English 9 · Lesson 5.4 · Unit 5 · RI.9-10.8

Is the evidence sufficient, relevant and true

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The key ideas" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

Three tests apply to evidence: is it relevant to the claim, is there enough of it, and is it accurate.

Relevance fails when evidence supports something adjacent to the claim rather than the claim itself.

Sufficiency fails when a general conclusion rests on too few cases, an error called hasty generalization.

An ad hominem attacks the person rather than the argument, and it is a fallacy even when the criticism is accurate.

A straw man restates the opponent's position in a weakened form and then defeats the restatement.

A false dilemma presents two options when more are available.

2 Reading the primary source

Find this quoted source on the lesson page, along with its analysis.

“I heartily accept the motto, "That government is best which governs least"; and I should like to see it acted up to more rapidly and systematically. Carried out, it finally amounts to this, which also I believe, "That...”

Sourcing (HIPP). Who wrote this, when, and for what audience? Why does that matter?

What does this source show about the lesson's main idea?

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.