it should be treated as a lead requiring
corroboration rather than as proof. "Memory is complicated" or a restatement of the question is
too general to defend and earns nothing.
B(i): One particular finding, with its source named: the roughly 46% of
observers in Source B who missed the unexpected figure, the three-of-four partial report in
Source A, or the 40.8 versus 34.0 mile-per-hour estimates in Source C. Saying only that "Source
B is about attention" is not evidence.
B(ii): A named concept, correctly applied, that connects that finding to the
claim: selective attention and encoding failure, the limited capacity of short-term memory, or
the rapid decay of sensory memory. The explanation must say why the finding makes confident
testimony less trustworthy, not merely restate the finding.
C(i): A second specific finding drawn from a different source than
B(i). Two findings from the same summary cannot earn this point, however good they are.
C(ii): A second named concept from a genuinely different family of
explanation: reconstructive memory, the misinformation effect, source amnesia, or schema-driven
retrieval if B(ii) used attention and encoding. "Attention" and "noticing" count as the same
concept twice and cap this row at 1 point.
Show a 7/7 response
A A court should treat a confident eyewitness memory as a lead worth
investigating rather than as proof, because memory can fail at two separate stages (what gets
into the system, and what comes back out of it), and neither failure feels like a failure to the
witness. Source A shows how briefly the raw visual record is even available. Confidence tracks
how vivid a report feels, not how accurate it is, so testimony should carry real weight only
when something outside the witness's memory corroborates it.
B(i) Source B reports that when observers were counting basketball
passes, about 46% of them failed to notice a person in a gorilla suit who walked through the
middle of the scene and was visible for several seconds, while observers given no counting task
noticed the figure nearly every time. B(ii) This supports my claim
through selective attention and the encoding failure it produces. Attention is a bottleneck:
what is in the attended stream gets encoded into short-term memory, and what falls outside it
is never stored, so there is no trace to retrieve. The observers were not careless; they were
doing exactly what they were told, and the price of that focus was blindness to everything
else. A witness watching a weapon may never encode the rest of the scene, including the face a
lineup will later ask about. Because she has no memory of failing to see it, nothing signals
that anything is missing, and she will describe what she did encode with complete sincerity.
The jury hears certainty; the psychology says that certainty is about the fragment that was
attended, not about the event.
C(i) Source C reports that a week after watching a filmed crash, about
32% of participants asked how fast the cars were going when they "smashed into" each other said
they had seen broken glass, against about 14% asked with the verb "hit", and the film contained
none. C(ii) This supports the same claim through a different mechanism:
reconstructive memory and the misinformation effect. Retrieval is not playback. A memory is
rebuilt each time from a partial trace plus whatever else fits it: schemas, expectations, and
information met after the event. One verb implied a violent collision, broken glass fits that
picture, and a week later the inference was reported as something seen. What should worry a
court is that the distortion came from the question itself, asked by an experimenter with no
motive to mislead. Every interview, lineup instruction, and news story between the crime and the
trial is post-event information of the same kind, so a confident memory at trial may be partly a
record of those rather than of the crime. Because Source B's failure happens at encoding and
Source C's at retrieval, careful interviewing cannot repair what was never encoded, and close
attention cannot protect a memory from later contamination, which is why corroboration, not
confidence, should decide the weight.
Where the points are earned
A: Defensible claim (1): The first sentence takes a position the sources
can defend and that someone could disagree with: confident eyewitness memory is a lead
requiring corroboration, not proof, because memory fails at two stages. It answers the
question asked ("how much confidence"), rather than summarizing the sources or asserting
something no evidence could contradict.
B(i): Evidence from a source (1): A specific, accurate finding with the
source cited: about 46% of observers in Source B missed the unexpected figure while
observers without the counting task saw it nearly every time. The contrast between the two
conditions is what makes it evidence rather than an anecdote.
B(ii): Explanation with a concept (2): Selective attention is named and
applied correctly (the attended stream is what reaches short-term memory, so unattended
information is never encoded and cannot be retrieved), and the explanation then carries that
mechanism to the claim by pointing out that the witness has no internal signal that anything
is missing, which is exactly why confidence and accuracy come apart.
C(i): Evidence from a different source (1): The second finding comes
from Source C, not Source B: about 32% versus about 14% reporting broken glass that was
never in the film, a week after a single verb changed. The evidence therefore spans two
sources, as the directions require.
C(ii): Explanation with a different concept (2): Reconstructive memory
and the misinformation effect are named and correctly applied to a retrieval-stage
distortion, which is a genuinely different family of explanation from the attention and
encoding account used in B(ii): different stage, different mechanism, not a rewording. The
closing sentences make the difference explicit and use it to justify the claim, since a fix
for one stage does nothing for the other.
EBQ 5 · 45 minutes · 7 points
Using the three sources, develop and justify an argument about whether self-control is best understood as a limited resource that can be used up.
