Algebra-based mechanics (kinematics, forces, energy, momentum, rotation, oscillations, and fluids) taught unit by unit to the current College Board framework. Every lesson pairs the equation with the reasoning, because the exam grades the explanation as much as the number. Exam format from 2027: this is a hybrid digital exam: multiple choice in Bluebook, free response handwritten in a paper booklet. Work the practice problems on paper and check your steps against the worked answer, the way you will sit the free-response section in May.
3H EXAM42 MCQ4 FRQ69 LESSONS80 PRACTICE PROBLEMSPREREQ: GEOMETRY
What this course covers, and how the exam weights it.
AP Physics 1 follows the eight units of the College Board course framework (revised for the 2024–25 school year, when fluids returned to the course). Forces and energy together are roughly 40% of the exam, and the free-response section always includes an experimental-design question and a qualitative/quantitative translation question.
U1Kinematics10–15%
U2Force and Translational Dynamics18–23%
U3Work, Energy, and Power18–23%
U4Linear Momentum10–15%
U5Torque and Rotational Dynamics10–15%
U6Energy and Momentum of Rotating Systems5–8%
U7Oscillations5–8%
U8Fluids10–15%
All eight units are open, 69 topics in all. Every topic opens with the method, worked examples, and a set of practice problems. Every problem has a full worked solution, so you can find the step where yours went wrong. Each unit closes with a ten-problem mixed review.
Free preview: all of Unit 1, its lessons and its review set,
is open to everyone with no account. Past that, a few more lessons open
for free, and a free account can start a free month of this course: no
card, every lesson and practice set open for 30 days. Grading of
written work and teacher review come with a paid plan.
Two drivers leave the same town at the same speed of 60 miles per hour. One ends up in the city to the north and the other in the
city to the south. A speedometer cannot tell them apart, yet they are in very different places. The reason is that
“60 mph” is only half a description of their motion: it says how fast but not which way. Physics
sorts every measurable quantity into one of two families according to whether direction matters, and the whole of mechanics
is written in that language. This lesson sets the vocabulary and the sign rules you will use in every one of the eight units.
Learning objectives · 1.1.A and 1.1.B
Describe a scalar or vector quantity using magnitude and direction, as appropriate. Describe a vector sum in one dimension.
Required content · EK 1.1.A.1 to 1.1.B.1
Scalars are quantities described by magnitude only; vectors are quantities described by both magnitude and direction.
Vectors can be visually modeled as arrows with appropriate direction and lengths proportional to their magnitude.
Distance and speed are examples of scalar quantities, while position, displacement, velocity, and acceleration are examples of vector quantities.
Vectors are notated with an arrow above the symbol for that quantity. Vector notation is not required for vector components along an axis. In one dimension, the sign of the component completely describes the direction of that component.
When determining a vector sum in a given one-dimensional coordinate system, opposite directions are denoted by opposite signs.
Magnitude and direction
A scalar is a quantity fully described by a number and a unit: a mass of 2.0 kg, a time of 7 s, a distance of 300 m,
a speed of 15 m/s. A vector needs a number, a unit and a direction: a displacement of 300 m north,
a velocity of 15 m/s to the right. The number and unit together are the vector’s magnitude, which is
always zero or positive, because it measures size only.
A vector is drawn as an arrow. The arrow points in the direction of the vector and its length is proportional to the magnitude,
so an arrow twice as long represents a vector twice as large. In print a vector is named with an arrow over its symbol,
\(\vec{v}\), \(\vec{a}\), \(\Delta\vec{x}\); the magnitude is written without the arrow, \(v\), or with bars, \(|\vec{v}|\).
Figure 1.1a Vectors drawn as arrows. Length is proportional to magnitude and the arrowhead shows direction. In one dimension the sign of the component carries the direction: right is plus, left is minus. B has a smaller magnitude than A but a larger magnitude than C.
Scalars (magnitude only)
Vectors (magnitude and direction)
distance \(d\), the total path length
position \(x\) and displacement \(\Delta x\)
speed, the magnitude of velocity
velocity \(v\) and acceleration \(a\)
time, mass, energy (Unit 3)
force (Unit 2), momentum (Unit 4)
One dimension: the sign is the direction
When all motion lies along a single straight line, you do not need arrows over your symbols. You choose a coordinate axis, say
\(x\), and decide which way is positive. Every vector component along that axis is then a signed number: a plus sign means
“along the positive direction” and a minus sign means “along the negative direction.”
A velocity of \(v_x = -3\ \text{m/s}\) is a motion of 3 m/s in the negative direction. The sign is part of the answer.
Two habits prevent the most common errors. First, state the axis before you calculate: write “right is positive” or
“up is positive” at the top of your work. Second, remember that the minus sign says nothing about size.
A velocity of \(-8\ \text{m/s}\) has a greater magnitude than \(+3\ \text{m/s}\): it is the faster motion, only in
the opposite direction. “Negative” does not mean “smaller” and it does not mean “slowing down.”
Figure 1.1b The physics does not care which way the axis points, but the signs do. The same trip has a positive displacement when right is positive and a negative displacement when left is positive. Choose the axis first, then keep every quantity consistent with it.
The choice of axis is yours, and the physics is the same for either choice, as Figure 1.1b shows. Flipping the axis flips every
sign in the problem, but the magnitudes, the times and the physical conclusions do not change. What you may not do is mix: if
right is positive for displacement, it must be positive for velocity and acceleration in the same problem.
Position, displacement and distance
Position \(x\) tells where an object is relative to a chosen origin, and it is a vector: \(x = +12\ \text{m}\) and
\(x = -12\ \text{m}\) are different places. Displacement is the change in position,
\(\Delta x = x_f - x_i\), the straight-line “how far and which way from the start to the finish.”
It can be positive, negative or zero. Distance is the total length of the path actually traveled, which is why it
is a scalar and can never be negative or decrease. Any trip that ends where it started has zero displacement but a large distance.
Figure 1.1c A three-leg walk along a straight path. The legs are drawn in separate rows so they do not overlap. Distance adds the lengths: 40 + 25 + 10 = 75 m. Displacement adds the signed components: +40 − 25 + 10 = +25 m.
Adding vectors in one dimension
In one dimension the vector sum is an ordinary sum of signed numbers. Vectors pointing the same way
reinforce; vectors pointing in opposite directions partly cancel, because they carry opposite signs. If a plane flies at
\(+200\ \text{m/s}\) relative to the air and the wind adds \(-30\ \text{m/s}\) (a headwind), the resulting velocity relative to
the ground is \(+200 + (-30) = +170\ \text{m/s}\).
The same rule explains the first equation of motion on the AP reference sheet. An object’s final velocity is its initial velocity
plus the change in velocity, and the change in velocity is the acceleration times the time:
\[ \vec{v} = \vec{v}_0 + \vec{a}\,t \qquad\text{which in one dimension reads}\qquad v_x = v_{x0} + a_x t. \]
Each term has its own sign. You will use this equation constantly, and it is nothing more than a vector sum.
Worked example · distance and displacement
A hiker walks 40 m east, turns back and walks 25 m west, then walks 10 m east again, in a total time of 50 s. Take east as positive. Find (a) the distance, (b) the displacement, (c) the average speed and (d) the magnitude and direction of the average velocity.
Step 1, signed legs. The displacements of the three legs are \(+40\ \text{m}\), \(-25\ \text{m}\) and \(+10\ \text{m}\).
Step 5, average velocity. Velocity uses displacement: \(\dfrac{+25\ \text{m}}{50\ \text{s}} = +0.50\ \text{m/s}\), that is, 0.50 m/s east.
Check. The average speed (1.5 m/s) is larger than the magnitude of the average velocity (0.50 m/s). That is always true unless the path is a straight line with no backtracking.
Worked example · velocity as a vector sum
A cart rolls to the left at 6.0 m/s along a track, and a steady push gives it an acceleration of \(+2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) (to the right) for 4.0 s. Take right as positive. What is its velocity at the end?
Step 1, signs. The initial velocity is to the left, so \(v_{x0} = -6.0\ \text{m/s}\); the acceleration is to the right, \(a_x = +2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Interpretation. The cart now moves to the right at 2.0 m/s. It slowed down, stopped for an instant after 3.0 s, reversed direction, and sped up the other way. The sign change shows the reversal; no “turning around” step had to be added by hand.
Worked example · same motion, two axes
A student rolls a ball from a mark at \(x = +2.0\ \text{m}\) to a mark at \(x = +7.0\ \text{m}\). Describe the displacement if (a) right is positive and the marks are as given, and (b) the student instead calls left positive.
(a) \(\Delta x = x_f - x_i = 7.0 - 2.0 = +5.0\ \text{m}\). (b) With the axis reversed, the same two places have coordinates \(-2.0\ \text{m}\) and \(-7.0\ \text{m}\), so \(\Delta x = -7.0 - (-2.0) = -5.0\ \text{m}\). The ball moved 5.0 m in both descriptions; only the sign changed, because the positive direction changed.
Exam focus
Name the axis. Free-response graders reward “take up as positive” because every later sign depends on it.
Keep the sign in your answer. “\(-4\ \text{m/s}\)” and “\(4\ \text{m/s}\)” are different answers. When a question asks for a magnitude, drop the sign; when it asks for a velocity, keep it.
Distance is not displacement. Average speed uses distance and average velocity uses displacement; confusing them is the single most common slip in Unit 1.
Do not say “negative means slowing.” A negative sign gives direction only. Whether something slows down depends on how its velocity and acceleration compare (lesson 1.2).
Vector sums are signed sums. In one dimension there is no need for a triangle or a protractor; opposite directions are opposite signs.
Practice
Classify each as scalar or vector: temperature of 20 \(^\circ\)C, a force of 30 N downward, a time of 12 s, an acceleration of \(-3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), a speed of 25 m/s.
Show answer
Scalars: temperature, time, speed (they have magnitude only). Vectors: the 30 N downward force and the acceleration of \(-3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), since each has a direction (given in words in the first case and by the sign in the second).
A runner goes once around a 400 m track and finishes where she started in 80 s. Find her distance, displacement, average speed and average velocity.
Show answer
Distance 400 m. Displacement 0 m, since she ends at the start. Average speed \(400/80 = 5.0\ \text{m/s}\). Average velocity \(0/80 = 0\ \text{m/s}\).
With right positive, a car moves at \(-18\ \text{m/s}\) and a bicycle at \(+9\ \text{m/s}\). Which is moving faster? Which way is each moving?
Show answer
The car is faster: its magnitude, 18 m/s, exceeds the bicycle’s 9 m/s. The car moves to the left (negative direction) and the bicycle to the right.
A student walks 30 m north, then 50 m south, then 10 m north. Take north as positive. Find the displacement and the distance.
Show answer
\(\Delta x = +30 - 50 + 10 = -10\ \text{m}\), which is 10 m south of the start. The distance is \(30 + 50 + 10 = 90\ \text{m}\).
A skater glides at \(+5.0\ \text{m/s}\) and a gust gives her \(a_x = -1.5\ \text{m/s}^2\) for 2.0 s. Find her final velocity.
Show answer
\(v_x = v_{x0} + a_x t = 5.0 + (-1.5)(2.0) = 5.0 - 3.0 = +2.0\ \text{m/s}\). She is still moving in the positive direction, only more slowly.
Explain, using the idea of a sign convention, why a problem solved with “down is positive” and the same problem solved with “up is positive” give different signs but the same physical result.
Show answer
The positive direction is an arbitrary choice. Reversing it multiplies every vector component by \(-1\) (displacement, velocity and acceleration all flip sign together), but the magnitudes, the times and the real motion are unchanged. As long as the same choice is used throughout one solution, both versions describe the same event.
Kinematics is the description of motion, with no questions yet about what causes it. Three quantities do all the work:
how far the object moved, how fast its position is changing, and how fast that is changing. They are displacement,
velocity and acceleration, and each one is defined as a rate of change of the one before it. Students who learn the definitions
precisely find the rest of Unit 1 almost mechanical; students who rely on the everyday meaning of “accelerate”
(which in ordinary speech means only “speed up”) lose points on nearly every exam. Physics gives the word a
sharper meaning, and this lesson builds it.
Learning objectives · 1.2.A and 1.2.B
Describe a change in an object’s position. Describe the average velocity and acceleration of an object, and describe its velocity and acceleration.
Required content · EK 1.2.A.1 to 1.2.B.5
When using the object model, the size, shape, and internal configuration are ignored. The object may be treated as a single point with extensive properties such as mass and charge.
Displacement is the change in an object’s position.
Averages of velocity and acceleration are calculated considering the initial and final states of an object over an interval of time.
Average velocity is the displacement of an object divided by the interval of time in which that displacement occurs. Average acceleration is the change in velocity divided by the interval of time in which that change in velocity occurs.
An object is accelerating if the magnitude and/or direction of the object’s velocity are changing.
Calculating average velocity or average acceleration over a very small time interval yields a value that is very close to the instantaneous velocity or instantaneous acceleration.
The object model
A real car has wheels, a roof and passengers; a real ball spins. To describe where something is and how it moves from place to place, none of
that matters. The object model replaces the real thing with a single point that carries its mass. Position then means the position
of that point. This simplification is why we can talk about “the position of a car” at all. It stops working when the shape or
the rotation matters, for example in a question about a spinning wheel (Unit 5), and then the object must be treated as a rigid system instead.
Displacement and average velocity
The displacement of an object during an interval is its final position minus its initial position,
\[ \Delta x = x - x_0 . \]
The average velocity over the interval is the displacement divided by the time that the displacement took:
\[ v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{x - x_0}{t - t_0}. \]
Its unit is meters per second. Because \(\Delta x\) is a vector component, so is the average velocity: it has the sign of the displacement.
Notice what the definition leaves out. It looks only at the beginning and the end of the interval, so two objects can have the same average
velocity while moving in completely different ways in between.
Acceleration is a change in velocity
The average acceleration over an interval is the change in velocity divided by the time of the change:
\[ a_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta v}{\Delta t} = \frac{v - v_0}{t - t_0}. \]
The unit is meters per second per second, \(\text{m/s}^2\). An acceleration of \(+3\ \text{m/s}^2\) means that every second the velocity
increases by \(3\ \text{m/s}\) in the positive direction. The velocity starts at 0, then it is \(+3\), then \(+6\), then \(+9\ \text{m/s}\), and so on.
Because velocity is a vector, an object accelerates whenever the magnitude of its velocity, the direction of its velocity, or both, change.
Three different situations qualify. A car pulling away from a light speeds up. A car braking for a stop sign slows down. And a car going around
a curve at a steady speedometer reading is also accelerating, because the direction of its velocity keeps changing (Unit 2 returns to this).
In one dimension the direction can only reverse, and a reversal is a change of velocity just as surely as a change in speed.
Figure 1.2a Motion diagrams. The dots show the position at equal time intervals and the blue arrows show the velocity. Equal gaps mean constant velocity. Gaps that grow mean the velocity arrows grow, so the acceleration points the same way as the motion. Gaps that shrink mean the acceleration points opposite to the motion.
A motion diagram like Figure 1.2a makes this visible. Dots show where the object was at equal time intervals, and arrows above the dots
show the velocity. When the spacing of the dots is uniform the velocity is constant and the acceleration is zero. When the spacing grows,
the velocity arrows grow, and the acceleration points in the same direction as the motion. When the spacing shrinks, the acceleration points
opposite to the motion. The acceleration arrow always points in the direction of the change in velocity.
Speeding up or slowing down: compare the signs
The sign of the acceleration alone does not tell you whether an object speeds up. What matters is whether the velocity and the acceleration
point the same way. If they have the same sign, the speed increases; if they have opposite signs, the speed decreases. A ball thrown upward
(taking up as positive) has \(v \gt 0\) and \(a \lt 0\) on the way up and slows down. On the way down it has \(v \lt 0\) and \(a \lt 0\) and speeds up.
The acceleration did not change at all; the velocity did.
Figure 1.2b Speeding up or slowing down depends on whether the velocity and the acceleration have the same sign, not on the sign of the acceleration alone. A negative acceleration speeds an object up if the object is already moving in the negative direction.
Two further facts break common mistakes. First, zero velocity does not mean zero acceleration. At the instant a thrown ball reaches the
top of its flight its velocity is zero, but its velocity is changing, so its acceleration is not zero (it is \(-10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as lesson 1.5 shows).
Second, zero acceleration does not mean zero velocity: a car cruising at constant velocity on a straight road has \(a = 0\) with a large \(v\).
Instantaneous values from small intervals
Average velocity describes a whole interval, but a speedometer reads the velocity right now. The instantaneous velocity is
what the average velocity approaches as the time interval is made very small. Suppose a car’s position is \(x = t^2\) in meters, with \(t\) in seconds.
To find its velocity at \(t = 3.0\ \text{s}\), compute the average velocity from 3.0 s to a slightly later time and watch the value settle:
Interval
\(\Delta x\)
\(\Delta t\)
average velocity
3.0 s to 4.0 s
7.0 m
1.0 s
7.0 m/s
3.0 s to 3.5 s
3.25 m
0.5 s
6.5 m/s
3.0 s to 3.1 s
0.61 m
0.1 s
6.1 m/s
3.0 s to 3.01 s
0.0601 m
0.01 s
6.01 m/s
The averages close in on \(6.0\ \text{m/s}\), the instantaneous velocity at 3.0 s. The same idea works for acceleration: the average acceleration over a very small
interval is very nearly the instantaneous acceleration. Lesson 1.3 shows the geometric version of this idea, where the instantaneous velocity is the slope of a tangent line.
Figure 1.2c Average velocity over shorter and shorter intervals. Each dashed line has the slope of an average velocity from t = 3 s to a later time: to 5.5 s it is 8.5 m/s, to 4.5 s it is 7.5 m/s, and to 3.5 s it is 6.5 m/s. As the interval shrinks the slope approaches 6 m/s, the slope of the tangent, which is the instantaneous velocity at 3 s.
Worked example · average velocity
A cyclist is at \(x = 12\ \text{m}\) when the clock reads 2.0 s and at \(x = 42\ \text{m}\) when it reads 7.0 s. Find the displacement and average velocity.
Step 1. \(\Delta x = 42 - 12 = +30\ \text{m}\) and \(\Delta t = 7.0 - 2.0 = 5.0\ \text{s}\).
Step 2. \(v_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{+30\ \text{m}}{5.0\ \text{s}} = +6.0\ \text{m/s}\), in the positive direction.
Check. The cyclist moved a little over 4 m each second for 5 s, so the answer is in the right range if the speed were steady; it need not have been steady, only the average is known.
Worked example · average acceleration while braking
A car moving at \(+25\ \text{m/s}\) brakes steadily and slows to \(+10\ \text{m/s}\) in 6.0 s. Find its average acceleration and say what the sign means.
Step 1, change in velocity. \(\Delta v = 10 - 25 = -15\ \text{m/s}\).
Meaning. The velocity is positive and the acceleration is negative, opposite signs, so the car slows down by 2.5 m/s each second. The acceleration points opposite to the motion.
Worked example · a reversal of direction
A ball moving at \(+8.0\ \text{m/s}\) (toward a wall) bounces back at \(-6.0\ \text{m/s}\). The contact lasts 0.020 s. Find the average acceleration during the contact.
Step 1. \(\Delta v = v - v_0 = (-6.0) - (+8.0) = -14.0\ \text{m/s}\). The change is larger than either speed because the direction reversed: the ball had to be brought to rest and then sent back.
Meaning. The acceleration is large because the time is short, and it is negative, pointing away from the wall. This is why impacts feel so violent: the changes of velocity are ordinary, but they happen in thousandths of a second.
Exam focus
Subtract in the right order. \(\Delta v = v - v_0\), final minus initial. A reversed subtraction flips the sign of the answer and the conclusion about slowing or speeding up.
Compare signs of \(v\) and \(a\). Same sign means speeding up; opposite signs mean slowing down. Write this reasoning in words on free-response questions.
Acceleration is not “speed.” Never describe a constant acceleration as a constant speed or the reverse.
Units. Velocity is m/s, acceleration is \(\text{m/s}^2\). A numerical answer without units loses a point.
Direction can change without speed changing. A question may ask whether an object is accelerating while its speedometer is steady; the answer is yes if it is turning.
Practice
A train is at \(x = 150\ \text{m}\) at \(t = 10\ \text{s}\) and at \(x = 30\ \text{m}\) at \(t = 30\ \text{s}\). Find its displacement and average velocity.
Show answer
\(\Delta x = 30 - 150 = -120\ \text{m}\), \(\Delta t = 20\ \text{s}\), so \(v_{\text{avg}} = -120/20 = -6.0\ \text{m/s}\). The train is moving, on average, in the negative direction at 6.0 m/s.
A sprinter goes from rest to \(+9.0\ \text{m/s}\) in 1.5 s. Find her average acceleration.
Show answer
An elevator moving at \(-4.0\ \text{m/s}\) (downward) stops in 2.0 s. Find the average acceleration, and state whether the elevator was speeding up or slowing down.
Show answer
\(a = (0 - (-4.0))/2.0 = +2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). The velocity was negative and the acceleration is positive, opposite signs, so the elevator was slowing down.
A student claims, “At the top of its flight a tossed ball has zero velocity, so it must have zero acceleration.” Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is wrong. Velocity is zero only for an instant, but it is changing from positive to negative through that instant, so the acceleration is not zero. In fact gravity gives the ball the same acceleration, about \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) downward, at every point of its flight.
A puck moving at \(+3.0\ \text{m/s}\) strikes a board and rebounds at \(-2.0\ \text{m/s}\) in 0.010 s. Find the average acceleration.
Show answer
A car travels around a circular track at a constant speed of 20 m/s. Is it accelerating? Explain using the definition of acceleration.
Show answer
Yes. Acceleration is a change in the magnitude or the direction of the velocity. The speed is constant, but the direction of the velocity changes continuously as the car goes around, so the velocity vector changes and the car is accelerating.
Lesson 1.3 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.3 (representations)
The same motion can be told in several languages: a motion diagram, a story in words, an equation, or a graph. AP Physics 1 expects you to move freely among them,
and the exam often hands you one representation and asks for another. Graphs are the most compact of these languages, because a single picture shows how position,
velocity and acceleration change together. This lesson teaches you to read the three motion graphs by asking two questions of any point or region: what is the
slope here? and what is the area here?
Learning objective · 1.3.A
Describe the position, velocity, and acceleration of an object using representations of that object’s motion.
Required content · EK 1.3.A.1 and 1.3.A.4
Motion can be represented by motion diagrams, figures, graphs, equations, and narrative descriptions.
Graphs of position, velocity, and acceleration as functions of time can be used to find the relationships between those quantities.
An object’s instantaneous velocity is the rate of change of the object’s position, which is equal to the slope of a line tangent to a point on a graph of the object’s position as a function of time.
An object’s instantaneous acceleration is the rate of change of the object’s velocity, which is equal to the slope of a line tangent to a point on a graph of the object’s velocity as a function of time.
The displacement of an object during a time interval is equal to the area under the curve of a graph of the object’s velocity as a function of time.
The change in velocity of an object during a time interval is equal to the area under the curve of a graph of the acceleration of the object as a function of time.
Boundary statement
AP Physics 1 does not expect students to quantitatively analyze nonuniform acceleration. However, students will be expected to be able to qualitatively analyze, sketch appropriate graphs of, and discuss situations in which acceleration is nonuniform.
Position against time: the slope is the velocity
On a graph of \(x\) against \(t\), the slope is rise over run, \(\Delta x/\Delta t\), which is exactly the definition of velocity. A steeper line means a larger
magnitude of velocity. A line sloping upward to the right means positive velocity, a line sloping downward means negative velocity, and a horizontal line means the object is at rest.
When the graph is a curve, the velocity changes from moment to moment, and the velocity at a particular instant is the slope of the tangent line drawn at that point,
the straight line that just touches the curve there (Figure 1.2c in the last lesson showed secant lines closing in on the tangent).
Figure 1.3a Reading position-time graphs. Slope is velocity: a flat line means at rest, a straight sloped line means constant velocity, a curve getting steeper means the velocity is growing, and a curve whose slope changes from positive to negative means the object turned around.
Read curves by describing how the slope changes. A curve that gets steeper to the right means the velocity is growing. A curve that gets flatter means the velocity is shrinking.
A hilltop, where the slope passes through zero from positive to negative, is the moment the object turns around.
Velocity against time: slope is acceleration, area is displacement
The same two questions apply one level up. On a graph of \(v\) against \(t\), the slope is \(\Delta v/\Delta t\), the acceleration. A horizontal line is constant velocity,
a straight sloped line is constant acceleration, and a curved line is changing acceleration. The area between the graph and the time axis is the displacement, because
velocity times time is displacement. Area above the axis is positive displacement (moving in the positive direction) and area below the axis is negative displacement.
The vertical position of the line also carries information. A point above the axis means positive velocity; below means negative; where the line crosses the axis, the object is
momentarily at rest and its direction reverses. The line can be rising while it is below the axis: that is a negative velocity getting closer to zero, which means the object is
slowing down while moving in the negative direction.
Acceleration against time: the area is the change in velocity
On a graph of \(a\) against \(t\), the area between the graph and the time axis is \(a\Delta t = \Delta v\), the change in velocity. The graph does not tell you the velocity itself;
you also need the starting velocity. Constant acceleration appears as a horizontal line, and zero acceleration as a line lying on the axis.
Graph
Slope gives
Area gives
position against time
velocity
(nothing useful)
velocity against time
acceleration
displacement
acceleration against time
(rate of change of acceleration, not used here)
change in velocity
Figure 1.3b One trip, three representations. During the first 4 s the acceleration is +2 m/s² (velocity rises, position curves upward). From 4 s to 8 s the acceleration is zero (constant velocity, straight line on the position graph). From 8 s to 10 s the acceleration is −4 m/s² (velocity falls to zero, position levels off). The dashed lines mark where the motion changes.
Figure 1.3b shows one trip in all three forms. Reading across the dashed lines, you can follow how a feature of one graph produces a feature of the next. A corner in the
velocity graph (at 4 s and 8 s) becomes a jump in the acceleration graph, because the acceleration changed suddenly, and a change of slope in the position graph, because the
velocity changed. A flat piece of the velocity graph becomes a zero on the acceleration graph and a straight sloped line on the position graph. Each graph is the slope of the one above it,
and the area under each graph builds the one above.
Figure 1.3c The area between the velocity graph and the time axis is the displacement. Splitting this graph into a triangle, a rectangle and a triangle gives 16 m + 32 m + 8 m = 56 m, which agrees with the position graph in Figure 1.3b at t = 10 s.
Nonuniform acceleration, qualitatively
Real motion rarely has constant acceleration. A car that accelerates from a stoplight gets less acceleration as it gains speed, so its velocity graph curves over and flattens.
AP Physics 1 does not ask you to calculate with such graphs, only to describe and sketch them. Use the same two questions. If the \(v\)–\(t\) curve gets flatter, the slope, and so the
acceleration, is decreasing. If it gets steeper, the acceleration is increasing. The position graph in that case bends more and more gently upward, with the slope still increasing but
at a slower rate.
Worked example · reading a position graph
Figure 1.3d shows an object’s position over 8 s. Describe the motion, find the velocity in each interval, and find the average velocity and average speed for the whole trip.
Figure 1.3d A position-time graph made of three straight pieces. The slope of each piece is the velocity during that interval: +4 m/s, then 0, then −3 m/s.
Step 1, slopes. From 0 to 2 s the position rises from 0 to 8 m: \(v = 8/2 = +4\ \text{m/s}\). From 2 s to 4 s the line is flat: \(v = 0\). From 4 s to 8 s the position falls from 8 m to \(-4\ \text{m}\): \(v = (-4 - 8)/4 = -3\ \text{m/s}\).
Step 2, story. The object moves forward at 4 m/s, stops for 2 s, then moves backward at 3 m/s, passing through the origin and ending 4 m on the negative side.
Step 3, whole trip. The displacement is \(-4 - 0 = -4\ \text{m}\), so \(v_{\text{avg}} = -4/8 = -0.50\ \text{m/s}\). The distance is \(8 + 0 + 12 = 20\ \text{m}\), so the average speed is \(20/8 = 2.5\ \text{m/s}\). They differ because the object turned around.
Worked example · area under a velocity graph
Using the velocity graph in Figure 1.3b, find the displacement from 0 to 10 s and the average velocity.
Step 1, areas. The graph is a triangle (0 to 4 s, rising to 8 m/s), a rectangle (4 s to 8 s at 8 m/s) and a triangle (8 s to 10 s, falling to zero), shown in Figure 1.3c.
Step 3. \(v_{\text{avg}} = 56/10 = 5.6\ \text{m/s}\), which is less than the 8 m/s maximum, as an average over a trip with slow beginning and end should be.
Worked example · velocity graph that crosses the axis
A cart’s velocity falls steadily from \(+6\ \text{m/s}\) at \(t = 0\) to \(-6\ \text{m/s}\) at \(t = 6\ \text{s}\) (Figure 1.3e). Find its acceleration, the time it is at rest, its displacement and the distance it travels.
Figure 1.3e Area above the time axis counts as positive displacement and area below counts as negative displacement. Here the two triangles cancel, so the object ends where it started even though it traveled 18 m in total.
Acceleration. The slope is \((-6 - 6)/6 = -2\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Rest. The velocity is zero where the line crosses the axis, at \(t = 3\ \text{s}\), because \(6 - 2t = 0\).
Displacement. The triangle above the axis has area \(\tfrac12(3)(6) = +9\ \text{m}\); the one below has area \(-\tfrac12(3)(6) = -9\ \text{m}\). The total is \(0\): the cart returns to its start.
Distance. Distance counts both areas as positive: \(9 + 9 = 18\ \text{m}\).
Exam focus
Say which graph you are reading. “The slope is the velocity” is correct on an \(x\)–\(t\) graph and wrong on a \(v\)–\(t\) graph, where the slope is the acceleration.
Signed area. Area below the time axis is negative displacement. For distance, add the absolute values of the areas.
Axis crossing is not “stopping for good.” A velocity graph crossing zero means the object is momentarily at rest and reversing.
Check the axes. Read the labels and the scale before using a graph. A graph of speed (always positive) is different from a graph of velocity.
Sketching. When asked to sketch a second graph from the first, mark where slopes change sign and where they are zero, and keep the same time scale on every graph.
Practice
A position-time graph is a straight line from \((0\ \text{s}, 2\ \text{m})\) to \((4\ \text{s}, 14\ \text{m})\). Find the velocity.
Show answer
The slope is \((14 - 2)/(4 - 0) = +3.0\ \text{m/s}\). The velocity is constant at +3.0 m/s.
A velocity graph is constant at \(+5\ \text{m/s}\) from 0 to 6 s and then falls straight to zero at 10 s. Find the total displacement.
Show answer
An acceleration graph shows \(+3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) for 4.0 s. The object started at \(+2.0\ \text{m/s}\). What is its velocity at the end of the 4.0 s?
Show answer
The area under the graph is \((3.0)(4.0) = 12\ \text{m/s}\), the change in velocity. The final velocity is \(2.0 + 12 = +14\ \text{m/s}\).
A velocity-time graph is a straight line sloping upward from \(-4\ \text{m/s}\) at \(t = 0\) to \(+4\ \text{m/s}\) at \(t = 4\ \text{s}\). Is the object speeding up or slowing down during the first 2 s? Explain.
Show answer
It is slowing down. Its velocity is negative but moving toward zero, so the speed decreases from 4 m/s to 0. The slope (acceleration) is \(+2\ \text{m/s}^2\), opposite in sign to the negative velocity, which is the condition for slowing down.
Describe in words the motion shown by an \(x\)–\(t\) graph that starts at the origin, curves upward with an increasing slope for 3 s, then continues as a straight line.
Show answer
For the first 3 s the slope (velocity) keeps increasing, so the object speeds up with positive acceleration. After 3 s the slope is constant, so the object moves at a constant velocity equal to the slope it had reached at 3 s. The acceleration is zero.
Two cars A and B have identical \(v\)–\(t\) graphs except that A’s line is steeper. Which has the greater acceleration? Which has the greater displacement after 5 s if both start from rest?
Show answer
A has the greater acceleration because the slope of a velocity graph is acceleration. Starting from rest, A also has the larger velocity at every later time, so the area under its graph, and therefore its displacement after 5 s, is larger.
Graphs show motion; equations let you predict it. If you know where an object starts, how fast it is moving and how it is accelerating, three short equations tell you where it will be and how fast it will be moving at any later time.
They apply whenever the acceleration is constant, which covers a car braking steadily, a rock falling near the ground, a sled sliding down a smooth slope, and many more situations you will meet this year.
The skill is not remembering the equations, which are printed on the AP reference sheet, but choosing the right one and keeping the signs straight. This lesson builds the equations from the graphs of lesson 1.3 so that none of them is a mystery.
Learning objective · 1.3.A
Describe the position, velocity, and acceleration of an object using representations of that object’s motion.
Required content · EK 1.3.A.2
For constant acceleration, three kinematic equations can be used to describe instantaneous linear motion in one dimension: \(v_x = v_{x0} + a_x t\), \(x = x_0 + v_{x0}t + \tfrac12 a_x t^2\), and \(v_x^2 = v_{x0}^2 + 2a_x(x - x_0)\).
The equations above are written to indicate motion in the \(x\)-direction, but these equations can be used in any single dimension as appropriate.
Where the equations come from
Start with a velocity graph for constant acceleration (Figure 1.4a). The graph is a straight line that begins at \(v_{x0}\) and ends at \(v_x\) after a time \(t\). Its slope is the acceleration, so the rise, \(v_x - v_{x0}\), equals \(a_x t\). Rearranging that one statement gives the first equation:
\[ v_x = v_{x0} + a_x t. \]
The displacement is the area under the line. That area is a rectangle of height \(v_{x0}\) and width \(t\), plus a triangle of base \(t\) and height \(a_x t\), so \(\Delta x = v_{x0}t + \tfrac12 (a_x t)\,t\). This is the second equation:
\[ x = x_0 + v_{x0} t + \tfrac12 a_x t^2. \]
Figure 1.4a Deriving the position equation. For constant acceleration the velocity graph is a straight line. The area under it is a rectangle, v0t, plus a triangle, ½(v − v0)t. Because v − v0 = at, the triangle is ½at², so Δx = v0t + ½at².
The third equation removes time. Solve the first equation for \(t = (v_x - v_{x0})/a_x\) and substitute it into the second, or equivalently use the trapezoid: the displacement is the average velocity times the time, \(\Delta x = \tfrac12 (v_{x0} + v_x)\,t\), and eliminating \(t\) gives the third equation:
\[ v_x^2 = v_{x0}^2 + 2a_x (x - x_0). \]
Whenever the time is neither given nor wanted, this equation is the shortest route.
The average-velocity statement \(\Delta x = \tfrac12 (v_{x0} + v_x) t\) is useful in its own right, but be careful: it holds only when the acceleration is constant. For any motion, the average velocity is simply \(\Delta x/\Delta t\); the version with the arithmetic mean of the initial and final velocities is a property of straight-line velocity graphs.
A method for choosing the equation
Five quantities appear in the three equations: the displacement \(\Delta x\), the time \(t\), the initial velocity \(v_{x0}\), the final velocity \(v_x\) and the acceleration \(a_x\). Each equation contains four of them and leaves one out (Figure 1.4b). If you know three and want a fourth, exactly one equation contains your four quantities and omits the fifth, so there is never a long search.
Figure 1.4b Choosing the equation. Each of the three equations leaves out one of the five kinematic quantities. List what you know and what you want, find the quantity that appears in neither list, and use the equation that omits it.
Draw a sketch and choose an axis. Write “right (or up) is positive.”
List the knowns with signs and units, including hidden ones: “starts from rest” means \(v_{x0} = 0\); “comes to a stop” means \(v_x = 0\); a dropped object has \(v_{x0} = 0\).
Name the unknown and find the quantity that is neither known nor wanted.
Choose the equation that omits that quantity, solve symbolically, then substitute.
Check the answer for sign, units and reasonableness.
The AP exam values this symbolic habit. Free-response questions often ask for a derived expression in terms of given variables, with the numbers coming later or not at all.
Worked example · braking to a stop
A car moving at \(+20\ \text{m/s}\) brakes with a constant acceleration of \(-5.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) until it stops. How long does the stop take, and how far does the car travel?
Time. The distance is not wanted, so use the first equation: \(t = \dfrac{v_x - v_{x0}}{a_x} = \dfrac{0 - 20}{-5.0} = 4.0\ \text{s}\).
Distance. Time is already known, but the third equation avoids relying on it: \(0 = (20)^2 + 2(-5.0)\Delta x\), so \(\Delta x = \dfrac{400}{10} = 40\ \text{m}\).
Check. The average velocity during the stop was \(\tfrac12(20 + 0) = 10\ \text{m/s}\); \(10\ \text{m/s} \times 4.0\ \text{s} = 40\ \text{m}\). The two methods agree.
Worked example · starting from rest
A car starts from rest and accelerates at \(+4.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) for 10 s. Find its final velocity and displacement. How long does it need to cover the first 100 m?
Displacement. \(\Delta x = 0 + \tfrac12(4.0)(10)^2 = 200\ \text{m}\).
First 100 m. From rest, \(\Delta x = \tfrac12 a_x t^2\), so \(t = \sqrt{\dfrac{2\Delta x}{a_x}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(100)}{4.0}} = \sqrt{50} = 7.1\ \text{s}\).
Interpretation. The car covers the first 100 m in 7.1 s and the second 100 m in only 2.9 s more, because it is moving faster. Starting from rest at constant acceleration, distance grows as \(t^2\).
Worked example · speeding up on a ramp
A car on an entrance ramp speeds up from \(+10\ \text{m/s}\) to \(+25\ \text{m/s}\) with a constant acceleration of \(+3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). How far does it travel, and how long does it take?
Distance. Time is neither given nor wanted first, so \(v_x^2 = v_{x0}^2 + 2a_x\Delta x\) gives \(\Delta x = \dfrac{625 - 100}{2(3.0)} = \dfrac{525}{6.0} = 87.5\ \text{m}\).
The third equation explains one of the most important facts in everyday physics. If a car brakes to a stop with deceleration magnitude \(|a|\), then \(0 = v_0^2 - 2|a|d\) and
\[ d = \frac{v_0^2}{2|a|}. \]
The stopping distance depends on the square of the initial speed. With \(|a| = 5.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), a car at 10 m/s stops in 10 m, at 20 m/s in 40 m, and at 30 m/s in 90 m (Figure 1.4c).
Doubling the speed quadruples the distance. On a real road the driver also covers distance during the reaction time, at the full speed: at 20 m/s and a 1.0 s reaction time that adds another 20 m, for a total of 60 m.
Figure 1.4c Stopping distance grows with the square of the speed. With a steady deceleration of 5 m/s², doubling the speed from 10 m/s to 20 m/s multiplies the braking distance by four, and tripling it multiplies it by nine.
Exam focus
Constant acceleration only. Before using any of the three equations, confirm the acceleration is constant. Say so in your solution.
Hidden zeros. “From rest,” “dropped” and “stops” each supply a known velocity of zero. Read the wording for them.
Signs on \(a_x\). A braking car moving in the positive direction has a negative acceleration. Entering a positive value gives a stop that takes negative time, which is your cue that a sign is wrong.
Symbolic first. Solve for the unknown before substituting numbers; graders can then follow your reasoning even if the arithmetic slips.
Squares. If the speed doubles and the acceleration stays the same, the distance covered in changing the speed is four times as large. Use this ratio reasoning on qualitative questions.
Practice
A cyclist starts from rest and accelerates at \(0.50\ \text{m/s}^2\) for 12 s. Find the final speed and the distance covered.
Show answer
A puck slides on ice with an initial velocity of \(+8.0\ \text{m/s}\) and a constant acceleration of \(-0.50\ \text{m/s}^2\). How far does it slide before stopping?
Show answer
\(0 = 8.0^2 + 2(-0.50)\Delta x\), so \(\Delta x = 64/1.0 = 64\ \text{m}\). The slide lasts \(8.0/0.50 = 16\ \text{s}\).
Car A and car B brake with the same deceleration. A is going twice as fast as B when the brakes are applied. Compare their stopping distances and stopping times. Justify your answer with equations.
Show answer
From \(d = v_0^2/(2|a|)\), A’s stopping distance is four times B’s. From \(t = v_0/|a|\), A’s stopping time is twice B’s. Speed enters the distance as a square and the time only to the first power.
Lesson 1.5 · Unit 1 · CED topic 1.3 (gravity near Earth)
Drop a coin and a pen from the same height at the same moment and, when air matters little, they hit the floor together. This was the observation that undermined centuries of belief that heavier things fall faster, and it remains one of the clearest examples of constant acceleration in all of physics.
Free fall is motion under the influence of gravity alone. It includes objects that are dropped, thrown downward and thrown upward, and it is the simplest place to practice the equations of lesson 1.4, because the acceleration is known before you start.
Learning objective · 1.3.A
Describe the position, velocity, and acceleration of an object using representations of that object’s motion.
Required content · EK 1.3.A.3 and the boundary statement
Near the surface of Earth, the vertical acceleration caused by the force of gravity is downward, constant, and has a measured value approximately equal to \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\).
For all situations in which a numerical quantity is required for \(g\), the value \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\) will be used. However, students will not be penalized for correctly using the more precise commonly accepted values of \(g = 9.8\ \text{m/s}^2\) or \(g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2\).
One acceleration for every falling object
An object in free fall accelerates downward at \(g\), about \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) near Earth’s surface. Every second that passes, the downward velocity increases by 10 m/s. The value does not depend on the mass, the size or the material of the object, and it does not depend on whether the object is moving up, moving down or momentarily at rest.
In this course we use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as the exam does; computing with 9.8 would change the answers by about 2 percent and would also be accepted.
Why the independence of mass? A heavier object feels a larger gravitational force, but it also has more inertia, and the two effects cancel exactly. Unit 2 explains this with Newton’s second law. In everyday life, air resistance makes a feather fall slowly; in a vacuum chamber, and on the Moon when an astronaut dropped a hammer and a feather together in 1971, they land at the same instant.
Unless a problem says otherwise, neglect air resistance. That is the “free” in free fall.
Up, down and the sign of \(a\)
Choose a positive direction first. If up is positive, the acceleration is \(a_y = -g = -10\ \text{m/s}^2\) at every instant, including while the object rises. If down is positive, \(a_y = +10\ \text{m/s}^2\) throughout. Both are correct; mixing them is not. Most problems with an object tossed upward are easiest with up positive, so that the starting velocity is positive and the acceleration negative.
Figure 1.5a A ball tossed upward at 20 m/s. Each position is drawn at a different horizontal place so the five moments can be seen side by side. The velocity falls by 10 m/s every second: +20, +10, 0, −10, −20. The acceleration, 10 m/s² downward, does not change at all.
Figure 1.5a shows a ball thrown straight up at 20 m/s. On the way up the velocity (an upward arrow) gets shorter by 10 m/s each second, until at the top it is zero. Then it points downward and grows again. The acceleration, drawn as a downward arrow at every position, never changes.
This is the picture that corrects the most common error in Unit 1: at the top the velocity is zero but the acceleration is still \(-10\ \text{m/s}^2\). If the acceleration were zero there, the ball would stay at the top forever.
Figure 1.5b Graphs of the toss in Figure 1.5a, with up as positive. Height is a parabola peaking at 20 m at t = 2 s. Velocity falls on a straight line with slope −10 m/s², crossing zero at the peak. The acceleration graph is a flat line at −10 m/s², even where the velocity is zero.
Symmetry of the toss
When an object is thrown up and returns to its starting height, three symmetries follow from the constant acceleration and make many questions fast. The time going up equals the time coming down. The object passes any given height twice, once up and once down, with the same speed in the two directions. And it returns to its launch height with the same speed it had at launch, but now pointing downward.
At the top, \(v_y = 0\), so \(t_{\text{up}} = v_0/g\) and the height gained is \(h = v_0^2/(2g)\).
time (s)
distance fallen from rest (m)
velocity (m/s, down positive)
fell during this second (m)
1
5
10
5
2
20
20
15
3
45
30
25
4
80
40
35
The table shows a dropped object. The distance fallen grows as \(t^2\) (\(\tfrac12 g t^2 = 5t^2\)), while the velocity grows in proportion to \(t\). In successive seconds the object falls 5 m, 15 m, 25 m, 35 m: a steadily growing share of the total, because it is moving faster each second.
Worked example · a ball tossed upward
A ball is thrown straight up at 20 m/s from the ground. Find the maximum height, the time to reach it, the total time in the air, and the velocity just before it lands.
Axis. Up is positive, so \(v_{y0} = +20\ \text{m/s}\) and \(a_y = -10\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Time to the top. At the top \(v_y = 0\): \(0 = 20 - 10t\), so \(t = 2.0\ \text{s}\).
Maximum height. \(0 = 20^2 + 2(-10)h\), so \(h = 400/20 = 20\ \text{m}\).
Total time. The trip down mirrors the trip up, so the total is \(2 \times 2.0 = 4.0\ \text{s}\). Check with \(y = v_{y0}t + \tfrac12 a_y t^2 = 20(4) - 5(16) = 0\). ✓
Landing velocity. \(v_y = 20 - 10(4.0) = -20\ \text{m/s}\): the same speed as at launch, now directed downward.
Worked example · a dropped object
A construction worker drops a bolt from the top of a building 45 m high. How long does it take to hit the ground and how fast is it going?
Axis. Down is positive, so \(v_{y0} = 0\), \(a_y = +10\ \text{m/s}^2\), \(\Delta y = +45\ \text{m}\).
Speed. \(v_y = a_y t = (10)(3.0) = 30\ \text{m/s}\) downward. Check with \(v_y^2 = 2a_y\Delta y = 2(10)(45) = 900\), so \(v_y = 30\ \text{m/s}\). ✓
Worked example · thrown upward from a cliff
A student stands at the edge of a 15 m cliff and throws a stone straight up at 10 m/s. The stone misses the cliff on the way down and lands at the bottom. Find the maximum height above the cliff edge, the time of flight and the landing velocity.
Axis. Up is positive, origin at the edge: \(v_{y0} = +10\ \text{m/s}\), \(a_y = -10\ \text{m/s}^2\), landing at \(y = -15\ \text{m}\).
Maximum height. \(0 = 10^2 + 2(-10)h\), so \(h = 5.0\ \text{m}\) above the edge, reached at \(t = 1.0\ \text{s}\).
Time of flight. \(-15 = 10t - 5t^2\), so \(5t^2 - 10t - 15 = 0\) and \(t^2 - 2t - 3 = 0\), giving \((t - 3)(t + 1) = 0\). The physical root is \(t = 3.0\ \text{s}\); the root \(t = -1\ \text{s}\) is a time before the throw and is rejected.
Landing velocity. \(v_y = 10 - 10(3.0) = -20\ \text{m/s}\). The stone passes the edge on the way down at \(-10\ \text{m/s}\) (the symmetry rule) and then gains another 10 m/s over the last 1.0 s.
Exam focus
Constant \(-g\), always. If a graph, diagram or sentence suggests the acceleration is zero at the top, that is the trap.
Choose and state the axis. The acceleration of an object in free fall has the sign opposite to the one you assigned to “up.”
Two roots. A quadratic in \(t\) can give a negative time. Say why you rejected it.
Neglect air resistance unless told otherwise, and say so when the question asks about the assumptions of your model.
Mass does not appear. If a question gives masses in a free-fall setting, the masses are distractors; the motion is the same for all of them.
Practice
A rock is dropped from a cliff 80 m high. How long does it fall and how fast is it moving when it lands?
Show answer
A ball is thrown straight up at 30 m/s. Find the maximum height and the total time in the air (landing at the same height).
Show answer
\(h = 30^2/(2 \cdot 10) = 45\ \text{m}\). Time up \(= 30/10 = 3.0\ \text{s}\); total \(= 6.0\ \text{s}\).
A stone dropped into a well hits the water 2.0 s later. Ignoring the time sound takes to return, how deep is the well?
Show answer
\(\Delta y = \tfrac12 g t^2 = \tfrac12(10)(2.0)^2 = 20\ \text{m}\).
A ball is thrown straight down at 10 m/s from a window 15 m above the ground. Find the time to land and the landing speed.
Show answer
With down positive: \(15 = 10t + 5t^2\), so \(t^2 + 2t - 3 = 0\) and \(t = 1.0\ \text{s}\). \(v = 10 + 10(1.0) = 20\ \text{m/s}\).
A 1 kg ball and a 5 kg ball are dropped from the same height at the same time. Which reaches the ground first, and why?
Show answer
They land together. Near Earth’s surface every freely falling object has the same acceleration, \(g\), independent of mass; the larger gravitational force on the heavier ball is exactly offset by its larger inertia. Air resistance is neglected.
A ball is thrown upward. Describe its velocity and acceleration at the top of its path, and sketch (in words) the shape of its \(v\)–\(t\) graph.
Show answer
At the top the velocity is zero for an instant and the acceleration is \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) downward. The \(v\)–\(t\) graph, with up positive, is a single straight line with a negative slope of \(-10\ \text{m/s}^2\), starting at the positive launch velocity, crossing the time axis at the top and continuing below the axis as the ball falls.
Sitting in a train that is standing at a station, you watch the train beside you begin to move, and for a moment you cannot tell whether it is the other train or your own that is rolling. Motion is always measured relative to something.
That something is the observer’s reference frame, and the numbers you record for position and velocity depend on the choice. What does not depend on the choice, as this lesson shows, is acceleration, and that fact will be the foundation for Newton’s laws in Unit 2.
Learning objectives · 1.4.A and 1.4.B
Describe the reference frame of a given observer. Describe the motion of objects as measured by observers in different inertial reference frames.
Required content · EK 1.4.A.1 to 1.4.B.2.ii
The choice of reference frame will determine the direction and magnitude of quantities measured by an observer in that reference frame.
Measurements from a given reference frame may be converted to measurements from another reference frame.
The observed velocity of an object results from the combination of the object’s velocity and the velocity of the observer’s reference frame. Combining the motion of an object and the motion of an observer in a given reference frame involves the addition or subtraction of vectors.
The acceleration of any object is the same as measured from all inertial reference frames.
Boundary statement
Unless otherwise stated, the frame of reference of any problem may be assumed to be inertial. Adding or subtracting vectors to find relative velocities is restricted to motion along one dimension for AP Physics 1.
What a reference frame is
A reference frame is a point of view: an origin and a set of axes attached to an observer, together with the observer’s own motion. “The frame of the road” means measuring everything from a person standing on the road. “The frame of the train” means measuring from a passenger sitting in it.
The same event gets different numbers in different frames. A coffee cup on the train table is at rest in the train’s frame and moving at 30 m/s in the road’s frame, and both statements are correct.
An inertial reference frame is one in which Newton’s first law holds: an object with no net force on it keeps a constant velocity. Any frame moving at constant velocity relative to an inertial frame is also inertial. A frame that is accelerating, such as a car braking hard or a merry-go-round, is not. Unless a question says otherwise, assume the frame is inertial; the road and a train moving smoothly at constant velocity both qualify.
Converting velocities between frames
The rule is a vector sum. If object A moves at \(v_{A/B}\) as measured by observer B, and observer B moves at \(v_{B/G}\) as measured from the ground G, then the velocity of A measured from the ground is
\[ v_{A/G} = v_{A/B} + v_{B/G}. \]
Read each subscript \(X/Y\) as “X as measured by Y.” The inner labels match and cancel, leaving A as measured by G, which is how to keep the chain straight. In one dimension, velocities carry signs, so the addition is a signed addition.
A person walking forward at +2 m/s inside a train moving at +30 m/s relative to the ground is moving at +32 m/s relative to the ground (Figure 1.6a); a person walking toward the back of the same train at \(-2\ \text{m/s}\) relative to the train is moving at +28 m/s relative to the ground.
Figure 1.6a The same person seen from two reference frames. A passenger on the train sees the walker moving at +2 m/s. An observer on the ground sees the walker moving at +30 + 2 = +32 m/s. Velocities in different frames are related by a vector sum, which in one dimension is a signed sum.
To change frames in the other direction, subtract the velocity of the new observer from every velocity. If you ride in a car moving at \(+15\ \text{m/s}\), a neighboring car moving at \(+25\ \text{m/s}\) relative to the road is moving at \(25 - 15 = +10\ \text{m/s}\) relative to you, and your own car, of course, is at rest in your frame.
The two frames in Figure 1.6b describe the same pair of cars and the same motion.
Figure 1.6b The same two cars in two frames. Subtract the observer’s velocity from every velocity: in the frame of car B, B has velocity 15 − 15 = 0 and A has velocity 25 − 15 = +10 m/s. Accelerations are the same in both frames.
What changes and what does not
Positions, displacements and velocities all change when you change frames, because they all depend on where the origin is and how it moves. So does the kinetic energy of an object (Unit 3): the cup that is at rest on the train has zero kinetic energy in the train’s frame and a great deal in the road’s.
Acceleration, however, is the same in every inertial frame. Two frames that differ only by a constant velocity differ by a constant, and the change in velocity over any interval is the same for both. If the train is moving at constant velocity relative to the road, a coin dropped by a passenger falls with \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) downward in both frames.
This is why Newton’s laws, which link force to acceleration, can be used in any inertial frame and give the same predictions. It is also why you cannot detect your own constant velocity without looking outside: nothing you can measure about accelerations changes.
Worked example · cars on a highway
Car A is traveling at \(+25\ \text{m/s}\) and car B at \(+15\ \text{m/s}\), both in the same direction on a straight road. Car A is 200 m behind car B. (a) What is A’s velocity relative to B? (b) How long until A catches B?
(a) \(v_{A/B} = v_{A/G} - v_{B/G} = 25 - 15 = +10\ \text{m/s}\). In B’s frame, A approaches at 10 m/s.
(b) In B’s frame, A must cover the 200 m gap at a constant 10 m/s: \(t = \dfrac{200\ \text{m}}{10\ \text{m/s}} = 20\ \text{s}\).
Check in the road frame. In 20 s, A travels \((25)(20) = 500\ \text{m}\) and B travels \((15)(20) = 300\ \text{m}\). A has gained \(500 - 300 = 200\ \text{m}\). ✓ The frame of car B made the problem a one-line division.
Worked example · opposite directions
Car A is moving at \(+25\ \text{m/s}\) and car C is coming toward it at \(-20\ \text{m/s}\), as measured on the road. How fast does each appear to move from the other’s point of view?
Step 1. \(v_{A/C} = v_{A/G} - v_{C/G} = 25 - (-20) = +45\ \text{m/s}\). C sees A approaching at 45 m/s.
Step 2. \(v_{C/A} = -20 - 25 = -45\ \text{m/s}\). A sees C approaching at 45 m/s in the negative direction.
Interpretation. The relative speed is the sum of the two speeds when objects approach head-on. This is why a head-on crash at 25 m/s and 20 m/s feels like hitting a wall at 45 m/s from either car’s own frame.
Worked example · boat in a river
A boat can move at 5.0 m/s relative to the water. A river flows at 2.0 m/s. How long does a trip take that goes 210 m downstream and then 210 m back upstream? What is the average speed over the round trip?
Downstream. Take the current direction as positive. \(v_{\text{boat/ground}} = 5.0 + 2.0 = +7.0\ \text{m/s}\), so \(t_1 = 210/7.0 = 30\ \text{s}\).
Upstream. \(v_{\text{boat/ground}} = -5.0 + 2.0 = -3.0\ \text{m/s}\), a speed of 3.0 m/s, so \(t_2 = 210/3.0 = 70\ \text{s}\).
Round trip. The total time is \(30 + 70 = 100\ \text{s}\) for \(420\ \text{m}\), so the average speed is \(420/100 = 4.2\ \text{m/s}\), less than the 5.0 m/s still-water speed. The current helps for a short time and hinders for a long time, so it costs more than it gives.
Figure 1.6c A boat with a speed of 5 m/s relative to the water, in a river flowing at +2 m/s. Downstream the velocities add, 5 + 2 = +7 m/s relative to the ground. Pointing upstream (−5 m/s through the water) the sum is −5 + 2 = −3 m/s, so the boat still drifts backward relative to the ground.
Exam focus
State the frame. “The velocity of the ball” is incomplete without “relative to the ground” or “relative to the train.” Good answers name the frame.
Use the subscript chain. Write \(v_{A/G} = v_{A/B} + v_{B/G}\) before substituting, and check that the inner labels cancel.
Acceleration is the same. When a question asks what an observer in a different inertial frame would measure for acceleration, the answer is the same value. For velocity and kinetic energy it is different.
One dimension only. Relative-velocity questions on this exam are along a line, so signs do the work.
Pick the convenient frame. Switching to the frame of one of the objects often makes the other the only thing moving, which simplifies catch-up and passing problems.
Practice
A bus moves at \(+20\ \text{m/s}\). A passenger walks toward the rear at 1.5 m/s relative to the bus. What is the passenger’s velocity relative to the road?
Show answer
\(v = +20 + (-1.5) = +18.5\ \text{m/s}\).
Two trains, each 150 m long, approach on parallel tracks at \(+30\ \text{m/s}\) and \(-25\ \text{m/s}\) relative to the ground. How long do they take to pass completely, from the moment the fronts meet to the moment the rears separate?
Show answer
The relative speed is \(30 - (-25) = 55\ \text{m/s}\). The trains must move past each other by their combined length, \(300\ \text{m}\), so \(t = 300/55 = 5.5\ \text{s}\).
A swimmer who can swim at 1.5 m/s in still water swims 50 m upstream in a river that flows at 1.0 m/s, then returns downstream. Find the time for each leg.
Show answer
Upstream the ground speed is \(1.5 - 1.0 = 0.5\ \text{m/s}\), so \(t = 50/0.5 = 100\ \text{s}\). Downstream it is \(1.5 + 1.0 = 2.5\ \text{m/s}\), so \(t = 50/2.5 = 20\ \text{s}\).
A passenger in a train moving smoothly at constant velocity tosses a ball straight up. Describe where it lands relative to the passenger and explain using reference frames.
Show answer
It lands back in the passenger’s hand. In the train’s frame (inertial, since the train moves at constant velocity) the ball goes straight up and straight down, with acceleration \(g\) downward. The acceleration is the same in the ground frame, and the ball keeps the train’s forward velocity throughout, so it stays above the passenger.
An airplane has an airspeed of 200 m/s (its speed relative to the air) and flies into a headwind of 30 m/s. How long does it need to cover \(1.7 \times 10^5\ \text{m}\) along the ground?
Show answer
For an object that moves at constant acceleration, which quantities are the same when measured in two different inertial frames: position, velocity, acceleration, kinetic energy? Explain briefly.
Show answer
Only the acceleration. Two inertial frames differ by a constant relative velocity, which shifts every measured velocity by the same constant and so shifts position and kinetic energy as well. A constant does not change how fast the velocity changes, so the acceleration is the same.
Most real motion is not along a single line. A thrown ball rises and travels forward at the same time. A boat crossing a river is carried downstream while it heads for the other bank. A skier moves down a slope that is neither horizontal nor vertical.
The central idea of two-dimensional mechanics is a trick that turns every such problem back into one-dimensional problems: split each vector into two perpendicular components, solve the two straight-line problems separately, and put the answers back together. This lesson develops the trick; the next one uses it on projectiles, and it returns in Unit 2 with forces on inclines.
Learning objective · 1.5.A
Describe the perpendicular components of a vector.
Required content · EK 1.5.A.1 to 1.5.A.3
Vectors can be mathematically modeled as the resultant of two perpendicular components.
Vectors can be resolved into components using a chosen coordinate system.
Vectors can be resolved into perpendicular components using trigonometric functions and relationships: \(\sin\theta\), \(\cos\theta\), \(\tan\theta\), and \(a^2 + b^2 = c^2\).
Resolving a vector into components
Any vector in a plane can be replaced by two perpendicular vectors, usually along the horizontal and vertical axes, that together have exactly the same effect. These are its components. If a vector \(\vec{A}\) has magnitude \(A\) and makes an angle \(\theta\) with the positive \(x\)-axis, the right triangle in Figure 1.7a gives
\[ A_x = A\cos\theta, \qquad A_y = A\sin\theta. \]
The component along an axis is the “shadow” of the vector on that axis. When the vector lies along the axis (\(\theta = 0\)) its component is the whole vector, \(A_x = A\) and \(A_y = 0\); when it lies at right angles to the axis the shadow vanishes.
Figure 1.7a Resolving a vector into perpendicular components. With θ measured from the +x axis, Ax = A cos θ (adjacent) and Ay = A sin θ (opposite). Going the other way, A = √(Ax² + Ay²) and tan θ = Ay/Ax.
Going the other way, if you know the components, the magnitude of the vector and its direction follow from the Pythagorean relationship and the tangent:
\[ A = \sqrt{A_x^2 + A_y^2}, \qquad \tan\theta = \frac{A_y}{A_x}. \]
A reliable habit is to compute the angle from the absolute values of the components, then place it in the correct quadrant by looking at the signs. A calculator’s inverse tangent cannot distinguish \((+3, +4)\) from \((-3, -4)\), so always check the sketch.
Direction of the vector
sign of \(A_x\)
sign of \(A_y\)
up and to the right (first quadrant)
+
+
up and to the left (second)
\(-\)
+
down and to the left (third)
\(-\)
\(-\)
down and to the right (fourth)
+
\(-\)
Choosing the axes
The axes do not have to be horizontal and vertical. In Unit 2 you will often tilt them so that one axis runs parallel to the surface of an inclined plane, because that makes one of the two component problems trivial. The components depend on the axes you choose, but the vector itself does not. The skill is to choose axes that make the problem easiest, state them, and then resolve every vector in the problem onto those same axes.
Adding vectors by components
To add vectors in two dimensions, add their \(x\)-components to get the \(x\)-component of the resultant, and do the same for \(y\). The sum is independent of order, and it can be pictured by placing the vectors tip to tail: the resultant runs from the start of the first vector to the tip of the last (Figure 1.7b).
A displacement of 30 m east followed by one of 40 m north gives a resultant with \(R_x = 30\ \text{m}\), \(R_y = 40\ \text{m}\), a magnitude of 50 m and a direction of \(\tan^{-1}(40/30) = 53^\circ\) north of east. Notice that the magnitude of the resultant, 50 m, is less than the sum of the magnitudes, 70 m: magnitudes add only when the vectors point the same way.
Figure 1.7b Adding perpendicular vectors. Place the vectors tip to tail: the resultant runs from the start of the first to the tip of the last. Its components are the sums of the components, Rx = 30 m and Ry = 40 m, so R = √(30² + 40²) = 50 m at θ = tan−1(40/30) = 53° above the +x axis.
The same procedure applies to every vector quantity you meet: displacement, velocity, acceleration, and later force and momentum. It is the reason AP Physics 1 problems with several forces or velocities at angles are never harder than a table with two columns, one for each component.
Worked example · resolving a velocity
A ball leaves a bat with a speed of 25 m/s at an angle of 37\(^\circ\) above the horizontal. Find the horizontal and vertical components of its velocity.
Check. \(\sqrt{20.0^2 + 15.0^2} = \sqrt{400 + 225} = \sqrt{625} = 25\ \text{m/s}\). ✓ The numbers 15, 20, 25 form a 3-4-5 right triangle, which is why 37\(^\circ\) appears so often in problems.
Worked example · components to a vector
A particle has velocity components \(v_x = -6.0\ \text{m/s}\) and \(v_y = -8.0\ \text{m/s}\). Find its speed and the direction of its motion.
Angle. Using the absolute values, \(\tan\phi = 8.0/6.0\), so \(\phi = 53^\circ\). Both components are negative, so the vector points down and to the left: 53\(^\circ\) below the negative \(x\)-axis. (Measured counterclockwise from \(+x\), that is \(180^\circ + 53^\circ = 233^\circ\).)
Worked example · adding three displacements
A hiker walks 8.0 m east, then 6.0 m west, then 9.0 m north. Find the resultant displacement.
Components. With east as \(+x\) and north as \(+y\): \(R_x = +8.0 - 6.0 + 0 = +2.0\ \text{m}\) and \(R_y = 0 + 0 + 9.0 = +9.0\ \text{m}\).
Direction. \(\theta = \tan^{-1}(9.0/2.0) = 77^\circ\) north of east. The hiker has walked 23 m but is only 9.2 m from the start.
Exam focus
Always draw the triangle. Sketch the vector, mark the angle and say from which axis it is measured. Mixing up sine and cosine is the usual error, and the sketch prevents it.
Measured from the horizontal. For an angle from the horizontal, the horizontal component uses the cosine. For an angle from the vertical, the roles swap.
Use the same axes for every vector in one problem.
Keep signs. A component pointing in the negative direction is negative. The sign tells you the quadrant.
Calculator in degrees. Check the mode: \(\sin 30^\circ = 0.5\), not \(-0.988\).
Practice
A plane climbs at 200 m/s at 30\(^\circ\) above the horizontal. Find its horizontal speed and its rate of climb.
Show answer
An object slides 10 m along an incline that makes 30\(^\circ\) with the horizontal. Find the horizontal and vertical parts of the displacement.
Show answer
Horizontal: \(10\cos 30^\circ = 8.66\ \text{m}\). Vertical: \(10\sin 30^\circ = 5.0\ \text{m}\) (a drop, if it slides downhill).
A velocity has \(v_x = -3.0\ \text{m/s}\) and \(v_y = +4.0\ \text{m/s}\). Give its speed and direction.
Show answer
Speed \(= 5.0\ \text{m/s}\). \(\tan^{-1}(4.0/3.0) = 53^\circ\). The vector points up and to the left: 53\(^\circ\) above the negative \(x\)-axis, which is \(127^\circ\) from the positive \(x\)-axis.
Three students walk the displacements 20 m east, 20 m north and 20 m west. Find the net displacement.
Show answer
\(R_x = 20 - 20 = 0\), \(R_y = +20\ \text{m}\). The displacement is 20 m north.
A student claims a vector of magnitude 10 at 45\(^\circ\) has components of 10 and 10 because both axes see the whole arrow. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is wrong. At 45\(^\circ\) the two components are equal, but each is \(10\cos 45^\circ = 7.1\), and \(\sqrt{7.1^2 + 7.1^2} = 10\). Components of 10 and 10 would give a vector of magnitude 14, which is larger than the original.
A basketball arcing toward the hoop, water from a fountain, a stone skipped off a cliff: after the throw, the only force on each is gravity (when air resistance is small), and each follows the same curved path. The path is a parabola, and the reason it is a parabola is the most useful result of Unit 1: the horizontal and vertical motions are independent of each other.
The vertical motion is free fall that you already understand, and the horizontal motion is the simplest motion of all, a constant velocity. This lesson puts the two together.
Learning objective · 1.5.B
Describe the motion of an object moving in two dimensions.
Required content · EK 1.5.B.1 and 1.5.B.2
Motion in two dimensions can be analyzed using one-dimensional kinematic relationships if the motion is separated into components.
Projectile motion is a special case of two-dimensional motion that has zero acceleration in one dimension and constant, nonzero acceleration in the second dimension.
Two independent motions
A projectile is an object moving under the influence of gravity alone, after it has been launched. With up taken as positive and air resistance neglected:
Horizontal: \(a_x = 0\), so \(v_x\) is constant and \(x = x_0 + v_{x0}t\).
Vertical: \(a_y = -g = -10\ \text{m/s}^2\), so \(v_y = v_{y0} - gt\) and \(y = y_0 + v_{y0}t - \tfrac12 g t^2\).
The only thing the two motions share is the time. Time is the link: you find it from the vertical motion, which has the constant acceleration, and then use it in the horizontal motion to find how far the object has gone sideways. Figure 1.8a shows the result for a launch at 25 m/s: the horizontal arrow is the same length at every position, while the vertical arrow shrinks, vanishes at the peak and reverses.
Figure 1.8a Projectile motion split into components, dots every 0.5 s. The horizontal velocity arrow is the same length at every point because the horizontal acceleration is zero. The vertical arrow shrinks by 5 m/s each half second, vanishes at the top and then reverses, because the vertical acceleration is −10 m/s². The launch speed is 25 m/s at 37°.
A key consequence: the sideways motion does not change how fast the object falls. A ball rolled off a table and a ball dropped from the same height at the same moment hit the floor together, as Figure 1.8b shows with a cliff. The launched ball covers a great deal of ground sideways, but its vertical position at each instant matches the dropped ball’s exactly.
Figure 1.8b A ball launched horizontally at 15 m/s (red) and a ball dropped from rest at the same moment (blue). At every instant they are at the same height: the dashed lines are horizontal. The sideways motion has no effect on the vertical motion, so both fall 5 m, 20 m and 45 m in 1 s, 2 s and 3 s, and both land together.
The launch at an angle
For a launch at speed \(v_0\) at an angle \(\theta\) above the horizontal, resolve the initial velocity: \(v_{x0} = v_0\cos\theta\) and \(v_{y0} = v_0\sin\theta\). Then:
The time to the peak is when \(v_y = 0\): \(t_{\text{up}} = v_{y0}/g\).
The maximum height above the launch point is \(H = v_{y0}^2/(2g)\).
For a landing at the launch height, the time of flight is twice the time to the peak, \(T = 2v_{y0}/g\), and the range is \(R = v_{x0}T\).
At the peak the velocity is purely horizontal, \(v = v_{x0}\), the smallest speed of the flight. The acceleration there is still \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) downward.
For the same launch speed, the range is greatest at 45\(^\circ\) on level ground, and two angles that add up to 90\(^\circ\) have equal ranges, because \(R = (v_0^2/g)\sin 2\theta\). The steeper of the two paths rises higher and stays in the air longer (Figure 1.8c). These are results to remember, but the exam is more interested in your ability to explain them with the independence of the components than in your ability to recall them.
Figure 1.8c Five launches at the same speed, 20 m/s, over level ground. The range is greatest at 45° (40 m). Angles that add up to 90° give the same range: 15° and 75° both reach 20 m, and 30° and 60° both reach about 34.6 m, though the steeper launch stays in the air longer.
Component graphs complete the picture. The horizontal position \(x\) grows along a straight line and the horizontal velocity \(v_x\) is a flat line. The vertical velocity \(v_y\) falls along a straight line of slope \(-10\ \text{m/s}^2\) and the vertical position \(y\) is a downward-opening parabola. The vertical graphs are exactly the free-fall graphs of lesson 1.5.
Worked example · horizontal launch from a cliff
A ball is thrown horizontally at 15 m/s from the top of a 45 m cliff. How long is it in the air, how far from the base does it land, and what are the speed and direction of its velocity at impact?
Time. The vertical motion starts from rest vertically. With down positive, \(45 = \tfrac12(10)t^2\), so \(t = \sqrt{9.0} = 3.0\ \text{s}\).
Distance. \(x = v_x t = (15)(3.0) = 45\ \text{m}\).
Impact velocity. The horizontal component is still \(v_x = 15\ \text{m/s}\). The vertical component is \(v_y = gt = 30\ \text{m/s}\) downward. The speed is \(\sqrt{15^2 + 30^2} = \sqrt{1125} = 34\ \text{m/s}\), directed at \(\tan^{-1}(30/15) = 63^\circ\) below the horizontal.
Worked example · a ball launched from the ground
A ball is launched from level ground with a horizontal velocity component of 20 m/s and a vertical component of 15 m/s (a launch speed of 25 m/s at about 37\(^\circ\)). Find the time of flight, the maximum height and the range.
Peak. \(t_{\text{up}} = 15/10 = 1.5\ \text{s}\), so the time of flight is \(T = 3.0\ \text{s}\).
Height. \(H = \dfrac{15^2}{2(10)} = \dfrac{225}{20} = 11\ \text{m}\) (11.25 m, kept as 11 m to two significant figures).
Range. \(R = (20)(3.0) = 60\ \text{m}\).
At the peak, the velocity is 20 m/s horizontal and the acceleration is \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) down. The ball lands with the same speed it had at launch, 25 m/s, at 37\(^\circ\) below the horizontal.
Worked example · launched upward from a roof
A ball is thrown from the edge of a 15 m high roof with a horizontal component of 12 m/s and an upward component of 10 m/s. How far from the building does it land, and what is its speed on landing?
Time. The vertical motion is the cliff problem of lesson 1.5: \(-15 = 10t - 5t^2\), so \(t^2 - 2t - 3 = 0\) and \(t = 3.0\ \text{s}\).
Separate, solve, recombine. Write the vertical equations and the horizontal equations as two columns, with time as the common variable.
Horizontal acceleration is zero (no air resistance). A question that asks for the net acceleration at the top of a flight has the answer \(g\) downward, not zero.
Qualitative claims need a reason. To argue that two balls land together, say that they have the same vertical acceleration and the same initial vertical velocity, so the same vertical motion.
Speed versus components. The speed at any moment is \(\sqrt{v_x^2 + v_y^2}\); the smallest speed of a symmetric flight occurs at the top, where \(v_y = 0\).
Experiment design. A common free-response task is to predict the landing spot of a ball launched horizontally from a known height: measure the height and the launch speed, compute the time from the height, then the range.
Practice
A marble rolls off a table 1.25 m high at 2.0 m/s. How long does it fall and how far from the table does it land?
Show answer
A soccer ball is kicked from level ground at 20 m/s at 30\(^\circ\) above the horizontal. Find the time of flight, the maximum height and the range.
Show answer
A package is dropped from a plane flying horizontally at 80 m/s at an altitude of 500 m. Ignoring air resistance, how long does it fall, how far ahead of the drop point does it land, and where is the plane at that moment?
Show answer
\(t = \sqrt{2(500)/10} = 10\ \text{s}\). \(x = (80)(10) = 800\ \text{m}\) ahead of the release point. The package keeps the plane’s horizontal velocity, so if the plane continues unchanged it is directly above the package the whole time, 500 m above it when the package lands.
A projectile has horizontal velocity 12 m/s and initial vertical velocity 16 m/s. What are its speed and acceleration at the top of its path?
Show answer
At the top \(v_y = 0\), so the speed is just the horizontal component, 12 m/s. The acceleration is \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\) downward, as at every other point.
Two balls are launched at the same speed from level ground, one at 40\(^\circ\) and one at 50\(^\circ\). Which stays in the air longer and which goes farther? Explain.
Show answer
The 50\(^\circ\) ball has the larger vertical component, so it takes longer to rise and fall and stays in the air longer. The ranges are equal, because 40\(^\circ\) and 50\(^\circ\) add to 90\(^\circ\): the 40\(^\circ\) ball has the larger horizontal speed but less time, and the 50\(^\circ\) ball has the reverse, and the products are the same.
Sketch in words the four graphs, \(x\)–\(t\), \(y\)–\(t\), \(v_x\)–\(t\) and \(v_y\)–\(t\), for a ball thrown at an angle from level ground and landing at the same height.
Show answer
\(x\)–\(t\): a straight line with constant positive slope. \(y\)–\(t\): a downward-opening parabola starting and ending at zero. \(v_x\)–\(t\): a horizontal line at the launch value. \(v_y\)–\(t\): a straight line with slope \(-10\ \text{m/s}^2\), starting at the launch value, crossing zero at the peak and ending at the negative of the launch value.
Unit 1 practice · 10 problems
Unit 1 practice: Kinematics
Ten problems covering the whole unit, in roughly exam order. Work each one
on paper before revealing the answer: the reveal shows the governing
equation, the substitution, and the answer with units. Use
\(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as the exam does. A calculator is fine for the arithmetic.
A hiker walks 12 m north, then 5.0 m east, taking 10 s. Find the distance traveled, the displacement (magnitude and direction), the average speed, and the average velocity.
Show answer
Distance is path length: \(12 + 5.0 = 17\) m. Displacement is the straight arrow from start to finish: \(|\Delta\vec{x}| = \sqrt{12^2 + 5.0^2} = 13\) m at \(\tan^{-1}(5.0/12) = 23^\circ\) east of north. Average speed \(= 17\ \text{m}/10\ \text{s} = 1.7\) m/s. Average velocity \(= \Delta\vec{x}/\Delta t = 13\ \text{m}/10\ \text{s} = 1.3\) m/s, 23° east of north.
A position–time graph rises in a straight line from \(x = 0\) at \(t = 0\) to \(x = 20\) m at \(t = 5.0\) s, is flat until \(t = 8.0\) s, then falls in a straight line to \(x = -10\) m at \(t = 13\) s. Find the velocity in each segment, the total distance traveled, and the displacement.
Show answer
Velocity is the slope of \(x\)–\(t\). Segment 1: \(v = \dfrac{20\ \text{m}}{5.0\ \text{s}} = +4.0\) m/s. Segment 2: \(v = 0\) (at rest). Segment 3: \(v = \dfrac{-10 - 20\ \text{m}}{5.0\ \text{s}} = -6.0\) m/s. Distance \(= 20 + 0 + 30 = 50\) m; displacement \(= x_f - x_0 = -10\) m (10 m in the negative direction). The \(v\)–\(t\) graph is three horizontal steps at \(+4.0\), \(0\), and \(-6.0\) m/s.
A velocity–time graph rises in a straight line from 0 to 12 m/s during the first 4.0 s, stays at 12 m/s until \(t = 10\) s, then falls in a straight line to 0 at \(t = 12\) s. Find the acceleration in each part and the total displacement.
Show answer
Acceleration is the slope of \(v\)–\(t\): \(a_1 = \dfrac{12\ \text{m/s}}{4.0\ \text{s}} = 3.0\) m/s², \(a_2 = 0\), \(a_3 = \dfrac{0 - 12\ \text{m/s}}{2.0\ \text{s}} = -6.0\) m/s². Displacement is the area: triangle \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)(12) = 24\) m, rectangle \((6.0)(12) = 72\) m, triangle \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(12) = 12\) m. Total \(\Delta x = 108\) m.
A car traveling at 30 m/s brakes with constant acceleration and stops in 75 m. Find the acceleration and the time to stop.
Show answer
No time given, so use \(v_x^2 = v_{x0}^2 + 2a_x(x - x_0)\): \(0 = (30\ \text{m/s})^2 + 2a_x(75\ \text{m})\), so \(a_x = -\dfrac{900}{150} = -6.0\) m/s² (opposite the velocity). Then \(v_x = v_{x0} + a_x t\): \(t = \dfrac{0 - 30\ \text{m/s}}{-6.0\ \text{m/s}^2} = 5.0\) s.
A ball is thrown straight up at 25 m/s from ground level. Find its maximum height, its total time in the air, and its velocity just before it lands.
Show answer
Up positive, \(a_y = -10\) m/s². At the top \(v_y = 0\): \(y_{\max} = \dfrac{v_{y0}^2}{2g} = \dfrac{(25\ \text{m/s})^2}{2(10\ \text{m/s}^2)} = 31\) m (31.25 m). Time up: \(t = \dfrac{25}{10} = 2.5\) s, so total flight \(= 5.0\) s by symmetry. It lands at 25 m/s downward: same speed as launch, opposite direction.
