AP Biology · Science

AP Biology

College-level biology, from the hydrogen bonds in a water molecule to the carbon flowing through an ecosystem, taught unit by unit to the College Board framework. Every lesson ends with practice problems that have full worked answers, and every unit ends with a 20-question quiz that mixes stimulus-based multiple choice with short free-response items scored against the real AP rubric. Exam format from 2027: this is a hybrid digital exam: multiple choice in Bluebook, free response handwritten in a paper booklet. Work the free-response practice on paper first, then either type your answer into the response box or photograph your page and have it read in for scoring.

3H EXAM 60 MCQ 6 FRQ 64 LESSONS 160 QUIZ QUESTIONS PREREQ: BIOLOGY + CHEM

Read the free lessons and the full lesson list for AP Biology

Free exam guides for AP Biology (9)

Course overview

What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.

AP Biology follows the eight units of the College Board course framework. Unit 7 (natural selection) is the heaviest at 13–20%, with Units 3 and 6 close behind at 12–16% each, so the lessons below give those units the most room. The exam is three hours: 60 multiple-choice questions in 90 minutes for the first half, then six free-response questions in 90 minutes for the second, two long questions worth 9 points each (interpreting and evaluating experimental results, and the same task with a graph you construct) and four short questions worth 4 points each (scientific investigation, conceptual analysis, analysis of a model or visual representation, and data analysis). Every unit below ends with a quiz of 15 multiple-choice questions and 5 short free-response questions, several of them built on described data sets, graphs, and models, with a writing space that scores against the four-point AP rubric and a model 4/4 response to compare against.

  • U1Chemistry of Life8–11%
  • U2Cell Structure and Function10–13%
  • U3Cellular Energetics12–16%
  • U4Cell Communication and Cell Cycle10–15%
  • U5Heredity8–11%
  • U6Gene Expression and Regulation12–16%
  • U7Natural Selection13–20%
  • U8Ecology10–15%

All eight units are open, 64 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a twenty-problem mixed review.

Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set, is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.

Lesson 1.1 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.1

Structure of water and hydrogen bonding

Life began in water, and most cells are still 70 to 95 percent water by mass. Water is not just filler. A molecule of only three atoms explains why a tree can lift water 100 meters without a pump, why sweating cools you, why a pond does not freeze solid, and why a water strider can stand on the surface. Every one of those facts traces back to the same two ideas: water molecules are polar, and polar molecules stick to each other with hydrogen bonds.

Learning objective · 1.1.A

Explain how the properties of water that result from its polarity and hydrogen bonding affect its biological function. Notice the verb: explain asks for the how or why, not just a list of properties. You will practice that skill all through this lesson.

A polar molecule

A water molecule is one oxygen atom covalently bonded to two hydrogen atoms at an angle of about 104.5°. Oxygen attracts the shared electrons more strongly than hydrogen does, so the electrons spend more time near the oxygen. That makes each O–H bond a polar covalent bond: a partial negative charge (δ−) on the oxygen and a partial positive charge (δ+) on each hydrogen. Because the molecule is bent, the charges do not cancel. One side of the molecule is slightly negative and the other slightly positive, so the whole molecule is polar. (Carbon dioxide, by contrast, is a straight line with two polar bonds pointing opposite ways. The charges cancel and CO2 is nonpolar.)

One molecule: polar covalent bondsOHH104.5°δ−δ+δ+Oxygen pulls the shared electronsharder than hydrogen does.Many molecules: hydrogen bondsδ−δ+δ+- - - hydrogen bondEach bond is weak and short-lived,but together they hold the liquid.
Figure 1.1a Left: the bent molecule is polar, δ− at the oxygen and δ+ at each hydrogen. Right: the δ+ hydrogen of one molecule is attracted to the δ− oxygen of its neighbor, so a molecule can donate two hydrogen bonds and accept two.
Definition

A hydrogen bond is the attraction between the δ+ hydrogen of one polar molecule and a δ− atom (in water, the oxygen) of another. A water molecule can donate two hydrogen bonds and accept two, so it can be linked to as many as four neighbors. Hydrogen bonds also form between and within biological molecules: they hold the two strands of DNA together and help fold proteins, as you will see later in this unit.

Covalent bondHydrogen bond
What it isTwo atoms share electronsAttraction between a δ+ hydrogen and a δ− oxygen or nitrogen
WhereInside a molecule (the O–H bonds of water)Between water molecules, or between and within biological molecules
StrengthStrong: about 460 kJ per mole for O–HWeak: about 20 kJ per mole in water, roughly one-twentieth as strong
LifetimeStays intact under cell conditionsConstantly breaks and re-forms, each lasting only picoseconds

One hydrogen bond is flimsy. But liquid water has an enormous number of them, and each molecule keeps swapping partners, so the liquid holds together while still flowing. Every property below is the combined effect of those many weak bonds.

Cohesion, adhesion, and surface tension

Definitions · EK 1.1.A.2
  • Cohesion: attraction between water molecules, from hydrogen bonds between them.
  • Adhesion: attraction between water and a different polar or charged surface, such as glass or the wall of a plant cell.
  • Surface tension: the resistance of the water surface to being stretched or broken. A molecule at the surface has no water above it, so it is pulled sideways and inward and the surface acts like a stretched skin.
Why a surface behaves like a skinbalancedno neighbors abovenet pull inwardWhat it lets an insect doinsect (denser than water)Legs press the surface down;the stretched film pushes back.Added soap or detergent breaks upthe hydrogen bonds and the insect sinks.
Figure 1.1b Left: a molecule in the interior is pulled equally in every direction, so the forces cancel. A molecule at the surface has no neighbors above it, so it is pulled sideways and inward, which makes the surface resist stretching. Right: that resistance is surface tension, a result of cohesion.

Surface tension is large in water, about 72 millinewtons per meter at 25 °C, higher than for most common liquids. It lets insects walk on ponds and lets a drop of water stand up as a dome instead of spreading flat. Anything that interferes with the hydrogen bonds at the surface lowers it. Soap and detergent molecules do exactly that.

glass tubedish of wateradhesionWater molecules are attracted to the polarglass wall, so the edge of the water climbs it.cohesionHydrogen bonds between water moleculesdrag the rest of the water up behind the edge.The narrower the tube, the higher the rise.
Figure 1.1c Capillary action needs both forces. Adhesion pulls the water at the wall upward; cohesion carries the water in the middle with it. A wax-coated (nonpolar) tube would give almost no rise, because wax has no partial charges for water to adhere to.

Cohesion and adhesion work as a team in plants. Water evaporates from leaf cells (transpiration), which pulls on the water column below. Cohesion keeps the chain of water molecules unbroken, and adhesion to the walls of the xylem keeps the column from slipping back down. The tallest redwoods lift water more than 100 meters this way, with no pump, powered by the evaporation of water from the leaves.

leaf cellswater vapor leaves (transpiration)Evaporation at the leafpulls on the whole chain.cohesionhydrogen bonds link themolecules into a chainadhesionwater sticks to thexylem wall, so the columndoes not slip backroot: water enters from the soil
Figure 1.1d Cohesion lets a column of water 100 m tall hang together as one unbroken chain. Adhesion to the xylem wall supports it. No pumping is needed: the energy that lifts the water comes from evaporation.
Worked example · Drops on a penny

A class counts how many drops of each liquid a penny can hold before the liquid spills over the edge. They use the same dropper, the same penny, and the same temperature for every trial. Distilled water is the control. Five trials each:

LiquidTrial 12345Mean2 × SEM
Distilled water242723262525.0±1.4
Salt solution263025272727.0±1.7
Soapy water9121081110.0±1.4

Step 1, name the variables. The independent variable is the type of liquid. The dependent variable is the number of drops the penny holds. Distilled water is the control, the baseline the other liquids are compared with.

Step 2, describe the result. Soapy water held a mean of 10 drops compared with 25 for water, which is 60 percent fewer.

Step 3, explain it. Detergent molecules push in between water molecules at the surface and disrupt the hydrogen bonds that hold the surface together. With weaker cohesion, the surface tension drops, the drop can no longer stand up as a dome, and the penny holds fewer drops.

Step 4, evaluate the salt result. The means differ (27 against 25), but the intervals of mean ± 2 × SEM overlap: 23.6 to 26.4 for water and 25.3 to 28.7 for the salt solution. These data do not show a real difference. A sentence that claims salt “increases surface tension” would not be supported without more trials. The soap result is different: 8.6 to 11.4 does not come near 23.6 to 26.4.

Heat: specific heat capacity and heat of vaporization

Heat is energy transferred between objects, measured in joules. Temperature measures the average kinetic energy of the molecules. They are different quantities, and water is unusual in how much heat it can absorb for a small change in temperature.

Formula · EK 1.1.A.1.ii

The specific heat capacity \(c\) of a substance is the heat needed to raise 1 g of it by 1 °C. Water's value is \(4.18\) J/g·°C, among the highest of common substances. \[ q = mc\Delta T \] \(q\) is heat in joules, \(m\) is mass in grams, and \(\Delta T\) is the change in temperature in °C. Water's high value exists because heat added to water first goes into breaking hydrogen bonds, not just into making molecules move faster, so the temperature rises slowly. As water cools, hydrogen bonds re-form and release that energy back, so the temperature falls slowly. The result is thermal stability: cells, bodies, ponds, and oceans resist rapid temperature change.

102030405001,0002,0003,0004,000Heat absorbed by 100 g (J)Temperature rise (°C)26.1 °C8.57 °C5.00 °CDry sand, c = 0.80Ethanol, c = 2.44Water, c = 4.182,090 J
Figure 1.1e Each line is \(\Delta T = q / (mc)\) for 100 g. A higher specific heat gives a flatter line: water absorbs more energy for each degree of warming. At the dashed line (2,090 J) water warms 5.00 °C, ethanol 8.57 °C and sand 26.1 °C.
Worked example · Same heat, two liquids

100.0 g of water and 100.0 g of ethanol (\(c = 2.44\) J/g·°C) each absorb 2090 J. Find \(\Delta T\) for each and explain the difference.

\[ \Delta T = \frac{q}{mc} = \frac{2090}{(100.0)(4.18)} = 5.00\ ^\circ\mathrm{C}\quad\text{(water)} \] \[ \Delta T = \frac{2090}{(100.0)(2.44)} = 8.57\ ^\circ\mathrm{C}\quad\text{(ethanol)} \] Ethanol warms about 1.7 times as much. To explain rather than only describe, add the reason: each water molecule can form up to four hydrogen bonds while an ethanol molecule can form fewer, so more of the 2090 J is used to break hydrogen bonds in water and less is left to speed up its molecules.

Definition · EK 1.1.A.1.iii

The heat of vaporization is the heat needed to change 1 g of a liquid into a gas at constant temperature. For water it is about 2260 J/g at 100 °C and about 2400 J/g at the temperature of skin, much higher than most liquids, because a molecule can only escape into the air after nearly all of its hydrogen bonds are broken. Evaporative cooling follows: the fastest, highest-energy molecules are the ones that escape, and they carry their energy with them, so the liquid left behind is cooler. Sweating, panting, and transpiration from leaves all cool an organism this way.

0255075100125050100150200250Energy absorbed by 100 g of water (kJ)Temperature (°C)liquid warms41.8 kJvaporization: 226 kJtemperature stays at 100 °C while hydrogen bonds breaksteam
Figure 1.1f Warming 100 g of water from 0 to 100 °C takes 41.8 kJ. Turning the same 100 g into vapor takes 226 kJ, about 5.4 times as much, with no temperature change. This large energy cost is the high heat of vaporization that makes evaporative cooling work.
Worked example · What a quarter liter of sweat can do

A runner evaporates 250 g of sweat. Using 2400 J/g, how much heat leaves the body, and by how many degrees would that heat have raised the temperature of a 70 kg body (specific heat about 3.5 J/g·°C)?

\[ q = (250\ \mathrm{g})(2400\ \mathrm{J/g}) = 6.00 \times 10^{5}\ \mathrm{J} = 600\ \mathrm{kJ} \] \[ \Delta T = \frac{q}{mc} = \frac{6.00 \times 10^{5}}{(70\,000)(3.5)} = 2.4\ ^\circ\mathrm{C} \] Evaporating a quarter liter of sweat removes enough heat to offset a 2.4 °C rise. This is one way the body keeps its temperature steady (homeostasis). On a humid day the air already holds a lot of water vapor, so sweat evaporates more slowly, less heat leaves, and the same exercise feels hotter.

Two more properties you will meet again

The CED does not list these under topic 1.1, but the rest of the course relies on them. Ice floats. In ice, each molecule is held by four stable hydrogen bonds in an open lattice, which keeps the molecules slightly farther apart than in the liquid, so ice is about 8 percent less dense (0.92 g/cm3 against 1.00). A lake freezes from the top down, and the ice layer insulates the water beneath it. Water is an excellent solvent for ions and polar molecules. Their charges attract water molecules, which surround them and pull them apart. Substances that mix with water are hydrophilic; nonpolar substances such as oils do not mix and are hydrophobic. That single contrast is why cell membranes form (Unit 2) and why proteins fold the way they do (lesson 1.7).

Exam focus
  • A three-part explanation earns the point. (1) Name the property. (2) Give the molecular cause: polarity leads to hydrogen bonds. (3) Give the biological consequence. “Water has a high specific heat, which keeps body temperature stable” names the property and the consequence but skips the cause.
  • Get the cause in the right direction. Water forms hydrogen bonds because it is polar. It is not polar because it has hydrogen bonds.
  • Do not mix up the two bonds. The bond between O and H inside a molecule is covalent. The hydrogen bond is between molecules.
  • Cohesion is water to water; adhesion is water to something else.
  • Heat is not temperature. Say “absorbs a lot of heat with a small temperature change.”
Practice
  1. Explain why a water strider can stand on the surface of a pond without sinking. Use the term hydrogen bond in your answer.
    Show answer

    Water molecules at the surface form hydrogen bonds with the molecules beside and below them but have no water molecules above. The pull is sideways and inward, so the surface resists stretching, an effect called surface tension (a result of cohesion). The strider's legs press the surface down, and the stretched film pushes back strongly enough to support the insect. Naming the property alone is a description; naming the hydrogen bonds is the explanation.

  2. Describe the roles of cohesion and adhesion in moving water up the xylem of a tall tree.
    Show answer

    Evaporation of water from the leaves pulls on the water column in the xylem. Cohesion, the hydrogen bonding between water molecules, keeps the column as one unbroken chain, so water at the bottom is pulled up when water at the top leaves. Adhesion, the attraction between water and the polar walls of the xylem, helps hold the column up and keeps it from slipping back. The energy that lifts the water comes from evaporation, not from the plant pumping.

  3. A 400 g sample of pond water (\(c = 4.18\) J/g·°C) and a 400 g sample of dry sand (\(c = 0.80\) J/g·°C) each absorb 5000 J. Calculate the temperature change of each and state which has the higher specific heat.
    Show answer

    Water: \(\Delta T = 5000 / (400 \times 4.18) = 2.99\) °C. Sand: \(\Delta T = 5000 / (400 \times 0.80) = 15.6\) °C. Water has the higher specific heat: it warms by only about one-fifth as much as sand for the same heat input, because much of the energy goes into breaking hydrogen bonds.

  4. Predict how the yearly temperature range (hottest month minus coldest month) of a coastal city compares with a city at the same latitude far inland, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Prediction: the coastal city has the smaller range. Justification: the nearby ocean is water with a high specific heat capacity, so it absorbs a large amount of heat in summer with a small rise in temperature and releases heat slowly in winter. Winds from the water moderate the coast, while the inland land surface warms and cools much faster.

  5. A student heats 100 g of water at a constant rate and records its temperature. Describe the pattern and explain the data between minutes 8 and 16.
    Time (min)0246810121416
    Temperature (°C)20406080100100100100100
    Show answer

    Description: the temperature rises steadily by 10 °C per minute (20 °C each 2 minutes) from 20 °C to 100 °C at minute 8, then stays at 100 °C from minute 8 to minute 16. Explanation: at 100 °C the added energy is no longer raising the molecules' kinetic energy. It is being used to break the hydrogen bonds between water molecules so they can escape as vapor. This large energy cost is water's high heat of vaporization, so the temperature stays constant until the liquid has boiled away.

  6. A student coats the inside of a glass capillary tube with a nonpolar wax and stands it in water beside an untreated tube. Predict how far the water rises in the waxed tube compared with the untreated tube, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Prediction: the water rises much less in the waxed tube, and may not rise at all. Justification: capillary rise depends on adhesion, the attraction between the δ+ hydrogens of water and the δ− oxygens of the polar glass. Wax is nonpolar and has no partial charges, so water cannot adhere to the wall. Cohesion alone holds the water together but gives it nothing to climb. A prediction without a named mechanism is only a guess; the justification point requires the link to hydrogen bonding.

Lesson 1.2 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.2

Elements of life

About 90 elements occur naturally, yet living things are built mostly from six of them. Everything a cell makes, from a sugar to a strand of DNA, is assembled from these atoms, and which of them a molecule contains tells you a great deal about what kind of molecule it is. That is more than trivia: scientists have used it as a tool, as you will see in the Hershey–Chase experiment below.

Learning objective · 1.2.A

Describe the composition of the macromolecules required by living organisms: which elements make up carbohydrates, lipids, proteins, and nucleic acids.

Six elements do almost everything

ElementSymbolApproximate share of human body mass
OxygenO65%
CarbonC18%
HydrogenH10%
NitrogenN3%
PhosphorusP1%
SulfurS0.25%

These six, remembered as CHNOPS, add up to about 97 percent of body mass. Calcium (about 1.5 percent) is next, but it is found mainly in bones and teeth and is not a building block of the four classes of macromolecules. Oxygen and hydrogen rank so high mostly because the body is mostly water.

Which element goes into which molecule

Required content · EK 1.2.A.1

Carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen are the most prevalent elements in the building of carbohydrates, lipids, proteins, and nucleic acids. Beyond those three: sulfur is used in building proteins, phosphorus in phospholipids and nucleic acids, and nitrogen in nucleic acids. (Every amino acid also has an amino group, so proteins contain nitrogen as well. The CED lists it with nucleic acids because that is where the nitrogenous bases are.)

MacromoleculeCHONPS
Carbohydrates●●●
Fats and steroids●●●
Phospholipids●●●some●
Proteins●●●●some
Nucleic acids●●●●●

In the table, “some” means that many phospholipid head groups contain nitrogen (choline, for example) and that only some amino acids contain sulfur (cysteine and methionine). Two elements are especially useful as markers. Phosphorus is in DNA and RNA (in every phosphate of the backbone) but not in proteins. Sulfur is in some proteins (the amino acids cysteine and methionine) but not in DNA.

Why carbon is the backbone

A carbon atom has four electrons in its outer shell, so it forms four covalent bonds. It can bond to hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and other elements, and also to other carbon atoms. That last ability matters most: carbon atoms link into chains, branches, and rings of nearly any length, with single or double bonds between them. The bonds are strong and stable, which suits molecules that must last in a warm, watery cell. The carbon–carbon and carbon–hydrogen bonds are also nonpolar, which matters for lipids and for the cores of folded proteins.

HHHHCfour covalent bondsmethane, CH4chainunbranched backbonebranchedringclosed loop of carbonsIn the three skeletons, each dot is a carbon atom; the hydrogens are not drawn.
Figure 1.2a Because carbon forms four stable covalent bonds, it can build chains, branches and rings of almost any size. These carbon skeletons are the frames that every carbohydrate, lipid, protein and nucleic acid is built on.

Functional groups: what the atoms attached to the skeleton do

A bare carbon skeleton is not very reactive. What a molecule does depends largely on the functional groups attached to it: small clusters of atoms that behave the same way wherever they appear. A hydroxyl group makes a molecule polar and able to hydrogen-bond whether it sits on a sugar or on a nucleic acid.

Hydroxylpolar; hydrogen-bondswith waterROHCarbonylpolar; found in sugars(aldehyde or ketone)RCR′OCarboxylacidic: loses H+to become COO−RCOHOAminobasic: gains H+to become NH3+RNHHSulfhydryltwo can link into adisulfide bridgeRSHPhosphatenegatively charged;in ATP and DNAROPO−O−OMethylnonpolar;hydrophobicRCH3R = the rest of the molecule(the carbon skeleton)
Figure 1.2b A functional group is a small cluster of atoms that gives any molecule carrying it the same chemical behavior. For this course, know the carboxyl and amino groups (every amino acid), the phosphate group (nucleotides and phospholipids) and the hydroxyl group (the 3′ end of a nucleic acid).
Where you will meet them
  • Hydroxyl (−OH): polar and hydrogen-bonding; on sugars and on the 3′ end of every nucleic acid (lesson 1.6).
  • Carbonyl (C=O): polar; sugars are aldehydes or ketones (lesson 1.4).
  • Carboxyl (−COOH): acidic; in every amino acid and fatty acid.
  • Amino (−NH2): basic; in every amino acid, so every protein has one at its N-terminus (lesson 1.7).
  • Sulfhydryl (−SH): two of these can join into a disulfide bridge that holds a protein's shape (lesson 1.7).
  • Phosphate: negatively charged; in nucleotides, phospholipids, and ATP.
  • Methyl (−CH3): nonpolar; makes a region hydrophobic.

The exam does not ask you to draw these structures. Know the names, the properties, and where each one shows up.

Worked example · Hershey–Chase: an element as a tag

In 1952 Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase asked whether protein or DNA carries a virus's genetic information. A bacteriophage is a virus that infects bacteria: a protein coat around a DNA core. They grew one batch of phages with radioactive sulfur (35S) and a second batch with radioactive phosphorus (32P). Each batch infected bacteria. After a few minutes they agitated the mixture in a blender to shake the empty phage coats off the cells, then spun it in a centrifuge so the heavy bacterial cells formed a pellet and the lighter coats stayed in the liquid above (the supernatant).

Why those two elements? Protein contains sulfur but no phosphorus; DNA contains phosphorus but no sulfur. So 35S tags only protein and 32P tags only DNA. The independent variable is which radioactive element was used; the dependent variable is where the radioactivity was found afterward.

Result. In the 35S experiment most of the radioactivity stayed in the supernatant, with the empty protein coats. In the 32P experiment most of it was in the pellet, inside the bacteria. Conclusion. It was the phage DNA, not its protein, that entered the bacteria and directed the making of new viruses, so DNA is the genetic material. The reasoning depends entirely on a fact from this lesson: phosphorus marks nucleic acid and sulfur marks protein.

Worked example · Which class is it?

An analysis reports the composition by mass of one small molecule from each class of macromolecule. Name the class of each from the elements present, and explain how you can tell.

MoleculeCHONPS
A40.06.753.3000
B75.912.211.9000
C29.75.826.411.6026.5
D36.34.329.021.19.40

D contains both nitrogen and phosphorus, and nucleic acids are the class that contains both along with C, H, and O, so D is a nucleotide. C contains nitrogen and sulfur, which together point to protein (an amino acid with sulfur, cysteine). A and B both contain only C, H, and O, so you need the proportions. In A the H to O atom ratio is 2 to 1 (6.7 / 1.008 : 53.3 / 15.999 is about 6.6 : 3.3), the same as in water, which is the signature of a carbohydrate; it is glucose. In B oxygen is only 11.9 percent and hydrogen 12.2 percent, so there are about 16 hydrogens for each oxygen. A molecule that is mostly carbon and hydrogen with very little oxygen is nonpolar and energy-rich: a fat (this one is tripalmitin).

Careful: phosphorus alone does not prove a nucleic acid, because phospholipids contain phosphorus too. A phospholipid would also show a very high carbon content and little nitrogen, so check the proportions.

Exam focus
  • Learn the markers: P for nucleic acids (and phospholipids), S for proteins, N for proteins and nucleic acids, only C, H, O for carbohydrates and fats.
  • A question that shows an elemental analysis or a radioactive-tracer experiment is asking you to match elements to molecules. Name the element, then name the macromolecule that contains it.
  • When you describe an experiment like Hershey–Chase, always state what was measured (where the radioactivity ended up) and what the result means.
Practice
  1. Name the elements found in (a) a triglyceride, (b) a protein that contains cysteine, (c) a molecule of DNA, and (d) a phospholipid.
    Show answer

    (a) Carbon, hydrogen, oxygen only. (b) Carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur (the sulfur comes from cysteine). (c) Carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and phosphorus. (d) Carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and phosphorus, plus nitrogen in many head groups such as choline.

  2. Bacteria are grown on a medium whose only phosphorus is radioactive 32P, then the cell contents are separated into classes of macromolecules. Which classes will contain radioactivity, and which will not? Justify your answer.
    Show answer

    Nucleic acids (DNA and RNA) and phospholipids will be radioactive, because both contain phosphorus (in the phosphate groups of the nucleotide backbone and in the phospholipid head). Proteins, carbohydrates, and fats will not, because they contain no phosphorus. Naming the element in each class is the justification.

  3. An unknown compound is 32.0% carbon, 6.7% hydrogen, 18.7% nitrogen, and 42.6% oxygen by mass, with no phosphorus or sulfur. Can it be a nucleic acid? Can it be a protein? Justify each answer.
    Show answer

    It cannot be a nucleic acid: nucleic acids contain phosphorus and this compound has none. It could be a protein (or an amino acid): it contains nitrogen as an amino group requires, and the missing sulfur does not rule out a protein, because only some amino acids contain sulfur. (The compound is glycine, C2H5NO2.)

  4. A carbon atom in the middle of a carbon chain is bonded to two neighboring carbons by single bonds. How many hydrogens can attach to it? What happens to that number if one of its bonds to a neighbor becomes a double bond? Explain.
    Show answer

    Two hydrogens, because carbon always forms four covalent bonds: two to carbon neighbors plus two to hydrogen. If one bond to a neighbor becomes a double bond, that carbon now has three bonds to carbon, leaving room for only one hydrogen. This is why a fatty acid with C=C double bonds holds fewer hydrogens than one with only single bonds (lesson 1.5).

  5. An amino acid has a carboxyl group and an amino group. Predict whether it can act as an acid, a base, or both, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Both. The carboxyl group is acidic: it can release H+ and become −COO−. The amino group is basic: it can accept H+ and become −NH3+. Because one molecule carries a group of each kind, it can donate or accept a proton depending on the pH of its surroundings.

Lesson 1.3 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.3

Introduction to macromolecules

Cells need molecules far larger than water or glucose: enzymes, DNA, cell walls, and energy stores. Instead of inventing a new giant structure for each job, cells build large molecules by linking many small, similar ones, the way a long necklace is strung from beads. The small units are monomers. A chain of many of them is a polymer, and a very large polymer is a macromolecule. Joining and splitting monomers follows the same two chemical reactions every time, and this lesson is about those reactions.

Learning objective · 1.3.A

Describe the chemical reactions that build and break biological macromolecules.

Four classes, one set of reactions

ClassMonomerPolymerBond that joins them
CarbohydratesMonosaccharide (simple sugar)PolysaccharideGlycosidic linkage
ProteinsAmino acidPolypeptidePeptide bond
Nucleic acidsNucleotideDNA or RNA strandPhosphodiester bond
LipidsNot true polymers: built from smaller parts such as glycerol and fatty acidsEster linkage (in fats)

Notice that lipids do not fit the monomer and polymer pattern. A fat is assembled from one glycerol and three fatty acids, which are not repeating copies of one unit, so a fat is not a polymer. The reaction that builds it is still the same one.

Dehydration synthesis and hydrolysis

monomerOH+Hmonomermonomermonomer+H2Ocovalent bondDehydration synthesiswater is removed, a bond formsHydrolysiswater is added, the bond breaks
Figure 1.3a Forward: an OH (hydroxyl) is removed from one monomer and an H from the other. Together they leave as H2O, and a covalent bond joins the two monomers. Reverse: water is added across the bond; the H goes to one monomer and the OH to the other.
Rule · EK 1.3.A.2

Dehydration synthesis joins two smaller molecules by a covalent bond. A hydroxyl group (−OH) is removed from one monomer and a hydrogen (−H) from the other. Together they form a water molecule, so the reaction releases H2O, and the two monomers are now connected. Repeating it many times is polymerization. The name says what happens: de-hydration means water is taken out.

Rule · EK 1.3.A.1

Hydrolysis is the reverse: it breaks a covalent bond between monomers by adding water. The hydrogen of the water molecule goes to one monomer and the hydroxyl to the other, restoring both. The name means water (hydro) is used to split (lysis) the bond. Digestion is hydrolysis: enzymes in your gut break the polymers in food into monomers small enough to absorb.

Dehydration synthesisHydrolysis
WaterReleased (a product)Added (a reactant)
Covalent bondFormedBroken
Size of moleculesSmaller molecules become largerLarger molecules become smaller
EnergyNeeds an input of energy (cells use ATP)Releases energy
ExampleAmino acids → polypeptide; glucose → starchDigesting protein in the stomach; breaking down glycogen

Both directions need enzymes (Unit 3) to proceed at a useful rate in a cell. Hydrolysis releases energy, but the bonds are stable, so without an enzyme the reaction would take far too long.

Counting water and mass

Each bond formed in a linear polymer releases one water, so joining \(n\) monomers by \(n-1\) bonds releases \(n-1\) water molecules. That gives the mass of the polymer:

Formula

\[ M_{\text{polymer}} = n\,M_{\text{monomer}} - (n-1)(18.02) \] \(M\) is molar mass in g/mol and 18.02 g/mol is the molar mass of water. The polymer is lighter than the sum of its monomers because \(n-1\) waters were removed. Hydrolysis of the same linear polymer back into \(n\) monomers consumes \(n-1\) water molecules. (A circular polymer, such as a bacterial chromosome, has \(n\) bonds instead.)

Worked example · The mass of a short polypeptide

A cell links 20 glycine monomers (\(M = 75.07\) g/mol) into one linear polypeptide. Find the number of waters released and the molar mass of the polypeptide.

Bonds and water. 20 monomers joined in a line make \(20 - 1 = 19\) peptide bonds, so 19 water molecules are released.
Mass. \[ M = (20)(75.07) - (19)(18.02) = 1501.4 - 342.38 = 1159.02 \approx 1.16 \times 10^{3}\ \mathrm{g/mol} \] The polymer is 22.8 percent lighter than the 20 free glycines (1501.4 g/mol). If it were hydrolyzed completely, 19 water molecules would be added back and the result would be 20 free glycine molecules.

Worked example · A fat is built the same way

A triglyceride forms from one glycerol (\(M = 92.09\) g/mol) and three palmitic acid molecules (\(M = 256.43\) g/mol each). How many waters are released, and what is the molar mass of the fat?

Each fatty acid joins the glycerol through its own bond, so \(3\) waters are released. \[ M = 92.09 + 3(256.43) - 3(18.02) = 92.09 + 769.29 - 54.06 = 807.32\ \mathrm{g/mol} \] This matches the known molar mass of tripalmitin, 807.3 g/mol. The same arithmetic worked even though a fat is not a polymer, because the reaction is the same.

Exam focus
  • Say where the water goes. Dehydration synthesis releases water; hydrolysis uses water. A common error is to say a water molecule is “lost” in hydrolysis.
  • Say which atoms are involved. The H and the OH come from the two monomers being joined, not from somewhere else. In hydrolysis the H and the OH of the added water go to the two new ends.
  • Reading a diagram (the “describe the visual representation” skill): look at the arrow's direction, whether H2O is on the left or right, and whether the monomers end up joined or separated.
  • Do not call a fat a polymer.
Practice
  1. Two glucose molecules react to form maltose and one water molecule. Name the reaction, say which atoms form the water, and state what happens to the covalent bonds.
    Show answer

    The reaction is dehydration synthesis. The water is formed from the −OH of one glucose and a −H from the other. A new covalent bond forms between the two glucose units (a glycosidic linkage), which makes the disaccharide maltose. The reverse reaction, hydrolysis, would add one water and break that bond.

  2. A cell assembles a linear polypeptide from 50 alanine monomers (\(M = 89.09\) g/mol). How many peptide bonds form, and what is the molar mass of the polypeptide?
    Show answer

    50 monomers make \(50 - 1 = 49\) peptide bonds, releasing 49 waters. \(M = (50)(89.09) - (49)(18.02) = 4454.5 - 882.98 = 3571.52 \approx 3.57 \times 10^{3}\) g/mol.

  3. A linear strand of DNA contains 240 nucleotides. How many water molecules are needed to hydrolyze it completely into free nucleotides?
    Show answer

    The strand has \(240 - 1 = 239\) bonds between nucleotides, and hydrolysis breaks each one by adding one water molecule, so 239 waters are needed.

  4. A researcher blocks the enzyme that catalyzes hydrolysis of glycogen in liver cells. Predict the effect on the release of glucose into the blood, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Prediction: less glucose is released, and blood glucose would fall during fasting. Justification: glycogen is a polymer of glucose, and glucose is freed from it only by hydrolysis of the bonds between units. With the enzyme blocked, the bonds are not broken at a useful rate, so few glucose monomers are produced.

  5. Fats are made by dehydration synthesis, yet lipids are not called polymers. Explain.
    Show answer

    Fats are built by dehydration synthesis: each of three fatty acids bonds to glycerol, with a water released at each ester linkage. But a polymer is a chain of many repeating, similar monomers, and a fat is only one glycerol and three fatty acids, which are different kinds of molecule and are not repeated into a long chain. So the reaction is the same, but a fat is not a polymer.

Lesson 1.4 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.4

Carbohydrates

Every cell runs on sugar, and many organisms are built from it. Plants wrap each cell in a wall made of a sugar polymer, and animals store sugar in the liver and muscles for later. All of these are carbohydrates, and the lesson is about a single idea: the same sugar monomer, joined in different patterns, gives molecules with completely different jobs.

Learning objective · 1.4.A

Describe the structure and function of carbohydrates. The required statement (EK 1.4.A.1): monosaccharides are the monomers of polysaccharides, joined by covalent bonds, and the polymers may be linear or branched. Examples named by the CED: cellulose, starch, and glycogen.

Monosaccharides and the molecules built from them

A monosaccharide is a simple sugar. Its general formula is \((\mathrm{CH_2O})_n\), which is where the name “carbo-hydrate” (carbon plus water) comes from. Glucose, fructose, and galactose all have the formula C6H12O6 but differ in how the atoms are arranged, so they behave differently. The five-carbon sugars ribose and deoxyribose are part of RNA and DNA (lesson 1.6). Sugar names end in -ose.

Building up
  • Monosaccharide: one sugar unit (glucose, fructose, galactose).
  • Disaccharide: two units joined by dehydration synthesis. Sucrose is glucose + fructose, lactose is glucose + galactose, and maltose is glucose + glucose.
  • Polysaccharide: many units joined in a chain. The bond between sugar units is a glycosidic linkage.
O12345OHHOHOCH2OHOHα-glucoseOH on carbon 1 points down(hashed bond)O12345OHHOHOCH2OHOHβ-glucoseOH on carbon 1 points up(solid wedge)
Figure 1.4a The two ring forms of glucose are identical except for the −OH on carbon 1. When glucose units link into a chain, that one difference changes the shape of the polymer: α linkages give the coiled, digestible structure of starch and glycogen, β linkages give the straight, rigid chains of cellulose. You do not need to draw these on the exam.

Glucose exists mainly as a ring. In the ring form it comes in two versions, α (alpha) and β (beta), that differ only in which way the −OH on carbon 1 points. That small difference changes the shape of any chain built from it, which turns out to separate starch from cellulose. (The CED states that the molecular structure of specific carbohydrate polymers is beyond the scope of the exam. Know the idea, not the drawing.)

Three polysaccharides, one monomer

Starchplants store energycoiled, few branches(α linkages)Glycogenanimals store energyhighly branched: many ends(α linkages)Celluloseplant cell wallsstraight chains, bundledby hydrogen bonds (β linkages)= one glucose unit- - - hydrogen bonds between chains
Figure 1.4b All three are polymers of glucose, yet they behave very differently because of how the units are linked and arranged. Branching puts many chain ends in one place, which suits fast release of glucose; straight, bundled chains suit strength.
PolysaccharideFound inFunctionStructure that fits the job
StarchPlants (roots, seeds, tubers)Stores energyCoiled chains with only a few branches; easily broken down by enzymes
GlycogenAnimals and fungi; stored mainly in the liver and muscleStores energy for quick useVery highly branched (a branch about every 10 units), so there are many free ends for enzymes to work from at once
CellulosePlant cell wallsProvides structural supportLong straight chains lying side by side and held together by many hydrogen bonds; rigid and strong

Storage versus structure. Starch and glycogen must be taken apart quickly when the cell needs energy, so they are coiled or branched and easy to reach. Cellulose must not be taken apart, so it is straight, tightly bundled, and hard for most organisms to digest. Humans can digest starch but not cellulose, because our enzymes cannot break the β linkages between cellulose's glucose units. Cellulose passes through us as dietary fiber. Cows can live on cellulose because microbes in their stomachs make an enzyme that can.

Worked example · Why branching matters

Two glucose polymers each contain 10,000 glucose units. Polymer A is unbranched. Polymer B has a branch every 10 units, like glycogen. In a simple model, an enzyme can remove one glucose per second from each free end, and one enzyme can work at each free end at the same time. Compare how long each polymer takes to break down completely.

Count the ends. The unbranched polymer has 1 free end. Each branch point creates one more free end. Polymer B has \(10{,}000 / 10 = 1000\) branch points, so \(1000 + 1 = 1001\) free ends.
Time. A: \(10{,}000\) glucose \(\div\) 1 end \(= 10{,}000\) s, nearly 2.8 hours. B: \(10{,}000 \div 1001 = 9.99\) s.
Conclusion. The branched polymer breaks down about 1000 times faster. This is why animals store glucose as glycogen: when an animal needs energy, many enzymes can release glucose at once. The model is simplified, since real enzymes are not this tidy, but the relationship between branches, ends, and speed is the point.

Worked example · Why can a cow live on grass and a person cannot?

Grass is mostly cellulose. Answer in three parts: a claim, the evidence, and the reasoning.

Claim. A cow can obtain energy from cellulose; a human cannot.
Evidence. Cellulose and starch are both polymers of glucose, yet humans digest starch (bread, rice) and cellulose passes through them undigested as fiber.
Reasoning. To use a polysaccharide, an organism must hydrolyze the linkages between its glucose units, and the enzyme that does so is specific to the type of linkage. Starch has α linkages, which human enzymes cleave. Cellulose has β linkages, which human enzymes cannot cleave. Cows host microbes in their stomachs that make an enzyme (cellulase) that does cleave β linkages, so the cow's microbes release glucose and other products the cow uses. Answers that only say “cows have four stomachs” do not earn the reasoning point: the explanation must be about the linkage and the enzyme.

Exam focus
  • Tie structure to function. Do not just list the three polysaccharides. Say why each shape suits its job (branched for fast release, straight and bundled for strength).
  • Starch, glycogen, and cellulose are all made of glucose. The difference is how the units are linked and arranged, not what the units are.
  • Bookkeeping: a linear polysaccharide of \(n\) glucose units has the formula C6nH10n+2O5n+1 (the glucose atoms minus \(n-1\) water molecules).
  • You are not asked to draw the structure of a specific carbohydrate.
Practice
  1. Starch and cellulose are both polymers of glucose. Explain why a human can use starch but not cellulose as a source of glucose.
    Show answer

    The two polymers differ in the linkage between glucose units: starch has α linkages and cellulose has β linkages. The enzymes that hydrolyze these bonds are specific to the type of linkage. Human digestive enzymes cleave the α linkages of starch but cannot cleave the β linkages of cellulose, so cellulose passes through undigested as fiber.

  2. Explain how the structure of glycogen makes it well suited to rapid release of glucose.
    Show answer

    Glycogen is highly branched, with a branch about every 10 glucose units. Every branch creates another free end, and enzymes remove glucose from the ends, so a highly branched molecule has many ends where many enzymes can work at once. Glucose can be released very quickly when the cell or animal needs energy.

  3. A glycogen molecule has 4000 glucose units with a branch every 8 units. In the model of the worked example (one glucose removed per second per free end), how many free ends does it have, and how long would complete breakdown take compared with an unbranched polymer of the same size?
    Show answer

    Branch points: \(4000 / 8 = 500\). Free ends: \(500 + 1 = 501\). Time: \(4000 / 501 = 7.98\) s, compared with \(4000 / 1 = 4000\) s for the unbranched polymer, about 500 times faster.

  4. A linear polysaccharide is made of 100 glucose units (C6H12O6 each). Write its molecular formula and state how many water molecules are needed to hydrolyze it completely.
    Show answer

    Joining 100 glucose units by 99 dehydration reactions removes 99 H2O. Carbon: \(6 \times 100 = 600\). Hydrogen: \(12 \times 100 - 2 \times 99 = 1002\). Oxygen: \(6 \times 100 - 99 = 501\). The formula is C600H1002O501. Complete hydrolysis needs 99 water molecules.

  5. A student claims, “Plants use cellulose to store energy, just as animals use glycogen.” Evaluate this claim, and correct it if needed.
    Show answer

    The claim is incorrect. Plants store energy as starch; cellulose is the structural polysaccharide in plant cell walls. Cellulose has β linkages and forms straight, rigid, hydrogen-bonded bundles that give strength, and most organisms cannot digest it, which makes it a poor energy store. Starch is coiled with a few branches and is easily hydrolyzed when the plant needs glucose.

Lesson 1.5 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.5

Lipids

Oil and water do not mix, and that fact runs a surprising share of biology. Fat stores energy, hormones carry signals, and the membrane around every cell keeps the inside separate from the outside, all using molecules that avoid water. These are the lipids. Unlike the other three classes, lipids are not defined by a shared structure but by a shared behavior: they are mostly nonpolar and do not dissolve in water.

Learning objective · 1.5.A

Describe the structure and function of lipids. The required statements: lipids are typically nonpolar, hydrophobic molecules whose structure and function come from how their parts are assembled (EK 1.5.A.1); examples are fats, steroids including cholesterol, and phospholipids (EK 1.5.A.2). The CED notes that the molecular structure of specific lipids is beyond the scope of the exam.

Why lipids avoid water

Recall from lesson 1.1 that water dissolves things by attracting their partial charges. A lipid is mostly long chains of carbon and hydrogen, and a carbon–hydrogen bond is nonpolar: the electrons are shared almost equally, so there are no partial charges for water to attract. Water molecules, which prefer to hydrogen-bond with each other, squeeze the nonpolar molecules together. Substances that behave this way are hydrophobic; substances that interact well with water are hydrophilic. Everything that follows is a consequence of that one difference.

Fats: energy storage

OCOOCOOCOglycerolester linkages3 bonds, each made by dehydration synthesisthree fatty acid tails(nonpolar, hydrophobic)glycerol + 3 fatty acids → triglyceride + 3 H2O
Figure 1.5b A fat (triglyceride) is not a polymer of repeating monomers. It is assembled from one glycerol and three fatty acids, releasing three water molecules. Long carbon-hydrogen tails make it nonpolar and give it its high energy content.

A fat (a triglyceride) is built from one glycerol and three fatty acids. A fatty acid is a long hydrocarbon tail with a carboxyl group at one end. Three dehydration synthesis reactions join the fatty acids to glycerol, releasing three waters, and each new bond is an ester linkage. Because the tails are long chains of C–H bonds, a fat is strongly hydrophobic and packed with stored chemical energy. Fat provides about 9 kilocalories per gram, compared with about 4 kcal per gram for carbohydrates and proteins. Fat also insulates (the blubber of marine mammals, the layer under the skin of humans) and cushions organs.

Saturated and unsaturated fatty acids

Required content · EK 1.5.A.1
  • Saturated fatty acids have only single bonds between carbon atoms. The chain is straight.
  • Unsaturated fatty acids have at least one carbon–carbon double bond, which makes the chain kink (bend).
  • The more double bonds in the tails, the more unsaturated the lipid.
  • The more unsaturated a lipid is, the more liquid it is at room temperature.
Saturated fatty acid (stearic acid, 18 carbons)HOOCno C=C: every carbon holds as manyhydrogens as it can, so the tail is straightUnsaturated fatty acid (oleic acid, one C=C)HOOCcis C=Cone double bond bends the tail:the carbons on either side sit on thesame side of the double bondStraight tails pack tightlysolid at room temperature (butter, lard)Kinked tails cannot pack tightlyliquid at room temperature (oils)
Figure 1.5a A double bond (C=C) in the carbon tail makes the chain bend. The more double bonds a fatty acid has, the more kinks, the looser the packing, and the more liquid the fat is at room temperature. Blue dots are the polar carboxyl heads.

The word “saturated” refers to hydrogen: a saturated chain holds as many hydrogen atoms as its carbons can bond to. Every double bond removes two hydrogens from the chain (carbon always makes four bonds, lesson 1.2). Straight tails can lie side by side and pack tightly, so the molecules attract each other strongly and the fat is solid at room temperature (butter, lard). Kinked tails cannot pack closely, so the molecules slide past one another and the fat is liquid at room temperature (vegetable oils). Most animal fats are mostly saturated and most plant oils are mostly unsaturated.

-20020406080Melting point (°C)70Stearic0 C=C13Oleic1 C=C−5Linoleic2 C=C−11α-Linolenic3 C=Croom temperature, about 25 °C
Figure 1.5d All four fatty acids have 18 carbons; they differ only in the number of C=C double bonds. Each added double bond lowers the melting point. Only stearic acid, above the dashed room-temperature line, is a solid. Values are approximate.
Worked example · Reading a structure–function trend from data

The table gives approximate melting points of four fatty acids, all with an 18-carbon chain. Describe the trend, explain it, and predict what would happen to a liquid oil if hydrogen were added to its double bonds.

Fatty acidNumber of C=C double bondsMelting point (°C)
Stearic070
Oleic113
Linoleic2−5
α-Linolenic3−11

Describe. As the number of double bonds increases from 0 to 3, the melting point falls steadily from 70 °C to −11 °C. Only stearic acid is a solid at room temperature (about 25 °C); the other three melt below that temperature, so they are liquids.
Explain. Each double bond puts a kink in the chain. Straight (saturated) chains pack closely and need more energy (a higher temperature) to pull apart. Kinked chains cannot pack tightly, so less energy is needed to separate them and they melt at a lower temperature.
Predict. Adding hydrogen to an oil’s double bonds (hydrogenation) converts C=C into C–C, so the chains become straighter and pack more tightly. The oil would become more solid, which is how liquid oil is turned into margarine.

Phospholipids: the membrane builders

A phospholipid has a glycerol backbone, two fatty acid tails, and a phosphate-containing head in place of the third tail. The head is charged and hydrophilic and the tails are hydrophobic, so one molecule has two personalities. A molecule with both a hydrophilic and a hydrophobic region is amphipathic. In water, phospholipids arrange themselves so that the heads face the water and the tails face each other, away from it. The result is a lipid bilayer: the basic structure of the plasma membrane and of the membranes around organelles (Unit 2).

waterwaterhydrophilic headsface the waterhydrophobic tailsface each other,away from watercholesterol(animal cells)
Figure 1.5c Each phospholipid has a polar (hydrophilic) head and two nonpolar (hydrophobic) tails, so it is amphipathic. In water the molecules arrange themselves into a double layer with the tails hidden inside. Cholesterol sits between the tails of animal cell membranes and stabilizes them.

Steroids and cholesterol

Steroids do not look like fats. Their carbon skeleton is four connected rings, but they are still nonpolar and hydrophobic. Many hormones are steroids (estrogen, testosterone, and cortisol), and steroid hormones support growth and development, energy metabolism, and homeostasis. Cholesterol is a steroid found in the membranes of animal cells. It sits between the phospholipid tails and gives the membrane essential structural stability. Cholesterol is also the starting material for the cell to make other steroids.

LipidStructure in briefFunction (EK 1.5.A.2)
FatsGlycerol + 3 fatty acidsEnergy storage and cell function; insulation in some mammals
PhospholipidsGlycerol + 2 fatty acids + phosphate head (amphipathic)Form the lipid bilayer of plasma and cell membranes
SteroidsFour fused carbon ringsHormones that support growth, development, energy metabolism, and homeostasis
Cholesterol (a steroid)Four fused rings with a small hydroxyl groupStabilizes animal cell membranes
Worked example · Counting energy

A snack bar label lists 14 g fat, 6 g carbohydrate, and 6 g protein. Use 9 kcal/g for fat and 4 kcal/g for carbohydrate and protein to find the energy in the bar and the percent that comes from fat. Then: a migrating bird must carry 1800 kcal of stored energy. Glycogen provides about 4 kcal/g and holds about 2 g of water for every gram stored. Compare the mass of fat and of hydrated glycogen the bird would need.

The bar. \(14 \times 9 + 6 \times 4 + 6 \times 4 = 126 + 24 + 24 = 174\) kcal. Fat supplies \(126 / 174 = 72.4\) percent.
The bird, as fat. \(1800 / 9 = 200\) g.
The bird, as glycogen. \(1800 / 4 = 450\) g of glycogen, plus \(2 \times 450 = 900\) g of bound water, so \(1350\) g in all, which is \(1350 / 200 = 6.75\) times heavier than the fat. Per gram of dry mass, fat stores 2.25 times as much energy as glycogen (\(9/4\)), and because fat is hydrophobic it holds no water. That makes it the better fuel for a flying animal.

Worked example · Predict and justify

A few phospholipid molecules are shaken into a beaker of water. Predict what arrangement they form, and justify your prediction.

Prediction. The phospholipids form a bilayer (or, in small droplets, a ball of one layer) with the hydrophilic heads facing the water and the hydrophobic tails facing each other, away from the water.
Justification. The heads are charged or polar, so they form hydrogen bonds and other attractions with water and prefer to stay in contact with it. The tails are nonpolar and cannot interact with water, and the water's hydrogen bonding squeezes them away from it. The only arrangement that satisfies both is one with the heads outward and the tails buried together. A grader looks for both halves: the arrangement, and the hydrophilic/hydrophobic reason.

Exam focus
  • Lipid does not mean fat. Fats, phospholipids, and steroids are all lipids with different structures and functions. Match the function to the right type.
  • Saturated means no C=C and a straight tail. Unsaturated means at least one C=C and a kinked tail. Say “kink” and “packing” when you explain why unsaturated fats are liquid.
  • A question about a trend (more double bonds, lower melting point) wants all three steps: describe the trend, explain it with molecular packing, and use it to make a prediction.
  • Amphipathic molecules (phospholipids) are the reason membranes form: heads toward water, tails away.
  • Cholesterol is in animal cell membranes. It is a steroid, not a fat.
Practice
  1. Explain why lipids do not dissolve in water, using what you know about bonds and charge.
    Show answer

    Lipids consist mainly of carbon–hydrogen bonds, which are nonpolar because the electrons are shared almost equally, so lipids have no partial charges. Water dissolves a substance by attracting its charges. With nothing to attract, water cannot form hydrogen bonds with a lipid, and the water molecules, which hydrogen-bond with each other, push the lipid molecules together. The lipids are hydrophobic and stay separate.

  2. Describe how a saturated fatty acid differs from an unsaturated one, and explain why butter is solid and olive oil is liquid at room temperature.
    Show answer

    A saturated fatty acid has only single bonds between carbon atoms and a straight tail. An unsaturated fatty acid has at least one carbon–carbon double bond, which kinks the tail. Butter is rich in saturated fatty acids, whose straight tails pack tightly together, so it is solid at room temperature. Olive oil is rich in unsaturated fatty acids, whose kinked tails cannot pack closely, so the molecules move past one another and it is liquid.

  3. Identify the lipid described in each case: (a) forms the double layer around a cell; (b) stabilizes the membrane of an animal cell; (c) stored under the skin of a mammal for insulation and energy; (d) a hormone that regulates growth and development.
    Show answer

    (a) Phospholipids. (b) Cholesterol. (c) Fat (triglycerides). (d) A steroid hormone (such as estrogen or testosterone).

  4. A cold-water fish has more unsaturated fatty acids in its membranes than a warm-water fish. Predict what would happen to the fish’s membranes if they instead contained mostly saturated fatty acids, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Prediction: the membranes would become too stiff, nearly solid, in cold water. Justification: straight saturated tails pack tightly, so a membrane made of them gets more rigid as temperature falls. Kinked unsaturated tails cannot pack closely, which keeps the membrane fluid at low temperature. A membrane that is too stiff cannot function, so the fish needs unsaturated fatty acids in cold water.

  5. A nutrition label shows 5 g fat, 40 g carbohydrate, and 10 g protein. Calculate the total energy and the percent of the energy from fat (9 kcal/g for fat, 4 kcal/g for the others).
    Show answer

    Energy: \(5 \times 9 + 40 \times 4 + 10 \times 4 = 45 + 160 + 40 = 245\) kcal. Percent from fat: \(45 / 245 = 18.4\) percent.

Lesson 1.6 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.6

Nucleic acids

A cell has to store the instructions for building every protein it will ever need, copy them accurately each time it divides, and read them when a protein is needed. Nucleic acids do all of that. They store information in a very simple way: as a sequence. The order of four kinds of subunit along a strand is the message, much as the order of letters makes the words on this page. Every other topic in genetics depends on understanding the structure in this lesson.

Learning objective · 1.6.A

Describe the structure and function of DNA and RNA. The CED states that the molecular structure of specific nucleotides is beyond the scope of the exam. You should know the parts of a nucleotide and how they are arranged, not draw each base.

The nucleotide: three parts

The monomer of a nucleic acid is the nucleotide. Each nucleotide has a five-carbon sugar, a phosphate group, and a nitrogenous base. (EK 1.6.A.1)

O1′2′3′4′5′Pphosphatenitrogenous baseA, T, G, C (DNA)A, U, G, C (RNA)OH3′ hydroxylH or OH2′: H in DNA,OH in RNAfive-carbon sugardeoxyribose (DNA) or ribose (RNA)
Figure 1.6a Each nucleotide has three parts: a phosphate, a five-carbon sugar and a nitrogenous base. The carbons of the sugar are numbered 1′ to 5′ (read “one prime”). The two ends of a nucleic acid are named for the sugar carbon that is free: the phosphate on 5′ and the hydroxyl on 3′.
The five bases
  • Adenine (A) and guanine (G) are larger bases with two rings (purines).
  • Cytosine (C), thymine (T), and uracil (U) are smaller bases with one ring (pyrimidines).
  • DNA uses A, T, G, and C. RNA uses A, U, G, and C: uracil takes the place of thymine.

The sugar is deoxyribose in DNA and ribose in RNA. Ribose has an extra −OH on carbon 2′; deoxyribose has only a hydrogen there, which is why it is “deoxy.” The ′ symbol (read “prime”) separates the numbering of the sugar's carbons from the numbering of the atoms in the base.

A strand has direction

Required content · EK 1.6.A.2

Nucleotides join in a linear sequence with two different ends, defined by the sugar: the 5′ end has a free phosphate on the 5′ carbon, and the 3′ end has a free hydroxyl on the 3′ carbon. Covalent bonds join the 3′ hydroxyl of one nucleotide to the phosphate on the 5′ carbon of the next. This is a phosphodiester bond. The repeating sugar and phosphate form the sugar-phosphate backbone, and the bases extend from it. During nucleic acid synthesis, new nucleotides are always added to the 3′ end of the growing strand.

PPPAGCOH5′ endfree phosphate3′ endfree hydroxyl (OH)5′ → 3′base: carries the informationphosphodiester bond:covalent link between the 3′ carbonof one sugar and the 5′ phosphateof the next nucleotidesugar-phosphate backbone(identical in every nucleic acid)
Figure 1.6b Nucleotides join by covalent bonds between the 3′ hydroxyl of one nucleotide and the 5′ phosphate of the next, forming a sugar-phosphate backbone with the bases sticking out. The strand has direction: during synthesis, new nucleotides are always added to the 3′ end.

The direction matters because everything the cell does with a nucleic acid (copying it, reading it) proceeds in a particular direction along the strand. By convention a sequence is written from the 5′ end to the 3′ end.

The double helix

Required content · EK 1.6.A.3

DNA is an antiparallel double helix: two strands of nucleotides run in opposite directions, one 5′ to 3′ and the other 3′ to 5′. The bases point inward and pair through hydrogen bonds: adenine pairs with thymine (A–T, two hydrogen bonds) and cytosine pairs with guanine (C–G, three hydrogen bonds). In RNA, adenine pairs with uracil (A–U). Each pair joins one large purine to one small pyrimidine, so the helix has a constant width. Strands that fit together this way are complementary.

GCG–C: 3 H bondsATA–T: 2 H bondsTAT–A: 2 H bondsTAT–A: 2 H bondsATA–T: 2 H bondsCGC–G: 3 H bonds5′3′3′5′5′ → 3′purine (A, G): two ringspyrimidine (C, T): one ring
Figure 1.6c The two strands are antiparallel: the left strand runs 5′ to 3′ downward, the right strand 5′ to 3′ upward. Every rung joins a large purine to a small pyrimidine, so the ladder has a constant width. The left strand is 5′-GATTAC-3′ and its partner is 3′-CTAATG-5′.

Notice what holds each part together. The sugar-phosphate backbone of a strand is held by strong covalent bonds, so a strand does not fall apart. The two strands are held to each other by many individually weak hydrogen bonds (lesson 1.1), so they can be pulled apart when the cell needs to copy or read the sequence, and then come back together. A stretch rich in G–C pairs has three hydrogen bonds per pair instead of two, so it takes more energy (a higher temperature) to separate.

Required content · EK 1.6.A.4
DNARNA
SugarDeoxyriboseRibose
BasesA, T, G, C (contains thymine)A, U, G, C (contains uracil)
StrandsTypically double strandedTypically single stranded
Main roleStores genetic informationCarries and uses the information (Unit 6)
Worked example · Writing the complementary strand

One strand of DNA is 5′-GATTAC-3′. Write the complementary strand, give it in the conventional 5′ to 3′ direction, and count the hydrogen bonds between the strands.

Pair each base. G pairs with C, A with T, T with A, T with A, A with T, and C with G. Written directly under the first strand, the partner reads 3′-CTAATG-5′ (it runs the opposite way).
Write it 5′ to 3′. Reverse the order: 5′-GTAATC-3′. Graders accept either form only if the 5′ and 3′ ends are labeled correctly.
Count hydrogen bonds. The pairs are G–C (3), A–T (2), T–A (2), T–A (2), A–T (2), C–G (3): \(3 + 2 + 2 + 2 + 2 + 3 = 14\) hydrogen bonds.

Worked example · Chargaff’s data and the base-pairing rule

Around 1950 Erwin Chargaff measured the percentage of each base in DNA from different organisms. The values below are approximate historical data. Describe the pattern in the data and explain what it suggests about DNA structure.

Source% A% T% G% CA/TG/C
Human30.929.419.919.81.051.01
E. coli26.023.924.925.21.090.99
Yeast31.332.918.717.10.951.09

Describe. In every organism the percentage of A is close to the percentage of T, and the percentage of G is close to the percentage of C (both ratios are near 1.0). The overall proportion of A+T versus G+C differs from species to species: human DNA is 60.3 percent A+T, E. coli 49.9 percent.
Explain. If A always pairs with T and G always with C, then each A on one strand has a T opposite it on the other strand, so the totals match: %A = %T and %G = %C. The data are therefore evidence for base pairing, and since each pair has one purine and one pyrimidine, the total purines (A + G) should equal the total pyrimidines (T + C). That also fits (the ratio is 1.03 for human DNA). The small departures from 1.0 come from measurement error. The amounts of A+T versus G+C vary between species because organisms have different sequences, but the pairing rule is the same.

Exam focus
  • Always label the ends. A complementary strand written without 5′ and 3′ labels, or with them in the wrong places, can lose the point.
  • Two kinds of bond. Covalent bonds (phosphodiester) link nucleotides along one strand; hydrogen bonds link the bases of the two strands. A question about “what holds the two strands together” wants hydrogen bonds.
  • New nucleotides go on the 3′ end, so a strand is made in the 5′ to 3′ direction.
  • RNA has U where DNA has T, ribose where DNA has deoxyribose, and is usually a single strand.
  • For a percentage problem: %A = %T, %G = %C, and all four add to 100. If \(\%G = 28\), then \(\%C = 28\) and \(\%A = \%T = (100 - 56)/2 = 22\).
Practice
  1. A DNA strand has the sequence 5′-TACGGATTC-3′. Write the complementary strand in the 5′ to 3′ direction.
    Show answer

    Pairing under the strand gives 3′-ATGCCTAAG-5′. Reversed so that it reads 5′ to 3′, it is 5′-GAATCCGTA-3′.

  2. List three structural differences between DNA and RNA.
    Show answer

    (1) DNA contains deoxyribose; RNA contains ribose. (2) DNA contains thymine; RNA contains uracil in its place. (3) DNA is typically double stranded; RNA is typically single stranded.

  3. In a sample of double-stranded DNA, 28% of the bases are guanine. Find the percentage of each of the other three bases.
    Show answer

    Cytosine pairs with guanine, so C = 28%. The remaining \(100 - 56 = 44\)% is A plus T, and since A pairs with T they are equal: A = 22% and T = 22%.

  4. A 12-base-pair DNA fragment contains 7 G–C pairs and 5 A–T pairs. How many hydrogen bonds hold the strands together, and how many phosphodiester bonds are in the whole fragment?
    Show answer

    Hydrogen bonds: \(7 \times 3 + 5 \times 2 = 21 + 10 = 31\). Each strand has 12 nucleotides and so \(12 - 1 = 11\) phosphodiester bonds; two strands have \(2 \times 11 = 22\).

  5. Two DNA molecules have the same length. One is 70% G–C and the other is 30% G–C. Predict which needs the higher temperature to separate its strands, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    Prediction: the 70% G–C molecule needs the higher temperature. Justification: the strands are held together by hydrogen bonds, and each G–C pair has three hydrogen bonds while each A–T pair has two. The molecule with more G–C pairs has more hydrogen bonds in total, so more energy is needed to break them and separate the strands.

  6. A growing DNA strand ends with a nucleotide whose 3′ carbon carries a free hydroxyl group. At which end of the strand will the next nucleotide be added, and which part of the incoming nucleotide bonds to it?
    Show answer

    It is added at the 3′ end. The 5′ phosphate of the incoming nucleotide forms a covalent (phosphodiester) bond with the free 3′ hydroxyl of the last nucleotide in the chain, so the strand grows in the 5′ to 3′ direction.

Lesson 1.7 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.7

Proteins

If DNA is the instruction manual, proteins are the workers. Enzymes speed up reactions, hemoglobin carries oxygen, collagen holds skin together, antibodies recognize invaders, and channels in membranes let specific substances through. A cell contains thousands of different proteins, and they are all built from the same 20 kinds of amino acid. What makes one protein an enzyme and another a structural fiber is the order of its amino acids and, as a result, the three-dimensional shape it folds into.

Learning objective · 1.7.A

Describe the structure and function of proteins. The CED states that the molecular structure of the amino acids is beyond the scope of the exam. You should know the parts they share, the three kinds of R group, and the four levels of structure.

Amino acids and the peptide bond

Required content · EK 1.7.A.1 and 1.7.A.2

Every amino acid has a central carbon bonded to four things: a hydrogen atom, a carboxyl group (−COOH), an amino group (−NH2), and a variable R group. The R group is the only difference among the 20 amino acids. Amino acids are linked by peptide bonds, covalent bonds between the carboxyl group of one amino acid and the amino group of the next. This is dehydration synthesis (lesson 1.3), so each peptide bond releases one water. A chain of amino acids is a polypeptide, with an N-terminus (free amino group) at one end and a C-terminus (free carboxyl group) at the other.

Two amino acidsH2NCHCOR₁OHH2NCHCOR₂OHOH + H leave as H2Odehydration synthesisH2NCHCOR₁NHCHR₂COOH+ H2Opeptide bondN-terminus(free amino group)C-terminus(free carboxyl group)
Figure 1.7a Every amino acid has the same backbone, an amino group, a central carbon carrying an R group, and a carboxyl group; only the R group differs. A peptide bond forms between the carboxyl carbon of one amino acid and the amino nitrogen of the next, releasing H2O. A chain has an N-terminus at one end and a C-terminus at the other.

The R groups fall into three categories by their chemical properties, and these properties decide how a protein folds.

R-group categoryPropertyExamplesWhere it tends to end up in a folded protein
Hydrophobic (nonpolar)No charges; avoids waterValine, leucine, alanineInside the protein, away from water
Hydrophilic (polar)Partial charges; hydrogen-bonds with waterSerine, threonineOn the surface, in contact with water; or hydrogen-bonded inside
Ionic (charged)Full positive or negative chargeGlutamate (−), lysine (+)On the surface; opposite charges can form ionic bonds with each other

The R groups on the amino acids determine the structure and function of that region of the protein. The sequence of amino acids is called the protein's primary structure (EK 1.7.A.3), and it determines the overall shape.

Four levels of structure

1° Primary: the amino acid sequenceValHisLeuThrProGluGluLysNCheld together by peptide bonds (covalent):the order sets all later folding2° Secondary: local foldingα helixβ pleated sheethydrogen bonds between backbone atoms3° Tertiary: 3-D shape of one chain12+−341hydrophobic interactionsnonpolar groups pack inside2disulfide bridgeS–S between cysteines3ionic bondoppositely charged R groups4hydrogen bondbetween polar R groups4° Quaternaryseveral chains togetherhemoglobin: 4 chains
Figure 1.7b Primary structure is the sequence. Secondary structure is local folding held by hydrogen bonds between backbone atoms. Tertiary structure is the full 3-D shape of one chain, held by interactions between R groups. Quaternary structure exists only when two or more polypeptides assemble into one protein.
Required content · EK 1.7.A.3 to 1.7.A.6
  • Primary: the linear sequence of amino acids, held together by covalent peptide bonds.
  • Secondary: local folding of the chain into shapes such as the α helix and the β pleated sheet. These are held by hydrogen bonds between atoms of the polypeptide backbone (not the R groups).
  • Tertiary: the overall three-dimensional shape of one polypeptide. It forms through interactions between R groups: hydrogen bonds, hydrophobic interactions, ionic interactions, and disulfide bridges (covalent S–S bonds between the sulfhydryl groups of two cysteines).
  • Quaternary: the arrangement of two or more polypeptides into one functional protein. Hemoglobin, with four chains, is an example. A protein made of a single chain has no quaternary structure.

All four levels together determine the function of the protein. A change at the lowest level can ripple upward: alter one amino acid in the sequence and the folding, the shape, and the function can all change. That is the cause-and-effect reasoning the exam asks you to practice (“predict the causes or effects of a change in a biological system”).

Denaturation: losing the shape

The weak interactions that hold secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure are easily disrupted. Heat, a change in pH, or certain chemicals can break them, and the protein unfolds. This is denaturation. The primary structure is not affected, because the peptide bonds are covalent and strong, but without its shape the protein cannot function. Cooking an egg is denaturation: the clear proteins unfold and tangle into a white solid, and the change is not reversed when the egg cools. Breaking the peptide bonds themselves is a different process, hydrolysis (lesson 1.3).

Worked example · A protein and temperature

Samples of an enzyme were kept for 10 minutes at different temperatures, then cooled to 25 °C and tested for activity. Activity is given as a percentage of the 25 °C sample. Describe the pattern, explain it, and predict the result for the same enzyme from a hot-spring bacterium.

Temperature of 10 min exposure (°C)254050607080
Activity measured at 25 °C (% of control)10098853040

Describe. Activity stays near 100% up to 40 °C, then falls: 85% at 50 °C, 30% at 60 °C, 4% at 70 °C, and none at 80 °C. The steepest drop is between 50 and 60 °C (55 percentage points).
Explain. Higher temperature makes the atoms move faster until the weak hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, and hydrophobic interactions that hold the enzyme's folded shape break. The protein unfolds (denatures) and its active site no longer has the correct shape, so it cannot bind its substrate. The peptide bonds are covalent, so the primary structure stays intact. Because the activity was measured after cooling to 25 °C, the low values show that the enzyme did not refold, so the damage was not reversible in this case.
Predict. An enzyme from a hot-spring bacterium would keep its activity at higher temperatures, with the steep drop shifted well above 60 °C. Its amino acid sequence differs, so it has extra stabilizing interactions (for example more ionic interactions or disulfide bridges) that hold the shape together at high temperature.

Worked example · Sequence determines shape (Anfinsen)

In the 1960s Christian Anfinsen studied ribonuclease, an enzyme with 124 amino acids and four disulfide bridges. He treated it with urea (which disrupts hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic interactions) and β-mercaptoethanol (which breaks disulfide bridges). The enzyme unfolded and lost nearly all activity. When he removed both chemicals, the enzyme refolded and regained nearly all of its original activity.

Native enzymefolded; 4 disulfide bridges100% activityDenaturedurea + β-mercaptoethanol:bridges broken, chain unfoldedabout 0% activityBoth chemicals removedrefolds without helpnearly 100% activity
Figure 1.7c Anfinsen unfolded ribonuclease with urea and a reducing agent, then removed both. The chain refolded into its working shape without help, showing that the amino acid sequence alone contains the information for the final shape.

Question. What does the experiment show about how a protein gets its shape? Claim: the amino acid sequence contains the information that determines the final folded shape. Evidence: the enzyme refolded correctly after the denaturing chemicals were removed, with no other cell machinery present, and the only thing that was never changed was the amino acid sequence (the peptide bonds were never broken). Reasoning: if the sequence were not enough, a chain that was unfolded in a test tube could not find its correct shape on its own. A supporting detail: with eight cysteines there are \(7 \times 5 \times 3 \times 1 = 105\) ways to pair them into four disulfide bridges, and only one gives an active enzyme. A random pairing would be correct less than 1 percent of the time, yet the refolded enzyme was almost fully active.

Worked example · Predict the effect of one change (sickle-cell hemoglobin)

Hemoglobin carries oxygen in red blood cells. It has four polypeptides, two α chains and two β chains. In sickle-cell disease, the sixth amino acid in the β chain is valine instead of glutamate. Predict the effect on the protein and justify it.

Identify the change. Glutamate has an acidic, negatively charged R group, so it is hydrophilic and sits happily on the surface of the protein in contact with water. Valine has a nonpolar, hydrophobic R group.
Predict. The substitution creates a hydrophobic spot on the outside of the protein, where there used to be a charged one.
Justify. Hydrophobic regions avoid water and attract other hydrophobic regions. In low-oxygen conditions the exposed valine of one hemoglobin molecule fits into a hydrophobic pocket on another, so the molecules stick together and form long rigid fibers (a change in how the subunits interact). The fibers distort red blood cells into a sickle shape, which can block small blood vessels. One amino acid out of about 146 in the chain changes the behavior of the whole protein, because the primary structure sets everything above it.

Formula · counting possibilities

There are 20 possible amino acids at each position, so the number of different sequences of length \(n\) is \(20^{n}\). For \(n = 10\) that is \(20^{10} = 1.024 \times 10^{13}\) different peptides; for a 100-amino-acid protein it is \(20^{100} \approx 1.3 \times 10^{130}\). A linear chain of \(n\) amino acids has \(n-1\) peptide bonds. The diversity of protein sequences is what lets a few kinds of subunit make an unlimited variety of molecules.

Exam focus
  • Name the bond for each level. Primary: peptide bonds. Secondary: hydrogen bonds between backbone atoms. Tertiary: R-group interactions (hydrogen, hydrophobic, ionic, disulfide). Quaternary: interactions between polypeptides.
  • Denaturation affects secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure, not the primary. It does not break peptide bonds.
  • When you predict the effect of a mutation or change in pH, trace the chain: R group changed, interactions changed, shape changed, function changed.
  • Say whether an amino acid R group is hydrophobic, polar, or ionic, and where it would sit in the folded protein.
  • Not every protein has quaternary structure.
Practice
  1. Match each type of bond or interaction with the level of protein structure it stabilizes: (a) peptide bond; (b) hydrogen bonds between the backbone N–H and C=O groups; (c) disulfide bridge between two cysteines; (d) interactions between two separate polypeptide chains.
    Show answer

    (a) Primary structure. (b) Secondary structure (α helix and β pleated sheet). (c) Tertiary structure. (d) Quaternary structure.

  2. Insulin is made of two polypeptides, one with 21 amino acids and one with 30. How many peptide bonds does it contain?
    Show answer

    The 21-residue chain has \(21 - 1 = 20\) peptide bonds and the 30-residue chain has \(30 - 1 = 29\), so \(20 + 29 = 49\) in total.

  3. How many different peptides of length 5 could be made from the 20 amino acids? Why is this relevant to the variety of proteins?
    Show answer

    \(20^{5} = 3{,}200{,}000\). Even a very short chain can be arranged in millions of ways; real proteins are hundreds of amino acids long, so the number of possible sequences is far larger than the number of proteins that exist. The order of the amino acids gives each protein its own shape and function.

  4. A mutation replaces a leucine buried in the hydrophobic core of an enzyme with aspartate, an amino acid with a negatively charged R group. Predict the effect on the enzyme and justify it.
    Show answer

    Prediction: the enzyme would misfold or become unstable and lose most of its activity. Justification: leucine is nonpolar and was held in the core by hydrophobic interactions away from water. Aspartate is charged and hydrophilic and does not fit in a nonpolar interior, so the hydrophobic interactions are disrupted. The tertiary structure changes, the active site changes shape, and the enzyme can no longer bind its substrate.

  5. Adding lemon juice (acid) to milk causes the milk to curdle. Explain this in terms of protein structure.
    Show answer

    The acid lowers the pH, which adds hydrogen ions to the R groups of the milk proteins and changes their charges. That disrupts the ionic interactions and hydrogen bonds that hold the proteins in their folded shapes, so they denature, unfold, and clump together as curds. The peptide bonds are not broken, so the primary structure stays the same.

  6. A student states: “Heating a protein breaks its peptide bonds, which is why it stops working.” Evaluate this statement.
    Show answer

    The statement is incorrect. Ordinary heating denatures a protein by breaking the weak hydrogen bonds, ionic interactions, and hydrophobic interactions that hold its secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure. The covalent peptide bonds, which make up the primary structure, stay intact. The protein stops working because it has lost its shape, not because the chain has been cut.

Unit 1 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 1 quiz: Chemistry of Life

Fifteen multiple-choice items and five short free-response questions covering all seven topics of the unit: water, the elements of life, the reactions that build and break macromolecules, carbohydrates, lipids, nucleic acids, and proteins. The multiple-choice items follow the order of the lessons. Click an option to see why each choice is right or wrong, and write each free-response answer out before opening the model response.

Multiple choice

  1. Data: three 200.0 g samples, each in an insulated container, were given 4180 J of heat. Every sample started at 22.0 °C.

    SubstanceWaterEthanolDry sand
    Specific heat (J/g·°C)4.182.440.80
    Temperature change (°C)5.08.626.1

    Which claim is best supported by the data?

    Every sample received exactly 4180 J, so heat is the variable being held constant and cannot explain the difference. A larger temperature change for the same energy means the substance stores less energy per degree, which is the opposite of what this choice claims.

    Water's 5.0 °C rise is the smallest of the three for the same 4180 J, so it takes the most energy to warm each gram by one degree. A water molecule can hydrogen-bond to up to four neighbors, and energy spent pulling those bonds apart does not show up as faster motion, which is what temperature measures.

    Mass is held constant at 200.0 g in all three containers, so the number of grams is not the variable. What differs is specific heat, which traces back to how many hydrogen bonds each molecule can form: ethanol's single hydroxyl group offers far fewer than water's two hydrogens and two lone pairs.

    Reaching a high temperature quickly is the mark of a poor coolant, not a good one. A coolant has to carry heat away, and sand's 26.1 °C rise for the same 4180 J: about 5.2 times water's rise: shows it carries the least energy for a given temperature change.

  2. Data: two runners of the same mass ran the same 10 km course at the same pace on two different days. Each produced 1.50 L of sweat. Core body temperature was measured at the finish.

    Day 1: dry air (30% humidity)Day 2: humid air (90% humidity)
    Sweat that evaporated (L)1.100.35
    Sweat that dripped off unevaporated (L)0.401.15
    Rise in core body temperature (°C)1.02.9

    Which claim is best supported by the data and by the properties of water?

    Both runners produced the same 1.50 L of sweat, yet their temperatures rose by very different amounts, so the amount of sweat cannot be what determines cooling. Warming a small amount of liquid on the skin absorbs little heat compared with evaporating it.

    The day-1 runner evaporated 1.10 L and warmed 1.0 °C; the day-2 runner evaporated 0.35 L and warmed 2.9 °C. Because water has a high heat of vaporization (about 2400 J/g at skin temperature), 1.10 L removes roughly 2.6 MJ of heat and 0.35 L only about 0.84 MJ. The molecules that escape take their energy with them, which is evaporative cooling.

    Humidity does not change the strength of the hydrogen bonds. What changes is that humid air already holds a lot of water vapor, so fewer molecules net-escape from the skin. The conclusion that evaporation slowed is right, but the stated reason is not.

    Sweat that falls off as liquid takes very little heat with it, because it is still liquid at about the temperature of the skin. The heat is removed when water changes from liquid to vapor, and the day-2 runner, with the most dripping and the least evaporation, warmed the most.

  3. A researcher coats the inner wall of one glass capillary tube with a nonpolar wax and leaves an identical tube untreated. Both are stood upright in a dish of water. Which statement most likely describes the result and its cause?

    Capillary rise is not limited by friction; it is driven by an attraction that pulls water up the wall. Removing that attraction removes the driving force, so the waxed tube performs worse rather than better.

    Cohesion holds the column together once it is climbing, but something has to grip the wall first. Without adhesion the water has nothing to climb, which is why the same cohesive liquid behaves differently in the two tubes, and why a tree needs both to move water up xylem.

    Glass exposes δ− oxygens that hydrogen-bond with water's δ+ hydrogens, and that grip on the wall is adhesion. A nonpolar wax has no partial charges, so no hydrogen bonds form, and the cohesive column has no anchor to pull itself up along.

    Surface tension comes from cohesion among the water molecules themselves and is a property of the liquid, not of the tube's coating. Even if it rose, higher surface tension alone would not lift a column up a wall the water cannot bond to.

  4. Data: the pH of 0.1 M aqueous solutions of four small organic molecules at 25 °C, with the functional groups each molecule carries.

    MoleculeEthanolAcetic acidEthylamineGlycine
    Functional group(s)hydroxylcarboxylaminoamino and carboxyl
    pH of 0.1 M solution7.02.911.86.1

    Which claim about functional groups is best supported by the data?

    Ethanol's hydroxyl group contains oxygen, yet its 0.1 M solution sits at pH 7.0: exactly neutral. The table separates "contains oxygen" from "donates H+": only the carboxyl group does the second, because losing H+ leaves a resonance-stabilized: COO−.

    Acetic acid's carboxyl drives the solution to pH 2.9 by donating H+, ethylamine's amino group drives it to pH 11.8 by accepting H+, and glycine, which has both, lands at 6.1: close to ethanol's neutral 7.0 and nowhere near either extreme. The two groups act in opposite directions and largely cancel.

    Polarity and acidity are different properties. Ethanol's hydroxyl is polar enough to hydrogen-bond freely with water, which is why ethanol dissolves without limit, yet its pH is 7.0: polarity governs solubility, while acidity depends on whether a group can actually release a proton.

    Glycine at pH 6.1 is a zwitterion: its carboxyl has donated H+ to become, COO− and its amino group has accepted one to become, NH3+. It carries two charges, not none; the solution is near neutral because those charges balance, not because they are absent.

  5. Data: bacteria were grown for several generations in a medium whose only phosphorus was radioactive 32P. The cells were broken open and separated into four fractions. Radioactivity of each fraction is given in counts per minute (cpm).

    FractionDNA and RNAPhospholipidsProteinsCarbohydrates
    Radioactivity (cpm)840021509045

    Which conclusion is best supported by the data?

    The two highly radioactive fractions, nucleic acids (8400 cpm) and phospholipids (2150 cpm), are the two classes that the CED lists as containing phosphorus. Proteins (90 cpm) and carbohydrates (45 cpm) are close to background, which fits their lacking phosphorus in their basic structure.

    The nucleic acid fraction is the most radioactive, but the phospholipid fraction (2150 cpm) is also strongly labeled, so the data contradict the claim that phosphorus occurs only in nucleic acids. Phospholipids have a phosphate in their head groups.

    An experiment that follows only phosphorus cannot tell you which other elements a molecule contains. Proteins do contain more than carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen (nitrogen in every amino acid, sulfur in some), but this data set only shows that they contain little or no phosphorus.

    Only phospholipids contain phosphorus. Fats (triglycerides) and steroids are made of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. The label appears in the phospholipid fraction because its head groups contain phosphate, not because all lipids do.

  6. A linear polymer made of 10 identical monomers is converted completely into 10 free monomers by an enzyme in the presence of water. Which statement correctly describes the reaction?

    Breaking bonds between monomers by adding water is hydrolysis. Dehydration synthesis does the opposite: it forms bonds and releases water, so it cannot take a polymer apart.

    The reaction is hydrolysis, but the count is wrong. Ten monomers in a line are held together by only 9 bonds (one fewer than the number of monomers), and each bond broken uses one water, so 9 waters are needed, not 10.

    A chain of 10 monomers has \(10 - 1 = 9\) bonds. Hydrolysis adds the H and OH of one water to the two ends created at each bond it breaks, so it uses 9 waters to free all 10 monomers.

    Joining monomers is dehydration synthesis and it releases water; it does not consume water. Taking the polymer apart with the help of water is hydrolysis, and it uses 9 waters, not 10.

  7. A polypeptide is built by dehydration synthesis from 25 alanine monomers (M = 89.09 g/mol). Water has M = 18.02 g/mol. What is the molar mass of the finished polypeptide?

    This subtracts 25 waters instead of 24: 2227.25 − 25(18.02) = 1776.75. A chain of n monomers has only n − 1 bonds between them, so 25 residues release 24 waters, not 25: count the links, not the beads.

    Twenty-five residues require 24 peptide bonds, and each bond releases one water: 25(89.09) − 24(18.02) = 2227.25 − 432.48 = 1794.77 g/mol. Equivalently, every residue after the first adds only 89.09 − 18.02 = 71.07 g/mol to the chain.

    This is the combined mass of 25 free alanine molecules with no water removed at all. The polymer must weigh less than its monomers did separately, and the missing 432.48 g/mol is exactly the water the cell released while building it.

    This adds the water instead of removing it: 2227.25 + 432.48 = 2659.73. Adding water is hydrolysis, the reaction that takes the chain apart; dehydration synthesis, which builds it, removes one H2O per bond formed.

  8. Humans digest starch but pass cellulose through largely unchanged, even though both are polymers of glucose. Which of the following best explains the difference?

    The monomer is the same; the geometry of the bond is not. An α-1,4 linkage produces a helical chain amylase can grip and cut, while a β-1,4 linkage rotates alternate residues 180°, giving flat chains that hydrogen-bond to each other into microfibrils. Enzyme–substrate specificity depends on shape, and humans make no enzyme shaped for β-1,4.

    Both polymers are made entirely of glucose. That is precisely what makes the comparison useful: with the monomer held constant, the only variable left is the linkage, so the linkage has to be the explanation.

    Size is not the barrier: starch molecules are also far too large to absorb, which is exactly why amylase digests them into maltose and glucose first. The problem with cellulose is that the digestive step never happens.

    Both starch and cellulose are held together by covalent glycosidic linkages. Hydrogen bonds do appear in cellulose, but between neighboring chains, where they add strength rather than weakness: the opposite of what this choice implies.

  9. Data: melting points of four fatty acids at 1 atm.

    Fatty acidMyristicPalmiticStearicOleic
    Carbons in the tail14161818
    C=C double bonds0001
    Melting point (°C)54.462.969.613.4

    Which claim is best supported by the data?

    Stearic and oleic acid have the same 18 carbons yet melt 56.2 °C apart, so chain length cannot be the only factor. The table was built with that pair deliberately matched so that the effect of the double bond could be isolated.

    The data run the other way: oleic acid, the only unsaturated one, melts lowest at 13.4 °C. The strength of the C=C bond itself is irrelevant to melting, which depends on the weak attractions between neighboring tails, and a cis kink keeps those tails from stacking closely enough to form many.

    Among the three saturated acids the melting point climbs steadily with length, from 54.4 °C at 14 carbons to 69.6 °C at 18. Length matters; it simply matters less than unsaturation does.

    Compare the two controlled contrasts. Going from stearic (18:0) to oleic (18:1) holds length constant and drops the melting point 56.2 °C; going from stearic (18:0) to myristic (14:0) holds saturation constant and drops it only 15.2 °C. One kink outweighs four carbons by nearly four to one, which is why a membrane rich in unsaturated tails stays fluid in the cold.

  10. A migrating bird must store 1800 kcal. Fat yields about 9 kcal/g. Glycogen yields about 4 kcal/g and binds roughly 2 g of water for every gram stored. Approximately how many times greater is the total mass the bird must carry if it stores the energy as hydrated glycogen rather than as fat?

    This is 450/200, the comparison of dry glycogen to fat. It leaves out the water, which is the whole reason glycogen is a poor long-term store: the stem gives you 2 g of water per gram of glycogen for a reason.

    This is 900/200, counting only the bound water and forgetting the glycogen itself. The carried mass is the polymer plus its water, not one or the other.

    Fat: 1800/9 = 200 g. Glycogen: 1800/4 = 450 g, plus 2(450) = 900 g of bound water, for 1350 g total. Then 1350/200 = 6.8. Fat wins twice over (its highly reduced, C) H-rich tails carry more energy per gram, and being hydrophobic it drags no water along.

    This is 2700/200, which doubles the hydrated glycogen mass once too often. Two grams of water per gram of glycogen gives 900 g of water on top of 450 g of polymer, for 1350 g, not 2700 g.

  11. A small amount of phospholipid is shaken into a beaker of water. Which arrangement of the molecules is most likely to form, and why?

    This reverses the properties. The phosphate-containing head is the polar, charged part, and the long hydrocarbon tails are the nonpolar part. An arrangement with the tails facing the water would put the hydrophobic parts in contact with it.

    A phospholipid is amphipathic: only its head is hydrophilic. Its two long nonpolar tails are not dissolved by water, so the molecules do not scatter as separate molecules; they assemble so the tails are hidden together.

    The polar heads form attractions, including hydrogen bonds, with water, so they stay in contact with it. Water's hydrogen bonding squeezes the nonpolar tails away, so they cluster in the middle. The result is the lipid bilayer found in cell membranes.

    Most lipids are less dense than water, which is why oil floats. More importantly, the question is about how the molecules are arranged: the amphipathic shape produces a bilayer, not a settled layer.

  12. Data: base composition of three nucleic acid samples, in mole percent of total bases.

    SampleAT or UGC
    W22.122.0 (T)27.928.0
    X29.830.1 (T)20.219.9
    Y24.019.5 (U)31.225.3

    Which claim is best supported by the data?

    This reverses the relationship. Sample X is 20.2 + 19.9 = 40.1% G + C, while W is 27.9 + 28.0 = 55.9%, and each G–C pair is held by three hydrogen bonds against A–T's two, so W is the sample that needs more thermal energy to come apart.

    Summing to 100% only means the four bases account for all the bases present; it says nothing about pairing. The test for a duplex is whether A matches its partner and G matches its partner, and Y fails both, which is why its composition is free to be lopsided.

    Y does not obey them: its A and U differ by 4.5 percentage points and its G and C by 5.9. Chargaff's rules hold only where every base has a complementary partner on a second strand, so a violation is evidence that no such strand exists.

    W and X both satisfy %A = %T and %G = %C within rounding, the signature of complementary base pairing in a duplex. W's 55.9% G + C against X's 40.1% means more three-bond pairs per base, hence the higher melting temperature. Y contains uracil and breaks both equalities, 24.0 ≠ 19.5 and 31.2 ≠ 25.3, so it is single-stranded RNA.

  13. A double-stranded DNA fragment is 12 base pairs long and contains 7 G–C pairs. How many hydrogen bonds hold the two strands together?

    This treats all 12 pairs as if each had two hydrogen bonds. Only A–T pairs have two; G–C pairs have three, and the extra bond per G–C pair is the reason GC-rich DNA melts at a higher temperature.

    This swaps the two counts, giving G–C pairs two bonds and A–T pairs three: 7(2) + 5(3) = 29. Remember it by ring count and letters: guanine and cytosine, the "three-letter" pair in the mnemonic sense, share three bonds.

    If 7 of the 12 pairs are G–C, the remaining 5 are A–T. Then 7(3) + 5(2) = 21 + 10 = 31 hydrogen bonds. Note that the purine–pyrimidine rule guarantees exactly 12 pairs total, so no base is left unpaired.

    This treats all 12 pairs as three-bond G–C pairs, which would require a fragment with no adenine or thymine at all. The stem specifies only 7 G–C pairs, and the other 5 must be A–T.

  14. Data: initial rate of a purified intestinal enzyme at 37 °C. Row 1 gives the rate measured at the pH in that column. Row 2 gives the rate measured at pH 7 for a sample that was first held for 20 minutes at the pH in that column and then returned to pH 7.

    pH of treatment357911
    Rate at that pH (µmol/min)42255111
    Rate after return to pH 7 (µmol/min)35455532

    Which statement best explains why the pH 5 and pH 9 samples recover after being returned to pH 7 while the pH 3 and pH 11 samples do not?

    If peptide bonds were broken there would be no chain left to recover, but the row-2 values of 3 and 2 µmol/min are not the issue: the pH 5 and pH 9 samples show the chain survives this treatment intact and simply needs its fold back. Denaturation rearranges weak interactions; it does not cut the covalent backbone.

    Row 2 is the decisive comparison. The pH 5 and pH 9 samples return to 54 and 53 µmol/min, essentially the untreated 55, so their loss of activity was nothing but a reversible change in the charge on acidic and basic R groups. At pH 3 and pH 11 the ionic and hydrogen bonds between R groups were disrupted enough that the chain settled into a misfolded state, and restoring the pH restores only 3 and 2 µmol/min.

    Row 1 alone would fit this idea, but row 2 refutes it: the pH 5 sample was tested away from pH 7 and came back to 54 µmol/min. Being off the optimum is not the same as being permanently damaged, and telling the two apart is exactly what the second row was designed to do.

    A competitive inhibitor is removed when it is washed out, so returning the sample to pH 7 would restore activity in every column, which is not what row 2 shows. H+ changes the enzyme by protonating its R groups rather than by occupying the active site.

  15. A mutation replaces a valine buried in the hydrophobic core of a globular enzyme with a lysine. Which of the following is the most likely consequence, with the best reason?

    The active site is not an independent part; it is a shape produced by the whole fold, and the fold is held together by R-group interactions throughout the chain. Anfinsen's result that the sequence alone dictates the native structure is the reason a change far from the site can still abolish activity.

    Ionic bonds do stabilize tertiary structure, but only where a partner of opposite charge sits nearby and water can reach them. Inside a water-excluded core there is no hydration and usually no counter-ion, so the buried charge destabilizes the fold instead of reinforcing it.

    A substitution changes the primary structure; it does not destroy it. The ribosome still builds a full-length chain of the same number of residues: the problem arises afterward, when that chain folds into the wrong shape.

    Burying a hydrophobic R group in the core is energetically favorable because it lets water maximize its own hydrogen bonding. A charged lysine there is the opposite: the protein must partially unfold or rearrange to let the charge reach solvent, and the active site, whose geometry depends on that fold, no longer matches the substrate.

Free response

  1. Investigation: the effect of heat on purified lactase, the enzyme that hydrolyzes lactose into glucose and galactose.

    A student divided one stock solution of purified lactase into five identical tubes. Tube 1 was held at 25 °C for the entire experiment. Tubes 2 through 5 were held for 10 minutes at 45 °C, 65 °C, 85 °C, and 100 °C respectively, then cooled back to 25 °C. The student then added the same volume of the same lactose solution to every tube and measured the initial rate at which glucose appeared, in µmol per minute, with every tube at 25 °C.

    Using the investigation described, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in the investigation, and describe the purpose of tube 1.
    2. Explain how holding lactase at 85 °C changes its ability to bind lactose.
    3. Construct a graph the student could use to display the results: state which variable belongs on the x-axis and which on the y-axis, give an appropriate scale and label for each axis, and describe the shape of the curve you would expect.
    4. The student claims that the loss of activity is caused by a change in the enzyme's three-dimensional shape rather than by destruction of its amino acid sequence. Justify this claim using evidence from Anfinsen's ribonuclease experiment.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the independent variable is the temperature at which each tube was held for the 10-minute pre-treatment (45, 65, 85, or 100 °C, with 25 °C as the untreated level). Tube 1 is the control: it receives every step except the heating, so it establishes the activity of undamaged enzyme against which the heated tubes are compared. Do not accept: "temperature" with no indication that it is the pre-treatment temperature rather than the assay temperature; naming tube 1 "the control" without describing what it establishes; identifying the rate of glucose production as the independent variable.
    • (b) Accept: heat raises molecular motion enough to break the hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, and hydrophobic interactions among R groups that hold the tertiary fold; the active site loses the shape complementary to lactose, the enzyme–substrate complex no longer forms, and the rate of glucose production falls. Do not accept: "the enzyme is denatured" or "the enzyme is destroyed" with no mechanism; "the enzyme dies"; any claim that heat breaks peptide bonds or alters the amino acid sequence; a general statement about enzymes that is never tied to lactase and lactose.
    • (c) Accept: pre-treatment temperature in °C on the x-axis because it is the independent variable, with an even scale covering 25–100 °C; initial rate of glucose production in µmol/min on the y-axis, starting at 0 and extending just past the tube 1 rate; both axes labeled with the quantity and its unit. Expected shape: near the tube 1 rate at 25 °C and 45 °C, falling steeply between 45 °C and 85 °C, and near zero at 85 °C and 100 °C. Do not accept: the independent variable on the y-axis; axes named without units; a rate axis that does not begin at zero; "plot rate against temperature" with no scale or labels given; a described shape that rises with temperature throughout.
    • (d) Accept: Anfinsen treated ribonuclease A with urea and β-mercaptoethanol, which disrupted the weak interactions and reduced the disulfide bridges, and activity fell to nearly zero; when both reagents were dialyzed away, activity returned to about 95% of the untreated control with no cellular machinery present. Because the same chain regained function once the weak interactions could re-form, the sequence must have survived the treatment intact and only the folded shape had been lost. Do not accept: restating the claim in other words; naming Anfinsen without describing the refolding result; "primary structure determines tertiary structure" asserted with no experimental evidence attached; evidence cited with no statement of why it supports the claim.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is the temperature each tube was held at for the 10-minute pre-treatment, 25, 45, 65, 85, or 100 °C. Tube 1 is the control: it gets every step except the heating, so its rate shows what lactase does undamaged.

    b At 85 °C the extra molecular motion shakes apart the hydrogen bonds, ionic bonds, and hydrophobic clustering between R groups that hold lactase in its folded shape. The active site is made by that fold, so once it opens up lactose no longer fits, the enzyme–substrate complex does not form, and almost no glucose appears.

    c Pre-treatment temperature in °C goes on the x-axis, since that is what I changed, scaled 25 to 100 °C in steps of 25; initial rate of glucose production in µmol/min goes on the y-axis, starting at 0 and running just past tube 1's rate. Both axes get the quantity and the unit. The curve stays near tube 1's rate through 45 °C, drops steeply from 45 to 85 °C, and flattens near zero at 85 and 100 °C.

    d Anfinsen treated ribonuclease A with urea and β-mercaptoethanol until it lost nearly all activity, then dialyzed both reagents away, and activity returned to about 95% of the untreated control with no help from any cell. The same chain was there throughout, so the sequence was never destroyed: only the fold was, and it came back on its own.

  2. A shallow pond and a bare granite outcrop sit side by side in a desert and receive the same sunlight through the day. Answer (a) through (d).

    1. Describe the feature of a water molecule's structure that allows one water molecule to hydrogen-bond to as many as four neighbors.
    2. Explain how hydrogen bonding between water molecules accounts for water's unusually high specific heat.
    3. Water has a specific heat of 4.18 J/g·°C and granite 0.79 J/g·°C. Calculate the temperature change of a 500.0 g sample of each when it absorbs 1.045 × 104 J, showing your setup.
    4. Using your calculated values, justify a claim about which of the two habitats offers an aquatic insect a more thermally stable daytime environment.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the molecule is bent at about 104.5°, and each O–H bond is polar covalent because oxygen pulls the shared electrons harder, leaving a partial negative charge on the oxygen and a partial positive charge on each hydrogen; because the molecule is bent those charges do not cancel, so each molecule can donate two hydrogen bonds through its two hydrogens and accept two at the oxygen's lone pairs. Do not accept: "water is polar" with no structural feature named; "water forms hydrogen bonds," which restates the stem; describing a hydrogen bond as a covalent bond between two water molecules.
    • (b) Accept: temperature measures average kinetic energy, and a large share of the heat added to water is consumed breaking hydrogen bonds between molecules rather than speeding molecules up, so a great deal of energy must be added per gram to raise the temperature one degree. Do not accept: "water has a high specific heat because of hydrogen bonding" with no statement of where the energy goes; confusing specific heat with heat of vaporization without linking either to bond breaking; a correct general statement never connected to water.
    • (c) Accept: \(\Delta T = q/(mc)\). Water: 10450/[(500.0)(4.18)] = 5.00 °C. Granite: 10450/[(500.0)(0.79)] = 26.5 °C. Both values with units and the setup shown. Do not accept: an answer with no setup; values with no units; multiplying instead of dividing by mc; a single value when two were requested.
    • (d) Accept: the pond, justified by the calculated values; for the same 1.045 × 104 J absorbed, the water warms only 5.00 °C while the granite warms 26.5 °C, about 5.3 times as much, because water's hydrogen-bond network absorbs energy the rock cannot. The insect in the pond therefore experiences a far smaller temperature swing over the day. Do not accept: naming the pond with no reference to the calculated values; citing the two numbers without saying which habitat they favor or why; "water has a high specific heat" alone with no evidence from (c).
    Show a 4/4 response

    a A water molecule is bent, with its two hydrogens about 104.5° apart, and oxygen pulls the shared electrons much harder than hydrogen does. That leaves a partial negative charge on the oxygen and a partial positive on each hydrogen, and because the shape is bent those charges do not cancel. One molecule can therefore donate two hydrogen bonds through its hydrogens and accept two at the oxygen's lone pairs.

    b Temperature measures how fast molecules move, but in water much of the heat I add goes into pulling hydrogen bonds apart instead of speeding molecules up. Energy spent that way does not raise the temperature, so warming a gram of water by one degree takes an unusually large amount of heat.

    c Rearranging q = mcΔT gives ΔT = q/(mc). Water: 10450/[(500.0)(4.18)] = 5.00 °C. Granite: 10450/[(500.0)(0.79)] = 26.5 °C.

    d The pond is the more stable habitat. Both absorb the same 1.045 × 104 J, but the water warms only 5.00 °C while the rock warms 26.5 °C, about 5.3 times as much, because water's hydrogen bonds soak up energy granite cannot store. The insect in the pond faces a temperature swing a fifth the size of the one on the rock.

  3. Model: a space-filling model of a 10 base-pair segment of B-form DNA, shown beside the X-ray diffraction pattern of the same form.

    In the model, two sugar–phosphate backbones spiral around the outside of the molecule and the paired bases lie flat in the interior, stacked 0.34 nm apart. The model's diameter is a uniform 2.0 nm along its entire length. In the diffraction pattern, dark spots form an X across the film and the layer-line spacing corresponds to a 3.4 nm repeat. One strand of the modeled segment reads 5'-GGATCCGTAC-3'.

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the bond that joins one nucleotide to the next within a single strand, and describe how the two strands of the model are oriented relative to each other.
    2. Explain how the uniform 2.0 nm diameter shown in the model supports the conclusion that each base pair joins a purine to a pyrimidine.
    3. Represent the strand complementary to 5'-GGATCCGTAC-3' with both of its ends labeled, and calculate the number of hydrogen bonds holding the 10 base-pair segment together, showing your setup.
    4. A student claims that a 10 base-pair segment whose strand reads 5'-AATTAATTAA-3' would separate into single strands at a lower temperature than the modeled segment. Justify this claim using your calculation from (c).
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: a phosphodiester bond, joining the 3' carbon of one sugar to the phosphate on the 5' carbon of the next. The two strands are antiparallel: one runs 5' to 3' while the other runs 3' to 5', so each strand's free 5' phosphate lies opposite the other's free 3' hydroxyl. Do not accept: "hydrogen bond" or "peptide bond"; "the strands are opposite" with no statement of 5' and 3' orientation; describing the backbones as running in the same direction.
    • (b) Accept: a purine has two fused rings and a pyrimidine one, so a purine paired with a purine would make a rung wider than 2.0 nm and two pyrimidines would make one narrower; only a two-ring base opposite a one-ring base keeps every rung the same length, and the model shows no variation in diameter anywhere along the molecule. Do not accept: "A pairs with T and G with C" restated with no reference to ring number or to width; any explanation that appeals only to hydrogen-bond counts; a correct general statement about purines and pyrimidines that is never linked to the uniform diameter.
    • (c) Accept: 3'-CCTAGGCATG-5' (equivalently written 5'-GTACGGATCC-3'), with both ends labeled. Hydrogen bonds: the segment has 6 G–C pairs and 4 A–T pairs, so 6(3) + 4(2) = 18 + 8 = 26. Do not accept: an unlabeled sequence; a complement written parallel to the given strand; 20 or 30 (treating all pairs alike); a bare number with no setup; a sequence containing uracil.
    • (d) Accept: the all-A–T segment is held by 10 A–T pairs, or 10(2) = 20 hydrogen bonds, against the modeled segment's 26 (six fewer, about 23% fewer), because each G–C pair contributes three hydrogen bonds and each A–T pair only two. Fewer hydrogen bonds means less thermal energy is needed to pull the strands apart, so the A–T segment melts first. Do not accept: "A–T pairs are weaker" with no bond counts; repeating the claim; citing the 20 and 26 without saying what they imply about the energy required.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Nucleotides within a strand are joined by phosphodiester bonds, linking the 3' carbon of one sugar to the phosphate on the 5' carbon of the next. The two strands are antiparallel: one runs 5' to 3' while the other runs 3' to 5', so a free 5' phosphate sits opposite a free 3' hydroxyl.

    b Purines have two fused rings and pyrimidines one. If two purines ever paired, that rung would be wider than the rest and the molecule would bulge; two pyrimidines would pinch it in. The model is a uniform 2.0 nm wide everywhere, so every rung must be the same length, which happens only when a two-ring base pairs with a one-ring base.

    c The complement is 3'-CCTAGGCATG-5'. The segment has 6 G–C pairs and 4 A–T pairs, so the hydrogen bonds come to 6(3) + 4(2) = 18 + 8 = 26.

    d The claim holds. A segment of 5'-AATTAATTAA-3' is 10 A–T pairs, or 10(2) = 20 hydrogen bonds, against the modeled segment's 26: six fewer, about 23% fewer, since G–C pairs bring three bonds each and A–T pairs two. Separating the strands means breaking all of them, so the segment with fewer needs less thermal energy and melts first.

  4. Data: fatty acid composition of the membrane phospholipids of rainbow trout held for six weeks at two water temperatures, as a percent of total fatty acids.

    Fatty acids (% of total)Trout at 5 °CTrout at 20 °C
    Saturated3455
    Monounsaturated3027
    Polyunsaturated3618

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the percent of fatty acids that are unsaturated in each group of trout, and describe the trend in the data.
    2. Explain how the number of cis double bonds in a fatty acid tail is related to the fluidity of the membrane that tail sits in.
    3. Calculate the ratio of unsaturated to saturated fatty acids for each acclimation temperature, showing your setup.
    4. A student claims that trout acclimated to 12 °C would have a percent of unsaturated fatty acids between the two values you found in (a). Justify this claim using the data and the relationship you described in (b).
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: unsaturated = monounsaturated + polyunsaturated, so 30 + 36 = 66% at 5 °C and 27 + 18 = 45% at 20 °C; the trend is that the percent of unsaturated fatty acids falls, by 21 percentage points, as acclimation temperature rises, with the polyunsaturated fraction accounting for most of the change (36% to 18%). Do not accept: reporting only the saturated percentages; giving the two values with no trend stated; "the fatty acids change" with no direction; adding the columns incorrectly.
    • (b) Accept: a cis double bond puts a permanent kink in the hydrocarbon tail, so neighboring tails cannot stack closely; fewer attractions form between them, the phospholipids move past one another more easily, and the bilayer stays fluid at lower temperatures. More double bonds means more kinks and a more fluid membrane at any given temperature. Do not accept: "unsaturated fats are liquid" with no mechanism; describing the double bond as making the tail itself more flexible without reference to packing between tails; any statement about fluidity that is never tied to the tails' arrangement.
    • (c) Accept: at 5 °C, 66/34 = 1.94; at 20 °C, 45/55 = 0.82. Setups shown; two significant figures or better acceptable. Do not accept: inverted ratios presented as unsaturated to saturated; one ratio when two were asked for; a ratio with no setup; use of only the polyunsaturated row.
    • (d) Accept: the claim is supported because 12 °C lies between the two tested temperatures and the data show a consistent inverse relationship, 66% unsaturated at 5 °C and 45% at 20 °C, so a fish held between those temperatures needs a membrane that is fluid enough for 12 °C but not so fluid as it would be at 5 °C, giving an intermediate value. Do not accept: "yes, because it is in the middle" with no reference to the data or the mechanism; asserting a specific number with no reasoning; restating the relationship from (b) with no connection to the claim about 12 °C.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Adding the monounsaturated and polyunsaturated rows, the 5 °C trout are 30 + 36 = 66% unsaturated and the 20 °C trout are 27 + 18 = 45%. Unsaturated fatty acids drop by 21 percentage points as the water warms, and most of that comes from the polyunsaturated fraction falling from 36% to 18%.

    b Every cis double bond puts a fixed kink in the tail, and kinked tails cannot pack tightly against their neighbors. With fewer attractions holding them the phospholipids slide past each other more easily, so a membrane with more double bonds stays fluid at a lower temperature than one built from straight saturated tails.

    c At 5 °C the ratio of unsaturated to saturated is 66/34 = 1.94. At 20 °C it is 45/55 = 0.82.

    d I agree. The data show an inverse relationship between temperature and unsaturation, 66% at 5 °C against 45% at 20 °C, because cold would stiffen a saturated membrane into a gel, so a cold fish needs kinks to stay fluid. At 12 °C that pressure is real but milder than at 5 °C, which puts the trout's unsaturated percentage between the two measured values.

  5. A cell assembles a polypeptide from 40 glycine monomers (M = 75.07 g/mol). Water has M = 18.02 g/mol. Answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the reaction that joins two glycine monomers, and describe what happens to the atoms that are removed from them.
    2. Explain why the molar mass of the finished polypeptide is lower than the combined molar mass of 40 free glycine molecules.
    3. Calculate the molar mass of the finished polypeptide, showing your setup.
    4. A protease completely hydrolyzes the polypeptide back to free glycine. Justify a claim about how the total mass of dissolved solute changes, using your calculation from (c).
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: dehydration synthesis (condensation), forming a peptide bond between the carboxyl group of one glycine and the amino group of the next; the, OH taken from one monomer and the, H taken from the other combine and leave as a molecule of water. Do not accept: "hydrolysis"; naming the reaction with no account of the removed atoms; saying atoms are "lost" or "destroyed" rather than released as water.
    • (b) Accept: each of the 39 bonds formed removes one whole water molecule from the chain, so the polymer's mass is the summed monomer mass minus the mass of the water released; the missing mass is not destroyed but has left the molecule as H2O. Do not accept: "some mass is lost" with no identification of water as what left; an answer that describes the reaction but never addresses mass; claiming the bond itself has negative mass or that atoms disappear.
    • (c) Accept: 40 residues require 39 bonds, so 40(75.07) − 39(18.02) = 3002.80 − 702.78 = 2300.02 g/mol. Setup shown and units given. Do not accept: 40 waters subtracted (2282.00); no water subtracted (3002.80); water added (3705.58); a value with no setup or no units.
    • (d) Accept: the total solute mass rises, from 2300.02 g/mol of polypeptide to 40(75.07) = 3002.80 g/mol of free glycine, an increase of 702.78 g/mol: exactly the 39(18.02) g/mol of water subtracted in (c). The justification is that hydrolysis inserts one water molecule at each of the 39 bonds, transferring mass from the solvent into the solutes rather than creating it. Do not accept: "the mass increases" with no value or no mechanism; claiming mass is created; claiming the total is unchanged; citing the numbers without explaining where the added mass came from.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The two glycines are joined by dehydration synthesis, which forms a peptide bond between the carboxyl group of one and the amino group of the other. An, OH comes off one monomer and an, H off the other, and those atoms leave together as one molecule of water.

    b Building a chain of 40 residues takes 39 bonds, and every bond costs one whole water molecule that used to be part of the monomers. The mass is not gone, it walked away as H2O, but it is no longer counted in the polymer, so the finished chain weighs less than the 40 separate glycines did.

    c Forty residues means 39 peptide bonds, so the molar mass is 40(75.07) − 39(18.02) = 3002.80 − 702.78 = 2300.02 g/mol.

    d The total dissolved solute mass goes up, from 2300.02 g/mol of polypeptide to 40(75.07) = 3002.80 g/mol of free glycine, a gain of 702.78 g/mol. That figure is exactly the 39(18.02) g/mol I subtracted in (c), which is my evidence for what is happening: hydrolysis puts one water molecule back into each of the 39 bonds, so the mass is transferred out of the solvent and into the solutes instead of being created.

Lesson 2.1 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.1

Cell structure and function

A cell is a tiny factory with departments. Unit 1 gave you the molecules; this unit shows where they are made, used, and shipped. Almost every organelle on the AP exam is tested the same way: you are given a structure, and you must explain how that structure lets the cell do its job. The skill is not memorizing a list of names but connecting each shape to a function.

Learning objective · 2.1.A

Explain how the structure and function of subcellular components and organelles contribute to the function of cells. The required statements cover ribosomes (EK 2.1.A.1), the endomembrane system (2.1.A.2), the endoplasmic reticulum (2.1.A.3), the Golgi complex (2.1.A.4), mitochondria (2.1.A.5), lysosomes (2.1.A.6), vacuoles (2.1.A.7), and chloroplasts (2.1.A.8).

DNANucleusNucleolusLysosomeFree ribosomesMitochondrionGolgi complexPlasma membraneVacuoleRough ERSmooth ER
Figure 2.1a Organelles in an animal cell, not drawn to scale. Rough ER carries ribosomes on its surface; smooth ER does not. The Golgi receives vesicles from the ER on one side and ships them from the other. Plant cells add a cell wall, chloroplasts, and one large central vacuole.

Ribosomes: the protein makers

Ribosomes are made of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and protein. They have no membrane around them, and they are found in cells of every form of life, which is part of the evidence that all known life shares a common ancestor. A ribosome reads the sequence of a messenger RNA (mRNA) and links amino acids together in the matching order (Unit 6 covers how). Ribosomes in the cytosol make proteins that will work inside the cell. Ribosomes attached to the endoplasmic reticulum make proteins that will be exported, built into membranes, or sent to lysosomes. The ribosomes themselves are the same in both places; what differs is where the mRNA is sent.

The endomembrane system

Required content · EK 2.1.A.2

The endomembrane system is a group of membrane-bound organelles and structures that work together to modify, package, and transport polysaccharides, lipids, and proteins. It includes the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), the Golgi complex, lysosomes, vacuoles and transport vesicles, the nuclear envelope, and the plasma membrane.

Nucleusmakes mRNARough ERmakes, folds proteinGolgimodifies, sortsvesiclesecretory vesicleplasma membraneLysosomedigestive enzymesexocytosis
Figure 2.1b The endomembrane system works like an assembly line. A protein made on the rough ER is carried in a vesicle to the Golgi, which modifies and sorts it. From the Golgi it goes to a lysosome, to the plasma membrane (exocytosis), or out of the cell. Free ribosomes in the cytosol make proteins that stay in the cell.

The pieces are connected, either directly or by vesicles, small membrane-bound sacs that bud off from one compartment and fuse with the next. Because membranes are continuous or exchanged by vesicles, a protein can travel from where it is made to where it is needed without ever leaving a membrane-enclosed space or touching the cytosol.

Endoplasmic reticulum

The endoplasmic reticulum is a network of flattened sacs and tubes joined to the nuclear envelope. It gives the cell mechanical support, helping it keep its shape, and it plays a role in transport inside the cell. It comes in two forms that are connected to each other:

  • Rough ER has ribosomes on its surface. It helps carry out protein synthesis, and it divides the cell into compartments (a compartment is a space where conditions can differ from the rest of the cell, a theme of lessons 2.9 and 2.10). A protein is threaded into the rough ER as it is made, folded there, and then sent on in a vesicle.
  • Smooth ER has no ribosomes. Its functions include detoxification (breaking down drugs and poisons) and lipid synthesis. The CED treats the specific roles of smooth ER in specialized cells as beyond the scope of the exam.

Golgi complex

The Golgi complex is a stack of flattened membrane sacs. Vesicles from the ER arrive at one side, the contents are processed as they move through the stack, and vesicles leave from the other side. Its functions are to fold correctly and chemically modify newly made products and to package proteins for transport. A common modification is glycosylation, attaching sugar chains to a protein. These chemical changes help determine the protein’s function and where it will be delivered, so the Golgi works like a post office that adds an address label to each package. (The roles of the Golgi in making specific phospholipids and packaging specific enzymes are outside the scope of the exam.)

Mitochondria, lysosomes, vacuoles, and chloroplasts

OrganelleStructure (what you must know)Function
MitochondrionDouble membrane. The outer membrane is smooth; the inner membrane is highly folded (cristae), forming separate compartments.Aerobic cellular respiration. The folds give more inner membrane, so ATP can be made more efficiently (Unit 3).
LysosomeMembrane-enclosed sac containing hydrolytic (water-using) enzymes.Digests material, such as worn-out organelles and food particles. Also takes part in programmed cell death (apoptosis).
VacuoleMembrane-bound sac. In plants, one large central vacuole; in animals, smaller and more numerous.Plants: stores nutrients and water and maintains turgor pressure. Animals: stores cellular materials.
ChloroplastDouble membrane; found in plants and photosynthetic algae.Site of photosynthesis (Unit 3).
Worked example · Reading a pulse-chase experiment

Pancreatic cells were given a brief 3-minute “pulse” of radioactive amino acids, then moved to a medium with nonradioactive amino acids (the “chase”). Samples taken later show where the labeled protein is. This is the design used by George Palade, and it is a standard way to follow a product through a cell. Use the table to put three compartments in the order a secreted protein passes through them.

Time after the pulseRough ER (% of label)Golgi (% of label)Secretory vesicles (% of label)
3 minutes8893
20 minutes355213
90 minutes62173

Identify the pattern. At 3 minutes almost all of the label (88 percent) is in the rough ER. At 20 minutes the largest share (52 percent) has moved to the Golgi. At 90 minutes most (73 percent) is in secretory vesicles. Each compartment peaks in turn.
Draw the conclusion. The label moves rough ER, then Golgi, then secretory vesicles. A graph of each compartment would show a peak that appears later for each step, like a wave moving down a line.
Justify. The protein is made on the rough ER first (the pulse is short, so only newly made protein is labeled), so the ER holds the label earliest. Because the label leaves the ER as the Golgi fills, and leaves the Golgi as the vesicles fill, the Golgi is a middle step between them. A grader wants the order, a number from the table for each step, and the reasoning that the label moves from one compartment to the next.

Worked example · Structure predicts function

Two cell types are compared under an electron microscope. A pancreatic cell that secretes digestive enzymes is crowded with rough ER. A liver cell that breaks down drugs has abundant smooth ER. Explain the difference.

Claim. Each cell is packed with the organelle that does its main job.
Evidence. The pancreatic cell has abundant rough ER; the liver cell has abundant smooth ER.
Reasoning. Digestive enzymes are proteins that leave the cell, and proteins for export are made on ribosomes attached to the rough ER, then moved to the Golgi and out. A cell that makes large amounts of a protein needs a lot of rough ER. Detoxification and lipid synthesis are smooth ER functions, and the liver is the organ that processes drugs and poisons, so its cells need a lot of smooth ER. In both cases the amount of a membrane system matches the amount of work the cell does.

Worked example · Predict a disruption

A drug stops transport vesicles from fusing with the Golgi. Predict what builds up in the cell and what stops reaching the plasma membrane.

Prediction. Vesicles filled with newly made protein pile up near the rough ER because they cannot deliver their contents to the Golgi. Proteins that depend on the Golgi for modification and shipping (secreted proteins, membrane proteins, and lysosomal enzymes) would no longer reach the plasma membrane, the outside of the cell, or the lysosomes.
Justification. The endomembrane system is a pathway, so a block at one step stops everything downstream of it and causes a backup upstream.

Exam focus
  • Ribosomes have no membrane and are in all cells, so they are not part of the endomembrane system. They are evidence of common ancestry.
  • Rough ER = ribosomes, protein synthesis. Smooth ER = lipid synthesis, detoxification. Golgi = modify, package, ship. Mitochondria and chloroplasts have double membranes.
  • A good answer names the structure and the property that gives it the function: “the folded inner membrane increases the area for making ATP,” not just “mitochondria make ATP.”
  • Questions that give a cell type and ask what organelle it has more of want you to name the product the cell makes, then match it to the organelle that makes it.
  • In a pulse-chase table, the compartment that holds the label earliest is first in the pathway.
Practice
  1. List the structures that make up the endomembrane system, and state what the system does with lipids, proteins, and polysaccharides.
    Show answer

    The endoplasmic reticulum, the Golgi complex, lysosomes, vacuoles and transport vesicles, the nuclear envelope, and the plasma membrane. Together they modify, package, and transport polysaccharides, lipids, and proteins.

  2. Describe how rough ER differs from smooth ER in structure and in function.
    Show answer

    Rough ER has ribosomes attached to its surface and helps carry out protein synthesis (and compartmentalizes the cell). Smooth ER has no ribosomes and is involved in lipid synthesis and detoxification.

  3. Explain why the inner membrane of a mitochondrion is folded into cristae.
    Show answer

    Folding increases the surface area of the inner membrane within the same volume. ATP is made by proteins in that membrane, so more membrane holds more of them and ATP can be made more efficiently. The two membranes also create separate compartments for different reactions of aerobic respiration.

  4. A cell makes a hormone that is a protein and releases it into the blood. Trace the path the hormone takes from synthesis to release, naming each organelle in order.
    Show answer

    It is made by a ribosome on the rough ER and threaded into the ER, where it folds. A transport vesicle carries it to the Golgi, which modifies and packages it. A secretory vesicle then carries it to the plasma membrane, and the vesicle fuses with the membrane (exocytosis) to release the hormone out of the cell.

  5. A mutation prevents lysosomes from working. Predict one effect on the cell and justify it.
    Show answer

    Material that the cell would normally break down, such as worn-out organelles and engulfed particles, builds up inside the cell, because lysosomes hold the hydrolytic enzymes that digest it. Programmed cell death, which also involves lysosomes, would also be affected.

  6. Distinguish the function of a large central vacuole in a plant cell from that of the vacuoles in an animal cell.
    Show answer

    In a plant cell, the large central vacuole stores nutrients and water and maintains turgor pressure, which keeps the cell firm. In an animal cell, vacuoles are smaller and more numerous and store cellular materials.

Lesson 2.2 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.2

Cell size and surface area-to-volume ratio

Why are almost all cells microscopic? A whale is larger than a mouse, yet its cells are about the same size. The reason is geometry. A cell must take in nutrients and oxygen and get rid of wastes through its surface, but it needs those materials for everything inside its volume. As a cell grows, the two quantities do not grow at the same rate, and that mismatch sets the upper limit on cell size.

