College-level chemistry (atomic structure, bonding, intermolecular forces, stoichiometry, kinetics, thermochemistry, equilibrium, acids and bases, and electrochemistry) taught unit by unit to the College Board framework, with the calculations and the particle-level explanations the exam asks for. Exam format from 2027: this is a hybrid digital exam: multiple choice in Bluebook, free response handwritten in a paper booklet. Work the practice problems on paper and check your steps against the worked answer, the way you will sit the free-response section in May.
3H 15M EXAM60 MCQ7 FRQ69 LESSONS90 PRACTICE PROBLEMSPREREQ: CHEM + ALGEBRA II
What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.
AP Chemistry follows the nine units of the College Board course framework. Unit 3 (properties of substances and mixtures) and Unit 8 (acids and bases) carry the most weight, and nearly every free-response question asks you to connect a calculation to a particle-level explanation: the lessons below practice both halves every time.
U1Atomic Structure and Properties7–9%
U2Compound Structure and Properties7–9%
U3Properties of Substances and Mixtures18–22%
U4Chemical Reactions7–9%
U5Kinetics7–9%
U6Thermochemistry7–9%
U7Equilibrium7–9%
U8Acids and Bases11–15%
U9Thermodynamics and Electrochemistry7–9%
All nine units are open, 69 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a ten-problem mixed review.
Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set,
is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open
for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no
card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of
written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.
A chemist cannot count atoms. A single drop of water holds more molecules than there are drops of water in all of
Earth’s oceans, and no instrument can tally them one at a time. What a chemist can do is weigh a sample on a balance.
The whole of quantitative chemistry rests on one idea that connects the two: the mole. Every
calculation in this course, from reaction yields to gas volumes to equilibrium concentrations, starts by converting a
measured mass into a number of moles. Master this lesson and the rest of the year has a firm floor under it.
Learning objective · 1.1.A
Calculate quantities of a substance or its relative number of particles using dimensional analysis and the mole concept.
Required content · EK 1.1.A.1 to 1.1.A.3
One cannot count particles directly while performing laboratory work, so there must be a connection between the masses of substances reacting and the actual number of particles undergoing chemical changes.
Avogadro’s number (NA = 6.022 × 1023 mol−1) provides the connection between the number of moles in a pure sample of a substance and the number of constituent particles (or formula units) of that substance.
The average mass in amu of one particle of a substance is numerically equal to the molar mass of that substance in grams. This gives a quantitative connection between the mass of a substance and the number of particles it contains.
The mole is a counting unit
A dozen means 12 of anything. A mole means 6.022 × 1023 of anything. That number is
Avogadro’s number, NA, and it is a plain count, exactly like a dozen, only enormously larger.
It was chosen so that the numbers work out neatly on a balance, as the next section shows. One mole of marbles would cover
the whole Earth to a depth of many kilometers; one mole of atoms is a small, easily weighed pile.
The word “particle” covers whatever the substance is made of. In helium it is an atom; in water it is a molecule;
in sodium chloride it is a formula unit, one Na+ and one Cl− taken together, because ionic
solids are lattices and have no separate molecules. So “1 mol of NaCl” contains 6.022 × 1023 formula units, which is
6.022 × 1023 sodium ions and 6.022 × 1023 chloride ions.
Molar mass connects mass to moles
The atomic mass unit (amu) is a mass scale built for single atoms. Carbon-12 is defined as exactly 12 amu, and every other
atom is measured against it. The periodic table lists the average atomic mass of each element in amu: 12.01 for carbon,
16.00 for oxygen, 1.008 for hydrogen. The remarkable fact, and the reason NA has the value it does, is that
the same number is the mass in grams of one mole. One carbon atom averages 12.01 amu, and 1 mol of carbon atoms has a mass of 12.01 g.
That mass of one mole is the molar mass, M, with units g/mol.
Figure 1.1b One mole of any substance contains the same number of particles, 6.022 × 1023, but the masses differ because the particles differ in mass. The mass of one mole in grams equals the average mass of one particle in amu.
To find the molar mass of a compound, add the molar masses of every atom in the formula, counting each one as many times as the subscript says.
For water, H2O: 2(1.008) + 15.999 = 18.015 g/mol. For glucose, C6H12O6: 6(12.011) + 12(1.008) + 6(15.999) = 180.156 g/mol.
For a compound with parentheses, such as (NH4)2SO4, the subscript outside multiplies everything inside: 2 N, 8 H, 1 S and 4 O.
Equation on the AP reference sheet
\[ n = \dfrac{m}{M} \]
where \(n\) is the amount in moles, \(m\) is the mass in grams and \(M\) is the molar mass in g/mol. Rearranged, \(m = nM\).
To convert between moles and particles, multiply or divide by \(N_A\): number of particles \(= n \times 6.022 \times 10^{23}\).
Figure 1.1a The mole as the bridge between what is measured (mass) and what is counted (particles). To go from grams to moles divide by the molar mass; to go from moles to particles multiply by Avogadro’s number.
Dimensional analysis
Dimensional analysis means writing each conversion as a fraction equal to 1 and arranging the fractions so that the unwanted units cancel.
The two relationships in this lesson give two such fractions:
\(\dfrac{1\ \text{mol}}{M\ \text{g}}\) and \(\dfrac{6.022\times10^{23}\ \text{particles}}{1\ \text{mol}}\).
The chain for “grams to particles” is always grams, then moles, then particles, never a shortcut. Writing the units and canceling them
catches most errors before they happen: if the units on your answer are not the ones you wanted, the setup is wrong.
Worked example · grams to moles
How many moles are in 25.0 g of ammonium sulfate, (NH4)2SO4?
Notice the size of a single particle. One water molecule has a mass of \(\dfrac{18.015\ \text{g/mol}}{6.022\times10^{23}\ \text{mol}^{-1}} = 2.99\times10^{-23}\) g.
A balance that reads to 0.001 g cannot see anything smaller than about \(10^{19}\) molecules, which is exactly why chemists count by the mole.
Exam focus
Count the atoms in the formula. Many missed points come from using the molar mass of the compound when the question asks about one element inside it (or the reverse).
Grams, then moles, then particles. Mass never converts straight to a particle count; it always passes through moles.
Significant figures. Use the molar mass to at least one more digit than the data, and report the answer with the same number of significant figures as the least precise measurement.
Show the units. On free-response questions the setup with units is often what earns the point, even if the arithmetic slips.
Formula units are particles too. Say “formula units” for an ionic compound, not “molecules.”
Practice
Calculate the molar mass of C12H22O11 (sucrose) and the number of moles in 5.00 g.
Show answer
What is the mass, in grams, of one atom of copper?
Show answer
One mole has a mass of 63.546 g and holds \(6.022\times10^{23}\) atoms, so one atom has a mass of \(63.546 / 6.022\times10^{23} = 1.06\times10^{-22}\) g.
Explain why the molar mass of carbon in g/mol has the same numerical value as the average mass of one carbon atom in amu.
Show answer
The mole is defined so that a mole of carbon-12 atoms has a mass of exactly 12 g, and one carbon-12 atom has a mass of exactly 12 amu. Avogadro’s number is the conversion factor between grams and amu, so for every substance the average mass of one particle in amu equals the mass of a mole in grams.
A student says that 18 g of water and 18 g of glucose contain the same number of molecules because they have the same mass. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is incorrect. Water has M = 18.015 g/mol, so 18 g is about 1.0 mol. Glucose has M = 180.156 g/mol, so 18 g is about 0.10 mol. The water sample has about ten times as many molecules, because each glucose molecule is about ten times heavier. Equal numbers of particles require equal numbers of moles, not equal masses.
A sample of an ionic compound contains 0.250 mol of calcium chloride, CaCl2. How many chloride ions does it contain?
Show answer
Each formula unit has 2 Cl−, so there are 0.500 mol of chloride ions. \(0.500 \times 6.022\times10^{23} = 3.01\times10^{23}\) chloride ions.
The periodic table says chlorine has a mass of 35.45 amu. Yet no chlorine atom weighs 35.45 amu. Every chlorine atom has
a whole number of protons and neutrons, so its mass is very close to 35 or to 37, never in between. The reconciling fact is that
natural chlorine is a mixture of two kinds of atoms, and 35.45 is their average. The instrument that reveals this, and measures how much of each kind
there is, is the mass spectrometer.
Learning objective · 1.2.A
Explain the quantitative relationship between the mass spectrum of an element and the masses of the element’s isotopes.
Required content · EK 1.2.A.1 and 1.2.A.2
The mass spectrum of a sample containing a single element can be used to determine the identity of the isotopes of that element and the relative abundance of each isotope in nature.
The average atomic mass of an element can be estimated from the weighted average of the isotopic masses using the mass of each isotope and its relative abundance.
Exclusion: interpreting spectra of samples with several elements, or peaks from anything other than singly charged monatomic ions, is not assessed.
Isotopes
The number of protons fixes the element; the number of neutrons can vary. Isotopes are atoms of the same element with different numbers
of neutrons, and therefore different masses. Chlorine-35 has 17 protons and 18 neutrons; chlorine-37 has 17 protons and 20 neutrons. They have the same
electron arrangement and so behave identically in reactions, but they differ in mass. The mass number (protons plus neutrons) is the whole number in the name.
The actual isotopic mass in amu is very close to the mass number but not exactly equal (34.969 amu for chlorine-35).
How a mass spectrometer works
A sample is vaporized, and a beam of electrons knocks one electron off each atom, producing singly charged positive ions. The ions are accelerated by an electric field
so that all of them gain the same energy, then pass through a magnetic field that bends their path. Heavier ions have more inertia and bend less; lighter ions
bend more. Each isotope lands at its own position on a detector, and the strength of the signal is proportional to how many ions arrive there.
Figure 1.2a A mass spectrometer separates ions by their mass-to-charge ratio. For the AP exam the ions are singly charged atoms, so the horizontal axis is the mass of the isotope in amu.
The result is a mass spectrum: a bar graph with mass (in amu, since the ions carry a charge of +1) on the horizontal axis and
relative abundance on the vertical axis. One bar means one isotope. The position tells you the isotope’s mass; the height tells you the
percentage of atoms in nature that are that isotope.
Figure 1.2b Mass spectra of two elements. Each peak is one isotope: its position is the isotope’s mass in amu and its height is the relative abundance. The average atomic mass is the abundance-weighted average of these masses.
Read the two spectra above. Chlorine has two bars, at 35 and 37 amu, with the 35 bar about three times as tall: about 75.8% of chlorine atoms are chlorine-35.
Magnesium has three bars, at 24, 25 and 26, and the tallest, at 24, accounts for about 79% of atoms. Because the bars show the share of atoms, the heights in a complete spectrum add up to 100%.
Average atomic mass
The mass in the periodic table is a weighted average: each isotope’s mass is multiplied by its fractional abundance, and the products are added.
It is weighted because an isotope that makes up 75% of the atoms contributes three times as much as one that makes up 25%.
Average atomic mass
\[ \text{average atomic mass} = \sum (\text{isotopic mass}) \times (\text{fractional abundance}) \]
Use fractions (0.7577) rather than percentages (75.77%), or divide the final sum by 100.
Worked example · average mass of chlorine
Chlorine-35 has a mass of 34.969 amu and an abundance of 75.77%. Chlorine-37 has a mass of 36.966 amu and an abundance of 24.23%. Find the average atomic mass.
Step 1. \(34.969 \times 0.7577 = 26.496\) amu from chlorine-35.
Step 2. \(36.966 \times 0.2423 = 8.957\) amu from chlorine-37.
Step 3. Add: \(26.496 + 8.957 = 35.453\), which rounds to 35.45 amu, the periodic table value.
Reasonableness. The average must lie between 35 and 37, and closer to 35 because that isotope is more abundant. It does.
Worked example · estimating from a spectrum
On the AP exam you are often asked only to estimate, using mass numbers. For magnesium: \(24(0.7899) + 25(0.1000) + 26(0.1101) = 18.96 + 2.50 + 2.86 = 24.32\), so the average is a little over 24.3 amu. The accurate value using exact isotopic masses is 24.305 amu.
Worked example · finding an abundance
Copper has two isotopes, copper-63 (62.930 amu) and copper-65 (64.928 amu). The average atomic mass is 63.55 amu. What is the abundance of each?
Let \(x\) be the fraction of copper-63. Then copper-65 is \(1 - x\):
\(62.930x + 64.928(1-x) = 63.55\), so \(64.928 - 1.998x = 63.55\) and \(x = \dfrac{1.378}{1.998} = 0.690\).
Copper-63 is 69.0% and copper-65 is 31.0%.
Check. The average (63.55) is nearer 63 than 65, so copper-63 must be the more abundant. It is.
A quick check that always works: the average atomic mass is pulled toward the isotope with the tallest bar. If the periodic-table mass is 35.45, the spectrum must show a taller peak at 35 than at 37.
Also notice what the table value is not: it is not the mass of any real atom, and it is not simply the midpoint of the isotopes.
Exam focus
Peak position is mass; peak height is abundance. Do not swap them.
The average is weighted. Averaging 35 and 37 to get 36 is the classic error.
The answer must fall between the lightest and heaviest isotope, and lean toward the more abundant one. Use this to catch arithmetic slips.
Same element, same number of protons. Isotopes differ only in neutrons, so they have the same chemical behavior.
Stay within the scope. The exam uses spectra of one element with singly charged ions, so the horizontal axis is the isotope mass in amu.
Practice
Boron has two isotopes: boron-10 (10.013 amu, 19.9%) and boron-11 (11.009 amu, 80.1%). Estimate the average atomic mass using mass numbers.
Show answer
\(10(0.199) + 11(0.801) = 1.99 + 8.81 = 10.80\) amu. This is close to the accepted 10.81. The answer lies nearer 11 because boron-11 is much more abundant.
A mass spectrum of an element shows peaks at 24 amu (height 79), 25 amu (height 10) and 26 amu (height 11). How many isotopes does the element have, and which is the most abundant?
Show answer
Three isotopes, one per peak. The most abundant is the 24 amu isotope, because its peak is the tallest (79%).
Why is the atomic mass of chlorine on the periodic table not a whole number even though every chlorine atom has a whole number of protons and neutrons?
Show answer
Natural chlorine is a mixture of isotopes, about 76% chlorine-35 and 24% chlorine-37. The table value is the weighted average of the isotopic masses, so it falls between 35 and 37 and is not the mass of any single atom.
An element has two isotopes with masses 79 amu and 81 amu. The average atomic mass is 79.90 amu. Estimate which isotope is more abundant and find the percentages.
Show answer
The average is nearer 79 than 81, so the 79 amu isotope is more abundant. If \(x\) is the fraction at 79: \(79x + 81(1-x) = 79.90\), so \(81 - 2x = 79.90\) and \(x = 0.55\). The 79 amu isotope is 55% and the 81 amu isotope is 45%.
A student reports that the average atomic mass of an element with isotopes of mass 20 and 22 is 21, because 21 is the middle of the two. What information would show that this is probably wrong?
Show answer
The average is weighted by abundance, so it equals 21 only if the two isotopes are present in exactly equal amounts. The spectrum’s peak heights would show whether that is true; if one peak is taller, the average lies nearer to that isotope.
A spectrum of a sample of element X shows two peaks of equal height at 69 amu and 71 amu. Estimate the average atomic mass and describe the percent abundances.
Show answer
Equal heights means 50% each, so the average is \(0.50(69) + 0.50(71) = 70\) amu. Each isotope makes up half of the atoms.
How do you know what a substance is? Color, melting point and smell help, but the most direct answer is to find out what it is made of and in what proportions.
A chemist who burns a sample, weighs the products and works out the masses of carbon and hydrogen in it is doing elemental analysis, and from those masses
the formula follows. The same measurement can also tell you how pure a sample is. This lesson covers both: composition by mass of pure substances, and composition of mixtures.
Learning objectives · 1.3.A and 1.4.A
1.3.A Explain the quantitative relationship between the elemental composition by mass and the empirical formula of a pure substance.
1.4.A Explain the quantitative relationship between the elemental composition by mass and the composition of substances in a mixture.
Required content · EK 1.3.A.1 to 1.3.A.3 and 1.4.A.1 to 1.4.A.2
Some pure substances are composed of individual molecules, while others consist of atoms or ions held together in fixed proportions as described by a formula unit.
According to the law of definite proportions, the ratio of the masses of the constituent elements in any pure sample of that compound is always the same.
The chemical formula that lists the lowest whole number ratio of atoms of the elements in a compound is the empirical formula.
Pure substances contain atoms, molecules or formula units of a single type. Mixtures contain two or more types, whose relative proportions can vary.
Elemental analysis can be used to determine the relative numbers of atoms in a substance and to determine its purity.
Pure substances: fixed proportions
A pure substance is made of one kind of particle throughout. An element is pure (every atom is the same element); a compound is pure
(every molecule or formula unit is the same). Some pure compounds are built of separate molecules (water, carbon dioxide, glucose). Others, such as
sodium chloride and other ionic solids, are lattices with no separate molecules, so their formula describes a formula unit: the simplest repeating
ratio of ions.
The law of definite proportions says that a compound always contains the same elements in the same ratio by mass. Pure water from a lake, from a
glacier or from a chemistry lab is always 8 parts oxygen to 1 part hydrogen by mass (more precisely 8.0 g of oxygen for each 1.0 g of hydrogen). A sample in which the ratio
were different would be either not water or not pure.
Figure 1.3a The law of definite proportions: whatever the size of the sample or where it came from, pure water is always 8 parts oxygen to 1 part hydrogen by mass. The ratio identifies the compound.
Why is the ratio by mass fixed? Because the ratio of atoms is fixed (2 H for each O) and each kind of atom has its own fixed mass. Two hydrogen atoms
(2 × 1.008 amu) bonded to one oxygen atom (15.999 amu) give 16.0 : 2.0, which is 8 : 1.
Empirical formulas
The empirical formula gives the smallest whole number ratio of atoms in a compound. Glucose is C6H12O6 (the molecular formula,
the actual atoms in one molecule), but its empirical formula is CH2O because 6 : 12 : 6 reduces to 1 : 2 : 1. For ionic compounds the formula unit is
the empirical formula: NaCl, CaCl2, Al2O3.
Experiments deliver masses or percentages, not atoms. To go from data to formula you convert to moles, because moles are proportional to numbers of atoms.
Figure 1.3b From mass percent to empirical formula. The example is a compound that is 40.0% C, 6.7% H and 53.3% O by mass, which has the empirical formula CH2O.
Worked example · percent composition to empirical formula
A compound is 40.0% carbon, 6.7% hydrogen and 53.3% oxygen by mass. Find its empirical formula, and its molecular formula if the molar mass is 180.16 g/mol.
Step 1. Assume 100.0 g, so the masses are 40.0 g C, 6.7 g H, 53.3 g O.
Step 3, divide by the smallest (3.330). C: 1.00. H: 2.00. O: 1.00. The ratio is 1 : 2 : 1, so the empirical formula is CH2O.
Step 4, molecular formula. The empirical formula mass is 12.011 + 2(1.008) + 15.999 = 30.026 g/mol. \(\dfrac{180.16}{30.026} = 6.00\), so multiply every subscript by 6: C6H12O6.
Worked example · when the ratio is not whole
An alcohol is 52.14% C, 13.13% H and 34.73% O. In 100.0 g: C 4.341 mol, H 13.03 mol, O 2.171 mol. Dividing by 2.171 gives 2.00 : 6.00 : 1.00, so the formula is C2H6O. If a ratio comes out as 1 : 1.5, multiply all values by 2; if 1 : 1.33, multiply by 3. A value such as 1.98 or 2.03 is rounding error and is rounded to 2, but 1.5 is not.
Worked example · a hydrate from mass data
A 2.500 g sample of blue copper(II) sulfate crystals is heated until all the water is driven off, leaving 1.598 g of white CuSO4. Find the formula of the hydrate, CuSO4·xH2O.
Mass of water lost: 2.500 − 1.598 = 0.902 g, which is 0.902 / 18.015 = 0.0501 mol H2O. Moles CuSO4: 1.598 / 159.602 = 0.01001 mol. Ratio: 0.0501 / 0.01001 = 5.00. The formula is CuSO4·5H2O.
Mixtures and purity
A mixture contains two or more kinds of particles in proportions that can vary. Salt water can be weakly or strongly salty; air has varying amounts of water vapor.
This variability is the key difference from a compound. In a homogeneous mixture (a solution) the parts are uniformly spread; in a heterogeneous mixture (sand and gravel) they are not.
Elemental analysis tests purity. Suppose a sample is supposed to be calcium carbonate, CaCO3. Pure CaCO3 is
\(\dfrac{40.078}{100.086} \times 100 = 40.04\%\) calcium by mass. If an analysis finds less than that, the sample contains other material with less calcium (or none).
Figure 1.3c Elemental analysis and purity. Pure CaCO3 is 40.04% calcium by mass. A sample with a lower percentage contains other material that has less calcium (or none), and the ratio of the percentages gives the purity.
Worked example · purity from elemental analysis
A limestone sample is analyzed and found to contain 38.04% calcium by mass. Assuming the only calcium compound is CaCO3, what is the percent purity?
Purity \(= \dfrac{38.04}{40.04} \times 100 = 95.0\%\). A second sample that is 34.0% calcium is \(\dfrac{34.0}{40.04} = 84.9\%\) CaCO3, with the remainder impurities such as sand.
Worked example · composition of a mixture
A 1.000 g mixture of sodium chloride and potassium nitrate is dissolved, and analysis finds 0.2200 g of chlorine. Only the NaCl contains chlorine. NaCl is \(\dfrac{35.45}{58.44} = 60.66\%\) chlorine, so the mass of NaCl is \(0.2200 / 0.6066 = 0.3627\) g, and the mixture is 36.27% NaCl and 63.73% potassium nitrate by mass.
The skill in both purity problems is to identify which component carries the element you measured, find that element’s mass fraction in the component, and divide.
Exam focus
Percent means grams if you assume 100 g. This one move starts nearly every empirical formula problem.
Always convert to moles before comparing. Comparing masses tells you nothing about atom ratios.
Do not round a non-whole ratio. 1.5 means multiply by 2. Only round values within about 0.1 of a whole number.
Empirical is not molecular. The molecular formula is a whole-number multiple of the empirical one, found from the molar mass.
A pure substance has a fixed composition; a mixture does not. Use this to decide between a compound and a mixture from data on several samples.
Practice
Iron(III) oxide is Fe2O3. What is its mass percent iron?
Show answer
M = 2(55.845) + 3(15.999) = 159.687 g/mol. Iron: \(111.690 / 159.687 = 0.6994\), so 69.94% iron.
Two samples of a pure compound of carbon and oxygen contain 3.00 g C with 8.00 g O, and 6.00 g C with 16.0 g O. Does this agree with the law of definite proportions?
Show answer
Yes. The mass ratio O : C is 8.00 / 3.00 = 2.67 in the first sample and 16.0 / 6.00 = 2.67 in the second. The ratio is the same for different sample sizes, which is what the law predicts for a pure compound.
Analysis of a compound gives 85.7% carbon and 14.3% hydrogen by mass. Find the empirical formula.
Show answer
In 100 g: C = 85.7 / 12.011 = 7.14 mol; H = 14.3 / 1.008 = 14.19 mol. Dividing by 7.14: C 1.00, H 1.99. The empirical formula is CH2.
The compound in question 3 has a molar mass of 56.1 g/mol. What is its molecular formula?
Show answer
The empirical formula mass of CH2 is 12.011 + 2(1.008) = 14.027. \(56.1 / 14.027 = 4.00\), so the molecular formula is C4H8.
A sample labeled pure CaCO3 is found to contain 36.0% calcium. Is it pure? If not, estimate its purity assuming the only calcium compound present is CaCO3.
Show answer
Pure CaCO3 is 40.04% calcium, so the sample is not pure. Its purity is \(36.0 / 40.04 = 0.899\), about 89.9% CaCO3.
A student claims that because seawater contains the same elements everywhere, it is a compound. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is wrong. Seawater is a mixture: its salt content varies from place to place (and can be changed by evaporation), and its components can be separated physically. A compound has a fixed composition by mass, as stated in the law of definite proportions.
Almost everything in chemistry, from why sodium explodes in water to why diamond is hard, comes down to how electrons are arranged around nuclei.
The arrangement is not random. Electrons occupy a definite set of energy levels, fill them in a predictable order, and the pattern of that filling is
exactly what the shape of the periodic table records. In this lesson you learn to write that arrangement, the
electron configuration, for any atom or ion, and the physical law that explains why it takes the form it does.
Learning objective · 1.5.A
Represent the ground-state electron configuration of an atom of an element or its ions using the Aufbau principle.
Required content · EK 1.5.A.1 to 1.5.A.4
The atom is composed of negatively charged electrons and a positively charged nucleus that is made of protons and neutrons.
Coulomb’s law is used to calculate the force between two charged particles: \(F \propto \dfrac{q_1 q_2}{r^2}\).
In atoms and ions, the electrons can be thought of as being in “shells (energy levels)” and “subshells (sublevels),” as described by the ground-state electron configuration. Inner electrons are called core electrons, and outer electrons are called valence electrons. The configuration is explained by quantum mechanics, as delineated in the Aufbau principle and exemplified in the periodic table.
The relative energy required to remove an electron from different subshells of an atom or ion, or from the same subshell in different atoms or ions (ionization energy), can be estimated through a qualitative application of Coulomb’s law. This energy is related to the distance from the nucleus and the effective (shield) charge of the nucleus.
Exclusion: assigning quantum numbers to electrons in subshells is not assessed.
Particles in the atom
An atom has a tiny, dense nucleus of protons (charge +1, mass about 1 amu) and neutrons (no charge, mass about 1 amu), surrounded by electrons
(charge −1, mass about 1/1836 amu). The number of protons is the atomic number, Z, and defines the element. A neutral atom has equal numbers of protons and electrons.
An ion has gained or lost electrons: a cation (positive) has lost them, an anion (negative) has gained them. A sodium atom has 11 electrons; the Na+ ion has 10.
Coulomb’s law
The force between two charged particles depends on the size of the charges and the distance between them:
\[ F \propto \dfrac{q_1\, q_2}{r^2} \]
Opposite charges attract and like charges repel. The attraction grows when the charges are larger and when the particles are closer, and it falls off with the square of the distance.
This single relationship, used qualitatively, explains the whole of Unit 1: how strongly an electron is held depends on the charge pulling it in and how far away it is.
Figure 1.4a Coulomb’s law: the force between charged particles is proportional to the product of the charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance. Doubling the distance cuts the force to one fourth; quadrupling the charge product quadruples the force.
Worked example · scaling with Coulomb’s law
Two ions attract each other with force \(F\). How does the force change if (a) the charges change from +1 and −1 to +2 and −1, and (b) the distance is also doubled?
(a) The product of the charges goes from 1 to 2, so the force doubles: \(2F\). (b) Doubling \(r\) divides the force by \(2^2 = 4\), so the force becomes \(2F / 4 = F/2\).
Shells and subshells
Electrons are found in shells, numbered \(n = 1, 2, 3, \ldots\) with higher numbers farther from the nucleus and higher in energy.
Each shell is divided into subshells labeled s, p, d and f. Shell 1 has only s; shell 2 has s and p; shell 3 has s, p and d; shell 4 has s, p, d and f.
A subshell holds a fixed number of electrons because it contains orbitals, each holding at most two electrons:
Subshell
Orbitals
Maximum electrons
s
1
2
p
3
6
d
5
10
f
7
14
The inner electrons are core electrons; the electrons in the outermost shell are valence electrons, and they are the ones that take part in bonding.
The Aufbau principle
The ground state is the lowest-energy arrangement. The Aufbau principle (German for “building up”) says electrons fill the lowest-energy subshell available first.
The order of increasing energy is
\[ 1s,\ 2s,\ 2p,\ 3s,\ 3p,\ 4s,\ 3d,\ 4p,\ 5s,\ 4d,\ 5p,\ 6s,\ 4f,\ 5d,\ 6p,\ 7s,\ 5f,\ldots \]
Note that 4s fills before 3d. You do not need to memorize the list: the periodic table is the memory aid, because its blocks are the subshells
(two columns of s, six of p, ten of d, fourteen of f) and its rows run along the filling order.
Figure 1.4b The order in which subshells are filled in the ground state of an atom, read left to right and then on the second row. The periodic table is organized to follow this order.
A configuration is written as subshell labels with the electron count as a superscript: sodium (Z = 11) is \(1s^2\,2s^2\,2p^6\,3s^1\), where the sum of superscripts (2 + 2 + 6 + 1) is 11.
The shorthand replaces the core with the previous noble gas in brackets: Na is [Ne] 3s1. Here are more examples:
Species
Electrons
Configuration
Oxygen, O
8
1s2 2s2 2p4
Chlorine, Cl
17
[Ne] 3s2 3p5
Iron, Fe
26
[Ar] 4s2 3d6
Sodium ion, Na+
10
1s2 2s2 2p6 (same as Ne)
Chloride ion, Cl−
18
[Ne] 3s2 3p6 (same as Ar)
Iron(II) ion, Fe2+
24
[Ar] 3d6
Ions and the order of removal
To write an anion’s configuration, add the extra electrons to the next available spots. For a cation, remove electrons from the outermost shell first, which is the highest value of \(n\), not the last subshell filled.
That is why Fe2+ loses its two 4s electrons (the outer shell) and not two 3d electrons, giving [Ar] 3d6. Transition metals follow this rule.
Orbital diagrams: Hund’s rule
An orbital diagram draws each orbital as a box and each electron as an arrow. Two electrons in the same orbital must have opposite spins (one up, one down). When filling a subshell with several orbitals,
Hund’s rule says electrons occupy separate orbitals with parallel spins before any orbital gets a second electron. This minimizes repulsion between electrons.
Nitrogen (2p3) has three unpaired electrons; oxygen (2p4) has two unpaired electrons and one pair.
Figure 1.4c Orbital diagrams. Electrons fill the boxes of a subshell one at a time with parallel spins (Hund’s rule) before pairing, and no box holds more than two electrons with opposite spins (the Pauli exclusion principle).
The number of unpaired electrons tells you whether an atom is paramagnetic (attracted to a magnet; has one or more unpaired electrons) or diamagnetic (weakly repelled; all electrons paired).
Nitrogen and oxygen atoms are paramagnetic. Neon, with every orbital filled, is diamagnetic.
Worked example · configuration, valence electrons and unpaired electrons
Write the configuration of phosphorus (Z = 15), count its valence electrons, and say how many are unpaired.
Fill in order. 1s² (2) → 2s² (4) → 2p⁶ (10) → 3s² (12) → 3p³ (15). The configuration is \(1s^2\,2s^2\,2p^6\,3s^2\,3p^3\), or [Ne] 3s2 3p3.
Valence electrons. Those in shell 3: 2 + 3 = 5.
Unpaired. The three 3p electrons occupy three orbitals singly (Hund’s rule), so there are 3 unpaired electrons.
Worked example · identifying an element from its ion
An ion with charge 2+ has the configuration 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p⁶. Which element is it?
The ion has 18 electrons. A 2+ charge means two electrons were lost, so the neutral atom had 20 electrons and Z = 20: calcium, Ca2+.
One note on scope: chromium and copper (and a few others) do not follow the Aufbau pattern exactly, because a half-filled or filled 3d subshell is slightly more stable. Writing the configurations of these exceptions will not be assessed on the AP Exam.
Exam focus
Check the total. The superscripts must add to the number of electrons (not the atomic number) of the species. For an ion, count the electrons first.
4s before 3d to fill; 4s before 3d to empty. Cations lose the outermost-shell electrons first.
Valence electrons are in the highest shell (for main-group elements, the group number tells you how many).
Coulomb’s law is the reason. Free-response explanations of why one electron is held more tightly than another should name the nuclear charge and the distance.
Draw unpaired electrons separately in a p, d or f subshell until each orbital has one.
Practice
Write the ground-state configuration of sulfur (Z = 16) and state the number of valence electrons.
Show answer
Write the configuration of the calcium ion, Ca2+, and name the noble gas it matches.
Show answer
Ca has 20 electrons ([Ar] 4s²). Removing two 4s electrons gives 18 electrons: 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p⁶, the same as argon.
Write the configuration of Fe3+ (Z = 26) and state the number of unpaired electrons.
Show answer
Fe is [Ar] 4s² 3d⁶. To make Fe³⁺, remove the two 4s electrons and then one 3d electron: [Ar] 3d⁵. Five d electrons in five orbitals means 5 unpaired electrons.
How many unpaired electrons does an atom of nitrogen have, and is it paramagnetic or diamagnetic?
Show answer
Nitrogen is 1s² 2s² 2p³. By Hund’s rule the three 2p electrons are in separate orbitals, so there are 3 unpaired electrons and the atom is paramagnetic.
Particle X has a charge of +2 and particle Y has −2 at a separation of \(r\). The particles are moved to a separation of \(3r\). By what factor does the attractive force change?
Show answer
The charges are unchanged, but \(r\) triples, so the force is divided by \(3^2 = 9\). It becomes one-ninth of the original.
Explain why the 1s electron in a helium atom is held more tightly than the 1s electron in a hydrogen atom, even though both are in the 1s subshell.
Show answer
Helium has two protons (+2 nuclear charge) while hydrogen has one (+1). The 1s electrons are at about the same distance, so by Coulomb’s law the greater nuclear charge in helium produces a stronger attraction. (The second electron repels only partly, so the net pull is still larger.)
Electron configurations are not just a bookkeeping device. They can be measured. A technique called photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) fires high-energy light at a sample and
records the energy it takes to knock each electron out. The resulting graph is a direct picture of an atom’s shells and subshells: a series of peaks, one for each subshell, with their heights
counting the electrons. In this lesson you learn to read these spectra and to use Coulomb’s law to explain where the peaks fall.
Learning objective · 1.6.A
Explain the relationship between the photoelectron spectrum of an atom or ion and (i) the ground-state electron configuration of the species and (ii) the interactions between the electrons and the nucleus.
Required content · EK 1.6.A.1
The energies of the electrons in a given shell can be measured experimentally with photoelectron spectroscopy (PES). The position of each peak in the PES spectrum is related to the energy required to remove an electron from the corresponding subshell, and the relative height of each peak is (ideally) proportional to the number of electrons in that subshell.
How PES works
A beam of photons of known energy strikes a gas-phase sample. A photon with enough energy ejects an electron, and the instrument measures the electron’s kinetic energy. Energy is conserved:
\[ E_{\text{photon}} = E_{\text{binding}} + E_{\text{kinetic}} \]
so the binding energy (the energy needed to remove the electron from its subshell) is the photon energy minus the measured kinetic energy. Electrons held tightly give up less kinetic energy and show a large binding energy.
Each subshell has its own characteristic binding energy, so electrons from the same subshell show up together as one peak.
Reading a PES spectrum
The spectrum plots relative number of electrons (peak height) against binding energy, and by convention the energy axis runs from high on the left to low on the right.
Two rules do all the work:
Position = subshell. Peaks farther left (higher binding energy) belong to subshells closer to the nucleus. The leftmost peak is 1s, then 2s, then 2p, and so on.
Height = number of electrons. A peak twice as tall as another holds twice as many electrons in that subshell.
Figure 1.5a Photoelectron spectra (binding energies approximate). The position of a peak tells how strongly electrons of that subshell are held; the height tells how many electrons are in it. Neon is 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ and sodium is 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s¹.
The neon spectrum has three peaks, at 870, 48.5 and 21.6 eV, with relative heights 2 : 2 : 6. Match them to subshells from the left: 1s with 2 electrons, 2s with 2, and 2p with 6, which is 1s² 2s² 2p⁶, the configuration of neon (Z = 10).
Sodium has the same first three peaks (at much higher energies) and one extra small peak at the far right, at 5.14 eV, a single electron: the 3s electron. Adding it up gives 2 + 2 + 6 + 1 = 11 electrons, so the element has Z = 11, sodium.
The number of peaks equals the number of occupied subshells, and the sum of the relative heights equals the number of electrons. For a neutral atom, that number is the atomic number.
Explaining peak positions with Coulomb’s law
Why does the 1s peak for sodium (1071 eV) sit so far to the left of the 1s peak for neon (870 eV)? Sodium’s nucleus carries a charge of +11 and neon’s +10.
The 1s electrons in both atoms are at nearly the same distance and are barely shielded, so by Coulomb’s law the larger nuclear charge holds the 1s electrons more tightly, and more energy is needed to remove them.
The same reasoning explains every comparison of the same subshell across elements: more protons, same shielding, higher binding energy.
Within one atom, the peaks fall in order because inner electrons are closer to the nucleus (a smaller \(r\) in Coulomb’s law) and feel more of its charge (less shielding by other electrons). The 1s electrons of sodium need 1071 eV;
the outermost 3s electron, far from the nucleus and shielded by ten inner electrons, needs only 5.14 eV.
The large jump in binding energy between shells (1071 to 63.5 to 5.14 eV) is the experimental evidence for the shell model.
Worked example · element from a spectrum
A PES spectrum of a neutral atom shows peaks with relative heights 2, 2, 3 at binding energies of 410, 25.7 and 14.5 eV. Identify the element.
Step 1. Three peaks means three occupied subshells: 1s, 2s, 2p. The heights give the electrons: 1s² 2s² 2p³.
Step 2. The total is 2 + 2 + 3 = 7 electrons, so Z = 7: nitrogen.
Worked example · comparing two spectra
Spectrum A has peaks at 1311, 88.7, 49.5 and 7.65 eV with heights 2, 2, 6, 2. Spectrum B has peaks at 1071, 63.5, 30.6 and 5.14 eV with heights 2, 2, 6, 1. Identify both and explain why the leftmost peak of A is at higher energy.
A is 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s², 12 electrons: magnesium. B is 1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s¹, 11 electrons: sodium. The 1s electrons in magnesium (nuclear charge +12) are attracted more strongly than those in sodium (+11) at nearly the same distance, so the 1s peak of magnesium sits at the higher binding energy.
Worked example · energy balance
An X-ray photon of 1486.6 eV ejects a sodium 1s electron (binding energy 1071 eV). What is the electron’s kinetic energy?
The spectrum of an ion has the same pattern as the matching noble-gas-like configuration. Na+ has 10 electrons, so its spectrum shows three peaks with heights 2 : 2 : 6 and no 3s peak. The peaks of the ion are shifted to somewhat higher energy compared with the atom,
because with fewer electrons there is less repulsion and each remaining electron feels a stronger net pull from the nucleus.
Exam focus
Left means harder to remove. The high-energy end is on the left of the axis.
Do not read the peak height as energy. Height counts electrons; position gives the energy.
Use the sum of the heights. Neutral atom: the total is the atomic number. Ion: adjust for the charge.
A full explanation names Coulomb’s law. State the nuclear charge, the distance or the shielding, and the effect on the attraction.
Treat heights as electron counts. Real spectra are only roughly proportional, but on the exam the relative heights give the number of electrons in each subshell.
Practice
A neutral atom shows two peaks with relative heights 2 and 1. Identify the element and write its configuration.
Show answer
Two subshells with 2 and 1 electrons: 1s² 2s¹, 3 electrons, so Z = 3: lithium.
A PES spectrum has peaks of relative height 2, 2, 6, 2, 4 (left to right). Identify the element.
Show answer
1s² 2s² 2p⁶ 3s² 3p⁴: 16 electrons, so Z = 16: sulfur.
On a PES spectrum, the peak at the far right is tallest in spectrum X and is the same height as the others in spectrum Y. What can you infer about the outermost subshell in each?
Show answer
The tallest peak at the far right means the outermost subshell holds the most electrons in X. A peak the same height as the others in Y means the outermost subshell holds a similar number of electrons as the others. Height always counts electrons, so compare with the subshell capacities (s 2, p 6).
Explain why the 1s peak of oxygen is at a higher binding energy than the 1s peak of carbon.
Show answer
Oxygen has 8 protons and carbon has 6. The 1s electrons are at about the same distance and are not shielded by other electrons, so by Coulomb’s law the larger nuclear charge of oxygen pulls them harder, and more energy is needed to remove them.
An electron is ejected from an atom by a photon of 100.0 eV and leaves with a kinetic energy of 63.5 eV. What was its binding energy?
Show answer
\(E_{\text{binding}} = 100.0 - 63.5 = 36.5\) eV.
Describe how the PES spectrum of Na+ differs from that of Na.
Show answer
Na+ lacks the 3s electron, so its spectrum has only three peaks (1s, 2s, 2p) with heights 2 : 2 : 6 and no peak at the low-energy end near 5 eV. The remaining peaks are slightly shifted to higher energy.
Dmitri Mendeleev arranged the elements by mass and noticed that properties recur at regular intervals. We now know why: the table is organized by electron configuration,
and properties such as size and the grip on outer electrons repeat whenever a new shell begins. This lesson gives you the working tools of periodicity,
effective nuclear charge and shielding, and applies them to four properties: ionization energy, atomic and ionic radius, electron affinity and electronegativity.
Everything is an application of Coulomb’s law.
Learning objective · 1.7.A
Explain the relationship between trends in atomic properties of elements and electronic structure and periodicity.
Required content · EK 1.7.A.1 to 1.7.A.3
The organization of the periodic table is based on patterns of recurring properties of the elements, which are explained by patterns of ground-state electron configurations and the presence of completely or partially filled shells (and subshells) of electrons in atoms.
Trends in atomic properties within the periodic table (periodicity) can be predicted by the position of the element on the periodic table and qualitatively understood using Coulomb’s law, the shell model, and the concepts of shielding and effective nuclear charge. These properties include ionization energy, atomic and ionic radii, electron affinity and electronegativity.
The periodicity is useful to predict or estimate values of properties in the absence of data.
Exclusion: writing the configuration of elements that are exceptions to the Aufbau principle is not assessed.
Shielding and effective nuclear charge
A valence electron is attracted by the nucleus but repelled by the other electrons. The inner (core) electrons shield it: they sit between the nucleus and the valence electron and cancel part of the nuclear charge.
The net pull the valence electron feels is the effective nuclear charge, \(Z_{\text{eff}}\), roughly the nuclear charge minus the number of core electrons. For sodium that is about 11 − 10 = +1; for chlorine about 17 − 10 = +7.
Figure 1.6c Effective nuclear charge. Core electrons shield valence electrons from part of the nuclear charge, so Zeff ≈ Z − (core electrons). Both atoms have 10 core electrons, but chlorine’s larger Z gives a stronger pull on its valence shell.
Two facts organize all of the trends:
Across a period (left to right) protons are added but the new electrons go into the same shell, which shields almost not at all. \(Z_{\text{eff}}\) increases, and the valence electrons are pulled in and held more tightly.
Down a group a whole new shell is added. The valence electrons are farther from the nucleus (larger \(r\)) and shielded by more core electrons, so they are held more loosely even though the nuclear charge is larger.
Ionization energy
The first ionization energy is the energy needed to remove one electron from a gaseous atom: \(\text{X}(g) \rightarrow \text{X}^+(g) + e^-\). A high value means the electron is held tightly.
By the two facts above, ionization energy increases across a period and decreases down a group.
Figure 1.6a First ionization energies across period 2 (kJ/mol). The general rise comes from increasing effective nuclear charge; the dips at B (a higher-energy 2p subshell) and O (a paired 2p electron that is repelled) are the exceptions you are expected to explain.
The graph for period 2 rises overall from lithium (520 kJ/mol) to neon (2081 kJ/mol), with two dips. Beryllium (900) to boron (800): the boron electron being removed is in a 2p subshell, which is higher in energy and slightly farther out than the 2s electrons of beryllium, and partly shielded by them.
Nitrogen (1402) to oxygen (1314): in oxygen the electron removed comes from a 2p orbital that holds two electrons; the repulsion between the pair makes that electron easier to remove than the unpaired electron in nitrogen.
Successive ionization energies
Removing a second, third and later electron costs more each time, because the remaining electrons feel a larger net pull from the same nuclear charge. The key pattern is a huge jump when the first core electron is removed.
Sodium needs 496 kJ/mol for the first electron and 4562 kJ/mol for the second, a jump of about nine times. That tells you sodium has one valence electron, because the second comes from the inner shell, which is much closer to the nucleus.
Figure 1.6e Successive ionization energies (kJ/mol). A large jump shows that the next electron comes from an inner shell: the jump after IE1 for Na, after IE2 for Mg and after IE3 for Al shows the number of valence electrons (1, 2, 3).
Worked example · the group from successive ionization energies
An element has ionization energies (kJ/mol) of 578, 1817, 2745 and 11,577 for the first four electrons. How many valence electrons does it have, and what element in period 3 is it?
The big jump is between the third and fourth, so three electrons are valence electrons (group 13). In period 3, group 13 is aluminum.
Atomic radius
Atomic radius is half the distance between nuclei of two bonded atoms. It decreases across a period (rising \(Z_{\text{eff}}\) pulls the shell in) and increases down a group (added shells).
Sodium (186 pm) to chlorine (99 pm), and lithium (152 pm) to cesium (265 pm) show the two directions.
Figure 1.6b Atomic radius increases down a group (more shells) and decreases across a period (greater effective nuclear charge pulls the same shell closer). Values are approximate.
Ionic radius
A cation is smaller than its atom: it has lost its outermost shell (or, for a few cases, the electron count falls so repulsion drops) and the same nuclear charge now holds fewer electrons. Na (186 pm) becomes Na+ (102 pm).
An anion is larger than its atom: electrons are added to the same shell with the same nuclear charge, so repulsion rises and the cloud expands. Cl (99 pm) becomes Cl− (181 pm).
For isoelectronic species (the same number of electrons), the one with the larger nuclear charge is smaller: O2− (8 protons, 140 pm) is bigger than F−, which is bigger than Na+ (11 protons, 102 pm), which is bigger than Mg2+ (12 protons, 72 pm).
Figure 1.6d Atoms and their ions (radii in pm, approximate). Losing electrons makes a cation smaller (fewer electrons, and often the outer shell is gone); gaining electrons makes an anion larger (more electron-electron repulsion for the same nuclear charge).
Electron affinity and electronegativity
Electron affinity is the energy change when a gaseous atom gains an electron. Elements near the top right (the halogens especially) release the most energy because the added electron meets a high \(Z_{\text{eff}}\)
(chlorine releases 349 kJ/mol). Noble gases and some elements with filled subshells do not add an electron favorably.
Electronegativity is a different idea: how strongly an atom in a bond attracts the shared electrons. It follows the same pattern as ionization energy: it increases across a period and decreases down a group, so fluorine is the most electronegative element and the elements at the lower left (cesium, francium) the least.
The AP course uses electronegativity as a qualitative guide to bond polarity in Unit 2.
Property
Across a period (→)
Down a group (↓)
Reason
Atomic radius
Decreases
Increases
Zeff up across; new shells down
First ionization energy
Increases (with small dips)
Decreases
Tighter grip across; farther and shielded down
Electronegativity
Increases
Decreases
Same as ionization energy
Electron affinity
Generally more negative (exceptions)
Generally less negative
Zeff and distance
Worked example · a full free-response explanation
Explain why the first ionization energy of sodium (496 kJ/mol) is lower than that of lithium (520 kJ/mol).
Both atoms have one valence electron. In sodium it is in the third shell and in lithium in the second, so the sodium valence electron is farther from the nucleus. It is also shielded by ten core electrons rather than two.
Although sodium has a larger nuclear charge (+11 against +3), the greater distance and shielding mean that by Coulomb’s law the attraction to the valence electron is weaker, so less energy is needed to remove it.
Exam focus
Every answer needs three parts: the comparison (nuclear charge, distance, shielding), the Coulomb’s law consequence (weaker or stronger attraction), and the result (easier or harder to remove).
Do not say “it wants a full shell.” Atoms do not want; explain with forces and distances.
Cations shrink, anions grow. Compare isoelectronic ions by nuclear charge.
Use the jump. A very large increase in successive ionization energy marks the end of the valence electrons.
Know the two dips in period 2 ionization energy and the reason for each (subshell change; paired electrons).
Practice
Rank Li, Na and K from lowest to highest first ionization energy and justify the ranking.
Show answer
K < Na < Li. Down the group the valence electron is in a higher shell, farther from the nucleus and shielded by more core electrons, so it is held less tightly and removed more easily.
Rank Na, Mg, Al and Cl by atomic radius, largest first, and explain.
Show answer
Na > Mg > Al > Cl. All are in period 3, so the valence electrons are in the same shell, but the nuclear charge increases from 11 to 17 with almost no extra shielding, so the electron cloud is pulled in.
The successive ionization energies of an element (kJ/mol) are 738, 1451, 7733 and 10,540. Identify its group and a likely ion charge.
Show answer
The jump is between the second and third ionization energy, so there are two valence electrons (group 2). It will form an ion with charge 2+ (and is magnesium, if in period 3).
Explain why the Cl− ion (181 pm) is larger than the Cl atom (99 pm).
Show answer
Cl− has one more electron than the atom but the same nuclear charge (+17). The added electron increases electron-electron repulsion in the third shell and each electron feels a smaller share of the nuclear attraction, so the electron cloud expands.
Arrange K+, Ca2+ and Cl− from smallest to largest and explain.
Show answer
Ca2+ < K+ < Cl−. All have 18 electrons (isoelectronic), so the ion with the most protons pulls the electrons in the most: Ca (20) > K (19) > Cl (17).
The first ionization energy of oxygen (1314 kJ/mol) is lower than that of nitrogen (1402 kJ/mol), even though oxygen is farther right. Explain.
Show answer
The electron removed from oxygen comes from a 2p orbital that already holds two electrons. The repulsion between the paired electrons raises the energy of that electron, so it is easier to remove than the unpaired 2p electron of nitrogen, which is in an orbital by itself.
Sodium is a soft metal that reacts violently with water; chlorine is a poisonous green gas. Put them together and you get table salt, a stable white solid you sprinkle on food.
The change is explained entirely by valence electrons: sodium has one it can give up easily, and chlorine has a vacancy for one it holds strongly. This lesson uses periodic trends to predict
which elements bond, what charges they take, and what formulas their ionic compounds have.
Learning objective · 1.8.A
Explain the relationship between trends in the reactivity of elements and periodicity.
Required content · EK 1.8.A.1 to 1.8.A.3
The likelihood that two elements will form a chemical bond is determined by the interactions between the valence electrons and nuclei of elements.
Elements in the same column of the periodic table tend to form analogous compounds.
Typical charges of atoms in ionic compounds are governed by the number of valence electrons and predicted by their location on the periodic table.
Valence electrons and the periodic table
For the main-group elements (groups 1, 2 and 13 to 18), the number of valence electrons is set by the column: group 1 has 1, group 2 has 2, group 13 has 3, and so on up to 8 for the noble gases (helium has 2).
Because elements in the same column have the same valence configuration (all of group 1 is \(ns^1\), all of group 17 is \(ns^2 np^5\)), they behave alike and form analogous compounds.
If you know that NaCl, KCl and LiCl exist, you can predict RbCl; if you know H2O, you can predict H2S.
Why ions form: ionization energy and electron affinity
Atoms with low ionization energies (metals, at the left of the table) lose their valence electrons fairly easily. Atoms with high electron affinity (nonmetals, at the right) gain electrons.
When a metal meets a nonmetal, electrons move from the metal to the nonmetal. The result is a positive cation and a negative anion, held together by the Coulomb attraction between opposite charges: an ionic bond.
Figure 1.7b Formation of an ionic compound. The valence electron of sodium moves to chlorine; each ion ends with a noble-gas electron configuration, and the oppositely charged ions attract each other (Coulomb’s law).
Notice that removing electrons costs energy, so the transfer by itself is not favorable (sodium’s ionization energy is 496 kJ/mol while chlorine releases only 349 kJ/mol on gaining an electron).
The energy that makes the compound stable is the large attraction of the ions in the solid lattice, which you will compare in Unit 2.
What the periodic trends tell you now is which atoms are good donors and acceptors.
Typical charges
Main-group atoms tend to form ions with the electron configuration of the nearest noble gas, because the next electron to remove (or add) would be from or to a very different energy level. This is why successive ionization energies jump after the valence electrons,
as you saw in the last lesson. The typical charge follows from the group:
Figure 1.7a Typical ion charges of main-group elements follow from the valence electrons: metals lose electrons to reach the electron configuration of the previous noble gas, and nonmetals gain electrons to reach that of the next noble gas.
Group
Valence e−
Typical ion
Examples
1
1
1+
Li+, Na+, K+
2
2
2+
Mg2+, Ca2+, Ba2+
13
3
3+
Al3+
15
5
3−
N3−, P3−
16
6
2−
O2−, S2−
17
7
1−
F−, Cl−, Br−
The transition metals (groups 3 to 12) do not follow a single rule, because their valence electrons are in both the s and d subshells, which are close in energy. They commonly form several charges: iron makes Fe2+ and Fe3+, copper makes Cu+ and Cu2+.
Their ionic compounds are named with a Roman numeral, as in iron(III) oxide. The cation always has the same charge-balance rule as any other.
Formulas from charges
An ionic compound is electrically neutral overall, so the total positive charge equals the total negative charge. Find the smallest numbers of each ion that balance.
Worked example · writing formulas
Calcium and chlorine. Ca2+ and Cl−: one calcium needs two chlorides, so CaCl2.
Aluminum and oxygen. Al3+ and O2−: the least common multiple of 3 and 2 is 6, so two aluminum (+6) and three oxygen (−6): Al2O3.
Magnesium and nitrogen. Mg2+ and N3−: three magnesium (+6) and two nitrogen (−6): Mg3N2.
Check. The formula units come out as the empirical formulas of Lesson 1.3. Check that the charges sum to zero: \(2(+3) + 3(-2) = 0\).
Reactivity trends
The reactivity of a metal depends on how easily it loses electrons. Going down group 1, ionization energy falls (Li 520, Na 496, K 419 kJ/mol), so reactivity with water rises:
lithium fizzes steadily, sodium melts into a ball and darts about, potassium bursts into flame.
For nonmetals, reactivity depends on how strongly an atom attracts electrons. Going down group 17 the electron-attracting ability falls, so fluorine is the most reactive halogen, then chlorine, bromine and iodine.
Both statements are Coulomb’s law again: farther from the nucleus and more shielded means weaker control over electrons.
Worked example · predicting a reaction
Predict the formula of the compound formed by strontium and iodine, and compare its likely reactivity with that of calcium and iodine.
Strontium is in group 2 (Sr2+) and iodine in group 17 (I−), so the compound is SrI2. Strontium is in the same group as calcium, so it forms an analogous compound, CaI2. Strontium is below calcium, with a lower first and second ionization energy, so it loses electrons slightly more easily and reacts a little more vigorously.
Exam focus
The group number gives the valence electrons and, for main-group elements, the typical charge.
Ions are neutral overall. Always check that the formula’s charges balance.
Reasoning from trends, not from memory. “Sodium reacts more vigorously than lithium because its valence electron is farther away and more shielded, so less energy is needed to remove it” earns the point; “because it is bigger” does not.
Transition metals vary. Do not give them one fixed charge; use the name or the problem to decide.
Use analogies. If you are asked about an unfamiliar compound, find a member of the same group you do know.
Practice
Write the formula of the compound formed from barium and bromine.
Show answer
Barium is in group 2 (Ba2+) and bromine in group 17 (Br−). Two bromides balance one barium: BaBr2.
Write the formula of aluminum sulfide and state the charge on each ion.
Show answer
Al3+ and S2−. Two Al (+6) balance three S (−6): Al2S3.
An element in period 3 has first through fourth ionization energies (kJ/mol) of 496, 4562, 6910 and 9543. What is the formula of its compound with chlorine?
Show answer
The jump after the first ionization energy shows one valence electron (group 1, sodium), so the ion is Na+ and the compound is NaCl.
Explain why potassium is more reactive than lithium toward water.
Show answer
Potassium’s valence electron is in the fourth shell, farther from the nucleus and shielded by more core electrons than lithium’s valence electron in the second shell. By Coulomb’s law the attraction to the nucleus is weaker, so the first ionization energy is lower (419 against 520 kJ/mol) and potassium loses its electron more easily.
Why do sodium and potassium form analogous compounds, such as NaCl and KCl?
Show answer
Both are in group 1 and have one valence electron (ns1), so both form 1+ ions and combine with chlorine in a 1 : 1 ratio.
Predict the charge of the most common ion of selenium (group 16) and write the formula of its compound with sodium.
Show answer
Selenium has 6 valence electrons and typically gains 2 to form Se2−. Two Na+ balance one Se2−, so the formula is Na2Se.
Unit 1 practice · 10 problems
Unit 1 practice: Atomic Structure and Properties
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on
paper before revealing the answer: the reveal shows the key steps, not just the
number. Calculator allowed; use \(N_A = 6.022 \times 10^{23}\) and periodic-table masses.
How many moles of calcium nitrate, Ca(NO3)2, are in a 45.0 g sample? How many nitrate ions does it contain?
Show answer
Molar mass: \(40.08 + 2(14.01) + 6(16.00) = 164.10\) g/mol. \(n = 45.0 / 164.10 = 0.274\) mol. Each formula unit has two NO3−: \(0.274 \times 2 \times 6.022 \times 10^{23} = 3.30 \times 10^{23}\) nitrate ions.
What is the mass, in grams, of \(4.25 \times 10^{23}\) molecules of water?
A mass spectrum of an element shows peaks at 27.977 amu (92.23%), 28.976 amu (4.67%), and 29.974 amu (3.10%). Compute the average atomic mass and identify the element.
Show answer
\(0.9223(27.977) + 0.0467(28.976) + 0.0310(29.974) = 25.80 + 1.353 + 0.929 = 28.09\) amu. The periodic table gives 28.09 for silicon. Check: the average sits just above the dominant 28 peak, pulled slightly up by the two heavier isotopes.
A mass spectrum of an element shows two peaks: one at 63 amu that is three times as tall as the other at 65 amu. The average atomic mass is closest to
63.0 would be the average only if every atom had mass 63, but one atom in four is the 65 isotope, so the weighted average must sit above 63. The heavier peak is small, but it is not zero.
Heights 3 : 1 mean fractions 0.75 and 0.25: \(0.75(63) + 0.25(65) = 63.5\) amu: copper. The average always lies between the peaks and is pulled toward the taller one.
64.0 is the simple midpoint of 63 and 65, which treats the two isotopes as equally abundant. The 3 : 1 peak-height ratio means abundances of 75% and 25%, so the average is pulled toward 63.
64.5 would require the 65 peak to be the taller one (75% of the atoms at 65 amu). This choice reverses which isotope is more abundant.
Iron(III) oxide, Fe2O3, is the main ore of iron. What is the mass percent of iron, and what mass of iron can be obtained from 25.0 g of pure Fe2O3?
Show answer
Molar mass \(= 2(55.85) + 3(16.00) = 159.70\) g/mol. \(\%\mathrm{Fe} = \dfrac{111.70}{159.70} \times 100\% = 69.94\%\). Mass of Fe: \(25.0\ \mathrm{g} \times 0.6994 = 17.5\) g.
A hydrocarbon is 92.26% carbon and 7.74% hydrogen by mass, with a molar mass of 78.11 g/mol. Find its empirical and molecular formulas.
Show answer
Per 100 g: C \(92.26/12.01 = 7.682\) mol; H \(7.74/1.008 = 7.679\) mol. Ratio 1 : 1 → empirical formula CH, mass 13.02 g/mol. \(78.11 / 13.02 = 6.00\), so the molecular formula is C6H6 (benzene).
Write the full and noble-gas electron configurations of selenium (Z = 34). How many unpaired electrons does a Se atom have? Write the configuration of Se2−.
Show answer
1s22s22p63s23p64s23d104p4 = [Ar]4s23d104p4. By Hund's rule the four 4p electrons occupy three orbitals as one pair plus two singles: 2 unpaired. Se2− gains two electrons to fill 4p: [Ar]4s23d104p6, the same as krypton.
A photoelectron spectrum shows peaks at about 39.6, 2.45, and 1.40 MJ/mol with relative heights 2 : 2 : 3. Identify the element, and explain why the 39.6 MJ/mol peak is so far from the other two.
Show answer
Highest energy first: 1s2, 2s2, 2p3: seven electrons, so nitrogen. The 1s electrons are in the \(n = 1\) shell, much closer to the nucleus and with no inner electrons to shield them, so they feel nearly the full +7 charge; by Coulomb's law the attraction (\(\propto q_1 q_2 / r^2\)) is far stronger and far more energy is needed to remove them. The 2s and 2p electrons are farther out and shielded by the 1s pair.
Ca2+, K+, and Cl− each have 18 electrons. Rank them from smallest to largest radius and justify with Coulomb's law.
Show answer
Ca2+ < K+ < Cl−. Same number of electrons in the same shells, so shielding is identical; the ion with more protons (Ca 20, K 19, Cl 17) exerts a stronger pull on each electron, drawing the cloud in. Isoelectronic ions shrink as nuclear charge grows.
An element has successive ionization energies (kJ/mol) of 578, 1817, 2745, and 11,577. How many valence electrons does it have, which group is it in, and why is the fourth value so much larger than the third?
Show answer
The huge jump comes between the third and fourth electrons, so three valence electrons: group 13 (this is aluminum). The first three electrons come from the \(n = 3\) shell; the fourth must be pulled from the \(n = 2\) core, which is much closer to the nucleus and shielded only by the two 1s electrons, and it is being removed from an ion that already carries a +3 charge.
A diamond will cut glass, a salt crystal shatters when struck, a copper wire carries electricity, and a candle wax softens in your hand.
These very different behaviors trace back to one question: what are the atoms in the substance doing with their valence electrons?
Atoms can share them, transfer them, or pool them with many neighbors, and the choice is governed by a single property you met in Unit 1, the ability of an atom to attract electrons.
This lesson sorts bonds into three families and shows why the borders between them are blurry.
Learning objective · 2.1.A
Explain the relationship between the type of bonding and the properties of the elements participating in the bond.
Required content · EK 2.1.A.1 to 2.1.A.5
Electronegativity values for the representative elements increase going from left to right across a period and decrease going down a group. These trends can be understood qualitatively through the electronic structure of the atoms, the shell model, and Coulomb’s law.
Valence electrons shared between atoms of similar electronegativity constitute a nonpolar covalent bond. For example, bonds between carbon and hydrogen are effectively nonpolar even though carbon is slightly more electronegative than hydrogen.
Valence electrons shared between atoms of unequal electronegativity constitute a polar covalent bond. The atom with the higher electronegativity develops a partial negative charge relative to the other atom. In single bonds, greater differences in electronegativity lead to greater bond dipoles. All polar bonds have some ionic character, and the difference between ionic and covalent bonding is not distinct but rather a continuum.
The difference in electronegativity is not the only factor in determining if a bond should be designated as ionic or covalent. Generally, bonds between a metal and nonmetal are ionic, and bonds between two nonmetals are covalent. Examination of the properties of a compound is the best way to characterize the type of bonding.
In a metallic solid, the valence electrons from the metal atoms are considered to be delocalized and not associated with any individual atom.
Electronegativity
Electronegativity measures how strongly an atom attracts the shared electrons in a bond. It follows the same trend as ionization energy, for the same reason you learned in Unit 1:
across a period the effective nuclear charge rises and the valence shell stays the same distance away, and down a group the valence electrons are farther out and more shielded.
So electronegativity increases from left to right and decreases from top to bottom, and fluorine, at the top right, is the most electronegative element.
Some approximate Pauling values: Na 0.9, H 2.1, C 2.5, N 3.0, Cl 3.0, O 3.5, F 4.0. (The exam does not require memorizing numbers; it expects you to rank atoms from their positions.)
The three families of bonds
Ionic
Covalent
Metallic
Between
metal and nonmetal
two nonmetals
metal atoms
Electrons
transferred from one atom to another
shared between two atoms
delocalized over the whole solid
Example
NaCl, MgO
H2O, CO2, diamond
Cu, Fe, brass
Properties of solids
hard and brittle, high melting point, conduct only when molten or dissolved
molecular solids are soft with low melting points; network solids are very hard
conduct as solids, malleable, ductile, shiny
Covalent bonds: nonpolar and polar
In a nonpolar covalent bond the two atoms attract the shared electrons about equally, so the electron cloud sits in the middle. Bonds between identical atoms (Cl–Cl, O=O) are perfectly nonpolar, and so are bonds between atoms of very similar electronegativity,
such as C–H (2.5 and 2.1). The AP course treats C–H as effectively nonpolar, which is why hydrocarbons behave as nonpolar substances.
When the atoms differ in electronegativity, the bond is a polar covalent bond: the electrons are shared unequally and the more electronegative atom carries a partial negative charge, written δ−, while the other carries δ+.
The pair of separated partial charges is a bond dipole, drawn as an arrow pointing toward the δ− end. In single bonds, the larger the difference in electronegativity, the larger the bond dipole.
Ranked: H–F (ΔEN = 1.9) is more polar than H–Cl (0.9), which is more polar than H–I (0.4).
Figure 2.1b The shaded cloud shows where the shared electrons spend their time. The greater the difference in electronegativity, the more the cloud shifts to one atom. All polar bonds have some ionic character.
A continuum, not three boxes
As ΔEN grows, the shared electrons are pulled further toward one atom, until in the limit one atom has taken them: an ionic bond. All polar bonds have some ionic character, and even the most ionic compounds have a little covalent character.
The classification is a guide, not a wall.
Figure 2.1a Bonding is a continuum, not three separate boxes. Chlorine with chlorine (ΔEN = 0) shares electrons equally; hydrogen with chlorine shares them unequally; sodium with chlorine is mostly ionic. The labels are guides, not sharp cutoffs.
The electronegativity difference is useful but is not the only criterion. The simplest rule is that a metal plus a nonmetal gives an ionic compound, and two nonmetals give a covalent one. The most reliable test is to examine the properties of the substance:
a solid that is hard and brittle, melts above 600 °C, and conducts electricity when molten but not as a solid is ionic. A substance that is a gas, liquid or low-melting solid and does not conduct is molecular.
Metallic bonding
In a metal, each atom gives up its valence electrons to a common pool. The result is an array of positive ions (the cores) surrounded by delocalized valence electrons that belong to no one atom, often called the “sea of electrons.”
Figure 2.1c Metallic bonding: a lattice of positive ions in a “sea” of delocalized valence electrons that belong to no single atom. This explains electrical conductivity, malleability and luster.
The sea explains what you can see. Because the electrons move freely, a metal conducts electricity and heat. Because layers of ions can slide over each other while the electrons keep holding them together, metals are
malleable (can be hammered flat) and ductile (can be drawn into wire). The electrons interact with light, which gives metals their luster.
Worked example · classify and rank
Classify the bonds in each of NaF, HBr, Br2 and Fe, and rank the three covalent or ionic ones by bond polarity.
NaF: metal and nonmetal, large ΔEN (0.9 and 4.0), so ionic. HBr: two nonmetals, H 2.1 and Br 2.8, polar covalent with δ+ on H and δ− on Br. Br2: identical atoms, nonpolar covalent. Fe: metallic.
Ranking by polarity (most to least): NaF, then HBr, then Br2.
Worked example · connecting bonding to properties
Solid A melts at 801 °C, shatters when hammered, and does not conduct as a solid but conducts when melted. Solid B melts at 1085 °C, bends when hammered and conducts as a solid. What type of bonding does each most likely have?
A is ionic: high melting point, brittle, and conducts only when its ions are free to move (molten). B is metallic: it conducts as a solid because delocalized electrons carry charge, and it deforms without breaking because the electron sea holds shifted layers together.
Exam focus
Use the position on the periodic table to rank electronegativity and say which atom gets the δ−.
Polar is about unequal sharing; ionic is about transfer. Do not call HCl ionic because it is polar.
Explain properties by the particles. “Metals conduct because they have delocalized valence electrons that can move” earns the point; “because they are metals” does not.
C–H counts as nonpolar on the AP exam even though carbon is slightly more electronegative.
Use the word continuum when asked about the difference between ionic and covalent.
Practice
Rank the bonds C–F, C–O and C–N from most to least polar, and identify the partial negative end of each.
Show answer
C–F > C–O > C–N. Fluorine, oxygen and nitrogen are increasingly farther left in period 2, so their electronegativity (4.0, 3.5, 3.0) and difference from carbon (2.5) decrease in that order. In each bond the second atom carries δ−.
Classify each substance as ionic, polar covalent, nonpolar covalent or metallic: MgCl2, CH4, NH3, N2, Al.
Show answer
Explain why a copper wire can be bent into a loop without breaking but a crystal of sodium chloride breaks when struck.
Show answer
In copper the positive ions are held by a delocalized electron sea, so layers can slide while the electrons continue to bond the whole lattice. In sodium chloride a shift of layers brings ions of the same charge next to each other, and the repulsion splits the crystal.
A student says that a bond between two atoms is either 100% ionic or 100% covalent. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is wrong. Bonding is a continuum: equal sharing between identical atoms is the covalent extreme, but any bond between different atoms has unequal sharing, and all polar bonds have some ionic character. Even NaCl has a little covalent character.
Substance X is a solid at room temperature, melts at 1710 °C, is hard, and does not conduct electricity even when melted or dissolved. Which bonding type is NOT likely to be its main type?
Show answer
It is not metallic (a metal would conduct) and not ionic (an ionic compound would conduct when molten). The data fit a covalent network solid, in which atoms are bonded in a continuous covalent lattice, as in silicon dioxide.
Place the following in order of increasing electronegativity: Na, Cl, S, Mg.
Show answer
Na < Mg < S < Cl. All are in period 3, and electronegativity increases from left to right across a period as the effective nuclear charge increases.
Why do two hydrogen atoms bond at all, and why do they stop at a particular distance instead of merging completely? The answer is an energy story.
Every pair of atoms has a potential energy that depends on how far apart they are, and a bond forms at the separation where that energy is lowest.
Reading that energy curve, and knowing how it shifts for different atoms, is a core AP skill. It also gives you a second use of Coulomb’s law: ranking the strength of ionic attractions from the charges and sizes of the ions.
Learning objective · 2.2.A
Represent the relationship between potential energy and distance between atoms, based on factors that influence the interaction strength.
Required content · EK 2.2.A.1 to 2.2.A.3
A graph of potential energy versus the distance between atoms (internuclear distance) is a useful representation for describing the interactions between atoms. Such graphs illustrate both the equilibrium bond length (the separation at which the potential energy is lowest) and the bond energy (the energy required to separate the atoms).
In a covalent bond, the bond length is influenced by both the size of the atom’s core and the bond order (single, double, triple). Bonds with a higher order are shorter and have larger bond energies.
Coulomb’s law can be used to understand the strength of interactions between cations and anions. Because the interaction strength is proportional to the charge on each ion, larger charges lead to stronger interactions. Because it increases as the distance between the centers of the ions decreases, smaller ions lead to stronger interactions.
The potential energy curve
Choose zero energy for two atoms very far apart. As they approach, each nucleus begins to attract the other atom’s electrons, and the potential energy falls: the attraction wins.
But if the atoms keep coming together, the nuclei repel each other and the electron clouds repel each other, and the energy shoots up steeply. In between is a minimum.
Figure 2.2a As two atoms approach, attraction lowers the energy until electron and nuclear repulsion take over. The minimum is the equilibrium bond length; the depth of the well is the bond energy, the energy needed to separate the atoms. (Curve shown for H2.)
Three features of the graph matter:
Equilibrium bond length: the internuclear distance at the lowest point of the curve. For H2 it is 74 pm. At larger distances attraction pulls the atoms in; at smaller distances repulsion pushes them out.
Bond energy: the depth of the well, measured from zero (separated atoms) down to the minimum. It is the energy that must be supplied to separate the atoms completely. For H2 it is 436 kJ/mol.
Stability: the bonded pair is lower in energy than the separated atoms, which is why the bond forms. A deeper well means a more stable, stronger bond.
A graph that you are asked to analyze may compare two molecules. The one whose minimum is lower (a deeper well) has the larger bond energy; the one whose minimum is at a smaller distance has the shorter bond.
Note that energy released in forming the bond equals energy required to break it, and that breaking a bond always absorbs energy.
Bond order, length and energy
The bond order is the number of shared electron pairs: 1 for a single bond, 2 for a double, 3 for a triple. More shared pairs pull the nuclei closer together and bind them more tightly, so for the same two atoms
a higher bond order gives a shorter, stronger bond.
Figure 2.2b Higher bond order means a shorter and stronger bond. More shared electron pairs pull the nuclei closer and take more energy to separate.
