AP European History · History & Social Science

AP European History

Europe from c. 1450 to the present, argued from the documents themselves, not just memorized dates. Every unit is taught through the sources historians actually use, every unit ends with a stimulus-based review, and the essay sections let you write DBQs and LEQs against the real College Board rubrics with a top-score response to compare against.

3H 15M EXAM 55 MCQ 3 SAQ 1 DBQ 1 LEQ 79 LESSONS 108 REVIEW QUESTIONS 10 ESSAY PROMPTS NO PREREQ

Read the free lessons and the full lesson list for AP European History

Free exam guides for AP European History (8)

Course overview

What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.

AP European History follows the nine units of the College Board course framework, from the Renaissance to contemporary Europe, and every lesson follows one or two topics of the official course and exam description (79 lessons in all). Each lesson opens with a Required content box that quotes the learning objectives and key concepts it covers, then teaches them with a primary source and HIPP sourcing, worked source analyses, an Exam focus box, and six practice items. The units are weighted almost evenly, each worth 10 to 15 percent of the exam, so no period can be safely skipped. The DBQ is drawn from the period c. 1600 to c. 2001, and the three LEQ choices span roughly Units 1 to 3, 4 to 6, and 7 to 9. Every unit ends with a stimulus-based multiple-choice and short-answer review, and the two essay sections at the bottom of the outline hold five DBQ and five LEQ prompts with a writing space that scores against the official rubric.

  • U1Unit 1: Renaissance and Exploration, c. 1450–c. 164810–15%
  • U2Unit 2: Age of Reformation, c. 1450–c. 164810–15%
  • U3Unit 3: Absolutism and Constitutionalism, c. 1648–c. 181510–15%
  • U4Unit 4: Scientific, Philosophical, and Political Developments, c. 1648–c. 181510–15%
  • U5Unit 5: Conflict, Crisis, and Reaction in the Late 18th Century, c. 1648–c. 181510–15%
  • U6Unit 6: Industrialization and Its Effects, c. 1815–c. 191410–15%
  • U7Unit 7: 19th-Century Perspectives and Political Developments, c. 1815–c. 191410–15%
  • U8Unit 8: 20th-Century Global Conflicts, c. 1914–present10–15%
  • U9Unit 9: Cold War and Contemporary Europe, c. 1914–present10–15%

All nine units are open, 79 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a twelve-problem mixed review.

Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set, is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.

Lesson 1.1 · Unit 1 · CED topics 1.1 and 1.2

Renaissance humanism and the Italian city-states

Between about 1450 and 1648 Europe was remade by a rebirth of learning, a rush overseas, a religious split, and the rise of stronger states. Before any of that makes sense you need the context, the conditions that made change possible. Learning Objective A asks you to explain that context, and Learning Objectives B and C ask how the revival of classical texts produced the Italian Renaissance and what its political, intellectual, and cultural effects were. This lesson does both jobs: it sets the stage, then explains why the first great cultural change began in Italy.

Required content · 1A, 1C, 1B

Learning objectives.

  • 1A. Explain the context in which the Renaissance and Age of Discovery developed.
  • 1C. Explain the political, intellectual, and cultural effects of the Italian Renaissance.
  • 1B. Explain how the revival of classical texts contributed to the development of the Renaissance in Italy.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.I.B. Humanist revival of Greek and Roman texts, spread by the printing press, challenged the institutional power of universities and the Catholic Church. This shifted education away from a primary focus on theological writings toward classical texts and new methods of scientific inquiry.
  • 1.1.I.C. Admiration for Greek and Roman political institutions supported a revival of civic humanist culture in the Italian city-states and produced secular models for individual and political behavior.
  • 1.1.I.A. Italian Renaissance humanists, including Petrarch, promoted a revival in classical literature and created new philological approaches to ancient texts. Some Renaissance humanists furthered the values of secularism and individualism.
  • 1.1.III.A. In the Italian Renaissance, rulers and popes concerned with enhancing their prestige commissioned paintings and architectural works based on classical styles, the developing “naturalism” in the artistic world, and often the newly invented technique of geometric perspective.

The context: a shaken medieval world

Contextualization means describing the conditions before, during, or after an event that help explain it. For the Renaissance, four conditions matter.

  • Catastrophe and doubt. The Black Death (1347 to 1351) killed perhaps a third of Europe's people, weakened the old labor system, and shook confidence in the church's answers. The Hundred Years' War (1337 to 1453) and the Great Schism of the papacy (1378 to 1417, when rival popes claimed authority) damaged the prestige of both kings and church.
  • Wealthy cities. Trade with the eastern Mediterranean made Italian cities, especially Florence, Venice, and Milan, rich. They were independent city-states, not parts of a large kingdom, so wealthy merchants and bankers competed to rule and to be admired.
  • A recovered past. Italians lived among Roman ruins and inherited Latin manuscripts. After the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople in 1453, Greek scholars and Greek books also reached Italy.
  • Political fragmentation. Italy had no single ruler. Rival states used diplomacy, mercenary armies, and propaganda, which made it a laboratory for ideas about how power really works.

Humanism and the revival of classical texts

Humanism was a program of education built on the study of Greek and Roman literature, history, and moral philosophy. Humanists wanted to recover the original ancient texts and to learn from them how to live well in the present.

  • Petrarch (1304 to 1374), often called the father of humanism, hunted for lost Latin manuscripts and urged readers to imitate the style and moral seriousness of Cicero. He criticized the medieval centuries as a dark age between a glorious past and a hoped-for revival.
  • Philology, the careful study of the language and history of texts, became a weapon. In 1440 Lorenzo Valla showed from its Latin that the Donation of Constantine, the document the papacy used to claim authority over western Europe, could not have been written in the fourth century.
  • Civic humanism. In Florence, writers such as Leonardo Bruni admired the Roman Republic and argued that an educated citizen should take part in public life. Admiration for Greek and Roman political institutions produced secular models of individual and political behavior.
  • Platonism. Marsilio Ficino translated Plato and led a circle of scholars in Florence, and Pico della Mirandola wrote about human dignity and the human power to shape oneself.

Humanism changed education. Schools and universities that had focused on theology began to add grammar, rhetoric, poetry, history, and moral philosophy drawn from classical texts. Some humanists stressed secularism, a concern with this world, and individualism, the value of personal achievement. Most remained Christians, so the Renaissance was a change of emphasis, not a rejection of religion.

Patronage and the new art

Rulers, popes, and wealthy families spent money on art to display their prestige. The Medici family, bankers who dominated Florence from 1434, commissioned buildings, paintings, and sculpture and protected scholars. Popes, notably Julius II, hired Michelangelo and Raphael to decorate Rome.

Artists drew on classical styles and on closer study of the natural world.

  • Linear perspective, a geometric method of drawing depth on a flat surface, was developed by Brunelleschi and described by Alberti around 1435. Painters could now create convincing space.
  • Naturalism meant careful observation of anatomy and nature, visible in Donatello's sculpture and in the work of Leonardo da Vinci.
  • Classical forms returned in architecture, for example Brunelleschi's dome in Florence and later the buildings of Palladio, with columns, arches, and balanced proportions.

Raphael's School of Athens (about 1510) shows ancient philosophers in a classical hall, a picture of the humanist ideal.

1347-51 Black Death kills about a third of Europe 1434 Medici begin to rule Florence c. 1450 Gutenberg's movable-type press 1453 Constantinople falls to the Ottomans 1508-12 Michelangelo paints the Sistine ceiling 1513 Machiavelli writes The Prince 1516 Erasmus's Greek New Testament; More's Utopia 1528 Castiglione's The Courtier
Figure 1.1. Renaissance milestones. Crisis and wealth in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries set the stage, printing spread the movement, and humanist works appeared in both Italy and the north.

Machiavelli and the secular state

Political fragmentation shaped political thought. Niccolò Machiavelli, a Florentine diplomat, wrote The Prince (1513, published 1532) to analyze how rulers actually gain and keep power, not how they ought to in an ideal Christian world. Baldassare Castiglione's Book of the Courtier (1528), by contrast, described the ideal courtly gentleman. Both works belong to a secular literature of individual and political behavior.

Primary source · A realist theory of rule

Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince, chapter 17 (written 1513; early twentieth-century English translation), on whether a ruler should be loved or feared, excerpt.

...it is much safer to be feared than loved...

Sourcing (HIPP). Machiavelli was an out-of-office Florentine official writing after the Medici returned to power in 1512, and he dedicated the book to a Medici. His historical situation was a divided Italy repeatedly invaded by French and Spanish armies. His purpose was partly to give practical advice and partly to show his own political skill. His audience was a ruler and the educated court. The source reflects the humanist habit of drawing political lessons from experience and ancient examples, and its detachment from religious morality is exactly what shocked many readers.

Source analysis · What the passage assumes

Claim. Machiavelli claims that a ruler who must choose between being loved and being feared should choose fear.

Evidence. The passage says it is "much safer to be feared than loved."

Reasoning. The claim treats politics as a matter of security and results, not of Christian virtue. It fits the Italian city-state context, where rulers faced rivals, plots, and invasions, and it shows the secular turn in humanist thought. A limit on the evidence is that Machiavelli is writing advice to a prince, so it does not describe how most rulers or citizens actually behaved.

Worked example · Contextualization

Question. Describe one historical context that helps explain why the Renaissance began in Italy.

Model. One context was the wealth and political competition of the Italian city-states. Trade with the eastern Mediterranean made cities such as Florence rich, and because Italy had no single ruler, bankers like the Medici and popes competed for prestige by commissioning art and supporting scholars. This patronage created a market for the humanist scholars and artists who revived classical models.

Exam focus

Contextualization is more than a date or a one-word label. Give a condition (wealthy independent cities, the recovery of classical texts, crisis after the plague) and explain how it linked to the development in question. For Learning Objectives B and C, tie humanism to its consequences in education, politics, and art. A common error is to say the Renaissance was "anti-religious." Most humanists were devout, and the CED's own wording is that some furthered secularism and individualism.

Practice
  1. Define humanism and name one humanist.
    Show answer

    Humanism was an educational and cultural movement based on reviving Greek and Roman texts and applying their lessons to human life. Examples include Petrarch, Valla, Bruni, Ficino, and Pico della Mirandola.

  2. Explain how Italy's political fragmentation helped the Renaissance.
    Show answer

    Rival city-states and ruling families competed for prestige, and they paid for art and scholarship. Fragmentation also encouraged practical thinking about power, as in Machiavelli's writing.

  3. How did Lorenzo Valla's work challenge the church?
    Show answer

    He used the study of Latin to show that the Donation of Constantine was a later forgery, undermining a document the papacy used to claim authority.

  4. Identify two features of Renaissance art that came from classical models or close study of nature.
    Show answer

    Linear perspective and naturalism, along with classical architectural forms such as columns, arches, and domes.

  5. What was civic humanism?
    Show answer

    The admiration for Greek and Roman republican institutions that led humanists, especially in Florence, to argue that educated citizens should take part in public life.

  6. Why is The Prince a useful source for historians of the Italian city-states, and what is one limit on it?
    Show answer

    It shows how thinkers analyzed power in a divided, war-torn Italy and drew secular lessons from experience. A limit is that it is advice written for a ruler (and to win favor from the Medici), not a description of how typical rulers behaved.

Lesson 1.2 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.3

The Northern Renaissance and Christian humanism

When Renaissance ideas crossed the Alps in the late fifteenth and sixteenth centuries they did not arrive unchanged. Learning Objective D asks how Renaissance ideas were developed, maintained, and changed as they spread to northern Europe. Northern scholars kept the Italian love of classical texts, but they pointed it at a different target: the reform of Christian life. Northern artists, working in a commercial and more strongly religious culture, also developed their own kind of naturalism.

Required content · 1D

Learning objective.

  • 1D. Explain how Renaissance ideas were developed, maintained, and changed as the Renaissance spread to northern Europe.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.III.B. The Northern Renaissance retained a more religious focus, which resulted in more human-centered naturalism that considered individuals and everyday life appropriate objects of artistic representation.
  • 1.2.I.A. Christian humanism, embodied in the writings of Erasmus, employed Renaissance learning in the service of religious reform.

Why the north was different

Italy's humanists often served courts and city governments and stressed civic life, secular models of behavior, and classical Latin style. In England, France, Germany, and the Low Countries, humanists more often worked in universities, churches, and royal households, and the church was a bigger part of daily life. The Northern Renaissance therefore kept a more religious focus. Humanist learning became a tool for returning to the original sources of Christianity: the Bible and the early church fathers.

Christian humanism

Christian humanism used the methods of Renaissance scholarship (philology, comparing manuscripts, close reading of original languages) to renew religion.

  • Desiderius Erasmus (about 1466 to 1536), the greatest northern humanist, published a Greek edition of the New Testament in 1516 with a new Latin translation. Readers could now compare the church's Latin Vulgate with the Greek original. His Handbook of the Christian Soldier and The Praise of Folly (1511) urged an inward, practical piety, which he called the "philosophy of Christ," and mocked corrupt clergy, empty ceremonies, and scholastic quarrels.
  • Thomas More, an English lawyer and statesman, wrote Utopia (1516), a fictional island society that used its imaginary perfection to criticize greed, inequality, and war in Europe.
  • Reform from inside. Christian humanists wanted a better-educated clergy, more Bible reading, and moral reform. Most of them did not wish to break with Rome. Erasmus hoped the church could be reformed without a split, which is one reason his ideas are linked to the Reformation but also separated from it. He later disagreed sharply with Martin Luther.

The contribution to the coming Reformation was real, though. Printed Bibles and critical editions encouraged readers to judge church practice against scripture, and Erasmus's biting criticism of abuses made them widely discussed.

Northern art and everyday life

Northern artists admired the Italian mastery of perspective but worked from a different tradition of detailed observation, often in oil paint on panel or canvas.

  • Jan van Eyck (early fifteenth century) painted portraits and domestic interiors with minute detail.
  • Albrecht Dürer of Nuremberg visited Italy, studied perspective and proportion, and became a leading printmaker. Woodcuts and engravings spread images cheaply.
  • Pieter Bruegel the Elder painted peasants working, feasting, and playing in the sixteenth century.
  • In the seventeenth century, Dutch painters such as Rembrandt continued the tradition of portraits and scenes of ordinary life.

The result was a human-centered naturalism that treated individuals and everyday life as appropriate subjects for art, not only saints and rulers. Commercial city culture, with merchants and guilds as buyers, supported it.

Primary source · Satire of ceremony

Description of: Desiderius Erasmus, The Praise of Folly (1511), a satire narrated by the personification of Folly. The speaker mocks theologians who dispute subtle questions, monks who boast of ritual observance, and pardon-sellers who promise salvation for money, while praising the simple faith of ordinary Christians.

Sourcing (HIPP). Erasmus wrote in Latin for educated readers, many of them fellow humanists, and he dedicated the book to his friend Thomas More (the Latin title puns on More's name). The historical situation was a church with widespread complaints about clerical abuses, yet before Luther's protest of 1517. Erasmus's point of view was that of a devout priest-scholar who wanted reform inside the church. His purpose was to persuade readers to value inward faith over formal practice. Because it is a satire, the passage exaggerates, so it shows what critics believed more than it measures how common each abuse was.

Source analysis · Reform without a break

Claim. Erasmus uses satire to argue that church life had drifted from the simple Christianity of the Gospels.

Evidence. In the description of the work, Folly mocks theologians' subtle disputes, monks' pride in ritual, and the sale of pardons, while praising ordinary people's simple faith.

Reasoning. The targets are specific institutions and practices (scholastic theology, ritual, indulgences), not the Christian faith, which fits Christian humanism's aim of reform from within. Writing in Latin for an educated audience limits the source as evidence of popular opinion. Because it came before Luther, it also shows that criticism of the church existed before the Reformation began.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one way the Northern Renaissance continued Italian Renaissance ideas and one way it differed.

Model. The Northern Renaissance continued the Italian humanist method of recovering and studying original texts, as when Erasmus published a Greek New Testament. It differed in its focus: Italian humanists often stressed secular civic life and classical models of individual behavior, while northern humanists used the same scholarship mainly to reform Christian religion, a more religious aim.

Exam focus

Learning Objective D is a continuity and change question about an idea that moved. Name what stayed the same (the study of classical and original texts, the print and educated audience, naturalism in art) and what changed (a religious aim, a focus on Scripture, reform of the church from within). Do not treat Erasmus as a Protestant. He remained Catholic and criticized Luther. His importance for the Reformation is that he made criticism of the church widespread and gave readers a Greek New Testament.

Practice
  1. What is Christian humanism?
    Show answer

    The use of Renaissance humanist methods, such as the study of original texts, to reform Christian belief and practice.

  2. Name two works by northern humanists and what they criticized.
    Show answer

    Erasmus's Praise of Folly criticized clerical abuses and empty ceremony; More's Utopia criticized greed, inequality, and war in European society.

  3. How did Erasmus's 1516 Greek New Testament matter?
    Show answer

    It let readers compare the church's Latin Vulgate with the Greek original, encouraging them to judge church practice against the text of scripture.

  4. Identify one way northern art differed from Italian art.
    Show answer

    Northern artists often showed individuals and everyday life, such as peasants and domestic scenes, with close detail, expressing a more human-centered naturalism within a stronger religious culture.

  5. Why is it misleading to call Erasmus a Protestant?
    Show answer

    He wanted to reform the church from within, stayed Catholic, and disagreed with Luther, even though his criticism and his scholarship helped prepare the Reformation.

  6. A historian argues that the Northern Renaissance was more religious than the Italian Renaissance. Give one piece of evidence.
    Show answer

    Northern humanists such as Erasmus used classical scholarship to renew the Bible and Christian practice, rather than mainly to build secular models of public life.

Lesson 1.3 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.4

Printing and the spread of ideas

Few inventions changed European life as much as the printing press. Learning Objective E asks you to explain the influence of the printing press on cultural and intellectual developments in modern European history. The CED's central claim is that printing, introduced in the 1450s, helped spread the Renaissance beyond Italy and encouraged the growth of vernacular literature, which would eventually contribute to national cultures. This lesson explains how the technology worked, why it mattered, and where its effects were limited.

Required content · 1E

Learning objective.

  • 1E. Explain the influence of the printing press on cultural and intellectual developments in modern European history.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.II.A. The invention of the printing press in the 1450s helped spread the Renaissance beyond Italy and encouraged the growth of vernacular literature, which would eventually contribute to the development of national cultures.

What changed in the 1450s

Before printing, books were copied by hand, mostly by monks and professional scribes. A single Bible could take a year or more to copy, and every copy was slightly different. Books were rare and costly.

Around 1450 Johannes Gutenberg of Mainz combined several existing techniques into a working system: movable metal type cast in a mold, an oil-based ink, and a press adapted from wine and olive presses. The famous Gutenberg Bible appeared in the mid-1450s. The method spread quickly along trade routes to Italian cities, Paris, the Low Countries, and London, where William Caxton printed English books in the 1470s. By 1500 presses had produced millions of books, and printers worked in well over a hundred towns.

The key effects were economic. Printing cut the cost and time of making a text, so more people could own books, and every copy of an edition was identical. Standardized texts meant scholars in different cities could refer to the same page and compare their arguments.

Effects on the Renaissance

  • Spreading humanism. Printers published the classics, grammars, and works by humanists. Aldus Manutius in Venice printed compact editions of Greek and Latin authors. Ideas that had taken years to travel in manuscript now moved in months, so the Renaissance spread beyond Italy to the north.
  • A reading public. Printed pamphlets, almanacs, and books built a larger audience that was not limited to clergy and the nobility. Literacy was not universal, but reading aloud in taverns and households carried printed ideas to people who could not read.
  • Science and knowledge. Accurate printed diagrams, maps, and anatomical drawings allowed knowledge to accumulate. Copernicus and Vesalius both published in 1543, and later scientists used printed tables and treatises to build on one another's results.

Vernacular literature and national cultures

Learned books were generally printed in Latin. But printers also found a large market in the vernacular, the everyday languages. Printed Bibles, prayer books, poems, and chronicles in German, English, French, and Italian helped standardize spelling and grammar and created a shared written language over wide areas. Over time, a shared language and a shared body of literature supported a sense of national identity, which the CED says would eventually contribute to national cultures. Dante's Italian, Luther's German Bible (1522 to 1534), the French of Rabelais and Montaigne, and the English of Shakespeare and the King James Bible (1611) show the connection.

Printing and religion

Printing also gave Martin Luther's ideas a speed that earlier reformers lacked. Within weeks of its appearance in 1517, his criticism of indulgences circulated widely in printed form, and hundreds of thousands of pamphlets followed in the next years. Woodcut cartoons carried arguments to people who could not read. Reformers on all sides later used the press, so printing was a cause of the religious conflict covered in Unit 2.

Authorities responded with control. The church compiled the Index of Prohibited Books (first issued in 1559), and governments licensed printers, censored works, and burned books. These efforts show that rulers understood the press's power, but they never fully succeeded in stopping it.

Primary source · A printed argument

Description of: An early sixteenth-century German woodcut pamphlet attacking the sale of indulgences. A small panel at the top shows a preacher and a cross; the main image shows a friar at a chest taking coins, with a short rhyming caption in German beneath it.

Sourcing (HIPP). The pamphlet was printed in German, not Latin, and carried a woodcut, so its intended audience included people with little or no schooling. The historical situation was the indulgence controversy after 1517, when printers in Wittenberg, Nuremberg, and elsewhere quickly produced cheap tracts. Its point of view is critical of the church, and its purpose was to persuade, not to inform neutrally. As evidence it shows how reformers combined image and vernacular text, but one pamphlet cannot show how many people accepted its argument.

Source analysis · What the form shows

Claim. Reform arguments in the 1520s reached a wide audience because of the format of printed pamphlets.

Evidence. The pamphlet is in the vernacular, short and cheap, and combines a woodcut with rhymed text.

Reasoning. An image and short rhyme could reach readers with limited literacy and could be passed from person to person. That fits the CED's point about printing spreading ideas beyond the learned elite. A limit is that the surviving copy tells us what the author wanted to say, not what readers believed.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way the printing press affected cultural development in Europe between 1450 and 1648.

Model. The printing press encouraged vernacular literature. Printers found a market for Bibles and other books in German, English, and French, and widely distributed printed texts helped fix standard spelling and grammar. Over time, a shared written language and literature supported the growth of national cultures.

Exam focus

The CED's summary has two parts: printing spread the Renaissance and encouraged vernacular literature that eventually fed national cultures. Use the words eventually and contribute. Printing did not create nations by itself, and many people still could not read in 1500. A strong answer ties the technology (movable type, lower cost, identical copies) to a specific effect and avoids a one-line "printing spread ideas."

Practice
  1. Who developed movable-type printing in Europe, and when?
    Show answer

    Johannes Gutenberg of Mainz, in the 1450s.

  2. Name two ways printing differed from hand copying.
    Show answer

    It was cheaper and faster, and every copy of an edition was identical, so texts were standardized.

  3. How did printing help spread the Renaissance beyond Italy?
    Show answer

    It allowed humanist texts, classical editions, and grammars to be produced in large numbers and carried quickly to northern Europe.

  4. Explain how printing encouraged vernacular literature.
    Show answer

    Printers sold books in everyday languages to a growing reading public, which helped standardize those languages and build a written literature that later supported national cultures.

  5. How did authorities respond to the power of print?
    Show answer

    They censored and licensed printers, burned books, and the church issued the Index of Prohibited Books.

  6. Give one limit on the effect of printing before 1648.
    Show answer

    Literacy remained limited, especially among rural people and women, so many people reached printed ideas only through reading aloud, images, or sermons.

Lesson 1.4 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.5

The new monarchies and the rise of the state

After the chaos of the late Middle Ages, kings in several parts of Europe rebuilt royal power. Learning Objective F asks you to explain the causes and effects of the development of political institutions between 1450 and 1648. Historians call the stronger rulers of the late fifteenth and sixteenth centuries the new monarchies, because they laid the foundation of the centralized modern state. The state is the key word of this lesson: a government that claims a monopoly on taxation, armed force, justice, and, in this period, religion.

Required content · 1F

Learning objective.

  • 1F. Explain the causes and effects of the development of political institutions from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.2.II.A. Monarchs and princes, including the English rulers Henry VIII and Elizabeth I, initiated religious reform from the top down in an effort to exercise greater control over religious life and morality.
  • 1.5.I.A. New monarchies laid the foundation for the centralized modern state by establishing monopolies on tax collection, employing military force, dispensing justice, and gaining the right to determine the religion of their subjects.
  • 1.5.I.C. Across Europe, commercial and professional groups gained in power and played a greater role in political affairs.
  • 1.5.I.D. Continued political fragmentation in Renaissance Italy provided a background for the development of new concepts of the secular state.

Why monarchs gained strength

Several developments made stronger kings possible.

  • War and exhaustion. The Hundred Years' War (to 1453) and the Wars of the Roses in England (1455 to 1485) weakened the great nobles. Rulers who won, or who ended civil war, gained prestige.
  • Money. Growing trade and towns gave monarchs new taxes and loans. Rulers hired professional officials, often educated commoners or lawyers, who owed their positions to the crown.
  • Gunpowder. Cannon could break castle walls, and large armies needed money that only central governments could raise. The CED stresses that new monarchies used military force as part of their toolkit.
  • Allies. Merchants and professional groups supported strong kings who would keep the peace and protect trade. Commercial and professional groups gained power and played a greater role in political affairs.

What the new monarchies did

The CED lists four powers that rulers worked to monopolize: tax collection, military force, justice, and the right to determine the religion of their subjects.

  • France. Louis XI and his successors reduced noble independence, raised the royal tax (the taille), and kept a standing army. The Concordat of Bologna (1516) gave Francis I the right to name French bishops.
  • Spain. Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile married in 1469, ruled jointly, completed the conquest of Muslim Granada in 1492, and used the Spanish Inquisition (founded 1478) to enforce religious conformity. In 1492 they expelled Jews who would not convert, and later pressed Muslims to convert. They also took control of the military orders.
  • England. Henry VII ended the Wars of the Roses, built up royal finances, and used the royal Star Chamber court to restrain nobles. His son Henry VIII went further: the Act of Supremacy (1534) made the monarch head of the English church. Elizabeth I's religious settlement (1559) and the Book of Common Prayer kept the monarch in control of the church. The CED notes that rulers such as Henry VIII and Elizabeth I initiated religious reform from the top down to control religious life and morality.
  • The Holy Roman Empire. The Peace of Augsburg (1555) let each prince choose Lutheranism or Catholicism for his own territory, which strengthened local rulers, not the emperor. The CED's formula for the same trend is that states gained the right to determine the religion of their subjects.

Italy and the secular state

Italy shows an opposite pattern. The peninsula stayed politically fragmented into rival states. Ideas about sovereignty and politics were nonetheless central to the Renaissance. Machiavelli's The Prince, Guicciardini's histories, and later thinkers such as Jean Bodin (on sovereignty) and Hugo Grotius (on law between states) supplied new concepts of the secular state, a government justified by security and law, not religion. Fragmentation provided the background for those ideas.

Limits on royal power

Monarchs still faced obstacles. Nobles, towns, representative bodies, and local customs resisted. The Edict of Nantes (1598), which allowed French Protestants limited toleration, shows a ruler adjusting to division. In England, Parliament kept its power over taxation, which would matter greatly in the seventeenth century (see Unit 3).

Primary source · A king takes the church

Description of: The Act of Supremacy (1534), an English statute passed by Parliament. It declares that the king is "the only supreme head in earth of the Church of England" and gives the crown authority to correct church errors and abuses.

Sourcing (HIPP). The act is a law, so it shows how the state acted, not merely what individuals thought. The historical situation was Henry VIII's break with Rome after the pope refused to annul his marriage to Catherine of Aragon. The audience was English subjects and the church itself. The purpose was to make the monarch the legal head of the church. Because Parliament voted for it, the act also shows that kings often used representative bodies to strengthen their authority, not to limit it.

Source analysis · Religion and state power

Claim. The Act of Supremacy expanded royal control over religion in England.

Evidence. The statute names the king the supreme head of the Church of England with authority to correct abuses.

Reasoning. Taking church authority from the pope gave the crown control over church property, appointments, and doctrine, which fits the CED's point that monarchs sought the right to determine subjects' religion. The motive was both religious and political: Henry wanted a divorce and church wealth. The statute describes legal authority, not how fully the people accepted it.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause and one effect of the rise of the new monarchies.

Model. One cause was the growth of commerce and professional groups: merchants and lawyers supported strong rulers who kept order, and their taxes and loans funded armies and officials. One effect was that states gained monopolies on taxation, military force, and justice, laying the foundation for the centralized modern state.

Exam focus

For this learning objective give both causes and effects. Strong answers use the CED's four powers (tax collection, force, justice, religion) and name a concrete ruler or institution (Ferdinand and Isabella, the Spanish Inquisition, Henry VIII and the Act of Supremacy, the Concordat of Bologna, Star Chamber). Do not say monarchs became "absolute" in this period; absolutism is the subject of Unit 3. The new monarchies were a step on the way and met real limits.

Practice
  1. Name the four powers the new monarchies tried to monopolize.
    Show answer

    Tax collection, military force, justice, and the right to decide the religion of their subjects.

  2. Give one example of a state action to control religion.
    Show answer

    The Spanish Inquisition, the Concordat of Bologna, the Act of Supremacy, the Book of Common Prayer, or the Peace of Augsburg.

  3. How did gunpowder weapons favor stronger monarchs?
    Show answer

    Cannon could break castle walls and large armies were expensive, so only rulers who could tax and borrow effectively could use them, reducing the independence of nobles.

  4. Which groups gained power as monarchies grew, and why?
    Show answer

    Commercial and professional groups such as merchants and lawyers, because rulers needed their money and skills and gave them a greater political role.

  5. How did Italian fragmentation influence ideas about the state?
    Show answer

    Rival states in Italy encouraged analysis of power and sovereignty, producing secular models of politics by thinkers such as Machiavelli, Bodin, and Grotius.

  6. Identify a limit on the power of a new monarch.
    Show answer

    Nobles, towns, representative assemblies such as Parliament, and religious divisions all limited royal power; the Edict of Nantes shows a king accepting a compromise.

Lesson 1.5 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.6

Technology and the Age of Exploration

In 1450 Europeans knew little of the Atlantic beyond the coast of West Africa. Within a century they had sailed round Africa to India, crossed the Atlantic to a continent unknown to them, and circled the globe. Learning Objective G asks you to explain the technological factors that made European exploration possible, and Learning Objective H asks about the motivations and effects between 1450 and 1648. This lesson covers both.

Required content · 1G, 1H

Learning objectives.

  • 1G. Explain the technological factors that facilitated European exploration and expansion from 1450 to 1648.
  • 1H. Explain the motivations for and effects of European exploration and expansion from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.3.I.A. European states sought direct access to gold, spices, and luxury goods to enhance personal wealth and state power.
  • 1.3.I.B. The rise of mercantilism gave the state a new role in promoting commercial development and the acquisition of colonies overseas.
  • 1.3.I.C. Christianity was a stimulus for exploration as governments and religious authorities sought to spread the faith, and for some it served as a justification for the subjugation of indigenous civilizations.

Technology that made voyages possible

Exploration depended on a package of tools and ideas, many borrowed from other cultures.

  • Navigation. The compass (from China, by way of the Islamic world) kept ships on course; the astrolabe and quadrant measured the height of the sun and stars to find latitude; portolan charts mapped coastlines and harbors. Later maps and printed atlases spread the knowledge.
  • Ships. The Portuguese caravel was small, fast, and maneuverable. It combined the square sails of northern ships with the triangular lateen rig from the Mediterranean, which allowed sailing against the wind, and a sternpost rudder for steering. Larger carracks carried more cargo.
  • Weapons. Guns and gunpowder gave European ships the ability to bombard ports and to defeat much larger forces. Armed ships dominated the Indian Ocean trade by force.
  • Organization. The state or wealthy investors financed voyages. Prince Henry "the Navigator" of Portugal supported systematic exploration of the African coast in the fifteenth century.

Motives: gold, glory, and God

The CED identifies three motives, often mixed together.

  • Wealth. European states sought direct access to gold, spices, and luxury goods to enhance personal wealth and state power. The Ottoman conquest of Constantinople (1453) and Venetian and Muslim middlemen raised the price of Asian goods, so sailing round them promised large profits.
  • Mercantilism. The rise of mercantilism, the belief that a state's power depends on a favorable balance of trade and on gathering precious metals, gave the state a new role in promoting commerce and acquiring colonies overseas.
  • Religion. Christianity was a stimulus for exploration, as governments and religious authorities sought to spread the faith. For some, it served as a justification for the subjugation of indigenous civilizations. Missionaries, including Jesuits, followed the explorers.
1488 Dias rounds the Cape of Good Hope 1492 Columbus reaches the Caribbean 1494 Treaty of Tordesillas 1498 Da Gama reaches India 1519-22 Magellan's expedition circles the globe 1521 Cortés takes Tenochtitlan 1532-33 Pizarro conquers the Inca 1602 Dutch East India Company founded
Figure 1.2. From voyages to empire. Portuguese and Spanish voyages came first; the Dutch company shows the Atlantic powers following in the seventeenth century.

The voyages

Portugal led. Its ships worked down the African coast. In 1488 Bartolomeu Dias rounded the Cape of Good Hope. In 1498 Vasco da Gama reached Calicut in India, opening a sea route for spices. The Portuguese built a trading-post empire by force at Goa, Malacca, and elsewhere.

Spain looked west. In 1492 Christopher Columbus, an Italian sailing for Ferdinand and Isabella, crossed the Atlantic and reached the Caribbean, thinking he was near Asia. In 1494 the Treaty of Tordesillas, arbitrated by the pope, divided the non-European world between Spain and Portugal along a north-south line. Hernán Cortés (1519 to 1521) and Francisco Pizarro (1532 to 1533) conquered the Aztec and Inca empires with small forces, steel weapons, horses, allies, and epidemic disease. The expedition of Ferdinand Magellan (1519 to 1522) completed the first circumnavigation of the globe.

Effects

  • Colonies and silver. Spain gained gold and enormous amounts of silver, especially from Potosí in the Andes, and its government grew rich, though it also became dependent on imports of treasure.
  • Shifting economic power. Over time, trade and wealth moved from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic states (see the next lesson).
  • Subjugation of indigenous peoples. Conquest, forced labor, and disease killed millions in the Americas. Religious justification and a belief in European superiority supported conquest, though some Europeans, notably the Dominican friar Bartolomé de las Casas, publicly criticized the cruelty of Spanish rule.
  • State involvement. The CED notes the new role of the state: governments chartered companies, claimed territory, and built navies to protect trade.
Primary source · A letter from the Caribbean

Description of: Christopher Columbus, letter on the first voyage (1493), addressed to the Spanish court. Columbus reports islands rich in gold, fertile, and inhabited by gentle people who might easily be converted to Christianity, and he asks the monarchs for more support.

Sourcing (HIPP). Columbus wrote to the sovereigns who had financed him, so his purpose was to justify his voyage and to win more money and titles. His point of view was that of a European newcomer who misread what he saw, and he exaggerated the wealth of the islands. His audience was the Spanish court, and the letter was soon printed and circulated across Europe, which spread news of the discovery. As evidence it reveals European motives (gold, conversion), but it says little reliable about the Taino people it describes.

Source analysis · Motives in the letter

Claim. The letter links exploration to wealth and religion.

Evidence. It describes gold, fertile land, and people who might be converted, and it asks for more support.

Reasoning. Pairing wealth with conversion matches the CED's finding that governments and religious authorities sought both economic gain and the spread of Christianity. Because Columbus was pleading for funds, he likely exaggerated the wealth; the letter shows what he wanted the court to believe.

Worked example · Technology and motive

Question. Explain one technological factor and one motive for European exploration between 1450 and 1648.

Model. One technological factor was the caravel with its lateen sail, which let ships sail against the wind and travel long distances along unknown coasts. One motive was the search for direct access to gold, spices, and luxury goods: European states and merchants wanted to bypass middlemen who raised the price of Asian goods, and monarchs wanted the wealth to strengthen the state.

Exam focus

Learning Objective G asks about technology and Learning Objective H about motives and effects. Keep them separate in your answer. For technology, name a specific tool and what it allowed (lateen sail and sailing against the wind, astrolabe and finding latitude, guns and naval power). For motives, remember that the CED stresses state power and mercantilism along with religion. Avoid the claim that Columbus proved the earth was round; educated Europeans already knew it.

Practice
  1. Name two technologies that helped European explorers navigate.
    Show answer

    The compass and the astrolabe or quadrant (also portolan charts and the sternpost rudder).

  2. Why was the caravel important?
    Show answer

    Its lateen sails let it sail against the wind and it was fast and maneuverable, suited to long voyages along unknown coasts.

  3. List three motives for European exploration.
    Show answer

    Direct access to gold, spices, and luxury goods; state power through mercantilism; and the spread of Christianity.

  4. What did the Treaty of Tordesillas do?
    Show answer

    It divided newly claimed lands outside Europe between Spain and Portugal along a line agreed in 1494.

  5. Why did conquistadors with small forces defeat large empires?
    Show answer

    Steel weapons and horses helped, but allies among rivals of the Aztecs and Incas, and epidemic disease that killed large numbers, were also decisive.

  6. What is mercantilism, and how did it affect exploration?
    Show answer

    It is the idea that a state's strength depends on wealth, especially precious metals and a favorable balance of trade. It encouraged governments to promote trade and to acquire colonies overseas.

Lesson 1.6 · Unit 1 · CED topics 1.7 and 1.8

Rival empires and the Columbian Exchange

Once Spain and Portugal showed what overseas trade could bring, other states followed, and Europe's competition moved onto the oceans. Learning Objective I asks how and why trading networks and colonial expansion affected relations between and among European states. Learning Objectives J and K ask about the economic and the social and cultural impact of colonial expansion and of the trade networks it created. This lesson follows empire from Iberian dominance to Atlantic rivalry, then examines the exchange of living things that changed both hemispheres.

Required content · 1I, 1J, 1K

Learning objectives.

  • 1I. Explain how and why trading networks and colonial expansion affected relations between and among European states.
  • 1J. Explain the economic impact of European colonial expansion and development of trade networks.
  • 1K. Explain the social and cultural impact of European colonial expansion and development of trade networks.

Historical developments.

  • 1.3.III.B. The Spanish established colonies across the Americas, the Caribbean, and the Pacific, which made Spain a dominant state in Europe in the 16th century.
  • 1.3.III.C. The Atlantic nations of France, England, and the Netherlands followed by establishing their own colonies and trading networks to compete with Portuguese and Spanish dominance in the 17th century.
  • 1.3.III.D. The competition for trade led to conflicts and rivalries among European powers in the 17th and 18th centuries.
  • 1.3.III.A. The Portuguese established a commercial network along the African coast, in South and East Asia, and in South America in the late 15th and throughout the 16th centuries.
  • 1.3.IV.A. The exchange of goods shifted the center of economic power in Europe from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic states and brought the latter into an expanding world economy.
  • 1.3.IV.B.i. The exchange of new plants, animals, and diseases, the Columbian Exchange, created economic opportunities for Europeans.
  • 1.3.IV.B.ii. The exchange of new plants, animals, and diseases, the Columbian Exchange, in some cases facilitated European subjugation and destruction of indigenous peoples, particularly in the Americas.

From Iberian dominance to Atlantic rivals

  • Portugal built a commercial network along the African coast, in South and East Asia, and in Brazil during the late fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It used fortified trading posts, such as Goa and Malacca, rather than large territorial colonies in Asia.
  • Spain established colonies across the Americas, the Caribbean, and the Pacific (the Philippines). Silver from Mexico and Potosí made Spain the dominant state in sixteenth-century Europe, and from 1580 to 1640 the Spanish king also ruled Portugal and its empire.
  • The Dutch, English, and French. In the seventeenth century the Atlantic nations followed with their own colonies and trading networks to compete with Portuguese and Spanish dominance. The Dutch East India Company (1602) used armed ships to seize much of the Asian spice trade, and the Dutch also operated in the Atlantic. England planted colonies in North America and the Caribbean, and France in Canada and the Caribbean. These powers often used joint-stock companies, in which investors pooled money and shared profits and risks.

Competition for trade led to conflicts and rivalries among European powers in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Examples are the Anglo-Dutch wars, the War of the Spanish Succession (1701 to 1714), which ended with the British granting access to the asiento, the contract to supply enslaved Africans to Spanish America, and the Seven Years' War (1756 to 1763), fought in Europe, North America, the Caribbean, and India. Earlier, the Treaty of Tordesillas (1494) had tried to avoid such rivalry by dividing the world between two Catholic crowns, but the other powers did not accept the pope's division.

The Atlantic economy

The CED says that the exchange of goods shifted the center of economic power in Europe from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic states and brought them into an expanding world economy. Port cities such as Lisbon, Seville, Antwerp, Amsterdam, London, and Bristol grew rich handling sugar, tobacco, silver, textiles, and eventually enslaved people. Italian cities remained important but lost their edge.

Colonies also produced the price revolution: a flood of American silver contributed to rising prices across sixteenth-century Europe. Landowners who sold crops gained, while wage-earners saw living standards fall (see Lesson 1.8).

The Columbian Exchange

Historian Alfred Crosby coined the term Columbian Exchange for the movement of plants, animals, and diseases between the Americas and the rest of the world after 1492.

From Europe to the AmericasFrom the Americas to Europe
Wheat, sugar cane, grapesPotatoes, corn (maize), tomatoes
Horses, cattle, pigs, sheepSquash, beans, peppers, cacao
Smallpox, measles, influenzaTobacco, turkeys
  • Economic opportunities for Europeans. New foods, especially the potato and corn, helped feed growing populations; sugar and tobacco became profitable plantation crops; and animals such as cattle and horses spread across American grasslands.
  • Subjugation and destruction of indigenous peoples. In some cases the exchange facilitated European conquest. Epidemic diseases carried from Europe killed huge shares of the indigenous population in the Americas, in many regions on the order of most of the population within a century, which weakened resistance and created labor shortages that Europeans filled by coercion and, later, enslaved Africans.
Europe sends wheat, sugar cane horses, cattle, pigs sheep smallpox, measles firearms, tools The Americas send potatoes, corn tomatoes, beans cacao, peppers tobacco silver and gold plants, animals, disease food crops, tobacco, silver Africa: enslaved labor The Columbian Exchange
Figure 1.3. The Columbian Exchange. Plants, animals, and diseases crossed the Atlantic in both directions, while enslaved Africans were carried to the Americas to work plantations.
Primary source · Silver and prices

Description of: Jean Bodin, Response to the Paradoxes of Malestroit (1568), a French thinker's explanation of why prices in France had risen so sharply. Bodin argues that the main cause was the great abundance of gold and silver brought from the New World, along with other factors such as monopolies and royal spending.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bodin was a French lawyer and political thinker writing in the middle of the century of rising prices, so he was an informed contemporary, not a modern economist. His purpose was to correct another writer, Malestroit, who had blamed the coin's metal content. He was among the first to link the quantity of money to prices. As evidence it shows that contemporaries noticed the economic effects of overseas empire, but his claim is only one explanation, and modern historians also point to population growth.

Source analysis · A contemporary's explanation

Claim. Bodin attributes rising prices to the arrival of American silver and gold.

Evidence. In the described argument, he names abundant precious metals from the New World as the main cause of price increases.

Reasoning. The claim shows that colonial expansion affected European economies far from the colonies, which supports the CED's point that the exchange of goods integrated Europe into a wider economy. A limit is that other causes mattered too, so Bodin's single explanation is incomplete.

Worked example · Impact of the Columbian Exchange

Question. Explain one economic effect and one social effect of the Columbian Exchange.

Model. One economic effect was the creation of new economic opportunities for Europeans: American crops such as potatoes and corn increased the food supply, and plantations producing sugar and tobacco brought wealth to merchants and colonizers. One social effect was the destruction of indigenous societies in the Americas, because European diseases such as smallpox killed a large share of the population and made conquest and coerced labor easier.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives I, J, and K cover three different things: state rivalry, economic impact, and social and cultural impact. Match the evidence to the objective. The CED's own phrase for the economic shift is that economic power moved from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic. For rivalry, name the powers and a conflict (War of the Spanish Succession, Seven Years' War). For the exchange, show it went in both directions, and recognize that it helped Europeans while harming indigenous peoples.

Practice
  1. Which three Atlantic nations challenged Spanish and Portuguese dominance in the seventeenth century?
    Show answer

    France, England, and the Netherlands.

  2. What was a joint-stock company?
    Show answer

    A business owned by many investors who pooled money to finance overseas trade and shared the profits and risks, such as the Dutch East India Company.

  3. Name one conflict that grew out of commercial and colonial rivalry.
    Show answer

    The Anglo-Dutch wars, the War of the Spanish Succession, or the Seven Years' War.

  4. How did the Columbian Exchange help Europeans economically?
    Show answer

    New crops such as potatoes and corn increased the food supply, and sugar and tobacco plantations created profitable trade.

  5. How did European diseases affect the Americas?
    Show answer

    Epidemics of smallpox and measles killed a large share of the indigenous population, weakening resistance to conquest and leading to labor shortages.

  6. What was the price revolution, and how was it connected to the Americas?
    Show answer

    It was a long rise in prices across sixteenth-century Europe, partly caused by the large inflow of American silver that increased the supply of money.

Lesson 1.7 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.9

The Atlantic slave trade

The transatlantic slave trade was one of the largest forced migrations in history and a central part of European colonial expansion. Learning Objective L asks you to explain the causes for and the development of the slave trade. The CED's explanation is specific: Europeans expanded the trade of enslaved Africans in response to the establishment of a plantation economy in the Americas and demographic catastrophes among indigenous peoples. This lesson places the trade in that economic setting, describes how it worked, and examines how people at the time understood it.

Required content · 1L

Learning objective.

  • 1L. Explain the causes for and the development of the slave trade.

Historical developments.

  • 1.3.IV.C. Europeans expanded the trade of enslaved Africans in response to the establishment of a plantation economy in the Americas and demographic catastrophes among indigenous peoples.

Origins and causes

Slavery existed in many societies, including Africa, the Mediterranean, and the Islamic world. What changed after 1500 was the scale and the system.

  • Sugar and plantations. Europeans learned to grow sugar on Atlantic islands such as Madeira and the Canaries, and then in Brazil and the Caribbean. Sugar, and later tobacco, cotton, and rice, was grown on large estates called plantations that needed many workers for hard, year-round labor.
  • The labor shortage. European diseases and forced labor killed large numbers of indigenous people in the Americas. The Spanish encomienda system had forced native peoples to work, but that supply collapsed. Europeans did not wish to settle in tropical colonies as laborers, and indentured servants from Europe were never enough.
  • Existing slave trades. Portuguese traders had bought enslaved people on the African coast since the 1440s. The Europeans took advantage of existing African trading states, which sold captives, usually taken in war or raids, in exchange for goods such as cloth, metalware, firearms, and alcohol.
  • Racial ideas. Europeans increasingly justified slavery by claiming Africans were inferior. Over time, laws tied slavery to race and made it hereditary.

How the trade developed

The Portuguese were the first major carriers in the sixteenth century, sending captives to Brazil and to Spanish colonies under licenses called asientos. In the seventeenth century the Dutch, English, and French entered the trade and settled sugar islands such as Barbados and Saint-Domingue. The eighteenth century was the peak: British ships carried the largest share, and Liverpool, Bristol, Nantes, and Lisbon grew rich as slave-trading ports. All told, historians estimate that roughly twelve million Africans were embarked on ships across the Atlantic, and that many died on the way or soon after landing.

  • The Middle Passage. Captives were packed into ships for the ocean crossing, which lasted weeks or months. Disease, brutal conditions, suicide, and revolts killed a significant number on each voyage.
  • Planter society. In the Americas, planters held enormous power, and enslaved people were treated as property, forced to work under violence, and often separated from their families. Societies in the Caribbean and Brazil were majority-enslaved, and white elites feared revolt.

The trade tied together three continents in what is often drawn as a triangle: manufactured goods from Europe to Africa, enslaved people from Africa to the Americas, and sugar, tobacco, and other products from the Americas to Europe. In reality there were many routes, and the pattern was more complicated than a neat triangle.

Effects and resistance

For Europe, the trade enriched merchants, shipbuilders, banks, and port cities and supplied raw materials and consumer goods, such as sugar, that shaped European diets. For Africa, the loss of millions of people, the spread of warfare to capture captives, and the strengthening of some states that sold slaves had lasting effects. Enslaved people resisted in many ways, from daily sabotage to open revolt and the formation of communities of escaped people.

Primary source · An account of the voyage

Description of: The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano (1789), the autobiography of a man who said he was born in what is now Nigeria, was kidnapped as a child, endured the Middle Passage, and later purchased his freedom and became an abolitionist in Britain. In the passage on the voyage, Equiano describes the stench, the crowding, the sickness, and his terror on the ship.

Sourcing (HIPP). The narrative was written by a man who had experienced slavery, so the point of view is first-hand, and it is one of the rare accounts by an enslaved African. It was written and published in 1789 in Britain, in the abolition campaign, so its purpose was to persuade British readers to end the trade and the audience was a literate, mostly white readership. Historians have discussed whether Equiano described his early life from memory or drew on others' accounts, so the narrative is strongest as evidence of the experience of the passage and of abolitionist argument.

Source analysis · What the narrative can show

Claim. Equiano's account shows the human cost of the Middle Passage and was used to argue for abolition.

Evidence. In the described passage, he reports crowding, stench, and sickness aboard the ship, and his fear.

Reasoning. The detail supports the CED's point that the trade was a large and brutal system, and the 1789 publication date and British audience show how the account was used in the abolition movement. A limit is that it comes from one individual and was shaped for readers, so it cannot show how every voyage went.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause of the expansion of the Atlantic slave trade.

Model. One cause was the growth of plantation agriculture in the Americas. Sugar and tobacco estates needed large numbers of laborers, and the supply of indigenous workers had collapsed because of disease and forced labor. European planters and merchants turned to enslaved Africans, bought through African trading partners, to fill the demand.

Exam focus

The CED names two causes: the plantation economy and the demographic catastrophe among indigenous peoples. A top-level answer links them: disease destroyed one labor supply, plantations created demand for another. Remember the other direction too, that the trade shaped the European economy through ports, banks, and consumer goods. Avoid describing enslaved people as passive; resistance is part of the history, as are African participants in the trade.

Practice
  1. What crops drove the demand for enslaved labor in the Americas?
    Show answer

    Sugar above all, and also tobacco, rice, and later cotton, grown on large plantations.

  2. Explain how the decline of indigenous populations contributed to the slave trade.
    Show answer

    Disease and forced labor killed many indigenous workers, creating a labor shortage that European colonists filled by importing enslaved Africans.

  3. What was the Middle Passage?
    Show answer

    The Atlantic crossing that carried enslaved Africans to the Americas, marked by crowding, disease, and high death rates.

  4. Which European powers carried the largest share of the trade, and when did it peak?
    Show answer

    Portugal carried the most over the whole period, with Britain a leading carrier in the eighteenth century, when the trade reached its peak.

  5. Name one way enslaved people resisted.
    Show answer

    Revolt, escape and the formation of communities of escaped people, or everyday acts such as slowing work and sabotage.

  6. Why is Equiano's narrative useful, and what limit should a historian keep in mind?
    Show answer

    It is a rare first-hand account by someone who experienced the Middle Passage and shows how abolitionists used personal testimony. It reflects one person's story and was shaped for a British audience, so it does not represent every experience.

Lesson 1.8 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.10

The Commercial Revolution and social change

Between 1450 and 1648 the economy of Europe changed, but not as fast as its politics or religion. Learning Objectives M and N ask about commercial and agricultural developments and their economic and social effects. The key idea is that money and markets grew, new elites rose, and old hierarchies persisted, so this is a lesson in both continuity and change. Most Europeans were still peasants, farming the land.

Required content · 1M, 1N

Learning objectives.

  • 1M. Explain European commercial and agricultural developments and their economic effects from 1450 to 1648.
  • 1N. Explain European commercial and agricultural developments and their social effects from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.4.I.A. Innovations in banking and finance promoted the growth of urban financial centers and a money economy.
  • 1.4.II.A. Subsistence agriculture was the rule in most areas, with three-crop field rotation in the north and two-crop rotation in the Mediterranean; in many cases, farmers paid rent and labor services for their lands.
  • 1.4.II.B. The price revolution contributed to the accumulation of capital and the expansion of the market economy through the commercialization of agriculture, which benefited large landowners in western Europe.
  • 1.4.III.A. Population recovered to its pre-Great Plague level in the 16th century, and continuing population pressures contributed to uneven price increases; agricultural commodities increased more sharply than wages, reducing living standards for some.
  • 1.4.I.B. The growth of commerce produced a new economic elite, which related to traditional land-holding elites in different ways in Europe’s various geographic regions.
  • 1.4.II.C. As western Europe moved toward a free peasantry and commercial agriculture, serfdom was codified in the east, where nobles continued to dominate economic life on large estates.
  • 1.4.II.D. The attempts of landlords to increase their revenues by restricting or abolishing the traditional rights of peasants led to revolt.
  • 1.4.III.B. Migrants to the cities challenged the ability of merchant elites and craft guilds to govern, and strained resources.
  • 1.4.IV.C. From the late 16th century on, Europeans responded to economic and environmental challenges, such as the Little Ice Age, by delaying marriage and childbearing. This European marriage pattern restrained population growth and ultimately improved the economic condition of families.

Finance and the growth of commerce

The CED begins with the claim that innovations in banking and finance promoted the growth of urban financial centers and a money economy.

  • Banks and credit. Italian merchants developed bills of exchange, deposit banking, and double-entry bookkeeping, which recorded debts and profits accurately. The Medici bank was one of the largest in the fifteenth century. In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries financial leadership moved north to Antwerp and then Amsterdam, where the Bank of Amsterdam (1609) and a stock exchange supported trade.
  • Joint-stock companies. The Dutch East India Company (1602) and the English East India Company (1600) raised capital from many investors for risky overseas ventures.
  • Price revolution. From about 1500 to 1650 prices rose steadily, partly from the inflow of American silver and partly from population growth. Agricultural prices rose faster than wages, which reduced living standards for many workers while helping landowners and merchants.

Agriculture: east and west

Farming was the foundation of the economy. The CED notes that subsistence agriculture was the rule in most areas, with three-crop field rotation in the north and two-crop rotation in the Mediterranean, and that in many cases farmers paid rent and labor services for their lands.

But the paths of eastern and western Europe diverged.

  • In the west, peasants moved toward a free peasantry and commercialized agriculture: farming for markets, with landlords seeking profit. In England, landlords began enclosing open fields and common land to raise sheep or crops for market, which benefited large landowners and displaced some tenants.
  • In the east, nobles used their power to tie peasants to the land. Serfdom was codified in Prussia, Poland, and Russia as nobles built large estates to export grain to the booming western market.
  • Revolts. When landlords tried to increase their revenues by restricting or abolishing the traditional rights of peasants, peasants sometimes rebelled, as in the German Peasants' War of 1524 to 1525.

New elites and the city

Commerce created a new economic elite of merchants and bankers, such as the Fuggers of Augsburg and Italian merchant princes. They related to traditional land-holding elites in different ways in Europe's various regions. In France, wealthy bourgeois could buy offices and become nobles of the robe; in England, the gentry and merchants intermarried; in the Dutch Republic, merchant oligarchs ruled the cities.

Cities grew as migrants moved from the countryside. The CED states that migrants to the cities challenged the ability of merchant elites and craft guilds to govern and strained resources. Overcrowding caused sanitation problems, poverty, and crime, and city governments responded with poor relief and policing.

Population and family

Population recovered to its pre-plague level in the sixteenth century. Pressure on land and food contributed to uneven price increases. From the late sixteenth century, Europeans responded to economic and environmental challenges, including the Little Ice Age, a long period of cooler temperatures, by delaying marriage and childbearing. This European marriage pattern (late marriage, many people never marrying) restrained population growth and ultimately improved the economic condition of families.

Primary source · Enclosure and its critics

Description of: Thomas More, Utopia (1516), Book I, in which a character criticizes English landlords who turn farmland into sheep pastures. He says sheep, which are usually "so meek and tame," have become so greedy that they "eat up and swallow down the very men themselves," and he describes tenants evicted from farms and driven to beggary or theft.

Sourcing (HIPP). More was a lawyer and later royal councilor writing a literary work, so his criticism comes through a fictional speaker and a witty exaggeration. The historical situation was early enclosure in England, when wool exports were profitable. His purpose was to criticize greed and social injustice. The passage is good evidence of how educated contemporaries saw enclosure but overstates the speed and scale of the change, and it says little about landlords' reasons.

Source analysis · Reading a satire

Claim. More argues that commercial agriculture harmed the poor.

Evidence. The speaker says sheep "eat up and swallow down the very men themselves" and describes evicted tenants forced into begging or theft.

Reasoning. The image of sheep devouring people is a satirical way to describe the loss of farmland and livelihood to profitable wool production, which matches the CED's point about the commercialization of agriculture benefiting large landowners. A limit is that Utopia is fiction, so More's exaggeration shows opinion, not exact numbers.

Worked example · East and west

Question. Explain one way agriculture developed differently in eastern and western Europe between 1450 and 1648.

Model. In western Europe the trend was toward a free peasantry and commercial agriculture, as in England, where landlords enclosed fields for profit. In eastern Europe nobles instead consolidated large estates producing grain for export and tied peasants to the land through serfdom, which was codified. The difference was that in the west market forces reduced feudal obligations, while in the east the market strengthened them.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives M and N require you to connect economic change (banks, companies, prices, enclosure) to social effects (new elites, strained cities, serfdom in the east, revolts, the marriage pattern). Always say who gained and who lost. The best answers also keep continuity in mind: most people were farmers, hierarchies of class and rank endured, and the economy was slow to change. The east-west contrast is a frequent exam theme.

Practice
  1. Name two innovations in banking and finance in this period.
    Show answer

    Double-entry bookkeeping and joint-stock companies such as the Dutch East India Company, along with new banks like the Bank of Amsterdam.

  2. What was the price revolution, and who benefited from it?
    Show answer

    A long rise in prices from about 1500 to 1650; landowners and merchants who sold goods benefited while wage earners lost purchasing power.

  3. Explain the enclosure movement.
    Show answer

    Landlords in England fenced off open fields and common land to use for sheep or market crops, benefiting large landowners and displacing small tenants.

  4. How did serfdom differ in eastern and western Europe?
    Show answer

    In the west, serfdom declined as peasants became free and farming commercialized; in the east, nobles codified serfdom to run large estates producing grain for export.

  5. Why did migrants to cities strain urban government?
    Show answer

    They increased overcrowding, poverty, crime, and sanitation problems, challenging the ability of merchant elites and guilds to govern and provide resources.

  6. What was the European marriage pattern?
    Show answer

    A tendency toward later marriage and later childbearing, with many people never marrying, which restrained population growth and improved family economic conditions.

Lesson 1.9 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.11

Causation: why the Renaissance and exploration happened

The last topic of each unit practices a skill instead of adding new content. Here the skill is causation: explaining how and why events, developments, or processes happened and what their effects were. Learning Objective O asks you to explain the causes and consequences of the Renaissance and the Age of Discovery. This lesson shows you how to build a causal argument from the evidence of Unit 1.

Required content · 1O

Learning objective.

  • 1O. Explain the causes and consequences of the Renaissance and Age of Discovery.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

What causation means

A historian does not stop at "X led to Y." Strong causal reasoning asks four questions.

  • Which causes, and of what kind? Long-term causes build slowly (a growing economy, new ideas). Short-term causes trigger events (a conquest, a fall of a city). Causes can be economic, political, intellectual, religious, or technological.
  • How strong was each cause? Some are necessary conditions, without which the event could not happen. Others are only contributing factors.
  • What links cause to effect? The explanation needs a mechanism: what actually carried the effect from one thing to the next?
  • What are the effects, and how do they differ by time and group? Immediate effects differ from long-term ones, and winners differ from losers.

Applying it to Unit 1

The Renaissance. Long-term causes included the wealth of Italian city-states, the competition among rulers and families for prestige, the recovery of classical texts, and the crisis of the fourteenth century that weakened old certainties. The short-term trigger of the 1450s and after was printing, which was a technological cause that spread the movement. The consequences include a new emphasis on secular and individual values, changes in education, new forms of art, and, through Christian humanism and critical scholarship, pressure for church reform.

The Age of Discovery. The causes were economic (the search for gold, spices, and luxury goods and for direct access to Asian trade), political (rivalry among states and the new role of the state in promoting commerce), religious (the wish to spread Christianity), and technological (the caravel, the compass, astrolabe, and guns). The consequences include the creation of colonial empires, the Columbian Exchange, the destruction of indigenous societies, the rise of the Atlantic slave trade, and a shift of economic power from the Mediterranean to the Atlantic.

Causes Consequences Developments Wealthy city-states Classical texts Printing Search for gold and spice State rivalry Navigation technology Secular and individual values Pressure for church reform Overseas empires Columbian Exchange Atlantic slave trade Power shifts to Atlantic states The Renaissance The Age of Discovery printing spreads maps, knowledge
Figure 1.4. A causal web for Unit 1. Several kinds of cause (economic, intellectual, technological, political) feed two linked developments, which in turn produce political, religious, economic, and social consequences.

Connections between the two

The Renaissance and the Age of Discovery were related. Printing spread maps, travel accounts, and navigation manuals; humanist curiosity about the natural world supported science; and the same wealthy, competitive states financed both art and voyages. Overseas wealth, in turn, funded courts and patrons. Good causal arguments show such interactions, and not just two separate lists.

Primary source · A historian's argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument, as it might appear on an exam. The author contends that the voyages of discovery were driven less by curiosity than by the pressure of competition among European states and the search for profit, and that once Spain and Portugal showed that overseas empire could bring great wealth, other states felt forced to follow.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author is a modern historian writing with hindsight, so the point of view is analytical and later than the events. The purpose is to explain a cause, and the audience is students and scholars. A secondary source like this offers an argument rather than evidence from the time, so a strong response identifies the claim and then tests it against facts such as the Portuguese and Spanish voyages, the Dutch and English companies, and the role of mercantilism.

Source analysis · Claim and evidence

Claim. The historian claims competition among states and the search for profit drove exploration.

Evidence. The argument points to the pressure on other states to follow Spain and Portugal after they showed the profits of overseas empire. Facts that support it include the entry of the Dutch, English, and French with trading companies in the seventeenth century.

Reasoning. This supports the causal claim because rivals copied a successful model, which fits the CED's emphasis on state power and mercantilism. A limit is that it leaves out religion and technology, which also mattered, so the argument is best seen as one important cause among several.

Worked example · Causes and consequences

Question. Explain one cause and one consequence of the Age of Discovery.

Model. One cause was the search for direct access to gold and spices: Ottoman control of eastern routes and Italian middlemen made Asian goods expensive, so Portugal and Spain sponsored voyages that bypassed them. One consequence was the Columbian Exchange, in which crops, animals, and diseases crossed the Atlantic, enriching Europeans with new foods and profitable crops while epidemics devastated indigenous peoples.

Exam focus

On the exam, causation questions ask you to explain how or why, often for causes and for effects. Name a specific cause, state the link, and give evidence: "The wealth of Italian city-states led to patronage because rulers competed for prestige, as when the Medici commissioned art." Use the words because, led to, and as a result. Keep causes in categories (economic, political, religious, technological) so that you can show that several factors worked together, and rank them if asked which was most important.

Practice
  1. Distinguish a long-term cause from a short-term cause with an example from Unit 1.
    Show answer

    A long-term cause develops over time, such as the growing wealth of Italian cities; a short-term cause triggers an event, such as the arrival of printing, which sped the spread of Renaissance ideas.

  2. Give two causes of the Renaissance.
    Show answer

    The wealth and competition of Italian city-states and the revival of classical texts (also patronage, crisis in the fourteenth century, and printing).

  3. Give two causes of the Age of Discovery and name their type.
    Show answer

    Economic: the search for gold, spices, and luxury goods. Technological: the caravel, compass, and astrolabe. (Also political rivalry and religion.)

  4. Name one consequence of the Age of Discovery for Europe and one for indigenous Americans.
    Show answer

    For Europe, new wealth and a shift of economic power to Atlantic states; for indigenous Americans, epidemic disease, conquest, and forced labor.

  5. How did printing connect the Renaissance and the Age of Discovery?
    Show answer

    It spread humanist ideas, maps, and travel and navigation knowledge, which supported both cultural change and exploration.

  6. Why might a historian rank economic causes above religious ones in explaining exploration?
    Show answer

    State and merchant profits, mercantile competition, and the demand for gold and spices appear in nearly every voyage, while religion often accompanied or justified expansion but did not by itself finance it.

Unit 1 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 1 review: Renaissance and Exploration, c. 1450–c. 1648

Ten stimulus- and knowledge-based multiple-choice questions and two short-answer questions covering Italian and northern humanism, printing, the new monarchies, and the voyages that opened the Atlantic world: click an option to see why each answer is right or wrong, then write the SAQs on paper before opening the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince, written 1513.

    "It may be answered that one should wish to be both [loved and feared], but, because it is difficult to unite them in one person, it is much safer to be feared than loved, when, of the two, either must be dispensed with."

    The passage best reflects which development in Renaissance thought?

    Correct. Machiavelli judges the ruler by whether the strategy works, reasoning from Roman precedent rather than from Christian virtue: the humanist method applied to politics.

    Divine-right theory grounds obedience in God's will. Machiavelli grounds it in calculation about what keeps a prince secure, and never appeals to divine appointment here.

    Machiavelli did favor republics in his Discourses, but this passage is advice to a prince about holding power and says nothing about the best form of government.

    Appeals to scripture as the sole guide belong to the Reformation after 1517. This passage does the opposite, setting religious standards aside in favor of effectiveness.

  2. Description of: Erasmus, In Praise of Folly, 1511.

    A mock oration spoken by the goddess Folly, who praises herself while cataloging the absurdities of those who claim wisdom. Her longest passages mock theologians arguing over unanswerable technical questions and monks who count ceremonies as if piety were arithmetic.

    The work is best understood as an expression of which movement?

    Civic humanism concerned the citizen's duty to the state, as in Bruni's Florence. Erasmus's target here is clerical practice, not political participation.

    Correct. Erasmus used humanist scholarship and satire to attack abuses inside the church while remaining within it: the defining program of Christian humanism.

    Erasmus never broke with Rome and opposed Luther on free will. Writing six years before the Ninety-Five Theses, he criticized abuses without challenging papal authority itself.

    Scholastic theologians are precisely who Folly mocks. The passage attacks their method rather than exemplifying it.

  3. Which best explains why the printing press contributed to the spread of the Reformation after 1517?

    The church did use print, but it lost the pamphlet war badly in the 1520s. Reformers reached lay audiences in German while much Catholic output remained in Latin.

    Correct. Speed and dispersal were decisive: Luther's theses circulated in German within weeks, and no authority could seize copies in dozens of towns at once.

    Literacy rose but remained a minority accomplishment well past 1600. Pamphlets often worked by being read aloud to listeners who could not read them.

    Printing was a commercial trade operating across confessional lines, and Catholic polemic was printed throughout. Censorship was attempted by both sides, not monopolized.

  4. The policies of Ferdinand and Isabella in Spain after 1478 are best characterized as an attempt to

    Correct. Aragon and Castile kept separate laws and institutions, so a crown-run Inquisition from 1478 and the 1492 expulsion gave the monarchs a unifying instrument they otherwise lacked.

    Spain's representative bodies, the Cortes, were weakened rather than strengthened in this period, and no parliamentary check on the crown developed.

    Noble privilege and exemption from direct taxation survived in Spain into the eighteenth century. The new monarchies curbed noble violence, not noble wealth.

    The opposite occurred: the 1492 decree expelled Jews who would not convert, and Muslims faced forced conversion within a decade, at considerable economic cost.

  5. Source: Christopher Columbus, letter to Luis de Santángel, 1493.

    "I found very many islands filled with people innumerable, and of them all I have taken possession for their Highnesses, by proclamation made and with the royal standard unfurled, and no opposition was offered to me."

    A historian would most need to account for which feature of this source when using it as evidence?

    Columbus wrote on the return voyage in 1493, within months of the landfall. Distance in time is not the problem with this document.

    Correct. Santángel had helped arrange financing, and the letter was printed across Europe within months, so the populous, rich islands and the effortless possession serve a fundraising purpose.

    The letter was printed and widely distributed almost immediately, which is the opposite of private. Its public circulation is central to how it should be read.

    Columbus commanded the expedition and depended on royal favor for a second voyage, giving him a direct personal interest in how the first was reported.

  6. Description of: silver production and European price data, sixteenth century.

    Registered silver shipments from Spanish American mines rise steeply after the opening of Potosí in 1545. Across the same century, grain and other commodity prices in western Europe rise several-fold, while money rents fixed by long leases remain unchanged.

    The data best support which conclusion about sixteenth-century Europe?

    Correct. When prices rise and rents are fixed by long lease, the landlord's real income falls while those selling goods at rising prices gain: the core social effect of the price revolution.

    Wages lagged behind prices through the century, so real wages for laborers fell. The price revolution worsened rather than relieved poverty.

    Spanish silver largely paid for imports and wars, and Spain's manufacturing remained weak; much of the bullion ended up in the Netherlands, Italy, and Asia.

    The stimulus states that prices rose several-fold. Deflation is the opposite of what the data show.

  7. Which best explains why Portugal pioneered a sea route to Asia in the fifteenth century?

    Portugal was small and comparatively poor. Its advantage lay in focus and position on the Atlantic, not in scale of resources.

    Correct. Decades of crown-backed voyages down the African coast, plus the caravel, lateen sail, compass, and astrolabe, made Dias's 1488 rounding of the Cape and da Gama's 1498 arrival at Calicut possible.

    Tordesillas came in 1494, after the voyages had begun, and divided claims between Portugal and Castile rather than granting either a prior monopoly.

    Portugal sat on the Atlantic, not the Mediterranean. Its distance from the Italian-controlled eastern trade is precisely why it sought an alternative route.

  8. Humanist education differed most significantly from medieval scholastic education in its

    Humanists were overwhelmingly Christian and commissioned religious art. They added a classical vocabulary of virtue rather than replacing their faith.

    Correct. The studia humanitatis centered on grammar, rhetoric, poetry, history, and moral philosophy, against scholasticism's formal logic and Aristotelian metaphysics.

    Humanists prized classical Latin and Greek and often criticized medieval Latin as debased. Vernacular writing grew in this period but was not the humanist program.

    Systematic experiment belongs to the Scientific Revolution of the following century. Humanists worked on texts.

  9. Description of: a sixteenth-century woodcut of a printing workshop.

    A single room with two work stations: at the left a man inks a forme of set type with leather ink balls while another pulls the bar of a heavy screw press; at the right a compositor picks individual letters into a hand-held stick. Printed sheets hang overhead to dry.

    The image is most useful as evidence for which of the following?

    The image shows a workshop but says nothing about guild regulation, which in fact governed most urban trades throughout this period.

    Correct. The press, type, and specialized division of labor between compositor and pressman all indicate substantial investment and skilled staff, not a household activity.

    The press shown is hand-operated by screw and lever. Water and steam power in manufacturing belong to a much later period.

    The image depicts production, not readership, and rural literacy remained low. An image of a workshop cannot document who read the output.

  10. Description of: Bartolomé de las Casas, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies, written 1542.

    A Dominican friar who had held an encomienda before renouncing it addresses the future Philip II, describing province by province the killings, forced labor, and population collapse he attributes to Spanish conduct, and arguing that Indigenous peoples are rational subjects capable of Christianity.

    The document is strongest as evidence for which of the following?

    Las Casas's numbers are rhetorical rather than statistical, chosen to shock the crown into action. They are the weakest part of the document.

    Correct. Written as the New Laws were being debated and answered by Sepúlveda at Valladolid in 1550–1551, it shows the conquest being contested inside Spain at the time.

    The document is itself European criticism, so it disproves rather than supports this claim.

    Las Casas was a Spanish friar writing for a Spanish king. Indigenous perspectives reach us through other sources, not this one.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE difference between Italian humanism and northern Christian humanism in the period 1450–1550.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the printing press contributed to the difference you described in (a), or to the spread of either movement.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way humanist scholarship contributed to religious change in Europe in the period 1500–1600.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: Italian humanists applied classical learning mainly to secular subjects (rhetoric, history, politics, the duties of the citizen), while northern humanists such as Erasmus applied the same linguistic method to scripture and the church fathers to reform Christian practice. Do not accept: a purely geographic statement; "northern humanists were more religious" without specifying the scholarly method; or any claim that Italian humanists rejected Christianity.
    • (b) Accept: printing carried Italian texts and methods north cheaply and quickly; it made Erasmus's Greek New Testament available to scholars across Europe; it created a lay reading public that could be addressed in the vernacular. Must explain the mechanism, not merely name the press.
    • (c) Accept: Erasmus's Greek New Testament (1516) exposed discrepancies in the Latin Vulgate and gave reformers a textual basis for challenging official doctrine; humanist ad fontes method encouraged returning to scripture over tradition; humanist satire made clerical abuse a respectable public subject. Do not accept: naming Luther with no link to humanist scholarship.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Italian humanists such as Leonardo Bruni applied the recovery of classical texts mainly to secular concerns: rhetoric, history, and the duties of the citizen in the republic. Northern Christian humanists such as Erasmus used the same scholarly method on scripture and the early church, aiming to recover a simpler biblical Christianity.

    (b) The printing press carried humanist scholarship north at a cost scribal copying could never match. Erasmus's Greek New Testament of 1516 could be printed and distributed to scholars across Europe, so a textual method developed in Italian workshops became available to northern theologians within a single career.

    (c) Humanist scholarship supplied the Reformation with its central weapon. By comparing the Vulgate with the original Greek, Erasmus showed that the church's authorized Latin text contained errors, which allowed Luther and others to argue that official doctrine could be wrong and that scripture in its earliest form should be the standard.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way European monarchs strengthened royal authority in the period 1450–1550.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way overseas expansion was connected to the growth of state power in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE consequence of the Columbian Exchange for Europe in the period 1492–1600.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: regular taxation without consent (the French taille); curbing noble violence through royal courts (Star Chamber under Henry VII); a crown-controlled Inquisition in Spain from 1478; professional bureaucracies and standing forces; royal influence over church appointments. Do not accept: "they became absolute" with no mechanism.
    • (b) Accept: crowns licensed and financed voyages and claimed the territory and revenue, as with Castile and Columbus or the Portuguese crown's African program; American silver funded Spanish armies and diplomacy; Tordesillas showed crowns disposing of territory by treaty. Must link expansion to state capacity.
    • (c) Accept: silver inflow and the price revolution, with its effects on rents and merchants; new crops such as the potato and maize supporting later population growth; new consumption of sugar and tobacco; the growth of Atlantic ports and the slave trade. Do not accept: effects on the Americas only, since the question asks about Europe.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Monarchs secured revenue that did not depend on the consent of representative bodies. In France, Louis XI collected the taille as a regular direct tax without summoning the Estates-General, which let the crown pay officials and troops without bargaining with the nobility.

    (b) Overseas expansion was a royal enterprise that returned royal revenue. Castile licensed and partly financed Columbus's voyage and claimed sovereignty over what he found, and after the opening of Potosí in 1545 American silver paid for the armies and diplomacy that made Spain the dominant power of the sixteenth century.

    (c) The inflow of American silver expanded Europe's money supply and contributed to a price revolution in which commodity prices rose several-fold across the sixteenth century. Landlords collecting rents fixed by long lease lost real income, while merchants and farmers selling at rising prices gained, shifting wealth toward commercial groups.

Lesson 2.1 · Unit 2 · CED topics 2.1 and 2.2

Context and Luther: the Reformation begins

In 1517 a German monk challenged the sale of indulgences, and within a generation Western Christianity was split. Learning Objective A asks for the context of the religious, political, and cultural developments of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Learning Objective B asks how and why religious belief and practice changed between 1450 and 1648. This lesson sets the stage and then follows Martin Luther from protest to a new church.

Required content · 2A, 2B

Learning objectives.

  • 2A. Explain the context in which the religious, political, and cultural developments of the 16th and 17th centuries took place.
  • 2B. Explain how and why religious belief and practices changed from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.2.I.B. Reformers Martin Luther and John Calvin criticized Catholic abuses and established new interpretations of Christian doctrine and practice. Responses to Luther and Calvin included religious radicals, including the Anabaptists, and other groups, such as German peasants.
  • 1.2.I.C. Some Protestant groups sanctioned the notion that wealth accumulation was a sign of God’s favor and a reward for hard work.

The context: a church under pressure

By 1500 many Europeans felt that the church had lost its way, though most of them were still deeply religious.

  • Complaints about the clergy. Bishops held several offices and lived like princes, parish priests were often poorly educated, and some Renaissance popes spent lavishly on politics, war, and art. Complaints about clerical wealth, ignorance, and immorality were widespread.
  • Popular piety. Ordinary people sought salvation through pilgrimages, relics, saints, and the purchase of indulgences, certificates that reduced the time a soul would spend in purgatory. Fear of death and judgment was intense after the plague.
  • New learning. Humanists such as Erasmus urged a return to the Bible and criticized the abuses. Printing (Lesson 1.3) meant new ideas could spread rapidly.
  • Political ambition. Princes and kings resented the pope's claims to authority and the flow of money to Rome. The Holy Roman Empire was a patchwork of hundreds of states under a weak emperor, which made it easier for local rulers to protect a reformer.

Martin Luther

Martin Luther (1483 to 1546), an Augustinian monk and professor at the University of Wittenberg, was tormented by the question of how a sinful person could be saved. Studying the Bible, especially Paul's letters, he concluded that salvation comes through faith alone, as a gift of God's grace, not through good works or purchased pardons.

The occasion for protest was the sale of indulgences to fund the rebuilding of St. Peter's Basilica in Rome. In October 1517, Luther sent his Ninety-Five Theses to his archbishop and, according to tradition, posted them in Wittenberg. Printers spread them across Germany within weeks. In the next years Luther developed core Protestant teachings.

  • Justification by faith alone (not by works or indulgences).
  • The authority of scripture alone (not the pope or church tradition).
  • The priesthood of all believers: every Christian may read the Bible and approach God directly, which undermined the special status of the clergy. Luther translated the New Testament into German in 1522.
  • Two sacraments (baptism and the Lord's Supper) and the rejection of purgatory, monasticism, and clerical celibacy; clergy could marry, and Luther himself married a former nun.

The Catholic Church condemned him. At the Diet of Worms (1521), Emperor Charles V demanded that he recant. Luther refused, and the emperor declared him an outlaw. Frederick the Wise, elector of Saxony, protected him, and Luther's ideas spread.

Princes, peasants, and the settlement

Luther's protest quickly took on political meaning. Many German princes embraced reform out of belief and also to seize church lands and to resist the emperor. Luther in turn looked to princes to protect the church, so the Lutheran church was tied closely to the state.

In 1524 and 1525 peasants rose in the German Peasants' War, citing Christian freedom to demand an end to serfdom. Luther condemned the revolt and urged the princes to crush it, and tens of thousands of peasants were killed. The episode shows both that religious ideas could raise social demands and that the main Reformers sided with order.

Religious war followed. The Peace of Augsburg (1555) ended the first stage by allowing each prince of the Holy Roman Empire to choose Catholicism or Lutheranism for his own territory; subjects of another faith could emigrate. It did not recognize Calvinism or any other group, and it did not establish individual religious freedom.

Why the Reformation spread

Protestants used the printing press to spread their ideas (Lesson 1.3), including vernacular Bibles, pamphlets, and woodcuts. Rulers who wanted control of church wealth and authority supported reform. And many people found Luther's emphasis on personal faith and scripture convincing. By 1555 much of northern Germany and Scandinavia was Lutheran.

Primary source · A challenge to indulgences

Description of: Martin Luther, Ninety-Five Theses (1517), a list of statements for academic debate written in Latin. Luther argues that the pope cannot forgive sins by selling indulgences, that true repentance is inward, and that "the true treasure of the church" is the gospel of God's grace, not papal pardons. He also asks why the pope, who is richer than the richest man, does not build St. Peter's with his own money.

Sourcing (HIPP). Luther wrote as a university professor, in Latin, for scholars and church leaders, and intended the theses as a debate, not a break from Rome. His point of view was that of a loyal but troubled monk. The historical situation was the indulgence campaign of the Dominican preacher Johann Tetzel, authorized by the pope to raise money for St. Peter's. The document spread beyond its audience when printers translated and printed it in German, which shows how the printing press turned a local academic protest into a movement.

Source analysis · Reform within the church

Claim. The Ninety-Five Theses criticize the sale of indulgences as a distortion of Christian teaching.

Evidence. Luther says true repentance is inward, that the pope cannot forgive sin by selling pardons, and that the real treasure of the church is the gospel.

Reasoning. The theses reflect the central change in religious belief: a shift of authority from church practice to scripture and personal faith. The document is written in Latin as an invitation to debate, so it shows Luther's intent to reform, not yet to split. Its rapid printing and translation explain how it reached the public.

Worked example · Religious change

Question. Explain one way religious belief changed and one way religious practice changed as a result of Luther's reforms.

Model. One change in belief was justification by faith alone: Luther taught that salvation comes from God's grace received through faith, not good works or indulgences. One change in practice was that worship and Bible reading moved into the vernacular and clergy were allowed to marry, as Luther translated the New Testament into German and rejected clerical celibacy.

Exam focus

Learning Objective B has two parts, belief and practice. Pair each with a specific example: belief (faith alone, scripture alone, the priesthood of all believers) and practice (vernacular Bible, married clergy, fewer sacraments, the end of indulgences). For context, avoid saying the church was simply corrupt and ignorant; many people were devout, and Catholic reform movements existed before 1517. Name the political side too: princes protected Luther and gained church lands.

Practice
  1. Name three beliefs central to Luther's teaching.
    Show answer

    Justification by faith alone, the authority of scripture alone, and the priesthood of all believers.

  2. What was an indulgence, and why was it controversial?
    Show answer

    A document reducing punishment for sins in purgatory. It was controversial because it was sold, especially to fund St. Peter's, which Luther saw as a corruption of Christian teaching.

  3. Why did Frederick the Wise matter to Luther's survival?
    Show answer

    As elector of Saxony he protected Luther from the emperor and the pope after the Diet of Worms.

  4. How did the Peasants' War show the limits of Luther's support for change?
    Show answer

    Peasants used religious arguments to demand social reform, but Luther condemned them and supported the princes who crushed the revolt.

  5. What did the Peace of Augsburg (1555) decide?
    Show answer

    Each prince in the Holy Roman Empire could choose Catholicism or Lutheranism for his territory; Calvinists were not included.

  6. Why might a historian say the Reformation was political as well as religious?
    Show answer

    Princes supported reform to gain church lands and resist the emperor and pope, and the settlement at Augsburg gave rulers control of religion in their lands.

Lesson 2.2 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.3

Calvin, radicals, and the English Reformation

Luther started the Reformation, but he did not control it. Learning Objective B continues here: how and why religious belief and practice changed from 1450 to 1648. The CED highlights three points. Protestant reformers used the printing press to spread their ideas; some Protestants, including Calvin and the Anabaptists, refused to recognize the subordination of the church to the secular state; and religious conflicts became a basis for challenging the monarchs' control of religious institutions. This lesson follows reform in Switzerland, in radical groups, and in England.

Required content · 2B

Learning objective.

  • 2B. Explain how and why religious belief and practices changed from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.II.B. Protestant reformers used the printing press to disseminate their ideas, which spurred religious reform and helped it to become widely established.
  • 1.2.II.B. Some Protestants, including Calvin and the Anabaptists, refused to recognize the subordination of the church to the secular state.
  • 1.2.II.C. Religious conflicts became a basis for challenging the monarchs’ control of religious institutions.

Zwingli and Calvin

  • Huldrych Zwingli led reform in Zurich from the 1520s. He wanted to remove from worship anything not found in scripture, and he disagreed with Luther about the meaning of the Lord's Supper.
  • John Calvin (1509 to 1564), a French lawyer and theologian, published the Institutes of the Christian Religion (first edition 1536), a clear and logical summary of Protestant belief. He settled in Geneva, where reformers governed the city from 1541.

Calvin stressed the absolute sovereignty of God and predestination: God has already chosen who will be saved. Believers could not earn salvation, but they could look for signs of their election in a disciplined, godly life. Some Calvinists therefore came to see hard work and success as signs of God's favor. Geneva's consistory, a board of ministers and elders, supervised public morals, and the city became a model that attracted refugees from across Europe, who carried Calvinism home.

Calvinism spread as the Reformed church to France (the Huguenots), the Netherlands, Scotland (under John Knox, the Presbyterian church), and parts of Germany and Hungary. It also inspired the English Puritans. Calvinists often organized churches by elected elders and were willing to resist rulers who opposed their faith, so they refused to accept that the church should be subordinate to the state.

Western Christianity, 1517 Lutheran Luther German states, Scandinavia Reformed Zwingli, Calvin Switzerland, Scotland, Netherlands, Huguenots Anglican Henry VIII, Elizabeth I England Anabaptist Adult baptism; church apart from the state Catholic Reformed at Trent; Spain, Italy, Austria, Poland
Figure 2.1. After the Reformation. Reformers split from the Catholic Church in several directions, each tied to particular regions and leaders, while the Catholic Church reformed itself at Trent.

The radicals: Anabaptists

The Anabaptists ("rebaptizers") believed that only adults who consciously chose faith should be baptized, that the church was a voluntary community separate from the state, and that Christians should not hold office or bear arms. Most were peaceful, but a radical group seized the city of Münster in 1534 and set up a short-lived communal regime. Catholics, Lutherans, and Calvinists all persecuted Anabaptists, because rejecting infant baptism and state authority threatened the unity of church and community. Their descendants include Mennonites and the Amish.

The English Reformation: a break from above

England shows reform led by the monarch. Henry VIII had been a defender of the pope against Luther, but he wanted an annulment of his marriage to Catherine of Aragon in order to have a male heir. When the pope refused, Parliament passed the Act of Supremacy (1534), making the king head of the Church of England. Henry also dissolved the monasteries and sold their lands, which gave many families a stake in the new settlement.

Under his son Edward VI the church became more Protestant, with the Book of Common Prayer (1549) in English. His Catholic half-sister Mary I restored Catholicism and executed about 280 Protestants. Elizabeth I (r. 1558 to 1603) created a compromise, the Elizabethan Settlement, with a Protestant doctrine and traditional church structure of bishops, which satisfied most people. Puritans wanted to "purify" it further, while some Catholics remained loyal to Rome. The CED's term for the monarchs' policy is reform from the top down.

Religious conflict and royal authority

The CED notes that religious conflicts became a basis for challenging monarchs. Examples are French Calvinists (Huguenots) who rebelled against a Catholic monarchy, English Puritans who opposed the Stuart kings' church policy, and nobles in Poland who defended religious freedom in order to protect their own privileges against the king. Rulers who tried to impose one faith found that religion could rally resistance.