Learning objective · 2.2.A

Explain the effect of surface area-to-volume ratios on the exchange of materials between cells or organisms and the environment. EK 2.2.A.1 says that the ratio affects the ability of a biological system to obtain nutrients, eliminate wastes, acquire or dissipate thermal energy, and otherwise exchange chemicals and energy with the environment. EK 2.2.A.2 gives five consequences, covered below.

Surface area grows more slowly than volume

Take a cube with sides of length \(s\). Its surface area is \(SA = 6s^2\) and its volume is \(V = s^3\), so the surface area-to-volume ratio is \(SA/V = 6/s\). Double the side and the ratio is cut in half. The exam gives you the formulas for the common shapes, but you must be able to use them.

side 1 cmSA = 6 cm²V = 1³ = 1 cm³SA:V = 6 : 1side 2 cmSA = 24 cm²V = 2³ = 8 cm³SA:V = 3 : 1side 4 cmSA = 96 cm²V = 4³ = 64 cm³SA:V = 1.5 : 1Doubling the side multiplies the volume by 8 but the surface by only 4
Figure 2.2a Surface area grows with the square of the side and volume with the cube, so the ratio SA:V = 6/s falls as the cube gets bigger. The same rule limits how large a cell can be before its surface cannot supply its volume.
Formulas given on the AP exam
ShapeVolumeSurface area
Sphere (radius \(r\))\(V = \tfrac{4}{3}\pi r^3\)\(SA = 4\pi r^2\)
Cube (side \(s\))\(V = s^3\)\(SA = 6s^2\)
Rectangular solid (length \(l\), width \(w\), height \(h\))\(V = lwh\)\(SA = 2lh + 2lw + 2wh\)
Cylinder (radius \(r\), height \(h\))\(V = \pi r^2 h\)\(SA = 2\pi r h + 2\pi r^2\)
Required content · EK 2.2.A.2
  • The surface area of the plasma membrane must be large enough to exchange materials adequately. A small cell has a higher SA:V ratio and exchanges materials with its environment more efficiently than a large cell.
  • As cells increase in volume, the SA:V ratio decreases and the demand for internal resources increases.
  • More complex cellular structures, such as membrane folds, are needed to exchange materials adequately.
  • As organisms increase in size, their SA:V ratio decreases, which changes properties such as the rate of heat exchange with the environment. A smaller mass exchanges proportionally more heat than a larger one.
  • The smaller the organism, the higher its metabolic rate per unit of body mass.
Worked example · Calculating SA:V for spherical cells

Compare two spherical cells, one with a radius of 5 \(\mu\)m and one with a radius of 10 \(\mu\)m. Calculate the SA:V ratio of each and state which can exchange materials more efficiently.

Cell with \(r = 5\) \(\mu\)m. \(SA = 4\pi(5)^2 = 314.2\ \mu\text{m}^2\). \(V = \tfrac{4}{3}\pi(5)^3 = 523.6\ \mu\text{m}^3\). \(SA/V = 314.2/523.6 = 0.60\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\).
Cell with \(r = 10\) \(\mu\)m. \(SA = 4\pi(10)^2 = 1256.6\ \mu\text{m}^2\). \(V = \tfrac{4}{3}\pi(10)^3 = 4188.8\ \mu\text{m}^3\). \(SA/V = 1256.6/4188.8 = 0.30\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\).
Conclusion. Doubling the radius multiplied the surface area by 4 but the volume by 8, so the ratio fell by half. The 5 \(\mu\)m cell has the higher ratio, so it can supply its interior more efficiently and its materials do not have to travel as far. (For a sphere, \(SA/V = 3/r\), which gives the same results: 0.60 and 0.30.)

Shape and folds raise the ratio

A cell that cannot stay small can change its shape. A flat or long, thin cell has a higher SA:V than a sphere of the same volume. A cell can also fold its membrane, which adds surface area without adding much volume.

Smooth surfacelength of surface = 100 unitsrelative surface area = 1.0Folded surface (microvilli)relative surface area = 5.0in the same widthA larger surface with the same footprint lets a cellabsorb more nutrients and release more waste.
Figure 2.2b Folds increase surface area without increasing the volume of the cell. Five fingers 40 units tall on a 100-unit base give 5.0 times the surface. Microvilli on gut cells, root hairs, and the folded inner membrane of a mitochondrion all work this way.
ExampleWhat increases surface areaWhy it helps
Root hairsLong, thin extensions of root cellsMore membrane in contact with soil water and minerals
Gut (intestinal) epithelial cellsMicrovilli on the free surfaceMore membrane for absorbing nutrients
MitochondriaFolded inner membrane (cristae)More room for the proteins that make ATP
Stomata and guard cellsPores in leaf surface that open and closeGas exchange and control of water loss
CiliaMany short projectionsSurface for moving fluids and for exchange
Worked example · Same volume, different shape

A rectangular solid cell measures 20 \(\mu\)m by 20 \(\mu\)m by 2 \(\mu\)m. A cube-shaped cell has the same volume. Compare their SA:V ratios.

Flat cell. \(V = 20 \times 20 \times 2 = 800\ \mu\text{m}^3\). \(SA = 2(20)(2) + 2(20)(20) + 2(20)(2) = 80 + 800 + 80 = 960\ \mu\text{m}^2\). \(SA/V = 960/800 = 1.20\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\).
Cube of the same volume. \(s = \sqrt[3]{800} = 9.28\ \mu\text{m}\). \(SA = 6(9.28)^2 = 517.1\ \mu\text{m}^2\). \(SA/V = 517.1/800 = 0.65\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\).
Conclusion. The flat cell has almost twice the ratio (1.20 to 0.65) with exactly the same amount of cytoplasm. This is why many cells that must absorb a lot, such as the cells lining a leaf or an intestine, are flattened or have projections.

Whole organisms: heat exchange and metabolic rate

The same rule applies to a whole animal. A mouse has a much larger SA:V ratio than an elephant, so it loses body heat to the environment much faster for each gram of tissue. To stay warm the mouse must burn fuel at a high rate, which is why its metabolic rate per gram is far higher than the elephant’s and why a mouse must eat a large amount of food for its size. An elephant has the opposite problem: its small ratio makes it hard to lose heat, and its large ears, rich in blood vessels, act as radiators.

Worked example · The agar-cube diffusion investigation

Agar cubes containing a pH indicator (phenolphthalein, which is pink in base) are placed in dilute sodium hydroxide for 10 minutes. The base diffuses in about 0.3 cm from every face and turns that outer layer pink. The colorless center was not reached. Calculate the percent of the volume that turned pink in cubes with sides of 1 cm, 2 cm, and 3 cm, and explain the trend.

Cube side (cm)Total volume (cm³)Colorless center (cm³)Percent pink
11.000\(0.4^3 = 0.064\)93.6
28.000\(1.4^3 = 2.744\)65.7
327.000\(2.4^3 = 13.824\)48.8

Method. The colorless center is a smaller cube whose side is the cube side minus 0.3 cm from each of two opposite faces, that is, \(s - 0.6\). The percent pink is \((V_{\text{total}} - V_{\text{center}})/V_{\text{total}} \times 100\). For \(s = 2\): \((8 - 2.744)/8 \times 100 = 65.7\) percent.
Trend. Larger cubes are reached by the base over a smaller fraction of their volume: 93.6, 65.7, then 48.8 percent. The distance the base can travel in a given time is about the same for every cube, but the larger cube has more volume for each unit of surface.
Connection to cells. The percent that diffusion reaches in time stands for how well a cell can supply its interior. A large cell has a lower SA:V ratio, so a smaller fraction of its cytoplasm is within reach of the surface.

Exam focus
  • Write the formula, substitute with units, and state the answer with units. SA:V has units of 1/length (for example \(\mu\text{m}^{-1}\)).
  • The pattern to state: as size increases, volume (cubed) grows faster than surface area (squared), so SA:V decreases.
  • Small cells are not “better.” Large cells compensate with folds, flattening, projections, or many small cells, so know the examples (microvilli, root hairs, cristae).
  • For a whole organism, a larger SA:V means faster heat exchange and a higher metabolic rate per gram.
  • Lab questions: identify what is held constant (time, concentration) and what is measured (depth or percent of the cube that changed color).
Practice
  1. A cube-shaped cell has a side of 4 \(\mu\)m. Calculate its surface area, volume, and SA:V ratio.
    Show answer

    \(SA = 6(4)^2 = 96\ \mu\text{m}^2\). \(V = 4^3 = 64\ \mu\text{m}^3\). \(SA/V = 96/64 = 1.5\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\).

  2. A spherical bacterium has a radius of 1 \(\mu\)m and a spherical eukaryotic cell has a radius of 10 \(\mu\)m. Calculate each SA:V ratio and explain what the difference means for the exchange of materials.
    Show answer

    For a sphere \(SA/V = 3/r\). Bacterium: \(3/1 = 3.0\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\). Eukaryotic cell: \(3/10 = 0.30\ \mu\text{m}^{-1}\). The bacterium has ten times the surface area for each unit of volume, so nutrients and wastes cross its membrane and reach every part of the cell quickly. The eukaryote cannot rely on its surface alone, which is one reason it has internal membranes and organelles.

  3. Explain why the cells that line the small intestine have microvilli.
    Show answer

    Microvilli are folds of the plasma membrane that greatly increase its surface area without increasing the volume of the cell. More membrane in contact with the digested food means more transport proteins and faster absorption of nutrients.

  4. A student claims that if a cell doubles its radius, it needs twice as much surface area to stay supplied. Evaluate the claim using the formulas.
    Show answer

    The claim is incorrect. Doubling the radius multiplies the surface area by \(2^2 = 4\) but the volume by \(2^3 = 8\), so the cell’s needs (which scale with volume) grow twice as fast as its supply (which scales with surface area). The cell would need 8 times the supply but gets only 4 times the surface. The SA:V ratio is cut in half.

  5. A shrew (a very small mammal) must eat nearly continuously, while a cow can go hours between meals. Explain this using SA:V.
    Show answer

    A shrew has a much higher SA:V ratio, so it loses body heat to the environment much faster per gram. To keep its body temperature steady it must produce heat at a high rate, so its metabolic rate per gram of body mass is high and it needs a lot of food. The cow has a small SA:V ratio, loses heat slowly per gram, and has a lower metabolic rate per gram.

  6. Agar cubes of side 1, 2, and 3 cm are soaked for the same time. Predict which has the greatest percent of its volume reached by the indicator and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    The 1 cm cube. It has the highest SA:V ratio (6 compared with 3 and 2), so the diffusing substance can reach the largest fraction of its volume. Because the distance moved is about the same for each cube, the percent reached falls as the cube gets larger.

Lesson 2.3 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.3

The plasma membrane

Every cell is separated from its surroundings by a plasma membrane, a thin boundary only about two molecules thick that is also the most active surface in the cell. It must keep the inside different from the outside, let some materials pass, stop others, receive signals, and recognize neighbors. Lesson 1.5 introduced the phospholipid that makes this possible. Here you will see how the whole membrane is put together.

Learning objectives · 2.3.A and 2.3.B

2.3.A Describe the roles of each component of the cell membrane in maintaining the internal environment of the cell. EK 2.3.A.1 covers phospholipids; EK 2.3.A.2 covers embedded proteins. 2.3.B Describe the fluid mosaic model of cell membranes (EK 2.3.B.1).

Outside the cellInside the cell (cytosol)GlycoproteinGlycolipidPhospholipid bilayerCholesterolTransmembrane proteinPeripheral proteinchannelcarrier
Figure 2.3a The fluid mosaic model: a flexible bilayer of phospholipids (the fluid) with proteins, cholesterol, glycoproteins, and glycolipids (the mosaic) that can move sideways within the surface. Hydrophobic stretches of transmembrane proteins sit among the fatty acid tails; hydrophilic stretches face the water.

Phospholipids: the framework

Each phospholipid has a polar, hydrophilic phosphate-containing head and two nonpolar, hydrophobic fatty acid tails. In water the polar heads are oriented toward the watery environment, the cytosol on one side and the external fluid on the other, and the fatty acid tails face each other in the interior of the membrane (EK 2.3.A.1). This double layer is the phospholipid bilayer. Because the tails form a nonpolar layer in the middle, the bilayer is a barrier to water-soluble substances, a fact that the next lesson builds on. The phospholipids are not locked in place. Each molecule moves sideways within its own layer many times per second, so the membrane behaves more like a thin oil than like a solid sheet.

Embedded proteins

Proteins are scattered through the bilayer. Their orientation follows the same rule as the phospholipids: the way a protein sits depends on which parts of it like water. Using the chemistry of the R groups from lesson 1.7:

Required content · EK 2.3.A.2
  • Embedded proteins can be hydrophilic (with charged and polar side groups), hydrophobic (with nonpolar side groups), or both.
  • The hydrophilic regions are either inside the protein or exposed to the cytosol (and the outside fluid).
  • The hydrophobic regions make up the protein surface that interacts with the fatty acid tails in the interior of the membrane.

A protein that spans the whole bilayer (a transmembrane protein) is both: its middle section has nonpolar R groups that fit among the tails, and its two ends have polar R groups that face the water on either side. Many transmembrane proteins form channels or carriers (lessons 2.5 and 2.6), and others are receptors that detect signals (Unit 4). A peripheral protein sits on the surface instead of passing through; it is held by interactions with the polar heads or with other proteins.

The fluid mosaic model

Required content · EK 2.3.B.1

Plasma membranes consist of a structural framework of phospholipid molecules embedded with proteins, steroids (such as cholesterol in vertebrate animals), glycoproteins, and glycolipids. All of these can move around the surface of the cell within the membrane, as shown by the fluid mosaic model.

ComponentWhat it isRole in the membrane
PhospholipidsPolar head, two nonpolar tailsForm the bilayer that separates the inside from the outside
CholesterolA steroid between the tails (animal cells)Stabilizes the membrane: it keeps it from becoming too fluid when warm and from packing too tightly when cold
Transmembrane proteinsSpan both layersChannels, carriers, pumps, and receptors
GlycoproteinsProteins with sugar chains on the outer surfaceCell identification and recognition, such as the markers that identify a cell to the immune system
GlycolipidsLipids with sugar chains on the outer surfaceCell recognition and stability

The word fluid means the components can move sideways within the membrane. The word mosaic means the membrane is a patchwork of different molecules, not a uniform sheet.

Worked example · How we know the membrane is a bilayer (Gorter and Grendel)

In 1925 Gorter and Grendel extracted all of the lipids from a known number of red blood cells and spread them in a single layer on water. They then compared the area of that lipid film with the calculated surface area of the cells. Illustrative values: the lipid film covered 0.92 m\(^2\); the combined surface area of the cells was 0.46 m\(^2\). Calculate the ratio and state the conclusion.

Calculation. \(0.92 / 0.46 = 2.0\).
Conclusion. The lipids were able to cover twice the surface area of the cells, so each cell has enough lipid for a layer two molecules deep. This supports the model of a phospholipid bilayer.
Why it works. Mature red blood cells have no nucleus or organelles, so the plasma membrane is almost their only membrane. Nearly all of the lipid extracted therefore came from the plasma membrane.

Worked example · Evidence that membrane proteins move (Frye and Edidin)

Mouse cells and human cells were fused into hybrid cells. Surface proteins were tagged with fluorescent labels, red on the mouse proteins and green on the human proteins. Immediately after fusion the colors were in separate halves of the cell. The table gives the percent of hybrid cells in which the two colors had completely mixed (approximate values). Interpret the data.

Temperature (°C)Time after fusion (min)Cells with fully mixed colors (%)
3700
3740100
1400

Describe. At 37 °C the colors mixed in every cell within 40 minutes; at 1 °C no cell had mixed after 40 minutes.
Explain. The mixing shows that the proteins move sideways within the membrane, which is the “fluid” part of the fluid mosaic model. The cold stopped the mixing because at low temperature the phospholipids pack more closely and the membrane becomes less fluid, so proteins cannot move freely. Heat energy drives the movement.
Predict. Cholesterol would reduce the temperature effect: it keeps the membrane from becoming too stiff in the cold and too loose in the heat, so a membrane with cholesterol would show a smaller change in mixing between 1 °C and 37 °C.

Exam focus
  • Say why each part sits where it does: heads toward water because they are polar; tails inside because they are nonpolar; a transmembrane protein is hydrophobic where it touches the tails and hydrophilic where it touches water.
  • Fluid = parts move sideways. Mosaic = many kinds of parts. If you draw the model, label the bilayer, a transmembrane protein, cholesterol, and a carbohydrate chain on the outer face.
  • Cholesterol is a steroid in animal cell membranes, not a phospholipid. It buffers fluidity against temperature changes.
  • Glycoproteins and glycolipids face outward and are involved in cell recognition and signaling.
  • Questions on membrane diagrams often ask you to predict what happens if a component is removed or changed, so state the function first, then the effect.
Practice
  1. Explain why the phospholipids of a plasma membrane arrange themselves with the heads outward and the tails inward.
    Show answer

    The heads are polar and hydrophilic, so they interact with the water on both sides of the membrane (the cytosol and the extracellular fluid). The tails are nonpolar and hydrophobic, so they avoid water and cluster together in the interior, facing each other.

  2. A transmembrane protein has a stretch of 22 amino acids in the middle of its sequence that all have nonpolar R groups. Predict where that stretch is located, and justify your prediction.
    Show answer

    It lies within the interior of the membrane, among the fatty acid tails. Nonpolar R groups can interact with the nonpolar tails but not with water, so the hydrophobic stretch spans the middle of the bilayer while the polar regions at the ends are exposed to the water.

  3. Describe what the words “fluid” and “mosaic” mean in the fluid mosaic model.
    Show answer

    Fluid: the phospholipids and many proteins can move around within the membrane. Mosaic: the membrane is made of many different molecules (phospholipids, proteins, cholesterol, glycoproteins, and glycolipids) arranged like pieces of a mosaic.

  4. In an experiment like Gorter and Grendel’s, extracted lipid from red blood cells covers 0.80 m\(^2\) and the combined surface area of the same cells is 0.40 m\(^2\). Calculate the ratio, state what it suggests about membrane structure, and say why red blood cells make a good choice.
    Show answer

    \(0.80 / 0.40 = 2.0\). The lipid could cover twice the cell surface, which suggests the membrane is a bilayer (two lipid layers). Mature red blood cells have no nucleus or other membrane-bound organelles, so nearly all of the extracted lipid comes from the plasma membrane.

  5. Identify the membrane component described: (a) provides a recognition marker on the outer surface; (b) stabilizes fluidity in animal membranes; (c) forms a channel through the bilayer.
    Show answer

    (a) A glycoprotein or glycolipid (a molecule with a carbohydrate chain). (b) Cholesterol. (c) A transmembrane (integral) protein.

Lesson 2.4 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.4

Membrane permeability and the cell wall

A membrane that let everything through would be useless, and one that let nothing through would starve the cell. The plasma membrane is selectively permeable: it allows some substances to cross easily, others only with help, and others not at all. This lesson shows how that selectivity follows from the structure you met in lesson 2.3, and why many cells add a cell wall.

Learning objectives · 2.4.A and 2.4.B

2.4.A Explain how the structure of biological membranes influences selective permeability (EK 2.4.A.1 to 2.4.A.3). 2.4.B Describe the role of the cell wall in maintaining cell structure and function (EK 2.4.B.1).

The hydrophobic interior decides

Required content · EK 2.4.A.1 to 2.4.A.3
  • Plasma membranes separate the internal environment of the cell from the external environment. Selective permeability is the result of the membrane having a hydrophobic interior.
  • Small nonpolar molecules, including N2, O2, and CO2, freely pass across the membrane. Hydrophilic substances, such as large polar molecules and ions, cross through embedded channels and transport proteins.
  • The nonpolar hydrocarbon tails of phospholipids prevent the movement of ions and polar molecules. Small polar, uncharged molecules, such as H2O or NH3, pass through in small amounts.
bilayerOutsideInsideO2, CO2, N2small, nonpolarpasses freelyH2O, NH3small, polar, unchargedpasses slowly, in small amountsglucose, amino acidslarge, polarneeds a transport proteinNa+, K+, Cl−, H+ions (charged)blocked; needs a channel or pump
Figure 2.4a The hydrophobic interior makes the membrane selectively permeable. Small nonpolar molecules dissolve in the tails and pass through; polar molecules and ions cannot dissolve in the tails and need embedded channel or transport proteins.

Think of the bilayer as a layer of oil. A nonpolar molecule such as oxygen can dissolve in oil, so it slips between the tails and across the membrane. A charged ion is surrounded by water molecules in solution, and it cannot shed them and enter the oil, so it stays out. A glucose molecule is too large and has too many polar \(\text{–OH}\) groups to pass between the tails at a useful rate. Small polar molecules such as water are not repelled completely; a few squeeze between the phospholipids, so water crosses slowly through the lipid alone. Cells that must move a great deal of water add special channels for it (lesson 2.6).

Type of substanceExamplesCrossing the bilayer
Small, nonpolarO2, CO2, N2Pass freely through the lipid
Small, polar, unchargedH2O, NH3Pass slowly, in small amounts
Large, polarGlucose, amino acidsNeed a transport protein
Ions (charged)Na+, K+, Cl−, H+Blocked by the tails; need a channel or pump
Worked example · Using data to evaluate a hypothesis

A student predicts that a substance’s ability to cross a pure phospholipid bilayer depends on its size and polarity. Artificial vesicles (made only of phospholipids, with no proteins) were placed in solutions of different substances for 10 minutes. The table gives the percent of each substance that entered the vesicles (a hypothetical data set). Evaluate the hypothesis.

SubstanceSize and polarityEntered the vesicles in 10 min (%)
Carbon dioxideSmall, nonpolar95
EthanolSmall, slightly polar90
WaterSmall, polar18
UreaSmall, polar6
GlucoseLarge, polar0.8
Sodium ionsCharged0.01

Describe the data. Entry falls from 95 percent for carbon dioxide to 0.01 percent for sodium ions. The most nonpolar and smallest substances entered most; the large polar molecule and the ion barely entered.
Evaluate. The data support the hypothesis: crossing decreases as polarity and size increase and is lowest for charged ions. The trend follows the structure of the membrane: a hydrophobic interior favors nonpolar, small molecules.
Add to the claim. Water and urea crossed in small but measurable amounts, matching the idea that small polar molecules can pass in small amounts. Two substances (glucose and Na+) are very important to cells yet cross very poorly in a pure bilayer, so a living cell must have other ways to move them: transport proteins.
A good follow-up experiment. Repeat the test with vesicles that contain glucose transport proteins. If the hypothesis about the bilayer is right and proteins supply the missing route, glucose entry should increase while sodium entry stays low.

The cell wall

Required content · EK 2.4.B.1

Cell walls of Bacteria, Archaea, Fungi, and plants provide a structural boundary, as well as a permeability barrier for some substances to the internal or external cellular environments, and protection from osmotic lysis.

A cell wall is a rigid layer outside the plasma membrane. It is made of different materials in different groups (cellulose in plants, chitin in fungi, and other polymers in bacteria and archaea), but the roles are the same. The wall gives the cell its shape and mechanical support. It is porous to water and small solutes, so it acts as a coarse filter that keeps out large particles. Most importantly, it prevents osmotic lysis. When a cell sits in a dilute solution, water flows in (lesson 2.7). A cell without a wall, such as an animal cell, would swell and burst, but a cell with a wall stretches only until the wall pushes back, so the cell does not break. Animal cells have no wall; they instead rely on regulating the solutes inside and outside.

FeaturePlasma membraneCell wall
Present inAll cellsBacteria, Archaea, Fungi, and plants (not animals)
LocationInside the wall, around the cytoplasmOutside the plasma membrane
Made ofPhospholipid bilayer with proteinsPolysaccharides or other polymers, depending on the group
PermeabilitySelective: controls what enters and leavesMostly permeable to water and small solutes; a coarse barrier
Main roleControls exchange with the environmentShape, support, and protection against bursting
Worked example · Predict and justify

Bacteria are placed in pure water, and an enzyme that digests the cell wall is added. Predict what happens and explain.

Prediction. The cells swell and burst (lyse).
Justification. The cytoplasm has a higher solute concentration than pure water, so water moves into the cells by osmosis. Normally the wall resists the swelling, but once the wall is digested nothing holds the membrane from expanding, and it bursts. A complete answer names the direction of water movement, says why, and states the role of the wall.

Exam focus
  • The cause of selective permeability is the hydrophobic interior of the bilayer. Always connect the substance (size, charge, polarity) to the membrane’s nonpolar tails.
  • Memorize the four rows: small nonpolar pass freely; small polar slowly; large polar and ions need proteins.
  • Do not write that the membrane is “a barrier” with no reason. A grader wants “ions are charged and cannot enter the nonpolar tails.”
  • The cell wall is outside the membrane and protects against osmotic lysis. Animal cells do not have one.
  • Data questions: describe the trend with numbers from the table, state whether the hypothesis is supported, and propose a follow-up test.
Practice
  1. Explain why oxygen can cross a plasma membrane without a protein but a sodium ion cannot.
    Show answer

    Oxygen is a small nonpolar molecule that dissolves in the hydrophobic interior of the bilayer, so it passes between the fatty acid tails. A sodium ion is charged, and the nonpolar tails prevent the movement of ions, so a sodium ion cannot cross the bilayer by itself and needs a channel or transport protein.

  2. Rank oxygen, glucose, water, and potassium ion from most to least permeable through a pure phospholipid bilayer, and justify the ranking.
    Show answer

    Oxygen (small, nonpolar) first, then water (small, polar, uncharged; passes in small amounts), then glucose (large, polar), then potassium ion (charged; blocked by the tails). The ranking follows size and polarity: the more the molecule resembles the nonpolar interior, the easier it crosses.

  3. Describe two roles of the cell wall.
    Show answer

    (Any two.) It provides a structural boundary that gives the cell shape and support; it acts as a permeability barrier for some substances; it protects the cell from osmotic lysis.

  4. A plant cell and an animal cell are placed in pure water. The animal cell bursts but the plant cell does not. Explain the difference.
    Show answer

    Water enters both cells by osmosis because their cytoplasm has a higher solute concentration than pure water. The animal cell has only a plasma membrane, which cannot resist the swelling, so it lyses. The plant cell has a cell wall outside the membrane that resists expansion, so the cell becomes firm (turgid) without bursting.

  5. Carbon dioxide produced by respiration leaves a cell without any transport protein, but glucose entering the cell needs one. Use membrane structure to explain both.
    Show answer

    CO2 is small and nonpolar, so it can dissolve in the hydrophobic interior of the membrane and diffuse across freely. Glucose is a large polar molecule that cannot pass between the nonpolar tails at a useful rate, so it must cross through a transport protein embedded in the membrane.

Lesson 2.5 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.5

Membrane transport

A living cell is never in equilibrium with its surroundings. It keeps some substances at a higher concentration than outside and others at a lower concentration, and it does this by controlling what crosses its membrane and how. The question to ask about any movement across a membrane is simple: does the cell have to spend energy? That single question splits all transport into two families, plus a third route for particles too big to cross any other way.

Learning objectives · 2.5.A and 2.5.B

2.5.A Describe the mechanisms that organisms use to maintain solute and water balance: the selective permeability of membranes allows concentration gradients to form (EK 2.5.A.1); passive transport (EK 2.5.A.2); active transport (EK 2.5.A.3). 2.5.B Describe the mechanisms that organisms use to transport large molecules across the plasma membrane: endocytosis and exocytosis (EK 2.5.B.1).

Concentration gradients

A concentration gradient is a difference in the concentration of a substance between two places. Because the membrane is selectively permeable (lesson 2.4), it can hold different amounts of a solute on its two sides, which forms a gradient. Molecules are always in random motion. When a gradient exists and the substance can cross, more molecules happen to move from the crowded side to the sparse side than the other way. The result, the net movement down the gradient, needs no outside push.

Simple diffusionoutsideinsideFacilitated diffusionoutsideinsideActive transportoutsideinsideATP→ ADP + PHigh to low: no energyHigh to low: proteins, no energyLow to high: needs ATP
Figure 2.5a Passive transport (left and center) moves molecules down their concentration gradient with no input of metabolic energy. Active transport (right) uses ATP and a membrane protein to move molecules against the gradient, from low to high concentration.

Passive transport

Required content · EK 2.5.A.2

Passive transport is the net movement of molecules from regions of high concentration to regions of low concentration without the direct input of metabolic energy.

Passive transport includes simple diffusion (small nonpolar molecules passing through the lipid, such as O2 and CO2), osmosis (the diffusion of water across a selectively permeable membrane; lesson 2.7), and facilitated diffusion (movement through a channel or carrier protein; lesson 2.6). The energy for the movement comes from the motion of the molecules themselves. It continues until the gradient disappears, at which point the molecules still move but there is no net movement (dynamic equilibrium).

Active transport

Required content · EK 2.5.A.3

Active transport requires the direct input of energy to move molecules. In some cases it is used to move molecules from regions of low concentration to regions of high concentration, against the gradient.

Pushing molecules uphill is like pumping water uphill: it takes work. The cell usually does that work with ATP, using a transport protein as the pump (lesson 2.8 gives the sodium-potassium pump as the example). Active transport lets a cell accumulate what it needs (such as the root cell that takes up mineral ions from soil that has very few) and get rid of what it must not hold (such as sodium ions). It also builds up the gradients that passive transport later uses.

FeaturePassive transportActive transport
DirectionDown the concentration gradient (high to low)Often against the gradient (low to high)
EnergyNo direct input of metabolic energyRequires direct input of energy, usually ATP
Membrane proteinNot needed (simple diffusion, osmosis) or channel/carrier (facilitated diffusion)Always needed (a pump or other transport protein)
ResultGradient decreases until equilibriumGradient is created or maintained
ExamplesO2 into a cell, water by osmosis, glucose through a carrierNa+/K+ pump, proton pumps
Worked example · Deciding whether transport is active

Cells are placed in a solution containing 1.0 mM of nutrient X. The table shows the concentration of X inside the cells over time for cells that were untreated and for cells treated with a poison that stops ATP production. Decide how X enters the untreated cells.

Time (min)010203040
Inside, untreated (mM)0.21.83.14.04.2
Inside, ATP poison (mM)0.20.50.81.01.0

Describe. In untreated cells the inside concentration rose from 0.2 mM to 4.2 mM, four times the outside concentration of 1.0 mM. In poisoned cells it rose only to 1.0 mM and stopped.
Interpret. A substance that is moving only by passive transport can never be more concentrated inside than outside; the inside would level off at 1.0 mM, as it did in the poisoned cells. The untreated cells accumulated X against its concentration gradient (from 1.0 outside to 4.2 inside).
Conclude. X enters the untreated cells by active transport. The poison shows that the extra uptake depends on ATP: with no ATP, only passive movement down the gradient remained, so the concentration stopped rising at equilibrium.

Moving large molecules: endocytosis and exocytosis

Proteins, polysaccharides, and particles such as bacteria are far too large to pass through the bilayer or through a channel. The cell moves them in vesicles instead.

Required content · EK 2.5.B.1

The processes of endocytosis and exocytosis require energy to move large substances or large amounts of substances into and out of cells.

  • In endocytosis, the cell takes in large molecules and particulate matter by folding the plasma membrane in on itself and forming new (small) vesicles that engulf material from the external environment.
  • In exocytosis, internal vesicles release material from cells by fusing with the plasma membrane and secreting large molecules from the cell.
Endocytosis: the cell takes material inExocytosis: the cell releases materialparticle outsidemembrane folds in around itpinches off as a vesiclevesicle inside the cellvesicle fuses with membranecontents released outside
Figure 2.5b Bulk transport moves large molecules or large amounts of material and requires energy. In both processes membrane-bound vesicles form from, or fuse with, the plasma membrane, so the total membrane area of the cell stays about the same. In each row the top of the picture is outside the cell.

Endocytosis has several forms. In phagocytosis (“cell eating”) the cell engulfs a large particle, such as a white blood cell taking in a bacterium. In pinocytosis (“cell drinking”) it takes in a small droplet of fluid and its dissolved contents. In receptor-mediated endocytosis receptor proteins bind a specific molecule (such as cholesterol-carrying particles) and the vesicle forms where the receptors cluster. You do not need to memorize these three names for the exam, but they show how the general process is adapted. Exocytosis is how a pancreatic cell releases insulin, how a nerve cell releases neurotransmitters, and how the Golgi’s secretory vesicles (lesson 2.1) deliver their contents out of the cell. Because both processes move membrane in and out, exocytosis adds membrane to the plasma membrane and endocytosis removes it.

Worked example · Classify the transport

Classify each of the following as simple diffusion, facilitated diffusion, active transport, endocytosis, or exocytosis, and give a reason: (a) O2 entering a cell; (b) a white blood cell engulfing a bacterium; (c) a plant root cell taking in nitrate against a gradient; (d) insulin leaving a pancreatic cell.

(a) Simple diffusion. O2 is small and nonpolar, so it crosses the lipid directly down its gradient with no protein or energy.
(b) Endocytosis (phagocytosis). A particle too large for any channel is taken in by a folding of the membrane that forms a vesicle.
(c) Active transport. The ion moves from low to high concentration, which requires energy and a transport protein.
(d) Exocytosis. Insulin is a large protein released when a secretory vesicle fuses with the plasma membrane.

Exam focus
  • The deciding questions: Which direction (down or up the gradient)? Is energy used? Is a protein needed? Answering these three sorts any example.
  • Passive does not mean “nothing is happening.” Molecules still move in both directions; the net movement goes down the gradient.
  • Never write that active transport “moves things from high to low.” Active transport can move substances against the gradient (low to high).
  • Endocytosis and exocytosis require energy, and both use vesicles. Keep the direction straight: endo = in, exo = out.
  • A graph in which a substance is concentrated higher inside than outside, or in which uptake stops with an ATP inhibitor, signals active transport.
Practice
  1. State two differences between passive and active transport.
    Show answer

    Passive transport moves molecules down their concentration gradient (high to low) and needs no direct input of metabolic energy. Active transport requires direct input of energy (usually ATP) and a membrane protein, and can move molecules against their gradient (low to high).

  2. A student claims that diffusion stops when a concentration gradient disappears. Evaluate the claim.
    Show answer

    The claim is partly wrong. Molecules keep moving randomly in both directions at equilibrium, but the movements balance, so there is no net movement. What stops is the net movement, not the motion of the molecules.

  3. The concentration of potassium ions is 140 mM inside a cell and 5 mM outside, yet the cell keeps taking in more potassium. Name the type of transport and justify.
    Show answer

    Active transport. Potassium ions are moving from low concentration (5 mM) to high concentration (140 mM), against the gradient, which cannot happen by passive transport and requires the direct input of energy and a transport protein.

  4. Describe how a cell releases a protein hormone that is too large to cross the membrane, and name the process.
    Show answer

    The hormone is packaged in a vesicle from the Golgi. The vesicle moves to the plasma membrane and fuses with it, opening to the outside and releasing the hormone. The process is exocytosis, and it requires energy.

  5. In a graph of an experiment, the uptake of substance Y into cells is fast at 25 °C but nearly stops when the cells are put in a solution containing a cyanide-like inhibitor of ATP production, yet the concentration outside is higher than inside. A student concludes that Y enters by active transport. Explain what is wrong with the reasoning and what additional evidence would test the conclusion.
    Show answer

    If the concentration outside is higher than inside, Y is moving down its gradient, which is consistent with passive transport, so the gradient direction does not support active transport. The inhibitor result could be an indirect effect (ATP may be needed for other cell processes). Better evidence would be to show uptake continuing until the inside concentration exceeds the outside concentration (against the gradient), or to show that Y uptake depends on a specific transport protein that requires ATP.

  6. A cell is treated with a drug that stops it from making new vesicles. Predict the effect on its ability to secrete a protein and on the area of its plasma membrane over time, and justify the prediction.
    Show answer

    The cell could no longer secrete the protein by exocytosis, because exocytosis needs vesicles. Since exocytosis also adds membrane to the plasma membrane, and if endocytosis continued to remove it, the plasma membrane area would gradually decrease.

Lesson 2.6 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.6

Facilitated diffusion

Glucose is the fuel of almost every cell, yet it cannot cross a lipid bilayer by itself. Sodium and potassium ions, which cells use to carry electrical signals, cannot either. These substances still move across membranes without any ATP, because the cell has built protein pathways for them. This is facilitated diffusion: passive transport, but with help from a membrane protein.

Learning objective · 2.6.A

Explain how the structure of a molecule affects its ability to pass through the plasma membrane. EK 2.6.A.1: facilitated diffusion requires transport or channel proteins to enable the movement of charged ions. EK 2.6.A.2: it enables the movement of large polar molecules through membranes with no energy input, down the concentration gradient. EK 2.6.A.3: aquaporins transport large quantities of water.

Ion channeloutsideinsideCarrier proteinoutsideinsideAquaporinoutsideinsideNa+ or K+ pass througha water-filled porebinds glucoseshape change releases itwater crosses in single file,very fast, down its gradient
Figure 2.6a Facilitated diffusion uses proteins but no ATP. Channels let charged ions pass through a pore; carriers bind a molecule and change shape; aquaporins carry large quantities of water. In every case the net movement is from high concentration to low.

Why a protein is needed

From lesson 2.4, the nonpolar interior of the bilayer blocks ions and large polar molecules. A transport protein solves this by offering a different environment: its interior surface has polar or charged R groups that attract the substance, so the molecule passes through the protein and never meets the nonpolar tails. The movement is still diffusion, so it goes from high concentration to low concentration and uses no ATP.

Required content · EK 2.6.A.1 to 2.6.A.3
  • Channel proteins have a pore that lets charged ions such as Na+ and K+ cross the membrane. Many are gated: they open or close in response to a signal, such as a change in voltage or the binding of a molecule.
  • Carrier (transport) proteins bind a specific molecule on one side, change shape, and release it on the other side. This is how large polar molecules such as glucose cross.
  • Aquaporins are channels for water. They move large quantities of water across membranes much faster than the lipid alone allows (a single aquaporin can pass billions of water molecules per second).
  • The movement of ions can make the two sides of the membrane electrically different, so membranes may become polarized by the movement of ions across them.

Specificity and saturation

A transport protein is specific: the shape and chemistry of its binding site or pore fit one substance or a small group, in the same way an enzyme fits its substrate (lesson 3.1). A glucose carrier will not carry an amino acid, and a K+ channel passes K+ far better than the slightly smaller Na+. Because there is only a limited number of proteins in a membrane, facilitated diffusion has a maximum rate. Simple diffusion has none: there is no protein to fill up.

02460246810Concentration gradient (arbitrary units)Rate of transportmaximum rate (all carriers busy)facilitated diffusionsimple diffusion
Figure 2.6b Simple diffusion increases in direct proportion to the gradient. Facilitated diffusion levels off because there is a limited number of transport proteins; once every protein is working, a bigger gradient cannot raise the rate. (Model curve: rate = 5S/(1.5 + S) for facilitated, 0.25S for simple.)
Gradient (arbitrary units)1246810
Simple diffusion rate0.250.501.001.502.002.50
Facilitated diffusion rate2.002.863.644.004.214.35
Worked example · Explaining a saturation curve

Use the table to describe how each type of transport responds to an increasing gradient, and explain the difference in terms of membrane structure. (The values are from a model: facilitated rate \(= 5S/(1.5 + S)\) and simple rate \(= 0.25S\).)

Describe. The simple diffusion rate increases by the same amount each time the gradient increases by the same amount: 0.25 at a gradient of 1, 1.00 at 4, 2.50 at 10 (a straight line through zero; the rate is proportional to the gradient). The facilitated rate rises steeply at first (2.00 at 1, 3.64 at 4), then increases more slowly (4.00 at 6, 4.35 at 10), and approaches a maximum near 5.
Explain. Simple diffusion passes through the lipid itself, which has room for an unlimited number of molecules, so doubling the gradient doubles the rate. Facilitated diffusion depends on a limited number of transport proteins. At a low gradient, many are free and the rate rises quickly. At a high gradient, all of the proteins are busy and adding more substance cannot speed up the movement: the transport is saturated.
Compare. At the highest gradient (10) the simple diffusion rate (2.50) is still rising, but the facilitated rate (4.35) has leveled off; a cell that needs fast uptake at a low gradient depends on facilitated diffusion.

Worked example · Predict the effect of a change

(a) A cell is given extra genes for a glucose carrier so it makes twice as many carriers. Predict the effect on glucose uptake. (b) A mutation changes the shape of the pore of a K+ channel so it no longer opens. Predict the effect.

(a) The maximum rate of glucose uptake increases (about doubles), because there are more proteins to carry glucose. At a low glucose concentration the uptake also increases. The movement is still down the gradient and still uses no ATP.
(b) K+ cannot cross by its channel, so K+ that would normally leave the cell down its gradient stays inside. The membrane would not become polarized in the normal way, and a cell that relies on the flow of K+ (such as a nerve or muscle cell) would not work properly. Because K+ is charged, it cannot cross the lipid bilayer to take another route.

Worked example · Water movement and aquaporins

Red blood cells and a lipid-only vesicle are placed in pure water. The red blood cells swell and burst in seconds; the vesicle swells much more slowly. Explain the difference.

Explanation. Water crosses a pure lipid bilayer slowly because it is polar, although it can squeeze past the tails in small amounts (lesson 2.4). Red blood cell membranes contain aquaporins, which transport large quantities of water. Water therefore flows into the red blood cells by osmosis much faster, and the cells swell and burst (lesson 2.7).

Exam focus
  • Facilitated diffusion is passive: no ATP, down the gradient. The protein only provides a pathway.
  • Match the substance to the protein: ions use channels; large polar molecules such as glucose use carriers; water in bulk uses aquaporins.
  • A rate curve that levels off means the proteins are saturated. Say “a limited number of transport proteins.”
  • Do not confuse a carrier that changes shape with active transport. If no ATP is used and the movement is down the gradient, it is facilitated diffusion.
  • For a “predict” question, name the protein that changed, then state what substance can no longer cross and what that does to the cell.
Practice
  1. Explain why sodium ions need a channel protein to cross a membrane even though they are small.
    Show answer

    Sodium ions are charged, and the nonpolar hydrocarbon tails in the interior of the membrane prevent the movement of ions, however small. A channel protein provides a polar, water-filled pore through which the ion can cross without touching the tails.

  2. Describe how a carrier protein moves glucose into a cell, and state whether ATP is needed.
    Show answer

    Glucose binds to a specific site on the carrier on the outside of the membrane. The carrier changes shape and releases glucose on the inside. The movement is down the concentration gradient, so no ATP is needed (facilitated diffusion).

  3. Why does the rate of facilitated diffusion level off as the concentration of the transported molecule increases, while the rate of simple diffusion does not?
    Show answer

    There is a limited number of transport proteins. When they are all in use (saturated), a larger concentration cannot increase the rate. Simple diffusion goes through the lipid itself and does not depend on a limited number of proteins, so its rate keeps rising in proportion to the gradient.

  4. A drug blocks the aquaporins in kidney cells. Predict the effect on water movement across the membrane and justify it.
    Show answer

    Water would cross the membrane much more slowly, because aquaporins carry large quantities of water. Only the small amount that passes between the phospholipids would still cross. The cells could not move water quickly in response to a change in solute concentration.

  5. Glucose is at a concentration of 5 mM outside a cell and 1 mM inside. A cell with glucose carriers takes it in without using ATP. What would happen if the concentration inside rose above the concentration outside, and which type of transport would be needed for the cell to keep taking in glucose?
    Show answer

    Net movement by facilitated diffusion would stop (and could reverse), because it only goes from high to low concentration. To keep accumulating glucose against its gradient the cell would need active transport, which uses energy.

  6. Two proteins are found in a membrane. Protein A passes only K+ and is open only when the membrane voltage changes. Protein B binds glucose and changes shape. Identify each and explain what they have in common and one difference.
    Show answer

    A is a gated ion channel; B is a carrier protein. Both are used in facilitated diffusion: they are specific for their substance, work without ATP, and move substances down their gradient. A difference: the channel provides a pore that the ion passes through, while the carrier binds the molecule and changes shape to move it across.

Lesson 2.7 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.7

Tonicity and osmoregulation

Put a freshwater fish in the ocean, or a slug in salt, and the result is the same: water leaves the body. Water is the most abundant molecule in every cell, and it crosses membranes freely, so the direction it moves decides whether a cell swells, shrinks, or stays healthy. This lesson gives you the vocabulary to predict that direction and the equation to calculate it.

Learning objectives · 2.7.A and 2.7.B

2.7.A Explain how concentration gradients affect the movement of molecules across membranes (EK 2.7.A.1). 2.7.B Explain how osmoregulatory mechanisms contribute to the health and survival of organisms (EK 2.7.B.1 and 2.7.B.2).

Osmosis and tonicity

Osmosis is the diffusion of water across a selectively permeable membrane. Water moves toward the side with the higher solute concentration, because that side has proportionally less free water. Solutes such as sucrose or salt cannot cross the membrane easily, so the water is the one that moves. Tonicity describes how a solution outside the cell compares with the inside of the cell:

Required content · EK 2.7.A.1
  • An external environment can be hypotonic (lower solute concentration than the cell), hypertonic (higher solute concentration than the cell), or isotonic (equal solute concentration) to the internal environment of the cell.
  • Movement of water can also be described as moving from hypotonic to hypertonic regions.
  • Water moves by osmosis from regions of high water potential to regions of low water potential.
Hypotonic solutionless solute than the cellIsotonic solutionsame solute as the cellHypertonic solutionmore solute than the cellswells, may lysestays the sameshrivels (crenation)turgid (firm)flaccid (limp)plasmolyzedBlue arrows show the net movement of water. Green outline = cell wall.
Figure 2.7a Water moves by osmosis toward the side with more solute (lower water potential). In a hypotonic solution water enters the cell: an animal cell swells and may burst, while a plant cell is held by its wall and becomes turgid. In a hypertonic solution water leaves: an animal cell shrinks, and in a plant cell the membrane pulls away from the wall (plasmolysis).

The cell wall changes how the same situation looks. An animal cell has no wall, so in a hypotonic solution it keeps taking in water and may lyse (burst); in a hypertonic solution it loses water and shrivels. A plant cell in a hypotonic solution takes in water until the wall pushes back, and the firm, swollen cell is turgid, the healthy condition that holds a plant upright. In an isotonic solution a plant cell is flaccid, and the plant wilts. In a hypertonic solution the membrane pulls away from the wall: plasmolysis.

Water potential

Tonicity compares two solutions in words. Water potential (\(\Psi\), the Greek letter psi, in bars) measures the tendency of water to move, so it can be calculated. Water always moves from higher water potential to lower water potential. Pure water in an open container has \(\Psi = 0\), and everything else is lower (negative).

Equations on the AP exam

\[ \Psi = \Psi_P + \Psi_S \qquad\qquad \Psi_S = -iCRT \]

  • \(\Psi_P\) is the pressure potential: physical pressure on the water. In an open container it is 0. In a turgid plant cell it is positive (the wall squeezes the contents).
  • \(\Psi_S\) is the solute potential. Dissolved solutes lower the water potential, so \(\Psi_S\) is always negative or zero.
  • \(i\) is the ionization constant: the number of particles a molecule makes in water (1 for sucrose and glucose; 2 for NaCl, which splits into Na+ and Cl−).
  • \(C\) is the molar concentration (mol/L). \(R\) is the pressure constant, \(0.0831\ \text{L·bar/(mol·K)}\). \(T\) is the temperature in kelvin (\(^\circ\text{C} + 273\)).
Worked example · Calculating solute potential

Calculate \(\Psi_S\) at 22 °C for (a) 0.30 M sucrose and (b) 0.15 M NaCl. Compare the results.

Temperature. \(T = 22 + 273 = 295\) K, so \(RT = 0.0831 \times 295 = 24.51\) L·bar/mol.
(a) Sucrose (\(i = 1\)): \(\Psi_S = -(1)(0.30)(24.51) = -7.35\) bars.
(b) NaCl (\(i = 2\)): \(\Psi_S = -(2)(0.15)(24.51) = -7.35\) bars.
Compare. The two solutions have the same solute potential, because 0.15 M NaCl gives 0.30 M of dissolved particles (0.15 M Na+ plus 0.15 M Cl−), the same as 0.30 M sucrose. If they were separated by a selectively permeable membrane, there would be no net movement of water. Remember to include \(i\): forgetting it is the most common mistake.

Worked example · Which way does the water move?

Two open beakers are separated by a membrane that passes water but not sucrose. Side A holds 0.40 M sucrose; side B holds 0.20 M sucrose. The temperature is 22 °C. Find \(\Psi\) on each side and state the direction of net water movement.

Side A. \(\Psi_P = 0\) (open). \(\Psi_S = -(1)(0.40)(24.51) = -9.81\) bars, so \(\Psi = 0 + (-9.81) = -9.81\) bars.
Side B. \(\Psi_S = -(1)(0.20)(24.51) = -4.90\) bars, so \(\Psi = -4.90\) bars.
Direction. Water moves from higher water potential to lower: from B (\(-4.90\) bars) to A (\(-9.81\) bars). In words: from the more dilute (hypotonic) side to the more concentrated (hypertonic) side. Side A will rise in volume.

Worked example · A plant cell and the role of pressure

A plant cell has \(\Psi_S = -7.0\) bars and \(\Psi_P = +2.0\) bars. It is placed in a beaker of pure water (\(\Psi = 0\)). Describe what happens and what \(\Psi_P\) will be when water stops entering.

Start. The cell has \(\Psi = 2.0 + (-7.0) = -5.0\) bars. The water outside has \(\Psi = 0\), higher than the cell, so water enters the cell.
As water enters. The cell swells against its wall, so \(\Psi_P\) rises. \(\Psi_S\) becomes slightly less negative as the cell dilutes, but the main change is the pressure.
At equilibrium. Net movement stops when the cell’s \(\Psi\) equals the water outside, 0 bars. If \(\Psi_S\) stays near \(-7.0\) bars, \(\Psi_P\) must be about \(+7.0\) bars (\(\Psi = 7.0 + (-7.0) = 0\)). The cell is turgid, and the wall, not an animal-style membrane, keeps it from bursting.

Using water potential in the lab: the potato core

A standard investigation measures the mass of potato cores before and after soaking in sucrose solutions. A core gains mass in a solution with a higher water potential than the cell sap and loses mass in one with a lower water potential. The concentration at which there is no change in mass is the solution that is isotonic to the potato cells.

−30−20−100+10+200.00.20.40.60.81.0Sucrose concentration of the bathing solution (M)Change in mass (%)x-intercept ≈ 0.29 Mgains mass: water entersloses mass: water leaves
Figure 2.7b Percent change in mass of potato cores after hours in sucrose solutions. At the x-intercept (about 0.29 M) a core neither gains nor loses water, so the solution is isotonic to the potato cells and the solute potential inside the cells equals that of the solution.
Worked example · Finding the solute potential of potato cells

Use the graph (percent change: +18 at 0 M, +6 at 0.2 M, −7 at 0.4 M, −17 at 0.6 M, −24 at 0.8 M, −28 at 1.0 M) to estimate the molarity of potato cell sap and its \(\Psi_S\) at 22 °C.

Find the x-intercept. The line crosses zero between 0.2 M (+6) and 0.4 M (−7). By interpolation: \(0.2 + 0.2 \times 6/13 = 0.29\) M.
Interpret. At 0.29 M sucrose, the core neither gains nor loses water, so its cell sap has the same solute potential as the solution.
Calculate. \(\Psi_S = -(1)(0.29)(24.51) = -7.1\) bars. (The pressure potential of the soaked-then-weighed core is taken as 0, so \(\Psi_S\) equals \(\Psi\) of the cell sap.)
Mass data. At 0 M (pure water), the core gained 18 percent because water entered the cells (the cell sap has a lower water potential than pure water). At 1.0 M the core lost 28 percent as water left.

Osmoregulation

Required content · EK 2.7.B.1 and 2.7.B.2
  • Growth and homeostasis are maintained by the constant movement of molecules across membranes.
  • Osmoregulation maintains water balance and allows organisms to control their internal solute composition and water potential. Water moves from regions of low osmolarity (solute concentration) to regions of high osmolarity.

Every organism has a way of staying in water balance. A Paramecium living in fresh water is hypertonic to its surroundings, so water floods in constantly. Its contractile vacuole collects the excess and pumps it out using energy, and without it the cell would burst. A plant cell uses its large central vacuole and its cell wall to hold turgor pressure, which keeps a leaf firm. In vertebrates the kidney adjusts how much water to keep or lose, and a hormone (ADH) tells the kidney to retain water when the blood becomes too concentrated (Unit 4 returns to this feedback loop).

Exam focus
  • Memorize the direction: water moves from high \(\Psi\) to low \(\Psi\), which is from hypotonic (low solute) to hypertonic (high solute). Pure water has \(\Psi = 0\); solutes make it negative.
  • In \(\Psi_S = -iCRT\), do not forget the negative sign and the \(i\). Use \(T\) in kelvin. Give the answer in bars.
  • In an open beaker \(\Psi_P = 0\). A turgid plant cell has a positive \(\Psi_P\). A plant cell does not burst because the wall supplies the pressure.
  • Tonicity is always described relative to the cell. “The solution is hypertonic” means it has more solute than the cell, so the cell loses water.
  • For a percent-change-in-mass graph, the x-intercept is the solution that is isotonic to the tissue.
  • Show the formula, substitute, and include units. Graphs need labeled axes with units, accurate points, and a trend line.
Practice
  1. A red blood cell is placed in a solution that has a lower solute concentration than the cell. Name the type of solution, describe the direction of water movement, and predict the result.
    Show answer

    The solution is hypotonic to the cell. Water moves by osmosis into the cell (from high to low water potential). The cell swells and, because it has no wall, it may burst (lyse).

  2. Calculate the solute potential of 0.50 M glucose at 25 °C. (\(R = 0.0831\) L·bar/(mol·K).)
    Show answer

    \(T = 25 + 273 = 298\) K. \(\Psi_S = -iCRT = -(1)(0.50)(0.0831)(298) = -12.4\) bars.

  3. Calculate the solute potential of 0.20 M NaCl at 25 °C and explain why it is different from that of 0.20 M glucose.
    Show answer

    \(\Psi_S = -(2)(0.20)(0.0831)(298) = -9.9\) bars. For 0.20 M glucose it would be \(-4.95\) bars. NaCl separates into two ions (\(i = 2\)), so it makes twice as many dissolved particles per mole and lowers the water potential twice as much.

  4. Solution X has \(\Psi = -6.0\) bars and solution Y has \(\Psi = -3.5\) bars; they are separated by a membrane permeable only to water. State which direction water moves and which side becomes more dilute.
    Show answer

    Water moves from Y (higher water potential, \(-3.5\)) to X (lower, \(-6.0\)). The X side takes in water, so X becomes more dilute and increases in volume; Y becomes more concentrated.

  5. A plant cell has \(\Psi_S = -4.0\) bars. It is in equilibrium with an open beaker of a solution with \(\Psi = -1.5\) bars. Find the cell’s \(\Psi_P\).
    Show answer

    At equilibrium the cell’s \(\Psi\) equals that of the solution, \(-1.5\) bars. \(\Psi = \Psi_P + \Psi_S\), so \(\Psi_P = -1.5 - (-4.0) = +2.5\) bars.

  6. Celery sticks placed in a salty solution become limp. Explain this in terms of tonicity and water potential.
    Show answer

    The salty solution is hypertonic to the celery cells and has a lower water potential. Water leaves the cells by osmosis, so the central vacuoles shrink, the turgor pressure (\(\Psi_P\)) falls, and the cell membranes may pull away from the wall (plasmolysis). Without turgor the tissue loses its firmness.

Lesson 2.8 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.8

Mechanisms of transport: active transport and electrochemical gradients

Passive transport can only run downhill. But a cell needs to hold sodium low and potassium high, absorb nutrients that are scarce outside, and keep an electrical charge across its membrane. None of this can happen by diffusion alone. The cell has to do work, and the main way it does so is to spend ATP on a pump. This lesson covers the pump that every animal cell depends on.

Learning objective · 2.8.A

Describe the processes that allow ions and other molecules to move across membranes. EK 2.8.A.1: metabolic energy (such as that from ATP) is required for active transport of molecules and ions across the membrane and to establish and maintain electrochemical gradients. Membrane proteins are necessary for active transport, and the Na+/K+ pump and ATPase contribute to the maintenance of the membrane potential.

What an electrochemical gradient is

An ion has two things that push it across a membrane: the difference in its concentration and the difference in electrical charge between the two sides. Together these make the electrochemical gradient. A positive ion is pulled toward a negative side even if its concentration is already higher there. The voltage across a membrane is called the membrane potential; in most animal cells the inside is negative relative to the outside. Pumps that move ions help to set it up, and the gradients they build store energy, as water behind a dam does, that the cell later uses for other work.

The sodium-potassium pump

Required content · EK 2.8.A.1
  • Active transport needs metabolic energy such as ATP.
  • Membrane proteins are necessary for active transport.
  • The Na+/K+ pump (an ATPase) contributes to the maintenance of the membrane potential.
1. Open to the insideoutsideinsideNaNaNaATP → ADP + P3 Na+ bind; ATP adds P2. Shape changeoutsideinsidePNaNaNaNa+ released outside3. Open to the outsideoutsideinsideKK2 K+ bind, P leaves, K+ in
Figure 2.8a Each cycle uses one ATP to move 3 Na+ out of the cell and 2 K+ into it, both against their concentration gradients. The unequal exchange (3 positive charges out, 2 in) helps make the inside of the cell negative relative to the outside.

The pump is a transmembrane protein that is also an enzyme: an ATPase, because it hydrolyzes ATP. In each cycle it carries three Na+ out of the cell and two K+ into the cell. Here is the sequence:

  1. Three sodium ions from the cytosol bind to the pump, which is open to the inside.
  2. ATP is hydrolyzed and its phosphate group attaches to the pump (phosphorylation). The added phosphate changes the protein’s shape so it opens to the outside, and the sodium ions are released into the extracellular fluid.
  3. Two potassium ions from outside bind to the pump. This causes the phosphate group to be released, and the pump returns to its original shape, opening to the inside and releasing the potassium ions into the cytosol.

Both ions are being moved up their concentration gradients (sodium is already higher outside; potassium is already higher inside), which is why ATP is needed. Because 3 positive charges leave while only 2 enter, each cycle makes the inside slightly more negative, which contributes to the membrane potential. The pump also keeps the cell from swelling: by pumping out more particles than it takes in, it prevents solutes, and the water that follows them, from building up inside.

Worked example · Counting what a pump does

A patch of membrane has 2,000,000 sodium-potassium pumps, and each completes 50 cycles per second. Calculate the number of ATP molecules used, Na+ ions moved out, K+ ions moved in, and net positive charges removed per second.

Cycles. \(2.0 \times 10^6 \times 50 = 1.0 \times 10^8\) cycles per second.
ATP. One ATP per cycle, so \(1.0 \times 10^8\) ATP per second.
Na+ out. \(3 \times 1.0 \times 10^8 = 3.0 \times 10^8\) ions per second.
K+ in. \(2 \times 1.0 \times 10^8 = 2.0 \times 10^8\) ions per second.
Net charge. \(3 - 2 = 1\) positive charge removed per cycle, so \(1.0 \times 10^8\) charges per second leave the cell. This is the “electrogenic” part of the pump.

Worked example · Predict the effect of stopping the pump

A poison stops ATP production in a nerve cell. Predict what happens to the Na+ and K+ gradients and to the membrane potential, and justify.

Prediction. Without ATP the pump stops. Na+ slowly leaks into the cell (down its gradient through channels) and K+ leaks out, so both gradients run down. The membrane potential falls toward zero, and the nerve cell can no longer send signals. Because Na+ builds up inside and the cell holds more solute, water also tends to enter, and the cell can swell.
Justification. Gradients are not permanent; they must be rebuilt by active transport all the time. The Na+/K+ pump uses ATP to restore the gradients as quickly as passive channels run them down.

Using the gradient: cotransport

An established gradient is a store of energy that can be used for other work. In cotransport (secondary active transport), a protein couples the downhill movement of one substance to the uphill movement of another. For example, a carrier in intestinal cells brings Na+ into the cell down its gradient and brings glucose in along with it, even when there is more glucose inside than outside. The cell does not spend ATP on the glucose carrier directly; the sodium gradient, which the Na+/K+ pump keeps up with ATP, supplies the energy. In plants, a proton pump uses ATP to push H+ out of the cell, and the resulting gradient is used to bring in nutrients such as sucrose by cotransport. (The exam requires the direct case, but this extension shows why a pump matters beyond itself.)

Comparing the transport proteins

ProteinEnergy neededDirectionExample
ChannelNoDown the gradientK+ channel, aquaporin
Carrier (facilitated diffusion)NoDown the gradientGlucose carrier in red blood cells
Pump (primary active transport)Yes: ATPAgainst the gradientNa+/K+ ATPase, proton pump
Cotransporter (secondary active transport)Uses a gradient made by a pumpOne substance down, one upNa+-glucose cotransporter
Exam focus
  • Active transport needs a membrane protein and energy. If a question says “against the gradient,” the answer needs ATP and a pump.
  • Know the numbers: the Na+/K+ pump moves 3 Na+ out and 2 K+ in per ATP. Sodium out, potassium in.
  • ATPase means an enzyme that hydrolyzes ATP. The phosphate transferred to the pump is what changes its shape.
  • The pump helps maintain the membrane potential and the gradients that other transport depends on.
  • Gradients run down without ATP, so a drug that stops ATP production or blocks the pump causes the gradients to collapse.
  • Distinguish this from facilitated diffusion: both use proteins, but only active transport needs ATP and can move substances uphill.
Practice
  1. Describe the net movement of ions in one cycle of the sodium-potassium pump.
    Show answer

    Three Na+ are moved out of the cell and two K+ are moved into the cell, using the energy of one ATP. Both ions move against their concentration gradients.

  2. Explain the role of ATP in the sodium-potassium pump.
    Show answer

    ATP is hydrolyzed and its phosphate group attaches to the pump, changing the protein’s shape so it can release the sodium ions outside. The energy is needed because both ions are being moved against their concentration gradients.

  3. A pump completes 100 cycles per second. Calculate how many sodium ions, potassium ions, and net positive charges it moves in one minute.
    Show answer

    Cycles in 60 s: \(100 \times 60 = 6000\). Na+ out: \(3 \times 6000 = 18{,}000\). K+ in: \(2 \times 6000 = 12{,}000\). Net charge removed: \(1 \times 6000 = 6000\) positive charges.

  4. Describe two ways an electrochemical gradient differs from a simple concentration gradient.
    Show answer

    An electrochemical gradient includes both the difference in concentration of an ion and the difference in electrical charge across the membrane, so a charged ion is affected by both. A simple concentration gradient involves only the difference in concentration. Also, an ion can move “uphill” in concentration but still “downhill” electrically.

  5. Cells in a tissue sample are chilled to 2 °C, which greatly slows the production of ATP. Predict the effect on the sodium and potassium concentrations inside the cells over the next hour, and justify.
    Show answer

    Na+ would gradually rise inside the cells and K+ would fall, because the pump needs ATP to move them against their gradients and without it the ions leak down their gradients through channels. (Cold also slows the leak somewhat, so the change is slower than it would be at body temperature.)

  6. Compare facilitated diffusion of glucose and cotransport of glucose with sodium. Which can accumulate glucose to a higher concentration inside a cell than outside, and why?
    Show answer

    Cotransport can. Facilitated diffusion goes only down the gradient, so the inside can never exceed the outside. In cotransport, the downhill movement of Na+ (the gradient maintained by the Na+/K+ pump using ATP) is coupled to the uphill movement of glucose, so glucose can be concentrated against its own gradient.

Lesson 2.9 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.9

Cell compartmentalization

Imagine a kitchen where the dishwasher’s detergent, the bleach, and the food were all in one open bucket. Nothing would work. A eukaryotic cell avoids this by dividing its interior into rooms, each bounded by a membrane, where a particular set of reactions can run under the right conditions. This is compartmentalization, and it is the main reason eukaryotic cells can be thousands of times larger than bacteria and still work.

Learning objectives · 2.9.A and 2.9.B

2.9.A Describe the membrane-bound structures of the eukaryotic cell. EK 2.9.A.1: membranes and membrane-bound organelles in eukaryotic cells compartmentalize intracellular metabolic processes and specific enzymatic reactions. 2.9.B Explain how internal membranes and membrane-bound organelles contribute to compartmentalization of eukaryotic cell functions. EK 2.9.B.1: internal membranes facilitate cellular processes by minimizing competing interactions and by increasing the surface area where reactions can occur.

Eukaryotic cellLysosomepH about 5MitochondrionpH about 8Cytosol: pH about 7.2What compartments doKeep different conditions indifferent places (pH, ions)Concentrate enzymes andsubstrates so reactions are fastSeparate reactions that wouldinterfere with each otherAdd membrane surface wherereactions can occur
Figure 2.9a Compartments let one cell run many reactions at once. The enzymes of the lysosome work in acid, which would damage the rest of the cell, so they are kept inside a membrane. (pH values are approximate.)

Why compartments help

BenefitHow it worksExample
Different conditions in different placesA membrane can hold a different pH, ion concentration, or enzyme set on each side (using the pumps of lesson 2.8)The lysosome stays acidic (about pH 5) while the cytosol is about pH 7.2
Minimizing competing interactionsReactions or enzymes that would interfere with each other are kept apartDigestive enzymes are sealed inside lysosomes so they do not digest the cell’s own proteins
Concentrating reactantsThe same number of molecules in a smaller volume collide more oftenRespiratory enzymes in the mitochondrion
Increasing surface areaMembranes hold enzymes and carry out reactions; more membrane means more reactions at onceCristae of the mitochondrion; the extensive ER
Efficient transport and quality controlProducts move in vesicles from one compartment to the next, such as ER to GolgiThe endomembrane system (lesson 2.1)

Membrane-bound structures to know

The eukaryotic cell has these membrane-bound structures (a review of lesson 2.1 through the lens of compartments): the nucleus (a double membrane, the nuclear envelope, separates DNA from the cytosol); the ER and Golgi complex; lysosomes; vacuoles; mitochondria and chloroplasts (double membranes with a third compartment inside); and the plasma membrane itself. Ribosomes are not membrane-bound.

Worked example · Increasing the surface area for reactions

Model a mitochondrion as a cylinder with a radius of 0.5 \(\mu\)m and a length of 2.0 \(\mu\)m. Its inner membrane, if smooth, would follow the surface of the cylinder. Now suppose the inner membrane has 20 flat folds (cristae), each a disc of radius 0.4 \(\mu\)m with two faces. Calculate the area of the smooth membrane and the total area with folds, and state how much the folds add.

Smooth cylinder. \(SA = 2\pi r h + 2\pi r^2 = 2\pi(0.5)(2.0) + 2\pi(0.5)^2 = 6.28 + 1.57 = 7.85\ \mu\text{m}^2\).
One fold. Two faces, each \(\pi r^2 = \pi(0.4)^2 = 0.503\ \mu\text{m}^2\), so \(2 \times 0.503 = 1.005\ \mu\text{m}^2\). Twenty folds add \(20 \times 1.005 = 20.1\ \mu\text{m}^2\).
Total. \(7.85 + 20.1 = 28.0\ \mu\text{m}^2\), which is \(28.0 / 7.85 = 3.6\) times the smooth area.
Meaning. The ATP-making proteins sit in the inner membrane, so 3.6 times as much membrane can hold about 3.6 times as many of them in the same organelle. (This simple model ignores the thickness of the folds and their sharing of the cylinder wall.)

Worked example · Concentrating enzymes

A cell has a volume of 1000 \(\mu\)m\(^3\) and contains 500 molecules of an enzyme. (a) Calculate the enzyme density if the molecules are spread through the whole cell. (b) Calculate it if they are all inside an organelle of volume 10 \(\mu\)m\(^3\).

(a) \(500 / 1000 = 0.5\) molecules per \(\mu\text{m}^3\).
(b) \(500 / 10 = 50\) molecules per \(\mu\text{m}^3\).
Comparison. The compartment holds the enzyme at 100 times the density, so the enzyme meets its substrate (also gathered in the compartment) far more often, and the reaction goes faster with the same number of molecules.

Worked example · Predict a disruption

A mutation makes the lysosomal membrane leaky, so its enzymes escape into the cytosol. Predict what happens and justify.

Prediction. The cell would be damaged, but less than if the enzymes were fully active. The hydrolytic enzymes would begin to digest cell proteins and other molecules, so the cell may die. Cytosol is near pH 7.2, and lysosomal enzymes work best in acid (about pH 5), so their activity would be lower than inside the lysosome, which gives the cell some protection.
Justification. A membrane keeps the enzymes apart from molecules they would destroy, so removing it removes the isolation (minimizing competing interactions) and also the special pH that the compartment kept.

Exam focus
  • The two reasons the CED requires: internal membranes minimize competing interactions and increase the surface area where reactions can occur. Use these words.
  • For each organelle, tie the membrane to the job: cristae provide area for ATP production; the lysosome keeps digestive enzymes away from the cytosol.
  • If asked what happens when a membrane is damaged, answer with what mixes that should be separate.
  • Calculations may ask for surface area or concentration changes: show the formula, substitute, and state units.
Practice
  1. State two ways internal membranes help a eukaryotic cell carry out its functions.
    Show answer

    They minimize competing interactions by keeping incompatible reactions or enzymes separate, and they increase the surface area where reactions can occur (for example, the folded inner mitochondrial membrane or the ER).

  2. Explain why the lysosome’s enzymes would be less harmful to the cell if they leaked into the cytosol than if the cytosol also had a pH of 5.
    Show answer

    Lysosomal enzymes work best in acid. The cytosol is near neutral (about pH 7.2), so the enzymes would be much less active there. The lysosome’s membrane maintains the acid conditions, which is an example of compartments allowing different conditions in different places.

  3. A chloroplast has a surface area for its thylakoid membranes of 120 \(\mu\text{m}^2\) in a 10 \(\mu\text{m}^3\) space. Another has 60 \(\mu\text{m}^2\) in the same space. Which can carry out more photosynthetic reactions in the membrane, and why?
    Show answer

    The first one. Light-capturing proteins and the ATP-making machinery are embedded in the thylakoid membranes, so twice the membrane area can hold about twice as many of them and carry out more reactions at once.

  4. An enzyme is made of 800 molecules in a cell of 2000 \(\mu\text{m}^3\). Calculate the enzyme density, then the density if all of it is inside an organelle of 20 \(\mu\text{m}^3\), and the factor of increase.
    Show answer

    In the whole cell: \(800 / 2000 = 0.4\) per \(\mu\text{m}^3\). In the organelle: \(800 / 20 = 40\) per \(\mu\text{m}^3\). The increase is \(40 / 0.4 = 100\) times.

  5. Name two structures that are membrane-bound in a eukaryotic cell but have no counterpart in a typical bacterium, and one structure found in both.
    Show answer

    Any two of: nucleus, endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi complex, mitochondria, lysosomes, chloroplasts. Found in both: ribosomes (and the plasma membrane).

Lesson 2.10 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.10

Origins of cell compartmentalization

Prokaryotes lived alone on Earth for well over a billion years. Then a new kind of cell appeared with a nucleus and a set of internal compartments. Where did those compartments come from? The answer is one of the best-supported ideas in biology, and it also links this unit to evolution (Unit 7): two of the organelles you studied in this unit were once independent organisms.

Learning objective · 2.10.A

Describe similarities and/or differences in compartmentalization between prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. EK 2.10.A.1: membrane-bound organelles such as mitochondria and chloroplasts evolved from once free-living prokaryotic cells via endosymbiosis. EK 2.10.A.2: prokaryotes typically lack internal membrane-bound organelles but have internal regions with specialized structures and functions. EK 2.10.A.3: eukaryotic cells maintain internal membranes that partition the cell into specialized regions.

Prokaryotes and eukaryotes compared

Prokaryotic cellCell wall and plasma membraneDNA in a nucleoid regionRibosomes, no organellesCircular DNA plasmidsEukaryotic cellNucleus and many membrane-bound organellesLinear DNA in chromosomesMitochondria (and chloroplasts in plants, algae)Endomembrane system
Figure 2.10b Prokaryotes lack internal membrane-bound organelles but still have specialized regions, such as the nucleoid, where DNA is kept. Eukaryotes partition the cell with internal membranes. Drawings are not to scale: eukaryotic cells are typically about 10 times wider.
FeatureProkaryotic cell (Bacteria, Archaea)Eukaryotic cell
Internal membrane-bound organellesTypically noneMany: nucleus, ER, Golgi, mitochondria, lysosomes, and in plants and algae, chloroplasts
DNAUsually one circular chromosome in a region called the nucleoid (no membrane); small circular plasmidsSeveral linear chromosomes inside a nucleus enclosed by a double membrane
RibosomesPresent (smaller type)Present (larger type in the cytosol; smaller type in mitochondria and chloroplasts)
Typical sizeAbout 1 to 10 \(\mu\)mAbout 10 to 100 \(\mu\)m
CompartmentalizationSpecialized regions without a membrane around them (nucleoid, ribosome-rich cytoplasm); in some groups, internal membrane foldsInternal membranes partition the cell into specialized compartments

The word “typically” matters: a prokaryote is not a bag of unsorted material. Its DNA is gathered in the nucleoid, its ribosomes are concentrated in the cytoplasm, and in some bacteria (such as photosynthetic cyanobacteria) the plasma membrane is folded inward to carry out photosynthesis or respiration. These are specialized regions with specialized functions, but no organelle is surrounded by its own separate membrane. A eukaryote partitions the interior with real membranes (EK 2.10.A.3).

The endosymbiotic theory

1. Ancestral host cell2. Mitochondrion3. Chloroplastengulfs an aerobic bacteriumbut does not digest itbacterium becomesthe mitochondrionengulfs a photosyntheticbacterium (chloroplast)Plants and algae: nucleus + mitochondria + chloroplasts.Animals and fungi: nucleus + mitochondria.
Figure 2.10a In the endosymbiotic theory, mitochondria and chloroplasts descend from free-living prokaryotes that were taken into a host cell and stayed. Both organelles have a double membrane, their own circular DNA, and ribosomes like those of bacteria, and they divide by splitting like bacteria.

Endosymbiosis (“living together inside”) means that one cell lives inside another. According to the theory developed by Lynn Margulis from earlier ideas, mitochondria and chloroplasts were once free-living prokaryotes. A larger ancestral cell took in a small aerobic bacterium, which was not digested. The two benefited each other: the host gave protection and nutrients, and the bacterium made ATP efficiently using oxygen. Over time the bacterium became the mitochondrion. Later, a cell with mitochondria took in a photosynthetic bacterium (like a cyanobacterium), which became the chloroplast. That is why animal and fungal cells have mitochondria only, while plant and algal cells have both.

Evidence for endosymbiosis
  • Double membranes. The inner membrane is like the original bacterium’s plasma membrane; the outer membrane is like the host vesicle that engulfed it.
  • Their own DNA. Mitochondria and chloroplasts have a small circular chromosome, like bacterial DNA, separate from the DNA in the nucleus.
  • Their own ribosomes. These resemble bacterial ribosomes in size and in rRNA sequence, and they are sensitive to some antibiotics that stop bacterial protein synthesis.
  • Reproduction like bacteria. They divide by splitting in two, independently of the cell’s division, and a cell cannot make new ones from scratch.
  • Molecular similarity. Gene sequences from mitochondria are most similar to those of certain bacteria, and those from chloroplasts to cyanobacteria.
Worked example · Using sequence data as evidence

Scientists compared a ribosomal RNA gene from a mitochondrion of yeast with the same gene from three other sources. The percent identity of each source to the mitochondrial gene is shown (illustrative values). Use the data to evaluate the endosymbiotic hypothesis.

Source of the rRNA geneIdentity to the yeast mitochondrial gene (%)
A bacterium (Rickettsia)78
A cyanobacterium69
Yeast nuclear rRNA gene28

Describe. The mitochondrial gene is 78 percent identical to the gene of the bacterium and 69 percent identical to that of the cyanobacterium, but only 28 percent identical to the rRNA gene in the nucleus of its own cell.
Claim. The data support the hypothesis that mitochondria descended from bacteria and not from the host cell’s own nuclear genome.
Reasoning. If the mitochondrial genes had come from the host nucleus, the two genes in the same cell would be most similar to each other. Instead, the mitochondrial gene is much closer to bacterial genes, which is the pattern predicted if mitochondria descend from a bacterium.
Limit. A similarity of 78 percent does not identify the exact ancestor, and 69 percent for the cyanobacterium (a photosynthetic group) shows that all bacteria share some similarity; more species would be needed.

Worked example · Predict from the theory

An antibiotic that stops protein synthesis on bacterial-type ribosomes is given to a patient. Predict a side effect on the patient’s own cells, and justify it with the endosymbiotic theory.

Prediction. The drug may affect protein synthesis in the patient’s mitochondria, which could cause some toxicity in cells that use a lot of ATP.
Justification. Mitochondria evolved from bacteria and kept bacterial-type ribosomes. A drug that blocks bacterial ribosomes can therefore also act (more weakly, at higher doses) on the ribosomes of mitochondria, though it does not affect the 80S ribosomes in the cytosol.

Worked example · Comparing and contrasting

Compare the way a bacterium and an animal cell separate their metabolic reactions.

Similarity. Both separate certain processes in space: the bacterium keeps DNA in the nucleoid and ribosomes in the cytoplasm; the animal cell keeps DNA in the nucleus and makes proteins on ribosomes.
Difference. The animal cell separates processes with membrane-bound compartments (the nucleus, mitochondria, ER, lysosomes), whereas the bacterium’s specialized regions have no membrane around them, so there is less isolation of reactions and less internal membrane surface for reactions.

Exam focus
  • “Prokaryotes have no compartments” is wrong. They have specialized regions (nucleoid, ribosomes) but typically no membrane-bound organelles.
  • Endosymbiosis applies to mitochondria and chloroplasts only. The nucleus and the endomembrane system are thought to have come from infolding of the plasma membrane, not from engulfed cells.
  • Learn the evidence list: double membrane, circular DNA, bacterial-type ribosomes, binary-fission-like reproduction, sequence similarity.
  • For an evidence question, give the observation, say which hypothesis it supports, and explain why the other explanation fits less well.
  • Every cell, prokaryotic or eukaryotic, has a plasma membrane and ribosomes. These are used as evidence of common ancestry.
Practice
  1. State what is meant by endosymbiosis, and name the two organelles that evolved this way.
    Show answer

    Endosymbiosis is the process in which one cell lives inside another and the two become dependent on each other. Mitochondria and chloroplasts evolved from once free-living prokaryotic cells that were taken into a host cell.

  2. List three pieces of evidence that mitochondria were once free-living bacteria.
    Show answer

    (Any three.) They have a double membrane; they have their own circular DNA; they have their own ribosomes, similar to bacterial ribosomes; they reproduce by splitting in two; their gene sequences are similar to those of certain bacteria.

  3. A student states that bacteria have no compartmentalization at all. Correct the statement.
    Show answer

    Bacteria typically lack internal membrane-bound organelles, but they do have internal regions with specialized structures and functions, such as the nucleoid where DNA is kept and areas rich in ribosomes. Some also have folds of the plasma membrane for certain reactions.

  4. Explain why a plant cell is thought to have been formed by two endosymbiotic events but an animal cell by only one.
    Show answer

    Both have mitochondria (from the engulfing of an aerobic bacterium). Plants and algae also have chloroplasts, which came from a later engulfing of a photosynthetic bacterium. Animals do not have chloroplasts, so only the first event is needed to explain their organelles.

  5. The DNA of a chloroplast is sequenced and is most similar to the DNA of cyanobacteria. State the conclusion this supports and what the data would look like if the chloroplast gene had instead come from the plant’s nucleus.
    Show answer

    It supports the hypothesis that chloroplasts descended from a cyanobacterium by endosymbiosis. If the gene had come from the nucleus, it would be most similar to other nuclear genes of the plant and not to cyanobacterial DNA.

  6. Describe one similarity and one difference in how a prokaryotic cell and a eukaryotic cell store their DNA.
    Show answer

    Similarity: both store their genetic information as DNA that is kept in a specific region of the cell. Difference: a eukaryotic cell keeps its DNA (in linear chromosomes) in a nucleus surrounded by a double membrane, while a prokaryote typically has one circular chromosome in a nucleoid with no membrane around it.

Unit 2 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 2 quiz: Cell Structure and Function

Fifteen multiple-choice items and five short free-response questions on organelles and the endomembrane system, surface area-to-volume constraints, membrane structure, passive and active transport, water potential, and the endosymbiotic origin of compartments: click an option to see why each choice is right or wrong, and write each FRQ out before opening the model response.

Multiple choice

  1. Data: the volume occupied by four structures in three mammalian cell types, as a percent of total cell volume.

    Structure (% of cell volume)Cell DCell ECell F
    Rough ER2537
    Smooth ER2419
    Mitochondria73215
    Secretory vesicles1801

    Which claim is best supported by the data?

    Ribosomes on the rough ER deposit proteins destined for export into the ER lumen, and secretory vesicles carry the finished product to the plasma membrane. Cell D devotes 25% plus 18% of its volume to those two steps, more than five times cell F's combined 8%, which is what a plasma cell or a pancreatic acinar cell looks like inside.

    A secretory cell is full of loaded vesicles, not empty of them; cell E has none at all. Its 32% mitochondria, more than four times cell D's, points instead to a cell that spends ATP continuously, such as cardiac muscle.

    Cell F's 7% rough ER does exceed cell E's 3%, but that is not evidence of specialization when cell D's is 25%. Cell F's real signature is 19% smooth ER against only 1% secretory vesicles, which fits lipid synthesis and drug detoxification in a liver cell rather than protein export.

    Every cell needs some rough ER for membrane and lysosomal proteins, so its mere presence says nothing about rate. The data are given as percentages precisely so that the proportion of the cell devoted to a task can be compared, and those proportions differ by a factor of eight.

  2. Data: a pulse–chase experiment. Cells were given radioactive leucine for 3 minutes, washed, and returned to unlabeled leucine. Three membrane fractions were separated at intervals and the label in each was measured as a percent of the total label recovered.

    Minutes after the pulse282550
    Fraction P (% of label)8840145
    Fraction Q (% of label)10484115
    Fraction R (% of label)2124580

    Which statement is best supported by the data?

    Holding the most label late says where protein ends up, not where it was made. At 2 minutes, when the labeled amino acid had just been incorporated, fraction R held only 2%: synthesis happened in P, which held 88%.

    Independent synthesis would give three curves that rise together and stay up. Instead each fraction rises and then falls as the next one rises, and that hand-off pattern is what a shared assembly line looks like.

    P peaks at 2 minutes, Q at 8, and R at 50, and no fraction peaks before the one upstream of it does: the signature of compartments acting in order, matching ribosome and rough ER, then Golgi, then secretory vesicle. The columns summing to 100% shows the label is being relocated, not created or lost.

    The columns sum to 100% at every time point, so no label leaves the system and none is added. Radioactive leucine that disappears from P appears in Q and then R, which is transfer, not destruction and resynthesis.

  3. Lysosomes contain powerful hydrolytic enzymes that digest proteins, yet the proteins in the cytosol of the same cell are not digested. Which statement best explains this?

    Lysosomal enzymes are made continuously by the rough ER and Golgi in healthy cells. They are not absent; they are kept inside the lysosome.

    Compartmentalization minimizes competing interactions: the membrane isolates the enzymes from the molecules they would break down. The pump-maintained acid inside the lysosome adds a second safeguard, because the enzymes are much less active at the cytosol's pH of about 7.2.

    Proteins in the cytosol are polypeptides, held together by peptide bonds. Those are exactly the bonds that hydrolytic enzymes break.

    Ribosomes build proteins; they do not inactivate enzymes. The protection comes from the membrane and the pH difference.

  4. Model: three model cells, each with a volume of 64 µm³ but a different shape. All dimensions are in micrometers.

    Model cellCube 4 × 4 × 4Sheet 16 × 4 × 1Rod 32 × 2 × 1
    Surface area (µm²)96168196
    Volume (µm³)646464
    Surface area-to-volume ratio (µm−1)1.502.633.06
    Greatest distance from a surface to the interior (µm)2.00.50.5

    Which claim is best supported by the model?

    Volume is held constant at 64 µm³ across all three cells, yet the ratio doubles from 1.50 to 3.06 µm−1. That is exactly the comparison the model was built to make: with volume fixed, any difference left has to come from shape.

    The sheet and the rod hold the same 64 µm³ as the cube but wrap it in 168 and 196 µm² of membrane instead of 96, raising the ratio to 2.63 and 3.06 µm−1. Because both are only 1 µm thick, nothing inside them sits more than 0.5 µm from a surface, against 2.0 µm in the cube, and since diffusion time scales with the square of distance, that trip is about sixteen times faster.

    All three cells have the same volume, 64 µm³, so volume cannot explain the difference. The rod wins on ratio because stretching a fixed volume into a thin shape exposes more of it as surface.

    Being compact is the problem, not the solution. The cube has the lowest ratio, 1.50 µm−1, and the longest distance from any surface to its interior, 2.0 µm, so it is the worst of the three at supplying its own inside.

  5. A spherical cell doubles its radius while keeping its shape. Which of the following best explains why supplying its interior becomes harder?

    Nothing about being larger changes the cytoplasm's viscosity, and the diffusion coefficient of a solute is the same in a big cell and a small one. What changes is the distance that has to be covered and the area available to cover it.

    Membrane is manufactured as the cell grows rather than stretched like a balloon, and its thickness stays about 7–8 nm. Protein density per square micrometer is not the limiting factor here; total square micrometers per cubic micrometer is.

    For a sphere, SA = 4πr² and V = (4/3)πr³, so SA:V = 3/r; doubling r halves the ratio. At the same time the center moves twice as far from the surface, and because diffusion time goes as the square of distance, that doubles into a fourfold delay. Supply per unit of demand falls and delivery slows at once.

    A larger cell needs more material in total, and roughly the same amount per unit volume, since the same metabolic reactions run everywhere in the cytoplasm. The mismatch arises because the demand rises with volume while the supply rises only with surface.

  6. Data: permeability coefficients measured for a pure phospholipid bilayer containing no proteins, at 25 °C.

    SoluteO2H2OGlycerolGlucoseK+
    Molar mass (g/mol)32189218039
    Permeability (cm/s)10−110−310−610−710−12

    Which claim is best supported by the data?

    The table breaks that pattern twice. Water is the lightest solute at 18 g/mol yet is 100 times less permeant than O2 at 32 g/mol, and K+ at 39 g/mol is the least permeant of all: less than glucose, which is more than four times its mass.

    The bilayer in this experiment contains no proteins at all, and water still crosses it at 10−3 cm/s. Aquaporins raise that rate enormously in cells that need it, but the data show they are not required for water to get through.

    K+ has a molar mass of 39 g/mol against glucose's 180, so on size alone it should cross more easily; instead it is 10−12 against 10−7 cm/s, a factor of 105 the other way. An ion must shed the hydration shell of water molecules bound to its charge before it can enter the hydrocarbon core, and that costs more energy than it has.

    Being more permeant than glucose is evidence that glycerol crosses the bare lipid well, not that it needs help. Glycerol is small and uncharged, so like water and urea it trickles through the hydrophobic core unaided: this bilayer has no proteins in it at all.

  7. Which statement best explains how cholesterol helps a mammalian cell survive both a cold night and a hot afternoon?

    Cholesterol sits among the tails permanently and buffers fluidity in both directions. In the cold its bulky fused rings get in the way of tight packing, so the bilayer does not solidify; in the heat those same rings limit how freely the tails can move, so the bilayer does not become too fluid and leaky.

    Cholesterol does not migrate in and out with temperature; it is a permanent component of the animal cell membrane, anchored by its hydroxyl group near the phosphate heads with its rings among the tails. A molecule that left the core in the heat could not restrain the tails, which is half of what cholesterol does.

    Cholesterol's single hydroxyl group does interact with the head region, but that is an anchor, not the mechanism. The two leaflets are held together by the hydrophobic effect on the tails, and cholesterol's effect on fluidity comes from the rings physically wedged between those tails.

    Nothing converts one fatty acid into another inside a finished membrane; changing tail saturation requires enzymes that synthesize new phospholipids, which is what bacteria do over hours or days. Cholesterol works instantly and physically, without any chemical change to the phospholipids.

  8. An integral membrane protein is extracted from a bilayer and its sequence examined. Which of the following would most likely be found in the stretch of the chain that spanned the hydrophobic core?

    Phosphate heads line the two surfaces of the bilayer, not its core, so they cannot stabilize anything in the middle. Charged R groups do cluster where the protein meets the head region and the surrounding water, which is the opposite end of the span.

    Sugar chains mark glycoproteins, and they are always on the outer face where they serve cell–cell recognition. Sugars are highly polar and hydrogen-bond with water, so the hydrophobic core is the last place one would sit.

    Disulfide bridges form between two cysteine R groups within or between polypeptides, never between a protein and a phospholipid, which has no sulfhydryl group to bond with. This choice swaps a real protein-stabilizing interaction into a place it cannot occur.

    The membrane's interior is a hydrocarbon environment, so the residues facing it must be hydrocarbon-like too: leucine, isoleucine, valine, phenylalanine. Burying a charged or polar R group there would mean stripping away its hydration shell at a large energetic cost, which is why membrane-spanning helices read as long nonpolar stretches.

  9. Data: rate of glucose uptake at 37 °C by human red blood cells and by artificial lipid vesicles that contain no proteins.

    [Glucose] outside (mM)125102550
    Red blood cells (µmol/min)2036668496100
    Protein-free vesicles (µmol/min)0.81.64.08.020.040.0

    Which statement best explains why the red blood cell rate levels off while the vesicle rate does not?

    Facilitated diffusion spends no ATP: glucose is moving down its own gradient, and the carrier only provides a path. A plateau produced by an energy shortage would also appear in a red cell starved of glucose, which is the opposite of the condition here.

    Consumption inside the cell would keep the internal concentration low and so keep the gradient large, which would raise uptake rather than cap it. The ceiling appears at high external concentration, exactly where the gradient is biggest.

    The data say the reverse. At every concentration the red cells take up more, and at 1 mM they take up 20 µmol/min against the vesicles' 0.8, twenty-five times as much. What the vesicles have is not more permeability but a rate that never stops rising.

    Each carrier binds a glucose molecule, changes shape, releases it, and resets, and that cycle takes time. Once every carrier is working continuously, near 100 µmol/min here, adding substrate cannot add rate. The vesicle row has no such ceiling: it is a straight line at 0.8 µmol/min per mM through the whole range, because simple diffusion has nothing to saturate.

  10. A kidney collecting-duct cell responds to a hormone by inserting additional aquaporins into its plasma membrane. Which of the following best describes the effect?

    An aquaporin is a channel, not a pump: it forms an open hydrophilic pore that a single file of water molecules passes through, and it hydrolyzes no ATP. Nothing in the cell can move water against its own potential gradient directly.

    Adding channels changes how fast water can cross, not which way it goes. Water still moves from higher water potential to lower, so the hormone lets the kidney reabsorb water quickly when the interstitial fluid is concentrated, and stops the flow when the potentials equalize.

    Water is small and uncharged, so it trickles through a bare bilayer on its own at about 10−3 cm/s. That is slow for a kidney cell, which is why aquaporins matter, but it is not zero.

    Aquaporins pass water and exclude solutes, including H+, so inserting them moves no solute at all. The cell's solute potential is set by what is dissolved in it, and that is unchanged.

  11. Two compartments separated by a membrane permeable to glucose have reached equal glucose concentrations. Which statement best describes what happens next?

    Molecular motion does not switch off; every glucose molecule is still moving and still encountering the membrane. What disappears at equilibrium is the imbalance in crossings, not the crossings themselves.

    This is what "dynamic" means in dynamic equilibrium. With equal concentrations on both sides, the probability of a molecule crossing left to right equals the probability of crossing right to left, so the two flows cancel and the measured concentrations hold steady while traffic continues in both directions.

    Maintaining equal concentrations is the spontaneous, high-entropy arrangement and costs nothing. ATP is needed only to move a solute against its gradient, which lowers entropy locally: the situation in active transport, not here.

    Spontaneous movement back into a gradient would lower the system's entropy with no energy input, which does not happen. Re-establishing a gradient is precisely the job a cell has to pay for with ATP.

  12. Data: six dialysis bags, all filled with the same sucrose solution of unknown molarity, were weighed, submerged for 30 minutes at 22 °C in the beakers shown, blotted, and reweighed.

    Beaker [sucrose] (M)0.00.20.40.60.81.0
    % change in mass+13.8+8.4+2.9−2.9−8.2−13.6

    Which value best estimates the sucrose molarity of the solution inside the bags?

    Bags in 0.2 M gained 8.4% and bags in 0.4 M gained 2.9%, so a bag in 0.30 M would gain mass too. Water entering means the bag contents have the lower water potential, so the bag must be more concentrated than 0.30 M.

    At 0.4 M the bags still gained 2.9% of their mass, and a gain means net water movement inward. The bags cannot be 0.40 M, because a bag matched to its bath shows no change at all.

    The percent change crosses zero exactly halfway between 0.4 M (+2.9%) and 0.6 M (−2.9%), at 0.50 M. Zero net water movement means the bath and the bag have the same water potential, and since both contain only sucrose in water, they must have the same molarity. Divide by initial mass rather than final, and read the crossing rather than any single point.

    In 0.6 M the bags lost 2.9%, so water left them and the bath had the lower water potential of the two. That places the bag's concentration below 0.60 M, not at it.

  13. Calculate the solute potential of a 0.25 M CaCl2 solution at 27 °C. Use \(\Psi_s = -iCRT\) with \(R = 0.0831\) L·bar/(mol·K).

    This leaves the temperature in degrees Celsius: −(3)(0.25)(0.0831)(27) = −1.68. The gas constant is defined per kelvin, so the temperature must be converted first, 27 + 273 = 300 K.

    This uses i = 1, as if CaCl2 stayed intact in solution: −(1)(0.25)(0.0831)(300) = −6.23. Solute potential depends on the number of dissolved particles, and calcium chloride dissociates into three of them.

    This uses i = 2, the value for NaCl. Each CaCl2 formula unit releases one Ca2+ and two Cl−, so the ionization constant is 3, not 2: count the ions, not the elements.

    With i = 3, C = 0.25 M, R = 0.0831, and T = 27 + 273 = 300 K, \(\Psi_s = -(3)(0.25)(0.0831)(300) = -18.70\) bars. The two places students lose this point are forgetting i and leaving T in Celsius; the negative sign is required because dissolved solute can only pull water potential down.

  14. Data: features of a bacterium, a mitochondrion from a eukaryotic cell, and the cytosol (nuclear genome) of that same eukaryotic cell.

    FeatureBacteriumMitochondrionEukaryotic cytosol and nucleus
    Ribosome type70S70S80S
    DNA formCircularCircularLinear chromosomes
    Protein synthesis blocked by chloramphenicolYesYesNo
    Divides by splitting in twoYesYesNo (mitosis)

    Which conclusion is best supported by the data?

    The data show similarity, not that mitochondria can live independently today. Mitochondria depend on the host for most of their proteins, which are encoded in the nucleus. The claim goes beyond the evidence.

    Both the host nucleus and the mitochondrion contain DNA, but the nuclear DNA is linear and the mitochondrial DNA is circular, and the data give no support for a bacterial origin of the nucleus. Endosymbiosis explains mitochondria and chloroplasts, not the nucleus.

    In all four rows the mitochondrion matches the bacterium (70S ribosomes, circular DNA, chloramphenicol sensitivity, splitting in two) and not the host cell. That pattern is predicted if mitochondria descended from a bacterium.

    If mitochondria had come from the nucleus they would resemble the nuclear genome and 80S ribosomes. The data show the opposite: they differ from the cytosol in every row.

  15. A neuron's sodium–potassium pumps hydrolyze 4.5 × 108 ATP molecules per second. How many Na+ ions leave the cell per second, and what net positive charge leaves per second?

    This uses the potassium stoichiometry for sodium. Each ATP drives one cycle that sends 3 Na+ out and brings 2 K+ in, so 9.0 × 108 is the number of K+ imported, not the number of Na+ exported.

    One ATP per cycle gives 3(4.5 × 108) = 1.35 × 109 Na+ out and 2(4.5 × 108) = 9.0 × 108 K+ in. The charge balance per cycle is three positive out against two positive in, a net of one, so 4.5 × 108 positive charges leave each second, which is why the pump is called electrogenic and adds a few millivolts to the resting potential.

    2.25 × 109 is 5(4.5 × 108), the total number of ions moved per second in both directions. Net charge is a difference, not a sum: the 9.0 × 108 K+ entering cancel all but 4.5 × 108 of the sodium's charge.

    The exchange is not one for one. Three sodium ions leave for every two potassium ions that enter, so each cycle leaves the interior one positive charge more negative: an imbalance that accumulates at 4.5 × 108 charges per second.

Free response

  1. Investigation: cubes of agar containing the indicator phenolphthalein were soaked in 0.1 M NaOH, which turns the agar bright pink wherever it penetrates.

    Four cubes with sides of 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, and 4.0 cm were cut from one slab of agar, soaked together in the same beaker of NaOH for 10 minutes at 22 °C, blotted, and cut open. In every cube the pink zone extended 0.5 cm inward from each face.

    Cube side (cm)1.02.03.04.0
    Surface area (cm²)6.024.054.096.0
    Volume (cm³)1.08.027.064.0
    Surface area-to-volume ratio (cm−1)6.03.02.01.5
    Percent of volume turned pink10087.570.457.8

    Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in the investigation, and describe one variable that had to be held constant and why holding it constant mattered.
    2. Explain the relationship between a cube's surface area-to-volume ratio and the percent of its volume that turned pink.
    3. Construct a graph that displays the relationship between cube side length and percent of volume turned pink: state which variable belongs on each axis, give an appropriate scale and label for each, and describe the shape of the curve.
    4. A student claims that no living cell could function at the size of the 4.0 cm cube. Justify this claim using the data.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the independent variable is the cube's side length (its size). One constant, with a reason: soak time, because the NaOH front advances with time and a longer soak would deepen the pink zone for a reason unrelated to size; or NaOH concentration, temperature, or agar composition, each because it sets how fast the front advances. Do not accept: naming a constant with no reason attached; "all other variables were kept the same" with none named; identifying percent pink or penetration depth as the independent variable.
    • (b) Accept: as the ratio falls from 6.0 to 1.5 cm−1, the percent pink falls from 100 to 57.8; because the NaOH travels the same 0.5 cm into every cube, the reacted shell scales with surface area while the interior needing to be reached scales with volume, so a cube with less surface per unit volume leaves a larger fraction untouched. Do not accept: "larger cubes take longer to soak" (penetration depth was the same in all four); restating both columns with no causal connection; a general statement about SA:V never applied to these cubes.
    • (c) Accept: cube side length in cm on the x-axis because it is the independent variable, with an even scale from 0 to 4 cm; percent of volume turned pink on the y-axis, scaled 0 to 100% in even intervals; both axes labeled with quantity and unit. Shape: starts at 100% at 1.0 cm and falls, steeply at first and then more gradually, to 57.8% at 4.0 cm. Do not accept: the independent variable on the y-axis; axes with no units; a percent axis that does not include 0 and 100; "plot the data" with no axes, scale, or labels specified; a straight line through the origin.
    • (d) Accept: the 4.0 cm cube has a surface area-to-volume ratio of only 1.5 cm−1 and just 57.8% of its volume was reached in 10 minutes, leaving 42.2% untouched; a cell of that size would have more than two-fifths of its cytoplasm receiving no oxygen or nutrients and unable to clear waste, because the membrane area available for exchange is too small for the volume behind it. Do not accept: "it is too big" with no value cited; quoting 57.8% or 1.5 cm−1 without saying what it means for a living cell; claiming diffusion slows down inside large cells.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is the side length of the cube: 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, or 4.0 cm. Soak time had to be held at 10 minutes for all four, because the NaOH front advances with time, so a cube left in longer would have a deeper pink zone for a reason unrelated to its size.

    b The NaOH moved the same 0.5 cm into every cube, so the pink shell tracks surface area while the pale core tracks volume. As side length grows, volume grows faster than surface does and the ratio drops from 6.0 to 1.5 cm−1, so a shell of fixed thickness covers a smaller share of a bigger cube, which is why percent pink falls from 100 to 57.8.

    c Side length in cm goes on the x-axis because that is what I set, scaled 0 to 4 cm in 1 cm steps; percent of volume turned pink goes on the y-axis, scaled 0 to 100% in steps of 20. Both axes get the quantity and the unit. The curve starts at 100% at 1.0 cm and falls, steeply at first and then more gently, to 57.8% at 4.0 cm.

    d I agree. The 4.0 cm cube has a ratio of only 1.5 cm−1 and only 57.8% of it turned pink, so 42.2% of the interior got nothing in 10 minutes. A cell that size would have more than two-fifths of its cytoplasm cut off from oxygen and nutrients and from waste removal, because its surface is far too small to serve the volume behind it.

  2. A researcher prepares artificial vesicles from pure phospholipid and a second batch of vesicles from the same phospholipid plus cholesterol. Answer (a) through (d).

    1. Describe how the phospholipid molecules are arranged in the bilayer of one of these vesicles, and identify the region of the bilayer a solute must pass through to cross it.
    2. Explain why O2 crosses a pure phospholipid bilayer readily while Na+ crosses at a negligible rate, even though a sodium ion is smaller than an oxygen molecule.
    3. Predict how the fluidity of the cholesterol-containing vesicles compares with that of the pure phospholipid vesicles at 5 °C and at 40 °C.
    4. Justify your prediction in (c) by describing how cholesterol interacts with the phospholipid tails.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: two layers of phospholipids with their hydrophilic phosphate heads facing the water on the outside of the vesicle and on the inside, and their hydrophobic fatty acid tails pointing inward toward each other, away from water; a solute must pass through the hydrophobic core formed by those tails. Do not accept: "a phospholipid bilayer" restated with no description of head and tail orientation; heads and tails reversed; identifying the phosphate heads as the barrier.
    • (b) Accept: O2 is small and nonpolar, so it dissolves directly into the hydrocarbon core and passes through. Na+ carries a full positive charge and holds a shell of water molecules oriented around it; entering the core would require stripping that hydration shell away, which costs far more energy than the ion has, so charge rather than size is the barrier. Do not accept: "ions are too big" with no mention of charge or hydration; "the membrane is selectively permeable," which restates the question; a correct general rule never applied to O2 and Na+.
    • (c) Accept a two-part directional prediction: at 5 °C the cholesterol vesicles are more fluid than the pure phospholipid vesicles, and at 40 °C they are less fluid. Do not accept: a single prediction covering only one temperature; "cholesterol changes fluidity" with no direction; "cholesterol makes the membrane more fluid" at both temperatures.
    • (d) Accept: cholesterol's rigid fused-ring system sits wedged between neighboring phospholipid tails; in the cold it physically prevents the tails from packing into a tightly ordered gel, keeping the bilayer fluid, and in the heat the same rings restrict how far and how fast the tails can swing, holding the bilayer together and preventing it from becoming too fluid and leaky. Do not accept: calling cholesterol a "fluidity buffer" with no mechanism; describing only one of the two temperature effects; claiming cholesterol changes the saturation of the tails.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The phospholipids sit in two layers with their phosphate heads facing water (the outside of the vesicle for one layer, the enclosed interior for the other), and their fatty acid tails pointing inward at each other, away from water. Anything crossing must pass through that hydrophobic core of tails.

    b O2 is small and nonpolar, so it dissolves into the hydrocarbon core the way it would into oil and comes out the far side. Na+ carries a full positive charge, and in water it is wrapped in a shell of water molecules turned toward it. Entering the core would mean shedding that shell, which costs more energy than the ion has, so the barrier is charge, not size.

    c I predict the cholesterol vesicles are more fluid than the pure phospholipid vesicles at 5 °C and less fluid than them at 40 °C.

    d Cholesterol's stiff ring system wedges between neighboring tails. At 5 °C those rings block the tails from packing into a tight, ordered gel, so the cholesterol membrane stays fluid while the pure one starts to solidify. At 40 °C the same rings limit how far the tails can swing, so it holds together while the pure one turns too fluid and leaky.

  3. Model: a cross-sectional diagram of a mitochondrion inside a cultured human cell.

    The diagram shows a smooth outer membrane and, within it, an inner membrane thrown into deep folds labeled cristae; the space enclosed by the inner membrane is labeled the matrix. In the matrix the diagram shows a small closed loop of DNA with no histone proteins attached and several ribosomes labeled 70S. Ribosomes drawn in the surrounding cytosol are labeled 80S. An arrow beside the organelle is labeled "divides by binary fission."

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify TWO features shown in the model that the endosymbiotic theory predicts, and describe what that theory proposes each of the two membranes was derived from.
    2. Explain how the cristae shown in the model increase the amount of ATP a single mitochondrion can produce.
    3. An antibiotic that binds 70S ribosomes and blocks translation is added to the culture medium. Predict its effect on protein synthesis in the cytosol and on protein synthesis inside the mitochondrion.
    4. Justify your prediction in (c) using specific features labeled in the model.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept any two of: the double membrane, the circular DNA lacking histones, the 70S (bacterial-size) ribosomes, and division by binary fission. Membranes: the inner membrane is proposed to be the engulfed bacterium's own plasma membrane and the outer membrane the host cell's engulfing vesicle. Do not accept: only one feature named; features listed with no account of where each membrane came from; naming the cristae as evidence of endosymbiosis, since folding is a surface-area adaptation rather than a prediction of the model.
    • (b) Accept: the folds pack a large area of inner membrane into a small volume, and the electron transport chain proteins and ATP synthase are embedded in that membrane, so more folding means more of those complexes per organelle, more H+ pumped into the intermembrane space, and more ATP made per unit of mitochondrial volume. Do not accept: "cristae increase surface area" with no statement of what the added area holds; placing the electron transport chain in the matrix or in the outer membrane; an answer about ATP that never mentions membrane area.
    • (c) Accept a two-part directional prediction: cytosolic protein synthesis continues at close to its normal rate, while protein synthesis inside the mitochondrion is inhibited, so mitochondrially encoded proteins are not made and ATP output falls over time. Do not accept: "protein synthesis stops" without distinguishing the two compartments; predicting an effect with no direction; "nothing changes."
    • (d) Accept: the model labels the matrix ribosomes 70S and the cytosolic ribosomes 80S, and the drug binds only 70S, so the mitochondrial ribosomes are targets and the cell's own are not. The 70S label is itself one of the endosymbiotic predictions, since 70S is the ribosome size found in bacteria. Do not accept: repeating the prediction in other words; asserting shared ancestry with no labeled feature named; citing the double membrane or circular DNA, neither of which determines what the drug binds.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Two features the theory predicts are the circular DNA with no histones and the 70S ribosomes in the matrix. On this model the inner membrane is the plasma membrane of the bacterium that was engulfed long ago, and the outer membrane is the vesicle the host cell wrapped around it as it took the bacterium in.

    b The cristae fold the inner membrane back on itself so a large membrane area fits inside a small organelle. The electron transport chain proteins and ATP synthase are embedded in that membrane, so the more of it a mitochondrion packs in, the more of those complexes it holds, the more H+ it pumps into the intermembrane space, and the more ATP it makes per unit volume.

    c I predict cytosolic protein synthesis continues at close to its normal rate while translation inside the mitochondrion shuts down, so mitochondrial proteins stop being made and the cell's ATP output drops over the following hours.

    d The model labels the matrix ribosomes 70S and the cytosolic ones 80S, and the drug binds only 70S, so the mitochondrion's ribosomes are targets and the cell's own are not. That 70S label is itself one of the endosymbiotic predictions, since 70S is the bacterial ribosome size.

  4. Data: potato cores of equal starting mass were blotted, weighed, submerged for 24 hours at 25 °C in the open beakers shown, blotted again, and reweighed.

    [Sucrose] in the beaker (M)0.00.20.40.60.8
    % change in mass+16.2+8.7+1.8−5.4−12.0

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the dependent variable in the investigation, and describe the trend in the data.
    2. Explain, in terms of water potential, why the cores in the 0.0 M beaker gained mass while the cores in the 0.8 M beaker lost mass.
    3. Determine the sucrose molarity at which the cores would show no net change in mass, then calculate the solute potential of that solution at 25 °C, showing your setup. Use \(\Psi_s = -iCRT\) with \(R = 0.0831\) L·bar/(mol·K) and \(i = 1\) for sucrose.
    4. Justify the claim that the water potential of the potato cores is −11.14 bars, using your result from (c) and the conditions of the investigation.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the dependent variable is the percent change in mass of the potato cores. Trend: percent change falls steadily as beaker sucrose concentration rises, from +16.2% at 0.0 M to −12.0% at 0.8 M, changing from a gain to a loss between 0.4 M and 0.6 M. Do not accept: naming sucrose concentration as the dependent variable; "the mass changed" with no direction; listing the endpoints with no statement of the trend.
    • (b) Accept: pure water in an open beaker has Ψ = 0 bars, the highest value possible, which is higher than the cores' negative Ψ, so water moved into the cells and the cores gained mass. The 0.8 M beaker has a strongly negative solute potential and therefore a Ψ lower than the cores', so water moved out of the cells into the beaker and the cores lost mass. Do not accept: "water moves toward the higher solute concentration" with no reference to water potential; a reversed direction; a general rule never applied to these cores.
    • (c) Accept: interpolating between 0.4 M (+1.8%) and 0.6 M (−5.4%), the line falls 7.2 percentage points across 0.2 M, so zero lies 1.8/7.2 = 0.25 of the way, at 0.4 + 0.25(0.2) = 0.45 M. Then with T = 25 + 273 = 298 K, \(\Psi_s = -(1)(0.45)(0.0831)(298) = -11.14\) bars. Do not accept: reading the crossing as 0.4 M or 0.6 M with no interpolation; T left in °C; a missing negative sign; a value with no units; a value with no setup shown.
    • (d) Accept: at 0.45 M there is no net movement of water, so the cores and the bath are at equilibrium and their water potentials are equal. The beaker is open, so its pressure potential is 0 and its water potential equals its solute potential, −11.14 bars; therefore the cores' water potential is −11.14 bars as well. Do not accept: restating the value; asserting the equality with no mention of zero net water movement or of Ψp = 0 in an open beaker; using the 0.8 M beaker's value.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The dependent variable is the percent change in mass of the potato cores. It falls steadily as the beaker gets more concentrated, from +16.2% in pure water to −12.0% at 0.8 M, switching from a gain to a loss between 0.4 M and 0.6 M.

    b Pure water in an open beaker has a water potential of 0 bars, the highest there is, while the cores' Ψ is negative because of the solutes in their cells. Water moves from higher Ψ to lower, so it entered the cells and those cores gained mass. The 0.8 M beaker has a strongly negative solute potential, putting its Ψ below the cores', so water left the cells instead.

    c Between 0.4 M (+1.8%) and 0.6 M (−5.4%) the line drops 7.2 percentage points, so zero sits 1.8/7.2 = 0.25 of the way across: 0.4 + 0.25(0.2) = 0.45 M. With T = 25 + 273 = 298 K, Ψs = −(1)(0.45)(0.0831)(298) = −11.14 bars.

    d At 0.45 M the cores neither gain nor lose mass, which means no net water movement and therefore equal water potentials on both sides. The beaker is open to the air, so its pressure potential is 0 and its water potential is nothing but its solute potential, −11.14 bars. Since the cores match it at equilibrium, their water potential is −11.14 bars too.

  5. Data: glucose uptake across the apical membrane of cultured intestinal epithelial cells over 10 minutes under four conditions. Ouabain inhibits the sodium–potassium pump; phlorizin blocks the SGLT1 sodium–glucose cotransporter.

    ConditionComplete mediumNa+ removedOuabain addedPhlorizin added
    Glucose uptake (nmol/min per mg protein)62695

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the transport mechanism that carries glucose across the apical membrane in the complete medium, and describe the immediate source of free energy that drives it.
    2. Explain why ouabain lowers glucose uptake even though it does not bind the SGLT1 cotransporter.
    3. Calculate the percent decrease in glucose uptake caused by removing Na+ and the percent decrease caused by ouabain, showing your setup.
    4. A student claims that cells in a complete medium whose ATP synthesis has been blocked for 30 minutes would take up glucose at a rate close to the ouabain value rather than the complete-medium value. Justify this claim using the data.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: secondary active transport by the SGLT1 Na+–glucose cotransporter; the immediate energy source is the electrochemical gradient of Na+ across the apical membrane, whose free energy is released as Na+ moves down that gradient into the cell and is used to haul glucose in against its own gradient. Do not accept: "active transport" with no statement that it is secondary or that Na+ supplies the energy; naming ATP hydrolysis at SGLT1 as the immediate source; "facilitated diffusion" or "simple diffusion."
    • (b) Accept: ouabain inhibits the sodium–potassium pump, which is what continually exports Na+ and keeps intracellular Na+ low; with the pump stopped, Na+ leaks in until the gradient runs down, and once there is no gradient there is no free energy for the cotransporter to spend, so uptake falls to 9: close to the value with Na+ removed entirely. Do not accept: claiming ouabain blocks SGLT1; "ATP is needed for transport" with no reference to the pump or the gradient; naming the pump with no explanation of how its loss reaches glucose uptake.
    • (c) Accept: Na+ removed, (62 − 6)/62 × 100 = 90.3%; ouabain, (62 − 9)/62 × 100 = 85.5%. Setups shown; rounding to one decimal or to the nearest whole percent acceptable. Do not accept: dividing by the treated value instead of the control; reporting the remaining percentage (9.7% and 14.5%) as the decrease; one calculation when two were asked for; a bare number with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: the claim is supported because blocking ATP synthesis stops the sodium–potassium pump for the same reason ouabain does, and the data show that stopping that pump drops uptake from 62 to 9 even with Na+ still present in the medium. That result is close to the 6 obtained with no Na+ at all, which shows the gradient, not the presence of Na+, is what the cotransporter depends on. Do not accept: "no ATP means no transport" with no mention of the pump or the gradient; restating the claim; citing the ouabain value with no explanation of why blocking ATP synthesis produces the same outcome.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Glucose crosses the apical membrane by secondary active transport through the SGLT1 cotransporter. The immediate energy source is the Na+ electrochemical gradient: sodium falls down its own gradient into the cell, and the free energy released as it does drags glucose in with it, uphill against glucose's gradient.

    b Ouabain blocks the sodium–potassium pump, which is the protein that keeps pushing Na+ back out and holds internal sodium low. Once the pump stops, Na+ leaks in until inside and outside are nearly equal, and a gradient that has run down releases no free energy. The cotransporter is untouched but has nothing left to spend, so uptake collapses to 9.

    c Removing Na+: (62 − 6)/62 × 100 = 90.3%. Ouabain: (62 − 9)/62 × 100 = 85.5%.

    d I agree with the student. Blocking ATP synthesis stops the sodium–potassium pump for the same reason ouabain does, just from the fuel side instead of the protein side, and the data show what happens when that pump stops: uptake fell from 62 to 9 even though Na+ was still in the medium the whole time. That 9 is close to the 6 measured with no Na+ at all, which tells me the cotransporter needs the gradient rather than just the ion.

Lesson 3.1 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.1

Enzymes

A sugar cube can sit on a table for years without turning into carbon dioxide and water, even though that change releases energy. Your cells break down sugar in seconds. The difference is the enzyme. Nearly every chemical reaction in a living cell would be far too slow at body temperature without a protein catalyst to speed it up, and the cell controls which reactions happen by controlling which enzymes are present and active. This lesson explains what an enzyme does and how it does it.

Learning objective · 3.1.A

Explain how enzymes affect the rate of biological reactions. EK 3.1.A.1: the structure and function of enzymes contribute to the regulation of biological processes. Enzymes are proteins that are biological catalysts that facilitate chemical reactions in cells by lowering the activation energy. EK 3.1.A.2: for an enzyme-mediated reaction to occur, the shape and charge of the substrate must be compatible with the active site of the enzyme, as illustrated by the enzyme-substrate complex model.

Why reactions need help: activation energy

Even a reaction that releases energy overall does not start by itself. Before the old bonds in the reactants can be replaced by new ones, the reactants must pass through an unstable, high-energy arrangement. The energy needed to reach it is the activation energy (Ea). It acts like a hill that molecules must climb. At body temperature, only a tiny fraction of molecules collide with enough energy to get over a tall hill, so the reaction is very slow.

Energy of the systemProgress of the reactionEaEaenergy released(same either way)reactantsproductswithout enzymewith enzyme
Figure 3.1a An enzyme lowers the activation energy (Ea), the energy barrier that reactants must climb before they can become products. It does not change the energy of the reactants or products, so it does not change how much energy the reaction releases or which way it tends to go. It only makes the reaction faster.

A catalyst speeds up a reaction without being used up. Heat is also a way to speed a reaction, but a cell cannot be heated to hundreds of degrees without destroying itself. An enzyme works instead by providing an easier route: it lowers the activation energy, so many more molecules can react at body temperature. Notice what the graph does not show changing: the energy of the reactants and of the products stays the same, so the enzyme does not change how much energy the reaction releases, or whether the reaction is energetically favorable. It does not make an impossible reaction happen; it makes a possible one fast.

Enzymes are proteins with active sites

Required content · EK 3.1.A.1

Enzymes are proteins that are biological catalysts. They facilitate chemical reactions in cells by lowering the activation energy.

Because an enzyme is a protein, its shape comes from its amino acid sequence and the folding you studied in lesson 1.7. Somewhere on the surface of the folded protein is a pocket or groove called the active site. The molecule an enzyme acts on is its substrate; the substance made is the product. The active site is made up of the R groups of a few amino acids that happen to be near each other after folding, and those R groups have a particular shape and charge.

Required content · EK 3.1.A.2

For an enzyme-mediated chemical reaction to occur, the shape and charge of the substrate must be compatible with the active site of the enzyme. This is illustrated by the enzyme-substrate complex model.

1. Substrateapproaches2. Enzyme-substratecomplex forms3. Bonds changeat the active site4. Products leave,enzyme is reusedsubstrateenzymeenzymeenzymeenzyme
Figure 3.1b The substrate fits the enzyme’s active site by shape and charge. Binding can slightly change the enzyme’s shape to fit the substrate even better (induced fit). Bonds in the substrate are broken or formed, the products are released, and the enzyme is free to work again. An enzyme is not used up.

The steps are the same for every enzyme. The substrate enters the active site, and the two are held by weak interactions (hydrogen bonds, ionic attractions, and hydrophobic interactions) to form the enzyme-substrate complex. The active site then helps the substrate change: it may strain a bond, bring two substrates close together in the right orientation, or provide a charge that stabilizes the high-energy arrangement. Products leave, and the enzyme, which was not changed, is ready to bind another substrate. One enzyme molecule can process thousands of substrate molecules each second, so a small amount of enzyme goes a long way.

Active sites are specific. The enzyme sucrase digests sucrose and not lactose, and lactase digests lactose and not sucrose, because only one of those sugars has the shape and charge distribution that fits. Many enzymes are named for their substrate, with the ending “-ase” (lipase digests lipids, protease digests proteins). When a substrate binds, the active site often shifts slightly to grip it more tightly. This is called induced fit. Some enzymes also need a helper, a metal ion or an organic coenzyme (often derived from a vitamin), to work.