Bond length also depends on the size of the atoms’ cores. Larger atoms have more shells, so their nuclei sit farther apart when bonded: the H–F bond (92 pm) is shorter than H–Cl (127 pm), which is shorter than H–Br (141 pm), and the bond energy falls in the same order.
Longer bonds are generally weaker because the shared electrons are farther from both nuclei.
Worked example · comparing two graphs
The potential energy curves for molecule X2 and Y2 have minima at (110 pm, −945 kJ/mol) and (141 pm, −159 kJ/mol). Which has the stronger bond, which has the longer bond, and which has the higher bond order?
X2 has the deeper well (−945 kJ/mol against −159), so its bond energy is larger: it is the stronger bond. Y2 has the larger equilibrium distance, so it has the longer bond. A shorter, stronger bond points to the higher bond order, so X2 has the higher bond order (like N≡N, 110 pm and 945 kJ/mol, against F–F, 141 pm and 159 kJ/mol).
Coulomb’s law in ionic bonds
In an ionic solid the attraction between a cation and an anion follows Coulomb’s law: it is proportional to the product of the charges and falls off as the square of the distance between the centers of the ions:
\[ F \propto \dfrac{q_1\,q_2}{r^2} \]
So two things strengthen an ionic bond: larger charges and smaller ions (which let the centers get closer).
Figure 2.2c Coulomb’s law for ionic solids: the attraction is proportional to the product of the charges and gets stronger as the ions get closer. MgO has charges twice as large and ions that are closer together, so its ionic bonds are much stronger and it melts about 2000 °C higher.
Worked example · NaCl against MgO
Compare the attraction in NaCl (Na+ 102 pm, Cl− 181 pm) with that in MgO (Mg2+ 72 pm, O2− 140 pm).
Charges. NaCl: (+1)(−1), magnitude 1. MgO: (+2)(−2), magnitude 4. The charge product is 4 times larger in MgO.
Comparison. \(\dfrac{F_{\text{MgO}}}{F_{\text{NaCl}}} = \dfrac{4}{1} \times \left(\dfrac{283}{212}\right)^2 = 4 \times 1.78 = 7.1\). The ion pair in MgO attracts about seven times as strongly. This is why MgO melts at 2852 °C and NaCl at 801 °C.
Worked example · ranking with a pattern
Rank LiF, NaF and KF by the strength of their ionic bonding.
All have charges +1 and −1, so the charge product is the same. Going down group 1 the cation gets larger (Li+ < Na+ < K+), so the distance between centers grows and the attraction falls: LiF > NaF > KF.
Exam focus
Label the graph correctly. The bond length is read on the horizontal axis at the minimum; the bond energy is the vertical distance from zero to the minimum, not the y-value of the minimum read as a positive number from zero.
Higher bond order: shorter and stronger. Say both.
A complete Coulomb answer names both charge and distance. If the charges are equal, argue from size; if the sizes are similar, argue from charge.
Distance means the centers of the ions, the sum of the two ionic radii.
Breaking bonds absorbs energy; forming bonds releases it.
Practice
On a potential energy curve, what happens to the energy of two bonded atoms if they are pushed closer together than the equilibrium bond length? Explain.
Show answer
The energy rises steeply. At shorter distances the repulsion between the two nuclei and between the electron clouds becomes larger than the attraction, so the system is less stable than at the equilibrium separation.
Rank the bonds C–C, C=C and C≡C by length and by energy.
Show answer
Length: C≡C (120 pm) < C=C (134 pm) < C–C (154 pm). Energy: C≡C (839 kJ/mol) > C=C (614) > C–C (347). A higher bond order gives a shorter and stronger bond.
Explain why the H–Cl bond (127 pm) is longer than the H–F bond (92 pm).
Show answer
Chlorine is in period 3 and fluorine is in period 2, so chlorine has a larger core with an extra shell. The shared electrons are farther from the nucleus, so the bonded nuclei settle at a larger separation.
Rank NaF, MgO and CaO by expected strength of ionic bonding and justify.
Show answer
MgO > CaO > NaF. MgO and CaO have charges of 2+ and 2−, so a charge product of 4, and NaF only 1. Between MgO and CaO the Mg2+ ion is smaller than Ca2+, so the ion centers are closer and the attraction is stronger in MgO.
The energy released when two atoms form a bond is 243 kJ/mol. What energy is needed to break one mole of these bonds, and is the process exothermic or endothermic?
Show answer
Breaking requires 243 kJ/mol, equal to the energy released in forming the bond. Breaking is endothermic (energy absorbed); forming is exothermic.
Two ion pairs have the same charges. Pair 1 has ions with radii of 95 pm and 133 pm; pair 2 has radii of 133 pm and 181 pm. Which pair has the stronger attraction and by roughly what factor?
Show answer
Distances between centers: pair 1 = 228 pm, pair 2 = 314 pm. Pair 1 is stronger. The force ratio is \((314/228)^2 = 1.90\), so pair 1 attracts about twice as strongly.
Table salt and a steel nail are both solids built from huge numbers of particles packed in repeating patterns, yet one shatters and the other bends.
The difference lies in how the particles are arranged and what holds them together. This lesson builds particle-level pictures of two kinds of solid, ionic crystals and metals,
and then shows how mixing metals produces alloys with new properties. As always, the goal is to explain a visible property from a model of the particles.
Learning objectives · 2.3.A and 2.4.A
2.3.A Represent an ionic solid with a particulate model that is consistent with Coulomb’s law and the properties of the constituent ions.
2.4.A Represent a metallic solid and/or alloy using a model to show essential characteristics of the structure and interactions present in the substance.
Required content · EK 2.3.A.1 and 2.4.A.1 to 2.4.A.3
The cations and anions in an ionic crystal are arranged in a systematic, periodic 3-D array that maximizes the attractive forces among cations and anions while minimizing the repulsive forces.
Metallic bonding can be represented as an array of positive metal ions surrounded by delocalized valence electrons (a “sea of electrons”).
Interstitial alloys form between atoms of significantly different radii, where the smaller atoms fill the interstitial spaces between the larger atoms (for example, steel, in which carbon occupies the interstices in iron).
Substitutional alloys form between atoms of comparable radius, where one atom substitutes for the other in the lattice (for example, in certain brass alloys, other elements, usually zinc, substitute for copper).
Exclusion: knowledge of specific crystal structures is not assessed.
Ionic crystals
An ionic compound does not consist of separate NaCl molecules. Instead, trillions of ions are stacked in a regular, repeating three-dimensional array called a crystal lattice.
Each cation is surrounded by anions, and each anion by cations. This arrangement is not an accident: it is the pattern that puts opposite charges as close as possible (maximizing attraction) and keeps like charges as far apart as possible (minimizing repulsion).
Figure 2.3a Cross section of an ionic crystal: a regular, repeating three-dimensional array in which cations and anions alternate. The arrangement maximizes attraction between opposite charges and minimizes repulsion between like charges. (Specific crystal structures are not assessed.)
When you draw a particle model of an ionic solid, follow the rules the figure obeys: alternating positive and negative ions; every ion touching ions of the opposite charge; cations drawn smaller than anions (cations have lost their outer shell; anions have gained electrons and expanded);
and the overall array neutral, with the ratio of ions matching the formula (in CaCl2, twice as many chloride ions as calcium ions).
Properties of ionic solids from the model
High melting points and hardness. Every ion is held by many strong Coulomb attractions in all directions. Melting requires pulling the lattice apart, which takes a lot of energy (NaCl melts at 801 °C).
Brittleness. A blow can shift one layer of the crystal by one ion position, which lines up like charges next to each other. The repulsion splits the crystal along that plane.
Electrical conductivity. A solid does not conduct because its ions are locked in place and there are no mobile electrons. Molten or dissolved, the ions are free to move and carry current.
Figure 2.3b Why ionic solids are brittle: a blow slides one layer over another, bringing ions of the same charge side by side. The repulsion splits the crystal along the layer. Metals do not break this way because their electrons are shared by the whole lattice.
Metals revisited: structure and properties
The model of a metal from the last lesson is a lattice of positive ions in a sea of delocalized valence electrons. Unlike the ionic crystal, nothing here depends on the exact arrangement of charges, so the layers can slide.
This model explains the properties of metals directly:
Malleable and ductile: shifted layers stay bound by the electron sea.
Good conductors of heat and electricity: the electrons are free to move.
Luster: the mobile electrons absorb and re-emit light.
High melting points in general (but varying widely): more valence electrons in the sea and smaller cores give stronger bonding, so sodium melts at 98 °C and tungsten at 3422 °C.
Alloys
An alloy is a mixture of a metal with other elements, which is usually harder or stronger than the pure metal. Why? Foreign atoms disturb the regular layers, so they cannot slide as easily. The two types differ in how the second atom fits.
Figure 2.4a Two kinds of alloy. In an interstitial alloy the atoms differ greatly in size and the small atoms fill the gaps. In a substitutional alloy the atoms have comparable radii and one replaces the other in the lattice.
Interstitial alloy
Substitutional alloy
Atom sizes
significantly different radii
comparable radii
Where the second atom goes
in the gaps (interstices) between larger atoms
replaces a host atom in the lattice
Example
steel: carbon in iron
brass: zinc in copper; sterling silver: copper in silver
Effect
much harder and stronger, less ductile
harder than pure metal, still fairly ductile
Steel with a little carbon is much stronger than pure iron because the small carbon atoms jam the layers; the more carbon, the harder and more brittle the steel.
In brass, zinc atoms (about the same size as copper) sit in copper positions and break up the regular rows enough to make the alloy harder than copper while remaining a good conductor.
Worked example · classify an alloy from atomic radii
Iron has an atomic radius of 126 pm, carbon 77 pm, copper 128 pm and zinc 134 pm. Classify each pairing, and justify.
Fe and C: the radii differ greatly (carbon is about 60% of the size of iron), so carbon fits in the gaps: interstitial. Cu and Zn: radii differ by only about 5%, so zinc can replace copper in the lattice: substitutional.
Worked example · ionic solid model
Describe a particulate model of calcium fluoride, CaF2, and the likely behavior under a hammer.
The model shows Ca2+ ions (small) and F− ions (larger) in a repeating array with two fluoride ions for every calcium ion, each calcium surrounded by fluoride and each fluoride by calcium. The solid is hard with a high melting point (1418 °C) and brittle, since displacement of a layer puts like charges adjacent.
Exam focus
Draw ions alternating and in the formula ratio, cations smaller than anions.
Explain brittleness with repulsion between like charges, not with “the bonds are weak.” The bonds are strong; it is the shift in alignment that causes the break.
Conductivity depends on mobile charge carriers: ions (liquid or aqueous) or electrons (metals). A solid ionic compound has neither.
Match the alloy type to the radii. Very different radii mean interstitial; similar radii mean substitutional.
An alloy is a mixture, so its composition can vary.
Practice
Sketch the ratio of ions in a particulate model of magnesium chloride, MgCl2, and say what is different from a model of NaCl.
Show answer
The model has two Cl− for every Mg2+, so more anions than cations. In NaCl the ratio is 1 : 1. In both, cations are smaller than anions and are surrounded by anions.
Explain why solid potassium iodide does not conduct electricity but molten potassium iodide does.
Show answer
In the solid, K+ and I− ions are fixed in the lattice and cannot move; there are no free electrons. When molten, the ions are free to move and carry charge.
Pure gold is soft; 14-karat gold is an alloy with copper and silver atoms of similar size. What type of alloy is it, and why is it harder?
Show answer
It is a substitutional alloy, because gold, silver and copper have comparable atomic radii and the atoms replace one another in the lattice. The differently sized atoms disrupt the regular layers, so the layers do not slide as easily and the alloy is harder than pure gold.
Why does steel with 1% carbon resist deformation better than pure iron?
Show answer
It is an interstitial alloy: small carbon atoms sit in the gaps between iron atoms and lock the layers so they cannot slide over one another easily.
A solid conducts electricity, bends without breaking, and has a shiny surface. Which type of particulate model best fits, and what particles carry the current?
Show answer
A metallic model: positive ions in a sea of delocalized electrons. The mobile valence electrons carry the current.
Compare the melting points of sodium (98 °C) and magnesium (650 °C) using the electron-sea model.
Show answer
Magnesium has two valence electrons per atom in the sea and a smaller, more highly charged core (Mg2+) than sodium (Na+), so the attraction between the ions and the electron sea is stronger and more energy is needed to melt it.
To predict how a molecule behaves, you first need to know how its atoms are connected and where its electrons are. A Lewis diagram is the chemist’s quickest way to record both.
It is a bookkeeping device with firm rules: every valence electron is placed somewhere, either in a shared pair (a bond) or in a lone pair. Drawing these diagrams is a skill you will use for the rest of the course,
for shape and polarity (this unit), for intermolecular forces (Unit 3) and for acids and bases (Unit 8).
Learning objective · 2.5.A
Represent a molecule with a Lewis diagram.
Required content · EK 2.5.A.1
Lewis diagrams can be constructed according to an established set of principles.
What a Lewis diagram shows
A Lewis diagram (also called a Lewis structure) uses element symbols for the nuclei and core electrons, a line for each bonding pair of electrons shared by two atoms,
and a pair of dots for each lone pair (nonbonding pair) on an atom. A single line is a single bond, two lines a double bond, three a triple bond.
Most second-period atoms in stable molecules follow the octet rule: each is surrounded by eight electrons (counting each bond line as two electrons). Hydrogen is the exception; it is complete with 2 electrons, a duet.
The routine
Figure 2.5a A reliable routine for Lewis diagrams. Always finish by checking that the electrons in the diagram equal the count from step 1.
Count the total valence electrons. Add the group number of each atom. For an anion add one electron for each unit of negative charge; for a cation subtract one for each unit of positive charge.
Draw the skeleton. Put the least electronegative atom (other than hydrogen) in the center and connect each outer atom with a single bond. Hydrogen is always on the outside because it can form only one bond.
Give each outer atom an octet with lone pairs (hydrogen needs no lone pairs).
Place any remaining electrons on the central atom.
Check the central atom. If it has fewer than 8 electrons, move a lone pair from an outer atom into a bond to make a double (or triple) bond until the central atom has an octet.
Verify: the total electrons shown must equal the count from step 1.
Worked example · carbon dioxide, CO2
1. C has 4 and each O has 6: 4 + 2(6) = 16 electrons.
2. Carbon is less electronegative, so O–C–O (2 bonds use 4 electrons).
3. Each O gets three lone pairs (12 electrons). Total used: 4 + 12 = 16, so none are left.
5. Carbon has only 4 electrons around it. Move one lone pair from each oxygen into a bond: O=C=O. Now each atom has 8 electrons, and the count is still 16.
Worked example · hydrogen cyanide, HCN
1. H 1 + C 4 + N 5 = 10 electrons.
2 and 3. Skeleton H–C–N uses 4 electrons. Nitrogen gets three lone pairs (6 electrons), so all 10 are placed. But carbon has only 4 electrons around it.
5. Move two lone pairs from nitrogen into the C–N bond to make a triple bond: H–C≡N, with one lone pair left on N. Carbon now has 2 + 6 = 8 electrons and nitrogen has 6 + 2 = 8.
6. Check. H–C (2) + C≡N (6) + lone pair on N (2) = 10 electrons. ✓
Figure 2.5b Each line is a shared pair (two electrons) and each pair of dots is a lone pair. Water and ammonia have lone pairs on the central atom; carbon dioxide has two double bonds; in methane all four electron pairs are bonding pairs.
Worked example · a polyatomic ion, ammonium NH4+
N 5 + 4(1) − 1 (for the + charge) = 8 electrons. Four N–H bonds use all 8, nitrogen has an octet, and each hydrogen has a duet. Draw brackets around the structure and write the charge outside: [NH4]+. There are no lone pairs on nitrogen, because all four of its pairs are bonding pairs.
Where the octet rule has limits
Incomplete octets: Atoms of boron (and beryllium) can be stable with fewer than eight electrons. BF3 has 24 electrons and boron has only six around it (three single bonds).
Expanded octets: Atoms from period 3 and below (P, S, Cl, Xe and others) can hold more than eight electrons. SF6 has 48 electrons and sulfur has 12 around it. These appear when the central atom has more than four attached atoms or lone pairs.
Odd numbers of electrons: A molecule such as NO (11 electrons) cannot satisfy the octet rule for every atom. The model has limits here, which lesson 2.5 returns to.
The best way to avoid mistakes: after drawing, count the electrons around every atom and the total in the diagram. A diagram that fails either test is wrong, however neat it looks.
Exam focus
The total electron count controls everything. Count first; check last.
Charges matter. Subtract an electron for each positive charge and add for each negative charge.
The central atom is the least electronegative (and never H). Carbon is nearly always central.
Lone pairs count as electron domains for shape (lesson 2.6), so draw every one.
Do not show an octet for hydrogen. Hydrogen has 2 electrons.
Practice
How many valence electrons must be shown in the Lewis diagram of the sulfate ion, SO42−?
Show answer
S 6 + 4(6) = 30, plus 2 for the 2− charge = 32 electrons.
Draw the Lewis diagram of PCl3 and state the number of lone pairs on phosphorus.
Show answer
P 5 + 3(7) = 26 electrons. P is the center with three single bonds to Cl (6 electrons). Each Cl gets three lone pairs (18), for a total of 24, and the remaining 2 electrons form one lone pair on P. So phosphorus has 1 lone pair, and every atom has an octet.
Draw the Lewis diagram of H2CO (formaldehyde) and describe the bond between C and O.
Show answer
H 2(1) + C 4 + O 6 = 12 electrons. Skeleton: C in the center bonded to two H and one O (6 electrons). Oxygen gets 3 lone pairs (6) for 12 total, but carbon has only 6 around it. Move one lone pair from O into the C–O bond: C=O is a double bond, and O keeps two lone pairs. Carbon: 2 + 2 + 4 = 8.
Draw the Lewis diagram of the cyanide ion, CN−.
Show answer
C 4 + N 5 + 1 = 10 electrons. A triple bond C≡N with one lone pair on each atom: each atom has 2 + 6 = 8 electrons. The diagram is shown in brackets with a − charge.
Explain why BF3 is an exception to the octet rule.
Show answer
Boron has three valence electrons and forms three single bonds to fluorine, giving it only 6 electrons. Moving lone pairs from fluorine to make double bonds would put positive formal charge on very electronegative fluorine, so the stable diagram keeps the incomplete octet on boron.
A student draws H2O with a double bond to one hydrogen. Why is this wrong?
Show answer
Hydrogen has only the 1s orbital and is full with 2 electrons, so it can form only one bond. A double bond would put four electrons around hydrogen, which is not possible.
Sometimes the electron rules give you not one Lewis diagram but several, and the experiments say that none of them is quite right.
In ozone, a single diagram suggests one long bond and one short bond, yet careful measurement finds two bonds of exactly equal length.
Chemists solve this with a refinement called resonance. And when different valid diagrams really are different, a bookkeeping quantity called formal charge tells you which is the best model.
This lesson gives you both tools, and also honest limits for the whole Lewis model.
Learning objective · 2.6.A
Represent a molecule with a Lewis diagram that accounts for resonance between equivalent structures or that uses formal charge to select between nonequivalent structures.
Required content · EK 2.6.A.1 to 2.6.A.3
In cases where more than one equivalent Lewis structure can be constructed, resonance must be included as a refinement to the Lewis structure. In many such cases, this refinement is needed to provide qualitatively accurate predictions of molecular structure and properties.
The octet rule and formal charge can be used as criteria for determining which of several possible valid Lewis diagrams provides the best model for predicting molecular structure and properties.
As with any model, there are limitations to the use of the Lewis structure model, particularly in cases with an odd number of valence electrons.
Resonance
Ozone, O3, has 18 valence electrons. A good Lewis diagram has one O=O double bond and one O–O single bond, and you can draw it with the double bond on the left or on the right. These two diagrams differ only in the placement of electrons,
not atoms, and they are exactly equivalent. They are called resonance structures, joined by a double-headed arrow.
Figure 2.6a Resonance. Neither Lewis diagram alone describes ozone: the molecule has two identical O–O bonds, each between a single and a double bond. The double-headed arrow means the actual structure is a hybrid, not a rapid switch between the two. (Formal charges are shown in color.)
The real molecule is neither one. Measurement shows the two O–O bonds in ozone are identical, 128 pm long, between the length of an O–O single bond (148 pm) and an O=O double bond (121 pm). The true electronic structure is a hybrid
(an average) of the resonance structures, with the electrons of the extra bond delocalized over the three atoms. The molecule does not flip back and forth; a mule is not a horse part of the time and a donkey the rest. Each resonance structure is a flawed picture of one real thing.
For the bond order of a hybrid, average over the structures. In ozone each O–O bond is single in one structure and double in the other, so its bond order is \(\dfrac{1 + 2}{2} = 1.5\).
Worked example · the nitrate ion, NO3−
Electrons. N 5 + 3(6) + 1 (charge) = 24. Skeleton: N in the center with three O atoms. After three N–O single bonds (6) and lone pairs on each O (18), all 24 electrons are placed, but N has only 6. Move a lone pair from one O into a bond: one N=O and two N–O.
Equivalent structures. The double bond can go to any of the three oxygens, so there are three equivalent resonance structures. They must all be shown (or the hybrid described).
Bond order. Each N–O bond is double in one of three structures and single in two: \(\dfrac{2 + 1 + 1}{3} = \dfrac{4}{3} \approx 1.33\). All three N–O bonds are equal in length (about 124 pm), longer than N=O in a true double bond and shorter than a single bond, and each oxygen carries the same share of the negative charge.
Resonance shows up whenever a double bond could be placed in more than one position: the carbonate ion CO32−, the sulfur dioxide molecule, and the benzene ring, which has six identical carbon-carbon bonds of order 1.5.
Rule of thumb: if the structures can be written with the same atoms in the same positions and only the electrons moved, they are resonance structures.
Formal charge
Not every set of valid diagrams is equivalent. Carbon dioxide can be drawn O=C=O or as O≡C–O. Both obey the octet rule, but which is the better model? Compare how electrons are assigned to each atom with the formal charge:
\[ \text{formal charge} = (\text{valence electrons}) - (\text{nonbonding electrons}) - (\text{number of bonds}) \]
Formal charge pretends every bond is shared perfectly equally. Each atom is given all of its lone-pair electrons and half of its bonding electrons (which is one electron per bond). It is not the real charge, only a tool.
The formal charges of all atoms in a species add up to the overall charge of the species.
Figure 2.6b Both structures obey the octet rule and have 16 electrons, but A is the better model because every formal charge is zero. Formal charge = (valence electrons) − (nonbonding electrons) − (number of bonds).
Worked example · computing formal charges
Structure A, O=C=O. Each O: 6 − 4 − 2 = 0. C: 4 − 0 − 4 = 0. All zero.
Structure B, O≡C–O. Left O (triple bond, one lone pair): 6 − 2 − 3 = +1. C: 4 − 0 − 4 = 0. Right O (single bond, three lone pairs): 6 − 6 − 1 = −1. The sum is 0, matching a neutral molecule.
Structure A is preferred because its formal charges are all zero.
Choosing the best Lewis structure
The best structure obeys the octet rule for as many atoms as possible.
Formal charges should be as close to zero as possible.
If charges are unavoidable, a negative formal charge should sit on the more electronegative atom, and like charges should not be on adjacent atoms.
Worked example · selecting between structures
The thiocyanate ion, SCN− (16 electrons), could be drawn S=C=N, S–C≡N or S≡C–N, all with the right electron count. The formal charges are: S=C=N: S 0, C 0, N −1; S–C≡N: S −1, C 0, N 0; S≡C–N: S +1, C 0, N −2.
The last is poor (large charges). Between the first two, the negative charge belongs on the more electronegative atom, nitrogen (3.0) rather than sulfur (2.5), which favors S=C=N; but S–C≡N, with the charge on sulfur and a triple bond to nitrogen, also contributes strongly, and thiocyanate is best described as a resonance hybrid dominated by these two.
Limits of the model
The Lewis model is just that: a model. It has real limitations. It assigns electrons in pairs, so it fails for molecules with an odd number of valence electrons, like nitrogen monoxide, NO (11 electrons), and NO2 (17).
No arrangement gives every atom an octet, and the formal charges cannot all be zero. It also cannot explain why O2 is attracted to a magnet (it has two unpaired electrons, but the Lewis diagram O=O shows none),
and it treats all bonds as localized, so it needs resonance to describe delocalized electrons. A good model is useful within its limits; part of the AP skill is saying when it breaks down.
Exam focus
Resonance structures differ only in the placement of electrons, never of atoms. Use the arrow with two heads.
The molecule is a hybrid, not a mixture and not a flipping between structures.
Bond order of a delocalized bond is the average, and it predicts a bond length between single and double.
Show the formal-charge arithmetic in free response: valence − nonbonding − bonds.
State a limit when asked about the model, such as odd-electron molecules.
Practice
Calculate the formal charge on each atom of the hydroxide ion, OH− (O with three lone pairs and one bond to H).
Show answer
O: 6 − 6 − 1 = −1. H: 1 − 0 − 1 = 0. The sum is −1, the charge on the ion.
How many resonance structures can be drawn for the carbonate ion, CO32−, and what is the C–O bond order?
Show answer
Three equivalent structures (the C=O double bond can be on any of the three oxygens). The bond order is \((2 + 1 + 1)/3 = 4/3 \approx 1.33\) for each C–O bond.
Experimental data show that both N–O bonds in the nitrite ion, NO2−, are 124 pm. A single N–O bond is about 136 pm and a double N=O bond about 115 pm. Explain the data with a Lewis model.
Show answer
Two equivalent resonance structures can be drawn, with N=O on either side. The real ion is a hybrid with a bond order of 1.5 in each N–O bond, so the lengths are the same and between the single and double values.
For nitrous oxide, N2O (16 electrons), compare N≡N–O with N=N=O using formal charges. Which is the better model?
Show answer
N≡N–O: first N (one lone pair, three bonds) 5 − 2 − 3 = 0; central N (four bonds) 5 − 0 − 4 = +1; O (three lone pairs, one bond) 6 − 6 − 1 = −1. N=N=O: first N (two lone pairs, two bonds) 5 − 4 − 2 = −1; central N +1; O (two lone pairs, two bonds) 6 − 4 − 2 = 0. Both have charges of +1 and −1, but the first puts the −1 on the more electronegative oxygen, so N≡N–O is the better single structure (the real molecule is a hybrid of the two).
Why can the Lewis model not give an accurate diagram of nitrogen dioxide, NO2?
Show answer
NO2 has 17 valence electrons, an odd number. The model places electrons in pairs, so one electron must be left unpaired and not every atom can have an octet.
A student says that ozone constantly switches between its two resonance structures. Correct the statement.
Show answer
Ozone does not switch. Its structure is a single hybrid in which both O–O bonds are identical and delocalized (bond order 1.5). The two resonance structures are two inadequate drawings of one real arrangement of electrons.
Water is bent and carbon dioxide is straight. That one difference is why water is a liquid that dissolves salt and carbon dioxide is a gas that barely dissolves in it.
A Lewis diagram tells you which atoms are bonded but not the three-dimensional shape of the molecule, and shape controls polarity, intermolecular forces, and how molecules fit together in biology and materials.
This lesson turns a Lewis diagram into a shape, then into a prediction about polarity, hybridization and the kinds of bonds present.
Learning objective · 2.7.A
Based on the relationship between Lewis diagrams, VSEPR theory, bond orders and bond polarities: (i) explain structural properties of molecules; (ii) explain electron properties of molecules.
Required content · EK 2.7.A.1 to 2.7.A.4
VSEPR theory uses the Coulombic repulsion between electrons as a basis for predicting the arrangement of electron pairs around a central atom.
Both Lewis diagrams and VSEPR theory must be used for predicting electronic and structural properties of many covalently bonded molecules and polyatomic ions, including molecular geometry (linear, trigonal planar, tetrahedral, trigonal pyramidal, bent, trigonal bipyramidal, seesaw, T-shaped, octahedral, square pyramidal, square planar), bond angles, relative bond energies based on bond order, relative bond lengths, the presence of a dipole moment, and hybridization of valence orbitals.
The terms “hybridization” and “hybrid atomic orbital” are used to describe the arrangement of electrons around a central atom. When the central atom is sp hybridized, its ideal bond angles are 180°; for sp2 they are 120°; for sp3 they are 109.5°.
Bond formation is associated with overlap between atomic orbitals. In multiple bonds, such overlap leads to the formation of both sigma and pi bonds. The overlap is stronger in sigma than pi bonds, which is reflected in sigma bonds having greater bond energy than pi bonds. The presence of a pi bond also prevents the rotation of the bond and leads to geometric isomers.
Exclusions: deriving and drawing hybrid orbitals, hybridization involving d orbitals (for more than four electron pairs only the shape is required), and molecular orbital diagrams are not assessed.
Valence-shell electron-pair repulsion
VSEPR theory rests on Coulomb’s law: electron pairs are negative, so they repel, and they arrange themselves around the central atom as far apart as possible.
An electron domain is a region where electrons are concentrated: each single, double or triple bond counts as one domain, and each lone pair is one domain.
The number of domains sets the electron-domain geometry; the positions of the atoms (ignoring lone pairs) give the molecular geometry, the shape you name.
Draw the Lewis diagram.
Count the electron domains on the central atom (bonded atoms plus lone pairs).
Choose the geometry that places that many domains as far apart as possible.
Name the shape by the positions of the atoms.
Figure 2.7a Molecular shapes by VSEPR. Each row is one electron-domain geometry; each lone pair (shaded oval) removes a bonded position and changes the shape. Lone pairs take more space than bonding pairs, so bond angles shrink slightly (<). Drawings are schematic projections.
Lone pairs are held by only one nucleus, so they occupy more space than bonding pairs and squeeze the bond angles together. That is why the bond angle in NH3 (about 107°) is smaller than the ideal tetrahedral 109.5°,
and in H2O (about 104.5°) it is smaller still. In the five-domain shapes, lone pairs go in the equatorial positions (where there is the most room).
Worked example · shape from the formula
Predict the molecular shape and approximate bond angle of (a) SO2, (b) NH3, (c) XeF4.
(a) SO2. 18 electrons; S is central with one double bond, one single bond and one lone pair: 3 domains, trigonal planar electron geometry, with 2 bonded atoms: bent, about 120° (slightly less than 120°).
(b) NH3. 8 electrons; N has three bonds and one lone pair: 4 domains, tetrahedral electron geometry with 3 bonded atoms: trigonal pyramidal, about 107°.
(c) XeF4. Xe has 8 + 4(7) = 36 electrons; four bonds and two lone pairs: 6 domains, octahedral electron geometry. The two lone pairs sit opposite each other, so the four F atoms lie in a plane: square planar, 90°.
Polarity of molecules: the dipole moment
Each polar bond has a dipole pointing toward the more electronegative atom. A molecule has a dipole moment (is polar) when those bond dipoles do not cancel. Whether they cancel depends on the shape.
Cancel (nonpolar): CO2 (linear), BF3 (trigonal planar), CH4 and CCl4 (tetrahedral with identical atoms), XeF4 (square planar). The dipoles are equal and point in opposite directions.
Do not cancel (polar): H2O (bent), NH3 (pyramidal), CH3Cl (tetrahedral but not identical outer atoms), SO2 (bent).
So a molecule with polar bonds can still be nonpolar overall. The reasoning is two steps: (1) are the bonds polar? (2) is the shape symmetric so that the dipoles cancel?
Hybridization
To explain why carbon makes four equivalent bonds at 109.5° even though its ground-state valence electrons are in different subshells (2s and 2p), chemists describe the central atom’s valence orbitals as hybridized:
they combine to give new equivalent orbitals pointing in the VSEPR directions. The exam only asks you to match the hybridization to the number of electron domains.
Figure 2.7b The number of electron domains on an atom sets its hybridization: 2 domains is sp, 3 is sp², 4 is sp³. The ideal bond angles are 180°, 120° and 109.5°. (Lone pairs count as domains.)
Electron domains
Hybridization
Ideal angle
Examples
2
sp
180°
CO2 (C), HCN (C)
3
sp2
120°
BF3, H2C=O (C), O3 (central O)
4
sp3
109.5°
CH4, NH3 (N), H2O (O)
Notice that lone pairs count: the nitrogen in NH3 has four domains (three bonds, one lone pair) and is sp3 even though the molecule is pyramidal, not tetrahedral.
Sigma and pi bonds
Orbitals overlap to form bonds. Overlap along the line joining the nuclei makes a sigma (σ) bond; every single bond is a σ bond. A second or third bond between the same atoms forms by sideways overlap above and below the axis, a pi (π) bond.
So a double bond is 1 σ + 1 π, and a triple bond is 1 σ + 2 π.
Figure 2.7c A single bond is one σ bond. A double bond is one σ plus one π bond; a triple bond is one σ plus two π bonds. The π overlap is weaker, so a π bond is easier to break, and it prevents rotation about the bond.
The σ overlap is stronger, so a σ bond has a larger bond energy than a π bond (the C–C σ bond is about 347 kJ/mol while adding the π bond raises the C=C total to 614, a gain of only 267).
A π bond also prevents rotation about the bond, because turning one end would break the sideways overlap. This is why molecules with C=C can have geometric isomers:
in cis-2-butene the two CH3 groups are on the same side of the double bond, and in trans-2-butene they are on opposite sides. The two forms do not interconvert at room temperature and have different properties.
Worked example · hybridization and bond counts
Acrylonitrile is H2C=CH–C≡N. Give the hybridization of each carbon and the nitrogen, and count σ and π bonds.
Hybridization. The first carbon: 3 domains (two C–H and the double bond), sp2. The second carbon: 3 domains (one C–H, C=C, C–C), sp2. The third carbon: 2 domains (single C–C, triple C≡N), sp. Nitrogen: 2 domains (triple bond and lone pair), sp.
Bonds. σ bonds: 3 C–H + 1 C–C + 1 (in C=C) + 1 (in C≡N) = 6. π bonds: 1 (in C=C) + 2 (in C≡N) = 3. Check: there are 9 bond lines in the diagram, and 6 + 3 = 9. ✓
Exam focus
Count domains, not bonds. A double or triple bond is one domain; a lone pair is one domain.
Name the molecular shape by the atoms, not the domains: NH3 is trigonal pyramidal, not tetrahedral.
Polar bonds do not guarantee a polar molecule. Check the symmetry.
Hybridization follows the domain count: 2, 3, 4 domains mean sp, sp2, sp3.
One σ in every bond; extra bonds are π. A π bond blocks rotation and gives geometric isomers.
Practice
Predict the shape and polarity of CCl4 and of CHCl3.
Show answer
Both are tetrahedral with four domains. CCl4 has four identical polar C–Cl bonds whose dipoles cancel, so it is nonpolar. In CHCl3 the C–H bond is effectively nonpolar and the three C–Cl dipoles do not cancel, so the molecule is polar.
What are the molecular shape, bond angle and hybridization of the central atom in H2S?
Show answer
S has two bonds and two lone pairs: 4 domains, so the electron geometry is tetrahedral and the molecular shape is bent, with a bond angle a little under 109.5°. The sulfur is sp3.
Predict the shape of SF4 (34 electrons) and explain why it is not tetrahedral.
Show answer
S has four bonds and one lone pair, 5 domains, trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry. The lone pair takes an equatorial position, leaving a seesaw shape. It is not tetrahedral because tetrahedral would need only four electron domains.
How many σ and π bonds are in acetic acid, CH3COOH, which contains one C=O double bond?
Show answer
Explain why the bond angle in H2O (104.5°) is smaller than in CH4 (109.5°) even though both central atoms are sp3.
Show answer
Water has two lone pairs on oxygen. A lone pair is attracted by only one nucleus, so it occupies more space and repels the bonding pairs more strongly than bonding pairs repel each other, pushing the O–H bonds closer together. Methane has no lone pairs.
Why does 2-butene have cis and trans forms, but butane (all single bonds) does not have corresponding geometric isomers?
Show answer
The C=C double bond in 2-butene contains a π bond that prevents rotation, so the groups stay fixed on the same side (cis) or opposite sides (trans). Single σ bonds in butane allow free rotation, so those arrangements interconvert.
Unit 2 practice · 10 problems
Unit 2 practice: Compound Structure and Properties
Ten problems covering the whole unit. Work each one on paper before revealing the
answer. No calculator needed. Electronegativities where needed: K 0.82, Br 2.96, N 3.04, F 3.98.
Classify the bonding in KBr, N2, NF3, and Ag as ionic, nonpolar covalent, polar covalent, or metallic. Give one piece of evidence for each.
Show answer
KBr: metal + nonmetal, ΔEN = 2.14 → ionic (high-melting crystalline solid, conducts when molten). N2: identical atoms, ΔEN = 0 → nonpolar covalent. NF3: two nonmetals, ΔEN = 0.94 → polar covalent, F end δ−. Ag: a metal alone → metallic (conducts as a solid, malleable).
Three potential-energy curves have minima at (127 pm, −431 kJ/mol), (141 pm, −366 kJ/mol), and (161 pm, −298 kJ/mol). They belong to HCl, HBr, and HI. Match each and explain the trend.
Show answer
HCl: 127 pm, 431 kJ/mol; HBr: 141 pm, 366 kJ/mol; HI: 161 pm, 298 kJ/mol. Down the group the halogen is larger, with its bonding electrons in a higher shell and more core electrons in between, so the nuclei sit farther apart at the minimum (longer bond) and the attraction between them and the shared pair is weaker at that distance (shallower well). Longer bond, weaker bond.
Which compound has the largest lattice energy?
NaCl has 1+ and 1− ions, so its charge product is a quarter that of MgO or CaO, and its lattice energy (787 kJ/mol) is roughly a quarter of theirs. Small ions help, but in \(E \propto q_1 q_2 / r\) the charges dominate.
KCl has the same 1+/1− charges as NaCl but a larger cation, so the ion centers are farther apart and its lattice energy (715 kJ/mol) is the smallest of the four.
Lattice energy follows \(E \propto q_1 q_2 / r\). MgO and CaO have 2+/2− ions, four times the charge product of the chlorides; between them Mg2+ is smaller than Ca2+, so the ion centers are closer in MgO (about 3800 vs. 3400 kJ/mol).
CaO has the right 2+/2− charges, but Ca2+ has one more electron shell than Mg2+, so the distance \(r\) is larger and the attraction weaker than in MgO. When the charges tie, the smaller ions win.
Solid KBr does not conduct electricity, but molten KBr does; copper conducts as a solid and bends without breaking. Explain all three observations at the particle level. Then classify steel (C in Fe) and brass (Zn in Cu) as interstitial or substitutional alloys.
Show answer
In solid KBr the K+ and Br− ions are locked in a lattice; no charged particle can move. Melting frees the ions to migrate, so the liquid conducts. Copper's valence electrons are delocalized in an electron sea that carries current, and because cations are attracted to that uniform sea rather than to specific partners, planes of atoms slide past each other without shattering. Steel is interstitial (small C atoms fill gaps between Fe atoms); brass is substitutional (similar-sized Zn replaces Cu). Both are harder than the pure metal because the foreign atoms pin the layers.
Describe the Lewis diagram of the sulfite ion, SO32−: total valence electrons, bonds, lone pairs, and the formal charge on each atom. Then give its molecular geometry and approximate bond angle.
Show answer
Electrons: \(6 + 3(6) + 2 = 26\). S central with three S–O single bonds (6 e−), three lone pairs on each O (18), and the remaining 2 as a lone pair on S. Every atom has an octet. Formal charges: S \(= 6 - 2 - \tfrac{1}{2}(6) = +1\); each O \(= 6 - 6 - \tfrac{1}{2}(2) = -1\); sum \(+1 - 3 = -2\). ✓ Four electron domains with one lone pair: trigonal pyramidal, about 107°, sp3 sulfur.
Count the valence electrons in XeF2 and describe its Lewis diagram. Why is this arrangement allowed for xenon? Separately, how many valence electrons does ClO2 have, and what does that number tell you?
Show answer
XeF2: \(8 + 2(7) = 22\). Two Xe–F bonds (4), three lone pairs on each F (12), and the remaining 6 as three lone pairs on Xe: ten electrons around Xe, an expanded octet, allowed because a period-5 atom is large enough to hold more than four pairs. Five domains with three lone pairs make it linear. ClO2: \(7 + 2(6) = 19\), an odd number, so one electron must be unpaired: ClO2 is a radical, which is why it is so reactive.
Draw (in words) the resonance structures of the nitrite ion, NO2−. Give the formal charge on each atom in one structure, the N–O bond order, and what experiment shows about the two bond lengths.
Show answer
Electrons: \(5 + 2(6) + 1 = 18\). N central with one N=O and one N–O, a lone pair on N, two lone pairs on the doubly bonded O and three on the singly bonded O. The double bond can be on either oxygen: two equivalent structures. Formal charges: N \(= 5 - 2 - 3 = 0\); double-bonded O \(= 6 - 4 - 2 = 0\); single-bonded O \(= 6 - 6 - 1 = -1\); sum −1. ✓ Bond order \(= 3/2\); both N–O bonds are the same length, between a typical N–O single and N=O double bond.
Dinitrogen monoxide, N2O, has the skeleton N–N–O and 16 valence electrons. Three Lewis structures are possible: N≡N–O, N=N=O, and N–N≡O. Compute the formal charges and identify the dominant structure.
Show answer
Formal charges (terminal N, central N, O): N≡N–O: 0, +1, −1. N=N=O: −1, +1, 0. N–N≡O: −2, +1, +1. The third has large, separated charges and contributes little. The first two each have charges of one unit; N≡N–O puts the negative charge on oxygen, the most electronegative atom, so it is the largest contributor, with N=N=O a close second. (Check each: the charges sum to 0, the molecule's charge.)
For each molecule give the number of electron domains on the central atom, the molecular geometry, the approximate bond angle, and whether it is polar: (a) PCl3, (b) SF4, (c) CS2.
Propene is CH3–CH=CH2. How many σ and π bonds does it contain? State the hybridization of each carbon, and which carbon–carbon bond is shorter.
Show answer
Six C–H σ bonds, one C–C σ bond, and one C=C (σ + π): 8 σ and 1 π. The CH3 carbon has 4 domains → sp3 (~109.5°); the two alkene carbons have 3 domains each → sp2 (~120°). The C=C bond is shorter: two shared pairs put more electron density between the nuclei and pull them closer than the C–C single bond does.
Water boils at 100 °C and methane, a molecule of nearly the same mass, boils at −162 °C. Nothing inside the molecules explains that gap: both have strong covalent bonds that stay intact when the liquid boils.
What differs is the attraction between molecules. Those weaker attractions, collectively called intermolecular forces, determine whether a substance is a gas, a liquid or a solid at room temperature, how it dissolves, and how it behaves in every material you handle.
On the AP exam this is the single most-tested explanatory idea in Unit 3, and it is the idea students most often answer vaguely. The goal of this lesson is to name the force and justify its strength.
Learning objective · 3.1.A
Explain the relationship between the chemical structures of molecules and the relative strength of their intermolecular forces when (i) the molecules are of the same chemical species and (ii) the molecules are of two different chemical species.
Required content · EK 3.1.A.1 to 3.1.A.5
London dispersion forces are a result of the Coulombic interactions between temporary, fluctuating dipoles. They are often the strongest net intermolecular force between large molecules. Dispersion forces increase with increasing contact area between molecules and with increasing polarizability of the molecules. Polarizability increases with an increasing number of electrons in the molecule and the size of the electron cloud, and is enhanced by the presence of pi bonding. The term “London dispersion forces” should not be used synonymously with “van der Waals forces.”
The dipole moment of a polar molecule leads to additional interactions: dipole-induced dipole interactions between a polar and a nonpolar molecule (always attractive); dipole-dipole interactions between polar molecules, which act in addition to London dispersion forces; and ion-dipole forces between ions and polar molecules, which tend to be stronger than dipole-dipole forces.
The relative strength and orientation dependence of dipole-dipole and ion-dipole forces can be understood qualitatively by considering the sign of the partial charges responsible for the molecular dipole moment, and how these partial charges interact with an ion or with an adjacent dipole.
Hydrogen bonding is a strong type of intermolecular interaction that exists when hydrogen atoms covalently bonded to the highly electronegative atoms (N, O and F) are attracted to the negative end of a dipole formed by the electronegative atom (N, O and F) in a different molecule, or a different part of the same molecule.
In large biomolecules, noncovalent interactions may occur between different molecules or between different regions of the same large biomolecule.
Intermolecular against intramolecular
Intramolecular forces are the covalent bonds inside a molecule (water’s O–H bonds, about 460 kJ/mol). Intermolecular forces act between molecules and are far weaker (water’s hydrogen bonds, about 20 kJ/mol).
When water boils, the molecules separate but each stays H2O, so the covalent bonds are not broken: what boiling overcomes is the intermolecular force. The two terms look alike and are a frequent source of lost points. For ionic and metallic solids the same role is played by
interparticle forces, the attractions between ions or between metal cores and electrons.
Figure 3.1a The four types of attraction between particles in order of how they arise. All molecules have London dispersion forces; the others add to them when the molecules are polar, contain H on N, O or F, or are ions interacting with polar molecules.
London dispersion forces
Every molecule, polar or not, has electrons that are in constant motion. At any instant the electron cloud may be slightly more on one side, creating a temporary dipole. That dipole distorts the cloud of a neighbor, inducing a dipole in it, and the two attract.
This attraction is the London dispersion force. It exists between all particles, including noble-gas atoms (which is why they can be liquefied).
Two things control how strong it is:
Polarizability: how easily the electron cloud can be distorted. It increases with the number of electrons and the size of the cloud, and pi bonds make it larger. Iodine, with 106 electrons per molecule and a large cloud, is a solid at room temperature; fluorine, with 18, is a gas.
Contact area: long, straight molecules touch neighbors along their whole length, while compact, branched molecules touch only at a few points. Pentane boils at 36 °C and its branched isomer 2,2-dimethylpropane at 9.5 °C, with identical mass and electrons.
Figure 3.1c Dispersion forces grow with the number of electrons and with the contact area between molecules. Larger halogen molecules have bigger, more polarizable electron clouds; longer alkane chains have more surface to touch their neighbors.
For large molecules dispersion forces are often the strongest net intermolecular force, even when the molecule is polar. One caution about vocabulary: “London dispersion forces” is a specific term. Do not use it as a synonym for “van der Waals forces,” a broader name that also covers dipole forces.
Forces that involve permanent dipoles
Dipole-dipole: polar molecules orient so that the δ+ end of one is near the δ− end of another. Because these act in addition to dispersion forces, polar molecules usually boil higher than nonpolar molecules of similar size. The strength rises with the size of the dipoles.
Dipole-induced dipole: a polar molecule distorts the cloud of a nonpolar neighbor and attracts it. Always attractive; it grows with the dipole of the polar molecule and the polarizability of the nonpolar one. (It is why a little O2 dissolves in water.)
Ion-dipole: an ion attracts the oppositely charged end of a polar molecule. These tend to be stronger than dipole-dipole forces, and are the basis of dissolving ionic solids in water (lesson 3.6).
Hydrogen bonding
A hydrogen bond forms when a hydrogen atom bonded to N, O or F is attracted to a lone pair on an N, O or F atom of another molecule (or a different part of the same large molecule). It is a particularly strong dipole-dipole interaction because the N, O and F atoms are small and highly electronegative, leaving hydrogen with a large δ+ that sits close to the neighbor’s lone pair.
Both conditions are required: H must be on N, O or F, and there must be an N, O or F with a lone pair to accept it. CH4 and CH3F do not hydrogen bond; CH3OH and NH3 do.
Figure 3.1b Boiling points of the hydrides of groups 14 to 17. Group 14 molecules are nonpolar and rise smoothly with size (more electrons, more dispersion force). NH3, H2O and HF stand far above the trend because they form hydrogen bonds.
The graph is the classic evidence. Group 14 hydrides are nonpolar and their boiling points climb smoothly as the molecules get larger. The hydrides of groups 15, 16 and 17 follow the same climb from period 3 downward, but NH3, H2O and HF boil far above where that trend points, because of hydrogen bonding.
Water is the extreme case since each molecule can donate two hydrogen bonds and accept two.
Noncovalent interactions in large molecules
In proteins, DNA and polymers, the same forces act between different regions of one huge molecule. Hydrogen bonds hold the two DNA strands together and help fold proteins; dispersion forces between nonpolar side chains pack the interior of a protein; ion-ion and ion-dipole interactions occur at charged groups. Each is weak,
but there are very many of them, and together they determine the shape of the molecule, which determines its function.
Worked example · name the forces
Identify the intermolecular forces in a sample of each substance: (a) Ar, (b) HCl, (c) CH3OH, (d) NaCl in water.
(a) Ar: nonpolar atoms, London dispersion only. (b) HCl: polar, so dipole-dipole plus dispersion (H is bonded to Cl, not N, O or F, so no hydrogen bonding). (c) CH3OH: H on O and lone pairs on O, so hydrogen bonding, plus dipole-dipole and dispersion. (d) NaCl in water: ion-dipole between Na+/Cl− and water, plus hydrogen bonding among water molecules.
Worked example · same formula, different forces
Ethanol (CH3CH2OH) boils at 78 °C and dimethyl ether (CH3OCH3) at −24 °C. Both are C2H6O. Explain.
They have the same number of electrons and similar size, so dispersion forces are about equal. Ethanol has an O–H bond, so its molecules hydrogen bond to each other. Dimethyl ether has no H on oxygen, so it has only dipole-dipole and dispersion forces. The stronger intermolecular attraction in ethanol means more energy is needed to separate the molecules, so it boils higher.
Exam focus
Name the force; never just say “strong” or “weak.” The exam awards points for identifying hydrogen bonding, dipole-dipole or dispersion and tying it to the structure.
Rank in two steps. First check for hydrogen bonding and polarity. If the molecules have the same kinds of force, rank by size (number of electrons) and shape.
Do not claim that boiling breaks covalent bonds. It overcomes intermolecular forces.
All molecules have dispersion forces. Larger molecules can be dominated by them even if polar.
Hydrogen bonding needs H on N, O or F. A C–H hydrogen does not count.
Practice
Rank Ne, Ar and Kr by boiling point and justify.
Show answer
Ne < Ar < Kr. All are nonpolar atoms with only London dispersion forces. Going down the group the number of electrons and size of the cloud increase, so the polarizability and the dispersion forces increase, requiring more energy to separate the atoms.
Which has the higher boiling point, CH3CH2CH2CH3 (butane) or CH3CH2CH2OH (propanol)? Explain.
Show answer
Propanol (97 °C against −0.5 °C). The two have similar numbers of electrons, but propanol has an O–H group and forms hydrogen bonds in addition to dispersion forces, so its intermolecular attractions are stronger.
CHCl3 is polar and CCl4 is nonpolar. Which has the higher boiling point, and why?
Show answer
CCl4 boils higher (77 °C against 61 °C for CHCl3), even though CHCl3 is polar. CCl4 has more electrons (74 against 58), so it is more polarizable and has stronger dispersion forces, which outweigh the extra dipole-dipole attraction in CHCl3.
Which of the following can form hydrogen bonds with other molecules of its own kind: CH3F, HF, CH3NH2, H2S?
Show answer
HF and CH3NH2 (each has H bonded to F or N and has a lone pair on F or N). CH3F has no H on F, and H2S has H on sulfur, which is not N, O or F.
Pentane (36 °C) and 2,2-dimethylpropane (9.5 °C) have the same formula, C5H12. Explain the difference in boiling point.
Show answer
Both are nonpolar and have only dispersion forces with the same number of electrons. Pentane is a long chain that makes more contact with its neighbors, so its dispersion forces are stronger. The compact, nearly spherical branched molecule has less contact area and weaker net attraction.
A student says that water boils at 100 °C because the O–H bonds are very strong. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is wrong. Boiling separates whole water molecules from one another, which requires overcoming the hydrogen bonds between molecules, not the covalent O–H bonds inside them (which stay intact in the vapor). Water’s high boiling point is due to its extensive hydrogen bonding.
Diamond cuts steel, graphite marks paper, and both are pure carbon. Ice floats in water, dry ice vanishes into vapor without ever becoming liquid, and a gas fills every container you give it.
These contrasts all come from the same two questions: what are the particles, and how do they attract each other? This lesson connects the particle-level structure of each type of substance to what you can measure at the macroscopic level,
which is the central skill of the unit.
Learning objectives · 3.2.A and 3.3.A
3.2.A Explain the relationship among the macroscopic properties of a substance, the particulate-level structure of the substance, and the interactions between these particles.
3.3.A Represent the differences between solid, liquid and gas phases using a particulate-level model.
Required content · EK 3.2.A.1 to 3.2.A.7 and 3.3.A.1 to 3.3.A.4
Many properties of liquids and solids are determined by the strengths and types of intermolecular forces present. Because intermolecular interactions are overcome completely when a substance vaporizes, the vapor pressure and boiling point are directly related to the strength of those interactions. Melting points also tend to correlate with interaction strength, but because the interactions are only rearranged in melting, the relations can be more subtle.
Particulate-level representations, showing multiple interacting chemical species, are a useful means to communicate how intermolecular interactions help to establish macroscopic properties.
Because of strong interactions between ions, ionic solids tend to have low vapor pressures and high melting and boiling points. They tend to be brittle. They conduct electricity only when the ions are mobile, as when melted or dissolved.
In covalent network solids, atoms are covalently bonded into a three-dimensional network (diamond) or layers of two-dimensional networks (graphite). They are formed only from nonmetals and metalloids and have high melting points. Three-dimensional network solids are rigid and hard; graphite is soft because adjacent layers can slide past each other.
Molecular solids are composed of distinct molecules attracted to each other through relatively weak intermolecular forces. They generally have low melting points and do not conduct electricity. Some are composed of very large molecules or polymers.
Metallic solids conduct electricity and heat because of free valence electrons, and tend to be malleable and ductile. Interstitial atoms make the lattice more rigid, decreasing malleability. Alloys typically retain a sea of mobile electrons and remain conducting.
Solids can be crystalline (a regular three-dimensional structure) or amorphous (no regular order). In both, particles do not undergo overall translation with respect to each other.
Particles in liquids are in close contact, continually moving and colliding, and the solid and liquid phases of a substance have similar molar volumes. In a gas the particles are in constant motion with minimal effects of forces between particles, so a gas has neither a definite volume nor a definite shape.
Exclusion: interpreting phase diagrams is not assessed.
Vapor pressure, boiling point and melting point
Molecules in a liquid are constantly escaping into the gas above it and returning. At a given temperature the pressure of that vapor, at equilibrium with the liquid, is the vapor pressure. When intermolecular forces are strong, fewer molecules have enough energy to escape,
so stronger forces mean lower vapor pressure and higher boiling point. A liquid boils when its vapor pressure equals the external pressure.
Because vaporization separates the molecules completely, the boiling point tracks the strength of the intermolecular forces directly.
Melting points also generally rise with the strength of the forces, but the relationship is looser. In melting the particles are only rearranged, not separated, and the efficiency of packing in the crystal matters. A symmetrical molecule may pack so well that it melts higher than a less symmetrical one with stronger forces.
Boiling-point arguments are therefore the cleaner ones on the exam.
The four types of solid
Figure 3.2a Four kinds of solid. What the particles are, and what holds them together, determines melting point, hardness and conductivity.
Type
Particles and forces
Melting point
Hardness
Conducts electricity?
Examples
Ionic
cations and anions; strong ionic attractions
high
hard, brittle
no as a solid; yes when molten or dissolved
NaCl, MgO, CaF2
Covalent network
atoms in a network of covalent bonds
very high
very hard (graphite soft)
no (graphite yes along layers)
diamond, SiO2, SiC
Molecular
molecules; weak intermolecular forces
low
soft
no
ice, I2, sucrose, CO2
Metallic
cations in a sea of delocalized electrons
variable, mostly high
malleable, ductile
yes
Cu, Fe, Na, brass
Why diamond is hard and graphite is soft. In diamond each carbon is bonded to four others in a rigid three-dimensional network at fixed 109.5° angles; to scratch it you must break covalent bonds. In graphite each carbon bonds to three others in flat sheets,
and the sheets are held to each other only by weak dispersion forces, so they slide past one another, which is why graphite is a lubricant and writes on paper. The delocalized electrons within each sheet also let graphite conduct along the layers.
Why molecular solids melt low. Melting a molecular solid overcomes only the weak intermolecular forces, not the covalent bonds within molecules. Their electrons are held in bonds and lone pairs, so they do not conduct.
A very large molecule or a polymer (such as polyethylene) has so many dispersion forces that it can be a solid even at moderate temperature, but it is still molecular.
Crystalline and amorphous solids. A crystalline solid has a regular repeating three-dimensional structure and a sharp melting point. An amorphous solid, such as glass or most plastics, has particles in a disordered arrangement and softens over a range of temperatures. In either, the particles vibrate in place and do not move past each other.
Liquids and gases
Figure 3.2b Particle models of the three phases. Solid and liquid particles are in contact, so they have similar molar volumes; gas particles are far apart and move freely, so a gas has no fixed shape or volume.
Solid: particles in contact in fixed positions, vibrating. Definite shape and volume.
Liquid: particles in contact but free to slide past each other, continually moving and colliding. Definite volume, shape of the container. The strength of the forces (polarity, hydrogen bonding) and the temperature determine how easily it flows.
Gas: particles far apart (the distances are about ten times the particle diameter or more), in constant fast random motion, with negligible attraction between them. No definite shape or volume.
Because particles in a solid and its liquid are in close contact, the two phases have similar molar volumes. Liquid water at 100 °C has a molar volume of about 18.8 mL; the same mole as steam at 100 °C and 1 atm occupies \(V = \dfrac{nRT}{P} = \dfrac{(1\ \text{mol})(0.08206)(373.15)}{1\ \text{atm}} = 30.6\) L, about 1,600 times as much.
Almost all of the volume of a gas is empty space.
Worked example · from properties to particle type
A solid melts at 2,830 °C and does not conduct electricity as a solid or when molten. Another melts at 114 °C, is soft and does not conduct. A third melts at 660 °C, conducts as a solid and is malleable. Classify each.
The first is a covalent network solid (very high melting point; molten it has no ions, so no conduction): silicon carbide-like. The second is molecular (low melting point, soft, no conduction): iodine melts at 114 °C. The third is metallic (conducts as a solid, malleable): aluminum melts at 660 °C.
Worked example · vapor pressure ranking
At 25 °C, which has the higher vapor pressure, water or diethyl ether (CH3CH2OCH2CH3)?
Water molecules form extensive hydrogen bonds, so few have enough energy to escape. Diethyl ether has no O–H and only dipole-dipole and dispersion forces, so its intermolecular attractions are weaker and its molecules escape much more easily. Ether has the higher vapor pressure (about 0.7 atm against 0.03 atm for water at 25 °C) and lower boiling point (35 °C).
Exam focus
Always link property to particle to force. “Solid X has a low melting point because it is molecular and only weak intermolecular forces must be overcome” is the full chain.
Do not say that covalent bonds are broken in melting a molecular solid.
Graphite is the exception to “network solids do not conduct.” It conducts along its layers and is soft.
Ionic solids conduct only when the ions can move, as a liquid or in solution.
Particle diagrams: draw touching particles for solids and liquids, widely spaced for gases, and show a regular pattern only for crystalline solids.
Practice
Explain why SiO2 melts at 1,710 °C while CO2 sublimes at −78 °C.
Show answer
SiO2 is a covalent network solid: melting requires breaking strong covalent bonds throughout the network. CO2 is a molecular solid made of separate nonpolar molecules held by weak dispersion forces, so very little energy is needed to separate them.
Which has the higher boiling point, CH3OH or CH3SH? Justify.
Show answer
CH3OH (65 °C against 6 °C). It has H bonded to oxygen and so forms hydrogen bonds; CH3SH has H bonded to sulfur, which does not hydrogen bond, leaving weaker dipole-dipole and dispersion forces.
Describe the difference in particle arrangement between a crystalline and an amorphous solid.
Show answer
In a crystalline solid the particles form a regular repeating three-dimensional pattern. In an amorphous solid the particles are in contact and fixed in place but are not arranged in a regular repeating pattern.
A student sketches a gas with particles touching and a regular pattern. Identify what is wrong.
Show answer
In a gas the particles are far apart (mostly empty space), randomly located and in rapid motion. Touching particles in a regular pattern describes a crystalline solid.
Explain why one mole of a liquid and one mole of its solid have similar volumes, while the gas of the same substance has a very much larger volume.
Show answer
In solid and liquid phases the particles are in close contact, so the volume is set by the particle sizes. In a gas the particles are far apart and move independently, so the volume depends on temperature and pressure and is much larger.
A white crystalline solid melts at 801 °C and conducts electricity only when molten. Classify it and justify.
Show answer
It is ionic (probably NaCl). The high melting point shows strong interparticle forces, and conduction only in the liquid shows that ions are present and become mobile only when the lattice is broken down.
A tire goes flat on a cold morning, a sealed bag of chips balloons on a mountain pass, a scuba diver must breathe out on the way up. In every case the pressure, volume, temperature and amount of a gas are tied together by one equation.
Unlike the other states of matter, gases follow a simple, universal rule, nearly independent of what the gas is. In this lesson you learn to use that rule quantitatively, to reason about how changing one variable changes another, and to handle mixtures of gases.
Learning objective · 3.4.A
Explain the relationship between the macroscopic properties of a sample of gas or mixture of gases using the ideal gas law.
Required content · EK 3.4.A.1 to 3.4.A.3
The macroscopic properties of ideal gases are related through the ideal gas law: \(PV = nRT\).
In a sample containing a mixture of ideal gases, the pressure exerted by each component (the partial pressure) is independent of the other components. Therefore, the partial pressure of a gas within the mixture is proportional to its mole fraction, and the total pressure of the sample is the sum of the partial pressures: \(P_A = P_{\text{total}} \times X_A\), where \(X_A = \dfrac{\text{moles of A}}{\text{total moles}}\); \(P_{\text{total}} = P_A + P_B + P_C + \cdots\).
Graphical representations of the relationships between P, V, T and n are useful to describe gas behavior.
The four variables
A gas sample is described by four measurable quantities:
Pressure, P: force per unit area from particles colliding with the container walls. Units: atm, kPa, mmHg or torr. 1 atm = 101.325 kPa = 760 mmHg = 760 torr.
Volume, V: the volume of the container (liters). A gas fills its container.
Temperature, T:always in kelvin, \(T(\text{K}) = T(^\circ\text{C}) + 273.15\).
Amount, n: moles of gas.
Equation on the AP reference sheet
\[ PV = nRT \]
\(R = 0.08206\ \text{L·atm·mol}^{-1}\text{·K}^{-1}\) = 8.314 J·mol−1·K−1 = 62.36 L·torr·mol−1·K−1. Choose the value of \(R\) whose units match the pressure and volume units in the problem.
The ideal gas law says nothing about what the gas is: 1 mol of any ideal gas at 273.15 K and 1.000 atm (standard temperature and pressure, STP) occupies \(V = \dfrac{(1)(0.08206)(273.15)}{1.000} = 22.4\) L.
Relationships between the variables
When you hold two of the four variables fixed, the others relate in simple ways. These are special cases of \(PV = nRT\), not separate laws to memorize:
Figure 3.3a Graphical forms of the gas laws, all special cases of PV = nRT. A straight line through the origin means direct proportion; the curve for P against V is an inverse proportion.
Boyle’s law (n, T constant): \(PV\) is constant, so \(P_1 V_1 = P_2 V_2\). Squeeze a gas to half its volume and its pressure doubles. P against V is a curve; P against \(1/V\) is a straight line.
Charles’s law (n, P constant): \(V/T\) is constant. Volume is proportional to kelvin temperature, so a graph of V against T(K) is a straight line through the origin.
Gay-Lussac’s law (n, V constant): \(P/T\) is constant, so pressure is proportional to kelvin temperature.
Avogadro’s law (P, T constant): V is proportional to n. Equal volumes of gases at the same T and P contain equal numbers of particles.
For a fixed amount of gas whose conditions change, combine them: \(\dfrac{P_1 V_1}{T_1} = \dfrac{P_2 V_2}{T_2}\).
Worked example · using PV = nRT
How many moles of gas are in a 2.50 L flask at 1.20 atm and 27 °C?
A gas occupies 3.0 L at 1.0 atm and 300 K. What is its volume at 5.0 atm and 450 K?
\(V_2 = V_1 \dfrac{P_1}{P_2}\dfrac{T_2}{T_1} = 3.0 \times \dfrac{1.0}{5.0} \times \dfrac{450}{300} = 0.90\) L. Reasonableness. Higher pressure shrinks the volume (factor 1/5) and higher temperature expands it (factor 1.5); the net factor 0.30 gives 0.90 L.
Worked example · molar mass from density
An unknown gas has a density of 2.85 g/L at 1.00 atm and 25 °C. Find its molar mass.
Since \(n = m/M\), \(PV = (m/M)RT\) gives \(M = \dfrac{(m/V)RT}{P} = \dfrac{dRT}{P}\). With \(d = 2.85\) g/L and \(T = 298.15\) K: \(M = \dfrac{(2.85)(0.08206)(298.15)}{1.00} = 69.7\) g/mol.
Worked example · qualitative reasoning
A sealed rigid container of gas is heated from 300 K to 600 K. What happens to the pressure, and why?
The volume and amount are fixed, so \(P \propto T\): the pressure doubles. On the particle level the molecules move faster, so they hit the walls more often and with more force.
Mixtures of gases: Dalton’s law
In an ideal gas the particles do not interact, so each gas in a mixture behaves as if it were alone in the container. The partial pressure of gas A, \(P_A\), is the pressure it would exert alone.
The total pressure is the sum, and each partial pressure is the total times the mole fraction:
\[ P_{\text{total}} = P_A + P_B + P_C + \cdots \qquad P_A = P_{\text{total}}\, X_A \qquad X_A = \dfrac{n_A}{n_{\text{total}}} \]
Figure 3.3b Dalton’s law for dry air. Each gas contributes a partial pressure equal to its mole fraction times the total pressure, and the partial pressures add up to the total.
Worked example · mole fractions
A 6.00 atm mixture contains 2.00 mol N2 and 1.00 mol O2. Find each partial pressure.
\(X(\text{N}_2) = 2.00/3.00 = 0.667\), so \(P(\text{N}_2) = 6.00 \times 0.667 = 4.00\) atm. \(X(\text{O}_2) = 0.333\), so \(P(\text{O}_2) = 2.00\) atm. The sum is 6.00 atm. ✓
Worked example · gas collected over water
Hydrogen is collected over water at 25 °C. The total pressure is 745 torr, the vapor pressure of water at 25 °C is 23.8 torr, and the volume is 0.250 L. How many moles of H2 were collected?
The collected gas is a mixture of H2 and water vapor: \(P(\text{H}_2) = 745 - 23.8 = 721.2\) torr \(= 0.949\) atm. \(n = \dfrac{(0.949)(0.250)}{(0.08206)(298.15)} = 0.00970\) mol.
Exam focus
Kelvin, always. A temperature in °C in any gas-law equation is the most common arithmetic error.
Match R to the units. With P in atm and V in liters use 0.08206; with P in kPa and V in liters use 8.314 L·kPa/(mol·K).
Reason with proportions. “P doubles because T doubles at constant V and n” is exactly what the exam asks for.
Mole fraction, not mass fraction, goes into Dalton’s law.
Subtract water vapor pressure when a gas is collected over water.
Practice
What pressure is exerted by 0.500 mol of gas in a 10.0 L container at 77 °C?
Show answer
A 4.0 L sample at 1.0 atm is compressed at constant temperature to 2.5 atm. What is the new volume?
Show answer
\(V_2 = \dfrac{P_1V_1}{P_2} = \dfrac{(1.0)(4.0)}{2.5} = 1.6\) L.
A mixture of 0.60 mol N2 and 0.40 mol O2 has a total pressure of 2.5 atm. Find the partial pressure of each gas.
Show answer
\(X(\text{O}_2) = 0.40\), so \(P(\text{O}_2) = 1.0\) atm. \(X(\text{N}_2) = 0.60\), so \(P(\text{N}_2) = 1.5\) atm. They total 2.5 atm.
Explain, using the ideal gas law, why an inflated balloon shrinks when placed in a freezer.
Show answer
The amount of gas and the (outside) pressure are constant, so \(V \propto T\). Lowering the temperature lowers the volume. On the particle level, the molecules move more slowly and push less hard on the balloon, so it contracts until the inside pressure again matches the outside.
What is the density of N2 gas at 1.00 atm and 25 °C?
Show answer
Two flasks of equal volume, one holding H2 and the other CO2, are at the same temperature and pressure. Compare the number of molecules and the mass of gas.
Show answer
The numbers of molecules are equal (same P, V, T gives the same n). The CO2 flask has the greater mass, about 22 times as much, because the molar mass of CO2 (44.0 g/mol) is 22 times that of H2 (2.02 g/mol).
The ideal gas law describes how gases behave. It does not say why. The kinetic molecular theory does: it pictures a gas as a swarm of tiny particles in rapid random motion and derives the macroscopic laws from collisions with the walls.
That one picture explains pressure, why gases expand to fill a container, what temperature really measures, and why lighter gases effuse faster.
And because no model is perfect, you also learn here when the ideal gas law fails and which particle-level feature is responsible.
Learning objectives · 3.5.A and 3.6.A
3.5.A Explain the relationship between the motion of particles and the macroscopic properties of gases with (i) the kinetic molecular theory, (ii) a particulate model and (iii) a graphical representation.
3.6.A Explain the relationship among non-ideal behaviors of gases, interparticle forces and/or volumes.
Required content · EK 3.5.A.1 to 3.5.A.4 and 3.6.A.1
The kinetic molecular theory (KMT) relates the macroscopic properties of gases to motions of the particles in the gas. The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution describes the distribution of the kinetic energies of particles at a given temperature.
All the particles in a sample of matter are in continuous, random motion. The average kinetic energy of a particle is related to its average velocity by \(KE = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\).
The Kelvin temperature of a sample of matter is proportional to the average kinetic energy of the particles in the sample.
The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution provides a graphical representation of the energies and velocities of particles at a given temperature.
The ideal gas law does not explain the actual behavior of real gases. Deviations may result from interparticle attractions among gas molecules, particularly at conditions close to those resulting in condensation. Deviations may also arise from particle volumes, particularly at extremely high pressures.
The postulates of KMT
A gas is made of a huge number of particles in constant, random, straight-line motion, changing direction only by collisions.
The particles are so small, and so far apart on average, that their own volume is negligible compared with the container.
There are no attractive or repulsive forces between the particles, except during collisions.
Collisions with each other and with the walls are elastic: no kinetic energy is lost.
The average kinetic energy of the particles is proportional to the kelvin temperature, and is the same for all gases at the same temperature.
A gas that follows all of these is an ideal gas, and its behavior is exactly the ideal gas law.
Temperature and kinetic energy
Each particle has kinetic energy \(KE = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\). Temperature is a measure of the average kinetic energy: if the kelvin temperature doubles, the average kinetic energy doubles. Two consequences deserve to be said in full sentences:
At the same temperature, all gases have the same average kinetic energy. A hydrogen molecule and a carbon dioxide molecule at 300 K have the same average KE, so the lighter one must be moving faster. For helium against nitrogen, the speed ratio is \(\sqrt{28.014/4.003} = 2.65\), so a typical helium atom is about 2.65 times as fast as a nitrogen molecule at the same temperature.
Speed grows only as the square root of T. Doubling the kelvin temperature doubles the average KE but raises the typical speed by only \(\sqrt{2} = 1.41\). Going from 300 K to 900 K triples the average KE and raises the speed by \(\sqrt{3} = 1.73\).
The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution
Not all particles in a gas move at the same speed. Collisions constantly pass energy around, so at any moment there is a spread of speeds: a few particles are slow, most are near the middle, and a few are very fast. The graph of the fraction of particles against speed is the
Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution.
Figure 3.4a Distribution of molecular speeds. Raising the temperature shifts the peak to higher speed and spreads the curve; at the same temperature lighter molecules are faster. The area under each curve is the same, since each represents all the molecules.
Read the two graphs this way. On the left, raising the temperature shifts the peak to a higher speed, lowers and flattens the peak, and broadens the curve toward the high-speed end: more particles are moving fast, and the average KE is higher. The area under each curve is the same because the number of molecules did not change.
On the right, at a single temperature the lighter gas has the peak at higher speed and the wider curve; the heaviest gas is narrow and slow. Remember that the average kinetic energy is the same for all three; only the speeds differ.