At the highest point of the ball's flight in the previous problem, which statement is correct?
The velocity is indeed zero for an instant, but acceleration is the rate of change of velocity, and the velocity is changing from upward to downward right through that instant. If \(a\) were zero at the top, the ball would hover there.
The velocity passes through zero as it reverses, but gravity acts the whole time, so \(a = -g\), or 10 m/s² downward, at the top just as everywhere else in the flight.
For a ball thrown straight up, the velocity at the peak is exactly zero: that is what defines the peak. And free-fall acceleration is never zero while gravity acts, so both halves of this statement fail.
Nothing about the motion points upward at the peak: the velocity is momentarily zero, and the acceleration due to gravity is downward throughout. Confusing “was moving up” with “is accelerating up” is the misconception here.
A truck moves at \(+18\) m/s along a straight road. A car 90 m behind it moves at \(+27\) m/s in the same direction. Find (a) the velocity of the car relative to the truck, (b) the time for the car to catch up, and (c) the distance the car travels in that time.
Show answer
(a) \(v_{\text{car/truck}} = v_{\text{car/ground}} - v_{\text{truck/ground}} = 27 - 18 = +9\) m/s. (b) In the truck’s frame the car must close a 90 m gap at 9 m/s: \(t = 90/9 = 10\) s. (c) In the road frame the car travels \((27)(10) = 270\) m, while the truck travels 180 m; the difference is the 90 m gap.
A ball is kicked from level ground at 25 m/s, 30° above the horizontal. Find the time of flight, the range, and the maximum height.
Show answer
Components: \(v_{x0} = 25\cos 30^\circ = 21.7\) m/s, \(v_{y0} = 25\sin 30^\circ = 12.5\) m/s. Lands when \(y = 0\): \(0 = v_{y0}t - \tfrac{1}{2}gt^2 \Rightarrow t = \dfrac{2v_{y0}}{g} = \dfrac{2(12.5)}{10} = 2.5\) s. Range \(x = v_{x0}t = (21.65)(2.5) = 54\) m. Max height, where \(v_y = 0\): \(y_{\max} = \dfrac{v_{y0}^2}{2g} = \dfrac{(12.5)^2}{20} = 7.8\) m.
Three identical balls are thrown from the edge of a 30 m cliff, all at 20 m/s: ball X horizontally, ball Y at 30° above the horizontal, ball Z at 30° below the horizontal. Ignore air resistance. Rank the balls by time in the air, then by speed just before landing. Explain each ranking in words.
Show answer
Time: \(Y \gt X \gt Z\). Only the vertical motion sets the flight time. Y starts with upward velocity and must rise and fall back before descending the cliff; X starts with zero vertical velocity; Z starts already moving downward and reaches the ground soonest. Landing speed: \(X = Y = Z\). Gravity is the only force, and \(v^2 = v_0^2 + 2g\,\Delta h\) holds for the full velocity regardless of launch angle: the same 20 m/s launch and the same 30 m drop give the same landing speed, \(\sqrt{20^2 + 2(10)(30)} = 32\) m/s. (Unit 3 says the same thing with energy.) Their landing directions differ.
Experimental design. You have a steel ball, a meterstick, and a motion sensor or high-speed camera that records position versus time. Describe a procedure to measure \(g\), say what graph you would make and how you would get \(g\) from it, and name one way to reduce the uncertainty.
Show answer
Drop the ball from rest from several measured heights \(h\) (e.g. 0.5 m to 2.0 m) and record the fall time \(t\) for each; repeat each height at least three times and average. Since \(h = \tfrac{1}{2}gt^2\) for release from rest, plot \(h\) on the vertical axis against \(t^2\) on the horizontal axis: the data should be a straight line through the origin with slope \(g/2\), so \(g = 2 \times \text{slope}\) (expected slope 5 m/s²). Reduce uncertainty by using the sensor or frame-by-frame video rather than a hand-held stopwatch (reaction time is comparable to the fall time), using the larger heights, and fitting a best-fit line rather than using one point.
Unit 1 described how things move. Unit 2 asks why they move that way, and the first step is deciding what is moving. A bicycle and its rider can be treated as one thing or as two; a spacecraft can be treated as a single dot or as a tank full of sloshing fuel. The choice is yours, and it is one of the most important decisions in a physics solution, because it determines which forces count and which do not.
This lesson introduces the idea of a system, the difference between internal and external interactions, and the single point, the center of mass, that lets an extended system move as though it were one object.
Learning objectives · 2.1.A and 2.1.B
Describe the properties and interactions of a system. Describe the location of a system’s center of mass with respect to the system’s constituent parts.
Required content · EK 2.1.A.1 to 2.1.B.3
System properties are determined by the interactions between objects within the system.
If the properties or interactions of the constituent objects within a system are not important in modeling the behavior of the macroscopic system, the system can itself be treated as a single object.
Systems may allow interactions between constituent parts of the system and the environment, which may result in the transfer of energy or mass.
Individual objects within a chosen system may behave differently from each other as well as from the system as a whole. The internal structure of a system affects the analysis of that system. As variables external to a system are changed, the system’s substructure may change.
For systems with symmetrical mass distributions, the center of mass is located on lines of symmetry. The location of a system’s center of mass along a given axis can be calculated using \(x_{\text{cm}} = \sum m_i x_i / \sum m_i\).
A system can be modeled as a singular object that is located at the system’s center of mass.
Boundary statement
AP Physics 1 only expects students to calculate the center of mass for systems of five or fewer particles arranged in a two-dimensional configuration or for systems that are highly symmetrical.
What a system is
A system is whatever collection of objects you decide to analyze. Everything else is the environment (or surroundings). The boundary between them is imaginary, a dashed line you draw in your head or on the page, and you can put it wherever it is most useful, as long as you stay with your choice for the whole problem.
Sometimes the system is a single object: a ball in flight, a hockey puck. The word object in physics means a system whose internal structure does not matter for the question at hand, so that it can be treated as a point with mass (the object model of lesson 1.2). A car driving down a highway can be an object when you want to know how far it travels. If you want to know what happens to a passenger when the car brakes, the car and the passenger are now two parts of a larger system, and the object model is no longer enough, because the passenger and the car do not behave identically.
Systems are not always rigid. A system of two carts joined by a spring can change shape; a system of a gas in a cylinder can be compressed. The internal structure matters when the parts can move relative to each other, and when external conditions change (pushing on a spring, heating a gas), the structure itself can change. The system also exchanges things with its surroundings: a cup of coffee loses energy to the room, a rocket loses mass as it burns fuel. The accounting depends on where you draw the boundary.
Internal and external interactions
Forces that one part of the system exerts on another part are internal. Forces that come from objects outside the boundary are external. Figure 2.1c shows a person pushing a cart. If the system is the cart alone, the person’s push is external and speeds the cart up. If the system is the person plus the cart, the push is internal: two parts of the system push on each other, and the system as a whole does not get a net push from it. The only horizontal external force on the person-plus-cart system is friction from the ground.
Figure 2.1c The choice of system decides which forces are external. Around the cart alone, the person’s push is an external force that changes the cart’s velocity. Around person plus cart, the push is a pair of internal forces that cannot change the center-of-mass velocity of the system; only external forces, such as friction from the ground, can.
This distinction will drive two of the most important principles of the course. In Newton’s second law (lesson 2.5), only external forces change the velocity of a system’s center of mass. In conservation of energy (Unit 3) and conservation of momentum (Unit 4), the first step is always to choose a system so that you can say which interactions are internal and which are external.
The center of mass
When an extended system moves, different parts go different ways: a thrown wrench tumbles end over end and a diver somersaults. Remarkably, there is always one point whose path is simple. The center of mass is the mass-weighted average position of the system, and under gravity alone it follows the smooth parabola of a projectile, however the rest of the system spins. Wherever the center of mass is, you may treat the whole system as a single object located there, with all the system’s mass.
For a symmetric, uniform object the center of mass lies on the lines of symmetry: the middle of a rod, the center of a ball, the center of a ring (even though there is no material there), as in Figure 2.1b. For a lopsided object, such as a bat, it is displaced toward the heavier part.
Figure 2.1b Centers of mass. For a symmetric, uniform object the center of mass lies on the lines of symmetry. It need not lie inside the material: the center of mass of a ring is at its empty center. For a bat, whose mass is not spread evenly, it lies closer to the heavy end.
For a set of particles along an axis, the location is a weighted average,
\[ x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2 + \cdots}{m_1 + m_2 + \cdots} = \frac{\sum m_i x_i}{\sum m_i}, \]
and the same formula applies separately to \(y\) in two dimensions. A heavier particle pulls the average toward itself, so the center of mass lies closer to the heavier mass and always between the particles (Figure 2.1a). With two masses on a line, it divides the distance between them in inverse proportion to the masses.
Figure 2.1a The center of mass of two masses lies on the line between them, closer to the heavier one. A single support placed there would balance the pair. The same calculation, a mass-weighted average of the positions, works for any collection of up to five particles.
Worked example · two masses on a line
A 3.0 kg block is at \(x = 0\) and a 5.0 kg block is at \(x = 2.0\ \text{m}\). Find the center of mass.
Check. The answer lies between 0 and 2.0 m, and closer to the heavier block (0.75 m from it, against 1.25 m from the lighter one). The distances are in the ratio 3 to 5, the inverse of the masses. ✓
Worked example · three particles in a plane
Three particles are placed at the following coordinates: 2.0 kg at \((0, 0)\), 3.0 kg at \((4.0\ \text{m}, 0)\) and 5.0 kg at \((0, 3.0\ \text{m})\). Locate the center of mass.
The center of mass is at \((1.2\ \text{m}, 1.5\ \text{m})\). It is nearer the 5.0 kg particle than the other two, as expected, and it does not sit on any of the particles.
Worked example · internal forces cannot move the center of mass
A 60 kg skater and a 40 kg skater stand on frictionless ice 10 m apart, holding the two ends of a taut rope. They pull on the rope and glide toward each other. Where do they meet?
System. Take both skaters and the rope as the system. The pulls through the rope are internal. The only external forces, gravity and the normal force from the ice, are vertical and cancel, so no external horizontal force acts, and the horizontal position of the center of mass cannot change.
Center of mass. Put the 60 kg skater at \(x = 0\) and the 40 kg skater at \(x = 10\ \text{m}\): \(x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{(60)(0) + (40)(10)}{100} = 4.0\ \text{m}\).
Result. The skaters meet at \(x = 4.0\ \text{m}\): the lighter skater slides 6.0 m while the heavier one slides only 4.0 m. Pulling harder, or one skater pulling alone while the other holds the rope loosely, changes nothing about where they meet.
Exam focus
Say what your system is. A good free-response answer begins “Choose the system to be the block and the cart,” and then classifies each force as internal or external.
Internal forces cancel in pairs. The forces that parts of a system exert on one another are equal and opposite (Newton’s third law, lesson 2.3), so they cannot change the motion of the center of mass.
The center of mass need not be on the object. A ring, a boomerang or a horseshoe has its center of mass in empty space.
Weighted average. Use the masses as weights. An unweighted average of the positions is the most common mistake.
Limits. Expect no more than five particles, or highly symmetrical shapes.
Practice
Particles of 1.0 kg, 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg are at \(x = 0\), \(x = 3.0\ \text{m}\) and \(x = 6.0\ \text{m}\). Find the center of mass.
Show answer
A light rod 1.0 m long has a 4.0 kg mass at one end and a 1.0 kg mass at the other. How far from the 4.0 kg mass is the center of mass?
Show answer
Put the 4.0 kg mass at \(x = 0\): \(x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{(4.0)(0) + (1.0)(1.0)}{5.0} = 0.20\ \text{m}\) from the heavy end.
Particles: 2.0 kg at \((0, 0)\), 2.0 kg at \((6.0, 0)\) and 4.0 kg at \((3.0, 4.0)\), in meters. Find the center of mass.
Show answer
\(x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{0 + 12 + 12}{8.0} = 3.0\ \text{m}\); \(y_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{0 + 0 + 16}{8.0} = 2.0\ \text{m}\). The center of mass is at \((3.0\ \text{m}, 2.0\ \text{m})\).
For the system of a block sliding on a table, and the table, is the friction between them an internal or an external force? What if the system is just the block?
Show answer
For the block-plus-table system, friction is internal: it is an interaction between two parts of the system. For the block alone, friction is an external force exerted by the table, and it changes the block’s velocity.
A student claims the center of mass of a hollow metal ring must be on the metal, since that is where the mass is. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is incorrect. The center of mass is the mass-weighted average position. For a uniform ring, the average of all the positions around the circle is the center of the circle, where there is no material at all. For symmetric systems the center of mass is on the lines of symmetry, whether or not material is there.
An astronaut floating far from any planet throws a wrench away. Explain what happens to the center of mass of the astronaut-plus-wrench system.
Show answer
Nothing happens to it. The push between astronaut and wrench is internal, and no external force acts, so the center-of-mass velocity stays constant (here, zero, if both started at rest). The astronaut recoils in the opposite direction, so the center of mass stays put.
Kinematics tells you how an object moves. A force tells you why it moves that way. Every problem in the rest of the course, from a block on a ramp to a satellite in orbit, begins with the same question: what are all the forces on this object? The tool that answers it is the free-body diagram, a simple picture that, when drawn carefully, does about half the work of the solution. Students who skip it tend to forget a force, add one that does not exist, or put an arrow in the wrong direction. This lesson teaches what a force is, where real forces come from and the exact conventions the AP exam uses for free-body diagrams.
Learning objectives · 2.2.A and 2.2.B
Describe a force as an interaction between two objects or systems. Describe the forces exerted on an object or system using a free-body diagram.
Required content · EK 2.2.A.1 to 2.2.B.4
Forces are vector quantities that describe the interactions between objects or systems. A force exerted on an object or system is always due to the interaction of that object with another object or system. An object or system cannot exert a net force on itself.
Contact forces describe the interaction of an object or system touching another object or system and are macroscopic effects of interatomic electric forces.
Free-body diagrams are useful tools for visualizing forces being exerted on a single object or system and for determining the equations that represent a physical situation. The free-body diagram of an object or system shows each of the forces exerted on the object by the environment.
Forces exerted on an object or system are represented as vectors originating from the representation of the center of mass, such as a dot. A system is treated as though all of its mass is located at the center of mass.
A coordinate system with one axis parallel to the direction of acceleration of the object or system simplifies the translation from free-body diagram to algebraic representation. For example, in a free-body diagram of an object on an inclined plane, it is useful to set one axis parallel to the surface of the incline.
Boundary statement
AP Physics 1 only expects students to depict the forces exerted on objects, not the force components on free-body diagrams. On the AP Physics exams, individual forces represented on a free-body diagram must be drawn as individual straight arrows, originating on the dot and pointing in the direction of the force. Individual forces that are in the same direction must be drawn side by side, not overlapping.
A force is an interaction
A force is a push or a pull, but the important word in the definition is interaction. A force always involves two objects: one that exerts the force and one that has it exerted on it. “The table pushes up on the book” is a force. “An upward force” with no agent is not, and neither is a force that an object exerts on itself: you cannot lift yourself by pulling on your own hair, and a car cannot accelerate by pushing on its own windshield from inside. Name every force with an agent and a victim: the force of something on something. The SI unit of force is the newton (N), where \(1\ \text{N} = 1\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}^2\).
Forces come in two kinds. Contact forces need the two objects to touch. They include the normal force, friction, tension in a rope, the push of a spring and a push by a hand. At the atomic level they are all electric repulsions or attractions between the atoms at the two surfaces, but on the scale of everyday objects they behave as simple pushes and pulls. The only noncontact force in AP Physics 1 is gravity, the pull of one mass on another at a distance. If an arrow on your diagram is neither gravity nor something that touches the object, it should not be there.
Force
Symbol
Direction
When it appears
Gravity
\(F_g = mg\)
straight down, toward the center of Earth
always, for anything near Earth
Normal
\(F_N\)
perpendicular to the surface, away from it
whenever the object touches a surface
Friction
\(F_f\)
parallel to the surface, opposing sliding (or its tendency)
when there is contact with a rough surface
Tension
\(F_T\) or \(T\)
along the string, pulling away from the object
when a string, rope or cable is attached
Spring
\(F_s\)
along the spring, toward its relaxed length
when a stretched or compressed spring is attached
Applied push or pull
\(F_A\)
the direction of the push
when a hand, engine or person pushes or pulls
Figure 2.2b Every force on an object comes from another object, and you should be able to name it: “the normal force, exerted by the table.” If you cannot name what is pushing or pulling, there is no force. Contact forces (normal, friction, tension, spring) need touching. Gravity is the only noncontact force in AP Physics 1.
Drawing a free-body diagram
A free-body diagram (FBD) shows one object, or one system treated as an object, isolated from everything else, with an arrow for every force the environment exerts on it. The AP conventions are strict, and exam graders deduct for breaking them:
Represent the object as a dot (its center of mass). Do not draw a box or a sketch of the object on the diagram; draw only the dot.
Draw each force as a single straight arrow that begins on the dot and points in the direction of the force. Forces in the same direction are drawn side by side, not on top of each other.
Draw only forces exerted on the object. The forces the object exerts on other things belong on other diagrams.
Label each arrow with the type of force, for example \(F_g\), \(F_N\), \(F_f\), \(F_T\), ideally with its agent (“\(F_{\text{table on block}}\)”).
Make the lengths match the physics. If the object is not accelerating up or down, the upward arrows must equal the downward ones in total length. If it speeds up to the right, the rightward arrows must be longer than the leftward ones.
Do not draw components. A force at an angle is drawn as one arrow at that angle; resolving it into components is done in your equations, not on the diagram.
Figure 2.2a Four free-body diagrams. Each has a dot for the object, only the forces exerted on the object, and straight arrows that start on the dot. Arrow length tells the relative size of the force. Where the object is not accelerating vertically, the arrows up and down are equal.
The gallery in Figure 2.2a shows four typical diagrams. The book at rest has two forces of equal size. The sliding block has a normal force and a gravitational force that balance each other vertically; the push to the right is longer than the friction to the left, so the block speeds up. The hanging object has only tension and gravity. The block on the ramp has a normal force perpendicular to the surface (so not vertical), friction parallel to the surface and up the slope, and gravity straight down.
Choosing axes for the equations
Once the diagram is right, you turn it into equations by choosing axes. The best choice puts one axis along the direction in which the object accelerates (or would accelerate). On a level floor, use horizontal and vertical. On a ramp, tilt the axes so that one runs parallel to the surface and the other perpendicular to it. Then the acceleration lies along one axis, the other axis has zero acceleration, and every force is either along an axis or must be split into components using the angle. The gravitational force is the only one that you must split on a ramp. You will do this in lessons 2.4 and 2.7.
Worked example · a book at rest
A 2.0 kg book rests on a level table. Draw and describe the free-body diagram, and give the magnitude of each force.
Forces. Two forces act on the book: gravity, \(F_g = mg = (2.0)(10) = 20\ \text{N}\), straight down, exerted by Earth; and the normal force, straight up, exerted by the table.
Sizes. The book is at rest, so it is not accelerating, and the up and down forces must balance: \(F_N = 20\ \text{N}\). The two arrows are drawn the same length. Note that the normal force equals the weight here, because nothing else is pushing or pulling vertically; this is not a general rule.
Worked example · a ball in flight
A ball is thrown upward. Draw the free-body diagram at three moments: just after release moving up, at the top, and on the way down. Ignore air resistance.
All three diagrams are identical. Each shows one arrow: gravity, \(F_g = mg\), pointing down. Once the ball leaves the hand, nothing touches it, and gravity is the only force. There is no upward arrow for “the force of the throw”: the hand’s force ended at release, and velocity is a quantity of motion, not a force. This is why the ball slows while rising, stops at the top and speeds up while falling, all with the same downward acceleration.
Worked example · a block pushed at constant speed
A person pushes a crate to the right across a rough floor at constant velocity. List the forces, say which are equal in size and explain why.
Forces. Gravity down, normal up (the floor), a push to the right (the person) and friction to the left (the floor).
Equalities. The velocity is constant, so the acceleration is zero in both directions. Vertically, \(F_N = F_g\). Horizontally, the push equals the friction. The push is not larger than the friction: if it were, the crate would speed up. Constant velocity means balanced forces, not “a force in the direction of motion.”
Exam focus
One dot, arrows from the dot. The most frequent deductions are for drawing a box instead of a dot, for arrows that do not begin on the dot, and for drawing two forces on top of each other.
No components, no velocity, no acceleration. Do not put \(v\), \(a\) or \(ma\) on a free-body diagram; they are not forces. Mark acceleration separately, beside the diagram, if you want to show it.
Name the agent. If you cannot say what object exerts a force, it is not a force. “Force of motion,” “force of the throw” and “centripetal force” as an extra arrow are all errors.
Normal force is not always \(mg\). It is whatever the surface must push with so that the object does not move through it.
Make arrow lengths consistent with the motion described in the question.
Practice
A hockey puck slides at constant velocity on frictionless ice. Which forces act on it?
Show answer
Only two: gravity downward and the normal force upward from the ice, equal in size. There is no horizontal force at all. Constant velocity does not need a force in the direction of motion.
List the forces on a skier moving down a snowy slope at a constant speed.
Show answer
Gravity (down), the normal force from the snow (perpendicular to the slope, away from it) and friction from the snow (parallel to the slope, up the slope), and air resistance if it is included (up the slope). Because the speed is constant, the forces balance: the components of gravity along the slope are matched by friction and drag.
A 5.0 kg block is pushed down onto a table by a 30 N downward force from a hand. What is the normal force on the block?
Show answer
The block is at rest vertically. The downward forces are gravity, \((5.0)(10) = 50\ \text{N}\), and the hand, 30 N, for a total of 80 N. The normal force balances them: \(F_N = 80\ \text{N}\), larger than the weight.
Which of the following are forces on a car coasting uphill after the driver lets off the gas: the force of its motion, gravity, the normal force, friction from the road, the force of the engine?
Show answer
Gravity, the normal force from the road and friction (and air resistance) are forces. “The force of its motion” is not a force. With the engine disengaged there is no driving force, although a rolling car also has rolling resistance from the road.
A student draws the free-body diagram of a box on a ramp with two arrows for the weight, one parallel to the ramp and one perpendicular to it. What is wrong?
Show answer
Components do not belong on an AP free-body diagram. The weight must be a single arrow pointing straight down from the dot. The parallel and perpendicular components appear only in the equations, after the axes have been chosen.
Explain why a sailboat cannot be driven by a fan mounted on the boat and blowing on its own sail.
Show answer
If the system is the boat, fan and sail together, the force the fan exerts on the air and the force the air exerts on the sail are both internal to the system. An object or system cannot exert a net force on itself, so there is no net external horizontal force, and the boat does not accelerate (apart from small effects of the outside air).
When you push on a wall, the wall pushes back. When a bat strikes a ball, the ball strikes the bat. When Earth pulls on you, you pull on Earth. Forces never come alone: each is one half of an interaction between two objects, and the other half is always there. Newton’s third law states this precisely. It is the principle behind rocket flight, walking, swimming and every collision, and it is also one of the most commonly misapplied laws on the exam, so this lesson spends time on the three conditions that identify a true third-law pair.
Learning objective · 2.3.A
Describe the interaction of two objects using Newton’s third law and a representation of paired forces exerted on each object.
Required content · EK 2.3.A.1 to 2.3.A.3
Newton’s third law describes the interaction of two objects in terms of the paired forces that each exerts on the other: \(\vec{F}_{A\text{ on }B} = -\vec{F}_{B\text{ on }A}\).
Interactions between objects within a system (internal forces) do not influence the motion of a system’s center of mass.
Tension is the macroscopic net result of forces that segments of a string, cable, chain, or similar system exert on each other in response to an external force. An ideal string has negligible mass and does not stretch when under tension. The tension in an ideal string is the same at all points within the string. In a string with nonnegligible mass, tension may not be the same at all points within the string. An ideal pulley has negligible mass and rotates about an axle through its center of mass with negligible friction.
Boundary statements
AP Physics 1 only expects students to describe tension qualitatively in a string, cable, chain, or similar system with mass. For example, students might note that the tension in a hanging chain is greater toward the top of the chain. The interaction between objects or systems at a distance is limited to gravitational forces in AP Physics 1.
The law and its three conditions
Newton’s third law: if object A exerts a force on object B, then object B exerts a force on object A that is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction,
\[ \vec{F}_{A\text{ on }B} = -\vec{F}_{B\text{ on }A}. \]
The two forces form a third-law pair, and a true pair always satisfies all three of these conditions:
Different objects. One force acts on A and the other acts on B. They never act on the same object, so they can never be added together, and they can never “cancel” to produce equilibrium.
Same type. A gravitational force is paired with a gravitational force, a normal force with a normal force, friction with friction.
Equal magnitude, opposite direction, and simultaneous. Neither force comes first; they exist and end together.
A pair is easy to name once you swap the two objects. If the force is “Earth on book (gravity),” its partner is “book on Earth (gravity).” If it is “table on book (normal),” the partner is “book on table (normal).” Figure 2.3a shows both pairs for a book on a table.
Figure 2.3a Two third-law pairs. Blue pair: the table pushes up on the book, and the book pushes down on the table. Orange pair: Earth pulls down on the book, and the book pulls up on Earth. The members of a pair are equal in size and opposite in direction, always act on different objects, and are always the same kind of force. The up and down forces on the book balance by Newton’s first law, not by the third.
The figure also corrects the most popular mistake. On the book itself, the normal force up and the gravitational force down happen to be equal when the book is at rest, and students often call them a third-law pair. They are not: they act on the same object, they are different types of force, and if you pressed down on the book with your hand, they would no longer be equal while the third-law pairs still would be. The two forces on the book balance because of Newton’s first law (lesson 2.4), not the third.
Equal forces, unequal effects
The forces of a pair are equal, yet the objects often respond very differently, because the effect of a force depends on the object’s mass (Newton’s second law, lesson 2.5). When a heavy truck and a light car collide, each exerts the same size of force on the other. The car, with one tenth of the mass, has ten times the acceleration. When Earth pulls you down with a force of 600 N, you pull Earth up with a force of 600 N, and the Earth’s acceleration is far too small to notice because its mass is so large.
Figure 2.3b In a collision the truck and the car exert forces on each other that are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. The effects differ because the masses differ: by Newton’s second law the lighter car has the much larger acceleration.
The third law also explains how motion begins. A walker pushes backward on the ground with her foot, the ground pushes forward on her with an equal friction force, and the forward force is what accelerates her. A swimmer pushes water back; the water pushes the swimmer forward. A rocket pushes exhaust gas down; the gas pushes the rocket up. In each case a force that you apply to the world is paired with the force by which the world accelerates you.
Internal forces and the system
If both objects of a pair are inside the system you have chosen, the two forces are equal and opposite and act within the system. They cannot give the system as a whole a net push, so they do not influence the motion of the system’s center of mass. This is the law behind lesson 2.1’s skaters, who meet at the center of mass no matter how they pull. It is also why you can tell exactly when a force matters: only the forces between the system and objects outside it can change the center-of-mass velocity.
Tension, strings and pulleys
Tension is the force a string, rope or cable transmits along its length. It always pulls on the objects attached to its ends, directed along the string and away from the object. Inside the string, every segment is pulled from both sides by its neighbors, and these internal pulls are what we call tension. For many problems, the string is modeled as ideal: negligible mass and no stretch. Two consequences make solutions easy. First, an ideal string has the same tension at every point, because a segment of negligible mass with unequal pulls would have an infinite acceleration. Second, because it does not stretch, objects tied to its ends and moving along it have the same speed and the same magnitude of acceleration.
An ideal pulley has negligible mass and turns without friction. Its only job is to redirect the string, so the tension on both sides of an ideal pulley is the same. A hanging mass of 3.0 kg held motionless by a string over an ideal pulley has \(T = mg = 30\ \text{N}\) in the string, which means 30 N on the other side as well.
Figure 2.3c Tension is the macroscopic result of the pulls that the pieces of a string, cable or chain exert on each other. In an ideal string (negligible mass, no stretch) the tension is the same at all points. In a chain whose own weight matters, each link must also support the links below it, so the tension is greatest at the top.
If the string has non-negligible mass, tension is no longer uniform. Think of a heavy chain hanging from a hook. The top link must support the whole chain, and the lowest link only itself, so the tension is greatest at the top and decreases down the chain (Figure 2.3c). AP Physics 1 only asks you to describe this qualitatively.
Worked example · a collision
A 10 000 kg truck and a 1000 kg car collide head-on. During the collision the truck exerts a force of 40 000 N on the car. (a) What force does the car exert on the truck? (b) Compare the magnitudes of their accelerations.
(a) By the third law, the car exerts a force of 40 000 N on the truck, in the opposite direction. The force on the car is not larger just because the truck is larger.
(b) With \(a = F/m\): \(a_{\text{truck}} = \dfrac{40\,000}{10\,000} = 4.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) and \(a_{\text{car}} = \dfrac{40\,000}{1000} = 40\ \text{m/s}^2\). The car’s acceleration is ten times larger, the reverse of the masses, which is why the occupants of the car are far more likely to be hurt.
Worked example · identifying third-law partners
A person stands on a floor. Name the third-law partner of each force on the person: (a) Earth’s gravity on the person, (b) the floor’s normal force on the person.
(a) The partner of “Earth pulls the person down” is “the person pulls Earth up,” a gravitational force acting on Earth.
(b) The partner of “floor pushes the person up” is “the person pushes the floor down,” a normal (contact) force acting on the floor.
Common error. The partner of the person’s weight is not the normal force. Swapping the objects always gives you the partner: if you did not swap the objects, you did not find the partner.
Worked example · a string over a pulley
A 2.0 kg block hangs from a string that passes over an ideal pulley and is tied to a wall on the other side. The block is at rest. What is the tension in the string, and what force does the string exert on the wall?
Block. At rest, so \(T = mg = (2.0)(10) = 20\ \text{N}\) (up on the block).
Wall. An ideal string has the same tension throughout, and an ideal pulley does not change it, so the string pulls on the wall with 20 N, directed along the string away from the wall’s end. The wall pulls back on the string with 20 N (third-law pair).
Exam focus
Name the pair with agent and victim. “The force of the truck on the car” and “the force of the car on the truck.” An answer that names only one object is not a pair.
Pairs never appear on the same free-body diagram. They act on different objects.
Equal forces, unequal accelerations. When asked who “feels” a larger force in an interaction, the answer is neither; when asked who accelerates more, it is the one with less mass.
Pairs cannot cancel. If a question says forces “cancel,” they act on one object and are balanced by the first law, not paired by the third.
Ideal strings. State the assumption (“ideal string, so the tension is uniform”) whenever you use equal tensions at the two ends.
Practice
A foot kicks a soccer ball with a force of 120 N. What is the force of the ball on the foot, and why is the ball the one that flies away?
Show answer
The ball pushes back on the foot with 120 N in the opposite direction. The ball flies away because its mass is small, so the same force gives it a large acceleration; the foot is attached to a much more massive leg and body, and its acceleration is small.
The Moon is pulled toward Earth by a gravitational force. What is the third-law partner of that force, and how do the magnitudes compare?
Show answer
The partner is the gravitational pull of the Moon on Earth. The magnitudes are exactly equal, even though Earth is far more massive. The accelerations differ because the masses differ.
Two students, one heavy and one light, stand on skateboards and the heavy one pushes the light one away. Compare the forces on them and their accelerations.
Show answer
The forces are equal in size and opposite in direction (third law). The lighter student has the larger acceleration, in proportion to the inverse of the mass, and so ends with the greater speed.
A 3.0 kg bucket hangs at rest from a rope over a pulley. What is the tension in the rope? How does the tension change if the rope has a large mass?
Show answer
For an ideal rope, \(T = mg = 30\ \text{N}\). If the rope has a significant mass, the tension is larger near the top of the hanging part, which must also support the rope’s own weight, so it differs from point to point; at the bucket it is still 30 N.
A student argues, “The book sits at rest on a table because the force of the table up on the book and Earth’s gravity down on the book are an action-reaction pair, so they cancel.” Identify the error.
Show answer
These two forces are not a third-law pair: both act on the same object, and they are of different types (contact and gravitational). They balance because the book is not accelerating, which is Newton’s first law. The partner of the table’s push on the book is the book’s push on the table.
A horse pulls a cart forward. A student says, “The cart pulls back on the horse with an equal force, so they can never move.” Explain what is wrong.
Show answer
The pair of forces acts on two different objects, so it does not cancel on either. The cart accelerates because the forces on the cart (the horse’s pull forward and friction backward) do not balance. The horse accelerates because the ground pushes it forward (friction on its hooves) more than the cart pulls it back. The horse-cart system as a whole is moved by the external friction force of the ground on the horse.
For nearly two thousand years it seemed obvious that a moving object needed something to keep it moving: a cart stops when the horse stops, a pushed book slides to rest. Galileo and Newton saw what was hidden by friction and air resistance. Things keep moving by themselves; it takes a force to change their motion, not to maintain it. This idea, Newton’s first law, reverses the everyday picture, and the exam tests it relentlessly, often with a diagram in which something is moving and you must decide whether the forces balance. This lesson shows how to use the law and how to set up the equations for the common situation of an object in equilibrium.
Learning objective · 2.4.A
Describe the conditions under which a system’s velocity remains constant.
Required content · EK 2.4.A.1 to 2.4.A.5
The net force on a system is the vector sum of all forces exerted on the system.
Translational equilibrium is a configuration of forces such that the net force exerted on a system is zero: \(\sum \vec{F} = 0\).
Newton’s first law states that if the net force exerted on a system is zero, the velocity of that system will remain constant.
Forces may be balanced in one dimension but unbalanced in another. The system’s velocity will change only in the direction of the unbalanced force.
An inertial reference frame is one from which an observer would verify Newton’s first law of motion.
Net force and the first law
Several forces can act on an object at once. Their combined effect is the net force, the vector sum of all the forces exerted on it, \(\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \sum\vec{F}\). In one dimension, add the signed values; in two dimensions, add the \(x\)-components and the \(y\)-components separately (lesson 1.7).
Newton’s first law: if the net force on a system is zero, its velocity does not change. An object at rest stays at rest; an object moving stays moving in a straight line at constant speed. The tendency of an object to keep its velocity is called inertia, and mass measures it: more mass means more resistance to change. The first law does not say that an object with a net force is moving, or that an object that is moving has a force. It only says that, with zero net force, the velocity cannot change.
A system in which the net force is zero is in translational equilibrium. Equilibrium includes both the case of being at rest (static equilibrium) and the case of moving at constant velocity. A box sliding on a rough floor with a constant velocity, a car cruising at constant speed on a straight road and a skydiver at terminal velocity are all in equilibrium. In each case forces are present, but they balance exactly.
Equilibrium component by component
Because forces are vectors, the condition \(\sum\vec{F} = 0\) is really two conditions, one for each axis:
\[ \sum F_x = 0 \qquad\text{and}\qquad \sum F_y = 0. \]
Forces can balance in one direction but not in the other. A ball thrown horizontally has no horizontal force on it (ignoring air), so its horizontal velocity stays constant, while its vertical forces are unbalanced and its vertical velocity changes. A block sliding across a table has balanced vertical forces (gravity and normal) and, if it is slowing down, an unbalanced horizontal force (friction). Its velocity changes only along the direction of the unbalanced force: it slows horizontally while remaining at the same height.
The procedure for equilibrium problems is the same each time: draw the free-body diagram, choose axes, write \(\sum F_x = 0\) and \(\sum F_y = 0\), resolve any angled force into components, and solve.
Figure 2.4a A sign at rest. At the junction two equal tensions pull up and outward along the cables, and gravity pulls down. The horizontal parts of the two tensions cancel. The vertical parts together support the weight: 2T sin 40° = mg. Equilibrium holds in each direction separately.
In Figure 2.4a an 8.0 kg sign hangs at rest from two cables, each at \(40^\circ\) to the horizontal. By symmetry the tensions are equal. The horizontal components of the two tensions are equal and opposite, so the horizontal equation is already satisfied. The vertical equation gives \(2T\sin 40^\circ - mg = 0\), which determines the tension. Notice a result that surprises many people: the tension in each cable (62 N) is larger than half the weight (40 N), because only the vertical part of each tension supports the sign. As Figure 2.4b shows, the flatter the cables, the larger the tension, and a perfectly horizontal pair could never hold the sign up at all.
Figure 2.4b Flatter cables need far more tension to hold the same weight. For an 80 N sign, each cable carries 40 N when hanging straight up (90°), 62 N at 40° and 230 N at 10°. Because the vertical component is the only part that supports the weight, the tension grows without limit as the angle approaches zero.
Inertial reference frames
The first law can be used to define the frames in which the laws of mechanics take their simple forms. An inertial reference frame is one in which an object with no net force on it moves with constant velocity. A frame at rest on the ground (ignoring Earth’s small rotation) and any frame moving at constant velocity relative to it are inertial. A frame that accelerates, such as a braking car, is not: inside it, an object on a smooth floor with no horizontal force on it starts to slide forward, apparently with no cause, and the first law fails to hold. Unless the problem says otherwise, we use inertial frames.
Worked example · the hanging sign
An 8.0 kg sign hangs from two identical cables, each making \(40^\circ\) with the horizontal. Find the tension in each cable.
Check. If the cables were vertical, each would carry 40 N. At \(40^\circ\) they must carry more, and 62 N is more. The horizontal components, \(62\cos 40^\circ = 48\ \text{N}\), pull the cables outward and cancel in pairs.
Worked example · a crate pulled by a rope
A 20 kg crate is dragged at constant velocity across a floor by a rope that makes \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal. The tension in the rope is 100 N. Find the friction force and the normal force.
Forces. Gravity \(mg = 200\ \text{N}\) down, normal force up, friction to the left (opposite the motion), and the tension 100 N at \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal to the right.
Meaning. The normal force is less than the 200 N weight, because part of the tension holds the crate up. Less normal force means less friction, which is why pulling at a slight upward angle is easier than pulling horizontally.
Worked example · a lamp on two ropes
A 3.0 kg lamp is held at rest by rope A, which pulls up and to the left at \(60^\circ\) above the horizontal, and rope B, which pulls horizontally to the right. Find both tensions.
Vertical. Only rope A has a vertical part: \(T_A\sin 60^\circ = mg = 30\ \text{N}\), so \(T_A = \dfrac{30}{0.866} = 35\ \text{N}\).
Check. The horizontal part of rope A, 17 N, is exactly what rope B supplies, and the two components of rope A combine to \(\sqrt{30^2 + 17.3^2} = 34.6\ \text{N}\), the tension found above. ✓
Exam focus
Constant velocity means balanced forces. If a question says an object moves at constant velocity (or at constant speed in a straight line), set the net force to zero, even if it is moving fast and even if friction is present.
Do not invent a forward force. A moving object does not need a force in its direction of motion; an unbalanced force changes velocity, it does not maintain it.
Component equations. Write \(\sum F_x = 0\) and \(\sum F_y = 0\) separately. A common error is to apply the vertical balance to the horizontal forces.
Check the extremes. When the angle goes to zero or the mass goes to zero, does your tension formula behave sensibly?
Reference frame. Say “in an inertial frame” when you apply the first law, particularly in elevator and train problems.
Practice
A 1500 kg car cruises at a constant 25 m/s on a level road. The air resistance and rolling friction total 600 N. What is the force of the road on the tires (the driving force) and the net force?
Show answer
The velocity is constant, so the net force is zero. The driving force exerted by the road on the car must equal the 600 N of resistance, 600 N forward.
A 10 kg block hangs from two cables, each at \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal. Find the tension in each cable.
Show answer
\(2T\sin 30^\circ = mg = 100\ \text{N}\), so \(T = 100/(2 \times 0.50) = 100\ \text{N}\). Each cable carries as much tension as the weight.
A 5.0 kg block is held at rest on a \(30^\circ\) frictional incline. Find the friction force and the normal force.
Show answer
With axes along and perpendicular to the incline, the weight (50 N) has components \(mg\sin 30^\circ = 25\ \text{N}\) down the slope and \(mg\cos 30^\circ = 43\ \text{N}\) into the surface. The block is at rest, so \(F_f = 25\ \text{N}\) up the slope and \(F_N = 43\ \text{N}\).
A skydiver falls at a constant speed of 55 m/s with the parachute closed, then opens it. Describe the net force just after the parachute opens and the long-term outcome.
Show answer
Just after opening, the air drag is much larger than the weight, so the net force is upward; the skydiver accelerates upward (slows down). As the speed drops, the drag falls until it again equals the weight, and the skydiver falls at a new, smaller constant speed (net force zero).
A student pushes a box across the floor and says, “The box moves at constant speed, so my push must be bigger than friction, to keep it going.” Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim is incorrect. At constant velocity the net force is zero, so the push equals the friction force exactly. A push larger than friction would make the box speed up.
A student in a bus that is braking sees a ball on the smooth floor roll forward with no one touching it. Is the bus an inertial frame? Explain.
Show answer
No. In an inertial frame, an object with zero net force keeps a constant velocity. In the braking bus the ball accelerates forward even though no horizontal force acts on it, so Newton’s first law fails in that frame. The bus is accelerating relative to the ground, and so is a noninertial frame.
Newton’s first law says what happens when forces balance: nothing changes. The second law says what happens when they do not. It is the central equation of this unit and one of the most useful equations in all of physics: it connects the causes of motion (forces) to the effect (acceleration) through the one property of the object that matters, its mass. With it, you can start from a free-body diagram and predict how an object will move, or work backward from observed motion and find the forces that must have acted. This lesson states the law, shows how to apply it component by component, and develops the graphs and reasoning the exam asks for.
Learning objective · 2.5.A
Describe the conditions under which a system’s velocity changes.
Required content · EK 2.5.A.1 to 2.5.A.3
Unbalanced forces are a configuration of forces such that the net force exerted on a system is not equal to zero.
Newton’s second law of motion states that the acceleration of a system’s center of mass has a magnitude proportional to the magnitude of the net force exerted on the system and is in the same direction as that net force: \(\vec{a}_{\text{sys}} = \sum\vec{F}/m_{\text{sys}} = \vec{F}_{\text{net}}/m_{\text{sys}}\).
The velocity of a system’s center of mass will only change if a nonzero net external force is exerted on that system.
The law
Newton’s second law: the acceleration of an object is directly proportional to the net force on it, inversely proportional to its mass, and in the same direction as the net force:
\[ \vec{a} = \frac{\sum\vec{F}}{m} \qquad\text{or, equivalently,}\qquad \sum\vec{F} = m\vec{a}. \]
Each word matters. Net means the vector sum of all the forces on the object, not any single one. Same direction means the acceleration points where the net force points, not necessarily where the object is moving. And the mass is the mass of the whole object or system to which the net force applies.
The units confirm the definition of the newton: a net force of 1 N gives a 1 kg object an acceleration of \(1\ \text{m/s}^2\), so \(1\ \text{N} = 1\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}^2\). With \(g\) near \(10\ \text{m/s}^2\), a 1 kg object weighs about 10 N, and a 0.1 kg apple weighs about 1 N.
The law has two proportionalities, and both appear on exams as graphs and as reasoning questions. At fixed mass, the acceleration is proportional to the net force: doubling the net force doubles the acceleration (Figure 2.5a). At fixed net force, the acceleration is inversely proportional to the mass: doubling the mass halves the acceleration (Figure 2.5b).
Figure 2.5a For a fixed mass, acceleration is directly proportional to net force: the graph is a straight line through the origin. The slope is 1/m, so a larger mass gives a shallower line. At a net force of 20 N the accelerations are 20, 10 and 5 m/s² for the 1, 2 and 4 kg objects.Figure 2.5b For a fixed net force, acceleration is inversely proportional to mass. Doubling the mass halves the acceleration: 12 N gives 12 m/s² to a 1 kg object, 6 m/s² to a 2 kg object, and 3 m/s² to a 4 kg object.
Working in components
The vector equation \(\sum\vec{F} = m\vec{a}\) stands for two independent equations,
\[ \sum F_x = ma_x \qquad\text{and}\qquad \sum F_y = ma_y, \]
or, with tilted axes, one along the acceleration and one perpendicular to it. The procedure never changes: draw the free-body diagram, choose axes, write \(\sum F = ma\) for each axis with the signs set by the axes, resolve any angled forces, and solve. If the object does not accelerate along an axis, the left side of that equation is zero, and the equation becomes an equilibrium equation from lesson 2.4.
Figure 2.5c A pull at an angle. Only the horizontal component of the 20 N pull accelerates the 5.0 kg block, ΣFx = F cos 30° = max. The vertical component, F sin 30° = 10 N, partly supports the block, so the normal force is smaller than the weight: FN = mg − F sin 30° = 40 N.
Figure 2.5c shows a typical case. A 20 N force pulls a 5.0 kg block at \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal across a frictionless floor. Only the horizontal component of the pull, \(F\cos 30^\circ = 17.3\ \text{N}\), accelerates the block. The vertical component, \(F\sin 30^\circ = 10\ \text{N}\), helps hold the block up, so the normal force is 40 N rather than the 50 N weight.
Which forces count: the system and its center of mass
The law applies to the center of mass of a system and to the net external force on that system. Forces between parts of the system are internal and cancel in pairs (lesson 2.3), so they cannot change the center-of-mass velocity. This is why the velocity of a system’s center of mass changes only when a nonzero net external force acts. When you apply \(\sum F = ma\) to a single object, the system is that object, and every force on it from anything else is external.
Worked example · net force from motion
A 1200 kg car accelerates from rest to 24 m/s in 8.0 s along a straight road. What is the net force on it?
Net force. \(F_{\text{net}} = ma = (1200)(3.0) = 3600\ \text{N}\), in the direction of motion. This is the sum of the forward force of the road on the tires (friction) and the backward air resistance and rolling resistance; if resistance totals 600 N, the driving force is 4200 N.
Worked example · forces in two directions
Two horizontal forces act on a 3.0 kg block on a frictionless table: 12 N to the east and 5.0 N to the north. Find the acceleration.
Net force. \(F_{\text{net}} = \sqrt{12^2 + 5.0^2} = 13\ \text{N}\) at \(\tan^{-1}(5.0/12) = 23^\circ\) north of east.
Acceleration. \(a = \dfrac{13}{3.0} = 4.3\ \text{m/s}^2\), in the same direction as the net force. Using components gives the same result: \(a_x = 12/3.0 = 4.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) and \(a_y = 5.0/3.0 = 1.7\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Worked example · the block pulled at an angle
A 5.0 kg block is pulled across a frictionless floor by a 20 N force at \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal (Figure 2.5c). Find the acceleration and the normal force.
Vertical. The block stays on the floor, \(a_y = 0\): \(F_N + F\sin 30^\circ - mg = 0\), so \(F_N = 50 - 10 = 40\ \text{N}\).
Worked example · finding the mass from an experiment
A student pulls a cart with a series of known net forces and records the acceleration each time:
net force (N)
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
acceleration (m/s²)
0.51
1.00
1.52
1.99
Plotting \(a\) against \(F\) gives a straight line through the origin, as the law predicts. Its slope is \(\dfrac{1.99 - 0}{4.0 - 0} \approx 0.50\ \text{m/(s}^2\text{N)}\). Because \(a = F/m\), the slope is \(1/m\), so \(m = 1/0.50 = 2.0\ \text{kg}\). Measuring over several forces and using the slope, rather than a single trial, averages out random errors.
Exam focus
Net force, not a force. \(ma\) is the sum of all the forces. When a problem gives one applied force and a frictional force, subtract before dividing by the mass.
Direction of \(\vec{a}\). The acceleration is along the net force, not along the velocity. An object can move to the right while the net force, and so the acceleration, points left.
\(ma\) is not a force. It never appears as an arrow on the free-body diagram; it is the right-hand side of the equation.
Proportional reasoning. “If the force is tripled and the mass doubled, the acceleration is multiplied by 3/2” is a typical qualitative question. Write the ratio from \(a = F/m\).
Graphs. A graph of \(a\) against \(F\) has slope \(1/m\); a graph of \(F\) against \(a\) has slope \(m\). Read the axes carefully before using the slope.
Practice
A net force of 15 N acts on a 3.0 kg cart. Find its acceleration.
Show answer
\(a = F/m = 15/3.0 = 5.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), in the direction of the force.
A 1000 kg car speeds up from rest to 20 m/s in 8.0 s. What is the net force?
Show answer
A 2.0 kg block is pushed to the right with 6.0 N while friction pulls it to the left with 2.0 N. Find its acceleration.
Show answer
\(F_{\text{net}} = 6.0 - 2.0 = 4.0\ \text{N}\) to the right. \(a = 4.0/2.0 = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) to the right.
The net force on an object is tripled and its mass is doubled. By what factor does the acceleration change?
Show answer
\(a = F/m\), so the new acceleration is \((3F)/(2m) = 1.5\,(F/m)\): it is multiplied by 1.5.
A 4.0 kg object has an acceleration of 3.0 m/s\(^2\) north. One force on it is 20 N north. If only one other force acts, what is it?
Show answer
The net force is \((4.0)(3.0) = 12\ \text{N}\) north. The second force is \(12 - 20 = -8.0\ \text{N}\): it is 8.0 N directed south.
A student says, “The net force on the block is 10 N, so the block must be moving at 10 m/s.” Evaluate the claim.
Show answer
The claim confuses force with velocity. A net force of 10 N gives the block an acceleration (\(a = 10/m\)), a change of velocity of \(10/m\) m/s every second. The block’s velocity at any moment depends on its history and could be anything, including zero.
Lesson 2.6 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.5 (applications)
Real problems rarely involve a single object. A locomotive pulls a train of cars, a crane lifts a load against a counterweight, a hanging bucket drags a cart across a table. In all of these, objects are linked by strings, rods or contact, and they influence one another. The method that handles them is simply Newton’s second law, applied carefully, with two ideas from earlier lessons: a free-body diagram for each object, and a decision about which system to analyze. This lesson develops a reliable procedure and works through the three standard situations of the exam: the pulley with two hanging masses, the block pulled over a table by a hanging mass, and blocks pushed together.
Learning objectives · 2.1.A, 2.3.A and 2.5.A (applied)
Describe the properties and interactions of a system; describe the interaction of two objects using Newton’s third law; describe the conditions under which a system’s velocity changes.
Required content · used in this lesson
An ideal string has negligible mass and does not stretch when under tension; the tension in an ideal string is the same at all points within the string. An ideal pulley has negligible mass and rotates about an axle through its center of mass with negligible friction.
Newton’s second law: the acceleration of a system’s center of mass is \(\vec{a}_{\text{sys}} = \sum\vec{F}/m_{\text{sys}}\), in the direction of the net force.
Interactions between objects within a system (internal forces) do not influence the motion of a system’s center of mass.
A procedure for connected objects
Decide what the objects are and how they are linked. A taut ideal string forces the objects to have the same speed and the same magnitude of acceleration, and gives them the same tension at both ends.
Choose a positive direction for each object that matches its likely motion. For a string over a pulley, call “the direction the string moves” positive for both objects, even though one goes up and one goes down. Then a single \(a\) describes both.
Draw a free-body diagram for each object (and only the forces on it).
Write \(\sum F = ma\) for each object along its own axis, using the common \(a\).
Solve the equations simultaneously. The unknowns are the common acceleration and the tension (or contact force). Two objects give two equations, which is exactly enough, because the common acceleration counts only once.
Check with a second route: treat the connected objects as one system (internal tensions drop out) and compare.
Two masses over a pulley: the Atwood machine
In an Atwood machine (Figure 2.6a), two masses \(m_1\) and \(m_2\), with \(m_2 \gt m_1\), hang from a string over an ideal pulley. Take the direction in which \(m_2\) moves (downward) as positive for \(m_2\) and the direction in which \(m_1\) moves (upward) as positive for \(m_1\). Then
\[ m_2 g - T = m_2 a, \qquad T - m_1 g = m_1 a. \]
Adding the two equations eliminates \(T\), the internal force:
\[ a = \frac{(m_2 - m_1)\,g}{m_1 + m_2}. \]
The same result comes from treating the pair as one system of mass \(m_1 + m_2\) with a net external force (the difference of the two weights, since the tension is internal): \(m_2 g - m_1 g = (m_1 + m_2)a\). Substituting back gives the tension, \(T = m_1(g + a) = \dfrac{2m_1 m_2}{m_1 + m_2}\,g\), which lies between the two weights.
Figure 2.6a An Atwood machine with a 3.0 kg and a 5.0 kg mass. The same string tension T acts upward on both masses, and both have the same acceleration magnitude. The heavier mass accelerates downward and the lighter mass upward. Writing ΣF = ma for each mass gives two equations in the two unknowns T and a.
A block on a table pulled by a hanging mass
In Figure 2.6b a block of mass \(m_1\) rests on a frictionless table and is tied to a hanging mass \(m_2\). The horizontal force on the block is the tension alone, \(T = m_1 a\); the hanging mass has \(m_2 g - T = m_2 a\). Together, \(a = \dfrac{m_2 g}{m_1 + m_2}\). The tension is smaller than \(m_2 g\), because the hanging mass accelerates downward, so the string does not hold its full weight.
Figure 2.6b A block pulled along a frictionless table by a hanging mass. The string’s tension is the only horizontal force on the block, T = m1a. The hanging mass has gravity downward and the tension upward, m2g − T = m2a. Because the string is ideal, both masses have the same acceleration magnitude.
Blocks pushed together
When two blocks in contact are pushed, the contact force between them is an internal force for the pair and an external force for each block. Figure 2.6c shows a 10 N push on a 2.0 kg block that is touching a 3.0 kg block on a frictionless floor. For the pair, \(a = 10/(2.0 + 3.0) = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). For the 3.0 kg block alone, the only horizontal force is the push of the first block, so that contact force is \((3.0)(2.0) = 6.0\ \text{N}\). By the third law the 3.0 kg block pushes back on the 2.0 kg block with the same 6.0 N, and the 2.0 kg block has the net force \(10 - 6.0 = 4.0\ \text{N}\), which gives \((2.0)(2.0) = 4.0\ \text{N}\), confirming the result. The block closer to the push feels the larger contact force.
Figure 2.6c Two blocks pushed together. The system of both blocks has a = 10 N / 5.0 kg = 2.0 m/s². The contact force between them is the force that accelerates the 3.0 kg block: F = (3.0)(2.0) = 6.0 N. The 2.0 kg block receives the same 6.0 N backward from it, so its net force is 10 − 6 = 4.0 N, giving (2.0)(2.0) = 4.0 N. ✓
Worked example · an Atwood machine
A 3.0 kg block and a 5.0 kg block hang from the two ends of a string over an ideal pulley. Find the acceleration and the tension after they are released from rest.
Acceleration. \(a = \dfrac{(5.0 - 3.0)(10)}{3.0 + 5.0} = \dfrac{20}{8.0} = 2.5\ \text{m/s}^2\), with the 5.0 kg block going down and the 3.0 kg block going up.
Tension. From the lighter block, \(T = m_1(g + a) = (3.0)(12.5) = 37.5\ \text{N}\). Check with the heavier block: \(m_2 g - T = 50 - 37.5 = 12.5\ \text{N}\), and \(m_2 a = (5.0)(2.5) = 12.5\ \text{N}\). ✓
Reasonableness. The tension (37.5 N) lies between the two weights (30 N and 50 N), as it must: it is more than the lighter block’s weight, so that block accelerates upward, and less than the heavier block’s weight, so that block accelerates downward.
Worked example · a hanging mass pulls a block along a table
A 4.0 kg block on a frictionless table is connected by a string over an ideal pulley to a 1.0 kg mass hanging over the edge. Find the acceleration and the tension.
Check. The tension (8.0 N) is less than the hanging weight (10 N), as expected. The acceleration is one fifth of \(g\) because the hanging mass is one fifth of the total mass.
Worked example · lifting two linked blocks
A 2.0 kg block is pulled straight up by a rope with a tension of 45 N. A 1.0 kg block hangs from the lower side of the 2.0 kg block by a second string. Find the acceleration and the tension in the lower string.
Whole system (3.0 kg). The external forces are the rope (45 N up) and gravity (30 N down): \(a = \dfrac{45 - 30}{3.0} = 5.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) upward.
Check on the upper block. \(45 - 20 - 15 = 10\ \text{N}\), and \(m a = (2.0)(5.0) = 10\ \text{N}\). ✓ Choosing the system cleverly (all three objects first) gave the acceleration without finding the tension.
Exam focus
One free-body diagram per object. Do not combine forces from different objects on a single diagram unless you are treating them as one system.
Tension on both sides of an ideal pulley is the same. It is not equal to a weight unless the object is in equilibrium.
Common acceleration. Objects linked by a taut ideal string have the same acceleration magnitude. Pick signs so that the common \(a\) is positive for both.
Check limiting cases. If \(m_1 = m_2\) the Atwood acceleration is zero; if \(m_1 \to 0\) it approaches \(g\); if the table block in Figure 2.6b were very heavy, \(a\) approaches zero. A formula that fails these checks has an error.
Choose the system that answers the question fastest. The whole-system equation eliminates internal forces; the single-object equation finds them.
Practice
An Atwood machine has masses of 4.0 kg and 6.0 kg. Find the acceleration and the tension.
Show answer
A 2.0 kg block on a frictionless table is tied over a pulley to a 3.0 kg hanging mass. Find the acceleration and the tension.
Show answer
\(a = \dfrac{m_2 g}{m_1 + m_2} = \dfrac{30}{5.0} = 6.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). \(T = m_1 a = (2.0)(6.0) = 12\ \text{N}\), less than the 30 N weight of the hanging mass.
Blocks of 1.0 kg, 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg touch each other in that order on a frictionless floor, and a 12 N force pushes the 1.0 kg block. Find the acceleration and the force between the 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg blocks.
Show answer
\(a = 12/6.0 = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). The 3.0 kg block alone is accelerated by the contact force from the 2.0 kg block, \((3.0)(2.0) = 6.0\ \text{N}\). (The force between the 1.0 kg and 2.0 kg blocks is \((5.0)(2.0) = 10\ \text{N}\).)
In the hanging-mass-and-table problem, is the tension greater than, equal to, or less than the weight of the hanging mass? Explain.
Show answer
Less than. The hanging mass accelerates downward, so the net force on it is downward, which requires \(m_2 g \gt T\). Only if the system were not accelerating (for example, if the block were held fixed) would the tension equal the weight.
An Atwood machine has two equal masses of 2.0 kg each. Describe the motion if the masses are released from rest, and give the tension.
Show answer
The net force on each mass is zero when \(T = mg\), so the acceleration is zero and the masses stay at rest. \(T = (2.0)(10) = 20\ \text{N}\). If they were already moving, they would keep moving at constant velocity.
A 5.0 kg crate and a 3.0 kg crate are tied together and pulled to the right across a frictionless floor by a 24 N force applied to the 5.0 kg crate. What is the tension in the rope between them?
Show answer
System: \(a = 24/8.0 = 3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\). The only horizontal force on the 3.0 kg crate is the tension: \(T = (3.0)(3.0) = 9.0\ \text{N}\).
Why does an apple fall to the ground while the Moon, which is also falling toward Earth, never arrives? Newton’s great insight was that these are the same question. The force that pulls the apple down also holds the Moon in its path, and it acts between any two masses in the universe. In AP Physics 1 this force is the only interaction at a distance, so it deserves careful attention: what its size depends on, how to describe its effect with a field, when it is safe to treat it as a constant, and how it is related to the quantity \(g\) that you have been using since Unit 1.
Learning objectives · 2.6.A and 2.6.B
Describe the gravitational interaction between two objects or systems with mass. Describe situations in which the gravitational force can be considered constant.
Required content · EK 2.6.A.1 to 2.6.B.2
Newton’s law of universal gravitation describes the gravitational force between two objects or systems as directly proportional to each of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the systems’ centers of mass: \(F_g = G\,m_1 m_2/r^2\). The gravitational force is attractive, is always exerted along the line connecting the centers of mass of the two interacting systems, and on a system can be considered to be exerted on the system’s center of mass.
A field models the effects of a noncontact force exerted on an object at various positions in space. The magnitude of the gravitational field created by a system of mass \(M\) at a point in space is equal to the ratio of the gravitational force exerted by the system on a test object of mass \(m\) to the mass of the test object: \(g = F_g/m = GM/r^2\).
If the gravitational force is the only force exerted on an object, the observed acceleration of the object (in \(\text{m/s}^2\)) is numerically equal to the magnitude of the gravitational field strength (in N/kg) at that location. The gravitational force exerted by an astronomical body on a relatively small nearby object is called weight: \(F_g = mg\).
If the gravitational force between two systems’ centers of mass has a negligible change as the relative position of the two systems changes, the gravitational force can be considered constant. Near the surface of Earth, the strength of the gravitational field is \(g = 10\ \text{N/kg}\).
Newton’s law of universal gravitation
Any two objects with mass attract each other with a force that is
proportional to the product of the masses: doubling either mass doubles the force;
inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the centers of mass: doubling the distance cuts the force to one quarter.
In symbols,
\[ F_g = G\,\frac{m_1 m_2}{r^2}, \qquad G = 6.67\times10^{-11}\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{kg}^2. \]
The force is always attractive and acts along the line joining the two centers. The two forces, one on each object, are a third-law pair (Figure 2.7a): they are equal in size no matter how different the masses, and opposite in direction. The constant \(G\) is tiny, which is why you do not feel the gravitational pull of the person next to you: two 1000 kg objects 2.0 m apart attract each other with only \(1.7\times10^{-5}\ \text{N}\). It is only when one of the masses is as large as a planet that gravity becomes noticeable.
Figure 2.7a Newton’s law of universal gravitation. Each sphere pulls on the other with a force of the same size, directed along the line joining their centers, and attractive. The force is proportional to the product of the masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the centers of mass.
The distance \(r\) is measured between centers of mass. For a spherical planet this means from the center, not the surface. If you stand on Earth’s surface, \(r\) is Earth’s radius, \(6.37\times10^6\ \text{m}\), and if you are in a satellite 400 km above the surface, \(r\) is \(6.77\times10^6\ \text{m}\): the satellite is much farther from the center than it appears. For an extended object, the gravitational force can be treated as acting at the object’s center of mass, the same point that is the dot of its free-body diagram.
The gravitational field
Gravity acts across empty space, which raises a question: how does Earth “know” that a mass is at a certain place? The field model answers by assigning to every point in space a quantity that describes what a mass would feel if it were placed there. The gravitational field strength at a point is the force per unit mass on a small test object, \(g = F_g/m\), and for a body of mass \(M\) it is
\[ g = \frac{GM}{r^2}. \]
The field points toward the source of mass (Figure 2.7b) and weakens with the square of the distance. It is measured in newtons per kilogram. Once you know the field at a point, the force on any mass \(m\) placed there is \(F_g = mg\), whatever \(m\) is.
Figure 2.7b A field model describes the effect of a noncontact force at every point in space. The gravitational field points toward the mass that creates it, and its magnitude is the force per unit mass on a test object, g = Fg/m = GM/r². The same field acts on any object placed at that point, whatever its mass.
Two further statements follow. First, if gravity is the only force on an object, Newton’s second law gives \(a = F_g/m = g\): the acceleration in \(\text{m/s}^2\) is numerically the field in N/kg, and independent of the mass of the object. This is why all objects fall together (lesson 1.5). Second, the gravitational force near a planet, \(mg\), is what we call weight. Weight is a force, in newtons, and depends on where you are: a 60 kg person weighs about 600 N on Earth but only about 220 N on Mars. Mass is a property of the object and is the same everywhere.
When can gravity be treated as constant?
The inverse-square law means the field changes with height, but for objects near Earth’s surface the change is negligible. Moving up a height \(h\) changes \(r\) from \(R\) to \(R + h\), and for \(h\) much smaller than \(R\) the field changes by only about \(2h/R\) as a fraction. At \(h = 1000\ \text{m}\) that is \(2(1000)/(6.37\times10^6) = 3\times10^{-4}\), about three hundredths of a percent. Over the trajectories of Unit 1 the field is constant to a part in thousands, and the value used is
\[ g = 10\ \text{N/kg}\quad\text{near Earth’s surface (more precisely 9.8 N/kg).} \]
Over distances comparable to Earth’s radius, as for a satellite or a rocket leaving Earth, the field is no longer constant, and the full law is needed (Figure 2.7c).
Figure 2.7c The gravitational field of Earth weakens with the square of the distance from its center. Twice as far from the center (one Earth radius above the surface) the field is one quarter as strong, 2.5 N/kg. Near the surface, a few kilometers change r by a tiny fraction, so g is essentially constant.
Worked example · gravity between ordinary masses
Two 1000 kg masses are 2.0 m apart (center to center). Find the gravitational force between them.
Meaning. The force is about a hundred-thousandth of a newton, the weight of a few grains of sand. It is real, but far too small to notice without a very sensitive instrument, which is why Cavendish’s measurement of \(G\) in 1798 was so difficult.
Worked example · the field far from Earth
At the surface of Earth, \(g = 10\ \text{N/kg}\). What is the field strength at a height of one Earth radius above the surface, and what would a 60 kg person weigh there?
Distance. One radius above the surface means \(r = 2R\). Because \(g\) varies as \(1/r^2\), \(g' = g\left(\dfrac{R}{2R}\right)^2 = \dfrac{10}{4} = 2.5\ \text{N/kg}\).
Weight. \(F_g = mg' = (60)(2.5) = 150\ \text{N}\), one quarter of the surface weight (600 N). The mass is still 60 kg.
Worked example · weight on another planet
Mars has a mass of \(6.42\times10^{23}\ \text{kg}\) and a radius of \(3.39\times10^6\ \text{m}\). Find the field strength at its surface and the weight there of a 60 kg person.
Weight. \(F_g = (60)(3.73) = 224\ \text{N}\), about 220 N (compare 600 N on Earth). The person’s mass, 60 kg, and inertia are unchanged; only the weight is smaller.
Worked example · scaling with ratios
A planet has four times Earth’s mass and twice Earth’s radius. How does the field strength at its surface compare with \(g\) on Earth?
Ratio method. \(g \propto M/R^2\), so \(\dfrac{g_{\text{planet}}}{g_{\text{Earth}}} = \dfrac{4}{2^2} = 1\). The surface field is the same as Earth’s, 10 N/kg. Ratio reasoning like this avoids \(G\) and the numbers altogether and is the style the exam often asks for.
Exam focus
Distance is center to center. A satellite 400 km above the surface is at \(r = R_E + 400\ \text{km}\), not at \(r = 400\ \text{km}\).
Inverse square. Doubling \(r\) divides the force by 4; tripling \(r\) divides it by 9. Doubling one mass doubles the force.
Mass is not weight. Mass (kg) is the same on every planet; weight (N) changes with the field.
Third-law pair. The gravitational force of Earth on a satellite and of the satellite on Earth are equal; the accelerations differ because the masses differ.
Use \(g = GM/r^2\) with the planet’s mass. The mass of the falling object does not appear in the field, only in the force.
Practice
Two 2.0 kg masses are 0.50 m apart. Find the gravitational force between them.
Show answer
By what factor does the gravitational force between two objects change if (a) the distance is doubled, (b) both masses are doubled, (c) one mass is tripled and the distance is tripled?
Show answer
(a) It becomes one quarter. (b) It is multiplied by \(2 \times 2 = 4\). (c) \((3)/(3^2) = 1/3\): it becomes one third.
A planet has the same mass as Earth but half of Earth’s radius. What is the field strength at its surface?
Show answer
\(g \propto M/R^2\), so with \(R\) halved, \(g\) is multiplied by \(1/(1/2)^2 = 4\): \(g = 40\ \text{N/kg}\).
At what height above Earth’s surface is the field strength one quarter of its surface value?
Show answer
\(g\) is one quarter when \(r\) is twice the radius, \(r = 2R_E\). The height above the surface is \(h = R_E = 6.4\times10^6\ \text{m}\) (about 6400 km).
A 50 kg astronaut stands on the Moon, where \(g = 1.6\ \text{N/kg}\). What are the astronaut’s mass and weight there?
Show answer
The mass is 50 kg. The weight is \(mg = (50)(1.6) = 80\ \text{N}\), about one sixth of the weight on Earth (500 N).
An apple falls toward Earth. Compare the gravitational force of Earth on the apple with the force of the apple on Earth, and explain why only the apple appears to move.
Show answer
The two forces are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, a third-law pair. The accelerations differ by the ratio of the masses: Earth’s mass is about \(10^{25}\) times the apple’s, so Earth’s acceleration is far too small to see.
Lesson 2.8 · Unit 2 · CED topic 2.6 (weight and mass)
In an express elevator you feel heavier as it starts upward and lighter as it starts downward. A passenger on a scale would see the reading change, even though the passenger’s mass and Earth’s pull have not changed at all. And astronauts on the International Space Station float, even though Earth’s gravity there is nearly as strong as on the ground. These everyday and not-so-everyday puzzles all turn on one distinction: the gravitational force on an object is not the same thing as the weight you feel. This lesson separates the two, applies Newton’s second law to accelerating scales, and then explains the deep reason that all objects fall alike: the equivalence of inertial and gravitational mass.
Learning objectives · 2.6.C and 2.6.D
Describe the conditions under which the magnitude of a system’s apparent weight is different from the magnitude of the gravitational force exerted on that system. Describe inertial and gravitational mass.
Required content · EK 2.6.C.1 to 2.6.D.3
The magnitude of the apparent weight of a system is the magnitude of the normal force exerted on the system.
If the system is accelerating, the apparent weight of the system is not equal to the magnitude of the gravitational force exerted on the system.
A system appears weightless when there are no forces exerted on the system or when the force of gravity is the only force exerted on the system.
The equivalence principle states that an observer in a noninertial reference frame is unable to distinguish between an object’s apparent weight and the gravitational force exerted on the object by a gravitational field.
Objects have inertial mass, or inertia, a property that determines how much an object’s motion resists changes when interacting with another object. Gravitational mass is related to the force of attraction between two systems with mass. Inertial mass and gravitational mass have been experimentally verified to be equivalent.
Weight and apparent weight
The gravitational force on an object, \(F_g = mg\), is its weight in the sense of lesson 2.7. What a scale measures, and what your body senses, is something different: it is the force that the supporting surface exerts on you, the normal force. This is the apparent weight. When you stand still, the normal force equals \(mg\), and the two coincide. When you accelerate vertically they do not.
Take up as positive and apply Newton’s second law to a person on a scale. The forces are the normal force (up) and gravity (down), so
\[ F_N - mg = ma \quad\Rightarrow\quad F_N = m(g + a). \]
Here \(a\) is the person’s vertical acceleration, positive if upward. If the elevator accelerates upward, \(a \gt 0\) and the scale reads more than \(mg\). If it accelerates downward, \(a \lt 0\) and the scale reads less. At constant velocity, whether moving up, down, or not at all, \(a = 0\) and the scale reads \(mg\). Notice that what matters is the acceleration, not the velocity: an elevator that is moving up but slowing down is accelerating downward, and the scale reads less.
Figure 2.8a A 60 kg person (weight 600 N) on a scale in an elevator. The scale reads the normal force, the apparent weight. It reads 600 N when a = 0, 720 N when accelerating upward at 2 m/s² (FN = m(g + a)), 480 N when accelerating downward at 2 m/s² (FN = m(g − a)), and 0 in free fall.
Weightlessness
If the elevator cable is cut and the elevator is in free fall, the acceleration is \(a = -g\), and \(F_N = m(g - g) = 0\). The scale reads zero: you are in apparent weightlessness. Gravity is still acting, since it is the reason you accelerate downward, but there is no normal force supporting you, and nothing pushes on your body to give you the feeling of weight. By the CED’s wording, a system appears weightless when it has no forces on it at all, or when gravity is the only force on it.
An astronaut on the International Space Station, 400 km above Earth, is subject to a gravitational field of about 8.7 N/kg, close to 90 percent of the field at the surface. The station and everything in it are in free fall around Earth, always falling toward the planet while moving sideways so fast that they keep missing it (lesson 2.13). Inside the station, nothing pushes on the astronauts from below, so they feel weightless. The reason is not that gravity has vanished; it is that the astronauts and the station accelerate together.
Inertial mass and gravitational mass
Physics has two different definitions of “mass,” and it is remarkable that they agree. Inertial mass is the mass in \(\sum F = ma\): it measures how strongly an object resists acceleration when a force is applied. Gravitational mass is the mass in \(F_g = GMm/r^2\): it measures how strongly an object is attracted by, and attracts, another mass. There is no obvious reason that these two measures should be the same property. Yet every experiment has found them equal, to extraordinary precision, and that equality is why every object falls with the same acceleration: the gravitational force is proportional to the object’s gravitational mass, the resistance to acceleration is proportional to its inertial mass, and the two cancel in \(a = F_g/m = g\).
This observation is the starting point for the equivalence principle. An observer in a closed room cannot tell, by any experiment inside the room, whether the room is sitting on the surface of a planet with field \(g\), or is in deep space accelerating upward at \(a = g\) (Figure 2.8b). In both cases a dropped ball falls to the floor with \(g\), and a scale reads the same. More precisely, in a noninertial frame, such as an accelerating room, an observer cannot distinguish an object’s apparent weight from the gravitational force of a field. This principle was the basis of Einstein’s general theory of relativity.
Figure 2.8b The equivalence principle. An observer in a closed room cannot tell whether the downward pull on objects is caused by a gravitational field or by the room accelerating upward. Inside either room, a ball released from rest falls to the floor with the same acceleration, and a scale reads the same.
Worked example · a scale in an elevator
A 60 kg person stands on a scale in an elevator. What does the scale read when the elevator (a) moves at a steady 3.0 m/s, (b) accelerates upward at 2.0 m/s\(^2\), (c) accelerates downward at 2.0 m/s\(^2\), (d) is in free fall?
Weight. \(mg = (60)(10) = 600\ \text{N}\).
(a) \(a = 0\), so \(F_N = 600\ \text{N}\).
(b) \(F_N = m(g + a) = 60(12) = 720\ \text{N}\).
(c) \(F_N = m(g - a) = 60(8.0) = 480\ \text{N}\).
(d) \(a = g\) downward, so \(F_N = 0\).
Worked example · working backward from the scale
The scale in an elevator reads 540 N for a 60 kg person. Find the acceleration, and describe the possible motions.
Step 1. \(F_N - mg = ma\): \(540 - 600 = 60a\), so \(a = -1.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), that is, 1.0 m/s\(^2\) downward.
Step 2. The elevator’s acceleration is downward. That is consistent with either moving down and speeding up, or moving up and slowing down. The scale reading cannot tell the two apart, because it responds only to acceleration.
Worked example · a hanging object in an accelerating elevator
A 2.0 kg object hangs from a spring scale in an elevator that accelerates downward at 4.0 m/s\(^2\). What does the spring scale read?
Forces. The spring pulls up with \(T\), the scale reading; gravity pulls down with \(mg = 20\ \text{N}\). With down positive, \(mg - T = ma\).
Solve. \(T = m(g - a) = (2.0)(10 - 4.0) = 12\ \text{N}\). The scale shows 12 N, less than the 20 N gravitational force.
Exam focus
The scale reads the normal force. Draw the free-body diagram with \(F_N\) up and \(mg\) down, then use Newton’s second law. Do not assume \(F_N = mg\) unless the acceleration is zero.
Acceleration, not velocity. An elevator moving down but slowing down has an upward acceleration, and the scale reads more than \(mg\).
Weightless is not “no gravity.” In free fall gravity is the only force, the normal force is zero, and the apparent weight is zero.
Inertial versus gravitational mass. Say which equation each appears in: \(\sum F = ma\) for inertial, \(F_g = GMm/r^2\) for gravitational. Their equality explains why the acceleration of free fall is independent of mass.
Equivalence. A closed-room experiment cannot distinguish an accelerating room from a gravitational field, so answers that appeal to looking outside the room do not count.
Practice
A 70 kg person stands on a scale in an elevator that accelerates upward at 1.5 m/s\(^2\). What does the scale read?
Show answer
The same elevator is moving downward and slowing to a stop with a deceleration of 1.5 m/s\(^2\). What does the scale read?
Show answer
The velocity is downward and decreasing in magnitude, so the acceleration is upward, \(+1.5\ \text{m/s}^2\). The scale reads \(70(10 + 1.5) = 805\ \text{N}\), the same as when speeding up while moving upward.
A student jumps off a platform. During the jump, before landing, what does a bathroom scale under the student’s feet read, ignoring air resistance?
Show answer
Zero. In free fall, gravity is the only force, the acceleration is \(g\) downward, and the normal force is zero. The student is momentarily weightless.
Why do astronauts in orbit float although gravity at their altitude is about 90 percent of its surface value?
Show answer
The astronauts and the spacecraft are in free fall together, with the same acceleration. The spacecraft exerts no normal force on them, so they have no apparent weight, even though gravity acts on them.
In a closed room with no windows, a ball released from rest falls with an acceleration of 10 m/s\(^2\). Can an observer in the room tell whether the room sits on a planet’s surface or is accelerating through space? Explain.
Show answer
No. By the equivalence principle, an observer in the accelerating (noninertial) room cannot distinguish the effects of acceleration from those of a gravitational field. A dropped ball falls at 10 m/s\(^2\) in both situations, and a scale reads the same.
Explain why a heavy object and a light object have the same acceleration in free fall, in terms of inertial and gravitational mass.
Show answer
The gravitational force on an object is proportional to its gravitational mass, \(F_g = m_{\text{grav}}\,g\), and its acceleration is that force divided by its inertial mass, \(a = F_g/m_{\text{inertial}}\). Because the two masses are equal, they cancel, and \(a = g\) for every object.
Friction is the force that keeps a parked car from rolling down a hill, lets you walk without slipping, and brings a skidding car to a stop. It is also the force that wastes energy in every machine and wears out every tire. Unlike gravity, which depends only on masses, friction depends on how two particular surfaces interact, and on whether they are sliding past each other or not. This lesson separates the two cases, shows how to put friction into a free-body diagram and into Newton’s second law, and develops the surprising rules the exam tests: friction does not depend on contact area, static friction adjusts itself, and there is a limit to how large it can get.
Learning objectives · 2.7.A and 2.7.B
Describe kinetic friction between two surfaces. Describe static friction between two surfaces.
Required content · EK 2.7.A.1 to 2.7.B.3
Kinetic friction occurs when two surfaces in contact move relative to each other. It is exerted in a direction opposite to the motion of each surface relative to the other surface.
The force of friction between two surfaces does not depend on the size of the surface area of contact.
The magnitude of the kinetic friction force exerted on an object is the product of the normal force the surface exerts on the object and the coefficient of kinetic friction: \(F_{f,k} = \mu_k F_N\). The coefficient of kinetic friction depends on the material properties of the surfaces in contact.
Normal force is the perpendicular component of the force exerted on an object by the surface with which it is in contact; it is directed away from the surface.
Static friction may occur between the contacting surfaces of two objects that are not moving relative to each other. It adopts the value and direction required to prevent an object from slipping or sliding on a surface.