Directions
You have 45 minutes. Read the three sources, then respond to every part in complete sentences,
in order, labeling each part. Your evidence must come from at least two of the three sources.
Cite a source as Source A, Source B, or Source C, or by the researcher's name. You do not need
outside research, but everything you say a source reports must be accurate.
A. Propose a specific and defensible claim based in psychological science
that responds to the question.
B(i). Support your claim using at least one piece of specific and relevant
evidence from one of the sources.
B(ii). Explain how the evidence from Part B(i) supports your claim using a
psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding learned in AP Psychology.
C(i). Provide additional support for your claim using at least one
additional piece of specific and relevant evidence from a different source than the
one used in Part B(i).
C(ii). Explain how the evidence from Part C(i) supports your claim using a
different psychological perspective, theory, concept, or research finding than the
one used in Part B(ii).
Source A
Source A: research summary written for this course, based on Baumeister and colleagues (1998).
Undergraduate participants were asked to skip a meal before the session so that they would
arrive hungry. Each was seated at a table holding freshly baked chocolate-chip cookies and a
bowl of radishes. Random assignment determined the condition: one group was told to eat only
the radishes and to leave the cookies alone, a second group was permitted the cookies, and a
third was brought to a table with no food on it. The experimenter then left the room, so
resisting the cookies had to be done unobserved. Everyone next worked on a set of geometric
tracing puzzles that had in fact been constructed so that they could not be solved, and the
measure was how many minutes the participant kept working before giving up. Those who had
been made to resist the cookies quit after roughly 8 minutes on average, while those who had
been allowed the cookies kept working for about 19 minutes and those who had seen no food for
about as long. The study was an experiment with random assignment, and persistence time on the
unsolvable task served as the operational definition of self-control still available. The
sample was a few dozen students, so the group difference, though large, rested on a small
number of people. The researchers proposed that acts of self-control draw on one limited
resource, a state later named ego depletion.
Source B
Source B: research summary written for this course, based on Hagger and colleagues (2016).
Nearly twenty years after the original report, a coordinated project set out to test the
depletion effect with one procedure agreed in advance. Twenty-three laboratories in several
countries ran the identical protocol, and the hypothesis and analysis plan were registered
publicly before any data were collected, so that no laboratory could select an analysis after
seeing its results. More than 2,000 participants in total were randomly assigned either to a
letter-crossing task governed by a demanding rule, designed to require self-control, or to a
version of the same task with no such rule; everyone then completed a second task on which
self-control could be measured. Pooled across all the laboratories, the difference between the
depleting and non-depleting conditions was about d = 0.04: an effect small enough to be
indistinguishable from no effect at all. Individual laboratories varied, some reporting small
differences in one direction and some in the other, the pattern expected from chance variation
around zero. The report also observed that published studies of depletion had nearly all
reported positive results, and that when journals accept positive findings more readily than
null ones, a research literature can appear far stronger than the evidence behind it. The
design was a set of direct replications rather than a new experiment, and whether the agreed
procedure was the fairest test of the original idea remains disputed.
Source C
Source C: research summary written for this course, based on Mischel and colleagues, with the replication by Watts, Duncan & Quan (2018).
In the original work, a preschool child was seated alone at a table with a single treat (a
marshmallow, a cookie, or a pretzel), and told that the experimenter was leaving for a while.
If the child waited until the experimenter came back, she would receive two treats; if she did
not want to wait, she could ring a bell at any time and eat the one in front of her. The
measure was how many minutes the child waited. Waiting times varied a great deal. Follow-ups
years later, of a few dozen children who had all attended one university's nursery school,
reported that children who had waited longer tended to be rated as more competent adolescents
and to score higher on college-entrance tests. A later study repeated the delay task with more
than 900 children from a much broader and more socioeconomically varied sample and followed
them to about age 15. The association between waiting time and later achievement was present
but roughly half the size reported earlier, and it shrank further, in some analyses to near
zero, once family background, mother's education, and early cognitive ability were
statistically controlled. At the follow-up stage both are correlational: waiting time was
measured rather than assigned, so the link to later outcomes cannot show that waiting caused
them.
Your response
What a reader looks for on this prompt
A: A claim that takes a side on whether self-control behaves like a resource
that is spent: for example, that the depletion account has not survived rigorous retesting and
self-control is better explained by situation and learning history. A response arguing the other
way can also earn every point, as long as it handles Source B honestly. "Self-control is
important" or a restatement of the question is not defensible.
B(i): One particular finding, with the source named: the near-zero pooled
effect of about d = 0.04 across 23 laboratories and more than 2,000 participants in Source B,
the roughly 8 versus 19 minutes of persistence in Source A, or the halved association in Source
C. "Source B failed to replicate" without a figure or a described result is thin.
B(ii): A named concept, correctly applied: effect size, direct replication,
preregistration, publication bias and the file drawer, or the ego-depletion strength model
itself. Translating d = 0.04 into what it means about two distributions is the move that earns
the second point.