Worked example · KMT explains the laws
Use the kinetic molecular theory to explain why the pressure of a gas rises when it is heated in a rigid container.
Pressure is the force per unit area from particles colliding with the walls. When the temperature increases, the average kinetic energy and speed of the particles increase. The particles hit the walls more often and with more force per collision. Because the volume is fixed, the force per unit area, the pressure, rises. This matches \(P \propto T\) at constant \(n\) and \(V\).
Worked example · reading a distribution
Gas samples X and Y at the same temperature have curves with peaks at 420 m/s and 1,100 m/s. Which has the greater molar mass?
Same temperature means same average KE. Since \(KE = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), the sample with the lower speed must have the greater mass. Sample X (420 m/s) has the greater molar mass (roughly N2 against He).
Why real gases deviate
The two assumptions most likely to fail are the ones that ignore the particles’ size and their attraction to each other. Real gas behavior is compared with ideal by the ratio \(PV/nRT\), which equals exactly 1 for an ideal gas.
Figure 3.4b Deviation from ideal behavior (schematic). Below 1 means attractions are pulling the molecules together and the pressure is lower than the ideal gas predicts; above 1 at high pressure means the volume of the molecules themselves is significant.
Attractions (low temperature, moderate pressure). Close to the condensation point, molecules spend longer near each other and attract. The attractions pull molecules slightly away from the walls, so they hit with less force: the measured pressure is lower than ideal, and \(PV/nRT < 1\). Gases with stronger intermolecular forces (CO2, NH3) show larger dips than gases with weak ones (He, H2).
Particle volume (very high pressure). When gas is squeezed hard, the molecules themselves take up a significant part of the volume, so the free space is smaller than \(V\) and the pressure is higher than ideal: \(PV/nRT > 1\).
So a real gas behaves most ideally at high temperature and low pressure, where particles are fast (weakening the effect of attractions) and far apart (making their own volume negligible). Small, nonpolar atoms and molecules such as He and H2 are the closest to ideal.
Worked example · which gas is more ideal?
At 300 K and 50 atm, which is closer to ideal behavior, H2 or NH3? Explain.
H2 is closer to ideal. Its molecules are small and nonpolar, with only very weak dispersion forces, so attractions barely lower the pressure. NH3 molecules hydrogen bond and attract strongly at this pressure, so its \(PV/nRT\) falls well below 1. (NH3 is also close to its condensation point at these conditions.)
Exam focus
Average kinetic energy depends only on temperature. Different gases at the same T have different speeds but the same average KE.
Describe distribution changes with all three features: peak shifts right, peak lowers, curve broadens when T rises.
Name the correct deviation cause. Attractions give pressure lower than ideal; particle volume gives pressure higher than ideal.
Ideal conditions: high T, low P.
Use KMT language (collisions per second, force per collision) when asked to explain a gas law at the particle level.
Practice
Explain, using KMT, why the pressure of a gas increases when its volume is halved at constant temperature.
Show answer
The average speed (temperature) does not change, but the particles now have half the distance to travel between walls, so they hit the walls twice as often. Force per unit area doubles, so the pressure doubles (Boyle’s law).
By what factor does the average kinetic energy of the particles change when a gas is heated from 25 °C to 100 °C?
Show answer
Convert to kelvin: 298.15 K and 373.15 K. The ratio is \(373.15/298.15 = 1.25\). The average kinetic energy increases by 25%, not by a factor of 4.
Neon and krypton are at the same temperature. Which has the higher average speed, and which has the higher average kinetic energy?
Show answer
Neon has the higher average speed, since it has the smaller mass and the KE is equal. Their average kinetic energies are equal because the temperatures are equal.
On a Maxwell-Boltzmann graph the curve for sample A at 300 K and sample B at 600 K are compared. Describe two differences.
Show answer
The peak of B is at higher speed, and B’s curve is lower and broader because the same number of particles is spread over a wider range of speeds. (The area under each is equal.)
Why does CO2 deviate more from ideal behavior than He at 250 K and 20 atm?
Show answer
CO2 has more electrons and a larger cloud, so it has much stronger London dispersion forces. At high pressure the molecules are close together and attract, which lowers the pressure below the ideal value. Helium has extremely weak attractions and small atoms and stays nearly ideal.
A student claims that a real gas always exerts a lower pressure than the ideal gas law predicts. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is incorrect. Attractions lower the pressure at moderate pressures and low temperatures, but at very high pressures the volume of the molecules themselves is significant, so the free volume is smaller and the pressure is higher than the ideal value.
Most reactions in a chemistry lab, and nearly every reaction in your body, happen in solution. To work with solutions you need two skills: the numerical skill of stating how much solute is present
(concentration), and the visual skill of drawing what the particles in the solution are actually doing. The AP exam asks for both, often in the same question.
Learning objectives · 3.7.A and 3.8.A
3.7.A Calculate the number of solute particles, volume or molarity of solutions.
3.8.A Using particulate models for mixtures: (i) represent interactions between components; (ii) represent concentrations of components.
Required content · EK 3.7.A.1, 3.7.A.2 and 3.8.A.1
Solutions, also called homogeneous mixtures, can be solids, liquids or gases. In a solution, the macroscopic properties do not vary throughout the sample. In a heterogeneous mixture, the macroscopic properties depend on location in the mixture.
Solution composition can be expressed in a variety of ways; molarity is the most common method used in the laboratory: \(M = \dfrac{n_{\text{solute}}}{L_{\text{solution}}}\).
Particulate representations of solutions communicate the structure and properties of solutions by illustration of the relative concentrations of the components and/or drawings that show interactions among the components.
Exclusions: colligative properties and calculations of molality, percent by mass and percent by volume are not assessed.
Solutions and mixtures
A solution is a homogeneous mixture: the particles are mixed at the molecular level, so the composition and properties are the same everywhere in the sample (salt water, air, brass). The component present in the larger amount is the solvent, and the
other is the solute. Solutions can be liquid, gas or solid. A heterogeneous mixture (sand in water, oil and vinegar dressing) has regions with different properties, and its parts can often be seen or separated by filtering.
A solution passes through filter paper unchanged; the particles are too small to be caught.
Dissolving at the particle level
An ionic solid dissolves in water when ion-dipole attractions between the ions and water molecules are strong enough to pull ions out of the crystal. The ions end up surrounded by water molecules, a process called hydration.
Molecular solids such as sugar dissolve when their molecules form hydrogen bonds with water; nonpolar molecules do not dissolve in water because water molecules prefer each other (lesson 3.6).
Figure 3.5a Hydration of ions. Each ion is surrounded by water molecules oriented so the partial charge opposite to the ion’s faces it. These ion-dipole attractions replace the ion-ion attractions of the crystal, which is what allows a salt to dissolve.
The dissolution equation shows what happens to the particles: NaCl(s) → Na+(aq) + Cl−(aq). Notice that ionic compounds dissociate into separate ions, so one formula unit of CaCl2 gives three ions, while a molecular compound such as sucrose stays as whole molecules: C12H22O11(s) → C12H22O11(aq).
Molarity
Molarity (M, mol/L) is the amount of solute in moles per liter of solution (not per liter of solvent):
\[ M = \dfrac{n_{\text{solute}}}{V_{\text{solution}}\ (\text{L})} \]
It is the most common way to state concentration because the volume of a solution is easy to measure and a given volume holds a known number of particles. Equivalent forms are \(n = MV\) (the key to stoichiometry in solutions) and \(V = n/M\).
Worked example · molarity from mass
5.00 g of NaCl is dissolved in enough water to make 250. mL of solution. What is the molarity?
Describe how to prepare 500.0 mL of 0.100 M CuSO4.
\(n = MV = (0.100)(0.5000) = 0.0500\) mol, which is \(0.0500 \times 159.602 = 7.98\) g of CuSO4. Weigh 7.98 g, dissolve it in some water in a 500.0 mL volumetric flask, then add water up to the calibration mark and mix. (Add water to the mark; do not add 500 mL of water, because the solute adds volume.)
Worked example · dilution
25.0 mL of 2.00 M HCl is diluted with water to 100.0 mL. What is the new concentration?
Diluting changes the volume but not the moles of solute: \(M_1V_1 = M_2V_2\). \(M_2 = \dfrac{(2.00)(25.0)}{100.0} = 0.500\) M. The volume quadrupled, so the concentration fell to one-quarter.
Worked example · counting particles and mixing
(a) How many chloride ions are in 50.0 mL of 0.150 M CaCl2? (b) What is the concentration when 100.0 mL of 0.200 M NaCl is mixed with 150.0 mL of 0.100 M NaCl?
(a) Each CaCl2 gives 2 Cl−, so [Cl−] = 0.300 M. Moles Cl− = (0.300)(0.0500) = 0.0150 mol, which is \(0.0150 \times 6.022 \times 10^{23} = 9.03 \times 10^{21}\) ions.
(b) Total moles = (0.200)(0.1000) + (0.100)(0.1500) = 0.0200 + 0.0150 = 0.0350 mol in 0.2500 L, so \(M = 0.140\) M. (The answer is between the two original concentrations, nearer the one with more solute.)
Particulate representations
A particle diagram of a solution shows the same information in a picture. Whatever you draw, follow these rules:
Draw the right species. An ionic solute appears as separate cations and anions (not as formula units). A molecular solute appears as intact molecules. A strong acid appears as ions; a weak acid, mostly as intact molecules (Unit 8).
Keep the ratio of ions equal to the formula. For CaCl2, twice as many Cl− as Ca2+. Charges must balance.
Show relative concentrations by the number of particles in the same size region: a more concentrated solution has more solute particles per solvent particle, in the same volume.
Show interactions. Orient water molecules with their oxygen ends toward cations and hydrogen ends toward anions.
Be consistent with conservation of matter. If a particle diagram shows a dilution, the number of solute particles stays the same while the number of solvent particles increases.
For example, if one beaker of 0.10 M NaCl is drawn with 4 Na+ and 4 Cl−, a beaker of 0.20 M NaCl of the same volume has 8 and 8, and a 0.10 M MgCl2 solution of the same volume has 4 Mg2+ and 8 Cl−.
Exam focus
Molarity uses volume of solution in liters. Convert mL to L before dividing.
Moles are conserved in a dilution; concentration is not.
Dissociate ionic compounds in your count. One mole of Al2(SO4)3 gives 2 mol Al3+ and 3 mol SO42−.
In particle diagrams, draw ions separated for strong electrolytes and do not draw bonds between the ions.
Do not use molality or percent composition; they are outside the AP course.
Practice
What is the molarity of a solution containing 12.5 g of glucose (C6H12O6, 180.16 g/mol) in 0.400 L of solution?
Show answer
What volume of 0.250 M KOH contains 0.0300 mol of KOH?
Show answer
\(V = n/M = 0.0300 / 0.250 = 0.120\) L = 120. mL.
How would you dilute 50.0 mL of 6.00 M H2SO4 to make a 1.50 M solution, and what is the final volume?
Show answer
\(V_2 = M_1V_1/M_2 = (6.00)(50.0)/1.50 = 200.\) mL. Add water to the 50.0 mL of acid until the total volume is 200. mL (adding 150. mL of water, with care for the safety rule of adding acid to water).
What are the concentrations of each ion in 0.200 M Al(NO3)3?
Show answer
Each formula unit gives 1 Al3+ and 3 NO3−, so [Al3+] = 0.200 M and [NO3−] = 0.600 M.
A particle diagram of a solution of K2SO4 shows 6 K+ ions. How many sulfate ions should it show, and should the K+ and SO42− be drawn bonded together?
Show answer
Three sulfate ions (2 K+ for each SO42−). The ions are separate and surrounded by water; they are not drawn bonded to each other.
Explain why sand in water is a heterogeneous mixture but sugar in water is a solution.
Show answer
Sugar molecules are distributed uniformly among the water molecules on the molecular scale, so the properties are the same throughout and it cannot be filtered out. Sand grains are large clusters of particles that settle and can be seen and filtered, so the mixture varies from place to place.
How do you get fresh water from the sea, caffeine out of coffee beans, or each dye out of a drop of black ink? Every separation exploits a difference in how the components interact with their surroundings,
which is the same intermolecular-force story you have been building. And before you can separate a mixture, it helps to know why substances mix at all. This lesson ties the two together: why some things dissolve in each other,
and how chemists use differences in intermolecular forces to pull a mixture apart.
Learning objectives · 3.9.A and 3.10.A
3.9.A Explain the results of a separation experiment based on intermolecular interactions.
3.10.A Explain the relationship between the solubility of ionic and molecular compounds in aqueous and nonaqueous solvents and the intermolecular interactions between particles.
Required content · EK 3.9.A.1 and 3.10.A.1
The components of a liquid solution cannot be separated by filtration. They can, however, be separated using processes that take advantage of differences in the intermolecular interactions of the components.
Chromatography (paper, thin-layer and column) separates chemical species by taking advantage of the differential strength of intermolecular interactions between and among the components of the solution (the mobile phase) and with the surface components of the stationary phase. The resulting chromatogram can be used to infer the relative polarities of components in a mixture.
Distillation separates chemical species by taking advantage of the differential strength of intermolecular interactions between and among the components and the effects these interactions have on the vapor pressures of the components in the mixture.
Substances with similar intermolecular interactions tend to be miscible or soluble in one another.
Solubility: like dissolves like
Whether one substance dissolves in another depends on the balance of three attractions: solute with solute, solvent with solvent, and solute with solvent.
A substance dissolves readily when the new solute-solvent attractions are about as strong as the ones that had to be overcome. The compact rule is “like dissolves like”:
substances with similar intermolecular forces tend to be soluble (or miscible, for liquids) in each other.
Solute
Solvent
Result
Reason
NaCl (ionic)
water (polar)
dissolves
ion-dipole attractions with water replace the ionic lattice attractions
NaCl
hexane (nonpolar)
insoluble
hexane offers only weak dispersion forces, too weak to separate ions
ethanol (polar, H-bonding)
water
miscible
hydrogen bonds between ethanol and water
hexane (nonpolar)
water
immiscible
water molecules attract each other far more strongly than hexane
hexane
octane (nonpolar)
miscible
similar dispersion forces
I2 (nonpolar)
hexane
dissolves
dispersion forces on both sides
Why oil and water do not mix. A water molecule is held to its neighbors by hydrogen bonds. A hexane molecule can offer only weak dispersion attractions in return, so inserting it among water molecules replaces strong hydrogen bonds with weaker contact. It is energetically unfavorable, and the liquids separate into layers.
A single molecule with two natures. A long-chain alcohol has a polar O–H end that hydrogen bonds to water and a nonpolar hydrocarbon tail that does not. As the tail gets longer the nonpolar part dominates and the solubility in water falls:
methanol, ethanol and propanol are miscible with water; 1-butanol dissolves only to about 7 g per 100 mL; 1-hexanol to about 0.6 g per 100 mL. This is also why soaps work: one end binds to water and the other to grease.
Worked example · predict solubility
Predict whether each dissolves in water: (a) CH3OH, (b) CCl4, (c) KNO3, (d) C8H18.
(a) Soluble: polar with an O–H group, hydrogen bonds with water. (b) Insoluble: nonpolar, only dispersion forces. (c) Soluble: ionic, hydrated by ion-dipole forces. (d) Insoluble: nonpolar hydrocarbon.
Separating a mixture
A heterogeneous mixture can be separated by physical differences you can see (sieving, filtering a solid from a liquid). A solution, though, passes straight through filter paper, since its particles are separated at the molecular level.
To separate the components of a solution you must use differences in how strongly the components attract their surroundings.
Chromatography
In chromatography a mixture is carried by a moving solvent (the mobile phase) across a solid or coated surface (the stationary phase, such as paper or silica). Each component is attracted to both phases, and the balance of those attractions sets how fast it moves.
A component that is attracted strongly to the stationary phase lags behind; one that is attracted more strongly to the mobile phase travels farther.
Figure 3.6a A paper chromatogram. Compare the mixture lane with pure reference lanes to identify the components. Dye C travels farthest, so it is attracted least to the polar paper (stationary phase) and most to the solvent (mobile phase).
The result is a chromatogram. The retention factor \(R_f\) identifies each spot:
\[ R_f = \dfrac{\text{distance moved by the spot}}{\text{distance moved by the solvent front}} \]
\(R_f\) is always between 0 and 1. On polar paper with a nonpolar solvent, the more polar components stick to the paper and have lower \(R_f\), while less polar components travel with the solvent and have higher \(R_f\). Reverse the polarities of the phases and the order reverses.
So a chromatogram lets you infer the relative polarities of the components.
Worked example · reading a chromatogram
On polar paper using a nonpolar solvent, dyes A, B and C move 2.0, 4.0 and 6.5 cm while the solvent front moves 8.0 cm. Compute \(R_f\) and rank the dyes by polarity.
\(R_f\)(A) = 2.0/8.0 = 0.25; \(R_f\)(B) = 4.0/8.0 = 0.50; \(R_f\)(C) = 6.5/8.0 = 0.81. The most polar dye is attracted most strongly to the polar paper and moves least: A is the most polar, then B, then C (the least polar).
Distillation
Distillation separates liquids with different boiling points. The mixture is heated; the component with weaker intermolecular forces has the higher vapor pressure and boils first. Its vapor travels into a condenser, cools and drips into a receiving flask.
The residue left behind is richer in the component with the stronger intermolecular forces.
Figure 3.6b Distillation separates liquids by boiling point. The component with weaker intermolecular forces has the higher vapor pressure, boils first, is condensed and collects in the receiver.
Ethanol (78 °C) and water (100 °C) are separated this way: both hydrogen bond, but ethanol’s molecules are held less strongly overall, so it comes off first. Distillation also separates a dissolved nonvolatile solid from its solvent, as in desalinating seawater: the water evaporates and condenses, and the salt stays behind.
Exam focus
Always explain solubility by comparing forces: solute-solvent attractions against the attractions that must be broken.
Do not say “like dissolves like” alone. Name the forces on each side.
In chromatography, relate movement to polarity and say which phase is polar. Higher Rf means more attracted to the mobile phase.
Distillation works because of different vapor pressures, which come from different intermolecular forces.
Filtration cannot separate a solution.
Practice
Explain why iodine (I2) dissolves in hexane but not in water.
Show answer
I2 is nonpolar and has only London dispersion forces, which it can share with hexane. Water molecules hold each other with strong hydrogen bonds, and I2 cannot offer comparable attractions, so it is not soluble in water.
Predict which is more soluble in water, 1-propanol or 1-octanol, and justify.
Show answer
1-propanol. Both have a polar O–H group, but octanol has a much longer nonpolar hydrocarbon tail whose dispersion forces cannot compete with water’s hydrogen bonds, so it is far less soluble.
In a paper chromatography experiment, one component has \(R_f = 0.20\) and another \(R_f = 0.70\) using a nonpolar solvent on polar paper. Which is more polar?
Show answer
The one with \(R_f = 0.20\). It is attracted more strongly to the polar stationary phase, so it moves less far than the solvent.
A spot moved 3.6 cm and the solvent front moved 9.0 cm. What is its \(R_f\)?
Show answer
\(R_f = 3.6 / 9.0 = 0.40\).
Why can saltwater not be separated by filtration, but can be separated by distillation?
Show answer
The ions in solution are far smaller than the pores of filter paper and pass through. In distillation, water has a much higher vapor pressure than the dissolved ionic solid (which is nonvolatile because of strong ionic attractions), so it vaporizes and is condensed while the salt remains.
A mixture of acetone (56 °C) and ethylene glycol (197 °C) is distilled. Which collects first, and what does this say about their intermolecular forces?
Show answer
Acetone collects first. Its lower boiling point means weaker intermolecular forces (dipole-dipole and dispersion), whereas ethylene glycol, with two O–H groups, forms extensive hydrogen bonds and has a lower vapor pressure.
A microwave oven heats food, an infrared camera sees body heat, and ultraviolet light causes sunburn. All three are electromagnetic radiation, yet they do very different things to molecules.
The reason is energy: each type of radiation carries photons of a different energy, and a molecule can respond only to photons that match a gap between its own energy levels.
This lesson connects the regions of the spectrum to the kinds of motion they excite and gives you the two equations that link wavelength, frequency and photon energy.
Learning objectives · 3.11.A and 3.12.A
3.11.A Explain the relationship between a region of the electromagnetic spectrum and the types of molecular or electronic transitions associated with that region.
3.12.A Explain the properties of an absorbed or emitted photon in relationship to an electronic transition in an atom or molecule.
Required content · EK 3.11.A.1, 3.12.A.1 and 3.12.A.2
Differences in absorption or emission of photons in different spectral regions are related to the different types of molecular motion or electronic transition: microwave radiation is associated with transitions in molecular rotational levels; infrared radiation with transitions in molecular vibrational levels; ultraviolet and visible radiation with transitions in electronic energy levels.
When a photon is absorbed (or emitted) by an atom or molecule, the energy of the species is increased (or decreased) by an amount equal to the energy of the photon.
The wavelength of the electromagnetic wave is related to its frequency and the speed of light by \(c = \lambda\nu\). The energy of a photon is related to the frequency by Planck’s equation, \(E = h\nu\).
Light as waves and as photons
Electromagnetic radiation behaves as a wave with a wavelength \(\lambda\) (distance between crests, in meters) and a frequency \(\nu\) (crests per second, in hertz = s−1). All of it travels in a vacuum at the same speed, \(c = 3.00 \times 10^8\) m/s, so wavelength and frequency are inversely related:
\[ c = \lambda\nu \]
It also behaves as a stream of particles, photons, each carrying a packet of energy proportional to its frequency (Planck’s equation), with \(h = 6.626 \times 10^{-34}\) J·s:
\[ E = h\nu = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda} \]
So short wavelength means high frequency means high energy. A gamma-ray photon is far more energetic than a radio photon.
Figure 3.7a Regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. Low-energy microwave photons change how a molecule rotates, infrared photons change how its bonds vibrate, and ultraviolet and visible photons are energetic enough to move electrons between energy levels.
Which radiation does what
Region
Typical wavelength
Energy per photon
What it changes in a molecule
Microwave
about 1 mm to 10 cm
about 10−24 J
rotational energy levels (the molecule spins faster)
Infrared
about 1 to 100 µm
about 10−20 J
vibrational energy levels (bonds stretch and bend more)
Visible and ultraviolet
about 100 to 700 nm
about 10−19 J
electronic energy levels (an electron moves to a higher level)
The ordering follows the spacing of the energy levels: rotational levels are very closely spaced, vibrational levels are farther apart, and electronic levels are farthest apart, so electronic transitions need the most energetic photons.
This is why a microwave oven (rotation of water molecules) warms food but does not break bonds, why infrared spectroscopy identifies functional groups by the vibrations of their bonds, and why UV light can drive chemical reactions and damage DNA.
Absorption and emission
An atom or molecule has only certain allowed energy levels. It can absorb a photon only if the photon’s energy exactly equals the difference between two levels. Light of the wrong energy passes through. Likewise, when a species drops from a higher to a lower level it can emit a photon whose energy equals the gap.
Figure 3.7b A species absorbs a photon only if the photon energy equals the gap between two energy levels, and the energy released when it falls to a lower level equals the energy of the photon emitted.
\[ \Delta E = E_{\text{final}} - E_{\text{initial}} = h\nu = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda} \]
A solution that appears blue absorbs light in the orange-red region, so the colors we see are the ones that are not absorbed.
Worked example · frequency and energy of green light
Green light has a wavelength of 520 nm. Find its frequency, the energy of one photon, and the energy per mole of photons.
Per mole. \((3.82 \times 10^{-19}\ \text{J})(6.022 \times 10^{23}\ \text{mol}^{-1}) = 2.30 \times 10^5\) J/mol = 230 kJ/mol. (Comparable to a covalent bond energy, which is why light can drive reactions.)
Worked example · comparing regions
Compare a microwave photon (2.45 GHz, used in ovens) with the green photon above.
The wavelength of the microwave is \(\lambda = c/\nu = \dfrac{3.00 \times 10^8}{2.45 \times 10^{9}} = 0.122\) m, and its energy is \(E = h\nu = (6.626 \times 10^{-34})(2.45 \times 10^9) = 1.62 \times 10^{-24}\) J, about \(2 \times 10^5\) times smaller than a green photon. That is why microwaves can only rotate molecules and cannot excite electrons.
Worked example · connecting to Unit 1
The first ionization energy of sodium is 5.14 eV (8.23 × 10−19 J per atom). What is the longest wavelength of light that could remove that electron?
\(\lambda = \dfrac{hc}{E} = \dfrac{(6.626 \times 10^{-34})(3.00 \times 10^8)}{8.23 \times 10^{-19}} = 2.41 \times 10^{-7}\) m = 241 nm, in the ultraviolet. Visible light does not have enough energy per photon to ionize a sodium atom, no matter how bright it is.
Exam focus
Short wavelength, high frequency, high energy. Be ready to rank photons from any one of the three.
Convert units first: nm to m (\(10^{-9}\)), GHz to Hz (\(10^9\)). A wrong exponent is the most common error.
Match region to transition: microwave to rotation, infrared to vibration, UV/visible to electronic.
A photon must match an energy gap exactly. More intense light does not help if each photon has too little energy.
Per photon against per mole: multiply by \(N_A\) for a mole.
Practice
Rank the following photons from lowest to highest energy: infrared at 3.3 µm, ultraviolet at 250 nm, microwave at 12 cm.
Show answer
Microwave (12 cm) < infrared (3.3 µm) < ultraviolet (250 nm). Energy is inversely proportional to wavelength, so the longest wavelength carries the least energy.
Calculate the energy of one photon of 250 nm ultraviolet light and compare it with a typical C–C bond energy (347 kJ/mol).
Show answer
\(E = hc/\lambda = (6.626 \times 10^{-34})(3.00 \times 10^8)/(250 \times 10^{-9}) = 7.95 \times 10^{-19}\) J, which is \(479\) kJ/mol. That is greater than the C–C bond energy, so UV photons of this wavelength can break C–C bonds.
What is the frequency of a photon with energy \(3.0 \times 10^{-19}\) J?
Show answer
Which type of radiation would be used to study the stretching of bonds in a molecule, and why?
Show answer
Infrared. Its photon energies match the spacing of vibrational energy levels, so molecules absorb IR light when a bond vibration can be excited.
A solution appears red. What can you say about the light it absorbs?
Show answer
It transmits red light and absorbs light from other parts of the visible spectrum, mainly the complementary colors (blue to green). A species absorbs a photon only when the photon energy matches an electronic energy gap.
An electron in a molecule moves from a level with energy \(-4.50 \times 10^{-19}\) J to one at \(-2.10 \times 10^{-19}\) J. Is a photon absorbed or emitted, and what is its wavelength?
Show answer
The energy increases, so a photon is absorbed. \(\Delta E = 2.40 \times 10^{-19}\) J. \(\lambda = hc/\Delta E = (6.626 \times 10^{-34})(3.00 \times 10^8)/(2.40 \times 10^{-19}) = 8.28 \times 10^{-7}\) m = 828 nm, in the near infrared.
A drop of dye in a glass of water makes it faintly colored; ten drops make it dark. That everyday observation, made quantitative, becomes a laboratory tool: the darker the solution, the more light it absorbs,
and the relationship is a straight line. Chemists use it to measure the concentration of everything from blood glucose to nitrate in a river sample. This lesson explains the law, how to use a calibration line,
and what can go wrong.
Learning objective · 3.13.A
Explain the amount of light absorbed by a solution of molecules or ions in relationship to the concentration, path length and molar absorptivity.
Required content · EK 3.13.A.1 and 3.13.A.2
The Beer-Lambert law relates the absorption of light by a solution to three variables according to the equation \(A = \varepsilon b c\). The molar absorptivity, \(\varepsilon\), describes how intensely a chemical species absorbs light of a specific wavelength. The path length, \(b\), and concentration, \(c\), are proportional to the number of light-absorbing particles in the light path.
In most experiments the path length and wavelength of light are held constant. In such cases the absorbance is proportional only to the concentration of absorbing molecules or ions. The spectrophotometer is typically set to the wavelength of maximum absorbance (optimum wavelength) for the species being analyzed to ensure the maximum sensitivity of measurement.
Absorbance and transmittance
In a spectrophotometer, light of one chosen wavelength passes through a sample in a transparent container (a cuvette) and a detector measures how much gets through. The fraction that gets through is the transmittance,
\(T = I/I_0\), where \(I_0\) is the light entering and \(I\) the light leaving. Instruments report absorbance, defined as
\[ A = -\log_{10} T = \log_{10}\dfrac{I_0}{I} \]
Absorbance has no units. If 100% of the light gets through (T = 1), A = 0. If 50% gets through, A = 0.301. If 25% gets through, A = 0.602. If only 1% gets through, A = 2. Because of the logarithm, each increase of 1 in absorbance means 10 times less light gets through.
The law
Equation on the AP reference sheet
\[ A = \varepsilon\, b\, c \]
\(A\) is the absorbance (unitless), \(\varepsilon\) the molar absorptivity (L·mol−1·cm−1), \(b\) the path length through the sample (cm, commonly 1.00 cm), and \(c\) the concentration (mol/L).
The logic is simple. Light is absorbed by the particles it meets in its path. Doubling the concentration doubles the number of absorbing particles in the beam; doubling the path length also doubles it. Either change doubles A.
The molar absorptivity \(\varepsilon\) says how strongly each mole of the species absorbs at that wavelength: a pale species has a small \(\varepsilon\), an intensely colored one a large \(\varepsilon\).
Figure 3.8a The Beer-Lambert law, A = εbc. With fixed path length and wavelength, absorbance rises in direct proportion to concentration, so a calibration line of standards lets you find the concentration of an unknown from its absorbance.
Using the law in the lab
Choose the wavelength of maximum absorbance (λmax) for the species, where \(\varepsilon\) is largest, so that a small change in concentration produces the biggest change in A (greatest sensitivity).
Zero the instrument with a blank (solvent only), so that absorption by the cuvette and solvent is not counted.
Measure standards of known concentration and plot absorbance against concentration. With constant b and wavelength, the graph is a straight line through the origin whose slope is \(\varepsilon b\).
Measure the unknown and read its concentration from the line (or use \(c = A/\varepsilon b\)).
Worked example · from absorbance to concentration
A dye has \(\varepsilon = 4{,}200\) L·mol−1·cm−1 at its \(\lambda_{\max}\). A sample in a 1.00 cm cuvette has an absorbance of 0.37. What is the concentration?
A solution has A = 0.42 in a 1.00 cm cuvette. What is the absorbance (a) in a 2.00 cm cuvette, (b) after diluting 1.00 mL to 5.00 mL?
(a) A is proportional to b, so A doubles to 0.84. (b) The concentration falls to one-fifth, so \(A = 0.42 / 5 = 0.084\).
Worked example · transmittance
A sample transmits 25% of the light at the chosen wavelength. What is its absorbance, and what would the absorbance be if the concentration were doubled?
\(A = -\log(0.25) = 0.602\). Doubling \(c\) doubles A to 1.20, which means \(T = 10^{-1.20} = 0.063\), only 6.3% transmitted. Note that the transmittance does not simply halve; absorbance is the quantity that is proportional to concentration.
Sources of error
Beer-Lambert is a model, and a good experimenter can list how it fails:
Very high concentration or absorbance (above about 1 to 2): very little light reaches the detector, and the line curves; dilute the sample instead.
The wrong wavelength: away from \(\lambda_{\max}\) the signal is small and less sensitive.
A dirty, scratched or fingerprinted cuvette, bubbles, or particles that scatter light: they add apparent absorbance not due to the species.
Not blanking with the same solvent and cuvette.
Different path lengths between standards and unknown (for example, mismatched cuvettes).
Chemical changes: if the species reacts, associates or breaks down as the concentration changes, \(\varepsilon\) is no longer constant.
Exam focus
Absorbance is proportional to concentration (and to path length), not transmittance.
Plot A against c. The line goes through the origin when the blank is correct.
Use \(\lambda_{\max}\). The reason is maximum sensitivity.
Check units: \(\varepsilon\) in L·mol−1·cm−1 goes with b in cm and c in mol/L.
Be ready to name a source of error and state how it would change the calculated concentration.
Practice
A solution of \(\varepsilon = 1.50 \times 10^4\) L·mol−1·cm−1 has A = 0.75 in a 1.00 cm cell. Find the concentration.
Show answer
\(c = A/(\varepsilon b) = 0.75/(1.50 \times 10^4)(1.00) = 5.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M.
What happens to the absorbance if the concentration is tripled and the path length is halved?
Show answer
A is proportional to both: \(3 \times \tfrac{1}{2} = 1.5\), so the absorbance increases by a factor of 1.5.
Why does a spectrophotometer measurement use the wavelength of maximum absorbance?
Show answer
At that wavelength \(\varepsilon\) is largest, so each unit of concentration produces the largest absorbance, giving the greatest sensitivity and the smallest relative error.
A student measures A for several standards and gets a line that curves toward the horizontal at the highest concentrations. Give one reason and one fix.
Show answer
At high absorbance very little light reaches the detector and the instrument response (and sometimes the chemistry) no longer follows the law, so the line flattens. Dilute the samples so that the absorbance is below about 1.
A student forgets to wipe fingerprints off the cuvette. Will the calculated concentration be too high or too low? Explain.
Show answer
Too high. Fingerprints scatter or absorb light, which adds to the measured absorbance, so the instrument reports a higher A than the solution alone gives and the concentration calculated from A is too high.
Calculate the transmittance of a sample with A = 1.00.
Show answer
\(T = 10^{-A} = 10^{-1.00} = 0.10\), so 10% of the light is transmitted.
Unit 3 practice · 10 problems
Unit 3 practice: Properties of Substances and Mixtures
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed; \(R = 0.08206\) L·atm/(mol·K).
Propane (CH3CH2CH3), dimethyl ether (CH3OCH3), and ethanol (CH3CH2OH) all have 26 electrons. Rank them by boiling point and justify each placement with the intermolecular forces present.
Show answer
Propane (−42 °C) < dimethyl ether (−24 °C) < ethanol (78 °C). Equal electron counts make the London dispersion forces comparable, so the difference is in the other forces. Propane is nonpolar: LDF only. Dimethyl ether is polar (bent C–O–C) and adds dipole–dipole attractions. Ethanol has an O–H bond, so it hydrogen-bonds to the lone pairs on neighboring oxygens: the strongest of the three, needing the most energy to separate.
Acetone (CH3COCH3) and 2-propanol (CH3CHOHCH3) have similar molar masses. Which has the higher vapor pressure at 25 °C, and which would distill out of a mixture first? Explain.
Show answer
Acetone on both counts. Both are polar with similar LDF, but 2-propanol has an O–H group and hydrogen-bonds; acetone has no H on O and relies on dipole–dipole forces. At the same temperature the molecules share the same kinetic-energy distribution, but a larger fraction of acetone molecules have enough energy to escape their weaker attractions, so its vapor pressure is higher (about 230 vs. 44 torr) and its boiling point lower (56 vs. 82 °C): it boils off first.
Classify each solid as molecular, covalent network, ionic, or metallic: diamond, I2(s), CaF2, Fe. Which has the lowest melting point and which the highest? Explain in terms of what must be overcome.
Show answer
Diamond: covalent network; I2: molecular; CaF2: ionic; Fe: metallic. Lowest: I2 (114 °C): melting only disrupts London dispersion forces between intact I2 molecules; the I–I bonds stay put. Highest: diamond (above 3500 °C), every atom is covalently bonded to four neighbors, so melting means breaking C–C bonds throughout. CaF2 (Coulombic attraction between Ca2+ and F−) and Fe (cations in an electron sea) fall in between.
A 2.00 L flask at 300 K and 1.00 atm holds 3.58 g of an unknown gas. Find its molar mass and identify it as CO2, N2, or Ar.
Show answer
\(n = \dfrac{PV}{RT} = \dfrac{(1.00)(2.00)}{(0.08206)(300)} = 0.0812\) mol. \(M = \dfrac{3.58\ \mathrm{g}}{0.0812\ \mathrm{mol}} = 44.1\) g/mol → CO2 (44.01). N2 would be 28.0 and Ar 39.9.
Zn(s) + 2 HCl(aq) → ZnCl2(aq) + H2(g). What volume of hydrogen gas at 1.00 atm and 298 K is produced when 2.00 g of zinc reacts with excess acid?
Show answer
\(2.00 / 65.38 = 0.0306\) mol Zn; the ratio is 1 : 1, so 0.0306 mol H2. \(V = \dfrac{nRT}{P} = \dfrac{(0.0306)(0.08206)(298)}{1.00} = 0.748\) L. Grams → moles → mole ratio → gas law.
0.250 mol N2 and 0.750 mol He share a 10.0 L container at 298 K. Find the total pressure and the partial pressure of N2.
Show answer
\(P_{\text{total}} = \dfrac{(1.000)(0.08206)(298)}{10.0} = 2.45\) atm. Mole fraction \(X_{\mathrm{N_2}} = 0.250/1.000 = 0.250\), so \(P_{\mathrm{N_2}} = 0.250 \times 2.45 = 0.611\) atm (and He contributes 1.83 atm). Each gas acts as if it were alone in the container.
Two rigid 1.0 L flasks at the same temperature hold 0.10 mol He and 0.10 mol Ar respectively. Which statement is true?
Average kinetic energy depends only on temperature (\(KE_{\text{avg}} = \tfrac{3}{2}k_BT\)), so at the same \(T\) the He and Ar atoms have exactly the same average kinetic energy. He atoms are faster, not more energetic.
Since \(KE = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\) is the same for both, the lighter He atoms must move faster; Ar atoms, ten times heavier, are the slower ones by a factor of \(\sqrt{10}\). This choice reverses the mass–speed relationship.
Equal \(n\), \(V\), and \(T\) give equal \(P\) by \(PV = nRT\); heavier atoms hit the wall harder but less often, and the two effects cancel exactly for an ideal gas. (Compressed to very high pressure, Ar would deviate more from ideal behavior: its atoms are larger and more polarizable, so their own volume and their London dispersion forces matter more.)
Pressure comes from the momentum transferred per collision times the collision frequency. Ar atoms carry more momentum per hit but hit less often because they are slower, so the pressure is the same: mass drops out of the ideal gas law.
What volume of 2.50 M Na2SO4 stock is needed to prepare 500.0 mL of 0.150 M Na2SO4? What is [Na+] in the final solution?
Show answer
\(V_1 = \dfrac{M_2 V_2}{M_1} = \dfrac{(0.150)(500.0\ \mathrm{mL})}{2.50} = 30.0\) mL, then dilute to the 500.0 mL mark. Each formula unit releases two Na+: \([\mathrm{Na^+}] = 2 \times 0.150 = 0.300\) M (and \([\mathrm{SO_4^{2-}}] = 0.150\) M).
Two compounds are spotted on polar paper and run with a nonpolar solvent. Spot A moves 4.5 cm and spot B moves 1.5 cm while the solvent front moves 7.5 cm. Compute each \(R_f\) and decide which compound is more polar.
Show answer
\(R_f(\mathrm{A}) = 4.5/7.5 = 0.60\); \(R_f(\mathrm{B}) = 1.5/7.5 = 0.20\). B is more polar: it is held back by strong dipole–dipole or hydrogen-bonding attractions to the polar stationary phase and has little affinity for the nonpolar mobile phase. A interacts weakly with the paper and travels with the solvent.
A standard solution of a dye at \(1.50 \times 10^{-4}\) M has absorbance 0.210 in a 1.00 cm cuvette. (a) Find the molar absorptivity. (b) An unknown reads 0.455 in the same cuvette; find its concentration. (c) What absorbance would the standard give in a 2.00 cm cuvette?
Ice melts, iron rusts, sugar dissolves, wood burns. All four are changes, but only two make new substances. Telling these apart is the first step in the study of reactions, and it is harder than it sounds,
because the evidence you can see (bubbles, color, heat) can come from either kind of change. The reliable test is at the particle level: were bonds broken and formed, or did the particles merely rearrange or separate?
Learning objectives · 4.1.A and 4.4.A
4.1.A Identify evidence of chemical and physical changes in matter.
4.4.A Explain the relationship between macroscopic characteristics and bond interactions for chemical and physical processes.
Required content · EK 4.1.A.1, 4.1.A.2, 4.4.A.1 and 4.4.A.2
A physical change occurs when a substance undergoes a change in properties but not a change in composition. Changes in the phase of a substance or formation/separation of mixtures of substances are common physical changes.
A chemical change occurs when substances are transformed into new substances, typically with different compositions. Production of heat or light, formation of a gas, formation of a precipitate and/or color change provide possible evidence that a chemical change has occurred.
Processes that involve the breaking and/or formation of chemical bonds are typically classified as chemical processes. Processes that involve only changes in intermolecular interactions, such as phase changes, are typically classified as physical processes.
Sometimes physical processes involve the breaking of chemical bonds. For example, plausible arguments could be made for the dissolution of a salt in water, as either a physical or chemical process, since it involves breaking of ionic bonds and the formation of ion-dipole interactions between ions and solvent.
Physical changes
In a physical change the substance keeps its identity: its composition is the same before and after. Typical examples are changes of state (melting, freezing, boiling, condensing, sublimation), crushing or cutting, and mixing or separating substances (making salt water, filtering sand from water, distilling alcohol from a mixture).
Water vapor is still H2O. At the particle level, only the intermolecular interactions change: how far apart the molecules are and how strongly they attract each other.
Physical changes can usually be reversed by changing the temperature or by separating the mixture.
Chemical changes
In a chemical change (a chemical reaction) one or more substances are converted into new substances with different compositions and different properties. Atoms are the same, but the bonds that hold them together are broken and new bonds form.
Hydrogen and oxygen, both gases, become water, a liquid; iron and oxygen become rust, a brittle orange solid.
Figure 4.1b Physical changes alter only intermolecular interactions (phase changes, mixing, dissolving molecular solids); chemical changes break and form covalent or ionic bonds, producing new substances.
Macroscopic evidence that a chemical change may have occurred:
Figure 4.1a Common evidence that a chemical change has occurred. None is proof by itself: boiling also makes bubbles and dissolving a dye changes color. The firm test is whether new substances with new properties formed.
Production of heat or light (combustion, a glow stick, a warming hand pack).
Formation of a gas not simply from boiling (antacid fizzing, a metal in acid).
Formation of a precipitate (a solid appearing when two clear solutions mix).
Color change not caused by dilution or mixing dyes (silver tarnishing, an indicator changing color).
The wording “possible evidence” matters. Each of these can also occur in a physical change: boiling water forms bubbles and gives off no new substance; a drop of food coloring changes the color of water without a reaction;
a freezing solution releases heat. A strong claim needs more than one clue or a test of the substance’s properties (a new boiling point, new solubility, new odor).
The gray area
Classification follows the bonds. If covalent or ionic bonds are broken and new ones formed, the process is chemical; if only intermolecular forces change, it is physical. Some processes are less clear.
Dissolving an ionic solid such as NaCl in water breaks the ionic bonds of the lattice and forms new ion-dipole attractions with water. It is usually called a physical change, because the ions are still Na+ and Cl− and can be recovered by evaporating the water,
but a plausible case can be made that it is chemical, because ionic bonds were broken. The AP course accepts either answer when the reasoning is about the bonds. Dissolving a molecular solid such as sugar is physical (only intermolecular forces change). Dissolving HCl in water is chemical: a covalent bond breaks and ions form.
Process
What happens to particles
Type
Boiling water
H2O molecules separate; hydrogen bonds overcome
physical
Rusting iron
Fe atoms and O2 form Fe2O3; new bonds
chemical
Dissolving sugar
molecules separate and hydrogen bond with water
physical
Burning methane
C–H and O=O bonds broken; C=O and O–H formed
chemical
Melting copper
metal cores move more freely; metallic bonding persists
physical
Dissolving NaCl in water
ionic bonds broken, ion-dipole attractions formed
either, with bond-based reasoning
Worked example · justify a classification
A student heats a white powder and observes that it turns yellow while a gas with a pungent smell is released. The yellow solid does not turn white on cooling. Is the change physical or chemical?
Chemical. A new gas formed (odor), the solid has a different color that persists after cooling (so it is not just thermal expansion or a phase change), and the change is not reversed. Together these indicate new substances with new bonds. Each piece of evidence alone would be weaker; the combination of a gas, a color change and non-reversibility is strong.
Worked example · from data
A liquid boils at 78 °C. After a reaction the liquid in the flask boils at 118 °C and has a different odor. What can be concluded?
Boiling point is a property that depends on the identity of the substance (its intermolecular forces). A different boiling point and odor show that a different substance is present, so a chemical change occurred. If the boiling point were unchanged, the liquid is probably the same substance.
Exam focus
Base the classification on the bonds. “It changed color” alone is not an argument.
Use the word “possible.” Evidence suggests a chemical change; only a change of composition proves it.
Phase changes are physical; the molecules stay the same, and the covalent bonds do not break.
Dissolving salts is the debatable case: accept either label only with the ionic-bond and ion-dipole reasoning shown.
New properties of the product (melting point, boiling point, solubility, conductivity) are the best experimental evidence.
Practice
Classify as physical or chemical and justify: (a) dry ice sublimes, (b) milk sours, (c) a silver spoon tarnishes, (d) iodine crystals dissolve in hexane.
Show answer
(a) Physical: CO2 molecules separate; no bonds break. (b) Chemical: bacteria convert lactose to lactic acid, a new substance. (c) Chemical: silver reacts with sulfur compounds in the air to form Ag2S. (d) Physical: I2 molecules remain intact; only intermolecular forces change.
Two clear solutions are mixed and a white solid forms. Give two further observations that would strengthen the claim that a chemical change occurred.
Show answer
Examples: the solid does not redissolve when the mixture is warmed or diluted; the solid has a different melting point or solubility than either reactant; the temperature of the mixture changes; the solid is identified as a different compound.
Explain why boiling water is a physical change even though bubbles of gas form.
Show answer
The bubbles are water vapor, the same compound as the liquid. Boiling separates H2O molecules by overcoming intermolecular hydrogen bonds; the covalent O–H bonds are not broken and no new substance forms.
A student argues that dissolving table salt in water is a chemical change. Give the reasoning that supports this claim, and the reasoning against it.
Show answer
For: the ionic bonds in the crystal are broken and new ion-dipole attractions form between the ions and water. Against: the ions Na+ and Cl− are unchanged and no new substance is made, and the salt can be recovered unchanged by evaporating the water.
An unknown substance is heated and gives off a gas that relights a glowing splint. The remaining solid has a different color and melting point. Is this evidence of a chemical change?
Show answer
Yes. A gas was formed (and its identity, oxygen, is consistent with a decomposition), and the residue has different properties (color, melting point) from the original, so a new substance formed.
Is melting copper a chemical or physical change? What happens to the metallic bonding?
Show answer
Physical. The positive cores of liquid copper still sit in a sea of delocalized electrons; the atoms gain enough kinetic energy to move past each other, but no new substance forms and the metallic bonding is maintained.
An equation is a sentence in the language of chemistry: it says which substances react, which are formed, and in what proportions. A good equation obeys two conservation laws that cannot be broken, conservation of atoms and conservation of charge.
For reactions in water, there are three ways to write the same reaction, and the one you choose depends on what you want to say. The net ionic equation, which strips away everything that does not change, is the most informative and the one the AP exam asks for most.
Learning objective · 4.2.A
Represent changes in matter with a balanced chemical or net ionic equation: (i) for physical changes; (ii) for given information about the identity of the reactants and/or product; (iii) for ions in a given chemical reaction.
Required content · EK 4.2.A.1 to 4.2.A.3
All physical and chemical processes can be represented symbolically by balanced equations.
Chemical equations represent chemical changes. These changes are the result of a rearrangement of atoms into new combinations; thus, any representation of a chemical change must contain equal numbers of atoms of every element before and after the change occurred. Equations thus demonstrate that mass and charge are conserved in chemical reactions.
Balanced molecular, complete ionic and net ionic equations are differing symbolic forms used to represent a chemical reaction. The form used to represent the reaction depends on the context in which it is to be used.
Balancing an equation
A balanced equation has the same number of atoms of every element on both sides. You balance by changing coefficients (the numbers in front), never subscripts, since changing a subscript changes the substance.
Physical changes are also written as equations: H2O(l) → H2O(g) for boiling, NaCl(s) → Na+(aq) + Cl−(aq) for dissolving.
Write correct formulas for every reactant and product.
Balance elements that appear in only one substance on each side first; leave H and O (often in many substances) and free elements for last.
Adjust coefficients, then check every element. Use the smallest whole-number coefficients.
Add state symbols: (s), (l), (g), (aq).
Worked example · balancing a combustion
Balance C3H8 + O2 → CO2 + H2O.
Carbon: 3 on the left, so 3 CO2. Hydrogen: 8 on the left, so 4 H2O. Oxygen on the right: 3(2) + 4(1) = 10, so 5 O2 on the left. C3H8 + 5 O2 → 3 CO2 + 4 H2O. Check: 3 C, 8 H and 10 O on each side. ✓
Three ways to write a reaction in water
Many reactions in water involve ionic compounds. An ionic compound that dissolves exists as separate ions, so the same reaction can be written at three levels of detail. Take the mixing of silver nitrate and sodium chloride solutions.
Figure 4.2a Precipitation as a particle picture. Silver and chloride ions come together to form insoluble AgCl; sodium and nitrate ions never change, so they are spectator ions and do not appear in the net ionic equation.
The ions that appear unchanged on both sides (Na+ and NO3− here) are spectator ions: they are present but do not take part. Removing them leaves the net ionic equation, which shows the chemistry that really happened.
Any silver salt that gives Ag+ and any chloride that gives Cl− would produce the same net change, which is why net ionic equations are so useful.
Which species to split into ions
Write as ions: soluble ionic compounds (aq), and strong acids (HCl, HBr, HI, HNO3, H2SO4, HClO4) and strong bases (group 1 and heavier group 2 hydroxides) in solution.
Keep as formulas: solids (s), liquids (l) such as H2O, gases (g), weak acids and weak bases (they are mostly un-ionized: CH3COOH, HF, NH3), and insoluble ionic compounds.
What counts as soluble? The AP course asks you to know the general statement that all sodium, potassium, ammonium and nitrate salts are soluble. Other cases are given in the problem or inferred from the data (a precipitate was observed, so the product must be insoluble).
Memorizing a long table is not required.
Procedure for a net ionic equation
Write the balanced molecular equation with states.
Split every (aq) strong electrolyte into its ions, using the subscripts and charges (CaCl2 gives Ca2+ + 2 Cl−). This is the complete ionic equation.
Cancel identical ions on both sides (the spectators).
Check that atoms and total charge balance, and that coefficients are in lowest terms.
Worked example · a precipitate
Aqueous lead(II) nitrate reacts with aqueous potassium iodide to form solid lead(II) iodide. Write the net ionic equation.
Pb2+(aq) + 2 I−(aq) → PbI2(s). Charge: +2 − 2 = 0 on the left; PbI2 is neutral. ✓
Worked example · strong acid with strong base
HCl(aq) + NaOH(aq) → NaCl(aq) + H2O(l). Complete ionic: H+ + Cl− + Na+ + OH− → Na+ + Cl− + H2O(l). Cancel Na+ and Cl−: H+(aq) + OH−(aq) → H2O(l). This is the net equation for every strong acid with every strong base.
Worked example · a weak acid and a gas
(a) Acetic acid, a weak acid, reacts with NaOH: CH3COOH(aq) + OH−(aq) → CH3COO−(aq) + H2O(l). The acid is kept as a molecule because it is mostly un-ionized, so unlike the strong-acid case, nothing cancels from the acid.
Zinc metal is placed in copper(II) sulfate solution: Zn(s) + CuSO4(aq) → ZnSO4(aq) + Cu(s). The spectator is SO42−. Net: Zn(s) + Cu2+(aq) → Zn2+(aq) + Cu(s). Atoms balance and charge balances (+2 on each side).
Exam focus
Balance both atoms and charge. A net ionic equation can be balanced in atoms but wrong in charge.
Never split solids, gases, water or weak acids and bases.
Write the ions with their charges and use correct formulas, especially for polyatomic ions (NO3−, SO42−, NH4+).
Include state symbols. They are part of the answer.
Spectator ions are the same on both sides; if nothing is left after canceling, there was no reaction.
Practice
Balance: Al + O2 → Al2O3.
Show answer
4 Al + 3 O2 → 2 Al2O3. Check: 4 Al and 6 O on each side.
Write the net ionic equation for aqueous calcium chloride mixed with aqueous sodium carbonate, forming solid calcium carbonate.
Show answer
Ca2+(aq) + CO32−(aq) → CaCO3(s). The spectators are Na+ and Cl−.
Write the net ionic equation for the reaction of aqueous ammonia (a weak base) with hydrochloric acid.
Show answer
NH3(aq) + H+(aq) → NH4+(aq). The ammonia is written as a molecule; Cl− is a spectator.
Identify the spectator ions when aqueous barium chloride reacts with aqueous sodium sulfate to form solid barium sulfate, and write the net ionic equation.
Show answer
Spectators: Na+ and Cl−. Net: Ba2+(aq) + SO42−(aq) → BaSO4(s).
A student writes Cu(s) + Ag+(aq) → Cu2+(aq) + Ag(s). Identify the error and correct it.
Show answer
Charge is not balanced: +1 on the left, +2 on the right. The balanced equation is Cu(s) + 2 Ag+(aq) → Cu2+(aq) + 2 Ag(s), with +2 on each side.
Write the equation for the dissolution of calcium chloride in water, and state the number of moles of ions produced per mole of solid.
Show answer
CaCl2(s) → Ca2+(aq) + 2 Cl−(aq). One mole of solid produces 3 mol of ions (1 mol Ca2+ and 2 mol Cl−).
An equation is compact, but a picture can show what an equation hides: how many of each particle, which are left over, and which are ions and which molecules. The AP exam regularly hands you a particle diagram and asks you to write the equation, or gives the equation and asks you to draw the result.
This lesson trains you to move in both directions between the symbols and the picture, using conservation of atoms as your only rule.
Learning objective · 4.3.A
Represent a given chemical reaction or physical process with a consistent particulate model.
Required content · EK 4.3.A.1
Balanced chemical equations in their various forms can be translated into symbolic particulate representations.
Reading a particle diagram
In a particle diagram each circle (or cluster) stands for an atom, molecule or ion, and the picture is a snapshot of a sample before and after. Three rules make every diagram consistent:
Atoms are conserved. Count each kind of atom in the “before” box and in the “after” box. The totals must match, even though the particles are rearranged.
Charge is conserved. If ions are shown, the total charge before equals the total charge after.
Substances are shown in the form they take. Molecular substances as intact molecules, ionic compounds in solution as separated ions, metals as atoms, and solids as touching particles.
Figure 4.3a A particle diagram obeys conservation of atoms: the same numbers of H and O atoms appear before and after, just rearranged. Dividing by 2 gives the balanced equation with the smallest whole-number coefficients.
To go from a diagram to an equation: identify each distinct kind of particle and write its formula; count how many of each there are; then reduce the numbers to the smallest whole-number ratio. In the diagram above there are 4 H2 and 2 O2 before and 4 H2O after: dividing by 2 gives 2 H2 + O2 → 2 H2O.
The number of particles drawn does not have to equal the coefficients; only the ratios need to match.
Worked example · equation from a diagram
A before-box shows 4 N2 molecules and 12 H2 molecules. The after-box shows 8 NH3 molecules and nothing else. Write the equation.
Check the atoms first. Before: 8 N and 24 H. After: 8 NH3 has 8 N and 24 H. The diagram is consistent. Ratio. 4 : 12 : 8 reduces to 1 : 3 : 2, so the equation is N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3. If the after-box had shown 8 NH3 from only 3 N2, the atom count (6 N against 8 N) would have exposed the error.
Limiting reactant in pictures
When the reactants are not present in the ratio of the coefficients, one is used up first and limits the amount of product. The reactant left over is in excess. A diagram makes this visible: after the reaction, one of the reactants is completely absent and some of the other is left.
Figure 4.4b A limiting-reactant particle diagram. Hydrogen runs out first, so it limits the product: 6 H₂ can make only 4 NH₃. Excess nitrogen remains.
Worked example · drawing the products
For N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3, draw the contents after reaction if the mixture starts with 3 N2 and 6 H2 (as shown above).
Step 1. Every N2 needs 3 H2. With 6 H2, only 2 N2 can react (using 6 H2). Step 2. Hydrogen is the limiting reactant. Step 3. Products: 2 N2 reacting give 4 NH3. Leftover: 1 N2. Check atoms: before, 6 N and 12 H; after, 4 N + 2 N = 6 N and 12 H. ✓
Diagrams of aqueous reactions
For reactions in water, draw the dissolved ionic compounds as separate ions and show the precipitate as a clump of touching ions or formula units. Spectator ions appear unchanged on both sides, and the number of each ion should match the formula.
A neutralization (H+ + OH− → H2O) shows hydrogen and hydroxide ions disappearing and water molecules appearing; the leftover cation and anion are spectators.
Worked example · precipitation diagram
Before mixing, one solution contains 4 Ag+ and 4 NO3− and another contains 6 Na+ and 6 Cl−. Describe the after-diagram when they are mixed.
4 Ag+ combine with 4 Cl− to form 4 AgCl(s) (shown as a solid at the bottom). The remaining particles in solution are 2 Cl− (leftover reactant, since chloride was in excess), 6 Na+ and 4 NO3−. Check charge in solution: +6 for Na+ and −2 −4 = −6 for Cl− and NO3−. ✓ Ag+ is the limiting reactant.
Exam focus
Count atoms of each element before and after. If they do not match, the diagram is wrong.
Interpret the ratio, not the absolute numbers, to get coefficients.
The limiting reactant is the one that is completely gone in the after-box.
Draw ions separately for dissolved ionic compounds; do not draw formula-unit pairs in solution.
Show intact molecules for covalent substances; a reaction rearranges atoms but cannot create or destroy them.
Practice
A before-box shows 4 H2 and 4 Cl2. Write the equation for forming HCl, and describe the after-box.
Show answer
H2 + Cl2 → 2 HCl. The reactants are in a 1 : 1 ratio, so all are used: the after-box has 8 HCl molecules and no H2 or Cl2.
For 2 CO + O2 → 2 CO2, the before-box has 6 CO and 2 O2. Describe the after-box and name the limiting reactant.
Show answer
2 O2 can react with 4 CO to give 4 CO2. O2 is limiting. After the reaction: 4 CO2 and 2 CO left over. Atoms: 6 C and 10 O before (6 + 4); 4 + 2 = 6 C and 8 + 2 = 10 O after. ✓
A diagram shows 3 H2O2 molecules before and 3 H2O and 2 O2 after. Is it consistent with 2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + O2?
Show answer
No. 3 H2O2 would give 3 H2O and 1.5 O2, not 2 O2. For 2 O2 formed and 4 H2O, the before-box needs 4 H2O2. Atoms must match: 3 H2O2 has 6 H and 6 O; the after-box (3 H2O + 2 O2) has 6 H and 7 O.
Describe a particle diagram for the neutralization of HCl(aq) by NaOH(aq).
Show answer
Before: H+ and Cl− ions from the acid, Na+ and OH− ions from the base. After: water molecules (from H+ + OH−) and Na+ and Cl− ions. Na+ and Cl− are spectators and are drawn unchanged.
A student draws the dissolving of CaCl2 with 1 Ca2+ and 1 Cl−. What is wrong?
Show answer
The ratio is wrong. CaCl2 gives two chloride ions for each calcium ion, so the picture should show 1 Ca2+ and 2 Cl− (and the charges then balance).
For 2 Mg + O2 → 2 MgO, how many MgO are formed from 5 Mg atoms and 2 O2 molecules, and what is left over?
Show answer
2 O2 contain 4 O atoms, enough for 4 MgO using 4 Mg. Oxygen is limiting. 4 MgO form and 1 Mg atom is left over.
A baker doubling a recipe multiplies every ingredient by the same factor. A chemist does exactly the same with a balanced equation, except that the ingredients are counted in moles.
Stoichiometry is the arithmetic of recipes at the particle scale: how much of one substance reacts with, or forms from, a given amount of another.
It is the most practical skill in the course, since it turns an equation into a prediction of how much you will make, how much you need, and which reactant will run out first.
Learning objective · 4.5.A
Explain changes in the amounts of reactants and products based on the balanced reaction equation for a chemical process.
Required content · EK 4.5.A.1 to 4.5.A.3
Because atoms must be conserved during a chemical process, it is possible to calculate product amounts by using known reactant amounts, or to calculate reactant amounts given known product amounts.
Coefficients of balanced chemical equations contain information regarding the proportionality of the amounts of substances involved in the reaction. These values can be used in chemical calculations involving the mole concept.
Stoichiometric calculations can be combined with the ideal gas law and calculations involving molarity to quantitatively study gases and solutions.
The mole ratio
The coefficients of a balanced equation give the ratio of moles (not grams) of the substances. For 2 H2 + O2 → 2 H2O, 2 mol of H2 reacts with 1 mol of O2 to form 2 mol of H2O, so each mole of O2 consumed corresponds to 2 mol of H2 consumed and 2 mol of water formed.
That ratio is the only bridge between different substances.
Figure 4.4a The stoichiometry roadmap. The coefficients of the balanced equation are the only link between different substances, so every problem must pass through moles.
Every calculation follows the same route: convert what you are given to moles (by molar mass, by \(n = PV/RT\) for gases, or by \(n = MV\) for solutions), multiply by the mole ratio from the equation, then convert moles of the wanted substance to whatever is asked.
Worked example · mass to mass
How many grams of CO2 form, and how many grams of O2 are needed, when 25.0 g of propane burns completely? C3H8 + 5 O2 → 3 CO2 + 4 H2O.
Moles of propane: 25.0 g ÷ 44.097 g/mol = 0.5669 mol.
Check. Mass is conserved: reactants 25.0 + 90.7 = 115.7 g; products 74.9 g CO2 + 40.9 g H2O = 115.8 g (the 0.1 g difference is rounding).
Limiting reactant and percent yield
Reactants are rarely mixed in exact ratio. The limiting reactant is the one that is used up first, and it determines how much product can form (the theoretical yield). Any other reactant is in excess.
To find the limiting reactant, convert both amounts to moles, then compare each with what the coefficients require. Do not compare grams to grams, the most frequent error on this topic.
Worked example · limiting reactant and percent yield
28.0 g of N2 reacts with 8.00 g of H2: N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3. (a) Find the limiting reactant. (b) Find the theoretical yield of NH3. (c) If 28.5 g of NH3 is collected, find the percent yield.
(a) Moles: N2 = 28.0 ÷ 28.014 = 0.9995 mol; H2 = 8.00 ÷ 2.016 = 3.968 mol. H2 needed for all the N2 = 3 × 0.9995 = 2.999 mol, which is less than the 3.968 mol available. So N2 is limiting, and H2 is in excess (3.968 − 2.999 = 0.970 mol, or 1.96 g, left over).
Stoichiometry combines with the earlier relationships. For a gas, use the ideal gas law to link volume to moles: \(n = PV/RT\) (or the molar volume at the stated conditions). For a solution, \(n = MV\) gives moles from molarity and volume in liters.
Worked example · volume of gas
What volume of O2 at 25 °C and 1.00 atm is produced by heating 5.00 g of KClO3? 2 KClO3 → 2 KCl + 3 O2.
How much PbI2 precipitates when 50.0 mL of 0.200 M Pb(NO3)2 is mixed with excess KI? Pb(NO3)2 + 2 KI → PbI2 + 2 KNO3.
\(n(\text{Pb}^{2+}) = MV = (0.200)(0.0500) = 0.0100\) mol. The ratio is 1 : 1, so 0.0100 mol PbI2 forms: \(0.0100 \times 461.0 = 4.61\) g.
Worked example · qualitative reasoning
For 2 Mg + O2 → 2 MgO, a student doubles the mass of Mg used with the same excess of O2. What happens to the mass of MgO formed?
Moles of Mg double, and since the ratio is 1 : 1 the moles of MgO double. The mass of MgO doubles (the molar mass is constant). The coefficient 2 does not matter when both amounts are expressed in moles of the same ratio.
Exam focus
Always convert to moles first. Coefficients relate moles, not grams or liters of solution.
To find the limiting reactant, compare mole ratios, not masses.
Percent yield = actual ÷ theoretical. It cannot exceed 100% in a well-run experiment; a value above 100% suggests impurities or wet product.
Gases: if conditions are stated, use \(PV = nRT\). If the gases are at the same T and P, volumes are proportional to moles.
Carry units and significant figures through the setup; the setup earns the point even if the arithmetic slips.
Practice
2 Al + 3 Cl2 → 2 AlCl3. How many moles of AlCl3 form from 0.600 mol Al with excess Cl2?
Show answer
The ratio is 2 : 2, so 0.600 mol AlCl3 forms.
Zn + 2 HCl → ZnCl2 + H2. What volume of H2 at 1.00 atm and 298 K forms from 2.00 g of Zn?
Show answer
\(n(\text{Zn}) = 2.00/65.38 = 0.03059\) mol, so 0.03059 mol H2. \(V = (0.03059)(0.08206)(298)/1.00 = 0.748\) L.
For 4 NH3 + 5 O2 → 4 NO + 6 H2O, 2.0 mol NH3 and 2.0 mol O2 are mixed. Which is limiting, and how many moles of NO form?
Show answer
NH3 needed for 2.0 mol O2 = 2.0 × 4/5 = 1.6 mol, less than the 2.0 mol available, so O2 is limiting. NO formed = 2.0 × 4/5 = 1.6 mol.
A reaction has a theoretical yield of 12.5 g and an actual yield of 9.80 g. What is the percent yield?
Show answer
\(9.80 / 12.5 \times 100 = 78.4\%\).
What volume of 0.150 M HCl is needed to react completely with 2.50 g of CaCO3? CaCO3 + 2 HCl → CaCl2 + H2O + CO2.
Show answer
A student calculates the limiting reactant by comparing 10.0 g of A with 10.0 g of B and picks the one with the smaller mass. Why is this unreliable?
Show answer
Equal masses are not equal numbers of particles, and the coefficients also matter. The limiting reactant must be found by converting each mass to moles and comparing with the mole ratio in the balanced equation.
How much acid is in a glass of orange juice, how much vitamin C in a tablet, how much chlorine in a swimming pool? You cannot see inside the solution to count particles, but you can add a second solution of known concentration, a drop at a time, until the reaction is exactly complete.
That is a titration. It is stoichiometry made into a laboratory measurement, and the one calculation that goes with it is short: moles of titrant at the equivalence point tell you moles of analyte.
Learning objective · 4.6.A
Identify the equivalence point in a titration based on the amounts of the titrant and analyte, assuming the titration reaction goes to completion.
Required content · EK 4.6.A.1
Titrations may be used to determine the amount of an analyte in solution. The titrant has a known concentration of a species that reacts specifically and quantitatively with the analyte. The equivalence point of the titration occurs when the analyte is totally consumed by the reacting species in the titrant. The equivalence point is often indicated by a change in a property (such as color) that occurs when the equivalence point is reached. This observable event is called the endpoint of the titration.
The vocabulary
Analyte: the solution whose concentration is unknown, measured into a flask with a pipet.
Titrant: the solution of known concentration, delivered from a buret.
Equivalence point: the moment when the titrant has added exactly the amount that the balanced equation says reacts with all the analyte. It is a theoretical point.
Endpoint: the point at which an observable change occurs, such as an indicator changing color. A good experiment chooses an indicator so that the endpoint is as close as possible to the equivalence point.
Figure 4.5a Titration setup. The titrant is added slowly from the buret until the indicator changes color at the endpoint, which approximates the equivalence point.
Doing the calculation
At the equivalence point the moles of titrant added are in the ratio of the coefficients to the moles of analyte originally present. For a 1 : 1 reaction, such as HCl + NaOH,
\[ M_{\text{acid}}V_{\text{acid}} = M_{\text{base}}V_{\text{base}} \]
For any other ratio use the balanced equation to convert: moles of titrant = \(M_{\text{titrant}} \times V_{\text{titrant}}\) at the endpoint, then multiply by the mole ratio to get moles of analyte, then divide by the volume of analyte to get its molarity.
Volumes must be in the same units, and the titrant volume is the difference between the final and initial buret readings.
Worked example · a 1 : 1 titration
A 25.00 mL sample of HCl needs 31.82 mL of 0.1050 M NaOH to reach the endpoint. What is the molarity of the HCl?
20.00 mL of H2SO4 is neutralized by 28.40 mL of 0.1500 M NaOH. H2SO4 + 2 NaOH → Na2SO4 + 2 H2O. Find the molarity of the acid.
Moles NaOH = (0.1500)(0.02840) = 0.004260 mol. Moles H2SO4 = 0.004260 / 2 = 0.002130 mol. \(M = 0.002130 / 0.02000 = 0.1065\) M. (Forgetting the factor of 2 would give 0.2130 M, twice the true value.)
Worked example · a weak acid in vinegar
A 10.00 mL sample of vinegar (acetic acid, CH3COOH) needs 16.40 mL of 0.500 M NaOH. What is the concentration of acetic acid?
CH3COOH + NaOH → CH3COONa + H2O is 1 : 1. Moles = (0.500)(0.01640) = 0.00820 mol, so \(M = 0.00820 / 0.01000 = 0.820\) M. The reaction goes essentially to completion even though acetic acid is a weak acid, because the strong base removes its protons.
The titration curve
A graph of pH against volume of titrant added shows what happens at each stage. For a strong acid titrated with a strong base:
Figure 4.5b Strong acid titrated with strong base. The pH changes slowly at first, then rises almost vertically through the equivalence point (25.0 mL, pH 7.00) and levels off as excess OH− accumulates.
Stage
Particles in the flask
pH
Before any base (0 mL)
H+, Cl−
low (1.00 for 0.100 M)
Before the equivalence point
H+ (not yet neutralized), Cl−, Na+
rising slowly; still acidic
Equivalence point (25.0 mL)
Na+, Cl− and water only
7.00 for strong acid and strong base
After the equivalence point
Na+, Cl− and excess OH−
high; approaches that of the titrant
The curve is nearly vertical at the equivalence point: one drop of base changes the pH by several units, which is exactly why an indicator such as phenolphthalein (colorless below pH 8, pink above pH 10) changes color within one drop of the true equivalence point.
A titration involving a weak acid or base has a different shape and a different pH at equivalence; you will analyze those in Unit 8.
Worked example · reading the curve
The curve above was made by titrating 25.0 mL of an HCl solution with 0.100 M NaOH. Estimate the original concentration of the HCl.
The steep rise (equivalence point) is at 25.0 mL, so moles NaOH = (0.100)(0.0250) = 0.00250 mol = moles HCl. \(M = 0.00250 / 0.0250 = 0.100\) M. The initial pH of 1.00 agrees: \(-\log(0.100) = 1.00\).
Exam focus
Equivalence is about moles, not volumes. Equal volumes do not mean equivalence unless the reaction is 1 : 1 and the concentrations are the same.
Use the balanced equation for the mole ratio (H2SO4 needs 2 NaOH).
Equivalence point is theoretical; the endpoint is what you see. They should be close.
Read the equivalence point on a curve as the middle of the steep vertical section.
Record buret readings as differences and use the same units on both solutions.
Practice
What volume of 0.200 M NaOH is needed to neutralize 15.0 mL of 0.300 M HCl?
Show answer
How many mL of 0.150 M NaOH are required to reach the equivalence point with 20.0 mL of 0.100 M H3PO4 if all three protons are neutralized?
Show answer
Moles H3PO4 = (0.100)(0.0200) = 0.00200 mol, and each needs 3 NaOH: 0.00600 mol NaOH. \(V = 0.00600 / 0.150 = 0.0400\) L = 40.0 mL.
Explain the difference between the equivalence point and the endpoint, and describe how an inappropriate indicator would affect the result.
Show answer
The equivalence point is where the moles of titrant exactly equal the moles needed to react with the analyte; the endpoint is where the indicator visibly changes. An indicator that changes color too early or too late gives an endpoint away from the equivalence point, so the volume of titrant is too small or too large and the calculated concentration is wrong.
A student reads the initial buret level as 0.50 mL and the final level as 24.30 mL, then uses 24.30 mL in the calculation. What error was made and how does it affect the calculated concentration of the analyte?
Show answer
The volume delivered is 24.30 − 0.50 = 23.80 mL. Using 24.30 mL overstates the moles of titrant, so the calculated analyte concentration is too high.