There exists a maximum value for which static friction will prevent an object from slipping on a given surface: \(F_{f,s} \le \mu_s F_N\), so \(F_{f,s,\max} = \mu_s F_N\).
The coefficient of static friction is typically greater than the coefficient of kinetic friction for a given pair of surfaces.
Where friction comes from
Even surfaces that look and feel smooth are rough when seen at the scale of atoms. Where two surfaces touch, small bumps interlock and the atoms attract one another. To make one surface slide over the other, these contacts must be broken and re-formed, and that requires a force. Friction is the net result of all these microscopic interactions. It is a force exerted by one surface on the other, parallel to the surfaces in contact, and it always acts to oppose the sliding (or the attempt at sliding) of the surfaces relative to each other.
Friction is closely linked to the normal force. The harder two surfaces are pressed together, the more contacts there are and the larger the friction. That is why it is the normal force, not the weight, that appears in the friction law, and why the two are the same only when a surface is level and nothing else pushes on the object vertically.
Kinetic friction
Kinetic friction acts when the two surfaces are sliding past each other. Its direction is opposite to the motion of the object relative to the surface, and its magnitude is proportional to the normal force:
\[ F_{f,k} = \mu_k F_N. \]
The constant \(\mu_k\) is the coefficient of kinetic friction. It is a pure number with no units, and it depends on the two materials and on their condition (dry or wet, polished or rough), but not on the speed of sliding at this level of treatment. A typical value for rubber on dry concrete is about 0.7; for steel on ice it is as low as 0.02.
Note that the equation gives the magnitude of friction. The direction comes from the physical situation: it points opposite to the relative motion. On a free-body diagram, draw it as a force arrow parallel to the surface, opposite the direction the object slides. When you write \(\sum F = ma\) along the surface, give friction a negative sign if the object moves in the positive direction.
Static friction
Static friction acts when the surfaces are in contact but not moving relative to each other, and it is subtler. Push gently on a heavy crate resting on the floor. It does not move, which means the net force on it is zero, so the floor must be pushing back on the crate with a friction force exactly equal to your push. Push twice as hard and the crate still does not move; the friction has doubled, too. Static friction adopts the value and direction required to prevent slipping.
But it cannot grow without limit. There is a maximum static friction force, proportional to the normal force:
\[ F_{f,s} \le \mu_s F_N, \qquad F_{f,s,\max} = \mu_s F_N. \]
Once your push exceeds this maximum, the crate starts to slide. After it starts, kinetic friction takes over, and because \(\mu_s\) is typically larger than \(\mu_k\) for the same two surfaces, the friction force drops. This is why it takes a larger push to start something moving than to keep it moving, and why a tire that starts to skid loses grip. Figure 2.9a shows the whole story for a 50 kg crate with \(\mu_s = 0.60\) and \(\mu_k = 0.40\).
Figure 2.9a Static and kinetic friction on a 50 kg crate with μs = 0.60 and μk = 0.40 (FN = 500 N). While the crate is at rest, static friction matches the applied force, growing from 0 up to its maximum of μsFN = 300 N. Once the crate slips, friction drops to the constant kinetic value μkFN = 200 N.
Two warnings follow from this. First, the inequality is not an equation: for a crate at rest under a modest push, the static friction is whatever it needs to be to keep the net force at zero, not \(\mu_s F_N\). You use the equation \(F_{f,s} = \mu_s F_N\) only at the threshold of slipping, when the problem says the object is about to move or the push is the largest that will not move it. Second, static friction does not only oppose a pushing force. A car accelerating forward on level ground is pushed forward by static friction from the road on its drive wheels, because the tire surface at the point of contact is not sliding along the road. Friction is not always a “drag.”
Friction on a slope
On an incline, the normal force is not equal to the weight. Choose axes along and perpendicular to the surface. The weight \(mg\) splits into a component \(mg\sin\theta\) down the slope and a component \(mg\cos\theta\) into the surface (Figure 2.9b). With no acceleration perpendicular to the surface, the normal force is \(F_N = mg\cos\theta\). Friction then has maximum value \(\mu_s mg\cos\theta\) and, while sliding, equals \(\mu_k mg\cos\theta\). Along the slope, the net force is the weight component minus friction, which lets you find the acceleration of a block sliding down:
\[ a = g(\sin\theta - \mu_k\cos\theta). \]
A block resting on a slope stays put as long as the weight component does not exceed the maximum static friction: \(mg\sin\theta \le \mu_s mg\cos\theta\), that is, \(\tan\theta \le \mu_s\). The mass cancels, so the steepest slope on which an object can rest depends only on \(\mu_s\), not on how heavy the object is. A block that slides down at constant speed has zero acceleration, which means \(\mu_k = \tan\theta\).
Figure 2.9b A block on an incline. The weight must be resolved along axes parallel and perpendicular to the surface: the parallel component is mg sin θ (down the slope) and the perpendicular component is mg cos θ (into the surface). The normal force balances the perpendicular component, FN = mg cos θ, and friction opposes the parallel one.
Friction does not depend on the contact area
It may seem that a wide tire should grip better than a narrow one, or that a block should slide more easily on a small face. The model used on this exam says otherwise: the friction force depends on the materials and the normal force, and not on the area of contact (Figure 2.9c). If you spread the same weight over twice the area, the pressure on each part of the surface is halved, but there is twice as much area, and the effects cancel. (Real tires, especially racing tires, do deviate from this simple model, which is one reason they are designed with soft, sticky rubber rather than simply wide treads.)
Figure 2.9c Kinetic friction depends on the normal force and on the materials in contact, but not on the size of the contact area. The same block, with the same weight, feels the same friction on its large face and on its narrow face. A smaller area means a larger pressure over that area, but the total force is unchanged.
Worked example · pushing a crate
A 50 kg crate rests on a level floor with \(\mu_s = 0.60\) and \(\mu_k = 0.40\). Find the friction force and the acceleration if a horizontal push of (a) 200 N and (b) 350 N is applied. Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Normal force. The floor is level and the push is horizontal, so \(F_N = mg = 500\ \text{N}\). The maximum static friction is \(\mu_s F_N = (0.60)(500) = 300\ \text{N}\), and the kinetic friction is \(\mu_k F_N = (0.40)(500) = 200\ \text{N}\).
(a) The push of 200 N is less than 300 N, so the crate does not move. Static friction matches the push: \(F_{f,s} = 200\ \text{N}\), and \(a = 0\). Note that \(200 \ne \mu_s F_N\); the equality would hold only at 300 N.
(b) The push of 350 N exceeds 300 N, so the crate slides, and kinetic friction of 200 N acts. \(\sum F = 350 - 200 = 150\ \text{N}\), so \(a = \dfrac{150}{50} = 3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) in the direction of the push.
Worked example · a skidding car
A car skids to a stop on a level road with all four wheels locked. The coefficient of kinetic friction is 0.70 and the initial speed is 20 m/s. Find the deceleration and the stopping distance.
Deceleration. The only horizontal force is kinetic friction, \(\mu_k mg\), so \(a = \mu_k g = (0.70)(10) = 7.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) opposite the motion. The mass cancels, so a heavier car decelerates just as quickly.
Distance. From \(v^2 = v_0^2 + 2a\Delta x\) with \(v = 0\): \(\Delta x = \dfrac{(20)^2}{2(7.0)} = \dfrac{400}{14} = 29\ \text{m}\) (28.6 m to three figures).
Reasonableness. Doubling the initial speed would quadruple the distance, which is why speed matters so much on the road.
Worked example · a block sliding down a ramp
A 5.0 kg block slides down a \(30^\circ\) ramp with \(\mu_k = 0.20\). Find the acceleration.
Friction. \(F_{f,k} = (0.20)(43.3) = 8.7\ \text{N}\), directed up the slope.
Along the slope. \(mg\sin 30^\circ - F_{f,k} = ma\), so \(a = \dfrac{25 - 8.66}{5.0} = 3.3\ \text{m/s}^2\) down the slope.
Check by the formula. \(a = g(\sin\theta - \mu_k\cos\theta) = 10(0.500 - 0.173) = 3.3\ \text{m/s}^2\). ✓
Worked example · will it slip?
A block rests on a \(30^\circ\) incline where \(\mu_s = 0.60\). Does it slide? What if the incline is raised to \(35^\circ\)?
Test. Compare \(\tan\theta\) with \(\mu_s\). At \(30^\circ\), \(\tan 30^\circ = 0.577\), which is less than 0.60, so the block stays at rest; the static friction needed, \(mg\sin\theta\), is slightly below its maximum. For a 5.0 kg block, the needed friction is 25 N and the maximum is \((0.60)(43.3) = 26.0\ \text{N}\).
At \(35^\circ\). \(\tan 35^\circ = 0.700 \gt 0.60\), so the maximum static friction is too small and the block starts to slide. The mass did not matter in either test.
Exam focus
Normal force first. Always find \(F_N\) from the forces perpendicular to the surface before finding friction. On inclines or with angled pulls it is not \(mg\).
Static friction is not always \(\mu_s F_N\). Use the equality only at the threshold of slipping. Otherwise static friction equals whatever force prevents motion.
Direction. Kinetic friction opposes the sliding of the object relative to the surface; static friction opposes the sliding that would occur without it.
Area and speed do not matter. Questions that change the contact area, or the speed (while sliding), want the answer “friction does not change.” Questions that change the normal force (heavier load, pull or push at an angle) want a change.
Graphs and experiments. A graph of maximum friction against normal force is a line through the origin whose slope is \(\mu\). To measure \(\mu_k\), pull an object at constant velocity so \(F_{\text{applied}} = F_{f,k}\), and plot against the normal force.
Practice
A 20 kg box on a level floor is pushed horizontally with 100 N. The coefficient of kinetic friction is 0.30. What is the acceleration?
Show answer
A 10 kg box with \(\mu_s = 0.50\) is pushed with a horizontal 30 N force. Does it move? What is the friction force?
Show answer
The maximum static friction is \((0.50)(100) = 50\ \text{N}\), more than the 30 N push, so the box does not move. Static friction is 30 N, equal to the push and opposite to it.
A student drags a 4.0 kg block at constant velocity across a level table with a horizontal 12 N force. Find \(\mu_k\).
Show answer
Constant velocity means the friction equals the pull: \(F_{f,k} = 12\ \text{N}\). With \(F_N = 40\ \text{N}\), \(\mu_k = 12/40 = 0.30\).
A block slides down a \(30^\circ\) ramp at constant speed. Find \(\mu_k\).
Show answer
Constant speed means \(a = 0\): \(mg\sin\theta = \mu_k mg\cos\theta\), so \(\mu_k = \tan 30^\circ = 0.58\).
The same block is placed on its narrow face instead of its wide face. How does the kinetic friction change? Explain.
Show answer
It does not change. Friction depends on the normal force and the materials, \(F_{f,k} = \mu_k F_N\), not on the area of contact. The normal force is the same (the weight), and so is the coefficient.
A block on a table is pushed with a small force and does not move. A student says, “The friction force is \(\mu_s F_N\).” Evaluate this statement.
Show answer
It is incorrect. The block is at rest, so static friction equals the push, which is less than the maximum \(\mu_s F_N\). The expression \(\mu_s F_N\) is only the upper limit, reached just as the block begins to slip.
A trampoline, a car’s suspension, the click of a ballpoint pen and the bounce of a diving board all depend on the same behavior: when you deform an elastic object, it pushes back. The simplest and most useful model of this behavior is the ideal spring, a spring whose force grows in direct proportion to how far it is stretched or compressed. This lesson states that model (Hooke’s law), shows how to read the force’s direction and size from a spring’s position, and develops the graph and experimental ideas the exam asks for, including how to measure a spring constant from data. Later in the course the same spring will return in two roles: as a store of potential energy (Unit 3) and as the engine of oscillation (Unit 7).
Learning objective · 2.8.A
Describe the force exerted on an object by an ideal spring.
Required content · EK 2.8.A.1 to 2.8.A.3
An ideal spring has negligible mass and exerts a force that is proportional to the change in its length as measured from its relaxed length.
The magnitude of the force exerted by an ideal spring on an object is given by Hooke’s law: \(\lvert\vec{F}_s\rvert = k\lvert\Delta\vec{x}\rvert\).
The force exerted on an object by a spring is always directed toward the equilibrium position of the object–spring system.
The ideal spring and Hooke’s law
The relaxed length of a spring is its length when no force is applied to it. If you stretch or compress the spring by an amount \(x\), measured from the relaxed length, an ideal spring exerts a force of magnitude
\[ F_s = kx. \]
This is Hooke’s law. The constant \(k\), the spring constant, measures stiffness and has units of newtons per meter (N/m). A large \(k\) is a stiff spring: it takes a big force to stretch it a little. A small \(k\) is a soft spring. Doubling the stretch doubles the force, and a force of \(F\) stretches a spring of constant \(k\) by \(x = F/k\).
The word ideal matters. The spring is assumed to have negligible mass, so it can be treated as transmitting force from one end to the other without needing a net force of its own, and it obeys the proportionality exactly. Real springs follow Hooke’s law for modest deformations; if you stretch them too far, they either deform permanently or stop obeying the straight-line rule.
A graph of the force exerted by a spring against its stretch is a straight line through the origin, and its slope is \(k\) (Figure 2.10a). This is the representation to use when you have experimental data: plot force against stretch, draw the best-fit line, and read \(k\) from the slope, not from any single point. Points that fall below the line at large stretches are a sign that the spring has been pushed beyond the range where Hooke’s law applies.
Figure 2.10a Hooke’s law. The force magnitude is proportional to the stretch or compression, F = kx, so the graph of force against stretch is a straight line through the origin whose slope is the spring constant k. The stiffer spring (k = 200 N/m) has the steeper line. Measured points at 0.025 m, 0.050 m, 0.075 m and 0.100 m give 5, 10, 15 and 20 N.
The force points toward equilibrium
The magnitude \(kx\) gives the size of the force; the direction comes from physical reasoning. The spring always tries to return to its relaxed length. If it is stretched, it pulls the object back toward the spring’s anchor; if it is compressed, it pushes the object away from the anchor. In both cases the force is directed toward the equilibrium position, the position at which the spring is neither stretched nor compressed and the spring force is zero (Figure 2.10b). A force with this property is called a restoring force.
In one dimension, with the origin of the \(x\)-axis at the equilibrium position, the two statements combine into one: \(F_x = -kx\). The minus sign says that the force is in the opposite direction to the displacement. When the object is displaced to positive \(x\), the force is negative (toward the equilibrium); when it is displaced to negative \(x\), the force is positive. On the exam you can use either the vector form with a stated direction, or the signed form, as long as the direction is clear.
Figure 2.10b The spring force is always directed toward the equilibrium position, where the spring is neither stretched nor compressed. Stretched, the spring pulls the block back toward the wall. Compressed, it pushes the block away from the wall. This is why it is called a restoring force, and why the force carries a minus sign: Fx = −kx.
Notice what the force does not depend on: the force depends on the position of the object, not on its velocity or on how it got there. A block at \(x = +0.10\ \text{m}\) feels the same spring force whether it is moving outward, moving inward, or momentarily at rest.
Springs in equilibrium and in motion
When an object hangs at rest from a vertical spring (Figure 2.10c), the net force is zero, so the spring force upward balances the weight downward: \(kx = mg\), and the stretch is \(x = mg/k\). The stretch is measured from the relaxed length, not from the position where the spring hangs once loaded. A common experiment loads the spring with several known masses, measures each stretch, and plots \(mg\) against \(x\). The slope of the best-fit line is \(k\).
Figure 2.10c A mass hanging at rest from a spring. The stretch x from the relaxed length makes the spring pull up with F = kx, which balances the weight: kx = mg, so x = mg/k. Measuring x for several known masses and plotting mg against x gives k as the slope.
When an object is not at rest, a spring is simply one of the forces in \(\sum F = ma\). Because the spring force changes as the object moves, the acceleration changes too. A block released from rest at a large stretch begins with a large acceleration; as the spring contracts, \(kx\) shrinks and so does the acceleration. At the equilibrium position, the spring force is zero and the acceleration (if no other forces act in that direction) is zero, even though the block may be moving at its maximum speed. This changing acceleration is the key to why a block on a spring oscillates, which Unit 7 will develop.
Worked example · size and direction
A spring has \(k = 200\ \text{N/m}\). What force does it exert when (a) stretched by 0.080 m, (b) compressed by 0.15 m? State the direction relative to the equilibrium position.
(a) \(F = kx = (200)(0.080) = 16\ \text{N}\), directed toward the equilibrium position, that is, back toward the anchor.
(b) \(F = (200)(0.15) = 30\ \text{N}\), directed toward the equilibrium position, that is, away from the anchor.
Worked example · finding k, then predicting a stretch
A 0.50 kg mass hanging at rest stretches a vertical spring by 0.050 m. (a) Find \(k\). (b) How far will a 1.2 kg mass stretch the same spring?
Check by proportion. The mass is 2.4 times larger, so the stretch is 2.4 times larger: \((2.4)(0.050) = 0.12\ \text{m}\). ✓
Worked example · acceleration of a block on a spring
A 2.0 kg block on a frictionless table is attached to a spring with \(k = 150\ \text{N/m}\). The block is pulled 0.12 m from equilibrium and released. Find its acceleration at release, and when it is 0.060 m from equilibrium.
At release. \(F = kx = (150)(0.12) = 18\ \text{N}\), so \(a = F/m = 18/2.0 = 9.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) toward the equilibrium position.
Halfway. \(F = (150)(0.060) = 9.0\ \text{N}\), so \(a = 4.5\ \text{m/s}^2\), again toward the equilibrium.
Interpretation. The block speeds up as it moves toward equilibrium, but its acceleration decreases the whole way, reaching zero at equilibrium. This is a case where acceleration is not constant, so the constant-acceleration equations of Unit 1 do not apply.
Worked example · a spring holding a block on a ramp
A 2.0 kg block rests on a frictionless \(30^\circ\) incline and is held in place by a spring parallel to the incline, with \(k = 200\ \text{N/m}\). How far is the spring stretched?
Along the slope. The block is at rest, so the spring force balances the component of the weight down the slope: \(kx = mg\sin 30^\circ = (20)(0.50) = 10\ \text{N}\).
A student hangs known forces on a spring and measures the stretch each time.
force (N)
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
stretch (cm)
2.1
3.9
6.2
8.0
Converting to meters, the points are (0.021, 2.0), (0.039, 4.0), (0.062, 6.0) and (0.080, 8.0). A line through the origin that fits them well has a slope of about \(\dfrac{8.0}{0.080} = 100\ \text{N/m}\), and a least-squares fit gives 99 N/m. The measured \(k\) is therefore about \(1.0 \times 10^2\ \text{N/m}\). The scatter of the points about the line reflects measurement error, not a failure of Hooke’s law.
Exam focus
Stretch, not length. \(x\) in \(F = kx\) is the change from the relaxed length. If a problem gives the spring’s total length, subtract the relaxed length first.
Direction toward equilibrium. Draw the spring force on the object toward the position where the spring is relaxed. A compressed spring pushes; a stretched spring pulls.
Slope is \(k\). On a graph of \(F\) against \(x\), the slope is the spring constant. On a graph of \(x\) against \(F\), the slope is \(1/k\). Read the axes before using the slope.
The force is not constant. A spring force that changes with position gives a changing acceleration. Do not use the constant-acceleration kinematics equations once a spring force is the main force acting.
Proportional reasoning. Doubling the stretch doubles the force; doubling \(k\) at fixed stretch doubles the force; at fixed force, doubling \(k\) halves the stretch.
Practice
A spring with \(k = 400\ \text{N/m}\) is stretched 0.050 m. What force does it exert?
Show answer
A 30 N force compresses a spring by 0.10 m. What is its spring constant?
Show answer
\(k = F/x = 30/0.10 = 300\ \text{N/m}\).
A spring stretched 4.0 cm exerts a force of 6.0 N. What force does it exert when stretched 10 cm?
Show answer
The force is proportional to the stretch: \((10/4.0)(6.0) = 15\ \text{N}\). (Equivalently, \(k = 6.0/0.040 = 150\ \text{N/m}\) and \(F = (150)(0.10) = 15\ \text{N}\).)
A block is attached to the right end of a spring whose left end is fixed to a wall, and the block is displaced 0.20 m to the right of equilibrium. In what direction is the force on the block?
Show answer
To the left, toward the equilibrium position and the wall. The spring is stretched, so it pulls the block back.
A 0.40 kg mass hangs at rest from a spring with \(k = 80\ \text{N/m}\). How far is the spring stretched?
Show answer
\(kx = mg\), so \(x = \dfrac{(0.40)(10)}{80} = 0.050\ \text{m}\).
A student plots stretch (horizontal axis) against force (vertical axis) and finds that the best-fit line passes through the origin and the point (0.040 m, 10 N). Find \(k\).
Show answer
The graph has force on the vertical axis, so the slope is \(k\): \(k = 10/0.040 = 250\ \text{N/m}\). (If the axes had been reversed, the slope would have been \(1/k\).)
Uniform circular motion and centripetal acceleration
A car rounds a curve at a steady 20 m/s. Its speedometer does not change, yet the car is certainly accelerating: you feel pressed against the door, and the tires must grip the road. In Unit 1 you learned that acceleration is a change in velocity, and velocity is a vector, so an object that changes direction accelerates even if its speed is constant. Circular motion is the cleanest example of this idea, and it is the foundation for everything from amusement park rides to planetary orbits. This lesson describes circular motion with speed, period and frequency, derives the magnitude and direction of the centripetal acceleration, connects it to forces through Newton’s second law, and adds the case where the speed also changes.
Learning objective · 2.9.A (first part)
Describe the motion of an object traveling in a circular path.
Required content · EK 2.9.A.1, 2.9.A.3 to 2.9.A.5
Centripetal acceleration is the component of an object’s acceleration directed toward the center of the object’s circular path. Its magnitude is the ratio of the object’s tangential speed squared to the radius of the circular path, \(a_c = v^2/r\), and it is directed toward the center of the circular path.
Tangential acceleration is the rate at which an object’s speed changes and is directed tangent to the object’s circular path.
The net acceleration of an object moving in a circle is the vector sum of the centripetal acceleration and tangential acceleration.
The revolution of an object traveling in a circular path at a constant speed (uniform circular motion) can be described using period and frequency. The time to complete one full circular path is the period, \(T\). The rate at which an object completes revolutions is the frequency, \(f = 1/T\). For constant speed in a circular path, the period is \(T = 2\pi r/v\).
Velocity and acceleration in uniform circular motion
In uniform circular motion an object moves around a circle at constant speed. The speed is constant, but the velocity is not: at every instant the velocity is tangent to the circle, and as the object moves around, the tangent direction keeps rotating (Figure 2.11a). Because the velocity changes direction, the object has an acceleration.
The direction of that acceleration is found by comparing the velocity at two nearby points. Over a short time, the change in velocity points toward the inside of the circle. In the limit of a very short time, it points exactly toward the center, perpendicular to the velocity. This is the centripetal acceleration (“center-seeking”). It changes the direction of the velocity without changing the speed, which is exactly what a force perpendicular to the motion does.
Figure 2.11a Uniform circular motion. The velocity is always tangent to the path and has constant magnitude, but its direction keeps changing. That change of direction is an acceleration, the centripetal acceleration, which is always perpendicular to the velocity and points toward the center of the circle, with magnitude ac = v²/r.
Its magnitude depends on how fast the object moves and how tight the circle is:
\[ a_c = \frac{v^2}{r}. \]
A larger speed means the velocity direction rotates faster, and a smaller radius means a sharper turn; both increase \(a_c\). Doubling the speed at a fixed radius quadruples the centripetal acceleration; doubling the radius at a fixed speed halves it. Taking a curve at 30 m/s instead of 15 m/s demands four times the acceleration, which is one reason high speed on a curve is so dangerous.
Period, frequency and speed
An object in uniform circular motion repeats its motion. The time for one full trip around the circle is the period \(T\), in seconds. The number of trips per second is the frequency \(f\), in hertz (Hz, or 1/s). They are reciprocals:
\[ f = \frac{1}{T}. \]
In one period the object travels one circumference, \(2\pi r\), at speed \(v\), so
\[ v = \frac{2\pi r}{T} = 2\pi r f. \]
Combining this with \(a_c = v^2/r\) gives a form of the centripetal acceleration written in terms of the period:
\[ a_c = \frac{4\pi^2 r}{T^2}. \]
This is useful when the question gives you how long one revolution takes, as for a rotating ride or a satellite, rather than the speed directly. Revolutions per minute (rpm) convert to frequency by dividing by 60: a wheel turning at 1200 rpm has \(f = 20\ \text{Hz}\) and \(T = 0.050\ \text{s}\).
Centripetal force
Newton’s second law applies to circular motion just as it does to straight-line motion. An object with centripetal acceleration \(a_c\) must have a net force toward the center, with magnitude
\[ F_{\text{net, center}} = m a_c = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
The name centripetal force labels this net force toward the center. It is not a new force with its own free-body-diagram arrow. Instead, one or more of the real forces already on the free-body diagram (tension, gravity, friction, the normal force, or components of these) points toward the center, and their combined effect supplies the \(mv^2/r\). When you solve a circular-motion problem, draw the free-body diagram with only the real forces, then set the sum of the components toward the center equal to \(mv^2/r\) (Figure 2.11b).
The force, like the acceleration, is perpendicular to the velocity, so it does not change the speed. If the force toward the center disappears, say the string breaks, nothing remains to bend the path, and by Newton’s first law the object moves off in a straight line along the tangent, not outward along the radius, which is a classic misconception.
Figure 2.11b The centripetal force is whatever real force points toward the center. For a ball on a string it is the tension. If the string is cut, the force toward the center disappears, and by Newton’s first law the ball continues in a straight line in the direction of its velocity at that instant, along the tangent, not outward along the radius.
When the speed changes: tangential acceleration
Many real motions combine circling with speeding up or slowing down: a car accelerating out of a curve, a ball swung faster on a string. The acceleration then has two perpendicular parts. The centripetal acceleration \(a_c = v^2/r\) points toward the center and changes the direction of the velocity. The tangential acceleration \(a_t\) points along the path (the direction of motion if the speed rises, opposite if it falls) and changes the speed at the rate \(a_t = \Delta v/\Delta t\) (Figure 2.11c). The net acceleration is their vector sum. Because the two are perpendicular,
\[ a = \sqrt{a_c^2 + a_t^2}. \]
The net acceleration points between the center direction and the direction of travel (or the opposite of travel if the object is slowing). At any instant, \(a_c\) is computed from the speed at that instant.
Figure 2.11c When the speed is also changing, the acceleration has two perpendicular parts. The centripetal component ac = v²/r points toward the center and changes the direction of the velocity. The tangential component at points along the path and changes the speed. The net acceleration is their vector sum.
Worked example · a car on a curve
A 1000 kg car travels at a constant 20 m/s around a circular curve of radius 50 m. Find the centripetal acceleration and the net force.
Acceleration. \(a_c = \dfrac{v^2}{r} = \dfrac{(20)^2}{50} = 8.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), toward the center of the curve.
Force. \(F = ma_c = (1000)(8.0) = 8000\ \text{N}\), directed toward the center. On a level road, this force is supplied by the friction between the tires and the road.
Worked example · period and frequency
A ball on a string moves in a horizontal circle of radius 0.80 m, completing one revolution every 0.50 s. Find the frequency, speed and centripetal acceleration.
Frequency. \(f = 1/T = 1/0.50 = 2.0\ \text{Hz}\).
Speed. \(v = \dfrac{2\pi r}{T} = \dfrac{2\pi(0.80)}{0.50} = 10\ \text{m/s}\) (10.05 m/s to three figures).
Acceleration. \(a_c = \dfrac{v^2}{r} = \dfrac{(10.05)^2}{0.80} = 126\ \text{m/s}^2\). The period form gives the same: \(\dfrac{4\pi^2(0.80)}{(0.50)^2} = 126\ \text{m/s}^2\), about 13 times \(g\). ✓
Worked example · tension as the centripetal force
A 0.30 kg ball moves at 4.0 m/s in a horizontal circle of radius 0.60 m on a string (ignore gravity’s effect on the string’s angle). What is the tension?
Force toward the center. The only force toward the center is the tension: \(T = \dfrac{mv^2}{r} = \dfrac{(0.30)(4.0)^2}{0.60} = \dfrac{4.8}{0.60} = 8.0\ \text{N}\).
Doubling the speed. At 8.0 m/s the tension would be four times larger, 32 N, because \(T\) is proportional to \(v^2\).
Worked example · speeding up around a curve
A car on a flat circular track of radius 100 m is moving at 15 m/s and speeding up at \(2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) along the track. Find its net acceleration.
Components. \(a_c = \dfrac{(15)^2}{100} = 2.25\ \text{m/s}^2\) toward the center and \(a_t = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) along the direction of motion.
Net. \(a = \sqrt{(2.25)^2 + (2.0)^2} = 3.0\ \text{m/s}^2\), directed \(\tan^{-1}(2.0/2.25) = 42^\circ\) from the inward direction, toward the forward direction.
Note. As the car’s speed rises, \(a_c\) grows too, so the net acceleration direction swings toward the center.
Exam focus
Constant speed does not mean zero acceleration. Any circular motion has an acceleration toward the center.
Centripetal force is not a separate force. Do not draw it on the free-body diagram. Name the real forces and say which ones point toward the center.
Direction. Velocity: tangent. Centripetal acceleration and net force (in uniform motion): toward the center. There is no outward force on the object; the “outward push” felt by a passenger is the object’s own inertia.
Scaling. \(a_c \propto v^2/r\). Use ratios: doubling \(v\) with \(r\) fixed gives 4 times; doubling \(r\) with \(v\) fixed gives half; doubling the period at fixed radius divides \(a_c\) by 4.
Released objects. If the force toward the center vanishes, the object moves in a straight line along the tangent at constant velocity.
Practice
A runner moves at 10 m/s around a circular track of radius 5.0 m. Find the centripetal acceleration.
Show answer
A horse on a carousel is 4.0 m from the center, and the carousel completes one turn every 8.0 s. Find the horse’s speed and centripetal acceleration.
Show answer
\(v = \dfrac{2\pi(4.0)}{8.0} = 3.1\ \text{m/s}\). \(a_c = \dfrac{(3.14)^2}{4.0} = 2.5\ \text{m/s}^2\). (The period form gives \(4\pi^2(4.0)/64 = 2.5\ \text{m/s}^2\).)
A fan blade completes 5.0 revolutions each second. What is its period?
Show answer
The frequency is 5.0 Hz, so \(T = 1/f = 0.20\ \text{s}\).
An object moves in a circle. Its speed doubles and the radius doubles. How does the centripetal acceleration change?
Show answer
\(a_c = v^2/r\): the new value is \((2v)^2/(2r) = 4v^2/2r = 2v^2/r\). It doubles.
A satellite orbits at a constant speed. Explain why it is accelerating.
Show answer
Its velocity is changing even though its speed is not, because the direction of the velocity keeps rotating. Acceleration is the rate of change of velocity, so the satellite has a centripetal acceleration directed toward the center of the orbit.
A car moving at 10 m/s on a circle of radius 50 m is speeding up at \(1.5\ \text{m/s}^2\) along the path. What is the magnitude of its net acceleration?
Show answer
Forces in circular motion: curves, loops and conical pendulums
Lesson 2.11 showed that circular motion needs a net force toward the center, \(mv^2/r\). This lesson asks the question the exam asks over and over: which force or forces supply it? The answer changes from situation to situation. For a car on a flat road it is friction. For a roller coaster at the top of a loop it is gravity plus the track’s push. On a banked highway curve it is part of the normal force. For a ball swinging in a horizontal circle it is part of the tension. The solving method never changes: draw the free-body diagram with real forces only, choose the axis toward the center, and write \(\sum F_{\text{toward center}} = mv^2/r\). Perpendicular to that axis there is no acceleration, so the forces balance.
Learning objective · 2.9.A (second part)
Describe the motion of an object traveling in a circular path.
Required content · EK 2.9.A.2 and its parts
Centripetal acceleration can result from a single force, more than one force, or components of forces exerted on an object in circular motion.
At the top of a vertical, circular loop, an object requires a minimum speed to maintain circular motion. At this point, and with this minimum speed, the gravitational force is the only force that causes the centripetal acceleration: \(v = \sqrt{gr}\).
Components of the static friction force and the normal force can contribute to the net force producing centripetal acceleration of an object traveling in a circle on a banked surface.
A component of tension contributes to the net force producing centripetal acceleration experienced by a conical pendulum.
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 only expects students to quantitatively analyze banked curves in which no friction is required to maintain uniform circular motion. Analysis of situations in which friction is required on a banked curve is limited to qualitative descriptions.
A flat curve: friction supplies the force
A car rounds a level, circular curve. Vertically, the road’s normal force balances the weight, \(F_N = mg\). The only horizontal force is the friction of the road on the tires, and it points toward the center of the curve (Figure 2.12a). The tires are not sliding sideways across the road, so this is static friction. It supplies the whole centripetal force:
\[ F_f = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
Friction has a limit, \(F_{f,s} \le \mu_s F_N = \mu_s mg\). The fastest the car can go without skidding sideways is reached when friction is at its maximum:
\[ \frac{mv_{\max}^2}{r} = \mu_s mg \quad\Rightarrow\quad v_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_s g r}. \]
The mass cancels, so a loaded truck and a small car share the same limit on the same road. Notice what this equation says: a wet road (small \(\mu_s\)) lowers the speed limit, and a tighter curve (small \(r\)) lowers it too. Once the speed exceeds \(v_{\max}\), the available friction is too small, and the car slides toward the outside of the curve along its original straight-line path.
Figure 2.12a A car rounding a flat curve. Gravity and the normal force balance vertically. The only horizontal force is static friction from the road on the tires, directed toward the center of the curve, and it supplies the centripetal force: Ff = mv²/r. Friction is not an extra “centripetal force”; it is the real force that has the job.
A vertical circle: gravity and the normal force
In a vertical circle, such as a roller coaster loop or a bucket swung overhead, gravity points down at every point, but the center of the circle is in a different direction at different points, so the forces toward the center change (Figure 2.12b). Take toward the center as the positive direction, then write \(\sum F = mv^2/r\) at each point.
At the bottom, the center is above, so the normal force (up) points toward the center and gravity (down) points away: \(F_N - mg = \dfrac{mv^2}{r}\), so \(F_N = mg + \dfrac{mv^2}{r}\). The normal force is larger than the weight, which is why you feel heavy at the bottom of a dip or loop.
At the top, the center is below, so both gravity and the normal force point toward the center: \(F_N + mg = \dfrac{mv^2}{r}\), so \(F_N = \dfrac{mv^2}{r} - mg\). You feel light there.
There is a limit at the top. The normal force from a track can push but cannot pull, so \(F_N \ge 0\). The minimum speed to stay in contact is the one for which \(F_N = 0\): gravity alone supplies the centripetal force, \(mg = mv^2/r\), so \(v_{\min} = \sqrt{gr}\). Below this speed, gravity pulls the object downward faster than the circle curves, and it leaves the track. The same reasoning applies to the top of a hill: a car crossing the crest of a rounded hill has gravity (down, toward the center of its circular path) and the road’s normal force (up, away from the center), so \(mg - F_N = mv^2/r\), and the road pushes with less than the weight.
Figure 2.12b Forces on an object moving in a vertical circle (a loop-the-loop). Take toward the center as positive. At the top, the normal force and gravity both point toward the center: FN + mg = mv²/r. At the bottom, the normal force points toward the center but gravity points away: FN − mg = mv²/r. The normal force is much larger at the bottom than at the top.
A banked curve: the normal force tilts
On a banked road, the surface is tilted toward the inside of the curve by an angle \(\theta\). The normal force is perpendicular to the road, so it leans toward the center. Even with no friction at all, a car can round the curve because a component of the normal force points toward the center (Figure 2.12c). With the vertical and horizontal axes (the horizontal axis points to the center, since the car’s path is a horizontal circle),
\[ F_N\cos\theta = mg, \qquad F_N\sin\theta = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
Dividing the second equation by the first eliminates both \(F_N\) and the mass:
\[ \tan\theta = \frac{v^2}{rg}. \]
This gives the design speed of the bank, \(v = \sqrt{rg\tan\theta}\), at which the car needs no friction at all. The normal force is larger than the weight, \(F_N = mg/\cos\theta\).
Real roads work at other speeds because of friction, and the CED asks for a qualitative description only. Going slower than the design speed, the car tends to slide down the bank, so static friction acts up the slope, which has a component pointing away from the center and helps balance the extra normal-force component. Going faster, the car tends to slide up and out, so static friction acts down the slope, with a component toward the center that adds to the normal force’s. Either way, banking lets cars take a curve faster than the flat-curve limit.
Figure 2.12c A frictionless banked curve. The normal force is perpendicular to the road, so it tilts toward the center of the curve. Its vertical component balances gravity, FN cos θ = mg, and its horizontal component supplies the centripetal force, FN sin θ = mv²/r. Dividing the two equations gives tan θ = v²/(rg).
A conical pendulum: a component of the tension
A conical pendulum is a ball on a string that swings in a horizontal circle, with the string tracing out a cone (Figure 2.12d). Two forces act on the ball: gravity down and tension along the string, at angle \(\theta\) from the vertical. The tension is not horizontal, so it cannot alone supply the centripetal force; instead its horizontal component does, and its vertical component balances gravity:
\[ T\cos\theta = mg, \qquad T\sin\theta = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
With the radius of the circle \(r = L\sin\theta\), where \(L\) is the length of the string, dividing again gives \(\tan\theta = v^2/(rg)\), the same relation as for the banked curve. The mathematics is identical because both situations have the same structure: one force straight up that balances gravity, and a horizontal remainder toward the center. The net force on the ball is horizontal and points to the center of the circle, not along the string.
Figure 2.12d A conical pendulum: a ball on a string of length L moving in a horizontal circle of radius r = L sin θ. Only two forces act, tension and gravity. The vertical component of the tension balances gravity, T cos θ = mg, and the horizontal component supplies the centripetal force, T sin θ = mv²/r. The net force is horizontal and points to the center of the circle, not along the string.
Worked example · the fastest safe speed on a flat curve
A curve of radius 50 m is on a level road. What is the maximum speed at which a car can round it with \(\mu_s = 0.80\) (dry road)? What about a wet road with \(\mu_s = 0.40\)?
Dry. \(v_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_s g r} = \sqrt{(0.80)(10)(50)} = \sqrt{400} = 20\ \text{m/s}\), about 72 km/h.
Wet. \(v_{\max} = \sqrt{(0.40)(10)(50)} = \sqrt{200} = 14\ \text{m/s}\). Halving \(\mu_s\) reduces the limit by a factor of \(\sqrt{2}\), not by half.
Worked example · over the top of a hill
A 1000 kg car crosses the top of a rounded hill of radius 40 m at 10 m/s. What is the normal force from the road?
Toward the center (down). \(mg - F_N = \dfrac{mv^2}{r}\), so \(F_N = mg - \dfrac{mv^2}{r} = 10\,000 - \dfrac{(1000)(100)}{40} = 10\,000 - 2500 = 7500\ \text{N}\).
Interpretation. The road pushes up with 7500 N, only 75 percent of the 10 000 N weight, so the driver feels lighter. At \(v = \sqrt{gr} = 20\ \text{m/s}\), the normal force would drop to zero and the car would leave the road.
Worked example · a loop-the-loop
A 50 kg rider travels through a vertical loop of radius 10 m at 15 m/s at both the bottom and the top (assume the speed is the same for simplicity). Find the normal force at each point, and the minimum speed at the top.
Bottom. \(\dfrac{mv^2}{r} = \dfrac{(50)(225)}{10} = 1125\ \text{N}\), so \(F_N = mg + 1125 = 500 + 1125 = 1625\ \text{N}\), more than three times the weight.
Minimum speed at the top. \(v_{\min} = \sqrt{gr} = \sqrt{(10)(10)} = 10\ \text{m/s}\). Since the rider at 15 m/s exceeds it, contact is maintained. (In a real loop the speed at the top would be lower than at the bottom; Unit 3 will show how to find it from energy.)
Worked example · a frictionless banked curve
A highway curve has radius 100 m. At what angle should it be banked so that a car at 20 m/s needs no friction? What is the normal force on a 1000 kg car?
A 0.20 kg ball on a 1.0 m string moves in a horizontal circle with the string at \(30^\circ\) from the vertical. Find the tension, the speed and the period.
Toward the center is positive. Choose that axis first. Forces pointing toward the center are positive; forces pointing away are negative.
Which forces? Name them. Flat curve: friction. Top of a loop: gravity (and the normal force). Bottom: the normal force minus gravity. Banked: a component of the normal force. Conical pendulum: a component of the tension.
The vertical balance. For a horizontal circle with an angled force, the vertical components balance, \(F\cos\theta = mg\), and the horizontal components supply \(mv^2/r\). Divide to get \(\tan\theta = v^2/(rg)\).
Minimum speed. At the top of a loop, \(F_N = 0\) gives \(v_{\min} = \sqrt{gr}\). Below it, the object leaves the track.
Mass cancels in the flat-curve speed limit, the banked-curve angle and the conical-pendulum angle; it does not cancel in the force values.
Practice
A car rounds a level curve of radius 40 m. If \(\mu_s = 0.50\), what is the maximum speed?
Show answer
A 0.50 kg ball on a 0.80 m string moves in a horizontal circle with the string at \(45^\circ\) from the vertical. Find the tension and the speed.
Show answer
Why is the maximum speed on a flat curve the same for a loaded truck and an empty one on the same road?
Show answer
The maximum friction is \(\mu_s mg\) and the required centripetal force is \(mv^2/r\). Both are proportional to the mass, so the mass cancels: \(v_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_s g r}\), independent of mass.
The International Space Station circles Earth every 92 minutes at about 7.7 kilometers per second, and a weather satellite hovers over the same spot on the equator for years. The Moon has circled Earth for billions of years. None of these objects has an engine pushing it along. They are all doing the same thing: falling toward the center of the body they orbit while moving sideways so fast that they keep missing it. This lesson puts together the two big ideas of the unit, the universal law of gravitation and centripetal acceleration, and shows that they give a single equation connecting the period and radius of any circular orbit to the mass of the central body.
Learning objective · 2.9.B
Describe circular orbits using Kepler’s third law.
Required content · EK 2.9.B.1
For a satellite in circular orbit around a central body, the satellite’s centripetal acceleration is caused only by gravitational attraction. The period and radius of the circular orbit are related to the mass of the central body: \(T^2 = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{GM}\,r^3\).
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 does not expect students to know Kepler’s first or second laws of planetary motion.
Why a satellite stays up
Newton imagined a cannon on top of a very tall mountain. A cannonball fired horizontally falls to the ground some distance away. Fire it faster and it lands farther away. Fire it fast enough, and the ground curves away beneath the cannonball as fast as the ball falls toward it: it never lands. That ball is in orbit. The key point is that the satellite is not outside the reach of gravity. At the Space Station’s height of 400 km, the gravitational field is still about 8.7 N/kg, close to 90 percent of its value at the surface. The astronauts float because they, and the station, are in free fall together (lesson 2.8), not because gravity has gone away.
The orbit equations
Consider a satellite of mass \(m\) in a circular orbit of radius \(r\) (measured from the center of the central body, mass \(M\)) at speed \(v\) (Figure 2.13a). The only force on it is the gravitational attraction of the central body, which points toward the center. That is the centripetal force:
\[ \frac{GMm}{r^2} = \frac{mv^2}{r}. \]
The satellite’s mass cancels, so the orbital speed depends only on the central body and the radius:
\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}}. \]
This has a counterintuitive implication: a satellite in a higher orbit moves more slowly. The speed falls as \(1/\sqrt{r}\).
Figure 2.13a A circular orbit. The only force on the satellite is the gravitational attraction of the central body, which points toward the center and supplies the centripetal force: GMm/r² = mv²/r. The satellite’s mass cancels, so the orbital speed v = √(GM/r) and period T depend only on the central mass and the orbital radius r, measured from the center of the central body.
To find the period, use \(v = 2\pi r/T\) in the same equation:
\[ \frac{GM}{r^2} = \frac{4\pi^2 r}{T^2} \quad\Rightarrow\quad T^2 = \frac{4\pi^2}{GM}\,r^3. \]
This is the form of Kepler’s third law for circular orbits: the square of the period is proportional to the cube of the radius, with a constant of proportionality that depends only on the mass of the central body. (Johannes Kepler found this relationship from the observed motions of the planets, before Newton explained why it holds.) Two consequences are useful on the exam:
Comparing orbits of the same body. Because \(T^2 \propto r^3\), a satellite with four times the orbital radius has a period \(4^{3/2} = 8\) times as long, and a satellite with twice the radius has a period \(2^{3/2} = 2.8\) times as long.
Weighing the central body. If you can measure the period and radius of any satellite, you can solve for the mass of the object it orbits, \(M = 4\pi^2 r^3/(GT^2)\). This is how astronomers find the mass of the Sun, of the planets that have moons, and of distant stars with planets.
If you plot \(T^2\) against \(r^3\) for several satellites of the same body, you get a straight line through the origin with slope \(4\pi^2/(GM)\) (Figure 2.13b). A body with larger mass gives a smaller slope, because at the same radius a satellite must go around faster, with a shorter period.
Figure 2.13b Period squared against radius cubed for satellites of one central body is a straight line through the origin, as T² = (4π²/GM) r³ predicts. The slope, 4π²/(GM), gives the mass of the central body. (The axis values here are illustrative.)
What the equations leave out
The mass of the satellite does not appear anywhere. A 1 kg satellite and a 1000 kg satellite at the same radius have the same speed and period; a bowling ball and an astronaut released together in orbit stay together. The radius is measured from the center of the central body, so for an orbit around Earth you add the altitude to Earth’s radius. (The equations assume \(M \gg m\), so that the central body is essentially stationary.) Finally, these equations apply only to circular orbits. Orbits that are not circular, with the speed changing along the way, are beyond this course.
Worked example · the International Space Station
The ISS orbits 400 km above Earth’s surface. Find its speed and period. (\(G = 6.67\times10^{-11}\ \text{N·m}^2/\text{kg}^2\), \(M_E = 5.97\times10^{24}\ \text{kg}\), \(R_E = 6.37\times10^{6}\ \text{m}\).)
Period. \(T = \dfrac{2\pi r}{v} = \dfrac{2\pi(6.77\times10^{6})}{7.67\times10^{3}} = 5.5\times10^{3}\ \text{s}\), about 92 minutes, so the station circles the Earth about 15.6 times per day.
Acceleration. \(a_c = v^2/r = GM/r^2 = 8.7\ \text{m/s}^2\), toward Earth’s center, which is the gravitational field at that altitude.
Worked example · a geostationary satellite
A communications satellite stays above one point on the equator, so its period equals Earth’s rotation period, 24 h = 86 400 s. Find its orbital radius and speed.
Radius. From \(T^2 = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{GM}r^3\): \(r^3 = \dfrac{GMT^2}{4\pi^2} = \dfrac{(3.98\times10^{14})(86\,400)^2}{4\pi^2} = 7.53\times10^{22}\ \text{m}^3\), so \(r = 4.2\times10^{7}\ \text{m}\), about 36 000 km above the surface.
Speed. \(v = \sqrt{GM/r} = \sqrt{\dfrac{3.98\times10^{14}}{4.22\times10^{7}}} = 3.1\times10^{3}\ \text{m/s}\), much slower than the ISS, as expected for a higher orbit.
Worked example · the mass of the Sun
Earth orbits the Sun at an average radius of \(1.50\times10^{11}\ \text{m}\) with a period of one year, \(3.156\times10^{7}\ \text{s}\). Find the Sun’s mass.
Interpretation. The Sun is about 330 000 times more massive than Earth, and Earth’s own mass has no effect on this result. The same calculation works for any planet; all give the same \(M\).
Worked example · scaling a period
Satellite A orbits at radius \(r\) with period 2.0 h around a planet. Satellite B orbits at radius \(4r\) around the same planet. What is its period and how does its speed compare?
Speed. \(v \propto r^{-1/2}\), so \(v_B = v_A/\sqrt{4} = v_A/2\). Check using \(v = 2\pi r/T\): the circumference is 4 times larger and the period 8 times larger, so \(v_B/v_A = 4/8 = 1/2\). ✓
Exam focus
One force, one equation. Gravity is the only force, so \(GMm/r^2 = mv^2/r\). Start from that and derive whatever you need.
The radius is from the center. Add the altitude to the planet’s radius. Using the altitude alone is a very common error.
Higher means slower. A farther orbit has a smaller speed and a longer period. The mass of the satellite does not matter.
Ratios. \(T^2 \propto r^3\) and \(v \propto 1/\sqrt{r}\) allow quick scaling without numbers.
Mass of the central body only. The \(M\) in these equations is the mass of the body being orbited, not of the satellite.
Practice
A satellite’s orbital radius is quadrupled. By what factor does its period change?
Show answer
\(T \propto r^{3/2}\), so the period is multiplied by \(4^{3/2} = 8\).
The Moon orbits Earth at a radius of \(3.84\times10^{8}\ \text{m}\) with a period of 27.3 days (\(2.36\times10^{6}\ \text{s}\)). Find Earth’s mass.
Show answer
Explain why an astronaut inside a spacecraft in orbit moves along the same path as the spacecraft, even though the astronaut is not attached to it.
Show answer
The orbital speed and period depend only on the radius and the mass of the central body, not on the mass of the orbiting object. The astronaut at the same radius has the same speed and orbit as the spacecraft.
A planet orbits a star at four times the orbital radius of Earth around the Sun, and the star has the same mass as the Sun. What is the planet’s period in Earth years?
Show answer
\(T \propto r^{3/2}\) with the same central mass: \(T = (1\ \text{yr})(4)^{3/2} = 8\ \text{yr}\).
What is the centripetal acceleration of the ISS, and what provides it?
Show answer
\(a_c = GM/r^2 = 8.7\ \text{m/s}^2\), directed toward Earth’s center. It is provided entirely by Earth’s gravitational attraction on the station.
Unit 2 practice · 10 problems
Unit 2 practice: Force and Translational Dynamics
Ten problems covering the whole unit: one of the two heaviest units on
the exam. Draw the free-body diagram before you write any equation. Use
\(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as the exam does.
(a) A 3.0 kg block sits at \(x = 0\) and a 5.0 kg block at \(x = 2.0\) m. Find the center of mass. (b) A block slides down a rough incline. List every force on its free-body diagram with its direction, and state which arrow must be shorter than the weight arrow and why.
Show answer
(a) \(x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{\sum m_i x_i}{\sum m_i} = \dfrac{(3.0)(0) + (5.0)(2.0)}{8.0} = 1.25\) m, closer to the heavier block. (b) Gravity \(mg\) straight down; normal force perpendicular to the incline surface, away from it; kinetic friction parallel to the surface, up the slope (opposite the sliding). The normal arrow is shorter than the weight arrow because it balances only the perpendicular component \(mg\cos\theta\). No "force of motion" arrow: velocity is not a force.
An 8.0 kg sign hangs at rest from two identical cables, each making 40° with the horizontal. Find the tension in each cable.
Show answer
FBD: weight down, two equal tensions \(T\) at 40° above horizontal leaning opposite ways; horizontal components cancel. \(\sum F_y = 2T\sin 40^\circ - mg = 0\), so \(T = \dfrac{mg}{2\sin 40^\circ} = \dfrac{(8.0)(10)}{2(0.643)} = \dfrac{80\ \text{N}}{1.29} = 62\) N. Each cable carries more than half the weight because only part of its pull is vertical.
A book rests on a table. Which force is the Newton's third-law partner of Earth's gravitational pull on the book?
The normal force happens to be equal and opposite to the book's weight here, but it is a different type of force (contact, not gravitational) acting on the same object; it balances gravity by Newton's first law, not the third. Third-law pairs never act on the same object.
Third-law pairs swap the two objects and keep the type: Earth pulls the book gravitationally, so the book pulls Earth gravitationally, with equal magnitude and opposite direction.
The normal force of the book on the table is the third-law partner of the normal force of the table on the book: a contact-force pair. It is not paired with the gravitational force at all.
The table's weight is Earth's pull on a different object entirely and is paired with nothing acting on the book. Its own third-law partner would be the table's gravitational pull on Earth.
Box A (3.0 kg) and box B (5.0 kg) sit on a frictionless floor, connected by a light string. A horizontal 24 N force pulls B, dragging A behind it. Find the acceleration and the tension in the string.
Show answer
Whole system (8.0 kg): the string is internal, so \(a = \dfrac{\sum F_x}{m_{\text{tot}}} = \dfrac{24\ \text{N}}{8.0\ \text{kg}} = 3.0\) m/s². Box A alone: the only horizontal force is \(T\), so \(T = m_A a = (3.0)(3.0) = 9.0\) N. Check on B: \(24 - T = m_B a \Rightarrow 24 - 9.0 = (5.0)(3.0) = 15\) N ✓.
(a) An 80 kg person stands on a scale in an elevator accelerating downward at 3.0 m/s². What does the scale read, and does the person feel heavier or lighter? (b) A planet has three times Earth's mass and twice Earth's radius. Find \(g\) at its surface.
Show answer
(a) Up positive: \(\sum F_y = N - mg = m(-3.0)\), so \(N = m(g - a) = (80)(10 - 3.0) = 560\) N, less than the 800 N weight: lighter. (b) \(g = \dfrac{GM}{r^2}\), so \(g_{\text{planet}} = g_E \cdot \dfrac{3}{2^2} = \dfrac{3}{4}(10) = 7.5\) m/s². Tripling the mass triples \(g\); doubling the radius cuts it by four.
A 4.0 kg block slides down a 25° incline with \(\mu_k = 0.15\). Find the normal force, the friction force, and the acceleration.
Show answer
Axes along and perpendicular to the slope. Perpendicular: \(N = mg\cos\theta = (4.0)(10)\cos 25^\circ = 36\) N. Friction: \(f_k = \mu_k N = (0.15)(36.3) = 5.4\) N, up the slope. Along the slope: \(mg\sin\theta - f_k = ma\), so \(a = \dfrac{(4.0)(10)(0.423) - 5.44}{4.0} = \dfrac{16.9 - 5.44}{4.0} = 2.9\) m/s². Equivalently \(a = g(\sin\theta - \mu_k\cos\theta)\); the mass cancels.
A student hangs masses from a spring and records spring force versus stretch. Two points on the best-fit line are (0.10 m, 12 N) and (0.25 m, 30 N). Find \(k\), then find how far the spring stretches when a 0.60 kg mass hangs at rest from it.
Show answer
\(k = \text{slope} = \dfrac{30 - 12\ \text{N}}{0.25 - 0.10\ \text{m}} = \dfrac{18}{0.15} = 120\) N/m. Hanging mass at rest: \(\sum F_y = k\,\Delta x - mg = 0\), so \(\Delta x = \dfrac{mg}{k} = \dfrac{(0.60)(10)}{120} = 0.050\) m = 5.0 cm. The line passes through the origin because an unstretched spring exerts no force.
(a) A 0.50 kg ball on a 1.2 m string moves in a horizontal circle at 6.0 m/s on a frictionless table. Find the tension. (b) What is the fastest a car can round a flat curve of radius 60 m if \(\mu_s = 0.70\)? (c) A satellite’s orbital radius is increased to four times its original value. By what factor does its period change?
Show answer
(a) Tension is the only inward force: \(T = m\dfrac{v^2}{r} = (0.50)\dfrac{(6.0)^2}{1.2} = 15\) N. (b) Static friction supplies the inward force, at most \(\mu_s N = \mu_s mg\): \(\mu_s mg = m\dfrac{v^2}{r} \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{\mu_s g r} = \sqrt{(0.70)(10)(60)} = \sqrt{420} = 20\) m/s. The mass cancels: a truck and a bike have the same limit on the same road. (c) Gravity supplies the centripetal force, so \(T^2 \propto r^3\) and \(T \propto r^{3/2}\): the period is multiplied by \(4^{3/2} = 8\).
A passenger in a car turning sharply left says, "I was thrown outward against the door." In a short paragraph, explain what actually happened using Newton's laws, and state whether an outward force belongs on the passenger's free-body diagram.
Show answer
By Newton's first law the passenger tends to keep moving in a straight line at constant velocity. The car turns left beneath her, so relative to the car she slides toward the right-hand door, but nothing pushed her outward. When she reaches the door, the door pushes inward on her (a normal force), and that inward force is what makes her follow the curve: \(\sum F_{\text{in}} = mv^2/r\). Her free-body diagram shows gravity, the seat's normal force, and the door's inward push. No outward "centrifugal" force appears, because no object exerts one.
Experimental design. You have a wooden block, a set of masses, a spring scale, and a horizontal table. Design a procedure to measure the coefficient of kinetic friction between block and table. State what you measure, what you vary, what graph you plot, and how \(\mu_k\) comes from the graph.
Show answer
Pull the block horizontally with the spring scale at constant speed; then \(\sum F_x = 0\), so the scale reading equals \(f_k\). Vary the normal force by stacking known masses on the block; on a horizontal table \(N = (m_{\text{block}} + m_{\text{added}})g\). Repeat each load several times and average. Plot \(f_k\) (vertical) against \(N\) (horizontal): \(f_k = \mu_k N\) predicts a straight line through the origin with slope \(\mu_k\). Using the slope of a best-fit line rather than one ratio reduces the effect of random error; pulling with the scale parallel to the table keeps \(N\) equal to the weight.
In Unit 2 you predicted motion by following forces moment by moment: find the net force, divide by the mass, get the acceleration, then use kinematics. That method always works, but it can be laborious, and for many problems you only care about the beginning and the end of the motion, such as how fast a roller coaster is moving at the bottom of a hill. Energy offers a shortcut. Instead of tracking the changing acceleration along the path, you keep a running account of a quantity that moves from one place or form to another. The first entry in that account is the energy an object has because it is moving: its translational kinetic energy.
Learning objective · 3.1.A
Describe the translational kinetic energy of an object in terms of the object’s mass and velocity.
Required content · EK 3.1.A.1 to 3.1.A.3
An object’s translational kinetic energy is given by the equation \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\).
Translational kinetic energy is a scalar quantity.
Different observers may measure different values of the translational kinetic energy of an object, depending on the observer’s frame of reference.
The definition
An object of mass \(m\) moving with speed \(v\) has translational kinetic energy
\[ K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2. \]
The word translational distinguishes this energy from the energy of rotation, which you will meet in Unit 5. For a point-like object, or for the motion of the center of mass of an extended one, translational kinetic energy is the only kinetic energy there is.
Energy is measured in joules (J). From the formula, \(1\ \text{J} = 1\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}^2\), which is the same as \(1\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), a force of one newton acting over one meter. A 1 kg object moving at 1 m/s has \(K = 0.5\ \text{J}\), and a 0.15 kg baseball at 40 m/s has \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.15)(40)^2 = 120\ \text{J}\). A 1000 kg car at 20 m/s has \(2 \times 10^5\ \text{J}\), about a thousand times as much.
A scalar that depends on speed squared
Kinetic energy is a scalar. It has a magnitude but no direction, and it depends on the object’s speed, not its velocity vector. A car traveling north at 20 m/s and an identical car traveling east at 20 m/s have exactly the same kinetic energy. Kinetic energy can never be negative, because \(m\) and \(v^2\) are both nonnegative. It is zero only when the object is at rest.
The squared speed makes kinetic energy grow much faster than speed (Figure 3.1a). If you double the speed, the kinetic energy increases by a factor of four; triple it, and the energy grows by a factor of nine. If you double the mass at fixed speed, the energy merely doubles. This is why speed matters so much in a collision, and why a small, fast object can carry more energy than a large, slow one: a 0.15 kg baseball at 40 m/s (120 J) has nearly four times the kinetic energy of a 7.0 kg bowling ball rolling at 3.0 m/s (31.5 J).
Figure 3.1a Kinetic energy against speed for a 2.0 kg object. Because K = ½mv², the graph is a parabola, not a straight line: doubling the speed from 2 to 4 m/s multiplies the kinetic energy by four, from 4 J to 16 J.
Because of the square, ratios are especially useful. If two objects have the same kinetic energy and one has four times the mass of the other, then the lighter one moves twice as fast: \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4m)v_A^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}m v_B^2\) gives \(v_B = 2v_A\). The factor on speed is the square root of the factor on mass.
Kinetic energy depends on the observer
Velocity is measured relative to something, so kinetic energy is, too. Consider a 60 kg passenger sitting still on a train that moves at 20 m/s relative to the ground (Figure 3.1b). An observer on the ground sees the passenger moving at 20 m/s and calculates \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(60)(20)^2 = 12\,000\ \text{J}\). An observer sitting on the train sees the passenger at rest and calculates \(K = 0\). Neither is wrong. The kinetic energy is not a property of the passenger alone; it is a property of the passenger and the frame of reference in which the speed is measured. Always say which frame you are using, and use the same frame for every quantity in a problem.
Figure 3.1b Kinetic energy depends on the frame of reference. For a 60 kg passenger seated on a train moving at 20 m/s, an observer on the ground finds K = 12 000 J, while an observer on the train finds K = 0. Both are correct for their own frames; the numbers differ because the speeds differ.
Kinetic energy and the idea of a system
A system consisting of a single object can have only kinetic energy. Other forms of energy, such as the energy of a stretched spring or of a ball high above the ground, belong to systems with more than one part, and you will meet them in the next lessons. For now, kinetic energy is the energy of motion. What changes it? Newton’s second law says that a net force changes velocity; the next two lessons show that the exact bookkeeping of that change is done with a quantity called work.
Worked example · comparing two speeds
A 1200 kg car moves at 15 m/s, then speeds up to 30 m/s. Find the kinetic energy at each speed and the factor by which it changes.
Factor. \(5.4 \times 10^{5} / 1.35 \times 10^{5} = 4.0\). Doubling the speed quadruples the kinetic energy, so the braking system must remove four times as much energy to stop a car at 30 m/s as at 15 m/s.
Worked example · from energy to speed
A 0.20 kg ball has a kinetic energy of 25 J. How fast is it moving? If its speed is doubled, what is its new kinetic energy?
Doubling. The kinetic energy becomes \(4 \times 25 = 100\ \text{J}\), without needing to recompute from the mass.
Worked example · same energy, different masses
Objects A and B have the same kinetic energy, and A has four times the mass of B. Compare their speeds.
Equate. \(\tfrac{1}{2}m_A v_A^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}m_B v_B^2\) with \(m_A = 4m_B\): \(4v_A^2 = v_B^2\), so \(v_B = 2v_A\).
Interpretation. The lighter object moves twice as fast. A common error is to say it moves four times as fast, which would be true if the two had the same momentum (Unit 4), not the same kinetic energy.
Worked example · two frames
A 70 kg passenger walks forward at 1.5 m/s along the aisle of a train that moves at 20 m/s relative to the ground. Find the passenger’s kinetic energy as measured by an observer on the ground and by one on the train.
On the train. \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(70)(1.5)^2 = 79\ \text{J}\).
On the ground. The passenger’s speed is \(20 + 1.5 = 21.5\ \text{m/s}\) (Unit 1, relative motion in one dimension), so \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(70)(21.5)^2 = 1.6 \times 10^{4}\ \text{J}\).
Note. The two values are not related by simply adding \(79\ \text{J}\) to \(\tfrac{1}{2}(70)(20)^2 = 1.4 \times 10^{4}\ \text{J}\), because kinetic energy depends on the square of the total speed.
Exam focus
Speed, not velocity. Direction does not matter for \(K\). Two objects with the same mass and speed have the same kinetic energy whatever their directions.
Squares. Double the speed means four times the energy; half the speed means one quarter. State the factor and why.
Frames. If a question asks about kinetic energy “as measured by an observer,” identify the observer’s frame first and use speeds relative to that observer.
Graphs. \(K\) against \(v\) is a parabola; \(K\) against \(v^2\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(m/2\).
Never negative. A calculated negative kinetic energy is always an arithmetic error.
Practice
A 0.50 kg ball moves at 12 m/s. What is its kinetic energy?
Show answer
\(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.50)(12)^2 = 36\ \text{J}\).
An object’s speed triples. By what factor does its kinetic energy change?
Show answer
\(K \propto v^2\), so the energy is multiplied by \(3^2 = 9\).
A 4.0 kg cart has a kinetic energy of 200 J. Find its speed.
Show answer
Object 1 has mass \(2m\) and speed \(v\). Object 2 has mass \(m\) and speed \(2v\). Which has more kinetic energy, and by what factor?
Show answer
\(K_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}(2m)v^2 = mv^2\); \(K_2 = \tfrac{1}{2}m(2v)^2 = 2mv^2\). Object 2 has twice as much kinetic energy.
A 70 kg person sits still in a train moving at 20 m/s relative to the ground. What is the person’s kinetic energy in the train’s frame and in the ground’s frame?
Show answer
In the train’s frame the person is at rest, so \(K = 0\). In the ground frame, \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(70)(20)^2 = 1.4 \times 10^{4}\ \text{J}\).
A student says, “The kinetic energy of the ball is \(-8\ \text{J}\) because it is moving downward.” Evaluate the statement.
Show answer
It is incorrect. Kinetic energy is a scalar and depends on speed squared, so it cannot be negative and has no direction. A ball moving downward at speed \(v\) has the same kinetic energy as one moving upward at the same speed.
Lesson 3.2 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2 (work, part 1)
In everyday speech, “work” means effort: studying, carrying a heavy suitcase through an airport, holding a barbell motionless overhead. Physics uses the word in a narrower and much more useful way. Work is the amount of energy transferred into or out of a system by a force acting over a distance. It is the bridge between the forces of Unit 2 and the energies of this unit: forces do work, and work changes energy. By the end of this lesson you will be able to calculate the work done by any constant force, decide whether that work is positive, negative or zero, and explain why a force that does no work can still change the direction of an object’s motion.
Learning objective · 3.2.A (first part)
Describe the work done on an object or system by a given force or collection of forces.
Required content · EK 3.2.A.1 to 3.2.A.3
Work is the amount of energy transferred into or out of a system by a force exerted on that system over a distance.
Work is a scalar quantity that may be positive, negative, or zero.
The amount of work done on a system by a constant force is related to the components of that force and the displacement of the point at which that force is exerted: \(W = F\,d\cos\theta\).
Only the component of the force exerted on a system that is parallel to the displacement of the point of application of the force will change the system’s total energy.
The component of the force exerted on a system perpendicular to the direction of the displacement of the system’s center of mass can change the direction of the system’s motion without changing the system’s kinetic energy.
The definition of work
For a constant force \(\vec{F}\) acting on an object that undergoes a displacement of magnitude \(d\), the work done by the force is
\[ W = F\,d\cos\theta, \]
where \(\theta\) is the angle between the force vector and the displacement vector. The product \(F\cos\theta\) is the component of the force along the direction of motion, so the equation says: work is the component of the force along the displacement, multiplied by the distance moved. The force and the distance must belong together: \(d\) is the displacement of the point where the force is applied.
The unit of work is the same as the unit of energy, the joule: \(1\ \text{J} = 1\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\). Work is a scalar, even though it is built from two vectors. It has a size and a sign but no direction. Lifting a 1 kg object 1 m takes about \(mgh = (1)(10)(1) = 10\ \text{J}\); pushing a shopping cart 10 m with a 20 N force along the floor transfers 200 J.
Why only the parallel component? A force component perpendicular to the motion pushes the object sideways but does not push it any farther along its path, so it moves no energy in or out. Figure 3.2a shows a box pulled by a 50 N force at \(30^\circ\) above the floor. The vertical part, \(F\sin\theta\), partly holds the box up and lessens the normal force, but it does no work because the box does not move vertically. The horizontal part, \(F\cos\theta = 43\ \text{N}\), is the only part that adds energy.
Figure 3.2a Work by a force at an angle. Only the component of the force parallel to the displacement, F cos θ, transfers energy. The perpendicular component, F sin θ, changes the normal force but does no work. For F = 50 N, d = 10 m and θ = 30°, W = (50)(10)cos 30° = 430 J.
Positive, negative and zero work
The sign of the work comes from the cosine of the angle (Figure 3.2b).
\(0^\circ \le \theta \lt 90^\circ\): positive work. The force has a component along the motion. It adds energy to the system. A rope pulling a sled forward does positive work on the sled.
\(90^\circ \lt \theta \le 180^\circ\): negative work. The force has a component opposite to the motion. It takes energy out of the system. Kinetic friction, air resistance, and the force of the brakes do negative work on a moving object. At exactly \(180^\circ\), \(W = -Fd\).
\(\theta = 90^\circ\): zero work. The force is perpendicular to the motion and moves no energy at all.
Figure 3.2b The sign of the work depends on the angle between the force and the displacement. A force with a component along the motion does positive work and adds energy to the system. A force with a component opposite to the motion, such as kinetic friction, does negative work and removes energy. A force perpendicular to the motion, such as the normal force on a sliding block, does zero work.
The zero-work case is more important than it first looks. The normal force on a block sliding across a table is perpendicular to the motion and does no work. The tension in a string that keeps a ball moving in a circle is perpendicular to the ball’s velocity at every instant and does no work, which is why a ball can move in a circle at constant speed. Gravity does no work on a cart rolling across level ground. In all these cases the force changes the direction of the motion, as the centripetal force of Unit 2 does, but not the speed or the kinetic energy.
Work by several forces
When more than one force acts, compute the work done by each force separately, using the same displacement but each force’s own angle, and add them with their signs. The sum is the net work. You can also find the net force first and compute its work: \(W_{\text{net}} = F_{\text{net}}\,d\cos\theta\) gives the same number when all forces are constant. The two methods are equivalent, and checking one against the other is a good way to catch mistakes.
One more subtlety concerns whose displacement to use. The work done by a force depends on the displacement of the point where the force is applied. A person pushing hard on a fixed wall exerts a large force, but the point of application does not move, so no work is done on the wall (the person’s muscles still use up chemical energy, which is a different matter). Similarly, when a car’s tire grips the road without slipping, the patch of rubber touching the road is momentarily at rest, so the static friction force on that patch does no work, even though it is the force that accelerates the car forward. The car’s kinetic energy comes from the engine’s chemical energy, working through the tires. Problems at this level almost always treat the system as a single point-like object, where the displacement is simply that of the object.
Worked example · work by each force on a sled
A 20 kg sled is pulled 10 m along level snow by a rope with a tension of 50 N directed \(30^\circ\) above the horizontal. Kinetic friction exerts 15 N opposite to the motion. Find the work done by each force and the net work.
Net work. \(+100 - 100 = 0\), which fits the fact that the box’s speed did not change. The person’s positive work is stored in the system as potential energy, a topic for lesson 3.6.
Worked example · an angle larger than 90 degrees
A force of 30 N acts on an object that moves 5.0 m, with the angle between the force and the displacement equal to \(120^\circ\). Find the work.
Interpretation. The force has a component opposing the motion, so it removes 75 J of energy from the system.
Worked example · work by gravity on a ramp
A 5.0 kg block slides 4.0 m down a frictionless \(30^\circ\) ramp. Find the work done by gravity and by the normal force.
Gravity. The component of the weight along the ramp is \(mg\sin 30^\circ = (50)(0.50) = 25\ \text{N}\), in the direction of motion: \(W_g = (25)(4.0) = +100\ \text{J}\). The block drops \(4.0\sin 30^\circ = 2.0\ \text{m}\), and \(mgh = (50)(2.0) = 100\ \text{J}\), the same number.
Normal force. It is perpendicular to the ramp surface and the motion, so \(W_N = 0\).
Exam focus
The angle is between force and displacement. Not between the force and the horizontal or the ramp, unless those happen to be the displacement direction. Draw both vectors with a common starting point and measure.
Each force separately. Compute the work by every force on the free-body diagram, including those that do zero work, and add with signs.
Perpendicular means zero. Normal forces on sliding objects, tension in circular motion, and gravity on level ground do no work. A force that does no work can still change the direction of motion.
Sign is information. Positive work adds energy to the system, negative work removes it. Say which one and why.
Work is a scalar. Never give a direction for it. A negative sign does not mean “backward.”
Practice
A 40 N horizontal force pushes a crate 5.0 m along the floor in the direction of the force. How much work does it do?
Show answer
A person carries a 10 kg bag horizontally for 20 m at constant speed. How much work does the person’s upward force on the bag do?
Show answer
Zero. The upward force (equal to the weight) is perpendicular to the horizontal displacement, so \(\cos 90^\circ = 0\). The person’s muscles may tire, but that is not work done on the bag.
A satellite moves in a circular orbit at constant speed. How much work does gravity do on it over one revolution, and why does gravity not change its kinetic energy?
Show answer
Zero. At every point the gravitational force points toward the center, perpendicular to the satellite’s velocity (the displacement over a short time is along the velocity). Perpendicular force components do no work, so the force changes the direction of the velocity without changing the speed or the kinetic energy.
Lesson 3.3 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2 (work, part 2)
Lesson 3.2 defined work as an energy transfer; lesson 3.1 defined kinetic energy. The work–energy theorem connects them in a single statement: the net work done on an object equals the change in its kinetic energy. It turns the second law into an energy equation, and it lets you find speeds and stopping distances without ever computing an acceleration or a time. When the force varies or the path curves, the method still works, which is exactly where kinematics runs out of steam. This lesson states the theorem, derives it for a constant force, and uses it for the three most common question types: finding a speed, finding a distance and finding a force.
Learning objective · 3.2.A (second part)
Describe the work done on an object or system by a given force or collection of forces.
Required content · EK 3.2.A.4
The work–energy theorem states that the change in an object’s kinetic energy is equal to the sum of the work (net work) being done by all forces exerted on the object: \(\Delta K = \sum W = W_{\text{net}}\).
An external force may change the configuration of a system. The component of the external force parallel to the displacement times the displacement of the point of application of the force gives the change in kinetic energy of the system.
If the system’s center of mass and the point of application of the force move the same distance when a force is exerted on a system, then the system may be modeled as an object, and only the system’s kinetic energy can change.
The energy dissipated by friction is typically equated to the force of friction times the length of the path over which the force is exerted.
Statement and derivation
The work–energy theorem says
\[ W_{\text{net}} = \Delta K = K_f - K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_f^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_i^2. \]
Net work is the sum of the work done by all the forces on the object. If the net work is positive, the object speeds up; if it is negative, the object slows down; if it is zero, the speed does not change.
For a constant net force along a straight line the theorem follows from Newton’s second law and kinematics. With \(F_{\text{net}} = ma\) and \(v_f^2 = v_i^2 + 2ad\), multiply the second equation by \(m/2\):
\[ \tfrac{1}{2}mv_f^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_i^2 = m a d = F_{\text{net}}\,d = W_{\text{net}}. \]
The advantage of the energy form is that it also holds when the force changes along the way, and when the path is curved, as you will see in the next lessons. When the forces are constant the two methods agree, and a quick check of one against the other is an excellent way to catch an error.
Figure 3.3a shows the idea as a bar chart: start with the kinetic energy you had, add the net work, and you end up with the new kinetic energy. A cart whose speed rises from 3.0 m/s to 5.0 m/s has gained \(25 - 9 = 16\ \text{J}\) of kinetic energy, so the net work done on it is 16 J, no matter how that work was delivered.
Figure 3.3a The work–energy theorem as a bar chart. The initial kinetic energy plus the net work equals the final kinetic energy: 9 J + 16 J = 25 J. Net work added to a system increases its kinetic energy by exactly that amount.
A graph that tests the theorem
For an object starting from rest, \(F_{\text{net}}d = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v^2 = \dfrac{2F_{\text{net}}}{m}\,d\). A graph of \(v^2\) against distance is therefore a straight line through the origin with slope \(2F_{\text{net}}/m\) (Figure 3.3b). This is the preferred way to analyze data from a cart pulled by a known force: measure the speed at several distances, plot \(v^2\) against \(d\), and compare the slope with \(2F/m\). A straight line confirms that the net work grows in step with the kinetic energy.
Figure 3.3b For a constant net force on an object starting from rest, Fnetd = ½mv², so v² = (2Fnet/m)d. A graph of v² against d is a straight line through the origin whose slope is 2Fnet/m. This is the same result as the kinematics equation v² = 2ad.
Using the theorem
Whenever you are given forces and distances and asked about speeds, or given speeds and asked about forces or distances, try the work–energy theorem first. The method has four steps.
Choose the object (the system) and the two instants: before and after.
Draw a free-body diagram and list every force that does nonzero work. Forces perpendicular to the motion do none.
Write \(W_{\text{net}} = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_f^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_i^2\), with \(W_{\text{net}}\) built from the work done by each force, signs included.
Solve for the unknown, then check the sign: if the object slows down, \(W_{\text{net}}\) must be negative.
A consequence worth remembering: because \(K\) depends on \(v^2\), the work needed to change an object’s speed depends on where it starts. Taking an object from 10 to 20 m/s takes three times as much work as taking it from 0 to 10 m/s, because \(\tfrac{1}{2}m(20^2 - 10^2) = 150m\) while \(\tfrac{1}{2}m(10^2 - 0) = 50m\).
The theorem also gives the first quantitative treatment of friction. When kinetic friction acts on an object sliding a distance \(d\) along a path, it does work \(-f_k d\) on it. The energy this removes from the object’s kinetic energy does not vanish; it is dissipated, mostly as thermal energy of the surfaces, with some sound. The energy dissipated is typically equated to the friction force times the length of the path over which it acts. Lesson 3.9 develops this idea fully.
Worked example · pulling a crate (finding a speed)
A rope pulls a 15 kg crate 8.0 m across a floor with a 40 N force directed \(25^\circ\) above the horizontal, while friction opposes the motion with 10 N. The crate starts from rest. Find the net work and the final speed.
Work by each force. Rope: \((40)(8.0)\cos 25^\circ = 290\ \text{J}\). Friction: \(-(10)(8.0) = -80\ \text{J}\). Gravity and the normal force: 0 (perpendicular to the motion).
Net work. \(W_{\text{net}} = 290 - 80 = 210\ \text{J}\).
Scaling. Because \(d \propto v_i^2\), the same car at 40 m/s with the same brakes needs 160 m, four times as far.
Worked example · free fall (mass cancels)
A ball of any mass is dropped from rest and falls 5.0 m. Find its speed just before it lands, ignoring air resistance.
Net work. Only gravity acts: \(W_g = mgh = m(10)(5.0) = 50m\).
Theorem. \(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(10)(5.0)} = 10\ \text{m/s}\), independent of the mass, in agreement with the kinematics result \(v^2 = 2ad\).
Worked example · finding a force from a change in speed
A 0.050 kg bullet traveling at 200 m/s hits a wooden block and stops after penetrating 0.10 m. Find the average stopping force.
Interpretation. This is an average force over the penetration. The actual force probably varies with depth, but the theorem needs only the total work, \(\bar{F}\,d\).
Exam focus
Net work, not one force’s work. The theorem uses the sum of the work done by all forces. Do not set \(\Delta K\) equal to the work of the applied force alone when friction or gravity also does work.