IdeaWhat it meansCommon mistake
CatalystSpeeds up a reaction and is not used upSaying the enzyme is “consumed” or turned into the product
Activation energyEnergy needed to start a reaction; the enzyme lowers itSaying the enzyme supplies energy or changes the energy of the products
Active sitePart of the enzyme where the substrate binds; shape and charge fit the substrateCalling the whole enzyme “the active site”
SpecificityEach enzyme works on one substrate (or a few similar ones)Saying any enzyme can act on any molecule

Measuring how fast an enzyme works

The rate of an enzyme-catalyzed reaction is the amount of product formed (or substrate used up) per unit of time. On a graph of product against time, the rate is the slope of the line. The slope is steepest at the start, when plenty of substrate is present, and then flattens as substrate is used up. The initial rate is therefore the best measure of how well the enzyme works.

Worked example · Calculating a reaction rate from data

The enzyme catalase breaks down hydrogen peroxide into water and oxygen. A student measures the amount of oxygen released over time by a sample of liver extract (the table), and also measures a control with no enzyme that releases 0.3 \(\mu\)mol of oxygen per minute. Calculate the initial rate, the rate in the last two minutes, and how much faster the enzyme is, and explain why the rate changes.

Time (min)0123456
O2 released (\(\mu\)mol)0122333414648

Initial rate (0 to 2 min). \((23 - 0)/(2 - 0) = 11.5\ \mu\text{mol/min}\).
Rate in the last two minutes (4 to 6 min). \((48 - 41)/(6 - 4) = 3.5\ \mu\text{mol/min}\).
Compared with no enzyme. \(11.5 / 0.3 = 38\) times faster.
Explain the change. The rate falls because the substrate (hydrogen peroxide) is being used up. With less substrate there are fewer enzyme-substrate complexes at any moment, so the enzyme produces less product each minute, and the curve levels off as the substrate is nearly gone. The enzyme is not “worn out”: adding more substrate would raise the rate again.

Designing an enzyme experiment

Worked example · Identifying variables and controls

A student wants to test whether the amount of catalase affects the rate at which hydrogen peroxide breaks down. She places 1, 2, 3, or 4 filter-paper disks soaked in catalase extract in a beaker of 3 percent hydrogen peroxide and times how long each takes to rise to the surface (bubbles of oxygen lift the disk). Identify the independent variable, the dependent variable, appropriate controls, and what must be held constant, and justify the controls.

Independent variable. The amount of enzyme (number of disks).
Dependent variable. The time to rise (a shorter time means a faster reaction).
Controls. (1) A disk soaked in water or in boiled catalase placed in hydrogen peroxide. If it does not rise, the rising in the other trials is due to active enzyme and not to the disk or to spontaneous breakdown. (2) A catalase disk placed in water with no peroxide, to show that the substrate is required.
Held constant. Temperature, pH, volume and concentration of hydrogen peroxide, size and type of disk, and the extract used.
Why controls matter. A control shows that the effect comes from the variable being tested and not from something else. Boiling denatures the protein (lesson 3.2), so a boiled-enzyme control separates the effect of a working enzyme from the effect of the other ingredients.

Exam focus
  • An enzyme lowers the activation energy. It does not change the energy of the reactants or products, does not supply energy, and is not used up.
  • Say that the shape and charge of the substrate must be compatible with the active site. Specificity comes from the protein’s structure.
  • Rate is the slope of product against time. Show the subtraction, divide, and write units (for example \(\mu\)mol/min).
  • When a reaction slows toward the end of an experiment, the usual reason is that the substrate is used up, not that the enzyme has stopped working.
  • Experimental design: name the independent and dependent variables, a control (such as boiled enzyme), and the factors held constant.
Practice
  1. Explain how an enzyme speeds up a reaction, and state what it does not change.
    Show answer

    An enzyme lowers the activation energy of the reaction, so more molecules have enough energy to react and the reaction goes faster. It does not change the energy of the reactants or of the products (so it does not change the total energy released), and it is not used up in the reaction.

  2. Describe the enzyme-substrate complex and explain why an enzyme that digests sucrose will not digest lactose.
    Show answer

    The enzyme-substrate complex forms when the substrate binds to the active site of the enzyme. The active site has a specific shape and charge, and sucrase’s active site is compatible with sucrose but not with lactose, which has a different shape and charge distribution, so lactose does not bind well enough to react.

  3. An enzyme assay gives these data: 0 \(\mu\)mol at 0 min, 18 \(\mu\)mol at 3 min, and 30 \(\mu\)mol at 6 min. Calculate the rate for the first three minutes and for the next three minutes, and explain the difference.
    Show answer

    First interval: \((18 - 0)/3 = 6.0\ \mu\text{mol/min}\). Second interval: \((30 - 18)/3 = 4.0\ \mu\text{mol/min}\). The rate decreases because substrate is being used up, so fewer enzyme-substrate complexes form per minute.

  4. A mutation changes one amino acid in the active site of an enzyme from one with a negative R group to one with a positive R group. Predict the effect on the enzyme and justify.
    Show answer

    The reaction rate would probably decrease or stop. The charge of the active site changes, so a substrate that was compatible with the old shape and charge may no longer bind properly, and the enzyme is less able to lower the activation energy.

  5. In an experiment to find how the amount of enzyme affects the rate, a student boils the enzyme and adds it to the substrate as a control. No product forms. State what this control shows.
    Show answer

    It shows that the product in the other tubes was made by active enzyme and not by the substrate breaking down on its own or by other ingredients in the mixture. The boiled enzyme is denatured, so it cannot catalyze the reaction.

  6. A student states that “enzymes provide the energy needed to start a reaction.” Correct the statement.
    Show answer

    Enzymes do not supply energy. They lower the activation energy by giving the reaction an easier path, so the energy that molecules already have is enough to make the reaction happen quickly at body temperature.

Lesson 3.2 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2

Environmental effects on enzyme function

An enzyme is a folded protein, and a folded protein is a delicate thing. Warm it too much, put it in the wrong pH, or add a molecule that looks like its substrate, and its rate changes. These effects are some of the most common data questions on the AP exam, and they all follow from two ideas from earlier: an enzyme works because of the shape of its active site (lesson 3.1), and that shape is held by weak interactions (lesson 1.7).

Learning objectives · 3.2.A and 3.2.B

3.2.A Explain how changes to the structure of an enzyme may affect its function (EK 3.2.A.1 and 3.2.A.2). 3.2.B Explain how the cellular environment affects enzyme activity (EK 3.2.B.1 to 3.2.B.3).

Changing the enzyme: denaturation

Required content · EK 3.2.A.1 and 3.2.A.2
  • A change to the molecular structure of a component in an enzymatic system may result in a change to its function or efficiency.
  • Denaturation of a protein, such as an enzyme, occurs when the protein structure is disrupted by a change in temperature, pH, or chemical environment. It eliminates the ability to catalyze reactions.
  • Environmental temperatures and pH outside the optimal range for a given enzyme cause changes to its structure (by disrupting the hydrogen bonds), altering the efficiency with which it catalyzes reactions.
  • In some cases, denaturation is reversible, allowing the enzyme to regain activity.

Heat makes the atoms of the protein vibrate harder and breaks the weak hydrogen bonds and other interactions that hold the tertiary structure. A change in pH changes the charge on acidic and basic R groups, which breaks ionic bonds and hydrogen bonds and can alter the active site. Chemicals such as detergents and urea disrupt the interactions as well. The peptide bonds of the primary structure are not broken. The chain simply unfolds, the active site loses its shape, and the substrate no longer fits (the enzyme-substrate complex cannot form). If the change was gentle, the protein may refold when conditions return to normal, as Anfinsen’s ribonuclease did (lesson 1.7); if it was severe, as when an egg white is cooked, the change is permanent.

Temperature and pH have optimum values

Temperature020406080100Temperature (°C)Reaction ratehuman enzyme (37 °C)hot-spring bacterium (72 °C)pH02468101214pHpepsintrypsinamylase
Figure 3.2a Each enzyme has an optimum. Rate rises with temperature because collisions are more frequent and energetic, then falls sharply when the protein denatures. Optimum pH depends on where the enzyme works: pepsin in the acid stomach, trypsin in the slightly basic small intestine. (Schematic curves.)

As temperature rises, molecules move faster, so enzymes and substrates collide more often and with more energy. The rate increases until the optimal temperature is reached (EK 3.2.B.2). Above the optimum, the enzyme begins to denature and the rate falls rapidly, often to zero within about ten degrees. A human enzyme works best near 37 °C. Enzymes of bacteria that live in hot springs have optima above 70 °C, because their proteins are held together by extra stabilizing interactions. Each enzyme also has an optimal pH, matching where it works: pepsin works in the stomach at about pH 2, and trypsin in the small intestine at about pH 8.

Worked example · Reading a temperature curve and calculating Q10

The table shows the rate of an enzyme-catalyzed reaction at different temperatures. Describe the data, explain the shape of the graph, and calculate the factor by which the rate increases for each 10 °C rise between 20 and 40 °C (\(Q_{10} = R_2/R_1\)).

Temperature (°C)102030405060
Rate (\(\mu\)mol/min)1.12.34.68.93.10.2

Describe. The rate roughly doubles with every 10 °C from 10 to 40 °C (from 1.1 to 8.9 \(\mu\)mol/min), peaks at about 40 °C, then drops sharply to 3.1 at 50 °C and 0.2 at 60 °C.
Explain. From 10 to 40 °C, higher temperature increases the speed of the molecules, so there are more collisions between enzyme and substrate and more of them have enough energy to react. Above about 40 °C the heat disrupts the hydrogen bonds that hold the active site in shape, so the enzyme denatures and fewer molecules are active.
Calculate \(Q_{10}\). From 20 to 30 °C: \(4.6/2.3 = 2.0\). From 30 to 40 °C: \(8.9/4.6 = 1.9\). The rate about doubles per 10 °C rise below the optimum.
Careful. The decline from 40 to 60 °C is not a slower reaction but a loss of working enzyme: it would not recover if the sample were cooled to 30 °C.

Worked example · Matching enzyme to environment

The table gives the relative activity (percent of maximum) of two digestive enzymes at different pH values. Identify which is pepsin (stomach) and which is trypsin (small intestine), and predict what happens to pepsin that is swept into the small intestine.

pH1235789
Enzyme P (% of maximum)55100656000
Enzyme T (% of maximum)00286510080

Identify. Enzyme P is pepsin: it is most active at pH 2, the acidic pH of the stomach. Enzyme T is trypsin: it is most active at pH 8, the slightly basic pH of the small intestine.
Predict. Pepsin that enters the small intestine (pH about 8) would have almost no activity (0 percent at pH 8 in the table).
Justify. At the higher pH the charges on the R groups of the enzyme change, which alters the ionic and hydrogen bonds that hold the active site in shape; the substrate no longer fits well, so the enzyme cannot catalyze the reaction. This protects the intestine’s own cells from digestion.

Concentrations of substrate and product

The cellular environment includes the amounts of substrate and product. The relative concentrations of substrates and products determine how efficiently an enzymatic reaction proceeds (EK 3.2.B.1). At a low substrate concentration the enzyme molecules are mostly empty, so adding substrate raises the rate quickly. At a high substrate concentration nearly every active site is occupied, and the enzyme is saturated; more substrate cannot raise the rate, which levels off at the maximum rate. Adding more enzyme at that point would raise it again. If a product builds up and is not removed, the reverse reaction becomes more likely and the net rate falls, which is why cells keep passing products on to the next step (lesson 3.3).

Inhibitors

Required content · EK 3.2.B.3

Competitive inhibitor molecules can bind reversibly to the active site of the enzyme. Noncompetitive inhibitors can bind to allosteric sites (a site other than the active site), changing the activity of the enzyme.

No inhibitorsubstrate binds and is convertedenzymeCompetitive inhibitorblocks the active siteenzymeNoncompetitive inhibitorbinds at another siteenzymesubstrateinhibitorinhibitor binds theallosteric sitereaction proceedssubstrate is blockedactive site no longer fits
Figure 3.2b A competitive inhibitor resembles the substrate and binds reversibly to the active site, so the two compete. A noncompetitive inhibitor binds to an allosteric site elsewhere on the enzyme and changes its activity even when the active site is open.

A competitive inhibitor has a shape and charge similar to the substrate, so it fits the active site and takes the place of the substrate, as a wrong key that fits the lock but does not turn. It is reversible: if the amount of substrate is increased enough, the substrate outcompetes the inhibitor. A noncompetitive inhibitor binds elsewhere and alters the shape of the active site, so extra substrate cannot overcome it. Many cells use this idea on purpose. In feedback inhibition, the end product of a pathway binds to an allosteric site on an early enzyme and shuts it off when there is enough product, so the cell does not waste resources. Many drugs are enzyme inhibitors; statins, for example, compete with the substrate of an enzyme that makes cholesterol.

020406080100010203040Substrate concentration (mM)Reaction rate (µmol/min)no inhibitorcompetitive: same maximum,needs more substratenoncompetitive: lower maximum
Figure 3.2c Model curves: rate = Vmax·S/(Km + S). A competitive inhibitor can be overcome by adding more substrate, so the maximum rate is unchanged. A noncompetitive inhibitor disables some of the enzyme molecules, so the maximum rate drops and extra substrate cannot fix it.
Worked example · Identifying the type of inhibitor from data

An enzyme was tested at different substrate concentrations with no inhibitor, with inhibitor X, and with inhibitor Y (rates in \(\mu\)mol/min). Decide which inhibitor is competitive and which is noncompetitive, and justify.

Substrate (mM)12481632
No inhibitor33.350.066.780.088.994.1
Inhibitor X14.325.040.057.172.784.2
Inhibitor Y16.725.033.340.044.447.1

Inhibitor X is competitive. It lowers the rate at low substrate concentrations (14.3 compared with 33.3 at 1 mM) but the rate keeps climbing toward the same maximum as the uninhibited enzyme (84.2 compared with 94.1 at 32 mM). More substrate overcomes it because the substrate competes for the same active site.
Inhibitor Y is noncompetitive. The rate levels off at about half the uninhibited value (47.1 compared with 94.1 at 32 mM) no matter how much substrate is added. The inhibitor disables a fraction of the enzyme molecules at an allosteric site, so the maximum rate is lower and additional substrate cannot restore it.

Exam focus
  • Denaturation changes the shape of the enzyme by breaking hydrogen bonds and other weak interactions, so the substrate no longer fits the active site. The peptide bonds stay intact.
  • For a temperature curve, explain both halves: the rise (more collisions and energy) and the fall (denaturation). Name the optimum.
  • An enzyme’s optimum pH reflects where it works. Predict that an enzyme is inactive far outside its optimum, and say why (the charges on R groups change).
  • The curve that levels off against substrate concentration means the enzymes are saturated. Increase the enzyme to raise the maximum.
  • Competitive: binds the active site; overcome by more substrate; maximum rate unchanged. Noncompetitive: binds an allosteric site; not overcome; maximum rate decreases.
Practice
  1. Explain why boiling an enzyme destroys its activity, even though no peptide bonds are broken.
    Show answer

    Heat disrupts the hydrogen bonds and other weak interactions that hold the enzyme in its folded tertiary structure. The protein unfolds, so the active site loses its shape and the substrate can no longer bind. The amino acid sequence (peptide bonds) is the same, but the function depends on the shape.

  2. An enzyme with an optimum of 37 °C is warmed from 20 °C to 35 °C and then to 55 °C. Describe the effect on its rate in each step and explain.
    Show answer

    From 20 to 35 °C the rate increases because molecules move faster, so collisions between enzyme and substrate are more frequent and energetic. From 35 to 55 °C, the rate drops sharply because the heat denatures the enzyme by disrupting its hydrogen bonds, so fewer molecules have a functional active site.

  3. The rate of an enzyme at 20 °C is 3.0 \(\mu\)mol/min and at 30 °C is 5.7 \(\mu\)mol/min. Calculate \(Q_{10}\) and say whether the result is typical.
    Show answer

    \(Q_{10} = 5.7/3.0 = 1.9\). This is typical: the rate of an enzyme-catalyzed reaction about doubles for each 10 °C rise in temperature below the optimum.

  4. A rate versus substrate concentration graph levels off at 90 \(\mu\)mol/min. Explain why, and state two ways to raise the maximum rate.
    Show answer

    At high substrate concentration all of the active sites are occupied, so the enzyme is saturated and extra substrate cannot increase the rate. The maximum rate can be raised by adding more enzyme (more active sites) or by changing the temperature or pH toward the optimum if they are not already at it.

  5. An inhibitor is added to an enzyme-catalyzed reaction. At a very high substrate concentration, the rate returns to the same maximum as without the inhibitor. Identify the inhibitor type and explain.
    Show answer

    It is a competitive inhibitor. It binds reversibly to the active site, so it competes with the substrate. At very high substrate concentrations, substrate molecules far outnumber inhibitor molecules and occupy almost all active sites, so the rate approaches the normal maximum.

  6. An end product of a metabolic pathway binds to the first enzyme of the pathway at a site away from its active site, and the first enzyme slows down. Name this regulation and explain its benefit.
    Show answer

    It is feedback inhibition by noncompetitive (allosteric) regulation. When the product is plentiful it turns down the first enzyme, so the cell does not waste substrate and energy making more than it needs. When the product is used up, the inhibitor leaves and the pathway speeds up again.

Lesson 3.3 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.3

Cellular energy and ATP

A living cell is a highly organized structure that does not stay organized on its own. Left alone, a pile of bricks does not become a wall, and a dead cell falls apart. Staying alive means continually spending energy on keeping order: building molecules, pumping ions, moving organelles, copying DNA. This lesson is about where that energy comes from, how it is passed around, and why a cell that stops getting it dies.

Learning objectives · 3.3.A and 3.3.B

3.3.A Describe the role of energy in living organisms. All living systems require an input of energy (EK 3.3.A.1). Life requires a highly ordered system and does not violate the first and second laws of thermodynamics (EK 3.3.A.2). Energy-related pathways are sequential to allow a more controlled transfer of energy (EK 3.3.A.3). 3.3.B Explain how shared, conserved, and fundamental processes support common ancestry for all organisms. Core metabolic pathways (for example glycolysis and oxidative phosphorylation) are conserved across all current domains (EK 3.3.B.1). The CED notes that the equation for Gibbs free energy is beyond the scope of the exam; the concept of energy is not.

Energy and order: two laws of thermodynamics

The first law of thermodynamics says that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed from one form to another. A cell does not make energy. It takes in energy (chemical energy in food, or light energy in photosynthesis) and changes it into other forms: the chemical energy of ATP, the movement of motor proteins, the electrical energy of a nerve signal, and heat. The second law says that every energy transfer increases the disorder (entropy) of the universe, and that some energy ends up as heat that cannot be used to do more work.

Required content · EK 3.3.A.2
  • Life requires a highly ordered system and does not violate the first and second laws of thermodynamics.
  • Energy input must exceed energy loss to maintain order and to power cellular processes.
  • Cellular processes that release energy may be coupled with cellular processes that require energy.
  • A significant loss of order or energy flow results in death.

How can a cell stay organized if everything tends toward disorder? It does so by being an open system. A cell takes in organized, energy-rich molecules and releases heat and disordered waste (carbon dioxide and water). The order inside the cell is paid for by an even larger increase in disorder outside it, so the total disorder of the universe still increases, and the second law is not broken. Take away the energy supply, and the cell cannot keep up the order, and it dies. This is why every organism needs a constant input of energy: light for photosynthetic organisms, chemical energy in food for the rest.

ATP: the cell’s energy currency

A cell cannot use the energy in a glucose molecule directly. It would be like paying for a snack with a car. Instead, energy from food or light is first used to make ATP (adenosine triphosphate), a molecule that holds a small, usable amount of energy and is spent where it is needed. ATP has an adenine base, a ribose sugar, and a chain of three phosphate groups (it is a modified nucleotide, as in lesson 1.6). The terminal phosphate is joined to the rest by a bond that releases energy when it is broken by water (hydrolysis), because the phosphate groups are all negatively charged and repel one another.

AdenineRibosePPPATPadenosine triphosphatehydrolysis (+ H2O)phosphorylationAdenineRibosePPADP+PPiEnergy released is used for work:movement, active transport, synthesisEnergy to rebuild ATP comes from:cellular respiration or the light reactions
Figure 3.3a ATP is the cell’s energy currency. Breaking the bond to its terminal phosphate releases energy that is used to do work; the cell remakes ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate (Pi) using energy from food or light. A working cell recycles its whole ATP supply many times a day.

The cell does not store a large amount of ATP. A typical cell holds only a few seconds’ supply, and it constantly re-makes ATP from ADP and Pi. Adding a phosphate to ADP needs energy, which comes from cellular respiration or photosynthesis (lessons 3.4 to 3.7). In this way, ATP carries energy from the pathways that capture it to the processes that use it.

Coupled reactions

Many essential reactions in a cell, such as joining amino acids or pumping ions uphill, require energy. The cell makes them happen by coupling them to a reaction that releases energy, usually the hydrolysis of ATP (EK 3.3.A.2.ii). In many cases a phosphate group is transferred from ATP to the other molecule, which makes it more reactive.

Energy-releasing reactionEnergy-requiring reactionATP + H2OADP + Pienergy releasedglucose + Piglucose phosphateenergy requiredcoupled
Figure 3.3b In a coupled reaction the energy released by ATP hydrolysis drives an energy-requiring reaction. Typically the phosphate from ATP is transferred to the other molecule, making it more reactive. Energy-requiring processes in cells (building polymers, pumping ions, moving) are all powered this way.
Worked example · Coupling an energy-requiring reaction to ATP

Phosphorylating glucose to make glucose phosphate requires about 13.8 kJ per mole. The hydrolysis of ATP to ADP and Pi releases about 30.5 kJ per mole. Calculate the energy change when the two reactions are coupled, and explain why the coupled reaction proceeds.

Calculation. The energy released is 30.5 kJ/mol and the energy required is 13.8 kJ/mol, so the net is \(30.5 - 13.8 = 16.7\) kJ/mol of energy released.
Explanation. Alone, the phosphorylation of glucose would not occur, because it needs energy. Coupled to ATP hydrolysis, the total process releases energy, so it proceeds. The enzyme (a kinase) binds both glucose and ATP and transfers the phosphate group. Note that the numbers show only the direction of the coupled reaction; you do not need to use a Gibbs equation on the exam.

Metabolic pathways: small steps

Required content · EK 3.3.A.3

Energy-related pathways in biological systems are sequential, which allows a more controlled transfer of energy. A product of a reaction in a metabolic pathway is typically the reactant for the subsequent step in the pathway.

Burning glucose in a flame releases its energy all at once as heat. A cell breaks glucose down in many small steps, each with its own enzyme, and captures part of the energy at each one in ATP and in electron carriers (lesson 3.6). This avoids a wasteful burst of heat and lets the cell control the speed of the whole pathway by controlling a single step. In a pathway \(A \rightarrow B \rightarrow C \rightarrow D\), compound B is the product of the first enzyme and the substrate of the second. If the enzyme that makes C from B is missing or blocked, B accumulates and neither C nor D is made, which is how scientists have worked out the order of steps in many pathways.

Conserved pathways and common ancestry

Glycolysis (the first stage of glucose breakdown) is found in organisms from all three domains: Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya, and the reactions are nearly the same in each. So is the electron transport chain with ATP synthase that makes most of the ATP (oxidative phosphorylation in aerobic respiration). A pathway that is nearly the same in a bacterium, a yeast, and a human is a shared, conserved feature, and the most likely explanation is that it was present in their common ancestor and inherited by all of its descendants (EK 3.3.B.1). The ATP molecule itself is the energy currency of all known life.

Worked example · An energy budget for an endotherm and an ectotherm

An endotherm (a 25 g mouse, which keeps its body warm with its own metabolism) uses about 18 kJ per day for maintenance. An ectotherm (a 25 g lizard, which takes heat from its environment) uses about 1.2 kJ per day. Suppose each animal takes in and absorbs an amount of food energy, the mouse 22 kJ per day and the lizard 2.0 kJ per day. Calculate the energy left for growth and reproduction for each, as a percent of the energy absorbed, and compare the maintenance costs.

Mouse. \(22 - 18 = 4\) kJ per day left. \(4/22 \times 100 = 18.2\) percent of the absorbed energy.
Lizard. \(2.0 - 1.2 = 0.8\) kJ per day left. \(0.8/2.0 \times 100 = 40\) percent.
Maintenance comparison. \(18 / 1.2 = 15\), so the mouse spends 15 times as much energy as the lizard per day to stay alive.
Interpretation. The endotherm pays a high cost to keep its body temperature high and steady, which lets it stay active in the cold, but means it must eat a lot, and leaves a smaller fraction of its energy for growth and reproduction. The ectotherm uses far less energy, so it can spend a larger fraction on growth and reproduction, but its activity depends on the temperature of its surroundings. In both, energy input exceeds energy loss, which is the requirement of EK 3.3.A.2.

Worked example · Why growth does not violate the second law

A student writes: “A growing seedling becomes more organized, so living things break the second law of thermodynamics.” Evaluate the claim.

Evaluation. The claim is incorrect. The second law applies to the total disorder of the whole system, including the surroundings. The seedling is an open system: it takes in light energy, which it captures in photosynthesis, and it releases heat and other waste. The order that it builds inside is paid for by a larger increase in disorder outside (the sun’s energy being turned into heat). Total disorder still increases, so there is no violation. If the energy supply stopped, the seedling could not keep its order and would die.

Exam focus
  • To explain how life does not violate the second law: an open system with a continuous energy input, and heat released to the surroundings.
  • Energy input must exceed energy loss. A loss of energy flow or order leads to death.
  • ATP is the energy currency: it carries energy from energy-releasing processes (respiration, light reactions) to energy-requiring ones (synthesis, transport, movement). The cell recycles it between ATP and ADP + Pi.
  • Coupling = an energy-releasing reaction (ATP hydrolysis) drives an energy-requiring one. State both halves.
  • Pathways are sequential: the product of one step is the reactant of the next, so a block at one step makes the earlier intermediate build up.
  • Glycolysis and oxidative phosphorylation are conserved across Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya: evidence of common ancestry.
Practice
  1. Explain why organisms need a constant input of energy even if they are not growing.
    Show answer

    A living system is highly ordered and tends toward disorder, so it must keep spending energy to maintain order (repairing and making molecules, pumping ions, keeping gradients). Energy input must exceed energy loss, and a significant loss of order or energy flow results in death.

  2. Describe how ATP stores and releases energy, and how the cell regenerates it.
    Show answer

    ATP has three phosphate groups; hydrolysis of the terminal phosphate bond releases energy and forms ADP and inorganic phosphate (Pi). The cell regenerates ATP by adding a phosphate to ADP, using energy from the breakdown of food (cellular respiration) or from light (photosynthesis).

  3. An energy-requiring reaction needs 20 kJ/mol. The hydrolysis of ATP releases 30.5 kJ/mol. Calculate the net energy change if the two are coupled, and say whether the coupled reaction can proceed.
    Show answer

    Net energy released: \(30.5 - 20 = 10.5\) kJ/mol. Because the coupled process releases energy overall, it can proceed.

  4. In a metabolic pathway \(A \rightarrow B \rightarrow C \rightarrow D\), a mutant lacks the enzyme that converts B to C. Predict which compounds accumulate and which are absent, and justify.
    Show answer

    B accumulates (it is made but not used), while C and D are not made, so they are absent or very low. Each product is the reactant for the next step, so a block at one step stops everything downstream of it and causes the compound before it to build up.

  5. A student claims that because a bacterium and a human both carry out glycolysis, the human must have gotten glycolysis from the bacterium. Evaluate the claim and give a better explanation.
    Show answer

    The claim is not supported. The shared pathway is better explained by common ancestry: it was already present in a common ancestor of both and was inherited by its descendants, so glycolysis is conserved across the domains. It is evidence for common ancestry, not for transfer from one to the other.

  6. Two animals have the same mass. One is an endotherm and one an ectotherm. Compare their energy needs for maintenance and explain the difference.
    Show answer

    The endotherm uses much more energy for maintenance, because it uses its own metabolism to produce heat and keep a high, steady body temperature. The ectotherm relies on heat from the environment, so its metabolic needs are much lower. The endotherm must eat far more to meet its needs.

Lesson 3.4 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.4

Photosynthesis I: capturing light energy

Nearly all the energy that runs life on Earth started as sunlight. Plants, algae, and cyanobacteria are the organisms that catch it. They use light to turn carbon dioxide and water into sugar and release oxygen, and everything that eats them, directly or not, lives on that sugar. Photosynthesis happens in two linked stages. This lesson covers the first, the light reactions, which turn light into chemical energy; lesson 3.5 covers the second, which uses that energy to build sugar.

Learning objectives · 3.4.A and 3.4.B

3.4.A Describe the photosynthetic processes and structural features of the chloroplast that allow organisms to capture and store energy (EK 3.4.A.1 to 3.4.A.3). 3.4.B Explain how cells capture energy from light and transfer it to biological molecules for storage and use (EK 3.4.B.1 to 3.4.B.6). The CED excludes memorizing the steps of the Calvin cycle, the structures of its molecules, enzyme names (except ATP synthase), and the full names of the specific electron carriers.

The big picture

Required content · EK 3.4.A.1

Photosynthesis is the series of reactions that use carbon dioxide (CO2), water (H2O), and light energy to make carbohydrates and oxygen (O2). \(6\,\text{CO}_2 + 6\,\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{light energy} \rightarrow \text{C}_6\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_6 + 6\,\text{O}_2\).

  • Photosynthetic organisms capture energy from the sun and produce sugars that can be used in biological processes or stored.
  • Photosynthesis first evolved in prokaryotic organisms. Scientific evidence supports the claim that prokaryotic (cyanobacterial) photosynthesis was responsible for the production of an oxygenated atmosphere.
  • Prokaryotic photosynthetic pathways were the foundation of eukaryotic photosynthesis.

In terms of electrons: water gives up electrons (it is oxidized to O2), and CO2 gains them (it is reduced to sugar). Light energy is what drives electrons uphill. The light reactions do two jobs: they split water to get electrons, and they use the energy of light to make ATP and NADPH, an electron carrier that holds energy-rich electrons. The Calvin cycle (lesson 3.5) then uses the ATP and NADPH to build carbohydrate.

The chloroplast: structure fits function

Outer membraneInner membraneStromaThylakoid membraneGranum (stack of thylakoids)Thylakoid space (lumen)(Calvin cycle occurs here)
Figure 3.4a The chloroplast has a double membrane. Inside is the fluid stroma, where the Calvin cycle (carbon fixation) occurs, and flattened sacs called thylakoids stacked into grana. The light reactions happen in the thylakoid membranes, which contain chlorophyll organized into photosystems and the electron transport chain.
Required content · EK 3.4.A.2
  • The stroma is the fluid within the inner chloroplast membrane and outside the thylakoid. The carbon fixation (Calvin cycle) reactions occur in the stroma.
  • The thylakoid membranes contain chlorophyll pigments organized into two photosystems, as well as electron transport proteins.
  • Thylakoids are organized into stacks called grana. The light reactions occur in the grana.

The chloroplast has a double membrane, like the mitochondrion (lesson 2.1), and its internal membrane system has a clear job. The stack of thylakoid sacs gives a very large membrane area for pigments and proteins, in the same way that cristae do in a mitochondrion. The sealed space inside each thylakoid is the compartment where protons will accumulate, and the stroma is the space where sugar is made. Because the two compartments are separate, a gradient can form between them.

Capturing light: pigments and photosystems

Light is a form of energy that comes in packets called photons, and the energy of a photon depends on its wavelength. A pigment absorbs only some wavelengths. Chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b absorb mainly blue-violet and red light and reflect green, which is why leaves are green. Accessory pigments, such as carotenoids, absorb other wavelengths and pass the energy to chlorophyll. When a pigment absorbs a photon, one of its electrons is boosted to a higher energy level. This excited electron is the energy that the chloroplast uses.

00.51400450500550600650700Wavelength of light (nm)Relative absorption or rategreen: little absorbedchlorophyll achlorophyll bcarotenoidsaction spectrum
Figure 3.4c Chlorophylls absorb mostly blue and red light and reflect green, which is why leaves look green. Accessory pigments such as carotenoids absorb other blue-green wavelengths and pass the energy on. The action spectrum (the rate of photosynthesis at each wavelength) closely follows the combined absorption of the pigments. (Schematic curves.)

The pigments are organized with proteins into two photosystems, photosystem II (PSII) and photosystem I (PSI), which are embedded in the thylakoid membranes (EK 3.4.B.3). (They are named in the order they were discovered, not the order in which electrons pass through them.)

Worked example · Engelmann’s experiment: from absorption to action

In 1882 Theodor Engelmann passed light through a prism so that different colors fell on different parts of a filament of green alga, in a drop of water containing aerobic bacteria that move toward oxygen. He counted the bacteria that gathered at each part of the filament (a modern version of the data is given). Interpret the results.

Color (wavelength, nm)Violet-blue (450)Blue-green (500)Green (550)Orange (600)Red (650)Far red (700)
Bacteria gathered11835204810530

Describe. Most bacteria gathered in the violet-blue (118) and red (105) regions, and the fewest in green (20).
Interpret. The bacteria are attracted to oxygen, so more bacteria means more oxygen produced, and so more photosynthesis. Photosynthesis is fastest in blue and red light and slowest in green light.
Connect. The pattern of the rate of photosynthesis (the action spectrum) matches the wavelengths absorbed by chlorophyll. This supports the conclusion that chlorophyll is the main pigment that captures light energy for photosynthesis, and that green light is mostly reflected, not used.

Worked example · Separating pigments by paper chromatography

A leaf extract is spotted on chromatography paper, and the solvent travels 8.0 cm. Four pigment bands are found at distances of 7.6, 5.2, 3.6, and 2.8 cm from the spot. Calculate the \(R_f\) value of each (\(R_f = \) distance moved by the pigment / distance moved by the solvent) and explain why the pigments separate.

Carotene. \(7.6/8.0 = 0.95\). Xanthophyll. \(5.2/8.0 = 0.65\). Chlorophyll a. \(3.6/8.0 = 0.45\). Chlorophyll b. \(2.8/8.0 = 0.35\).
Explain. The pigments dissolve in the solvent to different extents and stick to the polar paper to different extents. A pigment that is more soluble in the (nonpolar) solvent and less attracted to the paper travels farther and has a higher \(R_f\). Carotene, the least polar, is carried almost to the solvent front, while chlorophyll b, the most polar of these, moves the least. \(R_f\) is always between 0 and 1 and has no units.

The light reactions step by step

Stroma (lower H+)Thylakoid space (higher H+)PSIIETCPSIATP synthaselightlight2 H2O → O2 + 4 H+ + 4 e−NADP+ + H+ + 2 e− → NADPHETC pumps H+into the spaceH+ flows outthrough ATP synthaseADP + Pi → ATP
Figure 3.4b Light excites electrons in photosystems II and I. Water is split to replace the electrons lost by photosystem II, releasing O2 and H+. The electrons move through the electron transport chain, which pumps H+ into the thylakoid space; at photosystem I they are passed on to NADP+, making NADPH. H+ flows back to the stroma through ATP synthase (chemiosmosis), which makes ATP (photophosphorylation).
Required content · EK 3.4.A.3 and 3.4.B.1 to 3.4.B.5
  1. Light absorption. Chlorophylls absorb energy from light, boosting electrons to a higher energy level in photosystems II and I.
  2. Water splitting. Water is split, which supplies electrons to replace those lost from photosystem II. Oxygen (O2) and H+ are released.
  3. Electron transport chain (ETC). Photosystems I and II are connected by the transfer of electrons through an ETC embedded in the thylakoid membrane. As electrons are transferred between molecules in a series of oxidation-reduction (redox) reactions, they lose energy.
  4. Proton gradient. The released energy is used to move protons (H+) across the thylakoid membrane. An electrochemical gradient of protons is established: a region of low proton concentration outside the thylakoid (the stroma) and a region of high proton concentration inside the thylakoid.
  5. ATP synthesis. Protons flow back through ATP synthase, a membrane-bound protein, by chemiosmosis. The flow drives the formation of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate (photophosphorylation).
  6. NADPH. At photosystem I, the electrons are boosted again and are ultimately transferred to NADP+, reducing it to NADPH.

The energy captured in the light reactions and held in ATP and NADPH powers the production of carbohydrates from carbon dioxide in the Calvin cycle, which occurs in the stroma (EK 3.4.B.6).

You can think of the process as a hydroelectric dam. Light energy pushes electrons through the ETC, which acts as a pump moving protons uphill into a small space, like water piled up behind a dam. The protons can only go back down through ATP synthase, like the water passing through a turbine, and the flow makes ATP. Notice that the same idea, an ETC building a proton gradient that powers ATP synthase, will appear again in the mitochondrion (lesson 3.7). It occurs in chloroplasts, in mitochondria, and across the plasma membranes of prokaryotes (EK 3.4.B.1).

Worked example · Evidence for chemiosmosis: the acid-bath experiment

Andre Jagendorf soaked isolated thylakoids in a solution at pH 4 in the dark until the inside of the thylakoids was also pH 4. He then moved them quickly into a solution at pH 8 that contained ADP and Pi, still in the dark. ATP was produced. Explain what the experiment shows.

Reasoning. The thylakoid space was acidic (pH 4, high H+ concentration) and the surrounding solution was basic (pH 8, low H+), so a proton gradient existed across the membrane without any light. The protons flowed out through ATP synthase, and ATP was made.
Conclusion. A proton gradient alone is enough to drive ATP synthesis. Light is not needed for the last step; light only makes the gradient (by driving electron transport). This supports the chemiosmotic model.

Worked example · Predict a disruption

The herbicide DCMU blocks the transfer of electrons from photosystem II into the electron transport chain. Predict the effects on oxygen release, ATP and NADPH production, and the Calvin cycle.

Prediction. With electron flow blocked, the proton gradient cannot form, so ATP synthase makes little ATP. Without a flow of electrons to photosystem I, NADPH is not made. The Calvin cycle needs ATP and NADPH, so sugar production stops. Oxygen release also stops because photosystem II is no longer cycling electrons, so water is not split. Justification. The light reactions are a single chain of linked steps: a block at the start stops everything downstream (a pathway, as in lesson 3.3). The Calvin cycle can fail even if the plant has plenty of CO2, since it depends on the products of the light reactions.

An oxygenated Earth

The first photosynthetic organisms were prokaryotes. Cyanobacteria evolved a form of photosynthesis that splits water and releases oxygen. Over hundreds of millions of years, this oxygen entered the oceans and then the atmosphere. Evidence includes banded iron formations in ancient rocks (iron that rusted as oxygen was released into the oceans), fossilized microbial mats called stromatolites, and the rise of oxygen-requiring organisms. The rise in oxygen began about 2.4 billion years ago, and it made aerobic respiration (lessons 3.6 and 3.7) possible. Eukaryotic photosynthesis arose later, when a eukaryotic cell took in a cyanobacterium that became the chloroplast (lesson 2.10), so the plant light reactions are an inheritance of the prokaryotic pathway.

Exam focus
  • Know the locations: light reactions in the thylakoid membranes (grana); Calvin cycle in the stroma. Inputs of the light reactions: light, H2O, ADP + Pi, NADP+. Outputs: O2, ATP, NADPH.
  • The oxygen comes from water, not from CO2. Water is the source of electrons that replace those lost from photosystem II.
  • The proton gradient: high H+ inside the thylakoid, low in the stroma. ATP is made when protons flow back through ATP synthase (chemiosmosis).
  • An action spectrum follows chlorophyll absorption: high in blue and red, low in green.
  • Questions on a disruption (a herbicide, a leaky membrane, no light) want you to follow the chain: electron flow, gradient, ATP and NADPH, Calvin cycle.
  • Cyanobacteria were the first organisms to release O2 by photosynthesis, which oxygenated the atmosphere.
Practice
  1. State the inputs and outputs of the light reactions and where they occur.
    Show answer

    Inputs: light energy, water, ADP + Pi, and NADP+. Outputs: O2, ATP, and NADPH. They occur in the thylakoid membranes of the chloroplast (in the grana).

  2. Explain how the electron transport chain in a thylakoid leads to the formation of ATP.
    Show answer

    As electrons pass through the chain in redox reactions, the energy released is used to move H+ across the thylakoid membrane into the thylakoid space, producing a proton gradient. The protons flow back to the stroma through ATP synthase by chemiosmosis, and this flow drives the formation of ATP from ADP and Pi.

  3. In an experiment, plants are given water containing a heavy isotope of oxygen (18O) and CO2 with ordinary oxygen. Predict which molecule contains the 18O in the products and justify.
    Show answer

    The 18O appears in the O2 released. The O2 comes from the splitting of water in photosystem II (the source of the electrons), not from CO2. (Some of the labeled oxygen is later in sugar and water through other reactions, but the O2 gas is the direct evidence.)

  4. A pigment extract is run on chromatography paper. The solvent front moves 10.0 cm and a pigment moves 4.5 cm. Calculate its Rf.
    Show answer

    \(R_f = 4.5/10.0 = 0.45\).

  5. A student claims that green light is the most efficient for photosynthesis because leaves are green. Evaluate the claim.
    Show answer

    The claim is wrong. Leaves look green because chlorophyll reflects green light and absorbs mainly blue and red. The action spectrum shows the highest rates of photosynthesis in blue and red light and the lowest in green, so green light is the least efficient.

  6. Explain why a leaky thylakoid membrane (permeable to protons) would reduce the production of ATP, even in bright light.
    Show answer

    ATP synthase needs a proton gradient: a high concentration of H+ inside the thylakoid and low in the stroma. If the membrane leaks, protons flow back without passing through ATP synthase, so the gradient cannot be maintained and little ATP is made, even though the electron transport chain is still working.

Lesson 3.5 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.4

Photosynthesis II: the Calvin cycle and measuring photosynthesis

The light reactions leave the chloroplast with a supply of ATP and NADPH but no sugar. Turning CO2 into sugar is the job of the second stage, the Calvin cycle. This stage does not use light directly, but it cannot run without the products of the light reactions. On the exam you will not be asked to name the molecules in the cycle, but you will be asked what goes in, what comes out, where it happens, and what happens to it when conditions change.

Learning objective · 3.4.A and 3.4.B (continued)

EK 3.4.A.2: the carbon fixation (Calvin cycle) reactions of photosynthesis occur in the stroma. EK 3.4.B.6: the energy captured in the light reactions and transferred to ATP and NADPH powers the production of carbohydrates from carbon dioxide in the Calvin cycle. Memorization of the steps, the structures of the molecules, and the names of the enzymes is beyond the scope of the exam.

Three phases

1. Carbon fixationCO2 joins a 5-carbon sugar2. ReductionATP + NADPH make G3P3. RegenerationATP rebuilds the 5-C sugarCO2 inATP and NADPHfrom the light reactionsG3P out(makes glucoseand other sugars)Calvin cycle(in the stroma)3 CO2 in, 1 G3P out (3 turns); 6 turns supply the 6 carbons of one glucose.
Figure 3.5a The Calvin cycle uses the ATP and NADPH from the light reactions to build carbohydrate from CO2. It takes place in the stroma. You do not need to memorize the intermediate molecules or enzymes (the CED excludes them), but you must know the inputs, outputs, location, and why it depends on the light reactions.

The cycle can be described in three phases:

  1. Carbon fixation. CO2 from the air is attached to an existing five-carbon sugar. Fixation means taking carbon from an inorganic form (a gas) and putting it into an organic molecule. The resulting six-carbon compound splits at once into two three-carbon molecules. The enzyme that does this, called rubisco, is the most abundant protein on Earth, but its name is not needed for the exam.
  2. Reduction. The three-carbon molecules are converted to a three-carbon sugar called G3P (glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate). Here the ATP and NADPH from the light reactions are used: ATP supplies energy, and NADPH supplies the electrons that reduce the carbon.
  3. Regeneration. Most of the G3P is not removed but rearranged, using more ATP, to remake the five-carbon sugar so the cycle can keep going. For every three CO2 fixed, one G3P leaves the cycle.

The G3P that leaves is the starting point for the cell’s organic molecules: two G3P can be joined into glucose, and the carbon can also be built into sucrose (for transport), starch (for storage), cellulose (for the cell wall), amino acids, and lipids. The ADP and NADP+ that the cycle produces go back to the light reactions to be recharged.

Light reactionsCalvin cycle
LocationThylakoid membranes (grana)Stroma
Needs light directly?YesNo (but depends on the ATP and NADPH made in the light)
InputsLight, H2O, ADP + Pi, NADP+CO2, ATP, NADPH
OutputsO2, ATP, NADPHG3P (sugar), ADP + Pi, NADP+
ProcessCaptures energyFixes carbon and stores the energy in sugar
Worked example · Bookkeeping for one glucose

For each CO2 fixed, the Calvin cycle uses 3 ATP and 2 NADPH. Calculate the numbers of CO2, ATP, and NADPH needed to make one G3P, and then one glucose (which contains 6 carbons and is made from two G3P).

One G3P (3 carbons): 3 CO2 must be fixed. ATP: \(3 \times 3 = 9\). NADPH: \(3 \times 2 = 6\).
One glucose (6 carbons = 2 G3P): 6 CO2; ATP: \(6 \times 3 = 18\); NADPH: \(6 \times 2 = 12\).
Meaning. Every sugar molecule made in the Calvin cycle “costs” many ATP and NADPH, which must be supplied by the light reactions. If the light reactions slow down, for example in dim light, the supply falls, and the Calvin cycle slows. That is why light intensity limits the rate of photosynthesis even though the cycle itself does not use light.

Worked example · Where does the oxygen come from?

In an experiment, one group of algae was given water labeled with the heavy isotope 18O along with ordinary CO2. A second group was given ordinary water and CO2 labeled with 18O. The oxygen gas (O2) released by each group was tested. Group 1 released O2 containing 18O; group 2 released ordinary O2. Draw a conclusion.

Conclusion. The O2 released in photosynthesis comes from water, not from CO2. The labeled oxygen from CO2 (group 2) is found instead in the sugar and water produced by the Calvin cycle. This agrees with the light reactions, in which water is split.

Measuring the rate of photosynthesis

The rate of photosynthesis can be measured by the production of oxygen, the consumption of CO2, or the increase in biomass. A common investigation is the floating leaf-disk assay. Disks cut from a leaf are placed in a syringe with a bicarbonate solution (a source of CO2) and a vacuum is applied to remove air from the leaf tissue, so the disks sink. In light, photosynthesis produces O2, which collects in the leaf and makes the disks float. The time at which half of the disks are floating, called ET50, is a measure of the rate.

0246810048121620Time (minutes)Disks floating (of 10)brightmediumdim
Figure 3.5b In the floating leaf-disk assay, disks are first sunk by removing the air from their tissue. As photosynthesis makes oxygen, bubbles collect inside the leaf and the disks rise. The time for half of the disks to float (ET50) is a measure of the rate of photosynthesis: the shorter the time, the faster the rate.
Worked example · Analyzing a leaf-disk experiment

Ten disks were tested under three light intensities. The number floating at each time is in the table. Estimate ET50 for each (the time at which 5 disks are floating, by interpolation), and compare the rates.

Time (min)02468101214161820
Bright light012468910101010
Medium light0001246891010
Dim light00000012589

Bright light. 4 floating at 6 min and 6 at 8 min, so 5 floating at 7.0 min. ET50 = 7.0 min.
Medium light. 4 at 10 min and 6 at 12 min, so ET50 = 11.0 min.
Dim light. 5 floating at 16 min, so ET50 = 16.0 min.
Compare rates. Rate is proportional to 1/ET50: bright \(1/7.0 = 0.143\) min−1, medium \(1/11.0 = 0.091\), dim \(1/16.0 = 0.0625\). Bright light is \(16.0/7.0 = 2.3\) times as fast as dim light.
Explain. More light means more photons absorbed, a faster flow of electrons, more ATP and NADPH, and a faster Calvin cycle, so more O2 is made and the disks rise sooner.
Controls. Disks in bicarbonate solution kept in the dark (they should not float), and disks in plain water without bicarbonate (to show the effect of CO2). Temperature and the distance to the light must be the same in every trial.

Other factors have limiting effects. Rate increases with CO2 concentration until the enzymes of the Calvin cycle are saturated. Rate rises with temperature until the enzymes begin to denature (lesson 3.2). The rate of photosynthesis is set by whichever input is in shortest supply. Light intensity raises the rate at first, but once the light reactions are working at their maximum, a brighter light will not increase it.

Photosynthesis and respiration are linked

The products of photosynthesis (sugar and O2) are the inputs of cellular respiration, and the products of respiration (CO2 and H2O) are the inputs of photosynthesis. Plants carry out both: photosynthesis in the chloroplasts of green cells, and cellular respiration in the mitochondria of every cell, including the leaf cells. Plants make more sugar than they use, so they produce a net release of O2 in the light. The matter cycles through the ecosystem, but the energy does not: it enters as light and leaves as heat.

Extension (not required by the CED). In hot, dry weather a plant closes its stomata to save water, which stops CO2 from entering and lets O2 build up. The cycle’s enzyme then sometimes fixes O2 instead of CO2 (photorespiration), which wastes energy. Some plants avoid this by adaptations: C4 plants such as corn first fix CO2 in one set of cells and deliver it to the Calvin cycle in another, and CAM plants such as cacti open their stomata only at night.

Exam focus
  • Calvin cycle: stroma; inputs CO2, ATP, NADPH; output G3P (sugar). It does not use light directly but depends on the light reactions.
  • You do not need the intermediate molecules or enzyme names. You do need: fixing CO2 into an organic molecule, reduction by NADPH using ATP, and the cycle continuing.
  • The O2 comes from water; the carbon of the sugar comes from CO2.
  • Rate of photosynthesis: measured by O2 production, CO2 use, or leaf-disk ET50 (shorter time = faster rate). Say which variable is limiting.
  • On a graph of rate against light intensity, the curve rises and then plateaus: another factor (CO2, temperature, or the enzymes) becomes limiting.
  • Plants do cellular respiration too; photosynthesis stores energy, respiration releases it.
Practice
  1. Explain why the Calvin cycle stops soon after a plant is placed in the dark, even though the cycle does not use light directly.
    Show answer

    The Calvin cycle needs ATP and NADPH, which are made by the light reactions. In the dark the light reactions stop, the supply of ATP and NADPH runs out, and the cycle can no longer reduce carbon to make sugar.

  2. Describe what happens to the carbon in CO2 in the Calvin cycle and what leaves the cycle.
    Show answer

    CO2 is fixed: its carbon is attached to an existing organic molecule. The carbon is then reduced using ATP and NADPH to form G3P, a three-carbon sugar. G3P leaves the cycle to be used to make glucose and other organic molecules, while the rest is used to regenerate the starting molecule so the cycle continues.

  3. Calculate the ATP and NADPH needed to fix 12 molecules of CO2 (3 ATP and 2 NADPH per CO2), and the number of G3P made.
    Show answer

    ATP: \(12 \times 3 = 36\). NADPH: \(12 \times 2 = 24\). G3P: 3 CO2 make 1 G3P, so \(12 / 3 = 4\) G3P.

  4. In a leaf-disk assay, ET50 is 9 minutes at 25 °C and 15 minutes at 15 °C. Calculate the ratio of the rates and explain the result.
    Show answer

    Rate is proportional to \(1/\text{ET}_{50}\), so the ratio of rates (25 °C to 15 °C) is \(15/9 = 1.7\). The warmer disks photosynthesize about 1.7 times as fast, because higher temperature increases enzyme-substrate collisions and reaction rate, below the temperature that denatures enzymes.

  5. A researcher increases the light intensity to a very high level, but the rate of photosynthesis stops rising. Give a possible explanation and a way to test it.
    Show answer

    Another factor has become limiting, such as the CO2 concentration or the number of enzymes and photosystems working at maximum rate. To test it, raise the CO2 concentration (add more bicarbonate) at the same high light; if the rate rises, CO2 was limiting.

  6. Explain how the products of photosynthesis and cellular respiration are related.
    Show answer

    The sugar and O2 made by photosynthesis are the reactants of cellular respiration, and the CO2 and H2O made by respiration are the reactants of photosynthesis. Matter is cycled between the processes, while energy flows through: light energy is captured in sugar and eventually lost as heat.

Lesson 3.6 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.5

Cellular respiration I: harvesting energy from glucose

Every cell needs ATP, and most of it comes from the breakdown of food molecules. Cellular respiration is the set of reactions that transfers the energy stored in macromolecules, mostly glucose, to ATP. It is the reverse, in spirit, of photosynthesis: the sugar that the chloroplast built is taken apart again, and its energy is passed along in a series of small steps. Respiration is not the same as breathing. Breathing brings oxygen into the body; respiration is what the cells do with it.

Learning objectives · 3.5.A and 3.5.B

3.5.A Describe the processes and structural features of mitochondria that allow organisms to use energy stored in biological macromolecules (EK 3.5.A.1 to 3.5.A.3). 3.5.B Explain how cells obtain energy from biological macromolecules in order to power cellular functions (EK 3.5.B.1 to 3.5.B.6). The CED excludes memorizing the steps of glycolysis and the Krebs cycle, molecule structures, and enzyme names. Here the focus is on where each stage occurs, what goes in, and what comes out.

The overall reaction

Required content · EK 3.5.A.1 and 3.5.A.2
  • Cellular respiration uses energy from biological macromolecules to synthesize ATP. Respiration and fermentation are characteristic of all forms of life.
  • Aerobic cellular respiration in eukaryotes involves a series of coordinated enzyme-catalyzed reactions that capture energy from biological macromolecules.

The overall equation for aerobic respiration of glucose is \(\text{C}_6\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_6 + 6\,\text{O}_2 \rightarrow 6\,\text{CO}_2 + 6\,\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{energy (ATP and heat)}\). In terms of electrons, glucose is oxidized (it loses electrons, and hydrogens) and oxygen is reduced (it gains electrons and hydrogens to form water). The energy released by moving electrons from glucose to oxygen is captured in steps. Plants, animals, fungi, and many prokaryotes all do this, and some organisms that live without oxygen use another molecule in place of O2 (lesson 3.7). All cells carry out at least the first stage.

The cell does not move electrons directly. It uses carrier molecules: NAD+ picks up two electrons (and a proton) to become NADH, and FAD picks up electrons to become FADH2. These are the shuttles that carry high-energy electrons to the electron transport chain, where most of the ATP is made. ATP can also be made directly at a few steps by transferring a phosphate group from a substrate to ADP, called substrate-level phosphorylation.

Where it happens: the mitochondrion

Outer membrane (smooth)Intermembrane spaceInner membrane (folded)Cristae (folds)MatrixKrebs cycle occurs here
Figure 3.6a A mitochondrion has two membranes. The smooth outer membrane encloses the intermembrane space; the folded inner membrane (cristae) encloses the matrix. Folding increases the surface area of the inner membrane, which holds the electron transport chain and ATP synthase, so more ATP can be made.

The first stage, glycolysis, occurs in the cytosol. The rest of aerobic respiration takes place in the mitochondrion (lesson 2.1). The two membranes make separate compartments: the intermembrane space between the membranes, and the inner space, the matrix, which contains the enzymes of the Krebs cycle. The inner membrane is folded into cristae, which increase its surface area and hold the electron transport chain and ATP synthase (lesson 3.7). The compartments let a gradient of protons form across the inner membrane.

Glycolysiscytosolglucose (6 C) in2 ATP net2 NADH2 pyruvate (3 C)Pyruvate oxidationmitochondrial matrix2 pyruvate in2 NADH2 CO22 acetyl groups (2 C)Krebs cyclemitochondrial matrix2 acetyl groups in2 ATP6 NADH, 2 FADH24 CO2Electron transportinner membrane10 NADH + 2 FADH2 inO2 in, H2O outabout 26 to 28 ATPPer glucose: 6 CO2 released in all (2 + 4); 10 NADH + 2 FADH2 made; about 30 to 32 ATP in all(2 from glycolysis, 2 from the Krebs cycle, and about 26 to 28 from the electron transport chain)
Figure 3.6b Per molecule of glucose: glycolysis nets 2 ATP and 2 NADH; pyruvate oxidation makes 2 NADH; the Krebs cycle (two turns) makes 2 ATP, 6 NADH, and 2 FADH2; the 10 NADH and 2 FADH2 then deliver electrons to the electron transport chain. The exact ATP yield varies (the CED does not require a number); recent textbooks give about 30 to 32.

Stage 1: Glycolysis (cytosol)

Required content · EK 3.5.B.1

Glycolysis is a biochemical pathway that releases the energy in glucose molecules to form ATP (from ADP and inorganic phosphate), NADH (from NAD+), and pyruvate.

Glycolysis (“splitting sugar”) breaks the six-carbon glucose into two three-carbon molecules of pyruvate. It needs no oxygen and occurs in the cytosol. The cell first spends 2 ATP to start the process, and then makes 4 ATP, so the net gain is 2 ATP per glucose, together with 2 NADH. Glycolysis is conserved in organisms from all three domains (lesson 3.3), which suggests it is among the most ancient metabolic pathways.

Stage 2: Pyruvate oxidation and the Krebs cycle (mitochondrial matrix)

Required content · EK 3.5.B.2 and 3.5.B.3
  • Pyruvate is transported from the cytosol to the mitochondrion, where oxidation occurs. This process releases electrons during the Krebs (citric acid) cycle, reducing NAD+ to NADH and FAD to FADH2, and releasing CO2.
  • The Krebs cycle takes place in the mitochondrial matrix. During the cycle, carbon dioxide is released from organic intermediates, ATP is synthesized from ADP and inorganic phosphate, and electrons are transferred by the coenzymes NAD+ and FAD.

Before the Krebs cycle, each pyruvate is converted to a two-carbon acetyl group: one carbon leaves as CO2 and one NADH is made. The acetyl group enters the cycle, and for each turn two more carbons leave as CO2, so the cycle completes the oxidation of the glucose carbon. One turn makes 1 ATP, 3 NADH, and 1 FADH2. Since one glucose gives two pyruvate (and so two turns), the totals per glucose are doubled.

StageLocationATP made directlyNADHFADH2CO2
GlycolysisCytosol2 (net)200
Pyruvate oxidationMatrix0202
Krebs cycle (2 turns)Matrix2624
Total41026

Stages 1 and 2 make only 4 ATP directly. The main product is the electron carriers: 10 NADH and 2 FADH2. These hold most of the energy that was in glucose. Lesson 3.7 shows how that energy is turned into ATP in the electron transport chain.

Worked example · Tracking the carbon and the carriers

A cell completely oxidizes 3 molecules of glucose by aerobic respiration. Calculate the total CO2 released, the NADH and FADH2 formed, and the ATP made directly (before the electron transport chain). Then explain where the carbon in the CO2 came from.

Per glucose (table above): 6 CO2, 10 NADH, 2 FADH2, 4 ATP.
For 3 glucose: \(3 \times 6 = 18\) CO2; \(3 \times 10 = 30\) NADH; \(3 \times 2 = 6\) FADH2; \(3 \times 4 = 12\) ATP.
Source of the carbon. Each glucose has 6 carbons and each produces 6 CO2, so every carbon of glucose ends up in CO2: 2 carbons are released when pyruvate is oxidized and 4 in the Krebs cycle. This is why the CO2 you exhale comes from the food you ate.

Other fuels

Glucose is not the only fuel. Cells also use fats and proteins. Fatty acids are broken into two-carbon acetyl groups that enter the Krebs cycle directly, which is why fat is so rich in energy (about 9 kcal per gram, compared with about 4 kcal per gram for carbohydrate; lesson 1.5). Proteins can be broken into amino acids, which lose their nitrogen group and enter the pathway at various points. The same pathways therefore process all of the energy-rich macromolecules (EK 3.5.A.1).

Worked example · Which fuel is being used? The respiratory quotient

The respiratory quotient (RQ) is the ratio of CO2 released to O2 consumed. Calculate it for glucose (\(\text{C}_6\text{H}_{12}\text{O}_6 + 6\,\text{O}_2 \rightarrow 6\,\text{CO}_2 + 6\,\text{H}_2\text{O}\)) and for a fat, tripalmitin (\(\text{C}_{51}\text{H}_{98}\text{O}_6 + 72.5\,\text{O}_2 \rightarrow 51\,\text{CO}_2 + 49\,\text{H}_2\text{O}\)). A germinating seed has an RQ of 0.7. Which fuel is it using?

Glucose. \(RQ = 6/6 = 1.0\).
Tripalmitin. \(RQ = 51/72.5 = 0.70\).
The seed. An RQ of 0.7 matches fat, so the seed is mostly using stored fat as fuel.
Why they differ. A fat molecule has much less oxygen in it than glucose, so more O2 must be taken in to oxidize it, compared with the CO2 that comes out.

Exam focus
  • Know the locations: glycolysis in the cytosol; pyruvate oxidation and the Krebs cycle in the mitochondrial matrix; the electron transport chain in the inner membrane (lesson 3.7).
  • Glycolysis: glucose → 2 pyruvate + net 2 ATP + 2 NADH, no oxygen needed. Krebs cycle: releases CO2, makes NADH, FADH2, and a little ATP.
  • The carbon of glucose leaves as CO2; the oxygen in the CO2 comes from the glucose and from the cycle’s molecules, not directly from O2. O2 is used at the end of the electron transport chain to form water.
  • The main output of the early stages is the electron carriers NADH and FADH2. They deliver electrons to the ETC.
  • Do not memorize the intermediate molecules or enzymes; the CED excludes them.
  • Respiration is found in all forms of life, including plants. Cellular respiration is not breathing.
Practice
  1. State the location, the starting molecule, and the main products of glycolysis.
    Show answer

    Glycolysis occurs in the cytosol. It starts with glucose and produces 2 pyruvate, a net gain of 2 ATP, and 2 NADH. It does not require oxygen.

  2. Describe what happens to pyruvate when oxygen is available in a eukaryotic cell.
    Show answer

    Pyruvate is transported from the cytosol into the mitochondrion. There it is oxidized: it loses a carbon as CO2, makes NADH, and the remaining two-carbon group enters the Krebs cycle in the matrix, where further CO2 is released and NADH, FADH2, and ATP are made.

  3. For 5 glucose molecules fully oxidized, calculate the CO2 released and the NADH produced.
    Show answer

    CO2: \(5 \times 6 = 30\). NADH: \(5 \times 10 = 50\) (2 from glycolysis, 2 from pyruvate oxidation, and 6 from the Krebs cycle, per glucose).

  4. A cell is given glucose labeled with radioactive carbon. Predict where the label ends up after complete aerobic respiration, and justify.
    Show answer

    The label ends up in CO2. All six carbons of glucose are released as CO2, two as pyruvate is oxidized and four in the Krebs cycle.

  5. An athlete’s breath shows an RQ of 1.0 during a sprint and 0.75 during a long, slow walk. State what the data suggest about the fuels used and why.
    Show answer

    An RQ of 1.0 matches the oxidation of carbohydrate (glucose), so the sprint uses mainly carbohydrate. An RQ near 0.7 to 0.8 indicates that mostly fat (with some carbohydrate) is being oxidized during the walk. Fat contains less oxygen per carbon, so oxidizing it uses more O2 relative to the CO2 produced.

  6. Explain why a plant, which makes its own sugar by photosynthesis, still needs mitochondria.
    Show answer

    Photosynthesis stores energy in sugar but does not make usable ATP for most of the cell’s needs. Plant cells, including those without chloroplasts (roots) and all cells at night, need cellular respiration in mitochondria to release the energy of sugar and make ATP.

Lesson 3.7 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.5

Cellular respiration II: the electron transport chain and fermentation

By the end of the Krebs cycle a cell has used up the carbon of glucose but has made only 4 ATP. Most of the energy is still sitting in the electron carriers NADH and FADH2. The last stage turns that energy into ATP, and it uses the same principle as the light reactions: electrons flow down a chain, the chain builds a proton gradient, and the gradient drives ATP synthase. This lesson explains that stage, what happens when oxygen is missing, and how the whole process can be measured.

Learning objectives · 3.5.A and 3.5.B (continued)

EK 3.5.A.3: the electron transport chain (ETC) transfers electrons in a series of oxidation-reduction reactions that establish an electrochemical gradient across membranes. EK 3.5.B.4 to 3.5.B.6: NADH and FADH2 carry electrons to the ETC in the inner mitochondrial membrane; an electrochemical gradient of protons forms across it; fermentation allows glycolysis to proceed in the absence of oxygen.

The electron transport chain and oxidative phosphorylation

Intermembrane space (high H+, lower pH)Matrix (low H+, higher pH)ETCETCETCH+ pumped out of the matrixNADH → NAD+ + H+ + 2 e−½ O2 + 2 H+ + 2 e− → H2OATP synthaseH+ flows backADP + Pi → ATP
Figure 3.7a Electrons from NADH and FADH2 pass along the electron transport chain to oxygen, the final electron acceptor, which forms water. The energy released pumps H+ from the matrix into the intermembrane space, making the matrix pH higher than the space outside it. H+ flows back through ATP synthase by chemiosmosis, which drives the formation of ATP (oxidative phosphorylation).
Required content · EK 3.5.A.3 and 3.5.B.4 to 3.5.B.5
  • Electrons extracted in glycolysis and the Krebs cycle are transferred by NADH and FADH2 to the ETC in the inner mitochondrial membrane.
  • Electrons delivered by NADH and FADH2 are passed to a series of electron acceptors as they move toward the terminal electron acceptor, oxygen. Aerobic prokaryotes use oxygen as a terminal electron acceptor, while anaerobic prokaryotes use other molecules.
  • The transfer of electrons through the ETC is accompanied by the formation of a proton gradient across the inner mitochondrial membrane: a region of high proton concentration in the intermembrane space and low proton concentration in the matrix. The pH inside the matrix is higher than in the intermembrane space.
  • The folding of the inner membrane increases the surface area, which allows more ATP to be synthesized. In prokaryotes, the passage of electrons is accompanied by the movement of protons across the plasma membrane.
  • The flow of protons back through membrane-bound ATP synthase by chemiosmosis drives the formation of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate. This is known as oxidative phosphorylation in aerobic cellular respiration.

Here is the sequence. NADH gives its electrons to the first protein complex of the chain, and becomes NAD+, which returns to the matrix to be used again. The electrons pass from one carrier to the next, each with a stronger pull on electrons than the last, and lose a little energy at every step. That released energy is used to pump H+ from the matrix into the intermembrane space. At the end of the chain, oxygen has the strongest pull. It accepts the electrons and combines with H+ to form water. This is the only step in which O2 is used, and it explains why we need to breathe it. The H+ then flows down its gradient through ATP synthase, and the flow of protons turns the machine and joins ADP and Pi into ATP.

Without oxygen, the chain has no final acceptor, so electrons back up, the chain stops, the proton gradient is lost, and the NADH cannot be converted back to NAD+. The Krebs cycle also stops, because it needs NAD+. A poison such as cyanide, which blocks the last step of the chain, kills quickly for this reason: the cells lose their ATP supply.

How much ATP?

Each NADH delivers enough energy for about 2.5 ATP, and each FADH2 (which enters the chain later) for about 1.5. For one glucose: \(10 \times 2.5 + 2 \times 1.5 = 28\) ATP from the chain, plus the 4 made directly in glycolysis and the Krebs cycle, for about 32 in all. Older textbooks gave 36 to 38; the exact number varies by cell type and conditions because some protons leak back, and the CED does not ask for a number. What matters is that the electron transport chain makes the large majority of the ATP.

Worked example · Efficiency of aerobic respiration versus fermentation

Complete oxidation of one mole of glucose releases about 2,870 kJ. The hydrolysis of ATP stores about 30.5 kJ per mole. Compare the percent of the energy captured as ATP by aerobic respiration (about 32 ATP) and by fermentation (2 ATP).

Aerobic. \(32 \times 30.5 = 976\) kJ captured. \(976 / 2870 \times 100 = 34\) percent.
Fermentation. \(2 \times 30.5 = 61\) kJ captured. \(61 / 2870 \times 100 = 2.1\) percent.
Meaning. Aerobic respiration captures about 16 times as much of the glucose energy as ATP (\(34/2.1 = 16\)). The rest of the energy is released as heat, which warms the body of an endotherm (see below).

Decoupling: heat instead of ATP

The proton gradient is a store of energy that can either make ATP (through ATP synthase) or be spent in another way. If the membrane becomes leaky to protons, or if a protein provides another path, the protons cross without passing through ATP synthase. The electron transport chain keeps running, even faster, but the energy is released as heat. This is called decoupling oxidative phosphorylation from electron transport (EK 3.5.A.3.iv). Endothermic organisms use this to regulate body temperature: newborn babies and hibernating mammals have brown fat, whose mitochondria contain a protein that lets protons leak back on purpose, to produce heat.

Worked example · Predict the effect of an uncoupler

The chemical DNP makes the inner mitochondrial membrane permeable to protons. Predict its effect on oxygen consumption, ATP production, and body temperature, and justify.

Prediction. The proton gradient can no longer be kept, because protons flow back across the membrane without passing through ATP synthase, so ATP production drops. The electron transport chain, no longer slowed by a large gradient, runs faster, so oxygen consumption increases as the cell tries to restore the gradient. The energy that would have gone into ATP is released as heat, and body temperature rises.
Justification. It shows that the electron transport and ATP production are coupled by the proton gradient. This was used as evidence for Peter Mitchell’s chemiosmotic model. (DNP was once used as a weight-loss drug, but it is dangerous because it can cause fatal overheating.)

Without oxygen: fermentation

Required content · EK 3.5.B.6

Fermentation allows glycolysis to proceed in the absence of oxygen and produces organic molecules such as alcohol and lactic acid.

Glucose(6 C)glycolysis2 pyruvate+ 2 ATP (net)+ 2 NADHLactic acid fermentationpyruvate + NADH → lactate + NAD+muscle cells, some bacteriaAlcohol fermentationpyruvate → CO2 + ethanol (NAD+ regenerated)yeast, some bacteriaBoth end by regenerating NAD+, which lets glycolysis keep making ATP without oxygen.
Figure 3.7b Without oxygen the electron transport chain stops and NADH cannot be recycled. Fermentation uses the pyruvate to take the electrons from NADH, regenerating NAD+ so glycolysis can continue. It makes only the 2 ATP from glycolysis per glucose, far less than aerobic respiration.

When there is no oxygen to accept the electrons, the cell cannot recycle NADH to NAD+ through the chain. Glycolysis needs NAD+, so without a way to regenerate it, even glycolysis would stop. Fermentation solves this: pyruvate takes the electrons from NADH, which regenerates NAD+. In lactic acid fermentation (muscle cells during intense exercise, and some bacteria) pyruvate becomes lactate. In alcohol fermentation (yeast) pyruvate is converted into ethanol and CO2, which is how bread rises and beer is made. Fermentation makes only the 2 ATP from glycolysis, but it is fast, and it keeps cells alive when oxygen runs out.

Aerobic respirationFermentation
Oxygen neededYes (final electron acceptor)No
LocationCytosol and mitochondrionCytosol
ATP per glucoseAbout 30 to 322
End productsCO2 and H2OLactate, or ethanol and CO2
Role of NAD+Regenerated by the ETCRegenerated by converting pyruvate

Measuring respiration

Worked example · Respirometer data

A respirometer measures oxygen consumption: CO2 is absorbed by a chemical, so the volume of gas falls only as O2 is used. A control vial with glass beads corrects for changes in temperature and pressure. Germinating seeds (5.0 g) at 22 °C in the experimental vial show a drop of 0.15, 0.31, 0.45, and 0.60 mL at 5, 10, 15, and 20 minutes, and the bead control shows 0.05, 0.11, 0.15, and 0.20 mL. Calculate the corrected O2 consumption, the rate in mL/min and mL/g/h. The same seeds at 10 °C give a corrected rate of 0.008 mL/min. Calculate the ratio of the rates and explain the difference.

Correct the data. Subtract the control: \(0.15 - 0.05 = 0.10\); \(0.31 - 0.11 = 0.20\); \(0.45 - 0.15 = 0.30\); \(0.60 - 0.20 = 0.40\) mL.
Rate (22 °C). \(0.40 / 20 = 0.020\) mL/min. Per gram of seeds: \(0.020 / 5.0 = 0.0040\) mL/g/min, which is \(0.0040 \times 60 = 0.24\) mL/g/h.
Ratio. \(0.020 / 0.008 = 2.5\) times as fast at 22 °C as at 10 °C.
Explain. Respiration is controlled by enzymes (lesson 3.2). At a lower temperature, enzyme-substrate collisions are less frequent and less energetic, so the reactions run more slowly and less O2 is used. Dormant seeds, with little metabolic activity, would show a rate close to zero.

Exam focus
  • The ETC is in the inner mitochondrial membrane. It passes electrons from NADH and FADH2 to O2 (final acceptor, forming H2O) and pumps H+ into the intermembrane space; ATP synthase makes ATP as H+ flows back into the matrix (chemiosmosis).
  • Compare with photosynthesis: the same idea, with a different gradient direction. In the thylakoid, H+ accumulates inside the thylakoid; in the mitochondrion, H+ accumulates in the intermembrane space (outside the inner membrane). Pumped from the stroma or matrix, to the thylakoid space or intermembrane space.
  • Most of the ATP comes from oxidative phosphorylation. Without O2, the chain stops, NADH backs up, and the cell must ferment.
  • Fermentation = glycolysis + regenerating NAD+; 2 ATP; lactate (animals) or ethanol + CO2 (yeast).
  • Uncoupling = H+ leaks past ATP synthase; oxygen use rises, ATP falls, heat rises.
  • Respiration, fermentation, and glycolysis occur in all forms of life: evidence of common ancestry.
Practice
  1. Explain the role of oxygen in aerobic respiration and what would happen to the ETC without it.
    Show answer

    Oxygen is the terminal (final) electron acceptor of the electron transport chain; it takes the electrons and combines with H+ to form water. Without oxygen, electrons cannot leave the chain, so it stops, no more protons are pumped, ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation stops, and NADH cannot be converted back to NAD+.

  2. Describe how the ETC and ATP synthase work together to make ATP in a mitochondrion.
    Show answer

    As electrons pass along the ETC in the inner membrane, the energy released is used to pump H+ from the matrix into the intermembrane space, creating a proton gradient (high H+ outside, low inside). The protons flow back into the matrix through ATP synthase, and this flow (chemiosmosis) drives the formation of ATP from ADP and Pi.

  3. Calculate the ATP produced from the electron transport chain for 8 NADH and 2 FADH2, using 2.5 and 1.5 ATP per carrier.
    Show answer

    \(8 \times 2.5 + 2 \times 1.5 = 20 + 3 = 23\) ATP.

  4. A yeast culture is moved from a flask with air to a sealed flask. Predict the effect on its rate of glucose use and on the products, and justify.
    Show answer

    The yeast switches to alcohol fermentation. Glucose use increases greatly because each glucose yields only 2 ATP instead of about 32, so the cells must break down much more glucose to meet their ATP needs. The products are ethanol and CO2 instead of CO2 and water.

  5. In cyanide poisoning, the last step of the electron transport chain is blocked. Predict the effect on the NADH:NAD+ ratio and on the Krebs cycle, and justify.
    Show answer

    NADH accumulates and NAD+ is depleted, because NADH cannot give up its electrons to the chain. The Krebs cycle (and glycolysis) needs NAD+ to continue, so these pathways also slow or stop. ATP production collapses.

  6. Compare a mitochondrion and a chloroplast in how they use a proton gradient to make ATP. State one similarity and one difference.
    Show answer

    Similarity: in both, an electron transport chain pumps protons across a membrane to build a gradient, and the protons return through ATP synthase, driving ATP synthesis by chemiosmosis. Difference: in the chloroplast the electrons come from water and the energy from light, and protons accumulate inside the thylakoid; in the mitochondrion the electrons come from NADH and FADH2, and protons accumulate in the intermembrane space.

Unit 3 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 3 quiz: Cellular Energetics

Fifteen multiple-choice questions and five short free-response questions across all seven lessons: enzymes and their inhibitors, free energy and ATP coupling, the light reactions and the Calvin cycle, and the whole path from glucose to ATP. Click an option to see why each choice is right or wrong, then write each free response on paper against the clock before you open the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Model: a reaction-coordinate diagram for the conversion of substrate S to product P, drawn twice on the same axes.

    Free energy in kJ/mol runs up the y-axis; reaction progress runs along the x-axis. Both curves start on the same reactant shelf at 0 and end on the same product shelf at −32. Curve 1, for the uncatalyzed reaction, climbs to a peak of +84 before dropping to the product shelf. Curve 2, measured with enzyme present, follows the same shelves but peaks at only +35.

    Which statement is best supported by the two curves?

    Correct. The barrier falls from +84 to +35, a drop of \(84 - 35 = 49\) kJ/mol, and both curves end on the same product shelf, so \(\Delta G\) is −32 kJ/mol with and without enzyme. Naming the right quantity is the whole item: an enzyme changes \(E_a\), never \(\Delta G\).

    This is the arithmetic slip of subtracting the barrier reduction from \(\Delta G\): −32 − 49 gives −81. But the product shelf never moved on the diagram, so the free-energy change is identical on both curves. "The enzyme lowers the energy of the reaction" is the wrong quantity and earns nothing on an exam.

    Nothing in the figure shows the product shelf rising, and if it did the reaction would release less free energy, not more. Enzymes also cannot shift an equilibrium position: they speed the forward and reverse directions by the same factor, so the system simply arrives at the same equilibrium sooner.

    The 32 here is \(\Delta G\), not the change in the barrier; the barrier fell by 49 kJ/mol. The second half of the choice repeats the most common enzyme misconception: a catalyst changes the rate of approach to equilibrium, not the position of the equilibrium itself.

  2. Which observation provides the strongest evidence for the induced-fit model of enzyme action rather than a rigid lock-and-key active site?

    This is true and important, it is why a cell runs a high-throughput pathway on a tiny amount of protein, but a rigid lock-and-key enzyme would also be regenerated unchanged. An observation that both models predict cannot distinguish between them.

    Correct. Induced fit claims the active site is not pre-formed: contact with the substrate changes its shape, straining the bonds about to break and positioning the catalytic groups. A structure that differs before and after binding is direct evidence of that conformational change, which lock-and-key does not predict.

    Every catalyst, rigid or flexible, lowers \(E_a\) without touching \(\Delta G\). This statement describes what enzymes do, not how the active site behaves when substrate arrives, so it says nothing about which binding model is right.

    Saturation follows from having a finite number of active sites and is predicted equally well by both models. It is good evidence that catalysis happens at discrete sites, but it does not tell you whether those sites change shape on binding.

  3. Data: initial reaction rate of one enzyme at 30 °C and pH 7.0 across a range of substrate concentrations, with no inhibitor and with each of two inhibitors held at a fixed concentration.

    [Substrate] (mM)1251020
    No inhibitor (µmol/min)8.014.025.032.036.0
    + Inhibitor X (µmol/min)3.06.013.022.033.0
    + Inhibitor Y (µmol/min)3.25.610.012.814.4

    Which conclusion about inhibitor Y is best supported by the data?

    Both inhibitors lower the rate at every concentration in the table, so this feature cannot tell them apart. The diagnostic question is what happens as substrate is flooded in: X climbs to 33.0 µmol/min, nearly the uninhibited 36.0, while Y stalls at 14.4.

    Correct. \(14.4/36.0 = 0.40\), so Y caps the enzyme at 40% of its maximum however much substrate is added. That is the signature of a noncompetitive inhibitor: it binds an allosteric site and distorts the active site, so a fixed fraction of enzyme molecules is dead and substrate cannot compete it away.

    A right-shifted curve that still reaches the uninhibited plateau does describe a competitive inhibitor, but that is inhibitor X, not Y. Y's curve is not merely shifted; its ceiling is lower, which is a different effect with a different mechanism.

    A denatured enzyme has lost its tertiary fold and gives a rate near zero at every substrate concentration. Y-treated enzyme still rises from 3.2 to 14.4 µmol/min as substrate increases, so the remaining enzyme is folded and working; it is inhibited, not destroyed.

  4. A lizard's oxygen consumption is 3.50 mL O2 g−1 h−1 at 20 °C and 8.75 mL O2 g−1 h−1 at 30 °C, both temperatures below the optimum for its enzymes. What is Q10, and what does that value indicate?

    Correct. \(Q_{10} = (8.75/3.50)^{10/10} = 2.50\). Most biological rates give 2 to 3 below the optimum, because warming both increases collision frequency and raises the fraction of collisions carrying enough energy to cross the activation barrier.

    This is the arithmetic difference, \(8.75 - 3.50\), not a ratio. \(Q_{10}\) is defined as the factor by which a rate is multiplied per 10 °C, so it is unitless; an answer carrying mL O2 g−1 h−1 cannot be a \(Q_{10}\).

    0.40 is \(3.50/8.75\): the ratio taken upside down. A \(Q_{10}\) below 1 does signal denaturation, but only when the measured rate actually falls with warming, and here it more than doubled.

    1.25 would mean a 25% increase per 10 °C, which is roughly what simple diffusion does. Enzyme-catalyzed processes respond far more steeply, and 2.5 is exactly that steeper response.

  5. Synthesis of a cellular intermediate has ΔG = +21.0 kJ/mol. In the cell this step is coupled to ATP hydrolysis, ΔG = −30.5 kJ/mol. What is ΔG for the coupled reaction, and will it proceed?

    Adding 21.0 to 30.5 ignores the sign on ATP hydrolysis, which releases free energy. Coupled reactions are summed with their signs: \(+21.0 + (-30.5)\). Losing the sign here turns a spontaneous process into an impossible one.

    Correct. \(+21.0 + (-30.5) = -9.5\) kJ/mol, and a negative sum means the coupled reaction is exergonic and proceeds. Mechanically, ATP phosphorylates an intermediate so the two steps share one pathway; the 9.5 kJ/mol left over is the margin that makes the pair spontaneous.

    This treats ATP hydrolysis as if the endergonic step were free. The synthesis still costs +21.0 kJ/mol, and that cost is paid out of the 30.5 released, leaving −9.5. Coupling is never free: that is why cells need so much ATP.

    ATP hydrolysis is a source of free energy, not a catalyst; it changes \(\Delta G\), while enzymes change \(E_a\). Keeping those two roles separate is the whole point of this topic, and confusing them is the most common error on coupling questions.

  6. Data: daily energy budget of a 40 g mouse and a 40 g lizard, each measured in a 25 °C chamber over 24 hours.

    MeasurementMouse (endotherm)Lizard (ectotherm)
    Energy taken in (kJ/day)12020
    Energy spent on maintenance (kJ/day)1088

    Which statement is best supported by the data?

    Intake alone does not say what is left over. The energy available for growth and reproduction is intake minus maintenance, and both animals land on the same surplus: \(120 - 108 = 12\) kJ/day and \(20 - 8 = 12\) kJ/day.

    Correct. The surpluses are identical at 12 kJ/day, but \(12/120 = 10\%\) versus \(12/20 = 60\%\). The mouse holds 37 °C against a 25 °C room and burns most of its intake as heat; the lizard lets its body temperature follow the chamber, so almost nothing is spent on thermoregulation.

    The 60% is the share of intake left after maintenance, not the share converted into tissue: some of that surplus is lost in assimilation and in the cost of building. The table gives no measurement of tissue gained, so this claim goes beyond the data.

    Both maintenance figures are below the corresponding intake, so each animal has a positive surplus. An organism whose maintenance truly consumed its whole intake would lose mass and stop reproducing, which is the link between energy budgets and fitness.

  7. Figure: two traces on the same axes; percent of each trace's own maximum on the y-axis (0 to 100), wavelength in nm on the x-axis (400 to 700).

    Trace 1 is the absorption spectrum of purified chlorophyll a: 100 at 430 nm, falling to 6 at 550 nm, rising again to 92 at 680 nm. Trace 2 is the action spectrum of an intact Elodea leaf, measured as oxygen released: 85 at 430 nm, 24 at 550 nm, and 100 at 680 nm.

    Which best explains why the two traces differ most at 550 nm?

    Reflected light has by definition left the leaf without being absorbed, so it cannot drive photolysis. Reflection in the green band is why leaves look green; it is the reason the action spectrum dips at 550 nm, not the reason it is higher than chlorophyll a's absorption there.

    If extraction lowered absorption uniformly, trace 1 would sit below trace 2 everywhere. It does not, chlorophyll a reads 100 at 430 nm while the leaf reads 85, so a general underestimate cannot be the explanation for a gap that appears only in the green.

    Correct. Trace 1 is one purified pigment; trace 2 is a whole leaf containing chlorophyll b and carotenoids, which absorb in the band where chlorophyll a is nearly transparent and transfer that excitation energy to chlorophyll a in the reaction center. That is why the action spectrum reads 24 where absorption reads 6.

    Oxygen release requires photolysis of water at photosystem II, which needs photons arriving now; stored ATP and NADPH are products of the light reactions and cannot substitute for them. A leaf in the dark releases no oxygen at all.

  8. DCMU blocks the transfer of electrons from photosystem II to plastoquinone. A suspension of isolated chloroplasts is illuminated in the presence of DCMU. Which result is predicted?

    This reverses the dependency. Photolysis is not a light-driven reaction that runs on its own: it is the replacement step, triggered when P680 has lost electrons. Block the downstream transfer and photosystem II stays reduced, so it stops pulling electrons off water.

    Correct. Water is the electron source, and it is split only to refill photosystem II. With the exit blocked, no photolysis occurs, so no O2 is released; NADPH production also collapses, because photosystem I receives no electrons to pass to NADP+ reductase.

    Electrons that cannot leave photosystem II do not generate additional products: the excited electrons simply return to the ground state, releasing the energy as heat and fluorescence. Nothing in a blocked chain makes more oxygen or more NADPH.

    The proton gradient is built by the electron transport chain pumping H+ into the lumen and by photolysis releasing H+ there. Blocking electron flow removes both sources, so the gradient dissipates and ATP synthase runs down.

  9. A leaf fixes 18 molecules of CO2 through the Calvin cycle. How much ATP and NADPH are consumed, and how many molecules of glucose could be assembled from the G3P exported?

    These are the per-G3P figures for three turns, not for eighteen. One turn fixes one CO2 and costs 3 ATP and 2 NADPH, so eighteen fixations cost six times as much. Anchor every Calvin-cycle calculation on "one CO2 per turn."

    Correct. Eighteen turns cost \(18 \times 3 = 54\) ATP and \(18 \times 2 = 36\) NADPH. Every three turns export one net G3P, giving \(18/3 = 6\) G3P, and two G3P build one glucose, so \(6/2 = 3\) glucose. Check it the other way: \(3 \times 18 = 54\) ATP and \(3 \times 12 = 36\) NADPH.

    Doubling the correct values usually comes from applying the per-glucose costs (18 ATP, 12 NADPH) to each of six turns. Those per-glucose figures already include all six turns, so using them again multiplies the cost twice.

    The ATP and NADPH are right, but six glucose would need \(6 \times 6 = 36\) carbons fixed, twice what the stem gives. Dividing 18 by 3 to get glucose confuses turns per exported G3P with turns per glucose, which is six.

  10. Data: net photosynthesis of soybean (a C3 plant) and maize (a C4 plant), measured at a leaf temperature of 35 °C in full sun at three atmospheric CO2 concentrations.

    Atmospheric CO2 (ppm)200400800
    Soybean, C3 (µmol CO2 m−2 s−1)81830
    Maize, C4 (µmol CO2 m−2 s−1)283435

    Raising CO2 from 200 to 800 ppm multiplies soybean's rate by 3.75 but raises maize's by only 25%. Which explanation is best supported?

    Correct. C4 anatomy delivers CO2 to rubisco at a high local concentration, so maize starts at 28 and has little room to gain: \(35/28 = 1.25\). Soybean's rubisco is CO2-limited and competing with O2 at 200 ppm, so extra CO2 both feeds carboxylation and suppresses photorespiration: \(30/8 = 3.75\).

    Maize at 200 ppm already outperforms soybean at 400 ppm, which rules out a plant that cannot get CO2 in. C4 plants in fact run with less stomatal opening for the same carbon gain, which is why they conserve water, but stomatal number is not what the data here distinguish.

    CO2 is not used in the light reactions at all: it enters at the carbon-fixation step of the Calvin cycle. Chlorophyll content sets how much light energy is captured, which is not the limiting factor in full sun at 200 ppm CO2.

    Rubisco is essentially the same enzyme in both plants; the C4 advantage is in delivery, not affinity. PEP carboxylase, the enzyme that first captures CO2 in maize, is the one with no affinity for O2: swapping the two enzymes is the standard error on this question.

  11. A cell is supplied with glucose in which all six carbons are 14C and respires it completely in the presence of oxygen. Where does the labeled carbon leave, and in what amounts per glucose?

    Glycolysis splits a 6-carbon glucose into two 3-carbon pyruvate, \(2 \times 3 = 6\), so every carbon is still in the cell when glycolysis ends. Expecting CO2 from glycolysis is one of the most common errors on respiration items.

    The citric acid cycle contributes 4 of the 6, two per turn over two turns. The other two leave earlier, during pyruvate oxidation, when each pyruvate loses one carbon as it is converted to the 2-carbon acetyl group on coenzyme A.

    Correct. Pyruvate oxidation releases one CO2 per pyruvate, so 2 per glucose; each of the two Krebs turns releases 2, so 4 more. \(2 + 4 = 6\), and the glucose skeleton is fully dismantled before the electron transport chain does anything.

    Oxygen's role at the end of the chain is to accept electrons and H+, forming water, no carbon is involved. Every CO2 is released by a decarboxylation reaction upstream, in the matrix, before the electrons ever reach the chain.

  12. Per molecule of glucose, how much ATP is produced before the electron transport chain, and by what mechanism?

    The 2 is glycolysis alone, and the mechanism is wrong twice over: glycolysis happens in the cytosol, and oxidative phosphorylation is the chemiosmotic process that occurs only once electrons reach the chain. Substrate-level phosphorylation hands a phosphate straight from an intermediate to ADP.

    Ten is the number of NADH per glucose, not ATP. Those carriers hold most of the energy, but it is not released as ATP until the electron transport chain, and each NADH yields roughly 2.5 ATP there, not 1.

    Thirty-two is the approximate total for the whole of aerobic respiration, including the chain, and chemiosmosis happens after the stages in question. The point of this item is that the stages before the chain produce very little ATP directly.

    Correct. Glycolysis makes 4 ATP but invests 2, for a net 2, and each of the two Krebs turns yields 1 ATP (or GTP). All four come from substrate-level phosphorylation; the real product of these stages is the 10 NADH and 2 FADH2.

  13. Data: pipette readings (mL) from three respirometers held in a 22 °C water bath for 20 minutes. KOH in each vial absorbs the CO2 released, and each seed vial contains 15.0 g of peas.

    VialReading at 0 minReading at 20 min
    Germinating peas1.000.55
    Dormant peas0.950.92
    Glass beads only (control)0.900.93

    What is the rate of oxygen consumption of the germinating peas, corrected using the control?

    This is the uncorrected value: \(0.45/(15.0 \times 20) = 1.5 \times 10^{-3}\). The bead vial drifted \(0.93 - 0.90 = +0.03\) mL from changes in room temperature and pressure, and that drift pushed every reading up, so it must be subtracted before the rate is computed.

    \(2.0 \times 10^{-4}\) is the dormant peas' rate: \(0.06/(15.0 \times 20)\) after the same correction. It is a useful comparison: germinating seeds respire \(0.48/0.06 = 8\) times as fast, but it is not what the question asks for.

    Correct. Drift \(= 0.93 - 0.90 = +0.03\) mL. Germinating: \((0.55 - 1.00) - 0.03 = -0.48\), so 0.48 mL of O2 was consumed, and \(0.48/(15.0 \times 20) = 1.6 \times 10^{-3}\) mL O2 g−1 min−1.

    This is \(0.48/20\): the time division only. Respirometer rates are normalized per gram as well as per minute so that vials with different amounts of tissue can be compared; dropping the mass term also drops g−1 from the units, which is the clue that something is missing.

  14. Data: isolated mitochondria supplied with substrate and treated with one of three compounds. All values are percentages of the untreated control.

    TreatmentO2 consumptionATP synthesisHeat released
    Control100100100
    Compound M16512230
    Compound N8620
    Compound P22935

    Compound P inhibits ATP synthase and does not act on the electron carriers directly. Which feature of the data is consistent with that action, and why?

    That row is compound M, and the pattern is the signature of an uncoupler: protons leak back across the membrane without passing the synthase, so nothing opposes the pumps and electron transport accelerates. An ATP synthase inhibitor does the opposite: it leaves the gradient in place.

    Correct. With the return path shut, H+ accumulates in the intermembrane space until the pumps can no longer push against it, so electron transport slows and oxygen consumption falls to 22%. This coupling of ATP demand to oxygen use is called respiratory control.

    Oxygen, not ATP synthase, is the final electron acceptor: that is the vocabulary error the distractor is testing. The 8%/20% row is compound N, consistent with a chemical such as cyanide that blocks the last complex of the chain so oxygen cannot be reduced at all.

    Energy that cannot be captured as ATP is released as heat only when the protons are allowed to flow back, which is what an uncoupler permits and an ATP synthase inhibitor prevents. Compound P's heat is 35%, well below the control, exactly because the whole chain has slowed.

  15. A yeast culture producing about 32 ATP per glucose aerobically is shifted to anaerobic conditions, where it produces 2 ATP per glucose. By what factor must glucose consumption rise to hold ATP production steady, and what does fermentation itself contribute?

    Correct. \(32/2 = 16\), so the cell must burn sixteen times as much glucose per minute. Fermentation's own reactions (pyruvate to ethanol and CO2, or pyruvate to lactate) make no ATP; they oxidize NADH back to NAD+, without which glycolysis would stall within seconds and even the 2 ATP would stop.

    The factor is right, but the 2 ATP are made in glycolysis, not in the fermentation step that follows. Attributing them to fermentation hides the real function of those reactions, which is recycling the electron carrier.

    Thirty is the difference \(32 - 2\), not the ratio, and the recycling runs the other way: NADH is oxidized to NAD+. The citric acid cycle is not running at all under anaerobic conditions, because the chain that reoxidizes its carriers has no final electron acceptor.

    Fermentation yields \(2/32 = 6.25\%\) of the aerobic ATP per glucose. It is actually faster per unit time than aerobic respiration, which is why sprinting muscle uses it, but it is far less thorough: most of the glucose's energy is left in ethanol or lactate.

Free response

  1. Data: initial rate of O2 production by catalase acting on 1.0% hydrogen peroxide at 25 °C. Each value is the mean of three trials. A second set of tubes received catalase that had been boiled for 10 minutes and cooled before use.

    pH of buffer357911
    Catalase (µmol O2/min)42248203
    Boiled catalase (µmol O2/min)00000

    A student investigated how pH affects catalase activity. Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in the investigation, and describe the purpose of the boiled-catalase treatment.
    2. Explain the relationship between pH and the initial reaction rate in terms of the structure of the enzyme.
    3. Construct a graph of the catalase data: place pH on the x-axis scaled from 3 to 11 and initial rate on the y-axis scaled from 0 to 50 µmol O2/min, label both axes with units, plot the five points, and connect them.
    4. A classmate claims the data show that catalase is permanently denatured at pH 11. Justify whether the data provided are sufficient to support that claim.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the independent variable is the pH of the buffer the reaction is run in. The boiled tubes are a control showing that the oxygen measured depends on folded, functional enzyme, not on hydrogen peroxide decomposing on its own or on any other component of the mixture at that pH. Do not accept: naming the enzyme, the peroxide, or the reaction rate as the independent variable; "it is the control" with no statement of what it controls for; restating the stem.
    • (b) Accept: the rate rises from pH 3 to a maximum at pH 7 and falls on either side, and away from the optimum excess H+ or OH− changes the charges on the R groups lining the active site, breaking the ionic and hydrogen bonds that hold its shape, so the site no longer complements hydrogen peroxide and fewer enzyme–substrate complexes form. Do not accept: "pH affects the enzyme"; "the enzyme dies"; a description of the trend with no structural mechanism: describing is not explaining.
    • (c) Accept: pH on the x-axis from 3 to 11 with an even scale, initial rate on the y-axis from 0 to 50, both axes labeled with units (pH; µmol O2/min), the five points (3, 4), (5, 22), (7, 48), (9, 20), (11, 3) plotted and connected into a single peak at pH 7. Do not accept: axes reversed; units omitted from the axis labels; points that do not match the table.
    • (d) Accept: the data are not sufficient; they show only that activity is low at pH 11, which is equally consistent with reversible inhibition; supporting permanent denaturation requires returning the pH 11 enzyme to pH 7 and showing that activity does not recover. Do not accept: "yes, because the rate is only 3 µmol/min"; a claim with no reference to a missing recovery test; asserting denaturation from the boiled row, which was a different treatment.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is the pH of the buffer the reaction runs in. The boiled catalase is the control: the oxygen I measured came from folded, working enzyme and not from peroxide breaking down on its own, because those tubes gave 0 µmol O2/min at every pH.

    b The rate climbs from 4 µmol/min at pH 3 to 48 at pH 7, then drops back to 3 at pH 11. Away from pH 7 the extra H+ or OH− changes the charges on the R groups lining catalase's active site, breaking the ionic and hydrogen bonds that hold that site in shape. A misshapen site no longer fits hydrogen peroxide, so fewer enzyme–substrate complexes form each second and the rate falls.

    c I would put pH on the x-axis from 3 to 11 and initial rate on the y-axis from 0 to 50 µmol O2/min, label both axes with those units, plot (3, 4), (5, 22), (7, 48), (9, 20) and (11, 3), and connect them into a single peak at pH 7.

    d The data are not enough. All the table shows is that activity is low at pH 11, and reversible inhibition would look exactly the same. To support "permanently denatured" I would have to take the enzyme out of pH 11 buffer, put it back at pH 7, and show that the rate does not come back.

  2. Data: standard free-energy changes for three reactions in a plant cell.

    ReactionΔG (kJ/mol)
    1. glucose + fructose → sucrose + H2O+27.0
    2. ATP + H2O → ADP + Pi−30.5
    3. activation of one amino acid for protein synthesis+34.0

    Using the values in the table, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify which reactions in the table are endergonic, and describe one structural feature of ATP that makes reaction 2 exergonic.
    2. Explain how coupling reaction 2 to reaction 1 allows a plant cell to make sucrose even though reaction 1 by itself will not proceed.
    3. Calculate ΔG for reaction 1 coupled to one ATP hydrolysis, and for reaction 3 coupled to one ATP hydrolysis. Show your setup and give units.
    4. Justify, using your calculated values, the claim that reaction 3 requires the hydrolysis of two ATP rather than one.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: reactions 1 and 3 are endergonic (positive ΔG). Feature: the three phosphate groups sit in a row and each carries a negative charge, so they repel one another; removing the terminal phosphate relieves that repulsion, and ADP and inorganic phosphate are more stable in water than ATP was. Do not accept: "ATP's bonds store a lot of energy" with nothing structural; identifying reaction 2 as endergonic; naming the reactions with no described feature of ATP.
    • (b) Accept: ATP transfers its terminal phosphate onto one of the sugars, and that phosphorylated intermediate is reactive enough to proceed; because the two steps share the intermediate they occur as a single reaction, so only the sum of the two ΔG values determines whether it runs. Do not accept: "ATP gives the reaction energy" with no intermediate and no reference to summing; a correct general statement about coupling that is never applied to sucrose.
    • (c) Accept: reaction 1, \(+27.0 + (-30.5) = -3.5\) kJ/mol; reaction 3, \(+34.0 + (-30.5) = +3.5\) kJ/mol. Setup must be shown and units are required. Do not accept: values with no setup; a sign error that reports reaction 1 as +3.5; answers with no units.
    • (d) Accept: with one ATP, reaction 3 is still +3.5 kJ/mol: positive, so it remains endergonic and will not proceed; with two, \(+34.0 + 2(-30.5) = -27.0\) kJ/mol, which is negative and therefore spontaneous. The evidence cited must be the sign of a computed sum. Do not accept: "two ATP give more energy" with no value; restating part (c) without drawing the conclusion about spontaneity.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Reactions 1 and 3 are endergonic: both have a positive ΔG. ATP's three phosphate groups sit in a row and each carries a negative charge, so they repel one another. Cutting off the terminal phosphate relieves that repulsion, and ADP plus free phosphate are more stable in water than ATP was, so the hydrolysis releases free energy.

    b The cell does not run the two reactions side by side and hope. ATP hands its terminal phosphate to one of the sugars first, and that phosphorylated sugar is unstable enough to react with the other one. Because both steps go through the same intermediate they are really one reaction, so what decides whether sucrose gets made is the sum of the two ΔG values, not reaction 1's value on its own.

    c Reaction 1 with one ATP: \(+27.0 + (-30.5) = -3.5\) kJ/mol. Reaction 3 with one ATP: \(+34.0 + (-30.5) = +3.5\) kJ/mol.

    d With one ATP, reaction 3 still comes out at +3.5 kJ/mol. That is positive, so the coupled reaction is still endergonic and will not run on its own. With two ATP, \(+34.0 + 2(-30.5) = -27.0\) kJ/mol, which is negative and therefore spontaneous. The sign of that sum is the evidence that one ATP is not enough and two are.

  3. Model: a thylakoid membrane drawn in cross-section, with the stroma above the membrane and the thylakoid lumen below it.

    Embedded in the membrane from left to right are photosystem II, plastoquinone, the cytochrome complex, plastocyanin, photosystem I, and, at the far right, ATP synthase. An arrow labeled 2 H2O → 4 H+ + 4 e− + O2 points from the lumen into photosystem II. Curved arrows at the cytochrome complex show H+ moving from the stroma into the lumen. On the stroma side, NADP+ reductase is drawn accepting electrons from photosystem I. A pair of labels gives the stroma as pH 8.0 and the lumen as pH 5.0 in a leaf that has been illuminated for several minutes.

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the source of the electrons that replace those lost by photosystem II, and describe where in the model protons accumulate.
    2. Explain how electron flow through the model generates the pH difference shown between the stroma and the lumen.
    3. Calculate the ratio of the H+ concentration in the lumen to the H+ concentration in the stroma in the illuminated leaf. Show your setup.
    4. A chemical is added that makes the thylakoid membrane freely permeable to H+. Justify the claim that ATP synthesis will fall sharply even though electrons continue to flow from photosystem II to NADP+.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the electrons come from water, split by photolysis on the lumen side (2 H2O → 4 H+ + 4 e− + O2); protons accumulate in the thylakoid lumen. Do not accept: "from the sun," "from NADPH," or "from chlorophyll"; naming water without saying which compartment the protons build up in.
    • (b) Accept: two sources with directions stated; photolysis releases H+ directly into the lumen, and the cytochrome complex uses the energy of electrons falling through the chain to pump H+ from the stroma into the lumen; both raise lumen H+ and lower stroma H+. Do not accept: "the chain builds a gradient" with no mechanism or no direction; reversing the two compartments.
    • (c) Accept: pH 5.0 gives [H+] = 1 × 10−5 M and pH 8.0 gives 1 × 10−8 M, so the ratio is \((1 \times 10^{-5})/(1 \times 10^{-8}) = 1 \times 10^{3}\), i.e. 1000 : 1 with the lumen higher. Do not accept: 8/5 or a difference of 3 reported as the ratio; an answer that does not say which compartment is more concentrated; no setup shown.
    • (d) Accept: ATP synthase is driven by H+ flowing down the gradient through it, so if H+ can cross the membrane anywhere the gradient dissipates as fast as it is built, few protons take the route through the synthase, and little ADP is phosphorylated; electron transport is a separate process and continues because no carrier has been blocked. Do not accept: "the chemical breaks ATP synthase"; a claim that never identifies the gradient as the energy source for ATP synthesis.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The replacement electrons come from water. In the model, water is split on the lumen side into 4 H+, 4 e−, and O2, and those electrons go into photosystem II. The protons build up inside the thylakoid lumen, which is the compartment labeled pH 5.0.

    b Two things load the lumen with H+. Splitting water dumps protons straight into it, and as electrons fall from photosystem II through plastoquinone to the cytochrome complex, that complex uses the released energy to pump more H+ out of the stroma and into the lumen. Both moves raise lumen H+ and lower stroma H+, which is why the lumen sits at pH 5.0 and the stroma at pH 8.0.

    c pH 5.0 means [H+] = 1 × 10−5 M and pH 8.0 means [H+] = 1 × 10−8 M, so the ratio is \((1 \times 10^{-5})/(1 \times 10^{-8}) = 1 \times 10^{3}\). The lumen is 1000 times more concentrated in H+ than the stroma.

    d ATP synthase only works because protons are forced back into the stroma through it. If the membrane leaks H+ everywhere, the gradient drains as fast as the chain builds it, so hardly any protons take the route through the synthase and ATP output collapses. Nothing has touched the electron carriers, so electrons still reach NADP+, which is what shows ATP synthesis depends on the gradient, not on electron flow alone.

  4. Data: pipette readings (mL) from three respirometers in a 25 °C water bath, read at 0 and 15 minutes. Each vial contains KOH to absorb CO2, and the two seed vials each hold 20.0 g of peas.

    VialReading at 0 minReading at 15 min
    Germinating peas0.800.35
    Dormant peas0.820.79
    Glass beads only0.780.80

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in the investigation, and describe the purpose of the vial containing only glass beads.
    2. Explain the relationship between the metabolic state of the peas and the volume of oxygen consumed.
    3. Calculate the corrected rate of oxygen consumption of the germinating peas in mL O2 per gram per minute. Show your setup and give units.
    4. Justify the claim that the difference between the two seed vials is caused by respiration rather than by the amount of seed used.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the independent variable is the metabolic state of the vial's contents (germinating peas, dormant peas, or no living tissue). The bead vial is a control for volume changes caused by shifts in room temperature and barometric pressure over the 15 minutes; its drift is subtracted from the other vials' readings. Do not accept: naming oxygen consumption (the dependent variable) as the independent variable; "the beads are the control" with no statement of what they control for.
    • (b) Accept: germinating seeds are synthesizing proteins, building walls and dividing cells, so their ATP demand is high; most of that ATP comes from oxidative phosphorylation, and the electron transport chain runs only while oxygen accepts electrons at the end, so a high ATP demand produces a high rate of oxygen consumption. Dormant seeds have very low ATP demand and consume little. Do not accept: "germinating seeds respire more," which restates the data; a mechanism that never mentions ATP demand or oxygen's role as final electron acceptor.
    • (c) Accept: drift \(= 0.80 - 0.78 = +0.02\) mL; germinating change \(= 0.35 - 0.80 = -0.45\) mL; corrected \(= -0.45 - 0.02 = -0.47\) mL, so 0.47 mL of O2 was consumed; rate \(= 0.47/(20.0 \times 15) = 1.57 \times 10^{-3}\) mL O2 g−1 min−1. Accept 1.6 × 10−3 if the setup shows the correction. Units are required. Do not accept: 1.5 × 10−3 with no correction shown; dividing by time or by mass alone; a bare number.
    • (d) Accept: mass was a controlled variable, both seed vials held 20.0 g, so it cannot account for 0.47 mL versus 0.05 mL, a difference of about ninefold; the only variable that differed between those two vials is whether the seeds were germinating. Do not accept: repeating the two volumes with no reference to the controlled mass; "germinating seeds are more active" as the entire justification.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is what is in the vial: germinating peas, dormant peas, or just beads. The bead vial has no living tissue, so anything that changes its reading has to be the room warming or the pressure shifting rather than respiration. It drifted +0.02 mL in 15 minutes, and I subtract that drift from the other two vials.

    b Germinating seeds are building tissue: transcribing genes, making proteins, dividing cells, and all of that costs ATP. Most of that ATP comes from oxidative phosphorylation, and the electron transport chain can only keep running while oxygen accepts electrons at the end, so a high ATP demand means a high oxygen demand. Dormant seeds are barely metabolizing, so they take up almost none.

    c Drift \(= 0.80 - 0.78 = +0.02\) mL. Germinating peas: \(0.35 - 0.80 = -0.45\) mL, corrected to \(-0.45 - 0.02 = -0.47\) mL, so 0.47 mL of O2 was consumed. Rate \(= 0.47/(20.0 \times 15) = 1.57 \times 10^{-3}\) mL O2 g−1 min−1.

    d Mass was held constant at 20.0 g in both seed vials, so it cannot be why germinating peas used 0.47 mL and dormant peas only 0.05 mL: about nine times less. The one thing that differed between those two vials is whether the seeds were germinating, so the evidence supports metabolic state as the cause.

  5. Data: relative concentrations of two Calvin-cycle intermediates in illuminated Chlorella. The light was switched off at time 0; CO2 was held at 1% throughout.

    Time (s)−300153060
    3-PGA (relative units)100100145168175
    RuBP (relative units)10010042188

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the two products of the light reactions that the Calvin cycle requires, and describe what happens to the concentration of RuBP after the light is switched off.
    2. Explain why 3-PGA accumulates over the same interval in which RuBP falls.
    3. Predict the direction of change in 3-PGA and in RuBP if instead the light were left on and CO2 were removed from the chamber at time 0.
    4. Justify your prediction in (c) using the sequence of reactions in the Calvin cycle.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: ATP and NADPH. RuBP falls steeply, from 100 relative units to 42 within 15 s and to 8 by 60 s, a 92% decrease. Do not accept: naming O2, G3P, or glucose as a required product of the light reactions; "RuBP changes" with no direction; a restatement of the stem.
    • (b) Accept: with the light off no new ATP or NADPH is made, so the reduction of 3-PGA to G3P stalls and 3-PGA stops being consumed, while rubisco, which needs no light, keeps fixing the CO2 still present onto the RuBP already in the stroma, making more 3-PGA and using up RuBP, which cannot be regenerated because regeneration also costs ATP. Do not accept: "the Calvin cycle stops," which the data contradict; an answer that never links ATP or NADPH to a specific step of the cycle.
    • (c) Accept: 3-PGA falls and RuBP rises. Both directions are required. Do not accept: "the cycle slows down"; only one of the two directions; "no change."
    • (d) Accept: CO2 is rubisco's other substrate, so removing it stops carboxylation and no new 3-PGA is formed; because the light is still on, ATP and NADPH keep arriving and the existing 3-PGA continues to be reduced to G3P and drained away, while G3P still feeds regeneration, so RuBP is rebuilt with nothing to consume it and accumulates. Do not accept: restating the prediction in other words; a justification that does not name CO2 as rubisco's substrate or does not use the continued supply of ATP and NADPH.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The Calvin cycle needs ATP and NADPH from the light reactions. Once the light goes off, RuBP drops fast, from 100 relative units to 42 in the first 15 seconds and down to 8 by 60 seconds, a 92% fall.

    b In the dark there is no new ATP or NADPH, so the step that reduces 3-PGA to G3P stalls and 3-PGA stops getting used up. Rubisco does not need light, though, so it keeps attaching the CO2 still in the chamber onto the RuBP already sitting in the stroma. That makes more 3-PGA while consuming RuBP, and rebuilding RuBP also costs ATP, so the RuBP pool drains and is never refilled. That is why one rises 75% while the other collapses.

    c 3-PGA would fall and RuBP would rise: the opposite of what the table shows.

    d CO2 is rubisco's other substrate, so taking it away stops carboxylation and no new 3-PGA is made. The light is still on, so ATP and NADPH keep arriving and the 3-PGA already there keeps being reduced to G3P, draining that pool. The G3P still feeds the regeneration phase, so RuBP gets rebuilt with nothing to carboxylate it and piles up. That is the mirror image of the dark experiment, which is what makes the prediction consistent with the model.

Lesson 4.1 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.1

Cell communication

A single-celled bacterium can sense how crowded its neighborhood is. A cell in your pancreas can tell your liver cells that a meal has arrived. A T cell can recognize that a neighboring cell is infected and destroy it. None of this would be possible if cells were silent. Every living system, from a bacterial colony to a human body, depends on cells storing, transmitting, and responding to information, which is the theme of Big Idea 3. This lesson sorts the ways cells talk to each other by distance. The next lessons look inside the target cell to see what happens when a message arrives.

Learning objectives · 4.1.A and 4.1.B

Describe the ways that cells can communicate with one another, and explain how cells communicate over short and long distances.

Contact or chemical: the two basic strategies

Direct contactcells touch or share channelsLocal signalingsignal reaches nearby cellsLong-distance signalinghormone travels in the bloodgap junctions (animals),plasmodesmata (plants)surface proteins fit together(immune cells)senderneurotransmitters, growthfactors, quorum sensing(only nearby cells respond)glandblood vesseltargetinsulin, thyroid hormone,estrogen, testosterone
Figure 4.1a Cells communicate by direct contact with other cells or from a distance by chemical signaling. Local regulators act on cells in the vicinity of the cell that releases them; hormones released by one cell type travel long distances (for example in the bloodstream) to target cells of another type.
Required content · EK 4.1.A.1

Cells communicate with one another through direct contact with other cells or from a distance via chemical signaling.

In direct contact, the cells touch, and the message passes through the contact itself. In animals, gap junctions are channels that connect the cytoplasm of two neighboring cells, so small molecules and ions pass directly from one to the other; in plants the equivalent channels are plasmodesmata, which pass through the cell walls. A second kind of contact signaling does not move anything between the cells: a protein on the surface of one cell fits a receptor on the surface of the other. This is how many immune cells work. An antigen-presenting cell displays a fragment of a pathogen on its surface; a helper T cell whose receptor fits that fragment binds to it and is activated; and a killer T cell finds an infected cell in the same way, by checking proteins displayed on its surface. Contact signaling is fast and exact, because only the cells that actually touch can take part.

In chemical signaling, one cell releases a molecule, a ligand, that travels through the fluid between cells (or through the blood) to reach other cells, which respond if they have a matching receptor. The two kinds of chemical signal are separated by how far they go, which is the content of the next section.

Short distance and long distance

Required content · EK 4.1.B.1 and 4.1.B.2
  • Cells communicate over short distances by using local regulators that target cells in the vicinity of the signal-emitting cell.
  • Signals released by one cell type can travel long distances to target cells of another type.

Local regulators are released into the fluid around the cell and are broken down, taken up, or diluted quickly, so only nearby cells receive a signal strong enough to respond. Three examples appear in the CED.

  • Neurotransmitters. A neuron releases a neurotransmitter into the tiny gap (the synapse) between it and the next cell. The gap is only about 20 nanometers wide, so the signal crosses it in a fraction of a millisecond and is then removed. A neurotransmitter is a local signal even though the neuron itself may be a meter long.
  • Quorum sensing in bacteria. Bacteria release a signaling molecule into their surroundings. When the population is dense, the molecule accumulates, and when its concentration crosses a threshold the whole population changes gene expression together: for example, the bioluminescent bacterium Vibrio fischeri makes light only when many cells are present. This is communication within a species of single-celled organisms, so it is a local signal that depends on population density.
  • Morphogens in embryonic development. Cells at one end of a developing embryo release a signaling molecule that spreads out and forms a concentration gradient. Cells nearer the source respond one way and cells farther away respond another way, which helps lay out the body plan. (Plants also use local signals: when a leaf is damaged, nearby cells make chemicals that start the plant immune response.)

Long-distance signals are released by one cell type and travel to target cells of another type, often in the bloodstream. In animals these are hormones, made by endocrine glands. Insulin from the pancreas, human growth hormone from the pituitary, thyroid hormones from the thyroid gland, and the sex hormones testosterone and estrogen are the CED examples. Because a hormone is carried throughout the body, it reaches every cell, but it affects only the target cells that have a receptor for it. This is why insulin affects liver, muscle, and fat cells but not, for example, a red blood cell (which has few insulin receptors). The receptor decides who listens.

Direct contactLocal regulatorLong-distance signal
How the message movesThrough channels, or by surface proteins that touchDiffusion through the fluid between cellsCarried in the bloodstream (or plant vascular tissue)
Who receives itOnly touching cellsCells in the vicinityTarget cells of another type, anywhere in the body
ExamplesGap junctions; plasmodesmata; T cell with antigen-presenting cellNeurotransmitters; quorum sensing; morphogensInsulin, growth hormone, thyroid hormone, testosterone, estrogen

Why the receptor decides everything

The same signal can mean different things to different cells, and a cell with no receptor ignores the signal completely. A message needs three parts: a sender that releases the ligand, a ligand that carries the information, and a receptor in the target cell that is specific for that ligand, in the same way that an enzyme is specific for its substrate (lesson 3.1). This is why only a small number of ligands are needed to coordinate trillions of cells: each target cell type has its own set of receptors, and so it listens only to its own set of signals. The next lesson follows a signal from the receptor into the cell.

Worked example · Choose the type of signaling from the data

Researchers studying a bacterium find that it produces a signaling molecule at a steady rate in all conditions. In a dilute culture (about \(10^4\) cells per mL) the cells do not make a light-producing enzyme. In a dense culture (about \(10^8\) cells per mL) they do. When dense culture fluid is filtered to remove all bacteria and added to a dilute culture, the dilute cells also begin to make the enzyme. Identify the type of signaling and explain what the data show.

Claim. This is local chemical signaling by a diffusing ligand (quorum sensing). It is not direct contact.
Evidence. The signal is present in cell-free fluid, so it is a molecule released into the environment, not a surface protein that needs cell-to-cell contact. The response depends on cell density, because each cell releases the molecule at a constant rate, so the concentration in the surroundings rises with the number of cells; the response needs a threshold concentration.
Reasoning. The signaling molecule accumulates only when many cells are present (\(10^8\) cells release \(10^4\) times as much as \(10^4\) cells in the same volume), and the cells respond to it through receptors, so the whole population acts together.

Exam focus
  • Two big categories: direct contact (gap junctions, plasmodesmata, surface proteins) and chemical signaling from a distance.
  • Sort chemical signals by distance: local regulators (neurotransmitters, quorum sensing, morphogens) and long-distance signals (hormones carried in the blood to target cells of a different type).
  • A cell responds only if it has the right receptor. Use the words “target cell” and “specific receptor” in explanations.
  • Quorum sensing is a signal that depends on population density, with a threshold.
Practice
  1. Describe two ways that cells communicate by direct contact, one in animals and one in plants.
    Show answer

    In animals, gap junctions connect the cytoplasm of neighboring cells and allow small molecules and ions to pass. In plants, plasmodesmata are channels through the cell walls that connect the cytoplasm of neighboring cells. (Cell-surface proteins binding to receptors on a touching cell, as with immune cells, is another form of direct contact.)

  2. Distinguish a local regulator from a hormone, with one example of each.
    Show answer

    A local regulator acts on cells in the vicinity of the cell that released it, such as a neurotransmitter crossing a synapse. A hormone is released by one cell type and travels long distances, usually in the bloodstream, to target cells of another type, such as insulin from the pancreas acting on liver, muscle, and fat cells.

  3. Insulin is carried in the blood to every tissue, but it changes the behavior of only some cells. Explain why.
    Show answer

    Only the target cells have receptors that bind insulin. Cells without the specific receptor cannot detect the ligand, so they do not respond even though the hormone reaches them.

  4. Explain why a neurotransmitter is considered a local regulator even though a neuron can be very long.
    Show answer

    The neurotransmitter is released into the synapse and acts only on the cell on the other side of this tiny gap (about 20 nm), where it is quickly removed. The signal travels along the neuron as an electrical impulse, but the chemical signal itself reaches only cells in the immediate vicinity.