What species are present in the flask at the equivalence point of a HNO3 + KOH titration, and what is the pH?
Show answer
K+, NO3− and water. Neither ion reacts with water to a measurable degree, so the pH is 7.00 (at 25 °C).
There are millions of chemical reactions but only a few things that can happen at the particle level: ions can pair up and fall out of solution, a proton can move from one species to another, or electrons can move from one species to another.
Learning to see which is occurring lets you predict products you have never seen before and decide, from a single equation, what kind of experiment it describes.
This lesson gives you a quick test for each type and the tool, oxidation numbers, that makes the third one visible.
Learning objective · 4.7.A
Identify a reaction as acid-base, oxidation-reduction or precipitation.
Required content · EK 4.7.A.1 to 4.7.A.5
Acid-base reactions involve transfer of one or more protons (H+ ions) between chemical species.
Oxidation-reduction (redox) reactions involve transfer of one or more electrons between chemical species, as indicated by changes in oxidation numbers of the involved species. Combustion is an important subclass of redox reactions in which a species reacts with oxygen gas. In the case of hydrocarbons, carbon dioxide and water are products of complete combustion.
In a redox reaction, electrons are transferred from the species that is oxidized to the species that is reduced.
Oxidation numbers may be assigned to each of the atoms in the reactants and products; this is often an effective way to identify the oxidized and reduced species in a redox reaction.
Precipitation reactions frequently involve mixing ions in aqueous solution to produce an insoluble or sparingly soluble ionic compound. All sodium, potassium, ammonium and nitrate salts are soluble in water.
Exclusions: the terms “reducing agent” and “oxidizing agent,” and rote memorization of solubility rules beyond those implied, are not assessed.
Figure 4.6a The three main reaction types on the AP exam. Identify the type by asking what moves: nothing (ions combine), a proton, or electrons.
Precipitation
When solutions of two ionic compounds are mixed, the ions can swap partners. If one possible new combination is insoluble, it forms as a solid precipitate.
The test is: are there two ions that, when combined, give an ionic compound that does not dissolve in water? Since all sodium, potassium, ammonium and nitrate salts are soluble, a combination that includes one of those ions as the only cation or anion will not precipitate.
For the others you use the information in the problem, a given observation, or a short list of solubility facts provided. Common insoluble combinations include most carbonates, phosphates and sulfides (except of group 1 and ammonium), the chlorides of silver and lead(II), and most hydroxides (except group 1).
Worked example · does a precipitate form?
When aqueous Na2CO3 and aqueous CaCl2 are mixed, the possible new compounds are NaCl and CaCO3. Which forms a precipitate?
All sodium salts are soluble, so NaCl stays dissolved. CaCO3 (a carbonate of a group 2 metal) is insoluble. Net ionic: Ca2+(aq) + CO32−(aq) → CaCO3(s). Na+ and Cl− are spectators.
Acid-base
An acid-base reaction is the transfer of a proton (H+) from one species to another. HCl(aq) + NaOH(aq), with net equation H+ + OH− → H2O, is the classic example, but so is NH3 + H2O → NH4+ + OH−.
The next lesson develops this in detail. Clues: an acid (a species with a transferable H) and a base (a species with a lone pair to accept it), water or a salt as a product, and no change in oxidation numbers.
Oxidation-reduction
In a redox reaction electrons move from one species to another. The species that loses electrons is oxidized; the species that gains electrons is reduced. The two always happen together. You can recognize redox by a change in oxidation numbers, bookkeeping charges assigned by these rules, in order:
The oxidation number of an atom in an element is 0 (Na, O2, S8).
A monatomic ion has an oxidation number equal to its charge (Fe3+ is +3).
In compounds: group 1 is +1, group 2 is +2, fluorine is −1; hydrogen is +1 (−1 in metal hydrides); oxygen is −2 (−1 in peroxides).
The sum of oxidation numbers equals the overall charge: 0 for a neutral compound, the ion’s charge for a polyatomic ion.
Worked example · assigning oxidation numbers
Find the oxidation number of the underlined atom: Mn in MnO4−, S in SO42−, C in CH4, Cr in Cr2O72−.
MnO4−: Mn + 4(−2) = −1, so Mn = +7. SO42−: S + 4(−2) = −2, so S = +6. CH4: C + 4(+1) = 0, so C = −4. Cr2O72−: 2 Cr + 7(−2) = −2, so each Cr = +6.
In a redox reaction, an atom whose oxidation number increases has been oxidized (lost electrons); an atom whose oxidation number decreases has been reduced (gained electrons).
Combustion is a common type: a substance reacts with O2. The complete combustion of a hydrocarbon forms CO2 and H2O: carbon goes from −4 (in CH4) to +4 (in CO2) and is oxidized; oxygen goes from 0 to −2 and is reduced.
(a) Precipitation: a solid forms from ions; no oxidation numbers change. (b) Acid-base: H+ moves from acetic acid to ammonia. (c) Redox (and combustion): Mg goes 0 to +2 (oxidized), O goes 0 to −2 (reduced). (d) Redox: Fe goes 0 to +2 (oxidized), Cu2+ goes +2 to 0 (reduced).
Exam focus
Ask what moves. Nothing: precipitation (ions combine). A proton: acid-base. Electrons: redox.
Justify with evidence from the equation: the new solid, the proton transfer, or the changing oxidation numbers.
An element on one side only as a free element usually signals redox (a metal displacing ions, combustion with O2).
Oxidation number changes show oxidation and reduction; an increase means oxidation.
Memorize only the stated solubility fact (sodium, potassium, ammonium and nitrate salts are soluble).
Practice
Find the oxidation number of nitrogen in NH3, NO2 and NO3−.
Show answer
NH3: N + 3(+1) = 0, so N = −3. NO2: N + 2(−2) = 0, so N = +4. NO3−: N + 3(−2) = −1, so N = +5.
In 2 Na + Cl2 → 2 NaCl, which atoms are oxidized and reduced, and how many electrons are transferred per formula unit?
Show answer
Sodium goes from 0 to +1 (oxidized); chlorine goes from 0 to −1 (reduced). One electron is transferred per NaCl formula unit, from Na to Cl.
Classify as precipitation, acid-base or redox: (a) Zn + 2 HCl → ZnCl2 + H2; (b) HNO3 + KOH → KNO3 + H2O.
Show answer
(a) Redox: Zn goes from 0 to +2 and H goes from +1 to 0. (b) Acid-base: HNO3 donates H+ to OH−; no oxidation number changes.
Write the balanced equation for the complete combustion of ethane, C2H6, and state which element is oxidized.
Show answer
2 C2H6 + 7 O2 → 4 CO2 + 6 H2O. Carbon is oxidized (from −3 in ethane to +4 in CO2); oxygen is reduced (0 to −2). Hydrogen stays +1.
Will a precipitate form when aqueous KNO3 and aqueous NaCl are mixed? Explain.
Show answer
No. The possible products, NaNO3 and KCl, are both soluble because all sodium, potassium and nitrate salts are soluble. All the ions remain dissolved, so there is no net reaction.
A student says that a reaction in which the oxidation number of every atom stays the same cannot be redox. Is this correct?
Show answer
Yes. Redox requires electron transfer, which always shows up as a change in the oxidation number of at least one species (one atom increases and another decreases). Precipitation and acid-base reactions leave oxidation numbers unchanged.
Lemon juice is sour, soap feels slippery, and baking soda fizzes in vinegar. Chemists have used acids and bases for centuries, but the modern definition is simple and powerful: an acid-base reaction is a transfer of a proton.
That one idea explains why water can act as either an acid or a base, why every acid has a partner base, and it prepares the ground for the whole of Unit 8. Here you learn the definitions, how to find the conjugate pairs, and how to write the proton transfer as an equation.
Learning objective · 4.8.A
Identify species as Brønsted-Lowry acids, bases and/or conjugate acid-base pairs, based on proton transfer involving those species.
Required content · EK 4.8.A.1 to 4.8.A.3
By definition, a Brønsted-Lowry acid is a proton donor and a Brønsted-Lowry base is a proton acceptor.
Only in aqueous solutions, water plays an important role in many acid-base reactions, as its molecular structure allows it to accept protons from and donate protons to dissolved species.
When an acid or base ionizes in water, the conjugate acid-base pairs can be identified and their relative strengths compared.
Exclusion: Lewis acid-base concepts are not assessed. The emphasis is on reactions in aqueous solution.
Brønsted-Lowry acids and bases
A Brønsted-Lowry acid is a proton donor. A Brønsted-Lowry base is a proton acceptor. A “proton” here means H+, a hydrogen atom that has lost its electron.
To be an acid, a species must have an H that can leave (usually bonded to a very electronegative atom, such as O in acetic acid or Cl in HCl). To be a base, a species must have a lone pair that can form a bond to the incoming H+ (the O in OH−, the N in NH3).
Figure 4.7a A Brønsted-Lowry acid-base reaction. HCl donates H+ and is the acid; water accepts it and is the base. Each reactant forms its conjugate partner by losing or gaining one H+.
In HCl(aq) + H2O(l) → Cl−(aq) + H3O+(aq), HCl donates a proton and is the acid; water accepts it and is the base. The hydronium ion, H3O+, is a water molecule carrying an extra proton; it is how H+(aq) really exists in water.
Chemists often write H+(aq) as shorthand for H3O+(aq).
Conjugate acid-base pairs
Every proton transfer is reversible in principle, so every acid has a partner. When an acid loses a proton, what remains is its conjugate base; when a base gains a proton, the result is its conjugate acid. The two members of a pair differ by exactly one H+.
Acid
Conjugate base
HCl
→ H+ +
Cl−
H2O
→ H+ +
OH−
H3O+
→ H+ +
H2O
NH4+
→ H+ +
NH3
CH3COOH
→ H+ +
CH3COO−
H2CO3
→ H+ +
HCO3−
HCO3−
→ H+ +
CO32−
Note that H2O and HCO3− appear on both sides: they can lose an H+ (as acids) or gain one (as bases). A species that can do either is amphoteric. Water is the most important example: it accepts protons from dissolved acids and donates them to dissolved bases.
The relation is a strict one: a conjugate pair differs by one proton, not more, so HCl and Cl− are a pair but HCl and ClO− are not.
Strength and the direction of the reaction
When an acid ionizes in water, the extent depends on how readily the acid gives up its proton. A strong acid (HCl, HBr, HI, HNO3, HClO4, and the first proton of H2SO4) transfers essentially all its protons to water; its conjugate base (Cl−, NO3−) is so weak it does not accept protons back.
A weak acid (acetic acid, HF, H2CO3) transfers only a small fraction, and the reaction goes both ways:
CH3COOH(aq) + H2O(l) ⇌ CH3COO−(aq) + H3O+(aq). The double arrow means the reaction does not go to completion.
Strong bases (NaOH, KOH, Ba(OH)2) dissociate completely to give OH−; weak bases (NH3) accept protons from water only slightly: NH3 + H2O ⇌ NH4+ + OH−.
The stronger the acid, the weaker its conjugate base, and vice versa. A proton transfer favors the side with the weaker acid and weaker base: the reaction proceeds toward the weaker acid, because a strong acid holds its proton less tightly than a weak one.
Detailed quantitative treatment, with \(K_a\) and \(K_b\), is the subject of Unit 8.
Worked example · label an equation
In NH3(aq) + H2O(l) ⇌ NH4+(aq) + OH−(aq), identify the acid, base, conjugate acid and conjugate base.
NH3 gains a proton to become NH4+, so NH3 is the base and NH4+ is its conjugate acid. Water loses a proton to become OH−, so H2O is the acid and OH− is its conjugate base. Water acts as an acid here, and in the HCl example it acted as a base.
Worked example · proton transfer between two dissolved species
Write the reaction of hydrofluoric acid with the carbonate ion and identify both conjugate pairs.
HF(aq) + CO32−(aq) → F−(aq) + HCO3−(aq). HF donates a proton, so HF is the acid and F− its conjugate base. CO32− accepts it, so it is the base and HCO3− is its conjugate acid. The pairs are HF / F− and HCO3− / CO32−.
Worked example · amphoteric behavior
Write one equation in which HCO3− acts as an acid and one in which it acts as a base, each with water.
As an acid: HCO3− + H2O ⇌ CO32− + H3O+. As a base: HCO3− + H2O ⇌ H2CO3 + OH−.
Exam focus
Acid = proton donor; base = proton acceptor. Always state the direction of the proton.
A conjugate pair differs by exactly one H+. Check the charges: the conjugate base has one more negative charge.
Water can be either, so identify its role in each equation from what happens to it.
Strong acids ionize completely (single arrow); weak acids use the double arrow.
Stronger acid, weaker conjugate base.
Practice
Write the formula of the conjugate base of H2PO4− and the conjugate acid of H2PO4−.
Show answer
Conjugate base (remove H+): HPO42−. Conjugate acid (add H+): H3PO4. H2PO4− is amphoteric.
Identify the acid, base, conjugate acid and conjugate base in HNO2 + H2O ⇌ NO2− + H3O+.
Show answer
Is NH3 a Brønsted-Lowry acid, base, or both? Explain.
Show answer
Mainly a base: it has a lone pair on N and accepts a proton to form NH4+. It can act as an extremely weak acid by losing an H+ to form NH2−, but this does not happen in water.
Explain why Cl− is not a base in water to any significant extent.
Show answer
Cl− is the conjugate base of HCl, a strong acid. Because HCl gives up its proton essentially completely, Cl− has almost no tendency to take a proton back.
Write the equation for the reaction of HCO3− with H3O+ and name the role of HCO3−.
Show answer
HCO3− + H3O+ → H2CO3 + H2O. HCO3− accepts a proton, so it acts as a base.
For the reaction HCN + F− ⇌ CN− + HF, HF is a stronger acid than HCN. Predict whether the reaction favors reactants or products.
Show answer
It favors the reactants. The reaction goes toward the weaker acid and weaker base. HCN (weaker acid) and F− (the conjugate base of a stronger acid, so a weaker base than CN−) are the weaker pair, so they are favored.
Batteries, rusting, respiration, photosynthesis, bleach and the burning of fuel are all redox reactions. Some of the equations are hard to balance by inspection, because electrons and charges as well as atoms must be accounted for.
The method of half-reactions makes this manageable: split the reaction into the electron-losing part and the electron-gaining part, balance each separately, and join them. It is also the foundation for the electrochemistry of Unit 9.
Learning objective · 4.9.A
Represent a balanced redox reaction equation using half-reactions.
Required content · EK 4.9.A.1
Balanced chemical equations for redox reactions can be constructed from half-reactions.
Oxidation and reduction as half-reactions
Every redox reaction is a pair of processes that cannot occur separately: oxidation, the loss of electrons, and reduction, the gain of electrons. The mnemonic is OIL RIG: Oxidation Is Loss, Reduction Is Gain.
Writing each process as its own half-reaction with the electrons shown explicitly displays the transfer clearly.
Figure 4.8a Electron transfer in a redox reaction. Zinc is oxidized (loses electrons; oxidation number increases from 0 to +2) and copper(II) is reduced (gains electrons; +2 to 0). Oxidation and reduction always occur together.
Half-reaction
Type
Electrons
Oxidation number
Zn(s) → Zn2+(aq) + 2 e−
oxidation
on the product side
increases (0 to +2)
Cu2+(aq) + 2 e− → Cu(s)
reduction
on the reactant side
decreases (+2 to 0)
The electrons lost in one half-reaction must equal the electrons gained in the other. Adding the half-reactions (and canceling the electrons) gives the overall equation: Zn(s) + Cu2+(aq) → Zn2+(aq) + Cu(s).
Worked example · unequal electron counts
Balance Al(s) + Ag+(aq) → Al3+(aq) + Ag(s).
Oxidation: Al → Al3+ + 3 e−. Reduction: Ag+ + e− → Ag. The electrons must match, so multiply the reduction by 3: 3 Ag+ + 3 e− → 3 Ag. Add and cancel the electrons:
Al + 3 Ag+ → Al3+ + 3 Ag. Charge: +3 on each side. ✓
Balancing in acidic solution
When oxygen-containing ions such as MnO4− or Cr2O72− are involved, water and H+ take part, and you must balance O and H as well. The routine for each half-reaction in acidic solution:
Balance all atoms other than O and H.
Balance O by adding H2O to the side that needs it.
Balance H by adding H+ to the side that needs it.
Balance charge by adding electrons (e−) to the more positive side.
Multiply the half-reactions so the electrons are equal, add them, and cancel anything that appears on both sides (electrons, H+, H2O).
Check atoms and charge.
Worked example · permanganate and iron(II)
Balance MnO4−(aq) + Fe2+(aq) → Mn2+(aq) + Fe3+(aq) in acid.
Reduction half. MnO4− → Mn2+. Balance O: add 4 H2O on the right. Balance H: add 8 H+ on the left. Charge: left = −1 + 8 = +7; right = +2; add 5 e− to the left: MnO4− + 8 H+ + 5 e− → Mn2+ + 4 H2O.
Oxidation half. Fe2+ → Fe3+ + e−.
Combine. Multiply the oxidation by 5 to match 5 e−: 5 Fe2+ → 5 Fe3+ + 5 e−. Add:
MnO4− + 8 H+ + 5 Fe2+ → Mn2+ + 4 H2O + 5 Fe3+.
Check. Atoms: 1 Mn, 4 O, 8 H and 5 Fe on each side. Charge: left −1 + 8 + 10 = +17; right +2 + 15 = +17. ✓
Worked example · dichromate
The reduction half of dichromate is Cr2O72− + 14 H+ + 6 e− → 2 Cr3+ + 7 H2O (charge: −2 + 14 − 6 = +6 on the left, +6 on the right ✓). Combined with 6 Fe2+ → 6 Fe3+ + 6 e−, the overall equation is
Cr2O72− + 14 H+ + 6 Fe2+ → 2 Cr3+ + 7 H2O + 6 Fe3+ (charge +24 on each side).
For a reaction in basic solution, balance as if it were acidic, then add to both sides as many OH− as there are H+; the H+ and OH− on one side combine into H2O, and you cancel any extra H2O.
Putting it to work: a redox titration
The equation above is the basis of a common titration: permanganate is deep purple and Mn2+ is nearly colorless, so the first persistent pink color shows the equivalence point without any indicator.
Worked example · redox stoichiometry
A 25.00 mL sample of Fe2+ solution requires 21.40 mL of 0.0200 M KMnO4. Find the concentration of Fe2+.
Moles MnO4− = (0.0200)(0.02140) = 4.28 × 10−4 mol. The equation gives 5 Fe2+ per MnO4−, so moles Fe2+ = 5 × 4.28 × 10−4 = 2.14 × 10−3 mol. \(M = 2.14 \times 10^{-3} / 0.02500 = 0.0856\) M.
Exam focus
Balance atoms and charge. A redox equation balanced in atoms but not in charge is wrong.
Electrons appear on the product side of oxidation and the reactant side of reduction.
Equalize the electrons before adding the half-reactions; the final equation has no free electrons.
In acid, add H2O for oxygen and H+ for hydrogen, then electrons for charge.
Use the balanced equation’s ratio in redox titration calculations (5 Fe2+ per MnO4−).
Practice
Write the oxidation and reduction half-reactions for Mg(s) + 2 Ag+(aq) → Mg2+(aq) + 2 Ag(s).
Show answer
Oxidation: Mg → Mg2+ + 2 e−. Reduction: 2 Ag+ + 2 e− → 2 Ag. The 2 electrons lost equal the 2 gained.
Balance: Cu(s) + Ag+(aq) → Cu2+(aq) + Ag(s).
Show answer
Cu → Cu2+ + 2 e−; 2 Ag+ + 2 e− → 2 Ag. Overall: Cu + 2 Ag+ → Cu2+ + 2 Ag. Charge: +2 on each side.
Balance the half-reaction NO3− → NO in acidic solution.
Show answer
NO3− → NO + 2 H2O (balance O); add 4 H+ on the left (balance H); charge: left −1 + 4 = +3, right 0, so add 3 e− to the left: NO3− + 4 H+ + 3 e− → NO + 2 H2O.
In the reaction Cl2 + 2 Br− → 2 Cl− + Br2, which species is oxidized and which is reduced?
Show answer
Bromide is oxidized (−1 to 0, loses electrons); chlorine is reduced (0 to −1, gains electrons).
A 20.00 mL sample of Fe2+ is titrated with 0.0200 M K2Cr2O7, using Cr2O72− + 14 H+ + 6 Fe2+ → 2 Cr3+ + 7 H2O + 6 Fe3+. If 15.00 mL of dichromate is needed, find [Fe2+].
Show answer
A student writes MnO4− + 5 e− → Mn2+ as the reduction half-reaction. What is missing?
Show answer
Oxygen and hydrogen are not balanced, and the charge does not balance (−6 on the left, +2 on the right). The correct half-reaction adds 8 H+ on the left and 4 H2O on the right: MnO4− + 8 H+ + 5 e− → Mn2+ + 4 H2O.
Unit 4 practice · 10 problems
Unit 4 practice: Chemical Reactions
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed for the stoichiometry.
Balance the combustion of butane: C4H10 + O2 → CO2 + H2O. Classify the reaction in two ways.
Show answer
Balance C (4 CO2), then H (5 H2O), then O: the right side has 8 + 5 = 13 O, so 6½ O2; double everything: 2 C4H10 + 13 O2 → 8 CO2 + 10 H2O. Check: 8 C, 20 H, 26 O each side. It is a combustion reaction and also redox: O goes 0 → −2 and C is oxidized.
Aqueous iron(III) nitrate is mixed with aqueous sodium hydroxide and a rust-colored solid forms. Write the molecular, complete ionic, and net ionic equations, and name the spectator ions.
A particle diagram shows a box containing 4 CO molecules and 3 O2 molecules. Describe the box after 2 CO + O2 → 2 CO2 runs to completion, and identify the limiting reactant.
Show answer
4 CO need only 2 O2, so CO is limiting. After: 4 CO2 and 1 O2, no CO. Atom check: C 4 → 4; O \(4 + 6 = 10\) → \(8 + 2 = 10\). The leftover O2 must appear in the "after" box.
Which reaction is not an oxidation–reduction reaction?
Free elements appear on the left, so oxidation numbers must change: Na goes from 0 to +1 and Cl from 0 to −1. Any reaction that consumes or produces a free element is redox.
Combustion is always redox: C goes from −4 in CH4 to +4 in CO2, and O goes from 0 in O2 to −2. It involves no metals, which is why students sometimes miss the electron transfer.
This is a precipitation reaction: ions swap partners and every oxidation number is unchanged (Ag +1, Br −1, K +1, N +5, O −2 before and after). No electrons are transferred.
This is a single-replacement redox reaction: Zn goes from 0 to +2 (oxidized) and Cu from +2 to 0 (reduced). A free metal on each side is the giveaway.
N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3. 28.0 g of N2 reacts with 8.00 g of H2. Find the limiting reactant, the theoretical yield of NH3, the mass of excess reactant left over, and the percent yield if 28.5 g of NH3 is collected.
C2H5OH + 3 O2 → 2 CO2 + 3 H2O. What mass of oxygen is required to burn 10.0 g of ethanol completely, and what mass of CO2 forms?
Show answer
\(10.0 / 46.07 = 0.217\) mol ethanol. O2: \(0.217 \times 3 = 0.651\) mol \(\times 32.00 = 20.8\) g. CO2: \(0.217 \times 2 = 0.434\) mol \(\times 44.01 = 19.1\) g. Both chains: g → mol → mole ratio → g.
20.00 mL of barium hydroxide solution requires 27.30 mL of 0.1000 M HCl to reach the endpoint. Write the balanced equation and find [Ba(OH)2].
Show answer
Ba(OH)2 + 2 HCl → BaCl2 + 2 H2O. Moles HCl: \(0.02730 \times 0.1000 = 2.730 \times 10^{-3}\) mol. Each Ba(OH)2 neutralizes two H+, so moles base \(= 1.365 \times 10^{-3}\). \([\mathrm{Ba(OH)_2}] = \dfrac{1.365 \times 10^{-3}}{0.02000} = 0.06825\) M: four sig figs, and don't skip the factor of 2.
In a titration of an acid with standardized NaOH, describe the effect on the calculated acid concentration (too high, too low, or unchanged) if (a) the flask of acid is diluted with extra distilled water before titrating; (b) an air bubble in the buret tip escapes during the titration; (c) the buret is rinsed with water instead of NaOH before filling.
Show answer
(a) Unchanged: dilution adds no moles of acid, and the calculation uses moles of base and the original acid volume. (b) Too high: the bubble's volume is read as delivered titrant, so the student overstates the moles of NaOH and therefore the moles (and concentration) of acid. (c) Too high: the diluted NaOH is weaker than its label, more volume is needed, and the student again computes too many moles of base.
(a) In HCO3− + H2O ⇌ H2CO3 + OH−, identify the Brønsted–Lowry acid, base, and the two conjugate pairs. (b) Assign the oxidation number of P in H3PO4, Mn in MnO2, N in NO3−, and S in S2O32−.
Show answer
(a) H2O donates a proton: acid, conjugate base OH−. HCO3− accepts it: base, conjugate acid H2CO3. Pairs: H2O/OH− and H2CO3/HCO3−. (b) H3PO4: \(3(+1) + \mathrm{P} + 4(-2) = 0\) → P = +5. MnO2: Mn = +4. NO3−: \(\mathrm{N} - 6 = -1\) → N = +5. S2O32−: \(2\mathrm{S} - 6 = -2\) → each S = +2.
Magnesium metal placed in a solution of Fe3+ produces iron metal. Identify what is oxidized and reduced, name the oxidizing and reducing agents, and write the balanced net ionic equation.
Show answer
Mg goes 0 → +2: oxidized, so Mg is the reducing agent. Fe goes +3 → 0: reduced, so Fe3+ is the oxidizing agent. Half-reactions: Mg → Mg2+ + 2 e− (×3) and Fe3+ + 3 e− → Fe (×2), six electrons each: 3 Mg(s) + 2 Fe3+(aq) → 3 Mg2+(aq) + 2 Fe(s). Charge check: +6 on each side.
A firework burns in a flash; iron rusts over years; the same reaction can be fast in a hot oven and slow in a refrigerator.
So far in this course a reaction was something that happens and gives a certain amount of product. Kinetics asks a different question: how fast?
This matters to everyone from the pharmacist deciding how often a drug must be taken to the engineer designing a catalytic converter. In this first lesson you learn to define a rate, relate the rates of different substances to one another through the coefficients, and explain what makes reactions go faster or slower.
Learning objective · 5.1.A
Explain the relationship between the rate of a chemical reaction and experimental parameters.
Required content · EK 5.1.A.1 to 5.1.A.3
The kinetics of a chemical reaction is defined as the rate at which an amount of reactants is converted to products per unit of time.
The rates of change of reactant and product concentrations are determined by the stoichiometry in the balanced chemical equation.
The rate of a reaction is influenced by reactant concentrations, temperature, surface area, catalysts and other environmental factors.
Defining the rate
The rate of reaction is how quickly the concentration of a reactant falls or a product rises. For a reactant A, the average rate over a time interval is
\[ \text{rate} = -\dfrac{\Delta[\text{A}]}{\Delta t} \]
where the square brackets mean molar concentration. The minus sign is there because [A] decreases, and a rate is always reported as a positive quantity. For a product the sign is positive: \(\text{rate} = +\Delta[\text{P}]/\Delta t\).
Units are M/s (or M/min, mol L−1 s−1).
A graph of concentration against time shows that the rate changes as the reaction proceeds. Early on the curve is steep (high concentrations, fast reaction) and it flattens as reactants are used up.
The average rate is the slope of the straight line between two points on the curve; the instantaneous rate at one moment is the slope of the tangent line at that point. The initial rate, the instantaneous rate at \(t = 0\), is the one used to compare experiments.
Figure 5.1a All the rates are tied together by the coefficients. For 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2, NO2 forms twice as fast as N2O5 disappears, and O2 forms half as fast. Each curve flattens as the reaction slows.
Worked example · average rate from data
In a reaction, [A] falls from 1.00 M to 0.60 M in the first 20 s. What is the average rate of disappearance of A?
\(\text{rate} = -\dfrac{0.60 - 1.00}{20\ \text{s}} = 0.020\) M/s. Over the next 20 s [A] falls only from 0.60 to 0.36 M, an average rate of 0.012 M/s: slower, because [A] is lower.
Rates and the balanced equation
Different substances in the same reaction change at different speeds, in the ratio of their coefficients. For \(a\text{A} + b\text{B} \rightarrow c\text{C} + d\text{D}\), the rate of reaction is written so that it is the same number whichever species you follow:
\[ \text{rate} = -\dfrac{1}{a}\dfrac{\Delta[\text{A}]}{\Delta t} = -\dfrac{1}{b}\dfrac{\Delta[\text{B}]}{\Delta t} = +\dfrac{1}{c}\dfrac{\Delta[\text{C}]}{\Delta t} = +\dfrac{1}{d}\dfrac{\Delta[\text{D}]}{\Delta t} \]
Worked example · using the coefficients
In 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2, N2O5 disappears at 2.0 × 10−3 M/s. How fast do NO2 and O2 appear?
For each 2 N2O5 lost, 4 NO2 and 1 O2 form. Rate of NO2 formation = 2.0 × 10−3 × (4/2) = 4.0 × 10−3 M/s. Rate of O2 formation = 2.0 × 10−3 × (1/2) = 1.0 × 10−3 M/s. The overall rate of reaction is 1.0 × 10−3 M/s.
What controls the rate
The common thread is the collision model you will meet in lesson 5.4: reactions occur when particles collide with enough energy and the right orientation. Anything that increases the number or effectiveness of collisions speeds the reaction.
Factor
Effect on rate
Particle-level reason
Higher concentration (or pressure of a gas)
faster
more particles per volume, so more collisions per second
Higher temperature
faster (often a large effect)
particles move faster, so collisions are more frequent, and many more collisions have at least the activation energy
Greater surface area of a solid
faster
more exposed particles can collide with the other reactant
A catalyst
faster
provides a path with a lower activation energy (lesson 5.9)
The reactants themselves
varies enormously
depends on how many bonds must break and the energy needed
For example, powdered iron burns brilliantly in oxygen but an iron nail only glows; milk spoils in days in a warm kitchen but weeks in a refrigerator; a crushed antacid tablet dissolves faster than a whole one.
Temperature has the largest effect on most reactions, because it affects not only how often particles collide but what fraction of collisions are energetic enough to react. A common rule of thumb is that the rate roughly doubles for each 10 °C rise.
Worked example · explaining a change in rate
A student places zinc granules and zinc powder (same mass) in separate beakers of 1.0 M HCl. The powder reacts faster. Explain.
The concentration of acid and temperature are the same, and the chemical reaction is the same. The powder has a much larger total surface area exposed to the acid, so more zinc atoms can be struck by H+ ions at once. More collisions per second between reactants occur, so the rate is higher. The total amount of hydrogen produced is the same, since the moles of zinc are the same.
How rates are measured
The rate is found by following some property that changes with the amount of a species: the color of a solution (spectrophotometer and Beer’s law from Unit 3), the pressure of a gas in a closed container, the mass lost as a gas escapes, the conductivity of the solution, or by taking samples and titrating them.
The choice depends on what changes noticeably during the reaction.
Exam focus
A rate is always positive. Use the minus sign for reactants.
Divide by the coefficient when comparing the rates of different species.
Distinguish average, instantaneous and initial rate on a graph.
Explain every factor with collisions: frequency, energy and orientation.
Rate is not the same as extent: a fast reaction can have a small yield and a slow reaction a large one.
Practice
For N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3, H2 is consumed at 0.45 M/s. At what rate is NH3 formed?
Show answer
NH3 forms at 0.45 × (2/3) = 0.30 M/s.
[B] falls from 0.800 M to 0.500 M over 60. s. Find the average rate of disappearance.
Show answer
\(0.300 / 60. = 5.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M/s.
Explain, using the collision model, why a reaction is slower in a refrigerator.
Show answer
At lower temperature particles have lower average kinetic energy, so they collide less often and, more importantly, a much smaller fraction of collisions have at least the activation energy, so the reaction rate falls.
Why does the instantaneous rate of most reactions decrease as the reaction proceeds?
Show answer
Reactant concentrations fall as reactants are consumed, so there are fewer collisions per second. The slope of the concentration-time graph becomes less steep.
For 2 HI → H2 + I2 the rate of formation of H2 is 3.0 × 10−4 M/s. What is the rate of disappearance of HI?
Show answer
HI disappears twice as fast as H2 forms: 6.0 × 10−4 M/s.
A student claims that a higher temperature increases the rate only because the particles collide more often. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
Collision frequency does rise with temperature, but this is a small effect. The main reason is that a much larger fraction of collisions have energy at or above the activation energy, as the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution shows.
How does the rate of a reaction depend on the concentrations of the reactants? You cannot read the answer from the balanced equation, because the powers in the answer are found only by experiment.
The result, a rate law, is a compact equation that predicts the rate from the concentrations and is the first step in learning how a reaction really happens.
This lesson shows how to write a rate law, what orders and rate constants mean, and the standard experimental method for finding them: the method of initial rates.
Learning objective · 5.2.A
Represent experimental data with a consistent rate law expression.
Required content · EK 5.2.A.1 to 5.2.A.5
Experimental methods can be used to monitor the amounts of reactants and/or products of a reaction over time and to determine the rate of the reaction.
The rate law expresses the rate of a reaction as proportional to the concentration of each reactant raised to a power.
The power of each reactant in the rate law is the order of the reaction with respect to that reactant. The sum of the powers of the reactant concentrations in the rate law is the overall order of the reaction.
The proportionality constant in the rate law is called the rate constant. The value of this constant is temperature dependent and the units reflect the overall reaction order.
Comparing initial rates of a reaction is a method to determine the order with respect to each reactant.
The rate law
For a reaction with reactants A and B, the rate law has the form
\[ \text{rate} = k[\text{A}]^{m}[\text{B}]^{n} \]
The exponents \(m\) and \(n\) are the orders with respect to A and B. They are whole numbers (usually 0, 1 or 2) found from experimental data, and they are not the coefficients in the balanced equation unless the reaction happens to be a single step (lesson 5.4).
The overall order is the sum \(m + n\). The proportionality constant \(k\) is the rate constant: it is specific to the reaction and the temperature, and it is large for fast reactions and small for slow ones.
What the order means for how the rate responds to concentration:
Figure 5.2a How the rate depends on [A] for each order (with k = 1 in each case). Doubling [A] leaves a zero-order rate unchanged, doubles a first-order rate and quadruples a second-order rate.
Order in A
If [A] doubles, the rate
If [A] triples, the rate
0
is unchanged (×1)
is unchanged (×1)
1
doubles (×2)
triples (×3)
2
quadruples (×4)
increases nine-fold (×9)
Units of the rate constant
Because the rate has units of M/s, the units of \(k\) must make the equation consistent, and they depend on the overall order:
Overall order
Rate law
Units of k
0
rate = k
M s−1
1
rate = k[A]
s−1
2
rate = k[A]2 or k[A][B]
M−1 s−1
3
rate = k[A]2[B]
M−2 s−1
The units of \(k\) are therefore a quick way to identify the overall order. A rate constant with units of s−1 signals a first-order reaction.
\(k\) also increases with temperature (the rate law form does not change, but the number does).
The method of initial rates
To find the orders, run the reaction several times, changing the concentration of one reactant at a time while keeping the others constant, and measure the initial rate each time. Compare two experiments in which only one concentration changed:
the factor by which the rate changed, compared with the factor by which the concentration changed, gives the order. (Initial rates are used because the concentrations are known exactly at the start, before products can affect the rate.)
Worked example · determining the rate law
For 2 NO(g) + O2(g) → 2 NO2(g), the initial rates were measured:
Experiment
[NO] (M)
[O2] (M)
Initial rate (M/s)
1
0.010
0.010
2.5 × 10−5
2
0.020
0.010
1.0 × 10−4
3
0.010
0.020
5.0 × 10−5
Order in NO. Experiments 1 and 2: [O2] is constant and [NO] doubles. The rate goes from 2.5 × 10−5 to 1.0 × 10−4, a factor of 4 = 22, so the reaction is second order in NO.
Order in O2. Experiments 1 and 3: [NO] is constant and [O2] doubles. The rate doubles, a factor of 2 = 21, so the reaction is first order in O2.
Rate law: rate = k[NO]2[O2], third order overall.
Rate constant. Use any experiment: \(k = \dfrac{\text{rate}}{[\text{NO}]^2[\text{O}_2]} = \dfrac{2.5 \times 10^{-5}}{(0.010)^2(0.010)} = 25\) M−2 s−1. Check with experiment 2: \(1.0 \times 10^{-4} / [(0.020)^2(0.010)] = 25\). ✓
Worked example · predicting a new rate
Using the rate law above, what is the initial rate when [NO] = 0.030 M and [O2] = 0.015 M?
rate = (25)(0.030)2(0.015) = (25)(9.0 × 10−4)(0.015) = 3.4 × 10−4 M/s. Reasoning by ratios: [NO] ×3 gives ×9, and [O2] ×1.5 gives ×1.5, so the rate is 2.5 × 10−5 × 9 × 1.5 = 3.4 × 10−4 M/s.
Worked example · when the factors are not 2
Tripling [A] (with [B] fixed) multiplies the rate by 9. What is the order in A? If tripling [B] has no effect on the rate, what is the order in B?
\(3^m = 9\), so \(m = 2\): second order in A. \(3^n = 1\), so \(n = 0\): zero order in B. The rate law is rate = k[A]2, and B does not appear.
Exam focus
Orders come from experiment, not from coefficients. Say “determined from the data.”
Change one variable at a time when comparing experiments, and show the ratio (factor in rate = factor in concentration raised to the order).
Include units on k and make sure they match the overall order.
A zero-order reactant does not appear in the rate law, but it is still consumed and may be needed for the reaction.
k depends on temperature but not on concentration.
Practice
The rate law for a reaction is rate = k[A]2[B]. By what factor does the rate change if [A] is halved and [B] is doubled?
Show answer
Halving [A] multiplies the rate by (1/2)2 = 1/4; doubling [B] multiplies it by 2. Net factor: 1/4 × 2 = 1/2, so the rate is halved.
What are the units of k for a reaction with rate = k[A][B] when concentrations are in M and time is in seconds?
Show answer
\(k = \text{rate}/([\text{A}][\text{B}])\) has units of M s−1 / M2 = M−1 s−1.
For A + B → products, the initial rate is 4.0 × 10−3 M/s when [A] = [B] = 0.10 M; 1.6 × 10−2 M/s when [A] = 0.20 M and [B] = 0.10 M; and 4.0 × 10−3 M/s when [A] = 0.10 M and [B] = 0.20 M. Find the rate law and k.
Show answer
Doubling [A] quadruples the rate, so second order in A. Doubling [B] does not change the rate, so zero order in B. Rate = k[A]2. \(k = 4.0 \times 10^{-3} / (0.10)^2 = 0.40\) M−1 s−1.
A reaction is first order in X. Rate = 6.0 × 10−4 M/s when [X] = 0.30 M. What is the rate when [X] = 0.90 M?
Show answer
Why are initial rates, not rates measured later in the reaction, used to determine orders?
Show answer
At the start the concentrations of the reactants are known exactly (the amounts prepared), and there is negligible product to slow the reaction or react in reverse. Later the concentrations have changed and are not the values you set.
A reaction has k = 3.2 × 10−3 s−1. What is the overall order, and what happens to k when the temperature is raised?
Show answer
Units of s−1 mean first order overall. k increases when the temperature is raised, because a larger fraction of collisions have enough energy.
Initial rates tell you the rate law from a handful of separate experiments. But a single experiment, followed over time, contains the same information.
If you track how the concentration of a reactant falls as the minutes pass, the shape of the curve reveals the order, and the numbers on it give the rate constant. This lesson turns that idea into three integrated rate laws, a half-life for first-order reactions,
and the tools to answer questions such as “how long until half the drug is gone?” or “how old is this bone?”.
Learning objective · 5.3.A
Identify the rate law expression of a chemical reaction using data that show how the concentrations of reaction species change over time.
Required content · EK 5.3.A.1 to 5.3.A.6
The order of a reaction can be inferred from a graph of concentration of reactant versus time.
If a reaction is first order with respect to a reactant being monitored, a plot of the natural log (ln) of the reactant concentration as a function of time will be linear. If it is second order, a plot of the reciprocal of the concentration versus time will be linear.
The slopes of the concentration versus time data for zeroth, first and second order reactions can be used to determine the rate constant. Zeroth order: \([A]_t - [A]_0 = -kt\). First order: \(\ln[A]_t - \ln[A]_0 = -kt\). Second order: \(\dfrac{1}{[A]_t} - \dfrac{1}{[A]_0} = kt\).
Half-life is a critical parameter for first-order reactions because the half-life is constant and related to the rate constant by \(t_{1/2} = 0.693/k\).
Radioactive decay processes provide an important illustration of first-order kinetics.
Three integrated rate laws
For a reaction with a single reactant A, the rate law connects the rate to \([A]\); integrating it gives the concentration at any time. The three results, and the plot that is a straight line for each, are:
Order
Rate law
Integrated rate law
Linear plot
Slope
Zero
rate = k
\([A]_t = [A]_0 - kt\)
[A] vs t
−k
First
rate = k[A]
\(\ln[A]_t = \ln[A]_0 - kt\)
ln[A] vs t
−k
Second
rate = k[A]2
\(\dfrac{1}{[A]_t} = \dfrac{1}{[A]_0} + kt\)
1/[A] vs t
+k
Each equation has the form \(y = mx + b\), which is why a particular plot is linear for a particular order.
Figure 5.3a Which plot is a straight line tells the order. In each row the highlighted graph is linear. The slope of that line gives the rate constant: −k for zero and first order, +k for second order.
How to find the order from data: make all three plots (or test them). Whichever one is a straight line gives the order, and its slope gives \(k\). The plot of [A] against t itself curves for first and second order reactions, and a zero-order reaction is the only one for which the concentration falls in a straight line.
Worked example · finding the order from data
The concentration of A is measured over time. Determine the order and k.
t (s)
0
100
200
300
[A] (M)
0.800
0.400
0.267
0.200
1/[A] (M−1)
1.25
2.50
3.75
5.00
[A] is not linear (it falls 0.400 in the first 100 s but only 0.133 in the next). The half-life is not constant either (0.800 to 0.400 took 100 s, but 0.400 to 0.200 took 200 s), so it is not first order. The reciprocal rises by exactly 1.25 every 100 s: linear. The reaction is second order. Slope = \(k = \dfrac{5.00 - 1.25}{300} = 0.0125\) M−1 s−1.
Worked example · using each integrated law
Zero order: \([A]_0 = 1.00\) M, \(k = 0.020\) M/s. How long until [A] = 0.40 M? \(t = (1.00 - 0.40)/0.020 = 30\) s.
First order: \([A]_0 = 0.500\) M, \(k = 0.0300\) min−1. What is [A] at 40 min? \(\ln[A] = \ln(0.500) - (0.0300)(40) = -0.693 - 1.20 = -1.893\), so [A] = \(e^{-1.893}\) = 0.151 M.
Second order: \([A]_0 = 0.50\) M, \(k = 0.20\) M−1 s−1. [A] at 30 s? \(1/[A] = 1/0.50 + (0.20)(30) = 2.0 + 6.0 = 8.0\), so [A] = 0.125 M.
Half-life
The half-life, \(t_{1/2}\), is the time for the concentration of a reactant to fall to half its value. For a first-order reaction, putting \([A]_t = \tfrac{1}{2}[A]_0\) into the integrated law gives
\[ t_{1/2} = \dfrac{\ln 2}{k} = \dfrac{0.693}{k} \]
This is independent of the starting concentration: it takes the same time to go from 1.00 M to 0.50 M as from 0.10 M to 0.050 M. A constant half-life is the signature of a first-order process.
(For second-order reactions each successive half-life is twice as long as the one before, and for zero-order reactions each is half as long, since they depend on the starting concentration.)
Figure 5.3b For a first-order reaction each half-life (here 10 min, so k = 0.0693 min−1) cuts the concentration in half, no matter where you start. That constant half-life is a signature of first-order kinetics.
Worked example · first-order half-life
A first-order reaction has \(k = 0.0231\) min−1. (a) Find the half-life. (b) What fraction remains after 90 min? (c) How long until 25% remains?
(a) \(t_{1/2} = 0.693 / 0.0231 = 30.0\) min. (b) 90 min is 3 half-lives, so the fraction remaining is \((1/2)^3 = 1/8 = 12.5\%\). (c) 25% = (1/2)2, so 2 half-lives = 60 min. (Check: \(t = \ln(4)/k = 1.386/0.0231 = 60.0\) min.)
Radioactive decay
Radioactive decay is the classic first-order process: each nucleus has a fixed probability of decaying per unit time, regardless of the other nuclei, so the number of nuclei falls exponentially with a constant half-life. This is why isotopes can serve as clocks.
Carbon-14 has a half-life of 5,730 years; living things take in carbon-14 from the atmosphere, but after death the carbon-14 decays without being replaced.
Worked example · radiocarbon age
A wooden artifact has one-quarter of the carbon-14 activity of living wood. How old is it?
One-quarter is two half-lives, so the age is 2 × 5,730 = 11,460 years.
Exam focus
Order from the linear plot: [A] vs t (zero), ln[A] vs t (first), 1/[A] vs t (second).
Constant half-life means first order. Check by comparing two successive half-lives.
The slope is −k for zero and first order, but +k for second order (reciprocal plot).
Use natural logs (ln), not log10, with these equations.
The units of k tell the order, as in the last lesson.
Practice
A first-order reaction has a half-life of 20.0 min. Find k.
Show answer
A plot of ln[A] against time is a straight line with a slope of −0.045 s−1. What is the order, and what is k?
Show answer
Linear ln[A] vs t means first order. k = −slope = 0.045 s−1. The half-life is 0.693 / 0.045 = 15 s.
A drug is eliminated by a first-order process with a half-life of 6.0 h. If a patient takes 200 mg, how much is left after 24 h?
Show answer
24 h is 4 half-lives, so 200 × (1/2)4 = 12.5 mg.
Data show that [A] decreases by 0.10 M every 50 s from 1.00 M, at a constant rate. What is the order and what is k?
Show answer
A constant decrease per unit time is a linear [A] vs t graph, so the reaction is zero order. \(k = 0.10/50 = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M/s.
Explain how you could tell, from successive half-lives alone, that a reaction is not first order.
Show answer
For a first-order reaction the half-life is constant. If the time for [A] to fall from 0.80 to 0.40 M differs from the time to fall from 0.40 to 0.20 M (for example, doubling), the half-life depends on concentration, so the reaction is not first order.
Why does the rate law have the powers it does? And why does temperature matter so much? Both questions are answered by looking at a single molecular event: two particles meet.
The collision model says a reaction happens only if the particles collide, with enough energy, in the right orientation. That simple idea explains the effect of concentration, temperature and the very form of the rate law for the simplest class of reactions, the elementary reactions.
Learning objectives · 5.4.A and 5.5.A
5.4.A Represent an elementary reaction as a rate law expression using stoichiometry.
5.5.A Explain the relationship between the rate of an elementary reaction and the frequency, energy and orientation of particle collisions.
Required content · EK 5.4.A.1, 5.4.A.2 and 5.5.A.1 to 5.5.A.3
The rate law of an elementary reaction can be inferred from the stoichiometry of the particles participating in a collision.
Elementary reactions involving the simultaneous collision of three or more particles are rare.
For an elementary reaction to successfully produce products, reactants must successfully collide to initiate bond-breaking and bond-making events.
In most reactions, only a small fraction of the collisions leads to a reaction. Successful collisions have both sufficient energy to overcome the activation energy requirements and orientations that allow the bonds to rearrange in the required manner.
The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution curve describes the distribution of particle energies; this distribution can be used to gain a qualitative estimate of the fraction of collisions with sufficient energy to lead to a reaction, and also how that fraction depends on temperature.
Elementary reactions
Most reactions you write as one balanced equation are not single events. An elementary reaction (or elementary step) is one that happens in a single molecular event, exactly as written: bonds break and form in one collision or one rearrangement. The overall equation often summarizes a sequence of elementary steps (the mechanism, lesson 5.6).
For an elementary reaction only, the rate law follows directly from the equation: the rate is proportional to the product of the concentrations of the colliding particles, each raised to the power of its coefficient.
Elementary step
Molecularity
Rate law
A → products
unimolecular
rate = k[A]
A + B → products
bimolecular
rate = k[A][B]
2 A → products
bimolecular
rate = k[A]2
A + B + C → products
termolecular (rare)
rate = k[A][B][C]
The reasoning is about collisions: the number of A–B collisions per second is proportional to [A] and to [B], so doubling either doubles the collision frequency. For 2 A the particles must both be A, giving [A]2. A collision of three particles at the same instant is very improbable, so elementary steps with more than two reactants are rare, and mechanisms use sequences of one- and two-particle steps instead.
Worked example · rate law of an elementary step
The step NO(g) + O3(g) → NO2(g) + O2(g) is elementary. Write its rate law and say what happens to the rate if [NO] is doubled and [O3] is halved.
Rate = k[NO][O3], bimolecular. Doubling [NO] doubles the rate and halving [O3] halves it, so the rate is unchanged.
A warning. You may use the equation to write the rate law only when you are told the step is elementary. For the overall reaction 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2 the equation suggests rate = k[NO]2[O2], and in that case the experiment agrees, but for most overall reactions it does not (for example, the rate law for 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2 is rate = k[N2O5], first order and not second).
The collision model
For two particles to react, three conditions must be met at once:
They must collide (frequency). More particles per volume (higher concentration) means more collisions per second.
The collision must have enough energy to overcome the activation energy, \(E_a\), the minimum energy needed to start breaking old bonds. Colliding particles with less than \(E_a\) simply bounce apart.
The particles must have the right orientation, so the atoms that must bond come together and the bonds that must break are in the right place.
Figure 5.4a The collision model. A collision leads to reaction only if the particles collide with at least the activation energy and in an orientation that lets bonds break and form. Most collisions fail one test or the other.
Only a tiny fraction of collisions meet both requirements, which is why most reactions are far slower than the collision frequency alone would allow. (In air at room temperature each molecule collides billions of times a second.)
Temperature and the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution
The molecules in a sample have a spread of kinetic energies (the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution from Unit 3). Only those in the high-energy tail have at least \(E_a\).
Figure 5.4b Why heating speeds up reactions. The fraction of molecules with energy at or above the activation energy (shaded) is small at low temperature and grows substantially at higher temperature, so a larger share of collisions succeed.
Raising the temperature does two things. It makes collisions more frequent (particles move faster), a modest effect. It also shifts and broadens the distribution, so the shaded area beyond \(E_a\) grows dramatically. This second effect is what makes the rate rise so steeply:
for a typical reaction with \(E_a\) near 50 kJ/mol, a 10 °C rise near room temperature roughly doubles or triples the rate. The rate constant is larger at higher temperature, because \(k\) contains the fraction of collisions with enough energy.
A higher activation energy means a smaller fraction of molecules qualify, so a reaction with a larger \(E_a\) is slower at the same temperature and is more sensitive to temperature changes.
Worked example · explaining an observation
Two reactions, X and Y, are run at the same temperature with the same concentrations. X is much faster than Y. Which has the larger activation energy, and how would raising the temperature affect the two?
Y is slower, so a smaller fraction of Y collisions has energy of at least \(E_a\): Y has the larger activation energy (orientation requirements could also play a part). Raising the temperature increases the fraction of energetic collisions for both, and because the fraction for Y is in the steeper, far-tail part of the distribution, its rate increases by a larger factor, although X is still faster in absolute terms.
Exam focus
The rate law of an elementary step follows its coefficients; an overall equation does not tell you the rate law.
Name all three requirements: frequency, energy of at least \(E_a\), and orientation.
Explain the temperature effect with the fraction of molecules above \(E_a\), not merely with faster motion.
Draw the distribution correctly: same area, higher T gives a lower, broader peak shifted right.
Termolecular steps are rare. If a proposed step has three reactants colliding at once, suspect it is wrong.
Practice
The elementary step 2 NO2 → NO + NO3 is proposed. Write its rate law.
Show answer
Rate = k[NO2]2: bimolecular, with two NO2 in the collision.
By what factor does the rate of the elementary reaction A + B → C increase if the volume of the container is halved (gas-phase)?
Show answer
Halving the volume doubles both [A] and [B]. Rate = k[A][B] increases by 2 × 2 = 4.
Explain why most collisions between reactant molecules do not lead to reaction.
Show answer
Most collisions have less energy than the activation energy, and many that have enough energy have the wrong orientation, so bonds cannot rearrange. Only collisions that satisfy both requirements are effective.
On a Maxwell-Boltzmann diagram, a vertical line marks \(E_a\). Describe what happens to the area to the right of the line when the temperature is increased, and what this means for the rate.
Show answer
The area increases, because the distribution shifts to higher energies and broadens. A larger fraction of molecules has energy of at least \(E_a\), so more collisions are effective and the rate constant and rate increase.
A student claims that doubling the temperature (in kelvin) doubles the reaction rate. Evaluate.
Show answer
It is not valid. Rate depends exponentially on the fraction of molecules above \(E_a\), so a modest temperature rise can change the rate by a large factor, while doubling the kelvin temperature would change it by far more than a factor of 2. There is no simple proportionality.
Why is the rate law of the overall reaction 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2 (first order in N2O5) not second order?
Show answer
The overall reaction is not a single elementary step. It occurs by a mechanism, and the rate depends on the slowest step, which involves only one N2O5 molecule. The coefficient 2 in the balanced equation does not become the order.
A boulder at the top of a hill releases energy when it rolls down, but it will not start rolling until something gives it a push over the lip of a small ridge.
Chemical reactions are the same. A fuel can release a great deal of energy when it burns, yet gasoline sits safely in a tank until a spark gets the process started.
A reaction energy profile is a picture of that hill: it shows the energy of the particles as they rearrange from reactants to products, the barrier in between, and the net energy released or absorbed.
Learning objective · 5.6.A
Represent the activation energy and overall energy change in an elementary reaction using a reaction energy profile.
Required content · EK 5.6.A.1 to 5.6.A.4
Elementary reactions typically involve the breaking of some bonds and the forming of new ones.
The reaction coordinate is the axis along which the complex set of motions involved in rearranging reactants to form products can be plotted.
The energy profile gives the energy along the reaction coordinate, which typically proceeds from reactants, through a transition state, to products. The energy difference between the reactants and the transition state is the activation energy for the forward reaction.
The rate of an elementary reaction is temperature dependent because the proportion of particle collisions that are energetic enough to reach the transition state varies with temperature. The Arrhenius equation relates the temperature dependence of the rate of an elementary reaction to the activation energy needed by molecular collisions to reach the transition state.
Exclusion: calculations involving the Arrhenius equation are not assessed.
Reading a profile
A reaction energy profile plots potential energy (vertical) against the reaction coordinate (horizontal), a measure of how far the reaction has progressed from reactants (left) to products (right).
The reaction coordinate has no numbers: it stands for the combined stretching, breaking and forming of bonds.
Figure 5.5a Energy profile for a one-step reaction. The activation energy Eₐ is the energy difference between the reactants and the transition state (the peak). ΔH is the energy difference between products and reactants. A reaction can have a large Eₐ and be exothermic.
Reactants are at the left, at their own energy level; products at the right.
The transition state (activated complex) is the peak: the highest-energy arrangement along the path, where old bonds are partly broken and new bonds are partly formed. It is not a species that can be isolated; it exists for about the time of one bond vibration.
The activation energy \(E_a\) is the vertical distance from the reactants to the top of the peak. It is the energy barrier that colliding particles must supply.
The enthalpy change ΔH is the vertical distance between reactants and products: negative if the products are lower (exothermic: energy released), positive if higher (endothermic: energy absorbed).
The two quantities are independent: a reaction can have a large barrier and a large energy release (a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen is stable until ignited, then releases enormous energy), or a small barrier and a small or positive ΔH.
The size of \(E_a\) controls the rate; ΔH tells you the energy change and, from Unit 6 and Unit 9, helps decide whether the reaction is favorable.
The reverse reaction
The same profile read from right to left is the reverse reaction. Its activation energy is the vertical distance from the products to the top of the peak:
\[ E_{a,\text{reverse}} = E_{a,\text{forward}} - \Delta H \]
So for an exothermic reaction the reverse barrier is larger than the forward barrier by \(|\Delta H|\); for an endothermic reaction it is smaller. Also, ΔHforward = −ΔHreverse.
Worked example · from numbers to a profile
An elementary reaction has \(E_a = 75\) kJ/mol and ΔH = −40 kJ/mol. Describe its profile and find the activation energy for the reverse reaction.
Take the reactants at 0 kJ/mol. The transition state is at +75 kJ/mol. The products are at −40 kJ/mol, below the reactants (exothermic). For the reverse reaction the barrier is measured from the products at −40 to the peak at +75: \(E_{a,\text{reverse}} = 75 - (-40) = 115\) kJ/mol. The reverse reaction is slower than the forward reaction at the same temperature.
Worked example · endothermic
For an elementary reaction \(E_a = 90\) kJ/mol and ΔH = +30 kJ/mol. Find \(E_{a,\text{reverse}}\).
\(E_{a,\text{reverse}} = 90 - 30 = 60\) kJ/mol. The products sit 30 kJ/mol above the reactants, and the peak is 60 kJ/mol above the products.
Temperature and the activation energy
The Arrhenius equation expresses how the rate constant depends on temperature and \(E_a\): \(k = Ae^{-E_a/RT}\). The exam does not ask for calculations with it, but you should be able to read its message. The factor \(e^{-E_a/RT}\) is the fraction of collisions with energy of at least \(E_a\):
A larger \(E_a\) gives a smaller fraction and therefore a smaller \(k\) and a slower reaction.
A higher T gives a larger fraction and a larger \(k\) and a faster reaction.
The pre-exponential factor \(A\) represents the frequency of collisions with a suitable orientation.
Importantly, a larger activation energy also means the rate is more sensitive to temperature: heating helps a high-barrier reaction more than a low-barrier one.
Worked example · comparing profiles
Two exothermic reactions release the same energy. Reaction 1 has \(E_a = 40\) kJ/mol and reaction 2 has \(E_a = 120\) kJ/mol. Compare their rates at the same temperature and sketch what changes in the profiles.
The ΔH values are equal, so the products sit at the same depth below the reactants. Reaction 2 has a taller peak. A much smaller fraction of collisions has enough energy to climb it, so reaction 2 is much slower even though it releases the same energy. (Burning wood and burning natural gas in air both release energy, but both need a spark; the barrier is why they do not burn spontaneously.)
Exam focus
Label the axes (potential energy and reaction coordinate) and mark \(E_a\) and ΔH with arrows from the correct levels.
\(E_a\) is measured from the reactants to the peak; ΔH from reactants to products.
Exothermic means the products are lower. A lower product energy does not make the reaction fast.
The transition state is at the peak and is not an intermediate.
The reverse activation energy equals \(E_a - \Delta H\).
Practice
An endothermic elementary reaction has \(E_a = 130\) kJ/mol and ΔH = +60 kJ/mol. Find \(E_{a,\text{reverse}}\).
Show answer
\(130 - 60 = 70\) kJ/mol.
Sketch in words an energy profile for an exothermic reaction with \(E_a = 50\) kJ/mol and ΔH = −100 kJ/mol. What is the reverse activation energy?
Show answer
Reactants at 0, a peak at +50, and products at −100. \(E_{a,\text{reverse}} = 50 - (-100) = 150\) kJ/mol, so the reverse reaction is much slower.
Explain why a reaction with a large negative ΔH can still be very slow at room temperature.
Show answer
The rate depends on the activation energy, not on ΔH. If \(E_a\) is large, only a very tiny fraction of collisions have enough energy, so the reaction is slow even though it releases much energy overall.
Is the transition state the same as a reaction intermediate? Explain.
Show answer
No. A transition state is the energy maximum at the top of a barrier and cannot be isolated. An intermediate is a real, if short-lived, species sitting in an energy minimum between two barriers.
How does an increase in temperature change an energy profile?
Show answer
It does not change the profile (the energies of reactants, transition state and products stay the same). It changes how many molecules have enough energy to climb the barrier, so it changes the rate.
Two reactions have \(E_a\) of 60 kJ/mol and 90 kJ/mol. Which has the larger rate constant at 300 K, and which is affected more by heating to 350 K?
Show answer
The 60 kJ/mol reaction has the larger rate constant, since a larger fraction of collisions exceeds the lower barrier. The 90 kJ/mol reaction is affected more strongly (by a larger factor) by the temperature increase.
The balanced equation for a reaction is a bookkeeping summary. It tells you what goes in and what comes out, but not how. Most reactions happen in a sequence of simple steps, and the sequence is called the mechanism.
The rate law you measure in the laboratory is the clue that lets you test a proposed mechanism: a mechanism is only believable if the steps add up to the overall equation and predict the rate law you observe.
Learning objectives · 5.7.A and 5.8.A
5.7.A Identify the components of a reaction mechanism. 5.8.A Identify the rate law for a reaction from a mechanism in which the first step is rate limiting.
Required content · EK 5.7.A.1 to 5.7.A.4 and 5.8.A.1
A reaction mechanism consists of a series of elementary reactions, or steps, that occur in sequence. The components may include reactants, intermediates, products, and catalysts.
The elementary steps when combined should align with the overall balanced equation of a chemical reaction.
A reaction intermediate is produced by some elementary steps and consumed by others, such that it is present only while a reaction is occurring.
Experimental detection of a reaction intermediate is a common way to build evidence in support of one reaction mechanism over an alternative mechanism. (Collection of data on detecting an intermediate is not assessed.)
For reaction mechanisms in which each elementary step is irreversible, or in which the first step is rate limiting, the rate law of the reaction is set by the molecularity of the slowest elementary step (the rate-limiting step).
The parts of a mechanism
A mechanism is an ordered list of elementary steps. Each step is elementary, so its rate law follows from its own coefficients (lesson 5.4). Four kinds of species can appear:
Reactants are consumed and appear on the left side of the overall equation.
Products are formed and appear on the right side of the overall equation.
An intermediate is formed in one step and used up in a later step. It never appears in the overall equation, because it is made and consumed. It is a real species with a finite lifetime, sitting in an energy valley between two barriers.
A catalyst is used in one step and regenerated in a later step. It also cancels from the overall equation, but unlike an intermediate it is present at the start (lesson 5.9).
A quick way to tell them apart: an intermediate appears first on the right side of a step (it is made) and later on the left side (it is consumed). A catalyst appears first on the left and later on the right.
The steps must add up to the overall equation. Add the steps, cancel the species that appear on both sides, and what remains must match the balanced overall reaction.
Worked example · checking a mechanism
A proposed mechanism for 2 NO2 + F2 → 2 NO2F is:
Step 1 (slow): NO2 + F2 → NO2F + F Step 2 (fast): NO2 + F → NO2F
Add the steps: NO2 + F2 + NO2 + F → NO2F + F + NO2F. The F atom appears on both sides and cancels, leaving 2 NO2 + F2 → 2 NO2F, the overall equation. F is an intermediate (made in step 1, consumed in step 2). There is no catalyst.
Worked example · intermediate or catalyst
Mechanism for the decomposition of ozone catalyzed by chlorine atoms: Step 1: Cl + O3 → ClO + O2. Step 2: ClO + O → Cl + O2. Identify the intermediate and the catalyst.
ClO is made in step 1 and used in step 2: it is the intermediate. Cl is used in step 1 and re-formed in step 2: it is the catalyst. (The oxygen atom O comes from another process in the stratosphere; the overall result is O3 + O → 2 O2.)
The rate-limiting step
In a sequence of steps, the products cannot form faster than the slowest step allows. Think of an assembly line in which one worker is far slower than the others: the output of the whole line equals the output of that worker. The slowest elementary step is the rate-limiting step (or rate-determining step), and the overall rate of the reaction is set by the rate of that step.
The rate-limiting step is the one with the highest activation energy (the tallest barrier in the energy profile, lesson 5.8). Steps that come after it can be fast without affecting the rate, because they only consume what the slow step provides.
From mechanism to rate law
When the first step is the slow step, the rate law of the overall reaction is the rate law of that elementary step, written directly from its coefficients. Only species present at the start appear, because the slow step comes first, so there are no intermediates in it.
Worked example · rate law from a slow first step
Using the NO2/F2 mechanism above, in which step 1 is slow, write the rate law for the overall reaction.
The slow step is NO2 + F2 → NO2F + F, a bimolecular elementary step, so rate = k[NO2][F2]. This is first order in each reactant and second order overall. Note that the overall coefficient of NO2 is 2, but the rate law has only one power of [NO2]: the second NO2 reacts in the fast step, which does not affect the rate. If experiments give this rate law, the mechanism is consistent with the data (consistency is evidence, not proof).
Worked example · comparing two mechanisms
For 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2 the observed rate law is rate = k[N2O5]. Mechanism A has one step: 2 N2O5 → 4 NO2 + O2. Mechanism B begins with a slow step N2O5 → NO2 + NO3, followed by faster steps. Which can be correct?
A would give rate = k[N2O5]2, which disagrees with the experiment. B has a unimolecular slow first step, giving rate = k[N2O5], which agrees. A mechanism is ruled out when it predicts the wrong rate law; B survives, though other mechanisms might also agree.
When the slow step is not the first step, its rate law would contain an intermediate, but intermediates cannot be measured or controlled in the experiment, so the rate law must be rewritten in terms of the reactants. That is the subject of the next lesson (pre-equilibrium).
Exam focus
Add the steps and cancel to check a mechanism against the overall equation.
Intermediate: made, then consumed. Catalyst: consumed, then regenerated. Neither is in the overall equation.
Rate law from the slow step, using its coefficients as powers, only when that step is elementary and has no intermediate.
The overall coefficients do not set the orders.
Agreement with the rate law supports a mechanism but cannot prove it. Disagreement rules it out.
Practice
Mechanism: Step 1 (slow) O3 → O2 + O. Step 2 (fast) O + O3 → 2 O2. Give the overall equation, the intermediate and the rate law.
Show answer
Overall: 2 O3 → 3 O2. The intermediate is O (made in step 1, consumed in step 2). The slow step is unimolecular, so rate = k[O3].
Step 1 (slow): A + B → C + D. Step 2 (fast): D + B → E. What is the overall reaction, and what is the rate law?
Show answer
Overall: A + 2 B → C + E (D cancels, so D is an intermediate). Rate = k[A][B], from the slow first step.
In the mechanism H2O2 + I− → H2O + IO− (slow), then H2O2 + IO− → H2O + O2 + I− (fast), identify the catalyst and the intermediate, and give the rate law.
Show answer
I− is the catalyst (used in step 1, regenerated in step 2); IO− is the intermediate. The slow step gives rate = k[H2O2][I−]. The overall equation is 2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + O2.
A student writes a mechanism whose steps add up to a different equation than the observed overall reaction. What should be concluded?
Show answer
The mechanism is invalid. The elementary steps, when combined, must give the overall balanced equation.
Why is the slowest step the one that determines the overall rate?
Show answer
Later steps can proceed only as fast as the slow step supplies their reactants, like an assembly line limited by its slowest worker, so the overall rate cannot exceed the rate of the slow step.
An experiment shows rate = k[X]2 for 2 X + Y → Z. Is a one-step mechanism consistent? Is it the only possibility?
Show answer
A single termolecular step 2 X + Y → Z would predict rate = k[X]2[Y], which disagrees, so one step is ruled out. A mechanism with a slow first step 2 X → intermediate followed by a fast step with Y would agree, but agreement does not prove it is the only possibility.
In the last lesson the slow step came first, which made the rate law easy to read. Often it does not. When a fast reversible step comes before the slow step, the slow step involves an intermediate, and an intermediate cannot appear in an experimental rate law because you cannot set its concentration.
The pre-equilibrium approximation is the trick that replaces the intermediate with the reactants that make it.
Learning objective · 5.9.A
Identify the rate law for a reaction from a mechanism in which the first step is not rate limiting.
Required content · EK 5.9.A.1
If the first elementary reaction is not rate limiting, approximations (such as pre-equilibrium) must be made to determine a rate law expression.
The problem
Consider 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2, whose measured rate law (lesson 5.2) is rate = k[NO]2[O2]. A proposed mechanism:
Step 1 (fast, reversible): NO + NO ⇌ N2O2
Step 2 (slow): N2O2 + O2 → 2 NO2
The steps add to the overall equation (N2O2 cancels). The slow step is step 2, so the rate law of the reaction is the rate law of that step:
\[ \text{rate} = k_2[\text{N}_2\text{O}_2][\text{O}_2] \]
This contains the intermediate N2O2, which is not an experimental variable. We must express [N2O2] using the reactants.
The idea
Step 1 is fast in both directions compared with step 2. N2O2 is formed and falls apart again many times before any of it reacts with O2, so step 1 reaches equilibrium (a "pre-equilibrium") before step 2 does anything noticeable. At equilibrium the forward and reverse rates of step 1 are equal:
\[ k_1[\text{NO}]^2 = k_{-1}[\text{N}_2\text{O}_2] \quad\Rightarrow\quad [\text{N}_2\text{O}_2] = \frac{k_1}{k_{-1}}[\text{NO}]^2 \]
Substituting into the rate law of the slow step:
\[ \text{rate} = k_2\cdot\frac{k_1}{k_{-1}}[\text{NO}]^2[\text{O}_2] = k[\text{NO}]^2[\text{O}_2],\qquad k = \frac{k_1k_2}{k_{-1}} \]
This matches the experimental rate law exactly, so the mechanism is consistent with the data. (You will meet equilibrium constants properly in Unit 7; here the ratio \(k_1/k_{-1}\) is simply the equilibrium constant of step 1.)
Procedure
Identify the slow step and write its rate law from its coefficients.
If it contains an intermediate, find the fast reversible step that makes it.
Set the forward rate of that fast step equal to its reverse rate, and solve for the intermediate's concentration in terms of reactants.
Substitute into the slow step's rate law and combine constants into one \(k\).
Worked example · a second mechanism
For 2 NO + Br2 → 2 NOBr, the mechanism is: Step 1 (fast, reversible): NO + Br2 ⇌ NOBr2. Step 2 (slow): NOBr2 + NO → 2 NOBr. Find the rate law.
Slow step: rate = k2[NOBr2][NO]. Pre-equilibrium: k1[NO][Br2] = k−1[NOBr2], so [NOBr2] = (k1/k−1)[NO][Br2]. Substituting: rate = (k1k2/k−1)[NO]2[Br2]: second order in NO, first in Br2, third order overall.
Worked example · what the measured orders reveal
A reaction 2 A + B → C has a measured rate law rate = k[A]2[B]. Propose a mechanism with a pre-equilibrium.
The rate law has A twice and B once. One possibility: Step 1 (fast, reversible) A + A ⇌ A2; Step 2 (slow) A2 + B → C. Then rate = k2[A2][B] with [A2] = (k1/k−1)[A]2, giving rate = k[A]2[B]. The rate law agrees, but other mechanisms could as well; the experiment alone cannot prove which is right.
When the slow step is first you did not need this approximation, because the slow step contains only starting reactants. When the slow step is not first and the earlier step is fast and reversible, use the pre-equilibrium: the intermediate is replaced by the reactants that make it, which usually raises the orders in the final rate law compared with the slow step alone.
Exam focus
The final rate law may contain only reactants (or catalysts), never an intermediate.
Show the equality of forward and reverse rates for the fast step, then substitute. Write it out; the substitution is the evidence.
Reading the result: the powers come from the species consumed before and in the slow step.
Match to data. If the derived rate law agrees with the experiment, the mechanism is consistent; it is not proven.
Practice
Step 1 (fast, reversible): A ⇌ B + C. Step 2 (slow): C + D → E. Find the rate law in terms of reactants.
Show answer
Slow step: rate = k2[C][D]. From step 1: [B][C]k−1 = k1[A], so [C] = k1[A] / (k−1[B]). Rate = (k1k2/k−1)[A][D]/[B]. The product B appears in the denominator.
Step 1 (fast, reversible): 2 NO ⇌ N2O2. Step 2 (slow): N2O2 + H2 → N2O + H2O. Find the rate law.
Show answer
rate = k[NO]2[H2], from [N2O2] = (k1/k−1)[NO]2 substituted into k2[N2O2][H2].
Why can't [N2O2] appear in the final experimental rate law?