Constant speed means zero net work. A force can still do work (for example, a rope lifting a box at constant speed), as long as another force does equal and opposite work.
Signs check the answer. Slowing down needs negative net work; the final kinetic energy cannot be negative.
No direction. The theorem is a scalar equation. It gives the final speed, not its direction. For direction, use forces and kinematics.
Choose it when time is not asked for. Energy skips the time and the acceleration, which is why it is the first thing to try for speeds, distances and average forces.
Practice
A 3.0 kg cart starts from rest and receives 54 J of net work. Find its speed.
Show answer
\(54 = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)v^2\), so \(v^2 = 36\) and \(v = 6.0\ \text{m/s}\).
How much net work is needed to speed a 1000 kg car from 20 m/s to 30 m/s?
Show answer
A 2.0 kg block slides at 5.0 m/s across a rough floor and stops. Kinetic friction is 4.0 N. How far does it slide?
Show answer
\(-f d = 0 - \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(5.0)^2 = -25\ \text{J}\), so \(d = 25/4.0 = 6.3\ \text{m}\).
The work needed to speed a car from rest to 10 m/s is \(W_1\). How does the work needed to speed it from 10 m/s to 20 m/s compare?
Show answer
\(W_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}m(10^2) = 50m\). The second change needs \(\tfrac{1}{2}m(20^2 - 10^2) = 150m = 3W_1\). It takes three times as much work, because \(K\) depends on \(v^2\).
A ball is thrown straight up at 20 m/s. Use the work–energy theorem to find the maximum height, ignoring air resistance.
Show answer
Only gravity does work, and it is negative on the way up: \(-mgh = 0 - \tfrac{1}{2}mv_i^2\), so \(h = \dfrac{v_i^2}{2g} = \dfrac{400}{20} = 20\ \text{m}\).
A box moves at constant velocity across a floor while a person pushes it with a force of 30 N. Is the net work zero? Is the work done by the person zero? Explain.
Show answer
The net work is zero because the kinetic energy does not change. The person’s work is not zero: the 30 N push acts along the motion and does positive work, but friction does an equal negative amount, so the sum is zero.
Lesson 3.4 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.2 (work, part 3)
So far every force has been constant, so work was a simple product. Many real forces are not constant. A spring pulls harder the more it is stretched, a bowstring pushes with a force that grows as the archer draws it back, and the force of a muscle changes through the motion of a limb. The equation \(W = Fd\cos\theta\) no longer applies directly, but the idea behind it does: work is a sum of tiny pieces, each equal to the force times a small displacement. Graphically that sum is an area. This lesson uses areas under force–position graphs to find work, applies the result to the ideal spring, and shows how to combine it with the work–energy theorem to find speeds when the force changes along the way.
Learning objective · 3.2.A (third part)
Describe the work done on an object or system by a given force or collection of forces.
Required content · EK 3.2.A.5 and related
Work is equal to the area under the curve of a graph of the force component parallel to the displacement as a function of position.
Work is a scalar quantity that may be positive, negative, or zero (3.2.A.2): area above the axis is positive work, area below is negative work.
The elastic potential energy stored in an ideal spring is \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\), where \(x\) is the distance the spring has been stretched or compressed from its equilibrium length (3.3.A.4.i), the same area applied in the next lessons.
Work as an area
Suppose a force \(F\) points along the line of motion and you plot it against the position \(x\) along that line. Over a short interval \(\Delta x\), the force is nearly constant, so the work is nearly \(F\,\Delta x\), the area of a thin rectangle on the graph. Add up all the rectangles from the start to the end and the total is the area between the graph and the \(x\)-axis. That gives a rule that always works:
\[ W = \text{area under the } F\text{ versus }x\text{ graph}. \]
For a constant force the graph is a horizontal line and the area is a rectangle of height \(F\) and width \(d\), the familiar \(Fd\). For a force that rises steadily the area is a triangle or a trapezoid. For a curve, count squares or ask for the formula.
The sign matters. Where the force graph lies above the axis (the force points along the positive direction of motion), the area is positive work. Where it lies below the axis (the force opposes the motion), the area counts as negative work, and the net work is the signed sum. Figure 3.4a shows a typical case in which the force rises to 30 N over the first 2.0 m and then stays constant until 5.0 m. The triangle has area \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(30) = 30\ \text{J}\) and the rectangle \((3.0)(30) = 90\ \text{J}\), so the total work is 120 J.
Figure 3.4a Work is the area under a graph of force against position. For a force that rises from 0 to 30 N over the first 2.0 m and then stays at 30 N until 5.0 m, the triangle contributes ½(2.0)(30) = 30 J and the rectangle contributes (3.0)(30) = 90 J, for a total of 120 J.
Figure 3.4b shows a case with both signs. A constant 20 N force acts along the motion for the first 3.0 m, adding 60 J. Then the force reverses to \(-10\ \text{N}\) for the next 2.0 m, removing 20 J. The net work is \(+60 - 20 = +40\ \text{J}\).
Figure 3.4b Areas above the position axis count as positive work and areas below count as negative work. Here 20 N acts along the motion for 3.0 m (+60 J), and then a 10 N force opposes the motion for 2.0 m (−20 J). The net work is +40 J.
Work done by a spring
An ideal spring exerts a force \(F = kx\) that grows in proportion to the stretch (lesson 2.10). To stretch it slowly from its relaxed length to a stretch \(x\), an outside force must match the spring force at every point, so the graph of that force against position is a straight line through the origin (Figure 3.4c). The area under it is a triangle with base \(x\) and height \(kx\):
\[ W = \tfrac{1}{2}(x)(kx) = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2. \]
This is the energy that goes into the spring, and it can be recovered when the spring is released. For a spring with \(k = 200\ \text{N/m}\), stretching from 0 to 0.10 m takes \(\tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.10)^2 = 1.0\ \text{J}\). Because the work depends on \(x^2\), stretching the spring by twice as far takes four times as much work. In particular, stretching from 0.10 m to 0.20 m is not another 1.0 J but \(\tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.20^2 - 0.10^2) = 3.0\ \text{J}\): the later part of the stretch is harder and costs more.
Figure 3.4c The work needed to stretch an ideal spring from rest to a stretch x equals the area of the triangle under the F = kx line: ½(x)(kx) = ½kx². For k = 200 N/m and x = 0.10 m this is ½(0.10)(20) = 1.0 J. The same energy is stored in the spring.
Another way to see the same number: the average force during a steady stretch from 0 to \(x\) is \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx\), halfway between 0 and the final force, and the work is average force times distance. This trick works only for forces that change linearly with position.
Combining graphs with the work–energy theorem
The work found from a graph is the work done by that force. If it is the only force that does work (or you add the work from the other forces), the work–energy theorem gives the change in kinetic energy, and so the speed. This is a big win over kinematics: with a force that changes along the path, the acceleration is not constant, and the equations of Unit 1 cannot be used, but the area under the \(F\)–\(x\) graph and the theorem solve the problem in two lines.
Worked example · a variable force on a cart
A force acting on a 4.0 kg cart on a frictionless track rises in a straight line from 0 to 30 N between \(x = 0\) and \(x = 2.0\) m, then stays at 30 N from 2.0 m to 5.0 m. The cart starts from rest at \(x = 0\). Find the work and the speed at \(x = 5.0\) m.
Note. The acceleration changed during the first 2.0 m, so the kinematics equations could not have been used; the energy method did not need them.
Worked example · forces with both signs
The force graph in Figure 3.4b acts on a 2.0 kg object that starts from rest. Find its speed after 5.0 m.
Net work. \(+60\ \text{J} - 20\ \text{J} = +40\ \text{J}\).
Speed. \(40 = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)v^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{40} = 6.3\ \text{m/s}\). The reversed force slowed the object during the last 2.0 m but did not stop it.
Worked example · stretching a spring
A spring with \(k = 200\ \text{N/m}\) is stretched from rest (relaxed length) to 0.10 m, and then to 0.20 m. Find the work needed for each part.
First 0.10 m. \(W_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.10)^2 = 1.0\ \text{J}\).
0.10 m to 0.20 m. \(W_2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.20)^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.10)^2 = 4.0 - 1.0 = 3.0\ \text{J}\).
Check by average force. The force rises from 20 N to 40 N over 0.10 m, an average of 30 N, and \((30)(0.10) = 3.0\ \text{J}\). ✓
Worked example · reading a graph from an experiment
A student uses a force sensor and a motion sensor to measure the force exerted by a stretched elastic band on a cart. The force decreases linearly from 8.0 N at \(x = 0\) to 0 at \(x = 0.50\ \text{m}\), where the band goes slack. How much work does the band do on the cart?
Area. The graph is a triangle with base 0.50 m and height 8.0 N: \(W = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.50)(8.0) = 2.0\ \text{J}\).
Use. If the cart has a mass of 0.50 kg and starts from rest, with no friction, its speed after the band goes slack is \(v = \sqrt{2(2.0)/0.50} = \sqrt{8.0} = 2.8\ \text{m/s}\).
Exam focus
Area, with sign. Areas above the axis are positive work; areas below are negative. Net work is the signed total.
The force must be along the motion. The graph should show the component of force parallel to the displacement. If a problem gives a force at an angle, take its component first.
Springs: \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\), not \(kx\cdot x\). The factor of one half comes from the force growing from zero. Doubling the stretch quadruples the work.
Units from a graph. The unit of the area is the product of the axis units: newtons times meters is joules. If the horizontal axis is in centimeters, convert to meters first.
Combine with the theorem. Graph area gives \(W_{\text{net}}\) if it is the only force doing work; add the others if not. Then \(W_{\text{net}} = \Delta K\).
Practice
A constant 15 N force acts along the motion for 4.0 m. What is the area under the \(F\)–\(x\) graph, and what does it represent?
Show answer
The area is a rectangle: \((15)(4.0) = 60\ \text{J}\). It is the work done by the force.
A force increases uniformly from 0 to 20 N over a distance of 3.0 m. How much work does it do?
Show answer
The graph is a triangle: \(W = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(20) = 30\ \text{J}\).
How much work is needed to stretch a spring with \(k = 300\ \text{N/m}\) by 0.20 m from its relaxed length?
Show answer
Suppose you carry a suitcase from the ground floor to the third floor of a building. You can take the stairs, the elevator or a long winding ramp. Did gravity do the same amount of work on the suitcase in each case? And if you slide the suitcase across a rough floor from one door to another, does it matter whether you go straight or detour around the furniture? The answers separate the forces of physics into two families, and that separation is what makes the idea of potential energy possible. Forces such as gravity and the spring force are conservative: the energy they take from a system can be recovered later. Forces such as friction and air resistance are nonconservative: the energy they take is dissipated. This lesson defines the two families, gives tests for telling them apart, and shows why only the first kind has a potential energy.
Learning objective · 3.2.A (fourth part)
Describe the work done on an object or system by a given force or collection of forces.
Required content · EK 3.2.A.1.i to 3.2.A.1.v
The work done by a conservative force exerted on a system is path-independent and only depends on the initial and final configurations of that system.
The work done by a conservative force on a system, or the change in the potential energy of the system, will be zero if the system returns to its initial configuration.
Potential energies are associated only with conservative forces.
The work done by a nonconservative force is path-dependent.
Examples of nonconservative forces are friction and air resistance.
Path independence: the test for a conservative force
A force is conservative if the work it does in moving an object from point A to point B is the same for every path between A and B. Gravity is the model example. When an object moves up by a height \(h\) near Earth’s surface, gravity does \(W_g = -mgh\) on it, no matter whether the object goes straight up, climbs a ramp, takes a staircase or zigzags (Figure 3.5a). Only the vertical rise matters, because only the vertical component of the displacement is along the line of the force. Every sideways step contributes zero. The same is true going down, with the opposite sign: \(+mgh\).
Figure 3.5a Gravity is a conservative force: the work it does depends only on the starting and ending points, not on the path. Going from A to B, a 5.0 kg block moves up h = 2.0 m by any route, so gravity does W = −mgh = −100 J on it whether it moves along the ramp, the stairs or the winding path.
An equivalent test: the work done by a conservative force over a round trip, a path that returns to the starting point, is zero. Climb 2.0 m and come back down, and gravity does \(-mgh\) going up and \(+mgh\) coming down, for a net of zero. The system returns to its initial configuration, so the work done by the conservative force and the change in potential energy are both zero. This is the sense of the word “conservative”: whatever energy the force takes out of the motion on the way up it puts back on the way down.
Nonconservative forces: the work depends on the path
Now slide a box across a rough floor from A to B. Kinetic friction always points opposite to the motion, so at every step it does negative work equal to \(-f_k\) times the distance of that step. The total is \(-f_k\) times the length of the path (Figure 3.5b). A direct 4.0 m path with 10 N of friction removes 40 J; a curved 6.0 m path between the same two points removes 60 J. The work depends on the route, not just the endpoints, so friction is nonconservative. A round trip makes this worse, not better: out and back along a 4.0 m path, friction does \(-40 - 40 = -80\ \text{J}\), never zero. Air resistance behaves the same way, because it always opposes the motion.
Figure 3.5b Kinetic friction is nonconservative: the work it does depends on the path. A 10 N kinetic friction force removes 40 J along the 4.0 m direct path but 60 J along a 6.0 m curved path between the same two points. The energy removed is dissipated as thermal energy, not stored.
What happens to the energy that nonconservative forces remove? It does not become stored energy that the system can use again. It is dissipated into the internal motion of the atoms of the surfaces (thermal energy), and a little into sound. The energy is still there, conserved overall, but it is no longer available to the mechanical motion. The amount dissipated by friction is typically equated to the friction force times the length of the path.
Why potential energy needs a conservative force
Potential energy is the energy stored in the configuration of a system, such as the positions of the objects in it or the stretch of a spring. For the stored energy to be meaningful, it must depend only on the current configuration, not on the history of how the system got there. That requirement is met only if the work done by the force depends only on the beginning and end of the path, which is the definition of a conservative force. The change in potential energy of a system is then
\[ \Delta U = -W_{\text{by conservative forces}}. \]
The minus sign says that when the conservative force does positive work (the object “falls” with the force), the stored energy goes down. There is no potential energy for friction or air resistance, because there is no unique value to store: the work they do depends on the route taken, so the “stored energy” would have no single value for a given position. Whenever a nonconservative force acts, the lost mechanical energy shows up as thermal energy of the surfaces instead.
Sorting the forces you know
force
type
why
gravity
conservative
work depends only on the change in height; zero over a round trip
ideal spring force
conservative
work depends only on the initial and final stretch
kinetic friction
nonconservative
work is \(-f_k\) times the path length
air resistance
nonconservative
always opposes motion, so the work grows with path length
normal force, tension (in a fixed string)
not an energy store here
often does zero work because it is perpendicular to the motion
a person’s push (applied force)
external force
can add or remove energy; not tied to a potential energy
Worked example · two routes up
A 5.0 kg block is raised 2.0 m, first by lifting it straight up and then by pushing it up a frictionless ramp 4.0 m long. Find the work done by gravity in each case.
Up the ramp. The weight component along the ramp is \(mg\sin\theta\) with \(\sin\theta = 2.0/4.0 = 0.50\), so it is \(25\ \text{N}\) down the slope, and the displacement is 4.0 m up it: \(W_g = -(25)(4.0) = -100\ \text{J}\).
Conclusion. The two routes give the same answer, as they must for a conservative force. The ramp needs a smaller force, but over a longer distance.
Worked example · any path from ten meters up
A 2.0 kg ball is released from a window 10 m above the ground. In one trial it is dropped straight down; in another it is thrown sideways and follows a curved path to the ground. Compare the work done by gravity.
Both trials. The ball drops 10 m, so \(W_g = +mgh = (2.0)(10)(10) = +200\ \text{J}\) in both cases.
Note. The sideways motion contributes nothing to the work by gravity. The thrown ball has more kinetic energy when it lands, but only because the thrower did additional work at the start.
Worked example · friction on two paths and a round trip
A box slides on a floor with a constant kinetic friction force of 10 N. Find the work done by friction along a 4.0 m direct path, along a 6.0 m curved path, and on a trip of 4.0 m out and 4.0 m back.
Round trip. \(W_f = -(10)(8.0) = -80\ \text{J}\), not zero, even though the box ends where it began. Compare gravity, which would give zero for a round trip.
Worked example · classifying from a statement
A student says, “When I lift a book from the table and put it back, the total work done by gravity is zero, so gravity must be nonconservative.” Evaluate.
Answer. The conclusion is backward. Zero work over a round trip is the signature of a conservative force. For a nonconservative force like friction the round-trip work is not zero.
Exam focus
The two tests. Conservative: same work for every path between two points; zero over a closed loop. Nonconservative: work depends on the path.
Gravity depends on height only. Horizontal motion contributes nothing to the work done by gravity, whatever the path.
Friction scales with path length. Use the length of the path, not the displacement.
Potential energy requires a conservative force. Never write a “potential energy of friction.” The energy goes to thermal energy.
Sign of \(\Delta U\). \(\Delta U = -W_{\text{conservative}}\): when the force does negative work (as gravity does on a rising object), potential energy increases.
Practice
A 3.0 kg object is carried up a staircase to a height of 5.0 m. How much work does gravity do?
Show answer
\(W_g = -mgh = -(3.0)(10)(5.0) = -150\ \text{J}\), independent of the staircase’s shape.
The object is then carried back down to the starting point. What is the net work done by gravity over the complete trip?
Show answer
\(-150\ \text{J} + 150\ \text{J} = 0\). Gravity is conservative, so its work over a round trip is zero.
A block experiences 8.0 N of kinetic friction. Find the work done by friction on a 3.0 m path and on a 5.0 m path between the same two points.
Show answer
\(-(8.0)(3.0) = -24\ \text{J}\) and \(-(8.0)(5.0) = -40\ \text{J}\). The work depends on the path, so friction is nonconservative.
Which of these forces are conservative: spring force, air drag, gravity, kinetic friction?
Show answer
The spring force and gravity are conservative. Air drag and kinetic friction are nonconservative.
A 1.0 kg pendulum bob swings down through a vertical drop of 0.50 m. How much work does gravity do, and how much does the string tension do?
Show answer
Gravity: \(W_g = +mgh = (1.0)(10)(0.50) = +5.0\ \text{J}\) (the path is curved, but only the vertical drop matters). Tension is perpendicular to the motion at every point, so \(W_T = 0\).
Explain why a potential energy can be defined for the spring force but not for friction.
Show answer
The spring force does work that depends only on the initial and final stretch, so the stored energy has a single value for each configuration. The work done by friction depends on the path, so there is no single stored value for a position; the energy it removes is dissipated as thermal energy.
Lesson 3.6 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.3 (potential energy, part 1)
A boulder on a cliff does nothing. But push it over the edge and it will crash into the valley with a lot of kinetic energy. Where did that energy come from? It was stored in the boulder’s position relative to the Earth, and the push merely released it. This stored energy is called potential energy, and the type that comes from gravity is gravitational potential energy. This lesson explains what it means, why it belongs to a system rather than to a single object, how to calculate it near the surface of the Earth and between planets and moons, and why the choice of where it is zero is up to you.
Learning objective · 3.3.A (first part)
Describe the potential energy of a system.
Required content · EK 3.3.A.1 to 3.3.A.5 (gravitational parts)
A system composed of two or more objects has potential energy if the objects within that system only interact with each other through conservative forces.
Potential energy is a scalar quantity associated with the position of objects within a system.
The definition of zero potential energy for a given system is a decision made by the observer considering the situation to simplify or otherwise assist in analysis.
The general form for the gravitational potential energy of a system consisting of two approximately spherical distributions of mass (for example, moons, planets or stars) is \(U_G = -\dfrac{Gm_1m_2}{r}\).
Because the gravitational field near the surface of a planet is nearly constant, the change in gravitational potential energy in a system consisting of an object with mass \(m\) and a planet with gravitational field of magnitude \(g\), when the object is near the surface of the planet, may be approximated by \(\Delta U_g = mg\,\Delta h\).
The total potential energy of a system containing more than two objects is the sum of the potential energy of each pair of objects within the system.
Potential energy belongs to a system
A single object by itself can only have kinetic energy. Potential energy is stored in the relationship between objects that interact through a conservative force: a book and the Earth, two planets, a block and a spring. When we say a book on a shelf “has” potential energy, we mean the system of book plus Earth does, and that energy is associated with their separation. If the book falls, the gravitational force between it and the Earth does positive work, the stored energy decreases, and the book’s kinetic energy increases by the same amount. (The Earth also moves, but its enormous mass makes its share of the kinetic energy negligible.)
This system view has a practical consequence for bookkeeping, and it is a favorite exam topic. If you choose the book alone as the system, gravity is an external force doing work on it, and there is no potential energy in the system. If you choose book plus Earth as the system, gravity is an internal conservative force, its work is accounted for by a change in potential energy, and no external work is done. Both choices give the same physics, and you must not mix them: do not count both the work done by gravity and the change in gravitational potential energy for the same system.
Near the surface: \(\Delta U_g = mg\,\Delta h\)
Near the Earth’s surface, the gravitational force on an object of mass \(m\) is the constant weight \(mg\). To raise the object a height \(\Delta h\) slowly, an outside force \(mg\) must act through the distance \(\Delta h\) and does work \(mg\Delta h\), which is stored in the system. So
\[ \Delta U_g = mg\,\Delta h. \]
Only the change in height matters, not the path taken (the force is conservative; lesson 3.5), and the result is a scalar that may be positive (rising) or negative (falling). A 2.0 kg book lifted 1.0 m gains \(\Delta U_g = (2.0)(10)(1.0) = 20\ \text{J}\); lowered by 1.0 m, it loses 20 J. A 70 kg hiker who climbs 300 m increases the gravitational potential energy of the hiker–Earth system by \((70)(10)(300) = 2.1 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\).
You choose the zero
The equation gives only changes in potential energy. Writing \(U_g = mgh\) requires choosing a reference height \(h = 0\) where \(U_g = 0\), and the choice is yours. Put zero at the floor, the table top or the ceiling: the potential energy of a book on a table takes a different value for each, but the change when the book moves between two positions is always the same (Figure 3.6a). Pick the zero that makes the problem simplest, usually the lowest point reached in the motion, and stick with it throughout. Negative potential energy is perfectly acceptable when the zero is above the object.
Figure 3.6a The zero of potential energy is a choice. For a 2.0 kg book on a table 1.0 m above the floor (and 1.0 m below the ceiling), Ug is +20 J, 0, or −20 J depending on whether the zero is placed at the floor, the table or the ceiling. The change in Ug when the book moves to the floor is −20 J in all three cases, and only changes have physical meaning.
The general form: \(U_G = -Gm_1m_2/r\)
The constant-\(mg\) approximation fails for large changes in height, such as for a satellite or a spacecraft traveling to the Moon, because the force of gravity weakens with distance (lesson 2.7). For two approximately spherical masses \(m_1\) and \(m_2\) whose centers are a distance \(r\) apart, the gravitational potential energy is
\[ U_G = -\frac{Gm_1m_2}{r}. \]
The zero of this expression is placed at infinite separation, where the force and the stored energy both vanish. At any finite separation \(U_G\) is negative, and it becomes less negative (increases) as the objects move apart (Figure 3.6b). The negative sign reflects that you must do positive work against the attraction to pull two masses apart, so the energy of the pair rises toward zero as they separate. Doubling the separation halves the magnitude: \(U_G\) at \(2r\) is half as negative as at \(r\).
Figure 3.6b The gravitational potential energy of two spherical masses is U = −Gm1m2/r, with zero at infinite separation. It is negative and increases toward zero as the separation grows. Near the surface (the dashed tangent line) the curve is almost straight, so the change in potential energy is well approximated by ΔU = mgΔh.
Where does \(mg\Delta h\) come from? Close to the surface, \(r\) changes by only a tiny fraction of the planet’s radius, and \(\Delta U_G \approx \dfrac{GMm}{R^2}\Delta h = mg\Delta h\) with \(g = GM/R^2\). The dashed tangent line in Figure 3.6b is this approximation: it is almost indistinguishable from the curve over small heights. For a 1.0 kg object lifted 100 m, the exact energy is 981 J and the approximation 1000 J (using \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\)), a difference of about 2 percent.
More than two objects
If a system contains three or more objects, every pair has its own potential energy, and the total is the sum of the pair energies (Figure 3.6c). Three equal masses \(m\) at the corners of an equilateral triangle of side \(d\) have three pairs, each with \(U = -Gm^2/d\), so the total is \(-3Gm^2/d\). Count each pair once.
Figure 3.6c The total potential energy of a system of more than two objects is the sum of the potential energy of each pair. For three objects there are three pairs, AB, AC and BC, and each pair is counted once.
Worked example · a climber
A 70 kg climber ascends a mountain trail from 1200 m to 1500 m above sea level. Find the change in the gravitational potential energy of the climber–Earth system, taking the zero at sea level and then at the starting point.
Zero at sea level. \(U_i = (70)(10)(1200) = 8.4 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\) and \(U_f = (70)(10)(1500) = 1.05 \times 10^{6}\ \text{J}\), so \(\Delta U = 2.1 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\).
Zero at the start. \(U_i = 0\), \(U_f = (70)(10)(300) = 2.1 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\), and the same \(\Delta U\).
Conclusion. The two choices give different values of \(U\) but the same \(\Delta U\), which is what matters.
Worked example · a negative \(\Delta U\)
A 0.50 kg ball falls from a shelf 1.8 m above the floor to a table 0.80 m above the floor. Find \(\Delta U_g\) for the ball–Earth system.
Change in height. \(\Delta h = 0.80 - 1.8 = -1.0\ \text{m}\).
Result. \(\Delta U_g = mg\Delta h = (0.50)(10)(-1.0) = -5.0\ \text{J}\). The system’s potential energy decreases by 5.0 J, and 5.0 J of kinetic energy appears.
Worked example · the exact formula for large heights
Find the increase in gravitational potential energy when a 2.0 kg satellite is raised from Earth’s surface to 400 km above it. Compare with \(mg\Delta h\). (\(G = 6.67\times10^{-11}\ \text{N·m}^2/\text{kg}^2\), \(M_E = 5.97\times10^{24}\ \text{kg}\), \(R_E = 6.37\times10^{6}\ \text{m}\).)
Approximation. \(mg\Delta h = (2.0)(10)(4.0\times10^{5}) = 8.0\times10^{6}\ \text{J}\), about 8 percent too large, because \(g\) is weaker at that altitude (8.7 N/kg) than at the surface. The approximation is good for small heights but not here.
Worked example · scaling the general form
The potential energy of two planets is \(-6.0 \times 10^{28}\ \text{J}\). What is it if the separation of their centers is tripled? If the mass of one planet is doubled?
Tripled separation. \(U \propto 1/r\), so \(U = -2.0 \times 10^{28}\ \text{J}\), which is larger (less negative).
A system, not an object. Say “the object–Earth system has potential energy.” Do not both count the work of gravity and the change in \(U_g\) for the same system.
Choose and state the zero. Write “\(h = 0\) at the floor” (or wherever). Only changes in \(U_g\) are physical.
Which equation. Near the surface, use \(\Delta U_g = mg\Delta h\). For planets, moons, or orbits use \(U_G = -Gm_1m_2/r\), and remember it is negative and increases as the objects separate.
Sign of \(\Delta U\). Moving up (against gravity) increases \(U\); moving down decreases it. The sign tells you whether kinetic energy is gained or lost.
Pairs. For three or more objects add up every pair exactly once.
Practice
How much does the gravitational potential energy of a 4.0 kg box increase when it is lifted 1.5 m?
Show answer
\(\Delta U_g = mg\Delta h = (4.0)(10)(1.5) = 60\ \text{J}\).
A 60 kg diver steps off a platform 5.0 m above the water. By how much does the diver–Earth system’s potential energy change by the time the diver reaches the water?
Show answer
\(\Delta U_g = (60)(10)(-5.0) = -3000\ \text{J}\), a decrease of 3.0 kJ.
A student takes the floor as \(h = 0\) and finds a 3.0 kg book on a shelf at 2.0 m has \(U_g = 60\ \text{J}\). Another student takes the table top (0.75 m high) as \(h = 0\). What does the second student get for the book on the shelf, and for the change in \(U_g\) when the book moves to the table?
Show answer
The shelf is 1.25 m above the table: \(U_g = (3.0)(10)(1.25) = 37.5\ \text{J}\). The change on moving to the table is \(-37.5\ \text{J}\) for the second student and \(60 - (3.0)(10)(0.75) = -37.5\ \text{J}\) for the first. The changes agree; the values of \(U\) do not.
Two objects are 4.0 m apart with potential energy \(-8.0\ \text{J}\) (using \(U = -Gm_1m_2/r\)). What is the potential energy if they are moved to 8.0 m apart?
Show answer
\(U \propto 1/r\), so doubling \(r\) halves the magnitude: \(U = -4.0\ \text{J}\). The potential energy increased by 4.0 J.
Why is the gravitational potential energy of two masses negative?
Show answer
The zero is defined at infinite separation. Bringing the masses together from infinity, the attractive force does positive work and the system’s potential energy decreases below zero, so at finite separations it is negative. It takes positive work by an outside force to pull the masses back apart to zero.
Three equal masses \(m\) are at the corners of an equilateral triangle of side \(d\). What is the total gravitational potential energy?
Show answer
There are three pairs, each with \(U = -Gm^2/d\). The total is \(-3Gm^2/d\).
Lesson 3.7 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.3 (potential energy, part 2)
A drawn bow, a compressed pogo-stick spring and a stretched rubber band all store energy because of their shape. Release them, and that stored energy turns into the motion of an arrow, a child and a paper airplane. Gravitational potential energy depends on how far apart two masses are; elastic potential energy depends on how far a spring or other elastic object has been deformed from its relaxed shape. This lesson gives the equation for the energy stored in an ideal spring, shows where it comes from, and uses it with the work–energy ideas of the last lessons to analyze launches, oscillations and hanging masses. The same idea of an object–spring system will return in Unit 7 when we study oscillations.
Learning objective · 3.3.A (second part)
Describe the potential energy of a system.
Required content · EK 3.3.A.4.i and related
The potential energy of common physical systems can be described using the physical properties of that system.
The elastic potential energy of an ideal spring is \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\), where \(x\) is the distance the spring has been stretched or compressed from its equilibrium length.
A system that contains objects that interact via conservative forces or that can change its shape reversibly may have both kinetic and potential energies (3.4.A.2).
The energy stored in a spring
An ideal spring exerts the force \(F = kx\) (Hooke’s law, lesson 2.10), and its force is conservative: the work depends only on the initial and final stretch. In lesson 3.4 you found, from the area under the \(F\)–\(x\) graph, that stretching or compressing the spring slowly from its relaxed length to a distance \(x\) takes work \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\). That work is stored in the spring (really, in the object–spring system) as
\[ U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2. \]
The zero is built in: \(U_s = 0\) at \(x = 0\), the relaxed length. Unlike gravitational potential energy, you do not get to choose the zero, because the spring is relaxed at one natural position. The quantity \(x\) is the stretch or compression from that position, and since it is squared, stretching and compressing by the same amount store the same energy, as the symmetric parabola in Figure 3.7a shows.
Figure 3.7a Elastic potential energy of an ideal spring, Us = ½kx², plotted against displacement from equilibrium. The graph is a parabola that is symmetric about x = 0: stretching and compressing by the same amount stores the same energy. Doubling the stretch from 0.05 m to 0.10 m multiplies the stored energy by four (0.25 J to 1.0 J).
Three consequences are worth memorizing. First, \(U_s\) depends on \(x^2\): double the stretch and the energy quadruples; triple it and the energy grows ninefold. Second, a stiffer spring stores more energy for the same stretch, in proportion to \(k\). Third, \(U_s \ge 0\) always, so the energy of a spring system is smallest at equilibrium. A block released from a stretched spring is pulled toward equilibrium because the system “wants” to lower its potential energy.
Energy flows between forms
In a system of a block and a spring with no friction, the block’s kinetic energy and the spring’s elastic potential energy can change into each other while their sum stays constant. A compressed spring that launches a ball (Figure 3.7b) is the cleanest example: all the energy is elastic when the spring is compressed and the ball is at rest; it becomes kinetic energy as the spring extends and the ball speeds up; and if the ball is shot upward, the kinetic energy later becomes gravitational potential energy as the ball rises and slows. Each bar chart in the figure has a total of 10 J, redistributed among the forms.
Figure 3.7b A spring launching a 0.25 kg ball straight up (k = 500 N/m, compression 0.20 m). The 10 J stored in the compressed spring, ½kx², becomes 10 J of kinetic energy as the ball leaves the spring, and then 10 J of gravitational potential energy at the top, where mgh = 10 J gives h = 4.0 m. (The small gravity effect during the 0.20 m of launch is ignored.)
A vertical spring combines two kinds of potential energy, which you must add: the elastic energy \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\) of the spring and the gravitational energy \(mg\Delta h\) of the mass. Be careful with the stretch \(x\): it is always measured from the relaxed length, not from the position where the mass hangs at rest. A mass released from rest at the relaxed length of a vertical spring falls until \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = mgx\), which gives \(x_{\max} = 2mg/k\), twice the stretch at equilibrium (\(mg/k\)), because it overshoots the equilibrium point as it converts gravitational energy to elastic energy and kinetic energy and back.
Worked example · energy of a stretched spring
A spring with \(k = 500\ \text{N/m}\) is compressed 0.040 m, then 0.080 m. Find the energy stored in each case.
Second. \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}(500)(0.080)^2 = 1.6\ \text{J}\), four times as much, because the compression doubled.
Worked example · a spring launching a block
A 2.0 kg block rests against a spring (\(k = 400\ \text{N/m}\)) compressed 0.10 m on a frictionless horizontal table. The spring is released. Find the block’s speed when it leaves the spring.
System. Block plus spring, no friction, so all the stored energy becomes kinetic energy: \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\).
Solve. \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}(400)(0.10)^2 = 2.0\ \text{J}\), so \(v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(2.0)}{2.0}} = 1.4\ \text{m/s}\). Equivalently \(v = x\sqrt{k/m} = (0.10)\sqrt{200} = 1.4\ \text{m/s}\). Doubling the compression doubles the speed.
Worked example · a spring that shoots a ball upward
A spring with \(k = 500\ \text{N/m}\) is compressed 0.20 m and used to launch a 0.25 kg ball straight up. Ignoring air resistance and the small distance over which the spring pushes, how high does the ball rise above the launch point?
Before. Only elastic energy: \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}(500)(0.20)^2 = 10\ \text{J}\). At the top. Only gravitational energy (\(K = 0\)): \(mg\Delta h\).
Solve. \(10 = (0.25)(10)\Delta h\), so \(\Delta h = 4.0\ \text{m}\). Halving the compression would reduce the energy to one fourth and the height to 1.0 m.
Worked example · a mass hanging from a spring
A 0.50 kg mass is attached to a vertical spring with \(k = 100\ \text{N/m}\), held at the spring’s relaxed length and released from rest. Find the greatest stretch, and the stretch where the mass hangs at rest.
Greatest stretch. At the lowest point the mass is momentarily at rest, so the lost gravitational energy equals the stored elastic energy: \(mgx = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\), \(x = \dfrac{2mg}{k} = 0.10\ \text{m}\). The mass swings between the relaxed length and 0.10 m, centered on the equilibrium point 0.050 m.
Check. Gravitational loss \((5.0)(0.10) = 0.50\ \text{J}\); elastic gain \(\tfrac{1}{2}(100)(0.10)^2 = 0.50\ \text{J}\). ✓
Exam focus
\(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\), with \(x\) from the relaxed length. The stretch is not measured from the position where a hanging mass is at rest.
The zero is not a choice. \(U_s = 0\) at the relaxed length. Compression and stretching both increase \(U_s\).
Quadratic dependence. Double the stretch: four times the energy, two times the launch speed. Double \(k\): double the energy, but \(\sqrt{2}\) times the speed.
Add the forms. For a vertical spring, include both \(U_s\) and \(U_g\) when comparing two positions.
Graph analysis. A graph of \(U_s\) against \(x^2\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(k/2\); a graph of \(v^2\) against \(x^2\) (for a launched cart) has slope \(k/m\).
Practice
How much energy is stored in a spring with \(k = 500\ \text{N/m}\) stretched 0.040 m?
Show answer
A spring is stretched by twice as much. How does the energy stored change?
Show answer
\(U_s \propto x^2\), so the energy is multiplied by \(2^2 = 4\).
A spring is compressed 0.20 m, then released until it is compressed 0.10 m. By what factor did the stored energy change?
Show answer
The energy is proportional to \(x^2\): \((0.10/0.20)^2 = 1/4\). It drops to one quarter of the original value.
A 0.50 kg block is launched across a frictionless table by a spring with \(k = 800\ \text{N/m}\) compressed 0.050 m. Find the launch speed.
Show answer
A 0.20 kg mass is released from rest at the relaxed length of a vertical spring with \(k = 50\ \text{N/m}\). How far does it fall before it stops momentarily?
Show answer
Release a pendulum bob from the side. It swings down, speeds up, passes the bottom, rises on the other side to nearly the same height, and swings back. Throughout the motion the speed and the height change continuously, but their combination does not: whatever the bob loses in height it gains in speed, and vice versa. This is the most powerful idea in the unit, and one of the most powerful in all of physics. Energy is conserved: it can move from one object to another and change from one form to another, but the total in an isolated system stays the same. This lesson develops the idea for mechanical energy (kinetic plus potential), shows how the choice of system decides whether it applies, and teaches the energy bar chart, a representation the exam asks you to draw and read.
Learning objectives · 3.4.A, 3.4.B and 3.4.C
Describe the energies present in a system. Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of mechanical energy principles. Describe how the selection of a system determines whether the energy of that system changes.
Required content · EK 3.4.A.1 to 3.4.C.3
A system composed of only a single object can only have kinetic energy. A system that contains objects that interact via conservative forces or that can change its shape reversibly may have both kinetic and potential energies.
Mechanical energy is the sum of a system’s kinetic and potential energies.
Any change to a type of energy within a system must be balanced by an equivalent change of other types of energies within the system or by a transfer of energy between the system and its surroundings.
A system may be selected so that the total energy of that system is constant. If the total energy of a system changes, that change will be equivalent to the energy transferred into or out of the system.
Energy is conserved in all interactions. If the work done on a selected system is zero and there are no nonconservative interactions within the system, the total mechanical energy of the system is constant. If the work done on a selected system is nonzero, energy is transferred between the system and the environment.
Mechanical energy and the conservation law
The mechanical energy of a system is the sum of its kinetic energy and all of its potential energies:
\[ E_{\text{mech}} = K + U. \]
If no nonconservative force (such as friction) does work inside the system and no outside force does work on it, the mechanical energy is constant:
\[ K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f. \]
Any increase in one form is exactly balanced by a decrease in the other. This law is not independent of Newton’s laws, which gave rise to it, but it frees you from solving for forces and accelerations along a complicated path. All you need is the state of the system at the beginning and at the end.
Choosing the system
Whether energy is conserved depends on what you include in the system. The same falling ball can be described in two equivalent ways (Figure 3.8a). If the system is the ball alone, gravity is an external force that does work on it, \(K_i + W_g = K_f\), and there is no potential energy in the system. If the system is the ball and the Earth, gravity is an internal conservative force; its effect is the potential energy of the pair, there is no external work, and \(K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f\). Both give the same speed, but you must pick one and not count the same effect twice. In general, choose the system so that the forces that do work on it are internal and conservative, if you can: then the mechanical energy of the system is constant.
Figure 3.8a The choice of system determines how gravity is counted. With the ball alone as the system, gravity is an external force that does work on it: Ki + Wg = Kf. With the ball and the Earth as the system, gravity is an internal conservative force with a potential energy, and no external work is done: Ki + Ui = Kf + Uf. Use one description or the other, never both.
When the system is not isolated, energy can enter or leave. If an external force does work \(W_{\text{ext}}\) on the system, its total energy changes by exactly that amount (lesson 3.9 develops this). Conservation of energy is never violated; it is only that the chosen system exchanges energy with its surroundings.
Energy bar charts
An energy bar chart shows, for a chosen system, the amount of each form of energy at a particular instant. You draw one chart for the initial state and one for the final state; if the system is isolated and conservative, the total height of the bars must be the same on both. The bars let you track the energy qualitatively without any numbers, so they are an excellent first step: they tell you which forms are present, which change, and whether any energy has come in or gone out. Figure 3.8b shows a pendulum with a 1.0 kg bob released from \(60^\circ\), so that it starts \(h = L(1 - \cos 60^\circ) = 0.50\ \text{m}\) above its lowest point. At the ends of the swing the bob is momentarily at rest, so all of the energy is gravitational potential (5.0 J); at the lowest point, with the zero of \(U_g\) chosen there, all of the energy is kinetic.
Figure 3.8b A pendulum (1.0 kg, 1.0 m long, released at rest from 60°, so h = 0.50 m). The bob and Earth form the system, and the string tension does no work, so K + Ug is constant. At the ends, K = 0 and Ug = mgh = 5.0 J. At the lowest point, with Ug = 0 chosen there, K = 5.0 J and v = √(2gh) = 3.2 m/s.
The same idea, for a car on a track with no friction, is shown in Figure 3.8c. The height of the track measures the potential energy, and the gap up to the level of the starting height measures the kinetic energy. The car is fastest at the bottom, slowest on top of the hills, and can never rise above its starting height, because that would need negative kinetic energy.
Figure 3.8c A frictionless track. Total mechanical energy is constant (dashed line). At any point the gap between the dashed line and the track is the kinetic energy, K = mg(30 m − h), and the height of the track is the potential energy, Ug = mgh. At the lowest point nearly all the energy is kinetic; at the top of the second hill only the energy corresponding to the unused height is kinetic.
Solving problems with conservation of mechanical energy
Choose the system (usually the object and the Earth, plus any spring) and the two instants.
Decide the zero of potential energy (usually the lowest point).
Check that no nonconservative force does work and no external force does work. The normal force and string tension usually do none.
Write \(K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f\), cancel the mass if possible, and solve.
Notice what does not matter: the shape of the path. A ball sliding down a frictionless steep ramp and one sliding down a gentle ramp of the same height reach the bottom with the same speed, because the normal force does no work and gravity’s work depends only on the height. The two take different times, though; energy gives the speed but not the time.
Worked example · the pendulum
A 1.0 kg pendulum bob is released from rest at a position 0.50 m above its lowest point. Find its speed at the bottom.
System. Bob and Earth; tension does no work. Zero of \(U_g\) at the bottom.
Conservation. \(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(10)(0.50)} = \sqrt{10} = 3.2\ \text{m/s}\). The mass and the length of the string cancel.
Worked example · the roller coaster
A roller-coaster car is at rest at a height of 30 m and rolls down a frictionless track to a point 10 m above the ground. Find its speed there and the fraction of the original potential energy (measured from the ground) that is still potential.
Half the height (3.6 m). \(\tfrac{1}{2}v_i^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}v^2 + g(3.6)\): \(72 = \tfrac{1}{2}v^2 + 36\), so \(v^2 = 72\) and \(v = 8.5\ \text{m/s}\). Half of the kinetic energy is gone at half the height, but the speed is not half: it is \(1/\sqrt{2}\) of the launch speed.
Worked example · the loop-the-loop
A cart rolls down a frictionless track from rest and enters a vertical loop of radius \(r = 8.0\ \text{m}\). From what height above the bottom must it be released to just stay on the track at the top?
At the top (forces). The slowest safe speed has \(F_N = 0\): \(mg = mv^2/r\), so \(v_{\text{top}}^2 = gr\) (lesson 2.12).
Energy. The top is at height \(2r\): \(mgh = mg(2r) + \tfrac{1}{2}m(gr)\), so \(h = 2r + \tfrac{r}{2} = 2.5r = 20\ \text{m}\). The mass cancels.
Bar chart at the top. The gravitational potential energy is four fifths of the total, and the kinetic energy one fifth.
Exam focus
State the system and the energies. A sentence like “system: ball and Earth; initially all \(U_g\), finally all \(K\)” earns points on free-response questions.
Check the conditions. Mechanical energy is constant only if no friction or other nonconservative force does work and no external work is done on the system.
One description only. Either count the work of gravity (object alone) or count \(U_g\) (object and Earth), not both.
Speed, not time. Energy conservation gives speeds at points. Equal heights mean equal speeds on any frictionless path. It does not give the time.
Bar charts add up. The initial and final bars must show the same total height. If they do not, something (work or thermal energy) is missing.
Practice
A ball is dropped from rest from 20 m. Find its speed just before it lands, ignoring air resistance.
Show answer
\(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{2(10)(20)} = 20\ \text{m/s}\).
A ball is thrown straight up at 15 m/s. What maximum height does it reach?
Show answer
\(h = v^2/2g = 225/20 = 11\ \text{m}\) (11.25 m).
Two identical blocks slide from rest down two frictionless ramps of the same height, one steep and one gentle. Compare their speeds at the bottom.
Show answer
They are equal. Both lose \(mgh\) of potential energy and the normal force does no work, so both have \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = mgh\). (The steep one gets there first.)
A 0.50 kg pendulum bob on a 1.5 m string is pulled aside until it is 0.30 m higher than its lowest point and released from rest. Find its speed at the lowest point.
Show answer
\(v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(10)(0.30)} = \sqrt{6.0} = 2.4\ \text{m/s}\), independent of the mass and of the string length.
A student analyzes a falling ball using the system “ball and Earth,” and includes both \(\Delta U_g\) and the work done by gravity. What error was made?
Show answer
Gravity is an internal force of the ball–Earth system, and its effect is already accounted for by the potential energy. Counting the work done by gravity as well counts the same energy transfer twice. For this system there is no external work.
A skier starts from rest at the top of a frictionless hill 30 m high. At a point 10 m above the bottom, what are the kinetic energy and the potential energy, as fractions of the total?
Show answer
Taking zero at the bottom, \(U\) is 10/30 = 1/3 of the total and \(K\) is 2/3. The two always add up to the original \(mg(30)\).
Lesson 3.9 · Unit 3 · CED topic 3.4 (conservation, part 2)
Real motion rarely conserves mechanical energy. A skateboarder coasting up a ramp slows down more than the equations of lesson 3.8 predict; a ball that bounces never quite regains its starting height; and to lift a box, someone has to put energy in. In each case the total energy is still conserved, but the mechanical energy of the system you chose is not, because energy has crossed the boundary of the system or been converted to thermal energy. This lesson extends conservation of energy in two directions: nonconservative forces inside the system, which turn mechanical energy into thermal energy, and external forces that do work on the system and change its total energy. The result is one equation that covers every case in this unit.
Learning objectives · 3.4.B and 3.4.C (continued)
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of energy principles. Describe how the selection of a system determines whether the energy of that system changes.
Required content · EK 3.4.B.2, 3.4.B.4, 3.4.C.1 to 3.4.C.3, 3.2.A.4.iii
Any change to a type of energy within a system must be balanced by an equivalent change of other types of energies within the system or by a transfer of energy between the system and its surroundings.
If the total energy of a system changes, that change will be equivalent to the energy transferred into or out of the system.
Energy is conserved in all interactions. If the work done on a selected system is nonzero, energy is transferred between the system and the environment.
The energy dissipated by friction is typically equated to the force of friction times the length of the path over which the force is exerted.
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 expects students to know that mechanical energy can be dissipated as thermal energy or sound by nonconservative forces. Students analyze the transfer of mechanical energy, although they should be aware that mechanical energy may be dissipated; the transfer of thermal energy by heating and cooling is studied in AP Physics 2.
Nonconservative forces inside the system: thermal energy
When two surfaces slide against each other with friction, the surfaces heat up. The atoms near the interface are jostled into more vigorous random motion. The mechanical energy that seems to “disappear” has actually become thermal energy (with a little sound), and it can no longer be recovered as the motion of the block. The energy dissipated equals the friction force times the length of the path over which it acts:
\[ \Delta E_{\text{th}} = f_k\,d. \]
Here \(d\) is the distance along the path while sliding, not the net displacement. Figure 3.9a shows a 2.0 kg block that slides at 5.0 m/s and stops after 6.25 m on a surface with 4.0 N of kinetic friction. The initial kinetic energy is 25 J, and the thermal energy produced is \((4.0)(6.25) = 25\ \text{J}\): all of the kinetic energy has been converted.
Figure 3.9a A 2.0 kg block slides at 5.0 m/s and stops after 6.25 m on a surface with 4.0 N of kinetic friction. Its initial kinetic energy, 25 J, equals the energy dissipated, ΔEth = fkd = (4.0)(6.25) = 25 J. The energy is not destroyed; it appears as thermal energy of the block and floor.
This lets you write conservation of energy so that it always works, once you include the thermal energy as one of the forms in the system:
\[ K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f + \Delta E_{\text{th}}. \]
Here the system is everything (the block, the Earth, the surface); no outside work is done; and the total is conserved. The thermal energy bar is a new column on the bar chart, always growing and never negative.
External work: energy crossing the boundary
The other source of change is an external force that acts on the system and does work. If you choose the system as the box and the Earth, and a person lifts the box, the person is outside the system, and the work \(W_{\text{ext}}\) done by the person raises the system’s energy (Figure 3.9b). In general,
\[ K_i + U_i + W_{\text{ext}} = K_f + U_f + \Delta E_{\text{th}}. \]
This one equation covers everything in the unit. If \(W_{\text{ext}} = 0\) and \(\Delta E_{\text{th}} = 0\), it reduces to conservation of mechanical energy. If there is friction but no external work, it gives the thermal energy. If an external force does work and there is no friction, it says the energy of the system rises by that amount. The work done by an external force is positive if it adds energy and negative if it removes it. When the system is just a single object, the equation is the work–energy theorem, with the internal forces counted as work instead of potential energy.
Figure 3.9b When an outside force does work on a system, the total energy of the system changes by that amount: Ei + Wext = Ef. Left: lifting a box at constant speed puts the hand’s 60 J into the box–Earth system as potential energy. Right: a 30 N push over 2.0 m puts 60 J into a cart as kinetic energy.
A word about where the energy goes. In the language of this course, we can only say that mechanical energy was dissipated as thermal energy or sound. The details of how thermal energy spreads and is transferred by heating and cooling belong to a later course. For this course the important thing is bookkeeping: when you list the energies at the start and at the end and the totals do not match, the difference is thermal energy (if the nonconservative force is inside the system) or external work (if a force from outside acts).
A strategy for energy problems
Name the system and the two states (initial and final).
List the forms of energy present in each state: \(K\), \(U_g\), \(U_s\), and thermal energy.
Identify any external work (pushes, pulls, lifts) and any nonconservative forces acting within the system (friction, air resistance).
Write the energy equation with every term, then drop the terms that are zero.
Solve, and check that the thermal energy is positive and the final kinetic energy is not negative.
Worked example · ramp, then a rough floor
A 3.0 kg block starts from rest at the top of a frictionless ramp 4.0 m high, slides down, and then moves across a horizontal floor with \(\mu_k = 0.25\). Find its speed at the bottom of the ramp and how far it slides on the floor.
Ramp (no friction). \(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{2(10)(4.0)} = 8.9\ \text{m/s}\), and \(K = mgh = (3.0)(10)(4.0) = 120\ \text{J}\).
Floor. The friction force is \(f_k = \mu_k mg = (0.25)(3.0)(10) = 7.5\ \text{N}\). All of the kinetic energy becomes thermal: \(f_k d = 120\), so \(d = \dfrac{120}{7.5} = 16\ \text{m}\). (Equivalently \(d = h/\mu_k = 4.0/0.25 = 16\ \text{m}\); the mass cancels.)
Bar chart. Start: one tall \(U_g\) bar (120 J). Bottom of ramp: one tall \(K\) bar (120 J). End: one tall \(E_{\text{th}}\) bar (120 J). The total never changes (Figure 3.9c).
Figure 3.9c A 3.0 kg block released from rest at the top of a frictionless 4.0 m ramp. At A all 120 J is gravitational potential energy (mgh). At B it is all kinetic energy (v = 8.9 m/s). On the rough floor kinetic friction converts the kinetic energy into thermal energy, so at C the block has stopped and all 120 J is thermal energy. The total never changes; with μk = 0.25 the block slides 16 m.
Worked example · a rough incline
A 2.0 kg block slides 5.0 m down a \(30^\circ\) incline with \(\mu_k = 0.20\), starting from rest. Find its speed at the bottom.
Heights and forces. The drop is \(5.0\sin 30^\circ = 2.5\ \text{m}\), so \(\Delta U_g = -(2.0)(10)(2.5) = -50\ \text{J}\). The normal force is \(mg\cos 30^\circ = 17.3\ \text{N}\) and \(f_k = (0.20)(17.3) = 3.46\ \text{N}\).
Energy. \(U_i = K_f + \Delta E_{\text{th}}\): \(K_f = 50 - 17.3 = 32.7\ \text{J}\), so \(v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(32.7)}{2.0}} = 5.7\ \text{m/s}\). Without friction the speed would have been \(\sqrt{2(10)(2.5)} = 7.1\ \text{m/s}\).
Worked example · external work
A person lifts a 3.0 kg box 2.0 m at constant speed. A second person pushes a 4.0 kg cart from rest with a constant 30 N horizontal force across 2.0 m of frictionless floor. For each, find the external work and its effect on the energy of the system.
Box and Earth. \(W_{\text{ext}} = Fd = (30)(2.0) = +60\ \text{J}\) (the person pushes up with \(mg = 30\ \text{N}\)). With no change in kinetic energy, \(\Delta U_g = +60\ \text{J}\), equal to \(mg\Delta h = (3.0)(10)(2.0)\). ✓
A 1000 kg car traveling at 20 m/s brakes to a stop. How much thermal energy is produced, and where does it appear?
Energy. \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1000)(20)^2 = 2.0 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\) and \(K_f = 0\). On level ground there is no change in \(U_g\), so \(\Delta E_{\text{th}} = 2.0 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\).
Where. Mostly in the brake pads and discs (the friction there is what slows the wheels), with some in the tires and road. If the speed were doubled, the thermal energy would be four times larger.
Exam focus
The master equation. \(K_i + U_i + W_{\text{ext}} = K_f + U_f + \Delta E_{\text{th}}\). Write all four kinds of term, then cross out those that are zero.
Thermal energy is \(f_k\) times the path length. It is positive and never negative; it appears in the system, so it goes on the final side.
Choose the system on purpose. If the person doing the work is outside the system, the work is external. If the surfaces are inside the system, the friction produces thermal energy inside it. Both statements describe the same physics.
Normal force and tension. They typically do no work, so they do not appear in the energy equation.
Describe in words. “Mechanical energy was dissipated as thermal energy” is the expected statement. Do not say energy was “lost” or “used up.”
Practice
A 1000 kg car moving at 20 m/s brakes to a stop on level ground. How much thermal energy is produced?
Show answer
A 4.0 kg cart on a frictionless floor is pushed from rest with a constant 40 N force across 3.0 m. Find the final speed.
Show answer
\(W_{\text{ext}} = (40)(3.0) = 120\ \text{J}\), so \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)v^2 = 120\) and \(v = \sqrt{60} = 7.7\ \text{m/s}\).
A 5.0 kg block slides from rest down a rough ramp that drops 2.0 m. The friction force is 6.0 N and the ramp is 5.0 m long. Find the speed at the bottom.
Show answer
A hand lifts a 4.0 kg box 1.5 m at constant speed. What is the work done by the hand, and what happens to the energy of the box–Earth system?
Show answer
\(W_{\text{ext}} = mgh = (4.0)(10)(1.5) = 60\ \text{J}\). The kinetic energy does not change, so the system’s gravitational potential energy increases by 60 J.
A ball dropped from 2.0 m bounces back up to only 1.5 m. Where did the missing energy go, and is energy conserved?
Show answer
Energy is conserved. For a 0.50 kg ball, \(mg(2.0 - 1.5) = 2.5\ \text{J}\) of mechanical energy was dissipated, mostly as thermal energy and sound in the ball and floor during the impact (and a little to air resistance).
A block slides to a stop on a rough surface. A student says, “The block’s kinetic energy was lost.” Rewrite the statement correctly.
Show answer
The block’s kinetic energy was converted to thermal energy of the block and the surface (and a little sound) by kinetic friction. The total energy of the block–surface system is unchanged; the kinetic energy is no longer available as organized motion.
Two people carry identical boxes up the same flight of stairs. One walks, the other runs. They do the same work and raise the potential energy of the box–Earth system by the same amount, but the runner finishes sooner and ends up out of breath. What separates the two is not how much energy was transferred but how fast. The rate at which energy is transferred or converted is called power. It determines how big an engine or motor must be to do a job in a given time, why a 100 W lamp is brighter than a 40 W one, and how quickly a car can accelerate. This lesson defines power, shows how to find it from energy, work and force and speed, reads power from graphs, and connects it to the units on your electricity bill.
Learning objective · 3.5.A
Describe the transfer of energy into, out of, or within a system in terms of power.
Required content · EK 3.5.A.1 to 3.5.A.4
Power is the rate at which energy changes with respect to time, either by transfer into or out of a system or by conversion from one type to another within a system.
Average power is the amount of energy being transferred or converted, divided by the time it took for that transfer or conversion to occur: \(P_{\text{avg}} = \Delta E/\Delta t\).
Because work is the change in energy of an object or system due to a force, average power is the total work done, divided by the time during which that work was done: \(P_{\text{avg}} = W/\Delta t\).
The instantaneous power delivered to an object by the component of a constant force parallel to the object’s velocity can be described with the derived equation \(P = F_{\parallel}\,v\).
Power as a rate of energy transfer
Average power is the energy transferred or converted divided by the time it took:
\[ P_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta E}{\Delta t} = \frac{W}{\Delta t}. \]
The unit is the watt (W), equal to one joule per second: \(1\ \text{W} = 1\ \text{J/s}\). A kilowatt is 1000 W. Power is a scalar. It is the same quantity whether the energy is being moved into a system (a motor lifting a load), out of it (brakes absorbing a car’s kinetic energy) or within it (a lamp converting electrical energy to light). A person at rest uses energy at about 100 W; a sustained effort by a cyclist is about 200 W; a car engine on the highway delivers tens of kilowatts.
Since a rate is a slope, power appears on graphs in two ways. On a graph of energy transferred against time, the slope is the power (Figure 3.10a): a steeper line is a more powerful machine. On a graph of power against time, the area under the curve is the energy transferred (Figure 3.10b), because power times time is energy. If the power is not constant, the average power is the total energy divided by the total time.
Figure 3.10a On a graph of energy against time, the slope is the power. Both machines are doing steady work, but the one with the steeper line transfers energy three times as fast (1.5 kW against 0.5 kW), so it delivers 15 kJ in 10 s while the other delivers 5 kJ.Figure 3.10b On a graph of power against time, the area under the curve is the energy transferred. A machine that delivers 200 W for 10 s transfers 2000 J; then 400 W for 5 s transfers another 2000 J. The total is 4000 J, and the average power over the 15 s is 4000/15 = 270 W.
Power from force and velocity
For a constant force acting on an object that moves with velocity \(v\) along the line of the force, the work done in a short time \(\Delta t\) is \(F\,\Delta x = F\,v\,\Delta t\), so the instantaneous power delivered by the force is
\[ P = F_{\parallel}\,v. \]
Only the component of the force parallel to the velocity delivers power (a perpendicular force does no work, and so delivers none). This equation is the practical way to compute the power of a vehicle: a car at constant velocity against a 500 N resistance, at 20 m/s, needs an engine force of 500 N, and so delivers \(P = (500)(20) = 10\,000\ \text{W} = 10\ \text{kW}\) (Figure 3.10c). At 40 m/s the same force would take twice the power, which is one reason high-speed driving consumes so much fuel (and in real life the air resistance force also grows with speed, making it worse).
Figure 3.10c Instantaneous power is the force component along the velocity times the speed, P = Fv. A car moving at constant velocity of 20 m/s against 500 N of resistance has a driving force of 500 N, so the engine delivers P = (500 N)(20 m/s) = 10 kW. At higher speeds the same resistance force requires more power.
The two views fit together. An engine that exerts a constant forward force while the car speeds up delivers a growing power, because \(v\) grows. Its average power over the interval is the total work divided by the time; if \(F\) is constant and the car starts from rest, the average power is half the final instantaneous power, because the speed averages half its final value.
Practical units: the kilowatt-hour
Utility companies sell energy, not power, and measure it in kilowatt-hours (kWh), the energy used by a device with a 1 kW power in one hour: \(1\ \text{kWh} = (1000\ \text{W})(3600\ \text{s}) = 3.6 \times 10^{6}\ \text{J}\). A 100 W bulb left on for 10 hours uses \(1.0\ \text{kWh}\). The kilowatt-hour is a unit of energy, not power, a point that is often confused. Another old unit is the horsepower: \(1\ \text{hp} = 746\ \text{W}\).
Worked example · a hoist
A hoist lifts a 120 kg load through 15 m at constant speed in 12 s. What average power does it deliver?
Work. At constant speed the work equals the gain in gravitational potential energy: \(W = mgh = (120)(10)(15) = 1.8 \times 10^{4}\ \text{J}\).
A car cruises at a constant 20 m/s against 500 N of total resistance. What power does the engine deliver to the wheels?
Force. Constant velocity means the forward force equals the resistance, 500 N.
Power. \(P = Fv = (500)(20) = 1.0 \times 10^{4}\ \text{W} = 10\ \text{kW}\), all of which is converted to thermal energy of the air, tires and road.
Worked example · average and instantaneous power
A 1000 kg car accelerates from rest to 20 m/s in 8.0 s along a level road. Ignoring resistance, find the average power and the instantaneous power at the end.
Instantaneous at 20 m/s. The acceleration is \(20/8.0 = 2.5\ \text{m/s}^2\), so \(F = ma = 2500\ \text{N}\) and \(P = Fv = (2500)(20) = 5.0 \times 10^{4}\ \text{W} = 50\ \text{kW}\), twice the average, as expected for a constant force starting from rest.
Worked example · energy from a power graph
A motor delivers 200 W for 10 s and then 400 W for 5.0 s (Figure 3.10b). Find the total energy and the average power.
Energy. The areas are \((200)(10) = 2000\ \text{J}\) and \((400)(5.0) = 2000\ \text{J}\), so the total is 4000 J.
Average power. \(\dfrac{4000\ \text{J}}{15\ \text{s}} = 270\ \text{W}\), not the simple average of 200 W and 400 W (300 W) because the time at each power differs.
Exam focus
Power is a rate. Two machines doing the same work have the same energy transfer but different powers if they take different times. Work done does not depend on how long it takes; power does.
Which formula. Use \(P = \Delta E/\Delta t\) or \(W/\Delta t\) for averages over an interval; use \(P = Fv\) for the instantaneous power of a force along the velocity.
Graphs. Slope of \(E\)–\(t\) is power. Area under \(P\)–\(t\) is energy.
Units. Watts are joules per second. Kilowatt-hours are energy, equal to \(3.6 \times 10^{6}\ \text{J}\).
Constant velocity. The engine force equals the resistance, so the power is resistance times speed. Doubling the speed against the same resistance doubles the power.
Practice
A 60 W lamp is left on for 2.0 hours. How much energy does it use, in joules?
Show answer
Student A climbs a flight of stairs in 10 s. Student B, with the same mass, climbs it in 20 s. Compare the work done and the average power of the two.
Show answer
The work is the same (\(mgh\) in both cases). Student A’s power is twice that of student B, because the same energy is transferred in half the time.
A device delivers 300 W for 4.0 s, then 100 W for 6.0 s. Find the total energy and the average power.
Show answer
A car’s engine exerts a constant 2000 N force along the road. By what factor does the engine’s power change when the car’s speed doubles from 10 m/s to 20 m/s?
Show answer
\(P = Fv\) with \(F\) fixed: the power doubles, from 20 kW to 40 kW.
Unit 3 practice · 10 problems
Unit 3 practice: Work, Energy, and Power
Ten problems covering the whole unit. For each energy problem, name the
system and the forms of energy present before and after: that sentence
earns points on the exam. Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as the exam does.
Find the kinetic energy of a 1200 kg car at 15 m/s and at 30 m/s. By what factor does it change, and why?
Show answer
\(K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\): \(K_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}(1200)(15)^2 = 1.35\times10^{5}\) J; \(K_2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(1200)(30)^2 = 5.4\times10^{5}\) J. Doubling the speed quadruples \(K\), because speed enters squared.
Objects A and B have the same kinetic energy, and A has four times the mass of B. The ratio of B's speed to A's speed is
A ratio of 4 assumes speed scales inversely with mass, as it would for equal momentum (\(p = mv\)). Kinetic energy depends on \(v^2\), so the speed ratio is the square root of the mass ratio.
Set \(\tfrac{1}{2}m_A v_A^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}m_B v_B^2\) with \(m_A = 4m_B\): \(4v_A^2 = v_B^2\), so \(v_B = 2v_A\). The lighter object is faster by the square root of the mass ratio, not by the mass ratio itself.
1/2 has the right size but the wrong direction: it is A's speed over B's. The lighter object B must be the faster one to carry the same kinetic energy with a quarter of the mass.
16 comes from squaring the mass ratio instead of taking its square root. Since \(K \propto v^2\), a factor of 4 in mass corresponds to a factor of \(\sqrt{4} = 2\) in speed.
A rope pulls a 15 kg crate 8.0 m across a floor with a 40 N force directed 25° above the horizontal, while friction opposes with 10 N. The crate starts from rest. Find the work done by each force, the net work, and the final speed.
Show answer
\(W = Fd\cos\theta\). Rope: \((40)(8.0)\cos 25^\circ = 290\) J. Friction: \(-(10)(8.0) = -80\) J. Gravity and normal force: 0 J (perpendicular to the motion). \(W_{\text{net}} = 290 - 80 = 210\) J. Work–energy theorem: \(W_{\text{net}} = \Delta K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), so \(v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(210)}{15}} = 5.3\) m/s.
A force–position graph for a 4.0 kg cart on a frictionless track rises in a straight line from 0 to 30 N between \(x = 0\) and \(x = 2.0\) m, then stays at 30 N from 2.0 m to 5.0 m. The cart starts from rest at \(x = 0\). Find the work done and the cart's speed at \(x = 5.0\) m.
Show answer
Work is the area under \(F\)–\(x\): triangle \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(30) = 30\) J plus rectangle \((3.0)(30) = 90\) J, total \(W = 120\) J. Then \(W = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(120)}{4.0}} = 7.7\) m/s. The acceleration was changing during the first 2.0 m; energy never needed it.
A spring with \(k = 500\) N/m is compressed 0.20 m and used to launch a 0.25 kg ball straight up. Ignoring air resistance and the small initial compression distance, how high above the launch point does the ball rise? State the energy forms before and after.
Show answer
Before: elastic potential energy only, \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(500)(0.20)^2 = 10\) J. At the top: gravitational potential energy only (\(K = 0\)). \(U_s = mg\,\Delta h \Rightarrow \Delta h = \dfrac{10\ \text{J}}{(0.25)(10)} = 4.0\) m. Halving the compression would cut the height to one quarter.
A 3.0 kg block starts from rest at the top of a frictionless ramp 4.0 m high, slides down, then moves across a horizontal floor with \(\mu_k = 0.25\). Find its speed at the bottom of the ramp and how far it slides on the floor. Describe the energy bar chart at the start, the bottom, and the end.
Show answer
Ramp: \(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(10)(4.0)} = 8.9\) m/s (\(K = 120\) J). Floor: friction \(f_k = \mu_k mg = (0.25)(3.0)(10) = 7.5\) N converts all of \(K\) to thermal energy: \(f_k d = K \Rightarrow d = \dfrac{120}{7.5} = 16\) m (or \(d = h/\mu_k\)). Bars: start, one tall \(U_g\) bar (120 J); bottom, the same height, now all \(K\); end, the same height, now all thermal energy. The total never changes.
A roller-coaster car is at rest at a height of 30 m and rolls down a frictionless track to a point 10 m above the ground. Find its speed there, and say what fraction of the original potential energy (measured from the ground) is still potential.
Show answer
System: car + Earth, no friction, so \(K_i + U_i = K_f + U_f\): \(0 + mg(30) = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 + mg(10)\). Mass cancels: \(v = \sqrt{2g(20)} = \sqrt{2(10)(20)} = 20\) m/s. Potential energy remaining: \(\dfrac{mg(10)}{mg(30)} = \dfrac{1}{3}\); two-thirds has become kinetic.
Two identical blocks are released from rest at the same height on two frictionless ramps, one steep and one shallow, both ending at the same floor. Compare the blocks' speeds at the bottom and their times to reach the bottom. Explain both comparisons in words.
Show answer
Same speed at the bottom: on a frictionless ramp the normal force does no work (it is perpendicular to the motion), so only gravity transfers energy, and gravity's work depends only on the height dropped, \(mgh\). Equal \(mgh\) means equal \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\). Different times: the steep ramp gives a larger acceleration \(g\sin\theta\) along a shorter path, so the block on it arrives first. The shallow ramp's block travels farther at lower average speed. Energy tells you the final speed; only forces and kinematics tell you the time.
(a) A hoist lifts a 120 kg load through 15 m at constant speed in 12 s. What average power does it deliver? (b) A car cruises at a constant 20 m/s against 500 N of total resistance. What power does the engine deliver to the wheels?
Show answer
(a) At constant speed the work equals the gain in \(U_g\): \(P = \dfrac{mgh}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{(120)(10)(15)}{12} = \dfrac{18\,000\ \text{J}}{12\ \text{s}} = 1500\) W = 1.5 kW. (b) Constant velocity means the forward force equals the 500 N resistance, so \(P = Fv = (500)(20) = 1.0\times10^{4}\) W = 10 kW, all of it going to thermal energy of air and tires.
Experimental design. A cart on a frictionless track is launched by a spring compressed a distance \(x\). You have a motion sensor, a meterstick, and a balance. Design an experiment to test whether the cart's kinetic energy is proportional to \(x^2\), and say how you would use a graph to find \(k\).
Show answer
Measure the cart's mass \(m\). Compress the spring by several measured distances \(x\), release, and use the motion sensor to record the cart's speed \(v\) after it leaves the spring; repeat each \(x\) and average. If \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), then \(v^2 = \dfrac{k}{m}x^2\). Plot \(v^2\) (vertical) against \(x^2\) (horizontal): a straight line through the origin confirms the proportionality, and \(k = m \times \text{slope}\). Plotting \(v\) against \(x\) also works (a line with slope \(\sqrt{k/m}\)), but the squared plot tests the \(x^2\) dependence directly.
Why is it harder to stop a loaded freight train than a bicycle moving at the same speed? Why does a slow, heavy object and a fast, light one sometimes hit equally hard? Part of the answer is energy, which you studied in Unit 3. But energy has a limitation: it is a scalar, so it cannot say which way things move, and it is not conserved when objects collide and deform. A second quantity, linear momentum, fills the gap. It is a vector, it points in the direction of motion, and in the absence of outside forces the total momentum of a group of interacting objects never changes, no matter how violent the collision. This lesson defines momentum, shows how it differs from kinetic energy, and introduces the two situations it is best at describing: collisions and explosions.
Learning objective · 4.1.A
Describe the linear momentum of an object or system.
Required content · EK 4.1.A.1 to 4.1.A.3
Linear momentum is defined by the equation \(\vec{p} = m\vec{v}\).
Momentum is a vector quantity and has the same direction as the velocity.
Momentum can be used to analyze collisions and explosions. A collision is a model for an interaction where the forces exerted between the involved objects in the system are much larger than the net external force exerted on those objects during the interaction. As only the initial and final states of a collision are analyzed, the object model may be used to analyze collisions.
An explosion is a model for an interaction in which forces internal to the system move objects within that system apart.
Boundary statement from the CED
Unless otherwise stated, the general term “momentum” will refer specifically to linear momentum.
The definition
The linear momentum of an object of mass \(m\) moving with velocity \(\vec{v}\) is
\[ \vec{p} = m\vec{v}. \]
The SI unit is the kilogram-meter per second, \(\text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) (which is the same as the newton-second, as you will see in the next lesson). Because velocity is a vector, so is momentum: it points in the same direction as the velocity, and it has a magnitude \(p = mv\). Momentum depends on both mass and velocity, and it grows linearly with each. Double the speed and the momentum doubles; double the mass and the momentum doubles (Figure 4.1a). A 1000 kg car moving at 20 m/s has momentum \(2.0 \times 10^{4}\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\); a 0.010 kg bullet at 400 m/s has only 4.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s.
Figure 4.1a Momentum against velocity for objects of different mass. Since p = mv, each graph is a straight line through the origin and its slope is the mass. Doubling the speed doubles the momentum (unlike kinetic energy, which would quadruple).
The graph of \(p\) against \(v\) for a given mass is a straight line through the origin, and the slope is the mass. A larger mass gives a steeper line. This is in contrast with kinetic energy, which depends on \(v^2\) and curves upward.
Momentum is a vector: signs in one dimension
In a straight-line problem you handle the vector nature of momentum by choosing a positive direction and giving every velocity (and so every momentum) a sign. An object moving in the positive direction has positive momentum; one moving in the negative direction has negative momentum. Momenta combine by signed addition. Figure 4.1b shows a 2.0 kg cart moving right at 3.0 m/s (\(p = +6.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\)) and a 1.0 kg cart moving left at 4.0 m/s (\(p = -4.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\)). The total momentum of the two-cart system is the sum of the individual momenta,
\[ p_{\text{total}} = (+6.0) + (-4.0) = +2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}. \]
Notice that the momenta can partly cancel. Kinetic energies, in contrast, are scalars and cannot cancel: the same carts have \(9\ \text{J} + 8\ \text{J} = 17\ \text{J}\) of kinetic energy. This difference is the reason momentum is so useful for collisions: head-on motion of two objects has a small total momentum but a large total energy.
Figure 4.1b Momentum is a vector, so in one dimension it carries a sign. With rightward as positive, the 2.0 kg cart has p = +6.0 kg·m/s and the 1.0 kg cart moving left has p = −4.0 kg·m/s. The total momentum is the signed sum, +2.0 kg·m/s. Kinetic energy, a scalar, would simply add: 9 J + 8 J.
Momentum compared with kinetic energy
Momentum and kinetic energy both increase with mass and speed, but they are different quantities and they can rank objects differently. Compare a 0.045 kg golf ball at 70 m/s with an 80 kg jogger at 3.0 m/s. The jogger has far more momentum (\(240\) against \(3.2\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), about 75 times as much) but only about three times the kinetic energy (\(360\ \text{J}\) against \(110\ \text{J}\)). Momentum is proportional to \(v\) and energy to \(v^2\), so speed counts for more in energy and mass counts for relatively more in momentum. The two quantities are linked by \(K = p^2/2m\) (you will use this in lesson 4.7).
Collisions and explosions
Momentum is the main tool for two kinds of interactions.
A collision is an interaction in which objects exert forces on each other that are much larger than any outside forces during the short time they touch. Two cars crashing, a bat hitting a ball and a ball bouncing off the floor are all collisions. Because the contact forces are so large and last such a short time, outside forces such as friction or gravity have negligible effect during the collision, and the total momentum just before equals the total momentum just after.
An explosion is an interaction in which forces internal to the system push its parts apart: a firecracker, a gun recoiling when it fires, two skaters pushing off from one another, or a spring releasing two carts. The system starts with some total momentum, often zero, and the pieces fly apart in such a way that the total is unchanged.
In both cases you do not need to know the details of the force during the interaction, which may be complicated and unknown. You only need the states before and after, which is why the “object model” (treating each body as a single point with a mass and velocity) is enough. The next four lessons develop the tools: impulse (what changes momentum), systems and the center of mass, the conservation law, and the classification of collisions by what happens to the kinetic energy.
Worked example · comparing momentum and energy
Find the momentum and the kinetic energy of a 0.045 kg golf ball at 70 m/s and of an 80 kg jogger at 3.0 m/s.
Ratios. Jogger to ball: momentum 75 times as large, energy only 3.3 times as large. The two quantities rank the objects the same way here but by very different factors.
Worked example · total momentum with signs
Cart A (4.0 kg) rolls right at 2.0 m/s and cart B (6.0 kg) rolls left at 1.5 m/s. Find the total momentum of the system.
Choose right as positive. \(p_A = (4.0)(+2.0) = +8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) and \(p_B = (6.0)(-1.5) = -9.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Total. \(p_{\text{sys}} = +8.0 - 9.0 = -1.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), that is 1.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s to the left. The kinetic energies, 8.0 J and 6.75 J, simply add to 14.75 J.
Worked example · a change in momentum
A 1000 kg car speeds up from 10 m/s to 25 m/s in a straight line. Find its change in momentum.
Change. \(\Delta p = p_f - p_i = 1.5 \times 10^{4}\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), in the direction of motion. The next lesson shows this change is exactly the impulse the net force delivers.
Worked example · the same momentum, different speeds
A 2.0 kg object and an 8.0 kg object have the same momentum, 16 kg\(\cdot\)m/s. Compare their speeds and their kinetic energies.
Speeds. \(v = p/m\): 8.0 m/s for the 2.0 kg object and 2.0 m/s for the 8.0 kg object. The lighter one is four times as fast.
Energies. \(K = p^2/2m\): \(\dfrac{256}{4.0} = 64\ \text{J}\) and \(\dfrac{256}{16} = 16\ \text{J}\). The lighter object carries four times as much kinetic energy.
Exam focus
Direction matters. Pick a positive direction and carry the signs. An object moving left has negative momentum, and total momentum is the signed sum.
Linear in speed. Doubling speed doubles \(p\) but quadruples \(K\). Do not mix them up in proportional reasoning.
Momentum is not energy. A system can have zero total momentum and a large total kinetic energy (two carts moving apart).
Units. kg\(\cdot\)m/s, equivalently N\(\cdot\)s.
Collision versus explosion. In a collision the objects come together and interact briefly; in an explosion internal forces push parts of the system apart. Both conserve momentum if external forces are negligible.
Practice
Find the momentum of a 0.15 kg baseball moving at 40 m/s.
Show answer
\(p = mv = (0.15)(40) = 6.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), in the direction of motion.
A 3.0 kg cart moves left at 2.0 m/s. With right positive, what is its momentum?
Show answer
Two objects have equal kinetic energy, and one has four times the mass of the other. Which has more momentum, and by what factor?
Show answer
\(p = \sqrt{2mK}\), so the heavier object has \(\sqrt{4} = 2\) times the momentum.
Describe the difference between a collision and an explosion in terms of the direction of the internal forces.
Show answer
In a collision the objects approach, touch and exert large forces on each other for a short time. In an explosion the forces internal to the system push the parts of the system apart. In both, if outside forces are negligible during the interaction, the total momentum is the same before and after.