Primary source · Election and predestination

John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion (1559 edition), Book III, chapter 21 (translated by Henry Beveridge, 1845), excerpt.

...we say that God has once for all determined, both whom he would admit to salvation, and whom he would condemn to destruction.

Sourcing (HIPP). Calvin wrote as a scholar-pastor and a refugee from France, building a systematic theology. His audience was fellow reformers and educated readers, and the Latin and French editions spread through printing. His purpose was to explain and defend the doctrine of election, which he regarded as a source of comfort for believers. The historical situation was the competition among Protestant and Catholic churches for followers. As evidence the passage shows what Calvin believed, but it does not show how ordinary Calvinists lived with the doctrine, which many experienced as a call to discipline and work.

Source analysis · A distinctive belief

Claim. Calvin teaches that God has predetermined who will be saved and who will be condemned.

Evidence. He says God "has once for all determined" both groups.

Reasoning. The passage separates Calvinism from Catholic and Lutheran emphasis on human response, and it helps explain Calvinist stress on discipline: believers looked for signs of election in their conduct. As a statement of doctrine it shows belief, not practice, so a historian would pair it with evidence of how Geneva and other Calvinist societies actually worked.

Worked example · Church and state

Question. Explain one way religious conflict challenged royal control of religion in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.

Model. In France, Calvinist Huguenots refused to accept the monarchy's Catholic religion and some nobles used the cause to resist the crown, leading to civil war. In England, Puritans challenged the monarch's control of the Church of England, which led to conflict with the Stuart kings. In both cases, religious conviction gave opponents a reason to resist the crown.

Exam focus

Distinguish the Protestant groups by their ideas: Lutheran (justification by faith, close ties with princes), Calvinist (predestination, church discipline, sometimes resistance), Anabaptist (adult baptism, separation of church and state), Anglican (monarch as head of the church). The CED's linking points are the press, the refusal of church subordination by Calvin and the Anabaptists, and challenges to monarchs. Do not claim that Calvinists invented capitalism; the CED only says some Protestants saw wealth as a sign of God's favor.

Practice
  1. What doctrine is most associated with Calvin?
    Show answer

    Predestination, the idea that God has already determined who will be saved.

  2. How did Geneva serve as a model for other Protestants?
    Show answer

    It was governed by reformers with a consistory that supervised morals, and its example and refugees carried Calvinism to France, Scotland, the Netherlands, and elsewhere.

  3. Why were the Anabaptists persecuted by many Christians?
    Show answer

    They rejected infant baptism, separated church from state, and refused to take part in government or military service, which threatened established religious and political order.

  4. What caused Henry VIII's break with Rome, and what did the Act of Supremacy do?
    Show answer

    The pope would not annul his marriage; the act made the king head of the Church of England.

  5. Describe the Elizabethan Settlement.
    Show answer

    A compromise church with Protestant doctrine and the traditional structure of bishops and a prayer book in English, intended to satisfy most people.

  6. Give an example of religious conflict that challenged a monarch.
    Show answer

    French Huguenots resisting the Catholic crown, English Puritans opposing Stuart church policy, or Polish nobles defending religious freedom against the king.

Lesson 2.3 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.4

Wars of religion, 1562 to 1648

By the second half of the sixteenth century religious division had turned into war. Learning Objective C asks how matters of religion influenced and were influenced by political factors between 1450 and 1648. The CED's main points: religious reform made conflict between monarchs and nobles worse (as in France); the Habsburgs faced an expanded Ottoman Empire while failing to restore Catholic unity; states exploited religious conflict for political and economic gain; a few states allowed pluralism to keep peace; and the Peace of Westphalia (1648) ended the medieval ideal of universal Christendom.

Required content · 2C

Learning objective.

  • 2C. Explain how matters of religion influenced and were influenced by political factors from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.2.III.A. Issues of religious reform exacerbated conflicts between the monarchy and the nobility, as in the French wars of religion.
  • 1.2.III.B. Habsburg rulers confronted an expanded Ottoman Empire while attempting unsuccessfully to restore Catholic unity across Europe.
  • 1.2.III.C. States exploited religious conflicts to promote political and economic interests.
  • 1.2.III.D. A few states, such as France with the Edict of Nantes, allowed religious pluralism in order to maintain domestic peace.
  • 1.5.I.B. The Peace of Westphalia (1648), which marked the effective end of the medieval ideal of universal Christendom, accelerated the decline of the Holy Roman Empire by granting princes, bishops, and other local leaders control over religion.

The Habsburgs: Catholic unity and the Ottoman threat

Charles V (ruled Spain, the Netherlands, and the Holy Roman Empire from 1519 to 1556) tried to defend the unity of Catholic Christendom. He failed. Lutheran princes resisted him, and he had to fight France and the Ottoman Empire, which under Suleiman the Magnificent took Hungary (1526) and besieged Vienna (1529). The Ottoman danger meant that the emperor often needed Protestant princes' help, which limited his ability to crush them. When Charles gave up his crowns, he split the Habsburg lands between his brother (Austria and the empire) and his son Philip II (Spain, the Netherlands, and the New World).

France: religion, nobles, and the crown

France shows how reform deepened conflict between the monarchy and the nobility. In the French Wars of Religion (1562 to 1598), Catholic and Calvinist (Huguenot) noble families, led by the Guise and Bourbon houses, fought for control of a weak monarchy under the sons of Henry II.

  • Catherine de' Medici, the queen mother, tried to balance the factions. The tension ended in the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre (August 1572), when Catholic mobs and soldiers killed thousands of Huguenots in Paris, and massacres spread to other cities.
  • In the War of the Three Henrys (1587 to 1589), the king, Henry of Guise, and Henry of Navarre (a Huguenot) each fought for the throne. Henry of Navarre became Henry IV, converted to Catholicism in 1593, and issued the Edict of Nantes (1598), which gave Huguenots freedom of worship in many places and legal rights. The CED cites it as an example of a state that allowed religious pluralism to maintain domestic peace. The politiques, moderates who put the unity of the state above religious unity, supported this approach.

The Dutch Revolt and Spain against England

In the Netherlands, Philip II tried to enforce Catholic orthodoxy and heavier taxes. Calvinists and nobles rebelled from 1566. The northern provinces formed the Union of Utrecht (1579) and declared independence in 1581, becoming the Dutch Republic, which Spain recognized only in 1648. Spain also fought Protestant England, and in 1588 the Spanish Armada failed to invade it. These conflicts show how states exploited religious conflicts to promote political and economic interests: England backed Dutch rebels for strategic reasons as well as religious ones.

The Thirty Years' War (1618 to 1648)

The war began in the Holy Roman Empire when Protestant Bohemian nobles threw royal officials from a window in Prague (the Defenestration of Prague, 1618) to resist the Catholic Habsburg emperor. It grew into a general European conflict in phases (Bohemian, Danish, Swedish, French) and came to be fought less for religion than for power.

  • Sweden under Gustavus Adolphus and Denmark joined to protect Protestants and to gain territory and influence.
  • Catholic France, led by Cardinal Richelieu, supported the Protestant side to weaken its Habsburg rival.

Armies lived off the land, and disease and famine accompanied them. Parts of Germany lost a large share of their people, and historians estimate that the empire's population fell by about one-fifth overall, much more in some regions.

1555 Peace of Augsburg 1562 French Wars of Religion begin 1566 Dutch Revolt begins 1572 St. Bartholomew's Day massacre 1588 Spanish Armada fails 1598 Edict of Nantes 1618 Defenestration of Prague; war begins 1635 France enters the war against the Habsburgs 1648 Peace of Westphalia
Figure 2.2. The wars of religion. Conflict moved from the Holy Roman Empire to France and the Netherlands and back to a continent-wide war, ending in the treaties of 1648.

The Peace of Westphalia (1648)

The treaties ending the war made lasting changes.

  • Religion. The Peace of Augsburg principle was renewed and extended to Calvinism. Princes controlled religion in their lands, with some protection for minorities.
  • The empire. Princes, bishops, and local leaders gained sovereignty, so the Holy Roman Empire declined into a loose association, and the emperor's power was weakened.
  • Winners and losers. France and Sweden gained territory. The independence of the Dutch Republic and the Swiss was recognized. Spain, drained by war, began its decline.

The CED says the treaties marked the effective end of the medieval ideal of universal Christendom. Rulers could no longer claim to speak for a single Christian community, so relations among states came to rest on sovereignty and the balance of power (Unit 3).

Primary source · Pluralism for peace

Description of: The Edict of Nantes (1598), issued by Henry IV of France. The edict declares that Catholicism is to be restored across the kingdom, but grants Huguenots freedom of conscience, the right to worship publicly in specified places, access to public offices, and several fortified towns for their security.

Sourcing (HIPP). The edict is a royal law written to end thirty-six years of civil war, so its purpose was political: to restore order and royal authority. The audience was the French people and the courts that had to register it. Henry IV, who had been Protestant and became Catholic to gain the crown, had personal knowledge of both sides. The edict shows that a state could choose toleration for practical reasons, but it gave Huguenots only limited, conditional rights, and Louis XIV later revoked it (Unit 3).

Source analysis · Toleration as policy

Claim. The Edict of Nantes gave French Protestants rights in order to end civil war.

Evidence. It allows Huguenots freedom of conscience, public worship in specified places, access to offices, and fortified towns.

Reasoning. Granting such protections shows a king balancing religious pluralism against the unity of the realm, which matches the CED's example of a state allowing pluralism for domestic peace. The limits on the edict (specified places, Catholicism as the official faith) show that it was a compromise, not a statement of religious liberty.

Worked example · Politics and religion

Question. Explain one way political factors influenced religious conflict between 1450 and 1648.

Model. States exploited religious conflict for political and economic interests. In the Thirty Years' War, Catholic France under Richelieu allied with Protestant Sweden and Denmark against the Catholic Habsburgs, because weakening the Habsburgs served French power more than Catholic unity did. This shows that political aims could outweigh religious loyalty.

Exam focus

Learning Objective C is about the two-way connection of religion and politics. Show religion shaping politics (nobles using faith to resist the crown, rulers choosing a faith) and politics shaping religion (states using conflict for gain, the Edict of Nantes, the Peace of Westphalia). The strongest examples are the French wars, the Dutch Revolt, and the Thirty Years' War, where Catholic France fought on the Protestant side. Remember the CED's end-point: Westphalia ended the ideal of universal Christendom.

Practice
  1. Why did the Ottoman Empire matter to the failure of Catholic unity under Charles V?
    Show answer

    The emperor had to fight the Ottomans, who took Hungary and besieged Vienna, so he needed Protestant princes' support and could not crush the Reformation.

  2. What was the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre?
    Show answer

    The killing of thousands of Huguenots by Catholic mobs and soldiers, starting in Paris in August 1572, during the French Wars of Religion.

  3. How did the Edict of Nantes end the French civil wars?
    Show answer

    Henry IV granted Huguenots freedom of conscience, limited public worship, and security rights while keeping Catholicism as the kingdom's religion.

  4. Give an example of a state exploiting religious conflict for its own interests.
    Show answer

    Catholic France allying with Protestant powers against the Habsburgs in the Thirty Years' War, or England aiding the Dutch Revolt against Spain.

  5. List two results of the Peace of Westphalia.
    Show answer

    Calvinism was recognized, princes gained control over religion, the Holy Roman Empire weakened, and Dutch and Swiss independence were recognized.

  6. What did the CED mean by the end of "universal Christendom"?
    Show answer

    The medieval idea of a single Christian community under pope and emperor was over, and states with their own religions and sovereignty dealt with one another as equals.

Lesson 2.4 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.5

The Catholic Reformation

The Catholic Church did not simply watch the Protestants take its members. Learning Objective D asks you to explain the continuities and changes in the role of the Catholic Church between 1450 and 1648. The CED's statement is balanced: the Catholic Reformation, exemplified by the Jesuit Order and the Council of Trent, revived the church but cemented division within Christianity. This lesson covers what changed, what stayed the same, and how the church used old and new tools to fight back.

Required content · 2D

Learning objective.

  • 2D. Explain the continuities and changes in the role of the Catholic Church from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.2.I.D. The Catholic Reformation, exemplified by the Jesuit Order and the Council of Trent, revived the church but cemented division within Christianity.

Reform before and after Luther

Catholic reform began before 1517, in reform-minded orders and in the writing of humanists such as Erasmus. After Luther, reform became a response to Protestantism, and historians use two overlapping terms. The Catholic Reformation stresses the renewal of piety and discipline; the Counter-Reformation stresses the effort to stop and reverse Protestant gains.

The Council of Trent (1545 to 1563)

After long delays, Pope Paul III called a general council, which met at Trent in northern Italy in three sessions over eighteen years. It did two things.

  • It reaffirmed doctrine against Protestants. Salvation comes through both faith and good works; there are seven sacraments; the bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ (transubstantiation); scripture and church tradition both carry authority; the Latin Vulgate is the authoritative Bible; and purgatory and the veneration of saints are legitimate. The council did not compromise with Protestants, so it ended any hope of reunion.
  • It reformed abuses. Bishops had to live in their dioceses, and holding several offices was restricted. Every diocese was to set up a seminary to train priests, and priests had to be better educated. Preaching and instruction of the laity (catechisms) were strengthened, and the abuses in the sale of indulgences were curbed.

The decrees shaped Catholic life for centuries. They changed the church by improving the clergy and discipline, and they kept continuity in doctrine and in the pope's authority.

The Jesuits

The Society of Jesus was founded by Ignatius of Loyola, a Spanish soldier who turned to religion after a wound, and approved by the pope in 1540. The Jesuits were organized like a disciplined army with a vow of special obedience to the pope. Their Spiritual Exercises trained members in prayer and self-discipline. They became the Catholic Church's most effective educators and missionaries.

  • Education. Jesuit schools and colleges taught the sons of the nobility and the middle class a humanist curriculum with Catholic teaching, which won back many in Germany, Poland, and France.
  • Politics. Jesuits served as confessors to Catholic rulers and advisers in courts.
  • Missions. Francis Xavier took Christianity to India, Southeast Asia, and Japan; others worked in China and in the Americas. The CED notes that religious motives helped drive European expansion (Lesson 1.5).

New orders and spirituality

  • Teresa of Ávila (1515 to 1582), a Spanish Carmelite nun and mystic, reformed her order and wrote about prayer and inward experience; she was later declared a Doctor of the Church.
  • The Ursulines, founded by Angela Merici in 1535, were a women's order that educated girls. They show how reform created new roles for women, though under church supervision.

Enforcement

The church also used coercion. The Roman Inquisition (established 1542) investigated heresy in Italy and tried cases such as that of Galileo in the next century. The Index of Prohibited Books (first issued in 1559) listed works Catholics were forbidden to read, reflecting the church's fear of the printing press. Where Catholic rulers cooperated, as in Spain and Italy, these tools were effective; in northern Europe they were not.

Result: a divided Christendom

The Catholic Reformation revived the church. Piety deepened, the clergy improved, and Catholic areas in southern and central Europe held firm and even regained territory such as Bavaria, Poland, and parts of the Habsburg lands. But Trent's firm stand also cemented division. By 1600 Europe was split into hostile confessional camps, and in the next decades they fought one another (Lesson 2.3).

Primary source · A rule for obedience

Description of: Ignatius of Loyola, Spiritual Exercises (1548), "Rules for Thinking with the Church." Ignatius advises that to keep the right mind in everything, a person should be ready to obey the church's authority, praise its traditions and sacraments, and set aside personal judgment, even to the point of believing something white to be black if the hierarchical church so defines it.

Sourcing (HIPP). Ignatius was a former soldier and the founder of the Jesuits, and he wrote as a spiritual director for members of his order. His purpose was to instill obedience and loyalty to the church at the moment when many were rejecting its authority. The historical situation was the Reformation and the effort to hold Catholic loyalty. The passage reflects the Catholic emphasis on authority and tradition against the Protestant principle of scripture alone. Because the text is an instruction manual, it shows ideals, not how all Jesuits behaved.

Source analysis · Authority against private judgment

Claim. The Catholic Reformation stressed obedience to church authority in response to Protestant challenges.

Evidence. Ignatius advises readers to praise church traditions and to submit personal judgment to the hierarchy.

Reasoning. This is the reverse of the Protestant principle of scripture alone and the priesthood of all believers, which shows how the Catholic response hardened differences, in line with the CED's point that the Catholic Reformation cemented division. The document is a guide for members of an order, so it reflects an ideal, not universal Catholic practice.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in the role of the Catholic Church between 1450 and 1648.

Model. One continuity was the church's claim to authority in doctrine and the pope's leadership: the Council of Trent reaffirmed the seven sacraments, the authority of tradition, and papal supremacy. One change was reform of the clergy and the church's educational role, as Trent required seminaries and the Jesuits built schools and missions, which revived Catholic life.

Exam focus

Learning Objective D asks for continuity and change, so organize your answer that way. Continuity: doctrine, sacraments, papal authority, enforcement through the Inquisition and Index. Change: seminaries and better-trained priests, the Jesuits and other new orders, a more active role in education and missions. State the CED conclusion: the reforms revived the church but cemented division. Do not describe the Counter-Reformation as only repression.

Practice
  1. What two tasks did the Council of Trent carry out?
    Show answer

    It reaffirmed Catholic doctrine against Protestant teachings and reformed abuses within the church.

  2. Give two reforms of Trent that affected the clergy.
    Show answer

    Seminaries for training priests, required residence for bishops, and limits on holding several church offices.

  3. Who founded the Jesuits, and what were their main activities?
    Show answer

    Ignatius of Loyola founded the order in 1540; the Jesuits worked as educators, advisers to rulers, and missionaries.

  4. How did Teresa of Ávila or the Ursulines add to Catholic reform?
    Show answer

    Teresa reformed the Carmelite order and wrote on mystical prayer; the Ursulines educated girls and expanded women's religious roles.

  5. What were the Roman Inquisition and the Index of Prohibited Books?
    Show answer

    Church tools of enforcement: a court that investigated heresy and a list of books Catholics were forbidden to read.

  6. In what sense did the Catholic Reformation "cement division"?
    Show answer

    Trent refused compromise on core doctrines, ending hopes of reunion and making the split between Catholic and Protestant churches permanent.

Lesson 2.5 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.6

Society, family, and witch hunts

The wars and arguments of the sixteenth century happened among people who lived in villages, towns, and households, and who were slow to change their ways. Learning Objective E asks how economic and intellectual developments from 1450 to 1648 affected social norms and hierarchies. The CED stresses continuity: established hierarchies of class, religion, and gender kept defining social status, work was done by households, and communal leisure and enforcement of norms continued. At the same time, the Renaissance and Reformation raised new debates, and a wave of witch trials shows an anxious age.

Required content · 2E

Learning objective.

  • 2E. Explain how economic and intellectual developments from 1450 to 1648 affected social norms and hierarchies.

Historical developments.

  • 1.4.I.C. Established hierarchies of class, religion, and gender continued to define social status and perceptions in rural and urban settings.
  • 1.4.IV.A. Rural and urban households worked as units, with men and women engaged in separate but complementary tasks.
  • 1.4.IV.B. The Renaissance and Reformation raised debates about female education and women’s roles in the family, church, and society.
  • 1.4.III.C. Social dislocation, coupled with the shifting authority of religious institutions during the Reformation, left city governments with the task of regulating public morals.
  • 1.4.V.A. Leisure activities continued to be organized according to the religious calendar and the agricultural cycle, and remained communal in nature.
  • 1.4.V.B. Local and church authorities continued to enforce communal norms through rituals of public humiliation.
  • 1.4.V.C. Reflecting folk ideas and social and economic upheaval, accusations of witchcraft peaked between 1580 and 1650.

Hierarchies that lasted

Society was organized by rank. At the top stood nobles, whose prestige rested on land ownership, along with tax exemptions, legal privileges, and the right to bear arms. Clergy formed a separate order with its own courts and privileges. Below them came merchants and professionals, then artisans and the great mass of peasants. The rich and the poor were visibly separated by law and by dress. Religion marked status too: in many places only members of the established church could hold office.

Gender was also a hierarchy. Women were excluded from politics and most professions, and they could not vote, attend universities, or hold offices. A husband was legally the head of his household.

The household as the unit of work

In both rural and urban settings, the household was the basic unit of production. Men and women had separate but complementary tasks. In a farm family, men plowed and harvested while women raised poultry, made dairy products, spun thread, and took produce to market; in a town, a master craftsman's wife often kept accounts and sold goods, and apprentices lived in the household. The family was an economic partnership, though it was headed by the husband.

Debates about women

The Renaissance and Reformation raised debates about female education and women's roles in the family, church, and society. The long literary debate known as la querelle des femmes argued whether women were intellectually and morally equal to men. Humanists such as Erasmus and Thomas More favored educating girls, and some women wrote on the topic. Protestants stressed that every believer should read the Bible, which encouraged literacy for girls, and they praised marriage over celibacy. Yet most reformers kept women out of church office, and some radical groups saw women as preachers. Overall, women's legal and social position changed very little.

Controlling public morals

The Reformation shifted religious authority, and the CED notes that social dislocation, coupled with the shifting authority of religious institutions, left city governments with the task of regulating public morals. Town councils passed new secular laws on private life, including stricter codes on prostitution and begging. Many cities closed brothels, restricted or abolished Carnival, and set up poor relief. Geneva's consistory is the best-known example (Lesson 2.2). Both Protestant and Catholic authorities tried to discipline popular culture.

Leisure and communal norms

Leisure activities were organized by the religious calendar and the agricultural cycle and remained communal: saints' day festivities, Carnival before Lent, harvest festivals, and blood sports such as bull-baiting. Communities enforced norms through rituals of public humiliation. In a charivari, neighbors made noise and mocked a couple whose marriage broke custom, such as an old widower marrying a young bride; offenders could also be put in the stocks or publicly whipped or branded.

The witch hunts

Witchcraft accusations peaked between 1580 and 1650, reflecting folk ideas and social and economic upheaval. Historians estimate that tens of thousands of people were tried and perhaps 40,000 to 60,000 executed in Europe, mostly in the Holy Roman Empire, Switzerland, and Scotland, with fewer in Spain and Italy where the Inquisition was skeptical.

  • Prominence of women. Most of the accused were women, often older, poor, or single, who were seen as outsiders or whose neighbors blamed them for misfortunes such as a sick child or a dead cow.
  • Regional variation. Intensity depended on local courts, religious tension, and the beliefs of the local authorities. Some regions, such as Spain and Ireland, saw few trials.
  • Social upheaval. Plague, war, crop failure, and the religious divisions of the Reformation produced anxiety, and communities looked for someone to blame. Both Protestant and Catholic authorities took part.

The hunts declined after about 1650 as courts demanded better evidence and educated people became skeptical.

Primary source · A king on witchcraft

Description of: King James VI of Scotland (later James I of England), Daemonologie (1597), a book on witchcraft written as a dialogue. James argues that witches exist, that they have made a pact with the devil, and that magistrates are obligated to find and punish them; he also says that women are more easily seduced by the devil than men.

Sourcing (HIPP). James wrote as a king who had taken a personal interest in the North Berwick witch trials in Scotland in the early 1590s, so his point of view is that of a ruler convinced of the danger. The purpose was to defend the reality of witchcraft against skeptics and to guide judges. The audience was educated readers and officials. The book shows how elite beliefs, religion, and gender assumptions supported the persecution, though it says nothing directly about the views of the accused themselves.

Source analysis · Elite belief and persecution

Claim. Learned authorities helped drive the witch hunts.

Evidence. James VI writes that witches have made a pact with the devil, that magistrates must punish them, and that women are more easily led astray.

Reasoning. This shows how elite religious ideas and assumptions about women provided justification for trials, which fits the CED's observation that women were prominent among the accused and that religious institutions' authority was shifting. Because the source comes from the ruling class, it must be paired with records of local accusations to understand why neighbors accused one another.

Worked example · Continuity

Question. Explain one way social hierarchies continued in the sixteenth century despite Renaissance and Reformation ideas.

Model. Gender hierarchy persisted: although humanists and Protestants debated women's education and the need for them to read the Bible, women remained excluded from political life and most professions, and the household was headed by the husband. Even in households where women contributed to work, the tasks were separate and the husband held the authority.

Exam focus

Learning Objective E rewards answers that balance continuity (class, religion, and gender hierarchies, household work, communal leisure, public humiliation) with change (new debates about women, secular laws regulating morals, the Reformation's challenge to religious authority). For witchcraft, give the dates (peak 1580 to 1650) and cite three factors: women's prominence, regional variation, and social upheaval. Avoid the myth that the witch hunts were a medieval event; they peaked in the early modern period.

Practice
  1. What was the basic unit of work in sixteenth-century society?
    Show answer

    The household, in which men and women performed separate but complementary tasks.

  2. Give one way the Renaissance or Reformation affected debates about women.
    Show answer

    Humanists and Protestants argued for female education, especially to read the Bible, and the querelle des femmes debated women's intellect and roles.

  3. Why did city governments regulate public morals more strictly?
    Show answer

    Social dislocation and the shifting authority of religious institutions during the Reformation left cities responsible for order, so they passed laws on prostitution, begging, and Carnival.

  4. Describe one ritual of public humiliation.
    Show answer

    A charivari, in which neighbors mocked a couple who broke marriage customs; also the stocks, public whipping, or branding.

  5. When did witch accusations peak, and who was accused?
    Show answer

    Between about 1580 and 1650; the accused were mostly women, often poor or older, accused during times of social or economic upheaval.

  6. Why did the intensity of witch trials vary by region?
    Show answer

    It depended on local courts and authorities, religious tension, and local beliefs; some places with skeptical courts, such as Spain, had few trials.

Lesson 2.6 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.7

Mannerism and Baroque art as persuasion

Art in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries was not only decoration. Learning Objective F asks you to explain how and why artistic expression changed from 1450 to 1648. The CED's key point is that Mannerist and Baroque artists employed distortion, drama, and illusion, and that monarchies, city-states, and the church commissioned these works as a means of promoting their own stature and power. This lesson shows what the styles looked like and, above all, who paid for them and why.

Required content · 2F

Learning objective.

  • 2F. Explain how and why artistic expression changed from 1450 to 1648.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.III.C. Mannerist and Baroque artists employed distortion, drama, and illusion in their work. Monarchies, city-states, and the church commissioned these works as a means of promoting their own stature and power.

From the High Renaissance to Mannerism

The harmony, balance, and clear space of the High Renaissance, in the work of Leonardo, Raphael, and Michelangelo, seemed to some younger artists to have reached perfection. After about 1520, and in a Europe shaken by religious conflict, the sack of Rome (1527), and political uncertainty, artists began to experiment. Mannerism is the name for the style.

  • Distortion. Figures are elongated, twisted, and posed in unnatural ways, as in Parmigianino's Madonna with the Long Neck.
  • Unbalanced space. Perspective is made ambiguous, colors are bright and unusual, and compositions are crowded or tense.
  • Emotion and unease. The calm of earlier art gives way to a more intense, personal, and sometimes anxious mood.

The Greek-born painter El Greco, working in Spain, used elongated figures and dramatic light to express deep religious feeling.

The Baroque

Baroque art arose in Rome in the late sixteenth century and spread across Catholic Europe in the seventeenth. It is associated with the Catholic Reformation and with absolutist monarchs. The Council of Trent had said that religious art should instruct and inspire the faithful, and Baroque artists did this by moving the viewer.

  • Drama. Strong contrasts of light and shadow (chiaroscuro), diagonal compositions, and a frozen moment of action. Caravaggio painted saints as real, working-class figures in sharp light.
  • Illusion. Painted ceilings seem to open into heaven, and sculpture appears to move. Gian Lorenzo Bernini's Ecstasy of Saint Teresa (1647 to 1652) shows the saint in a rapture, lit from a hidden window, and was designed as theater in a chapel.
  • Emotion and grandeur. Peter Paul Rubens of Flanders painted large, energetic scenes of religion, mythology, and politics. Artemisia Gentileschi, one of the first successful women painters, painted powerful biblical heroines such as Judith, and she worked in Italy in Caravaggio's manner.
  • Monumental architecture. Domes, curved facades, and grand squares, as at St. Peter's in Rome, and, later, the palace of Versailles.

Patrons and power

The CED stresses that these works were used to promote the stature and power of those who paid for them.

  • The church. The papacy and Catholic orders used Baroque churches, altarpieces, and sculpture to rebuild the faith's appeal after the Reformation, awing the faithful with beauty and emotion.
  • Monarchs. Kings and princes commissioned portraits, palaces, and public buildings to show wealth and divine favor. Philip IV of Spain employed Velázquez as court painter; Louis XIV's Versailles (built from the 1660s) turned Baroque grandeur into a stage for absolute monarchy.
  • City-states and wealthy individuals. City councils and banking families also commissioned art to boost their standing.

Not all art served religion and kings. In the Protestant Dutch Republic, where Calvinists distrusted religious images, painters sold portraits, landscapes, and scenes of daily life to merchants and townspeople (Lesson 4.4).

Primary source · A saint in ecstasy

Description of: Gian Lorenzo Bernini, The Ecstasy of Saint Teresa (marble, 1647 to 1652), in the Cornaro Chapel of Santa Maria della Vittoria, Rome. The marble saint reclines on a cloud, eyes half closed and mouth open, while a smiling angel holds a golden arrow. Gilded rays fall from a hidden window above, and sculpted members of the Cornaro family look on from side balconies like spectators in a theater.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bernini created the work for Cardinal Federico Cornaro, who paid for the chapel as a memorial to his family, so the purpose was both religious and a display of the patron's status. The historical situation was the Catholic Reformation, which valued Teresa's mystical writing and the emotional power of art. The audience was worshippers entering the chapel. The sculpture shows how the church used drama and illusion to inspire devotion, but as one commissioned work it cannot represent all artists, many of whom worked for other patrons.

Source analysis · Art as persuasion

Claim. Bernini's chapel used drama and illusion to promote Catholic devotion and the Cornaro family's prestige.

Evidence. The saint appears in rapture, lit by hidden light, with family members watching from balconies as if at a play.

Reasoning. The staged lighting and emotional intensity match the CED's description of Baroque art, while the portraits of the family show the patron's use of art to promote his own stature. Because it was commissioned by a cardinal for a Catholic church, it reflects the aims of the Catholic Reformation, not those of artists in Protestant regions.

Worked example · Change in artistic expression

Question. Explain one way artistic expression changed between the High Renaissance and the Baroque.

Model. High Renaissance art stressed harmony, balance, and calm proportion, while Baroque artists used strong contrasts of light, dramatic action, and illusion to move the viewer. The change was driven partly by the Catholic Reformation, which wanted religious art to inspire emotion, and partly by patrons such as popes and monarchs who wished to display power.

Exam focus

Learning Objective F has a how and a why. The how: Mannerism uses distortion; the Baroque uses drama and illusion. The why: patrons such as the church, monarchies, and city-states used art to promote their stature and power. Always name an artist and a patron. Remember that the Protestant Dutch followed a different pattern, which Unit 4 covers.

Practice
  1. What features characterize Mannerist painting?
    Show answer

    Elongated and twisted figures, ambiguous space, bright unusual color, and an intense or uneasy mood.

  2. Name two Baroque artists and one feature of their work.
    Show answer

    Caravaggio used dramatic light and shadow (chiaroscuro); Bernini created dramatic, theatrical sculpture; Rubens painted energetic, grand scenes; Gentileschi painted powerful biblical heroines.

  3. Why was Baroque art associated with the Catholic Reformation?
    Show answer

    The church wanted art to inspire faith and emotion after the Reformation, and Baroque drama and illusion did this.

  4. How did monarchs use art?
    Show answer

    They commissioned portraits, palaces, and public buildings, such as Versailles, to display wealth and power.

  5. Who commissioned Bernini's Ecstasy of Saint Teresa, and why does that matter?
    Show answer

    Cardinal Federico Cornaro commissioned it, which shows that patrons used religious art to express devotion and also to promote their own family's status.

  6. Why is one artwork limited as evidence of the whole period?
    Show answer

    It reflects the views of a specific patron and artist, so it cannot show the range of styles, such as the Protestant Dutch tradition of everyday scenes.

Lesson 2.7 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.8

Causation: why the Reformation and its wars happened

The last topic of Unit 2 practices causation on the evidence of the whole unit. Learning Objective G asks you to explain how the religious, political, and cultural developments of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries affected European society between 1450 and 1648. In Unit 1 you learned to separate causes by type and time. Here you add a second skill: tracing a chain of effects across religion, politics, and everyday life.

Required content · 2G

Learning objective.

  • 2G. Explain how the religious, political, and cultural developments of the 16th and 17th centuries affected European society from 1450 to 1648.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

The causes of the Reformation

Build the explanation in layers.

  • Long-term causes. Complaints about clerical wealth and ignorance; a popular piety that valued indulgences and pilgrimages; the Great Schism and the loss of papal prestige; humanist criticism and the call to return to the Bible.
  • Intellectual and technological causes. Humanism (Lesson 1.1) and printing (Lesson 1.3) gave reformers texts to cite and a way to reach readers quickly.
  • Political causes. Rulers wanted control of church wealth and authority; the Holy Roman Empire's fragmented politics let local princes protect Luther; kings in England, France, and Spain were building states (Lesson 1.4).
  • The short-term trigger. The sale of indulgences for St. Peter's in 1517, and Luther's refusal to recant at Worms in 1521.

A strong answer ranks these. Without the indulgence controversy there might not have been a spark, but without long-term discontent, printing, and princes' support, one monk's protest would have been silenced as earlier ones (such as Jan Hus's) were.

The chain of effects

The Reformation did not stop with religious change. Its effects spread in a chain.

  1. Religious: Western Christianity split into Catholic, Lutheran, Reformed (Calvinist), Anglican, and radical groups, and the Catholic Church reformed itself at Trent.
  2. Political: Rulers gained power over churches (the Act of Supremacy, the Peace of Augsburg). Religious conflict was used by nobles and states, producing civil wars in France and the Netherlands and the Thirty Years' War.
  3. International: The Peace of Westphalia ended the medieval ideal of universal Christendom and left sovereign states that dealt with each other on the basis of power.
  4. Social and cultural: Cities and rulers regulated morals; literacy grew as Protestants emphasized reading scripture; witch trials, public discipline, and new forms of art (the Baroque) reflected the age's anxieties and the competition for loyalty.
Religious Church splits into many confessions Trent reforms Catholic Church Political Rulers control churches Nobles use faith to resist kings International Civil wars and the Thirty Years' War Westphalia ends universal Christendom Social and cultural Literacy and Bible reading spread Cities regulate morals Witch hunts; Baroque art The Reformation of 1517 and its effects, in sequence
Figure 2.3. Chain of effects. The religious split led to political change, then to war and a new international order, with changes in society and culture alongside.

Using evidence and avoiding traps

  • Distinguish correlation from cause. Printing and the Reformation grew together, but printing did not cause belief. It was a means that made the movement spread faster.
  • Weigh religion against politics. The Thirty Years' War began over religion but included Catholic France on the Protestant side, so politics clearly mattered.
  • Remember continuity. Most hierarchies of class and gender, and most people's daily lives, changed little (Lesson 2.5). A causal claim should not say that the Reformation transformed everything.
Primary source · A secondary argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument. The author maintains that religious belief was a genuine cause of the wars of religion, not just a cover for politics, because rulers and nobles risked their lives and fortunes for doctrine and because ordinary people took part in religious riots and massacres, though political and dynastic ambitions shaped when and how conflicts broke out.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author is a modern scholar writing with hindsight, so the point of view is analytical and the purpose is to evaluate a causal claim. A secondary source gives an argument and evidence selected by the historian, not the voices of the time. A strong response identifies the claim (belief was a real cause), checks it against evidence (religious riots, the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre, conversions with political motives, France's alliance with Protestants), and notes that the historian acknowledges political causes too.

Source analysis · Evaluating a causal claim

Claim. The historian argues that religious belief was a real cause of the wars of religion, alongside politics.

Evidence. Facts that support it include the participation of ordinary people in religious riots and the massacre of Huguenots in 1572; facts that complicate it include France's alliance with Protestant powers against the Habsburgs in the Thirty Years' War.

Reasoning. The claim is balanced: religion motivated people and gave conflicts their intensity, but states also used religion for political goals. The best reading treats the two as interacting causes, in line with the CED's statement that matters of religion influenced and were influenced by political factors.

Worked example · Chain of effects

Question. Explain one way the Reformation led to changes in European politics.

Model. The Reformation gave rulers more control over religion and weakened the church's independence: in England the Act of Supremacy made the king head of the church, and in the Holy Roman Empire the Peace of Augsburg let princes choose their territory's religion. Religious division also led to long wars, and the settlement at Westphalia in 1648 ended the medieval ideal of a single Christendom, so politics shifted toward sovereign states.

Exam focus

A good causal essay or SAQ names the cause, the link, and the effect, and it separates immediate from long-term effects. Check that you cover more than one type of cause and more than one sphere of effect (religion, politics, society, culture). If asked for the most important cause, rank the causes and defend the ranking with evidence, and name a limit on the argument.

Practice
  1. Give one long-term and one short-term cause of the Reformation.
    Show answer

    Long-term: clerical abuses and the call to return to scripture, or humanist criticism. Short-term: the sale of indulgences in 1517, which triggered Luther's protest.

  2. How did printing contribute to the Reformation without being its cause?
    Show answer

    It was a means of spreading ideas, such as pamphlets and Bibles, which made the movement larger and faster, while the causes lay in belief, politics, and discontent.

  3. Give two political effects of the Reformation.
    Show answer

    Rulers gained control over churches and religion, and religious conflicts led to civil wars and the Thirty Years' War, ending in the Peace of Westphalia.

  4. How can a historian show that politics as well as religion shaped the Thirty Years' War?
    Show answer

    Catholic France under Richelieu supported Protestant powers against the Habsburgs, showing that power competition affected alliances.

  5. Name one social or cultural effect of the Reformation.
    Show answer

    Greater emphasis on literacy and Bible reading, regulation of public morals, the witch hunts, or Baroque art serving religion and monarchy.

  6. Why is it misleading to say the Reformation transformed all of European life?
    Show answer

    Many continuities remained: social hierarchies of class and gender, the household economy, and communal customs continued even as religion changed.

Unit 2 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 2 review: Age of Reformation, c. 1450–c. 1648

Ten questions on Luther and Calvin, the Catholic Reformation, the wars of religion from St. Bartholomew's Day to Westphalia, and the society that fought them, plus two short-answer questions on confessional change and its political consequences.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Martin Luther, Ninety-Five Theses, 1517, thesis 27.

    "They preach only human doctrines who say that as soon as the money clinks into the money chest, the soul flies out of purgatory."

    The thesis was originally intended as

    Correct. Luther posted the theses in Latin for university debate in the ordinary academic manner; printers then translated and circulated them to a lay public he had not addressed.

    Luther did not call for separation in 1517 and still hoped for reform within the church. The break came over the following four years under pressure of debate.

    The theses were an academic document, not a petition, and Luther first faced the imperial diet at Worms in 1521, four years later.

    They were written in Latin, the language of the university, not preached in German. The German translations were the printers' work.

  2. The Peace of Augsburg (1555) settled religious conflict in the Holy Roman Empire by

    The choice belonged to rulers, not subjects. Individuals who dissented from their prince's religion could emigrate, not worship freely where they were.

    Correct. Cuius regio, eius religio assigned the confessional question to each territorial prince, which settled the conflict politically rather than theologically.

    Calvinism was excluded in 1555 and gained recognition only at Westphalia in 1648: an omission that helped make the Thirty Years' War possible.

    Augsburg reduced rather than restored papal authority, since Lutheran princes controlled churches in their own territories.

  3. Source: John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book III.

    "By predestination we mean the eternal decree of God, by which he determined with himself whatever he wished to happen with regard to every man. All are not created on equal terms, but some are preordained to eternal life, others to eternal damnation."

    In practice, this doctrine most often encouraged Calvinist communities to

    This is the common misreading. Because no one could be certain of election, disciplined living was sought as a sign of it, which intensified rather than relaxed moral effort.

    Correct. Geneva's consistory of pastors and lay elders supervised belief and conduct closely, and the same disciplinary model traveled with Calvinism to France, Scotland, and the Netherlands.

    Calvin's Geneva executed Servetus for heresy in 1553 and tolerated little dissent. Pluralism was not the doctrine's practical result.

    Calvinism built strong church government through consistories and synods. Rejection of church structures was an Anabaptist rather than a Calvinist position.

  4. Which best describes the work of the Council of Trent (1545–1563)?

    Trent explicitly rejected justification by faith alone, holding that faith and works are both necessary. No doctrinal concession was made.

    Correct. Trent combined doctrinal firmness with genuine institutional reform: banning the sale of offices, requiring bishops to reside in their dioceses, and mandating a seminary in every diocese.

    Trent affirmed the authority of the Latin Vulgate and retained the Latin liturgy. Vernacular worship was a Protestant position.

    Protestants did not participate meaningfully, and Trent's decrees closed off compromise by defining the disputed doctrines against them.

  5. Description of: the Edict of Nantes, issued by Henry IV of France, 1598.

    Grants Huguenots freedom of conscience and public worship in specified places, admits them to offices and universities, creates special chambers with Protestant judges, and allows them to garrison a number of fortified towns at royal expense for a fixed term.

    The provision for fortified towns most strongly suggests that the edict was

    Correct. A genuine grant of liberty would not need to leave one party armed; the garrisons are security guarantees between recent combatants after thirty-six years of civil war.

    Toleration was limited and geographically restricted, Protestant worship was barred in Paris, and it applied to Huguenots specifically, not to all faiths.

    Henry IV converted to Catholicism in 1593 in order to secure the throne. The edict was issued by a Catholic king.

    Louis XIV revoked it in 1685, which demonstrates that it bound no successor. It lasted only as long as the crown found it useful.

  6. France's entry into the Thirty Years' War on the side of Protestant Sweden best illustrates that

    France remained firmly Catholic and Richelieu was a cardinal. The alignment was strategic, not doctrinal.

    Correct. Richelieu judged Habsburg encirclement the greater threat to French security and subsidized, then joined, the Protestant side against fellow Catholics.

    The war began in 1618 as a confessional revolt in Bohemia and religion mattered greatly to many participants throughout. The shift was gradual, not total.

    No such agreement existed. Sweden remained Lutheran and intervened for its own Baltic interests as well as for Protestantism.

  7. Description of: the pattern of testimony in German witchcraft trial records, late sixteenth century.

    Neighbors recall a quarrel, a refused loan or denied request for food, followed by misfortune: a cow that stopped giving milk, a child that sickened. The accused is usually an older woman, often widowed and dependent on charity. Under interrogation, frequently with torture, confessions converge on a pact with the devil, a detail the accusers had not mentioned.

    The divergence between neighbors' complaints and the confessions is best explained by

    The demonic pact appears only after interrogation under torture, not in the original complaints: a pattern that points to the questioning rather than to the conduct.

    Correct. Villagers complained about harm to livestock and children; the elite theory of a satanic pact entered at the interrogation stage, showing two different mental worlds meeting in the courtroom.

    There is no evidence of concealment, and neighbors testified in detail about the harms they attributed to the accused.

    The reverse is true: magistrates and clergy held the learned demonology, drawn from texts villagers had not read.

  8. Baroque religious art of the seventeenth century was most directly shaped by

    Iconoclasm produced the opposite result: Protestant churches without religious images, which pushed Dutch painters toward secular genres.

    Correct. Trent made persuasion the purpose of sacred art, and Bernini, Rubens, and Caravaggio supplied drama, theatrical light, and emotion at its peak to serve it.

    That describes Renaissance classicism or later Neoclassicism. Baroque works through movement, diagonals, and intensity rather than restraint.

    Dutch private patronage produced portraits, landscapes, and still life: the contrasting Protestant market, not Baroque altarpieces.

  9. Source: Ignatius Loyola, "Rules for Thinking with the Church," in the Spiritual Exercises.

    "That we may be altogether of the same mind and in conformity with the Church herself, if she shall have defined anything to be black which to our eyes appears to be white, we ought in like manner to pronounce it to be black."

    The passage is best understood as a direct response to which Protestant claim?

    Justification is a doctrinal dispute Trent addressed elsewhere. This rule concerns authority, who decides, rather than how salvation works.

    Correct. Where Protestants made the believer with scripture the judge of truth, Loyola makes submission to the institution the test of genuine faith, even against one's own perception.

    Clerical marriage was a real point of difference but is not what this rule about obedience in judgment addresses.

    Eucharistic theology divided Protestants among themselves as well as from Rome, but the passage concerns obedience in general, not one sacrament.

  10. The Peace of Westphalia (1648) is significant for European politics primarily because it

    Westphalia extended Augsburg's principle to Calvinism, but the choice still belonged to rulers rather than to individuals.

    Correct. Sovereign states recognizing no superior, settling disputes among themselves, became the organizing principle of European politics for the next century and a half.

    The opposite occurred: the settlement confirmed the independence of the German princes and left the empire more fragmented than before.

    Papal authority was reduced, and Pope Innocent X denounced the treaty for exactly that reason.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way the Protestant Reformation changed the relationship between religious and political authority in the period 1517–1600.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the Catholic Church responded to the Protestant challenge.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way religious division contributed to warfare in Europe in the period 1550–1648.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: rulers gained control over churches in their territories, formalized by the Peace of Augsburg's cuius regio, eius religio; Henry VIII's Act of Supremacy made the monarch head of the English church; princes seized monastic lands. Do not accept: "people became Protestant" with no reference to authority.
    • (b) Accept: the Council of Trent reaffirming doctrine and requiring seminaries and resident bishops; the Jesuits as educators and missionaries recovering territory; the Roman Inquisition and the Index. Must explain how it responded to the challenge.
    • (c) Accept: the French Wars of Religion and St. Bartholomew's Day; the Dutch Revolt against Philip II; the Spanish Armada; the Thirty Years' War beginning as a Bohemian Protestant revolt against Habsburg authority. Credit answers noting that political motives increasingly mixed with or overtook religious ones, provided a religious dimension is explained.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The Reformation transferred control of the church to secular rulers. The Peace of Augsburg in 1555 established that each German prince would decide whether his territory was Lutheran or Catholic, making religious allegiance a matter of territorial politics rather than of a single universal church.

    (b) The Council of Trent required every diocese to establish a seminary, producing clergy trained in doctrine and able to preach. This addressed the clerical ignorance Protestants had criticized and gave the church parish priests capable of arguing its case, which helped it hold and in places recover territory.

    (c) Confessional division turned political disputes into wars of annihilation. In France, conflict between the Catholic crown and party and the Calvinist Huguenot nobility produced thirty-six years of civil war from 1562, including the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre of 1572, because neither side could accept the other's worship within one kingdom.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE characteristic of European society in the sixteenth century that contributed to the witch hunts.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason witchcraft prosecutions varied significantly between European regions.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way confessional competition affected everyday life in the period 1550–1650.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: village dependence on neighborly charity, which made refusal and resentment dangerous; the vulnerability of older, widowed, or poor women; learned demonology treating witchcraft as a devilish pact; judicial use of torture; economic and subsistence stress. Do not accept: "people were superstitious" alone.
    • (b) Accept: strength of central judicial review, the Parlement of Paris regularly overturned local convictions while small jurisdictions in the fragmented Holy Roman Empire faced little oversight; differences in the use of torture; intensity of confessional competition. Must give an institutional or comparative explanation.
    • (c) Accept: church and civil authorities regulating festivals, carnival, and popular religion; prosecution of sexual conduct and drunkenness; compulsory catechism; poor laws distinguishing deserving from undeserving poor; confessional schooling. Must tie to ordinary life rather than to doctrine alone.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Village life depended heavily on informal charity between neighbors, and older widowed women without households of their own relied on it. When such a woman was refused help and misfortune followed, suspicion attached to her easily, which is why the great majority of the accused were poor, older, and female.

    (b) Prosecutions were far more common where central judicial review was weak. In the fragmented Holy Roman Empire, small local courts could use torture and execute with almost no oversight, while in France the Parlement of Paris reviewed and frequently overturned local witchcraft convictions, sharply limiting executions there.

    (c) Both Protestant and Catholic authorities set out to discipline popular behavior. They regulated or suppressed carnival and local festivals they considered superstitious, prosecuted fornication and drunkenness in church courts, and required parishioners to learn a catechism, so confessional competition reached directly into ordinary recreation and family life.

Lesson 3.1 · Unit 3 · CED topics 3.1 and 3.2

England: Civil War and the Glorious Revolution

Between 1648 and 1815 European states found two very different ways to organize power. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which different forms of political power developed. Learning Objective B asks about the causes and consequences of the English Civil War. The CED's lead idea is that monarchs seeking more power faced challenges from nobles who wanted to keep traditional shared governance and regional autonomy, and from minority local and regional identities that resisted the dominant national group. England is the most famous case in which the challengers won.

Required content · 3A, 3B

Learning objectives.

  • 3A. Explain the context in which different forms of political power developed from 1648 to 1815.
  • 3B. Explain the causes and consequences of the English Civil War.

Historical developments.

  • 1.5.III.B. Monarchies seeking enhanced power faced challenges from nobles who wished to retain traditional forms of shared governance and regional autonomy.
  • 1.5.III.C. Within states, minority local and regional identities based on language and culture led to resistance against the dominant national group.
  • 1.5.III.A. The English Civil War, a conflict among the monarchy, Parliament, and other elites over their respective roles in the political structure, exemplified the competition for power among monarchs and competing groups.
  • 2.1.II.A. The outcome of the English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution protected the rights of gentry and aristocracy from absolutism through assertions of the rights of Parliament.

The context: sovereignty and its challengers

After Westphalia, states claimed to be sovereign, the highest authority in their territory. Monarchs wanted to use that claim to gather money and armies. They met resistance of two kinds.

  • Competition with nobles. In France, Louis XIII's minister Cardinal Richelieu broke noble power in the 1620s and 1630s, but during Louis XIV's childhood the nobles and the high courts rose in the Fronde (1648 to 1653), a civil war that the crown eventually won. In Spain, the Catalan Revolt of 1640 resisted royal taxes and centralization.
  • Minority regional identities. Within states, groups with their own language and culture resisted the dominant nation: the Celtic regions of Scotland, Ireland, and Brittany; the Dutch against Spanish rule; and the Czech lands, where the memory of Jan Hus and the Defenestration of Prague of 1618 kept a separate identity alive in the Holy Roman Empire.

The outcomes varied, which is why the unit contrasts two paths, absolutism and constitutionalism.

The Stuarts and Parliament

When Elizabeth I died childless in 1603, her cousin James VI of Scotland became James I of England, joining the crowns. James held a strong belief in the divine right of kings, the claim that monarchs rule by God's authority and answer to God alone. His son Charles I (1625 to 1649) clashed with Parliament over three issues.

  • Money. English kings could not impose taxes without Parliament's consent. Charles tried to raise funds by forced loans and "ship money." Parliament answered with the Petition of Right (1628). From 1629 to 1640 he ruled without calling Parliament.
  • Religion. Archbishop William Laud's high-church reforms offended Puritans, who wanted a simpler, more Calvinist church. When Charles tried to impose a prayer book on Presbyterian Scotland, the Scots rebelled, and he had to call Parliament to pay for the army.
  • Power. The Long Parliament (1640) limited the king and attacked his advisers. When Charles tried to arrest its leaders in 1642, civil war began.

The war and the Commonwealth

The English Civil War (1642 to 1651, in several stages) was a conflict among the monarchy, Parliament, and other elites over their respective roles. Royalists (Cavaliers) fought Parliamentarians (Roundheads). Parliament won, aided by Scottish allies and by the disciplined New Model Army and its general Oliver Cromwell. In 1649 Charles I was tried and executed. England became a republic, the Commonwealth, and from 1653 Cromwell ruled as Lord Protector, in effect a military dictator. He also conquered Ireland and Scotland.

Cromwell's death (1658) and the unpopularity of military rule led to the Restoration of Charles II in 1660, with Parliament and the established church back in place. Thomas Hobbes had defended strong government in his Leviathan (1651), arguing that people need a powerful sovereign to escape the war of all against all.

The Glorious Revolution (1688 to 1689)

Charles's brother James II (1685 to 1688) was a Catholic who appointed Catholics to office and kept a standing army, and when he had a son, Protestants feared a Catholic dynasty. Leading nobles invited James's Protestant daughter Mary and her husband William of Orange, ruler of the Dutch Republic, to take the crown. William landed in 1688 and James fled with almost no bloodshed, which is why it was called glorious.

Parliament offered the crown to William and Mary on conditions, expressed in the English Bill of Rights (1689):

  • The king could not suspend laws or levy taxes without Parliament's consent.
  • Parliament had to meet regularly and elections and debates were to be free.
  • Subjects had the right to petition, and cruel punishments and excessive bail were forbidden.
  • A Protestant had to hold the throne, and a Toleration Act (1689) gave Protestant dissenters freedom of worship.

The outcome of the Civil War and the Glorious Revolution protected the rights of gentry and aristocracy from absolutism by asserting the rights of Parliament. England became a constitutional monarchy: parliamentary sovereignty, not the king's will, was the final authority. John Locke defended the settlement in his Two Treatises of Government (1689 to 1690), arguing that governments rest on the consent of the governed (Lesson 4.2).

1603 James I takes the throne 1628 Petition of Right 1642 Civil war begins 1649 Charles I executed 1660 Restoration of Charles II 1688 Glorious Revolution 1689 Bill of Rights, Toleration Act
Figure 3.1. England's struggle over power. Disputes over money and religion led to war and the execution of a king, and the settlement of 1688 and 1689 made Parliament the center of political authority.
Primary source · The rights of Parliament

English Bill of Rights (1689), excerpt.

That the pretended power of suspending of laws or the execution of laws by regal authority without consent of Parliament is illegal.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Bill of Rights is a statute passed by Parliament, which is also the party that gained from it, so its point of view is that of the political nation of gentry and aristocracy. Its purpose was to state the limits on the crown that William and Mary had to accept and to justify the removal of James II. The audience was the king, the public, and later generations as a constitutional precedent. It shows what Parliament claimed, but not the views of the poor, Catholics, or those who did not vote.

Source analysis · A limit on the crown

Claim. The Bill of Rights placed the power to suspend laws under Parliament's control.

Evidence. It declares the king's "pretended power of suspending of laws" without Parliament's consent illegal.

Reasoning. The sentence rejects the kind of royal claim made by James II and the Stuarts, and it shows the move toward parliamentary sovereignty, which protected the property and privileges of the gentry and aristocracy. A limit is that it was written by and for the political elite, so it does not show that all English people gained rights.

Worked example · Causes and consequences

Question. Explain one cause and one consequence of the English Civil War.

Model. One cause was the dispute over taxation and religion between Charles I and Parliament: Charles raised money without Parliament's consent and supported Laud's church policies that Puritans opposed. One consequence was that the war ended in the execution of the king and, after the Restoration and the Glorious Revolution, in the assertion of the rights of Parliament that protected the gentry and aristocracy from absolutism.

Exam focus

Learning Objective B asks for causes and consequences. Causes: money, religion, and the struggle for power between crown and Parliament. Consequences: the execution of the king, the Commonwealth, the Restoration, and, in the end, the Glorious Revolution and parliamentary sovereignty. The CED frames the outcome as protection of gentry and aristocracy from absolutism, not democracy. Compare with France in Lesson 3.5 and the comparison lesson that closes the unit.

Practice
  1. What was the main dispute between Charles I and Parliament?
    Show answer

    Taxes without consent, religion (Puritans against Laud's church policy), and who held final power in the state.

  2. Who won the English Civil War, and what happened to Charles I?
    Show answer

    Parliament's forces, led by the New Model Army, won, and Charles I was tried and executed in 1649.

  3. What was the Glorious Revolution?
    Show answer

    The 1688 removal of James II, a Catholic king, and the offer of the crown to William and Mary on terms set by Parliament, with almost no bloodshed.

  4. Name two limits on the monarch in the English Bill of Rights.
    Show answer

    The king could not suspend laws or raise taxes without Parliament's consent, and Parliament had to meet regularly and debate freely.

  5. How did the Fronde or the Catalan Revolt show the challenges monarchs faced?
    Show answer

    Nobles and regional leaders resisted royal taxes and centralization, showing competition between monarchs and traditional elites.

  6. Why is it accurate to call England's settlement constitutionalism but not democracy?
    Show answer

    It limited the monarch and made Parliament sovereign, but Parliament represented only the gentry and aristocracy, not the whole population.

Lesson 3.2 · Unit 3 · CED topics 3.3 and 3.4

Economic change and mercantilism

The seventeenth and eighteenth centuries saw steady economic growth, still within an agricultural world. Learning Objective C asks you to explain the continuities and changes in commercial and economic developments from 1648 to 1815. The CED puts the changes in two groups: the Agricultural Revolution and the market economy within Europe, and mercantilism and the overseas trade that fed it. In both, you should track what changed and what did not.

Required content · 3C

Learning objective.

  • 3C. Explain the continuities and changes in commercial and economic developments from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.2.I.B. The Agricultural Revolution raised productivity and increased the supply of food and other agricultural products.
  • 2.2.II.D. The importation and transplantation of agricultural products from the Americas contributed to an increase in the food supply in Europe.
  • 2.2.I.A. Labor and trade in commodities were increasingly freed from traditional restrictions imposed by governments and corporate entities.
  • 2.2.I.C. The putting-out system, or cottage industry, expanded as increasing numbers of laborers in homes or workshops produced for markets through merchant intermediaries or workshop owners.
  • 2.2.I.D. The development of the market economy led to new financial practices and institutions.
  • 2.2.II.A. European states followed mercantilist policies by drawing resources from colonies in the New World and elsewhere.
  • 2.2.II.B. The transatlantic slave-labor system expanded in the 17th and 18th centuries as demand for New World products increased.
  • 2.2.II.C. Overseas products and influences contributed to the development of a consumer culture in Europe.
  • 2.2.II.E. Foreign lands provided raw materials, finished goods, laborers, and markets for the commercial and industrial enterprises in Europe.

The Agricultural Revolution

By the eighteenth century, especially in the Netherlands and Britain, farmers raised productivity and increased the supply of food and other agricultural products.

  • New methods. Crop rotation that added clover and turnips (the Norfolk system) fed livestock through the winter and restored the soil, replacing the old fallow year. Selective breeding produced bigger animals, and tools such as Jethro Tull's seed drill (1701) improved planting.
  • Enclosure. Landowners combined scattered strips and common land into enclosed fields farmed for profit. Output rose, but many small farmers lost access to the commons and became wage laborers.
  • Imported crops. The importation and transplantation of agricultural products from the Americas, notably the potato and maize, contributed to an increase in the food supply.

More food supported population growth (see Lesson 4.3) and allowed fewer workers to feed more people, a shift that later helped industrialization.

The market economy

The CED notes that labor and trade in commodities were increasingly freed from traditional restrictions imposed by governments and corporate entities such as guilds. Old rules on prices, wages, and who could make what were loosened, especially in Britain and the Netherlands.

  • The putting-out system (cottage industry) expanded. A merchant gave raw materials, such as wool or flax, to rural families, who spun and wove in their homes and were paid by the piece. It escaped guild rules and employed many women and children, though the workers had little bargaining power.
  • New financial practices and institutions. Insurance spread, especially marine insurance in London (Lloyd's coffeehouse). Banks turned private savings into venture capital, and the Bank of England (1694) lent to the government and managed public debt. Laws gave clearer property rights and protection against confiscation, which encouraged investment. Stock exchanges in Amsterdam and London traded shares in companies.

Mercantilism

Mercantilism was the dominant economic policy. Its assumptions: wealth is limited, a nation gains by exporting more than it imports, and colonies exist to supply the mother country with raw materials and to buy its manufactured goods. States followed mercantilist policies by drawing resources from colonies in the New World and elsewhere.

  • France: Louis XIV's finance minister Jean-Baptiste Colbert built state-supported industries, protective tariffs, and a navy and merchant fleet.
  • England: The Navigation Acts (from 1651) required that colonial goods travel in English ships and be sent through English ports.
  • Colonies as suppliers. Foreign lands provided raw materials, finished goods, laborers, and markets for the commercial and industrial enterprises in Europe.

The slave-labor system and consumer culture

The CED stresses that the transatlantic slave-labor system expanded in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries as demand for New World products increased (Lesson 1.7). Sugar, tobacco, and rum produced profits for planters and merchants, and the triangular trade linked Europe, Africa, and the Americas.

These overseas products also contributed to a consumer culture in Europe. Sugar, tea, coffee, chocolate, tobacco, rum, and Asian silks and porcelain became part of daily life for the middle classes and many of the poor. Coffeehouses, which sold coffee and provided newspapers, became centers of conversation and business.

Mother country manufactures and exports Colonies raw materials, plantations finished goods; market sugar, tobacco, raw materials Enslaved Africans Mercantilist flow of goods Navigation Acts require trade in English ships
Figure 3.2. Mercantilism in practice. Colonies supplied raw materials and a protected market to the mother country, and the slave-labor system supplied plantation workers.
Primary source · The Navigation Act

Description of: The English Navigation Act (1651), passed by the Commonwealth Parliament. It requires that goods imported into England and its colonies from Asia, Africa, and America be carried in English-owned ships with mostly English crews, and that European goods come directly from their place of origin or in English ships.

Sourcing (HIPP). The act is a law, which reveals policy more than belief. The purpose was to build English shipping and to take trade away from the Dutch, who then carried most of Europe's freight. It was a cause of the Anglo-Dutch wars. The audience was merchants, shipowners, and colonial officials. The act shows how mercantilist thinking guided states, but its effects on colonists, who had to buy and sell on English terms, are not part of the text itself.

Source analysis · Policy and rivalry

Claim. The Navigation Act used state power to channel colonial trade to English benefit.

Evidence. It requires goods to travel in English ships and from their place of origin to English ports.

Reasoning. The rules build English shipping and cut out Dutch middlemen, which matches the mercantilist goal of a favorable balance of trade. The result was war with the Dutch, which shows that economic policy was also a way of competing among states. A law shows intent, not how effectively it was enforced.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in European economic life between 1648 and 1815.

Model. One continuity was that most Europeans still worked in agriculture and lived near subsistence, and governments continued mercantilist policies that drew wealth from colonies. One change was the development of market institutions: the putting-out system expanded, and new financial institutions such as the Bank of England and insurance companies supported investment and trade.

Exam focus

Learning Objective C is a continuity-and-change objective, so sort your evidence. Changes: higher agricultural productivity, the freeing of labor and trade, the putting-out system, new finance (the Bank of England, insurance), consumer culture. Continuities: agriculture remained the main occupation, mercantilist policy, and, in the Atlantic world, an expanding slave system. Keep in mind that the slave-labor system is part of the economic story, not a separate subject.

Practice
  1. Name two ways farming became more productive in the eighteenth century.
    Show answer

    New crop rotations with clover and turnips, selective breeding, new tools such as the seed drill, and enclosure.

  2. What was the putting-out system?
    Show answer

    Merchants supplied raw materials to rural households who worked at home and were paid by the piece, a cottage industry outside guild rules.

  3. Give one new financial institution or practice of the period.
    Show answer

    The Bank of England, insurance (as at Lloyd's), banking that turned savings into capital, or stock exchanges.

  4. How did mercantilism treat colonies?
    Show answer

    As suppliers of raw materials and markets for finished goods, to be controlled for the benefit of the mother country.

  5. How did overseas trade change daily life in Europe?
    Show answer

    It created a consumer culture around imports such as sugar, tea, coffee, tobacco, and silks, while expanding the slave economy that produced some of them.

  6. Identify one continuity in the economy from 1648 to 1815.
    Show answer

    Most people still worked in agriculture, and states continued mercantilist policies throughout the period.

Lesson 3.3 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.5

The Dutch Golden Age

In the seventeenth century a small, wet, Protestant republic became Europe's richest country and its financial and commercial center. Learning Objective D asks you to explain the factors that contributed to the development of the Dutch Republic. The CED's statement is that the Dutch Republic, established by a Protestant revolt against the Habsburg monarchy, developed an oligarchy of urban gentry and rural landholders to promote trade and protect traditional rights. The Dutch are the clearest example of a state that grew strong without an absolute monarch.

Required content · 3D

Learning objective.

  • 3D. Explain the factors that contributed to the development of the Dutch Republic.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.II.B. The Dutch Republic, established by a Protestant revolt against the Habsburg monarchy, developed an oligarchy of urban gentry and rural landholders to promote trade and protect traditional rights.

Origins in revolt

The seven northern provinces of the Netherlands rebelled against Philip II of Spain from 1566, resisting heavy taxes, the loss of local privileges, and the persecution of Calvinists (Lesson 2.3). They declared independence in 1581 and fought on until Spain recognized them in 1648. The leaders of the revolt, among them William of Orange ("the Silent"), were city magistrates, nobles, and merchants who had defended traditional rights against a distant king.

An oligarchy, not a monarchy

The new state was a republic, formally the United Provinces.

  • Provincial power. Each province kept its own assembly and customs. The States General met to handle common matters such as war and foreign policy, but it had little power to compel the provinces.
  • Regents. In practice, the leading merchant and landholding families, called regents, controlled the town councils and provincial assemblies. This oligarchy of urban gentry and rural landholders governed to promote trade and to protect their own rights.
  • The stadtholder. The House of Orange held the office of stadtholder, a military and executive leader, which royalists and the common people supported. Rivalry between the regents and the Orange family was a constant political theme.

The Dutch therefore had shared governance and strong local autonomy. They show that political power could be organized without an absolute king and without England's national parliament.

Sources of prosperity

  • Trade. Dutch ships carried the Baltic grain, timber, and fish, and the products of the colonies, across Europe. Cheap, efficient fluyt cargo ships gave them an edge in freight costs. The Dutch East India Company (1602) dominated the spice trade, and Dutch merchants also traded in the Atlantic and in slave labor.
  • Finance. Amsterdam became Europe's financial center. The Bank of Amsterdam (1609) provided a stable currency, and the exchange traded shares and futures. A famous speculative bubble, tulip mania (1636 to 1637), shows how developed the market had become.
  • Agriculture and industry. Drained land (polders), intensive farming, and specialized industries such as textiles, shipbuilding, and printing supported a high urban population.
  • Toleration. The Calvinist church was privileged, but the republic tolerated Catholics, Jews, and other Protestants in practice, partly because merchants valued trade over conformity. Skilled refugees, such as French Huguenots and Sephardic Jews, brought money and skills.

Culture and limits

The wealth of Dutch merchants supported a distinctive culture. Painters such as Rembrandt and Jan Vermeer sold portraits, landscapes, and scenes of everyday life to a bourgeois market, and scholars such as Hugo Grotius wrote influential works on international law and the freedom of the seas.

The republic's Golden Age was brief. Competition from England (the Navigation Acts and three Anglo-Dutch wars between 1652 and 1674) and the invasion by Louis XIV in 1672 strained its resources. The small population could not match larger states, and by the eighteenth century Dutch commercial leadership passed to Britain, though Amsterdam remained a financial center.

Primary source · The freedom of the seas

Description of: Hugo Grotius, Mare Liberum (The Free Sea, 1609), a Latin treatise written for the Dutch East India Company. Grotius argues that the sea is common to all nations and cannot be owned, so that the Portuguese had no right to bar the Dutch from trading in the East Indies.

Sourcing (HIPP). Grotius, a Dutch lawyer, wrote it at the request of the Company, so the purpose was to defend Dutch commercial interests against the Portuguese claim to a monopoly. The historical situation was the Dutch challenge to Portuguese power in Asia. The audience included European rulers and jurists. The argument became a cornerstone of international law, but it was also self-serving: the Dutch used force to dominate trade in the spice islands and later defended their own monopolies.

Source analysis · Principle and interest

Claim. Grotius argues that the sea is open to all nations for trade.

Evidence. He contends the sea cannot be owned and that Portugal has no right to exclude Dutch ships.

Reasoning. The argument supports the commercial interests of a state governed by merchants, which fits the CED's picture of an oligarchy that promoted trade. Because the Company commissioned it, the principle serves Dutch interests, and the Dutch themselves acted as monopolists where they could, so the claim should not be taken as a universal rule they always followed.

Worked example · Factors in development

Question. Explain one factor that contributed to the development of the Dutch Republic.

Model. One factor was the political system of rule by merchant and landholding oligarchs who protected traditional rights and promoted trade: town regents made policy that favored shipping, finance, and toleration of skilled immigrants, which helped Amsterdam become Europe's commercial center. Another factor was the Protestant revolt against Habsburg rule, which created a state organized around local rights.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective D name several factors and link each to the republic's success: the revolt (origin), the oligarchic, decentralized political system (shared governance protecting trade), commerce and finance (VOC, Bank of Amsterdam, fluyt), and toleration (skilled migrants). Be ready to compare this with absolutism and with England: the Dutch Republic had no king and no national parliament with the English balance, and its rulers were a narrow elite.

Practice
  1. What event created the Dutch Republic?
    Show answer

    A Protestant revolt against Habsburg Spain, begun in 1566, with independence declared in 1581 and recognized in 1648.

  2. Who governed the Dutch Republic in practice?
    Show answer

    An oligarchy of merchant and landholding regent families who controlled the town councils and provincial assemblies.

  3. Name two sources of Dutch commercial strength.
    Show answer

    The fluyt cargo ship, the Dutch East India Company, Amsterdam's banks and exchange, or control of Baltic and colonial trade.

  4. How did toleration help the Dutch economy?
    Show answer

    It attracted skilled and wealthy migrants such as Huguenots and Jews and let merchants trade across religious lines.

  5. Why did Dutch power decline after the seventeenth century?
    Show answer

    Competition from England, wars with England and France, and the republic's small population and resources limited it.

  6. How was Dutch government different from absolutism?
    Show answer

    Power was shared among provinces and regent families with no single ruler, and the rulers protected traditional rights.

Lesson 3.4 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.6

The balance of power and the military revolution

After 1648, European states fought over territory, trade, and dynastic claims more than over religion. Learning Objective E asks how European states attempted to establish and maintain a balance of power between 1648 and 1815, and Learning Objective F asks how advances in technology contributed to it. The CED's main points are that, after Westphalia, religion declined as a cause of war and the concept of the balance of power structured diplomacy; that several states rose or fell; and that new military techniques, the military revolution, favored states that could raise the resources.

Required content · 3E, 3F

Learning objectives.

  • 3E. Explain how European states attempted to establish and maintain a balance of power on the continent throughout the period from 1648 to 1815.
  • 3F. Explain how advances in technology contributed to a developing balance of power on the continent throughout the period from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 1.5.II.A. Following the Peace of Westphalia, religion declined in importance as a cause for warfare among European states; the concept of the balance of power played an important role in structuring diplomatic and military objectives.
  • 2.1.I.D. The inability of the Polish monarchy to consolidate its authority over the nobility led to Poland’s partition by Prussia, Russia, and Austria, and its disappearance from the map of Europe.
  • 2.1.III.B. After the Austrian defeat of the Turks in 1683 at the Battle of Vienna, the Ottomans ceased their westward expansion.
  • 2.1.III.C. Louis XIV’s nearly continuous wars, pursuing both dynastic and state interests, provoked a coalition of European powers opposing him.
  • 1.5.II.B. Advances in military technology led to new forms of warfare, including greater reliance on infantry, firearms, mobile cannon, and more elaborate fortifications, all financed by heavier taxation and requiring a larger bureaucracy. New military techniques and institutions (i.e., the military revolution) tipped the balance of power toward states able to marshal sufficient resources for the new military environment.

The idea of the balance of power

A balance of power means that states aim to prevent any single power from becoming strong enough to dominate the others. When one state grew threatening, the others formed a coalition against it. The principle replaced the medieval dream of a united Christendom (Lesson 2.3) with a system of sovereign states that dealt with each other on the basis of power and interest.

Louis XIV and the coalitions

Louis XIV's France was the strongest state in Europe, and the CED says his nearly continuous wars, pursuing both dynastic and state interests, provoked a coalition of powers against him.

  • The Dutch War (1672 to 1678) tried to crush the Dutch Republic, and the Dutch with allies resisted.
  • The Nine Years' War (1688 to 1697) pitted France against a coalition including England (under William III), the Dutch, and the Habsburgs.
  • The War of the Spanish Succession (1701 to 1714) began when the last Spanish Habsburg died childless and Louis's grandson Philip claimed the throne. Other states feared a union of France and Spain, so they fought to prevent it. The Peace of Utrecht (1713) recognized Philip as king of Spain on the condition that the French and Spanish crowns never be united, gave Britain Gibraltar, Minorca, and territories in North America, and gave Austria the Spanish Netherlands, Milan, and Naples. It is the classic example of a balance-of-power settlement.

Winners and losers

  • Britain emerged as a major sea power and began to supplant France; its role is covered in Unit 5.
  • Austria, after the Ottoman defeat at Vienna (1683), pushed east. The CED says that after the Austrian defeat of the Turks in 1683 the Ottomans ceased their westward expansion, and the Habsburgs shifted their empire eastward.
  • Sweden under Gustavus Adolphus had been a power in the Thirty Years' War and a Baltic power until Peter the Great's Russia defeated it in the Great Northern War (1700 to 1721).
  • Spain, once dominant, declined.
  • Poland lost out entirely. The CED explains that the Polish monarchy was unable to consolidate its authority over the nobility, who elected the king and used the liberum veto to block any decision. Prussia, Russia, and Austria partitioned Poland in 1772, 1793, and 1795, and it disappeared from the map until 1918.

The military revolution

The CED describes advances in military technology that led to new forms of warfare, including greater reliance on infantry, firearms, mobile cannon, and more elaborate fortifications. Armies grew from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands, with uniforms, drill, and standing armies. Fortresses designed by engineers such as Louis XIV's Vauban could withstand cannon fire, so wars turned into long sieges.

These changes were financed by heavier taxation and required a larger bureaucracy. States that could raise money and organize officials, such as France, Sweden, Prussia, and Britain, gained advantage, and the CED concludes that the military revolution tipped the balance of power toward states able to marshal sufficient resources. That link between war, taxation, and state building helps explain absolutism, which you study next.

France Louis XIV; largest army in Europe threatens balances Coalition against France Britain Dutch Republic Austria (Habsburgs) Result: the Peace of Utrecht (1713)
Figure 3.3. The balance of power. When France threatened to dominate, rival states formed coalitions, and the Peace of Utrecht redistributed territory to restore a balance.
Primary source · Preventing a union

Description of: The Treaty of Utrecht (1713), the settlement ending the War of the Spanish Succession. Philip V is confirmed as king of Spain, but the treaty requires that the crowns of France and Spain never be united on one head, and it transfers territories among the powers, including Gibraltar to Britain and the Spanish Netherlands to Austria.

Sourcing (HIPP). A treaty is a negotiated document that reflects the interests of the powers that signed it, mainly Britain, France, the Dutch, and Austria; Spain's own leaders and the peoples of the transferred territories did not have a say. Its purpose was to end the war and to prevent any one power from dominating Europe. It shows balance-of-power thinking in practice, but it is a statement of agreement, not evidence about how well each side kept it.

Source analysis · A balance-of-power settlement

Claim. The treaty tried to prevent French domination of Europe.

Evidence. It forbids the union of the French and Spanish crowns and redistributes territory among Britain, Austria, and others.

Reasoning. Instead of destroying France, the powers allowed Louis's grandson to rule Spain but divided other possessions, which restored a balance. This fits the CED's description of states using diplomacy and war to keep a balance after Westphalia. The treaty reflects what the winners wanted, so it should be read with attention to who negotiated it.

Worked example · Technology and power

Question. Explain one way military technology affected the balance of power between 1648 and 1815.

Model. New forms of warfare based on firearms, infantry, mobile cannon, and elaborate fortifications required large armies that states had to pay for with heavy taxes and a large bureaucracy. Because only states that could raise those resources could compete, the military revolution tipped the balance of power toward richer, better-organized states such as France and later Prussia, and against weaker ones such as Poland.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives E and F have two parts: diplomacy (the balance of power, coalitions, the Peace of Utrecht) and technology (the military revolution and its costs). Link them: new weapons raised costs, so states needed more tax and bureaucracy, and the states that could do so rose. Be ready to explain why Poland vanished, why Louis XIV provoked coalitions, and why religion declined as a cause of war.

Practice
  1. Define the balance of power.
    Show answer

    A system in which states act to stop any single power from becoming dominant, often by forming coalitions against a threatening state.

  2. Why did Louis XIV's wars provoke coalitions?
    Show answer

    He pursued dynastic and state goals through nearly continuous war, which threatened to give France dominance, so other powers allied to oppose him.

  3. What did the Peace of Utrecht do?
    Show answer

    It ended the War of the Spanish Succession, recognizing Philip V in Spain on condition that France and Spain never unite, and it redistributed territory to Britain, Austria, and others.

  4. Why did Poland disappear?
    Show answer

    The Polish monarchy could not control the nobility, who elected the king and blocked decisions, so neighbors Prussia, Russia, and Austria partitioned it in 1772, 1793, and 1795.

  5. What changes made up the military revolution?
    Show answer

    Greater reliance on infantry and firearms, mobile cannon, elaborate fortifications, and larger standing armies.

  6. How did the military revolution encourage the growth of bureaucracies?
    Show answer

    Large armies were expensive, so states needed heavier taxation and more officials to collect and manage money.

Lesson 3.5 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.7

France under Louis XIV: the model of absolutism

France in the seventeenth century became the model of absolutism, a form of monarchy in which the ruler claims supreme authority and does not share power with a representative assembly or the nobility. Learning Objective G asks how absolutist forms of rule affected social and political development between 1648 and 1815. This lesson uses the CED's two statements about France: absolute monarchies limited the nobility's participation in governance but preserved their social position and legal privileges, and Louis XIV and his finance minister Colbert extended the administrative, financial, military, and religious control of the central state over the population.

Required content · 3G

Learning objective.

  • 3G. Explain how absolutist forms of rule affected social and political development from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.I.A. Absolute monarchies limited the nobility’s participation in governance but preserved the aristocracy’s social position and legal privileges.
  • 2.1.I.B. Louis XIV and his finance minister, Jean-Baptiste Colbert, extended the administrative, financial, military, and religious control of the central state over the French population.

The Sun King's rise

Louis XIV became king in 1643 at age four. During his childhood, Cardinal Mazarin governed, and the nobles and the high court of Paris rebelled in the Fronde (1648 to 1653). The humiliation of fleeing Paris as a boy shaped Louis's determination to keep the nobility under control. When Mazarin died in 1661, Louis announced that he would rule personally and would have no first minister. He reigned until 1715, the longest reign in European history.

Divine right and the theory of absolutism

Louis's government rested on the idea of divine right: the king receives power from God and answers only to God. The bishop Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet defended this idea with arguments from scripture. The king was also the source of law, and his motto, Nec pluribus impar ("not unequal to many"), and his emblem of the sun expressed his claim to be the center of the state. The famous phrase "I am the state" (L'état, c'est moi) is almost certainly a later invention, but it expresses what contemporaries thought.

Extending the power of the state

The CED identifies four areas of control.

  • Administrative. Louis governed through royal councils and intendants, officials sent to the provinces who answered to him and collected taxes, supervised justice, and enforced his orders. They replaced local nobles and old assemblies. The Estates General did not meet from 1614 until 1789.
  • Financial. Jean-Baptiste Colbert, the controller general of finances, practiced mercantilism: he built state-supported manufactures such as luxury textiles, tariffs on foreign goods, trading companies, and a navy (Lesson 3.2). Taxes, and the sale of offices, funded the state, but the burden fell mostly on peasants, since the nobility and clergy had major exemptions.
  • Military. The marquis de Louvois and Vauban modernized the army into a large, disciplined, royal force. Louis's army was probably the largest in Europe, and the crown now claimed a monopoly of armed force.
  • Religious. Louis insisted on one religion. In 1685 he revoked the Edict of Nantes (the Edict of Fontainebleau), outlawing Protestant worship. Hundreds of thousands of Huguenots fled, taking skills and capital to England, the Dutch Republic, and Brandenburg-Prussia, which hurt France economically. Louis also controlled the French church's appointments and defended its independence from the pope.

Versailles and the nobility

The CED says that absolute monarchs limited the nobility's participation in governance but preserved the aristocracy's social position and legal privileges. Louis's palace at Versailles, where the court was based from 1682, shows the bargain. Nobles were drawn to the palace and given ceremonial roles, pensions, and favors, while they lost real power in the provinces. Their privileges, such as exemption from many taxes and their high social rank, were kept, and the king relied on aristocratic officers and on wealthy officeholders of the "nobility of the robe." The nobles' loyalty was bought, and the king was kept in view of his rivals.

1643 Louis XIV becomes king 1648-53 The Fronde 1661 Personal rule begins; Colbert 1682 Court moves to Versailles 1685 Edict of Nantes revoked 1701-14 War of the Spanish Succession 1715 Louis XIV dies
Figure 3.4. Louis XIV's reign. A childhood rebellion shaped a personal rule that centralized power, expanded the army, and led to wars that drained the treasury.

Costs and legacy

Louis's wars (Lesson 3.4) left France deeply in debt and its people weighed down by taxes. When he died in 1715 his great-grandson Louis XV inherited a state with a strong administration but weak finances. The structure of privilege and the unreformed tax system became a cause of the crisis of 1789 (Unit 5). Other monarchs studied Versailles, and they imitated its palaces, courts, and military organization.

Primary source · A theory of absolute power

Description of: Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet, Politics Drawn from the Very Words of Holy Scripture (written in the 1670s for Louis XIV's son, published 1709). Bossuet argues that royal power comes from God, that the king's person is sacred, and that subjects owe obedience even to a bad king, since God, not the people, will judge him. He adds that the king must still use his power for the good of the state.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bossuet, a bishop and the tutor of Louis XIV's son, wrote to teach the heir and to give royal power a religious justification, so his point of view supports the monarchy and his purpose is to teach and to legitimate it. The historical situation was the Fronde's memory and the crown's drive to centralize. The text shows how defenders of absolutism argued, but it describes an ideal and says little about the actual limits on royal power, such as the tax exemptions and privileges the king had to respect.

Source analysis · Divine right defended

Claim. Bossuet argues that the king's authority comes from God and should be obeyed.

Evidence. In the described passages, he says royal power is sacred, that subjects owe obedience even to a bad ruler, and that God will judge the king.

Reasoning. The argument gave Louis XIV a religious basis for ending the nobles' and courts' claims to share power, in line with the CED's account of centralization. It was written by a churchman who served the court, so it presents an ideal. It should be compared with how the crown really governed, through intendants, taxes, and a large army.

Worked example · Effects on the nobility

Question. Explain one way absolutism affected the nobility in France.

Model. Under Louis XIV the nobility lost real political power: intendants replaced local nobles in the provinces, and the king required courtiers to live at Versailles where they were occupied with ceremony and favors. But nobles kept their social position and legal privileges, including exemption from many taxes, so absolutism limited their governance without destroying their status.

Exam focus

Learning Objective G asks about effects on society and politics. Always cover both halves of the CED's formula for the nobility: limited governance, preserved privilege. Name the tools of control (intendants, Colbert's mercantilism, a large army, revocation of the Edict of Nantes, Versailles). Avoid saying Louis had unlimited power; he was constrained by privileges, finances, and the need to rely on the nobles and officeholders.

Practice
  1. What is absolutism?
    Show answer

    A form of monarchy in which the ruler claims supreme authority and does not share governing power with an assembly or the nobility.

  2. How did intendants strengthen royal power?
    Show answer

    They were officials sent to the provinces to collect taxes, enforce justice, and carry out royal orders, replacing local nobles and old institutions.

  3. What did Colbert contribute to Louis XIV's state?
    Show answer

    A mercantilist program of state-supported industries, protective tariffs, trading companies, and a navy to raise the wealth of France and the crown.

  4. What was the effect of revoking the Edict of Nantes?
    Show answer

    It outlawed Protestant worship and drove hundreds of thousands of Huguenots abroad, taking skills and capital with them and harming France economically.

  5. How did Versailles help control the nobility?
    Show answer

    Nobles lived at court, occupied with ceremony and favors, away from their provincial power bases, while keeping their privileges.

  6. Why is "I am the state" a doubtful source?
    Show answer

    The phrase is probably a later invention, so it is better evidence of how people viewed Louis than of what he said.

Lesson 3.6 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.7

Absolutism beyond France: Spain, England, and Russia

France was the model, but absolutism took different forms across Europe. Learning Objective G still asks how absolutist forms of rule affected social and political development. The CED lists as absolute monarchs James I of England, Peter the Great of Russia, and Philip II, III, and IV of Spain, and it gives one more specific statement: Peter the Great "westernized" the Russian state and society, transforming political, religious, and cultural institutions, and Catherine the Great continued this process. This lesson compares the rulers' claims and what they actually achieved.

Required content · 3G

Learning objective.

  • 3G. Explain how absolutist forms of rule affected social and political development from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.I.E. Peter the Great “westernized” the Russian state and society, transforming political, religious, and cultural institutions; Catherine the Great continued this process.

James I and divine right in England

James I (r. 1603 to 1625) wrote on the divine right of kings and told Parliament in 1610 that kings are called gods. But England had a long tradition of parliamentary consent to taxes, a strong common law, and a gentry class represented in the House of Commons. James lacked a large standing army and a bureaucracy, so he could not rule alone, and his son's attempt ended in the Civil War (Lesson 3.1). England shows absolutist claims without absolutist means.

Spain under the Habsburgs

Philip II, III, and IV ruled the largest empire in the world and made strong claims of royal authority, supported by the Inquisition and the Catholic Church. But Spain's absolutism was costly and uneven. American silver was spent on wars, and the crown went bankrupt several times. The kingdoms of Spain kept their own laws and privileges, and when the chief minister, the Count-Duke of Olivares, tried to impose taxes and centralization, Catalonia and Portugal revolted in 1640 (Lesson 3.1). By the later seventeenth century Spain was in decline, which shows the limits of absolutism when it was not matched by a productive economy.

Peter the Great and the westernization of Russia

Russia's absolutism was the most thorough. Peter I ("the Great," r. 1682 to 1725) ruled over a vast, poor, largely agricultural land with a powerful nobility and a church that had stood apart from the West. After he traveled in western Europe in 1697 to 1698, he set out to modernize.

  • Military. He built a modern army with conscription and drill and a navy. He fought the Great Northern War against Sweden (1700 to 1721), won at Poltava in 1709, and gained a Baltic coast.
  • Government. In 1721 he took the title emperor and organized a bureaucracy under the Table of Ranks (1722), which ranked officials by service rather than birth. The nobility had to serve the state.
  • Religion. He abolished the patriarchate of the Orthodox church and placed it under a council controlled by the state, the Holy Synod.
  • Culture. He founded St. Petersburg (1703) as a "window on the West," required nobles to adopt Western dress, taxed beards, set up schools, and founded the Academy of Sciences (1724).

The CED's phrase is that he transformed political, religious, and cultural institutions. The changes were imposed from above, and they strengthened the state and the nobility at the expense of peasants, who were tied more tightly to the land as serfs and bore the costs of war and new cities.