Show answer
It is an intermediate that is produced and consumed during the reaction, so an experimenter cannot set or measure its starting concentration; the rate law must be written in terms of the reactants.
If [NO] is tripled in the first mechanism of this lesson, by what factor does the rate change?
Show answer
The rate law is second order in NO, so the rate increases by 32 = 9.
What does "pre-equilibrium" assume about the speeds of the steps?
Show answer
That the first step, forward and reverse, is much faster than the following slow step, so the first step stays at equilibrium while the slow step proceeds.
Two mechanisms predict the same rate law. Can the rate law tell you which is correct?
Show answer
No. Rate-law agreement cannot distinguish them. Additional evidence is needed, such as detecting an intermediate.
A reaction with a mechanism of two or more steps is like a trip over two hills with a valley between them. Each step has its own barrier, the valley holds the intermediate, and the highest peak marks the slowest step.
Drawing the energy profile of the whole sequence puts every idea in this unit on one picture: activation energy, rate-limiting step, intermediate, transition state and overall energy change.
Learning objective · 5.10.A
Represent the activation energy and overall energy change in a multistep reaction with a reaction energy profile.
Required content · EK 5.10.A.1
Knowledge of the energetics of each elementary reaction in a mechanism allows for the construction of an energy profile for a multistep reaction.
Building the profile
Draw one hill for each elementary step. Between consecutive hills is a valley, and the species in the valley is a reaction intermediate. The profile begins at the reactants and ends at the products.
Figure 5.8a Two-step mechanism. Each elementary step has its own transition state and activation energy. The intermediate sits in a valley between the peaks. The step with the highest barrier (here step 1) is the slowest and controls the overall rate.
Each peak is a transition state (one per step). The number of peaks equals the number of elementary steps.
Each valley is an intermediate. A two-step mechanism has one valley; a three-step mechanism has two.
Each step has its own activation energy, measured from the energy just before that step (the reactants for step 1, the intermediate for step 2) to the top of its peak.
The overall ΔH is the difference between final products and initial reactants. It does not depend on the intermediates or the path.
The rate-limiting step is the step with the highest activation energy. Often, but not always, this is the highest peak. The tallest barrier is measured from the preceding valley, not from the reactants. In a simple profile, compare the individual climbs.
Worked example · reading a two-step profile
A two-step reaction has these energies relative to the reactants (kJ/mol): reactants 0, first transition state +85, intermediate +30, second transition state +60, products −45. Find (a) the activation energy of each step, (b) the rate-limiting step, (c) ΔH overall and for each step.
(a) Step 1: \(E_a = 85 - 0 = 85\) kJ/mol. Step 2: \(E_a = 60 - 30 = 30\) kJ/mol. (b) Step 1 has the larger barrier, so it is the rate-limiting step, and the rate law is that of step 1 (in this case the first step is slow). (c) Step 1: ΔH = 30 − 0 = +30 (endothermic). Step 2: ΔH = −45 − 30 = −75 (exothermic). Overall: ΔH = −45 − 0 = −45 kJ/mol (the sum of the steps: +30 + (−75) = −45 ✓). The reaction is exothermic overall, although its first step is endothermic.
Worked example · the highest peak is not always the slow step
Energies (kJ/mol): reactants 0, TS1 +50, intermediate −40, TS2 +30, products −90. Which step is rate limiting?
Step 1 climbs 50 − 0 = 50 kJ/mol. Step 2 climbs 30 − (−40) = 70 kJ/mol. Step 2 has the larger activation energy, so step 2 is rate limiting, even though TS1 (+50) is the higher peak. The intermediate sits in a deep valley and must climb out of it. In this case the slow step is not first, so a pre-equilibrium treatment could be needed for the rate law.
Connecting to the mechanism
The profile tells you about the mechanism, and the mechanism tells you how to draw the profile:
If the first step is slow, the first peak is the tallest climb, and the rate law uses the reactants of step 1.
If the first step is fast and reversible, its barrier is small and the intermediate in the valley is in equilibrium with the reactants (pre-equilibrium).
A very shallow valley or a very low barrier out of it means the intermediate is short-lived and hard to detect.
Worked example · sketch from a mechanism
The mechanism for 2 NO2 + F2 → 2 NO2F has a slow first step and a fast second step, and the overall reaction is exothermic. Describe the profile.
Two peaks, with the first taller than the second because step 1 is slow. A valley between them for the intermediate F. The products end lower than the reactants. The activation energy of the reaction as a whole is dominated by the first barrier.
Exam focus
One peak per step, one valley per intermediate.
Measure each \(E_a\) from the energy just before that step to its peak.
The overall ΔH is final minus initial, ignoring the path.
Rate-limiting step: the largest activation energy. Label peaks with transition states and valleys with intermediates, not the other way round.
Practice
Energies (kJ/mol): reactants 0, TS1 +70, intermediate +20, TS2 +45, products −30. Find \(E_a\) of each step, the rate-limiting step and the overall ΔH.
Show answer
How many transition states and intermediates are in a three-step mechanism?
Show answer
Three transition states (one per step) and two intermediates (between consecutive steps).
Energies (kJ/mol): reactants 0, TS1 +40, intermediate +10, TS2 +90, products −20. Which step is rate limiting and what is its activation energy?
Show answer
Can the overall ΔH of a reaction be negative if one of its steps is endothermic? Explain.
Show answer
Yes. The overall ΔH is the sum of the ΔH values of the steps, so a strongly exothermic step can outweigh an endothermic one.
Distinguish the species at a peak from the species in a valley.
Show answer
The species at a peak is a transition state, a fleeting arrangement that cannot be isolated. The species in a valley is an intermediate, a real species with a measurable (if short) lifetime that is produced and consumed.
Why does the rate of the whole reaction depend mostly on the rate-limiting step and not on the faster steps?
Show answer
The faster steps have lower barriers, so they proceed quickly once material arrives; the throughput of the sequence is limited by the step with the highest barrier.
Your body digests food at 37 °C because enzymes speed up reactions that would otherwise take years. A car's catalytic converter turns poisonous exhaust gases into harmless ones in a fraction of a second. Both are catalysts: substances that make a reaction faster without being used up.
This lesson shows how they do it, and why they change the speed but not the outcome.
Learning objective · 5.11.A
Explain the relationship between the effect of a catalyst on a reaction and the reaction mechanism.
Required content · EK 5.11.A.1 to 5.11.A.5
In order for a catalyst to increase the rate of a reaction, the addition of the catalyst must increase the number of effective collisions and/or provide a reaction path with a lower activation energy relative to the original reaction coordinate.
In a reaction mechanism containing a catalyst, the net concentration of the catalyst is constant. However, the catalyst will frequently be consumed in the rate-determining step of the reaction, only to be regenerated in a subsequent step in the mechanism.
Some catalysts accelerate a reaction by binding to the reactant(s). The reactants are either oriented more favorably or react with lower activation energy. There is often a new reaction intermediate in which the catalyst is bound to the reactant(s). Many enzymes function in this manner.
Some catalysts involve covalent bonding between the catalyst and the reactant(s). An example is acid-base catalysis, in which a reactant or intermediate either gains or loses a proton. This introduces a new reaction intermediate and new elementary reactions involving that intermediate.
In surface catalysis, a reactant or intermediate binds to, or forms a covalent bond with, the surface. This introduces elementary reactions involving these new bound reaction intermediate(s).
What a catalyst does
A catalyst speeds up a reaction by providing a different pathway (a different mechanism) with a lower activation energy. A larger fraction of collisions now has enough energy, so the rate rises. A catalyst may also increase the number of effective collisions, for example by holding reactants in the right orientation.
Figure 5.9a A catalyst provides a different mechanism with lower activation energies. It does not change the energies of the reactants or products, so ΔH is unchanged; it speeds up both the forward and the reverse reaction.
The profile shows the key facts about a catalyst:
The activation energy falls (for the forward and the reverse reaction), usually by replacing one high barrier with several lower ones.
The reactants and products stay at the same energy, so ΔH is unchanged. A catalyst cannot make an unfavorable reaction favorable.
The catalyst is not consumed. It takes part in one step and is regenerated in a later step, so it appears in the mechanism but cancels out of the overall equation.
The equilibrium is unchanged: because the forward and reverse rates are increased equally, the same equilibrium is reached faster (Unit 7).
The rate law may include the catalyst, because it takes part in the rate-limiting step. The rate increases with the catalyst concentration.
A catalyst in a mechanism
Figure 5.9b A catalytic cycle. The catalyst is used in an early step and regenerated in a later one, so it appears in the mechanism but not in the overall equation. The bound forms are reaction intermediates.
Worked example · iodide catalyzes the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide
Uncatalyzed, 2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + O2 is very slow. With iodide ions the mechanism is: Step 1 (slow): H2O2 + I− → H2O + IO−. Step 2 (fast): H2O2 + IO− → H2O + O2 + I−.
Adding the steps gives 2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + O2: I− and IO− cancel. I− is the catalyst (consumed in step 1, regenerated in step 2); IO− is an intermediate. The slow step gives rate = k[H2O2][I−]: doubling the iodide concentration doubles the rate, even though the iodide is not used up.
Worked example · catalyst or intermediate?
In a mechanism, species X is present before the reaction starts and is present at the end at the same concentration. Species Y is absent at the start and at the end. Classify them.
X is a catalyst (present at the start and regenerated). Y is an intermediate (formed and consumed). If X were present at the start but at a lower concentration at the end, it would be a reactant that is consumed.
Types of catalysis
Type
How it works
Example
Acid-base catalysis
Transfers H+ to or from a reactant, making it more reactive.
H+ speeds up the hydrolysis of esters and the conversion of sugars.
Surface catalysis
Reactant molecules adsorb on a solid surface, where bonds weaken and reactants are held in good orientation, then products leave.
Platinum and rhodium in a catalytic converter; iron in the Haber process; nickel in hydrogenation of vegetable oils.
Enzyme catalysis
A protein with a specific active site binds the reactant (substrate), stabilizes the transition state, and releases the product.
Amylase breaks down starch; catalase decomposes hydrogen peroxide in cells.
The exam does not assess the details of these mechanisms, but you should recognize each type and say how a catalyst changes the energy profile. Enzymes are extremely specific and can speed reactions by factors of millions, but they work only within a limited range of temperature and pH, because heat or extreme pH changes the shape of the active site (Biology Unit 3).
Worked example · explaining a catalytic converter
A catalytic converter converts CO and NO to CO2 and N2. Explain why the catalyst is a solid while the reactants are gases, and why it can be used for years.
The gas molecules adsorb on the surface of the metal, where bonds in NO and CO weaken and the molecules are held next to each other in good orientations, lowering the activation energy. The products desorb, freeing the surface, so the metal is regenerated and is not used up (although it can become coated with poisons such as lead, which block active sites). The solid surface lets the gas stream flow past while the catalyst stays in place, and a high surface area gives many active sites.
Exam focus
A catalyst lowers the activation energy by changing the mechanism; it does not change ΔH, the products, the equilibrium or the amount of product formed.
A catalyst is not consumed. It appears in the mechanism but cancels in the overall equation.
Draw the catalyzed profile with a lower barrier (often with two small peaks) and the same starting and ending levels.
Explain with fractions of collisions: a lower \(E_a\) means a larger fraction of collisions with enough energy.
Catalyst versus intermediate is a frequent question.
Practice
State two things that a catalyst does not change about a reaction.
Show answer
It does not change ΔH (the overall energy change) or the position of the equilibrium (the final amounts of products). It also is not consumed.
Step 1: NO2 + SO2 → NO + SO3. Step 2: 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2. Identify the catalyst and give the overall reaction.
Show answer
NO2 is used in step 1 and made in step 2 (after doubling step 1 to balance NO), so it is the catalyst; NO is an intermediate. Doubling step 1 and adding step 2: 2 SO2 + O2 → 2 SO3.
Describe how the energy profile changes when a catalyst is added.
Show answer
The reactants and products stay at the same energies. The single high barrier is replaced by a lower barrier, often two smaller peaks with a valley for an intermediate, so the activation energy of both the forward and reverse reactions falls.
Use the collision model to explain why a catalyst increases the rate.
Show answer
The catalyzed pathway has a lower activation energy, so at the same temperature a larger fraction of collisions has enough energy; a catalyst may also hold the reactants in a favorable orientation.
Why does heating an enzyme-catalyzed reaction much above body temperature usually slow it down?
Show answer
Heat denatures the enzyme, changing the shape of its active site so the substrate no longer binds, even though higher temperature would otherwise increase the rate.
A catalyst provides a pathway with a lower barrier for the forward reaction. What is the effect on the reverse reaction?
Show answer
It also has a lower barrier, by the same amount, because the reactants, products and ΔH are unchanged, so the reverse reaction is sped up as well.
Unit 5 practice · 10 problems
Unit 5 practice: Kinetics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed.
4 NH3(g) + 5 O2(g) → 4 NO(g) + 6 H2O(g). If NH3 is consumed at 0.240 M/s, at what rates is O2 consumed and H2O produced?
Show answer
Rates scale with coefficients: O2 \(= 0.240 \times \tfrac{5}{4} = 0.300\) M/s consumed; H2O \(= 0.240 \times \tfrac{6}{4} = 0.360\) M/s produced. (NO forms at 0.240 M/s.)
For A + B → products, initial-rate data at one temperature are shown. Find the rate law and the value and units of \(k\).
Trial
[A]₀ (M)
[B]₀ (M)
Initial rate (M/s)
1
0.100
0.100
4.0 × 10⁻³
2
0.200
0.100
8.0 × 10⁻³
3
0.200
0.200
3.2 × 10⁻²
Show answer
Trials 1 → 2: [A] doubles, rate doubles → first order in A. Trials 2 → 3: [B] doubles, rate ×4 → second order in B. \(\text{rate} = k[\mathrm{A}][\mathrm{B}]^2\), third order overall. From trial 1: \(k = \dfrac{4.0 \times 10^{-3}}{(0.100)(0.100)^2} = 4.0\ \mathrm{M^{-2}\,s^{-1}}\).
A reaction is first order in A with \(k = 1.20 \times 10^{-2}\ \mathrm{s^{-1}}\). Starting from [A] = 0.800 M, what is [A] after 120 s? What is the half-life?
Show answer
\(\ln[\mathrm{A}]_t = \ln(0.800) - (0.0120)(120) = -0.223 - 1.44 = -1.663\), so \([\mathrm{A}]_t = e^{-1.663} = 0.190\) M. \(t_{1/2} = 0.693 / 0.0120 = 57.8\) s. Check: 120 s is about two half-lives, and \(0.800/4 = 0.200\). ✓
Concentration data for the decomposition of A: \(t = 0, 10, 20, 30\) s; \([\mathrm{A}] = 1.000, 0.500, 0.333, 0.250\) M. Determine the order and \(k\), and explain how you know.
Show answer
Test the plots. \(1/[\mathrm{A}] = 1.00, 2.00, 3.00, 4.00\ \mathrm{M^{-1}}\): a straight line versus \(t\), so the reaction is second order, with \(k = \text{slope} = 0.100\ \mathrm{M^{-1}\,s^{-1}}\). It is not first order: the successive half-lives (10 s from 1.000 to 0.500, then 20 s from 0.500 to 0.250) double as the concentration falls, whereas a first-order half-life is constant.
A first-order reaction has a half-life of 20.0 min. What fraction of the reactant remains after 60.0 min?
1/3 treats the decay as linear, “60 minutes is three 20-minute periods, so a third is left”, but first-order decay halves the remaining amount each half-life rather than removing a fixed amount each interval.
1/4 is what remains after two half-lives (40.0 min), not three. Stopping one half-life early, or counting \(60/20 - 1\) half-lives, is the usual slip.
60.0 min is three half-lives, and each half-life halves whatever is present regardless of concentration: \((\tfrac{1}{2})^3 = \tfrac{1}{8}\). A concentration-independent half-life is the fingerprint of first-order kinetics.
1/6 comes from multiplying 2 by 3, the “half” times three half-lives, instead of raising \(\tfrac{1}{2}\) to the third power. Half-lives compound multiplicatively, not additively.
On an energy profile the reactants sit at 30 kJ/mol, the transition state at 145 kJ/mol, and the products at 75 kJ/mol. Find the forward activation energy, \(\Delta H\), and the reverse activation energy. Is the reaction endothermic or exothermic?
Raising the temperature of a reaction from 20 °C to 30 °C roughly doubles its rate, yet the average kinetic energy rises only about 3%. Explain, using the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution, in the language graders expect.
Show answer
Collision frequency rises only slightly with a 3% increase in average kinetic energy. The dominant effect is on the distribution: at higher T the curve flattens and its high-energy tail extends further, so a much larger fraction of collisions have energy greater than or equal to the activation energy. Because that fraction is exponential in \(-E_a/RT\), a small temperature change produces a large change in the number of successful collisions.
Proposed mechanism for 2 NO2 + F2 → 2 NO2F: Step 1 (slow): NO2 + F2 → NO2F + F. Step 2 (fast): NO2 + F → NO2F. Show the steps sum to the overall equation, identify any intermediate, and predict the rate law.
Show answer
Adding: 2 NO2 + F2 + F → 2 NO2F + F; the F atom cancels, leaving 2 NO2 + F2 → 2 NO2F. ✓ The F atom is an intermediate (made in step 1, consumed in step 2). The slow step is bimolecular in NO2 and F2: rate = k[NO2][F2]: first order in NO2 even though its overall coefficient is 2.
The experimental rate law for H2 + I2 → 2 HI is rate = k[H2][I2]. Proposed mechanism: Step 1 (fast, reversible): I2 ⇌ 2 I. Step 2 (slow): H2 + 2 I → 2 HI. Show that this mechanism is consistent with the rate law.
Show answer
The slow step gives rate \(= k_2[\mathrm{H_2}][\mathrm{I}]^2\), but I is an intermediate. Step 1 is at equilibrium, so \(k_1[\mathrm{I_2}] = k_{-1}[\mathrm{I}]^2\), giving \([\mathrm{I}]^2 = \dfrac{k_1}{k_{-1}}[\mathrm{I_2}]\). Substituting: \(\text{rate} = \dfrac{k_2 k_1}{k_{-1}}[\mathrm{H_2}][\mathrm{I_2}] = k[\mathrm{H_2}][\mathrm{I_2}]\). ✓ The steps also sum to H2 + I2 → 2 HI.
Nitrogen dioxide speeds the oxidation of SO2: Step 1: SO2 + NO2 → SO3 + NO (×2). Step 2: 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2. Write the overall reaction, identify the catalyst and the intermediate, and state what the catalyst does and does not change.
Show answer
Overall: 2 SO2 + O2 → 2 SO3 (the NO2 and NO cancel). NO2 is consumed first and regenerated later: the catalyst. NO is produced first and consumed later: the intermediate. The catalyst provides a pathway with a lower activation energy, so a larger fraction of collisions succeed and \(k\) increases: for both directions. It does not change \(\Delta H\), the equilibrium constant, or the equilibrium composition; those depend only on reactants and products.
A campfire warms your hands; an instant cold pack chills a sprained ankle; sweat cools your skin as it evaporates. Every one of these is a change in energy, and you detect each one by feeling a temperature change in what surrounds the process.
Thermochemistry is the study of these energy changes. This lesson gives you the vocabulary (system, surroundings, endothermic, exothermic), the particle-level reason a solution warms or cools, and the energy diagram that summarizes it all.
Learning objectives · 6.1.A and 6.2.A
6.1.A Explain the relationship between experimental observations and energy changes associated with a chemical or physical transformation. 6.2.A Represent a chemical or physical transformation with an energy diagram.
Required content · EK 6.1.A.1 to 6.1.A.4 and 6.2.A.1
Temperature changes in a system indicate energy changes.
Energy changes in a system can be described as endothermic and exothermic processes such as the heating or cooling of a substance, phase changes, or chemical transformations.
When a chemical reaction occurs, the energy of the system either decreases (exothermic reaction), increases (endothermic reaction), or remains the same. For exothermic reactions, the energy lost by the reacting species (system) is gained by the surroundings, as heat transfer from or work done by the system. Likewise, for endothermic reactions, the system gains energy from the surroundings by heat transfer to or work done on the system.
The formation of a solution may be an exothermic or endothermic process, depending on the relative strengths of intermolecular/interparticle interactions before and after the dissolution process.
A physical or chemical process can be described with an energy diagram that shows the endothermic or exothermic nature of that process.
System and surroundings
To keep track of energy, chemists draw a boundary. The system is the part of the universe you are studying (the reacting chemicals, the melting ice); the surroundings are everything else (the water in the beaker, the beaker, the air, your hand). Energy can pass across the boundary as heat (energy transferred because of a temperature difference) or as work (for example, a gas expanding and pushing back the atmosphere).
Energy is conserved: whatever the system loses, the surroundings gain, and the reverse. That is why you can learn about the system by watching the thermometer in the surroundings.
An exothermic process releases energy from the system to the surroundings. The system's energy decreases; the surroundings warm. Examples: combustion, freezing, condensation, neutralization.
An endothermic process absorbs energy from the surroundings. The system's energy increases; the surroundings cool. Examples: melting, boiling, evaporation, photosynthesis, dissolving ammonium nitrate.
Figure 6.1a The energy of the system, not the temperature of the surroundings, defines the direction. Energy lost by an exothermic system is gained by the surroundings, so a thermometer in the surroundings rises. An endothermic system draws energy in, and the surroundings cool.
The two words describe the system. If the beaker feels hot, the surroundings gained energy, so the process in the beaker is exothermic. Many students mix this up because the surroundings do the opposite of the system. A useful check: the thermometer in the solution reports on the system and its immediate surroundings, so a temperature rise means energy was released (exothermic), and a temperature fall means energy was absorbed (endothermic).
Worked example · classifying from observation
Classify each: (a) a hand warmer packet heats up when opened; (b) water evaporates from your skin, leaving it cool; (c) a campfire; (d) ice melts in a drink and the drink gets colder.
(a) The surroundings warm, so the process releases energy: exothermic. (b) The skin loses energy to the evaporating liquid, so evaporation is endothermic. (c) Combustion releases energy: exothermic. (d) The ice absorbs energy from the drink as it melts, so melting is endothermic.
Why heat appears or disappears
Energy cannot appear from nowhere. In a chemical reaction the chemical potential energy stored in the arrangement of the atoms and electrons changes, because bonds are broken (which takes energy) and new bonds are formed (which releases energy). If the new bonds are, overall, stronger than the old ones, the potential energy of the particles falls and the lost energy appears as increased kinetic energy of the particles, which you detect as a temperature rise. If the new bonds are weaker, kinetic energy is converted to potential energy and the temperature falls.
Phase changes work the same way, though no bonds break: melting and vaporizing overcome the attractions between particles (a potential-energy increase, paid for by energy taken from the surroundings), while freezing and condensing allow attractions to form (energy released).
Dissolving: warm or cool?
Forming a solution involves three energy steps. Energy must be supplied to pull the solute particles apart (overcoming solute-solute attractions), and to push the solvent particles apart to make room (overcoming solvent-solvent attractions). Energy is released when the solute and solvent particles attract one another (solute-solvent interactions, such as ion-dipole forces).
If the new solute-solvent attractions are stronger than the attractions that were overcome, energy is released: exothermic, and the solution warms (calcium chloride in water; sodium hydroxide in water).
If the new attractions are weaker, energy is absorbed: endothermic, and the solution cools (ammonium nitrate in water, used in instant cold packs).
Worked example · explaining a cold pack
A cold pack contains solid ammonium nitrate and a pouch of water. When the pouch is broken the contents get cold. Explain in terms of particle interactions and energy.
The ammonium and nitrate ions in the crystal are held by strong ionic attractions. When the salt dissolves, those attractions must be overcome, and water molecules must be pushed apart. The ion-dipole attractions that form between the ions and water release less energy than was needed. The system therefore absorbs energy from the surroundings: dissolving is endothermic, kinetic energy of the solution decreases, and the temperature falls.
Energy diagrams
An energy diagram shows the energy of the system as a horizontal level for the reactants and another for the products, with an arrow between them for the change.
Exothermic: products below reactants. The arrow points down and ΔH is negative.
Endothermic: products above reactants. The arrow points up and ΔH is positive.
The vertical distance is the size of the energy change, and the diagram should be labeled with the species, an axis labeled energy, and ΔH with its sign.
(A reaction energy profile, as in Unit 5, adds the activation-energy barrier between the two levels. The energy diagram here ignores the barrier and concentrates on the overall change.)
Worked example · from words to a diagram
The dissolution of NaOH(s) in water makes the solution warm. Describe the energy diagram.
The solution warms, so energy is released: exothermic. Draw the starting level (NaOH(s) + H2O(l)) high and the final level (NaOH(aq)) lower, with a downward arrow labeled ΔH < 0. The surroundings gain the energy lost by the system.
Exam focus
State who gains and who loses: “the system loses energy and the surroundings gain it.”
Temperature of the surroundings goes up for exothermic, down for endothermic. Do not say a reaction “makes cold” without saying it absorbs energy.
Justify with particles: compare the strengths of the attractions broken and formed.
Diagram: label axis, levels, arrow direction and sign of ΔH.
Heat is not temperature. Temperature measures average kinetic energy; heat is energy transferred.
Practice
When a student mixes two solutions the beaker feels cooler. Is the reaction endothermic or exothermic? Where does the energy come from?
Show answer
Endothermic. The system absorbs energy from the surroundings (including the solution's own thermal energy and the beaker), so the temperature falls.
Classify each as endothermic or exothermic: freezing water, condensation of steam, boiling water, burning methane.
Show answer
Explain why dissolving CaCl2 in water warms the solution, using the strengths of interactions.
Show answer
The ion-dipole attractions between Ca2+ or Cl− and water release more energy than is needed to separate the ions and to move water molecules apart, so the net energy is released to the surroundings and the temperature rises.
Sketch in words the energy diagram for an endothermic reaction.
Show answer
Energy on the vertical axis. A lower level for the reactants and a higher level for the products, with an upward arrow between them labeled ΔH > 0.
A reaction mixture is in a closed, insulated container and its temperature rises from 20 °C to 30 °C. Has the energy of the system plus its surroundings changed? Explain.
Show answer
No. Energy is conserved. Chemical potential energy of the reacting species was converted to kinetic (thermal) energy of the mixture; the total energy is unchanged.
A student says that the reaction in a cold pack is “creating cold.” Correct the statement.
Show answer
Cold is not a substance or energy. The dissolving is endothermic: it absorbs energy from the water and the surroundings, which lowers their temperature.
A metal spoon in hot soup gets hot almost at once, but a wooden spoon takes longer and feels cooler; a lake stays cool on a day when the beach sand burns your feet. Behind all of this is how thermal energy moves between objects and how much energy it takes to change an object's temperature.
This lesson turns those ideas into a single equation, \(q = mc\Delta T\), and shows how to use it in a calorimeter to measure the energy of a reaction.
Learning objectives · 6.3.A and 6.4.A
6.3.A Explain the relationship between the transfer of thermal energy and molecular collisions. 6.4.A Calculate the heat q absorbed or released by a system undergoing heating or cooling based on the amount of the substance, the heat capacity, and the change in temperature.
Required content · EK 6.3.A.1 to 6.3.A.3 and 6.4.A.1 to 6.4.A.7
The particles in a warmer body have a greater average kinetic energy than those in a cooler body.
Collisions between particles in thermal contact can result in the transfer of energy. This process is called “heat transfer,” “heat exchange,” or “transfer of energy as heat.”
Eventually, thermal equilibrium is reached as the particles continue to collide. At thermal equilibrium, the average kinetic energy of both bodies is the same, and hence, their temperatures are the same.
The heating of a cool body by a warmer body is an important form of energy transfer between two systems. The amount of heat transferred between two bodies may be quantified by the heat transfer equation \(q = mc\Delta T\). Calorimetry experiments are used to measure the transfer of heat.
The first law of thermodynamics states that energy is conserved in chemical and physical processes.
The transfer of a given amount of thermal energy will not produce the same temperature change in equal masses of matter with differing specific heat capacities.
Heating a system increases the energy of the system, while cooling a system decreases the energy of the system.
The specific heat capacity of a substance and the molar heat capacity are both used in energy calculations.
Chemical systems change their energy through three main processes: heating/cooling, phase transitions, and chemical reactions.
In calorimetry experiments involving dissolution, temperature changes of the mixture within the calorimeter can be used to determine the direction of energy flow. If the temperature of the mixture increases, thermal energy is released by the dissolution process (exothermic). If the temperature of the mixture decreases, thermal energy is absorbed by the dissolution process (endothermic).
Thermal equilibrium
Temperature is a measure of the average kinetic energy of the particles. In a hot body the particles move, vibrate or rotate with larger average kinetic energy than in a cold one. When two bodies touch, particles at the boundary collide. On average, faster particles lose energy to slower ones, so energy flows from the hotter body to the colder one. This transfer is called heat (symbol \(q\)).
Figure 6.2b Two equal bodies of the same material placed in contact. Collisions at the boundary move energy from the faster particles of the hot body to the slower particles of the cold body until the average kinetic energies, and therefore the temperatures, are equal (here 60 °C).
The flow continues until the average kinetic energies are equal, which is thermal equilibrium: the temperatures are the same and there is no net transfer. Notice that it is the temperatures that become equal, not the energy contents (a large cool pool holds far more thermal energy than a hot cup of coffee).
The heat equation
The energy needed to change the temperature of a substance depends on how much there is, how much its temperature changes, and the substance itself:
\[ q = mc\Delta T \]
where \(q\) is heat (J or kJ), \(m\) is mass (g), \(\Delta T = T_{\text{final}} - T_{\text{initial}}\) (°C or K; the size of a degree is the same), and \(c\) is the specific heat capacity, the energy needed to raise 1 g of the substance by 1 °C. For liquid water \(c = 4.18\) J g−1 °C−1. The same idea can be written with moles and a molar heat capacity: \(q = nC\Delta T\).
Heating gives \(\Delta T \gt 0\) and positive \(q\): the substance gains energy.
Cooling gives \(\Delta T \lt 0\) and negative \(q\): the substance loses energy.
A large \(c\) means a large amount of energy is needed for a small temperature change. Water's value is unusually large because of hydrogen bonding, which is why coastal climates are mild and why water is good for cooling.
Substance
c (J g−1 °C−1)
Water (liquid)
4.18
Ice
2.09
Steam
2.01
Aluminum
0.897
Iron
0.449
Copper
0.385
Worked example · heat to warm water
How much heat is absorbed by 60.0 g of water warmed from 20.0 °C to 35.0 °C?
\(\Delta T = 35.0 - 20.0 = 15.0\) °C. \(q = mc\Delta T = (60.0)(4.18)(15.0) = 3762\) J = 3.76 kJ, positive because the water gained energy.
Worked example · same energy, different substances
Equal masses of water and copper each absorb the same amount of heat. Which warms more?
\(\Delta T = q/(mc)\), so for the same \(q\) and \(m\) the substance with the smaller \(c\) has the larger temperature change. Copper (0.385) warms about 11 times more than water (4.18). That is why a copper pan heats quickly while the water in it takes much longer.
Calorimetry
A calorimeter is an insulated container in which a process occurs so that the energy it releases or absorbs changes the temperature of a known mass of water or solution. Because energy is conserved (the first law of thermodynamics), if no heat escapes then
\[ q_{\text{system}} + q_{\text{surroundings}} = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad q_{\text{reaction}} = -q_{\text{solution}} \]
Figure 6.2c A coffee-cup calorimeter. The insulated cup keeps the energy inside, so the energy lost or gained by the reaction is gained or lost by the solution. Measuring the solution's temperature change gives the heat of the reaction.
To use a calorimeter: measure the mass of solution, record the temperature before and after, calculate \(q_{\text{solution}} = mc\Delta T\) (with \(c\) taken as that of water, 4.18 J g−1 °C−1, unless told otherwise), and change the sign to get the heat of the reaction. A temperature rise means the reaction released energy.
Worked example · specific heat of an unknown metal
A 45.0 g piece of metal is heated to 100.0 °C and dropped into 100.0 g of water at 22.0 °C in an insulated cup. The final temperature is 25.5 °C. Find the specific heat of the metal.
Heat gained by water: \(q = (100.0)(4.18)(25.5 - 22.0) = 1463\) J. The metal lost the same amount: \(q_{\text{metal}} = -1463\) J. For the metal \(\Delta T = 25.5 - 100.0 = -74.5\) °C. \(c = q/(m\Delta T) = (-1463)/[(45.0)(-74.5)] = \) 0.436 J g−1 °C−1.
Worked example · heat of neutralization
50.0 mL of 1.00 M HCl is mixed with 50.0 mL of 1.00 M NaOH in a foam-cup calorimeter. The temperature rises from 21.0 °C to 27.8 °C. Assume the solution has density 1.00 g/mL and \(c = 4.18\) J g−1 °C−1. Find the heat of reaction per mole of water formed.
Mass of solution = 100.0 g. \(q_{\text{soln}} = (100.0)(4.18)(6.8) = 2842\) J, so \(q_{\text{rxn}} = -2842\) J = −2.84 kJ. Moles of water formed = 0.0500 mol (the limiting amount: 0.0500 mol each). Per mole: \(-2.842 / 0.0500 = \) −56.8 kJ/mol. The negative sign shows the reaction is exothermic, as the temperature rise suggested.
Worked example · direction of energy flow in dissolution
Dissolving 5.00 g of NH4NO3 (80.05 g/mol) in 100.0 g of water lowers the temperature from 22.0 °C to 19.2 °C. Is dissolving endothermic or exothermic, and what is the heat per mole? (Treat the solution mass as 105.0 g, \(c = 4.18\).)
The temperature fell, so energy was absorbed: endothermic. \(q_{\text{soln}} = (105.0)(4.18)(19.2 - 22.0) = -1229\) J, so the dissolution absorbed +1229 J. Moles: 5.00 / 80.05 = 0.06246 mol. Per mole: \(1.229/0.06246 = \) +19.7 kJ/mol.
Exam focus
Sign conventions: \(q \gt 0\) when a substance gains energy. For the reaction, \(q_{\text{rxn}} = -q_{\text{solution}}\).
\(\Delta T\) is final minus initial, and units of c must match the units of m and T.
Always say what is assumed: no heat lost to the surroundings (or the cup), solution has the density and c of water.
Equal masses, equal heat: the smaller c gives the larger temperature change.
Equilibrium means equal temperature, not equal energy.
Practice
How much heat is needed to warm 250. g of water from 18.0 °C to 42.0 °C?
Show answer
A 20.0 g metal sample at 90.0 °C is placed in 50.0 g of water at 20.0 °C. The final temperature is 24.0 °C. Find the specific heat of the metal.
Show answer
Heat gained by water: (50.0)(4.18)(4.0) = 836 J. Metal: \(c = 836/[(20.0)(66.0)] = 0.633\) J g−1 °C−1.
In a calorimeter, 100. g of solution warms by 3.5 °C when a reaction occurs. What is q for the reaction? Is it exothermic?
Show answer
Why are the final temperatures of a hot metal and cool water in a calorimeter the same, but their changes in thermal energy are not?
Show answer
At equilibrium both are at the same temperature (equal average kinetic energy). The energy changes are equal in size and opposite in sign, but the temperature changes differ because the masses and specific heats differ.
A student's measured heat of a reaction is lower than the accepted value. Give one source of error that could explain it.
Show answer
Some energy was lost to the cup, the thermometer or the air, so the measured temperature change was too small. The calorimeter was not perfectly insulated.
Put a pot of water on a stove and its temperature climbs until it boils. Then something odd happens: the burner keeps pouring in energy, but the temperature stays at 100 °C until the last drop has become steam.
Where does the energy go? It goes into pulling the molecules apart. This lesson explains that plateau and shows how to calculate the energy for melting, freezing, boiling and condensing, and for a whole journey from ice to steam.
Learning objective · 6.5.A
Explain changes in the heat q absorbed or released by a system undergoing a phase transition based on the amount of the substance in moles and the molar enthalpy of the phase transition.
Required content · EK 6.5.A.1 and 6.5.A.2
Energy must be transferred to a system to cause a substance to melt (or boil). The energy of the system therefore increases as the system undergoes a solid-to-liquid (or liquid-to-gas) phase transition. Likewise, a system releases energy when it freezes (or condenses). The energy of the system decreases as the system undergoes a liquid-to-solid (or gas-to-liquid) phase transition. The temperature of a pure substance remains constant during a phase change.
The energy absorbed during a phase change is equal to the energy released during a complementary phase change in the opposite direction. For example, the molar enthalpy of condensation of a substance is equal to the negative of its molar enthalpy of vaporization. Similarly, the molar enthalpy of fusion can be used to calculate the energy absorbed when melting a substance and the energy released when freezing a substance.
Why the temperature stays constant
Temperature tracks the average kinetic energy of particles. During a phase change the energy added does not speed the particles up; it works against the attractions between them (the intermolecular forces of Unit 3). Melting loosens the fixed positions of a solid, and boiling separates molecules entirely. Energy goes into potential energy, so the temperature stays constant while the two phases coexist at their transition temperature (a pure substance at a fixed pressure).
Figure 6.2a Heat added to 18.0 g (1 mol) of water at constant pressure. Temperature rises on the sloped segments (the energy goes into kinetic energy) and stays constant during melting and boiling (the energy goes into overcoming attractions). Boiling needs almost seven times as much energy as melting.
The heating curve above has five segments. On the three sloped segments the substance warms and \(q = mc\Delta T\) applies. On the two flat segments the substance changes phase at constant temperature and the energy is given by the molar enthalpy of the transition.
Notice that the boiling plateau is far longer than the melting plateau: vaporization separates molecules completely (all the attractions are overcome) while melting only loosens them.
Molar enthalpies of phase change
Phase-change energies are measured per mole and reported as molar enthalpy changes:
\[ q = n\,\Delta H_{\text{phase}} \]
The molar enthalpy of fusion \(\Delta H_{\text{fus}}\) is the energy to melt one mole at the melting point; the molar enthalpy of vaporization \(\Delta H_{\text{vap}}\) is the energy to vaporize one mole at the boiling point. Both are positive (endothermic). For water, \(\Delta H_{\text{fus}} = 6.01\) kJ/mol and \(\Delta H_{\text{vap}} = 40.7\) kJ/mol.
The reverse changes have the same size and the opposite sign: freezing \(= -\Delta H_{\text{fus}}\) (−6.01 kJ/mol) and condensation \(= -\Delta H_{\text{vap}}\) (−40.7 kJ/mol). This follows from conservation of energy: the energy you put in to separate the particles is the energy released when they come back together. That is why steam burns are so severe: condensing on skin releases 40.7 kJ per mole before the liquid even starts to cool.
Substance
ΔHfus (kJ/mol)
ΔHvap (kJ/mol)
Why
Water
6.01
40.7
strong hydrogen bonding
Ethanol
4.93
38.6
hydrogen bonding
Methane
0.94
8.2
only weak dispersion forces
Worked example · energy to melt ice
How much energy is needed to melt 50.0 g of ice at 0 °C?
Moles: \(50.0 / 18.02 = 2.775\) mol. \(q = (2.775)(6.01) = 16.7\) kJ absorbed. Throughout the melting the temperature stays at 0 °C.
Worked example · the full journey
How much energy is needed to turn 36.0 g of ice at −10.0 °C into steam at 110.0 °C? Use \(c_{\text{ice}} = 2.09\), \(c_{\text{water}} = 4.18\), \(c_{\text{steam}} = 2.01\) J g−1 °C−1.
Moles: 36.0 / 18.0 = 2.00 mol. Break the path into five steps and add them, all in kJ:
Warm the ice from −10 to 0 °C: \((36.0)(2.09)(10.0) = 752\) J = 0.752 kJ.
Melt: \((2.00)(6.01) = 12.02\) kJ.
Warm the liquid from 0 to 100 °C: \((36.0)(4.18)(100.0) = 15{,}048\) J = 15.05 kJ.
Vaporize: \((2.00)(40.7) = 81.4\) kJ.
Warm the steam from 100 to 110 °C: \((36.0)(2.01)(10.0) = 724\) J = 0.724 kJ.
Total: 0.752 + 12.02 + 15.05 + 81.4 + 0.724 = 109.9 kJ. Vaporization alone accounts for nearly three quarters of the total.
Worked example · condensation releases energy
How much energy is released when 9.00 g of steam condenses at 100 °C?
Using the right formula: if the temperature changes, use \(q = mc\Delta T\). If the substance changes phase at the transition temperature, use \(q = n\Delta H_{\text{phase}}\). A journey across a phase boundary needs both, step by step, never a single \(mc\Delta T\) across a boundary.
Exam focus
Explain the plateau: the added energy increases potential energy (overcoming attractions), not average kinetic energy, so the temperature is constant.
Pick the equation by what is happening: temperature change, \(mc\Delta T\); phase change, \(n\Delta H\).
Opposite processes have equal and opposite energies.
Convert grams to moles before using a molar enthalpy, and keep kJ and J consistent.
Compare substances by their forces: stronger attractions give larger ΔHvap.
Practice
How much energy is released when 100. g of liquid water freezes at 0 °C?
Show answer
Why does ΔHvap of water (40.7 kJ/mol) greatly exceed ΔHfus (6.01 kJ/mol)?
Show answer
Melting only loosens the hydrogen-bonded network; many bonds remain in the liquid. Vaporizing must separate the molecules entirely, overcoming essentially all the hydrogen bonds, so much more energy is required.
Methane has ΔHvap = 8.2 kJ/mol and water 40.7 kJ/mol. Which has the lower boiling point and why?
Show answer
Methane, because it has only weak dispersion forces between molecules, which are easy to overcome, as the small ΔHvap shows. Water has strong hydrogen bonds.
A student adds heat steadily to a pure ice-water mixture at 0 °C and reads the thermometer. What does it show, and what is the energy doing?
Show answer
It stays at 0 °C until all the ice has melted. The energy goes into overcoming the attractions that hold the solid together (potential energy), not into raising the average kinetic energy.
How much heat is needed to warm 18.0 g of liquid water from 25.0 °C to 100.0 °C and then vaporize it all?
Show answer
A gallon of gasoline holds roughly the energy that a person could generate by hard physical work in a year. A hand warmer gives off heat for hours from a small packet of iron powder. Chemical reactions are the world's main energy source, and chemists measure the energy in a single number: the enthalpy change of the reaction, written ΔH.
This lesson defines it, shows how it scales with the amount reacting, and uses it to predict how much heat a given quantity of reactant produces.
Learning objective · 6.6.A
Calculate the heat q absorbed or released by a system undergoing a chemical reaction in relationship to the amount of the reacting substance in moles and the molar enthalpy of reaction.
Required content · EK 6.6.A.1 to 6.6.A.3
The enthalpy change of a reaction gives the amount of heat energy released (for negative values) or absorbed (for positive values) by a chemical reaction at constant pressure.
When the products of a reaction are at a different temperature than their surroundings, they exchange energy with the surroundings to reach thermal equilibrium. Thermal energy is transferred to the surroundings as the reactants convert to products in an exothermic reaction. Thermal energy is transferred from the surroundings as the reactants convert to products in an endothermic reaction.
The chemical potential energy of the products of a reaction is different from that of the reactants because of the breaking and forming of bonds. The energy difference results in a change in the kinetic energy of the particles, which manifests as a temperature change.
Exclusion: the technical distinctions between enthalpy and internal energy are not assessed. Most reactions studied at the AP level are carried out at constant pressure, where the enthalpy change of the process is equal to the heat (and by extension, the energy) of reaction.
What ΔH means
The enthalpy change of a reaction, ΔH, is the heat absorbed or released when the reaction runs at constant pressure (open to the atmosphere, as most laboratory reactions are). Its sign tells the direction:
ΔH < 0: the products are lower in energy than the reactants; heat is released to the surroundings: exothermic.
ΔH > 0: the products are higher in energy; heat is absorbed from the surroundings: endothermic.
Why is energy released or absorbed? Chemical bonds store potential energy. Breaking old bonds raises the potential energy of the particles; forming new bonds lowers it. The difference between the two appears as heat: if the products have lower potential energy, the extra energy becomes kinetic energy of the particles, so the temperature of the mixture rises and heat flows to the cooler surroundings until thermal equilibrium is reached.
Thermochemical equations
A thermochemical equation is a balanced equation with the ΔH written beside it:
\[ \text{CH}_4(g) + 2\,\text{O}_2(g) \rightarrow \text{CO}_2(g) + 2\,\text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \qquad \Delta H = -890.3\ \text{kJ} \]
The number is for the reaction as written: when 1 mol CH4 reacts with 2 mol O2, 890.3 kJ is released. Three consequences:
ΔH scales with the amount. Doubling all the coefficients doubles ΔH; half the coefficients give half the ΔH. The energy released is proportional to the moles that react.
Reversing a reaction reverses the sign. CO2 + 2 H2O(l) → CH4 + 2 O2 has ΔH = +890.3 kJ.
The states matter. If the water is produced as a gas, ΔH is −802 kJ, because 88 kJ more is needed for 2 mol of liquid to become vapor (2 × 44.0 kJ/mol at 25 °C). The states (s, l, g, aq) must be given.
Worked example · heat from a mass of fuel
How much heat is released when 10.0 g of methane burns completely? (CH4 = 16.04 g/mol; ΔH = −890.3 kJ per mole of CH4.)
Moles: 10.0 / 16.04 = 0.6234 mol. Heat: \(q = (0.6234)(-890.3) = -555\) kJ, so 555 kJ of heat is released. The negative sign shows the system (the reaction) lost the energy.
Worked example · using the coefficients
2 H2(g) + O2(g) → 2 H2O(l), ΔH = −571.6 kJ. How much energy is released when 4.00 g of H2 (2.016 g/mol) reacts with excess oxygen?
Moles of H2 = 4.00 / 2.016 = 1.984 mol. The equation releases 571.6 kJ per 2 mol H2, so \(q = (1.984)(571.6/2) = 567\) kJ released. Per gram, hydrogen releases 142 kJ, more than twice as much as methane (55.5 kJ/g), which is why it is attractive as a fuel.
Worked example · limiting reactant
For N2(g) + 3 H2(g) → 2 NH3(g), ΔH = −92.2 kJ. How much heat is released when 2.00 mol N2 reacts with 3.00 mol H2?
The limiting reactant is H2: 3.00 mol H2 needs only 1.00 mol N2. The equation (3 mol H2) releases 92.2 kJ, so 92.2 kJ is released. Extra N2 does not release more energy because it has nothing to react with.
Worked example · from a calorimeter to ΔH
The reaction of 0.0250 mol of a solid with water in a calorimeter raises 100.0 g of water by 2.50 °C. Find ΔH per mole of solid.
\(q_{\text{water}} = (100.0)(4.18)(2.50) = 1045\) J, so \(q_{\text{rxn}} = -1045\) J. Per mole: \(-1.045\ \text{kJ}/0.0250\ \text{mol} = -41.8\) kJ/mol. (The calorimetry of lesson 6.2 is how most ΔH values are measured.)
Seeing the surroundings
In an exothermic reaction the thermometer in the mixture rises; heat then flows to the cooler surroundings until the mixture and the surroundings reach the same temperature. In an endothermic reaction the mixture cools below the surroundings and energy flows in. The enthalpy change describes the energy exchanged after the products are returned to the starting temperature. This is how heat-pack and cold-pack chemistry is designed: iron rusting in a hand warmer (exothermic) or ammonium nitrate dissolving in a cold pack (endothermic).
Exam focus
ΔH is per mole of reaction as written. Use the coefficients as the conversion factor.
Signs: negative for exothermic, positive for endothermic. “Heat released is 555 kJ” and “q = −555 kJ” mean the same thing.
Reverse the equation, reverse the sign; multiply the equation, multiply ΔH.
Limiting reactant first, then energy.
Give the states in thermochemical equations.
Practice
C3H8(g) + 5 O2(g) → 3 CO2(g) + 4 H2O(l), ΔH = −2220 kJ. How much heat is released by 11.0 g of propane (44.10 g/mol)?
Show answer
If ΔH = −92.2 kJ for N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3, what is ΔH for 2 NH3 → N2 + 3 H2, and for 4 NH3 → 2 N2 + 6 H2?
Show answer
Reverse: +92.2 kJ. The 4 NH3 equation is the reverse doubled: +184.4 kJ.
An endothermic reaction has ΔH = +58 kJ. How much heat is absorbed when 0.50 mol of the equation-as-written (per mole of reaction) occurs?
Show answer
Half the reaction as written: 0.50 × 58 = +29 kJ absorbed.
Explain at the particle level why an exothermic reaction heats its surroundings.
Show answer
The bonds formed in the products are stronger overall than the bonds broken, so the potential energy of the particles decreases. The lost potential energy becomes kinetic energy, raising the temperature of the mixture, which then transfers energy as heat to the cooler surroundings.
Burning 1.00 mol of methane gives −890.3 kJ when water is liquid and −802 kJ when it is gas. Explain the difference.
Show answer
Producing liquid water releases extra energy (condensation of 2 mol of vapor releases about 88 kJ). So the liquid-product reaction is more exothermic by that amount.
A student calculates the heat from 5.0 g of a fuel but forgets to convert grams to moles. Which quantity in the answer will be wrong, and by what factor?
Show answer
The heat will be wrong by a factor of the molar mass: ΔH is per mole, so using grams (5.0) instead of moles (5.0 / M) overstates or understates the answer by M.
Why does burning methane release heat while forming ozone from oxygen needs energy? The answer is in the bonds. Every reaction breaks some bonds and forms others, and if you know how much energy each kind of bond holds you can estimate the energy change of a reaction before running it.
This lesson gives you that bookkeeping method and shows both how useful and how approximate it is.
Learning objective · 6.7.A
Calculate the enthalpy change of a reaction based on the average bond energies of bonds broken and formed in the reaction.
Required content · EK 6.7.A.1 and 6.7.A.2
During a chemical reaction, bonds are broken and/or formed, and these events change the potential energy of the system.
The average energy required to break all of the bonds in the reactant molecules can be estimated by adding up the average bond energies of all the bonds in the reactant molecules. Likewise, the average energy released in forming the bonds in the product molecules can be estimated. If the energy released is greater than the energy required, the reaction is exothermic. If the energy required is greater than the energy released, the reaction is endothermic.
Bond enthalpy
The bond enthalpy (or bond energy) is the energy needed to break one mole of a particular bond in the gas phase. Because breaking a bond always requires energy, bond enthalpies are positive; forming the same bond releases exactly that much energy. Stronger bonds (higher values) hold atoms more tightly. Values are averages over many molecules, because the same type of bond (such as C–H) has slightly different strength in different compounds.
Bond
kJ/mol
Bond
kJ/mol
Bond
kJ/mol
H–H
436
C–C
347
N≡N
945
C–H
413
C=C
614
N–H
391
O–H
463
C≡C
839
Cl–Cl
242
O=O
498
C–O
358
H–Cl
431
C=O (in CO2)
799
C=O (other)
745
H–Br
366
Trends from the table: for the same two atoms, a multiple bond is stronger than a single bond (C–C 347, C=C 614, C≡C 839), and N≡N at 945 kJ/mol is why nitrogen gas is so unreactive. This links to Unit 2: more shared electron pairs means a higher bond order, a shorter bond and a higher bond enthalpy.
The bookkeeping method
Imagine every reactant molecule being pulled completely apart into separate gaseous atoms, and then the atoms assembling into the product molecules. Energy is absorbed to break bonds and released when bonds form:
\[ \Delta H \approx \sum(\text{bond enthalpies of bonds broken}) - \sum(\text{bond enthalpies of bonds formed}) \]
Written as “energy in minus energy out.” If more energy is released in forming the product bonds than was needed to break the reactant bonds, ΔH is negative: exothermic. If more energy is needed to break the bonds, ΔH is positive: endothermic.
Figure 6.5a Bond-enthalpy bookkeeping for CH4 + 2 O2 → CO2 + 2 H2O(g). Breaking bonds takes energy; forming bonds releases energy. More energy is released than was needed, so the reaction is exothermic.
Procedure
Draw the Lewis structures so that every bond in every molecule can be counted.
List every bond in the reactants (multiply by the coefficient) and add their enthalpies: that is the energy absorbed.
List every bond in the products (with coefficients) and add: that is the energy released.
Bonds broken: 4 C–H (4 × 413 = 1652) and 2 O=O (2 × 498 = 996): total 2648 kJ. Bonds formed: 2 C=O in CO2 (2 × 799 = 1598) and 4 O–H (4 × 463 = 1852): total 3450 kJ. \(\Delta H = 2648 - 3450 = \) −802 kJ. The experimental value for gaseous water is −802 kJ, in this case in excellent agreement.
Worked example · hydrogen chloride
Estimate ΔH for H2(g) + Cl2(g) → 2 HCl(g).
Broken: H–H (436) + Cl–Cl (242) = 678 kJ. Formed: 2 H–Cl = 2 × 431 = 862 kJ. \(\Delta H = 678 - 862 = \) −184 kJ. Exothermic, because the two H–Cl bonds are stronger in total than the two bonds broken.
Worked example · ammonia synthesis
Estimate ΔH for N2(g) + 3 H2(g) → 2 NH3(g).
Broken: N≡N (945) + 3 H–H (3 × 436 = 1308) = 2253 kJ. Formed: 6 N–H (6 × 391 = 2346) kJ. \(\Delta H = 2253 - 2346 = \) −93 kJ, close to the measured −92.2 kJ.
Worked example · a reaction where only some bonds change
Estimate ΔH for C2H4 + H2 → C2H6 (hydrogenation of ethene).
Only the C=C double bond and the H–H bond are broken and only a C–C single bond and two new C–H bonds are formed (the other C–H bonds are unchanged and may be ignored). Broken: C=C (614) + H–H (436) = 1050. Formed: C–C (347) + 2 C–H (826) = 1173. \(\Delta H = 1050 - 1173 = \) −123 kJ.
Limits of the method
Bond enthalpies are averages, so answers are estimates, typically within 5 to 10 percent.
They apply to gas-phase molecules. Energies of condensing or dissolving are not included, so the method will not give the −890.3 kJ for liquid water.
The method says nothing about the speed of the reaction (activation energy).
A quick qualitative judgment is also possible: if the product bonds are stronger than the reactant bonds in total, the reaction is exothermic. That explains why reactions that form very strong bonds, such as C=O in CO2 or the O–H bonds in water, release large amounts of energy.
Exam focus
Broken minus formed. Energy in is positive, energy out is negative; ΔH = Σ(broken) − Σ(formed).
Count every bond, using the coefficient and the Lewis structure (multiple bonds count once with their own enthalpy).
Say “estimate”: bond enthalpies are averages for the gas phase.
Link bond strength to the sign: stronger bonds formed than broken means exothermic.
Check units (kJ per mole of reaction as written).
Practice
Estimate ΔH for 2 H2 + O2 → 2 H2O(g) using H–H 436, O=O 498, O–H 463.
Show answer
Without calculating, decide whether the reaction N2 → 2 N is endothermic or exothermic and give its enthalpy.
Show answer
It only breaks a bond, so it is endothermic. ΔH = +945 kJ per mole of N2 (the N≡N bond enthalpy).
C2H4 + H2 → C2H6 was estimated as −123 kJ. What do the signs and the bond data tell you about the strengths of the bonds formed and broken?
Show answer
The energy released on forming a C–C bond and two C–H bonds (1173 kJ) exceeds the energy needed to break C=C and H–H (1050 kJ), so the products have stronger total bonding and the reaction is exothermic.
Why does the bond-enthalpy method give only an approximate answer?
Show answer
Bond enthalpies are averages over many molecules, not exact values for the molecules in question, and the method assumes all species are gases, so it neglects the energy of phase changes.
The N≡N bond enthalpy is 945 kJ/mol and the Cl–Cl bond is 242 kJ/mol. Which molecule is more reactive, in general, and why?
Show answer
Cl2 is more reactive: its bond is much easier to break. The very strong triple bond makes N2 unreactive, because a lot of energy is needed to break it (as well as a high activation energy).
There are millions of possible reactions and no one could measure the heat of every one. Fortunately we do not have to. If we measure, once, the energy to make each compound from its elements, we can calculate the enthalpy change of any reaction from those few numbers, the way a map with a single sea-level reference lets you work out the height difference between any two hills.
This lesson introduces the standard enthalpy of formation and the equation that does it.
Learning objective · 6.8.A
Calculate the enthalpy change for a chemical or physical process based on the standard enthalpies of formation.
Required content · EK 6.8.A.1
Tables of standard enthalpies of formation can be used to calculate the standard enthalpies of reactions. \(\Delta H^\circ_{\text{reaction}} = \sum \Delta H^\circ_f(\text{products}) - \sum \Delta H^\circ_f(\text{reactants})\)
Standard enthalpy of formation
The standard enthalpy of formation, \(\Delta H^\circ_f\), of a compound is the enthalpy change when one mole of the compound forms from its elements in their standard states (the most stable form at 1 bar and, usually, 25 °C). The superscript ° means standard conditions.
For example, the formation reaction of carbon dioxide and of liquid water are
Notice the pattern: exactly one mole of the compound on the right, only elements on the left, and fractional coefficients are allowed to make that so.
The \(\Delta H^\circ_f\) of an element in its standard state is zero by definition: O2(g), H2(g), N2(g), C(graphite), Fe(s), Br2(l), Na(s). (Forming an element from itself takes no energy.) A different form, such as diamond or O3, has a nonzero value.
Negative values (like CO2) are exothermic formations: such compounds are energetically stable relative to their elements. Positive values (like NO, +90.3) mean energy is needed to form the compound.
The physical state matters: H2O(l) is −285.8 but H2O(g) is −241.8 kJ/mol.
Substance
ΔH°f (kJ/mol)
Substance
ΔH°f (kJ/mol)
CO2(g)
−393.5
CH4(g)
−74.8
H2O(l)
−285.8
C3H8(g)
−103.8
H2O(g)
−241.8
NO(g)
+90.3
Fe2O3(s)
−824.2
NO2(g)
+33.2
Al2O3(s)
−1675.7
O2(g), C(graphite)
0
Calculating the enthalpy of a reaction
Any reaction can be imagined as the reactants breaking down into their elements and the elements recombining into the products. The first path costs the reverse of the reactants' formation; the second costs the formation of the products. Adding the two paths gives
\[ \Delta H^\circ_{\text{rxn}} = \sum n\,\Delta H^\circ_f(\text{products}) - \sum n\,\Delta H^\circ_f(\text{reactants}) \]
where \(n\) is the coefficient in the balanced equation. Always products minus reactants, and always multiply each value by its coefficient.
Figure 6.6a Standard enthalpies of formation put every substance on one scale, with elements in their standard states at zero. The reaction enthalpy is the difference between the product level and the reactant level.
Products: (−393.5) + 2(−285.8) = −965.1 kJ. Reactants: (−74.8) + 2(0) = −74.8 kJ. \(\Delta H^\circ = -965.1 - (-74.8) = \) −890.3 kJ. O2 contributes zero because it is an element in its standard state.
Products: −1675.7 + 2(0). Reactants: −824.2 + 2(0). \(\Delta H^\circ = -1675.7 - (-824.2) = \) −851.5 kJ. The reaction is so exothermic that the iron produced is molten.
Worked example · a reaction with positive formation enthalpies
Why is ΔH°f of Br2(l) zero but that of Br2(g) is +30.9 kJ/mol?
Show answer
Liquid bromine is the standard (most stable) state of bromine at 25 °C and 1 bar, so its formation enthalpy is zero by definition. Forming the gas from the liquid requires energy (vaporization), giving a positive value.
A student uses ΔH°f of H2O(g) in a combustion in which liquid water forms. What mistake has been made and what is its effect?
Show answer
The wrong state was used. The gas has a less negative formation enthalpy, so the calculated heat released will be too small by the enthalpy of vaporization of the water formed.
Burning carbon to carbon monoxide is a messy reaction: it always overshoots to carbon dioxide, so nobody can measure its heat directly. Yet its enthalpy is known to three digits. How? By adding together the enthalpies of reactions that can be measured.
That is Hess’s law, the idea that an enthalpy change does not care which path you took, only where you started and finished. It is the tool behind the formation-enthalpy equation of the last lesson.
Learning objectives · 6.9.A and 6.9.B
6.9.A Represent a chemical or physical process as a sequence of steps. 6.9.B Explain the relationship between the enthalpy of a chemical or physical process and the sum of the enthalpies of the individual steps.
Required content · EK 6.9.A.1, 6.9.B.1 and 6.9.B.2
Many processes can be broken down into a series of steps. Each step in the series has its own energy change.
Because total energy is conserved (first law of thermodynamics), and each individual reaction in a sequence transfers thermal energy to or from the surroundings, the net thermal energy transferred in the sequence will be equal to the sum of the thermal energy transfers in each of the steps. These thermal energy transfers are the result of potential energy changes among the species in the reaction sequence; thus, at constant pressure, the enthalpy change of the overall process is equal to the sum of the enthalpy changes of the individual steps.
The following are essential principles of Hess’s law: (i) When a reaction is reversed, the enthalpy change stays constant in magnitude but becomes reversed in mathematical sign. (ii) When a reaction is multiplied by a factor c, the enthalpy change is multiplied by the same factor c. (iii) When two (or more) reactions are added to obtain an overall reaction, the individual enthalpy changes of each reaction are added to obtain the net enthalpy change of the overall reaction.
Exclusion: the concept of state functions is not assessed.
Why steps add
Suppose a reaction can go from reactants to products in one step or in several. Energy is conserved, so the net energy released to the surroundings cannot depend on the route; otherwise you could go round a cycle and gain energy for free. Therefore the total enthalpy change is the sum of the enthalpy changes of the steps.
Figure 6.7a Hess's law. Whether carbon burns to CO2 in one step or in two (first to CO, then to CO2), the total enthalpy change is the same, because energy is conserved. The enthalpy changes of the steps add up to the overall value.
Carbon burns to CO2 directly (ΔH = −393.5 kJ), or it can burn first to CO (−110.5 kJ) and then CO burns to CO2 (−283.0 kJ). The two routes agree: −110.5 + (−283.0) = −393.5 kJ.
The three rules
If you…
then ΔH…
Example
reverse the reaction
changes sign
H2O(l) → H2 + ½ O2 has ΔH = +285.8 kJ
multiply the coefficients by c
is multiplied by c
2 H2 + O2 → 2 H2O has ΔH = 2(−285.8) = −571.6 kJ
add reactions
values are added
the carbon example above
Procedure for a Hess's law problem
Write the target equation.
For each given equation, decide whether to reverse it and what to multiply it by so that each reactant and product of the target appears on the correct side in the correct amount. Start with a species that appears in only one given equation.
Adjust the ΔH of each equation to match (change sign when reversing, multiply when scaling).
Add the adjusted equations; species that appear on both sides (intermediates) must cancel exactly, leaving the target.
C2H4 is a reactant in the target and in (1): keep (1) as written. C2H6 is a product in the target but a reactant in (2): reverse (2) to get 2 CO2 + 3 H2O → C2H6 + 7/2 O2, ΔH = +1560 kJ. H2 is a reactant in (3): keep (3). Add the three, and the CO2, O2 and H2O cancel (checked below), leaving the target. \(\Delta H = -1411 + 1560 + (-286) = \) −137 kJ.
Check the cancellation: left side total: C2H4 + 3 O2 + 2 CO2 + 3 H2O + H2 + ½ O2. Right side total: 2 CO2 + 2 H2O + C2H6 + 7/2 O2 + H2O. Cancel 2 CO2, 3 H2O (both sides), and 7/2 O2 (both sides): C2H4 + H2 → C2H6. ✓
C2H2 is a product in the target, so reverse (1): +1300 kJ. The target has 2 C, so multiply (2) by 2: −787.0 kJ. Keep (3): −285.8 kJ. \(\Delta H = +1300 - 787.0 - 285.8 = \) +227.2 kJ. The formation of acetylene is endothermic.
Worked example · a diagram problem
An energy diagram shows A at 0 kJ, B at +120 kJ, and C at −60 kJ, with A → B → C as two steps. Find ΔH for each step and for A → C.
A → B: +120 − 0 = +120 kJ (endothermic). B → C: −60 − 120 = −180 kJ (exothermic). Overall A → C: −60 − 0 = −60 kJ, equal to +120 + (−180). ✓
Connection to the last lesson. The formation-enthalpy equation is Hess’s law applied to one particular set of steps: break the reactants into their elements, then form the products from the elements. The reaction route through the elements always works because each formation reaction is a measurable step.
Exam focus
Reverse changes the sign; multiply scales ΔH; add the values.
Check that intermediates cancel and that the sum is exactly the target equation, states included.
Work from species that appear in only one given equation to decide the direction.
Justify with conservation of energy: the total energy transfer is independent of the route.
A change of state is a step too (e.g., H2O(l) → H2O(g), +44.0 kJ/mol) and may be needed to reconcile equations.
Practice
Given S(s) + O2 → SO2, ΔH = −296.8 kJ, and 2 SO3 → 2 SO2 + O2, ΔH = +197.8 kJ, find ΔH for 2 S(s) + 3 O2 → 2 SO3.
Show answer
Double the first: 2 S + 2 O2 → 2 SO2, −593.6 kJ. Reverse the second: 2 SO2 + O2 → 2 SO3, −197.8 kJ. Sum: −791.4 kJ.
Given N2 + O2 → 2 NO, ΔH = +180.6 kJ, and 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2, ΔH = −114.2 kJ, find ΔH for N2 + 2 O2 → 2 NO2.
Show answer
Add the two as written (NO cancels): +180.6 + (−114.2) = +66.4 kJ.
If ΔH for C(graphite) + O2 → CO2 is −393.5 kJ and for C(diamond) + O2 → CO2 is −395.4 kJ, find ΔH for C(graphite) → C(diamond).
Show answer
Keep the graphite equation and reverse the diamond equation: −393.5 + 395.4 = +1.9 kJ. Graphite is slightly more stable.
Why must the intermediates cancel when equations are added?
Show answer
A species that appears on both sides is formed in one step and consumed in another, so it is not part of the overall reaction. The sum equals the target only if these species cancel completely.
A student reverses an equation but forgets to change the sign of ΔH. How is the final answer affected?
Show answer
The final ΔH will be wrong by twice the value of that equation's ΔH, because +x was needed and −x was used (or the reverse).
Explain why Hess’s law follows from conservation of energy.
Show answer
The net energy transferred as heat at constant pressure is determined by the difference in energy between the starting and ending states. If two routes between the same states gave different values, energy could be created by going around a loop, which would violate the first law.
Unit 6 practice · 10 problems
Unit 6 practice: Thermochemistry
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed; \(c_{\text{water}} = 4.18\) J/(g·°C),
and for water \(\Delta H_{\text{fus}} = 6.01\) kJ/mol, \(\Delta H_{\text{vap}} = 40.7\) kJ/mol.
An ice cube melts in your hand. Taking the ice as the system, give the sign of \(q\) and \(\Delta H\), classify the process, and say where the products sit on an energy diagram. Explain at the particle level why your hand feels cold.
Show answer
The ice absorbs heat: \(q \gt 0\), \(\Delta H \gt 0\), endothermic; liquid water sits above ice on the diagram. Fast-moving particles in your skin collide with the slower water molecules in the ice and transfer kinetic energy to them; that energy goes into pulling molecules apart against their hydrogen bonds. Your skin's particles are left with less kinetic energy, a lower temperature, so it feels cold.
How much heat is needed to warm 250.0 g of water from 20.0 °C to 85.0 °C?
Show answer
\(q = mc\,\Delta T = (250.0\ \mathrm{g})(4.18\ \mathrm{J/(g·°C)})(65.0\ \mathrm{°C}) = 6.79 \times 10^{4}\ \mathrm{J} = 67.9\) kJ. Positive: heat flows into the water.
A 75.0 g metal sample at 95.0 °C is placed in 150.0 g of water at 20.0 °C. The final temperature is 24.0 °C. Find the specific heat of the metal.
Show answer
Water gains \(q = (150.0)(4.18)(4.0) = 2508\) J, so the metal loses 2508 J: \(q_{\text{metal}} = -2508\) J with \(\Delta T = 24.0 - 95.0 = -71.0\) °C. \(c = \dfrac{-2508}{(75.0)(-71.0)} = 0.47\) J/(g·°C). The two negatives cancel; a negative result means a sign slipped. (Two sig figs, from the 4.0 °C rise.)
5.00 g of NH4NO3 (80.05 g/mol) dissolves in 100.0 g of water in a coffee-cup calorimeter. The temperature drops from 22.00 °C to 18.35 °C. Assuming the solution has the specific heat of water, find \(\Delta H\) of solution in kJ/mol.
Show answer
Solution mass 105.0 g. \(q_{\text{soln}} = (105.0)(4.18)(18.35 - 22.00) = -1602\) J, so \(q_{\text{dissolving}} = +1602\) J. Moles: \(5.00/80.05 = 0.0625\) mol. \(\Delta H = \dfrac{1602\ \mathrm{J}}{0.0625\ \mathrm{mol}} = +2.56 \times 10^{4}\ \mathrm{J/mol} = +25.6\) kJ/mol. Endothermic: the accepted value is +25.7 kJ/mol.
How much heat is required to convert 25.0 g of liquid water at 25.0 °C to steam at 100.0 °C?
Show answer
Warm the liquid: \((25.0)(4.18)(75.0) = 7838\ \mathrm{J} = 7.84\) kJ. Vaporize: \(n = 25.0/18.02 = 1.387\) mol; \((1.387)(40.7) = 56.5\) kJ. Total \(= 7.84 + 56.5 = 64.3\) kJ. Boiling takes more than seven times the energy of the 75-degree warm-up, and \(\Delta H_{\text{vap}}\) is per mole, so convert the grams first.
While water boils at 100 °C, its temperature does not rise even though heat is added steadily. This is because
The water absorbs heat the whole time: that is what drives the boiling, at 40.7 kJ per mole vaporized. The energy is going somewhere; it just isn't showing up as a temperature rise.
Temperature measures average kinetic energy. During a phase change the incoming heat does the work of pulling molecules out of the liquid's hydrogen-bonded network, increasing their potential energy; average kinetic energy, and therefore temperature, stays fixed until the change is complete.
Molecules at 100 °C are moving vigorously, and the escaping vapor molecules have the same average kinetic energy as the liquid ones. Motion never stops above absolute zero; it is the average kinetic energy that stays constant.
Specific heat is a property of a single phase and does not vanish; rather, \(q = mc\Delta T\) simply doesn't apply during a phase change, where the relevant relation is \(q = n\Delta H_{\text{vap}}\). Using the wrong equation is the error, not a constant dropping to zero.
Using average bond enthalpies (H–H 436, O=O 495, O–H 467 kJ/mol), estimate \(\Delta H\) for 2 H2(g) + O2(g) → 2 H2O(g). How much heat is released when 0.500 mol of O2 reacts?
Show answer
Broken: 2 H–H + 1 O=O \(= 2(436) + 495 = 1367\) kJ. Formed: 4 O–H \(= 4(467) = 1868\) kJ. \(\Delta H \approx 1367 - 1868 = -501\) kJ for the reaction as written (accepted −484 kJ; averages are approximate). Exothermic because the bonds formed are stronger in total. For 0.500 mol O2, half the reaction, \(0.500 \times 501 = 251\) kJ released, about 250 kJ.
Using \(\Delta H^\circ_f\) values CH4(g) −74.8, CO2(g) −393.5, and H2O(l) −285.8 kJ/mol, find \(\Delta H^\circ\) for CH4(g) + 2 O2(g) → CO2(g) + 2 H2O(l). Why is this more negative than the bond-enthalpy estimate of −802 kJ (for gaseous water) from Lesson 6.5?
Show answer
\(\Delta H^\circ = [(-393.5) + 2(-285.8)] - [(-74.8) + 2(0)] = -965.1 + 74.8 = -890.3\) kJ/mol. O2 is an element in its standard state, so its \(\Delta H^\circ_f = 0\). It is more negative partly because here the water is liquid: condensing 2 mol of water vapor releases an additional \(2 \times 44 = 88\) kJ, and the bond-enthalpy method is only an estimate from averages.
Given (1) 2 C(s) + O2(g) → 2 CO(g), \(\Delta H^\circ = -221.0\) kJ, and (2) C(s) + O2(g) → CO2(g), \(\Delta H^\circ = -393.5\) kJ, use Hess's law to find \(\Delta H^\circ\) for 2 CO(g) + O2(g) → 2 CO2(g).