  5. In the worked example, the dense culture’s fluid was heated to 100 °C before it was added to the dilute cells, and it no longer caused any response. Which conclusion is better supported: the signal is a protein, or the signal is a lipid? Justify.
    Show answer

    The data support a protein (or another heat-sensitive molecule). Heating to 100 °C denatures proteins, and a denatured ligand no longer fits its receptor, so the signal is lost. This is not conclusive, because other molecules can also be heat-sensitive, but it does not support a stable lipid.

  6. A student claims that quorum sensing shows that bacteria communicate with a long-distance signal like a hormone. Evaluate the claim.
    Show answer

    The claim is not correct. Quorum sensing uses a ligand that diffuses through the surroundings and affects nearby cells of the same kind, so it is a local regulator that depends on population density. A hormone is released by one cell type and travels long distances to target cells of a different type, often in a bloodstream, which a bacterial culture does not have.

Lesson 4.2 · Unit 4 · CED topics 4.2 and 4.3 (part 1)

Signal transduction: from receptor to response

A hormone such as epinephrine (adrenaline) never enters a liver cell, yet within seconds the cell begins breaking down glycogen and releasing glucose into the blood. How can a molecule that stays outside the cell change what happens inside? The answer is signal transduction: the signal is converted from one form (a ligand bound to a receptor) into another (a chain of changes inside the cell) that ends in a response. This lesson follows the signal from the outside of the cell to the end, and shows how one molecule can produce a response by millions.

Learning objectives · 4.2.A, 4.2.B and 4.3.A

Describe the components of a signal transduction pathway and the role of each in producing a cellular response, and describe the different types of cellular responses elicited by a pathway.

Three stages: reception, transduction, response

plasma membranecytoplasmligand1. Receptorbinds ligandchanges shape2. G proteinactivatedby receptor3. Enzymemakes secondmessenger4. cAMPspreads inthe cell5. Kinaseseach stepadds a P6. Responseenzyme orgene changeLigand binding is the signal; the cascade relays it and amplifies it into a response.Each step can be regulated, and each is a place where a mutation or a drug can interfere.
Figure 4.2a A signal transduction pathway links signal reception with a cellular response. Reception: a ligand binds a receptor. Transduction: relay molecules, second messengers, and phosphorylation cascades pass the signal inward. Response: a change in enzyme activity, secretion, or gene expression.
Required content · EK 4.2.A.1 and 4.2.A.2
  • Signal transduction pathways link signal receptions with cellular responses.
  • Many signal transduction pathways include protein modifications and involve phosphorylation cascades.

It helps to think of three stages. Reception: the ligand binds to a receptor. Transduction: the receptor passes the message inward through a series of relay molecules. Response: the cell does something different, such as changing the activity of an enzyme, secreting a molecule, growing, or turning a gene on or off. Biologists use a pathway diagram like the one above because the same plan is used again and again, with different molecules, in animals, plants, fungi, and bacteria.

Reception: ligand and receptor

Required content · EK 4.2.B.1
  • Signaling begins with the recognition of a chemical messenger (a ligand) by a receptor protein in a target cell.
  • The ligand-binding domain of a receptor recognizes a specific chemical messenger, which can be a peptide (protein) or a small molecule.
  • G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are an example of a receptor protein in eukaryotes.
  • Receptors may be located on the surface of a target cell or in the cytoplasm or nucleus of the target cell.
Cell-surface receptorIntracellular receptorwater-soluble ligandcannot crosspeptide hormones, growth factorsneurotransmitterssignal is relayed from the surfacesmall nonpolar ligandRDNAsteroid and thyroid hormonesturn genes on or off
Figure 4.2b Where the receptor is located depends on the ligand. Hydrophilic signals cannot cross the lipid bilayer, so their receptors are on the cell surface. Small nonpolar signals, such as steroid hormones, cross the membrane and bind receptors in the cytoplasm or nucleus.

A receptor is a protein with a ligand-binding domain whose shape fits one ligand, like an enzyme’s active site (lesson 3.1). Where the receptor sits depends on the ligand’s chemistry (lesson 2.3). A large or charged (hydrophilic) ligand, such as a peptide hormone, a growth factor, or a neurotransmitter, cannot cross the hydrophobic interior of the plasma membrane, so it binds to a receptor in the membrane and the signal is passed across the membrane by the receptor itself. A small nonpolar ligand, such as a steroid hormone (estrogen, testosterone) or thyroid hormone, dissolves in the lipid bilayer, crosses into the cell, and binds a receptor in the cytoplasm or nucleus; the ligand-receptor complex then usually acts directly on DNA to change gene expression. G protein-coupled receptors are the largest family of cell-surface receptors in eukaryotes. A GPCR passes through the membrane and, when its ligand binds, changes shape on the inside of the cell and activates a G protein, a protein that is switched on by binding GTP. The activated G protein then activates the next component of the pathway.

Transduction: relaying and amplifying

Required content · EK 4.2.B.2
  • Signaling cascades relay signals from receptors to cell targets, often amplifying the incoming signals, resulting in the appropriate responses by the cell. Responses could include cell growth, secretion of molecules, or gene expression.
  • After the ligand binds, the intracellular domain of a receptor protein changes shape, initiating transduction of the signal.
  • Enzymes and second messengers, such as cyclic AMP (cAMP), relay and amplify the intracellular signal.
  • Hormones are an example of a signaling messenger that can travel long distances in the bloodstream.
  • The binding of ligands to ligand-gated channels can cause the channel to open or close.

Once the receptor changes shape, the signal must be relayed. Two tools are used most often.

Phosphorylation cascades. A kinase is an enzyme that adds a phosphate group (taken from ATP) to another protein; this is phosphorylation. Adding a phosphate changes the shape of the target protein and can switch it on (or off). In a cascade, an active kinase phosphorylates the next kinase, which becomes active and phosphorylates the next, and so on. A phosphatase removes the phosphate again and switches the pathway off, so the cell can stop responding when the signal stops.

Second messengers. The ligand is the first messenger. A second messenger is a small, nonprotein molecule or ion made inside the cell that spreads quickly through the cytoplasm and activates other proteins. Cyclic AMP (cAMP) is made from ATP by the enzyme adenylyl cyclase, which a G protein activates; cAMP then activates a protein kinase. Because second messengers are small, they diffuse rapidly and reach all parts of the cell. Calcium ions are another example.

110102103104105106Number of molecules (log scale)Ligand-bound receptors1G proteins activated100cAMP molecules made10,000Enzymes activated1,000,000
Figure 4.2c Each step in the cascade activates many molecules at the next step. A single signal molecule can therefore produce a response by millions of enzyme molecules (an amplification of a million-fold in this model). The model assumes each activated molecule activates 100 molecules at the next step.

Amplification is the reason that these cascades are so useful. At each step, one active molecule can activate many molecules of the next kind, because enzymes are catalysts that do not get used up (lesson 3.1). In the model shown above, a single ligand-bound receptor activates 100 G proteins, which cause 10,000 cAMP molecules to be made, which activate 1,000,000 enzyme molecules: the response is a million times the original signal. This is how a few molecules of epinephrine can release a large amount of glucose from the liver in seconds.

Ligand-gated channels work without a cascade. The receptor is itself an ion channel that opens (or closes) when the ligand binds. In a neuron, a neurotransmitter binding to a ligand-gated channel opens it, so ions flow through and change the electrical state of the cell at once. This is the fastest kind of signaling, and it shows that the response to a ligand can be the opening of a gate as well as the starting of a cascade.

Worked example · Epinephrine and glycogen breakdown

Epinephrine is a hormone that binds to a GPCR on liver cells. The sequence of events is: (1) epinephrine binds the receptor; (2) the receptor activates a G protein; (3) the G protein activates adenylyl cyclase, which makes cAMP; (4) cAMP activates a protein kinase; (5) a kinase cascade activates glycogen phosphorylase; (6) glycogen is broken down to glucose. Label each step as reception, transduction, or response, and predict what happens if cells are treated with a chemical that destroys cAMP as fast as it is made.

Reception: step 1. Transduction: steps 2 to 5 (G protein, enzyme, second messenger, kinases). Response: step 6, the change in enzyme activity that breaks down glycogen.
Prediction. If cAMP is destroyed as fast as it is made, it never builds up and the kinase is not activated, so the cascade stops and the cell does not break down glycogen, even though epinephrine is bound to the receptor. Reception happens, and the response does not.
Justification. cAMP is the second messenger that links the G protein to the kinase. Without it, the signal cannot be transduced. (Caffeine has the opposite effect in cells: it blocks the enzyme that breaks down cAMP, so cAMP stays high for longer and the response is prolonged.)

Responses

Required content · EK 4.3.A.1

Signal transduction may result in changes in gene expression and cell function, which may alter phenotype or result in programmed cell death (apoptosis).

The end of the pathway can be one of three kinds of response. (1) An enzyme or other protein is activated or inhibited, as with glycogen phosphorylase, so the response is immediate. (2) A transcription factor is activated and enters the nucleus, where it turns genes on or off; this takes longer, because proteins have to be made, but it can change the cell’s phenotype for a long time (for example in cell growth, division, or the development of a cell type). (3) The cell is told to die. Apoptosis is programmed cell death, in which a cell dismantles itself in an orderly way. It is used to remove cells that are damaged, are infected, or are no longer needed (such as the tissue between the fingers in an embryo). In every case the response depends on which signal the cell receives, which receptors it has, and which relay proteins are present, so the same ligand can have different effects in different cell types.

Exam focus
  • Use the three stages: reception (ligand binds receptor), transduction (relay, second messengers, phosphorylation cascade), response (enzyme activity, secretion, growth, gene expression, apoptosis).
  • Receptor location matches ligand chemistry: hydrophilic ligand means a surface receptor; small nonpolar ligand means a cytoplasmic or nuclear receptor.
  • A kinase adds phosphate (using ATP), a phosphatase removes it. cAMP is a second messenger. GPCRs activate G proteins.
  • Amplification: one signal molecule leads to many activated molecules at each step.
  • Ligand-gated channels open or close when a ligand binds: no cascade is needed.
  • To predict what happens when a component is missing or blocked, say which step stops and what happens downstream.
Practice
  1. Testosterone is a steroid hormone. Predict where its receptor is located in a target cell and justify.
    Show answer

    Its receptor is inside the cell, in the cytoplasm or nucleus. Testosterone is small and nonpolar (a lipid), so it can pass through the hydrophobic interior of the plasma membrane and bind to an intracellular receptor, which then acts on gene expression.

  2. Insulin is a protein hormone. Explain why its receptor is on the cell surface.
    Show answer

    Insulin is a large, hydrophilic protein that cannot cross the hydrophobic core of the lipid bilayer, so its receptor must be in the plasma membrane, with a ligand-binding domain outside and an intracellular domain that starts transduction inside.

  3. A single active kinase molecule phosphorylates 50 molecules of the next kinase, and each of those phosphorylates 50 molecules of a third kinase. Calculate the number of molecules of the third kinase that are activated by one signal, and explain the biological advantage.
    Show answer

    \(50 \times 50 = 2{,}500\) molecules. The advantage is amplification: a very small signal (a few ligand molecules binding) produces a large response, so the cell can respond quickly and to low concentrations.

  4. Describe the roles of a kinase and a phosphatase in a signaling pathway.
    Show answer

    A kinase adds a phosphate group (from ATP) to a protein, which changes its shape and usually activates it, passing the signal on. A phosphatase removes the phosphate, which returns the protein to its inactive state and turns the pathway off when the signal ends.

  5. A neurotransmitter binds to a ligand-gated ion channel. Describe how the response differs from one that uses a GPCR and a second messenger.
    Show answer

    When the ligand binds a ligand-gated channel, the channel itself opens (or closes) and ions cross the membrane immediately, so the response is very fast and there is no cascade or second messenger. A GPCR passes the signal through a G protein, an enzyme, a second messenger such as cAMP, and often a kinase cascade, which is slower but amplifies the signal.

  6. Some cells can respond to epinephrine by breaking down glycogen, and others, such as smooth muscle cells in blood vessels, respond by relaxing or contracting. Explain how one ligand can have different effects.
    Show answer

    The response depends on the receptors and relay proteins each cell type has and on the target proteins at the end of the pathway. The same ligand binding to a receptor (or to different receptors) can start different pathways in different cells, so liver cells respond with enzyme activation, and muscle cells with a change in contraction.

Lesson 4.3 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.3

When a pathway changes: mutations and chemicals

A signaling pathway is a chain, and a chain is only as reliable as its weakest link. A single change in one protein can make a cell deaf to a signal, or make it act as if the signal were always present. Many diseases, including some cancers, diabetes, and cholera, are caused by exactly this kind of change, and many drugs work by changing a pathway on purpose. This lesson explains how, and how to predict the effect.

Learning objectives · 4.3.B

Explain how a change in the structure of any signaling molecule affects the activity of the signaling pathway.

Mutations in the receptor or any component

Required content · EK 4.3.B.1 and 4.3.B.2
  • Changes in signal transduction pathways can alter cellular responses. Mutations in any domain of the receptor protein or in any component of the signaling pathway may affect the downstream components by altering the subsequent transduction of the signal.
  • Chemicals that interact with any component of the signaling pathway may activate or inhibit the pathway.
LigandReceptorRelay (kinases)ResponseNormalpathwaypresentactiveactiveONLigand-bindingdomain mutatedpresentno bindinginactiveOFFIntracellular domainstuck activeabsentalways activeactiveON, no signalDrug inhibitsa kinasepresentactiveblockedOFF
Figure 4.3a A mutation in any domain of the receptor, or in any component of the pathway, can change the response. A defective ligand-binding domain makes the cell deaf to the signal; a receptor stuck in the active shape produces a response with no signal. A chemical that interacts with a component can activate or inhibit the pathway.

A mutation changes the sequence of amino acids in a protein, and a change in sequence can change its three-dimensional shape and so its function (lesson 1.7). In a receptor, the effect depends on the domain that is changed.

  • Ligand-binding domain. If the binding site no longer fits the ligand, the ligand cannot bind, the receptor is never activated, and the cell does not respond. The pathway is blocked at the first step even though all of the other components are normal. (If the change makes the site fit a different molecule better, the cell could respond to the wrong signal.)
  • Intracellular domain. A change here can lock the receptor in its active shape, so it starts the cascade whether or not the ligand is present. The response is on all the time with no signal. If the response is cell division, this is a path to uncontrolled growth.
  • Any downstream component. A mutation in a G protein, a kinase, or a transcription factor can stop the signal at that step (loss of function) or keep it on (gain of function). Because each step passes the message to the next, the change affects all of the downstream components.

An important idea for the exam is that a change is passed downstream. If a protein in the middle of the pathway is always on, then it does not matter that the receptor upstream is off, and everything after that point is active. If a protein is lost, nothing after it can be activated, however much ligand is present. This is the reasoning to use when you are asked to predict the effect of a mutation, as in the worked example below.

Chemicals that activate or inhibit

Many molecules interact with the components of a pathway without being the natural ligand. A chemical that mimics the ligand and activates the receptor is an agonist; a chemical that binds the receptor without activating it and so blocks the natural ligand is an antagonist, which acts as a competitive inhibitor (lesson 3.2). Beta-blockers, for example, are antagonists of the receptors for epinephrine, and they slow the heart. Other chemicals act farther along the pathway. A drug that blocks the active site of a kinase stops every step after it, which is how many cancer drugs work, and cholera toxin changes a G protein so that it stays active, so intestinal cells keep making cAMP and release large amounts of water and ions, which causes severe diarrhea.

Worked example · Predicting the effect of mutations (cell lines)

Researchers study a pathway in which a growth factor (GF) binds a receptor (R), which activates kinase 1 (K1), then kinase 2 (K2), and K2 activates a transcription factor that turns on genes for cell division. Four cell lines were tested with and without the growth factor, and cell division was measured as the percent of cells that divided in 24 hours.

Cell lineWithout GFWith GF
Normal4%62%
Mutant A5%6%
Mutant B58%60%
Mutant C4%5%

Mutant A has a defect in the ligand-binding domain of R, mutant B has a defect that locks K1 in its active form, and mutant C lacks K2 completely. Match each mutant to the data and explain.

Normal. The growth factor increases division by \(62 - 4 = 58\) percentage points, so the pathway works and depends on the ligand.
Mutant B (K1 always on). Division is high (58%) even without GF, and GF has almost no further effect (\(60 - 58 = 2\) points), so the pathway is constantly on. Its position matters: K1 is downstream of the receptor, so the receptor is no longer needed.
Mutant A (ligand-binding domain) and mutant C (no K2). Both show a low rate with and without GF (\(6 - 5 = 1\) point and \(5 - 4 = 1\) point), so the signal is blocked. The data alone cannot separate them. To tell them apart, an experiment could place an active form of K1 in each cell: in mutant A, which still has K2, division would rise to a high level; in mutant C, which lacks K2, it would not, because there is no K2 to relay the signal.
Reasoning. A mutation affects all of the downstream components, so each mutant’s pattern of response gives information about where in the pathway it acts.

Illustrative examples from the CED

  • Cytokines regulate gene expression to allow for cell replication and division.
  • Mating pheromones in yeast trigger mating gene expression: a signal from one yeast cell changes the expression of genes in another.
  • Ethylene is a gas made by ripening fruit; it changes the production of different enzymes, which soften the fruit and change its color. Because it is a gas, it also signals to neighboring fruit.
  • HOX genes regulate animal body plans during embryonic development: signals along the embryo switch on different HOX genes in different regions, and a mutation can put a body part in the wrong place.
  • Epinephrine stimulates glycogen breakdown in mammals (lesson 4.2), and quorum sensing regulates specific genes in response to population density (lesson 4.1).
Exam focus
  • A mutation in the ligand-binding domain usually blocks the response (no binding). A mutation in an intracellular domain or downstream protein can lock the pathway on or off.
  • Always follow the signal downstream: what is affected by the change, and what is not.
  • Chemicals can activate (mimic or stimulate) or inhibit (block a receptor or enzyme) at any step.
  • Say what you predict and why: the response is higher, lower, or unchanged, with the reason connected to the missing or active component.
  • A pathway that is always on in the absence of a signal can lead to uncontrolled cell division (see lesson 4.6).
Practice
  1. A mutation changes the ligand-binding domain of a receptor so that the ligand no longer fits. Predict the effect on a cell exposed to the ligand, and explain.
    Show answer

    The cell will not respond. The ligand cannot bind to the receptor, so the receptor does not change shape and the pathway is never started, even if all of the downstream components are normal.

  2. A mutation locks a kinase in the middle of a pathway in the active form. Predict the effect on the response with and without the ligand, and justify.
    Show answer

    The response occurs with or without the ligand. The active kinase passes the signal to the components that follow it whether or not the receptor above it is activated, so everything downstream is on all the time and the ligand is no longer needed.

  3. A drug binds to the receptor for a hormone but does not change its shape. Describe the effect on the cell, and name the type of chemical.
    Show answer

    The drug is an antagonist (a competitive inhibitor of the receptor). It occupies the ligand-binding site without activating the receptor, so the natural hormone cannot bind and the cell does not respond.

  4. In the worked example, the researchers add GF to mutant B and measure 60% division, compared with 58% without GF. A student concludes that GF has no effect on the normal pathway. Evaluate.
    Show answer

    The conclusion is not supported. In the normal cell line GF raised division from 4% to 62%. Mutant B has a kinase that is always active, so the pathway is already at its maximum and GF has almost nothing to add (a 2-point change). The data show that GF acts upstream of the defect in K1, not that GF is ineffective.

  5. Cholera toxin permanently activates a G protein in intestinal cells. Predict the effect on the level of cAMP and explain the symptoms.
    Show answer

    cAMP levels rise and stay high, because the active G protein continues to activate the enzyme that makes cAMP. High cAMP keeps the pathway on, and in intestinal cells the response is the release of large amounts of ions and water into the intestine, which causes severe diarrhea.

  6. A pathway ends in a transcription factor that turns on a gene needed for cell division. Describe two different mutations that could result in uncontrolled division.
    Show answer

    First, a mutation in the receptor’s intracellular domain that locks the receptor active, so that the pathway is on without the signal. Second, a mutation that locks a kinase or the transcription factor in the active form. (A mutation that removes a component that switches the pathway off, such as a phosphatase, would also keep the pathway on.) In each case the response, division, occurs in the absence of the growth signal.

Lesson 4.4 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.4

Feedback and homeostasis

Your blood glucose is about the same before breakfast and an hour after it, although you may have just taken in 50 grams of sugar. Your body temperature is nearly the same on a winter morning and in a summer afternoon. Organisms stay alive because their internal conditions, the “set point” for each variable, change only a little while the outside world changes a lot. The control mechanism is feedback: the output of a process is sensed and fed back to change the process. This lesson covers the two kinds of feedback, why most of them are negative, and why a few are positive.

Learning objective · 4.4.A

Explain how positive and negative feedback help maintain homeostasis.

Negative feedback: the stabilizer

Negative feedbackVariable movesaway from the set pointSensor and control centerdetect the changeEffector respondsreturns variable to set point−response reduces the stimuluskeeps the variable near its set pointPositive feedbackVariable changesinitial stimulusSensor and control centerdetect the changeEffector respondspushes the variable further away+response amplifies the stimuluscontinues until an endpoint is reached
Figure 4.4a Negative feedback reduces the initial stimulus and returns a system to its set point; it is the most common way organisms maintain homeostasis. Positive feedback amplifies a response and moves the variable further from the initial set point, as in childbirth, blood clotting, and fruit ripening.
Required content · EK 4.4.A.1
  • Organisms use feedback mechanisms to maintain their internal environments in response to internal and external changes.
  • Negative feedback mechanisms maintain homeostasis by reducing the initial stimulus to regulate physiological processes. If a system is perturbed or disrupted, negative feedback mechanisms return the system back to its target set point. These processes operate at the molecular, cellular, and organismal levels.
  • Positive feedback mechanisms amplify responses and processes in biological organisms. The variable initiating the response is moved further away from the initial set point. Amplification occurs when the stimulus is further intensified, which, in turn, initiates an additional response that produces system change.

A feedback loop has four parts. A sensor detects a change in a variable, such as temperature or concentration; a control center compares it with the set point; an effector (a cell, tissue, or enzyme) acts; and the result changes the variable. In negative feedback, the result is the opposite of the change that started the loop: if the variable goes up, the response pushes it down, and if it goes down, the response pushes it up. A home thermostat is the standard analogy. When the room gets too warm, the air conditioner turns on, which cools the room, and when the cooling goes far enough, it turns off. Negative feedback works at every level of biology: it controls molecules (an end product that inhibits the first enzyme of its own pathway, as in lesson 3.2), cells (the pathways in this unit are turned off when the signal is removed), and organisms (body temperature, blood pH, blood glucose).

Blood sugar: a negative feedback loop with two hormones

The CED example is blood sugar regulation by insulin and glucagon, two hormones from the pancreas (they are long-distance signals, lesson 4.1). After a meal, glucose enters the blood and the level rises above the set point (about 90 mg/dL in this lesson’s example). Pancreatic cells sense the rise and release insulin. Insulin binds to receptors on liver, muscle, and fat cells; the signal pathway (lesson 4.2) causes these cells to take up glucose and store it as glycogen or fat. Blood glucose falls back to the set point, and the release of insulin falls with it. If the blood glucose falls too low, for example between meals or during exercise, a different set of pancreatic cells release glucagon, which signals liver cells to break down glycogen and release glucose, so the level rises back to the set point. Two hormones with opposite effects give control in both directions.

6010014018022000.511.522.53Time after a meal (hours)Blood glucose (mg/dL)set point (90 mg/dL)normalinsulin resistant
Figure 4.4b Insulin released after a meal signals cells to take up glucose, lowering blood glucose back toward the set point (negative feedback). When cells respond poorly to insulin, the peak is higher and the return to the set point is much slower.

The graph shows the idea with illustrative values. In the normal person (green), glucose rises after a meal to a peak of 135 mg/dL at 30 minutes and returns to about 90 mg/dL by three hours. In a person whose cells respond poorly to insulin (insulin resistance, as in type 2 diabetes), the same meal makes glucose rise to 210 mg/dL, and after three hours it is still 175 mg/dL. The loop still exists, but the sensor-effector connection is weak: insulin is released, but the target cells do not respond well, because their receptors or the pathway behind them (lesson 4.3) are defective. In type 1 diabetes, a different problem causes the same outcome: the cells that make insulin are destroyed, so too little hormone is released.

Worked example · Analyzing the glucose data

Use the data in the graph: set point 90 mg/dL; normal person: 90 (0 h), 135 (0.5 h), 115 (1 h), 95 (2 h), 90 (3 h); insulin-resistant person: 110, 170, 210, 195, 175. Calculate the percent increase in glucose from the start to the peak for each person, and the amount by which each differs from the set point of 90 at 3 hours. Then explain what the differences show.

Normal. Peak 135 at 0.5 h. Percent increase \(= (135 - 90)/90 \times 100 = 50\%\).
Insulin resistant. Peak 210 at 1 h. Percent increase \(= (210 - 110)/110 \times 100 = 91\%\).
At 3 hours. Normal: \(90 - 90 = 0\) mg/dL from the set point. Insulin resistant: \(175 - 90 = 85\) mg/dL above it.
Explanation. The normal person rises by 50% to a lower peak at 0.5 h and returns to the set point within 3 hours. The insulin-resistant person starts higher, rises by 91% to a higher and later peak (1 h), and has not returned to the set point at 3 hours. This shows a slower and weaker negative feedback response: the response to insulin is reduced, so the stimulus (high glucose) is not reduced as quickly.

Positive feedback: the amplifier

In positive feedback, the response increases the change that started it. The variable moves further from its starting point, which strengthens the stimulus, which strengthens the response, and so on. Left alone, such a loop would run away, so every biological positive feedback loop has an endpoint at which something else stops it. Positive feedback is not used to maintain a set point; it is used when a process needs to be rapid, complete, and all-or-nothing. The CED lists three examples.

  • Onset of labor in childbirth. Pressure of the baby’s head on the cervix stimulates nerve signals to the brain, which releases oxytocin. Oxytocin makes the uterus contract more strongly, which pushes the baby harder against the cervix, which causes the release of more oxytocin. The loop continues until the baby is born and the pressure stops.
  • Lactation in mammals. Suckling stimulates the release of oxytocin and prolactin; milk is released, which makes the infant suckle more, which stimulates more release of hormone. The more the infant feeds, the more milk is produced.
  • Ripening of fruit. A ripening fruit produces ethylene gas, which causes the fruit and neighboring fruit to make more ethylene. This is why one ripe banana speeds up the ripening of the bunch, and why fruit is often stored in a bag.

Blood clotting is another well-known example (platelets that stick to a wound release chemicals that attract more platelets), though it is not listed in the CED. In every case the loop ends when the process is complete: the baby is born, the fruit is ripe, the clot seals the vessel.

Negative feedbackPositive feedback
Effect of the responseReduces the initial stimulusAmplifies the initial stimulus
VariableReturns toward the set pointMoves further from the starting point
RoleMaintains homeostasisDrives a process to completion
ExamplesBlood glucose, body temperature, enzyme end-product inhibitionLabor, lactation, fruit ripening
Exam focus
  • Decide by what the response does to the stimulus: it reduces it (negative) or increases it (positive). Do not decide by whether the response seems “good” or “bad.”
  • Negative feedback returns the variable to the set point and maintains homeostasis; most homeostasis is negative feedback.
  • Positive feedback amplifies the response and moves the variable away; it ends when the process is complete (labor, lactation, fruit ripening).
  • Blood sugar: high glucose, then insulin, then uptake and storage, then lower glucose. Low glucose, then glucagon, then release from the liver, then higher glucose.
  • When a loop fails (a missing hormone or a defective receptor), the variable stays away from the set point.
Practice
  1. Body temperature rises during exercise, and the body responds by sweating. Is this positive or negative feedback? Justify.
    Show answer

    Negative feedback. Sweating cools the body, which reduces the initial stimulus (the rise in temperature) and returns the temperature toward the set point.

  2. Explain how insulin and glucagon work together to keep blood glucose near the set point.
    Show answer

    When glucose is above the set point, insulin is released and signals cells to take up glucose and store it, which lowers the level. When glucose is below the set point, glucagon is released and signals the liver to break down glycogen and release glucose, which raises the level. Opposite responses allow correction in either direction (negative feedback).

  3. Describe the positive feedback loop that occurs during childbirth, and explain what ends it.
    Show answer

    Pressure of the baby on the cervix triggers the release of oxytocin, which increases the strength of uterine contractions, which pushes the baby harder against the cervix, which causes more oxytocin release. The loop ends when the baby is born and the pressure on the cervix stops.

  4. A student claims that a feedback loop must be negative if it keeps a process under control and positive if it makes the body worse. Evaluate.
    Show answer

    The claim is incorrect. The type of feedback is determined by the effect of the response on the original stimulus: a response that reduces the stimulus is negative, and one that amplifies it is positive. Positive feedback is not necessarily harmful (labor and fruit ripening are normal and useful) and negative feedback can be harmful if the set point is wrong.

  5. Using the glucose graph, calculate the time at which the normal person’s glucose is back within 5 mg/dL of the set point, and the difference between the two people at that time.
    Show answer

    The normal person is at 95 mg/dL at 2 hours, which is within 5 of 90. At 2 hours the insulin-resistant person is at 195, so the difference is \(195 - 95 = 100\) mg/dL.

  6. An end product of a metabolic pathway binds to the first enzyme and inhibits it. Classify the feedback, and predict what happens when the end product is used up.
    Show answer

    This is negative feedback: the product reduces the activity that makes it. When the end product is used up, less of it is bound to the first enzyme, so the enzyme becomes active again and more product is made, which keeps the amount of product near a steady level.

Lesson 4.5 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.5 (part 1)

The cell cycle and interphase

You began as a single cell, and your body now has about 30 trillion. Every one of those cells came from the division of an earlier cell, and the repeated process of growing and dividing is called the cell cycle. A cell does not simply split in two: it first has to double its contents, and it must copy its DNA exactly, because each daughter cell needs a complete set of genetic information. This lesson covers the long preparation, called interphase, and the next lesson covers the division itself.

Learning objective · 4.5.A

Describe the events that occur in the cell cycle.

An organized series of stages

G1SG2McellcycleInterphase = G1 + S + G2 (about 23 of the 24 hours)G0 (resting)G1 (11 h)Growth; organelles and cytosol duplicatedS (8 h)DNA replicates; sister chromatidsG2 (4 h)Proteins made; centrosomes replicateM (1 h)Mitosis, then cytokinesisTimes are typical of a fast-dividing human cellculture; cells in a body vary a great deal.
Figure 4.5a The cell cycle: interphase (G1, S, G2), then mitosis and cytokinesis. A cell can leave G1 for G0, in which it no longer divides, and may reenter the cycle in response to appropriate cues. The durations shown are illustrative values for a rapidly dividing cell.
Required content · EK 4.5.A.1
  • The cell cycle is a highly regulated series of events that controls the growth and reproduction of eukaryotic cells.
  • The cell cycle consists of sequential stages of interphase (G1, S, G2), mitosis, and cytokinesis.
  • G1 phase: the cell is metabolically active, duplicating organelles and cytosolic components.
  • S phase: DNA is in the form of chromatin and replicates to form two sister chromatids connected at a centromere.
  • G2 phase: protein synthesis occurs, ATP is produced in large quantities, and centrosomes replicate.
  • A cell can enter a stage (G0) in which it no longer divides, but it can reenter the cell cycle in response to appropriate cues.
  • Nondividing cells may exit the cell cycle or be held at a particular stage in the cell cycle.

Interphase is the time between divisions, and it is not a resting stage: it is when the cell does its normal work, grows, and prepares to divide. It is divided into three phases (the “G” stands for “gap”; the S stands for synthesis).

  • G1 (first gap). The cell is metabolically active. It grows, makes proteins and lipids, and duplicates its organelles (mitochondria, ribosomes, endoplasmic reticulum) and cytosol. In many cells this is the longest and most variable phase. During G1 the cell decides whether to go on, by the checkpoint described in lesson 4.7.
  • S (synthesis). The cell replicates its DNA. Before S phase, each chromosome is a single, unreplicated DNA molecule. DNA is spread out as chromatin (DNA wrapped around histone proteins) during interphase, so it cannot be seen as separate chromosomes. After S phase, each chromosome has two identical copies, the sister chromatids, joined at the centromere. The number of chromosomes has not changed, but the amount of DNA has doubled.
  • G2 (second gap). The cell makes the proteins it needs for division (such as the proteins of the spindle), makes ATP in large quantities, and replicates the centrosomes, the structures that organize the microtubules of the spindle.

After G2 comes M phase, which includes mitosis (division of the nucleus) and cytokinesis (division of the cytoplasm). M phase is short: in the model above it takes only 1 of 24 hours, so most cells that you look at under a microscope are in interphase. The next lesson describes it in detail.

Counting chromosomes and DNA

Students often confuse the number of chromosomes with the amount of DNA. A chromosome is counted by its centromere, and a replicated chromosome (two sister chromatids) is still one chromosome. A human body cell has 46 chromosomes (23 pairs). Using \(n\) for the number of different chromosomes in a set (\(n = 23\) in humans), a body cell is \(2n = 46\). Letting a 2n cell have DNA content of 2C in G1:

StageChromosomesChromatidsDNA content
G146462C
After S and G246924C
Anaphase of mitosis (each chromatid is now a chromosome)92924C
Each daughter cell after division46462C

G0: leaving the cycle

Not every cell keeps dividing. A cell may leave G1 and enter G0, a state in which it carries out its normal functions but no longer divides. Some cells enter G0 and re-enter the cycle when the appropriate cues are received: liver cells divide only after injury, and a lymphocyte divides when it is stimulated by an antigen. Others are held at a particular stage in the cell cycle: for example, a human egg cell is held at one stage of meiosis (unit 5) for years. Highly specialized cells such as mature neurons and most muscle cells in the heart enter G0 and ordinarily never divide again, which is why damage to the brain or heart heals poorly. The cell cycle is therefore regulated: the cell receives signals (the pathways of lessons 4.1 to 4.3) that tell it to go ahead, pause, or stop.

Worked example · Interpreting a cell cycle diagram and population growth

A culture of human cells has a cycle of 24 hours: G1 11 h, S 8 h, G2 4 h, and M 1 h. (a) Calculate the percent of the cycle spent in each phase and in interphase. (b) A culture starts with 1,000 cells and all of them divide on schedule; how many cells are in the culture after 72 hours? (c) If the cells in a sample are in different phases at random, what percent of them would you expect to be in M?

(a) G1: \(11/24 \times 100 = 45.8\%\). S: \(8/24 = 33.3\%\). G2: \(4/24 = 16.7\%\). M: \(1/24 = 4.2\%\). Interphase \(= (11 + 8 + 4)/24 = 23/24 = 95.8\%\).
(b) Number of cycles \(= 72/24 = 3\). The number of cells doubles each cycle: \(1{,}000 \times 2^3 = 8{,}000\) cells.
(c) In a random population, the fraction of cells in a phase equals the fraction of the cycle that the phase takes. About 4.2% would be in M and about 95.8% in interphase. (This is the idea behind the mitotic index in lesson 4.6.)

Exam focus
  • Interphase = G1, S, G2; then mitosis and cytokinesis (M phase). Interphase is the longest part of the cycle; it is not a resting phase.
  • G1: growth, organelle duplication. S: DNA replication (sister chromatids joined at a centromere). G2: proteins, ATP, centrosome replication.
  • DNA content doubles in S (2C to 4C); the number of chromosomes stays the same until anaphase. Mitosis returns each daughter to 2C.
  • G0: not dividing; some cells re-enter, others never do.
  • Prokaryotes divide by binary fission, not by this cycle (it is a eukaryotic cycle).
Practice
  1. Name the phase in which each event occurs: (a) the DNA is copied; (b) centrosomes replicate; (c) the cell grows and duplicates its organelles.
    Show answer

    (a) S phase. (b) G2 phase. (c) G1 phase.

  2. A cell has 8 chromosomes in G1. State the number of chromosomes, the number of chromatids, and the relative DNA content after S phase.
    Show answer

    It still has 8 chromosomes. Each chromosome now consists of two sister chromatids, so there are 16 chromatids, and the DNA content is doubled (from 2C to 4C).

  3. Explain why interphase is not a resting stage.
    Show answer

    During interphase the cell is metabolically active and carries out its normal functions. In G1 it grows and duplicates organelles, in S it replicates all of its DNA, and in G2 it makes the proteins and ATP needed for division and replicates the centrosomes. Many of the events needed for division happen before mitosis starts.

  4. In a sample of 500 cells from a tissue culture, 480 are in interphase. Estimate the percent of the cell cycle spent in M, and the length of M if the cycle takes 20 hours.
    Show answer

    Cells not in interphase \(= 500 - 480 = 20\), which is \(20/500 = 4\%\). If the cells are randomly distributed through the cycle, M is about 4% of the cycle: \(0.04 \times 20 = 0.8\) hours (48 minutes).

  5. Nerve cells in an adult brain do not divide. Describe the state in which these cells are and what it means for repair.
    Show answer

    They have entered G0, in which a cell carries out its functions but no longer divides. Because mature neurons do not normally re-enter the cell cycle, damaged neurons are not replaced by division, so repair of the brain is limited.

  6. A cell is treated with a chemical that blocks DNA replication. Predict the phase in which the cell would stop and the effect on the amount of DNA.
    Show answer

    The cell would stop in or at the end of S phase (it cannot complete S, and the checkpoint before mitosis would not be passed). The DNA content would stay between 2C and 4C instead of reaching 4C, so the cell could not divide and give each daughter a complete set.

Lesson 4.6 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.5 (part 2)

Mitosis and cytokinesis

After interphase, the cell contains two complete copies of its genome. Now they must be separated so that each of two daughter cells gets exactly one, and not a random half. That job is done by mitosis, one of the most precisely organized events in biology: a cell with 46 chromosomes must hand 46 chromosomes to each daughter, with none missing and none extra. Mistakes of this kind are a cause of cancer and of developmental disorders.

Learning objective · 4.5.B

Explain how mitosis results in the transmission of chromosomes from one generation of cells to the next.

Why a cell divides by mitosis

Required content · EK 4.5.B.1 (i and ii)
  • Mitosis is a process that ensures the transfer of a complete genome from a parent cell to two genetically identical daughter cells in eukaryotes.
  • Mitosis plays a role in growth, tissue repair, and asexual reproduction.
  • Mitosis occurs in sequential steps (prophase, metaphase, anaphase, telophase) and alternates with interphase in the cell cycle.

Mitosis produces cells that are genetically identical to the parent cell (apart from rare mutations). This is the way a fertilized egg becomes an organism with trillions of cells, how skin and the lining of the intestine are replaced every few days, how a wound heals, and how many organisms reproduce asexually (a yeast bud, a hydra, a strawberry runner, a plant grown from a cutting). In each case the offspring or new cells are clones. The key to this exactness is that each chromosome was copied in S phase, and mitosis separates the two sister chromatids of each chromosome so that one goes to each daughter.

The four phases

Interphase (G2)DNA copied;chromatin looseProphasechromosomescondenseMetaphasechromosomes alignat the equatorAnaphasesister chromatidspulled to the polesTelophasenuclei re-form;cytoplasm dividesCytokinesis (cleavage furrow or cell plate) then separates the two daughter cells.
Figure 4.5b Mitosis in a cell with four chromosomes (two colors show the two members of each pair). Each chromosome was copied in S phase, so each X is two sister chromatids joined at a centromere. At anaphase the sister chromatids separate, and each daughter cell receives a complete, identical set.
Required content · EK 4.5.B.1 (iii to vi)
  • Prophase: sister chromatids condense, the mitotic spindle begins to form, and centrosomes move to opposite poles of the cell.
  • Metaphase: spindle fibers align chromosomes along the equator of the cell.
  • Anaphase: paired sister chromatids separate as spindle fibers pull chromatids toward the poles.
  • Telophase: the mitotic spindle breaks down, a new nuclear envelope develops, and then the cytoplasm divides.

Prophase. The chromatin coils tightly (condenses) so that each chromosome becomes a compact, visible structure made of two sister chromatids. The nucleolus disappears. The two centrosomes, copied in G2, move toward opposite ends (poles) of the cell, and microtubules grow out from them to form the mitotic spindle. Toward the end of prophase the nuclear envelope breaks down, so the spindle can reach the chromosomes.

Metaphase. Spindle microtubules attach to each chromosome at a structure on the centromere (the kinetochore), one from each pole, and the pulling and pushing line all of the chromosomes up along the metaphase plate, the equator of the cell. This is the best time to count chromosomes, because they are all in one plane and are at their most condensed.

Anaphase. The proteins that hold the sister chromatids together at the centromere are cut, and the sister chromatids separate. Each chromatid is now a chromosome of its own. Spindle fibers shorten and pull the chromosomes to opposite poles, and the cell elongates. This is the shortest phase, and it is the point at which the number of chromosomes doubles (46 to 92 in a human cell) before it is halved again by division.

Telophase. A set of chromosomes has arrived at each pole. The spindle breaks down, a new nuclear envelope forms around each set, the chromosomes uncoil back into chromatin, and the nucleoli reappear. Telophase is essentially prophase in reverse.

Cytokinesis: dividing the cytoplasm

Animal cell: cleavage furrowPlant cell: cell platea ring of protein filamentspinches the cell in twovesicles fuse into a cell platethat grows to the cell wall
Figure 4.5c Cytokinesis divides the cytoplasm. In animal cells a cleavage furrow forms; in plant cells, which have a rigid wall, a cell plate forms and becomes the new wall between the two daughter cells.
Required content · EK 4.5.B.1 (vii)

Cytokinesis: a cleavage furrow forms in animal cells or a cell plate forms in plant cells, resulting in two new daughter cells.

Cytokinesis usually begins during late anaphase or telophase and divides the cytoplasm. In an animal cell, a ring of actin filaments and the motor protein myosin forms just inside the plasma membrane at the equator and contracts, like a drawstring, pulling the membrane inward as a cleavage furrow until the cell is pinched in two. In a plant cell, the rigid wall prevents pinching. Instead, vesicles from the Golgi apparatus carrying cell wall material move to the middle of the cell and fuse to form a cell plate, which grows outward until it joins the existing wall; it becomes the new wall between the two daughter cells. Mitosis is division of the nucleus, and cytokinesis is division of the cytoplasm; they are separate events, and a cell can undergo mitosis without cytokinesis.

Worked example · Onion root tip data: how long does each phase last?

An onion root tip has actively dividing cells. A student counts 200 cells in a micrograph and finds: interphase 168, prophase 16, metaphase 6, anaphase 4, telophase 6. The cell cycle of onion root tip cells at room temperature takes about 18 hours (1,080 minutes). Calculate the percent of cells in each phase, the mitotic index, and the time spent in each phase, and say which phase is the shortest.

PhaseCells countedPercent of cellsTime (minutes)
Interphase16884.0%907.2
Prophase168.0%86.4
Metaphase63.0%32.4
Anaphase42.0%21.6
Telophase63.0%32.4

Percent. \(168/200 = 84.0\%\), \(16/200 = 8.0\%\), \(6/200 = 3.0\%\), \(4/200 = 2.0\%\), \(6/200 = 3.0\%\).
Mitotic index. The fraction of cells in mitosis \(= (16 + 6 + 4 + 6)/200 = 32/200 = 16\%\).
Time. The time in a phase is the fraction of cells in that phase times the length of the cycle: for interphase \(0.84 \times 1{,}080 = 907.2\) min; prophase \(0.08 \times 1{,}080 = 86.4\) min; metaphase and telophase \(0.03 \times 1{,}080 = 32.4\) min each; anaphase \(0.02 \times 1{,}080 = 21.6\) min. The total is 1,080 min.
Conclusion. Anaphase is the shortest phase (about 22 minutes), and the cells spend most of the cycle (84%) in interphase. The reasoning assumes that the cells are not synchronized, so each phase is represented in proportion to its duration.

Comparing mitosis in animal and plant cells

The sequence is the same, and the differences are in the details. Animal cells have centrosomes that organize the spindle (and pairs of centrioles); plant cells form a spindle without centrioles. Cytokinesis uses a cleavage furrow in animal cells and a cell plate in plant cells. Prokaryotes do not undergo mitosis: they divide by binary fission, which has no spindle and no condensed chromosomes.

Exam focus
  • PMAT: prophase (condense, spindle forms), metaphase (align at the equator), anaphase (sister chromatids separate), telophase (new nuclei, spindle breaks down). Mitosis is followed by cytokinesis.
  • Mitosis produces two genetically identical diploid daughter cells and is used for growth, tissue repair, and asexual reproduction.
  • Chromosome number does not change in mitosis; it doubles only briefly in anaphase. DNA is 4C before division and 2C in each daughter.
  • Cleavage furrow (animal) versus cell plate (plant).
  • For data questions, percent of cells in a phase = percent of the cycle time: time \(=\) fraction of cells \(\times\) length of cycle.
Practice
  1. Identify the phase of mitosis: (a) chromosomes lined up at the equator; (b) sister chromatids moving to opposite poles; (c) the nuclear envelope re-forming.
    Show answer

    (a) Metaphase. (b) Anaphase. (c) Telophase.

  2. A human skin cell (46 chromosomes) undergoes mitosis. State the number of chromosomes in each daughter cell, and in the cell during anaphase.
    Show answer

    Each daughter cell has 46 chromosomes. During anaphase, after the sister chromatids separate, the cell temporarily has 92 chromosomes (46 moving to each pole).

  3. Explain why mitosis produces genetically identical daughter cells.
    Show answer

    Each chromosome is copied exactly in S phase, producing two identical sister chromatids. In anaphase, the sister chromatids separate, so each daughter receives one copy of every chromosome. Each daughter therefore has a complete genome identical to that of the parent cell.

  4. In a count of 250 root tip cells, 15 are in prophase, 5 in metaphase, 3 in anaphase, and 7 in telophase. Calculate the mitotic index and the minutes in prophase if the cycle is 16 hours.
    Show answer

    Mitotic index \(= (15 + 5 + 3 + 7)/250 = 30/250 = 12\%\). Prophase fraction \(= 15/250 = 0.06\); the cycle is \(16 \times 60 = 960\) min, so prophase lasts \(0.06 \times 960 = 57.6\) min.

  5. Compare cytokinesis in a plant cell and an animal cell, and explain the reason for the difference.
    Show answer

    An animal cell forms a cleavage furrow, in which a ring of protein filaments contracts and pinches the cell in two. A plant cell forms a cell plate, in which vesicles fuse in the middle of the cell and build a new cell wall outward until the cell is divided. The plant cell has a rigid cell wall, which does not allow a pinching of the cell, so a new wall must be built across it.

  6. A drug prevents the formation of the mitotic spindle. Predict the phase in which the dividing cells would stop, and explain.
    Show answer

    The cells would stop before anaphase, typically near metaphase (or prophase), because without a spindle, the chromosomes cannot be aligned at the equator or pulled apart. The sister chromatids would not separate, so mitosis cannot be completed and the cell cannot divide. (Some cancer drugs act in this way.)

Lesson 4.7 · Unit 4 · CED topic 4.6

Regulation of the cell cycle

Your skin cells divide every few weeks, your neurons almost never do, and a liver cell can wait years and then divide in days when part of the liver is removed. Division at the wrong time or in the wrong place is dangerous: a cell that divides with damaged DNA passes its damage to all its descendants, and a cell that divides without any signal can become a tumor. The cell cycle is therefore controlled by an internal system of checks, and cancer is what happens when the system fails.

Learning objectives · 4.6.A and 4.6.B

Describe the role of checkpoints in regulating the cell cycle, and describe the effects of disruptions to the cell cycle on the cell or organism.

Checkpoints

G1SG2M123G0: cell leaves the cycle1 G1 checkpointIs the cell large enough?Are nutrients and growthsignals present? Is the DNAundamaged? If not: stop,repair, or enter G0.2 G2 checkpointHas all of the DNA beencopied? Is it undamaged?If not, the cycle pausesuntil the problem is fixed.3 Spindle checkpointAt metaphase: is everychromosome attached tospindle fibers? Only thendoes anaphase begin.
Figure 4.6a Internal controls, or checkpoints, regulate progression through the cell cycle. If a condition is not met, the cycle stops until it is fixed; if the problem cannot be fixed, the cell may be sent to apoptosis.
Required content · EK 4.6.A.1

A number of internal controls or checkpoints regulate progression through the cell cycle.

A checkpoint is a point in the cycle at which the cell stops and “checks” that the conditions are right before it goes on. If they are not, the cycle is paused to allow repair. Three are usually described (the specific checkpoints are not listed in the CED, but you should know the idea).

  • G1 checkpoint (at the end of G1). It checks that the cell is large enough, that nutrients and growth signals (lesson 4.2) are present, and that the DNA is undamaged. This is the main decision point: a cell that does not pass may stop and repair, or may enter G0. A cell that passes is generally committed to completing the cycle.
  • G2 checkpoint (at the end of G2). It checks that the DNA was completely and accurately replicated and is not damaged, before the cell enters mitosis.
  • Spindle (M) checkpoint (in metaphase). It checks that every chromosome is attached to spindle fibers from both poles. Anaphase does not begin until all of them are attached, which prevents a daughter cell from getting too many or too few chromosomes.

Cyclins and CDKs

02550751000612182430364248Time (hours)Relative amountMMCDK (steady)cyclinrises, peaks, thenis broken down
Figure 4.6b Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) are present at a steady level but are active only when bound to a cyclin. Cyclin levels rise and fall through the cycle, so CDK activity rises and falls too (illustrative values).
Required content · EK 4.6.A.2

Interactions between cyclins and cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) control the cell cycle.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of specific cyclin-CDK pairs or growth factors is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

The checkpoints are enforced by two kinds of proteins that work together. A cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) is a kinase (an enzyme that adds phosphate groups to other proteins, lesson 4.2) that is present at a fairly constant level throughout the cell cycle, but is inactive on its own. A cyclin is a protein whose amount rises and falls during the cycle. When a cyclin binds to a CDK, the CDK becomes active, and it phosphorylates target proteins that switch on the events of the next phase (such as DNA replication or the entry into mitosis). Because the active complex needs the cyclin, the cyclin level controls when the CDK is active, and the cyclin is broken down at the end of the phase, which turns the CDK off and lets the cell move on. This is a phosphorylation cascade (lesson 4.2) applied to the cell cycle, and the name of the cyclin comes from this cycling of its concentration. Different cyclins are made at different times of the cycle, so there is a different active complex for each stage. Signals from outside the cell (growth factors, lesson 4.2) and damage signals from inside can act on this system, which is how checkpoints stop the cycle: for example, damaged DNA triggers a pathway that blocks the CDK.

When regulation fails: cancer and apoptosis

Required content · EK 4.6.B.1

Disruptions to the cell cycle may result in cancer or apoptosis (programmed cell death).

Cancer is uncontrolled cell division. It happens when a cell ignores its checkpoints and the signals that tell it to stop, usually because of mutations in genes that code for the proteins of these pathways (lesson 4.3). A mutation can lock a growth-signal pathway in the “on” position, so that the cell divides without a signal, or it can disable the protein that detects DNA damage, so that damaged cells are not stopped. One well-known example is p53, a protein that is activated by DNA damage; it halts the cycle at the G1 checkpoint so that the damage can be repaired, or triggers apoptosis if it cannot. Cells with no working p53 keep dividing with damaged DNA, and the gene is mutated in about half of all human cancers. (Genes whose normal products promote division are called proto-oncogenes, and genes whose normal products stop the cycle or repair DNA are tumor suppressors; you do not need these terms for the exam, but they explain why more than one mutation is usually needed.) A cell that has lost its controls divides over and over, forming a mass of cells called a tumor. If the cells also invade other tissues and spread through the blood or lymph (metastasis), the tumor is malignant. The mutations accumulate over time, which is one reason that cancer is more common with age.

Apoptosis is the other possible outcome. If the damage is too severe to repair, the checkpoint pathway can send the cell into programmed cell death: the cell shrinks, dismantles its DNA and organelles in an orderly way, and is eaten by neighboring cells without causing inflammation. Apoptosis removes cells that could become cancerous, so it is part of the defense against cancer, and it is also used normally in development (the tissue between the digits of a fetus) and by the immune system. A cell that cannot undergo apoptosis, because the protein that triggers it is defective, can continue to divide with damaged DNA, which also contributes to cancer.

Worked example · A drug that stops cell division (DNA content data)

Researchers treat a culture of 10,000 cells for 24 hours with a drug, and then measure the DNA content of each cell. Cells with 2C DNA are in G1 (or G0), cells with 4C are in G2 or M, and cells with an amount between 2C and 4C are in S. Results: control, 50% 2C, 30% in S, 20% 4C. Drug-treated: 15% 2C, 20% in S, 65% 4C. Describe the effect of the drug, calculate the number of cells in each category, and propose where in the cell cycle the cells are held.

Numbers. Control: \(0.50 \times 10{,}000 = 5{,}000\) cells at 2C; \(3{,}000\) in S; \(2{,}000\) at 4C. Drug: \(1{,}500\) at 2C; \(2{,}000\) in S; \(6{,}500\) at 4C.
Change. The number of cells with 4C DNA rose from 2,000 to 6,500, a \(6{,}500/2{,}000 = 3.25\) times increase, while the number with 2C DNA fell from 5,000 to 1,500, a decrease of \((5{,}000 - 1{,}500)/5{,}000 = 70\%\).
Interpretation. The cells have replicated their DNA (they are at 4C), but they are not completing division, because they are not returning to 2C. The most likely explanation is that the drug holds the cells at the G2 checkpoint or in mitosis, for example by blocking the spindle (the spindle checkpoint keeps cells with unattached chromosomes from reaching anaphase). Cells that stay arrested may eventually undergo apoptosis, which is why drugs of this kind are used to treat cancers.
Limits. DNA content alone cannot separate G2 from M. To tell them apart, the researchers could count the cells with visible condensed chromosomes under the microscope.

Exam focus
  • Checkpoints (G1, G2, spindle) stop the cycle until conditions are right: size, nutrients, signals, DNA replication and damage, chromosome attachment.
  • Cyclins (levels rise and fall) bind CDKs (steady level, kinases that need a cyclin) to drive the cycle. Do not memorize specific pairs.
  • Cancer = loss of control of division, usually from mutations in pathway components or checkpoint proteins. Apoptosis = programmed cell death, which removes damaged cells.
  • For a mutation or drug question, predict whether the cell passes or fails the checkpoint, and what happens to the damaged cell (repair, arrest, apoptosis, or uncontrolled division).
  • On a DNA content graph or table: 2C is G1, 4C is G2 or M, in between is S.
Practice
  1. Explain the purpose of the G1 checkpoint and what could happen to a cell that does not pass it.
    Show answer

    The G1 checkpoint checks that the cell is large enough, that nutrients and growth signals are present, and that the DNA is undamaged, before the cell commits to replicating its DNA. A cell that does not pass may pause to repair the problem, enter G0 (a nondividing state), or, if the damage cannot be repaired, undergo apoptosis.

  2. Describe how a cyclin and a CDK work together, and why the level of the CDK does not control the cycle by itself.
    Show answer

    A CDK is a kinase that is inactive unless it is bound to a cyclin. The cyclin-CDK complex phosphorylates target proteins that start the events of the next phase. The CDK is present at a fairly steady level, so the activity of the complex depends on the level of the cyclin, which rises and falls through the cycle.

  3. In the cyclin graph, estimate the time in a 24-hour cycle at which cyclin is at its peak, and predict what happens to CDK activity when the cyclin level falls sharply.
    Show answer

    The peak is at the end of the cycle, at about 23 hours (the M phase). When the cyclin level falls sharply, most CDK is no longer bound to cyclin, so the CDK activity falls, and the cell exits mitosis and can begin the next cycle.

  4. A cell has a mutation that prevents it from detecting unattached chromosomes. Predict the effect on its daughter cells, and justify.
    Show answer

    Without a working spindle checkpoint, the cell enters anaphase before all of the chromosomes are attached to the spindle, so some chromosomes may not be separated correctly. The daughter cells could receive too many or too few chromosomes (an abnormal chromosome number), which can lead to cell death or to cancer.

  5. Explain how mutations in the proteins of a signaling pathway for a growth factor could lead to cancer.
    Show answer

    A mutation that locks a receptor or a kinase in the active state (lesson 4.3) causes the pathway to send a “divide” signal even without the growth factor. The cell passes the G1 checkpoint and divides repeatedly without a signal, which is uncontrolled division. Several mutations like this, together with loss of the checkpoint or apoptosis controls, can produce a tumor.

  6. Compare the outcomes of apoptosis and cancer for a cell with damaged DNA, and explain why apoptosis is beneficial to the organism.
    Show answer

    In apoptosis the damaged cell is destroyed in a controlled way, so its damaged DNA is not passed on. In cancer the damaged cell keeps dividing, and the damage is inherited by all of its descendants. Apoptosis benefits the organism by removing cells that could become tumors, and by removing cells that are no longer needed.

Unit 4 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 4 quiz: Cell Communication and Cell Cycle

Fifteen multiple-choice questions and five short free-response questions across all seven lessons: signal types and receptors, the three stages of transduction, pathways broken by mutation or toxin, feedback and homeostasis, and the cell cycle with its checkpoints. Click an option to see why each choice is right or wrong, then time yourself on each free response before opening the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Data: luminescence of Vibrio fischeri cultures grown in seawater medium and assayed at five cell densities.

    Cell density (cells/mL)2×1052×1068×1062×1078×107
    Light output (relative units)0.22.08.060800
    Light output per 106 cells1.01.01.03.010.0

    Which conclusion about the threshold for light production is best supported by the data?

    Light at the lowest density is 0.2 units: exactly what 0.2 million cells glowing at the baseline rate of 1.0 per 106 would give. A faint glow proportional to cell number is what an unregulated population looks like, so this density shows no switching on at all.

    Total output does rise across the whole range, but not proportionally. From 8×106 to 8×107 the density rises tenfold while light rises \(800/8.0 = 100\)-fold. A proportional relationship would hold the per-cell row constant, and it does not.

    Correct. Dividing light by density removes the effect of simply adding more cells. The per-cell row is 1.0, 1.0, 1.0, then 3.0 and 10.0, so somewhere between 8×106 and 2×107 cells/mL each cell begins producing more light: the autoinducer has reached a concentration that switches the luminescence genes on.

    8×107 is where output is highest, not where it changes character. A threshold is the point at which the behavior of the system changes, and the per-cell row shows that change happening an order of magnitude earlier.

  2. Epinephrine released into the bloodstream circulates past every cell in the body, yet only some cells respond. Which statement best accounts for this?

    Correct. Specificity comes from the complementary fit between ligand and receptor, exactly as it does between substrate and enzyme. One ligand can even produce different responses in different cell types, because what lies downstream of the receptor differs from tissue to tissue.

    Endocrine signals are built to travel: that is the point of releasing them into the blood. Epinephrine reaches the heart in about 20 seconds and acts on tissues throughout the body, so distance from the gland is not what sorts responders from non-responders.

    Epinephrine is hydrophilic and does not cross the bilayer in any cell; its receptor is a membrane protein. The signals that diffuse through membranes are small hydrophobic ones such as steroid and thyroid hormones, and cholesterol buffers fluidity rather than gating entry.

    Target cells do not make the hormone: the adrenal glands do. Responding to a signal requires a receptor, not the gene for the signal, and confusing the sending cell with the receiving cell is the misconception being tested here.

  3. Testosterone's receptor is inside the cell, while insulin's receptor spans the plasma membrane. Which property of the two signals best explains the difference?

    Concentration determines how much receptor is occupied, not where the receptor can usefully sit. A hydrophilic hormone at any concentration still cannot cross the hydrophobic interior of the bilayer, which is what sets receptor location.

    Correct. The bilayer's interior is a hydrophobic barrier: small nonpolar molecules pass freely, large polar ones do not. Testosterone diffuses in and binds an intracellular receptor that acts as a transcription factor; insulin must be detected at the surface and have its message relayed inward by a phosphorylation cascade.

    The two categories are swapped: insulin is a protein hormone and testosterone is the steroid. The reasoning in the second half is right, which is what makes this a tempting choice: check the chemical class before you apply the rule.

    The speeds are reversed. Steroid responses require transcription and translation and take hours; membrane-receptor cascades change enzyme activity within seconds. Slow and long-lasting is the trade-off steroid signaling makes for changing gene expression.

  4. Which feature of a phosphorylation cascade allows a signal both to be amplified and to be switched off quickly once the ligand is gone?

    A one-to-one relay would transmit the signal without amplifying it, and destroying the chain after each use would make the response impossible to repeat. Cascades are built from reusable enzymes precisely so the cell can respond again a minute later.

    Correct. The multiplication at each step is the amplification, and the phosphatases are the off switch: they are always working, so as soon as new phosphorylation stops the existing phosphates are stripped and the relay proteins return to their inactive shapes.

    cAMP is a nucleotide derived from ATP, not a protein, so proteases have no effect on it. It is degraded to AMP by phosphodiesterase, which is a real off switch, but the question asks about the kinase cascade itself.

    Receptor internalization does end new signaling at the top of the pathway, but it does nothing to proteins already phosphorylated further down. Reversing those requires an enzyme that removes phosphate groups, which is what a phosphatase does.

  5. Data: glycogen phosphorylase activity (relative units) measured after liver cells were broken open and separated into a membrane fraction and a soluble fraction containing the enzyme.

    TreatmentActivity
    Intact cells + epinephrine100
    Soluble fraction alone4
    Soluble fraction + epinephrine5
    Membrane fraction + epinephrine; boiled supernatant then added to soluble fraction96
    Membrane fraction, no epinephrine; boiled supernatant then added to soluble fraction6

    Which conclusion is best supported by these results?

    Four units becomes five: a change far smaller than the 96 obtained through the membrane route, and within the noise of the assay. If the hormone acted on the enzyme directly, hormone plus enzyme alone should have given close to the intact-cell value of 100.

    Correct. Activity appears only in the treatment where membranes met the hormone first and the supernatant was then transferred; membranes without hormone gave 6. That is the logic that identified cyclic AMP: the hormone never enters the cell, and something small and diffusible carries the message inward.

    The enzyme was in the soluble fraction, which is where the assay was performed in every row. What was transferred from the membrane treatment was the small molecule in the supernatant, and it produced activity only because the soluble fraction supplying the enzyme was already there.

    Boiling denatures proteins, so surviving it argues that the messenger is not a protein: it is a small, heat-stable molecule. Reading the evidence backwards is exactly the trap; ask what the treatment would have destroyed.

  6. Data: glucose release (µmol/min per 106 cells) from four liver-cell lines, each assayed untreated, with the hormone, with forskolin (which activates adenylyl cyclase directly), and with a membrane-permeable cAMP analog.

    TreatmentWild typeLine ALine BLine C
    None2.02.11.92.0
    + hormone40.02.42.22.3
    + forskolin39.038.52.52.4
    + cAMP analog38.038.037.52.6

    In which line is the defect best placed at adenylyl cyclase, and on what evidence?

    Line A does fail with the hormone, but it responds fully to forskolin (\(38.5/2.1 = 18\)-fold), which acts directly on adenylyl cyclase. A working cyclase places the break above it, at the receptor or the G protein.

    Line C fails with everything including the cAMP analog (\(2.6/2.0 = 1.3\)-fold), so the break is at or below protein kinase A. The cAMP analog enters the pathway below the cyclase, so a cell that cannot respond to it has a defect further downstream still.

    Correct. Line B gives \(2.5/1.9 = 1.3\)-fold with forskolin but \(37.5/1.9 = 19.7\)-fold with the analog. Forskolin needs a functional cyclase to make cAMP; the analog is cAMP and skips the cyclase entirely. The one component that separates the two treatments is adenylyl cyclase.

    Forty versus thirty-nine is assay-to-assay variation, not a defect; the wild type is the reference every line is compared against, and it responds about twentyfold to all three activating treatments.

  7. Cholera toxin modifies the α subunit of a Gs protein so that it can no longer hydrolyze its bound GTP. Which description of the effect is correct?

    The toxin blocks GTP hydrolysis, not GTP binding: the difference between failing to switch on and failing to switch off. Because the G protein's own GTPase activity is its timer, removing it leaves the protein permanently on.

    An agonist binds the receptor's ligand site and triggers the normal, reversible response. Cholera toxin acts one step below the receptor, on the G protein itself, which is why deleting the receptor would not protect the cell from it.

    The clinical effect runs the other way: cAMP rises sharply, chloride channels open, water follows the salt into the gut, and the result is severe diarrhea. A pathway locked on produces too much signal, not too little.

    Correct. A component stuck in its active state produces the response constitutively, no ligand required. That is the definition of a gain-of-function change, and it is why cholera's effects continue long after any hormone would have been cleared.

  8. A patient taking a β-adrenergic antagonist shows a smaller rise in heart rate during exercise than an untreated person. Which additional result would best confirm that the drug acts at the receptor rather than further down the pathway?

    Correct. This is the bypass logic the exam rewards: the analog enters the pathway below the receptor, the G protein, and the cyclase. A full response to it shows everything from cAMP downward is intact, so the block must lie above, at the receptor the drug occupies.

    Normal epinephrine only shows that the signal is being released; it says nothing about where the receiving cell fails. Both a receptor block and a downstream block would leave circulating hormone untouched.

    Resting heart rate is set largely by parasympathetic input and pacemaker activity, so a normal resting value is compatible with a block at any step of the β-adrenergic pathway. It does not localize anything.

    Failing both would place the break at or below cAMP: the opposite of the conclusion being tested. That pattern would argue the drug acts on protein kinase A or downstream, not on the receptor.

  9. Data: blood glucose (mg/dL) measured hourly after the same standard meal in two adults.

    Time after meal (h)01234
    Person X (mg/dL)851351008885
    Person Y (mg/dL)118215195178165

    Between hour 1 and hour 3, at what average rate does Person Y's blood glucose fall, and what does the comparison with Person X indicate?

    Correct. \((178 - 215)/(3 - 1) = -18.5\) mg/dL per hour for Y and \((88 - 135)/(3 - 1) = -23.5\) for X. Y also starts higher and peaks higher, and at hour 4 has corrected only \((97 - 47)/97 = 51.5\%\) of its excursion against X's 100%: the loop runs but its gain is low, which is what insulin resistance looks like.

    These are the total drops over the two-hour interval, not rates: \(215 - 178 = 37\) and \(135 - 88 = 47\). A rate requires dividing by the elapsed time, and note that the larger number here belongs to X, so even the comparison is stated backwards.

    \((165 - 215)/3 = -16.7\) mg/dL per hour is the slope from hour 1 to hour 4, a different interval from the one the question names. There is also no standard that privileges the four-hour slope; you must read which interval is asked for.

    The rates are genuinely different, 18.5 against 23.5, and a higher baseline does not make a slower correction equivalent. Measured against each person's own excursion the gap widens rather than closes, because Y rose 97 mg/dL and X only 50.

  10. Which of the following is controlled by positive feedback, and what distinguishes it from the others?

    Shivering is negative feedback: the muscle activity generates heat, which raises body temperature back toward the set point and therefore removes the stimulus that started it. The description of the effect here is reversed.

    Correct. The output of the loop, stronger contractions, increases the very stimulus that produced it, so the process accelerates instead of settling at a value. Positive loops have no stable point to sit at, which is why they are reserved for fast, committed, one-way transitions ended by an outside event.

    ADH inserts aquaporins into the collecting duct so more water is reabsorbed into the blood, which dilutes it and lowers osmolarity toward the set point. That is negative feedback, and the choice states the direction backwards.

    Insulin is negative feedback: glucose uptake and glycogen storage lower blood glucose, which removes the stimulus for further insulin release. The loop stops at the set point near 90 mg/dL, not at exhaustion: running glucose to zero would be lethal.

  11. Data: a partly completed table for a somatic cell of an organism with 2n = 16 dividing by mitosis. One cell of the table has been left blank.

    StageG1G2MetaphaseAnaphaseEach daughter cell
    Chromosomes161616?16
    DNA molecules (chromatids)1632323216

    What value belongs in the cell marked ?, and why?

    The chromosome number does not double in S phase: that is the single most common error on this topic, and the table itself shows it: the count stays 16 from G1 through metaphase while DNA molecules go from 16 to 32, because the two chromatids share one centromere.

    Correct. Count centromeres for chromosomes and chromatids for DNA. When cohesin is cleaved in anaphase, each chromatid gains its own centromere and therefore counts as a chromosome, so 16 becomes 32 with no new DNA synthesized at all. Cytokinesis then returns each daughter to 16.

    Homologous chromosomes are separated in meiosis I, not in mitosis. Mitotic anaphase separates sister chromatids, and the halving to 16 per cell happens at cytokinesis when the cytoplasm divides, not by any event that reduces the count below the parental number.

    No DNA is replicated during anaphase; the DNA-molecule row correctly stays at 32 throughout M phase. Doubling both rows counts the same chromatids twice, once as DNA and once again as new chromosomes.

  12. Which statement correctly compares cytokinesis in a plant cell with cytokinesis in an animal cell and explains the difference?

    The two mechanisms are swapped. Animal cells form the furrow; plant cells form the plate. Membrane flexibility is not the constraint either: the cellulose wall outside the plant membrane is what cannot be squeezed inward.

    Binary fission is prokaryotic: one circular chromosome, one origin, no spindle and no mitosis. Plant cells are eukaryotic and divide by mitosis followed by cell-plate formation; having a wall does not make a cell prokaryotic.

    Correct. The animal cell is pinched from the outside in by a contractile ring just inside the plasma membrane; the plant cell is divided from the inside out by Golgi vesicles that line up at the midline and fuse into a plate that joins the existing wall. The wall is the reason the new boundary must be built in place.

    A plant cell forms no furrow at all. The vesicles that carry wall material fuse into a disc that grows outward from the center: the opposite geometry from a furrow, which closes inward from the perimeter.

  13. Figure: two traces on one set of axes for an early frog embryo; relative amount from 0 to 100 on the y-axis, time in minutes from 0 to 80 on the x-axis.

    The cyclin B trace rises in a straight line from 5 at 0 min to 95 at 36 min, then falls to 5 within about 5 minutes, and repeats the same pattern through a second cycle. The MPF activity trace is flat near 4 until 26 min, rises steeply to 94 by 32 min, holds through metaphase, and drops below 5 by 38 min.

    Which pair of rise rates is correct, and what does the comparison show about how MPF is controlled?

    The rates are right, \((95-5)/36 = 2.5\) and \((94-4)/(32-26) = 15.0\), but the interpretation is not. MPF is not a molecule being synthesized; it is cyclin B bound to CDK1, and the trace shows its activity. CDK1 concentration is constant.

    2.8 comes from \((94-4)/32\), dividing by the time since 0 min rather than by the 6 minutes over which MPF actually rose. The trace is flat until 26 min, so those first 26 minutes are not part of the rise and must not be in the denominator.

    Correct. \((95-5)/36 = 2.5\) and \((94-4)/6 = 15.0\), a ratio of 6. Because activity climbs six times more steeply than the cyclin driving it, MPF cannot be a proportional readout: cyclin must accumulate past a threshold before enough CDK1 is bound, and then activation is nearly all-or-none.

    These are peak heights, not rates: a rate needs a change divided by an elapsed time. Matching maxima say nothing about control, and the interesting feature of the figure is precisely that the two traces have different shapes.

  14. A tumor cell line carries two nonfunctional copies of the gene for p53. Which consequence follows most directly?

    p53 has no role in spindle assembly; the M checkpoint monitors kinetochore attachment and works independently of it. A p53-null cell builds a normal spindle, which is part of why the damage it carries is passed on so efficiently.

    Cyclin B degradation is triggered by the anaphase-promoting complex that MPF itself switches on, and it is what allows exit from mitosis. p53 acts much earlier, before S phase, and losing it does not trap cells in metaphase.

    Entering G0 is what a cell does when it fails the G1 checkpoint, so losing p53 makes cells less likely to stop, not more. Cancer cells are characteristically able to divide without the growth-factor signals normal cells require.

    Correct. DNA damage normally activates p53, which induces the CDK inhibitor p21 and halts the cycle in G1 for repair or directs the cell to apoptosis. Without it a damaged cell proceeds into S phase, the damage becomes a fixed mutation, and every descendant inherits it.

  15. Data: distribution of cells by stage in a human cell culture 6 hours after adding a drug that prevents microtubules from attaching to kinetochores, compared with an untreated culture. Values are percentages of 1,000 cells scored.

    StageUntreated (%)Drug-treated (%)
    Interphase8834
    Prophase68
    Metaphase356
    Anaphase11
    Telophase21

    Which explanation best accounts for the distribution in the treated culture?

    Correct. Metaphase rises from 3% to 56% while anaphase and telophase stay at 1%, so cells are entering mitosis and stopping at exactly the transition the checkpoint guards. A single unattached kinetochore is enough to keep the wait signal on, which is why the cells sit at metaphase rather than proceeding with a chromosome missing.

    A block before S phase would raise the interphase percentage, and here it fell from 88% to 34%. The data show cells leaving interphase normally and being stopped later, which rules out an arrest at G1.

    Prophase barely changed, 6% to 8%, and shortening a stage cannot by itself produce an eighteenfold accumulation in the next one. Cells pile up where they are held, not where they pass through quickly.

    Indestructible cyclin B does arrest cells in M phase, so the pattern is superficially similar, but the drug described acts on microtubule attachment, and the checkpoint it trips is what stops anaphase here. Match the mechanism to the stated action of the treatment, not just to the shape of the data.

Free response

  1. Data: luminescence of Vibrio fischeri cultures held at a constant density of 5×106 cells/mL. Each culture received a different concentration of synthetic autoinducer; light output was measured after 60 minutes.

    [Autoinducer] (nM)0152050100
    Light output (relative units)0.50.61.222180240

    An investigator tested whether the autoinducer alone, rather than crowding, switches on luminescence. Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent and dependent variables, and describe the purpose of the 0 nM treatment.
    2. Explain the relationship between autoinducer concentration and light output shown by the data.
    3. Construct a graph of these data: place autoinducer concentration on the x-axis scaled from 0 to 100 nM and light output on the y-axis scaled from 0 to 250 relative units, label both axes with units, plot the six points, and connect them.
    4. Justify the claim that light output is controlled by autoinducer concentration rather than by cell density, using a feature of the investigation's design.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: independent variable is autoinducer concentration in nM; dependent variable is light output in relative units. The 0 nM culture is the control: it establishes the baseline light produced by cells at this density with no autoinducer added (0.5 units), the value every treatment is compared against. Do not accept: the two variables reversed; "0 nM is the control" with no statement of what it establishes; naming cell density as the independent variable.
    • (b) Accept: output is essentially flat from 0 to 5 nM (0.5 to 1.2 units), rises steeply between 5 and 50 nM, and begins to level off by 100 nM: a threshold relationship rather than a proportional one, in which the luminescence genes stay off below a critical autoinducer concentration and switch on above it. Do not accept: "as autoinducer rises, light rises," which misses the threshold that is the feature of these data; an answer that cites no values from the table.
    • (c) Accept: x-axis = autoinducer concentration in nM from 0 to 100, evenly scaled; y-axis = light output in relative units from 0 to 250; both axes labeled with units; the six points (0, 0.5), (1, 0.6), (5, 1.2), (20, 22), (50, 180), (100, 240) plotted and connected. Do not accept: axes reversed; units omitted from the axis labels; a bar graph of unlabeled categories.
    • (d) Accept: cell density was held constant at 5×106 cells/mL in every culture, making it a controlled variable that cannot account for the roughly 480-fold difference in output; the only variable that differed across the tubes was autoinducer concentration. Do not accept: repeating the trend described in (b); "the autoinducer caused it" with no reference to the constant density.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is the concentration of synthetic autoinducer in nM, and the dependent variable is light output in relative units. The 0 nM culture is the control: it shows how much light these cells make at this density with no autoinducer added; 0.5 units, so I have a baseline to compare every other tube against.

    b The relationship is a threshold, not a straight line. From 0 to 5 nM the light barely moves, 0.5 up to 1.2 units. Between 5 and 50 nM it jumps from 1.2 to 180, and by 100 nM it is 240 and flattening. Below a critical autoinducer concentration the luminescence genes stay off, and once the cells sense enough they switch on almost at once.

    c I would put autoinducer concentration on the x-axis from 0 to 100 nM and light output on the y-axis from 0 to 250 relative units, label both with those units, plot (0, 0.5), (1, 0.6), (5, 1.2), (20, 22), (50, 180) and (100, 240), and connect them into an S-shaped curve.

    d Every culture was held at 5×106 cells/mL, so density was a controlled variable rather than something that changed with the light. Since tubes with identical density differed about 480-fold in output, crowding cannot be what turned the genes on: autoinducer concentration is the only thing that varied.

  2. Blood glucose in a healthy adult is held near a set point of about 90 mg/dL. Answer (a) through (d).

    1. Describe the difference between negative feedback and positive feedback in terms of the effect the response has on the original stimulus.
    2. Explain how insulin and glucagon together return blood glucose to the set point both after it rises and after it falls.
    3. Predict what happens to the height of the glucose peak and to the time required to return to the set point in a person whose β cells release normal amounts of insulin but whose liver and muscle cells carry only about 30% of the normal number of insulin receptors.
    4. Justify your prediction in (c) by identifying which component of the feedback loop is impaired and stating what that does to the loop.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: in negative feedback the response opposes the stimulus and drives the variable back toward the set point; in positive feedback the response reinforces the stimulus, so the variable moves further from its starting value until an event outside the loop ends the process. Do not accept: "negative is harmful and positive is helpful"; "negative decreases and positive increases" with no reference to the stimulus.
    • (b) Accept: rising glucose is detected by pancreatic β cells, which release insulin; insulin causes liver and muscle cells to take glucose up and store it as glycogen, so glucose falls and the stimulus for insulin is removed. Falling glucose triggers α cells to release glucagon, which drives glycogen breakdown and glucose release from the liver, so glucose rises. Do not accept: naming the two hormones with no effector action; reversing insulin and glucagon.
    • (c) Accept: the peak is higher than normal and the return to the set point takes longer. Both directional claims are required. Do not accept: "blood glucose is affected"; only one of the two claims; a prediction of no change.
    • (d) Accept: the impaired component is the effector arm, the target cells' response to insulin. The sensor and the signal are intact and insulin is released normally, but with about 30% of the receptors the same insulin concentration produces far less glucose uptake, so the loop's gain is low and the correction is slow and incomplete. Do not accept: "there is not enough insulin," which contradicts the stem; naming the receptor with no statement of the consequence for the loop.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a In negative feedback the response pushes back against whatever started it, so the variable heads back toward the set point. In positive feedback the response makes the original stimulus stronger, so the system runs further and further from where it started until something outside the loop stops it.

    b When glucose rises after a meal, β cells in the pancreas detect it and release insulin. Insulin makes liver and muscle cells pull glucose out of the blood and store it as glycogen, which brings the level down, and lowering glucose removes the signal for more insulin. When glucose drops too low, α cells release glucagon instead, the liver breaks glycogen back down and releases glucose, and the level climbs back toward 90 mg/dL.

    c The peak will be higher than a normal person's, and it will take longer than normal to get back down to about 90 mg/dL.

    d The sensor and the hormone are fine: this person releases normal insulin, so the problem is not detection or signaling. What is impaired is the effector arm: the target cells have only about 30% of the usual receptors, so the same amount of insulin triggers far less glucose uptake. A loop with a weak effector still runs, but with low gain, and low gain is exactly what a high peak and a slow correction look like.

  3. Model: a signal-transduction pathway drawn as a vertical sequence of labeled boxes and arrows for a liver cell responding to epinephrine.

    At the top, epinephrine outside the cell binds a β-adrenergic receptor spanning the plasma membrane. An arrow leads to a Gs protein on the inner face of the membrane, labeled "1 activated receptor → 50 active G proteins." Each active G protein switches on one adenylyl cyclase, labeled "each cyclase → 300 cAMP." An arrow from cAMP leads to protein kinase A, labeled "4 cAMP bind to activate 1 PKA." From PKA an arrow leads to phosphorylase kinase, labeled "each PKA phosphorylates 120 phosphorylase kinase." A final arrow runs from phosphorylase kinase to glycogen phosphorylase and then to glucose leaving the cell. A side arrow shows phosphodiesterase converting cAMP to AMP.

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the ligand and the second messenger in the model, and describe the role of the Gs protein.
    2. Explain how the model accounts for a liver cell responding to epinephrine present in the blood at about 10−10 M.
    3. Calculate the number of phosphorylase kinase molecules activated per activated receptor. Show your setup.
    4. A drug inhibits the phosphodiesterase shown in the model. Justify the claim that the response will last longer without its peak becoming larger.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the ligand is epinephrine and the second messenger is cAMP. The Gs protein is the relay between the activated receptor and adenylyl cyclase: the receptor switches it on, and it in turn switches on the cyclase. Do not accept: naming cAMP as the ligand or epinephrine as the second messenger; "the G protein passes the signal along" with no named partner on either side.
    • (b) Accept: each step activates many molecules at the next step, so the step factors multiply rather than add and one bound hormone molecule produces hundreds of thousands of downstream events; a concentration far too low to act directly is therefore sufficient. Do not accept: "the signal gets bigger" with no reference to multiplying step factors; a number quoted with no explanation.
    • (c) Accept: cAMP per receptor \(= 50 \times 300 = 15{,}000\); PKA activated \(= 15{,}000/4 = 3{,}750\); phosphorylase kinase \(= 3{,}750 \times 120 = 450{,}000\), i.e. \(4.5 \times 10^{5}\) per activated receptor. The setup must show the division at the cAMP-to-PKA step. Do not accept: \(50 \times 300 \times 4 \times 120 = 7.2 \times 10^{6}\), which multiplies where the model divides; a final number with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: phosphodiesterase is the enzyme that removes cAMP, so inhibiting it disables the off switch rather than the production step; cAMP already made persists and PKA stays active longer, but nothing in the drug's action increases the rate at which adenylyl cyclase produces cAMP, so the peak is still set by reception and transduction. Do not accept: "the drug makes more cAMP"; restating the claim; a justification that never states what phosphodiesterase does.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The ligand is epinephrine and the second messenger is cAMP. The Gs protein sits just inside the membrane and works as a relay: the activated receptor switches it on, and it then switches on adenylyl cyclase.

    b Every arrow in the model multiplies instead of adding. One receptor turns on 50 G proteins, each cyclase makes 300 cAMP, and each PKA goes on to phosphorylate 120 more enzymes. Because those factors multiply, a single hormone molecule ends up moving hundreds of thousands of downstream molecules, which is how a hormone at 10−10 M can produce a whole-cell response.

    c cAMP made per receptor \(= 50 \times 300 = 15{,}000\). It takes 4 cAMP to activate one PKA, so PKA \(= 15{,}000/4 = 3{,}750\). Each PKA phosphorylates 120, so \(3{,}750 \times 120 = 450{,}000\), or \(4.5 \times 10^{5}\) phosphorylase kinase molecules per activated receptor.

    d Phosphodiesterase is the only thing in the model that gets rid of cAMP. Blocking it removes the off switch, so cAMP that has already been made hangs around and PKA keeps working after the hormone is gone: the response lasts longer. But the drug does nothing to the receptor, the G protein, or the cyclase, and those are what set how fast cAMP is made, so the highest level the response reaches is unchanged.

  4. Data: 250 cells from an onion root tip scored by stage. For these cells the complete cell cycle takes 18 hours.

    StageInterphaseProphaseMetaphaseAnaphaseTelophase
    Cells counted (of 250)1853512612

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the stage in which these cells spend the most time, and describe the assumption that allows a count of cells in a stage to be converted into the time spent in that stage.
    2. Explain why so few cells are observed in anaphase.
    3. Calculate the number of minutes a cell spends in metaphase and the mitotic index for this root tip. Show your setup.
    4. A second root tip has a mitotic index of 12%. Justify the claim that the first tip is dividing more actively, using both mitotic indices.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: interphase, with 185 of the 250 cells. The assumption is that the cells were fixed at random moments in their cycles, so the proportion of cells caught in a stage equals the proportion of the cycle that stage occupies. Do not accept: "most cells are in interphase" as the answer to the second task, which restates the data instead of stating the assumption; naming a stage with no assumption given.
    • (b) Accept: anaphase is the briefest stage, once cohesin is cleaved the separation of sister chromatids to the poles takes only a few minutes, so at any instant only a small fraction of the population is in it. Do not accept: "anaphase is rare"; "the cells were not dividing"; an answer that never connects a short duration to a small count.
    • (c) Accept: cycle \(= 18 \times 60 = 1080\) min; metaphase \(= (12/250) \times 1080 = 51.84\) min (accept 51.8 or about 52 min with correct setup); mitotic index \(= (250 - 185)/250 = 65/250 = 26.0\%\). Units required for the time. Do not accept: reporting 12/250 as the time; a mitotic index computed from metaphase cells alone; an answer with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: 26.0% against 12% means that at any instant more than twice as large a fraction of the first tip's cells are in M phase; because the mitotic index stands for the fraction of the cycle spent dividing, the first tip's cells are completing cycles more often. Do not accept: "26 is bigger than 12" with no reference to what the index measures; a comparison that treats the index as a count rather than a proportion.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Cells spend the most time in interphase, 185 of the 250 scored were in it. The assumption is that the root tip was fixed at one random moment, so the fraction of cells caught in a stage is the same as the fraction of the cycle that stage takes up.

    b Anaphase is the shortest part of the cycle. Once the cohesin holding the sister chromatids together is cleaved, the spindle pulls them to opposite poles in only a few minutes, so hardly any cells are caught in it at a given instant: 6 out of 250 here.

    c The cycle is \(18 \times 60 = 1080\) min. Metaphase \(= (12/250) \times 1080 = 51.84\) min, about 52 minutes. Mitotic index \(= (250 - 185)/250 = 65/250 = 0.260\), or 26.0%.

    d The mitotic index is the fraction of cells caught in M phase, which stands for the fraction of the cycle spent dividing. At 26.0% the first tip has more than twice the fraction of the second tip's 12%, so its cells spend more of their time in division and finish cycles more often. That is what dividing more actively means, and both numbers come from the same kind of count.

  5. Data: percentage of cells in each phase of the cell cycle 12 hours after a DNA-damaging dose of UV, for a human cell line with normal p53 and a line in which both p53 genes have been knocked out.

    Phasep53 normal, no UVp53 normal, + UVp53 null, no UVp53 null, + UV
    G1 (%)52885051
    S (%)2853029
    G2 + M (%)2072020

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the checkpoint at which p53 acts, and describe the change in the distribution of the p53-normal cells after UV exposure.
    2. Explain how p53 produces that change at the molecular level.
    3. Calculate the change in the percentage of cells in G1 caused by UV in each cell line, and state which line arrests.
    4. Justify the claim that a cell that loses p53 function is more likely to accumulate mutations, using the data.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the G1 checkpoint (the restriction point). After UV the p53-normal cells shift into G1, from 52% to 88%, while S falls from 28% to 5% and G2 + M from 20% to 7%: cells are being held before S phase. Do not accept: naming the G2 or M (spindle) checkpoint; "the cells stopped dividing" with no statement of where they accumulated.
    • (b) Accept: DNA damage activates p53, which acts as a transcription factor and induces the CDK inhibitor p21; p21 blocks the G1 cyclin–CDK complex so the cell cannot pass the restriction point, and it arrests in G1 while repair enzymes work or is directed to apoptosis if the damage is too severe. Do not accept: "p53 stops the cell cycle" with no named intermediate or target; describing p53 as an enzyme that repairs DNA itself.
    • (c) Accept: p53 normal, \(88 - 52 = +36\) percentage points; p53 null, \(51 - 50 = +1\) percentage point; only the p53-normal line arrests in G1. Do not accept: a ratio such as 88/52 offered as the change; omitting one of the two lines; failing to state which line arrests.
    • (d) Accept: the p53-null line barely changes after UV, 29% of its cells are still in S phase, so damaged cells enter S phase and replicate the damage instead of pausing to repair it, and both daughter cells inherit the resulting mutation; the 36-point shift into G1 in the normal line is the pause that prevents this. Do not accept: "p53 is a tumor suppressor" as the whole justification; a claim that cites no number or comparison from the table.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a p53 acts at the G1 checkpoint. After UV the p53-normal cells pile up in G1 (52% before, 88% after), while S phase drops from 28% to 5% and G2 plus M from 20% to 7%. They are being held before S phase instead of moving through it.

    b UV damage activates p53, and p53 is a transcription factor. It switches on the gene for p21, a CDK inhibitor, and p21 blocks the G1 cyclin–CDK complex the cell needs in order to pass the restriction point. With that complex inhibited the cell cannot enter S phase, so it waits in G1 while repair enzymes work, or is sent to apoptosis if the damage is too severe to fix.

    c p53 normal: \(88 - 52 = +36\) percentage points in G1. p53 null: \(51 - 50 = +1\) percentage point. Only the p53-normal line arrests.

    d In the knockout line UV barely changed anything, 29% of the cells were still in S phase 12 hours after the damage, against 5% in the normal line. Those cells are replicating damaged DNA instead of pausing, so the damage gets copied into both daughter cells and becomes a permanent mutation. The 36-point pile-up in G1 in the normal line is the pause that prevents exactly that, and the knockout has lost it.

Lesson 5.1 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.1

Meiosis: making haploid cells

You inherited 23 chromosomes from your mother and 23 from your father. If your parents had passed on all 46 each, you would have 92, and your children would have 184. Something has to cut the number in half every generation, and that something is meiosis. In sexually reproducing organisms, meiosis makes the gametes (sperm and egg cells) with half the chromosomes of an ordinary body cell, so that fertilization restores the full number. Mitosis (lesson 4.6) copies a cell; meiosis shuffles and halves it. This lesson follows the process stage by stage.

Learning objective · 5.1.A

Explain how meiosis results in the transmission of chromosomes from one generation to the next.

Diploid, haploid, and homologous chromosomes

Required content · EK 5.1.A.1

Meiosis is a process that ensures the formation of haploid gamete cells, sometimes referred to as daughter cells, in sexually reproducing diploid organisms.

A diploid cell (written 2n) has two sets of chromosomes, one from each parent: in humans 2n = 46. The two chromosomes of each pair are called homologous chromosomes (homologs). They are the same size, have the same genes in the same order, and one came from each parent, but they can carry different alleles (versions) of those genes. A haploid cell (n) has one set, with one chromosome of each kind: in humans n = 23. Remember that the homologs are not the same thing as the sister chromatids of lesson 4.5: sister chromatids are two identical copies of one chromosome made in S phase, and homologs are two different chromosomes, one from each parent.

Meiosis starts after the same S phase as mitosis, so each chromosome is already a pair of sister chromatids. It then divides the cell twice (meiosis I and meiosis II) with only one round of DNA replication, which is why the number of chromosomes ends up halved. The result in animals is four haploid daughter cells.

Meiosis I: separating the homologs

Prophase Ihomologs pair up;crossing overMetaphase Ihomologous pairsalign at the plateAnaphase Ihomologs separate;chromatids stay joinedTelophase Itwo haploid cells,chromatids still joinedResult: two haploid cells (n = 2 chromosomes), but each chromosome is still two sister chromatids.
Figure 5.1a Meiosis I in a cell with 2n = 4. Red and green show the maternal and paternal member of each homologous pair. Homologous chromosomes pair (synapsis), may form chiasmata where crossing over occurs, and are separated in anaphase I. Sister chromatids stay attached, so the cells formed are haploid.
Required content · EK 5.1.A.2
  • Prophase I: homologous chromosomes pair up and condense; synapsis occurs, and then chiasmata may form; the meiotic spindle begins to form, centrosomes move to opposite poles of the cell, and the nuclear envelope breaks down.
  • Metaphase I: meiotic spindle fibers align homologous pairs of chromosomes along the equator of the cell at the metaphase plate.
  • Anaphase I: homologous chromosomes separate, while sister chromatids remain attached, as meiotic spindle fibers pull chromosomes toward poles.
  • Telophase I: the meiotic spindle breaks down, a new nuclear envelope develops, a cleavage furrow (animal cell) or cell plate (plant cell) forms, and cytokinesis occurs. Two haploid daughter cells are formed (at the end of meiosis I).

The difference from mitosis is in prophase I and metaphase I. In prophase I the homologs find each other and pair up along their length, a process called synapsis. Each pair of homologs, now four chromatids, is called a tetrad. While they are paired, the homologs can form cross-shaped connections called chiasmata (singular: chiasma), at which non-sister chromatids exchange segments: this is crossing over (lesson 5.2). In metaphase I the pairs line up at the equator, with one homolog of each pair facing each pole. (In mitosis, individual chromosomes line up, not pairs.) In anaphase I the homologs are pulled apart, but the centromeres do not split, so each chromosome still has two sister chromatids. After telophase I and cytokinesis there are two cells. Each has one chromosome from each homologous pair, so the number of chromosomes has been halved: they are haploid. This is why meiosis I is called the reduction division.

Meiosis II: separating the sister chromatids

Prophase IIspindle forms;chromatids still joinedMetaphase IIchromosomes alignat the plateAnaphase IIsister chromatidspulled apartTelophase IIfour haploid cells,unduplicated chromatidsMeiosis II looks like mitosis, but the cells start haploid.
Figure 5.1b Meiosis II separates sister chromatids, as in mitosis. Each cell from meiosis I divides, giving four haploid cells in all. Each daughter has one unduplicated chromatid of each kind, and the combination differs from cell to cell.
Required content · EK 5.1.A.3
  • Prophase II: the meiotic spindle forms; sister chromatids connected at the centromere attach to the meiotic spindle.
  • Metaphase II: chromosomes align along the metaphase plate; the kinetochore of each chromatid is attached to a microtubule extending from the poles.
  • Anaphase II: proteins at the centromeres break down, and sister chromatids are pulled apart and toward opposite poles in the cell.
  • Telophase II: the meiotic spindle breaks down, a new nuclear envelope develops, a cleavage furrow (animal cell) or a cell plate (plant cell) forms, chromatids begin to decondense, and cytokinesis occurs. Four haploid daughter cells are formed, each with an unduplicated chromatid.

Meiosis II is like mitosis, with two differences: the cells begin haploid, and there is no DNA replication before it. In each of the two cells from meiosis I, the chromosomes line up singly at the equator (metaphase II), the centromeres split, and the sister chromatids are pulled apart (anaphase II). Each chromatid is now a chromosome. Cytokinesis then divides each cell, giving four haploid cells. Because of crossing over and the random assortment described in the next lesson, the four cells are not identical to each other or to the parent cell.

Keeping track: chromosome number and DNA content

Worked example · Counting through meiosis (2n = 8)

A cell of an organism with 2n = 8 has a DNA content of 2C per cell in G1. Complete a table of chromosomes, chromatids, and DNA content per cell for the stages below, and explain the changes.

Stage (per cell)ChromosomesChromatidsDNA content
G1882C
After S phase (G2)8164C
End of meiosis I (each of two cells)482C
End of meiosis II (each of four cells)441C

S phase. DNA is replicated, so the DNA content doubles (2C to 4C) and each of the 8 chromosomes becomes two sister chromatids (16). The number of chromosomes does not change.
Meiosis I. The homologs separate, so each cell gets 4 chromosomes (one from each of the 4 pairs). The chromosome number is halved (8 to 4), and the DNA content per cell is halved (4C to 2C). Each chromosome is still two chromatids, so there are still 8 chromatids per cell.
Meiosis II. Sister chromatids separate, so each cell now has 4 chromosomes with 1 chromatid each, and a DNA content of 1C. The chromosome number is unchanged from the end of meiosis I (4), but the DNA content is halved again.
Check. One cell with 4C DNA gave four cells with 1C each (\(4 \times 1 = 4\)), so no DNA was lost or gained.

Where meiosis happens

In animals, meiosis takes place in the germ cells of the gonads (testes and ovaries) and makes the gametes directly. In plants and fungi it makes spores, which later divide by mitosis to produce a haploid body that makes gametes (the details of life cycles in different plants and animals are beyond the scope of the AP Exam). In human males, one cell that enters meiosis gives four sperm. In human females the cytoplasm divides unequally, so one large egg and small cells called polar bodies are produced; the polar bodies are discarded, so the egg has most of the cytoplasm for the embryo. In both cases the key result is the same: cells with one set of chromosomes.

Exam focus
  • Meiosis: one round of DNA replication and two divisions, giving four haploid cells that are genetically different.
  • Meiosis I separates homologous chromosomes (reduction division; the cells become haploid). Meiosis II separates sister chromatids (like mitosis).
  • Special to meiosis I: synapsis in prophase I, tetrads, chiasmata and crossing over, homologous pairs at the metaphase plate.
  • For counting: the chromosome number is halved in meiosis I; the DNA per cell is halved in meiosis I and again in meiosis II.
  • Do not confuse homologs (one from each parent, may carry different alleles) with sister chromatids (identical copies).
Practice
  1. Explain why meiosis I, not meiosis II, is called the reduction division.
    Show answer

    In meiosis I the homologous chromosomes are separated into two different cells, so each daughter cell has only one chromosome of each pair: the chromosome number is reduced from diploid (2n) to haploid (n). In meiosis II only sister chromatids are separated, so the number of chromosomes stays the same.

  2. A human cell in G1 has 46 chromosomes. State the number of chromosomes and chromatids in one cell at the end of prophase I, and at the end of meiosis I.
    Show answer

    At the end of prophase I (after S phase): 46 chromosomes and 92 chromatids. At the end of meiosis I: each cell has 23 chromosomes and 46 chromatids.

  3. Name the stage in which each event happens: (a) homologous chromosomes pair; (b) homologous pairs line up at the equator; (c) sister chromatids separate.
    Show answer

    (a) Prophase I (synapsis). (b) Metaphase I. (c) Anaphase II (in meiosis; in mitosis this occurs at anaphase).

  4. Describe two differences between metaphase I of meiosis and metaphase of mitosis.
    Show answer

    In metaphase I, homologous pairs (tetrads) line up at the equator, with the two homologs facing opposite poles; in mitotic metaphase, individual duplicated chromosomes line up, and no pairing occurs. Also, in metaphase I the kinetochores of the two sister chromatids of a chromosome attach to microtubules from the same pole, while in mitosis they attach to opposite poles.

  5. An organism has 2n = 12. How many chromosomes are in each of its gametes, and how many chromatids does each have?
    Show answer

    Each gamete is haploid, with n = 6 chromosomes. Each chromosome is a single, unduplicated chromatid, so there are 6 chromatids.

  6. A cell has 4C DNA at the beginning of meiosis I. Predict the DNA content of each of the four cells at the end of meiosis II, and the content of one cell after meiosis I, and justify.
    Show answer

    After meiosis I each of the two cells has 2C, because the homologs were divided between two cells. After meiosis II each of the four cells has 1C, because the sister chromatids were divided. The total stays at 4C throughout (\(4 \times 1 = 4\)).

Lesson 5.2 · Unit 5 · CED topics 5.1 (comparison) and 5.2

Meiosis and genetic diversity

Brothers and sisters can have the same two parents and yet look and act differently, and except for identical twins no two of them have the same genes. Mitosis produces clones. Meiosis does the opposite: it produces cells that are all different, and this variation is the raw material on which natural selection (unit 7) works. This lesson compares the two processes and explains the three ways in which sexual reproduction generates variation: crossing over, independent assortment, and random fertilization.

Learning objectives · 5.1.B and 5.2.A

Describe the similarities and differences between the phases and outcomes of mitosis and meiosis, and explain how the process of meiosis generates genetic diversity.

Mitosis compared with meiosis

MitosisMeiosis2nthen 1 division2nthen 2 divisions2n2n2 cells, diploid,genetically identicalgrowth, repair, asexual reproductionnnnn4 cells, haploid,genetically differentgametes (sexual reproduction)
Figure 5.2a Mitosis and meiosis both use a spindle to move chromosomes, but they differ in the number of cells produced and in the genetic content of the daughter cells.
Required content · EK 5.1.B.1

Mitosis and meiosis are similar in the use of a spindle apparatus to move chromosomes but differ in the number of cells produced and the genetic content of the daughter cells.

MitosisMeiosis
Where and whyBody (somatic) cells: growth, repair, asexual reproductionGerm cells: production of gametes or spores for sexual reproduction
DNA replicationsOne (S phase)One (S phase)
DivisionsOneTwo (meiosis I and II)
Cells produced24
Chromosome number of daughtersSame as the parent (2n to 2n)Half of the parent (2n to n)
Synapsis and crossing overNoYes, in prophase I
What lines up at the metaphase plateIndividual chromosomesHomologous pairs (meiosis I); individual chromosomes (meiosis II)
What separates in anaphaseSister chromatidsHomologs (anaphase I); sister chromatids (anaphase II)
Genetic content of daughtersIdentical to each other and to the parentDifferent from each other and from the parent

Correct separation: the haploid set

Required content · EK 5.2.A.1

Correct separation of the homologous chromosomes in meiosis I and sister chromatids in meiosis II ensures that each gamete receives a haploid (1n) set of chromosomes that comprises an assortment of both maternal and paternal chromosomes. When incorrect separation occurs (nondisjunction), gametes are no longer haploid.

Each gamete gets exactly one chromosome from each homologous pair, but which one, the maternal or the paternal copy, is a matter of chance. This is the first source of variation.

Source 1: independent assortment of homologs

Arrangement 1metaphase IgametegameteArrangement 2metaphase Igametegamete
Figure 5.2c Each homologous pair lines up independently of the others, so the maternal and paternal chromosomes are sorted into gametes in random combinations. With 2 pairs there are 4 possible gametes (2 squared); with 23 pairs there are 2 to the 23rd power, which is 8,388,608, before any crossing over.

In metaphase I each homologous pair lines up at the equator, and which homolog faces which pole is random. The orientation of one pair does not influence the orientation of any other. This is called independent assortment, and it means that the gametes get random mixtures of maternal and paternal chromosomes. For \(n\) pairs of chromosomes there are \(2^n\) different combinations of chromosomes possible in the gametes.

Worked example · How many different gametes, and how many different children?

Calculate (a) the number of different gametes that one person could make from independent assortment alone, ignoring crossing over, using \(n = 23\); (b) the number of different zygotes from two parents; (c) the same for a fruit fly with \(2n = 8\); and (d) explain what the numbers show.

(a) \(2^{23} = 8{,}388{,}608\) possible gametes from one person.
(b) Fertilization combines one gamete from each parent, and the choices are independent, so the numbers multiply: \(8{,}388{,}608 \times 8{,}388{,}608 = 2^{46} = 70{,}368{,}744{,}177{,}664\), about \(7.0 \times 10^{13}\) different zygotes. That is hundreds of times the roughly \(1 \times 10^{11}\) people estimated to have ever lived, so no two children of the same parents are expected to get the same combination of chromosomes.
(c) For \(2n = 8\), \(n = 4\), so \(2^4 = 16\) different gametes.
(d) Independent assortment produces a huge number of combinations in humans and a much smaller number in an organism with few chromosomes. These numbers are a minimum, since they do not include crossing over, which makes each chromosome a mixture and so adds many more possibilities. (Identical twins are the exception, because they come from a single zygote.)

Source 2: crossing over

Prophase I: homologs pairedAfter crossing overchiasmacrossing overABABababABAbaBabABAbaBabAB and ab are parental; Ab and aB are recombinant.
Figure 5.2b During prophase I, non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes exchange genetic material by crossing over (recombination). Two of the four chromatids are now recombinant, which increases genetic diversity among the resulting gametes.
Required content · EK 5.2.A.2

During prophase I of meiosis, non-sister chromatids exchange genetic material via a process called crossing over (recombination), which increases genetic diversity among the resultant gametes.

While the homologs are paired in prophase I, matching segments of non-sister chromatids are cut and swapped at the chiasmata. The chromatids that result are recombinant: they carry a mix of maternal and paternal alleles that did not exist together before. In the figure, the parent has alleles A and B on one homolog and a and b on the other. Without crossing over only the AB and ab gametes would be formed; after crossing over, Ab and aB gametes are also formed. Crossing over also means that the sister chromatids of a chromosome are no longer identical at the end of prophase I, and that the chromosomes that go to the gametes are mosaics of the two parental chromosomes. The closer two genes are on a chromosome, the less likely they are to be separated by a crossover, a fact used for mapping in lesson 5.6.

Source 3: random fertilization

Required content · EK 5.2.A.3

Sexual reproduction in eukaryotes increases genetic variation, including crossing over, random assortment of chromosomes during meiosis, and subsequent fertilization of gametes.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of the details of sexual reproduction cycles in various plants and animals is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Any sperm can fuse with any egg. Since each gamete is already unique, the zygote is a new combination of alleles (as the worked example showed, there are about \(7 \times 10^{13}\) possible combinations in humans even before crossing over). Mutations (lesson 6.7) are the original source of new alleles, and the three mechanisms of this lesson shuffle those alleles into new combinations.

When separation fails: nondisjunction

Meiosis I errorhomologs fail to separaten+1n+1n−1n−1Meiosis II errorsister chromatids fail to separaten+1n−1nnFertilization of an n+1 gamete by a normal gamete gives a trisomy (2n+1);fertilization of an n−1 gamete gives a monosomy (2n−1).
Figure 5.2d Nondisjunction is the incorrect separation of chromosomes. Gametes are no longer haploid with one copy of each chromosome: they have an extra copy (n+1) or lack one (n−1), and some may be normal.

Nondisjunction is the failure of chromosomes or chromatids to separate properly. If homologs fail to separate in anaphase I, two of the four gametes have both homologs of that chromosome (n + 1) and two have none (n − 1). If sister chromatids fail to separate in anaphase II, one gamete is n + 1, one is n − 1, and two are normal. If an n + 1 gamete is fertilized by a normal gamete, the zygote has three copies of one chromosome (trisomy, 2n + 1); with an n − 1 gamete it has only one (monosomy, 2n − 1). Most such zygotes do not survive. Trisomy 21 causes Down syndrome (47 chromosomes); a female with one X chromosome and no second sex chromosome (45, X) has Turner syndrome; and a male with an extra X (47, XXY) has Klinefelter syndrome. The risk of nondisjunction in the egg increases with the age of the mother.

Exam focus
  • Mitosis: 1 division, 2 identical diploid cells (growth, repair). Meiosis: 2 divisions, 4 different haploid cells (gametes). Both use a spindle.
  • Three sources of variation: crossing over (prophase I, non-sister chromatids), independent assortment (metaphase I, \(2^n\) combinations), random fertilization.
  • Only the alleles are new from mutation; the three processes above recombine them.
  • Nondisjunction gives gametes that are n + 1 or n − 1; fertilization gives trisomy or monosomy.
  • For a number-of-gametes question, count the pairs: \(2^n\), and multiply for two parents.
Practice
  1. Describe two similarities and two differences between mitosis and meiosis.
    Show answer

    Similarities: both are preceded by one round of DNA replication, and both use a spindle to move chromosomes (and have the same phases of prophase, metaphase, anaphase, and telophase). Differences: mitosis has one division and produces two genetically identical diploid cells, while meiosis has two divisions and produces four genetically different haploid cells; and meiosis has synapsis and crossing over in prophase I, while mitosis does not.

  2. Calculate the number of different chromosome combinations in the gametes of an organism with 2n = 20, ignoring crossing over.
    Show answer

    \(n = 10\), so the number is \(2^{10} = 1{,}024\).

  3. Explain how crossing over increases genetic diversity.
    Show answer

    In prophase I, non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes exchange segments. The chromatids that result carry new combinations of alleles (recombinants) that were not together on either parental chromosome, so the gametes have combinations of alleles that would not be found without crossing over.

  4. A parent has the genotype AaBb for two genes on the same chromosome, with A and B together on one homolog. Name the gametes made without crossing over and the extra gametes made with it.
    Show answer

    Without crossing over the gametes are AB and ab. With crossing over between the two genes, the recombinant gametes Ab and aB are also made.

  5. In a particular meiosis, the sister chromatids of chromosome 21 fail to separate in anaphase II. Predict the chromosome 21 content of the four gametes.
    Show answer

    One gamete has two copies of chromosome 21 (n + 1), one has none (n − 1), and two have one copy each (normal, n). Fertilization of the n + 1 gamete would give trisomy 21.

  6. A student states that crossing over increases the number of chromosomes in a gamete. Evaluate this claim.
    Show answer

    The claim is incorrect. Crossing over exchanges segments between homologous chromosomes, which changes the combination of alleles on each chromosome, but it does not change the number of chromosomes. Gametes remain haploid.

Lesson 5.3 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.3

Mendelian genetics: segregation, assortment, and probability

In the 1850s and 1860s, the monk Gregor Mendel grew thousands of pea plants and counted the offspring of his crosses. He did not know about chromosomes or DNA, but from the numbers he worked out rules for how traits are passed on, and the rules turned out to describe the behavior of chromosomes in meiosis. In this lesson you will learn his two laws, the vocabulary of genetics, and how to predict the outcome of a cross with a Punnett square or with the rules of probability.

Learning objective · 5.3.A

Explain the inheritance of genes and traits as described by Mendel’s laws.

Genes, alleles, genotype, and phenotype

Required content · EK 5.3.A.2 (iii and iv)
  • An organism’s genotype is the set of alleles inherited for one or more genes by an individual organism. An organism’s genotype can be homozygous or heterozygous for each gene.
  • An organism’s phenotype is the observable expression of the inherited traits.

A gene is a section of DNA that codes for a product, and an allele is one version of a gene. This is a distinction that students often miss (and the exam tests it): a diploid organism has two copies of each gene, but each can be a different allele. In peas, the gene for flower color has a purple allele (P) and a white allele (p). An organism with two identical alleles (PP or pp) is homozygous for that gene, and one with two different alleles (Pp) is heterozygous. The dominant allele (P) is the one whose phenotype appears in a heterozygote, and the recessive allele (p) is expressed only if there is no dominant allele. So PP and Pp have the same phenotype (purple) but different genotypes. Dominance describes how an allele is expressed; it does not mean that an allele is the more common or the more beneficial one.

The law of segregation

Required content · EK 5.3.A.1

Mendel’s laws of segregation and independent assortment can be applied to genes that are on different chromosomes.

The law of segregation says that the two alleles for a gene separate (segregate) when gametes are formed, so each gamete gets only one allele of each gene. We now know why: the two alleles are on homologous chromosomes, and the homologs are separated in anaphase I of meiosis (lesson 5.1). A Pp plant makes half P gametes and half p gametes. The law of independent assortment says that the alleles of different genes are sorted into gametes independently of each other. The reason is that homologous pairs line up independently in metaphase I (lesson 5.2). A PpYy plant makes four kinds of gametes (PY, Py, pY, py) in equal numbers. The law applies to genes on different chromosomes; genes close together on the same chromosome (linked genes, lesson 5.6) do not follow it.

Predicting crosses with Punnett squares

Monohybrid: Pp × PpDihybrid: AaBb × AaBbPPppPPPpPppp3 purple : 1 white1 PP : 2 Pp : 1 ppABABAbAbaBaBabab9 AB3 Abb3 aaB_1 aabb9 : 3 : 3 : 1 phenotypic ratio
Figure 5.3a A Punnett square lists the possible gametes of each parent along the sides and the resulting genotypes inside. A monohybrid cross of two heterozygotes gives 3:1; a dihybrid cross of two double heterozygotes gives 9:3:3:1 when the genes assort independently.
Required content · EK 5.3.A.2 (i, ii and v)
  • In most cases, fertilization involves the fusion of two haploid gametes, restoring the diploid number of chromosomes and increasing genetic variation in populations by creating new combinations of alleles in the zygote.
  • Rules of probability can be applied to analyze the passing of single-gene traits from parent to offspring.
  • Monohybrid, dihybrid, and test crosses can be used to determine whether alleles are dominant or recessive.
  • Patterns of inheritance (autosomal, genetically linked, sex-linked) and whether an allele is dominant or recessive can often be predicted from data, including pedigrees. Punnett squares can be used to predict the genotypes and phenotypes of parents and offspring.

A monohybrid cross follows one gene. Mendel crossed true-breeding (homozygous) purple plants with true-breeding white plants. All of the offspring (the F1 generation) were purple, so the white trait seemed to have disappeared. When the F1 plants (all Pp) were allowed to self-pollinate, the white trait came back in about one quarter of the F2 generation: the ratio was about 3 purple to 1 white. The Punnett square shows why. Each Pp parent makes P and p gametes in equal numbers, and the four combinations are equally likely: \(\tfrac14 PP\), \(\tfrac12 Pp\), \(\tfrac14 pp\). The genotypic ratio is 1 : 2 : 1 and the phenotypic ratio is 3 : 1. The recessive allele was masked in the F1, not lost.

A dihybrid cross follows two genes. A cross of two AaBb parents gives 16 equally likely combinations in a 4 × 4 square, in four phenotypic classes in the ratio 9 : 3 : 3 : 1: 9 show both dominant traits, 3 show the first dominant and second recessive, 3 the reverse, and 1 shows both recessive traits. This ratio is the evidence for independent assortment. If genes are linked, the observed ratio will be quite different (lesson 5.6).

The test cross

A purple plant could be PP or Pp, and you cannot tell by looking. A test cross crosses the unknown individual with a homozygous recessive one (pp), which can contribute only p gametes, so the phenotypes of the offspring reveal the gametes of the unknown parent. If the unknown is PP, all offspring are Pp (purple). If it is Pp, half the offspring are Pp (purple) and half are pp (white). A single white offspring proves that the parent is Pp.

Using the rules of probability

Relevant equations (on the AP Exam equation sheet)

If A and B are mutually exclusive: \(P(A \text{ or } B) = P(A) + P(B)\). If A and B are independent: \(P(A \text{ and } B) = P(A) \times P(B)\).

Drawing a 64-square grid for three genes is slow, and the rules of probability are quicker. The product rule applies to independent events (the genes assort independently, so the result for one gene does not affect the result for another). The sum rule applies to mutually exclusive outcomes (a plant cannot be both Pp and pp). The method is to work out each gene separately and multiply the results.

Worked example · A trihybrid cross by probability

In peas, purple (P) is dominant to white, tall (T) is dominant to dwarf, and round (R) is dominant to wrinkled. All three genes are on different chromosomes. A PpTtRr plant is crossed with a PpTtrr plant. Find (a) the probability that an offspring is purple, tall, and wrinkled; (b) the probability that it is white, dwarf, and round; (c) the probability that it is purple (any other traits).

Gene by gene. Pp × Pp: \(P(\text{purple}) = 3/4\), \(P(\text{white}) = 1/4\). Tt × Tt: \(P(\text{tall}) = 3/4\), \(P(\text{dwarf}) = 1/4\). Rr × rr: \(P(\text{round}) = 1/2\), \(P(\text{wrinkled}) = 1/2\).
(a) Purple and tall and wrinkled (product rule): \(3/4 \times 3/4 \times 1/2 = 9/32 = 0.28\).
(b) White and dwarf and round: \(1/4 \times 1/4 \times 1/2 = 1/32 = 0.031\).
(c) The other genes do not matter, so \(P = 3/4\). (Using the sum rule for the genotypes: \(P(PP) + P(Pp) = 1/4 + 1/2 = 3/4\).)
Check. The method does not depend on the Punnett square, so a three-gene cross takes the same effort as a one-gene cross. If the parents produced 320 offspring, the number expected in class (a) would be \(320 \times 9/32 = 90\).

Probability also reminds you that each offspring is an independent event: two heterozygous parents with a purple-flowered first child have a \(3/4\) chance of a purple second child, not a lower one. The numbers are expected values: with small samples, the observed ratio may be far from 3:1 by chance (a chi-square test, in lesson 5.6, tells you whether a difference is larger than chance would allow).

Exam focus
  • Segregation: the two alleles of a gene separate into different gametes (anaphase I). Independent assortment: genes on different chromosomes are inherited independently (metaphase I).
  • Gene = the section of DNA; allele = a version of the gene. Genotype = alleles; phenotype = the observable trait. Homozygous or heterozygous.
  • Monohybrid Aa × Aa: 3 : 1 (genotypes 1 : 2 : 1). Dihybrid AaBb × AaBb: 9 : 3 : 3 : 1. Test cross: unknown × homozygous recessive; a 1 : 1 result means heterozygous.
  • Product rule (independent events, AND) and sum rule (mutually exclusive outcomes, OR): do the genes one at a time.
  • Always read the question: is it asking for the probability of a genotype, a phenotype, or a count of offspring?
Practice
  1. In pea plants, yellow seeds (Y) are dominant to green (y). Two heterozygous plants are crossed. State the expected phenotypic ratio, and the number of green-seeded plants expected among 200 offspring.
    Show answer

    The ratio is 3 yellow : 1 green. Expected green seeds: \(200 \times 1/4 = 50\).

  2. Explain the difference between a gene and an allele, and between genotype and phenotype.
    Show answer

    A gene is a section of DNA that codes for a product, and an allele is one version of that gene. The genotype is the combination of alleles that an organism has, and the phenotype is the observable trait that results from them.

  3. A black rabbit (dominant B) is test-crossed to a brown rabbit. Of 8 offspring, all are black. Estimate the genotype of the black rabbit, and calculate the probability of this result if the black rabbit were Bb.
    Show answer

    It is probably BB. If it were Bb, each offspring would be black with a probability of 1/2, so the probability of 8 black offspring would be \((1/2)^8 = 1/256 \approx 0.004\), which is very unlikely.

  4. For the cross AaBbCc × AaBbCc, calculate the probability of an offspring that is aabbcc, and the probability that it shows all three dominant phenotypes.
    Show answer

    aabbcc: \(1/4 \times 1/4 \times 1/4 = 1/64\). All three dominant: \(3/4 \times 3/4 \times 3/4 = 27/64\).

  5. List the gametes of a RrYy individual and the expected fraction of each, and explain which law this follows.
    Show answer

    RY, Ry, rY, and ry, each \(1/4\). This follows the law of segregation (each gamete gets one allele of each gene) and the law of independent assortment (the alleles of the two genes are sorted independently, because the genes are on different chromosomes).

  6. Two parents with brown eyes (dominant) have a blue-eyed child. State the genotypes of the parents and the probability that their next child has blue eyes, and justify.
    Show answer

    Both parents must be heterozygous (Bb), because each carries a recessive allele passed to the blue-eyed child (bb). For each child, the probability of bb is \(1/4\), regardless of the earlier children, since each fertilization is an independent event.

Lesson 5.4 · Unit 5 · CED topics 5.3 (pedigrees) and 5.4 (sex-linked)

Pedigrees and sex-linked inheritance

You cannot do a test cross on a human family, and you cannot choose which people marry. Geneticists studying human traits instead read pedigrees, family trees that show who has a trait and who does not. From a pedigree you can work out whether a trait is dominant or recessive, whether it is on an autosome or a sex chromosome, and the genotypes of the people involved. In this lesson you will learn to do this and to explain why some traits, such as red-green color blindness, are much more common in males.

Learning objectives · 5.3.A and 5.4.A (sex-linked traits)

Explain how patterns of inheritance, including autosomal and sex-linked, can be predicted from data such as pedigrees, and explain deviations from Mendel’s model for traits determined by genes on sex chromosomes.

Reading a pedigree

Autosomal recessiveX-linked recessiveAaAaaaA_A_affected child of unaffected parents(both sexes can be affected)XR YXR Xrskips a generation; more males affected than femalesmalefemaleaffectedcarrier (dot)
Figure 5.4a Pedigrees show how a trait is passed through a family. Squares are males and circles are females; filled symbols are affected. Unaffected parents with an affected child indicate a recessive allele. If more males than females are affected, the allele may be X-linked.