Catherine the Great

Catherine II (r. 1762 to 1796), a German princess who took the throne after her husband was overthrown, continued the process. She corresponded with Enlightenment writers and promised reforms, but she kept serfdom and relied on the nobility. After the great peasant revolt led by Pugachev (1773 to 1775) she tightened control, and in 1785 she issued a charter confirming the nobles' privileges. She expanded Russia southward to the Black Sea and westward through the partitions of Poland, making it a European great power.

The pattern

Across these cases, absolutism meant a stronger central government, a standing army, taxation, and a bureaucracy, built partly by bargains with the nobility. In each state the nobles gave up independent power but kept social privilege. Where rulers could not get these tools (England), or used wealth badly (Spain), absolutism failed or declined. Where they could (France, Russia), the state became more powerful.

Primary source · The king as a god

King James I of England, speech to Parliament (1610), excerpt.

The state of monarchy is the supremest thing upon earth; for kings are not only God's lieutenants upon earth, and sit upon God's throne, but even by God himself they are called gods.

Sourcing (HIPP). James spoke as the king to Parliament, so the speech is a statement of royal claims, made in a dispute over money and the rights of Parliament. His audience was members of the House of Lords and the House of Commons, and his purpose was to defend his authority against their claims. The speech shows how a monarch described his power, but the repeated conflicts with Parliament over taxes show that others did not accept this description.

Source analysis · Claim and reality

Claim. James I asserts that the king's power is supreme and comes from God.

Evidence. He calls monarchy "the supremest thing upon earth" and says kings are called gods.

Reasoning. The speech expresses the divine-right theory behind absolutism, but it was delivered to a Parliament that controlled taxation, and England lacked an army and bureaucracy to enforce such claims. The gap between what James claimed and what he could do helps explain the conflict that led to the Civil War.

Worked example · Westernization

Question. Explain one way Peter the Great changed Russian society and one limit on his reforms.

Model. Peter changed Russian institutions by modernizing the army, creating the Table of Ranks to tie nobles to state service, and placing the church under state control, and he introduced Western dress and education and built St. Petersburg. A limit was that the reforms were imposed from above and strengthened serfdom: peasants bore the costs of war and construction, and the nobles gained rather than lost privilege.

Exam focus

Use the CED's examples as cases for the same argument: absolutism meant central power, an army, and a bureaucracy, built by bargains with nobles. Peter and Catherine show westernization and expansion; Philip II to IV show costly empire and decline; James I shows claims without means. For Learning Objective G also remember the social effects: privilege for nobles and heavier burdens on peasants.

Practice
  1. Name two absolute monarchs listed by the CED.
    Show answer

    James I of England, Peter the Great of Russia, and Philip II, III, and IV of Spain.

  2. Why did James I's absolutist claims fail in England?
    Show answer

    He lacked a large army and bureaucracy and had to rely on a Parliament that controlled taxation, so his claims led to conflict.

  3. Describe two reforms of Peter the Great.
    Show answer

    He modernized the army and navy, introduced the Table of Ranks, put the church under state control through the Holy Synod, founded St. Petersburg, or promoted Western culture and education.

  4. How did Catherine the Great continue Peter's work?
    Show answer

    She expanded Russian territory and influence, corresponded with Enlightenment writers, and strengthened the state, while keeping serfdom and nobles' privileges.

  5. How did absolutism affect Russian peasants?
    Show answer

    They were tied more closely to the land as serfs and carried the burden of military service, taxes, and labor for new projects.

  6. Compare absolutism in Spain and in Russia in one sentence.
    Show answer

    Both rulers claimed supreme authority, but Russia's rulers used reform and expansion to build a stronger state, while Spain's costly wars and weak economy led to decline.

Lesson 3.7 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.8

Comparison: absolutism and constitutionalism

The last topic of Unit 3 practices the skill of comparison: identifying similarities and differences between developments and explaining why they matter. Learning Objective H asks you to compare the different forms of political power that developed in Europe from 1648 to 1815. You now have four main cases: France, Russia, England, and the Dutch Republic. This lesson shows how to build a comparison that earns top credit.

Required content · 3H

Learning objective.

  • 3H. Compare the different forms of political power that developed in Europe from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 1.5.III.B. Monarchies seeking enhanced power faced challenges from nobles who wished to retain traditional forms of shared governance and regional autonomy.
  • 1.5.III.C. Within states, minority local and regional identities based on language and culture led to resistance against the dominant national group.

What comparison asks of you

A weak comparison describes two things one after the other. A strong comparison does four things.

  1. Choose criteria. Decide the categories to compare, such as who held power, how the ruler raised money and an army, the role of nobles and a representative body, and the role of religion and the economy.
  2. Name similarities and differences. Include both, with evidence for each.
  3. Explain why. Link the differences to causes: geography, history, and the resources the ruler had.
  4. Judge significance. Say which similarity or difference is the most important and why.

The four cases

CriterionFranceRussiaEnglandDutch Republic
Who holds powerKing, who claims divine rightTsar or emperorKing and Parliament together after 1689Regents, provinces, and a stadtholder
Tax and armyIntendants, a large royal armyConscription, state serviceParliament controls taxes; a smaller armyMerchant oligarchs fund a navy and mercenaries
NoblesKept privilege, lost governanceBound to state service, kept serfsGentry and aristocracy share power in ParliamentLandholders and urban elites govern
Representative bodyEstates General not called after 1614NoneParliament (sovereign)Provincial assemblies and States General
Key limitDebt, privilegesSerfdom, distancePublic and Parliament's rightsSmall size, rivals

Similarities

  • Elite rule. In every case, a small elite (aristocrats, gentry, or merchant regents) governed. Neither constitutionalism nor absolutism meant rule by the people. The CED notes that the English outcome protected the rights of gentry and aristocracy, and the Dutch system was an oligarchy.
  • State building. All states used taxes, armies, and bureaucracies, and all were shaped by the military revolution and competition (Lesson 3.4).
  • Privilege. In both absolutist and constitutional states, nobles kept social privileges.

Differences

  • Source and limits of authority. In France and Russia, the monarch claimed authority from God and was limited only by custom and resources. In England after 1689, Parliament's consent was required for laws and taxes. In the Dutch Republic, power was shared among provinces and families.
  • Representation. France stopped calling the Estates General; Russia had no equivalent; England's Parliament became sovereign.
  • Religion. Louis XIV demanded one religion; the Dutch practiced practical toleration; England allowed Protestant dissenters worship after 1689 but excluded Catholics from the throne.

Explaining the differences

Historians point to several causes. England's gentry controlled tax collection and local government and refused to accept a standing army under a king, while France's crown built a bureaucracy to replace nobles. Dutch commerce and decentralization came from the revolt against Spain. Russia's size, weak middle class, and the need to defend open frontiers pushed rulers to demand state service from the nobility. In short, geography, history, and resources shaped which path a state followed.

The CED's wider framing

The CED adds a second layer: monarchs seeking enhanced power faced challenges from nobles and from minority local and regional identities. Compare how France handled the Fronde and revolts, how Spain handled Catalonia, and how Britain would later handle Scotland and Ireland. In each case the central government tried to dominate, and the outcome depended on the balance of forces.

Primary source · Two answers to disorder

Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651), chapter 13, excerpt; and John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1689), chapter 2, excerpt.

Hobbes: ...the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.

Locke: ...reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions.

Sourcing (HIPP). Both English writers lived through the Civil War era but drew opposite lessons. Hobbes wrote in 1651, during the Commonwealth, to defend a strong sovereign as the cure for the fear and violence of a state of nature, so his purpose supported absolute authority. Locke wrote after the Glorious Revolution to defend limits on the ruler and natural rights, which supported constitutionalism. Both were philosophers, not rulers, writing for educated readers, so they show ideas that shaped later debate, not exactly what governments did.

Source analysis · A pair of arguments

Claim. Hobbes and Locke gave different justifications for political power.

Evidence. Hobbes describes human life without government as "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short"; Locke says reason teaches that no one ought to harm another in life, health, liberty, or possessions.

Reasoning. For Hobbes, fear of disorder justified a powerful sovereign, which resembles the logic of absolutism. For Locke, natural rights existed before government and limited it, which fits England's constitutional settlement. A limit on the comparison is that the writers were not describing any specific state exactly, since Hobbes was not defending Louis XIV's divine right, but a sovereign created by agreement.

Worked example · A comparison

Question. Compare one way French absolutism and English constitutionalism were similar and one way they were different.

Model. They were similar in that in both states a small elite, the nobility in France and the gentry and aristocracy in England, kept its social privileges and power in society while the central state grew. They differed in the source of political authority: Louis XIV claimed divine right and governed through intendants and a royal army without a representative assembly, while after 1689 the English monarchy depended on Parliament's consent for laws and taxes.

Exam focus

A comparison answer needs a criterion, a similarity, a difference, and a because. Use comparison words (both, similarly, whereas, in contrast). Do not treat absolutism and constitutionalism as simple opposites; both protected elites and built stronger states. When asked "to what extent," judge which is the larger difference or likeness. The CED's own comparison topic uses the unit's two key ideas: monarchs against nobles, and dominant groups against minority identities.

Practice
  1. Name two criteria you could use to compare forms of government.
    Show answer

    Who holds power and how it is limited, how taxes and armies are raised, the role of nobles, the role of a representative body, and religion.

  2. Give one similarity between absolutist and constitutional states.
    Show answer

    Both were governed by elites, built larger states with taxes, armies, and officials, and preserved the nobles' social privileges.

  3. Give one difference between France and England.
    Show answer

    France's king ruled without a representative assembly, while England's Parliament had the power to consent to laws and taxes.

  4. How did the Dutch Republic differ from both France and England?
    Show answer

    It had no monarch with central power and no sovereign national parliament; power was shared among provinces and merchant regents.

  5. Explain one reason for the difference between France and England.
    Show answer

    England's gentry controlled local government and taxation and resisted a standing army, while the French crown built a bureaucracy that replaced independent nobles.

  6. How do Hobbes and Locke relate to absolutism and constitutionalism?
    Show answer

    Hobbes defended a strong sovereign as protection from disorder, which resembles absolutist logic, and Locke defended natural rights and limits on government, which supports constitutionalism.

Unit 3 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 3 review: Absolutism and Constitutionalism, c. 1648–c. 1815

Ten questions on the English Civil War and Glorious Revolution, Louis XIV and the eastern absolutisms, mercantilism, the Dutch Golden Age, and the balance of power, plus two short-answer questions comparing the two roads to state power.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: the English Bill of Rights, 1689.

    "That levying money for or to the use of the Crown by pretence of prerogative, without grant of Parliament, … is illegal. … That the raising or keeping a standing army within the kingdom in time of peace, unless it be with consent of Parliament, is against law."

    These clauses were most directly responses to

    Correct. Each clause names something a Stuart king had done (Charles I's ship money and personal rule, James II's standing army), so the document converts recent grievances into statute.

    Cromwell's rule was resented, but the 1689 settlement was drafted against James II and the Stuart prerogative claims, not against the republic three decades earlier.

    Chartism belongs to the 1830s and 1840s, nearly 150 years later, and demanded democratic suffrage rather than limits on royal prerogative.

    The settlement required parliamentary consent for revenue, which made war finance depend on Parliament rather than allowing the crown to avoid it.

  2. Louis XIV's decision to move the royal court to Versailles in 1682 primarily served to

    Versailles was ruinously expensive. Its purpose was political control, achieved at great cost rather than in order to save money.

    Correct. A duke competing for ceremonial privileges at court was a duke not raising troops in his province: the lesson Louis drew from the Fronde of his childhood.

    Versailles lies just outside Paris, far from the eastern frontier, and Louis directed campaigns through ministers rather than from the field.

    Louis curtailed the parlements' capacity to obstruct royal edicts. Versailles removed the court from Paris, where the parlement sat.

  3. Source: Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, 1651.

    "The only way to erect such a common power … is to confer all their power and strength upon one man, or upon one assembly of men, that may reduce all their wills … unto one will."

    Hobbes's justification for absolute sovereignty differed from that of Bossuet in that Hobbes grounded it in

    Correct. Hobbes argues from the intolerable condition of life without a common power (a secular, consequentialist case) where Bossuet argued that the royal throne is established by God.

    That is Bossuet's argument, not Hobbes's. Hobbes reasons from human nature and the state of nature rather than from scripture.

    Hobbes's sovereign could be one man or an assembly, and his argument does not depend on heredity at all.

    Hobbes begins from the rough natural equality of human beings, which is why no one can claim authority by birth in his account.

  4. Absolutism in Brandenburg-Prussia and Russia differed from French absolutism chiefly in that eastern rulers

    Serfdom was tightening east of the Elbe in exactly this period, not being abolished. Russia emancipated its serfs only in 1861.

    Correct. The Hohenzollerns confirmed Junker control of the land and drew officers from them; Peter's Table of Ranks bound the nobility to state service. Power was built through the nobility, not against it.

    Eastern rulers weakened or ignored representative bodies. Poland, where the Sejm retained power through the liberum veto, is the counter-example that failed to consolidate.

    Eastern towns were small and weak, which is precisely why rulers depended on landed nobles rather than on urban wealth.

  5. Source: Thomas Mun, England's Treasure by Forraign Trade, published 1664.

    "The ordinary means therefore to increase our wealth and treasure is by Forraign Trade, wherein wee must ever observe this rule; to sell more to strangers yearly than wee consume of theirs in value."

    Mun's argument is best understood in light of the fact that he

    Mun was a merchant and company director, not a customs official. His interest was commercial rather than administrative.

    Correct. By insisting the balance be judged across all trade rather than transaction by transaction, he defended precisely the practice his company was accused of: economic doctrine emerging from commercial self-defense.

    He was a director of the largest such company and wrote to defend it against its critics.

    The passage states the mercantilist rule itself. The free-trade critique came from Adam Smith more than a century later.

  6. The Dutch Republic's commercial dominance in the seventeenth century rested most directly on

    Correct. The Amsterdam exchange bank of 1609 and transferable VOC shares lowered the cost of capital, financing large fleets and long voyages: the republic's decisive advantage.

    The Dutch population was small, under two million, and wages were high. Scarcity of labor eventually limited the republic's capacity to sustain prolonged war.

    The Dutch lacked coal and iron and imported fuel, relying on peat and on wind power. Resource endowment was not the source of their wealth.

    The republic was a federation of provinces run largely by merchant regents, with no monarch: the clearest contemporary alternative to absolutism.

  7. Description of: the Peace of Utrecht, 1713.

    Recognizes Philip V as king of Spain while requiring renunciations ensuring the French and Spanish crowns are never held by one person; transfers the Spanish Netherlands and Italian possessions to Austria; grants Britain Gibraltar, Minorca, and the asiento. Several articles state the arrangements are made to secure the peace and equilibrium of Europe.

    The explicit appeal to "equilibrium" is historically significant because it shows that

    Eighteenth-century Europe was full of wars. The settlement limited their aims rather than ending the practice.

    Correct. The balance of power moved from a description of how states behaved to an explicit objective written into treaty text: the organizing logic of the next century.

    The opposite: Catholic Austria, Protestant Britain, and the Calvinist Dutch had allied against Catholic France without controversy.

    The negotiations were conducted among states, and papal influence over such settlements had declined sharply since Westphalia.

  8. Which best explains why the English crown, unlike the French, could not govern for long periods without its representative body?

    English monarchs held substantial crown lands and ordinary revenues. The constraint was on extraordinary taxation, not on royal property.

    Correct. Charles I's eleven-year personal rule ended the moment war with Scotland required funds beyond what prerogative devices like ship money could raise.

    Noble private armies had been curtailed since the Tudors. Parliament's power was fiscal and legal rather than military.

    The English crown was hereditary. Parliament altered the succession in 1689, but monarchs were not elected.

  9. Description of: Peter the Great's decrees on dress and beards, and the Table of Ranks (1722).

    Nobles, officials, and townsmen must shave and wear German or Hungarian coats; those keeping a beard pay a graduated annual tax and carry a token proving payment. The Table of Ranks establishes fourteen parallel grades in army, navy, and civil service, and provides that reaching a specified grade confers noble status regardless of birth.

    Taken together, these measures indicate that Peter's primary goal was to

    Peter created no representative body. His westernization was administrative, military, and cultural, not constitutional.

    Correct. Compulsory western appearance made obedience visible, and the Table of Ranks tied status to state service rather than birth, giving Peter the trained servants his war with Sweden demanded.

    Peasants and clergy were largely exempt from the dress rules, and serfdom tightened under Peter, with conscripted labor used to build St. Petersburg.

    The Table of Ranks expanded the nobility by opening it to talent rather than abolishing it, and the reforms were extremely expensive.

  10. Which statement best assesses the limits of Louis XIV's absolutism?

    The Estates-General did not meet at all between 1614 and 1789. That was a measure of royal strength, not weakness.

    Correct. Louis concentrated decision-making but never touched the fiscal privileges of the first two estates, leaving a state that could fight Europe for fifty years and not pay for it: the contradiction that produced 1789.

    Louis used intendants precisely to bypass provincial officials, who held no such veto.

    Louis frequently acted against papal wishes, notably in asserting Gallican control over the French church.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE difference between the development of royal power in England and in France in the seventeenth century.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason for the difference you described in (a).
    3. Briefly explain ONE way commercial or financial developments affected state power in the period 1600–1750.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: England's monarchy became limited by statute after 1689 while France's became more absolute; Parliament's consent was required for English taxation while Louis XIV governed without the Estates-General; England had no standing army in peacetime without consent. Do not accept: "England was free and France was not."
    • (b) Accept: Parliament's legal control of taxation made it impossible to dispense with when extraordinary revenue was needed, as Charles I discovered in 1640; the French crown could levy the taille without consent; England's island position reduced the need for a large standing army. Must explain causally.
    • (c) Accept: the Bank of England and funded debt letting Britain borrow cheaply and at scale; Dutch financial institutions financing fleets; mercantilist policy and the Navigation Acts tying trade to state power; chartered companies exercising sovereign powers abroad. Must link finance or commerce to state capacity.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) In France royal power became less constrained across the century, with Louis XIV governing without summoning the Estates-General at all, while in England the Bill of Rights of 1689 made it illegal for the monarch to suspend laws, levy taxes, or keep a peacetime standing army without Parliament's consent.

    (b) The difference rested on control of revenue. French kings could collect the taille as a direct tax without consent, so they could fund armies and officials independently, whereas English monarchs legally required parliamentary approval for taxation, which is why Charles I's eleven-year personal rule collapsed as soon as war with Scotland demanded money he could not raise otherwise.

    (c) The creation of the Bank of England in 1694 and a funded national debt allowed the British state to borrow very large sums at low interest against taxes Parliament had guaranteed. This let Britain sustain long naval wars against France, a larger and wealthier country whose crown was a poorer credit risk and paid far higher rates.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE method absolutist rulers used to increase their authority in the period 1648–1750.
    2. Briefly explain ONE limitation on absolutist power in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way the balance of power shaped European diplomacy after 1648.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: intendants bypassing provincial institutions; court ceremony at Versailles domesticating the nobility; standing armies; state control of the church (revocation of the Edict of Nantes, Peter's synod); a service nobility under the Table of Ranks. Must name a mechanism.
    • (b) Accept: noble and clerical tax exemption; venal offices the crown could not recall; separate provincial legal customs; dependence on nobles for officers and administration, especially in the east; the practical limits of communication. Do not accept: "the people could revolt" with no institutional content.
    • (c) Accept: coalitions forming against any dominant power, especially against Louis XIV; the War of the Spanish Succession fought to prevent a Bourbon union; Utrecht writing equilibrium into treaty; Britain acting as the habitual arbiter. Must show the principle operating.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Louis XIV governed the French provinces through intendants, royal agents sent out from the center with authority over taxation, justice, and policing. Because they owed their position entirely to the crown and served away from their home regions, they allowed the king to bypass provincial estates and local officeholders.

    (b) Absolutist rulers could not touch the fiscal privileges of the nobility and clergy. In France the first two estates remained largely exempt from direct taxation throughout Louis XIV's reign, so a state powerful enough to fight most of Europe for fifty years was never able to fund those wars from its wealthiest subjects.

    (c) States repeatedly combined against whichever power threatened to dominate the continent. When Louis XIV's grandson stood to inherit Spain, Britain, Austria, and the Dutch Republic fought the War of the Spanish Succession to prevent it, and the Peace of Utrecht in 1713 permanently separated the two crowns in the name of European equilibrium.

Lesson 4.1 · Unit 4 · CED topics 4.1 and 4.2

Context and the Scientific Revolution

Between the mid-sixteenth and the late seventeenth centuries, a small group of thinkers rebuilt Europe's picture of the heavens, the human body, and the way to gain knowledge. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment developed, and Learning Objective B asks how understanding of the natural world developed and changed. The CED's key idea is that new ideas and methods led people to question the authority of the ancients and traditional knowledge. This lesson sets the context and then follows astronomy, medicine, and method.

Required content · 4A, 4B

Learning objectives.

  • 4A. Explain the context in which the Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment developed in Europe.
  • 4B. Explain how understanding of the natural world developed and changed during the Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment.

Historical developments.

  • 1.1.IV.A. New ideas and methods in astronomy led individuals, including Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton, to question the authority of the ancients and traditional knowledge, and to develop a heliocentric view of the cosmos.
  • 1.1.IV.B. Anatomical and medical discoveries by physicians, including William Harvey, presented the body as an integrated system, challenging the traditional humoral theory of the body and of disease espoused by Galen.
  • 1.1.IV.C. Francis Bacon and René Descartes defined inductive and deductive reasoning and promoted experimentation and the use of mathematics, which would ultimately shape the scientific method.
  • 1.1.IV.D. Alchemy and astrology continued to appeal to elites and some natural philosophers, in part because they shared with the new science the notion of a predictable and knowable universe. At the same time, many people continued to believe that the cosmos was governed by spiritual forces.

The context for new knowledge

Several developments of the previous two centuries prepared the way.

  • Renaissance humanism. The recovery of Greek texts, including mathematics and Plato, and the habit of comparing sources and criticizing errors (Lesson 1.1) trained scholars to question received authority.
  • Printing. Printed books, diagrams, and tables let scientists share data and build on each other's work (Lesson 1.3).
  • Exploration. Voyages revealed new lands, plants, animals, and peoples that ancient authorities had never described, so the ancients could be wrong (Lesson 1.5).
  • The Reformation. The Protestant challenge to church authority, and the religious wars that followed, encouraged people to rely on individual judgment and weakened the power of any single institution to control ideas.
  • State and commercial needs. Governments and merchants needed better maps, navigation methods, and military technology, which encouraged measurement and mathematics.

From earth-centered to sun-centered astronomy

Medieval scholars accepted Aristotle and the astronomer Ptolemy: the earth stood still at the center, and the sun and planets moved in perfect circles around it.

  • Nicolaus Copernicus (1543, On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres) argued that the earth and planets orbit the sun, a heliocentric model. He kept circular orbits, but his hypothesis made the calculations simpler and challenged common sense and the Bible's apparent picture.
  • Tycho Brahe gathered precise observations without a telescope, and Johannes Kepler used them to show that planets move in ellipses and speed up when closer to the sun (1609).
  • Galileo Galilei used the telescope from 1609 to see mountains on the moon, moons orbiting Jupiter, and phases of Venus, evidence that supported Copernicus. His Dialogue (1632) brought him before the Roman Inquisition in 1633, which forced him to recant. He also showed that motion on earth followed mathematical laws.
  • Isaac Newton (Principia, 1687) brought these ideas together in laws of motion and the law of universal gravitation, showing that the same forces govern earthly and heavenly bodies. The universe was a predictable system open to reason.

Medicine and the body

Medicine had followed Galen, a second-century Greek physician, who taught the humoral theory: disease results from imbalance among four bodily fluids. Andreas Vesalius (1543) corrected Galen's anatomy through dissection, and William Harvey (1628) showed that blood circulates, pumped by the heart. These discoveries presented the body as an integrated system, challenging Galen's theory. Paracelsus, in the sixteenth century, had already promoted chemical remedies over ancient formulas.

New methods of reasoning

Two thinkers defined the methods that would shape the scientific method.

  • Francis Bacon (Novum Organum, 1620) championed inductive reasoning: gather many observations and experiments and then draw general conclusions.
  • René Descartes (Discourse on Method, 1637) championed deductive reasoning: start with clear and certain principles, such as "I think, therefore I am," and use mathematics to reach conclusions.

Together they promoted experimentation and the use of mathematics. Scientific societies, such as the Royal Society of London (1660) and the French Academy of Sciences (1666), published findings and tested claims.

1543 Copernicus, Vesalius 1609 Kepler's elliptical orbits 1610 Galileo's telescope 1620 Bacon, Novum Organum 1628 Harvey and the circulation of blood 1637 Descartes, Discourse on Method 1660 Royal Society founded 1687 Newton's Principia
Figure 4.1. The Scientific Revolution. Astronomy, anatomy, and method changed together, and scientific societies spread the results.

Continuities

The Scientific Revolution did not end older beliefs. The CED notes that alchemy and astrology continued to appeal to elites and some natural philosophers because they shared with the new science the notion of a predictable and knowable universe. Kepler cast horoscopes, and Newton wrote about alchemy and theology. At the same time, many people continued to believe that spiritual forces governed the cosmos, and most of the population, who were not reading scientific books, saw no change in their lives.

Primary source · Knowledge and power

Francis Bacon, Novum Organum (1620), Book I, aphorism 3 (English translation of 1857), excerpt.

Human knowledge and human power meet in one; for where the cause is not known the effect cannot be produced.

Sourcing (HIPP). Bacon was an English lawyer, statesman, and philosopher who wrote in Latin, so his audience was educated Europeans, and his purpose was to persuade them to abandon reliance on ancient authority and to investigate nature by experiment. His historical situation was a time of growing trade and of recent discoveries that challenged the ancients. The passage connects knowledge and practical use, so it fits a commercial, state-building age, but Bacon was describing a program, not practicing the experiments himself.

Source analysis · A new purpose for knowledge

Claim. Bacon argues that understanding causes lets humans produce effects, so knowledge should be practical.

Evidence. He says knowledge and power "meet in one" because without knowing the cause an effect cannot be produced.

Reasoning. The claim moves away from reliance on ancient authority toward investigation of nature, which is the CED's emphasis on questioning traditional knowledge. It also helps explain why states and merchants supported science. A limit is that the quotation states an ideal, and many natural philosophers continued to use older beliefs.

Worked example · Change in understanding

Question. Explain one way ideas about the natural world changed during the Scientific Revolution.

Model. Astronomers shifted from an earth-centered cosmos, based on Aristotle and Ptolemy, to a sun-centered one. Copernicus proposed it, Galileo's telescope observations supported it, Kepler described elliptical orbits, and Newton explained the motion of the planets with universal gravitation. The change replaced the authority of the ancients with observation and mathematics.

Exam focus

Learning Objective B is about how understanding changed, so name the old view (Aristotle, Ptolemy, Galen, the humoral theory) and the new (heliocentrism, circulation of blood, inductive and deductive methods). Then add continuity: alchemy, astrology, and belief in spiritual forces persisted among elites and the public. For context, tie the Scientific Revolution to earlier developments: humanism, printing, exploration, and the Reformation.

Practice
  1. Name two contexts that helped the Scientific Revolution develop.
    Show answer

    Renaissance humanism and the habit of criticizing sources, printing, exploration, the Reformation's challenge to authority, and state and commercial needs.

  2. Who proposed the heliocentric model, and who confirmed key evidence with a telescope?
    Show answer

    Copernicus proposed it in 1543, and Galileo's telescope observations supported it.

  3. What did Newton show?
    Show answer

    The laws of motion and universal gravitation, which explained earthly and heavenly motion with the same mathematical principles.

  4. How did Vesalius and Harvey challenge Galen?
    Show answer

    Vesalius corrected Galen's anatomy through dissection, and Harvey showed that blood circulates, replacing Galen's humoral theory with a view of the body as an integrated system.

  5. Distinguish Bacon's and Descartes's methods.
    Show answer

    Bacon promoted inductive reasoning from observations and experiments; Descartes promoted deductive reasoning from clear principles using mathematics.

  6. Give one continuity from before the Scientific Revolution.
    Show answer

    Alchemy and astrology continued to attract elites and some natural philosophers, and many people still believed spiritual forces governed the cosmos.

Lesson 4.2 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.3

The Enlightenment

In the eighteenth century a movement of writers and thinkers applied the methods of the Scientific Revolution to society, government, and religion. Learning Objective C asks you to explain the causes and consequences of Enlightenment thought on European society, and Learning Objective D asks about its influence on European intellectual development. The Enlightenment has a name, the Age of Reason, but it was also an age of argument, publishing, and conversation.

Required content · 4C, 4D

Learning objectives.

  • 4C. Explain the causes and consequences of Enlightenment thought on European society from 1648 to 1815.
  • 4D. Explain the influence of Enlightenment thought on European intellectual development from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.3.I.A. Intellectuals, including Voltaire and Diderot, began to apply the principles of the Scientific Revolution to society and human institutions.
  • 2.3.I.B. Locke and Rousseau developed new political models based on the concept of natural rights and the social contract.
  • 2.3.I.C. Despite the principles of equality espoused by the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, intellectuals such as Rousseau offered controversial arguments for the exclusion of women from political life.
  • 2.3.II.A. A variety of institutions, including salons, explored and disseminated Enlightenment culture.
  • 2.3.III.A. Political theories, including John Locke’s, conceived of society as composed of individuals driven by self-interest and argued that the state originated in the consent of the governed (i.e., a social contract) rather than in divine right or tradition.
  • 2.3.III.B. Mercantilist theory and practice were challenged by new economic ideas, including Adam Smith’s, which espoused free trade and a free market.
  • 2.3.IV.A. Intellectuals, including Voltaire and Diderot, developed new philosophies of deism, skepticism, and atheism.
  • 2.3.IV.B. Religion was viewed increasingly as a matter of private rather than public concern.

The core ideas

The philosophes, mostly French writers who saw themselves as spreading light against ignorance, shared several convictions: that reason can discover natural laws that govern society as well as nature; that human beings can improve through education and reform; that custom, superstition, and arbitrary authority are enemies; and that individuals have natural rights.

Applying science to society

The CED says intellectuals such as Voltaire and Diderot began to apply the principles of the Scientific Revolution to society and human institutions.

  • Voltaire (1694 to 1778) used satire and essays to attack religious intolerance and abuses of power. Letters on England (1733) praised English liberty, and Candide (1759) mocked naive optimism. He defended freedom of speech and religious toleration.
  • Denis Diderot edited the Encyclopédie (1751 to 1772), a huge collaborative work that gathered knowledge in the arts, sciences, and trades and criticized superstition and absolute authority.
  • Montesquieu's The Spirit of the Laws (1748) compared governments and recommended separation of powers to prevent despotism. Cesare Beccaria's On Crimes and Punishments (1764) argued against torture and the death penalty and for proportional punishments.

Natural rights and the social contract

  • John Locke (Lesson 3.1) argued that all people have natural rights to life, liberty, and property, and that government is created by consent to protect them. The CED's wording: society is composed of individuals driven by self-interest, and the state originated in the consent of the governed, a social contract, not in divine right or tradition.
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau (The Social Contract, 1762) held that legitimate authority rests on the general will of the people. He opened with the line that people are born free but are everywhere in chains.

Economic ideas

Mercantilist theory and practice (Lesson 3.2) were challenged by new economic ideas. The Physiocrats, such as François Quesnay and Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot, argued that wealth came from land and that government should leave trade alone (laissez-faire). Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations (1776) argued that free trade and a free market, guided by individuals pursuing self-interest, produce prosperity better than state controls.

Religion

Enlightenment thinkers criticized organized religion and the church's power. The CED says Voltaire and Diderot developed new philosophies of deism (a creator who set the universe in motion but does not intervene), skepticism (David Hume), and atheism (Baron d'Holbach). By 1800 religion was viewed increasingly as a matter of private rather than public concern. A very different movement, the German Pietism revival, stressed personal devotion, which shows that religious feeling remained strong.

Women and the Enlightenment

Enlightenment principles of equality raised the question of women's rights, but the CED notes that, despite the principles espoused by the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, intellectuals such as Rousseau offered controversial arguments for the exclusion of women from political life. Rousseau held that women's education should prepare them for domestic roles. Mary Wollstonecraft (A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, 1792) and the Marquis de Condorcet challenged him and argued for equal education and rights.

Spreading the ideas

A variety of institutions explored and disseminated Enlightenment culture: salons, hosted by women such as Madame Geoffrin in Paris, where writers, nobles, and officials discussed ideas; coffeehouses, which spread across Britain and the Continent; scientific and literary academies; lending libraries; and Masonic lodges. Books were often published abroad to escape censors.

Primary source · The motto of the age

Immanuel Kant, "What Is Enlightenment?" (1784), excerpt in an early English translation.

Enlightenment is man's emergence from his self-incurred immaturity.... Sapere aude! Have courage to use your own understanding!

Sourcing (HIPP). Kant was a professor in Prussia writing an essay in a Berlin magazine in response to a reader's question. His audience was educated readers, and his purpose was to urge them to think for themselves. His historical situation was the reign of Frederick the Great, whom he praised for allowing freedom to argue, while expecting obedience in action. The passage defines the movement in its own terms, but it describes an ideal and does not show how many people actually had access to such freedom.

Source analysis · Reason and independence

Claim. Kant argues that enlightenment means using one's own reason instead of depending on others' authority.

Evidence. He defines enlightenment as emergence from "self-incurred immaturity" and urges readers to "have courage to use your own understanding."

Reasoning. This reflects the Enlightenment's principle that traditional authority, whether religious or political, must be tested by reason, which is why the movement challenged established institutions. The source was addressed to educated readers in a particular state, so it expresses an elite ideal, not a mass movement.

Worked example · Consequences

Question. Explain one way Enlightenment thought challenged existing political or economic ideas.

Model. Locke and Rousseau developed political models based on natural rights and the social contract, which replaced divine right as the justification of government with the consent of the governed. This challenged absolute monarchy and provided arguments used later in revolutions. In economics, Adam Smith challenged mercantilism by arguing for free trade and a free market.

Exam focus

Link each thinker to an idea and, where you can, to a consequence: Locke and Rousseau (natural rights, social contract), Montesquieu (separation of powers), Voltaire and Diderot (reason, criticism, deism, skepticism), Smith (free market against mercantilism), Wollstonecraft and Condorcet (challenges to excluding women). Remember the institutions that spread these ideas and the limits: the audience was mostly educated men and women of the elite, and many Europeans stayed religious.

Practice
  1. What did the philosophes believe?
    Show answer

    That reason can discover natural laws governing society, that human beings can improve through education, and that custom and arbitrary authority should be challenged.

  2. How did Locke and Rousseau change thinking about government?
    Show answer

    They based political authority on natural rights, consent, and the social contract instead of divine right or tradition.

  3. How did Adam Smith challenge mercantilism?
    Show answer

    He argued that free trade and a free market guided by self-interest produce wealth better than state controls and monopolies.

  4. Define deism.
    Show answer

    The belief in a creator who set the universe in motion but does not intervene in human affairs, a position favored by thinkers such as Voltaire.

  5. Name two institutions that spread Enlightenment culture.
    Show answer

    Salons, coffeehouses, academies, lending libraries, and Masonic lodges.

  6. Why did Wollstonecraft criticize Rousseau?
    Show answer

    Rousseau argued that women should be excluded from political life and educated for domestic roles, while Wollstonecraft argued for equal education and rights.

Lesson 4.3 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.4

Eighteenth-century society and demographics

Behind the debates of philosophers, the lives of ordinary Europeans were changing in the eighteenth century. Learning Objective E asks you to explain the factors contributing to and the consequences of demographic changes between 1648 and 1815. The central fact is population growth, which brought changes in family life, in the way people thought about children, and in the size and problems of cities.

Required content · 4E

Learning objective.

  • 4E. Explain the factors contributing to and the consequences of demographic changes from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.4.I.A. By the middle of the 18th century, higher agricultural productivity and improved transportation increased the food supply, allowing populations to grow and reducing the number of demographic crises (a process known as the Agricultural Revolution).
  • 2.4.I.B. In the 18th century, plague disappeared as a major epidemic disease, and inoculation reduced smallpox mortality.
  • 2.4.III.A. Although the rate of illegitimate births increased in the 18th century, population growth was limited by the European marriage pattern, and in some areas by various birth control methods.
  • 2.4.III.B. As infant and child mortality decreased, and commercial wealth increased, families dedicated more space and resources to children and child-rearing, as well as private life and comfort.
  • 2.4.IV.A. The Agricultural Revolution produced more food using fewer workers; as a result, people migrated from rural areas to the cities in search of work.
  • 2.4.IV.B. The growth of cities eroded traditional communal values, and city governments strained to provide protection and a healthy environment.
  • 2.4.IV.C. The concentration of the poor in cities led to a greater awareness of poverty, crime, and prostitution as social problems, and prompted increased efforts to police marginal groups.

More food, fewer epidemics

Europe's population grew substantially in the eighteenth century, after stagnating in the seventeenth, and the continent had many more people in 1800 than in 1700. The CED identifies several causes.

  • Higher agricultural productivity and improved transportation. By the middle of the century higher productivity and better roads, canals, and shipping increased the food supply, allowing populations to grow and reducing the number of demographic crises such as famines. This process is the Agricultural Revolution (Lesson 3.2). Crops such as the potato helped feed the poor, especially in Ireland and northern Europe.
  • The end of plague. In the eighteenth century plague disappeared as a major epidemic disease in western Europe. The last big outbreak in France struck Marseille in 1720. Historians point to better quarantines and changes in trade and in rodent populations as causes.
  • Inoculation. Inoculation reduced smallpox mortality. Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, wife of a British ambassador, observed the practice in the Ottoman Empire and promoted it in Britain in the 1720s. Edward Jenner's cowpox vaccination (1796) made the protection safer.

Family patterns

The CED adds that, although the rate of illegitimate births increased in the eighteenth century, population growth was limited by the European marriage pattern (late marriage, many people never marrying) and in some areas by various birth control methods. Families in the countryside still depended on land and inheritance to decide when a couple could marry.

As infant and child mortality decreased and commercial wealth increased, families dedicated more space and resources to children and child-rearing, as well as private life and comfort. Parents and writers took greater interest in children's education and health. Rousseau's Émile (1762) urged parents to let children develop naturally, and portraits of families became popular. In the middle classes, homes began to have separate rooms for sleeping and family life.

Migration and the growth of cities

The same Agricultural Revolution that produced more food used fewer workers, so people migrated from rural areas to the cities in search of work. London became the largest city in Europe, with roughly a tenth of the English population living there by 1800, and Paris and other capitals and ports grew too.

  • Strain on communal life. The CED says the growth of cities eroded traditional communal values and that city governments strained to provide protection and a healthy environment. Migrants lived in crowded, unsanitary housing, and the old village networks of mutual help and control disappeared.
  • Poverty and crime. The concentration of the poor in cities led to greater awareness of poverty, crime, and prostitution as social problems. Governments and reformers prompted increased efforts to police marginal groups: beggars, vagrants, and the poor were confined to workhouses and general hospitals, such as the Hôpital Général in Paris, and police forces and night watches grew.
Causes More food from the Agricultural Revolution Plague ends; inoculation spreads Population growth Fewer demographic crises Limited by the European marriage pattern Consequences More attention to children Migration to cities Poverty, crime, policing
Figure 4.2. Population growth in the eighteenth century. Better food supply and fewer epidemics allowed numbers to rise, which changed family life and swelled the cities.
Primary source · Gin Lane

Description of: William Hogarth, Gin Lane (engraving, 1751), a print showing a London slum. A drunken mother lets her baby fall from her arms, a pawnbroker does a brisk trade while shops decay, and the only prosperous buildings are the pawnshop, the gin seller, and the undertaker.

Sourcing (HIPP). Hogarth was an English artist and engraver who made cheap prints for a wide audience, so his purpose was commercial and moral. He issued Gin Lane with a companion, Beer Street, to support the Gin Act of 1751 that restricted sales of spirits. His point of view is that of a middle-class reformer, and the image exaggerates for effect. It is useful evidence for how elite and middle-class contemporaries saw urban poverty, but it should be checked against other sources about what life was like for the poor.

Source analysis · A view of the city

Claim. Hogarth presents the urban poor as threatened by drink and destitution.

Evidence. In Gin Lane a mother drops her baby, shops decay, and only the pawnbroker, gin seller, and undertaker thrive.

Reasoning. The print reflects the CED's point that concentration of the poor in cities led to a greater awareness of poverty and crime as social problems, and it supported efforts to regulate behavior. As a deliberate exaggeration made to support a law, it shows middle-class fears and reform goals more than daily conditions.

Worked example · Causes and consequences

Question. Explain one factor that caused population growth in the eighteenth century and one consequence.

Model. One factor was the Agricultural Revolution, which increased the food supply and reduced famines, along with the disappearance of plague. One consequence was migration to cities, because agriculture needed fewer workers and the growing population looked for jobs in towns, which strained city governments and led to more concern about poverty and crime.

Exam focus

Learning Objective E asks for factors (food supply, end of plague, inoculation, the marriage pattern limiting growth) and consequences (more attention to children and private life, urbanization, poverty, policing of marginal groups). Keep the CED's careful words: population growth was limited by the European marriage pattern. Use specific details: Marseille 1720, Montagu and inoculation, London's growth, workhouses.

Practice
  1. Name two causes of population growth in the eighteenth century.
    Show answer

    Higher agricultural productivity and better transportation increased food supply, plague disappeared, and inoculation reduced smallpox deaths.

  2. How did the European marriage pattern affect population?
    Show answer

    Late marriage and many people never marrying limited the birth rate and held back growth.

  3. How did family life change as child mortality fell?
    Show answer

    Families devoted more space, resources, and attention to children and private life, as in the interest in education and the family portrait.

  4. Why did people migrate to cities?
    Show answer

    The Agricultural Revolution needed fewer farm workers, so people moved to towns to find work.

  5. How did cities respond to poverty and crime?
    Show answer

    Governments and reformers confined the poor in workhouses and hospitals and expanded policing of vagrants and other marginal groups.

  6. Why should a historian use Hogarth's Gin Lane carefully?
    Show answer

    It was made to support a reform law and exaggerates for effect, so it shows reformers' views more than the actual conditions of the poor.

Lesson 4.4 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.5

Eighteenth-century culture and the arts

The eighteenth century produced a larger reading public, a new literary form, and arts that reflected a changing society. Learning Objective F asks you to explain how European cultural and intellectual life was maintained and changed between 1648 and 1815. The CED's points fall into three groups: print and public opinion; the outside world and challenges to norms; and the change from Baroque to bourgeois and neoclassical art.

Required content · 4F

Learning objective.

  • 4F. Explain how European cultural and intellectual life was maintained and changed throughout the period from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.3.II.B. Despite censorship, increasingly numerous and varied printed materials served a growing literate public and led to the development of public opinion.
  • 2.3.II.C. Natural sciences, literature, and popular culture increasingly exposed Europeans to representations of peoples outside Europe and, on occasion, challenges to accepted social norms.
  • 2.3.V.A. Until about 1750, Baroque art and music promoted religious feeling and was employed by monarchs to illustrate state power.
  • 2.3.V.B. 18th-century art and literature increasingly reflected the outlook and values of commercial and bourgeois society. Neoclassicism expressed new Enlightenment ideals of citizenship and political participation.

Print and public opinion

Despite censorship, increasingly numerous and varied printed materials served a growing literate public and led to the development of public opinion. Books, pamphlets, and periodicals multiplied, and newspapers appeared in London, Amsterdam, Paris, and other cities. The French Encyclopédie (1751 to 1772) was a landmark, though church and state tried to suppress it. Governments licensed printers, burned books, and imprisoned authors, but publishers moved abroad to the Dutch Republic and Switzerland. By the late century, rulers and ministers had to take account of opinion expressed in print, coffeehouses, and clubs, a new force beside the court and the church.

Literacy was uneven. It was high in Protestant northern and western Europe, in cities, and among men, and low among rural people, the poor, and women, especially in southern and eastern Europe. People who could not read still heard texts read aloud and saw printed images.

The novel

The novel became the favorite new form for a reading public that included many women and middle-class readers.

  • Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe (1719) told of a resourceful shipwrecked Englishman and reflected commercial individualism.
  • Samuel Richardson's Pamela (1740) and Henry Fielding's Tom Jones (1749) explored love, class, and morality in contemporary English society.
  • Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's The Sorrows of Young Werther (1774) captured emotion and individual feeling and anticipated Romanticism (Lesson 5.8). Jane Austen's novels, appearing from 1811, examined manners, marriage, and money.

Europe and the wider world

The CED says that natural sciences, literature, and popular culture increasingly exposed Europeans to representations of peoples outside Europe and, on occasion, challenges to accepted social norms. Travel accounts, such as those of Captain James Cook's Pacific voyages, and reports from missionaries and merchants circulated widely. Writers used imagined foreigners to criticize Europe: Montesquieu's Persian Letters (1721) imagines two Persian visitors who mock French customs. The "noble savage" image, and fashions for Chinese porcelain and wallpaper and Turkish costume, show interest in non-European peoples, though the images were often simplified, and the same contact supported colonial and racial thinking.

From Baroque to bourgeois and neoclassical art

  • Baroque until about 1750. Baroque art and music promoted religious feeling and were employed by monarchs to illustrate state power: the paintings of Velázquez at the Spanish court, Bernini's sculpture and architecture in Rome, the palace of Versailles, and the church music of J. S. Bach and the oratorios of George Frideric Handel.
  • Bourgeois values. The CED says 18th-century art and literature increasingly reflected the outlook and values of commercial and bourgeois society. Dutch painters such as Rembrandt and Vermeer, and later English and French painters, depicted merchants, interiors, and daily life. Hogarth's engravings and Chardin's quiet kitchen scenes show middle-class subjects.
  • Neoclassicism. In the late century artists reacted against the Baroque and the lighter Rococo style. Neoclassicism expressed new Enlightenment ideals of citizenship and political participation, drawing on Greek and Roman models of simplicity, order, and civic virtue. Jacques-Louis David's Oath of the Horatii (1784) shows Roman citizens vowing to sacrifice for the state, and the Pantheon in Paris (begun 1758) used a classical temple front.
Primary source · Against arbitrary power

Description of: Denis Diderot, article "Political Authority" in the Encyclopédie (1751). Diderot writes that no man has received from nature the right to command others, that freedom is a gift of heaven, and that true authority must rest on reason and on the consent of those who are governed.

Sourcing (HIPP). Diderot was a leading philosophe and the chief editor of the work, writing for an educated audience across Europe, so his purpose was to apply reason to politics and to spread new ideas. The historical situation was French absolutism under Louis XV, with royal censorship. The article was published despite official opposition, which shows both the demand for such ideas and the limits on free expression. As evidence it shows how critics of absolutism argued, but the Encyclopédie reached a limited, mainly elite readership.

Source analysis · Print and criticism

Claim. Diderot uses a printed reference work to challenge arbitrary political authority.

Evidence. He says no man has received from nature the right to command others and that authority depends on reason and consent.

Reasoning. The article applies Enlightenment ideas to politics, and the publication shows that, despite censorship, printed material was reaching a growing public and shaping opinion, as the CED states. The work was expensive and aimed at educated readers, so it does not show what ordinary people thought.

Worked example · Change in the arts

Question. Explain one way European art and literature changed in the eighteenth century.

Model. Art and literature increasingly reflected the values of commercial and middle-class society. Novels such as Robinson Crusoe and Pamela appealed to a broader reading public and dealt with individual enterprise and morality, and painters depicted middle-class and everyday scenes, in contrast to the Baroque art that glorified religion and monarchy.

Exam focus

Learning Objective F is about continuity and change in culture. Continuity: Baroque art and music serving church and monarchy until about 1750. Change: a larger reading public and public opinion despite censorship, new literary forms such as the novel, exposure to non-European peoples, bourgeois subjects, and Neoclassicism with its Enlightenment ideals. Use named examples (the Encyclopédie, Defoe, Richardson, David, the Pantheon) for each point.

Practice
  1. How did print culture help create public opinion?
    Show answer

    More newspapers, periodicals, books, and pamphlets reached a growing literate public, which discussed politics and ideas despite censorship.

  2. Name two novelists and what their works show about society.
    Show answer

    Defoe's Robinson Crusoe showed commercial individualism; Richardson's Pamela and Fielding's Tom Jones explored class, love, and morality (also Goethe and Austen).

  3. How did Europeans learn about peoples outside Europe?
    Show answer

    Through travel accounts, scientific voyages, literature, and popular culture, which sometimes used foreign visitors to criticize European customs.

  4. What did Baroque art do until about 1750?
    Show answer

    It promoted religious feeling and was used by monarchs to display state power.

  5. What was Neoclassicism and what ideals did it express?
    Show answer

    An art style based on Greek and Roman forms that expressed Enlightenment ideals of citizenship and political participation.

  6. Why is the Encyclopédie useful evidence and what is its limit?
    Show answer

    It shows how Enlightenment ideas were spread despite censorship, but it was costly and read mainly by educated elites.

Lesson 4.5 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.6

Enlightened absolutism and the rise of Prussia

By the mid-eighteenth century several monarchs claimed to rule by the principles of the Enlightenment. Learning Objective G asks how different forms of political power were influenced by Enlightenment thought, and Learning Objective H asks how political and religious developments challenged or reinforced the idea of a unified Europe. The CED's points: a number of states in eastern and central Europe experimented with enlightened absolutism; by 1800 most governments had extended toleration to Christian minorities and, in some states, civil equality to Jews; and, after the Peace of Westphalia limited the Holy Roman Empire, Prussia rose to power and the Habsburgs shifted eastward.

Required content · 4G, 4H

Learning objectives.

  • 4G. Explain how different forms of political power were influenced by Enlightenment thought from 1648 to 1815.
  • 4H. Explain how and why political and religious developments challenged or reinforced the idea of a unified Europe from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.I.C. In the 18th century, a number of states in eastern and central Europe experimented with enlightened absolutism.
  • 2.3.IV.C. By 1800, most governments in western and central Europe had extended toleration to Christian minorities and, in some states, civil equality to Jews.
  • 2.1.III.A. As a result of the Holy Roman Empire’s limitation of sovereignty in the Peace of Westphalia, Prussia rose to power, and the Habsburgs, centered in Austria, shifted their empire eastward.

What was enlightened absolutism?

Enlightened absolutism is the label for rulers who kept absolute power but justified it by reforms based on reason and the welfare of their subjects. Such a ruler might promote education, religious toleration, legal reform, and economic improvement, while still making all decisions himself or herself. Historians debate how sincere the rulers were. Reform also strengthened the state, so it served both reason and power.

Prussia: Frederick the Great

Prussia, a collection of Hohenzollern territories around Brandenburg, was small, poor, and exposed. Its strength came from an army and a disciplined administration.

  • Frederick William I (r. 1713 to 1740), the "soldier king," built a large army and a frugal bureaucracy.
  • Frederick II ("the Great," r. 1740 to 1786) seized the rich Austrian province of Silesia in 1740 and held it through the War of the Austrian Succession (1740 to 1748) and the Seven Years' War (1756 to 1763). Prussia became a great power.

Frederick corresponded with Voltaire, called himself "the first servant of the state," and made reforms. He allowed religious toleration for Protestants, Catholics, and Jews in practice (while keeping Jews out of many roles), reformed the legal code, limited torture, promoted education and agriculture (including the potato), and encouraged free discussion in his academy. But he kept serfdom, relied on the Junker nobles as officers and officials, and expanded the army, which shows the limits of enlightenment.

The Habsburg monarchy

After Westphalia reduced the emperor's real power in Germany, and after the victory at Vienna (1683), the Habsburgs shifted their empire eastward toward Hungary, Bohemia, and the Balkans, centered on Austria.

  • Maria Theresa (r. 1740 to 1780) strengthened the state with a better tax system, a larger army, and primary schools, after nearly losing Silesia and her throne.
  • Joseph II (r. 1780 to 1790), her son and an admirer of the philosophes, issued reforms: the Edict of Toleration (1781) giving rights to Protestants and Orthodox Christians and relief to Jews, the end of personal serfdom, and the reduction of church privileges. He tried to impose them quickly and without consent, and nobles, the Catholic Church, and Hungarians resisted, so many reforms were reversed.

Catherine II and toleration

Catherine the Great of Russia (Lesson 3.6) wrote an instruction on law (the Nakaz, 1767) drawing on Montesquieu and Beccaria, but her reforms stopped short of changing serfdom. In most of western and central Europe, governments by 1800 had extended toleration to Christian minorities, and in some states to Jews, because rulers wanted loyal subjects and economic activity, and because Enlightenment writers argued against persecution. Full civil equality for Jews came first in revolutionary France (1791).

Enlightened reform Limits Frederick II of Prussia Toleration; legal reform schools Serfdom kept army and Junkers Maria Theresa of Austria Tax system; army primary schools Aimed at a stronger state Joseph II of Austria Edict of Toleration end of personal serfdom Imposed without consent reversed Catherine II of Russia Nakaz on law promoted education Serfdom and noble privilege kept
Figure 4.3. Enlightened absolutism. Four rulers adopted reforms inspired by Enlightenment ideas, but each kept absolute power and the social order that supported it.

A unified Europe?

Learning Objective H asks whether religious and political developments challenged the idea of a unified Europe. The Reformation had already broken religious unity, and Westphalia had established that sovereign states and their rulers, not the emperor or pope, controlled religion in their lands. Prussia's rise at the expense of Austria showed that the Holy Roman Empire could not hold the German states together. At the same time, Enlightenment culture itself created a shared European elite: French was the language of courts, and writers and rulers exchanged letters across borders. Europe was politically divided but culturally interconnected.

Primary source · The first servant of the state

Frederick II of Prussia, writings on kingship (1740s to 1750s), excerpt in English translation.

The sovereign is the first servant of the State.

Sourcing (HIPP). Frederick wrote as a reigning king, so he was both author and subject, and his purpose was to justify his rule in the language of the Enlightenment and to guide his successors. He used the phrase in several writings in the 1740s and 1750s. The audience included philosophes whose good opinion he valued, such as Voltaire. His point of view was self-serving, since he took Silesia by force, and the statement of service sits beside his policy of expanding the army and keeping serfdom, so the claim should be tested against what he did.

Source analysis · A ruler's self-portrait

Claim. Frederick presents himself as a ruler who serves the state, not one who owns it.

Evidence. He calls the sovereign "the first servant of the State."

Reasoning. The phrase reflects Enlightenment ideas that government should serve the public good, which fits the CED's picture of enlightened absolutism. But the claim comes from a king defending his own policies, and his actions (invading Silesia, retaining serfdom, strengthening the army) show that his reforms served state power as well as his subjects.

Worked example · Enlightenment and power

Question. Explain one way Enlightenment thought influenced a ruler and one limit on that influence.

Model. Joseph II was influenced by Enlightenment ideas of toleration and reason when he issued the Edict of Toleration in 1781 and ended personal serfdom. The limit was that he imposed the changes without the consent of nobles, the church, or Hungarians, who resisted, and many of his reforms were reversed, which shows that enlightened absolutism depended on the ruler's will.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective G, use Frederick II, Joseph II, Maria Theresa, and Catherine II as examples of enlightened absolutism, and always include its limits: serfdom stayed, nobles remained powerful, and the reforms strengthened the state. For Learning Objective H, connect Westphalia, the rise of Prussia, the eastward shift of the Habsburgs, and extended toleration to the idea of a Europe that was divided politically but shared an Enlightenment culture.

Practice
  1. What is enlightened absolutism?
    Show answer

    Rule by an absolute monarch who justifies power by reforms based on reason and the welfare of subjects, such as toleration, legal reform, and education.

  2. Give one reform and one limit of Frederick the Great's rule.
    Show answer

    He allowed religious toleration and reformed law and education; he kept serfdom and relied on the nobles and army.

  3. What did Joseph II's Edict of Toleration do?
    Show answer

    It extended rights to Protestants, Orthodox Christians, and Jews in the Habsburg lands (1781).

  4. Why did Joseph II's reforms often fail?
    Show answer

    He imposed them rapidly and without consent, and nobles, the church, and Hungarians resisted.

  5. How did Prussia's rise relate to the Peace of Westphalia?
    Show answer

    Westphalia limited the emperor's sovereignty over German princes, which allowed Prussia to grow as a power independent of Habsburg control.

  6. In what sense was Europe both divided and unified in the eighteenth century?
    Show answer

    Politically it was divided into sovereign states and confessions, while an Enlightenment culture, shared by elites and expressed in French, connected the states.

Lesson 4.6 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.7

Causation: how science and reason challenged the old order

The last topic of Unit 4 again practices causation. Learning Objective I asks you to explain how and why the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment challenged the existing European order and understanding of the world. The skill is to connect a set of causes to a set of effects across intellectual, political, economic, and religious life, and to weigh how much each cause mattered.

Required content · 4I

Learning objective.

  • 4I. Explain how and why the Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment challenged the existing European order and understanding of the world.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

Causes: where the challenge came from

  • Intellectual roots. Renaissance humanism and the critical study of texts, Christian humanists' criticism of the church, and the Scientific Revolution's success in explaining nature (Lesson 4.1) gave Europeans a method for questioning authority: observation, reason, and mathematics.
  • Technology and institutions. Printing, scientific societies, academies, and later salons, coffeehouses, and periodicals (Lessons 4.2 and 4.4) spread ideas to a larger public and created public opinion.
  • Religious division. The Reformation and the wars of religion weakened the claim of any church to speak for all Christians and made toleration attractive after Westphalia.
  • Commercial and urban change. A wealthier and more literate middle class in Britain, the Netherlands, and France, the growth of cities (Lesson 4.3), and overseas trade created an audience that wanted ideas about useful knowledge, economic freedom, and political participation.
  • Political context. The absolutist state's claim to unlimited power invited criticism, and the English experience of limiting a king (Lesson 3.1) gave an example.

Effects: what was challenged

  1. View of nature. The cosmos was a system governed by natural laws that reason could discover, which challenged Aristotle, Ptolemy, and Galen.
  2. Authority and politics. Natural rights and the social contract undermined divine right and absolute monarchy and supported ideas of separation of powers and consent.
  3. Economy. Free-market ideas challenged mercantilism and guilds.
  4. Religion. Deism, skepticism, and toleration moved religion toward private belief.
  5. Society. Debates over education, crime, and women's rights questioned social hierarchy, though rulers and elites often adopted the ideas selectively, as in enlightened absolutism.
Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment Nature natural laws; reason Politics natural rights; consent Economy free market vs mercantilism Religion deism; toleration Society education; women's rights
Figure 4.4. Effects of the new ideas. The Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment questioned traditional authority in five areas, from the study of nature to the organization of society.

Evaluating the strength of the effects

Strong causal analysis includes limits. Most Europeans were not reading Locke or Voltaire, and monarchs used enlightenment to strengthen states. Serfdom and slavery persisted, and women's exclusion from political life was defended even by Enlightenment authors. Ideas also had long-term consequences that early observers could not see: the principles of natural rights and popular sovereignty became weapons in the French Revolution of 1789 (Unit 5), and the confidence in reason shaped the nineteenth century's optimism about progress (Unit 7).

Primary source · A historian's argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument. The author argues that the Enlightenment grew out of the Scientific Revolution because thinkers such as Voltaire and Diderot copied its methods, but adds that the movement also depended on the printing industry, salons, and coffeehouses that carried ideas to a public, and that many ideas had little effect until rulers or revolutionaries chose to use them.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author writes with hindsight and a clear purpose: to explain the relationship between science, social institutions, and political change. The audience is scholars and students. As a secondary source, it presents an interpretation. A strong answer states the claim (the Enlightenment depended on both ideas and institutions), supports it with evidence (Voltaire's use of science, the Encyclopédie, salons), and notes that the author sees limits, since ideas influenced politics only when used by powerful people.

Source analysis · Ideas and institutions

Claim. The historian argues that the Enlightenment depended on both scientific method and the institutions that spread ideas.

Evidence. Voltaire and Diderot applied scientific principles to society, and the Encyclopédie, salons, and coffeehouses distributed their work.

Reasoning. The claim fits the CED's account of intellectuals applying science to institutions and of institutions disseminating Enlightenment culture. The qualification that rulers and revolutionaries had to adopt ideas to give them effect is a reminder that a cause is often a necessary condition, not a sufficient one.

Worked example · Causation

Question. Explain one way the Scientific Revolution contributed to the Enlightenment's challenge to the old order.

Model. The Scientific Revolution showed that reason, observation, and mathematics could uncover natural laws, which led thinkers such as Voltaire and Diderot to apply the same methods to society and its institutions. Their criticism of arbitrary authority and tradition challenged absolutism and church power and helped create a political language of natural rights and consent.

Exam focus

A causation answer should separate causes by type (intellectual, technological, religious, economic, political), show a link, and name effects in different spheres (nature, politics, economy, religion, society). To judge importance, say which cause was necessary and which only helped, and note limits: elites used the ideas selectively, and many Europeans were untouched. Connect to the later French Revolution as a long-term effect.

Practice
  1. Give two causes of the Enlightenment challenge to the existing order.
    Show answer

    The success of the Scientific Revolution's methods, the spread of ideas through print and institutions, religious division and weariness of conflict, and the growth of a wealthy, literate middle class.

  2. How did religious division contribute?
    Show answer

    The Reformation and wars of religion weakened the claim of any single church to authority and made toleration and private religion attractive.

  3. Name two areas where the Enlightenment challenged existing ideas, with an example for each.
    Show answer

    Politics (natural rights and the social contract against divine right) and economics (free-market ideas against mercantilism); also religion (deism) or society (women's rights).

  4. Why did enlightened monarchs adopt only some ideas?
    Show answer

    They wanted to strengthen their states and keep control, so they used reform to improve efficiency while keeping serfdom and absolute power.

  5. What was a long-term consequence of Enlightenment ideas?
    Show answer

    Their principles of natural rights and popular sovereignty were used by revolutionaries, notably in the French Revolution.

  6. Why might a historian say the Enlightenment's effects were limited before 1789?
    Show answer

    Most Europeans did not read Enlightenment works, rulers adopted ideas selectively, and serfdom, slavery, and the exclusion of women continued.

Unit 4 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 4 review: Scientific, Philosophical, and Political Developments

Ten questions on the Scientific Revolution, the Enlightenment and its publics, eighteenth-century society and the arts, and the limits of enlightened absolutism, plus two short-answer questions on reason applied to nature and to society.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Galileo Galilei, Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina, 1615.

    "The intention of the Holy Ghost is to teach us how one goes to heaven, not how heaven goes."

    Galileo's argument here is best characterized as a claim that

    Correct. Galileo, a devout Catholic, separates the domains: scripture teaches salvation, astronomy describes the heavens, so a conflict between them is only apparent.

    He affirms scripture's authority on its own subject, salvation. His argument is about jurisdiction, not about scripture's reliability.

    Galileo sought to persuade church authorities, not to strip them of doctrinal authority, and remained within the church throughout.

    This reverses his claim. He argues that astronomical questions should be settled by observation rather than by scriptural interpretation.

  2. Kepler's contribution was essential to the acceptance of heliocentrism because he

    Copernicus published the heliocentric model in 1543, decades before Kepler worked on Brahe's data.

    Correct. Copernicus had kept circular orbits, which left the model no more accurate than the old one; elliptical orbits finally made heliocentrism match the observations.

    Galileo made the telescopic observations of Jupiter's moons in 1609–1610. Kepler's work was mathematical, using Brahe's naked-eye data.

    Universal gravitation was Newton's achievement in the Principia of 1687.

  3. Bacon and Descartes differed principally in that Bacon emphasized

    Correct. Bacon's Novum Organum argued for induction (gather observations methodically, then generalize) against both scholastic logic and pure deduction.

    That is Descartes's method, beginning from principles he could not doubt and reasoning outward.

    Both men rejected Aristotelian authority. Attacking it was their common starting point.

    The mechanical, mathematically described universe is characteristically Cartesian, not Baconian.

  4. Source: John Locke, Second Treatise of Government, 1689.

    "The great and chief end, therefore, of men's uniting into commonwealths, and putting themselves under government, is the preservation of their property."

    A historian would most usefully note that this work was published

    Locke's argument limits royal authority rather than defending it, and Charles I was executed forty years before publication.

    Correct. Published anonymously in 1689, it reads as a justification of what had just happened, a monarch removed for violating his trust, which is why later revolutions found it so useful.

    The French Revolution began a century later, in 1789. Its leaders drew on Locke but did not prompt him.

    The civil war began in 1642, nearly fifty years before publication.

  5. Montesquieu's The Spirit of the Laws contributed most directly to later political practice through its argument for

    The general will is Rousseau's concept, and Montesquieu distrusted concentrated authority of any kind, including popular.

    Correct. Separating legislative, executive, and judicial functions so that each checks the others became a template for written constitutions.

    Free trade was Adam Smith's argument in 1776. Montesquieu wrote about the structure of government.

    Montesquieu admired the English constitutional monarchy and did not call for abolishing kingship.

  6. Salons contributed to the Enlightenment primarily by

    Academies such as the Académie des Sciences were separate crown institutions. Salons were private gatherings in women's homes.

    Correct. A hostess such as Madame Geoffrin selected guests and enforced conversational rules under which a marquis and a penniless writer could argue as equals, circulating ideas among people with influence.

    The clandestine book trade was carried on by printers and smugglers, often operating from the Dutch Republic or Switzerland.

    European universities remained closed to women throughout this period. Salons gave women intellectual influence outside the universities, not within them.

  7. Source: Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, 1792.

    "Taught from their infancy that beauty is woman's sceptre, the mind shapes itself to the body, and, roaming round its gilt cage, only seeks to adorn its prison. … I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves."

    Wollstonecraft's argument rests on which Enlightenment premise?

    Correct. She argues women appear frivolous because they are educated to be so: Locke's premise that the mind is shaped by experience, turned on the education of women.

    She argues for equal rational capacity, not for a separate or superior female nature, which would concede the difference she disputes.

    Divine-right argument is what Enlightenment writers attacked. Nothing in the passage appeals to it.

    Deference to custom is the conservative position Wollstonecraft is arguing against.

  8. Source: Frederick II of Prussia, Essay on the Forms of Government, 1777.

    "He is only the first servant of the state, who is obliged to act with probity and prudence."

    Read against Frederick's actual policies, the passage is best used as evidence for

    Frederick left serfdom on noble estates untouched, limiting reform to his own royal domains, because he depended on the Junkers for officers.

    Correct. He defines the monarch's duty as service while conceding nothing about who judges whether it is performed: Enlightenment vocabulary serving unchanged practice.

    No such assembly existed. Frederick's reforms were administrative and legal, never constitutional.

    Frederick seized Silesia from Austria in 1740 in a war of opportunity and later joined the partitions of Poland.

  9. The reversal of most of Joseph II's reforms after 1790 best illustrates that enlightened absolutism was limited by

    The war ended in 1763, well before Joseph's reign began in 1780, and his difficulties were political rather than fiscal.

    Correct. Joseph abolished serfdom and attacked noble and Hungarian privilege; resistance from those groups was strong enough to undo the measures at and after his death.

    Joseph dissolved contemplative monasteries and subordinated the church to the state despite papal objection, which he was able to sustain.

    Resistance came chiefly from nobles and the Hungarian estates defending privilege and autonomy, not from popular religious demand.

  10. The partitions of Poland in 1772, 1793, and 1795 are most often cited as evidence that

    The opposite: three rulers who corresponded with philosophes erased a sovereign state, showing enlightenment imposed no restraint at all.

    Correct. Prussia, Austria, and Russia, the three states most identified with enlightened absolutism, partitioned a neighbor out of existence purely for advantage.

    Poland's 1791 constitution was a reform effort that its neighbors suppressed rather than protected, using it as a pretext for further partition.

    The partitions are a clear case of annexation succeeding, which the balance of power failed to prevent because the three partitioning powers cooperated.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way the Scientific Revolution changed what counted as reliable knowledge.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way Enlightenment thinkers applied that change to the study of society.
    3. Briefly explain ONE limitation of Enlightenment thought as it was applied in the eighteenth century.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: observation, mathematics, and repeatable demonstration replaced the authority of Aristotle and of scriptural interpretation; findings became cumulative and correctable; scientific societies published results so others could repeat them. Do not accept: "people stopped believing in God."
    • (b) Accept: Locke reasoning from a state of nature to the ends of government; Montesquieu comparing constitutions to derive principles; Smith analyzing markets; Beccaria applying utility to punishment. Must show the method being transferred.
    • (c) Accept: most philosophes did not extend rights to women, the poor, or the enslaved; enlightened rulers reformed only where it strengthened the state; colonial slavery continued and expanded; the partitions of Poland. Do not accept: vague claims that it was "not very effective."
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Claims about the natural world came to be settled by observation, mathematics, and repeatable demonstration rather than by the authority of ancient writers. Galileo's telescopic evidence could be checked by anyone with a telescope, which is why Kepler could correct Copernicus and Newton could subsume both.

    (b) Enlightenment writers applied the same standard to human institutions. Montesquieu compared the constitutions of different states in order to derive general principles about what prevents tyranny, treating political arrangements as a subject for systematic analysis rather than as inherited custom beyond question.

    (c) Enlightenment universalism was applied very selectively. Most philosophes assumed political rights belonged to propertied men, and the same decades saw the Atlantic slave trade reach its peak, so the premise that all should be judged by reason coexisted with the exclusion of women, the poor, and the enslaved.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE reform enacted by an enlightened absolutist ruler.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason such rulers pursued reforms of this kind.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way eighteenth-century social or economic change affected ordinary people.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: Frederick II's religious toleration, legal codification, or abolition of judicial torture; Joseph II's Patent of Toleration (1781), abolition of serfdom, or monastic dissolution; Catherine II's Instruction of 1767. Must name ruler and measure.
    • (b) Accept: reforms that increased state reach at the expense of church, noble, or local authority; the need for educated and healthy subjects and soldiers; desire for standing among the philosophes; efficiency of a uniform legal and administrative system. Must explain the ruler's interest.
    • (c) Accept: enclosure stripping common rights and pushing smallholders into wage labor; the putting-out system bringing piece-rate manufacturing into rural households; falling mortality and population growth; the consumer revolution making tea, sugar, and cotton ordinary purchases. Must connect to people's actual conditions.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Joseph II of Austria issued the Patent of Toleration in 1781, granting Protestants and Jews rights of worship and access to occupations from which they had previously been excluded in the Habsburg lands.

    (b) Such reforms strengthened the state at the expense of rival institutions. Toleration weakened the Catholic Church's monopoly over religious life and brought previously excluded subjects into economic and military service, so the measure increased royal authority while also satisfying enlightened opinion abroad.

    (c) Enclosure consolidated common fields into private farms and stripped cottagers of the grazing and gleaning rights that had made small holdings viable. Many rural families lost the margin that kept them independent and had to take wage work or piece-rate spinning and weaving under the putting-out system instead.

Lesson 5.1 · Unit 5 · CED topics 5.1 and 5.2

Eighteenth-century states and global markets

Unit 5 covers the long crisis of the old order in Europe, from the wars of the eighteenth century through the French Revolution and Napoleon to the settlement of 1815. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which European states experienced crisis and conflict between 1648 and 1815, and Learning Objective B asks about the causes and consequences of European maritime competition. The CED's statements on this topic are that European sea powers vied for Atlantic influence throughout the eighteenth century, and that rivalries in Asia culminated in British domination in India and Dutch control of the East Indies.

Required content · 5A, 5B

Learning objectives.

  • 5A. Explain the context in which the European states experienced crisis and conflict from 1648 to 1815.
  • 5B. Explain the causes and consequences of European maritime competition from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.2.III.A. European sea powers vied for Atlantic influence throughout the 18th century.
  • 2.2.III.B. Portuguese, Dutch, French, and British rivalries in Asia culminated in British domination in India and Dutch control of the East Indies.

The context: states under pressure

By 1700 Europe was a system of competing states, and wars shaped their politics.

  • Monarchy and privilege. Most states were monarchies ruled with the support of aristocracies. Societies were divided into legal ranks, or estates, with privileges for clergy and nobles and heavy burdens for commoners. Peasants in eastern Europe were serfs.
  • War and money. The military revolution (Lesson 3.4) made war more expensive each decade. States borrowed, sold offices, and raised taxes, and the strain on finances would produce political crises, above all in France.
  • New ideas. The Enlightenment (Unit 4) questioned the justification of privilege and absolute rule and gave critics a vocabulary.
  • Commerce. Overseas trade made merchants and colonies central to state policy, and it linked European politics to conflicts across the globe.

Rivalry for the Atlantic

The CED says European sea powers vied for Atlantic influence throughout the eighteenth century. Spain still held the largest American empire, but its power had faded; Portugal controlled Brazil; and Britain, France, and the Dutch fought for the Caribbean sugar islands, the North American fur and fishing trade, and the slave trade. The sugar colonies of Saint-Domingue (French) and Jamaica (British) were among the most valuable possessions in the world. States used mercantilist laws, navies, privateers, and wars to protect their trade and to hurt rivals.

The rise of global markets

The result was a world economy centered on Europe.

  • The Atlantic circuit. Manufactured goods, enslaved Africans, sugar, tobacco, rice, cotton, and silver moved around the Atlantic (Lessons 1.7 and 3.2).
  • The Asian trade. Europeans bought Asian tea, silk, spices, cotton cloth, and porcelain, paid for largely with American silver, and sold them at home. The Dutch and British East India Companies were among the largest businesses on earth.
  • A consumer revolution. Sugar, tea, tobacco, coffee, and printed cotton cloth became part of everyday life in Europe for people of middling income (Lesson 3.2).

Adam Smith called the opening of the Atlantic and the sea route to India two of the most important events in human history, and he also warned that the system of mercantile monopolies favored merchants over consumers.

Rivalries in Asia

By the eighteenth century the Portuguese, Dutch, French, and British were all active in Asia, mostly as traders with fortified bases.

  • The Dutch controlled the spice islands of the East Indies (modern Indonesia) through the Dutch East India Company, with its base at Batavia.
  • The British and French competed for India. After the Mughal Empire weakened in the early eighteenth century, local rulers fought for power and the European companies took sides. British victory at Plassey (1757), led by Robert Clive of the East India Company, started British rule in Bengal, and the Seven Years' War ended French hopes (Lesson 5.2). The CED's conclusion is British domination in India and Dutch control of the East Indies.

Consequences

  • Within Europe. Competition for overseas wealth fed wars between European states and made naval power decisive. It raised taxes and debts, which later drove political change.
  • Within the colonies. Colonial peoples were conquered, enslaved, or forced into trade on European terms, and indigenous rulers in India lost power to a company army.
  • In the balance of economic power. Britain, with the largest navy and the most successful commercial system, gained the most, and the Dutch lost relative power. (This is covered further in Lesson 5.2.)
Primary source · A verdict on empire and trade

Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), Book IV, chapter 7, excerpt.

The discovery of America, and that of a passage to the East Indies by the Cape of Good Hope, are the two greatest and most important events recorded in the history of mankind.

Sourcing (HIPP). Smith was a Scottish philosopher and economist writing for educated readers in Britain, and his purpose in the chapter was to evaluate colonies and to argue against the mercantile system of monopoly. His historical situation was the American colonies' rebellion, which began as he published. He was impressed by the scale of the events, but he also noted that their benefits were limited by monopolies and that for the people of the Americas and the East Indies they had brought "dreadful misfortunes." The passage shows an Enlightenment thinker's view of the global economy, but it comes from one author and one national perspective.

Source analysis · A contemporary's judgment

Claim. Smith argues that the opening of the Atlantic and Asian sea routes was among the most important events in human history.

Evidence. He calls the discovery of America and the passage to the East Indies "the two greatest and most important events."

Reasoning. The statement supports the CED's point that maritime expansion built a world economy and shifted power to Atlantic states. Smith's overall argument in the book, however, was that mercantile monopolies and colonial empires brought less benefit than free trade would have, so the passage should not be read as a simple endorsement of empire.

Worked example · Causes and consequences

Question. Explain one cause and one consequence of European maritime competition in the eighteenth century.

Model. One cause was mercantilism: states believed that wealth came from colonies and trade, so they used navies and wars to protect their own routes and weaken rivals. One consequence was British domination in India and Dutch control of the East Indies, with Britain's naval and commercial strength making it the leading power overseas.

Exam focus

For the context topic, describe conditions (estates and privilege, costly war, new ideas, global commerce) in more than a phrase. For Learning Objective B, give both causes (mercantilism, the profits of sugar, spices, and slaves) and consequences (British domination in India, Dutch control of the East Indies, war debts, a global economy). Do not say Britain simply conquered India in 1757; a private company took Bengal and expanded gradually.

Practice
  1. Name two conditions that made European states vulnerable to crisis in the eighteenth century.
    Show answer

    Costly wars that strained finances, a system of privileged estates, and new Enlightenment criticism of the existing order.

  2. Why were the Caribbean sugar colonies so important?
    Show answer

    They produced valuable crops with slave labor, enriched merchants and states, and became prizes in wars among Britain, France, and others.

  3. What did Europeans trade for Asian goods?
    Show answer

    Largely American silver, since Asian markets wanted few European manufactured goods.

  4. What did the Dutch control in Asia?
    Show answer

    The East Indies, especially the spice trade, through the Dutch East India Company.

  5. How did Plassey (1757) matter?
    Show answer

    The East India Company's victory under Clive began British rule in Bengal and the extension of British power in India at France's expense.

  6. State one consequence of maritime rivalry for European politics.
    Show answer

    It raised war costs, taxes, and debt, and it made naval power decisive in the balance among states.

Lesson 5.2 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.3

Britain's ascendancy and the Seven Years' War

By 1763 Britain had defeated its great rival and become the greatest European power overseas. Learning Objective C asks you to explain the economic and political consequences of the rivalry between Britain and France between 1648 and 1815. The CED's account: rivalry resulted in world wars fought both in Europe and in the colonies, with Britain supplanting France as the greatest European power. The chain that led to the American and French Revolutions began here.

Required content · 5C

Learning objective.

  • 5C. Explain the economic and political consequences of the rivalry between Britain and France from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.III.D. Rivalry between Britain and France resulted in world wars fought both in Europe and in the colonies, with Britain supplanting France as the greatest European power.

Britain and France before 1756

Both states were rich and ambitious, but their systems differed (Lesson 3.7). Louis XIV's France had the larger population and army. Britain, after the Glorious Revolution, had a parliamentary monarchy that was dominated by commercial and landed interests, so it borrowed money cheaply through the Bank of England and a funded national debt, and it built the strongest navy. Historians call it a fiscal-military state: a government that could finance long wars with credit. Britain also benefited from the Act of Union (1707) joining England and Scotland.

Earlier wars, the War of the Spanish Succession (1701 to 1714) and the War of the Austrian Succession (1740 to 1748), brought Britain gains at Utrecht (Gibraltar, Minorca, Nova Scotia, and the asiento) and kept the balance in Europe.

The Seven Years' War (1756 to 1763)

The conflict began over borders in North America, where French and British colonists and their Native allies had competed for the Ohio valley, and over Prussia's seizure of Silesia in Europe. A "Diplomatic Revolution" reversed alliances: Britain allied with Prussia, and France with Austria and Russia. The fighting spread across Europe, North America, the Caribbean, West Africa, India, and the oceans, which is why historians call it a world war.

  • In Europe, Frederick II of Prussia survived against great odds and held Silesia.
  • Overseas, British forces led by William Pitt, who gave priority to the colonial war, won key victories: Plassey in India (1757), Quebec in Canada (1759), and the naval battle of Quiberon Bay (1759), which ended French invasion plans.

The Treaty of Paris (1763) gave Britain all of French Canada and territory east of the Mississippi, plus Florida from Spain, and left it the dominant power in India. France kept sugar islands in the Caribbean but lost most of its North American empire.

Economic and political consequences

  • Britain supplanted France as the greatest European power. It controlled the seas, held a larger empire, and increased its trade, which later helped finance its industrial growth (Unit 6).
  • War debt in Britain. The cost of the war nearly doubled the British national debt. Parliament decided that the American colonies, protected by the war, should pay a larger share through new taxes such as the Stamp Act (1765). The colonists' resistance led to the American Revolution (1775 to 1783).
  • Revenge and bankruptcy in France. France helped the American rebels and, with Spanish and Dutch aid, forced Britain to accept independence in 1783. The price was a national debt that the French monarchy could not pay, and the fiscal crisis was a direct cause of the Revolution of 1789 (Lesson 5.3).
  • Imperial redefinition. Britain lost the thirteen colonies but kept a larger empire in Canada, the Caribbean, India, and the Pacific, and its trade with the United States recovered.

The CED's example of conflict between the French and the British lists the Seven Years' War and the American Revolution together because they are linked.

1700 1725 1750 1775 1800 Nine Years' War Spanish Succession Austrian Succession Seven Years' War American Revolution Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars Wars between Britain and France, 1689 to 1815
Figure 5.1. A long rivalry. Britain and France fought a series of wars over trade, colonies, and the balance of power, ending with Britain as the leading European power overseas.
Primary source · The terms of peace

Description of: The Treaty of Paris (1763), signed by Britain, France, and Spain. France gives up Canada and its claims east of the Mississippi to Britain, Spain gives up Florida to Britain, and France keeps fishing rights off Newfoundland and several sugar islands in the Caribbean.

Sourcing (HIPP). The treaty is a diplomatic document drawn up by the victors, and it reflects British dominance in the negotiations. Its purpose was to end the war and to settle territory. The audience was the governments, officials, and merchants of the states involved. It shows what each power gained and lost, but it says nothing about the opinions of the Native peoples and colonists whose lands were transferred without their consent.

Source analysis · A settlement of empire

Claim. The treaty confirmed British gains and reduced French power in North America.

Evidence. France gave Canada and the land east of the Mississippi to Britain, and Spain ceded Florida.

Reasoning. The transfers show the CED's point that Britain supplanted France as the greatest European power, and they created the conditions for later conflict by removing the French threat that had kept the American colonies loyal and by leaving Britain with a huge debt. The treaty was negotiated by European governments, so it omits the views of Native peoples who were most affected.

Worked example · Consequences

Question. Explain one economic consequence of the rivalry between Britain and France.

Model. The rivalry left both states with large war debts. Britain's debt led Parliament to tax the American colonies, producing resistance and the American Revolution. France's debt, increased by its aid to the American rebels, produced a fiscal crisis that the monarchy could not solve, which led to the calling of the Estates General in 1789.

Exam focus

Learning Objective C wants economic and political consequences, and the best answers connect them in a chain: war, then debt, then new taxes or reform, then revolution. Say that the Seven Years' War was a global war, name its theaters, and show why Britain won (naval power, credit, a strong ally in Prussia, and a clear colonial strategy). The CED's pairing of the Seven Years' War and the American Revolution shows that you should treat them as part of one story.

Practice
  1. What advantages helped Britain in its rivalry with France?
    Show answer

    A powerful navy, a parliamentary system that let it borrow cheaply through the Bank of England, and strong commercial interests.

  2. Why was the Seven Years' War a world war?
    Show answer

    It was fought in Europe, North America, the Caribbean, West Africa, India, and on the seas.

  3. What did Britain gain in the Treaty of Paris (1763)?
    Show answer

    French Canada and the land east of the Mississippi, Florida from Spain, and a dominant position in India.

  4. How did the war lead to the American Revolution?
    Show answer

    It left Britain with a heavy debt, so Parliament taxed the colonies, which resisted and eventually rebelled.

  5. How did French aid in the American Revolution affect France?
    Show answer

    It increased French debt and contributed to the fiscal crisis that led to the French Revolution.

  6. What does fiscal-military state mean?
    Show answer

    A state able to finance large armies and navies through taxes and credit, as Britain did with the Bank of England and the national debt.

Lesson 5.3 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4

The French Revolution: causes and the liberal phase

The French Revolution of 1789 was the most important political event of the era, and the CED asks for its causes, events, and consequences in Learning Objective D. This lesson covers the causes and the first, or liberal, phase of the revolution, in which a constitutional monarchy replaced absolutism. The next lesson covers the radical phase and the Terror.

Required content · 5D

Learning objective.

  • 5D. Explain the causes, events, and consequences of the French Revolution.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.IV.A. The French Revolution resulted from a combination of long-term social and political causes, as well as Enlightenment ideas, exacerbated by short-term fiscal and economic crises.
  • 2.1.IV.B. The first, or liberal, phase of the French Revolution established a constitutional monarchy, increased popular participation, nationalized the Catholic Church, and abolished hereditary privileges.
  • 2.1.IV.E. Women enthusiastically participated in the early phases of the revolution; however, while there were brief improvements in the legal status of women, citizenship in the republic was soon restricted to men.

Long-term causes

The CED says the revolution resulted from a combination of long-term social and political causes, as well as Enlightenment ideas, exacerbated by short-term fiscal and economic crises.

  • Social. French society was divided into three estates: the First (clergy), the Second (nobles), and the Third, which included everyone else, from wealthy bourgeois lawyers and merchants to urban workers and peasants. The privileged estates were a small minority and paid few taxes, while the Third Estate, the great majority, paid most of them, along with feudal dues to landlords and the tithe to the church. Educated bourgeois resented being excluded from office despite their wealth and talent.
  • Political. The monarchy was absolute in theory but weak in practice. Louis XVI (r. 1774 to 1792) was indecisive. The regional high courts (parlements) and the aristocracy resisted reforms, and the Estates General had not met since 1614.
  • Intellectual. Enlightenment ideas of equality before the law, natural rights, and popular sovereignty (Lesson 4.2) gave critics a language, and clubs, salons, and pamphlets spread them.

Short-term causes: the fiscal and economic crisis

  • Debt. France was deeply in debt after the wars of the century and the aid given in the American Revolution (Lesson 5.2). By the 1780s, interest on the debt took roughly half of royal spending.
  • Failed reform. Finance ministers such as Turgot, Necker, and Calonne proposed taxing the privileged. An Assembly of Notables (1787) refused, and the parlements blocked new taxes, so Louis XVI was forced to call the Estates General for the first time in 175 years.
  • Hunger. A poor harvest in 1788 and a hard winter drove up the price of bread, the staple of the poor, and caused unrest in the spring of 1789.

The Third Estate and the National Assembly

The Estates General opened at Versailles in May 1789. Each estate had one vote, so the first two could always outvote the third. The Abbé Sieyès published a pamphlet in January 1789 in which he asked what the Third Estate was. His answer was that it was everything, although until then it had counted for nothing in politics, and that it should become something.

On June 17 the Third Estate declared itself the National Assembly, and on June 20 its members, locked out of their hall, took the Tennis Court Oath, swearing not to disband until France had a constitution. The king, under pressure, accepted. On July 14 a Paris crowd stormed the Bastille, a royal fortress and prison, seeking arms. The event symbolized popular resistance to royal power, and the king had to recognize the new order. In the countryside, the Great Fear of rumored aristocratic plots led peasants to attack manor houses and burn feudal records.

The liberal reforms of 1789 to 1791

The CED says the first phase established a constitutional monarchy, increased popular participation, nationalized the Catholic Church, and abolished hereditary privileges.