A baseball bat meets a ball for about a thousandth of a second, but in that instant the ball reverses its motion and leaves at high speed. A golfer follows through; a boxer “rolls with the punch”; a cyclist crumples a helmet instead of a skull. All these everyday ideas rest on one fact: what changes an object’s momentum is not just the force on it, but how long the force acts. The product of force and time is called impulse, and the impulse–momentum theorem says that the impulse delivered to a system equals its change in momentum. It is Newton’s second law rewritten in a form that works for short, violent forces that change all the time, and it is the bridge to conservation of momentum.
Learning objectives · 4.2.A and 4.2.B
Describe the impulse delivered to an object or system. Describe the relationship between the impulse exerted on an object or a system and the change in momentum of the object or system.
Required content · EK 4.2.A.1 to 4.2.B.3
The rate of change of momentum is equal to the net external force exerted on an object or system: \(\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \Delta\vec{p}/\Delta t\).
Impulse is defined as the product of the average force exerted on a system and the time interval during which that force is exerted on the system: \(\vec{J} = \vec{F}_{\text{avg}}\,\Delta t\). Impulse is a vector quantity and has the same direction as the net force exerted on the system.
The impulse delivered to a system by a net external force is equal to the area under the curve of a graph of the net external force exerted on the system as a function of time. The net external force is equal to the slope of a graph of the momentum of the system as a function of time.
Change in momentum is the difference between a system’s final momentum and its initial momentum: \(\Delta\vec{p} = \vec{p}_f - \vec{p}_i\). The impulse–momentum theorem relates the two: \(\vec{J} = \Delta\vec{p}\).
Newton’s second law of motion is a direct result of the impulse–momentum theorem applied to systems with constant mass.
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 does not require students to quantitatively analyze systems in which the mass of the system changes with respect to time.
Impulse
The impulse delivered to a system by a force is the average force multiplied by the time the force acts:
\[ \vec{J} = \vec{F}_{\text{avg}}\,\Delta t. \]
Impulse is a vector in the direction of the net force. Its unit, the newton-second (\(\text{N}\cdot\text{s}\)), is the same as the unit of momentum, \(\text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\): since \(1\ \text{N} = 1\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}^2\), \(1\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s} = 1\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\). That is the first hint that impulse and momentum are closely related.
In real collisions the force is not constant; it climbs from zero, reaches a peak, and drops back to zero, all in a few milliseconds (Figure 4.2a). The correct generalization is that the impulse is the area under the force–time graph. For the triangular pulse of the figure, with a peak of 500 N and a duration of 20 ms, the area is \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.020\ \text{s})(500\ \text{N}) = 5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\). A constant force of 250 N acting for the same 20 ms would deliver the same impulse, so 250 N is the average force of the pulse, the height of the rectangle with equal area. The impulse formula \(F_{\text{avg}}\Delta t\) uses this average.
Figure 4.2a Impulse is the area under a graph of force against time. This triangular pulse of 500 N peak lasting 20 ms has an impulse of ½(0.020 s)(500 N) = 5.0 N·s. A constant force of 250 N acting for the same 20 ms would deliver the same impulse, so 250 N is the average force over the pulse.
When the force changes direction, areas below the axis count as negative impulse, just as negative areas counted as negative work in lesson 3.4. Do not confuse the two graphs: the area under a force–time graph is impulse (a vector), whereas the area under a force–position graph is work (a scalar).
The impulse–momentum theorem
Newton’s second law for a system of constant mass is \(\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = m\vec{a} = m\,\dfrac{\Delta\vec{v}}{\Delta t}\). Because \(m\) is constant, \(m\Delta\vec{v} = \Delta(m\vec{v}) = \Delta\vec{p}\), so
\[ \vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \frac{\Delta\vec{p}}{\Delta t}, \qquad\text{or}\qquad \vec{F}_{\text{net}}\,\Delta t = \Delta\vec{p}. \]
The left side is the impulse of the net force, and the right side is the change in momentum, so the impulse–momentum theorem is
\[ \vec{J} = \Delta\vec{p} = m\vec{v}_f - m\vec{v}_i. \]
It says that the net impulse on a system equals its change in momentum. This version of Newton’s second law is the more general: it states that the net force is the rate of change of momentum, and it handles forces that change moment to moment, for which \(F = ma\) with a constant acceleration does not apply. Here, \(\vec{F}_{\text{net}}\) means the net external force on the system; forces between the parts of the system are internal and cancel in pairs (lesson 4.5).
The theorem has a graphical form too: on a graph of momentum against time, the slope is the net external force (Figure 4.2b). A rising line means a positive net force; a flat line means zero net force, so the momentum is constant; a falling line means a negative net force.
Figure 4.2b The net external force equals the slope of a graph of momentum against time, Fnet = Δp/Δt. This system receives +5.0 N for 4.0 s (momentum rises by 20 kg·m/s), then no net force for 4.0 s (momentum constant), then −3.0 N for 4.0 s (momentum falls by 12 kg·m/s).
Two reminders for using the theorem. First, it is a vector equation: in one dimension, choose a positive direction and give \(v_i\) and \(v_f\) their signs. Second, the force in it is the net force. For a collision, the large contact force is usually the only one that matters, and you can ignore weight; for a long interval, such as a car accelerating for ten seconds, you must include every force that acts.
Worked example · a force that rises and falls
The force on a 0.50 kg ball initially at rest rises in a straight line from 0 to 400 N in 0.010 s, holds at 400 N until \(t = 0.030\) s, then falls in a straight line to 0 at \(t = 0.050\) s. Find the impulse, the final speed and the average force.
Final speed. \(J = m v_f - 0\), so \(v_f = \dfrac{14}{0.50} = 28\ \text{m/s}\).
Average force. \(F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{J}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{14}{0.050} = 280\ \text{N}\), the height of a rectangle 0.050 s wide with the same area.
Worked example · a constant force for several seconds
A net force of 2000 N pushes a 1000 kg car, initially at rest, for 5.0 s. Find the impulse, the change in momentum, and the final speed.
Theorem. \(\Delta p = J = 1.0 \times 10^{4}\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), so \(v_f = \dfrac{1.0 \times 10^{4}}{1000} = 10\ \text{m/s}\).
Check by kinematics. \(a = F/m = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) and \(v = at = 10\ \text{m/s}\). ✓
Worked example · from the momentum graph to the force
Using Figure 4.2b, find the net force on the system during each of the three time intervals.
0 to 4.0 s. The momentum rises from 0 to 20 kg\(\cdot\)m/s: \(F = \dfrac{20}{4.0} = +5.0\ \text{N}\).
4.0 to 8.0 s. The momentum is constant: \(F = 0\).
8.0 to 12 s. The momentum falls from 20 to 8.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s: \(F = \dfrac{8.0 - 20}{4.0} = -3.0\ \text{N}\).
Impulses. \(+20\), \(0\), and \(-12\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\), which add to the total change in momentum, \(+8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Worked example · the force from a known impulse
A 0.14 kg ball moving at 30 m/s is caught and brought to rest by a glove, in 0.020 s. Find the average force on the ball.
Choose the ball’s direction as positive. \(\Delta p = 0 - (0.14)(30) = -4.2\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Force. \(F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{\Delta p}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{-4.2}{0.020} = -210\ \text{N}\), directed opposite to the ball’s motion. The ball’s weight, 1.4 N, is negligible by comparison.
Exam focus
Impulse equals area under \(F\)–\(t\). Net force is the slope of \(p\)–\(t\). Do not confuse these with work (area under \(F\)–\(x\)).
Net external force. The theorem uses the net external force on the system. Internal forces do not change the system’s momentum.
Signs. Impulse is a vector. Reversing direction means \(\Delta p = m(v_f - v_i)\) with \(v_i\) and \(v_f\) of opposite sign, so the magnitudes add.
It is Newton’s second law. If a question says the force is variable, use impulse–momentum, not \(F = ma\) with constant \(a\).
Units. N\(\cdot\)s and kg\(\cdot\)m/s are the same unit.
Practice
A constant 20 N force acts on an object for 3.0 s. What is the impulse?
Show answer
\(J = F\Delta t = (20)(3.0) = 60\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\), in the direction of the force.
A 2.0 kg object at rest receives an impulse of 12 N\(\cdot\)s. What is its final speed?
Show answer
An egg dropped on a tile floor breaks; the same egg dropped on a pillow does not. A person who lands from a jump with stiff legs risks injury, but one who bends the knees walks away. Cars have crumple zones, boxers lean away from punches and catchers pull their gloves back as the ball arrives. In every case, the same change in momentum is being delivered, and the whole art of safety, and of sports, is to adjust the time over which it happens. The impulse–momentum theorem of lesson 4.2 gives the tool: \(F_{\text{avg}}\,\Delta t = \Delta p\). This lesson applies it to three families of problems: bounces, where the momentum change is larger than it looks; stopping, where time is your friend; and mixed problems where you must decide which forces to include.
Learning objective · 4.2.A and 4.2.B (applied)
Describe the impulse delivered to an object or system, and the relationship between the impulse exerted on an object or system and the change in momentum of that object or system.
Required content · used in this lesson
Impulse is the product of the average force and the time interval during which it acts, \(\vec{J} = \vec{F}_{\text{avg}}\Delta t\); it has the direction of the net force.
The impulse–momentum theorem: \(\vec{J} = \Delta\vec{p} = \vec{p}_f - \vec{p}_i\).
A collision is a model for an interaction where the forces between the objects are much larger than the net external force during the interaction (4.1.A.3.i).
Bounces: the change in momentum is bigger than you think
When an object bounces off a wall or floor, its velocity reverses. The momentum before and after has opposite signs, so the change in momentum is the sum of the magnitudes, not the difference. A 0.50 kg ball that hits a wall at 10 m/s and rebounds at 8.0 m/s has (taking the direction toward the wall as positive) \(p_i = +5.0\) and \(p_f = -4.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), so \(\Delta p = -4.0 - 5.0 = -9.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) (Figure 4.3a). The wall delivers an impulse of 9.0 N\(\cdot\)s away from the wall. The classic error is subtracting speeds, \(10 - 8.0\), and getting a tiny number. Always draw the momentum vectors and subtract \(\vec{p}_i\) from \(\vec{p}_f\).
Figure 4.3a A ball that bounces reverses its direction, so its change in momentum is larger than either momentum alone. With toward the wall as positive, pi = (0.50)(+10) = +5.0 kg·m/s and pf = (0.50)(−8.0) = −4.0 kg·m/s, so Δp = pf − pi = −9.0 kg·m/s. The wall delivers an impulse of 9.0 N·s directed away from the wall.
The consequence is that a bounce gives a larger impulse than a stop. A 0.10 kg lump of clay thrown at 6.0 m/s onto a wall sticks; a 0.10 kg rubber ball at the same speed bounces back at 6.0 m/s. The clay has \(\Delta p = 0 - 0.60 = -0.60\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) and the ball has \(\Delta p = -0.60 - 0.60 = -1.2\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), twice as much. If the contact times are equal, the wall pushes twice as hard on the bouncing ball. This is why a pelting stream of rubber balls would push a door harder than a stream of clay balls with the same speed and mass.
By Newton’s third law, the ball pushes on the wall with an equal and opposite force, so the wall receives an impulse of the same size but opposite direction. Ignore weight during such a short collision unless it is comparable to the contact force.
Stopping: stretch out the time
The impulse needed to stop a moving object is fixed by its momentum: \(\Delta p = -mv\). Since \(F_{\text{avg}} = \Delta p/\Delta t\), the force depends on the stopping time, inversely. Figure 4.3b shows the case of a 60 kg crash-test dummy stopping from 15 m/s: the required impulse is 900 N\(\cdot\)s. If a rigid dashboard stops it in 0.050 s, the average force is 18 000 N; with an air bag that stretches the stop to 0.20 s, the force falls to 4500 N, a factor of four. The impulse is identical in both cases, but the force, which does the damage, is not.
Figure 4.3b For a fixed change in momentum, the average force is inversely proportional to the stopping time: Favg = Δp/Δt. A 60 kg crash-test dummy stopping from 15 m/s must lose 900 kg·m/s of momentum. Stopping in 0.050 s against a hard surface takes 18 kN; stopping in 0.20 s with an air bag takes only 4.5 kN.
Everyday examples all follow this pattern. An egg stops in a few milliseconds on a floor but takes much longer on a pillow. A gymnast lands with bent knees to lengthen the time. A crumple zone in a car collapses progressively so the passengers’ deceleration takes longer. A catcher moves the mitt backward while catching a fast ball. Conversely, when you want a large change in momentum (a strike), you make the contact time long by following through, because a larger impulse sends the ball faster. A karate chop does the opposite: a short, hard contact gives a large force.
Which forces count?
The theorem uses the net external force. For a very short contact, the collision force is much larger than the weight or friction, and you can ignore them. For example, a 0.25 kg ball hitting the floor at 8.0 m/s with a contact force of about 230 N has a weight of only 2.5 N, 1% of the contact force. For a long interval, such as a rocket coasting while gravity acts, you must keep every force. A good habit is to compare the contact force with the weight in the result, and keep the weight if it is more than a few percent.
Worked example · a ball bouncing on the floor
A 0.25 kg ball hits the floor moving downward at 8.0 m/s and rebounds upward at 6.0 m/s. Contact lasts 0.015 s. Find the impulse on the ball and the average force from the floor.
Choose up as positive. \(v_i = -8.0\ \text{m/s}\), \(v_f = +6.0\ \text{m/s}\).
Average force. \(F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{J}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{3.5}{0.015} = 2.3 \times 10^{2}\ \text{N}\) upward. The weight, \(mg = 2.5\ \text{N}\), is about 1% of this, so ignoring it is reasonable. The common error is to write \(8.0 - 6.0\); because the velocity reversed, the change is the sum of the speeds.
Worked example · landing from a jump
A 70 kg person lands from a jump with a speed of 5.0 m/s and stops. Compare the average force on the legs if the stopping time is 0.020 s (stiff legs) and 0.30 s (bent knees). Include the person’s weight in the net force.
Impulse needed. \(\Delta p = 0 - (70)(5.0) = -350\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\) (upward net impulse of 350 N\(\cdot\)s).
Stiff. \(F_{\text{net}} = 350/0.020 = 1.75 \times 10^{4}\ \text{N}\). The ground force is this plus the weight (700 N): about 1.8 \(\times 10^{4}\) N, roughly 25 times the person’s weight.
Bent knees. \(F_{\text{net}} = 350/0.30 = 1170\ \text{N}\); the ground force is about 1870 N, under three times the weight. Lengthening the stop by a factor of 15 reduced the force by nearly a factor of 10; the weight, no longer negligible, accounts for the difference.
Worked example · clay or rubber?
A 0.10 kg clay ball and a 0.10 kg rubber ball strike a wall at 6.0 m/s. The clay sticks; the rubber ball rebounds at 6.0 m/s. Both contacts last 0.010 s. Compare the average forces.
Rubber. \(\Delta p = -0.60 - 0.60 = -1.2\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\); \(F_{\text{avg}} = 120\ \text{N}\), twice as large.
Worked example · pulling the hand back
A 0.15 kg ball at 30 m/s is caught. If the catcher’s hand stops it in 0.010 s the average force is large; if the hand moves back so that it stops in 0.050 s, what happens to the force and the impulse?
Impulse. \(\Delta p = -(0.15)(30) = -4.5\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\) in both cases.
Force. \(F = 4.5/0.010 = 450\ \text{N}\) with the short stop and \(4.5/0.050 = 90\ \text{N}\) with the long stop. The impulse is unchanged; the force is five times smaller.
Exam focus
Reversal doubles the trouble. When an object bounces, add the magnitudes of the momenta to find \(\Delta p\). A bounce gives a larger impulse than sticking.
Same \(\Delta p\), different time. Questions about safety devices want: the change in momentum is the same, the time is longer, so the force is smaller (\(F = \Delta p/\Delta t\)).
Ignore weight when you can justify it. In a very short collision the contact force is far larger than the weight. State that assumption.
Direction. The force on the ball and on the wall are equal and opposite (third law), and so are the impulses.
Graph reading. If two collisions have the same area under \(F\)–\(t\) but different widths, the narrower one has the higher peak force.
Practice
A 0.50 kg ball moving at 10 m/s hits a wall and rebounds at 8.0 m/s. What is the magnitude of the impulse? If the contact lasts 0.020 s, what is the average force?
Show answer
A 60 kg passenger moving at 15 m/s stops in 0.20 s against an air bag. What is the average force?
Show answer
\(F = \Delta p/\Delta t = 900/0.20 = 4500\ \text{N}\).
An egg dropped onto a hard floor breaks, but the same egg dropped from the same height onto a pillow does not. In a short paragraph explain using impulse and momentum.
Show answer
Both eggs arrive with the same momentum and end at rest, so the impulse each receives, \(\Delta p\), is the same. Impulse equals \(F_{\text{avg}}\Delta t\). The pillow deforms and makes the stopping time much longer, so the average force on the egg is much smaller. On the hard floor the stop is very short, so the force is large enough to break the shell.
A 0.20 kg ball moving at 5.0 m/s is hit by a bat and returns along the same line at 20 m/s. The contact time is 0.0010 s. Find the average force.
Show answer
Take the incoming direction as positive: \(\Delta p = (0.20)(-20 - 5.0) = -5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\). \(F_{\text{avg}} = 5.0/0.0010 = 5000\ \text{N}\) in the direction the ball leaves.
A rubber ball and a clay ball of equal mass strike a wall at the same speed; the clay sticks and the rubber ball bounces back at nearly the same speed. Which receives the larger impulse, and why?
Show answer
The rubber ball. Its momentum reverses, so \(\Delta p\) is about \(2mv\), while the clay only goes from \(mv\) to 0, a change of \(mv\). The wall delivers about twice the impulse to the rubber ball.
A boxer “rolls with the punch,” moving the head backward as the glove hits. Explain how this reduces the force on the head.
Show answer
Moving with the punch lengthens the time during which the glove stops relative to the head. The change in momentum of the glove (the impulse) is about the same, so a longer contact time means a smaller average force, \(F = \Delta p/\Delta t\).
When two carts collide, each one’s velocity changes abruptly and in complicated ways. Yet there is one point, the center of mass of the pair, whose motion does not change at all unless something from outside the pair pushes on them. Treating a collection of objects as one system with a single center-of-mass velocity is a powerful simplification: it replaces a messy interaction with the simplest possible motion. This lesson shows how to choose a system, how to find the total momentum of a system and the velocity of its center of mass, and why internal interactions can never change either one.
Learning objective · 4.3.A (first part)
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of linear momentum.
Required content · EK 4.3.A.1 and 4.3.A.2
A collection of objects with individual momenta can be described as one system with one center-of-mass velocity.
For a collection of objects, the velocity of a system’s center of mass can be calculated using the equation \(\vec{v}_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{\sum m_i\vec{v}_i}{\sum m_i}\).
The velocity of a system’s center of mass is constant in the absence of a net external force.
The total momentum of a system is the sum of the momenta of the system’s constituent parts.
Choosing a system
A system is whatever collection of objects you decide to analyze. Everything else is the surroundings. The choice is yours, and it decides which forces are internal (between objects inside the system) and which are external (exerted by something outside). Two carts connected by a spring, a skater and a ball, a car and the road: any of these can be a system, but what counts as internal changes with the choice. You already did this in Unit 2 when you treated connected blocks as one object, and in Unit 3 when you chose “ball plus Earth.” For momentum, the rule is simple: choose the system so that the large forces during the interaction are internal, and the external forces are small or cancel.
Total momentum of a system
The total momentum of a system is the vector sum of the momenta of its parts:
\[ \vec{p}_{\text{sys}} = \vec{p}_1 + \vec{p}_2 + \cdots = m_1\vec{v}_1 + m_2\vec{v}_2 + \cdots. \]
In one dimension, this is a signed sum with a chosen positive direction. Be careful that all velocities are measured in the same frame. The total momentum is a property of the whole system; it cannot be found by adding speeds or magnitudes.
The center of mass and its velocity
The center of mass of a system is the mass-weighted average of the positions of its parts. For particles at positions \(x_i\) on a line,
\[ x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1x_1 + m_2x_2 + \cdots}{m_1 + m_2 + \cdots}. \]
It lies closer to the heavier objects. A 2.0 kg cart at \(x = 1.0\ \text{m}\) and a 1.0 kg cart at \(x = 4.0\ \text{m}\) have a center of mass at \((2.0)(1.0) + (1.0)(4.0)\) divided by 3.0, which is \(x_{\text{cm}} = 2.0\ \text{m}\) (the diamond in Figure 4.4a). If the objects move, the center of mass moves, and its velocity is the mass-weighted average of their velocities:
\[ \vec{v}_{\text{cm}} = \frac{\sum m_i\vec{v}_i}{\sum m_i} = \frac{\vec{p}_{\text{sys}}}{M}, \]
where \(M\) is the total mass. Equivalently, the system’s total momentum equals the total mass times the velocity of its center of mass: \(\vec{p}_{\text{sys}} = M\vec{v}_{\text{cm}}\), just as if all the mass were concentrated at that one point. For the carts, \(v_{\text{cm}} = (2.0 \cdot 3.0 + 1.0 \cdot 0)/3.0 = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\).
Figure 4.4a The velocity of the center of mass of a system. vcm = (m1v1 + m2v2)/(m1 + m2) = (6.0 + 0)/3.0 = 2.0 m/s. With no net external force, vcm is the same before the collision and after it; here the stuck-together carts move at exactly that speed.
(On the exam, systems of up to five particles are used, with the objects arranged in one dimension or at the corners of simple figures; you are not asked to locate the center of mass of a continuous body.)
Why the center of mass is special
Newton’s second law for a system says that the acceleration of its center of mass is the net external force divided by the total mass, \(\vec{a}_{\text{cm}} = \vec{F}_{\text{net,ext}}/M\) (lesson 2.5). Interactions between the parts, such as a collision or the spring in an explosion, are internal forces; by Newton’s third law they come in equal-and-opposite pairs and cancel in the sum, so they cannot change the center-of-mass motion. Hence:
If the net external force on the system is zero, the velocity of the center of mass is constant, and the total momentum is constant.
A collision or an explosion changes the velocities of the individual objects but leaves \(\vec{v}_{\text{cm}}\) unchanged. In the example of Figure 4.4a, the center of mass moves at 2.0 m/s before the carts stick together, and the combined 3.0 kg cart moves at 2.0 m/s afterward.
If the system starts at rest and no outside force acts, its center of mass stays at rest, even if the pieces fly apart. Two ice skaters who push off each other move in opposite directions, but their common center of mass does not move.
This is the idea behind the conservation of momentum of the next lesson, and it also makes a good consistency check: after a collision, the center-of-mass velocity computed from the new velocities must equal the one computed before.
Worked example · velocity of the center of mass
A 2.0 kg cart moving right at 3.0 m/s and a 1.0 kg cart moving left at 4.0 m/s form a system. Find the total momentum and the velocity of the center of mass.
Total momentum. \(p = (2.0)(+3.0) + (1.0)(-4.0) = +2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Center of mass. \(v_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{2.0}{3.0} = +0.67\ \text{m/s}\), to the right. Although one cart moves faster than this and the other opposite to it, the center of mass moves slowly to the right.
Worked example · a three-cart system
Three carts of mass 1.0 kg, 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg move at \(+4.0\ \text{m/s}\), \(-1.0\ \text{m/s}\) and \(+0.50\ \text{m/s}\). Find \(v_{\text{cm}}\).
Momenta. \(+4.0\), \(-2.0\) and \(+1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\); the total is \(+3.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Worked example · an explosion does not move the center of mass
A 5.0 kg object at rest splits into two parts of 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg by an internal explosion. The 2.0 kg part moves left at 6.0 m/s. Find the velocity of the 3.0 kg part and the center-of-mass velocity afterward.
Momentum. The total was zero and must remain zero: \(0 = (2.0)(-6.0) + (3.0)v\), so \(v = +4.0\ \text{m/s}\).
Center of mass. \(v_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{(2.0)(-6.0) + (3.0)(4.0)}{5.0} = 0\), unchanged from before the explosion.
Worked example · center of mass position
Masses 1.0 kg, 2.0 kg and 3.0 kg sit at \(x = 0\), \(x = 3.0\ \text{m}\) and \(x = 6.0\ \text{m}\). Find the center of mass.
Solve. \(x_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{(1.0)(0) + (2.0)(3.0) + (3.0)(6.0)}{6.0} = \dfrac{24}{6.0} = 4.0\ \text{m}\), closer to the 3.0 kg mass.
Exam focus
Choose the system so internal forces do the interacting. Collision forces between two carts are internal if both carts are in the system.
\(v_{\text{cm}} = p_{\text{total}}/M\). It is a weighted average, so it lies between the objects’ velocities (when they all point the same way) and is pulled toward the heavier ones.
Internal interactions cannot change it. Collisions and explosions leave \(v_{\text{cm}}\) and the total momentum unchanged if no external force acts.
Frames. If the observer moves, all velocities change by the same amount, and so does \(v_{\text{cm}}\), but the center of mass is at rest in the frame in which the total momentum is zero.
Signs. Total momentum is a signed sum. Do not average speeds.
Practice
A 3.0 kg block moving at 4.0 m/s and a 1.0 kg block moving at 2.0 m/s, both to the right, form a system. Find \(v_{\text{cm}}\).
Show answer
\(v_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{(3.0)(4.0) + (1.0)(2.0)}{4.0} = \dfrac{14}{4.0} = 3.5\ \text{m/s}\), to the right.
Two skaters of masses 60 kg and 90 kg are at rest on frictionless ice and push off from each other. What is the velocity of their center of mass afterward?
Show answer
Zero. The total momentum was zero and the push is an internal force, so it stays zero, and \(v_{\text{cm}} = 0\).
A 4.0 kg cart moves right at 3.0 m/s and a 2.0 kg cart moves left at 3.0 m/s. Find the total momentum and \(v_{\text{cm}}\).
Show answer
Two objects collide and stick together. The center of mass velocity before the collision is 2.5 m/s to the right and no external force acts. What is the velocity of the combined object?
Show answer
2.5 m/s to the right. After sticking, the combined object is the center of mass of the system, and \(v_{\text{cm}}\) did not change.
A student says, “The two carts exploded apart, so the center of mass must have moved.” Evaluate.
Show answer
Incorrect. The spring or explosive forces are internal to the two-cart system and cancel in pairs, so the velocity of the center of mass is unchanged. If the carts started at rest, the center of mass stays at rest while the pieces move in opposite directions.
An astronaut floating in space throws a tool and drifts the other way. A rifle kicks back when it fires. Two skaters push apart. A railroad car coupling latches onto another and the pair moves off together at a new speed. None of these can be analyzed easily with forces, because the forces change from instant to instant in ways nobody knows. But all of them follow one simple rule: the total momentum of the system just after equals the total just before. This is the law of conservation of linear momentum, one of the most reliable laws in physics, and a direct consequence of Newton’s third law. This lesson states it, explains why it works, shows how the choice of system determines whether it applies, and gives the method for using it in problems.
Learning objectives · 4.3.A (continued) and 4.3.B
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of linear momentum. Describe how the selection of a system determines whether the momentum of that system changes.
Required content · EK 4.3.A.3 to 4.3.B.3
In the absence of net external forces, any change to the momentum of an object within a system must be balanced by an equivalent and opposite change of momentum elsewhere within the system. Any change to the momentum of a system is due to a transfer of momentum between the system and its surroundings.
The impulse exerted by one object on a second object is equal and opposite to the impulse exerted by the second object on the first. This is a direct result of Newton’s third law.
A system may be selected so that the total momentum of that system is constant. If the total momentum of a system changes, that change will be equivalent to the impulse exerted on the system: \(\Delta\vec{p}_{\text{sys}} = \vec{F}_{\text{net,ext}}\Delta t\).
Momentum is conserved in all interactions. If the net external force on the selected system is zero, the total momentum of the system is constant. If the net external force on the selected system is nonzero, momentum is transferred between the system and the environment.
Correct application of conservation of momentum can be used to determine the velocity of a system immediately before and immediately after collisions or explosions.
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 includes a quantitative and qualitative treatment of conservation of momentum in one dimension and a semiquantitative treatment of conservation of momentum in two dimensions. Exam questions involving solution of simultaneous equations are not included, but the exam may include questions that assess whether students can set up the equations properly and reason about how changing a given mass, speed, or angle would affect other quantities.
Why momentum is conserved
Two objects A and B collide. During the contact, A pushes on B with a force \(\vec{F}_{AB}\) and B pushes on A with \(\vec{F}_{BA}\). Newton’s third law says these forces are equal and opposite at every instant, and they last the same length of time. So the impulses are equal and opposite, too (Figure 4.5a): whatever impulse A delivers to B, B delivers the negative of it to A. By the impulse–momentum theorem, each object’s change in momentum equals the impulse it receives, so
\[ \Delta\vec{p}_B = \vec{J}_{AB} = -\vec{J}_{BA} = -\Delta\vec{p}_A. \]
Momentum that A loses, B gains, so the total change is zero:
\[ \Delta\vec{p}_A + \Delta\vec{p}_B = 0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \vec{p}_{A,i} + \vec{p}_{B,i} = \vec{p}_{A,f} + \vec{p}_{B,f}. \]
Figure 4.5a During a collision, the forces the two objects exert on each other are equal and opposite at every instant (Newton’s third law) and last for the same time. The impulses, the areas under the two curves, are therefore equal and opposite: +5.0 N·s on B and −5.0 N·s on A, so the total momentum of the pair does not change.
This argument works for any internal interaction: collisions, explosions, recoils, or pushes. It does not depend on the size or shape of the force. Because each pair of internal forces cancels, the total momentum of a system can only be changed by external forces. In terms of impulse, \(\Delta\vec{p}_{\text{sys}} = \vec{J}_{\text{ext}} = \vec{F}_{\text{net,ext}}\Delta t\), which is the impulse–momentum theorem of lesson 4.2 applied to the whole system.
Conserved or not? Choose the system
Momentum is always conserved for a properly chosen system. Whether it is constant for a given system depends on whether there is a net external force on it.
If the net external force is zero, the system’s total momentum is constant. This is the case for the two carts on a level frictionless track: gravity and the normal force on each cart cancel, and no horizontal force acts from outside.
If the net external force is not zero, momentum is transferred between the system and its surroundings. A single sliding block on a rough floor loses momentum to the floor through friction. But if you expand the system to include the floor and the Earth, the momentum lost by the block is gained by the Earth (which, being enormous, moves imperceptibly: a 1.0 kg ball falling at 10 m/s gives the 6 \(\times 10^{24}\) kg Earth a speed of only \(1.7 \times 10^{-24}\ \text{m/s}\)).
In a collision, the contact forces are so much larger than the external forces such as friction or gravity that the external impulse during the short contact is negligible, so the total momentum just before equals just after, even on a rough surface.
So “momentum is conserved” should always be preceded by a justification: name the system, and say why the external force is zero or negligible during the interaction. The exam rewards that sentence.
The method
Choose the system (usually all the objects that interact) and the two instants: just before and just after.
Choose a positive direction. Draw before and after sketches with the velocities and their signs.
Justify: “the net external force on the system is zero (or negligible during the interaction).”
Write \(\sum p_i = \sum p_f\) and substitute \(m\) and \(v\) with signs.
Solve for the unknown, then check: does the sign of the answer make sense, and does the center-of-mass velocity agree before and after?
The bar chart of Figure 4.5b is a quick way to set up the problem. Draw the momentum of each object before, and after, as signed bars; the total bar must have the same height in both charts.
Figure 4.5b A momentum bar chart for the collision in Figure 4.4a (the same pair of carts). Cart A loses 2 kg·m/s and cart B gains 2 kg·m/s, so the total is 6.0 kg·m/s both before and after. Whatever momentum one object loses, the other gains.
Worked example · carts that stick
A 2.0 kg cart moving right at 3.0 m/s hits a 1.0 kg cart at rest on a level frictionless track, and they stick together. Find their common velocity.
System and justification. Both carts; the net external horizontal force is zero (the track is frictionless and level), so momentum is conserved.
Equation. \((2.0)(3.0) + (1.0)(0) = (2.0 + 1.0)v_f\), so \(v_f = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\) to the right, the same as the center-of-mass velocity found in lesson 4.4.
Worked example · recoil of an astronaut
An 80 kg astronaut floating at rest throws a 4.0 kg tool at 10 m/s. Find the astronaut’s recoil velocity.
Justify. The astronaut and tool form the system; there is no external force in space, so the total momentum remains zero.
Equation. \(0 = (4.0)(+10) + (80)v\), so \(v = -0.50\ \text{m/s}\), opposite to the throw. The astronaut has 20 times the mass and so one twentieth of the speed.
Worked example · a system that is not isolated
A 2.0 kg block slides on a rough floor at 6.0 m/s. A constant kinetic friction force of 4.0 N acts for 1.0 s. Find the block’s speed, and say what happened to its momentum.
System: the block alone. Friction is an external force: \(\Delta p = F\Delta t = (-4.0)(1.0) = -4.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Speed. \(p_f = (2.0)(6.0) - 4.0 = 8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), so \(v_f = 4.0\ \text{m/s}\). The block lost 4.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s; the floor (and the Earth) gained it.
Worked example · two skaters
A 60 kg skater and a 90 kg skater, both at rest on frictionless ice, push off each other. The 60 kg skater moves at 3.0 m/s. Find the other skater’s velocity.
Equation. \(0 = (60)(+3.0) + (90)v\), so \(v = -2.0\ \text{m/s}\). The momenta are equal and opposite (\(\pm 180\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\)); the lighter skater moves faster.
Energy note. The kinetic energies, 270 J and 180 J, are not equal: the skaters’ muscles supplied 450 J in total, which is not conserved in the same way as momentum.
Exam focus
Justify the conservation. “The net external force on the system is zero (or negligible during the short collision), so momentum is conserved.”
Equal and opposite changes. If object A gains momentum, object B loses the same amount. The momentum changes are equal and opposite even when the masses and speeds are very different.
Impulses are equal and opposite because the forces are (Newton’s third law) and the contact times are equal.
Choose the system. If the system is not isolated, momentum changes by the external impulse. Enlarge the system to include the source of the external force (the Earth, the floor) and it is conserved.
Vector equation. Signs matter. For two dimensions, conserve each component separately.
Practice
A 3.0 kg cart moving at 4.0 m/s sticks to a 1.0 kg cart at rest. What is their common speed?
Show answer
\((3.0)(4.0) = (4.0)v\), so \(v = 3.0\ \text{m/s}\).
A 50 kg skater at rest throws a 2.0 kg ball forward at 10 m/s. Find the skater’s recoil speed (frictionless ice).
Show answer
\(0 = (2.0)(10) + (50)v\), so \(v = -0.40\ \text{m/s}\): 0.40 m/s backward.
A 4.0 kg object moves right at 5.0 m/s and collides with a 2.0 kg object moving left at 4.0 m/s. After the collision the 4.0 kg object moves right at 2.0 m/s. Find the velocity of the 2.0 kg object.
Show answer
Right positive: \((4.0)(5.0) + (2.0)(-4.0) = (4.0)(2.0) + (2.0)v\), so \(12 = 8.0 + 2.0v\) and \(v = +2.0\ \text{m/s}\), to the right.
An ice hockey puck slides on ice and slows slightly because of friction. Is the puck’s momentum conserved? Is the momentum of the system puck plus Earth conserved?
Show answer
Not for the puck alone: friction from the ice is an external force that transfers momentum out of the puck. For the system of puck and Earth, friction is internal, and the total momentum is conserved: the Earth gains the momentum the puck loses (by an amount too small to detect).
Two carts of equal mass collide, and during the collision cart A exerts a 20 N force on cart B for 0.050 s. How much momentum does cart A lose?
Show answer
By the third law, B exerts a 20 N force on A for the same time. The impulse on A is \(-(20)(0.050) = -1.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{s}\), so A loses 1.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s, exactly what B gains.
A student says, “Momentum is conserved because kinetic energy is conserved.” Evaluate.
Show answer
The reasoning is wrong. Momentum conservation follows from Newton’s third law and a zero net external force on the system. It holds in all collisions, including those in which kinetic energy is not conserved, such as objects that stick together.
Collisions that stick and explosions that push apart
Two kinds of interaction cover most of the momentum problems you will meet. In the first, objects collide and stay together: a football tackle, two railroad cars coupling, a bullet burying itself in a block of wood. In the second, a system that starts together flies apart: a rifle and its bullet, two skaters pushing away from each other, a firework shell bursting. They look like opposites, and they are, in the sense that one is a time-reversed copy of the other. The method is the same, though: conserve momentum, and treat the energy separately. This lesson works through both, adds the classic ballistic pendulum, which combines momentum conservation with the energy methods of Unit 3, and shows that kinetic energy behaves very differently from momentum in these interactions.
Learning objective · 4.3.A (applied)
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of linear momentum, to determine the velocity of a system immediately before and immediately after collisions or explosions.
Required content · used in this lesson
A collision is a model for an interaction where the forces exerted between the involved objects are much larger than the net external force; an explosion is a model for an interaction in which forces internal to the system move objects within that system apart (4.1.A.3).
If the net external force on the selected system is zero, the total momentum of the system is constant (4.3.B.2).
In a perfectly inelastic collision, the objects stick together and move with the same velocity after the collision (4.4.A.5).
Perfectly inelastic collisions: objects that stick
When objects stick together, they move as one body with a single velocity \(v_f\) after the collision. This is a perfectly inelastic collision, and it is the easiest to solve:
\[ m_1v_1 + m_2v_2 = (m_1 + m_2)v_f \quad\Longrightarrow\quad v_f = \frac{m_1v_1 + m_2v_2}{m_1 + m_2}. \]
The result equals the velocity of the center of mass (lesson 4.4), as it must. In Figure 4.6a a 1.5 kg cart at 4.0 m/s hits a 2.5 kg cart at rest. The momentum before is \(6.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), the combined 4.0 kg cart moves at \(6.0/4.0 = 1.5\ \text{m/s}\), and the momentum after is again 6.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s.
Figure 4.6a A perfectly inelastic collision. Momentum is conserved (6.0 kg·m/s before and after), so the combined cart moves at v = 6.0/4.0 = 1.5 m/s. Kinetic energy is not conserved: 12 J before, 4.5 J after.
Momentum is conserved, but the kinetic energy is not. It was \(\tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(4.0)^2 = 12\ \text{J}\) before and \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)(1.5)^2 = 4.5\ \text{J}\) after. The missing 7.5 J, about 62 percent, has been converted to thermal energy, sound and the energy of deformation. A perfectly inelastic collision loses the largest fraction of kinetic energy that momentum conservation allows. Do not try to “conserve” kinetic energy here: the carts have no way to re-release it.
Explosions and recoil
In an explosion the system starts with some total momentum (very often zero) and ends with its pieces moving apart. The total momentum is the same before and after, so the pieces must move in such a way that their momenta add to the original total. If the system started at rest, the momenta are equal and opposite. In Figure 4.6b a compressed spring pushes a 2.0 kg cart and a 3.0 kg cart apart. The cart on the left moves at 3.0 m/s, so the other moves at 2.0 m/s the other way: \(0 = (2.0)(-3.0) + (3.0)(+2.0)\). The lighter object ends up with the larger speed, because the momenta have equal sizes (\(6.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) each).
Figure 4.6b An explosion: forces internal to the system push the objects apart. The total momentum was zero and remains zero, so the momenta are equal and opposite: (2.0)(−3.0) + (3.0)(+2.0) = 0. The lighter cart ends with the larger speed. The kinetic energy (9 J + 6 J = 15 J) came from the spring’s stored energy.
The kinetic energy increases in an explosion: here from 0 to \(9 + 6 = 15\ \text{J}\), because energy stored in the spring (or in a chemical explosive) is released. This is the mirror image of a perfectly inelastic collision, in which kinetic energy decreases. A rifle fires a bullet forward, and the rifle recoils backward with equal and opposite momentum. A 4.0 kg rifle that fires a 0.020 kg bullet at 500 m/s recoils at \(-(0.020)(500)/4.0 = -2.5\ \text{m/s}\). The bullet carries \(2500\ \text{J}\) of kinetic energy but the rifle only \(12.5\ \text{J}\): the same momentum gives much less energy to the heavy object, \(K = p^2/2m\). This is why a heavy gun recoils gently and a lighter one “kicks.”
Putting momentum and energy together: the ballistic pendulum
Often a problem has two stages, and you must use the right law for each. The classic example is the ballistic pendulum, a way to measure a bullet’s speed. A bullet embeds itself in a block hanging from strings; the block swings up. Stage 1, the very brief embedding, is a perfectly inelastic collision: use momentum (energy is not conserved, and the swing has not started). Stage 2, the swing, has only gravity doing work: use energy (momentum is not conserved because the string tension and gravity are external forces that act over a long time). The mistake to avoid is applying energy conservation through the embedding.
Worked example · coupling railroad cars
A 1500 kg car moving at 4.0 m/s couples with a 2500 kg car at rest. What is their speed, and how much kinetic energy is lost?
Momentum. \((1500)(4.0) = (4000)v\), so \(v = 1.5\ \text{m/s}\).
Worked example · collisions in opposite directions
A 1000 kg car moving east at 20 m/s hits head-on a 1500 kg car moving west at 10 m/s, and they lock together. Find the velocity just after.
East positive. \((1000)(+20) + (1500)(-10) = (2500)v\), so \(v = \dfrac{20\,000 - 15\,000}{2500} = +2.0\ \text{m/s}\), to the east.
Interpretation. The heavier-momentum car (the 20 000 kg\(\cdot\)m/s one) decides the direction. If the 1500 kg car had been going west at 13.3 m/s, the wreckage would have stopped dead.
Worked example · an explosion with a heavy piece
A 6.0 kg object at rest explodes into a 1.0 kg piece moving at 15 m/s east and a second piece. Find the velocity of the 5.0 kg piece and the total kinetic energy released.
Momentum. \(0 = (1.0)(+15) + (5.0)v\), so \(v = -3.0\ \text{m/s}\), that is 3.0 m/s west.
Energy. \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(15)^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(5.0)(3.0)^2 = 112.5 + 22.5 = 135\ \text{J}\), all of it supplied by the explosion.
Worked example · the ballistic pendulum
A 0.010 kg bullet moving at 400 m/s embeds in a 2.0 kg block hanging at rest from strings. How high does the block swing?
Energy accounting. The bullet began with 800 J but the block and bullet have only \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.010)(1.99)^2 = 4.0\ \text{J}\) just after the embedding: 99.5% of the kinetic energy was dissipated in the collision.
Exam focus
Perfectly inelastic: one final velocity, \(v_f = p_{\text{total}}/M\). Kinetic energy decreases.
Explosion: total momentum unchanged (often zero), kinetic energy increases. Lighter piece, larger speed; momenta are equal and opposite when starting at rest.
Use each law for its stage. Momentum for the brief collision; energy for the slower motion before or after (swing, slide, rise).
Signs. Pieces that move in opposite directions have opposite signs. A negative answer for a velocity just means it points in the negative direction.
Reasonableness. After a sticking collision the combined speed lies between the original speeds (if they were in the same direction) and the momentum of the heavier or faster object dominates the direction.
Practice
A 2.0 kg cart at 6.0 m/s collides with a 4.0 kg cart at rest and sticks. Find the final speed and the kinetic energy lost.
Show answer
\(v = (2.0)(6.0)/6.0 = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\). \(K_i = 36\ \text{J}\); \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(6.0)(2.0)^2 = 12\ \text{J}\); lost 24 J.
A 1200 kg car at 15 m/s east collides with an 1800 kg truck at 10 m/s north and they lock together. Find the velocity just after the collision.
Show answer
Conserve each component. East: \((1200)(15) = (3000)v_x\), so \(v_x = 6.0\ \text{m/s}\). North: \((1800)(10) = (3000)v_y\), so \(v_y = 6.0\ \text{m/s}\). Speed \(8.5\ \text{m/s}\) at \(45^\circ\) north of east.
A 0.020 kg bullet leaves a 4.0 kg rifle at 500 m/s. Find the rifle’s recoil speed, and compare the kinetic energies of the bullet and the rifle.
Show answer
Two ice skaters of masses 40 kg and 60 kg are at rest and push apart. The 40 kg skater has a speed of 3.0 m/s. What is the other’s speed, and is the total kinetic energy before or after greater?
Show answer
\(0 = (40)(3.0) - (60)v\), so \(v = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\). The kinetic energy before is zero and after is \(\tfrac{1}{2}(40)(9) + \tfrac{1}{2}(60)(4) = 180 + 120 = 300\ \text{J}\): it is greater afterward.
In a ballistic-pendulum experiment, the bullet’s speed is found by measuring how high the block rises. Explain why energy conservation cannot be applied to the embedding itself.
Show answer
The embedding is a perfectly inelastic collision: most of the bullet’s kinetic energy is dissipated into thermal energy and deformation of the wood. Momentum, not energy, is conserved in that stage. Energy conservation applies only afterward, during the swing.
A 1.0 kg object at rest explodes into two pieces. A student claims the two pieces have equal speeds. Under what condition would this be true, and what if the masses are unequal?
Show answer
Their momenta are equal and opposite, \(m_1v_1 = m_2v_2\). Equal speeds would require equal masses. If the masses differ, the lighter piece moves faster in inverse proportion to its mass.
Momentum is conserved in every collision. Kinetic energy is not. Two steel balls clack together and bounce apart almost as fast as they came; two lumps of clay thud together and stop; a car crumples in a crash and its passengers survive because the crumpling absorbs energy. The difference between these is not in momentum but in what happens to the kinetic energy, and physicists classify collisions by it. This lesson defines elastic, inelastic and perfectly inelastic collisions, shows how to tell them apart from data, and gives the shortcut for the most common elastic case, one object at rest.
Learning objective · 4.4.A
Describe whether an interaction between objects is elastic or inelastic.
Required content · EK 4.4.A.1 to 4.4.A.5
An elastic collision between objects is one in which the initial kinetic energy of the system is equal to the final kinetic energy of the system.
In an elastic collision, the final kinetic energies of each of the objects within the system may be different from their initial kinetic energies.
An inelastic collision between objects is one in which the total kinetic energy of the system decreases.
In an inelastic collision, some of the initial kinetic energy is not restored to kinetic energy but is transformed by nonconservative forces into other forms of energy.
In a perfectly inelastic collision, the objects stick together and move with the same velocity after the collision.
Three kinds of collision
Elastic: the total kinetic energy of the system is the same before and after. The objects bounce, and the energy goes into the motion of the objects only (briefly stored in the elastic deformation and then returned). Collisions between hard steel balls or between air-track gliders with spring bumpers are nearly elastic. Individual objects can gain or lose kinetic energy; it is the total that is unchanged.
Inelastic: the total kinetic energy decreases. Some of the initial kinetic energy is transformed by nonconservative forces into other forms, mostly thermal energy, sound and permanent deformation. Most real collisions are inelastic, and the lost fraction ranges from a little (a bouncy rubber ball) to a lot.
Perfectly inelastic: the objects stick together and move with a single common velocity. This is the inelastic collision with the greatest possible loss of kinetic energy for given masses and initial velocities.
All three conserve momentum, provided the system is chosen so that the external forces are negligible. A collision in which kinetic energy increases is not a collision at all but an explosion: stored energy has been released (lesson 4.6). Figure 4.7a shows the same collision under all three conditions. A 2.0 kg object at 3.0 m/s strikes a 1.0 kg object at rest. The total momentum is 6.0 kg\(\cdot\)m/s in each case, but the kinetic energy that remains differs: 9 J (elastic, final velocities 1.0 m/s and 4.0 m/s), 7.1 J (an inelastic example, 1.4 m/s and 3.2 m/s), and 6.0 J (perfectly inelastic, both at 2.0 m/s).
Figure 4.7a The same collision (2.0 kg at 3.0 m/s striking a 1.0 kg object at rest, 9 J before) under three conditions. Elastic: the final speeds are 1.0 m/s and 4.0 m/s and all 9 J remain. Inelastic: for example 1.4 m/s and 3.2 m/s leave 7.1 J. Perfectly inelastic: both objects move at 2.0 m/s and 6.0 J remains, the largest loss consistent with momentum conservation. Momentum is 6.0 kg·m/s in all three.
How to classify a collision from data
Given the masses and the velocities before and after, you do two calculations. First check that the momentum is conserved (if it is not, something external acted, or a velocity was misread). Then compare the total kinetic energy before and after: equal means elastic; smaller means inelastic; if the two objects move together afterward, it is perfectly inelastic. Allow for measurement uncertainty: a difference of a few percent in an experiment is within the error, not a loss.
There is a useful way to write the same energy fact in terms of momentum. Since \(K = p^2/2m\) (Figure 4.7b), the same momentum carries a lot more energy in a light object than in a heavy one. In an elastic collision, the energy simply moves between objects, with the total fixed.
Figure 4.7b Kinetic energy in terms of momentum: K = p²/(2m). For the same momentum, the lighter object has more kinetic energy. At p = 20 kg·m/s a 1.0 kg object has 200 J and a 4.0 kg object has 50 J. This is why recoil carries little energy: the heavy object gets the same momentum but far less kinetic energy.
A shortcut for elastic collisions with a target at rest
Elastic collisions are determined by conservation of both momentum and kinetic energy. For the common case in which object 1 (mass \(m_1\), velocity \(v_1\)) hits object 2 (mass \(m_2\)) at rest, solving the two equations (this algebra is not required on the exam, but the results are worth knowing) gives
\[ v_{1f} = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}\,v_1, \qquad v_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}\,v_1. \]
Several special cases are worth remembering. If the masses are equal, object 1 stops and object 2 moves off with the original speed, so the two simply exchange velocities (as in the swinging balls of a Newton’s cradle). If the moving object is much heavier, it barely slows down and the light object shoots forward at about twice its speed. If the moving object is much lighter, it bounces back at nearly its original speed and the heavy target hardly moves, like a ball hitting a wall. Also, the speed of approach equals the speed of separation: \(v_{1} - v_{2} = -(v_{1f} - v_{2f})\), which is another way to recognize an elastic collision.
For a perfectly inelastic collision with the target at rest, the fraction of kinetic energy lost is \(\dfrac{m_2}{m_1 + m_2}\), because \(v_f = \dfrac{m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_1\) and so \(K_f/K_i = \dfrac{m_1}{m_1 + m_2}\). A light object hitting a heavy one and sticking loses nearly all of its kinetic energy; a heavy object hitting a light one and sticking loses little.
Worked example · an elastic collision
A 1.0 kg cart moving at 6.0 m/s collides elastically with a 2.0 kg cart at rest. Find both final velocities and verify that kinetic energy is conserved.
Worked example · classifying from experimental data
A 0.50 kg glider moving at 1.2 m/s hits a 0.30 kg glider at rest. In trial A the final velocities are 0.30 m/s and 1.50 m/s. In trial B they are 0.40 m/s and 1.33 m/s. Classify each.
Trial A. \(p = (0.50)(0.30) + (0.30)(1.50) = 0.60\); \(K = 0.0225 + 0.3375 = 0.36\ \text{J}\). Momentum and energy are conserved: elastic.
Trial B. \(p = 0.20 + 0.40 = 0.60\); \(K = 0.040 + 0.265 = 0.305\ \text{J}\), about 15% less. Momentum conserved, energy not: inelastic (but not perfectly, since the gliders do not stick).
Worked example · equal masses
A 1.0 kg ball moving at 4.0 m/s strikes an identical ball at rest in an elastic collision. Describe the result.
Result. The first ball stops and the second leaves at 4.0 m/s. The velocities are exchanged, and all the kinetic energy (8.0 J) has moved from one ball to the other.
Worked example · how much energy is lost?
A 1.5 kg cart at 4.0 m/s hits a 2.5 kg cart at rest and they stick. What fraction of the kinetic energy is lost?
Fraction. \(\dfrac{m_2}{m_1 + m_2} = \dfrac{2.5}{4.0} = 0.625\), or 62.5%. This agrees with 12 J before and 4.5 J after (7.5 J lost). A heavier target takes more of the energy in a perfectly inelastic collision.
Exam focus
Always conserve momentum; only sometimes conserve energy. The test for elastic is whether the total kinetic energy is unchanged.
Perfectly inelastic is the extreme. Objects stick and the most kinetic energy that momentum conservation allows is lost, but not all of it (unless the total momentum is zero).
Where does the energy go? Thermal energy, sound and deformation, via nonconservative forces. Say this, rather than “the energy disappears.”
Approach and separation speeds. Equal in an elastic collision; the separation speed is smaller in an inelastic one; zero in a perfectly inelastic one.
Check with data. Compute both \(p\) and \(K\) before and after, in the same frame and with signs on the momenta.
Practice
A 1.0 kg ball moving at 5.0 m/s collides with an identical ball at rest, and afterward both move together at 2.5 m/s. Classify the collision and find the kinetic energy lost.
Show answer
They stick, so the collision is perfectly inelastic. \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(5.0)^2 = 12.5\ \text{J}\); \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(2.5)^2 = 6.25\ \text{J}\). Lost: 6.25 J, half.
A 2.0 kg object at 4.0 m/s hits a 2.0 kg object at rest. After the collision the first is at rest and the second moves at 4.0 m/s. Is this elastic?
Show answer
Yes. Momentum: \(8.0 = 8.0\). Kinetic energy: \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(16) = 16\ \text{J}\) before and after.
Two carts collide and the total kinetic energy after the collision is 30% less than before. Classify the collision.
Show answer
Inelastic: the total kinetic energy decreased. It is perfectly inelastic only if the carts stick together and share one velocity.
A 3.0 kg block at 2.0 m/s collides elastically with a 1.0 kg block at rest. Find the final velocities.
Show answer
In a collision the total momentum is the same before and after but the total kinetic energy increased. Can this be a collision between two objects with no energy source? Explain.
Show answer
No. A collision between ordinary objects cannot add kinetic energy; it can only keep it or convert it to other forms. An increase means energy was released from somewhere (stored elastic or chemical energy), as in an explosion.
A light ball bounces off a massive wall elastically. What are the approximate speeds of the ball and the wall afterward, relative to the originals?
Show answer
The ball’s speed is nearly unchanged but its direction reverses (\(v_{1f} \approx -v_1\)); the wall’s speed is essentially zero, though it receives momentum \(2mv\), since its mass is enormous.
Real collisions do not stay on a line. Cars meet at intersections, billiard balls glance off one another, and fragments of an explosion fly in many directions. Because momentum is a vector, its conservation holds in every direction independently, and that gives you a simple way to handle motion in a plane: split each momentum into east-west and north-south components, conserve each set separately, and put the answers back together. This lesson develops that method. In line with the AP Physics 1 course, the treatment is semiquantitative: you will set up the equations correctly, solve the simple cases where each direction has only one unknown, and reason about how changing a mass, a speed or an angle changes the result. (Problems that need simultaneous equations are not on the exam.)
Learning objective · 4.3.A (two dimensions)
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of linear momentum.
Required content · EK 4.3.A.3, 4.3.A.4 and the boundary statement
The total momentum of a system is the sum of the momenta of its constituent parts; in the absence of net external forces, any change to the momentum of an object within a system must be balanced by an equivalent and opposite change of momentum elsewhere within the system.
Correct application of conservation of momentum can be used to determine the velocity of a system immediately before and immediately after collisions or explosions.
AP Physics 1 includes a semiquantitative treatment of conservation of momentum in two dimensions: students should be able to set up the equations properly and reason about how changing a given mass, speed or angle would affect other quantities.
Components and conservation
Choose axes, for example \(x\) to the east and \(y\) to the north. A momentum vector \(\vec{p} = m\vec{v}\) has components \(p_x = mv_x\) and \(p_y = mv_y\), where \(v_x = v\cos\theta\) and \(v_y = v\sin\theta\) for a velocity at angle \(\theta\) above the \(x\)-axis. If the net external force on the system is zero, each component of the total momentum is conserved:
\[ \sum p_{x,i} = \sum p_{x,f}, \qquad \sum p_{y,i} = \sum p_{y,f}. \]
These are two separate equations. Momentum in the \(x\) direction does not “leak” into the \(y\) direction. After finding the final components, combine them: \(p = \sqrt{p_x^2 + p_y^2}\) for the magnitude and \(\tan\theta = p_y/p_x\) for the direction.
A perpendicular collision that sticks
The simplest two-dimensional problem is two objects that collide at right angles and stick (Figure 4.8a). Before the collision a 1200 kg car moves east at 15 m/s and an 1800 kg truck moves north at 10 m/s. The car has all its momentum in the \(x\) direction (\(18\,000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\)) and the truck all of its momentum in the \(y\) direction (\(18\,000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\)). After they lock together, the combined 3000 kg wreck has total components \(p_x = 18\,000\) and \(p_y = 18\,000\), so its velocity components are \(v_x = 6.0\ \text{m/s}\) and \(v_y = 6.0\ \text{m/s}\): the speed is \(8.5\ \text{m/s}\) directed \(45^\circ\) north of east.
Figure 4.8a Momentum is conserved separately in each direction. East: (1200)(15) = 18 000 kg·m/s. North: (1800)(10) = 18 000 kg·m/s. The total momentum of the locked vehicles is the vector sum, √(18 000² + 18 000²) = 25 500 kg·m/s at 45° north of east, so their common velocity is 25 500/3000 = 8.5 m/s in that direction.
The vector diagram makes the reasoning visible. The initial momenta of the two vehicles, drawn tip to tail, form the two legs of a right triangle; the total momentum is the hypotenuse, and it is the same after the collision. The wreck moves in the direction of the hypotenuse, which points between east and north, closer to whichever vehicle had more momentum.
Reasoning about changes
The exam often asks “what happens if…?” rather than for a number. With the equations set up, you can answer by inspection.
If the truck were faster: \(p_y\) increases, \(p_x\) is unchanged, so the wreck’s direction swings toward north and its speed increases.
If the car were heavier: \(p_x\) increases, so the direction swings toward east; the speed also depends on the total mass, which increased.
If the two vehicles were identical and moving at equal speeds: the components are equal and the wreck moves at \(45^\circ\), at a speed \(1/\sqrt{2}\) of the original speed of each vehicle.
Notice also that the kinetic energy decreases a great deal. It is a scalar, so there are no components: \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1200)(15)^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(1800)(10)^2 = 2.25 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\) and \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(3000)(8.49)^2 = 1.08 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\), a loss of \(1.17 \times 10^{5}\ \text{J}\).
Glancing and exploding systems
In a collision where the objects bounce off at angles, the total momentum vector after must equal the total momentum vector before. This tells you a lot without numbers. If a moving object hits an identical object at rest and the first object is deflected upward, the second must move off downward, so that the \(y\) components cancel. If one piece of an explosion flies east, the others must have net momentum to the west. For an elastic collision between two equal masses with one at rest, the two velocities after the collision are always at right angles to each other (unless it is head-on); you may use that as a qualitative fact.
An explosion of an object at rest has zero total momentum, so the momentum vectors of all the pieces must add to zero: the vectors form a closed polygon. If you know all the pieces but one, the missing one is the negative of the vector sum of the others.
Worked example · a right-angle collision with different momenta
A 1000 kg car moving east at 20 m/s and a 1500 kg SUV moving north at 10 m/s collide and stick. Find the velocity just after the collision.
Components of the momentum. \(p_x = (1000)(20) = 20\,000\); \(p_y = (1500)(10) = 15\,000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Total. \(p = \sqrt{20\,000^2 + 15\,000^2} = 25\,000\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\), at \(\tan^{-1}(15\,000/20\,000) = 37^\circ\) north of east.
Velocity. \(v = \dfrac{25\,000}{2500} = 10\ \text{m/s}\) at \(37^\circ\) north of east. The direction is closer to east, since the car had the larger momentum component.
Worked example · the missing fragment
A 3.0 kg object at rest explodes into three 1.0 kg pieces. One moves east at 6.0 m/s and another north at 8.0 m/s. Find the velocity of the third piece.
Zero total momentum. The third piece must cancel the other two: \(p_x = -(1.0)(6.0) = -6.0\) and \(p_y = -(1.0)(8.0) = -8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\).
Velocity. Its speed is \(\sqrt{6.0^2 + 8.0^2} = 10\ \text{m/s}\), directed \(\tan^{-1}(8.0/6.0) = 53^\circ\) south of west.
Worked example · an angled approach
A 0.50 kg puck moving at 4.0 m/s at \(30^\circ\) above the \(+x\) axis hits an identical stationary puck, and they stick. What is their velocity?
Velocity. Total mass 1.0 kg: \(v_x = 1.73\ \text{m/s}\), \(v_y = 1.00\ \text{m/s}\), so \(v = 2.0\ \text{m/s}\) at the same \(30^\circ\) as the original direction. Only the speed changed, to half the original.
Exam focus
Conserve each component separately. Write one equation for the east-west direction and one for the north-south direction.
Vector diagrams. Draw the momentum vectors tip to tail. The total before and after must be the same vector.
Perpendicular components do not mix. A force (or collision) along one axis changes only that component.
Set up, then reason. Be ready to say how the final speed or angle changes if a mass, speed or angle changes, using the equations without solving.
Energy is a scalar. Compute kinetic energy from the speeds, not the components, and compare before and after.
Practice
A 2.0 kg object moves east at 3.0 m/s and a 2.0 kg object moves north at 4.0 m/s. They collide and stick together. Find the velocity afterward.
Show answer
\(p_x = 6.0\), \(p_y = 8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\). \(p = 10\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) and the mass is 4.0 kg, so \(v = 2.5\ \text{m/s}\) at \(\tan^{-1}(8.0/6.0) = 53^\circ\) north of east.
A 4.0 kg object at rest explodes into two pieces. A 1.0 kg piece moves east at 12 m/s. What is the momentum of the other piece, and what is its velocity?
Show answer
The momenta must cancel: the 3.0 kg piece has \(-12\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\) (to the west), so its velocity is \(-12/3.0 = -4.0\ \text{m/s}\), i.e. 4.0 m/s west.
In the car and truck collision of Figure 4.8a, the truck had been moving faster, at 15 m/s. How would the direction of the wreck change?
Show answer
\(p_y\) increases while \(p_x\) stays the same, so the angle \(\tan^{-1}(p_y/p_x)\) north of east increases: the wreck heads closer to north than before. Its speed also increases.
Two identical pucks, one moving and one at rest, undergo a glancing collision. After the collision the moving puck goes off at \(40^\circ\) above the original direction. Where must the other puck go, qualitatively?
Show answer
It must move off at an angle below the original direction line, so that the \(y\) components of the momenta cancel (the total \(y\) momentum was zero). It also carries part of the original \(x\) momentum.
A 1.0 kg object moving east at 6.0 m/s collides with a 1.0 kg object at rest. After the collision the first moves at 3.0 m/s north. What are the components of the momentum of the second object?
Show answer
East: \(6.0 - 0 = 6.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\). North: \(0 - 3.0 = -3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m/s}\). The second object moves east and south, at a speed of \(\sqrt{36 + 9} = 6.7\ \text{m/s}\).
A student says that after a collision at right angles, the total momentum can be found by adding the magnitudes of the two original momenta. Evaluate.
Show answer
Incorrect. Momentum is a vector. For perpendicular momenta the total is the vector (Pythagorean) sum, \(\sqrt{p_1^2 + p_2^2}\), which is less than \(p_1 + p_2\).
Unit 4 practice · 10 problems
Unit 4 practice: Linear Momentum
Ten problems covering the whole unit. Choose a positive direction and
carry signs on every momentum. Before you conserve momentum, say why it
is conserved. Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), as the exam does.
Compare the momentum and the kinetic energy of a 0.045 kg golf ball at 70 m/s with those of an 80 kg jogger at 3.0 m/s.
Show answer
Momentum \(p = mv\): golf ball \((0.045)(70) = 3.2\) kg·m/s; jogger \((80)(3.0) = 240\) kg·m/s: the jogger has about 75 times more. Kinetic energy \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\): ball \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.045)(70)^2 = 110\) J; jogger \(\tfrac{1}{2}(80)(3.0)^2 = 360\) J. Momentum is linear in \(v\), energy is quadratic, so the two comparisons can come out differently.
Cart A (4.0 kg) rolls right at 2.0 m/s while cart B (6.0 kg) rolls left at 1.5 m/s. Find the total momentum of the two-cart system, magnitude and direction.
Show answer
Right positive. \(p_A = (4.0)(+2.0) = +8.0\) kg·m/s; \(p_B = (6.0)(-1.5) = -9.0\) kg·m/s. \(p_{\text{sys}} = +8.0 - 9.0 = -1.0\) kg·m/s, i.e. 1.0 kg·m/s to the left. Momenta add with signs; kinetic energies (8.0 J and 6.75 J) would simply add.
The force on a 0.50 kg ball, initially at rest, is graphed against time: it rises in a straight line from 0 to 400 N in 0.010 s, holds at 400 N until \(t = 0.030\) s, then falls in a straight line to 0 at \(t = 0.050\) s. Find the impulse, the ball's final speed, and the average force.
Show answer
Impulse is the area under \(F\)–\(t\): \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.010)(400) + (0.020)(400) + \tfrac{1}{2}(0.020)(400) = 2.0 + 8.0 + 4.0 = 14\) N·s. \(J = \Delta p = m v_f - 0 \Rightarrow v_f = \dfrac{14}{0.50} = 28\) m/s. \(F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{J}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{14}{0.050} = 280\) N, the height of the rectangle with the same area.
A 0.25 kg ball hits the floor moving downward at 8.0 m/s and rebounds upward at 6.0 m/s. Contact lasts 0.015 s. Find the impulse on the ball and the average force from the floor. Is the ball's weight important during the contact?
Show answer
Up positive: \(v_i = -8.0\) m/s, \(v_f = +6.0\) m/s. \(J = m(v_f - v_i) = (0.25)\big(6.0 - (-8.0)\big) = +3.5\) kg·m/s, upward. \(F_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{J}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{3.5}{0.015} = 230\) N (233 N) upward. The weight is \(mg = 2.5\) N: about 1% of the contact force, so neglecting it here is reasonable. The classic error is \(8.0 - 6.0\); the velocity reversed, so the change is the sum of the speeds.
An egg dropped onto a hard floor from 1 m breaks; the same egg dropped onto a thick pillow does not. Both eggs stop. In a short paragraph, explain why using impulse and momentum.
Show answer
Both eggs arrive with the same momentum and both end at rest, so the impulse \(\Delta p\) each receives is the same. Impulse is \(F_{\text{avg}}\,\Delta t\). The pillow deforms, so the egg takes much longer to stop; with the same \(\Delta p\) spread over a longer \(\Delta t\), the average force on the shell is smaller by the same factor. The hard floor stops the egg in a very short time, requiring a large force that exceeds what the shell can withstand. Airbags, crumple zones, and bending your knees on landing all work the same way: same impulse, longer time, smaller force.
Cart A (1.5 kg) moving at 4.0 m/s collides with cart B (2.5 kg) at rest, and they stick together. Find their common final velocity and the kinetic energy lost. Where did that energy go?
Show answer
No net external horizontal force acts on the two-cart system during the collision, so momentum is conserved: \(m_A v_A = (m_A + m_B)v_f \Rightarrow v_f = \dfrac{(1.5)(4.0)}{4.0} = 1.5\) m/s, forward. \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(4.0)^2 = 12\) J; \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)(1.5)^2 = 4.5\) J. Lost: \(7.5\) J, about 62%: it became thermal energy, sound, and deformation of the couplers. Momentum cannot be "lost" this way; it has no other form to take.
An 80 kg astronaut floating at rest throws a 4.0 kg tool at 10 m/s. The astronaut's recoil speed is
0.050 m/s is off by a factor of ten: a misplaced decimal, or dividing the tool's 40 kg·m/s by 800 instead of 80. Check it: 80 kg at 0.050 m/s carries only 4 kg·m/s, far short of the tool's 40.
Total momentum is zero before and after: \(0 = (4.0)(10) + (80)v \Rightarrow v = -0.50\) m/s, opposite the throw. The astronaut has 20 times the mass, so one-twentieth the speed.
2.0 m/s comes from dividing 80 by 40 instead of 40 by 80: inverting the ratio. The heavier object must recoil slower than the tool moves, not faster.
Equal speeds would mean equal speeds, not equal momenta; conservation of momentum requires \(m_1 v_1 = m_2 v_2\), so the 80 kg astronaut cannot move as fast as the 4.0 kg tool.
A 1.0 kg cart moving at 6.0 m/s collides elastically with a 2.0 kg cart at rest. Find both final velocities and verify that kinetic energy is conserved.
A 1200 kg car heading east at 15 m/s collides at an intersection with an 1800 kg truck heading north at 10 m/s. The vehicles lock together. Find their velocity just after the collision and the kinetic energy lost.
Show answer
Conserve each component separately. East: \((1200)(15) = (3000)v_x \Rightarrow v_x = 6.0\) m/s. North: \((1800)(10) = (3000)v_y \Rightarrow v_y = 6.0\) m/s. Speed \(= \sqrt{6.0^2 + 6.0^2} = 8.5\) m/s at \(45^\circ\) north of east. \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(1200)(15)^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(1800)(10)^2 = 2.25\times10^{5}\) J; \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(3000)(8.49)^2 = 1.08\times10^{5}\) J. Lost: \(1.17\times10^{5}\) J.
Experimental design. Two carts with spring bumpers roll on a level track; you have two motion sensors and a balance. Design a procedure to decide whether a collision between them is elastic, and state what result would show that momentum was conserved even if the collision was not elastic.
Show answer
Measure both masses. Place one sensor at each end of the track so each cart's velocity is recorded before and after the collision (sign matters: take one direction as positive). Compute total momentum \(m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2\) before and after, and total kinetic energy \(\tfrac{1}{2}m_1 v_1^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}m_2 v_2^2\) before and after; repeat several trials. Elastic: total \(K\) after equals total \(K\) before (within uncertainty). Momentum conserved: total momentum after equals total momentum before; expected in every trial, elastic or not, because the track exerts no net horizontal force on the two-cart system. Level the track first so gravity contributes no horizontal component.
A bicycle wheel, a ceiling fan, a spinning skater and the Earth itself all rotate, and none of them can be treated as a single point moving along a path. Different parts of the same wheel move in different directions at different speeds at the same moment: the top of a turning wheel moves one way, the bottom the other, and a point near the hub barely moves at all. Yet the wheel as a whole has one simple description. Every part of it turns through the same angle in the same time. This unit builds a second, parallel set of motion and force ideas for rotation, and this first lesson supplies the vocabulary: angular displacement, angular velocity and angular acceleration. If you remember position, velocity and acceleration from Unit 1, you will find that every idea here has a close twin.
Learning objective · 5.1.A
Describe the rotation of a system with respect to time using angular displacement, angular velocity, and angular acceleration.
Required content · EK 5.1.A.1 to 5.1.A.3
Angular displacement is the measurement of the angle, in radians, through which a point on a rigid system rotates about a specified axis.
A rigid system is one that holds its shape but in which different points on the system move in different directions during rotation. A rigid system cannot be modeled as an object.
One direction of angular displacement about an axis of rotation, clockwise or counterclockwise, is typically indicated as mathematically positive, with the other direction becoming mathematically negative.
If the rotation of a system about an axis may be well described using the motion of the system’s center of mass, the system may be treated as a single object. For example, the rotation of Earth about its axis may be considered negligible when considering the revolution of Earth about the center of mass of the Earth–Sun system.
Average angular velocity is the average rate at which angular position changes with respect to time.
Average angular acceleration is the average rate at which the angular velocity changes with respect to time.
Boundary statement from the CED
Descriptions of the directions of rotation for a point or object are limited to clockwise and counterclockwise with respect to a given axis of rotation.
Rigid systems and the axis of rotation
In Units 1 to 4 you modeled things as objects: single points with a mass, a position and a velocity. A rigid system is different. It keeps its shape (the distances between its parts do not change) but its parts move in different directions as it turns, so one velocity cannot describe it. A turntable, a seesaw, an opening door, a hanging pendulum rod and a spinning planet are all rigid systems. What they have in common is an axis of rotation, a line about which the whole system turns. A door turns about the line through its hinges; a wheel turns about its axle. In this course you consider rotation about one axis at a time.
Sometimes you can ignore the rotation and treat the system as an object after all. The CED’s example is the Earth. It spins once a day, but when you study its yearly orbit around the Sun, only the motion of its center of mass matters, and you can model the Earth as a single point. The decision rests on the question being asked: if the rotation does not affect the quantity you want, use the object model; if it does, you need the tools of this unit.
Angular displacement and the radian
To describe how far a rigid system has turned, you give the angle through which any one of its points has turned about the axis. This is the angular displacement, \(\Delta\theta\). AP Physics 1 measures it in radians. An angle in radians is the length of the arc it cuts off divided by the radius,
\[ \theta = \frac{s}{r}. \]
An arc exactly as long as the radius cuts off an angle of one radian, about \(57.3^\circ\) (Figure 5.1a). Since the whole circumference is \(2\pi r\), one full revolution is \(2\pi\) radians, and
\[ 1\ \text{rev} = 360^\circ = 2\pi\ \text{rad} \approx 6.28\ \text{rad}. \]
A radian is a ratio of two lengths, so it has no units in the strict sense; you write “rad” to remind yourself which angle measure is in use. This matters because the neat relations of rotational motion, such as \(s = r\theta\) in lesson 5.3, work only when the angle is in radians.
Figure 5.1a The radian. An angle in radians is the arc length divided by the radius, so an arc exactly as long as the radius subtends one radian (57.3°). One full turn is 2π radians, because the circumference is 2πr. In AP Physics 1 equations, angles are always in radians.
Notice what the figure does not say: the angle in radians does not depend on how big the circle is. A \(90^\circ\) turn is always \(\pi/2\) radians whether the circle is a coin or a carousel. That is exactly why angle is the right quantity for describing a rigid system. Look at Figure 5.1b. When the wheel turns through \(\Delta\theta\), an outer point and an inner point both sweep out the same angle, though the outer one travels along a longer arc.
Figure 5.1b A rigid system turns as a whole, so every point on it sweeps out the same angle in the same time. All points share the same angular displacement, angular velocity and angular acceleration. They differ only in how far they travel along their circles (s = rθ).
That property is what makes rotation tractable. Every point of a rigid system has the same angular displacement, the same angular velocity and the same angular acceleration. So you can say “the wheel turned through 0.70 rad” without saying which point of the wheel you mean.
Positive and negative rotation
Angular displacement has a direction, but in this course that direction is only one of two: clockwise or counterclockwise about the axis. You pick one as positive and the other becomes negative (Figure 5.1c). Counterclockwise as positive is the usual choice, and it matches the way angles are measured on a graph. Whatever you choose, keep it for the whole problem, and state it. A wheel that turns \(+5.0\) rad counterclockwise and then \(-5.0\) rad clockwise has returned to its starting angle: its net angular displacement is zero, just as a cart that goes 5 m right and then 5 m left has zero displacement.
Figure 5.1c Choose one direction of rotation about the axis to be positive and the other negative. Counterclockwise is the usual choice. Angular displacement, velocity and acceleration all take the sign of this choice; there is no other directional vocabulary needed in AP Physics 1.
Angular velocity and angular acceleration
The average angular velocity is the rate at which angular position changes:
\[ \omega_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta\theta}{\Delta t}, \]
measured in radians per second. It is positive for counterclockwise rotation and negative for clockwise rotation (given the usual choice). The average angular acceleration is the rate at which angular velocity changes:
\[ \alpha_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta\omega}{\Delta t}, \]
in radians per second squared. Compare these with \(v = \Delta x/\Delta t\) and \(a = \Delta v/\Delta t\): the form is identical, with \(\theta\) in place of \(x\), \(\omega\) in place of \(v\) and \(\alpha\) in place of \(a\). The CED states the point directly: angular displacement, velocity and acceleration about one axis are analogous to their linear counterparts and have the same mathematical relationships. Everything you learned about linear kinematics can be carried across.
Rotation rates are often quoted in revolutions per minute (rpm). Convert before using any equation: multiply by \(2\pi\) rad per revolution and divide by 60 s per minute. A record turning at 45 rpm has
\[ \omega = 45\ \text{rev/min} \times \frac{2\pi\ \text{rad}}{1\ \text{rev}} \times \frac{1\ \text{min}}{60\ \text{s}} = 4.71\ \text{rad/s}. \]
Some everyday values give a feel for the numbers. The second hand of a clock turns once in 60 s, so \(\omega = 2\pi/60 = 0.105\) rad/s. The Earth turns once in 86,400 s, so \(\omega = 7.27 \times 10^{-5}\) rad/s. A washing machine in its spin cycle, about 1,200 rpm, reaches 126 rad/s.
Worked example · average angular velocity
A wheel turns through 3.0 complete revolutions in 2.0 s. Find its angular displacement in radians and its average angular velocity.
Divide by the time. \(\omega_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{18.8\ \text{rad}}{2.0\ \text{s}} = 9.4\) rad/s. This is the same as 1.5 revolutions per second, or 90 rpm.
Worked example · average angular acceleration
A ceiling fan starts from rest and reaches an angular velocity of 30 rad/s after 6.0 s. What is its average angular acceleration?
Use the definition. \(\alpha_{\text{avg}} = \dfrac{\omega - \omega_0}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{30 - 0}{6.0} = 5.0\ \text{rad/s}^2\).
Interpret. Each second the fan’s angular velocity increases by 5.0 rad/s. Because the fan is speeding up while turning in the positive direction, \(\omega\) and \(\alpha\) have the same sign, just as a car speeding up forward has \(v\) and \(a\) with the same sign.
Worked example · a negative angular velocity
A turntable turns clockwise at 5.0 rad/s. Taking counterclockwise as positive, find its angular displacement in 3.0 s, in radians and in revolutions.
Sign. Clockwise is negative, so \(\omega = -5.0\) rad/s.
Displacement. \(\Delta\theta = \omega\,\Delta t = (-5.0)(3.0) = -15\) rad. The negative sign says the net turn is clockwise.
Radians inside every equation. Convert degrees, revolutions and rpm first. Convert back only in the final answer, if asked.
Same angle for every point. If a question asks which point of a rigid wheel has the larger \(\omega\) or \(\Delta\theta\), the answer is neither: they are all equal.
State the sign convention. Only two directions exist, clockwise and counterclockwise, so a short statement such as “counterclockwise is positive” is enough.
The linear analogy is your check. If you do not remember a rotational relation, write the linear one and swap the letters.
Object or rigid system? A system whose rotation does not matter to the question can be modeled as a single object; one whose rotation does matter cannot.
Practice
A drum rotates at 120 rpm. Express this angular velocity in rad/s.
Show answer
\(120 \times 2\pi/60 = 4\pi = 12.6\) rad/s.
A wheel turns through 15.7 rad. How many revolutions is that?
Show answer
\(15.7/2\pi = 2.50\) revolutions.
A wheel’s angular velocity increases from 8.0 rad/s to 20 rad/s in 4.0 s. Find the average angular acceleration.
Show answer
Point A is 0.20 m from the axle of a spinning wheel and point B is 0.50 m from it. Which point has the greater angular displacement in one turn?