In a pedigree, a square is a male and a circle a female; a filled symbol is a person with the trait. A horizontal line joins two parents and a vertical line leads to their children. The clues for the pattern of inheritance are as follows.

  • Autosomal recessive. Two unaffected parents have an affected child (the parents are both carriers). Males and females are affected in about equal numbers. The trait can skip generations. (If a trait appeared in a child but in neither parent, it cannot be dominant.)
  • Autosomal dominant. Every affected person has at least one affected parent, and the trait does not skip generations. Two affected parents can have an unaffected child (if both are heterozygous). Males and females are affected equally.
  • X-linked recessive. Many more males than females are affected. An affected male usually has unaffected parents, and the trait passes from an unaffected carrier mother to her sons. An affected father passes the allele to all of his daughters (who become carriers) and to none of his sons, because sons receive his Y chromosome.

The method is to find a family in which two unaffected parents have an affected child (which proves recessive), and then ask whether the affected people are mostly male (X-linked) or of both sexes (autosomal). Then write the genotypes, starting with the people that you can be sure of: an affected person with a recessive trait is homozygous recessive, and an unaffected parent of an affected child is a carrier.

Sex chromosomes and sex linkage

Required content · EK 5.4.A.2

Some traits, known as sex-linked traits (X- or Y-linked), are determined by genes on sex chromosomes. The pattern of inheritance of sex-linked traits can often be predicted from data, including pedigrees, indicating the genotypes and phenotypes of both parents and offspring.

In humans and many other animals, females are XX and males XY. The X chromosome is large and carries about 800 or more protein-coding genes, and the Y chromosome is small and carries few (including the gene that triggers male development). All other chromosomes are autosomes. Genes on the X chromosome that have no counterpart on the Y are X-linked. A female has two copies of each X-linked gene, like an autosomal gene, but a male has only one, so any allele on his X chromosome is expressed, whether or not it is recessive. Males are said to be hemizygous for X-linked genes. Genes on the Y chromosome (Y-linked) are passed only from fathers to sons.

X-linked cross: carrier mother × unaffected fatherXRYXRXrXR XRfemale, unaffectedXR Ymale, unaffectedXR Xrfemale, carrierXr Ymale, affectedHalf of the sons are affected;no daughters are affected(but half are carriers).
Figure 5.4b A recessive X-linked allele is expressed in every male that inherits it, because males have only one X. Females need two copies, so most affected people are male.

Examples of X-linked recessive traits in humans are red-green color blindness, hemophilia A (a defect in a blood clotting protein), and Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Thomas Hunt Morgan’s discovery of the white-eye trait in the fruit fly Drosophila in 1910 was the first evidence that a gene is on a particular chromosome: white eyes appeared almost entirely in males, and the results of crosses fit the behavior of the X chromosome. The Punnett square above shows a cross of a carrier mother (XRXr) and an unaffected father (XRY): half of the sons are affected, and none of the daughters, though half of them are carriers. In a female, one of the two X chromosomes in each cell is randomly inactivated early in development (it becomes a condensed Barr body), so a carrier female is a mosaic of cells expressing each allele. This is the origin of the patches of two colors in tortoiseshell and calico cats, whose coat color gene is on the X chromosome.

Illustrative examples · EK 5.4.A.2
  • Sex-linked traits (X- or Y-linked) reside on sex chromosomes.
  • Sex-linked traits are inherited at higher rates in XY individuals than they are in XX individuals.
  • In certain species, the chromosomal basis of sex determination is not based on X and Y chromosomes: for example, ZW in birds (the female is ZW and the male ZZ, the reverse of the human pattern) and haplodiploidy in bees (females develop from fertilized eggs and are diploid; males develop from unfertilized eggs and are haploid).
Worked example · Why color blindness is more common in males

About 8% of males (XY) in a population have red-green color blindness, which is caused by a recessive X-linked allele. (a) Estimate the frequency q of the allele. (b) Estimate the percent of females who are color blind. (c) A woman who is not color blind but whose father is color blind has a child with a man who is not color blind. State the probability that a son is color blind, and that a daughter is color blind.

(a) A male has only one X, so the fraction of males affected equals the allele frequency: \(q = 0.08\).
(b) A female is affected only if she has two copies: \(q^2 = 0.08 \times 0.08 = 0.0064\), or about 0.64% (roughly 1 in 150), which is \(0.08/0.0064 = 12.5\) times lower than in males.
(c) Her father is color blind (XrY), and he must have given her his X, so she is a carrier (XRXr). The father of the child is XRY. As in the Punnett square, each son has a \(1/2\) chance of being color blind, and no daughter will be color blind (each has a \(1/2\) chance of being a carrier).
Reasoning. The difference in rates in the population is a consequence of the number of X chromosomes: a recessive allele on the single X of a male is always expressed, while a female needs two copies.

Putting it together: solving a pedigree

Suppose a pedigree shows a rare trait in which an affected mother has an affected son, and in a second family two unaffected parents have an affected son but no affected daughters. Is the trait autosomal or X-linked? The first family is not enough, because an affected mother and son are possible in either case. In the second, unaffected parents with an affected child show that the trait is recessive, and the fact that all of the affected people are male favors X-linked inheritance, although with a small number of children it could be chance. The best way to decide is to look for a feature that is impossible in one pattern: an affected daughter of an unaffected father would rule out X-linked recessive inheritance, since the father would have given the X to all of his daughters. On the exam, state the pattern, give the evidence from specific individuals, and name the genotypes.

Exam focus
  • Unaffected parents with an affected child: recessive. Mostly males affected and no father-to-son transmission: X-linked.
  • X-linked recessive: an affected father gives the allele to all daughters and no sons; a carrier mother gives it to half of her sons (affected) and half of her daughters (carriers).
  • Males have one X, so one copy of the recessive allele is enough; the frequency in males is q and in females q2.
  • Other systems: ZW (birds, female is ZW), haplodiploidy (bees).
  • For pedigree questions, write the genotype of each person (or A_ if not known) and check each parent-child link.
Practice
  1. Two unaffected parents have an affected daughter. Determine the mode of inheritance and the parents’ genotypes, and justify.
    Show answer

    The trait is autosomal recessive. If it were X-linked recessive, an affected daughter would have to have received an X with the allele from her father, who would then be affected. As the father is unaffected, the gene must be on an autosome, and both parents are heterozygous carriers (Aa).

  2. A man with hemophilia (X-linked recessive) and an unaffected woman who is not a carrier have children. Predict the phenotypes of their sons and daughters.
    Show answer

    All sons are unaffected (they receive the father’s Y and the mother’s normal X). All daughters are unaffected carriers (they receive the father’s X with the allele and a normal X from the mother).

  3. A carrier mother and an unaffected father have four children. What is the probability that a given child is an affected son? What is the probability that a given son is affected?
    Show answer

    Of the four equally likely combinations, one is an affected son, so the probability that a child is an affected son is \(1/4\). Among sons only (XRY or XrY), half are affected: \(1/2\).

  4. Explain why a recessive X-linked trait is more common in males than in females.
    Show answer

    Males (XY) have only one X chromosome, so a single copy of the recessive allele is expressed. Females (XX) must inherit two copies of the allele to show the trait, which is less likely (\(q^2\) compared with \(q\)); with one copy they are carriers with the dominant allele on their other X.

  5. In birds, the female is ZW and the male is ZZ. A recessive Z-linked allele is carried by a male (heterozygous) that is crossed with a normal female. Predict which sex will be affected among the offspring, and justify.
    Show answer

    Only daughters (ZW) can be affected. A son receives a Z from each parent, and so gets the normal Z from the mother (and is at most a carrier). A daughter receives the mother’s W and the father’s Z, and half of the daughters get the Z carrying the recessive allele, so half of the daughters are affected. This is the reverse of the human pattern because the heterogametic sex (ZW) is female.

  6. About 1 in 10,000 males has an X-linked recessive disorder. Estimate the frequency of affected females, and explain the relation between the two values.
    Show answer

    The allele frequency q equals the frequency in males, \(1/10{,}000 = 0.0001\). The frequency in females is \(q^2 = (0.0001)^2 = 1 \times 10^{-8}\), or 1 in 100 million. Females are rarely affected, because they need two copies of an allele that is rare in the population.

Lesson 5.5 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4 (part 2)

Beyond Mendel: dominance patterns, pleiotropy, and non-nuclear inheritance

Mendel was lucky. He chose seven pea traits, each controlled by one gene with one dominant and one recessive allele, on different chromosomes. Most traits are not so simple. A cross of red and white snapdragons gives pink flowers, human blood type has three alleles, one gene can affect many different traits, and some traits are inherited from the mother only. The ratios in these cases do not match Mendel’s 3:1 and 9:3:3:1, and recognizing why is a standard exam skill.

Learning objective · 5.4.A

Explain deviations from Mendel’s model of the inheritance of traits.

Codominance and incomplete dominance

Complete dominanceIncomplete dominanceCodominanceRR × rr → Rrheterozygote looks likethe dominant homozygoteRR × WW → RWheterozygote is a blend(pink from red and white)RR × WW → RWheterozygote shows bothphenotypes at once
Figure 5.5a In complete dominance the heterozygote shows the dominant phenotype. In incomplete dominance neither allele masks the other, and the heterozygote is a blend. In codominance both alleles are expressed fully, so the heterozygote has a phenotype different from either homozygote.
Required content · EK 5.4.A.1 (ii and iii)
  • Codominance occurs when the phenotype from both alleles is expressed such that the heterozygote would have a different phenotype than either homozygote.
  • Incomplete dominance occurs when neither allele of a gene can mask the other, so the phenotype of the heterozygote is a blended version of the dominant and recessive phenotypes.

In complete dominance, the heterozygote looks like the dominant homozygote. In incomplete dominance, the heterozygote has an intermediate phenotype. In snapdragons, a red-flowered (RR) plant crossed to a white-flowered (WW) plant gives all pink (RW) offspring. The pink plants were not produced by “blending” of the alleles themselves: if two pink plants are crossed, the red and white phenotypes reappear in the F2 in the ratio 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white. This is the same 1 : 2 : 1 as the genotypic ratio, because each genotype now has its own phenotype. In codominance, both alleles are fully expressed in the heterozygote. In the human ABO blood group, the alleles IA and IB code for different carbohydrate markers on red blood cells, and a heterozygote (IAIB) makes both, so the blood type is AB. A roan cow with both red and white hairs is another example. Do not confuse the two: incomplete dominance gives a blend, and codominance shows both phenotypes separately.

The ABO group also shows multiple alleles: there are three alleles in the population (IA, IB, and i), though each person has only two. IA and IB are both dominant to i, so type A is IAIA or IAi, type B is IBIB or IBi, type AB is IAIB, and type O is ii.

Worked example · Incomplete dominance and blood types

(a) Two pink snapdragons are crossed. Predict the number of red, pink, and white offspring among 400. (b) A mother with blood type A (IAi) and a father with blood type B (IBi) have children. List the possible blood types and their probabilities. (c) A mother with type O and a father with type AB are told that their child has type O. Evaluate.

(a) RW × RW gives \(1/4\) RR, \(1/2\) RW, \(1/4\) WW. Of 400: \(100\) red, \(200\) pink, \(100\) white (a 1 : 2 : 1 ratio, because each genotype has its own phenotype).
(b) The gametes are IA or i from the mother and IB or i from the father. The four equally likely combinations are IAIB (type AB), IAi (A), IBi (B), and ii (O): each blood type has a probability of \(1/4\).
(c) The father (IAIB) can give only IA or IB, and the mother (ii) can give only i. The possible children are type A (IAi) or type B (IBi), so a type O child is impossible: the man cannot be the biological father (unless there was an error in the test).

Pleiotropy

Required content · EK 5.4.A.3

Pleiotropy is a phenomenon in which the expression of a single gene results in multiple traits or effects; these traits therefore do not segregate independently.

One gene can have many effects, because a protein can be used in more than one place in the body. The best-known example is sickle-cell disease. A single change in the gene for the β-globin chain of hemoglobin makes the hemoglobin form long fibers when oxygen is low. The result is a set of effects that seem unrelated: red blood cells bend into a sickle shape, anemia, blocked small blood vessels, pain, damage to organs such as the spleen and kidneys, and, in heterozygotes, resistance to malaria. All of these come from the same gene, so they are inherited together and do not follow independent assortment with each other. In the exam, if a question describes several traits that always appear together and are caused by one gene, the answer is pleiotropy, not linkage (linkage is for separate genes that are close together).

Non-nuclear inheritance

Mitochondrial trait: maternal inheritanceaffected mother:all children affectedaffected father (II):no children affectedMitochondria come from the egg.
Figure 5.5b Traits determined by mitochondrial or chloroplast DNA are typically maternally inherited: mitochondria are transmitted in the egg and not in the sperm (or ovule and not pollen in plants), so only the mother passes on the trait.
Required content · EK 5.4.A.4
  • Some traits result from non-nuclear inheritance.
  • Chloroplasts and mitochondria are randomly assorted to gametes and daughter cells; thus, traits determined by chloroplast and mitochondrial DNA do not follow simple Mendelian rules.
  • In animals, mitochondria are usually transmitted by the egg and not by sperm; thus, traits determined by the mitochondrial DNA are typically maternally inherited.
  • In plants, mitochondria and chloroplasts are transmitted in the ovule and not in the pollen; as such, mitochondria-determined and chloroplast-determined traits are typically maternally inherited.

Mitochondria and chloroplasts have their own small circular DNA (lesson 2.10, endosymbiosis). Their genes are not on the nuclear chromosomes, so they are not separated by meiosis, and they do not follow Mendel’s laws. A cell contains many mitochondria, and when it divides they are distributed at random to the daughter cells, so the proportion of mutated mitochondria can differ between offspring. A sperm contributes almost only its nucleus to the zygote, and the egg provides nearly all of the cytoplasm, including the mitochondria, so the mitochondrial genes come from the mother. In a pedigree the signature is: an affected mother passes the trait to all of her children (sons and daughters), and an affected father passes it to none. An example in humans is a group of mitochondrial diseases that affect the muscles and nerves, which require much energy. A plant example is the variegated four-o’clock (Mirabilis jalapa): the color of a seedling’s leaves (green, white, or variegated) depends on the chloroplasts in the ovule of the branch that produced the seed, whatever pollen was used.

Extensions that appear in data questions

Two more patterns are outside the list of required knowledge, but they appear often in exam data sets because they change a ratio in a way that you can work out. In epistasis, one gene masks or changes the expression of a different gene. In Labrador retrievers, one gene determines the color of the pigment (B black, b chocolate) and a second gene decides whether the pigment is deposited in the fur (E deposits, ee does not and the dog is yellow, whatever its B genotype). A cross of two BbEe dogs gives 9 black : 3 chocolate : 4 yellow, a modified form of 9:3:3:1 in which two of the classes are combined. In polygenic inheritance, many genes add up to determine one trait, such as human height or skin color, which gives a continuous range of phenotypes (a bell curve) instead of discrete classes. Whenever the data show a ratio that is not one of the Mendelian ones, ask which of these patterns could produce it, and then test your idea with a chi-square test (lesson 5.6).

Exam focus
  • Incomplete dominance: heterozygote is a blend, F2 ratio 1 : 2 : 1 (phenotypes). Codominance: heterozygote shows both phenotypes (AB blood type).
  • Multiple alleles (ABO): three alleles in the population, two per person.
  • Pleiotropy: one gene, many traits (sickle-cell). Epistasis: one gene affects the expression of another (9 : 3 : 4). Polygenic: many genes, one continuous trait.
  • Non-nuclear (mitochondria, chloroplasts): maternal inheritance, since the egg supplies the cytoplasm; not Mendelian.
  • When a result does not fit 3:1 or 9:3:3:1, name a pattern that explains it, then support it with the numbers.
Practice
  1. Compare incomplete dominance and codominance with an example of each.
    Show answer

    In incomplete dominance neither allele masks the other and the heterozygote has an intermediate (blended) phenotype, as in pink snapdragons from red × white. In codominance both alleles are expressed fully and separately in the heterozygote, as in the AB blood type (IAIB), where both A and B markers are present.

  2. Two pink snapdragons are crossed and give 80 offspring. Predict the number of each phenotype.
    Show answer

    The ratio is 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white, so 20 red, 40 pink, and 20 white.

  3. A woman with type A blood (IAi) and a man with type A blood (IAi) have a child. Calculate the probability that the child has type O blood.
    Show answer

    Each parent gives i with a probability of 1/2, so the probability of ii (type O) is \(1/2 \times 1/2 = 1/4\).

  4. A single mutation in one gene causes a person to have short fingers, a heart defect, and hearing loss. State the term for this phenomenon and why the three traits are inherited together.
    Show answer

    This is pleiotropy: the gene product affects more than one trait. The three effects are inherited together because they are all caused by the same gene, so they cannot segregate independently.

  5. A mother with a mitochondrial disease has four children, and the father is unaffected. Predict the phenotypes of the children, and then predict the children of an affected father and an unaffected mother.
    Show answer

    All four children of an affected mother are expected to inherit the mitochondrial trait (sons and daughters), since the egg provides the mitochondria. All the children of an affected father and an unaffected mother are expected to be unaffected, because sperm do not contribute mitochondria to the zygote.

  6. In a plant, a cross of a green-leaved female and a white-leaved male produces only green offspring, and the reciprocal cross (white female × green male) produces only white offspring. Explain.
    Show answer

    The trait is determined by genes in the chloroplasts, which are inherited through the ovule (the female parent) and not through the pollen. The offspring therefore always resemble the mother, in both crosses, which is not a Mendelian pattern.

Lesson 5.6 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4 (linkage) and chi-square

Linked genes, gene mapping, and the chi-square test

Mendel’s 9:3:3:1 assumes that two genes are inherited independently. But there are tens of thousands of genes and only 23 pairs of human chromosomes, so many genes must lie on the same chromosome. What happens then? In the early 1900s, Thomas Hunt Morgan’s work with fruit flies showed that such genes tend to be inherited together, and the exceptions turned out to be a ruler for measuring distances along a chromosome. This lesson also introduces the chi-square test, which is the standard way to decide whether the numbers you counted agree with the ratio you expected.

Learning objective · 5.4.A (linked genes) and the skill of chi-square hypothesis testing

Explain deviations from Mendel’s model identified by quantitative analysis, including genetically linked genes and gene mapping.

Linked genes and recombination frequency

Map of one chromosomeTest cross of 1,000 offspringABC12 map units25 map units1 map unit = 1% recombinant offspring(distance between A and B: 12%)AB (parental)440ab (parental)440Ab (recomb.)60aB (recomb.)60(60 + 60) ÷ 1,000 = 12%
Figure 5.6a Genes on the same chromosome are linked and tend to be inherited together. The percent of recombinant offspring in a test cross equals the map distance in map units. Linked genes give far more parental than recombinant offspring, which departs from the 1:1:1:1 ratio of unlinked genes.
Required content · EK 5.4.A.1 and 5.4.A.1.i
  • Patterns of inheritance of many traits do not follow the ratios predicted by Mendel’s laws and can be identified by quantitative analysis, when the observed phenotypic ratios statistically differ from the predicted ratios.
  • Genes located on the same chromosome are referred to as being genetically linked. The probability that these linked genes segregate together during meiosis can be used to calculate the map distance (or map units) between them on a chromosome. This calculation is called gene or genetic mapping.

Genes on the same chromosome travel together through meiosis, because a chromosome is passed on as a unit. If a parent has alleles A and B on one chromosome and a and b on its homolog, the gametes will mostly be AB and ab, the parental types. But crossing over (lesson 5.2) will sometimes occur between the two genes, producing Ab and aB gametes, the recombinant types. The probability that a crossover will happen between two genes depends on the distance between them: genes far apart are separated often, and genes close together are almost never separated. The percent of recombinant offspring is called the recombination frequency:

\[ \text{recombination frequency} = \frac{\text{number of recombinant offspring}}{\text{total offspring}} \times 100\% \]

One percent recombination is defined as one map unit (also called a centimorgan). The best way to measure it is a test cross, in which the parent that is heterozygous for both genes is crossed with a homozygous recessive parent, because every offspring then shows the gamete it received from the heterozygous parent (lesson 5.3). The key signs of linkage in the data are that the two parental classes are much more common than the two recombinant classes, and that the two parental classes are about equal to each other, as are the two recombinant classes. Unlinked genes would give four equal classes (a 1:1:1:1 ratio). The maximum recombination frequency is 50%, which is also what independent assortment gives, so genes that are very far apart on the same chromosome behave as if they were unlinked.

Map distances can be combined to place genes in order. If the distance from gene A to B is 12 map units and from B to C is 25, then A to C is either \(12 + 25 = 37\) (if B is in the middle) or \(25 - 12 = 13\) (if A is in the middle). A third measurement tells you the order. Morgan’s student Alfred Sturtevant used this reasoning to make the first genetic map in 1913.

Worked example · Morgan’s test cross in Drosophila

A female fruit fly that is heterozygous for body color (gray b+ is dominant to black b) and wing length (long vg+ is dominant to vestigial vg), with the dominant alleles on one chromosome and the recessive alleles on the other, was crossed with a black, vestigial male. Of 2,300 offspring: 965 gray, long; 944 black, vestigial; 206 black, long; 185 gray, vestigial. (a) Which classes are parental and which are recombinant? (b) Calculate the map distance. (c) Test whether the genes assort independently.

(a) The two most common classes, gray-long (965) and black-vestigial (944), have the combinations of the parent’s chromosomes, so they are parental. Black-long (206) and gray-vestigial (185) have new combinations: they are recombinants.
(b) Recombination frequency \(= (206 + 185)/2{,}300 \times 100 = 391/2{,}300 \times 100 = 17.0\%\). The genes are 17 map units apart.
(c) If the genes were on different chromosomes, the expected ratio would be 1 : 1 : 1 : 1, or \(2{,}300/4 = 575\) in each class. The chi-square value (see below) is \(\chi^2 = (965-575)^2/575 + (944-575)^2/575 + (206-575)^2/575 + (185-575)^2/575 = 576{,}522/575 = 1{,}002.6\), far above the critical value of 7.815 (df = 3). The null hypothesis of independent assortment is rejected: the genes are linked.
Reasoning. The parental classes make up \(1{,}909/2{,}300 = 83\%\) of the offspring, much more than the 50% expected for independent assortment. The 17% recombinants are the result of crossing over between the genes in prophase I.

The chi-square test

0.00.10.202468101214chi-square value (df = 3)critical value 7.8155% of the area:reject the nullfail to reject(95% of the area)
Figure 5.6b For a chi-square goodness-of-fit test, a calculated value larger than the critical value for the degrees of freedom (here 7.815 for df = 3 at p = 0.05) falls in the rejection region: the observed counts differ from the expected counts by more than chance would usually allow.

Real counts never match the predicted ratio exactly: a 3:1 ratio does not give exactly 750 to 250 in 1,000 offspring, because of chance. The question is whether the difference is small enough to be a chance effect, or large enough to mean that the hypothesis is wrong. The chi-square goodness-of-fit test answers it.

\[ \chi^2 = \sum \frac{(o - e)^2}{e} \]

where \(o\) is the observed count in a category and \(e\) is the expected count (from the ratio and the total). The steps are:

  1. State the null hypothesis \(H_0\): there is no difference between the observed and the expected results; any difference is due to chance (for example, the genes assort independently).
  2. Calculate the expected count for each category: the total times the fraction predicted by the hypothesis.
  3. Calculate \((o - e)^2 / e\) for each category and add them to give \(\chi^2\).
  4. Find the degrees of freedom: \(df = \) (number of categories) \(- 1\).
  5. Compare \(\chi^2\) with the critical value for that \(df\) at \(p = 0.05\) (given on the exam table): for 1, 2, 3, 4 degrees of freedom the values are 3.84, 5.99, 7.81, 9.49.
  6. If \(\chi^2\) is greater than the critical value (the \(p\)-value is below 0.05), reject \(H_0\); the difference is statistically significant. If it is less than or equal to the critical value, you fail to reject \(H_0\): the data are consistent with the hypothesis (you cannot say that the hypothesis is proved).
Worked example · Mendel’s dihybrid cross

Mendel crossed plants that were heterozygous for seed shape (round R dominant) and seed color (yellow Y dominant) and counted 556 offspring: 315 round yellow, 108 round green, 101 wrinkled yellow, and 32 wrinkled green. Test the hypothesis that the genes assort independently (9:3:3:1).

PhenotypeObserved (o)Expected (e)(o − e)² / e
Round, yellow315312.750.016
Round, green108104.250.135
Wrinkled, yellow101104.250.101
Wrinkled, green3234.750.218
Total556556\(\chi^2 = 0.470\)

Expected. \(556 \times 9/16 = 312.75\); \(556 \times 3/16 = 104.25\) (twice); \(556 \times 1/16 = 34.75\).
Chi-square. The sum is \(0.016 + 0.135 + 0.101 + 0.218 = 0.470\).
Degrees of freedom. There are 4 categories, so \(df = 3\); the critical value at \(p = 0.05\) is 7.815.
Conclusion. \(0.470 \lt 7.815\), so we fail to reject the null hypothesis. The observed numbers do not differ significantly from a 9:3:3:1 ratio, and the differences are consistent with chance. The data support independent assortment of the two genes. (Rejecting the null in the Drosophila example is what showed that those genes were linked.)

Exam focus
  • Linked genes (same chromosome): parental types are more common than recombinants; test cross ratio not 1:1:1:1. Recombination frequency = recombinants / total × 100% = map units. Maximum 50%.
  • Chi-square: \(\chi^2 = \sum (o - e)^2/e\); \(df =\) categories − 1; compare with the critical value at \(p = 0.05\).
  • \(\chi^2\) > critical: reject \(H_0\) (significant difference). \(\chi^2\) ≤ critical: fail to reject \(H_0\) (consistent with chance). Do not say “accept” or “prove.”
  • Always use counts, not percentages, for \(o\) and \(e\). Compute \(e\) from the total and the ratio.
  • Write the conclusion about the biology (linked or independent), not only the statistics.
Practice
  1. A test cross of 1,000 offspring gives 440 AB, 440 ab, 60 Ab, and 60 aB. Calculate the map distance between the genes, and state which classes are recombinants.
    Show answer

    The recombinants are Ab and aB: \((60 + 60)/1{,}000 \times 100 = 12\%\), so the genes are 12 map units apart.

  2. In a monohybrid cross, 792 offspring show the dominant phenotype and 208 the recessive. Test the 3:1 hypothesis at \(p = 0.05\) (df = 1, critical value 3.84).
    Show answer

    Expected: 750 and 250. \(\chi^2 = (792-750)^2/750 + (208-250)^2/250 = 1{,}764/750 + 1{,}764/250 = 2.352 + 7.056 = 9.41\). Since \(9.41 \gt 3.84\), reject the null hypothesis: the results differ significantly from a 3:1 ratio.

  3. State the null hypothesis for a chi-square test of a dihybrid cross and explain what a calculated \(\chi^2\) of 2.1 (df = 3) means.
    Show answer

    The null hypothesis is that the genes assort independently and the observed counts do not differ from a 9:3:3:1 ratio except by chance. A value of 2.1 is below the critical value of 7.815, so we fail to reject the null hypothesis: the data are consistent with independent assortment.

  4. Explain why two genes that are 50 map units apart on the same chromosome behave as if they were on different chromosomes.
    Show answer

    If the genes are far apart, there is almost always at least one crossover between them, so the recombinant and parental gametes are made in equal numbers. The recombination frequency is 50%, the same as for independent assortment, and the test cross gives a 1:1:1:1 ratio.

  5. The map distances are A to B 8, B to C 5, and A to C 13. Give the order of the genes.
    Show answer

    The order is A, B, C, with B in the middle, since the distance from A to C (13) is the sum of the other two (\(8 + 5 = 13\)).

  6. A student calculated \(\chi^2\) using percentages (75 and 25) instead of counts for 80 offspring (62 dominant, 18 recessive). Explain the error and calculate the correct value (df = 1).
    Show answer

    The formula uses the number of individuals, because the size of the sample determines how likely a difference is to be due to chance. With counts: expected 60 and 20; \(\chi^2 = (62-60)^2/60 + (18-20)^2/20 = 0.067 + 0.200 = 0.267\). This is less than 3.84, so we fail to reject the 3:1 hypothesis.

Lesson 5.7 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.5

Environmental effects on phenotype

Identical twins have the same genotype, yet after years of different diets, sun exposure, and habits, they can differ in height, weight, and skin. A hydrangea bush bears blue flowers in acidic soil and pink flowers in alkaline soil, although every cell has the same DNA. A genotype is a set of instructions, but how the instructions are carried out depends on the conditions in which the organism develops. This lesson explains this idea, which finishes the story of heredity in unit 5.

Learning objective · 5.5.A

Explain how the same genotype can result in multiple phenotypes under different environmental conditions.

Phenotype = genotype + environment

Required content · EK 5.5.A.1

Environmental conditions influence gene expression and can lead to phenotypic plasticity (for example, the ability of individual genotypes to produce different phenotypes).

The phenotype is not fixed by the genotype alone. Environmental conditions such as temperature, light, nutrition, and chemical signals can change which genes are expressed, when, and how much (the regulation of gene expression is the subject of unit 6). Because of this, one genotype can produce several phenotypes, and the ability to do so is called phenotypic plasticity. Plasticity is often an adaptation: an organism that can change in response to its surroundings is better able to survive in a changing environment.

01020304050cool (15 °C)moderate (22 °C)warm (29 °C)Growing temperaturePlant height (cm)Genotype 1Genotype 2
Figure 5.7a The same genotype can produce different phenotypes in different environments (phenotypic plasticity). Here each genotype is a different line; the two genotypes also respond differently to temperature (illustrative values).

The graph shows the idea with illustrative data. Plants of one genotype grown at three temperatures have three different heights, so the line is not flat. A second genotype responds differently, and the lines cross: at a cool temperature genotype 1 is taller, and at a warm temperature genotype 2 is taller. This shows that both the genotype and the environment matter, and that they can interact. Genes set a range of possible phenotypes, and the environment decides where in the range an individual ends up.

Worked example · Analyzing a plasticity data set

Use the graph: genotype 1 grows 20, 30, and 34 cm at 15, 22, and 29 °C; genotype 2 grows 12, 22, and 40 cm. (a) Calculate the percent increase in height from 15 to 29 °C for each genotype. (b) Calculate the average rate of change in cm per °C. (c) State which genotype is more plastic, and which genotype is taller at 22 °C. (d) Explain what the data show about genes and environment.

(a) Genotype 1: \((34 - 20)/20 \times 100 = 70\%\). Genotype 2: \((40 - 12)/12 \times 100 = 233\%\).
(b) The temperature change is \(29 - 15 = 14\) °C. Genotype 1: \(14/14 = 1.0\) cm/°C. Genotype 2: \(28/14 = 2.0\) cm/°C.
(c) Genotype 2 is the more plastic (its height changes more with the temperature, 233% compared with 70%). At 22 °C genotype 1 is taller (30 cm compared with 22 cm).
(d) The same genotype has different phenotypes at different temperatures, which shows that the environment affects the phenotype. The genotypes also differ from each other at every temperature, and respond differently to temperature, so genes and environment interact. Because the ranking of the genotypes reverses between 22 and 29 °C, it is not enough to say that one genotype “is taller”: you must specify the environment.

Examples from the CED

  • Height and weight in humans. Genes set a range for height, but nutrition and health in childhood affect the height reached, and body weight depends on diet and exercise as well as on genes. This is why heights of populations have increased as nutrition has improved, over a few generations, while the gene pool has not changed much.
  • Flower color based on soil pH. In hydrangeas, aluminum ions in acidic soil combine with the pigment and give blue flowers; in neutral or alkaline soil aluminum is not available and the flowers are pink. Cuttings of one plant can have different colors in different soils.
  • Seasonal fur color in arctic animals. The arctic fox and the snowshoe hare grow a brown or gray coat in summer and a white coat in winter. The change in day length and temperature changes the expression of the genes for pigment, so the same animal is camouflaged in both seasons. (The Himalayan rabbit and the Siamese cat show a related effect: the enzyme that makes the dark pigment is temperature sensitive and is active only in the cooler extremities, so the ears, paws, tail, and nose are dark.)
  • Sex determination in reptiles. In many turtles and in alligators, the sex of the offspring depends on the temperature at which the eggs are incubated, not on sex chromosomes. In some turtles warm nests produce females, and in alligators warm nests produce males.
  • Effect of increased UV on melanin production in animals. Exposure to UV light causes skin cells to make more of the pigment melanin (a tan), which protects the cells’ DNA. The genotype is unchanged, but the gene is expressed more.
  • Presence of the opposite mating type on pheromone production in yeast and other fungi. A yeast cell makes mating pheromone, a signal (lesson 4.1), when it detects the signal of a cell of the opposite mating type. This is a response of gene expression to a chemical signal from the environment.

Why this matters: heritability and the limits of genes

Two consequences follow. First, a difference between two organisms is not always genetic: to decide whether a trait is inherited, you have to compare organisms in the same environment (or the same genotype in different environments). The classic design is the one in the worked example: grow genetically identical individuals, such as cuttings or inbred lines, under different conditions, and measure the difference. Any difference between them must be due to the environment. Second, a trait can be acquired by an individual without being inherited. A body builder’s muscles are the result of exercise and are not passed to the children: only changes to the DNA of the gametes are inherited. (Natural selection (unit 7) can act only on the variation that is inherited.)

Exam focus
  • Same genotype, different phenotype in different environments = phenotypic plasticity. The environment affects gene expression.
  • Examples to know: height and nutrition, hydrangea and soil pH, seasonal coat color, temperature-dependent sex determination in reptiles, UV and melanin, pheromones in yeast.
  • To show an environmental effect, hold the genotype constant and vary the environment (cuttings, clones, inbred lines).
  • An acquired trait is not inherited; only changes in the DNA of the gametes are.
  • In an explanation use both words: “the genotype sets the range, and the environment affects which genes are expressed.”
Practice
  1. Define phenotypic plasticity and give one example.
    Show answer

    Phenotypic plasticity is the ability of one genotype to produce different phenotypes under different environmental conditions. Example: a hydrangea has blue flowers in acidic soil and pink flowers in alkaline soil, although the DNA is the same.

  2. Identical twins raised apart differ in height by 6 cm. Explain whether this could be due to genes.
    Show answer

    It could not be due to the genotype, because identical twins have the same genes. The difference must be caused by environmental factors such as nutrition and health, which influenced the expression of the genes for growth.

  3. An arctic hare has brown fur in summer and white fur in winter. Describe how the same genotype produces two phenotypes, and the advantage.
    Show answer

    Changes in day length and temperature change the expression of genes for pigment production, so the fur is brown when the days are long and warm and white when they are short and cold. The same animal is camouflaged against both the summer ground and the winter snow, which reduces predation.

  4. A researcher grows 20 cuttings from one plant in two soils (10 per soil) and measures 14 cm and 22 cm mean height. Calculate the percent difference and state what the data show.
    Show answer

    \((22 - 14)/14 \times 100 = 57\%\) taller in the second soil. Because the cuttings are genetically identical, the difference is caused by the environment (the soil), which demonstrates phenotypic plasticity.

  5. A female alligator’s eggs are incubated at two temperatures and the percent of males is 5% at the cooler and 95% at the warmer temperature. Describe what the data show, and explain why this is not like sex determination in humans.
    Show answer

    The sex of the offspring depends on the incubation temperature, so the same genotype can produce males or females under different conditions. In humans the sex is determined by the sex chromosomes the zygote receives (XX or XY) and is not affected by the temperature.

  6. A student claims that a person who gains muscle through exercise will pass on stronger muscles to their children. Evaluate the claim.
    Show answer

    The claim is incorrect. Muscle gain from exercise is an effect of the environment on gene expression in body cells, and does not change the DNA in the gametes. Only changes in the DNA that are in the gametes can be inherited.

Unit 5 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 5 quiz: Heredity

Fifteen multiple-choice questions and five short free-response questions covering meiosis, the three sources of genetic diversity, Mendelian crosses and chi-square, non-Mendelian patterns and environmental effects, and sex-linked, chromosomal, and extranuclear inheritance: click an option to see why each answer works or fails, and write each FRQ on paper before you open the model response.

Multiple choice

  1. Figure: a dividing cell from an organism with 2n = 6, drawn from a light micrograph.

    Six chromosomes, each clearly made of two sister chromatids, lie across the middle of the cell. They are arranged as three side-by-side pairs, so the row is three units long rather than six. Spindle fibers reach each chromosome from one pole only, and the two members of each pair are attached to opposite poles. No nuclear envelope is visible.

    The cell shown is in which stage of division?

    Correct. Three side-by-side pairs of replicated chromosomes are three tetrads, which is what a 2n = 6 cell makes, and the one-pole attachment per chromosome is the arrangement that lets whole homologs, not chromatids, be pulled apart in anaphase I.

    Metaphase II follows the reduction division, so each cell would hold only three replicated chromosomes, not six, and they would line up singly with fibers from both poles. Counting the chromatids in the figure gives twelve, twice what a haploid cell in meiosis II contains.

    In anaphase I the homologs have already separated and are moving toward opposite poles, so the chromosomes would be in two groups away from the equator. Here everything is still aligned in a single row at the center, which defines a metaphase, not an anaphase.

    Mitotic metaphase in a 2n = 6 cell would show six replicated chromosomes lined up singly, six units long, with spindle fibers from both poles attached to each centromere. The figure shows paired chromosomes with one-pole attachment, which mitosis never produces because it does not pair homologs at all.

  2. Data: chromosome and DNA content of one grasshopper cell (2n = 10) as it proceeds through meiosis, measured at four points.

    Per cellEnd of G1End of G2End of meiosis IEnd of meiosis II
    Chromosomes10105?
    DNA (pg)6.012.06.0?

    Which pair of values correctly completes the final column?

    The DNA value is right but the chromosome count is not: the diploid number is restored only at fertilization, never by a meiotic division. Meiosis II separates sister chromatids within an already haploid cell, so the count stays at 5 and cannot climb back to 10.

    The chromosome count is right and the DNA value is not. Anaphase II pulls the two chromatids of each chromosome apart into different cells, so the 6.0 pg held by a cell at the end of meiosis I is divided between two products, giving 3.0 pg each.

    Correct. Meiosis II is an equational division: chromosome number stays at 5 because each chromosome keeps its single centromere, while the DNA halves from 6.0 to 3.0 pg as the chromatids separate. Check the bookkeeping: four products at 3.0 pg account for the 12.0 pg present at the end of G2.

    Chromosomes are counted as whole physical structures, so a fractional chromosome number is not possible. This choice comes from halving both rows again, as though a third division followed; meiosis is exactly two divisions after one round of replication.

  3. Which event occurs during meiosis I but never during mitosis?

    Nuclear envelope breakdown, spindle assembly, and reassembly at telophase occur in mitosis and in both meiotic divisions. Shared machinery like this is common in distractors because it is true: it just does not answer the question being asked.

    Sister chromatids separate in mitotic anaphase and again in anaphase II, so this is the one event the two processes share most obviously. It is also precisely what does not happen in anaphase I, where the chromatids stay joined while the homologs are pulled apart.

    Both processes are preceded by a single S phase that doubles the DNA; that is why a meiotic cell needs two divisions to reach the haploid amount. Replication is the shared setup, not the distinguishing step.

    Correct. Synapsis pairs the two homologs into a tetrad and crossing over swaps segments between non-sister chromatids, and neither happens in mitosis, where homologs behave as unrelated chromosomes. That pairing is also what makes the reduction to haploid possible in the first place.

  4. Data: offspring of a test cross in tomato. An F1 plant heterozygous for stem height and fruit skin was crossed to a dwarf, peach-skinned plant, and 1,400 offspring were scored.

    Offspring phenotypeTall, smoothDwarf, peachTall, peachDwarf, smooth
    Number6216049877

    What is the map distance between the two loci?

    This is \(77/1400\), only one of the two recombinant classes. A single crossover between the loci produces both reciprocal products in roughly equal numbers, so 98 and 77 must be added before dividing by the total.

    Correct. The two frequent classes are parental, so the recombinants are \(98 + 77 = 175\) out of 1,400, and \(175/1400 \times 100\% = 12.5\%\), which by definition is 12.5 map units. The near-equality of 98 and 77 is the sign that both came from the same crossover event.

    This doubles the recombination frequency, a step that has no justification: one map unit is defined as 1% recombinant offspring, with no factor of two. The doubling error usually comes from thinking each crossover involves two chromatids and therefore needs correcting.

    Unlinked genes give a 1:1:1:1 test-cross ratio, which here would be four classes of 350. Instead two classes hold 1,225 of the 1,400 offspring, so the alleles are traveling together far more often than chance allows and the genes must be linked.

  5. In a human primary oocyte, the sister chromatids of chromosome 21 fail to separate during meiosis II. Which statement best describes the four products of that meiosis?

    A product with two copies of chromosome 21 has 24 chromosomes, not 23: adding a chromosome changes the count. This choice confuses an extra chromosome with an extra chromatid, which is the distinction anaphase II actually resolves.

    No meiotic product is diploid. Meiosis II separates chromatids within cells that are already haploid, so the products range from 22 to 24 chromosomes; a 46-chromosome cell would require both divisions to be skipped.

    This is the outcome of nondisjunction in meiosis I, where both homologs go to the same pole and every downstream cell inherits the mistake. A meiosis II error happens after the two cells have already separated, so only one of them can be affected.

    Correct. The cell that divides normally yields two products with 23 chromosomes; the cell whose chromatids fail to separate yields one product with both copies of chromosome 21 (24 chromosomes) and one missing it entirely (22). Half the products are normal, which is the signature of a meiosis II error.

  6. Description of a karyotype prepared from cultured cells of a newborn and arranged by chromosome size.

    Forty-five chromosomes are present. Twenty-two matched autosomal pairs are arranged in order; no autosome appears in one copy or in three. There is a single X chromosome and no second sex chromosome.

    Which statement about this karyotype is best supported?

    Correct. Notation 45,X arises when a gamete that received no sex chromosome, from nondisjunction in either meiotic division, fertilizes or is fertilized by a normal gamete. Only X chromosomes beyond the first are condensed into Barr bodies, so a cell with a single X has none.

    X inactivation silences every X past the first, not the only X a cell has: a typical XX female cell shows one Barr body and a typical XY cell shows none. Silencing the lone X here would leave the cell with no expressed copy of hundreds of essential genes.

    Gaining a chromosome would raise the total above 46, not lower it to 45. The count is odd because one chromosome is absent, which is what makes 45,X a monosomy rather than a trisomy.

    Trisomy 21 would show three copies of chromosome 21 and a total of 47, and the description states explicitly that every autosome is present as a matched pair. The missing chromosome here is a sex chromosome, so the nondisjunction involved the X–Y pair or the two X chromatids.

  7. Data: F2 phenotypes from a monohybrid cross in peas, with the counts expected under a 3:1 ratio.

    PhenotypeTallDwarfTotal
    Observed7922081,000
    Expected (3:1)7502501,000

    Using \(\chi^{2} = \sum (o-e)^{2}/e\) and the critical value 3.841, which conclusion is best supported?

    Correct. The terms are \((792-750)^{2}/750 = 1764/750 = 2.352\) and \((208-250)^{2}/250 = 1764/250 = 7.056\), summing to 9.408. Two phenotype classes give \(df = 1\), and 9.41 exceeds 3.841, so the null hypothesis of a 3:1 ratio is rejected.

    The chi-square value is computed correctly but the degrees of freedom are not: \(df\) is the number of phenotype classes minus one, and there are two classes here, not four. Using 7.815 flips a rejection into a non-rejection, which is why counting classes first is worth the five seconds.

    This is what you get by dividing the raw deviation by the expected value instead of the squared deviation: \(42/750 + 42/250 = 0.224\). Squaring is what makes the statistic insensitive to the direction of the deviation and puts it on the scale the critical values were built for.

    A chi-square test never proves anything, and rejecting a 3:1 ratio does not implicate segregation specifically. Reduced viability of one genotype, a second gene affecting height, or a scoring bias would all produce this result, so the honest conclusion names the ratio, not the mechanism.

  8. In the cross AaBbCc × AaBbcc, with all three genes unlinked, what is the probability that an offspring shows the dominant phenotype for gene A and the recessive phenotypes for genes B and C?

    This multiplies \(3/4 \times 3/4 \times 1/4\), which is the probability of dominant A, dominant B, and recessive C. Reading which gene needs the recessive phenotype is half the work in these items; the stem asks for recessive at both B and C.

    This uses \(1/4\) for the C gene, as if both parents were Cc. The second parent is cc and contributes only c, so a Cc × cc cross gives \(1/2\) recessive offspring, not \(1/4\).

    Correct. Treat each gene separately and multiply: \(Aa \times Aa\) gives \(3/4\) dominant, \(Bb \times Bb\) gives \(1/4\) bb, and \(Cc \times cc\) gives \(1/2\) cc, so \(3/4 \times 1/4 \times 1/2 = 3/32\), about 9.4%. The product rule gets this in seconds; a 32-box grid does not.

    This is \(1/4 \times 1/4\), the answer for recessive at A and B with the C gene ignored altogether. Every gene named in the stem has to appear as a factor, even when its probability is \(1/2\) rather than \(1/4\).

  9. A breeder has a purple-flowered plant and needs to know whether it is PP or Pp, where purple is dominant to white. Which cross settles the question, and what result identifies a heterozygote?

    Correct. A test cross to the homozygous recessive contributes only p, so each offspring's phenotype reports the allele it received from the unknown parent. A Pp plant donates p half the time, giving about 20 white offspring in 40; a PP plant donates P every time and gives none.

    A PP partner donates P to every offspring, so every offspring has at least one dominant allele and all of them are purple whatever the unknown plant is. A cross that gives the same result for both hypotheses cannot distinguish them.

    Selfing does work in principle, but the interpretation here is backwards: a Pp plant selfed gives about \(1/4\) white offspring, so 40 purple offspring point toward PP, not Pp. The test cross is preferred because it produces a 1:1 split, which is easier to detect in a small litter than 3:1.

    White offspring are pp and need a p allele from each parent, so a white offspring shows the plant is Pp: the opposite of what this choice claims. An unknown second parent also leaves the result uninterpretable when no white offspring appear.

  10. Data: coat colors among 160 F2 Labrador retriever puppies from crosses between black F1 dogs of genotype BbEe.

    Coat colorBlackChocolateYellow
    Number of puppies883339

    Which statement best explains why the yellow class is larger than the chocolate class?

    Yellow and chocolate are not alleles of one gene, so no dominance relationship exists between them: yellow is an ee phenotype at one locus and chocolate is a bbE_ phenotype involving both. Treating the three coat colors as three alleles of a single gene is the usual first move here, and it cannot generate a 9:3:4 ratio.

    Correct. Any ee dog fails to deposit pigment in the coat and is yellow no matter what the B gene says, so the \(3/16\) B_ee and \(1/16\) bbee classes merge. Expected counts in 160 puppies are 90 black, 30 chocolate, and 40 yellow, and the observed 88, 33, 39 match closely.

    Linkage changes which allele combinations travel together and would distort the ratio in a test cross, but it cannot merge two phenotype classes into one. The clue that this is epistasis rather than linkage is that the yellow class is exactly the sum of two of the four dihybrid classes.

    Sampling error explains the gap between 39 and the expected 40, not the gap between the chocolate and yellow classes, which is predicted by the model before any puppies are counted. Expected values of 30 and 40 are not equal, so no sample size would make the observed classes converge.

  11. A woman with type O blood has a child with type B blood. She names a man with type AB blood as the father. Which statement is best supported?

    IA and IB are codominant with each other but both are dominant to i, so a child who receives IA from the father and i from the mother is type A, and one who receives IB is type B. Only a child carrying both IA and IB is type AB, which is impossible with an ii mother.

    Blood typing can exclude a man but can never confirm one, because a large share of the population carries the same alleles. Any type AB or type B man in the population would be equally compatible with this child, so the evidence is consistent with him rather than specific to him.

    A type AB man is IAIB and donates one of those two alleles to each child, so half his children by a type O mother are expected to be type B. The exclusion rule works the other way round: an AB man cannot father a type O child, because he carries no i.

    Correct. Work backwards from the child: type B is IBIB or IBi, and since the mother can only supply i, the child is IBi and needs IB from the father. A type AB man has one, so nothing in these data excludes him.

  12. Data: twelve cuttings taken from a single hydrangea plant, rooted and then grown one season in soils adjusted to four pH values, three cuttings per soil.

    Soil pH4.55.56.57.5
    Flower colordeep blueblue-purplepink-purplepink
    Cuttings scored3333

    Which conclusion is best supported by these data?

    Cuttings from one plant are clones, so this conclusion contradicts the design of the investigation rather than following from it. The whole point of using cuttings is to hold the genotype constant so that any variation in phenotype has to come from somewhere else.

    Mutations are random changes in base sequence, not directed responses that happen to produce a useful or matching phenotype in every one of three plants per treatment. A mutagen would also not produce the same color in all three cuttings at each pH, and reversing the color when the plant is moved would be impossible.

    Correct. All twelve plants carry identical DNA, and the only variable that differs among the groups is soil pH, which controls how much aluminum the roots can take up and therefore the color of the pigment complex in the petals. Phenotype is genotype plus environment, and this design isolates the environmental half.

    Incomplete dominance is a relationship between two alleles at one locus, which would require genetically different plants and would give a fixed ratio of colors within one environment. Here the color tracks a measured environmental gradient across clones, which no allele-based model can explain.

  13. Description of a three-generation pedigree for a rare human trait. Squares are males, circles are females, and filled symbols are affected.

    Generation I: I-1, an affected male, is married to I-2, an unaffected female. Their children are II-1, an unaffected female, and II-3, an unaffected male. II-1 married II-2, an unaffected male from outside the family; II-3 married II-4, an unaffected female from outside the family. Generation III: II-1 and II-2 have III-1, an affected male, and III-2, an unaffected female. II-3 and II-4 have III-3, an unaffected male, and III-4, an unaffected female.

    Which mode of inheritance is best supported by this pedigree?

    A dominant allele is expressed in every carrier, so an affected child must have an affected parent. III-1 is affected while both II-1 and II-2 are unaffected, which rules dominance out at once and tells you the allele is recessive.

    A Y-linked allele passes from father to every son and to no daughter, so II-3 would be affected and would pass the trait to III-3. Both are unaffected, and the trait instead reappears through I-1's daughter, which a Y-linked allele can never do.

    Correct. I-1 passes his only X to both daughters, so II-1 is an obligate carrier, and her son III-1 received her Xa with no second X to mask it. The same allele cannot reach III-3 through II-3, because a father gives his son a Y, which is exactly the skipping pattern the pedigree shows.

    Mitochondrial DNA is inherited from the egg alone, so an affected father transmits to none of his children and an affected mother to all of hers. Here the affected individual in generation I is male and his grandson is affected through a daughter, the opposite of maternal transmission.

  14. An X-linked recessive allele has a frequency of \(q = 0.04\) in a large population that mates at random. Approximately what percentage of males and of females are affected?

    This treats the two sexes as equivalent, which is exactly what X-linkage rules out. A male is hemizygous, so one copy of the allele is enough; a female needs two, and those are very different probabilities when \(q\) is small.

    Correct. A male is affected whenever his single X carries the allele, so the frequency is \(q = 0.04\), or 4%. A female needs the allele on both X chromosomes, so the frequency is \(q^{2} = 0.0016\), or 0.16%, and \(0.04/0.0016 = 25\).

    The two values are the right numbers assigned to the wrong sexes. Squaring a frequency below one always makes it smaller, so the rarer outcome, \(q^{2}\), has to belong to the sex that needs two copies, which is the female.

    Nothing in the model doubles the male frequency; having one X means the probability is \(q\) itself, not \(2q\). The factor of two shows up in \(2pq\), the frequency of heterozygous carrier females, which is \(2(0.96)(0.04) = 7.7\%\) here.

  15. Description of a pedigree for a human myopathy that causes exercise intolerance. Squares are males, circles are females, and filled symbols are affected.

    Generation I: I-1, an affected female, married I-2, an unaffected male. All four of their children are affected: II-1 (male), II-2 (female), II-3 (male), and II-4 (female). Generation III: II-1 married an unaffected woman, and neither of their two children is affected. II-2 married an unaffected man, and both of their children are affected.

    Which statement best explains the pattern of transmission in this pedigree?

    An X-linked dominant allele in a heterozygous mother reaches about half her children, not all four, and an affected father would transmit it to every daughter. Here II-1 is affected and has no affected children at all, which no X-linked model allows.

    Correct. Essentially all of a zygote's mitochondria come from the egg's cytoplasm, so every child of an affected mother inherits the mutant organelles while a father contributes none. The pedigree shows exactly that asymmetry: II-2's children are affected and II-1's are not.

    Incomplete penetrance would produce unaffected carriers scattered through the pedigree in both sexes, not a clean split by the sex of the transmitting parent. It also cannot explain why all of an affected mother's children are affected while none of an affected father's are.

    Under X-linked recessive inheritance an affected female passes her allele to every son, so all of I-1's sons would be affected but her daughters would only be carriers, and II-2 is affected, not a carrier. The variable severity mitochondrial disorders show is a better fit for the same data.

Free response

  1. Data: F2 phenotypes from a dihybrid cross in tomato. True-breeding tall, purple-stemmed plants were crossed to true-breeding dwarf, green-stemmed plants; the F1 were all tall and purple-stemmed and were allowed to self-pollinate. 640 F2 plants were scored.

    F2 phenotypeTall, purpleTall, greenDwarf, purpleDwarf, green
    Observed number37111812625

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the null hypothesis being tested by a chi-square analysis of these data, and describe the phenotypic ratio that hypothesis predicts.
    2. Explain why a chi-square test rather than an inspection of the counts is needed to decide whether these data are consistent with independent assortment.
    3. Calculate the chi-square value for these data. Show the expected count for each phenotype class and your setup.
    4. The critical value at \(p = 0.05\) with \(df = 3\) is 7.815. Justify a conclusion about independent assortment of these two genes, using your calculated value as evidence.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the null hypothesis is that the two genes assort independently and the F2 fits a 9:3:3:1 phenotypic ratio, so any deviation from that ratio is due to chance sampling. Do not accept: "the genes are linked" (that is the alternative hypothesis); restating the stem; naming 9:3:3:1 with no statement of what the hypothesis claims.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation that every real sample deviates from its expected ratio by chance, so a decision needs a measure of how large the deviation is relative to what chance alone produces; the test converts the four deviations into one number that can be compared with a threshold. Do not accept: "the numbers look close" or "to be more accurate" with no reasoning; a description of how to compute the statistic instead of why it is needed.
    • (c) Accept: expected counts of \(640 \times 9/16 = 360\), \(640 \times 3/16 = 120\) twice, and \(640 \times 1/16 = 40\); terms 0.336, 0.033, 0.300, and 5.625; \(\chi^{2} = 6.29\) (accept 6.28–6.30). Setup must be shown. Do not accept: a bare number with no expected values; expected counts that do not sum to 640; use of percentages in place of counts.
    • (d) Accept: \(\chi^{2} = 6.29\) is less than 7.815, so we fail to reject the null hypothesis and the data are consistent with independent assortment; the reasoning must name the comparison. Do not accept: "the genes assort independently" stated as proven; "we accept the null hypothesis"; a conclusion with no comparison to the critical value.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The null hypothesis is that the height gene and the stem-color gene assort independently, so the F2 should fall into a 9:3:3:1 ratio of tall purple to tall green to dwarf purple to dwarf green, and any difference from that is just chance.

    b Even if the genes really do assort independently, I would never get exactly 360:120:120:40 in a real sample of 640 plants, because which gametes happen to fuse is random. The chi-square test tells me how big my deviation is compared with the deviations chance alone produces, so I am not just eyeballing whether 25 is "close enough" to 40.

    c Expected: \(640 \times 9/16 = 360\), \(640 \times 3/16 = 120\), \(640 \times 3/16 = 120\), \(640 \times 1/16 = 40\). Terms: \((371-360)^{2}/360 = 0.336\), \((118-120)^{2}/120 = 0.033\), \((126-120)^{2}/120 = 0.300\), \((25-40)^{2}/40 = 5.625\). Adding them, \(\chi^{2} = 6.29\).

    d Since 6.29 is less than the critical value of 7.815 at \(df = 3\), I fail to reject the null hypothesis. Almost all of the statistic comes from the dwarf green class being 15 plants short, and a deviation that size still falls inside the range chance produces, so these data are consistent with the two genes assorting independently.

  2. Description of a pedigree for a rare human metabolic disorder. Squares are males, circles are females, and filled symbols are affected.

    Family 1: I-1, an unaffected male, and I-2, an unaffected female, have three children: II-1, an affected female; II-2, an unaffected male; and II-3, an unaffected female. Family 2: I-3, an unaffected male, and I-4, an unaffected female, have two children: II-4, an affected male, and II-5, an unaffected female. II-2 and II-5 have married; they have no children yet. No one else in either family is affected.

    Using the pedigree, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the mode of inheritance of this disorder, and describe the feature of the pedigree that rules out a dominant allele.
    2. Explain why the pedigree is not consistent with X-linked recessive inheritance.
    3. Calculate the probability that the first child of II-2 and II-5 is affected. Show your setup.
    4. Justify the claim that II-2 and II-5 are at higher risk of having an affected child than a couple chosen at random from the population, using evidence from the pedigree.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: autosomal recessive, supported by affected children born to two unaffected parents in both families (I-1 × I-2 → II-1; I-3 × I-4 → II-4), which means carriers exist and the allele is not expressed in them. Do not accept: naming "recessive" with no evidence; citing only one family; claiming the trait skipped a generation without saying what that implies.
    • (b) Accept: II-1 is an affected female whose father I-1 is unaffected; under X-linked recessive inheritance an affected female must be XaXa and therefore must have received an Xa from her father, who would then be affected himself. Do not accept: "affected individuals are both male and female" alone, which is suggestive but not decisive; any answer that does not use a specific individual.
    • (c) Accept: \(2/3 \times 2/3 \times 1/4 = 4/36 = 1/9 \approx 11\%\), with the \(2/3\) values explained as the probability that an unaffected child of two carriers is a heterozygote. Setup required. Do not accept: \(1/4\) (ignoring the parents' genotype uncertainty); \(1/2 \times 1/2 \times 1/4\) (using \(1/2\) for the carrier probabilities); a bare fraction with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: each of them has an affected full sibling, so both sets of grandparents are obligate carriers and each of II-2 and II-5 is a carrier with probability \(2/3\), far above the carrier frequency for a rare allele in the general population; the named evidence must be the affected siblings. Do not accept: "it runs in the family"; repeating the \(1/9\) figure with no comparison; a claim with no reasoning attached.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a It is autosomal recessive. In both families two unaffected parents have an affected child (I-1 and I-2 have II-1, and I-3 and I-4 have II-4), and a dominant allele has to show up in anyone who carries it, so neither set of parents could have been hiding a dominant allele.

    b It is not X-linked recessive because II-1 is an affected female. She would have to be XaXa, and one of those X chromosomes came from her father I-1, who would then be XaY and affected himself. He is unaffected, so the gene is on an autosome.

    c II-2 is unaffected and his parents are both carriers, so he is \(2/3\) likely to be Aa; the same reasoning gives II-5 a \(2/3\) chance. If both are carriers, \(1/4\) of their children are aa. So \(P = 2/3 \times 2/3 \times 1/4 = 4/36 = 1/9\), about 11%.

    d Both of them have an affected full sibling, which proves all four of their parents carry the allele; that is what makes each of them a \(2/3\) carrier instead of the very low carrier frequency you would expect for a rare recessive allele in the general population. Two \(2/3\) carriers marrying is exactly why the risk climbs to \(1/9\).

  3. Data: a test cross in Drosophila melanogaster. A female heterozygous for two autosomal genes, eye color (wild type dominant to scarlet) and bristle shape (straight dominant to forked), was crossed to a male homozygous recessive for both genes. 1,000 offspring were scored.

    Offspring phenotypeWild eyes, straightScarlet eyes, forkedWild eyes, forkedScarlet eyes, straight
    Number4524485248

    Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the dependent variable in this investigation, and describe the purpose of crossing the heterozygous female to a male that is homozygous recessive for both genes.
    2. Explain how the distribution of the four offspring classes shows that these two genes are not assorting independently.
    3. Calculate the recombination frequency, and convert it to a map distance in map units. Show your setup.
    4. Justify a claim about the two recombinant classes being nearly equal in number, using the mechanism of crossing over as your reasoning.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the dependent variable is the number (or frequency) of offspring in each of the four phenotype classes; the homozygous recessive father contributes only recessive alleles, so every offspring's phenotype reports directly which allele combination the egg carried. Do not accept: naming the variable with no description of the cross's purpose; "the father is the control" with no mechanism; calling eye color alone the dependent variable.
    • (b) Accept: independent assortment predicts four equal classes of about 250 each, but two classes hold 900 of the 1,000 offspring while the other two hold 100, so the parental allele combinations stay together far more often than chance allows, which happens when the loci are on the same chromosome. Do not accept: "the numbers are uneven" with no expected ratio named; asserting linkage with no comparison to 1:1:1:1.
    • (c) Accept: recombinants \(= 52 + 48 = 100\); \(\mathrm{RF} = 100/1000 \times 100\% = 10.0\%\), so the genes are 10 map units apart. Do not accept: using one recombinant class only; doubling the frequency; omitting the conversion statement that 1% recombination equals 1 map unit.
    • (d) Accept: a single crossover between the two loci is a reciprocal exchange between non-sister chromatids, so it produces one chromosome of each recombinant type at the same time, and the two classes should therefore appear in about equal numbers, 52 and 48 differ by an amount chance sampling easily explains. Do not accept: "they are close so it is random"; restating the numbers with no mechanism; attributing the equality to independent assortment.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The dependent variable is the number of offspring falling into each of the four phenotype classes. The father is homozygous recessive for both genes, so he can only donate recessive alleles and never masks anything; that means each offspring's appearance tells me exactly which pair of alleles came in the egg.

    b If these genes were on different chromosomes, independent assortment would give four classes of about 250 each. Instead the wild-straight and scarlet-forked classes together hold 900 flies and the other two hold only 100, so the alleles the mother inherited together are staying together. That happens when both loci sit on the same chromosome and only a crossover can separate them.

    c The recombinants are the two rare classes: \(52 + 48 = 100\) out of 1,000. So \(\mathrm{RF} = 100/1000 \times 100\% = 10.0\%\), and since 1% recombination is defined as one map unit, the genes are about 10 map units apart.

    d A crossover is a reciprocal swap between two non-sister chromatids, so the same event that makes a wild-forked chromosome also makes a scarlet-straight one. The two recombinant classes therefore come out of the same events in equal numbers, and the observed 52 versus 48 is the kind of small gap random sampling of 1,000 flies produces.

  4. An animal has a diploid chromosome number of 2n = 10. Answer (a) through (d) about meiosis in this organism.

    1. Describe one difference between anaphase I and anaphase II in terms of what structures separate and what happens to ploidy.
    2. Explain how crossing over during prophase I increases the genetic variation among gametes beyond what independent assortment alone can produce.
    3. Calculate the number of chromosomally distinct gametes this organism can produce from independent assortment alone, and the number of distinct zygote combinations possible when two such individuals mate. Show your setup.
    4. A mutant of this species cannot assemble the synaptonemal complex, so homologs never synapse and each replicated chromosome attaches to the spindle independently. Predict the fraction of meiosis I products that receive a balanced haploid set, and justify your prediction.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: in anaphase I homologous chromosomes separate while sister chromatids stay attached, and ploidy falls from 2n to n; in anaphase II sister chromatids separate and ploidy stays at n. Do not accept: "chromosomes separate in both" with no distinction; describing only one of the two anaphases; saying meiosis II halves the chromosome number.
    • (b) Accept: independent assortment shuffles whole chromosomes, so each gamete gets one intact maternal or paternal chromosome per pair; crossing over exchanges segments between non-sister chromatids, producing chromosomes that carry maternal alleles at some loci and paternal alleles at others, which are combinations independent assortment cannot make. Do not accept: "it makes more variation" with no mechanism; confusing crossing over with independent assortment; describing crossing over without connecting it to allele combinations.
    • (c) Accept: \(n = 5\), so \(2^{5} = 32\) chromosomally distinct gametes, and \(32 \times 32 = 1{,}024\) zygote combinations. Do not accept: \(2^{10}\) (using the diploid number); \(32 + 32\); an answer with no setup shown.
    • (d) Accept: about \(1/32\) or 3.125%, justified by noting that without synapsis each of the 5 pairs segregates at random, giving each pair a \(1/2\) chance of sending its two homologs to opposite poles, and \((1/2)^{5} = 1/32\) for all five together. Do not accept: "most gametes will be abnormal" with no number; a number with no link between pairing and segregation; the claim that no gametes at all would be balanced.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a In anaphase I whole homologous chromosomes are pulled apart while their sister chromatids stay stuck together at the centromere, and that is the step where the cell goes from 2n to n. In anaphase II the sister chromatids finally separate, and ploidy does not change: the products are still haploid, just with unreplicated chromosomes.

    b Independent assortment only decides which whole chromosome of each pair goes to a pole, so every chromosome in a gamete would be an intact copy from one grandparent. Crossing over swaps segments between non-sister chromatids, so a single chromosome ends up carrying my grandmother's alleles at some loci and my grandfather's at others. Those mixed chromosomes are new combinations that no amount of shuffling whole chromosomes could produce.

    c With 2n = 10, \(n = 5\), so independent assortment gives \(2^{5} = 32\) chromosomally different gametes. Two individuals mating gives \(32 \times 32 = 1{,}024\) zygote combinations.

    d I predict about \(1/32\), or 3.1%, are balanced. Without a synaptonemal complex the homologs never pair, so nothing makes the two members of a pair face opposite poles; each pair segregates correctly by chance with probability \(1/2\), and the five pairs are independent, so \((1/2)^{5} = 1/32\). Everything else is aneuploid, which shows that pairing is what guarantees an even split.

  5. Data: Himalayan rabbits from one inbred, genetically uniform line were raised from weaning at five ambient temperatures, ten rabbits per group. At twelve weeks the percentage of body surface covered by black fur was measured.

    Ambient temperature (°C)515253035
    Black fur (% of body surface)967241120

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Describe the relationship between ambient temperature and the percentage of body surface covered by black fur.
    2. Explain, in terms of the pigment-producing enzyme, why rabbits with identical genotypes differ in coat color across the five groups.
    3. Construct a graph of these data: put ambient temperature in °C on the x-axis with a scale from 0 to 40, put percent black fur on the y-axis with a scale from 0 to 100, label both axes with units, plot the five points, and draw a best-fit line. Then calculate the mean rate of change in percent black fur per degree Celsius between 5 °C and 35 °C.
    4. A student claims that the rabbits raised at 35 °C must carry a different allele of the pigment gene from those raised at 5 °C. Justify a rejection of that claim, using evidence from the investigation.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: as ambient temperature rises the percentage of black fur falls, from 96% at 5 °C to 0% at 35 °C, a negative relationship, with the sharpest drop between 25 °C and 30 °C. Accept a correct statement of the inverse relationship with at least one pair of values cited. Do not accept: "temperature affects fur color" with no direction; restating the table row by row with no trend statement.
    • (b) Accept: all the rabbits carry the same temperature-sensitive form of the pigment-producing enzyme, which folds and functions at cool surface temperatures but denatures above roughly 33 °C, so pigment is deposited only where the skin is cool; warm-reared rabbits keep almost no cool skin, so almost no fur is pigmented. Do not accept: "the cold makes it black" with no enzyme named; "the gene turns off in the heat" with no mechanism; any claim that the genotype changes.
    • (c) Accept: temperature on the x-axis (0–40 °C) and percent black fur on the y-axis (0–100%), both axes labeled with units, all five points plotted correctly, and a best-fit line drawn; plus \((0 - 96)/(35 - 5) = -96/30 = -3.2\) percentage points per °C. Accept 3.2 stated as a decrease. Do not accept: reversed axes; an unlabeled axis or missing units; a rate with no sign or no units; connecting the dots in place of a best-fit line is acceptable only if the line is described as such.
    • (d) Accept: the rabbits come from one inbred, genetically uniform line and were assigned to temperature groups, so genotype was held constant by design and cannot be the source of the difference; the only variable that differed was ambient temperature, so the phenotype difference is environmental. Do not accept: "phenotype equals genotype plus environment" with no reference to this investigation; rejecting the claim with no evidence named; arguing only that alleles cannot change.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The warmer the rabbits were raised, the less black fur they had. Black coverage falls steadily from 96% of the body surface at 5 °C to 0% at 35 °C, and the steepest part of the drop is between 25 °C and 30 °C, where it falls from 41% to 12%.

    b Every rabbit has the same allele for the pigment enzyme, and in this breed that enzyme only works at cool temperatures: above about 33 °C it denatures and stops making pigment. In a cold room most of the skin surface is cool enough for the enzyme to fold properly, so most of the fur grows in black; in a warm room almost no skin is cool enough, so the fur grows in white.

    c I put ambient temperature (°C) on the x-axis from 0 to 40 and percent black fur on the y-axis from 0 to 100, labeled both with units, plotted (5, 96), (15, 72), (25, 41), (30, 12), and (35, 0), and drew a best-fit line through them. Mean rate of change: \((0 - 96)/(35 - 5) = -96/30 = -3.2\) percentage points of black fur per °C.

    d I reject that claim. All fifty rabbits came from one inbred, genetically uniform line, so their pigment-gene alleles are the same before the experiment starts: genotype was controlled by the design. The only thing that differed between the 5 °C and 35 °C groups was the temperature they were raised at, so the difference in coat color has to be environmental, not allelic.

Lesson 6.1 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.1

DNA and RNA structure: the molecules of heredity

Until the 1940s, most biologists believed that heredity was carried by proteins, which seemed complex enough to hold the instructions for a whole organism, while DNA looked too simple, a repeating molecule of four kinds of units. The experiments that overturned this idea, and the discovery of the structure of DNA in 1953, are the starting point for the whole of molecular biology. In this lesson you will see the evidence that DNA is the genetic material, and then how its structure explains how it can store information and be copied.

Learning objectives · 6.1.A and 6.1.B

Describe the structures involved in passing hereditary information from one generation to the next, and describe the characteristics of DNA that allow it to be used as hereditary material.

Evidence that DNA is the genetic material

In 1928 Frederick Griffith injected mice with two strains of the bacterium Streptococcus pneumoniae: the S strain, which has a capsule and kills mice, and the R strain, which has no capsule and is harmless. Heat-killed S bacteria did not harm the mice. But a mixture of live R bacteria and heat-killed S bacteria killed them, and live S bacteria could be recovered from the dead mice. Some “transforming principle” had passed from the dead S cells to the living R cells and changed their heritable traits (transformation). In 1944, Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod, and Maclyn McCarty identified the principle by a process of elimination. They treated the extract from S cells with enzymes that destroy protein, RNA, or DNA. Transformation still occurred after the protein and RNA were destroyed, but not after DNA was destroyed: the transforming principle is DNA.

Phage labeled with 35S(protein coat labeled)supernatantpelletradioactivenot radioactiveprotein stays outside the cells(spun down: cells in the pellet)Phage labeled with 32P(DNA labeled)supernatantpelletnot radioactiveradioactiveDNA enters the bacteria(spun down: cells in the pellet)Conclusion: DNA, not protein, is the genetic material of the phage.
Figure 6.1c In the Hershey-Chase experiment, bacteria infected with phage were blended to remove the phage coats and spun in a centrifuge. Phage protein (35S) stayed in the supernatant; phage DNA (32P) went into the cells in the pellet and directed the production of new phage.

Some scientists still doubted, because the extracts might contain traces of protein. In 1952 Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase settled it with a bacteriophage (a virus that infects bacteria, made of a protein coat and DNA). They grew one batch of phage with radioactive sulfur (35S), which labels protein (proteins contain sulfur in some amino acids, DNA has none), and another with radioactive phosphorus (32P), which labels DNA (the phosphate groups; proteins have little phosphorus). They let each batch infect bacteria, blended the mixture to shear the empty coats off the cells, and spun it in a centrifuge so the heavy bacteria formed a pellet and the lighter coats stayed in the liquid (the supernatant). With 35S most of the radioactivity was in the supernatant: the protein did not enter the cells. With 32P most was in the pellet, inside the bacteria, which went on to make new phage. DNA is what the virus injects, so DNA carries the genetic information.

The structure of nucleic acids

Required content · EK 6.1.A.1 and 6.1.A.2
  • Genetic information is stored in and passed to subsequent generations through DNA molecules and, in some cases, RNA molecules.
  • Prokaryotic organisms typically have circular chromosomes.
  • Eukaryotic organisms typically have multiple linear chromosomes that are comprised of DNA. These chromosomes are condensed using histones and associated proteins.
  • Prokaryotes and eukaryotes can contain plasmids, which are extra-chromosomal circular molecules of DNA.
ProkaryoteEukaryote: DNA packaged with histonescircularchromosomeplasmidusually one circular chromosome;plasmids are extra circles of DNADNA helixnucleosomeschromatinchromosomehistones are proteins that DNA wraps around(beads = histone cores)
Figure 6.1b Prokaryotes typically have a circular chromosome (and often plasmids). Eukaryotes typically have multiple linear chromosomes of DNA, condensed using histones and associated proteins. Plasmids are extra-chromosomal circular DNA molecules that prokaryotes and some eukaryotes can contain.

A bacterium typically has a single circular chromosome of about a few million base pairs, plus smaller plasmids that often carry genes such as antibiotic resistance. A eukaryotic cell has several linear chromosomes in a nucleus. The DNA is very long (the 46 human chromosomes contain about 2 meters of DNA in a nucleus a few micrometers across), so it is wound around histone proteins to form nucleosomes, and then coiled and folded again and again to give chromatin and, in cell division, the condensed chromosomes of lesson 4.5. Some viruses use RNA instead of DNA as their genetic material (lesson 6.4).

Both DNA and RNA are polymers of nucleotides (lesson 1.6). Each nucleotide has a five-carbon sugar (deoxyribose in DNA, ribose in RNA), a phosphate group, and a nitrogenous base. Nucleotides are joined by bonds between the phosphate of one and the sugar of the next, giving a sugar-phosphate backbone with a direction: one end has a free phosphate on the 5′ carbon (the 5′ end) and the other has a free hydroxyl on the 3′ carbon (the 3′ end). This direction matters in everything that follows: new nucleotides are always added at the 3′ end.

DNA: two antiparallel strandsPurines pair with pyrimidines5'3'3'5'ATTAGCCGATGCAGCTpurines: double ring (A, G)pyrimidines: single ring (C, T, U)A pairs with T (U in RNA); G pairs with C
Figure 6.1a Nucleic acids show specific base pairing that is conserved through evolution. Purines (guanine and adenine) have a double ring; pyrimidines (cytosine, thymine, and uracil) have a single ring. Purines pair with pyrimidines: A with T (or U in RNA) and G with C.
Required content · EK 6.1.B.1
  • Nucleic acids exhibit specific nucleotide base pairing that is conserved through evolution.
  • Purines (guanine and adenine) have a double ring structure.
  • Pyrimidines (cytosine, thymine, and uracil) have a single ring structure.
  • Purines pair with pyrimidines: adenine with thymine (or uracil in RNA) and guanine with cytosine.

DNA is a double helix: two strands wind around each other, with the sugar-phosphate backbones on the outside and the bases on the inside. The two strands are antiparallel: one runs 5′ to 3′ and the other 3′ to 5′. The bases are held together by hydrogen bonds: A with T by two, and G with C by three. Every base pair is a purine with a pyrimidine, so the helix has a constant width (a purine pair with a purine would be too wide, a pyrimidine pair with a pyrimidine too narrow). Because of the specific pairing, the sequence of one strand determines the sequence of the other: each strand is the template for a new complementary strand. This single property explains both how DNA is copied (lesson 6.2) and how genes are read (lesson 6.3). RNA differs from DNA in three ways: its sugar is ribose, its base uracil (U) replaces thymine (T), and it is usually single-stranded (although it can fold on itself to give structures such as the loops of tRNA). The ability of RNA to base pair and to fold also lets it act as a catalyst in some cases, such as in the ribosome.

The model of the double helix was built in 1953 by James Watson and Francis Crick, using two sets of evidence: Erwin Chargaff’s rule and the X-ray diffraction images made by Rosalind Franklin (and Maurice Wilkins), which showed that DNA is a helix with a regular repeat. Chargaff had found that in the DNA of any species the amount of A equals the amount of T and the amount of G equals the amount of C, though the ratio of A+T to G+C varies between species. The pairing rule explains Chargaff’s rule.

Worked example · Base composition from Chargaff’s rule

A sample of double-stranded DNA from a bacterium has 22% guanine. (a) Calculate the percent of the other three bases. (b) A second sample has 31% A, 31% T, 19% G, and 19% C, and a third has 24% A, 32% U, 26% G, and 18% C. Identify the type of nucleic acid in each, and justify.

(a) G pairs with C, so \(\%C = \%G = 22\%\). That leaves \(100 - 22 - 22 = 56\%\) for A and T, which are equal: \(\%A = \%T = 28\%\).
(b) The second sample is double-stranded DNA: it contains T, and \(A = T\) and \(G = C\), as expected from base pairing between two strands. The third sample is RNA (it contains U), and it is single-stranded, because \(A \ne U\) and \(G \ne C\): there is no complementary strand to impose equal amounts.
Reasoning. The one-to-one pairing of purines with pyrimidines gives equal numbers of A and T (or U) and of G and C only when both strands are present.

Exam focus
  • Evidence that DNA is the genetic material: Griffith (transformation), Avery, MacLeod, McCarty (DNA is the transforming principle), Hershey-Chase (32P DNA enters the cell; 35S protein stays outside).
  • DNA: deoxyribose, A T G C, double-stranded, antiparallel. RNA: ribose, A U G C, usually single-stranded.
  • Purines (A, G; double ring) pair with pyrimidines (C, T, U; single ring): A-T (U) with two hydrogen bonds, G-C with three.
  • Prokaryotes: circular chromosome and plasmids. Eukaryotes: linear chromosomes packaged with histones.
  • Base pairing means one strand can be used as a template for the other.
Practice
  1. In Hershey and Chase’s experiment, predict where the radioactivity would be found if protein, and not DNA, were the genetic material.
    Show answer

    If protein carried the genetic information, the protein would have to enter the bacteria, so the 35S label would be found in the pellet with the cells, and the 32P label would be found in the supernatant. The results were the opposite, which indicates that DNA is the genetic material.

  2. Explain why 32P labels DNA but not protein, and 35S labels protein but not DNA.
    Show answer

    DNA contains phosphorus (in the phosphate groups of the backbone) but no sulfur, so 32P labels DNA. Many proteins contain sulfur (in the amino acids cysteine and methionine) but very little phosphorus, so 35S labels protein.

  3. A double-stranded DNA sample has 18% thymine. Calculate the percent of each of the other bases.
    Show answer

    A = T = 18%, so A + T = 36%. G + C = 64%, so G = C = 32%.

  4. State two structural differences between DNA and RNA and one structural similarity.
    Show answer

    Differences: DNA has deoxyribose and RNA has ribose; DNA has thymine where RNA has uracil; DNA is usually a double helix, and RNA is usually single-stranded. Similarity: both are polymers of nucleotides, each with a sugar, a phosphate group, and a nitrogenous base, joined in a sugar-phosphate backbone (also both use A, G, and C).

  5. Explain why a purine always pairs with a pyrimidine in DNA.
    Show answer

    A purine has two rings and a pyrimidine has one, so a purine-pyrimidine pair has the same width along the whole helix, three rings across. A purine-purine pair would be too wide, and a pyrimidine-pyrimidine pair too narrow, to fit between the backbones, and the hydrogen bonds could not form properly.

  6. Describe two differences between a bacterial chromosome and a human chromosome.
    Show answer

    A bacterial chromosome is typically a single circular molecule of DNA, not wound around histones in a nucleus; a human chromosome is a linear DNA molecule that is packaged with histones, and there are 46 of them in the nucleus. (Bacteria also often carry plasmids, small circles of extra DNA.)

Lesson 6.2 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.2

DNA replication

Every time a cell divides, it must copy its whole genome, billions of base pairs in humans, with almost no mistakes, and it must do so in hours. Watson and Crick ended their 1953 paper with the understated remark that the base pairing they proposed “suggests a possible copying mechanism.” This lesson describes that mechanism: how the two strands of the double helix serve as templates, what enzymes do the work, and how the experiment of Meselson and Stahl proved the model.

Learning objective · 6.2.A

Describe the mechanisms by which genetic information is copied for transmission between generations.

Semiconservative replication

Required content · EK 6.2.A.1 (i and ii)
  • DNA replication ensures continuity of hereditary information.
  • DNA is synthesized in the 5′ to 3′ direction.
  • Replication is a semiconservative process, meaning one strand of DNA serves as the template for a new strand of complementary DNA.

In semiconservative replication, each of the two new DNA molecules consists of one old (parental) strand and one new strand. The two parental strands separate, and each is used as a template: a nucleotide is added only if its base pairs with the template base (A with T, G with C). Because of this rule, the two molecules produced are identical to the original. There are two other models that were possible in principle: a conservative model, in which the parental double helix stays together and an entirely new double helix is made, and a dispersive model, in which each new molecule is a patchwork of old and new segments.

Generation 0all 15N (heavy)After 1 generationall hybridAfter 2 generations1/2 hybrid, 1/2 lightAfter 3 generations1/4 hybrid, 3/4 lightBands: top = light (14N 14N), middle = hybrid, bottom = heavy (15N 15N). Band width shows the fraction.
Figure 6.2b The Meselson-Stahl results fit the semiconservative model: after one generation all DNA is hybrid (one old strand, one new strand); after two, half is hybrid and half is light; after three, one quarter is hybrid and three quarters are light. A conservative model would have given separate heavy and light bands after one generation.

In 1958, Matthew Meselson and Franklin Stahl tested the three models. They grew E. coli for many generations in a medium with the heavy isotope 15N as the only nitrogen source, so that all the DNA was heavy. They then transferred the bacteria to a medium with ordinary 14N, and took samples after each doubling. DNA was extracted and centrifuged in a cesium chloride gradient, in which molecules form a band at the position where their density equals that of the solution: heavy DNA sinks lower than light DNA, and DNA with one heavy and one light strand (hybrid) is in the middle. After one generation there was a single band at the hybrid position. This result rejected the conservative model, which predicts two bands (one heavy, one light). After two generations there were two bands, one hybrid and one light, which rejected the dispersive model (which predicts a single band that moves gradually toward the light position). Only semiconservative replication fits all the data.

Worked example · Predicting the bands

Predict the fraction of hybrid and light DNA after generations 1 to 4 in the Meselson-Stahl experiment, and the bands that a conservative model would predict after generation 1.

Method. Start with one heavy molecule (two 15N strands). After \(n\) generations there are \(2^n\) molecules. The two original heavy strands are never destroyed, so they are in exactly 2 hybrid molecules, and all the others are light (both strands new, 14N).
Hybrid fraction \(= 2/2^n = 1/2^{n-1}\); light fraction \(= 1 - 1/2^{n-1}\).
Generation 1: \(2\) molecules, hybrid \(2/2 = 100\%\), light 0%. Generation 2: \(4\) molecules, hybrid \(2/4 = 50\%\), light 50%. Generation 3: \(8\) molecules, hybrid \(2/8 = 25\%\), light 75%. Generation 4: \(16\) molecules, hybrid \(2/16 = 12.5\%\), light 87.5%.
Conservative model, generation 1. The old double helix stays heavy, and the new one is light: 50% heavy and 50% light, with no hybrid band.
Check. The hybrid band gets smaller each generation, but it never disappears completely, because the original heavy strands always remain in two molecules.

The replication fork and the enzymes

Replication fork moves to the right3'5'5'3'5'3'HPPThelicase (H)topoisomerase (T)leading strand: continuouslagging strand: Okazaki fragmentsDNA polymerase (P) addsnucleotides to 3' ends onlyorange = RNA primerligase joins the fragments
Figure 6.2a DNA is synthesized only in the 5' to 3' direction. Helicase unwinds the DNA, topoisomerase relaxes supercoiling ahead of the fork, DNA polymerase needs RNA primers, makes the leading strand continuously and the lagging strand discontinuously, and ligase joins the fragments.
Required content · EK 6.2.A.1 (iii to vii)
  • Helicase unwinds the DNA strands.
  • Topoisomerase relaxes supercoiling in front of the replication fork.
  • DNA polymerase requires RNA primers to initiate DNA synthesis.
  • DNA polymerase synthesizes new strands of DNA continuously on the leading strand and discontinuously on the lagging strand.
  • Ligase joins the fragments on the lagging strand.

Exclusion statement: the names of the steps and particular enzymes involved, excluding DNA polymerase, ligase, RNA polymerase, helicase, and topoisomerase, are beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Replication begins at specific sites called origins of replication, where the DNA is opened to form a replication bubble with two replication forks that move in opposite directions. The steps at a fork are as follows.

  1. Helicase unwinds the double helix at the fork by breaking the hydrogen bonds between the strands. As the helix is opened, the DNA ahead of the fork is twisted more tightly (supercoiled), and topoisomerase relieves this strain by cutting and rejoining the DNA.
  2. DNA polymerase cannot start a new strand; it can only add nucleotides to the 3′ end of an existing strand. So an enzyme called primase first makes a short RNA primer that base pairs with the template.
  3. DNA polymerase adds nucleotides to the 3′ end of the primer, using the template to select the base. It works only in the 5′ to 3′ direction, as it reads the template 3′ to 5′.
  4. Because the two template strands are antiparallel, the two new strands cannot both be made in the direction of the fork. On one template, the leading strand, polymerase follows the helicase and makes the new strand continuously. On the other, the lagging strand, polymerase must work away from the fork: it makes a short piece, an Okazaki fragment (about 100 to 200 nucleotides in eukaryotes, 1,000 to 2,000 in bacteria), starting with a new primer each time as more of the template is opened.
  5. Finally, the RNA primers are replaced by DNA, and ligase joins the fragments to make a continuous strand.

DNA polymerase also proofreads: when it adds a wrong nucleotide, it can detect the mismatch, back up, and remove it. Without proofreading, one error is made about every 100,000 nucleotides; with it, about one in 10 million, and other repair systems that check the DNA after replication lower the final error rate to roughly one in a billion (or less). The remaining errors are the source of many mutations (lesson 6.7).

Worked example · Why many origins are needed, and what the ends of linear chromosomes need

(a) The E. coli chromosome has 4.6 million base pairs (4.6 Mb), with one origin and two forks, each moving at about 1,000 nucleotides per second. Estimate the replication time. (b) Human chromosome 1 has about 248 million base pairs. If it were replicated from one origin with two forks that moved at 50 nucleotides per second, estimate the time, and explain how the human cell does it. (c) Each time that a linear chromosome is copied, the lagging-strand end cannot be completely replicated, and about 70 base pairs of the telomere are lost. If a telomere has 10,000 bp at birth and cells stop dividing at 4,000 bp, estimate the number of divisions.

(a) Two forks together copy \(2 \times 1{,}000 = 2{,}000\) nt per second: \(4.6 \times 10^6 / 2{,}000 = 2{,}300\) s, which is about 38 minutes.
(b) \(248 \times 10^6 / (2 \times 50) = 2.48 \times 10^6\) s, which is about 29 days, far too long for a cell cycle of 24 hours. Eukaryotic chromosomes have many origins (tens of thousands in a human cell) that start at different times, so many sections are copied at once.
(c) \((10{,}000 - 4{,}000)/70 = 86\) divisions. This shows how telomeres, repeated sequences at the ends of chromosomes, protect the genes from shortening, and why cells that divide many times, such as stem cells and cancer cells, use the enzyme telomerase to rebuild them (the number is an approximate model).

Exam focus
  • Semiconservative: each new molecule has one old and one new strand (Meselson-Stahl: hybrid band after generation 1; hybrid and light bands after generation 2).
  • Synthesis is always 5′ to 3′; polymerase adds to the 3′ end and needs an RNA primer.
  • Helicase unwinds; topoisomerase relieves supercoiling ahead of the fork; DNA polymerase builds; ligase joins Okazaki fragments.
  • Leading strand: continuous, toward the fork. Lagging strand: discontinuous (Okazaki fragments), away from the fork.
  • For a data question on isotopes: after \(n\) generations the hybrid fraction is \(1/2^{n-1}\).
Practice
  1. Describe what “semiconservative” means, and state the result of the Meselson-Stahl experiment after one generation that supports it.
    Show answer

    Each new DNA molecule has one parental strand and one newly made strand. After one generation all of the DNA was hybrid (one 15N strand and one 14N strand), forming a single band of intermediate density. The conservative model would have given a heavy and a light band.

  2. A template strand reads 3′-TACGGATC-5′. Write the new strand made by DNA polymerase, with its polarity.
    Show answer

    The complementary strand is 5′-ATGCCTAG-3′. It is antiparallel to the template and is made 5′ to 3′.

  3. Explain why the lagging strand is made in fragments.
    Show answer

    DNA polymerase can add nucleotides only to a 3′ end, so it can make DNA only in the 5′ to 3′ direction. On the lagging-strand template this direction is away from the replication fork, so the polymerase has to wait until more of the DNA is unwound and then start a new fragment with a new primer each time. The fragments are joined by ligase.

  4. Predict the effect on replication of a mutation that inactivates DNA ligase.
    Show answer

    The Okazaki fragments of the lagging strand would not be joined, so the lagging strand would have many nicks (breaks) and the new DNA would be fragmented. The leading strand would still be made continuously.

  5. In the Meselson-Stahl experiment, calculate the fraction of light DNA after the fifth generation.
    Show answer

    Hybrid fraction \(= 1/2^{5-1} = 1/16 = 6.25\%\), so the light fraction is \(1 - 1/16 = 15/16 = 93.75\%\).

  6. Describe the role of helicase and the role of topoisomerase, and what would happen at the fork without topoisomerase.
    Show answer

    Helicase unwinds the double helix at the fork by breaking the hydrogen bonds. Topoisomerase relieves the supercoiling (tension) that builds up in the DNA ahead of the fork. Without it, the strain would stop the helicase from advancing, and replication would be blocked or the DNA could break.

Lesson 6.3 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.3

Transcription and RNA processing

The DNA in your nucleus holds the instructions for every protein in your body, but DNA never leaves the nucleus and the proteins are made in the cytoplasm, so the instructions have to be copied and carried. The copy is made of RNA. Francis Crick called the flow of information from DNA to RNA to protein the central dogma. In this lesson you will follow the first step, transcription, and see how a eukaryotic cell edits the copy before it is used.

Learning objective · 6.3.A

Describe the mechanisms by which genetic information flows from DNA to RNA to protein.

Three kinds of RNA

Required content · EK 6.3.A.1

The sequence of the RNA bases, together with the structure of the RNA molecule, determines RNA function.

  • Messenger RNA (mRNA) molecules carry information from DNA in the nucleus to the ribosome in the cytoplasm.
  • Distinct transfer RNA (tRNA) molecules bind specific amino acids and have anticodon sequences that base pair with the codons of mRNA. tRNA is recruited to the ribosome during translation to generate the primary peptide sequence based on the mRNA sequence.
  • Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) molecules are functional building blocks of ribosomes.

mRNA is the message: it is a copy of a gene, and its sequence is read by the ribosome to build a protein. tRNA is the adapter: each tRNA is folded into a compact shape with an anticodon of three bases at one end, which base pairs with an mRNA codon, and a site at the other end that carries the corresponding amino acid. rRNA is a structural and catalytic part of the ribosome: together with proteins, it makes the two ribosomal subunits, and it helps to form the peptide bonds. The function of each type of RNA depends on its sequence and on the three-dimensional shape that the sequence folds into, as with a protein.

Transcription

Transcription: RNA polymerase moves to the right5'3'3'5'RNApolymerase5'3'promoterterminatormRNA 5' to 3'coding strand: 5' to 3'template strand: 3' to 5' (read by polymerase)
Figure 6.3a RNA polymerase uses a single template strand of DNA to direct the inclusion of bases in the new RNA molecule (transcription). It reads the template 3' to 5' and builds the mRNA 5' to 3'.
Required content · EK 6.3.A.2 and 6.3.A.3
  • RNA polymerases use a single template strand of DNA to direct the inclusion of bases in the newly formed RNA molecule. This process is known as transcription.
  • The enzyme RNA polymerase synthesizes mRNA molecules in the 5′ to 3′ direction by reading the template DNA strand in the 3′ to 5′ direction.

Transcription has three stages. In initiation, RNA polymerase binds to a promoter, a DNA sequence at the start of a gene that tells the polymerase where to begin and which strand to read (in eukaryotes, transcription factors must bind first, lesson 6.6). The DNA unwinds, forming a transcription bubble. In elongation, the polymerase moves along the template strand from 3′ to 5′, and adds RNA nucleotides that pair with the template (template A pairs with U, T with A, G with C, and C with G) to the 3′ end of the growing RNA, so the RNA is made 5′ to 3′. Unlike DNA polymerase, RNA polymerase does not need a primer. In termination, the polymerase reaches a terminator sequence and releases the RNA, and the DNA closes up.

Only one of the two DNA strands is the template for any given gene. The other, the coding strand, has the same sequence as the mRNA (with T in place of U). Different genes can use different strands as the template, so the template for one gene may be the coding strand for its neighbor. Many RNA polymerases can transcribe the same gene at once, so a cell can make many copies of an mRNA quickly. In bacteria there is one kind of RNA polymerase and the process occurs in the cytoplasm; in eukaryotes there are several, and transcription occurs in the nucleus.

Worked example · Transcribing a gene

The template strand of part of a gene reads 3′-TACGGTCATAG-5′. Write the mRNA and the coding strand, label the ends, and state which end of the template the polymerase begins at.

mRNA. Pair each template base with its RNA complement (T gives A, A gives U, C gives G, G gives C): template T A C G G T C A T A G gives A U G C C A G U A U C. Because the mRNA is antiparallel to the template and its 5′ end pairs with the template’s 3′ end, the mRNA is 5′-AUGCCAGUAUC-3′.
Coding strand. It has the same sequence as the mRNA, with T in place of U: 5′-ATGCCAGTATC-3′.
Direction. RNA polymerase reads the template 3′ to 5′, so it begins at the 3′ end of the template (the T at the left end) and moves toward the 5′ end.
Check. The mRNA begins with AUG, the start codon (lesson 6.4).

RNA processing in eukaryotes

pre-mRNAG123AAAAmaturemRNAG123AAAAcap added, tail added, introns removed (spliceosome)alternativesplicingG123AAAAG13AAAAexons 1, 2, 3 (protein A)exon 2 skipped (protein B)gray = introns (removed); colored = exons (retained and spliced)
Figure 6.3b In eukaryotes the mRNA transcript is modified: a GTP cap helps with ribosomal recognition, a poly-A tail makes the mRNA more stable, and introns are excised while exons are spliced. Different combinations of exons give different mature mRNAs (alternative splicing).
Required content · EK 6.3.A.4

In eukaryotic cells the mRNA transcript undergoes a series of enzyme-mediated modifications.

  • The addition of a poly-A tail makes mRNA more stable.
  • The addition of a GTP cap helps with ribosomal recognition.
  • The excision of introns, along with the splicing and retention of exons, generates different versions of the resulting mature mRNA molecule. This process is known as alternative splicing.

The first RNA made from a eukaryotic gene is a pre-mRNA, and it is not ready for use. Three changes are made in the nucleus. A modified guanine nucleotide, the 5′ cap, is added to the 5′ end, which protects the mRNA from being broken down and is recognized by the ribosome. A poly-A tail, a string of about 100 to 250 adenine nucleotides, is added to the 3′ end, and helps to export the mRNA and to protect it from enzymes that digest RNA, so it lasts longer in the cytoplasm. Most eukaryotic genes also contain introns, noncoding segments that interrupt the coding segments, the exons (exons are expressed; introns are intervening). A complex of RNA and proteins called the spliceosome cuts out the introns and joins the exons. In humans the average gene has about 8 introns, and an intron may be much longer than an exon: the dystrophin gene is about 2,400,000 base pairs long, but its mature mRNA is only about 14,000 nucleotides, which is less than 1% (\(14{,}000/2{,}400{,}000 = 0.58\%\)).

Alternative splicing means that the exons of a pre-mRNA can be joined in different combinations, so that one gene gives rise to more than one mRNA and so to more than one protein. It is one reason why humans have only about 20,000 protein-coding genes but make more than 100,000 different proteins. Different cell types can splice the same pre-mRNA differently, so alternative splicing is also a way to regulate gene expression (lesson 6.6). Bacteria have no introns, and their mRNA is used as soon as it is made (in fact, translation begins before transcription is finished, lesson 6.4).

Worked example · Counting products of alternative splicing

A gene has five exons. The first and the last exon are always included in the mature mRNA, and each of the three internal exons can independently be included or skipped. Calculate the number of different mature mRNAs that can be made, and the number if the internal exons must be used in order but at least one internal exon must be included.

All combinations. Each of three internal exons has two choices (in or out), and the choices are independent, so \(2 \times 2 \times 2 = 2^3 = 8\) different mRNAs.
At least one internal exon. One of the 8 combinations has none of them (exons 1 and 5 only), so \(8 - 1 = 7\).
Meaning. A single gene with five exons can code for as many as 8 different proteins, which is much more information than the number of genes suggests.

Exam focus
  • Three RNAs: mRNA (message), tRNA (adapter with an anticodon and an amino acid), rRNA (part of the ribosome).
  • Transcription: RNA polymerase reads the template strand 3′ to 5′ and makes RNA 5′ to 3′; no primer needed; U pairs with A.
  • The mRNA has the same sequence as the coding strand (with U for T).
  • Eukaryotic processing: 5′ GTP cap (ribosome recognition), poly-A tail (stability), introns removed, exons joined. Alternative splicing gives different mRNAs from one gene.
  • Transcription is in the nucleus (eukaryotes); processing is before export. Prokaryotes: no nucleus, no introns.
Practice
  1. Write the mRNA (with polarity) transcribed from the template strand 3′-TACTTCAAA-5′.
    Show answer

    The mRNA is 5′-AUGAAGUUU-3′.

  2. Compare the roles of mRNA, tRNA, and rRNA in gene expression.
    Show answer

    mRNA carries the information of a gene from the DNA to the ribosome. tRNA brings specific amino acids to the ribosome, and its anticodon base pairs with the mRNA codon. rRNA is a component of the ribosome that helps to hold the mRNA and tRNAs and to form peptide bonds.

  3. Explain why a poly-A tail and a cap are added to a eukaryotic mRNA.
    Show answer

    The 5′ cap protects the mRNA and helps the ribosome to recognize and bind it. The poly-A tail makes the mRNA more stable, so it lasts longer in the cytoplasm before being broken down, so that more protein can be made from it.

  4. A gene has 6 exons: exons 1 and 6 are always retained, and each of the four internal exons can be in or out. State the number of possible mRNAs.
    Show answer

    Four independent in-or-out choices give \(2^4 = 16\) different mRNAs.

  5. A mutation changes the promoter of a gene so that RNA polymerase cannot bind. Predict the effect on the mRNA and on the protein.
    Show answer

    Transcription of the gene would be much reduced or absent, so little or no mRNA would be made, and so little or no protein would be produced, although the coding sequence is intact.

  6. A student states that RNA polymerase uses both strands of the DNA at the same time to make the mRNA. Evaluate.
    Show answer

    The statement is incorrect. RNA polymerase uses a single template strand to direct the order of bases in the RNA. The other strand (the coding strand) has the same sequence as the RNA, apart from T in place of U, and is not read.

Lesson 6.4 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.4

Translation: from mRNA to protein

A mature mRNA reaches the cytoplasm carrying a message written in four letters. A protein is written in an alphabet of twenty amino acids. Translation is the conversion from one language to the other, and it is done by the ribosome with the help of tRNAs. Since proteins determine the structure and function of cells (units 1 to 3), translation is the step that links the genotype to the phenotype. In this lesson you will learn how the code is read and how a ribosome builds a polypeptide.

Learning objective · 6.4.A

Explain how the phenotype of an organism is determined by its genotype.

The genetic code

Required content · EK 6.4.A.3 (ii to iv)
  • The sequence of nucleotides on the mRNA is read in triplets, called codons.
  • Each codon encodes a specific amino acid, which can be deduced by using a genetic code chart. Many amino acids are encoded by more than one codon.
  • Nearly all living organisms use the same genetic code, which is evidence for the common ancestry of all living organisms.

Exclusion statement: memorization of the genetic code, with the exception of the start codon AUG, is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

The code is read in groups of three nucleotides, because four letters taken one or two at a time give only \(4^1 = 4\) or \(4^2 = 16\) combinations, fewer than the 20 amino acids, and three at a time give \(4^3 = 64\) combinations, which is enough. Of the 64 codons, 61 specify amino acids and 3 are stop codons (UAA, UAG, UGA). The codon AUG codes for methionine and is the start codon that begins translation. Because there are 61 codons for 20 amino acids, the code is redundant (several codons for one amino acid, often differing in the third base), but it is not ambiguous: no codon codes for more than one amino acid. The code is nearly universal: the same codon has the same meaning in bacteria, plants, and humans. This is why a bacterium can make human insulin from a human gene (lesson 6.9), and it is strong evidence that all life shares a common ancestor. On the exam, you will be given a table of the code, as in the excerpt below (only AUG has to be known from memory).

mRNA codonAUGGCUUUACACGGAGAGGUGUAG
Amino acidMet (start)AlaLeuHisGlyGluValStop

The machinery of translation

AUGGCUUUACACGGAUAG5'3'stopsmall subunitlarge subunitEPACGAAAUGUGHisMet-Ala-Leuribosome moves toward the 3' end of the mRNAA: new tRNA bindsP: holds the chainE: empty tRNA exits
Figure 6.4a Translation on a ribosome: mRNA is read in codons, and each tRNA's anticodon pairs with a codon, bringing the specified amino acid. The amino acid is transferred to the growing chain, the ribosome moves along the mRNA, and translation ends when a stop codon is reached.
Required content · EK 6.4.A.1 and 6.4.A.2
  • Translation of the mRNA to generate a polypeptide occurs on ribosomes that are present in the cytoplasm of both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, as well as the cytoplasmic surface of the rough ER of eukaryotic cells.
  • In prokaryotic organisms, translation of the mRNA molecule occurs while it is being transcribed.

A ribosome is made of rRNA and proteins in two subunits, a large and a small one. The small subunit binds the mRNA, and the large subunit forms the peptide bonds. The ribosome has three sites for tRNA: the A site (aminoacyl, where an incoming tRNA binds), the P site (peptidyl, which holds the tRNA carrying the growing chain), and the E site (exit, from which an empty tRNA leaves). Each tRNA is first “charged”: an enzyme attaches the correct amino acid to the correct tRNA, so the tRNA acts as the dictionary that matches each codon to its amino acid. Ribosomes in the cytoplasm make proteins that stay in the cytosol, and those on the rough ER make proteins to be secreted or placed in membranes (lesson 2.1). In bacteria, where there is no nucleus, ribosomes can attach to an mRNA while it is still being made, so translation and transcription are coupled; in eukaryotes the mRNA must first be processed and exported from the nucleus.

The steps of translation

Required content · EK 6.4.A.3 (i, v to viii)
  • Translation involves many sequential steps, including initiation, elongation, and termination.
  • Translation is initiated when the rRNA in the ribosome interacts with the mRNA at the start codon (AUG, coding for the amino acid methionine).
  • tRNA brings the correct amino acid to the place specified by the codon on the mRNA.
  • The amino acid is transferred to the growing polypeptide chain.
  • The process continues along the mRNA until a stop codon is reached.
  • Translation terminates with the release of the newly synthesized protein.

Exclusion statement: the details and names of the enzymes and factors involved in each of these steps are beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Initiation. The small subunit binds to the mRNA (in eukaryotes, at the 5′ cap) and moves along until it finds the start codon AUG. A tRNA carrying methionine, with the anticodon UAC, pairs with it in the P site, and the large subunit joins. Elongation. A tRNA whose anticodon is complementary to the next codon enters the A site. The ribosome transfers the growing chain from the tRNA in the P site to the amino acid on the tRNA in the A site, forming a peptide bond. The ribosome then moves one codon along the mRNA toward the 3′ end: the tRNA that now carries the chain is in the P site, the empty tRNA is in the E site and leaves, and the A site is open for the next tRNA. This is repeated for every codon, adding about 15 amino acids per second in bacteria. Termination. When a stop codon enters the A site, no tRNA matches it. A release factor binds instead, the polypeptide is released from the last tRNA, and the ribosome comes apart. The polypeptide then folds, often with help, into its functional three-dimensional shape (lesson 1.7).

Several ribosomes can translate one mRNA at the same time, in a chain called a polyribosome (polysome), so many copies of the protein are made from one mRNA.

Worked example · Reading an mRNA

An mRNA reads 5′-AUGGCUUUACACGGAUAG-3′. (a) Give the amino acid sequence. (b) Give the anticodon (with polarity) of the tRNA that reads the third codon. (c) How many nucleotides of mRNA are needed to code for the 146 amino acids of the β-globin chain of hemoglobin?

(a) Divide into triplets from the start codon: AUG | GCU | UUA | CAC | GGA | UAG. Using the code: Met – Ala – Leu – His – Gly – stop. The polypeptide is Met-Ala-Leu-His-Gly, 5 amino acids (the stop codon does not code for an amino acid).
(b) The third codon is UUA (5′-UUA-3′). The anticodon is complementary and antiparallel: 3′-AAU-5′ (written 5′-UAA-3′).
(c) There are three nucleotides per codon, and one stop codon follows the last amino acid: \((146 + 1) \times 3 = 441\) nucleotides (the mRNA is longer, with untranslated regions at each end).
Check. A change in the reading frame (adding or removing one nucleotide) would give completely different triplets (lesson 6.7).

One gene, one enzyme: from genotype to phenotype

The connection between genes and proteins was first shown by George Beadle and Edward Tatum in the 1940s. They exposed the bread mold Neurospora to X-rays and found mutants that could not grow on a minimal medium but could grow when a particular nutrient was added. By testing mutants on arginine and its precursors, they could place each mutant in a step of a pathway: precursor → ornithine → citrulline → arginine. A mutant that grows on citrulline or arginine but not on ornithine is blocked after ornithine, and so on. Each mutant lacked one enzyme, and each enzyme is a protein made from one gene, so they proposed “one gene, one enzyme” (now refined, because genes can give several polypeptides by alternative splicing, and some genes code for RNA). The flow is DNA → RNA → protein → trait, and a change in the DNA can change the protein and then the phenotype.

StrainMinimal+ ornithine+ citrulline+ arginine
Wild typegrowsgrowsgrowsgrows
Mutant 1nogrowsgrowsgrows
Mutant 2nonogrowsgrows
Mutant 3nononogrows

Mutant 3 grows only on arginine, so its block is the last step (citrulline to arginine). Mutant 2 grows on citrulline, so its block comes before citrulline (ornithine to citrulline). Mutant 1 grows on ornithine, so its block is before ornithine. The order of the blocks follows the order of the pathway.

Retroviruses: information flowing backward

Required content · EK 6.4.A.4

Genetic information in retroviruses is a special case and has an alternate flow of information: from RNA to DNA, made possible by reverse transcriptase, an enzyme that copies the viral RNA genome into DNA. This DNA integrates into the host genome and is transcribed and translated for the assembly of new viral progeny.

HIV is a retrovirus. Its genome is RNA. After it enters a host cell, reverse transcriptase makes a DNA copy, which is inserted into the host chromosomes. From then on the host cell’s own RNA polymerase and ribosomes transcribe and translate the viral genes, and new viruses are assembled. The viral DNA is copied with the host DNA at each cell division, which is why an infection by a retrovirus lasts for life, and why drugs that block reverse transcriptase are used to treat HIV.

Exam focus
  • The code: triplet codons, 64 codons, AUG = start (Met), 3 stop codons, redundant but not ambiguous, nearly universal (evidence of common ancestry). Use the table that you are given.
  • Ribosome sites: A (new tRNA enters), P (holds the chain), E (exit). The ribosome moves toward the 3′ end of the mRNA.
  • Initiation (small subunit at AUG), elongation (codon-anticodon pairing, peptide bond, translocation), termination (stop codon, release).
  • Prokaryotes: transcription and translation are coupled. Eukaryotes: mRNA is processed and exported first.
  • Retrovirus: RNA → DNA by reverse transcriptase → integrates into host DNA → transcribed and translated.
  • For the number of nucleotides: 3 × (number of amino acids + stop codon).
Practice
  1. Translate the mRNA 5′-AUGGAGGUGUAA-3′ using the table above.
    Show answer

    AUG | GAG | GUG | UAA: Met-Glu-Val, then stop (UAA is a stop codon). The polypeptide is Met-Glu-Val.

  2. A tRNA has the anticodon 3′-CCU-5′. State the mRNA codon that it pairs with, and the amino acid if the code table gives GGA for Gly.
    Show answer

    The codon is complementary and antiparallel: 5′-GGA-3′, which codes for glycine, so this tRNA carries glycine.

  3. Describe what happens in the A, P, and E sites during one round of elongation.
    Show answer

    A tRNA with the matching anticodon enters the A site. The chain is transferred from the tRNA in the P site to the amino acid on the tRNA in the A site by a peptide bond. The ribosome then moves one codon: the tRNA with the chain moves from A to P, the empty tRNA in P moves to E and leaves, and the A site is free for the next tRNA.

  4. Explain why a bacterium can begin translating an mRNA before its transcription is complete, but a eukaryotic cell cannot.
    Show answer

    A bacterium has no nucleus, so the ribosomes can bind to the mRNA as it comes out of the RNA polymerase. In a eukaryotic cell, transcription happens in the nucleus and the mRNA must be processed (cap, tail, splicing) and exported to the cytoplasm, where the ribosomes are, before translation can start.

  5. A polypeptide has 250 amino acids. Calculate the minimum number of mRNA nucleotides between and including the start and stop codons.
    Show answer

    \((250 + 1) \times 3 = 753\) nucleotides (250 codons for amino acids, including the start codon AUG for the first, plus one stop codon).

  6. In a Beadle-Tatum experiment, a mutant grows on minimal medium plus citrulline or arginine, but not on ornithine. Identify where the block is, and justify.
    Show answer

    The block is between ornithine and citrulline: the cell cannot make citrulline from ornithine, so adding ornithine does not help, but adding citrulline (which is after the block) or arginine allows growth. The enzyme for the step from ornithine to citrulline is missing or defective.

Lesson 6.5 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.5 (part 1)

Regulating genes in prokaryotes: operons

A bacterium that lives in your intestine may go for hours without lactose and then be flooded with milk sugar. Making the enzymes that digest lactose when there is none would waste energy, and not making them when lactose arrives would waste food. The bacterium solves the problem by switching the genes for those enzymes on only when they are needed. This is gene regulation, and the bacterial system, worked out in 1961 by François Jacob and Jacques Monod, was the first example understood in detail.

Learning objectives · 6.5.A and 6.5.B (prokaryotes)

Describe the types of interactions that regulate gene expression, and explain how the location of regulatory sequences relates to their function.

Regulatory sequences and proteins

Required content · EK 6.5.A.1

Regulatory sequences are stretches of DNA that interact with regulatory proteins to control transcription. Some genes are constitutively expressed, and others are inducible.

Not every gene is expressed all the time, or at the same level. A constitutively expressed gene is transcribed continuously at a fairly constant rate: for example, the genes for glycolysis enzymes and ribosomal RNA, which every cell needs all the time. An inducible gene is usually off and is turned on by a signal, such as the presence of a substrate (or, in eukaryotes, a hormone). The control is exerted by regulatory sequences, stretches of DNA near the gene, which are bound by regulatory proteins. A protein that blocks transcription is a repressor (negative regulation), and one that helps transcription is an activator (positive regulation). The location of the regulatory sequence determines its effect: a sequence that is near the start of the gene, where RNA polymerase binds, can block or allow the start of transcription.

Operons

Required content · EK 6.5.B.1 (i)

Both prokaryotes and eukaryotes have groups of genes that are coordinately regulated. Prokaryotes regulate operons in an inducible or repressible system.

In bacteria, genes for the steps of one pathway are often next to each other and are transcribed together as one mRNA, under the control of a single promoter. This unit is an operon. It has three parts: the promoter, where RNA polymerase binds; the operator, a short DNA sequence between the promoter and the genes, where a repressor can bind; and the structural genes that code for the enzymes. A separate regulatory gene, which can be elsewhere on the chromosome, codes for the repressor protein. Because the genes are on one mRNA, they are switched on and off together: the cell is regulating a group of genes with one switch.

The lac operon: an inducible operon

Lactose absent: operon OFFregulatorpromoteroperatorgene 1gene 2gene 3RRNA polThe repressor binds the operator and blocks RNA polymerase.Lactose present: operon ONregulatorpromoteroperatorgene 1gene 2gene 3RallolactoseRNA polmRNAAllolactose binds the repressor, which releases the operator; the genes are transcribed.
Figure 6.5a An inducible operon, such as the lac operon, is normally off. The inducer (allolactose, made from lactose) inactivates the repressor, so transcription of the genes for lactose use begins only when lactose is available.

The lac operon of E. coli has three structural genes for the use of lactose: lacZ (β-galactosidase, which cuts lactose into glucose and galactose), lacY (a permease that brings lactose into the cell), and lacA. The regulatory gene lacI makes the lac repressor.

  • No lactose. The repressor is active and binds to the operator, which blocks the RNA polymerase from moving along the DNA. The genes are off, and no enzyme is wasted.
  • Lactose present. A small amount of lactose is converted into allolactose, the inducer. Allolactose binds to the repressor and changes its shape, so it can no longer bind to the operator. RNA polymerase transcribes the genes, and the enzymes are made. When the lactose is used up, the repressor returns to the operator and the genes are off again.

The lac operon is therefore inducible: it is normally off and is turned on by the inducer. There is a second level of control that also shows positive regulation. Glucose is a better source of energy than lactose, so when glucose is present the cell has no need for the lac enzymes even if lactose is also there. When glucose is low, a molecule of cAMP (lesson 4.2) builds up, binds to an activator protein (CAP), and the cAMP-CAP complex binds near the promoter and increases the binding of RNA polymerase. If both lactose is present and glucose is absent, the operon is on at a high level; if lactose is present but glucose is also present, it is on only at a low level. This is why bacteria in a medium with both sugars use the glucose first.

The trp operon: a repressible operon

Tryptophan scarce: operon ONregulatorpromoteroperatorgene 1gene 2gene 3RRNA polmRNAThe repressor is inactive on its own, so the genes are transcribed.Tryptophan plentiful: operon OFFregulatorpromoteroperatorgene 1gene 2gene 3Rtryptophan (corepressor)RNA polTryptophan binds the repressor; the complex blocks transcription.
Figure 6.5b A repressible operon, such as the trp operon, is normally on. The end product (tryptophan) activates the repressor, so the cell stops making the enzymes that make tryptophan when enough is present (negative feedback).

The trp operon contains five genes for the enzymes that make the amino acid tryptophan. It works in the opposite way to the lac operon. The trp repressor is made in an inactive form. When tryptophan is scarce, the repressor cannot bind the operator, and the operon is on: the cell makes its own tryptophan. When tryptophan is plentiful (for example, when the cell is growing in a medium with tryptophan), it binds to the repressor as a corepressor. The repressor-tryptophan complex binds the operator, and the operon is turned off. The cell does not make an amino acid that it can take from the medium. The trp operon is repressible: it is normally on, and the end product of the pathway turns it off. This is a form of negative feedback (lesson 4.4), as in the end-product inhibition of enzymes (lesson 3.2), but acting on transcription.

Inducible (lac)Repressible (trp)
Normal stateOffOn
Repressor aloneActive (binds operator)Inactive
Small moleculeInducer (allolactose) inactivates the repressorCorepressor (tryptophan) activates the repressor
Signal that changes the stateLactose present: operon turns onTryptophan present: operon turns off
Type of pathwayBreaking down a nutrient (catabolic)Making a product (anabolic)
Worked example · Jacob and Monod’s mutants

β-galactosidase activity (arbitrary units) was measured in E. coli grown in a medium with glycerol (no lactose, no glucose) and in a medium with glycerol plus lactose.

StrainGlycerol onlyGlycerol + lactose
Wild type1100
Mutant A100100
Mutant B00
Mutant C11

Mutant A has a defect in the repressor gene or in the operator. Mutant B has a deletion of lacZ. Mutant C has a mutation in the lacI gene that makes a repressor that cannot bind allolactose. Match each mutant to the data, and explain.

Wild type. Activity is low without lactose (1) and rises 100-fold with lactose (\(100/1 = 100\)): inducible regulation.
Mutant A (constitutive). Activity is high with or without lactose (100 and 100), so the operon is always on. It is explained by a repressor that does not bind the operator (a defective lacI gene) or by an operator that the repressor cannot bind: the “brake” has failed.
Mutant B. The mutant makes no enzyme in either medium (0 and 0), as expected when the structural gene lacZ is deleted: whatever the regulation is, there is no gene to express.
Mutant C. A repressor that cannot bind the inducer cannot be inactivated, so it stays on the operator even when lactose is present, and the activity is low in both media (1 and 1): the operon is always off.
Reasoning. Each result is read as a change in the on/off state of the operon in each condition, and then linked to the component that could cause it.

Exam focus
  • An operon = promoter + operator + structural genes under one control (one mRNA). Genes in an operon are expressed together.
  • lac (inducible, usually off): allolactose binds the repressor, which releases the operator, so transcription begins. trp (repressible, usually on): tryptophan binds the repressor, which then binds the operator, so transcription stops.
  • Constitutive genes are always expressed; inducible genes are expressed in response to a signal.
  • cAMP-CAP is an activator (positive regulation) for lac: glucose low, cAMP high, operon on (if lactose is present).
  • For a mutant question: decide if the operon is always on, always off, or normal, and name the part (repressor, operator, structural gene, promoter) that explains it.
Practice
  1. Describe how the lac operon is regulated in the presence and in the absence of lactose.
    Show answer

    Without lactose, the repressor is active and binds to the operator, blocking transcription of the genes. With lactose, allolactose binds to the repressor and changes its shape, so it releases the operator and RNA polymerase can transcribe the genes for lactose use.

  2. Predict the effect on the lac operon of a mutation of the operator so that the repressor cannot bind it, in a medium without lactose.
    Show answer

    The genes would be transcribed even without lactose, because the repressor cannot block the polymerase: the operon is constitutively on, and the cell would make β-galactosidase and the other enzymes that are not needed.

  3. Explain why the trp operon is described as repressible, and what turns it off.
    Show answer

    It is normally on, and its activity can be reduced (repressed). It is turned off when tryptophan, the end product of the pathway, binds to the repressor and activates it, so that the repressor binds to the operator and blocks transcription.

  4. E. coli is grown in a medium with lactose and a high concentration of glucose. Predict the expression of the lac operon, and justify.
    Show answer

    It is expressed at a low level. Lactose inactivates the repressor, so the operator is free, but glucose keeps the cAMP level low, so the activator CAP does not bind and RNA polymerase transcribes little. The cell uses the glucose first.

  5. A mutation in the lacI gene results in a repressor that cannot bind the operator. Describe the β-galactosidase activity with and without lactose, and the type of regulation that is lost.
    Show answer

    Activity is high both with and without lactose, because there is no functional repressor to block transcription. The regulation lost is the inducible control of the operon: it is expressed constitutively.