  • August 4, 1789. The Assembly abolished feudal dues, the tithe, and legal privileges of nobles and clergy.
  • Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (August 26): a statement of natural rights, liberty, equality before the law, and popular sovereignty.
  • Church reform. The Assembly nationalized church lands and, in the Civil Constitution of the Clergy (1790), made priests elected, salaried state officials who swore loyalty to the nation. The pope condemned it, and many priests refused the oath, so French Catholics divided.
  • Constitution of 1791. A limited monarchy with a one-house Legislative Assembly elected by "active" male citizens who paid a minimum tax, and a reorganization of France into departments with uniform administration.

Women in the early revolution

The CED notes that women enthusiastically participated in the early phases. Thousands of Parisian women marched to Versailles in October 1789 to demand bread and brought the royal family to Paris. Olympe de Gouges wrote the Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen (1791) to demand equal rights, but citizenship in the republic was soon restricted to men, and brief improvements in women's legal status (such as divorce and equal inheritance) did not give them political rights.

May 1789 Estates General meets June 1789 Tennis Court Oath 14 July 1789 Fall of the Bastille Aug 1789 Feudal privileges abolished; Declaration of Rights 1791 Constitution; flight to Varennes Sept 1792 Republic declared Jan 1793 Louis XVI executed 1793-94 Reign of Terror July 1794 Thermidor: Robespierre falls
Figure 5.2. Phases of the French Revolution. A liberal constitutional monarchy gave way to a republic and then to the radical Terror, which ended with the fall of Robespierre.
Primary source · The rights proclaimed

Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789), Article 1, excerpt in an early English translation.

Men are born and remain free and equal in rights. Social distinctions may be founded only upon the general good.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Declaration was drafted by the National Assembly, mostly bourgeois and liberal nobles, in August 1789, so its point of view is that of reformers attacking privilege. Its purpose was to state the principles of the new order and to justify the abolition of feudalism. The audience was the French people and Europe. Its words say "men," and it did not apply in practice to women, enslaved people in the colonies, or the poor who could not vote, so it shows ideals more than the revolution's results.

Source analysis · The principle and its limits

Claim. The Declaration established legal equality as a foundation of the new France.

Evidence. Article 1 says men are "born and remain free and equal in rights" and that distinctions may rest only on "the general good."

Reasoning. The sentence rejects the hereditary privileges of the estates and expresses Enlightenment ideas of natural rights. A limit is that the text's "men" was applied narrowly, as the exclusion of women (Olympe de Gouges's protest) and the property requirement for the vote show, and the Declaration says nothing about slavery.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one long-term cause and one short-term cause of the French Revolution.

Model. One long-term cause was social and political inequality: the Third Estate paid most taxes and feudal dues while nobles and clergy were privileged, and educated bourgeois were excluded from power. One short-term cause was the fiscal crisis: debt from wars and aid to the American Revolution meant that the king could not raise taxes without the privileged, which forced him to call the Estates General in 1789.

Exam focus

Learning Objective D asks for causes, events, and consequences. Organize the causes into long-term (inequality of estates, absolute monarchy's weakness, Enlightenment ideas) and short-term (debt, failed reforms, bread prices). Name the key events in order (Estates General, National Assembly, Tennis Court Oath, Bastille, August 4, Declaration, Civil Constitution, Constitution of 1791). Remember the CED's point on women: early participation, then exclusion from citizenship.

Practice
  1. Name the three estates.
    Show answer

    The First Estate (clergy), the Second Estate (nobility), and the Third Estate (everyone else).

  2. Give two short-term causes of the revolution.
    Show answer

    The fiscal crisis (debt and the failure to tax the privileged) and bread shortages after a poor harvest in 1788.

  3. What was the Tennis Court Oath?
    Show answer

    A pledge by members of the Third Estate, in June 1789, not to separate until France had a constitution.

  4. What did the Assembly do on August 4, 1789?
    Show answer

    It abolished feudal dues and the legal privileges of nobles and clergy.

  5. What was the Civil Constitution of the Clergy and why did it divide France?
    Show answer

    It made priests elected state officials who swore loyalty to the nation; the pope condemned it and many priests refused, splitting French Catholics.

  6. How were women treated in the early revolution?
    Show answer

    Women participated eagerly, as in the October march to Versailles, but citizenship in the new republic was restricted to men, despite protests such as Olympe de Gouges's declaration.

Lesson 5.4 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4

The Terror and the radical republic

By 1792 the revolution was at war with Europe and divided at home. Learning Objective D asks for the events and consequences of the revolution, and the CED's account of its second phase is brief but important: after the execution of Louis XVI, the radical Jacobin republic led by Robespierre responded to opposition at home and war abroad by instituting the Reign of Terror, fixing prices and wages, and pursuing a policy of de-Christianization. It adds that revolutionary armies, raised by mass conscription, sought to bring the changes initiated in France to the rest of Europe.

Required content · 5D

Learning objective.

  • 5D. Explain the causes, events, and consequences of the French Revolution.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.IV.C. After the execution of Louis XVI, the radical Jacobin republic led by Robespierre responded to opposition at home and war abroad by instituting the Reign of Terror, fixing prices and wages, and pursuing a policy of de-Christianization.
  • 2.1.IV.D. Revolutionary armies, raised by mass conscription, sought to bring the changes initiated in France to the rest of Europe.

War and the end of the monarchy

Other monarchs, afraid of revolutionary ideas and wishing to protect Marie Antoinette's family, the Austrian ruling house, threatened intervention. Louis XVI tried to flee in June 1791 and was caught at Varennes, which damaged trust in him. In April 1792 France declared war on Austria, and Prussia joined. Early defeats led to the Brunswick Manifesto, a Prussian threat to destroy Paris if the royal family was harmed.

In August 1792 a Paris crowd stormed the Tuileries Palace and the monarchy fell. In September France was declared a republic, and the National Convention, elected by all men, took power. The Convention tried Louis XVI for treason and executed him on January 21, 1793. That act led Britain, Spain, the Dutch, and others to join the war.

Crisis and the Committee of Public Safety

In 1793 the republic faced foreign invasion, a royalist and Catholic revolt in the Vendée, and revolts in some provincial cities. The Convention gave emergency power to the Committee of Public Safety, led by Maximilien Robespierre, a lawyer and leader of the Jacobin club. Other Jacobin leaders included Georges Danton, an orator who was executed in 1794, and Jean-Paul Marat, a radical journalist assassinated in 1793.

  • The levée en masse (August 1793). The Convention ordered mass conscription of all able-bodied men and put the whole nation to work for the war. France raised armies of hundreds of thousands, the largest Europe had seen, led by officers promoted for ability. By 1794 these armies had driven the invaders back.
  • The Reign of Terror (September 1793 to July 1794). The Law of Suspects and the Revolutionary Tribunal allowed arrest and swift trial of people deemed enemies of the revolution. Tens of thousands died, including about 16,000 to 17,000 executed by the guillotine after trial, among them the queen Marie Antoinette, rival revolutionaries, and ordinary people. Many more died in prisons or in the suppression of the Vendée.
  • Economic controls. The Law of the Maximum fixed the price of bread and other goods and limited wages, to satisfy the urban poor, the sans-culottes.
  • De-Christianization. The republic closed churches, encouraged a "Cult of Reason," introduced a new calendar without Sundays or saints' days, and pressed priests to renounce the faith, which angered devout peasants.

Women in the radical phase

Women's clubs, such as the Society of Republican Revolutionary Women (1793), demanded rights. In October 1793 the Convention banned women's political clubs, and Olympe de Gouges was executed in November, which, as the CED notes, shows that citizenship in the republic was soon restricted to men.

Thermidor and the Directory

By 1794 the military danger had eased, but the Terror continued, and many in the Convention feared they would be the next victims. On 9 Thermidor (July 27, 1794) they overthrew Robespierre and sent him to the guillotine. The Convention ended the Terror and in 1795 created the Directory, a government of five directors, a moderate republic that depended on the army and was unstable.

Exporting the revolution

The revolutionary armies, raised by mass conscription and motivated by patriotic enthusiasm, defeated the professional armies of the old regimes and, in the CED's words, sought to bring the changes initiated in France to the rest of Europe. They occupied Belgium, the Rhineland, and Italy, abolished feudal privileges, and set up sister republics. In the process, the war changed from a defense of the revolution into a war of conquest.

Primary source · Terror as virtue

Description of: Maximilien Robespierre, speech "On the Principles of Political Morality" to the Convention (February 1794). He states that the republic needs both virtue and terror: "Terror is nothing other than justice, prompt, severe, inflexible," and he describes terror as a means to defend democracy against its enemies.

Sourcing (HIPP). Robespierre was the leading figure of the Committee of Public Safety, and he addressed the Convention to defend its emergency measures, so his purpose was to justify the Terror in the name of the revolution's principles. The historical situation was war, civil war, and fear of conspiracy. His audience was the deputies and the public. The speech shows how a revolutionary leader justified violence, but it gives his side only and does not show the experience of the victims or the full scale of the killings.

Source analysis · Justifying the Terror

Claim. Robespierre argues that terror was a legitimate defense of the republic.

Evidence. He calls terror "justice, prompt, severe, inflexible" and presents it as a means to protect the republic's principles.

Reasoning. The argument shows how the emergency of war and rebellion led a government to justify violence, matching the CED's point that the Jacobin republic responded to opposition at home and war abroad with the Terror. Because he was defending his own government, the speech cannot be used to measure the real scale of the killings or their effects on society.

Worked example · Radical measures

Question. Explain one way the radical phase of the French Revolution differed from the liberal phase.

Model. The liberal phase created a constitutional monarchy, abolished privilege, and set up an elected assembly under the king, while the radical phase abolished the monarchy and executed Louis XVI, and the Jacobin republic used emergency measures: the Reign of Terror to destroy opposition, price controls, mass conscription, and de-Christianization. Government became more centralized and more violent in response to war and civil conflict.

Exam focus

Be able to describe two phases and the link between them: war and fear of counterrevolution moved the revolution from a constitutional monarchy to the Terror. Use the CED's list of radical policies (Terror, price and wage controls, de-Christianization) and the levée en masse as a source of military power. Avoid saying Robespierre acted alone; the Committee, the Convention, and the sans-culottes all mattered, and Robespierre himself fell victim to the process.

Practice
  1. What caused the fall of the monarchy in 1792?
    Show answer

    War with Austria and Prussia, fear of royal betrayal after Louis XVI's flight to Varennes, and the Brunswick Manifesto led to the storming of the Tuileries.

  2. What was the levée en masse?
    Show answer

    A 1793 decree of mass conscription that put the whole nation at the service of the war and raised huge citizen armies.

  3. Describe two features of the Reign of Terror.
    Show answer

    The Law of Suspects and Revolutionary Tribunal allowed swift arrests and trials, and thousands were executed by guillotine.

  4. What was de-Christianization?
    Show answer

    A policy of closing churches, encouraging a Cult of Reason, and introducing a new calendar to remove Christianity from public life.

  5. How did Thermidor end the Terror?
    Show answer

    Deputies overthrew and executed Robespierre on 9 Thermidor (July 27, 1794), and the Convention moved to a more moderate government, the Directory.

  6. How did revolutionary armies spread the revolution?
    Show answer

    They defeated old-regime armies, occupied neighboring lands, abolished feudal privileges, and set up sister republics, turning defense into conquest.

Lesson 5.5 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.5

The effects of the French Revolution

The revolution did not stay inside France. Learning Objective E asks how the events and developments of the French Revolution influenced political and social ideas between 1648 and 1815. The CED gives two main examples. Revolutionary ideals inspired a revolt of enslaved people led by Toussaint L'Ouverture in Saint-Domingue, which became the independent nation of Haiti in 1804; and, while many were inspired by the revolution's emphasis on equality and human rights, others condemned its violence and disregard for traditional authority.

Required content · 5E

Learning objective.

  • 5E. Explain how the events and developments of the French Revolution influenced political and social ideas from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.IV.F. Revolutionary ideals inspired a revolt of enslaved people led by Toussaint L’Ouverture in the French colony of Saint-Domingue, which became the independent nation of Haiti in 1804.
  • 2.1.IV.G. While many were inspired by the revolution’s emphasis on equality and human rights, others condemned its violence and disregard for traditional authority.

The Haitian Revolution

Saint-Domingue, the French sugar colony on the western part of Hispaniola, was the richest colony in the world, and it depended on the labor of about half a million enslaved people. In 1789 its society was divided among white planters and officials, free people of color, and the enslaved majority.

  • 1791. News of the revolution divided the white colonists and raised the hopes of free people of color for equal rights. In August 1791 enslaved people in the north rose in a massive revolt.
  • Toussaint L'Ouverture. A formerly enslaved man of exceptional military and political ability, he became the leading commander. He fought Spanish and British invaders and, after the French government abolished slavery in 1794 (the National Convention's decree, extended to the colonies), he joined the French side and governed the colony.
  • Napoleon's response. In 1802 Napoleon sent an expedition to restore French control and slavery. Toussaint was seized and died in a French prison in 1803. His successors, notably Jean-Jacques Dessalines, defeated the French, helped by yellow fever.
  • Independence. On January 1, 1804, Haiti declared independence as the first state founded by formerly enslaved people, and the second independent republic in the Americas. France's loss pushed Napoleon to sell Louisiana to the United States in 1803.

The revolution proved that the ideals of liberty and equality could be claimed by enslaved people, and it frightened slaveholders in the Americas, while inspiring opponents of slavery and later independence movements. Note the CED's wording: revolutionary ideals inspired the revolt, which began as a rebellion against slavery and colonial rule with its own goals.

Reactions: inspiration

Many Europeans welcomed the revolution's emphasis on equality and human rights. Reformers in Britain, Ireland, the German states, the Netherlands, and Italy saw hope for change. The Declaration of the Rights of Man became a model for later reformers. The revolution's sweeping reforms (the end of feudal privilege, legal equality, a written constitution, secular government) became a standard against which later movements measured themselves.

Reactions: condemnation

Others were horrified. Edmund Burke, a British statesman who had supported the American colonists, published Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790), warning that the destruction of traditional institutions would lead to disorder and tyranny, and he is regarded as a founder of modern conservatism. His prediction seemed borne out by the Terror. Mary Wollstonecraft answered him in A Vindication of the Rights of Men (1790), defending the revolution's principles. Many rulers and nobles viewed the revolution as a threat, and governments across Europe censored and suppressed reformers as a result.

Lasting effects on ideas

  • Equality and citizenship. The idea that people are citizens with equal rights, and that governments depend on the nation, not on the monarch's divine right, spread. (The practice excluded women and the enslaved at first, but the principle could be used against exclusion.)
  • Nationalism. The idea of the nation as a community of citizens, shown by mass armies fighting for their country, became powerful (Lesson 5.6).
  • Political language. Words such as left and right (from the seating in the Assembly), liberal, and conservative, and the idea of a revolution as a model, entered political life.
  • Secularism. The attack on the Catholic Church and the creation of civil institutions weakened clerical power in public life.
Primary source · A conservative warning

Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790), excerpt.

The age of chivalry is gone. That of sophisters, economists, and calculators, has succeeded; and the glory of Europe is extinguished for ever.

Sourcing (HIPP). Burke was a member of the British Parliament writing in 1790, before the Terror, in a long letter to a French correspondent that was published in England. His purpose was to warn against imitating the revolution in Britain and to defend inherited institutions, and his audience was educated British readers. He wrote with emotion, and the passage is about the queen's humiliation during the October Days. As evidence, it shows a leading conservative reaction, but it presents one view, and it did not predict events exactly.

Source analysis · A critique of change

Claim. Burke argues that the revolution has destroyed a valuable social order and replaced it with cold calculation.

Evidence. He says "the age of chivalry is gone" and has been replaced by "sophisters, economists, and calculators."

Reasoning. The line shows the CED's second kind of reaction: condemnation of the revolution's disregard for traditional authority. Burke's alarm was based on early events and on an idealized view of the old regime, so the passage is better evidence of the origins of conservative thought than of what actually happened in France.

Worked example · Influence

Question. Explain one way the French Revolution influenced political ideas outside France.

Model. Revolutionary ideals of equality and rights inspired the revolt of enslaved people in Saint-Domingue led by Toussaint L'Ouverture, which created independent Haiti in 1804 and showed that universal principles could be used to challenge slavery and colonial rule. In Europe the revolution also produced a conservative response, such as Burke's, that defended traditional authority and condemned the revolution's violence.

Exam focus

Learning Objective E asks for influence on political and social ideas, so name a set of ideas (equality, human rights, nationalism, secularism) and a reaction on each side: supporters (reformers, Haiti) and critics (Burke, conservatives, ruling elites). Treat Haiti as a revolution in its own right, inspired by the French ideals. Avoid describing the revolution as only violent or only liberating; the CED shows both responses.

Practice
  1. What event in Saint-Domingue did revolutionary ideals inspire?
    Show answer

    A revolt of enslaved people beginning in 1791, led by Toussaint L'Ouverture, that ended in independent Haiti in 1804.

  2. What happened to Toussaint L'Ouverture after Napoleon sent troops in 1802?
    Show answer

    He was captured and died in a French prison in 1803; Dessalines carried on and won independence.

  3. Why did some Europeans welcome the revolution?
    Show answer

    They were inspired by its emphasis on equality, human rights, and the end of privilege.

  4. What was Burke's main criticism?
    Show answer

    That the revolution destroyed traditional institutions and authority, which would lead to disorder and tyranny.

  5. Give one lasting effect of the revolution on political ideas.
    Show answer

    The idea of equal citizenship and rights, the force of nationalism, or the language of left, right, liberal, and conservative.

  6. Why is it misleading to say the revolution gave equal rights to everyone?
    Show answer

    The practice excluded women, the poor, and the enslaved at first, though the principles were later used against those exclusions.

Lesson 5.6 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.6

Napoleon: rise, dominance, and defeat

In 1799 a young general took power in France, and for fifteen years he dominated Europe. Learning Objective F asks you to explain the effects of Napoleon's rule on European social, economic, and political life, and Learning Objective G asks about the nationalist responses to Napoleon's rule. The CED's three statements are: Napoleon undertook enduring domestic reforms while curtailing rights and manipulating popular impulses behind a façade of representative institutions; his new military tactics let him control much of the continent, spreading the ideals of the revolution; and his expanding empire created nationalist responses.

Required content · 5F, 5G

Learning objectives.

  • 5F. Explain the effects of Napoleon’s rule on European social, economic, and political life.
  • 5G. Explain the nationalist responses to Napoleon’s rule in Europe.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.V.A. As first consul and emperor, Napoleon undertook a number of enduring domestic reforms while often curtailing some rights and manipulating popular impulses behind a façade of representative institutions.
  • 2.1.V.B. Napoleon’s new military tactics allowed him to exert direct or indirect control over much of the European continent, spreading the ideals of the French Revolution across Europe.
  • 2.1.V.C. Napoleon’s expanding empire created nationalist responses throughout Europe.

The rise to power

Napoleon Bonaparte, from a minor Corsican noble family, rose quickly in the revolutionary army and won fame in Italy and Egypt. The Directory was weak, and in November 1799 (the coup of 18 Brumaire) he and allies overthrew it and made himself First Consul. A plebiscite approved the new constitution, and in 1802 he became consul for life. In 1804, again confirmed by a plebiscite, he crowned himself Emperor of the French.

Domestic reforms

The CED says Napoleon undertook a number of enduring domestic reforms.

  • The Civil Code (1804). A single, clear body of law for all of France, based on equality before the law, protection of property, and religious toleration, and the end of feudal privilege. It spread across Europe and still influences European law.
  • Centralized administration. Prefects appointed by Paris governed each department, and tax collection was efficient. The Bank of France (1800) stabilized finances.
  • Careers open to talent. Government and army posts were given for ability, not birth, and a new Legion of Honor rewarded service.
  • Education. State secondary schools (lycées) and a central university system trained officials and officers.
  • The Concordat of 1801. An agreement with the pope that recognized Catholicism as the religion of most French people but kept church lands in the hands of those who had bought them and put clergy under state supervision. It ended the religious split of the 1790s.

Rights curtailed

The same government curtailed rights and manipulated popular support behind a façade of representative institutions. Plebiscites and powerless assemblies gave the look of consent. Napoleon used a secret police under Joseph Fouché and censorship of newspapers and books. The Civil Code limited women's rights: a wife owed obedience to her husband and had limited control over property, and divorce was restricted. In this sense he kept the revolution's legal equality for men but ended its political freedom.

Military tactics and the empire

Napoleon was a master of rapid movement, using large citizen armies, flexible army corps, and concentration of force against the weak point of the enemy. After victories such as Austerlitz (1805) over Austria and Russia, and Jena (1806) over Prussia, he controlled much of the continent, either directly or through allied states and kingdoms ruled by his relatives. His victories brought about the end of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806, and he rearranged German states into a Confederation of the Rhine.

In the territories he held, Napoleon spread the ideals of the French Revolution: he abolished feudal dues and serfdom in many places, introduced the Civil Code, ended guild restrictions, and in some places gave Jews legal equality. Many middle-class Europeans welcomed these reforms. But the empire also meant conscription, taxation, looting of art, and rule by French officials in the interest of France.

Economic warfare

Britain, protected by its navy (Trafalgar, 1805), remained at war with him. Napoleon tried to defeat it by the Continental System (1806), forbidding trade with Britain in Europe. The system hurt European economies, and smuggling made it leaky, and enforcing it led him to invade Portugal, Spain, and Russia.

Nationalist responses

The CED says Napoleon's expanding empire created nationalist responses throughout Europe. Examples:

  • Spain. After Napoleon put his brother on the throne in 1808, Spaniards rose in a guerrilla war (the Spanish word for "little war") that tied down French troops for years.
  • The German states. Prussia, humiliated at Jena, carried out reforms of its army and administration, and writers such as Johann Gottlieb Fichte (Addresses to the German Nation, 1807 to 1808) appealed to German national feeling. Students and others protested French rule.
  • Russia. When the tsar left the Continental System, Napoleon invaded in 1812 with the Grand Army of more than 600,000 men. The Russians retreated and used a scorched earth policy, destroying supplies. Napoleon entered Moscow but it burned, and his army was destroyed by hunger, cold, and attack on the retreat.

Defeat

A coalition of Russia, Prussia, Austria, and Britain defeated Napoleon at Leipzig (the Battle of the Nations, 1813), and he abdicated in 1814 and was exiled to Elba. He returned for the Hundred Days in 1815 but was beaten at Waterloo (June 1815) and exiled to St. Helena.

1799 Coup of Brumaire; First Consul 1801 Concordat with the pope 1804 Civil Code; Napoleon crowned emperor 1805 Austerlitz; Trafalgar 1806 Continental System 1808 Spanish uprising 1812 Invasion of Russia 1813 Leipzig 1815 Waterloo; Congress of Vienna ends
Figure 5.3. Napoleon's career. Domestic reforms came first, then conquest, and finally a coalition and nationalist resistance ended the empire.
Primary source · Law in the family

Napoleonic Civil Code (1804), Article 213, excerpt in English translation.

A husband owes protection to his wife; a wife obedience to her husband.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Civil Code was drafted by a commission of jurists under Napoleon's direction, so it is an official law, written to be clear and uniform. Its purpose was to settle the revolution's legal changes and to strengthen the family and state. The audience was the French people, and later the peoples under French rule. The article shows how the Code, while confirming equality before the law for men, put wives under husbands' authority, which fits the CED's statement that Napoleon limited women's rights. It describes what the law required, not how families lived.

Source analysis · Equality and its limits

Claim. The Civil Code confirmed legal hierarchy within the family.

Evidence. Article 213 says a wife owes obedience to her husband.

Reasoning. The line shows that Napoleon's enduring reforms also curtailed some rights, in line with the CED. The Code's equality before the law in property and for male citizens contrasts with this treatment of married women. A law states a standard and does not show how often it was enforced.

Worked example · Effects of his rule

Question. Explain one way Napoleon continued the ideals of the French Revolution and one way he reversed them.

Model. Napoleon continued revolutionary ideals by keeping legal equality, ending feudal privilege, and opening careers to talent, and by spreading these reforms through the Civil Code in lands he controlled. He reversed them by creating a secret police, censoring the press, controlling elections through plebiscites, and limiting women's rights, so he preserved equality of law for men while ending political freedom.

Exam focus

Learning Objective F asks for social, economic, and political effects. Give the CED's balance: enduring reforms (Civil Code, bureaucracy, careers open to talent, Concordat) against curtailed rights (censorship, secret police, façade of representation, limited women's rights). For Learning Objective G, link cause and response: French conquest and domination provoked nationalism (Spain, German states, Russia). Treat the Continental System as an economic failure that led to the invasions of Spain and Russia.

Practice
  1. What came to power in the coup of 18 Brumaire?
    Show answer

    Napoleon and his allies overthrew the Directory and made him First Consul in November 1799.

  2. Name two enduring reforms of Napoleon.
    Show answer

    The Civil Code, a centralized bureaucracy with prefects, the Bank of France, careers open to talent, state schools, or the Concordat of 1801.

  3. How did Napoleon limit freedom?
    Show answer

    Through secret police, censorship, plebiscites with no real choice, and a Civil Code that limited women's rights.

  4. How did Napoleon spread the revolution's ideals?
    Show answer

    In conquered lands he abolished feudal dues and privileges, introduced the Civil Code, and sometimes gave Jews equal rights.

  5. Give two examples of nationalist reactions to Napoleon.
    Show answer

    The guerrilla war in Spain, Prussian reform and German national feeling, or Russian resistance including scorched earth in 1812.

  6. Why did the invasion of Russia fail?
    Show answer

    The Russians retreated and destroyed supplies, Moscow burned, and hunger, cold, and attacks destroyed the Grand Army on its retreat.

Lesson 5.7 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.7

The Congress of Vienna

After twenty-five years of revolution and war, the victorious powers met in Vienna to rebuild Europe. Learning Objective H asks you to explain how states responded to Napoleonic rule in Europe and the consequences of the response. The CED's statement is that after the defeat of Napoleon by a coalition of European powers, the Congress of Vienna (1814 to 1815) attempted to restore the balance of power in Europe and contain the danger of revolutionary or nationalistic upheavals in the future.

Required content · 5H

Learning objective.

  • 5H. Explain how states responded to Napoleonic rule in Europe and the consequences of the response.

Historical developments.

  • 2.1.V.D. After the defeat of Napoleon by a coalition of European powers, the Congress of Vienna (1814–1815) attempted to restore the balance of power in Europe and contain the danger of revolutionary or nationalistic upheavals in the future.

Who met and what they wanted

The Congress, hosted by Austria in 1814 and 1815 (interrupted by Napoleon's Hundred Days), was dominated by the four great powers that had defeated him.

  • Klemens von Metternich, Austria's foreign minister and the host, wanted stability and a strong, conservative Habsburg monarchy in the center of Europe.
  • Viscount Castlereagh, Britain's foreign secretary, wanted a balance of power and a stable continent, which suited British trade and security.
  • Tsar Alexander I of Russia wanted a leading role for Russia and, at times, spoke of a Christian union of monarchs.
  • Prussia, represented by Hardenberg, wanted more territory.
  • Talleyrand, representing defeated France, skillfully argued that France should be treated as an equal partner under its restored Bourbon king, Louis XVIII.

The principles

The statesmen held three ideas in common.

  • Balance of power. No single state should be strong enough to dominate Europe, as France had.
  • Legitimacy. Rightful hereditary rulers, such as the Bourbons in France and Spain, should be restored, since revolutions were seen as the source of war.
  • Compensation and containment. The great powers would gain territory, and a ring of stronger states would surround France to prevent renewed expansion.

The settlement

  • France was reduced roughly to its 1792 borders, was required to pay an indemnity and accept an army of occupation for a time, but was not harshly punished, so it would not seek revenge.
  • Containing France. The Austrian Netherlands (Belgium) were joined to the Dutch Republic to make a stronger Netherlands, Prussia received lands on the Rhine, and Piedmont in Italy was strengthened.
  • Austria gained Lombardy and Venetia and kept influence in Italy, and Metternich led a German Confederation of thirty-nine states under Austrian presidency, a loose union instead of a unified Germany.
  • Russia received most of Poland (the "Congress Poland"), and Prussia gained part of Saxony.
  • Britain kept naval bases and colonies it had taken, such as Cape Colony, Malta, and Ceylon.

The Concert of Europe

Beyond the treaty, the powers agreed to meet regularly to settle disputes, a system called the Concert of Europe (Lesson 6.4). Russia, Austria, and Prussia also formed the Holy Alliance (1815), pledging to rule by Christian principles, which in practice meant cooperation against revolution.

Consequences

  • Peace among the great powers. No general European war occurred until the Crimean War (1853 to 1856), and none involving all the great powers until 1914. Historians credit the balance and the consultation system.
  • Conservative restoration. The settlement favored dynasties and the old order and resisted constitutions.
  • Neglect of nationalism and liberalism. The negotiators ignored the national feelings that Napoleon's wars had aroused: Poland, Italy, and Germany were divided, and Belgians were placed under Dutch rule. In the CED's words the aim was to contain the danger of revolutionary and nationalistic upheavals, but they could not be removed, and they returned in the revolutions of 1820, 1830, and 1848 (Unit 6).
Primary source · The new map of Europe

Description of: The Final Act of the Congress of Vienna (June 1815). The act sets boundaries and forms of government across Europe: it joins Belgium to the Netherlands, creates the German Confederation, gives Lombardy and Venetia to Austria, and assigns most of Poland to the Russian tsar.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Final Act is an international treaty negotiated by the monarchs and diplomats of the great powers, so it reflects their interests, and the peoples whose lands were transferred, such as Poles, Italians, Belgians, and Norwegians, had no part in the decisions. Its purpose was to end the wars and prevent a new one. The text shows how the powers drew boundaries to balance one another, but it says nothing about the nationalist and liberal feeling that would later challenge the settlement.

Source analysis · Diplomacy without the peoples

Claim. The Final Act reorganized Europe to contain France and maintain a balance among the great powers.

Evidence. It combined Belgium with the Netherlands, formed the German Confederation under Austria, and gave Austria and Russia territory in Italy and Poland.

Reasoning. The terms match the CED's account of an attempt to restore the balance and contain revolution. The act treats territories as pieces in a balance and does not consult the people, which helps explain the nationalist and liberal movements that would later undo parts of the settlement.

Worked example · Responses and consequences

Question. Explain one way the Congress of Vienna responded to Napoleonic rule and one consequence.

Model. The Congress surrounded France with stronger states, such as a united Netherlands and a larger Prussia on the Rhine, and restored the Bourbon monarchy in order to prevent renewed French expansion and to contain revolution. One consequence was a long period without a general European war, because the powers kept a balance and consulted one another; another was that the settlement ignored nationalism and liberalism, which led to later revolts.

Exam focus

Learning Objective H wants the response (balance of power, legitimacy, containing France, the Concert) and its consequences (long peace; conservative order; neglected nationalism). Balance your judgment: the Congress was not simply reactionary, since it tried to avoid humiliating France and kept peace for decades, yet it also repressed popular and national movements. Always tie the CED's two aims, balance of power and containing revolutionary or nationalistic upheaval, to specific provisions.

Practice
  1. Which powers dominated the Congress of Vienna?
    Show answer

    Austria, Britain, Russia, and Prussia, with France represented by Talleyrand.

  2. What three principles guided the peacemakers?
    Show answer

    Balance of power, legitimacy (restoring hereditary rulers), and compensation and containment of France.

  3. How did the settlement contain France?
    Show answer

    It reduced France to roughly its 1792 borders and strengthened neighbors such as the Netherlands (with Belgium), Prussia on the Rhine, and Piedmont.

  4. What was the German Confederation?
    Show answer

    A loose union of thirty-nine German states under Austrian leadership, created instead of a unified Germany.

  5. What was one positive consequence of the Congress?
    Show answer

    A long period without a general European war, helped by the balance of power and the Concert of Europe.

  6. What did the Congress overlook that caused later trouble?
    Show answer

    The nationalist and liberal feelings aroused by the revolution and Napoleon, which later produced revolts and unification movements.

Lesson 5.8 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.8

Romanticism and the religious revival

Just as the Enlightenment seemed to be winning, a movement arose that valued feeling over reason. Learning Objective I asks you to explain how and why the Romantic Movement and religious revival challenged Enlightenment thought. The CED gives four statements. Rousseau questioned the exclusive reliance on reason and emphasized emotions in the moral improvement of self and society; Romanticism emerged as a challenge to Enlightenment rationality; consistent with it, religious revival occurred, including Methodism, founded by John Wesley; and revolution, war, and rebellion demonstrated the emotional power of mass politics and nationalism.

Required content · 5I

Learning objective.

  • 5I. Explain how and why the Romantic Movement and religious revival challenged Enlightenment thought from 1648 to 1815.

Historical developments.

  • 2.3.VI.A. Rousseau questioned the exclusive reliance on reason and emphasized the role of emotions in the moral improvement of self and society.
  • 2.3.VI.B. Romanticism emerged as a challenge to Enlightenment rationality.
  • 2.3.VI.C. Consistent with the Romantic Movement, religious revival occurred in Europe and included notable movements such as Methodism, founded by John Wesley.
  • 2.3.VI.D. Revolution, war and rebellion demonstrated the emotional power of mass politics and nationalism.

Rousseau's challenge

Rousseau (Lesson 4.2) was himself an Enlightenment figure, but his writings opened a different path. In Émile and in his Confessions he argued that people are naturally good, that civilization corrupts them, and that feeling, conscience, and direct experience matter as much as reasoning. His emphasis on emotion in the moral life, and on the individual's inner self, influenced the Romantics.

The Romantic Movement

Romanticism, which flourished from the 1790s to the 1840s, was an artistic and intellectual movement that broke from Neoclassical forms and from the Enlightenment's faith in reason alone. Its main themes were:

  • Emotion and imagination. Romantics held that deep feeling, intuition, and the creative imagination reach truths that reason alone cannot. Genius and originality were prized.
  • Nature. Nature was not a machine to be measured, as in Newton's science, but a source of beauty, awe, and spiritual renewal, including the sublime (the overwhelming power of mountains and storms).
  • The individual. The artist, rebel, or lonely hero stood against convention and society.
  • The past and the folk. Romantics studied medieval history, legend, and peasant folk tales as expressions of national character. Johann Gottfried Herder argued that each people (Volk) has its own spirit and language, and the Brothers Grimm collected German folk tales. This love of the national past would feed nationalism.

The movement appeared in all the arts: poets such as William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who published Lyrical Ballads (1798), and later Byron, Shelley, and Keats; the German writers Goethe and Schiller; the composer Ludwig van Beethoven, whose music broke classical forms; and painters such as Caspar David Friedrich, J. M. W. Turner, and Eugène Delacroix. Unit 7 returns to the arts (Lesson 7.7).

Religious revival

The CED says the Romantic Movement was accompanied by religious revival. The Enlightenment's critics of the church had not ended religious feeling, and many people sought a more emotional faith.

  • Methodism. John Wesley, an Anglican priest, began a movement in the 1730s that stressed personal conversion, discipline, and preaching to ordinary people, including coal miners and workers. It grew into a separate church and was influential among the working class in Britain.
  • Pietism and evangelicalism. In the German states, Pietists emphasized heartfelt faith over doctrine, and similar evangelical revivals occurred in Britain and elsewhere. In Catholic regions, devotion revived after the revolution.

These movements challenged the Enlightenment's rational religion (deism) with an appeal to emotion and personal experience.

The emotional power of mass politics

The CED adds that revolution, war, and rebellion demonstrated the emotional power of mass politics and nationalism. The French Revolution and Napoleonic Wars had shown that crowds, citizen armies, songs, flags, and speeches could move millions (Lessons 5.4 and 5.6). Romantic writers and artists described the nation as a living community, and many political leaders learned to use symbol and sentiment. Not all Romantics were conservatives: some were revolutionaries and some were nationalists.

Primary source · A new definition of poetry

William Wordsworth, Preface to the Lyrical Ballads (1800), excerpt.

...all good poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings.

Sourcing (HIPP). Wordsworth wrote the preface to defend a new kind of poetry that used everyday language and common people as subjects, in response to the formal poetry of the eighteenth century. His audience was educated English readers and critics, and his purpose was to explain and justify the experiment. The line is a statement of Romantic principles, so it shows the movement's own view, but it represents one poet and does not describe what every Romantic believed.

Source analysis · Feeling over rules

Claim. Wordsworth defines good poetry as the expression of strong feeling.

Evidence. He calls it "the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings."

Reasoning. The definition shifts the source of art from rules and reason to emotion, in line with the CED's description of Romanticism as a challenge to Enlightenment rationality. The statement reflects the views of a poet defending his own work, so it should be compared with other Romantics, some of whom stressed nature, the supernatural, or politics instead.

Worked example · Challenge to the Enlightenment

Question. Explain one way the Romantic Movement challenged Enlightenment thought.

Model. Romantics rejected the Enlightenment's exclusive reliance on reason and its view of nature as a machine. They emphasized emotion, imagination, and the individual, as in Wordsworth's poetry and Beethoven's music, and they valued nature as a source of beauty and awe. A similar challenge came from religious revival, as in Methodism, which stressed emotional personal faith over rational religion.

Exam focus

Learning Objective I links three things: Rousseau's emphasis on feeling, the Romantic Movement, and religious revival (Methodism), all challenging rationality. Add the CED's fourth point: revolution and war showed the emotional power of mass politics and nationalism. Avoid describing Romanticism as simply anti-Enlightenment; it grew out of Rousseau and shared many Enlightenment hopes for human freedom, though it rejected reason as the only guide.

Practice
  1. How did Rousseau help prepare Romanticism?
    Show answer

    He questioned reliance on reason alone and stressed emotion and conscience in moral improvement.

  2. List two themes of Romanticism.
    Show answer

    Emotion and imagination, the beauty and power of nature, the individual, and the national past and folk culture.

  3. Name two Romantic artists or writers and their medium.
    Show answer

    Wordsworth (poetry), Beethoven (music), Friedrich or Turner (painting), Goethe (literature).

  4. What was Methodism and who founded it?
    Show answer

    A religious revival movement stressing personal conversion and preaching to ordinary people, founded by John Wesley.

  5. How did Romanticism connect to nationalism?
    Show answer

    Romantics valued folk culture, language, and national history as expressions of a people's spirit, and they described the nation as a living community.

  6. Give an example of how war and revolution showed the emotional power of politics.
    Show answer

    French citizen armies and the nationalist uprisings against Napoleon showed that symbols, songs, and loyalty to the nation could mobilize large numbers of people.

Lesson 5.9 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.9

Continuity and change in the eighteenth-century states

The last topic of Unit 5 practices continuity and change over time. Learning Objective J asks you to explain how the developments and challenges to the political order resulted in change in the period from 1648 to 1815. This is the skill of comparing a state of affairs at the start of a period with one at its end, deciding what changed, what did not, and why. Unit 5 is the place to practice it, because the years from 1648 to 1815 contain both an old order that survived and a revolution that tried to end it.

Required content · 5J

Learning objective.

  • 5J. Explain how the developments and challenges to the political order resulted in change in the period from 1648 to 1815.

Reasoning process. Continuity and change. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

How to build a continuity-and-change argument

  1. Set the period and the topic. Here the topic is political order: who held power and on what basis.
  2. Describe the starting point. In 1648 most states were monarchies justified by tradition and, often, divine right. Societies were organized by privileged estates.
  3. Describe the end point. By 1815 the French Revolution and Napoleon had produced written constitutions, equality before the law in some states, mass armies, and the idea of the nation as the source of authority.
  4. Sort the evidence. List the changes, the continuities, and the turning points.
  5. Explain causes and judge. Say why change happened and whether continuity or change was more significant.

The evidence

Theme1648By 1815Change or continuity?
Source of authorityDivine right, traditionNation and constitution in France; monarchs restored elsewhereBoth: new ideas, old monarchies
Social orderPrivileged estatesLegal equality in France and under Napoleon; privilege remained in most statesChange in France, continuity in the east
WarfareProfessional armies, dynastic warsMass conscript armies and national warChange
Religion and the stateChurches tied to rulersWeaker church power in France; the church restored in 1801Change with limits
International orderBalance of power after WestphaliaBalance of power restored at ViennaContinuity
EconomyAgricultural, mercantilistStill mainly agricultural; global markets grownBoth

Turning points

  • 1648, Westphalia: sovereign states replaced universal Christendom.
  • 1688 to 1689, Glorious Revolution: a king limited by Parliament.
  • 1756 to 1763, Seven Years' War: the shift of power to Britain and the debts that led to revolution.
  • 1789, the French Revolution: the claim that sovereignty belongs to the nation, and the end of privileges in France.
  • 1799 to 1815, Napoleon and Vienna: the spread of revolutionary reforms, a nationalist reaction, and a conservative restoration.

Causes of change

The changes came from several sources working together: the cost of war, which strained finances; Enlightenment ideas that gave critics a language; economic change that created a wealthy middle class excluded from power; and the example of earlier revolutions, in England and America. The CED notes that revolution, war, and rebellion demonstrated the emotional power of mass politics and nationalism, which produced new kinds of political action.

Continuity matters too

Do not overstate change. Most Europeans were still farmers, and in eastern Europe serfdom lasted. Monarchies returned across Europe in 1815. The Congress of Vienna restored the balance of power that had been a principle since 1648, and Britain, Russia, and Austria were great powers before and after.

Primary source · A historian's argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument that the French Revolution was both a break and a continuation. The author argues that the revolution destroyed privilege and introduced the idea of popular sovereignty, a decisive break, but also that it strengthened the centralized state that absolutist monarchs had begun to build and that Napoleon completed.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author is a modern scholar writing with hindsight, so the purpose is to interpret a long-term process, and the audience is students and scholars. As a secondary source, it gives an argument, not direct evidence from 1789. A strong answer identifies the claim (both break and continuity), supports it with facts (abolition of estates; the centralized prefects and Civil Code under Napoleon), and tests it against limits (monarchy and the church were restored in 1815).

Source analysis · Break or continuity

Claim. The historian argues that the revolution both broke with the past and continued state building.

Evidence. Facts that support a break include the abolition of privilege and popular sovereignty; facts that support continuity include the centralization of administration under Napoleon, which built on royal bureaucracy.

Reasoning. The claim avoids a simple either-or and fits the evidence, since the revolution changed the basis of authority but strengthened the machinery of the state. A limit is that the argument focuses on France, and across Europe the restoration of 1815 shows significant continuity with the old order.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in European political order between 1648 and 1815.

Model. One continuity was the principle of the balance of power: after Westphalia, states sought to prevent domination by any one power, and the Congress of Vienna in 1815 used the same principle to contain France. One change was the idea that political authority comes from the nation and the people, not from divine right, which the French Revolution established and Napoleon spread through legal reforms.

Exam focus

A continuity-and-change answer must name both, with specific evidence, and explain why. Use dates and turning points (1648, 1688, 1763, 1789, 1815). When asked about the extent of change, judge: for Unit 5, a good judgment is that the ideas of authority changed profoundly while the international system and much of the social order stayed the same. The CED's learning objective stresses how developments and challenges to the political order produced change.

Practice
  1. Name two things that changed in the political order between 1648 and 1815.
    Show answer

    The source of authority (from divine right toward the nation), the nature of armies (mass conscription), and legal equality in France.

  2. Name two continuities.
    Show answer

    The balance of power among states, monarchies in most countries after 1815, and agricultural economies and serfdom in eastern Europe.

  3. Why was 1789 a turning point?
    Show answer

    The revolution ended legal privilege and claimed that sovereignty belongs to the nation, which challenged the basis of the old order.

  4. How did the Seven Years' War contribute to political change?
    Show answer

    It left Britain and France with heavy debts that led to the American Revolution and the French fiscal crisis.

  5. What is one reason not to overstate change?
    Show answer

    The Congress of Vienna restored monarchies and the balance of power, and most Europeans still lived in agricultural societies with continuing hierarchies.

  6. What does it mean to "judge" the extent of change?
    Show answer

    To weigh the evidence and decide whether change or continuity was more significant, giving reasons and acknowledging limits.

Unit 5 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 5 review: Conflict, Crisis, and Reaction in the Late 18th Century

Ten questions on Britain's ascendancy, the French Revolution from 1789 to Thermidor, its export abroad, Napoleon, and the settlement at Vienna, plus two short-answer questions on revolution and reaction.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, 26 August 1789.

    "Men are born and remain free and equal in rights. … Property being an inviolable and sacred right, no one shall be deprived thereof except where public necessity … clearly demands it."

    The juxtaposition of these two articles helps explain why the Declaration could be used to justify

    Correct. Universal equality justified sweeping away seigneurial privilege, while the sanctity of property supported restricting political rights to men of means: the document's central tension.

    Women were excluded from political rights, and the 1791 constitution divided citizens into active and passive by tax qualification.

    The Declaration followed the night of 4 August, which had abolished those privileges. It was written against them.

    Article 17 declares property inviolable and sacred, which is the opposite of abolishing it.

  2. The immediate cause of the summoning of the Estates-General in 1789 was

    The Great Fear in the countryside came in July 1789, after the Estates-General had already convened. Rural revolt was a consequence, not the cause.

    Correct. Debt service consumed most ordinary revenue, the parlements and Assembly of Notables blocked new taxes on the privileged, and the crown could borrow no further.

    France's intervention in the American war was a strategic success; the damage was financial rather than territorial.

    Louis XVI was alive and reigning in 1789, and was executed in January 1793.

  3. The National Assembly's renunciation of feudal privileges on 4 August 1789 is best understood as

    The deputies had not planned it; the session was called in response to the crisis and the renunciations came in a single dramatic night.

    Correct. With the Great Fear spreading and peasants burning seigneurial records across France, the Assembly abolished dues it could no longer enforce.

    Louis XVI resisted rather than demanded the August decrees and delayed sanctioning them.

    France was not at war in August 1789; war with Austria began in April 1792.

  4. Source: Olympe de Gouges, Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen, 1791.

    "Woman is born free and lives equal to man in her rights. … Woman has the right to mount the scaffold; she must equally have the right to mount the rostrum."

    De Gouges's decision to rewrite the 1789 Declaration article by article was rhetorically effective because it

    Correct. Every clause was recognizable, so the substitution of "woman" made the original's silence impossible to overlook: holding the Revolution to its own premise.

    The parallel structure made the argument more conspicuous, not less. She was executed in 1793.

    She accepted that men had been granted rights; her complaint was that women had been excluded from the same grant.

    She argued from revolutionary principles of natural rights, not from religious tradition.

  5. Which best explains the radicalization of the Revolution after 1791?

    The 1791 constitution satisfied few: it divided citizens by tax qualification and collapsed within a year.

    Correct. War from April 1792, defeat, and the king's suspected collusion produced a permanent emergency in which dissent looked like conspiracy, justifying the Committee of Public Safety.

    The Vendée rising was an internal counter-revolutionary revolt, not a British invasion, and it followed rather than caused radicalization.

    Abolition came in February 1794, during the Terror, and was a consequence of radicalization and events in Saint-Domingue rather than its cause.

  6. Description of: the decree of the French National Convention abolishing slavery in the colonies, February 1794.

    Extremely short. Declares slavery abolished throughout the colonies, states that all men resident there without distinction of color are French citizens, and orders immediate execution. No compensation, timetable, or transitional apprenticeship is provided.

    The decree's brevity and absence of transitional provisions most strongly suggest that it

    Detailed abolitionist legislation elsewhere included compensation and apprenticeship schemes. Their absence here indicates emergency rather than preparation.

    Correct. Enslaved people had been in revolt since 1791 and the colony was effectively outside French control; the decree recognized facts and turned the insurgents into allies against Britain and Spain.

    Napoleon restored slavery in 1802 and sent an army to enforce it, which the Haitians defeated.

    The decree applied to all colonies and made no distinction based on loyalty.

  7. Source: the French Civil Code (Napoleonic Code), 1804, Article 213.

    "The husband owes protection to his wife, the wife obedience to her husband."

    The Code as a whole is best characterized as

    The Code confirmed the abolition of feudalism, careers open to talent, and secure title to land bought during the Revolution: none of which the old regime allowed.

    Correct. It kept legal equality among men and the property settlement of 1789 while restoring husbands' authority and curtailing the divorce and property rights women had gained in the 1790s.

    Article 213 does the opposite for women, and the Code protected property owners rather than the propertyless.

    The Code was imposed across occupied Europe and outlasted Napoleon's empire by generations, forming the basis of many modern legal systems.

  8. The Continental System failed primarily because

    Correct. The Royal Navy could not be excluded from the seas, smuggling was extensive, and client states resenting the loss of British goods became unreliable: a chain leading to the Peninsular War and the Russian campaign.

    Britain expanded trade with the Americas and Asia during the blockade, which is part of why it survived.

    France occupied much of the European coastline; enforcement failed at sea and through smuggling, not for want of soldiers.

    Napoleon maintained and extended the system from 1806 until his fall, and invaded Russia partly over its violation.

  9. The Congress of Vienna's treatment of France after 1815 is best explained by the statesmen's desire to

    France was a defeated aggressor, and the restraint reflected calculation about future stability rather than reward.

    Correct. Moderate terms and the restoration of the Bourbons were designed to give France a stake in the new order, and a ring of strengthened states was built along its frontiers as insurance.

    The settlement was designed to contain France, not to place it at the head of Europe.

    The Congress worked from dynastic legitimacy and explicitly disregarded national self-determination, which is its most criticized feature.

  10. Romanticism is best understood as a reaction against

    Romanticism came three centuries after the Renaissance and often admired medieval rather than classical models.

    Correct. Romantics prized emotion, imagination, nature, the medieval past, and the distinctive genius of each people against Enlightenment universalism and Neoclassical form.

    Predestination was a sixteenth-century theological controversy, not the target of a nineteenth-century artistic movement.

    Romantics objected to a purely mechanical view of nature but did not attempt to refute Newton's physics experimentally.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE cause of the outbreak of the French Revolution in 1789.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way popular action shaped the course of the Revolution between 1789 and 1794.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way the Revolution affected territories outside France.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: fiscal crisis and unpayable debt after the American war; refusal of the privileged orders to accept taxation; bad harvests and bread prices in 1788–1789; Enlightenment criticism of privilege; the deadlock over voting by order. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: the storming of the Bastille making royal dissolution of the Assembly impossible; the Great Fear forcing the abolition of feudalism on 4 August; the October march bringing the king to Paris; sans-culotte pressure driving the Convention toward the Terror. Must show the causal pressure.
    • (c) Accept: the Haitian Revolution and the 1794 abolition decree; sister republics and the export of revolutionary law; the spread of nationalism in reaction to French occupation; the Napoleonic Code adopted across Europe. Must name a specific territory or effect.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The monarchy faced a fiscal crisis it could not resolve. Debt from the Seven Years' War and from intervention in the American war consumed most ordinary revenue, and when the parlements and the Assembly of Notables blocked taxing the nobility and clergy, Louis XVI had to summon the Estates-General for the first time since 1614.

    (b) Peasant revolt during the Great Fear forced the National Assembly's hand. With rural crowds burning seigneurial records across France in July 1789, the deputies renounced feudal dues, tithes, and privileges on the night of 4 August: recognizing in law what peasants were already achieving by force.

    (c) Enslaved people in Saint-Domingue invoked the Declaration's claim that men are born free and equal and revolted from 1791. Their military success compelled the Convention to abolish slavery throughout the colonies in 1794, and the war they continued against Napoleon's attempt to restore it produced Haitian independence in 1804.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way Napoleon preserved changes made by the French Revolution.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way Napoleon reversed changes made by the Revolution.
    3. Briefly explain ONE way the Congress of Vienna's settlement created long-term problems for Europe.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the Civil Code confirming legal equality among men, careers open to talent, and secure title to land sold during the Revolution; the Concordat leaving church lands with their purchasers; abolition of feudal dues carried into occupied territories. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: censorship and secret police; the end of representative government and elected assemblies; making himself emperor in 1804; restoring husbands' legal authority and restricting divorce; restoring slavery in the colonies in 1802. Must be specific.
    • (c) Accept: nationalism disregarded, leaving Germans, Italians, Poles, and Belgians under foreign or divided rule and producing revolts in 1830 and 1848; liberal demands suppressed rather than accommodated; the Concert committed to repressing constitutional movements. Must name the later consequence.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The Civil Code of 1804 confirmed legal equality among men, careers open to talent, and secure ownership for those who had bought confiscated church and noble land during the Revolution, making the abolition of feudal privilege permanent in France and in much of the territory Napoleon controlled.

    (b) He destroyed the Revolution's political liberties. Napoleon censored the press, employed secret police, replaced representative government with plebiscites whose outcome was never in doubt, and crowned himself emperor in 1804, ending the republic the Revolution had created.

    (c) The Congress redistributed territory according to dynastic legitimacy and the balance of power while ignoring national feeling, leaving Italians and Germans divided under Austrian influence and Poland partitioned. Nationalist grievances produced repeated revolts, most seriously in 1848, and eventually the unification of Italy and Germany that overturned the settlement.

Lesson 6.1 · Unit 6 · CED topics 6.1 and 6.2

Industrialization: origins and spread

In the century after 1815 Europe changed from a mainly agricultural society into the first industrial one. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which industrialization originated, developed, and spread, and Learning Objective B asks about the factors that influenced the development of industrialization between 1815 and 1914. This lesson explains why industry began in Britain, how it spread to the continent, and why some regions lagged.

Required content · 6A, 6B

Learning objectives.

  • 6A. Explain the context in which industrialization originated, developed, and spread in Europe.
  • 6B. Explain the factors that influenced the development of industrialization in Europe from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.I.A. Britain’s ready supplies of coal, iron ore, and other essential raw materials promoted industrial growth.
  • 3.1.I.B. Economic institutions and human capital such as engineers, inventors, and capitalists helped Britain lead the process of industrialization, largely through private initiative.
  • 3.1.I.C. Britain’s parliamentary government promoted commercial and industrial interests because those interests were represented in Parliament.
  • 3.1.II.A. France moved toward industrialization at a more gradual pace than Great Britain, with government support and with less dislocation of traditional methods of production.
  • 3.1.II.C. A combination of factors, including geography, lack of resources, the dominance of traditional landed elites, the persistence of serfdom in some areas, and inadequate government sponsorship, accounted for eastern and southern Europe’s lag in industrial development.

The context: what industrialization means

Industrialization is the shift from farm and handicraft production to machines, factories, and fossil-fuel power, along with changes in transport, trade, and society. Historians call the first stage the Industrial Revolution, beginning in Britain in the later eighteenth century with cotton textiles, iron, and steam power. The context was a Europe with growing population, rising agricultural output (Lesson 4.3), expanding world trade (Lesson 5.1), and states that competed in war and wealth.

Typical inventions of the first stage:

  • Textiles. The spinning jenny (Hargreaves, 1764), the water frame (Arkwright, 1769), and the power loom (Cartwright, 1785) multiplied output of cotton cloth.
  • Steam. Newcomen's engine pumped water from mines (1712), and James Watt's improvements (patented 1769) made steam power efficient and usable in factories.
  • Iron and coal. Abraham Darby's use of coke in smelting (1709) made cheap iron available, and the use of coal as fuel spread.
  • Transport. Canals, then railways: George Stephenson's Rocket (1829) and the Liverpool and Manchester Railway (1830) began the railway age.
1709 Darby smelts iron with coke 1769 Watt's engine; water frame 1785 Power loom 1830 Liverpool and Manchester Railway 1834 Zollverein begins 1851 Great Exhibition, London 1856 Bessemer process 1879 Edison's electric lamp 1886 Benz's automobile
Figure 6.1. Industrial milestones. The first wave (coal, iron, steam, textiles) centered on Britain, and the second wave (steel, electricity, the engine) drew in Germany and other states.

Why Britain led

The CED names three groups of factors.

  • Resources. Britain had ready supplies of coal, iron ore, and other essential raw materials, often close to each other and to ports and navigable water.
  • Institutions and people. Economic institutions and human capital, such as engineers, inventors, and capitalists, helped Britain lead, largely through private initiative. A banking system, secure property rights, a market for patents, and a skilled workforce let new ideas become businesses. Agricultural improvement had freed workers for factories and produced cash for investment, and colonies supplied raw cotton and markets.
  • Government. Britain's parliamentary government promoted commercial and industrial interests because those interests were represented in Parliament. Landowners and merchants sat in Parliament, so laws favored trade, enclosure, patents, canals, and, in 1846, the repeal of the Corn Laws, which had kept grain prices high.

The Crystal Palace at the Great Exhibition of 1851 in London, a huge glass hall displaying the world's machines, symbolized Britain's leadership.

The spread to the continent

Industry spread in different ways.

  • France moved toward industrialization at a more gradual pace than Britain, with government support and with less dislocation of traditional methods of production. Artisan and small-scale production stayed strong, and the state helped with railways and credit.
  • Belgium industrialized early because it had coal and iron, and parts of the German states, such as the Ruhr and Saxony, followed in the 1830s and later. Governments built railways and canals and, in 1834, the Prussian-led Zollverein, a customs union, lowered trade barriers.
  • Eastern and southern Europe lagged. The CED lists geography, lack of resources, the dominance of traditional landed elites, the persistence of serfdom in some areas, and inadequate government sponsorship. Russia, Austria-Hungary, Spain, and southern Italy had little coal, poor transport, small domestic markets, and nobles with no interest in changing the order. Peasants lacked money and freedom to move to factories.

Where agriculture failed, famine followed. Examples are the "Hungry Forties" of crop failures in the mid-1840s and the Irish potato famine (1845 to 1852), in which perhaps a million people died and a million more emigrated.

Primary source · The exhibition and progress

Prince Albert, speech at the Mansion House, London (March 21, 1850), excerpt.

The Exhibition of 1851 is to give us a true test and a living picture of the point of development at which the whole of mankind has arrived in this great task...

Sourcing (HIPP). Albert was the husband of Queen Victoria and president of the Royal Commission for the Exhibition, so his purpose was to win public and business support for the event, and the audience was London's civic and commercial leaders. His point of view reflects confidence in progress and in Britain's role as host. The passage shows how elites in the industrial lead state saw industry: as a universal sign of civilization. It cannot tell us how workers, or the people who supplied raw materials, experienced industrialization.

Source analysis · A vision of progress

Claim. Albert presents industrial development as a measure of human progress that the exhibition will display.

Evidence. He says the exhibition will give "a true test and a living picture" of how far "the whole of mankind has arrived."

Reasoning. The statement reflects the optimism of Britain's industrial and political elites, which fits the CED's picture of a state with commercial interests represented in government. A limit is that it is a promotional speech, so it says little about the costs of industrialization for workers or for regions that did not industrialize.

Worked example · Factors

Question. Explain one factor that helped Britain industrialize earlier than other European states and one reason eastern Europe lagged.

Model. Britain had ready supplies of coal and iron ore and a government in which commercial and industrial interests were represented, so laws favored trade and investment. Eastern Europe lagged partly because of the persistence of serfdom and dominance of landed elites, which kept peasants from moving to cities and left little demand for manufactured goods, along with poor transport and lack of resources.

Exam focus

Learning Objective B asks for factors, so build answers from three groups: resources (coal, iron), institutions and people (banks, engineers, private initiative, parliament that served commercial interests), and the pace and method of spread (France gradual with government support; Britain and Belgium early; eastern and southern Europe late for stated reasons). Keep the contrast between regions in mind, since the exam often asks you to explain why industrialization developed unevenly.

Practice
  1. Name two inventions of the first Industrial Revolution.
    Show answer

    The spinning jenny, water frame, power loom, Watt's steam engine, the railway locomotive, or coke-smelted iron.

  2. Give two reasons Britain industrialized first.
    Show answer

    Ready supplies of coal and iron ore, strong economic institutions and human capital such as engineers and capitalists, and a parliament representing commercial interests.

  3. How did French industrialization differ from British?
    Show answer

    It was slower, with government support and less disruption of traditional production methods.

  4. What was the Zollverein?
    Show answer

    A customs union led by Prussia (1834) that lowered trade barriers among German states and helped industrial growth.

  5. Give two reasons eastern and southern Europe lagged.
    Show answer

    Lack of resources and transport, the dominance of landed elites, serfdom, and inadequate government sponsorship.

  6. What was the Irish potato famine and what did it show?
    Show answer

    A famine of 1845 to 1852 caused by crop failure that killed about a million people and drove another million to emigrate, showing the danger of dependence on a single crop in an agricultural economy.

Lesson 6.2 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.3

The second wave of industrialization and its effects

After about 1870 a second wave of industrial innovation, centered on steel, chemicals, electricity, and the internal combustion engine, transformed Europe again. Learning Objective C asks how innovations and advances in technology during the Industrial Revolutions led to economic and social change, and Learning Objective D asks how industrialization influenced economic and political development between 1815 and 1914. The CED stresses mechanization, integrated national economies, new industries, and the efforts of states to manage business cycles.

Required content · 6C, 6D

Learning objectives.

  • 6C. Explain how innovations and advances in technology during the Industrial Revolutions led to economic and social change.
  • 6D. Explain how industrialization influenced economic and political development throughout the period from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.1.III.A. Mechanization and the factory system became the predominant modes of production by 1914.
  • 3.1.III.B. New technologies and means of communication and transportation, including railroads, resulted in more fully integrated national economies, a higher level of urbanization, and a truly global economic network.
  • 3.2.IV.B. New, efficient methods of transportation and other innovations created new industries, improved the distribution of goods, increased consumerism, and enhanced quality of life.
  • 3.1.III.C. Volatile business cycles in the last quarter of the 19th century led corporations and governments to try to manage the market through a variety of methods, including monopolies, banking practices, and tariffs.
  • 3.2.II.A. Along with better harvests caused in part by the commercialization of agriculture, industrialization promoted population growth, longer life expectancy, and lowered infant mortality.
  • 3.2.IV.A. Industrialization in Prussia allowed that state to become the leader of a unified Germany, which subsequently underwent rapid industrialization under government sponsorship.

The second wave

The first wave (textiles, coal, iron, steam) was mostly British. The second wave drew in Germany, France, Belgium, the United States, and Japan, and relied more on science and large organizations.

  • Steel. The Bessemer process (1856) and later methods made cheap steel for rails, ships, machines, and buildings.
  • Chemicals. New dyes, fertilizers, explosives, and medicines came from laboratory research, especially in Germany.
  • Electricity. Generators, electric lighting (Edison, 1879), and electric motors and streetcars changed factories and cities and created utilities.
  • Engines and communication. The internal combustion engine (Otto, 1876; Daimler and Benz in the 1880s) led to the automobile and, by 1903, the airplane. The telegraph, telephone (1876), and radio (1890s) sped communication, and steamships and refrigerated rail cars carried goods and food across the world.
  • Organization. Mass production with interchangeable parts and assembly methods, and large firms like Krupp in Essen and Siemens in Berlin.

Economic effects

  • Mechanization and the factory system became the predominant modes of production by 1914, replacing the household and craft workshop in most branches of manufacturing.
  • Integrated economies. The CED notes that new technologies of communication and transportation, including railroads, produced more fully integrated national economies, a higher level of urbanization, and a truly global economic network. A farmer in Ukraine and a mill owner in Manchester could be linked by markets, telegraph, and steamship.
  • New industries and consumerism. The CED lists new, efficient methods of transportation and other innovations that created new industries, improved the distribution of goods, increased consumerism, and enhanced quality of life: railways, refrigerated cars, ice boxes, streetcars, bicycles, the chemical industry, electric utilities, and later the automobile and leisure travel. Department stores such as the Bon Marché in Paris (1852) sold ready-made goods with fixed prices.
  • Business cycles and the state. In the last quarter of the nineteenth century, volatile business cycles (a long depression from the 1870s to the 1890s) led corporations and governments to try to manage the market through monopolies and cartels, banking practices, and tariffs. Large firms combined to control prices, and states raised tariffs to protect their industries.

Demographic effects

Along with better harvests caused in part by the commercialization of agriculture, industrialization promoted population growth, longer life expectancy, and lowered infant mortality. Better food, cheaper clothing, and later sanitation and medicine played a part. Europe's population rose rapidly, and many people emigrated to the Americas and elsewhere.

Political effects: Germany

The CED singles out Germany: industrialization in Prussia allowed that state to become the leader of a unified Germany, which subsequently underwent rapid industrialization under government sponsorship. Prussia's coal and iron in the Ruhr and Silesia, its railways, and the Zollverein gave it economic leadership in the German states, and the money and weapons to win wars (Lesson 7.2). After unification in 1871, the new Germany surpassed Britain in steel and chemicals by 1914, and its government supported banks, railways, and tariffs. This economic rise changed the balance of power.

Primary source · A company and its image

Description of: A photograph of the Krupp cast-steel works at Essen, Germany, from the later nineteenth century. The image shows rows of tall chimneys, large sheds, and railway lines extending into the distance, with a crowd of workers by the gate. The firm, which made rails, guns, and machinery, was one of the largest industrial enterprises in Europe.

Sourcing (HIPP). Photographs of this kind were often commissioned by the company, so the purpose was to display its size and power to customers and governments. The audience was clients, officials, and the public at exhibitions. The image shows the scale of second-wave industry and the importance of heavy industry and private enterprise working with the state, since the firm supplied armies. It shows what the company wanted to be seen and does not show workers' conditions or opinions.

Source analysis · Scale and purpose

Claim. The photograph presents large-scale steel and arms production as a source of national and corporate power.

Evidence. It shows many chimneys, large buildings, railway lines, and workers.

Reasoning. The scale supports the CED's point that mechanization and the factory system had become predominant and that German industry grew under close relations with the state. As a company image, it presents the owner's view of the works, so it cannot show conditions of work or how workers saw the factory.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way new technologies of transportation and communication changed Europe between 1870 and 1914.

Model. Railways, steamships, the telegraph, and refrigerated transport linked national economies and created a global network of trade. Food and goods could move across continents, new industries and department stores appeared, and consumer culture grew, while cities grew because people could live and work in larger concentrations.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives C and D are about economic and social change and political and economic development. Group your evidence: technology (steel, chemicals, electricity, the engine, the telegraph), economic effects (factory system, integrated markets, consumerism, cartels and tariffs), demographic effects, and political effects (Prussia and then Germany). Note the CED's careful verbs: states and companies tried to manage the market, and with limited success.

Practice
  1. Name two technologies of the second wave of industrialization.
    Show answer

    Steel (Bessemer process), electricity, chemicals, the internal combustion engine, the telephone and telegraph, or the airplane.

  2. What had become the predominant mode of production by 1914?
    Show answer

    Mechanization and the factory system.

  3. How did railways and the telegraph change economies?
    Show answer

    They integrated national economies, increased urbanization, and helped create a global economic network.

  4. Why did businesses and governments try to manage markets after 1873?
    Show answer

    Volatile business cycles and depressions led firms to form monopolies and cartels and states to use banking practices and tariffs.

  5. How did industrialization help Prussia unify Germany?
    Show answer

    Industrial growth gave Prussia the economic leadership of the German states and the resources for war, and Germany then industrialized rapidly under state sponsorship.

  6. Give one demographic effect of industrialization.
    Show answer

    Population growth, longer life expectancy, and lower infant mortality, along with migration to cities and abroad.

Lesson 6.3 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.4

The social effects of industrialization

Industrialization changed how people worked, where they lived, and how they understood themselves. Learning Objective E asks you to explain the causes and consequences of social developments resulting from industrialization. The CED lists effects on classes, cities, families, working conditions, and leisure. A theme throughout is that industrialization produced new self-conscious classes and new pressures on the family.

Required content · 6E

Learning objective.

  • 6E. Explain the causes and consequences of social developments resulting from industrialization.

Historical developments.

  • 3.2.I.A. In industrialized areas of Europe (i.e., western and northern Europe), socioeconomic changes created divisions of labor that led to the development of self-conscious classes, including the proletariat and the bourgeoisie.
  • 3.2.I.B. In some of the less industrialized areas of Europe, the dominance of agricultural elites continued into the 20th century.
  • 3.2.I.C. Class identity developed and was reinforced through participation in philanthropic, political, and social associations among the middle classes, and in mutual aid societies and trade unions among the working classes.
  • 3.2.II.B. With migration from rural to urban areas in industrialized regions, cities experienced overcrowding, while affected rural areas suffered declines in available labor as well as weakened communities.
  • 3.2.III.A. Bourgeois families became focused on the nuclear family and the cult of domesticity, with distinct gender roles for men and women.
  • 3.2.III.B. By the end of the century, higher wages, laws restricting the labor of children and women, social welfare programs, improved diet, and increased access to birth control affected the quality of life for the working class.
  • 3.2.III.C. Economic motivations for marriage, while still important for all classes, diminished as the middle-class notion of companionate marriage began to be adopted by the working classes.
  • 3.2.III.D. Leisure time centered increasingly on the family or small groups, concurrent with the development of activities and spaces to use that time.

New classes

In the industrialized areas of western and northern Europe, socioeconomic change created divisions of labor that led to the development of self-conscious classes.

  • The bourgeoisie included factory owners, bankers, merchants, and professionals. Their income came from business and trade, and they valued thrift, education, and hard work. Samuel Smiles's Self-Help (1859) became a manual of the middle-class creed.
  • The proletariat (the industrial working class) sold its labor for wages. Workers lived in rented housing in the new industrial towns and worked long hours in factories, mills, and mines, under the clock and under supervision, with little security.
  • In less industrialized regions, the CED says the dominance of agricultural elites continued into the twentieth century. In Prussia's east, the Junker landowners, in Russia and Hungary, great nobles with serf or peasant labor, and in southern Italy and Spain, big estates kept much of the old social order.

Class identity and organization

Class identity developed and was reinforced through associations. The middle classes joined philanthropic societies, political clubs, and social associations. The working classes formed mutual aid societies (to help members in sickness and death) and trade unions. In Britain, laws banning combinations of workers were repealed in 1824 to 1825, and unions grew later in the century.

Cities and the countryside

With migration from rural to urban areas in industrialized regions, cities such as Manchester, Birmingham, Lille, and the Ruhr towns grew rapidly. The CED says cities experienced overcrowding, while rural areas suffered declines in available labor and weakened communities. Workers lived in crowded, damp housing, often without clean water or sewage, and diseases such as cholera and typhus spread. Reformers and writers, such as Friedrich Engels in The Condition of the Working Class in England (1845), documented the conditions.

The family and gender roles

  • The cult of domesticity. Bourgeois families became focused on the nuclear family (parents and children) and on the cult of domesticity, an ideal in which the husband worked in the public world and the wife managed the home and raised the children, with distinct gender roles. The household was seen as a refuge from the harsh world of work.
  • Working-class families. Most working-class households needed women's and children's wages. Women worked in textile mills, as domestic servants, and in sweatshops, usually at lower pay than men.
  • Marriage. Economic motives for marriage, while still important for all classes, diminished as the middle-class idea of companionate marriage, based on affection and partnership, was adopted by the working classes.

Improving conditions

By the end of the century, several developments improved life for the working class: higher wages, laws restricting the labor of children and women, social welfare programs, improved diet, and increased access to birth control.

  • The Factory Act of 1833 in Britain limited the hours of children in textile mills and required some schooling, and the Mines Act of 1842 banned women and young boys from underground work. The Ten Hours Act of 1847 limited hours for women and young persons in factories.
  • Governments enforced the laws with inspectors, though weakly at first.

Leisure

Leisure time centered increasingly on the family or small groups, along with the development of activities and spaces to use it. The CED lists parks, sports clubs and arenas, beaches, department stores, museums, theaters, and opera houses. Railways allowed day trips, and cheap newspapers, music halls, and football provided entertainment for the working classes, while the middle classes attended concerts and traveled.

Primary source · The middle-class creed

Samuel Smiles, Self-Help (1859), opening, excerpt.

"Heaven helps those who help themselves" is a well-tried maxim.

Sourcing (HIPP). Smiles was a Scottish writer and reformer whose book of success stories sold widely, so his audience was ambitious, literate members of the working and middle classes, and his purpose was to persuade them that character and effort, not government aid, bring success. The historical situation was Victorian Britain, where industrial success seemed to confirm his claim. The maxim reflects bourgeois values, but it omits the way low wages, illness, and unemployment could defeat hardworking people, which critics such as Engels stressed.

Source analysis · A class viewpoint

Claim. Smiles argues that individuals should rely on their own effort to improve their lives.

Evidence. He opens with the maxim "Heaven helps those who help themselves."

Reasoning. The creed reflects the values of the bourgeoisie, in line with the CED's account of middle-class identity built through thrift, education, and associations. Its limit is that it treats success as a matter of character, which ignores the structural obstacles many workers faced, so it should be paired with a source from the working-class perspective.

Worked example · Social consequences

Question. Explain one way industrialization changed family life in the nineteenth century.

Model. Bourgeois families became centered on the nuclear family and the cult of domesticity, with men working outside the home and women managing the household, so gender roles became more distinct. Among workers, companionate marriage and families' use of leisure time together became more common, while laws limiting women's and children's work changed the family economy.

Exam focus

Learning Objective E needs causes and consequences and clear links to class, city, and family. Cover: new classes (bourgeoisie, proletariat) and the continued dominance of landed elites elsewhere; associations that built class identity; overcrowding and rural decline; gender roles (cult of domesticity); reforms that improved conditions (Factory Act, Mines Act, Ten Hours Act); and leisure. Avoid saying all workers lived in misery throughout; conditions improved by century's end.

Practice
  1. Define bourgeoisie and proletariat.
    Show answer

    The bourgeoisie were the middle-class owners, merchants, and professionals; the proletariat were industrial wage laborers.

  2. How did class identity develop among workers?
    Show answer

    Through trade unions and mutual aid societies, and shared experience of factory work and urban life.

  3. What problems did rapid urbanization create?
    Show answer

    Overcrowding, poor sanitation, and disease in cities, and declining labor and weakened communities in the countryside.

  4. Explain the cult of domesticity.
    Show answer

    A middle-class ideal in which men worked in the public sphere while women managed the home and children in a nuclear family with distinct gender roles.

  5. Name two laws that limited the labor of women or children.
    Show answer

    The Factory Act (1833), the Mines Act (1842), or the Ten Hours Act (1847).

  6. How did leisure change by the end of the century?
    Show answer

    It centered on family or small groups and new venues, such as parks, sports clubs, beaches, museums, theaters, and department stores.

Lesson 6.4 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.5

The Concert of Europe and conservatism

After 1815 the great powers tried to prevent another revolution. Learning Objective F asks you to explain how the European political order was maintained and challenged between 1815 and 1914. The CED's statements for this topic are that conservatives developed a new ideology in support of traditional political and religious authorities, based on the idea that human nature was not perfectible; that Metternich, architect of the Concert of Europe, used it to suppress nationalist and liberal revolutions; and that conservatives reestablished control in many states, trying to suppress movements for change and, in some areas, to strengthen adherence to religious authorities.

Required content · 6F

Learning objective.

  • 6F. Explain how the European political order was maintained and challenged from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.3.I.C. Conservatives developed a new ideology in support of traditional political and religious authorities, which was based on the idea that human nature was not perfectible.
  • 3.4.I.A. Metternich, architect of the Concert of Europe, used it to suppress nationalist and liberal revolutions.
  • 3.4.I.B. Conservatives reestablished control in many European states and attempted to suppress movements for change and, in some areas, to strengthen adherence to religious authorities.

Conservatism as an ideology

Conservatism took shape as a response to the French Revolution. Its main thinkers were Edmund Burke in Britain (Lesson 5.5), who defended gradual change and inherited institutions, and Joseph de Maistre, a French-speaking writer who defended monarchy and the church as foundations of order. Conservatives held that:

  • Human nature is not perfectible. People are flawed, so a government cannot be redesigned on rational principles; tradition, hierarchy, and authority restrain selfishness and disorder.
  • Society is an organic whole, built over centuries, and not a contract that can be remade at will.
  • Religion and monarchy are the bases of social order, and revolution leads to chaos and tyranny, as the Terror showed.

Conservatives did not oppose all change, but they preferred change that was slow and led by those in authority.

Metternich and the Concert

Klemens von Metternich (Austrian foreign minister 1809 to 1848, and chancellor from 1821) was the leading conservative statesman. As architect of the Concert of Europe, the system in which the great powers met in conferences to manage crises, he used it to suppress nationalist and liberal revolutions. His concern was acute because the Austrian Empire, with its many nationalities, could be torn apart by nationalism.

  • The Congress system. At meetings in Troppau (1820), Laibach (1821), and Verona (1822) Austria, Prussia, and Russia agreed to intervene against revolutions. Austrian troops put down revolts in Naples and Piedmont (1821), and a French army restored the Spanish king (1823). Britain refused to join in interference in other states' internal affairs and withdrew from the system, which showed that the great powers did not all agree.
  • Repression at home. The Carlsbad Decrees (1819) imposed censorship of the press, supervision of universities, and a ban on student societies in the German Confederation, after a student murdered a conservative writer. Secret police and informers watched liberals and nationalists across Austria and the Italian states.

Restoration of control and religion

In many states, conservatives reestablished control and tried to suppress movements for change. Bourbon rulers returned in France, Spain, and Naples, and monarchs rolled back reforms. Many governments also tried to strengthen adherence to religious authorities. The papacy recovered Church lands and the Jesuit order was restored in 1814, and the alliance of "throne and altar" gave rulers the support of churches. In Russia, Tsar Nicholas I (1825 to 1855) ruled by "Orthodoxy, autocracy, and nationality."

Challenges to the order

The order was never fully secure.

  • Liberals and nationalists formed secret societies, such as the Carbonari in Italy, and organized revolts.
  • The Concert's unity weakened. Britain's withdrawal, the Greek revolt (Lesson 6.5), and the revolutions of 1830 and 1848 broke through. The Concert nevertheless was a lasting model of great-power consultation, and it helped keep the peace on major matters for decades.
Primary source · Repression of ideas

Description of: The Carlsbad Decrees (1819), adopted by the German Confederation at Metternich's urging. The decrees require governments to appoint officials to watch university professors and students, ban nationalist student societies, and establish censorship of newspapers and books under 320 pages, and they set up a commission to investigate revolutionary plots.

Sourcing (HIPP). The decrees are a government measure drafted by Metternich and adopted by the German states' representatives, so they show how conservative authorities responded to liberal and nationalist ideas. Their purpose was to prevent revolutionary movements in the universities, which were centers of nationalist student societies. The audience was the governments that had to enforce them. They describe policy, not results, and in practice enforcement was uneven.

Source analysis · Policing ideas

Claim. The Carlsbad Decrees were a conservative effort to suppress liberal and nationalist movements.

Evidence. They ordered surveillance of universities, a ban on student societies, and censorship of publications.

Reasoning. The measures fit the CED's description of Metternich using the Concert system to suppress nationalist and liberal revolutions. The fact that student societies and printed political writing were targeted shows the sources of opposition, though enforcement varied and the movements survived.

Worked example · Maintaining the order

Question. Explain one way conservatives maintained the European political order after 1815 and one way it was challenged.

Model. Metternich used the Concert of Europe to organize great-power intervention against revolutions, as when Austrian troops put down revolts in Naples and Piedmont in 1821, and imposed censorship and surveillance through the Carlsbad Decrees. The order was challenged by liberal and nationalist movements and by disagreement among the powers, as when Britain refused to support intervention in other states' affairs.

Exam focus

Learning Objective F has two sides: how the order was maintained (conservative ideology, the Concert and congress system, repression, alliance of throne and altar) and how it was challenged (liberalism and nationalism, the disunity of the powers, revolutions). Remember the CED's definition: conservatism rests on the view that human nature is not perfectible. Avoid saying conservatives opposed all change.

Practice
  1. What did conservatives believe about human nature?
    Show answer

    That it is not perfectible, so traditional authority in church and state is needed to maintain order.

  2. Who was Metternich and what was his goal?
    Show answer

    The Austrian foreign minister and architect of the Concert of Europe, who used it to suppress nationalist and liberal revolutions.

  3. Name one example of intervention by the Concert powers.
    Show answer

    Austrian troops putting down revolts in Naples and Piedmont in 1821, or a French army restoring the Spanish king in 1823.

  4. What did the Carlsbad Decrees do?
    Show answer

    They imposed censorship, supervision of universities, and a ban on nationalist student societies in the German states.

  5. How did conservatives use religion?
    Show answer

    They tried to strengthen adherence to religious authorities and allied throne and altar, as in the restoration of papal power and Nicholas I's "Orthodoxy, autocracy, and nationality."

  6. Why was the Concert not fully united?
    Show answer

    Britain refused to join interference in other states' internal affairs, showing that the great powers did not agree on the goal of suppressing all revolutions.

Lesson 6.5 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.6

Reactions and revolutions, 1815 to 1905

The conservative order of 1815 faced revolts for the rest of the century. Learning Objective G asks you to explain how and why various groups reacted against the existing order from 1815 to 1914. The CED's statements are that, in the first half of the century, revolutionaries attempted to destroy the status quo; that the revolutions of 1848, triggered by economic hardship and discontent with the political status quo, challenged conservative governments and led to the breakdown of the Concert of Europe; and that in Russia, autocratic leaders pushed through reform and modernization, including the emancipation of the serfs, which gave rise to revolutionary movements and the Russian Revolution of 1905.

Required content · 6G

Learning objective.

  • 6G. Explain how and why various groups reacted against the existing order from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.4.I.C. In the first half of the 19th century, revolutionaries attempted to destroy the status quo.
  • 3.4.I.D. The revolutions of 1848, triggered by economic hardship and discontent with the political status quo, challenged conservative politicians and governments and led to the breakdown of the Concert of Europe.
  • 3.4.II.D. In Russia, autocratic leaders pushed through a program of reform and modernization, including the emancipation of the serfs, which gave rise to revolutionary movements and eventually the Russian Revolution of 1905.

Early revolts, 1820 to 1831

  • Greek independence (1821 to 1832). Greeks rebelled against Ottoman rule. European liberals, Romantics such as Lord Byron, and Christian opinion supported them, and Britain, France, and Russia intervened. Greece became independent in 1830, with international recognition in 1832.
  • Decembrist revolt (1825). A group of Russian army officers influenced by Western liberal ideas tried to block Nicholas I's accession and demand a constitution. It was crushed, and Nicholas ruled by repression.
  • July Revolution in France (1830). Charles X's attempt to restrict the press and the electorate led to three days of street fighting in Paris and his overthrow. The "July Monarchy" of Louis-Philippe was a more liberal constitutional monarchy supported by the wealthy middle class.
  • Belgium and Poland (1830 to 1831). Belgians won independence from the Dutch. A Polish rebellion against Russian rule was crushed.

The revolutions of 1848

In 1848 nearly every state in central and western Europe saw revolution.

Causes. The CED names economic hardship and discontent with the political status quo. Crop failures in 1845 to 1847, especially the potato blight, and an industrial depression threw many workers and peasants into poverty (Lesson 6.1). Middle-class liberals wanted constitutions, voting rights, and a free press; nationalists wanted unification or independence; workers wanted jobs and bread. Liberals and nationalists shared a hatred of the conservative order.

Events.

  • France. In February 1848, Paris crowds overthrew Louis-Philippe. The Second Republic was declared with universal male suffrage. Liberals and socialists soon split: the "National Workshops" for the unemployed were closed in June, leading to the bloody June Days, in which the army suppressed workers. In December Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte, Napoleon's nephew, was elected president by a large majority, and in 1852 he made himself emperor as Napoleon III.
  • Austrian Empire. In March, riots in Vienna forced Metternich to resign and flee. Hungarians under Louis Kossuth demanded self-government, and Czechs and other groups made their own claims. The Habsburgs recovered with the help of loyal armies and a Russian intervention in Hungary in 1849.
  • Prussia and the German states. In Berlin, Frederick William IV promised a constitution. A Frankfurt Parliament of liberals met in 1848 to write a constitution for a united Germany and offered the crown to Frederick William in 1849. He refused to accept a crown from an elected assembly, and the effort collapsed.
  • Italy. Revolts against Austrian rule and for a constitutional government in several states were put down.

Results. By 1849 the revolutions had mostly failed. The reasons: liberals and radicals split over how far to go, middle-class liberals feared working-class radicals, nationalities clashed (Germans, Czechs, Hungarians, Slavs), and the armies stayed loyal to rulers. Yet the revolutions had lasting effects: serfdom ended in the Habsburg lands, more constitutions were granted, and the Concert of Europe broke down, in the CED's phrase, because conservative unity could no longer hold. Italian and German unification would come from above, through states, within two decades.

Feb Paris: Louis-Philippe falls; Second Republic March Vienna: Metternich flees; Berlin: constitution promised May Frankfurt Parliament opens June June Days in Paris Dec Louis-Napoleon elected president 1849 Frankfurt crown refused; Hungary defeated
Figure 6.2. The revolutions of 1848. Revolts began in Paris and spread across the continent in weeks, but divisions among the revolutionaries and loyal armies brought defeat by 1849.

Russia: reform and revolution

Russia's rulers pushed reform from above. After the humiliating defeat in the Crimean War (1853 to 1856), Alexander II (r. 1855 to 1881) enacted the emancipation of the serfs (1861), and created local councils (zemstvos, 1864), a modern legal system, and military reform. These reforms were meant to modernize the state but left peasants with heavy payments and little land, and they raised hopes that autocracy could not meet. Revolutionary movements grew, including the People's Will, which assassinated Alexander II in 1881. His successors pursued repression and, under ministers such as Sergei Witte, rapid state-led industrialization (the Trans-Siberian Railway). After defeat by Japan in 1904 to 1905 and Bloody Sunday (January 1905), when troops fired on peaceful workers, strikes and revolt spread, and Nicholas II issued the October Manifesto granting a Duma (parliament). The Revolution of 1905 and the later land reforms of Peter Stolypin failed to solve the regime's basic problems.

Primary source · Freeing the serfs

Description of: Alexander II, Emancipation Manifesto (March 1861). The tsar announces that serfs will receive personal freedom and the rights of free rural inhabitants, that landowners will keep their estates but must provide peasants with land in return for payments, and that the changes will be introduced over a transition period.

Sourcing (HIPP). The manifesto is an imperial decree from the autocrat, so it presents emancipation as a gift of a benevolent ruler, with a purpose of persuading both nobles and peasants to accept the change and of avoiding revolt from below. The historical situation was Russia's defeat in the Crimean War, which exposed its backwardness. The audience was the Russian people, many of them illiterate and hearing the text read aloud. It shows the regime's intentions, but the terms were less generous in practice, since peasants had to pay redemption fees for decades, and many were disappointed.

Source analysis · Reform from above

Claim. Alexander II used emancipation to modernize Russia while keeping autocracy.

Evidence. The manifesto gives serfs personal freedom but keeps landowners' estates and requires peasants to pay for their land.

Reasoning. The decree matches the CED's description of autocratic leaders pushing through reform and modernization. The limits of the reform, such as redemption payments and little land, helped produce disappointment and revolutionary movements. The tsar's own words stress goodwill, so a historian would compare them with peasants' reactions.

Worked example · Why 1848 failed

Question. Explain one cause of the revolutions of 1848 and one reason they failed.

