Geometry · Lesson 2.3 · Unit 2 · G-CO.9

Two valid forms, and the two invalid ones that resemble them

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The method" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

Deductive reasoning applies general statements to reach a certain conclusion. If the premises are true and the form is valid, the conclusion cannot be false.

The law of detachment: if "if \( p \), then \( q \)" is true and \( p \) is true, then \( q \) is true.

The law of syllogism: if "if \( p \), then \( q \)" and "if \( q \), then \( r \)" are both true, then "if \( p \), then \( r \)" is true.

Syllogism chains conditionals; detachment cashes one in against a specific case.

The invalid twin of detachment is affirming the conclusion: from "if \( p \), then \( q \)" and \( q \), concluding \( p \). This is using the converse.

The invalid twin of the contrapositive is denying the hypothesis: from "if \( p \), then \( q \)" and not \( p \), concluding not \( q \). This is using the inverse.

2 Worked example

Read the "Worked example" box. Then, without looking back, try writing your own answer below.

Determine whether each argument is valid, and name the law or the error. (a) If two angles are vertical, they are congruent. \( \angle 1 \) and \( \angle 2 \) are vertical. Therefore \( \angle 1 \cong \angle 2 \). (b) If two angles are vertical, they are congruent. \( \angle 3 \cong \angle 4 \). Therefore \( \angle 3 \) and \( \angle 4 \) are vertical. (c) If a figure is a square, it is a rectangle. If a figure is a rectangle, it is a parallelogram. Therefore if a figure is a square, it is a parallelogram. (d) If a figure is a square, it is a rectangle. \( F \) is not a square. Therefore \( F \) is not a rectangle.

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.