World History · Lesson 1.4 · Unit 1 · CA HSS 10.1.2

When does obedience end?

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The key ideas" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

Aristotle distinguishes rule by law from tyranny by whose interest is served: a king rules for the common good, a tyrant for himself.

The classical test is purpose, not procedure. A ruler who came to power lawfully can still be a tyrant, which means legitimacy is about how power is used rather than only how it was obtained.

Medieval thinkers added the distinction between a tyrant by conduct, who rules badly, and a tyrant by origin, who seized power with no title at all.

Resistance theory developed slowly, because the obvious objection is that any rebel will claim the ruler is a tyrant.

The standard safeguard was to require that resistance be led by lesser magistrates rather than by private individuals, which limits who may judge.

The problem is unsolved, not solved. Every theory of legitimate resistance has to answer who decides, and none answers it fully.

2 Reading the primary source

Find this quoted source on the lesson page, along with its analysis.

“Of forms of government in which one rules, we call that which regards the common interests, kingship or royalty; that which regards the interests of the wealthy few, aristocracy; and when the multitude administer the...”

Sourcing (HIPP). Who wrote this, when, and for what audience? Why does that matter?

What does this source show about the lesson's main idea?

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.