Show answer
Neither. Both points turn through \(2\pi\) rad in one turn. Points on a rigid system share the same angular displacement, angular velocity and angular acceleration. B travels a longer arc (\(s = r\theta\)) but through the same angle.
A disk first turns +12 rad counterclockwise and then 20 rad clockwise. With counterclockwise positive, what is its net angular displacement?
Show answer
\(\Delta\theta = (+12) + (-20) = -8\) rad: a net turn of 8 rad clockwise.
For which of these questions can the Earth be modeled as a single object: (i) the time for the Earth to orbit the Sun, (ii) the speed of a point on the equator relative to the Earth’s center?
Show answer
(i). The orbit is described by the motion of the center of mass, so the Earth’s spin can be ignored. In (ii) the spin is the whole point, so the Earth must be treated as a rotating rigid system.
A potter’s wheel is switched on and speeds up, a flywheel is braked to a stop, a hard drive spins up to its operating rate. In each case you want to predict how fast the rotor will be turning after some time, or how many turns it will make before it stops. In Unit 1 you answered the same questions for a car or a ball with the constant-acceleration equations. The CED tells you something very convenient: angular displacement, angular velocity and angular acceleration about one axis show the same mathematical relationships as their linear counterparts. This lesson writes out the rotational set, uses it on typical problems and shows how to read the graphs.
Learning objective · 5.1.A
Describe the rotation of a system with respect to time using angular displacement, angular velocity, and angular acceleration.
Required content · EK 5.1.A.4
Angular displacement, angular velocity, and angular acceleration around one axis are analogous to linear displacement, velocity, and acceleration in one dimension and demonstrate the same mathematical relationships.
For constant angular acceleration, the mathematical relationships between angular displacement, angular velocity, and angular acceleration can be described with the following equations (the rotational kinematic equations).
Graphs of angular displacement, angular velocity, and angular acceleration as functions of time can be used to find the relationships between those quantities.
The equations for constant angular acceleration
When the angular acceleration is constant, the three equations from the Unit 1 “kinematics kit” carry across with the letters swapped:
Linear
Rotational
Missing variable
\(v = v_0 + at\)
\(\omega = \omega_0 + \alpha t\)
\(\Delta\theta\)
\(\Delta x = v_0 t + \tfrac{1}{2}at^2\)
\(\Delta\theta = \omega_0 t + \tfrac{1}{2}\alpha t^2\)
The same method applies. List the five quantities (\(\Delta\theta\), \(\omega_0\), \(\omega\), \(\alpha\), \(t\)), write down the three you know, and choose the equation that contains the quantity you want and does not contain the one you neither know nor need. And the same warning applies: these equations hold only when \(\alpha\) is constant. If the net effect on the wheel changes with time, split the motion into stages.
Keep every quantity in radians, radians per second and radians per second squared. A very common error is to leave \(\omega\) in rpm or to leave \(\Delta\theta\) in degrees; the equations are then wrong by a factor of \(2\pi\) or \(60\) or \(180/\pi\). Convert at the start, and convert back to revolutions only at the end if the question asks.
Reading rotational graphs
The graphs also match their linear twins (Figure 5.2a). On an angular velocity against time graph:
the slope is the angular acceleration, \(\alpha = \Delta\omega/\Delta t\);
the area between the graph and the time axis is the angular displacement, \(\Delta\theta\) (area above the axis counts as positive turning, below as negative).
On an angular position against time graph, the slope at any instant is the angular velocity. A straight \(\theta\)–\(t\) line is a steady rotation (\(\alpha = 0\)); a curve that steepens upward means \(\omega\) is increasing, so \(\alpha \gt 0\). On an \(\alpha\)–\(t\) graph, the area is the change in angular velocity.
Figure 5.2a A wheel with ω0 = 4.0 rad/s and constant α = 4.0 rad/s². On the ω–t graph the slope is α and the area is Δθ. On the θ–t graph the slope at any instant is ω. These are the linear graphs of Unit 1 with new labels.
In Figure 5.2a the wheel starts at \(\omega_0 = 4.0\) rad/s and speeds up at 4.0 rad/s\(^2\). The \(\omega\)–\(t\) line climbs by 4.0 rad/s every second. By \(t = 5.0\) s the area under it is a trapezoid with \(\omega = 24\) rad/s at the end, so \(\Delta\theta = \tfrac{1}{2}(4 + 24)(5.0) = 70\) rad, and the \(\theta\)–\(t\) parabola on the right has reached 70 rad at that time. The two graphs describe the same motion.
Slowing down
When a rotor speeds up, \(\omega\) and \(\alpha\) have the same sign; when it slows down, they have opposite signs. For a wheel turning counterclockwise (positive \(\omega\)) that is being braked, \(\alpha\) is negative. Figure 5.2b shows a wheel at 20 rad/s braked uniformly at 4.0 rad/s\(^2\). The line falls to zero in 5.0 s, and the triangle beneath it, with area \(\tfrac{1}{2}(20)(5.0) = 50\) rad, is the angle the wheel turns while stopping. That is 8.0 revolutions.
Figure 5.2b A wheel spinning at 20 rad/s is braked uniformly at 4.0 rad/s². The line falls to zero at t = 5.0 s; the area of the triangle, ½(20)(5.0) = 50 rad, is the angle it turns while stopping (7.96 revolutions).
Worked example · speeding up
A potter’s wheel at 4.0 rad/s speeds up with constant \(\alpha = 2.0\ \text{rad/s}^2\) for 5.0 s. Find its final angular velocity and the angle it turns.
Final angular velocity. \(\omega = \omega_0 + \alpha t = 4.0 + (2.0)(5.0) = 14\) rad/s.
Angle. \(\Delta\theta = \omega_0 t + \tfrac{1}{2}\alpha t^2 = (4.0)(5.0) + \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(5.0)^2 = 20 + 25 = 45\) rad, which is \(45/2\pi = 7.2\) revolutions.
Check. The average angular velocity is \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0 + 14) = 9.0\) rad/s, and \(9.0 \times 5.0 = 45\) rad. ✓
Worked example · the time-free equation
A drill chuck starts from rest and has \(\alpha = 3.0\ \text{rad/s}^2\) while it turns through 24 rad. How fast is it turning at the end?
Choose the equation. The time is neither given nor asked for, so use \(\omega^2 = \omega_0^2 + 2\alpha\,\Delta\theta\).
An \(\omega\)–\(t\) graph is a straight line from 6.0 rad/s at \(t = 0\) to 18 rad/s at \(t = 3.0\) s. Find \(\alpha\) and \(\Delta\theta\).
Show answer
A bicycle tire turns at a certain angular velocity, and the bicycle moves along the road at a certain speed. A record spins at a steady rate, and the needle in its groove sees the surface rush past. A merry-go-round turns as a single rigid unit, and yet a child on the rim feels far more motion than one near the center. Each of these is the same question: how does a point’s linear motion (distance, speed, acceleration along its circle) follow from the rotation of the whole system? This lesson gives the bridge between the two descriptions. It rests on one fact from lesson 5.1, that a rigid system has a single \(\omega\) and a single \(\alpha\), and on one geometric quantity, the distance \(r\) of the point from the axis.
Learning objective · 5.2.A
Describe the linear motion of a point on a rotating rigid system that corresponds to the rotational motion of that point, and vice versa.
Required content · EK 5.2.A.1 to 5.2.A.3
For a point at a distance \(r\) from a fixed axis of rotation, the linear distance \(s\) traveled by the point as the system rotates through an angle \(\Delta\theta\) is given by the equation \(s = r\,\Delta\theta\).
Derived relationships of linear velocity and of the tangential component of acceleration to their respective angular quantities are given by the equations \(v = r\omega\) and \(a_t = r\alpha\).
For a rigid system, all points within that system have the same angular velocity and angular acceleration.
Boundary statement from the CED
Descriptions of the directions of rotation for a point or object are limited to clockwise and counterclockwise with respect to a given axis of rotation.
Distance, speed and tangential acceleration
Start from the definition of the radian, \(\theta = s/r\). Solved for the arc length it gives
\[ s = r\,\Delta\theta, \]
the distance traveled along its circular path by a point at radius \(r\) when the system turns through \(\Delta\theta\) radians. Divide both sides by the time interval. The left side becomes the speed along the path; on the right, \(r\) is constant and \(\Delta\theta/\Delta t\) is the angular velocity:
\[ v = r\omega. \]
Divide again to compare the changes in speed and angular velocity, and you find the tangential acceleration, the part of the acceleration that changes the speed of the point along its circle:
\[ a_t = r\alpha. \]
All three equations require the angle to be in radians. They are the way you translate between the rotational description of the system (one \(\Delta\theta\), \(\omega\) and \(\alpha\) for everything) and the linear description of any one point on it.
The velocity of the point is tangent to its circle, in the direction of rotation (Figure 5.3a). The tangential acceleration is also along that tangent: it speeds the point up when \(\alpha\) has the same sign as \(\omega\) and slows it down when the signs are opposite.
The centripetal acceleration is always there
Whenever a point moves in a circle, it also has the centripetal acceleration of Unit 2, directed toward the axis. Written with angular quantities,
\[ a_c = \frac{v^2}{r} = \frac{(r\omega)^2}{r} = r\omega^2. \]
Do not confuse the two components. \(a_t = r\alpha\) depends on how fast \(\omega\) is changing and points along the velocity. \(a_c = r\omega^2\) depends on how fast the wheel is turning and points toward the center. A wheel spinning at a perfectly steady rate (\(\alpha = 0\)) has \(a_t = 0\) but still has \(a_c \ne 0\); that is the acceleration that keeps the point on its circle. The two components are perpendicular, so the total acceleration of the point has magnitude \(\sqrt{a_t^2 + a_c^2}\).
Figure 5.3a A point on a rotating wheel. Its velocity is tangent to the circle with magnitude v = rω. If the wheel speeds up, the point also has a tangential acceleration at = rα along the velocity; whatever the α, it has a centripetal acceleration ac = v²/r = rω² toward the axis.
Why a point farther out moves faster
Because every point of the rigid system shares the same \(\omega\) and \(\alpha\), the speed and the accelerations of a point are proportional to its distance from the axis. Figure 5.3b plots \(v\) against \(r\) for a disk turning at 20 rad/s: a straight line through the origin whose slope is \(\omega\). A point 0.20 m from the axis moves at 4.0 m/s; a point 0.40 m out moves at 8.0 m/s; the point on the axis does not move at all. Double the radius and you double \(v\), double \(a_t\) and, since \(a_c = r\omega^2\), double \(a_c\) as well. Everything that grows with \(r\) does so linearly, so a rotating rigid body is a collection of circles with the same period but different circumferences.
Figure 5.3b On a rigid disk spinning at constant ω, speed grows in direct proportion to distance from the axis: v = rω. The slope of the v–r graph is ω. The rim moves fastest; the center does not move at all.
The shared \(\omega\) is also the key to rolling. If a tire rolls along a road without slipping, the point on the tire that is touching the road is momentarily at rest relative to the road, and the center of the tire moves at \(v = r\omega\) relative to the road. A car at 14 m/s on tires of radius 0.35 m has tires turning at \(\omega = v/r = 14/0.35 = 40\) rad/s, and in 10 full revolutions (\(\Delta\theta = 20\pi\) rad) the car moves \(s = r\,\Delta\theta = 0.35 \times 62.8 = 22\) m. You will return to rolling in Unit 6.
Worked example · three quantities for a point on a wheel
A wheel of radius 0.30 m has \(\omega = 20\) rad/s and \(\alpha = 5.0\ \text{rad/s}^2\) at some instant. Find the speed, tangential acceleration and centripetal acceleration of a point on its rim.
Comment. The centripetal part is 80 times the tangential part, so the total acceleration, \(\sqrt{120^2 + 1.5^2} = 120\ \text{m/s}^2\), points almost exactly toward the axis.
Worked example · a rolling tire
A car moves at 14 m/s on tires of radius 0.35 m, with no slipping. Find the angular velocity of a tire and the distance the car moves while a tire makes 10 revolutions.
Distance. \(\Delta\theta = 10 \times 2\pi = 62.8\) rad, so \(s = r\,\Delta\theta = (0.35)(62.8) = 22\) m. (This is also ten circumferences: \(10 \times 2\pi(0.35) = 22\) m.)
Worked example · comparing two points
A disk turns at 15 rad/s. Compare a point at 0.20 m with a point at 0.40 m.
Shared. Both have \(\omega = 15\) rad/s (and the same \(\alpha\)).
Speed. \(v = (0.20)(15) = 3.0\) m/s and \((0.40)(15) = 6.0\) m/s: the outer point is twice as fast.
Centripetal acceleration. \(r\omega^2 = (0.20)(225) = 45\) and \((0.40)(225) = 90\ \text{m/s}^2\): twice as large, in proportion to \(r\).
Exam focus
What is shared and what is not. \(\theta,\ \omega,\ \alpha\) are the same for every point of a rigid system. \(s,\ v,\ a_t,\ a_c\) all grow with \(r\).
Two components of acceleration. \(a_t = r\alpha\) (tangent, changes speed) and \(a_c = r\omega^2\) (toward the axis, changes direction). Writing \(a_c = r\alpha\) is a classic error.
Radians only. \(s = r\theta\), \(v = r\omega\) and \(a_t = r\alpha\) are valid only with angles in radians.
Rolling without slipping. The center’s speed is \(r\omega\), and the distance rolled is \(r\,\Delta\theta\).
Ratios. Questions often ask what happens when \(r\) or \(\omega\) changes; use \(v \propto r\omega\) and \(a_c \propto r\omega^2\).
Practice
A wheel of radius 0.40 m turns through 2.5 rad. How far does a point on its rim travel?
Show answer
\(s = r\,\Delta\theta = (0.40)(2.5) = 1.0\) m.
A disk turns at 12 rad/s. For a point 0.25 m from the axis find the speed and the centripetal acceleration.
Show answer
Point P is at radius \(R\) and point Q is at \(R/2\) on a spinning rigid disk. How do their angular velocities, speeds and centripetal accelerations compare?
Show answer
The angular velocities are equal. Q’s speed is half of P’s (\(v = r\omega\)). Q’s centripetal acceleration is also half of P’s (\(a_c = r\omega^2\)).
A point 0.40 m from the axis has \(\omega = 10\) rad/s and \(\alpha = 3.0\ \text{rad/s}^2\). Find the two components of its acceleration and say which dominates.
Show answer
\(a_c = r\omega^2 = (0.40)(100) = 40\ \text{m/s}^2\). \(a_t = r\alpha = (0.40)(3.0) = 1.2\ \text{m/s}^2\). The centripetal component dominates; the total is \(\sqrt{40^2 + 1.2^2} \approx 40\ \text{m/s}^2\).
To open a stuck door you push at the handle, not near the hinges. To loosen a rusted bolt you slide a pipe over the wrench to make it longer. To start a playground merry-go-round you push along its edge, in the direction it would move, and not straight toward the middle. In each case the size of the force is only part of the story: where you push and in what direction matter just as much. A force changes the translational motion of an object (Unit 2). To change the rotation of a rigid system you need a different quantity, one that combines force, position and direction. That quantity is torque, and it plays for rotation the role that force plays for translation.
Learning objective · 5.3.A
Identify the torques exerted on a rigid system.
Learning objective · 5.3.B
Describe the torques exerted on a rigid system.
Required content · EK 5.3.A.1, 5.3.A.2, 5.3.B.1, 5.3.B.2
Torque results only from the force component perpendicular to the position vector from the axis of rotation to the point of application of the force.
The lever arm is the perpendicular distance from the axis of rotation to the line of action of the exerted force.
Torques can be described using force diagrams. Force diagrams are similar to free-body diagrams and are used to analyze the torques exerted on a rigid system. Similar to free-body diagrams, force diagrams represent the relative magnitude and direction of the forces exerted on a rigid system. Force diagrams also depict the location at which those forces are exerted relative to the axis of rotation.
The magnitude of the torque exerted on a rigid system by a force is described by the equation \(\tau = r_\perp F = rF\sin\theta\), where \(\theta\) is the angle between the force vector and the position vector from the axis of rotation to the point of application of the force.
Boundary statement from the CED
While AP Physics 1 expects students to mathematically manipulate the magnitude of torque using vector conventions, the direction of torque is beyond the scope of the course.
The definition of torque
Pick an axis of rotation. Draw the position vector \(\vec{r}\) from the axis to the point where the force is applied, and let \(\theta\) be the angle between \(\vec{r}\) and the force \(\vec{F}\). The magnitude of the torque of that force about the axis is
\[ \tau = rF\sin\theta. \]
The SI unit is the newton-meter (N·m). Torque is not a force, and N·m here is not joules: work and energy are in joules, but torque is a different quantity that happens to share the dimensions. (Write “N·m” for torque and keep “J” for energy.) Torque depends on the axis: the same force has a different torque about a different axis, which is why you must always say which axis (pivot) you are using.
The factor \(\sin\theta\) says that only the part of the force perpendicular to \(\vec{r}\) produces torque: \(F_\perp = F\sin\theta\). The component of the force along \(\vec{r}\) tries to push the system straight toward or away from the axis, and a rigid system with a fixed axis does not respond to that by rotating. So a force aimed directly at the axis (\(\theta = 0^\circ\)) or directly away from it (\(\theta = 180^\circ\)) has zero torque; a force at \(90^\circ\) to \(\vec{r}\) has the largest torque for a given \(F\) and \(r\).
The lever arm
There is a second way to read the same formula. Group the factors as \(r\sin\theta\) and you get \(r_\perp\), the lever arm: the perpendicular distance from the axis to the line of action of the force, which is the infinite line along which the force points. Then
\[ \tau = r_\perp F. \]
Figure 5.4a shows a wrench of length 0.25 m turning about a bolt, with an 80 N pull at the end at \(30^\circ\) to the wrench. Extending the force’s line backward and dropping a perpendicular from the bolt gives a lever arm of \(r\sin 30^\circ = 0.125\) m, and
\[ \tau = rF\sin\theta = (0.25)(80)\sin 30^\circ = 10\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m} = (0.125)(80). \]
The two readings (the perpendicular component of the force times the full distance, or the full force times the perpendicular distance) are the same number. Use whichever the geometry makes easier.
Figure 5.4a Torque about a pivot: τ = rF sinθ, where θ is the angle between the position vector (pivot to the point where the force acts) and the force. Equivalently, torque is the force times the lever arm, the perpendicular distance from the pivot to the line of action. Only the component of the force perpendicular to the wrench turns it.
The lever arm explains why a force can do nothing if it is aimed at the axis: its line of action passes through the axis, so the lever arm is zero. It also explains why a longer wrench is an advantage: with the same force at \(90^\circ\), the torque grows in direct proportion to the distance.
An example you can feel: the door
Figure 5.4b shows the same 25 N push at the handle of a 0.80 m door, applied three different ways. At \(90^\circ\) to the door the torque is \((0.80)(25)\sin 90^\circ = 20\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\). At \(45^\circ\) it falls to \((0.80)(25)(0.707) = 14\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), because only the perpendicular part of the push helps. Pushing straight along the door toward the hinges, \(\theta = 0\), gives zero. If you push at 0.40 m instead of 0.80 m, the torque halves. To open the door with the least effort, push far from the hinges and at right angles to the door, which is exactly what everyone does without thinking about it.
Figure 5.4b The same 25 N force at the same point gives very different torques. Perpendicular to the door (θ = 90°), τ = 20 N·m. At 45° only part of the force is perpendicular, so τ = 14 N·m. A force along the line of the door has no perpendicular component and no lever arm: τ = 0.
Force diagrams and net torque
To handle several forces, draw a force diagram. It resembles a free-body diagram: it shows the forces on the rigid system with their relative sizes and directions. The important difference is that it also shows where each force acts relative to the axis, because torque depends on position. (In a free-body diagram of a single object, every force can be drawn from the same dot, since position does not matter for translation.) Mark the axis, draw each force at its point of application and label the distances.
Each force has a torque about the axis, and you add them with signs. The only possible directions in this course are clockwise and counterclockwise, so choose one as positive (counterclockwise is usual) and give each torque a sign according to which way its force would turn the system if it acted alone. The sum is the net torque, \(\sum\tau\). In Figure 5.4c a 30 N force at 0.40 m to the right of the axis (up) and a 20 N force at 0.20 m to the left (down) both tend to turn the rod counterclockwise, so \(\sum\tau = +12 + 4.0 = +16\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\). Had the left force pointed upward instead, its torque would have been clockwise, \(-4.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), and the net would be \(+8.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\).
Figure 5.4c A force diagram for torque shows each force where it acts. An upward force on the right and a downward force on the left both rotate the rod counterclockwise, so their torques add: +12 + 4.0 = +16 N·m. (The left force would be clockwise if it pulled up.)
The sign of a torque is easy to find with the following check: imagine the axis as a fixed pin and picture the force acting alone. Does the rod swing clockwise or counterclockwise? A force on the right pointing up lifts the right end, which is counterclockwise; a force on the right pointing down lowers it, which is clockwise.
Worked example · torque of an angled force
A 0.40 m wrench is used with a 60 N force that makes an angle of \(40^\circ\) with the wrench. Find the torque, and the force that would give the same torque if applied at \(90^\circ\).
Equivalent perpendicular force. \(F_\perp = \dfrac{\tau}{r} = \dfrac{15.4}{0.40} = 39\) N. The wrench “feels” only 39 N of the 60 N.
Worked example · net torque from two forces
A rod pivots about its left end. A 10 N upward force acts at 0.60 m from the pivot, and a 5.0 N downward force acts at 1.0 m from the pivot. Find the net torque.
Signs. The 10 N force pointing up on the right of the pivot is counterclockwise (+). The 5.0 N force pointing down on the right is clockwise (−).
You need 12 N·m of torque to loosen a nut, and your wrench is 0.20 m long. What force perpendicular to the wrench must you apply? What if you slide a pipe on to make the effective length 0.60 m?
Short wrench. \(F = \tau/r = 12/0.20 = 60\) N.
Pipe on. \(F = 12/0.60 = 20\) N. Tripling the distance reduced the needed force to one third.
Exam focus
Name the axis. A torque has no meaning until you say about what point or axis it is measured.
Two equivalent forms. \(\tau = rF\sin\theta = r_\perp F\). Check which angle your \(\theta\) is: the angle between \(\vec{r}\) and \(\vec{F}\) (not the angle with the vertical or the ground).
A force through the axis has no torque. The lever arm is zero.
Add torques with signs. State your convention and give each torque a sign by the way it would turn the system.
Direction is out of scope. You need only clockwise and counterclockwise, not a vector direction for torque.
Draw a force diagram. Show the point of application of each force and the distances.
Practice
A 50 N force acts perpendicular to a wrench 0.30 m from the bolt. What is the torque?
Show answer
What force perpendicular to a 0.20 m handle produces 12 N·m?
Show answer
\(F = 12/0.20 = 60\) N.
A rod pivots about its left end. A 10 N force acts upward 0.60 m from the pivot and a 5.0 N force acts downward 1.0 m from it. What is the net torque and in which direction would the rod turn?
Show answer
\(+(0.60)(10) - (1.0)(5.0) = +1.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), so the rod would start to turn counterclockwise (the right end up).
Why does a long-handled wrench make it easier to loosen a bolt?
Show answer
Torque equals force times lever arm. A longer handle puts the force at a larger distance, so the same force makes more torque (or the same torque needs less force).
A student pushes on a door directly along its length toward the hinge. Why does the door not turn?
Show answer
The force is along the line from the hinge to the point of application, so \(\theta = 0\) and \(\sin\theta = 0\). Equivalently, the line of action passes through the hinge, so the lever arm is zero. There is no torque.
Rotational inertia: how mass is distributed matters
Hold a long pole in the middle and twist it back and forth: easy. Hold it at the end with a weight hanging from the far tip: much harder, even though the mass has not changed. A figure skater spins slowly with arms out and fast with arms pulled in. A baseball bat is easy to swing when you choke up on it. In each case the resistance to changes in rotation depends not just on how much mass there is but on where it is, measured from the axis. For translation, the resistance to changes in motion is the mass, and nothing else. For rotation the matching quantity is the rotational inertia (also called the moment of inertia), and its dependence on position is what makes rotation richer than translation.
Learning objective · 5.4.A
Describe the rotational inertia of a rigid system relative to a given axis of rotation.
Required content · EK 5.4.A.1 to 5.4.A.3
Rotational inertia measures a rigid system’s resistance to changes in rotation and is related to the mass of the system and the distribution of that mass relative to the axis of rotation.
The rotational inertia of an object rotating a perpendicular distance \(r\) from an axis is described by the equation \(I = mr^2\).
The total rotational inertia of a collection of objects about an axis is the sum of the rotational inertias of each object about that axis: \(I = \sum m_i r_i^2\).
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 only expects students to calculate the rotational inertia for systems of five or fewer objects arranged in a two-dimensional configuration. Students do not need to know the rotational inertia of extended rigid systems, as these will be provided within the exam. Students should have a qualitative understanding of the factors that affect rotational inertia; for example, how rotational inertia is greater when mass is farther from the axis of rotation, which is why a hoop has more rotational inertia than a solid disk of the same mass and radius.
One mass: \(I = mr^2\)
Begin with the simplest rigid system: a small mass \(m\) on a light rod, a distance \(r\) from a fixed axis. The mass is moving in a circle, and its speed is \(v = r\omega\). The rotational inertia is defined as
\[ I = mr^2, \]
in units of kg·m\(^2\). In lesson 5.8 you will see why this is the right quantity: when a torque acts, the mass accelerates at \(a_t = r\alpha\), and the torque needed to produce a given angular acceleration comes out as \(\tau = (mr^2)\alpha\). The important fact is the square of the distance. A given mass contributes four times as much rotational inertia when it is twice as far from the axis, and nine times as much when three times as far (Figure 5.5c). Moving mass outward is therefore far more effective at raising \(I\) than adding mass.
Figure 5.5c Rotational inertia grows as the square of the distance. Doubling the distance quadruples I; tripling it multiplies I by 9. Moving mass away from the axis is by far the most effective way to raise rotational inertia.
A collection of masses: \(I = \sum m_i r_i^2\)
For a rigid system made of several point masses, the rotational inertia about a given axis is the sum of the contributions of all the masses, each calculated with its own perpendicular distance from that axis:
\[ I = \sum_i m_i r_i^2. \]
The CED asks you to do this calculation only for systems of five or fewer objects in a plane. In Figure 5.5a a 2.0 kg mass sits 0.50 m from the axis and a 3.0 kg mass sits 0.20 m from it on the other side, joined by a rod of negligible mass:
\[ I = (2.0)(0.50)^2 + (3.0)(0.20)^2 = 0.50 + 0.12 = 0.62\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2. \]
The lighter mass contributes the larger share because it is farther away. Which side of the axis a mass lies on makes no difference, since \(r^2\) is always positive. The distance that matters is always the perpendicular distance from the axis, not from the center of mass or from any other point.
Figure 5.5a Rotational inertia of a system of point masses about an axis: I = Σ miri². Each mass contributes its mass times the square of its distance from the axis, so the lighter mass farther away contributes more (0.50 against 0.12). The side of the axis a mass is on does not matter.
Because the same system has a different \(r_i\) for each choice of axis, its rotational inertia depends on the axis. Always say the axis (“about the left end”, “about the center”) when you quote an \(I\). Lesson 5.6 shows how to move between axes.
Distribution of mass: the hoop and the disk
For a continuous rigid system, such as a hoop, disk, sphere or uniform rod, you add up the contribution of every bit of mass. The AP exam does not make you do that; the result for each standard shape is given on the exam. What you are expected to know is the idea: the more of the mass that lies far from the axis, the larger the rotational inertia. Figure 5.5b compares two objects with the same mass \(M\) and radius \(R\), each turning about its center. In the hoop all of the mass is at distance \(R\), so \(I = MR^2\). In the disk some of the mass is near the center, where it contributes little, so \(I = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\). The hoop has twice the rotational inertia. Given the same torque, the disk would spin up twice as fast.
Figure 5.5b How mass is distributed matters. All the mass of a hoop is at distance R from the axis, so I = MR². A disk of the same mass and radius has much of its mass closer in, so I = ½MR². These formulas for extended shapes are given on the exam; you must know which of two shapes has the larger value.
This explains many familiar effects. A figure skater with arms extended has a larger \(I\) than with arms tucked in, because the mass of the arms is farther from the body’s axis. A bicycle wheel with its mass concentrated on the rim is harder to spin up than a solid disc of the same weight. Gripping a bat near the barrel (choking up on it) lowers its rotational inertia about the hands, so it swings with a larger angular acceleration for the same effort.
Worked example · three masses on a line
Three small masses on a light rod: 1.0 kg at \(x = 0\), 2.0 kg at \(x = 0.30\) m and 1.0 kg at \(x = 0.60\) m. Find the rotational inertia about (a) an axis through the left mass and (b) an axis through the middle mass. Both axes are perpendicular to the rod.
Comment. The same masses give a value three times as large about the end. The middle axis is the center of mass, which is why it gives the smaller value (lesson 5.6).
Worked example · four masses in a plane
Four 0.50 kg masses sit at the corners of a square of side 0.60 m, joined by a light frame. Find the rotational inertia about an axis perpendicular to the square through (a) its center and (b) one corner.
(a) Center. Each mass is at distance \(r = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.60)\sqrt{2} = 0.424\) m, so \(r^2 = 0.18\ \text{m}^2\). \(I = 4(0.50)(0.18) = 0.36\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\).
(b) Corner. The distances are 0, 0.60, 0.60 and \(0.60\sqrt{2}\) m, with squares 0, 0.36, 0.36 and 0.72. \(I = (0.50)(0 + 0.36 + 0.36 + 0.72) = 0.72\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), twice the value about the center.
Worked example · scaling with distance
A 0.50 kg mass is moved from 0.20 m to 0.60 m from the axis. By what factor does its rotational inertia change?
Factor. The distance tripled, so \(I\) grew by \(3^2 = 9\).
Exam focus
The axis comes first. \(I\) is defined about a specific axis. Measure every \(r\) perpendicular to that axis.
Square the distance. Doubling \(r\) multiplies a mass’s \(I\) by 4.
Five or fewer point masses. You will add up \(m r^2\) for at most five objects in a plane; the formulas for extended shapes are given.
Qualitative ranking. Be ready to say which of two objects (hoop or disk, arms in or out) has the larger \(I\), using the distribution of mass.
Different from mass. Two systems with the same mass can have very different \(I\), and one system can change its \(I\) without changing its mass (the skater).
Practice
A 0.50 kg mass is 0.40 m from an axis. Find \(I\).
Show answer
A mass is moved to twice its original distance from the axis. What happens to its rotational inertia?
Show answer
It becomes four times larger, since \(I \propto r^2\).
A hoop and a solid disk have the same mass and radius. Which has the larger rotational inertia about its center, and why?
Show answer
The hoop. All of its mass is at the full radius, while much of the disk’s mass lies closer to the axis and contributes less (\(MR^2\) against \(\tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\)).
For the three masses of the first worked example, would the rotational inertia about an axis through the right mass be larger or smaller than 0.54 kg·m\(^2\)? Calculate it.
Show answer
The arrangement is symmetric, so it is the same as the left end: \(I = (1.0)(0.60)^2 + (2.0)(0.30)^2 + 0 = 0.54\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\).
A skater spinning with arms out pulls them in. What happens to the rotational inertia, and why?
Show answer
It decreases, because the arms’ mass moves closer to the axis, and each bit of mass contributes \(m r^2\) with a smaller \(r\).
Lesson 5.6 · Unit 5 · CED topic 5.4 (axes that miss the center of mass)
A baseball bat is much easier to swing by the handle than by the barrel end. A long pole is much easier to twist about its middle than about one end. Both observations share one idea. The same rigid system has a different rotational inertia for each axis you choose, and the value depends on how far that axis is from the center of mass. This lesson makes the dependence exact. It lets you find the rotational inertia about any axis that is parallel to one you already know through the center of mass, and it explains why the center of mass axis is the easiest one to turn about.
Learning objective · 5.4.B
Describe the rotational inertia of a rigid system rotating about an axis that does not pass through the system’s center of mass.
Required content · EK 5.4.B.1, 5.4.B.2
A rigid system’s rotational inertia in a given plane is at a minimum when the rotational axis passes through the system’s center of mass.
The parallel axis theorem uses the following equation to relate the rotational inertia of a rigid system about any axis that is parallel to an axis through its center of mass: \(I = I_{cm} + Md^2\).
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 only expects students to calculate the rotational inertia for systems of five or fewer objects arranged in a two-dimensional configuration. Students do not need to know the rotational inertia of extended rigid systems, as these will be provided within the exam.
The theorem
Let \(I_{cm}\) be the rotational inertia of a rigid system of total mass \(M\) about an axis through its center of mass. Take any second axis that is parallel to the first, a perpendicular distance \(d\) away. The rotational inertia about the second axis is
\[ I = I_{cm} + Md^2. \]
This is the parallel axis theorem. It has two consequences. First, because \(Md^2\) is never negative, \(I \ge I_{cm}\): the center of mass axis gives the smallest rotational inertia of any axis in that direction (Figure 5.6c). Second, once you know \(I_{cm}\), you can find \(I\) for any parallel axis without redoing the sum of \(mr^2\).
The theorem works because the center of mass is the balance point of the system: the pieces of mass on one side of it contribute cross terms that cancel the pieces on the other side. You do not need to prove it for this course, but you can check it on a small example.
Checking the theorem on a dumbbell
Take two 1.5 kg masses joined by a light rod, 0.80 m between them (Figure 5.6a). The center of mass is at the midpoint, 0.40 m from each, so about that axis
\[ I_{cm} = 2(1.5)(0.40)^2 = 0.48\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2. \]
Now move the axis to pass through one of the masses, a distance \(d = 0.40\) m away. Doing the sum directly, that mass is at \(r = 0\) and the other is 0.80 m away:
\[ I = (1.5)(0)^2 + (1.5)(0.80)^2 = 0.96\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2. \]
The theorem gives the same result with no new sum: \(I = I_{cm} + Md^2 = 0.48 + (3.0)(0.40)^2 = 0.48 + 0.48 = 0.96\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). Shifting the axis to the end doubled the rotational inertia, even though nothing about the dumbbell itself changed.
Figure 5.6a Parallel axis theorem: I = Icm + Md². The dumbbell has I = 0.48 kg·m² about its center. About an axis through one mass, 0.40 m away, only the other mass contributes, (1.5)(0.80)² = 0.96 kg·m², exactly the value the theorem gives. The center of mass axis always gives the smallest I.
Extended shapes: values from the exam
For rods, disks and hoops the rotational inertia about the center of mass axis is given on the exam. You should know how to use them, not memorize them, but it is useful to know the common ones: for a mass \(M\) and a length \(L\) or radius \(R\),
Shape
Axis
\(I\)
Thin hoop
through the center, perpendicular to the plane
\(MR^2\)
Solid disk or cylinder
through the center
\(\tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\)
Uniform thin rod
through the center, perpendicular to the rod
\(\tfrac{1}{12}ML^2\)
Uniform thin rod
through one end, perpendicular to the rod
\(\tfrac{1}{3}ML^2\)
The two rod values are connected by the parallel axis theorem, which is a good check of it. Moving the axis from the center of the rod to the end is a shift of \(d = L/2\), so
\[ I_{\text{end}} = \tfrac{1}{12}ML^2 + M\left(\tfrac{L}{2}\right)^2 = \tfrac{1}{12}ML^2 + \tfrac{1}{4}ML^2 = \tfrac{1}{3}ML^2. \]
For a rod with \(M = 2.0\) kg and \(L = 1.2\) m, that is 0.24 kg·m\(^2\) about the center and 0.96 kg·m\(^2\) about an end, four times as much (Figure 5.6b). A rod of a given length is thus four times as hard to spin up about its end as about its middle.
Figure 5.6b A uniform rod: I = (1/12)ML² about its center and (1/3)ML² about one end (values given on the exam). The end value is four times the center value, as the parallel axis theorem predicts, because the axis is moved a distance L/2.
Figure 5.6c plots the rod’s \(I\) against the position of a parallel axis. It is a parabola, \(I = 0.24 + 2.0\,d^2\), with its minimum at \(d = 0\) and the same value, 0.96, at both ends. A pivot at the center of mass is the easiest for the rod to turn around.
Figure 5.6c Rotational inertia as the axis is shifted along the rod. It is smallest when the axis passes through the center of mass (d = 0) and increases as d² as the axis moves away in either direction.
Worked example · a meter stick
A uniform meter stick has mass 0.20 kg. Find its rotational inertia about (a) a perpendicular axis through its center, (b) a perpendicular axis at one end and (c) a perpendicular axis 0.25 m from its center.
A uniform disk has mass 4.0 kg and radius 0.50 m. Find its rotational inertia about a perpendicular axis through the center and about a parallel axis at the rim.
Rim. \(d = R = 0.50\) m, so \(I = 0.50 + (4.0)(0.50)^2 = 0.50 + 1.0 = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), three times the center value.
Worked example · unequal masses
A 1.0 kg mass and a 3.0 kg mass are 1.0 m apart on a light rod. Find the rotational inertia about the axis through the center of mass, and about the axis through the 1.0 kg mass.
Center of mass. Measured from the 1.0 kg mass, \(x_{cm} = \dfrac{(1.0)(0) + (3.0)(1.0)}{4.0} = 0.75\) m.
About the center of mass. \(I_{cm} = (1.0)(0.75)^2 + (3.0)(0.25)^2 = 0.5625 + 0.1875 = 0.75\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\).
About the 1.0 kg mass. Directly, \(I = (3.0)(1.0)^2 = 3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). By the theorem, \(I = 0.75 + (4.0)(0.75)^2 = 0.75 + 2.25 = 3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). ✓
Exam focus
Only for parallel axes. \(I = I_{cm} + Md^2\) shifts an axis parallel to one through the center of mass. It does not connect two arbitrary axes.
\(M\) is the total mass and \(d\) is the distance between the two axes, not from either axis to some other point.
The center of mass axis is the minimum. Any other parallel axis gives a larger \(I\); the increase grows as \(d^2\).
Formulas for shapes are provided. Practice using the given \(I_{cm}\) and the theorem rather than memorizing.
Qualitative questions. Be ready to say what happens to \(I\) (and hence to \(\alpha\) for a given torque) when the pivot moves toward or away from the center of mass.
Practice
A uniform rod has mass 3.0 kg and length 0.60 m. Find \(I\) about an axis through one end perpendicular to the rod.
Show answer
For which axis, through the center of mass or through a point off center, will a given torque produce the larger angular acceleration, and why?
Show answer
The center of mass axis, because \(I\) is smallest there and \(\alpha = \tau/I\) (lesson 5.8).
A student says the rotational inertia about an axis 0.20 m from the center of mass equals \(I_{cm}\) plus the same amount whether the axis is to the left or the right. Is that right?
Show answer
Yes. The added term \(Md^2\) depends only on the distance \(d\), not on which side the axis is on.
Rotational equilibrium and Newton’s first law for rotation
A seesaw with two children of different weights can balance if the lighter child sits farther out. A shelf bracket holds a heavy load without turning. A diving board stays put while a diver stands at its tip. A ceiling fan, once it has reached its steady speed, keeps turning at that speed with almost no push. All these are examples of a net torque of zero: nothing is changing the rotation. This lesson develops the rotational version of Newton’s first law, shows how to use “net torque equals zero” to solve for unknown forces (a very common exam problem), and separates carefully the two kinds of equilibrium, translational and rotational, which are independent of each other.
Learning objective · 5.5.A
Describe the conditions under which a system’s angular velocity remains constant.
Required content · EK 5.5.A.1 and 5.5.A.2
A system may exhibit rotational equilibrium (constant angular velocity) without being in translational equilibrium, and vice versa.
Free-body and force diagrams describe the nature of the forces and torques exerted on an object or rigid system.
Rotational equilibrium is a configuration of torques such that the net torque exerted on the system is zero: \(\sum\tau = 0\).
The rotational analog of Newton’s first law is that a system will have a constant angular velocity only if the net torque exerted on the system is zero.
A rotational corollary to Newton’s second law states that if the torques exerted on a rigid system are not balanced, the system’s angular velocity must be changing.
Boundary statement from the CED
AP Physics 1 does not expect students to simultaneously analyze rotation in multiple planes.
Newton’s first law, rotational form
In Unit 2 an object keeps a constant velocity only if the net force on it is zero. Its rotational twin: a rigid system keeps a constant angular velocity only if the net torque on it is zero. Constant angular velocity includes \(\omega = 0\), a system not turning at all, and also any steady non-zero \(\omega\), such as a flywheel turning at a fixed rate. If the net torque is not zero, the angular velocity must change; the next lesson shows by how much.
The condition is \(\sum\tau = 0\), where each torque is measured about the same axis and signed by clockwise or counterclockwise. Because the sum is zero, the clockwise torques have the same total size as the counterclockwise torques. A seesaw balances when \(m_1 g\, r_1 = m_2 g\, r_2\): a 30 kg child 2.0 m from the pivot balances a 40 kg child 1.5 m from it, since \((30)(2.0) = (40)(1.5) = 60\) in the same units.
Rotational and translational equilibrium are independent
Translational equilibrium (\(\sum\vec{F} = 0\), so a constant velocity of the center of mass) and rotational equilibrium (\(\sum\tau = 0\), so a constant angular velocity) are separate conditions. A system can satisfy one without the other (Figure 5.7a).
Net force zero, net torque not zero. Two equal and opposite forces that do not lie along the same line, such as the two hands of a person turning a steering wheel. The center of mass does not accelerate, but the wheel spins faster.
Net torque zero, net force not zero. One force whose line of action passes through the center of mass, such as a push through the middle of a block on ice. The block accelerates but does not start to spin.
Both zero. A seesaw at rest. This is static equilibrium: nothing translates and nothing rotates.
Figure 5.7a Translational and rotational equilibrium are separate conditions. A pair of equal, opposite forces along different lines gives ΣF = 0 but Στ ≠ 0. A single force through the center of mass gives Στ = 0 but ΣF ≠ 0. A system can exhibit either without the other; only static equilibrium needs both.
So whenever a problem says an object is “in equilibrium” and at rest, you may use both \(\sum\vec{F} = 0\) (one equation for each direction) and \(\sum\tau = 0\). These give you the equations you need to find several unknown forces.
Choosing a good axis
If a system is in static equilibrium, the net torque is zero about every axis, not just a particular one. You are free to choose the axis for the torque equation, and a smart choice makes the problem easy: place the axis where an unknown force acts. That force has a lever arm of zero about that point, so it drops out of the equation. The standard strategy is therefore:
Draw a force diagram showing every force at its point of application.
Choose an axis at the point where the force you do not need acts.
Write \(\sum\tau = 0\) with signs, solving for the one remaining unknown.
Use \(\sum F_x = 0\) and \(\sum F_y = 0\) to find the rest.
Check by taking torques about a different axis.
The weight of a uniform object acts at its center, a single force equal to \(Mg\) applied there, which has the same torque as all the little weights of the pieces added up. For a uniform beam of length \(L\), the weight acts at \(L/2\).
A plank on two supports
Figure 5.7b shows a 4.0 m plank of weight 100 N resting on two supports at its ends, with a 500 N person standing 1.0 m from the left end. Choose the left support as the axis: the unknown \(F_L\) has a lever arm of zero and does not appear. The torques about that point are: the plank’s weight, 100 N at 2.0 m (clockwise); the person, 500 N at 1.0 m (clockwise); and the right support \(F_R\) at 4.0 m (counterclockwise). Setting the net to zero gives
\[ F_R(4.0) = (100)(2.0) + (500)(1.0) = 700 \quad\Rightarrow\quad F_R = 175\ \text{N}. \]
Then vertical forces: \(F_L + F_R = 100 + 500 = 600\ \text{N}\), so \(F_L = 600 - 175 = 425\) N. As a check, take torques about the right support: \(F_L(4.0) = (100)(2.0) + (500)(3.0) = 1700\), so \(F_L = 425\) N. ✓ The person stands closer to the left, so the left support carries more.
Figure 5.7b A force diagram for a plank in static equilibrium. Taking torques about the left support removes the unknown FL, giving FR = 175 N. Then ΣF = 0 gives FL = 600 − 175 = 425 N. The weight of a uniform plank acts at its center.
A beam held by a hinge and a cable
A more demanding case appears in Figure 5.7c: a uniform horizontal beam, weight 200 N, hinged to a wall at its left end and held level by a cable that makes \(30^\circ\) with the beam at its right end, which also carries a 400 N load. The hinge force is unknown in both size and direction, but if you choose the hinge as the axis, none of its components has a lever arm. Let \(L\) be the beam’s length. Only the vertical component of the tension, \(T\sin 30^\circ\), is perpendicular to the beam, so
\[ (T\sin 30^\circ)L = (200)\left(\tfrac{L}{2}\right) + (400)L = 500\,L \quad\Rightarrow\quad T = \frac{500}{0.50} = 1000\ \text{N}. \]
Notice that \(L\) cancels, so you did not need to know the length. The force equations then give the hinge: horizontally, the hinge force must balance \(T\cos 30^\circ = 866\) N, so it pushes outward with 866 N; vertically, \(V + T\sin 30^\circ = 600\), so \(V = 600 - 500 = 100\) N upward.
Figure 5.7c A hinged beam held by a cable. Choose the hinge as the pivot so the hinge force drops out of the torque equation: only the vertical part of the tension (T sin 30°) has a lever arm. This gives T = 1000 N; then the force equations give the hinge force components, 866 N horizontal and 100 N vertical.
Worked example · a balanced seesaw
A 30 kg child sits 2.0 m from the pivot of a light seesaw. Where must a 40 kg child sit on the other side to balance it?
Torque balance about the pivot. \((30)(10)(2.0) = (40)(10)\,x\), so \(x = \dfrac{600}{400} = 1.5\) m. (The factor \(g\) cancels, so only the masses matter.)
Support force. The pivot pushes up with \((30 + 40)(10) = 700\) N plus the seesaw’s own weight, if any.
Worked example · the balance point of a loaded stick
A uniform 1.0 m stick of mass 0.20 kg has a 0.50 kg mass attached at the 0.10 m mark. At what position should a pivot be placed so that the stick balances horizontally?
Set the torques about the pivot at position \(x\) equal. The mass (left of the pivot) gives \((0.50)(x - 0.10)\) and the stick’s weight, at 0.50 m, gives \((0.20)(0.50 - x)\): \(0.50x - 0.050 = 0.10 - 0.20x\).
Solve. \(0.70x = 0.15\), so \(x = 0.21\) m. (This is the center of mass of the system.)
Worked example · board and person
A uniform 20 kg board 2.0 m long rests on supports at its two ends. A 60 kg person stands 0.50 m from the right end. Find the force from each support.
Weights. The board: 200 N at the middle. The person: 600 N at 1.5 m from the left support.
Torques about the left support. \(F_R(2.0) = (200)(1.0) + (600)(1.5) = 1100\), so \(F_R = 550\) N.
Vertical forces. \(F_L = 800 - 550 = 250\) N. The person is closer to the right, which carries more.
Exam focus
Two independent conditions. \(\sum\vec{F} = 0\) and \(\sum\tau = 0\). Say which one (or both) applies to the situation.
Constant \(\omega\), not zero \(\omega\). \(\sum\tau = 0\) means constant angular velocity, which includes steady rotation, not only rest.
Pivot choice. Choose the point where the force you do not want acts, so it disappears from the equation.
Weight at the center. For a uniform object, the weight acts at the geometric center.
Unbalanced torque means changing \(\omega\). If a question gives unbalanced torques, the answer involves an angular acceleration, not equilibrium.
Practice
A 30 kg child sits 2.0 m from the pivot of a seesaw. How far from the pivot on the other side must a 40 kg child sit to balance?
Show answer
\((30)(2.0) = (40)x\), so \(x = 1.5\) m.
A uniform 1.0 m stick of mass 0.20 kg has a 0.50 kg mass at the 0.10 m mark. Where should it be pivoted to balance?
Show answer
A uniform 20 kg board 2.0 m long lies on supports at its ends. A 60 kg person stands 0.50 m from the right end. Find both support forces (use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\)).
Show answer
About the left end: \(F_R(2.0) = (200)(1.0) + (600)(1.5) = 1100\), so \(F_R = 550\) N and \(F_L = 800 - 550 = 250\) N.
A flywheel spins at a constant 50 rad/s with negligible friction. What is the net torque on it, and why?
Show answer
Zero. A constant angular velocity means \(\alpha = 0\), so by the rotational analog of Newton’s first law the net torque is zero.
Two equal and opposite forces act on a rod at different points along a line perpendicular to the rod. Is the rod in translational equilibrium? In rotational equilibrium?
Show answer
Translational: yes, \(\sum\vec{F} = 0\). Rotational: no. The forces do not share a line of action, so their torques about the center add rather than cancel (\(\sum\tau \ne 0\)), and the rod’s angular velocity will change.
In the beam and cable problem, why is the hinge the best point for the axis?
Show answer
The hinge force is unknown in size and direction. Taking torques about the hinge gives it a zero lever arm, so it drops out of the torque equation, leaving the tension as the only unknown.
Pull the cord of a toy top, and the top spins up faster the harder and longer you pull. A heavy flywheel is hard to start and hard to stop; a light one responds quickly. Apply the brakes to a spinning wheel and its angular velocity falls at a rate that depends on how hard the brake grips and on how much rotational inertia the wheel has. These observations summarize the rotational form of Newton’s second law: the angular acceleration of a rigid system is proportional to the net torque and inversely proportional to its rotational inertia. This is the core equation of the unit. It connects the torque of lesson 5.4 and the rotational inertia of lessons 5.5 and 5.6 to the angular kinematics of lessons 5.1 and 5.2.
Learning objective · 5.6.A
Describe the conditions under which a system’s angular velocity changes.
Required content · EK 5.6.A.1 and 5.6.A.2
Angular velocity changes when the net torque exerted on the object or system is not equal to zero.
The rate at which the angular velocity of a rigid system changes is directly proportional to the net torque exerted on the rigid system and is in the same direction. The angular acceleration of the rigid system is inversely proportional to the rotational inertia of the rigid system: \(\alpha = \sum\tau/I\).
The law
For a rigid system turning about a fixed axis,
\[ \alpha = \frac{\sum\tau}{I} \qquad\text{or}\qquad \sum\tau = I\alpha. \]
Compare it with \(\vec{a} = \sum\vec{F}/m\): the net torque takes the place of the net force, the rotational inertia takes the place of mass and the angular acceleration takes the place of acceleration. The angular acceleration has the same sign as the net torque, so a net counterclockwise torque speeds up a counterclockwise rotation (or slows down a clockwise one). When the net torque is zero, \(\alpha = 0\) and the angular velocity stays constant, which is the rotational first law of lesson 5.7.
The two proportionalities are the content of the law (Figure 5.8a):
At a fixed rotational inertia, doubling the net torque doubles \(\alpha\) (direct proportionality).
At a fixed net torque, doubling the rotational inertia halves \(\alpha\) (inverse proportionality).
On an \(\alpha\)–\(\tau\) graph, the data fall on a straight line through the origin whose slope is \(1/I\). That is how a laboratory experiment finds the rotational inertia of an unknown wheel: apply a series of known torques (for example with a hanging mass on a string around a pulley), measure the resulting angular accelerations, and take the slope of the line. A smaller slope means a larger rotational inertia.
Figure 5.8a Angular acceleration is directly proportional to net torque and inversely proportional to rotational inertia. On an α–τ graph the slope is 1/I, so a system with twice the rotational inertia gives half the slope. Measuring the slope is how an experiment finds I.
Where the law comes from
The law is just Newton’s second law applied to every piece of the rigid system at once. Consider one small mass \(m\) at a distance \(r\) from the axis. A tangential force \(F\) on it gives \(F = m a_t = m r\alpha\). Multiply by \(r\) to get its torque:
\[ \tau = rF = (mr^2)\alpha. \]
The quantity in the brackets is the rotational inertia of that mass. For a whole rigid system, all the pieces share the same \(\alpha\), and the torques and the inertias \(m_i r_i^2\) add, giving \(\sum\tau = (\sum m_i r_i^2)\alpha = I\alpha\). This is why rotational inertia is defined with \(r^2\): it is exactly the factor that makes the law work.
Using the law
A typical rotational dynamics problem has the same shape as a Unit 2 problem:
Choose the axis (the pivot or the axle) and a sign convention.
Draw a force diagram and find the torque of each force about that axis, using \(\tau = rF\sin\theta\).
Add the torques with signs to get \(\sum\tau\).
Find \(I\) about that same axis (sum of \(m r^2\), or a given value with the parallel axis theorem).
Find \(\alpha = \sum\tau/I\). Then use rotational kinematics (lesson 5.2) or \(a_t = r\alpha\) (lesson 5.3) for anything else.
In Figure 5.8b a string wound around a wheel of radius 0.10 m is pulled with a steady 12 N force. The torque is \(RF = (0.10)(12) = 1.2\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), and with \(I = 0.060\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), \(\alpha = 1.2/0.060 = 20\ \text{rad/s}^2\). The string, if it does not slip, unwinds at the rim speed \(v = R\omega\), so the string accelerates at \(a = R\alpha = 2.0\ \text{m/s}^2\).
Figure 5.8b Newton’s second law for rotation, Στ = Iα. A tangential string pull F at the rim makes a torque RF. For a wheel with I = 0.060 kg·m² the 12 N pull gives α = 1.2/0.060 = 20 rad/s².
A word about direction: the torque points the same way as the angular acceleration. In practice you only need to think clockwise or counterclockwise. If the net torque is opposite to the current rotation, the system slows down, and it may stop and then reverse unless the torque goes away.
Worked example · a disk and a constant torque
A uniform disk (\(M = 4.0\) kg, \(R = 0.50\) m) at rest is acted on by a constant net torque of 5.0 N·m. Find \(\alpha\) and its angular velocity after 3.0 s.
A flywheel with \(I = 2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) turns at 40 rad/s. A brake pad presses on the rim (radius 0.25 m) with a friction force of 20 N. How long does the flywheel take to stop, and through what angle does it turn?
Torque. The friction is tangential, so \(\tau = rF = (0.25)(20) = 5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), opposite to the rotation: \(\tau = -5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\).
A constant net torque of 6.0 N·m acts for 2.0 s on a rotor with \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), starting from rest. Find the final angular velocity.
Show answer
An experiment applies several known torques to a wheel and measures \(\alpha\) each time, getting a line on an \(\alpha\)–\(\tau\) graph with a slope of 4.0 rad/s\(^2\) per N·m. What is the rotational inertia?
Show answer
The slope is \(1/I\), so \(I = 1/4.0 = 0.25\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\).
Many real machines combine moving and turning parts: a bucket lowered on a rope from a well windlass, an elevator counterweight over a heavy pulley, a yo-yo, a crane lifting a load from a spinning drum. In each, some parts translate and others rotate, and they are tied together by a rope or string. You cannot describe the whole machine with a single equation, because Newton’s second law for translation says nothing about the pulley’s spin, and the rotational law says nothing about the block’s motion. The CED states the strategy plainly: to fully describe a rotating rigid system, linear and rotational analyses may need to be performed independently. This lesson shows how to do that systematically and how to join the two analyses with the link \(a = R\alpha\) that a string provides.
Learning objective · 5.6.A
Describe the conditions under which a system’s angular velocity changes.
Required content · EK 5.6.A.3
To fully describe a rotating rigid system, linear and rotational analyses may need to be performed independently.
One system, two kinds of equations
For each part of the machine, ask what it does:
An object that only translates (a hanging block) obeys \(\sum F = ma\), with its own free-body diagram.
A rigid system that only rotates about a fixed axle (a pulley) obeys \(\sum\tau = I\alpha\), with a force diagram showing where the forces act. Its own weight and the axle force pass through the axis, so they have no torque.
A connection (a string that does not slip and does not stretch) ties the two together: the string’s speed and acceleration equal the rim’s tangential speed and acceleration, \(v = R\omega\) and \(a = R\alpha\).
The procedure is to write one equation for each unknown: Newton’s second law for every translating object, \(\sum\tau = I\alpha\) for every rotating system, and one link equation \(a = R\alpha\) for every string over a pulley. Then solve the set. The key realization, and the one students most often miss, is that a pulley with mass makes the tension different on the two sides of it. A massless pulley (or a frictionless one with negligible inertia) has the same tension on both sides because no net torque is needed to turn it. A massive pulley needs a net torque to accelerate, and that torque comes from the difference of the string tensions.
A block hanging from a pulley
A 1.5 kg block hangs from a string wrapped around a uniform disk pulley of mass \(M = 2.0\) kg and radius \(R = 0.10\) m (Figure 5.9a), and is released. Take \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\). The pulley is a disk, so \(I = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\).
Block (down is positive): \(mg - T = ma\).
Pulley: the string exerts the only torque, \(\tau = TR\): \(TR = I\alpha = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\,\alpha\).
Link: \(\alpha = a/R\).
Substitute the link into the pulley equation: \(TR = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2(a/R) = \tfrac{1}{2}MRa\), so \(T = \tfrac{1}{2}Ma\). The radius canceled. Put that into the block’s equation: \(mg - \tfrac{1}{2}Ma = ma\), so
\[ a = \frac{mg}{m + \tfrac{1}{2}M} = \frac{(1.5)(10)}{1.5 + 1.0} = 6.0\ \text{m/s}^2. \]
Then \(T = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(6.0) = 6.0\) N and \(\alpha = a/R = 6.0/0.10 = 60\ \text{rad/s}^2\). Check: \(mg - T = 15 - 6.0 = 9.0\ \text{N} = ma = (1.5)(6.0)\). ✓
Figure 5.9a A hanging block unwinds a string from a disk pulley (R = 0.10 m). Newton’s second law for the block, the rotational second law for the pulley and the link a = Rα give three equations for T, a and α. Here a = 6.0 m/s², less than g = 10 m/s² because the pulley must be spun up too.
Three sanity checks are worth making every time. The acceleration is less than \(g\), because part of the weight’s effect goes into spinning the pulley. The tension (6.0 N) is less than the weight (15 N), as it must be for the block to accelerate downward. And if the pulley mass \(M\) goes to zero, the formula gives \(a = g\), the free fall of a block that has nothing to spin up.
An Atwood machine with a massive pulley
Now hang a 3.0 kg block and a 1.0 kg block on opposite sides of a 2.0 kg disk pulley (Figure 5.9b). Let the heavier block go down. Each block has its own Newton’s second law equation, and the pulley now has two string forces on it that produce opposite torques:
Adding the two block equations gives \((m_1 - m_2)g - (T_1 - T_2) = (m_1 + m_2)a\); substituting the pulley result,
\[ a = \frac{(m_1 - m_2)g}{m_1 + m_2 + \tfrac{1}{2}M} = \frac{(3.0 - 1.0)(10)}{3.0 + 1.0 + 1.0} = 4.0\ \text{m/s}^2. \]
Then \(T_1 = m_1(g - a) = 3.0(10 - 4.0) = 18\) N and \(T_2 = m_2(g + a) = 1.0(10 + 4.0) = 14\) N. The tensions differ by 4.0 N, and \((T_1 - T_2)R = \tfrac{1}{2}MRa\) checks: \(4.0 = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(4.0)\). ✓ Had the pulley been massless, the acceleration would have been \((3.0 - 1.0)(10)/4.0 = 5.0\ \text{m/s}^2\) and the tensions both 15 N.
Figure 5.9b With a massive pulley the two string tensions are not equal. The difference provides the net torque that spins the pulley: (T1 − T2)R = Iα. Here T1 = 18 N, T2 = 14 N, and a = 4.0 m/s² (a pulley of negligible mass would give T1 = T2).
Notice that \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\) is used throughout this course, in line with the exam, and that the answers come out as round numbers because the problem was designed that way. On the exam you may be asked to derive an expression, such as \(a\) in terms of \(m\), \(M\) and \(g\), rather than a number; the same three equations apply, and the work is the same.
Worked example · a heavier pulley
A 2.0 kg block hangs from a string over a disk pulley with \(M = 4.0\) kg and \(R = 0.20\) m. Find \(a\), \(T\) and \(\alpha\).
If the pulley in problem 1 is replaced by one of the same radius but twice the mass, what happens to the block’s acceleration and to the tension?
Show answer
The acceleration falls to \(20/6.0 = 3.3\ \text{m/s}^2\) and the tension rises to \(\tfrac{1}{2}(8.0)(3.33) = 13\) N.
A 4.0 kg block and a 2.0 kg block hang over a disk pulley with \(M = 4.0\) kg. Find the acceleration and the tensions.
Show answer
Why are the tensions on the two sides of a massive pulley different when the blocks accelerate?
Show answer
The pulley has rotational inertia and is angularly accelerating, so the net torque on it is not zero. The only torques come from the two string forces, so they must differ: \((T_1 - T_2)R = I\alpha\).
In the block and pulley problem, what limit does \(a = mg/(m + \tfrac{1}{2}M)\) approach when the pulley mass is very large? What does that mean physically?
Show answer
\(a \to 0\). A pulley with a huge rotational inertia is almost impossible to spin up, so the block hardly accelerates.
Suppose some friction at the axle opposes the pulley’s rotation. How does the block’s acceleration compare with the frictionless case?
Show answer
It is smaller. Friction adds a torque against the rotation, so the string must supply more torque to give the same \(\alpha\), which means a larger tension and a smaller net force on the block.
Unit 5 practice · 10 problems
Unit 5 practice: Torque and Rotational Dynamics
Ten problems covering the whole unit. Keep every angular speed in
radians per second inside an equation, and always say which pivot you
chose. Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\).
A wheel starts from rest and reaches 1200 rpm in 5.0 s with constant angular acceleration. Find \(\alpha\) and the number of revolutions during the spin-up.
A turntable spinning at 40 rad/s is switched off and slows at 4.0 rad/s². Through what angle does it turn before stopping, and how long does that take?
A wheel of radius 0.40 m turns at 15 rad/s. Point P is on the rim; point Q is 0.20 m from the axle. Find the speed and centripetal acceleration of each point, and state which of \(\omega\), \(v\), and \(a_c\) the two points share.
Show answer
Both points share \(\omega = 15\) rad/s (the whole wheel turns together). \(v = r\omega\): P: \((0.40)(15) = 6.0\) m/s; Q: \((0.20)(15) = 3.0\) m/s. \(a_c = r\omega^2\): P: \((0.40)(15)^2 = 90\) m/s²; Q: \((0.20)(225) = 45\) m/s². Speed and centripetal acceleration both scale with \(r\); only \(\omega\) is shared.
A door is 0.80 m wide. Find the torque about the hinges when you push at the outer edge with 25 N (a) perpendicular to the door, (b) at 45° to the door's surface, (c) directly toward the hinges along the door.
Show answer
\(\tau = rF\sin\theta\). (a) \((0.80)(25)\sin 90^\circ = 20\) N·m. (b) \((0.80)(25)\sin 45^\circ = 14\) N·m: only the perpendicular component of the push counts. (c) \(\theta = 0\), so \(\tau = 0\): a force along the line through the pivot has no lever arm and cannot rotate the door.
Which change, made alone, doubles the torque a person exerts on a wrench?
Torque is \(\tau = r_\perp F = rF\sin\theta\), so with \(r\) and the 90° angle fixed, doubling \(F\) doubles \(\tau\). Everything else in the expression is unchanged.
Torque is proportional to the lever arm, so halving the distance from the bolt halves the torque. Moving the hand closer to the pivot does the opposite of what a longer wrench does.
Only the perpendicular component of the force, \(F\sin\theta\), produces torque, and \(\sin 30^\circ = 0.5\), so this halves the torque instead of doubling it. Perpendicular (90°) is already the most effective angle.
A force directed along the handle toward the bolt passes straight through the pivot, so its lever arm is zero and it produces no torque at all. It pushes on the bolt but does not turn it.
Two 2.0 kg point masses sit at the ends of a light 1.0 m rod. Find the rotational inertia about the rod's center and about one end, and verify the end value with the parallel axis theorem. Explain in a sentence why they differ.
Show answer
\(I = \sum m_i r_i^2\). Center: each mass is 0.50 m away, \(I = 2(2.0)(0.50)^2 = 1.0\) kg·m². End: one mass at \(r = 0\), the other at 1.0 m, \(I = (2.0)(0)^2 + (2.0)(1.0)^2 = 2.0\) kg·m². Parallel axis check: \(I = I_{cm} + Md^2 = 1.0 + (4.0)(0.50)^2 = 2.0\) kg·m² ✓. Distance enters squared, so moving one mass from 0.50 m to 1.0 m adds more than moving the other from 0.50 m to 0 removes.
A hoop, a solid disk, and a solid sphere have the same mass \(M\) and radius \(R\). Rank their rotational inertias about their centers from largest to smallest, and explain the ranking in words without formulas.
Show answer
Hoop \(\gt\) disk \(\gt\) sphere: \(MR^2 \gt \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2 \gt \tfrac{2}{5}MR^2\). Rotational inertia counts each bit of mass by the square of its distance from the axis. The hoop keeps all its mass at the full radius \(R\). The disk spreads mass from the center outward, so much of it sits at small \(r\). The sphere goes further (its mass is spread in three dimensions, and slices near the poles are close to the axis), so its average \(r^2\) is smallest of the three.
A uniform 3.0 m plank of mass 20 kg rests on supports at both ends. A 60 kg person stands 1.0 m from the left end. Find the upward force from each support.
Show answer
Weights: plank \(200\) N at its center (1.5 m), person \(600\) N at 1.0 m. Pivot at the left support so \(F_L\) drops out; counterclockwise positive: \(\sum\tau = F_R(3.0) - (200)(1.5) - (600)(1.0) = 0 \Rightarrow F_R = \dfrac{300 + 600}{3.0} = 300\) N. Forces: \(F_L + F_R = 800\) N, so \(F_L = 500\) N. Check about the right end: \(F_L(3.0) = 200(1.5) + 600(2.0) = 1500 \Rightarrow F_L = 500\) N ✓. The support nearer the person carries more.
A 3.0 kg block hangs from a light string wrapped around a solid-disk pulley of mass 2.0 kg and radius 0.20 m on a frictionless axle. The system is released from rest. Find the block's acceleration, the tension, and the pulley's angular acceleration.
Show answer
Block: \(mg - T = ma\). Pulley: \(TR = I\alpha = \left(\tfrac{1}{2}MR^2\right)\dfrac{a}{R} \Rightarrow T = \tfrac{1}{2}Ma\). Combine: \(mg = \left(m + \tfrac{1}{2}M\right)a \Rightarrow a = \dfrac{(3.0)(10)}{3.0 + 1.0} = 7.5\) m/s². \(T = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(7.5) = 7.5\) N (less than the 30 N weight, as it must be). \(\alpha = \dfrac{a}{R} = \dfrac{7.5}{0.20} = 38\) rad/s².
Experimental design. A wheel of unknown rotational inertia spins on a low-friction axle. You have string, a set of hanging masses, a meterstick, and a motion sensor that records the falling mass's position versus time. Design a procedure to determine the wheel's rotational inertia, including the graph you would plot.
Show answer
Wrap the string around a hub of measured radius \(R\), hang a known mass \(m\), release from rest, and use the sensor to find the mass's acceleration \(a\) (from the slope of \(v\)–\(t\) or a fit to \(x\)–\(t\)). For the mass, \(mg - T = ma\) gives \(T = m(g - a)\). The torque on the wheel is \(\tau = TR\) and its angular acceleration is \(\alpha = a/R\). Repeat for several hanging masses and plot \(\tau\) (vertical) against \(\alpha\) (horizontal): since \(\tau = I\alpha\), the slope of the best-fit line is \(I\). A nonzero intercept would reveal a frictional torque at the axle. Keeping the string taut and vertical, and using a low-mass string, keeps the model valid.
A spinning bicycle wheel stores energy: it can lift a weight through a dynamo, heat a brake pad, or keep a flywheel-powered toy running across the floor. A hard-drive platter, a washing machine drum and a spinning planet all hold energy because their parts are in motion, even when their center of mass does not move at all. In Unit 3 you learned that the kinetic energy of an object is \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\). That formula does not tell you anything about a wheel turning in place, since its center of mass is at rest and \(v_{cm} = 0\). This lesson extends the energy ideas of Unit 3 to rotation by adding up the kinetic energy of all the moving points of a rigid system. The result looks like \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\) with the rotational twins of mass and speed.
Learning objective · 6.1.A
Describe the rotational kinetic energy of a rigid system in terms of the rotational inertia and angular velocity of that rigid system.
Required content · EK 6.1.A.1 to 6.1.A.3
The rotational kinetic energy of an object or rigid system is related to the rotational inertia and angular velocity of the rigid system and is given by the equation \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\).
The rotational inertia of an object about a fixed axis can be used to show that the rotational kinetic energy of that object is equivalent to its translational kinetic energy, which is its total kinetic energy.
The total kinetic energy of a rigid system is the sum of its rotational kinetic energy due to its rotation about its center of mass and the translational kinetic energy due to the linear motion of its center of mass.
A rigid system can have rotational kinetic energy while its center of mass is at rest due to the individual points within the rigid system having linear speed and, therefore, kinetic energy.
Rotational kinetic energy is a scalar quantity.
From \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\) to \(\tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\)
Take a rigid system made of small pieces of mass \(m_1, m_2, \dots\) at distances \(r_1, r_2, \dots\) from a fixed axis. As the system turns at angular velocity \(\omega\), piece \(i\) moves in a circle at speed \(v_i = r_i\omega\) (lesson 5.3). Its kinetic energy is \(\tfrac{1}{2}m_i v_i^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}m_i r_i^2\omega^2\). The kinetic energy of the whole system is the sum:
\[ K = \sum_i \tfrac{1}{2}m_i r_i^2\omega^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}\Big(\sum_i m_i r_i^2\Big)\omega^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2. \]
The quantity in brackets is the rotational inertia \(I\) of lesson 5.5, and \(\omega\) is the same for every piece, so it comes out of the sum. This is the content of the CED statement that the rotational kinetic energy is equivalent to the translational kinetic energy of all the pieces. It is not a new kind of energy; it is the same kinetic energy, bookkept with the angular description that suits a rigid system. Compare \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\): mass is replaced by rotational inertia and speed by angular velocity.
Figure 6.1a shows the idea on a dumbbell. Two 1.5 kg masses at 0.40 m from the axis turn at \(\omega = 10\) rad/s, so each moves at \(v = r\omega = 4.0\) m/s and has \(\tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(4.0)^2 = 12\) J. The total, 24 J, matches \(\tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\) with \(I = 2(1.5)(0.40)^2 = 0.48\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). The dumbbell’s center of mass is at rest, yet the system has 24 J of kinetic energy, because the individual points have speed (EK 6.1.A.2).
Figure 6.1a Rotational kinetic energy is just the kinetic energy of the moving points added up. The center of mass of this dumbbell is at rest, yet its two masses move, so the system has K = 24 J. Writing each speed as rω gives K = Σ½mi(riω)² = ½(Σmiri²)ω² = ½Iω².
How the energy depends on the variables
The formula \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\) says that the energy of a rotating system grows in proportion to its rotational inertia and as the square of its angular velocity (Figure 6.1b). Double \(\omega\) and you quadruple the energy; double \(I\) at the same \(\omega\) and you double it. Two systems turning at the same \(\omega\) can store very different amounts of energy if their rotational inertias differ. A hoop has twice the rotational inertia of a disk of the same mass and radius, so at the same angular velocity it holds twice the kinetic energy.
Figure 6.1b Rotational kinetic energy grows as the square of the angular velocity and in direct proportion to the rotational inertia, just as translational K grows as v² and m. Doubling ω multiplies K by 4; doubling I at fixed ω doubles K.
Rotational kinetic energy is a scalar, like all energies. It has no direction, and it is never negative. A wheel turning clockwise at 10 rad/s and an identical wheel turning counterclockwise at 10 rad/s have exactly the same kinetic energy: \(\omega^2\) removes the sign. This is different from angular momentum, which depends on the sense of rotation (lesson 6.3).
Translation plus rotation
Many systems both move and rotate: a rolling wheel, a spinning baseball flying through the air, a tumbling gymnast. The kinetic energy of a rigid system is the sum of the energy of its overall motion and the energy of its rotation about its center of mass:
\[ K_{\text{tot}} = K_{\text{trans}} + K_{\text{rot}} = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}I_{cm}\omega^2. \]
The two terms are separate bookkeeping entries. A system can have one without the other, as the dumbbell (only \(K_{rot}\)) and a sliding block (only \(K_{trans}\)) show. Figure 6.1c shows a 2.0 kg disk of radius 0.20 m that moves at 3.0 m/s while spinning at 15 rad/s. Its rotational inertia is \(I = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2 = 0.040\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), so \(K_{trans} = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(3.0)^2 = 9.0\) J and \(K_{rot} = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.040)(15)^2 = 4.5\) J, giving a total of 13.5 J.
Figure 6.1c A rigid system that moves and spins has two kinds of kinetic energy. Ktrans = ½Mvcm² = ½(2.0)(3.0)² = 9.0 J and Krot = ½Iω² = ½(0.040)(15)² = 4.5 J, with I = ½MR² = 0.040 kg·m². The total is the sum, 13.5 J. Both are scalars and both are positive.
The work–energy theorem of Unit 3 carries over unchanged: the total work done on the system by external forces equals the change in the total kinetic energy, \(W_{\text{net}} = \Delta K_{\text{tot}}\), and energy bar charts for such a system now have separate bars for translational and rotational kinetic energy. The next lesson shows how torques do work and add to \(K_{rot}\).
Worked example · a spinning disk
A uniform disk of mass 4.0 kg and radius 0.50 m spins about its center at 20 rad/s. How much kinetic energy does it have? What if the same disk spins at 40 rad/s?
Energies. Hoop: \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.18)(12)^2 = 13\) J. Disk: \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.090)(12)^2 = 6.5\) J. The hoop has twice as much, in the ratio of the rotational inertias.
Worked example · the angular velocity from the energy
A flywheel with \(I = 1.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) stores 50 J of rotational kinetic energy. How fast is it turning?
Same energy, new bookkeeping. \(K_{rot}\) is the total kinetic energy of the individual moving points. An object can have it with its center of mass at rest.
Radians per second. \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\) needs \(\omega\) in rad/s. Convert rpm first.
\(\omega^2\), not \(\omega\). Doubling \(\omega\) quadruples \(K\); a common error is to double it.
Add, do not mix. \(K_{tot} = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\). The first term uses the speed of the center of mass; the second uses the angular velocity about it.
Scalar. No direction and no sign. Clockwise and counterclockwise rotations have the same \(K\).
Practice
A wheel has \(I = 0.30\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) and \(\omega = 10\) rad/s. Find \(K\).
Show answer
\(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.30)(10)^2 = 15\) J.
The wheel in problem 1 speeds up to 20 rad/s. By what factor does its kinetic energy change, and what is the new value?
Show answer
\(\omega\) doubles, so \(K\) is multiplied by 4: \(K = 60\) J.
A rotor with \(I = 2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) has 400 J of kinetic energy. Find \(\omega\).
Show answer
A 3.0 kg uniform disk of radius 0.20 m rolls and slides along a table at 2.0 m/s while spinning at 10 rad/s. Find its total kinetic energy.
Show answer
\(K_{trans} = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(2.0)^2 = 6.0\) J. \(I = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(0.20)^2 = 0.060\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), so \(K_{rot} = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.060)(10)^2 = 3.0\) J. Total: 9.0 J.
A dumbbell turns about its center. Its center of mass is at rest. Explain why it nonetheless has kinetic energy.
Show answer
Its individual masses move in circles and each has speed \(v = r\omega\), so each has \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\). The sum of these is \(\tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\), nonzero even though \(v_{cm} = 0\).
A clockwise-spinning wheel and a counterclockwise-spinning wheel are identical and turn at the same rate. Compare their kinetic energies.
Show answer
Equal. Kinetic energy is a scalar and depends on \(\omega^2\), so the direction of rotation does not matter.
A person cranks a winch, a motor spins up a drill chuck, and a brake pad grips a flywheel. In each case energy moves into or out of a rotating system, and the agent that carries it is a torque acting while the system turns. In Unit 3 you saw that a force transfers energy to an object when it acts through a displacement, and that the work is the area under an F–x graph. This lesson builds the rotational counterpart: a torque does work when it acts through an angular displacement, the work is \(\tau\,\Delta\theta\), and the area under a \(\tau\)–\(\theta\) graph gives it. The rotational work–energy theorem then ties it to \(K_{rot}\) of lesson 6.1.
Learning objective · 6.2.A
Describe the work done on a rigid system by a given torque or collection of torques.
Required content · EK 6.2.A.1 to 6.2.A.3
A torque can transfer energy into or out of an object or rigid system if the torque is exerted over an angular displacement.
The amount of work done on a rigid system by a torque is related to the magnitude of that torque and the angular displacement through which the rigid system rotates during the interval in which that torque is exerted: \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta\).
Work done on a rigid system by a given torque can be found from the area under the curve of a graph of torque as a function of angular position.
Work equals torque times angle
For a constant torque acting along the direction of the rotation, the work done on a rigid system is
\[ W = \tau\,\Delta\theta, \]
with \(\tau\) in N·m and \(\Delta\theta\) in radians, so that \(W\) comes out in joules. (N·m is the unit for torque and J for work and energy; the radian is dimensionless, which is why the product is a joule.) It resembles \(W = F\,\Delta x\), with torque in place of force and angular displacement in place of displacement. The sign follows the usual rule: positive work when the torque has the same sense as the rotation (it speeds the system up), negative work when it opposes the rotation (it slows the system down), and zero when there is no angular displacement. Holding a wheel still against a torque is no work at all, and a torque acting on a system that does not turn does none.
The rotational formula is not a new law. It is the usual \(W = Fs\) in disguise. Figure 6.2a shows a 12 N force pulling a string that unwinds 3.0 m from a wheel of radius 0.10 m. The work by the force is \(Fs = (12)(3.0) = 36\) J. In angular terms the wheel turns through \(\Delta\theta = s/R = 30\) rad under a torque \(\tau = RF = 1.2\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), and \(\tau\,\Delta\theta = (1.2)(30) = 36\) J: the same energy, counted two ways.
Figure 6.2a Two ways to count the same energy. The pulling force does W = Fs = 36 J through the 3.0 m of string. The same 36 J equals τΔθ = (1.2)(30), since τ = RF and Δθ = s/R. The wheel gains 36 J of rotational kinetic energy if nothing else does work on it.
Variable torque: area under the graph
When the torque changes during the rotation, the work is the area under the torque–angular position graph (Figure 6.2b), exactly as for a variable force. In the figure a torque grows linearly from 0 to 6.0 N·m over the first 2.0 rad, then stays at 6.0 N·m for a further 2.0 rad. The triangle has area \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(6.0) = 6.0\) J and the rectangle \((2.0)(6.0) = 12\) J, a total of 18 J transferred to the system. Break the area into triangles, rectangles and trapezoids; areas below the axis count as negative work.