  6. Give one advantage to a bacterium of having the genes for lactose use grouped in an operon.
    Show answer

    One promoter and one operator control all of the genes, so they are switched on and off together as a single mRNA, and the cell makes all of the enzymes needed for the pathway at the same time and only when they are needed, saving energy.

Lesson 6.6 · Unit 6 · CED topics 6.5 and 6.6

Regulating genes in eukaryotes and cell specialization

A neuron in your brain and a cell in your liver have exactly the same DNA, yet one transmits electrical signals and the other detoxifies drugs. A single fertilized egg gives rise to more than 200 cell types. The difference lies not in which genes a cell has but in which genes it expresses, and how much. Eukaryotes have more ways of controlling expression than bacteria, and this lesson explains the main ones and how they produce cell specialization.

Learning objectives · 6.5.A, 6.5.B, 6.6.A and 6.6.B

Explain how the binding of transcription factors to promoter regions affects gene expression and the phenotype of the organism, and explain the connection between the regulation of gene expression and phenotypic differences in cells and organisms.

Transcription factors, promoters, and enhancers

enhancer. . .promotergeneDNA loops: enhancer can be far from the promoteractivatorsRNA pol +general TFstranscriptionactivator transcription factor
Figure 6.6a RNA polymerase and transcription factors bind promoter or enhancer DNA sequences to initiate transcription. These sequences can be upstream or downstream of the transcription start site. Negative regulators inhibit expression by binding DNA and blocking transcription.
Required content · EK 6.6.A.1 and 6.6.A.2
  • RNA polymerase and transcription factors bind to promoter or enhancer DNA sequences to initiate transcription. These sequences can be upstream or downstream of the transcription start site.
  • Negative regulatory molecules inhibit gene expression by binding to DNA and blocking transcription.

In eukaryotes, RNA polymerase cannot start transcription by itself. It needs a set of general transcription factors, proteins that bind first at the promoter (often a sequence called the TATA box, close to the start site) and then recruit the polymerase. This is enough only for a low level of transcription. The rate is controlled by specific transcription factors, proteins that recognize short DNA sequences called enhancers, which can be thousands of base pairs away from the gene, upstream, downstream, or even within an intron. An activator bound at an enhancer bends the DNA into a loop so that it touches the proteins at the promoter, and increases the rate of transcription. A repressor bound at a regulatory sequence (a silencer) blocks transcription, either by blocking the activator or the polymerase, which is a negative regulation. Every cell type has its own combination of transcription factors, so the same gene can be on in one cell and off in another.

Genes that are controlled by the same transcription factors are expressed together, even if they are on different chromosomes: this is the eukaryotic equivalent of an operon (EK 6.5.B.1.ii). For example, the genes of all the enzymes that a liver cell uses to make bile each have an enhancer with a binding site for the same liver transcription factors. A signal, such as a hormone, can switch on a whole group of genes in one step by activating one transcription factor (the signal pathways of lessons 4.2 and 4.3 often end this way: a steroid hormone and its receptor form a transcription factor).

Epigenetic regulation

Loose chromatin: gene accessibleTight chromatin: gene silencedAcAcAcAcRNA polmRNAhistone acetylation (Ac)loosens the packingCH3 (methyl groups)RNA polDNA methylation (CH3), no acetylationcompacts chromatin; gene off
Figure 6.6b Epigenetic changes affect gene expression through reversible modifications of DNA or histones without changing the DNA sequence. Methylated DNA and tightly packed chromatin generally reduce transcription; acetylated histones and loosely packed chromatin generally allow it.
Required content · EK 6.5.A.2

Epigenetic changes can affect gene expression through reversible modifications of DNA or histones.

Whether a transcription factor can reach a gene also depends on how tightly the DNA is packed (lesson 6.1). Chemical tags on DNA and on histones change the packing without changing the base sequence. DNA methylation, the addition of methyl (CH3) groups to cytosine bases, is usually associated with silenced genes. Histone acetylation, the addition of acetyl groups to histone proteins, loosens the DNA and is usually associated with active genes (histone methylation can have either effect). These are called epigenetic changes, because they are on top of the sequence, are reversible, and can be passed on when cells divide. The tags can be affected by the environment, such as diet and stress, so they are a way for the environment to alter gene expression (lesson 5.7). An example is the inactivation of one X chromosome in female mammals (lesson 5.4): methylation and tight packing silence nearly all of the genes on it. Identical twins have the same sequence, but their patterns of methylation become more different as they get older.

Small RNAs

Required content · EK 6.6.B.2

Certain small RNA molecules have roles in regulating gene expression.

Regulation also happens after transcription. Short RNA molecules, about 21 to 25 nucleotides long, such as microRNAs (miRNAs) and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), bind by base pairing to a complementary sequence in a target mRNA, and form a complex with proteins that either breaks down the mRNA or blocks its translation. The gene is then expressed less, though it is transcribed normally. Humans have more than 1,000 miRNAs, and they regulate a large share of all genes; researchers can also use siRNAs to turn down a chosen gene to find out what it does.

From regulation to cell specialization

Required content · EK 6.5.A.3 and 6.6.B.1
  • The phenotype of a cell or an organism is determined by the combination of genes that are expressed and the levels at which they are expressed.
  • Observable cell differentiation results from the expression of genes for tissue-specific proteins.
  • Induction of transcription factors during development results in sequential gene expression.
  • The function and amount of gene products determine the phenotype of organisms.
  • Gene regulation results in differential gene expression and influences cell products and functions.

Differential gene expression is the main explanation of cell specialization. Almost every body cell has the same genome (red blood cells lose their nucleus, and gametes are haploid, but the rest contain the complete set; this was shown when the nucleus of an adult frog or sheep cell was transplanted into an egg and gave rise to a whole animal, in cloning). Each cell type makes a different set of proteins: red blood cell precursors make large amounts of hemoglobin, pancreatic β cells make insulin, and neurons make neurotransmitter receptors. These tissue-specific proteins give each cell its structure and function. A fraction of the genes, the housekeeping genes, are expressed in every cell type, because all cells need the enzymes for basic functions such as glycolysis.

In development, cells become different in a sequence. A signal (lesson 4.1, morphogens) switches on a transcription factor in some cells of the embryo. That transcription factor turns on the genes for other transcription factors, and so on, in a cascade, so that each step in development depends on the previous one: this is sequential gene expression. The Hox genes, which code for transcription factors that decide the identity of the segments along the head-to-tail axis, are examples. A mutation in a Hox gene can place a leg where an antenna should be in a fruit fly. Because the expression of a gene determines the amount and the function of the gene product, it determines the phenotype: a person with a mutation in the enhancer of a hemoglobin gene may make too little hemoglobin, even though the protein sequence is normal.

Worked example · Differential expression data

The relative amount of mRNA (arbitrary units) for three genes was measured in liver cells and in brain cells from the same person: albumin (a blood protein) 120 in liver and 4 in brain; a neurotransmitter receptor 2 in liver and 80 in brain; and a glycolysis enzyme 50 in liver and 52 in brain. Calculate the fold difference for each gene, classify each gene, and explain what the data show about the genomes of the two tissues.

Albumin. \(120/4 = 30\) times higher in liver. Receptor. \(80/2 = 40\) times higher in brain. Glycolysis enzyme. \(52/50 = 1.04\), essentially the same.
Classification. Albumin is a liver-specific (tissue-specific) gene, the receptor is brain-specific, and the glycolysis gene is a housekeeping gene, which is expressed at a similar level in both.
Explanation. Both tissues have all three genes (they have the same DNA), but the amounts of mRNA are different, so the differences are due to differential gene expression, not to a different genome. A tissue-specific transcription factor in the liver could activate albumin, and a different set in neurons the receptor gene; epigenetic marks and small RNAs might help to keep the other genes off.

Exam focus
  • Eukaryotic transcription needs transcription factors plus RNA polymerase at the promoter; enhancers (can be far away, upstream or downstream) boost it; repressors block it.
  • Epigenetic changes are reversible changes to DNA or histones: DNA methylation (usually silences), histone acetylation (usually activates). The sequence is not changed.
  • Small RNAs (miRNA, siRNA) bind mRNA and block translation or cause breakdown.
  • Cell differentiation = differential gene expression of the same genome, not different DNA. Tissue-specific proteins and housekeeping genes.
  • In development, transcription factors switch on other transcription factors: sequential gene expression (for example, Hox genes).
  • Regulation can happen at many levels: chromatin, transcription, RNA processing, translation (RNAs), protein activity.
Practice
  1. Describe the roles of the promoter and the enhancer in the transcription of a eukaryotic gene.
    Show answer

    The promoter, near the start of the gene, is where the general transcription factors and RNA polymerase assemble, so it allows transcription to begin at a low rate. An enhancer is a regulatory sequence, which may be far from the gene, where activator proteins bind and loop the DNA to the promoter to increase the rate of transcription.

  2. A drug increases the acetylation of histones in a cell. Predict the effect on gene expression, and justify.
    Show answer

    Gene expression in the affected regions is likely to increase, because acetylation loosens the packing of the DNA around the histones, so transcription factors and RNA polymerase can more easily reach the genes.

  3. Explain how a muscle cell and a nerve cell from the same person can be so different when they have the same DNA.
    Show answer

    They express different sets of genes. Each cell type has its own set of transcription factors (and epigenetic marks), so it makes different tissue-specific proteins, which give it a different structure and function. The genome is the same.

  4. A small RNA of 22 nucleotides is made that is complementary to the mRNA of gene X. Predict the effect on the amount of protein X and on the amount of mRNA X.
    Show answer

    The amount of protein X would decrease, because the small RNA base pairs with the mRNA and blocks its translation or leads to its breakdown. The mRNA X may also decrease if it is broken down; transcription of the gene is not affected directly.

  5. In the worked example, a student claims that the liver cells lack the receptor gene because the mRNA level is only 2 units. Evaluate with data.
    Show answer

    The claim is not supported. The liver cells are from the same person as the brain cells and have the same genome. The liver has a low but nonzero level (2 units), compared with 80 in the brain, so the gene is present but expressed at a very low level (40 times lower), which is the result of regulation, not of absence of the gene.

  6. Describe how a transcription factor made in the early embryo can result in the sequential development of a body region.
    Show answer

    A signal in some cells induces the production of a transcription factor, which turns on the genes for other transcription factors and tissue-specific proteins. Those in turn switch on further genes, so that expression happens in a sequence in which each stage depends on the previous one, and the cells in the region develop a specific identity and structure.

Lesson 6.7 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.7 (part 1)

Mutations: changes in the genetic message

Every time a human cell copies its 6.4 billion base pairs, the DNA polymerase makes a few mistakes that escape repair, and each child is born with about 70 new changes that are in neither parent. Almost all of them have no visible effect, but a very few change a protein in a way that matters, for better or for worse. A mutation is any change in the sequence of DNA, and mutations are the original source of all the new alleles on which evolution works. In this lesson you will classify mutations, predict their effects on a protein, and see why the same mutation can be harmful in one environment and useful in another.

Learning objectives · 6.7.A and 6.7.B

Describe the various types of mutation, and explain how changes in genotype may result in changes in phenotype.

Types of mutation

mutationmRNA codonspolypeptideOriginalAUGGAGGUCUACMet - Glu - Val - TyrSilentAUGGAAGUCUACMet - Glu - Val - Tyr (no change)MissenseAUGGUGGUCUACMet - Val - Val - Tyr (Glu to Val)NonsenseAUGGAGGUCUAAMet - Glu - Val - STOPFrameshiftAUGGGAGGUCUACMet - Gly - Gly - Leu ... (all changed)Frameshift: one base inserted after AUG (a G), so every later codon is read in a new frame.
Figure 6.7a Point mutations substitute one nucleotide for another: silent (no change in the amino acid), missense (a different amino acid), or nonsense (a premature stop). Frameshift mutations are insertions or deletions that shift the reading frame. The missense example is the change that causes sickle-cell anemia (Glu to Val).
Required content · EK 6.7.A.1

Alterations in a DNA sequence are mutations that can cause changes in the type or amount of the protein produced and the consequent phenotype. DNA mutations can be beneficial, detrimental, or neutral based on the effect or the lack of effect they have on the resulting nucleic acid or protein and the phenotypes that are conferred by the protein.

  • Point mutations occur when one nucleotide has been substituted for a different nucleotide.
  • Frameshift mutations occur when one or more nucleotides are inserted or deleted, causing the reading frame to be shifted.
  • Nonsense mutations occur when there is a point mutation that causes a premature stop.
  • Silent mutations occur when the change in the nucleotide sequence has no effect on the amino acid sequence.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of specific mutations and their effects is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

The effect of a mutation depends on what kind of change it is and where it happens, and you should use these terms exactly (the exam asks for them, and, as the CED points out, a common error is to say that a point mutation causes a frameshift: a substitution never shifts the frame).

  • Silent mutation. A substitution that changes a codon into a different codon for the same amino acid, which is possible because of the redundancy of the code (often a change in the third base). The protein is unchanged.
  • Missense mutation. A substitution that changes the codon for one amino acid into a codon for a different amino acid. The effect can range from none (if the new amino acid is similar and is not in an important place) to severe (if it is in the active site or alters the folding, as in the sickle-cell example below).
  • Nonsense mutation. A substitution that changes an amino acid codon into a stop codon. Translation ends early, and the polypeptide is shorter and is usually nonfunctional. This is generally the most serious type of point mutation, especially early in the gene.
  • Frameshift mutation. The insertion or deletion of nucleotides, in numbers that are not a multiple of three. Every codon after the change is read in a new frame, so the amino acid sequence from that point on is different, and a stop codon often appears soon. It is usually severe. If three nucleotides (or a multiple of three) are added or deleted, the frame is kept, and only one or a few amino acids are added or lost (as in the common cystic fibrosis mutation, which deletes three nucleotides and so one phenylalanine of the CFTR protein, which then fails to transport ions properly).

Mutations in non-coding DNA can also matter. A mutation in a promoter or enhancer can change the amount of a protein, without changing its sequence (lesson 6.6), and a mutation in the sequence at an intron-exon boundary can change how the pre-mRNA is spliced.

Worked example · Classifying mutations, with sickle-cell anemia

The template strand of the start of a gene reads 3′-TAC CTC CAG ATG-5′. Find the mRNA and the polypeptide, then classify and predict the effect of each change to the template: (1) CTC changes to CTT; (2) CTC changes to CAC; (3) the last triplet ATG changes to ATT; (4) a C is inserted after the first triplet (TACCCTCCAGATG).

Original. The mRNA is 5′-AUG GAG GUC UAC-3′, which codes for Met-Glu-Val-Tyr.
(1) CTC to CTT. The mRNA codon changes from GAG to GAA, which also codes for Glu: a silent mutation. The protein is unchanged (Met-Glu-Val-Tyr).
(2) CTC to CAC. The codon changes from GAG to GUG, which codes for Val: a missense mutation, giving Met-Val-Val-Tyr. This is the change that causes sickle-cell anemia in the sixth codon of the β-globin gene: the polar glutamic acid is replaced by the nonpolar valine on the surface of the hemoglobin, which makes the molecules stick together into fibers when the oxygen concentration is low (lesson 1.7).
(3) ATG to ATT. The codon UAC changes to UAA, a stop codon: a nonsense mutation, giving Met-Glu-Val (shortened).
(4) Insertion of C. The mRNA is 5′-AUG G GAG GUC UAC-3′, which is read as AUG GGA GGU CUA C: Met-Gly-Gly-Leu. This is a frameshift mutation. Every amino acid after the first is changed.
Ranking. In terms of the usual effect on the protein: silent (none) < missense (variable) < nonsense and frameshift (usually severe).

Causes of mutations

Required content · EK 6.7.B.1
  • Errors in DNA replication or DNA repair mechanisms as well as external factors, including radiation and reactive chemicals, can cause random mutations in the DNA.
  • Whether a mutation is beneficial, detrimental, or neutral depends on the environmental context.
  • Mutations are a source of genetic variation.

Some mutations are spontaneous: they are caused by mistakes of DNA polymerase that were not corrected by proofreading and mismatch repair (lesson 6.2), or by the DNA being damaged by normal chemistry in the cell. Others are caused by mutagens: ultraviolet light (which links neighboring thymines in a skin cell), X-rays and gamma rays (which break the DNA), and reactive chemicals such as those in tobacco smoke. A mutation is random with respect to its usefulness: it is not caused by a need for the change. Mutations in somatic cells affect only the individual (and may lead to cancer, lesson 4.7), while mutations in germ line cells (the cells that make gametes) can be passed on to the offspring and are the ones that matter in evolution.

Whether a mutation is good or bad depends on the environment. Rock pocket mice live on dark lava flows and on light-colored sand. A mutation in the MC1R gene gives a dark coat (adaptive melanism). On the lava it is beneficial, as it camouflages the mouse from owls, but on the light sand the same mutation is detrimental. The sickle-cell allele is harmful in a homozygote, but a heterozygote is protected against malaria, so in regions with malaria it can be beneficial. Most mutations are neutral: they are silent, or in noncoding DNA, or they change a protein in a way that makes no difference.

Changes in chromosomes

Required content · EK 6.7.B.2
  • Errors in mitosis or meiosis can result in changes in phenotype.
  • Changes in chromosome number resulting from nondisjunction often result in new phenotypes caused by aneuploidy (an extra or missing chromosome).
  • Changes in chromosome number often result in disorders with developmental limitations.
  • Alterations in chromosome structure lead to genetic disorders.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of specific disorders related to changes in chromosome number is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Mutations can also affect whole chromosomes. Nondisjunction (lesson 5.2) gives gametes with an extra or a missing chromosome and, after fertilization, a zygote with one chromosome too many (trisomy) or too few (monosomy), a condition called aneuploidy. Because genes are expressed in the right amounts only if there are two copies, such changes usually disturb development, and most of them are lethal in the embryo. (Whole extra sets of chromosomes, polyploidy, are tolerated in many plants, which is how many crops such as wheat and bananas arose.) Changes in the structure of a chromosome include a deletion (a segment is lost), a duplication (a segment is repeated), an inversion (a segment is reversed), and a translocation (a segment moves to a different, non-homologous chromosome). Each can change the genes that are present, their number, or how they are regulated, and so lead to genetic disorders or to cancer.

Exam focus
  • Substitution (point): silent, missense, or nonsense. Insertion or deletion: frameshift (unless a multiple of three).
  • A point mutation does not cause a frameshift, and a mutation does not automatically denature a protein: describe the change in the amino acid and how it changes the shape or function.
  • Connect the levels: DNA change → mRNA change → amino acid change → protein shape and function → phenotype.
  • Causes: replication or repair errors, radiation, chemicals. Mutations are random; whether they are beneficial, harmful, or neutral depends on the environment. Not all mutations are harmful.
  • Nondisjunction gives aneuploidy; structural changes: deletion, duplication, inversion, translocation. Germ line mutations are inherited.
Practice
  1. Distinguish a silent mutation from a missense mutation, and explain why a silent mutation is possible.
    Show answer

    A silent mutation changes a codon to another codon for the same amino acid, so the protein is not changed; a missense mutation changes the codon to one for a different amino acid, so the protein has a different amino acid. Silent mutations are possible because the genetic code is redundant: most amino acids have more than one codon.

  2. An mRNA codon CAG (Gln) is changed to UAG by a mutation. Name the type of mutation and predict the effect on the protein.
    Show answer

    It is a nonsense mutation, because UAG is a stop codon. Translation would end at that point, so the polypeptide would be truncated and most likely nonfunctional.

  3. Explain why the deletion of three consecutive nucleotides in a gene is often less damaging than the deletion of one.
    Show answer

    Deleting three nucleotides removes one codon (or changes two) but keeps the reading frame, so the rest of the protein is unchanged except for one missing amino acid. Deleting one nucleotide causes a frameshift: all of the codons after the deletion are read in a different frame, so the amino acid sequence from there on is changed, and a stop codon is likely to appear early.

  4. A student says that a point mutation caused a frameshift in a gene. Evaluate the statement.
    Show answer

    The statement is incorrect. A point mutation substitutes one nucleotide for another, so the number of nucleotides and the reading frame do not change. Frameshift mutations are caused by insertions or deletions that are not a multiple of three nucleotides.

  5. The same coat color mutation is found in two populations of mice, one on dark rocks and one on pale sand. Predict the effect on survival in each, and justify.
    Show answer

    On dark rocks, the dark coat is camouflaged from predators, so the mutation is beneficial and the mice with it are more likely to survive and reproduce. On pale sand, the dark mice are easily seen by predators, so the mutation is detrimental. This shows that whether a mutation is good or bad depends on the environment.

  6. Describe how a mutation in a promoter could change the phenotype without changing the amino acid sequence of the protein.
    Show answer

    If the mutation changes how well RNA polymerase or transcription factors bind to the promoter, the amount of mRNA made, and so the amount of protein, would be changed. The protein is the same, but there is more or less of it, and the phenotype depends on the amount of a gene product as well as on its function.

Lesson 6.8 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.7 (part 2)

Variation, selection, and horizontal gene transfer

In 1940, penicillin was a miracle drug. Within a few years, strains of bacteria that resisted it were common, and today some bacterial infections resist almost every antibiotic. How did a population change so fast? Bacteria reproduce by dividing, and so they should produce identical copies. The answer is that they have several sources of variation, mutation and several ways of picking up genes from other cells, and that each one can be acted on by natural selection. This lesson links the mutations of lesson 6.7 to evolution (unit 7).

Learning objective · 6.7.C

Explain how alterations in DNA sequences contribute to variation that can be subject to natural selection.

Mutation is random, and selection is not

Required content · EK 6.7.C.1

Changes in genotype may affect phenotypes that are subject to natural selection. Genetic changes that enhance survival and reproduction can be selected for by environmental conditions.

Mutations arise by chance, without regard to what the organism needs. The environment does not cause the useful mutation; it only decides which variants survive and reproduce. This was shown for bacteria by Joshua and Esther Lederberg in 1952, with replica plating. They spread bacteria on a plate without antibiotic, so that each cell grew into a colony. They then pressed a piece of sterile velvet onto the plate and stamped it onto several plates with an antibiotic, so that each colony was copied to the same position on each new plate. Colonies resistant to the antibiotic appeared at the same positions on every replica plate. If resistance had been caused by exposure to the antibiotic, the resistant colonies should have been at random positions on each plate. The fact that they were in the same places means that the resistant cells were already present in the original colonies, before they were exposed to the antibiotic. Mutations that give resistance occur at random, and the antibiotic simply selects the cells that already have them.

Worked example · Resistance before exposure

A culture of \(2.0 \times 10^9\) E. coli cells, all grown from a single streptomycin-sensitive cell in medium without antibiotic, has a mutation rate to streptomycin resistance of about \(1 \times 10^{-8}\) per cell (in the population as a whole). The culture is spread on plates with streptomycin. (a) Predict the number of resistant cells and the result on the plates. (b) Explain what would be expected if the antibiotic caused the mutations, and what the pattern of the colonies from replica plating tells us.

(a) Expected resistant cells \(= 2.0 \times 10^9 \times 1 \times 10^{-8} = 20\). All of the sensitive cells are killed, and the 20 resistant cells survive and each forms a colony: about 20 colonies appear. The population changes from almost entirely sensitive to entirely resistant, even though the antibiotic did not cause any of the mutations.
(b) If the antibiotic caused the mutations, resistance would be induced only after the plating, so resistant colonies on replicas should be at unrelated positions, and the number would be about the same on every plate. The same positions on each replica show that resistance was present before the exposure: it came from random mutation, and selection acted on existing variation.
Meaning. Evolution by natural selection needs genetic variation in the population before the selecting condition appears, and then the selected variants increase because they leave more offspring.

Horizontal gene transfer in prokaryotes

Transformationuptake of DNAfrom the environmentTransductiona virus carriesDNA between cellsConjugationcell-to-celltransfer of DNATranspositiontransposona DNA segment moveswithin or between DNAsAll four move genes without reproduction, adding genetic variation.
Figure 6.8a In prokaryotes, genetic information can be acquired horizontally by transformation, transduction, conjugation, and transposition. These processes increase genetic variation without cell division.
Required content · EK 6.7.C.1 (i)

The horizontal acquisitions of genetic information in prokaryotes via transformation (uptake of DNA), transduction (viral transmission of genetic information), conjugation (cell-to-cell transfer of DNA), and transposition (movement of DNA segments within and between DNA molecules) increase genetic variation.

Vertical transmission passes genes from parent to offspring. Horizontal gene transfer passes genes between cells that are not parent and offspring, even between different species, and it is an important source of variation in bacteria, which reproduce asexually and would otherwise have only mutation. There are four mechanisms.

  • Transformation. A bacterium takes up free DNA from its surroundings (for example, DNA released by a dead cell) and may incorporate it into its chromosome. This is the process that Griffith observed (lesson 6.1), and it is used in the laboratory to introduce plasmids into bacteria (lesson 6.9).
  • Transduction. A bacteriophage (virus) that infects one bacterium may accidentally package a piece of that cell’s DNA in a new virus particle, and then carry it to the next cell it infects.
  • Conjugation. Two bacterial cells join through a protein tube, the pilus, and DNA, usually a plasmid, is passed from the donor to the recipient. Plasmids can carry genes for antibiotic resistance, so conjugation can make a recipient resistant in a short time, and it can happen between different species.
  • Transposition. A transposon (a “jumping gene”) is a segment of DNA that can move from one place to another, within a chromosome or between a chromosome and a plasmid. A transposon that carries a resistance gene can thus move onto a plasmid that is then passed on by conjugation. Transposons are also found in eukaryotes, where they make up almost half of the human genome.

The result is that a resistance gene which arose once by mutation in one cell can quickly spread through a population, and between species, so that bacteria with “multidrug resistance” are more and more common. When an antibiotic kills the sensitive cells in a patient, the resistant ones that are left are selected for, and they multiply (a case of natural selection that you can observe over days).

Viruses and conserved reproductive processes

Required content · EK 6.7.C.1 (ii and iii)
  • Related viruses can recombine genetic information if they infect the same host cell.
  • Reproductive processes that increase genetic variation are evolutionarily conserved and are shared by various organisms.

Viruses also exchange genes. If two related viruses infect the same cell, their genomes can be mixed in the new viruses. The influenza virus has a genome in eight separate RNA segments, so if two strains infect the same cell (for example, a human strain and a bird strain, in a pig), the new viruses can get some segments from each, which is called reassortment. This can give a new strain to which people have no immunity, and has led to flu pandemics. Processes that increase variation are widespread: crossing over and independent assortment in meiosis (lesson 5.2) are found in plants, animals, and fungi, and mechanisms for exchanging DNA are found in bacteria and archaea. The fact that they are shared by so many organisms, as with the genetic code (lesson 6.4), is evidence for a common origin of these processes.

Exam focus
  • Mutations are random. The environment selects among existing variants; it does not create them. Replica plating shows resistance is present before exposure.
  • Four mechanisms of horizontal gene transfer: transformation (uptake of DNA), transduction (virus carries DNA), conjugation (cell-to-cell, plasmid), transposition (jumping segment).
  • Plasmids with resistance genes spread resistance; antibiotic use selects for resistant bacteria.
  • Related viruses can recombine in the same host (flu reassortment).
  • Avoid Lamarckian wording: bacteria did not “become resistant to survive”; the resistant variants already there were selected.
Practice
  1. Name the horizontal transfer process in each case: (a) a bacterium takes up a plasmid from the medium; (b) a bacteriophage carries bacterial DNA to a new cell; (c) two bacteria connect by a pilus and pass a plasmid.
    Show answer

    (a) Transformation. (b) Transduction. (c) Conjugation.

  2. Explain how the results of replica plating show that mutations for resistance are random and not caused by the antibiotic.
    Show answer

    Resistant colonies appeared at the same positions on every replica plate. This means that the resistant cells were present in the original colonies before they were exposed to the antibiotic, so the mutation was not caused by it. The antibiotic only selected the cells that were already resistant.

  3. A culture of \(5 \times 10^8\) cells has a frequency of \(2 \times 10^{-8}\) for a mutation to resistance. Calculate the expected number of resistant cells.
    Show answer

    \(5 \times 10^8 \times 2 \times 10^{-8} = 10\) resistant cells.

  4. Describe how a resistance gene that arose in one species of bacteria could end up in a different species.
    Show answer

    The gene could be on a plasmid or a transposon that is passed to a cell of another species by conjugation (or carried there by a virus in transduction, or taken up from the medium by transformation). The recipient cell then expresses the gene and is resistant.

  5. A patient takes only half of a course of antibiotics, and the infection returns and resists the drug. Explain, using natural selection and avoiding Lamarckian language.
    Show answer

    The population of bacteria contained some cells with variants that were more resistant. The antibiotic killed most of the sensitive cells but not all of the resistant cells, which survived, reproduced, and passed on the resistance genes (vertically, and possibly horizontally), so the infection that returned consisted mostly of resistant cells. The drug did not cause resistance; it selected it.

  6. Describe how two different strains of influenza virus can give a new strain.
    Show answer

    If both strains infect the same host cell, the eight RNA segments of each genome can be mixed (reassortment) in the new virus particles. A new virus can thus have a combination of segments from the two strains, with different surface proteins, to which the immune system has not been exposed.

Lesson 6.9 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.8

Biotechnology: reading and editing DNA

A single hair left at a crime scene, a few cells from an ancient bone, and a nasal swab from a patient are all enough for a laboratory to identify who they came from or which virus is present. Bacteria carrying a human gene make insulin for millions of people. These techniques rest on what you have learned in this unit: DNA pairs by complementary bases, can be cut and joined, is copied by a polymerase, and can be transferred between organisms because the genetic code is shared. This lesson covers the tools that the CED lists and the calculations that the exam asks for.

Learning objective · 6.8.A

Explain the use of genetic engineering techniques in analyzing or manipulating DNA.

The toolkit

Required content · EK 6.8.A.1

Genetic engineering techniques can be used to analyze and manipulate DNA and RNA.

  • Gel electrophoresis is a process that separates DNA fragments by size and charge.
  • During polymerase chain reaction (PCR), DNA fragments are amplified by denaturing DNA, annealing primers to the original strand, and extending the new DNA molecule.
  • Bacterial transformation introduces foreign DNA into bacterial cells.
  • DNA sequencing technology determines the order of nucleotides in a DNA molecule. Typically, these techniques result in a DNA fingerprint that allows for the comparison of DNA sequences from various samples.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of the details of each of these genetic engineering techniques is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Gel electrophoresis and restriction enzymes

negative electrode (−)positive electrode (+)laddersampleundigested10,0005,0003,0002,0001,000500DNA movestoward +small piecesmove farther
Figure 6.9b Gel electrophoresis separates DNA fragments by size and charge. DNA is negatively charged, so it moves toward the positive electrode through the gel, and shorter fragments move faster and farther. The sizes of unknown fragments can be estimated from the ladder.

DNA can be cut at specific sequences by restriction enzymes (restriction endonucleases), which come from bacteria, where they protect the cell by cutting the DNA of invading viruses. Each enzyme recognizes a short sequence of 4 to 8 base pairs, often a palindrome (the same sequence read 5′ to 3′ on both strands): EcoRI cuts at 5′-GAATTC-3′. A long DNA molecule is thus cut into fragments whose sizes depend on where the recognition sites are. Many enzymes make a staggered cut and leave short single-stranded “sticky ends”, and DNA cut with the same enzyme from two sources can be joined by base pairing and by ligase.

The fragments are separated by gel electrophoresis. The DNA is placed in wells at one end of a slab of agarose gel, a mesh of polysaccharide, in a buffer, and an electric field is applied. The phosphate groups make DNA negatively charged, so the DNA moves toward the positive electrode. The gel acts as a sieve: short fragments move faster and farther, and long ones are held back. The DNA is stained to show bands, and a ladder of fragments of known sizes is run in one lane for comparison. For a ladder, the distance traveled is roughly proportional to the logarithm of the size (a straight line on a graph of distance against log size), so an unknown band can be sized by comparison.

Worked example · Sizing fragments and reading a digest

On the gel shown, the ladder bands are at the following distances (in mm) from the well: 10,000 bp at 12; 5,000 at 22; 3,000 at 29; 2,000 at 35; 1,500 at 39; 1,000 at 45; 500 at 55. A circular plasmid digested with EcoRI gives two bands, at 32 mm and at 42 mm. (a) Estimate the sizes. (b) Estimate the size of the plasmid and the number of EcoRI sites. (c) Explain why the undigested plasmid runs differently.

(a) The band at 32 mm is between 3,000 (29 mm) and 2,000 (35 mm), halfway (\((32-29)/(35-29) = 0.5\)). Halfway on the log scale: \(\log_{10}(3{,}000) = 3.477\) and \(\log_{10}(2{,}000) = 3.301\), the mean is 3.389, and \(10^{3.389} \approx 2{,}450\), so about 2,500 bp. The band at 42 mm is halfway between 1,500 (39) and 1,000 (45): the mean of 3.176 and 3.000 is 3.088, and \(10^{3.088} \approx 1{,}220\), so about 1,200 bp.
(b) The fragments of a digested plasmid add up to the whole plasmid: \(2{,}500 + 1{,}200 = 3{,}700\) bp. A circular molecule that is cut at \(n\) sites gives \(n\) fragments, so two fragments mean two EcoRI sites.
(c) In the gel shown, the uncut plasmid is a single band near the top. Circular DNA does not move like a linear fragment of the same length: a relaxed (nicked) circle moves more slowly, and a supercoiled circle faster than the relaxed form, so an uncut plasmid cannot be sized from a linear ladder.
Reasoning. A log scale is used because the mobility depends on the logarithm of the size; estimates from a gel are approximate (here to about 5%).

PCR: copying DNA in a test tube

1. Denature95 °C: strands separateheat2. Anneal55 to 60 °C: primers bindprimers3. Extend72 °C: polymerase copiesPEach cycle doubles the number of copies of the target DNA0 cycles11 cycles22 cycles43 cycles810 cycles1,02420 cycles1,048,57630 cycles1.07 billion
Figure 6.9a In PCR, DNA fragments are amplified by denaturing the DNA, annealing primers to the original strand, and extending the new DNA molecule. Because the number of copies doubles each cycle, n cycles give 2 to the nth power copies of the target from one starting molecule.

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR), invented by Kary Mullis in 1983, makes millions of copies of a chosen DNA segment from a tiny sample. The tube contains the sample DNA, two short synthetic primers (complementary to the ends of the region to be copied), nucleotides, and a heat-stable DNA polymerase (from a bacterium that lives in hot springs, so that it is not destroyed by the heat). Each cycle has three steps, controlled by temperature: denaturation (about 95 °C, which separates the strands), annealing (about 55 to 60 °C, when the primers base pair with the single strands), and extension (about 72 °C, when the polymerase adds nucleotides to the primers). Each cycle doubles the amount of target DNA, so after \(n\) cycles there are \(2^n\) copies per starting molecule: 25 cycles give \(2^{25} = 33{,}554{,}432\) copies, and 30 cycles about \(2^{30} = 1.07 \times 10^9\). PCR is used to detect viruses (such as the coronavirus that causes COVID-19), to diagnose genetic diseases, to prepare DNA for sequencing, to identify an organism from its DNA, and to study the evolutionary relationships of species (phylogenetic analysis), even from ancient or degraded samples.

Bacterial transformation and gene cloning

In the laboratory, transformation (lesson 6.8) is used to introduce a gene into bacteria. A gene of interest and a plasmid are cut with the same restriction enzyme, mixed, and joined by ligase to make a recombinant plasmid. The plasmid is added to bacteria that have been treated (with calcium ions and a heat shock) so that their membranes take up DNA. The plasmid also carries a gene for antibiotic resistance as a marker, so that only cells that took up the plasmid grow on a medium with the antibiotic. Each transformed cell grows into a colony (a clone) with many copies of the plasmid, which is how a fragment of DNA is propagated: gene cloning. If the gene is expressed (the code is universal, lesson 6.4), the bacteria make the protein: human insulin, growth hormone, and clotting factors are produced in this way. Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) have DNA from another species; transgenic animals, for example, carry a gene that was introduced into the genome.

Worked example · Transformation efficiency

A student mixes 0.25 µg of a plasmid with competent E. coli, heat-shocks them, and brings the mixture to a total volume of 1,000 µL. She spreads 200 µL on an agar plate with ampicillin and counts 150 colonies. Calculate the transformation efficiency in colonies per microgram of DNA.

Total colonies. The plate had \(200/1{,}000 = 1/5\) of the mixture, so the whole mixture would give \(150 \times 5 = 750\) colonies.
Efficiency. \(750 / 0.25 = 3{,}000\) colonies per µg, or \(3.0 \times 10^3\).
Reasoning. Only transformed cells, which have the plasmid with the ampicillin-resistance gene, can grow on the plate, so each colony is one transformed cell. Most cells are not transformed, which is why the efficiency is far lower than 100%.

Sequencing and DNA fingerprints

DNA sequencing determines the order of the nucleotides in a DNA molecule. Modern methods read millions of fragments at once, and the first human genome (3.2 billion base pairs) was completed in 2003 after 13 years, while it can now be done in a day. A DNA fingerprint is a pattern that identifies a person by looking at regions of the genome, such as short tandem repeats (STRs), which vary in the number of repeats from person to person. The regions are amplified by PCR and separated by size. Two samples that come from the same person show the same pattern; related people share some bands. Used for forensic identification, paternity tests, and the identification of species, the pattern from a sample is compared with others.

Worked example · Matching a DNA fingerprint

DNA from a crime scene gives fragments of 2.1, 1.4, and 0.8 kb. Suspect A has 2.1, 1.1, and 0.8 kb, and suspect B has 2.1, 1.4, and 0.8 kb. If the probability that a random person has a particular band is 0.1 and the bands are independent, calculate the probability of a chance match at all three, and interpret.

Comparison. Suspect B matches all three bands. Suspect A has a band at 1.1 kb instead of 1.4, so A is excluded (a single mismatch is enough to exclude).
Probability. By the product rule (lesson 5.3): \(0.1 \times 0.1 \times 0.1 = 0.001\), or 1 in 1,000. This is not enough to identify a person on its own: real tests use many more loci (13 or more), which give probabilities of 1 in billions or smaller.
Interpretation. The match is consistent with suspect B but does not prove guilt: it shows that B cannot be excluded and that the sample is from someone with this pattern, and the more regions that are compared, the stronger the evidence.

Exam focus
  • Gel electrophoresis: DNA is negative; moves toward +; smaller fragments move farther. Use a ladder (log scale) to estimate sizes. Fragments of a digest add up to the size of the DNA.
  • Restriction enzymes cut at specific sequences (circular DNA with \(n\) sites gives \(n\) fragments); sticky ends can be joined by ligase.
  • PCR: denature, anneal primers, extend (heat-stable polymerase); \(2^n\) copies after \(n\) cycles.
  • Transformation: plasmid + antibiotic resistance marker; only transformed cells grow on the antibiotic. Efficiency = colonies per µg of DNA (scale up for the fraction plated).
  • Sequencing / fingerprints: compare patterns; one mismatch excludes; more loci mean stronger evidence. Applications: forensics, identification, phylogeny, GMOs, cloning.
  • The details of each method are beyond the scope of the AP exam, but you must be able to interpret the results and say what each technique is used for.
Practice
  1. Explain why DNA fragments move toward the positive electrode, and why shorter fragments travel farther in the gel.
    Show answer

    DNA has a negative charge because of the phosphate groups of its backbone, so it is attracted to the positive electrode. The gel is a mesh through which short fragments can move more easily than long fragments, so shorter pieces move faster and farther in the same time.

  2. A linear DNA molecule of 6,000 bp is cut by a restriction enzyme at two sites and gives fragments of 1,500 and 2,000 bp and a third one. Calculate the size of the third fragment, and the number of cuts.
    Show answer

    The third fragment is \(6{,}000 - 1{,}500 - 2{,}000 = 2{,}500\) bp. A linear molecule that is cut at two sites gives three fragments, so there were two cuts.

  3. Calculate the number of copies of a target after 12 PCR cycles starting from one molecule, and from 50 molecules after 10 cycles.
    Show answer

    \(2^{12} = 4{,}096\) copies. From 50 molecules after 10 cycles: \(50 \times 2^{10} = 50 \times 1{,}024 = 51{,}200\) copies.

  4. In a transformation experiment, plates with ampicillin show no colonies for the control that had no plasmid, but 80 colonies for the sample with plasmid. Explain the roles of the control and of ampicillin.
    Show answer

    Ampicillin kills bacteria that do not have the resistance gene on the plasmid, so only transformed cells form colonies. The control without plasmid shows that the bacteria are not already resistant and that the ampicillin works: no colonies grow. The colonies of the other plate are therefore the result of the plasmid.

  5. 0.5 µg of plasmid was used and 100 µL out of 500 µL was plated, giving 240 colonies. Calculate the transformation efficiency.
    Show answer

    Total colonies \(= 240 \times 500/100 = 1{,}200\). Efficiency \(= 1{,}200/0.5 = 2{,}400\) colonies per µg.

  6. Describe two uses of PCR and explain why a heat-stable DNA polymerase is needed.
    Show answer

    Uses: detecting a virus in a sample; making enough DNA for sequencing or for a DNA fingerprint in forensics (also identifying species and diagnosing genetic diseases). A heat-stable polymerase is needed because each cycle includes a step at about 95 °C to separate the strands, which would denature an ordinary enzyme, so it would have to be added again after each cycle.

Unit 6 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 6 quiz: Gene Expression and Regulation

Fifteen multiple-choice questions and five short free-response questions covering the experiments that identified DNA, replication, transcription and RNA processing, translation and the genetic code, operons and epigenetic regulation, mutations and horizontal gene transfer, and the tools of biotechnology: click an option to see why each answer works or fails, and write each FRQ on paper before you open the model response.

Multiple choice

  1. Data: a repetition of the Hershey–Chase experiment. T2 bacteriophage were grown with either 35S or 32P, allowed to infect E. coli for ten minutes, blended to shear off the spent coats, and centrifuged. Heavy bacteria form the pellet; light phage ghosts stay in the supernatant.

    Labeled phageRadioactivity in pellet (cells)Radioactivity in supernatant (ghosts)
    35S, labels protein only18%82%
    32P, labels DNA only72%28%

    Which conclusion is best supported by these data?

    Correct. Sulfur labels only protein and phosphorus only DNA, so the two rows track the two candidate molecules independently. Four-fifths of the protein label stays outside with the ghosts while nearly three-quarters of the DNA label goes in with the cells that make new phage, which identifies DNA as the injected genetic material.

    Radioactivity appears in both fractions because separation is imperfect, not because both molecules enter. The design answers the question through the difference between the two rows, and 18% versus 72% is not an equal split by any reading.

    DNA contains phosphorus in its sugar–phosphate backbone and the protein coat contains essentially none, which is exactly why 32P is a DNA label. The coat is protein, which is why it carries the 35S and is left behind in the supernatant.

    An 18% carryover is what you expect when blending does not shear every coat free of every cell, and it is the small fraction rather than the large one. The comparison that matters is 18% against 72%: the isotope that ends up inside the infected cells is the one in DNA.

  2. In the Avery–MacLeod–McCarty experiment, extract from heat-killed S cells was divided among tubes treated with protease, with RNase, or with DNase before being mixed with live R cells. Why was it essential to include the protease and RNase treatments rather than testing DNase alone?

    DNase acts on DNA in a crude mixture perfectly well, and the three enzymes were used on separate portions of the same extract rather than in sequence. Reading them as purification steps loses the entire logic of the design, which is elimination one component at a time.

    Correct. Without them, a critic could argue that any enzyme treatment, or simply the handling, ruins the extract. Protease and RNase show that the extract survives an equally destructive treatment aimed at a different molecule, so only the removal of DNA abolishes the transforming activity.

    The extract certainly contained protein and RNA: that is why those enzymes had something to digest. What the experiment shows is that neither of those molecules is required for transformation, which is a different claim from their being absent.

    The dependent variable is whether R cells are converted into S cells, not whether R cells survive. All three treatments had to leave the R cells alive for the assay to work at all, so killing them would have destroyed the experiment rather than served as a control.

  3. Data: base composition, in mol %, of nucleic acid isolated from three sources.

    SampleATGC
    P31.031.019.019.0
    Q17.517.532.532.5
    R24.032.026.018.0

    Which statement is best supported by the data?

    A low G + C content is normal for double-stranded DNA, the A + T to G + C ratio varies widely among species, and sample P satisfies both Chargaff equalities exactly. Strandedness is read from the equalities, not from the size of the GC fraction.

    This reverses the relationship. Sample Q is 65% G + C and sample P is 38%, and each G–C pair is held by three hydrogen bonds rather than two, so Q requires a higher temperature to melt.

    The premise is true and the conclusion does not follow: in sample R, A + G = 50.0 and T + C = 50.0, yet A ≠ T. Chargaff's rule for double-stranded DNA is the stricter pairwise equality, because every A is hydrogen-bonded to a specific T and every G to a specific C.

    Correct. In sample R, A is 24.0 while T is 32.0, and G is 26.0 while C is 18.0. With no complementary partner strand, nothing forces those equalities, so a molecule that breaks both of them is single-stranded.

  4. Figure: one replication fork of a bacterial chromosome, drawn as the parental duplex opens toward the right.

    The upper parental strand runs 3' at the left end to 5' at the right end; the lower parental strand runs 5' at the left to 3' at the right. Against the upper parental strand a single new strand is drawn as one long arrow whose head points right, toward the fork. Against the lower parental strand three short new arrows are drawn, each with its head pointing left, away from the fork, and each begins with a short segment shaded differently from the rest of the arrow.

    Which statement about the three short new segments is correct?

    Helicase unwinds the double helix as a unit, so both templates become available at the same rate. The asymmetry comes from the antiparallel arrangement of the two parental strands, which is a matter of orientation rather than speed.

    The leading strand is the continuous arrow on the upper template, drawn as a single piece pointing toward the fork. The differently shaded starts are RNA primers laid down by primase, not binding proteins: single-strand binding proteins coat the separated parental DNA and are not part of the new strand.

    Correct. Because the lower template runs 5'→3' toward the fork, a new strand copied from it must grow away from the fork to keep its own 5'→3' direction. That forces discontinuous synthesis: the polymerase waits for more template, a new primer is laid, and another fragment is built, later joined by DNA polymerase I and ligase.

    No DNA polymerase synthesizes 3'→5'; the enzyme attaches each incoming nucleotide's phosphate to the free 3'-OH at the end of the growing chain, which makes 5'→3' the only possible direction. The fragments point away from the fork despite that rule, not because of an exception to it.

  5. Figure: mean telomere length versus number of population doublings for two cultures of human fibroblasts.

    Both axes are linear: population doublings from 0 to 60 on the x-axis, mean telomere length from 0 to 12 kilobases on the y-axis. Curve A, untreated fibroblasts, starts at 10 kb and falls as a straight line to 5 kb at 50 doublings, where the cells stop dividing. Curve B, the same fibroblasts after an active telomerase gene was introduced, starts at 10 kb and stays within 0.3 kb of 10 kb all the way to 60 doublings, and those cells are still dividing.

    Which statement best explains the difference between the two curves?

    Proofreading and mismatch repair are functions of DNA polymerase III and the repair system; telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that extends chromosome ends using its own RNA template. Error rate and end shortening are separate problems, and the graph measures length, not fidelity.

    Correct. Curve A falls 5 kb over 50 doublings, which is \(5/50 = 0.1\) kb, about 100 base pairs, lost per division, exactly the end-replication problem. Telomerase adds repeats back onto the 3' overhang, which is why curve B holds steady and those cells keep dividing past the point where curve A arrests.

    Speed is irrelevant to the problem. However fast the polymerase runs, it still cannot replace the terminal RNA primer on the lagging strand, because replacement requires a free 3'-OH upstream and there is no DNA there to provide one.

    Replication is semiconservative in all cells, as Meselson and Stahl showed, and a change in that mechanism is not something a single introduced gene could produce. Conservative replication would also not solve end shortening, since the new duplex would still be built by the same primer-dependent polymerase.

  6. The template strand of a short gene reads 3'-TACCCGAAGGTTACT-5'. Which choice gives the mRNA transcript and the coding strand correctly?

    Correct. Pairing A→U, T→A, C→G, G→C down the template gives 5'-AUGGGCUUCCAAUGA-3', which reads AUG GGC UUC CAA UGA: start, Gly, Phe, Gln, stop. The coding strand is that same sequence with T for U, which is the check worth running: the mRNA always matches the coding strand, never the template.

    The coding strand is right, but the mRNA has been written in the wrong direction; this is the correct transcript read 3' to 5' and then labeled as though it were 5' to 3'. Because the template is given 3'→5' from left to right, its complement comes out 5'→3' in the same left-to-right order.

    The mRNA is right, but the coding strand cannot be the template: those are the two different strands of the duplex. The coding strand is the one whose sequence the mRNA reproduces, so it reads 5'-ATGGGCTTCCAATGA-3'.

    This copies the template letter for letter, swapping U for T, instead of pairing each template base with its complement. Transcription is complementary base pairing, so a template T specifies an A in the RNA, not a U, and a transcript beginning UAC has no start codon.

  7. Data: three human protein-coding genes compared. In each gene the first and last exon are always retained, and every internal exon can independently be included or skipped during splicing.

    GenePQR
    Pre-mRNA length (nt)12,0004,0002,500
    Mature mRNA length (nt)1,5003,2001,000
    Number of exons943

    Which statement is best supported by the data?

    Correct. Gene P removes \((12{,}000-1{,}500)/12{,}000 = 87.5\%\) against 20.0% for Q and 60.0% for R, and with 9 exons it has 7 internal exons that can each be kept or skipped, giving \(2^{7} = 128\) combinations versus 4 for Q and 2 for R.

    Mature mRNA length says nothing about splice-variant number; what matters is how many internal exons are optional. Gene Q has only 2 internal exons, so it tops out at \(2^{2} = 4\) mature mRNAs even though its finished transcript is the longest of the three.

    Gene R loses 1,500 nucleotides, but gene P loses \(12{,}000 - 1{,}500 = 10{,}500\), so R does not lose the most in absolute terms either. As a fraction, R removes 60.0% and P removes 87.5%, so the claim fails on both readings.

    Alternative splicing means the same pre-mRNA can be cut in more than one way, some internal exons are removed along with the introns that flank them, which is precisely why one gene can specify several proteins. If splicing were fixed, there would be exactly one mature mRNA per gene.

  8. An mRNA reads 5'-AUGCACGGAUCCUAG-3'. How many amino acids does the polypeptide contain, and what anticodon does the tRNA that delivers the third amino acid carry?

    This counts the stop codon as a fifth amino acid. UAG is read by a release factor, not by a charged tRNA, and no residue is added when it enters the A site: the polypeptide is simply let go.

    Correct. The triplets are AUG CAC GGA UCC UAG, which is Met–His–Gly–Ser–stop, so four amino acids are joined. The third amino acid is glycine from the codon 5'-GGA-3', and its anticodon pairs antiparallel and complementary: 3'-CCU-5'.

    An anticodon is complementary to its codon, not identical to it. Writing 5'-GGA-3' simply repeats the codon, which would leave the tRNA unable to base-pair with the message at all.

    The anticodon is right, but the initiator methionine is a real residue in the polypeptide as it comes off the ribosome. It is often cleaved off afterward by a separate enzyme, which is why sickle-cell is called a change at the sixth residue of the mature β chain, but the ribosome still made it.

  9. Data: growth of wild-type Neurospora crassa and three arginine-requiring mutants on minimal medium and on minimal medium supplemented with one intermediate of the arginine pathway, which runs precursor → ornithine → citrulline → arginine.

    StrainMinimal+ ornithine+ citrulline+ arginine
    Wild typegrowsgrowsgrowsgrows
    arg-1nonenonenonegrows
    arg-2nonenonegrowsgrows
    arg-3nonegrowsgrowsgrows

    Which strain carries a defect in the enzyme that converts ornithine to citrulline?

    arg-1 grows only when arginine itself is supplied, so it is blocked at the last step, converting citrulline to arginine. Supplying ornithine or citrulline does not help because neither can get past that block.

    Correct. A mutant grows on any intermediate downstream of its block. arg-2 is rescued by citrulline and arginine but not by ornithine, which places the broken enzyme exactly between ornithine and citrulline.

    arg-3 is rescued by all three supplements, including the earliest one, so its block lies before ornithine, in the conversion of the precursor to ornithine. The rule to remember is that the more supplements rescue a strain, the earlier its block.

    Wild type is the control, and it grows everywhere precisely because it has every enzyme in the pathway. Its row establishes that the media themselves support growth, so a "none" in any mutant row reflects a missing enzyme rather than a bad plate.

  10. E. coli growing in medium containing both lactose and glucose makes only a small amount of β-galactosidase. Which statement best explains this result?

    The operator is bound by the repressor protein, not by a sugar, and glucose never contacts the DNA. Mistaking a small-molecule signal for a DNA-binding protein loses the two-layer design that makes catabolite repression work.

    Regulation changes how much a gene is transcribed; it does not delete or restore genes. A cell that discarded lacZ in glucose could never induce it again when lactose returned, which is the opposite of what the wild type does.

    This describes the trp operon's corepressor logic, not the lac operon's. The lac repressor is switched off by allolactose and has no binding site for glucose; glucose acts one level up, through cAMP and CAP.

    Correct. Two switches control this operon. Lactose removes the block, and low glucose supplies the push: when glucose is abundant, cAMP falls, CAP cannot bind upstream of the promoter, and transcription is weak even with the operator free. The cell builds the enzymes only when lactose is present and the better fuel is not.

  11. A hepatocyte and a neuron taken from the same person contain identical DNA sequences but very different sets of proteins. Which statement best explains this difference?

    Somatic mutations do accumulate, but they are rare, random, and scattered, so they cannot produce the reproducible, cell-type-specific protein profiles that define a hepatocyte or a neuron in every person. A mechanism that explains a reliable outcome cannot itself be random.

    The stem states that the DNA sequences are identical, and that is the experimental fact: every somatic cell descends by mitosis from one zygote and inherits the whole genome. Differentiation changes which genes are read, not which genes are present.

    Correct. A cell's identity is essentially the set of transcription factors it is expressing; those proteins bind enhancers and promoters and recruit the transcription machinery to a particular subset of genes. Epigenetic marks such as promoter methylation and histone acetylation keep that subset stable through mitosis.

    The genetic code is nearly universal (the same codon table runs in bacteria, yeast, and every cell of your body), which is why a bacterium can be engineered to build human insulin. Two cells of one person certainly do not read different codes.

  12. Sequence: the first six triplets of the template strand of a gene, written 3' to 5'.

    3'-TAC AGA GGT CTC TTC ACC-5'. A single base substitution changes the sixth template triplet from ACC to ACT. No other change is made to the gene.

    Which classification of this mutation, with its predicted effect on the polypeptide, is correct?

    Redundancy often does make third-position changes silent, but not always, and this is one of the exceptions: the original codon UGG is the only codon for tryptophan, so any change to it must change the message. Checking the actual codon beats relying on the general rule.

    This is the outcome of a different substitution. Template ACC → ACA would give the mRNA codon UGU, which is cysteine, and that change would be missense. The substitution given here is to ACT, which specifies UGA.

    Correct. The template reads 3'-TAC AGA GGT CTC TTC ACC-5', so the mRNA is 5'-AUG UCU CCA GAG AAG UGG-3': Met–Ser–Pro–Glu–Lys–Trp. Changing the template's ACC to ACT makes that sixth codon UGA, a stop, so a release factor ends translation after five residues.

    Frameshifts are caused by insertions or deletions of a number of bases not divisible by three, which changes how the message is parsed downstream. A substitution swaps one base for another and leaves the total length, and therefore the reading frame, untouched.

  13. Colonies were grown on a non-selective master plate, stamped with sterile velvet onto several plates containing an antibiotic, and resistant colonies appeared at the same coordinates on every independent replica. Which conclusion is best supported?

    Correct. Because each replica preserves the master plate's colony map, identical positions across replicas trace the resistance back to particular master-plate colonies, and picking that colony from the never-exposed master plate yields an already-resistant culture. Selection edits existing variation; it does not create it.

    Individual organisms do not evolve, and a bacterium cannot direct a mutation to the gene it needs. The variation arises randomly during replication, and the environment then determines which pre-existing variants leave descendants.

    Conjugation would transfer resistance to whichever cells happened to be adjacent on each plate, which would scatter survivors differently on every replica. The perfectly reproducible pattern is exactly what horizontal transfer after stamping cannot produce.

    Independent plates could not agree on coordinates by chance if the antibiotic were creating the mutations after stamping; matching positions can only mean the difference was already there in the master plate's colonies. This is the reversed cause and effect the exam penalizes most heavily.

  14. Data: a 9,000 bp circular plasmid digested to completion with EcoRI alone, with BamHI alone, and with both enzymes together, then separated by gel electrophoresis.

    DigestEcoRI onlyBamHI onlyEcoRI + BamHI
    Fragment sizes (bp)9,0006,000 and 3,0004,000, 3,000, and 2,000

    Which statement is best supported by the gel?

    This swaps the two enzymes. BamHI produces two fragments and so has two sites; EcoRI produces one full-length linear molecule and so has one.

    The 3,000 bp band appears unchanged in both the BamHI lane and the double-digest lane, which is the evidence that EcoRI does not cut inside it. The fragment that disappears in the double digest is the one containing the extra site.

    One cut in a circle produces one linear molecule of the full length, which is the single 9,000 bp band in the EcoRI lane. Two cuts would give two fragments summing to 9,000, as the BamHI lane shows.

    Correct. The single full-length EcoRI band means one site; BamHI's two bands summing to 9,000 bp mean two sites. In the double digest the 3,000 bp band survives untouched while the 6,000 bp fragment is replaced by 4,000 and 2,000, which places the EcoRI site within it and fixes both distances.

  15. A student adds 0.25 µg of a plasmid carrying an ampicillin-resistance gene to competent E. coli, heat-shocks them, and brings the recovery mixture to a total volume of 1,000 µL. She spreads 200 µL on an LB/ampicillin plate and counts 96 colonies. What is the transformation efficiency?

    This is \(96/0.25\), which ignores the fact that only one-fifth of the mixture was plated. The colonies you counted came from the DNA in 200 µL, not from all 0.25 µg, so the dilution has to be applied before dividing.

    480 is the number of colonies the whole 1,000 µL would have produced: a useful intermediate, but not an efficiency, because efficiency is colonies per microgram of plasmid DNA. The last step, dividing by 0.25 µg, is still missing.

    Correct. The fraction plated is \(200/1000 = 0.20\), so the DNA represented on the plate is \(0.25 \times 0.20 = 0.050\) µg, and \(96/0.050 = 1{,}920\) colonies/µg. Cross-check the other way: 96 colonies from one-fifth implies 480 in the whole mixture, and \(480/0.25 = 1{,}920\).

    This divides by 0.010 µg, as though one twenty-fifth of the mixture had been plated. Multiplying by the dilution factor twice, once on the volume and again on the mass, is the usual route to a five-fold overestimate, and the units do not catch it.

Free response

  1. Data: a density-gradient investigation. E. coli were grown for many generations in medium whose only nitrogen source was 15N, then transferred at time zero into medium containing only 14N. A sample was taken each generation, its DNA was spun to equilibrium in a cesium chloride gradient, and the percentage of DNA at each of three band positions was recorded.

    Generations after transfer0123
    % at heavy position100000
    % at hybrid position01005025
    % at light position005075

    Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in this investigation, and describe the purpose of the generation-0 sample.
    2. Explain how the generation-1 result eliminates the conservative model of replication.
    3. Predict the percentage of DNA at the hybrid position after four generations, and show the calculation that supports your prediction.
    4. Justify the claim that replication is semiconservative rather than dispersive, using evidence from more than one generation.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the independent variable is the number of generations after the transfer to 14N medium; the generation-0 sample marks the position of fully heavy DNA in the gradient so that later bands can be located relative to it. Accept "a reference/control that establishes the heavy band position". Do not accept: naming 15N as the independent variable; naming the variable with no description of the sample's purpose; "it is the control" with no statement of what it establishes.
    • (b) Accept: the conservative model predicts that the two original strands stay together, so generation 1 would show a heavy band and a light band and no DNA in between; the data show 100% at a single intermediate position, which conservative replication cannot produce. Do not accept: "the DNA was hybrid, so it is semiconservative" with no statement of what conservative predicted; describing the conservative model without applying it to generation 1.
    • (c) Accept: 12.5%, supported by \(2/2^{4} = 2/16 = 0.125\): only the two original 15N strands can ever be in hybrid molecules, and the total number of molecules doubles each generation. Accept the equivalent \(1/2^{\,n-1}\) form. Do not accept: a value with no calculation; 6.25% (an extra generation); any answer implying the hybrid band disappears.
    • (d) Accept: dispersive replication predicts one band that drifts steadily lighter and never splits, because every strand is a patchwork; the data show a single hybrid band at generation 1 that then splits into two discrete bands at generations 2 and 3, with a constant hybrid position. The evidence must be tied to at least two generations. Do not accept: citing generation 1 alone (both models predict one intermediate band); a conclusion with no reference to what dispersive replication predicts.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is the number of generations the cells have grown in 14N after the switch. The generation-0 sample is taken before any replication in light medium, so it shows where fully heavy DNA sits in the gradient and gives me a reference position to compare every later band against.

    b If replication were conservative, the two original 15N strands would stay paired with each other and the brand-new duplex would be all 14N, so generation 1 should show two bands, one heavy and one light, and nothing in between. Instead 100% of the DNA sits at one intermediate position, which means every molecule contains one old strand and one new one.

    c Only the two original heavy strands exist, and they can never be in more than two molecules. After 4 generations there are \(2^{4} = 16\) molecules per starting duplex, so hybrid \(= 2/16 = 0.125 = 12.5\%\), and the other 87.5% is light.

    d The dispersive model says every strand is a patchwork of old and new, so there should be one band that gets steadily lighter each generation and never splits. The data show the opposite: at generation 1 there is one hybrid band, and at generations 2 and 3 it splits into two separate bands, with the hybrid band staying at exactly the same position while it shrinks from 50% to 25%. A fixed hybrid position plus a second, distinct light band is what semiconservative replication predicts and dispersive replication cannot give.

  2. Data: β-galactosidase activity, in arbitrary units, for wild-type E. coli and three mutant strains grown in three media. Glycerol supplies carbon without lactose or glucose.

    StrainGlycerol+ lactose+ lactose and glucose
    Wild type42,00080
    Strain 11,6001,70070
    Strain 256055
    Strain 3354

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the strain that expresses the operon constitutively, and describe the evidence in the table that supports your choice.
    2. Explain why wild-type cells produce far less β-galactosidase in lactose plus glucose than in lactose alone.
    3. Calculate the fold induction by lactose for the wild type and for strain 1. Show your setup.
    4. Justify a conclusion about which component of the lac system is defective in strain 2, using evidence from the table.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: strain 1, because its activity in glycerol is 1,600 units (nearly its fully induced level of 1,700), so it makes the enzyme with no lactose present, which is what constitutive means. Do not accept: naming strain 1 with no number cited; "it is always on" with no reference to the glycerol column; selecting strain 2 or 3.
    • (b) Accept: glucose lowers cAMP, so the CAP activator cannot bind upstream of the lac promoter and RNA polymerase binds only weakly; the repressor is already off the operator because allolactose is present, so the loss of activity is due to the missing activator, not to repression. Do not accept: "glucose represses the operon" with no mechanism; claiming the repressor rebinds in the presence of glucose; any answer that never mentions cAMP or CAP.
    • (c) Accept: wild type \(2{,}000/4 = 500\)-fold; strain 1 \(1{,}700/1{,}600 = 1.06\)-fold (accept ≈1.1 or "about 1-fold, essentially no induction"). Setup must be shown. Do not accept: differences instead of ratios (1,996 and 100); a ratio taken against the lactose-plus-glucose column; bare numbers with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: the cAMP–CAP activation system is defective, justified by the pattern that strain 2 is inducible but only to 60 units, a 12-fold rise, and that adding glucose barely changes it (55 versus 60, about a 9% drop) whereas glucose cuts the wild type by 96%. The repressor must still work because activity in glycerol is at background. Do not accept: "the repressor is broken" (contradicted by the glycerol column); naming CAP with no supporting numbers; a claim with no comparison to the wild-type glucose effect.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Strain 1 is constitutive. In glycerol, with no lactose anywhere, it already shows 1,600 units, and adding lactose only takes it to 1,700, so it is making β-galactosidase all the time instead of only when the substrate is there. Either its repressor protein or its operator is broken.

    b In lactose alone, allolactose knocks the repressor off the operator and low glucose means cAMP is high, so CAP binds upstream and helps RNA polymerase onto the promoter. Adding glucose drops cAMP, CAP goes inactive, and without that activator the polymerase binds the lac promoter weakly, so transcription, and enzyme activity, falls to 80 units even though the operator is free.

    c Wild type: \(2{,}000/4 = 500\)-fold induction. Strain 1: \(1{,}700/1{,}600 = 1.06\)-fold, so essentially none.

    d Strain 2's CAP activation is broken. Its glycerol value of 5 units is background, so the repressor still holds the operator shut, and lactose does induce it, but only to 60 units, 12-fold instead of 500-fold. The clincher is the glucose column: glucose cuts wild type from 2,000 to 80, a 96% drop, but only takes strain 2 from 60 to 55, about 9%. A strain that barely notices glucose is a strain that was never getting the CAP boost in the first place.

  3. Model: a scale drawing of a eukaryotic protein-coding gene, read left to right along the coding strand from 5' to 3'.

    The labeled segments, in order from left to right, are: a promoter of 150 base pairs; exon 1, 210 base pairs; intron 1, 1,500 base pairs; exon 2, 402 base pairs; intron 2, 900 base pairs; exon 3, 351 base pairs; and a polyadenylation signal at the right-hand end. Transcription begins at the first base of exon 1 and ends downstream of the polyadenylation signal. Assume that every base of the three exons is translated, including the stop codon.

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the segments of the primary transcript that are absent from the mature mRNA, and describe the structure that removes them.
    2. Explain why the promoter sequence is not represented in the mature mRNA even though the gene cannot be expressed without it.
    3. Calculate the length of the mature mRNA's coding sequence and the number of amino acids in the polypeptide it specifies. Show your setup.
    4. A student claims that a single-base substitution anywhere inside intron 1 cannot affect the protein. Justify a response to that claim, using the model as your evidence.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: intron 1 (1,500 nt) and intron 2 (900 nt) are transcribed but excised; the spliceosome, built from snRNPs, cuts them out and joins the flanking exons. Do not accept: naming the introns with no structure named; "enzymes remove them"; identifying the promoter or the poly-A tail as removed sequence.
    • (b) Accept: the promoter is the DNA sequence upstream of the transcription start site where RNA polymerase and general transcription factors assemble, and transcription begins downstream of it, so it is never copied into RNA; it acts as a binding site on DNA rather than as information carried in the message. Do not accept: "it is spliced out" (it is never transcribed); "it is not a gene"; a restatement that it is upstream with no consequence drawn.
    • (c) Accept: \(210 + 402 + 351 = 963\) nucleotides; \(963/3 = 321\) codons; one of those is the stop codon, so the polypeptide is 320 amino acids. Do not accept: including intron lengths; 321 amino acids (counting the stop codon as a residue); an answer with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: reject the claim, the spliceosome recognizes conserved sequences at each intron's 5' and 3' boundaries, and those bases lie inside intron 1, so a substitution at a splice site can prevent the cut and leave all 1,500 nucleotides of the intron in the mature mRNA; the ribosome then translates intron sequence until it reaches an in-frame stop codon, truncating or altering the protein. The evidence must name the splice site. Do not accept: "mutations can always matter" with no mechanism; agreeing with the student; claiming that a substitution anywhere in the intron would change the protein.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Intron 1 (1,500 nt) and intron 2 (900 nt) are in the primary transcript but not in the mature mRNA. The spliceosome, a complex of snRNPs and proteins, recognizes each intron's boundaries, cuts it out, and ligates exon 1 to exon 2 and exon 2 to exon 3.

    b The promoter is a stretch of DNA upstream of where transcription starts. RNA polymerase and general transcription factors assemble on it to position the polymerase, and then the polymerase begins copying at the first base of exon 1, so the promoter is behind the enzyme the whole time and never gets transcribed. It works as a landing pad on the DNA, not as information in the message.

    c Coding sequence \(= 210 + 402 + 351 = 963\) nucleotides. That is \(963/3 = 321\) codons, and one of them is the stop codon, which does not add a residue. So the polypeptide is 320 amino acids long.

    d I would reject the claim. The spliceosome finds an intron by its conserved sequences at the 5' and 3' ends, and those bases are inside intron 1. If a substitution destroys the 5' splice site, intron 1 is not cut out and all 1,500 of its nucleotides stay in the mature mRNA, so the ribosome translates intron sequence until it hits an in-frame stop, usually within a few dozen codons, and the protein comes out truncated or completely different. So a base deep in the middle of the intron probably does nothing, but a base at its boundary is as damaging as a mutation in an exon.

  4. A liquid culture of \(2.0 \times 10^{9}\) E. coli cells was grown from a single streptomycin-sensitive cell in antibiotic-free medium. The culture is then spread on plates containing streptomycin, and a small number of colonies grow. Answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the process that produced the streptomycin-resistance allele in this culture, and describe where in the cell the change occurred.
    2. Explain why exposure to streptomycin cannot have been the cause of the resistance alleles in this investigation.
    3. The spontaneous mutation rate at this locus is \(1.0 \times 10^{-8}\) per cell per generation. Calculate the expected number of resistant cells in the culture before it was plated. Show your setup.
    4. Justify the claim that the resistant cells were present before plating, using the design of a replica-plating experiment as your reasoning.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: spontaneous mutation, an uncorrected error during DNA replication (or damage by a mutagen), in the bacterium's chromosomal DNA, in the gene encoding the ribosomal target of streptomycin. Accept "a point mutation in a chromosomal gene". Do not accept: "the bacteria adapted"; naming mutation with no location; horizontal gene transfer, which is excluded because the culture descends from one cell in pure medium.
    • (b) Accept: the culture was grown in antibiotic-free medium from a single cell, so every cell's genome was copied billions of times before any cell met streptomycin; the antibiotic was added only at plating and therefore could not have directed a change that was already present. Mutations are random with respect to what the cell needs. Do not accept: "mutations are random" with no reference to this culture; any answer that allows the antibiotic to induce a specific useful change.
    • (c) Accept: \((1.0 \times 10^{-8})(2.0 \times 10^{9}) = 20\) resistant cells. Setup must be shown. Do not accept: a number with no multiplication shown; \(2 \times 10^{-17}\) or other order-of-magnitude errors; an answer given as a rate rather than a count.
    • (d) Accept: in replica plating, colonies are grown on a non-selective master plate and stamped onto antibiotic plates, and resistant colonies appear at the same coordinates on every independent replica; cells picked from that position on the never-exposed master plate are already resistant, which shows the allele existed before exposure. Selection acts on existing variation. Do not accept: restating the claim; describing replica plating with no statement of what the matching coordinates prove; using the plate count from (c) as the justification.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Spontaneous mutation produced it: an error during DNA replication that was not caught by proofreading or mismatch repair. The change is in the cell's chromosomal DNA, in the gene coding for the ribosomal protein that streptomycin binds, so the altered ribosome no longer binds the drug.

    b The whole culture grew from one sensitive cell in medium with no streptomycin in it, so all \(2.0 \times 10^{9}\) genomes were copied long before a single cell ever encountered the drug. Streptomycin was only added at the moment of plating, so it cannot have caused a change that had to exist already for those colonies to survive the plating. Mutations happen at random and the environment sorts them afterwards.

    c Expected resistant cells \(= (1.0 \times 10^{-8}\ \text{per cell})(2.0 \times 10^{9}\ \text{cells}) = 20\) cells. That handful is enough to explain the small number of colonies on the plate.

    d Replica plating settles it. You grow colonies on a plate with no antibiotic, press velvet onto it, and stamp several antibiotic plates so each replica keeps the same colony map. The resistant colonies come up at identical coordinates on every replica, which independent plates could never match by chance if the drug were creating the mutations, and when you go back and pick that colony from the master plate, which never met streptomycin, it is already resistant. That is direct evidence the allele was there first.

  5. Data: an agarose gel. Lane 1 holds a size ladder; lane 2 holds a circular plasmid of unknown size digested to completion with EcoRI. Migration distance is measured from the well.

    Ladder band1234
    Distance migrated (mm)15253545
    Fragment size (bp)8,0004,0002,0001,000

    Lane 2 contains exactly two bands, one at 20 mm and one at 30 mm.

    Using the gel, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the electrode toward which the fragments migrate, and describe the feature of DNA that makes them move that way.
    2. Explain why smaller fragments migrate farther through the agarose than larger ones.
    3. Construct a calibration graph: put distance migrated in mm on the x-axis with a scale from 0 to 50, put \(\log_{10}\) of fragment size on the y-axis with a scale from 3.0 to 4.0, label both axes, plot the four ladder bands, and draw a best-fit straight line. Then use the line to estimate the size of each band in lane 2, and calculate the total size of the plasmid.
    4. Justify the claim that this plasmid carries exactly two EcoRI recognition sites, using evidence from the gel.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: toward the positive electrode (anode), because the sugar–phosphate backbone carries a negative charge at every pH used for electrophoresis, so the whole molecule is an anion regardless of its base sequence. Do not accept: naming the electrode with no reason; attributing the charge to the nitrogenous bases; "DNA is attracted to the positive end" with no structural feature named.
    • (b) Accept: agarose is a porous mesh, and small fragments pass through the pores with less obstruction while large fragments are slowed by having to thread through, so in a fixed run time the small ones travel farther. Do not accept: "small ones are lighter"; "small ones move faster" with no reference to the gel matrix; restating the trend as its own explanation.
    • (c) Accept: distance on the x-axis (0–50 mm) and \(\log_{10}\) size on the y-axis (3.0–4.0), both labeled with units where applicable, the four ladder points plotted at (15, 3.90), (25, 3.60), (35, 3.30), (45, 3.00), and a best-fit straight line; then about 5,700 bp at 20 mm and about 2,800 bp at 30 mm (accept 5,500–5,900 and 2,700–2,900), and a plasmid of about 8,500 bp (accept 8,200–8,800). Do not accept: reversed axes; plotting raw size rather than its logarithm; interpolating on raw size, which gives 6,000 and 3,000 bp; a total with no sizes shown.
    • (d) Accept: the digest of a circular molecule produced two bands, and a circle must be cut twice before it yields two separate fragments, one cut converts a circle into a single full-length linear molecule. Therefore two sites. Do not accept: "two bands means two sites" stated for a linear molecule; counting the sites with no reference to the plasmid being circular; a claim with no evidence from the gel.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The fragments move toward the positive electrode. Every nucleotide in the sugar–phosphate backbone carries a negatively charged phosphate group at the pH of the running buffer, so a DNA fragment of any sequence is a large anion and is pulled toward the anode.

    b Agarose sets as a mesh full of pores. A short fragment slips through the pores with little obstruction, while a long fragment has to worm its way through and gets hung up constantly, so in the same run time the short fragment ends up farther from the well.

    c I put distance migrated (mm) on the x-axis from 0 to 50 and \(\log_{10}\)(size in bp) on the y-axis from 3.0 to 4.0, labeled both, and plotted (15, 3.90), (25, 3.60), (35, 3.30), and (45, 3.00), then drew a best-fit line through them; the line drops 0.301 log units per 10 mm. At 20 mm, \(\log_{10}S = 3.90 - 0.15 = 3.75\), so \(S \approx 5{,}700\) bp. At 30 mm, \(\log_{10}S = 3.60 - 0.15 = 3.45\), so \(S \approx 2{,}800\) bp. Plasmid \(= 5{,}700 + 2{,}800 \approx 8{,}500\) bp.

    d The plasmid is circular, and cutting a circle once just opens it into one linear molecule of the full length: you would see a single band. Lane 2 has two bands, so the circle had to be cut in two places to release two separate pieces. That is the evidence for exactly two EcoRI sites, and the two fragment sizes tell me how far apart they are around the circle.

Lesson 7.1 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.1

Introduction to natural selection

In the late 1940s, farmers and health workers began spraying houses and fields with DDT, and houseflies died by the millions. Within a few years the flies in many places were no longer dying. Nobody had changed the flies on purpose, and no single fly “learned” to survive the poison. The population had changed, because the few flies that happened to survive left nearly all of the offspring. That is the core of natural selection, the idea Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace proposed in 1858 and that Darwin developed in On the Origin of Species (1859). This lesson sets out the logic of the theory, what “fitness” means in biology, and why the direction of selection can change when the environment changes.

Learning objective · 7.1.A

Describe the causes of natural selection.

The logic of natural selection

Required content · EK 7.1.A.1 and 7.1.A.2

Natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution.

According to Darwin’s theory of natural selection, competition for limited resources results in differential survival. Individuals with more favorable phenotypes are more likely to survive and produce more offspring, thus passing on those favorable traits to subsequent generations.

Evolution is a change in the genetic makeup of a population over time, which means a change in allele frequencies from one generation to the next. Natural selection is one mechanism that can cause such a change (the others, mutation, genetic drift, and gene flow, come in lesson 7.4). It is not a force that plans ahead. It is the outcome of four observations that are each easy to check, and one conclusion that follows from them.

  1. Variation. Individuals in a population differ in their traits, such as beak size, flowering time, or the ability to digest a toxin.
  2. Heritability. At least some of this variation is inherited, so offspring tend to resemble their parents (lessons 5.1 to 5.6).
  3. Overproduction. Populations can produce far more offspring than the environment can support. A single oak makes thousands of acorns, and a single cod lays millions of eggs.
  4. Limited resources. Food, water, light, nesting sites, and mates are limited, so individuals compete, and they also face predators, parasites, and harsh conditions. Not all offspring survive and reproduce.

Conclusion: individuals whose inherited traits suit the environment better leave more offspring than others, so those traits (and the alleles behind them) become more common in the next generation. This is differential survival and reproduction.

Three points are tested again and again. First, selection acts on individuals, but only populations evolve. A fly does not change its alleles when it is sprayed with DDT; the population changes because of which flies survive and reproduce. Second, selection acts on phenotypes, the traits that can be seen, and it changes the frequency of the alleles that contribute to them. Third, only inherited variation matters: a bodybuilder’s large muscles are not passed to the children, and a plant that grows tall in rich soil has not changed its alleles.

02550751000.01%generation 00.99%generation 150%generation 299%generation 3Percent of flies that are resistant
Figure 7.1a Selection for resistance. Each generation the insecticide kills 99 percent of susceptible flies and no resistant flies, and the survivors rebuild the population (a model with illustrative numbers). A rare allele becomes the common one in only three generations.
Worked example · Selection for resistance to an insecticide

A population of 1,000,000 flies contains an allele for resistance to DDT. One fly in 10,000 is resistant (100 flies). Each generation, DDT kills 99% of the susceptible flies and none of the resistant ones, and the survivors then breed until the population is back to 1,000,000 flies, with the same proportion of resistant offspring as in the survivors. Calculate the percent of resistant flies after the first and second sprayings, and explain the result.

Generation 0. Resistant: 100. Susceptible: \(999{,}900\). The fraction resistant is \(100/1{,}000{,}000 = 0.01\%\).
After the first spraying. Survivors: 100 resistant and \(999{,}900 \times 0.01 = 9{,}999\) susceptible, a total of 10,099. The resistant fraction is \(100/10{,}099 = 0.99\%\). After breeding back to 1,000,000, about 9,900 flies are resistant.
After the second spraying. Survivors: about 9,902 resistant and \(990{,}098 \times 0.01 \approx 9{,}901\) susceptible, so the resistant fraction is about 50%. A third spraying leaves about 99%.
Reasoning. The resistance allele was already present (variation), it is inherited, and the insecticide changed which flies could reproduce (selection). The allele frequency rose from 0.01% to 99% in three generations, which is evolution of the population. The insecticide did not create the resistance, it selected for it.

Fitness is reproductive success

Learning objective · 7.1.B

Explain how natural selection affects populations.

Required content · EK 7.1.B.1 and 7.1.B.2

Evolutionary fitness is measured by reproductive success.

Biotic and abiotic environments can fluctuate, affecting the rate and direction of evolution. Different genetic variations can be selected in each generation.

In everyday speech, “fit” means strong or healthy. In biology, fitness means reproductive success: how many offspring an individual contributes to the next generation, usually counted as offspring that themselves survive to reproduce. A huge, strong male who lives to age 20 but leaves no offspring has a fitness of zero. A small, short-lived plant that sets many viable seeds has high fitness. Survival matters only because an organism that dies young leaves fewer offspring.

Fitness is also relative. It depends on the environment and on the other individuals in the population. Biologists often compare relative fitness, \(w\), by dividing the number of offspring of a phenotype by the number of offspring of the most successful phenotype. The selection coefficient is \(s = 1 - w\), the proportional disadvantage.

Worked example · Relative fitness

In a population of annual plants, plants with hairy leaves (which discourage insects) produce an average of 10 surviving offspring, and plants with smooth leaves produce an average of 8. Find the relative fitness and the selection coefficient for smooth leaves, and predict what will happen to the frequency of the hairy-leaf allele if the trait is inherited.

Relative fitness. Hairy leaves have \(w = 10/10 = 1.0\), and smooth leaves have \(w = 8/10 = 0.8\).
Selection coefficient. \(s = 1 - 0.8 = 0.2\), so smooth-leaved plants leave 20% fewer offspring.
Prediction. If the difference stays the same and the trait is heritable, hairy-leaf offspring make up a larger share of each new generation, so the frequency of the hairy-leaf allele increases. The change is gradual, because the smooth-leaved plants still reproduce.
Reasoning. What counts is the offspring, not the size or the longevity of the parents.

A changing environment changes the selection

The environment includes biotic factors (predators, prey, competitors, parasites, mates, and pathogens) and abiotic factors (temperature, rainfall, salinity, soil chemistry, light, and fire). Both can fluctuate from year to year, so a trait that is favored in one generation may be neutral or harmful in the next. This is what the CED means by the rate and direction of evolution. In a wet year the finches of a Galapagos island eat many small, soft seeds; in a drought only large, hard seeds remain, and birds with deeper beaks survive better (lesson 7.2). If the rains return, the advantage disappears, and the direction of selection can reverse.

Two consequences follow. First, there is no single “best” phenotype: a trait is adaptive only in a particular environment, and an adaptation is a heritable trait that increases fitness in the environment in which it evolved. Second, populations do not become perfectly adapted, because the environment keeps changing, because selection acts only on the variation that exists, and because the other processes of evolution (lesson 7.4) also change allele frequencies. Evolution is also not progress toward a goal: it has no foresight, and organisms do not change because they “need” to. The variation arises by mutation and recombination without regard to need, and the environment then selects among it.

Exam focus
  • Name the conditions for selection: variation, heritability, overproduction, competition. The result is differential reproduction.
  • Individuals do not evolve; populations do. Look for answers that describe a change in allele frequency over generations, not a change in one organism.
  • Fitness = reproductive success, not strength or lifespan. Relative fitness \(w = \) offspring / offspring of the best; \(s = 1 - w\).
  • Variation arises before selection and is random with respect to need. The drug, pesticide, or drought selects; it does not cause the mutation.
  • A trait that is an advantage in one environment can be a disadvantage in another: the direction of selection depends on the environment.
  • Acquired traits (a scar, big muscles) are not inherited and are not selected.
Practice
  1. A student says, “The moths developed dark wings because they needed camouflage.” Rewrite the statement so that it is correct, using the terms variation, selection, and allele frequency.
    Show answer

    The moth population already contained variation in wing color, and some of it was heritable. When soot darkened the trees, dark moths were less likely to be eaten by birds, so they survived and reproduced more. Each generation had a higher frequency of the allele for dark wings. The need did not cause the dark phenotype; selection changed the frequency of an allele that was already present.

  2. Two male deer, one large and one small, live for the same number of years. The large male fathers 6 fawns that survive to adulthood and the small male fathers 2. State which has the higher fitness and calculate the relative fitness of the small male.
    Show answer

    The large male has the higher fitness because fitness is reproductive success. The relative fitness of the small male is \(2/6 = 0.33\), so \(s = 0.67\).

  3. Explain why an individual fly that is sprayed with DDT cannot become resistant, but a population can.
    Show answer

    The alleles in an individual are fixed at fertilization; spraying does not change them. A population contains different individuals, a few of which carry a resistance allele. The spraying kills most susceptible flies, so the survivors, which carry the allele, leave most of the offspring, and the frequency of the allele in the population increases.

  4. A population of lizards has a heritable trait, tail length. Predict whether a long tail will become more common if a new predator that catches lizards by their tails arrives, and state what would happen if the predator disappeared.
    Show answer

    If long tails make a lizard easier to catch, lizards with shorter tails survive and reproduce more, and the frequency of alleles for long tails falls over the generations (assuming the trait is heritable). If the predator disappeared, the selection would stop or change direction, and long tails might be neutral or even favored again (for example, if they help in mate choice).

  5. A population doubles in size every generation but its food supply does not change. Explain how this leads to natural selection.
    Show answer

    More individuals are born than the food can support, so individuals compete for the limited food and many die or fail to reproduce. If individuals differ in heritable traits that affect their success in getting food, those with the more favorable traits survive and reproduce more, and their alleles become more frequent in the next generation.

  6. Give one example of a change in the biotic environment and one in the abiotic environment that could change the direction of selection in a population.
    Show answer

    Biotic: the arrival of a new predator, competitor, or pathogen (or the disappearance of a food species). Abiotic: a drought, a rise in temperature, a change in salinity, or a fire. In each case a trait that gave an advantage before can become neutral or a disadvantage, so different variations are selected in each generation.

Lesson 7.2 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.2

Natural selection: variation, selective pressure, and fitness

Lesson 7.1 gave the logic of natural selection. This lesson looks at how it works on real populations and real data. You will see what kinds of variation selection acts on, how the environment applies a selective pressure, the three ways selection can change the shape of a distribution, and how differences among molecules inside cells can matter for survival. The best-known data come from Peter and Rosemary Grant, who measured every finch on the small Galapagos island of Daphne Major for more than 40 years, and the exam often asks you to describe such data in a table or graph.

Learning objective · 7.2.A

Describe the importance of phenotypic variation in a population.

Selection acts on phenotypic variation

Required content · EK 7.2.A.1 to 7.2.A.3

Natural selection acts on phenotypic variations in populations.

Environments change and apply selective pressures to populations.

Some phenotypic variations can increase or decrease the fitness of an organism in particular environments.

Natural selection does not see genes. It “sees” whole organisms, which means phenotypes, and a phenotype is the product of genes and environment (lesson 5.7). If differences in a trait come only from the environment (a plant that is short because of poor soil), selection changes nothing in the next generation. If differences are caused at least partly by alleles, the more successful phenotypes pass on more of those alleles. The part of the variation in a trait that is due to genetic differences is its heritability, written \(h^2\), a number between 0 and 1.

The source of the variation matters too. New alleles come from mutation, and new combinations of them come from meiosis (crossing over and independent assortment) and from sexual reproduction, as you saw in Unit 5. Selection can only choose among variants that already exist. It cannot produce a trait a population has no variation for, and it does not drive mutations in a useful direction.

A selective pressure is any feature of the environment that causes differences in survival or reproduction: a predator, a drought, a parasite, a competitor, a cold winter, or a change in the food supply. Two examples from the CED illustrate how an environment changes the fitness of a variation.

  • Flowering time and climate change. Many plants flower earlier as spring temperatures rise. A plant that flowers before its pollinators emerge sets few seeds, so selection favors the genotypes that flower at the new best time. Studies of some wild plants show that the average flowering date has moved earlier by days over decades, which is partly a response of individual plants to temperature (a plastic response) and partly a change in allele frequencies.
  • Sickle cell allele. The allele \(\text{Hb}^\text{S}\) gives severe anemia when a person has two copies, but a person with one copy (a carrier) is far less likely to die of severe malaria. Where malaria is common, carriers have the highest fitness, so the allele stays at a high frequency (up to 10 to 15% in parts of West Africa), while in regions without malaria it is rare. The same allele is harmful in one environment and helpful in another, which is EK 7.2.A.3.

The three modes of selection

Directionalone extreme is favoredtrait valueStabilizingthe middle is favoredtrait valueDisruptiveboth extremes are favoredtrait valuedashed = before selection; solid = after selection in the next generation
Figure 7.2a Three modes of natural selection. Directional selection shifts the mean toward one extreme; stabilizing selection reduces variation by favoring the average; disruptive selection favors both extremes and can split a population into two.

For a trait that varies continuously, such as height, beak depth, or body mass, the distribution in a population is a bell curve. Selection changes the curve in one of three ways.

  • Directional selection favors one extreme, so the mean shifts toward it. Examples: antibiotic resistance, the deeper beaks of Daphne Major finches in a drought, and the darker moths in sooty forests.
  • Stabilizing selection favors the intermediate phenotype and removes the extremes, so the mean stays the same and the variation decreases. Example: human birth weight. Babies of average weight (about 3 to 3.5 kg) are the most likely to survive; very small and very large babies have higher mortality.
  • Disruptive selection favors both extremes over the middle, so the distribution becomes bimodal (two peaks). Example: African seedcracker finches, in which birds with small bills or large bills eat the abundant soft or hard seeds, but birds with intermediate bills are less efficient at both. Disruptive selection can, over long periods, split a population into two (lesson 7.9).

Data: the Galapagos finches

0102030407.58.08.59.09.510.010.511.0Beak depth (mm), start of each classPercent of birdsbefore drought (mean 9.2 mm)survivors (mean 9.7 mm)
Figure 7.2b Directional selection in a drought: birds with deeper beaks could open the large, hard seeds that remained, so survivors had a higher mean beak depth (illustrative distributions based on the Grants' Galapagos finch study).

In 1977 a drought on Daphne Major killed most of the plants that produce the small, soft seeds that medium ground finches (Geospiza fortis) usually eat. The remaining seeds were large and hard. About 85% of the birds died. The survivors had, on average, deeper beaks, which let them crack the larger seeds, and the offspring of the survivors had deeper beaks than the offspring born before the drought, because beak depth is highly heritable. The graph above uses distributions modeled on those data.

Worked example · Describing and quantifying a shift

A sample of 100 finches before a drought contains 20 with shallow beaks (mean 8.5 mm), 60 with medium beaks (mean 9.2 mm), and 20 with deep beaks (mean 10.0 mm). After the drought 4, 18, and 18 of those birds, respectively, are alive. (a) Find the percent survival of each class. (b) Find the mean beak depth before and after. (c) The heritability of beak depth is 0.7: predict the mean beak depth of the next generation. (d) State which mode of selection this is.

(a) Shallow: \(4/20 = 20\%\). Medium: \(18/60 = 30\%\). Deep: \(18/20 = 90\%\). Survival rises with beak depth.
(b) Before: \((20 \times 8.5 + 60 \times 9.2 + 20 \times 10.0)/100 = 922/100 = 9.22\) mm. After: \((4 \times 8.5 + 18 \times 9.2 + 18 \times 10.0)/40 = 379.6/40 = 9.49\) mm.
(c) The selection differential is the difference between the mean of the survivors and the mean of the original population: \(S = 9.49 - 9.22 = 0.27\) mm. The expected response to selection is \(R = h^2 S = 0.7 \times 0.27 = 0.19\) mm, so the offspring should average about \(9.22 + 0.19 = 9.41\) mm. (The offspring do not reach the mean of the survivors, because only part of the difference is heritable.)
(d) Directional selection: the mean moved toward one extreme and the high end of the range was favored.
Reasoning. A change in the mean of a graph is not evolution unless the trait is heritable. If \(h^2\) were zero, the offspring would still average 9.22 mm.

When you describe a graph on the exam, state the trend (the mean increased from 9.2 to 9.7 mm), name the variable and the units, and give the biological reason (deeper beaks could open the large seeds that were left, so those birds survived and reproduced). A good answer joins the data to the theory.

Variation inside cells

Learning objective · 7.2.B

Explain how variation in molecules within cells connects to the fitness of an organism.

Required content · EK 7.2.B.1

Variation in the number and types of molecules within cells can provide populations a greater ability to survive and reproduce in different environments.

Phenotypes are produced by molecules, so variation in molecules is the underlying source of variation in fitness. A change in a gene (lesson 6.7) can change the amino acid sequence of a protein and so its shape and function; a change in regulation (lessons 6.5 and 6.6) can change the number of copies of a protein. Both can matter.

  • Types of molecules. Hemoglobin variants differ in their affinity for oxygen. Deer mice at high altitude carry hemoglobin alleles that bind oxygen more tightly, which helps them in thin air. Enzyme variants with a different temperature optimum let a population function in warmer water. Bacteria with a mutated target protein are not inhibited by an antibiotic, and bacteria with an altered membrane protein can pump a drug out of the cell.
  • Number of molecules. Humans differ in the number of copies of the gene for salivary amylase, the enzyme that begins starch digestion. Populations with a long history of eating starchy foods tend to have more copies and more amylase in saliva. Cells that make more of a heat-shock protein tolerate a hot day better, and a bacterium that makes more of a drug-degrading enzyme survives a higher dose.

The link is always the same: genotype (variation in the DNA) leads to variation in molecules (the types and numbers of proteins and other products), which leads to variation in phenotype and so in fitness. When the environment changes, a population with a wider range of molecular variation is more likely to contain individuals that can survive (lesson 7.7).

Worked example · From molecule to fitness

In a population of bacteria, 1 cell in 100,000 carries a mutation that makes a membrane pump that removes a certain antibiotic. In a culture of \(10^8\) cells, how many carry the mutation, and what happens to the culture when the antibiotic is added?

Number. \(10^8/10^5 = 10^3 = 1{,}000\) cells.
Effect. Without the antibiotic the pump may be a burden (it uses energy), so the mutation stays rare. With the antibiotic, the other \(99.999\%\) of the cells are killed or stop growing, and the 1,000 cells that can pump the drug out survive and divide, so within a few generations the culture is mostly resistant.
Reasoning. The molecular variation (the pump) was present before the antibiotic and became advantageous only in the new environment.

Exam focus
  • Selection acts on phenotypes; evolution is the change in allele frequencies. Only heritable variation responds.
  • Directional: mean shifts. Stabilizing: variation narrows around the mean. Disruptive: two peaks. Be able to identify each from a graph.
  • Describe data with the trend, numbers with units, and the mechanism: “survivors had deeper beaks, so they could crack large seeds and reproduce”.
  • \(R = h^2 S\): the response is the heritability times the selection differential.
  • An allele can be good in one environment and bad in another (sickle cell allele with and without malaria).
  • Molecular variation: type (altered protein) and number (more or fewer copies) both affect fitness.
Practice
  1. Identify the mode of selection: (a) the mean body size does not change but the range decreases; (b) a population of snails splits into mostly light and mostly dark shells; (c) the average running speed of a prey species increases.
    Show answer

    (a) Stabilizing selection: the extremes are removed. (b) Disruptive selection: the two extremes are favored and the intermediate shell color is selected against. (c) Directional selection: the mean moves toward one extreme.

  2. Plants of a species are on average 20 cm tall. The mean of the plants allowed to reproduce is 24 cm and the heritability of height is 0.5. Predict the mean height of the offspring.
    Show answer

    \(S = 24 - 20 = 4\) cm, \(R = h^2 S = 0.5 \times 4 = 2\) cm, so the offspring average about 22 cm.

  3. Explain why the large beak depth of the finches after the drought is an example of natural selection and not an example of the birds “growing” bigger beaks.
    Show answer

    Individual birds did not change their beaks. Birds with deeper beaks were more likely to survive and reproduce, and because beak depth is heritable, their offspring had deeper beaks too. The average beak depth of the population therefore increased from one generation to the next as the frequency of the alleles for deep beaks went up.

  4. In a region where malaria is absent, predict how the frequency of the sickle cell allele changes over many generations, and explain.
    Show answer

    The frequency decreases. Without malaria, carriers have no advantage, and people with two copies suffer severe anemia and reproduce less, so the allele is selected against and becomes rarer (although it is not lost completely because it is kept in carriers, who are healthy).

  5. A gene in a plant is duplicated so that some plants have four copies of a gene for a heat-shock protein and others have two. Explain how the difference could cause a difference in fitness in a warming climate.
    Show answer

    Plants with four copies may make more heat-shock protein, which helps other proteins keep their shape at high temperature. During hot periods, those plants are more likely to survive and set seed than those with two copies. If the number of copies is inherited, the alleles for more copies become more frequent as the climate warms.

  6. A student claims, “A change in the mean of a trait always shows evolution.” Give a reason this claim may be wrong.
    Show answer

    The change in the mean may be due to the environment and not to genes. For example, a population fed better may be taller than the previous generation although the alleles are the same. Evolution requires a change in allele frequencies, so the trait must be heritable.

Lesson 7.3 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.3

Artificial selection: humans as the selective pressure

Cabbage, broccoli, kale, cauliflower, and Brussels sprouts look nothing alike, but they are all one species, Brassica oleracea, descended from a wild plant of the European coast with a few leaves and small flowers. A Chihuahua and a Great Dane are the same species, Canis familiaris, and both come from wolves. None of these forms were designed. People chose which individuals could reproduce, generation after generation, and the populations changed. Darwin began On the Origin of Species with domesticated pigeons for this reason: artificial selection is natural selection with a human as the selective pressure, and it shows how fast a population can change.

Learning objective · 7.3.A

Explain how humans can affect diversity within a population.

Required content · EK 7.3.A.1

Through artificial selection, humans affect variation in other species.

How artificial selection works

In artificial selection (also called selective breeding), people choose the individuals with the desired phenotype and allow only those to breed. The offspring are examined, and again only the best are bred. The steps are the same as for natural selection (variation, heritability, differential reproduction), but the difference is the agent of selection and the criterion. In nature the criterion is fitness in the environment; in artificial selection it is what the breeder wants, which may have no benefit, or even a disadvantage, for the organism. A bulldog with a very short snout does not breathe easily; a broiler chicken grows so fast that its legs can fail; a seedless grape cannot reproduce on its own.

OrganismAncestorTrait selectedResult
Corn (maize)Teosinte, a wild grassLarge, soft kernels, many rows on a cobA cob with hundreds of kernels from a plant with a few small, hard ones
Brassica oleraceaWild mustardLeaves (kale, cabbage), flower buds (broccoli, cauliflower), side buds (Brussels sprouts), stems (kohlrabi)Six or more vegetables from one species
DogsGray wolfHerding, hunting, size, coat, temperamentHundreds of breeds that vary 50-fold in mass
Dairy cattleAurochsMilk yieldA modern cow can give several times as much milk as a primitive breed
Wheat, riceWild grassesSeeds that stay on the stalk, high yieldGrain that is easy to harvest

Artificial selection has acted for thousands of years, and the earliest breeders did not know about genes. Corn is a clear example: the oldest cobs from Mexican caves, about 6,000 to 9,000 years old, are only a few centimeters long with a few kernels. The wild ancestor, teosinte, differs from corn at several genes, and a few of them have a large effect.

Reading a selection experiment

1620242832012345Generation of selective breedingMean height (cm)20.022.124.025.827.328.5+2.1+1.9+1.8+1.5+1.2
Figure 7.3a Artificial selection: in each generation only the tallest plants are allowed to breed. The mean rises each generation, but the gain per generation gets smaller as the variation in the population is used up (illustrative data).

The AP Biology lab on artificial selection uses rapid-cycling Brassica rapa (Wisconsin Fast Plants). Students pick the plants with the most hairs on their leaves, or the tallest, cross them, and measure the next generation. The data can be summarized on a graph like the one above, and the exam asks you to describe a trend and to explain a relationship between variables.

Worked example · Describing data from a breeding program

Each generation, only the tallest plants of a population are allowed to breed. The mean height (in cm) of generations 0 to 5 is 20.0, 22.1, 24.0, 25.8, 27.3, and 28.5. (a) Calculate the gain in each generation. (b) Calculate the percent change over the whole experiment. (c) Describe the trend and explain it. (d) Predict what would happen if the breeders stopped selecting.

(a) The gains are \(22.1 - 20.0 = 2.1\), \(24.0 - 22.1 = 1.9\), \(25.8 - 24.0 = 1.8\), \(27.3 - 25.8 = 1.5\), and \(28.5 - 27.3 = 1.2\) cm.
(b) \((28.5 - 20.0)/20.0 \times 100 = 42.5\%\) taller than the starting population.
(c) Trend: mean height increases every generation, but the gain per generation gets smaller (from 2.1 to 1.2 cm). Explanation: selection acts on the existing variation. Early on, there are many tall genotypes to choose from; after several generations the alleles for height have become common and the population has less variation left, so the selection differential and the response to selection decrease (\(R = h^2 S\), lesson 7.2). New variation then has to come from mutation, which is slow.
(d) If breeding stopped and the plants mated at random, the mean would stay near 28.5 cm for a while, because the alleles are still in the population, although it could slowly decrease if tall plants are less fit in the environment (for example, because tall plants fall over or take more resources).
Reasoning. The graph gives the relationship between the variable on the x-axis (generation) and the one on the y-axis (mean height) and the shape of the curve (a rise that levels off) carries the biological message.

What artificial selection does to variation

The CED states that humans affect variation. This has two sides.

  • Between populations, variation increases. By choosing different traits in different lines, breeders produce populations that are very different from each other and from the ancestor (dog breeds, cabbage varieties, pigeon breeds).
  • Within a population, variation decreases. Choosing a few individuals as parents removes alleles, and a breed is often made from a small number of founders, so many alleles are lost. Close relatives are often mated (inbreeding), which raises the frequency of homozygous genotypes and uncovers harmful recessive alleles, which is the reason for the inherited diseases seen in some breeds of dogs (such as hip dysplasia in large breeds).

The loss of variation has consequences that connect to lesson 7.7. A monoculture, a crop planted as genetically identical plants, is highly productive but vulnerable: one disease that can infect one plant can infect all of them. In 1970 a fungus, southern corn leaf blight, destroyed about 15% of the US corn crop because most of the corn carried the same cytoplasmic male-sterility gene. The banana you buy in the store is nearly always one clone, the Cavendish, which replaced the earlier Gros Michel when a fungus killed most of the Gros Michel plantations in the 1950s. A new strain of the fungus now threatens the Cavendish.

Artificial selection also acts on organisms by accident. Fishing nets that catch only large fish select for fish that mature at a smaller size; antibiotics used on farms select for resistant bacteria; and herbicides select for resistant weeds. These are not intended, but they are artificial selection by human activity, and they are discussed again in lesson 7.7.

Worked example · Natural against artificial

A seed company selects the largest tomatoes each year. Compare this with natural selection on wild tomatoes, and predict one disadvantage of the large tomato in the wild.

Similarity. Both depend on variation in a heritable trait and on differential reproduction: only some individuals contribute seeds to the next generation.
Difference. In the company the criterion is size (chosen by people) and the plants are protected from competition and pests; in the wild the criterion is survival and reproduction in the environment.
Disadvantage in the wild. Large fruit may need more water and nutrients, ripen later, or have a weak stem or thin skin, so the plant might produce fewer viable seeds when it has to compete, which means lower fitness in nature.
Reasoning. A trait that is favored by people is not necessarily adaptive in the natural environment.

Exam focus
  • Artificial selection: humans choose which individuals breed; the criterion is human preference. The mechanism is the same as in natural selection.
  • It increases differences between breeds or varieties and reduces genetic variation within each, which can lead to inbreeding problems and vulnerability to disease or change.
  • For a breeding graph: describe the trend, then explain why gains level off (less variation left, and the response depends on \(h^2\) and \(S\)).
  • Examples: corn from teosinte, Brassica vegetables, dog breeds. Unintended artificial selection: antibiotic resistance, herbicide-resistant weeds, smaller fish.
  • No mutation is “caused” by the breeder; the breeder selects variation that exists.
Practice
  1. List two ways in which artificial selection is similar to natural selection and one way in which it differs.
    Show answer

    Similar: both need heritable variation, and both result from differential reproduction, which changes allele frequencies over generations. Different: in artificial selection a person decides which individuals reproduce, according to a human goal, and the favored trait may reduce fitness in nature; in natural selection the environment determines who survives and reproduces.

  2. A dairy farmer breeds only the cows that give the most milk. Mean yield was 20 L per day and the selected cows average 26 L. If the heritability is 0.4, predict the mean yield of the next generation.
    Show answer

    \(S = 26 - 20 = 6\) L, \(R = 0.4 \times 6 = 2.4\) L, so the next generation averages \(20 + 2.4 = 22.4\) L per day.

  3. Explain why gains per generation in a selection experiment usually decrease.
    Show answer

    Each generation of selection removes the alleles for the unwanted phenotypes, so the genetic variation for the trait decreases. With less variation, the selected parents differ less from the population, so the selection differential gets smaller. Further gain would depend on new mutations or recombination.

  4. Why are inherited diseases more common in some purebred dog breeds than in mixed-breed dogs?
    Show answer

    A breed is founded from a small number of individuals and bred within itself, often to related dogs. This reduces genetic variation and increases the frequency of homozygous genotypes, so recessive alleles that cause disease are more likely to be expressed than in an outbred population.

  5. A farmer plants 10,000 acres with a single genetically identical variety of wheat. Predict a risk of this practice and a way to reduce it.
    Show answer

    Risk: because all plants have the same genotype, a pathogen or pest that can infect one plant can infect all, so a single outbreak could destroy the crop. Reduction: plant several varieties (more genetic diversity), rotate crops, or breed resistance genes from wild relatives into the crop.

  6. Large-mesh fishing nets catch only fish above a certain size, and over decades the mean size at which fish reproduce falls. Explain this as artificial selection.
    Show answer

    Fishing removes the large fish, so fish that mature and reproduce at a smaller size leave more offspring. If the age or size at maturity is heritable, the alleles for early maturity at a small size become more frequent. People are the selective pressure, although they did not intend to change the fish.

Lesson 7.4 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.4

Population genetics: mutation, drift, and gene flow

In the 1890s hunters had reduced the northern elephant seal to about 20 animals. The species recovered to more than 100,000, but the genome of every living seal is strikingly uniform, as if all were descended from a handful of individuals, which they are. Nothing about those 20 seals was “better”: the survivors were mostly a matter of chance. Natural selection is the only process of evolution that tends to produce adaptation, but it is not the only one that changes allele frequencies. This lesson covers the random processes: mutation, genetic drift (including the bottleneck and founder effects), and gene flow.

Learning objective · 7.4.A

Explain how random occurrences affect the genetic makeup of a population.

Required content · EK 7.4.A.1

Evolution is also driven by random occurrences.

  1. Mutation is a random process that adds new genetic variation to a population.
  2. Genetic drift is a change in allele frequencies attributable to a nonselective process occurring in small populations.
  3. The bottleneck effect is a type of genetic drift that occurs when a population size is reduced to a small number of individuals for at least one generation.
  4. The founder effect is a type of genetic drift that occurs when a population is separated from other members of the population. The frequency of genes and traits will shift based on the genes in this new founder population.
  5. Migration can result in gene flow (the addition or removal of alleles from a population).

How to tell that a population is evolving

Required content · EK 7.4.C.1

Changes in allele frequencies provide evidence for the occurrence of evolution in a population.

The gene pool of a population is the sum of all of its alleles. The frequency of an allele is the fraction of all copies of the gene that are that allele. In a diploid population of \(N\) individuals there are \(2N\) copies of an autosomal gene, so you can count: each homozygote has two copies of its allele and each heterozygote has one of each.

Worked example · Counting alleles to detect evolution

A population of 200 flowers has 50 \(AA\), 100 \(Aa\), and 50 \(aa\) plants. Ten generations later a sample of 200 plants has 72 \(AA\), 96 \(Aa\), and 32 \(aa\). Has the population evolved?

Generation 0. There are \(2 \times 200 = 400\) copies. Allele \(A\): \(2 \times 50 + 100 = 200\) copies, so \(p = 200/400 = 0.50\), and \(q = 0.50\).
Generation 10. Allele \(A\): \(2 \times 72 + 96 = 240\) copies, so \(p = 240/400 = 0.60\), and \(q = 0.40\).
Conclusion. The frequency of \(A\) rose from 0.50 to 0.60, so the population evolved. The data alone do not say why: selection, drift, gene flow, or mutation could each be responsible, so the cause has to be determined from other information (the population size, the environment, whether individuals moved).
Reasoning. Evolution is defined as a change in allele frequencies over generations, so this is the evidence that the CED asks for.

Mutation: the source of new variation

A mutation is a change in DNA (lesson 6.7). Mutations occur at random, in the sense that they do not arise because they would be useful. In humans each child has roughly 50 to 100 new mutations that neither parent had, nearly all in non-coding DNA or without effect on the phenotype. Mutation is the only source of entirely new alleles, so it is the raw material on which the other processes act: selection can only select what mutation (and recombination) has provided (EK 7.4.B.1.i). Because the rate is so low, about \(10^{-8}\) per base pair per generation, mutation on its own changes allele frequencies very slowly. Its role is to supply variation, not to move frequencies rapidly.

Genetic drift

Learning objective · 7.4.B

Describe the role of random processes in the evolution of specific populations.

Required content · EK 7.4.B.1

Random processes can lead to changes in allele frequencies in a population.

  1. Mutations result in genetic variation, which provides phenotypes on which natural selection acts.
  2. Genetic drift can allow a small population to diverge from other populations of the same species.
  3. Gene flow between two populations prevents them from diverging into separate species.
Small population (N = 10)00.5102040GenerationLarge population (N = 500)00.5102040GenerationAllele frequency
Figure 7.4a Genetic drift is a change in allele frequencies caused by chance in small populations. Five simulated populations for each size all begin at 0.5; random sampling of alleles changes the frequency much more in the small population, where alleles can be lost or fixed.

The alleles that end up in the next generation are a sample of the alleles in the parents, and a sample from a small group can differ from the whole by chance, just as 10 tosses of a coin rarely give exactly 5 heads. Genetic drift is this random change in allele frequencies. It has four properties.

  • It is stronger in small populations. The graph shows five simulated populations of 10 individuals and five of 500, all starting with an allele frequency of 0.5. In the small populations the frequency jumps around and some alleles are lost or fixed (frequency 1) within 10 to 30 generations. In the large populations the changes are small.
  • It is not selection: the change does not depend on whether the allele is helpful, so it can fix a neutral or even a slightly harmful allele.
  • It reduces genetic variation within a population, because alleles are lost, and in the end the population becomes homozygous for that gene.
  • It makes different populations diverge: separate small populations drift in different directions, so the populations become genetically different (EK 7.4.B.1.ii).
Worked example · How strong is drift?

For an allele with \(p = q = 0.5\) in a population of \(N\) breeding individuals, the standard deviation of the random change in allele frequency in one generation is about \(\sqrt{pq/2N}\). Compare \(N = 10\) with \(N = 1{,}000\). Then give the chance that a new neutral mutation in a population of 50 becomes fixed.

\(N = 10\). \(\sqrt{0.25/20} = \sqrt{0.0125} = 0.112\). A typical change in one generation is about 0.11, so a frequency of 0.5 can easily become 0.4 or 0.6 in a single generation.
\(N = 1{,}000\). \(\sqrt{0.25/2000} = \sqrt{0.000125} = 0.0112\), a typical change of about 0.01. The population that is 100 times larger has a change that is 10 times smaller (the factor is \(\sqrt{100}\)).
Fixation. For a neutral allele the chance of eventual fixation equals its current frequency. A new mutation is one copy among \(2N = 100\) copies, so the frequency is 0.01 and the chance of fixation is 1%. In 99% of cases the new allele is lost by chance, even though it is harmless.
Reasoning. Drift depends on population size: the smaller the population, the larger the random changes.

Bottleneck and founder effects

Bottleneck effectFounder effectoriginal50% redsurvivors75% redregrown75% redoriginal50% redfounders25% redregrown25% redsurvivors are a chance sample of thealleles in the original populationfounders carry only some of the alleles,so the new population differs from the source
Figure 7.4b A bottleneck is a type of genetic drift in which a population is reduced to a small number of individuals for at least one generation. In the founder effect, a population is separated from other members of the species; the frequency of genes and traits shifts based on the genes in the new founder population.

Two situations produce strong drift even in species that are usually abundant.

The bottleneck effect happens when a population is reduced to a few individuals for at least one generation, by a disaster, disease, or hunting. The survivors are a random sample, so the allele frequencies may be very different from the original population, and rare alleles are often lost. Even if the population recovers, the variation does not return quickly. The northern elephant seal went from about 20 to over 100,000 individuals but has very little variation; the cheetah has such low variation that skin grafts between unrelated cheetahs are accepted, which would be rejected in most species.

The founder effect happens when a few individuals leave a large population and found a new one, on an island or in a new habitat. The founders carry only a part of the alleles, in proportions that can differ from the source population, and the new population grows from them. Many rare disease alleles are common in populations that began with a few founders. Ellis-van Creveld syndrome, a recessive condition that causes extra fingers and short stature, is rare in the world but affects about 1 in 200 of the Old Order Amish of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, a group descended from about 200 founders in the 1700s, one of whom carried the allele.

Worked example · Predicting a founder effect

A large mainland population of beetles has 10% red beetles (allele \(r\) is recessive for red, \(R\) is dominant for green; the frequency of \(r\) is \(q = \sqrt{0.10} = 0.32\)). Four females and four males, picked at random, are carried to an island by a storm. Predict the frequency of red beetles on the island and say how it would differ from the mainland.

Expected value. On average the founders would carry the mainland frequency, so the best single prediction for the island is about 10% red.
Variation. But eight founders carry only 16 gene copies, so the actual frequency of \(r\) could be 0.1, 0.4, or 0, by chance. The frequency on the island may be much higher or much lower than on the mainland, and the island population may be 0% or 50% red, depending on the founders, even when the environment is the same.
Reasoning. A founder effect is a prediction of divergence between island and mainland that is random in direction, and the smaller the founding group, the larger the expected difference. Selection can then act on the new gene pool.

Gene flow

Gene flow is the movement of alleles between populations when individuals (or gametes, such as pollen or seeds) migrate and reproduce. It adds alleles to a population or removes them (EK 7.4.A.1.v). Gene flow makes populations more similar, because the alleles in one are mixed into the other. If it is high enough, it prevents two populations from diverging into separate species (EK 7.4.B.1.iii), and that is why it is important to speciation (lesson 7.9). It can also bring in alleles that a population lacked: the spread of insecticide resistance through pollen or insects that move between fields is one example.

Worked example · A migration calculation

A population of 600 beetles has an allele frequency \(q = 0.10\) for a color allele. 200 migrants from a neighboring population, where \(q = 0.70\), arrive and breed. What is \(q\) in the combined population?

Weighted average. \((600 \times 0.10 + 200 \times 0.70)/800 = (60 + 140)/800 = 200/800 = 0.25\).
Interpretation. The frequency of the allele rose from 0.10 to 0.25 in one generation without any selection or mutation, just because of migration. The recipient population changed toward the donor population, and the two populations are now less different (0.25 compared with 0.70, instead of 0.10 compared with 0.70).
Reasoning. The new frequency is always between those of the two sources, closer to the larger population.

Exam focus
  • Evolution = change in allele frequencies over generations. Compute frequencies by counting copies (\(2N\) per gene).
  • Mutation makes new alleles (slow, random); drift is chance change in small populations; bottleneck and founder are two kinds of drift; gene flow is migration of alleles; selection is non-random.
  • Drift decreases variation within a population and increases differences among populations. Gene flow does the opposite (more alike).
  • Drift acts in small populations; it can fix or lose alleles regardless of their effect on fitness.
  • Bottleneck: survivors of a disaster. Founder: a few individuals start a new population.
  • A change in allele frequency alone does not tell the cause: use population size and environment to decide between drift and selection.
Practice
  1. A population of 500 has 180 \(BB\), 240 \(Bb\), and 80 \(bb\). Calculate the frequency of \(b\).
    Show answer

    Copies of \(b\): \(2 \times 80 + 240 = 400\) of \(2 \times 500 = 1{,}000\) copies, so \(q = 0.40\).

  2. A forest fire kills most of a population of 10,000 plants, and 25 survivors replace it. Name the process and predict the effect on genetic variation, including whether the survivors are likely to be the best-adapted ones.
    Show answer

    This is a bottleneck effect, a kind of genetic drift. The 25 survivors are a small, largely random sample, so many alleles, especially rare ones, are lost and variation decreases. The survivors are not necessarily the best-adapted, because the fire killed regardless of genotype.

  3. Explain why drift is a much weaker force in a population of 1 million than in a population of 20.
    Show answer

    Drift is a sampling error: the alleles in the next generation are a sample of the parental alleles. The error is large when the sample is small and small when the sample is large, so changes in frequency are much smaller in the larger population, where the frequency stays near the expected value.

  4. Population X has \(q = 0.20\) and population Y has \(q = 0.60\). If 100 individuals of Y move into X (which has 300 individuals) and breed, what is \(q\) in the combined population?
    Show answer

    \((300 \times 0.20 + 100 \times 0.60)/400 = (60 + 60)/400 = 0.30\).

  5. Describe how gene flow and genetic drift have opposite effects on the differences between two populations.
    Show answer

    Genetic drift changes allele frequencies randomly and independently in each small population, so the populations become more different from each other. Gene flow mixes the alleles of the two populations, which makes them more similar. If gene flow is high, it can prevent the populations from diverging into different species.

  6. A new island population shows a high frequency of a rare genetic disease that is uncommon on the mainland. Give a hypothesis and say how you could test it.
    Show answer

    Hypothesis: a founder effect, in which one or more of the few founders carried the allele, so it was much more frequent in the founders than in the mainland and it has remained common. Test: compare the genetic markers of the island and mainland populations and look for a small number of ancestral lineages, check the records of the founders, and see whether the allele is associated with a single haplotype (consistent with one founder). If the allele also has a fitness advantage, selection would have to be considered.

Lesson 7.5 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.5

Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium: the null model of evolution

If you know that cystic fibrosis affects 1 baby in 2,500 among people of European descent, can you work out how many people carry one copy of the allele without symptoms? You can, and the answer, about 1 person in 25, is higher than most people expect. The tool is the Hardy-Weinberg equation, published independently in 1908 by the English mathematician G. H. Hardy and the German physician Wilhelm Weinberg. It describes what allele and genotype frequencies would be in a population in which nothing is changing them. Because it gives the “no evolution” prediction, it lets you recognize evolution by comparing real populations with it. It is also the most common source of calculation questions in the AP Biology exam.

Learning objective · 7.5.A

Describe the conditions under which allele and genotype frequencies will change in populations.

Required content · EK 7.5.A.1 and 7.5.A.2

The Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium is a model for describing and predicting allele frequencies in a non-evolving population. Conditions for a population or an allele to be in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium are:

  1. A large population size
  2. No migration
  3. No new mutations
  4. Random mating
  5. No natural selection

These conditions are never met, but they provide a valuable null hypothesis.

Allele frequencies in a nonevolving population can be calculated from genotype frequencies.

Relevant equations: \(p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1\) and \(p + q = 1\), where \(p\) = frequency of allele 1 in the population and \(q\) = frequency of allele 2 in the population.

Where the equation comes from

000.250.250.50.50.750.7511Frequency of allele a (q)Genotype frequencyAA = p²Aa = 2pqaa = q²q = 0.3: 0.49, 0.42, 0.09
Figure 7.5a Under Hardy-Weinberg conditions, genotype frequencies are determined by the allele frequencies: p² + 2pq + q² = 1. Heterozygotes are most frequent when the two alleles are equally common, and rare alleles are mostly found in heterozygotes.