Show answer
The target has 2 CO as a reactant, so reverse (1): 2 CO → 2 C + O2, \(+221.0\) kJ. It has 2 CO2 as product, so double (2): 2 C + 2 O2 → 2 CO2, \(2(-393.5) = -787.0\) kJ. Add: the 2 C cancel and one O2 cancels, leaving 2 CO + O2 → 2 CO2 with \(\Delta H^\circ = 221.0 - 787.0 = -566.0\) kJ. (Check with formation enthalpies: \(2(-393.5) - 2(-110.5) = -566.0\). ✓)
2 H2O2(l) → 2 H2O(l) + O2(g) has \(\Delta H = -196\) kJ. Is the decomposition endothermic or exothermic? How much heat is released when 10.0 g of hydrogen peroxide (34.02 g/mol) decomposes?
Show answer
Negative \(\Delta H\): exothermic. \(10.0/34.02 = 0.294\) mol H2O2. The equation releases 196 kJ per 2 mol, i.e. 98 kJ per mole: \(0.294 \times 98.0 = 28.8\) kJ released. \(\Delta H\) is extensive: always ask "per mole of what?"
Pour water into a sealed bottle and leave it. For a while the water level falls as molecules escape to the air, then it stops changing. The bottle looks perfectly still, yet molecules are leaving the liquid and returning to it by the billion every second.
That busy stillness is chemical equilibrium. Nearly everything in the rest of this course, from acids and bases to buffers and solubility, rests on the idea in this lesson.
Learning objectives · 7.1.A, 7.2.A and 7.8.A
7.1.A Explain the relationship between the occurrence of a reversible chemical or physical process, and the establishment of equilibrium, to experimental observations. 7.2.A Explain the relationship between the direction in which a reversible reaction proceeds and the relative rates of the forward and reverse reactions. 7.8.A Represent a system undergoing a reversible reaction with a particulate model.
Required content · EK 7.1.A.1 to 7.1.A.4, 7.2.A.1 and 7.8.A.1
Many observable processes are reversible. Examples include evaporation and condensation of water, absorption and desorption of a gas, or dissolution and precipitation of a salt. Some important reversible chemical processes include the transfer of protons in acid-base reactions and the transfer of electrons in redox reactions.
When equilibrium is reached, no observable changes occur in the system. Reactants and products are simultaneously present, and the concentrations or partial pressures of all species remain constant.
The equilibrium state is dynamic. The forward and reverse processes continue to occur at equal rates, resulting in no net observable change.
Graphs of concentration, partial pressure, or rate of reaction versus time for simple chemical reactions can be used to understand the establishment of chemical equilibrium.
If the rate of the forward reaction is greater than the reverse reaction, then there is a net conversion of reactants to products. If the rate of the reverse reaction is greater than that of the forward reaction, then there is a net conversion of products to reactants. An equilibrium state is reached when these rates are equal.
Particulate representations can be used to describe the relative numbers of reactant and product particles present prior to and at equilibrium, and the value of the equilibrium constant.
Reversible processes
So far most reactions in this course were written with a single arrow, as if they ran to completion. Many do not. A reversible process can run in both directions, and the double arrow \(\rightleftharpoons\) shows it. Familiar examples:
Evaporation and condensation of water in a closed container: H2O(l) ⇌ H2O(g).
Dissolving and precipitating a salt: AgCl(s) ⇌ Ag+(aq) + Cl−(aq).
Absorption and release of a gas such as CO2 in a soda: CO2(g) ⇌ CO2(aq).
Proton transfer in an acid-base reaction: CH3COOH + H2O ⇌ CH3COO− + H3O+.
Chemical reactions such as the colorless-brown change N2O4(g) ⇌ 2 NO2(g).
How equilibrium is established
Take the simple reversible reaction A ⇌ B and start with only A. At the beginning the forward reaction (A → B) proceeds at its highest rate, since [A] is largest, and the reverse reaction is zero since there is no B. As B accumulates the reverse rate rises; as A is used up the forward rate falls. Eventually the two rates become equal.
Figure 7.1a Approach to equilibrium for A ⇌ B starting from pure A. Left: the concentrations change, then stay constant. Right: the forward rate falls, the reverse rate rises, and equilibrium begins when the two rates are equal. After that point nothing changes macroscopically, but both reactions continue.
From that moment the net change is zero: forward rate = reverse rate. Every A that becomes B is matched by a B that becomes A, so the concentrations (or partial pressures, for gases) stay constant. This is dynamic equilibrium. Four things are true at equilibrium:
The forward and reverse rates are equal (not the concentrations).
The concentrations of all the species are constant, but not necessarily equal to each other.
Reactants and products are both present.
The system must be closed (nothing enters or leaves), and the same equilibrium can be reached from either direction, starting with reactants only, products only, or any mixture.
Equilibrium is not a sign that the reaction has stopped or that half the material has reacted. A reaction can reach equilibrium with almost all reactants (the reaction barely goes) or almost all products (it goes nearly to completion). How far it goes is measured by the equilibrium constant, the topic of the next lesson.
Worked example · reading the graphs
A student follows A ⇌ B and obtains these data: [A] = 1.00, 0.70, 0.52, 0.42, 0.40, 0.40 M and [B] = 0.00, 0.30, 0.48, 0.58, 0.60, 0.60 M at times 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 min. When is the system at equilibrium, and what does that tell you about the rates?
The concentrations stop changing at about 4 min (0.40 M and 0.60 M at 4 and 5 min). At that point the forward rate equals the reverse rate. Before that, [A] was falling and [B] rising, so the forward rate exceeded the reverse rate (net conversion of A to B). The total \([A] + [B] = 1.00\) M is conserved at all times, as the balanced equation requires.
Worked example · from the other side
Another flask begins with 1.00 M B and no A. What are the concentrations at equilibrium, and which reaction is faster at first?
The same equilibrium is reached: [A] = 0.40 M and [B] = 0.60 M, since the temperature and total amount are the same as before. At first only the reverse reaction (B → A) occurs, so the reverse rate is greater than the forward rate until the two become equal.
Particle representations
Particle pictures show the same ideas. In a particulate drawing of A ⇌ B, the numbers of A and B particles change during the approach to equilibrium and then stay the same; at equilibrium two drawings taken at different times show identical numbers of each kind of particle even though individual particles are switching between A and B.
Figure 7.1b A particulate view of A ⇌ B. The numbers of A and B particles stop changing at equilibrium (here 3 A and 7 B, so K = [B]/[A] = 7/3 ≈ 2.3 in a fixed volume), but individual particles keep converting back and forth.
A particle drawing also lets you read the value of the equilibrium constant. For A ⇌ B in a fixed volume, the ratio of particle counts equals the ratio of concentrations, so with 3 A and 7 B at equilibrium \(K = [\text{B}]/[\text{A}] = 7/3\). More B than A means K greater than 1, and more A than B means K less than 1. For particle drawings, remember that a drawing is at equilibrium only if the numbers match between successive frames.
Worked example · is this drawing at equilibrium?
Three drawings of 2 NO2 ⇌ N2O4 at 10 s, 20 s and 30 s show 6 NO2 and 3 N2O4; 4 NO2 and 4 N2O4; and 4 NO2 and 4 N2O4. When was equilibrium established?
The composition changed between 10 s and 20 s (6 → 4 NO2), so the system was not yet at equilibrium at 10 s. It is unchanged between 20 s and 30 s, so equilibrium is reached by 20 s. (Conservation check: the count of NO2 units is 6 + 2(3) = 12 in the first drawing and 4 + 2(4) = 12 in the others, so the amount of nitrogen is unchanged.)
Exam focus
Say “rates are equal,” not “concentrations are equal.”
Equilibrium is dynamic: both reactions continue.
A graph of concentration against time becomes flat at equilibrium; a graph of rates shows the two curves meeting.
Direction from the rates: forward faster means net products; reverse faster means net reactants.
Particle drawings: equilibrium means no change in the numbers from one frame to the next.
Practice
In a sealed flask the brown color of N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 stops changing. A student says the reaction has stopped. Correct this.
Show answer
The reaction has not stopped. The forward and reverse reactions continue at equal rates, so there is no net change in concentration and the color stays constant: a dynamic equilibrium.
For A ⇌ B at some moment the forward rate is 4.0 M/min and the reverse rate is 1.5 M/min. Which way is the system moving?
Show answer
Toward products (B): the forward rate exceeds the reverse rate, giving a net conversion of A to B.
True or false: at equilibrium [reactants] = [products]. Explain.
Show answer
False. Concentrations are constant but need not be equal; only the rates of the forward and reverse reactions are equal.
A drawing of A ⇌ B shows 2 A and 8 B at equilibrium. Estimate K.
Show answer
\(K = [\text{B}]/[\text{A}] = 8/2 = 4\) (same volume, so the ratio of particle numbers equals the ratio of concentrations).
Why can equilibrium be reached starting from either reactants or products?
Show answer
Both the forward and reverse reactions occur, so whichever is initially faster brings the system to the point where the two rates are equal. The final composition depends on K and the total amount, not on the starting side.
Why must the system be closed for equilibrium to be established?
Show answer
If a product escaped (for example, a gas leaving an open container), the reverse reaction could never catch up with the forward reaction, so the forward and reverse rates would not become equal.
The reaction quotient and the equilibrium constant
Equilibrium looks different for every reaction, but the same simple equation describes them all. At a given temperature the ratio of product concentrations to reactant concentrations, each raised to the power of its coefficient, always settles at the same number, the equilibrium constant.
This lesson shows how to write that ratio, how to leave out solids and liquids, and how to find the number from experimental data.
Learning objectives · 7.3.A and 7.4.A
7.3.A Represent the reaction quotient \(Q_c\) or \(Q_p\), for a reversible reaction, and the corresponding equilibrium expressions \(K_c = Q_c\) or \(K_p = Q_p\). 7.4.A Calculate \(K_c\) or \(K_p\) based on experimental observations of concentrations or pressures at equilibrium.
Required content · EK 7.3.A.1, 7.3.A.2 and 7.4.A.1
The reaction quotient \(Q_c\) describes the relative concentrations of reaction species at any time. For gas phase reactions, the reaction quotient may instead be written in terms of partial pressures as \(Q_p\). The reaction quotient tends toward the equilibrium constant such that at equilibrium \(K_c = Q_c\) and \(K_p = Q_p\). For the reaction a A + b B ⇌ c C + d D, the law of mass action indicates that the equilibrium expression is \(K_c = \dfrac{[C]^c[D]^d}{[A]^a[B]^b}\) and \(K_p = \dfrac{(P_C)^c(P_D)^d}{(P_A)^a(P_B)^b}\).
Exclusions: conversion between \(K_c\) and \(K_p\) is not assessed (be aware of the difference and of which is used in a question), nor are equilibrium calculations on systems where a dissolved species is in equilibrium with that species in the gas phase.
The reaction quotient does not include substances whose concentrations (or partial pressures) are independent of the amount, such as for solids and pure liquids.
Equilibrium constants can be determined from experimental measurements of the concentrations or partial pressures of the reactants and products at equilibrium.
The reaction quotient Q
For the general reversible reaction \(a\text{A} + b\text{B} \rightleftharpoons c\text{C} + d\text{D}\), the reaction quotient compares the current amounts of products and reactants:
\[ Q_c = \frac{[\text{C}]^c[\text{D}]^d}{[\text{A}]^a[\text{B}]^b} \]
Products go on top, reactants on the bottom, and each concentration is raised to the power of its coefficient in the balanced equation. \(Q\) can be calculated at any moment, whether or not the system is at equilibrium. For gases the same expression can be written with partial pressures (in atm or bar), giving \(Q_p\).
The equilibrium constant K
At equilibrium, \(Q\) has a special value: the equilibrium constant \(K\). It is constant at a given temperature, whatever the starting amounts (this is the law of mass action):
\[ K_c = \frac{[\text{C}]^c_{\text{eq}}[\text{D}]^d_{\text{eq}}}{[\text{A}]^a_{\text{eq}}[\text{B}]^b_{\text{eq}}} \]
\(K\) depends only on the reaction (as written) and the temperature. It does not depend on the starting concentrations, on adding a catalyst, or on the volume. By convention \(K\) is given without units.
Worked example · writing expressions
Write \(K_c\) for (a) N2(g) + 3 H2(g) ⇌ 2 NH3(g); (b) 2 SO2(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2 SO3(g); and \(K_p\) for (a).
The concentration of a pure solid or pure liquid is a constant (set by its density), independent of how much is present, so these substances do not appear in \(Q\) or \(K\). Only gases and dissolved species (aqueous) appear.
In aqueous reactions the solvent, liquid water, is also left out (as in the acid-base reactions of Unit 8).
Notice that some solid must still be present for the equilibrium to exist; if all the CaCO3 has decomposed there is no equilibrium, but the amount of solid does not change the value of \(K\).
Worked example · heterogeneous equilibrium
Write the equilibrium expression for 3 Fe(s) + 4 H2O(g) ⇌ Fe3O4(s) + 4 H2(g).
Only the gases appear: \(K_p = \dfrac{(P_{\text{H}_2})^4}{(P_{\text{H}_2\text{O}})^4}\). Both solids are omitted.
Kc or Kp
\(K_c\) uses molar concentrations and \(K_p\) uses partial pressures; the two numbers are generally different (their conversion is not assessed). On the exam read carefully which one a question gives and use the matching quantities (M for \(K_c\), atm or bar for \(K_p\)).
Calculating K from data
To find \(K\), put the equilibrium concentrations (or partial pressures) into the expression. If you are given initial amounts and one equilibrium concentration, use stoichiometry to find the others (an ICE table, in the next lesson).
Worked example · K from equilibrium concentrations
In a flask at a fixed temperature the equilibrium concentrations for N2O4(g) ⇌ 2 NO2(g) are [N2O4] = 0.0340 M and [NO2] = 0.0660 M. Find \(K_c\).
\(K_c = \dfrac{[\text{NO}_2]^2}{[\text{N}_2\text{O}_4]} = \dfrac{(0.0660)^2}{0.0340} = \dfrac{4.356 \times 10^{-3}}{0.0340} = \) 0.128. Note that the NO2 concentration is squared because its coefficient is 2.
Worked example · K from initial and one equilibrium value
A 1.00 L flask is filled with 1.00 mol H2 and 1.00 mol I2. At equilibrium there is 1.56 mol HI. Find \(K_c\) for H2 + I2 ⇌ 2 HI.
HI formed: 1.56 M, which used up half as much H2 and I2: 0.78 M each. So [H2] = [I2] = 1.00 − 0.78 = 0.22 M. \(K_c = \dfrac{(1.56)^2}{(0.22)(0.22)} = \dfrac{2.434}{0.0484} = \) 50.3 (to three significant figures; the equilibrium concentrations have two).
Worked example · Kp from partial pressures
At equilibrium for N2 + 3 H2 ⇌ 2 NH3, the partial pressures are 0.25 atm (N2), 0.75 atm (H2) and 0.50 atm (NH3). Find \(K_p\).
Check the units and form: forgetting an exponent (using [NO2] instead of [NO2]2) is the most frequent error. And never put initial concentrations into \(K\); only equilibrium values belong there. If initial values are used, the quantity calculated is \(Q\), not \(K\).
Exam focus
Products over reactants, coefficients as exponents.
Leave out solids and pure liquids. Include (g) and (aq) species.
K uses equilibrium values only; Q uses whatever values are present now.
K depends only on temperature (and on how the equation is written).
Use Kc with concentrations and Kp with partial pressures; do not mix them.
Practice
Write the \(K_c\) expression for 4 NH3(g) + 5 O2(g) ⇌ 4 NO(g) + 6 H2O(g).
Show answer
Write \(K_c\) for Zn(s) + Cu2+(aq) ⇌ Zn2+(aq) + Cu(s).
Show answer
\(K_c = \dfrac{[\text{Zn}^{2+}]}{[\text{Cu}^{2+}]}\); the solids Zn and Cu are omitted.
For 2 NO2 ⇌ N2O4, equilibrium concentrations are [NO2] = 0.0200 M and [N2O4] = 0.0300 M. Find \(K_c\).
Show answer
\(K_c = 0.0300/(0.0200)^2 = 75.0\).
A flask holds 0.40 atm CO2 in equilibrium with solid CaCO3 and CaO at some temperature. Find \(K_p\) for CaCO3(s) ⇌ CaO(s) + CO2(g), and say what happens to the pressure if more CaCO3 is added.
Show answer
\(K_p = P_{\text{CO}_2} = 0.40\). Adding solid does not change \(K\), so the pressure of CO2 stays at 0.40 atm.
Initial [A] = 1.00 M and [B] = 0 for A ⇌ 2 B. At equilibrium [B] = 0.30 M. Find \(K_c\).
Show answer
[A] used = 0.15 M so [A] = 0.85 M. \(K_c = (0.30)^2/0.85 = 0.106\).
A student writes \(K = [\text{C}]/([\text{A}][\text{B}])\) for A + 2 B ⇌ C. Find the error.
Show answer
The coefficient of B must appear as an exponent: \(K = [\text{C}]/([\text{A}][\text{B}]^2)\).
A single number, K, tells you whether a reaction is worth running. Some reactions have enormous K values and finish almost completely (burning fuel); others have tiny K values and barely begin (nitrogen and oxygen in air do not make nitrogen oxides at room temperature).
This lesson shows how to read the size of K, and then how K is transformed when you reverse an equation, rescale it, or combine two equations. These manipulations are the foundation for all of Unit 8.
Learning objectives · 7.5.A and 7.6.A
7.5.A Explain the relationship between very large or very small values of K and the relative concentrations of chemical species at equilibrium. 7.6.A Represent a multistep process with an overall equilibrium expression, using the constituent K expressions for each individual reaction.
Required content · EK 7.5.A.1 and 7.6.A.1 to 7.6.A.4
Some equilibrium reactions have very large K values and proceed essentially to completion. Others have very small K values and barely proceed at all.
When a reaction is reversed, K is inverted.
When the stoichiometric coefficients of a reaction are multiplied by a factor c, K is raised to the power c.
When reactions are added together, the K of the resulting overall reaction is the product of the K’s for the reactions that were summed.
Since the expressions for K and Q have identical mathematical forms, all valid algebraic manipulations of K also apply to Q.
What the size of K tells you
Because \(K\) is a ratio of products to reactants, its size shows where the equilibrium lies:
Figure 7.3a The size of K shows how far a reaction goes. K is a ratio of product to reactant concentrations, so a very large K means products dominate and a very small K means almost no products form. A large K says nothing about how fast equilibrium is reached.
K much greater than 1 (say above \(10^3\)): products are strongly favored. The reaction goes nearly to completion. Example: the Haber synthesis of ammonia at 25 °C has \(K_p\) of about \(10^5\) to \(10^6\).
K close to 1 (roughly \(10^{-3}\) to \(10^{3}\)): significant amounts of both reactants and products are present.
K much less than 1 (below about \(10^{-3}\)): reactants are strongly favored. The reaction barely proceeds. Example: N2 + O2 ⇌ 2 NO has \(K\) near \(10^{-30}\) at 25 °C, which is why air does not spontaneously become smog.
Two warnings. First, K says how far, not how fast. A reaction with a huge K can still be extremely slow (a diamond is thermodynamically willing to burn, and does not) because the activation energy is high; K and the rate are separate questions. Second, K is for the equation as written, so you must always say which equation you mean.
Worked example · what K means for composition
For A ⇌ B, start with 1.00 M A. Find [A] and [B] at equilibrium if (a) \(K = 1000\) and (b) \(K = 0.0010\).
(a) \([\text{B}]/[\text{A}] = 1000\) and \([\text{A}] + [\text{B}] = 1.00\), so \([\text{A}] = 1.00/1001 = 0.00100\) M and [B] = 0.999 M: essentially complete. (b) \([\text{B}]/[\text{A}] = 0.0010\), so \([\text{B}] = 1.00/1001 \approx 0.00100\) M and [A] = 0.999 M: almost nothing happens.
Manipulating K
Equilibrium expressions are products and quotients of concentrations, so changing the equation changes \(K\) in predictable ways. Let the original reaction have constant \(K\).
If you…
the new K is…
Why
reverse the reaction
1/K
products and reactants swap places in the expression
multiply the coefficients by c
Kc
every exponent is multiplied by c
add two reactions
K1 × K2
the terms of the two expressions multiply; intermediates cancel
Compare these with Hess’s law in Unit 6: ΔH changes sign, is multiplied, and is added, while K is inverted, raised to a power, and multiplied.
Worked example · reversing and scaling
For N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2, \(K = 0.128\). Find K for (a) 2 NO2 ⇌ N2O4, and (b) 2 N2O4 ⇌ 4 NO2.
For H2 + I2 ⇌ 2 HI, \(K = 50.3\). Find K for HI ⇌ ½ H2 + ½ I2.
Reverse (factor 1/K) and halve the coefficients (power 1/2): \(K' = (1/50.3)^{1/2} = 0.141\).
Worked example · adding reactions
Given (1) A ⇌ B, \(K_1 = 0.20\), and (2) B ⇌ C, \(K_2 = 5.0\), find K for A ⇌ C.
Adding the equations cancels B: A ⇌ C. \(K = K_1K_2 = (0.20)(5.0) = 1.0\). Check by expression: \(K_1K_2 = \dfrac{[B]}{[A]}\cdot\dfrac{[C]}{[B]} = \dfrac{[C]}{[A]}\) ✓.
Worked example · a combined manipulation
Given (1) 2 A ⇌ B, \(K_1 = 4.0\), and (2) C ⇌ B, \(K_2 = 0.50\), find K for 2 A ⇌ C.
Target has 2 A on the left (use (1) as written) and C on the right, so reverse (2): B ⇌ C with \(K = 1/0.50 = 2.0\). Add: 2 A ⇌ C, \(K = (4.0)(2.0) = 8.0\).
The same algebra applies to the reaction quotient \(Q\): if you rewrite an equation, \(Q\) is inverted, raised to the power, or multiplied in exactly the same way as \(K\) (because \(K\) is just the value of \(Q\) at equilibrium).
Exam focus
Large K: products favored; small K: reactants favored. Use the words “at equilibrium”.
K is not speed. Large K says nothing about rate.
Reverse: invert. Scale by c: raise to c. Add: multiply. Cancel intermediates when adding.
Always say which equation a K belongs to.
Apply the same rules to Q.
Practice
For 2 SO2 + O2 ⇌ 2 SO3, \(K_c = 280\). Find K for 2 SO3 ⇌ 2 SO2 + O2.
Show answer
\(K = 1/280 = 3.6 \times 10^{-3}\).
For A ⇌ B, \(K = 3.0\). What is K for 3 A ⇌ 3 B?
Show answer
\(K = 3.0^3 = 27\).
Given N2 + O2 ⇌ 2 NO, \(K_1\), and 2 NO + O2 ⇌ 2 NO2, \(K_2\), write K for N2 + 2 O2 ⇌ 2 NO2.
Show answer
Add the equations (NO cancels): \(K = K_1K_2\).
A reaction has \(K = 2 \times 10^{-12}\). Describe the composition at equilibrium and say whether it will be fast or slow.
Show answer
Mostly reactants, with only a tiny amount of product. The size of K gives no information about the rate, so it may be fast or slow.
For A ⇌ B, \(K = 0.25\). What is K for 2 B ⇌ 2 A?
Show answer
Reverse: 1/0.25 = 4.0. Double the coefficients: \(4.0^2 = 16\).
A student claims a reaction with \(K = 10^{20}\) must be instantaneous. Evaluate.
Show answer
Incorrect. A very large K means products are strongly favored at equilibrium, but the rate depends on the activation energy. Such a reaction can be extremely slow.
An engineer designing an ammonia plant needs to know how much product the reactor will hold at equilibrium before building it. A chemist testing a mixture needs to know which way it will move. Both questions have the same answer: compare the reaction quotient with K, and then, if the amounts are wanted, solve for the changes with an ICE table.
This lesson teaches both skills.
Learning objective · 7.7.A
Identify the concentrations or partial pressures of chemical species at equilibrium based on the initial conditions and the equilibrium constant.
Required content · EK 7.7.A.1 and 7.7.A.2
The concentrations or partial pressures of species at equilibrium can be predicted given the balanced reaction, initial concentrations, and the appropriate K.
When Q < K, the reaction will proceed with a net consumption of reactants and generation of products. When Q > K, the reaction will proceed with a net consumption of products and generation of reactants. When Q = K, the system is at dynamic equilibrium; both forward and reverse reactions proceed at the same rate, and the proportion of reactants and products remains constant.
Which way will it go? Compare Q with K
Calculate \(Q\) from the present concentrations (the same expression as \(K\)) and compare:
Figure 7.4a Q compared with K gives the direction. The system always moves so that Q approaches K: if Q is too small there are too few products, so more form; if Q is too large there are too many products, so some are consumed.
\(Q \lt K\): too few products; the forward reaction proceeds, consuming reactants and forming products.
\(Q \gt K\): too many products; the reverse reaction proceeds, consuming products and forming reactants.
\(Q = K\): equilibrium; no net change.
Worked example · direction of change
For H2(g) + I2(g) ⇌ 2 HI(g), \(K_c = 50.3\) at a given temperature. A mixture has [H2] = 0.50 M, [I2] = 0.50 M and [HI] = 2.0 M. Which way does the reaction go?
\(Q = \dfrac{(2.0)^2}{(0.50)(0.50)} = \dfrac{4.0}{0.25} = 16\). Since \(Q = 16 \lt 50.3 = K\), the mixture contains too little HI: the forward reaction proceeds, making HI and consuming H2 and I2, until \(Q\) rises to 50.3.
Worked example · the other direction
For N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2, \(K_c = 0.128\). A mixture has [NO2] = 0.0500 M and [N2O4] = 0.0100 M. Which way does it shift?
\(Q = (0.0500)^2/0.0100 = 0.250 \gt 0.128\). Too much NO2: the reverse reaction proceeds, forming N2O4.
ICE tables
To find the equilibrium amounts, track three rows: Initial, Change and Equilibrium. Let \(x\) be the amount (M) of the reaction that proceeds, and write each change as \(x\) times its coefficient (negative for substances consumed, positive for those produced). Then substitute the equilibrium row into \(K\) and solve for \(x\).
Procedure
Write the balanced equation and \(K\) expression.
Set up the table with initial concentrations. Use \(Q\) to decide the direction if both sides have material.
Fill the change row using \(x\) and the coefficients.
Fill the equilibrium row (initial + change).
Substitute into \(K\) and solve. Reject any answer that gives a negative concentration.
Check by recalculating \(K\) from the answer.
Worked example · a perfect square
A 1.00 L flask holds 1.00 M H2 and 1.00 M I2 (no HI). With \(K_c = 50.3\), find the equilibrium concentrations.
[H2]
[I2]
[HI]
I
1.00
1.00
0
C
−x
−x
+2x
E
1.00 − x
1.00 − x
2x
\(K = \dfrac{(2x)^2}{(1.00 - x)^2} = 50.3\). Both sides are perfect squares, so take the square root: \(\dfrac{2x}{1.00 - x} = \sqrt{50.3} = 7.092\). Then \(2x = 7.092 - 7.092x\), so \(9.092x = 7.092\) and \(x = 0.780\). Equilibrium: [H2] = [I2] = 0.220 M and [HI] = 1.56 M. Check: \((1.56)^2/(0.220)^2 = 50.3\) ✓.
Worked example · a quadratic
Start with 0.100 M N2O4 and no NO2. With \(K_c = 0.128\) for N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2, find the equilibrium concentrations.
Changes: N2O4 = 0.100 − x, NO2 = 2x. \(K = \dfrac{(2x)^2}{0.100 - x} = 0.128\). Cross-multiply: \(4x^2 = 0.128(0.100 - x)\), so \(4x^2 + 0.128x - 0.0128 = 0\). The quadratic formula gives \(x = \dfrac{-0.128 + \sqrt{(0.128)^2 + 4(4)(0.0128)}}{2(4)} = \dfrac{-0.128 + 0.4703}{8} = 0.0428\) (the negative root is rejected). [NO2] = 2x = 0.0856 M and [N2O4] = 0.100 − 0.0428 = 0.0572 M. Check: \((0.0856)^2/0.0572 = 0.128\) ✓. (This is the equilibrium mixture used in the next lesson.)
When K is very small: the approximation
If \(K\) is tiny compared with the starting concentration, so little reacts that \(x\) is negligible next to the initial amount, and \((0.500 - x) \approx 0.500\). The algebra simplifies and no quadratic is needed. A common check is the 5 percent rule: after solving, if \(x\) is less than 5 percent of the initial concentration the approximation was valid.
Worked example · small K
N2(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2 NO(g) has \(K_c = 4.0 \times 10^{-4}\) at a high temperature. Start with 0.500 M N2 and 0.500 M O2. Find [NO] at equilibrium.
\(K = \dfrac{(2x)^2}{(0.500 - x)^2} = 4.0 \times 10^{-4}\). Taking square roots: \(\dfrac{2x}{0.500 - x} = 0.020\). Approximating \(0.500 - x \approx 0.500\): \(2x = 0.0100\), \(x = 0.0050\). This is 1.0 percent of 0.500, so the approximation is valid. [NO] = 2x = 0.0099 M, and [N2] = [O2] = 0.495 M. (Solving exactly gives \(x = 0.00495\), the same to two significant figures.)
Partial pressures. The same method works with partial pressures and \(K_p\); let \(x\) be a change in pressure (atm) instead of concentration. If a reaction starts with products only, the change row has the opposite signs.
Exam focus
Q first for direction, ICE table for amounts.
Change row uses coefficients: \(+2x\) for a product with coefficient 2, and the \(2x\) is then squared in K.
Use perfect squares or the small-K approximation when you can; justify with the 5 percent rule.
Reject negative concentrations; check by substituting back.
Show setup and units: concentrations in M (or atm for \(K_p\)).
Practice
For A ⇌ B with \(K = 4.0\), is a mixture with [A] = 0.50 M and [B] = 3.0 M at equilibrium? Which way does it shift?
Show answer
\(Q = 3.0/0.50 = 6.0 \gt 4.0\): not at equilibrium; the reverse reaction proceeds (B converts to A).
For A ⇌ B with \(K = 4.0\), start with 1.00 M A only. Find [A] and [B] at equilibrium.
Show answer
\(K = x/(1.00 - x) = 4.0\), so \(x = 4.0 - 4.0x\), \(5.0x = 4.0\), \(x = 0.80\). [B] = 0.80 M and [A] = 0.20 M. Check: 0.80/0.20 = 4.0 ✓.
For 2 A ⇌ B with \(K = 0.50\) and initially [A] = 1.00 M, write the equilibrium row and the equation to solve (do not solve).
Show answer
For 2 HI ⇌ H2 + I2 with \(K_c = 0.0199\), start with 1.00 M HI. Find [H2] at equilibrium.
Show answer
HI = 1.00 − 2x; H2 = I2 = x. \(K = x^2/(1.00 - 2x)^2 = 0.0199\), so \(x/(1.00 - 2x) = 0.141\). Then \(x = 0.141 - 0.282x\), \(x = 0.110\). [H2] = 0.110 M (HI = 0.78 M).
For a reaction with \(K = 1.0 \times 10^{-8}\), why can the “x is small” approximation be used, and how would you check it?
Show answer
K is tiny, so very little reactant is consumed, making \(x\) negligible compared with the initial concentration. After solving, check that \(x\) is less than 5 percent of the initial concentration.
A student gets a negative concentration from the quadratic. What should be done?
Show answer
Discard that root, because a concentration cannot be negative, and use the other root (which gives positive concentrations). Then check by recalculating K.
Le Châtelier’s principle and the reaction quotient
A fertilizer plant wants as much ammonia as possible from nitrogen and hydrogen. A scuba diver’s blood must not release nitrogen too fast on the way up. A cobalt chloride test strip changes color with humidity. All of these are equilibria that respond to a change in conditions, and the response can be predicted.
The prediction tool is Le Châtelier’s principle, and the explanation for why it works is the comparison of Q with K from the last lesson.
Learning objectives · 7.9.A and 7.10.A
7.9.A Identify the response of a system at equilibrium to an external stress, using Le Châtelier’s principle. 7.10.A Explain the relationships between Q, K, and the direction in which a reversible reaction will proceed to reach equilibrium.
Required content · EK 7.9.A.1, 7.9.A.2, 7.10.A.1 and 7.10.A.2
Le Châtelier’s principle can be used to predict the response of a system to stresses such as addition or removal of a chemical species, change in temperature, change in volume/pressure of a gas-phase system, or dilution of a reaction system.
Le Châtelier’s principle can be used to predict the effect that a stress will have on experimentally measurable properties such as pH, temperature, and color of a solution.
A disturbance to a system at equilibrium causes Q to differ from K, thereby taking the system out of equilibrium. The system responds by bringing Q back into agreement with K, thereby establishing a new equilibrium state.
Some stresses, such as changes in concentration, cause a change in Q only. A change in temperature causes a change in K. In either case, the concentrations or partial pressures of species redistribute to bring Q and K back into equality.
The principle
Le Châtelier’s principle: when a system at equilibrium is disturbed by a stress, the system shifts in the direction that partly relieves the stress, and a new equilibrium is established. “Shifting to the right” means more products form; “shifting to the left” means more reactants. It is a shorthand for what the \(Q\) versus \(K\) comparison shows.
Stress 1: change in concentration
Adding a substance shifts the reaction to consume it; removing a substance shifts the reaction to replace it. Why: adding a reactant lowers \(Q\) (the denominator grows), so \(Q \lt K\) and the forward reaction proceeds; adding a product raises \(Q\), so \(Q \gt K\) and the reverse reaction proceeds. \(K\) itself is unchanged.
Figure 7.5a Response of N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 (K = 0.128) to added NO2. The addition makes Q greater than K, so the reaction shifts left: some NO2 is consumed and more N2O4 forms. Both concentrations settle at new constant values, and Q returns to the same K.
Worked example · adding a product
For N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 (\(K_c = 0.128\)) at equilibrium, [NO2] = 0.0856 M and [N2O4] = 0.0572 M. NO2 is added suddenly until [NO2] = 0.1356 M. Which way does the system shift?
\(Q = (0.1356)^2/0.0572 = 0.321 \gt 0.128\). The reverse reaction proceeds: some NO2 turns into N2O4 until \(Q\) falls back to 0.128. The new equilibrium has [NO2] = 0.0985 M and [N2O4] = 0.0758 M: higher than the original for both, but the added NO2 has only been partly used up. (Le Châtelier’s principle says the stress is partly relieved, never fully.)
Stress 2: change in volume or pressure (gases)
Compressing the system (smaller volume, higher pressure) raises every concentration. The system shifts toward the side with fewer moles of gas to lower the pressure. Expanding it shifts toward the side with more moles of gas. If the moles of gas are equal on both sides, volume has no effect on the position. The \(Q\) explanation: if volume is halved, every concentration doubles, and \(Q\) changes by a factor determined by the difference in the numbers of moles.
Worked example · compressing a gas mixture
The same N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 equilibrium is compressed to half its volume at constant temperature. Predict the shift and justify it with Q.
When the volume halves, both concentrations double instantly: [NO2] = 0.1712 M, [N2O4] = 0.1144 M. \(Q = (0.1712)^2/0.1144 = 0.256 = 2K\), so \(Q \gt K\) and the reverse reaction proceeds, toward N2O4: 1 mol of gas instead of 2 mol, which relieves the pressure. At the new equilibrium (in the smaller volume) [NO2] = 0.131 M and [N2O4] = 0.134 M.
Adding an inert gas at constant volume does not change any concentration or partial pressure of the reacting species, so there is no shift. (Adding it at constant pressure expands the volume, which acts like a decrease in pressure.)
Stress 3: dilution
Adding solvent lowers every dissolved concentration. The system shifts toward the side with more dissolved particles. Example: the cobalt complex [Co(H2O)6]2+(aq, pink) + 4 Cl−(aq) ⇌ CoCl42−(aq, blue) + 6 H2O(l). The left has 5 dissolved particles and the right has 1 (the water is a solvent, not counted). Adding water doubles the volume, so every dissolved concentration halves. The numerator of \(Q\) is multiplied by 1/2 and the denominator by (1/2)5 = 1/32, so \(Q\) becomes 16 times larger than \(K\). Since \(Q \gt K\), the reverse reaction proceeds and the system shifts left, to the pink color.
Stress 4: change in temperature
Temperature is the one stress that changes the value of K. Treat heat as a reactant or product:
Reaction type
Heating
Cooling
Effect on K
Endothermic (ΔH > 0): heat is a reactant
shifts right
shifts left
K increases when heated
Exothermic (ΔH < 0): heat is a product
shifts left
shifts right
K decreases when heated
So for the Haber synthesis N2 + 3 H2 ⇌ 2 NH3 (ΔH = −92.2 kJ), a low temperature favors ammonia (larger K) but is too slow, so industry compromises with a moderate temperature, high pressure (4 mol of gas becomes 2) and an iron catalyst. For the endothermic N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 (ΔH = +57 kJ), heating produces more of the brown NO2, so a heated flask darkens.
Worked example · temperature and measurable properties
The cobalt equilibrium above is endothermic as written. What happens to the color when a pink solution is warmed in a hot-water bath? When it is cooled in ice?
Heat acts like a reactant, so warming shifts the reaction right and the blue CoCl42− increases (K is larger at the higher temperature). Cooling shifts it left, so the solution turns pink.
What does not shift an equilibrium
A catalyst speeds the forward and reverse reactions equally, so equilibrium is reached faster but the position and \(K\) are unchanged.
Adding or removing a pure solid or liquid does not change the position because it does not appear in \(Q\) (as long as some remains).
Adding an inert gas at constant volume.
Summary with Q
Concentration, volume and pressure changes: \(K\) is unchanged; \(Q\) is momentarily different; the shift restores \(Q = K\).
Temperature changes: \(K\) itself changes; \(Q\) is momentarily the same as the old \(K\), and the system shifts until \(Q\) equals the new \(K\).
Exam focus
State the stress, the shift (right or left) and the reason in terms of Q compared with K.
Only temperature changes K. Everything else changes Q.
Pressure effects follow moles of gas; equal moles means no effect.
A catalyst never changes the position of equilibrium.
Relate to observations: color, pH, temperature, amount of solid.
Practice
For N2 + 3 H2 ⇌ 2 NH3 (exothermic), predict the effect of (a) adding H2, (b) removing NH3, (c) raising the pressure by compression, (d) raising the temperature, and (e) adding a catalyst.
Show answer
(a) Shifts right. (b) Shifts right. (c) Shifts right (4 mol gas becomes 2 mol). (d) Shifts left and K decreases. (e) No shift; equilibrium is reached faster.
For H2 + I2 ⇌ 2 HI, what is the effect of compressing the mixture?
Show answer
No shift in position, because the moles of gas are equal on both sides (2 and 2). Concentrations all increase, but Q is unchanged.
For C(s) + CO2(g) ⇌ 2 CO(g), ΔH > 0, predict the effect of adding more C(s) and of heating.
Show answer
Adding more solid carbon does not change the position (a solid is not in Q). Heating shifts right, forming more CO, and K increases.
An equilibrium mixture of a reaction with \(Q = K = 10\) is suddenly diluted so that all concentrations halve, for A + B ⇌ C. Find Q right after dilution and the shift.
Show answer
\(Q = [\text{C}]/([\text{A}][\text{B}])\): the numerator is multiplied by 1/2 and the denominator by 1/4, so \(Q = 2K = 20\). Since \(Q \gt K\), the reverse reaction proceeds, toward the side with more dissolved particles (A + B).
Explain why a catalyst does not change K.
Show answer
It lowers the activation energy for both the forward and reverse reactions by the same amount, so both rates increase equally. The equilibrium composition, and therefore K, is unchanged; only the time to reach it is shorter.
The reaction 2 NO2(g, brown) ⇌ N2O4(g, colorless) is exothermic. A sealed flask in hot water is darker than one in ice water. Explain.
Show answer
Heating an exothermic reaction shifts it left (heat is a product), forming more brown NO2, and K decreases at the higher temperature. Cooling shifts it right, favoring colorless N2O4.
Teeth are made of an ionic solid that dissolves a little in saliva and re-forms again; kidney stones, stalactites and the scale in a kettle are all solids that came out of solution when the conditions allowed. “Insoluble” in the solubility rules really means “extremely slightly soluble.”
The solubility product constant, Ksp, is the equilibrium constant that puts a number on that tiny solubility, and lets you calculate it, compare it and predict when a precipitate will form.
Learning objective · 7.11.A
Calculate the solubility of a salt based on the value of Ksp for the salt.
Required content · EK 7.11.A.1 to 7.11.A.4
The dissolution of a salt is a reversible process whose extent can be described by Ksp, the solubility-product constant.
The solubility of a substance can be calculated from the Ksp for the dissolution process. This relationship can also be used to predict the relative solubility of different substances.
The solubility rules (see 4.7.A.5) can be quantitatively related to Ksp, in which Ksp values > 1 correspond to soluble salts.
The molar solubility of one or more species in a saturated solution can be used to calculate the Ksp of a substance.
The solubility product
When a slightly soluble ionic solid is in contact with water, it dissolves until the solution is saturated, and then the solid and its ions are in dynamic equilibrium.
Figure 7.6a A saturated solution is a dynamic equilibrium. Ions leave the solid and ions return to it at the same rate, so the concentrations of the dissolved ions stay constant. Ksp is the equilibrium constant for this process; the solid does not appear in the expression.
The equilibrium constant for dissolving is the solubility product, \(K_{sp}\). The solid is omitted from the expression, so only the dissolved ions appear, each raised to the power of its coefficient:
A larger \(K_{sp}\) for formulas of the same type means a more soluble salt. The solubility rules of Unit 4 correspond to the size of \(K_{sp}\): salts with \(K_{sp} \gt 1\) are soluble (they dissolve almost completely), while “insoluble” salts have \(K_{sp}\) far below 1 (typically \(10^{-5}\) or smaller).
From Ksp to molar solubility
The molar solubility, \(s\), is the number of moles of the salt that dissolve per liter of solution to make a saturated solution. Each formula unit that dissolves gives ions according to the coefficients, so write the ion concentrations in terms of \(s\), substitute into \(K_{sp}\), and solve.
Worked example · a 1:1 salt
\(K_{sp}\) of AgCl is \(1.8 \times 10^{-10}\). Find its molar solubility in pure water and its solubility in g/L (M = 143.32 g/mol).
If two salts have the same ion ratio (for example both 1:1), the one with the larger \(K_{sp}\) is more soluble. Silver halides: AgCl \(1.8 \times 10^{-10}\), AgBr \(5.0 \times 10^{-13}\), AgI \(8.3 \times 10^{-17}\): AgCl is the most soluble.
If the ion ratios differ you must compare the solubilities \(s\), not the \(K_{sp}\) values. Silver chromate has a smaller \(K_{sp}\) (\(1.1 \times 10^{-12}\)) than silver chloride (\(1.8 \times 10^{-10}\)), yet it is more soluble: \(s = 6.5 \times 10^{-5}\) M compared with \(1.3 \times 10^{-5}\) M.
Will a precipitate form?
For dissolution, the reaction quotient is written with the concentrations present now (sometimes written \(Q_{sp}\)). Compare it with \(K_{sp}\), as for any equilibrium:
\(Q \lt K_{sp}\): unsaturated; more solid could dissolve; no precipitate forms.
\(Q = K_{sp}\): saturated; at equilibrium.
\(Q \gt K_{sp}\): supersaturated; a precipitate forms until \(Q\) falls to \(K_{sp}\).
Worked example · mixing solutions
50.0 mL of \(2.0 \times 10^{-4}\) M AgNO3 is mixed with 50.0 mL of \(2.0 \times 10^{-4}\) M NaCl. Does AgCl precipitate? (\(K_{sp} = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}\).)
Mixing doubles the volume, so each concentration is halved: \([\text{Ag}^+] = [\text{Cl}^-] = 1.0 \times 10^{-4}\) M. \(Q = (1.0 \times 10^{-4})^2 = 1.0 \times 10^{-8}\). This is much larger than \(1.8 \times 10^{-10}\), so \(Q \gt K_{sp}\) and AgCl precipitates.
Worked example · no precipitate
100. mL of \(1.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M Pb(NO3)2 is mixed with 100. mL of \(2.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M NaI. Does PbI2 (\(K_{sp} = 9.8 \times 10^{-9}\)) precipitate?
After mixing, \([\text{Pb}^{2+}] = 5.0 \times 10^{-4}\) M and \([\text{I}^-] = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M. \(Q = (5.0 \times 10^{-4})(1.0 \times 10^{-3})^2 = 5.0 \times 10^{-10}\). Since \(Q \lt K_{sp}\), no precipitate forms.
Exam focus
The solid is not in the expression. Write each ion to the power of its coefficient.
Define s, then write [ions] in terms of s (e.g., 2s for a coefficient 2) before substituting.
Compare Ksp directly only for the same ion ratio; otherwise compare molar solubilities.
Q against Ksp predicts a precipitate. Dilute by mixing before calculating Q.
Ksp is the equilibrium constant and depends on temperature.
Practice
Write the Ksp expressions for CaCO3 and for Fe(OH)3.
Show answer
\(K_{sp} = [\text{Ca}^{2+}][\text{CO}_3^{2-}]\) and \(K_{sp} = [\text{Fe}^{3+}][\text{OH}^-]^3\).
The solubility of BaSO4 is \(1.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M. Find \(K_{sp}\).
Show answer
\(K_{sp}\) of Mg(OH)2 is \(5.6 \times 10^{-12}\). Find its molar solubility.
Show answer
\(K_{sp} = s(2s)^2 = 4s^3\), so \(s^3 = 1.4 \times 10^{-12}\) and \(s = 1.1 \times 10^{-4}\) M.
AgBr (\(K_{sp} = 5.0 \times 10^{-13}\)) and AgCl (\(1.8 \times 10^{-10}\)) are both 1:1 salts. Which is more soluble, and by roughly what factor in solubility?
Show answer
AgCl. \(s\) values: \(1.3 \times 10^{-5}\) and \(7.1 \times 10^{-7}\) M, a factor of about 19 (the square root of the ratio of the Ksp values).
Equal volumes of \(4.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M Ag+ and \(4.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M Cl− are mixed. Does AgCl precipitate?
Show answer
After mixing each is \(2.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M, so \(Q = 4.0 \times 10^{-10} \gt 1.8 \times 10^{-10}\). Yes, it precipitates (just barely).
Why can a salt with a smaller Ksp be more soluble than one with a larger Ksp?
Show answer
When the formulas give different numbers of ions, Ksp involves different powers of s (for example \(s^2\) against \(4s^3\)), so Ksp values cannot be compared directly; the molar solubilities must be compared.
Silver chloride barely dissolves in pure water. Put it in salty water and it dissolves a thousand times less. Chemists use this to precipitate nearly all of an ion out of a solution on purpose, and it is the equilibrium idea behind water softeners, the purification of salts, and part of how buffers resist change in Unit 8.
This lesson applies Le Châtelier’s principle to the solubility equilibrium of the last lesson.
Learning objective · 7.12.A
Identify the solubility of a salt, and/or the value of Ksp for the salt, based on the concentration of a common ion already present in solution.
Required content · EK 7.12.A.1
The solubility of a salt is reduced when it is dissolved into a solution that already contains one of the ions present in the salt. The impact of this “common-ion effect” on solubility can be understood qualitatively using Le Châtelier’s principle or calculated from the Ksp for the dissolution process.
The effect
Consider AgCl(s) ⇌ Ag+(aq) + Cl−(aq). If the solution already contains chloride (from dissolved NaCl, for instance), there is an extra product on the right. By Le Châtelier’s principle the equilibrium shifts left: less AgCl dissolves, and some of the Ag+ already present precipitates as AgCl. A common ion is an ion that appears both in the salt and in the solution it dissolves into, and its effect is to decrease the solubility of the salt.
In terms of \(Q\): the extra Cl− raises \(Q = [\text{Ag}^+][\text{Cl}^-]\) above \(K_{sp}\), so solid forms until \(Q\) returns to \(K_{sp}\). \(K_{sp}\) is unchanged, because the temperature is unchanged; only the solubility changes.
Calculating solubility with a common ion
Let \(s\) be the molar solubility in the solution containing the common ion. The common ion's concentration is its initial value plus the small amount from the salt. Because \(s\) is usually tiny next to the existing concentration, the addition can be neglected, and the calculation is simple.
Worked example · AgCl in salt water
What is the solubility of AgCl (\(K_{sp} = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}\)) in 0.10 M NaCl?
NaCl provides \([\text{Cl}^-] = 0.10\) M. At equilibrium \([\text{Ag}^+] = s\) and \([\text{Cl}^-] = 0.10 + s \approx 0.10\). \(K_{sp} = s(0.10) = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}\), so \(s = 1.8 \times 10^{-9}\) M. The approximation is valid because \(1.8 \times 10^{-9}\) is negligible next to 0.10. In pure water the solubility is \(1.3 \times 10^{-5}\) M, so the common ion has cut it by a factor of about 7,500.
Worked example · the common ion appears twice
Find the solubility of PbI2 (\(K_{sp} = 9.8 \times 10^{-9}\)) in 0.10 M NaI.
\([\text{Pb}^{2+}] = s\) and \([\text{I}^-] = 0.10 + 2s \approx 0.10\) M. \(K_{sp} = s(0.10)^2 = 9.8 \times 10^{-9}\), so \(s = 9.8 \times 10^{-7}\) M. In pure water the solubility is \(1.35 \times 10^{-3}\) M, so it falls by a factor of about 1,400. Note that the iodide concentration is squared in \(K_{sp}\), so the equilibrium is more sensitive to the ion with the larger exponent.
Worked example · a common ion from a different salt
Find the solubility of AgCl in 0.020 M CaCl2.
Each CaCl2 gives two Cl−, so \([\text{Cl}^-] = 2(0.020) = 0.040\) M. \(s = K_{sp}/[\text{Cl}^-] = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}/0.040 = 4.5 \times 10^{-9}\) M.
Worked example · CaF2 in fluoride
Find the solubility of CaF2 (\(K_{sp} = 4.0 \times 10^{-11}\)) in 0.010 M NaF.
\([\text{F}^-] \approx 0.010\) M, so \(s = [\text{Ca}^{2+}] = K_{sp}/(0.010)^2 = 4.0 \times 10^{-11}/1.0 \times 10^{-4} = 4.0 \times 10^{-7}\) M. In pure water it is \(2.2 \times 10^{-4}\) M, about 540 times larger.
Finding Ksp or a concentration
Worked example · how much common ion is needed?
What concentration of Cl− must be present to keep the silver ion concentration in a saturated AgCl solution at \(1.0 \times 10^{-8}\) M?
\([\text{Cl}^-] = K_{sp}/[\text{Ag}^+] = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}/1.0 \times 10^{-8} = 0.018\) M. This is the idea behind removing a toxic ion from wastewater by adding a source of its counter-ion.
Explaining and predicting experiments
The same reasoning explains experimental changes. If sodium chloride solution is added to a saturated solution of AgCl with excess solid, more solid appears (the dissolved Ag+ concentration falls and solid grows). If the common ion is removed, for example by adding something that binds it, the solid dissolves further. If a student rinses a precipitate with pure water instead of a dilute solution of the common ion, a little of the product is lost; a dilute solution of the common ion avoids the loss. In every case: shift to relieve the stress, and \(K_{sp}\) stays constant.
Exam focus
Name the common ion and say the equilibrium shifts toward the solid, lowering solubility; Ksp does not change.
Set the shared-ion concentration = existing + s; drop \(s\) if it is negligible and say why.
Count the ions delivered by the source: CaCl2 gives 2 Cl− per formula unit.
Solubility always decreases, never increases, with a common ion.
Experiment design: predict what happens to the amount of solid and to the dissolved ion when the common ion is added or removed.
Practice
Calculate the solubility of AgCl in 0.50 M NaCl.
Show answer
\(s = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}/0.50 = 3.6 \times 10^{-10}\) M.
Solid BaSO4 (\(K_{sp} = 1.1 \times 10^{-10}\)) is stirred in 0.010 M Na2SO4. Find [Ba2+].
Show answer
\([\text{SO}_4^{2-}] \approx 0.010\) M. \([\text{Ba}^{2+}] = 1.1 \times 10^{-10}/0.010 = 1.1 \times 10^{-8}\) M.
Is PbI2 more soluble in water or in 0.10 M Pb(NO3)2? Explain.
Show answer
More soluble in pure water. Pb2+ from Pb(NO3)2 is a common ion, which shifts the dissolution equilibrium toward the solid and reduces solubility.
Solid AgCl is in equilibrium with its saturated solution. A few drops of concentrated NaCl are added. Describe what happens to the mass of solid and to [Ag+].
Show answer
The added Cl− raises Q above Ksp, so more AgCl precipitates: the mass of solid increases and [Ag+] decreases. Ksp is unchanged.
In 0.020 M NaF, the solubility of CaF2 is how many times smaller than in 0.010 M NaF (same Ksp)?
Show answer
\(s\) is proportional to \(1/[\text{F}^-]^2\). Doubling [F−] reduces \(s\) by a factor of \(2^2 = 4\).
Why is the approximation \([\text{Cl}^-] = 0.10 + s \approx 0.10\) acceptable for AgCl?
Show answer
Ksp is so small that \(s\) (about \(10^{-9}\) M) is far smaller than 0.10 M, much less than 5 percent of it, so adding it changes the chloride concentration negligibly.
Unit 7 practice · 10 problems
Unit 7 practice: Equilibrium
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed.
Write the \(K_c\) expression for 2 NO(g) + Br2(g) ⇌ 2 NOBr(g) and the \(K_p\) expression for C(s) + CO2(g) ⇌ 2 CO(g). Why does carbon not appear?
Show answer
\(K_c = \dfrac{[\mathrm{NOBr}]^2}{[\mathrm{NO}]^2[\mathrm{Br_2}]}\). \(K_p = \dfrac{(P_{\mathrm{CO}})^2}{P_{\mathrm{CO_2}}}\). Solid carbon is omitted because a pure solid's "concentration" is fixed; adding or removing it changes nothing about the gas-phase equilibrium.
H2(g) + I2(g) ⇌ 2 HI(g) has \(K_c = 54\) at 700 K. A flask holds [H2] = 0.20 M, [I2] = 0.10 M, and [HI] = 0.80 M. Is the system at equilibrium? If not, which way does it proceed, and why at the particle level?
Show answer
\(Q = \dfrac{(0.80)^2}{(0.20)(0.10)} = 32\). \(Q \lt K\), so not at equilibrium; the reaction proceeds forward, making HI. With more reactant than equilibrium allows, H2–I2 collisions that form HI outnumber HI decompositions until the ratio climbs to 54.
N2O4(g) ⇌ 2 NO2(g). A flask starts with 0.200 M N2O4 and no NO2; at equilibrium [NO2] = 0.100 M. Find \(K_c\).
Show answer
ICE: N2O4 \(0.200 - x\), NO2 \(2x\). \(2x = 0.100\) gives \(x = 0.050\), so [N2O4] \(= 0.150\) M. \(K_c = \dfrac{(0.100)^2}{0.150} = 0.0667\). Watch the coefficient: the change in NO2 is \(+2x\), not \(+x\).
COCl2(g) ⇌ CO(g) + Cl2(g) has \(K_c = 2.2 \times 10^{-10}\) at 373 K. Starting with 0.500 M COCl2, find the equilibrium [CO] and justify any approximation.
Show answer
\(\dfrac{x^2}{0.500 - x} \approx \dfrac{x^2}{0.500} = 2.2 \times 10^{-10}\), so \(x^2 = 1.1 \times 10^{-10}\) and \(x = [\mathrm{CO}] = 1.0 \times 10^{-5}\) M. Check: \(x/0.500 = 0.002\%\), far under 5%, so \(0.500 - x \approx 0.500\) is valid. Tiny \(K\), tiny \(x\).
N2(g) + 3 H2(g) ⇌ 2 NH3(g) has \(K = 6.0 \times 10^{5}\) at 298 K. Find \(K\) for NH3(g) ⇌ ½ N2(g) + 3⁄2 H2(g).
Show answer
Reverse (\(1/K\)) and halve (square root): \(K' = \left(\dfrac{1}{6.0 \times 10^{5}}\right)^{1/2} = (1.67 \times 10^{-6})^{1/2} = 1.3 \times 10^{-3}\). Sensible: decomposing ammonia is unfavorable when forming it is favorable.
At 25 °C, N2(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2 NO(g) has \(K_1 = 2.0 \times 10^{-31}\) and 2 NO(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2 NO2(g) has \(K_2 = 5.3 \times 10^{12}\). Find \(K\) for NO2(g) ⇌ ½ N2(g) + O2(g).
Show answer
Adding the two gives N2 + 2 O2 ⇌ 2 NO2 with \(K = K_1 K_2 = 1.06 \times 10^{-18}\). The target is that reaction reversed and halved: \(K' = \left(\dfrac{1}{1.06 \times 10^{-18}}\right)^{1/2} = (9.4 \times 10^{17})^{1/2} = 9.7 \times 10^{8}\). Large: NO2 strongly prefers to fall apart into the elements at room temperature.
2 SO2(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2 SO3(g), \(\Delta H = -198\) kJ. Predict the direction of shift, if any, and justify each with \(Q\) versus \(K\): (a) adding O2; (b) halving the volume; (c) raising the temperature; (d) adding argon at constant volume; (e) adding a catalyst.
Show answer
(a) O2 is in the denominator, so \(Q \lt K\): forward. (b) Every concentration doubles; the denominator (3 gas moles) grows by \(2^3 = 8\), the numerator by \(2^2 = 4\), so \(Q = K/2 \lt K\): forward, toward fewer gas moles. (c) Exothermic, so heat is a product; adding heat lowers \(K\) itself, making \(Q \gt K\): reverse. (d) No partial pressure of any reactant or product changes, so \(Q = K\): no shift. (e) A catalyst speeds both directions equally: no shift, equilibrium is just reached sooner.
PCl5(g) ⇌ PCl3(g) + Cl2(g) is endothermic. Which change increases the equilibrium amount of PCl3?
Cl2 is a product, so adding it makes \(Q \gt K\) and the system shifts in reverse, consuming PCl3. Adding a reactant would push forward; adding a product pushes back.
Decreasing the volume raises the total pressure, and the system shifts toward the side with fewer moles of gas: here the PCl5 side (1 mol vs. 2 mol). That is the reverse direction, so PCl3 decreases.
Endothermic means heat is effectively a reactant, so raising \(T\) increases \(K\) itself and the system shifts forward, producing more PCl3. Temperature is the only change listed that alters \(K\).
A catalyst lowers the activation energy for the forward and reverse reactions equally, so equilibrium is reached faster but its position, and \(K\), is unchanged. Rate and extent are different questions.
\(K_{sp}\)(CaF2) \(= 3.9 \times 10^{-11}\). (a) Find its molar solubility in pure water. (b) Find it in 0.10 M NaF. (c) Would CaF2 be more or less soluble in an acidic solution? Explain.
Show answer
(a) \([\mathrm{Ca^{2+}}] = s\), \([\mathrm{F^-}] = 2s\): \(s(2s)^2 = 4s^3 = 3.9 \times 10^{-11}\), \(s^3 = 9.75 \times 10^{-12}\), \(s = 2.1 \times 10^{-4}\) M. (b) \([\mathrm{F^-}] \approx 0.10\): \(s(0.10)^2 = 3.9 \times 10^{-11}\), \(s = 3.9 \times 10^{-9}\) M: the common ion cuts solubility about 50,000-fold. (c) More soluble: F− is a weak base, so H+ converts it to HF, lowering [F−], making \(Q \lt K_{sp}\), and pulling more solid into solution.
25.0 mL of \(2.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M Pb(NO3)2 is mixed with 25.0 mL of \(4.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M KI. \(K_{sp}\)(PbI2) \(= 9.8 \times 10^{-9}\). Does PbI2 precipitate?
Show answer
Mixing equal volumes halves each: \([\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}] = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M, \([\mathrm{I^-}] = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M. \(Q = [\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}][\mathrm{I^-}]^2 = (1.0 \times 10^{-3})(2.0 \times 10^{-3})^2 = 4.0 \times 10^{-9}\). \(Q \lt K_{sp}\), so no precipitate forms; the solution is unsaturated. (Don't forget the square on iodide or the dilution.)
Your stomach sits near pH 2, your blood is held between 7.35 and 7.45, and a swimming pool is kept near 7.4. A change of one pH unit in your blood would be fatal.
pH is the standard way to say how acidic or basic a solution is, and it all starts with a surprising fact: even perfectly pure water contains a tiny amount of acid and base, because water molecules react with each other.
Learning objective · 8.1.A
Calculate the values of pH and pOH, based on Kw and the concentration of all species present in a neutral solution of water.
Required content · EK 8.1.A.1 to 8.1.A.4
The concentrations of hydronium ion and hydroxide ion are often reported as pH and pOH, respectively: \(\text{pH} = -\log[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+]\) and \(\text{pOH} = -\log[\text{OH}^-]\). The terms “hydrogen ion” and “hydronium ion” and the symbols H+(aq) and H3O+(aq) are often used interchangeably for the aqueous ion of hydrogen. Hydronium ion and H3O+(aq) are preferred, but H+(aq) is also accepted on the AP Exam.
Water autoionizes with an equilibrium constant Kw: \(K_w = [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{OH}^-] = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}\) at 25 °C.
In pure water, pH = pOH, which is called a neutral solution. At 25 °C, pKw = 14.0 and thus pH = pOH = 7.0, with \(\text{p}K_w = 14 = \text{pH} + \text{pOH}\).
The value of Kw is temperature dependent, so the pH of pure, neutral water will deviate from 7.0 at temperatures other than 25 °C.
Acids, bases and the hydronium ion
In this unit we use the Brønsted-Lowry definitions you met in Unit 4: an acid is a proton (H+) donor and a base is a proton acceptor. In water, a proton does not float free; it attaches to a water molecule to form the hydronium ion, H3O+. (The symbol H+(aq) is an accepted shorthand for the same thing.) A hydroxide ion, OH−, is the base typically formed in water.
Autoionization of water
Water is both an acid and a base (it is amphoteric). Occasionally one water molecule transfers a proton to another:
\[ 2\,\text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \rightleftharpoons \text{H}_3\text{O}^+(aq) + \text{OH}^-(aq) \]
This is an equilibrium with a very small constant, called the ion-product constant of water. Pure liquid water is omitted from the expression:
\[ K_w = [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{OH}^-] = 1.0 \times 10^{-14} \quad (25\ ^\circ\text{C}) \]
In pure water the two ions are produced in equal numbers, so \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = [\text{OH}^-] = \sqrt{1.0 \times 10^{-14}} = 1.0 \times 10^{-7}\) M. Only about one molecule in 550 million is ionized at any instant.
The equation \(K_w = [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{OH}^-]\) is true for every aqueous solution at 25 °C, not just pure water. If you add acid and [H3O+] rises, then [OH−] must fall so that the product stays \(1.0 \times 10^{-14}\), and vice versa. A solution is:
neutral when \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = [\text{OH}^-]\) (\(1.0 \times 10^{-7}\) M each at 25 °C);
acidic when \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] \gt [\text{OH}^-]\);
basic when \([\text{OH}^-] \gt [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+]\).
The pH and pOH scales
Hydronium concentrations range over many powers of ten, so we use a logarithmic scale:
\[ \text{pH} = -\log[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] \qquad \text{pOH} = -\log[\text{OH}^-] \qquad \text{p}K_w = -\log K_w \]
Taking the negative log of \(K_w\) gives, at 25 °C,
\[ \text{pH} + \text{pOH} = \text{p}K_w = 14.00 \]
Because the scale is logarithmic, each pH unit is a factor of 10 in [H3O+]: a solution with pH 3 is ten times more acidic than pH 4 and a hundred times more acidic than pH 5. A smaller pH means a more acidic solution.
Figure 8.1a The pH scale at 25 °C. Each unit is a factor of 10 in [H3O+]: pH 3 has 100 times the hydronium of pH 5. Values for household substances are approximate.
Significant figures. The number of digits to the right of the decimal point in a pH equals the number of significant figures in the concentration: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 3.2 \times 10^{-4}\) (two significant figures) gives pH = 3.49 (two decimal places).
Worked example · from concentration to pH
[H3O+] in a sample of rainwater is \(3.2 \times 10^{-4}\) M. Find pH, pOH and [OH−], and classify the solution.
How many times greater is [H3O+] in a solution of pH 2.0 than in one of pH 5.0?
The difference of 3 pH units is a factor of \(10^3 = 1000\), so [H3O+] is 1000 times greater (\(1.0 \times 10^{-2}\) against \(1.0 \times 10^{-5}\)).
Temperature changes Kw
The autoionization of water is endothermic: it takes energy to pull a proton off a water molecule. By Le Châtelier’s principle, raising the temperature shifts the equilibrium to the right, so \(K_w\) increases. At 50 °C \(K_w = 5.5 \times 10^{-14}\). Pure water still has \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = [\text{OH}^-]\), so it is still neutral, but now each is \(\sqrt{5.5 \times 10^{-14}} = 2.3 \times 10^{-7}\) M and the pH is 6.63.
This does not mean the water has become acidic. Neutrality means [H3O+] = [OH−], and at 50 °C that happens at pH 6.63. The pH + pOH = 14 relation and the neutral value 7.0 apply only at 25 °C.
Worked example · neutral water at another temperature
At 50 °C, \(K_w = 5.5 \times 10^{-14}\). Find the pH of neutral water, and say whether a solution with pH 6.9 at this temperature is acidic, basic or neutral.
Neutral: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = \sqrt{5.5 \times 10^{-14}} = 2.3 \times 10^{-7}\) M, so pH = 6.63. A solution with pH 6.9 has a pH above 6.63, so \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] \lt [\text{OH}^-]\): it is slightly basic at this temperature, though it would look acidic at 25 °C.
Exam focus
pH = −log[H3O+]; pH + pOH = 14.00 at 25 °C only.
Neutral means equal concentrations, not pH 7, except at 25 °C.
Show Kw to convert between [H3O+] and [OH−].
One pH unit is a factor of 10.
Report pH to as many decimal places as the concentration has significant figures.
Practice
Find the pH and pOH of a solution with \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 4.0 \times 10^{-9}\) M.
Show answer
A student says that water at 100 °C with pH 6.1 is acidic. Evaluate.
Show answer
Not necessarily. Kw is much larger at 100 °C (about 5 × 10−13), so neutral water has a pH near 6.1 there. [H3O+] = [OH−] means neutral, so the water is neutral.
Why does adding acid to water decrease [OH−]?
Show answer
Kw = [H3O+][OH−] is constant at a given temperature. Adding acid increases [H3O+], shifting the autoionization equilibrium left (Le Châtelier), so [OH−] decreases until the product is again Kw.
Drain cleaner, battery acid and the hydrochloric acid in a swimming-pool store are all strong electrolytes, and the pH of their solutions needs almost no calculation. When an acid or base dissociates completely, the concentration of the ion that sets the pH is simply the concentration you made the solution at (times the number of ions per formula unit).
This lesson shows how little algebra you need for strong acids and bases, and how to avoid the few traps.
Learning objective · 8.2.A
Calculate pH and pOH based on concentrations of all species in a solution of a strong acid or a strong base.
Required content · EK 8.2.A.1 and 8.2.A.2
Molecules of a strong acid (e.g., HCl, HBr, HI, HClO4, H2SO4, and HNO3) will completely ionize in aqueous solution to produce hydronium ions and the conjugate base of the acid. As such, the concentration of H3O+ in a strong acid solution is equal to the initial concentration of the strong acid, and thus the pH of the strong acid solution is easily calculated.
When dissolved in solution, strong bases (e.g., group I and II hydroxides) completely dissociate to produce hydroxide ions. As such, the concentration of OH− in a strong base solution is equal to the initial concentration of a group I hydroxide and double the initial concentration of a group II hydroxide, and thus the pOH (and pH) of the strong base solution is easily calculated.
Strong acids
A strong acid transfers essentially every proton to water:
\[ \text{HA}(aq) + \text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \rightarrow \text{A}^-(aq) + \text{H}_3\text{O}^+(aq) \]
The common strong acids are HCl, HBr, HI, HClO4, HNO3 and H2SO4 (for sulfuric acid, only the first proton is strong). No un-ionized HA remains, so we write a single arrow, and
\[ [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = c_{\text{acid}} \qquad \text{pH} = -\log c_{\text{acid}} \]
Figure 8.2a Water molecules are omitted. A strong acid ionizes completely, so its [H3O+] equals the starting concentration. A weak acid sets up an equilibrium in which most molecules stay un-ionized.
Worked example · a strong acid
Find the pH of 0.025 M HCl.
HCl is strong, so \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 0.025\) M and \(\text{pH} = -\log(0.025) = \) 1.60. Then \(\text{pOH} = 12.40\) and \([\text{OH}^-] = 4.0 \times 10^{-13}\) M.
Worked example · after dilution
10.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl is diluted with water to a total volume of 1000. mL. Find the pH.
Moles of H+ = (0.0100 L)(0.100 M) = \(1.00 \times 10^{-3}\) mol, so the new concentration is \(1.00 \times 10^{-3}\) mol / 1.000 L = \(1.00 \times 10^{-3}\) M and pH = 3.00. A hundred-fold dilution raises the pH by 2 units.
Worked example · from pH to concentration
The pH of a nitric acid solution is 2.35. What is [HNO3]?
\([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 10^{-2.35} = 4.5 \times 10^{-3}\) M, and since HNO3 is strong, [HNO3] (as originally prepared) = \(4.5 \times 10^{-3}\) M.
Trap: very dilute acid. The formula \(\text{pH} = -\log c\) assumes that the acid supplies nearly all the hydronium. For a very dilute acid, such as \(1 \times 10^{-8}\) M HCl, the \(1 \times 10^{-7}\) M hydronium from water is not negligible, and the pH is about 6.98, not 8. Adding an acid can never make the solution basic.
Strong bases
The strong bases are the hydroxides of Group 1 and the heavier Group 2 metals (LiOH, NaOH, KOH, RbOH, CsOH; Ca(OH)2, Sr(OH)2, Ba(OH)2). These ionic solids dissociate completely, so the hydroxide concentration is the formula concentration times the number of OH− per formula unit:
Then use \(\text{pOH} = -\log[\text{OH}^-]\) and \(\text{pH} = 14.00 - \text{pOH}\). (Mg(OH)2 and Ca(OH)2 are only slightly soluble, which limits how concentrated such solutions can be.)
Worked example · a Group 1 hydroxide
Find the pH of 0.040 M NaOH.
\([\text{OH}^-] = 0.040\) M. \(\text{pOH} = -\log(0.040) = 1.40\), so \(\text{pH} = 14.00 - 1.40 = \) 12.60.
Worked example · a Group 2 hydroxide
Find the pH of 0.0050 M Ba(OH)2.
Each formula unit gives two hydroxides: \([\text{OH}^-] = 2(0.0050) = 0.0100\) M. \(\text{pOH} = 2.00\) and \(\text{pH} = \) 12.00.
Worked example · mass needed
What mass of NaOH (40.00 g/mol) is needed to make 500. mL of solution with pH 12.30?
\(\text{pOH} = 14.00 - 12.30 = 1.70\), so \([\text{OH}^-] = 10^{-1.70} = 0.0200\) M. Moles: \((0.0200\ \text{M})(0.500\ \text{L}) = 0.0100\) mol; mass = (0.0100 mol)(40.00 g/mol) = 0.40 g.
What does “strong” mean?
“Strong” describes how completely an acid ionizes, not how concentrated it is or how dangerous it is. A 0.0010 M solution of HCl is a dilute solution of a strong acid (pH 3.00), while a 10 M solution of acetic acid is a concentrated solution of a weak acid. The particle picture in the figure shows the difference: all of the strong acid is ionized, but most weak-acid molecules stay together. The next lesson tackles the weak case, where an equilibrium calculation is required.
Exam focus
Name the species list: know the six strong acids and the Group 1 and Group 2 hydroxides.
[H3O+] = c for a monoprotic strong acid; [OH−] = c × (OH− per formula).
Convert dilution first, then take the log.
A strong acid does not mean a concentrated acid.
Check that your answer is on the correct side of 7.
Practice
Find the pH of 0.0030 M HNO3.
Show answer
pH = −log(0.0030) = 2.52.
Find the pH of 0.015 M KOH.
Show answer
pOH = −log(0.015) = 1.82; pH = 12.18.