Figure 6.2b Work done by a torque. For a constant torque, W = τΔθ. When the torque varies, the work is the area under the τ–θ graph, just as work by a variable force is the area under an F–x graph. Here 6.0 J + 12 J = 18 J is transferred to the system.
Work and rotational kinetic energy
Work is the transfer of energy, so the net work done by all the torques on a rigid system equals the change in its rotational kinetic energy:
\[ W_{\text{net}} = \sum\tau\,\Delta\theta = \Delta K_{rot} = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2 - \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega_0^2. \]
You can verify that this agrees with the kinematics of Unit 5. For constant net torque, \(\alpha = \tau/I\) and \(\omega^2 = \omega_0^2 + 2\alpha\,\Delta\theta\) give \(\tfrac{1}{2}I(\omega^2 - \omega_0^2) = I\alpha\,\Delta\theta = \tau\,\Delta\theta\). The energy approach is the quickest route when you are told the angle and want the final angular velocity, and it avoids finding \(\alpha\) and the time. It is also the best tool when the torque is not constant, since you only need the area.
Systems that translate and rotate follow the same rule with both kinds of kinetic energy: net work equals the change in \(K_{trans} + K_{rot}\). Friction at a slipping contact (lesson 6.7) and the dissipative forces of Unit 3 remove energy as before.
Worked example · a motor spins a disk
A motor exerts a constant net torque of 5.0 N·m on a disk with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), starting from rest, while the disk turns through 4.0 rad. Find the work done and the final angular velocity.
Work. \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta = (5.0)(4.0) = 20\) J.
Final angular velocity. \(W = \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\), so \(\omega = \sqrt{2W/I} = \sqrt{2(20)/0.50} = 8.9\) rad/s.
Check by kinematics. \(\alpha = \tau/I = 10\ \text{rad/s}^2\), and \(\omega^2 = 2\alpha\,\Delta\theta = 80\), so \(\omega = 8.9\) rad/s. ✓
Worked example · a brake
A flywheel with \(I = 2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) turns at 40 rad/s. A brake pad presses on its rim (radius 0.25 m) with a friction force of 20 N. Through what angle does the flywheel turn before it stops?
Energy to remove. \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(40)^2 = 1600\) J.
Torque. \(\tau = RF = (0.25)(20) = 5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), opposite to the rotation, so the work is negative: \(W = -\tau\,\Delta\theta\).
Set the net work equal to the change in energy. \(-(5.0)\Delta\theta = 0 - 1600\), so \(\Delta\theta = 320\) rad, about 51 revolutions. (This is the same as the result of lesson 5.8, found without the time.)
Worked example · a varying torque
A torque of 3.0 N·m is applied from \(\theta = 0\) to 2.0 rad, then decreases linearly to zero at \(\theta = 4.0\) rad. What is the work done?
Rectangle. \((3.0)(2.0) = 6.0\) J.
Triangle. \(\tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(2.0) = 3.0\) J.
Total. \(W = 9.0\) J.
Exam focus
Two words, one idea. Work by a force through a distance and work by a torque through an angle are the same energy transfer; use whichever form the data suits.
Radians. \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta\) gives joules only if \(\Delta\theta\) is in radians.
Sign of the work. A torque opposing the rotation does negative work and lowers \(K_{rot}\).
Graph. Work is the area under a \(\tau\)–\(\theta\) graph. (Not under a \(\tau\)–\(t\) graph; that area is angular impulse, lesson 6.4.)
Energy shortcut. When given an angle (not a time), use \(W_{net} = \Delta K\) rather than finding \(\alpha\).
Practice
A constant torque of 4.0 N·m acts through 5.0 rad. How much work does it do?
Show answer
\(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta = (4.0)(5.0) = 20\) J.
A wheel with \(I = 0.40\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), starting from rest, receives 20 J of work from a torque. What is its angular velocity?
Show answer
A torque is constant at 3.0 N·m from 0 to 2.0 rad and then falls linearly to zero at 4.0 rad. Find the work.
Show answer
\((3.0)(2.0) + \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(2.0) = 6.0 + 3.0 = 9.0\) J.
A 15 N force acts tangentially at the rim of a 0.20 m radius wheel while the wheel turns through 2.0 revolutions. Find the torque and the work.
Show answer
You hold a heavy wheel at rest against a torque of 10 N·m. How much work does the torque do?
Show answer
Zero. The wheel has no angular displacement, so \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta = 0\).
A friction torque slows a wheel down. Is the work done by that torque positive or negative, and what happens to the wheel’s energy?
Show answer
Negative, because the torque opposes the rotation. The wheel’s rotational kinetic energy decreases by that amount, and the energy is dissipated as thermal energy.
A gyroscope keeps pointing in the same direction, a spinning top resists being knocked over, and a spinning football flies more steadily than a tumbling one. A figure skater who has begun to turn keeps turning, and the harder it is to start a wheel spinning the harder it is to stop it. All of this points to a rotational twin of momentum: a quantity that measures how much rotational motion a system has and that, like linear momentum, is conserved under the right conditions. That quantity is angular momentum. This lesson defines it for rigid systems and for a single object moving in a straight line, and the next two lessons show how it changes and when it is conserved.
Learning objective · 6.3.A
Describe the angular momentum of an object or rigid system.
Required content · EK 6.3.A.1 and 6.3.A.2
The magnitude of the angular momentum of a rigid system about a specific axis can be described with the equation \(L = I\omega\).
The magnitude of the angular momentum of an object about a given point is \(L = mvr\sin\theta\) (written in terms of the mass, speed, and distance from the point, with \(\theta\) the angle between the radial distance and the velocity).
The selection of the axis about which an object is considered to rotate influences the determination of the angular momentum of that object.
The measured angular momentum of an object traveling in a straight line depends on the distance between the reference point and the object, the mass of the object, the speed of the object, and the angle between the radial distance and the velocity of the object.
Boundary statement from the CED
While AP Physics 1 expects that students can mathematically manipulate the magnitude of angular momentum using one-dimensional vector conventions, the direction of angular momentum and angular impulse is beyond the scope of the course.
A rigid system: \(L = I\omega\)
The angular momentum of a rigid system about its axis of rotation is the product of its rotational inertia and angular velocity:
\[ L = I\omega. \]
The SI unit is \(\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\). Compare \(p = mv\): rotational inertia takes the place of mass, angular velocity takes the place of velocity. As with \(\omega\), angular momentum has two possible senses, clockwise and counterclockwise, that you handle with a sign. Because it is proportional to \(\omega\) (and not to \(\omega^2\)), angular momentum doubles when the angular velocity doubles, while the kinetic energy quadruples (Figure 6.3a). Two systems with the same angular velocity can have very different angular momenta: a disk with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) at 20 rad/s has \(L = 10\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\), while a hoop with twice the rotational inertia at the same \(\omega\) has \(20\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\).
Figure 6.3a Angular momentum L = Iω is directly proportional to ω, while kinetic energy K = ½Iω² is proportional to ω². Doubling ω doubles L and quadruples K. This difference matters in lesson 6.5, where L is conserved and K is not.
The same system can be described by its angular momentum or its kinetic energy, but they answer different questions. They are related by \(K = L^2/2I\): at a given \(L\), the system with the smaller \(I\) has the larger \(K\), a fact that explains the energy increase when a skater pulls in the arms (lesson 6.5).
A single object: \(L = mvr\sin\theta\)
An object does not have to be part of a rotating system to have angular momentum about some reference point. A particle of mass \(m\) moving with speed \(v\) has angular momentum about a point \(O\) of magnitude
\[ L = mvr\sin\theta, \]
where \(r\) is the distance from \(O\) to the particle and \(\theta\) is the angle between the line from \(O\) to the particle and the velocity. Since \(r\sin\theta\) is the perpendicular distance from \(O\) to the particle’s line of motion, the formula can also be written \(L = mvr_\perp\). In Figure 6.3b, a 2.0 kg particle moves at 3.0 m/s along a line 4.0 m from the reference point: \(L = (2.0)(3.0)(4.0) = 24\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\), and the value is the same wherever the particle is along the line, since \(r_\perp\) does not change. If the particle moved straight toward or away from the point, \(\theta\) would be \(0^\circ\) or \(180^\circ\) and \(L\) would be zero.
Figure 6.3b A particle moving in a straight line has angular momentum about any reference point not on its path: L = mvr sinθ, where r is the distance to the point and θ the angle between r and the velocity. Because r sinθ is the perpendicular distance from the point to the line of motion, L = mvr⊥ = 24 kg·m²/s here, and it stays 24 as the particle moves along the line. If the path went straight through the point, L would be zero.
Two consequences are important. First, the angular momentum depends on the choice of reference point or axis: the same particle has different angular momenta about different points, and zero about any point on its line of motion. A problem must therefore state or imply the axis. Second, the idea reconciles the two formulas. A point mass \(m\) moving in a circle of radius \(r\) at speed \(v\) has \(\theta = 90^\circ\), so \(L = mvr\); with \(v = r\omega\) this is \((mr^2)\omega = I\omega\), the rigid-system formula. A rigid system’s angular momentum is the sum of the angular momenta of its parts about the axis.
Angular momentum and torque
Just as a net force changes linear momentum, a net torque changes angular momentum; this is the subject of lesson 6.4. A quick preview shows why \(L\) deserves its name. For constant \(I\), \(\sum\tau = I\alpha = I\,\Delta\omega/\Delta t = \Delta L/\Delta t\): the net torque is the rate of change of angular momentum. If the net torque is zero, \(L\) does not change.
Worked example · a spinning disk
A disk with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) spins at 20 rad/s. Find its angular momentum, and its kinetic energy. Then find both if \(\omega\) is doubled.
A 0.50 kg ball moves at 6.0 m/s. Its line of motion passes at \(r = 2.0\) m from a reference point, with \(\theta = 30^\circ\) between the line from the point to the ball and the ball’s velocity. Find its angular momentum about the point. What if the ball were moving directly toward the point?
A 0.50 kg ball moves at 6.0 m/s along a line with \(r = 2.0\) m from a point and \(\theta = 30^\circ\). Find its angular momentum about that point.
Show answer
A student says that a car driving in a straight line has no angular momentum because it is not rotating. Evaluate.
Show answer
Incorrect. About a reference point not on its path, \(L = mvr\sin\theta = mvr_\perp\), which is not zero. The value depends on the reference point and is zero only about points on the line of motion.
Angular impulse and the change in angular momentum
To spin a merry-go-round up to speed you can give a hard shove for a short time or a gentle push for a long time. Either way the final spin depends on the total “amount of pushing,” the torque times the time it acts. In Unit 4 you met the same idea for translation: the impulse, force times time, equals the change in momentum. This lesson develops the rotational counterpart. The angular impulse of a torque is the product of the torque and the time interval over which it acts, and it equals the change in the angular momentum of lesson 6.3. This is Newton’s second law in a form that suits situations in which you know how long a torque acts rather than through what angle.
Learning objective · 6.3.B
Describe the angular impulse delivered to an object or rigid system by a torque.
Learning objective · 6.3.C
Relate the change in angular momentum of an object or rigid system to the angular impulse given to that object or rigid system.
Required content · EK 6.3.B.1 to 6.3.C.4
Angular impulse is defined as the product of the torque exerted on an object or rigid system and the time interval during which the torque is exerted: angular impulse \(= \tau\,\Delta t\).
Angular impulse has the same direction as the torque exerted on the object or system.
The angular impulse delivered to an object or rigid system by a torque can be found from the area under the curve of a graph of the torque as a function of time.
The magnitude of the change in angular momentum can be described by comparing the magnitudes of the final and initial angular momenta of the object or rigid system: \(\Delta L = L - L_0\).
A rotational form of the impulse–momentum theorem relates the angular impulse delivered to an object or rigid system and the change in angular momentum of that object or rigid system: \(\tau\,\Delta t = \Delta L\).
The rotational form of the impulse–momentum theorem is a direct result of the rotational form of Newton’s second law of motion for cases in which rotational inertia is constant: \(\tau = I\alpha = I\,\Delta\omega/\Delta t\).
The net torque exerted on an object is equal to the slope of the graph of the angular momentum of an object as a function of time.
The angular impulse delivered to an object is equal to the area under the curve of a graph of the net external torque exerted on an object as a function of time.
Boundary statement from the CED
The direction of angular momentum and angular impulse is beyond the scope of the course.
Angular impulse
If a constant net torque \(\tau\) acts on a system for a time \(\Delta t\), the angular impulse is
\[ \text{angular impulse} = \tau\,\Delta t, \]
in units of N·m·s, which is the same as \(\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\), the unit of angular momentum. The angular impulse points the same way as the torque: counterclockwise for a counterclockwise torque. If the torque varies, the angular impulse is the area under the torque–time graph (left panel of Figure 6.4a): in the figure a torque builds up to 8.0 N·m and falls again over 1.5 s, and the area of the triangle, \(\tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(8.0) = 6.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\cdot\text{s}\), is the angular impulse.
The impulse–momentum theorem for rotation
The change in the angular momentum of a system equals the angular impulse delivered to it:
\[ \tau\,\Delta t = \Delta L = L - L_0. \]
For a rigid system with constant \(I\) this follows from Newton’s second law for rotation. Since \(\tau = I\alpha = I\,\Delta\omega/\Delta t\), multiplying by \(\Delta t\) gives \(\tau\,\Delta t = I\,\Delta\omega = \Delta(I\omega)\). The theorem is more general than that derivation: it holds also when the rotational inertia changes, as it does for a skater who pulls in the arms, provided \(L\) is the total angular momentum. (A net torque is exactly what changes the angular momentum: with no net torque \(\Delta L = 0\), which is the subject of the next lesson.)
Two companion statements fall out of this and are worth memorizing as graph-reading rules (Figure 6.4a):
The area under a net torque–time graph is the change in angular momentum.
The slope of an angular momentum–time graph is the net torque.
Figure 6.4a Two ways to read rotational graphs. The area under a net-torque–time graph is the angular impulse, which equals the change in angular momentum (here 6.0 N·m·s). The slope of an angular-momentum–time graph is the net torque (here 4.0 N·m). Slope and area are inverse operations, as for force and linear momentum.
The right-hand panel shows \(L\) rising steadily from 4 to 16 kg·m\(^2\)/s over 3.0 s; the slope, \((16 - 4)/3.0 = 4.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), is the constant net torque acting. Slope and area are the two directions of the same relationship, exactly as for force and linear momentum.
Using the theorem
Choose the impulse form when the problem gives a time, and the work–energy form (lesson 6.2) when it gives an angle. In Figure 6.4b a 5.0 N·m torque acts for 3.0 s on a disk with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) that starts at rest. The angular impulse is \((5.0)(3.0) = 15\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\cdot\text{s}\), so \(L = 0 + 15 = 15\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\) and \(\omega = L/I = 30\) rad/s. This is the same answer you would get from \(\alpha = \tau/I = 10\ \text{rad/s}^2\) and \(\omega = \alpha t\), but the impulse method handles a variable torque with no extra work, since it only needs the area.
Figure 6.4b The rotational impulse–momentum theorem, τΔt = ΔL. A constant net torque of 5.0 N·m acting for 3.0 s gives an angular impulse of 15 N·m·s, so the disk’s angular momentum rises from 0 to 15 kg·m²/s. With constant I this is the same as τ = Iα (lesson 5.8): α = 10 rad/s² and ω = αt = 30 rad/s.
Because the two theorems answer different questions, it is useful to see both on one system. For the same disk, the work done over those 3.0 s is \(\Delta K = \tfrac{1}{2}(0.50)(30)^2 = 225\) J, and the angle turned is \(\tfrac{1}{2}\alpha t^2 = 45\) rad, which gives \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta = (5.0)(45) = 225\) J. Time and angle are different, so the impulse and the work are different numbers: 15 N·m·s against 225 J.
Worked example · a constant torque for a time
A net torque of 6.0 N·m acts for 2.0 s on a rotor with \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) that starts from rest. Find its final angular momentum and angular velocity.
Angular impulse. \(\tau\,\Delta t = (6.0)(2.0) = 12\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\cdot\text{s}\).
Check. The angular impulse is \((6.0)(5.0) = 30\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\cdot\text{s}\), equal to \(\Delta L\). ✓
Worked example · a brake and the time to stop
A flywheel with \(I = 2.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) turns at 40 rad/s. A brake applies a constant opposing torque of 5.0 N·m. How long does it take to stop?
Impulse needed. \(\tau\,\Delta t = L - L_0 = 0 - 80\), with \(\tau = -5.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\), so \(\Delta t = 16\) s. (This agrees with lesson 5.8.)
Exam focus
Time versus angle. Angular impulse \(\tau\,\Delta t\) goes with \(\Delta L\); work \(\tau\,\Delta\theta\) goes with \(\Delta K\). Choose by what is given.
Graph rules. Area under \(\tau\)–\(t\) is \(\Delta L\); slope of \(L\)–\(t\) is the net torque.
Net, external. Only the net external torque on the chosen system changes its \(L\).
Units. N·m·s and \(\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\) are the same; do not confuse N·m·s with N·m or J.
Connect to Newton. Be ready to show that \(\tau\,\Delta t = \Delta L\) follows from \(\tau = I\alpha\) for constant \(I\).
Practice
A 6.0 N·m net torque acts for 2.0 s. What is the angular impulse, and what is the final \(\omega\) for a rotor with \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) starting from rest?
Show answer
The angular momentum of a wheel changes from 10 to 40 kg·m\(^2\)/s in 5.0 s at a steady rate. What is the net torque?
Show answer
The slope: \(30/5.0 = 6.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\).
A torque of 4.0 N·m is applied for 3.0 s and then removed. What angular impulse does it deliver?
Show answer
The area of a rectangle: \((4.0)(3.0) = 12\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\cdot\text{s}\).
A wheel with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) speeds up from 6.0 to 14 rad/s in 2.0 s under a constant torque. Find the torque.
Show answer
\(\Delta L = I\Delta\omega = (0.50)(8.0) = 4.0\), so \(\tau = \Delta L/\Delta t = 2.0\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}\).
A torque of 5.0 N·m acts for 3.0 s on a disk with \(I = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) starting from rest. Find the final angular momentum and kinetic energy.
Show answer
A figure skater begins a spin with arms wide and then draws them in: without any push from anyone, the spin rate jumps. A diver tucks into a ball to rotate several times before the water and opens out to enter cleanly. A cat dropped upside down turns itself over by twisting its body. A neutron star spins at hundreds of turns a second because the massive star it came from collapsed in size. These look different, but a single principle governs all of them: when no net external torque acts on a system, its total angular momentum cannot change. This lesson is the rotational twin of conservation of linear momentum from Unit 4, and it is one of the most powerful tools in the course.
Learning objective · 6.4.A
Describe the behavior of a system using conservation of angular momentum.
Learning objective · 6.4.B
Describe how the selection of a system determines whether the angular momentum of that system changes.
Required content · EK 6.4.A.1, 6.4.A.2, 6.4.B.1 to 6.4.B.3
The total angular momentum of a system about a rotational axis is the sum of the angular momenta of the system’s constituent parts about that axis.
Any change to a system’s angular momentum must be due to an interaction between the system and its surroundings.
The angular impulse exerted by one object or system on a second object or system is equal and opposite to the angular impulse exerted by the second object or system on the first. This is a direct result of Newton’s third law.
A system may be selected so that the total angular momentum of that system is constant.
The angular speed of a nonrigid system may change without the angular momentum of the system changing if the system changes shape by moving mass closer to or further from the rotational axis.
If the total angular momentum of a system changes, that change will be equivalent to the angular impulse exerted on the system.
Angular momentum is conserved in all interactions.
If the net external torque exerted on a selected object or rigid system is zero, the total angular momentum of that system is constant.
If the net external torque exerted on a selected object or rigid system is nonzero, angular momentum is transferred between the system and the environment.
The conservation law
The impulse–momentum theorem of lesson 6.4 says that the change in a system’s angular momentum equals the angular impulse of the net external torque, \(\Delta L = \tau_{\text{net,ext}}\,\Delta t\). If the net external torque is zero, \(\Delta L = 0\):
\[ L_{\text{initial}} = L_{\text{final}} \qquad\text{(no net external torque).} \]
The total angular momentum of the system, found by adding the angular momenta of all its parts about the same axis, stays constant. That does not mean the parts stay the same. They can exchange angular momentum with one another, and each part’s angular velocity can change, as long as the total is fixed. This is possible because internal interactions come in equal and opposite pairs: by Newton’s third law, the torque (and so the angular impulse) object A exerts on B is equal and opposite to that B exerts on A, so the internal exchanges cancel in the total.
Equally important is the choice of system. If you choose a system for which a net external torque acts (say, a spinning wheel with a brake pad that you did not include in the system), the angular momentum of the wheel changes, and it is “transferred” to the environment. If you expand the system to include both the wheel and the brake, there is no net external torque on the pair, and the combined angular momentum is constant. The principle that angular momentum is conserved in all interactions is therefore always true for a properly selected isolated system; what changes from problem to problem is which system you can treat as isolated.
Changing the shape of a nonrigid system
A rigid system has a fixed rotational inertia, so its angular velocity can change only through an external torque. A nonrigid system, such as a person who can move their arms and legs, can change its own rotational inertia by moving mass toward or away from the axis. With no external torque, \(L = I\omega\) must stay the same, so if \(I\) decreases, \(\omega\) must increase, and vice versa.
Figure 6.5a shows a skater with rotational inertia 4.0 kg·m\(^2\) at 2.0 rad/s (arms out), so \(L = 8.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\). When the arms are pulled in, \(I\) falls to 1.0 kg·m\(^2\), so \(\omega = L/I = 8.0\) rad/s. The kinetic energy, however, goes from \(\tfrac{1}{2}(4.0)(2.0)^2 = 8.0\) J to \(\tfrac{1}{2}(1.0)(8.0)^2 = 32\) J. Angular momentum is conserved; kinetic energy is not. The extra 24 J came from the work done by the skater’s muscles pulling the arms inward: the arms are moving in circles, and the skater’s muscles must supply the inward force that bends their path while they move toward the axis, so those internal forces do positive work. (Internal forces cannot change \(L\), but they can change \(K\).)
Figure 6.5a A nonrigid system changes its shape. With no net external torque, L = Iω stays constant, so decreasing I from 4.0 to 1.0 kg·m² raises ω from 2.0 to 8.0 rad/s. The kinetic energy goes from ½(4.0)(2.0)² = 8.0 J to ½(1.0)(8.0)² = 32 J: the extra 24 J comes from the work the skater does pulling the arms inward.
The same reasoning explains the diver (tuck for fast rotation, open out to slow it) and the neutron star. A collapsing star that shrinks its radius a hundredfold decreases its rotational inertia by a factor of \(10^4\) (since \(I \propto R^2\)), and its rotation rate rises by the same factor.
Rotational collisions
When two rotating objects interact on the same axis, such as a clutch engaging a flywheel, or a child jumping onto a merry-go-round, the interaction forces between them supply equal and opposite angular impulses. The total angular momentum of the pair is the same before and after, which works as the rotational analog of an inelastic collision. In Figure 6.5b, a disk with \(I_1 = 0.50\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) turning at 12 rad/s drops onto a stationary disk with \(I_2 = 0.30\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) on the same axis and the two stick. Then
\[ I_1\omega_1 = (I_1 + I_2)\omega_f \quad\Rightarrow\quad \omega_f = \frac{(0.50)(12)}{0.80} = 7.5\ \text{rad/s}. \]
The kinetic energy falls from 36 J to \(\tfrac{1}{2}(0.80)(7.5)^2 = 22.5\) J; the lost 13.5 J is turned into thermal energy at the sliding contact. As with perfectly inelastic linear collisions, momentum (here angular momentum) is conserved while kinetic energy is not.
Figure 6.5b A rotational collision. Friction between the disks supplies equal and opposite angular impulses, so the total angular momentum of the pair is unchanged: 6.0 kg·m²/s before and after, giving ω = 6.0/0.80 = 7.5 rad/s. The collision is inelastic: kinetic energy falls from 36 J to 22.5 J.
Worked example · a skater
A skater has \(I = 3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) and is spinning at 1.5 rad/s with arms out. She pulls her arms in, reducing \(I\) to 1.5 kg·m\(^2\). Find her new angular velocity and the change in kinetic energy.
Energy. \(K_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}(3.0)(1.5)^2 = 3.4\) J. \(K_2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(1.5)(3.0)^2 = 6.75\) J. The kinetic energy doubles (same \(L\), half the \(I\)), and the 3.4 J increase is the work done by her muscles.
Worked example · a child jumps onto a merry-go-round
A merry-go-round (a uniform disk of mass 100 kg and radius 2.0 m) turns at 1.0 rad/s. A 30 kg child standing at rest next to it jumps onto its rim, without exerting any torque on it, and holds on. Find the new angular velocity.
Conserve \(L\). The child, at rest and not moving about the axis, has no initial angular momentum about it. \(200 \times 1.0 = (200 + 120)\omega_f\), so \(\omega_f = 0.625\) rad/s.
Comment. The merry-go-round slows from 1.0 to 0.63 rad/s: angular momentum is shared with the child.
Worked example · a diver
A diver leaves the board in a layout position with \(I = 4.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\), rotating at 2.0 rad/s. She tucks, so that \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). What is her angular velocity in the tuck, and what is it if she then opens out again?
Open. Back to \(I = 4.5\) gives \(\omega = 2.0\) rad/s again, with \(L = 9.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{s}\) the whole time (the small torque of air and gravity about the center of mass is negligible, and gravity has zero torque about the center of mass).
Exam focus
Condition. \(L\) is constant only if the net external torque on the chosen system is zero. State the system.
Same axis. Add angular momenta of all parts about the same axis, with signs for sense of rotation.
\(L\) yes, \(K\) no. Inelastic rotational collisions and changes of shape conserve \(L\); \(K\) changes (down in a collision, up when internal work pulls mass in).
Reasoning pattern. \(L\) constant, so \(I\) down means \(\omega\) up, and \(I\) up means \(\omega\) down. \(K = L^2/2I\) goes the same way as \(\omega\).
Transfer to the environment. If there is a net external torque, angular momentum is transferred between system and surroundings, equal to the angular impulse.
Practice
A skater has \(I = 3.0\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) at 1.5 rad/s and pulls in her arms so that \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). Find her new \(\omega\).
Show answer
\(\omega_2 = (3.0)(1.5)/1.5 = 3.0\) rad/s.
By what factor does her kinetic energy change in problem 1?
Show answer
It doubles: \(K = L^2/2I\) with the same \(L\) and half the \(I\). (3.4 J to 6.75 J.)
A disk with \(I = 0.20\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) at 10 rad/s is dropped onto a stationary disk with \(I = 0.30\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) on the same axis and they stick. Find the final angular velocity.
Show answer
\((0.20)(10) = (0.50)\omega\), so \(\omega = 4.0\) rad/s.
A diver with \(I = 4.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\) rotating at 2.0 rad/s tucks to \(I = 1.5\ \text{kg}\cdot\text{m}^2\). Find \(\omega\).
Show answer
\(\omega = (4.5)(2.0)/1.5 = 6.0\) rad/s.
A student claims that angular momentum is not conserved when a spinning wheel slows because of friction in its bearings. Explain, using the choice of system.
Show answer
If the system is the wheel alone, the bearing friction is an external torque, so the wheel’s \(L\) decreases; the lost angular momentum is transferred to the environment (the mounting and the Earth). If the system includes the wheel and its mount, the friction is internal, and the total \(L\) is conserved.
Why can a skater change the spin rate without any outside torque, yet cannot change her total angular momentum?
Show answer
Moving her arms changes \(I\), and with \(L = I\omega\) fixed by the absence of a net external torque, \(\omega\) changes in the opposite direction. Internal forces can change the shape and \(K\), but not the total \(L\).
Lesson 6.6 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.5 (rolling without slipping)
Let a solid ball, a hollow ball, a can of soup and a block of ice go down the same ramp from rest. The block of ice (if the ramp is slick) wins by a wide margin; the others come after it in an order that depends only on their shape and not on their mass or size. Rolling objects are everywhere: wheels, bearings, rolling pins, the planets themselves as they turn. They combine translation and rotation in a very specific way, with a link between the speed of the center and the spin rate. This lesson uses energy and the link \(v = R\omega\) to explain why a rolling object is slower than a sliding one, and why the shape of a rolling object decides how fast it goes.
Learning objective · 6.5.A
Describe the kinetic energy of a system that has translational and rotational motion.
Learning objective · 6.5.B
Describe the motion of a system that is rolling without slipping.
Required content · EK 6.5.A.1, 6.5.B.1, 6.5.B.2
The total kinetic energy of a system is the sum of the system’s translational and rotational kinetic energies: \(K_{tot} = K_{trans} + K_{rot}\).
While rolling without slipping, the translational motion of a system’s center of mass is related to the rotational motion of the system itself with the equations \(v_{cm} = R\omega\) and \(a_{cm} = R\alpha\).
For ideal cases, rolling without slipping implies that the frictional force does not dissipate any energy from the rolling system.
Boundary statement from the CED
Rolling friction is beyond the scope of AP Physics 1.
What “rolling without slipping” means
Picture a wheel of radius \(R\) rolling along a road. In one full turn the wheel’s center advances one circumference, \(2\pi R\), and the point on the rim that touched the road at the start touches it again. If the wheel does not slip, then the length of road passed equals the length of rim unrolled: the center moves a distance \(s = R\,\Delta\theta\) while the wheel turns through \(\Delta\theta\). Dividing by time gives
\[ v_{cm} = R\omega, \qquad a_{cm} = R\alpha. \]
These are the same relations as \(v = r\omega\) and \(a_t = r\alpha\) of lesson 5.3, now applied to the center of mass. They tie the translational and rotational motion together, so a rolling object needs only one motion variable instead of two.
Figure 6.6a shows how it works. Seen from the road, the motion of each point is the translation of the center at \(v\) plus the rotation about the center at \(R\omega = v\). At the top the two add: \(2v\). At the bottom, where the rotation points backward, they cancel: \(v - v = 0\). The point of the wheel touching the ground is momentarily at rest relative to the ground. This explains the energy statement of the CED. The friction between the wheel and the surface is static friction, acting at a point that does not slide, so the point where it is applied does not move. Static friction in an ideal case therefore does no work and does not dissipate energy; it only supplies the torque that makes the wheel roll instead of slide. (Rolling friction, from the deformation of soft surfaces, is not part of the course.)
Figure 6.6a Rolling without slipping is a combination of translation at vcm and rotation at ω about the center, with vcm = Rω. The point at the bottom has the velocity v − Rω = 0 relative to the ground, so it does not slide, and the point at the top moves at 2v. The ground’s static friction acts at a point at rest, so it does no work.
Kinetic energy of a rolling object
A rolling object has both kinds of kinetic energy, and with \(\omega = v/R\) they can be written in terms of the speed alone. For a rigid object with rotational inertia \(I = cMR^2\) (where \(c\) is a number that depends on the shape: 1 for a hoop, \(\tfrac{1}{2}\) for a solid disk, \(\tfrac{2}{5}\) for a solid sphere),
\[ K_{tot} = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(cMR^2)\frac{v^2}{R^2} = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv^2(1 + c). \]
For a disk, \(K_{tot} = \tfrac{3}{4}Mv^2\), of which one third is rotational. For a hoop, \(K_{tot} = Mv^2\), half rotational. The more the mass is concentrated at the rim, the larger the share of the energy that goes into rotation. A 2.0 kg disk rolling at 4.0 m/s has \(K_{trans} = 16\) J and \(K_{rot} = \tfrac{1}{2}(\tfrac{1}{2}MR^2)(v/R)^2 = \tfrac{1}{4}Mv^2 = 8.0\) J, for a total of 24 J.
Down a ramp
Now release the objects from rest at a height \(h\) on an incline (Figure 6.6b). Because the friction is static, no mechanical energy is lost, so \(Mgh = K_{tot}\). For a sliding frictionless block, all of it becomes translation: \(Mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv^2\) and \(v = \sqrt{2gh}\). A rolling disk must supply rotational kinetic energy as well, so it moves more slowly:
\[ Mgh = \tfrac{3}{4}Mv^2 \quad\Rightarrow\quad v = \sqrt{\tfrac{4}{3}gh}. \]
For a hoop, \(Mgh = Mv^2\) and \(v = \sqrt{gh}\). With \(h = 1.2\) m and \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), the speeds are 4.9 m/s for the block, 4.0 m/s for the disk and 3.5 m/s for the hoop. Notice that the mass \(M\) and the radius \(R\) cancel from every one of these, which is why any two solid disks of different size and mass come down together. Only the shape, through \(c\), matters.
Figure 6.6b The same release height, three different speeds. Mgh = ½Mv² gives v = 4.9 m/s for the block. For rolling objects some energy goes into rotation: Mgh = ½Mv² + ½Iω² gives v = √(4gh/3) = 4.0 m/s for a disk and v = √(gh) = 3.5 m/s for a hoop. The more of the mass is far from the axis, the more energy goes into rotation and the slower the object moves down the ramp.
Figure 6.6c shows the energy accounting for the disk: 24 J of gravitational potential energy at the top becomes 16 J of translational and 8.0 J of rotational kinetic energy at the bottom. The block has no rotational energy and puts all 24 J into translation. In the same way, a rolling object also takes longer to reach the bottom: its acceleration along the incline of angle \(\theta\) is \(a = g\sin\theta/(1 + c)\), which is \(\tfrac{2}{3}g\sin\theta\) for a disk and \(\tfrac{1}{2}g\sin\theta\) for a hoop (compared with \(g\sin\theta\) for the block). For \(\theta = 30^\circ\) these are 3.3, 2.5 and 5.0 m/s\(^2\).
Figure 6.6c Energy bars for rolling without slipping. The 24 J of gravitational potential energy becomes both kinds of kinetic energy, 16 J translational and 8.0 J rotational (a one-to-two split for a disk, since Krot/Ktot = 1/3). A sliding block would put all 24 J into translation, so it would reach the bottom faster.
This acceleration can also be explained with forces. Static friction \(f\) acts up the slope on the rolling disk and produces the torque \(fR\) that gives it its angular acceleration, \(fR = I\alpha = \tfrac{1}{2}MR^2(a/R)\). Along the slope, \(Mg\sin\theta - f = Ma\). Solving these gives \(a = \tfrac{2}{3}g\sin\theta\) and \(f = \tfrac{1}{3}Mg\sin\theta\). Here the friction force reduces the acceleration (it acts up the slope) while doing no net work (the contact point is at rest). Without friction the disk would slide down with no spin at all.
Worked example · a rolling disk
A solid disk of mass 2.0 kg and radius 0.30 m rolls without slipping at 4.0 m/s. Find its angular velocity and its total kinetic energy.
Check. Treating it as if it were only translating would give 73.5 J, half the truth.
Exam focus
One link, two motions. \(v_{cm} = R\omega\) and \(a_{cm} = R\alpha\) hold only without slipping.
Two energy terms. \(K_{tot} = \tfrac{1}{2}Mv_{cm}^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2\). Do not forget the second one.
Static friction does no work. Mechanical energy is conserved for ideal rolling, so \(Mgh = K_{tot}\).
Shape decides the order. More mass near the rim means larger \(I\), more rotational energy, less speed: block \(\gt\) sphere \(\gt\) disk \(\gt\) hoop. Mass and radius do not matter.
Reason with forces and with energy. Be ready to explain the ranking with a force diagram (friction’s torque) and with energy bars.
Practice
What fraction of the total kinetic energy of a rolling solid disk is rotational? Of a rolling hoop?
Show answer
Explain why static friction does no work on a wheel rolling without slipping.
Show answer
The friction acts at the contact point, which is momentarily at rest relative to the surface. A force does work only if its point of application moves, so the static friction transfers no energy.
A solid disk and a hoop with a greater mass and a larger radius roll down the same ramp. Which reaches the bottom first?
Show answer
The disk. The acceleration \(a = g\sin\theta/(1 + c)\) depends only on the shape factor \(c\) (\(\tfrac{1}{2}\) for the disk, 1 for the hoop), not on mass or radius.
Lesson 6.7 · Unit 6 · CED topic 6.5 (rolling while slipping)
A bowling ball leaves the bowler’s hand sliding down the lane with almost no spin. A car spinning its tires on ice moves hardly at all while the wheels turn rapidly. A driver who locks the brakes sends the wheels skidding with no rotation while the car goes on moving. In each of these the neat link of the last lesson, \(v = R\omega\), is broken: the speed of the center and the spin of the wheel do not match, and the surface of the object slides over the ground. This lesson asks what happens then. The CED asks only for a qualitative description: you should be able to explain how the linear and angular quantities change and why energy is lost, but not to calculate the relationship between them.
Learning objective · 6.5.C
Describe the motion of a system that is rolling while slipping.
Required content · EK 6.5.C.1 and 6.5.C.2
When slipping, the motion of a system’s center of mass and the system’s rotational motion cannot be directly related.
When a rotating system is slipping relative to another surface, the point of application of the force of kinetic friction exerted on the system moves with respect to the surface, so the force of kinetic friction will dissipate energy from the system.
Boundary statement from the CED
The precise mathematical relationships between linear and angular quantities while a rigid body is rolling while slipping are beyond the scope of AP Physics 1 and 2, and students will not be expected to model those relationships quantitatively. However, students are expected to qualitatively explain the changes to linear and angular quantities while a rigid body is rolling while slipping.
When the link \(v = R\omega\) breaks
For rolling without slipping, a single condition ties the translational and rotational motion together: \(v_{cm} = R\omega\). With slipping that tie is gone (EK 6.5.C.1), and you can only describe the two motions separately. Two kinds of slipping occur.
Skidding (\(v_{cm} \gt R\omega\)): the center moves faster than the rotation would allow. The bottom of the wheel slides forward over the surface. A locked wheel (\(\omega = 0\)) is the extreme case, and so is a bowling ball just released.
Spinning in place (\(v_{cm} \lt R\omega\)): the wheel turns faster than it advances. The bottom of the wheel slides backward over the surface. A car starting on ice, with the tires whirring, is an example. In the extreme case \(v_{cm} = 0\).
In both cases the point of the object that touches the surface is moving relative to the surface, so the friction that acts is kinetic friction, directed opposite to the sliding motion of the contact point, with magnitude \(\mu_k N\).
What kinetic friction does
Kinetic friction does two things at once to a slipping wheel, because it acts at the rim, away from the center of mass.
As a force, it changes the motion of the center of mass: it opposes the sliding of the contact point, so for a skidding wheel it points backward and decreases \(v_{cm}\) (Figure 6.7a).
As a torque about the center, it changes the spin. For the skidding wheel, a backward force at the bottom of the wheel gives a torque that increases \(\omega\) in the rolling sense.
So while a skidding ball slips, its center slows and its spin increases. Both changes bring the two motions toward matching each other. Eventually \(v_{cm} = R\omega\), the contact point stops sliding, the friction becomes static, and the ball rolls without slipping from then on (an ideal case, ignoring rolling friction). A wheel that is spinning in place behaves the other way: the friction on it points forward (it opposes the backward slide of the contact point), increasing \(v_{cm}\) and, by its torque, reducing \(\omega\), until again \(v_{cm} = R\omega\). In both cases kinetic friction pushes the system toward rolling without slipping.
Figure 6.7a Rolling while slipping. When v > Rω the bottom of the ball slides forward over the floor, so kinetic friction acts backward on it. That friction decreases v and (by its torque) increases ω until v = Rω. During the slipping the point of application of friction moves relative to the surface, so mechanical energy is dissipated. After that the ball rolls without slipping.
Why energy is dissipated
The work done by a force depends on how far its point of application moves. Static friction at the contact point of a rolling wheel does no work because the point does not move relative to the surface (lesson 6.6). Kinetic friction is different. The contact point slides over the surface, so the point of application of the friction force moves relative to the surface and the friction does work, negative overall: it removes mechanical energy from the system and turns it into thermal energy in the wheel and the surface (EK 6.5.C.2). This is why a slipping ball ends up rolling with less kinetic energy than it started with, and why skidding tires get hot and wear away. Energy is conserved overall, but the mechanical energy of the rolling system is not.
This gives a clean contrast to remember: if the object rolls without slipping, the friction is static, does no work, and mechanical energy is conserved (so \(Mgh = K_{tot}\) on a ramp); if it slips, the friction is kinetic, dissipates energy, and the ideal energy equations no longer hold. Notice also that for a slipping object the speed of the center and the rotation rate cannot be related by \(v = R\omega\), so you have to describe each motion with its own net force or net torque.
A comparison of three cases
A wheel rolls down an incline from rest and then crosses a flat surface. Compare three cases that differ only in the friction between the wheel and the surface. In Case 1 the surface is rough enough that there is no slipping. In Case 2 there is some friction but the wheel slips. In Case 3 there is no friction at all.
Case 3 (no friction). There is no torque about the center, so the wheel does not spin up at all; it slides down like a block and arrives with all its energy translational and \(K_{rot} = 0\). Its total mechanical energy is conserved at its initial \(Mgh\).
Case 1 (no slipping). Static friction supplies the torque that makes the wheel spin, and does no work, so the energy is conserved, shared between translation and rotation. The translational kinetic energy is smaller than in Case 3 and the rotational kinetic energy larger than in Case 2.
Case 2 (slipping). The wheel gains some spin, but the kinetic friction dissipates energy, so the total mechanical energy at the bottom is less than in Cases 1 and 3.
For the rotational energy at the bottom, the order is \(K_{rot,1} \gt K_{rot,2} \gt K_{rot,3} = 0\); for the total mechanical energy, \(E_1 = E_3 \gt E_2\); and the frictionless wheel (Case 3) has the largest translational kinetic energy, since all of its energy is translational. Practice stating such rankings and the reasons, in terms of the friction force, its torque, and its work.
Worked example · a thrown bowling ball
A bowling ball is thrown down the lane with a large forward speed and no spin. Describe qualitatively what happens to \(v_{cm}\), \(\omega\) and the mechanical energy until it begins to roll.
At release. \(\omega = 0\) but \(v_{cm} \gt 0\), so the bottom of the ball slides forward over the lane: \(v_{cm} \gt R\omega\). Kinetic friction acts backward on the ball.
While it slides. The friction force decreases \(v_{cm}\); its torque about the center increases \(\omega\) in the rolling direction.
Rolling begins. When \(v_{cm} = R\omega\) the sliding stops, and static friction takes over, doing no work.
Energy. During the slide the kinetic friction does negative work as its point of application moves relative to the lane, so the ball’s total kinetic energy at the start of rolling is less than at release. The difference became thermal energy.
Worked example · spinning in place
A tire is suddenly spun up to a high angular velocity while the car is still. Describe the friction on the tire and its effects.
Contact point. It slides backward relative to the road (the tire turns, the car does not move), so kinetic friction on the tire points forward.
Effects. That friction gives the car a forward acceleration (the force), and its torque reduces the tire’s spin. The tire is also heated by the sliding, which is the energy dissipated.
Exam focus
The condition. Rolling without slipping: \(v_{cm} = R\omega\). Slipping: \(v_{cm} \ne R\omega\), and you may not use that equation.
Which friction. Slipping means kinetic friction, which dissipates energy; no slipping means static friction, which does no work.
Two effects of friction. The force changes \(v_{cm}\); the torque changes \(\omega\). Both push the system toward \(v_{cm} = R\omega\).
Ranking tasks. Rank \(K_{trans}\), \(K_{rot}\) and total \(E\) by case, with reasons in terms of friction’s force, torque and work.
Qualitative only. No calculations are needed for slipping; explain the direction of each change.
Practice
A wheel slides along a rough floor with \(\omega = 0\). Which way does the friction on it point, and what does it do to \(v_{cm}\) and \(\omega\)?
Show answer
Backward, opposite to the sliding of the contact point. It decreases \(v_{cm}\) and, by its torque, makes \(\omega\) increase from zero in the sense of rolling.
When does the slipping stop?
Show answer
When \(v_{cm} = R\omega\). The contact point is then at rest relative to the surface and the friction becomes static.
Does kinetic friction dissipate energy from a slipping wheel? Explain in terms of its point of application.
Show answer
Yes. The point of the wheel where the friction acts slides over the surface, so the friction does work on the system and removes mechanical energy as thermal energy.
A wheel spins with \(v_{cm} = 0\) on slippery ground and the surface suddenly gets rough. Which way does the friction on the wheel point?
Show answer
Forward (in the direction in which the wheel would roll). The bottom of the wheel is sliding backward relative to the ground, so friction opposes that, giving a forward force and reducing the spin.
Case 1: no slipping. Case 2: slipping. Case 3: no friction. A wheel starts from rest at the top of an incline. Rank the total mechanical energy at the bottom.
Show answer
\(E_1 = E_3 \gt E_2\). Cases 1 and 3 have no dissipation (static friction does no work; there is no friction at all). In Case 2 kinetic friction dissipates energy.
In the same three cases, rank the rotational kinetic energy at the bottom.
Show answer
\(K_{rot,1} \gt K_{rot,2} \gt K_{rot,3} = 0\). With no friction there is no torque and no spin; with slipping the torque of kinetic friction gives some spin; static friction in Case 1 gives the full rolling spin.
The Moon circles the Earth, the Earth circles the Sun, and thousands of satellites circle the Earth on paths that range from nearly circular to long ellipses. In Unit 2 you saw that gravity supplies the centripetal force for a circular orbit and found the orbital speed. This unit adds the two tools of conservation: energy (Unit 3) and angular momentum (lessons 6.3 to 6.5). Together they say a great deal about orbits without solving any equations of motion. A satellite on a circular path keeps constant speed and energies; on an ellipse it speeds up as it falls toward the central object and slows as it climbs away, in a way you can predict exactly from the two conservation laws.
Learning objective · 6.6.A
Describe the motions of a system consisting of two objects interacting only via gravitational forces.
Required content · EK 6.6.A.1 and 6.6.A.2
In a system consisting only of a massive central object and an orbiting satellite with mass that is negligible in comparison to the central object’s mass, the motion of the central object itself is negligible.
The motion of satellites in orbits is constrained by conservation laws.
In circular orbits, the system’s total mechanical energy, the system’s gravitational potential energy, and the satellite’s angular momentum and kinetic energy are constant.
In elliptical orbits, the system’s total mechanical energy and the satellite’s angular momentum are constant, but the system’s gravitational potential energy and the satellite’s kinetic energy can each change.
The gravitational potential energy of a system consisting of a satellite and a massive central object is defined to be zero when the satellite is an infinite distance from the central object: \(U_g = -Gm_1m_2/r\).
The model: a heavy center and a light satellite
Both bodies in a two-body system move around their common center of mass. But when the central object is much more massive than the satellite, as the Earth is compared with any satellite, that center of mass is practically at the center of the large object, and its motion is negligible. We can then treat the central object as fixed and follow only the satellite. The system consists of the two objects, and the forces between them are internal; the only force on the satellite is gravity from the central object, so no outside force changes the system’s energy.
Gravitational potential energy: zero at infinity
Near the Earth’s surface you used \(U_g = mgh\), a good approximation for small heights. For an orbit, where the distance from the center changes by a large factor, you need the full expression for the gravitational potential energy of the system of a satellite of mass \(m\) and a central object of mass \(M\) separated by \(r\):
\[ U_g = -\frac{GMm}{r}. \]
The zero of potential energy is defined at infinite separation. At any finite distance the potential energy is negative, because the force is attractive: separating the bodies to infinity takes positive work from outside, so the energy at finite \(r\) must lie below the zero value. The potential energy is more negative at smaller \(r\), and rises toward zero as \(r\) increases (Figure 6.9a in the next lesson shows this as a curve). The sign takes some getting used to, but it is consistent with the rest of the unit: only changes in \(U_g\) matter physically.
Circular orbits
In a circular orbit gravity is the only force, so it supplies the centripetal force: \(GMm/r^2 = mv^2/r\), which gives the orbital speed
\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}}. \]
Because \(r\) and \(v\) are constant, so are \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2\), \(U_g\), and the total \(E = K + U_g\). Putting in \(v^2 = GM/r\),
\[ K = \frac{GMm}{2r}, \qquad U_g = -\frac{GMm}{r}, \qquad E = K + U_g = -\frac{GMm}{2r}. \]
Three facts follow and are worth remembering: \(U_g = -2K\), \(E = -K\), and the total energy of a circular orbit is negative, which is the signature of a bound system. Figure 6.8a shows the numbers for a 1000 kg satellite at \(r = 7.0 \times 10^6\) m (about 630 km above the Earth’s surface), with \(GM_E = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}^2\). The speed is \(\sqrt{3.98 \times 10^{14}/7.0 \times 10^{6}} = 7.5 \times 10^{3}\) m/s, so \(K = +2.84 \times 10^{10}\) J, \(U_g = -5.69 \times 10^{10}\) J and \(E = -2.84 \times 10^{10}\) J. The angular momentum \(L = mvr\) is constant as well (there is no torque about the center).
Figure 6.8a A 1000 kg satellite in a circular orbit of radius r = 7.0 × 106 m around the Earth. Here v = √(GM/r) = 7.5 km/s, K = ½mv² = +28.4 GJ, Ug = −GMm/r = −56.9 GJ (zero at infinite distance), and E = K + Ug = −28.4 GJ. In a circular orbit the energies and the angular momentum are all constant.
Compare orbits of different radius. For a larger orbit, the speed is lower (\(v \propto 1/\sqrt{r}\)), the kinetic energy is lower (\(K \propto 1/r\)), but the potential energy is higher (less negative), and so is the total energy, \(E = -K\). A satellite must therefore gain energy to move to a higher orbit, even though it ends up moving more slowly. If the radius doubles, \(v\) falls to \(1/\sqrt{2}\) of its value and \(K\) halves, \(U_g\) halves in magnitude, and \(E\) rises from \(-28.4\) to \(-14.2\) GJ.
Elliptical orbits
Not all orbits are circles. In an elliptical orbit the distance \(r\) changes, with the central object at one focus. The satellite is closest at perigee and farthest at apogee (Figure 6.8b). Two quantities remain constant. The angular momentum about the central object: the gravitational force always points to the center, so it exerts no torque about it, and \(L = mvr\sin\theta\) is fixed. The total mechanical energy \(E = K + U_g\), because gravity is a conservative force. But the kinetic and potential energies separately change: as the satellite falls toward perigee, \(U_g\) becomes more negative and \(K\) increases by the same amount.
Figure 6.8b In an elliptical orbit the angular momentum about the central object is constant (gravity points toward the center, so it exerts no torque about it), and so is the total mechanical energy. At the apsides v is perpendicular to r, so vprp = vara: twice the distance means half the speed. K is largest and Ug most negative at perigee; K is smallest at apogee.
At the two extreme points the velocity is perpendicular to the radius, so \(L = mvr\) there, and conservation of angular momentum gives \(m v_p r_p = m v_a r_a\), or
\[ \frac{v_p}{v_a} = \frac{r_a}{r_p}. \]
The satellite moves faster where it is closer. For the orbit of the figure, with \(r_p = 7.0 \times 10^6\) m and \(r_a = 1.4 \times 10^7\) m, twice as far at apogee means half the speed there: \(v_a = v_p/2\). Combining this with conservation of energy, \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv_p^2 - GMm/r_p = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_a^2 - GMm/r_a\), gives \(v_p = 8.7 \times 10^{3}\) m/s and \(v_a = 4.4 \times 10^{3}\) m/s, and the total energy \(E = -1.9 \times 10^{10}\) J for a 1000 kg satellite, at both points. Note that this total energy is negative, and it lies between the \(-2.8 \times 10^{10}\) J of a circular orbit at the perigee radius and the \(-1.4 \times 10^{10}\) J of a circular orbit at the apogee radius: it equals \(-GMm/(r_p + r_a)\), which is the circular-orbit formula with \(r\) replaced by the semimajor axis.
Worked example · a circular orbit
A 500 kg satellite is in a circular orbit of radius \(8.0 \times 10^6\) m around the Earth (\(GM_E = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}^2\)). Find its speed, kinetic energy, potential energy and total energy.
Energies. \(K = \tfrac{1}{2}(500)(7.06 \times 10^3)^2 = 1.24 \times 10^{10}\) J. \(U_g = -GMm/r = -2.49 \times 10^{10}\) J. \(E = K + U_g = -1.24 \times 10^{10}\) J.
Check. \(U_g = -2K\) and \(E = -K\). ✓
Worked example · speeds on an ellipse
A satellite moves on an elliptical orbit. At perigee, \(r_p = 7.0 \times 10^6\) m and \(v_p = 8.7 \times 10^3\) m/s. Find its speed at apogee, \(r_a = 1.4 \times 10^7\) m.
Energies. From perigee to apogee \(K\) decreases (the speed halves, so \(K\) falls to one quarter) and \(U_g\) increases (less negative); the total stays the same.
Worked example · changing the orbit radius
A satellite moves from a circular orbit of radius \(r\) to one of radius \(2r\). By what factor do the speed, kinetic energy, potential energy and total energy change?
Speed. \(v \propto 1/\sqrt{r}\), so it becomes \(1/\sqrt{2} = 0.71\) of the old value.
Kinetic energy. \(K \propto 1/r\), so it halves. \(U_g = -GMm/r\) is also halved in magnitude (less negative).
Total energy. \(E = -GMm/2r\) halves in magnitude, so it increases (becomes less negative): energy must be added to climb to the larger orbit.
Exam focus
Zero at infinity. \(U_g = -GMm/r\) is negative at every finite distance. Use \(mgh\) only for small heights near the surface.
Circular orbit. \(v = \sqrt{GM/r}\); \(K = -E = -U_g/2\); \(K\), \(U_g\), \(E\) and \(L\) are all constant.
Elliptical orbit. \(E\) and \(L\) are constant; \(K\) and \(U_g\) change. Closer means faster and with more negative \(U_g\).
Speed ratio. At the apsides, \(v_p r_p = v_a r_a\).
Higher orbit. Slower but with more total energy. Energy must be supplied to move to it.
Practice
A 500 kg satellite is in a circular orbit with \(r = 8.0 \times 10^6\) m around the Earth. Find \(v\) and the total energy.
Show answer
If the orbital radius doubles, how do the speed and the kinetic energy change?
Show answer
\(v\) is multiplied by \(1/\sqrt{2}\) (0.71) and \(K\) by \(\tfrac{1}{2}\).
An elliptical orbit has \(r_p = 7.0 \times 10^6\) m, \(r_a = 1.4 \times 10^7\) m and \(v_p = 8.7 \times 10^3\) m/s. Find \(v_a\).
Show answer
\(v_a = v_p r_p/r_a = 4.35 \times 10^3\) m/s.
For an elliptical orbit, which of \(K\), \(U_g\), \(E\) and \(L\) are constant?
Show answer
\(E\) (conservative gravity) and \(L\) (no torque about the center) are constant. \(K\) and \(U_g\) change, in opposite ways.
Why can the central object’s motion be neglected for a satellite orbiting the Earth?
Show answer
The central object is so much more massive than the satellite that the system’s center of mass is essentially at its center, and the force the satellite exerts on it produces a negligible acceleration.
A satellite in a circular orbit is raised to a higher circular orbit. Does its total energy increase or decrease, and why does its speed decrease?
Show answer
The total energy \(E = -GMm/2r\) increases (becomes less negative), so work must be done on it. The speed decreases, \(v = \sqrt{GM/r}\), because most of the added energy goes into the potential energy.
Throw a ball upward and it comes back. Throw it harder and it goes higher before returning. Is there a speed so great that it never comes back? Newton asked the same question about a cannonball fired from a mountaintop, and the answer is yes: a projectile launched fast enough will never return, because the Earth’s gravity weakens with distance and can never quite stop it. The minimum launch speed for this is the escape velocity. It sets the scale of rocket engines, explains why the Moon has no atmosphere to speak of while the Earth does, and why Jupiter holds on to hydrogen that Earth cannot. This lesson derives it from conservation of energy and uses the total energy to sort orbits into those that are bound and those that are not.
Learning objective · 6.6.A
Describe the motions of a system consisting of two objects interacting only via gravitational forces.
Required content · EK 6.6.A.3
The escape velocity of a satellite is the satellite’s velocity such that the mechanical energy of the satellite–central-object system is equal to zero.
When the only force exerted on a satellite is gravity from a central object, a satellite that reaches escape velocity will move away from the central body until its speed reaches zero at an infinite distance from the central body.
The escape velocity of a satellite from a central body of mass \(M\) can be derived using conservation of energy laws: \(v_{esc} = \sqrt{2GM/r}\).
Total energy decides the fate
For a satellite of mass \(m\) a distance \(r\) from a central object of mass \(M\), moving at speed \(v\), the total mechanical energy of the system is
\[ E = K + U_g = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 - \frac{GMm}{r}. \]
The potential energy is negative and rises toward zero as \(r\) increases (Figure 6.9a). When only gravity acts, \(E\) is constant. The satellite can only go where its kinetic energy would not be negative, that is, where the potential energy curve lies below the energy line, since \(K = E - U_g\) is the vertical gap between the line and the curve.
If \(E \lt 0\), the energy line crosses the curve at some maximum distance. The satellite cannot go beyond it: it is bound. It can orbit (circle or ellipse) or fall back.
If \(E = 0\), the line meets the curve only at infinity. The satellite just barely escapes, arriving infinitely far away with zero speed. This is the escape condition.
If \(E \gt 0\), the satellite escapes with speed left over at infinity.
Figure 6.9a The potential energy curve Ug = −GMm/r rises toward zero at infinite distance. A satellite with total energy below zero is bound: it can only reach distances where the curve lies below its energy line. At E = 0 it just reaches infinity with no speed left; this is the escape condition. The vertical gap between the energy line and the curve is the kinetic energy at that radius.
Figure 6.9b sketches the three kinds of path for a launch from the Earth’s surface: with negative total energy the projectile falls back (or orbits), with zero energy it just escapes, and with positive energy it escapes and keeps moving at a nonzero speed far away.
Figure 6.9b The sign of the total energy sorts the paths of a satellite launched from the surface: E < 0 bound, E = 0 the escape threshold (a satellite reaching infinity at rest), and E > 0 escaping with speed to spare. The escape speed from the surface is 11.2 km/s.
Deriving the escape velocity
Set \(E = 0\) at the launch point, at distance \(r\) from the center:
\[ \tfrac{1}{2}mv_{esc}^2 - \frac{GMm}{r} = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{r}}. \]
Three points deserve comment. First, \(m\) cancels, so the escape velocity does not depend on the mass of the projectile: a grain of sand and a spacecraft need the same speed. Second, it depends on the mass \(M\) of the central object and the distance \(r\) from its center (at the surface, \(r\) is the radius \(R\)). Third, it does not depend on the direction of launch, provided the path does not run into the planet, because energy is a scalar. Comparing with the circular-orbit speed at the same distance, \(v_{circ} = \sqrt{GM/r}\), we have
\[ v_{esc} = \sqrt{2}\,v_{circ}. \]
A satellite already in a circular orbit needs only about 41% more speed to escape.
For the Earth, \(GM_E = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}^2\) and \(R_E = 6.37 \times 10^{6}\) m, so
\[ v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2(3.98 \times 10^{14})}{6.37 \times 10^{6}}} = 1.12 \times 10^{4}\ \text{m/s} = 11.2\ \text{km/s}. \]
For the Moon (\(M = 7.35 \times 10^{22}\) kg, \(R = 1.74 \times 10^{6}\) m), \(v_{esc} = \sqrt{2(6.67 \times 10^{-11})(7.35 \times 10^{22})/(1.74 \times 10^{6})} = 2.4\) km/s. A gas molecule’s speed grows with temperature; the Moon’s low escape velocity means most of any atmosphere would leak away, while Earth’s higher value lets it keep its atmosphere.
Notice what the escape velocity is not: it is not the speed a rocket must hold the whole way up. A rocket with continuous thrust can leave at any speed; the escape velocity applies to a projectile launched with a given speed and then coasting under gravity alone.
Speed left over at infinity
If the launch speed exceeds \(v_{esc}\), the surplus appears as kinetic energy at infinity, where \(U_g = 0\): \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv_\infty^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 - GMm/R\). For example, launch a probe from the Earth’s surface at \(v = 1.5 \times 10^4\) m/s (above the 1.12 \(\times 10^4\) m/s needed). Per kilogram, \(\tfrac{1}{2}v^2 = 1.125 \times 10^8\) J and \(GM/R = 6.25 \times 10^7\) J, so \(\tfrac{1}{2}v_\infty^2 = 5.0 \times 10^{7}\) J and \(v_\infty = 1.0 \times 10^{4}\) m/s. (This neglects air resistance and the Sun’s gravity, and measures speeds relative to the Earth.)
Worked example · the escape velocity of the Earth
Find the escape velocity from the Earth’s surface, and compare it with the speed needed for a circular orbit just above the surface.
Escape speed at this \(r\). \(\sqrt{2}\,v_{circ} = 1.07 \times 10^{4}\) m/s.
Increase. \(1.07 \times 10^4 - 7.54 \times 10^3 = 3.1 \times 10^{3}\) m/s. For a 1000 kg satellite that is an energy increase of \(|E| = 2.84 \times 10^{10}\) J, taking its total energy from \(-2.84 \times 10^{10}\) J to zero.
Worked example · a heavier planet
A planet has four times the Earth’s mass and the same radius. What is its escape velocity?
Scaling. \(v_{esc} \propto \sqrt{M/R}\). With \(M\) times 4 and \(R\) unchanged, \(v_{esc}\) doubles to about 22.4 km/s.
Exam focus
Escape means \(E = 0\). Set \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 - GMm/r = 0\); the speed at infinity is zero.
The formula. \(v_{esc} = \sqrt{2GM/r}\), independent of the satellite’s mass and of the launch direction.
Compare with orbit. \(v_{esc} = \sqrt{2}\,v_{circ}\) at the same \(r\).
Sign of \(E\). \(E \lt 0\) bound, \(E = 0\) escape threshold, \(E \gt 0\) escape with speed to spare.
Derive it. The CED says it can be derived from conservation of energy; be ready to do the derivation in symbols.
Practice
Calculate the escape velocity from the Earth’s surface (\(GM = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}^2\), \(R = 6.37 \times 10^{6}\) m).
Show answer
Does the escape velocity depend on the mass of the projectile? Explain.
Show answer
No. The mass \(m\) cancels from \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = GMm/r\).
The central mass is quadrupled with the radius unchanged. What happens to \(v_{esc}\)?
Show answer
It doubles, since \(v_{esc} \propto \sqrt{M}\).
Find the escape velocity from a point \(2R_E\) from the Earth’s center (a distance of one radius above the surface).
Show answer
\(\sqrt{2GM/(2R_E)} = \sqrt{GM/R_E} = 7.9 \times 10^{3}\) m/s: smaller than at the surface by a factor of \(\sqrt{2}\).
A projectile launched at exactly \(v_{esc}\) travels out to a great distance. What is its speed at infinite distance and what is its total energy?
Show answer
Its speed approaches zero at infinity. Its total energy is zero throughout.
What is the ratio of the escape speed to the circular-orbit speed at the same distance from a planet?
Show answer
\(\sqrt{2} \approx 1.41\).
Unit 6 practice · 10 problems
Unit 6 practice: Energy and Momentum of Rotating Systems
Ten problems covering the whole unit. Write \(I = \beta MR^2\) for the
given shape, keep \(\omega\) in rad/s, and remember that rolling without
slipping means \(v_{\text{cm}} = R\omega\). Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\),
\(G = 6.67\times10^{-11}\) N·m²/kg², \(M_E = 5.97\times10^{24}\) kg, and
\(R_E = 6.37\times10^{6}\) m.
A solid-disk flywheel of mass 20 kg and radius 0.40 m spins at 1500 rpm. How much kinetic energy does it store?
A solid sphere, a solid disk, a hoop, and a frictionless sliding block are released from rest at the top of a 3.0 m high ramp; the round objects roll without slipping. Rank their speeds at the bottom from fastest to slowest, compute each, and explain the ranking in words.
Show answer
\(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2(1 + \beta) \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2gh}{1 + \beta}}\) with \(2gh = 60\) m²/s². Block (\(\beta = 0\)): 7.7 m/s. Sphere (\(\beta = \tfrac{2}{5}\)): \(\sqrt{60/1.4} = 6.5\) m/s. Disk (\(\beta = \tfrac{1}{2}\)): \(\sqrt{60/1.5} = 6.3\) m/s. Hoop (\(\beta = 1\)): \(\sqrt{60/2} = 5.5\) m/s. Ranking: block \(\gt\) sphere \(\gt\) disk \(\gt\) hoop. Every object converts the same \(mgh\), but a rolling object must split it between translation and rotation. The larger the share of mass far from the axis (larger \(\beta\)), the more energy goes into spinning and the less into moving forward. Mass and radius cancel: a big hoop and a small hoop tie.
A hoop rolls without slipping along level ground at 4.0 m/s and reaches a hill. How high up the hill does it rise? Compare with a frictionless block sliding at the same speed.
Show answer
All kinetic energy becomes \(U_g\): \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}(mR^2)\left(\dfrac{v}{R}\right)^2 = mv^2 = mgh\), so \(h = \dfrac{v^2}{g} = \dfrac{16}{10} = 1.6\) m. A sliding block reaches only \(\dfrac{v^2}{2g} = 0.80\) m. The hoop's rotational kinetic energy equals its translational kinetic energy, and both convert to height because static friction does no work in pure rolling.
Experimental design. You are handed a metal ball and told it is either solid or hollow, but you may not cut it open. You have an inclined ramp, a meterstick, and a stopwatch. Design a procedure to decide, and state the prediction you would test.
Show answer
Set the ramp at a measured angle \(\theta\) (from its height and length) and release the ball from rest. Time how long it takes to roll a measured distance \(L\); repeat several times and average. Since \(L = \tfrac{1}{2}at^2\), \(a = 2L/t^2\). Energy conservation for rolling without slipping predicts \(a = \dfrac{g\sin\theta}{1 + \beta}\): solid sphere (\(\beta = \tfrac{2}{5}\)) gives \(\tfrac{5}{7}g\sin\theta\); thin hollow sphere (\(\beta = \tfrac{2}{3}\)) gives \(\tfrac{3}{5}g\sin\theta\). At \(\theta = 20^\circ\), for example, that is 2.44 m/s² versus 2.05 m/s²: a 16% difference, easily resolved with a long ramp and repeated trials. Compare the measured \(a\) with both predictions; use a gentle slope so the ball rolls rather than slips.
A motor applies a constant 15 N·m torque to a wheel that turns through 20 revolutions in 4.0 s. Find the work done and the average power.
Show answer
\(\Delta\theta = 20\times 2\pi = 126\) rad. \(W = \tau\,\Delta\theta = (15)(125.7) = 1.9\times10^{3}\) J. \(P = \dfrac{W}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{1885}{4.0} = 470\) W. Radians are dimensionless, so N·m times rad gives joules.
Find the angular momentum of (a) a disk with \(I = 0.30\) kg·m² turning at 12 rad/s, and (b) a 0.20 kg puck sliding in a straight line at 5.0 m/s along a path that passes 2.0 m from point O, about point O. Does the puck's angular momentum change as it moves?
Show answer
(a) \(L = I\omega = (0.30)(12) = 3.6\) kg·m²/s. (b) \(L = mv\,r_\perp = (0.20)(5.0)(2.0) = 2.0\) kg·m²/s. No: the perpendicular distance from O to the line of motion stays 2.0 m as the puck moves, so \(L\) about O is constant (no torque acts about O).
A torque on a wheel (\(I = 0.35\) kg·m², initially at rest) is graphed against time: constant at 2.0 N·m for 3.0 s, then decreasing in a straight line to zero over the next 1.0 s. Find the wheel's final angular speed.
Show answer
Angular impulse is the area under \(\tau\)–\(t\): rectangle \((2.0)(3.0) = 6.0\) plus triangle \(\tfrac{1}{2}(2.0)(1.0) = 1.0\), so \(\Delta L = 7.0\) kg·m²/s. \(L = I\omega \Rightarrow \omega = \dfrac{7.0}{0.35} = 20\) rad/s.
A merry-go-round is a solid disk of mass 150 kg and radius 2.0 m turning at 1.5 rad/s. A 40 kg child, initially at rest, drops onto the rim and holds on. Find the new angular speed and the kinetic energy lost. Why is angular momentum conserved but not kinetic energy?
Show answer
\(I_{\text{disk}} = \tfrac{1}{2}(150)(2.0)^2 = 300\) kg·m²; child at rim adds \(mr^2 = (40)(2.0)^2 = 160\) kg·m². The axle exerts no torque and the child–platform friction is internal, so \(L_i = L_f\): \((300)(1.5) = (460)\omega_f \Rightarrow \omega_f = 0.98\) rad/s. \(K_i = \tfrac{1}{2}(300)(1.5)^2 = 338\) J; \(K_f = \tfrac{1}{2}(460)(0.978)^2 = 220\) J; about 120 J became thermal energy as the child's shoes skidded up to speed. Angular momentum is conserved because no external torque acts; kinetic energy is not, because the friction that brings the child up to speed does negative net work: a perfectly inelastic rotational collision.
A spinning figure skater pulls her arms in and spins faster. Which quantity stays constant during this motion?
Her angular speed is exactly what changes: the problem says she spins faster. Because \(L = I\omega\) is fixed, lowering \(I\) forces \(\omega\) to rise.
Her rotational kinetic energy \(K = L^2/2I\) increases as \(I\) drops; the extra energy comes from the work her muscles do pulling her arms inward. Energy is conserved overall, but not as rotational kinetic energy alone.
The ice exerts negligible torque about her spin axis, so her angular momentum \(L = I\omega\) is conserved; pulling her arms in lowers \(I\), so \(\omega\) must rise to keep \(L\) the same.
Her rotational inertia is what she deliberately changes: bringing mass closer to the axis reduces \(I = \sum mr^2\). Its decrease is the cause of the faster spin, not something held constant.
A satellite is in a circular orbit at a radius of two Earth radii, \(r = 2R_E = 1.27\times10^{7}\) m. Find its orbital speed and period, and the speed it would need to escape from that orbit. Does the answer depend on the satellite's mass?
Show answer
Gravity is the centripetal force: \(\dfrac{GM_E m}{r^2} = \dfrac{mv^2}{r} \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{\dfrac{GM_E}{r}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{(6.67\times10^{-11})(5.97\times10^{24})}{1.274\times10^{7}}} = \sqrt{3.13\times10^{7}} = 5.6\times10^{3}\) m/s. \(T = \dfrac{2\pi r}{v} = \dfrac{2\pi(1.274\times10^{7})}{5.59\times10^{3}} = 1.43\times10^{4}\) s ≈ 4.0 h. The satellite's mass canceled; every object at that radius orbits at that speed. Escape needs \(E = 0\), which gives \(v_{\text{esc}} = \sqrt{2GM_E/r} = \sqrt{2}\,v = 7.9\times10^{3}\) m/s, again independent of the satellite's mass.
A child on a swing, a guitar string, the balance wheel of a watch, the pistons of an engine, a building swaying in the wind, and the atoms in a solid are all doing the same thing: moving back and forth over and over again about a central position. Motion that repeats at regular intervals is called periodic motion. Among periodic motions one kind stands out, because it is both the simplest to describe and the most common in nature: simple harmonic motion, or SHM. It is simple because the force that drives it has a very plain form, and it is common because almost any system disturbed slightly from a stable equilibrium behaves this way. In this unit you will see that if you understand a mass on a spring, you understand a great deal about vibrations of every kind. This first lesson defines SHM and shows where it comes from.
Learning objective · 7.1.A
Describe simple harmonic motion.
Required content · EK 7.1.A.1 and 7.1.A.2
Simple harmonic motion is a special case of periodic motion.
SHM results when the magnitude of the restoring force exerted on an object is proportional to that object’s displacement from its equilibrium position: \(a = -\dfrac{k}{m}\,x\) (derived equation).
A restoring force is a force that is exerted in a direction opposite to the object’s displacement from an equilibrium position.
An equilibrium position is a location at which the net force exerted on an object or system is zero.
The motion of a pendulum with a small angular displacement can be modeled as simple harmonic motion because the restoring torque is proportional to the angular displacement.
Periodic motion and equilibrium
Periodic motion repeats itself exactly after a fixed time called the period. A planet orbiting the Sun and a rotating wheel are periodic, too, but SHM is the special back-and-forth kind about an equilibrium position. The equilibrium position is the place where the net force on the object is zero; if the object were placed there at rest it would stay there. Move it away, and it starts to move back, overshoots, turns around, and repeats. The distance from equilibrium at any moment is the displacement \(x\), measured with a sign: positive on one side of equilibrium and negative on the other. The largest value of \(|x|\) is the amplitude \(A\).
The restoring force
For an object to oscillate about an equilibrium it needs a restoring force: a force that always points toward the equilibrium, opposite to the displacement. Push the object to the right and the force points left; push it left and the force points right. This is what pulls the object back and makes it overshoot, because by the time it returns to equilibrium it has speed and carries on.
Simple harmonic motion occurs when, in addition, the magnitude of the restoring force is proportional to the displacement:
\[ F = -kx. \]
The constant \(k\) is the force per unit displacement (N/m), and the minus sign says that the force opposes the displacement. This is exactly the force of an ideal spring (Hooke’s law, Unit 3). Figure 7.1a shows a mass on a horizontal frictionless surface attached to a spring. Compressed, the spring pushes the mass back toward equilibrium; stretched, it pulls it back; at the natural length (\(x = 0\)) the force is zero. A graph of \(F\) against \(x\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(-k\) (Figure 7.1b).
Figure 7.1a A restoring force always points toward the equilibrium position and grows in proportion to the displacement: F = −kx. Compressed (x < 0), the spring pushes the mass back toward equilibrium; stretched (x > 0), it pulls the mass back. At x = 0 the net force is zero. This is the condition for simple harmonic motion.Figure 7.1b The signature of simple harmonic motion. The restoring force is proportional to the displacement and opposite to it, so the F–x graph is a straight line through the origin whose slope is −k. At x = 0.30 m the spring pulls back with 6.0 N. Newton’s second law then gives a = −(k/m)x.
Newton’s second law gives the acceleration: \(ma = -kx\), so
\[ a = -\frac{k}{m}\,x. \]
This equation is the heart of the unit. It says that the acceleration is proportional to the displacement and opposite to it. When the mass is far from equilibrium the acceleration is large and points back toward the center; at the center the acceleration is zero; the speed is greatest there. Note that the acceleration is not constant, so the kinematic equations of Unit 1 do not apply. The remaining lessons of this unit work out what this form of acceleration implies for the period, the graphs and the energy.
A word about the definition. Not every back-and-forth motion is SHM. A ball bouncing on the floor is periodic, but the force is not proportional to the displacement from any point; a mass on a spring with a very large stretch may be beyond the spring’s linear range. SHM requires a restoring force proportional to displacement. Systems that are only approximately of this form are still modeled as SHM when the displacement is small enough, as the next section shows.
The pendulum as SHM
A simple pendulum is a small bob hanging on a light string of length \(L\). At rest the bob hangs straight down, in equilibrium: the string tension balances the weight. Pull the bob aside through an angle \(\theta\) and release it (Figure 7.1c). The weight \(mg\) has a component along the circular path, \(mg\sin\theta\), directed toward the equilibrium position; the other component is balanced by the tension (strictly, the tension is a little larger than the radial component because the bob moves in a circle). So the restoring force along the arc is \(F = -mg\sin\theta\).
Figure 7.1c A pendulum’s restoring force. Of the bob’s weight, the component along the circular path, mg sinθ, points toward the equilibrium position; the tension balances the rest. For a small angle (in radians), sinθ ≈ θ, so the restoring force is proportional to the displacement along the arc, F ≈ −(mg/L)x, and the motion is simple harmonic. (Equivalently, the restoring torque is proportional to the angular displacement.)
For small angles measured in radians, \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\) (for \(\theta = 0.2\) rad, \(\sin\theta = 0.199\)). The displacement along the arc is \(x = L\theta\), so
\[ F \approx -mg\,\theta = -\left(\frac{mg}{L}\right)x. \]
This has the form \(F = -kx\) with an effective force constant \(k_{eff} = mg/L\). Therefore the pendulum with a small angular displacement can be modeled as SHM. The CED states the same result in terms of rotation: the restoring torque, \(-mgL\sin\theta \approx -mgL\theta\), is proportional to the angular displacement. For larger angles \(\sin\theta\) is noticeably less than \(\theta\), the restoring force is less than proportional, and the motion is no longer SHM. A rule of thumb is that 10 to 15 degrees is small enough for the approximation to be excellent.
Another example: a vertical spring
A mass hanging on a spring also executes SHM, though with a twist. Gravity pulls down with a constant force, which just shifts the equilibrium position: the equilibrium is where the spring force balances the weight, \(kx_0 = mg\). Measured from that position, the net force is \(-k(x_0 + y) + mg = -ky\), the same restoring force, so the motion is SHM about the new equilibrium (lesson 7.2). Gravity changes the center of the oscillation, not its character.
Worked example · is it SHM?
The net force on a 0.50 kg mass is \(F = -20x\) in SI units (newtons when \(x\) is in meters). Is the motion SHM? Find the acceleration when \(x = +0.30\) m.
Form. \(F\) is proportional to \(x\) and opposite to it, with \(k = 20\) N/m, so the motion is SHM.
A mass on a spring with \(k = 20\) N/m is released from rest at \(x = +0.30\) m. Find the force at \(x = +0.30\), \(+0.15\) and 0 m.
Force. \(F = -kx\): at 0.30 m, \(-6.0\) N; at 0.15 m, \(-3.0\) N; at 0, 0.
Interpretation. The force is largest at the extreme and falls linearly to zero at the center; the motion is the effect of a smoothly changing restoring force.
Worked example · the small-angle approximation
A pendulum is displaced by 0.10 rad. By what percentage does \(\sin\theta\) differ from \(\theta\)?
Compute. \(\sin(0.10) = 0.09983\), which is only 0.17% below \(\theta = 0.10\). So \(F = -mg\sin\theta\) is almost exactly \(-mg\theta\).
Larger angle. At 0.5 rad (29\(^\circ\)), \(\sin\theta = 0.479\), 4% below \(\theta\): the proportionality begins to fail.
Exam focus
Definition of SHM. A restoring force proportional to displacement: \(F = -kx\), equivalently \(a = -(k/m)x\).
Equilibrium and sign. Equilibrium is where the net force is zero; displacement is measured from it; the force and acceleration always point toward it.
Not constant acceleration. The acceleration varies with position, so the kinematic equations do not apply.
Pendulum. Small angles only (in radians), because \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\); the restoring torque is proportional to the angular displacement.
Graph. An \(F\)–\(x\) graph for SHM is a straight line through the origin with slope \(-k\).