Consider one gene with two alleles, \(A\) (frequency \(p\)) and \(a\) (frequency \(q\)). Since there are only two alleles, \(p + q = 1\). If the population mates at random, a sperm carrying \(A\) meets an egg carrying \(A\) with a probability of \(p \times p\), and the other combinations follow from the product rule (lesson 5.3):

GenotypeHow it formsFrequency
\(AA\)\(A\) egg and \(A\) sperm\(p \times p = p^2\)
\(Aa\)\(A\) egg and \(a\) sperm, or \(a\) egg and \(A\) sperm\(2pq\)
\(aa\)\(a\) egg and \(a\) sperm\(q \times q = q^2\)

The three frequencies add up to 1: \(p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = (p + q)^2 = 1\). The key point is that if the five conditions hold, the allele frequencies \(p\) and \(q\) do not change from generation to generation, and the genotype frequencies are given by the equation after one round of random mating. The graph shows how the three genotype frequencies depend on \(q\): heterozygotes are most common (0.5) when \(q = 0.5\), and when an allele is rare, nearly all copies of it are found in heterozygotes, hidden from selection.

Why the conditions matter. Each one corresponds to a process of evolution. A small population allows genetic drift. Migration is gene flow. Mutation adds or changes alleles. Non-random mating (for example inbreeding or choosing mates that look alike) changes the genotype frequencies without changing the allele frequencies. Selection changes allele frequencies because genotypes differ in fitness. If the observed frequencies do not match the Hardy-Weinberg prediction, at least one of the conditions is not met, which is the evidence for evolution.

Calculating frequencies

Almost every Hardy-Weinberg problem has the same structure: the number you are given is for a phenotype, you find \(q^2\) or a different starting point, and you work out the rest. If one allele is completely dominant, you cannot tell \(AA\) from \(Aa\) by looking, but you can identify the recessive homozygotes, so \(q^2\) is the frequency of the recessive phenotype.

Worked example · From a recessive phenotype to every frequency

In a population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, 16% of the plants have white flowers (the recessive phenotype, \(aa\)). Find the frequencies of both alleles and of all three genotypes, and the percent of purple plants that are heterozygous.

Step 1: \(q^2\). White plants are \(aa\), so \(q^2 = 0.16\).
Step 2: \(q\). \(q = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.40\).
Step 3: \(p\). \(p = 1 - q = 0.60\).
Step 4: genotypes. \(p^2 = 0.36\) (\(AA\)), \(2pq = 2 \times 0.60 \times 0.40 = 0.48\) (\(Aa\)), \(q^2 = 0.16\) (\(aa\)). The sum is \(0.36 + 0.48 + 0.16 = 1.00\).
Step 5: heterozygotes among purple plants. Purple plants are \(0.36 + 0.48 = 0.84\) of the population, so the fraction that is \(Aa\) is \(0.48/0.84 = 0.571\), about 57%.
Reasoning. Dominant phenotypes include both \(AA\) and \(Aa\). It is a common error to take \(p^2\) as the frequency of the dominant phenotype.

Worked example · Carriers of a disease allele

Cystic fibrosis is a recessive disease that affects about 1 in 2,500 newborns of European ancestry. Estimate the frequency of the allele and the percent of the population that are carriers.

\(q^2\). \(q^2 = 1/2{,}500 = 0.0004\).
\(q\). \(q = \sqrt{0.0004} = 0.02\), and \(p = 0.98\).
Carriers. \(2pq = 2 \times 0.98 \times 0.02 = 0.0392\), about 3.9%, or about 1 person in 25.
Reasoning. The allele frequency is only 2%, but because it is rare, almost all copies are in carriers: carriers outnumber affected people \(0.0392/0.0004 = 98\) to 1. Selection against the disease can remove an allele only from the small fraction of copies that are in affected people, which is why a recessive disease allele declines very slowly.

Sometimes you are given genotype counts and asked for allele frequencies. Then you can use counting (lesson 7.4). If a population of 1,000 has 410 \(AA\), 380 \(Aa\), and 210 \(aa\) individuals, the number of \(A\) copies is \(2 \times 410 + 380 = 1{,}200\) out of 2,000, so \(p = 0.60\) and \(q = 0.40\). This calculation does not require the population to be in equilibrium.

Testing whether a population is in equilibrium

Hardy-Weinberg works as a null hypothesis: “the population is not evolving, and its genotype frequencies match \(p^2\), \(2pq\), and \(q^2\)”. A \(\chi^2\) (chi-square) test (lesson 5.6) compares the observed counts with those expected.

Worked example · Chi-square test for Hardy-Weinberg

The population of 1,000 above has 410 \(AA\), 380 \(Aa\), and 210 \(aa\). Is it in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium? Use the critical value 3.841 (\(\alpha = 0.05\), 1 degree of freedom).

Allele frequencies. \(p = 0.60\), \(q = 0.40\).
Expected counts. \(AA\): \(0.36 \times 1{,}000 = 360\). \(Aa\): \(0.48 \times 1{,}000 = 480\). \(aa\): \(0.16 \times 1{,}000 = 160\).
Chi-square. \(\chi^2 = \dfrac{(410-360)^2}{360} + \dfrac{(380-480)^2}{480} + \dfrac{(210-160)^2}{160} = 6.94 + 20.83 + 15.63 = 43.40\).
Degrees of freedom. Three genotype classes, minus 1, minus 1 more because the allele frequency was estimated from the data: \(3 - 1 - 1 = 1\).
Decision. \(43.40 \gt 3.841\), so reject the null hypothesis: the population is not in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. There are too few heterozygotes (380 observed against 480 expected) and too many homozygotes. This pattern suggests non-random mating such as inbreeding, or a mix of two populations. It could also be selection.
Reasoning. The test says that the null model does not fit; it does not say which condition is violated.

Do not forget the lesson of the equation: a real population never meets all five conditions. A change in frequency from one generation to the next tells you that the population is evolving; and the framework helps you to ask which condition fails. For example, if a population of 100 beetles under heavy predation shows \(q\) falling from 0.50 to 0.30 in five generations, the large change in a short time makes selection the likely cause, since drift would not do this in a large population.

Exam focus
  • Equations: \(p + q = 1\) and \(p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1\) (both are on the AP formula sheet).
  • Start from \(q^2\) (the recessive phenotype), take the square root for \(q\), then \(p = 1 - q\), then \(2pq\). Never use the dominant phenotype percentage as \(p^2\).
  • Five conditions: large population, no migration, no mutation, random mating, no selection. None is ever fully met; HW is the null hypothesis.
  • \(\chi^2\) for HW: expected counts \(= p^2 N,\ 2pqN,\ q^2 N\); df = 1 for two alleles (3 classes \(- 1 - 1\) estimated allele frequency). Compare with 3.84.
  • A change in allele frequency across generations means evolution; non-random mating changes genotype frequencies but not allele frequencies.
  • For rare recessive alleles, most copies are in carriers (\(2pq \approx 2q\)).
Practice
  1. In a population in equilibrium, \(q^2 = 0.09\). Find \(q\), \(p\), \(p^2\), and \(2pq\).
    Show answer

    \(q = 0.30\), \(p = 0.70\), \(p^2 = 0.49\), \(2pq = 2 \times 0.70 \times 0.30 = 0.42\). Check: \(0.49 + 0.42 + 0.09 = 1.00\).

  2. 1 baby in 10,000 has phenylketonuria (PKU, a recessive disease). Estimate the allele frequency and the carrier frequency.
    Show answer

    \(q^2 = 0.0001\), so \(q = 0.01\) and \(p = 0.99\). Carriers: \(2pq = 2 \times 0.99 \times 0.01 = 0.0198\), about 2%, or 1 in 50.

  3. In a population in equilibrium, 84% of the individuals show the dominant phenotype. Calculate the frequency of the recessive allele and the percent of heterozygotes in the whole population.
    Show answer

    The recessive phenotype is \(1 - 0.84 = 0.16 = q^2\), so \(q = 0.40\) and \(p = 0.60\). Heterozygotes: \(2pq = 0.48\), or 48% of the population.

  4. A population has 90 \(AA\), 60 \(Aa\), and 50 \(aa\) individuals. Calculate \(p\) and \(q\), and the expected number of \(Aa\) if the population were in equilibrium.
    Show answer

    Copies of \(A\): \(2 \times 90 + 60 = 240\) of 400, so \(p = 0.60\) and \(q = 0.40\). Expected \(Aa\): \(2pq \times 200 = 0.48 \times 200 = 96\), compared with 60 observed.

  5. A student states: “Hardy-Weinberg shows that populations never evolve.” Correct the statement.
    Show answer

    Hardy-Weinberg describes what would happen if five conditions were met, namely a large population, no migration, no mutation, random mating, and no selection. Real populations never meet all of them, so they do evolve. The model is useful as a null hypothesis: a difference between observed and expected frequencies is evidence that a condition is violated and that evolution is occurring.

  6. Predict what happens to \(p\) and to the frequency of heterozygotes in a large population in which mating is non-random because individuals only mate with relatives.
    Show answer

    The allele frequencies \(p\) and \(q\) do not change, because mating by itself does not remove or add alleles. The proportion of heterozygotes decreases below \(2pq\) and the proportion of homozygotes increases, because related individuals are more likely to share alleles.

Lesson 7.6 · Unit 7 · CED topics 7.6 and 7.7

Evidence of evolution and common ancestry

A whale has a tiny pair of pelvic bones buried in its body, with nothing attached to them that is used for walking. A human has a few fused tail vertebrae, the coccyx. A cave fish has eyes that are covered with skin. Yeast, an oak, and you all read the same genetic code and use the same molecule, ATP, as energy currency. If species were created separately, there would be no reason for these features. If they descended from common ancestors, they are what we expect. This lesson reviews the lines of evidence that scientists use to show that evolution has happened and that all life is related, including the quantitative methods that the exam tests: radioactive dating, comparison of sequences, and the molecular clock.

Learning objective · 7.6.A

Describe the types of data that provide evidence for evolution.

Required content · EK 7.6.A.1

Evolution is supported by scientific evidence from many disciplines (geographical, geological, physical, biochemical, and mathematical data).

A strong scientific explanation is one that is supported by independent lines of evidence that agree. For evolution these include the following.

  • Geological data. Fossils in layers of rock (strata) show a sequence of forms. Deeper layers are older in undisturbed rock, and the fossils show organisms that change over time and many that are extinct. Transitional fossils, such as Tiktaalik (a fish with a neck and limb-like fins, about 375 million years old) and Archaeopteryx (a feathered dinosaur with a bird-like skeleton), show intermediate features.
  • Geographical data (biogeography). Species on an island are most like those on the nearest mainland, not like those in a similar habitat far away. Most native mammals of Australia are marsupials, which diverged and diversified when the continent was isolated by moving plates; the Galapagos finches are related to a South American finch.
  • Physical data. Radioactive decay gives absolute ages for rocks and fossils (below); continental drift explains the distribution of fossils of the same species on separate continents.
  • Biochemical and molecular data. All living things use DNA, RNA, ATP, and the same genetic code, and the sequences of genes and proteins resemble each other in proportion to the other evidence of relatedness.
  • Mathematical data. Rates of change in sequences (the molecular clock) and statistical comparison of trees.

Dating fossils

Learning objective · 7.6.B

Explain how morphological, biochemical, and geological data provide evidence that organisms have changed over time.

Required content · EK 7.6.B.1

Molecular, morphological, and genetic evidence from extant and extinct organisms adds to our understanding of evolution.

  1. Fossils can be dated by a variety of methods. These include 1) the age of the rocks where a fossil is found; 2) the rate of decay of isotopes including carbon-14; and 3) geographical data.
  2. Morphological homologies, including vestigial structures, provide evidence of common ancestry.
0255075100100%00 y50%15,730 y25%211,460 y12.5%317,190 y6.25%422,920 y3.125%528,650 yHalf-lives elapsed (carbon-14: 1 half-life = 5,730 years)Percent of isotope remaining
Figure 7.6a Radioactive decay. In each half-life half of the remaining unstable isotope changes into its decay product. The time scale shown is for carbon-14; a different isotope has a different half-life but the same shape.

Relative dating tells you which fossil is older: a fossil in a lower layer is older than one above it, and a fossil can be matched to others of known age by the layer it shares with them. Radiometric dating gives a number. An unstable isotope of an element decays into another isotope at a constant rate that is not affected by temperature, pressure, or chemistry. The time it takes for half of a sample to decay is the half-life, and it is different for each isotope. The percent remaining after \(n\) half-lives is \(100 \times (1/2)^n\).

  • Carbon-14 (half-life 5,730 years) forms in the atmosphere, is taken up by living things along with carbon-12, and starts to decay when the organism dies, so the ratio of C-14 to C-12 falls. It can date remains of organic material up to about 50,000 years old. After that too little is left to measure.
  • Potassium-40 (half-life 1.25 billion years) decays to argon-40 in volcanic rock, so it can date rock layers of millions to billions of years. A fossil in a sedimentary layer between two layers of volcanic ash is dated by the ages of the ash layers above and below it.
Worked example · Radiometric dating

(a) A wooden tool contains 25% of the C-14 of a living tree. How old is it? (b) A bone has 6.25% of its original C-14. (c) A volcanic rock contains 12.5% of its original K-40. How old is it? (d) Explain why C-14 cannot be used to date a 100-million-year-old dinosaur bone.

(a) 25% is \((1/2)^2\), so two half-lives have passed: \(2 \times 5{,}730 = 11{,}460\) years.
(b) 6.25% is \((1/2)^4 = 1/16\), so four half-lives: \(4 \times 5{,}730 = 22{,}920\) years.
(c) 12.5% is \((1/2)^3\), so three half-lives: \(3 \times 1.25 = 3.75\) billion years.
(d) The dinosaur is about 17,000 half-lives of C-14 old (\(100{,}000{,}000/5{,}730\)), so no detectable C-14 is left. A isotope with a much longer half-life, such as K-40 or uranium-238, in the rocks around the fossil has to be used.
Reasoning. Choose an isotope whose half-life is comparable with the age that is being measured.

Homology and vestigial structures

HumanCatWhaleBathumerusradius and ulnawrist bonesfinger bones
Figure 7.6b Homologous structures. The forelimbs of these four mammals are used for grasping, walking, swimming and flying, yet they contain the same bones in the same arrangement, which is evidence that they were inherited from a common ancestor (simplified drawings, not to scale).

Homologous structures are features in different species that have the same underlying structure because they were inherited from a common ancestor, even if they now have different functions. The forelimb of a human, a cat, a whale, and a bat has the same arrangement of bones (one upper arm bone, two forearm bones, wrist bones, and five digits), although it is used to grasp, walk, swim, and fly. A designer starting from scratch would not use the same plan for each use; descent with modification explains it. In contrast, analogous structures have a similar function but a different origin (the wing of a bird and the wing of an insect), and they evolved independently by convergent evolution (lesson 7.9), so they do not show common ancestry.

Vestigial structures are reduced features that have lost most or all of their original function, like the pelvic bones of whales, the leg bones of some snakes, the wings of flightless birds, and the eyes of blind cave fish. They are explained by ancestors in which the structure was functional. Embryology offers a similar line of evidence: embryos of fish, chickens, and humans all have pharyngeal pouches and a tail at an early stage, but in fish the pouches become gills and in the other animals they form parts of the ear and throat.

Molecular evidence

Required content · EK 7.6.B.2

A comparison of DNA nucleotide sequences and protein amino acid sequences provides evidence for evolution and common ancestry.

01020304050Chimpanzee0Rhesus monkey1Dog10Chicken13Tuna21Yeast44Amino acids that differ from the human protein (of 104)
Figure 7.6c A molecular comparison. The more distantly related an organism is to humans, the more differences there are in the amino acid sequence of cytochrome c, a protein of the electron transport chain (values are close to published ones, rounded for the exercise).

All species have DNA (or RNA) and proteins, and the order of the bases or of the amino acids is inherited with mutations that accumulate over time. After two species separate from a common ancestor, each lineage independently collects its own mutations, so the more recently two species diverged, the fewer differences their sequences have. This is a prediction that can fail, so it is a real test of evolutionary theory, and it works: the sequence differences match the trees from morphology and fossils.

Worked example · Comparing sequences

Cytochrome c has 104 amino acids in humans. The graph shows 1 difference for the rhesus monkey, 10 for the dog, 13 for the chicken, and 44 for yeast. Calculate the percent difference for each and state what the pattern shows.

Percent differences. Rhesus: \(1/104 = 0.96\%\). Dog: \(10/104 = 9.6\%\). Chicken: \(13/104 = 12.5\%\). Yeast: \(44/104 = 42.3\%\).
Pattern. The differences increase with the evolutionary distance: monkeys (primates) are the closest to humans, followed by the other mammals, birds, and finally the fungus. The pattern fits the branching order that is found from fossils and anatomy.
Interpretation. The protein is found in organisms from yeast to humans (it is used in the electron transport chain, lesson 3.7) and 60 of the 104 positions are the same in yeast and humans, which is expected if all inherited it from a common ancestor and if the protein is under strong selection to keep its function.
Reasoning. The more mutations that have accumulated, the longer ago the lineages split.

If mutations accumulate at a roughly constant rate, the number of differences can be used as a clock. A molecular clock is calibrated with a split of known date, which is often taken from a fossil. The date of the unknown split is then found by proportion.

Worked example · A molecular clock

Species A and B are known from fossils to have separated 20 million years ago, and their DNA sequences for a gene differ at 4 sites. Species C differs from A at 14 sites. Estimate when C and A diverged, and say what assumption you made.

Rate. 4 differences in 20 million years gives \(4/20 = 0.2\) differences per million years (or one per 5 million years) for the pair.
Date. \(14/0.2 = 70\) million years ago.
Assumption. The rate of change is constant, and the same, in all of the lineages. If C evolves faster, its true separation date is more recent than 70 million years. Clocks are usually calibrated with several fossils and many genes to reduce this error.

Common ancestry of all eukaryotes

Learning objective · 7.7.A

Describe structural and functional evidence on cellular and molecular levels that provides evidence for the common ancestry of all eukaryotes.

Required content · EK 7.7.A.1

Structural and functional evidence indicates common ancestry of all eukaryotes. This evidence includes:

  1. Membrane-bound organelles
  2. Linear chromosomes
  3. Genes that contain introns

Prokaryotes (bacteria and archaea) and eukaryotes are different in a number of ways, and eukaryotes, from yeast to plants to humans, share a set of features that bacteria lack. The simplest explanation is that these features arose once, in an ancestor of all eukaryotes.

  • Membrane-bound organelles. All eukaryotes have a nucleus enclosed by a double membrane, an endoplasmic reticulum, a Golgi apparatus, and (with few exceptions) mitochondria. Mitochondria and chloroplasts arose from bacteria that were engulfed (endosymbiosis, lesson 2.10): they have their own circular DNA and ribosomes like those of bacteria, two membranes, and they divide by a process like binary fission.
  • Linear chromosomes. Eukaryotic DNA is in linear chromosomes with ends (telomeres) and is wrapped around histone proteins, whereas most bacterial chromosomes are circular and have no histones.
  • Genes that contain introns. Eukaryotic genes have introns that are removed by splicing (lesson 6.3), while bacterial genes seldom have them.

Eukaryotes also share a cytoskeleton of microtubules and actin, mitosis and meiosis, similar histone proteins, and a similar pattern of the same cell signaling and cell-cycle proteins (lessons 4.1 to 4.7). A feature that is unnecessary for the survival of a given organism and is shared by all of them is best explained by common ancestry and not by independent origin.

Exam focus
  • Evidence for evolution comes from fossils (geologic layers and radiometric dating), biogeography, homologous and vestigial structures, embryology, and DNA/protein sequences. Independent lines that agree make the case strong.
  • Half-life: remaining \(= (1/2)^n\) of the original. Pick an isotope with a half-life that fits the age (C-14 for under 50,000 years; K-40 and U-238 for rocks).
  • Homologous = same origin, maybe different function (common ancestry). Analogous = same function, different origin (convergent evolution).
  • Fewer sequence differences = more recent common ancestor. A molecular clock needs a calibration point and a constant-rate assumption.
  • Eukaryote common ancestry: membrane-bound organelles, linear chromosomes, introns.
Practice
  1. A bone has 12.5% of its original C-14. Calculate its age and decide whether C-14 is appropriate.
    Show answer

    12.5% is \((1/2)^3\), so three half-lives have passed: \(3 \times 5{,}730 = 17{,}190\) years. C-14 is appropriate because the age is below about 50,000 years.

  2. Classify as homologous or analogous: (a) a bat wing and a human arm; (b) the wing of a bat and the wing of a butterfly. Justify.
    Show answer

    (a) Homologous: both have the same bones in the same arrangement, inherited from a common mammalian ancestor. (b) Analogous: both are used for flight, but they have a different structure and origin (a modified forelimb with bones against a wing of chitin), and they evolved independently.

  3. Explain how vestigial structures such as the pelvic bones of whales support the idea of common ancestry.
    Show answer

    The bones have no use for walking in a whale, so they are not explained by the whale’s way of life. They are explained if whales descended from four-legged land mammals that had a functional pelvis and hind limbs, which are reduced because the structure is no longer under selection in the sea. Fossil whales with hind limbs match this prediction.

  4. Two species A and B differ at 6 sites of a gene, and a fossil dates their separation at 30 million years ago. Species C differs from A at 10 sites. Estimate the divergence time of C and A.
    Show answer

    The rate is \(6/30 = 0.2\) differences per million years. \(10/0.2 = 50\) million years ago.

  5. Protein X differs in 3 of 150 amino acids between species 1 and 2, and in 30 of 150 between species 1 and 3. Which pair shares the more recent common ancestor, and what is the percent difference of each?
    Show answer

    Species 1 and 2 (3/150 = 2% difference) share a more recent common ancestor than species 1 and 3 (30/150 = 20% difference), because fewer mutations have accumulated.

  6. Name three features that provide evidence of the common ancestry of all eukaryotes and say how each differs in bacteria.
    Show answer

    Membrane-bound organelles (bacteria have none, apart from a few simple compartments); linear chromosomes with telomeres and histones (bacteria usually have one circular chromosome without histones); genes that contain introns (bacterial genes generally have no introns, so the mRNA is not spliced).

Lesson 7.7 · Unit 7 · CED topics 7.8 and 7.11

Continuing evolution and the value of genetic diversity

When penicillin became widely available in the 1940s, it was a miracle drug. Today, in many hospitals, more than half of the Staphylococcus aureus infections are resistant to methicillin, a drug in the same family. The influenza vaccine has to be redesigned nearly every year, and a new coronavirus in 2019 produced a series of variants within two years. Evolution is not a thing of the distant past or a thing that happened only in fossils: it is going on now in every population, and sometimes within weeks. This lesson looks at how we can observe ongoing evolution, and at the other side of the coin, that populations with little genetic diversity cannot respond when their environment changes.

Learning objective · 7.8.A

Explain how evolution is an ongoing process in all living organisms.

Required content · EK 7.8.A.1

All species have evolved and continue to evolve. Examples include:

  1. Genomic changes over time
  2. Continuous change in the fossil record
  3. Evolution of resistance to antibiotics, pesticides, herbicides, or chemotherapy drugs
  4. Pathogens evolving and causing emergent diseases

Evidence that evolution is continuing

  • Genomic changes over time. Comparing genomes of living people and ancient DNA shows allele frequencies changing in historical times. The allele for lactase persistence (the ability to digest milk sugar as an adult) is rare in the world as a whole but common in populations with a long history of dairying, and it rose in frequency within the last 10,000 years. Genome sequencing of a virus from patients over a few months shows mutations accumulating and lineages that spread.
  • Continuous change in the fossil record. Species appear, change, and disappear throughout the record. More than 99% of the species that have ever lived are extinct. There is no point at which the record shows that change stopped, so the species of today are a stage in a long series (lesson 7.9).
  • Resistance to drugs and pesticides. Bacteria, insects, weeds, and cancer cells have all evolved resistance to the chemicals used against them.
  • Emergent diseases. Pathogens evolve, and a new variant of a virus can infect a new host or avoid immunity. HIV, the 1918 and 2009 influenza strains, and SARS-CoV-2 are examples.

How resistance evolves

1.variation: a fewresistant cells2.drug kills susceptiblecells3.survivors reproduce4.mostly resistantpopulationsusceptibleresistant
Figure 7.7a How resistance spreads. The drug does not cause the resistance: the variation was already there. The drug is the selective pressure that lets resistant individuals leave more offspring.

The cycle in the figure is the same for an antibiotic, an insecticide, a herbicide, or a cancer drug, and it is the same cycle as in lesson 7.1. (1) A large population contains variation, and a few individuals carry a mutation that makes them resistant. Mutations arise by chance, whether or not the drug is present. (2) The drug is a selective pressure that kills the susceptible individuals. (3) The resistant survivors have little competition and reproduce. (4) The resistant offspring now make up most of the population. Three features make the process fast in microbes and insects: huge populations (so a rare mutation is present), short generation times, and (in bacteria) horizontal gene transfer (lesson 6.8), which passes resistance genes between cells, even between species.

Worked example · How fast can bacteria evolve?

A bacterial culture has \(10^9\) cells and the mutation to resistance to an antibiotic occurs in 1 cell in \(10^7\). (a) How many resistant cells are in the culture? (b) A single resistant cell divides every 20 minutes. How long does it take to produce \(10^9\) cells? (c) Two drugs are used together, and resistance to each is independent. How many cells would be expected to resist both?

(a) \(10^9 \times 10^{-7} = 100\) resistant cells, before any drug has been added.
(b) \(2^{30} = 1.07 \times 10^9\), so about 30 doublings are needed: \(30 \times 20\) minutes \(= 600\) minutes, or 10 hours.
(c) The probability of two independent mutations in one cell is \(10^{-7} \times 10^{-7} = 10^{-14}\) (product rule), so \(10^9 \times 10^{-14} = 10^{-5}\) cells are expected, that is, essentially none. This is the reason that combination therapy is used to treat tuberculosis, HIV, and many cancers.
Reasoning. Resistance is not caused by the drug. It is in the population already, and the drug selects it. This is also why finishing a course of antibiotics matters: stopping early leaves the partially resistant cells alive.

Resistance has a cost in many cases. In the absence of the drug, the resistant cells may grow more slowly (for example because the pump or the altered enzyme is less efficient), so the frequency of resistance can decrease when the drug is not used, which is an argument for using antibiotics only when needed. Overuse of drugs, or use in livestock feed, increases the selective pressure.

A new investigation (skill 3.D)

The exam asks you to evaluate an experiment and propose a follow-up. Take a typical study: bacteria are spread on plates with 0, 1, 2, and 4 µg/mL of an antibiotic, and the number of colonies is counted after 24 hours. A good proposal states a testable question that arises from the data, names the independent variable (what you change), the dependent variable (what you measure), the control, and what result would support the hypothesis. For example: “Does exposure to a low dose of the antibiotic select for resistance?” Grow a culture for 10 generations in a low dose of the antibiotic and a second culture with no antibiotic (control), plate both on a high dose, and count colonies. If the first culture has a much higher number of colonies, the data support selection for resistance. Several replicates and the same starting culture reduce the error.

Genetic diversity and the ability to respond

Learning objective · 7.11.A

Explain how the genetic diversity of a species or population affects its ability to withstand environmental pressures.

Required content · EK 7.11.A.1

The level of variation in a population affects population dynamics.

  1. The ability of a population to respond to changes in the environment is influenced by genetic diversity. Species and populations with little genetic diversity are at risk of decline or extinction.
  2. Genetically diverse populations are more resilient to environmental perturbation because they are more likely to contain individuals that can withstand the environmental pressure.
  3. Alleles that are adaptive in one environmental condition may be deleterious in another because of different selective pressures.

Selection can only act on the variation that is there. A population with many alleles is like a diversified portfolio: when conditions change, some of the individuals are likely to have a combination that works. A population with little variation has no such reserve. When a disease, a heat wave, or a new predator arrives, either everyone can cope or no one can.

Worked example · Why diversity protects a population

A new fungal disease kills every plant except those homozygous for a recessive resistance allele. Population A has 10,000 plants and the allele frequency is \(q = 0.10\). Population B has 10,000 plants that came from a few founders and \(q = 0.01\). How many resistant plants does each population have, and what are the consequences?

Population A. The frequency of resistant plants is \(q^2 = 0.01\), so \(0.01 \times 10{,}000 = 100\) plants survive.
Population B. \(q^2 = 0.0001\), so \(0.0001 \times 10{,}000 = 1\) plant survives.
Consequences. The 100 survivors in A form a population with a new frequency of the resistance allele of 1.0, which can recover, but it would have lost a large part of its variation at other genes. In B a single survivor (or none, by chance) leaves the population very small and likely to go extinct, or at least to be affected by inbreeding.
Reasoning. Because the population contained the allele before the disease arrived, it was able to respond, and the frequency of a rare allele determines how many individuals can survive.

The examples from the CED show what happens when genetic diversity is low.

  • California condor. By 1982 only 22 birds were left. All remaining birds were brought into captive breeding in 1987. The population has grown to several hundred, but it descends from a few founders and has low diversity and inherited health problems.
  • Black-footed ferret. Thought to be extinct until a small colony was found in Wyoming in 1981. All of today’s ferrets descend from a small number of survivors (about 18 reproduced in captivity), so they have low variation and are susceptible to the plague and distemper.
  • Greater prairie chicken. In Illinois, the population fell from millions in the 1800s to fewer than 50 birds in the 1990s, and the hatching rate of eggs fell. Introducing birds from other states (gene flow, lesson 7.4) raised the hatching rate and the numbers.
  • Potato blight. The Irish potato famine of the 1840s killed about a million people. Most Irish farmers grew one variety, a clone, so a single pathogen, Phytophthora infestans, could destroy the crop all over the country. The Andean potatoes of South America are much more diverse and are not so vulnerable.
  • Corn rust and the 1970 corn blight (lesson 7.3): genetically uniform crops are vulnerable to a single disease.
  • Antibiotic resistance. In a diverse bacterial population, some cells are resistant: the population as a whole survives an antibiotic treatment even though most cells die. That is a benefit of diversity to the bacteria and a problem to the patient.

The third part of EK 7.11.A.1 reminds you that an allele is not good or bad in itself. The sickle cell allele (lesson 7.2) is deleterious in a malaria-free environment and beneficial in a heterozygote where malaria is present. An allele that causes a plant to flower very early can help in a short summer but be lethal in a spring that has late frosts. Variation that does not help now may be the one that saves the population in the future, which is the reason conservation biologists try to preserve genetic diversity.

Exam focus
  • Four examples of ongoing evolution: genomic change, the fossil record, resistance (antibiotics, pesticides, herbicides, chemotherapy), emerging pathogens.
  • Resistance mechanism: variation exists before the drug, the drug selects and does not cause the mutation, resistant survivors reproduce, the frequency rises. Name the selective pressure.
  • Fast in microbes because of large populations, short generation times, and horizontal gene transfer. Combination therapy works because the probabilities multiply.
  • Diversity = resilience. Low diversity (condor, ferret, prairie chicken, clonal crops) means a higher risk of decline or extinction under a new pressure.
  • An allele can be adaptive in one environment and deleterious in another.
  • For “propose an investigation”: state a question, the independent and dependent variables, a control, replicates, and the expected result.
Practice
  1. A patient takes an antibiotic for three days, feels better, and stops. The infection returns and is more resistant. Explain using the terms variation and selection.
    Show answer

    The bacterial population had variation in sensitivity to the drug. The antibiotic killed the most susceptible cells first, and after three days the survivors included the less susceptible ones. Stopping early left them alive, and they reproduced without competition, so the next generation had a higher proportion of cells with resistance alleles. The drug acted as the selective pressure.

  2. In a culture of \(10^{10}\) bacteria, 1 cell in \(10^8\) is resistant to drug A and 1 in \(10^6\) to drug B (independent). Calculate the expected number resistant to A, to B, and to both.
    Show answer

    A: \(10^{10} \times 10^{-8} = 100\) cells. B: \(10^{10} \times 10^{-6} = 10{,}000\) cells. Both: \(10^{10} \times 10^{-8} \times 10^{-6} = 10^{-4}\), essentially none.

  3. A farmer sprays a field with a herbicide and 99.9% of the weeds die. Three years later the herbicide no longer works. Describe what happened in terms of allele frequency.
    Show answer

    A few weeds carried an allele that confers resistance. Each spraying killed the susceptible weeds and left the resistant ones, which set seed. The frequency of the resistance allele rose each year, and after three years most of the weeds were resistant.

  4. Explain why a population of cheetahs with very little genetic variation is at greater risk from a new disease than a population of zebras with a lot of variation.
    Show answer

    If the cheetahs are almost genetically identical, then an individual that is susceptible to the pathogen means that most or all of them are, so the disease could kill most of the population. A diverse population is likely to contain some individuals with immune genes or other alleles that give resistance, so some survive and reproduce and the population can recover.

  5. Propose an experiment to test whether bacteria exposed to a low dose of an antibiotic evolve resistance. Identify the independent and dependent variable and the control.
    Show answer

    Divide a culture into two sets of tubes, one grown with a low dose of the antibiotic and the control grown without it, for several generations. Then plate both on agar with a high dose of the antibiotic. The independent variable is the exposure to the low dose; the dependent variable is the number of colonies that grow (or the percent survival); the control is the culture with no antibiotic. If the exposed culture has more colonies, selection for resistance is supported. Use several replicates of each.

  6. Give an example of an allele that is beneficial in one environment and harmful in another and state which.
    Show answer

    The sickle cell allele: in a region with malaria, carriers (one copy) have an advantage because they are less likely to get severe malaria, so it is beneficial. Where there is no malaria, the allele has no advantage and causes sickle cell disease in people with two copies, so it is deleterious.

Lesson 7.8 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.9

Phylogeny: reading and building evolutionary trees

For a long time, whales were classified as a strange kind of fish, and birds were put in a group of their own. DNA sequencing then showed that the closest living relatives of whales are hippopotamuses, and the study of fossils with feathers showed that birds are a branch of the dinosaurs. These changes were not a matter of opinion: they came from a method for turning data on shared traits into a picture of relatedness. The picture is a phylogenetic tree or a cladogram, and the AP exam asks you to read one, to say what it shows and does not show, and to build a simple one from a table of traits.

Learning objective · 7.9.A

Describe the types of evidence that can be used to infer an evolutionary relationship.

Required content · EK 7.9.A.1 and 7.9.A.2

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms show hypothetical evolutionary relationships among lineages that can be tested.

Phylogenetic trees show the amount of change over time calibrated by fossils or a molecular clock, whereas cladograms do not show time scale or the evolutionary difference between groups.

How to read a tree

jawslungs, limbsamniotic egghairLamprey (outgroup)TroutFrogLizardMouseroot: common ancestor
Figure 7.8a A cladogram built from shared derived characters. Each orange mark is a trait gained on that branch and inherited by every lineage to its right. Branch lengths are not meaningful: a cladogram shows the order of branching, not time.

A tree represents the history of lineages (lines of descent). The parts have fixed meanings, and mixing them up is the most common error in questions on this topic.

  • Tips (the ends of the branches) are the species or groups that are being compared, usually living ones.
  • Branches are lineages through time.
  • Nodes (branch points) are speciation events. A node represents the most recent common ancestor of all the lineages that descend from it (EK 7.9.B.1).
  • Sister groups are two lineages that share an immediate common ancestor that is not shared with any other group (frog and the lizard-and-mouse group in the figure).
  • A clade is an ancestor and all of its descendants: cut one branch and everything that is attached to it is a clade. A group that leaves out some descendants is not a clade.
  • The outgroup is the lineage that is least closely related to the others. It branches first and is used as a reference: a trait found in the outgroup is probably the ancestral form.

Relatedness is about how recently lineages share an ancestor, not about how the tips look or how they are ordered on the page. The branches can be rotated at any node without changing the tree, like a mobile, so two tips that are next to each other are not necessarily closely related, and the order of the tips from top to bottom means nothing. In the figure, trout is not “less evolved” than mouse: all five tips are living species that have evolved for the same amount of time since the root.

Worked example · Reading a cladogram

Use the cladogram of lamprey, trout, frog, lizard, and mouse. (a) Which species is the outgroup? (b) Which species is the closest relative of the mouse? (c) Is the trout more closely related to the frog or to the lizard? (d) Which traits are shared by the lizard and the mouse but not by the frog? (e) Is the group “frog and lizard” (leaving out the mouse) a clade?

(a) The lamprey, which branches off first and lacks jaws.
(b) The lizard. They are sister groups that share a common ancestor, which had the amniotic egg, that is not shared with the frog or the trout.
(c) The trout is equally related to the frog and to the lizard: the common ancestor of the trout and the other three is a single node, and it is shared by all of them. (The trout is also equally related to the mouse.)
(d) The amniotic egg. (Jaws, lungs, and four limbs are also found in the frog, so they are not shared only by the lizard and the mouse.)
(e) No. The most recent common ancestor of the frog and the lizard is also the ancestor of the mouse, so a group that leaves out the mouse excludes one of its descendants. This is a paraphyletic group, not a clade.
Reasoning. Read the tree by finding the most recent node that connects two tips.

Phylogenetic trees and time

20151050Millions of years ago (approximate)OrangutanGorillaChimpanzeeHumannode: most recentcommon ancestor
Figure 7.8b A phylogenetic tree with a time scale. The position of each node shows when the lineages split (dates are approximate). Each node is the most recent common ancestor of the lineages to its right: humans and chimpanzees share a more recent ancestor with each other than either does with the gorilla.

A cladogram shows only the order of branching. The lengths of its branches have no meaning, and it does not show how many changes happened or how much time passed. A phylogenetic tree adds a scale: the length of the branch is proportional to time (calibrated with fossils or a molecular clock, lesson 7.6) or to the amount of genetic change. In the tree above the position of each node can be read from the time axis: the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees lived about 6 million years ago, and the ancestor shared with the gorilla about 9 million years ago. Because the chimpanzee and the human split from each other more recently than from the gorilla, chimpanzees are the closest living relatives of humans, and humans and chimpanzees together are the sister group of the gorilla.

Worked example · Reading time from a tree

In the tree above, how long ago did the human and gorilla lineages share a common ancestor, how long have the human and chimpanzee lineages been separate, and how much independent evolution separates a human from a chimpanzee?

Human and gorilla. Their last common ancestor is the node at about 9 million years ago.
Human and chimpanzee. Their lineages have been separate for about 6 million years.
Total change. Both lineages have been evolving since the split, so the distance between the two tips along the branches is \(6 + 6 = 12\) million years of lineage time. This is why a molecular clock counts the differences between two species as the sum of the changes along both branches.
Reasoning. The time scale is only available in a phylogenetic tree. In a cladogram you could say which splits came first, but not when.

Building a tree from traits

Required content · EK 7.9.A.3

Traits that are either gained or lost during evolution can be used to construct phylogenetic trees and cladograms. The outgroup represents the lineage that is least closely related to the remainder of the organisms in the phylogenetic tree or cladogram.

  1. Shared derived characters can be present in more than one lineage and indicate common ancestry. These are informative for the construction of phylogenetic trees and cladograms.
  2. Molecular data typically provide more accurate and reliable evidence than morphological traits in the construction of phylogenetic trees or cladograms.

The method is based on shared derived characters: traits that arose in the common ancestor of a group and that are found in its descendants but not in the outgroup. The derived state is the new one; the ancestral state is the older one, and it is found in the outgroup. A trait shared because it is ancestral (for example “has a backbone” in a tree of mammals) does not help to separate the mammals from each other: only derived characters can show which lineages form a clade. In the cladogram above, hair is a derived character that is found only in the mouse in this tree; the amniotic egg is derived and shared by the lizard and the mouse, which indicates that they have a common ancestor that the frog does not share.

The principle of parsimony. More than one tree can usually be drawn for the same data. Scientists prefer the tree that requires the fewest evolutionary changes, because it is the simplest explanation. This is a rule of thumb that works well, not a proof.

Worked example · Choosing a tree by parsimony

Three species and an outgroup (O) are scored for three characters, where 0 is the ancestral state, which O has, and 1 is the derived state.

SpeciesCharacter 1Character 2Character 3
Outgroup O000
Species 1110
Species 2111
Species 3001

Compare three possible trees: X groups species 1 and 2 as sister species (3 is the sister to them), Y groups 2 and 3, and Z groups 1 and 3. Which one needs the fewest changes?

Tree X (1 and 2 together). Characters 1 and 2 each arise once (in the ancestor of 1 and 2): 2 changes. Character 3 is found in species 2 and 3 but not in 1, which are not sister groups, so it must have arisen twice: 2 changes. Total 4.
Tree Y (2 and 3 together). Character 3 arises once (1 change), but characters 1 and 2 are in species 1 and 2 only and must arise twice each: 4 changes. Total 5.
Tree Z (1 and 3 together). Each of the three characters is shared by one member of the pair and by species 2 only, so each arises twice: Total 6.
Decision. Tree X, with 4 changes, is the most parsimonious, and it is the hypothesis that is preferred. Species 1 and 2 are the sister species.
Reasoning. A character that arises independently more than once is called homoplasy (for example, by convergent evolution), and a parsimonious tree minimizes it.

Molecular data are better than morphology in most cases. A DNA sequence has thousands to millions of characters, they are scored the same way for every species, and they are less subject to convergence in the case of neutral changes. In contrast, a morphological trait may evolve independently in distant groups for the same function: the streamlined body of a shark, an ichthyosaur, and a dolphin; the camera eye of squids and of vertebrates; the wings of birds, bats, and insects. Such analogous traits would give a false grouping. Fossils, which have only morphology, are essential, and the best trees combine molecular data on living species with morphological data on the fossil species.

Trees are hypotheses

Learning objective · 7.9.B

Explain how phylogenetic trees and cladograms can be used to infer evolutionary relatedness.

Required content · EK 7.9.B.1 to 7.9.B.3

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms can be used to illustrate speciation that has occurred. The nodes on a tree represent the most recent common ancestor of any two groups or lineages.

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms can be constructed from morphological similarities of living or fossil species and from DNA and protein sequence similarities.

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms represent hypotheses that are constantly being revised based on evidence.

A tree is a hypothesis: it makes predictions that can be tested with new data, such as a newly found fossil or a newly sequenced gene, and it is changed when the evidence requires it. The hippopotamus-and-whale relationship, the placement of birds within dinosaurs, and the discovery that fungi are closer to animals than to plants all came from new data. Trees also have limits: they show relatedness only for the traits and species used, and horizontal gene transfer in bacteria makes the history of genes more like a network than a tree.

Exam focus
  • A node is the most recent common ancestor of the groups to its right. Find relatedness by locating the most recent shared node, not by how close the tips are.
  • Cladogram: order of branching only, branch lengths mean nothing. Phylogenetic tree: branch length shows time (fossils or molecular clock) or amount of change.
  • Outgroup = the least related lineage; it shows the ancestral state. Only shared derived characters define clades.
  • A clade includes an ancestor and all its descendants.
  • Parsimony: prefer the tree with the fewest changes (count them for each candidate tree).
  • Molecular data are generally more reliable than morphology (convergence and homoplasy). Trees are hypotheses, revised with new evidence.
Practice
  1. In the cladogram of this lesson, state which has the more recent common ancestor with the frog: the lizard or the trout. Explain.
    Show answer

    The frog shares a more recent common ancestor with the lizard (and mouse) than with the trout. The node joining the frog with the lizard and mouse (the ancestor with lungs and four limbs) is later than the node that joins the trout with all three.

  2. A student says that the tip at the top of a cladogram is the most “primitive” species because it is at the top. Correct the statement.
    Show answer

    The order of tips has no meaning because branches can be rotated at the nodes. All species at the tips are living species that have evolved for the same length of time since the common ancestor. The most distantly related lineage is the outgroup, identified by where it branches off, not by its position on the page, and even it is not “primitive”, just the first to branch.

  3. Using the character table of this lesson, add a species 4 that has 0, 0, 0 for the three characters. Where would it be placed in the tree, and why?
    Show answer

    It has only the ancestral states, as the outgroup does, so it has no shared derived characters and gives no evidence that it belongs with the other species. It would be placed with the outgroup, at the base of the tree, branching before species 1, 2, and 3.

  4. Two unrelated desert plants both have thick, water-storing stems with spines. Explain why the shared trait is a poor character for a tree, and what to use instead.
    Show answer

    The two plants evolved the traits independently in response to a similar environment (convergent evolution), so the trait is analogous and not a shared derived character that was inherited from a common ancestor. Using it would put the plants together wrongly. DNA sequences, or homologous structures such as flower parts, would be a better indicator of relationships.

  5. On a phylogenetic tree with a time scale, species A and B split at 12 million years ago and species C splits from their common ancestor at 30 million years ago. Which pair is the most closely related, and how long have A and C been separate?
    Show answer

    A and B are the most closely related (the most recent node, 12 million years ago). A and C have been separate for 30 million years, since the node where C branches off.

  6. Explain why a tree based on DNA can overturn a tree based on anatomy, and why this does not show that science is unreliable.
    Show answer

    DNA gives a much larger number of characters that are less affected by convergence, so it can reveal that a similarity in anatomy is analogous rather than inherited. Trees are hypotheses, and revising them when better data appear is how science works. Each revision makes the hypothesis agree with more of the evidence.

Lesson 7.9 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.10

Speciation: how new species arise

A horse and a donkey can mate, and the offspring, a mule, is strong and healthy. But a mule is almost always sterile, and no mule population can continue on its own. Horses and donkeys are therefore two species even though they can hybridize. Hawaii has roughly 1,000 species of the fruit fly genus Drosophila, all descended from one or a few ancestors that arrived on the islands. How does one species become two? The answer links everything in this unit: variation, selection, drift, and the isolation of gene pools.

Learning objective · 7.10.A

Describe the conditions under which new species may arise.

Required content · EK 7.10.A.1 and 7.10.A.2

Speciation occurs when two populations become reproductively isolated from each other.

The biological species concept provides a commonly used definition of a species for sexually reproducing organisms. It states that species can be defined as a group capable of interbreeding and exchanging genetic information to produce viable, fertile offspring.

What is a species?

The biological species concept defines a species as a group of populations whose members can interbreed in nature and produce viable, fertile offspring, and which are reproductively isolated from other such groups. Both words matter: a mule is viable (it lives) but not fertile. The concept has limits. It cannot be applied to organisms that reproduce asexually, to fossils, or to groups that hybridize regularly (many plants, and some birds and fish), so biologists also use other definitions, based on morphology, ecology, or DNA. For the exam, the biological species concept is the one to know.

The central idea is that species stay separate because they do not exchange genes. Gene flow keeps populations similar, and when it stops, selection and drift in each population can make them diverge until they cannot interbreed. Speciation is therefore the evolution of reproductive isolation. It is not an event that is complete in one generation; it is a process that can last thousands to millions of years.

Reproductive barriers

Required content · EK 7.10.C.2

Various pre-zygotic and post-zygotic mechanisms can maintain reproductive isolation and prevent gene flow between populations.

Prezygotic barriers (before a zygote forms)Postzygotic barriers (after a zygote forms)Habitat isolationTemporal isolationBehavioral isolationMechanical isolationGametic isolationHybrid inviabilityHybrid sterilityHybrid breakdownmating and fertilization are preventedhybrid forms but cannot pass on genes
Figure 7.9a Barriers that keep gene pools separate. Any one of them, if complete, prevents gene flow between two populations. Prezygotic barriers act before fertilization; postzygotic barriers act after it and reduce the fitness of hybrids.
BarrierWhat prevents gene flowExample
Habitat isolationThe species live in different habitats and rarely meet.Two garter snake species, one living mainly in water and the other on land.
Temporal isolationThey breed at different times of day or year.Two species of pine that release pollen in February and April; the eastern and western spotted skunks.
Behavioral isolationCourtship signals do not attract the other species.Songs of birds, flashing patterns of fireflies, and dances of blue-footed boobies.
Mechanical isolationReproductive structures do not fit together.Flowers shaped for different pollinators; snail shells coiled in opposite directions.
Gametic isolationSperm and egg do not fuse, or pollen does not grow on the other species’ stigma.Sea urchins that release gametes into the same water: the egg and sperm proteins match only within a species.
Hybrid inviabilityA hybrid zygote does not develop or survive.Hybrids of some frogs and salamanders die as embryos.
Hybrid sterilityThe hybrid lives but cannot make functional gametes.The mule: horse \(2n = 64\) and donkey \(2n = 62\) give 63 chromosomes, which cannot pair evenly in meiosis.
Hybrid breakdownThe first generation is fertile but the next one is weak or sterile.Hybrids of some cotton and rice strains.

The prezygotic barriers act before a zygote forms and so save the energy of making inferior offspring. The postzygotic barriers act afterward. Each barrier that evolves further reduces gene flow, and several are usually present together.

Worked example · Classifying a barrier

Classify each of the following as prezygotic or postzygotic, and name the barrier. (a) Two species of frogs have calls that differ, and females respond only to the call of their own species. (b) A lion and a tiger can produce a liger, which is large but sterile. (c) The flowers of two orchid species fit different pollinators, so pollen from one species is never delivered to the other. (d) Two species of abalone release sperm and eggs into the sea together, but the sperm of one species cannot fertilize eggs of the other.

(a) Prezygotic, behavioral isolation (the signal for mate choice).
(b) Postzygotic, hybrid sterility: the zygote forms and develops, but the hybrid cannot reproduce.
(c) Prezygotic, mechanical isolation (the structures do not fit together, so pollen is not transferred between the species).
(d) Prezygotic, gametic isolation: the gametes meet but do not fuse.
Reasoning. Ask whether a zygote has been formed at the point where gene flow is stopped.

How populations become isolated

Learning objective · 7.10.C

Explain the processes and mechanisms that drive speciation.

Required content · EK 7.10.C.1

Sympatric speciation occurs in populations with geographic overlap. Allopatric speciation occurs in populations that are geographically isolated.

Allopatric speciation (separated by a barrier)1. one population2. barrier forms3. populations diverge4. contact again: no interbreedingSympatric speciation (same area): the apple maggot flyancestral flieshawthorn fruitapple fruitSame region, but each group matesand lays eggs on its own fruit,which ripens at a different time.Gene flow declines.
Figure 7.9b Two ways that populations become isolated. In allopatric speciation a physical barrier stops gene flow; in sympatric speciation a change in behavior, habitat use or chromosome number isolates populations that share a range.

Allopatric speciation (“other homeland”) is the most common route. A physical barrier splits a population, for example a river that changes its course, a mountain range that rises, or a few individuals that cross to an island (the founder effect, lesson 7.4). With no gene flow, each population is acted on by its own mutations, genetic drift, and a different set of selective pressures, and the gene pools drift apart. If the two groups meet again later and the differences are large enough that they no longer interbreed successfully, they are separate species. A classic example is the snapping shrimp of the genus Alpheus: when the Isthmus of Panama closed about 3 million years ago, the populations on the Pacific and Caribbean sides were separated, and today there are several pairs of closely related species, one on each side.

Sympatric speciation (“same homeland”) takes place in populations that live in the same area. It needs a mechanism that isolates part of the population in the absence of a physical barrier.

  • Polyploidy is common in plants. A failure of meiosis (lesson 5.2) produces diploid gametes, and the union of two of them gives a tetraploid (\(4n\)) plant that can mate with other tetraploids but whose offspring with diploid plants (triploid, \(3n\)) are sterile. A new species can form in one generation. Wheat, cotton, and many ferns arose in this way.
  • Habitat or resource shifts. The apple maggot fly, Rhagoletis pomonella, originally laid eggs only on hawthorn fruit. About 150 years ago some flies started to use apples, which ripen earlier. Flies mate on the fruit where they were raised, so apple flies mate with apple flies, and the two groups now differ in the timing of their life cycle and in some alleles, even though they live together.
  • Sexual selection can do the same: in the cichlid fishes of the African lakes, females in different color preferences mate with males of a certain color, and hundreds of species formed in Lake Victoria within roughly 100,000 years.

A zone where two diverging populations meet and mate is a hybrid zone. If the hybrids are less fit, selection favors prezygotic barriers (reinforcement), which strengthens the isolation. If the hybrids are fit, the populations may merge back into one.

The rate of evolution and speciation

Learning objective · 7.10.B

Describe the rate of evolution and speciation under different ecological conditions.

Required content · EK 7.10.B.1 to 7.10.B.3

Punctuated equilibrium is when evolution occurs rapidly after a long period of stasis. Gradualism is when evolution occurs slowly over hundreds of thousands or millions of years.

Divergent evolution occurs when adaptation to new habitats results in phenotypic diversification. Speciation rates can be especially rapid during times of adaptive radiation as new habitats become available.

Convergent evolution occurs when similar selective pressures result in similar phenotypic adaptations in different populations or species.

GradualismtimetraitPunctuated equilibriumtimetrait
Figure 7.9c Two models of the rate of evolution. Gradualism: change accumulates slowly and steadily over hundreds of thousands to millions of years. Punctuated equilibrium: long periods of little change (stasis) are interrupted by short periods of rapid change.

The fossil record contains examples of both patterns. In gradualism species change steadily; in punctuated equilibrium (proposed by Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould in 1972), most of a species’ life is a period of stasis with little change, which is interrupted by short bursts of change, often when a small population is isolated and a new species forms. “Short” here is relative to geological time: thousands to tens of thousands of years. The two models are not mutually exclusive, and the pattern can differ between lineages.

Worked example · Reading fossil data

The mean shell width of a fossil snail is measured in rock layers of different ages: 5.0 cm at 10.0 million years ago (mya), 5.1 cm at 8.0 mya, 5.0 cm at 6.0 mya, 7.4 cm at 5.9 mya, and 7.5 cm at 4.0 mya. Calculate the rate of change in the first interval and in the interval from 6.0 to 5.9 mya, and say which model of evolution the data support.

10.0 to 8.0 mya. The change is \(5.1 - 5.0 = 0.1\) cm in 2.0 million years: \(0.1/2.0 = 0.05\) cm per million years.
6.0 to 5.9 mya. The change is \(7.4 - 5.0 = 2.4\) cm in 0.1 million years: \(2.4/0.1 = 24\) cm per million years.
Comparison. The rate in the second interval is \(24/0.05 = 480\) times faster.
Model. A long period with almost no change (5.0 to 5.1 cm over 4 million years) followed by a short period of rapid change and then a new period of stasis (7.4 to 7.5 cm) fits punctuated equilibrium.
Reasoning. A fossil record has gaps, and a sudden step may only reflect a missing layer, so more samples between 6.0 and 5.9 mya would be needed to be sure.

Divergent evolution is the development of differences between related groups as they adapt to different habitats. Adaptive radiation is a burst of divergence in which one ancestral species gives rise to many new species adapted to different ways of life, which happens when new habitats or resources become available: after a mass extinction empties niches, after a colonization of islands, or after the evolution of a key trait. Darwin’s finches on the Galapagos (about 15 species from a single ancestor, with beaks for seeds, insects, or cactus), the Hawaiian honeycreepers, the Caribbean Anolis lizards (each island has similar forms of trunk, twig, and grass specialists), and the mammals after the dinosaurs went extinct 66 million years ago are all examples.

Convergent evolution is the opposite pattern: similar selective pressures produce similar adaptations in species that are not closely related. The streamlined body of sharks, ichthyosaurs, and dolphins; the wings of birds and bats; the succulent stems of cacti in the Americas and of euphorbs in Africa; and the repeated evolution of similar Anolis forms on different islands are all convergent. Convergence is the reason that similar traits are not always evidence of close relationship (lesson 7.8).

Extinction

Extinction is the end of a lineage, and it is as much a part of evolution as speciation. More than 99% of all the species that have lived are extinct. The usual rate, the background extinction rate, is on the order of 1 species per million species per year. If there are about 10 million species, that is about \(10{,}000{,}000 \times 10^{-6} = 10\) species per year. Mass extinctions are periods in which a large part of the species disappear in a geologically short time. There have been five in the last 500 million years (the Permian extinction about 252 million years ago eliminated an estimated 90% of marine species, and the end-Cretaceous about 66 million years ago killed the non-avian dinosaurs). Extinctions are usually followed by adaptive radiations of survivors. Many scientists argue that the present rate of extinction, caused by habitat loss, climate change, overharvest, and invasive species, is 100 to 1,000 times the background rate (lesson 8.7).

Exam focus
  • Speciation = reproductive isolation. Biological species concept: interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring.
  • Sort barriers: prezygotic (habitat, temporal, behavioral, mechanical, gametic) and postzygotic (hybrid inviability, hybrid sterility, hybrid breakdown).
  • Allopatric: geographic barrier (most common). Sympatric: same area (polyploidy, habitat or mate-choice shifts).
  • Gradualism against punctuated equilibrium (stasis then rapid change). Compare rates by dividing change by time.
  • Divergent/adaptive radiation: one ancestor, many niches, rapid speciation. Convergent: similar pressures, similar traits, unrelated species.
  • Gene flow opposes divergence; drift and selection without gene flow drive it.
Practice
  1. Two populations of a lizard are separated when a river changes its course. After 100,000 years they meet and do not interbreed. Describe the mode of speciation and give two evolutionary processes that contributed.
    Show answer

    Allopatric speciation, because a physical barrier stopped gene flow. During the isolation each population changed through natural selection by its environment and genetic drift (and different mutations), so they diverged genetically until reproductive barriers evolved.

  2. A wheat plant has 28 chromosomes (\(4n\)) and a related wild grass has 14 (\(2n\)). Predict the chromosome number of their hybrid and its fertility, and explain.
    Show answer

    The hybrid receives 14 chromosomes from the wheat gamete (\(2n\) gametes of a tetraploid) and 7 from the grass, so it has 21 (a triploid). It is sterile because the chromosomes cannot pair into complete sets in meiosis. This is a postzygotic barrier (hybrid sterility), and it keeps the gene pools of the two species separate.

  3. Two species of fireflies live in the same meadow. Males of one flash twice per second, and the others flash once every 3 seconds, and females respond only to their own pattern. Name the barrier.
    Show answer

    Behavioral isolation, a prezygotic barrier: the mating signal differs, so the individuals do not mate.

  4. Tooth width in a lineage of fossil mammals changed by 0.2 mm in 3 million years, then by 1.5 mm in the following 30,000 years. Calculate the two rates and name the pattern.
    Show answer

    First: \(0.2/3 = 0.067\) mm per million years. Second: \(1.5/0.03 = 50\) mm per million years, about 750 times faster. The pattern of long stasis and then rapid change is punctuated equilibrium.

  5. Distinguish between adaptive radiation and convergent evolution using one example of each.
    Show answer

    Adaptive radiation is the rapid diversification of one ancestral lineage into many species that use different habitats or resources: the Galapagos finches from one ancestral species. Convergent evolution is the independent evolution of similar traits in unrelated lineages with similar selective pressures: the streamlined bodies of dolphins (mammals) and sharks (fish).

  6. Explain why a small amount of gene flow between two populations can prevent them from becoming separate species.
    Show answer

    Gene flow mixes alleles between the populations, so differences that selection or drift build up in one are spread to the other. This keeps their gene pools similar. Speciation needs gene flow to be reduced to the point that the populations can follow independent evolutionary paths.

Lesson 7.10 · Unit 7 · CED topic 7.12

The origin of life on Earth

Every cell alive today comes from an earlier cell, and that is true of every cell back through billions of years. But when the Earth formed, it was a ball of molten rock with no cells at all. At some point, chemistry became biology. No one saw it happen, and the process is still not fully understood, but it is not outside the reach of science: there is physical evidence for when it could have happened, laboratory experiments that test how some of the steps could occur, and a leading hypothesis about the first genetic material. This lesson covers what the CED requires, which is the geological evidence for the timing and the RNA world hypothesis, along with the experiments that are used to explain the origin of the building blocks of life.

Learning objective · 7.12.A

Describe the scientific evidence that supports models of the origin of life on Earth.

Required content · EK 7.12.A.1

The origin of life on Earth is supported by scientific evidence.

  1. Geological evidence reinforces models of the origin of life on Earth.
  2. Earth formed approximately 4.6 billion years ago (bya). The environment was too hostile for life until about 3.9 bya, and the earliest fossil evidence for life dates to 3.5 bya. Taken together, this evidence provides a plausible range of dates for the origin of life.

When did life begin?

4.6 byaEarth forms3.9 byaHostile conditions end3.5 byaEarliest fossil evidence of life2.4 byaOxygen builds up0 byaTodayBillions of years ago (bya): the earlier events are on the lefttoo hostile for lifelife presentwindow for the origin of life
Figure 7.10a Dating the origin of life. Earth formed about 4.6 billion years ago (bya), the environment was too hostile for life until about 3.9 bya, and the earliest fossil evidence of life is 3.5 bya, so life probably arose in a window of a few hundred million years (the oxygen date is approximate).

Three dates set the limits.

  • 4.6 billion years ago: Earth forms. This date comes from radiometric dating (lesson 7.6) of the oldest meteorites, which formed from the same cloud of material as the planets, and of moon rocks. The oldest rocks on Earth itself are younger, because the crust has been recycled, but individual zircon crystals from Western Australia are about 4.4 billion years old.
  • About 3.9 billion years ago: conditions become less hostile. Early Earth was bombarded by large asteroids and comets, which could have vaporized the oceans and sterilized the surface. The impact record on the Moon shows that the heaviest bombardment ended about 3.9 bya. Before that, any life that appeared would probably have been wiped out.
  • About 3.5 billion years ago: the earliest fossil evidence of life. Layered structures called stromatolites, made of sediment trapped by mats of microorganisms, and microscopic fossils of cells, are found in rocks of that age from Western Australia and South Africa. They show that cellular life already existed.
Worked example · A window for the origin

Use the three dates to find the possible window for the origin of life, and the fraction of Earth’s history in which there has been life.

Window. Life could not have survived before 3.9 bya, and cells existed by 3.5 bya, so the origin must be between those dates: \(3.9 - 3.5 = 0.4\) billion years, or 400 million years. This is a relatively short time on a geological scale, which suggests that the origin of life was not extremely improbable under the conditions on early Earth, although the evidence is not conclusive.
Fraction. Life has existed for at least 3.5 billion of the 4.6 billion years: \(3.5/4.6 = 0.76\), about 76% of the history of the planet.
Also note. Fossils record only organisms that left a trace, so the true origin could have been earlier than 3.5 bya (as far back as 3.9 bya in this model) and what the fossils show is the latest time by which life must already have existed.
Reasoning. A model with a lower limit (hostile environment) and an upper limit (fossils) gives a plausible range.

The earliest organisms were prokaryotes. The oxygen in the air came later: photosynthesis by cyanobacteria released oxygen that built up in the atmosphere about 2.4 billion years ago, which changed the environment for all life (it was toxic to many anaerobes), and eukaryotes appear in the fossil record about 1.8 to 2 billion years ago, with the origin of mitochondria and chloroplasts by endosymbiosis (lesson 2.10).

Making the building blocks

boiling watercooltrap with productselectric sparkCH₄, NH₃, H₂, water vaporcondenserwater vaporturns to liquidamino acids and otherorganic molecules collect
Figure 7.10b The Miller-Urey experiment (1953). Gases thought to be present on early Earth were circulated past an electric spark, which models lightning. After a few days the liquid in the trap contained amino acids and other organic molecules (schematic).

In the 1920s Aleksandr Oparin and J. B. S. Haldane suggested independently that the Earth’s early atmosphere and oceans could have produced organic molecules from inorganic ones, using energy from lightning, ultraviolet light, and heat. In 1953 Stanley Miller and Harold Urey tested the idea. Their apparatus held water that was heated to produce vapor and a mixture of gases they thought was present on early Earth (methane, ammonia, hydrogen). Electric sparks modeled lightning. A condenser cooled the gases, and the products collected in a trap. After a week the liquid had turned brown and contained several amino acids and other organic molecules. A reanalysis of Miller’s stored samples decades later found more than 20 amino acids.

The result showed that organic building blocks can form without life under conditions that could exist naturally. Scientists now think that the early atmosphere was less rich in methane and ammonia than Miller assumed, but similar results have been obtained with other gas mixtures, and other sources have been suggested: deep-sea hydrothermal vents, which supply chemical energy and minerals; the organic molecules in meteorites (the Murchison meteorite, which fell in Australia in 1969, contains dozens of amino acids); and chemical reactions on mineral surfaces. A protocell is a droplet or vesicle with a boundary that holds chemicals. Phospholipids and fatty acids form bilayer vesicles by themselves in water, and in the laboratory vesicles can grow, divide, and take up RNA, which shows that a membrane compartment could have formed without enzymes.

Worked example · Predicting the results of an experiment (skill 3.B)

A student repeats the Miller-Urey experiment. State the question, a prediction, and the controls, and say what result would contradict the hypothesis.

Hypothesis. Organic molecules such as amino acids can form from simple inorganic gases when an energy source is present.
Null hypothesis. No organic molecules will form from the gases, with or without energy.
Prediction. With the spark, the liquid in the trap contains amino acids after several days.
Controls. (1) The same apparatus without the electric spark, which should give few or no amino acids. (2) A sterile apparatus, to show that the amino acids do not come from contamination by living things (microbes, or fingerprints). (3) The apparatus without the gases.
Contradicting result. If the control without a spark produced as much as the experimental set, the energy would not be the cause; if the sterile apparatus produced none while a contaminated one produced many, the amino acids could be from living things.
Reasoning. A prediction has to say what is measured (the organic molecules in the trap) and the comparison that would show that the independent variable matters.

The RNA world hypothesis

Required content · EK 7.12.A.2

The RNA world hypothesis proposes that RNA could have been the earliest genetic material. There are three assumptions:

  1. At some point in time, genetic continuity was assured by the replication of RNA.
  2. Base-pairing is necessary for replication.
  3. Genetically encoded proteins were not involved as catalysts.

Today’s cells have a puzzle at their center: DNA stores the information, but DNA can only be copied with the help of protein enzymes, and proteins can only be made with the instructions in DNA. Which came first? The RNA world hypothesis suggests an answer: RNA can do both. Like DNA, RNA is a polymer of nucleotides that carries information in the order of its bases and can be copied by base pairing (A with U and G with C, lesson 6.1). And, unlike DNA, some RNA molecules can fold into shapes and act as catalysts. These are called ribozymes. Thomas Cech and Sidney Altman discovered them in the 1980s, and they won the Nobel Prize in 1989.

The three assumptions in the CED describe what the hypothesis requires. (i) At some time RNA replicated so that its sequence could be passed on, which is genetic continuity. (ii) The replication used base pairing: a strand is copied by building a complementary strand. (iii) The catalysis that was needed was done by RNA itself, and not by proteins that were encoded by genes, since the code and the machinery to translate it did not exist yet.

The evidence that makes the hypothesis plausible:

  • Ribozymes exist today. The ribosome is a ribozyme: the bond between amino acids is made by ribosomal RNA, and the proteins of the ribosome have a supporting role (lesson 6.4). Some introns splice themselves out, and RNase P is a ribozyme that cuts tRNA.
  • In the laboratory, RNA molecules have been selected that copy other RNA molecules, although so far not with perfect accuracy.
  • Many of the central molecules of metabolism are nucleotides or are related to them: ATP, NAD, FAD, and coenzyme A all contain an adenine nucleotide, which may be a relic of the RNA world.

The hypothesis proposes that later, protein enzymes, which have 20 building blocks and are far more versatile catalysts, took over the work of catalysis, and the more stable and less reactive DNA took over the storage of information. RNA was left with the roles of messenger, adapter, and part of the ribosome. It is a hypothesis with open questions (for example, how the first RNA nucleotides formed and how copying began without enzymes), so you should describe it as a model supported by evidence and not as an established fact.

Exam focus
  • Dates: Earth 4.6 bya; too hostile until 3.9 bya; earliest fossil evidence 3.5 bya. The origin of life falls between 3.9 and 3.5 bya, a window of about 400 million years.
  • Evidence: radiometric dating of meteorites and rocks, the impact record, stromatolites and microfossils.
  • Miller-Urey: simulated early Earth (gases, water, spark) and produced amino acids. It shows that organic molecules can form abiotically; it does not show how life began. Know the controls.
  • RNA world: RNA stores information and catalyzes reactions (ribozymes). Three assumptions: RNA replication, base pairing, no encoded proteins as catalysts.
  • Supporting evidence: the ribosome is a ribozyme, self-splicing introns, laboratory selection of RNA, nucleotide cofactors.
  • These are models supported by evidence, and they are tested and revised.
Practice
  1. Explain why the date of the earliest fossils, 3.5 bya, does not by itself tell us when life first appeared.
    Show answer

    Fossils give a latest possible date: life must have existed by then. It could have originated earlier. The early fossils are rare because soft-bodied microbes seldom fossilize and because most early rocks have been destroyed or changed. Together with the 3.9 bya date for the end of the hostile conditions, the evidence gives a range, not an exact date.

  2. Why did the Miller-Urey apparatus include an electric spark and a condenser?
    Show answer

    The spark modeled lightning, an energy source on early Earth that could drive chemical reactions between the gases. The condenser cooled the vapor so that water and the molecules that formed could collect in the trap (as rain and the ocean would on early Earth) and be removed from the spark, which could destroy them.

  3. A mineral has 50% of its original uranium-238 left (half-life 4.47 billion years). Calculate its age and compare it with the age of the Earth.
    Show answer

    50% is one half-life, so the mineral is 4.47 billion years old. This is only slightly less than the 4.6 billion years of the Earth, so it is about as old as the oldest known zircon crystals (about 4.4 billion years) and must have formed very early in Earth’s history. A mineral with 25% left would be 8.94 billion years old, which is older than the Earth, so such a result would indicate an error or a sample that did not form on Earth.

  4. State the three assumptions of the RNA world hypothesis and give one piece of evidence for it.
    Show answer

    (i) RNA replication assured genetic continuity; (ii) base pairing is required for the replication; (iii) genetically encoded proteins were not needed as catalysts. Evidence: RNA molecules called ribozymes can act as catalysts. For example, the ribosome’s catalytic site that forms peptide bonds is made of RNA.

  5. Explain how the RNA world hypothesis could solve the problem that DNA needs proteins to be copied and proteins need DNA to be made.
    Show answer

    If RNA could store information in its base sequence and also catalyze reactions, including its own copying, neither DNA nor proteins would be needed at first. Later, proteins that were made from RNA instructions took over catalysis, and DNA took over the long-term storage of information.

  6. A student claims that the Miller-Urey experiment proved that life arose by chemical evolution. Evaluate the claim.
    Show answer

    The claim goes too far. The experiment showed that amino acids and other building blocks can form from simple gases with an energy source, which supports one step. It did not produce a cell, a self-replicating system, or genetic material. Also, the gas mixture used may not be an accurate model of the early atmosphere. It is evidence for one part of a model, not proof of the whole process.

Unit 7 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 7 quiz: Natural Selection

Fifteen multiple-choice items and five short free-response questions across all ten lessons (natural selection and its modes, artificial selection, drift and gene flow, Hardy–Weinberg, the evidence for evolution, continuing evolution and genetic diversity, phylogeny, speciation and extinction, and the origin of life), so click an option to see why each answer is right or wrong, then write each FRQ in ten minutes before you open the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Figure: bill width in a West African seedcracker finch population. Every fledgling in one cohort was measured and banded at the start of the dry season, and the survivors of that same cohort were re-measured six months later.

    Bill width (mm)12.013.014.015.016.0
    Fledglings (n = 200)2050605020
    Survivors (n = 100)2520102025

    Which statement best identifies the mode of selection acting on bill width and the evidence for it?

    The mean does not move at all: the fledgling mean is 2800/200 = 14.0 mm and the survivor mean is 1400/100 = 14.0 mm. Directional selection requires the whole distribution to slide toward one tail, and this one stayed centered while it spread.

    Stabilizing selection trims both tails and narrows the curve, which is the exact opposite of this result: the 14.0 mm class fell from 30% of the cohort to 10%, the worst survival of any class. Mortality highest in the middle is the signature of disruptive selection.

    Correct. The mean is unchanged but the spread grows: the 12.0 mm and 16.0 mm classes together go from 40/200 = 20% of the birds to 50/100 = 50%, while the intermediate class collapses. Name a mode from the mean and the spread together, and here only the spread changed.

    A constant mean is not evidence of no selection, because the mean is blind to changes in shape. Half the cohort died, and the survivors are not a random sample of it: the extremes were strongly favored, which is selection by definition.

  2. A male Pacific salmon returns to spawn at age 3, fertilizes about 900 eggs, and dies; 18 of his offspring survive to spawn themselves. A rival male of the same species delays returning until age 5, fertilizes about 2,400 eggs, and dies; 12 of his offspring survive to spawn. Which comparison of the two males' fitness is correct?

    Eggs fertilized is an intermediate step, not the currency. Most of those 2,400 zygotes never reach spawning age, and only the ones that do can pass the male's alleles into the next generation, which is why the count that matters is 12, not 2,400.

    Correct. Fitness is the number of offspring that survive to reproduce, relative to others in the population, so 18 beats 12 and nothing else in the stem changes that. The shorter lifespan is irrelevant except through its effect on that number.

    Survival raises fitness only insofar as it converts into offspring that themselves reproduce, and here the extra two years did not: the older male ended with six fewer reproducing offspring. Equating fitness with longevity, size, or strength is the most common error on this topic.

    "Both reproduced" is a yes-or-no statement, and fitness is a comparison of quantities. Selection works on the difference between 18 and 12, and over many generations a 50% edge in reproducing offspring per generation changes allele frequencies quickly.

  3. Description of: a replica-plating experiment on Escherichia coli, of the kind Joshua and Esther Lederberg performed in 1952.

    A master plate of antibiotic-free agar carries about 200 colonies in a scattered pattern. A sterile velvet pad is pressed onto the master plate and then onto each of three plates containing streptomycin, transferring the pattern intact. After incubation, all three streptomycin plates show colonies in the same three positions relative to a reference mark, and nowhere else. Cells are then scraped from those three positions on the master plate, which has never held any antibiotic, and grown in streptomycin broth. All three grow into fully resistant cultures.

    Which conclusion about the origin of streptomycin resistance is best supported by this result?

    If the drug induced the mutations, the surviving positions would differ from replica to replica, because induction would strike cells at random. Instead the same three positions grow every time, and the untreated master-plate cells from those positions are already resistant: so the drug selected variants, it did not create them.

    Correct. Resistance can be located on a plate that has never seen the antibiotic, which is only possible if the alleles arose by mutation beforehand. The antibiotic's role is to kill everything else, raising the frequency of a variant that was already there.

    The velvet transfers cells, not traits, and it touches every position equally, if it were spreading resistance, resistant growth would appear in far more than three positions and would not repeat in the same three each time.

    Conjugation does move resistance plasmids between bacteria, so this is a real mechanism, but it cannot explain this result: the master-plate cells that never touched streptomycin were already resistant before any incubation on the drug plates occurred.

  4. Over eighteen months, a hospital ward records carbapenem-resistant isolates of Klebsiella, Escherichia, and Enterobacter. Sequencing shows that all three genera carry the same resistance gene, with an identical sequence, on a plasmid of the same size. Which process best accounts for this pattern?

    Independent mutation is the source of new alleles, but it would not produce an identical sequence on an identically sized plasmid in three genera within eighteen months: convergence at that level of detail is vanishingly unlikely. Identical sequence in distant lineages points to a shared copy, not to three coincidences.

    Correct. Conjugation, transformation, and transduction move DNA between bacteria that are not parent and offspring, and a conjugative plasmid can cross genus boundaries in a single step. That is why resistance can appear in a new species faster than mutation and selection alone could deliver it.

    Bacteria are prokaryotes: they have no meiosis and no crossing over between homologous chromosomes in the eukaryotic sense. Recombination does reshuffle alleles in sexually reproducing eukaryotes, but it is not the route by which a gene enters a different species.

    An antibiotic cannot instruct a cell to build the protein that defeats it; drugs kill or fail to kill, and nothing more. Writing that the drug "made" the bacteria resistant reverses cause and effect, which costs the point every time it appears.

  5. A recessive metabolic disorder affects 1 in 2,500 newborns in a population that meets the Hardy–Weinberg conditions at this locus. Approximately what fraction of the population carries one copy of the allele without being affected?

    1 in 50 is \(q\) itself: \(q = \sqrt{1/2500} = 0.02\). But \(q\) is the frequency of allele copies in the gene pool, and carriers are individuals with one copy, whose frequency is \(2pq\): about twice as large. Stopping at \(q\) is the single most common slip on this calculation.

    Correct. \(q^2 = 1/2500 = 0.0004\), so \(q = 0.02\) and \(p = 0.98\), giving \(2pq = 2(0.98)(0.02) = 0.0392\), or about 1 in 25. Carriers outnumber affected individuals by \(0.0392/0.0004 = 98\) to 1, which is why a recessive allele persists so stubbornly.

    1 in 1,250 is half the affected frequency, which corresponds to no genotype in the model. Heterozygotes are the \(2pq\) term and are always far more common than the recessive homozygotes whenever \(q\) is small, never rarer.

    1 in 2,500 is \(q^2\), the frequency of the affected homozygote given in the stem. Carriers are unaffected by definition, so their frequency cannot equal the frequency of the disorder.

  6. Data: genotype counts at a shell-banding locus in 1,000 adult land snails collected from one hillside, shown with the counts expected under Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium calculated from the allele frequencies of this same sample.

    GenotypeBBBbbb
    Observed snails300200500
    Expected under equilibrium160480360

    A chi-square test on these counts gives \(\chi^2 = 340\) with 1 degree of freedom; the critical value at p = 0.05 is 3.841.

    Which explanation is most consistent with the direction of the departure from the expected counts?

    The expected counts were computed from this sample: \(p = [2(300) + 200]/2000 = 0.40\) and \(q = 0.60\), giving \(0.16(1000) = 160\), \(2(0.4)(0.6)(1000) = 480\), and \(0.36(1000) = 360\). The allele frequencies match by construction; it is the way those alleles are packaged into genotypes that does not.

    Correct. Both homozygote classes are far above expectation and the heterozygotes are less than half of it: the signature of assortative mating, inbreeding, or a sample pooled across patches that rarely interbreed. Nonrandom mating shifts genotype frequencies while leaving \(p\) and \(q\) untouched, exactly as the two rows show.

    Gene flow adds migrants carrying different allele frequencies, and mixing two differentiated groups and then letting them interbreed produces heterozygotes; on its own it does not create a two-thirds shortfall of them. The data show a heterozygote deficit, which points the other way.

    This sentence is true (drift is weak at \(N = 1000\), and it correctly rules one mechanism out), but ruling something out is not an explanation of the pattern. The question asks what produced the excess of homozygotes, and this option never says.

  7. Figure: allele frequency \(q\) at a neutral marker plotted against generation for 24 laboratory Drosophila populations, all founded at \(q = 0.50\) and followed for 20 generations with no selection on the marker.

    Twelve populations were held to 8 breeding adults each. Their traces fan out in both directions within five generations; by generation 20, seven have reached \(q = 0\), four have reached \(q = 1.00\), and the last sits at 0.31. The other twelve populations were held to 800 breeding adults each. Every one of those traces stays between 0.47 and 0.53 for all 20 generations, wandering with no consistent direction.

    Which statement is best supported by the figure?

    If the allele were deleterious in small populations, the small-population traces would move in one direction: down. They do not: four fixed the allele at \(q = 1.00\) while seven lost it entirely, and a selective disadvantage cannot push different populations opposite ways.

    Correct. This is genetic drift: sampling error in which gametes happen to make the next generation. Its magnitude scales as \(\sqrt{pq/2N}\), so the standard deviation of one generation's change is about \(\sqrt{0.25/16} = 0.125\) at \(N = 8\) but only \(\sqrt{0.25/1600} = 0.0125\) at \(N = 800\): a tenfold difference, and the traces show exactly that.

    The stem states there is no selection on the marker, and nothing in the figure measures resources. Attributing any allele-frequency change to selection by default is the habit this experiment was designed to break: chance alone moves frequencies, and in small populations it moves them a lot.

    The populations are separate cultures with no migration between them, so there is no gene flow to invoke. Gene flow would also make the populations more alike, whereas these diverged until most hit opposite ends of the scale.

  8. An island population of 750 beetles has \(q = 0.20\) for a wing-pattern allele. A storm carries 250 beetles from the mainland, where \(q = 0.80\), onto the island, and the newcomers breed freely with the residents. What is \(q\) in the combined population, and what mechanism has operated?

    Correct. Count allele copies rather than averaging frequencies: residents contribute \(2(750)(0.20) = 300\) copies and migrants \(2(250)(0.80) = 400\), out of \(2(1000) = 2000\) total, so \(q = 700/2000 = 0.35\). Migrants moving alleles between populations is the definition of gene flow.

    0.50 is the unweighted average of 0.20 and 0.80, which would be right only if the two groups were the same size. The residents outnumber the migrants three to one, so the combined frequency must sit much closer to the island's 0.20 than to the midpoint.

    0.60 weights the small migrant group far too heavily, and the mechanism is misnamed as well: drift is change from random sampling of who reproduces within a population, not from the arrival of individuals from outside it.

    Nonrandom mating really does change genotype frequencies without changing allele frequencies, that rule is worth knowing, but it is the wrong rule here. Immigrants physically add allele copies to the gene pool, so \(p\) and \(q\) must change.

  9. Data: amino-acid differences in a conserved 110-residue enzyme, each species compared with species A, alongside divergence times taken from the fossil record.

    Compared with species ABCDE
    Amino-acid differences6241836
    Fossil divergence time (Mya)25100not known150

    Using the three fossil-calibrated comparisons to set the rate, the best estimate of the time since species A and species D last shared a common ancestor is

    18 is the number of amino-acid differences, not a time. Differences only become a date once you divide by a rate, and the rate here is well under one difference per million years, so the age must be far larger than 18.

    Correct. All three calibration points give the same rate, \(6/25 = 0.24\), \(24/100 = 0.24\), and \(36/150 = 0.24\) differences per million years, so \(18/0.24 = 75\) million years. A clock this consistent across three independent nodes is about as good as molecular dating gets.

    92 is roughly the average of the three known divergence times (25, 100, and 150), which ignores species D's own data entirely. Averaging the calibration ages estimates nothing about D; the calibration is used to get a rate, and the rate is then applied to D's 18 differences.

    4.3 comes from multiplying by the rate, \(18 \times 0.24\), instead of dividing by it. Check the units: differences divided by (differences per million years) yields million years, which is the quantity the question asks for.

  10. The eye of an octopus and the eye of a vertebrate each have a cornea, a lens, an iris, and a retina. But in the octopus the photoreceptors face the incoming light, while in the vertebrate they face away from it, behind a layer of nerve fibers that exits through a hole in the retina and creates a blind spot. Which conclusion does this difference best support?

    Homologous structures share an underlying construction inherited from a common ancestor, and these two are built back to front relative to each other. The last common ancestor of molluscs and vertebrates had at most a light-sensitive patch, so the shared camera design was assembled twice.

    Correct. Similar function plus different underlying construction is the definition of analogy. Focusing light onto a sheet of receptors is a physics problem with a limited number of good solutions, so lineages that never shared a camera eye converged on one, and the inverted vertebrate retina is the developmental fingerprint that gives the separate origins away.

    Selection has no target and no scale of advancement; it sorts whatever variation exists in the environment that exists. The vertebrate retina's wiring is a historical constraint that works well enough, and "more highly evolved" is not a claim any data in the stem could support.

    A vestigial structure is a reduced remnant of a feature that was functional in an ancestor, such as a whale's internal pelvis. The vertebrate retina is fully functional; the blind spot is a byproduct of how the nerve fibers exit, not a leftover of anything.

  11. Data: five land plants scored for five characters (1 = present, 0 = absent), with two competing trees proposed for them.

    TaxonProtected embryoVascular tissueTrue rootsSeedsFlowers
    Green alga (out-group)00000
    Moss10000
    Fern11100
    Pine11110
    Sunflower11111

    Tree 1 is fully nested: the green alga branches off first, then the moss, then the fern, and the last node splits the pine from the sunflower. Tree 2 has the green alga branch off first, after which the remaining four taxa split into a moss + fern clade and a pine + sunflower clade.

    Under maximum parsimony, how many fewer character-state changes does Tree 1 require than Tree 2?

    They are not equally parsimonious, because the moss + fern grouping forces two characters to be explained twice. Run the count character by character before deciding: a tie is possible in principle, but here the totals differ.

    One character is not enough. Both vascular tissue and true roots have the same distribution (fern, pine, sunflower), so Tree 2 pays an extra change for each of them, not just for one.

    Correct. On Tree 1 every character arises exactly once on the branch below all the taxa that have it, for a total of 5 changes. On Tree 2, vascular tissue and true roots must each evolve twice, once in the fern and once in the pine + sunflower ancestor, or evolve once and be lost in the moss, so the total is 7. Tree 1 wins by \(7 - 5 = 2\) steps.

    5 is the total number of changes Tree 1 requires, not the difference between the trees. The comparison the question asks for is 7 minus 5, which is how you state a parsimony result: this tree explains the same data with two fewer assumed events.

  12. A published cladogram of eukaryotes places yeast at the far left-hand tip and humans at the far right-hand tip. A student concludes that humans are the most advanced taxon on the tree and that yeast is a human ancestor. Which statement identifies the errors in that reading?

    Correct. Tip order carries no information, since rotating a branch around its node produces a different-looking drawing of the same hypothesis. And every tip is a terminal lineage: yeast and humans are cousins descended from the node between them, so the ancestor is that node, which is not any living species.

    Reversing the direction of the same mistake does not fix it. Neither end of a cladogram is privileged, and no rotation of the branches makes any tip more "advanced" than another: all the tips are equally far in time from the root.

    Living species belong at tips, which is exactly where yeast is drawn. Nodes represent inferred common ancestors, and placing an extant species at one would assert something the data cannot show.

    Branch length means something only in a phylogram, where it represents amount of change, or a chronogram, where it represents time, and only when an axis or scale bar says so. In a plain cladogram branch lengths are drawn for legibility and carry no information at all.

  13. Two species of Ambystoma salamander breed in the same ponds during the same two weeks of March. Males of each species release a distinct chemical courtship signal, and females approach only the signal of their own species. When researchers fertilize eggs of one species with sperm of the other in the laboratory, the eggs develop into healthy, fully fertile hybrids. Which barrier maintains the separation in nature, and how is it classified?

    Gametic isolation means sperm and egg are chemically incompatible, and the laboratory cross rules it out: mixed gametes fuse and develop normally. The signal that fails is between adults, not between cells.

    Correct. Courtship signals that do not match keep females from ever approaching heterospecific males, so mating does not occur and no zygote is formed, which is what makes the barrier prezygotic. Prezygotic barriers are the cheaper kind, because nothing is invested in a hybrid that will not pay off.

    Postzygotic barriers act after fertilization, and the stem explicitly closes that door: the hybrids are healthy and fertile. If the hybrids thrive, the isolation in nature must be happening before the gametes ever meet.

    Temporal isolation means breeding at different times, and the stem specifies the same two weeks in the same ponds. The question lists that detail precisely so you can eliminate both temporal and habitat isolation: identify a barrier by what the data exclude as much as by what they show.

  14. Data: documented bird extinctions since 1500 CE, set beside the background extinction rate estimated from the fossil record.

    QuantityValue
    Bird species described10,425
    Interval considered500 years
    Documented extinctions in that interval161
    Background rate from the fossil record1 extinction per million species-years

    Which calculation and conclusion correctly use these data?

    Correct. The background rate is per million species-years, so you must multiply species by years first: \(10{,}425 \times 500 = 5{,}212{,}500\) species-years, or 5.21 million, which predicts 5.21 extinctions. Then \(161/5.21 = 30.9\), about 31 times background: a computed ratio with the assumption stated is what earns the point.

    A percentage of species lost has no time in it, and a rate must. The same 1.5% spread over 500,000 years instead of 500 would be unremarkable; it is the interval that makes this figure alarming, and dropping it throws the comparison away.

    0.32 extinctions per year is a legitimate description of the observed data, but it is not the background rate: it is the very quantity that needs to be compared with the background. The option relabels the observation as the expectation, which makes any excess vanish by definition.

    Dividing species by extinctions produces a number with the wrong units entirely and happens to land near the right order of magnitude by coincidence. Always check that the arithmetic matches the units of the rate you were given: extinctions per million species-years.

  15. A volcanic ash layer lying directly beneath a bed of microbial fossils contains potassium-40 at 12.5% of its original abundance. The half-life of potassium-40 is 1.25 billion years. What is the best estimate of the age of the ash, and what does the result establish about the fossils?

    0.16 billion years is \(0.125 \times 1.25\), which multiplies the half-life by the fraction remaining. Decay is exponential, not proportional: the fraction tells you how many half-lives have elapsed, and you multiply that count by the half-life.

    Correct. \(0.125 = (1/2)^3\), so three half-lives have passed and \(t = 3(1.25) = 3.75\) billion years. Ash beneath a fossil bed was deposited before the fossils were, so it sets a maximum age: the fossils are younger than 3.75 billion years, and dating ash above them would set the minimum.

    The age is right but the inference is not. The fossil bed sits on top of the ash, which means it formed afterward by an unknown interval; only bracketing the bed with dated layers above and below pins the fossils down, which is how the fossil record is actually calibrated.

    Three half-lives is correct, but the half-life used is carbon-14's 5,730 years rather than potassium-40's 1.25 billion. Match the isotope to the material and the timescale: carbon-14 works only on once-living material younger than roughly 50,000 years, and volcanic ash was never alive.

Free response

  1. Data: a student's investigation of streptomycin resistance in Escherichia coli. On day 0, \(1.0 \times 10^{8}\) cells from a culture that had never been exposed to an antibiotic were spread on each of ten agar plates containing streptomycin and on each of ten plates of plain agar. The plain plates grew a confluent lawn; the streptomycin plates averaged 40 colonies each. Survivors were then carried through 20 daily transfers in streptomycin broth, and each day's population was sampled to measure the percentage able to grow on streptomycin.

    Daily transfers05101520
    Population able to grow on streptomycin (%)0.000040.5125894

    Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the independent variable in the day-0 plating, and describe the purpose of the ten plates of plain agar.
    2. Explain how the percentage of the population able to grow on streptomycin rose from 0.00004% to 94% over 20 transfers, in terms of what happens to the cells in this culture.
    3. Construct a graph of the data. Put the number of daily transfers on the x-axis with a scale running from 0 to 20, put the percentage of the population able to grow on streptomycin on the y-axis with a scale running from 0 to 100, label both axes including units, plot the five points, and draw the curve through them.
    4. Justify, using the day-0 plate counts as evidence, the claim that alleles conferring streptomycin resistance were present in the culture before streptomycin was ever applied.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: presence or absence of streptomycin in the agar as the independent variable, plus a description of the plain plates as the control that shows the cells were viable and plated at the stated density, so that low colony counts on the drug plates can be attributed to the drug rather than to a bad culture or a plating error. Do not accept: naming the variable with no description of the control's purpose; identifying "the bacteria" or "colony number" as the independent variable (colony number is the dependent variable); "the plain plates are the control" with nothing further.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation that runs cause to effect in this culture; rare cells already carrying a resistance allele survive each transfer while susceptible cells die, the survivors divide and pass the allele to their descendants, so the allele's frequency in the population climbs with each transfer; heritable variation plus differential reproduction equals a change in allele frequency. Do not accept: any statement that streptomycin caused, induced, or triggered the mutations; "the bacteria adapted" or "the bacteria became resistant" with no mechanism; an explanation that describes selection in general without ever applying it to this E. coli population.
    • (c) Accept: transfers on the x-axis and percent resistant on the y-axis, both axes labeled with units, a linear scale that spans 0–20 and 0–100 respectively, all five points plotted correctly, and a curve that is nearly flat through transfer 5, rises steeply between 10 and 15, and bends toward the top by 20. Award the point only if the axes are correctly assigned and labeled. Do not accept: the variables on reversed axes; unlabeled axes or missing units; a scale that does not accommodate all five points; a straight line drawn from (0, 0.00004) to (20, 94).
    • (d) Accept: a claim supported by the named evidence; 40 colonies grew on the very first streptomycin plates from a culture with no prior exposure, so about \(40/(1.0\times10^{8}) = 4 \times 10^{-7}\) of the cells were already resistant; the drug could only select among cells that already existed on the plate, so the alleles pre-dated the exposure. A reference to the Lederbergs' replica-plating result as corroboration may be included but cannot substitute for the data. Do not accept: restating the claim ("they were already resistant because resistance was already there"); citing the 94% value at transfer 20, which is after exposure and cannot establish what preceded it; a justification with no number from the day-0 plates.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The independent variable is whether the agar contains streptomycin. The plain plates are the control: they show the cells were alive and plated at the density I claimed, so when only 40 colonies grow on the drug plates I can blame the streptomycin rather than a dead culture.

    b A few cells in the starting culture already carried a resistance allele from an earlier mutation. Each transfer into streptomycin broth killed the susceptible cells, and only those rare resistant cells divided and passed the allele on. Because resistance is heritable and only resistant cells reproduced, its frequency climbed each day until nearly every cell had it.

    c I put daily transfers on the x-axis from 0 to 20, marked every 5, and percent of the population able to grow on streptomycin on the y-axis from 0 to 100, marked every 10. I plotted (0, 0.00004), (5, 0.5), (10, 12), (15, 58) and (20, 94) and drew an S-shaped curve: flat to transfer 5, steepest from 10 to 15, bending toward 100 by 20.

    d On day 0, 40 colonies grew from \(1.0 \times 10^{8}\) cells that had never met an antibiotic, so about \(4 \times 10^{-7}\) of the population was already resistant. Streptomycin cannot make a colony appear; it can only fail to kill one, so those alleles were there first.

  2. Scenario: two populations of a stream salamander in the southern Appalachians.

    About 12,000 years ago a ridge uplift split one salamander species into an eastern and a western drainage, with no water connecting them. A canal dug in 1954 rejoined the drainages, and the two forms now meet along a 3 km contact zone. Genetic markers identify 8% of adults in the contact zone as hybrids. Clutches from within-population pairs hatch at 87%; clutches from hybrid pairs hatch at 21%, and the hybrids that do reach adulthood produce almost no viable sperm. Males of the two forms release different chemical courtship signals, and in the contact zone females approach a male of their own form in 9 of every 10 trials.

    Using the scenario, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the mode of speciation that produced the two salamander populations, and describe the evidence in the scenario that supports that identification.
    2. Explain how the difference in hatching success between within-population pairs and hybrid pairs affects the strength of selection on female response to the courtship signal in the contact zone.
    3. Predict how the percentage of adults in the contact zone that are hybrids will change over the next several hundred generations, and state the direction of that change.
    4. Justify your prediction in (c) using specific evidence from the scenario.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: allopatric speciation, described with the evidence, a physical barrier (the ridge uplift) separated the populations for about 12,000 years with no gene flow between drainages, and the reproductive barriers observed today accumulated during that separation. Do not accept: "sympatric speciation" (the divergence happened while the populations were physically separated, and the canal only reunited them); naming allopatric speciation with no reference to the uplift, the barrier, or the interruption of gene flow; a definition of speciation in general.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation linking the fitness cost of hybridizing to selection on mate choice in these salamanders, a female that responds to the wrong signal produces a clutch that hatches at 21% instead of 87% and whose sons are effectively sterile, so she leaves far fewer reproducing offspring; alleles for responding only to the home signal are therefore favored, and selection on discrimination is strong. Do not accept: "hybrids are less fit, so the species stay separate" with no link to female response or to allele frequencies; a statement that hybrids die without saying what that does to selection on the females; a correct general account of reinforcement that never uses the salamander numbers or the signal.
    • (c) Accept: a specific directional claim that the hybrid percentage decreases, falls below 8%, or approaches zero over that span. A numerical estimate is not required. Do not accept: "it will change"; "the two forms will become one species"; a prediction that hybrids increase; a restatement of the 8% figure with no direction.
    • (d) Accept: a justification naming evidence and saying why it supports the claim, the hybrid hatching rate of 21% against 87%, and the sterility of hybrid males, mean hybrid matings contribute very few reproducing offspring, so alleles for accurate signal discrimination rise in frequency each generation; the 9-in-10 discrimination already observed is evidence that the process is under way (reinforcement). Do not accept: a claim with no cited number or observation; "hybrids are unfit" restated as the reason without connecting it to the change in female behavior; evidence listed without an explanation of why it supports the prediction.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a This is allopatric speciation. The ridge uplift physically separated one species into two drainages 12,000 years ago and stopped gene flow between them, and the courtship-signal difference and the hybrid problems both built up during that separation.

    b A female that answers the wrong male's signal pays a large cost: her clutch hatches at 21% instead of 87%, and the few hybrid sons she raises make almost no viable sperm, so she gets very few grandchildren. A female that answers only her own form's signal gets the 87% clutch and fertile sons. Alleles for a picky response to the home signal therefore spread, so selection on discrimination in the contact zone is strong.

    c I predict the hybrid share of adults in the contact zone drops: below 8%, and eventually close to zero.

    d Hybrid clutches hatch at 21% against 87%, and hybrid males are effectively sterile, so almost none of the hybrids formed each generation reproduce. Meanwhile females already choose their own form 9 times in 10, which shows discrimination alleles are common and still being favored, so mismatched pairings should get rarer every generation.

  3. Figure: a cladogram of five tetrapods, with the characters that define each node listed beside it.

    The salamander branches off first. The next node leads to the turtle on one side and, on the other, to a clade containing the lizard, the crocodile, and the pigeon. Within that clade the lizard branches next, and the final node splits the crocodile from the pigeon. The characters are placed as follows: four limbs is present in all five taxa; the amniotic egg marks the node leading to turtle, lizard, crocodile, and pigeon; two openings behind the eye socket marks the node leading to lizard, crocodile, and pigeon; a muscular gizzard marks the node leading to crocodile and pigeon; feathers appear on the pigeon's branch alone.

    Using the cladogram, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the shared derived character that defines the clade containing only the crocodile and the pigeon, and describe what the node at the base of that clade represents.
    2. Explain why the presence of four limbs in all five taxa provides no support for any grouping within this cladogram.
    3. A newly described fossil tetrapod has an amniotic egg and two openings behind the eye socket, but no gizzard and no feathers. Represent its position: identify the part of the cladogram where its branch should attach, and describe how you would draw it.
    4. Justify your placement in (c) using the character data, and state what additional evidence would be needed to resolve its position further.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the muscular gizzard as the shared derived character (synapomorphy), plus a description of the node as the most recent common ancestor of the crocodile and the pigeon: an inferred ancestral population in which the gizzard arose, not a living species. Do not accept: naming feathers (which mark only the pigeon's own branch) or the amniotic egg (which defines a larger clade); naming the gizzard with no description of the node; describing the node as "where the crocodile turned into the pigeon" or as one of the two living taxa.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation that four limbs is an ancestral (shared primitive) character for this set of taxa; it is present in the salamander, which is the out-group, so it arose before any of the splits shown and is simply inherited by everything descended from that ancestor; a character shared by all taxa cannot distinguish subgroups within them. Only shared derived characters define clades. Do not accept: "it is not important"; "limbs evolved more than once"; a statement that the character is ancestral with no reference to the out-group or to why that prevents it from grouping taxa.
    • (c) Accept: the fossil attaches inside the clade defined by the two skull openings but outside the clade defined by the gizzard (that is, its branch comes off the tree after the skull-opening node and before the crocodile + pigeon node) drawn either as a sister branch to the crocodile + pigeon clade or as a sister branch to the lizard, since the characters given cannot distinguish those two positions. Do not accept: placing it outside the amniotic-egg node; placing it inside the crocodile + pigeon clade; placing it on the pigeon's branch; an answer that names a position but never describes how the branch is drawn.
    • (d) Accept: a justification that names the characters and says what each rules in or out, the amniotic egg puts it inside the amniote clade, the two skull openings put it inside the next clade down, and the absence of a gizzard means there is no evidence placing it inside the crocodile + pigeon clade; further resolution requires additional characters shared with one lineage and not the other (more skeletal characters, or DNA from a close relative if it were recoverable). Do not accept: a placement with no characters cited; citing the characters without saying how they support the branch point; claiming the position is certain when the data leave two possibilities.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The muscular gizzard is the shared derived character for the crocodile + pigeon clade. The node at its base stands for the most recent common ancestor those two share: an ancestral population in which the gizzard first appeared, not a living animal.

    b Four limbs is ancestral here. I know because the salamander, the out-group, already has it, so the character arose before any split shown. Something every taxon inherited from the same earlier ancestor cannot separate one subgroup from another. Only characters that arose within the tree, like the gizzard, mark clades.

    c I would attach the fossil's branch after the node marked by the two skull openings but before the node marked by the gizzard: a short branch off that stretch of the tree, drawn as sister either to the crocodile + pigeon clade or to the lizard.

    d The amniotic egg puts it inside the amniote clade and the two skull openings put it inside the lizard–crocodile–pigeon clade, while having no gizzard gives me no reason to nest it with the crocodile and pigeon, so it sits below that node. To choose between the two possible positions I would need more characters that the fossil shares with only one of those lineages.

  4. Data: mean hindlimb index (hindlimb length divided by body length) and mean perch diameter for Anolis lizards on six small islands. In year 0 a ground-hunting predatory lizard was introduced onto three of the islands; three comparable islands received no predator. Values are the means of the three islands in each group.

    Island groupHindlimb index, year 0Hindlimb index, year 6Perch diameter, year 0 (cm)Perch diameter, year 6 (cm)
    Predator introduced0.4800.4415.82.1
    No predator0.4780.4755.95.6

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the control in this investigation, and describe the change in mean hindlimb index on the predator islands between year 0 and year 6.
    2. Explain the relationship between the change in perch diameter and the change in hindlimb index in these lizards.
    3. Calculate the percent change in mean hindlimb index for the predator islands and for the predator-free islands, showing your setup for each.
    4. Justify the claim that the change on the predator islands resulted from natural selection rather than from some pre-existing difference between the two groups of islands, using evidence from the data.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: the three islands with no predator introduced as the control, plus a description of the change: mean hindlimb index fell from 0.480 to 0.441, a decrease of 0.039, so the lizards' hindlimbs became shorter relative to body length. Do not accept: "the lizards" or "year 0" as the control; a description that says only "it changed" or "it went down" with no values; reporting the perch data in place of the hindlimb data.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation connecting the two trends causally in these lizards, the ground predator makes the ground and wide low perches dangerous, so lizards that spend time on narrow high twigs survive better; long hindlimbs give speed on broad surfaces but poor balance and maneuvering on narrow ones, so on narrow perches shorter-limbed individuals survive and reproduce better and the mean index falls. Do not accept: "the perches got smaller so the legs got smaller"; any statement that individual lizards' legs shortened during their lives; a general statement that predators cause evolution, with no link between perch diameter and limb length.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: predator islands \((0.441 - 0.480)/0.480 \times 100 = -8.1\%\) (a decrease of about 8.1%), and predator-free islands \((0.475 - 0.478)/0.478 \times 100 = -0.6\%\) (a decrease of about 0.6%). Sign or the word "decrease" is required; answers rounded to 8% and 0.6% are acceptable. Do not accept: the raw differences 0.039 and 0.003 with no percentage; a percentage with no setup shown; dividing by the year-6 value.
    • (d) Accept: a claim supported by named evidence, the two island groups started at effectively the same hindlimb index (0.480 and 0.478) and the same perch diameter (5.8 and 5.9 cm), so they were not different to begin with; only the islands that received the predator changed appreciably (−8.1% against −0.6%), and the predator is the one factor that differed, so the change tracks the treatment. Do not accept: a justification that never mentions the control islands; "the data show natural selection" with no comparison; citing the year-6 values alone without the year-0 baseline that establishes the islands were alike.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The control is the three islands that got no predator. On the predator islands the mean hindlimb index fell from 0.480 in year 0 to 0.441 in year 6, a drop of 0.039, so those lizards ended up with shorter hindlimbs relative to body length.

    b The introduced predator hunts on the ground, so wide low perches became dangerous and the lizards shifted to narrow twigs: perch diameter fell from 5.8 cm to 2.1 cm. Long hindlimbs are good for sprinting on broad surfaces but clumsy on a thin twig, so the shorter-limbed lizards kept their footing, survived, and reproduced. Their alleles became more common, which is why the mean index dropped.

    c Predator islands: \((0.441 - 0.480)/0.480 = -0.039/0.480 = -0.081\), an 8.1% decrease. Predator-free islands: \((0.475 - 0.478)/0.478 = -0.003/0.478 = -0.006\), a 0.6% decrease.

    d The two groups started the same, 0.480 against 0.478 for hindlimb index and 5.8 cm against 5.9 cm for perch diameter, so the islands were not different beforehand. After six years the predator islands had changed by 8.1% and the controls by only 0.6%, and the predator is the only thing that differed, so the shift came from selection rather than from the islands themselves.

  5. Data: genotype counts for a coat-color gene in a rodent population living on a lava field, sampled in year 1 and again in year 20. Between the samples the surrounding vegetation was cleared, leaving more bare dark rock exposed. Allele D gives dark fur and is dominant to d, which gives pale fur. Each sample contains 1,000 adults.

    SampleDDDddd
    Year 1360480160
    Year 2049042090

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Using the year-1 counts, identify the frequency of the d allele, and describe how you obtained it from the genotype counts.
    2. Explain how both samples can match Hardy–Weinberg expectations and yet show that this population is evolving.
    3. Calculate the number of heterozygotes expected in year 20 if the population were in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium at the year-20 allele frequencies, showing your setup, and compare that value with the observed number.
    4. Justify a claim about which Hardy–Weinberg condition is most likely to have been violated between year 1 and year 20, using evidence from the data and the scenario.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: \(q = 0.40\), described as obtained by counting allele copies: \(q = [2(160) + 480]/2000 = 800/2000 = 0.40\), or equivalently from \(q = \sqrt{160/1000} = \sqrt{0.16} = 0.40\). The description of the method is required. Do not accept: 0.16 (that is \(q^2\), the frequency of the recessive phenotype); 0.60 (that is \(p\)); the correct value with no statement of how it was obtained.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation distinguishing the two things Hardy–Weinberg describes, the equation predicts how alleles are packaged into genotypes within a single generation, so a sample can fit it at whatever allele frequencies happen to exist at that moment; evolution is a change in allele frequencies across generations, and here \(q\) fell from 0.40 to 0.30 between the samples, so the population evolved even though each snapshot fits. Do not accept: "the population is in equilibrium, so it is not evolving"; a restatement of the five conditions with no reference to the change in \(q\); an answer that treats a good fit in one generation as proof that nothing changed.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \(p = [2(490) + 420]/2000 = 0.70\), \(q = 0.30\), so expected heterozygotes \(= 2pq(1000) = 2(0.70)(0.30)(1000) = 420\), which equals the observed 420: the genotype counts fit equilibrium exactly at the new allele frequencies. Do not accept: 480 (the year-1 value, carried over); a value with no setup; a comparison that reports the numbers but never states that they match.
    • (d) Accept: natural selection as the best-supported violated condition, justified with evidence; \(q\) fell from 0.40 to 0.30 in a directional way while the vegetation was cleared and more dark rock was exposed, which favors dark fur as camouflage; the sample is large (\(N = 1000\)), so drift is an unlikely explanation for a change of that size, and nothing in the scenario indicates migration or nonrandom mating. Do not accept: naming a condition with no evidence cited; "the population is not in equilibrium" (each sample fits the equation); claiming drift without addressing the population size; listing several conditions without arguing for one.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a In year 1, \(q = 0.40\). I counted allele copies rather than individuals: the 160 dd mice carry two d each and the 480 Dd mice carry one, so \(q = [2(160) + 480]/2000 = 800/2000 = 0.40\).

    b Hardy–Weinberg only predicts how the alleles present right now get combined into genotypes in one round of random mating, so a sample can fit it at any allele frequency. Evolution is a change in those frequencies over time, and \(q\) went from 0.40 in year 1 to 0.30 in year 20: the gene pool changed even though each snapshot matches the prediction.

    c Year 20: \(p = [2(490) + 420]/2000 = 1400/2000 = 0.70\), so \(q = 0.30\). Expected heterozygotes \(= 2pq \times 1000 = 2(0.70)(0.30)(1000) = 420\), which equals the observed 420, so the counts fit equilibrium exactly at the new frequencies.

    d Natural selection. \(q\) dropped from 0.40 to 0.30 over 20 years just as the vegetation was cleared and more dark rock was exposed, which makes dark fur better camouflage. With 1,000 adults sampled, drift is far too weak to move an allele that much, and nothing in the scenario mentions migrants or mate choice by color.

Lesson 8.1 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.1

Responses to the environment: behavior, signals, and fitness

A pill bug that is put in a dry, bright dish will walk until it reaches a damp, dark corner and then stop. A pine tree drops its growth in autumn as nights get longer, a bee that has found a flower patch returns to the hive and tells other bees where it is, and a gazelle that sees a cheetah makes a high-leaping display before it runs. Each of these is a response: a change in behavior or physiology that follows a change in the environment inside or outside the organism. Unit 8 is about the ways in which organisms and their environments interact, and it begins with the individual: how organisms detect conditions, exchange information with each other, and how these responses affect the number of offspring that they leave.

Learning objective · 8.1.A

Explain how the behavioral and physiological response of an organism is related to changes in internal or external environment.

Required content · EK 8.1.A.1 and 8.1.A.2

Organisms respond to changes in their environment through behavioral and physiological mechanisms.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of specific behavioral or physiological mechanisms is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Organisms exchange information with one another in response to internal changes and external cues, which can change behavior.

Behavioral and physiological responses

A stimulus is a change in the internal or external environment that an organism can detect, and a response is the reaction to it. Responses fall into two broad kinds, and they work together.

  • Behavioral responses are actions of the whole organism: moving toward or away from something, feeding, fleeing, resting, mating, or building. Examples from the CED: taxis (movement toward or away from a stimulus, such as a moth flying to light, or bacteria swimming toward sugar), kinesis (a change in the rate of movement or turning that depends on the intensity of the stimulus, not on its direction: pill bugs move faster in dry air and slow down in a damp place), and nocturnal or diurnal activity, in which an animal is active at night or by day.
  • Physiological responses are changes in the body’s internal functions: shivering and sweating to regulate temperature, release of epinephrine in the fight-or-flight response, hibernation, or the closing of stomata in dry air (lesson 4.4 on feedback and homeostasis).
  • Plants respond too. Phototropism is growth toward light, gravitropism is growth in response to gravity (roots down, shoots up), and photoperiodism is a response to the length of day and night: many plants flower only when the night is longer than a critical length (short-day plants) or shorter than it (long-day plants), which is how a plant uses the season as a cue. Plants that are chewed by herbivores release chemicals that cause nearby plants to make defense compounds, and that attract predators of the herbivore.

Responses are controlled by signal transduction (lesson 4.2) in cells, by hormones and by nerves, but the AP exam does not ask for the details of any specific mechanism. What you must be able to do is to say what the stimulus is, what the response is, and how the response helps the organism to survive or reproduce.

Many behaviors are innate: they are inherited, appear in the same way in every individual of a species without experience, and are therefore products of natural selection (a newborn mammal suckling, a spider building its web). Others are learned: they depend on experience, which gives flexibility when the environment changes. Learning includes habituation (ceasing to respond to a harmless repeated stimulus), imprinting (a young goose follows the first moving object it sees after hatching), and association (a bird avoids a brightly colored caterpillar after tasting a bad one). Even learned behavior has a genetic basis, in the capacity to learn.

Many responses are rhythmic. A circadian rhythm is a cycle of about 24 hours in activity, hormone levels, and body temperature that continues in constant darkness, which shows that it is generated inside the organism, and which light resets each day. Seasonal responses, such as migration, hibernation, and breeding, usually follow day length (photoperiod), which is a reliable signal because it is the same every year, unlike temperature.

0204060806345Dark half2745Lit halfNumber of isopodsobservedexpected if lighthas no effectχ² = 14.4critical value 3.841(df = 1, p = 0.05)
Figure 8.1a A choice-chamber experiment. Observed counts differ from the 45:45 expected if light has no effect, and the chi-square value is much larger than the critical value, so the null hypothesis is rejected.

Testing a response: experimental design and chi-square

The AP exam asks you to identify the procedure that fits a question: which variable is independent (changed by the investigator), which is dependent (measured), and which controls are needed and why. A classic lab for this topic is the choice chamber. Animals are placed in a chamber with two halves that differ in one factor, and the investigator counts how many are in each half after a fixed time.

Worked example · A choice chamber and chi-square

A student asks whether terrestrial isopods (pill bugs) prefer dark or light. Ninety isopods are placed at the center of a chamber with one half dark and one half lit, with the same temperature and humidity in both halves. After 10 minutes, 63 are in the dark half and 27 in the lit half. (a) Identify the variables and controls. (b) State the null hypothesis. (c) Calculate \(\chi^2\) and draw a conclusion with a critical value of 3.841.

(a) Variables. Independent variable: the light level (dark or lit). Dependent variable: the number of isopods in each half. Controls: the temperature and humidity are identical in both halves (so that only light differs), the isopods start at the center, all are of the same species and treated in the same way, and the same observation time is used. A further control is a chamber with both halves dark: it should give about 45:45, which shows that the chamber itself has no bias (for example, from a position effect).
(b) Null hypothesis. Light has no effect on where the isopods go, so the isopods are equally likely to be in either half: expected 45 and 45.
(c) Calculation. \(\chi^2 = \sum \dfrac{(o-e)^2}{e} = \dfrac{(63-45)^2}{45} + \dfrac{(27-45)^2}{45} = 7.2 + 7.2 = 14.4\). With 2 categories, \(df = 2 - 1 = 1\), and the critical value for \(p = 0.05\) is 3.841. Since \(14.4 \gt 3.841\), reject the null hypothesis.
Conclusion. The difference between the observed and expected counts is too large to be explained by chance, so the data support the hypothesis that isopods prefer the dark half (\(p \lt 0.05\)). This does not prove why: the response (a negative phototaxis, or a kinesis that makes them stop in the dark) is more likely a way to find damp, protected places, which would help survival.

The correct wording is important: you reject or fail to reject the null hypothesis, and you do not “accept” it or “prove” the hypothesis. When you propose a change to an experiment, look for a confounding variable (for example, if the light halves were also warmer, the isopods could be responding to heat).

Communication and fitness

Learning objective · 8.1.B

Explain how the behavioral responses of organisms affect their overall fitness and may contribute to the success of a population.

Required content · EK 8.1.B.1

Organisms communicate through various mechanisms (visual, audible, tactile, electrical, and/or chemical signals).

  1. Organisms have a variety of signaling behaviors that produce changes in the behavior of other organisms and can result in differential reproductive success.
  2. Animals use signals to indicate dominance, find food, establish territory, and ensure reproductive success.

Exclusion statement: knowledge of specific mechanisms of communication is beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Bees outside the hivesunfoodhive60°Dance on the vertical combup = toward the sunwaggle run60° right of upangle from vertical = angle from the sun
Figure 8.1b The waggle dance of honeybees (von Frisch). The angle of the waggle run from vertical tells nest mates the angle of the food from the direction of the sun, and the duration of the run tells the distance: a learned and communicated behavior that raises the fitness of the colony.

A signal is a behavior or structure that changes the behavior of another individual. Signals can be visual (the color of a flower, a peacock’s tail, the display of a gazelle), audible (bird song, the call of a frog, an alarm call), tactile (grooming, the contact between a mother and a young), electrical (the pulses of some fish) or chemical (pheromones, which are chemicals that act on members of the same species, such as the scent that marks a territory or the trail that ants follow to food). They are used to indicate dominance, to find food, to establish a territory, and to ensure reproductive success: courtship signals allow females to find males of their own species, and a bright flower signals a pollinator that nectar is present.

The honeybee waggle dance is a well-studied example. A forager that has found a good source of nectar returns to the dark hive and dances on the vertical comb. The angle between the waggle run and the vertical shows the angle of the food source from the direction of the sun, and the length of the run shows the distance. Karl von Frisch received a Nobel Prize in 1973 for showing this. The colony gains because more foragers go to the best sites, so the signal increases the fitness of the colony, and the bee that gives the information does not gain individually (since the workers are sisters, the benefit goes to the genes that they share).

Required content · EK 8.1.B.2

Responses to information and communication of information are vital to natural selection and evolution.

  1. Fitness favors innate and learned behaviors that increase survival and reproductive success.
  2. Cooperative behavior tends to increase the fitness of the individual and the survival of the population.

Exclusion statement: the details of the various communication and community behavioral systems are beyond the scope of the AP Exam.

Behavior is a phenotype, and natural selection acts on it as it does on any other trait (lesson 7.1). If a behavior has a genetic component and increases the number of offspring that survive, the alleles for it become more common. Examples of behaviors that raise fitness are the care of offspring by parents, courtship and mating behavior, the foraging of bees and of other animals, and the avoidance of predators.

Cooperative behavior includes pack hunting in wolves, herds, flocks, and schools (where each individual is less likely to be the one that is caught and there are more eyes to detect a predator), predator warnings, and the colonies of bees, ants, and termites. At first sight, a behavior that helps another individual at a cost to the actor, such as an alarm call that draws a predator’s attention, should not be favored. Kin selection explains it: a helper that helps relatives indirectly passes on copies of its own alleles, since relatives share them. Full siblings share on average half of their alleles (\(r = 0.5\)).

Worked example · Cooperation and kin

A young jay stays at the nest and helps its parents to raise 3 extra siblings (full siblings, \(r = 0.5\)), which costs it one offspring of its own (\(r = 0.5\) as well). Compare the number of copies of its alleles that it passes on by each strategy, and say whether helping can be favored.

Own offspring. One offspring carries on average 0.5 of the jay’s alleles: \(1 \times 0.5 = 0.5\) genome equivalents.
Helping. Three siblings carry \(3 \times 0.5 = 1.5\) genome equivalents of the jay’s alleles.
Comparison. \(1.5 \gt 0.5\), so helping passes on more copies. Hamilton’s rule states this as \(rB \gt C\): the benefit to the relative (B, here 3 individuals) multiplied by the relatedness is greater than the cost to the helper (C, here 1 offspring), as \(0.5 \times 3 = 1.5 \gt 1\).
Reasoning. The behavior is favored by natural selection not because it is “for the good of the group” but because it increases the frequency of the shared alleles. The same reasoning helps to explain alarm calls and colony behavior in insects.

Exam focus
  • Response = reaction to a stimulus; behavioral (movement, signals, migration) and physiological (hormones, temperature control). Specific mechanisms are not tested; the stimulus, the response, and the benefit are.
  • Plants respond too: phototropism, gravitropism, photoperiodism; chemical signals after herbivory.
  • Experimental design: name the independent and dependent variables, the control (and why it is needed), and the null hypothesis. Use \(\chi^2\) with \(df = \) categories \(- 1\) and say “reject” or “fail to reject”.
  • Signals: visual, audible, tactile, electrical, chemical. They indicate dominance, food, territory, and mates, and raise reproductive success.
  • Behavior evolves: fitness favors innate and learned behaviors that raise survival and reproduction. Cooperation raises the fitness of the individual and of the population; kin selection explains helping relatives.
Practice
  1. Classify each as a behavioral or a physiological response: (a) a lizard moves into the sun; (b) a person’s heart rate increases during a fright; (c) a bird migrates south in autumn; (d) a plant closes its stomata in dry air.
    Show answer

    (a) Behavioral (a movement that regulates body temperature). (b) Physiological (a change in an internal function through epinephrine and nerves). (c) Behavioral (it is triggered by day length, a physiological cue, but the response is a movement of the whole animal). (d) Physiological (the guard cells change in turgor).

