Financial Algebra · Lesson 5.6 · Unit 5 · F-LE.2

Pay the tax now or pay it later

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The method" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

A traditional account is taxed at withdrawal. The contribution comes off taxable income; the balance is taxed as income when withdrawn.

A Roth account is taxed at contribution. The contribution is made from after-tax pay, and qualified withdrawals are not taxed.

Compare at equal take-home cost. A \$6,000 traditional contribution at a 22 percent marginal rate costs the same take-home pay as a \$4,680 Roth contribution (\( 6000 \times 0.78 \)).

Both grow by the same factor. With the same return the growth factor cancels out of the comparison.

If the two tax rates are equal, the accounts are equal. Both give \( P \times g \times (1 - t) \), where \( g \) is the growth factor and \( t \) the tax rate.

If the rate at withdrawal is lower, the traditional account wins.

2 Worked example

Read the "Worked example" box. Then, without looking back, try writing your own answer below.

A saver in the 22 percent bracket can make a \$6,000 traditional contribution or the Roth contribution with the same take-home cost. The money grows at 7 percent a year for 30 years. (a) Find the Roth contribution. (b) Find the growth factor. (c) Find the after-tax value of each if the tax rate at withdrawal is 22 percent. (d) Repeat for 12 percent and 32 percent.

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.