Find the pH of 0.0020 M Ca(OH)2.
Show answer
[OH−] = 0.0040 M; pOH = 2.40; pH = 11.60.
What is the concentration of HCl in a solution with pH 1.30?
Show answer
[HCl] = [H3O+] = 10−1.30 = 0.050 M.
25.0 mL of 0.200 M HCl is diluted to 500. mL. Find the new pH.
Show answer
Moles = 0.00500 mol; new concentration 0.0100 M; pH = 2.00.
A student calculates the pH of 1.0 × 10−9 M HCl as 9.0. Why is this impossible?
Show answer
An acid cannot give a basic solution. At such a low concentration the hydronium from the autoionization of water (1 × 10−7 M) dominates, so the pH is just below 7 (about 7.0).
Vinegar is acetic acid, and its pH is nowhere near that of a hydrochloric acid solution of the same concentration. Household ammonia is a base, yet it is far less caustic than lye of the same molarity. Most acids and bases in nature are weak: they ionize only a little, and the extent is set by an equilibrium constant.
This lesson applies everything from Unit 7 (K, ICE tables, the small-x approximation) to acids and bases.
Learning objective · 8.3.A
Explain the relationship among pH, pOH, and concentrations of all species in a solution of a monoprotic weak acid or weak base.
Required content · EK 8.3.A.1 to 8.3.A.6
Weak acids react with water to produce hydronium ions. However, only a small percentage of molecules of a weak acid will ionize in this way. Thus, the concentration of H3O+ is much less than the initial concentration of the molecular acid, and the vast majority of the acid molecules remain un-ionized.
A solution of a weak acid involves equilibrium between an un-ionized acid and its conjugate base. The equilibrium constant for this reaction is Ka, often reported as pKa. The pH of a weak acid solution can be determined from the initial acid concentration and the pKa: \(K_a = \dfrac{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]}\), \(\text{p}K_a = -\log K_a\).
Weak bases react with water to produce hydroxide ions in solution. However, ordinarily just a small percentage of the molecules of a weak base in solution will ionize in this way. Thus, the concentration of OH− in the solution does not equal the initial concentration of the base, and the vast majority of the base molecules remain un-ionized.
A solution of a weak base involves equilibrium between an un-ionized base and its conjugate acid. The equilibrium constant for this reaction is Kb, often reported as pKb. The pH of a weak base solution can be determined from the initial base concentration and the pKb: \(K_b = \dfrac{[\text{OH}^-][\text{HB}^+]}{[\text{B}]}\), \(\text{p}K_b = -\log K_b\).
The percent ionization of a weak acid (or base) can be calculated from its pKa (pKb) and the initial concentration of the acid (base). The percent ionization can also be calculated from the initial concentration of the acid (base) and the equilibrium concentration of any of the species in the equilibrium expression.
For any conjugate acid-base pair, the acid ionization constant and base ionization constant are related by Kw: \(K_w = K_a \times K_b\) and \(\text{p}K_w = \text{p}K_a + \text{p}K_b\).
The weak acid equilibrium
A weak acid HA ionizes only slightly, and the reaction is reversible:
\[ \text{HA}(aq) + \text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \rightleftharpoons \text{H}_3\text{O}^+(aq) + \text{A}^-(aq) \qquad K_a = \frac{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]} \]
The acid ionization constant \(K_a\) is small for weak acids (acetic acid: \(1.8 \times 10^{-5}\); hydrofluoric acid: \(6.8 \times 10^{-4}\); hydrocyanic acid: \(6.2 \times 10^{-10}\)); the smaller the \(K_a\), the weaker the acid. Often it is reported as \(\text{p}K_a = -\log K_a\) (acetic acid: 4.74, where a smaller pKa is a stronger acid). Liquid water is not included in the expression.
The same method as Unit 7 applies: ICE table, substitute into \(K_a\), solve. Here \(x\) is the hydronium concentration produced by ionization.
Worked example · pH of a weak acid
Find the pH and the percent ionization of 0.100 M acetic acid (\(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\)).
[HA]
[H3O+]
[A−]
I
0.100
≈ 0
0
C
−x
+x
+x
E
0.100 − x
x
x
\(K_a = \dfrac{x^2}{0.100 - x} = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\). Since \(K_a\) is small, assume \(x \ll 0.100\): \(x^2 = (1.8 \times 10^{-5})(0.100) = 1.8 \times 10^{-6}\), so \(x = 1.3 \times 10^{-3}\) M. Check the 5 percent rule: \(1.3 \times 10^{-3}/0.100 = 1.3\) percent, so the approximation is valid. \(\text{pH} = -\log(1.3 \times 10^{-3}) = \) 2.87. Percent ionization = \(\dfrac{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+]}{[\text{HA}]_0} \times 100\) = 1.3 percent: more than 98 percent of the molecules remain as HA. A 0.100 M strong acid would have pH 1.00.
Worked example · when the approximation fails
Find the pH of 0.0010 M acetic acid.
The approximation gives \(x = \sqrt{(1.8 \times 10^{-5})(0.0010)} = 1.3 \times 10^{-4}\) M, which is 13 percent of 0.0010: too large. Use the quadratic: \(x^2 + (1.8 \times 10^{-5})x - 1.8 \times 10^{-8} = 0\), so \(x = 1.25 \times 10^{-4}\) M and \(\text{pH} = \) 3.90. The percent ionization is 12.5 percent. Dilute solutions of a weak acid are ionized to a larger percentage: more dilution shifts the equilibrium toward more ions (Le Châtelier).
Worked example · finding Ka from pH
A 0.100 M solution of a weak acid HA has a pH of 2.50. Find \(K_a\).
\([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 10^{-2.50} = 3.2 \times 10^{-3}\) M \(= [\text{A}^-]\), and \([\text{HA}] = 0.100 - 0.0032 = 0.0968\) M. \(K_a = \dfrac{(3.2 \times 10^{-3})^2}{0.0968} = \) \(1.0 \times 10^{-4}\). The percent ionization is 3.2 percent, and pKa = 4.0.
The weak base equilibrium
A weak base B accepts a proton from water, producing hydroxide:
\[ \text{B}(aq) + \text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \rightleftharpoons \text{HB}^+(aq) + \text{OH}^-(aq) \qquad K_b = \frac{[\text{HB}^+][\text{OH}^-]}{[\text{B}]} \]
Ammonia is the classic example (NH3 + H2O ⇌ NH4+ + OH−, \(K_b = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\)). The calculation gives \([\text{OH}^-]\), so you find pOH first and then pH.
Worked example · pH of a weak base
Find the pH and percent ionization of 0.200 M NH3.
The conjugate base of a weak acid (A−) is itself a weak base, and the conjugate acid of a weak base (HB+) is a weak acid. Their constants are linked: adding the two reactions gives the autoionization of water, so the constants multiply to \(K_w\):
\[ K_a \times K_b = K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14} \qquad \text{p}K_a + \text{p}K_b = 14.00 \]
The stronger the acid, the weaker its conjugate base: acetic acid (\(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\)) has the conjugate base acetate with \(K_b = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}/1.8 \times 10^{-5} = 5.6 \times 10^{-10}\). The conjugate bases of strong acids (Cl−, NO3−) are so weak they do not react with water at all.
Figure 8.3a Acid and conjugate-base strengths run in opposite directions. Strong acids have conjugate bases too weak to react with water; very weak acids have strongly basic conjugates. For any pair, Ka × Kb = Kw.
Worked example · a salt of a weak acid
Find the pH of 0.10 M sodium acetate (NaCH3COO). \(K_a(\text{CH}_3\text{COOH}) = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\).
Na+ is the cation of a strong base and does nothing. Acetate is a weak base: CH3COO− + H2O ⇌ CH3COOH + OH−. \(K_b = 5.6 \times 10^{-10}\). \(x^2/0.10 = 5.6 \times 10^{-10}\), so \([\text{OH}^-] = x = 7.5 \times 10^{-6}\) M, pOH = 5.13 and pH = 8.87. A solution of the salt of a weak acid is basic.
Worked example · Kb of a conjugate base
\(K_a\) of HF is \(6.8 \times 10^{-4}\). Find \(K_b\) of F−.
\(K_b = K_w/K_a = (1.0 \times 10^{-14})/(6.8 \times 10^{-4}) = 1.5 \times 10^{-11}\). Fluoride is a very weak base.
Exam focus
Write the reaction with water, the K expression and the ICE table. [H2O] is not included.
Justify the approximation with the 5 percent rule; use the quadratic if it fails (dilute solutions).
Weak base: x is [OH−]. Find pOH, then pH.
Ka × Kb = Kw for a conjugate pair; stronger acid means weaker conjugate base.
Percent ionization = [ionized]/[initial] × 100 and increases on dilution.
Practice
Find the pH of 0.50 M HF (\(K_a = 6.8 \times 10^{-4}\)).
Show answer
\(x = \sqrt{(6.8 \times 10^{-4})(0.50)} = 0.0184\) M. That is 3.7 percent of 0.50 (valid). pH = −log(0.0184) = 1.73.
Find the pH of 0.050 M methylamine, \(K_b = 4.4 \times 10^{-4}\) (use the quadratic if needed).
Show answer
Approximation: \(x = \sqrt{(4.4 \times 10^{-4})(0.050)} = 4.7 \times 10^{-3}\), which is 9.4 percent of 0.050, too large. Quadratic: \(x^2 + 4.4 \times 10^{-4}x - 2.2 \times 10^{-5} = 0\) gives \(x = 4.5 \times 10^{-3}\) M. pOH = 2.35; pH = 11.65.
The pKa of formic acid is 3.75. Find Ka and the pKb of formate.
Show answer
Two 0.10 M acids have \(K_a = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\) and \(1.0 \times 10^{-7}\). Which has the lower pH, and by roughly how many pH units do the solutions differ?
Show answer
The \(1.0 \times 10^{-3}\) acid: \(x = \sqrt{10^{-4}} = 0.010\), pH 2.0 (approximately). The other: \(x = \sqrt{10^{-8}} = 1.0 \times 10^{-4}\), pH 4.0. They differ by 2 pH units.
A weak acid solution has \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 2.0 \times 10^{-3}\) M at an initial acid concentration of 0.050 M. Find the percent ionization.
Show answer
(2.0 × 10−3/0.050) × 100 = 4.0 percent.
Is a solution of NH4Cl acidic, basic or neutral? Explain with the equilibrium.
Show answer
Acidic. NH4+ is the conjugate acid of a weak base: NH4+ + H2O ⇌ NH3 + H3O+. Cl− is the conjugate base of a strong acid and has no effect.
An antacid tablet neutralizes stomach acid, a baker’s sour milk reacts with baking soda, and an analytical chemist mixes a measured amount of base into an unknown acid to find its concentration. In each case an acid and a base are combined, and the question is the same: what is the pH of the result?
The method has two stages, and learning to separate them is the key to every acid-base problem on the exam.
Learning objective · 8.4.A
Explain the relationship among the concentrations of major species in a mixture of weak and strong acids and bases.
Required content · EK 8.4.A.1 to 8.4.A.4
When a strong acid and a strong base are mixed, they react quantitatively in a reaction represented by the equation H+(aq) + OH−(aq) → H2O(l). The pH of the resulting solution may be determined from the concentration of excess reagent.
When a weak acid and a strong base are mixed, they react quantitatively in a reaction represented by the equation HA(aq) + OH−(aq) → A−(aq) + H2O(l). If the weak acid is in excess, then a buffer solution is formed, and the pH can be determined from the Henderson-Hasselbalch (H-H) equation. If the strong base is in excess, then the pH can be determined from the moles of excess hydroxide ion and the total volume of solution. If they are equimolar, then the (slightly basic) pH can be determined from the equilibrium represented by the equation A−(aq) + H2O(l) ⇌ HA(aq) + OH−(aq).
When a weak base and a strong acid are mixed, they will react quantitatively in a reaction represented by the equation B(aq) + H3O+(aq) → HB+(aq) + H2O(l). If the weak base is in excess, then a buffer solution is formed, and the pH can be determined from the H-H equation. If the strong acid is in excess, then the pH can be determined from the moles of excess hydronium ion and the total volume of solution. If they are equimolar, then the (slightly acidic) pH can be determined from the equilibrium represented by the equation HB+(aq) + H2O(l) ⇌ B(aq) + H3O+(aq).
When a weak acid and a weak base are mixed, they will react to an equilibrium state whose reaction may be represented by the equation HA(aq) + B(aq) ⇌ A−(aq) + HB+(aq).
The two-stage method
Whenever a strong acid or strong base is added to something, the first stage is a stoichiometry problem and the second is an equilibrium problem:
Neutralization (reaction goes to completion). Calculate the moles of each reactant (\(n = MV\), conveniently in millimoles when volumes are in mL and concentrations in M), let the reaction with the strong reagent go to completion, and find the moles left of each species.
Identify the major species in the final solution and calculate the pH with the method appropriate to that mixture, using the total volume.
The reaction of a strong acid or base with a weak partner is essentially complete because its equilibrium constant is huge. For instance, HA + OH− → A− + H2O has \(K = K_a/K_w\), which for acetic acid is \(1.8 \times 10^{-5}/1.0 \times 10^{-14} = 1.8 \times 10^9\).
Strong acid + strong base
H3O+ + OH− → 2 H2O. After the reaction, whichever reagent is in excess controls the pH. If the amounts are exactly equal, the solution contains only the neutral ions and water: pH = 7.00 at 25 °C.
Worked example · excess strong acid
25.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl is mixed with 40.0 mL of 0.0500 M NaOH. Find the pH.
Moles: H+ = (25.0)(0.100) = 2.50 mmol; OH− = (40.0)(0.0500) = 2.00 mmol. After neutralization, 0.50 mmol H+ remains in a total volume of 65.0 mL: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 0.50/65.0 = 7.7 \times 10^{-3}\) M, so pH = 2.11.
Weak acid + strong base
HA + OH− → A− + H2O. After the reaction there are four possible situations:
Mole ratio
What remains
How to find pH
Before any base is added
only HA
weak-acid equilibrium (lesson 8.3)
OH− less than HA
HA and A−: a buffer
Henderson-Hasselbalch (lesson 8.7)
OH− equal to HA
only A− (a weak base)
weak-base equilibrium; pH > 7
OH− more than HA
A− and excess OH−
excess OH− (the weak base adds negligibly)
Worked example · weak acid in excess (a buffer)
50.0 mL of 0.100 M acetic acid (pKa = 4.74) is mixed with 20.0 mL of 0.100 M NaOH. Find the pH.
HA = 5.00 mmol; OH− = 2.00 mmol. After reaction: HA = 3.00 mmol and A− = 2.00 mmol, a buffer. \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\dfrac{[\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]} = 4.74 + \log\dfrac{2.00}{3.00} = 4.74 - 0.18 = \) 4.56. (The ratio of moles equals the ratio of concentrations since both are in the same volume.)
Worked example · equal moles
50.0 mL of 0.100 M acetic acid is mixed with 50.0 mL of 0.100 M NaOH. Find the pH.
Both are 5.00 mmol, so all HA becomes A−: 5.00 mmol in 100.0 mL = 0.0500 M. Acetate is a weak base: \(K_b = 5.6 \times 10^{-10}\). \([\text{OH}^-] = \sqrt{(5.6 \times 10^{-10})(0.0500)} = 5.3 \times 10^{-6}\) M, pOH = 5.28, pH = 8.72: slightly basic, as the CED says.
Worked example · strong base in excess
50.0 mL of 0.100 M acetic acid is mixed with 60.0 mL of 0.100 M NaOH. Find the pH.
OH− = 6.00 mmol exceeds HA = 5.00 mmol by 1.00 mmol. Total volume 110.0 mL: \([\text{OH}^-] = 1.00/110.0 = 9.1 \times 10^{-3}\) M, pOH = 2.04, pH = 11.96. The acetate (a very weak base) adds a negligible amount of OH−.
Weak base + strong acid
B + H3O+ → HB+ + H2O. The pattern mirrors the previous one: excess base gives a buffer (B and HB+); equal moles leave only the conjugate acid HB+, giving a slightly acidic pH; excess strong acid sets the pH from the excess H3O+.
Worked example · equal moles of weak base and strong acid
25.0 mL of 0.100 M NH3 is mixed with 25.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl. Find the pH. (\(K_b = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\), so \(K_a(\text{NH}_4^+) = 5.6 \times 10^{-10}\).)
2.50 mmol of each. All NH3 becomes NH4+: 2.50 mmol in 50.0 mL = 0.0500 M. NH4+ + H2O ⇌ NH3 + H3O+: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = \sqrt{(5.6 \times 10^{-10})(0.0500)} = 5.3 \times 10^{-6}\) M, pH = 5.28.
Worked example · weak base in excess
50.0 mL of 0.100 M NH3 is mixed with 20.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl. Find the pH.
Mixing a weak acid and a weak base gives an equilibrium: HA + B ⇌ A− + HB+. Which side is favored depends on the relative strengths. The proton goes to the stronger base from the stronger acid, so the equilibrium lies toward the weaker acid and weaker base. For acetic acid and ammonia, \(K = K_a(\text{HA})/K_a(\text{HB}^+) = (1.8 \times 10^{-5})/(5.6 \times 10^{-10}) = 3.2 \times 10^4\): the products are strongly favored.
Exam focus
Stoichiometry first (limiting reagent, in mmol), equilibrium second.
Use the total volume when you convert excess moles to a concentration.
Name the major species after the reaction: it tells you which equation to use.
Equal moles of weak acid and strong base: pH > 7. Weak base and strong acid: pH < 7.
Write the net ionic equation with the proper arrow: complete (→) for strong reagents.
Practice
Find the pH after mixing 30.0 mL of 0.200 M HNO3 with 20.0 mL of 0.100 M KOH.
Show answer
H+ = 6.00 mmol; OH− = 2.00 mmol; excess H+ = 4.00 mmol in 50.0 mL = 0.0800 M; pH = 1.10.
Find the pH after mixing 20.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl with 30.0 mL of 0.100 M NaOH.
Show answer
H+ = 2.00 mmol; OH− = 3.00 mmol; excess OH− = 1.00 mmol in 50.0 mL = 0.0200 M; pOH = 1.70; pH = 12.30.
40.0 mL of 0.100 M HF (pKa = 3.17) is mixed with 10.0 mL of 0.100 M NaOH. Find the pH.
Show answer
How much acid is in a bottle of vinegar? How much base is in a cleaning product? The answer comes from a titration: you add a solution of known concentration from a buret, little by little, to a measured sample of the unknown until the reaction is exactly complete.
A graph of pH against volume added, a titration curve, then tells you far more than the one point where the reaction ends: it reveals the strength of the acid and the pKa too.
Learning objective · 8.5.A
Explain results from the titration of a mono- or polyprotic acid or base solution, in relation to the properties of the solution and its components.
Required content · EK 8.5.A.1 to 8.5.A.5
An acid-base reaction can be carried out under controlled conditions in a titration. A titration curve, plotting pH against the volume of titrant added, is useful for summarizing results from a titration.
At the equivalence point for titrations of monoprotic acids or bases, the number of moles of titrant added is equal to the number of moles of analyte originally present. This relationship can be used to obtain the concentration of the analyte. This is the case for titrations of strong acids/bases and weak acids/bases.
For titrations of weak acids/bases, it is useful to consider the point halfway to the equivalence point, that is, the half-equivalence point. At this point, there are equal concentrations of each species in the conjugate acid-base pair, for example, for a weak acid [HA] = [A−]. Because pH = pKa when the conjugate acid and base have equal concentrations, the pKa can be determined from the pH at the half-equivalence point in a titration.
At the equivalence point, pH is determined by the major species in solution. Strong acid and strong base titrations result in neutral pH at the equivalence point. However, in titrations of weak acids (weak bases), the conjugate base of the weak acid (conjugate acid of the weak base) is present at the equivalence point and can undergo proton-transfer reactions with the surrounding water, producing basic (acidic) solutions.
For polyprotic acids, titration curves can be used to determine the number of acidic protons. In doing so, the major species present at any point along the curve can be identified, along with the pKa associated with each proton in a weak polyprotic acid.
Exclusion: computation of the concentration of each species present in the titration curve for polyprotic acids is not assessed (qualitative reasoning about which species are present in large versus small concentrations is within scope).
Titration vocabulary
The titrant is the solution of known concentration in the buret; the analyte is the solution of unknown concentration in the flask.
The equivalence point is where the moles of titrant added exactly equal the moles needed to react with the analyte (for a monoprotic acid and a monobasic base: \(n_{\text{titrant}} = n_{\text{analyte}}\)).
The endpoint is where the indicator changes color. A good indicator makes the endpoint very close to the equivalence point (lesson 8.7).
The half-equivalence point is when exactly half of the volume needed to reach the equivalence point has been added.
At the equivalence point of any monoprotic acid-base titration, \(M_aV_a = M_bV_b\). This gives the unknown concentration. The molar relationship changes if the acid or base has more than one proton or hydroxide (\(n_a M_aV_a = n_b M_bV_b\) with the numbers of protons \(n\)).
Worked example · concentration from the equivalence point
It takes 15.60 mL of 0.1000 M NaOH to titrate 20.00 mL of HCl of unknown concentration to the equivalence point. Find [HCl].
Moles NaOH = (0.01560 L)(0.1000 M) = \(1.560 \times 10^{-3}\) mol = moles HCl. [HCl] = \(1.560 \times 10^{-3}\) mol / 0.02000 L = 0.0780 M.
Strong acid with strong base
Figure 8.5a 25.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl titrated with 0.100 M NaOH. The curve is nearly flat, then rises almost vertically at the equivalence point (25.0 mL), where pH = 7 because only Na+, Cl− and water are present.
For 25.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl titrated with 0.100 M NaOH the pH changes very slowly at first (a large amount of acid remains), then abruptly near the equivalence point. Typical points (using the two-stage method from the last lesson):
V of NaOH (mL)
0
10.00
24.90
25.00
25.10
30.00
pH
1.00
1.37
3.70
7.00
10.30
11.96
From 24.90 mL to 25.10 mL (a change of two drops) the pH jumps by about 6.6 units. At the equivalence point only Na+, Cl− and water are present, so pH = 7.00. Titrating a strong base with a strong acid gives the mirror image, falling from high pH to low, with its equivalence point also at pH 7.
Weak acid with strong base
Figure 8.5b 25.0 mL of 0.100 M acetic acid (Ka = 1.8 × 10−5) titrated with 0.100 M NaOH. The half-equivalence point (12.5 mL) has [HA] = [A−], so pH = pKa. At the equivalence point the solution contains A−, a weak base, so the pH is above 7.
The curve for a weak acid is different in four ways:
Higher initial pH (the acid is only slightly ionized): for 0.100 M acetic acid, 2.87 rather than 1.00.
A buffer region before the equivalence point, where both HA and A− are present in large amounts, so the pH changes gradually.
The half-equivalence point in the middle of the buffer region, where \([\text{HA}] = [\text{A}^-]\), so \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a\).
An equivalence point above 7: all the HA has become A−, a weak base, so the pH is basic. For 0.100 M acetic acid (25.0 mL) titrated with 0.100 M NaOH it is 8.72 (from the previous lesson).
V of NaOH (mL)
0
6.25
12.50
18.75
25.00
30.00
pH
2.87
4.26
4.74
5.22
8.72
11.96
The values at 6.25 and 18.75 mL are \(\text{p}K_a + \log(1/3)\) and \(\text{p}K_a + \log 3\): one quarter and three quarters of the way to the equivalence point. After the equivalence point the curve follows the same excess-hydroxide values as for the strong acid. Titrating a weak base with a strong acid mirrors this: the equivalence point is below 7 (the conjugate acid is present) and the half-equivalence point gives \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a\) of the conjugate acid (so \(\text{pOH} = \text{p}K_b\)).
Worked example · finding Ka from a curve
25.00 mL of an unknown monoprotic weak acid is titrated with 0.1000 M NaOH. The equivalence point is at 18.40 mL, and the pH after 9.20 mL is 3.85. Find the concentration of the acid and its Ka.
Moles NaOH at equivalence = (0.01840)(0.1000) = \(1.840 \times 10^{-3}\) mol = moles HA. [HA] = \(1.840 \times 10^{-3}/0.02500\) = 0.0736 M. 9.20 mL is half of 18.40 mL, so this is the half-equivalence point, \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a = 3.85\), and \(K_a = 10^{-3.85} = \) \(1.4 \times 10^{-4}\).
Worked example · comparing curves
Two titration curves for 25.0 mL of 0.100 M acid with 0.100 M NaOH have equivalence points at the same volume (25.0 mL). Curve A begins at pH 1 and has its equivalence point at pH 7. Curve B begins at pH 2.9 and has its equivalence point at pH 8.7. Identify each.
Curve A: a strong acid (high [H3O+], neutral equivalence point). Curve B: a weak acid (low initial ionization, basic equivalence point because A− is a base). The same volume shows both acids have the same concentration and number of moles; the strength is shown by the shape.
Polyprotic acids
Figure 8.5c Titration of a diprotic weak acid H2A. Each acidic proton gives its own equivalence point and its own buffer region. Halfway to each equivalence point the pH equals the corresponding pKa: the number of steep rises counts the acidic protons.
A polyprotic acid has more than one acidic proton (H2SO4, H2CO3, H3PO4). Each proton is removed in its own step with its own \(K_a\), and each step is harder than the last (\(K_{a1} \gt K_{a2} \gt K_{a3}\)), because it is harder to remove a proton from a negatively charged ion. If the \(K_a\) values are far enough apart, the titration curve has one buffer region and one steep rise per acidic proton.
The number of steep rises (equivalence points) equals the number of acidic protons that can be titrated.
The volume of the second equivalence point is twice that of the first for a diprotic acid (equal moles of base per proton).
Halfway to the first equivalence point \([\text{H}_2\text{A}] = [\text{HA}^-]\) and pH = pKa1. Halfway between the first and second equivalence points \([\text{HA}^-] = [\text{A}^{2-}]\) and pH = pKa2.
At the first equivalence point the major species is HA−; at the second it is A2−.
Worked example · identifying species on a diprotic curve
For the diprotic acid H2A in the figure (first equivalence point at 20.0 mL, second at 40.0 mL), which species are the major ones at 10 mL, 20 mL, 30 mL and 40 mL?
10 mL: the half-way point to the first equivalence: equal H2A and HA− (pH = pKa1). 20 mL: mostly HA−. 30 mL: equal HA− and A2− (pH = pKa2). 40 mL: mostly A2−. The acid concentration follows from the second volume: if 20.00 mL of acid needs 40.00 mL of 0.1000 M NaOH for both protons, \([\text{H}_2\text{A}] = (0.1000)(40.00)/2/20.00 = 0.100\) M.
Exam focus
At the equivalence point, moles titrant = moles analyte (adjust for the number of protons).
In a titration of a weak acid with NaOH, the pH at the half-equivalence point is 5.10. What is the Ka?
Show answer
pKa = 5.10, so Ka = 10−5.10 = 7.9 × 10−6.
A weak acid titration has its equivalence point at 40.0 mL. At what volume is pH = pKa?
Show answer
At the half-equivalence point: 20.0 mL.
Why is the equivalence point above 7 when a weak acid is titrated with NaOH?
Show answer
At the equivalence point all the weak acid has been converted to its conjugate base, A−, which reacts with water (A− + H2O ⇌ HA + OH−) to produce hydroxide, so the solution is basic.
A titration curve of an acid shows three steep rises. What can you conclude?
Show answer
The acid has three titratable acidic protons (triprotic), such as H3PO4, with the three Ka values distinct enough to show separately.
For 25.00 mL of 0.0800 M NH3 titrated with 0.1000 M HCl, what volume of HCl is needed to reach the equivalence point, and is the pH there above or below 7?
Show answer
Moles NH3 = 2.000 × 10−3 mol, so V = 2.000 × 10−3/0.1000 = 20.00 mL. Below 7, because NH4+, a weak acid, is the major species.
Why is hydrochloric acid strong and acetic acid weak? Why is a carboxylic acid so much more acidic than an alcohol that also contains an O–H bond? Strength is not a mystery; it follows from structure.
An acid is strong when the conjugate base left behind is stable, because a stable conjugate base is happy to exist after the proton leaves. This lesson turns that single idea into a set of reasons you can use to explain and predict trends in acid strength.
Learning objective · 8.6.A
Explain the relationship between the strength of an acid or base and the structure of the molecule or ion.
Required content · EK 8.6.A.1
The protons on a molecule that will participate in acid-base reactions, and the relative strength of these protons, can be inferred from the molecular structure. (i) Strong acids (such as HCl, HBr, HI, HClO4, H2SO4, and HNO3) have very weak conjugate bases that are stabilized by electronegativity, inductive effects, resonance, or some combination thereof. (ii) Carboxylic acids are one common class of weak acid. (iii) Strong bases (such as group I and II hydroxides) have very weak conjugate acids. (iv) Common weak bases include nitrogenous bases such as ammonia as well as carboxylate ions. (v) Electronegative elements tend to stabilize the conjugate base relative to the conjugate acid, and so increase acid strength.
The central idea: stable conjugate base, strong acid
HA ⇌ H+ + A−. The more stable the anion A− is (relative to HA), the further the equilibrium lies to the right, and the stronger the acid. Anything that spreads out or stabilizes the negative charge on A− makes the acid stronger. Four factors do this.
Factor 1: electronegativity of the atom bearing the charge
An electronegative atom holds a negative charge more comfortably. Across a period the acidity of the hydrides rises as the atom bearing the negative charge becomes more electronegative:
\[ \text{CH}_4 \lt \text{NH}_3 \lt \text{H}_2\text{O} \lt \text{HF} \]
Fluorine is the most electronegative, so F− is the most stable of the conjugate bases and HF the strongest acid of the four (CH4 and NH3 are essentially not acidic in water).
Factor 2: size of the atom and bond strength (down a group)
Going down Group 17 the order of acidity reverses: HF is a weak acid (\(K_a = 6.8 \times 10^{-4}\)), while HCl, HBr and HI are strong, and HI is the strongest. The H–X bond becomes longer and weaker, and the large anion spreads its charge over a larger volume, so the proton leaves more easily. For acids with the proton on atoms in the same group, bond length and bond strength outweigh electronegativity.
Factor 3: the inductive effect
Electronegative atoms elsewhere in the molecule pull electron density through the bonds toward themselves. This inductive effect stabilizes the negative charge of the conjugate base. The more electronegative atoms nearby and the closer they are, the stronger the acid.
Figure 8.6a Structure and acid strength. Replacing hydrogens on the carbon next to the carboxyl group with electronegative chlorine atoms withdraws electron density, stabilizes the carboxylate anion, and strengthens the acid. Each added Cl raises Ka: by factors of about 77, 33 and 5 for the first, second and third chlorine.
Replacing hydrogens on the carbon next to the carboxyl group of acetic acid with chlorine lowers the pKa step by step: acetic acid 4.76, chloroacetic acid 2.87, dichloroacetic acid 1.35, trichloroacetic acid 0.66. The same effect makes the oxoacids of chlorine stronger as the number of oxygen atoms on the chlorine increases: HClO (pKa about 7.5) < HClO2 (about 2) < HClO3 < HClO4, the last two being strong. Each extra oxygen atom pulls electron density away from the O–H bond and stabilizes the anion. H2SO4 and HNO3 are strong, while H2SO3 and HNO2 (with one fewer oxygen) are weak.
Factor 4: resonance
If the negative charge on the conjugate base can be shared among several atoms (resonance), it is stabilized. When a carboxylic acid loses its proton, the carboxylate ion RCOO− has two equivalent resonance structures with the charge shared between two oxygen atoms. An alcohol such as ethanol loses its proton to give an alkoxide, RO−, whose charge is stuck on one oxygen. That is why a carboxylic acid (\(K_a \approx 10^{-5}\)) is about \(10^{11}\) times more acidic than an alcohol (\(K_a \approx 10^{-16}\)) even though both have an O–H bond. For a strong oxoacid such as HNO3, the nitrate ion has three equivalent resonance structures.
Worked example · explaining which acid is stronger
Explain why trichloroacetic acid (pKa 0.66) is stronger than acetic acid (pKa 4.76).
The three electronegative Cl atoms on the carbon next to the carboxyl group pull electron density away from the carboxylate through the bonds (inductive effect). This stabilizes the trichloroacetate anion relative to acetate, so the equilibrium lies further toward ionization: a larger Ka and a stronger acid.
Worked example · ranking by structure
Rank HClO, HClO3 and HClO2 from strongest to weakest acid and justify.
HClO3 > HClO2 > HClO. They have the same central atom, so the one with more oxygen atoms on chlorine has the stronger electron withdrawal and a more stable conjugate base (more resonance structures too), and so is the stronger acid.
Bases
The same ideas run in reverse. A base is strong when its conjugate acid is very weak (the proton is held very tightly after it is accepted).
Strong bases are the hydroxides of Groups 1 and 2: the OH− ion is the conjugate base of water, an extremely weak acid.
Weak bases include ammonia and the nitrogenous bases (amines), where the lone pair on nitrogen accepts a proton, and carboxylate ions, the conjugate bases of carboxylic acids. Carboxylates are weak because their conjugate acids (carboxylic acids) are not very weak.
Alkyl groups donate electron density to nitrogen, so amines are generally stronger bases than ammonia: methylamine \(K_b = 4.4 \times 10^{-4}\) compared with ammonia \(1.8 \times 10^{-5}\). Electron-withdrawing groups or resonance delocalization of the lone pair make nitrogen bases weaker.
The conjugate bases of strong acids (Cl−, Br−, NO3−, ClO4−) are extremely weak, with negligible basicity in water.
Worked example · which protons are acidic?
Acetic acid, CH3COOH, has four hydrogens. Which one is acidic and why?
Only the hydrogen on the O of the carboxyl group. Removing it leaves the carboxylate CH3COO−, stabilized by resonance over two oxygens and by the electronegativity of oxygen. The C–H hydrogens would leave a carbanion on carbon with no stabilization: they are not acidic in water.
Exam focus
Argue from the conjugate base: a more stable A− means a stronger acid.
Name the factor: electronegativity, bond strength/size, inductive effect or resonance.
Oxoacids: more oxygen atoms (or more electronegative central atoms) means a stronger acid.
Halogens: HI > HBr > HCl >> HF down the group (bond strength dominates).
Strong acid, very weak conjugate base; strong base, very weak conjugate acid.
Practice
Explain why HI is a stronger acid than HF.
Show answer
The H–I bond is much longer and weaker than the H–F bond, and the large iodide ion spreads its negative charge over a large volume, so HI ionizes more completely. (F is more electronegative, but bond strength dominates down a group.)
Arrange in order of increasing acid strength: CH3COOH, CH2ClCOOH, CHCl2COOH. Explain.
Show answer
CH3COOH < CH2ClCOOH < CHCl2COOH. More chlorine atoms stabilize the carboxylate through the inductive effect, increasing acid strength.
Why is a carboxylic acid more acidic than an alcohol?
Show answer
The carboxylate anion is stabilized by resonance (charge shared between two oxygens), while the alkoxide ion of an alcohol has its charge on a single oxygen.
Which is the stronger acid, H2SO4 or H2SO3? Justify.
Show answer
H2SO4. It has more oxygen atoms on the sulfur, which withdraw electron density and stabilize the conjugate base (HSO4−) through the inductive effect and resonance.
Why is methylamine a stronger base than ammonia?
Show answer
The methyl group donates electron density to nitrogen, making the lone pair more available to accept a proton and stabilizing the conjugate acid CH3NH3+.
Why is the acetate ion a weak base but the hydroxide ion a strong base?
Show answer
Acetate is the conjugate base of a moderately weak acid (acetic acid, Ka = 1.8 × 10−5) and is stabilized by resonance, so it has little tendency to accept a proton. Hydroxide is the conjugate base of water, an extremely weak acid, so it takes protons very readily.
Phenolphthalein turns pink at about pH 8.2, and litmus changes from red to blue near pH 7. Amino acids in your body switch between charged forms as the pH around them shifts. All of these respond to the same comparison: the pH of the solution against the pKa of an acid.
Put that comparison into an equation and you get the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, the quickest way to find the pH of a buffer.
Learning objectives · 8.7.A and 8.9.A
8.7.A Explain the relationship between the predominant form of a weak acid or base in solution at a given pH and the pKa of the conjugate acid or the pKb of the conjugate base. 8.9.A Identify the pH of a buffer solution based on the identity and concentrations of the conjugate acid-base pair used to create the buffer.
Required content · EK 8.7.A.1 to 8.7.A.3 and 8.9.A.1
The protonation state of an acid or base (i.e., the relative concentrations of HA and A−) can be predicted by comparing the pH of a solution to the pKa of the acid in that solution. When solution pH < acid pKa, the acid form has a higher concentration than the base form. When solution pH > acid pKa, the base form has a higher concentration than the acid form.
Acid-base indicators are substances that exhibit different properties (such as color) in their protonated versus deprotonated state, making that property respond to the pH of a solution.
To ensure accurate results in a titration experiment, acid-base indicators should be selected that have a pKa close to the pH at the equivalence point.
The pH of the buffer is related to the pKa of the acid and the concentration ratio of the conjugate acid-base pair. This relation is a consequence of the equilibrium expression associated with the dissociation of a weak acid, and is described by the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation: \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\dfrac{[\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]}\). Adding small amounts of acid or base to a buffered solution does not significantly change the ratio of [A−]/[HA] and thus does not significantly change the solution pH. The change in pH on addition of acid or base to a buffered solution is therefore much less than it would have been in the absence of the buffer.
Exclusions: computation of the change in pH resulting from the addition of an acid or a base to a buffer, and the derivation of the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, are not assessed.
Which form predominates?
Rearrange the acid ionization expression, \(K_a = [\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{A}^-]/[\text{HA}]\), to put the ratio of the two forms on one side:
\[ \frac{[\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]} = \frac{K_a}{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+]} \]
The ratio of the base form to the acid form is set by how \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+]\) compares with \(K_a\), or, equivalently, how pH compares with pKa:
Figure 8.7a Fraction of acetic acid as HA and as A− against pH (pKa = 4.74). Below the pKa the acid form dominates; above it the conjugate base dominates; at the pKa they are equal. A pH one unit away gives a 10 : 1 ratio.
pH < pKa: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] \gt K_a\), so \([\text{HA}] \gt [\text{A}^-]\): the acid form predominates.
pH = pKa: equal amounts of the two forms.
pH > pKa: the base form predominates.
This is the easiest way to remember it: at low pH (lots of H+), the proton stays on the molecule. A pH one unit away from the pKa corresponds to a 10 : 1 ratio, and two units away to a 100 : 1 ratio.
Worked example · predominant form
For acetic acid (pKa = 4.74), which form predominates at pH 2.0, 4.74 and 7.4, and what is the ratio at pH 7.4?
At pH 2.0 (below the pKa): CH3COOH. At 4.74: equal amounts. At 7.4 (above): CH3COO−, with \([\text{A}^-]/[\text{HA}] = 10^{7.4 - 4.74} = 10^{2.66} = 460\). So in blood, acetic acid exists almost completely as acetate.
Worked example · the same idea for a base
The pKa of NH4+ is 9.25. In a solution of pH 7.0 is ammonia mostly NH3 or NH4+?
The pH (7.0) is below the pKa of the conjugate acid (9.25), so the acid form, NH4+, predominates (by a factor of \(10^{2.25} \approx 180\)). Bases are protonated at low pH.
Indicators
An acid-base indicator is itself a weak acid HIn whose protonated and deprotonated forms differ in color. The color you see depends on the ratio \([\text{In}^-]/[\text{HIn}]\), which is controlled by pH. The eye detects a change when the ratio goes from about 1 : 10 to 10 : 1, so an indicator changes color over a range of about \(\text{p}K_a \pm 1\) (two pH units).
Indicator
Transition range
Acid color → base color
Methyl orange
3.1 to 4.4
red → yellow
Methyl red
4.4 to 6.2
red → yellow
Bromothymol blue
6.0 to 7.6
yellow → blue
Phenolphthalein
8.2 to 10.0
colorless → pink
To signal the end of a titration the indicator should change color where the pH jumps, so choose one whose \(\text{p}K_a\) (the midpoint of its range) is close to the pH at the equivalence point:
Strong acid-strong base (equivalence pH 7, steep over a wide range): bromothymol blue, or nearly any of the indicators above.
Weak acid-strong base (equivalence pH about 8.7): phenolphthalein.
Weak base-strong acid (equivalence pH about 5.3): methyl red.
Worked example · choosing an indicator
The equivalence point of a titration of 0.100 M acetic acid with NaOH is at pH 8.72. Which indicator should be used and why would methyl orange be a poor choice?
Phenolphthalein (8.2 to 10.0) changes color right where the pH is rising steeply through 8.7. Methyl orange (3.1 to 4.4) would change color early, at a pH reached during the buffer region long before the equivalence point, so the endpoint would be far from the equivalence point and the measured concentration would be wrong.
The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation
Take the logarithm of the expression above with a sign change, and you have the form used for buffers (a solution with sizable amounts of both HA and A−):
\[ \text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\frac{[\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]} \]
The ratio uses the equilibrium concentrations of the base and acid forms; for a buffer made by mixing HA and A− these are essentially the amounts you added, since little ionization occurs. Because both species are in the same solution, the volumes cancel and you may use moles instead of concentrations in the ratio.
If \([\text{A}^-] = [\text{HA}]\), the logarithm is zero and \(\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a\).
More base than acid: pH above pKa. More acid than base: pH below pKa.
The pH changes by 1 unit for every factor of 10 in the ratio.
Diluting a buffer with water does not change the ratio, and so does not (appreciably) change the pH.
Worked example · pH of a buffer
A buffer contains 0.20 M acetic acid and 0.10 M sodium acetate (pKa = 4.74). Find the pH.
\(\text{pH} = 4.74 + \log\dfrac{0.10}{0.20} = 4.74 - 0.30 = \) 4.44. The pH is below the pKa because the acid form is in excess.
Worked example · a buffer of a weak base
A solution contains 0.30 M NH3 and 0.15 M NH4Cl. Find the pH (pKa of NH4+ = 9.25).
The acid is NH4+ and the base is NH3: \(\text{pH} = 9.25 + \log\dfrac{0.30}{0.15} = 9.25 + 0.30 = \) 9.55.
Worked example · designing a buffer
How many grams of sodium acetate (82.03 g/mol) must be added to 1.00 L of 0.100 M acetic acid to make a buffer of pH 5.00? (Assume no volume change.)
\(5.00 = 4.74 + \log([\text{A}^-]/0.100)\), so \(\log\dfrac{[\text{A}^-]}{0.100} = 0.26\) and \([\text{A}^-]/[\text{HA}] = 10^{0.26} = 1.82\). \([\text{A}^-] = 0.182\) M, i.e., 0.182 mol in 1.00 L. Mass = (0.182 mol)(82.03 g/mol) = 14.9 g.
Worked example · choosing the acid
You need a buffer at pH 3.9. Is formic acid (pKa = 3.75) or acetic acid (pKa = 4.74) the better choice?
Formic acid. A buffer works best when pH is within about one unit of the pKa, so the ratio stays between 1 : 10 and 10 : 1. At pH 3.9 formic acid needs a ratio \(10^{3.9 - 3.75} = 1.4\), but acetic acid would need \(10^{3.9 - 4.74} = 0.14\) (almost all acid, little base, poor buffering against added acid).
Exam focus
pH < pKa: acid form dominates. pH > pKa: base form dominates.
H-H: pH = pKa + log([A−]/[HA]); the base is on top.
Check direction: more base than acid should give a pH above the pKa.
Pick an indicator whose transition range includes the equivalence-point pH.
The H-H equation is for solutions that contain both the weak acid and its conjugate base; do not use it for a solution of only one form.
Practice
Find the pH of a buffer with 0.50 M formic acid and 0.25 M sodium formate (pKa 3.75).
Show answer
pH = 3.75 + log(0.25/0.50) = 3.75 − 0.30 = 3.45.
A buffer has pH = pKa + 1.00. What is the ratio [A−]/[HA]?
Show answer
10 : 1 (log ratio = 1.00).
For HF (pKa 3.17), which form predominates at pH 2.0, and at pH 5.0?
Show answer
At pH 2.0, below the pKa: HF. At pH 5.0, above the pKa: F−.
Which indicator (from the table) suits the titration of NH3 with HCl, whose equivalence point is near pH 5.3?
Show answer
Methyl red (4.4 to 6.2).
A buffer is diluted to ten times its volume with water. Predict the effect on its pH, and the effect on its ability to resist change.
Show answer
The pH is essentially unchanged because the ratio [A−]/[HA] does not change. But the concentrations of the two components fall by a factor of 10, so the buffer can neutralize much less added acid or base.
A student claims that a solution containing only 0.10 M acetic acid can be treated with the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation with [A−] = 0.10. Evaluate.
Show answer
Incorrect. The equation requires the actual concentrations of both forms. In a solution of only HA, [A−] is very small (about 1.3 × 10−3 M) and equals the [H3O+], so the weak-acid equilibrium calculation must be used.
A single drop of hydrochloric acid in a glass of water changes its pH by several units. The same drop in a glass of blood plasma does almost nothing. Blood, seawater, the cytoplasm of every cell and the contact-lens solution in your drugstore all contain buffers, solutions that resist pH change when a little acid or base is added.
This lesson explains why a buffer works, what it is made of, and how much acid or base it can absorb before it fails.
Learning objectives · 8.8.A and 8.10.A
8.8.A Explain the relationship between the ability of a buffer to stabilize pH and the reactions that occur when an acid or a base is added to a buffered solution. 8.10.A Explain the relationship between the buffer capacity of a solution and the relative concentrations of the conjugate acid and conjugate base components of the solution.
Required content · EK 8.8.A.1, 8.10.A.1 and 8.10.A.2
A buffer solution contains a large concentration of both members in a conjugate acid-base pair. The conjugate acid reacts with added base and the conjugate base reacts with added acid. These reactions are responsible for the ability of a buffer to stabilize pH.
Increasing the concentration of the buffer components (while keeping the ratio of these concentrations constant) keeps the pH of the buffer the same but increases the capacity of the buffer to neutralize added acid or base.
When a buffer has more conjugate acid than base, it has a greater buffer capacity for addition of added base than acid. When a buffer has more conjugate base than acid, it has a greater buffer capacity for addition of added acid than base.
What a buffer is
A buffer contains a weak acid HA and its conjugate base A− (or a weak base and its conjugate acid), both in large amounts. Ways to make one:
Dissolve a weak acid and a salt of its conjugate base (acetic acid and sodium acetate).
Add a strong base to an excess of weak acid, so that part of the acid is converted to A− (lesson 8.4).
Add a strong acid to an excess of weak base.
A weak acid by itself is not a buffer (it has almost no conjugate base) and neither is a solution of a strong acid and its conjugate base (Cl− is not a base). The pair must be both present and both weak enough to coexist at equilibrium.
How a buffer works
The two components neutralize each other’s opposites:
Added acid (H3O+) is consumed by the conjugate base: \(\text{A}^- + \text{H}_3\text{O}^+ \rightarrow \text{HA} + \text{H}_2\text{O}\).
Added base (OH−) is consumed by the weak acid: \(\text{HA} + \text{OH}^- \rightarrow \text{A}^- + \text{H}_2\text{O}\).
Figure 8.8a How a buffer resists change. Added acid is consumed by the conjugate base A− (making a little more HA); added base is consumed by the weak acid HA (making a little more A−). The ratio changes only slightly, so the pH changes only slightly.
Strong acid or base is turned into a weak one, so the hydronium or hydroxide does not build up. The ratio \([\text{A}^-]/[\text{HA}]\) changes only slightly, and pH depends on the logarithm of that ratio (Henderson-Hasselbalch), so the pH changes only slightly. By Le Châtelier’s principle, the equilibrium HA + H2O ⇌ H3O+ + A− shifts to absorb the disturbance.
Worked example · buffered against unbuffered
1.00 L of a buffer that is 0.50 M in acetic acid and 0.50 M in sodium acetate has \(\text{pH} = 4.74\). Compare the effect of adding 0.020 mol HCl to it with the effect of adding 0.020 mol HCl to 1.00 L of pure water. (This comparison illustrates the idea; the numerical change in pH is not itself assessed.)
Pure water: \([\text{H}_3\text{O}^+] = 0.020\) M, so pH = 1.70, a drop of 5.3 units from pH 7.00. Buffer: the 0.020 mol of H3O+ reacts with 0.020 mol of acetate: acetic acid becomes 0.52 mol and acetate 0.48 mol. \(\text{pH} = 4.74 + \log(0.48/0.52) = 4.71\), a drop of only 0.03 units.
Buffer capacity
A buffer can absorb only so much. Buffer capacity is the amount of strong acid or base a buffer can neutralize before its pH changes substantially. It is used up when the component that reacts with the added reagent runs low. Capacity depends on two things:
The total concentrations of the components. More HA and A− means more material to react, so a larger capacity. Doubling both concentrations (same ratio) leaves the pH unchanged but doubles the capacity.
The ratio of the components. The component present in greater amount determines the capacity against the opposite reagent: more HA means a greater capacity for added base; more A− means a greater capacity for added acid. A buffer works best, with capacity in both directions, when the two are roughly equal, that is, when pH is close to pKa (within about \(\pm 1\) unit, a ratio between 1 : 10 and 10 : 1).
Worked example · concentration and capacity
Compare two acetate buffers with the same 1 : 1 ratio, 0.50 M each and 0.050 M each, after adding 0.020 mol HCl to 1.00 L of each.
The concentrated buffer (above) goes from pH 4.74 to 4.71. The dilute one has HA = 0.050 + 0.020 = 0.070 mol and A− = 0.050 − 0.020 = 0.030 mol, so \(\text{pH} = 4.74 + \log(0.030/0.070) = 4.37\), a change of 0.37 units. Both buffers started at the same pH, but the more concentrated one has the greater capacity: it consumed the same amount of acid with a far smaller change.
Worked example · the ratio and capacity
Buffer X has 0.40 M acetic acid and 0.10 M acetate; buffer Y has 0.10 M acetic acid and 0.40 M acetate. Which has the greater capacity for added base, and which for added acid?
X has much more HA, which reacts with added OH−, so X has the greater capacity for base. Y has much more A−, which reacts with added H3O+, so Y has the greater capacity for acid. Numbers confirm it (pKa = 4.74, 1.00 L of each, 0.050 mol of strong reagent added):
Starting pH
After adding 0.050 mol acid
After adding 0.050 mol base
Buffer X (0.40 HA, 0.10 A−)
4.14
3.79 (change −0.35)
4.37 (change +0.23)
Buffer Y (0.10 HA, 0.40 A−)
5.34
5.11 (change −0.23)
5.69 (change +0.35)
Each buffer changes less for the reagent that its more abundant component neutralizes.
Buffers in the body and the world
Blood is buffered mainly by carbonic acid and bicarbonate (H2CO3/HCO3−). With an effective pKa near 6.1 and a blood pH of 7.4, the ratio \([\text{HCO}_3^-]/[\text{H}_2\text{CO}_3]\) is \(10^{7.4 - 6.1} \approx 20\): far more base than acid, so blood has a large capacity for neutralizing acids produced by metabolism, and breathing (which controls dissolved CO2) adjusts the acid component. Seawater, soils and the phosphate buffers inside cells play similar roles.
Worked example · limits of buffering
A buffer contains 0.10 mol HA and 0.10 mol A−. What happens if 0.15 mol of strong acid is added?
The 0.10 mol of A− is used up and 0.05 mol of strong acid remains. The buffer has failed: the pH now depends on the excess strong acid (and falls sharply). Capacity is finite: it is exhausted when the reacting component is gone.
Exam focus
A buffer needs a weak acid and its conjugate base (or the base-acid pair), both in large amounts.
Write both reactions: A− + H3O+ → HA + H2O and HA + OH− → A− + H2O.
Same ratio, higher concentrations: same pH, greater capacity.
More acid component: more capacity for base; more base component: more capacity for acid.
Choose an acid whose pKa is near the target pH.
Practice
Which of these pairs forms a buffer? (a) HCl and NaCl; (b) HF and NaF; (c) NH3 and NH4Cl; (d) HNO3 and NaNO3.
Show answer
(b) and (c). Each has a weak acid with its conjugate base (HF/F−) or a weak base with its conjugate acid (NH3/NH4+). HCl and HNO3 are strong acids, whose anions are not basic.
Write the equations for what happens when a small amount of NaOH and a small amount of HCl are added to an HF/F− buffer.
Show answer
Buffer P is 1.0 M HA and 1.0 M A−. Buffer Q is 0.10 M HA and 0.10 M A−. Compare their pH and their capacity.
Show answer
Same pH (same ratio, so pH = pKa). Buffer P has ten times the capacity, since it contains ten times as much of each component.
A buffer has [HA] = 0.80 M and [A−] = 0.20 M. Does it resist added acid or added base better?
Show answer
Added base. There is far more HA, which neutralizes OH−. The small amount of A− is used up quickly by added acid.
Why is a mixture of 0.10 M acetic acid and 0.0010 M sodium acetate a poor buffer against added acid?
Show answer
It contains very little A−, the component that neutralizes acid, so its capacity for acid is tiny. The ratio would change a lot after a small amount of acid is added.
Why does diluting a buffer with water keep its pH almost the same but reduce its effectiveness?
Show answer
Dilution lowers both concentrations by the same factor, so the ratio and therefore the pH are essentially unchanged, but the lower amounts of HA and A− mean a lower capacity to neutralize added acid or base.
Tooth enamel is a calcium phosphate mineral, and it dissolves in acid: that is how sugar-eating bacteria cause cavities. Limestone caves form because rainwater, made acidic by dissolved CO2, slowly dissolves calcium carbonate. Antacids work by dissolving in stomach acid.
Why does adding acid dissolve some solids and have no effect on others? The answer combines the solubility equilibria of Unit 7 with the acid-base ideas of this unit.
Learning objective · 8.11.A
Identify the qualitative effect of changes in pH on the solubility of a salt.
Required content · EK 8.11.A.1
The solubility of a salt is pH sensitive when one of the constituent ions is a weak acid, a weak base, or the hydroxide ion. These effects can be understood qualitatively using Le Châtelier’s principle.
Exclusion: computations of solubility as a function of pH are not assessed.
Salts whose anion is a base
Consider the slightly soluble salt magnesium hydroxide:
\[ \text{Mg(OH)}_2(s) \rightleftharpoons \text{Mg}^{2+}(aq) + 2\,\text{OH}^-(aq) \qquad K_{sp} = [\text{Mg}^{2+}][\text{OH}^-]^2 \]
Adding acid supplies H3O+, which reacts with the OH− in solution: \(\text{H}_3\text{O}^+ + \text{OH}^- \rightarrow 2\,\text{H}_2\text{O}\). This lowers \([\text{OH}^-]\), so \(Q \lt K_{sp}\) and by Le Châtelier’s principle the equilibrium shifts right: more solid dissolves. Adding base (more OH−, a common ion) does the opposite: the solubility decreases.
Figure 8.9a Effect of pH on solubility. When the anion is a weak base (hydroxide, fluoride, carbonate, phosphate), added H3O+ consumes it, so by Le Châtelier’s principle more solid dissolves.
The same reasoning applies to any salt whose anion is the conjugate base of a weak acid, because that anion can take a proton from added acid:
CaF2(s) ⇌ Ca2+ + 2 F−; F− + H3O+ ⇌ HF + H2O (F− is the conjugate base of the weak acid HF). Acid removes F−, so more CaF2 dissolves.
CaCO3(s) ⇌ Ca2+ + CO32−; CO32− + H3O+ → HCO3− + H2O (and onward to H2CO3 and CO2). Limestone dissolves in acid.
Ca3(PO4)2, the enamel mineral hydroxyapatite, Fe(OH)3, Zn(OH)2, PbS, and other salts of weak-acid anions or hydroxide behave the same way.
Salts whose anion is not basic
If the anion is the conjugate base of a strong acid, it is such a weak base that it will not react with added H3O+. Salts such as AgCl, AgBr, AgI, PbCl2, BaSO4 (the HSO4− ion is moderately acidic, so the effect is small) and the nitrates and chlorides in general have solubilities that are essentially independent of pH.
Salt
Anion
Conjugate acid of anion
Solubility in acid
AgCl
Cl−
HCl (strong)
no change from pH
CaF2
F−
HF (weak)
increases
CaCO3
CO32−
HCO3− (weak)
increases
Mg(OH)2
OH−
H2O (very weak)
increases strongly
PbI2
I−
HI (strong)
no change from pH
Worked example · predicting the effect
For each solid in water, say whether its solubility is greater, less or the same in a solution of pH 2 than in pure water: (a) AgBr, (b) CaCO3, (c) Fe(OH)3, (d) PbCl2.
(a) The same: Br− is the conjugate base of a strong acid. (b) Greater: CO32− is protonated by H3O+, shifting the equilibrium right. (c) Greater: OH− is neutralized by acid. (d) The same (Cl− is neutral).
Worked example · explaining an observation
A student adds a few drops of 6 M HCl to a test tube holding a white precipitate of magnesium hydroxide suspended in water, and the solid dissolves. Explain at the particle level.
The solid is in equilibrium: Mg(OH)2 ⇌ Mg2+ + 2 OH−. The H3O+ from the acid reacts with the OH− to make water, which reduces [OH−] and makes \(Q \lt K_{sp}\). The system shifts toward the products, more Mg(OH)2 dissolves, and with enough acid all of it does.
Worked example · ocean acidification
Seawater absorbs CO2, forming carbonic acid and lowering the pH slightly. Predict the effect on coral skeletons, which are CaCO3.
The added acid lowers [CO32−] (it converts carbonate to bicarbonate), which shifts the equilibrium CaCO3 ⇌ Ca2+ + CO32− to the right: shells and skeletons dissolve more easily and are harder to build.
Connecting to the common-ion effect
The common-ion effect of Unit 7 lowers solubility when a product ion is added. The pH effect is a removal effect: acid removes the anion by reacting with it (so solubility rises), while base adds hydroxide (so a hydroxide salt becomes less soluble). Both are the same principle applied to different stresses, and in both cases the value of \(K_{sp}\) does not change.
Exam focus
Ask: is the anion (or cation) a weak acid or base, or OH−? If so, pH matters. If not, it does not.
Acid increases the solubility of salts of weak-acid anions and of hydroxides; base decreases the solubility of hydroxides (common ion).
Write the reaction that removes the ion (e.g., F− + H3O+ ⇌ HF + H2O), then apply Le Châtelier’s principle.
Ksp is unchanged; only the solubility changes.
No calculation is needed on the exam for solubility as a function of pH.
Practice
Which is more soluble in 1 M HNO3 than in water: AgCl, Ca(OH)2, BaSO4, or CaF2?
Show answer
Ca(OH)2 and CaF2. OH− is neutralized and F− is protonated by the acid. AgCl is unaffected (Cl− is the conjugate base of a strong acid); BaSO4 is affected very little.
What happens to the solubility of Mg(OH)2 when NaOH is added?
Show answer
It decreases (common-ion effect): OH− is a product, so the equilibrium shifts left, toward the solid.
Explain why an antacid such as Mg(OH)2 relieves excess stomach acid.
Show answer
The slightly soluble Mg(OH)2 supplies OH−, which reacts with H3O+. As OH− is consumed the solid keeps dissolving, so it continues to neutralize acid.
Zn(OH)2 is in a saturated solution at pH 9. Predict the effect of lowering the pH to 5 on [Zn2+].
Show answer
[Zn2+] increases. The lower pH means lower [OH−], so more Zn(OH)2 dissolves to restore the equilibrium.
A saturated solution of CaF2 is made more acidic. Write the equation for the reaction that shifts the equilibrium.
Show answer
F−(aq) + H3O+(aq) ⇌ HF(aq) + H2O(l). Removing F− shifts CaF2(s) ⇌ Ca2+ + 2 F− to the right.
Why does dissolving AgCl not depend on whether the solution is acidic?
Show answer
Cl− is the conjugate base of the strong acid HCl, so it does not react with H3O+ to any appreciable extent, and Ag+ is not affected either. No ion is removed by the acid, so the equilibrium does not shift.
Unit 8 practice · 10 problems
Unit 8 practice: Acids and Bases
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed; \(K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}\) at 25 °C.
Find the pH, pOH, and [OH−] of (a) 0.0400 M HNO3 and (b) 0.0020 M Sr(OH)2, both at 25 °C.
Show answer
(a) Strong acid: \([\mathrm{H_3O^+}] = 0.0400\) M, pH \(= -\log(0.0400) = 1.40\), pOH \(= 12.60\), \([\mathrm{OH^-}] = 10^{-12.60} = 2.5 \times 10^{-13}\) M. (b) Two OH− per formula unit: \([\mathrm{OH^-}] = 0.0040\) M, pOH \(= 2.40\), pH \(= 11.60\).
At 50 °C, \(K_w = 5.5 \times 10^{-14}\). Pure water at this temperature has pH 6.63. The water is
pH below 7 means acidic only at 25 °C, where \(K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}\) and neutral pH is 7.00. At 50 °C the neutral point itself has moved to 6.63, so pure water there is not acidic.
Autoionization produces H3O+ and OH− in equal amounts, so \([\mathrm{H_3O^+}] = [\mathrm{OH^-}] = \sqrt{5.5 \times 10^{-14}} = 2.3 \times 10^{-7}\) M and pH \(= -\log(2.3 \times 10^{-7}) = 6.63\). Neutral means equal concentrations, not pH 7; here pH + pOH = 13.26.
A pH of 6.63 could be basic only if it were above the neutral pH for that temperature, and at 50 °C the neutral pH is 6.63. Neither ion outnumbers the other in pure water at any temperature.
[OH−] is fully determined: in pure water it must equal [H3O+] by the stoichiometry of autoionization, and \(K_w\) fixes both at \(\sqrt{K_w}\). No extra information is needed.
Benzoic acid has \(K_a = 6.3 \times 10^{-5}\). Find the pH and percent ionization of a 0.0500 M solution. Show the ICE reasoning and check your approximation.
Show answer
HA ⇌ H3O+ + A−; E row: \(0.0500 - x\), \(x\), \(x\). \(\dfrac{x^2}{0.0500 - x} \approx \dfrac{x^2}{0.0500} = 6.3 \times 10^{-5}\), so \(x^2 = 3.15 \times 10^{-6}\) and \(x = 1.77 \times 10^{-3}\) M. Check: \(1.77 \times 10^{-3}/0.0500 = 3.5\%\), under 5%. ✓ pH \(= -\log(1.77 \times 10^{-3}) = 2.75\); percent ionization \(= 3.5\%\). Roughly 96 of every 100 molecules stay intact.
Methylamine, CH3NH2, has \(K_b = 4.4 \times 10^{-4}\). Find the pH of a 0.200 M solution, and find \(K_a\) of its conjugate acid CH3NH3+.
Show answer
B + H2O ⇌ BH+ + OH−: \(\dfrac{x^2}{0.200} = 4.4 \times 10^{-4}\), \(x = [\mathrm{OH^-}] = 9.4 \times 10^{-3}\) M (4.7% of 0.200: acceptable). pOH \(= 2.03\), pH \(= 11.97\). Conjugate pair: \(K_a = \dfrac{K_w}{K_b} = \dfrac{1.0 \times 10^{-14}}{4.4 \times 10^{-4}} = 2.3 \times 10^{-11}\): a fairly strong weak base has a very weak conjugate acid.
30.0 mL of 0.200 M NaOH is mixed with 50.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl. Find the pH of the resulting solution.
Show answer
OH−: \((30.0)(0.200) = 6.00\) mmol. H3O+: \((50.0)(0.100) = 5.00\) mmol. They react 1 : 1, leaving 1.00 mmol OH− in 80.0 mL: \([\mathrm{OH^-}] = 0.0125\) M, pOH \(= 1.90\), pH = 12.10. Use the total volume.
Which of these solutions are buffers? (a) 0.10 M HCN + 0.10 M NaCN; (b) 0.10 M HBr + 0.10 M NaBr; (c) 0.20 M NH3 + 0.10 M HCl; (d) 0.10 M NaOH + 0.10 M NaCl. For solution (a), write the net ionic equation that occurs when a little NaOH is added and explain why the pH barely changes.
Show answer
(a) Yes: weak acid + conjugate base. (b) No: HBr is strong and Br− has no tendency to accept a proton. (c) Yes: HCl converts half the NH3 to NH4+, leaving 0.10 M each of a weak base and its conjugate acid. (d) No: a strong base and a neutral salt. In (a), HCN + OH− → CN− + H2O: the strong base is consumed by the large reservoir of HCN, becoming an equal amount of the weak base CN−. Since \([\mathrm{H_3O^+}] = K_a[\mathrm{HCN}]/[\mathrm{CN^-}]\) and both amounts are large, the ratio, and so the pH, shifts only slightly.
A buffer is 0.30 M acetic acid (p\(K_a\) = 4.74) and 0.50 M sodium acetate. (a) Find its pH. (b) 0.020 mol of HCl is added to 1.0 L of this buffer. Find the new pH.
Show answer
(a) \(\text{pH} = 4.74 + \log\dfrac{0.50}{0.30} = 4.74 + 0.22 = 4.96\). (b) H3O+ + C2H3O2− → HC2H3O2 + H2O converts 0.020 mol acetate to acid: A− \(= 0.48\), HA \(= 0.32\) mol. \(\text{pH} = 4.74 + \log\dfrac{0.48}{0.32} = 4.74 + 0.18 = 4.92\). A drop of 0.04; the same acid in 1.0 L of pure water would give pH 1.70.
You need a buffer at pH 7.20. Available acids: HNO2 (\(K_a = 4.5 \times 10^{-4}\)), acetic acid (\(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\)), HClO (\(K_a = 3.0 \times 10^{-8}\)). Choose the acid and find the required [A−]/[HA] ratio. What determines the buffer's capacity?
Show answer
p\(K_a\) values: 3.35, 4.74, 7.52. Only HClO is within one unit of 7.20. \(7.20 = 7.52 + \log\dfrac{[\mathrm{A^-}]}{[\mathrm{HA}]}\), so \(\log(\text{ratio}) = -0.32\) and \(\dfrac{[\mathrm{ClO^-}]}{[\mathrm{HClO}]} = 10^{-0.32} = 0.48\). The pH is below p\(K_a\), so more acid than base: sensible. Capacity depends on the absolute amounts of HClO and ClO−, not the ratio: a 1.0 M / 0.48 M buffer absorbs ten times as much strong acid or base as 0.10 M / 0.048 M.
25.0 mL of 0.200 M formic acid, HCOOH (\(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-4}\)), is titrated with 0.100 M NaOH. Find the volume at equivalence, the pH at half-equivalence, the pH at equivalence, and a suitable indicator (methyl red 4.4–6.2, phenolphthalein 8.2–10.0).
Show answer
Acid: \((25.0)(0.200) = 5.00\) mmol, so equivalence needs \(5.00/0.100 = 50.0\) mL. At 25.0 mL (half-equivalence) [HA] = [A−]: pH = p\(K_a\) \(= 3.74\). At equivalence, 5.00 mmol formate in 75.0 mL \(= 0.0667\) M, a weak base with \(K_b = 1.0 \times 10^{-14}/1.8 \times 10^{-4} = 5.6 \times 10^{-11}\): \(x = \sqrt{(0.0667)(5.6 \times 10^{-11})} = 1.9 \times 10^{-6}\) M OH−, pOH \(= 5.72\), pH = 8.28. Phenolphthalein changes in the steep region near 8.3; methyl red would change in the buffer region and signal too early.
(a) Rank H2O, H2S, and H2Se from weakest to strongest acid and explain. (b) Fluoroacetic acid, CH2FCOOH, has \(K_a = 2.6 \times 10^{-3}\), versus \(1.8 \times 10^{-5}\) for acetic acid. Explain the difference at the molecular level.
Show answer
(a) H2O < H2S < H2Se. Down the group the central atom is larger, the H–X bond longer and weaker, so the proton is released more easily: bond strength outweighs the decreasing polarity, just as for HF < HCl < HBr < HI. (b) The electronegative F atom near the carboxyl group withdraws electron density, making the O–H bond more polar and weaker, and it stabilizes the CH2FCOO− anion by pulling negative charge toward itself. A more stable conjugate base means ionization is more favorable: about 140 times larger \(K_a\).
A hot cup of coffee cools to room temperature. A drop of ink spreads through a glass of water. A gas rushes into an empty container. None of these ever runs backward on its own, yet none of them violates energy conservation.
Something other than energy decides which way a change goes, and that something is entropy. This lesson defines it in terms of dispersal, shows how to predict the sign of an entropy change, and calculates it from tabulated values.
Learning objectives · 9.1.A and 9.2.A
9.1.A Identify the sign and relative magnitude of the entropy change associated with chemical or physical processes. 9.2.A Calculate the standard entropy change for a chemical or physical process based on the absolute entropies (standard molar entropies) of the species involved in the process.
Required content · EK 9.1.A.1, 9.1.A.2 and 9.2.A.1
Entropy increases when matter becomes more dispersed. For example, the phase change from solid to liquid or from liquid to gas results in a dispersal of matter as the individual particles become freer to move and generally occupy a larger volume. Similarly, for a gas, the entropy increases when there is an increase in volume (at constant temperature), and the gas molecules are able to move within a larger space. For reactions involving gas-phase reactants or products, the entropy generally increases when the total number of moles of gas-phase products is greater than the total number of moles of gas-phase reactants.
Entropy increases when energy is dispersed. According to kinetic molecular theory (KMT), the distribution of kinetic energy among the particles of a gas broadens as the temperature increases. As a result, the entropy of the system increases with an increase in temperature.
The entropy change for a process can be calculated from the absolute entropies of the species involved before and after the process occurs: \(\Delta S^\circ_{\text{reaction}} = \sum S^\circ_{\text{products}} - \sum S^\circ_{\text{reactants}}\).
What entropy measures
Entropy, \(S\), is a measure of how dispersed the matter and energy of a system are, or, equivalently, of the number of microscopic arrangements (ways) the particles and their energy can take for a given overall state. A system with more ways of being arranged has more entropy. Entropy is measured in joules per kelvin (J/K), or J mol−1 K−1 for molar quantities, which is small compared with the kilojoules typical of enthalpy.
Nature favors spreading out: matter spreads over more space, and energy spreads over more particles and more energy levels. Given two states, the more dispersed one is vastly more probable, which is why gases fill their containers and why heat flows from hot to cold, but not the reverse.
Predicting the sign of ΔS
1. Phase changes. Entropy increases as matter becomes more dispersed:
Figure 9.1a Entropy measures the dispersal of matter and energy. Going from solid to liquid to gas, particles become freer to move and occupy more space, so the number of ways to arrange them (and the entropy) increases.
S(solid) < S(liquid) << S(gas). Melting and vaporization have \(\Delta S \gt 0\); freezing and condensation have \(\Delta S \lt 0\). Vaporization raises entropy far more than melting, because particles go from touching to being widely separated.
2. Volume of a gas. At constant temperature, a gas expanding into a larger volume has more positions available to its molecules, so \(\Delta S \gt 0\). Compression gives \(\Delta S \lt 0\).
3. Moles of gas in a reaction. Gas particles are by far the most dispersed, so when a reaction produces more moles of gas than it consumes, \(\Delta S \gt 0\); when it consumes more moles of gas than it produces, \(\Delta S \lt 0\). If the number of moles of gas is unchanged, the sign is hard to predict. Examples: CaCO3(s) → CaO(s) + CO2(g) (a gas is produced: ΔS > 0), and N2(g) + 3 H2(g) → 2 NH3(g) (4 mol gas to 2 mol: ΔS < 0).
4. Dissolving and mixing. Mixing two substances, or dissolving a solid or gas in a liquid, usually increases the dispersal of matter; dissolving a gas in a liquid, however, decreases entropy because the gas loses so much freedom.
5. Temperature. Heating a substance increases entropy. By the kinetic molecular theory the distribution of kinetic energies broadens as T rises, so the energy is spread over a wider range of states.
Figure 9.1b At higher temperature the distribution of molecular kinetic energies broadens: energy is spread over a wider range of values. Wider spreading means more ways to distribute the energy, so the entropy rises with temperature.
6. Complexity and number of particles. For substances in the same phase, larger or more complex molecules (more atoms, more ways to vibrate and rotate) have a higher entropy; and one particle splitting into several raises entropy.