Model. One cause was economic hardship: crop failures and an economic depression in 1845 to 1847 produced hunger and unemployment, and combined with liberals' and nationalists' anger at conservative governments, led to revolts. One reason they failed was disunity among the revolutionaries: middle-class liberals feared workers' radicalism, and national groups such as Hungarians, Czechs, and Germans had conflicting aims, so rulers regained control with loyal armies.

Exam focus

Learning Objective G asks how and why groups reacted. Give causes (economic hardship, discontent with the political order, nationalism), events (the Greek revolt, 1830, 1848, Russian reform and 1905), and results (failure of 1848 but the breakdown of the Concert; reform and revolution in Russia). Keep the CED's contrast: in western and central Europe the challenge came from below, but in Russia reform from above led to revolutionary movements.

Practice
  1. Name two early nineteenth-century revolts against the order of 1815.
    Show answer

    The Greek War of Independence, the Decembrist revolt, the July Revolution in France, or the Polish rebellion.

  2. What were two causes of the revolutions of 1848?
    Show answer

    Economic hardship, including crop failures and unemployment, and discontent with the political status quo.

  3. What happened to Metternich in 1848?
    Show answer

    A revolt in Vienna forced him to resign and flee.

  4. Why did the revolutions of 1848 fail?
    Show answer

    Liberals and radicals split, middle-class liberals feared workers, nationalities clashed, and armies stayed loyal to rulers.

  5. What did Alexander II's emancipation do and not do?
    Show answer

    It freed the serfs personally but left them with heavy payments and little land, so it modernized the state without satisfying peasants.

  6. What was the Revolution of 1905?
    Show answer

    Strikes and revolts after defeat by Japan and Bloody Sunday, forcing Nicholas II to issue the October Manifesto and create a Duma.

Lesson 6.6 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.7

Ideologies of change: liberalism to Marxism

Conservatives were met by new ideologies of reform and revolution. Learning Objective H asks you to explain how and why different intellectual developments challenged the political and social order from 1815 to 1914. The CED lists four groups: liberals, radicals and republicans, socialists, and anarchists. Each proposed a different answer to the same question: what should government do about freedom, equality, property, and industrial society?

Required content · 6H

Learning objective.

  • 6H. Explain how and why different intellectual developments challenged the political and social order from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.3.I.A. Liberals emphasized popular sovereignty, individual rights, and enlightened self-interest but debated the extent to which all groups in society should actively participate in its governance.
  • 3.3.I.B. Radicals in Britain and republicans on the continent demanded universal male suffrage and full citizenship without regard to wealth and property ownership; some argued that such rights should be extended to women.
  • 3.3.I.D. Socialists called for the redistribution of society’s resources and wealth and evolved from a utopian to a Marxist scientific critique of capitalism.
  • 3.6.II.C. Marx’s scientific socialism provided a systematic critique of capitalism and a deterministic analysis of society and historical evolution.
  • 3.3.I.E. Anarchists asserted that all forms of governmental authority were unnecessary and should be overthrown and replaced with a society based on voluntary cooperation.

Liberalism

Liberals emphasized popular sovereignty, individual rights, and enlightened self-interest, but debated the extent to which all groups in society should actively participate in its governance.

  • Ideas. Liberals inherited the Enlightenment: the rule of law, constitutions, a free press, religious toleration, and free trade. In economics they backed laissez-faire, with government kept small.
  • Who they were. Mostly property-owning middle-class men, who often wanted the vote limited by wealth or education. They opposed both absolute monarchy and mass democracy.
  • Examples. Jeremy Bentham's utilitarianism (the greatest happiness for the greatest number), the Anti-Corn Law League (repeal in 1846), and John Stuart Mill, who defended individual freedom in On Liberty (1859).

Radicals and republicans

Radicals in Britain and republicans on the Continent demanded universal male suffrage and full citizenship without regard to wealth and property ownership, and some argued that rights should be extended to women. The Chartists, a British working-class movement, issued the People's Charter (1838) with six demands: the vote for all men, the secret ballot, no property qualification for members of Parliament, payment of members, equal electoral districts, and annual elections. Flora Tristan, a French socialist and feminist, argued for workers' and women's rights. Most of the Chartists' points were eventually adopted.

Socialism

Socialists called for the redistribution of society's resources and wealth. They criticized industrial capitalism for creating poverty alongside wealth.

  • Utopian socialists, such as Henri de Saint-Simon, Charles Fourier, and Robert Owen (who ran a model mill community at New Lanark), imagined cooperative communities and planned societies and hoped to persuade the wealthy to adopt them.
  • Marxists developed the CED's scientific critique of capitalism. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels wrote The Communist Manifesto (1848). Marx's later Capital (1867) argued that history is driven by class struggle: the bourgeoisie, who own the means of production, exploit the proletariat, who sell their labor. Capitalism's crises would lead, Marx predicted, to a workers' revolution and a classless society. The CED describes Marx's scientific socialism as a systematic critique of capitalism and a deterministic analysis of society and historical evolution.
  • Later Marxists such as Rosa Luxemburg and Clara Zetkin debated revolution against reform and the place of women, and Marxist parties grew across Europe.

Anarchism

Anarchists asserted that all forms of governmental authority were unnecessary and should be overthrown and replaced by a society based on voluntary cooperation. Mikhail Bakunin argued for revolt against the state and against Marx's ideas of a transitional workers' state, and Pierre-Joseph Proudhon wrote against property and government. Georges Sorel stressed the idea of the general strike. Anarchists were few but alarmed governments, since some committed assassinations.

Comparing the ideologies

IdeologyCore aimView of the stateSocial base
ConservatismPreserve order and traditionStrong, supports church and monarchyLanded elites, clergy
LiberalismIndividual rights, free marketsLimited, constitutionalMiddle class
Radicalism and republicanismUniversal male suffrageDemocratic republicArtisans, workers, some bourgeois
Socialism and MarxismRedistribute wealth, end classUse or seize the state (Marx: temporary)Industrial workers
AnarchismEnd all governmentAbolish itWorkers, peasants, some intellectuals
Primary source · A theory of history

Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The Communist Manifesto (1848; English translation of 1888), excerpt.

The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Manifesto was written for the Communist League, a small group of workers' radicals, on the eve of the revolutions of 1848, so its purpose was to state a program and to inspire revolution. The point of view is that of the authors' theory of history. It was not widely read until later decades, so its influence came after 1848. The famous opening sentence expresses a deterministic reading of history, which scholars debate, but the source shows what Marxists believed and why they challenged the liberal and conservative order.

Source analysis · Class conflict

Claim. Marx and Engels argue that conflict between classes is the central force in history.

Evidence. The opening sentence says all existing society's history is "the history of class struggles."

Reasoning. The sentence reduces politics and society to economic classes, which fits the CED's description of Marx's deterministic analysis and challenges both liberal ideas of harmony of interests and conservative ideas of social order. The Manifesto was a short program, and many historians question whether all history can be explained in this way.

Worked example · Competing ideologies

Question. Explain one difference between liberals and socialists in the nineteenth century.

Model. Liberals emphasized individual rights, constitutional government, and free markets, and many wanted the vote limited by property, while socialists criticized capitalism for creating poverty and called for the redistribution of wealth and, in Marx's version, a workers' revolution. Liberals saw private property as a protection of freedom; socialists saw it as the source of class exploitation.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective H, define each ideology in its own terms (rights and self-interest; universal suffrage; redistribution and class struggle; abolition of government) and show how it challenged the order. Keep the groups apart: Marx's scientific socialism is not the same as the utopian socialism of Owen; anarchists differ from Marxists on the state. Mention women's rights where relevant (Tristan, Zetkin).

Practice
  1. What did liberals emphasize?
    Show answer

    Popular sovereignty, individual rights, enlightened self-interest, constitutions, and free markets, though they debated how widely political participation should extend.

  2. What did the Chartists demand?
    Show answer

    Universal male suffrage, the secret ballot, no property qualification for office, payment of members of Parliament, equal districts, and annual elections.

  3. Distinguish utopian from Marxist socialism.
    Show answer

    Utopian socialists such as Owen planned cooperative communities and hoped to persuade the wealthy; Marxists presented a scientific critique of capitalism based on class struggle and predicted revolution.

  4. What was Marx's view of history?
    Show answer

    A deterministic view in which history is driven by class struggle and capitalism would give way to a workers' revolution and classless society.

  5. What did anarchists believe?
    Show answer

    That all government is unnecessary and should be replaced by voluntary cooperation.

  6. Why is the Communist Manifesto useful and what is its limit?
    Show answer

    It states Marxist ideas clearly at the time of 1848, but it was a short program by two authors and was not widely read until later.

Lesson 6.7 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.8

Nineteenth-century social reform movements

New ideas turned into organized movements. Learning Objective I asks you to explain the various movements and calls for social reform that resulted from intellectual developments between 1815 and 1914. The CED lists four developments: mass-based political parties, labor unions and workers' parties, feminism, and nongovernmental reform movements, many of them religious. All four show ordinary people, not just rulers and elites, entering politics.

Required content · 6I

Learning objective.

  • 6I. Explain the various movements and calls for social reform that resulted from intellectual developments from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.3.III.A. Mass-based political parties emerged as sophisticated vehicles for social, economic, and political reform.
  • 3.3.III.B. Workers established labor unions and movements promoting social and economic reforms that also developed into political parties.
  • 3.3.III.C. Feminists pressed for legal, economic, and political rights for women as well as improved working conditions.
  • 3.3.III.D. Various nongovernmental reform movements, many of them religious, assisted the poor and worked to end serfdom and slavery.

Mass-based political parties

In the early century, politics was run by small groups of notables. As the suffrage widened and newspapers and railways spread, mass-based political parties emerged as sophisticated vehicles for social, economic, and political reform. They had national organizations, paid officials, programs, and newspapers, and they appealed to millions of voters.

  • Great Britain: the Conservative and Liberal parties competed for votes after the Reform Acts of 1832, 1867, and 1884 widened the electorate.
  • France: Conservatives and Socialists took shape in the Third Republic.
  • Germany: the Social Democratic Party (SPD) became the largest party in the Reichstag by 1912.

Workers organize

The CED says workers established labor unions and movements promoting social and economic reforms that also developed into political parties. Unions bargained for wages, hours, and safety, and sometimes called strikes. British unions were legal from 1824 to 1825, and the Trades Union Congress began in 1868. Workers' parties followed: the German Social Democratic Party (founded 1875), the British Labor movement's party at the beginning of the twentieth century, and the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party (1898), which split into Bolsheviks and Mensheviks (Lesson 8.3). Governments sometimes banned these groups. Bismarck passed anti-socialist laws (1878 to 1890) while introducing social insurance to win workers away from socialism.

Feminism

Feminists pressed for legal, economic, and political rights for women as well as improved working conditions.

  • Early voices. Flora Tristan linked women's and workers' rights; Barbara Smith Bodichon campaigned for married women's property rights and women's education in Britain and helped found Girton College (1869).
  • Legal and economic goals. Women sought control of their property and wages, access to universities and professions, and an end to double standards in marriage and morals.
  • Suffrage. By the late century, the vote became the central demand. In Britain, the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies used petitions and lobbying, while the Women's Social and Political Union (founded 1903) of the Pankhurst family used militant tactics such as demonstrations, window breaking, and hunger strikes. John Stuart Mill's The Subjection of Women (1869) provided an intellectual argument. In Europe, women's suffrage was achieved in Finland (1906) and mostly after World War I (Lesson 9.7).
  • Opposition. Many men and some women argued that women's place was the home, and the cult of domesticity (Lesson 6.3) supported them.

Religious and nongovernmental reform

Various nongovernmental reform movements, many of them religious, assisted the poor and worked to end serfdom and slavery.

  • Education and charity. The Sunday School movement, begun by Robert Raikes in the 1780s, taught poor children to read, and church and charity groups ran hospitals, orphanages, and soup kitchens.
  • Temperance. Movements urged abstinence from alcohol, seen as a cause of poverty and family violence.
  • Abolition. The British abolitionist movement, led by Evangelical Christians and Quakers such as William Wilberforce and Thomas Clarkson, ended the British slave trade (1807) and slavery in the empire (1833). Reformers also pressed for the end of serfdom, which Russia ended in 1861.
  • Social purity and rights. Josephine Butler led a campaign against the Contagious Diseases Acts, which subjected women suspected of prostitution to forced medical examinations, until their repeal in 1886.

What these movements had in common

They organized members, held meetings, circulated petitions and pamphlets, and used elections and the press, all new techniques of mass politics. Many were led by or relied on the middle class and on women, who could not vote but could organize. Their pressure helped produce the reforms in the next lesson.

Primary source · The case for women's equality

John Stuart Mill, The Subjection of Women (1869), chapter 1, excerpt.

...the legal subordination of one sex to the other... is wrong in itself, and now one of the chief hindrances to human improvement.

Sourcing (HIPP). Mill was a leading liberal philosopher and a member of Parliament who had proposed votes for women in 1867. His purpose was to persuade educated readers that women's legal inequality was unjust and harmful to society. His point of view was influenced by his wife, Harriet Taylor Mill, and by liberal principles of individual liberty. The audience was mostly men in the middle and upper classes who controlled law. The source is evidence of a major strand of liberal feminism, but it is one man's argument and does not show the views of women from the working class or of those who opposed suffrage.

Source analysis · A liberal argument for reform

Claim. Mill argues that legal inequality between the sexes is wrong and harms society.

Evidence. He calls the legal subordination of one sex to the other "wrong in itself" and "one of the chief hindrances to human improvement."

Reasoning. The argument applies liberal ideas of individual rights to women and fits the CED's account of feminists pressing for legal, economic, and political rights. A male Member of Parliament writing for educated men gives a view from within the political elite, so it should be set beside the writings and campaigns of women, such as the Pankhursts and Bodichon.

Worked example · Movements

Question. Explain one way workers organized for reform and one way women organized for reform in the nineteenth century.

Model. Workers established labor unions to bargain for wages and conditions and formed political parties such as the German Social Democratic Party to promote social and economic reforms. Women organized feminist movements, such as Bodichon's campaign for married women's property rights and the Pankhursts' suffrage organization, to demand legal, economic, and political rights.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective I, give four types of organized movement (mass parties, labor unions and workers' parties, feminism, nongovernmental reform) with examples and goals. Link each to an intellectual development: liberalism, socialism, and religious conviction. Show methods that were new: national organizations, petitions, the press, and militant protest. Remember that many reformers, such as abolitionists, were motivated by religion.

Practice
  1. What was new about mass-based political parties?
    Show answer

    They had national organizations, programs, and newspapers and appealed to millions of voters, serving as vehicles for reform.

  2. How did labor unions become political?
    Show answer

    Workers' movements promoting wages and conditions developed into political parties such as the German Social Democratic Party.

  3. Name two feminist figures or groups and what they sought.
    Show answer

    Barbara Smith Bodichon sought married women's property rights and education; the Pankhursts' WSPU sought the vote through militant tactics; Flora Tristan sought rights for workers and women.

  4. Give two examples of nongovernmental reform movements.
    Show answer

    The Sunday School movement, the temperance movement, the British abolitionist movement, and Josephine Butler's campaign.

  5. How did religion contribute to reform?
    Show answer

    Evangelical and Quaker believers led abolition and charity movements and worked to help the poor and end slavery and serfdom.

  6. What did Bismarck do about the rise of socialism?
    Show answer

    He banned socialist organizations (1878 to 1890) and at the same time introduced social insurance to win workers' loyalty.

Lesson 6.8 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.9

Institutional responses and reform

Governments responded to the problems of industrial society, though slowly and often under pressure. Learning Objective J asks you to explain how and why governments and other institutions responded to challenges resulting from industrialization. The CED lists three responses: a shift in liberalism from laissez-faire to intervention; the transformation of unhealthy and overcrowded cities, including public health, prisons, and police; and compulsory public education, promoted to advance public order, nationalism, and economic growth.

Required content · 6J

Learning objective.

  • 6J. Explain how and why governments and other institutions responded to challenges resulting from industrialization.

Historical developments.

  • 3.3.II.A. Liberalism shifted from laissez-faire to interventionist economic and social policies in response to the challenges of industrialization.
  • 3.3.II.B. Reforms transformed unhealthy and overcrowded cities by modernizing infrastructure, regulating public health, reforming prisons, and establishing modern police forces. The reforms were enacted by governments motivated by such forces as public opinion, prominent individuals, and charity organizations.
  • 3.3.II.C. Reformers promoted compulsory public education to advance the goals of public order, nationalism, and economic growth.

From laissez-faire to intervention

Early liberals wanted government to keep out of the economy. But the evidence of urban misery, factory accidents, and strikes led many to conclude that the state had to act. The CED says that liberalism shifted from laissez-faire to interventionist economic and social policies in response to the challenges of industrialization.

  • In Britain, Parliament passed factory acts, public health acts, and, after 1867, extended the vote to many working men, so politicians had to listen to them.
  • Germany took a different path under Otto von Bismarck: in the 1880s his government created compulsory health insurance (1883), accident insurance (1884), and old-age and disability pensions (1889), the first major national welfare system, partly to weaken the appeal of socialism.
  • In Britain the Liberal government of 1906 to 1914 introduced old-age pensions (1908) and national health and unemployment insurance (1911).

Transforming the cities

The CED states that reforms transformed unhealthy and overcrowded cities by modernizing infrastructure, regulating public health, reforming prisons, and establishing modern police forces. The reforms were enacted by governments motivated by public opinion, prominent individuals, and charity organizations.

  • Public health. Cholera epidemics (1831 to 1832, 1848, 1854) forced officials to act. Edwin Chadwick's Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Laboring Population (1842) argued that disease was caused by filth and bad water and that clean water and drainage would save lives and money. Britain's Public Health Act of 1848 set up local health boards. After the "Great Stink" of 1858, London built a modern sewer system under Joseph Bazalgette, and the discovery of germ theory (Pasteur, Koch) later supported public health.
  • Infrastructure and urban planning. Governments built sewage and water systems, public lighting (gas, then electric), public housing, parks, and public transportation. In Paris, Georges Haussmann, working for Napoleon III from 1853, tore down medieval districts to build wide boulevards, parks, and sewers, which improved health, supported commerce, and also made it easier for troops to move against barricades.
  • Prisons and police. Reformers such as Bentham and Elizabeth Fry argued that prisons should reform inmates. Britain founded the Metropolitan Police in 1829 (the "bobbies," after Sir Robert Peel), and cities across Europe established professional police forces to replace local watchmen and the army.

Compulsory public education

Reformers promoted compulsory public education to advance the goals of public order, nationalism, and economic growth. Governments wanted a literate, disciplined workforce, loyal citizens who shared a national language and history, and soldiers who could read orders. Prussia had made schooling compulsory early. In Britain, the Education Act of 1870 created state schools where the churches did not provide them, and schooling became compulsory in the 1880s. In France, the Ferry laws (1881 to 1882) established free, compulsory, secular primary education, which also weakened the Catholic Church's role. Schools taught the national language and often discouraged regional languages and dialects.

Why the state acted

Several forces pushed governments: the fear of disease, which crossed class lines; fear of revolution and the power of socialist parties; middle-class philanthropy and public opinion informed by journalists and reformers; the need for healthy soldiers and workers in an age of national rivalry; and the expansion of the vote, which meant that politicians depended on working-class support.

Primary source · A sanitary argument

Description of: Edwin Chadwick, Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Laboring Population of Great Britain (1842). Chadwick gathers testimony from doctors and local officials showing that death rates in crowded, filthy districts were far higher than in clean ones, and he argues that drainage, a supply of clean water, and removal of refuse would reduce disease and also save public money spent on relief of the sick poor.

Sourcing (HIPP). Chadwick was an official of the Poor Law Commission, so the report was an official government investigation and its purpose was to persuade Parliament to act. His argument stressed cost, an appeal to a government and ratepayers that were wary of spending, and he believed in miasma theory, which held that disease arose from foul air, not germs. The evidence of high death rates in dirty districts was real, but his explanation was incomplete. The report shows how public health became a state matter, but it reflects an official's view of the poor.

Source analysis · Evidence for action

Claim. Chadwick argues that sanitation reform would reduce disease and save money.

Evidence. He collected testimony showing higher death rates in filthy, crowded areas and proposed drainage, clean water, and refuse removal.

Reasoning. The report is an example of the CED's reforms of cities by governments responding to public opinion and prominent individuals, and it appeals to economic reasons as well as humanitarian ones. A limit is that his theory of disease was wrong (he blamed foul air), though the remedies worked because they removed contaminated water and waste.

Worked example · Responses

Question. Explain one way a European government responded to the challenges of industrialization in the nineteenth century.

Model. Bismarck's government introduced health, accident, and old-age insurance in the 1880s, an interventionist response to the problems of industrial workers and also a way to reduce the appeal of socialism. In another example, Britain and France made schooling compulsory to create a literate workforce and loyal citizens.

Exam focus

Learning Objective J asks how and why. The how: shift from laissez-faire (welfare insurance, factory laws), urban reform (sewers, water, parks, prisons, police), and compulsory education. The why: public opinion and reformers, charity groups, fear of disease and revolution, the vote, and national economic and military needs. Use named examples (Chadwick, Haussmann, Bismarck, the Ferry laws).

Practice
  1. How did liberalism change in the nineteenth century?
    Show answer

    It shifted from laissez-faire toward interventionist economic and social policies in response to industrial problems.

  2. Name two urban reforms.
    Show answer

    Sewage and water systems, public lighting, parks, public housing, public transportation, regulated public health, prison reform, and modern police.

  3. What did Haussmann do in Paris?
    Show answer

    He rebuilt the city with wide boulevards, parks, and sewers under Napoleon III, improving health and commerce and making troop movement easier.

  4. Why did governments promote compulsory education?
    Show answer

    To maintain public order, spread nationalism, and supply a literate workforce for economic growth.

  5. What was Bismarck's social insurance?
    Show answer

    Health (1883), accident (1884), and old-age and disability insurance (1889), meant to help workers and weaken socialism.

  6. Name two forces that pushed governments to reform.
    Show answer

    Public opinion and reformers, charity organizations, fear of disease and revolution, and the expansion of the vote.

Lesson 6.9 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.10

Causation: how industrialization changed Europe

The last topic of Unit 6 practices causation again. Learning Objective K asks you to explain the influence of innovations and technological developments in Europe from 1815 to 1914. Here you extend the skill: not just listing causes and effects, but showing how a technological cause worked through economic, social, and political channels, and judging how strong its influence was compared with other causes.

Required content · 6K

Learning objective.

  • 6K. Explain the influence of innovations and technological developments in Europe from 1815 to 1914.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

From invention to consequences

A technological cause rarely acts alone. For industrialization, trace three steps.

  1. Invention and conditions. Machines and engines emerged from specific conditions: coal and iron, capital, skilled people, and a government favorable to business (Lesson 6.1).
  2. Direct effects. The technology changed production (factories), transport (railways, steamships), and communication (telegraph). It created new industries and new goods (Lesson 6.2).
  3. Indirect effects. Changes in work and wealth then changed families, cities, politics, and international relations.
Industrial technology steam, steel, electricity, rail Economic factories; global markets; cartels Social new classes; cities; family roles Political mass parties; welfare; Germany rises International raw materials; imperialism; power
Figure 6.3. From invention to consequences. Technology changed production first, then work and cities, then politics and international relations.

Effects across spheres

  • Economic. The factory system, integrated national and world markets, cartels and tariffs, and higher output. Wealth grew faster than population, though unevenly.
  • Social. New classes and organizations, urban growth, new family roles, and reforms of working and living conditions (Lessons 6.3 and 6.7).
  • Political. New ideologies (socialism, liberalism's change) and mass parties, workers' movements, state welfare, and the rise of Germany to economic leadership. Railways and industry also gave armies mobility and weapons, which changed warfare.
  • International. Industry produced a demand for raw materials and markets, and the technology of steamships, quinine, and rifles made overseas expansion cheaper and easier, which led to the New Imperialism (Unit 7). Industrial strength shifted the balance of power toward Germany and the United States.
  • Demographic and environmental. Population growth and urbanization, emigration, and pollution.

Judging the importance of technology

Strong analysis does not just assert that technology "caused" change.

  • Necessary or sufficient? Technology was necessary for industrial society, but not sufficient. In Russia and Spain, the same technologies arrived but social structures such as serfdom and landed elites slowed effects.
  • Other causes. Government policies (tariffs, railway building, the Zollverein), investment capital, and the expansion of the labor force also mattered. Political events, such as the revolutions of 1848 and the unification of Germany, were not caused only by technology.
  • Timing and region. Effects differed between Britain, Germany, and eastern Europe, so a good answer names the place and time.
  • Feedback. Effects could also be causes. Cities, once large, supported more industry; social unrest led to reform, which changed the labor market.

Counterfactual test

A useful test is to ask what would have happened without the cause. Without railways, national markets and large armies would have been far harder to create. But without legal reform and capital, railways would not have been built so fast, which shows that technology interacts with institutions.

Primary source · A historian's argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument that industrialization changed politics less through machines than through the social groups they created. The author argues that factories and cities produced a working class that formed unions and parties and a middle class that demanded political voice, and that states responded to both with new policies, so that technological change affected politics indirectly.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author writes with hindsight, so the point of view is analytical, and the purpose is to argue for an interpretation. The audience is scholars and students. As a secondary source, it presents a claim that you can test: it fits the evidence of mass parties, unions, and the welfare measures of Bismarck, but a critic could add that international competition and military needs also shaped state policy.

Source analysis · Indirect causes

Claim. The historian argues that industrial technology influenced politics indirectly, through new social groups.

Evidence. The growth of the working class led to unions and parties, such as the German Social Democrats, and the middle class demanded a political voice, and governments responded with welfare, education, and urban reform.

Reasoning. The claim fits the CED's account of social developments leading to organized movements and institutional responses. A weakness is that it underplays the direct military and international effects of industrial power, such as the rise of Germany.

Worked example · Technology and change

Question. Explain one way technological innovation influenced European political life between 1815 and 1914.

Model. Industrial technology produced a growing working class in cities and factories, which formed unions and mass political parties such as the German Social Democratic Party. Governments responded with reforms, including Bismarck's social insurance and factory laws. Industrial growth also gave Prussia and then Germany the resources to unify and to become a leading power.

Exam focus

A strong causation answer links a specific technology to a specific effect through a mechanism, covers more than one sphere (economic, social, political, international), and judges the cause's weight against others (institutions, policy, resources). The CED's learning objective stresses innovations and technological developments, so name them (steam, railways, steel, electricity, the telegraph) and say what each changed.

Practice
  1. Distinguish direct and indirect effects of industrial technology, with one example of each.
    Show answer

    Direct: factories and railways changed production and transport. Indirect: a new working class formed unions and parties that changed politics.

  2. Name two spheres affected by industrialization and one effect in each.
    Show answer

    Economic (integrated markets, cartels), social (new classes, urban growth), political (mass parties, welfare), or international (demand for raw materials, shifts in power).

  3. Why was technology necessary but not sufficient for industrial change?
    Show answer

    Machines depended on capital, resources, institutions, and policy, and in places with serfdom or landed elites the same technology had smaller effects.

  4. How did industrialization contribute to imperialism?
    Show answer

    It increased demand for raw materials and markets and produced steamships, rifles, and medicine that made overseas expansion easier.

  5. Give an example of an effect that also became a cause.
    Show answer

    Growing cities supported more industry, or social unrest led to reform that changed labor conditions.

  6. What does the counterfactual test ask?
    Show answer

    What would have happened without the cause, which helps judge how important it was.

Unit 6 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 6 review: Industrialization and Its Effects, c. 1815–c. 1914

Ten questions on industry's spread across Europe, its social costs, and the liberal, socialist, and reformist answers to it, including the revolutions of 1848, plus two short-answer questions on industrial society and its politics.

Multiple choice

  1. Which combination best explains why industrialization began in Britain?

    Correct. Expensive labor made substituting machines profitable, and cheap fuel made running them viable; neither factor alone would have produced the outcome.

    British wages were high by European standards, which is precisely why replacing workers with machines paid. Cheap labor reduced the incentive to mechanize.

    British industry was privately financed and owned. State direction of industry characterized later Russian development, not the British case.

    Guild restrictions had weakened in Britain, which allowed new production methods. Strong guilds elsewhere slowed change.

  2. Source: testimony of Elizabeth Bentley before the Sadler Committee, 1832.

    "What time did you begin to work at a factory? — When I was six years old. … What were your hours of labour in that mill? — From five in the morning till nine at night, when they were thronged."

    In using this source, a historian should most importantly note that

    Correct. The proceedings were designed to build a case for legislation, so the testimony shows conditions at their worst and how reformers shaped opinion, rather than a statistical average.

    Witnesses were named and their evidence recorded in the published report.

    Committees took sworn evidence and published it; the Sadler Report was itself widely circulated.

    Manufacturers complained at the time that they were not given such an opportunity, which is part of why the report was contested.

  3. The historical debate over the standard of living during early industrialization is best resolved by noting that

    Real wages stagnated until roughly the 1840s, and height data suggest nutrition worsened in the early decades. The measures do not agree.

    Correct. The first industrial generation bore the costs (urban mortality, longer hours, loss of control over work), and a later one collected the wage gains.

    Wage series, price data, height records, and mortality statistics all survive and are the basis of the debate.

    Urban life expectancy fell well below rural figures in the early industrial decades, so the claim does not hold for the period concerned.

  4. Public health legislation in mid-nineteenth-century Britain emerged most directly from

    Germ theory was established by Pasteur and Koch decades later. Early reformers worked from statistical correlation and miasma theory.

    Correct. Chadwick's 1842 sanitary report demonstrated that mortality tracked filth and poverty, and the Public Health Act followed in 1848 after further cholera epidemics.

    Many employers resisted sanitary rates and regulation as costly interference.

    The 1832 Reform Act extended the vote to roughly a fifth of adult men and excluded the working class entirely.

  5. Source: John Stuart Mill, On Liberty, 1859.

    "That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others."

    Mill's essay differs from earlier liberal writing chiefly in identifying the principal threat to liberty as

    That was Locke's target in 1689. By 1859 Britain's monarchy was already constitutionally limited.

    Correct. Mill feared a conformist public opinion coercing individuals as the franchise widened: liberalism turning to face a threat its anti-absolutist form never confronted.

    Mill opposed religious coercion, but the essay's distinctive argument concerns social and majority pressure generally.

    Wartime emergency is not the essay's subject; it addresses the ordinary limits of coercion in peacetime society.

  6. Chartism differed from the liberalism of the 1832 Reform Act principally in demanding

    Correct. The People's Charter's six points were political and democratic, aimed at the exclusion that the 1832 Act had left in place for working men.

    Chartism was a movement for political rights, not for abolishing property; that program belongs to socialism.

    Chartists generally opposed the Corn Laws, which raised the price of bread.

    Some Chartists had artisan grievances, but the Charter itself demanded parliamentary reform, not guild restoration.

  7. Source: Marx and Engels, Manifesto of the Communist Party, 1848.

    "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles. … The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win."

    Which statement about the Manifesto's historical significance is most accurate?

    The revolutions had their own causes (harvest failure, financial crisis, and liberal and national demands), and were already under way as the pamphlet appeared.

    Correct. Written for the small Communist League and published in the weeks before the risings, it attracted little attention at the time; its influence dates from after 1870.

    It was written for the Communist League, a tiny organization, not for a mass union federation.

    The turn to parliamentary reform came with Bernstein's revisionism at the end of the century, against the Manifesto's revolutionary argument.

  8. The Zollverein of 1834 contributed to German industrialization mainly by

    The Zollverein was a customs union, not a nationalization program; industry remained privately owned.

    Correct. Political fragmentation had denied German producers a large internal market, and removing the tariff barriers between states supplied one ahead of political unification.

    German technical education mattered greatly but developed separately, and was not the customs union's function.

    Union rights came much later and were restricted under Bismarck's anti-socialist laws of 1878.

  9. The Second Industrial Revolution differed from the first chiefly in that it

    Correct. Steel, chemicals, and electricity required laboratories and trained scientists, which is why Germany and the United States, with strong technical education, overtook Britain in the new sectors.

    Water power belonged to the earliest phase of mechanized spinning; the second phase added electricity and the internal combustion engine.

    Germany and the United States led it, and Britain lost its earlier dominance in precisely these industries.

    Firms grew far larger, with cartels and corporations replacing family businesses in heavy industry.

  10. The revolutions of 1848 failed most fundamentally because

    The Frankfurt Parliament offered the imperial crown to the king of Prussia, which was a compromise; he refused to take it from commoners.

    Correct. Liberals shot workers in the June Days, nationalities made incompatible claims, and no revolutionary body controlled an army, so the Habsburg and Prussian officer corps waited and then restored order.

    Workers were a minority even in the most industrial regions, and in Paris the June rising was defeated by artillery.

    Britain did not intervene militarily. Russian troops helped crush the Hungarian revolution in 1849, but there was no joint invasion.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way industrialization changed working life in the period 1780–1850.
    2. Briefly explain ONE response by governments or workers to the conditions you described.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason industrialization spread unevenly across Europe.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: separation of home from workplace; employer-controlled time discipline with fines; women's and children's factory labor; loss of artisan control over pace and method; migration to overcrowded industrial towns. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: the Factory Acts of 1833 and 1847; the Public Health Act of 1848; trade unions and friendly societies; Chartism; Owenite cooperation. Must connect the response to a condition.
    • (c) Accept: differences in coal and iron endowment; political fragmentation and internal tariffs before the Zollverein; availability of capital and banking; state direction in Russia; serfdom limiting labor mobility in the east. Must explain the cause of unevenness.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Factory production separated home from workplace and replaced task rhythms with employer-controlled time. Workers who had previously set their own pace in household production now worked fixed shifts of twelve hours or more under supervision, with fines or physical punishment for lateness.

    (b) Parliament responded with factory legislation after inquiries such as the Sadler Committee publicized conditions. The Factory Act of 1833 barred children under nine from textile mills and limited the hours of those aged nine to thirteen, and the Ten Hours Act of 1847 capped the working day for women and young people.

    (c) Political fragmentation delayed industrialization in the German lands. Producers faced tariffs crossing between dozens of states, which denied them a large internal market until the Zollverein removed those barriers in 1834, after which German heavy industry expanded rapidly.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE goal of nineteenth-century liberalism.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way socialism differed from liberalism in its analysis of industrial society.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason the revolutions of 1848 failed to achieve lasting change.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: constitutional government and the rule of law; free trade; careers open to talent; freedom of speech, religion, and assembly; a franchise based on property and education. Do not accept: universal democracy, which most liberals opposed.
    • (b) Accept: socialists located the problem in private ownership of the means of production and in class relations, while liberals saw free contract between individuals; Marx predicted class struggle and revolution rather than reform; socialists sought collective rather than individual solutions. Must contrast the analysis.
    • (c) Accept: the split between liberals and workers, shown by the June Days; competing national claims among Germans, Czechs, Hungarians, Croats, and Romanians; revolutionaries' lack of control over armies; Frederick William IV's refusal of the Frankfurt crown. Must explain why it mattered.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Liberals sought constitutional government limiting the ruler by law, together with legal equality, free trade, and careers open to talent. They generally wanted the vote restricted to men with property and education, on the view that independent judgment required independent means.

    (b) Socialists located the problem in ownership rather than in legal freedom. Marx and Engels argued in 1848 that society is divided by relation to the means of production and that conflict between those classes drives history, whereas liberals treated employer and worker as free individuals contracting on equal terms.

    (c) The revolutionary coalitions broke apart once initial victories were won. In Paris, moderate republicans closed the National Workshops and used the army to crush the workers' rising in the June Days, destroying the alliance that had overthrown Louis Philippe and frightening propertied voters into supporting Louis-Napoleon.

Lesson 7.1 · Unit 7 · CED topics 7.1 and 7.2

Nationalism: context and the nation-state

In the nineteenth century a powerful new idea reshaped Europe: that people who share a language, history, and culture should form a nation and govern themselves. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which nationalistic and imperialistic sentiments developed in Europe from 1815 to 1914, and Learning Objective B asks how the development and spread of nationalism affected Europe. This lesson covers the context and the main varieties of nationalism, including their darker sides.

Required content · 7A, 7B

Learning objectives.

  • 7A. Explain the context in which nationalistic and imperialistic sentiments developed in Europe from 1815 to 1914.
  • 7B. Explain how the development and spread of nationalism affected Europe from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.3.I.F. Nationalists encouraged loyalty to the nation in a variety of ways, including romantic idealism, liberal reform, political unification, racialism with a concomitant anti-Semitism, and chauvinism justifying national aggrandizement.
  • 3.3.I.G. While during the 19th century western European Jews became more socially and politically acculturated, Zionism, a form of Jewish nationalism, developed late in the century as a response to growing anti-Semitism throughout Europe.
  • 3.4.II.B. A new generation of conservative leaders, including Napoleon III, Cavour, and Bismarck, used popular nationalism to create or strengthen the state.
  • 3.4.II.C. The creation of the dual monarchy of Austria-Hungary, which recognized the political power of the largest ethnic minority, was an attempt to stabilize the state by reconfiguring national unity.

The context

  • The revolutionary inheritance. The French Revolution had defined the nation as a community of citizens (Lesson 5.5), and Napoleon's conquests provoked national resistance across Europe (Lesson 5.6). The Congress of Vienna (1815) ignored these feelings, leaving Poland, Italy, and Germany divided and Belgium under Dutch rule (Lesson 5.7).
  • Romanticism. Romantic writers praised folk culture, language, and national history as the soul of a people (Lesson 5.8). Herder, the Brothers Grimm, and historians created national stories.
  • Industrial and social change. Railways, newspapers, mass education, and military service brought people from different regions into a shared national life (Lessons 6.2 and 6.8), and economic competition made states want large unified markets.
  • Rivalry. As states competed in industry and power, they used national pride to gain support, and the same competition fed the imperialism covered later in this unit.

What is nationalism?

Nationalism is the belief that the nation is the proper basis of political loyalty and that each nation should have its own state, or at least self-government. It could serve very different political aims. The CED says nationalists encouraged loyalty to the nation in a variety of ways, including romantic idealism, liberal reform, political unification, racialism with a concomitant anti-Semitism, and chauvinism justifying national aggrandizement.

  • Romantic idealism. Writers such as J. G. Fichte and the Grimm brothers, who collected German folktales, celebrated the national language and spirit.
  • Liberal reform. Liberals such as Giuseppe Mazzini, who founded Young Italy (1831), argued that free nations would live in peace and that national unity and constitutional government went together.
  • Political unification. Nationalists in Italy and Germany sought a single state, the subject of the next lesson.
  • Racialism and anti-Semitism. Some nationalists defined the nation by race or blood and excluded minorities, especially Jews. Pan-Slavists urged a union of Slavic peoples under Russian leadership.
  • Chauvinism. Extreme nationalism claimed that one's own nation was superior and justified expansion and domination of others.

Anti-Semitism and Zionism

During the nineteenth century, western European Jews became more socially and politically acculturated, gaining civil rights and entering professions. But modern anti-Semitism, now based on race as well as religion, grew. The Dreyfus affair in France (1894 to 1906) is the best-known case: Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish army officer, was wrongly convicted of spying for Germany, and the army and much of the Catholic right resisted reopening the case until he was finally cleared. In Vienna, Karl Lueger, leader of the Christian Social Party, became mayor in 1897 on an anti-Semitic platform, and in the Russian Empire pogroms (violent attacks on Jewish communities) increased after 1881.

As a response to growing anti-Semitism throughout Europe, Zionism, a form of Jewish nationalism, developed late in the century. Theodor Herzl, a Viennese journalist who had covered the Dreyfus trial, argued in The Jewish State (1896) that Jews needed a state of their own, and the First Zionist Congress met at Basel in 1897.

Nationalism and the state

The CED notes that a new generation of conservative leaders, including Napoleon III, Cavour, and Bismarck, used popular nationalism to create or strengthen the state. They did not give way to nationalism: they adopted it to build stronger states and to win mass support, as seen in the wars of unification.

Austria-Hungary shows the other side. A multinational empire, it faced nationalism as a threat. After defeat by Prussia in 1866 the Habsburgs agreed to the Compromise of 1867, which created the dual monarchy: Austria and Hungary became separate states under one emperor, Francis Joseph. The CED explains that this recognized the political power of the largest ethnic minority (the Hungarians) as an attempt to stabilize the state by reconfiguring national unity. But Czechs, Slovaks, Croats, Serbs, Romanians, and others, who had no such status, were unsatisfied.

Primary source · A state for the Jews

Theodor Herzl, The Jewish State (1896), excerpt in English translation.

The Jews who wish for a State will have it.

Sourcing (HIPP). Herzl was an Austrian Jewish journalist who wrote the pamphlet after seeing anti-Semitism in Paris during the Dreyfus affair and in Vienna under Lueger. His purpose was to persuade Jews and European governments that a Jewish state was both necessary and possible, and the audience included Jewish communities and the powers. The statement is confident and political rather than descriptive, and many Jews at the time, especially assimilated western Jews and religious leaders, rejected it, so it represents one movement among Jewish responses.

Source analysis · Nationalism as a response

Claim. Herzl argues that Jews should achieve self-determination by forming a state.

Evidence. He says "The Jews who wish for a State will have it."

Reasoning. The statement fits the CED's account of Zionism as a form of nationalism that developed in response to growing anti-Semitism. Herzl's experience of the Dreyfus affair and Vienna politics lies behind it. It reflects only one view among Jews of the period, because many assimilated Jews and religious authorities opposed it.

Worked example · Uses of nationalism

Question. Explain one way nationalism was used to strengthen a state and one way it threatened a state in the nineteenth century.

Model. Conservative leaders such as Bismarck and Napoleon III used popular nationalism to create or strengthen states and win mass support: Bismarck used it to unify Germany under Prussia. Nationalism threatened multinational states such as Austria-Hungary, which had to reorganize itself as a dual monarchy in 1867 to keep the Hungarians loyal while many other nationalities remained dissatisfied.

Exam focus

Learning Objective B asks how nationalism affected Europe, so show its different forms (romantic, liberal, unifying, racist, chauvinist) and its opposite effects (building states, destabilizing empires). Use the CED's examples: Napoleon III, Cavour, and Bismarck used it; Austria-Hungary reconfigured itself; anti-Semitism and Zionism show its dark and defensive sides. Do not treat nationalism as only liberal or only aggressive.

Practice
  1. Name two contexts that helped nationalism grow in the nineteenth century.
    Show answer

    The legacy of the French Revolution and Napoleon, Romantic celebration of culture, the failure of the Congress of Vienna to respect national feeling, and railways, schools, and newspapers.

  2. List two forms nationalism took.
    Show answer

    Romantic idealism, liberal reform, political unification, racialism and anti-Semitism, or chauvinism.

  3. What was the Dreyfus affair and what did it show?
    Show answer

    The wrongful conviction of a Jewish army officer in France (1894), which showed persistent anti-Semitism in the army and society.

  4. What was Zionism?
    Show answer

    A form of Jewish nationalism that arose in the late nineteenth century in response to anti-Semitism, aiming at a Jewish state, led by Theodor Herzl.

  5. How did conservative leaders use nationalism?
    Show answer

    Napoleon III, Cavour, and Bismarck used popular nationalism to create or strengthen states and win mass support.

  6. Why did the Compromise of 1867 not solve Austria-Hungary's national problem?
    Show answer

    It recognized Hungarians but not Czechs, Slovaks, Croats, Serbs, Romanians, and others, who remained dissatisfied.

Lesson 7.2 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.3

Unifying Italy and Germany

For centuries Italy and Germany had been collections of separate states. Within a decade, between 1859 and 1871, both became nation-states and changed the balance of power. Learning Objective C asks you to explain the factors that resulted in Italian unification and German unification. The CED's account: the Crimean War demonstrated the weakness of the Ottoman Empire and contributed to the breakdown of the Concert of Europe, creating the conditions for unification; Cavour's diplomacy and Garibaldi's campaigns united Italy; and Bismarck used Realpolitik to unify Germany.

Required content · 7C

Learning objective.

  • 7C. Explain the factors that resulted in Italian unification and German unification.

Historical developments.

  • 3.4.II.A. The Crimean War demonstrated the weakness of the Ottoman Empire and contributed to the breakdown of the Concert of Europe, thereby creating the conditions in which Italy and Germany could be unified after centuries of fragmentation.
  • 3.4.III.A. Cavour’s diplomatic strategies, combined with the popular Garibaldi’s military campaigns, led to the unification of Italy.
  • 3.4.III.B. Bismarck used Realpolitik, employing diplomacy, industrialized warfare, weaponry, and the manipulation of democratic mechanisms to unify Germany.

The Crimean War and the end of the Concert

The Crimean War (1853 to 1856) began when Russia pressed the Ottoman Empire, "the sick man of Europe," over the protection of Christians and access to the Mediterranean. Britain and France, fearing Russian expansion, joined the Ottomans, and Piedmont later sent troops as well. Russia lost, and its military and social weaknesses were exposed (Lesson 6.5). Austria had refused to help Russia, which had saved the Habsburgs in 1849, so Russia was estranged from Austria. The Concert of Europe, which relied on conservative cooperation among Russia, Austria, and Prussia, broke down, leaving Italy and Germany free to act without a united great-power response.

Italian unification

After the failed revolutions of 1848, the Kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia was the only Italian state with a liberal constitution.

  • Cavour. Count Camillo di Cavour, prime minister from 1852, modernized Piedmont's economy and army and played diplomacy skillfully. He joined the Crimean War to gain a place among the powers. In 1858 he made a secret alliance with Napoleon III, and in 1859, after provoking Austria, he won the war with French help (Magenta and Solferino), and Piedmont gained Lombardy.
  • Garibaldi. The popular nationalist Giuseppe Garibaldi led about a thousand volunteers, the Red Shirts, to Sicily in 1860 and conquered it and southern Italy. Rather than letting him found a republic, Garibaldi handed his conquests to Piedmont's king.
  • The kingdom. In 1861 the Kingdom of Italy was proclaimed under Victor Emmanuel II. Venetia was added in 1866 (after Prussia defeated Austria), and Rome in 1870, when France withdrew its troops during the Franco-Prussian War.

The CED says Cavour's diplomatic strategies, combined with the popular Garibaldi's military campaigns, led to unification. The new state remained poor in the south and in conflict with the papacy, and Italy's leaders joked that "we have made Italy, now we must make Italians."

German unification

Germany was a loose German Confederation of thirty-nine states, with Austria and Prussia competing for leadership. Prussia led the Zollverein (Lesson 6.1) and grew stronger economically (Lesson 6.2).

Otto von Bismarck, appointed minister-president of Prussia in 1862 by King William I, became the central figure. He practiced Realpolitik, a politics of practical power, without regard for ideals. In 1862 he declared that the great questions of the day would be settled by "iron and blood," not speeches and majority votes. When the Prussian parliament refused to approve military funds, he collected taxes without its consent. The CED says Bismarck used diplomacy, industrialized warfare, weaponry, and the manipulation of democratic mechanisms to unify Germany. Three wars did it:

  1. War against Denmark (1864). Prussia and Austria seized Schleswig and Holstein, then quarreled over them.
  2. Austro-Prussian War (1866). In seven weeks, Prussia, with railways, telegraph, and the breech-loading needle gun, defeated Austria at Königgrätz. Austria was excluded from Germany, and Prussia formed the North German Confederation.
  3. Franco-Prussian War (1870 to 1871). Bismarck edited a telegram from the king, the Ems Dispatch, to make it appear that France had been insulted and vice versa, and France declared war. German armies captured Napoleon III at Sedan and besieged Paris. In January 1871, the German Empire was proclaimed at Versailles, with William I as emperor (kaiser). France lost Alsace and most of Lorraine and paid an indemnity, which left a lasting desire for revenge.

The new empire had a Reichstag elected by universal male suffrage, but the chancellor answered to the emperor, and the Prussian king and army kept dominance. Bismarck had used the mechanisms of democracy to strengthen the monarchy and his state.

1853-56 Crimean War 1859 Piedmont and France defeat Austria 1861 Kingdom of Italy 1862 Bismarck leads Prussia 1866 Austro-Prussian War 1870 Rome joins Italy; Franco-Prussian War 1871 German Empire proclaimed
Figure 7.1. Unification. The Crimean War opened the way, and within two decades two new national states appeared, one through diplomacy and volunteers and the other through three wars.
Primary source · A manipulated telegram

Description of: The Ems Dispatch (July 1870). King William I of Prussia sent his adviser a telegram describing a courteous but firm meeting with the French ambassador, who had demanded a guarantee that no Hohenzollern would ever take the Spanish throne. Bismarck shortened the text before releasing it to the press so that it appeared that the king had rudely dismissed the ambassador.

Sourcing (HIPP). The original dispatch was an official report from the king's staff, and the edited version was a political instrument, designed by Bismarck to provoke France into declaring war so that southern German states would join Prussia. His purpose was to unite Germans against a common enemy. The edit shows his Realpolitik and his control of the press, and it is a good example of the manipulation of public feeling that the CED mentions.

Source analysis · Realpolitik in action

Claim. Bismarck deliberately provoked France to complete German unification.

Evidence. He edited the king's dispatch to make it seem insulting, and France declared war.

Reasoning. The edit reflects Realpolitik: using a limited change in wording and public opinion to create a war that united the German states behind Prussia. It shows that unification was not simply the result of a popular national movement but also of calculated diplomacy and state power, in line with the CED.

Worked example · Methods of unification

Question. Explain one way Italian unification and German unification were similar and one way they were different.

Model. Both were led by the strongest state, Piedmont and Prussia, whose rulers used diplomacy and war and benefited from the breakdown of the Concert of Europe after the Crimean War. They differed in the role of popular movements: Italian unification combined Cavour's diplomacy with Garibaldi's volunteer army, while German unification was achieved from above through Bismarck's wars and diplomacy, with the army and the Prussian monarchy dominant.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective C list factors: the Crimean War and the breakdown of the Concert, strong leading states (Piedmont, Prussia), leaders (Cavour, Garibaldi, Bismarck), foreign alliances (France for Piedmont), military technology and railways (Prussia's needle gun and rail), and nationalism used by conservatives. A good answer compares: Italy through diplomacy and popular volunteers, Germany through Realpolitik and war.

Practice
  1. How did the Crimean War contribute to unification?
    Show answer

    It showed Ottoman weakness, estranged Russia and Austria, and broke down the Concert of Europe, so no united great-power response blocked unification.

  2. What roles did Cavour and Garibaldi play?
    Show answer

    Cavour used diplomacy and the French alliance to win Lombardy and lead Piedmont; Garibaldi's volunteers conquered Sicily and southern Italy, which were then joined to the kingdom.

  3. What is Realpolitik?
    Show answer

    A practical, power-based approach to politics, ignoring ideals, as practiced by Bismarck.

  4. Name the three wars that unified Germany.
    Show answer

    The war against Denmark (1864), the Austro-Prussian War (1866), and the Franco-Prussian War (1870 to 1871).

  5. What was the Ems Dispatch?
    Show answer

    A telegram edited by Bismarck to make a diplomatic exchange look like an insult, provoking France into war in 1870.

  6. How did Bismarck use democratic mechanisms?
    Show answer

    He gave the Reichstag male suffrage but kept the chancellor responsible to the kaiser, and used nationalist public opinion to support the monarchy and army.

Lesson 7.3 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.3

Alliances, rivalry, and the Balkan crises

Once Germany was united in 1871, it was the strongest power on the continent, and the other states had to adjust. Learning Objective D asks how nationalist sentiment and political alliances led to tension between and among European powers from 1815 to 1914. The CED traces a path: after 1871 Bismarck attempted to maintain the balance of power through a complex system of alliances directed at isolating France; his dismissal in 1890 eventually led to a system of mutually antagonistic alliances and heightened tensions; and nationalist tensions in the Balkans drew the Great Powers into a series of crises, leading up to World War I.

Required content · 7D

Learning objective.

  • 7D. Explain how nationalist sentiment and political alliances led to tension between and among European powers from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.4.III.C. After 1871, Bismarck attempted to maintain the balance of power through a complex system of alliances directed at isolating France.
  • 3.4.III.D. Bismarck’s dismissal in 1890 eventually led to a system of mutually antagonistic alliances and heightened international tensions.
  • 3.4.III.E. Nationalist tensions in the Balkans drew the Great Powers into a series of crises, leading up to World War I.

Bismarck's system, 1871 to 1890

Bismarck declared Germany "satisfied" and sought peace. His main fear was a French war of revenge for Alsace-Lorraine, especially if France found allies. So he built a web of agreements that kept France isolated.

  • The Three Emperors' League (1873, renewed 1881) linked Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Russia.
  • The Dual Alliance (1879) bound Germany and Austria-Hungary to aid each other if either was attacked by Russia. In 1882 Italy joined to make the Triple Alliance.
  • The Reinsurance Treaty (1887) with Russia promised neutrality if either was attacked by a third power, except in an aggressive war against Austria or France, which kept Russia from allying with France.
  • The Congress of Berlin (1878), which Bismarck chaired as an "honest broker," settled a crisis after a Russian-Ottoman war. It recognized the independence of Serbia, Montenegro, and Romania, and Austria-Hungary occupied Bosnia-Herzegovina.

The system depended on Bismarck's skill, since the alliances partly conflicted. It maintained peace in Europe for nearly two decades.

After Bismarck: antagonistic blocs

In 1890 the young Kaiser William II dismissed Bismarck. He wanted an active world policy (Weltpolitik) and a big navy. His government let the Reinsurance Treaty lapse. This eventually led to a system of mutually antagonistic alliances.

  • France and Russia drew together in the Franco-Russian Alliance (1894), pledging to support one another against Germany.
  • Britain, which had avoided continental alliances ("splendid isolation"), was alarmed by Germany's naval buildup and Weltpolitik. It settled colonial disputes with France in the Entente Cordiale (1904) and with Russia in the Anglo-Russian Entente (1907). Together with the Franco-Russian Alliance, the result was the Triple Entente.
  • The naval race. Britain's Dreadnought (1906), a new type of battleship, started an arms race with Germany.
  • Colonial crises. Germany challenged France in Morocco in 1905 and 1911, which made the Entente firmer (Lesson 7.6).

The result was two armed camps: the Triple Alliance (Germany, Austria-Hungary, Italy) and the Triple Entente (Britain, France, Russia). Each state feared that standing aside would mean losing an ally.

Triple Alliance Germany Dual Alliance 1879 Austria-Hungary joined by Italy 1882 Italy neutral in 1914 Triple Entente France Franco-Russian Alliance 1894 Russia Anglo-Russian Entente 1907 Britain Entente Cordiale 1904 Europe's armed camps, before 1914 Balkan crises, 1908 to 1913, tested the blocs
Figure 7.2. Alliance blocs. By 1907 Europe's great powers were divided into two groups, each fearing isolation, so a local crisis could involve all of them.

The Balkans: nationalism and great-power rivalry

The Balkans were the weakest point. The Ottoman Empire was declining, and its former subjects, especially the Serbs, sought independence and wanted to unite South Slavs. Austria-Hungary, with its own large Slavic population, feared Serbian nationalism, and Russia saw itself as the protector of Slavs.

  • Bosnian annexation crisis (1908). Austria-Hungary annexed Bosnia-Herzegovina, enraging Serbia. Russia, weakened by the war with Japan, backed down when Germany supported Austria.
  • Balkan Wars (1912 to 1913). Balkan states drove the Ottomans from nearly all of their European lands, then fought each other over the spoils. Serbia emerged much larger and more confident, and Austria-Hungary was determined to curb it.

The CED's summary is that nationalist tensions in the Balkans drew the Great Powers into a series of crises, leading up to World War I. The assassination at Sarajevo in June 1914 (Lesson 8.1) was the spark.

Primary source · The Dual Alliance

Description of: The Dual Alliance treaty between Germany and Austria-Hungary (October 1879), a secret agreement. If either is attacked by Russia, the other will come to its aid with its full strength; if attacked by another power, each partner promises at least benevolent neutrality, and the treaty is to remain secret.

Sourcing (HIPP). The treaty is a diplomatic document, secret at the time, so it shows what the rulers planned, not what the public knew. Bismarck's purpose was defensive: to ensure Austria's support against Russia and to keep Germany from isolation. Its audience was the two governments. It is an example of the alliance system that the CED describes. The treaty was kept secret until 1888, so it did not deter rivals openly, though its effect was to commit Germany to Austria's fate in later crises.

Source analysis · Alliances and commitments

Claim. The Dual Alliance committed Germany to Austria-Hungary against Russia.

Evidence. It promises full aid if either is attacked by Russia, and benevolent neutrality in other cases.

Reasoning. The agreement shows Bismarck's use of alliances to keep the balance of power and isolate France, as the CED says. The structure also tied Germany's security to Austria, which contributed to the risk in 1914, when Austria's Balkan troubles drew Germany in. A treaty shows commitments on paper, not how states acted.

Worked example · Alliances and tension

Question. Explain one way the alliance system changed between 1871 and 1914.

Model. Under Bismarck, alliances were designed to isolate France and keep peace by tying Russia and Austria to Germany. After his dismissal in 1890, Germany let the Reinsurance Treaty lapse and France and Russia allied in 1894, then Britain joined the Entente in 1904 and 1907, creating two opposing blocs. The system moved from one man's balancing to rigid hostile camps that made local crises dangerous.

Exam focus

Learning Objective D has a chain to explain: Bismarck's alliances (isolating France) → his dismissal → antagonistic blocs (Triple Alliance and Triple Entente) → Balkan nationalism (Bosnian crisis, Balkan Wars) → war. Give dates and name the agreements. Do not say alliances alone caused war; they made a local conflict into a general one, and nationalism and imperial rivalry also mattered.

Practice
  1. What was Bismarck's main goal in foreign policy after 1871?
    Show answer

    To keep peace and isolate France through a system of alliances so it could not seek revenge for Alsace-Lorraine.

  2. Name two parts of Bismarck's alliance system.
    Show answer

    The Three Emperors' League, the Dual Alliance with Austria-Hungary, the Triple Alliance with Italy, or the Reinsurance Treaty with Russia.

  3. What happened after Bismarck's dismissal in 1890?
    Show answer

    Germany let the Reinsurance Treaty with Russia lapse, France and Russia allied, and Britain later joined them in ententes, creating opposing blocs.

  4. Why did Britain join the Entente?
    Show answer

    Germany's naval buildup and world policy alarmed it, so it settled colonial disputes with France (1904) and Russia (1907).

  5. Why were the Balkans dangerous?
    Show answer

    Ottoman decline and Serbian nationalism clashed with Austria-Hungary's fear of Slavic nationalism and with Russia's role as protector of Slavs.

  6. What was the effect of the Balkan Wars of 1912 to 1913?
    Show answer

    Serbia grew larger and more confident, increasing Austria-Hungary's determination to curb it.

Lesson 7.4 · Unit 7 · CED topics 7.4 and 7.5

Darwin, science, and the Age of Progress

Science and thought changed as quickly as industry in the nineteenth century. Learning Objective E asks how Darwin's theories influenced scientific and social developments from 1815 to 1914, and Learning Objective F asks how science and other intellectual disciplines developed and changed. The CED's story runs from confident faith in scientific progress to a modern view in which irrationality, the unconscious, and uncertainty in physics all challenged older certainties.

Required content · 7E, 7F

Learning objectives.

  • 7E. Explain how Darwin’s theories influenced scientific and social developments from 1815 to 1914.
  • 7F. Explain how science and other intellectual disciplines developed and changed throughout the period from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.6.II.B. Charles Darwin provided a scientific and material account of biological change and the development of human beings as a species, and inadvertently, a justification for racialist theories that became known as Social Darwinism.
  • 3.6.II.A. Positivism, or the philosophy that science alone provides knowledge, emphasized the rational and scientific analysis of nature and human affairs.
  • 3.6.III.A. Philosophy largely moved from rational interpretations of nature and human society to an emphasis on irrationality and impulse, a view that contributed to the belief that conflict and struggle led to progress.
  • 3.6.III.B. Freudian psychology offered a new account of human nature that emphasized the role of the irrational and the struggle between the conscious and subconscious.
  • 3.6.III.C. Developments in the natural sciences, such as quantum mechanics and Einstein’s theory of relativity, undermined the primacy of Newtonian physics as an objective description of nature.

Darwin and evolution

Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859) argued that species change over time through natural selection: individuals with traits that help them survive and reproduce pass those traits to offspring, and over many generations new species arise. The CED says Darwin provided a scientific and material account of biological change and the development of human beings as a species. In The Descent of Man (1871) he applied the theory to humans. This challenged the biblical account of creation and the idea that humans were a unique, special creation, and it started a long public controversy over science and religion.

Social Darwinism

Others applied Darwin's ideas to society. The CED says that, inadvertently, Darwin's work provided a justification for racialist theories that became known as Social Darwinism. The philosopher Herbert Spencer coined the phrase "survival of the fittest." Social Darwinists argued that competition among individuals, classes, nations, and races was natural and produced progress. They used this idea to defend unrestrained capitalism, to justify imperial conquest as the triumph of "higher" races (Lesson 7.5), and, later, to support eugenics and extreme racism. Darwin himself did not endorse these uses, and most scientists today reject them.

Positivism and faith in progress

Positivism, the philosophy of Auguste Comte, held that science alone provides knowledge, and that society should be studied and improved by scientific methods. The CED says positivism emphasized the rational and scientific analysis of nature and human affairs. Combined with the achievements of industry and medicine (Pasteur's germ theory, anesthesia, sanitation), it supported a confident belief in progress: that knowledge, technology, and reason would improve life. Historians call the decades from 1850 to 1914 the "Age of Progress."

Challenges to rationalism

From the later nineteenth century, thinkers questioned reason's primacy. The CED says philosophy largely moved from rational interpretations of nature and human society to an emphasis on irrationality and impulse, a view that contributed to the belief that conflict and struggle led to progress.

  • Friedrich Nietzsche attacked conventional morality and religion (famously writing that "God is dead"), stressing the will to power and the creation of one's own values.
  • Henri Bergson emphasized intuition and the "life force" over mechanical reasoning, and Georges Sorel argued that myths and violence, such as the general strike, drove social change.
  • Sigmund Freud, a Viennese doctor, developed psychoanalysis. In The Interpretation of Dreams (1899) he argued that the unconscious mind, with its hidden desires and conflicts, shapes behavior. The CED says Freud offered a new account of human nature emphasizing the role of the irrational and the struggle between the conscious and subconscious.

Physics: the end of Newtonian certainty

The CED says developments in the natural sciences, such as quantum mechanics and Einstein's theory of relativity, undermined the primacy of Newtonian physics as an objective description of nature. Max Planck proposed in 1900 that energy comes in discrete units (quanta). Albert Einstein's special theory of relativity (1905) showed that time and space are not absolute, and he later explained gravity as curved space-time (1915). The discovery of X-rays (Röntgen, 1895) and radioactivity (the Curies, 1898) showed that the atom had a complex structure. Newton's universe had seemed solid and knowable. Scientists now saw uncertainty at its foundations.

Religion

Science, historical criticism of the Bible, and Darwin posed challenges to religious belief. Churches responded in different ways: some accommodated science, while the Catholic Church under Pius IX issued the Syllabus of Errors (1864) condemning liberalism and modern ideas. Many Europeans remained religious, but religion lost some of its public authority.

Primary source · Natural selection

Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species (1859), chapter 3, excerpt.

I have called this principle, by which each slight variation, if useful, is preserved, by the term of Natural Selection.

Sourcing (HIPP). Darwin was an English naturalist who wrote the book after decades of observation and was prompted to publish when Alfred Russel Wallace reached similar ideas. His audience was scientists and educated readers, and the purpose was to present evidence for his theory. His point of view was that of a careful scientist. The passage states the principle of natural selection, but it says nothing about human society, so the later Social Darwinist uses of it were the work of other writers.

Source analysis · A scientific principle

Claim. Darwin proposes a mechanism, natural selection, by which useful variations are preserved.

Evidence. He says he calls the principle by which "each slight variation, if useful, is preserved" by the term "Natural Selection."

Reasoning. The statement gives a natural and material explanation of biological change, which the CED identifies as Darwin's contribution. It shows why the theory challenged religious accounts and why others applied it to society. A limit is that Darwin's argument is about species, so Social Darwinism reflects the use others made of it, not what he wrote here.

Worked example · Influence of ideas

Question. Explain one way Darwin's theory influenced social thought and one way later science challenged earlier certainties.

Model. Darwin's theory was used by others to justify Social Darwinism, the claim that competition among individuals, classes, nations, and races was natural and produced progress, which supported racialist ideas and imperial expansion. Later, Planck's quantum theory and Einstein's relativity undermined the Newtonian picture of an objective, predictable universe, adding to a sense of uncertainty in thought.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives E and F cover two moods of the period: confidence (Darwin's science, positivism, progress) and doubt (irrationalism, Freud, quantum mechanics and relativity). For Darwin, separate his theory from Social Darwinism, which the CED calls an inadvertent justification. Name specific thinkers (Comte, Nietzsche, Bergson, Sorel, Freud, Planck, Einstein) and what each changed.

Practice
  1. What is natural selection?
    Show answer

    The process by which individuals with useful variations are more likely to survive and reproduce, leading over time to the development of new species.

  2. What was Social Darwinism and who used it?
    Show answer

    The application of evolution to society, claiming competition among individuals, nations, and races produced progress; it was used to justify capitalism, racism, and imperialism.

  3. What did positivism hold?
    Show answer

    That science alone provides knowledge and that society should be studied and improved through scientific methods.

  4. Name two thinkers who emphasized irrationality.
    Show answer

    Friedrich Nietzsche, Henri Bergson, Georges Sorel, or Sigmund Freud.

  5. What did Freud contribute?
    Show answer

    A new account of human nature emphasizing the unconscious and the struggle between conscious and subconscious mind.

  6. How did physics undermine Newtonian certainty?
    Show answer

    Planck's quantum theory and Einstein's relativity showed that energy, time, and space did not behave as Newtonian physics described.

Lesson 7.5 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.6

New imperialism: motives and methods

Between about 1870 and 1914, European states took control of most of Africa and large parts of Asia and the Pacific, more land in a few decades than in the preceding centuries. Learning Objective G asks you to explain the motivations that led to European imperialism from 1815 to 1914, and Learning Objective H asks how technological advances enabled it. Historians call this phase the New Imperialism, to distinguish it from the earlier colonization of the Americas.

Required content · 7G, 7H

Learning objectives.

  • 7G. Explain the motivations that led to European imperialism in the period from 1815 to 1914.
  • 7H. Explain how technological advances enabled European imperialism from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.5.I.A. European national rivalries and strategic concerns fostered imperial expansion and competition for colonies.
  • 3.5.I.B. The search for raw materials and markets for manufactured goods, as well as strategic and nationalistic considerations, drove Europeans to colonize Africa and Asia, even as European colonies in the Americas broke free politically, if not economically.
  • 3.5.I.C. European imperialists justified overseas expansion and rule by claiming cultural and racial superiority.
  • 3.5.II.A. The development of advanced weaponry ensured the military advantage of Europeans over colonized areas.
  • 3.5.II.B. Communication and transportation technologies facilitated the creation and expansion of European empires.
  • 3.5.II.C. Advances in medicine enabled European survival in Africa and Asia.

The scramble

  • Africa. Around 1870 Europeans held only coastal areas, such as Algeria (French since 1830), the Cape Colony, and trading posts. The Scramble for Africa began in the 1880s. At the Berlin Conference (1884 to 1885) European powers agreed on rules for claiming African territory, including "effective occupation," without consulting Africans. By 1914 only Ethiopia (which defeated Italy at Adwa in 1896) and Liberia remained independent. Britain took Egypt (1882), Sudan, Nigeria, and southern and eastern Africa, and fought the Boer War (1899 to 1902); France built a vast empire across West and North Africa; Germany, Italy, Portugal, and Belgium also claimed territory. King Leopold II of Belgium held the Congo as a private colony.
  • Asia. Britain ruled India directly after the 1857 rebellion, and the French took Indochina. The powers forced China open through the Opium Wars (1839 to 1842, 1856 to 1860) and then carved out spheres of influence there. Russia expanded into Central Asia and the Pacific coast.

Motives

The CED identifies three categories.

  • Rivalry and strategy. European national rivalries and strategic concerns fostered imperial expansion and competition for colonies. Powers feared losing out to rivals: Britain seized Egypt to protect the Suez Canal and the route to India, and France and Germany competed for prestige.
  • Economics. The search for raw materials and markets for manufactured goods, along with strategic and nationalistic considerations, drove Europeans to colonize Africa and Asia, even as European colonies in the Americas broke free politically, if not economically. Industry needed rubber, copper, cotton, palm oil, and other materials and wanted outlets for goods and investment. Colonies in Latin America had gained independence in the early nineteenth century, but they remained tied to European capital and trade.
  • Ideology. European imperialists justified overseas expansion and rule by claiming cultural and racial superiority. They spoke of a duty to civilize, as in Rudyard Kipling's poem about "the White Man's burden," or the French mission civilisatrice. Social Darwinism (Lesson 7.4) gave pseudo-scientific support. Christian missionaries, also, wished to convert. Historians note that such claims were also a cover for self-interest, and at home, popular newspapers and nationalist groups made empire a source of pride.

Methods: technology

The CED says the technological advantages made imperial rule possible.

  • Weapons. The CED says advanced weaponry ensured the military advantage of Europeans over colonized areas: the Minié ball (a conical bullet), breech-loading rifles, and the machine gun (the Maxim gun, 1884). At the battle of Omdurman (1898) in Sudan, a British force with machine guns killed some ten thousand Mahdist warriors while losing fewer than fifty of its own men.
  • Communication and transportation. Steamships, the Suez Canal (1869), railways, the telegraph, and photography facilitated the creation and expansion of European empires, letting governments move troops and orders quickly and bring home images and information.
  • Medicine. Advances in medicine enabled European survival in Africa and Asia: quinine to prevent malaria, Pasteur's germ theory, antiseptics, anesthesia, and public health measures. Before quinine, tropical diseases had killed Europeans in huge numbers.

These advantages did not guarantee conquest. Africans and Asians resisted fiercely, and Europeans often depended on local allies and soldiers, but the technology gave them a decisive edge in most clashes.

1830 France invades Algeria 1857 Indian rebellion 1869 Suez Canal opens 1882 Britain occupies Egypt 1884-85 Berlin Conference 1898 Omdurman; Fashoda 1899-1902 Boer War 1905, 1911 Moroccan crises
Figure 7.3. Empire and rivalry. Conquest in Africa and Asia accelerated after 1870, and colonial crises strained relations among the powers.
Primary source · The civilizing claim

Rudyard Kipling, "The White Man's Burden" (1899), opening line.

Take up the White Man's burden...

Sourcing (HIPP). Kipling, a British writer born in India, wrote the poem to urge the United States to take the Philippines after the Spanish-American War, so the purpose was persuasion of an American audience. It was widely read in Britain and elsewhere as a statement of imperial duty. His point of view is that of a supporter of empire who saw it as a heavy moral task, which is a form of racial and cultural superiority. The poem shows the ideology the CED describes, but it tells us nothing about how colonized peoples saw empire, and critics at the time attacked it.

Source analysis · A justification of empire

Claim. Kipling presents imperial rule as a duty of the "White Man."

Evidence. The poem opens with the command "Take up the White Man's burden."

Reasoning. The line expresses the claim of cultural and racial superiority that the CED lists among the justifications for imperialism. By describing conquest as a burden and duty, it hides the economic and strategic motives. Written for an American audience about the Philippines, it is evidence of how supporters framed empire, not of what colonized people experienced.

Worked example · Motives and methods

Question. Explain one motive and one enabling technology of the New Imperialism.

Model. One motive was the search for raw materials and markets for manufactured goods: industrial economies needed materials such as rubber and copper and wanted places to sell goods and invest capital. One enabling technology was advanced weaponry, such as breech-loading rifles and the machine gun, which gave Europeans a military advantage over colonized peoples, as at Omdurman in 1898.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives G and H call for motives and methods. Group the motives (rivalry and strategy, economics, ideology) and the methods (weapons, communication and transportation, medicine), each with a named example. Remember that imperialism followed industrialization (Unit 6), nationalism (Lesson 7.1), and Social Darwinism, and avoid claiming that Europeans were unopposed.

Practice
  1. What happened at the Berlin Conference (1884 to 1885)?
    Show answer

    European powers set rules for claiming African territory, such as effective occupation, without African participation.

  2. Name three motives for the New Imperialism.
    Show answer

    National rivalry and strategic concerns, raw materials and markets, and beliefs in cultural and racial superiority.

  3. How did Europeans justify imperial rule?
    Show answer

    By claiming a duty to civilize and a cultural and racial superiority, supported by Social Darwinism and missionary zeal.

  4. Name two weapons that gave Europeans an advantage.
    Show answer

    Breech-loading rifles, the Minié ball, and the machine gun.

  5. How did medicine help imperial expansion?
    Show answer

    Quinine protected against malaria, and germ theory, antiseptics, and public health measures reduced deaths among Europeans in Africa and Asia.

  6. Why did European colonies in the Americas not end European economic influence?
    Show answer

    They became politically independent in the early nineteenth century, but they remained tied to European capital and trade.

Lesson 7.6 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.7

Imperialism's effects in Europe and the world

Empires changed the colonized lands, and they changed Europe. Learning Objective I asks you to explain how European imperialism affected both European and non-European societies. The CED lists three effects: imperialism created diplomatic tensions among European states that strained alliance systems; imperial encounters influenced the styles and subject matter of artists and writers and provoked debate over the acquisition of colonies; and, as non-Europeans became educated in Western values, they challenged European imperialism through nationalist movements and by modernizing local economies and societies.

Required content · 7I

Learning objective.

  • 7I. Explain how European imperialism affected both European and non- European societies.

Historical developments.

  • 3.5.III.A. Imperialism created diplomatic tensions among European states that strained alliance systems.
  • 3.5.III.B. Imperial encounters with non-European peoples influenced the styles and subject matter of artists and writers and provoked debate over the acquisition of colonies.
  • 3.5.III.C. Especially as non-Europeans became educated in Western values, they challenged European imperialism through nationalist movements and by modernizing local economies and societies.

Tensions among the powers

Competition for colonies caused crises that strained the alliance systems.

  • The Berlin Conference (1884 to 1885) was called to regulate the race for Africa and to settle the Congo question, but it stimulated further claims.
  • The Fashoda crisis (1898): a French expedition reached Fashoda on the Nile in Sudan, where it met a British force. Britain's goal of a route from Cairo to the Cape clashed with France's plan for an east-west empire across Africa. France backed down, and the crisis pushed the two powers to settle their quarrels in the Entente Cordiale (1904) (Lesson 7.3).
  • The Moroccan crises (1905 and 1911): Germany challenged French claims on Morocco by landing the Kaiser at Tangier and sending a gunboat to Agadir. Britain backed France, which tightened the Entente and increased distrust of Germany.

Colonial disputes did not directly cause the First World War, but they poisoned relations and added to the arms and naval race.

The debate at home

Imperialism was controversial in Europe. The CED notes it provoked debate over the acquisition of colonies.

  • Supporters included nationalist groups such as the Pan-German League, businesses seeking markets, and many newspapers.
  • Critics. The British economist J. A. Hobson, in Imperialism: A Study (1902), argued that the search for profitable investments by wealthy financiers, not national interest, drove empire. The Russian revolutionary Vladimir Lenin developed this argument in 1916 to claim that imperialism was the final stage of capitalism. The Congo Reform Association (led by E. D. Morel and Roger Casement) exposed atrocities in Leopold II's Congo, where forced labor in rubber collecting killed millions, and forced the Belgian government to take over the colony in 1908.

Art and literature

Encounters with non-European peoples influenced European culture. Artists took ideas from African masks and sculpture, as in Picasso's Les Demoiselles d'Avignon (1907), from Pacific and Tahitian life, as in Gauguin, and from Japanese prints (Japonisme). Writers explored empire in novels such as Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness (1899), which criticized the brutality of colonial exploitation while still reflecting the racial thinking of its time. Exhibitions and world's fairs displayed colonial peoples as spectacles and fed popular beliefs about racial hierarchy.

Responses in the colonized world

The CED says that non-Europeans educated in Western values challenged European imperialism through nationalist movements and by modernizing local economies and societies. Resistance took many forms.

  • The Indian rebellion of 1857 (the Sepoy Mutiny), when Indian soldiers in the East India Company's army rose, was followed by direct British rule. Later, educated Indians founded the Indian National Congress (1885), at first to seek a greater voice and then self-rule.
  • The Zulu nation defeated a British column at Isandlwana (1879) but was conquered in the end.
  • China's Boxer Rebellion (1899 to 1901), an anti-foreign uprising, was crushed by an international force.
  • Japan's Meiji Restoration (from 1868) modernized the state, army, and economy on a Western model, kept Japan independent, and made it an imperial power that defeated Russia in 1905, a shock to European confidence.

Colonial rule also brought railways, ports, schools, and new administrative systems, built chiefly for European purposes. It disrupted local economies, imposed arbitrary borders, and forced people into cash crops and wage labor, and its effects are still debated and felt.

Primary source · A critic of empire

Description of: J. A. Hobson, Imperialism: A Study (1902). Hobson argues that imperial expansion benefited a small group of financiers and manufacturers seeking profitable investment abroad while costing the nation as a whole, and that the real cause of expansion was this economic interest, covered by appeals to national duty and to the civilizing of other peoples.

Sourcing (HIPP). Hobson was a British economist and journalist who traveled in South Africa and wrote after the Boer War, so his purpose was to oppose imperialism and persuade the public. His point of view was that of a liberal critic, and his audience was educated British readers. The book shows that debate about empire existed in Europe, though Hobson focuses on economic motives and gives less attention to strategic rivalry and ideology. It also says little about the experience of colonized people.

Source analysis · A critical argument

Claim. Hobson argues that imperialism served the interests of financiers, not the nation or the colonized.

Evidence. In the described argument, expansion benefits those seeking profitable overseas investment while appeals to duty cover the real motive.

Reasoning. The argument supports the CED's point that imperialism provoked debate in Europe, and it shows an economic interpretation that later influenced Lenin. A limit is that Hobson stressed one motive, so a historian would also consider strategic and nationalist causes, and the source comes from Britain, not from the colonized world.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one effect of imperialism on European politics and one on colonized societies.

Model. Imperial rivalry caused diplomatic crises, such as Fashoda and the Moroccan crises, that strained alliances and pushed Britain and France together against Germany. In colonized societies, Western-educated people formed nationalist movements, such as the Indian National Congress, that challenged imperial rule, while others, as in Meiji Japan, modernized their own economies and societies.

Exam focus

Learning Objective I wants effects on both Europe and the colonized world. The CED gives three: diplomatic tensions (Berlin, Fashoda, Morocco), cultural influence and debate (artists, writers, Hobson, the Congo reform movement), and responses by non-Europeans (nationalism, modernization, resistance). For the third, avoid describing colonized peoples only as victims; name the movements and leaders they created.

Practice
  1. Name two imperial crises between European powers.
    Show answer

    The Fashoda crisis (1898) and the Moroccan crises (1905 and 1911), among others.

  2. How did colonial rivalry affect alliances?
    Show answer

    It pushed Britain and France to settle disputes and align against Germany, tightening the Entente.

  3. What was Hobson's argument about imperialism?
    Show answer

    That it served the economic interests of financiers seeking profitable investments and was disguised by appeals to duty and civilization.

  4. How did empire influence European art?
    Show answer

    Artists took ideas from African, Pacific, and Japanese art, as with Picasso, Gauguin, and Japonisme.

  5. Name one nationalist response to imperialism.
    Show answer

    The Indian National Congress, the Zulu resistance, the Sepoy rebellion, China's Boxer Rebellion, or Meiji modernization in Japan.

  6. Why did the Meiji Restoration surprise Europeans?
    Show answer

    Japan modernized on a Western model, stayed independent, and defeated Russia in 1905, showing a non-European state could compete.

Lesson 7.7 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.8

Nineteenth-century culture and the arts

The arts of the nineteenth century moved through several styles in a century, and each one reacted to the one before and to social change. Learning Objective J asks you to explain the continuities and changes in European artistic expression from 1815 to 1914. The CED traces three movements: Romanticism, Realism, and modern art. The trend runs from emotion, to observation of ordinary life, to the subjective and abstract.

Required content · 7J

Learning objective.

  • 7J. Explain the continuities and changes in European artistic expression from 1815 to 1914.

Historical developments.

  • 3.6.I.A. Romantic artists and composers broke from classical artistic forms to emphasize emotion, nature, individuality, intuition, the supernatural, and national histories in their works.
  • 3.6.I.B. Romantic writers expressed similar themes while responding to the Industrial Revolution and to various political revolutions.
  • 3.6.II.D. Realist and materialist themes and attitudes influenced art and literature as painters and writers depicted the lives of ordinary people and drew attention to social problems.
  • 3.6.III.D. Modern art, including Impressionism, Post-Impressionism, and Cubism, moved beyond the representational to the subjective, abstract, and expressive and often provoked audiences that believed that art should reflect shared and idealized values, including beauty and patriotism.

Romanticism: emotion, nature, and the nation

The CED says Romantic artists and composers broke from classical artistic forms to emphasize emotion, nature, individuality, intuition, the supernatural, and national histories. (Lesson 5.8 introduced the movement.) Romanticism broke with Neoclassical forms and with rationalism, placing more emphasis on intuition and emotion.

  • Painters: Francisco Goya, Caspar David Friedrich, J. M. W. Turner, John Constable, and Eugène Delacroix, whose Liberty Leading the People (1830) celebrated the July Revolution.
  • Composers: Ludwig van Beethoven, Frédéric Chopin, Richard Wagner, and Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Many drew on folk music and national legends.
  • Writers: Goethe, William Wordsworth, Lord Byron, Percy and Mary Shelley, John Keats, and Victor Hugo.

The CED adds that Romantic writers expressed similar themes while responding to the Industrial Revolution and to various political revolutions. William Blake wrote of England's "dark Satanic mills," and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1818) explored the dangers of science without responsibility.

Realism: ordinary life and social problems

By the mid-century, Romanticism gave way to Realism. The CED says realist and materialist themes and attitudes influenced art and literature as painters and writers depicted the lives of ordinary people and drew attention to social problems. The movement reflected industrial society and the influence of science and positivism.

  • Novelists: Honoré de Balzac, Charles Dickens (exposing poverty and child labor), George Eliot (the pen name of Mary Ann Evans), Thomas Hardy, Fyodor Dostoevsky and Leo Tolstoy in Russia, and Émile Zola, who studied the workers of France in a nearly scientific way and was a leader of Naturalism.
  • Painters: Gustave Courbet, who painted workers breaking stones, Jean-François Millet (peasants), and Honoré Daumier, a satirist of the rich and powerful.

Realists wanted to show life as it was, often shocking audiences used to idealized subjects.

Modern art: beyond representation

The CED states that modern art, including Impressionism, Post-Impressionism, and Cubism, moved beyond the representational to the subjective, abstract, and expressive and often provoked audiences that believed that art should reflect shared and idealized values, including beauty and patriotism.

  • Impressionism (from the 1870s): Claude Monet, Pierre-Auguste Renoir, and Edgar Degas painted fleeting effects of light and modern city life, with loose brushwork. The name came from a critic's mocking review of Monet's Impression, Sunrise (1872). Photography, which could record reality exactly, freed painters from representation.
  • Post-Impressionism: Vincent van Gogh, Paul Cézanne, and Paul Gauguin used color and form to express feeling and structure. Cézanne's geometric treatment of objects influenced later artists.
  • Cubism (from about 1907): Pablo Picasso and Georges Braque broke objects into geometric shapes seen from several views at once.

Such art was often attacked by academies, critics, and the public as ugly or insulting. Exhibits such as the Salon des Refusés (1863), which showed works rejected by the official Salon, show the conflict between established tastes and the new art.

Why the arts changed

Several forces drove change: industrial society, which created a middle-class public and new subjects; science and photography, which changed ideas about representation; political revolutions and nationalism, which fed Romanticism; new psychological ideas (Lesson 7.4), which turned artists toward subjective experience; and encounters with non-European art (Lesson 7.6).

Primary source · A mocking review

Description of: Louis Leroy, review "Exhibition of the Impressionists," Le Charivari (April 1874), a satirical account of the first independent exhibition of Monet, Renoir, Degas, and others. Leroy pretends to walk through the show with a conservative painter who grows angry at unfinished-looking canvases, and he makes fun of Monet's Impression, Sunrise for being a mere "impression," not a finished picture.

Sourcing (HIPP). Leroy was a critic and humorist for a satirical paper, so his purpose was to entertain and to mock, and his audience was Parisian readers who valued traditional painting. His point of view was hostile to the new style, and the name "Impressionists" began as an insult that the artists later adopted. The review is good evidence of how the CED's "audiences that believed art should reflect shared and idealized values" reacted, but it reflects one critic and a limited public.

Source analysis · A hostile reception

Claim. Leroy's review shows that many critics rejected Impressionism as unfinished and unserious.

Evidence. He mocks Monet's work as a mere "impression" and presents its viewers as angry.

Reasoning. The reaction fits the CED's point that modern art provoked audiences who expected art to reflect beauty and idealized values. Because Leroy was writing satire for an audience who wanted a laugh, the review exaggerates, and the later recognition of the Impressionists shows that his view did not hold.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one change in European art between Romanticism and Realism.

Model. Romantic artists emphasized emotion, nature, the supernatural, and national history, while Realists, influenced by industrial society and science, depicted the lives of ordinary working people and drew attention to social problems, as in Courbet's painting of stone breakers and Dickens's novels about poverty.

Exam focus

Learning Objective J is a continuity and change objective across three movements. For each, give the core idea (Romanticism: emotion and the nation; Realism: ordinary life and social problems; modern art: the subjective and abstract), a named artist or work, and the reaction it provoked. Tie changes to causes (industry, science and photography, politics, psychology). Do not describe the movements as strictly separate; some artists crossed categories.

Practice
  1. Name three themes of Romantic art.
    Show answer

    Emotion, nature, individuality, intuition, the supernatural, and national histories.

  2. What did Realist artists and writers show?
    Show answer

    The lives of ordinary people and social problems, such as poverty, in a detailed and often critical way.

  3. Name two Realist writers or painters.
    Show answer

    Dickens, Balzac, Eliot, Zola, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Courbet, Millet, or Daumier.

  4. What was Impressionism?
    Show answer

    A style from the 1870s that painted fleeting effects of light and modern life with loose brushwork, led by Monet and Renoir.

  5. How did photography affect painting?
    Show answer

    It could record reality exactly, which freed painters to explore color, light, and subjective expression instead of exact representation.

  6. Why did modern art often provoke public anger?
    Show answer

    It moved beyond representation to the subjective and abstract, while many expected art to show beauty and shared idealized values such as patriotism.

Lesson 7.8 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.9

Causation: nationalism, imperialism, and stability

The last topic of Unit 7 practices causation on the evidence of nationalism and imperialism. Learning Objective K asks you to explain the influence of nationalist and imperialist movements on European and global stability between 1815 and 1914. The skill is to show how two powerful forces, one inside Europe and one outside, produced both order and disorder, and to judge how much each contributed to the crisis of 1914.