C(i): A second specific finding from a different source than B(i).
Two figures out of the same summary cannot earn this point.
C(ii): A concept from a different family than B(ii). If B(ii) argued from
methodology, C(ii) needs a substantive psychological account: operant conditioning and
reinforcement history, delay of gratification, executive function, or the person-situation
controversy. Using "replication" for one part and "effect size" for the other is the same
concept twice and caps this row at 1 point.
Show a 7/7 response
A Self-control is not well described as a single limited resource that
gets used up. The better-tested evidence points to self-control as behavior that depends on the
situation and on what a person's environment has taught them to expect about waiting. Source A
is the reason the resource idea took hold, and it is a real
experiment, but a claim about human nature has to rest on what replicates rather than on what
was found first.
B(i) Source B reports that 23 laboratories ran one agreed,
preregistered procedure with more than 2,000 participants and found the difference between the
depleting and non-depleting conditions to be about d = 0.04, with individual laboratories
scattered in both directions. B(ii) This supports my claim through the
research-methods concepts of effect size and direct replication. An effect size of 0.04 means
the two groups' means sit about four-hundredths of a standard deviation apart, so the
distributions lie almost on top of each other and there is nothing a real person would notice.
Sample size makes that estimate trustworthy: with more than 2,000 participants it is precise, so
an effect anywhere near the size of the gap in Source A would have been hard to miss.
Laboratories landing on both sides of zero is what chance variation around no effect looks like.
Because the analysis plan was registered in advance, no one could keep testing until something
worked. Publication bias explains the
gap between the two sources: journals print positive results far more readily than null ones, so
a literature built from small studies can look overwhelming while the real effect is near
zero.
C(i) Source C reports that when the delay-of-gratification task was
repeated with more than 900 children from a far more socioeconomically varied sample, the
association between waiting time and later achievement was about half the size found in the
original follow-ups, and shrank further, in some analyses to near zero, once family
background, mother's education, and early cognitive ability were controlled.
C(ii) This supports my claim through a different kind of explanation:
the behavioral perspective, and specifically reinforcement history. Waiting for the second treat
is operant behavior, and it only pays if the promise is reliable. A child whose household has
consistently delivered what it promised has been reinforced for waiting; a child whose
environment makes promises uncertain is behaving sensibly by taking the sure thing now. That is
why controlling for family background absorbs most of the association: waiting time measures the
child's learning history and circumstances as much as anything stored inside the child. The
person-situation controversy makes the same point from the trait side:
traits predict behavior averaged over many occasions, not one act, and a single afternoon with a
single marshmallow is one act. If the score largely indexes the situation, the inner fuel tank
explains very little, and the way to improve self-control is to change what the situation
rewards rather than ration a supply.
Where the points are earned
A: Defensible claim (1): The response takes a position the sources can
be used to defend and that someone could argue against: self-control is not a limited
resource that is spent, but behavior shaped by situation and learning history. It answers
the question asked, and it stays defensible by conceding that Source A is a real experiment
rather than pretending the opposing evidence does not exist.
B(i): Evidence from a source (1): A specific, accurate finding with the
source cited: the pooled effect of about d = 0.04 from 23 laboratories and more than 2,000
participants in Source B, together with the scatter of individual laboratories in both
directions.
B(ii): Explanation with a concept (2): Effect size and direct
replication are named and applied correctly. The response translates d = 0.04 into
overlapping distributions, explains why a large sample makes the near-zero estimate precise
enough to rule out an effect the size of Source A's, and adds preregistration and
publication bias to explain why the published record looked stronger than the evidence. That
is a mechanism connecting the evidence to the claim, not a restatement of it.
C(i): Evidence from a different source (1): The second piece of evidence
comes from Source C rather than Source B: the association between waiting time and later
achievement was about half the size in a sample of more than 900 children and fell further,
in some analyses to near zero, once family background and early cognitive ability were
controlled. The evidence therefore spans two sources.
C(ii): Explanation with a different concept (2): The behavioral
perspective, waiting as operant behavior under the control of reinforcement history and the
reliability of the promised reward, is a genuinely different family of explanation from the
methodological concepts used in B(ii), and it is applied to the specific result that the
association shrinks when background is controlled. The person-situation controversy is then
used correctly: traits predict aggregated behavior, not one act on one afternoon. Together
they explain why the delay score reflects the child's circumstances rather than a fixed
internal store, which is exactly the claim.
Unit recap
Unit recap
0:00 / 0:00
Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to
have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play
counts as your one free video.
Free preview complete
That's the end of the free preview.
You've opened five lessons, which is
as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've
already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go
back to it.