American Government · Lesson 5.2 · Unit 5 · CA HSS 12.5.2

Two judicial philosophies and what each produces

Name:   Date:  

1 Why this lesson matters

Read the opening paragraph and the "The key ideas" box on the lesson page. In your own words, restate each idea below.

Judicial restraint is a disposition to uphold the acts of elected branches unless they clearly violate the Constitution, and to decide cases on the narrowest available ground.

Judicial activism is a willingness to strike down laws and to reach broader constitutional holdings, including overruling precedent.

Neither term is inherently a criticism, although both are used as criticisms, which is why definitions must be stated before the words are used.

The restraint argument is democratic: unelected judges with life tenure should not override the decisions of officials the voters chose and can remove.

The activism argument is also constitutional: rights exist precisely to be enforced against majorities, and a court that defers to legislatures cannot protect minorities from them.

Stare decisis, the principle of standing by decided cases, is the practical center of the argument, since overruling precedent is the clearest activist act.

2 Worked example

Read the "Worked example" box. Then, without looking back, try writing your own answer below.

Read the worked example and explain, in your own words, what it shows.

3 Sum it up

In two or three sentences, explain this lesson's main idea to someone who has not read it.