Required content · 7K

Learning objective.

  • 7K. Explain the influence of nationalist and imperialist movements on European and global stability.

Reasoning process. Causation. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

Nationalism: two directions

Nationalism pushed in opposite directions, and a strong answer shows both.

  • State-building and consolidation. Italy and Germany were unified (Lesson 7.2), and conservative leaders used popular nationalism to strengthen states (Lesson 7.1). Unification changed the balance of power by creating a large industrial Germany in the center of Europe.
  • Division and disruption. Nationalism threatened multinational empires, such as Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire, which could not satisfy all their peoples. The Balkans became the most dangerous region in Europe (Lesson 7.3).
  • Aggressive nationalism. Chauvinism and racialism produced anti-Semitism, Pan-Germanism, and Pan-Slavism, and a belief in national rivalry as a natural struggle (Lesson 7.4).

Imperialism: spreading rivalry

  • Competition and crisis. The race for colonies, with crises at Fashoda and in Morocco, moved European rivalries to the world stage and strained alliances (Lesson 7.6).
  • Global stability. Empire brought Europeans power over much of the world, but it also produced resistance and nationalist movements in colonies (Lesson 7.6). Japan's rise and the defeat of Russia in 1905 showed new powers emerging.
  • Economic effects. Empire supported European industry, but it also imposed costs and encouraged competition and an arms race.

Tracing the chain to 1914

A causal explanation of why Europe became unstable could include these links.

  1. Unification of Germany (1871) created a strong state in the center, and Bismarck's alliances kept peace until 1890 (Lesson 7.3).
  2. Alliance blocs formed after 1890 as Germany's new policy alarmed others (Lesson 7.3).
  3. Imperial and naval rivalries led to crises that drew Britain and France together against Germany (Lesson 7.6).
  4. Balkan nationalism was the trigger: Serbia's rise threatened Austria-Hungary, and the alliance system turned a local clash into a general war (Lesson 8.1).

No single link was enough: nationalism, imperialism, alliances, militarism, and domestic politics acted together.

Judging

When asked to evaluate, rank the causes and argue for your ranking. A defensible argument might be that nationalism in the Balkans was the most important immediate cause, because it provided the spark, while alliances and imperial rivalry were the conditions that turned a spark into a general war. An opposing view stresses German policy (Weltpolitik and the naval race). Either way, provide evidence and recognize the limits of the argument.

Primary source · A historian's argument

Description of: A modern historian's argument that the First World War resulted from the combination of nationalist crises in the Balkans and a rigid alliance system, rather than from any one power's plan. The author maintains that colonial rivalry had strained relations among the powers but that the immediate cause was the escalation of the Serbian-Austrian conflict.

Sourcing (HIPP). The author writes with hindsight, so the point of view is analytical, and the purpose is to evaluate competing causes. The audience is scholars and students. As a secondary source, it presents a claim that you can test against evidence: the Balkan crises of 1908 and 1912 to 1913, the alliance commitments, and the colonial crises of 1905 and 1911. Strong responses note that other historians, who stress German aims, would challenge it.

Source analysis · Claim and evidence

Claim. The historian argues that Balkan nationalism, together with the alliance system, caused the war.

Evidence. The Bosnian crisis and Balkan Wars raised tensions between Serbia and Austria-Hungary, and alliance commitments linked each of them to a great power.

Reasoning. The claim fits the CED's statement that nationalist tensions in the Balkans drew the Great Powers into a series of crises. A limit is that it gives less weight to German policy and imperial rivalry, so a comparison with other interpretations would strengthen the answer.

Worked example · Influence on stability

Question. Explain one way nationalism and one way imperialism affected European stability between 1815 and 1914.

Model. Nationalism destabilized multinational empires: Serbian nationalism threatened Austria-Hungary, and Balkan crises drew the great powers into conflict. Imperialism created diplomatic crises, such as Fashoda and the Moroccan crises, that strained relations and pushed Britain and France together against Germany, hardening the alliance blocs.

Exam focus

A good causation answer on Learning Objective K shows both effects of each force: nationalism built states (Italy, Germany) and broke empires; imperialism spread European power and created rivalry and resistance. Include chains of events with dates, rank the causes, and note limits. Remember that not every historian agrees on which cause was most important.

Practice
  1. Give one stabilizing and one destabilizing effect of nationalism.
    Show answer

    Stabilizing: unification made Italy and Germany stronger states and conservatives used nationalism to build support. Destabilizing: it threatened multinational empires such as Austria-Hungary.

  2. How did imperialism strain European relations?
    Show answer

    Colonial rivalries produced crises such as Fashoda and Morocco, which strained alliances and increased suspicion.

  3. Why were the Balkans the most dangerous region?
    Show answer

    Serbian nationalism, Ottoman decline, and Austrian and Russian interests collided there, and alliances tied the great powers to local clashes.

  4. How did alliance blocs make local conflicts more dangerous?
    Show answer

    Each great power was committed to an ally, so a clash between two states could draw in all the others.

  5. Name two causes of instability in addition to nationalism and imperialism.
    Show answer

    The alliance system, the naval and arms race, militarism, and German foreign policy.

  6. Why might historians disagree about the most important cause?
    Show answer

    They weigh different evidence: some stress Balkan nationalism, others German policy or imperial rivalry, so rankings of causes differ.

Unit 7 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 7 review: 19th-Century Perspectives and Political Developments

Ten questions on Italian and German unification, mass politics and its limits, Darwin and Social Darwinism, and the New Imperialism, plus two short-answer questions on nationalism and empire.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: Giuseppe Mazzini, The Duties of Man, 1860.

    "Your country is the sign of the Mission which God has given you to fulfil towards Humanity. … In labouring for our own country on the right principle, we labour for Humanity."

    Mazzini's conception of nationalism differs most sharply from that of the late nineteenth century in its

    Correct. Early liberal nationalism treated each nation's freedom as a contribution to a shared human project, not as rivalry: the opposite of the exclusive, competitive nationalism of the century's end.

    Racial definitions of nationhood belong to the later period Mazzini is being contrasted with, and he appeals to mission and duty instead.

    That is Cavour's method, which Mazzini opposed. He favored popular insurrection.

    The passage invokes God directly, tying national mission to religious duty.

  2. Garibaldi's decision in 1860 to deliver his conquests to Victor Emmanuel rather than proclaim a republic is significant because it

    The Kingdom of Italy was proclaimed the following year, in 1861; the decision accelerated unification rather than halting it.

    Correct. A republican south against a monarchist north would have meant civil war, so the Mazzinian strand gave way: producing a constitutional monarchy under Piedmont rather than the republic Mazzini wanted.

    Rome was taken only in 1870, and the papacy remained hostile, forbidding Catholics to participate in Italian politics.

    Austria had been defeated in 1859 and lost Venetia in 1866; recognition was not what Garibaldi's handover achieved.

  3. Source: Otto von Bismarck, speech to the Prussian budget committee, September 1862.

    "Not by speeches and majority decisions will the great questions of the day be decided — that was the great mistake of 1848 and 1849 — but by iron and blood."

    Bismarck delivered this while

    Correct. He was telling a hostile liberal committee that the national unity it wanted could be had only by means it had rejected, and he then collected taxes without authorization for four years.

    The proclamation at Versailles came in January 1871, nearly a decade later.

    The Zollverein dated from 1834, long before Bismarck took office in 1862.

    Universal male suffrage for the Reichstag came with the constitutions of 1867 and 1871, after the wars this speech anticipated.

  4. German unification most fundamentally altered the European state system because it

    Austria remained a great power and became Germany's principal ally after 1879, though excluded from German affairs.

    Correct. Vienna had depended on German division to keep the center of Europe weak; a single empire with the strongest army and fastest-growing industry forced every other power to recalculate.

    France had introduced universal male suffrage earlier, and the German chancellor answered to the emperor rather than to the elected Reichstag.

    Bismarck built an elaborate alliance system precisely to manage the new situation, and the alliances of 1914 grew out of it.

  5. Source: Émile Zola, "J'Accuse…!", open letter published in L'Aurore, January 1898.

    "I accuse the War Office of having conducted an abominable campaign in the press … in order to cover up its own misdeeds. … As for the people I am accusing, I do not know them, I have never seen them, I feel neither resentment nor hatred toward them."

    Zola named specific officers on a newspaper front page primarily in order to

    Naming officers invited rather than avoided prosecution, and he was in fact convicted and fled to England.

    Correct. A libel trial was the mechanism by which suppressed evidence could be examined publicly: the strategy is the document's purpose.

    Zola was a novelist, not a candidate for office, and the letter attacks the government rather than applying to it.

    The letter's impact demonstrated the opposite: the mass press could force a state institution into daylight.

  6. Source: Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 1859.

    "As many more individuals of each species are born than can possibly survive; and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence, it follows that any being, if it vary however slightly in any manner profitable to itself … will have a better chance of surviving."

    Social Darwinists went beyond this passage principally by claiming that

    Correct. Darwin describes differential survival within a species with no claim about progress or societies; Spencer and others supplied both, then used them to justify laissez-faire and empire.

    Gradual change over long time-scales is Darwin's own position, stated in the book.

    Inheritance of acquired characteristics is Lamarck's theory, which natural selection was proposed to replace.

    Darwin himself made this argument in The Descent of Man in 1871; it is not a Social Darwinist addition.

  7. The wide range of causes Social Darwinism was used to justify (opposition to factory regulation, to poor relief, and to colonial self-government alike) best suggests that it

    It confused natural selection with progress toward European norms and made no testable predictions; its weakness as science is well established.

    Correct. One idea serving so many different interests indicates that it supplied respectable scientific vocabulary for arguments that existed independently of it.

    It was enormously popular among politicians, journalists, and businessmen, far beyond professional biology.

    It was used overwhelmingly to justify imperial expansion, not to criticize it; Hobson's critique came from economics instead.

  8. Description of: the General Act of the Berlin Conference, 1885, and a contemporary partition map of Africa.

    The Act declares free trade in the Congo and Niger basins, forbids the slave trade, and requires that a power claiming coastal territory notify the others and establish effective authority. Maps show territory assigned in straight lines and geometric blocks cutting across river systems and existing African polities.

    The most historically significant feature of the conference was that

    The declaration against the slave trade coexisted with the legitimation of Leopold's Congo Free State, where forced labor killed on a vast scale.

    Correct. The Act existed to prevent European wars over African territory; no African ruler attended, and the straight-line borders show how little the signatories knew or cared about what they divided.

    It did the opposite, providing the framework by which existing African polities were absorbed into European claims.

    The effective-occupation rule accelerated acquisition, and most of the partition occurred after 1885.

  9. Which best explains the timing and speed of the New Imperialism after 1870?

    Colonial ledgers show most possessions costing more in administration and defense than they returned, and powers seized territory of little commercial value.

    Correct. A unified Germany and Italy entered as claimants and France sought prestige after 1871, so territory not taken would be taken by a rival, and cheap enabling technology let the logic run to completion in thirty years.

    European populations were growing rapidly in this period, and few colonies attracted significant European settlement.

    Conquest was overwhelmingly resisted, from the Indian Rebellion of 1857 to Adwa in 1896 and the Boxer Uprising in 1900.

  10. Ethiopia's victory over Italy at Adwa in 1896 is historically significant chiefly because it

    Correct. Ethiopia's ability to acquire modern weapons and field a large coordinated army defeated a European invasion outright, undercutting claims of racial fitness that Social Darwinists used to justify conquest.

    The partition continued and accelerated after 1896; Ethiopia remained an exception rather than a turning point for the continent.

    Italy retained Eritrea and Somaliland and later invaded Ethiopia again in 1935.

    Menelik II had acquired substantial quantities of modern rifles and artillery, which is a central reason the battle went as it did.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way nationalism changed between the 1830s and the 1890s.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason Italian or German unification succeeded where the revolutions of 1848 had failed.
    3. Briefly explain ONE consequence of unification for the European balance of power.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: nationalism shifted from a liberal, democratic, and often revolutionary creed to a conservative instrument used by states; late-century nationalism became exclusive, competitive, and frequently racial and anti-Semitic. Do not accept: "it became more popular" with no change in content.
    • (b) Accept: unification was achieved by states with armies and diplomacy rather than by assemblies; Cavour's French alliance and war with Austria, Bismarck's three wars; conservative leadership avoided the class splits that divided 1848. Must explain the difference in method.
    • (c) Accept: a unified Germany with the strongest army replaced the fragmented center the Vienna settlement depended on, forcing realignment and eventually producing the alliance blocs of 1914; Austria was excluded from Germany and turned toward the Balkans. Must state the systemic consequence.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Nationalism changed sides politically. In the 1830s Mazzini presented national freedom as a democratic and republican duty owed to humanity as a whole, while by the 1890s conservative statesmen had harnessed nationalism to state power and it had become exclusive and competitive, frequently carrying racial and anti-Semitic content.

    (b) Unification succeeded because it was pursued by states with armies rather than by parliaments. The Frankfurt Parliament of 1848 debated for months and controlled no troops, whereas Bismarck built the Prussian army over parliamentary objection and fought three short wars between 1864 and 1871 to achieve unity on conservative terms.

    (c) German unification destroyed the balance the Congress of Vienna had built, which relied on keeping central Europe divided. A single empire with Europe's strongest army and fastest-growing industry forced France, Russia, and Britain to realign, eventually producing the two alliance blocs that went to war in 1914.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE motive for European imperial expansion after 1870.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason European powers were able to conquer territory so rapidly in this period.
    3. Briefly explain ONE long-term effect of imperialism on colonized societies.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: raw materials, markets, and outlets for investment; strategic routes such as Suez; national prestige and domestic politics; the civilizing mission and Social Darwinist racial hierarchy; missionary activity. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: quinine prophylaxis opening the African interior; steamships, railways, and the telegraph; breech-loading rifles and machine guns producing overwhelming firepower; exploitation of divisions among local polities. Must explain the mechanism.
    • (c) Accept: economies redirected toward export crops and extraction; borders drawn across existing polities; Western-educated elites who later led independence movements; population movement and labor coercion. Must state a durable consequence.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Strategic considerations drove much expansion. Britain occupied Egypt in 1882 largely to secure the Suez Canal, the route to India, rather than for the value of Egyptian territory itself, and once one power moved, others seized territory to deny it to rivals.

    (b) Technological advantages made conquest cheap in European lives. Quinine prophylaxis allowed Europeans to survive in regions where malaria had previously stopped them, while breech-loading rifles and machine guns gave small forces overwhelming firepower against armies that lacked them.

    (c) Colonial rule created Western-educated elites who later led independence movements. Schools founded to staff colonial administration taught European languages and political concepts such as national self-determination, and their graduates used that vocabulary to demand for their own peoples the sovereignty Europeans claimed for themselves.

Lesson 8.1 · Unit 8 · CED topics 8.1 and 8.2

Context and the causes of World War I

The twentieth century opened with the most destructive wars in history. Learning Objective A asks for the context in which global conflict developed, and Learning Objective B asks about the causes and effects of World War I. The CED's statement on causes is that a variety of factors, including nationalism, military plans, the alliance system, and imperial competition, turned a regional dispute in the Balkans into World War I. This lesson sets the context and explains how those factors fit together. The next lesson covers the war itself.

Required content · 8A, 8B

Learning objectives.

  • 8A. Explain the context in which global conflict developed in the 20th century.
  • 8B. Explain the causes and effects of World War I.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.I.A. A variety of factors, including nationalism, military plans, the alliance system, and imperial competition, turned a regional dispute in the Balkans into World War I.

The context: Europe in 1914

  • Great-power rivalry. Europe's economic and political power was at its peak, but rivalry was intense: Germany's rise upset the balance (Lesson 7.2), and the blocs of Triple Alliance and Triple Entente faced each other (Lesson 7.3).
  • Nationalism. National pride and ethnic nationalism were strong in every country, and in the Balkans and Austria-Hungary they threatened the existing states.
  • Imperial competition. Colonial rivalries had strained relations (Lesson 7.6), and European states ruled much of the world.
  • Militarism and the arms race. Armies and navies grew rapidly. Conscription gave Germany, France, and Russia armies of millions, and Britain and Germany raced to build battleships. Military leaders prepared detailed mobilization plans that relied on speed, which left little room for diplomacy.
  • Confidence in progress. Most Europeans believed in progress and many believed war would be short, glorious, and decisive.

The July Crisis, 1914

On June 28, 1914, Gavrilo Princip, a young Bosnian Serb nationalist linked to a Serbian secret society, shot and killed Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, and his wife in Sarajevo, Bosnia. Austria-Hungary, determined to crush Serbian nationalism, decided to act against Serbia.

  1. The blank check (July 5 to 6). Germany assured Austria-Hungary of its full support.
  2. The ultimatum (July 23). Austria-Hungary sent Serbia demands that were designed to be hard to accept entirely. Serbia accepted most of them.
  3. War on Serbia (July 28). Austria-Hungary declared war anyway.
  4. Mobilization. Russia, as Serbia's protector, began to mobilize. Germany saw Russian mobilization as a threat and declared war on Russia (August 1) and on France (August 3).
  5. The Schlieffen Plan. Germany's plan for a two-front war called for a quick defeat of France through Belgium before turning on Russia. German troops invaded neutral Belgium on August 4, and Britain, which had guaranteed Belgian neutrality, declared war on Germany.

Within a week, a Balkan dispute had involved all the great powers, which is the CED's meaning of a regional dispute turned into a world war.

June 28 Sarajevo assassination July 5-6 German blank check July 23 Ultimatum to Serbia July 28 Austria declares war on Serbia Aug 1-3 Germany declares war on Russia, France Aug 4 Belgium invaded; Britain enters From one assassination to a general war, 1914 Each step answered the one before it, and the alliances turned a local crisis into a European one
Figure 8.1. July Crisis. Within six weeks the killing of one archduke produced war among all the great powers of Europe.

Why did it happen? Weighing causes

Historians disagree about the importance of different causes, and a good answer weighs them.

CauseHow it contributedLimit
NationalismSerbian and Slavic nationalism threatened Austria-Hungary; national pride made compromise hardMost nationalists did not want a European war
Alliance systemCommitments linked local clashes to all the great powersSome allies were unreliable, and Britain was not firmly committed
Military plansMobilization timetables and the Schlieffen Plan made delay dangerousPlans were a response to political fears
Imperial competitionColonial crises hardened the blocs and fed distrustThe empires were not the immediate issue
German policySupport for Austria and a willingness to risk warOther states made decisions that raised tensions too

The CED's phrase is a variety of factors, so avoid naming only one. A defensible ranking is: Balkan nationalism as the spark, the alliance system and military plans as the mechanism that spread it, and imperial and naval rivalry as the background that made trust impossible.

Primary source · A guarantee and a plan

Description of: The "blank check" (July 5 to 6, 1914). Kaiser William II and his chancellor assured the Austro-Hungarian envoy that Germany would support Austria-Hungary if it acted against Serbia, even if Russia intervened, and advised swift action.

Sourcing (HIPP). The assurance was given in private conversation and recorded in diplomatic reports, so it is a record of a decision-making moment by the German leadership. Its purpose was to keep Austria-Hungary as an ally and to settle the Serbian question at a time Germany thought favorable. Because it was not a public statement, it shows what leaders intended, and historians use it to argue about German responsibility. It should be compared with the actions of Austria, Russia, France, and Britain that also contributed.

Source analysis · A decision and its consequences

Claim. Germany's promise of support encouraged Austria-Hungary to take a hard line against Serbia.

Evidence. German leaders promised backing even if Russia intervened, and advised quick action.

Reasoning. The assurance shows how the alliance system made a regional dispute larger, since Austria acted with the expectation of German support. It also supports arguments that German policy was an important cause. A limit is that the decisions of Russian, French, and British leaders also widened the war, so no single document explains it.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one way the alliance system and one way nationalism contributed to the outbreak of World War I.

Model. The alliance system tied the great powers to each other, so when Austria-Hungary attacked Serbia, Russia mobilized to support Serbia, Germany declared war on Russia and France to support its ally and plans, and Britain joined after Germany invaded Belgium. Nationalism contributed because Serbian nationalism, shown in the assassination at Sarajevo, threatened Austria-Hungary, which wanted to crush it.

Exam focus

Learning Objectives A and B are best answered with context first (rivalry, nationalism, imperial competition, militarism) and then the July Crisis sequence with dates. Always use the CED's list (nationalism, military plans, alliance system, imperial competition) and rank them. For "effects," look ahead to the next lesson, which covers technology, the home front, revolution, and the global character of the war.

Practice
  1. What was the immediate trigger for World War I?
    Show answer

    The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914, by a Bosnian Serb nationalist.

  2. Name the four factors the CED gives as causes.
    Show answer

    Nationalism, military plans, the alliance system, and imperial competition.

  3. What was the Schlieffen Plan, and what was its consequence?
    Show answer

    Germany's plan to defeat France quickly through Belgium before facing Russia; it led to the invasion of Belgium and British entry into the war.

  4. Why did the alliance system widen the conflict?
    Show answer

    Each great power was committed to an ally, so a clash between Austria-Hungary and Serbia drew in Russia, Germany, France, and Britain.

  5. Give one limit on blaming only German policy.
    Show answer

    Austria, Russia, France, and Britain also made decisions that escalated the crisis, such as Russian mobilization.

  6. Why would a historian rank Balkan nationalism as the spark but not the only cause?
    Show answer

    It provided the immediate crisis, but the alliance system, military plans, and imperial and naval rivalry explain why it became a general war.

Lesson 8.2 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.2

The Great War: technology, home front, and global effects

The war that began in August 1914 lasted more than four years and killed about ten million soldiers and millions of civilians. Learning Objectives B, C, and D ask for its effects, how new technology altered the conduct of the war, and how its developments changed political and diplomatic interactions among nations. The CED lists four points: new technologies confounded traditional strategies and led to trench warfare and massive troop losses; stalemate, national mobilization, and total war led to protest and insurrection and eventually to revolutions that changed the international balance of power; the war spread to non-European theaters; and Europe's relationship to the world shifted with the emergence of the United States as a world power and the overthrow of European empires.

Required content · 8B, 8C, 8D

Learning objectives.

  • 8B. Explain the causes and effects of World War I.
  • 8C. Explain how new technology altered the conduct of World War I.
  • 8D. Explain how the developments of World War I changed political and diplomatic interactions between and among nations.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.I.B. New technologies confounded traditional military strategies and led to trench warfare and massive troop losses.
  • 4.1.I.C. The effects of military stalemate, national mobilization, and total war led to protest and insurrection in the belligerent nations and eventually to revolutions that changed the international balance of power.
  • 4.1.I.D. The war in Europe quickly spread to non-European theaters, transforming the war into a global conflict.
  • 4.1.I.E. The relationship of Europe to the world shifted significantly with the globalization of the conflict, the emergence of the United States as a world power, and the overthrow of European empires.

The failure of quick victory

Germany's attack through Belgium was halted at the Battle of the Marne (September 1914). Both sides dug in, and from the English Channel to Switzerland, a line of trenches formed, with barbed wire and machine guns in front. For more than three years the Western Front barely moved.

New technology and trench warfare

The CED says new technologies confounded traditional military strategies. Infantry charges, which commanders believed would decide battles, met the machine gun, rapid-fire artillery, and barbed wire, and thousands died within hours. Other weapons followed.

  • Poison gas (first used by Germany in 1915).
  • Submarines (German U-boats attacked shipping).
  • Airplanes, at first for scouting and later bombing and combat.
  • Tanks, introduced by Britain in 1916 to break the stalemate.

The results were massive troop losses: at Verdun (1916) and the Somme (1916), each of which cost roughly a million casualties over months of fighting, gains were measured in yards.

Total war and the home front

The CED says the effects of military stalemate, national mobilization, and total war led to protest and insurrection in the belligerent nations. Total war means that every resource of a society, including factories, labor, food, money, and propaganda, is committed to the war.

  • Governments controlled economies, rationed food, took over industries, censored the press, and conscripted soldiers. Propaganda stirred hatred of the enemy.
  • Women worked in munitions factories, farms, and offices, and as nurses (Lesson 8.10).
  • Blockades. Britain's naval blockade of Germany caused food shortages, and German U-boats tried to starve Britain.
  • Strain. By 1917 war-weariness, food shortages, and heavy losses led to mutinies in armies (French mutinies in 1917) and the Easter Rebellion in Ireland (1916). In Russia, strain led to revolution (next lesson).

A global war

The war in Europe quickly spread to non-European theaters, transforming it into a global conflict. Britain and France drew on their empires for troops and labor from India, Africa, Australia, Canada, and elsewhere. Japan seized German possessions in China and the Pacific. The Ottoman Empire joined Germany in 1914, and the Armenian Genocide (1915 to 1916) saw the Ottoman government murder and deport about a million or more Armenians. Britain encouraged an Arab revolt against the Turks. In the war at sea and in colonial theaters, Germany lost its colonies.

The United States and the end

German unrestricted submarine warfare sank neutral ships and brought the United States into the war in April 1917. American troops and supplies turned the balance. Russia left the war after its revolution (1918), and Germany made a last offensive in spring 1918 that failed. By autumn, the German army was exhausted, its allies were collapsing, and revolution broke out at home. The Armistice took effect on November 11, 1918, and the Kaiser abdicated.

1914 Marne; trenches form 1915 Gas; Armenian Genocide 1916 Verdun; Somme; Easter Rising 1917 U.S. enters; Russian Revolution 1918 Brest-Litovsk; German offensive fails Nov 11, 1918 Armistice
Figure 8.2. World War I. A war expected to be short became a four-year stalemate of trenches and total mobilization that ended only when the United States entered and Germany collapsed.

Effects on the international order

The CED says the relationship of Europe to the world shifted significantly with the globalization of the conflict, the emergence of the United States as a world power, and the overthrow of European empires.

  • Empires fell. The German, Austro-Hungarian, Russian, and Ottoman empires were gone by 1918 to 1922. The mandate system gave Britain and France control of former German and Ottoman lands, the modern Turkish republic was created, and the Austro-Hungarian empire dissolved into new states.
  • A new balance of power. Europe was weakened economically and in human life, in debt to the United States, and its colonial peoples had learned how Europe could be shaken. The Russian Revolution created a communist state.
  • Social effects. The war left a generation of dead and disabled, a sense of disillusionment, and changed roles for women (Lesson 8.10).
Primary source · The old Lie

Wilfred Owen, "Dulce et Decorum Est" (written 1917, published 1920), closing lines.

The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est / Pro patria mori.

Sourcing (HIPP). Owen was a British officer who fought on the Western Front and wrote the poem after experiencing a gas attack, so his point of view is that of a soldier. He was killed in November 1918, a week before the Armistice, and the poem was published after his death. Its purpose was to attack the idea, drawn from the Roman poet Horace, that it is sweet and fitting to die for one's country. The poem is powerful evidence of the experience of some soldiers and of disillusionment, but it is one man's view, and many soldiers and civilians continued to believe in the cause.

Source analysis · Disillusionment

Claim. Owen rejects the claim that dying for one's country is glorious.

Evidence. He calls the Latin phrase meaning "it is sweet and fitting to die for one's country" "the old Lie."

Reasoning. The poem reflects the experience of industrialized warfare (gas, mass death), as the CED describes, and the disillusionment of many who fought. As the work of an individual soldier writing for a post-war audience, it cannot show the full range of opinions about the war.

Worked example · Technology and its effects

Question. Explain one way new technology changed World War I and one effect of the war on the international balance of power.

Model. Machine guns, barbed wire, and rapid-fire artillery defeated infantry charges and produced trench warfare and massive casualties, as at Verdun and the Somme. The war also shifted the balance: European empires such as the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman collapsed, and the United States emerged as a world power by providing troops, supplies, and loans.

Exam focus

Use the CED's four points as a checklist: technology and trench warfare, total war and the home front (leading to protest and revolution), global spread, and new balance of power (the United States, the fall of empires). Back each with a named example (Marne, Verdun, Easter Rebellion, Armenian Genocide, mandate system). Do not describe the war as only a European event.

Practice
  1. Why did the war become a stalemate on the Western Front?
    Show answer

    New technologies such as machine guns, artillery, and barbed wire favored defenders and made infantry charges deadly, so both sides dug trenches.

  2. Name two new weapons of the war.
    Show answer

    Poison gas, submarines, airplanes, tanks, and the machine gun.

  3. What does total war mean?
    Show answer

    The commitment of a society's whole resources, including industry, labor, food, and propaganda, to the war effort.

  4. How did the war become global?
    Show answer

    Empires sent colonial troops and labor, Japan and the Ottoman Empire entered, and fighting occurred in Africa, the Middle East, and Asia.

  5. Why did the United States' entry matter?
    Show answer

    Its troops, supplies, and loans tipped the balance and made it a world power after the war.

  6. What happened to empires after the war?
    Show answer

    The German, Austro-Hungarian, Russian, and Ottoman empires fell; the Austro-Hungarian lands dissolved, modern Turkey appeared, and Britain and France took mandates.

Lesson 8.3 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.3

The Russian Revolution and its effects

In 1917 the Russian Empire collapsed twice, first into a republic and then into the world's first communist state. Learning Objective E asks you to explain the causes and effects of the Russian Revolution. The CED lists four points: World War I exacerbated long-term problems of political stagnation, social inequality, incomplete industrialization, and food and land distribution, while creating support for revolutionary change; military and worker insurrections, aided by the revived Soviets, undermined the Provisional Government and set the stage for Lenin's long-planned Bolshevik Revolution; the takeover prompted a protracted civil war; and, to improve the economy, Lenin compromised communist principles under the New Economic Policy.

Required content · 8E

Learning objective.

  • 8E. Explain the causes and effects of the Russian Revolution.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.I.A. In Russia, World War I exacerbated long-term problems of political stagnation, social inequality, incomplete industrialization, and food and land distribution, all while creating support for revolutionary change.
  • 4.2.I.B. Military and worker insurrections, aided by the revived Soviets, undermined the Provisional Government and set the stage for Lenin’s long-planned Bolshevik Revolution and establishment of a communist state.
  • 4.2.I.C. The Bolshevik takeover prompted a protracted civil war between communist forces and their opponents, who were aided by foreign powers.
  • 4.2.I.D.i. In order to improve economic performance, Lenin compromised communist principles and employed some free-market principles under the New Economic Policy.

Long-term causes

  • Autocracy. Nicholas II ruled as an absolute tsar and resisted real reform even after the Revolution of 1905 (Lesson 6.5). The Duma had little power.
  • Social inequality. Most Russians were peasants who wanted more land. In the cities, a small, rapidly growing working class lived in harsh conditions.
  • Incomplete industrialization. Russia had modern factories but a weak industrial base and poor railways, and the war would expose this.
  • Revolutionary movements. Socialists and others, including the Bolsheviks, a disciplined party led by Vladimir Lenin that believed in a professional revolutionary vanguard, had organized underground for years.

How the war broke the regime

World War I brought defeats, huge casualties, and shortages. Food and fuel were scarce in cities, inflation rose, and the tsar took personal command of the army in 1915, so he was blamed for failures. The court's influence by Rasputin, a mystic, further damaged the monarchy's prestige.

The February (March) Revolution, 1917

In March 1917 (February in the old Russian calendar), bread riots and strikes in Petrograd (the capital, renamed from St. Petersburg) grew into a mass uprising, and soldiers refused to fire on the crowds. The tsar abdicated, ending 300 years of Romanov rule. Two bodies then shared power in a "dual power" arrangement:

  • The Provisional Government, of liberal and moderate socialist politicians (led later by Alexander Kerensky), wanted to continue the war and to prepare for an elected assembly.
  • The Petrograd Soviet, a council of workers' and soldiers' deputies, that commanded loyalty in the factories and army. The CED notes that the revived Soviets gave workers and soldiers an organization.

The Bolshevik Revolution, October (November) 1917

Lenin returned from exile in April and demanded "peace, land, and bread" and "all power to the soviets." The Provisional Government's decision to continue the war and failure to deliver land reform cost it support. Strikes, mutinies, and peasant land seizures undermined it. After a failed right-wing coup attempt, the Bolsheviks gained support in the soviets. On the night of November 6 to 7, 1917 (October in the old calendar), Bolshevik forces under the direction of Leon Trotsky and Lenin seized the Winter Palace in Petrograd with little resistance. The CED's description is Lenin's long-planned Bolshevik Revolution, which established a communist state.

The new government quickly issued decrees for peace and land. It dissolved the elected Constituent Assembly in January 1918, in which the Bolsheviks had won a minority, and made peace with Germany in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk (March 1918), giving up large territories.

Civil war and the New Economic Policy

The Bolshevik takeover prompted a protracted civil war (1918 to 1921) between the Reds (communists) and their opponents, the Whites, a mixed group of monarchists, liberals, and others who were aided by foreign powers, including Britain, France, the United States, and Japan, who sent troops and supplies. The Bolsheviks, with Trotsky's Red Army and the secret police (the Cheka), won. They used the policy of War Communism, seizing grain and nationalizing industry, and the Red Terror against opponents. The former tsar and his family were executed in 1918. Millions died from fighting, famine, and disease.

By 1921 the economy was in ruins and workers and peasants revolted (including sailors at Kronstadt). Lenin compromised communist principles by introducing the New Economic Policy (NEP), which allowed peasants to sell surplus grain and small private businesses to operate, while the state kept control of heavy industry and banks. The economy recovered. In 1922 the Bolsheviks created the Soviet Union (USSR).

1905 Revolution; Duma created 1914-16 War losses and shortages Mar 1917 Tsar abdicates; dual power Nov 1917 Bolsheviks seize power 1918-21 Civil war; War Communism 1921 New Economic Policy 1922 USSR formed
Figure 8.3. Russian Revolution. War strain toppled the monarchy, a second revolution put the Bolsheviks in power, and civil war and compromise shaped the new state.
Primary source · Land to the peasants

Description of: The Decree on Land (November 1917), issued by the Bolshevik government. It abolishes private ownership of land without compensation, places the estates of landowners, the church, and the crown at the disposal of local peasant committees and soviets, and says that the land of ordinary peasants and Cossacks will not be confiscated.

Sourcing (HIPP). The decree is an official government document, issued in the first days of Bolshevik power, so it shows the party's immediate goals and its attempt to win support. The audience was the peasant majority and the army, which was made up largely of peasants, and the purpose was to secure their loyalty. In practice, peasants had already seized much land, so the decree recognized a fact, and it came partly from the program of the rival Socialist Revolutionary party. It cannot show the later forced grain requisitions during the civil war that angered peasants.

Source analysis · Winning support

Claim. The Decree on Land was meant to win peasant support for the Bolsheviks.

Evidence. It ended private ownership of land and handed estates to peasant committees.

Reasoning. The decree responded to the long-term problem of land distribution that the CED lists and to the peasants' demand, which the Provisional Government had failed to meet. It shows how the Bolsheviks used popular grievances to gain power, though it does not show the later conflicts with peasants.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause of the Russian Revolution of 1917 and one effect of the Bolshevik takeover.

Model. One cause was World War I, which exacerbated long-term problems of political stagnation and food shortages and created support for revolutionary change, as when bread riots and military mutinies toppled the tsar. One effect was the civil war between the communists and their opponents, who were aided by foreign powers, which the Bolsheviks won at great cost and which led them to adopt the New Economic Policy.

Exam focus

Learning Objective E needs long-term causes (autocracy, inequality, incomplete industrialization, food and land), the role of the war, the two revolutions (February and October), and the effects (civil war, New Economic Policy, the creation of the USSR). Use the CED's phrasing Lenin's long-planned Bolshevik Revolution and remember dual power. Avoid saying the Bolsheviks simply took a weak government by surprise; they won support in the soviets first.

Practice
  1. Name two long-term causes of the Russian Revolution.
    Show answer

    Autocracy under Nicholas II, social inequality, incomplete industrialization, and land and food problems.

  2. How did World War I help cause revolution?
    Show answer

    Defeats, shortages, and heavy casualties exacerbated existing problems and created support for revolution, leading to the tsar's fall.

  3. What was dual power?
    Show answer

    The sharing of authority in 1917 between the Provisional Government and the Petrograd Soviet.

  4. What did Lenin promise in 1917?
    Show answer

    Peace, land, and bread, and all power to the soviets.

  5. Why did the civil war happen and who won?
    Show answer

    Opponents of the Bolsheviks, aided by foreign powers, fought the Red Army, and the Bolsheviks won by 1921.

  6. What was the New Economic Policy?
    Show answer

    Lenin's compromise allowing peasants to sell surplus grain and small private businesses while the state controlled heavy industry, adopted after the economy collapsed.

Lesson 8.4 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.4

The Versailles settlement and the League of Nations

The peacemakers who met in Paris in 1919 tried to build a lasting order out of the ruins of four empires. Learning Objective F asks you to explain the causes and effects of the Versailles settlement. The CED's points are that Wilsonian idealism clashed with postwar realities, that the League of Nations was weakened from the outset by the absence of major powers, that the settlement's guilt and reparations provisions hindered the Weimar Republic, and that the League's mandate system altered the imperial balance and created a strategic interest in the Middle East and its oil.

Required content · 8F

Learning objective.

  • 8F. Explain how and why the settlement of World War I failed to effectively resolve the political, economic, and diplomatic challenges of the early 20th century.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.II.A. Wilsonian idealism clashed with postwar realities in both the victorious and the defeated states. Democratic successor states emerged from former empires and eventually succumbed to significant political, economic, and diplomatic crises.
  • 4.1.II.B. The League of Nations, created to prevent future wars, was weakened from the outset by the nonparticipation of major powers, including the U.S., Germany, and the Soviet Union.
  • 4.1.II.C. The Versailles settlement, particularly its provisions on the assignment of guilt and reparations for the war, hindered the German Weimar Republic’s ability to establish a stable and legitimate political and economic system.
  • 4.1.VI.B. The League of Nations distributed former German and Ottoman possessions to France and Great Britain through the mandate system, thereby altering the imperial balance of power and creating a strategic interest in the Middle East and its oil.

The Paris Peace Conference, 1919

The "Big Three" dominated the talks, and the defeated powers were not allowed to negotiate.

LeaderCountryMain aim
Woodrow WilsonUnited StatesA just peace based on the Fourteen Points, self-determination, and a League of Nations
Georges ClemenceauFranceSecurity against Germany through punishment, limits on its army, and reparations
David Lloyd GeorgeBritainA compromise: punish Germany but avoid ruining its economy, and protect the empire and navy

Wilsonian idealism held that open diplomacy, national self-determination, and a collective body could prevent war. It clashed with postwar realities: France had suffered most of the fighting and wanted security, secret wartime treaties had promised territory to allies, and the victors' voters wanted Germany to pay.

The Treaty of Versailles (June 1919)

  • War guilt. Article 231 made Germany accept responsibility for the loss and damage caused by the war.
  • Reparations. Germany owed payments to the Allies, with the amount set in 1921 at 132 billion gold marks.
  • Territory. Germany lost Alsace-Lorraine to France, land to Poland (including a "corridor" to the sea), and all its colonies. The Rhineland was demilitarized.
  • Military limits. The army was limited to 100,000 men, with no air force, tanks, or submarines.

Germans saw the treaty as a diktat, a dictated peace, and the "war guilt clause" as humiliating. The CED states that these provisions hindered the Weimar Republic's ability to establish a stable and legitimate political and economic system, because the new democracy was blamed for signing and for the burden of reparations.

Other treaties and the successor states

Separate treaties dealt with Austria, Hungary, Bulgaria, and the Ottoman Empire. Democratic successor states appeared from the former empires, including Poland, Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, Austria, Hungary, and the Baltic states, but the CED notes that they eventually succumbed to significant political, economic, and diplomatic crises. They were small, economically weak, and had minorities that were unhappy, and most would fall to dictatorship or foreign domination.

The League of Nations and the mandates

The League of Nations was created to prevent future wars through collective security, but it was weakened from the outset. The United States Senate refused to ratify the treaty, Germany was at first excluded, and the Soviet Union was not admitted until 1934. The League had no army and relied on member states.

The League also distributed former German and Ottoman possessions to Britain and France through the mandate system. Britain took Palestine, Iraq, and Transjordan, and France took Syria and Lebanon, with Germany's African colonies divided between them. This extended the empires, altered the imperial balance of power, and, in the Middle East, created a strategic interest in the region and its oil.

Primary source · A just peace

Woodrow Wilson, address to Congress on the Fourteen Points, January 8, 1918 (a U.S. government document).

A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike.

Sourcing (HIPP). Wilson, the President of the United States, delivered the address to Congress during the war, so it is both a statement of war aims and a public appeal to peoples inside and outside the Allied nations. Its purpose was to rally support, to encourage the Central Powers to negotiate, and to define a peace that would avoid the old system of secret alliances. The quoted point is the fourteenth, which proposed what became the League of Nations. The proposals could not fully survive negotiation with allies who had their own interests, which is the clash the CED describes.

Source analysis · Ideal and reality

Claim. Wilson proposed a collective body to protect all states equally, but the actual settlement fell short of that ideal.

Evidence. The Fourteenth Point calls for mutual guarantees of independence and territorial integrity to "great and small states alike." The Treaty of Versailles imposed guilt and reparations on Germany, which was kept out of the League, and the United States never joined.

Reasoning. The gap illustrates the CED's claim that Wilsonian idealism clashed with postwar realities. As a wartime speech, the source shows aims, not results, so it must be set beside the treaty itself.

Worked example · Effects

Question. Explain one way the Treaty of Versailles weakened the Weimar Republic and one way the League of Nations was weak.

Model. The treaty's war guilt clause and reparations were resented as a humiliation and an economic burden, and because the democratic government had signed it, many Germans blamed the republic and not the war, which damaged its legitimacy. The League was weak because major powers were absent: the United States refused to join, and Germany and the Soviet Union were at first excluded, so it lacked the strength to enforce its decisions.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective F, connect provisions (guilt, reparations, territory, military limits) to effects (resentment, weak Weimar legitimacy, instability), and show the clash between ideals and interests. Name the missing powers (United States, Germany, Soviet Union) when judging the League, and mention the mandates as a way the empires grew. Avoid saying the treaty alone caused World War II; argue about how much it contributed.

Practice
  1. Who were the Big Three at the Paris Peace Conference?
    Show answer

    Woodrow Wilson of the United States, Georges Clemenceau of France, and David Lloyd George of Britain.

  2. What was the war guilt clause?
    Show answer

    Article 231, which made Germany accept responsibility for the war's losses and damage and was the basis for reparations.

  3. How did Versailles hurt the Weimar Republic?
    Show answer

    It was blamed for signing a humiliating treaty and for reparations, which undermined its legitimacy and economy.

  4. Why was the League of Nations weak?
    Show answer

    The United States did not join, Germany and the Soviet Union were excluded at first, and it had no army to enforce decisions.

  5. What was the mandate system?
    Show answer

    The League's assignment of former German and Ottoman territories to Britain and France to administer.

  6. What happened to many of the successor states?
    Show answer

    They faced political, economic, and diplomatic crises and most eventually fell to authoritarian rule or foreign domination.

Lesson 8.5 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.5

The global economic crisis

The prosperity of the 1920s rested on weak foundations, and in 1929 it collapsed. Learning Objective G asks you to explain the causes and effects of the global economic crisis of the 1930s. The CED's points are that war debts, tariffs, overproduction, weak currencies, disrupted trade, and speculation created weaknesses worldwide; that European dependence on American investment capital led to collapse when the United States cut it off after the 1929 crash; and that Western democracies failed to overcome the Great Depression and were weakened by extremist movements.

Required content · 8G

Learning objective.

  • 8G. Explain the causes and effects of the global economic crisis in the 1920s and 1930s.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.III.A. World War I debt, nationalistic tariff policies, overproduction, depreciated currencies, disrupted trade patterns, and speculation created weaknesses in economies worldwide.
  • 4.2.III.B. Dependence on post-World War I American investment capital led to financial collapse when, following the 1929 stock market crash, the United States cut off capital flows to Europe.
  • 4.2.III.C. Despite attempts to rethink economic theories and policies and forge political alliances, Western democracies failed to overcome the Great Depression and were weakened by extremist movements.

Weak foundations in the 1920s

  • War debt. Britain and France owed money to the United States and expected to pay it with German reparations. Germany paid reparations only with borrowed money.
  • A circle of loans. American banks lent to Germany (the Dawes Plan of 1924 arranged this), Germany paid reparations to Britain and France, and they repaid the United States. The system depended on a steady flow of American capital.
  • Tariffs. Nations protected their industries with high tariffs, which cut trade.
  • Overproduction. Farms and factories produced more than people could buy, so prices fell, especially for farm goods.
  • Currencies. Inflation (Germany's hyperinflation of 1923) and the unstable gold standard weakened confidence.
  • Speculation. Investors bought stocks on credit, driving prices far above the value of businesses.

The crash and its spread

In October 1929 the New York stock market collapsed. American banks and investors called in loans and cut off capital flows to Europe, as the CED says. Banks failed, factories closed, and trade shrank. A banking crisis in Austria and Germany in 1931 spread across the continent, and Britain left the gold standard in 1931. Unemployment soared, reaching about a third of the German workforce by 1932. Countries raised tariffs further, such as the American Smoot-Hawley Tariff (1930), which worsened the collapse in trade.

U.S. loans flow to Germany Reparations paid to Britain and France War debts repaid to the United States Crash, 1929 U.S. loans cut off Collapse Bank failures, unemployment Extremism Voters turn to radical parties The circle of money, and how it broke The system worked only while American capital kept flowing
Figure 8.4. Depression chain. Europe's postwar finances depended on American loans, so the 1929 crash and the end of lending set off a continental collapse.

Responses of the democracies

The CED says the democracies tried to rethink economic theories and policies and forge political alliances but failed to overcome the Great Depression.

  • Britain formed a National Government in 1931, cut spending, and adopted tariffs, and its economy recovered slowly.
  • France was hit later, and its Popular Front government (1936) passed labor reforms but could not end the crisis.
  • The United States under Franklin Roosevelt adopted the New Deal, with government spending and regulation. The economist John Maynard Keynes argued that governments should spend to stimulate demand during a slump, challenging the older belief in balanced budgets.
  • Sweden and other Scandinavian states used public spending and social programs.

Recovery was uneven, and rearmament later in the decade did more than any policy to end mass unemployment.

Political consequences

The depression discredited democratic governments and liberal capitalism in many people's eyes and gave a chance to extremist movements, which promised work and national revival. In Germany the Nazi party rose from a fringe party to the largest in the Reichstag in 1932 (Lesson 8.6). The Soviet Union, with its planned economy, seemed unaffected by the depression, and this attracted some admirers. Many democracies were more concerned with recovery at home than with the dangers abroad, which weakened their response to aggression (Lesson 8.7).

Primary source · Fear itself

Franklin D. Roosevelt, first Inaugural Address, March 4, 1933 (a U.S. government document).

The only thing we have to fear is fear itself.

Sourcing (HIPP). Roosevelt spoke at his inauguration, at the lowest point of the American banking crisis, with about a quarter of workers unemployed. His audience was the American public, and his purpose was to restore confidence and to prepare the country to accept strong government action. As evidence, the speech shows how a democratic leader tried to answer the depression without abandoning democracy. It is a statement of intention and mood, so it needs to be paired with evidence of the New Deal's actual effects, which were mixed.

Source analysis · Responses to crisis

Claim. Roosevelt framed the depression as a problem of confidence that democratic government could overcome.

Evidence. He declares that "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself" and asks Americans to support vigorous action.

Reasoning. The speech illustrates the CED's claim that Western democracies tried to rethink policy. Compared with the extremist movements in Europe that promised national salvation through dictatorship, it shows a democratic alternative. However, it does not prove the policy worked, since unemployment remained high until rearmament.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause of the global economic crisis and one political effect of the Great Depression in Europe.

Model. One cause was Europe's dependence on American capital: when the 1929 crash led the United States to stop lending, German and other European banks and economies collapsed. One political effect was that mass unemployment and the failures of democratic governments helped extremist movements, such as the Nazi party in Germany, gain support.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective G, tell the causal chain (war debts and reparations, American loans, the 1929 crash, the end of loans, bank failures, unemployment, extremism) and note the responses (New Deal, National Government, Keynes). Use the CED's list of weaknesses and its claim that the democracies failed to overcome the depression. Do not treat the crash alone as the cause; the weaknesses pre-dated it.

Practice
  1. Why was Europe vulnerable to an American collapse?
    Show answer

    Germany paid reparations with American loans, which paid Allied war debts to the United States, so a cutoff of capital broke the chain.

  2. Name two weaknesses of the 1920s economy.
    Show answer

    War debt, high tariffs, overproduction, unstable currencies, disrupted trade, and stock speculation.

  3. What did Keynes argue?
    Show answer

    That governments should spend during a slump to stimulate demand rather than balance the budget.

  4. How did the depression help extremists?
    Show answer

    Mass unemployment and discredited democratic governments made voters open to movements promising work and national revival.

  5. Give one democratic response to the depression.
    Show answer

    The New Deal in the United States, the National Government in Britain, or the Popular Front in France.

  6. Why did tariffs worsen the crisis?
    Show answer

    They reduced international trade, which hurt exporters and deepened the downturn.

Lesson 8.6 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.6

Fascism and totalitarianism

Between the wars, democracy lost ground to dictatorships of the right and the left. Learning Objective H asks you to explain the rise of fascism and totalitarian regimes, and Learning Objective I covers how they differed from earlier authoritarian rule and what they did. The CED's points are that fascist dictatorships used modern technology and propaganda, rejected democratic institutions, promoted charismatic leaders, and glorified war and nationalism; that Mussolini and Hitler rose by exploiting bitterness and instability, using terror, and manipulating weak democracies; that Franco's victory in the Spanish Civil War, aided by Italy and Germany, was a testing ground for World War II; that authoritarian dictatorships took power in central and eastern Europe; and that Stalin's modernization came at a high price.

Required content · 8H, 8I

Learning objectives.

  • 8H. Explain the factors that led to the development of fascist and totalitarian regimes in the aftermath of World War I.
  • 8I. Explain the consequences of Stalin’s economic policies and totalitarian rule in the Soviet Union.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.II.A. Fascist dictatorships used modern technology and propaganda that rejected democratic institutions, promoted charismatic leaders, and glorified war and nationalism to attract the disillusioned.
  • 4.2.II.B. Mussolini and Hitler rose to power by exploiting postwar bitterness and economic instability, using terror, and manipulating the fledgling and unpopular democracies in their countries.
  • 4.2.II.C. Franco’s alliance with Italian and German fascists in the Spanish Civil War, in which the Western democracies did not intervene, represented a testing ground for World War II and resulted in authoritarian rule in Spain from 1936 to the mid-1970s.
  • 4.2.II.D. After failures to establish functioning democracies, authoritarian dictatorships took power in central and eastern Europe during the interwar period.
  • 4.2.I.D.ii. After Lenin’s death, Stalin undertook a centralized program of rapid economic modernization, often with severe repercussions for the population.
  • 4.2.I.E. Stalin’s economic modernization of the Soviet Union came at a high price, including the liquidation of the kulaks (the land-owning peasantry) and other perceived enemies of the state, devastating famine in the Ukraine, purges of political rivals, and, ultimately, the creation of an oppressive political system.

What is fascism?

Fascism was a new kind of right-wing politics born in the aftermath of World War I.

  • It was ultranationalist and anti-democratic, rejecting parliaments, individual rights, and socialism.
  • It praised a charismatic leader and a single party, and glorified violence and war.
  • It used propaganda, mass rallies, radio, and film, and a secret police and terror against opponents.
  • It appealed to the disillusioned: veterans, the unemployed, the middle class fearing communism and economic ruin.

Totalitarianism describes states that tried to control every part of life, including the economy, education, culture, and private beliefs, through a single party, propaganda, and terror. Nazi Germany and Stalin's Soviet Union are the usual examples, and they differ from older autocracies in the extent of their ambitions and their use of modern technology.

Italy: Mussolini

Benito Mussolini, a former socialist, founded the Fascist movement in 1919. Italy was bitter over the peace settlement (a "mutilated victory"), unemployed veterans were angry, and landowners and industrialists feared socialist revolution. His Blackshirts used violence against socialists and unions. In October 1922, after the March on Rome, King Victor Emmanuel III invited him to form a government. By 1925 to 1926 he had made himself dictator, Il Duce, banning other parties and controlling the press. He signed the Lateran Accords with the Catholic Church (1929). He wanted to build a new Roman Empire and invaded Ethiopia in 1935.

Germany: Hitler

Adolf Hitler led the National Socialist (Nazi) party. After the failed Beer Hall Putsch (1923) he pursued power through elections and propaganda. The Great Depression gave the Nazis their chance: they promised work, national revival, the end of the Versailles settlement, and a scapegoat in Jews and communists. By 1932 they were the largest party. Conservative politicians who believed they could control him persuaded President Hindenburg to appoint Hitler chancellor on January 30, 1933.

He moved quickly. The Reichstag fire (February 1933) gave a pretext for suspending civil liberties, the Enabling Act (March 1933) gave him power to rule by decree, other parties and unions were banned, and in 1934 Hitler became Führer after Hindenburg's death. The state used the SS and Gestapo, concentration camps, censorship, and propaganda directed by Joseph Goebbels, and promoted racial anti-Semitism (Lesson 8.9). It rearmed, reduced unemployment through public works and arms production, and left the League of Nations.

Spain and eastern Europe

In Spain, a civil war began in 1936 when General Francisco Franco led a military revolt against the elected Republic. Germany and Italy supported Franco with troops and aircraft (the German bombing of Guernica in 1937 became famous), the Soviet Union aided the Republic, and Britain and France did not intervene. The war, which Franco won in 1939, served as a testing ground for World War II and led to authoritarian rule in Spain until the mid-1970s.

Elsewhere in central and eastern Europe, democracies created in 1919 failed and authoritarian dictatorships took power in Hungary, Poland, Yugoslavia, Romania, and others, usually run by nationalists or military leaders.

The Soviet Union: Stalin

After Lenin's death (1924), Joseph Stalin defeated Trotsky and others and became dictator. He ended the New Economic Policy and imposed Five-Year Plans (from 1928) of rapid industrialization with state-set targets, and collectivization of agriculture, forcing peasants into state-controlled farms. As the CED states, this modernization came at a high price:

  • Liquidation of the kulaks, the wealthier peasants, who were arrested, deported, or killed.
  • A devastating famine in Ukraine (1932 to 1933), when millions died.
  • Purges (the Great Terror, 1936 to 1938), in which Stalin's political rivals and many others were tried, executed, or sent to the Gulag labor camps.
  • A cult of personality, state control of culture, and an oppressive political system.

The USSR did become a major industrial power, but at the cost of millions of lives.

Fascist Italy Mussolini, Il Duce Single party, Blackshirts Ultranationalism, empire Lateran Accords, 1929 Nazi Germany Hitler, the Fuhrer SS, Gestapo, camps Racial nationalism Enabling Act, 1933 Soviet Union Stalin NKVD, Gulag, purges Communism, state economy Five-Year Plans, 1928 Three dictatorships between the wars Shared methods: one party, propaganda, terror, a cult of the leader
Figure 8.5. Dictatorships. The three regimes had different ideologies but shared methods of control, which is why historians group them under totalitarianism.
Primary source · The leader's party

Description of: Nazi propaganda of the 1930s, in posters, rallies, and film, built around the slogan "One People, One Reich, One Leader" and showing Germans of every class united behind Hitler.

Sourcing (HIPP). The material was produced by the Nazi party and state, so its purpose was to persuade, not to inform. The audience was the German public, and the images of different classes standing together aim at an end to class conflict through national unity. As evidence, it shows how the regime used mass media and a charismatic leader to attract the disillusioned, but it cannot show what Germans actually believed, nor the terror and exclusion that stood behind the message of unity.

Source analysis · Propaganda

Claim. Nazi propaganda presented the regime as a movement that united all Germans under one leader.

Evidence. Its slogan was "One People, One Reich, One Leader," and its images showed Germans of every class together.

Reasoning. The propaganda is an example of the CED's statement that fascist dictatorships used modern propaganda, promoted a charismatic leader, and glorified nationalism to attract the disillusioned. It is a record of what the regime wished to project, so a historian would use other evidence, such as the repression of opponents, to judge reality.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way Hitler and Stalin consolidated power.

Model. Both used terror and a single party to eliminate opposition: Hitler passed the Enabling Act, banned other parties, and used the Gestapo and concentration camps, while Stalin purged rivals in the Great Terror and sent millions to the Gulag. A difference was ideology, since Hitler's regime rested on racial nationalism and private ownership with state direction, while Stalin's rested on communism and state ownership of the economy.

Exam focus

For Learning Objectives H and I, name the common features (charismatic leader, single party, propaganda, terror, rejection of democracy) and the conditions that helped each regime (postwar bitterness, depression, weak democracy). Compare Hitler and Stalin carefully: they were enemies with different ideologies but used similar methods. Cite specific events with dates (March on Rome 1922, January 1933, Enabling Act, collectivization, the purges).

Practice
  1. Name three features of fascist dictatorships in the CED.
    Show answer

    Modern propaganda, rejection of democratic institutions, a charismatic leader, and the glorification of war and nationalism.

  2. How did Mussolini come to power?
    Show answer

    He exploited postwar bitterness and fear of socialism, used violence, and was invited to form a government after the March on Rome in 1922.

  3. How did Hitler become dictator?
    Show answer

    He became chancellor in January 1933, then used the Reichstag fire, the Enabling Act, and terror to destroy other parties and rule by decree.

  4. Why was the Spanish Civil War important?
    Show answer

    Germany and Italy aided Franco while the democracies stayed out, making it a testing ground for World War II.

  5. What was collectivization?
    Show answer

    Stalin's forcing of peasants onto state-controlled farms, which led to the destruction of the kulaks and famine in Ukraine.

  6. What were the purges?
    Show answer

    Stalin's campaign in the 1930s against rivals and perceived enemies, who were executed or sent to labor camps.

Lesson 8.7 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.7

Europe between the wars: appeasement and the road to war

In the 1930s the fascist powers rearmed and expanded while the democracies hesitated. Learning Objective J asks you to explain the causes and effects of the failure to stop aggression before 1939. The CED's explanation is that French and British fears of another war, American isolationism, and deep distrust between the Western democracies and the Soviet Union allowed fascist states to rearm and expand.

Required content · 8J

Learning objective.

  • 8J. Explain how and why various political and ideological factors resulted in the catastrophe of World War II.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.III.A. French and British fears of another war, American isolationism, and deep distrust between Western democratic, capitalist nations and the authoritarian, communist Soviet Union allowed fascist states to rearm and expand their territory.

Why the democracies did not act

  • Fear of another war. The memory of the Great War's millions of dead made leaders and voters in Britain and France want to avoid conflict at nearly any cost. Pacifism was strong.
  • The Depression. Governments had little money for rearmament and attention was on unemployment.
  • American isolationism. The United States, disillusioned by the war, passed Neutrality Acts in the 1930s and stayed out of European affairs.
  • Distrust of the USSR. Western leaders feared communism, and Stalin distrusted the West, so no firm alliance against Germany formed.
  • A belief that grievances were real. Many in Britain thought the Treaty of Versailles had been too harsh, so some of Hitler's demands seemed reasonable.

This is the background to appeasement, the policy of granting concessions to dictators to preserve peace, associated especially with British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain.

A chain of aggression

1931 Japan seizes Manchuria 1935 German rearming; Ethiopia 1936 Rhineland; Spanish war Mar 1938 Anschluss Sep 1938 Munich Aug 1939 Nazi-Soviet Pact Sep 1, 1939 Invasion of Poland
Figure 8.6. Road to war. Each unanswered step encouraged the next, until the invasion of Poland led Britain and France to declare war.
  1. 1931. Japan seized Manchuria. The League of Nations condemned it but did nothing.
  2. 1935. Hitler announced German rearmament and a military draft, which broke Versailles. Italy invaded Ethiopia, and the League's sanctions were weak.
  3. 1936. German troops entered the demilitarized Rhineland. France did not act without British support.
  4. 1936 to 1939. The Spanish Civil War (Lesson 8.6). Germany and Italy formed the Rome-Berlin Axis (1936), and Germany and Japan signed the Anti-Comintern Pact.
  5. March 1938. Germany annexed Austria (the Anschluss).
  6. September 1938. The Munich Conference: Britain and France agreed that Germany could take the Sudetenland, the German-speaking border region of Czechoslovakia, without Czechoslovakia being present. Chamberlain claimed "peace for our time."
  7. March 1939. Germany occupied the rest of Czechoslovakia, showing that Hitler's aims went beyond uniting Germans.
  8. August 1939. The Nazi-Soviet Pact: Germany and the USSR agreed not to attack each other, with a secret protocol dividing Poland and eastern Europe. It removed the danger of a two-front war for Hitler.
  9. September 1, 1939. Germany invaded Poland. Britain and France, which had guaranteed Polish independence, declared war on September 3.

Judging appeasement

Historians disagree. Critics say that appeasement encouraged Hitler and that resistance in 1936 or 1938, when Germany was weaker and allies like Czechoslovakia had strong defenses, might have prevented the war. Defenders argue that Britain and France were not ready militarily, that public opinion would not support war, and that the delay gave time to rearm. The CED's explanation, fear of war, isolationism, and distrust of the Soviets, shows why leaders made choices that look mistaken in hindsight.

Primary source · Peace for our time

Description of: Neville Chamberlain's statement on returning from the Munich Conference (September 30, 1938), in which he held up a paper signed by himself and Hitler and told the crowd that it meant "peace for our time," and the agreement transferred the Sudetenland to Germany.

Sourcing (HIPP). Chamberlain spoke as the head of the British government, to the British public and to Parliament, and his purpose was to justify the agreement and reassure a nation that feared war. It reflects the point of view of those who believed concessions could preserve peace. Within six months Germany occupied the rest of Czechoslovakia, so historians use the statement as evidence of the failure of appeasement, but they also consider the public support it received at the time.

Source analysis · Reasons for appeasement

Claim. Chamberlain believed that giving Germany the Sudetenland would secure peace.

Evidence. He announced "peace for our time" after the Munich agreement, to a public that dreaded another war.

Reasoning. His claim reflects the CED's point that French and British fears of another war led them to allow fascist expansion. The later occupation of Czechoslovakia in March 1939 shows that the policy failed, but the cheering crowds show why leaders thought it was politically necessary.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one reason Britain and France did not stop German rearmament and expansion in the 1930s.

Model. British and French leaders and voters feared another war after the enormous losses of World War I, so they accepted German violations such as the remilitarization of the Rhineland and the Anschluss. They also lacked American support, because the United States was isolationist, and they distrusted the Soviet Union, so they did not form a strong alliance against Hitler.

Exam focus

Learning Objective J asks for causes and effects, so combine the CED's three reasons (fear of war, American isolationism, distrust of the USSR) with a sequence of events (Rhineland, Anschluss, Munich, Prague, the Nazi-Soviet Pact, Poland). Evaluate appeasement from both sides. Remember the Nazi-Soviet Pact: it explains why war began in 1939 and is part of the distrust the CED mentions.

Practice
  1. What was appeasement?
    Show answer

    The policy of making concessions to aggressive dictators, especially Hitler, to avoid war.

  2. Why was Britain reluctant to go to war in the 1930s?
    Show answer

    Memories of World War I's losses, the Depression, and a belief that Versailles had been too harsh.

  3. What happened at Munich?
    Show answer

    Britain and France allowed Germany to take the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia in 1938 in hopes of preserving peace.

  4. What did the Nazi-Soviet Pact do?
    Show answer

    It promised nonaggression between Germany and the USSR and secretly divided Poland, freeing Hitler to attack in the west.

  5. What event started World War II in Europe?
    Show answer

    Germany's invasion of Poland on September 1, 1939.

  6. Name one argument defending appeasement.
    Show answer

    Britain and France were not ready for war, and public opinion opposed it, so delay gave time to rearm.

Lesson 8.8 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.8

World War II

World War II was fought across Europe, Asia, Africa, and the oceans, and it was the deadliest conflict in history. Learning Objective K asks you to explain how the war's course and outcome were shaped by strategy, industry, and technology. The CED's points are that Blitzkrieg and Japanese attacks gave the Axis powers early victories; that American and British industrial, scientific, and technological power, cooperation, strong leadership, civilian resistance, and the all-out commitment of the USSR brought Allied victory; and that military technologies made possible industrialized warfare, genocide, nuclear proliferation, and the risk of global nuclear war.

Required content · 8K

Learning objective.

  • 8K. Explain how technology and innovation affected the course of World War II and the 20th century.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.III.B. Germany’s Blitzkrieg warfare in Europe, combined with Japan’s attacks in Asia and the Pacific, brought the Axis powers early victories.
  • 4.1.III.C. American and British industrial, scientific, and technological power, cooperative military efforts under the strong leadership of individuals such as Winston Churchill, the resistance of civilians, and the all-out military commitment of the USSR contributed critically to the Allied victories.
  • 4.3.II.C. Military technologies made possible industrialized warfare, genocide, nuclear proliferation, and the risk of global nuclear war.

Axis victories, 1939 to 1941

  • Blitzkrieg. "Lightning war" combined fast tanks, motorized infantry, and aircraft to break through enemy lines and surround armies. Germany conquered Poland (September 1939), which the USSR also invaded from the east, then Denmark and Norway, the Low Countries, and France in spring 1940.
  • Britain stands. After the fall of France, Britain under Winston Churchill refused to make peace and won the Battle of Britain (1940) in the air, which prevented a German invasion.
  • The Soviet Union attacked. In June 1941 Germany invaded the USSR (Operation Barbarossa), breaking the Nazi-Soviet Pact, and reached the outskirts of Moscow by winter.
  • Japan in Asia. Japan had been at war with China since 1937. In December 1941 it attacked the American fleet at Pearl Harbor, and rapidly took Southeast Asia and Pacific islands. Germany then declared war on the United States, making the conflict global.

The turn, 1942 to 1943

In 1942 and 1943 the tide changed. The Allies won naval battles at Midway (June 1942), and the British at El Alamein in North Africa. The decisive land battle was Stalingrad (1942 to 1943), where the Soviet army destroyed a German army, and the Soviets began the long advance westward. The Allies invaded Italy in 1943, and Mussolini fell.

Why the Allies won

The CED lists several factors.

  • Industrial and technological power. The United States, "the arsenal of democracy," and Britain out-produced the Axis in tanks, aircraft, ships, and munitions. Scientific advances included radar, codebreaking, and long-range aircraft.
  • Cooperation. The Grand Alliance of Britain, the Soviet Union, and the United States, with leaders Churchill, Stalin, and Roosevelt, coordinated strategy despite deep distrust, meeting at Tehran (1943) and Yalta (1945).
  • Leadership. Churchill's determination in 1940 and Roosevelt's support through Lend-Lease aid are examples.
  • Civilian resistance. Resistance movements in occupied France, Poland, Yugoslavia, and elsewhere sabotaged German operations and gathered intelligence.
  • The Soviet commitment. The USSR fought most of the German army and suffered the heaviest losses, about 25 to 27 million dead, which was decisive in defeating Germany.

The end of the war

The Allies landed in Normandy on D-Day (June 6, 1944), and liberated France while the Soviets advanced from the east. Germany surrendered on May 8, 1945 after Hitler's suicide. In the Pacific, American forces advanced island by island, and the war ended after the United States dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945. Japan surrendered on September 2, 1945.

1939 Poland invaded 1940 France falls; Battle of Britain 1941 Barbarossa; Pearl Harbor 1942-43 Midway; Stalingrad 1944 D-Day May 1945 Germany surrenders Sep 1945 Japan surrenders
Figure 8.7. World War II. Early Axis victories gave way to Allied advances after 1942, ending in the surrender of Germany and then of Japan after atomic bombs.

Technology and the nature of the war

The CED states that military technologies made possible industrialized warfare, genocide, nuclear proliferation, and the risk of global nuclear war. Aircraft and bombing (of Coventry, Dresden, Tokyo, and others) brought war to civilians, and the atomic bomb created a weapon capable of destroying whole cities. Industrial methods were also applied to killing in the Holocaust (Lesson 8.9). Civilian deaths were far higher than in World War I, perhaps half of about 60 million total dead.

Primary source · Aims for the postwar world

Description of: The Atlantic Charter (August 1941), a joint statement by Franklin Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, a U.S. and British government document. It says that their countries seek no territorial gains, that territorial changes must match the wishes of the peoples concerned, that all peoples have the right to choose their own government, and that they hope for the disarmament of aggressors and a wider system of security.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Charter was written by two leaders meeting at sea, months before the United States entered the war, so it is a statement of shared aims and a public declaration meant to encourage allies and occupied peoples. Its purpose was to unite opposition to the Axis around principles echoing Wilson's Fourteen Points. Because it is a declaration of intentions, it does not show how the great powers acted when their interests differed, as later disputes over Poland and eastern Europe showed.

Source analysis · Aims and cooperation

Claim. The Atlantic Charter set out principles that the Allies would use to define their purpose in the war.

Evidence. It rejected territorial gains and affirmed that peoples may choose their own governments.

Reasoning. It shows the CED's theme of Allied cooperation under strong leaders, and it recalls Wilsonian ideals. As a statement before the United States entered the war, it shows intentions, and later events in eastern Europe show where the great powers' practice differed.

Worked example · Outcomes

Question. Explain one reason for early Axis success and one reason for Allied victory in World War II.

Model. Germany's Blitzkrieg, which combined tanks, motorized infantry, and aircraft, overwhelmed Poland and France in 1939 and 1940, and Japan's surprise attacks gave it early gains in Asia and the Pacific. The Allies won because of their industrial and technological power, as the United States and Britain produced far more weapons, and because the Soviet Union committed its whole society to the war and destroyed much of the German army, beginning at Stalingrad.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective K, show the change over time: early Axis victories (Blitzkrieg, Japan), then the turning points (Stalingrad, Midway, El Alamein), then Allied victory. Use the CED's list of causes (industry, technology, cooperation, leadership, resistance, the Soviet effort) and name at least one example for each. Mention the atomic bomb when asked about technology.

Practice
  1. What was Blitzkrieg?
    Show answer

    A fast offensive that combined tanks, motorized infantry, and aircraft to break through and surround enemy armies.

  2. What was the turning point on the Eastern Front?
    Show answer

    The Soviet victory at Stalingrad in 1942 to 1943.

  3. Name two reasons the Allies won.
    Show answer

    Industrial and technological power, cooperation among Britain, the USSR, and the United States, and the Soviet commitment.

  4. When did the war become global?
    Show answer

    In December 1941, when Japan attacked Pearl Harbor and Germany declared war on the United States.

  5. What happened on D-Day?
    Show answer

    The Allies landed in Normandy on June 6, 1944, opening a western front against Germany.

  6. Why did civilian deaths rise?
    Show answer

    Bombing, occupation, genocide, and total war brought the fighting to civilians, who made up about half of the dead.

Lesson 8.9 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.9

The Holocaust

Learning Objective L asks you to explain the causes and consequences of the Holocaust, the Nazi regime's systematic murder of about six million Jews and of millions of others. The CED states that, fueled by racism and anti-Semitism, Nazi Germany, with the cooperation of some other Axis powers and collaborationist governments, sought to establish a new racial order in Europe, which culminated with the Holocaust. It also states that the war virtually destroyed European Jewry, murdered millions of Roma, homosexuals, people with disabilities, and others, forced large-scale migrations, and undermined prewar class hierarchies.

Required content · 8L

Learning objective.

  • 8L. Explain how and why cultural and national identities were affected by war and the rise of fascist/totalitarian powers in the period from 1914 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.III.D. Fueled by racism and anti-Semitism, Nazi Germany, with the cooperation of some of the other Axis powers and collaborationist governments, sought to establish a “new racial order” in Europe, which culminated with the Holocaust.
  • 4.4.I.B. World War II decimated a generation of Russian and German men; virtually destroyed European Jewry; resulted in the murder of millions in other groups targeted by the Nazis including Roma, homosexuals, people with disabilities, and others; forced large-scale migrations; and undermined prewar class hierarchies.

Roots: anti-Semitism and racial ideology

Anti-Semitism, hatred of Jews, had a long history in Europe, and in the late nineteenth century it took a racial form (Lesson 7.4). The Nazis made it central: Hitler's party claimed that Germans were a superior "Aryan" race that was threatened by Jews and other "inferior" groups, and blamed Jews for Germany's defeat and economic troubles. This ideology, together with the Nazi aim of racial "purity," was the basis of the policies that followed.

Persecution, 1933 to 1939

  • Exclusion. Laws removed Jews from civil service and professions in 1933. The Nuremberg Laws (1935) stripped German Jews of citizenship and forbade marriage and relations between Jews and "Aryans."
  • Violence. On Kristallnacht (November 9 to 10, 1938), mobs and the SS burned synagogues, smashed shops, and sent about thirty thousand Jewish men to camps.
  • Other victims. The regime also persecuted Roma (Gypsies), homosexuals, Jehovah's Witnesses, political opponents, and people with disabilities, many of whom were killed in a "euthanasia" program that began in 1939.
  • Emigration. Many Jews fled, but other countries accepted few, and the war closed the exits.

War and the "Final Solution"

After the invasion of Poland in 1939, Jews were forced into ghettos, such as Warsaw. After Germany invaded the USSR in 1941, Einsatzgruppen (mobile killing units) shot more than a million Jews and others in occupied territories. At the Wannsee Conference in January 1942, officials coordinated the "Final Solution," the plan to murder all European Jews. Jews were deported by rail from across Europe to death camps such as Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka, and Sobibor, where many were killed in gas chambers, and others were worked to death. Altogether about six million Jews died, along with millions of others, including Roma, Soviet prisoners of war, Poles and other Slavs, and people with disabilities.

Cooperation, collaboration, and resistance

The CED notes the cooperation of some other Axis powers and collaborationist governments. Vichy France, Hungary, Romania, Slovakia, and others helped with deportations, and in many countries local officials, police, and civilians took part or looked away. There were also rescuers (such as those who hid Jews in the Netherlands, Denmark, and France), resistance (the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising of 1943), and countries that saved most of their Jews, like Denmark.

1933 Nazis take power 1935 Nuremberg Laws Nov 1938 Kristallnacht 1939-41 Ghettos; mobile killing units Jan 1942 Wannsee Conference 1942-44 Death camps 1945-46 Liberation; Nuremberg Trials
Figure 8.8. Holocaust. Legal exclusion and violence in the 1930s became systematic mass murder during the war, and the Nuremberg Trials followed.

Consequences

  • Destruction of European Jewry. Jewish communities that had existed for centuries, especially in eastern Europe, were destroyed. Survivors faced displacement, and many migrated to Palestine, later Israel, and the United States.
  • Demographic effects. The CED notes the war decimated a generation of Russian and German men, forced large-scale migrations, and undermined prewar class hierarchies. Millions of Germans were expelled from eastern Europe after 1945.
  • Justice and law. The Nuremberg Trials (1945 to 1946) prosecuted Nazi leaders for crimes against humanity, a new legal concept, and the United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) and the Genocide Convention (1948).
  • Memory. The Holocaust changed European and world thinking about human rights, racism, and the limits of state power.
Primary source · Citizens and non-citizens

Description of: The Nuremberg Laws (September 1935). The Reich Citizenship Law made only people of "German or related blood" citizens, and the Law for the Protection of German Blood and German Honor banned marriages and sexual relations between Jews and Germans.

Sourcing (HIPP). These were official laws announced at a Nazi party rally, so they are evidence of the regime's open policy and of its legal approach to persecution. Their purpose was to define Jews as a separate category and to exclude them from the nation. The audience was the German public and the party. As a source on the Holocaust, they show an early stage of persecution that was public, and they must be paired with later evidence (Wannsee, the death camps) to show how exclusion turned into murder.

Source analysis · Exclusion

Claim. The Nuremberg Laws turned racial ideology into law.

Evidence. They defined citizenship by "blood" and banned marriage and relations between Jews and other Germans.

Reasoning. The laws illustrate the CED's statement that racism and anti-Semitism drove the Nazi "new racial order." They show that persecution was open and legal in 1935, but they describe an early stage, since the mass murder began only after the war started.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause of the Holocaust and one effect of World War II on European society.

Model. One cause was Nazi racial ideology, which drew on long-standing anti-Semitism and claimed that Jews threatened Germany, leading to the Nuremberg Laws, the ghettos, and the death camps. One effect of the war was the destruction of European Jewry and forced migrations of millions of people, which also undermined prewar class hierarchies.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective L, show causes (racial anti-Semitism and Nazi ideology, war conditions, collaboration) and consequences (the murder of about six million Jews, other victims, migrations, Nuremberg, human rights law). Use accurate terms and name the other victims the CED lists. Note both collaboration and resistance, and do not treat the Holocaust as the work of only a few leaders.

Practice
  1. What did the Nuremberg Laws do?
    Show answer

    They stripped German Jews of citizenship and banned marriage and sexual relations between Jews and other Germans.

  2. What was the Final Solution?
    Show answer

    The Nazi plan, coordinated at Wannsee in 1942, to murder all European Jews.

  3. Name three other groups targeted by the Nazis.
    Show answer

    Roma, homosexuals, people with disabilities, political opponents, Soviet prisoners, and Slavs.

  4. What role did collaborationist governments play?
    Show answer

    Some, such as Vichy France and Hungary, helped round up and deport Jews.

  5. What were the Nuremberg Trials?
    Show answer

    Allied trials of Nazi leaders in 1945 to 1946 for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

  6. Name one demographic effect of World War II in Europe.
    Show answer

    Millions died, including a generation of Russian and German men, and millions more were forced to migrate or were expelled.

Lesson 8.10 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.10

Culture, ideas, and art in the age of the world wars

Learning Objective M asks you to explain how and why science, ideas, and the arts changed in the early twentieth century. The CED's points are that Europeans before 1914 were confident in science and technology despite the uncertainty created by new theories and psychology; that the challenge to the Newtonian universe opened the way to uncertainty while giving knowledge for nuclear weapons and power; that World War I created a "lost generation" and disillusionment and cynicism while transforming women's lives and democratizing societies; and that women became more involved in military, political, and economic mobilization during the world wars.

Required content · 8M

Learning objective.

  • 8M. Explain how the events of the first half of the 20th century challenged existing social, cultural, and intellectual understandings.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.I.A. When World War I began, Europeans were generally confident in the ability of science and technology to address human needs and problems despite the uncertainty created by the new scientific theories and psychology.
  • 4.3.II.A. The challenge to the certainties of the Newtonian universe in physics opened the door to uncertainty in other fields by undermining faith in objective knowledge while also providing the knowledge necessary for the development of nuclear weapons and power.
  • 4.4.I.A. World War I created a “lost generation” and fostered disillusionment and cynicism, while it transformed the lives of women, and democratized societies.
  • 4.4.II.A. During the world wars, women became increasingly involved in military and political mobilization, as well as in economic production.

Science: certainty gives way to uncertainty

Nineteenth-century science had given Europeans confidence in progress and an orderly, Newtonian universe in which events obeyed fixed laws. New ideas challenged this view.

  • Einstein's relativity (1905, 1915) showed that time and space are not absolute and that mass and energy are related (E = mc²).
  • Quantum theory (Planck, Bohr, and later Heisenberg, who stated the uncertainty principle in 1927) showed that at the atomic scale, events can be predicted only as probabilities.
  • Atomic physics. Rutherford and others found the structure of the atom, and in 1938 German scientists split the uranium nucleus. These discoveries led to nuclear weapons and nuclear power.
  • Psychology. Sigmund Freud argued that unconscious drives shape behavior, which challenged the belief in rational human nature. Others, such as Pavlov in Russia and later behaviorists, studied conditioned responses.

The CED's point is that these changes undermined faith in objective knowledge while also providing the knowledge for the atomic bomb.

The "lost generation" and disillusionment

Before 1914, most Europeans trusted science, technology, and progress to solve human problems. The slaughter of World War I badly damaged this confidence. Writers and artists spoke of a "lost generation", and disillusionment and cynicism spread.

  • Literature. Erich Maria Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front (1929) showed the war's cruelty, T. S. Eliot's The Waste Land (1922) expressed a sense of cultural collapse, and the poets Wilfred Owen and Siegfried Sassoon wrote against the glorification of war.
  • Philosophy. Existentialists such as Jean-Paul Sartre, after World War II, stressed human freedom and responsibility in a universe without fixed meaning.
  • Spengler's The Decline of the West (1918) argued that Western civilization was in decay.

Art

Artists broke with realism to express the new uncertainty and the inner mind.

  • Cubism (Pablo Picasso) showed objects from many angles, and his Guernica (1937) condemned the bombing of a Spanish town.
  • Dada mocked the values that led to the war with absurd works, and Surrealism (Salvador Dali) drew on dreams and the unconscious, inspired by Freud.
  • Abstract art (Kandinsky) dropped recognizable subjects, and Expressionism showed raw emotion.
  • Architecture and design. The Bauhaus in Germany combined art and industrial design, and functionalist architecture (Le Corbusier) favored plain forms.
  • Mass culture. Radio, film, and jazz spread to a wide audience, and totalitarian states used these media for propaganda (Lesson 8.6).

Women and society

The CED says World War I transformed the lives of women and democratized societies, and that during both world wars women became increasingly involved in military and political mobilization and in economic production.

  • Work. In World War I, women took jobs in munitions plants, transport, offices, and farms, and served as nurses and auxiliaries. In World War II, women took part in factories, the armed services (auxiliary forces in Britain and the United States, and Soviet women as pilots, snipers, and soldiers), and resistance movements.
  • Politics. Women won the vote after World War I in Britain (1918 for women over 30, 1928 on equal terms), Germany (1918), and other countries, and the war's mass mobilization expanded democracy for men as well. France gave women the vote in 1944 to 1945.
  • Limits. Many women lost wartime jobs when men returned, and fascist regimes promoted traditional roles, with motherhood as a national duty.
Science Relativity, quantum theory Uncertainty principle Freud and the unconscious Atomic physics Arts and ideas Lost generation writers Cubism, Dada, Surrealism Existentialism Bauhaus design Society Women in war work Women win the vote Mass culture, radio, film Propaganda in dictatorships Uncertainty in thought, change in daily life Faith in certain progress gave way to doubt after 1914
Figure 8.9. Cultural change. New theories, new art, and the experience of war together weakened the old confidence in progress and changed women's roles.
Primary source · A world without certainty

Description of: Werner Heisenberg's statement of the uncertainty principle (1927), which says that the position and the momentum of a particle cannot both be known exactly at the same time, so that physics at the atomic scale can predict only probabilities.

Sourcing (HIPP). Heisenberg was a German physicist writing for scientific colleagues, so the audience was specialist and the purpose was to explain a feature of the new quantum mechanics. As evidence of intellectual history, it matters because philosophers and writers read it as ending the Newtonian ideal of a fully predictable universe. The scientific claim is narrower than the popular interpretation, and a good answer separates what the physicists proved from how others used it.

Source analysis · A challenge to certainty

Claim. Quantum physics undermined the belief that nature follows fixed, predictable laws.

Evidence. The uncertainty principle says that position and momentum cannot both be known exactly, so predictions are probabilities.

Reasoning. This supports the CED's statement that the challenge to Newtonian physics opened the door to uncertainty in other fields. The same physics also provided the knowledge behind nuclear weapons, showing the double effect the CED notes.

Worked example · Effects of war on society

Question. Explain one way World War I changed European culture and one way the world wars changed women's roles.

Model. World War I produced a "lost generation" and disillusionment and cynicism, seen in works such as Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front and the poetry of Wilfred Owen, which rejected the glorification of war. Women's roles changed because mobilization brought them into war industries and services, and in many countries, such as Britain and Germany, women won the vote after World War I.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective M, link ideas to events: the new physics and psychology challenged certainty, and the war produced disillusionment. Give named examples of artists, writers, or scientists and explain what each shows. For women, use the CED's three areas (military, political, and economic mobilization) and note both change and limits.

Practice
  1. What did Einstein's theory of relativity change?
    Show answer

    It showed that space and time are not absolute and that mass and energy are related, challenging Newtonian physics.

  2. What is the "lost generation"?
    Show answer

    The generation shaped by World War I, marked by disillusionment and cynicism about progress.

  3. How did Freud challenge confidence in reason?
    Show answer

    He argued that unconscious drives shape behavior, so people are not wholly rational.

  4. Name two artistic movements of the interwar period.
    Show answer

    Cubism, Dada, Surrealism, Expressionism, or abstract art.

  5. How did the world wars change women's lives?
    Show answer

    Women took jobs in industry and services, joined military auxiliaries and resistance, and gained the vote in many countries.

  6. How did new physics have a double effect?
    Show answer

    It undermined belief in certainty and also supplied the knowledge for nuclear weapons and power.

Lesson 8.11 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.11

Continuity and change in an age of global conflict

The last topic of Unit 8 practices continuity and change over time across the age of the two world wars. Learning Objective N asks you to explain continuities and changes in the period 1914 to 1945 and what they meant for Europe's place in the world. The skill is to pick a theme, identify what stayed the same and what changed, and use dated evidence to judge how much the period was a break.

Required content · 8N

Learning objective.

  • 8N. Explain how economic challenges and ideological beliefs influenced prior conceptions about the relationship between the individual and the state.

Reasoning process. Continuity and change. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

Themes to trace

ThemeChangeContinuity
Europe's global positionEmpires fell, the United States and Soviet Union emerged, Europe was weakenedBritain and France still held colonial empires, extended through mandates
Political systemsDemocracies fell to fascism and communism; totalitarian states used terror and mass mediaNationalism remained strong; many democracies survived (Britain, France, Scandinavia)
WarfareIndustrialized, total war; aerial bombing; atomic weaponsWars were still fought over territory, power, and national rivalry
EconomyDepression, planned economies, state intervention, KeynesCapitalism and industry remained the base of European wealth
SocietyWomen's mobilization, migrations, loss of a generation, the HolocaustClass and gender inequality persisted
Ideas and cultureRelativity, quantum theory, Freud, modern art, existentialismReligion, science, and belief in progress continued, though shaken

Building a continuity and change argument

  1. Choose the period and the theme. For example, "the role of the state in the economy, 1914 to 1945."
  2. State what changed. World War I brought state control of production; the Depression brought public spending and regulation; the Soviet Five-Year Plans and the Nazi economy were state-directed.
  3. State what continued. Private property and markets survived in the democracies, and industrial capitalism remained.
  4. Give a judgment. Explain that the change was large in scale but not total, or argue that one period was the real turning point. Support the argument with dates and events.
Theme Change Continuity Europe's global role Empires fell; U.S. and USSR rose Colonial empires persisted Politics Fascism, communism, totalitarianism Nationalism; some democracies survived Warfare Total war, bombing, atomic bomb Wars over territory and power Economy State direction, Keynes Capitalism and industry endured
Figure 8.10. Continuity and change. For each theme, a strong answer names what changed and what stayed the same.

Turning points

Historians often argue about which event was the biggest break.

  • 1914: the beginning of total war and the end of the long peace.
  • 1917: the Russian Revolution and the U.S. entry into the war, which changed the balance of power.
  • 1929: the depression, which discredited liberal institutions.
  • 1939 to 1945: the Second World War, the Holocaust, and the atomic bomb, which ended European dominance.

