English 10 · Lesson 4.5 · Unit 4 · RI.9-10.8, RI.9-10.6

The deliberative speech, and the false dilemma

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The key ideas" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

Patrick Henry addressed the Virginia Convention on 23 March 1775, arguing that the colony should arm its militia.

No text survives from 1775. The speech was reconstructed by William Wirt in his 1817 biography, from the recollections of people who were there.

It is deliberative: it urges a specific decision about the future.

The exordium is an elaborate apology for disagreeing with respected colleagues, which builds ethos before any claim is made.

The central argument is inductive: ten years of petitions have been answered with troops, so further petitioning is futile.

The famous closing line is a false dilemma, as lesson 3.8 established.

2 Reading the primary source

Find this quoted source on the lesson page, along with its analysis.

“I have but one lamp by which my feet are guided, and that is the lamp of experience. I know of no way of judging of the future but by the past. And judging by the past, I wish to know what there has been in the conduct...”

Sourcing (HIPP). Who wrote this, when, and for what audience? Why does that matter?

What does this source show about the lesson's main idea?

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.