Worked example · predicting signs
Predict the sign of ΔS for (a) H2O(l) → H2O(g); (b) 2 SO2(g) + O2(g) → 2 SO3(g); (c) NaCl(s) → Na+(aq) + Cl−(aq); (d) cooling a gas at constant volume.
(a) Positive: liquid to gas. (b) Negative: 3 mol of gas become 2 mol. (c) Positive: an ordered crystal becomes freely moving ions. (d) Negative: the energy distribution narrows at lower temperature.
Worked example · ranking entropies
Rank from lowest to highest standard molar entropy: He(g), H2O(l), NaCl(s), CO2(g).
The two condensed phases come first and the gases last. From the table: H2O(l) 70.0 < NaCl(s) 72.1 < He(g) 126.2 < CO2(g) 213.8 J mol−1 K−1. Both gases are well above the condensed phases, and the more complex molecule CO2 beats the monatomic helium. (The solid-versus-liquid order is only reliable when you compare the same substance in different phases; here the two values are close.)
Absolute entropy: the third law
Unlike enthalpy, entropy has a natural zero: a perfect crystal at absolute zero has exactly one arrangement, so \(S = 0\) at 0 K (the third law of thermodynamics). All entropies are therefore absolute, and a table lists the standard molar entropy \(S^\circ\) of each substance at 298 K and 1 bar. Even elements have nonzero \(S^\circ\) values (unlike \(\Delta H^\circ_f\)). Some values (J mol−1 K−1):
Substance
S°
Substance
S°
Substance
S°
H2O(l)
70.0
H2(g)
130.7
CH4(g)
186.3
H2O(g)
188.8
N2(g)
191.6
CO2(g)
213.8
C(graphite)
5.7
O2(g)
205.0
NH3(g)
192.8
CaO(s)
39.8
CaCO3(s)
92.9
NaCl(s)
72.1
Calculating ΔS°
As with enthalpy, products minus reactants, multiplying each value by its coefficient:
\[ \Delta S^\circ_{\text{rxn}} = \sum nS^\circ(\text{products}) - \sum nS^\circ(\text{reactants}) \]
Remember that entropy is in J/K while enthalpy is usually in kJ; convert before combining them (next lesson).
Worked example · ammonia synthesis
Find ΔS° for N2(g) + 3 H2(g) → 2 NH3(g).
Products: 2(192.8) = 385.6. Reactants: 191.6 + 3(130.7) = 583.7. \(\Delta S^\circ = 385.6 - 583.7 = \) −198.1 J/K. Negative, as predicted from the drop from 4 mol to 2 mol of gas.
Worked example · thermal decomposition
Find ΔS° for CaCO3(s) → CaO(s) + CO2(g).
Products: 39.8 + 213.8 = 253.6. Reactants: 92.9. \(\Delta S^\circ = 253.6 - 92.9 = \) +160.7 J/K. Positive: a gas is produced from a solid.
Worked example · vaporization and combustion
Find ΔS° for (a) H2O(l) → H2O(g) and (b) CH4(g) + 2 O2(g) → CO2(g) + 2 H2O(l).
(a) 188.8 − 70.0 = +118.8 J/K. (b) Products: 213.8 + 2(70.0) = 353.8; reactants: 186.3 + 2(205.0) = 596.3; \(\Delta S^\circ = \) −242.5 J/K. Three moles of gas become one mole of gas, so the entropy falls, even though combustion releases a great deal of energy.
Exam focus
Entropy increases with dispersal: solid < liquid < gas; larger volume; more moles of gas; higher temperature; mixing.
Moles of gas first: compare moles of gas on each side to predict the sign for a reaction.
ΔS° = ΣS°(products) − ΣS°(reactants), with coefficients. Elements have nonzero S°.
Units are J/K, not kJ/K.
Describe it with particles: “more ways to arrange the particles and distribute the energy.”
Practice
Predict the sign of ΔS: (a) 2 NO2(g) → N2O4(g); (b) I2(s) → I2(g); (c) CO2(g) + H2O(l) → H2CO3(aq).
Show answer
(a) Negative: 2 mol of gas become 1 mol. (b) Positive: solid to gas. (c) Negative: a gas dissolves and combines (fewer particles with less freedom).
Calculate ΔS° for 2 H2(g) + O2(g) → 2 H2O(g), given S°(H2O(g)) = 188.8.
Show answer
Which has the greater entropy: 1 mol of H2O(s) at 0 °C or 1 mol of H2O(l) at 0 °C? Explain.
Show answer
The liquid. Its molecules can move past one another, giving more possible arrangements than the fixed positions of the solid.
A gas expands isothermally into an evacuated container, doubling its volume. Predict the sign of ΔS and explain with particles.
Show answer
Positive. Each molecule has twice as many positions available, so the number of possible arrangements increases.
Why does the entropy of a gas increase when its temperature increases (at constant volume)?
Show answer
The distribution of molecular kinetic energies broadens, so the energy is spread over a wider range of states, which means more microscopic arrangements.
The combustion of methane has ΔS° negative, yet the reaction is strongly favored. What does that tell you?
Show answer
Entropy change alone does not decide favorability. The very large release of energy (negative ΔH) outweighs the decrease in entropy, as the next lesson shows with ΔG.
Ice melts at room temperature but water does not freeze there. Ammonium nitrate dissolves in water and the beaker gets cold, even though that takes in energy. Methane burns and releases energy, yet a mixture of natural gas and air sits quietly until a spark arrives.
To explain all of this, chemists combine enthalpy and entropy into one quantity, the Gibbs free energy, whose sign says whether a process is favored. A second, separate question is whether it will happen at a useful speed.
Learning objectives · 9.3.A and 9.4.A
9.3.A Explain whether a physical or chemical process is thermodynamically favored based on an evaluation of ΔG°. 9.4.A Explain, in terms of kinetics, why a thermodynamically favored reaction might not occur at a measurable rate.
Required content · EK 9.3.A.1 to 9.3.A.6 and 9.4.A.1 to 9.4.A.2
The Gibbs free energy change for a chemical process in which all the reactants and products are present in a standard state (as pure substances, as solutions of 1.0 M concentration, or as gases at a pressure of 1.0 atm (or 1.0 bar)) is given the symbol ΔG°.
The standard Gibbs free energy change for a chemical or physical process is a measure of thermodynamic favorability. Historically, the term “spontaneous” has been used to describe processes for which ΔG° < 0. The phrase “thermodynamically favored” is preferred instead so that common misunderstandings (equating “spontaneous” with “suddenly” or “without cause”) can be avoided. When ΔG° < 0 for the process, it is said to be thermodynamically favored.
The standard Gibbs free energy change for a physical or chemical process may also be determined from the standard Gibbs free energy of formation of the reactants and products: \(\Delta G^\circ_{\text{rxn}} = \sum \Delta G^\circ_f(\text{products}) - \sum \Delta G^\circ_f(\text{reactants})\).
In some cases, it is necessary to consider both enthalpy and entropy to determine if a process will be thermodynamically favored. The freezing of water and the dissolution of sodium nitrate are examples of such phenomena.
Knowing the values of ΔH° and ΔS° for a process at a given temperature allows ΔG° to be calculated directly: \(\Delta G^\circ = \Delta H^\circ - T\Delta S^\circ\).
In general, the temperature conditions for a process to be thermodynamically favored (ΔG° < 0) can be predicted from the signs of ΔH° and ΔS° (table below). In cases where ΔH° < 0 and ΔS° > 0, no calculation of ΔG° is necessary to determine that the process is thermodynamically favored. In cases where ΔH° > 0 and ΔS° < 0, no calculation of ΔG° is necessary to determine that the process is thermodynamically unfavored.
Many processes that are thermodynamically favored do not occur to any measurable extent, or they occur at extremely slow rates. Processes that are thermodynamically favored, but do not proceed at a measurable rate, are under “kinetic control.” High activation energy is a common reason for a process to be under kinetic control. The fact that a process does not proceed at a noticeable rate does not mean that the chemical system is at equilibrium. If a process is known to be thermodynamically favored, and yet does not occur at a measurable rate, it is reasonable to conclude that the process is under kinetic control.
Free energy combines enthalpy and entropy
Two natural tendencies compete: systems tend toward lower energy (negative ΔH, which releases energy to the surroundings and increases the surroundings’ entropy), and toward higher entropy (positive ΔS of the system). The Gibbs free energy change weighs both:
\[ \Delta G^\circ = \Delta H^\circ - T\Delta S^\circ \]
where \(T\) is the absolute temperature (kelvin) and \(\Delta S^\circ\) must be converted to kJ/K (divide J/K by 1000) so that both terms have kJ. The superscript means all substances are in their standard states (pure solids and liquids, gases at 1 bar, solutions at 1 M).
The sign of ΔG° tells whether the process is thermodynamically favored (the older term is “spontaneous”):
\(\Delta G^\circ \lt 0\): favored (products are favored at equilibrium).
\(\Delta G^\circ \gt 0\): not favored (reactants are favored; the reverse process is favored).
\(\Delta G^\circ = 0\): the system is at equilibrium.
“Favored” does not mean fast, sudden, or without cause. It means that, given enough time and a path, the system can lower its free energy. A favored process may take a split second or a billion years.
The four sign combinations
Figure 9.3a ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS°. The intercept at T = 0 is ΔH° and the slope is −ΔS°. The signs of ΔH° and ΔS° decide whether the process is favored at all temperatures, at none, only at high T, or only at low T.
ΔH°
ΔS°
ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS°
Favored at…
Example
−
+
always negative
all temperatures
2 H2O2 → 2 H2O + O2
+
−
always positive
no temperature
3 O2 → 2 O3
+
+
negative at high T
high temperatures
CaCO3 → CaO + CO2; melting
−
−
negative at low T
low temperatures
freezing; N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3
When ΔH and ΔS have opposite signs, you need no calculation: the sign of ΔG° is the same at every temperature. When they have the same sign, temperature decides, and the changeover occurs where \(\Delta G^\circ = 0\), at \(T = \Delta H^\circ/\Delta S^\circ\). The exam wants you to reason about which factor is driving the process: “the reaction is favored because the large negative ΔH more than offsets the unfavorable entropy change,” rather than merely quoting the equation.
Worked example · ΔG° from ΔH° and ΔS°
For N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3, \(\Delta H^\circ = -92.2\) kJ and \(\Delta S^\circ = -198.1\) J/K. Find ΔG° at 298 K and the temperature at which the sign changes.
\(\Delta G^\circ = -92.2 - (298)(-0.1981) = -92.2 + 59.0 = \) −33.2 kJ (−33.1 kJ with T = 298.15 K): favored at 298 K. Both ΔH and ΔS are negative, so the process is favored at low temperature. The sign changes at \(T = \Delta H^\circ/\Delta S^\circ = (-92.2)/(-0.1981) = \) 465 K. Above 465 K the unfavorable entropy term dominates and ΔG° > 0 (at 298 K the enthalpy term, not the entropy term, drives the reaction).
Worked example · melting ice
Melting ice has ΔH° = +6.01 kJ/mol and ΔS° = +22.0 J mol−1 K−1. Find ΔG° at 298 K and at 263 K, and the melting temperature.
At 298 K: \(6.01 - (298.15)(0.0220) = 6.01 - 6.56 = -0.55\) kJ/mol: favored (ice melts). At 263 K: \(6.01 - (263.15)(0.0220) = +0.22\) kJ/mol: not favored (water freezes instead). At \(T = \Delta H^\circ/\Delta S^\circ = 6010/22.0 = 273\) K (0 °C), ΔG° = 0: ice and water are in equilibrium. This is a process in which both terms matter: ΔH > 0 (unfavorable), ΔS > 0 (favorable), and temperature decides.
Worked example · dissolving ammonium nitrate
NH4NO3(s) → NH4+(aq) + NO3−(aq) has ΔH° = +25.7 kJ/mol and ΔS° = +108.7 J mol−1 K−1. Is it favored at 298 K?
\(\Delta G^\circ = 25.7 - (298.15)(0.1087) = 25.7 - 32.4 = \) −6.7 kJ/mol. Favored, even though the process absorbs energy (the cold pack): the entropy increase from the freed ions outweighs the enthalpy cost. This is entropy-driven.
Worked example · decomposition of limestone
CaCO3(s) → CaO(s) + CO2(g): \(\Delta H^\circ = +178.3\) kJ, \(\Delta S^\circ = +160.7\) J/K. At what temperature does it become favored?
Both positive: favored at high T. \(T = 178{,}300/160.7 = \) 1110 K (about 840 °C). Below this the process is not favored, which is why limestone is stable at room temperature and is heated in a kiln to make lime.
ΔG° from free energies of formation
As with enthalpy, tabulated standard free energies of formation \(\Delta G^\circ_f\) (zero for elements in their standard states) give the free energy change of any reaction:
\[ \Delta G^\circ_{\text{rxn}} = \sum n\Delta G^\circ_f(\text{products}) - \sum n\Delta G^\circ_f(\text{reactants}) \]
Worked example · combustion of methane
Using \(\Delta G^\circ_f\) in kJ/mol: CH4(g) −50.7, CO2(g) −394.4, H2O(l) −237.1, find ΔG° for CH4 + 2 O2 → CO2 + 2 H2O(l).
Products: −394.4 + 2(−237.1) = −868.6. Reactants: −50.7 + 0. \(\Delta G^\circ = -868.6 + 50.7 = \) −817.9 kJ. Check with \(\Delta H^\circ = -890.3\) and \(\Delta S^\circ = -242.5\) J/K: \(-890.3 + (298.15)(0.2425) = -818.0\) kJ ✓. Strongly favored: the enthalpy term dominates the unfavorable entropy.
Thermodynamic versus kinetic control
ΔG° says whether the products are more stable than the reactants, not how fast the change happens. The rate is governed by the activation energy:
Figure 9.4a ΔG° tells whether products are favored, not how fast they form. If the activation energy is very high, a favored reaction does not occur at a measurable rate: it is under kinetic control. Diamond turning into graphite and fuels in air are examples.
Many favored reactions are extremely slow because their activation energy is high. A mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, or methane and oxygen, is thermodynamically unstable relative to water and carbon dioxide, but nothing happens until a spark supplies the activation energy. Diamond is thermodynamically unstable relative to graphite at room temperature (ΔG° = −2.9 kJ/mol), but diamonds last forever because the barrier is enormous. Such a process is said to be under kinetic control.
Importantly, a favored reaction that does not proceed is not at equilibrium: equilibrium requires that forward and reverse rates are equal, and here neither occurs at a measurable rate. And a catalyst does not change ΔG°; it lowers the barrier and so can bring a kinetically controlled reaction to a measurable rate.
Worked example · explaining with both ideas
Paper in air is thermodynamically unstable relative to CO2 and H2O, but a book on a shelf lasts centuries. Explain.
The combustion has a large negative ΔG° (favored), but its activation energy is high at room temperature, so the rate is immeasurably small: the process is under kinetic control. Heating or a flame supplies the activation energy and the reaction proceeds.
Exam focus
ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS°, with ΔS° converted to kJ/K and T in kelvin.
Say “thermodynamically favored,” not “fast.” Favored means ΔG° < 0.
Use the sign table: opposite signs mean the same answer at every T; same signs means temperature decides.
Argue which term drives the process, citing enthalpy and entropy (energy and dispersal).
Favored but not occurring: kinetic control (high activation energy), not equilibrium.
Practice
A reaction has ΔH° = −125 kJ and ΔS° = −250 J/K. Is it favored at 298 K? At 600 K?
Show answer
At 298 K: −125 − (298)(−0.250) = −125 + 74.5 = −50.5 kJ: favored. At 600 K: −125 + 150 = +25 kJ: not favored. (The sign changes at 500 K.)
A decomposition has ΔH° = +92 kJ and ΔS° = +199 J/K. Above what temperature is it favored?
Show answer
T = 92,000/199 = 462 K.
For a process ΔH° > 0 and ΔS° < 0. What can you say about its favorability at all temperatures?
Show answer
ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS° is positive at every temperature (both terms are positive), so it is never thermodynamically favored.
Explain why water freezes below 0 °C and melts above, using ΔH and ΔS.
Show answer
Freezing has ΔH < 0 (favorable) and ΔS < 0 (unfavorable). At low T the −TΔS term is small and the enthalpy dominates, so freezing is favored; at high T the entropy term dominates, so melting is favored. They balance at 273 K.
Use ΔG°f (kJ/mol): NO(g) +86.6, NO2(g) +51.3, to find ΔG° for 2 NO + O2 → 2 NO2.
Show answer
A student says a favored reaction must happen quickly. Give a counterexample and the term for it.
Show answer
Diamond turning into graphite (ΔG° < 0) or a fuel-air mixture without a spark: favored but immeasurably slow because of a high activation energy. Such a process is under kinetic control.
Unit 7 gave you the equilibrium constant K, which tells how far a reaction goes. Unit 9 gave you ΔG°, which tells whether a process is favored. They are two views of the same thing, and one equation connects them.
In this lesson you will convert between ΔG° and K, and apply the idea to a case you have already met in two units: the dissolving of a salt.
Learning objectives · 9.5.A and 9.6.A
9.5.A Explain whether a process is thermodynamically favored using the relationships between K, ΔG°, and T. 9.6.A Explain the relationship between the solubility of a salt and changes in the enthalpy and entropy that occur in the dissolution process.
Required content · EK 9.5.A.1 to 9.5.A.4 and 9.6.A.1
The phrase “thermodynamically favored” (ΔG° < 0) means that the products are favored at equilibrium (K > 1) under standard conditions.
The equilibrium constant is related to free energy by the equations \(K = e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT}\) and \(\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K\).
Connections between K and ΔG° can be made qualitatively through estimation. When ΔG° is near zero, the equilibrium constant will be close to 1. When ΔG° is much larger or much smaller than RT, the value of K deviates strongly from 1.
Processes with ΔG° < 0 favor products (i.e., K > 1) and those with ΔG° > 0 favor reactants (i.e., K < 1).
The free energy change (ΔG°) for dissolution of a substance reflects a number of factors: the breaking of the intermolecular interactions that hold the solid together, the reorganization of the solvent around the dissolved species, and the interaction of the dissolved species with the solvent. It is possible to estimate the sign and relative magnitude of the enthalpic and entropic contributions to each of these factors. However, making predictions for the total change in free energy of dissolution can be challenging due to the cancellations among the free energies associated with the three factors cited.
The link between ΔG° and K
Under standard conditions (all species at 1 M or 1 bar) ΔG° tells where the reaction would go from the standard starting point; K tells where it ends up at equilibrium. They are related by
\[ \Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K \qquad\text{or}\qquad K = e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT} \]
where \(R = 8.314\) J mol−1 K−1 (use 0.008314 kJ mol−1 K−1 if ΔG° is in kJ) and \(T\) is in kelvin. At 298 K, \(RT = 2.48\) kJ/mol.
Figure 9.5a K = e−ΔG°/RT. At 298 K each 5.7 kJ/mol of ΔG° changes K by a factor of 10. Near ΔG° = 0 the constant is close to 1; once |ΔG°| is much greater than RT (2.5 kJ/mol) K is far from 1.
\(\Delta G^\circ \lt 0\): \(K \gt 1\). Products are favored at equilibrium.
\(\Delta G^\circ = 0\): \(K = 1\).
\(\Delta G^\circ \gt 0\): \(K \lt 1\). Reactants are favored at equilibrium.
Because of the exponential, the size of \(\Delta G^\circ\) compared with \(RT\) (about 2.5 kJ/mol at room temperature) controls how extreme \(K\) is: at 298 K a ΔG° of −5.7 kJ/mol corresponds to \(K = 10\) and −11.4 kJ/mol to \(K = 100\). Values of ΔG° of tens of kJ/mol correspond to K values of thousands to many powers of ten. “Favored” with ΔG° of −0.5 kJ/mol means only \(K = 1.2\): products are favored, but by a small margin.
Worked example · K from ΔG°
For N2 + 3 H2 → 2 NH3, ΔG° = −33.1 kJ at 298 K. Find K.
\(\ln K = -\Delta G^\circ/RT = 33{,}100/[(8.314)(298.15)] = 13.35\), so \(K = e^{13.35} = \) \(6.3 \times 10^5\). The reaction goes very nearly to completion at 298 K (but slowly: kinetic control).
Worked example · ΔG° from K
The ionization of acetic acid has \(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\) at 298 K. Find ΔG° and comment.
\(\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K = -(8.314)(298.15)\ln(1.8 \times 10^{-5}) = -(2479)(-10.93) = +27{,}100\) J = +27.1 kJ/mol. Positive, so the reactants (HA) are favored at equilibrium, which is why only a tiny fraction of acetic acid ionizes. A weak acid has ΔG° > 0 for its ionization.
Worked example · temperature dependence
With ΔH° = −92.2 kJ and ΔS° = −198.1 J/K (assumed independent of T), estimate K for the ammonia synthesis at 500 K.
\(\Delta G^\circ_{500} = -92.2 - (500)(-0.1981) = +6.85\) kJ. \(\ln K = -6850/[(8.314)(500)] = -1.65\), so \(K = \) 0.19. Compare \(6.3 \times 10^5\) at 298 K: heating this exothermic reaction makes K far smaller. The connection between ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS° and K explains Le Châtelier’s prediction about temperature: for an exothermic reaction K decreases when T increases.
Worked example · estimating without a calculator
Two reactions have ΔG° = −0.4 kJ and ΔG° = −45 kJ at 298 K. Compare their K values qualitatively.
The first has ΔG° close to zero (much smaller than RT = 2.5 kJ in size), so K is near 1 (about 1.2). The second has |ΔG°| much larger than RT, so K is enormous (about \(e^{18} \approx 10^{8}\)): the reaction goes to completion.
Two meanings, one sign. ΔG° and K refer to the standard state. For a mixture that is not at standard conditions, the sign of the free energy change \(\Delta G = \Delta G^\circ + RT\ln Q\) decides the direction (the same logic as Q compared with K from Unit 7): when \(Q \lt K\), \(\Delta G \lt 0\) and the forward reaction proceeds; at equilibrium \(\Delta G = 0\) and \(Q = K\).
Free energy of dissolution
Dissolving a salt is an equilibrium (the \(K_{sp}\) of Unit 7), so its \(K_{sp}\) is linked to a free-energy change: \(\Delta G^\circ_{\text{diss}} = -RT\ln K_{sp}\). For AgCl, \(K_{sp} = 1.8 \times 10^{-10}\), so \(\Delta G^\circ = -(8.314)(298.15)\ln(1.8 \times 10^{-10}) = +55.6\) kJ/mol: strongly unfavorable, and the salt is barely soluble. A soluble salt has a negative or only slightly positive \(\Delta G^\circ\).
Why is the sign of ΔG° for dissolving so hard to predict? Because three different steps, each with its own enthalpy and entropy, add together:
Breaking the solid apart (overcoming the ionic or intermolecular attractions in the crystal): endothermic (ΔH > 0, unfavorable) with an increase in entropy (favorable).
Reorganizing the solvent (pushing water molecules apart to make room): endothermic (ΔH > 0), with some change in entropy.
Solute-solvent interactions (ion-dipole attractions as water surrounds the ions): exothermic (ΔH < 0, favorable), and entropy often decreases because water molecules become ordered around the ions (especially highly charged small ions).
The totals are the result of large numbers of opposite sign, so a small difference in the sizes decides the outcome, and predictions are difficult. The overall observable results: some salts dissolve with the solution warming (ΔH < 0: NaOH, CaCl2), some with cooling (ΔH > 0: NH4NO3, NaCl slightly), and what makes the process favored is either a sufficiently negative ΔH or a sufficiently positive TΔS.
Worked example · enthalpy-driven and entropy-driven dissolution
Dissolving NaOH(s) has ΔH ≈ −44 kJ/mol, and dissolving NH4NO3 has ΔH ≈ +26 kJ/mol. Both dissolve readily. Explain the driving force for each.
NaOH: strongly exothermic, so the negative ΔH makes ΔG negative (enthalpy-driven), even if the entropy change is small. NH4NO3: endothermic, yet it dissolves, so the entropy increase must be large enough that TΔS° > ΔH° (here \(298 \times 0.1087 = 32.4\) kJ > 25.7 kJ): it is entropy-driven, and the solution gets cold.
Worked example · a salt that is barely soluble
Silver chloride has ΔH° ≈ +65 kJ/mol and ΔS° ≈ +33 J mol−1 K−1 for dissolution. Is it favored at 298 K?
\(\Delta G^\circ = 65 - (298)(0.033) = +55\) kJ/mol (matching the value above from \(K_{sp}\)). Not favored: the very large energy cost of separating the strongly attracted ions outweighs the entropy gain, so the solubility is tiny.
Exam focus
ΔG° < 0 ⇔ K > 1; ΔG° > 0 ⇔ K < 1; ΔG° = 0 ⇔ K = 1.
ΔG° = −RT ln K, with R = 8.314 J/(mol·K) and T in kelvin; mind J versus kJ.
Estimate qualitatively: compare |ΔG°| with RT (about 2.5 kJ/mol).
Higher T: K increases for endothermic reactions and decreases for exothermic ones (consistent with ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS°).
Dissolution: name the three energy contributions and say whether enthalpy or entropy drives it.
Practice
A reaction has ΔG° = −20.0 kJ at 298 K. Find K.
Show answer
ln K = 20,000/(8.314 × 298.15) = 8.07; K = 3.2 × 103.
A reaction has ΔG° = +10.0 kJ at 298 K. Find K and say which side is favored.
Show answer
ln K = −10,000/2479 = −4.03; K = 0.018. Reactants are favored.
Without calculating, which has the larger K at 298 K: a reaction with ΔG° = −30 kJ or ΔG° = −5 kJ?
Show answer
The one with ΔG° = −30 kJ, since a more negative ΔG° corresponds to a larger K.
For a reaction at equilibrium, what are ΔG and Q compared with K?
Show answer
ΔG = 0 and Q = K. (ΔG° is generally not zero; it is related to K by ΔG° = −RT ln K.)
Find ΔG° for dissolving a salt with \(K_{sp} = 1.0 \times 10^{-5}\) at 298 K.
Show answer
A plant builds glucose from carbon dioxide and water, a reaction that would never run by itself. Your cells build proteins and DNA, which also run uphill. A lithium battery is charged by pushing current backward through it. How do thermodynamically unfavorable processes happen at all?
There are two strategies, and both are used everywhere in biology and technology: supply energy from outside, or couple the unfavorable process to a favorable one.
Learning objective · 9.7.A
Explain the relationship between external sources of energy or coupled reactions and their ability to drive thermodynamically unfavorable processes.
Required content · EK 9.7.A.1 and 9.7.A.2
An external source of energy can be used to make a thermodynamically unfavorable process occur. Examples include: (i) electrical energy to drive an electrolytic cell or charge a battery; (ii) light to drive the overall conversion of carbon dioxide to glucose in photosynthesis.
A desired product can be formed by coupling a thermodynamically unfavorable reaction that produces that product to a favorable reaction (e.g., the conversion of ATP to ADP in biological systems). In the coupled system, the individual reactions share one or more common intermediates. The sum of the individual reactions produces an overall reaction that achieves the desired outcome and has ΔG° < 0.
Strategy 1: an external source of energy
A reaction with \(\Delta G^\circ \gt 0\) will not proceed on its own. But energy supplied from outside can push it forward, in the same way that a pump moves water uphill. The input must at least cover the free energy cost.
Electrical energy. In an electrolytic cell an external voltage drives a nonfavored redox reaction: 2 H2O(l) → 2 H2(g) + O2(g) has \(\Delta G^\circ = +474.2\) kJ, and it only runs when a source supplies electrical energy. Recharging a battery is the same: the discharge reaction is favored, so the reverse is driven by the charger.
Light. In photosynthesis, 6 CO2 + 6 H2O → C6H12O6 + 6 O2 has \(\Delta G^\circ \approx +2879\) kJ per mole of glucose (using \(\Delta G^\circ_f\) values: \(-910.4 - [6(-394.4) + 6(-237.1)] = +2878.6\) kJ). Absorbed sunlight supplies the energy.
Heat can also supply energy; recall that a process with positive ΔH and positive ΔS (such as the decomposition of limestone) is driven when the temperature is raised until \(T\Delta S^\circ\) exceeds ΔH°.
The principle holds in every case: the external energy is used up, and the products now sit at higher free energy than the reactants (stored chemical energy). The reverse reaction, if it ran, would release it again, as when glucose is burned or respired.
Strategy 2: coupling reactions
Two reactions can be coupled when they share a common species (an intermediate): a species produced by one reaction is consumed by the other. If the unfavorable reaction (ΔG1° > 0) is added to a sufficiently favorable one (ΔG2° < 0), the free energy changes add:
\[ \Delta G^\circ_{\text{overall}} = \Delta G^\circ_1 + \Delta G^\circ_2 \]
and if the sum is negative, the combined process is favored and the product of the unfavorable reaction forms. The free energy needed by the first reaction is paid by the second.
Figure 9.7a Coupling an unfavorable reaction to a favorable one. The conversion of ATP to ADP (ΔG° = −30.5 kJ/mol) drives phosphorylation of glucose (+13.8 kJ/mol). The sum is favored (−16.7 kJ/mol). Values are biochemical standard values near pH 7.
The standard example is ATP. Hydrolysis of ATP, ATP + H2O → ADP + HPO42−, has \(\Delta G^\circ = -30.5\) kJ/mol (biochemical standard conditions), a favorable reaction used to drive many unfavorable steps. Phosphorylating glucose directly from phosphate is not favored: glucose + HPO42− → glucose-6-phosphate + H2O, \(\Delta G^\circ = +13.8\) kJ/mol. In the cell the two steps are coupled through a common intermediate (the phosphate group is transferred from ATP to glucose); the overall reaction glucose + ATP → glucose-6-phosphate + ADP has
\[ \Delta G^\circ = +13.8 + (-30.5) = -16.7\ \text{kJ/mol} \]
Favored: the cell has used the energy stored in ATP to make an otherwise uphill product.
Worked example · is the coupling enough?
A synthesis step has ΔG° = +50 kJ/mol. ATP hydrolysis has ΔG° = −30.5 kJ/mol. Is one ATP enough? How many are needed?
One ATP gives \(+50 + (-30.5) = +19.5\) kJ, still positive: not enough. Two ATP give \(+50 + 2(-30.5) = -11\) kJ: favored. The overall energy release must exceed the cost, so two ATP must be coupled (and the stoichiometry of the coupled reaction is adjusted to use two).
Worked example · adding reactions with a shared species
Reaction 1: A + B → C + D, ΔG° = +22 kJ. Reaction 2: D + E → F, ΔG° = −40 kJ. Write the coupled reaction and ΔG°. Which species is the common intermediate?
Adding: A + B + D + E → C + D + F, and D cancels: A + B + E → C + F, \(\Delta G^\circ = +22 + (-40) = -18\) kJ: favored. D is the common intermediate (produced by reaction 1 and consumed by reaction 2).
Worked example · extracting a metal
Heating ZnO alone to make Zn has \(\Delta G^\circ \gt 0\) at modest temperatures. Explain how adding carbon makes the process work.
Carbon is oxidized to CO in a reaction with a large negative ΔG°, which becomes even more negative as the temperature rises because a gas is produced (ΔS > 0). Coupled to the unfavorable ZnO → Zn + ½ O2, whose oxygen is the shared species, the overall reaction ZnO + C → Zn + CO is favored at the high temperature of a furnace.
Thermodynamic favorability still does not mean speed: a coupled reaction proceeds at a useful rate only if there is a pathway with a manageable activation energy, which is why enzymes are needed to bring the ATP and the glucose together.
Exam focus
Unfavorable (ΔG° > 0) processes need external energy or coupling to a favorable reaction.
Add the equations and the ΔG° values; the shared intermediate cancels.
The overall ΔG° must be negative for the coupled process to be favored; show the sum.
Examples to cite: electrolysis and battery charging (electrical), photosynthesis (light), ATP → ADP (coupling).
Coupling changes the overall outcome, not the ΔG° of each separate reaction.
Practice
Reaction X → Y has ΔG° = +35 kJ. Reaction Z → W has ΔG° = −48 kJ and shares a common intermediate with it. What is ΔG° for the coupled reaction?
Show answer
+35 + (−48) = −13 kJ. The coupled process is favored.
Why can electrolysis of water produce H2 and O2 although ΔG° = +474 kJ?
Show answer
An external source of electrical energy drives the reaction: the process is not favored by itself, but the electrical work supplied exceeds the free-energy cost.
What is the role of sunlight in photosynthesis in thermodynamic terms?
Show answer
It supplies the energy needed to drive a reaction with a large positive ΔG° (about +2879 kJ per mole of glucose), storing energy in the products.
For the glucose phosphorylation coupled to ATP hydrolysis, what is the common intermediate?
Show answer
The phosphate species (HPO42− or the phosphate group transferred from ATP): one reaction releases it and the other consumes it, so it cancels in the sum.
A student claims that coupling makes the unfavorable reaction itself favorable. Evaluate.
Show answer
Not quite. The unfavorable reaction still has ΔG° > 0 by itself; it is the overall coupled process (the sum) that has ΔG° < 0 and so can proceed.
Charging a phone battery requires an external source, but discharging does not. Explain with thermodynamics.
Show answer
Discharge is a favored redox reaction (ΔG° < 0). Charging runs the reverse, which has ΔG° > 0, so electrical energy from the charger must drive it.
How many ATP (ΔG° = −30.5 kJ each) are needed at minimum to drive a reaction with ΔG° = +70 kJ?
Show answer
Three: 70 − 3(30.5) = −21.5 kJ. Two would give 70 − 61 = +9 kJ, still unfavorable.
Every battery you own turns a chemical reaction into an electric current. Aluminum is made, and your car bumper chromed, by sending an electric current the other way through a chemical system.
Both are electrochemical cells, and once you can read a cell diagram, you can answer any question about which way electrons move, which electrode gains mass, and which ions go where.
Learning objective · 9.8.A
Explain the relationship between the physical components of an electrochemical cell and the overall operational principles of the cell.
Required content · EK 9.8.A.1 to 9.8.A.3
Each component of an electrochemical cell (electrodes, solutions in the half-cells, salt bridge, voltage/current measuring device) plays a specific role in the overall functioning of the cell. The operational characteristics of the cell (galvanic vs. electrolytic, direction of electron flow, reactions occurring in each half-cell, change in electrode mass, evolution of a gas at an electrode, ion flow through the salt bridge) can be described at both the macroscopic and particulate levels.
Galvanic, sometimes called voltaic, cells involve a thermodynamically favored reaction, whereas electrolytic cells involve a thermodynamically unfavored reaction. Visual representations of galvanic and electrolytic cells are tools of analysis to identify where half-reactions occur and in what direction current flows.
For all electrochemical cells, oxidation occurs at the anode and reduction occurs at the cathode.
Exclusion: labeling an electrode as positive or negative is not assessed.
Redox in two halves
A redox reaction transfers electrons from a reducing agent (which is oxidized) to an oxidizing agent (which is reduced). If the two halves are kept in separate containers and connected by a wire, the electrons must travel through the wire, and that moving charge is a current that can do work.
For Zn + Cu2+ → Zn2+ + Cu the half-reactions are
Oxidation: Zn → Zn2+ + 2 e−
Reduction: Cu2+ + 2 e− → Cu
Two terms never change, whatever the cell: oxidation occurs at the anode and reduction occurs at the cathode (remember “AN OX” and “RED CAT”), and electrons always flow through the external wire from the anode to the cathode.
Galvanic (voltaic) cells
Figure 9.8a Zn–Cu galvanic cell. Oxidation occurs at the anode (Zn), and reduction occurs at the cathode (Cu). Electrons flow through the wire from anode to cathode; ions flow through the salt bridge to keep each half-cell electrically neutral. The reaction is thermodynamically favored (E° > 0).
A galvanic cell uses a thermodynamically favored redox reaction (ΔG° < 0, E° > 0) to produce electrical energy. Its components:
Electrodes: conducting solids where the half-reactions occur. The anode (Zn) is where oxidation occurs; the cathode (Cu) is where reduction occurs.
Solutions in the half-cells: each contains the ions of its half-reaction (Zn2+ with an anion such as SO42−; Cu2+ with SO42−).
External circuit (wire and a voltmeter or device): carries the electrons from anode to cathode.
Salt bridge (or porous barrier): completes the circuit by letting ions move between the half-cells, keeping each solution electrically neutral. Without it, positive charge would pile up in the anode compartment (Zn2+ is produced) and negative charge in the cathode compartment (positive ions leave), and the current would stop at once. Anions flow toward the anode and cations toward the cathode.
What you would observe: the Zn electrode loses mass as Zn2+ enters the solution; the Cu electrode gains mass as copper plates onto it; the blue color of Cu2+ fades; the voltmeter reads about +1.10 V under standard conditions.
Worked example · reading a diagram
A cell consists of a Cu electrode in Cu2+ and an Ag electrode in Ag+, joined by a wire and a salt bridge of KNO3. The silver electrode gains mass. Identify the anode, cathode, direction of electron flow, and the direction in which NO3− moves.
Ag gains mass: Ag+ + e− → Ag is occurring there, so reduction occurs at the Ag electrode: Ag is the cathode and Cu is the anode (Cu → Cu2+ + 2 e−). Electrons flow through the wire from Cu to Ag. Nitrate (an anion) moves through the salt bridge toward the anode (the Cu half-cell), and K+ toward the cathode (Ag half-cell). Overall: Cu + 2 Ag+ → Cu2+ + 2 Ag.
Electrolytic cells
Figure 9.8b Electrolytic cell. An external source of electrical energy drives a reaction that is not thermodynamically favored. Oxidation still occurs at the anode and reduction at the cathode, but now the source pushes electrons toward the cathode.
An electrolytic cell uses electrical energy from an external source to force a thermodynamically unfavored reaction to occur (ΔG° > 0, E° < 0 for the cell reaction). Its definitions remain the same: oxidation at the anode, reduction at the cathode; electrons still travel through the wire from anode to cathode, but now they are driven by the external source. Often both electrodes are in the same container, because there is no need to separate the reaction halves.
For molten NaCl, chloride is oxidized at the anode (2 Cl− → Cl2 + 2 e−, chlorine gas is evolved), and sodium ions are reduced at the cathode (Na+ + e− → Na, liquid sodium is formed). The overall reaction 2 NaCl → 2 Na + Cl2 would never occur on its own at this temperature.
Galvanic cell
Electrolytic cell
Overall reaction
thermodynamically favored (ΔG° < 0, E° > 0)
thermodynamically unfavored (ΔG° > 0, E° < 0)
Energy conversion
chemical → electrical
electrical → chemical
Anode
oxidation
oxidation
Cathode
reduction
reduction
Electron flow in the wire
anode → cathode
anode → cathode
Ion flow
anions toward anode, cations toward cathode
anions toward anode, cations toward cathode
Source of current
the reaction itself
an external power supply
Worked example · electrolysis in solution
Copper(II) sulfate solution is electrolyzed with copper electrodes. The mass of the cathode increases and the mass of the anode decreases. Write the half-reactions.
Cathode (reduction): Cu2+ + 2 e− → Cu (copper plates onto the cathode: mass increases). Anode (oxidation): Cu → Cu2+ + 2 e− (copper dissolves: mass decreases). The net change transfers copper from the anode to the cathode, the basis of electroplating and electrorefining.
Worked example · modifying an experiment
In the Zn-Cu cell a student removes the salt bridge. Predict what happens to the voltage and explain at the particle level.
The voltage falls rapidly to zero and current stops. As electrons leave the Zn half-cell, Zn2+ ions accumulate there (a net positive charge) while the Cu half-cell loses positive ions (a net negative charge). Charge builds up and opposes the flow of further electrons. The salt bridge supplies ions to neutralize both, so the circuit is not complete without it.
Exam focus
Oxidation at the anode, reduction at the cathode, in every cell.
Electrons flow from anode to cathode through the wire; anions go toward the anode, cations toward the cathode in the salt bridge.
Galvanic = favored; electrolytic = unfavored (needs a source).
Connect observations to half-reactions: mass gain means a reduction there; mass loss means oxidation; gas evolved means a gas-forming half-reaction.
Describe the salt bridge function as maintaining charge neutrality, not carrying electrons.
Practice
In a Zn-Cu cell, which electrode increases in mass, and which half-reaction occurs there?
Show answer
The Cu electrode: Cu2+ + 2 e− → Cu (reduction at the cathode).
In an Fe/Ag cell, Fe is the anode. Write the overall reaction using Fe → Fe2+ and Ag+ → Ag.
Show answer
Fe → Fe2+ + 2 e− and 2 Ag+ + 2 e− → 2 Ag. Overall: Fe + 2 Ag+ → Fe2+ + 2 Ag.
In the electrolysis of molten NaCl, at which electrode is a gas evolved, and what is it?
Show answer
At the anode: Cl2 gas, from 2 Cl− → Cl2 + 2 e− (oxidation).
Give two differences between a galvanic and an electrolytic cell and one similarity.
Show answer
Galvanic: favored reaction, produces electrical energy. Electrolytic: unfavored reaction, needs an external source. Similarity: oxidation occurs at the anode and reduction at the cathode (and electrons flow from anode to cathode in the wire).
In a galvanic cell the NO3− ions in the salt bridge migrate toward the Zn half-cell. Which electrode is the anode?
Show answer
Zn is the anode. Anions flow toward the anode to balance the positive Zn2+ being produced there.
Why do electrons not flow through the salt bridge?
Show answer
The salt bridge contains an electrolyte solution, a medium for ion flow, not a conductor of electrons. Electrons travel through the metal wire; the ions move in solution to keep the charge balanced.
A AA battery is rated 1.5 V, a car battery 12 V, a lithium-ion cell 3.7 V. The voltage of a cell is not arbitrary: it is set by the chemistry of the two half-reactions, and it is a direct measure of how strongly favored the reaction is.
With a table of standard reduction potentials you can predict the voltage of a cell you have never built and decide whether a reaction will run.
Learning objective · 9.9.A
Explain whether an electrochemical cell is thermodynamically favored, based on its standard cell potential and the constituent half-reactions within the cell.
Required content · EK 9.9.A.1 to 9.9.A.3
Electrochemistry encompasses the study of redox reactions that occur within electrochemical cells. The reactions are either thermodynamically favored (resulting in a positive voltage) or thermodynamically unfavored (resulting in a negative voltage and requiring an externally applied potential for the reaction to proceed).
The standard cell potential of electrochemical cells can be calculated by identifying the oxidation and reduction half-reactions and their respective standard reduction potentials.
ΔG° (standard Gibbs free energy change) is proportional to the negative of the cell potential for the redox reaction from which it is constructed. Thus, a cell with a positive E° involves a thermodynamically favored reaction, and a cell with a negative E° involves a thermodynamically unfavored reaction: \(\Delta G^\circ = -nFE^\circ\).
Cell potential
The cell potential \(E_{\text{cell}}\) (also called the electromotive force or voltage) is the electrical potential difference between the two electrodes, measured in volts (1 V = 1 J of energy per coulomb of charge). It measures the “push” on the electrons. The standard cell potential \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}}\) refers to standard conditions: 1 M solutions, gases at 1 bar, 25 °C.
Standard reduction potentials
No one can measure the potential of a single half-reaction, so every half-reaction is compared with a reference, the standard hydrogen electrode: \(2\,\text{H}^+ + 2\,e^- \rightarrow \text{H}_2\), defined as \(E^\circ = 0.00\) V. Tables list the standard reduction potential \(E^\circ_{\text{red}}\) of each half-reaction written as a reduction.
Figure 9.9a Selected standard reduction potentials at 25 °C. The more positive E°, the stronger the oxidizing agent on the left of the arrow (the species most easily reduced). The species on the right of a low-E° half-reaction (Li, Al, Zn) are the strongest reducing agents.
The more positive \(E^\circ_{\text{red}}\), the stronger the tendency of the reactant to be reduced: the stronger the oxidizing agent on the left (F2, Cl2, O2, Ag+).
The more negative \(E^\circ_{\text{red}}\), the weaker the tendency to be reduced, so the stronger the reducing agent on the right (Li, Al, Zn).
Changing the coefficients of a half-reaction (multiplying by 2) does not change \(E^\circ\), because potential is energy per charge (an intensive property).
Reversing a half-reaction (to show oxidation) reverses the sign of \(E^\circ\).
Calculating E°cell
In any cell the half-reaction with the more positive \(E^\circ_{\text{red}}\) is the cathode (reduction), and the other runs in reverse as the anode (oxidation). Then
\[ E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = E^\circ_{\text{cathode}} - E^\circ_{\text{anode}} \]
where both are the reduction potentials from the table. (Equivalent: \(E^\circ_{\text{red}}\) of the cathode plus \(E^\circ_{\text{ox}}\) of the anode, where the oxidation potential is the negative of the reduction potential.)
Procedure
Write the two reduction half-reactions with their \(E^\circ\) values.
The more positive one is the cathode; the other is reversed to be the anode.
Balance the electrons (multiply half-reactions by whole numbers but do not change \(E^\circ\)) and add them to get the overall reaction.
\(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = E^\circ_{\text{cathode}} - E^\circ_{\text{anode}}\). If it is positive, the reaction is favored as written.
Worked example · the Daniell cell
Find \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}}\) for a cell built from Zn2+/Zn (\(-0.76\) V) and Cu2+/Cu (\(+0.34\) V).
Cu2+/Cu is more positive, so Cu is the cathode and Zn the anode. \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.34 - (-0.76) = \) +1.10 V. Overall: Zn + Cu2+ → Zn2+ + Cu. Positive: favored, a galvanic cell.
Worked example · multiplying a half-reaction
Find \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}}\) and the overall reaction for Al3+/Al (\(-1.66\) V) with Ag+/Ag (\(+0.80\) V).
Ag is the cathode, Al the anode. Balance electrons: 3 Ag+ + 3 e− → 3 Ag (\(E^\circ\) stays +0.80 V, not tripled) and Al → Al3+ + 3 e−. Overall: Al + 3 Ag+ → Al3+ + 3 Ag. \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.80 - (-1.66) = \) +2.46 V.
Worked example · will it react?
Will copper metal dissolve in 1 M HCl? Will zinc?
The oxidizing agent here is H+ (\(E^\circ = 0.00\) V). For Cu: \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.00 - 0.34 = -0.34\) V: not favored, copper does not dissolve in HCl. For Zn: \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.00 - (-0.76) = +0.76\) V: favored, zinc dissolves and releases H2. In general, a metal reacts with H+ if its reduction potential is below 0.00 V.
Cell potential and free energy
The cell potential is the energy per coulomb available from the reaction; the free energy change is the maximum energy available per mole of reaction. Multiplying the potential by the charge transferred per mole of reaction (\(nF\)) gives the energy:
\[ \Delta G^\circ = -nFE^\circ \]
where \(n\) is the number of moles of electrons transferred in the balanced equation, and \(F = 96{,}485\) C/mol e− (the Faraday constant). With \(E\) in volts, \(\Delta G^\circ\) comes out in joules (1 V × 1 C = 1 J).
\(E^\circ \lt 0\): \(\Delta G^\circ \gt 0\): not favored; the reverse is favored, and the reaction as written needs an applied potential (electrolytic).
Combining with \(\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K\) gives the link to equilibrium: \(E^\circ = (RT/nF)\ln K\), so a large positive E° means a large K.
Worked example · free energy and K from E°
For the Zn-Cu cell (\(E^\circ = 1.10\) V, \(n = 2\)) find ΔG° and K at 298 K.
\(\Delta G^\circ = -(2)(96{,}485)(1.10) = -212{,}000\) J = −212 kJ per mole of reaction. \(\ln K = -\Delta G^\circ/RT = 212{,}300/[(8.314)(298.15)] = 85.6\), so \(K = e^{85.6} \approx 10^{37}\): the reaction goes essentially to completion.
Worked example · an unfavored reaction
Is the reaction Cu + Zn2+ → Cu2+ + Zn favored? Find ΔG°.
It is the reverse of the Daniell reaction: \(E^\circ = -1.10\) V, so \(\Delta G^\circ = +212\) kJ. Not favored: copper does not reduce zinc ions. It could be driven in an electrolytic cell with an applied voltage greater than 1.10 V.
Worked example · choosing materials for a cell
For which pair would you get the larger voltage: Zn/Zn2+ with Cu2+/Cu, or Mg/Mg2+ (\(-2.37\) V) with Cu2+/Cu?
Mg with Cu: \(0.34 - (-2.37) = 2.71\) V, larger than 1.10 V, because Mg is a stronger reducing agent than Zn. The larger the difference between the two reduction potentials, the larger the cell potential.
Exam focus
E°cell = E°cathode − E°anode with reduction potentials; do not multiply E° by coefficients.
Positive E° means ΔG° < 0 (favored; galvanic). Negative E° means unfavored (electrolytic).
ΔG° = −nFE°: state n, use F = 96,485 C/mol, and convert J to kJ.
More positive E°red = stronger oxidizing agent.
Write the balanced overall equation before finding n.
Practice
Calculate E°cell for Fe2+/Fe (−0.44 V) and Ag+/Ag (+0.80 V), and write the cell reaction.
Show answer
Ag is the cathode, Fe the anode: E° = 0.80 − (−0.44) = +1.24 V. Fe + 2 Ag+ → Fe2+ + 2 Ag.
Find ΔG° for that reaction (n = 2).
Show answer
ΔG° = −(2)(96,485)(1.24) = −239,000 J = −239 kJ.
Will Ag metal react with 1 M HCl to produce H2? Explain with potentials.
Show answer
No. E° = 0.00 − 0.80 = −0.80 V, so the reaction is not favored.
Which is the strongest reducing agent among Li (−3.04 V), Zn (−0.76 V), Cu (+0.34 V)?
Show answer
Li. The most negative E°red belongs to the species that is hardest to reduce, so its reduced form (the metal) is the easiest to oxidize.
A cell has E° = −0.30 V. What does this say about the reaction as written, and how could it be made to occur?
Show answer
The reaction is not thermodynamically favored (ΔG° > 0). It could occur only if an external voltage greater than 0.30 V is applied (as in an electrolytic cell).
A student doubles all coefficients of a cell reaction and says E° doubles. Evaluate.
Show answer
E° does not change; it is energy per unit charge. However, n doubles, so ΔG° (= −nFE°) doubles, since twice as much reaction (and twice as many electrons) is being described.
A flashlight battery starts at its rated voltage and slowly fades. The chemistry has not changed; the concentrations have. As reactants are used up and products build up, the cell moves toward equilibrium, and its voltage drops until, at equilibrium, it reads zero: a dead battery.
Learning objective · 9.10.A
Explain the relationship between deviations from standard cell conditions and changes in the cell potential.
Required content · EK 9.10.A.1 to 9.10.A.4
In a real system under nonstandard conditions, the cell potential will vary depending on the concentrations of the active species. The cell potential is a driving force toward equilibrium; the farther the reaction is from equilibrium, the greater the magnitude of the cell potential.
Equilibrium arguments such as Le Châtelier’s principle do not apply to electrochemical systems, because the systems are not in equilibrium.
The standard cell potential E° corresponds to the standard conditions of Q = 1. As the system approaches equilibrium, the magnitude (i.e., absolute value) of the cell potential decreases, reaching zero at equilibrium (when Q = K). Deviations from standard conditions that take the cell further from equilibrium than Q = 1 will increase the magnitude of the cell potential relative to E°. Deviations from standard conditions that take the cell closer to equilibrium than Q = 1 will decrease the magnitude of the cell potential relative to E°. In concentration cells, the direction of spontaneous electron flow can be determined by considering the direction needed to reach equilibrium.
Algorithmic calculations using the Nernst equation are insufficient to demonstrate an understanding of electrochemical cells under nonstandard conditions. However, students should qualitatively understand the effects of concentration on cell potential and use conceptual reasoning, including the qualitative use of the Nernst equation: \(E = E^\circ - (RT/nF)\ln Q\).
The Nernst equation
The standard potential applies only when every solution is 1 M and every gas is at 1 bar, that is, when \(Q = 1\). Under any other conditions
\[ E = E^\circ - \frac{RT}{nF}\ln Q \]
where \(Q\) is the reaction quotient for the cell reaction (solids and pure liquids omitted), \(R = 8.314\) J/(mol·K), \(T\) is in kelvins, \(n\) is the moles of electrons and \(F = 96{,}485\) C/mol. At 25 °C the factor \(RT/F\) is 0.0257 V, which is small, so the correction is usually only a few hundredths of a volt unless Q is extreme.
Figure 9.10a E = E° − (RT/nF) ln Q for the Zn–Cu cell (n = 2). Increasing reactant concentration (smaller Q) raises the potential; as products build up (larger Q) the cell runs down. At equilibrium Q = K and E = 0: a dead battery.
The equation is a statement about direction, and you can reason with it without a calculator:
\(Q \lt 1\) (more reactants than standard, fewer products): \(\ln Q\) is negative, so \(E \gt E^\circ\). The cell is farther from equilibrium and pushes harder.
\(Q = 1\): \(E = E^\circ\).
\(Q \gt 1\) (more products): \(E \lt E^\circ\). The cell is closer to equilibrium and pushes less.
\(Q = K\): \(E = 0\) (the system is at equilibrium; the battery is dead). Check: at equilibrium \(E^\circ = (RT/nF)\ln K\), so \(E = 0\).
Notice what this means: the cell potential is the driving force toward equilibrium. The farther the reaction mixture sits from equilibrium, the larger the voltage; the closer it gets, the smaller the voltage. In a galvanic cell the reaction runs forward, so Q rises from its starting value toward K and E falls toward zero.
Worked example · qualitative prediction
In the Zn-Cu cell (Zn + Cu2+ → Zn2+ + Cu, \(E^\circ = 1.10\) V) the concentration of Cu2+ is lowered to 0.010 M while Zn2+ stays at 1.0 M. Is the voltage greater or less than 1.10 V?
\(Q = [\text{Zn}^{2+}]/[\text{Cu}^{2+}] = 1.0/0.010 = 100\), greater than 1, so \(\ln Q \gt 0\) and \(E \lt E^\circ\). Less reactant than standard means the cell is closer to equilibrium. Numerically, \(E = 1.10 - (0.0257/2)\ln 100 = 1.10 - 0.0592 = \) 1.04 V (the exam asks for the direction of the change, not this arithmetic).
Worked example · a cell that runs down
Explain, using Q and K, why the voltage of the Zn-Cu cell steadily declines as it runs, and what is true when it reads 0 V.
As the cell discharges, Zn2+ is produced and Cu2+ consumed, so Q increases from 1 (or lower) toward K (about \(10^{37}\)). Because \(E = E^\circ - (RT/nF)\ln Q\), E decreases as Q grows. When Q = K the cell is at equilibrium, E = 0, ΔG = 0 and no net current flows. A real cell is never allowed to go that far: it is exhausted when one reactant (the Zn electrode or the Cu2+) is nearly gone.
Concentration cells
A concentration cell has the same two half-cells (the same metal and the same ion) differing only in concentration. Then \(E^\circ = 0\), and the only driving force is the tendency of the concentrations to equalize. Electrons flow in the direction that moves the system toward equilibrium: the more dilute half-cell is the anode (the ion is produced there, raising its concentration) and the more concentrated half-cell is the cathode (the ion is consumed there, lowering its concentration). The voltage falls to zero when the two concentrations are equal.
Worked example · a copper concentration cell
One half-cell has Cu in 1.0 M Cu2+; the other has Cu in 0.010 M Cu2+. Identify the anode and cathode, the direction of electron flow, and the cell voltage.
Cathode: the 1.0 M half-cell, where Cu2+ is reduced to Cu (its concentration decreases). Anode: the 0.010 M half-cell, where Cu is oxidized to Cu2+ (its concentration increases). Electrons flow through the wire from the dilute half-cell to the concentrated one. \(Q = 0.010/1.0 = 0.010\), so \(E = 0 - (0.0257/2)\ln(0.010) = \) +0.059 V. As the cell runs, the two concentrations approach each other and the voltage declines toward zero.
Why Le Châtelier’s principle does not apply
Le Châtelier’s principle describes how a system at equilibrium responds to a disturbance. A working electrochemical cell is deliberately not at equilibrium: it is producing a current because it is far from it. So a statement such as “adding Cu2+ shifts the equilibrium to the right, increasing the voltage” is not a valid argument. The correct argument compares Q with K (or with 1) and tells you whether the cell is farther from or closer to equilibrium, and therefore whether the voltage rises or falls.
Worked example · adding a precipitating ion
A student adds NaOH to the Cu2+ half-cell of a Zn-Cu cell, precipitating Cu(OH)2. Predict the change in voltage and justify it.
The precipitation removes Cu2+ from solution, so \([\text{Cu}^{2+}]\) falls and \(Q = [\text{Zn}^{2+}]/[\text{Cu}^{2+}]\) rises. A larger Q means the cell is closer to equilibrium, so E falls below its earlier value: the voltage decreases. (The reasoning is about Q and the driving force, not about shifting an equilibrium.)
Exam focus
Compare Q with 1 (and with K): Q < 1 gives E > E°; Q > 1 gives E < E°; Q = K gives E = 0.
The cell potential is the driving force toward equilibrium; it shrinks as the cell runs.
Do not use Le Châtelier’s principle for a working cell; use Q and the Nernst equation qualitatively.
Concentration cell: dilute side is the anode, concentrated side is the cathode; E° = 0.
Write Q for the cell reaction before reasoning, leaving out solids and liquids.
Practice
For Zn + Cu2+ → Zn2+ + Cu, the Zn2+ concentration is raised to 2.0 M with Cu2+ at 1.0 M. Is E greater or less than E°?
Show answer
Q = 2.0/1.0 = 2, greater than 1, so E < E° (slightly less than 1.10 V). More product means closer to equilibrium.
What is the value of E when the cell reaction reaches equilibrium?
Show answer
Zero. At Q = K there is no driving force, so no net current flows.
In a Ag concentration cell, one half-cell is 0.10 M Ag+ and the other is 0.0010 M. Which is the cathode, and which way do the electrons flow?
Show answer
The 0.10 M half-cell is the cathode (Ag+ is reduced there, lowering the concentration). Electrons flow from the 0.0010 M anode to the 0.10 M cathode.
A battery’s voltage falls steadily during use. Explain in terms of Q.
Show answer
As the reaction proceeds, products accumulate and reactants are consumed, so Q increases toward K. Because E = E° − (RT/nF) ln Q, E decreases and reaches zero at Q = K.
A student says, “Adding more reactant shifts the equilibrium right, so the voltage goes up.” Critique this.
Show answer
The cell is not at equilibrium, so Le Châtelier’s principle does not apply. The correct claim: more reactant lowers Q below its earlier value, farther from equilibrium, so E increases. The conclusion is right but the argument must use Q and the driving force.
For a concentration cell with both half-cells 0.50 M, what is E?
Show answer
Zero. E° = 0 and Q = 1, so E = 0: with equal concentrations the cell is already at equilibrium.
How much copper is deposited by a given current in a given time? How long must a current flow to plate a ring with silver? How much electricity does it take to make a ton of aluminum? These are stoichiometry questions in which the “reagent” is electric charge, and one conversion factor, the Faraday constant, links charge to moles.
Learning objective · 9.11.A
Calculate the amount of charge flow based on changes in the amounts of reactants and products in an electrochemical cell.
Required content · EK 9.11.A.1
Faraday’s laws can be used to determine the stoichiometry of the redox reaction occurring in an electrochemical cell with respect to the following: (i) number of electrons transferred; (ii) mass of material deposited on or removed from an electrode (as in electroplating); (iii) current; (iv) time elapsed; (v) charge of ionic species. \(I = q/t\).
Charge, current and moles of electrons
Current \(I\) is the rate of charge flow: one ampere is one coulomb per second. So the charge that passes in a time \(t\) is
\[ q = It \qquad (I \text{ in amperes}, t \text{ in seconds}, q \text{ in coulombs}) \]
One mole of electrons carries a charge of \(F = 96{,}485\) C (the Faraday constant), so
\[ \text{moles of } e^- = \frac{q}{F} = \frac{It}{F} \]
This is Faraday’s law of electrolysis: the amount of substance produced or consumed at an electrode is proportional to the charge that passes, and it is set by how many electrons each particle needs, which comes from the half-reaction (Cu2+ + 2 e− → Cu needs 2 mol e− per mol Cu; Ag+ + e− → Ag needs 1; Al3+ + 3 e− → Al needs 3).
Figure 9.11a The path for Faraday's law calculations. Every electrolysis problem is a stoichiometry chain: electrical quantities to moles of electrons, then to moles of substance using the half-reaction, then to grams.
The roadmap
Charge: \(q = It\). (Convert minutes or hours to seconds.)
Moles of electrons: \(q/F\).
Moles of substance: use the electrons in the half-reaction (the mole ratio).
Mass (or gas volume): multiply by molar mass (or use \(PV = nRT\)).
You can enter at any box and travel in either direction, so the same map answers questions about mass, current or time.
Worked example · mass deposited
A current of 2.50 A flows through a CuSO4 solution for 30.0 minutes. What mass of copper plates out at the cathode?
\(q = (2.50)(30.0 \times 60) = 4500\) C. Moles of \(e^-\) = \(4500/96{,}485 = 0.04664\) mol. Cu2+ + 2 e− → Cu, so mol Cu = \(0.04664/2 = 0.02332\). Mass = \(0.02332 \times 63.55 = \) 1.48 g.
Worked example · time required
How long must a 1.00 A current flow to plate 2.00 g of silver from Ag+?
mol Ag = \(2.00/107.87 = 0.01854\). Ag+ + e− → Ag: mol \(e^-\) = 0.01854. \(q = 0.01854 \times 96{,}485 = 1789\) C. \(t = q/I = 1789/1.00 = 1789\) s = 29.8 min.
Worked example · the charge on the ion
How long must a 100 kA current (the scale of an aluminum smelter) flow to make 1.00 kg of aluminum from Al3+?
mol Al = \(1000/26.98 = 37.06\). Each Al3+ takes 3 e−: \(3 \times 37.06 = 111.2\) mol e−, so \(q = 111.2 \times 96{,}485 = 1.07 \times 10^7\) C. At \(1.00 \times 10^5\) A, \(t = 1.07 \times 10^7/10^5 = \) 107 s. Silver would need only 1 mol e− per mole of metal. The higher the charge of the ion, the more charge per mole of metal; this, and the energy of the process, are why aluminum is expensive in electricity.
Worked example · finding the charge of an ion
A current of 0.500 A passes for 1.00 hour through a solution of zinc ions of unknown charge, and 0.610 g of zinc (65.38 g/mol) is deposited. Find the charge of the ion.
\(q = (0.500)(3600) = 1800\) C; mol \(e^-\) = \(1800/96{,}485 = 0.01866\). mol Zn = \(0.610/65.38 = 0.00933\). Electrons per ion = \(0.01866/0.00933 = 2.00\), so the ion is Zn2+ (\(n = 2\)).
Gases and other products
The same method works when a gas is produced. In the electrolysis of water, the half-reactions are 2 H2O + 2 e− → H2 + 2 OH− (2 mol e− per mol H2) and 2 H2O → O2 + 4 H+ + 4 e− (4 mol e− per mol O2). Passing 0.0200 mol of electrons therefore makes 0.0100 mol H2 and 0.00500 mol O2, in the 2:1 volume ratio you see in the tubes.
Electroplating and refining
In electroplating the object to be coated is the cathode, so metal ions in solution are reduced onto it; the anode is often a bar of the plating metal that dissolves to replace the ions. Electrorefining of copper uses an impure copper anode that dissolves and a pure copper cathode that grows. The amount plated is exactly what Faraday’s law predicts, so the thickness of a coating is controlled by controlling the current and the time.
Exam focus
q = It, then mol e− = q/F; time must be in seconds.
Get the electrons per particle from the half-reaction, not from memory; the ion’s charge sets the mole ratio.
Work in a chain (charge, electrons, moles, mass) and carry units.
Higher charge on the ion means more charge per mole of metal.
Reduction at the cathode: the metal plates there; the anode loses mass if it is the metal.
Practice
How many coulombs pass when 3.00 A flows for 10.0 minutes?
Show answer
q = (3.00)(600) = 1800 C.
How many moles of electrons are in 1800 C?
Show answer
1800/96,485 = 0.01866 mol e−.
What mass of silver is deposited by 0.0187 mol of electrons?
Show answer
One electron per Ag: 0.0187 mol Ag × 107.87 g/mol = 2.02 g.
Which deposits more mass per mole of electrons, Ag+ or Cu2+? Explain.
Show answer
Per mole of electrons: Ag, 107.87 g; Cu, 63.55/2 = 31.8 g. Silver, because each Ag+ needs only one electron.
A current of 5.00 A flows for 1.00 hour through molten MgCl2. What mass of Mg forms?
Show answer
A student plating a spoon wants to double the mass of silver deposited. Give two ways.
Show answer
Double the time (same current) or double the current (same time); either doubles the charge, q = It.
Unit 9 practice · 10 problems
Unit 9 practice: Thermodynamics and Electrochemistry
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one on paper
before revealing the answer. Calculator allowed; \(R = 8.314\) J/(mol·K), \(F = 96{,}485\) C/mol e−.
Standard reduction potentials: Ag+/Ag +0.80 V, Cu2+/Cu +0.34 V, Ni2+/Ni −0.26 V, Zn2+/Zn −0.76 V, Al3+/Al −1.66 V.
Predict the sign of \(\Delta S\) for each and justify: (a) 2 H2(g) + O2(g) → 2 H2O(l); (b) NH4Cl(s) → NH3(g) + HCl(g); (c) I2(s) → I2(g); (d) 2 NO2(g) → N2O4(g).
Show answer
(a) Negative: three moles of gas become a liquid; far fewer positions and energy arrangements available. (b) Positive: a solid becomes two moles of gas. (c) Positive: solid → gas; molecules go from a fixed lattice to roaming the container. (d) Negative: two gas moles become one.
Using \(S^\circ\) values H2(g) 130.7, O2(g) 205.2, H2O(l) 69.9 J/(mol·K), calculate \(\Delta S^\circ\) for 2 H2O(l) → 2 H2(g) + O2(g). Does the sign match your prediction?
Show answer
\(\Delta S^\circ = [2(130.7) + 205.2] - 2(69.9) = 466.6 - 139.8 = +326.8\) J/(mol·K). Positive, as expected for a liquid turning into three moles of gas. Note that the elements do not have \(S^\circ = 0\), unlike \(\Delta H^\circ_f\).
For the reaction in problem 2, \(\Delta H^\circ = +571.6\) kJ. Find \(\Delta G^\circ\) at 298 K, decide whether the decomposition of water is favorable, and estimate the temperature above which it becomes favorable.
Show answer
Convert units: \(\Delta S^\circ = 0.3268\) kJ/K. \(\Delta G^\circ = 571.6 - (298)(0.3268) = 571.6 - 97.4 = +474.2\) kJ: unfavorable at 298 K (water doesn't fall apart). Crossover: \(T = \dfrac{\Delta H^\circ}{\Delta S^\circ} = \dfrac{571{,}600\ \mathrm{J}}{326.8\ \mathrm{J/K}} = 1750\) K. Above roughly 1750 K the \(T\Delta S\) term wins. Mixing kJ and J here is the classic error.
A reaction has \(\Delta H \lt 0\) and \(\Delta S \lt 0\). It is thermodynamically favorable
Favorable at all temperatures requires \(\Delta H \lt 0\) and \(\Delta S \gt 0\), so that both terms in \(\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S\) are negative. Here the entropy term opposes the reaction, so there is a temperature above which it wins.
Favorable at no temperature is the case \(\Delta H \gt 0\) and \(\Delta S \lt 0\), where both terms are positive. Here \(\Delta H\) is negative and drives the reaction whenever \(T\) is small enough.
\(\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S\): the negative \(\Delta H\) favors the reaction, the negative \(\Delta S\) opposes it, and the opposing term \(-T\Delta S\) grows with \(T\), so at low \(T\) the enthalpy wins and \(\Delta G \lt 0\) (freezing water is the example). Remember that \(\Delta G\) says favorable, not fast: diamond → graphite has \(\Delta G^\circ = -2.9\) kJ/mol, yet diamonds persist because rearranging every C–C bond has an enormous activation energy: the change is under kinetic control.
High temperature is where the \(-T\Delta S\) term dominates, and with \(\Delta S \lt 0\) that term is positive, making \(\Delta G \gt 0\). “Only at high temperatures” belongs to reactions with \(\Delta H \gt 0\) and \(\Delta S \gt 0\), such as melting.
Acetic acid has \(K_a = 1.8 \times 10^{-5}\) at 298 K. Calculate \(\Delta G^\circ\) for its ionization and interpret the sign.
Show answer
\(\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K = -(8.314)(298)\ln(1.8 \times 10^{-5}) = -(2478)(-10.93) = +2.71 \times 10^{4}\) J/mol \(= +27.1\) kJ/mol. Positive: \(K \lt 1\), so at equilibrium the un-ionized acid is favored over the ions; exactly what "weak acid" means.
A reaction has \(\Delta G^\circ = -16.4\) kJ/mol at 298 K. Find \(K\). Are products or reactants favored?
Show answer
\(\ln K = -\dfrac{\Delta G^\circ}{RT} = \dfrac{16{,}400\ \mathrm{J/mol}}{(8.314)(298)} = 6.62\), so \(K = e^{6.62} = 7.5 \times 10^{2}\). \(K \gt 1\): products favored. Convert kJ to J before dividing.
CuO(s) → Cu(s) + ½ O2(g) has \(\Delta G^\circ = +129.7\) kJ, and C(s) + ½ O2(g) → CO(g) has \(\Delta G^\circ = -137.2\) kJ. Show how carbon can be used to extract copper from its oxide, and find \(\Delta G^\circ\) for the coupled reaction.
Show answer
Add the two: the ½ O2 cancels, giving CuO(s) + C(s) → Cu(s) + CO(g) with \(\Delta G^\circ = 129.7 + (-137.2) = -7.5\) kJ. Free-energy changes add, so coupling the unfavorable decomposition to the more favorable oxidation of carbon (which consumes the O2 the first reaction produces) makes the overall process favorable.
A galvanic cell is built from Ni/Ni2+(1.0 M) and Ag/Ag+(1.0 M) half-cells. Identify the anode and cathode, write the half-reactions and the overall equation, find \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}}\), write the cell notation, and describe the direction of electron flow and of ion migration in the salt bridge.
Show answer
Ag+ has the higher reduction potential, so it is reduced: Ag is the cathode, Ni the anode. Anode: Ni → Ni2+ + 2 e−. Cathode: Ag+ + e− → Ag (×2). Overall: Ni(s) + 2 Ag+(aq) → Ni2+(aq) + 2 Ag(s). \(E^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.80 - (-0.26) = 1.06\) V (potentials are not multiplied by 2). Notation: Ni(s) | Ni2+(aq) || Ag+(aq) | Ag(s). Electrons flow Ni → Ag through the wire; in the salt bridge, anions drift toward the Ni half-cell (to balance the Ni2+ being produced) and cations toward the Ag half-cell.
For the Ni/Ag cell in problem 8, calculate \(\Delta G^\circ\). Then predict how \(E_{\text{cell}}\) changes if [Ag+] is increased to 2.0 M, with reasoning.
Show answer
Two electrons are transferred: \(\Delta G^\circ = -nFE^\circ = -(2)(96{,}485\ \mathrm{C/mol})(1.06\ \mathrm{J/C}) = -2.05 \times 10^{5}\) J \(= -205\) kJ/mol. Negative, matching \(E^\circ \gt 0\). Raising [Ag+] (a reactant) makes \(Q = [\mathrm{Ni^{2+}}]/[\mathrm{Ag^+}]^2\) smaller, so the system is farther from equilibrium and \(E \gt 1.06\) V. Particle-level: more Ag+ at the cathode means more frequent reduction events.
A current of 4.00 A passes through molten AlCl3 for 30.0 min. What mass of aluminum is deposited, and at which electrode?
Show answer
\(q = It = (4.00\ \mathrm{A})(1800\ \mathrm{s}) = 7200\) C. Moles of electrons: \(7200 / 96{,}485 = 0.0746\) mol. Al3+ + 3 e− → Al needs three electrons per atom: \(0.0746/3 = 0.0249\) mol Al \(\times 26.98 = 0.671\) g. Reduction happens at the cathode, even in an electrolytic cell.
Unit recap
Unit recap
0:00 / 0:00
Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to
have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play
counts as your one free video.
Free preview complete
That's the end of the free preview.
You've opened five lessons, which is
as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've
already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go
back to it.