A common thesis treats 1914 to 1945 as a single "age of catastrophe" in which the two wars and the depression are linked, since the settlement of the first made the second more likely, but a strong answer also asks what was different between the wars.

Primary source · The new weapon

Description of: The letter from Albert Einstein to President Franklin Roosevelt (August 1939), prepared with the physicist Leo Szilard, which warned that recent research on uranium made it possible to build "extremely powerful bombs of a new type," and urged the government to support American research because German scientists were working in the field.

Sourcing (HIPP). The letter was a private request to a government leader by an eminent scientist, a refugee from Nazi Germany, and its purpose was to persuade the United States to begin research on nuclear weapons. It shows how scientific discovery, the fear of an enemy, and state power combined, a change that makes the period distinct. It also shows continuity, since the weapon was sought for the old aim of securing victory in war.

Source analysis · Change and continuity

Claim. The letter reveals both a break with the past and a continuity in the purposes of war.

Evidence. It warns that uranium research could produce "extremely powerful bombs of a new type," and urges the government to act because Germany might do so first.

Reasoning. The new technology is a change that, as the CED notes, made possible nuclear proliferation and the risk of global nuclear war. The motive, a fear that an enemy would gain an advantage, shows a continuity with earlier arms races.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in Europe's role in the world from 1914 to 1945.

Model. One change was that Europe lost its leading position: the Great War and then the Second World War weakened it economically and demographically, and the United States and the Soviet Union emerged as the strongest powers. One continuity was that Britain and France still controlled large colonial empires, which they expanded after 1919 by taking the League mandates in the Middle East.

Exam focus

Learning Objective N asks for both continuity and change, with evidence and a judgment. Pick a theme, use dates, and avoid saying "everything changed." Note that the CED places the turning points at the world wars, the Russian Revolution, and the depression, and good answers compare what changed before 1918, between the wars, and after 1939.

Practice
  1. Name one change in Europe's global position from 1914 to 1945.
    Show answer

    Europe lost economic and political dominance as the United States and the Soviet Union became the leading powers.

  2. Name one continuity in the same period.
    Show answer

    Britain and France kept and even expanded colonial empires, and nationalism and capitalism endured.

  3. What does it mean to call 1914 to 1945 an "age of catastrophe"?
    Show answer

    The two world wars, the depression, and totalitarian regimes can be seen as linked disasters.

  4. Why is the Einstein-Szilard letter a sign of change?
    Show answer

    It shows scientists urging the state to build atomic weapons, a new technology that changed warfare.

  5. Give one turning point and explain it.
    Show answer

    1917, when the Russian Revolution and U.S. entry changed the balance of power in the war and afterwards.

  6. How can a strong answer avoid saying "everything changed"?
    Show answer

    By identifying specific continuities, such as empires, nationalism, capitalism, and inequality, alongside the changes.

Unit 8 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 8 review: 20th-Century Global Conflicts, c. 1914–present

Ten questions on the First World War, the Russian Revolution, Versailles, the interwar collapse, the dictatorships, and the Second World War and the Holocaust, plus two short-answer questions on total war and its political consequences.

Multiple choice

  1. Which best explains why the assassination at Sarajevo produced a general European war within six weeks?

    There was no single collective treaty; Europe was divided into two opposing blocs with separate and partly secret commitments.

    Correct. Austrian action against Serbia drew in Russia, whose mobilization triggered Germany's plan requiring an immediate westward attack through Belgium: leaving diplomats almost no time.

    Gavrilo Princip was a Bosnian Serb nationalist with links to a Serbian secret society; no Russian order existed.

    Britain entered last among the major powers, after the German invasion of Belgium.

  2. Description of: an official British photograph of a front-line trench, 1916, and a contemporary recruiting poster.

    The photograph shows a revetted cut in chalk soil with duckboards over standing water and men in helmets on a firing step; beyond the parapet the ground is churned and treeless. The poster shows a single uniformed figure in clean profile against a flat color field with a slogan appealing to duty, and no depiction of the front.

    Taken together, the two images are most useful as evidence for

    Neither image contains casualty data, and censorship forbade photographs of British dead.

    Correct. Both were produced by or for the state under censorship (one a sanitized documentary record, the other pure recruitment), so together they document official management of the home front.

    Private opinion appears in letters and diaries, not in officially produced photographs and posters.

    The images are from 1916 and show static trench conditions, not the combined-arms methods of 1918.

  3. The prolonged stalemate on the Western Front is best explained by

    Correct. Machine guns, wire, and artillery in prepared positions, plus railways moving defenders faster than attackers could advance on foot, gave defense a decisive edge until 1918.

    Commanders mounted repeated massive offensives: Verdun and the Somme in 1916 alone produced hundreds of thousands of casualties.

    Industrial economies produced shells in enormous and growing quantities; the 1915 British shell crisis was a shortfall in supply, not a general inability to attack.

    Mutinies occurred, notably in the French army in 1917, but they were exceptions rather than the cause of three years of stalemate.

  4. Source: V. I. Lenin, the April Theses, published in Pravda, 1917.

    "No support for the Provisional Government; the utter falsity of all its promises should be made clear … Not a parliamentary republic … but a republic of Soviets of Workers', Agricultural Labourers' and Peasants' Deputies throughout the country, from top to bottom."

    The immediate audience Lenin most needed to persuade with this document was

    He was attacking the government, not appealing to it, and had no interest in persuading its ministers.

    Correct. Most Bolsheviks in the capital favored cooperation; Lenin wrote to break that consensus, which is why the language admits no compromise.

    The theses were published in the Bolshevik paper in Russia and addressed Russian party policy in the immediate situation.

    Lenin sought power through the soviets and opposed the officer corps, which later backed the Whites in the civil war.

  5. The decisive reason the Provisional Government lost support between March and October 1917 was its

    The monarchy's fall was widely welcomed; Nicholas II abdicated amid strikes and mutiny with very little support for his restoration.

    Correct. Continuing the war meant further offensives soldiers would not mount and left land reform postponed, so the Bolsheviks' promise of peace and endorsement of land seizures matched what soldiers and peasants wanted.

    It postponed land reform until a constituent assembly, which is precisely why peasants seized land themselves without waiting.

    The Petrograd Soviet operated openly and held the loyalty of the troops throughout: the dual power that defined the period.

  6. Source: Treaty of Versailles, 1919, Article 231.

    "The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage … as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies."

    The most useful observation a historian can make about this clause is that

    Correct. Allied lawyers drafted it to establish liability so a bill could follow; German politics read it as a moral condemnation, and the gap between intent and reception is the historically important fact.

    Germany was not represented at the conference and negotiated none of the treaty's terms.

    Nearly identical wording appeared in the treaties with Austria and Hungary, which is evidence that the clause was a legal formula rather than a special judgment.

    The sum was fixed separately in 1921 and payment was rescheduled repeatedly, notably by the Dawes Plan of 1924.

  7. Description of: German unemployment figures and Reichstag election results, 1928–1933.

    Registered unemployment rises from roughly 1.4 million in 1928 to over 6 million by early 1932. The Nazi share of the vote rises from under 3 percent in 1928 to about 37 percent in July 1932; the Communist share also rises, while moderate liberal parties lose most of their support.

    A careful historian would caution that these two series together

    Nazi support was in fact strongest among Protestant rural and middle-class voters, while many unemployed workers voted Communist.

    Correct. Two trends moving together do not establish who moved; the composition of each group has to be examined before causation can be claimed.

    The Depression clearly destabilized German politics; the caution concerns the precise mechanism, not whether there was an effect.

    Weimar election returns are well documented and reliable; it is the registered unemployment figure that undercounts.

  8. Description of: the legal texts and official material of the Nazi racial state, 1933–1938.

    The 1935 Reich Citizenship Law distinguishes citizens of German blood from mere subjects, and an accompanying law forbids marriage between Jews and Germans. Supplementary decrees define Jewish descent by counting grandparents; later regulations exclude Jews from professions and schools and require registration of property. Posters and schoolbooks present the measures using biological and medical imagery.

    The bureaucratic and medical vocabulary of these materials is historically significant because it

    The regulations expanded continuously from 1933 onward, with no provision for expiry.

    Correct. Presenting persecution as administration and public hygiene normalized it for the ordinary functionaries who carried it out: the mechanism that later made mass murder administratively possible.

    These are state-produced documents and cannot show private opinion; they document what the regime wanted normalized.

    Racial science of this kind was pseudoscience. The vocabulary lent an appearance of authority, which is a different matter from justification.

  9. Which represents the most significant difference between Nazi Germany and Stalin's Soviet Union?

    Both used terror, camps, and single-party rule: the convergence of method is precisely why the comparison is made.

    Correct. A category defined by ancestry admits no redemption, while kulak or wrecker was defined by conduct or position and could in principle be revised, which is why "totalitarian" describes how they ruled without explaining what they were for.

    Both pursued rapid industrialization, the Soviet Union through the Five-Year Plans and Germany through rearmament.

    Both built extensive propaganda apparatus and leader cults.

  10. Historians generally describe the Holocaust as an escalation rather than the execution of a fixed plan because

    Correct. Each stage was adopted when the previous one was judged inadequate to a goal that grew more radical as conquest brought more people under German control, with the invasion of the Soviet Union the decisive turn.

    Extensive perpetrator documentation survives (railway schedules, unit reports, ministry correspondence), and was used at Nuremberg.

    Anti-Semitism was central to Nazi ideology from the outset, and the Nuremberg Laws date from 1935.

    The Wannsee Conference of January 1942 coordinated the program across ministries, and the camps were centrally run.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way the First World War transformed European societies at home.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the peace settlement of 1919 contributed to later instability.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason the Bolsheviks were able to take and hold power in Russia.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: state direction of industry and rationing; conscription; censorship and propaganda; women entering munitions work and transport in large numbers and subsequent suffrage extensions; enormous casualties reshaping populations. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: the war-guilt clause and reparations as a durable German grievance; a treaty harsh enough to enrage but not to disable Germany; successor states with large discontented minorities; the absence of enforcement once the United States withdrew. Must link to later instability.
    • (c) Accept: the promise of immediate peace and endorsement of peasant land seizures; the Provisional Government's decision to continue the war; control of the Petrograd Soviet and its loyalty among troops; Red Army victory in the civil war and War Communism. Must explain the mechanism.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Total war required states to direct their whole economies. Governments conscripted men, rationed food, took control of factories and raw materials, and censored the press, while women entered munitions work and transport in very large numbers: a mobilization of civilian life that no previous European war had demanded.

    (b) The settlement was harsh enough to humiliate Germany but not harsh enough to disable it. Germany kept its industrial base, national unity, and a population larger than France's, so it retained both the grievance created by the war-guilt clause and reparations and the capacity to act on it once enforcement collapsed.

    (c) The Bolsheviks alone offered what soldiers and peasants wanted. While the Provisional Government continued the war, Lenin promised immediate peace and endorsed the land seizures peasants were already carrying out, so when the Bolsheviks moved in October the garrison and the Petrograd Soviet would not defend the government.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE way the Great Depression affected European politics.
    2. Briefly explain ONE similarity between Nazi Germany and Stalin's Soviet Union.
    3. Briefly explain ONE difference between them.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: discrediting moderate governments that applied deflationary policy; the rise of Nazi and Communist voting in Germany; Popular Fronts in France and Spain; the collapse of parliamentary democracy across much of the continent by 1939. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: single-party rule and destruction of independent institutions; terror, secret police, and camps; leader cults; mass propaganda and mobilizing organizations; state direction of the economy. Must be specific.
    • (c) Accept: biological versus class-and-conduct definitions of enemies; racial hierarchy and conquest versus a classless industrial future; private ownership retained in Germany against collectivization in the USSR. Must contrast purposes or categories, not merely name the two states.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) The Depression discredited the moderate parties that governed through it. Governments responded with balanced budgets and wage cuts, which deepened unemployment and made parliamentary politics appear powerless, so German voters abandoned the liberal center for the Nazis and Communists, who together won a Reichstag majority hostile to the republic by July 1932.

    (b) Both destroyed independent institutions and ruled through a single party sustained by terror. Each abolished rival parties and free trade unions, built a secret police and a camp system for real and imagined enemies, and mobilized society through propaganda and mass organizations under a cult of the leader.

    (c) They defined their enemies differently, and the difference was decisive for their victims. The Nuremberg Laws of 1935 identified Jews by ancestry, a category no individual could alter, whereas Soviet victims were targeted as kulaks, wreckers, or disloyal party members: categories defined by conduct or position that the regime could in principle revise.

Lesson 9.1 · Unit 9 · CED topics 9.1 and 9.2

Europe in ruins and the Marshall Plan

Unit 9 follows Europe from 1945 to the present. Learning Objective A asks for the context of the Cold War and contemporary Europe, and Learning Objective B asks you to explain how Europe was rebuilt after the war. The CED's statement is that Marshall Plan funds from the United States financed extensive reconstruction of industry and infrastructure and stimulated an extended period of growth in Western and Central Europe, the "economic miracle," which increased the importance of consumerism.

Required content · 9A, 9B

Learning objectives.

  • 9A. Explain the context in which the Cold War developed, spread, and ended in Europe.
  • 9B. Explain how economic developments resulted in economic, political, and cultural change in the period after World War II.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.IV.A. Marshall Plan funds from the United States financed an extensive reconstruction of industry and infrastructure and stimulated an extended period of growth in Western and Central Europe, often referred to as an “economic miracle,” which increased the economic and cultural importance of consumerism.

Europe in 1945

  • Destruction. Cities were in ruins, factories and railways were wrecked, and tens of millions had died. Food and fuel were scarce, and millions of refugees and displaced persons were on the move.
  • Weakened powers. Britain and France were exhausted, Germany was defeated, occupied, and divided into four zones, and eastern Europe was in the grip of the Red Army.
  • New superpowers. The United States and the Soviet Union emerged with the strongest economies and armies, and with opposing ideologies of capitalism and democracy against communism (Lesson 9.2).
  • Hopes and fears. The war had ended with a desire for a more just society and a fear that economic misery would bring a return of extremism, as after 1919.

The Marshall Plan

In June 1947, American Secretary of State George Marshall proposed that the United States help Europe recover. The European Recovery Program, known as the Marshall Plan, provided about $13 billion in aid between 1948 and 1952, mostly grants, for food, machinery, fuel, and investment.

  • Motives. Humanitarian concern, a belief that prosperity would build stable democracies, a fear that poverty would help communist parties (which were strong in France and Italy), and an interest in rebuilding markets for American goods.
  • Cooperation. European governments had to plan together, which led to the Organization for European Economic Cooperation, a forerunner of later integration (Lesson 9.9).
  • The Soviet response. Stalin rejected the plan and forced the eastern European states to refuse it, and the USSR created its own system (Lesson 9.3).

The "economic miracle"

The CED describes an extended period of growth in Western and Central Europe, often called an economic miracle. West Germany's recovery (the Wirtschaftswunder) was the best known, helped by a currency reform in 1948, and France, Italy, and others saw rapid growth in the 1950s and 1960s. The causes included Marshall aid, high investment, cheap labor and energy, trade expansion, and government planning.

The result was consumerism. Rising incomes allowed families to buy cars, televisions, refrigerators, and washing machines, and shopping, advertising, and leisure became more central to life. Many Europeans also welcomed the welfare state (Lesson 9.5), which provided security.

U.S. aid About $13 billion, 1948 to 1952 Rebuilding Factories, rail, farms, ports Cooperation Joint planning among states Growth The economic miracle Consumerism Cars, appliances, television How the Marshall Plan fed recovery Aid was tied to joint European planning, which later helped integration
Figure 9.1. Marshall Plan. American grants rebuilt industry and encouraged cooperation, and the resulting growth reshaped daily life through consumer goods.
Primary source · Against hunger and chaos

George C. Marshall, address at Harvard University, June 5, 1947 (a U.S. government document).

Our policy is directed not against any country or doctrine but against hunger, poverty, desperation and chaos.

Sourcing (HIPP). Marshall, the Secretary of State and a famous general, spoke at a university commencement, so the occasion was relatively informal, but the audience was Europe's governments as well as the American public. The purpose was to invite European states to draw up a joint recovery plan and to present American aid as nonpolitical. The language of "not against any country" was meant to leave the door open to the Soviet Union, yet the plan also served American interests in stopping the spread of communism, so historians weigh both the generosity and the strategy.

Source analysis · Motives of aid

Claim. Marshall presented American aid as a response to economic misery, not as a weapon against a rival.

Evidence. He said the policy was directed "against hunger, poverty, desperation and chaos" and not against any country or doctrine.

Reasoning. The speech supports the humanitarian reading of the plan and recalls the lesson of the interwar years, when depression fed extremism (Lesson 8.5). However, the aid also helped contain communism, so the statement of purpose does not capture every motive.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one reason for the postwar "economic miracle" in Western Europe and one effect on society.

Model. One reason was the Marshall Plan, whose American funds financed the reconstruction of industry and infrastructure and encouraged European cooperation. One effect was the rise of consumer culture: with higher incomes, more families bought cars, appliances, and televisions, which changed daily life and the economy.

Exam focus

For Learning Objectives A and B, set the context (destruction, the two superpowers) and then explain the Marshall Plan with its motives, its size, and its results (the economic miracle and consumerism). Mention that the Soviet bloc rejected it, which links to the next lesson. Do not describe the plan as only altruistic or only strategic.

Practice
  1. What was the Marshall Plan?
    Show answer

    American aid of about $13 billion from 1948 to 1952 to rebuild Western European economies.

  2. Give two motives for the Marshall Plan.
    Show answer

    Humanitarian concern, preventing the spread of communism through poverty, and rebuilding markets for American goods.

  3. What was the "economic miracle"?
    Show answer

    The period of rapid growth in Western and Central Europe in the 1950s and 1960s, such as West Germany's Wirtschaftswunder.

  4. How did the plan encourage cooperation?
    Show answer

    European governments had to plan the use of aid together, leading to organizations that foreshadowed European integration.

  5. How did the Soviet Union respond?
    Show answer

    Stalin rejected the plan and forced eastern European states to refuse it.

  6. What was one social effect of recovery?
    Show answer

    Rising incomes and the growth of consumerism, with more families buying cars and household appliances.

Lesson 9.2 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.3

The Cold War

Learning Objective C asks you to explain the causes and the global character of the Cold War. The CED's points are that, despite efforts at cooperation through the United Nations, deep-seated tensions between the USSR and the West led to the division of Europe, called in the West the Iron Curtain, and that the Cold War played out on a global stage with propaganda, covert actions, limited "hot wars," and an arms race under the threat of nuclear war.

Required content · 9C

Learning objective.

  • 9C. Explain the causes, events, and effects of the Cold War in the period following World War II.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.IV.A. Despite efforts to maintain international cooperation through the newly created United Nations, deep-seated tensions between the USSR and the West led to the division of Europe, which was referred to in the West as the Iron Curtain.
  • 4.1.IV.B. The Cold War played out on a global stage and involved propaganda campaigns; covert actions; limited “hot wars” in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean; and an arms race, with the threat of a nuclear war.

Origins

The wartime alliance against Hitler broke down quickly.

  • Ideology. The United States stood for democracy and capitalism and the Soviet Union for one-party communism and a planned economy, and each saw the other as a threat.
  • Eastern Europe. At the Yalta (February 1945) and Potsdam (July 1945) conferences, the Allies agreed to free elections in liberated Europe, but Stalin installed communist-controlled governments in Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary, and other states occupied by the Red Army.
  • Security. Stalin wanted a buffer of friendly states against another invasion, while the West saw expansion. In 1946, the former British leader Winston Churchill said that an "iron curtain" had descended across the continent.
  • Mistrust. The Soviets resented the delay in opening a second front and American atomic monopoly, and the West distrusted Soviet aims.

The United Nations, founded in 1945, was meant to preserve cooperation, but its Security Council was blocked by the veto power of the five permanent members, including the United States and the USSR.

The division of Europe

  • The Truman Doctrine (1947). President Harry Truman pledged American support for "free peoples" resisting communism and began aid to Greece and Turkey. This is the policy of containment, which aimed to stop the spread of communism without war.
  • The Marshall Plan (1947 to 1948) gave economic aid (Lesson 9.1), and the Soviets responded with the Cominform.
  • Germany divided. The occupation zones hardened into two states in 1949: the Federal Republic (West Germany) and the German Democratic Republic (East Germany). The city of Berlin, deep inside East Germany, was also divided.
  • The Berlin Blockade (1948 to 1949). Stalin cut land access to West Berlin, and the Western powers supplied the city by the Berlin Airlift for nearly a year until he backed down.
  • Alliances. NATO (1949) and the Warsaw Pact (1955) formed opposing blocs (Lesson 9.3).

A global conflict

The CED says the Cold War played out on a global stage.

  • Limited wars. The superpowers avoided direct war but fought through allies and in "hot wars" in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean, including Korea (1950 to 1953) and Vietnam, and the Cuban Revolution led to the Cuban Missile Crisis (1962), when the world came close to nuclear war.
  • Arms race. The USSR tested an atomic bomb in 1949, and both sides built hydrogen bombs and long-range missiles, and entered a space race after the Soviet Sputnik (1957). The doctrine of mutual assured destruction meant that each side could destroy the other.
  • Propaganda and covert action. Both sides used radio, films, exhibitions, and intelligence agencies (CIA and KGB) to influence other countries, and sometimes backed coups.
  • Détente. In the 1970s, tensions eased with arms limitation talks (SALT) and the Helsinki Accords (1975), though tensions returned in the early 1980s.
1947 Truman Doctrine; Marshall Plan 1948-49 Berlin Blockade; NATO 1955 Warsaw Pact 1956 Hungary 1961-62 Berlin Wall; Cuban Missile Crisis 1968 Prague Spring 1975 Helsinki Accords 1989-91 Communism collapses
Figure 9.2. Cold War. A divided Europe lived through crises and revolts, and a period of easing tensions, before the Soviet bloc fell apart.
Primary source · Containment

Harry S. Truman, address to Congress, March 12, 1947, the Truman Doctrine (a U.S. government document).

I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.

Sourcing (HIPP). The President spoke to Congress to ask for $400 million in aid to Greece and Turkey, so his audience was members of Congress and the American public, and his purpose was to win support for a major new commitment. The speech divides the world into two ways of life, which is typical of Cold War rhetoric and was meant to persuade, and it describes the contest in terms of freedom, not interests. Historians use it as the declaration of the policy of containment but also note that it simplified complicated local situations.

Source analysis · Framing the conflict

Claim. Truman presented the Cold War as a defense of free peoples against outside pressure.

Evidence. He pledged support to "free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures."

Reasoning. The pledge supports the CED's point that deep-seated tensions led to the division of Europe, and it establishes containment as American policy. Its sharp division of the world suited the purpose of persuading Congress, so it may overstate the clarity of the contest.

Worked example · Causes and global effects

Question. Explain one cause of the Cold War and one way it became global.

Model. One cause was the Soviet establishment of communist governments in eastern Europe, which the West saw as a violation of the wartime promise of free elections and which led to the Iron Curtain. It became global as the superpowers supported rival sides in "hot wars" in Asia, such as Korea, and in Latin America, and competed in an arms race that threatened nuclear war.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective C, give causes (ideology, eastern Europe, mutual suspicion) and key events with dates (Truman Doctrine, Marshall Plan, Berlin Blockade, NATO, Korea, Cuba). Show the global scope with an example outside Europe. Define containment and the Iron Curtain, and avoid blaming only one side without considering the other.

Practice
  1. What was the Iron Curtain?
    Show answer

    The Western term for the division of Europe between the democratic West and the Soviet-dominated East.

  2. What was the policy of containment?
    Show answer

    The American strategy of stopping the spread of communism without direct war, as in the Truman Doctrine.

  3. What happened in the Berlin Blockade?
    Show answer

    The USSR cut land access to West Berlin in 1948 and the Western powers supplied it by airlift until 1949.

  4. Name two "hot wars" of the Cold War.
    Show answer

    Korea and Vietnam.

  5. What was mutual assured destruction?
    Show answer

    The idea that each superpower could destroy the other with nuclear weapons, which deterred direct war.

  6. Why was the United Nations limited in the Cold War?
    Show answer

    The veto of permanent members such as the United States and the USSR could block action.

Lesson 9.3 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.4

Two superpowers and the divided continent

Learning Objective D asks you to explain the effects of the rise of the superpowers on Europe. The CED states that the United States exerted strong influence in Western Europe, creating world monetary and trade systems and alliances including NATO; that countries east of the Iron Curtain came under Soviet domination within COMECON and the Warsaw Pact; that the Soviet bloc followed central planning, extensive social welfare, and specialized production, with restriction of individual rights and suppression of dissent; and that after 1956, Khrushchev's de-Stalinization failed to meet its economic goals and revolts in Eastern Europe ended with a reimposition of Soviet rule.

Required content · 9D

Learning objective.

  • 9D. Explain the economic and political consequences of the Cold War for Europe.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.IV.C. The United States exerted a strong military, political, and economic influence in Western Europe, leading to the creation of world monetary and trade systems and geopolitical alliances, including NATO.
  • 4.1.IV.D. Countries east of the Iron Curtain came under the military, political, and economic domination of the Soviet Union within the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (COMECON) and the Warsaw Pact.
  • 4.2.V.A. Central and Eastern European nations within the Soviet bloc followed an economic model based on central planning, extensive social welfare, and specialized production among bloc members. This brought with it the restriction of individual rights and freedoms, suppression of dissent, and constraint of emigration for the various populations within the Soviet bloc.
  • 4.2.V.B. After 1956, Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev’s de-Stalinization policies failed to meet their economic goals within the Soviet Union; combined with reactions to existing limitations on individual rights, this prompted revolts in Eastern Europe, which ended with a reimposition of Soviet rule and repressive totalitarian regimes.
  • 4.2.V.D.i. The rise of new nationalisms in Central and Eastern Europe brought peaceful revolution in most countries but resulted in instability in some former Soviet republics.

The West under American influence

  • Alliances. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), founded in 1949, bound the United States, Canada, and Western European states to defend one another. West Germany joined in 1955.
  • Economic systems. The United States helped create the Bretton Woods monetary system (1944), with the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, and the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (1947), which promoted trade among Western economies. The Marshall Plan tied Europe's recovery to American markets.
  • Democracy and welfare. Western Europe combined market economies with elected governments and welfare programs (Lesson 9.5).
  • Culture. American popular culture, music, and films spread widely (Lesson 9.11).

The East under Soviet domination

  • COMECON. The Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (1949) coordinated the economies of the Soviet bloc, which the USSR dominated.
  • The Warsaw Pact (1955). The Soviet-led military alliance of eastern European states was formed after West Germany joined NATO, and it let the USSR keep troops in its satellites.
  • The model. Communist governments followed the Soviet example: central planning of the economy, state ownership, extensive social welfare (jobs, housing, health care), and specialized production among bloc members. Collectivization of agriculture and heavy industry were emphasized, but consumer goods were scarce.
  • Control. One-party rule, secret police, censorship, and restrictions on emigration (the Berlin Wall, built in 1961, stopped East Germans from fleeing to the West) suppressed dissent.

De-Stalinization and revolt

After Stalin's death in 1953, Nikita Khrushchev gained power. In a "Secret Speech" in 1956, he denounced Stalin's crimes and cult of personality, and began a policy of de-Stalinization: releasing prisoners, easing censorship, and seeking to improve living standards and agriculture. Its economic goals were not met, and the relaxation encouraged hopes for reform.

  • Hungary, 1956. Protesters demanded democratic reform and the withdrawal of Soviet forces, and Imre Nagy's government promised to leave the Warsaw Pact. Soviet tanks crushed the revolution, and thousands were killed.
  • Czechoslovakia, 1968. The Prague Spring, led by Alexander Dubček, tried to create "socialism with a human face" with greater freedom. Warsaw Pact troops invaded in August, and the Brezhnev Doctrine declared the USSR's right to intervene to preserve communism in its allies.
  • Poland saw repeated unrest, and later the Solidarity movement (Lesson 9.6).

As the CED says, these revolts ended with a reimposition of Soviet rule and repressive totalitarian regimes.

The West United States leads NATO (1949) Market economies, Marshall aid Elected governments, welfare The East Soviet Union leads Warsaw Pact (1955) COMECON, central planning One-party rule, secret police Revolts in the East Hungary, 1956 Prague Spring, 1968 Poland, Solidarity, 1980 Soviet force, until 1989 Two blocs in a divided Europe Each superpower led an alliance, an economic system, and a political model
Figure 9.3. Two blocs. Western Europe took part in American-led institutions by choice, while the East was held by Soviet power, and its revolts were put down until 1989.
Primary source · Soviet tanks in Prague

Description of: An appeal in August 1968, broadcast by Czechoslovak radio during the Warsaw Pact invasion, urging citizens not to resist with arms but to stay calm and support their elected leaders, while reporting that the troops had entered without the knowledge of the government.

Sourcing (HIPP). Radio was the main means of reaching citizens quickly, so the broadcast reflects the point of view of Czechoslovak reformers facing an overwhelming force. Its purpose was to prevent bloodshed and to keep up morale. It is useful evidence of how the invasion looked to the people and officials involved, and it contrasts with the Soviet and Warsaw Pact claim that they had been invited to defend socialism. Careful use requires comparing both sides' accounts.

Source analysis · Two views of an invasion

Claim. Czechoslovak leaders and the Soviet Union gave opposing accounts of the 1968 invasion.

Evidence. The broadcast said that the troops had entered without the government's knowledge, whereas the USSR claimed it was defending socialism.

Reasoning. The broadcast supports the CED's statement that Soviet rule was reimposed after revolts in Eastern Europe. Because it is a one-sided appeal at a moment of crisis, a historian would also read Soviet statements and later archives.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way the United States influenced Western Europe with one way the USSR controlled Eastern Europe.

Model. The United States influenced Western Europe through NATO, an alliance of equals in which American power was central, and through economic systems such as the Marshall Plan and Bretton Woods, which Western governments joined voluntarily. The USSR controlled Eastern Europe through the Warsaw Pact and COMECON, and when Hungary (1956) and Czechoslovakia (1968) tried to reform, it used military force to restore communist rule.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective D, compare the two blocs: Western alliances, markets, and democratic governments against Eastern central planning, one-party rule, and Soviet military control. Name the revolts with dates (Hungary 1956, Czechoslovakia 1968) and the organizations (NATO, COMECON, Warsaw Pact). Do not say the Soviet bloc had no welfare; the CED says it had extensive social welfare and restricted rights.

Practice
  1. What was NATO?
    Show answer

    The Western military alliance formed in 1949 to defend its members against Soviet attack.

  2. What were COMECON and the Warsaw Pact?
    Show answer

    The Soviet bloc's economic organization (1949) and military alliance (1955).

  3. Name two features of the Soviet bloc economic model.
    Show answer

    Central planning, state ownership, extensive social welfare, and specialized production among members.

  4. What was the Secret Speech?
    Show answer

    Khrushchev's 1956 denunciation of Stalin's crimes, which began de-Stalinization.

  5. How did the USSR respond to Hungary in 1956?
    Show answer

    Soviet tanks crushed the revolution and restored communist rule.

  6. What was the Prague Spring?
    Show answer

    The 1968 reform movement in Czechoslovakia to create "socialism with a human face," ended by a Warsaw Pact invasion.

Lesson 9.4 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.5

Nationalism, ethnic conflict, and atrocities

Learning Objective E asks you to explain the causes and effects of postwar nationalism and ethnic conflict. The CED's statement is that new nationalisms in central and eastern Europe resulted in war and genocide in the Balkans. The lesson focuses on Yugoslavia, with comparisons to the peaceful breakup of Czechoslovakia (Lesson 9.6).

Required content · 9E

Learning objective.

  • 9E. Explain the causes and effects of mass atrocities in the period following World War II to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.V.D.ii. New nationalisms in central and eastern Europe resulted in war and genocide in the Balkans.

Yugoslavia under communism

Yugoslavia was created in 1918 and re-formed after World War II under the communist leader Josip Broz Tito. It was a federation of six republics (Serbia, Croatia, Slovenia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, and Montenegro) with many ethnic and religious groups, including Orthodox Serbs, Catholic Croats and Slovenes, and Muslim Bosniaks and Albanians. Tito broke with Stalin in 1948 and ran an independent communist state, and he kept ethnic tensions in check through a strong party and a policy of "brotherhood and unity." After he died in 1980, the system weakened, the economy declined, and politicians used nationalism to win support.

The breakup and wars

  • Milošević and Serbian nationalism. Slobodan Milošević rose in the late 1980s by appealing to Serb nationalism and reducing the autonomy of Kosovo.
  • Independence. Slovenia and Croatia declared independence in 1991 and Bosnia in 1992. Serbia, with the Yugoslav army, fought to keep Serbs in a larger state.
  • War in Croatia (1991 to 1995) and in Bosnia (1992 to 1995). Fighting among Serbs, Croats, and Bosniaks brought ethnic cleansing, the forced removal of a population by terror and killing, and the siege of Sarajevo.
  • Srebrenica (July 1995). Bosnian Serb forces killed about eight thousand Bosniak men and boys in the town, which the United Nations had declared a safe area. International courts have judged this a genocide.
  • Dayton Accords (1995). Mediated by the United States, they ended the Bosnian war and divided Bosnia into two parts.
  • Kosovo (1998 to 1999). Serbian repression of the Albanian majority in Kosovo led to a NATO bombing campaign in 1999. Kosovo later declared independence (2008).
  • Justice. The United Nations created the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia at The Hague, which tried Milošević and other leaders.

Causes and comparisons

Historians cite several causes: the end of communism left a vacuum, leaders used nationalism to keep power, historical memories of World War II atrocities were revived, the economy was in crisis, and international response was slow. The CED's phrase, war and genocide in the Balkans, ties the postwar period to earlier themes of nationalism (Lesson 7.4) and to the Holocaust and its legacy (Lesson 8.9), since the world had pledged "never again."

By contrast, the other new nationalisms in 1989 and after produced peaceful revolutions in most countries, and Czechoslovakia split peacefully in 1993.

1945 Tito founds federal Yugoslavia 1980 Tito dies 1991 Slovenia, Croatia declare independence 1992-95 War in Bosnia; siege of Sarajevo Jul 1995 Srebrenica Dec 1995 Dayton Accords 1999 Kosovo; NATO bombing
Figure 9.4. Yugoslavia. A communist federation held together by Tito broke apart in war after his death and the fall of communism.
Primary source · A town that was a safe area

Description of: United Nations Security Council Resolution 819 (April 1993), which demanded that all parties treat Srebrenica and its surroundings as a "safe area" free from armed attack.

Sourcing (HIPP). The resolution was an official act of an international body, drafted by member states under pressure from reports of attacks on civilians. Its purpose was to protect the population with UN troops, but peacekeepers were few and lightly armed, so the safe area was overrun in July 1995. The document is evidence of both the world community's intention and its limits, which is why historians and courts have examined the failure.

Source analysis · Intention and outcome

Claim. The United Nations tried but failed to protect civilians in Bosnia.

Evidence. Resolution 819 demanded that Srebrenica be treated as a safe area, yet in 1995 Bosnian Serb forces killed about eight thousand men and boys there.

Reasoning. The gap between the resolution and the result illustrates the CED's statement that nationalism led to war and genocide. As an official document, the resolution shows intention and not what happened on the ground, so it must be read with later court findings.

Worked example · Causes

Question. Explain one cause of the wars in Yugoslavia in the 1990s.

Model. One cause was the use of nationalism by political leaders such as Milošević after the end of communist rule and the death of Tito. When the federation weakened, they appealed to ethnic identity to gain power, which led republics to declare independence and fighting to break out, resulting in ethnic cleansing and the genocide at Srebrenica.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective E, name causes (the end of communism, nationalist leaders, ethnic and religious differences, economic crisis) and effects (war, ethnic cleansing, genocide, Dayton, tribunal). Use precise dates and places (Croatia 1991, Bosnia 1992 to 1995, Srebrenica 1995, Kosovo 1999). Compare the violent breakup of Yugoslavia with the peaceful separation of Czechoslovakia.

Practice
  1. Who held Yugoslavia together until 1980?
    Show answer

    Josip Broz Tito, through a strong communist party and a policy of "brotherhood and unity."

  2. What is ethnic cleansing?
    Show answer

    The forced removal of an ethnic group from an area through terror, expulsion, and killing.

  3. What happened at Srebrenica?
    Show answer

    In 1995 Bosnian Serb forces killed about eight thousand Bosniak men and boys in a UN safe area, which courts have called genocide.

  4. How did the Bosnian war end?
    Show answer

    With the Dayton Accords of 1995, mediated by the United States.

  5. What was the role of NATO in Kosovo?
    Show answer

    In 1999 it bombed Serbia to stop the repression of Kosovo's Albanian population.

  6. How did the breakup of Czechoslovakia differ?
    Show answer

    It was peaceful, in 1993, and did not lead to war.

Lesson 9.5 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.6

Contemporary Western democracies and the welfare state

Learning Objective F asks you to explain the development and the problems of Western democracies after 1945. The CED states that the expansion of cradle-to-grave social welfare programs after World War II, accompanied by high taxes, became a contentious domestic political issue as national budgets came under pressure in the late twentieth century.

Required content · 9F

Learning objective.

  • 9F. Explain state-based economic developments following World War II and the responses to these developments.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.IV.B. The expansion of cradle-to-grave social welfare programs in the aftermath of World War II, accompanied by high taxes, became a contentious domestic political issue as the budgets of European nations came under pressure in the late 20th century.

Rebuilding democracy

After the war, democracy returned to Western Europe and was strengthened. West Germany's Basic Law (1949) created a stable federal democracy, Italy and France wrote new constitutions, and Christian Democratic and Social Democratic parties, which accepted both markets and social protection, dominated politics. The memory of the interwar failures made leaders determined to give citizens economic security.

The welfare state

Cradle-to-grave welfare programs promised protection for the whole population from birth to old age.

  • Britain. The government of Clement Attlee (1945 to 1951) created the National Health Service (1948), a national insurance system, and nationalized industries such as coal and railways, following the Beveridge Report (1942).
  • France, West Germany, and Scandinavia. Governments provided pensions, unemployment insurance, family allowances, public education, and health care, with Sweden and its neighbors going furthest.
  • Reasons. The welfare state grew from wartime promises, fear of another depression, the influence of Keynesian ideas (Lesson 8.5), the rise of labor and left-wing parties, and the growth of the postwar economy that paid for it.

Strain and debate

The postwar boom ended with the oil crisis of 1973 and a period of "stagflation" (stagnant growth with inflation) in the 1970s. High taxes and government spending, rising unemployment, and an aging population put budgets under pressure.

  • Critics argued that the welfare state was too expensive, reduced incentives to work, and made industries inefficient. Margaret Thatcher, British Prime Minister from 1979 to 1990, led a conservative response of privatization, lower taxes, and reduced union power, and her ideas are often called neoliberalism.
  • Defenders argued that welfare programs provided security, equality, and stability, and that cuts harmed the poor. Most European countries kept their welfare systems while reforming them, and later governments struggled with pensions and health costs.

The CED calls this a contentious domestic political issue, and debates about taxes, benefits, and the role of the state continue.

Why it grew Memory of the depression Wartime promises Keynesian ideas Postwar growth Strain, 1970s Oil crisis, 1973 Stagflation High taxes and costs Aging population The debate Critics: Thatcher, privatization, tax cuts Defenders: security, equality, stability The welfare state and its critics Most countries reformed their systems and did not abolish them
Figure 9.5. Welfare debate. Programs built in the boom years faced pressure when growth slowed, and arguments over taxes and benefits became part of ordinary politics.
Primary source · A national health service

Description of: The National Health Service Act of 1946 (in force in July 1948), which made the British government responsible for providing comprehensive medical care, free at the point of use, financed by taxation.

Sourcing (HIPP). The Act was legislation passed by Parliament under the Attlee government, so it shows the policy of the state and the purpose of ensuring that cost would not prevent anyone from receiving care. It reflects the wartime ideas of the Beveridge Report and the political changes of 1945. Because it is a legal text, it describes the system's design and does not show how it worked in practice, such as the budget pressures that appeared later.

Source analysis · The welfare state

Claim. The National Health Service Act expanded the role of the state in protecting citizens.

Evidence. It made comprehensive care the responsibility of government and available regardless of ability to pay.

Reasoning. The Act is an example of the CED's cradle-to-grave welfare programs. It shows a response to depression and war, but the text does not show the later conflicts over cost that made the programs contentious.

Worked example · Continuity and debate

Question. Explain one reason the welfare state expanded after World War II and one reason it became controversial.

Model. It expanded because the memory of the depression and the hardship of war led voters and leaders to want economic security, and because postwar growth could pay for programs such as Britain's National Health Service. It became controversial because high taxes and rising costs strained budgets after the 1973 oil crisis, and critics such as Thatcher argued that the state should be reduced.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective F, show why welfare states grew (war, depression, growth, politics) and why they were contentious (taxes, budgets, stagflation). Use named examples (the NHS, Thatcher) and show that most countries reformed rather than abolished welfare. Avoid presenting the debate as only left against right.

Practice
  1. What does cradle-to-grave welfare mean?
    Show answer

    Social programs that protect people throughout life, including health care, pensions, and unemployment insurance.

  2. What was Britain's National Health Service?
    Show answer

    A national system created in 1948 to provide medical care free at the point of use, funded by taxes.

  3. Why did the welfare state come under pressure in the 1970s?
    Show answer

    The oil crisis and stagflation reduced growth while taxes and costs were high.

  4. What did Margaret Thatcher do?
    Show answer

    She led a conservative program of privatization, tax cuts, and reduced union power after 1979.

  5. Name two parties that supported postwar democracy and welfare.
    Show answer

    Christian Democratic and Social Democratic parties.

  6. Why did the welfare state grow after 1945?
    Show answer

    Memories of the depression and war, Keynesian ideas, strong labor parties, and postwar growth.

Lesson 9.6 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.7

The fall of communism

Learning Objective G asks you to explain the causes and the effects of the collapse of communism in Europe. The CED's points are that, after economic stagnation, Gorbachev's reforms of perestroika and glasnost failed to stave off the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of its control over Eastern and Central Europe, and that the collapse in 1991 ended the Cold War and led to capitalist economies throughout Eastern Europe, the reunification of Germany, the parting of the Czechs and Slovaks, the dissolution of Yugoslavia, and the enlargement of the European Union.

Required content · 9G

Learning objective.

  • 9G. Explain the causes and effects of the end of the Cold War.

Historical developments.

  • 4.2.V.C. Following a long period of economic stagnation, Mikhail Gorbachev’s internal reforms of perestroika and glasnost, designed to make the Soviet system more flexible, failed to stave off the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of its hegemonic control over Eastern and Central European satellites.
  • 4.1.IV.E. The collapse of the USSR in 1991 ended the Cold War and led to the establishment of capitalist economies throughout Eastern Europe. Germany was reunited, the Czechs and the Slovaks parted, Yugoslavia dissolved, and the European Union was enlarged through the admission of former Eastern bloc countries.

Stagnation

By the 1970s and 1980s the Soviet economy was stagnating. Central planning was inefficient, consumer goods were scarce, technology lagged behind the West, and military spending was a heavy burden, especially during the arms race of the early 1980s and the costly war in Afghanistan (1979 to 1989). Eastern European economies borrowed heavily from the West. Dissent grew, from the Helsinki groups in the USSR to Poland's Solidarity, a free trade union led by Lech Wałęsa that began in 1980 and was banned in 1981 under martial law.

Gorbachev's reforms

Mikhail Gorbachev became Soviet leader in 1985. He aimed to make the system more flexible.

  • Perestroika ("restructuring"): economic reforms that allowed some private enterprise and decentralization.
  • Glasnost ("openness"): greater freedom of speech and the press, and open discussion of the past.
  • Foreign policy. He sought arms control with the United States (the INF Treaty, 1987), withdrew from Afghanistan, and renounced the use of force to maintain communist regimes in Eastern Europe.

The reforms failed to stave off collapse: perestroika disrupted the economy without creating a market, and glasnost exposed the failures of communism and encouraged nationalist movements within the Soviet republics.

1989: the revolutions

Without the threat of Soviet intervention, communist governments fell in 1989 to a series of mostly peaceful revolutions.

  • Poland held semi-free elections in June 1989, and Solidarity won.
  • Hungary opened its border with Austria.
  • East Germany. Mass protests and the flight of citizens through Hungary led the government to open the Berlin Wall on November 9, 1989.
  • Czechoslovakia's "Velvet Revolution" removed the communists in weeks, and Romania was the one violent case, with the execution of Nicolae Ceaușescu.

Collapse of the USSR and its effects

An attempted coup by hardliners in August 1991 failed, and the Soviet republics declared independence. On December 25, 1991, Gorbachev resigned and the Soviet Union dissolved into fifteen states, ending the Cold War. The effects were large.

  • Economies. Former communist states moved to capitalist market economies, with painful transitions: inflation, unemployment, and, in Russia, a rapid sale of state property to a few wealthy individuals.
  • Germany reunified on October 3, 1990.
  • New states. Czechoslovakia split peacefully into the Czech Republic and Slovakia (1993), Yugoslavia broke up in violence (Lesson 9.4), and the Baltic states, Ukraine, and others became independent.
  • European Union enlargement. Many former Eastern bloc countries joined NATO and the EU in 2004 and later (Lesson 9.9).
  • Instability. The CED notes instability in some former Soviet republics, as with conflicts in Georgia, Moldova, and Ukraine.
1979-89 Afghanistan war 1980 Solidarity in Poland 1985 Gorbachev; glasnost, perestroika Jun 1989 Poland holds elections Nov 9, 1989 Berlin Wall opens Oct 1990 Germany reunified Dec 1991 USSR dissolves
Figure 9.6. Fall of communism. Economic stagnation and reform, together with the end of Soviet intervention, led from a Polish union to the end of the Soviet Union.
Primary source · Tear down this wall

Ronald Reagan, speech at the Brandenburg Gate, Berlin, June 12, 1987 (a U.S. government document).

Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!

Sourcing (HIPP). President Reagan spoke in West Berlin, near the wall, to a large audience and to the Soviet leadership, so the purpose was to challenge Gorbachev to go beyond his reforms and to reassure West Germans. The speech reflects the American view that Soviet communism was a failure that could be forced to change. Because he spoke two years before the wall opened, it is hard to say how much it influenced events, and historians give more weight to the Soviet economy, Gorbachev's decisions, and popular movements in the East.

Source analysis · Causes of change

Claim. Reagan challenged the Soviet leader to end the division of Europe.

Evidence. He said "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!" at the Brandenburg Gate in 1987.

Reasoning. The speech shows the Western pressure during the late Cold War, but the CED's explanation of the collapse stresses internal stagnation and Gorbachev's reforms, so the speech was probably one cause among many and not the decisive one.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one cause of the collapse of the Soviet Union and one effect on Eastern Europe.

Model. One cause was long-term economic stagnation, which Gorbachev's reforms of perestroika and glasnost could not fix, and which encouraged demands for independence and a loss of control over Eastern Europe. One effect was that former communist states adopted capitalist economies and joined institutions such as NATO and the European Union.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective G, build a chain: stagnation and arms race, Gorbachev's reforms, the end of Soviet intervention, 1989, the dissolution of the USSR in 1991. Use the CED's list of effects (capitalism, German reunification, Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, EU enlargement) and include a limit, such as instability in some states. Do not credit one leader or one cause for the collapse.

Practice
  1. What did perestroika and glasnost mean?
    Show answer

    Perestroika was economic restructuring and glasnost was political openness and freer speech.

  2. What was Solidarity?
    Show answer

    A free trade union in Poland led by Lech Wałęsa that challenged communist rule from 1980.

  3. What happened on November 9, 1989?
    Show answer

    East Germany opened the Berlin Wall.

  4. When did the Soviet Union dissolve?
    Show answer

    In December 1991, when Gorbachev resigned and the republics became independent.

  5. How did Czechoslovakia end?
    Show answer

    It split peacefully into the Czech Republic and Slovakia in 1993.

  6. Name one economic effect on Eastern Europe.
    Show answer

    A move to market capitalism, with inflation and unemployment, and later integration into the EU.

Lesson 9.7 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.8

Twentieth-century feminism

Learning Objective H asks you to explain how and why the status of women changed in the twentieth century. The CED states that feminists in Western Europe, and government policy in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union, brought women the vote, greater educational opportunities, and access to professional careers, while women continued to face social inequalities; that new modes of marriage, partnership, motherhood, divorce, and reproduction gave women more personal options; and that women attained high political office and increased their legislative representation.

Required content · 9H

Learning objective.

  • 9H. Explain how women’s roles and status developed and changed throughout the 20th and 21st centuries.

Historical developments.

  • 4.4.II.B. In Western Europe through the efforts of feminists, and in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union through government policy, women finally gained the vote, greater educational opportunities, and access to professional careers, even while continuing to face social inequalities.
  • 4.4.II.D. New modes of marriage, partnership, motherhood, divorce, and reproduction gave women more options in their personal lives.
  • 4.4.II.E. Women attained high political office and increased their representation in legislative bodies in many nations.

Suffrage and the first wave

Women's movements before 1914 had campaigned for the vote and legal rights in the nineteenth century. In Britain, the suffragettes led by Emmeline Pankhurst used militant tactics, and in 1918 women over 30 won the vote, with full equality in 1928. Women also won the vote after World War I in Germany (1918) and other countries, as a reward for wartime service and as part of democratization (Lesson 8.10). France gave the vote to women in 1944, Italy in 1945, and Switzerland not until 1971.

Different paths in East and West

  • Western Europe. Progress came through feminist movements, which argued for equal rights in law, education, and work. Simone de Beauvoir's The Second Sex (1949) argued that women's inferior position was a product of society, not nature, and influenced later feminism.
  • Soviet bloc. After the Russian Revolution, the state proclaimed equality and gave women access to education, jobs, and professions, including medicine and engineering, and often expected them to work full-time. Their status improved through government policy, not independent movements, and they still did most household work (the "double burden") and held few top political positions.

The second wave and new choices

In the 1960s and 1970s, a second wave of feminism in Western Europe pressed for equal pay, workplace rights, and control over their own bodies. The CED notes new modes of marriage, partnership, motherhood, divorce, and reproduction.

  • Birth control. The contraceptive pill, introduced in the 1960s, gave women control of reproduction, and many countries legalized or widened access to birth control and abortion (for example, France in 1975), though each was controversial.
  • Family law. Divorce became easier, cohabitation and single parenthood became more accepted, and families became smaller.
  • Work and education. More women attended universities and entered professions, and the share of women in paid work rose.
  • Politics. Women became heads of government, such as Margaret Thatcher in Britain (1979), and later Angela Merkel in Germany (2005), and quotas and reforms raised the number of women in parliaments, especially in Scandinavia.

Persisting inequality

Despite these gains, women continued to face social inequalities: pay gaps, concentration in lower-paid jobs, a heavier share of childcare and housework, and underrepresentation in the top levels of business and politics.

1918 British women over 30 vote; Germany 1928 Equal vote in Britain 1944-45 France, Italy give women the vote 1949 The Second Sex 1960s The pill; second wave 1979 Thatcher Prime Minister 2005 Merkel Chancellor
Figure 9.7. Women's status. Voting rights came in stages, and later decades brought new choices in family life, work, and politics.
Primary source · One is not born a woman

Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex (1949), a French philosophical work. The book's best-known claim is that "one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman," meaning that the roles assigned to women are produced by society and education.

Sourcing (HIPP). Beauvoir was a French philosopher and writer, so the audience was educated readers, and the purpose was to analyze and challenge the position of women. The work is a secondary analysis that was also a primary source for the history of feminism, for it helped shape the second wave. It reflects the postwar existentialist movement (Lesson 8.10). As an intellectual work, it cannot show the everyday experience of most women, which also depended on class, region, and law.

Source analysis · Changing ideas

Claim. Beauvoir argued that women's roles are made by society.

Evidence. She wrote that "one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman."

Reasoning. The claim supports the CED's description of new ideas that challenged social inequality, and it helped inspire movements for greater choice. Because it is an intellectual argument, it shows ideas more than the lives of most women.

Worked example · Comparison

Question. Compare one way women's status improved in Western Europe with one way it improved in the Soviet bloc.

Model. In Western Europe, women gained rights mainly through independent feminist movements, which won suffrage, access to birth control, and equal pay laws. In the Soviet bloc, the communist governments gave women access to education and professional jobs through state policy, though women still held little political power and did most housework.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective H, compare East and West (movements against state policy), include the CED's three areas (vote, education and careers, personal choices) and the limits (continued inequality). Give named people and dates, such as the Pankhursts, Beauvoir, the pill, Thatcher, and Merkel. Show change over time and not only one moment.

Practice
  1. When did British women win equal voting rights?
    Show answer

    In 1928, after women over 30 won the vote in 1918.

  2. What did Simone de Beauvoir argue?
    Show answer

    That women's roles are produced by society, not nature, in The Second Sex.

  3. How did the Soviet bloc improve women's status?
    Show answer

    Through government policy giving women access to education, jobs, and professions.

  4. What new options did women gain in personal life?
    Show answer

    Birth control, easier divorce, and new forms of partnership and motherhood.

  5. Name a woman who led a European government.
    Show answer

    Margaret Thatcher in Britain or Angela Merkel in Germany.

  6. Give one inequality that persisted.
    Show answer

    Pay gaps, a heavier burden of housework and childcare, and few women in top positions.

Lesson 9.8 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.9

Decolonization

Learning Objective I asks you to explain the causes and the effects of decolonization after World War II. The CED states that Wilson's principle of national self-determination raised expectations in the non-European world after World War I, and that, despite indigenous nationalist movements, independence for many African and Asian territories was delayed until the mid- and late twentieth century by imperial powers' reluctance to relinquish control, threats of interference from other nations, unstable economic and political systems, and Cold War strategic alignments.

Required content · 9I

Learning objective.

  • 9I. Explain the various ways in which colonial groups around the world sought independence from colonizers in the 20th and 21st centuries.

Historical developments.

  • 4.1.VI.A. At the end of World War I, U.S. President Woodrow Wilson’s principle of national self-determination raised expectations in the non-European world for new policies and freedoms.
  • 4.1.VI.C. Despite indigenous nationalist movements, independence for many African and Asian territories was delayed until the mid- and even late 20th century by the imperial powers’ reluctance to relinquish control, threats of interference from other nations, unstable economic and political systems, and Cold War strategic alignments.

Why empires ended

  • Rising expectations. After World War I, Wilson's talk of self-determination (Lesson 8.4) gave hope to colonial peoples, but the peace gave them mandates instead, and nationalist movements grew in India, Egypt, Vietnam, and elsewhere.
  • The world wars. Colonial soldiers and workers had fought for Europe, and Japan's early victories in 1941 to 1942 broke the myth of European invincibility. Britain and France were weak and in debt after 1945.
  • Nationalist leaders and movements. Leaders such as Mohandas Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru in India, Ho Chi Minh in Vietnam, Kwame Nkrumah in Ghana, and others organized mass movements.
  • The superpowers. The United States and the Soviet Union both opposed old-style colonialism, though each also pursued its own influence.

Paths to independence

RegionExampleHow independence came
South AsiaIndia and Pakistan, 1947Mass nonviolent resistance led by Gandhi and Congress; Britain withdrew, and partition brought violence and mass migration
Southeast AsiaVietnam, 1954War against France after 1946, ended at Dien Bien Phu (1954); Vietnam was divided and then fought further wars
Middle EastPalestine and Israel, 1948; EgyptBritish mandate ended; Israel was founded and wars followed; the Suez Crisis (1956) showed the decline of Britain and France
AfricaGhana 1957; many states 1960Mostly negotiated, as in Ghana; violent in Algeria (war with France, 1954 to 1962) and Kenya

Why independence was delayed

The CED lists reasons why independence for many territories was delayed:

  • Reluctance of imperial powers to give up control, such as France in Algeria, where a large settler population lived, or Portugal, which held its African colonies until the 1970s.
  • Threats of interference from other nations, including rival powers.
  • Unstable economic and political systems, since colonial economies depended on exports of raw materials and had few trained administrators.
  • Cold War alignments, as the superpowers supported rival groups and made decolonization part of their conflict, as in Congo and Angola.

Effects

  • For Europe. Empires ended, European states lost power and markets, and colonial migrants moved to Europe (Lesson 9.10). The process also encouraged Europeans to look to integration (Lesson 9.9).
  • For the new states. They faced poverty, borders drawn by colonial powers, ethnic conflict, and often authoritarian rule. Many joined the Non-Aligned Movement, which sought independence from both superpowers.
  • Neocolonialism. Critics argued that former colonies stayed dependent on the former rulers through trade, debt, and investment.
1947 India and Pakistan 1948 Israel founded 1954 Dien Bien Phu; Algerian war 1956 Suez Crisis 1957 Ghana 1960 Many African states 1962 Algeria 1975 Portuguese colonies
Figure 9.8. Decolonization. Independence came quickly in some regions and late and violently in others, ending the European empires within a generation.
Primary source · A nation's moment

Description of: Jawaharlal Nehru's "Tryst with Destiny" speech to India's Constituent Assembly on the eve of independence, August 14, 1947, in which he said that at the stroke of midnight, when the world sleeps, India will awake to life and freedom, and spoke of a moment that comes rarely in history, when a long-suppressed nation finds a voice.

Sourcing (HIPP). Nehru, soon to be India's first Prime Minister, spoke to the assembly and to the nation, so the speech combined a celebration of independence with a promise of service to the poor. It reflects the point of view of the nationalist leadership, and its date was just before the partition of the country, which brought mass violence and about fifteen million refugees. As a rhetorical text, it expresses hopes, so it should be read with evidence of the difficulties that followed.

Source analysis · Independence and its limits

Claim. Nehru presented independence as the fulfillment of a long national struggle.

Evidence. He spoke of a moment when a nation long suppressed finds a voice, and of India awakening "to life and freedom."

Reasoning. The speech illustrates the CED's reference to indigenous nationalist movements. It does not reflect the violence of partition that accompanied independence, so historians use it for its hopes and need other sources for the costs.

Worked example · Causes and delays

Question. Explain one cause of decolonization and one reason independence was delayed for some colonies.

Model. One cause was that World War II weakened Britain and France while nationalist movements, such as Gandhi's in India, gained mass support, so European powers could no longer keep control. Independence was delayed in places such as Algeria because France, with a large settler population there, was reluctant to give up control, and in other territories because of Cold War rivalries between the superpowers.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective I, give causes (self-determination, the world wars, nationalist movements, superpower pressure) and reasons for delay from the CED. Use specific examples with dates (India 1947, Vietnam 1954, Ghana 1957, Algeria 1962) and show that the paths differed (negotiated against violent). Include effects for both Europe and the new states.

Practice
  1. How did Wilson's idea of self-determination affect colonies?
    Show answer

    It raised expectations of independence, although the peace settlement gave mandates instead.

  2. Name two leaders of nationalist movements.
    Show answer

    Gandhi and Nehru in India, Ho Chi Minh in Vietnam, or Nkrumah in Ghana.

  3. What happened in India in 1947?
    Show answer

    Britain granted independence and divided the country into India and Pakistan, with violence and mass migration.

  4. Why did France resist leaving Algeria?
    Show answer

    A large settler population lived there, and it was treated as part of France, leading to a war from 1954 to 1962.

  5. How did the Cold War affect decolonization?
    Show answer

    The superpowers supported rival factions and alignments, which delayed or complicated independence.

  6. What was one effect on Europe?
    Show answer

    Loss of empires, power, and markets, and immigration from former colonies.

Lesson 9.9 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.10

The European Union

Learning Objectives J and K ask you to explain how and why European integration developed and the tensions it created. The CED states that the European Coal and Steel Community, envisioned to spur postwar economic recovery, developed into the European Economic Community (EEC or Common Market) and the European Union (EU), bringing increasing economic and political integration and efforts to establish a shared European identity, and that member nations continue to balance national sovereignty with the responsibilities of membership.

Required content · 9J, 9K

Learning objectives.

  • 9J. Explain how the formation and existence of the European Union influenced economic developments throughout the period following World War II to the present.
  • 9K. Explain how the European Union affected national and European identity throughout the period following World War II to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.4.IV.A. As the economic alliance known as the European Coal and Steel Community, envisioned as a means to spur postwar economic recovery, developed into the European Economic Community (EEC or Common Market) and the European Union (EU), Europe experienced increasing economic and political integration and efforts to establish a shared European identity.
  • 4.4.IV.B. EU member nations continue to balance questions of national sovereignty with the responsibilities of membership in an economic and political union.

Why integration?

  • Peace. Two world wars had begun in rivalry between France and Germany, and leaders wanted to make another war impossible by tying their economies together.
  • Recovery. Marshall Plan cooperation (Lesson 9.1) showed the benefits of joint planning.
  • The Cold War. A united Western Europe would be stronger against the Soviet bloc.
  • Decline of empires. After decolonization, Europe's states hoped that together they could keep influence in a world of superpowers.

Stages of integration

  1. European Coal and Steel Community (1951). Proposed by the French foreign minister Robert Schuman and Jean Monnet, it placed the coal and steel industries of France, West Germany, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg under a joint authority. These were the materials of war, so sharing them made a new conflict between France and Germany "materially impossible."
  2. Treaty of Rome (1957). The six created the European Economic Community, a common market with the removal of tariffs and free movement of goods, services, labor, and capital, plus a common agricultural policy.
  3. Enlargement. Britain, Ireland, and Denmark joined in 1973, Greece, Spain, and Portugal in the 1980s after their dictatorships ended, and more states after 1990.
  4. The Single European Act (1986) aimed to complete a single market by 1992.
  5. Maastricht Treaty (1992). It created the European Union, with plans for a single currency and common foreign policy. The euro began circulating in 2002 in most member states.
  6. Eastern enlargement (2004 and after). Many former communist states joined (Lesson 9.6), and the EU grew to 27 members after Britain left in 2020.
1951 Coal and Steel Community 1957 Treaty of Rome 1973 Britain, Ireland, Denmark join 1986 Single European Act 1992 Maastricht; the EU 2002 Euro circulates 2004 Eastern enlargement 2020 Britain leaves
Figure 9.9. European integration. A shared market grew into a union with common institutions and a currency, and in 2020 one member left.

Sovereignty and tension

The CED says member states balance questions of national sovereignty with the responsibilities of membership.

  • Supporters argue that integration brought peace, prosperity, and influence, and that shared problems such as trade, the environment, and migration need common action.
  • Critics (called Euroskeptics) argue that decisions were made by unelected officials in Brussels (a "democratic deficit"), that national identity and control of borders were being lost, and that the euro limited national economic policy. The financial crisis of 2008 to 2012 revealed strains among countries sharing a currency, especially Greece.
  • Brexit. In 2016, British voters narrowly chose to leave the EU, and the United Kingdom left in January 2020. Nationalist and populist parties in other countries also challenged integration.

The CED's phrase efforts to establish a shared European identity refers to symbols such as a flag, the euro, passports, and programs for students, as well as free movement across borders within the Schengen area.

Primary source · An ever closer union

Treaty establishing the European Economic Community (Treaty of Rome), 1957, preamble.

DETERMINED to lay the foundations of an ever closer union among the peoples of Europe.

Sourcing (HIPP). The treaty was drafted and signed by the governments of six states, so it reflects the intentions of political leaders and the purpose of creating a lasting economic and political bond. The phrase "ever closer union" was both an aim and a source of later disagreement, since supporters read it as promising deeper integration and critics, such as many in Britain, saw it as a threat to sovereignty. It is evidence of aims in 1957, not of how integration proceeded.

Source analysis · Aims and disputes

Claim. The founders aimed at a deep and growing political bond, not only a trade arrangement.

Evidence. The preamble states the determination "to lay the foundations of an ever closer union among the peoples of Europe."

Reasoning. The phrase supports the CED's statement that integration meant increasing economic and political ties, and it explains why sovereignty later became a problem. Because it states hopes, it does not show how far member states were willing to go in practice.

Worked example · Causes and tensions

Question. Explain one reason for European integration after World War II and one tension it created.

Model. One reason was the desire to prevent another war between France and Germany by joining their coal and steel industries in the European Coal and Steel Community, which then grew into the Common Market. One tension is between national sovereignty and the responsibilities of membership, which critics saw in the euro and in decisions made in Brussels, and which led to Britain's decision to leave in 2016.

Exam focus

For Learning Objectives J and K, show the stages (ECSC, EEC, Maastricht EU) with dates, give motives (peace, recovery, the Cold War), and show the sovereignty debate with an example (euro, Brexit). Use the CED's phrase shared European identity and avoid a simple story of steady progress, since integration has had setbacks.

Practice
  1. What was the European Coal and Steel Community?
    Show answer

    A 1951 agreement among six states to put their coal and steel industries under a joint authority, to make war between France and Germany impossible.

  2. What did the Treaty of Rome create?
    Show answer

    The European Economic Community, or Common Market, in 1957.

  3. What did the Maastricht Treaty do?
    Show answer

    It created the European Union in 1992 and set the course for a single currency.

  4. Why did countries like Poland and Hungary join the EU?
    Show answer

    After communism fell, they sought economic growth, security, and ties to the West, and joined in 2004.

  5. What is a sovereignty concern about the EU?
    Show answer

    That national governments give up decisions on trade, borders, or currency to EU institutions.

  6. What was Brexit?
    Show answer

    The United Kingdom's departure from the EU after a 2016 referendum, completed in 2020.

Lesson 9.10 · Unit 9 · CED topics 9.11 and 9.12

Migration, immigration, and technology

Learning Objectives L and M ask you to explain the causes and effects of migration and immigration and how technology, especially medicine, changed life and raised moral questions. The CED states that increased immigration altered Europe's religious makeup, causing debate over the role of religion; that migrant workers from southern Europe, Asia, and Africa came to western and central Europe in the 1950s and 1960s, but after the 1970s downturn they and their families became targets of anti-immigrant agitation and extreme nationalist parties; and that medical theories and technologies extended life but posed social and moral questions that eluded consensus.

Required content · 9L, 9M

Learning objectives.

  • 9L. Explain the causes and effects of changes to migration within and immigration to Europe throughout the period following World War II to the present.
  • 9M. Explain how innovation and advances in technology influenced cultural and intellectual developments in the period 1914 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.III.C. Increased immigration into Europe altered Europe’s religious makeup, causing debate and conflict over the role of religion in social and political life.
  • 4.4.III.D. Because of the economic growth of the 1950s and 1960s, migrant workers from southern Europe, Asia, and Africa immigrated to western and central Europe; however, after the economic downturn of the 1970s, these workers and their families often became targets of anti-immigrant agitation and extreme nationalist political parties.
  • 4.3.II.B. Medical theories and technologies extended life but posed social and moral questions that eluded consensus and crossed religious, political, and philosophical perspectives.

Migration after 1945

  • Refugees and expulsions. After the war, millions of Germans were expelled from eastern Europe, and refugees moved across the continent.
  • Guest workers. Economic growth in the 1950s and 1960s created labor shortages, and countries recruited migrant workers. West Germany signed agreements with Italy, Spain, Turkey, and Yugoslavia for "guest workers" (Gastarbeiter), and Britain, France, and the Netherlands accepted immigrants from their former colonies, including the Caribbean, South Asia, and North and West Africa.
  • Settlement. After the recession of the 1970s, recruitment ended, but many workers stayed and brought their families.
  • Later flows. Immigration continued from the former colonies, from Eastern Europe after 1989, and from the Middle East and Africa. The refugee crisis of 2015 brought more than a million people, many fleeing the war in Syria, to Europe.

Responses and conflict

  • Anti-immigrant agitation. After the economic downturn of the 1970s, immigrants and their families were blamed for unemployment and social problems. The CED notes that they became targets of extreme nationalist political parties, such as the National Front in France, and of violence.
  • Religion and identity. Immigration altered Europe's religious makeup, notably by increasing the Muslim population. Debates arose over the role of religion in public life, such as headscarves in French schools (1989 and the 2004 ban on visible religious symbols), mosque construction, and secularism against freedom of religion.
  • Integration. Governments debated multiculturalism (Britain and the Netherlands) against assimilation (France), and issues of citizenship, language, and discrimination.
Boom 1950s and 1960s labor shortages Recruitment Guest workers and colonial migrants Downturn 1970s economic slump Settlement Families join; communities form Debate Religion, identity, nationalist parties From labor shortage to political debate Temporary plans became lasting communities, which changed Europe's religious makeup
Figure 9.10. Migration. Workers recruited in the boom years stayed after the slump, and their presence became a central political question.

Technology and medicine

New technologies extended life and changed society.

  • Medicine. Antibiotics (penicillin, in widespread use after 1945), vaccines, and surgery raised life expectancy, and new methods included organ transplants and, in 1978, the first "test-tube baby" in Britain (in vitro fertilization). In the late twentieth century, genetics and DNA research opened new possibilities.
  • Moral questions. The CED says these posed social and moral questions that eluded consensus and crossed religious, political, and philosophical perspectives. Debates concerned abortion, euthanasia, reproductive technology, genetic testing and cloning, and the use of medical knowledge in the Nazi period, which led to rules for experiments on humans (the Nuremberg Code, 1947).
  • Other technology. Computers, television, and later the internet changed work and communication (Lesson 9.11), and nuclear power raised concerns about safety, especially after the Chernobyl disaster (1986).
Primary source · Guest workers

Description of: The German-Turkish recruitment agreement of 1961, which allowed West German employers to hire Turkish workers on temporary contracts to fill labor shortages during the economic boom.

Sourcing (HIPP). The agreement was an official bilateral treaty, so it reflects the interests of both governments: West Germany needed labor and Turkey wanted jobs and money sent home. Its purpose was temporary labor, and the term "guest workers" assumed they would return, which explains why later integration policies were slow to develop. The document therefore shows the intentions of the governments, while the actual history of settlement, family reunification, and discrimination appears in other sources.

Source analysis · Temporary plans, lasting change

Claim. The guest-worker programs were meant to be temporary but led to permanent settlement.

Evidence. The 1961 agreement allowed temporary employment during the boom, but after recruitment ended in the 1970s many workers stayed and brought families.

Reasoning. This illustrates the CED's account of migrant workers who came in the 1950s and 1960s and later became targets of anti-immigrant politics. The agreement shows what governments intended, but it does not describe what the workers experienced.

Worked example · Causes and effects

Question. Explain one reason for immigration to Western Europe in the 1950s and 1960s and one effect on politics.

Model. The economic growth of the 1950s and 1960s created labor shortages, so governments recruited migrant workers from southern Europe, Asia, and Africa. One effect was that, after the economic downturn of the 1970s, immigrants and their families were blamed for unemployment, which helped extreme nationalist parties gain support and made the role of religion a political debate.

Exam focus

For Learning Objectives L and M, tie migration to economic cycles (boom then downturn), show responses (nationalist parties, religious debate), and give examples (guest workers, headscarf debates, 2015). For technology, use medicine as an example of benefit and moral controversy and note that the CED says there was no consensus.

Practice
  1. Why did Western Europe recruit migrant workers in the 1950s and 1960s?
    Show answer

    Economic growth created labor shortages.

  2. What changed after the 1970s downturn?
    Show answer

    Workers and their families became targets of anti-immigrant agitation and extreme nationalist parties.

  3. How did immigration change religion in Europe?
    Show answer

    It increased the Muslim population, leading to debates about religion in public life.

  4. Name one medical advance of the postwar era.
    Show answer

    Antibiotics, vaccines, organ transplants, or in vitro fertilization.

  5. Why were new medical technologies controversial?
    Show answer

    They raised moral questions about abortion, reproduction, genetics, and end of life that had no consensus.

  6. What caused the 2015 refugee crisis?
    Show answer

    War in Syria and other conflicts sent more than a million people to Europe.

Lesson 9.11 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.13

Globalization

Learning Objective N asks you to explain the causes and effects of globalization in Europe. The CED states that increased imports of U.S. technology and popular culture after World War II generated both enthusiasm and criticism; that new communication and transportation technologies multiplied connections across space and time, transforming daily life and contributing to the proliferation of ideas and to globalization; and that Green parties in Western and Central Europe challenged consumerism, urged sustainable development, and cautioned against globalization.

Required content · 9N

Learning objective.

  • 9N. Explain the technological and cultural causes and consequences of increasing European globalization in the period from 1914 to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.IV.C. Increased imports of U.S. technology and popular culture after World War II generated both enthusiasm and criticism.
  • 4.4.I.D. New communication and transportation technologies multiplied the connections across space and time, transforming daily life and contributing to the proliferation of ideas and to globalization.
  • 4.4.III.A. Green parties in Western and Central Europe challenged consumerism, urged sustainable development, and, by the late 20th century, cautioned against globalization.

American influence

After 1945, American products, films, music, fashion, and consumer goods spread through Europe, helped by the Marshall Plan and American military presence. Jazz, rock and roll, Hollywood films, blue jeans, and soft drinks became part of youth culture. The CED says this generated both enthusiasm and criticism.

  • Enthusiasm. Many Europeans, especially the young, welcomed American style as modern and free.
  • Criticism. Others, including some conservatives and leftists, feared "Americanization" would erode national and local cultures, or condemned consumerism, and French critics worried about the loss of the French language and cinema. Soviet bloc authorities attacked Western culture as decadent, though it spread there too through radio and smuggled records.

Technology and connection

New communication and transportation technologies changed life.

  • Communication. Television became common in the 1950s and 1960s, then satellites, personal computers, mobile phones, and the internet and the World Wide Web (invented at CERN in Europe in 1989 to 1991) multiplied connections across space and time.
  • Transportation. Jet airplanes, motorways, container shipping, and high-speed trains (France's TGV, 1981) made travel and trade cheaper and faster, and the Channel Tunnel (1994) linked Britain to France.
  • Economic ties. Multinational corporations and trade agreements, and in Europe the single market and the euro, linked national economies, and production moved to countries with cheaper labor.
  • Ideas. Information, music, and ideas, including human rights and democratic ideals, spread quickly, and played a part in the revolutions of 1989.

The CED describes these as contributing to the proliferation of ideas and to globalization.

Europe American culture Trade and the euro Television, internet Jets, tunnels, trains Green critics Connections that shaped Europe after 1945 Each link brought both enthusiasm and criticism
Figure 9.11. Globalization. Culture, trade, communication, and transport tied Europe to the world, while Green parties questioned consumerism and growth.

Green parties and critics of globalization

The CED notes that Green parties in Western and Central Europe challenged consumerism, urged sustainable development, and cautioned against globalization.

  • Environmental concerns. Pollution, acid rain, nuclear accidents such as Chernobyl (1986), and climate change led to environmental movements.
  • Green parties. West Germany's Green Party entered the Bundestag in 1983, and Green parties later formed in many countries, sometimes sharing in governments. They argued for renewable energy, limits on growth, and local economies.
  • Anti-globalization protests. Critics argued that globalization increased inequality, weakened local industries and workers, and gave power to large corporations.
Primary source · Consuming the world

Description of: A Western European advertising campaign of the 1950s promoting new household appliances such as washing machines and refrigerators as symbols of the modern, comfortable home, with images of a smiling housewife and the slogan of convenience and leisure.

Sourcing (HIPP). Advertisements were produced by companies to sell products, so the purpose is commercial and the audience was the new consumer class. They show the postwar ideal of a comfortable family life and the American influence on style and advertising. As evidence, they show how the economic miracle changed expectations (Lesson 9.1), but the ideal image does not tell us about the lives of the many families who could not afford such goods, nor about the work that women still did at home.

Source analysis · The consumer ideal

Claim. Advertisements of the 1950s promoted consumption as part of a modern way of life.

Evidence. They showed appliances as sources of comfort and leisure.

Reasoning. This supports the CED's statement about the growth of consumer culture, and the American influence on style. As commercial material, it shows an ideal and not general experience, so it should be combined with other evidence, such as the critics of consumerism.

Worked example · Effects of globalization

Question. Explain one way new technology increased globalization and one way people criticized it.

Model. Communication and transportation technologies such as television, jets, and later the internet connected people across the world and spread ideas, trade, and culture. Critics such as Green parties argued that consumerism and globalization harmed the environment and local economies, and called for sustainable development.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective N, give both sides: enthusiasm and criticism. Use the CED's three claims (American imports, communication and transportation technologies, Green parties) with named examples. Show cause and effect: technology led to connection, which led to the spread of ideas and, in turn, to a reaction.

Practice
  1. Give two examples of American influence on postwar Europe.
    Show answer

    Films, popular music such as rock and roll, jeans, and consumer goods.

  2. Why did some Europeans criticize Americanization?
    Show answer

    They feared it would erode national cultures and promote consumerism.

  3. Name two technologies that connected Europe to the world.
    Show answer

    Television, jet travel, satellites, computers, and the internet.

  4. What did Green parties argue?
    Show answer

    They challenged consumerism, urged sustainable development, and warned about globalization.

  5. Why did Chernobyl matter politically?
    Show answer

    The 1986 nuclear accident increased concern for the environment and strengthened Green movements.

  6. How did ideas spread to the Soviet bloc?
    Show answer

    Through radio, television, music, and smuggled goods despite censorship.

Lesson 9.12 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.14

Culture, arts, and demographic trends since 1945

Learning Objective O asks you to explain developments in thought, religion, the arts, consumer culture, and social movements in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. The CED lists several points: the effects of the world wars and depression undermined confidence in science and reason, giving impetus to existentialism and producing postmodernism; the Christian churches gave mixed responses to totalitarianism and communism, and the Catholic Church's Second Vatican Council redefined doctrine and practices; new movements in the arts shifted standards and satirized Western values; writers challenged conventions; mass production created a consumer culture; the baby boom followed recovery; and social movements and the revolts of 1968 challenged the order.

Required content · 9O

Learning objective.

  • 9O. Explain how and why European culture changed from the period following World War II to the present.

Historical developments.

  • 4.3.I.B. The effects of world war and economic depression undermined this confidence in science and human reason, giving impetus to existentialism and producing postmodernism in the post-1945 period.
  • 4.3.III.A. The challenges of totalitarianism and communism in central and eastern Europe brought mixed responses from the Christian churches.
  • 4.3.III.B. Reform in the Catholic Church found expression in the Second Vatican Council, which redefined the church’s doctrine and practices and started to redefine its relations with other religious communities.
  • 4.3.IV.A. New movements in the visual arts, architecture, and music radically shifted existing aesthetic standards, explored subconscious and subjective states, and satirized Western society and its values.
  • 4.3.IV.B. Throughout the century, a number of writers challenged traditional literary conventions, questioned Western values, and addressed controversial social and political issues.
  • 4.4.I.C. Mass production, new food technologies, and industrial efficiency increased disposable income and created a consumer culture in which greater domestic comforts such as electricity, indoor plumbing, plastics, and synthetic fibers became available.
  • 4.4.II.C. With economic recovery after World War II, the birth rate increased dramatically (the baby boom), often promoted by government policies.
  • 4.4.III.B. Various movements, including women’s movements, political and social movements, gay and lesbian movements, and others, worked for expanded civil rights, in some cases obtaining the goals they sought, and in others facing strong opposition.
  • 4.4.III.C. Intellectuals and youth reacted against perceived bourgeois materialism and decadence, most significantly with the revolts of 1968.

Ideas: existentialism and postmodernism

After the Holocaust and two world wars, many thinkers lost faith in the confidence in reason that had marked earlier periods.

  • Existentialism. Jean-Paul Sartre, Albert Camus, and Simone de Beauvoir argued that humans exist without a given purpose and must create meaning through free choices, bearing responsibility for them.
  • Postmodernism. After 1945, thinkers such as Michel Foucault and Jacques Derrida questioned the idea of objective truth and progress, and examined how power shapes knowledge and language.

Religion

The CED says the Christian churches gave mixed responses to totalitarianism and communism. Some church leaders cooperated with or accommodated dictatorships, others resisted, as did Dietrich Bonhoeffer in Germany, and in Poland the Catholic Church became a center of opposition to communism, supported by the election of Pope John Paul II (1978). In the Soviet bloc, churches were repressed.

The Second Vatican Council (1962 to 1965) was a major reform of the Catholic Church. It allowed worship in local languages instead of Latin, gave a larger role to lay people, encouraged dialogue with other Christians and with Jews and other religions, and affirmed religious freedom. Church attendance fell throughout Western Europe, and Europe became more secular.

Arts and literature

  • Visual arts and architecture. Abstract expressionism, pop art (which satirized consumer culture), conceptual art, and film new waves broke with older standards. Modernist architecture (Le Corbusier) built plain concrete and glass structures, and postmodern buildings later mixed styles.
  • Music. Atonal and experimental composers (Schoenberg, Stockhausen) challenged harmony, and popular music, including rock (the Beatles, from the 1960s), became a global youth culture.
  • Literature. Writers challenged traditional conventions and questioned Western values: George Orwell's 1984 (1949) warned of totalitarianism, Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot (1953) expressed absurdity, and Alexander Solzhenitsyn exposed the Soviet camps in The Gulag Archipelago, and others addressed colonialism, war, and gender.

Consumer culture and the baby boom

Mass production, new food technologies, and industrial efficiency raised disposable income and made electricity, indoor plumbing, plastics, and synthetic fibers common in homes, creating a consumer culture (Lesson 9.1). After World War II, the birth rate rose sharply, the baby boom, often encouraged by governments that wanted to rebuild the population, and the babies of this boom became the youth of the 1960s.

Social movements and 1968

The CED notes that women's, political and social, and gay and lesbian movements worked for expanded civil rights, sometimes winning and sometimes meeting strong opposition. Intellectuals and youth reacted against bourgeois materialism and decadence, most visibly in the revolts of 1968.

  • Paris, May 1968. Student protests against the university system and society spread to a general strike of about ten million workers and shook the government of Charles de Gaulle, which survived.
  • Elsewhere. Student protests took place in West Germany, Italy, and Britain, and in Czechoslovakia, the Prague Spring (Lesson 9.3), where reformers sought freedom.
  • Results. The revolts did not overthrow governments, but they changed attitudes toward authority, sexuality, and gender, and strengthened later movements for gay rights, the environment, and peace.
Ideas and faith Existentialism, Sartre Postmodernism, Foucault Vatican II, 1962-65 Secularization Arts and writing Pop art, abstraction Orwell, Beckett Solzhenitsyn Global rock music Society Baby boom Consumer culture Civil rights movements Protests of 1968 Ideas and society after 1945 Prosperity and doubt shaped culture side by side
Figure 9.12. Culture since 1945. New philosophy, new art, and a youth generation shaped by prosperity challenged older authority and values.
Primary source · Slogans of a generation

Description of: Graffiti slogans from the Paris student revolt of May 1968, collected in later books, such as "Be realistic, demand the impossible" and "It is forbidden to forbid," which expressed rebellion against authority and conformity.

Sourcing (HIPP). The slogans were written anonymously on walls by students and demonstrators, so they show the mood of protest more than a program. Because they were collected after the event, historians must consider the selection and which slogans were remembered. They reflect the CED's description of youth reacting against bourgeois materialism, but they cannot show what all of the participants, who included workers and others with different aims, believed.

Source analysis · Protest and values

Claim. The 1968 slogans express youth rebellion against authority and conformity.

Evidence. Slogans such as "It is forbidden to forbid" rejected rules and traditional authority.

Reasoning. They illustrate the CED's point that intellectuals and youth reacted against materialism and the existing order in the revolts of 1968. As collected slogans, they show the spirit of the protest but not the wide range of goals or the limited political results.

Worked example · Change in ideas

Question. Explain one way the world wars affected European thought and one way the Catholic Church changed after 1945.

Model. The wars and the depression undermined confidence in science and human reason, which gave rise to existentialism, which held that people must create meaning for themselves, and later to postmodernism. The Catholic Church changed through the Second Vatican Council (1962 to 1965), which allowed worship in local languages, gave a greater role to lay people, and began a new dialogue with other religions.

Exam focus

For Learning Objective O, organize by category (ideas, religion, arts and literature, consumer culture, demography, social movements) and give a named example for each, using the CED's terms (existentialism, postmodernism, Vatican II, baby boom, 1968). Show causes as well as descriptions, for example the wars leading to existentialism and prosperity leading to consumer culture.

Practice
  1. What is existentialism?
    Show answer

    A philosophy stressing that people have no given purpose and must create meaning through free choices, associated with Sartre.

  2. What did the Second Vatican Council change?
    Show answer

    It allowed local languages in worship, expanded the role of lay people, and encouraged dialogue with other religions.

  3. What was the baby boom?
    Show answer

    The sharp rise in births after World War II, often encouraged by governments.

  4. What did pop art satirize?
    Show answer

    Consumer culture and the values of Western society.

  5. What were the revolts of 1968?
    Show answer

    Student and worker protests, especially in Paris, against authority and materialism.

  6. Name a writer who challenged totalitarianism.
    Show answer

    George Orwell, with 1984, or Alexander Solzhenitsyn, with The Gulag Archipelago.

Lesson 9.13 · Unit 9 · CED topic 9.15

Continuity and change since 1945

The last topic of the course practices continuity and change over time across the whole period from 1450 to the present. Learning Objective P asks you to explain continuities and changes in European history since 1945, and to relate them to earlier periods. The skill is the same as in Unit 8: choose a theme, say what changed, say what stayed the same, and judge the result with dated evidence.

Required content · 9P

Learning objective.

  • 9P. Explain how the challenges of the 20th century influenced what it means to be European.

Reasoning process. Continuity and change. The exam asks you to apply it to the developments of the whole unit, so this lesson practices it on the unit's central evidence.

Themes since 1945

ThemeChangeContinuity
Europe's place in the worldEmpires ended through decolonization; Europe lost its global power; the Cold War divided the continent and then endedEurope remained wealthy and influential, with ties to former colonies
PoliticsDemocracy expanded across Western Europe and then Eastern Europe after 1989; integration through the EUNationalism persisted, shown in the Balkans, Brexit, and populist parties
EconomyWelfare states, the "economic miracle," the shift to capitalism in the East, the euroIndustrial capitalism and the competition for markets; debate over the state's role
SocietyGreater rights for women, mass immigration, secularization, consumer cultureInequalities of class, gender, and ethnicity, and religious identity
Ideas and cultureExistentialism, postmodernism, mass culture, globalizationDebates about reason, tradition, and progress

Connections across the whole course

A strong answer can reach back to earlier units.

  • Nationalism grew from the French Revolution (Unit 5), shaped unification (Unit 7), contributed to the wars of the twentieth century, and reappeared in Yugoslavia and Brexit.
  • The state and the economy. The mercantilist state (Unit 3) gave way to liberalism (Unit 6), to state intervention in the world wars, and to the welfare state and then debate over it.
  • Empire. The overseas empires built from 1450 (Unit 1) were extended in the nineteenth century (Unit 7) and dismantled after 1945.
  • Rights. Ideas of rights from the Enlightenment (Unit 4) expanded in the twentieth century to include women's rights, minority and migrant rights, and human rights after the Holocaust.
  • Science and belief. The Scientific Revolution (Unit 4) produced confidence in reason, which was shaken by the world wars but remains central.
Theme Change Continuity Europe's role Empires ended; Cold War, then its end Wealth and influence remained Politics Integration; democracy in the East Nationalism and sovereignty debates Economy Welfare states; capitalism in the East Industry, markets, debate on the state Society Women's rights; migration; secular life Inequalities of class, gender, ethnicity
Figure 9.13. Continuity and change. A strong judgment names both what changed and what persisted for each theme.