Practice
A 2.0 kg mass has a restoring force \(F = -50x\). Find the acceleration at \(x = 0.10\) m.
Show answer
A mass on a spring with \(k = 20\) N/m is at \(x = -0.20\) m. What are the magnitude and direction of the spring force?
Show answer
\(F = -kx = -(20)(-0.20) = +4.0\) N, in the positive direction (toward equilibrium).
An object moves back and forth and the force on it is a constant 5.0 N in magnitude, always directed toward the center. Is the motion SHM?
Show answer
No. The magnitude of the force is not proportional to the displacement, which is what SHM requires.
Why can a pendulum be treated as SHM only for small angles?
Show answer
The restoring force is \(mg\sin\theta\), which is proportional to the displacement only when \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\), i.e. for small angles in radians.
Where is the net force zero for a mass hanging at rest on a spring, and what is this position called?
Show answer
Where the spring force balances the weight (\(kx_0 = mg\)): the equilibrium position.
What does the slope of an \(F\)–\(x\) graph of an ideal spring represent?
Show answer
The slope is \(-k\): the magnitude is the spring constant, and its sign shows that the force opposes the displacement.
Pluck a stiff, light spring and it buzzes quickly; hang a heavy mass on a soft spring and it bobs slowly. The time for one complete cycle, the period, depends on the mass and the spring, but surprisingly it does not depend on how far you pull the mass. Because the period is steady, springs were used to build the first portable clocks. This lesson gives the period of a spring–mass oscillator, shows how a lab measurement of period against mass reveals the spring constant, and explains why a vertical spring has the same period as a horizontal one.
Learning objective · 7.2.A
Describe the period and frequency of an object undergoing simple harmonic motion and how they relate to the properties of the system.
Required content · EK 7.2.A.1 to 7.2.A.3
The period of a spring–block oscillator is \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\) (derived).
The frequency is the reciprocal of the period: \(f = 1/T\). The period of the oscillator is independent of the amplitude.
For a vertical spring–mass system the motion is SHM about the equilibrium position, with the same period as a horizontal system.
Period, frequency and amplitude
The period \(T\) is the time for one complete cycle (out and back and out again to the starting point), measured in seconds. The frequency \(f\) is the number of cycles per second, measured in hertz (Hz), and the two are reciprocals:
\[ f = \frac{1}{T}, \qquad T = \frac{1}{f}. \]
A period of 0.50 s corresponds to a frequency of 2.0 Hz. The amplitude \(A\) is the maximum displacement from equilibrium; for SHM the motion extends from \(-A\) to \(+A\), a total distance of \(2A\) per half cycle and \(4A\) per full cycle.
The period of a spring–mass oscillator
For a mass \(m\) on an ideal spring of constant \(k\), the period is
\[ T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{m}{k}}. \]
This is a derived result, in the sense that it comes from the equation \(a = -(k/m)x\) of lesson 7.1 (the next lesson’s graphs show why). Think about what it says.
A larger mass gives a longer period. More inertia means the same force produces a smaller acceleration, so the cycle takes longer. Quadrupling the mass doubles the period.
A larger spring constant gives a shorter period. A stiffer spring pushes harder at the same displacement, so the mass accelerates faster. Quadrupling \(k\) halves the period.
The amplitude does not appear. A large oscillation has a larger restoring force, so the mass moves faster and covers more distance in the same time. The two effects cancel exactly, and this is a special property of the linear restoring force.
The period does not depend on gravity either. On the Moon or in orbit the same spring and mass have the same period.
In terms of frequency, \(f = \dfrac{1}{2\pi}\sqrt{k/m}\). For a 0.50 kg mass on a spring with \(k = 20\) N/m, \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{0.50/20} = 0.99\) s and \(f = 1.0\) Hz.
Linearizing: finding k from a graph
In the laboratory you can vary the mass, measure the period for each, and plot. A plot of \(T\) against \(m\) is a curve (Figure 7.2a, left), which is hard to analyze. But squaring the period equation gives
\[ T^2 = \frac{4\pi^2}{k}\,m, \]
so \(T^2\) against \(m\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(4\pi^2/k\) (right). Measure the slope of the best-fit line and then \(k = 4\pi^2/\text{slope}\). For the data in the figure the slope is 1.97 s\(^2\)/kg, so \(k = 39.5/1.97 = 20\) N/m. This kind of linearization (choosing the quantities to plot so the graph is a line) is a standard skill in the lab free-response question. Note also that a non-zero \(y\)-intercept would indicate that the spring itself has mass or another systematic effect.
Figure 7.2a The period of a spring–mass oscillator, T = 2π√(m/k), grows as the square root of the mass (left). Squaring both sides gives T² = (4π²/k)m, a straight line (right) whose slope 4π²/k yields the spring constant: k = 4π²/slope = 20 N/m. Plotting T² against m is the standard way to linearize the data in a lab.
A vertical spring
Hang a mass on a vertical spring and it sags to a new equilibrium at \(x_0 = mg/k\), where the spring force balances the weight (Figure 7.2b). Measured from that position, the net force on the mass is \(-ky\) just as before, since gravity is already balanced. Therefore the motion is SHM about the new equilibrium, and the period is the same \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\) as for a horizontal spring. The only thing gravity changes is where the oscillation is centered. For the figure, \(m = 0.50\) kg and \(k = 20\) N/m give \(x_0 = (0.50)(10)/20 = 0.25\) m and \(T = 0.99\) s.
Figure 7.2b A vertical spring. Gravity shifts the equilibrium position down to x0 = mg/k = (0.50)(10)/20 = 0.25 m, where the net force is zero. Measured from this new equilibrium, the mass oscillates in simple harmonic motion with the same period T = 2π√(m/k) as on a horizontal surface; gravity changes the center of the motion, not its period.
A related point: the formula only holds for an ideal spring of negligible mass. If the spring is massive, part of its mass moves too and the period is somewhat longer, and the intercept of a \(T^2\)–\(m\) graph is not zero.
Worked example · period and frequency
A 0.50 kg mass on a spring with \(k = 20\) N/m oscillates. Find the period and frequency.
Period. \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{0.50/20} = 2\pi(0.158) = 0.99\) s.
Frequency. \(f = 1/0.99 = 1.0\) Hz.
Worked example · what changes the period
The mass in the previous example is replaced by one four times as large (2.0 kg), and the amplitude is also doubled. What is the new period?
Mass. \(T \propto \sqrt{m}\): four times the mass gives twice the period.
Amplitude. No effect. \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{2.0/20} = 1.99\) s.
Worked example · finding k from a graph
A student measures \(T^2\) for several masses and the best-fit line passes through the origin with slope 2.5 s\(^2\)/kg. Find the spring constant.
Slope. \(4\pi^2/k = 2.5\) s\(^2\)/kg.
Solve. \(k = 4\pi^2/2.5 = 39.48/2.5 = 15.8\) N/m.
Exam focus
The formula. \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\); \(f = 1/T\). The period depends on \(m\) and \(k\) only, not on the amplitude or on \(g\).
Proportional reasoning. \(T \propto \sqrt{m}\) and \(T \propto 1/\sqrt{k}\). Quadruple the mass or divide \(k\) by four and the period doubles.
Linearization. Plot \(T^2\) against \(m\); slope \(=4\pi^2/k\).
Vertical spring. Same period; the equilibrium shifts down by \(mg/k\).
Units. Period in seconds, frequency in hertz (1/s).
Practice
A 0.25 kg mass on a spring with \(k = 100\) N/m. Find the period.
Show answer
\(T = 2\pi\sqrt{0.25/100} = 2\pi(0.05) = 0.31\) s.
An oscillator has a frequency of 4.0 Hz. What is its period?
Show answer
\(T = 1/f = 0.25\) s.
The amplitude of a spring oscillator is tripled. What happens to the period?
Show answer
Nothing; the period is independent of amplitude.
What mass must be hung on a spring with \(k = 40\) N/m to give a period of 1.0 s?
Show answer
\(m = kT^2/4\pi^2 = (40)(1.0)^2/39.48 = 1.0\) kg.
A 1.0 kg mass hangs at rest on a vertical spring, stretching it 0.25 m. Find \(k\) and the period (use \(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\)).
Show answer
Galileo is said to have watched a lamp swing in the cathedral at Pisa and timed it against his pulse. He noticed that the swings took the same time whether they were wide or narrow. That observation led, decades later, to the pendulum clock, the most accurate timekeeper for nearly three centuries. A pendulum is also a laboratory for measuring the strength of gravity: a long string and a stopwatch are enough. This lesson gives the period of a simple pendulum and shows how to use a graph to find \(g\).
Learning objective · 7.3.A
Describe the period of a simple pendulum.
Required content · EK 7.3.A.1 and 7.3.A.2
The period of a simple pendulum with small angular displacement is \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{L/g}\), where \(L\) is the length of the pendulum (derived).
The period is independent of the amplitude (for small angles) and of the mass of the bob.
The pendulum period
In lesson 7.1 we found that for small angles a pendulum has an effective force constant \(k_{eff} = mg/L\) for the displacement along the arc. Substitute into the spring result \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\) with \(m\) the mass of the bob:
\[ T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{m}{mg/L}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{L}{g}}. \]
The mass cancels, because the restoring force is itself proportional to the mass (it is a component of the weight). This is the period of a simple pendulum: a point-like bob on a light, inextensible string, swinging through a small angle (less than about 15\(^\circ\)).
Length. \(T \propto \sqrt{L}\). To double the period, make the string four times as long.
Gravity. \(T \propto 1/\sqrt{g}\). The same pendulum swings more slowly where \(g\) is smaller, for example on the Moon (\(g \approx 1.6\) m/s\(^2\)), where the period is about 2.5 times longer. Geologists have used pendulum clocks to detect small changes in \(g\) across the Earth.
Mass. No effect. A heavy bob and a light bob of the same string length swing together.
Amplitude. No effect, as long as the angle is small. For wide swings the true period is a little longer than the formula gives.
A pendulum of length 1.0 m with \(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\) has \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{1.0/10} = 1.99\) s, about 2 s. (A “seconds pendulum,” with a half period of 1 s, is close to 1 m long.)
Measuring g with a pendulum
Square the formula: \(T^2 = (4\pi^2/g)\,L\). Therefore a graph of \(T^2\) against \(L\) is a straight line through the origin with slope \(4\pi^2/g\), and
\[ g = \frac{4\pi^2}{\text{slope}}. \]
In Figure 7.3a the slope is 3.95 s\(^2\)/m, giving \(g = 39.48/3.95 = 10\) m/s\(^2\). Good technique: time many swings (say 20) and divide to reduce the error from reaction time; measure \(L\) from the pivot to the center of the bob; keep the angle small; and use several lengths and a line of best fit rather than one measurement. Measuring the period with a small angle also keeps the sine approximation valid.
Figure 7.3a Finding g with a pendulum. Squaring T = 2π√(L/g) gives T² = (4π²/g)L, so a plot of T² against L is a line through the origin with slope 4π²/g. Measuring the slope gives g = 4π²/slope. For g = 10 m/s² the slope is 3.95 s²/m and a 1.0 m pendulum has a period of 2.0 s.
Spring versus pendulum
The two systems are alike in that both are SHM and neither period depends on amplitude. They differ in an important way. For the spring, the period depends on the mass and spring constant, and not on gravity. For the pendulum, the period depends on the length and gravity, and not on the mass. So a mass–spring clock keeps the same time on the Moon but a pendulum clock does not. Remember this contrast; it is a favorite exam question.
Worked example · period of a pendulum
Find the period of a pendulum of length 0.80 m on the Earth (\(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\)).
Substitute. \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{0.80/10} = 2\pi(0.283) = 1.78\) s.
Frequency. \(f = 1/1.78 = 0.56\) Hz.
Worked example · changing length
A pendulum has a period of 2.0 s. What length would give a period of 1.0 s?
Scaling. \(T \propto \sqrt{L}\). Halving the period needs one quarter of the length.
Check. \(L = gT^2/4\pi^2 = (10)(1.0)^2/39.48 = 0.25\) m, which is one quarter of the 1.0 m for 2.0 s. ✓
Worked example · g from lab data
A pendulum of length 1.00 m has a measured period of 2.01 s. Find the value of \(g\) this gives.
Compare. This is 2% below 10 m/s\(^2\), within typical timing error.
Exam focus
The formula. \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{L/g}\), for small angles.
What it does not depend on. The mass of the bob and the amplitude (when small).
Contrast. Spring period depends on \(m\) and \(k\), not on \(g\); pendulum period depends on \(L\) and \(g\), not on \(m\).
Linearization. Plot \(T^2\) against \(L\); \(g = 4\pi^2/\text{slope}\).
Experimental design. Time many cycles, small angle, several lengths.
Practice
Find the period of a 2.5 m pendulum (\(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\)).
Show answer
\(T = 2\pi\sqrt{2.5/10} = 2\pi(0.5) = 3.14\) s.
By what factor must the length change to triple the period?
Show answer
\(T \propto \sqrt{L}\), so the length must increase by a factor of 9.
A pendulum bob’s mass is doubled. What happens to the period?
Show answer
Nothing; the mass cancels.
The slope of a \(T^2\)–\(L\) graph is 4.0 s\(^2\)/m. Find \(g\).
Show answer
\(g = 4\pi^2/4.0 = 9.87\) m/s\(^2\).
A pendulum is taken to a planet where \(g\) is 4 times as large. How does its period change?
Show answer
\(T \propto 1/\sqrt{g}\): the period is halved.
A student pulls a pendulum out to 60\(^\circ\) and times it. Why is the formula not reliable?
Show answer
The small-angle approximation fails; \(\sin\theta\) is noticeably less than \(\theta\), so the motion is not SHM and the period is longer than \(2\pi\sqrt{L/g}\).
An oscillator is easiest to understand when you can see it in several forms at once: a graph of where it is, a graph of how fast it is moving, a graph of how hard it is being pushed, and the equation that ties them together. A seismograph draws such a graph by dragging paper under a swinging pen; an oscilloscope draws one for an electrical signal. In this lesson you learn to read position, velocity and acceleration from graphs of SHM, to see how they relate, and to write the equation of motion.
Learning objective · 7.4.A
Represent the motion of an object undergoing simple harmonic motion.
Required content · EK 7.4.A.1 to 7.4.A.3
Position, velocity and acceleration of an object in SHM can be represented as functions of time by graphs and by sinusoidal equations.
The graphs of position, velocity and acceleration against time are sinusoidal; the maximum values of velocity and acceleration are related to the amplitude.
The velocity is zero at the extremes of the motion, where the acceleration has its maximum magnitude, and the acceleration is zero at equilibrium, where the speed is a maximum.
The position graph
If the mass is released from rest at \(x = +A\) at time \(t = 0\), its position follows a cosine:
\[ x(t) = A\cos(2\pi f t) = A\cos\!\left(\frac{2\pi}{T}\,t\right). \]
The quantity \(2\pi f\) is called the angular frequency \(\omega\) (in rad/s); \(\omega = \sqrt{k/m}\). If instead the mass is at equilibrium at \(t = 0\) and moving in the positive direction, \(x = A\sin(2\pi f t)\). The shape is the same, shifted in time. The graph oscillates between \(+A\) and \(-A\) and repeats every period \(T\). For \(A = 0.30\) m and \(T = 2.0\) s (so \(f = 0.50\) Hz), the position is zero at \(t = 0.50\) s, \(-0.30\) m at 1.0 s, and back to \(+0.30\) m at 2.0 s.
Velocity and acceleration
Velocity is the slope of the position graph. At the peaks and troughs the slope is zero, so \(v = 0\) there: the mass momentarily stops to turn around. The slope is steepest as the curve crosses \(x = 0\), so the speed is greatest at equilibrium. The maximum speed is
\[ v_{max} = A\omega = 2\pi f A. \]
With \(A = 0.30\) m and \(\omega = \pi\) rad/s the maximum speed is 0.94 m/s. The velocity graph is a negative sine (when starting at \(+A\)): the mass first moves in the negative direction.
Acceleration is the slope of the velocity graph, and also \(a = -\omega^2 x\) from \(a = -(k/m)x\). So the acceleration graph is the position graph turned upside down and scaled; its maximum magnitude is
\[ a_{max} = A\omega^2 = 4\pi^2 f^2 A, \]
which is 2.96 m/s\(^2\) in the example. It occurs at the extremes of the motion and is directed toward the center; it is zero at \(x = 0\).
Figure 7.4a The graphs of SHM for A = 0.30 m and T = 2.0 s, starting from rest at x = +A. Position is x = A cos(2πft). Velocity is the slope of x: it is zero at the extremes and has the greatest magnitude, Aω = 0.94 m/s, as the mass passes through equilibrium. Acceleration, a = −(k/m)x = −ω²x, is the mirror image of the position graph and has the greatest magnitude, Aω² = 2.96 m/s², at the extremes.
Notice the pattern: the velocity graph is a quarter cycle ahead of the position graph (the position is at a peak when the velocity is zero), and the acceleration graph is a half cycle out of step (opposite) with the position graph. Whenever you are asked where the speed is greatest, look for where the position curve crosses zero; where the acceleration is greatest, look for the peaks and troughs of the position curve.
Key positions in one cycle
Figure 7.4b sums up what happens at the extremes and at equilibrium, for a mass released from rest at \(x = +A\). At \(x = +A\) the velocity is zero and the acceleration is the most negative (toward the center). At \(x = 0\) the acceleration is zero and the velocity is the most negative. At \(x = -A\) the velocity is again zero and the acceleration is the most positive. Then the mass returns. Velocity and acceleration are in the same direction (speeding up) while it moves toward the center and in opposite directions (slowing) as it moves away from it.
Figure 7.4b Positions, velocities and accelerations in one cycle. At the extremes (x = ±A) the mass is momentarily at rest and the restoring force, hence the acceleration, is greatest. At equilibrium the net force and acceleration are zero and the speed is greatest. Velocity and displacement are never at their extremes together, and the acceleration is always opposite to the displacement.
Reading the period from a graph
The period is the time between two successive identical points, for instance peak to peak. The amplitude is the maximum displacement (half the peak-to-trough distance). Frequency follows from \(f = 1/T\). Reading a graph in which the position goes from \(+0.30\) m at \(t = 0\) to \(+0.30\) m next at \(t = 2.0\) s, the period is 2.0 s: don’t read the time to the first zero crossing, which is a quarter period.
Worked example · maximum speed and acceleration
A mass oscillates with amplitude 0.30 m and period 2.0 s. Find its maximum speed and maximum acceleration.
An oscillator never stops trading energy with itself. When a mass on a spring is at the end of its swing it is momentarily still but the spring is fully stretched or compressed; a moment later the spring has relaxed and the mass is moving at top speed. The energy swaps between the spring and the motion, and in an ideal system none is lost. This conservation of energy gives a fast route to speeds at any position and explains what happens when something is dropped onto an oscillator. It ties Unit 7 back to the work and energy of Unit 3.
Learning objective · 7.5.A
Describe the energy of an object undergoing simple harmonic motion.
Required content · EK 7.5.A.1 to 7.5.A.3
The total energy of an ideal oscillator is constant: \(E = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2\).
At any position, the sum of the kinetic and potential energies is the total energy: \(K + U = E\).
The kinetic energy is greatest, and the potential energy is least, at the equilibrium position; the opposite is true at the extremes of the motion.
Total energy and amplitude
For a mass on a horizontal spring with no friction, the only force doing work is the spring force, which is conservative. The system’s mechanical energy is therefore constant. At the extreme position \(x = \pm A\) the mass is at rest, so all of the energy is stored in the spring:
\[ E = U_{max} = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2. \]
The total energy grows with the square of the amplitude: double the amplitude and the energy is four times as great. At any other position,
\[ \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2. \]
For \(k = 20\) N/m and \(A = 0.30\) m, \(E = \tfrac{1}{2}(20)(0.30)^2 = 0.90\) J.
Kinetic and potential energy as the mass moves
The potential energy \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2\) is a parabola in \(x\), zero at equilibrium and greatest at the extremes (Figure 7.5a). The total \(E\) is a horizontal line. At each position the kinetic energy is the gap between the two: \(K = E - U\). At \(x = 0\), \(K = E\), and the speed is greatest; at \(x = \pm A\), \(K = 0\). At \(x = 0.15\) m (half the amplitude) \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}(20)(0.15)^2 = 0.225\) J, a quarter of the total, so \(K = 0.675\) J, three quarters of the total.
Figure 7.5a Energy in SHM. The potential energy U = ½kx² is a parabola; the total energy E = ½kA² = 0.90 J is a horizontal line. At each position the kinetic energy is the vertical gap between the line and the parabola, K = E − U. K is greatest (all of E) at x = 0, and zero at the turning points x = ±A, where U = E.
Energy bar charts (Figure 7.5b) show the same thing at three instants. The sum of the bars is the same in each: the spring’s energy and the kinetic energy trade off, and the total is fixed.
Figure 7.5b Energy bar charts at three instants. The total (0.90 J) never changes; energy moves between the spring (U) and the motion (K). At x = A/2 the potential energy is only one quarter of its maximum, ½(20)(0.15)² = 0.225 J, so three quarters of the energy is kinetic. The maximum speed follows from ½mvmax² = 0.90 J: vmax = 1.9 m/s.
Speed at any position
From \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}k(A^2 - x^2)\),
\[ v = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}\,(A^2 - x^2)}. \]
The maximum speed occurs at \(x = 0\): \(v_{max} = A\sqrt{k/m} = A\omega\), the same result as in lesson 7.4. For \(m = 0.50\) kg, \(k = 20\) N/m and \(A = 0.30\) m, \(v_{max} = 0.30\sqrt{40} = 1.90\) m/s. At \(x = 0.15\) m, \(v = \sqrt{40(0.09 - 0.0225)} = 1.64\) m/s. Note that using energy avoids the varying acceleration entirely, so it is the preferred method for speeds. Also notice that the kinetic energy and the potential energy each oscillate at twice the frequency of the motion: a full cycle passes through the center twice and the extremes twice.
Changing the system: dropping a mass on an oscillator
Suppose a lump of clay of mass 0.50 kg falls vertically onto a 0.50 kg cart that is oscillating on a horizontal spring (Figure 7.5c), and sticks. There are two cases, and the difference is a good test of understanding.
At the center (\(x = 0\)). The cart is moving at \(v_{max}\). The clay has no horizontal velocity, so horizontal momentum is conserved in a perfectly inelastic collision: the speed is halved (the mass has doubled). The kinetic energy, and therefore the total energy, is halved: \(E' = 0.45\) J. The new amplitude is \(A' = A/\sqrt{2} = 0.21\) m.
At an extreme (\(x = A\)). The cart is momentarily at rest, so the clay adds no kinetic energy; the energy remains \(\tfrac{1}{2}kA^2\) and the amplitude is unchanged, 0.30 m.
Figure 7.5c A lump of clay dropped onto an oscillating cart. At x = 0 the cart is at maximum speed, and the collision (momentum conserved) cuts the speed in half and the energy in half: A′ = A/√2. At x = A the cart is momentarily at rest and the clay adds no kinetic energy, so E = ½kA² and A are unchanged. In both cases the period increases, T = 2π√(m/k), because the mass doubled.
In both cases the period increases because the mass has doubled: \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{1.0/20} = 1.41\) s, compared with 0.99 s before. So amplitude and period are affected differently, and which one changes depends on where in the cycle the clay lands. Collisions lose mechanical energy, but afterward the oscillation conserves energy again with its new total.
Worked example · energy and speed
A 0.50 kg mass on a spring with \(k = 20\) N/m oscillates with amplitude 0.30 m. Find its total energy and its maximum speed.
Energy. \(E = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(20)(0.09) = 0.90\) J.
Maximum speed. \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv_{max}^2 = 0.90\), so \(v_{max} = \sqrt{2(0.90)/0.50} = 1.90\) m/s.
Worked example · speed at a position
For the same oscillator, find the kinetic energy and speed at \(x = 0.20\) m.
Potential energy. \(U = \tfrac{1}{2}(20)(0.20)^2 = 0.40\) J.
Kinetic energy. \(K = 0.90 - 0.40 = 0.50\) J.
Speed. \(v = \sqrt{2(0.50)/0.50} = 1.41\) m/s.
Worked example · doubling the amplitude
The amplitude of the oscillator is doubled to 0.60 m. What happens to the total energy and the maximum speed?
Energy. \(E \propto A^2\): the energy is four times as large, 3.6 J.
Maximum speed. \(v_{max} \propto A\): twice as large, 3.79 m/s. The period is unchanged at 0.99 s.
Exam focus
Total energy. \(E = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2\), constant for an ideal oscillator; it scales as \(A^2\).
Trading. \(K\) is greatest and \(U\) is zero at equilibrium; \(K = 0\) and \(U = E\) at the extremes.
Speed formula. \(v = \sqrt{(k/m)(A^2 - x^2)}\); use energy, not kinematics.
Perturbed oscillators. A dropped mass at \(x = 0\) changes the energy and amplitude; at \(x = A\) it changes only the period. Use momentum for the collision, then energy.
Representations. Be ready to draw \(U(x)\), \(K(x)\) and \(E\) and to read energy off bar charts.
Practice
A spring with \(k = 50\) N/m is stretched 0.20 m from equilibrium and released. Find the total energy.
Show answer
\(E = \tfrac{1}{2}(50)(0.20)^2 = 1.0\) J.
A 2.0 kg mass has total energy 1.0 J on a spring. What is its maximum speed?
Show answer
An oscillator has amplitude \(A\). At what displacement is its kinetic energy equal to its potential energy?
Show answer
\(K = U = E/2\): \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{4}kA^2\), so \(x = A/\sqrt{2} = 0.71A\).
The amplitude is tripled. By what factor does the maximum speed change? The total energy?
Show answer
Maximum speed: factor of 3. Total energy: factor of 9.
A 1.0 kg cart on a spring (\(k = 25\) N/m, \(A = 0.40\) m) passes the center. Clay of 1.0 kg is dropped on it there. Find the new amplitude.
Show answer
\(v_{max} = 0.40\sqrt{25} = 2.0\) m/s; after sticking, \(v = 1.0\) m/s. \(A' = v/\sqrt{k/m'} = 1.0/\sqrt{12.5} = 0.28\) m, which is \(A/\sqrt{2}\).
The same clay is dropped on the cart at \(x = +0.40\) m, its extreme. What is the new amplitude, and does the period change?
Show answer
The amplitude is unchanged at 0.40 m. The period increases because the mass doubled.
Unit 7 practice · 10 problems
Unit 7 practice: Oscillations
Ten problems covering the whole unit. Watch for what the period does
not depend on, and let energy do the work whenever a problem
asks for speed at a position. Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\).
A 0.80 kg block on a spring with \(k = 320\) N/m is pulled 0.050 m from equilibrium and released. Find the maximum force on the block and its maximum acceleration, and state where in the motion each occurs and where the speed is greatest.
Show answer
\(|F_{\max}| = kA = (320)(0.050) = 16\) N and \(|a_{\max}| = \dfrac{kA}{m} = \dfrac{16}{0.80} = 20\) m/s², both at the turning points \(x = \pm 0.050\) m, directed toward equilibrium. The speed is greatest at \(x = 0\), where the force and acceleration are zero.
A mass on a spring oscillates with period \(T\). If the amplitude is doubled, the new period is
Doubling the period assumes the mass travels twice the distance at the same speed. But a larger amplitude also means a larger restoring force and a larger maximum speed, and for a Hooke's-law spring the two effects cancel exactly.
A halved period would require the oscillator to speed up by more than the distance grows. In SHM the speed scales with amplitude exactly in step with the distance, so the period neither halves nor doubles.
\(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\) contains no amplitude. A larger swing covers more distance, but the restoring force, and therefore the speed, is proportionally larger, so the round trip takes the same time; amplitude independence is a defining property of SHM.
\(4T\) would correspond to a quantity that scales with amplitude squared, like the total energy \(\tfrac{1}{2}kA^2\). The energy does quadruple when the amplitude doubles, but the period is unaffected.
A 0.50 kg mass hangs from a spring with \(k = 80\) N/m. Find the period and frequency. What happens to the period if the spring is replaced by one four times as stiff?
Show answer
\(T = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{m}{k}} = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{0.50}{80}} = 2\pi\sqrt{0.00625} = 0.50\) s (0.497 s); \(f = \dfrac{1}{T} = 2.0\) Hz. Quadrupling \(k\) halves \(T\) to 0.25 s, since \(T \propto 1/\sqrt{k}\).
Find the period of a 0.75 m pendulum on Earth and on the Moon (\(g = 1.6\) m/s²). Would a 0.75 m pendulum with a heavier bob have a different period?
Show answer
\(T = 2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{L}{g}}\). Earth: \(2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{0.75}{10}} = 1.7\) s. Moon: \(2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{0.75}{1.6}} = 4.3\) s: weaker gravity, slower swing. Bob mass does not appear: a heavier bob feels proportionally more gravitational force and has proportionally more inertia, so its period is unchanged.
Four mass–spring systems: W has \(m = 1\) kg, \(k = 100\) N/m; X has \(m = 2\) kg, \(k = 100\) N/m; Y has \(m = 1\) kg, \(k = 400\) N/m; Z has \(m = 4\) kg, \(k = 400\) N/m. Rank their periods from longest to shortest, and identify any ties.
Show answer
\(T \propto \sqrt{m/k}\): W: \(\sqrt{1/100} = 0.10\); X: \(\sqrt{2/100} = 0.141\); Y: \(\sqrt{1/400} = 0.050\); Z: \(\sqrt{4/400} = 0.10\). Ranking: \(X \gt W = Z \gt Y\). W and Z tie because quadrupling both \(m\) and \(k\) leaves the ratio unchanged (both periods are 0.63 s; X is 0.89 s and Y is 0.31 s).
A position–time graph for a block on a spring shows maxima of \(+0.15\) m at \(t = 0\) and at \(t = 2.0\) s, with minima of \(-0.15\) m halfway between. Write \(x(t)\), find the maximum speed, and give the block's position, velocity, and acceleration at \(t = 0.50\) s.
Show answer
\(A = 0.15\) m (crest height), \(T = 2.0\) s (crest to crest). Starting at a maximum: \(x(t) = (0.15\ \text{m})\cos\!\left(\dfrac{2\pi t}{2.0\ \text{s}}\right) = 0.15\cos(\pi t)\). \(v_{\max} = \dfrac{2\pi A}{T} = \dfrac{2\pi(0.15)}{2.0} = 0.47\) m/s. At \(t = 0.50\) s \(= T/4\): \(x = 0.15\cos(\pi/2) = 0\); the block passes through equilibrium heading toward \(-x\), so \(v = -0.47\) m/s and \(a = 0\).
A student says: "At the equilibrium position the net force on the block is zero, so the block should stop there." Explain the error in a short paragraph.
Show answer
Zero net force means zero acceleration, the velocity is not changing at that instant, not zero velocity. Arriving at equilibrium the block has been accelerating toward it the whole way, so it is moving at its maximum speed exactly there. With no force to slow it at that instant, it simply keeps going, overshoots, and only then does the spring force build up (in the opposite direction) to slow it and turn it around at \(x = -A\). Newton's first law: an object with zero net force keeps its velocity, whatever that velocity is.
A 0.40 kg block on a spring with \(k = 200\) N/m oscillates with amplitude 0.060 m. Find the total energy, the maximum speed, and the speed when \(x = 0.030\) m. Is the speed at half amplitude half the maximum speed?
Show answer
\(E = \tfrac{1}{2}kA^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.060)^2 = 0.36\) J. At \(x = 0\): \(\tfrac{1}{2}mv_{\max}^2 = E \Rightarrow v_{\max} = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(0.36)}{0.40}} = 1.3\) m/s (1.34 m/s). At \(x = 0.030\) m: \(U_s = \tfrac{1}{2}(200)(0.030)^2 = 0.090\) J, so \(K = 0.36 - 0.090 = 0.27\) J and \(v = \sqrt{\dfrac{2(0.27)}{0.40}} = 1.2\) m/s (1.16 m/s). No: it is \(\sqrt{3}/2 \approx 0.87\) of \(v_{\max}\), because energy depends on the square of position.
(a) A pendulum of length 1.5 m is released from rest at 40° from the vertical. Find its speed at the lowest point. (b) For the oscillator in the previous problem, at what positions are the kinetic and potential energies equal?
Show answer
(a) Height drop \(h = L(1 - \cos 40^\circ) = (1.5)(1 - 0.766) = 0.35\) m. Tension does no work (perpendicular to the motion), so \(mgh = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2 \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{2(10)(0.351)} = 2.6\) m/s. (b) \(\tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}E = \tfrac{1}{4}kA^2 \Rightarrow x = \pm\dfrac{A}{\sqrt{2}} = \pm\dfrac{0.060}{1.414} = \pm 0.042\) m: closer to the ends than to the middle.
Experimental design. You have a spring of unknown constant, a set of known masses, and a stopwatch. Design a procedure to measure \(k\) using oscillations, including the graph you would plot and how \(k\) comes from it. Why time many oscillations rather than one?
Show answer
Hang each known mass \(m\) from the spring, displace it a small distance, release, and time 10 or 20 complete oscillations; divide by the count to get \(T\). Repeat and average. Squaring \(T = 2\pi\sqrt{m/k}\) gives \(T^2 = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{k}m\), so plot \(T^2\) (vertical) against \(m\) (horizontal): a straight line through the origin with slope \(4\pi^2/k\), so \(k = \dfrac{4\pi^2}{\text{slope}}\) (for \(k = 80\) N/m the slope would be 0.49 s²/kg). Timing many cycles divides the reaction-time error by the number of cycles; amplitude does not affect \(T\), so it need not be controlled precisely.
Water pours, air fills a room, honey creeps, and a block of ice keeps its shape. Everyday matter comes in a few familiar states, and the difference between them determines how objects move through them, how they push on walls, and why ships float. The word fluid covers any substance that flows, and the physics of fluids is built from the same ideas you have already met: forces, energy, and conservation laws. This first lesson describes what a fluid is, defines the density that characterizes it, and sets out the simplifying model, the ideal fluid, that the rest of the unit uses.
Learning objective · 8.1.A
Describe the properties of a fluid.
Required content · EK 8.1.A.1 to 8.1.A.4
Distinguishing properties of solids, liquids, and gases stem from the varying interactions between atoms and molecules.
A fluid is a substance that has no fixed shape.
Fluids can be characterized by their density. Density is defined as a ratio of mass to volume: \(\rho = m/V\).
An ideal fluid is incompressible and has no viscosity.
Solids, liquids and gases
The three common states of matter differ in how strongly neighboring atoms and molecules interact (Figure 8.1a). In a solid the particles are held in fixed positions by strong interactions; they vibrate but do not move past one another, so a solid keeps both its shape and its volume. In a liquid the particles are about as close as in a solid but can slide past one another, so a liquid keeps its volume but takes the shape of its container. In a gas the particles are far apart and interact only weakly, so a gas fills whatever container it is in. A fluid is a substance with no fixed shape: liquids and gases are both fluids.
Figure 8.1a Solids, liquids and gases differ in how strongly their atoms and molecules interact. A solid keeps its shape; a liquid keeps its volume but takes the shape of its container; a gas fills its container. Liquids and gases can flow, so both are called fluids.
Density
The density of a substance is the mass per unit volume:
\[ \rho = \frac{m}{V}. \]
Its SI unit is kg/m\(^3\). (The symbol \(\rho\) is the Greek letter rho.) Density describes a substance, not a particular piece of it: a thimble of water and a swimming pool of water have the same density, 1000 kg/m\(^3\), although their masses differ enormously. A graph of mass against volume is therefore a straight line through the origin for any one substance, and the slope of the line is the density (Figure 8.1b). A steeper line means a denser substance.
Figure 8.1b Density ρ = m/V is the slope of a mass–volume graph. Different substances give different lines; a given substance always gives the same line, however large or small the sample. Here 5 liters (5 × 10−3 m³) of iron has a mass of 39 kg, of aluminum 13.5 kg and of water 5.0 kg.
Typical values: air at room conditions about 1.2 kg/m\(^3\); fresh water 1000 kg/m\(^3\); ice about 920 kg/m\(^3\); aluminum 2700 kg/m\(^3\); iron 7870 kg/m\(^3\); mercury 13\,600 kg/m\(^3\). Gases are about a thousand times less dense than liquids and solids because their particles are so far apart. Remember the unit conversion that trips up many students: 1 liter is \(1.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\), and 1 m\(^3\) contains 1000 liters, so water has 1.0 kg per liter.
Density is not the same as weight. A small lead ball weighs less than a large foam ball, yet lead is far denser. To compare substances, compare equal volumes, or use the ratio.
The ideal fluid
Real fluids are complicated. A real liquid is slightly compressible (squeeze it hard and its density rises a little) and a real fluid has viscosity, an internal friction that makes honey flow more slowly than water. To make progress, AP Physics 1 uses the model of an ideal fluid, which is incompressible (its density is constant, however much pressure is applied) and has no viscosity (no internal friction, so flowing fluid loses no mechanical energy to thermal energy). The CED adds a boundary statement: all fluids are assumed to be ideal, and pipes are assumed to be completely filled by the fluid, unless otherwise stated. The ideal model works well for liquids like water moving at moderate speeds, and as a first approximation even for air flowing slowly.
Worked example · density of a block
A rectangular aluminum block measures 0.20 m by 0.10 m by 0.050 m and has a mass of 2.7 kg. Find its density.
A person can walk on snow in snowshoes but sinks in boots; a knife cuts better than a spoon pressed with the same force; a thumbtack goes into a wall under the push of a thumb. In each case what matters is not only the force but how the force is spread over an area. The quantity that captures this is pressure. This lesson defines pressure for a force on a surface, a scalar built from a vector force and an area; the next lesson applies it to fluids at rest.
Learning objective · 8.2.A
Describe the pressure exerted on a surface by a given force.
Required content · EK 8.2.A.1 to 8.2.A.3
Pressure is defined as the magnitude of the perpendicular force component exerted per unit area over a given surface area: \(P = F_{\perp}/A\).
Pressure is a scalar quantity.
The volume and density of a given amount of an incompressible fluid is constant regardless of the pressure exerted on that fluid.
Defining pressure
The pressure on a surface is the perpendicular (normal) force exerted on it divided by the area over which the force is spread:
\[ P = \frac{F_{\perp}}{A}. \]
The SI unit is the pascal: 1 Pa = 1 N/m\(^2\). A pascal is a small pressure (a dollar bill lying flat on a table exerts about 1 Pa), so engineers use kilopascals. Atmospheric pressure at sea level is about \(1.01\times10^{5}\) Pa, which is also called one atmosphere.
Two words in the definition deserve attention. Perpendicular: only the component of the force that is perpendicular to the surface counts. A force parallel to the surface (such as friction) does not contribute to the pressure. Per unit area: the same force on a smaller area gives a larger pressure. Figure 8.2a shows two identical 100 N weights. On a base of 0.020 m\(^2\) the pressure is 5.0 kPa; on a base of 0.0050 m\(^2\) it is four times larger, 20 kPa. That is why sharp tools work, and why wide tires and skis are used on soft ground.
Figure 8.2a The same force on a smaller area gives a larger pressure, P = F/A. A 100 N weight on 0.020 m² exerts 5.0 × 103 Pa; on 0.0050 m² it exerts 2.0 × 104 Pa, four times as much. Pressure is a scalar; the force that counts is the component perpendicular to the surface.
Pressure is a scalar. Force is a vector, with a direction, but pressure has only a magnitude: it has no direction of its own. A pressure acts on a surface and the force it produces is always perpendicular to the surface and pointing into it. When a fluid presses on a surface, the force is \(F = PA\), directed perpendicular to the surface; the direction comes from the surface’s orientation, not from the pressure.
Pressure in an incompressible fluid
For an ideal (incompressible) fluid, squeezing the fluid does not change its volume or density: the density of a given amount stays constant regardless of the pressure applied. This is a good approximation for liquids, whose volume changes by less than a part in ten thousand even under large pressure changes, and it makes the calculations in the rest of the unit manageable. (Gases, by contrast, are compressible, but the course treats flowing gases as ideal too.)
One consequence is worth knowing: when an external pressure is applied to a fluid confined in a container, the extra pressure appears throughout the fluid. A hydraulic jack uses this. A small force on a small piston creates a pressure \(F_1/A_1\) that acts on a large piston of area \(A_2\) and gives a force \(F_2 = (A_2/A_1)F_1\). The jack multiplies force, not energy: the small piston moves farther than the large one, and the work done on each is the same.
Worked example · standing on one foot
A 70 kg person (weight 700 N, taking \(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\)) stands on one foot with contact area 0.025 m\(^2\). Find the pressure on the floor. How does it compare with the same person on one high heel of area \(1.0\times10^{-4}\) m\(^2\)?
Foot. \(P = 700/0.025 = 2.8\times10^{4}\) Pa.
Heel. \(P = 700/(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 7.0\times10^{6}\) Pa, 250 times greater, which is why heels dent floors.
Worked example · the force of the atmosphere
Atmospheric pressure is \(1.01\times10^{5}\) Pa. Find the force on a window of area 0.50 m\(^2\).
Force. \(F = PA = (1.01\times10^{5})(0.50) = 5.1\times10^{4}\) N, about 5 tons. The window does not break because the same pressure pushes from the other side.
Worked example · a hydraulic lift
A small piston of area \(2.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^2\) is pushed with 150 N. The large piston has area 0.080 m\(^2\). What force does it exert?
Pressure. \(P = 150/(2.0\times10^{-3}) = 7.5\times10^{4}\) Pa everywhere in the fluid.
Large piston. \(F = PA = (7.5\times10^{4})(0.080) = 6.0\times10^{3}\) N.
Exam focus
Definition. \(P = F_{\perp}/A\), in pascals (N/m\(^2\)); a scalar.
Compare. Same force, smaller area means greater pressure; use ratios.
Force from pressure. \(F = PA\), perpendicular to the surface.
Incompressible. Density and volume of an ideal fluid stay constant under pressure.
Trap. Do not call pressure a vector or give it a direction.
Practice
A 200 N force acts perpendicular to a 0.040 m\(^2\) surface. Find the pressure.
Show answer
\(P = 200/0.040 = 5.0\times10^{3}\) Pa.
The area is halved with the same force. What happens to the pressure?
Show answer
It doubles.
Is pressure a vector or a scalar? Explain.
Show answer
A scalar: it has magnitude only. The force it exerts on a surface is perpendicular to the surface.
A 6.0 N force acts at 60\(^\circ\) to the normal of a 0.010 m\(^2\) surface. Find the pressure.
Show answer
Find the force on a 0.30 m\(^2\) surface at a pressure of \(2.0\times10^{5}\) Pa.
Show answer
\(F = PA = 6.0\times10^{4}\) N.
In a hydraulic jack the large piston has 25 times the area of the small one. If the small piston is pushed 5.0 cm, how far does the large piston rise?
Show answer
The fluid volume moved is the same, so \(A_1d_1 = A_2d_2\): \(d_2 = 5.0/25 = 0.20\) cm.
Lesson 8.3 · Unit 8 · CED topic 8.2 (pressure exerted by a fluid)
Dive to the bottom of a swimming pool and your ears hurt; dive deeper in a lake and they hurt more. The water presses on you from all sides, and the deeper you go the harder it presses. Dams are built thicker at the bottom than at the top for the same reason. This lesson explains where the pressure of a fluid comes from, and how to calculate it at any depth: the equation \(P = P_0 + \rho g h\), one of the most useful in the unit.
Learning objective · 8.2.B
Describe the pressure exerted by a fluid.
Required content · EK 8.2.B.1 to 8.2.B.3
The pressure exerted by a fluid is the result of the entirety of the interactions between the fluid’s constituent particles and the surface with which those particles interact.
The absolute pressure of a fluid at a given point is equal to the sum of a reference pressure \(P_0\), such as the atmospheric pressure \(P_{atm}\), and the gauge pressure \(P_{gauge}\): \(P = P_0 + P_{gauge}\).
The gauge pressure of a vertical column of fluid is described by the equation \(P_{gauge} = \rho g h\).
Where fluid pressure comes from
A fluid is made of particles in constant motion. When the particles collide with a surface, each collision exerts a small force; the sum of the very many collisions per second is a steady force spread over the surface. That is the pressure the fluid exerts. Because the particles move in all directions, a fluid at rest pushes on a surface in contact with it perpendicular to that surface, whichever way the surface faces: sideways on the wall of a tank, upward on a ceiling, downward on a floor.
Why pressure grows with depth
Imagine a thin horizontal slice of fluid at depth \(h\) below the surface, with a column of fluid above it of cross-sectional area \(A\) (the column of a tank, for example). The column’s weight is \(mg = \rho V g = \rho(Ah)g\). That weight presses on the slice, so the extra pressure at the bottom of the column is
\[ P_{gauge} = \frac{\rho A h g}{A} = \rho g h. \]
If the surface of the fluid is open to the air, the atmosphere also presses down on the surface with pressure \(P_0 = P_{atm} \approx 1.01\times10^{5}\) Pa, and this pressure is transmitted down through the fluid. Therefore the absolute pressure at depth \(h\) is
\[ P = P_0 + \rho g h. \]
The gauge pressure \(\rho g h\) is the amount by which the pressure exceeds the reference \(P_0\). A tire gauge, for instance, reads the pressure above atmospheric, so a tire reading 32 psi is 32 psi above atmospheric pressure. Figure 8.2b graphs the equation for fresh water: the intercept is atmospheric pressure and the slope is \(\rho g = 1.0\times10^{4}\) Pa for every meter of depth. About 10 m of water add one atmosphere, so at 20 m you feel about 3 atmospheres.
Figure 8.2b Pressure in a fluid at rest grows linearly with depth: P = P0 + ρgh. The intercept is the pressure at the surface (atmospheric pressure for an open container); the slope is ρg, about 1.0 × 104 Pa for each meter of fresh water. At 20 m the absolute pressure is 3.0 × 105 Pa, roughly three atmospheres.
What the pressure depends on
In \(P = P_0 + \rho g h\) the quantities that matter are the surface pressure \(P_0\), the fluid density \(\rho\), the gravitational field \(g\), and the depth \(h\) (measured from the surface, vertically). Several consequences follow, and the exam asks about them.
Depth only. Pressure depends on the vertical depth, not on the shape of the container or the amount of fluid. Figure 8.2c shows three containers of different shape filled to the same depth with the same liquid: the pressure at the bottom is the same in each, though they hold very different amounts of liquid.
Same level, same pressure. All points at the same depth in a connected fluid at rest have the same pressure. This is why water stands at the same level in the spout and the body of a teapot.
Denser fluid, greater pressure. At the same depth, mercury exerts 13.6 times the pressure that water does.
Direction. Pressure at a point acts equally in all directions; the force it exerts on a surface is perpendicular to the surface.
Figure 8.2c Fluid pressure depends on depth, not on the shape of the container or the amount of fluid. All three containers are filled to the same depth with the same liquid, so P = P0 + ρgh is the same at each bottom point, even though the narrow one holds much less fluid than the wide one.
Worked example · pressure at depth
Find the gauge and absolute pressures at the bottom of a lake 20 m deep (\(\rho = 1000\) kg/m\(^3\), \(g = 10\) m/s\(^2\), \(P_{atm} = 1.01\times10^{5}\) Pa).
Gauge. \(\rho g h = (1000)(10)(20) = 2.0\times10^{5}\) Pa.
A submarine porthole of area 0.040 m\(^2\) is 30 m below the surface of the sea (\(\rho = 1030\) kg/m\(^3\)). Find the extra force on the outside caused by the water (gauge pressure).
Why does water move through a pipe, and why does a fluid sitting in a tank stay put? Why do objects feel an upward push in water? None of this needs new laws of physics. A fluid is a collection of particles, and its motion follows from the same Newton’s laws you have applied to blocks and carts. This lesson shows how a net force, produced by a pressure difference, changes the velocity of a fluid, and how the same idea explains the origin of the buoyant force.
Learning objectives · 8.3.A and 8.3.B (first part)
Describe the conditions under which a fluid’s velocity changes. Describe the buoyant force exerted on an object interacting with a fluid.
Required content · EK 8.3.A.1, 8.3.A.2, 8.3.B.1, 8.3.B.2
Newton’s laws can be used to describe the motion of particles within a fluid.
The macroscopic behavior of a fluid is a result of the internal interactions between the fluid’s constituent particles and external forces exerted on the fluid.
The buoyant force is a net upward force exerted on an object by a fluid.
The buoyant force exerted on an object by a fluid is a result of the collective forces exerted on the object by the particles making up the fluid.
A pressure difference causes flow
Newton’s first law says that a fluid keeps its velocity unless a net force acts on it. In a fluid the forces are the weight, the push of the surrounding fluid, and the pushes of walls and pistons. The pushes of the surrounding fluid are pressure forces, and they can produce a net force. Consider a small parcel of fluid in a horizontal pipe, of cross-sectional area \(A\), with pressure \(P_1\) pushing on one end and \(P_2\) on the other. The net force on the parcel is
\[ F_{net} = P_1A - P_2A = (P_1 - P_2)A. \]
If \(P_1 = P_2\) the net horizontal force is zero and the fluid keeps moving at constant velocity (or stays at rest). If \(P_1 \gt P_2\) the net force points from the high pressure toward the low pressure and the fluid accelerates in that direction: \(a = (P_1 - P_2)A/m\). Fluids flow from high pressure to low pressure. A drinking straw works this way: sucking lowers the pressure in your mouth, and the greater atmospheric pressure outside pushes the drink up the straw.
The same reasoning applies vertically, and it explains why a fluid at rest stays at rest. In a tank, the fluid at depth \(h\) has pressure that increases with depth, and the upward push of the greater pressure below a parcel exactly balances its weight plus the downward push from above: the net force is zero, so the acceleration is zero. If the pressure gradient were any other, the fluid would move. The equation \(P = P_0 + \rho g h\) is just the condition for the vertical forces to balance.
Why the buoyant force exists
Put an object in a fluid and the fluid exerts forces on it all over its surface. At the bottom of the object the fluid is deeper and so at greater pressure than at the top. The force the fluid exerts upward on the bottom face is therefore larger than the force it exerts downward on the top face. The sideways forces cancel, but the up and down forces do not, leaving a net upward force: the buoyant force \(F_B\) (Figure 8.3a). It is not a new kind of force; it is the sum of the pressure forces of the fluid’s many particles on the object’s surface.
Figure 8.3a The origin of the buoyant force. Pressure is greater at the bottom of a submerged object than at the top, so the fluid pushes up on the bottom harder than it pushes down on the top. For a cube of height Δh and face area A the net upward force is (P2 − P1)A = ρgΔh A = ρVg: the weight of the fluid the cube displaces.
For a cube with top face at depth \(h_1\), bottom face at depth \(h_2\) and face area \(A\), the force down on the top is \(P_1A = (P_0 + \rho g h_1)A\) and the force up on the bottom is \(P_2A = (P_0 + \rho g h_2)A\). The atmospheric terms cancel, and
\[ F_B = (P_2 - P_1)A = \rho g(h_2 - h_1)A = \rho g V, \]
where \(V = (h_2 - h_1)A\) is the volume of the cube. This is the weight of a volume \(V\) of the fluid, the volume the object displaces: the next lesson turns it into a rule. Notice what controls the buoyant force: the density of the fluid, \(g\), and the volume of fluid displaced, and not the density, mass or depth of the object. A cube of the same size experiences the same buoyant force whether made of steel or foam, provided it is fully under the surface; depth does not matter because the pressure difference between top and bottom is the same at any depth.
Putting it together with free-body diagrams
To analyze an object in a fluid, draw its free-body diagram with the weight \(mg\) down and the buoyant force \(F_B\) up, and add any other forces (tension, a normal force from the container, a push). Then apply Newton’s second law as usual. Remember to draw forces rather than pressures, and to keep components out of free-body diagrams as the CED asks. The buoyant force is one force; it should not be added again for each face.
Worked example · acceleration of a fluid parcel
A parcel of water of mass 0.50 kg and cross-section 0.010 m\(^2\) sits in a horizontal pipe where the pressure is \(1.05\times10^{5}\) Pa on its upstream face and \(1.03\times10^{5}\) Pa on the downstream face. Find its acceleration.
Net force. \((1.05\times10^{5} - 1.03\times10^{5})(0.010) = 20\) N, downstream.
Acceleration. \(a = 20/0.50 = 40\) m/s\(^2\).
Worked example · buoyant force from pressure
A cube of side 0.10 m is held fully submerged in water with its top face 0.30 m below the surface. Find the pressures on the top and bottom faces and the net force from the water.
A steel ship weighing thousands of tons floats, while a small steel nail sinks. A hot-air balloon rises through air, and a diver with the right weights hovers in the water. All of these follow from one statement, usually credited to Archimedes of Syracuse, who is said to have found it while getting into a bath: the buoyant force on an object equals the weight of the fluid it displaces. This lesson turns that statement into a tool for predicting whether an object floats, how much of it is submerged, and what a scale reads when an object is under water.
Learning objective · 8.3.B
Describe the buoyant force exerted on an object interacting with a fluid.
Required content · EK 8.3.B.3
The magnitude of the buoyant force exerted on an object by a fluid is equivalent to the weight of the fluid displaced by the object: \(F_B = \rho_{fluid}V_{displaced}\,g\).
Archimedes’ principle
The upward buoyant force on an object wholly or partly immersed in a fluid has magnitude
\[ F_B = \rho_{fluid}\,V_{sub}\,g, \]
where \(\rho_{fluid}\) is the density of the fluid, \(V_{sub}\) is the volume of the object that is below the surface (the volume of fluid displaced), and \(\rho_{fluid}V_{sub}\) is the mass of the displaced fluid. So the buoyant force equals the weight of the displaced fluid. Lesson 8.4 derived this for a cube; it is true for any shape. Be careful with the subscripts: the density in the equation is the fluid’s, never the object’s.
Floating, sinking and rising
Whenever an object is in a fluid, two vertical forces act on it: its weight \(mg\) down and the buoyant force \(F_B\) up (Figure 8.3b). Their comparison decides the outcome.
If \(F_B \gt mg\) the net force is upward and the object accelerates upward: it rises (if submerged) until it reaches the surface.
If \(F_B \lt mg\) the net force is downward and the object sinks, with acceleration \((mg - F_B)/m\).
If \(F_B = mg\) the object is in equilibrium. A floating object is in equilibrium, with only part of its volume under the surface, just enough to displace its own weight of fluid.
Figure 8.3b An object in a fluid feels its weight mg down and the buoyant force FB = ρfluidVsubg up. Whichever is larger decides the acceleration: they balance for an object floating at rest; the weight wins for a sinking object; the buoyant force wins for one that rises. These are free-body diagrams, so forces are drawn without components.
For an object that is fully submerged, \(V_{sub} = V\) is the object’s whole volume, and comparing \(\rho_{fluid}Vg\) with \(\rho_{obj}Vg\) shows that the object sinks if its density is greater than the fluid’s, and rises if its density is smaller. For an object that floats at rest, \(F_B = mg\) gives \(\rho_{fluid}V_{sub}g = \rho_{obj}Vg\), so
\[ \frac{V_{sub}}{V} = \frac{\rho_{obj}}{\rho_{fluid}}. \]
The fraction submerged equals the ratio of the densities. Wood of density 600 kg/m\(^3\) floats in water with 60% of its volume below the surface; ice (about 920 kg/m\(^3\)) floats with about 92% below the surface, which is why most of an iceberg is hidden. A steel ship floats because its hollow shape displaces a large volume of water: its average density, steel plus enclosed air, is less than that of water.
Apparent weight
Hang an object from a scale and lower it into water. The scale reads less than in air, because the water pushes up on the object and the string needs to supply only the remainder. For an object at rest, \(T + F_B = mg\), so the apparent weight is
\[ T = mg - F_B. \]
In Figure 8.3c a 3.1 kg iron block of volume \(4.0\times10^{-4}\) m\(^3\) reads 31 N in air; in water it feels \(F_B = (1000)(4.0\times10^{-4})(10) = 4.0\) N, and the scale reads 27 N. This difference is what Archimedes could use to find the volume, and hence the density, of an irregular object such as a crown: the loss of apparent weight gives the volume of water displaced.
Figure 8.3c Apparent weight. An iron block of mass 3.1 kg and volume 4.0 × 10−4 m³ weighs 31 N. Fully submerged in water it feels FB = ρVg = (1000)(4.0 × 10−4)(10) = 4.0 N upward, so the supporting string pulls with only T = mg − FB = 27 N. The block has not become lighter; the water pushes it up.
Finally, keep in mind two common mistakes. The buoyant force does not depend on how deep a fully submerged object is. And a container of water on a scale: when an object hangs in the water, the scale reading goes up by \(F_B\), the reaction force to the water’s push on the object (Newton’s third law).
Worked example · how much of a block floats
A wooden block 0.30 m \(\times\) 0.20 m \(\times\) 0.10 m has a mass of 3.6 kg. Does it float in water? How much of its volume is submerged?
Density. \(V = 6.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\), so \(\rho = 3.6/6.0\times10^{-3} = 600\) kg/m\(^3\), less than water, so it floats.
Submerged. \(V_{sub}/V = 600/1000 = 0.60\), so \(3.6\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\) is under the surface. Check: \(F_B = (1000)(3.6\times10^{-3})(10) = 36\) N \(= mg\). ✓
Worked example · apparent weight
The iron block (3.1 kg, \(4.0\times10^{-4}\) m\(^3\)) is released in water. What is its acceleration?
A raft of volume 0.50 m\(^3\) and mass 50 kg floats in fresh water. What is the largest additional mass it can carry without sinking?
Maximum buoyant force. Fully submerged, \(F_B = (1000)(0.50)(10) = 5000\) N.
Load. The total weight can be at most 5000 N, so the total mass is 500 kg and the load is \(500 - 50 = 450\) kg.
Exam focus
Formula. \(F_B = \rho_{fluid}V_{sub}g\): weight of the fluid displaced.
Compare forces. \(F_B\) with \(mg\): rises, floats or sinks; or compare densities when fully submerged.
Floating. \(F_B = mg\), and \(V_{sub}/V = \rho_{obj}/\rho_{fluid}\).
Apparent weight. \(T = mg - F_B\).
Common errors. Using the object’s density in \(F_B\); thinking buoyancy depends on depth; thinking a floating object’s \(F_B\) depends on its volume instead of its weight.
Practice
Find the buoyant force on a 0.020 m\(^3\) object fully submerged in water.
Show answer
\(F_B = (1000)(0.020)(10) = 200\) N.
A 2.0 kg block of density 500 kg/m\(^3\) floats in water. What is the buoyant force, and what volume is submerged?
Show answer
\(F_B = mg = 20\) N; \(V_{sub} = 20/(1000\times10) = 2.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\) (half the block, whose volume is \(4.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\)).
A 5.0 kg object has a volume of \(2.0\times10^{-3}\) m\(^3\). Will it float in water?
Show answer
Its density is 2500 kg/m\(^3\), greater than water, so it sinks. (Fully submerged \(F_B = 20\) N is less than \(mg = 50\) N.)
A rock weighs 50 N in air and 32 N when hung fully submerged in water. Find its volume.
Show answer
Put your thumb over the end of a garden hose and the water shoots out faster. A river speeds up where it passes through a narrow gorge and slows in a wide pool. The water has not been pushed harder; the same amount of water per second has simply been squeezed through a smaller opening. This is conservation of mass applied to a flowing fluid, and it leads to the continuity equation. It is the first of two conservation laws that govern the flow of an ideal fluid; the second, conservation of energy, is Bernoulli’s equation, in the next lesson.
Learning objective · 8.4.A
Describe the flow of an incompressible fluid through a cross-sectional area by using mass conservation.
Required content · EK 8.4.A.1 and 8.4.A.2
A difference in pressure between two locations causes a fluid to flow.
The rate at which matter enters a fluid-filled tube open at both ends must equal the rate at which matter exits the tube.
The rate at which matter flows into a location is proportional to the cross-sectional area of the flow and the speed at which the fluid flows: \(V = Avt\) (derived).
The continuity equation for fluid flow describes conservation of mass flow rate in incompressible fluids: \(A_1v_1 = A_2v_2\).
Volume flow rate
A fluid flowing at speed \(v\) through a pipe of cross-sectional area \(A\) advances a distance \(vt\) in a time \(t\), so the volume that passes a point in that time is
\[ V = A\,v\,t. \]
The volume flow rate is therefore \(V/t = Av\), in m\(^3\)/s. For an incompressible fluid the density is constant, so the mass flow rate is \(\rho Av\), proportional to the volume flow rate.
The continuity equation
Now think of a pipe completely full of fluid, with no leaks and no places where fluid is created or stored. Matter cannot be created or destroyed, and an incompressible fluid cannot pile up, so the rate at which fluid enters one end must equal the rate at which it leaves the other. At any two cross sections,
\[ A_1v_1 = A_2v_2. \]
This is the continuity equation. Where the pipe is wide the fluid is slow; where it narrows the fluid speeds up. Figure 8.4a shows a pipe narrowing from 0.020 m\(^2\) to 0.0050 m\(^2\), a factor of 4: the fluid speeds up by a factor of 4, from 2.0 m/s to 8.0 m/s, and the flow rate is 0.040 m\(^3\)/s everywhere.
Figure 8.4a The continuity equation. An incompressible fluid that fills a pipe flows at the same volume rate everywhere along it, so A1v1 = A2v2. Where the pipe narrows to one quarter of the area the fluid moves four times faster. Here 0.020 × 2.0 = 0.0050 × 8.0 = 0.040 m³/s.
For circular pipes \(A = \pi r^2 = \pi d^2/4\), so the speed varies inversely as the square of the radius (or diameter). Halve the radius and the area falls to a quarter, so the speed rises by a factor of four. This is a frequent exam trap: it is the area, not the radius, that appears in \(A_1v_1 = A_2v_2\).
A fluid speeding up needs a net force. The force comes from a pressure difference: the pressure is higher in the wide part and lower in the narrow part, as lesson 8.7 shows. This is what lesson 8.4 said, that a pressure difference causes fluid to flow and to accelerate. Remember that continuity says nothing about pressure; it is a statement about mass conservation only.
The same equation applies to branching systems. If a pipe splits into several branches, the flow rate in the main pipe equals the sum of the flow rates in the branches: \(A_1v_1 = A_2v_2 + A_3v_3 + \cdots\). Blood flowing from the aorta into millions of capillaries slows down greatly even though each capillary is tiny, because the total cross-sectional area of all the capillaries is vast.
Worked example · a garden hose
Water flows at 2.0 m/s in a hose of radius 1.0 cm. The nozzle has a radius of 0.50 cm. Find the flow rate and the exit speed.
Time. \(t = V/(Av) = 0.90/(6.0\times10^{-3}) = 150\) s.
Worked example · a branching pipe
A main pipe of area 0.030 m\(^2\) carries water at 2.0 m/s and splits into three identical branches, each of area 0.0100 m\(^2\). Find the speed in each branch.
Airplane wings, spray bottles, shower curtains that blow inward, and the water jet from a hole in a bucket all involve fluids whose speed, height and pressure change from place to place. Continuity ties the speed to the pipe’s cross-section; this lesson ties together speed, pressure and height using conservation of energy. The result, Bernoulli’s equation, is the energy conservation law for an ideal fluid, and it gives a very clean special case, Torricelli’s theorem, for water leaving a tank. It also finishes the course’s treatment of mechanics, where the same two conservation laws, momentum and energy, have organized everything.
Learning objective · 8.4.B
Describe the flow of a fluid as a result of a difference in energy between two locations within the fluid–Earth system.
Required content · EK 8.4.B.1 to 8.4.B.3
A difference in gravitational potential energies between two locations in a fluid will result in a difference in kinetic energy and pressure between those two locations that is described by conservation laws.
Bernoulli’s equation describes the conservation of mechanical energy in fluid flow: \(P_1 + \rho g y_1 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_1^2 = P_2 + \rho g y_2 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_2^2\).
Torricelli’s theorem relates the speed of a fluid exiting an opening to the difference in height between the opening and the top surface of the fluid and can be derived from conservation of energy principles: \(v = \sqrt{2gh}\).
Boundary statement: all fluids are assumed to be ideal, and all pipes are assumed to be completely filled by the fluid, unless otherwise stated.
Energy per unit volume
Consider an ideal fluid flowing steadily. Follow a small volume \(V\) of it from point 1 to point 2. It has gravitational potential energy \(\rho Vgy\) (height \(y\) above a chosen reference), kinetic energy \(\tfrac{1}{2}\rho Vv^2\), and the pressure forces do work on it as it moves: the push from behind does \(P_1V\) and the push from ahead takes away \(P_2V\). With no viscosity, no mechanical energy is lost, so the work done by the pressure forces equals the change in the mechanical energy. Divide by \(V\) and rearrange:
\[ P_1 + \rho g y_1 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_1^2 = P_2 + \rho g y_2 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_2^2. \]
This is Bernoulli’s equation. Each term has the units of pressure (and of energy per unit volume): \(P\) is the pressure, \(\rho g y\) the gravitational potential energy per volume, and \(\tfrac{1}{2}\rho v^2\) the kinetic energy per volume. The sum is the same everywhere along a streamline. A difference in gravitational potential energy between two places in the fluid is balanced by a difference in kinetic energy and pressure.
What it says
Level pipe (\(y_1 = y_2\)). \(P_1 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_1^2 = P_2 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v_2^2\). Where the fluid moves faster, the pressure is lower (Figure 8.4b). Combine with continuity: in a narrowing pipe the speed goes up, so the pressure goes down. The pressure difference is exactly what provides the net force that accelerates the fluid into the narrow section.
Fluid at rest (\(v_1 = v_2 = 0\)). \(P_2 - P_1 = \rho g(y_1 - y_2)\), the familiar \(P = P_0 + \rho g h\) of lesson 8.3. Bernoulli’s equation contains hydrostatics as a special case.
Constant speed (uniform pipe). Pressure falls as the fluid climbs: \(P_2 = P_1 - \rho g(y_2 - y_1)\).
Figure 8.4b Bernoulli’s principle for a level pipe: where the fluid speeds up, the pressure drops. In the wide section the fluid is slow and the standpipe shows high pressure; in the narrow section the fluid is fast and the pressure is lower. The pressure difference is what accelerates the fluid into the narrow part. P + ½ρv² stays constant along a streamline.
The principle explains the lift on a wing (air moving faster over the curved top surface has lower pressure than the air below), the way a perfume sprayer pulls up liquid, and why a curtain in a shower is pulled in toward the faster-moving air. Its limits matter: it holds along a streamline in steady flow of an ideal fluid. Viscosity and turbulence, ignored here, matter in practice.
Torricelli’s theorem
A wide open tank has a small hole at a depth \(h\) below the surface (Figure 8.4c). Apply Bernoulli’s equation between the top surface (point 1) and the hole (point 2). Both are open to the air, so \(P_1 = P_2 = P_{atm}\). The tank is wide and the hole small, so continuity says the surface drops very slowly: \(v_1 \approx 0\). Take \(y_2 = 0\) at the hole so that \(y_1 = h\):
\[ P_{atm} + \rho g h + 0 = P_{atm} + 0 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v^2 \quad\Rightarrow\quad v = \sqrt{2gh}. \]
This is Torricelli’s theorem: the speed of the fluid leaving the opening is the speed an object would have after falling freely from rest through the same height \(h\). The result does not depend on the density of the fluid, and the hole’s size has no effect on the speed (though it affects the flow rate, \(Av\)). In effect, the fluid at the top has given up its gravitational potential energy and gained kinetic energy.
Figure 8.4c Torricelli’s theorem. For a wide tank open to the air, the surface drops very slowly (v1 ≈ 0) and the pressure at both the surface and the hole is atmospheric, so Bernoulli’s equation reduces to ρgh = ½ρv², giving v = √(2gh). For h = 2.5 m with g = 10 m/s², v = √50 = 7.1 m/s, the speed of an object that has fallen the same height.
The water leaves horizontally with speed \(v\), and then falls as a projectile. From Unit 1, the time to fall a height \(H\) to the ground is \(\sqrt{2H/g}\), and the horizontal range is \(vt\). Torricelli’s speed grows with the depth of the hole, so a lower hole makes a faster jet.
Worked example · pressure in a narrowing pipe
Water flows through a horizontal pipe at 2.0 m/s with pressure \(2.0\times10^{5}\) Pa. The pipe narrows and the speed becomes 8.0 m/s. Find the pressure in the narrow section.
Water flows at the same speed through a uniform pipe that rises 5.0 m. The pressure at the bottom is \(3.0\times10^{5}\) Pa. Find the pressure at the top.
Bernoulli. The speeds are equal, so \(P_2 = P_1 - \rho g(y_2 - y_1)\).
Equation. \(P + \rho g y + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v^2\) = constant along a streamline (conservation of mechanical energy, ideal fluid).
Faster means lower pressure at the same height; use continuity to find the speeds.
Torricelli. \(v = \sqrt{2gh}\), with \(h\) measured from the top surface to the opening; independent of \(\rho\) and of the hole size.
Setup. Choose points 1 and 2, state which terms are zero or equal (open to air, \(v_1 \approx 0\), same height) and why.
Derivation. Be ready to derive Torricelli’s theorem from conservation of energy.
Practice
Find the speed of water leaving a hole 1.8 m below the surface of a wide open tank.
Show answer
\(v = \sqrt{2(10)(1.8)} = 6.0\) m/s.
The hole depth is quadrupled. What happens to the exit speed?
Show answer
\(v \propto \sqrt{h}\): it doubles.
In a level pipe, water at 3.0 m/s and 150 kPa speeds up to 5.0 m/s. Find the new pressure.
Show answer
\(\Delta P = \tfrac{1}{2}(1000)(9.0 - 25) = -8000\) Pa, so \(P_2 = 142\) kPa.
Why does the pressure drop where a pipe narrows?
Show answer
The fluid speeds up (continuity), gaining kinetic energy per volume; for a level pipe Bernoulli’s equation then requires the pressure to fall.
Does Torricelli’s speed depend on the fluid’s density?
Show answer
No; \(\rho\) cancels from \(\rho g h = \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v^2\).
Show that Bernoulli’s equation gives \(P_2 - P_1 = \rho g h\) for a fluid at rest, with point 2 a depth \(h\) below point 1.
Show answer
With \(v_1 = v_2 = 0\), \(y_1 - y_2 = h\): \(P_1 + \rho g h = P_2\).
Unit 8 practice · 10 problems
Unit 8 practice: Fluids
Ten problems covering the whole unit. State whether a pressure is gauge
or absolute, and always name the assumptions behind Bernoulli's equation.
Use \(g = 10\ \text{m/s}^2\), \(\rho_{\text{water}} = 1000\) kg/m³, and
\(P_0 = 1.01\times10^{5}\) Pa.
A rectangular block measures 0.20 m × 0.10 m × 0.050 m and has mass 2.7 kg. Find its density and identify the likely material (aluminum 2700, iron 7870, gold 19 300 kg/m³). Would cutting the block in half change its density?
Show answer
\(V = (0.20)(0.10)(0.050) = 1.0\times10^{-3}\) m³. \(\rho = \dfrac{m}{V} = \dfrac{2.7\ \text{kg}}{1.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}^3} = 2700\) kg/m³: aluminum. Cutting it in half halves both \(m\) and \(V\); density is a property of the material, not the amount, and stays 2700 kg/m³.
A cargo ship floats in a freshwater river and then sails into the ocean, where the water is denser. Compared with the river, in the ocean the buoyant force on the ship is
It is tempting to say denser water pushes harder, but a floating object's buoyant force is fixed by its weight: \(F_b = mg\) in both cases. If the buoyant force were larger, the ship would accelerate upward until it wasn't.
A smaller buoyant force would leave the ship's weight unbalanced, and it would sink lower until \(F_b\) matched \(mg\) again. For any floating object the buoyant force equals the weight, whatever the fluid.
Floating means \(F_b = mg\), and the ship's weight has not changed, so the buoyant force is the same. Since \(F_b = \rho_{\text{fluid}}V_{\text{sub}}g\) and \(\rho\) is larger in seawater, the displaced volume must be smaller: the ship rides higher.
The buoyant force is indeed the same, but riding lower would mean displacing more water, and more of a denser fluid would give a buoyant force larger than the weight. A denser fluid needs less displaced volume, so the ship rises.
A tank of water is 4.0 m deep and open to the air. Find the gauge pressure and the absolute pressure at the bottom, and the net force on a 0.10 m × 0.10 m window in the bottom if the air outside the window is at atmospheric pressure.
Show answer
Gauge: \(\rho g h = (1000)(10)(4.0) = 4.0\times10^{4}\) Pa. Absolute: \(P_0 + \rho g h = 1.01\times10^{5} + 4.0\times10^{4} = 1.4\times10^{5}\) Pa. Atmospheric pressure pushes on both sides of the window, so only the gauge pressure produces a net force: \(F = P_{\text{gauge}}A = (4.0\times10^{4})(0.010) = 400\) N.
Three open containers (a narrow cylinder, a wide cylinder, and a cone with its wide end up) are each filled with fresh water to a depth of 0.50 m. A fourth, identical to the narrow cylinder, holds oil (\(\rho = 800\) kg/m³) to the same depth. Rank the gauge pressures at the bottom of the four containers and explain.
Show answer
Water containers tie; oil is lowest: \(P_{\text{narrow}} = P_{\text{wide}} = P_{\text{cone}} \gt P_{\text{oil}}\). Gauge pressure is \(\rho g h\); it depends only on depth and fluid density, not on the container's shape or the total amount of fluid. Water: \((1000)(10)(0.50) = 5000\) Pa in all three. Oil: \((800)(10)(0.50) = 4000\) Pa. The wide container holds far more water but the same column height presses on each square meter of its bottom.
A block of wood with density 750 kg/m³ floats in fresh water. What fraction of its volume is submerged? What fraction if it floats in seawater (\(\rho = 1025\) kg/m³)?
Show answer
Floating: \(F_b = mg \Rightarrow \rho_{\text{fluid}}V_{\text{sub}}g = \rho_{\text{wood}}Vg\), so \(\dfrac{V_{\text{sub}}}{V} = \dfrac{\rho_{\text{wood}}}{\rho_{\text{fluid}}}\). Fresh water: \(\dfrac{750}{1000} = 0.75\) (75% under). Seawater: \(\dfrac{750}{1025} = 0.73\) (73% under): denser fluid, less of the block submerged.
A 3.0 kg iron block (\(\rho = 7870\) kg/m³) hangs from a string, fully submerged in water. Find the buoyant force and the tension in the string. What fraction of its weight does the block appear to lose?
Show answer
\(V = \dfrac{m}{\rho} = \dfrac{3.0}{7870} = 3.8\times10^{-4}\) m³. \(F_b = \rho_{\text{water}}Vg = (1000)(3.81\times10^{-4})(10) = 3.8\) N. Equilibrium: \(T + F_b = mg \Rightarrow T = 30 - 3.81 = 26.2\) N ≈ 26 N. Fraction lost \(= \dfrac{F_b}{mg} = \dfrac{\rho_{\text{water}}}{\rho_{\text{iron}}} = \dfrac{1000}{7870} = 0.13\), about 13%.
A student holds an inflated beach ball completely under water and lets go. It accelerates upward, then pops partly out and settles floating. In a short paragraph, explain the motion using forces.
Show answer
Fully submerged, the buoyant force equals the weight of a ball-sized volume of water, \(\rho_{\text{water}}Vg\), while the ball's own weight is tiny because its average density (mostly air) is far below water's. The net force is upward and large, so the ball accelerates upward: \(a = (F_b - mg)/m\). As the ball rises through the surface, less of it is submerged, \(V_{\text{sub}}\) shrinks, and \(F_b\) decreases. It overshoots (it has upward momentum), then oscillates and settles where \(F_b = mg\), with only a small fraction submerged, equal to the ratio of the ball's average density to the water's.
Water flows at 1.5 m/s through a pipe of diameter 6.0 cm that narrows to a diameter of 2.0 cm. Find the speed in the narrow section and the volume flow rate.
Show answer
Continuity \(A_1v_1 = A_2v_2\), and area scales with diameter squared: \(v_2 = v_1\left(\dfrac{d_1}{d_2}\right)^2 = (1.5)\left(\dfrac{6.0}{2.0}\right)^2 = 1.5\times 9 = 14\) m/s (13.5 m/s). Flow rate: \(Q = A_1v_1 = \pi(0.030)^2(1.5) = 4.2\times10^{-3}\) m³/s ≈ 4.2 L/s, the same in both sections.
In a horizontal pipe, water at \(2.20\times10^{5}\) Pa moves at 3.0 m/s. Downstream the pipe's cross-sectional area is one-third as large. Find the speed and pressure there, and explain in a sentence why the pressure drops.
Show answer
Continuity: \(v_2 = v_1\dfrac{A_1}{A_2} = 3(3.0) = 9.0\) m/s. Bernoulli with \(y_1 = y_2\): \(P_2 = P_1 + \tfrac{1}{2}\rho(v_1^2 - v_2^2) = 2.20\times10^{5} + \tfrac{1}{2}(1000)(9.0 - 81) = 2.20\times10^{5} - 3.6\times10^{4} = 1.84\times10^{5}\) Pa. The fluid speeds up entering the narrow section, so a net force must push it forward: the pressure behind must exceed the pressure ahead. Bernoulli is energy per volume: kinetic energy per volume went up, so pressure went down.
(a) A large open tank has a small hole 1.8 m below the water surface. Find the speed of the water leaving the hole, stating your assumptions. (b) Experimental design: the hole is a height \(H\) above the floor. Describe how you could test \(v = \sqrt{2gh}\) by varying the water depth \(h\) and measuring where the jet lands, and what graph should be a straight line.
Show answer
(a) Bernoulli between the surface (1) and the hole (2): both open to air so \(P_1 = P_2\); the tank is wide so \(v_1 \approx 0\); the fluid is incompressible with negligible viscosity. Then \(\rho g h = \tfrac{1}{2}\rho v^2 \Rightarrow v = \sqrt{2gh} = \sqrt{2(10)(1.8)} = 6.0\) m/s. (b) The jet leaves horizontally and falls \(H\) in time \(t = \sqrt{2H/g}\), landing at \(x = vt = \sqrt{2gh}\sqrt{2H/g} = 2\sqrt{hH}\). Fill the tank to several depths \(h\), measure the landing distance \(x\) for each (refilling to keep \(h\) steady during the measurement), and plot \(x^2\) against \(h\): the prediction is a straight line through the origin with slope \(4H\). For \(H = 0.50\) m and \(h = 1.8\) m the jet should land 1.9 m out.
Unit recap
Unit recap
0:00 / 0:00
Animated recap with on-screen narration. Turn on Voice to
have it read aloud (uses your device's built-in voice). Pressing play
counts as your one free video.
Free preview complete
That's the end of the free preview.
You've opened five lessons, which is
as much as we can show without a subscription. Everything you've
already opened stays available; use the outline on the left to go
back to it.