  2. In a choice chamber with moist and dry halves, 20 of 40 isopods are in each half. Calculate \(\chi^2\) and state the conclusion.
    Show answer

    Expected 20 and 20, so \(\chi^2 = 0 + 0 = 0\), less than 3.841. Fail to reject the null hypothesis: the data do not show any preference for moisture in this experiment.

  3. For the isopod experiment, explain the purpose of a control chamber in which both halves are dark.
    Show answer

    It shows whether the chamber design or some other factor (such as a temperature gradient or the position of the release) causes the isopods to prefer one side. If the isopods split evenly in the control, the preference in the experimental chamber can be attributed to light.

  4. A student states that a bee’s waggle dance is an example of a learned behavior because the other bees learn from it. Evaluate.
    Show answer

    The dance itself is mostly innate: a naive bee performs it without being taught. The way in which nest mates respond to the information is also innate. The bees do learn the location of a food source and the odor of the flowers, so learning is involved in other parts of the behavior. In either case, the signal conveys information and raises the fitness of the colony.

  5. A wolf pack hunts a moose together. Explain how this cooperative behavior could be favored by natural selection although each wolf gets a smaller share of the food than a wolf that hunts a mouse alone.
    Show answer

    A pack can bring down large prey, which gives much more food in total than a single wolf could get, so each wolf has a higher net energy gain and the pups are better fed. Pack members are also often relatives, so kin selection adds to the benefit. Wolves with alleles for cooperative hunting would leave more surviving offspring.

  6. A helper gives up 2 offspring (C = 2) to help raise 6 extra nieces and nephews (\(r = 0.25\)). Apply Hamilton’s rule.
    Show answer

    \(rB = 0.25 \times 6 = 1.5\), and \(C = 2\). Since \(1.5 \lt 2\), the rule is not satisfied, so selection would not be expected to favor this form of helping.

Lesson 8.2 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.2 (energy)

Energy flow through ecosystems: producers, consumers, and the 10% rule

A hawk that eats a snake that ate a mouse that ate seeds is using sunlight that a plant captured weeks earlier. Every living thing needs a continuous supply of energy to build molecules, to move, to grow, and to keep its internal conditions stable (Unit 3), and almost all of it comes from the sun. This lesson follows the energy: how organisms acquire and spend it, how it is passed along a food chain, why so much is lost at each step, and what happens to populations when the supply changes.

Learning objective · 8.2.A

Describe the strategies organisms use to acquire and use energy.

Required content · EK 8.2.A.1 and 8.2.A.2

Organisms use energy to organize, grow, reproduce, and maintain homeostasis.

  1. Organisms use different strategies to regulate body temperature and metabolism. Endotherms use thermal energy generated by metabolism to maintain homeostatic body temperatures. Ectotherms lack efficient internal mechanisms for maintaining body temperature, although they may regulate their temperature behaviorally by moving into the sun or shade or by aggregating with other individuals.
  2. A net gain in energy results in energy storage, the growth of an organism, and increased reproductive output.
  3. A net loss of energy results in loss of mass, a decrease in reproductive output, and, eventually, the death of an organism.

Different organisms use various reproductive strategies in response to energy availability. Some organisms alternate between asexual and sexual reproduction in response to energy availability.

An organism’s energy budget

An organism’s energy budget is the balance between the energy that it takes in and the energy it spends on maintenance (cellular respiration to power homeostasis, movement, and repair), growth, and reproduction. When income is greater than the costs, the surplus is stored (as fat or starch) or used for growth and for making offspring: a net gain of energy. When the costs are higher than income, the organism uses its stores, loses mass, makes fewer offspring or none, and finally dies: a net loss. In a drought year, for instance, plants and animals have fewer seeds and young, and in a good year they have more.

Temperature regulation is a large part of the budget. Endotherms (birds and mammals) produce heat by metabolism and keep their body temperature nearly constant, in cold weather and in hot. This lets them stay active in the cold, but it is expensive: an endotherm may use roughly ten times as much energy per gram as an ectotherm of the same size and needs to eat much more. Ectotherms (most fish, amphibians, reptiles, and invertebrates) have no efficient internal source of heat. Their body temperature follows the environment, and they regulate it by behavior: a lizard basks in the sun to warm up and moves into shade or a burrow to cool, and bees cluster together in winter. They need much less food but are inactive when it is cold. Neither strategy is better: they are different ways of balancing costs and benefits.

Reproductive strategies also respond to energy. Seasonal breeding in animals and plants occurs at the time of year when food is most available for the young. Some organisms alternate between asexual and sexual reproduction. Aphids and water fleas (Daphnia) reproduce asexually by parthenogenesis when food is abundant, which gives a rapid increase in numbers, and switch to sexual reproduction when food or conditions become poor, which produces genetically varied, resistant eggs. Many plants also reproduce asexually by runners or sexually by seed. Others spread their reproduction over a lifetime (many birds) or reproduce once and die (biennial plants store energy in the first year and flower in the second; Pacific salmon spawn once).

Autotrophs and heterotrophs

Learning objective · 8.2.D

Explain how the activities of autotrophs and heterotrophs enable the flow of energy within an ecosystem.

Required content · EK 8.2.D.1 and 8.2.D.2

Autotrophs capture energy from physical or chemical sources in the environment.

  1. Photosynthetic organisms capture energy present in sunlight contributing to primary productivity.
  2. Chemosynthetic organisms capture energy from small inorganic molecules present in their environment, which can occur in the absence of oxygen.

Heterotrophs, which include carnivores, herbivores, omnivores, decomposers, and scavengers, metabolize carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins as sources of energy. Heterotrophs capture the energy present in carbon compounds by consuming organic matter derived from autotrophs, incorporating matter into their tissues.

Autotrophs (“self-feeders”) build their own organic molecules from inorganic ones. Photosynthetic autotrophs (plants, algae, cyanobacteria) use the energy in light (lesson 3.4). Chemosynthetic autotrophs, which are bacteria and archaea, use the energy that is released by the oxidation of small inorganic molecules such as hydrogen sulfide, ammonia, or iron(II) ions, and they can live without oxygen and without sunlight. They are the base of food webs around deep-sea hydrothermal vents, where giant tube worms host chemosynthetic bacteria. Heterotrophs cannot do this: they get the energy in organic compounds that were made by autotrophs, and incorporate part of the matter in their own tissues. They include herbivores (plants), carnivores (animals), omnivores (both), scavengers (dead animals), and decomposers (bacteria and fungi that break down dead matter and wastes and return the nutrients to the soil, lesson 8.3).

Trophic levels and food webs

GrassShrubsSeedsGrasshopperRabbitMouseFrogSnakeFoxHawkDecomposersrecycle nutrients fromevery trophic levelprimary consumerssecondary consumerstertiary consumer
Figure 8.2a A food web. Arrows point in the direction of energy flow, from the organism that is eaten to the one that eats it. An organism can occupy more than one trophic level: the mouse eats plants and the grasshopper, and the snake feeds at more than one level.

A trophic level is the position of an organism in a food chain, counted from the producers. Producers (autotrophs) are the first level. Primary consumers eat producers, secondary consumers eat primary consumers, tertiary and quaternary consumers eat those at the level below, and decomposers act on all levels. A food chain is a single path; a food web shows all the feeding relationships, and is closer to reality, because most animals eat more than one kind of food. A mouse that eats seeds is a primary consumer, but when it eats grasshoppers it is a secondary consumer.

The most common error on the exam is the direction of the arrows. In a food web, an arrow shows the flow of energy and matter: it points from the organism that is eaten to the one that eats it (grass \(\rightarrow\) rabbit \(\rightarrow\) fox). It does not mean “eats”. When a table of data is given, such as which species eat which, you build the web from the table, and the producers are the organisms that do not eat any other organism.

Productivity and the 10% rule

010,00020,00030,000GPP 30,000R 18,000NPP 12,000ForestGPP 14,000R 7,000NPP 7,000GrasslandGPP 5,000R 3,500Open oceanEnergy (kcal/m²/yr)net primaryproductivityproducerrespiration
Figure 8.2c Gross primary productivity (GPP) is all of the energy captured by producers; net primary productivity (NPP = GPP − R) is what is left after the producers use some for their own respiration, and is the energy available to consumers (illustrative values).

Primary productivity is the rate at which producers capture energy and make organic matter. Gross primary productivity (GPP) is the total energy captured by photosynthesis (or chemosynthesis) per unit area and time. The producers use part of it for their own cellular respiration (R), and what is left is stored in new biomass and is available for consumers: net primary productivity (NPP), with

\[ \text{NPP} = \text{GPP} - R \]

Worked example · Calculating NPP

A forest has a GPP of 30,000 kcal/m2/yr and a producer respiration of 18,000. A grassland has 14,000 and 7,000. The open ocean has 5,000 and 3,500. Calculate NPP and the percent of GPP that becomes NPP for each, and say which has the most energy available to consumers per unit area.

Forest. \(30{,}000 - 18{,}000 = 12{,}000\) kcal/m2/yr; \(12{,}000/30{,}000 = 40\%\).
Grassland. \(14{,}000 - 7{,}000 = 7{,}000\); \(7{,}000/14{,}000 = 50\%\).
Open ocean. \(5{,}000 - 3{,}500 = 1{,}500\); \(1{,}500/5{,}000 = 30\%\).
Conclusion. The forest has the largest NPP per unit area (12,000) and so the most energy for consumers. The grassland has the highest proportion of its GPP left over (50%).
Reasoning. Producers respire like every other organism, so NPP is always less than GPP. (The total NPP of the ocean is nevertheless very large because it covers about 70% of the Earth’s surface.)

20,000 kcal/m²/yrProducers2,000 kcal/m²/yrPrimary consumers200 kcal/m²/yrSecondary consumers20Tertiary consumers2Quaternary consumersabout 10%passes up
Figure 8.2b A pyramid of energy. Only about 10% of the energy at one trophic level is stored in the tissues of the next; the rest is used in respiration and released as heat, or is not eaten or digested. The pyramid cannot be inverted.

Energy is not recycled but flows one way through the ecosystem and leaves as heat (the second law of thermodynamics, lesson 3.3). At each transfer only about 10% of the energy at one level is stored in the biomass of the next. The remaining 90% is lost because (1) the organisms use most of the energy they take in for respiration (movement, maintenance, and heat); (2) part of the organisms are not eaten (roots, bones, and organisms that die and go to decomposers); and (3) part of what is eaten is not digested and leaves as feces. The percentage varies with the ecosystem (from 5% to 20%), but 10% is the number that is used on the exam.

Worked example · Energy at each trophic level

The NPP of a grassland is 20,000 kcal/m2/yr. Using the 10% rule, find the energy available to primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary consumers, and explain why food chains rarely have more than four or five levels.

Calculation. Primary consumers: \(20{,}000 \times 0.10 = 2{,}000\). Secondary: \(2{,}000 \times 0.10 = 200\). Tertiary: \(200 \times 0.10 = 20\). Quaternary: \(20 \times 0.10 = 2\) kcal/m2/yr.
Why chains are short. Only \(2/20{,}000 = 0.01\%\) of the producers’ energy reaches the fifth level, which is too little to support a viable population of large predators that have to hunt over a very large area. Top predators are rare for this reason (the lion, the orca, and the hawk have large ranges).
Pyramid shape. A pyramid of energy cannot be inverted, because more energy always enters a level than leaves it. A pyramid of numbers or biomass can look inverted in special cases (one tree supports thousands of insects), but a pyramid of energy never does.
Reasoning. The efficiency of the transfer, not the number of species, limits the length of the chain.

When energy availability changes

Learning objective · 8.2.C

Explain how changes in energy availability affect populations, communities, and ecosystems.

Required content · EK 8.2.C.1 and 8.2.C.2

Changes in energy availability can result in changes in population size.

Changes in energy availability can result in disruptions to an ecosystem.

  1. A change in energy resources such as sunlight can affect the number and size of the trophic levels. Trophic levels include producers; primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary consumers; and decomposers.
  2. A change in the biomass or number of producers in a given geographic area can affect the number and size of other trophic levels.

Since all of the energy comes from the producers, a change at the bottom is felt at every level above it. A bottom-up effect is a change in the producers that spreads upward. After a volcanic eruption fills the air with ash, or in a cloudy year, or in an ocean where the nutrients that the algae need are low, NPP falls, and the sizes of the populations of herbivores and then of carnivores fall in turn. An increase in sunlight, water, or nutrients has the opposite effect (up to a limit).

Worked example · Predicting the effect of a change in NPP

In the grassland above (NPP 20,000), a drought reduces NPP by 40%. Calculate the energy at each level of the chain with the 10% rule, and predict the effect on the hawk population.

New NPP. \(20{,}000 \times 0.60 = 12{,}000\).
Levels. Primary consumers 1,200; secondary 120; tertiary 12; quaternary 1.2 kcal/m2/yr.
Effect. Every level has 40% less energy, so the number of mice and of the other primary consumers will fall by about the same percent, and so the energy for the snakes, foxes, and hawks. Because the top level has the least energy to begin with (2 kcal falling to 1.2), the hawk population, which needs a minimum number of breeding individuals, is the most likely to disappear from the area.
Reasoning. A drop in the producers affects all levels, and the top predators are the most sensitive because their margin is the smallest.

Exam focus
  • Energy budget: net gain gives storage, growth, and reproduction; net loss gives loss of mass, fewer offspring, and death.
  • Endotherm: internal heat, constant temperature, high energy cost. Ectotherm: behavior controls temperature, low cost, less active when it is cold.
  • Photosynthetic and chemosynthetic autotrophs; heterotrophs include herbivores, carnivores, omnivores, scavengers, and decomposers.
  • Arrows point from the food to the eater (the direction of energy flow). Producers do not eat other organisms.
  • \(\text{NPP} = \text{GPP} - R\). Only about 10% of energy passes up each level; the rest is lost as heat, uneaten, or undigested. Energy flows one way and is not recycled.
  • Changes in producers (sunlight, nutrients) change all trophic levels. The pyramid of energy is never inverted.
Practice
  1. Explain why a lizard can survive on much less food than a mouse of the same mass.
    Show answer

    The mouse is an endotherm, which uses energy from metabolism to keep its body temperature high and constant, so it has a high metabolic rate and needs a lot of food. The lizard is an ectotherm that uses the sun and the shade to regulate its temperature, so it spends much less energy on heat.

  2. A producer has a GPP of 800 and a respiration of 500 (units of kcal/m2/day). Calculate NPP, and the energy available to secondary consumers using the 10% rule.
    Show answer

    NPP \(= 800 - 500 = 300\). Primary consumers get \(30\) and secondary consumers \(3\) kcal/m2/day.

  3. In a food web, a student draws an arrow from a fox to a rabbit to show that the fox eats the rabbit. Correct this.
    Show answer

    The arrow shows the flow of energy and matter, so it should point from the rabbit (the food) to the fox (the consumer). The arrow means “is eaten by” or “provides energy to”.

  4. Bacteria at a deep-sea vent make organic molecules using hydrogen sulfide. Classify them and explain why they do not need sunlight.
    Show answer

    They are chemosynthetic autotrophs. They get the energy from the oxidation of an inorganic molecule (hydrogen sulfide) and use it to fix carbon dioxide into organic compounds, so their energy source is chemical and not light.

  5. A lake receives 50% less sunlight for several years because of smoke. Predict the effects on phytoplankton, zooplankton, and fish, and say why.
    Show answer

    Phytoplankton productivity decreases, since less light is available for photosynthesis. With less energy entering the food web, the populations of zooplankton and then of the fish that eat them fall as well, and the effect is largest at the top. The energy available at each level decreases in proportion to the energy at the producers.

  6. Name the three reasons why only about 10% of the energy of a trophic level is available to the next.
    Show answer

    (1) Most of the energy is used in cellular respiration to run the organism and is lost as heat; (2) not all of the organism is eaten (for example, bones, roots, and organisms that die go to decomposers); (3) part of what is eaten is not digested or absorbed and is lost in the feces.

Lesson 8.3 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.2 (matter)

Biogeochemical cycles: how matter moves through ecosystems

The carbon atoms in your hand were, a few years ago, carbon dioxide in the air, and before that perhaps part of a grass blade, a cow, or a decaying leaf. The Earth receives energy from the sun, but it receives almost no new matter, so the water, carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus that make up living things have to be used again and again. Energy flows through an ecosystem in one direction and leaves as heat (lesson 8.2), but matter cycles between living organisms and the non-living environment. The paths are called biogeochemical cycles, because they involve living things (bio), rocks, air, and water (geo), and chemical changes.

Learning objective · 8.2.B

Explain how energy flows and matter cycles through trophic levels.

Required content · EK 8.2.B.1 to 8.2.B.3

Ecological levels of organization include populations, communities, ecosystems, and biomes.

Energy flows through ecosystems, while matter and nutrients cycle between the environment and organisms via biogeochemical cycles. The cycles are essential for life, and each cycle demonstrates the conservation of matter. The cycles are interdependent.

Biogeochemical cycles include abiotic and biotic reservoirs, as well as processes that cycle matter between reservoirs.

Levels of ecological organization

Ecology studies the interactions of organisms with each other and with the physical environment at several levels. An organism is an individual. A population is a group of individuals of the same species in the same area that can interbreed. A community is all of the populations of different species that live and interact in an area. An ecosystem is a community together with the abiotic factors (water, soil, light, temperature, and chemicals) with which it interacts, and in which energy flows and matter cycles. A biome is a large region of the Earth that is defined by its climate and by the characteristic plants and animals, such as tropical rain forest, desert, grassland, temperate forest, or tundra. The biosphere is all of the places on Earth in which there is life. Each level has properties that do not exist at the lower one (a population has a growth rate, and a community has a diversity).

Reservoirs, processes, and conservation of matter

In every cycle, an element is held in reservoirs, which are places where it is stored, and is moved among them by processes. A reservoir can be abiotic (the atmosphere, oceans, rocks, soil) or biotic (living organisms and dead organic matter). The cycles show the conservation of matter: atoms are not created or destroyed, only moved and combined in different molecules. The cycles are interdependent: photosynthesis (carbon cycle) needs water (water cycle) and nitrogen and phosphorus to make proteins and nucleic acids, and the decomposers that return nitrogen to the soil use carbon compounds as food. A change in one cycle therefore affects the others.

The water cycle

Oceancloudevaporationprecipitationtranspirationplantsrunoffgroundwatercondensation: vapor cools to droplets
Figure 8.3c The hydrologic (water) cycle. Reservoirs are oceans, surface water, the atmosphere, groundwater, and living organisms; the processes that move water between them are evaporation, condensation, precipitation, and transpiration.
Required content · EK 8.2.B.4

The hydrologic (water) cycle involves water movement and storage within the hydrosphere. Reservoirs include oceans, surface water, the atmosphere, and living organisms. Processes include evaporation, condensation, precipitation, and transpiration.

The sun’s energy drives the water cycle. Water evaporates from the oceans and from lakes and soil, and the water vapor rises, cools, and condenses into droplets that form clouds. It returns to the surface as precipitation (rain, snow). Water that falls on land runs off into streams and lakes, sinks into the soil to form groundwater, or is taken up by plant roots, and the plants lose it as vapor through the stomata in transpiration (cohesion in lesson 1.1, and the AP lab on transpiration). The oceans hold about 97% of the Earth’s water, and most of the fresh water is in ice and in groundwater. Water is also a reservoir in living things: the body of an organism is 60% to 90% water. Water is both an input and a product of metabolism (it is used in photosynthesis and is released in cellular respiration).

The carbon cycle

AtmosphereCO₂ProducerscarbohydratesConsumersorganic compoundsDecomposersdead matterFossil fuelscoal, oil, gasphotosynthesisrespirationrespirationrespiration ofdecomposerseatendiescombustionburial overmillions of years
Figure 8.3a The carbon cycle at its simplest has four main processes: photosynthesis (removes CO₂ from the air), cellular respiration, decomposition, and combustion (return CO₂). Carbon in fossil fuels is a reservoir that was stored for millions of years.
Required content · EK 8.2.B.5

The carbon cycle involves recycling carbon atoms through Earth’s biosphere into organisms as carbohydrates and back into the atmosphere as carbon dioxide (CO2). At the highest levels of organization, the carbon cycle can be simplified into four parts: photosynthesis, cellular respiration, decomposition, and combustion.

Carbon is the backbone of all organic molecules. The cycle can be reduced to four processes. Photosynthesis takes CO2 from the air (or bicarbonate from water) and fixes it into carbohydrates in producers. Cellular respiration, in producers, consumers, and decomposers, oxidizes organic molecules and returns CO2. Decomposition by bacteria and fungi breaks down dead organisms and wastes, returning CO2 by their respiration (and CH4 in the absence of oxygen). Combustion of wood and of fossil fuels returns carbon quickly that was stored for a long time. Consumers get carbon when they eat other organisms. The main reservoirs are the atmosphere (as CO2), the oceans (the largest, as dissolved inorganic carbon and the shells of organisms), living and dead organic matter, soils, and fossil fuels and carbonate rocks.

Worked example · Human effects on the carbon cycle

The concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere was about 280 parts per million (ppm) before the industrial revolution and about 420 ppm recently. (a) Calculate the percent increase. (b) Explain which processes contributed to the change. (c) Predict the effect of a large-scale loss of forest.

(a) \((420 - 280)/280 \times 100 = 50\%\) increase.
(b) Combustion of coal, oil, and gas moves carbon from the large and slow reservoir of fossil fuels to the atmosphere in a short time. Deforestation adds CO2 by burning and by the decomposition of the trees that are cut, and it removes the plants that took CO2 from the air. The oceans and plants take up about half of the carbon that is emitted, but not all of it.
(c) Fewer producers means that less CO2 is removed by photosynthesis, so the concentration in the air would rise more, and the stored carbon in the trees is released by the burning or decomposition.
Reasoning. A system is in balance when the rates of the processes that add carbon to the atmosphere are equal to those that remove it; human activity has increased the inputs faster than the outputs have grown.

The nitrogen cycle

AtmosphereN₂ gas (78%)AmmoniumNH₄⁺NitriteNO₂⁻NitrateNO₃⁻Plantsamino acids, DNAAnimalseat plantsDecomposersdead matter, wastenitrogen fixation(bacteria)nitrificationnitrificationassimilationeatenwastes, deathammonificationdenitrification(bacteria, no O₂)
Figure 8.3b The nitrogen cycle. The steps are performed by microorganisms in the soil: nitrogen fixation (N₂ to NH₃, which becomes NH₄⁺), nitrification (NH₄⁺ to NO₂⁻ to NO₃⁻), assimilation, ammonification, and denitrification (NO₃⁻ back to N₂).
Required content · EK 8.2.B.6

The nitrogen cycle involves several steps, including nitrogen fixation, assimilation, ammonification, nitrification, and denitrification. These steps are performed by microorganisms in the soil. The largest reservoir of nitrogen is the atmosphere. In nitrogen fixation, nitrogen gas (N2) is fixed into ammonia (NH3), which ionizes to ammonium (NH4+) by acquiring hydrogen ions from the soil solution.

Nitrogen is needed in amino acids (lesson 1.7) and nucleotides (lesson 1.6). The atmosphere is 78% nitrogen gas, but N2 has a triple bond that makes it unusable by plants and animals. Only some prokaryotes can break it. The cycle has five steps, and each is done by microorganisms:

  1. Nitrogen fixation: N2 is converted to ammonia (NH3), which picks up H+ from the soil water to become ammonium (NH4+). It is done by free-living soil bacteria and by Rhizobium bacteria in the root nodules of legumes (peas, beans, clover), which is why legumes are planted to enrich the soil. Lightning and the industrial Haber process also fix nitrogen.
  2. Nitrification: nitrifying bacteria in the soil oxidize ammonium to nitrite (NO2−) and then to nitrate (NO3−), the form that plants take up most easily. It requires oxygen.
  3. Assimilation: plants take up nitrate (and ammonium) through the roots and use it to make amino acids and nucleotides. Animals get nitrogen by eating plants or other animals.
  4. Ammonification: decomposers break down proteins and nucleic acids in dead organisms, in urine, and in feces, and release ammonium into the soil.
  5. Denitrification: denitrifying bacteria in waterlogged soil and sediments that have no oxygen convert nitrate back into N2 gas, which returns to the atmosphere.
Worked example · Where does the nitrogen go?

A farmer finds that corn grown after soybeans needs less fertilizer than corn grown after corn. Explain, and predict what happens if the soil becomes waterlogged for a long time after the fertilizer is applied.

Soybeans. They are legumes with nitrogen-fixing Rhizobium in root nodules. The bacteria convert N2 to ammonia, which becomes ammonium that the plant uses. When the roots and residues decompose, ammonification releases nitrogen into the soil for the next crop, so less fertilizer is needed.
Waterlogging. The soil has little oxygen, so denitrifying bacteria use nitrate instead and convert it to N2 gas, which escapes into the air. The soil loses nitrate that the plants could have taken up. (Nitrate is also easily washed out of the soil by water, which causes problems downstream; lesson 8.7.)
Reasoning. Each step is carried out by a different group of microorganisms under specific conditions (oxygen for nitrification, no oxygen for denitrification), so the balance depends on the soil.

The phosphorus cycle

Required content · EK 8.2.B.7

The phosphorus cycle involves weathering rocks releasing phosphate (PO43−) into soil and groundwater. Producers take in phosphate, which is incorporated into biological molecules; consumers eat producers, transferring phosphate to animals. Phosphorus returns to the soil via decomposition of biomass, or excretion. Phosphate can also be incorporated back into the environment via decomposition of decaying organic matter.

Phosphorus is part of DNA, RNA, ATP, and phospholipids (lessons 1.5, 1.6, and 2.3), and of bones and teeth. Unlike carbon and nitrogen, it has no significant gas phase: its main reservoir is rock (and sediment), and the cycle is slow. Weathering of rock by rain releases phosphate (PO43−) into the soil and water. Plants and algae take it up through the roots and incorporate it into biological molecules, consumers obtain it by eating producers or other consumers, and it returns to the soil by excretion and by the decomposition of dead organisms and wastes. Some of the phosphate is washed to the oceans, where it settles in sediments and becomes rock again over millions of years. Because the supply of available phosphate is often low, it is a limiting nutrient in many soils and lakes, and phosphate fertilizers are added in agriculture. The runoff from fields then causes eutrophication (lesson 8.7).

CycleMain reservoirKey processesImportant organisms
WaterOceansEvaporation, condensation, precipitation, transpirationPlants (transpiration)
CarbonOceans, rocks, fossil fuels (atmosphere is small)Photosynthesis, respiration, decomposition, combustionProducers, decomposers
NitrogenAtmosphere (N2)Fixation, nitrification, assimilation, ammonification, denitrificationSoil bacteria, Rhizobium
PhosphorusRocks and sedimentsWeathering, uptake, excretion, decompositionPlants, decomposers
Exam focus
  • Levels: organism, population (one species), community (all species), ecosystem (community plus abiotic factors), biome, biosphere.
  • Energy flows (one way); matter cycles. Cycles show conservation of matter and are interdependent. Know reservoirs (biotic and abiotic) and the processes between them.
  • Water: evaporation, condensation, precipitation, transpiration. Carbon: photosynthesis, cellular respiration, decomposition, combustion.
  • Nitrogen (five steps, all by microorganisms): fixation N2 \(\rightarrow\) NH3/NH4+; nitrification NH4+ \(\rightarrow\) NO2− \(\rightarrow\) NO3−; assimilation; ammonification; denitrification NO3− \(\rightarrow\) N2.
  • Phosphorus: rock reservoir, no gas phase; weathering releases PO43−; returns through excretion and decomposition.
  • Decomposers (bacteria and fungi) return matter to the abiotic pool in all of the cycles.
Practice
  1. Distinguish between a population, a community, and an ecosystem, using a pond as an example.
    Show answer

    A population is all the individuals of one species, for example all the bluegill fish in the pond. The community is all the populations of different species in the pond (fish, algae, insects, frogs, bacteria). The ecosystem is the community together with the abiotic factors, such as water, light, temperature, dissolved oxygen, and nutrients, and the interactions among them.

  2. Name the process in the carbon cycle that (a) removes CO2 from the atmosphere, and (b) returns CO2 to the atmosphere in three different ways.
    Show answer

    (a) Photosynthesis. (b) Cellular respiration of producers and consumers, decomposition (the respiration of decomposers), and combustion of wood and fossil fuels.

  3. Place the following in the order in which they occur in the nitrogen cycle, starting with N2 in the air: nitrification, assimilation, nitrogen fixation, denitrification, ammonification. Then say which is the only step that returns N2 to the atmosphere.
    Show answer

    Nitrogen fixation, nitrification, assimilation, ammonification (after death or excretion), and denitrification. Only denitrification returns N2 gas to the atmosphere.

  4. A student claims that decomposers are not necessary in an ecosystem because they do not provide food for other organisms. Evaluate.
    Show answer

    The claim is wrong. Decomposers break down dead organisms and wastes and return carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus to the soil, air, and water in forms that producers can use. Without them, the nutrients would remain locked in dead matter, and the producers (and so all the other trophic levels) would run out of the nutrients that they need.

  5. Explain why phosphorus is more often a limiting nutrient in lakes than carbon is.
    Show answer

    Carbon is available from the large reservoirs of CO2 in the air and of dissolved carbon in the water, and it exchanges with the atmosphere. Phosphorus has no gas phase and comes mainly from the slow weathering of rock, so its supply is low and slow to be replaced. Adding phosphate (as in runoff from fertilizer) therefore has a big effect on the growth of algae.

  6. Plants are grown in sterile soil that has no bacteria but contains ammonium, nitrate, and phosphate. Compared with plants in natural soil, would the nitrogen cycle matter for these plants? Explain.
    Show answer

    The plants have a supply of nitrate and ammonium that they can use directly, so they could grow without the bacterial steps for a while. But the supply would run out, because there are no bacteria to fix nitrogen or to carry out ammonification and nitrification on the dead material. In natural soil the microorganisms continuously supply the nitrogen that is needed.

Lesson 8.4 · Unit 8 · CED topics 8.3 and 8.4

Population ecology: growth models and the effect of density

In 1859 a farmer in Australia released 24 wild rabbits for hunting. Within 50 years there were hundreds of millions, and they had stripped much of the continent’s vegetation. Yet no population grows without limit: bacteria in a flask run out of food, deer in a park eat all the browse and starve, and even the rabbits eventually reached a ceiling. The study of how populations change in size, and of what stops them from growing, is called population ecology. It is one of the topics in which you will use equations on the exam, and the equations are on your reference sheet, so the main skill is to understand what each one says and how to use it.

Learning objective · 8.3.A

Describe factors that influence growth dynamics of populations.

Required content · EK 8.3.A.1 and 8.3.A.2

Populations comprise individual organisms of the same species that interact with one another and with the environment in complex ways.

Many adaptations in organisms are related to obtaining and using energy and matter in a particular environment.

  1. Population growth dynamics depend on birth rate, death rate, and population size.
  2. Reproduction without constraints results in the exponential growth of a population.

Relevant equations: Population growth: \(\dfrac{dN}{dt} = B - D\). Exponential growth: \(\dfrac{dN}{dt} = r_{\max} N\).

Describing a population

A population is a group of individuals of one species that live in the same area. Its size (\(N\)) is the number of individuals, and its density is the number per unit of area or volume (for example, 3 plants per m2 if 120 plants grow in 40 m2). Dispersion is the pattern of spacing: clumped (the most common, because resources are patchy or because animals live in groups), uniform (evenly spaced, as in territorial penguins or in creosote bushes that compete for water), or random (unpredictable, when resources are even and individuals do not attract or repel each other).

It is rarely possible to count every individual. Plants and slow animals are estimated by sampling quadrats (mean density \(\times\) total area). Mobile animals are estimated by mark and recapture: capture a sample, mark and release it, and later capture a second sample and count how many are marked. If the marked animals have mixed evenly with the others, the fraction of marked animals in the second sample equals the fraction of marked animals in the population, so

\[ N \approx \frac{(\text{number marked first}) \times (\text{size of second sample})}{\text{number of marked recaptured}} \]

Worked example · Mark and recapture

Fifty turtles in a pond are marked and released. A week later, 60 turtles are caught and 12 of them are marked. Estimate the size of the population.

Proportion. The fraction marked in the second sample is \(12/60 = 0.20\), which estimates the fraction of marked turtles in the whole pond.
Population. \(50 / N = 0.20\), so \(N = 50/0.20 = 250\) turtles.
Assumptions. The marks do not fall off and do not change survival, marked animals mix evenly with unmarked ones, there is no immigration, emigration, birth, or death in the week, and every animal is equally likely to be caught. If the marked turtles avoid traps, fewer are recaptured, and the estimate is too high.

Change in population size

The size of a population changes because of births, deaths, and (if you include movement) immigration and emigration. The basic equation, for a closed population, is

\[ \frac{dN}{dt} = B - D \]

where \(dN/dt\) is the change in the number of individuals per unit time, \(B\) is the number of births in that time, and \(D\) is the number of deaths. If \(B \gt D\) the population grows; if \(B \lt D\) it shrinks, and if they are equal it is stable. It is usually more useful to use per capita rates (per individual): with a per capita birth rate \(b\) and death rate \(d\), \(B = bN\) and \(D = dN\), and the per capita growth rate is \(r = b - d\).

Worked example · Birth and death rates

A population of 1,000 deer has 300 births and 100 deaths in one year. Calculate the change in population size, the per capita rates, and the growth rate \(r\).

Change. \(dN/dt = B - D = 300 - 100 = +200\) deer per year.
Per capita. \(b = 300/1{,}000 = 0.30\) and \(d = 100/1{,}000 = 0.10\) per individual per year.
Growth rate. \(r = b - d = 0.30 - 0.10 = 0.20\) per year, which is a 20% increase per year.
Reasoning. A population of 5,000 with the same per capita rates would have \(dN/dt = 0.20 \times 5{,}000 = 1{,}000\) per year, so the larger population adds more individuals each year, although the per capita rate is the same.

Exponential growth

0400800120005101520K = 1,000exponential growthlogistic growthTime (generations)Population size (N)
Figure 8.4a Exponential and logistic growth with the same starting size (50) and the same maximum per capita growth rate. Without limits the population grows exponentially; with limited resources it follows an S-shaped (sigmoid) curve and levels off near the carrying capacity K.

If resources are unlimited, each individual produces offspring at the same rate regardless of how many individuals there are, and the population increases by a constant percentage per unit time. Under ideal conditions the per capita growth rate has its maximum value, \(r_{\max}\), and

\[ \frac{dN}{dt} = r_{\max} N \]

This is exponential growth. The graph of \(N\) against time is a J-shaped curve, in which the rate of increase becomes larger as the population gets larger. The size at time \(t\) is \(N_t = N_0 e^{r_{\max} t}\). Examples are a bacterial culture in the first hours, a species that is introduced into a new area with plentiful resources (like the Australian rabbits in the beginning), and a recovering population after a disaster.

Worked example · Exponential growth

A population of 500 insects has \(r_{\max} = 0.20\) per year and unlimited resources. Calculate the growth rate at the start, the population after 5 years, and the doubling time.

Initial rate. \(dN/dt = 0.20 \times 500 = 100\) per year.
After 5 years. \(N = 500 \times e^{0.20 \times 5} = 500 \times e^{1.0} = 500 \times 2.718 = 1{,}359\).
Doubling time. \(\ln 2 / r = 0.693/0.20 = 3.47\) years.
Reasoning. The rate at \(N = 1{,}359\) is \(0.20 \times 1{,}359 = 272\) per year, much more than the initial 100. After 10 years the population would be \(500 \times e^{2} = 3{,}695\) and after 50 years more than \(10^{7}\) times the starting size, which is impossible in a finite environment, so something must limit the growth.

Carrying capacity and logistic growth

Learning objective · 8.4.A

Explain how the density of a population affects and is determined by resource availability in the environment.

Required content · EK 8.4.A.1 and 8.4.A.2

Carrying capacity is the sustainable abundance of a species that can be supported by the ecosystem’s total available resources.

As limits to growth attributable to density-dependent and density-independent factors are imposed, a logistic growth model typically ensues.

Relevant equation: Logistic growth: \(\dfrac{dN}{dt} = r_{\max} N \left( \dfrac{K - N}{K} \right)\), where \(K\) is the carrying capacity.

The carrying capacity, \(K\), is the largest population that an environment can support indefinitely with its food, water, space, and other resources. As the population approaches \(K\), the amount of resources per individual decreases, so the birth rate falls and the death rate rises. The factor \((K - N)/K\) in the logistic equation represents the “unused” fraction of the carrying capacity: it is close to 1 when \(N\) is small (growth is nearly exponential) and 0 when \(N = K\) (growth stops). The curve is S-shaped (sigmoid).

02040600250500750100037.55037.5K/2Population size (N)Growth rate dN/dt
Figure 8.4b Logistic growth rate against population size (r = 0.2 per year, K = 1,000). The population grows fastest at N = K/2; as N approaches K the rate falls to zero.
Worked example · Logistic growth rate at different sizes

A population has \(r_{\max} = 0.20\) per year and \(K = 1{,}000\). Calculate \(dN/dt\) at \(N = 250\), 500, 750, and 1,000, and say at which size the population grows the fastest.

\(N = 250\). \(0.20 \times 250 \times (1000 - 250)/1000 = 50 \times 0.75 = 37.5\) per year.
\(N = 500\). \(0.20 \times 500 \times 0.50 = 100 \times 0.50 = 50.0\) per year.
\(N = 750\). \(0.20 \times 750 \times 0.25 = 150 \times 0.25 = 37.5\) per year.
\(N = 1{,}000\). \(0.20 \times 1000 \times 0 = 0\).
Fastest growth. At \(N = 500 = K/2\), the point of inflection of the S-curve. This is also the most productive population size for a harvest that wants a sustainable yield, because it adds the most individuals per year. If \(N \gt K\), then \((K - N) \lt 0\) and \(dN/dt\) is negative, so the population falls back toward \(K\).
Reasoning. Growth is slow at the start because there are few individuals to reproduce, and slow at the end because resources are limiting.

Real populations often overshoot \(K\) and then drop, or oscillate around it, because of delays between the use of resources and the response of births and deaths. And \(K\) is not a constant: it changes with the season, with disturbance, and with the climate.

What limits populations: density-dependent and density-independent factors

Density-dependent factors affect a higher percentage of the population as the density increases. They are mostly biotic: competition for food, light, or space; predation (predators concentrate on abundant prey); disease and parasites (which spread faster in a dense population); the build-up of toxic waste; and stress that lowers the birth rate. They act as negative feedback (lesson 4.4) and keep the population near \(K\). Density-independent factors affect the same percentage of the population at any density: fires, floods, hurricanes, volcanic eruptions, freezes, and droughts. They can cause sudden drops of a population in a way that has nothing to do with its size.

Life-history strategies and survivorship

1101001,0000255075100Type IhumansType IImany birdsType IIIoysters, plantsPercent of maximum life spanSurvivors per 1,000 (log scale)
Figure 8.4c Survivorship curves. Type I (low death rate early, high late in life), Type II (a roughly constant death rate at all ages), and Type III (high death rates among the young, and few offspring that survive to adulthood).

Organisms have a limited budget of energy (lesson 8.2) and cannot maximize everything. Two extremes have been described, and most species lie between them. r-selected species live in unpredictable or disturbed environments and are far below \(K\) much of the time. They breed early, have many small offspring, and give them little care (insects, weeds, mice, bacteria). K-selected species live in stable environments near \(K\) and are favored for competing for scarce resources: they breed later, have few large offspring, and give much parental care (elephants, humans, oak trees).

The pattern of survival with age is shown by a survivorship curve, which plots the number of survivors against age (usually with a log scale). Type I: most individuals survive to old age, and death is concentrated in old age (humans, large mammals; K-selected, few offspring with parental care). Type II: a constant probability of death at all ages (many birds, some lizards, and small mammals). Type III: most individuals die very young, and the few that survive the early period live long (oysters, many fish, plants, and insects; r-selected, many offspring with no care).

Exam focus
  • \(dN/dt = B - D\). Per capita growth rate \(r = b - d\). Exponential: \(dN/dt = r_{\max} N\) (J-curve; unlimited resources).
  • Logistic: \(dN/dt = r_{\max} N (K - N)/K\) (S-curve). Growth is fastest at \(N = K/2\) and is zero at \(N = K\); negative if \(N \gt K\).
  • Carrying capacity is the sustainable population that the resources can support; it can change.
  • Density-dependent limits (competition, predation, disease, waste) act as negative feedback. Density-independent events (fire, flood, freeze) do not depend on density.
  • r-selected (many offspring, little care, Type III) against K-selected (few offspring, much care, Type I).
  • Graphing: choose the correct axis (time on the x-axis), label both with units, scale evenly, and use a log scale for survivorship or very large ranges.
Practice
  1. A population of 2,000 mice has 900 births and 500 deaths in a year, with no migration. Calculate \(dN/dt\) and the per capita growth rate.
    Show answer

    \(dN/dt = 900 - 500 = +400\) per year. \(r = 400/2{,}000 = 0.20\) per year (\(b = 0.45\), \(d = 0.25\)).

  2. A culture of 100 bacteria grows exponentially with \(r_{\max} = 0.69\) per hour. Calculate \(dN/dt\) at the start and the number of bacteria after 3 hours.
    Show answer

    \(dN/dt = 0.69 \times 100 = 69\) bacteria per hour. After 3 hours: \(100 \times e^{0.69 \times 3} = 100 \times e^{2.07} = 100 \times 7.9 \approx 790\) (the population doubles about every hour: \(100 \to 200 \to 400 \to 800\)).

  3. A population has \(K = 800\) and \(r_{\max} = 0.5\). Calculate \(dN/dt\) at \(N = 200\) and at \(N = 400\).
    Show answer

    At 200: \(0.5 \times 200 \times (800 - 200)/800 = 100 \times 0.75 = 75\). At 400: \(0.5 \times 400 \times 0.5 = 100\), which is the maximum.

  4. Classify each limit as density-dependent or density-independent: (a) a hurricane that destroys nests; (b) the spread of a disease in crowded deer; (c) competition for nest holes; (d) an unusual spring frost that kills flowers.
    Show answer

    (a) Density-independent. (b) Density-dependent. (c) Density-dependent. (d) Density-independent.

  5. Sketch in words the graph of a population of yeast in a closed flask with a limited supply of sugar over several days, and explain each phase.
    Show answer

    Phase 1: a slow increase (few cells). Phase 2: a rapid, nearly exponential increase, with abundant sugar. Phase 3: growth slows as the sugar runs out and waste (alcohol) accumulates, which is the logistic phase near \(K\). Phase 4: the population levels off, then declines when the sugar is exhausted and the alcohol is toxic (a closed flask has no input, so the carrying capacity falls to zero).

  6. Fifty fish are marked in a lake. A later sample of 80 fish includes 10 marked fish. Estimate \(N\), and say whether it is high or low if some marked fish died after release.
    Show answer

    \(N = 50 \times 80/10 = 400\) fish. If some marked fish died, fewer marked fish would be recaptured, so the fraction marked would be lower and the estimate (\(N\)) would be too high.

Lesson 8.5 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.5

Community ecology: diversity and species interactions

On Isle Royale, a wilderness island in Lake Superior, the numbers of moose and wolves have been counted every year since 1958. When the wolves are abundant the moose decline; when the moose are scarce the wolves starve and decline, and then the moose return. No species on the island lives alone. Each depends on, competes with, feeds on, or is used by others, and these interactions decide which species can live together and in what numbers. A community is the set of populations of different species that live in the same place and interact, and this lesson covers how to describe a community and how interactions shape it.

Learning objective · 8.5.A

Describe the structure of a community according to its species composition and diversity.

Required content · EK 8.5.A.1

The structure of a community is measured and described in terms of species composition and species diversity.

Relevant equation: Simpson’s diversity index: Diversity index \(= 1 - \sum \left( \dfrac{n}{N} \right)^2\), where \(n\) = total number of organisms of a particular species and \(N\) = total number of organisms of all species.

Species composition and diversity

Community A05010025sp. A25sp. B25sp. C25sp. DSimpson index = 0.75Community B05010085sp. A5sp. B5sp. C5sp. DSimpson index = 0.27Individuals counted
Figure 8.6a Richness against diversity. Both communities have four species (the same richness), but community A is more even, and its Simpson’s diversity index (0.75) is much higher than that of community B (0.27), which is dominated by one species.

Species composition is the list of species in a community, and which of them are present. Species diversity has two components: richness, the number of different species, and evenness (relative abundance), how equal the numbers of individuals of each species are. A forest with 4 species in equal numbers is more diverse than one with 4 species in which 85% of the trees belong to one species. Simpson’s diversity index combines the two. For each species, the fraction of the individuals that it represents is \(n/N\), and the index is

\[ D = 1 - \sum \left( \frac{n}{N} \right)^2 \]

The index is between 0 (one species only) and nearly 1 (many species, all equally common). A higher value means a higher diversity.

Worked example · Simpson’s diversity index

Two meadows each have four plant species. In meadow A the counts are 25, 25, 25, and 25 (\(N = 100\)). In meadow B they are 85, 5, 5, and 5 (\(N = 100\)). Calculate the index of each, and interpret.

Meadow A. Each fraction is 0.25, and \(0.25^2 = 0.0625\). The sum is \(4 \times 0.0625 = 0.25\), so \(D = 1 - 0.25 = \mathbf{0.75}\).
Meadow B. \((0.85)^2 = 0.7225\) and \(3 \times (0.05)^2 = 3 \times 0.0025 = 0.0075\). The sum is 0.73, so \(D = 1 - 0.73 = \mathbf{0.27}\).
Interpretation. The richness is the same (4 species), but meadow A has a much higher diversity because the species are equally abundant. In meadow B one species dominates, and a disease that affected that species would change the community greatly. A third meadow with counts 40, 30, 20, and 10 would give \(D = 1 - (0.16 + 0.09 + 0.04 + 0.01) = 0.70\).
Reasoning. Do the arithmetic in the order that is shown: square each fraction, add, then subtract from 1. A frequent mistake is to forget to subtract the sum from 1 (the sum is a measure of dominance, which goes the other way).

Interactions among populations

Learning objective · 8.5.B

Explain how interactions within and among populations influence community structure.

Required content · EK 8.5.B.1 to 8.5.B.4

Communities are groups of interacting populations of different species that change over time based on the interactions between those populations.

Interactions among populations determine how they access energy and matter within a community.

Relationships among interacting populations can be characterized by positive and negative effects and can be modeled. Examples include predator/prey interactions, cooperation, trophic cascades, and niche partitioning.

Competition, predation, and symbioses, including parasitism, mutualism, and commensalism, can drive population dynamics.

Interactions can be described by their effect on each partner, a plus (+) if the partner gains, a minus (−) if it loses, and a zero (0) if it is not affected.

InteractionEffectsDescription and examples
Competition− / −Both species use the same limited resource (light, water, food, nest sites). Barnacles of two species compete for space on rocks; weeds and crops compete for nutrients.
Predation (and herbivory)+ / −One organism kills and eats another (a hawk and a mouse), or eats part of a plant without always killing it (a deer on a shrub).
Parasitism+ / −A parasite lives on or in a host and feeds on it, usually without killing it quickly: tapeworms, ticks, mistletoe, the malaria parasite.
Mutualism+ / +Both gain: flowers and pollinators; mycorrhizal fungi and roots; nitrogen-fixing bacteria in legume nodules; the gut bacteria that digest food; corals and their algae.
Commensalism+ / 0One gains and the other is unaffected: epiphytic orchids on tree branches; barnacles on a whale; cattle egrets that feed on insects that the cattle disturb.

Parasitism, mutualism, and commensalism are symbioses, a close and long-lasting association between two species. A relationship can change with the conditions: a mutualism can become a parasitism if one partner gets more benefit than it gives.

Competition and the niche

Grown separately01002000481216Time (days)Grown together01002000481216Time (days)Population densityP. aureliaP. caudatum
Figure 8.5a Gause’s competition experiments (schematic, based on the results of the 1934 study). Each species can live alone on the same food, but when both are in one culture, the species that uses the food better excludes the other: the competitive exclusion principle.

The ecological niche of a species is the sum of its use of the biotic and abiotic resources: where it lives, what it eats, when it is active, the conditions that it tolerates, and its role in the community. The fundamental niche is what a species could use without competitors, and the realized niche is the part that it actually uses in the presence of competitors and predators.

The competitive exclusion principle states that two species that use the same limited resource in the same way cannot coexist indefinitely in the same place: the better competitor excludes the other. G. F. Gause tested this in 1934 with two species of Paramecium fed on the same bacteria. Each grew well alone and followed a logistic curve (lesson 8.4). When they were grown together, P. aurelia grew and P. caudatum disappeared. Species with different requirements coexisted: P. caudatum grown with P. bursaria, which feeds on a different part of the culture, did not exclude it.

Overlapping niches: strong competitionresource (food size, height in tree, or depth)Partitioned niches: coexistenceresource (food size, height in tree, or depth)Use of resource
Figure 8.5b Resource partitioning. When two species use the same resource, competition is strong. Natural selection can favor individuals that use different parts of the resource, so the realized niches become narrower and the species can coexist (for example, warblers that feed at different heights of the same spruce tree).

In nature, competitors often coexist because they divide the resource: resource partitioning or niche partitioning. Five species of warblers in a spruce tree feed in different parts of the tree, and the anoles of a Caribbean island live at different heights. Competition also selects for character displacement: where two related species live together, the beaks or other traits are more different than where each lives alone. Joseph Connell’s experiments on barnacles show the same effect: Chthamalus lives high on the shore in the presence of Balanus, but when Balanus is removed it can live lower, which shows that its realized niche is smaller than the fundamental one.

Predation, defense, and population cycles

Predators and their prey evolve together. Prey have adaptations that reduce the chance that they are caught: camouflage (cryptic coloration), warning colors (aposematic coloration) in species that are poisonous or taste bad, such as monarch butterflies and poison dart frogs, spines and toxins, and mimicry. In Batesian mimicry a harmless species resembles a harmful one (a hoverfly that looks like a wasp), and in Müllerian mimicry two harmful species resemble each other. Predators evolve better senses, speed, and methods of hunting, and poisons.

These interactions can control the size of the populations, as in the moose and wolves of Isle Royale and the classic records of the snowshoe hare and the Canada lynx, whose numbers rise and fall in cycles of about 10 years, with the peak of the lynx following the peak of the hare. The model is a negative feedback loop (lesson 4.4): more prey means more food for predators, which then increase and reduce the prey, so the food for predators decreases and their numbers fall, and the prey can recover. A cycle like this can also result from the food supply of the prey, so the cause of an observed cycle needs to be tested by experiment.

Worked example · Reading predator and prey data

On a graph, the number of hares peaks in years 2, 12, and 22, and the number of lynx peaks in years 4, 14, and 24. (a) What is the period? (b) Which species peaks first, and why? (c) Predict what would happen to the hare cycle if the lynx were removed.

(a) The peaks are 10 years apart, so the period is 10 years.
(b) The hares peak first, because the lynx population grows only when there is plenty of prey: the increase in lynx is a response to the increase in hares, so there is a delay of about 2 years.
(c) Without lynx, predation would not reduce the hares, and the population would grow until it was limited by food (the carrying capacity), which would probably give a larger population with a different pattern. Observations show that the food supply and disease also play a part.
Reasoning. The time lag between the peaks is the signature of a predator that responds to the density of its prey.

Comparing means: error bars

The exam often shows a bar graph with error bars and asks whether two means are different. An error bar can show the standard error of the mean (SE) or the 95% confidence interval, which is about the mean \(\pm\) 2 SE. If the 95% intervals of two means do not overlap, the means are probably significantly different (\(p \lt 0.05\)). If they overlap, you cannot conclude that there is a difference.

Worked example · Using error bars (skill 5.B)

In an experiment on competition, the mean mass of seedlings that were grown alone was \(14.8 \pm 0.9\) g (mean \(\pm\) SE), and of those that were grown with a competitor \(12.3 \pm 1.1\) g. Decide whether the difference is significant.

95% intervals (\(\pm\) 2 SE). Alone: \(14.8 \pm 1.8\) g, which is 13.0 to 16.6 g. With competitor: \(12.3 \pm 2.2\) g, which is 10.1 to 14.5 g.
Comparison. The intervals overlap between 13.0 and 14.5 g, so the data do not allow us to conclude that the means are different.
Conclusion. The seedlings with a competitor were smaller on average (2.5 g), but this difference is not statistically significant. Increasing the sample size would reduce the standard errors and could make the difference clear.
Reasoning. Do not claim that there is no effect: only that the evidence is not sufficient.

Exam focus
  • Diversity = richness (number of species) + evenness (relative abundance). Simpson’s \(D = 1 - \sum (n/N)^2\); higher = more diverse. Do not forget \(1 -\).
  • Competition (−/−), predation and parasitism (+/−), mutualism (+/+), commensalism (+/0). Parasitism, mutualism, and commensalism are symbioses (close associations).
  • Competitive exclusion: complete competitors cannot coexist (Gause). Niche (resource) partitioning allows coexistence. Fundamental against realized niche (Connell).
  • Predator-prey cycles show a lag: predators peak after prey; they are modeled by negative feedback.
  • Error bars: non-overlapping 95% intervals (mean \(\pm\) 2 SE) suggest a significant difference; overlap means you cannot conclude it.
Practice
  1. A pond has 50 individuals of species X, 30 of Y, and 20 of Z. Calculate Simpson’s index.
    Show answer

    \(D = 1 - (0.50^2 + 0.30^2 + 0.20^2) = 1 - (0.25 + 0.09 + 0.04) = 1 - 0.38 = 0.62\).

  2. Classify each interaction and give the sign for each species: (a) a lichen (fungus and alga); (b) a tick on a deer; (c) a bird that nests in a tree without affecting it; (d) two plant species that need the same light.
    Show answer

    (a) Mutualism (+/+). (b) Parasitism (+ for the tick, − for the deer). (c) Commensalism (+ for the bird, 0 for the tree). (d) Competition (−/−).

  3. Two species of lizards live on the same island. One feeds in the ground and the other in the canopy. Explain how this arrangement prevents competitive exclusion.
    Show answer

    They partition the resource (space and so food): each uses a different part of the habitat, so the niches overlap little and the competition is weak. As a result, neither species excludes the other and both can coexist. Selection may also have caused their traits to diverge.

  4. Barnacle species A lives high on the rocks, and B lives lower. When B is removed, A also lives lower; when A is removed, B does not live higher. Interpret the results in terms of the niche.
    Show answer

    The fundamental niche of A includes the lower zone, but B excludes it there, so its realized niche (high zone) is smaller than its fundamental niche. B is restricted to the lower zone by factors other than A (for example it cannot survive drying out), so its realized and fundamental niches are the same on the shore.

  5. Mean growth with a treatment is \(8.1 \pm 0.4\) (SE) and with the control \(6.9 \pm 0.3\). Decide whether the means differ significantly, using 2 SE.
    Show answer

    Treatment: \(8.1 \pm 0.8\) = 7.3 to 8.9. Control: \(6.9 \pm 0.6\) = 6.3 to 7.5. They overlap (7.3 to 7.5), so the difference is not clearly significant by this criterion.

  6. Explain why a harmless butterfly with the wing pattern of a bad-tasting species gains an advantage, and name the type of mimicry.
    Show answer

    Predators have learned that the bad-tasting species is unpleasant and avoid anything with that pattern, so the harmless mimic is eaten less and leaves more offspring. This is Batesian mimicry. The advantage declines if the mimics become more common than the model, because predators then more often find a harmless one.

Lesson 8.6 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.6

Biodiversity and the resilience of ecosystems

In the 1960s, the ecologist Robert Paine pulled the sea star Pisaster off a stretch of rocky shore in Washington State, once a month, and watched. The sea star was not especially common, and it was one of 15 species that lived on the rocks. Within a year the mussels, which the sea star had been eating, spread over the rock and crowded out almost everything else. After a few years only 8 species were left. A single species that makes up a small part of the community had held the whole community together. This lesson asks why some ecosystems are stable and others collapse, what makes a species important out of proportion to its numbers, and how a community recovers after a disturbance.

Learning objective · 8.6.A

Describe the relationship between ecosystem diversity and its resilience to changes in the environment.

Required content · EK 8.6.A.1 and 8.6.A.2

Natural and artificial ecosystems with fewer component parts, and with little diversity among the parts, are often less resilient to changes in the environment.

Keystone species, producers, and essential abiotic and biotic factors contribute to maintaining the diversity of an ecosystem.

Biodiversity: three levels

Biodiversity is the variety of life at three levels. Genetic diversity is the variation in alleles within a species (lesson 7.7). Species diversity is the number and the relative abundance of species in a community (lesson 8.5). Ecosystem diversity is the variety of habitats and ecosystems in a region. A diverse ecosystem is resilient: it resists change in a disturbance and recovers quickly afterward. An ecosystem with few species and little genetic variation, which can be a natural one (an arctic tundra or a salt flat) or an artificial one (a field of wheat), is more fragile. There are several reasons.

  • Redundancy. In a diverse community several species do the same job (several kinds of producers, several pollinators, many decomposers). If one is lost, others can take over its role in the energy flow and the cycling of nutrients, so the function of the ecosystem continues.
  • Response diversity. Species that do the same job respond differently to a drought, a frost, or a disease. Some always survive, so the total productivity of a diverse grassland varies less from year to year than that of a grassland with one or two species. Experiments in prairie plots (David Tilman’s work in Minnesota) found that plots with more species had greater and more stable productivity and recovered better from drought.
  • Weblike food webs. A predator in a diverse web can switch to another prey if its main prey declines. In a simple food chain that has one food source, the loss of one organism breaks the chain.
  • Resistance to invasion and disease. A diverse community has fewer unused resources for an invader, and a pathogen that specializes in one host species spreads slowly if the host is mixed with others.
Worked example · Why the monoculture is less resilient

A farm grows 1,000 acres of one wheat variety. Another farm grows five varieties in equal proportions on 200 acres each. A new fungus infects 100% of the variety A, and none of the other varieties. Compare the effect on the two farms, and relate it to EK 8.6.A.1.

Farm 1. All 1,000 acres are variety A, so the whole crop (100%) is affected.
Farm 2. Only variety A is infected: \(200/1{,}000 = 20\%\) of the crop. The other 80% is not damaged.
Relation. The ecosystem with fewer components and less diversity among them (an artificial monoculture) is less resilient to the change, here a disease. Genetic diversity gives response diversity: some varieties are resistant, and they keep the system producing. It is the same principle as in the Irish potato famine and the 1970 corn blight (lessons 7.3 and 7.7).
Reasoning. Diversity acts like insurance: it costs something (a mixed farm is more complicated to manage), but it reduces the risk.

Keystone species and trophic cascades

050100100Sea otters2090Sea urchins8510Kelp forestotters presentotters removedRelative abundance
Figure 8.6c A trophic cascade started by a keystone species (illustrative values). Sea otters eat sea urchins; when they are removed, the urchins increase and graze the kelp forest down to bare rock (an “urchin barren”), and the many species that depend on the kelp decrease.
Learning objective · 8.6.B

Explain how the addition or removal of any component of an ecosystem will affect its overall short-term and long-term structure.

Required content · EK 8.6.B.1

The effects of keystone species on the ecosystem are disproportionate relative to their abundance in the ecosystem. When they are removed from the ecosystem, it often collapses.

A keystone species is a species that has a much greater effect on its community than its abundance or biomass would suggest. Like the keystone at the top of an arch, it is a small part that holds the structure together. It is often a predator, but it can also be an engineer, a pollinator, or a mutualist.

  • Sea star (Pisaster ochraceus). It feeds on mussels that would otherwise take over the rocks. With the sea star present, space is available for algae, barnacles, and limpets, and the community has about 15 species. When Paine removed the sea star, the mussels monopolized the space and the number of species fell to about 8.
  • Sea otter. On the Pacific coast, otters eat sea urchins. Where otters were hunted almost to extinction, the urchins multiplied and grazed the kelp forests down to bare rock, called an urchin barren, and the fish and invertebrates that depended on the kelp disappeared. When otters were protected and returned, the kelp recovered.
  • Gray wolf in Yellowstone. Wolves were removed by 1926 and reintroduced in 1995. After their return, elk numbers and behavior changed, willows and aspen along streams regrew in some areas, and beavers and songbirds increased, although scientists continue to debate how large each part of the effect was.
  • Others: beavers (they change the water flow and create wetlands), fig trees in tropical forests (fruit available when others have none), and the prairie dog.

The sea otter story is a trophic cascade: a change at one trophic level has indirect effects on others, in alternate directions. Otters (top predator) reduce urchins (herbivore), so the kelp (producer) increases: \(+\) for otters, \(-\) for urchins, \(+\) for kelp. Remove the top predator and the signs are reversed. A cascade is a good example of the way that the removal of a single component changes both the short-term numbers (urchin numbers increase within a few years) and the long-term structure (a different, less diverse community).

Worked example · Predicting the effects of a removal

In a lake, a large predatory fish eats smaller fish that feed on zooplankton, and the zooplankton feed on algae. A disease kills most of the large predator. Predict the effects on each level, and say whether the predator is a keystone species.

Predator. Decreases (the disease).
Small fish. Increase, since there is less predation.
Zooplankton. Decrease, since more small fish are eating them.
Algae. Increase, since less grazing by zooplankton. The lake may turn green, and the nutrients and oxygen may change (lesson 8.7).
Keystone? If the change in the lake is much larger than the predator’s share of the biomass would predict, which is the case here, then it is a keystone species.
Reasoning. Alternating signs at successive levels are the signature of a trophic cascade.

Producers and essential abiotic factors maintain diversity in a similar way. The producers are the base of the energy flow, and a loss of them has an effect on all levels (lesson 8.2). Foundation species such as corals, kelp, and trees create habitat for others, and abiotic factors such as water, temperature, and nutrients set the limits for all the organisms.

Disturbance and succession

Bare rockafter glacieror lava flowPioneerslichens, mossesHerbs, grassessoil formsShrubsmore shadePine forestsun-lovingHardwood forestshade-tolerantHeight and complexity of the community increaseSoil depth, organic matter, and biodiversity increase over time (decades to centuries)
Figure 8.6b Primary succession begins on bare rock with no soil; the pioneer species make the first soil, and each stage changes the environment so that the next can grow. Secondary succession starts from soil that is already present (after a fire or a farm is abandoned) and is faster.

A community changes over time, which the CED describes by saying that communities “change over time based on the interactions between those populations”. Ecological succession is the gradual change in the species of a community after a disturbance. Primary succession begins in a place with no soil and no life, such as bare rock after a glacier retreats, a new volcanic island, or a sand dune. Pioneer species such as lichens and mosses colonize the rock, and as they die and decay and break the rock, they form the first thin soil. Then grasses and herbs come, then shrubs, and then trees. Secondary succession begins where a community was destroyed but the soil is still there, for example after a forest fire, a flood, or the abandonment of a farm. It is faster (decades instead of centuries), because the soil already contains seeds, roots, and nutrients.

Succession is driven by the species themselves: early species change the environment (more soil, shade, nutrients) in a way that makes it better for later ones, and the later species, which are tolerant of shade and competition, replace them. Early communities have species that are r-selected (lesson 8.4), and later ones K-selected. The final stage, which is relatively stable, is often called the climax community, but many ecologists note that disturbances such as fire and storms are common, so most communities are in a mosaic of stages. A moderate disturbance can increase species diversity (the intermediate disturbance hypothesis) because it opens space for the species that are early in the succession without destroying the later ones.

The size of an area and its isolation also affect diversity. On islands (and in isolated habitats such as mountaintops), larger islands have more species than small ones, since they have more habitats and larger populations that are less likely to go extinct, and islands that are closer to the mainland have more species than distant ones because they are reached more often by colonists (island biogeography). It is also the reason that the fragmentation of a habitat into small patches, which act like islands, causes a loss of species.

Exam focus
  • Diversity increases resilience: redundancy, response diversity, flexible food webs. Ecosystems with few components (monocultures) are less resilient to change.
  • Keystone species have a disproportionate effect compared with their abundance; their removal often causes a collapse or a large loss of diversity (sea star, sea otter, wolf).
  • Trophic cascade: the effects alternate in sign from one level to the next (predator \(\downarrow\), herbivore \(\uparrow\), producer \(\downarrow\)). Always say the direction of change at every level.
  • Primary succession (no soil; pioneers, centuries) against secondary (soil remains; faster).
  • Predicting the effect of removal or addition: give the short-term and the long-term effect.
  • Larger and less isolated habitats have more species (island biogeography).
Practice
  1. Explain why a rain forest is usually more resilient to the loss of one species than a field of corn.
    Show answer

    The forest has many species, and several fill similar roles, so if one is lost others can maintain the energy flow and nutrient cycles. It also contains genetic diversity, so some individuals are likely to survive a disturbance such as a disease. The cornfield has one species of plant of very little genetic diversity, so one pathogen or one weather event can affect all the plants, and it also requires inputs from people to be maintained.

  2. What is a keystone species, and why is a species that is rare not necessarily a keystone?
    Show answer

    A keystone species has an effect on the structure and diversity of the community that is much greater than its abundance. Being rare is not the criterion: many rare species have little effect. The test is what happens when the species is removed, a large change (a loss of species or a collapse) in the community as in the sea star example.

  3. Wolves are removed from a region. Predict the changes in the populations of deer and of the shrubs they browse, and the long-term consequence for songbirds that nest in the shrubs.
    Show answer

    Deer increase because there is less predation. The shrubs decrease because of heavier browsing. In the long term, the loss of shrubs removes the nesting habitat and food of the songbirds, so their populations decline, and the structure of the plant community changes (a trophic cascade).

  4. Compare primary and secondary succession, and say why secondary succession is faster.
    Show answer

    Primary succession starts on a surface with no soil (bare rock, new lava), so pioneer species first have to form soil, which takes centuries. Secondary succession starts after a disturbance that leaves the soil in place, with its nutrients, seeds, and roots, so the plants can regrow much sooner, in decades.

  5. Two grasslands have the same total biomass. Grassland A has 20 species, and B has 2. A drought kills 80% of the biomass of the most common species in each. Predict which recovers its productivity sooner and explain.
    Show answer

    Grassland A is likely to recover sooner. With 20 species, some will be tolerant of drought and increase in the space left by the damaged species (response diversity and redundancy), so total productivity is partly maintained. Grassland B has fewer species to take over, so the loss of the main species reduces productivity more and for longer.

  6. A new island 200 km from the mainland and a similar island 5 km from it are the same size. Predict which has more species after several centuries and why.
    Show answer

    The island 5 km from the mainland. Colonists reach a near island more often, so it gains species more quickly and the extinct species are replaced (the rescue effect), and it reaches a higher equilibrium number of species than the distant island of the same size.

Lesson 8.7 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.7

Disruptions to ecosystems: invasive species, pollution, and change

In the late 1940s, a cargo ship or military aircraft carried a few brown tree snakes from the South Pacific to the island of Guam, where there were no snakes that ate birds. Within 40 years, most of the native forest birds of the island were gone, and the snake had reached densities of thousands per square mile. A different disruption took place in the Gulf of Mexico: every summer, fertilizer from farms in the Mississippi basin creates a dead zone the size of a small state. Ecosystems are always changing, but some changes, in speed or in scale, are beyond what the organisms can adapt to. This last lesson of the unit brings together evolution, energy flow, cycles, and populations to ask what happens when an ecosystem is disrupted, by living organisms, by human activity, or by geology and weather.

Learning objective · 8.7.A

Explain the interaction between the environment and random or preexisting variations in populations.

Required content · EK 8.7.A.1 to 8.7.A.3

An adaptation is a genetic variation that is favored by selection and manifests as a trait that provides an advantage to an organism in a particular environment.

Heterozygote advantage is when the heterozygous genotype has a higher relative fitness than either the homozygous dominant or homozygous recessive genotype.

Mutations are not directed by specific environmental pressures.

How populations respond to environmental change

When the environment changes, a population has three possible outcomes: it can adapt by natural selection, it can move (migrate) to a place that still suits it, or it can decline and go extinct. Adaptation depends on whether the variation that is needed already exists in the population (lesson 7.7), since new mutations are rare and slow.

  • Adaptation. An adaptation is a heritable variation that is favored by selection and appears as a trait that gives an advantage in a particular environment (lesson 7.1). The same trait can be neutral or harmful elsewhere.
  • Mutations are not directed. Mutations occur at random with respect to their usefulness. The environment does not cause the mutation that is needed, but selects among variants that are already there. In the Luria-Delbrück experiment of 1943 and in later replica-plating experiments, bacteria that were resistant to a virus or an antibiotic were present in cultures that had never been exposed to it. So a drug or a pollutant selects, it does not “make” resistance.
  • Heterozygote advantage. Sometimes the heterozygote is the fittest genotype, which keeps both alleles in the population (a balanced polymorphism). The classic example is the sickle cell allele in regions with malaria.
Worked example · Heterozygote advantage

In a region with malaria, the relative fitness of \(\text{Hb}^\text{A}\text{Hb}^\text{A}\) (normal; susceptible to malaria) is 0.90, of \(\text{Hb}^\text{A}\text{Hb}^\text{S}\) (carrier; resistant to malaria, no anemia) is 1.00, and of \(\text{Hb}^\text{S}\text{Hb}^\text{S}\) (sickle cell disease) is 0.20. (a) Calculate the selection coefficients. (b) Explain why neither allele disappears. (c) The frequency of \(\text{Hb}^\text{S}\) at equilibrium is \(q = s_{AA}/(s_{AA} + s_{SS})\): calculate it.

(a) \(s = 1 - w\): \(s_{AA} = 0.10\), \(s_{AS} = 0\), \(s_{SS} = 0.80\).
(b) Selection against \(AA\) (malaria) favors the \(S\) allele, since each \(S\) copy is mostly in carriers, who do well. But when \(S\) becomes more common, more people are \(SS\), who have a low fitness, and this selects against \(S\). The two opposite pressures balance, so both alleles are maintained.
(c) \(q = 0.10/(0.10 + 0.80) = 0.10/0.90 = 0.11\). About 11% of the alleles are \(S\), and with Hardy-Weinberg (lesson 7.5) about \(2pq = 2 \times 0.89 \times 0.11 = 0.20\), or 20% of the people, would be carriers and \(q^2 = 1.2\%\) would have the disease, which is similar to the frequencies that are found in parts of West Africa.
Reasoning. If malaria is eliminated, \(s_{AA}\) falls to 0, and the equilibrium frequency of \(S\) falls toward 0.

Invasive species

Learning objective · 8.7.B

Explain how invasive species affect ecosystem dynamics.

Required content · EK 8.7.B.1

The intentional or unintentional introduction of an invasive species can allow the species to exploit a new niche free of predators or competitors or to outcompete native species for resources.

An invasive species is a non-native species that is introduced to a new area, by people on purpose or by accident, and that spreads and harms the ecosystem, the economy, or health. Most introduced species do not become invasive, but those that do can be very damaging. They succeed because they have escaped the controls that held their numbers down at home: predators, parasites, diseases, and competitors that evolved together with them. They can use a new niche that no native species fills, or they outcompete natives because they grow and breed faster (they are often r-selected). Native species may have no defenses against a new kind of predator or disease.

  • Kudzu, a vine from Japan introduced to the American South to control erosion, smothers trees and other plants.
  • Zebra mussels came in the ballast water of ships to the Great Lakes in the 1980s. They filter out the algae that native species feed on and clog water pipes.
  • Brown tree snake on Guam: it lacked predators and found birds that had evolved without snakes. It removed most of the native forest birds, and the loss of the birds affected the pollination and the spread of seeds.
  • Cane toads in Australia, which were brought to control beetles, poison predators that eat them. Burmese pythons in Florida have been followed by a large fall in the numbers of marsh rabbits and raccoons.

The effects spread through the food web and the cycles. A population of an invader can show exponential growth (lesson 8.4) in the beginning, with no limiting factors, and the effects on the native species are those of competition and predation (lesson 8.5), with possible loss of biodiversity and of resilience (lesson 8.6).

Human activities that change ecosystems

Learning objective · 8.7.C

Describe human activities that lead to changes in ecosystem structure and dynamics.

Required content · EK 8.7.C.1

Human impact accelerates changes at local and global levels. These activities can drive changes in ecosystems, such as the following, that cause extinctions to occur:

  1. Biomagnification
  2. Eutrophication

Human activities are now a major cause of the loss of species, and they work through a small number of mechanisms: habitat destruction and fragmentation (the most important), overharvesting, invasive species, pollution, and climate change. The CED highlights two forms of pollution.

Biomagnification

0.0000010.00010.011100Water0.000003 ppmPlankton0.04 ppmSmall fish0.5 ppmLarge fish2 ppmFish-eating bird25 ppmDDT concentration (ppm, log scale)
Figure 8.7a Biomagnification of a persistent pesticide (illustrative values). The concentration increases at every trophic level because DDT is stored in fat and is not excreted, so a predator accumulates the DDT of all of the prey it eats. The log scale hides the size of the increase: the bird has 8 million times the concentration of the water.

Some pollutants, such as the pesticide DDT, the industrial chemicals called PCBs, and mercury, are persistent (they are not broken down), and fat-soluble or bind to proteins, so they are stored in the bodies of organisms and are not excreted. When an organism eats many individuals from the level below, it accumulates all of the pollutant that was in its prey. As a result the concentration increases at each higher trophic level: this is biomagnification. Because only about 10% of the energy goes up each level (lesson 8.2), a predator has to eat a large mass of prey, and the pollutant is concentrated in a smaller mass of its own tissue. The top predators therefore have the highest concentrations.

Worked example · Magnification factors

In a food chain, the concentration of DDT is 0.000003 ppm in the water, 0.04 ppm in plankton, 0.5 ppm in small fish, 2 ppm in large fish, and 25 ppm in a fish-eating bird. Calculate the increase between levels and the overall increase, and explain the effect on the bird.

Between levels. Water to plankton: \(0.04/0.000003 = 13{,}333\) times. Plankton to small fish: \(0.5/0.04 = 12.5\) times. Small fish to large fish: \(2/0.5 = 4\) times. Large fish to bird: \(25/2 = 12.5\) times.
Overall. \(25/0.000003 = 8.3 \times 10^6\), or about 8 million times the concentration in the water.
Effect on the bird. In the 1950s and 1960s, DDT and its breakdown product DDE caused birds of prey such as bald eagles, peregrine falcons, and brown pelicans to lay eggs with thin shells that broke, and populations crashed. DDT was banned in the United States in 1972, and the populations recovered.
Reasoning. A concentration of the pollutant in water that is far too low to harm an animal directly can still harm a top predator, and it is the reason that the amounts of mercury in large fish such as swordfish and tuna are of concern.

Do not confuse bioaccumulation (the build-up of a substance in a single organism over its lifetime) with biomagnification (an increase in concentration from one trophic level to the next).

Eutrophication

Nutrient runofffertilizer,sewage1Algal bloomproducersgrow fast2Light blockedplants belowdie3Decompositionbacteria feedon dead algae4Hypoxiaoxygen usedup at depth5Fish killdead zone,less diversity6positive feedback in the lake: less oxygen, more release of phosphate from the sediment
Figure 8.7b Eutrophication. Excess nutrients cause a bloom of algae; when the algae die, decomposers use up the dissolved oxygen, and animals that need oxygen die. The result is a dead zone, such as the one in the Gulf of Mexico at the mouth of the Mississippi.

Eutrophication is the enrichment of a water body by nutrients, mostly nitrate and phosphate, from fertilizers, sewage, and animal waste. Nutrients that are limiting for the producers (lessons 8.2 and 8.3) cause a bloom of algae and cyanobacteria. The dense surface layer blocks the light, so the plants below die. When the algae die, the decomposers that feed on them use dissolved oxygen in their respiration, and the water becomes hypoxic (low in oxygen). Fish, crabs, and other animals that need oxygen die or leave, which creates a dead zone. Some cyanobacteria release toxins. The loss of the oxygen can also release more phosphate from the sediments, which is a positive feedback.

Worked example · Evaluating a hypothesis about eutrophication (skill 5.D)

A lake is divided by a plastic curtain into two basins. Phosphorus is added to basin 1 each week, and basin 2 is left as the control. After 8 weeks, the mean concentration of chlorophyll (a measure of algae) is 24 µg/L in basin 1 and 3 µg/L in basin 2, and the error bars (95% intervals) are much smaller than the difference. State the hypothesis, and decide whether the data support it.

Hypothesis. Phosphorus is the nutrient that limits algal growth in this lake, so adding it increases the algae. Null hypothesis: adding phosphorus has no effect on chlorophyll.
Data. Basin 1 has \(24/3 = 8\) times the chlorophyll of the control, and the intervals do not overlap (lesson 8.5), so the difference is statistically significant.
Conclusion. Reject the null hypothesis: the data support the hypothesis that phosphorus limits growth. A further prediction is that the oxygen concentration would later fall in the deep water of basin 1 as the algae die and decompose. (This design was used by David Schindler in the 1970s, and it led to a ban on phosphates in detergents in Canada and the United States.)
Reasoning. The curtain and the control basin make sure that only the nutrient differs between the two groups.

Climate change and carbon dioxide

Annual means, 1958 to 20233003403804201960198020002020Monthly, 2021 to 2023412416421426202120222023May peakOct lowCO₂ (ppm)
Figure 8.7c Atmospheric CO₂ measured at Mauna Loa (smoothed values). The long-term rise follows the burning of fossil fuels; the annual oscillation is caused by the seasonal photosynthesis of the Northern Hemisphere: CO₂ falls in summer when plants are growing and rises in winter.

The burning of fossil fuels and the clearing of forests have raised the concentration of CO2 (lesson 8.3), which is a greenhouse gas: it absorbs infrared radiation and warms the lower atmosphere. The record that Charles Keeling began at Mauna Loa in 1958 shows two patterns. The long-term trend is a rise from about 315 ppm in 1958 to about 420 ppm in 2023, an increase of \((420 - 315)/315 = 33\%\), and the rate of increase has become faster. The annual oscillation of about 6 ppm from peak to trough is caused by the seasons in the Northern Hemisphere, which has most of the land and vegetation: CO2 is lowest in autumn after the summer growth of plants has taken the CO2 from the air, and highest in spring (May) after the winter, when respiration and decomposition have exceeded photosynthesis. The year-to-year growth is that of human emissions.

The effects on ecosystems include a change in the ranges of species (to higher latitudes and altitudes), a change in the timing of events such as flowering, migration, and the hatching of insects, which can separate predators from their prey and plants from their pollinators, and ocean acidification: the ocean absorbs CO2, which forms carbonic acid, lowering the pH and the amount of carbonate that corals, mollusks, and plankton need to build their shells (the buffer chemistry of lesson 1.1). Melting ice and warmer water also change habitats.

Geological and meteorological events

Learning objective · 8.7.D

Explain how geological and meteorological activity leads to changes in ecosystem structure and dynamics.

Required content · EK 8.7.D.1

Geological and meteorological events affect habitat change and ecosystem distribution. Biogeographical studies illustrate these changes.

Not all the disruptions are caused by people. Volcanic eruptions (the 1980 eruption of Mount St. Helens covered the area in ash, and the return of life from the survivors and from the edges is one of the best-studied cases of succession, lesson 8.6), earthquakes and landslides, floods, hurricanes, droughts, and wildfires are disturbances that change habitats and the distribution of organisms. El Niño, a periodic warming of the Pacific Ocean, changes rainfall and the upwelling of nutrients, which affects fish, seabirds, and the coastal communities. Over long periods, continental drift (the motion of tectonic plates), the rise of mountains, and the advance and retreat of ice sheets have changed the climate and the connection between regions. Biogeography, the study of where species live and why, uses this information: marsupials are concentrated in Australia because the continent separated before the placental mammals spread there, and the species that live in the same band of latitude on different continents are the result of the movement of the plates and the climate (lesson 7.6).

Exam focus
  • Populations adapt (if variation exists), move, or go extinct. Mutations are not directed: the environment selects, it does not cause the variation.
  • Heterozygote advantage: heterozygote fitness is higher than that of both homozygotes, which keeps both alleles (sickle cell and malaria).
  • Invasive species: escape from predators, parasites, and competitors; use a new niche or outcompete natives; lose biodiversity.
  • Biomagnification: concentration of a persistent, fat-soluble pollutant increases at each higher trophic level (top predators are hit hardest). Eutrophication: nutrient runoff \(\rightarrow\) algal bloom \(\rightarrow\) death and decomposition \(\rightarrow\) low oxygen \(\rightarrow\) dead zone.
  • CO2 graph: long-term rise (fossil fuels, deforestation) and annual cycle (seasonal photosynthesis in the Northern Hemisphere).
  • Geological and meteorological events (eruptions, floods, El Niño, plate motion, ice ages) change habitats; biogeography illustrates the changes.
  • Hypothesis testing: state the null hypothesis, compare with the control, and reject or fail to reject.
Practice
  1. A student writes: “When the lake got polluted, the fish mutated to tolerate the pollution.” Correct the statement.
    Show answer

    Mutations are random and are not caused by the need to survive. Some fish already carried alleles that allowed tolerance of the pollutant, or such alleles arose by chance. The pollution acted as a selective pressure: fish without the alleles died or left fewer offspring, so the alleles became more frequent in the population over generations.

  2. Give two characteristics of an invasive species that make it successful, and one effect on a native species.
    Show answer

    Examples: the absence of predators, parasites, and diseases from its original habitat; rapid growth and reproduction; the ability to use a niche that is not used by native species. Effect: native species may be outcompeted for food or space, eaten (if they have no defenses), or may be infected by a disease that the invader carries, so their numbers fall.

  3. A pesticide has a concentration of 0.002 ppm in algae, 0.03 ppm in zooplankton, 0.4 ppm in minnows, and 5 ppm in a trout. Calculate the magnification from algae to trout and explain why the top fish is most at risk.
    Show answer

    \(5/0.002 = 2{,}500\) times. The pesticide is persistent and stored in fat, so each consumer accumulates the amount that is in all the prey it eats, and the concentration increases at each trophic level. The trout, at the top, has the highest concentration, and so the most risk (and so do the animals and people that eat it).

  4. Place in order: decomposition by bacteria, algal bloom, fish die, nutrient runoff, dissolved oxygen falls, dead algae sink.
    Show answer

    Nutrient runoff, algal bloom, dead algae sink, decomposition by bacteria, dissolved oxygen falls, fish die.

  5. In a graph of atmospheric CO2, explain why the concentration falls each summer in the Northern Hemisphere even though the long-term trend is up.
    Show answer

    In summer the large area of land vegetation of the Northern Hemisphere has maximum photosynthesis, which takes CO2 out of the air faster than respiration and decomposition return it. In winter, photosynthesis falls and respiration and decomposition continue, so CO2 rises. The long-term increase is caused by the human emissions, which are larger than the seasonal change from year to year.

  6. For a trait that is controlled by one gene, a heterozygote has a fitness of 1.0, and the homozygotes have 0.7 and 0.8. Predict what happens to the two alleles over time and name the situation.
    Show answer

    Neither allele is lost. Selection favors the heterozygote, so both alleles are kept in the population at an intermediate frequency (a balanced polymorphism), although each homozygote has a lower fitness. This is heterozygote advantage.

Unit 8 quiz · 15 multiple-choice · 5 free-response

Unit 8 quiz: Ecology

Fifteen multiple-choice items and five short free-response questions across all seven lessons (responses to the environment, energy flow, matter cycles, population growth models, community interactions, biodiversity and succession, and ecosystem disruption), so click an option to see why each answer is right or wrong, then write each FRQ in ten minutes before you open the model.

Multiple choice

  1. Data: a two-chamber choice test. Ninety terrestrial isopods were released at the junction of a chamber whose two halves were identical in temperature and humidity but differed in light. Counts were taken after 10 minutes.

    Chamber halfDarkLit
    Isopods observed6327
    Expected if light has no effect4545

    The critical value of \(\chi^2\) at df = 1 and p = 0.05 is 3.841.

    Which statement correctly reports the chi-square analysis and its conclusion?

    Correct. \(\chi^2 = (63-45)^2/45 + (27-45)^2/45 = 7.2 + 7.2 = 14.4\), and since 14.4 is larger than the critical value the deviation is too big to attribute to chance. "Reject the null hypothesis" is the required wording: the null is the 45:45 split, not the claim that light matters.

    The statistic is right and so is the decision, but the explanation attached to it is not something a chi-square test can deliver. The test says the observed split is unlikely under a random distribution; it says nothing about humidity, and no statistical test ever "proves" a mechanism.

    7.2 is only the first term. Chi-square sums \((o-e)^2/e\) over every category, so both the dark and the lit halves contribute, and dropping one halves the statistic. Here it happens not to change the decision, but on borderline data it would.

    17.1 comes from dividing each squared difference by the observed count, \(324/63 + 324/27\), rather than by the expected count. The denominator in \(\chi^2\) is always the expected value, because that is what sets the scale of the deviation you would tolerate by chance.

  2. A beetle larva moves in long straight runs across dry sand and in short, frequently reversing paths across damp sand, so that over an hour most of the larvae end up on the damp side of a tray. In a separate experiment, a male moth flies steadily upwind along a plume of female pheromone until it reaches the source. Which classification of the two responses is correct?

    Where the animals end up is the outcome, not the test. Kinesis produces a non-random final distribution without any steering at all (the larvae simply move less on damp sand, so they accumulate there), so a sensible endpoint cannot distinguish the two categories.

    Correct. The damp sand changes the larva's speed and turning rate but not the direction it faces, which is kinesis; the moth orients its body relative to the plume and holds a heading, which is taxis. The single question to ask is whether the stimulus sets the animal's heading.

    This reverses both. The larva never orients to the moisture gradient, and the moth's flight is directed by definition: it tracks a plume upwind rather than wandering until it happens to arrive.

    Kinesis and taxis are distinguished by whether movement is directed, not by which sense organ or stimulus type is involved. A chemical gradient can drive either one: chemotaxis in the moth here, and a chemically triggered kinesis in other species.

  3. Data: energy measured at four trophic levels of a salt-marsh food chain over one year, in kJ per square meter per year.

    Trophic levelProducersPrimary consumersSecondary consumersTertiary consumers
    Energy [kJ/(m²·yr)]15,0001,80015012

    Which statement is best supported by these measurements?

    Correct. The three transfer efficiencies are \(1800/15000 = 12.0\%\), \(150/1800 = 8.3\%\), and \(12/150 = 8.0\%\), so the first is the largest. Real ecosystems scatter around 10% rather than hitting it exactly, which is why the exam wants the ratio computed rather than assumed.

    Less energy is lost there in absolute terms (138 kJ against 13,200 kJ at the first step), but efficiency is a proportion, not a difference. As a proportion the last step is the worst of the three at 8.0%, and comparing raw losses across levels of wildly different size is the trap here.

    The 10% rule is a rough average, not a law that data must obey, and these data do not obey it: 12.0%, 8.3%, and 8.0%. Use it to estimate when you are given nothing else, but when you are handed numbers, divide.

    The arithmetic is off by a factor of ten: \(12/15000 = 0.0008 = 0.08\%\), not 0.8%. The point the number makes is still worth holding on to: a top predator here lives on eight parts in ten thousand of what the marsh grass stored.

  4. A forest plot's producers fix 4,200 g/(m²·yr) of carbon, and those producers respire 1,900 g/(m²·yr) of it in their own cellular respiration. Which quantity is available to the plot's primary consumers, and why?

    4,200 is gross primary productivity, the total fixed. A large share of it is spent immediately by the plants themselves keeping their own cells alive, and a consumer cannot eat energy that has already left as heat.

    Correct. \(\mathrm{NPP} = \mathrm{GPP} - R = 4200 - 1900 = 2300\) g/(m²·yr), which is 54.8% of GPP. NPP is the only part stored in leaves, stems, and roots, and it is therefore the only part that can move to the next trophic level.

    Producer respiration removes energy from the ecosystem as heat; it is the term you subtract, not the term consumers receive. Consumers run their own respiration on the biomass they eat, but the plants' respiration is gone before any herbivore arrives.

    Adding respiration to GPP double-counts, and it moves in the wrong direction as well: respiration is a loss. The equation has a minus sign for exactly this reason, and 6,100 exceeds the total the plot ever captured.

  5. In open-ocean plankton communities the standing biomass of phytoplankton at any moment is often smaller than the standing biomass of the zooplankton feeding on them, so a pyramid of biomass drawn for a single instant is inverted. Which statement explains how this is possible when a pyramid of energy can never be inverted?

    Zooplankton are heterotrophs and fix no carbon from light. Even if some did, the explanation the question asks for concerns the difference between a standing stock measured at one moment and a flow measured over time.

    Correct. A biomass pyramid is a snapshot; an energy pyramid is a rate. Phytoplankton turn over every few days, so the annual production passing through that thin standing crop is enormous, and the energy reaching the zooplankton is still far less than the producers fixed.

    Transfer efficiency near 10% is observed in aquatic systems too: it follows from respiration, unconsumed tissue, and undigested material, none of which are peculiar to land. The inverted biomass pyramid is about turnover time, not about a suspended rule.

    Decomposers recycle matter, returning nitrogen and phosphorus to the water, but the energy in dead material leaves as heat when they respire it. Energy flows through an ecosystem once and never returns to a higher level.

  6. Figure: population size \(N\) of a yeast culture plotted against time in hours.

    The curve starts at \(N = 60\) and rises slowly for the first few hours, then climbs steeply, reaching its steepest slope as it passes \(N = 3{,}000\) near hour 14. After that the slope eases and the curve bends over, approaching a dashed horizontal line drawn at \(N = 6{,}000\) without crossing it. The culture's maximum per-capita growth rate is \(r_{\max} = 0.4\ \mathrm{hr^{-1}}\).

    Applying the logistic model \(dN/dt = r_{\max}N(K-N)/K\) to this culture, which statement is correct?

    Correct. \(K = 6000\) is read off the dashed asymptote, and \(dN/dt = 0.4(3000)(6000-3000)/6000 = 1200(0.50) = 600\) cells/hr. Logistic growth always peaks at \(K/2\), where the product of population size and unused capacity is largest, which is exactly where the drawn curve is steepest.

    At \(N = 5900\) the population is large but the unused fraction \((K-N)/K = 100/6000 = 0.0167\) is nearly gone, so \(dN/dt = 0.4(5900)(0.0167) = 39\) cells/hr. Growth is the product of two terms, and near \(K\) the second one collapses.

    Per-capita rate and whole-population rate are different quantities. The per-capita rate \(r_{\max}(K-N)/K\) is greatest when \(N\) is smallest: near 60 cells it is almost the full 0.4 hr⁻¹, while the number of new cells per hour peaks at \(K/2\).

    \(dN/dt = 0\) at \(N = K = 6000\), the dashed line the curve approaches, not at \(N = 3000\). Half the carrying capacity is where growth is fastest, which is the opposite of where it stops.

  7. A population of 4,000 voles records 560 births and 240 deaths over one year, with no immigration or emigration. Which pair of values correctly reports the per-capita growth rate and the population growth rate?

    Correct. \(b = 560/4000 = 0.14\ \mathrm{yr^{-1}}\), \(d = 240/4000 = 0.06\ \mathrm{yr^{-1}}\), so \(r = b - d = 0.08\ \mathrm{yr^{-1}}\) and \(dN/dt = rN = 0.08(4000) = 320\) voles per year. Check the units as a safeguard: \(r\) is per individual per year, \(dN/dt\) is whole animals per year.

    The two values are swapped. A per-capita rate cannot be measured in voles, and a population growth rate cannot be a pure reciprocal-time quantity: the units alone rule this out without any arithmetic.

    0.14 is the birth rate \(b\) alone, and 560 is the number of births alone. Deaths are part of the population's change and must be subtracted, or the herd appears to grow at nearly twice its true rate.

    Adding \(b\) and \(d\) instead of subtracting gives 0.20 and 800. Births add individuals and deaths remove them, so the two terms have opposite signs in \(r = b - d\).

  8. Two factors reduce a deer herd. An unusually hard freeze kills roughly 30% of the animals whether the herd numbers 200 or 2,000. A lungworm parasite kills a far larger fraction of the herd when animals are crowded than when they are sparse. Which classification is correct, and which factor sets the herd's carrying capacity?

    Correct. The freeze removes the same fraction regardless of crowding, which is the definition of density-independent. The parasite's effect intensifies with crowding, so it feeds back on the population and produces the leveling-off at \(K\): density-dependent factors are what \(K\) is made of.

    This reverses the definitions. The test is not how many animals die but whether the proportion killed depends on density, and the stem states explicitly that the freeze's 30% does not.

    Every mortality factor reduces numbers, so that cannot be the criterion. A density-independent event such as weather would cut the same fraction from a herd of 20 or 2,000, and it therefore cannot hold a population at any particular size.

    Range size influences \(K\), but it does not act on the population on its own: it acts through density-dependent competition for the food and space that the range contains. And the parasite is clearly density-dependent by the stem's own description.

  9. Data: two ciliate species reared in identical tubes on the same daily ration of bacteria, each grown alone and the two grown together. Values are mean density on day 20.

    Mean density on day 20 (individuals/mL)Species MSpecies N
    Grown alone320150
    Grown together29014

    Which conclusion is best supported, and what role do the single-species tubes play?

    Correct. Species N falls \((150-14)/150 = 90.7\%\) below its own carrying capacity in the shared tube while species M loses only \((320-290)/320 = 9.4\%\). The single-species tubes are what make the claim possible: they show N thrives alone on this ration, so its collapse can be attributed to M's presence.

    Both species decline when together, so the direction of the effect is not what distinguishes them: the magnitude is. A 9.4% reduction is the cost of sharing a resource; a 90.7% reduction heading toward zero is exclusion.

    Mutualism is a +/+ interaction in which both partners benefit. Here both species do worse together than alone, which is a −/− interaction: competition.

    The control rules this out rather than supporting it. Grown alone on the same ration, species N reached 150 individuals per milliliter, so the food supply by itself was clearly sufficient; only the presence of M changed the outcome.

  10. In a rocky intertidal community, a predatory sea star that makes up under 2% of the total animal biomass is removed from experimental plots. Within three years mussels cover nearly all the rock in those plots and species richness falls from 15 to 8, while adjacent untouched plots remain at 15 species. Which statement best describes the sea star's role and the evidence for it?

    Correct. A keystone species has an effect out of all proportion to its biomass, and the removal experiment with untouched controls is exactly what demonstrates it: richness dropped \((15-8)/15 = 46.7\%\) where the sea star was taken out and held steady where it was not. The mechanism is predation on the dominant space competitor, which keeps rock open for everyone else.

    A dominant species does shape a community through sheer abundance, but the stem rules that out, under 2% of biomass. That contrast between tiny biomass and huge effect is precisely what makes "keystone" the right word.

    Pioneer species are the first colonists of bare substrate in primary succession, such as lichens on new rock. The sea star is a top predator in an established community, and nothing here concerns colonization of new surfaces.

    An invasive species is introduced from elsewhere and causes harm as it spreads. This sea star is a native resident, and the experiment removes it rather than adding it.

  11. Cattle egrets follow grazing cattle and catch insects flushed from the grass by the cattle's movement. A study finds that egrets foraging beside cattle capture significantly more insects per hour than egrets foraging alone, while the cattle's feeding rate, weight gain, and tick loads are statistically unchanged whether egrets are present or absent. How should the interaction be classified?

    Mutualism requires a measurable benefit to both partners, and the study looked for one in the cattle (feeding rate, weight gain, and tick load), and found none. Assuming the cattle must gain something because the egrets are nearby is the error the data were collected to test.

    Correct. The egret benefits from a higher capture rate and the cattle are measurably unaffected, which is the +/0 pattern. Note how the classification rests on the measurements rather than on the appearance of the association.

    Parasitism requires harm to the host, and no cost to the cattle was detected on any of the three measures. The egrets take insects from the grass, not resources from the cattle.

    Competition is a −/− interaction between species using the same limiting resource. Cattle eat grass and egrets eat insects, so they are not competing for anything, and only one of the two is affected at all.

  12. Data: two quadrat surveys, each counting 100 individuals across four plant species.

    CommunitySpecies 1Species 2Species 3Species 4
    Community 140302010
    Community 270101010

    Using Simpson's index \(D = 1 - \sum (n/N)^2\), which comparison of the two communities is correct?

    Correct. Community 1: \(0.40^2 + 0.30^2 + 0.20^2 + 0.10^2 = 0.30\), so \(D = 0.70\). Community 2: \(0.70^2 + 3(0.10^2) = 0.52\), so \(D = 0.48\). Both hold four species, so richness is identical and only the spread of individuals among them differs.

    These are the \(\sum(n/N)^2\) values with the final subtraction left out, and leaving it out reverses the ranking. The sum alone is the probability that two individuals drawn at random are the same species, which runs opposite to diversity.

    Both communities contain exactly four species, so richness cannot be the difference. This is the situation the index exists for: a count of species alone would call these two communities identical.

    Equal richness and equal sample size do not make equal diversity. Two plants drawn at random differ 70% of the time in community 1 but only 48% of the time in community 2, which is 70% one species.

  13. A conservation agency must choose between two reserves of equal total area. Reserve P is one continuous 250 km² block lying 5 km from a large intact forest. Reserve Q is fifty separate 5 km² fragments scattered across farmland, the nearest of them 60 km from any intact forest. Island biogeography theory predicts that reserve P will support more species. Which pair of reasons supports that prediction?

    Correct. Richness settles where immigration and extinction balance. Large area means larger populations, which are less vulnerable to drift, disease, and bad years, so extinction is lower; nearness means more dispersing colonists arrive, so immigration is higher. P wins on both rates at once.

    Fifty small fragments have far more edge per unit area than one compact block, so the premise is backwards. Edge also tends to favor a few disturbance-tolerant and invasive species while interior specialists disappear, which is why fragmentation reduces richness.

    Fragmentation cuts gene flow rather than raising it, that is one of the harms listed for it, because small populations are separated by farmland they cannot cross. Gene flow between populations generally lowers extinction risk by adding variation.

    Small patches often do show more species per square kilometer, partly because they are almost all edge, but that does not settle total richness. The species-area relationship rises with area, and each isolated 5 km² fragment loses its large-bodied and interior species independently.

  14. Data: PCB concentration measured at four levels of a marine food chain, in parts per million of wet mass.

    OrganismPhytoplanktonZooplanktonHerringSeal
    PCB (ppm)0.0250.352.842

    Which statement correctly describes the pattern in the data and the mechanism that produces it?

    Correct. \(42/0.025 = 1680\), with step factors of \(0.35/0.025 = 14\), \(2.8/0.35 = 8\), and \(42/2.8 = 15\). The asymmetry is the whole mechanism: a seal must eat many kilograms of herring to build one kilogram of itself, the energy in the rest is lost as heat, and the fat-soluble PCB in all of it stays behind.

    The factor is right and the word is wrong. Bioaccumulation is the build-up of a toxin within one organism across its own lifetime; the rise between trophic levels shown here is biomagnification. Both happen, but the table measures the second.

    16.8 is off by a factor of one hundred: \(42/0.025 = 1680\). Check an order-of-magnitude estimate before committing: going from hundredths of a ppm to tens of ppm is four orders of magnitude of movement, not one.

    Energy does the opposite: roughly 90% of it is lost at each transfer, which is why the pyramid of energy narrows upward. The toxin concentrates precisely because the energy does not: the biomass shrinks while the contaminant it carried does not.

  15. Fertilizer runoff raises the nitrate and phosphate concentrations of a shallow coastal bay. Which sequence best describes how that produces a hypoxic dead zone in the deep water?

    Correct. The oxygen is consumed by decomposers working on the dead bloom, not by the algae themselves, and the loss is worst at the bottom where the dead cells settle and where no light supports photosynthesis. Every step in the chain is needed: nutrients, bloom, die-off, decomposition, oxygen demand, hypoxia.

    Photosynthesis releases oxygen; it does not consume it. A living bloom actually raises surface oxygen during the day, which is why the dead zone appears below the bloom and after it, once decomposers take over.

    Ocean acidification is real but it is driven by dissolved CO₂ forming carbonic acid, not by nitrate and phosphate, and it is a separate consequence of climate change. This option swaps one disruption for another.

    Fish populations do not rise during eutrophication: they collapse or flee. And fish respiration is a minor oxygen sink next to the bacterial decomposition of an entire bloom's worth of dead algae.

Free response

  1. Data: a student's investigation of nutrient enrichment. Thirty identical flasks were filled from the same pond and held at 22 °C under identical light. Six flasks received each of five nitrate concentrations. Algal density and dissolved oxygen at the bottom of each flask were measured after 14 days; values are treatment means.

    Nitrate added (mg/L)0251020
    Algal density (10³ cells/mL)1548120265280
    Dissolved O₂ at day 14 (mg/L)8.67.96.23.41.1

    Using the investigation and the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the dependent variables in this investigation, and describe the purpose of the 0 mg/L treatment.
    2. Explain how adding nitrate to a flask leads to the fall in dissolved oxygen measured at day 14.
    3. Calculate the percent decrease in dissolved oxygen between the 0 mg/L and the 20 mg/L treatments, showing your setup.
    4. Justify a claim about whether these results support the hypothesis that agricultural runoff causes hypoxic dead zones in coastal bays, using evidence from the data and naming one limitation of the investigation.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: algal density and dissolved oxygen concentration as the dependent variables, plus a description of the 0 mg/L flasks as the control: the baseline showing what the pond water does with no added nitrate, so any change in the other treatments can be attributed to the nitrate rather than to the flask, the light, or the temperature. Do not accept: nitrate concentration as a dependent variable (it is the independent variable); "the 0 mg/L flasks are the control" with no statement of what they establish; naming only one dependent variable when the table reports two.
    • (b) Accept: a mechanism traced through these flasks; added nitrate relieves the nutrient limit on algal growth, so algal density rises; the enlarged algal population dies and settles; decomposing bacteria multiply on the dead algae and consume oxygen in aerobic respiration faster than photosynthesis and diffusion replace it at the bottom of the flask, so dissolved oxygen falls. Do not accept: "the algae used up the oxygen" (photosynthesis releases oxygen; the decomposers consume it); "more nitrate means less oxygen" with no intervening steps; a correct textbook account of eutrophication that never refers to the flasks or the data.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \((8.6 - 1.1)/8.6 \times 100 = 7.5/8.6 \times 100 = 87.2\%\) decrease (accept 87% or 87.2%). The word "decrease" or a negative sign is required. Do not accept: 7.5 mg/L reported as a percentage; a percentage with no setup; dividing by 1.1 instead of by the initial value of 8.6.
    • (d) Accept: a claim with named evidence and a named limitation, the data support the hypothesis, because oxygen falls monotonically as nitrate rises (8.6 to 1.1 mg/L, an 87% drop) while every other condition was held constant across the six-flask treatments, which is a controlled dose-response; the limitation must be specific, such as a 250 mL flask not reproducing the mixing, depth, tides, or grazers of a bay, only 14 days of observation, or a single pond's community. Do not accept: a claim with no data cited; a limitation stated as "more research is needed" or "the sample was small" without saying why that matters here; naming the limitation but never stating a claim.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The dependent variables are algal density and dissolved oxygen, both measured at day 14. The 0 mg/L flasks are the control: they show what this pond water does over 14 days with no nitrate added, so changes in the other flasks can be blamed on the nitrate and not on the glassware, light, or temperature.

    b Nitrate was the nutrient limiting algal growth, so adding it let the algae divide until density climbed from 15 to 280 thousand cells per milliliter. Those extra algae die and sink, and decomposing bacteria grow on them and respire aerobically. At the bottom there is little light and little mixing, so the bacteria pull oxygen out faster than it is replaced and dissolved oxygen drops to 1.1 mg/L.

    c \((8.6 - 1.1)/8.6 = 7.5/8.6 = 0.872\), so an 87.2% decrease.

    d The data support the hypothesis: oxygen fell at every step up in nitrate, to an 87% loss at 20 mg/L, and with six replicates per treatment under identical light and temperature the nitrate is the only thing that differed. The limitation is scale: a still flask has no tides, depth, or grazers, so it cannot show whether mixing would keep a real bay's bottom water oxygenated.

  2. A temperate grassland has a net primary productivity of 32,000 kJ/(m²·yr). Grasshoppers eat the grasses, spiders eat the grasshoppers, and shrews eat the spiders. Assume the standard 10% transfer between trophic levels, and answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the trophic level occupied by the spiders, and describe the difference between gross primary productivity and net primary productivity.
    2. Explain why roughly 90% of the energy at one trophic level never becomes biomass at the next level in this grassland.
    3. Calculate the energy available each year to the shrews, showing your setup.
    4. Justify, using your calculation, the claim that this grassland could not support a fifth trophic level of predators that eat shrews.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: spiders as secondary consumers, trophic level 3, plus a description distinguishing the two productivities: GPP is all the energy the producers fix by photosynthesis, while NPP is what remains after the producers' own cellular respiration (\(\mathrm{NPP} = \mathrm{GPP} - R\)) and is the only portion stored as biomass available to consumers. Do not accept: "tertiary consumer" or "level 4"; a definition of NPP with no mention of respiration or of GPP; naming the level without describing the productivities.
    • (b) Accept: at least two named fates applied to this grassland, most assimilated energy is released as heat in cellular respiration, a large share of each level is never eaten at all (roots, stems, dead leaves, uneaten insects), and part of what is eaten passes out undigested in feces; endotherms such as shrews spend most of their intake maintaining body temperature. Do not accept: "energy is lost" with no fate named; "energy is destroyed" or "used up" (it leaves as heat, and is conserved); a single fate named with no second.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \(0.10(32{,}000) = 3{,}200\) kJ/(m²·yr) to grasshoppers, \(0.10(3{,}200) = 320\) to spiders, \(0.10(320) = 32\) kJ/(m²·yr) to shrews. Units are required. Do not accept: 320 (stopping one level short); 3,200; a value with no setup; a number with no units.
    • (d) Accept: a claim tied to the computed value, a fifth level would receive about \(0.10(32) = 3.2\) kJ/(m²·yr), which is far too little to meet the metabolic demands of a breeding population of predators large enough to catch shrews, so the chain is limited by energy supply rather than by the availability of prey species. Do not accept: "there is not enough energy" with no number; "food chains are usually four levels long" offered as the reason; a justification that restates (b) without using the calculation from (c).
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The spiders are secondary consumers, trophic level 3, because they eat the grasshoppers that ate the grass. Gross primary productivity is everything the grasses fix by photosynthesis; net primary productivity is what remains after the grasses respire some of it themselves, \(\mathrm{NPP} = \mathrm{GPP} - R\). Only NPP becomes plant biomass, so only NPP can be eaten.

    b Most of the energy at each level is burned in cellular respiration and leaves as heat, which nothing recovers. A lot more is never eaten at all (roots, stems, and dead leaves that decomposers get instead of grasshoppers), and part of what is eaten passes through as feces. The shrews are endotherms besides, so they spend most of what they assimilate holding body temperature rather than building tissue.

    c Grasshoppers: \(0.10(32{,}000) = 3{,}200\) kJ/(m²·yr). Spiders: \(0.10(3{,}200) = 320\). Shrews: \(0.10(320) = 32\) kJ/(m²·yr).

    d A fifth level would get about \(0.10(32) = 3.2\) kJ per square meter per year. A predator big enough to hunt shrews needs far more than that, and needs a whole breeding population's worth of it, so the energy simply is not there. Chain length is set by energy, not by whether a suitable predator exists.

  3. Model: elk reintroduced to a fenced mountain valley. Wildlife biologists estimate the valley's carrying capacity at \(K = 2{,}000\) elk and the herd's maximum per-capita growth rate at \(r_{\max} = 0.30\ \mathrm{yr^{-1}}\). The herd currently numbers 100 animals, and biologists model it with the logistic equation \(dN/dt = r_{\max}N(K-N)/K\).

    Using the model, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the carrying capacity of the valley, and describe what the term \((K-N)/K\) represents in the logistic model.
    2. Explain how density-dependent factors acting on this elk herd produce the flattening of the logistic curve as \(N\) approaches \(K\).
    3. Calculate \(dN/dt\) at \(N = 500\) and at \(N = 1{,}000\), showing your setup. Then construct a graph of \(dN/dt\) against \(N\): put \(N\) on the x-axis with a scale from 0 to 2,000, put \(dN/dt\) in elk per year on the y-axis, label both axes with units, plot your two calculated points together with the values at \(N = 0\) and \(N = 2{,}000\), and mark the population size at which growth is fastest.
    4. Justify, using your calculated values, why a wildlife agency seeking the largest sustainable annual harvest would hold the herd near 1,000 animals rather than let it grow to 2,000.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: \(K = 2{,}000\) elk, plus a description of \((K-N)/K\) as the fraction of the environment's capacity still unused: it equals 1 when the valley is empty and 0 when \(N = K\), and it is the factor that scales exponential growth down as the herd fills the valley. Do not accept: identifying \(K\) with no description of the term; describing \((K-N)/K\) as "the number of elk that can still be added" (it is a fraction, not a count); calling it the growth rate.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation naming at least one density-dependent factor and tracing it to the rate in this herd, as elk density rises, competition for forage, winter range, and calving ground intensifies, and parasite and disease transmission increases, so the per-capita birth rate falls and the per-capita death rate rises; \(r\) declines toward zero and the curve levels off at \(K\). Do not accept: naming a density-independent factor such as a blizzard as the cause of leveling; "the elk run out of food, so they stop growing" with no reference to birth or death rates; a general definition of density dependence never applied to the elk.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \(dN/dt = 0.30(500)(2000-500)/2000 = 150(0.75) = 112.5\) elk/yr and \(0.30(1000)(2000-1000)/2000 = 300(0.50) = 150\) elk/yr, together with a graph that has \(N\) on the x-axis and \(dN/dt\) on the y-axis, both labeled with units, a scale accommodating 0–2,000 and 0–150, the points (0, 0), (500, 112.5), (1000, 150), and (2000, 0) plotted, and \(N = 1{,}000\) marked as the maximum. Award the point only if both calculations are correct and the axes are correctly assigned and labeled. Do not accept: reversed axes; a plot of \(N\) against time in place of the requested graph; unlabeled axes; the maximum marked at \(N = 2{,}000\).
    • (d) Accept: a justification built on the computed values, at \(N = 1{,}000\) the herd adds 150 elk per year, the largest surplus available, so 150 animals can be removed annually without reducing the herd, whereas at \(N = 2{,}000\) growth is \(0.30(2000)(0)/2000 = 0\) and any harvest drives the population below \(K\); holding the herd at \(K/2\) maximizes sustainable yield. Do not accept: "1,000 is half of \(K\), and \(K/2\) is best" with no values; a justification citing no number from (c); an answer that recommends 1,000 because the herd is healthier without linking it to growth rate.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The carrying capacity is 2,000 elk. The term \((K-N)/K\) is the fraction of the valley's capacity still unused: near 1 when the herd is tiny, so growth is nearly exponential, and 0 when \(N\) reaches 2,000, which shuts growth off.

    b As the herd gets denser, elk compete harder for forage, winter range, and calving areas, and parasites spread more easily between crowded animals. Cows in poor condition raise fewer calves and more animals die over winter, so the per-capita birth rate falls and the death rate climbs, squeezing \(r\) toward zero until the curve flattens at 2,000.

    c \(dN/dt = 0.30(500)(2000-500)/2000 = 150(0.75) = 112.5\) elk/yr, and \(0.30(1000)(2000-1000)/2000 = 300(0.50) = 150\) elk/yr. On my graph \(N\) (elk) goes on the x-axis from 0 to 2,000 every 500 and \(dN/dt\) (elk per year) on the y-axis from 0 to 160 every 20. I plotted (0, 0), (500, 112.5), (1000, 150) and (2000, 0), drew a smooth arch, and marked \(N = 1{,}000\) as the peak.

    d At 1,000 elk the herd adds 150 animals a year, the largest surplus on my curve, so the agency could take 150 annually and still leave 1,000 behind. At 2,000 the herd sits at \(K\) with \(dN/dt = 0\), so there is no surplus and any harvest pushes it down.

  4. Data: all woody stems over 10 cm diameter were counted in two 1-hectare forest plots on the same soil type. Plot A has never been logged; plot B was selectively logged 15 years ago. Each plot yielded 200 stems belonging to the same five canopy species.

    PlotSpecies 1Species 2Species 3Species 4Species 5
    Plot A (unlogged)5045403530
    Plot B (logged)1502015105

    Simpson's index of diversity is \(D = 1 - \sum (n/N)^2\). For plot A, \(D = 0.794\).

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the species richness of each plot, and describe how the two plots differ in evenness.
    2. Explain why two plots with the same species richness can have very different values of Simpson's index.
    3. Calculate Simpson's index for plot B, showing your setup.
    4. Justify a prediction about which plot will lose the smaller fraction of its productivity during a two-year drought, naming the mechanism that accounts for the difference.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: richness is 5 in both plots, plus a description of the evenness difference using the counts: plot A's stems are spread almost equally across the five species (50 down to 30), while plot B is dominated by species 1, which holds 150 of 200 stems, or 75% of them. Do not accept: reporting richness without describing evenness; "plot A is more even" with no reference to the counts; treating the 200 stems as the richness.
    • (b) Accept: an explanation that Simpson's index measures the probability that two individuals drawn at random are different species, so it responds to how individuals are distributed among species and not only to how many species are present; when one species dominates, most random pairs are the same species, the \(\sum(n/N)^2\) term is large, and \(D\) drops even though richness is unchanged. Do not accept: "the index includes evenness" with no account of how; a restatement of (a); an explanation that says richness differs between the plots.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \((150/200)^2 + (20/200)^2 + (15/200)^2 + (10/200)^2 + (5/200)^2 = 0.5625 + 0.0100 + 0.0056 + 0.0025 + 0.0006 = 0.5813\), so \(D = 1 - 0.5813 = 0.419\) (accept 0.42). Do not accept: 0.581 (the sum, with the subtraction omitted); a value with no setup; squaring the raw counts instead of the proportions.
    • (d) Accept: a prediction that plot A loses the smaller fraction, justified by a named mechanism; redundancy and response diversity, in that plot A's stems are spread across five species that differ in rooting depth and drought tolerance, so the more tolerant ones keep fixing carbon while the sensitive ones fail; in plot B, 75% of the stems belong to one species, so if that species' drought threshold is crossed there is nothing left to compensate. Do not accept: "diversity is good" or "plot A is more diverse, so it does better" with no mechanism; a prediction with no direction; naming plot B as the more resilient plot.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a Both plots have a richness of 5, since the same five canopy species appear in each. They differ in evenness: plot A's 200 stems are spread almost equally, 50 down to 30 per species, while in plot B one species holds 150 of the 200 stems, 75% of the plot, and the rarest is down to 5.

    b Simpson's index is the chance that two stems picked at random are different species, so it depends on how individuals are shared out, not only on how many species there are. When one species takes most of the stems its \((n/N)^2\) term gets very large and \(D\) collapses, even though the species list is unchanged.

    c \(\sum(n/N)^2 = (0.75)^2 + (0.10)^2 + (0.075)^2 + (0.05)^2 + (0.025)^2 = 0.5625 + 0.0100 + 0.0056 + 0.0025 + 0.0006 = 0.5813\), so \(D = 1 - 0.5813 = 0.419\).

    d Plot A loses the smaller fraction. Its stems are split nearly evenly across five species (\(D = 0.794\)) that differ in rooting depth and drought tolerance, so the deep-rooted ones keep photosynthesizing while the shallow-rooted ones shut down: response diversity, plus redundancy. Plot B has \(D = 0.419\) and 75% of its stems in one species, so once that species' threshold is crossed nothing takes up the slack.

  5. Data: a mountain valley from which wolves had been absent for seventy years. Wolves were reintroduced in 1995. Elk are the wolves' main prey and the main browser of young willow shoots along the streams.

    Year19952000200520102015
    Wolves in the valley21721069799
    Elk in the valley17,00011,7006,6004,6004,800
    Mean willow height (cm)4562118195240

    Using the data, answer (a) through (d).

    1. Identify the trophic level occupied by the elk in this food chain, and describe the trend in mean willow height between 1995 and 2015.
    2. Explain how the change in the wolf population between 1995 and 2005 produced the change in willow height over the same period.
    3. Calculate the percent change in the elk population between 1995 and 2015, showing your setup.
    4. Justify the claim that the wolf functions as a keystone species in this valley, citing specific evidence from the data.
    Your response
    Scoring notes
    • (a) Accept: elk as primary consumers, trophic level 2 (herbivores eating the willows), plus a description of the willow trend with values: mean height rose steadily from 45 cm in 1995 to 240 cm in 2015, with the steepest gains after 2005. Do not accept: "secondary consumer"; "the willows got taller" with no values or no time span; describing the elk trend in place of the willow trend.
    • (b) Accept: a cause-and-effect chain traced through these three levels; wolves rose from 21 to 106 and their predation, together with the elk's avoidance of exposed streamside areas, cut the elk herd from 17,000 to 6,600; with far fewer elk browsing, willow shoots survived their first seasons and grew, so mean height rose from 45 cm to 118 cm. The answer must connect all three levels. Do not accept: "wolves ate the elk, so the willows grew" with no reference to browsing pressure; an explanation that stops at the elk; a description of the trends with no causal link.
    • (c) Accept, with setup shown: \((4{,}800 - 17{,}000)/17{,}000 \times 100 = -12{,}200/17{,}000 \times 100 = -71.8\%\), a decrease of about 72%. Sign or the word "decrease" is required. Do not accept: 12,200 reported as a percentage; dividing by 4,800; a percentage with no setup.
    • (d) Accept: a claim supported by named evidence, the wolf is a keystone species because its effect on the community is far larger than its own abundance or biomass would suggest: about 100 wolves are associated with a 72% reduction in a 17,000-strong elk herd and a fivefold rise in willow height (45 cm to 240 cm), a trophic cascade running down three levels from predator to herbivore to producer. Do not accept: a claim with no numbers cited; "wolves are important to the ecosystem"; evidence listed with no statement of how it supports the keystone claim; confusing keystone with dominant (biomass-based) or invasive.
    Show a 4/4 response

    a The elk are primary consumers, trophic level 2, because they eat the willows. Mean willow height climbed steadily from 45 cm in 1995 to 240 cm in 2015, with the fastest gains after 2005, once the elk herd was already far smaller.

    b Between 1995 and 2005 the wolf population went from 21 to 106. Wolves killed elk and pushed the survivors away from open streamside areas where they were easy to ambush, so the herd fell from 17,000 to 6,600. With far fewer elk browsing the banks, young willow shoots were no longer eaten back every season and survived their first years, so mean height more than doubled from 45 cm to 118 cm.

    c \((4{,}800 - 17{,}000)/17{,}000 = -12{,}200/17{,}000 = -0.718\), a decrease of about 71.8%.

    d About 100 wolves, a tiny share of the valley's animal biomass next to thousands of elk, go with a 71.8% drop in the elk herd and a willow canopy more than five times taller, 45 cm to 240 cm. That effect is far out of proportion to the wolves' numbers and runs down three trophic levels from predator to herbivore to producer, which is what a keystone species and a trophic cascade look like.

Unit recap

Unit recap

0:00 / 0:00

Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play counts as your one free video.

Free preview complete

That's the end of the free preview.

You've opened five lessons, which is as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go back to it.

Book a tutor instead