Making an argument

  1. Choose a theme and a period. For example, "Europe's role in the world, 1945 to the present."
  2. Give specific evidence of change with dates, such as decolonization (1947 to 1960s) and the end of the Cold War (1989 to 1991).
  3. Give specific evidence of continuity, such as the persistence of nationalism and European economic strength.
  4. Make a judgment. Argue whether change or continuity was stronger and explain the reasons, recognizing the limits of your evidence.
Primary source · Reading the whole sweep

Description of: A historian's survey of Europe since 1945 that argues that the continent moved from a divided, war-torn region to a more integrated and prosperous one, but that old questions about nationalism, sovereignty, and identity continued to shape its politics.

Sourcing (HIPP). As a secondary source written with hindsight, it offers an interpretation and not raw evidence, and its purpose is to explain the period to students and general readers. The claim that both change and continuity matter is the kind of thesis you are asked to build and test against evidence, such as the EU's growth and Brexit. Other historians might emphasize different turning points, such as 1945, 1989, or 2008.

Source analysis · Interpretation

Claim. The historian argues that postwar Europe combined major change with the persistence of older issues.

Evidence. Integration and prosperity are changes, while debates about nationalism and sovereignty persisted.

Reasoning. This fits the CED's emphasis on both integration and the continuing balance of sovereignty and membership. To evaluate the claim, a student would test it with examples such as the EU, the Balkan wars, and Brexit.

Worked example · Continuity and change

Question. Explain one continuity and one change in Europe's political life from 1945 to the present.

Model. One change was the growth of integration, from the Coal and Steel Community in 1951 to the European Union, which tied states together as never before. One continuity was nationalism, which remained powerful, as shown by the wars in Yugoslavia and by Britain's decision to leave the EU in 2016.

Exam focus

Learning Objective P asks for continuity and change with a judgment. Use specific dates, give both sides, and make connections to earlier periods. Avoid the claim that the end of the Cold War "ended history"; show that older themes such as nationalism, inequality, and sovereignty continued.

Practice
  1. Name one change in Europe since 1945.
    Show answer

    Decolonization, the end of the Cold War, the growth of the EU, or expanded rights for women.

  2. Name one continuity.
    Show answer

    Nationalism, inequality, or debates over the state's role in the economy.

  3. How does nationalism connect different periods?
    Show answer

    It grew from the French Revolution, drove unification and the world wars, and reappeared in the Balkans and in Brexit.

  4. How did the idea of rights change over the course?
    Show answer

    From Enlightenment natural rights to women's suffrage, human rights after the Holocaust, and migrant and minority rights.

  5. Give a turning point and explain it.
    Show answer

    1989 to 1991, when communism fell and the Cold War ended, reshaping the political map and allowing EU enlargement.

  6. How can you make a strong judgment?
    Show answer

    State a claim about whether change or continuity was greater and support it with dated evidence and limits.

Unit 9 review · 10 multiple-choice · 2 short-answer

Unit 9 review: Cold War and Contemporary Europe, c. 1914–present

Ten questions on reconstruction and the Cold War division, Western welfare states and integration, 1989 and the fall of communism, and contemporary Europe, plus two short-answer questions on division and reunion.

Multiple choice

  1. Source: President Harry S. Truman, address to Congress, March 1947, and Secretary of State George C. Marshall, Harvard address, June 1947.

    Truman: "I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures." Marshall: "Our policy is directed not against any country or doctrine but against hunger, poverty, desperation and chaos."

    The difference in framing between the two speeches is best explained by

    Correct. Truman needed a reluctant Congress to fund commitments, so he offered a sweeping principle; Marshall framed aid as economic and non-ideological so the Soviet Union could apply and be seen to refuse.

    Both served the same administration and the same containment policy; the registers differ, not the strategy.

    Marshall spoke three months after Truman, with the division of Europe already well advanced.

    It was a public address to a joint session of Congress, deliberately publicized.

  2. The concept of a "security dilemma" applied to the early Cold War means that

    Both possessed formidable forces; the problem was interpretation of intent, not incapacity.

    Correct. Soviet buffer states looked like expansion to the west, and American economic reconstruction looked like encirclement to Moscow, so defensive steps produced escalation without either side needing hostile designs.

    Yalta produced vague commitments to free elections rather than an explicit division, and the disagreement over what had been agreed was itself a source of conflict.

    Large conventional forces remained central throughout, and NATO and the Warsaw Pact were built around them.

  3. The Soviet decision to forbid its satellites from accepting Marshall aid had the effect of

    Correct. Refusal drew the economic line that the political division then followed, and the gap in living standards it helped create became visible evidence against the eastern system.

    The program went ahead and delivered roughly thirteen billion dollars to western Europe between 1948 and 1952.

    Eastern economies recovered more slowly and were reoriented toward Soviet needs, falling further behind the west.

    NATO was founded in 1949 explicitly as a defensive alliance against the Soviet Union, which formed the Warsaw Pact in response.

  4. Description of: the Helsinki Final Act, 1975.

    Affirms the inviolability of existing European frontiers, sovereign equality, and non-intervention; provides for economic, scientific, and environmental cooperation; and commits signatories to respect human rights and fundamental freedoms and to facilitate contacts and the freer movement of people and information. All thirty-five participating states signed, including the Soviet Union.

    The human-rights provisions proved significant chiefly because

    No enforcement mechanism existed, which is precisely why Soviet negotiators accepted the clauses.

    Correct. Monitoring groups formed across the bloc, and demands framed as compliance with a treaty their governments had signed could no longer be dismissed as foreign interference.

    The Act contained no such requirement; the Wall opened in 1989, fourteen years later.

    The Soviet Union signed the Final Act in full, treating the human-rights section as a tolerable price for recognition of post-war borders.

  5. The Suez crisis of 1956 is most significant in European history because it

    The canal was built in the nineteenth century; 1956 concerned its nationalization by Nasser and the invasion that followed.

    Correct. American financial pressure forced the two former great powers to abandon the operation, showing publicly that independent European great-power action had ended.

    The EEC was created by the Treaty of Rome in 1957, arising from the coal and steel community rather than from Suez, though the crisis reinforced integrationist arguments.

    The Soviet Union threatened intervention rhetorically but did not station troops in Egypt as a result.

  6. Description of: the Schuman Declaration, May 1950.

    Proposes placing all French and German coal and steel production under a common High Authority, open to other European countries. States that Europe will not be made all at once but through concrete achievements that first create a solidarity in fact, and that war between France and Germany should become not merely unthinkable but materially impossible.

    The declaration indicates that European integration began principally as

    Correct. The stated aim is to make Franco-German war materially impossible by removing separate national control of the industries armaments depend on.

    The declaration explicitly rejects making Europe all at once or by a single plan, proposing one sector and concrete steps instead.

    The proposal came from the French foreign minister. American policy encouraged European cooperation but did not author this initiative.

    The declaration concerns coal, steel, and the prevention of war, not cultural identity.

  7. Western European welfare states established after 1945 rested on the principle that

    The post-war settlement moved decisively from charitable and poor-law provision to universal entitlement.

    Correct. Health provision, unemployment and sickness insurance, pensions, family allowances, and expanded education were built as citizen entitlements, of which the British NHS of 1948 was the most visible example.

    Coverage was extended broadly across the population rather than restricted to particular industries.

    These systems were funded by taxation and compulsory contributions, not by voluntary giving.

  8. The most decisive factor in the collapse of eastern European communist regimes in 1989 was

    Correct. Soviet troops had restored communist rule in Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968; withdrawing that guarantee changed the calculation for oppositions and party leaderships simultaneously.

    NATO did not intervene. The revolutions were overwhelmingly internal and largely peaceful.

    Leadership changes occurred but followed from the crisis rather than causing the simultaneous collapse across several states.

    Free elections were conceded under pressure from mass mobilization, not initiated jointly by the regimes.

  9. The wars accompanying Yugoslavia's breakup differed from the revolutions of 1989 elsewhere in eastern Europe chiefly because the conflict was

    That describes Poland or Czechoslovakia. In Yugoslavia the opposition was not unified but divided along national lines.

    Correct. Elsewhere an unpopular system depended on Soviet backing; in Yugoslavia rival national communities claimed the same territory, so removing outside support resolved nothing.

    External powers became involved, but the conflict originated in competing claims among Yugoslavia's own peoples.

    The breakup produced a decade of war including the Srebrenica massacre in 1995 and the Kosovo conflict in 1999.

  10. Description of: European demographic and religious-practice data, c. 1960–2020.

    Total fertility in western European states falls from above the replacement level of about 2.1 in the early 1960s to figures between roughly 1.3 and 1.9 by the 2000s. Life expectancy rises by more than a decade. Survey series on religious attendance show weekly participation falling from large majorities in several Catholic countries in the 1960s to small minorities by the 2010s.

    A historian should treat which of these findings with the greatest caution, and why?

    Birth registration was compulsory and comprehensive across western Europe, making fertility data highly reliable.

    Correct. Attendance figures come from surveys and depend on what respondents report, which historically overstates participation because people report what they consider respectable.

    Life expectancy is calculated from registered deaths by age, which is observational rather than projected.

    Civil registration in this period is among the most reliable historical data available; the caution applies specifically to survey-based measures.

Short answer

  1. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE reason the wartime alliance broke down after 1945.
    2. Briefly explain ONE way the Cold War affected western European states.
    3. Briefly explain ONE reason communist regimes in eastern Europe collapsed in 1989.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: Soviet installation of friendly governments against the Yalta promise of free elections; western reconstruction of Germany; mutual misreading of defensive measures; disputes over reparations and occupation policy. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: American security guarantees allowing lower defense spending and funding for welfare states; Marshall aid financing recovery; NATO membership and strategic subordination shown at Suez; the external umbrella making Franco-German integration possible. Must explain the effect.
    • (c) Accept: Gorbachev's refusal to intervene militarily; economic stagnation and visible comparison with western living standards; Solidarity's survival in Poland; Helsinki-based dissident monitoring. Must explain why it was decisive.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Each side read the other's security measures as aggression. The Soviet Union installed friendly governments across eastern Europe to create a buffer against future invasion, having been invaded twice through that region, but the western powers saw this as a violation of the Yalta commitment to free elections and as evidence of expansionist intent.

    (b) American security guarantees allowed western European states to spend on reconstruction rather than on defending themselves against one another. States that had fought three wars in seventy years could pool coal and steel from 1950 because the external umbrella removed the security competition that had previously made Franco-German cooperation impossible.

    (c) Gorbachev made clear that Soviet forces would not be used to keep the satellite governments in power. Since Soviet intervention had restored communist rule in Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968, withdrawing that guarantee left regimes with little popular support facing mass demonstrations they could not suppress alone.

  2. Answer (a), (b), and (c).

    1. Briefly describe ONE reason western European states pursued economic integration after 1950.
    2. Briefly explain ONE reason integration encountered greater difficulty after about 2000.
    3. Briefly explain ONE major demographic or social challenge facing Europe in the twenty-first century.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: preventing another Franco-German war by pooling coal and steel; rebuilding trade and prosperity; strengthening western Europe against the Soviet bloc; securing German recovery without German rearmament. Must be specific.
    • (b) Accept: the eurozone debt crisis exposing a shared currency without shared fiscal policy; slower growth distributing real costs rather than shared gains; enlargement increasing diversity of interests; migration disputes; Brexit. Must explain the difficulty.
    • (c) Accept: below-replacement fertility with rising longevity, straining pensions and health systems; dependence on immigration for labor combined with political conflict over integration and asylum; regional depopulation. Must explain the consequence.
    Show a 3/3 response

    (a) Integration was designed to make another Franco-German war impossible. The Schuman Declaration of 1950 proposed pooling French and German coal and steel under a common authority so that neither state would separately control the industries needed for armaments, turning a security guarantee into an economic institution.

    (b) Integration had been carried for decades by rapid growth that produced winners without obvious losers. When the eurozone debt crisis after 2009 exposed the difficulty of a shared currency without shared fiscal policy, member states faced real and unequally distributed costs, and the permissive consensus behind the project broke down: contributing to the British vote to leave in 2016.

    (c) Birth rates across Europe have fallen below replacement while life expectancy has risen, producing aging and in some countries shrinking populations. This strains pension and health systems funded by taxes on a shrinking workforce and creates demand for immigrant labor, which has itself become a central political conflict over integration and national identity.

DBQ 1 · Unit 2 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which the Protestant Reformation changed the relationship between religious and secular authority in the period 1517–1648.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis that says how much the relationship changed and in what respects, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the late medieval church and its entanglement with secular rulers before 1517, or the state system that followed 1648. Use the content of at least four documents to support your argument, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how the author's point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant to your argument. Finally, show complexity: qualify your claim, weigh one region or confession against another, or explain how the same reformation produced radically different settlements in different places.

Document 1

Source: Martin Luther, Ninety-Five Theses, Wittenberg, 1517, theses 82 and 86.

Why does not the pope empty purgatory for the sake of holy love and the dire need of the souls that are there? … Why does not the pope, whose wealth today is greater than the wealth of the richest Crassus, build the basilica of St. Peter with his own money rather than with the money of poor believers?

Document 2

Description of: Martin Luther, On Secular Authority, 1523, written after the Diet of Worms while Luther was under imperial ban and sheltered by the Elector of Saxony.

Luther argues that God has ordained two governments. The spiritual government works inwardly through the Word and produces genuine Christians, who need no law to compel them. The temporal government carries the sword to restrain the wicked and preserve outward peace, and Christians owe it obedience in all worldly matters. But he insists the sword has no authority over the soul: no prince can command what a subject must believe, and a ruler who orders subjects to hold a doctrine exceeds his office and is not to be obeyed in that respect.

Document 3

Description of: the Schleitheim Confession, adopted by Swiss Anabaptists, 1527.

The articles require believers' baptism on confession of faith, separation from what the signers call the abominations of the world, and refusal of the oath. On the sword, they hold that it is ordained by God outside the perfection of Christ, to punish the wicked and guard the good, but that it has no place within the congregation, which uses only the ban. They conclude that a Christian may not serve as a magistrate, since the office requires the exercise of force that Christ forbade to his followers.

Document 4

Description of: John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, on civil government, in the editions published from Geneva.

Calvin holds civil government to be ordained by God and necessary in this life, and he calls magistrates ministers of divine justice whose office is honorable rather than merely tolerated. He assigns the magistrate a duty to maintain true religion and suppress blasphemy and idolatry, so the civil power carries a religious charge. He nevertheless distinguishes spiritual from civil jurisdiction, and adds that where lesser magistrates exist to restrain a tyrant, they may lawfully do so: a qualification later Calvinists in France, Scotland, and the Netherlands would use to justify armed resistance.

Document 5

Source: Lucas Cranach the Elder and Philipp Melanchthon, Passional Christi und Antichristi, woodcut pamphlet, Wittenberg, 1521.

Image: described

The pamphlet pairs facing woodcuts. On one page Christ, barefoot and plainly dressed, washes the feet of his disciples in a bare room. On the facing page the pope, in tiara and full vestments, sits enthroned beneath a canopy while kneeling princes and a crowned emperor kiss his foot; attendants with staves hold back the crowd, and bags of coin are visible at the foot of the dais. Each pair carries a short caption beneath.

Document 6

Description of: the Peace of Augsburg, agreed in the imperial diet, 1555.

The settlement provides that each prince and each free imperial city may establish either the Catholic faith or the Augsburg Confession within its own territory, and that subjects who will not conform may sell their property and emigrate. Ecclesiastical princes who convert are required to surrender their lands and offices. Calvinists and Anabaptists receive no recognition of any kind. The agreement is framed as a measure for the peace of the empire and says nothing about which confession is true.

Document 7

Description of: the treaties of the Peace of Westphalia, Münster and Osnabrück, 1648.

The treaties extend the Augsburg principle to include Calvinism, fix a reference year for determining which confession each territory may practice, and grant limited private worship to dissenting minorities. They confirm the independence of the Dutch Republic and the Swiss Confederation, and recognize the German princes' authority over their own territories including the right to make alliances. No papal representative was permitted to shape the terms, and Pope Innocent X denounced the settlement as null and void.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization that works: describe how church and secular power were already entangled before 1517; bishops who were also territorial princes, monarchs who controlled church appointments in their realms, the papacy as an Italian territorial ruler, and the conciliar disputes and earlier reform movements of Wycliffe and Hus. Alternatively, set up the Habsburg imperial claim that the Reformation fractured. Two or three sentences tied to the question of how the relationship changed.
  • Document groupings that support an argument: the attack on papal jurisdiction and its finances (Docs 1 and 5); the theoretical redrawing of the two authorities (Docs 2, 3, and 4, which disagree sharply with one another and should be set against each other rather than lumped together); and the political settlements that turned theory into law (Docs 6 and 7). Group by what the documents do, never walk through them in order.
  • Evidence beyond the documents that fits: Henry VIII's Act of Supremacy (1534) making the monarch head of the English church; the dissolution of the monasteries and the transfer of church land to the crown and gentry; the Council of Trent (1545–1563) reasserting papal authority; Geneva's consistory supervising conduct; the Diet of Worms (1521) and Frederick the Wise's protection of an imperial outlaw; the Edict of Nantes (1598) and its revocation in 1685; Richelieu's Catholic France fighting the Catholic Habsburgs. Describe the evidence and use it, do not merely name it.
  • Sourcing moves worth making: Doc 1 was written in Latin for academic disputation, so its audience was a few dozen theologians, the radicalism came from printers who translated it for a lay public Luther had not addressed. Doc 2 was written by a man under imperial ban living under a prince's protection, which explains why it both commands obedience to secular rulers and denies them authority over belief. Doc 5 is a cheap illustrated pamphlet aimed at people who could not read Latin and perhaps could not read at all, which is evidence about how the argument was popularized. Doc 6's silence on which confession is true is itself the point: the settlement was political because a theological settlement was impossible.
  • A complexity path: argue that the Reformation transferred religious authority to secular rulers far more than it separated the two (Augsburg and Westphalia made princes the arbiters of confession, which is the opposite of liberty of conscience), while noting that the Anabaptist position in Doc 3 and Luther's own limit in Doc 2 planted a principle that no sixteenth-century state accepted. Or weigh the German settlement against England, where the crown simply absorbed the church, and against the Dutch Republic, where a comparatively tolerant order emerged from revolt.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Religious and secular authority were already thoroughly entangled before Luther. German bishops ruled territories as princes of the empire, the pope governed the Papal States as a temporal sovereign, and monarchs in France and Spain had negotiated substantial control over appointments within their kingdoms. Earlier challenges by Wycliffe and Hus had been suppressed because no ruler had a durable interest in protecting them. Thesis The Reformation transformed this relationship fundamentally, but not in the direction its boldest theorists imagined: rather than separating the two powers, it collapsed religious authority into the hands of secular rulers, who by 1648 determined the confession of their own territories. A genuine principle of conscience was articulated in these decades, but it was articulated by those with no power and rejected by every state that mattered.

Doc evidence The first blow was against papal jurisdiction itself. Doc 1 attacks the pope's claim over purgatory and, more damagingly, his finances, asking why a man richer than Crassus builds his basilica with the money of poor believers. Sourcing Luther wrote these in Latin for academic disputation, and the theses are hedged and technical; the radical effect came from printers who translated them for a lay readership he had never addressed, which is why a scholarly quarrel became a public assault on Rome within months. Doc 5 shows that popularization at work, pairing a barefoot Christ washing feet against an enthroned pope receiving the kisses of kneeling princes. Sourcing Its purpose is propaganda for people who read no Latin and perhaps could not read at all, and the choice to show an emperor kneeling identifies precisely what was at stake: whether spiritual authority stood above temporal.

Doc evidence Reformers then had to say what should replace papal jurisdiction, and they did not agree. Doc 2 divides the world into two governments and denies the prince any authority over the soul. Doc 3 goes much further, holding that the sword lies outside the perfection of Christ and that a true Christian cannot serve as a magistrate at all. Doc 4 moves in the opposite direction, making the magistrate a minister of divine justice charged with suppressing idolatry: a religious duty laid on the civil power. Outside evidence Geneva showed what that meant in practice: a consistory of pastors and elders supervised conduct, and Servetus was executed for heresy in 1553. Sourcing Doc 2's shape is explained by Luther's situation: an imperial outlaw sheltered by the Elector of Saxony, needing to command obedience to princes while denying them authority over belief, because his survival depended on the first and his movement on the second.

Doc evidence The settlements resolved the disagreement by giving the question to rulers. Doc 6 lets each prince and free city establish Catholicism or the Augsburg Confession and offers dissenting subjects only the right to sell up and leave; Calvinists and Anabaptists receive nothing. Doc 7 extends the same logic to Calvinism a century later and confirms the princes' authority over their territories, with no papal voice in the terms. Outside evidence England had reached the same destination by a different road: the Act of Supremacy of 1534 made the monarch head of the church for dynastic reasons, and the dissolution of the monasteries transferred vast church lands to the crown and the gentry who bought them.

Complexity The change was therefore enormous but nearly the reverse of religious liberty. Augsburg and Westphalia are usually cited as milestones of toleration, yet both assigned belief to princes and left subjects the choice of conformity or emigration; what they tolerated was territorial diversity, not individual conscience. Meanwhile the position that came closest to modern separation, Doc 3's refusal of the magistracy, was held by a group persecuted by Catholics and magisterial Protestants alike. The decisive evidence that authority had been secularized is that by the 1630s Catholic France under Richelieu was subsidizing Protestant Sweden against the Catholic Habsburgs: once princes controlled confession, confession stopped controlling princes.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The final two sentences of the introduction claim fundamental change in a specific direction, religious authority collapsing into secular hands rather than separating from it, and add the qualification that a conscience principle existed but held no power. That is a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the body follows.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening sentences describe the pre-1517 entanglement of the two authorities (prince-bishops, the papacy as territorial sovereign, royal control of appointments), and note why Wycliffe and Hus failed. Several sentences of relevant context, not a passing phrase.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): Six documents are used for their content and grouped by function (1 and 5 on the assault on papal jurisdiction, 2, 3, and 4 on the competing replacements, 6 and 7 on the settlements) with each described accurately and deployed to support the argument rather than summarized in turn.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Two pieces appear and are described, not merely named: Geneva's consistory and the execution of Servetus in 1553, and the English Act of Supremacy of 1534 with the dissolution of the monasteries.
  • Sourcing (1): Three sourcing moves are made: Doc 1's Latin academic audience against its printed lay reception, Doc 5's purpose as propaganda for the illiterate, and Doc 2's historical situation as the work of an outlaw dependent on a prince. Each explains why the feature matters for the argument.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph qualifies the standard reading of Augsburg and Westphalia as toleration milestones, notes that the most modern-sounding position was held by the least powerful group, and closes with Richelieu as evidence that the causal arrow had reversed. The qualification is sustained rather than a single phrase.

DBQ 2 · Unit 4 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which Enlightenment thought challenged existing social and political hierarchies in the eighteenth century.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how far Enlightenment thought challenged existing hierarchies, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the society of orders and privilege the philosophes inherited, or the revolutionary decade that followed. Use the content of at least four documents, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant. Finally, show complexity: distinguish between hierarchies that were challenged and those that were not, or between what was argued and what was actually changed.

Document 1

Source: John Locke, Second Treatise of Government, published anonymously in England, 1689.

The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one … that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions. … The great and chief end, therefore, of men's uniting into commonwealths, and putting themselves under government, is the preservation of their property.

Document 2

Description of: Montesquieu, The Spirit of the Laws, 1748, written by a nobleman of the robe who had held office in the Parlement of Bordeaux.

Montesquieu argues that political liberty requires that legislative, executive, and judicial powers not be united in the same hands, and praises the English constitution as an example. He holds that laws should suit the climate, customs, and circumstances of each people rather than follow a single universal model. He also defends the intermediate bodies (nobility, clergy, and the parlements) as necessary barriers between the monarch and his subjects, arguing that removing them opens the way to despotism.

Document 3

Source: Jean-Jacques Rousseau, The Social Contract, 1762.

Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains. One who believes himself the master of others is nonetheless a greater slave than they. … Since no man has any natural authority over his fellows, and since force alone bestows no right, all legitimate authority among men must be based on covenants.

Document 4

Description of: Denis Diderot and Jean le Rond d'Alembert, the Encyclopédie, published in France in twenty-eight volumes, 1751–1772.

The work sets out to gather and order all human knowledge, and treats the mechanical arts with the same seriousness as theology and philosophy: hundreds of detailed engraved plates show the tools and procedures of glassmakers, printers, weavers, and cutlers. Articles apply critical scrutiny to received authority, sometimes obliquely, using cross-references to place a skeptical remark where the censor was less likely to look. The project was suppressed by royal decree, condemned by the church, and continued with intermittent official connivance.

Document 5

Source: Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, London, 1792.

Taught from their infancy that beauty is woman's sceptre, the mind shapes itself to the body, and, roaming round its gilt cage, only seeks to adorn its prison. … I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves.

Document 6

Source: a painting of a Parisian salon, French school, mid-eighteenth century.

Image: described

A well-lit drawing room with paneled walls and a marble chimneypiece. Some twenty figures are arranged in a loose oval. A woman is seated at the center in a wide silk gown, turned toward the company and evidently directing the conversation; beside her a man reads aloud from a bound manuscript. The listeners include men in the plain dark coats of writers and men in the embroidered coats and swords of the nobility, seated together without any visible order of rank. A bust of a classical author stands on a pedestal at the side.

Document 7

Description of: the Patent of Toleration issued by Emperor Joseph II for the Habsburg lands, 1781.

The patent grants Lutherans, Calvinists, and Orthodox Christians private worship, the right to build houses of prayer without bells, towers, or street entrances, and admission to property ownership, trades, academic degrees, and public office. Catholicism remains the state religion with sole right of public worship and processions. Separate provisions extended over the following years eased restrictions on Jewish subjects while requiring German-language schooling and the adoption of fixed surnames. The measures were issued by decree, without consultation of the estates.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization that works: describe the society of orders the philosophes inherited (legal privilege for nobility and clergy, tax exemptions, venal offices, guild restrictions, censorship, established churches, serfdom east of the Elbe), or set up the Scientific Revolution's establishment of reason and observation as the test of claims, which the Enlightenment extended to society. Two or three sentences tied to the question.
  • Document groupings that support an argument: the theoretical challenge to political hierarchy (Docs 1 and 3); challenges to intellectual and social hierarchy (Docs 4 and 6); hierarchies barely touched or defended (Docs 2 and 5; Montesquieu defending noble intermediate bodies, Wollstonecraft naming what the movement had left alone); and reform from above that changed policy without changing power (Doc 7). Group by function, not by order.
  • Evidence beyond the documents that fits: Beccaria's argument against torture and capital punishment (1764) and its adoption by several rulers; Adam Smith's attack on mercantilist restriction (1776); Voltaire's campaigns over the Calas case; the partitions of Poland in 1772, 1793, and 1795 by three self-described enlightened rulers; Joseph II's abolition of serfdom and its reversal after 1790; the Atlantic slave trade reaching its peak in the same decades; Catherine the Great's Instruction of 1767 followed by retrenchment after Pugachev. Describe and use the evidence.
  • Sourcing moves worth making: Doc 1 was published anonymously immediately after the Glorious Revolution, which makes it a justification of a king's removal before it is a timeless theory, and its emphasis on property indicates whose rights were principally in view. Doc 2's author was a nobleman of the robe with an office in a parlement, which explains why his defense of liberty takes the form of defending the very corporate privileges other philosophes attacked. Doc 5's disclaimer that she seeks no power over men measures how narrow the space for the argument was even in 1792. Doc 7 was issued by decree without consulting the estates, so an act of toleration is simultaneously an assertion of absolute authority.
  • A complexity path: argue that the Enlightenment's method was more radical than its conclusions, the premise that every institution must justify itself by reason admitted no exceptions even though most philosophes wanted reform rather than revolution and assumed rights belonged to propertied men. Or weigh the hierarchies that were successfully attacked (religious uniformity, judicial cruelty, censorship, guild restriction) against those that were not (gender, slavery, serfdom in the east, property qualification), and explain why the line fell where it did.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Eighteenth-century Europe was organized as a society of orders in which law itself was unequal: nobility and clergy held tax exemptions and separate courts, offices were bought and inherited, guilds controlled entry to trades, censors licensed books, and serfdom bound most of the rural population east of the Elbe. The Scientific Revolution had established that claims about nature must answer to evidence rather than authority, and the Enlightenment's central move was to apply that standard to institutions. Thesis Enlightenment thought challenged those hierarchies profoundly at the level of method and selectively at the level of program: it made every arrangement answerable to reason, which no privilege could survive indefinitely, but the writers themselves attacked religious, legal, and intellectual hierarchy far more readily than hierarchies of gender, race, or property, and rulers adopted only the reforms that strengthened the state.

Doc evidence The challenge to political hierarchy was genuine and structural. Doc 1 grounds government in a contract to preserve natural rights and makes its legitimacy conditional on performance, which denies outright the divine-right claim that obedience is owed unconditionally. Doc 3 pushes further, insisting that no one has natural authority over another and that force confers no right, so every existing hierarchy must show a covenant or stand condemned. Sourcing Doc 1's timing matters: it appeared anonymously in 1689, immediately after a king had been removed, which makes it a justification of an accomplished fact before it is an abstract theory, and its repeated emphasis on property suggests whose rights the author principally had in view.

Doc evidence Intellectual and social hierarchies were attacked by method as much as by argument. Doc 4 places the procedures of glassmakers and weavers beside theology in the same alphabetical order, which implicitly denies that some knowledge is noble and some is base, and it evades censorship through cross-references: the suppression and continued publication together showing an authority that could harass the project but not stop it. Doc 6 shows the same leveling socially: writers in plain coats and nobles with swords sit together in no visible order of rank, with a woman directing the conversation. Outside evidence The practical results were real. Beccaria's argument in 1764 that punishment should deter rather than avenge helped persuade rulers including Frederick II to abolish judicial torture, and Adam Smith's attack on mercantilist restriction in 1776 supplied the case against guild and monopoly privilege.

Doc evidence Yet the documents also mark the limits. Doc 2 defends the nobility, clergy, and parlements as necessary barriers against despotism: a defense of corporate privilege written in the vocabulary of liberty. Sourcing Its author was a nobleman of the robe holding office in a parlement, so the argument protects the institution he belonged to, which is precisely why other philosophes found him insufficiently radical. Doc 5 names the hierarchy almost nobody had touched, arguing that women appear frivolous because they are educated to be so: Locke's premise about the formation of character turned on the one group it had never been applied to. Sourcing Her insistence that she seeks no power over men is a concession made to keep skeptical readers listening, and it measures how narrow the space for the argument remained even at the height of rights talk in 1792.

Complexity Doc 7 captures the whole ambiguity. Joseph II's patent granted Protestants and Orthodox worship, property, trades, and office, a substantial breach in confessional hierarchy, while preserving Catholicism's monopoly of public worship and, crucially, arriving by decree without consulting the estates. Toleration was thus delivered by an act of unrestrained absolutism, and reforms that touched the nobility fared very differently: Joseph's abolition of serfdom was largely reversed after his death in 1790. Outside evidence The same three rulers most identified with enlightened government partitioned Poland out of existence between 1772 and 1795, and the Atlantic slave trade reached its peak in these decades. The method proved more subversive than its practitioners: once privilege had to argue for itself, the burden of proof had permanently shifted, which is why the same texts served cautious reformers in the 1760s and revolutionaries thirty years later.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction's final sentence distinguishes the level of method from the level of program and says which hierarchies were attacked and which were not: a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the essay sustains.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the society of orders in concrete terms (tax exemption, venal office, guilds, censorship, serfdom), and connects the Scientific Revolution's standard of evidence to the Enlightenment's project. Several sentences, not a phrase.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): Six documents are used for their content and grouped by function (1 and 3 on political hierarchy, 4 and 6 on intellectual and social leveling, 2 and 5 on the limits, 7 on reform from above) each described accurately and turned to the argument.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Beccaria on punishment and Adam Smith on mercantilist restriction are described and used; the partitions of Poland and the peak of the slave trade supply a second, contrasting set in the final paragraph.
  • Sourcing (1): Four sourcing moves appear (Doc 1's anonymous publication in 1689 and its property emphasis, Doc 2's author's own corporate position, Doc 5's strategic concession, and Doc 7's issuance by decree) each explained for its relevance rather than merely noted.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph holds together the patent's genuine toleration and its absolutist form, contrasts reforms that survived with serfdom's reversal, and closes by arguing that the method outran its practitioners' intentions. The qualification runs through the essay rather than appearing once.

DBQ 3 · Unit 5 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which the French Revolution transformed French society in the period 1789–1815.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how far French society was transformed and in what respects, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the society of orders before 1789, or the Restoration that followed 1815. Use the content of at least four documents, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant. Finally, show complexity: distinguish groups for whom the change was permanent from those for whom it was reversed, or weigh legal transformation against social continuity.

Document 1

Description of: the cahiers de doléances drawn up by parish and corporate assemblies for the Estates-General, spring 1789.

Tens of thousands of these lists of grievances were compiled across France. Those of the Third Estate return again and again to the same complaints: seigneurial dues and the hunting and milling monopolies of the lords, the gabelle salt tax, the exemption of the first two orders from direct taxation, venal offices, and the multiplicity of internal customs barriers. Most ask for a written constitution and regular meetings of the Estates-General. Very few call for the abolition of monarchy or nobility as such.

Document 2

Source: Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, adopted by the National Assembly, 26 August 1789.

Men are born and remain free and equal in rights. Social distinctions may be founded only upon the general good. … The principle of all sovereignty resides essentially in the nation. … Property being an inviolable and sacred right, no one shall be deprived thereof except where public necessity … clearly demands it.

Document 3

Source: French etching, "It is to be hoped this game will be over soon," widely reprinted in 1789.

Image: described

A peasant in patched clothes and wooden shoes is bent almost double beneath the weight of two men riding on his back: a nobleman in an embroidered coat with a sword, and a cleric in a broad hat. The peasant leans on a hoe that is visibly bending. Rabbits and pigeons, game the lord alone might hunt, feed on the crop at his feet, and a paper labeled with tax dues protrudes from a pocket. His face is turned toward the viewer.

Document 4

Source: Olympe de Gouges, Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen, addressed to Marie Antoinette, 1791.

Woman is born free and lives equal to man in her rights. Social distinctions may be founded only on the common utility. … Woman has the right to mount the scaffold; she must equally have the right to mount the rostrum.

Document 5

Description of: the Civil Constitution of the Clergy, enacted by the National Assembly, July 1790, and the clerical oath required from November 1790.

The law redraws dioceses to match the new administrative departments, reduces their number, and provides that bishops and parish priests be elected by the same assemblies that choose civil officials. Clergy become salaried employees of the state, and the pope's role in appointments is removed. From November all clergy are required to swear an oath of loyalty to the constitution; roughly half refuse. Pope Pius VI condemns the measure the following spring, and the refusing clergy become a focus of resistance in the west and south.

Document 6

Source: a print of the rising in the Vendée, published in France after 1815 for a royalist readership.

Image: described

A column of peasants in smocks and clogs advances across broken country carrying farm implements, fowling pieces, and a banner bearing a sacred heart surmounted by a cross. A priest in a plain cassock walks among them holding a crucifix aloft; several men kneel to receive a blessing at the roadside. In the background a village church is intact and a republican column in uniform is drawn up in line. The composition places the peasants higher in the frame than the soldiers.

Document 7

Source: the French Civil Code (Napoleonic Code), promulgated 1804, Articles 213 and 1124 in a nineteenth-century English translation.

The husband owes protection to his wife, the wife obedience to her husband. … Persons legally incapable of contracting are minors, married women in the cases specified by law, persons under interdiction, and all those to whom the law forbids certain contracts.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization that works: describe the society of orders before 1789 (three estates with unequal legal standing, seigneurial dues and monopolies, tax exemption for nobility and clergy, venal offices, provincial legal diversity, an established church), or the fiscal crisis that forced the summoning of the Estates-General. Alternatively set up the Restoration of 1815 and ask what it could and could not undo. Two or three sentences tied to the question of transformation.
  • Document groupings that support an argument: what people actually asked for against what they got (Docs 1 and 2); the visual case against privilege and its legal abolition (Docs 3 and 2); the limits of universalism (Docs 4 and 7); and the revolution that produced counter-revolution (Docs 5 and 6). Set Doc 1 against Doc 2 rather than treating them as agreeing: the gap between grievance and outcome is itself an argument.
  • Evidence beyond the documents that fits: the night of 4 August 1789 abolishing feudal dues and privileges; the sale of church and émigré lands, and who bought them; the abolition of guilds by the Le Chapelier law (1791), which also banned workers' associations; the assignat and inflation; the abolition of slavery in the colonies in 1794 and its restoration by Napoleon in 1802; the Concordat of 1801; the metric system and departmental administration; conscription and the levée en masse. Describe the evidence and use it.
  • Sourcing moves worth making: Doc 1 was produced by assemblies operating under royal convocation and within the existing order, which is why the grievances are specific and the demands moderate, an essential baseline for measuring how far events outran intentions. Doc 2 was drafted by propertied lawyers and officials in the weeks after peasant revolt had forced their hand, which explains the coexistence of universal language and the protection of property. Doc 4 is written by rewriting Doc 2 article by article, a strategy designed to make the omission impossible to miss. Doc 6 was published after 1815 for a royalist public, so it is evidence about how the Restoration wished the Vendée remembered rather than a record of 1793.
  • A complexity path: argue that the transformation was most complete in law and property and least complete in social power; feudalism and legal privilege were destroyed permanently, and land changed hands irreversibly, while notables reconstituted themselves as a wealthy elite and women ended the period with fewer rights than they had held in 1793. Or weigh the permanence of the administrative and legal settlement against the reversibility of the political one, noting that the Restoration restored a king but could not restore the old regime.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Before 1789 France was a society of legal orders. Nobility and clergy held tax exemptions and separate jurisdictions, lords collected seigneurial dues and monopolized hunting and milling, offices were bought and inherited, provinces kept distinct legal customs, and the Catholic Church was established and untaxed. The fiscal crisis that followed intervention in the American war forced Louis XVI to summon the Estates-General for the first time since 1614. Thesis The Revolution transformed French society decisively in law and in property, permanently destroying legal privilege and redistributing land, but far less in the distribution of actual social power, and for women it ended in reversal. What proved irreversible was what a propertied male citizenry wanted kept; what could be undone was undone.

Doc evidence The distance between what was asked for and what happened measures the Revolution's radicalism. Doc 1 shows the Third Estate's assemblies complaining about seigneurial dues, the salt tax, tax exemption, and internal customs, and asking for a constitution and regular assemblies: very few demanded the end of monarchy or nobility. Sourcing These were compiled under royal convocation by people working inside the existing order, which is exactly why they are so useful: they establish the baseline against which the next five years can be measured. Doc 3 puts the same grievance in a form requiring no literacy, showing a peasant bent double beneath a nobleman and a cleric while protected game eats his crop. Doc 2 then abolishes the entire structure in principle, declaring men born free and equal and locating sovereignty in the nation. Outside evidence The night of 4 August 1789 had already converted that principle into law, renouncing feudal dues, tithes, venal offices, and provincial privileges wholesale.

Doc evidence Property changed hands as comprehensively as law changed. Doc 2's seventeenth article declares property inviolable and sacred, and that clause did real work: it protected the purchasers of confiscated church and émigré estates. Sourcing The Declaration was drafted by propertied lawyers and officials in the weeks after the Great Fear had forced their hand, which explains why sweeping universalism sits beside a guarantee of property in a single short document. Outside evidence The Le Chapelier law of 1791 shows the same logic from the other side, abolishing the guilds in the name of economic liberty while banning workers' associations and strikes: a measure that freed the market and disarmed labor.

Doc evidence The universalism had firm boundaries. Doc 4 rewrites Doc 2 article by article with "woman" substituted, a strategy that makes the original's silence impossible to overlook, and its author was guillotined in 1793. Doc 7 records where the question settled: the Civil Code makes the wife owe obedience and lists married women among those legally incapable of contracting, removing the divorce rights and property capacity women had gained in the 1790s. Doc 5 marks a different limit. Reorganizing the church as a branch of the state and requiring an oath split the clergy in half and turned devout Catholics who had supported 1789 against the Revolution, producing the resistance Doc 6 depicts.

Complexity The transformation was therefore permanent where it served property and reversible where it did not. The Restoration returned a Bourbon king in 1815 but could not return the land, restore the tithe, revive the guilds, or rebuild the provincial legal systems the departments had replaced; Napoleon's Code, not the old regime, governed French civil life into the twentieth century. Sourcing Doc 6 is itself evidence for this, since it was printed after 1815 for a royalist public and shows how the Restoration wished the Vendée remembered, an idealized peasantry defending altar and throne, rather than what happened in 1793. Yet the notables who emerged under Napoleon were substantially the same families who had been wealthy before, now holding position by property rather than by birth. Legal equality among men proved compatible with a very unequal society, and for women the Revolution closed with a settlement more restrictive than the one it had briefly created.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction's last two sentences claim decisive change in law and property, far less in social power, and reversal for women, with a stated reason: what a propertied male citizenry wanted kept proved irreversible. A defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the society of orders in specific terms (exemptions, seigneurial dues, venal office, provincial law, an established church), and names the fiscal crisis that opened the sequence. Several sentences.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): Six documents are used for content and grouped by function (1 and 3 against 2 on grievance versus outcome, 2 on property, 4 and 7 on the limits of universalism, 5 and 6 on counter-revolution), and each is described accurately.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): The night of 4 August and the Le Chapelier law of 1791 are both described and used to support the argument rather than merely listed.
  • Sourcing (1): Four sourcing moves appear (Doc 1's production within the existing order, Doc 2's drafters and timing, Doc 4's mirroring strategy, and Doc 6's post-1815 royalist audience) each tied to why it matters for the argument.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph distinguishes what the Restoration could and could not undo, notes the continuity of the notables beneath the legal transformation, and holds the reversal for women alongside the permanence for property. Sustained qualification rather than a single phrase.

DBQ 4 · Unit 6 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which industrialization changed the lives of working people in Europe in the period 1780–1900.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how much and in what respects the lives of working people changed, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: pre-industrial household production and the rural economy, or the mass politics that industrial society produced after 1870. Use the content of at least four documents, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant. Finally, show complexity: distinguish between periods, between measures of wellbeing, or between what workers lost and what they gained.

Document 1

Source: testimony of Elizabeth Bentley before the parliamentary committee chaired by Michael Sadler on the labor of children in factories, Britain, 1832.

What time did you begin to work at a factory? — When I was six years old. … What were your hours of labour in that mill? — From five in the morning till nine at night, when they were thronged. … Suppose you flagged a little, or were too late, what would they do? — Strap us.

Document 2

Description of: printed rules posted in a textile mill in the English midlands, 1840s.

The rules set the gates to close at a fixed minute after the bell, after which latecomers forfeit a portion of the day's wage. Fines are specified for leaving a machine without permission, for opening a window, for whistling, for talking during working hours, and for any lamp oil spilled. Workers are required to give two weeks' notice before leaving, while the firm reserves the right to dismiss without notice. Wages are stated as payable monthly, with advances available at the counting house.

Document 3

Description of: British real-wage and mortality series for industrial districts, as compiled from wage books, price data, and registration records, c. 1780–1900.

Money wages in the cotton districts rise across the whole period. Prices rise sharply during the French wars, so real wages for most manual trades are roughly flat between 1780 and the early 1840s, then rise substantially and continuously through the second half of the century, roughly doubling by 1900. Recorded life expectancy at birth in the large manufacturing towns in the 1840s is markedly lower than in rural counties, in some districts by more than a decade, and the gap narrows only after sanitary reform late in the century. Average adult male stature declines for cohorts born in the early industrial decades.

Document 4

Source: Friedrich Engels, The Condition of the Working Class in England, written after two years managing his family's firm in Manchester, published in German in 1845; standard English translation.

Every great city has one or more slums, where the working-class is crowded together. … The streets are generally unpaved, rough, dirty, filled with vegetable and animal refuse, without sewers or gutters, but supplied with foul, stagnant pools instead.

Document 5

Description of: the People's Charter and the national petition presented to the British House of Commons, 1842.

The Charter sets out six demands: universal male suffrage, the secret ballot, annual parliaments, equal electoral districts, abolition of the property qualification for members, and payment of members so that working men could serve. The accompanying petition, bearing more than three million signatures, complains that the labor of the many enriches the few, cites the hours worked and the wages received in the manufacturing districts, and argues that without the vote workers have no means of redress. The Commons declined to hear it.

Document 6

Source: a photograph of a court of back-to-back housing in an English manufacturing town, taken for a municipal sanitary survey, 1870s.

Image: described

A narrow paved yard perhaps twelve feet across runs between two facing terraces of brick houses. Washing is strung overhead between the upper windows. A single standpipe stands against one wall and a row of shared privies closes the far end; the drain running down the center of the yard is open. Several children stand in the doorways watching the camera; the walls are soot-blackened and the windows small.

Document 7

Description of: the rule book of a British craft union, 1880s.

Members pay a weekly subscription in return for defined benefits: payment during sickness, an allowance while unemployed or traveling in search of work, a sum toward funeral expenses, and support during an authorized dispute. Rules specify the minimum rate below which no member may accept work and the number of apprentices a shop may take. Branch meetings are held monthly, officers are elected annually, and the book records the society's accumulated funds and its affiliation to a national federation.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization that works: describe pre-industrial working life (household and workshop production paced by task and season, the putting-out system, guild regulation of entry and rates, the rural majority and its common rights), or set up the enclosure and population growth that supplied the industrial workforce. Two or three sentences tied to the question of change.
  • Document groupings that support an argument: the new discipline of the workplace (Docs 1 and 2); the material conditions of the industrial town (Docs 3, 4, and 6); and the collective responses workers built (Docs 5 and 7). Doc 3 should be set against the others rather than alongside them, because it complicates the picture the qualitative sources give.
  • Evidence beyond the documents that fits: the Factory Act of 1833 and the Ten Hours Act of 1847; Chadwick's sanitary report (1842) and the Public Health Act (1848); cholera epidemics in the early 1830s and late 1840s; the repeal of the Combination Acts and later legalization of unions; Bismarck's sickness, accident, and old-age insurance in the 1880s; the growth of the German SPD; the Le Chapelier law in France; enclosure and the loss of common rights. Describe and use the evidence.
  • Sourcing moves worth making: Doc 1 comes from a committee chaired by a reformer campaigning for a ten hours bill, who selected and questioned the witnesses and gave manufacturers no equivalent hearing, so it shows conditions at their worst and how reformers built opinion, not a statistical average. Doc 4's author was a communist writing to demonstrate capitalism's human cost, and was simultaneously managing his family's cotton firm, a position worth noting in both directions. Doc 6 was made for a municipal sanitary survey, so its purpose was to document conditions requiring intervention, which shapes what the photographer chose to frame. Doc 3's registration data is more reliable than its wage series, since wage books cover only some trades.
  • A complexity path: separate the measures rather than reaching one verdict; real wages rose substantially after the 1840s while health, hours, and autonomy deteriorated first, so the answer depends on which decade and which measure is chosen, and the first industrial generation paid costs a later one did not. Or argue that the most durable change was not material at all but organizational: industrialization created a working class that could act collectively, and Docs 5 and 7 show that capacity being built.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context Before industrialization most Europeans worked in households and small workshops at a pace set by task, daylight, and season, often combining agriculture with piece-rate spinning or weaving supplied by a merchant. Guilds regulated entry and rates in the towns, and rural families depended on common rights to grazing and fuel that made small holdings viable. Enclosure and rapid population growth then detached large numbers from the land. Thesis Industrialization changed working life profoundly, but the direction of the change depends on what is measured and when: the first two generations lost health, autonomy, and control over time while gaining little in real income, and only after the 1840s did material standards improve substantially. The most durable transformation was neither wages nor conditions but the creation of a class capable of organizing to change them.

Doc evidence The immediate change was in the nature of work itself. Doc 1 describes a child beginning at six and working from five in the morning until nine at night, punished physically for lateness. Doc 2 shows the same discipline in its administrative form: gates closing on a bell, fines for talking, whistling, or opening a window, and an asymmetry in notice under which the worker must give a fortnight and the firm none. Sourcing Doc 1 requires care: Sadler was campaigning for a ten hours bill and chose and questioned the witnesses himself, giving manufacturers no equivalent hearing, so the testimony shows conditions at their worst and how reformers built public opinion rather than a typical case. Doc 2 is more revealing precisely because it is routine: a firm listing its own rules had no reason to exaggerate, and the fines record what employers thought they needed to compel.

Doc evidence Conditions outside the mill were worse than inside it. Doc 4 describes unpaved streets filled with refuse and stagnant pools in the slums of great cities, and Doc 6 shows the same environment thirty years later: a twelve-foot yard with one standpipe, shared privies, and an open central drain. Sourcing Engels wrote to demonstrate capitalism's human cost, and the rhetorical charge is obvious; the fact that he was simultaneously managing his family's Manchester firm gives him access ordinary polemicists lacked, so the description is better evidence than the framing. Outside evidence Independent investigation reached the same conclusions: Chadwick's sanitary report of 1842 established that mortality tracked filth and overcrowding, and the Public Health Act followed in 1848 after a second cholera epidemic.

Doc evidence Doc 3 complicates this picture and must be confronted rather than ignored. Real wages were roughly flat until the early 1840s and then roughly doubled by 1900, so on the single measure most often cited industrialization eventually delivered. But the same source records urban life expectancy more than a decade below rural figures in the 1840s and declining adult stature for cohorts born in the early industrial decades: evidence that nutrition and health moved the other way exactly when wages did not.

Doc evidence What working people built in response proved the most consequential change. Doc 5 shows the Charter demanding universal male suffrage, the secret ballot, and payment of members so that working men could actually serve, backed by a petition of more than three million signatures: a national political movement of workers, which had no precedent. Doc 7 shows the quieter institution that outlasted it: a union providing sickness, unemployment, traveling, and funeral benefits, enforcing a minimum rate, electing officers, and affiliating to a national federation. Outside evidence That capacity eventually produced results neither document anticipated: Bismarck's sickness, accident, and old-age insurance in the 1880s was introduced explicitly to draw support away from a socialist movement that had become too large to suppress.

Complexity The standard-of-living question therefore has no single answer, and the strongest reading is chronological and distributional rather than a verdict. The generation that entered the mills between 1780 and 1840 bore the costs (shorter lives, longer hours, lost autonomy), and a later generation collected gains their parents had made possible. The Commons declined to hear the 1842 petition, yet nearly every Chartist demand was law within seventy years, which suggests the accurate measure of industrialization's effect on working people is not the wage series at any one date but the shift in their capacity to act. Workers who in 1780 bargained individually with a merchant were by 1900 organized in federations and mass parties.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims profound change whose direction depends on measure and period, specifies the early losses and later gains, and names the organizational transformation as most durable: a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes pre-industrial household and workshop production, guild regulation, common rights, and the enclosure and population growth that supplied the workforce. Several sentences of relevant context.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): Six documents are used for content and grouped by function, 1 and 2 on workplace discipline, 4 and 6 on urban conditions, 3 as the complicating quantitative case, 5 and 7 on collective response.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Chadwick's 1842 report with the 1848 Public Health Act, and Bismarck's social insurance of the 1880s, are both described and put to work.
  • Sourcing (1): Three moves are made (Sadler's selection of witnesses and campaigning purpose, the routine and self-interested nature of Doc 2's rules, and Engels's dual position as polemicist and mill manager) each explained for relevance.
  • Complexity (1): The essay confronts Doc 3 against the qualitative sources rather than suppressing the conflict, resolves it chronologically and distributionally, and closes by reframing the measure of change as capacity rather than wages. Sustained through the argument.

DBQ 5 · Unit 7 · 60 minutes (15 reading + 45 writing)

Evaluate the extent to which nationalism shaped European politics in the period 1815–1914.

Directions

Spend the first fifteen minutes reading the seven documents and planning; write for the next forty-five. Respond with a defensible thesis about how far nationalism shaped European politics, and that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context: the Vienna settlement's dynastic principles, or the revolutionary and Napoleonic era that spread national feeling. Use the content of at least four documents, and bring in at least one specific piece of evidence not in the documents. For at least two documents, explain how point of view, purpose, historical situation, or intended audience is relevant. Finally, show complexity: distinguish nationalism's liberal from its conservative and exclusive forms, or weigh it against other forces shaping the period.

Document 1

Source: Giuseppe Mazzini, The Duties of Man, addressed to Italian working men, 1860; contemporary English translation.

Your country is the sign of the Mission which God has given you to fulfil towards Humanity. … In laboring for our own country on the right principle, we labor for Humanity. … A country is not an aggregation, it is an association.

Document 2

Source: a lithograph of the Frankfurt Parliament in session in the Paulskirche, published commercially in the German states, 1848.

Image: described

A large church interior converted into a debating chamber, with tiered benches curving toward a raised presidential dais and a speaker's tribune below. Several hundred delegates in dark civilian coats fill the floor; crowded galleries look down from above. A large allegorical figure representing Germania hangs behind the dais with banners beside it. Almost every delegate shown is a professional man in middle age, no uniforms, no workers, no peasants.

Document 3

Source: Otto von Bismarck, remarks to the budget committee of the Prussian House of Deputies, 30 September 1862; standard English translation.

Germany does not look to Prussia's liberalism but to her power. … Not by speeches and majority decisions will the great questions of the day be decided — that was the great mistake of 1848 and 1849 — but by iron and blood.

Document 4

Description of: a petition from Czech representatives to the imperial government in Vienna, 1848–1849, and the position taken by Czech leaders toward the Frankfurt Parliament.

The petitioners ask for the union of the Bohemian lands under a single diet, equality of the Czech language with German in schools, courts, and administration, and a share of offices proportionate to population. They decline the invitation to send delegates to Frankfurt, arguing that the Bohemian crown lands belong to the Habsburg monarchy rather than to a German nation, and that a united Germany would submerge the Czechs. They express loyalty to the emperor and propose that the monarchy be reorganized on the basis of equality among its peoples.

Document 5

Source: a wall map and accompanying reader used in state primary schools in a western European country, 1890s.

Image: described

The map shows the national territory in strong color at the center of the sheet, with neighboring states left pale and unlabeled except at the borders; overseas possessions appear as inset panels in the same color as the homeland, with no scale indicated. The facing reader page carries a short passage on a national hero, a list of dates of victories to be memorized, and an engraving of children of the same age as the pupils saluting a flag.

Document 6

Source: Émile Zola, "J'Accuse…!", open letter to the President of the French Republic, L'Aurore, 13 January 1898; contemporary English translation.

I accuse the War Office of having conducted an abominable campaign in the press … in order to cover up its own misdeeds. … As for the people I am accusing, I do not know them, I have never seen them, I feel neither resentment nor hatred toward them. … My fiery protest is simply the cry of my soul.

Document 7

Description of: the alliance treaties and general staff mobilization plans of the European powers as they stood in 1914.

The treaties commit their signatories to come to one another's aid if attacked by specified powers, and several contain secret military conventions fixing the number of divisions each party will field and the number of days within which they must be ready. The general staff plans that accompany them specify railway timetables to the hour, and assume that a delay in beginning mobilization cannot be recovered once an opponent has begun. Several plans provide for attacking one power in order to reach another, regardless of the neutrality of states in between.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization that works: describe the Vienna settlement's principles of dynastic legitimacy and balance of power, which allocated peoples to rulers without regard to national feeling, or set up how the French Revolution and Napoleonic occupation spread both the idea of the sovereign nation and resentment against foreign rule. Two or three sentences tied to the question.
  • Document groupings that support an argument: nationalism as a liberal and democratic creed and its failure (Docs 1 and 2); its conservative capture by state-builders (Doc 3); nationalism dividing as well as uniting (Doc 4); its transmission to mass populations (Doc 5); its exclusive and racial turn (Doc 6); and its contribution to the crisis of 1914 (Doc 7).
  • Evidence beyond the documents that fits: Cavour's alliance with Napoleon III and Garibaldi's Thousand; Bismarck's three wars and the annexation of Alsace and Lorraine; the Kulturkampf; the Dreyfus verdict of 1894 and the exoneration of 1906; Herzl and the first Zionist Congress in 1897; the Balkan Wars of 1912–1913; the Magyarization policies of the Hungarian half of the Dual Monarchy; conscription and the spread of national school systems. Describe and use the evidence.
  • Sourcing moves worth making: Doc 1 was written for Italian workers at the moment unification was being completed by a monarchy Mazzini had opposed, so it is an attempt to preserve a democratic and moral conception of nationality against a dynastic settlement. Doc 2 was produced commercially for a liberal middle-class public that wished to see the assembly it supported, which is why the composition is orderly and dignified, and what it inadvertently documents is who was absent. Doc 3 was addressed to a hostile liberal committee that Bismarck was overriding, which makes it a statement of method aimed at the people he intended to defeat and then absorb. Doc 5 was produced by a state for compulsory schooling, so it is evidence of deliberate manufacture rather than of spontaneous popular feeling.
  • A complexity path: argue that nationalism was the most powerful political force of the period while insisting that it changed character within it; beginning as a liberal creed allied to constitutional reform and ending as an exclusive, militarized, and frequently racial doctrine serving conservative states. Or weigh nationalism against industrialization, class politics, and great-power rivalry, arguing that nationalism supplied the language in which those other conflicts were fought rather than being their cause.
Show a 7/7 sample response

Context The Congress of Vienna rebuilt Europe in 1815 on dynastic legitimacy and the balance of power, allocating Italians, Germans, Poles, and Belgians among ruling houses without reference to language or national feeling. That feeling had been spreading for a generation: revolutionary France had located sovereignty in the nation, and Napoleonic occupation had taught subject peoples from Spain to Prussia to define themselves against a foreign ruler. Thesis Nationalism became the decisive political force of the period, remaking the map and eventually the alliance system, but it did so by changing character within it, beginning as a liberal creed allied to constitutional reform and ending as an exclusive doctrine that conservative states manufactured, directed, and finally could not control.

Doc evidence In its first phase nationalism was democratic and universalist in intention. Doc 1 presents the nation as a mission owed to humanity and insists that a country is an association rather than an aggregation: national freedom as a duty, not a rivalry. Sourcing Mazzini wrote this for Italian workers precisely as unification was being completed by the Piedmontese monarchy he had opposed, so the document is an attempt to keep a moral conception of nationality alive against a dynastic settlement; it is evidence of what was being lost, not of what prevailed. Doc 2 shows the same strand failing in Germany, with several hundred professional men deliberating beneath an allegorical Germania. Sourcing The print was made commercially for a liberal public that wanted to see its assembly, which is why it looks orderly, and what it inadvertently records is the absence of workers, peasants, and above all soldiers.

Doc evidence Conservative statesmen then took the creed over. Doc 3 tells a liberal committee that Germany looks to Prussia's power rather than her liberalism and that the great questions will be settled by iron and blood, explicitly naming 1848 as the error to be avoided. Sourcing He was speaking to the men he was overriding, having collected taxes without authorization, so the remark is a statement of method addressed to the people he intended first to defeat and then to absorb, which is exactly what happened after 1866. Outside evidence Cavour had already demonstrated the method in Italy, securing French support at Plombières in 1858 and provoking war with Austria rather than waiting for a rising; Garibaldi's decision in 1860 to hand Naples to Victor Emmanuel rather than proclaim a republic completed the subordination of the democratic strand.

Doc evidence Nationalism divided as readily as it united, and Doc 4 is the essential corrective to any story of nations peacefully emerging. Czech petitioners asked for linguistic equality and a Bohemian diet while explicitly refusing to send delegates to Frankfurt, on the ground that a united Germany would submerge them: one people's national project was another's extinction. The same logic ran through the Habsburg lands, where Hungarians who demanded autonomy from Vienna governed Croats and Romanians who wanted none of Hungary.

Doc evidence By the century's end nationalism had been mass-produced and turned inward. Doc 5 shows a state teaching it: a map coloring the homeland strongly and leaving neighbors pale, colonies shown as extensions of the metropole, dates of victories to be memorized, and children saluting a flag. Sourcing This was produced by a government for compulsory schooling, so it documents deliberate manufacture rather than spontaneous feeling. Doc 6 shows what the manufactured version could do to a minority within the nation: Zola accuses the War Office of a press campaign to conceal its own conduct, in an affair in which a Jewish officer's guilt had become for many a test of loyalty to France itself. Outside evidence Theodor Herzl covered the affair as a journalist and concluded that assimilation would not protect European Jews, convening the first Zionist Congress in 1897.

Complexity Doc 7 shows where the trajectory ended, in alliance treaties with secret military conventions and mobilization timetables so rigid that delay could not be recovered: a system in which a Balkan dispute could commit the continent within weeks. Yet the complexity worth holding is that nationalism was not a single force operating throughout. The doctrine that inspired Mazzini to write of duty toward humanity is not the doctrine that produced the Dreyfus press or the annexation of Alsace and Lorraine, and treating them as one idea obscures the period's central development. Nationalism's real power lay in its adaptability: liberals used it against dynasties, dynasties then used it against liberals, and by 1914 states that had manufactured national feeling to secure their populations found that it constrained their own freedom to compromise.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims nationalism was decisive while specifying that it changed character within the period, from liberal creed to exclusive state-manufactured doctrine: a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the essay follows chronologically.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the Vienna settlement's dynastic allocation of peoples and the revolutionary and Napoleonic spread of national feeling. Several sentences tied to the prompt.
  • Evidence from the documents (2): Six documents are used for content and grouped by phase and function, 1 and 2 on liberal nationalism's failure, 3 on conservative capture, 4 on national conflict, 5 and 6 on mass manufacture and exclusion, 7 on 1914.
  • Evidence beyond the documents (1): Cavour at Plombières with Garibaldi's handover, and Herzl's response to the Dreyfus Affair, are described and used to support the argument.
  • Sourcing (1): Four moves appear: Mazzini's purpose against the monarchical settlement, Doc 2's commercial liberal audience and what it omits, Bismarck's hostile committee audience, and Doc 5's production by a state for compulsory schooling.
  • Complexity (1): The final paragraph insists that early and late nationalism are not one phenomenon, explains the adaptability that made it powerful, and notes the irony that states were constrained by the feeling they had manufactured. Sustained rather than asserted once.

LEQ 1 · Units 1–2 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which the printing press changed European intellectual and religious life in the period 1450–1600.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how much changed. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning (causation, comparison, or continuity and change) to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding by qualifying your claim, weighing multiple variables, or explaining connections across the period.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the manuscript culture printing replaced; books copied by hand in monastic and university scriptoria, costly and textually variable, with literacy concentrated among clergy and a commercial minority. Or the humanist recovery of classical texts that created demand for accurate copies.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: Gutenberg's movable type c. 1450 and the spread of presses to more than two hundred towns by 1500; Erasmus's Greek New Testament (1516) exposing Vulgate errors; Luther's theses translated and reprinted within weeks; Luther's German New Testament (1522); the pamphlet war of the 1520s; vernacular Bibles and rising lay reading; the Index of Prohibited Books (1559) and licensing systems; standardized texts enabling scholars in different cities to argue over the same page.
  • Reasoning: causation is the natural structure; print as a cause of religious rupture and of cumulative scholarship. Comparison also works: Wycliffe and Hus made similar arguments before print and were contained, while Luther could not be.
  • Complexity: qualify by noting that printing did not create the ideas and that its effects depended on pre-existing literacy and urban networks, so change was uneven between town and countryside and between regions. Or note that print served the Catholic Reformation as well: Trent's decrees, Jesuit textbooks, and the Index itself were products of the same technology.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context Before the middle of the fifteenth century every book in Europe was copied by hand, usually in a monastic or university scriptorium. A single volume took months, cost more than most artisans earned in a year, and differed from every other copy because scribes introduced errors. Reading was concentrated among clergy, lawyers, and a commercial minority in the towns. Thesis Printing transformed European intellectual and religious life profoundly, but it did so by changing the speed, reach, and reliability of ideas rather than by generating new ones, and its effects were sharply uneven, strongest where urban literacy already existed and weakest in the countryside where most Europeans lived.

Evidence The technology spread with extraordinary speed. Gutenberg's combination of movable metal type, oil-based ink, and a modified press appeared at Mainz around 1450, and by 1500 more than two hundred European towns had a press. The cost of a book fell far enough that a prosperous artisan could own one, and because every copy from a single setting of type was identical, a scholar in Kraków and a scholar in Seville could for the first time argue about the same page of the same edition. That reliability is what made cumulative scholarship possible: Erasmus's Greek New Testament of 1516 could be printed and distributed across Europe, and the discrepancies it exposed between the original Greek and the Latin Vulgate were available to every theologian at once rather than to whoever held a particular manuscript.

Evidence The religious consequences followed directly from that reach. Luther posted his theses in Latin for academic disputation in 1517, but printers translated them into German and reprinted them across the empire within weeks, turning a technical argument about penance into a public attack on papal finances. The pamphlet war of the following decade reached audiences who could not read Latin and, through reading aloud, audiences who could not read at all. Luther's German New Testament of 1522 placed scripture directly in lay hands, which gave sola scriptura a practical meaning it could not have had in a manuscript culture. Comparison The contrast with earlier reformers is decisive. Wycliffe and Hus had made comparable criticisms of clerical wealth and papal authority a century before; both movements were contained, and Hus was burned in 1415. What Luther possessed that they had not was a technology that could put an argument in dozens of towns faster than any authority could seize the copies.

Complexity Yet the transformation should not be overstated in two respects. First, print did not create the ideas it spread: humanism, anticlericalism, and demands for reform all predate it, which is why the technology is better understood as determining which ideas could survive and propagate than as originating them. Second, the same press served the Catholic Reformation with equal effectiveness: the decrees of Trent, Jesuit teaching manuals, and the Index of Prohibited Books issued in 1559 were all products of the technology, and Catholic polemic circulated throughout the century. The change was therefore real and irreversible, authorities that had once contained heterodoxy by seizing manuscripts could never do so again, but it was a change in the conditions of argument rather than a verdict in favor of any side, and its benefits reached the literate towns far more than the rural majority.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction's final sentence claims profound change of a specified kind (speed, reach, and reliability rather than origination), and adds that effects were uneven by region and literacy. A defensible claim with a line of reasoning.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes manuscript culture concretely: hand copying, cost, textual variation, and the narrow distribution of literacy.
  • Evidence (2): Multiple specific examples are described and explained rather than listed (the spread of presses by 1500, Erasmus's Greek New Testament, the reprinting of Luther's theses, the German New Testament of 1522, the Index of 1559) each tied to the claim about reach and reliability.
  • Analysis and reasoning (2): Causation structures the argument, and the explicit comparison with Wycliffe and Hus isolates print as the variable that changed the outcome. The final paragraph then qualifies on two fronts (print did not originate ideas, and it served both confessions) sustaining a complex understanding rather than asserting it once.

LEQ 2 · Units 3–4 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which absolutist rulers succeeded in centralizing state power in the period 1648–1789.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how far centralization succeeded. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning (causation, comparison, or continuity and change) to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the fragmented authority absolutists inherited (provincial estates, venal offices, noble jurisdictions, separate legal customs, church autonomy), or the wars of religion and the Fronde that made strong central authority attractive.
  • Evidence worth using, described rather than named: Louis XIV's intendants, the move to Versailles in 1682, Colbert's mercantilism, the revocation of the Edict of Nantes (1685), and the Estates-General not meeting between 1614 and 1789; Peter the Great's Table of Ranks (1722), the church under a state synod, and St. Petersburg; the Hohenzollern bargain with the Junkers; Habsburg composite monarchy; Joseph II's reforms and their reversal; the persistence of noble and clerical tax exemption; Poland's liberum veto as the counter-case.
  • Reasoning: comparison across states is the strongest structure; France against Prussia and Russia, or absolutist states against the English and Dutch alternatives. Causation also works if organized around what centralization was for.
  • Complexity: argue that centralization succeeded in decision-making and administration but failed where it mattered most fiscally, since the privileged orders kept their exemptions, and that the eastern states centralized by empowering nobles rather than by defeating them, so "centralization" means different things east and west. The French fiscal crisis of 1789 is the decisive test.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context The rulers who pursued absolutism inherited states in which authority was shared and fragmented. Provincial estates voted their own taxes, offices were bought and inherited so that the crown could not remove their holders, nobles exercised justice on their own lands, provinces kept distinct legal customs, and the church held jurisdiction and property beyond royal reach. The Fronde of 1648–1653, which twice drove the French court from Paris, taught Louis XIV what that fragmentation could cost. Thesis Absolutist rulers succeeded substantially in concentrating decision-making and building administrations loyal to the crown, but failed almost entirely to centralize the one thing that determined a state's capacity, taxation, and in eastern Europe they achieved central authority by empowering the nobility rather than by subordinating it, so the same word describes two different outcomes.

Evidence The administrative achievement was genuine. Louis XIV governed after 1661 without a first minister, running policy through councils staffed by middle-ranking professionals who owed everything to him, and sent intendants into the provinces with authority over taxation, justice, and policing that bypassed local institutions. Moving the court to Versailles in 1682 drew the high nobility into a world where proximity to the king was the only currency, so that a duke competing for ceremonial privilege was a duke not raising troops in his province. The Estates-General did not meet once between 1614 and 1789: a measure of how completely national representation had been dispensed with. Colbert's tariffs, state manufactures, and merchant fleet built revenue to match.

Evidence Yet the limits were structural and fatal. Nobility and clergy retained exemption from the principal direct taxes throughout the reign, venal offices could not be recalled, and provincial legal customs survived. The result was a state powerful enough to fight most of Europe for fifty years and structurally unable to pay for it: the contradiction that produced the fiscal crisis of 1788–1789, when the parlements and an Assembly of Notables blocked taxation of the privileged and Louis XVI had to summon the Estates-General after 175 years. Absolutism's most famous state collapsed at precisely the point it had never centralized.

Comparison The eastern cases show that centralization took a different form where social structures differed. Peter the Great subordinated the Russian church to a state synod, created the Table of Ranks in 1722 tying status to state service rather than birth, and built St. Petersburg with conscripted labor, but he confirmed and tightened serfdom, because he needed the nobility to officer his army. The Hohenzollerns made the bargain explicit, granting the Junkers authority over their peasants in exchange for service and taxation. Complexity Central power in the east therefore rested on delegating local power, which is the reverse of the French pattern of drawing authority away from nobles. Joseph II's failure completes the picture: he attempted the reform that would have broken the bargain, abolishing serfdom in the Habsburg lands, and most of it was undone after his death in 1790. Poland is the control case, where no such bargain was struck, the liberum veto paralyzed the Sejm, and the state was partitioned out of existence by neighbors who had made one. Absolutism succeeded where it strengthened the state without challenging the social order it depended on, and stopped exactly where that order began.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims substantial administrative success, near-total fiscal failure, and a different meaning of centralization in the east: a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the essay follows.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the fragmented authority absolutists inherited in concrete terms and names the Fronde as the immediate lesson.
  • Evidence (2): Multiple specific examples are described and explained (intendants, Versailles, the Estates-General's 175-year absence, Colbert, noble tax exemption and the 1789 crisis, the Table of Ranks, the Junker bargain, Joseph II's reversal, the Polish partitions) each connected to the claim.
  • Analysis and reasoning (2): Comparison structures the essay, setting the French pattern against the eastern one and using Poland as a control case. The complexity lies in showing that "centralization" denotes opposite relationships with the nobility in the two regions, and that success everywhere stopped at the social bargain: sustained across the final two paragraphs.

LEQ 3 · Units 5–6 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the most significant cause of the revolutions of 1848.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that identifies a most significant cause and establishes a line of reasoning: a thesis that simply lists causes will not earn the point. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding, for instance by weighing your chosen cause against a serious rival.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the Vienna settlement's suppression of liberal and national demands and the Concert's record of intervention since 1815; or the industrial and demographic pressures building in the 1840s.
  • Evidence worth using: the potato blight and grain failures of 1845–1847 and the resulting food prices; the commercial and credit crisis of 1847; artisan displacement by machine production; the banning of reform banquets in Paris in February 1848 and the fall of Louis Philippe; Metternich's flight in March; the Frankfurt Parliament and the grossdeutsch/kleindeutsch dispute; Hungarian, Czech, Croat, and Romanian claims; the June Days; Frederick William IV's refusal of the crown in 1849; Russian intervention in Hungary.
  • Reasoning: causation, organized around a hierarchy rather than a list. A strong essay distinguishes structural causes (liberal and national demands blocked since 1815) from triggers (harvest failure and financial crisis) and argues explicitly for one as most significant.
  • Complexity: weigh the chosen cause against a serious rival and explain why the other is insufficient; economic distress alone had not produced revolution in earlier bad years, while political demands alone had not produced it in the quiet 1830s. The strongest answers argue for the conjunction while still naming a primary cause and defending the choice.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context The Congress of Vienna had rebuilt Europe in 1815 on dynastic legitimacy, deliberately disregarding the liberal and national demands the revolutionary and Napoleonic era had released, and the Concert of Europe spent the following three decades suppressing the resulting movements, in Spain and Italy in the 1820s, in Poland in 1831. Constitutions were conceded in France and Belgium in 1830 and withheld nearly everywhere else. Thesis The most significant cause of the revolutions of 1848 was the accumulated blockage of liberal and national demands by regimes that would not concede reform, because that blockage is what converted an ordinary subsistence and financial crisis into a simultaneous political collapse across the continent. Economic distress supplied the timing and the crowds; the refusal of reform supplied the target and explains why the same year produced risings in Paris, Vienna, Berlin, Milan, and Budapest at once.

Evidence The economic trigger was real and severe. Potato blight and poor grain harvests between 1845 and 1847 drove food prices to levels that consumed most of a laboring family's income, and the commercial and credit crisis of 1847 produced urban unemployment on top of dear bread. Artisans in the German states and France faced displacement by machine production at exactly the moment food costs peaked. These conditions filled the streets. Comparison But similar subsistence crises had occurred repeatedly without producing revolution, the hardship of the 1810s and the 1830s did not overturn governments, which indicates that distress alone is not sufficient to explain 1848, and that what differed was the political situation the distress met.

Evidence That political situation was three decades of refused demands. In France, a government that banned the reform banquets of February 1848 rather than widen a franchise limited to a small propertied minority found itself without defenders when crowds appeared, and Louis Philippe abdicated within days. In the Habsburg lands, where Metternich had suppressed constitutional and national movements since 1815, his flight in March was followed within weeks by concessions of constitutions and assemblies across the German states, Italy, and Hungary. The speed of that collapse is the clearest evidence for the argument: regimes fell in days because they had built no constituency with an interest in defending them, having spent a generation refusing to share power with the classes that might have supplied one.

Complexity The strongest objection is that this explanation accounts for the outbreak but not the outcome, and the objection has force. The revolutions failed because the coalitions that made them were incompatible: in Paris, moderate republicans closed the National Workshops and crushed the workers' rising of the June Days four months after standing beside them; in central Europe, German, Czech, Hungarian, Croat, and Romanian national claims proved mutually exclusive, so that the Frankfurt Parliament could not even agree whom a German nation should include. Decisively, no revolutionary body controlled an army, and the Habsburg and Prussian officer corps remained intact and waited. This does not overturn the thesis but sharpens it: blocked demands explain why so many regimes fell at once, while the incoherence of what replaced them explains why almost all were restored within eighteen months. Both halves are needed, and the lesson was learned by Cavour and Bismarck rather than by the liberals of 1848.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction names one cause as most significant, blocked liberal and national demands, and gives the reason, distinguishing it from the economic trigger. It makes a claim rather than listing causes.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the Vienna settlement's disregard of liberal and national demands and the Concert's record of suppression through the 1820s and 1830s.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence appears on both sides and is explained: the blight and grain failures, the 1847 credit crisis, artisan displacement, the banned banquets and Louis Philippe's abdication, Metternich's flight and the concessions that followed.
  • Analysis and reasoning (2): Causation is structured as a hierarchy rather than a list, and the comparison with earlier subsistence crises isolates the political variable. The final paragraph raises the strongest counter-argument, concedes its force, and integrates it: sustained complexity rather than a closing gesture.

LEQ 4 · Units 7–8 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which imperial rivalry contributed to the outbreak of the First World War.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how far imperial rivalry contributed. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding: for instance by weighing imperial rivalry against other causes rather than treating it in isolation.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: German unification's disruption of the balance of power and Bismarck's alliance system designed to isolate France; or the New Imperialism after 1870 and the partition of Africa.
  • Evidence worth using: the Berlin Conference (1884–1885) managing partition without war; the Moroccan crises of 1905 and 1911; the Anglo-German naval race and the dreadnought program; Britain's abandonment of isolation in the Entente Cordiale (1904) and the Anglo-Russian agreement (1907); Wilhelm II's world policy and the lapse of the Russian treaty in 1890; Austro-Russian rivalry in the Balkans and the Balkan Wars of 1912–1913; the July crisis and the Schlieffen Plan's timetable.
  • Reasoning: causation, ideally weighing several causes and assigning relative weight rather than listing them. A comparison between extra-European imperial disputes, which were repeatedly settled, and Balkan disputes, which were not, is the sharpest analytical move available.
  • Complexity: argue that imperial rivalry mattered chiefly by shaping the alliance system and the naval race rather than by causing the war directly, since the actual crises over colonies (Morocco twice, Fashoda) were all resolved without war, while the war began over a European dispute in the Balkans. Alternatively, argue that Austro-Russian rivalry in the Balkans was itself imperial, which complicates the distinction.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context German unification in 1871 replaced the fragmented center on which the Vienna settlement depended with the continent's strongest army and fastest-growing industry, and Bismarck spent two decades building alliances to reassure his neighbors that Germany was satisfied. His successors reversed that policy: Wilhelm II let the reinsurance treaty with Russia lapse in 1890 and pursued a world policy that treated colonies and a battle fleet as the marks of a great power. Thesis Imperial rivalry contributed substantially to the outbreak of war, but indirectly: it built the alliance blocs and the naval antagonism that turned a regional dispute into a continental one, while the colonial disputes themselves were consistently settled by negotiation. The war began over a European question, and imperial rivalry is best understood as having created the conditions under which that question could not be contained.

Evidence The case for imperial rivalry as a cause rests on what it did to relationships between the powers. The Anglo-German naval race was its most damaging product: Germany's decision to build a battle fleet capable of challenging the Royal Navy convinced Britain that its security was directly threatened, and pushed a state that had practiced isolation into the Entente Cordiale with France in 1904 and an agreement with Russia in 1907; settling, notably, the very colonial disagreements in Africa and Asia that had divided them. The Moroccan crises of 1905 and 1911, in which Germany challenged French influence in order to test the Entente, had precisely the opposite of the intended effect, drawing Britain and France into military conversations. Imperial competition thus assembled the two blocs that would face each other in 1914.

Comparison Yet the record of the colonial disputes themselves argues against treating imperial rivalry as a direct cause. The Berlin Conference of 1884–1885 partitioned most of a continent without a European war. Britain and France came close to conflict at Fashoda in 1898 and stepped back. Both Moroccan crises were resolved by negotiation and territorial compensation. In every instance where European powers quarreled over territory outside Europe, they found a settlement, which suggests that colonies were negotiable in a way that European questions were not.

Evidence The crisis that produced war was of the second kind. Austro-Russian competition in the Balkans concerned the succession to Ottoman power in a region both regarded as vital, and it was entangled with the survival of Austria-Hungary as a multinational state facing South Slav nationalism. When a Bosnian Serb nationalist assassinated the Austrian heir in June 1914, Vienna judged that Serbia had to be crushed for the monarchy to survive, and no compensation was available that could substitute for that. Mobilization timetables built on railway schedules then removed the time diplomats had used in earlier crises.

Complexity The distinction between imperial and European causes is nevertheless less clean than it looks, and the strongest answers say so. Austria-Hungary and Russia were themselves empires, and their Balkan competition was imperial in every respect except geography: succession to a declining Ottoman Empire, rival claims over subject peoples, and prestige as the guarantor of client states. What distinguished it from the scramble for Africa was that the territory in question bordered both powers and bore directly on whether one of them could survive as a multinational state, which is exactly why compensation could not settle it. Imperial rivalry, on this reading, contributed to the war both by constructing the alliance system that globalized a local crisis and by supplying the specific quarrel that began it, but the mechanism differed in each case, and treating "imperialism" as a single cause obscures the difference.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction claims substantial but indirect contribution, specifying the mechanism, alliance blocs and naval antagonism, and distinguishing it from the crisis that actually began the war.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes unification's disruption of the balance, Bismarck's alliance system, and Wilhelm II's reversal of it.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence is described and explained throughout: the naval race, the Entente Cordiale and the 1907 agreement settling colonial disputes, the Moroccan crises, Berlin 1884–1885, Fashoda, the July crisis and mobilization timetables.
  • Analysis and reasoning (2): Causation is weighed rather than listed, and the comparison between repeatedly settled colonial disputes and the unsettleable Balkan question carries the argument. The final paragraph then complicates its own distinction by noting that Austro-Russian rivalry was itself imperial, and explains what nonetheless made it different: sustained complex understanding.

LEQ 5 · Units 8–9 · 40 minutes

Evaluate the extent to which the Cold War shaped Western European politics and society in the period 1945–1991.

Directions

Write for forty minutes. Respond with a historically defensible thesis that establishes a line of reasoning about how far the Cold War shaped western Europe. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support your argument with specific and relevant evidence, explaining how each piece supports your claim. Use historical reasoning to structure the argument, and demonstrate a complex understanding: for instance by distinguishing what the Cold War caused from what it merely accompanied.

Your essay
What a reader looks for on this prompt
  • Contextualization: the devastation of 1945 (cities destroyed, tens of millions dead, twelve million displaced, food and transport systems collapsed), or the vague Yalta and Potsdam agreements overtaken by where the armies stood.
  • Evidence worth using: the Truman Doctrine (1947) and Marshall Plan aid; the Berlin blockade and airlift; NATO (1949) and the two German states; the Schuman Declaration (1950), the ECSC, and the Treaty of Rome (1957); the post-war boom and the construction of welfare states including the NHS (1948); Suez (1956) as the end of independent great-power action; decolonization and postcolonial migration; guest-worker recruitment; large communist parties in France and Italy; 1968; détente and Helsinki (1975); the end of the division in 1989–1991.
  • Reasoning: causation, ideally distinguishing direct effects from enabling conditions. Continuity and change also works across the whole period.
  • Complexity: distinguish what the Cold War caused from what it enabled or merely accompanied, the welfare state had pre-war intellectual roots and would likely have been built anyway, while integration was made possible by the American security umbrella that removed the need for France and Germany to balance against one another. Or note that decolonization and the social changes of the 1960s had their own dynamics, so attributing everything in these decades to the Cold War overstates the case.
Show a 6/6 sample response

Context Europe in 1945 was ruined and occupied: cities lay in rubble, some twelve million displaced people were moving across a continent whose food and transport systems had collapsed, and the wartime agreements at Yalta and Potsdam were vague enough that outcomes were decided by where the armies happened to stand. Within three years the division was institutional, with Soviet-backed governments consolidated across the east and the Czechoslovak coup of February 1948 removing the last coalition government there. Thesis The Cold War shaped western European politics and society profoundly, but its most important effects were enabling rather than directly causal: by supplying an external security guarantee and a shared threat, it made possible the Franco-German integration and welfare-state expansion that Europeans had wanted for other reasons, while directly determining the region's strategic subordination and the limits of its domestic politics.

Evidence The direct effects were unmistakable. The Truman Doctrine of 1947 committed the United States to supporting states under communist pressure, and the Marshall Plan delivered roughly thirteen billion dollars for recovery on terms the Soviet Union forbade its satellites to accept: a decision that drew the economic line the political division then followed. The Berlin blockade and airlift of 1948–1949 turned Germany into the confrontation's front line, NATO followed in 1949, and two German states were founded the same year. Western Europe's defense thereafter rested on non-European powers and nuclear weapons. The consequences for independent action became explicit at Suez in 1956, when American financial pressure forced Britain and France to abandon an invasion of Egypt: a public demonstration that the former great powers could no longer act alone.

Evidence Domestic politics were shaped as directly. Large communist parties in France and Italy were permanently excluded from national government, which narrowed the political spectrum in both countries for four decades and made center-right and social democratic alternation the norm across the region. American aid came with expectations about economic openness, and anti-communism structured trade-union politics, publishing, and intellectual life.

Evidence The enabling effects were arguably more consequential. The Schuman Declaration of 1950 proposed pooling French and German coal and steel so that war between them would become materially impossible, and it led through the Treaty of Rome in 1957 to the European Economic Community. That project was conceivable only because the American security guarantee removed the need for France to balance against German recovery, and because the Soviet threat gave the two states a shared interest. Meanwhile the post-war boom funded comprehensive welfare states (health provision, social insurance, pensions, expanded education) of which Britain's National Health Service, founded in 1948, was the most visible.

Complexity The welfare state, however, is precisely where the Cold War thesis should be qualified. Its intellectual foundations were laid before the confrontation began (Britain's Beveridge Report appeared in 1942, and social insurance in Germany dated to the 1880s), and the political coalitions that built these systems were responding to the Depression and the war rather than to Moscow. The Cold War may have made elites more willing to concede, but attributing the welfare state to it overstates the case. The same caution applies to decolonization, driven by nationalist movements with their own histories, and to the social upheavals of 1968 and second-wave feminism, which drew on prosperity and demographic change rather than superpower conflict. The precise claim is that the Cold War set the boundaries within which western European politics operated (determining who could govern, what defense would cost, and how far independent action could go), while much of what happened inside those boundaries had other causes. That distinction is confirmed by what followed 1991: the division ended, and integration, welfare provision, and migration continued.

Where the points are earned
  • Thesis (1): The introduction distinguishes enabling from directly causal effects and specifies which belong in each category: a defensible claim about extent with a line of reasoning the essay sustains.
  • Contextualization (1): The opening describes the material devastation of 1945 and the vagueness of Yalta and Potsdam against the position of the armies.
  • Evidence (2): Specific evidence is described and explained: the Truman Doctrine and Marshall aid, the blockade and airlift, NATO and the two German states, Suez, the exclusion of communist parties, the Schuman Declaration and Treaty of Rome, the NHS.
  • Analysis and reasoning (2): Causation is analyzed rather than asserted, and the final paragraph separates what the Cold War caused from what it accompanied, using the Beveridge Report, decolonization, and 1968 as counter-evidence, then confirms the distinction with what continued after 1991. Complexity sustained to the end.

Unit recap

Unit recap

0:00 / 0:00

Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play counts as your one free video.

Free preview complete

That's the end of the free preview.

You've opened five lessons, which is as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go back to it.

Book a tutor instead